SB 875: Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-01-11
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-11: June 11 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act generally requires the State Department of Social Services to license, inspect, and regulate residential care facilities for the elderly and imposes criminal penalties on a person who violates the act or who willfully or repeatedly violates any rule or regulation adopted under the act. The act prohibits a placement agency, as defined, from placing an individual in a licensed residential care facility for the elderly if the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. The act requires an employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility is improperly operating without a license to report the facility to the department, and requires the department to investigate those reports. The act further requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a facility. The act specifically makes a violation of these requirements a crime.
Existing law requires a referral agency to obtain a license from the State Department of Public Health in order to refer a person to any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, or intermediate care facility. Existing law exempts a local public agency performing referral services without cost from these provisions. Under existing law, a violation of these provisions is subject to a civil penalty and suspension or revocation of the license.
This bill would additionally require a referral agency to obtain a license from the State Department of Social Services in order to refer a person to a residential care facility for the elderly. The bill would prohibit an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or residential care facility for the elderly from paying a commission or fee to a referral agency that is not licensed, as specified. The bill would prohibit a referral agency from holding any power of attorney or any other property of a person receiving referral services, or to receive or hold a clients property in any capacity. With respect to a residential care facility for the elderly, the bill would require a referral agency to disclose specified information to each person receiving its services, and to maintain records of those disclosures for a period of 3 years, as specified. The bill would specify that a referral agency licensee would be subject to specified provisions relating to placement agencies for residential care facilities for the elderly. By expanding the definition of a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would also require referral agencies to maintain liability insurance in specified amounts. The bill would also make it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a facility or licensee.
Existing law makes specified persons mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse, including administrators, supervisors, and licensed staff of a facility that provide care or services for elder or dependent adults. Under existing law, failure to report physical abuse, abandonment, abduction, isolation, financial abuse, or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is a misdemeanor.
The bill would include owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency as mandated reporters. By expanding the crime of failure to report elder or dependent adult abuse, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act generally requires the State Department of Social Services to license, inspect, and regulate residential care facilities for the elderly and imposes criminal penalties on a person who violates the act or who willfully or repeatedly violates any rule or regulation adopted under the act. The act prohibits a placement agency, as defined, from placing an individual in a licensed residential care facility for the elderly if the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. The act requires an employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility is improperly operating without a license to report the facility to the department, and requires the department to investigate those reports. The act further requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a facility. The act specifically makes a violation of these requirements a crime.
Existing law requires a referral agency to obtain a license from the State Department of Public Health in order to refer a person to any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, or intermediate care facility. Existing law exempts a local public agency performing referral services without cost from these provisions. Under existing law, a violation of these provisions is subject to a civil penalty and suspension or revocation of the license.
This bill would additionally require a referral agency to obtain a license from the State Department of Social Services in order to refer a person to a residential care facility for the elderly. The bill would prohibit an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or residential care facility for the elderly from paying a commission or fee to a referral agency that is not licensed, as specified. The bill would prohibit a referral agency from holding any power of attorney or any other property of a person receiving referral services, or to receive or hold a clients property in any capacity. With respect to a residential care facility for the elderly, the bill would require a referral agency to disclose specified information to each person receiving its services, and to maintain records of those disclosures for a period of 3 years, as specified. The bill would specify that a referral agency licensee would be subject to specified provisions relating to placement agencies for residential care facilities for the elderly. By expanding the definition of a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would also require referral agencies to maintain liability insurance in specified amounts. The bill would also make it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a facility or licensee.
Existing law makes specified persons mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse, including administrators, supervisors, and licensed staff of a facility that provide care or services for elder or dependent adults. Under existing law, failure to report physical abuse, abandonment, abduction, isolation, financial abuse, or neglect of an elder or dependent adult is a misdemeanor.
The bill would include owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency as mandated reporters. By expanding the crime of failure to report elder or dependent adult abuse, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act generally requires the State Department of Social Services to license, inspect, and regulate residential care facilities for the elderly and imposes criminal penalties on a person who violates the act or who willfully or repeatedly violates any rule or regulation adopted under the act. The act prohibits a placement agency, as defined, from placing an individual in a licensed residential care facility for the elderly if the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. The act requires an employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility is improperly operating without a license to report the facility to the department, and requires the department to investigate those reports. The act further requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a facility. The act specifically makes a violation of these requirements a crime.This bill additionally would impose requirements for referral sources, defined to mean any specified county department, stated-funded program, entity, or person that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at residential care facilities for the elderly. The bill would require a referral source, before sending a compensated referral, as defined, to a residential care facility for the elderly, to provide a person or their representative with specific written, electronic, or verbal disclosures that include, among others, the referral sources privacy policy. The bill would additionally require a compensated referral source to comply with additional requirements that include, among others, maintaining a minimum amount of liability insurance coverage. The bill would impose civil penalties for a violation of these provisions, as specified, in addition to any other remedy available by law.(1)The
The California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act generally requires the State Department of Social Services to license, inspect, and regulate residential care facilities for the elderly and imposes criminal penalties on a person who violates the act or who willfully or repeatedly violates any rule or regulation adopted under the act. The act prohibits a placement agency, as defined, from placing an individual in a licensed residential care facility for the elderly if the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. The act requires an employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility is improperly operating without a license to report the facility to the department, and requires the department to investigate those reports. The act further requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a facility. The act specifically makes a violation of these requirements a crime.
This bill would recast the requirements on a placement agency and its employees to instead be requirements on a referral source, additionally would impose requirements for referral sources, defined to mean any specified county department, stated-funded program, agency, entity, or person that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at residential care facilities for the elderly. The bill would prohibit a referral source from, among other things, referring a person to a residential care facility for the elderly in which the referral source has an ownership or management interest without a waiver. The bill would require a referral source, before sending a compensated referral referral, as defined, to a residential care facility for the elderly, to provide a person or their representative with specific written, electronic, or verbal disclosures that include, among others, the referral sources privacy policy. The bill would additionally require a compensated referral source to comply with additional requirements that include, among others, maintaining a minimum amount of liability insurance coverage. The bill would impose criminal penalties and civil penalties for a violation of these provisions, as specified. By expanding the existing crime under the act and specifying new criminal penalties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. specified, in addition to any other remedy available by law.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.(1)The California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act generally requires the State Department of Social Services to license, inspect, and regulate residential care facilities for the elderly and imposes criminal penalties on a person who violates the act or who willfully or repeatedly violates any rule or regulation adopted under the act. The act prohibits a placement agency, as defined, from placing an individual in a licensed residential care facility for the elderly if the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. The act requires an employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility is improperly operating without a license to report the facility to the department, and requires the department to investigate those reports. The act further requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a facility. The act specifically makes a violation of these requirements a crime.
This bill would recast the requirements on a placement agency and its employees to instead be requirements on a referral source, defined to mean any specified county department, stated-funded program, agency, or person that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at residential care facilities for the elderly. The bill would prohibit a referral source from, among other things, referring a person to a residential care facility for the elderly in which the referral source has an ownership or management interest without a waiver. The bill would require a referral source, before sending a compensated referral to a residential care facility for the elderly, to provide a person or their representative with specific written, electronic, or verbal disclosures that include, among others, the referral sources privacy policy. The bill would additionally require a compensated referral source to comply with additional requirements that include, among others, maintaining a minimum amount of liability insurance coverage. The bill would impose criminal penalties and civil penalties for a violation of these provisions, as specified. By expanding the existing crime under the act and specifying new criminal penalties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, without first having obtained a written license as provided in this chapter from the State Public Health Officer or from an inspection service approved by the State Public Health Officer pursuant to Section 1257, from the State Department of Social Services, or from both, as appropriate.
(b)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any person or agency outside a long-term health care facility, as defined in Section 1418, for professional services for which the long-term health care facility does not employ a qualified professional person to furnish a specific service, including, but not limited to, laboratory, diagnostic, or therapy services, unless the long-term health care facility complies with current federal and state laws regarding the provision of these services and all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The services will be provided in accordance with professional standards applicable to the provision of these services in a long-term health care facility.
(2)The long-term health care facility assumes responsibility for timeliness of the services.
(3)Services are provided or obtained only when ordered by the attending physician and a notation is made in the residents medical chart reflecting that the service has been provided to the resident.
(c)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any residential care facility for the elderly for professional services if that facility does not meet the licensing standards established in Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569). The referral agency may satisfy this requirement by obtaining and relying on the licensing status information for a residential care facility for the elderly that is published on the internet website of the State Department of Social Services.
(d)It is unlawful for any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, to pay a commission or fee to a referral agency that does not have a written license as provided in this chapter from the State Public Health Officer or from an inspection service approved by the State Public Health Officer pursuant to Section 1257, from the State Department of Social Services, or from both, as appropriate.
SEC. 2.Section 1401 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1401.As used in this chapter, referral agency means a private, profit or nonprofit agency that is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care facility, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility, or residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. Referral facility agency does not include any of the following:
(a)A licensed residential care facility for the elderly that does either of the following:
(1)Provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients.
(2)Provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
(b)A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed residential care facility for the elderly and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed residential care facility for the elderly.
(c)A staff member of the licensed residential care facility for the elderly who receives remuneration from the facility for professional services, including, but not limited to, sales and marketing efforts, on behalf of that facility.
SEC. 3.Section 1402 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1402.Residential care facility for the elderly has the same meaning as set forth in Section 1569.2.
SEC. 4.Section 1403 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1403.(a)Each application for a license or renewal of license under this chapter shall be accompanied by an annual Licensing and Certification Program fee. Each license shall expire 12 months from its date of issuance and application for renewal accompanied by the fee shall be filed with the director not later than 30 days prior to the date of expiration.
(b)The State Department of Public Health shall set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee in accordance with Section 1266.
(c)(1)The State Department of Social Services shall set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee at an amount no greater than the amount required to cover the reasonable and actual costs of administering the licensing program.
(2)The State Department of Social Services shall, no later than February 1, 2025, and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
SEC. 5.Section 1404 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1404.A licensee under this chapter shall not have a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee.
SEC. 6.Section 1404.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1404.5.A license application shall be submitted to either or both licensing department, as appropriate, whenever any of the following circumstances occur:
(a)Change of ownership of the referral agency.
(b)Change of name of the referral agency.
(c)Change of location of the referral agency.
SEC. 7.Section 1405 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1405.Any person, partnership, firm, corporation, or association desiring to obtain a license to refer persons to extended care facilities, skilled nursing homes, or intermediate care facilities, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, shall file with the State Department of Public Health an application on forms furnished by the State Department of Public Health. Any person, partnership, firm, corporation, or association desiring to obtain a license to refer persons to residential care facilities for the elderly shall file with the State Department of Social Services an application on forms furnished by the State Department of Social Services. The applications shall contain all of the following:
(a)Name of applicant, and if an individual, whether the applicant has attained the age of 18 years. 18 years of age.
(b)Name of referral agency.
(c)The location of the referral agency.
(d)The business or occupation engaged in by each applicant, and by each partner, officer, and director, for at least two years immediately preceding the filing of the application. In addition, each such person shall submit a statement setting forth whether the person has previously engaged in the operation of a referral agency, whether the person has been involved in, or the subject of, a refusal or revocation of a referral agency license, and whether the person has been convicted of a crime other than a minor traffic offense.
(e)If the applicant is a corporation, the name and principal business address of each officer and director of the corporation; and for nonpublic corporations, the name and business address of each stockholder owning 10 percent or more of the stock and the name and business address of any corporation member who has responsibility in the operation of the facility.
(f)If the applicant is a partnership, the name and principal business address of each partner.
(g)Evidence of the right to occupy the premises where the referral agency is to be located.
(h)A copy of the partnership agreement or the Articles of Incorporation, if applicable.
(i)A copy of the current organization chart.
(j)A schedule of fees to be charged and collected by the referral agency, and a statement of the method by which each fee is to be computed or determined.
(k)A declaration that the licensee will not have any financial interest in any health facility doing business with the referral agency.
(l)Evidence satisfactory to the licensing department that the applicant demonstrates reputable and responsible character and the capability to comply with this chapter.
(m)For a licensee to refer persons to residential care facilities for the elderly, both of the following:
(1)A declaration that the licensee will either conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities, or will comply with the requirements of subparagraph (G) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 1409.4. facilities. For purposes of this subdivision, suitability determination means a determination made by the licensee that the facility offers services to meet the needs of the person seeking a referral because of the following considerations:
(A)The level of care requested by the person seeking the referral.
(B)The cost of the facility and the ability of the financial means of the person seeking the referral.
(C)The social needs and preferences of the person seeking the referral.
(D)The geographic location of the facility and the geographic preference of the person seeking the referral.
(2)A declaration that the licensee trains all employees who make referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly regarding all of the following issues:
(A)All of the provisions of this chapter that apply to a referral agency, including, but not limited to, instruction on how to comply with all of those provisions.
(B)State governance and administrative functions of agency operations, including resident assessment and admission procedures.
(C)The psychosocial and physical needs of the elderly.
(D)Community supports, cultural competency, and sensitivity to residents needs.
SEC. 8.Section 1407 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1407.(a)Any licensee desiring to voluntarily surrender their license for cancellation or temporary suspension shall notify the licensing department in writing as soon as possible and, in all cases, at least 30 days prior to the effective date of cancellation or temporary suspension of the license.
(b)Any license placed in temporary suspension pursuant to this section may be reinstated by the licensing department within 12 months of the date of the voluntary suspension on receipt of an application and evidence showing compliance with licensing requirements.
SEC. 9.Section 1408 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1408.(a)Upon verification of compliance with this chapter and with the approval of the licensing department, the licensing department shall issue the license to the applicant.
(b)When issuing a license to a referral agency that provides referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly, the State Department of Social Services is not required to conduct an onsite licensing inspection as a condition of verifying compliance with this chapter.
(c)As a condition of verifying compliance with this chapter, the licensing department may require an applicant to submit a copy or example of the disclosures required by Section 1409.4.
(d)If the applicant is not in compliance with this chapter, the licensing department shall deny the applicant a license. Immediately upon the denial of any license, the licensing department shall notify the applicant in writing. Within 20 days of receipt of the notice, the applicant may present their written petition for a hearing to the licensing department. Proceedings conducted by the State Department of Public Health shall be conducted in accordance with Section 100171.
(e)For purposes of compliance with this chapter, an applicant is not required to have a physical place of business within the state.
