SB 846: Voter registration: California New Motor Voter Program.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-02-17
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires, in conformance with federal law, that the Secretary of State and the Department of Motor Vehicles establish and implement the California New Motor Voter Program for the purpose of increasing opportunities for voter registration for qualified voters. Existing law requires the department to transmit to the Secretary of State specified information related to a persons eligibility to vote, which the person provides when applying for a drivers license or identification card or when the person notifies the department of an address change. Existing law requires that if this information transmitted to the Secretary of State constitutes a completed affidavit of registration, the Secretary of State must register or preregister the person to vote, as applicable, unless the person affirmatively declines to register or is ineligible to vote, as specified.
This bill would additionally require the Department of Motor Vehicles to transmit specified information to the Secretary of State for a person submitting a drivers license application who provides documentation demonstrating United States citizenship and that the person is of an eligible age to register or preregister to vote. The bill would deem this information to constitute a completed affidavit of registration for such persons, and require the Secretary of State to register or preregister the person to vote, unless the Secretary of State determines they are ineligible. The bill would require, if a person is registered or preregistered to vote in this manner, that the county elections official send a notice to the person advising that they may decline to register or preregister to vote, designate a party preference, or select a language preference. The bill would also require the county elections official to send a notice to a person who is already registered to vote, but for whom the Secretary of State changes their registration information after receiving updated name or address information from the department.
This bill would prohibit the department from providing a person the opportunity to attest to meeting voter eligibility requirements when they submit a drivers license application, if the person provides a document to the department during the transaction demonstrating that the person is not a United States Citizen.
This bill would expand the definition of voter registration agency to include entities designated by the Secretary of State. The bill would require the Secretary of State to establish a schedule whereby specified voter registration agencies must provide the Secretary of State electronic information regarding individuals who are eligible to vote or who provide updated registration information.
This bill would make these provisions operative on the earlier of January 1, 2026, or 5 days after the Secretary of State certifies that the information technology infrastructure to substantially implement the bill is functional. The bill would allow the Secretary of State, commencing January 1, 2024, to perform administrative actions necessary to implement these provisions.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials with respect to voter registration, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)Every With respect to every drivers license application application, the department shall either include a voter registration application. All application as further specified in Section 2265 or provide to the Secretary of State the voter registration information specified in Section 2265.1, as applicable.
(b)All of the following apply to the voter registration application included with the drivers license application: application that is subject to Section 2265.
(1)The voter registration application shall require only the minimum information necessary to prevent duplicate voter registrations and to enable the Secretary of State to assess the eligibility of the applicant and to administer voter registration and other procedures for elections.
(2)The voter registration application shall not require any information that duplicates information required for the drivers license application, other than an additional signature or other information required by paragraph (3).
(3)The voter registration application shall include all of the following:
(A)A statement of the voter eligibility requirements, including those regarding citizenship.
(B)An attestation that the applicant meets each voter eligibility requirement.
(C)The signature of the applicant, under penalty of perjury.
(D)An opportunity to decline to register to vote.
(b)(c)A voter who attests to the voters eligibility as part of a voter registration application pursuant to Section 2265 shall be registered to vote unless the voter affirmatively declines to register to vote.
SEC. 2.Section 2265 of the Elections Code is amended to read:2265.(a)(1)The department, in consultation with the Secretary of State, shall establish a schedule and method for the department to electronically provide to the Secretary of State the records specified in this section.
(2)The department and the Secretary of State shall develop and enter into an interagency agreement specifying how the department and the Secretary of State will cooperate to fulfill the requirements of this chapter. The agreement shall be updated as necessary, and the current version of the agreement shall be published on the internet website of the Secretary of State, except those parts of the agreement for which publication would compromise security.
(b)(1)The department shall provide to the Secretary of State, in a manner and method to be determined by the department in consultation with the Secretary of State, the following information associated with each person who submits a drivers license application: application, provided that they are not currently registered to vote in California and the information is not subject to transmission to the Secretary of State pursuant to Section 2265.1:
(A)Name.
(B)Date of birth.
(C)Either or both of the following, as contained in the departments records:
(i)Residence address.
(ii)Mailing address.
(D)Digitized signature, as described in Section 12950.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(E)Telephone number, if available.
(F)Email address, if available.
(G)Language preference, if available.
(H)Political party preference, if available.
(I)Whether the person chooses to become a permanent vote by mail voter, if available. (J)(I)Whether the person affirmatively declined to become registered or preregistered to vote during a transaction with the department.
(K)(J)A notation that the applicant has attested that the person meets all voter eligibility requirements, including United States citizenship, specified in Section 2101 and, as applicable, the preregistration eligibility requirements in subdivision (d) of Section 2102.
(L)(K)Other information specified in regulations implementing this chapter.
(2)(A)A completed voter registration application included with a drivers license application and accepted at the department shall be transmitted to the Secretary of State no later than 10 days after the department accepts it.
(B)A completed voter registration application accepted within five days of the last day to register to vote for a federal or statewide election shall be transmitted to the Secretary of State no later than five days after the date of acceptance.
(C)(i)For purposes of establishing the departments transmittal deadlines required by this paragraph and by Section 20504(e) of Title 52 of the United States Code, the completed voter registration application included with the drivers license application shall be deemed accepted on the date the completed voter registration application arrives at the department, whether by mail, in person, electronically, or in another manner, the application contains all of the information in paragraph (1) except to the extent paragraph (1) requires certain information to be provided only if available, and the department approves the documentation of identity submitted by the applicant that is required by the Vehicle Code for the type of license or identification card for which the applicant has applied.
(ii)This subparagraph shall become operative upon the completion of the Digital eXperience Platform project described in Item 2740-001-0044 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Chs. 21 and 69, Stats. 2021), or on July 1, 2025, whichever is earlier.
(3)(A)The department shall accept and transmit a completed voter registration application included with a drivers license application as described in paragraph (2) even if, pursuant to the Vehicle Code, the drivers license application is incomplete or the drivers license or identification card associated with the voter who submitted the voter registration application is inactive due to a failure to pay fees, or any other reason that is unrelated to either of the following:
(i)The departments approval of an applicants identity documentation pursuant to the Vehicle Code.
(ii)An elections officials ability to prevent duplicate voter registrations or preregistrations, to assess the eligibility of the applicant, or to administer voter registration, preregistration, and other elections procedures.
(B)This paragraph shall become operative upon the completion of the Digital eXperience Platform project described in Item 2740-001-0044 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Chs. 21 and 69, Stats. 2021), or on July 1, 2025, whichever is earlier.
(4)(A)The department may provide the records described in paragraph (1) to the Secretary of State before the Secretary of State certifies that all of the conditions set forth in subdivision (e) of this section have been satisfied. Records provided pursuant to this paragraph shall only be used for purposes of outreach and education to eligible voters conducted by the Secretary of State.
(B)The Secretary of State shall provide materials created for purposes of outreach and education as described in this paragraph in languages other than English, as required by the federal Voting Rights Act of 1965 (52 U.S.C. Sec. 10503).
(5)If at the time of the transaction with the department, the person provides a document that demonstrates the person is not a United States citizen, the person shall not be offered the opportunity to attest that the person meets all voter eligibility requirements and the department shall not electronically provide records of that person to the Secretary of State.
(c)The Secretary of State shall not sell, transfer, or allow any third party access to the information acquired from the department pursuant to this chapter without approval of the department, except as permitted by this chapter and Section 2194.
(d)The department shall not electronically provide records of a person who applies for or is issued a drivers license pursuant to Section 12801.9 of the Vehicle Code because the person is unable to submit satisfactory proof that the persons presence in the United States is authorized under federal law.
(e)Except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (b), the department shall commence implementation of this section no later than one year after the Secretary of State certifies all of the following:
(1)The state has a statewide voter registration database that complies with the requirements of the federal Help America Vote Act of 2002 (52 U.S.C. Sec. 20901 et seq.).
(2)The Legislature has appropriated the funds necessary for the Secretary of State and the department to implement and maintain the California New Motor Voter Program.
(3)The regulations required by Section 2277 have been adopted.
(f)The department shall not electronically provide records pursuant to this section that contain a home address designated as confidential pursuant to Section 1808.2, 1808.4, or 1808.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature that the department continue its best practice of sending notice to voters when there is a delay in processing completed voter registration applications. It is further the intent of the Legislature that the notices continue to provide information about alternative options for submitting a voter registration application.
SEC. 3.Section 2265.1 is added to the Elections Code, to read:2265.1.(a)The Department of Motor Vehicles, in consultation with the Secretary of State, shall establish a schedule and method for the department to electronically provide to the Secretary of State the records specified in this section.
(b)(1)This subdivision applies to a person who meets all of the following conditions:
(A)The person is not currently registered to vote in California.
(B)The person submits a drivers license application.
(C)In the course of the persons business with the department, the person has provided documentation demonstrating United States citizenship and that the person is of an eligible age to register or preregister to vote.
(2)For each person who meets the conditions of paragraph (1), the department shall provide to the Secretary of State, in a manner and method to be determined by the department in consultation with the Secretary of State, the following information about the person:
(A)Name.
(B)Date of birth.
(C)Either or both of the following, as contained in the departments records:
(i)Residence address.
(ii)Mailing address.
(D)Digitized signature, as described in Section 12950.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(E)Telephone number, if available.
(F)Email address, if available.
(G)The language in which the person conducted the transaction with the department.
(H)Other information specified in regulations implementing this chapter.
(c)For a person who is currently registered to vote in California and who submits a drivers license application, the department shall provide to the Secretary of State, in a manner and method to be determined by the department and the Secretary of State, information regarding the persons name and address and any additional information required by the Secretary of State, for the purpose of maintaining current information for the persons voter registration.
(d)The department shall not electronically provide records pursuant to this section that contain a home address designated as confidential pursuant to Section 1808.2, 1808.4, or 1808.6 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)This section shall not be construed to amend the substantive qualifications for voter registration in California or to require documentary proof of citizenship for voter registration.
(f)This section shall not be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register a person to vote or to update voter registration information based on information in the possession of the department in the absence of a transaction by the person.
(g)The Secretary of State and the department shall jointly develop a process by which the department, upon obtaining a persons full name, date of birth, drivers license or state identification number, residence address, and mailing address if different from residence address, may use information from the statewide voter registration database to determine whether the person is already registered to vote in the state. The Secretary of State may satisfy the requirement in this subdivision by providing a copy of the statewide voter registration database to the department on a daily basis.