SEC. 10.Section 1409.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1409.3.(a)The licensee shall notify either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, within 10 days in writing when a change of stockholder owning 10 percent or more of the nonpublic corporate stock occurs. The writing shall include the name and principal mailing addresses of the new stockholder.
(b)When a change of agency manager occurs, either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, shall be notified in writing within 10 days by the licensee. The notification shall include the name of the new agency manager.
(c)Each licensee shall notify either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, within 10 days in writing of any change of the mailing address of the licensee. The writing shall include the new mailing address of the licensee.
(d)When a change in the principal officer of a corporate licensee, chairperson, president, or general manager occurs, either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, shall be notified within 10 days in writing by the licensee. The writing shall include the name and principal business address of the officer.
SEC. 11.Section 1409.4 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.4.(a)The following definitions shall apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Facility means a residential care facility for the elderly as defined in Section 1569.2.
(2)Licensee means a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405.
(b)(1)Before referring a person to a facility, a licensee shall disclose all of the following to the person:
(A)A description of the licensees service.
(B)The licensees contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number.
(C)A licensees privacy policy, or, if the licensee maintains an internet website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the internet website.
(D)Whether and under what circumstances the licensee will be paid a fee by facilities to which the person is referred.
(E)That the person or their representative may request at any time by email or by submitting a letter that the licensee cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the licensee will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
(F)The following statement: Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of Californias residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing Division internet website at www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this internet website.
(G)The following statement: State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area. This statement shall be followed by a link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging.
(H)A statement that the persons information may be sold or shared for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral and a link to an internet website where a person can opt out of selling or sharing or, if the licensee does not maintain an internet website, a description of how the person can opt out of their selling or sharing of their information.
(2)The licensee shall make the disclosures pursuant to this subdivision in the same language in which the licensee negotiates any referral services with the person receiving services.
(c)(1)The information and disclosures required by subdivision (b) shall be provided to the person or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and may be provided, together or separately, in either of the following methods:
(A)A written disclosure in at least 12-point, Arial-equivalent bold font, either in hardcopy form or by electronic means. If the person or their representative provides the licensee with an email address, the licensee shall send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representatives email address.
(B)An oral disclosure given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. The disclosure shall be spoken clearly, and in a pitch and tone that is understandable to the consumer. If an oral disclosure is provided, a written disclosure as described in subparagraph (A) shall also be sent to the person or their representative.
(2)The licensee shall maintain records of the disclosures set forth pursuant to subdivision (a) for a period of three years and shall provide additional copies of the disclosures to the person, their representative, or the facility, upon written request.
(d)(1)In addition to the other requirements of this section, a licensee shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on representatives of the licensee who have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
(B)Accept remuneration only from residential care facilities for the elderly with which the licensee has a written contract.
(C)Post a privacy policy on every internet website the licensee operates, through a conspicuous link, in a similar manner as other similarly posted links used by the business on its home page. If the licensee does not maintain an internet website, then it shall provide the person or their representative with a written copy of the privacy policy.
(D)Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b).
(E)Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b).
(2)In accordance with Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code, the person or the persons representative shall have the right, at any time, to direct the licensee not to sell or share their personal information, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
(3)The following definitions apply for purposes of this subdivision:
(A)Electronic request means either an email to the electronic address that the licensee has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving those requests, or completing an online form on the licensees internet website that it has posted for submitting those requests.
(B)Oral request means a request via the recorded telephone line that the licensee has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing those requests.
(e)(1)In addition to any other remedy available by law, a licensee that violates subdivision (b) or (d) is subject to a civil penalty of between two hundred fifty dollars ($250) and one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each violation. A district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to recover the civil penalty under this subdivision and to restrain and enjoin a violation of subdivision (b) or (d).
(2)A licensee subject to this section shall comply with the requirements of Section 1569.47.
SEC. 12.Section 1409.5 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.5.Owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405 are mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
SEC. 13.Section 1409.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.7.It is unlawful for a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405 to hold any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a clients property in any capacity.
SEC. 14.Section 1409.8 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.8.On and after July 1, 2025, all persons, associations, or corporations licensed pursuant to Section 1405 shall maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per person occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the total annual aggregate, for negligent acts or omissions by the licensee.
SEC. 15.Section 1409.9 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.9.A licensee shall display the licensees name and license number on all advertising, promotional or marketing material, and internet websites paid for, or operated by, the licensee.
SEC. 16.Section 1409.10 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.10.(a)It is unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a facility or licensee.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Facility means a residential care facility for the elderly as set forth in Section 1569.2.
(2)Licensee means a referral agency that is licensed pursuant to Section 1405.
SEC. 17.Section 1410 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1410.The licensing department may suspend or revoke a license issued under this chapter for violation of any provisions of this chapter or any rules and regulations promulgated hereunder. In addition, the licensing department shall assess a civil penalty in the amount of fees received by a licensee as a result of a violation of any provisions of this chapter or rules and regulations promulgated hereunder. Proceedings to suspend or revoke a license conducted by the State Department of Public Health shall be conducted pursuant to Section 100171.
SEC. 18.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any extended care, care facility, skilled nursing home or home, intermediate care facility facility, residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, without first having obtained a written license therefor as provided in this chapter from the director State Public Health Officer or from an inspection service approved by the director State Public Health Officer pursuant to Section 1257. 1257, from the State Department of Social Services, or from both, as appropriate.
(b)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any person or agency outside a long-term health care facility, as defined in Section 1418, for professional services for which the long-term health care facility does not employ a qualified professional person to furnish a specific service, including, but not limited to, laboratory, diagnostic, or therapy services, unless the long-term health care facility complies with current federal and state laws regarding the provision of these services and all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The services will be provided in accordance with professional standards applicable to the provision of these services in a long-term health care facility.
(2)The long-term health care facility assumes responsibility for timeliness of the services.
(3)Services are provided or obtained only when ordered by the attending physician and a notation is made in the residents medical chart reflecting that the service has been provided to the resident.
(c)It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any residential care facility for the elderly for professional services if that facility does not meet the licensing standards established in Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569). The referral agency may satisfy this requirement by obtaining and relying on the licensing status information for a residential care facility for the elderly that is published on the internet website of the State Department of Social Services.
(d)It is unlawful for any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, to pay a commission or fee to a referral agency that does not have a written license as provided in this chapter from the State Public Health Officer or from an inspection service approved by the State Public Health Officer pursuant to Section 1257, from the State Department of Social Services, or from both, as appropriate.
SEC. 2.Section 1401 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1401.As used in this chapter chapter, referral agency means a private, profit or nonprofit agency which that is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, care facility, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility facility, or residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. Referral facility does not include any of the following:
(a)A licensed residential care facility for the elderly that does either of the following:
(1)Provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients.
(2)Provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
(b)A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed residential care facility for the elderly and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed residential care facility for the elderly.
(c)A staff member of the licensed residential care facility for the elderly who receives remuneration from the facility for professional services, including, but not limited to, sales and marketing efforts, on behalf of that facility.
SEC. 3.Section 1402 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1402.Residential care facility for the elderly has the same meaning as set forth in Section 1569.2.
SEC. 4.Section 1403 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1403.(a)Each application for a license or renewal of license under this chapter shall be accompanied by an annual Licensing and Certification Program fee set in accordance with Section 1266. fee. Each license shall expire 12 months from its date of issuance and application for renewal accompanied by the fee shall be filed with the director not later than 30 days prior to the date of expiration.
(b)The State Department of Public Health shall set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee in accordance with Section 1266.
(c)(1)The State Department of Social Services shall set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee at an amount no greater than the amount required to cover the reasonable and actual costs of administering the licensing program.
(2)The State Department of Social Services shall, no later than February 1, 2025, and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
SEC. 5.Section 1404 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1404.No licensee under this chapter shall A licensee under this chapter shall not have a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee.
SEC. 6.Section 1404.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1404.5.A license application shall be submitted to the department either or both licensing department, as appropriate, whenever any of the following circumstances occur:
(a)Change of ownership of the referral agency.
(b)Change of name of the referral agency.
(c)Change of location of the referral agency.
SEC. 7.Section 1405 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1405.Any person, partnership, firm, corporation or association desiring to obtain a license shall file with the department an application on forms furnished by the department. The application corporation, or association desiring to obtain a license to refer persons to extended care facilities, skilled nursing homes, or intermediate care facilities, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, shall file with the State Department of Public Health an application on forms furnished by the State Department of Public Health. Any person, partnership, firm, corporation, or association desiring to obtain a license to refer persons to residential care facilities for the elderly shall file with the State Department of Social Services an application on forms furnished by the State Department of Social Services. The applications shall contain all of the following:
(a)Name of applicant, and if an individual, whether the applicant has attained the age of 18 years.
(b)Name of referral agency.
(c)The location of the referral agency.
(d)The business or occupation engaged in by each applicant, and by each partner, officer officer, and director, for at least two years immediately preceding the filing of the application. In addition, each such person shall submit a statement setting forth whether he or she the person has previously engaged in the operation of a referral agency, whether he or she the person has been involved in, or the subject of, a refusal or revocation of a referral agency license, and whether he or she the person has been convicted of a crime other than a minor traffic offense.
(e)If the applicant is a corporation, the name and principal business address of each officer and director of the corporation; and for nonpublic corporations, the name and business address of each stockholder owning 10 percent or more of the stock and the name and business address of any corporation member who has responsibility in the operation of the facility.
(f)If the applicant is a partnership, the name and principal business address of each partner.
(g)Evidence of the right to occupy the premises where the referral agency is to be located.
(h)A copy of the partnership agreement of or the Articles of Incorporation, if applicable.
(i)A copy of the current organization chart.
(j)A schedule of fees to be charged and collected by the referral agency, and a statement of the method by which each fee is to be computed or determined.
(k)A declaration that the licensee will not have any financial interest in any health facility doing business with the referral agency.
(l)Evidence satisfactory to the licensing department that the applicant demonstrates reputable and responsible character and the capability to comply with this chapter.
(m)For a licensee to refer persons to residential care facilities for the elderly, both of the following:
(1)A declaration that the licensee will either conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities, or will comply with the requirements of subparagraph (G) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 1409.4. For purposes of this subdivision, suitability determination means a determination made by the licensee that the facility offers services to meet the needs of the person seeking a referral because of the following considerations:
(A)The level of care requested by the person seeking the referral.
(B)The cost of the facility and the ability of the financial means of the person seeking the referral.
(C)The social needs and preferences of the person seeking the referral.
(D)The geographic location of the facility and the geographic preference of the person seeking the referral.
(2)A declaration that the licensee trains all employees who make referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly regarding all of the following issues:
(A)All of the provisions of this chapter that apply to a referral agency, including, but not limited to, instruction on how to comply with all of those provisions.
(B)State governance and administrative functions of agency operations, including resident assessment and admission procedures.
(C)The psychosocial and physical needs of the elderly.
(D)Community supports, cultural competency, and sensitivity to residents needs.
SEC. 8.Section 1407 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1407.(a)Any licensee desiring to voluntarily surrender his or her their license for cancellation or temporary suspension shall notify the licensing department in writing as soon as possible and, in all cases, at least 30 days prior to the effective date of cancellation or temporary suspension of the license.
(b)Any license placed in temporary suspension pursuant to this section may be reinstated by the licensing department within 12 months of the date of the voluntary suspension on receipt of an application and evidence showing compliance with licensing requirements.
SEC. 9.Section 1408 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1408.(a)Upon verification of compliance with this chapter and with the approval of the licensing department, the licensing department shall issue the license to the applicant.
(b) If the applicant is not in compliance with this chapter, the department shall deny the applicant a license. Immediately upon the denial of any license, the department shall notify the applicant in writing. Within 20 days of receipt of the departments notice, the applicant may present his or her written petition for a hearing to the department. The proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with Section 100171.(b)When issuing a license to a referral agency that provides referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly, the State Department of Social Services is not required to conduct an onsite licensing inspection as a condition of verifying compliance with this chapter.
(c)As a condition of verifying compliance with this chapter, the licensing department may require an applicant to submit a copy or example of the disclosures required by Section 1409.4.
(d)If the applicant is not in compliance with this chapter, the licensing department shall deny the applicant a license. Immediately upon the denial of any license, the licensing department shall notify the applicant in writing. Within 20 days of receipt of the notice, the applicant may present their written petition for a hearing to the licensing department. Proceedings conducted by the State Department of Public Health shall be conducted in accordance with Section 100171.
(e)For purposes of compliance with this chapter, an applicant is not required to have a physical place of business within the state.
SEC. 10.Section 1409.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1409.3.(a)The licensee shall notify the department either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, within 10 days in writing when a change of stockholder owning 10 percent or more of the nonpublic corporate stock occurs. The writing shall include the name and principal mailing addresses of the new stockholder.
(b)When a change of agency manager occurs, the department either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, shall be notified in writing within 10 days by the licensee. The notification shall include the name of the new agency manager.
(c)Each licensee shall notify the department either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, within 10 days in writing of any change of the mailing address of the licensee. The writing shall include the new mailing address of the licensee.
(d)When a change in the principal officer of a corporate licensee, chairperson, president, or general manager, occurs the department manager occurs, either or both licensing departments, as appropriate, shall be notified within 10 days in writing by the licensee. The writing shall include the name and principal business address of the officer.
SEC. 11.Section 1409.4 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.4.(a)The following definitions shall apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Facility means a residential care facility for the elderly as defined in Section 1569.2.
(2)Licensee means a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405.
(b)(1)Before referring a person to a facility, a licensee shall disclose all of the following to the person:
(A)A description of the licensees service.
(B)The licensees contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number.
(C)A licensees privacy policy, or, if the licensee maintains an internet website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the internet website.
(D)Whether and under what circumstances the licensee will be paid a fee by facilities to which the person is referred.
(E)That the person or their representative may request at any time by email or by submitting a letter that the licensee cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the licensee will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
(F)The following statement: Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of Californias residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing Division internet website at www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this internet website.
(G)The following statement: State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area. This statement shall be followed by a link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging.
(H)A statement that the persons information may be sold or shared for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral and a link to an internet website where a person can opt out of selling or sharing or, if the licensee does not maintain an internet website, a description of how the person can opt out of their selling or sharing of their information.
(2)The licensee shall make the disclosures pursuant to this subdivision in the same language in which the licensee negotiates any referral services with the person receiving services.
(c)(1)The information and disclosures required by subdivision (b) shall be provided to the person or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and may be provided, together or separately, in either of the following methods:
(A)A written disclosure in at least 12-point, Arial-equivalent bold font, either in hardcopy form or by electronic means. If the person or their representative provides the licensee with an email address, the licensee shall send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representatives email address.
(B)An oral disclosure given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. The disclosure shall be spoken clearly, and in a pitch and tone that is understandable to the consumer. If an oral disclosure is provided, a written disclosure as described in subparagraph (A) shall also be sent to the person or their representative.
(2)The licensee shall maintain records of the disclosures set forth pursuant to subdivision (a) for a period of three years and shall provide additional copies of the disclosures to the person, their representative, or the facility, upon written request.
(d)(1)In addition to the other requirements of this section, a licensee shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on representatives of the licensee who have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
(B)Accept remuneration only from residential care facilities for the elderly with which the licensee has a written contract.
(C)Post a privacy policy on every internet website the licensee operates, through a conspicuous link, in a similar manner as other similarly posted links used by the business on its home page. If the licensee does not maintain an internet website, then it shall provide the person or their representative with a written copy of the privacy policy.
(D)Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b).
(E)Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b).
(2)In accordance with Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code, the person or the persons representative shall have the right, at any time, to direct the licensee not to sell or share their personal information, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
(3)The following definitions apply for purposes of this subdivision:
(A)Electronic request means either an email to the electronic address that the licensee has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving those requests, or completing an online form on the licensees internet website that it has posted for submitting those requests.
(B)Oral request means a request via the recorded telephone line that the licensee has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing those requests.
(e)(1)In addition to any other remedy available by law, a licensee that violates subdivision (b) or (d) is subject to a civil penalty of between two hundred fifty dollars ($250) and one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each violation. A district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to recover the civil penalty under this subdivision and to restrain and enjoin a violation of subdivision (b) or (d).
(2)A licensee subject to this section shall comply with the requirements of Section 1569.47.
SEC. 12.Section 1409.5 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.5.Owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405 are mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
SEC. 13.Section 1409.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.7.It is unlawful for a referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405 to hold any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a clients property in any capacity.
SEC. 14.Section 1409.8 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.8.On and after July 1, 2025, all persons, associations, or corporations licensed pursuant to Section 1405 shall maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per person occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the total annual aggregate, for negligent acts or omissions by the licensee.
SEC. 15.Section 1409.9 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.9.A licensee shall display the licensees name and license number on all advertising, promotional or marketing material, and internet websites paid for, or operated by, the licensee.
SEC. 16.Section 1409.10 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1409.10.(a)It is unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a facility or licensee.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Facility means a residential care facility for the elderly as set forth in Section 1569.2.
(2)Licensee means a referral agency that is licensed pursuant to Section 1405.
SEC. 17.Section 1410 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1410.The licensing department may suspend or revoke licenses a license issued under this chapter for violation of any provisions of this chapter or any rules and regulations promulgated hereunder. In addition, the licensing department shall assess a civil penalty in the amount of fees received by a licensee as a result of a violation of any provisions of this chapter or rules and regulations promulgated hereunder. Proceedings to suspend or revoke a license conducted by the State Department of Public Health shall be conducted pursuant to Section 100171.
SEC. 18.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as amended in the Senate, April 11, 2023. (JR11)(a)The following definitions shall apply to this section:
(1)Compensated referral means a referral by a private, for-profit or nonprofit agency that is engaged in the business of referring entity that refers persons to residential care facilities for the elderly in exchange for any consideration or thing of value, including a fee, commission, gift, or any reciprocal benefit. For purposes of this section, case management services provided through the Medi-Cal program do not qualify as compensated referral.
(2)Referral means identifying and connecting a person or that persons representative to notifying a residential care facility for the elderly that a person seeking senior housing or that persons representative has consented to having the facility or the referral source contact them to facilitate the further evaluation, in consultation with the facility, evaluation of whether that facility is a suitable senior housing option for that person.
(3)(A)Referral source means any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private, for-profit, or nonprofit agency entity providing referral services, conservator pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 1800) of Division 4 of the Probate Code, conservator pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 5350) of Part 1 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities, or a person or entity that provides a referral to a residential care facility for the elderly on behalf of the aforementioned entities, that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at residential care facilities for the elderly.
(B)A referral source does not include a licensee of a residential care facility for the elderly, or any professional services staff member of a residential care facility for the elderly, who on behalf of that facility, makes a referral, even if they have received a discount or other remuneration from the facility.
(b)(1)A referral source shall not refer a person to a facility providing care and supervision or protective supervision if the referral source knows or should have known the facility is not licensed as a residential care facility for the elderly or is not exempt from licensing under Section 1569.145. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.(2)A referral source shall not refer an individual to a residential care facility for the elderly if the referral source knows or should have known the individual, because of their health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the facilitys license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.(3)A referral source shall not refer a person to a residential care facility for the elderly in which the referral source, and an affiliated group under Section 1585 of the Financial Code or an immediate family member of the referral source, has an ownership or management interest or a common employee in an executive management position, unless the referral source obtains a written waiver from the person or that persons representative before making the referral. For purposes of this subparagraph, immediate family means a spouse, parent, child, or any person related by consanguinity or affinity within the second degree. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.(4)(A)A referral source who knows or should have known that a facility that is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license shall report the name and address of the facility to the department. Failure to report as required by this subparagraph is a misdemeanor.(B)The department shall investigate any report filed under subparagraph (A). If the department has probable cause to believe that the facility that is the subject of the report is operating without a license, the department shall investigate the facility within 10 days after receipt of the report.(5)A referral source shall notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a residential care facility for the elderly. A violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor. Reportable incidents include, but are not limited to, all of the following:(A)Incidents of physical abuse.(B)Any violation of personal rights.(C)Any situation in which a facility is unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or in poor condition.(D)Any situation in which a facility has insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty.(E)Any situation in which residents experience mental or verbal abuse.(c)(b)(1)Before sending a compensated referral to a residential care facility for the elderly located in California, a referral source shall provide the person or their representative with information that includes all of the following disclosures: disclosures, in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers:
(A)A description of the referral sources service.
(B)The referral sources contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number.
(C)A referral sources privacy policy, or if the referral source maintains an internet website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the internet website.
(D)A statement regarding whether and under what circumstances the referral source will be paid a fee by residential care facilities for the elderly to which the person is referred.
(E)A statement that the person or their representative may request at any time via email or by submitting a letter that the referral source cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the referral source will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
(F)The following language: Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of Californias residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing website at: www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this website.
(G)A link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging.
(2)The information and disclosures required by paragraph (1) shall be provided to the person or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and may be provided, together or separately, in any of the following methods:
(A)A written disclosure at least in 12-point bold font in at least 12-point, Arial-equivalent bold font, either in hardcopy form or by electronic means. If the person or their representative provides the referral source with an email address, the referral source shall send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representatives email address.
(B)A link to an electronic disclosure displayed prominently on a web page in a larger font than the surrounding text.
(C)Verbally, if the verbal disclosure is given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. The disclosure shall be spoken clearly, and in a pitch and tone that is understandable to the consumer. At the time of the verbal disclosure, a person or their representative shall be informed that they may verbally request a written or electronic disclosure. If the person or their representative requests a written or electronic disclosure, the referral source shall provide the written or electronic disclosure to the person or their representative who makes the request. If, in a subsequent phone conversation, the person or their representative verbally requests a written disclosure, the referral agency shall inform them of the procedure for submitting the request in writing pursuant to paragraph (3).
(3)The referral source shall maintain records of the disclosures set forth pursuant to this subdivision for a period of three years and shall provide a copy of the disclosures provided to the person, representative, or the residential care facility for the elderly, upon written request.
(4)In addition to the requirements of paragraph (1), a compensated referral source shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on referral sources who have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
(B)Maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in total annual aggregate for negligent acts or omissions by the referral source or any of its employees.
(C)Accept remuneration only from residential care facilities for the elderly with which the referral source has a written contract.
(D)Maintain and prominently display a privacy policy on every internet website it operates or, if Post a privacy policy on every internet website it operates, through a conspicuous link in a similar manner as other similarly posted links used by the business on its homepage. If the referral source does not maintain an internet website, then it shall provide the person or their representative with a written copy of the privacy policy.
(E)Refrain from holding any power of attorney for a resident or potential resident or from holding that persons property in any capacity.
(F)(i)Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1).
(ii)An electronic request means the person or their representative either sending an email to the electronic address which the referral source has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving such those requests or completing an online form on the referral sources internet website that it has posted for submitting such those requests.
(iii)An oral request means the person or their representative making the request via the recorded phone line that the referral source has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing such those requests.
(G)(i)Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1).
(ii)An electronic request means the person or their representative either sending an email to the electronic address which the referral source has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving such those requests or completing an online form on the referral sources internet website that it has posted for submitting such those requests.
(iii)An oral request means the person or their representative making the request via the recorded phone line that the referral source has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing such those requests.
(H)Obtain the affirmative consent of the person or their representative for making referrals on a persons behalf. Consent may be obtained verbally in a telephone conversation and recorded in an audio file, electronically, or in writing.
(I)In accordance with Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code, the person or the persons representative shall have the right, at any time, to direct the referral source not to sell or share their personal information, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
(d)A(c)In addition to any other remedy available by law, a referral source that violates subdivision (c) (b) is subject to a civil penalty of between two hundred fifty dollars ($250) and one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each violation, and Section 1569.40 shall not apply. A district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to recover the civil penalty under this subdivision and to restrain and enjoin a violation of subdivision (c). (b).
(e)In addition to any other action, violations of this section may be subject to an action under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.(a)The following definitions shall apply to this section:
(1)Compensated referral means a referral by a private, for-profit or nonprofit agency that is engaged in the business of referring persons to residential care facilities for the elderly in exchange for any consideration or thing of value, including a fee, commission, gift, or any reciprocal benefit. For purposes of this section, case management services provided through the Medi-Cal program do not qualify as compensated referral.
(2)Referral means identifying and connecting a person or that persons representative to a residential care facility for the elderly to facilitate the further evaluation, in consultation with the facility, of whether that facility is a suitable senior housing option for that person.
(3)(A)Referral source means any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private, for-profit, or nonprofit agency providing referral services, conservator pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 1800) of Division 4 of the Probate Code, conservator pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 5350) of Part 1 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities, or a person or entity that provides a referral to a residential care facility for the elderly on behalf of the aforementioned entities, that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at residential care facilities for the elderly.
(B)A referral source does not include a licensee of a residential care facility for the elderly, or any professional services staff member of a residential care facility for the elderly, who on behalf of that facility, makes a referral, even if they have received a discount or other remuneration from the facility.
(b)(1)A referral source shall not refer a person to a facility providing care and supervision or protective supervision if the referral source knows or should have known the facility is not licensed as a residential care facility for the elderly or is not exempt from licensing under Section 1569.145. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.
(2)A referral source shall not refer an individual to a residential care facility for the elderly if the referral source knows or should have known the individual, because of their health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the facilitys license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.
(3)A referral source shall not refer a person to a residential care facility for the elderly in which the referral source, and an affiliated group under Section 1585 of the Financial Code or an immediate family member of the referral source, has an ownership or management interest or a common employee in an executive management position, unless the referral source obtains a written waiver from the person or that persons representative before making the referral. For purposes of this subparagraph, immediate family means a spouse, parent, child, or any person related by consanguinity or affinity within the second degree. Violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor.
(4)(A)A referral source who knows or should have known that a facility that is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license shall report the name and address of the facility to the department. Failure to report as required by this subparagraph is a misdemeanor.
(B)The department shall investigate any report filed under subparagraph (A). If the department has probable cause to believe that the facility that is the subject of the report is operating without a license, the department shall investigate the facility within 10 days after receipt of the report.
(5)A referral source shall notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a residential care facility for the elderly. A violation of this paragraph is a misdemeanor. Reportable incidents include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Incidents of physical abuse.
(B)Any violation of personal rights.
(C)Any situation in which a facility is unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or in poor condition.
(D)Any situation in which a facility has insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty.
(E)Any situation in which residents experience mental or verbal abuse.
(c)(1)Before sending a compensated referral to a residential care facility for the elderly located in California, a referral source shall provide the person or their representative with information that includes all of the following disclosures:
(A)A description of the referral sources service.
(B)The referral sources contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number.
(C)A referral sources privacy policy, or if the referral source maintains an internet website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the internet website.
(D)A statement regarding whether and under what circumstances the referral source will be paid a fee by residential care facilities for the elderly to which the person is referred.
(E)A statement that the person or their representative may request at any time via email or by submitting a letter that the referral source cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the referral source will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
(F)The following language: Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of Californias residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing website at: www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this website.
(2)The information and disclosures required by paragraph (1) shall be provided to the person or their representative in a clear manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and may be provided, together or separately, in any of the following methods:
(A)A written disclosure at least in 12-point bold font either in hardcopy form or by electronic means. If the person or their representative provides the referral source with an email address, the referral source shall send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representatives email address.
(B)A link to an electronic disclosure displayed on a web page in a larger font than the surrounding text.
(C)Verbally, if the verbal disclosure is given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. At the time of the verbal disclosure, a person or their representative shall be informed that they may verbally request a written or electronic disclosure. If the person or their representative requests a written or electronic disclosure, the referral source shall provide the written or electronic disclosure to the person or their representative who makes the request. If, in a subsequent phone conversation, the person or their representative verbally requests a written disclosure, the referral agency shall inform them of the procedure for submitting the request in writing pursuant to paragraph (3).
(3)The referral source shall maintain records of the disclosures set forth pursuant to this subdivision for a period of three years and shall provide a copy of the disclosures provided to the person, representative, or the residential care facility for the elderly, upon written request.
(4)In addition to the requirements of paragraph (1), a compensated referral source shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on referral sources who have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
(B)Maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in total annual aggregate for negligent acts or omissions by the referral source or any of its employees.
(C)Accept remuneration only from residential care facilities for the elderly with which the referral source has a written contract.
(D)Maintain and prominently display a privacy policy on every internet website it operates or, if the referral source does not maintain an internet website, then it shall provide the person or their representative with a written copy of the privacy policy.
(E)Refrain from holding any power of attorney for a resident or potential resident or from holding that persons property in any capacity.
(F)(i)Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1).
(ii)An electronic request means the person or their representative either sending an email to the electronic address which the referral source has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving such requests or completing an online form on the referral sources internet website that it has posted for submitting such requests.
(iii)An oral request means the person or their representative making the request via the recorded phone line that the referral source has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing such requests.
(G)(i)Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1).
(ii)An electronic request means the person or their representative either sending an email to the electronic address which the referral source has authorized in its privacy policy for receiving such requests or completing an online form on the referral sources internet website that it has posted for submitting such requests.