SEC. 4.Section 2266 of the Elections Code is amended to read:2266.(a)The willful, unauthorized disclosure of information obtained from the department pursuant to Section 2265 or 2265.1 to any person, or the use of any false representation to obtain any of that information or the use of any of that information for a purpose other than as stated in Section 2265, 2265 or 2265.1, is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) or imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, 364 days, or both fine and imprisonment.
(b)The Secretary of State shall establish procedures to protect the confidentiality of the information acquired from the department pursuant to Section 2265. 2265 or 2265.1. The disclosure of this information shall be governed by the Information Practices Act of 1977 (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 1798) of Title 1.8 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code), and the Secretary of State shall account for any disclosures, including those due to security breaches, in accordance with that act.
SEC. 5.Section 2267 of the Elections Code is amended to read:2267.(a)(1)If the records of a person designated in paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2265 constitute a completed voter registration application, the Secretary of State shall register the person to vote, or, as applicable, preregister the person to vote, unless any of the following conditions is satisfied:
(1)(A)The persons records, as described in Section 2265, reflect that the person affirmatively declined to become registered or preregistered to vote during a transaction with the department.
(2)(B)The persons records, as described in Section 2265, do not reflect that the person has attested to meeting all voter eligibility requirements specified in Section 2101 or, as applicable, all preregistration eligibility requirements in subdivision (d) of Section 2102.
(3)(C)The Secretary of State determines that the person is ineligible to vote or, as applicable, will be ineligible to vote when the person reaches 18 years of age.
(2)For any person registered pursuant to this subdivision, the statewide voter registration database shall include a notation that the person was registered pursuant to Section 2265.
(b)The records of a person designated in paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2265.1 shall constitute a completed affidavit of registration, and the Secretary of State shall register or preregister that person to vote, as applicable, unless the Secretary of State determines, respectively, that the person is ineligible to vote or will be ineligible to vote when the person reaches 18 years of age. For any person registered pursuant to this subdivision, the statewide voter registration database shall include a notation that the person was registered pursuant to Section 2265.1.
(b)(c)If the record for a person who is registered or preregistered to vote pursuant to this chapter does not provide or contain a party preference, the persons party preference shall be designated as Unknown on a voter registration index under Article 5 (commencing with Section 2183) of Chapter 2, and the person shall otherwise be treated as a No Party Preference voter.
(d)(1)When a person whose information was transmitted to the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 2265.1 becomes registered or preregistered to vote, the appropriate county elections official shall send to the persons address of record, by nonforwardable mail, a notice that the person has been registered or preregistered to vote, as applicable. The notice shall include a postage paid preaddressed return form by which the person may decline to be registered or preregistered, designate a party preference, or select a language preference. The notice may be combined with the notice required under Section 20507(a)(2) of Title 52 of the United States Code. The notice shall also do all of the following:
(A)Offer the person the opportunity to provide a party preference, state that doing so may be required in order to vote in that partys presidential primary election, and state that the person may also provide a party preference via the states online voter registration system.
(B)Offer the person the opportunity to select a language preference.
(C)Include an explanation of the eligibility requirements to register or preregister to vote, and a statement that, if the person is not eligible, the person should decline to register or preregister using the preaddressed return form.
(D)State the penalties for providing false information.
(E)Include a statement that, if the person declines to register or preregister to vote, the fact that the person has declined will remain confidential and will be used only for election administration purposes.
(F)Include a statement that, if the person does not decline to be registered or preregistered to vote, the department office at which the person was registered or preregistered will remain confidential and will be used only for election administration purposes.
(G)Provide information regarding how a person can obtain assistance and additional information about the notice.
(2)If the notice described in paragraph (1) is returned as undeliverable, the county elections official shall send the person a notice pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 2225.
(e)All of the following apply if a person returns the return form described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d):
(1)If the person indicates a party preference, the persons party preference shall be changed and marked as effective as of the date the form is received.
(2)If the person selects a language preference, the language preference shall be retained as part of the persons registration information.
(3)If the person declines to be registered to vote, the persons registration or preregistration shall be canceled, and the person shall be deemed to have never registered or preregistered to vote. Information related to the persons declining to be registered or preregistered to vote shall not be used for any purpose other than the administration of elections.
(4)If the person is registered or preregistered to vote and thereafter returns the form indicating that the person declines to be registered or preregistered to vote, but before returning the form the person votes in an election, the persons declining to register or preregister to vote on the return form shall have no force or effect.
(5)If a person returns a form but does not select or indicate any new information on the form, the form is of no force or effect.
(c)(f)If the Secretary of State receives from the department pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2265 the records of a person who is currently registered to vote, the Secretary of State shall use the information in the records to update the voters registration information. If the Secretary of State does not receive information for the voter pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2265 for which space is provided on the voter registration application, but that information was provided in the voters previous voter registration application, that information from the voters previous voter registration application shall remain part of the voters record. subdivision (c) of Section 2265.1 information that indicates a person who is currently registered to vote has a different name or address than the name or address included in the persons voter registration record, all of the following shall occur:
(1)The Secretary of State shall use the new information to update the name or address in the voters registration record and shall have the voters registration status updated to active.
(2)(A)The appropriate county elections officials shall send to the persons address of record, by forwardable mail, notice of the change and a postage paid preaddressed return form by which the person may verify or correct the information. The notice shall also provide information regarding how a person can obtain assistance and additional information about the notice.
(B)If the person returns the form described in subparagraph (A) indicating that the update to the name or address in the persons registration information was in error, the appropriate county elections officials shall immediately correct the information in the statewide voter registration database.
(g)(1)This subdivision applies to the notices described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) and subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f).
(2)The Secretary of State shall prescribe the form of the notices.
(3)The Secretary of State shall ensure that for each county with citizens of language minorities that qualify under Section 14201 of this code or Section 10503 of Title 52 of the United States Code, the notices shall be translated into all qualifying minority languages for the county, made publicly available, and provided to the county for its use. The Secretary of State shall also ensure that each notice contains, at a minimum, the following information translated into all qualifying minority languages for the county:
(A)Information regarding how a person can obtain assistance in the persons minority language and additional information about the notice.
(B)With respect to the notice described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the following information:
(i)The statement that the person has been registered to vote or preregistered to vote, as applicable.
(ii)The explanation of the eligibility requirements to register or preregister to vote and a statement that, if the person is not eligible, the person should decline to register or preregister to vote.
(C)With respect to the notice described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f), the statement that the persons voter registration information has changed.
(4)The Secretary of State shall promulgate regulations to ensure compliance by counties with this subdivision.
SEC. 6.Section 2270 of the Elections Code is amended to read:2270.(a)If a person who is ineligible to vote becomes registered or preregistered to vote pursuant to this chapter in the absence of a violation by that person of Section 18100, that persons registration or preregistration shall be presumed to have been effected with official authorization and not the fault of that person.
(b)The Secretary of State and the Department of Motor Vehicles shall develop procedures to ensure that a drivers license, identification card, or other identifying information submitted by an applicant pursuant to this chapter is sufficiently evaluated to determine whether the applicant is eligible to register or to preregister to vote and to protect against future erroneous registrations or preregistrations. If it becomes known to the Secretary of State or the department that either the Secretary of State or the department, or both, committed an error resulting in the registration or preregistration of an ineligible person pursuant to this chapter, and unless there is clear and convincing evidence that the person has violated Section 18100, the Secretary of State or the department shall do both of the following:
(1)Immediately contact the person to inform the person of the erroneous registration or preregistration.
(2)Provide the person a letter asserting that the Secretary of State or the department, or both, was responsible for the erroneous registration or preregistration. A copy of this letter shall be maintained permanently in the persons file with the department and shall be accessible to the person upon request.
SEC. 7.Section 2278 is added to the Elections Code, to read:2278.(a)A voter registration agency, as defined in Section 2401, shall annually provide to the Secretary of State information describing each designated office under the agencys supervision, the type of services the office provides, and a designated voter registration contact for that office. At the earliest practicable time, the Secretary of State or the Secretary of States designee shall assess which voter registration agencies, in the regular course of business and substantially in accordance with the procedures set forth in this chapter that apply to the department, collect sufficient information from applicants to confirm eligibility for registration or to update information for an existing registration, or both.
(b)(1)When the Secretary of State or the Secretary of States designee determines that during the regular course of business a voter registration agency collects the necessary information either to confirm eligibility for voter registration or to update information for an existing registration, or both, the Secretary of State shall establish a schedule by which the agency shall begin prospectively providing to the Secretary of State electronic records regarding individuals eligible to register to vote or individuals with updated voter registration information, or both if applicable.
(2)When the voter registration agency provides, and the Secretary of State or the county elections official processes, the electronic records described in paragraph (1), they shall do so substantially in accordance with the procedures and requirements set forth in this chapter that apply to the department, subject to any modifications necessary to comply with federal law.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the Secretary of State may develop procedures for processing electronic records received from an agency without an image of the applicants signature.
(4)This section shall not be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register individuals to vote or to update voter registration information based on information previously in the possession of the Secretary of State, the department, or another voter registration agency.
SEC. 8.Section 2401 of the Elections Code is amended to read:2401.For purposes of this chapter, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Voter preference form means the form described in Section 20506(a)(6)(B) of Title 52 of the United States Code.
(b)Voter registration agency means either of the following:
(1)A department, division, or office of state or local government, or a program supported by state funds, that is designated by executive order of the Governor or pursuant to the federal National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (52 U.S.C. Sec. 20501 et seq.) seq.), or that is designated by the Secretary of State, as a voter registration agency.
(2)A private entity under contract with a designated voter registration agency to provide services or assistance on behalf of the designated voter registration agency.
SEC. 9.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 10.(a)This act shall become operative on the earlier of the following:
(1)January 1, 2026.