(iii)An oral request means the person or their representative making the request via the recorded phone line that the referral source has designated on its internet website or in its privacy policy for processing such requests.
(H)Obtain the affirmative consent of the person or their representative for making referrals on a persons behalf. Consent may be obtained verbally in a telephone conversation and recorded in an audio file, electronically, or in writing.
(I)In accordance with Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code, the person or the persons representative shall have the right, at any time, to direct the referral source not to sell or share their personal information, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
(d)A referral source that violates subdivision (c) is subject to a civil penalty of between two hundred fifty dollars ($250) and one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each violation, and Section 1569.40 shall not apply. A district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to recover the civil penalty under this subdivision and to restrain and enjoin a violation of subdivision (c).
(e)In addition to any other action, violations of this section may be subject to an action under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 11, 2024 | June 11 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on HUM. S. and AGING & L.T.C. |
| Jan 29, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 29, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 0. Page 3056.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 22, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3012.) (January 18). |
| Jan 17, 2024 | Set for hearing January 18. |
| Jan 16, 2024 | January 16 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Jan 12, 2024 | Set for hearing January 16. |
| Jan 11, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 11, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0. Page 2980.) (January 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 9, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 3. Noes 0. Page 2958.) (January 8). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 4, 2024 | Set for hearing January 11 in JUD. pending receipt. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Dec 21, 2023 | Set for hearing January 8. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | Set for hearing April 25 in JUD. pending receipt. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | April 17 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Mar 13, 2023 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HUMAN S. and JUD. |
| Feb 21, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 29, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB875 Glazer | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 18, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 16, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 11, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jan 8, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 6BEDS, Inc. | ** Support | |
| ACT8 | ** Support | |
| Act8, LLC | ** Support | |
| ActEight, LLC | ** Support | |
| A Place For Mom | ** Support | |
| California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform | ** Against | |
| California Assisted Living Association | ** Support | |
| California Commission on Aging | ** Against | |
| California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association | ** Against | |
| California Office Of The State Long-Term Care Ombudsman | ** Against | |
| Canhr | ** Against | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Against | |
| Justice in Aging | ** Against | |
| LeadingAge California | ** Support | |
| National Placement And Referral Alliance | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: June 11, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Alex Lee, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 875
Author:(Glazer) – As Amended Ver:January 11, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 32-0
SUBJECT: Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies
SUMMARY: Extends existing licensing requirements for referral agencies licensed by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to apply to residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) referral agencies, to be licensed by the California Department of Social Services (CDSS). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires an entity that refers a person to an RCFE to obtain a license from CDSS.
- Requires CDSS, no later than February 1, 2025, and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, to submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
- Adds an entity that refers a person to an RCFE under the existing definition of a referral agency licensed by CDPH thereby making existing requirements that apply to a CDPH-licensed referral agency additionally apply to an RCFE referral agency.
- Provides that a referral agency does not include:
- A licensed RCFE that either:
- Provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients, or,
- Provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
- A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed RCFE and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed RCFE; or,
- A staff member of the licensed RCFE who receives remuneration from the RCFE for professional services, including sales and marketing efforts on behalf of the RCFE.
- A licensed RCFE that either:
- Prohibits an extended care facility, skilled nursing facility (SNF), intermediate care facility, or RFCE from paying a commission or fee to any referral agency not licensed by CDSS or CDPH, as applicable.
- Prohibits any person, association, or corporation from establishing, conducting, or maintaining a referral agency or from referring any person for remuneration to any RCFE for professional services if that facility does not meet existing licensing standards.
- Provides that an RCFE referral agency may satisfy 6) above by obtaining and relying on the licensing status information for an RCFE that is published on CDSS’ website.
- Requires an RCFE referral agency to declare that it will conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities. Provides that suitability determination means as a determination made by the licensee that the facility offers services to meet the needs of the person seeking a referral because of the following considerations:
- The level of care requested by the person seeking the referral;
- The cost of the facility and the ability of the financial means of the person seeking the referral;
- The social needs and preferences of the person seeking the referral; or,
- The geographic location of the facility and the geographic preference of the person seeking the referral.
- Requires a declaration that the licensee trains all employees who make referrals to RCFEs regarding all of the following issues:
- All provisions, as specified, apply to a referral agency, including, but not limited to, instruction on how to comply with all of those provisions;
- State governance and administrative functions of agency operations, including resident assessment and admission procedures;
- The psychosocial and physical needs of the elderly; and,
- Community supports, cultural competency, and sensitivity to residents’ needs.
- Requires an RCFE referral agency to make the following disclosures before referring a person to an RCFE:
- A description of the licensee’s service;
- The licensee’s contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number;
- A licensee’s privacy policy, or, if the licensee maintains a website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the website;
- Whether and under what circumstances the licensee will be paid a fee by facilities to which the person is referred;
- That the person or their representative may request at any time by email or by submitting a letter that the licensee cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the licensee will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative;
- The following statement: “Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of California’s residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing Division internet website at www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this internet website.”;
- The following statement: “The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area.” This statement shall be followed by a link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging; and,
- A statement that the person’s information may be sold or shared for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral and a link to a website where a person can opt out of selling or sharing or, if the licensee does not maintain a website, a description of how the person can opt out of their selling or sharing of their information.
- Provides that in addition to any other remedy available in law, makes a violation of the disclosure requirements in 10) subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation recoverable by a district attorney or a city attorney in superior court.
- Provides that a district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to enjoin a violation of the disclosure requirements in 10) above.
- Specifies that an RCFE referral agency must comply with existing law that established requirements for placement agencies.
- Makes owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency mandated reporters pursuant to the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act.
- Prohibits a referral agency from holding any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
- Requires, on and after July 1, 2025, all referral agencies to maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate for negligent acts or omissions.
- Makes it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to an RCFE or referral agency.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of extended care, SNFs, and intermediate care facilities by CDPH. (Health and Safety Code [HSC] § 1250 et seq.)
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of referral agencies of extended care facilities, SNFs, and intermediate care facilities. (HSC § 1400 et seq.)
- Defines “referral agency” to mean a private, profit, or nonprofit agency which is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. (HSC § 1401)
- Requires an application for a referral agency license or renewal of a referral agency license to be accompanied by an annual Licensing and Certification Program fee, as set annually by the CDPH Licensing and Certification Division. (HSC § 1403)
- Prohibits a referral agency from having a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee. (HSC § 1404)
- Establishes the California Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly Act. (HSC §1569)
- Defines an “RCFE” as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or over, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided. (HSC § 1569.2(o))
- Defines “placement agency” as any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private agency providing placement or referral services, conservator, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities which is engaged in finding homes or other places for the placement of elderly persons for temporary or permanent care. (HSC § 1569.47(a))
- Prohibits a placement agency from placing individuals in licensed RCFEs when the individual, because of their health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. Establishes a violation as a misdemeanor. (HSC § 1569.47(b))
- Prohibits a placement agency or an employee of a placement agency from placing, referring, or recommending placement of a person in a facility providing care and supervision, or protective supervision, unless the facility is licensed as an RCFE or is exempt from licensing. Establishes a violation as a misdemeanor. (HSC § 1569.47(c))
- Requires CDSS to investigate any report filed as a result of a facility which is not exempt from licensing, operating without a license. Requires, the department, if it has probable cause to believe that the facility is operating without a license, to investigate the facility within 10 days after receipt of the report. (HSC § 1569.47(e))
- Requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents which would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in an RCFE. Reportable incidents include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
- Incidents of physical abuse;
- Any violation of personal rights;
- Any situation in which a facility is unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or in poor condition;
- Any situation in which a facility has insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty; or,
- Any situation in which residents experience mental or verbal abuse. (HSC § 1569.47(f))
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee on January 12, 2024:
- Unknown ongoing costs, likely millions, for CDSS for state operations to establish and administer the new licensing program (Licensing and Certification Fund).
- CDPH does not anticipate a fiscal impact.
- Unknown, potentially significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate alleged violations of this measure (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund). While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
COMMENTS:
Background: Residential Care Facilities for The Elderly are non-medical facilities that house and care for individuals 60 years of age and older that have minimal health needs, but need basic daily help for services such as housekeeping, medication assistance, personal and hygiene care, and eating. There are three levels of care permitted in an RCFE which range from basic care when a resident still can retain some independence, to nonmedical care when a resident needs help with personal daily living activities, and the highest level of care is reserved for someone who needs extensive care with daily living activities and may have chronic health problems.
California’s network of RCFEs consists of small homes serving a handful of residents to larger RCFEs that can house over 100 residents in communities across the state. Facilities provide a special combination of housing, personalized supportive services, and 24-hour staff designed to respond to the individual needs of those who require help with activities of daily living. This level of care and supervision is for people who are unable to live by themselves but who do not need 24-hour nursing care. They are considered non-medical facilities and are not required to have nurses, certified nursing assistants, or doctors on staff. Facilities usually centrally store and distribute medications for residents to self-administer.
Placement and Referral Agencies. Existing law requires licensure and oversight by CDPH of referral agencies that refer individuals to specific extended care facilities, SNFs, or intermediate care facilities in return for compensation. According to Cal Health Find, there are only three licensed referral agencies operating in California. The low number of licensed referral agencies is likely because health facilities such as SNFs require a referral from a primary care physician, which reduces the need for referral services from an agency.
Unlike health facilities, care facilities such as RCFEs do not need a primary care physician referral. Thus, placement agencies step in to make such connections. Placement agencies are paid by aging care businesses such as home care, RCFEs, independent living, and Community Care Retirement Communities to successfully place residents in their respective facilities relative to their needs. Placement agencies serve as brokers by recommending facilities to prospective residents based on factors such as the level of care needed, budget, and location.
Currently, there are few consumer protections in place for placement agencies that refer to care facilities. As described above in existing law 8) -12), parameters include only referring to licensed or licensed-exempt facilities and reporting to CDSS if a facility is endangering a resident. As such, there have been numerous unsuccessful attempts to regulate this industry.
This is the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate compensated referral agencies. Broadly, these bills can be grouped into two separate efforts: One set of bills includes AB 2926 (Calderon of 2020) and AB 499 (B. Rubio of 2021). These bills would have recast requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to apply to a referral source. AB 2926 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file and AB 499 was vetoed by Governor Newsom due to concerns that referral entities would only provide referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation, creating equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice.
The other set of bills, including SB 648 (Mendoza of 2015), SB 648 (Mendoza of 2017), and
AB 2744 (Reyes of 2018), would have attempted to establish comprehensive regulatory schemes for these entities. SB 648 of 2015 was vetoed by Governor Brown due to costs and for a lack of demonstrated need for a new licensing structure. SB 648 of 2017 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file, and AB 2744 was placed on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
This bill takes elements of each of these bills and creates a licensing structure by adding to the current definition of a referral agency regulated by CDPH.
Cal Long Term Care Compare. When a person can no longer live independently due to advanced age or disability, locating appropriate housing and support can be an overwhelming endeavor. It is especially challenging if the person doing the searching is not familiar with the various types of assisted living services and settings. As an effort to assist future residents and their families in what can be an overwhelming process to find a facility, the Budget Act of 2022 allocated funding to establish a website to compare facilities and help consumers make decisions. This website is named “Cal Long Term Care Compare” and it provides free, unbiased information to help consumers make the best choice for long-term care. This includes information about:
- Nursing Homes
- Hospice Care
- Home Health Care
- Assisted Living Facilities
- Adult Residential Facilities
- Continuing Care Retirement Communities
- Adult Day Health Centers
The data on this website are from various state and federal government organizations. The University of California, Davis Center for Healthcare Policy and Research, School of Medicine, and School of Nursing analyze the data and create the ratings for this website.
Does This Industry Need More Oversight? Referral agencies recommend facilities for family members 60 years of age and older who are in need of assistance by making claims about the quality of these facilities. There are currently no requirements that these statements must be accurate or based on any independent assessment. As such, a referral agency might recommend a facility to someone that has multiple serious citations for endangering residents. In a Washington Post investigation on referral agencies, they found there were major discrepancies in what placement agencies deemed as a “top facility” and what state licensing agency’s survey results show. One example given was a referral agency in California that rated one Senior Living business with 41 properties as “The Best in Senior Living” despite 23 of its locations having violations. Violations included “medication errors, bedsores, falls, staff misconduct and exposure to hazards such as infestations by scabies and rats.” (Rowland, C., Rich, S., & Macmillian, D. (2024) Popular Assisted Living Referral ‘A Place For Mom’ Glosses Over Neglect - The Washington Post)
Referral agencies give their own ratings and awards of facilities based on, according to one business’s website, the review of residents and families. However, ratings do not include survey results, substantiated complaints, and/or citations. It may be misleading to some consumers who do not understand how RCFEs are regulated. This bill attempts to increase consumer protections by creating a licensing structure for referral agencies to adhere to.
Author’s Statement: According to the Author, “Navigating the process of finding an appropriate setting for an aging family member or friend can be stressful and is often done under pressing circumstances. Referral agencies are a crucial part of placement decisions for families and friends trying to find residential care facilities for aging loved ones. This bill creates consumer protections for families and friends using referral services to find residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFE). RCFEs are non-medical facilities that specialize in housing, personalized supportive services, and assistance in activities of daily living for dependent residents. RCFEs are licensed, inspected, and regulated by the California Department of Social Services. However, the provisions in current law only minimally regulate referral sources by imposing misdemeanors for referrals to unlicensed facilities or the wrong level of care and for failure to report unlicensed facilities or potentially harmful conditions at an RCFE. This bill seeks to establish a set of consumer protection practices to govern the interaction between the referral source and the consumer.
To address the lack of information and regulations on referral agencies, SB 875 would require compensated referral sources to give consumers important disclosures before referring them to a RCFE, creates licensing requirements for referral agencies, and ban certain practices. SB 875 requires referral sources that receive compensation to provide disclosures to the senior or their representative. Additionally, SB 875 would enact a notice requirement for providing families with information about the availability of state inspection and complaints regarding facilities, the referral agencies privacy policy and a statement that the family may request that the referral agency cease contact with the family. In addition, the bill provides for background checks on referral agencies’ employees who have direct contact with seniors, requires liability insurance coverage, limits any back-channel remuneration to a referral agency, requires that referral agencies maintain and display a privacy policy on their internet websites, and prevents conflict of interest situations in referrals.”
Equity Implications: According to the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), over the next two decades, California’s share of people over 65 years of age will nearly double. PPIC projects that by 2030 slightly more than one million seniors will require some assistance with self-care, and that the demand for nursing home care will begin to increase after decades of decline. In preparation for this increased demand, it is appropriate for the Legislature to ensure that consumers can trust the information being provided to them by referral agencies when it is time to seek care for their loved one According to data from the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF), 74% of residents are female and the average resident is 87 years of age. CAHF also reports residents staying an average of 28.3 months and that the majority of assisted living services are paid for with private funds since Medicare does not pay for assisted living services under any circumstances. It is likely that the majority of these residents outlived their spouses and are relying on one fixed income to pay for their care. As a result, it is important for families seeking the services of referral agencies to have access to reliable and unbiased information in order to make the best choice for their loved one.
Policy Considerations: The need for residential care will continue to increase as the proportion of those over the age of 65 in California continues to expand, as expected in 2030. Referral agencies could serve as an important tool for families to find the best care and best fit possible; and ensuring referral agencies are protecting these vulnerable consumers and their families is vital. However, this bill creates a regulatory structure that is unclear and includes provisions that do not protect consumers.
Licensing. This bill adds to CDPH’s licensing structure to include RCFEs, but excludes existing placement agencies, as defined in HSC § 1569.47. This structure makes it unclear who would be subjected to the provisions of this bill. This bill also tasks CDSS with licensing referral agencies, but it is unclear if CDSS is equipped to license these businesses.
Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to clarify and specify what a referral agency is and remove licensing requirements while retaining consumer protections.
Disclosures. This bill includes disclosures that are vague and are unlikely to protect consumers. The disclosures included in the bill include general license information, fees received by the agency from an RCFE, a general statement referring the potential resident to a generic website, a vague statement that the facilities recommended are not a comprehensive list, and an opt-out selection for the consent of private information to be sold to third parties.
Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to 1) provide a more detailed disclosure,
2) clarify that the disclosure must be done orally and written and in a language of their preference, 3) clarify that there is a free and impartial website run by the State of California, and 4) provide that persons can opt-in rather than an opt-out allowing agencies to sell their personal information.
Remedies. The population being referred to RCFEs is vulnerable and there is the possibility of great harm when referring a person to a facility that may not be a good fit. As noted above, RCFEs are not merely housing, but rather facilities that provide care and in some cases health-related care. As such, misconstruing information could be harmful to the resident and have impacts on their long-term health. Should a referral agency violate consumer protections, it is reasonable for them to assist in appropriate relocation.
Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to update remedies to provide for relocation as well as permit compensation for any harm caused.
Proposed Committee Amendments: The Committee proposes to address policy considerations stated above by striking the bill in print and recasting the bill as follows:
SEC. 1.
HSC § 1400.
(a) It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any extended care, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, without first having obtained a written license therefor as provided in this chapter from the director or from an inspection service approved by the director pursuant to Section 1257.
(b) It is unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any person or agency outside a long-term health care facility, as defined in Section 1418, for professional services for which the long-term health care facility does not employ a qualified professional person to furnish a specific service, including, but not limited to, laboratory, diagnostic, or therapy services, unless the long-term health care facility complies with current federal and state laws regarding the provision of these services and all of the following conditions are met:
(1) The services will be provided in accordance with professional standards applicable to the provision of these services in a long-term health care facility.
(2) The long-term health care facility assumes responsibility for timeliness of the services.
(3) Services are provided or obtained only when ordered by the attending physician and a notation is made in the resident’s medical chart reflecting that the service has been provided to the resident.
(C) A referral agency shall not refer, place, or recommend placement of individuals to licensed residential care facilities for the elderly for renumeration when the individual cannot be cared for in the facility. Violation of this subdivision is a misdemeanor. All provisions under Health and Safety Code Section 1569.47 apply to this section.
SEC. 2.
Section 1401 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:
HSC § 1401.
As used in this chapter chapter, “referral agency” means a private, profit or nonprofit agency which that is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, care facility, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility facility, or residential care facility for the elderly, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. “Referral agency” is a placement agency under Section 1569.47 for the purposes of that section and does not include any of the following:
(a) A licensed residential care facility for the elderly that does either of the following:
(1) Provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients.
(2) Provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
(b) A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed residential care facility for the elderly and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed residential care facility for the elderly.
(c) A staff member of the licensed residential care facility for the elderly who receives remuneration from the facility for professional services, including, but not limited to, sales and marketing efforts, on behalf of that facility.
SECTION 3
HSC § 1569.47.
(a) “Placement agency” means any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private agency providing placement or referral services, conservator pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 1800) of Division 4 of the Probate Code, conservator pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 5350) of Part 1 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities which is engaged in finding homes or other places for the placement of elderly persons for temporary or permanent care.
(b) A placement agency shall not place, refer, or recommend placement of individuals in licensed residential care facilities for the elderly when the individual, because of his or her health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. Violation of this subdivision is a misdemeanor.
(c) A placement agency or employee of a placement agency shall not place, refer, or recommend placement of a person in a facility providing care and supervision, or protective supervision, unless the facility is licensed as a residential care facility for the elderly or is exempt from licensing under Section 1569.145. Violation of this subdivision is a misdemeanor.
(d) Any employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility which is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license shall report the name and address of the facility to the department. Failure to report as required by this subdivision is a misdemeanor.
(e) The department shall investigate any report filed under subdivision (d). If the department has probable cause to believe that the facility which is the subject of the report is operating without a license, the department shall investigate the facility within 10 days after receipt of the report.
(f) A placement agency shall notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents which would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a residential care facility for the elderly. Reportable incidents include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1) Incidents of physical abuse.
(2) Any violation of personal rights.
(3) Any situation in which a facility is unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or in poor condition.
(4) Any situation in which a facility has insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty.
(5) Any situation in which experience mental or verbal abuse.
(g) A placement agency shall conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the agency and who is referred to a facility or facilities. Willful violation of this subsection is a misdemeanor. The department shall issue guidance on an appropriate suitability determination which includes, but does not limit, the following considerations:
(A) The level of care requested by the person seeking the referral.
(B) The cost of the facility and the ability of the financial means of the person seeking the referral.
(C) The social needs and preferences of the person seeking the referral.
(D) The geographic location of the facility and the geographic preference of the person seeking the referral.
(h) (1) A placement agency must provide the following disclosures to an individual for each referral, at the time the referral is made, or to a placement in a facility prior to such placement:
(A) The following statement: “The list provided includes ONLY referrals for which we receive compensation and is NOT comprehensive of all options available to you for residential care facilities in your area. For impartial and free information from the State of California with a full listing of residential facilities in your area, go to Cal Long Term Care Compare”
(B) A written record of all of the following:
(1) All substantiated complaints, and citations within five years as available from the California Department of Social Services for that facility.
(2) The information from Cal Long Term Care Compare for that facility, including the total number of citations
(C) If a person seeking a referral or person representative has communicated verbally, a verbal record of all the following:
(1) All substantiated complaints, and citations within five years as available from the California Department of Social Services for that facility.
(2) The information from Cal Long Term Care Compare for that facility, including the total number of citations
(D) If the placement agency engages in the sale of personal information to third parties for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral, a disclosure of that practice must be provided prior to making such a referral.
(E) A placement agency shall not sell or share the personal information of a person or the person’s representative unless the person or their representative affirmatively provides permission for the agency to do so for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
(F) The placement agency shall make the disclosures pursuant to this subdivision in the preferred or spoken language of the person receiving services and their authorized representative.
(G) That the person or their representative may request at any time orally, by email or by submitting a letter that the placement agency cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the agency will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
(i) (1) The information and disclosures required by subdivision (h) shall be provided to the person or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and must be provided, together, in both of the following methods:
(A) A written disclosure in the person’s spoken language in at least 12-point, Arial-equivalent bold font, either in hardcopy form or by electronic means. At the request of the person or their representative, the placement agency shall send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representative’s email address, as provided. And
(B) An oral disclosure given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. The disclosure shall be spoken clearly, and in a language that is understandable to the consumer.
(2) The placement agency shall maintain records of the disclosures set forth pursuant to this subdivision for a period of three years and shall provide additional copies of the disclosures to the person, their representative, or the facility, upon written request.
(j) (1) In addition to the other requirements of this section, a placement agency shall comply with all of the following:
(A) Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (g).
(B) Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request, pursuant to subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (g).
(k) Owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency as defined in HSC 1400 or placement agencies as defined in HSC 1569.47 are mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(l) It is unlawful for a referral agency as defined in HSC 1400 or placement agencies as defined in HSC 1569.47 to hold any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
(m) On and after July 1, 2025, all persons, associations, or corporations as defined in HSC 1400 or placement agencies as defined in HSC 1569.47 shall maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the total annual aggregate, for negligent acts or omissions by the licensee.
(n) In addition to any other remedy available by law, a placement agency that violates this section is subject to:
i) a civil penalty of between two hundred fifty dollars ($250) and five thousand dollars ($5,000) for each violation as determined by the department.
A) proceedings to appeal determinations of civil penalties by the department shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
ii) relocation compensation to a facility of their choice
iii) compensation for any injury or harm resulting from this violation to which the individual may be entitled under the law.
iiii) is a misdemeanor.
Double referral: Should this bill pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Aging and Long Term Care.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 499 (B. Rubio) of 2021, would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source; additionally would have required a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information, as specified. AB 499 was vetoed by Governor Newsom.
AB 2926 (Calderon) of 2020, would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. AB 2926 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2744 (Reyes) of 2018, would have required referral agencies providing referrals to RCFEs to register with CDSS, and set forth a number of requirements for these referral agencies including providing a client with a disclosure prior to providing a referral that includes certain pieces of information in clear language; displaying certain information on its website; and, displaying its name and registration number on all advertising, promotions, or marketing material. AB 2744 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza) of 2017, would have established requirements for private agencies that refer potential residents for a fee to adult residential facilities, including RCFEs, and would have required CDSS to track consumer complaints about private referral agencies, authorized CDSS to levy civil penalties, and required CDSS to submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of existing statutory remedies related to private referral agencies by January 1, 2023. SB 648 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza) of 2015, would have added referrals to RCFEs to the body of law requiring anyone who refers someone to a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility for compensation to be licensed as a referral agency and established new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosure of any agreement with the facilities that clients are being referred to, any commissions or fees received, and a requirement for liability insurance. SB 648 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
A Place for Mom (Co-Sponsor)
ACT8 (Co-Sponsor)
California Assisted Living Association
Elderly Care Everywhere
Opposition
AARP
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long Term Care Ombudsman Association (CLTCOA)
Justice in Aging
Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman
Analysis Prepared by: Alexandria Smith / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 875 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 875
Author: Glazer (D)
Amended: 1/11/24
Vote: 21
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 3-0, 1/8/24
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Ochoa Bogh, Hurtado
NO VOTE RECORDED: Menjivar, Wahab
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 1/11/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Gonzalez, Laird, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 1/18/24
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Ashby
SUBJECT: Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies
SOURCE: A Place for Mom
ActEight, LLC
DIGEST:
This bill (1) requires the licensure and regulation of agencies that refer consumers to residential care facilities for the elderly by the California Department of Social Services (CDSS); (2) establishes new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosures, background checks for licensee representatives, and cessation of contact and data sharing once requested, among other requirements, as specified; (3) requires a referral agency licensee to provide services, as specified, to persons seeking a referral; (4) authorizes the CDSS to verify compliance for licensure without conducting an onsite licensing inspection; (5) requires the CDSS to deny an applicant a license and provide a notice in writing if the applicant is not in compliance, and authorizes an applicant to present a written petition within 20 days of receipt of the written notice; and (6) authorizes an applicant for a referral agency license to have a physical place of business outside the state.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of extended care, skilled nursing home, and intermediate care facilities by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 1250 et seq.)
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of referral agencies of extended care facilities, skilled nursing homes, and intermediate care facilities. (HSC 1400 et seq.)
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFEs) by CDSS. (HSC 1569 et seq.)
- Defines a “RCFEs” as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or over, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided. (HSC 1569.2(o))
- Defines “referral agency” to mean a private, profit or nonprofit agency which is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. (HSC 1401)
- Requires an application for a referral agency license or renewal of a referral agency license to be accompanied by an annual Licensing and Certification Program fee, as set annually by the CDPH Licensing and Certification Division. (HSC 1403)
- Prohibits a referral agency from having a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee. (HSC 1404)
This bill:
- Requires an entity that refers a person to a RCFE to obtain a license from the CDSS.
- Requires CDSS, no later than February 1, 2025 and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, to submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
- Adds an entity that refers a person to a RCFE under the existing definition of a referral agency, thereby making existing requirements that apply to a referral agency additionally apply to a RCFE referral agency.
- Provides that a referral facility does not include:
- A licensed RCFE that either provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients or provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
- A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed RCFE and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed RCFE.
- A staff member of the licensed RCFE who receives remuneration from the RCFE for professional services, including sales and marketing efforts on behalf of the RCFE.
- Prohibits an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or RFCE from paying a commission or fee to any referral agency not licensed by CDSS or CDPH, as applicable.
- Prohibits any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any RCFE for professional services if that facility does not meet existing licensing standards.
- Provides that a RCFE referral agency may satisfy this requirement by obtaining and relying on the licensing status information for a RCFE that is published on the website of CDSS.
- Requires a RCFE referral agency to declare that it will either conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities or will provide a specified statement to the individual or their representative.
- Requires a RCFE referral agency to make specified disclosures before referring a person to a RCFE.
- In addition to any other remedy available at law, makes a violation of these disclosure requirements subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation recoverable by a district attorney or a city attorney in superior court.
- Provides that a district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to enjoin a violation of these disclosure requirements.
- Specifies that a RCFE referral agency must comply with the requirements of Section 1569.47 of the Health and Safety Code.
- Makes owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
- Prohibits a referral agency from holding any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
- Requires, on and after July 1, 2025, all referral agencies to maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate for negligent acts or omissions.
- Makes it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a RCFE or referral agency.
Comments
Author’s statement. According to the author, “Navigating the process of finding an appropriate setting for an aging family member or friend can be stressful and is often done under pressing circumstances. Referral agencies are a crucial part of placement decisions for families and friends trying to find residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFEs). RCFEs are non-medical facilities that specialize in housing, personalized supportive services, and assistance in activities of daily living for dependent residents. RCFEs are licensed, inspected, and regulated by the California Department of Social Services. However, the provisions in current law only minimally regulate referral agencies, who refer aging Californians to appropriate facilities, by imposing misdemeanors for referrals to unlicensed facilities or the wrong level of care and for failure to report unlicensed facilities or potentially harmful conditions at an RCFE.”