(2)Five days after the date the Secretary of State certifies that the information technology infrastructure to substantially implement this act is functional.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the Secretary of State may perform administrative actions necessary to implement this act prior to the operative date of this act.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 18, 2023 | May 18 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 8, 2023 | May 8 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 1, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 3. Page 904.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on TRANS. (Ayes 6. Noes 1. Page 424.) (March 21). Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Mar 13, 2023 | Set for hearing March 21. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A. and TRANS. |
| Feb 21, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 8, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation |
Passed |
|
| Mar 21, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Transportation] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AAPIs For Civic Empowerment - Education Fund | ** Support | |
| ACCE Action | ** Support | |
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| AHRI for Justice | ** Support | |
| Alliance for San Diego | ** Support | |
| Alliance San Diego | ** Support | |
| Asian American Senior Citizens Service Center | ** Support | |
| Asian Immigrant Women Advocates | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific Environmental Network | ** Support | |
| Bay Rising | ** Support | |
| Black Alliance for Just Immigration | ** Support | |
| California Black Power Network | ** Support | |
| California Calls | ** Support | |
| California Grassroots Democracy Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative | ** Support | |
| California Immigrant Policy Center | ** Support | |
| California Native Vote Project | ** Support | |
| Californians United for a Responsible Budget | ** Support | |
| Campaign Legal Center | ** Support | |
| Catalyst California | ** Support | |
| Center for Secure and Modern Elections | ** Support | |
| Central Coast Alliance United for a Sustainable Economy | ** Support | |
| Chinese Progressive Association | ** Support | |
| CHISPA | ** Support | |
| Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights | ** Support | |
| Communities for a New California Education Fund | ** Support | |
| Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice | ** Support | |
| Community Coalition | ** Support | |
| Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement | ** Support | |
| Courage California | ** Support | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Support | |
| Empowering Pacific Islander Communities | ** Support | |
| EPIC | ** Support | |
| Filipino Advocates for Justice | ** Support | |
| Greater Sacramento Urban League | ** Support | |
| Hmong Innovating Politics | ** Support | |
| Homeboy Industries | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Support | |
| Inland Empire United | ** Support | |
| InnerCity Struggle | ** Support | |
| Institute for Responsive Government | ** Support | |
| Jakara Movement | ** Support | |
| Khmer Girls in Action | ** Support | |
| League Of Women Voters Of California | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy | ** Support | |
| Mi Familia Vota | ** Support | |
| NALEO Educational Fund | ** Against | |
| National Union Of Healthcare Workers | ** Support | |
| NextGen California | ** Support | |
| Oakland Rising | ** Support | |
| OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates: East Bay Chapter | ** Support | |
| OC Action | ** Support | |
| Oca National | ** Support | |
| OCA San Mateo Chapter | ** Support | |
| Orange County Asian and Pacific Islander Community Alliance | ** Support | |
| Orange County Congregation Community Organization | ** Support | |
| Orange County Environmental Justice | ** Support | |
| Orange County Voter Information Project | ** Support | |
| Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans - PANA | ** Support | |
| PICO California | ** Support | |
| pilipino workers center | ** Support | |
| Powerca Action | ** Support | |
| Resilience Orange County | ** Support | |
| Safe Return Project | ** Support | |
| San Diego Pride | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Rising | ** Support | |
| SEIU CA State Council | ** Support | |
| South Bay Youth Changemakers | ** Support | |
| Strategic Concepts in Organizing and Policy Education | ** Support | |
| UC Student Association | ** Support | |
| Vietnamese Rainbow of Orange County | ** Support | |
| VOTEVETS | ** Support | |
| Working Partnerships USA | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 846 (Limón) - Voter registration: California New Motor Voter Program
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 846 would create a back-end automated voter registration system for registering voters via the California New Motor Voter Program (CNMVP) at the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV), as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Secretary of State (SOS) indicates that it would incur first-year costs of $3.9 million, and $2.7 million annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund).
- DMV’s administrative costs have yet to be determined, but would likely be, at a minimum, in the millions of dollars annually (special fund).
- By imposing additional requirements on local elections officials, this bill creates a state-mandated local program. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines that the provisions of this bill create a new program or impose a higher level of service on local agencies, local agencies could claim reimbursement of those costs. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant (General Fund).
- The bill would result in unknown, potentially significant costs to other impacted state agencies, including the University of California, California State University, and the community colleges.
Background:
In 1993, the federal government enacted the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA), commonly referred to as Motor Voter, to make it easier for Americans to register to vote and maintain their registration. Among other provisions in the NVRA, DMV provides customers the opportunity to register to vote when completing an application for a driver’s license or an identification card, when renewing a driver’s license, an identification card, or when a change of address transaction takes place. However, the NVRA also requires states to designate other agencies as “voter registration agencies” and provides an opportunity to register to vote for individuals interacting with the specified agencies. This includes offices that provide public assistance and offices that provide services to individuals with disabilities. In California, the Governor is also able to designate additional voter registration agencies.
In 2015, the Legislature enacted AB 1461 (Gonzalez), which provides that every person who submits an application for a driver's license, state identification card, or provides the DMV with a change of address, and who attests that they meet all voter eligibility requirements, is automatically registered to vote, unless that person opts out, as specified. Specifically, DMV, in consultation with SOS, is required to establish a schedule and method for it to electronically provide to SOS the records of each person who submits an application for a driver's license, state identification card, or provides the DMV with a change of address. The transmission of an individual’s record from the DMV to SOS constitutes a completed affidavit of voter registration unless the person affirmatively declines to register or preregister to vote at DMV, the person does not attest to meeting all voter eligibility requirements while at DMV, or SOS determines that the person is not eligible to register to vote. DMV is also prohibited from electronically providing the records of a person who is issued a driver's license pursuant to specified provisions of law because that person is unable to establish satisfactory proof that their presence in the United States is authorized under federal law.
Since the launch of the CNMVP in 2018, the DMV has faced a number of challenges related to DMV transactions and voter registration. In May 2018, a software error potentially affected approximately 77,000 voter records generated at the DMV. This error reportedly resulted in two registration forms for a single voter. In response, county elections officials contacted potentially affected voters and the software error was fixed.
In September 2018, the DMV reported 23,000 registration errors that stemmed from DMV technicians working with multiple screens and registration information being improperly merged. According to DMV, 4,600 individuals did not complete a voter registration affidavit, but had their information sent to SOS. In response, the DMV sent the 23,000 customers a letter notifying them of the problem and the SOS cancelled the 4,600 registrations that it received.
In October 2018, the DMV sent SOS a letter indicating that 1,500 customers may have been registered to vote in error when DMV technicians processed customer requests at field offices to change voter eligibility responses on driver license applications. DMV indicated that none of the processing errors were the fault of the customer and none were undocumented immigrants.
In response to these issues, in September 2018, Governor Brown directed the Department of Finance (DOF) to conduct a performance audit of the DMV’s information technology and customer service functions. In January 2019, Governor Newsom ordered an accelerated review of the independent audit of DMV initiated by Governor Brown. This was a performance audit of the DMV’s Information Technology and Customer Service Functions and publically released on March 1, 2019.
As part of the assessment, the report found and identified 83,684 records shown as duplicates in the SOS data set because they were sent initially to SOS with a blank “Political Party” field value and later the same records were resent with the corrected value of “No Party Preference” in the same field. However, this action did not have an impact on voter eligibility.
As a result, (DOF) released a five-part assessment of the Motor Voter application on August 9, 2019. The first four assessments were performed against an established set of evaluation criteria to highlight risks and develop recommendations for DMV and SOS (when applicable) in order to improve and ultimately enhance the effectiveness of the CNMVP. The fifth assessment, the Validation Report, was limited to providing the results of data comparisons and did not include an evaluation of the results.
While there were many recommendations for improvement, the fourth assessment examined the quality assurance of the CNMVP. The objective of this assessment was to review the Motor Voter data transfer processes against established evaluation criteria to highlight risks that, if not addressed, would adversely affect the realization of the intended benefits of the CNMVP and develop recommendations for improvement of the ongoing program’s effectiveness. From this assessment, stakeholders received nine recommendations for review and consideration for implementation. These recommendations sought to improve or enhance the overall effectiveness of the CNMVP or the Motor Voter application and many of the recommendations were implemented.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Keep the current CNMVP for individuals who are not currently registered to vote in California, whose information is not subject to transmission to SOS, and who either submit an application for a driver’s license, identification card, or notifies the DMV of a change of address. Provide that if at the time of the transaction with the DMV, the person provides a document that demonstrates the person is not a United States citizen, the person shall not be offered the opportunity to attest that the person meets all voter eligibility requirements and the DMV shall not electronically provide records of that person to the SOS.
- Require the DMV, in consultation with SOS, to establish a schedule and method for the DMV to electronically provide records to SOS, as specified.
- Provide the provisions related to the transfer of records between the DMV and the SOS shall not be construed to amend the substantive qualifications for voter registration in California or to require documentary proof of citizenship for voter registration.
- Provide the provisions related to the transfer of records between the DMV and the SOS shall not be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register individuals to vote or to update voter registration information based on information in the possession of the DMV before the person’s transaction.
- Require SOS and DMV to jointly develop a process by which DMV, upon obtaining a person’s full name, date of birth, driver’s license or state identification number, residence address, and mailing address if different from residence address, may use the information from the statewide voter registration database to determine whether the person is already registered to vote in California. Provide that the SOS may satisfy this requirement by providing a copy of the statewide voter registration database to the DMV on a daily basis.
- Change the maximum imprisonment penalty from one year to 364 days for the willful, unauthorized disclosure of information obtained from the DMV to any person, or the use of any false representation to obtain any of that information or the use of any of that information for a purpose other than prescribed in existing law, as specified.
- Require county elections officials to send to the person’s address of record, by nonforwardable mail, a notice that the person has been registered or preregistered to vote, as applicable, when a person whose information was transmitted by the DMV becomes registered or preregistered to vote, as specified.
- Require SOS and DMV to develop procedures to ensure that a driver’s license, identification card, or other identifying information submitted by an applicant pursuant to this chapter is sufficiently evaluated to determine whether the applicant is eligible to register or to preregister to vote and to protect against future erroneous registrations or preregistrations.
- Provide that if it becomes known to the SOS or DMV that either the SOS or DMV, or both, committed an error resulting in the registration or preregistration of an ineligible person, as specified, and unless there is clear and convincing evidence that the person has a specified provision of existing law, the SOS or DMV shall do both of the following: (1) immediately contact the person to inform the person of the erroneous registration or preregistration, and (2) provide the person a letter asserting that the SOS or DMV, or both, was responsible for the erroneous registration or preregistration. Require a copy of this letter be maintained permanently in the person’s file with the DMV and be accessible to the person upon request.
- Require voter registration agencies to annually provide to the SOS information describing each designated office under the agency’s supervision, the type of services the office provides, and a designated voter registration contact for that office. Requires, at the earliest practicable time, the SOS or their designee to assess which voter registration agencies, in the regular course of business and substantially, collect sufficient information from applicants to confirm eligibility for registration or to update information for an existing registration, or both, as specified.
- Require SOS to assess and, if necessary, establish a schedule by which the voter registration agency shall begin prospectively providing to the SOS electronic records regarding individuals eligible to register to vote or individuals with updated voter registration information, or both if applicable, as specified.
- Provide, notwithstanding any other law, the SOS may develop procedures for processing electronic records received from an agency without an image of the applicant’s signature, as specified. Provides these provisions are not to be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register individuals to vote or to update voter registration information based on information previously in the possession of the SOS, the DMV, or another voter registration agency.