The author further states, “In 2031, 1 in 4 Californians will be over the age of 60, and many will require support and care in RCFEs as they age. The legislature must ensure the state can keep track referral agencies by licensing them. Licensing ensures the state can weed out referral agencies who are not following the law. Additionally, this bill seeks to establish a set of best consumer protection practices to govern the interaction between the referral source and the consumer. This bill requires referral agencies disclosure their financial relationship between themselves and the facility so consumers can make an informed choice.”
RCFEs. RCFEs, also known as assisted living facilities, are residential facilities that provide 24-hour nonmedical care and supervision for persons in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living (ADLs) or for the protection of the individual who is 60 years of age or older.
RCFEs provide housing, housekeeping, supervision, and personal care assistance with ADLs to individuals who need that level of care. These are nonmedical facilities that are designed for individuals who are unable to live by themselves, but who do not need 24-hour nursing care. As such, these facilities are not required to have nurses, certified nursing assistants or doctors on staff. RCFEs usually centrally store and distribute medications for residents to self-administer. Residents of RCFEs may have mental, behavioral, or physical health needs or a developmental disability that results in their inability to live independently. These facilities range in size from small facilities operating out of single family homes serving a handful of residents to larger buildings that can house over a 100 residents.
RCFEs are licensed and regulated by CDSS’s Community Care Licensing Division. The Community Care Licensing Division protects the health and safety of persons residing in RCFEs through its regulatory and enforcement programs. In addition to its licensing requirements, the Community Care Licensing Division conducts regular inspections of facilities to assess compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Violations can result in citations, fines and, in extreme cases, loss of a license to operate a facility.
Unregulated Referral Agencies. When a person can no longer live independently due to age or disability, locating appropriate housing and support can be an overwhelming endeavor. It is especially challenging if the person doing the searching is not familiar with the various types of assisted living services and settings.
Under such circumstances, businesses, often referred to “referral agencies,” offer the service of identifying and referring seniors, or their representatives, to potentially suitable living arrangements, or “placements”. Referral agencies are also known as “placement agencies” and “referral sources” and they range from small local businesses to large, internet-based agencies that provide referral services across the country. By law, the referrals must be made to an appropriately licensed facility that can provide necessary care for the senior within the limits of the RCFE license.
Business models vary, but it is common that clients do not pay a fee for a referral. Clients also do not usually enter into a contract with the agency. Instead, referral agencies typically have financial arrangements with RCFEs and receive a fee, often, reportedly, the amount of one month’s rent in the facility, if an individual moves into an RCFE to which the agency has remade a referral.
California does not regulate this industry. Thus, it is difficult to estimate how many of these agencies operate in the state. However, the National Placement and Referral Alliance (NPRA), a national trade association for the senior placement industry, indicates it has about 200 members in California. NPRA has established a code of ethics and recommended set of best practices to ensure seniors and their families are cared for properly.
A History of Attempts to Regulate. This bill represents the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate compensated referral agencies. Broadly, these bills can be grouped into two separate efforts. One set of bills includes AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020) and AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021). These bills would have recast requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source.
The other set of bills, including SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015), SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), and AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018), would have attempted to establish comprehensive regulatory schemes for these entities.
Both approaches have been vetoed by the Governor. The most recent iteration of this bill was AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021). As introduced, this bill was almost identical to AB 499. In his veto message for AB 499, Governor Newsom wrote, in part:
It is important that individuals have access to objective, independent, comprehensive, and free information about RCFEs. The Budget Act of 2022 appropriated $1 million to the California Department of Aging to facilitate the display of this information on CalLongTermCareCompare.org. While I appreciate the author’s attempts to enact consumer protections for older adults and their loved ones looking for a RCFE, I am concerned this bill may serve to reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities are only providing referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation. While there is no cost to the consumer, there are equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice. This bill seeks to advance some important provisions and further conversation is needed to ensure consumers and their loved ones are provided with sufficient protections. I am directing the California Elder and Disability Justice Coordinating Council within the California Health and Human Services Agency to work with the author on a revised concept that includes stronger and more equitable consumer protections.
The Governor has also vetoed attempts to license this industry. The current version of this bill is very similar to SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), which was vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message for SB 648, Governor Brown wrote, in part “This bill creates an expansive and costly licensing scheme for agencies that make referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly. The proponents of this measure have not made a convincing case for this new licensing structure.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021) would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source; additionally would have required a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information, as specified. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020) would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. The bill was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018) would have required referral agencies providing referrals to RCFEs to register with CDSS, and set forth a number of requirements for these referral agencies including providing a client with a disclosure prior to providing a referral that includes certain pieces of information in clear language; displaying certain information on its internet website; and, displaying its name and registration number on all advertising, promotions, or marketing material. The bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) would have established requirements for private agencies that refer potential residents for a fee to adult residential facilities, including RCFEs, and would have required CDSS to track consumer complaints about private referral agencies, authorized CDSS to levy civil penalties, and required CDSS to submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of existing statutory remedies related to private referral agencies by January 1, 2023, as specified. The bill was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015) would have added referrals to RCFEs to the body of law requiring anyone who refers someone to a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility for compensation to be licensed as a referral agency, and established new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosure of any agreement with the facilities that clients are being referred to, any commissions or fees received, and a requirement for liability insurance. SB 648 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown ongoing costs, likely millions, for the CDSS for state operations to establish and administer the new licensing program (Licensing and Certification Fund). The CDPH does not anticipate a fiscal impact. Unknown, potentially significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate alleged violations of this measure (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund). While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
SUPPORT: (Verified 1/24/24)
A Place for Mom (co-source)
ActEight, LLC (co-source)
6Beds, Inc.
California Assisted Living Association
LeadingAge California
National Placement and Referral Alliance
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/24/24)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman
Disability Rights California
Justice in Aging
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: A Place for Mom writes in support, “SB 875 would require a referral agency to give consumers important disclosures before any referrals could be made, create regulatory safeguards, and ban certain practices…A Place for Mom is the largest national online senior living referral agencies with hundreds of highly trained, experienced, and compassionate senior living advisors located in cities across North America, including in California. They are committed to providing family members the critical assistance they need in finding the right assisted living facility for their loved one, often at a time of crisis, based on their unique needs and budget. They are paid by the assisted living facilities and care providers in its network, so the services are provided to families at no charge. SB 875 is the result of nine years of legislative discussions contemplating how to provide consumer benefit-oriented notice to families without costs to the state and without undue burden to the industry, while positively changing the playing field within the industry.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association writes in opposition, “Any proposed regulatory framework for referral agencies in California must at least ensure that such agencies are licensed and regulated by the state, and that both criminal and civil liability still exists for referral agencies who engage in practices like referring consumers to unlicensed facilities, referring consumers to facilities that are not licensed to provide the correct level of care, or otherwise violating existing provisions in the Health & Safety Code. SB-875, in its current form, does not provide assurance that all those essential regulatory mechanisms will be in place if this law is passed. And the stakes are too high for consumers and their families to enact a regulatory framework for referral agencies without them in California, which is why the Governor vetoed prior iterations of this bill.”
Prepared by: Heather Hopkins / HUMAN S. / (916) 651-1524
1/24/24 15:40:53
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 875 (Glazer) - Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 875 would require the licensure and regulation of agencies that refer consumers to Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs).
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown ongoing costs, likely millions, for the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) for state operations to establish and administer the new licensing program (Licensing and Certification Fund).
- The California Department of Public Health does not anticipate a fiscal impact.
- Unknown, potentially significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate alleged violations of this measure (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund). While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
Background:
RCFEs, also known as assisted living facilities, are residential facilities that provide 24-hour nonmedical care and supervision for persons in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living (ADLs) or for the protection of the individual who is 60 years of age or older. The CDSS licenses RCFEs.
Certain businesses, often referred to as “referral agencies,” offer the service of identifying and referring seniors, or their representatives, to potentially suitable living arrangements or placements. Business models vary, but it is common that clients do not pay a fee for a referral. Instead, referral agencies typically have financial arrangements with facilities and receive a fee if an individual moves into a facility to which the agency has made a referral. While current law requires that referrals to RCFEs must be made to an appropriately licensed facility that can provide necessary care for the senior within the limits of the RCFE license, California does not regulate referral agencies that refer persons to RCFEs.
Existing law does require a referral agency to obtain a license from the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) in order to refer a person to any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, or intermediate care facility.
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Require a referral agency to obtain a license from the CDSS in order to refer a person to an RCFE and require specified license application information.
- Require duties of referral agencies that refer persons to RCFEs, including the disclosure of specified information to persons before they are referred to an RCFE; and require that specified violations of these requirements are subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation.
- Require the CDSS to set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee at an amount no greater than the amount required to cover the reasonable and actual costs of administering the licensing program; and require CDSS, no later than February 1, 2025, and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, to submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
- Make it unlawful for any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or RCFE, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, to pay a commission or fee to a referral agency that does not have a written license with the state, as specified.
- Make it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to an RCFE or a referral agency licensed by CDPH or CDSS.
- Require that for referral agencies licensed by CDPH or CDSS:
- Owners, operators, and employees of the referral agency are mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse.
- It is unlawful for the referral agency to hold any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
- All persons, associations, or corporations licensed must maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the total annual aggregate, for negligent acts or omissions by the licensee.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 875 (Author:Glazer)
Version: January 3, 2024
Hearing Date: January 11, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies.
DIGEST
This bill requires an entity that refers a person to a residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE referral agency) to obtain a license from the State Department of Social Services (DSS) and generally applies existing requirements for referral agencies licensed by the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to RCFE referral agencies. The bill prohibits an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or RFCE from paying a commission or fee to any referral agency not licensed by DSS or DPH. The bill requires a RCFE referral agency to make specified disclosures. The bill makes other changes the statutes regulating referral agencies, such as making owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency mandated reporters.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Estimates indicate that by 2050 roughly 2.9 million people living in California will be 60 to 64 years of age. As Californians grow older, locating suitable and quality housing to provide personal and medical care becomes increasingly more important. When a family seeks to place a loved one in an assisted-living facility, they frequently turn to referral sources to find an appropriate fit for their needs, especially during times of crisis. While RCFEs are regulated under existing law by DSS, private referral sources, which typically provide free referrals but receive compensation from the RCFE, are not regulated. This bill is the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate RCFE referral agencies and is somewhat similar to SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) which was vetoed by then Governor Brown.
The bill is sponsored by A Place For Mom and ACT8 and supported by 6beds Inc. and
LeadingAge California. The bill is opposed by the California Office of the State Long-term Care Ombudsman and organizations that advocate for the elderly and those with disabilities as well as for nursing care home reform. The bill passed the Senate Human Services Committee on a vote of 3 to 0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the licensing and regulation of extended care, skilled nursing home, and intermediate care facilities by DPH. (Health & Saf. Code § 1250 et seq.) [1]
- Licenses and regulates referral agencies of extended care facilities, skilled nursing homes, and intermediate care facilities by DPH. (§ 1400 et seq.)
- Defines “referral agency” to mean a private, profit or nonprofit agency which is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. (§ 1401.)
- Prohibits a referral agency from having a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee. (§ 1404.)
- Provides that DPH may suspend or revoke referral agency license for a violation of any provision of the statutes governing referral agencies and that DPH is required to assess a civil penalty in the amount of fees received by a licensee as a result of a violation of any of those provisions.
- Establishes the California Residential Facilities for the Elderly Act to provide for the licensing and regulation of residential care facilities for the elderly by the State Department of Social Services. (§ 1569 et seq.)
- Defines “residential care facilities for the elderly” as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or older, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided, based upon the resident’s varying needs, as determined in order to be admitted and to remain in the facility. (§ 1569.2(o).)
- Defines “placement agency” as any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private agency providing placement or referral services, conservator, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities that is engaged in finding homes or other places for placement of elderly persons for care, as specified. (§ 1569.47(a).)
- Regulates placement or referral services as follows:
- Prohibits a placement agency from placing individuals in licensed residential care facilities for the elderly when the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. A violation of this provision is a misdemeanor. (Id. at (b).)
- Prohibits a placement agency or employee thereof from placing, referring, or recommending placement of a person in a facility providing care and supervision, or protective supervision, unless the facility is licensed as a residential care facility for the elderly, except as specified. A violation of this provision is a misdemeanor. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides that a placement agency or employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility that is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license must report the name and address of the facility to the department. Failure to report is a misdemeanor. (Id. at (d).) The department must investigate these reports, as specified. (Id. at (e).)
- Requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a residential care facility for the elderly, including: physical abuse; violations of personal rights; unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or poor conditions; insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty; and mental or verbal abuse. A violation is a misdemeanor. (Id. at (f).)
This bill:
- Requires an entity that refers a person to a RCFE to obtain a license from the DSS.
- Requires DSS, no later than February 1, 2025 and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, to submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
- Includes an entity that refers a person to a RCFE under the existing definition of a referral agency, thereby making existing requirements that apply to a referral agency additionally apply to a RCFE referral agency.
- Provides that a referral facility does not include:
- a licensed RCFE that either: (1) provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients, or (2) provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers;
- a resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed RCFE and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed RCFE;
- a staff member of the licensed RCFE who receives remuneration from the RCFE for professional services, including sales and marketing efforts on behalf of the RCFE.
- Prohibits an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or RFCE from paying a commission or fee to any referral agency not licensed by DSS or DPH, as applicable.
- Prohibits any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any RCFE for professional services if that facility does not meet existing licensing standards.
- Provides that a RCFE referral agency may satisfy this requirement by obtaining and relying on the licensing status information for a RCFE that is published on the website of DSS.
- Requires a RCFE referral agency to declare that it will either conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities or will provide a specified statement to the individual or their representative.
- Requires a RCFE referral agency to make specified disclosures before referring a person to a RCFE.
- In addition to any other remedy available at law, makes a violation of these disclosure requirements subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation recoverable by a district attorney or a city attorney in superior court.
- Provides that a district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to enjoin a violation of these disclosure requirements.
- Specifies that a RCFE referral agency must comply with the requirements of Section 1569.47 of the Health and Safety Code.
- Makes owners, operators, and employees of a referral agency mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
- Prohibits a referral agency from holding any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
- Requires, on and after July 1, 2025, all referral agencies to maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate for negligent acts or omissions.
- Makes it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a RCFE or referral agency.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
When families are looking to place a loved one in a residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) they often turn to referral sources. Referral sources are agencies that match individuals to RCFEs. They do this by gathering the individual and their families’ information and distribute that information to a number of facilities to locate an appropriate fit. This service is typically at no cost to the family, with the referral source being paid by the RCFE.
RCFEs are non-medical facilities that specialize in housing, personalized supportive services, and assistance in activities of daily living, such as getting dressed, eating, walking, etc. RCFEs are licensed, inspected, and regulated by the State Department of Social Services. While costs vary greatly, the average cost of one month’s stay at a California RCFE is $4,500.
By 2050, the number of Californians aged 60-64 is expected to increase 54%, or to almost 2.9 million people. While regulations are currently in place for RCFEs, regulations on referral sources is lacking. Referral sources are increasingly becoming a useful tool for families in easing a loved one’s transition from unassisted to assisted living. It is important that families are well informed, receive trusted information, and are protected when trying to place a loved one into an RCFE.
The provisions in current law only minimally regulate referral sources by imposing misdemeanors for referrals to unlicensed facilities or the wrong level of care and for failure to report unlicensed facilities or potentially harmful conditions at an RCFE. This bill seeks to establish a set of best consumer protection practices to govern the interaction between the referral source and the consumer.
- Background
- RCFEs
“Long-term care” facilities provide inpatient care to individuals over extended periods of time. In general, long-term care facilities are appropriate for persons who are elderly, chronically ill, or in need of extensive rehabilitative services. There are three generally recognized classifications of long-term care facilities: skilled nursing facilities, intermediate care facilities, and residential care facilities for the elderly. A “residential care facility for the elderly” is a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or older, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided, based upon the resident’s varying needs, as determined in order to be admitted and to remain in the facility. (§ 1569.2(o).) RCFEs are governed by the California Residential Facilities for the Elderly Act (Act), which provides for the licensing and regulation of these facilities by the DSS.
The Act defines the term “placement agency” as any county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private agency providing placement or referral services, conservator, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities that is engaged in finding homes or other places for placement of elderly persons for care, as specified. (§ 1569.47(a).) Additionally, the Act places the following requirements on a placement agency:
- Prohibits placing individuals in licensed residential care facilities for the elderly when the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. (Id. at (b).)
- Prohibits a placement agency or employee thereof from placing, referring, or recommending placement of a person in a facility providing care and supervision, or protective supervision, unless the facility is licensed as a residential care facility for the elderly, except as specified. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides that a placement agency or employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility that is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license must report the name and address of the facility to the department. (Id. at (d).) The department must investigate these reports, as specified. (Id. at (e).)
- Requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents that jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a RCFE, including: physical abuse; violations of personal rights; unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or poor conditions; insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty; and mental or verbal abuse. (Id. at (f).)
A violation of any of these requirements is punishable as a misdemeanor.
- Referral agencies
Existing law requires referral agencies that refer a person to an extended care facility, skilled nursing home, or intermediate care facility for compensation to obtain a license by DPH. This bill seeks to expand the existing licensing requirements for referral agencies to entities that refer a person to a RCFE for compensation. The bill would require a RCFE referral agency to be licensed by DSS. The bill also expands existing statutory requirements for all referral agencies and places specific disclosure requirements on RCFE referral agencies.
- Prior legislation
This bill represents the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate RCFE referral agencies and is somewhat similar to SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), which passed this Committee on a vote of 5 to 2, and SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015), which passed this Committee on a vote of 5 to 1.[2] SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file. SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015) was vetoed by then Governor Brown on the grounds that it created “an expansive and costly licensing scheme.” Some of the provisions in this bill are also similar to those found in AB 499 (Rubio, 2021), which passed this Committee on a vote of 10 to 1 but was ultimately vetoed by Governor Newsom who wrote:
I am concerned this bill may serve to reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities are only providing referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation […] there are equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice.” Governor Newsom concluded by stating: “I am directing the California Elder and Disability Justice Coordinating Council within the California Health and Human Services Agency to work with the author on a revised concept that includes stronger and more equitable consumer protections.
- Disclosure requirements for RCFE referral agencies
The bill requires a RCFE referral agency to make various disclosures before referring a person to a facility. These disclosures are as follows:
- A description of the licensee’s service.
- The licensee’s contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number.
- The licensee’s privacy policy, or, if the licensee maintains a website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the website.
- Whether and under what circumstances the licensee will be paid a fee by facilities to which the person is referred.
- That the person or their representative may request at any time by email or by submitting a letter that the licensee cease contact with the person or their representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the licensee will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
- The following statement: “Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of California’s residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing Division internet website at www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this internet website.”
- The following statement: “State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area.” This statement shall be followed by a link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging.
- A statement that the person’s information may be sold or shared for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral and a link to a website where a person can opt out of selling or sharing or, if the licensee does not maintain a website, a description of how the person can opt out of their selling or sharing of their information.
The bill makes a violation of these disclosure requirements subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation recoverable by a district attorney or a city attorney in superior court, and specifies that a district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to enjoin a violation of these disclosure requirements. The bill requires these disclosures to be provided in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and may be provided, together or separately, in either a written disclosure in at least 12-point, Arial-equivalent bold font, either in hardcopy form or by electronic means or as an oral disclosure given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative. If the person or their representative provides the licensee with an email address, the licensee must send an electronic version of the disclosure to the person or their representative’s email address. Any oral disclosure given telephonically and recorded with the consent of the person or their representative must be spoken clearly, and in a pitch and tone that is understandable to the consumer. If an oral disclosure is provided, a written disclosure must also be sent to the person or their representative. A RCFE referral agency is required to keep records of these disclosures for three years.
These requirements are substantially similar to ones that were included in AB 499 (Rubio, 2021). AB 499 was vetoed by Governor Newsom over concerns the bill could reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities were only providing referrals to those with whom they are contracted to receive compensation and that these financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, which could unfairly limit consumer information, access, and choice.
The existing statutes governing the licensure and regulation of referral agencies provides that “the department” is required to assess a civil penalty in the amount of fees received by a licensee as a result of a violation of any of those statutes or any regulations promulgated thereunder. (§ 1410.) The “department” for these purposes is defined as DPH. To avoid any ambiguity that DSS does not have the same authority over RCFE referral agencies to issue civil penalties, the author may wish to amend the bill to make it clear that “”the department” means DSS as it applies to RCFE referral agencies.
- Conflict-of-interest, consumer protection, and insurance requirements
The bill has several provisions that are intended to provide protections for consumers of RCFE referral agencies. These include:
- Requiring use of a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on representatives of the licensee who have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
- Accepting remuneration only from residential care facilities for the elderly with which the licensee has a written contract.
- Posting a privacy policy on every website the licensee operates, through a conspicuous link, in a similar manner as other similarly posted links used by the business on its home page. If the licensee does not maintain a website, then it must provide the person or their representative with a written copy of the privacy policy.
- Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible, but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request to do so.
- Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request to do so.
These requirements are substantially similar to ones that were included in AB 499 (Rubio, 2021).
The bill makes a violation of these provisions subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation recoverable by a district attorney or a city attorney in superior court, and specifies that a district attorney or a city attorney may institute a proceeding in superior court to enjoin a violation of these disclosure requirements. The bill also specifies that a RCFE referral agency must comply with Section 1569.47, which places various requirements on placement agencies and their employees.
The bill provides that owners, operators, and employees of any licensed referral agency are mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse pursuant to Section 15630 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. Additionally, the bill prohibits any licensed referral agency from holding power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity. The bill makes it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person who is acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, including, but not limited to, medical professionals, physicians, nurses, social workers, discharge planners, therapists, and geriatric care managers, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount, whether in the form of money or other consideration, as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a RCFE or licensed referral agency. Lastly, the bill requires, on and after July 1, 2025, that all referral agencies maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate for negligent acts or omissions.
- Proposed amendments
One of the statements that the bill requires an RCFE referral agency to make is inaccurate and contradicts other provisions of the bill. That statement is found in subparagraph (G) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 1409.4 and reads:
State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location.
Existing law prohibits a placement agency from placing individuals in licensed residential care facilities for the elderly when the individual, because of a health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient in a health facility. (§ 1569.47(b).) Additionally, the bill specifically states that a RCFE referral agency must comply with Section 1569.47. The Committee may wish to strike the inaccurate statement from the bill and make any additional necessary corresponding changes.
The specific amendments are as follows:[3]
Amendment 1
Amend paragraph (1) of subdivision (m) of Section 1405 of the Health and Safety Code to read:
(1) A declaration that the licensee will either conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities, or will comply with the requirements of subparagraph (G) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 1409.4. facilities. For purposes of this subdivision, “suitability determination” means a determination made by the licensee that the facility offers services to meet the needs of the person seeking a referral because of the following considerations:
Amendment 2
Amend subparagraph (G) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 1409.4 of the Health and Safety Code to read:
(G) The following statement: “State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The “The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area.” This statement shall be followed by a link to the callongtermcarecompare.org internet website maintained by the California Department of Aging.
- Opposition’s concerns
Opponents of the bill have several concerns. One common issue raised by all the opposition is the statement required to be made that is referenced above in the proposed amendments section of this analysis (see Comment 5, above). They point out the same inconsistencies with the statement this analysis highlights.
Additionally, they believe that adding RCFE referral agencies into the existing statutory structure for existing licensed referral agencies creates ambiguity as to whether or not they are placement agencies under Section 1569.47 and whether or not the existing misdemeanor penalty provisions would apply. The author may wish to address this issue by amending the definition of placement agencies to explicitly include a RCFE referral agency licensed pursuant to Section 1405.
Opposition also has concerns that the bill does not require disclosures be provided in the consumer’s preferred language, be provided both verbally and in writing, and believe that the disclosure requirements are inadequate and should be strengthened. They also raise concerns that the bill allows for consumer data to be sold to third parties unless they explicitly choose to opt out. Disability Rights Council and Justice In Aging note that the bill does not regulate placement agencies or entities that provide referrals to RCFEs.
- Statements in support
A Place For Mom, one of the sponsors of the bill and an entity that receives compensation for providing referrals to RCFEs, writes in support:
SB 875 is the result of nine years of legislative discussions contemplating how to provide consumer benefit-oriented notice to families without costs to the state and without undue burden to the industry, while positively changing the playing field within the industry.
The author and cosponsors have met with other stakeholders and the Administration over the past year to address the Governor’s concerns expressed in his veto message of AB499. Proposed amendments and amendments already made include striking out any changes to existing law that allegedly weakened current law, adding licensing requested by the State Nursing Home Ombudsman, clarifying that existing misdemeanor penalties continue to apply, clarifying that 17200 enforcement may be available in addition to new civil penalties, adding additional privacy disclosures, add additional disclosures as to the availability of information on the Department of Aging website Callongtermcare.org, adding foreign language disclosure requirements, and additional disclosures regarding the contractual relationship between the referral agency and the referred facilities.
The author and sponsors remain committed to working with all stakeholders to ensure that California has the strongest consumer protection law possible without hindering the ability of families to utilize referral services which are often critical to helping families facing difficult decisions for a loved one.
- Statements in opposition
Disability Rights California writes in opposition, stating:
A spouse or an adult child who is looking for information about assisted living facilities for their loved one is typically in crisis and looking for reliable information to help them make an informed decision about placement. Because this is one of the most consequential decisions a family will make for their loved ones, the information provided by referral and placement agencies is absolutely critical and should leave families better informed. While SB 875 was introduced with the intention of improving protections for individuals and their families in crisis, the different iterations of this bill, including the current bill create ambiguity, enforcement challenges, and opportunities for referral agencies to evade oversight over their business practices.
Justice In Aging writes in opposition stating:
SB 875 was introduced in 2023 promising to provide protection to at-risk persons and their families in crisis. Instead, SB 875 used ambiguity, weak enforcement, and confusing terms to ensure that referral agencies evade any oversight over their business practices that may exist. The bill also ensured that consumers are unaware of their rights, and are without a meaningful mechanism to enforce them. We submitted opposition letters to the previous versions of the bill on March 30, 2023, April 12, 2023, and November 20, 2023.
The proposed amendments to SB 875 fail to correct these significant shortcomings, recasting it as a weak licensing statute that again diminishes or eliminates existing protections and creates confusion and ambiguity.
SUPPORT
A Place For Mom (sponsor)
ACT8 (sponsor)
6beds Inc.
LeadingAge California
OPPOSITION
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long-term Care Ombudsman Association
California Office of the State Long-term Care Ombudsman
Disability Rights California
Justice in Aging
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
AB 499 (Rubio, 2021), similar to AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020), would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. AB 499 passed this Committee by a vote of 10-1. It was vetoed by Governor Newsom who wrote: “I am concerned this bill may serve to reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities are only providing referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation […] there are equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice.” Governor Newsom concluded by stating: “I am directing the California Elder and Disability Justice Coordinating Council within the California Health and Human Services Agency to work with the author on a revised concept that includes stronger and more equitable consumer protections.”
AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020) would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. AB 2926 was not heard by this Committee due to time constraints associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. The bill was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018) would have required referral agencies providing referrals to RCFEs to register with CDSS, and set forth a number of requirements for these referral agencies including providing a client with a disclosure prior to providing a referral that includes certain pieces of information in clear language; displaying certain information on its internet website; and, displaying its name and registration number on all advertising, promotions, or marketing material. AB 2744 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) would have established requirements for private agencies that refer potential residents for a fee to adult residential facilities, including RCFEs, and would have required CDSS to track consumer complaints about private referral agencies, authorized CDSS to levy civil penalties, and required CDSS to submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of existing statutory remedies related to private referral agencies by January 1, 2023, as specified. SB 648 passed this Committee by a vote of 5-2 but was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015) would have added referrals to RCFEs to the body of law requiring anyone who refers someone to a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility for compensation to be licensed as a referral agency, and established new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosure of any agreement with the facilities that clients are being referred to, any commissions or fees received, and a requirement for liability insurance. SB 648 passed this Committee by a vote of 5-1. It was vetoed by Governor Brown, who wrote: “This bill creates an expansive and costly licensing scheme for agencies that make referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly” and concluded: “The proponents of this measure have not made a convincing case for this new licensing structure.”
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Human Services Committee (3 Ayes, 0 Noes)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Alvarado-Gil, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | SB 875 | ||
Author: | Glazer | ||
Version: | January 3, 2024 | Hearing Date: | January 8, 2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Heather Hopkins | ||
Subject: Health and care facilities: residential care facilities for the elderly: referral agencies.