- Require this bill become operative on January 1, 2026, or five days after the date the SOS certifies that the information technology infrastructure to substantially implement the provisions of this bill is functional. Provides that the SOS may, commencing January 1, 2024, perform administrative actions necessary to implement the bill’s provisions.
Related Legislation:
- AB 796 (Berman, Chapter 314, Statutes of 2021), among other provisions, made various changes to the timing and transfer of voter information data from the DMV to SOS.
- SB 583 (Newman, 2021), substantially similar to this bill, would have created a back-end automated voter registration system for registering voters at the DMV, as specified. The bill was not considered by the Assembly Committee on Elections.
- AB 1137 (Mullin, 2021) would have required SOS to provide a report to the Legislature regarding the process and infrastructure of existing voter registration agencies, as specified. The bill was amended to address a different policy area.
- SB 57 (Bates, 2020) would have changed the CNMVP from an opt-out to an opt-in program. SB 57 failed passage in the Senate Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments.
- SB 511 (Moorlach, 2019) would have required the establishment of a committee including representatives of the SOS, DMV, and counties, for the purpose of facilitating the sharing of information necessary to implement CNMVP. SB 511 failed passage in the Senate Committee on Transportation.
- AB 1461 (Gonzalez, Chapter 729, Statutes of 2015) provided for every person who has a driver's license or state identification card and who is eligible to register to vote to be automatically registered to vote at the DMV, unless that person opts out. A prior version of AB 1461 included a back-end registration model similar to SB 846. However, the bill was amended to the front-end opt-out system that was subsequently chaptered.
Staff Comments:
This bill would create a back-end automated voter registration system for most individuals who interact with the DMV. This is similar to a system created in Oregon. In Oregon, if the Department of Transportation has information indicating that an individual is eligible to register to vote and the government has information to verify individuals' eligibility to vote, then the individual is automatically registered to vote. Individuals will have the option to opt-out of being registered, typically through a notice in the mail.
SOS indicates that changes included in this bill would require modifications to its VoteCal System and corresponding changes to County Election Management Systems (EMS). The impact to SOS for these changes would result in increased cost for contractor services to perform, among things, the following:
- VoteCal would need to be able to send current voter registration information to DMV so they could determine if an individual is registered or not in real time and direct their information into the appropriate workflow.
- VoteCal system changes would be needed to handle the two different data sets, integration services between VoteCal and the county EMS would also need to be updated, and system changes would also be required to account for the generation of new notices that are required to be mailed to voters.
- Additional VoteCal system changes would be needed to comply with adding additional automatic voter registration from other Voter Registration Agencies, and the processing of that data.
SOS also anticipates (1) the need for additional staff, (2) increased costs for translation, (3) increased mailing costs, and (4) costs to promulgate regulations. The bill would likely also result in additional workload and reporting costs to other entities, including counties and their social services offices, as well by the University of California, California State University, and the Community Colleges.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION
Senator Lena Gonzalez, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 846 Hearing Date: 4/25/2023
Author: | Limón | ||
Version: | 2/17/2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jacob O'Connor | ||
SUBJECT: Voter registration: California New Motor Voter Program
DIGEST: This bill would create a back-end automated voter registration system for registering voters via the California New Motor Voter Program at the
California Department of Motor Vehicles that will be implemented January 1, 2026.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Pursuant to the National Voter Registration Act, requires each state’s driver’s license application submitted to their motor vehicle authority serve as a simultaneous voter registration application unless the applicant fails to sign the voter registration application. (52 U.S. Code § 20504)
Existing state law:
- Provides that a person is entitled to register to vote who is a United States citizen, a resident of California, not imprisoned for the conviction of a felony, and at least 18 years of age at the time of the next election. (Elections Code (Elec) §2101)
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) and the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to establish the California New Motor Voter Program (CNMVP) for the purpose of increasing opportunities for voter registration by any person who is qualified to vote. (Elec §2263)
- Requires the DMV, in consultation with the SOS, to establish a schedule and method to electronically provide to the SOS the following information associated with each person who applies for, renews, or changes an address for a driver’s license or identification card issued by the DMV: (Elec §2265)
- Name;
- Date of birth;
- The residence and/or mailing address in the DMV’s records;
- Language preference;
- Political party preference;
- Whether the person chooses to become a permanent vote by mail voter;
- Whether the person affirmatively declined to become registered to vote;
- An attestation by the applicant that they meet all voter eligibility requirements, including United States citizenship; and
- Other specified information
- Provides that the DMV shall not electronically provide records of a person unable to submit satisfactory proof that the person’s presence in the United States is authorized under federal law or that contain a home address designated as confidential.
- Requires the SOS to establish procedures to protect the confidentiality of the information acquired from the DMV and requires the SOS to account for any disclosures, including those due to security breaches. (Elec §2266)
- Provides that the records of a person who registers to vote pursuant to the CNMVP shall constitute a completed affidavit of registration and the SOS shall register or preregister the person to vote, unless any of the following conditions is satisfied: (Elec §2267)
- The person’s records reflect that person affirmatively declined to become registered to vote during a transaction with the DMV;
- The person’s records do not reflect that person has attested to meeting all voter eligibility requirements; or
- The SOS otherwise determines that the person is ineligible to vote.
- States that if a person who is ineligible to vote becomes registered or preregistered to vote through the CNMVP and votes or attempts to vote they shall be presumed to have acted with official authorization and shall not be guilty of fraudulently attempting to vote unless that person willfully attempted to vote knowing that they were not entitled to do so. (Elec §2271)
This bill:
- Requires the DMV to not offer an individual the opportunity to attest that they meet voter eligibility requirement or to transfer their record to the SOS if, at the time of transaction with the DMV, the person provides a document demonstrating that they are not a United States citizen.
- Requires the SOS and the DMV to jointly develop a process by which the DMV, upon obtaining a person’s specified identifying information may use information from the statewide voter registration database to determine whether that person is already registered to vote in the state.
- Requires the DMV to provide the SOS information about any person not currently registered to vote in California who submits a driver’s license application and has, during their transaction with the DMV, provided documentation demonstrating United States citizenship and that they are of an eligible age to register or preregister to vote. This information includes:
- Name;
- Date of birth;
- Residence address and/or mailing address;
- Digitized signature, as specified;
- The language in which the person conducted the transaction; and
- Other information, as specified.
- Requires the DMV to provide to the SOS information regarding any person who is currently registered to vote in California and who submits a driver’s license application. This information includes:
- Name;
- Address, and
- Any additional information required by the SOS for maintaining information for the person’s voter registration.
- Requires the DMV, in consultation with the SOS, to establish a schedule and method for the DMV to electronically provide the SOS these records.
- Requires the SOS and DMV to develop procedures to ensure that identifying information submitted by an applicant as part of a DMV transaction is sufficiently evaluated to determine whether the applicant is eligible to register to vote and to protect against future erroneous registrations or preregistrations.
- Provides that these records constitute a completed affidavit of registration and requires the SOS to register or preregister that person to vote unless the SOS determines that person to be ineligible.
- Requires that when a person is registered to vote pursuant to this program the appropriate county elections official shall send to that person by mail a notice of registration. This notice shall:
- Include a postage-paid preaddressed return form;
- Offer the person the opportunity to decline registration;
- Offer the person the opportunity to provide party preference and to select a language preference;
- Explain the eligibility of requirements to register to vote and a statement that if ineligible, the person should decline using the form;
- State the penalties for providing false information; and
- Provide information regarding how a person can obtain assistance and additional information about the notice.
- Requires that if a person returns a form for the notice their information will be appropriately updated. If the person declines registration their registration shall be canceled and the person shall be deemed to have never registered unless that person has already voted, whereupon the form shall have no force or effect.
- Requires that when the SOS receives information from this program on a person who has already voted, the SOS shall use this new information to update the voter’s registration record. Then the appropriate county elections official shall send to that person by mail notice of any change with a postage-paid preaddressed return form by which the person can verify or correct the information.
- Requires the SOS to prescribe the form of these notices and ensure that notices shall be translated into all qualifying minority languages for a county and that all notices in a county contain a basic description of the subject of the notice in all qualifying minority languages in the county.
- Requires that in the event the SOS or DMV become aware of an error resulting in registration of an ineligible person they shall immediately contact that person to inform them and provide a letter asserting that the SOS or DMV was responsible for the erroneous registration or preregistration and keep a copy of this letter in the person’s file with the DMV.
- Maintains the current CNMVP for individuals who are not currently registered to vote in California and whose information is not subject to transmission to the SOS under this bill because they do not conduct their transaction with the DMV using documentation that proves citizenship.
- Expands the definition of “voter registration agency” to include entities designated by the SOS.
- Requires voter registration agencies to annually provide the SOS information describing each designated office under the agency’s supervision, the services they provide, and a designated voter registration contact for that office.
- Requires the SOS or their designee to assess which voter registration agencies collect sufficient information from applicants to confirm eligibility for registration or to update information for an existing registration. If the agency collects such information the SOS shall establish a schedule for that agency to prospectively provide the SOS electronic records regarding individuals eligible to vote or with updated voter registration information, as specified.
- Requires that the statewide voter registration database to include a notation describing if that person was registered pursuant to the old CNMVP or the new method established by this bill.
- Changes the maximum imprisonment penalty for the willful, unauthorized disclosure, obtaining, or use of information from the DMV from one year to 364 days.
- Requires this bill become operative on January 1, 2026 or five days after the date the SOS certifies that the information technology infrastructure to implement the provisions of this bill is functional. Provides that the SOS may perform administrative actions to implement this bill commencing January 1, 2024.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of bill. According to the author, “SB 846 builds on California’s existing Partial Automatic Voter Registration (AVR) system to further streamline voter registration. Utilizing procedures that are largely already in place at the DMV, this bill moves to a Secure AVR system. This upgrade will register millions more eligible Californians, bringing people of color, young people, and formerly incarcerated people into the political process. Similarly, this bill will update millions of existing voter registrations, ensuring more voters receive their mail-in ballots at the correct address and can vote without issues. Most importantly, this upgrade will significantly enhance protections for non-citizens by reducing the risk of unintentional registrations at the DMV. Oregon, Colorado, Nevada, Delaware, Massachusetts, Alaska, and Washington, D.C. have all already adopted Secure AVR, and California can join these states at the forefront of AVR.”
- National Voter Registration Act. In 1993, the federal government enacted the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA), commonly referred to as the "motor voter" law, to make it easier for Americans to register to vote and maintain their registration. Among other provisions in the NVRA, the DMV provides customers the opportunity to register to vote when completing an application for or a renewal of a driver’s license or an identification card and when a change of address transactions takes place. The NVRA also requires states to designate other agencies as “voter registration agencies” and provides an opportunity to register to vote for individuals interacting with the specified agencies. This includes offices that provide public assistance and offices that provide services to individuals with disabilities. In California, the Governor is also able to designate additional voter registration agencies.
- California New Motor Voter Program. In 2015, the Legislature passed and Governor Brown signed AB 1461 (Gonzalez, Chapter 729, Statutes of 2015), which provides for the automatic voter registration of every person who submits an application for a driver's license or state identification card (DL/ID), or provides DMV with a change of address, and who attests that they meet all voter eligibility requirements, unless that person opts out. In April 2018, California officially launched the CNMVP.
Since 2018, the CNMVP has contributed to a rise of registered voters in California. According to the most recent report of registration from the SOS, there are 21,940,874 registered voters in California out of an estimated 26,876,800 Californians who are eligible to register to vote, meaning that approximately 81.63% of eligible Californians are registered to vote. To compare, in January 2018, there were 18,980,481 registered voters or about 75.69%.
- Implementation of the CNMVP has been difficult. Since the launch of the CNMVP the DMV faced several challenges with transactions and voter registration. In 2018 three different incidents affected the records of approximately 100,000 customers. In perhaps the most dramatic incident, 1,500 customers may have been registered to vote in error when DMV technicians incorrectly processed customer requests at field offices to change voter eligibility responses on driver’s license applications.
In response to issues related to the DMV, in September 2018, Governor Brown directed the Department of Finance to conduct a performance audit of the DMV’s information technology and customer service functions resulting in the implementation of a quality assurance process to ensure the timely release of records from DMV to SOS and establishing data governance policies including data retention and sharing.
Problems with bringing this system into compliance with the NVRA led to a lawsuit by the League of Women Voters, which was settled with provisions regarding the CNMVP. However, this initial settlement was violated leading to registration delays for thousands of voters and causing the settlement to be extended with new terms. Many of these terms were codified into statute by AB 796 (Berman, Chapter 314, Statutes of 2021), in recognition of their efficacy in improving the functioning of the CNMVP.
- Creating a back-end automatic voter-registration system. This bill would create a new process for voter registration under the CNMVP. In the current “front-end” system, DMV customers who attest they are eligible to vote automatically have their information transferred to the SOS, unless they opt-out. SB 846 instead requires DMV to implement a new “back-end” system, whereby DMV customers who provide proof of U.S. citizenship (such as a U.S. passport or birth certificate) during their transaction automatically have their information transferred to the SOS.
In order to implement this, the DMV will have to check a client’s personal information provided during a transaction against a database provided by the SOS of registered voters. If a person is already registered to vote they will not be asked to register at the DMV, but their information shall be sent to the SOS which will check it against their current information and update their records if there is a difference. If they perform an update the SOS will then send a letter to the client alerting them of this and offering them the opportunity to correct the change if the new information is wrong.
If a person is not registered to vote then the DMV will have to assess the documents they used to apply for their license. If those documents prove that they are not a US citizen, they shall not be asked to register and their information will not be provided to the SOS. If their documents neither prove nor disprove their citizenship status, they shall go through the current, front-end, system where they are asked to attest to voter registration questions, offered the opportunity to deny registration, and then their information is then sent to the SOS if they do not deny.
If a person’s documents prove that they are citizens, their information shall be transmitted to the SOS for registration. Information provided during the driver’s license application will be used to complete their registration, which will not include party preference or language preference. Then the SOS shall mail to a person a notice of their registration which shall offer them the opportunity to deny registration, or provide language and party preference information.
- Registration rates and false registrations. Two major goals of this legislation are too increase voter registration rates in California and protect people from accidently registering to vote illegally. The evidence regarding the efficacy of “back-end” systems in providing these benefits is mixed. A study of Colorado, which transitioned form a “front-end” to a “back-end” system, found this transition resulted in a sudden, large increase in the rate at which DMV patrons registered to vote. However, other research comparing states with “front-end” and “back-end” systems has found little difference in rates. For a full discussion refer to the analysis by the Senate Committee on Elections.
- DMV wait times. DMV implementation of the federal REAL ID Act led to significant wait times and increased workload at DMV field offices as these transaction take longer to process than noncompliant transactions. Since peak wait times in 2018, DMV has made significant changes to their processes to move transactions that can be done online out of the field offices and cut transaction time at the field offices. It is possible that doing voter registration on the back-end will decrease DMV transaction times, but it is unclear by how much, if at all. Much of DMV’s current process has migrated online. DMV customers are encouraged to fill out their DL/ID application, including motor voter questions, online prior to coming to the field office and may be able to skip the field office entirely. In fact, it may be more likely that a back-end system will increase wait times, because under the current driver’s license system individuals do not have to specify ahead of time what types of documents they will be using to prove identity. As such, the DMV will not be able to determine how to route them through this new system until they reach the field office and provide their documents. In addition to the time it may take for a DMV staff member to evaluate an identifying document, forms which could have been filled out online will have to be done in-person if a person is then routed through the current CMVP at the field office.
- Complexity and implementation concerns. The DMV has a poor history of implementing automatic voter registration programs. This new back-end system seems substantially more complicated than the current system. It requires several additional transfers of information between the DMV, SOS, and client/voter. Each of these steps represents a new potential point of failure. Given the difficulty the DMV had in implementing the current system, it seems plausible they will face similar difficulty in implementing this system, leading to further confusion and potential lawsuits.
- Slow your (voter) rolls? The DMV is currently undergoing a modernization of its underlying IT system, which creates a layer of complexity for any additional IT projects the DMV might take on, including creating a back-end voter registration system. This process is expected to be completed in 2027, but this bill is to be implemented in 2027.
Additionally, an analysis of other state’s automatic voter systems indicated that coordination is key to the success of an automated system. While coordination does occur in California, a deeper analysis may be needed to determine the feasibility for developing a new process, the cost, and whether each entity (DMV, SOS, and counties) possess the technological infrastructure needed to perform the bill’s required tasks effectively. A delay to 2027 may allow time for these groups to meet and coordinate in addition to allowing for the IT modernization to be completed. As this bill moves through the process, the author may wish to consider amending the bill to delay implementation and establish a working group of the DMV, SOS, and county election officials to prepare a plan to successfully implement this new program.
- Double Referral. This bill was double-referred to the Senate Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments where it was heard on March 21, 2023 and was passed on a 6-1 vote.
Related Legislation:
AB 796 (Berman, Chapter 314, Statutes of 2021) – Made various changes to the timing and transfer of voter information data from the DMV to SOS to align with the settlement of the lawsuit with the League of Women Voters.
SB 57 (Bates, 2020) – Would have changed the CNMVP from an opt-out to an opt-in program. This bill failed passage in the Senate Elections Committee.
SB 511 (Moorlach, 2019) – Would have required the establishment of a committee including representatives of the SOS, DMV, and counties, for the purpose of facilitating the sharing of information necessary to implement CNMVP. This bill failed passage in the Senate Committee on Transportation.
AB 1461 (Gonzalez, Chapter 729, Statutes of 2015) – Provided for every person who has a driver's license or state identification card and who is eligible to register to vote to be automatically registered to vote at the DMV, unless that person opts out. A prior version of AB 1461 included a back-end registration model similar to SB 583 (Newman, 2021). However, the bill was amended to the front-end opt-out system that was subsequently chaptered.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Unknown
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday, April 19, 2023.)
SUPPORT:
AAPIs For Civic Empowerment - Education Fund
ACCE Action
Ahri for Justice
Alliance San Diego
Asian American Senior Citizens Service Center
Asian Immigrant Women Advocates
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Bay Rising
Black Alliance for Just Immigration
California Black Power Network
California Calls
California Grassroots Democracy Coalition
California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Native Vote Project
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Campaign Legal Center
Catalyst California
Center for Secure and Modern Elections
Central Coast Alliance United for a Sustainable Economy (CAUSE)
Chinese Progressive Association
Chispa
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA)
Communities for a New California Education Fund
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice (CURYJ)
Community Coalition
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement (COPE)
Courage California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Empowering Pacific Islander Communities (EPIC)
Filipino Advocates for Justice
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Hmong Innovating Politics
Homeboy Industries
Initiate Justice
Inland Empire United
InnerCity Struggle
Institute for Responsive Government
Jakara Movement
Khmer Girls in Action
Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy
Mi Familia Vota
National Union of Healthcare Workers
NextGen California
Oakland Rising
OC Action
OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates: East Bay Chapter (OCA-East Bay)
OCA National
OCA San Mateo Chapter
Orange County Congregation Community Organization (OCCCO)
Orange County Asian & Pacific Islander Community Alliance (OCAPICA)
Orange County Environmental Justice
Orange County Voter Information Project
Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans - PANA
PICO California
Pilipino Workers Center
PowerCA Action
Resilience Orange County
Safe Return Project
San Diego Pride
San Francisco Rising
SEIU CA State Council
South Bay Youth Changemakers
Strategic Concepts in Organizing and Policy Education (SCOPE)
UC Student Association (UCSA)
Vietnamese Rainbow of Orange County
Votevets
Working Partnerships USA
OPPOSITION:
ACLU California Action
League of Women Voters of California
Naleo Educational Fund
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to AAPI FORCE-EF, the sponsors of the bill, “Because of our experience and expertise in engaging voters year round, we recognize the importance of the reforms that SB 846 would promote for a truly authentic and representative democracy in California. SB 846 would establish a secure automatic voter registration (SAVR) system in California to help register millions of additional eligible voters, create more accurate voter rolls, and strengthen protections for non-citizen Californians.”
“We believe wholeheartedly in the promise of a SAVR system. Substantial evidence shows that Secure AVR significantly increases registration rates. In a 2022 Stanford study, Professors Rodden and Grimmer study how registration rates at the DMV surged exactly when Colorado shifted from Partial AVR (California’s current system) to Secure AVR. Colorado went from a Partial AVR system with a 65% declination rate to a Secure AVR system where only 1% of people who receive the post-transaction mailer decline. This before-and-after study of DMV registration rates in a single state is the best way to isolate and study the impact of the change.”
“The SAVR improvement to the current system would ensure that California’s electorate actually reflects the diversity of our state. Asian American, Black and Latinx voters are all underrepresented among registered voters, and SB 846 would help eliminate voter registration as a barrier to civic participation among California’s marginalized communities and voters of color. The evidence of this for Asian American voter participation is particularly poignant in Oregon, which has implemented a SAVR system. A study from USC by Eric McGhee and Mindy Romero found that Asian Americans were 6% more likely than other Oregonians to use back-end AVR for registration. By contrast, Asian Americans were actually slightly less likely than other Californians to use partial AVR for registration. This difference suggests that if California adopted back-end AVR, Asian Americans would be more likely to use it, and would be registered in greater numbers than under the current system…”
“Recognizing the number of immigrants and non-citizens who call California home, SB 846 takes significant steps to prevent inadvertent registration by non-citizens, protecting the integrity of our elections and giving non-citizens added peace of mind. With more streamlined and efficient ways to register and update existing registrations, California’s voter rolls will be more accurate and inclusive than ever, a key benefit that election administrators and grassroots democracy organizations alike will support.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to a coalition letter from the registered opposition, “Although we very much share the goals of increasing California’s voter registration rate and protecting ineligible individuals from accidental registration, we believe that the approach proposed by SB 846 has significant potential to increase voter confusion, incorrectly deny eligible voters registration opportunities, create erroneous registrations, and strip important voter preference information from registration records…
“The signatories to this letter receive detailed voter registration processing data from the DMV and regularly consult with the Secretary of State and the DMV on the effective implementation of the New Motor Voter Program. Despite the information and insights that this access has provided us, we have not seen any evidence that the current system results in the accidental registration of a significant number of ineligible people…
“Although SB 846 would replace this self-attestation system with one in which the DMV determines customers’ level of access to voter registration opportunities, it provides no guidance for how the DMV would make such an important determination. The bill language does not specify whether voter eligibility would be decided by individual DMV field office technicians – which would likely create significant risk of erroneous, arbitrary, or unfair decisions – or by some software that the DMV would need to develop…
“In addition to potentially increasing the risk of both erroneous registrations and the accompanying legal consequences of such registrations for ineligible people, SB 846 could also deteriorate the quality of California’s voter registration records and make it harder for some voters to participate in future elections. SB 846’s back-end model would remove all voter registration questions and information from certain DMV transactions and automatically register to vote any customer the DMV has deemed eligible unless the customer completes and returns an opt-out postcard mailed to them after their DMV transaction. We know that many people do not receive or do not notice these sorts of postcards…
“A significant majority of states that have adopted AVR policies use a front-end opt-out model, and studies have indicated that the rare states that have chosen to adopt the back-end opt-out model do “not produce higher registration rates than states that chose a front-end opt-out model.” Instead of placing false hopes in a back-end Motor Voter registration system, California should focus its resources on more effective, evidence-based approaches to increasing voter registration and closing turnout disparities.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB Hearing Date: 3/21/23
Author: | |||
Version: | 2/17/23 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Scott Matsumoto | ||
Subject: Voter registration: California New Motor Voter Program
DIGEST
This bill creates a back-end automated voter registration system for registering voters via the California New Motor Voter Program (CNMVP) at the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV), as specified.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides that a person is entitled to register to vote who is a United States citizen, a resident of California, not imprisoned for the conviction of a felony, and at least 18 years of age at the time of the next election.
- Permits a person who is at least 16 years old, and otherwise meets all voter eligibility requirements to preregister to vote. Provides that the person's voter registration will be deemed effective as soon as the person is 18 years old at the time of the next election.
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) and the DMV to establish the CNMVP for the purpose of increasing opportunities for voter registration by any person who is qualified to vote.
- Requires, pursuant to the CNMVP, that each eligible voter be registered or preregistered to vote by default when the individual submits an application for a driver's license or state identification card, or provides the DMV with a change of address, unless the voter specifically declines (i.e. opts-out).
- Provides that the SOS, not the DMV, is solely responsible for determining eligibility for voter registration and voting.
- Requires the DMV, in consultation with the SOS, to establish a schedule and a method to electronically provide to the SOS the following information associated with each person who submits an application for a driver’s license, identification card, or who notifies the DMV of a change of address:
- Name.
- Date of birth.
- Either or both the residence address or mailing address as contained in the DMV’s records.
- Digitized signature, as specified.
- Telephone number, if available.
- Email address, if available.
- Language preference.
- Political party preference.
- Whether the person chooses to become a permanent vote by mail voter.
- Whether the person affirmatively declined to become registered to vote during a transaction with the DMV.
- A notation that the applicant has attested that they meet all voter eligibility requirements, including United States citizenship.
- Other information as specified in regulations.
- Requires the SOS to provide specified outreach and education materials in languages other than English, as specified.
- Provides that the SOS shall not sell, transfer or allow any third party access to the information acquired from the DMV without approval of the DMV, except as otherwise permitted by law and as specified.
- Provides that the DMV shall not electronically provide records of a person who applies for or is issued a driver’s license who is unable to submit satisfactory proof that the person’s presence in the United States is authorized under federal law.
- Provides that the willful, unauthorized disclosure of information obtained from the DMV to any person, or the use of any false representation to obtain any of that information, or the use of any of that information for a purpose other than what is currently permitted by existing law, is a misdemeanor, as specified.
- Prohibits the DMV from electronically providing records pursuant to CNMVP that contain a home address designated as confidential.
- Requires the SOS to establish procedures to protect the confidentiality of the information acquired from the DMV, as specified, and requires the SOS to account for any disclosures, including those due to security breaches, in accordance with existing law.
- Provides that the records of a person who registers to vote pursuant to the CNMVP shall constitute a completed affidavit of registration and the SOS shall register the person to vote, unless any of the following conditions is satisfied:
- The person’s records reflect that person affirmatively declined to become registered to vote during a transaction with the DMV.
- The person’s records do not reflect that person has attested to meeting all voter eligibility requirements.
- The SOS otherwise determines that the person is ineligible to vote.
- Provides that if a person who is registered to vote does not provide a party preference, the voter’s party preference shall be designated as “Unknown” and the voter shall be treated as a “No Party Preference” voter. Any such person whose party preference is designated as “Unknown” shall not be counted for purposes of determining the total number of voters registered for political party qualification purposes under existing law.
- Provides that a person registered to vote may cancel their voter registration at any time by any current method.
- Provides that if a person who is ineligible to vote becomes registered to vote through the CNMVP in the absence of willful voter registration fraud, that person’s registration shall be presumed to have been effected with official authorization and to have not been the fault of that person.
- Provides that if a person who is ineligible to vote becomes registered to vote and votes or attempts to vote in an election held after the effective date of the person’s registration, that person shall be presumed to have acted with official authorization and shall not be guilty of fraudulently voting or attempting to vote unless that person willfully votes or attempts to vote knowing that the person is not entitled to vote.
- Requires the SOS to adopt specified regulations to implement the CNMVP.
- Defines “Voter registration agency” to mean either of the following:
- A department, division, or office of state or local government, or a program supported by state funds, that is designated by executive order of the Governor or pursuant to the federal National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (52 U.S.C. Sec. 20501 et seq.) as a voter registration agency.
- A private entity under contract with a designated voter registration agency to provide services or assistance on behalf of the designated voter registration agency.
This bill:
- Keeps the current CNMVP for individuals who are not currently registered to vote in California, whose information is not subject to transmission to the SOS, and who either submits an application for a driver’s license, identification card, or notifies the DMV of a change of address. Provides that if at the time of the transaction with the DMV, the person provides a document that demonstrates the person is not a United States citizen, the person shall not be offered the opportunity to attest that the person meets all voter eligibility requirements and the DMV shall not electronically provide records of that person to the SOS.
- Requires the DMV, in consultation with the SOS, to establish a schedule and method for the DMV to electronically provide records to the SOS, as specified. Specifically:
- Provides that this method of electronic transfer of records applies to individuals who meets all of the following conditions:
- The person is not currently registered to vote in California.
- The person submits an application for a driver’s license.
- The person provides documentation demonstrating United States citizenship and that the person is of an eligible age to register or preregister to vote during the person’s transaction with the DMV.
- Requires the DMV to provide to the SOS, in a manner and method to be determined by the DMV in consultation with the SOS, the following information about the person:
- Name.
- Date of birth.
- Either or both of the following, as contained in the DMV’s records:
- Residence address.
- Mailing address.
- Digitized signature, as specified.
- Telephone number, if available.
- Email address, if available.
- Language preference, including the language in which the person conducted the transaction with the DMV.
- Other information required in regulations, as specified.
- Requires the DMV to provide the SOS, in a manner and method to be determined by the DMV and the SOS, information regarding a person’s name, address, and any additional information required by the SOS, for the purpose of maintaining current information for the person’s voter registration record if the person is currently registered to vote in California and submits a driver’s license application.
- Provides that this method of electronic transfer of records applies to individuals who meets all of the following conditions:
- Prohibits the DMV from providing records electronically that contain a home address designated as confidential, as specified.
- Provides the provisions related to the transfer of records between the DMV and the SOS shall not be construed to amend the substantive qualifications for voter registration in California or to require documentary proof of citizenship for voter registration.
- Provides the provisions related to the transfer of records between the DMV and the SOS shall not be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register individuals to vote or to update voter registration information based on information in the possession of the DMV before the person’s transaction.
- Requires the SOS and the DMV to jointly develop a process by which the DMV, upon obtaining a person’s full name, date of birth, driver’s license or state identification number, residence address, and mailing address if different from residence address, may use the information from the statewide voter registration database to determine whether the person is already registered to vote in California. Provides that the SOS may satisfy this requirement by providing a copy of the statewide voter registration database to the DMV on a daily basis.
- Changes the maximum imprisonment penalty from one year to 364 days for the willful, unauthorized disclosure of information obtained from the DMV to any person, or the use of any false representation to obtain any of that information or the use of any of that information for a purpose other than prescribed in existing law, as specified.
- Requires county elections officials to send to the person’s address of record, by nonforwardable mail, a notice that the person has been registered or preregistered to vote, as applicable, when a person whose information was transmitted by the DMV becomes registered or preregistered to vote, as specified. Specifically:
- Provides that the notice include a postage paid preaddressed return form by which the person may decline to be registered or preregistered, designate a party preference, or select a language preference. The notice shall also do all of the following:
- Offer the person the opportunity to provide a party preference, state that doing so may be required in order to vote in that party’s presidential primary election, and state that the person may also provide a party preference via the state’s online voter registration system.
- Offer the person the opportunity to select a language preference.
- Include an explanation of the eligibility requirements to register or preregister to vote, and a statement that, if the person is not eligible, the person should decline to register or preregister using the preaddressed return form.
- State the penalties for providing false information.
- Include a statement that, if the person declines to register or preregister to vote, the fact that the person has declined will remain confidential and will be used only for election administration purposes.
- Include a statement that, if the person does not decline to be registered or preregistered to vote, the office at which the person was registered or preregistered will remain confidential and will be used only for election administration purposes.
- Provide information regarding how a person can obtain assistance and additional information about the notice.
- Requires the SOS to prescribe the form of the notice, as specified.
- Requires the county elections official to send the person a residency confirmation notice if the notice is returned as undeliverable, as specified.
- Provides that all of the following apply in the event that a person returns the return form:
- If the person selects a language preference , the language preference shall be retained as part of the person’s registration information.
- Provides that the notice include a postage paid preaddressed return form by which the person may decline to be registered or preregistered, designate a party preference, or select a language preference. The notice shall also do all of the following:
- If the person chooses to become a permanent vote by mail voter, the person shall be added to the list of permanent vote by mail voters.
- If the person declines to be registered to vote, the person’s registration or preregistration shall be canceled, and the person shall be deemed to have never registered or preregistered to vote. Information related to the person’s declining to be registered or preregistered to vote shall not be used for any purpose other than the administration of elections.
- If the person is registered or preregistered to vote and thereafter returns the form indicating that the person declines to be registered or preregistered to vote, but before returning the form the person votes in an election, the person’s declining to register or preregister to vote on the return form shall have no force and effect.
- If a person returns a form but does not select or indicate any new information on the form, the form is of no force and effect.
- Provides that if the SOS receives from the DMV updated name or address information for a person who is currently registered to vote, then all of the following shall occur:
- The SOS shall use the new information to update the voter’s registration information and shall have the voter’s registration status updated to active.
- The appropriate county elections official shall send to the person’s address of record, by forwardable mail, notice of the change and a postage paid preaddressed return form by which the person may verify or correct the information. Requires the notice to provide information regarding how a person can obtain assistance and additional information about the notice.
- If the person returns the form indicating that the update to the registration information was in error, the appropriate county elections officials shall immediately correct the information in the statewide voter registration database.
- Requires the SOS to prescribe the form of the notices.
- Requires SOS and DMV shall develop procedures to ensure that a driver’s license, identification card, or other identifying information submitted by an applicant pursuant to this chapter is sufficiently evaluated to determine whether the applicant is eligible to register or to preregister to vote and to protect against future erroneous registrations or preregistrations.
- Provides that if it becomes known to the SOS or DMV that either the SOS or DMV, or both, committed an error resulting in the registration or preregistration of an ineligible person, as specified, and unless there is clear and convincing evidence that the person has a specified provision of existing law, the SOS or DMV shall do both of the following:
- Immediately contact the person to inform the person of the erroneous registration or preregistration.
- Provide the person a letter asserting that the SOS or DMV, or both, was responsible for the erroneous registration or preregistration. Requires a copy of this letter be maintained permanently in the person’s file with the DMV and be accessible to the person upon request.
- Requires voter registration agencies to annually provide to the SOS information describing each designated office under the agency’s supervision, the type of services the office provides, and a designated voter registration contact for that office. Requires, at the earliest practicable time, the SOS or their designee to assess which voter registration agencies, in the regular course of business and substantially, collect sufficient information from applicants to confirm eligibility for registration or to update information for an existing registration, or both, as specified.
- Requires the SOS to assess and, if necessary, establish a schedule by which the voter registration agency shall begin prospectively providing to the SOS electronic records regarding individuals eligible to register to vote or individuals with updated voter registration information, or both if applicable, as specified.
- Provides, notwithstanding any other law, the SOS may develop procedures for processing electronic records received from an agency without an image of the applicant’s signature, as specified. Provides these provisions are not to be construed to provide a retroactive basis to register individuals to vote or to update voter registration information based on information previously in the possession of the SOS, the DMV, or another voter registration agency.
- Expands the definition of a “voter registration agency” to include a department, division, or office of state or local government, or a program supported by state funds designated by the SOS.
- Requires this bill become operative on January 1, 2026, or five days after the date the SOS certifies that the information technology infrastructure to substantially implement the provisions of this bill is functional. Provides that the SOS may, commencing January 1, 2024, perform administrative actions necessary to implement the bill’s provisions.
- Makes technical, nonsubstantive changes.
BACKGROUND
National Voter Registration Act. In 1993, the federal government enacted the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA), commonly referred to as the "motor voter" law or Motor Voter, to make it easier for Americans to register to vote and maintain their registration. Among other provisions in the NVRA, the DMV provides customers the opportunity to register to vote when completing an application for a driver’s license or an identification card, when renewing a driver’s license, an identification card, or when a change of address transaction takes place.
Despite being commonly referred to as “motor voter,” the NVRA also requires states to designate other agencies as “voter registration agencies” and provides an opportunity to register to vote for individuals interacting with the specified agencies. This includes offices that provide public assistance and offices that provide services to individuals with disabilities. In California, the Governor is also able to designate additional voter registration agencies.
California New Motor Voter Program. In 2015, the Legislature passed and Governor Brown signed AB 1461 (Gonzalez), Chapter 729, Statutes of 2015, which provides that every person who submits an application for a driver's license, state identification card, or provides the DMV with a change of address, and who attests that they meet all voter eligibility requirements, is automatically registered to vote, unless that person opts out, as specified.
Specifically, the DMV, in consultation with the SOS, is required to establish a schedule and method for the DMV to electronically provide to the SOS the records of each person who submits an application for a driver's license, state identification card, or provides the DMV with a change of address. The transmission of an individual’s record from the DMV to the SOS constitutes a completed affidavit of voter registration unless the person affirmatively declines to register or preregister to vote at the DMV, the person does not attest to meeting all voter eligibility requirements while at the DMV, or the SOS determines that the person is not eligible to register to vote.
The DMV is also prohibited from electronically providing the records of a person who is issued a driver's license pursuant to specified provisions of law because that person is unable to establish satisfactory proof that their presence in the United States is authorized under federal law.
In April 2018, California officially launched the CNMVP.
Issues at the DMV. Since the launch of the CNMVP in 2018, the DMV faced a number of challenges related to DMV transactions and voter registration. In May 2018, a software error potentially affected approximately 77,000 voter records generated at the DMV. According to news reports, this error resulted in two registration forms for a single voter. In response, county elections officials contacted potentially affected voters and the software error was fixed.
In September 2018, the DMV reported 23,000 registration errors that stemmed from DMV technicians working with multiple screens and registration information being improperly merged. According the DMV, 4,600 individuals did not complete a voter registration affidavit, but had their information sent to the SOS. The DMV also indicated that none of the applicants were undocumented immigrants. In response, the DMV sent the 23,000 customers a letter notifying them of the problem and the SOS cancelled the 4,600 registrations that it received.
In October 2018, the DMV sent the SOS a letter indicating that 1,500 customers may have been registered to vote in error when DMV technicians processed customer requests at field offices to change voter eligibility responses on driver license applications. The DMV indicated that none of the processing errors were the fault of the customer and none were undocumented immigrants.
Prior to the November 2018 election, the DMV did not timely transmit 589 voter records to the SOS prior to the close of registration. Of the 589 records, 329 were registering to vote and 260 were trying to change their address. According to the SOS, the number of affected individuals resulting from this error would not have changed any of the results certified by the SOS.
Responses to Issues at the DMV. In response to the issues related to the DMV, in September 2018, Governor Brown directed the Department of Finance to conduct a performance audit of the DMV’s information technology and customer service functions. In January 2019, Governor Newsom ordered an accelerated Review of Early Findings within 30 days of the independent audit of DMV initiated by Governor Brown, which was managed by the Department of Finance. This was a performance audit of the DMV’s Information Technology and Customer Service Functions and publically released on March 1, 2019.
The CNMVP was included in the Department of Finance’s audit, but was conducted by an independent, third-party organization. The Department of Finance contracted with Ernst & Young for an independent technical assessment of the DMV’s Enterprise Applications Systems Environment which included the California New Voter Motor Application.
As part of the assessment, the report found and identified 83,684 records shown as duplicates in the SOS data set because they were sent initially to the SOS with a blank “Political Party” field value and later the same records were resent with the corrected value of “No Party Preference” in the same field. However, this action did not have an impact on voter eligibility.
Assessment of the Motor Voter Application. As a result, the Department of Finance released a five-part assessment of the Motor Voter application on August 9, 2019. The first four assessments were performed against an established set of evaluation criteria to highlight risks and develop recommendations for the DMV and the SOS (when applicable) in order to improve and ultimately enhance the effectiveness of the CNMVP. The fifth assessment, the Validation Report, was limited to providing the results of data comparisons and did not include an evaluation of the results.
While there were many recommendations for improvement, the fourth assessment examined the quality assurance of the CNMVP. The objective of this assessment was to review the Motor Voter data transfer processes against established evaluation criteria to highlight risks that, if not addressed, would adversely affect the realization of the intended benefits of the CNMVP and develop recommendations for improvement of the ongoing program’s effectiveness. From this assessment, stakeholders received nine recommendations for review and consideration for implementation. These recommendations sought to improve or enhance the overall effectiveness of the CNMVP or the Motor Voter application and many of the recommendations were implemented.
DMV Voter Registration Statistics. According to information provided by the SOS, 4,815,801 new voter registration transactions have been processed since the CNMVP’s launch in April 2018 through January 2023. If voter re-registrations and updated addresses are included with new registrations, the total for the same duration is 20,300,497 transactions.
Conversely, there were 17,920,019 transactions where the individual chose to opt-out of voter registration through either the electronic driver’s license or identification card application, a renewal form, or a change of address form.
California Registration Statistics. Since 2018, the CNMVP has contributed to a rise of registered voters in California. According to the most recent report of registration from the SOS, there are 21,940,874 registered voters in California out of an estimated 26,876,800 Californians who are eligible to register to vote, meaning that approximately 81.63% of eligible Californians are registered to vote. To compare, in January 2018, there were 18,980,481 registered voters or about 75.69%.
Oregon's Automatic Voter Registration and Other States. For the vast majority of states, the responsibility for registering eligible individuals to vote is placed on the individual. North Dakota, which is the only state without voter registration, is the exception. As mentioned previously, in California, an individual interacting with the DMV goes through a process to determine voter eligibility and is registered to vote if eligible and the individual does not opt out. This occurs during a DMV transaction.
This bill creates a back-end automated voter registration system for most individuals who interact with the DMV. This is similar to a system created in Oregon. In Oregon, if the Department of Transportation has information indicating that an individual is eligible to register to vote and the government has information to verify individuals' eligibility to vote, then the individual is automatically registered to vote. Individuals will have the option to opt-out of being registered, typically through a notice in the mail.
According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, in addition to Oregon, Colorado uses a back-end automated voter registration system. Alaska, Delaware, and Massachusetts have also authorized similar procedures.
AB 60 Licensees. AB 60 (Alejo), Chapter 524, Statutes of 2013, required the DMV to issue an original driver’s license to an applicant who is unable to submit satisfactory proof of legal presence in the United States. Driver’s license applicants under AB 60 are required to meet all other qualifications for licensure and provide satisfactory proof of identity and California residency. Since the AB 60 licensing process was specifically established for individuals who are unable to submit satisfactory proof of legal presence in the United States, existing law prohibits the DMV from transmitting information to the SOS about individuals who applied for or received a driver’s license pursuant to AB 60.
The back-end system would transfer the responsibility of determining citizenship from the DMV customer to the DMV, which would ensure non-citizens do not mistakenly represent their status. However, under SB 846, it is unclear exactly how the DMV would determine citizenship status, leaving potential room for human (or machine) error on the back-end. The proponents of the bill believe that the SOS will be reviewing DMV Motor Voter data, but that this process will be happening after data is transmitted from the DMV to the SOS.
Statistics for Non-DMV NVRA Entities. In 2022, public assistance agencies, state-funded agencies primarily serving persons with disabilities, armed forces recruitment offices, and other California-designated agencies reported that 31,264 registrations were received. In total, from June 1995 through February 2023, 1,818,550 registrations were received.
REAL ID and DMV transaction time. Individuals seeking REAL ID compliant driver licenses and ID cards must visit a field office and provide certain specified documents, including U.S. passport, birth certificate, or other specified identity document, that DMV staff verify and scan. SB 846 would capitalize on the identity documentation required by REAL ID to also determine citizenship for purposes of voter registration.
DMV implementation of the federal REAL ID Act led to significant wait times and increased workload at DMV field offices as these transaction take longer to process than noncompliant transactions. Since peak wait times in 2018, the DMV has made significant changes to their processes to move transactions that can be done online out of the field office and cut transaction time at the field office. It is possible that doing voter registration on the back-end will decrease DMV transaction times, but unclear by how much if at all. Much of the DMV’s current process has migrated online where DMV customers are encouraged to fill out their DL/ID application, including motor voter questions, online prior to coming to the field office or may be able to skip the field office entirely.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: SB 846 builds on California’s existing partial automatic voter registration system to take the next step to streamline new registrations and registration updates at state agencies. Utilizing procedures that are largely already in place, this updated automatic voter registration system will register millions more eligible Californians, bringing people of color, young people, and formerly incarcerated people into the political process. Similarly, this bill will update millions of additional registrations, ensuring more voters receive their mail ballots at the correct address and can vote without any issues at the polls. This bill will also save election officials, agency officials, and voters time and money, and improve the state’s ability to audit registration procedures and data transfers. Most importantly, this upgrade will significantly enhance protections for non-citizens by reducing the risk of unintentional registrations.
Six states and the District of Colombia have already adopted this automatic voter registration system, with several more states set to adopt the change this year. California can join these states at the forefront of elections, ensuring truly automatic registration that allows all eligible Californians to participate in the political process, all while better protecting non-citizens from inadvertent errors.
- Party Preferences. California’s voter registration form asks the registrant whether the person wishes to disclose a political party preference. A registrant has the option of selecting to disclose a preference for one of the six qualified political parties in the state, to disclose a party preference for a political body that is attempting to qualify as a political party, or to decline to disclose a party preference. A voter who declines to disclose a party preference is considered to have an “Unknown” party preference. “Unknown” voters are treated as “No Party Preference” voters except for statistical purposes.
For example, there were 20,404 voters with an unknown party preference prior to the launch of CNMVP in January 2018. In February 2021, there were 123,497 voters with an unknown party preference. While it is uncertain that this increase in “Unknown” voters can be entirely attributed to CNMVP, it very likely played a significant role.
Under the provisions of this bill, a new voter’s party preference will be “unknown” between a DMV transaction and the return of the notice to an elections official or an update online. This will lead to an increase in the number of voters with an unknown party preference.
If a voter who did not return the mail notice or select a party preference on that notice, a voter will need to update their registration again either online, at polling location, or at the county elections office. AB 292 (Pellerin) of 2023 would provide a space for a voter to write in the name of a candidate for President of the United States who is nominated by a party that authorizes voters who decline to disclose a political party preference to vote in the party’s primary election. If the voter writes in the name of a candidate who is nominated by a party that does not authorize voters who decline to disclose a political preference to vote in the party’s primary election, the vote for that candidate shall not be counted. AB 292 is pending in the Assembly Committee on Elections.
- Who’s in the Driver’s Seat? Currently, when an individual seeks services at the DMV, they are provided with questions prior to visiting the DMV. This includes the Motor Voter questions (eligibility, if the person wants to be register to vote, update an existing registration, etc.). The individual decides whether to register/update and attests that the information provided is correct.
This bill would shift some of the responsibilities for voter registration from the person seeking assistance at the DMV to the DMV. This includes a larger role in the screening process. Under the bill, the DMV would be responsible for collecting documents that the individual provided to confirm their eligibility to vote and for the DMV transaction. If eligibility is unable to be confirmed, then the DMV directs the customer to additional prompts relating to voter registration.
Additionally, a person obtaining services at the DMV may not know that they are being registered to vote. Unless the DMV and the SOS have a robust check on the data being inputted and received, it is possible that the person who received services at the DMV will not have any notification of their registration until a notice is received in the mail. If an individual is ineligible to vote and does not know they are registered, there are protections if an inadvertent registration or voting occurs, but it is unknown whether those protections are enough. People who are ineligible to vote may have reservations visiting the DMV for fear that they are mistakenly being registered to vote.
- Collaboration and Input. While the current CNMVP has had its challenges, the program has increased voter registration and updated voter rolls since 2018. There are other legislative measures currently going through the legislative process to improve CNMVP.
Additionally, an analysis of Oregon’s Automated Voter Registration system and Colorado’s system prior to switching to a back-end registration system both indicated that coordination is key to the success of an automated system. While coordination does occur in California, a deeper analysis may be needed to determine the feasibility for developing a new process, the cost, and whether each entity (DMV, SOS, and counties) possess the technological infrastructure needed to perform the bill’s required tasks effectively.
Collaboration between the DMV, SOS, and county election officials is paramount for the successful implementation of a new Motor Voter endeavor. Feedback from the SOS and county election officials would provide additional valuable insights into any existing logistical challenges and the state’s ability to implement this change. Having this necessary feedback would give all involved parties an opportunity to express any potential or underlying concerns with this bill and work towards a solution.
- Argument in Support. In a letter supporting SB 846, the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights states, in part, the following:
SB 846 takes significant steps to modernize our voter registration systems and prevent inadvertent registration by non-citizens, protecting the integrity of our elections and giving non-citizens added peace of mind. With more streamlined and efficient ways to register and update existing registrations, California’s voter rolls will be more accurate and inclusive than ever, a key benefit that election administrators everywhere will support.
- Argument in Opposition. In a coalition letter opposing SB 846, they state, in part, the following:
A significant majority of states that have adopted AVR policies use a front-end opt-out model, and studies have indicated that the rare states that have chosen to adopt the back-end opt-out model do “not produce higher registration rates than states that chose a front-end opt-out model.” Instead of placing false hopes in a back-end Motor Voter registration system, California should focus its resources on more effective, evidence-based approaches to increasing voter registration and closing turnout disparities. For example, thoughtfully and carefully extending the AVR model currently in use at California’s DMV to other social services points-of-contact – such as applications for health coverage through Covered California – has the potential to bring voter registration to additional groups of under-represented Californians, including low-income voters who may be less likely to interact with the DMV. Further, continuing to improve our existing front-end Motor Voter program by requiring better data tracking, transparency and accountability mechanisms, and improved efficiency in application processing would also be a more practical way to ensure that this already successful program is as fair and accessible as possible.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, SB 846 will be re-referred to the Senate Committee on Transportation.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 796 (Berman), Chapter 314, Statutes of 2021, among other provisions, made various changes to the timing and transfer of voter information data from the DMV to SOS.
SB 583 (Newman) of 2021 would have created a back-end automated voter registration system for registering voters at the DMV, as specified. SB 583 passed the Senate, was referred to the Assembly Committee on Elections, and was not taken up for consideration. SB 846 is substantially similar to SB 583.
AB 1137 (Mullin) of 2021 would have required the SOS to provide a report to the Legislature regarding the process and infrastructure of existing voter registration agencies, as specified. AB 1137 was amended to another topic.
SB 57 (Bates) of 2020 would have changed the CNMVP from an opt-out to an opt-in program. SB 57 failed passage in this committee with a vote of 1-3.
SB 511 (Moorlach) of 2019 would have required the establishment of a committee including representatives of the SOS, DMV, and counties, for the purpose of facilitating the sharing of information necessary to implement CNMVP. SB 511 failed passage in the Senate Committee on Transportation with a vote of 4-5.
AB 1461 (Gonzalez), Chapter 729, Statutes of 2015, provided for every person who has a driver's license or state identification card and who is eligible to register to vote to be automatically registered to vote at the DMV, unless that person opts out. A prior version of AB 1461 included a back-end registration model similar to SB 846. However, the bill was amended to the front-end opt-out system that was subsequently chaptered.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Asian American Pacific Islanders for Civic Empowerment – Education Fund
Support: AHRI for Justice
Alliance for San Diego
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Bay Rising
California Black Power Network
California Calls
California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Native Vote Project
Campaign Legal Center
Center for Secure and Modern Elections
Central Coast Alliance United for a Sustainable Economy
Chinese Progressive Association
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights
Communities for a New California
Community Coalition
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Courage California
EPIC
Filipino Advocates for Justice
Hmong Innovating Politics
Inland Empire United
InnerCity Struggle
Jakara Movement
Khmer Girls in Action
LAANE
Mi Familia Vota
National Union of Healthcare Workers
NextGen California
Oakland Rising
OC Action
Orange County Asian and Pacific Islander Community Alliance
Orange County Congregation Community Organization
Orange County Environmental Justice
Orange County Voter Information Project
Pilipino Workers Center
PowerCA Action
Resilience Orange County
South Bay Youth Changemakers
Strategic Concepts in Organizing and Policy Education
VoteVets
Working Partnerships USA
Oppose: ACLU California Action
League of Women Voters of California
NALEO Educational Fund
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):