SUMMARY
This bill requires the licensure and regulation of agencies that refer consumers to residential care facilities for the elderly by the California Department of Social Services (CDSS). This bill establishes new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosures, background checks for licensee representatives, and cessation of contact and data sharing once requested, among other requirements, as specified.
This bill requires a referral agency licensee to provide services, as specified, to persons seeking a referral. This bill authorizes the CDSS to verify compliance for licensure without conducting an onsite licensing inspection. This bill requires the CDSS to deny an applicant a license and provide a notice in writing if the applicant is not in compliance, and authorizes an applicant to present a written petition within 20 days of receipt of the written notice. This bill additionally authorizes an applicant for a referral agency license to have a physical place of business outside the state.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of extended care, skilled nursing home, and intermediate care facilities by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 1250 et seq.)
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of referral agencies of extended care facilities, skilled nursing homes, and intermediate care facilities. (HSC 1400 et seq.)
- Provides for the licensing and regulation of residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFEs) by the California Department of Social Services (CDSS). (HSC 1569 et seq.)
- Defines a “residential care facility for the elderly” as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or over, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided. (HSC 1569.2(o))
- Defines “referral agency” to mean a private, profit or nonprofit agency which is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any extended care, skilled nursing home or intermediate care facility or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care. (HSC 1401)
- Requires an application for a referral agency license or renewal of a referral agency license to be accompanied by an annual Licensing and Certification Program fee, as set annually by the CDPH Licensing and Certification Division. (HSC 1403)
- Prohibits a referral agency from having a direct or indirect financial interest in any medical facility doing business with the licensee. (HSC 1404)
This Bill:
- Makes it unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any RCFE without first having obtained a written license from the State Public Health Officer, CDSS, or from both, as appropriate.
- Makes it unlawful for any person, association, or corporation to establish, conduct, or maintain a referral agency or to refer any person for remuneration to any RCFE for professional services if that facility does not meet licensing standards for RCFEs.
- Makes it unlawful for any extended care facility, skilled nursing home, intermediate care facility, or RCFE, or a distinct part of a facility providing extended care, skilled nursing home care, or intermediate care, to pay a commission or fee to a referral agency that does not have a written license from the State Public Health Officer or an inspection service approved by the State Public Health Officer, from the CDSS, or from both, as appropriate.
- Amends the definition of “referral agency” to include a private, profit or nonprofit agency that is engaged in the business of referring persons for remuneration to any RCFE. Specifies that “referral agency” does not include any of the following:
- A licensed RCFE that does either of the following:
- A licensed RCFE that does either of the following:
Provides discounts or other remuneration to residents or their families for referring new or prospective clients.
Provides remuneration to staff for marketing or sales offers.
- A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed RCFE and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed RCFE.
- A staff member of the licensed RCFE who receive remuneration from the RCFE who receives remuneration from the facility for professional services, as specified.
- A resident who refers a new or prospective resident to a licensed RCFE and receives a discount or other remuneration from the licensed RCFE.
- Requires the CDSS to set the annual Licensing and Certification Program fee at an amount no greater than the amount required to cover the reasonable and actual costs of administering the licensing program. Additionally requires the CDSS to, no later than February 1, 2025, and no later than February 1 of each year thereafter, to submit a proposed fee schedule as part of its budget proposal to the Legislature.
- Requires a referral agency license to be submitted to either or both of the CDPH or the CDSS licensing divisions, as appropriate.
- Requires any person, partnership, firm, corporation, or association desiring obtain a license to refer persons to RCFEs to file an application with the CDSS through forms furnished by the CDSS.
- Requires the applications for a license to refer persons to RCFEs to include both of the following:
- A declaration that the licensee will do either of the following:
- A declaration that the licensee will do either of the following:
Conduct a suitability determination of each person who seeks a referral from the licensee and who is referred to a facility or facilities. Defines “suitability determination” to mean a determination made by the licensee that the facility offers services to meet the needs of the person seeking a referral because of the following considerations:
The level of care requested by the person seeking the referral.
The cost of the facility and the ability of the financial means of the person seeking the referral.
The social needs and preferences of the person seeking the referral.
The geographic location of the facility and the geographic preference of the person seeking the referral.
Include a disclosure statement that state law does not require the referral agency to determine whether facilities to which consumers are referred are suitable to the individual based upon the consumer’s unique needs, as specified.
- A declaration that the licensee trains all employees who make referrals to RCFEs regarding all of the following issues:
- A declaration that the licensee trains all employees who make referrals to RCFEs regarding all of the following issues:
All licensure requirements applicable to a referral agency, but not limited to, instruction on how to comply with all of those requirements.
State governance and administrative functions of agency operations, including resident assessment and admission procedures.
The psychosocial and physical needs of the elderly.
Community supports, cultural competency, and sensitivity to residents’ needs.
- Specifies that, when issuing a license to a referral agency that provides referrals to RCFEs, the CDSS is not required to conduct an onsite licensing inspection to verify licensure compliance. Further specifies that CDPH and CDSS may require a referral agency applicant to submit a copy or examples of the disclosures required by this bill.
- Requires the CDPH or CDSS to deny a referral agency applicant a license if the applicant is not in compliance with licensure requirements. Requires the licensing department to provide a notice of denial to the applicant in writing. Further, within 20 days of receipt of the notice, authorizes the applicant to present a written petition for a hearing to the licensing department.
- Specifies that an applicant for a referral agency license is not required to have a physical place of business within the state.
- Provides that before referring a person to a facility, the licensee shall disclose all of the following:
- A description of the licensee’s services.
- The licensee’s contact information.
- A licensee’s privacy policy or link to privacy policy on the internet website.
- Whether and under what circumstances the licensee will be paid a fee by facilities to which the person is referred.
- That the person or their representative may request at any time by email or letter that the licensee cease contact at points of contact they designate, and that the licensee will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the person or their representative.
- A statement that information can be found at the CDSS website regarding complaints and other information about facilities.
- The following statement: “State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area.” The statement also must have a website link to callongtermcarecompare.org.
- A statement that the person’s information may be sold or shared for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral and a link to an internet website where a person can opt out of selling or sharing or, if the licensee does not maintain an internet website, a description of how the person can opt out of their selling or sharing of their information.
- A description of the licensee’s services.
- Provides that these disclosures shall be made in the same language in which the licensee negotiates any referral services with the person receiving services.
- Provides that the disclosures be provided to the person or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner by either written or oral disclosure.
- Provides that additionally a licensee shall comply with the following:
- Conduct background checks on representatives that have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
- Only accept remuneration from RCFEs with which they have a written contract.
- Post a privacy policy on every internet website they operate. If they do not have a website, the privacy policy shall be provided as a written copy.
- Cease making referrals on behalf of the person or their representative as soon as feasible but nor more than 10 days after the receipt of such request.
- Cease contacting a person or their representative as soon as feasible but not more than 10 days after receiving such a request.
- Conduct background checks on representatives that have direct contact with persons or their representatives.
- Provides that a person or their representative, in accordance with existing law, have the right at any time to direct the licensee not to sell or share their personal information, for purposes other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
- Provides for civil penalties for violations.
- Makes owners, operators, and employees of a licensed referral agency mandated reporters of elder or dependent adult abuse.
- Makes it unlawful for a licensed referral agency to hold any power of attorney for a person receiving placement referral services from that licensee, or to receive or hold a client’s property in any capacity.
- Requires all persons, associations, or corporations with a referral agency license to, beginning July 1, 2025, maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) per person occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the total annual aggregate, for negligent acts or omissions by the licensee.
- Requires a referral agency licensee to display the licensee’s name and license number on all advertising, promotional or marketing material, and internet websites paid for, or operated by, the licensee.
- Makes it unlawful for an employee, independent contractor, or other person acting on behalf of a governmental agency, hospital, or other health care institution, as specified, to offer, provide, or accept a payment, rebate, refund, commission, preference, or discount as payment, compensation, or inducement for referring patients, clients, or customers to a facility or licensee.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “Navigating the process of finding an appropriate setting for an aging family member or friend can be stressful and is often done under pressing circumstances. Referral agencies are a crucial part of placement decisions for families and friends trying to find residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFEs). RCFEs are non-medical facilities that specialize in housing, personalized supportive services, and assistance in activities of daily living for dependent residents. RCFEs are licensed, inspected, and regulated by the California Department of Social Services. However, the provisions in current law only minimally regulate referral agencies, who refer aging Californians to appropriate facilities, by imposing misdemeanors for referrals to unlicensed facilities or the wrong level of care and for failure to report unlicensed facilities or potentially harmful conditions at an RCFE.”
The author further states, “In 2031, 1 in 4 Californians will be over the age of 60, and many will require support and care in RCFEs as they age. The legislature must ensure the state can keep track referral agencies by licensing them. Licensing ensures the state can weed out referral agencies who are not following the law. Additionally, this bill seeks to establish a set of best consumer protection practices to govern the interaction between the referral source and the consumer. This bill requires referral agencies disclosure their financial relationship between themselves and the facility so consumers can make an informed choice.”
Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs)
RCFEs, also known as assisted living facilities, are residential facilities that provide 24-hour nonmedical care and supervision for persons in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living (ADLs) or for the protection of the individual who is 60 years of age or older.
RCFEs provide housing, housekeeping, supervision, and personal care assistance with ADLs to individuals who need that level of care. These are nonmedical facilities that are designed for individuals who are unable to live by themselves, but who do not need 24-hour nursing care. As such, these facilities are not required to have nurses, certified nursing assistants or doctors on staff. RCFEs usually centrally store and distribute medications for residents to self-administer. Residents of RCFEs may have mental, behavioral, or physical health needs or a developmental disability that results in their inability to live independently. These facilities range in size from small facilities operating out of single family homes serving a handful of residents to larger buildings that can house over a 100 residents.
RCFEs are licensed and regulated by CDSS’s Community Care Licensing Division. The Division protects the health and safety of persons residing in RCFEs through its regulatory and enforcement programs. In addition to its licensing requirements, the Division conducts regular inspections of facilities to assess compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Violations can result in citations, fines and, in extreme cases, loss of a license to operate a facility.
Unregulated Referral Agencies
When a person can no longer live independently due to age or disability, locating appropriate housing and support can be an overwhelming endeavor. It is especially challenging if the person doing the searching is not familiar with the various types of assisted living services and settings.
Under such circumstances, businesses, often referred to “referral agencies,” offer the service of identifying and referring seniors, or their representatives, to potentially suitable living arrangements, or “placements”. Referral agencies are also known as “placement agencies” and “referral sources” and they range from small local businesses to large, internet-based agencies that provide referral services across the country. By law, the referrals must be made to an appropriately licensed facility that can provide necessary care for the senior within the limits of the RCFE license.
Business models vary, but it is common that clients do not pay a fee for a referral. Clients also do not usually enter into a contract with the agency. Instead, referral agencies typically have financial arrangements with RCFEs and receive a fee, often, reportedly, the amount of one month’s rent in the facility, if an individual moves into an RCFE to which the agency has remade a referral.
California does not regulate this industry. Thus, it is difficult to estimate how many of these agencies operate in the state. However, the National Placement and Referral Alliance (NPRA), a national trade association for the senior placement industry, indicates it has about 200 members in California. NPRA has established a code of ethics and recommended set of best practices to ensure seniors and their families are cared for properly.
A History of Attempts to Regulate
This bill represents the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate compensated referral agencies. Broadly, these bills can be grouped into two separate efforts. One set of bills, which includes the previous version of SB 875, AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020) and AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021). These bills recast requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source.
The other set of bills, including the current version of SB 875, SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015), SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), and AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018), attempted to establish comprehensive regulatory schemes for these entities.
Both approaches have been vetoed by the Governor. The most recent iteration of this bill was AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021). As introduced, SB 875 was almost identical to AB 499. In his veto message for AB 499, Governor Newsom wrote, in part “It is important that individuals have access to objective, independent, comprehensive, and free information about RCFEs. The Budget Act of 2022 appropriated $1 million to the California Department of Aging to facilitate the display of this information on CalLongTermCareCompare.org. While I appreciate the author’s attempts to enact consumer protections for older adults and their loved ones looking for a RCFE, I am concerned this bill may serve to reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities are only providing referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation. While there is no cost to the consumer, there are equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice. This bill seeks to advance some important provisions and further conversation is needed to ensure consumers and their loved ones are provided with sufficient protections. I am directing the California Elder and Disability Justice Coordinating Council within the California Health and Human Services Agency to work with the author on a revised concept that includes stronger and more equitable consumer protections.”
The Governor has also vetoed attempts to license this industry. The current version of this bill is very similar to SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), which was vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message for SB 648, Governor Brown wrote, in part “This bill creates an expansive and costly licensing scheme for agencies that make referrals to residential care facilities for the elderly. The proponents of this measure have not made a convincing case for this new licensing structure.”
Related/Prior Legislation:
AB 499 (B. Rubio, 2021) would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source; additionally would have required a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information, as specified. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020) would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. AB 2926 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018) would have required referral agencies providing referrals to RCFEs to register with CDSS, and set forth a number of requirements for these referral agencies including providing a client with a disclosure prior to providing a referral that includes certain pieces of information in clear language; displaying certain information on its internet website; and, displaying its name and registration number on all advertising, promotions, or marketing material. AB 2744 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) would have established requirements for private agencies that refer potential residents for a fee to adult residential facilities, including RCFEs, and would have required CDSS to track consumer complaints about private referral agencies, authorized CDSS to levy civil penalties, and required CDSS to submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of existing statutory remedies related to private referral agencies by January 1, 2023, as specified. SB 648 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015) would have added referrals to RCFEs to the body of law requiring anyone who refers someone to a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility for compensation to be licensed as a referral agency, and established new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosure of any agreement with the facilities that clients are being referred to, any commissions or fees received, and a requirement for liability insurance. SB 648 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
COMMENTS
The bill in its current form has been gutted and amended since it was last set to be heard in this committee. These amendments change the approach in this bill to one of licensure. Stakeholders have specifically identified two areas the author may wish to address. First, current law defines “placement agencies” in HSC Section 1569.47. This bill defines “referral agencies.” Stakeholders are concerned that this would create a loophole where referral agencies would not be subject to liability under HSC that applies to placement agencies. The author may wish to consolidate the definitions for each to avoid potential loopholes. Second, as currently written this bill contains a disclosure that states, “State law does not require that we determine whether facilities to which we refer you are suitable for you based upon your care and social needs, financial means, and location. The list provided is not comprehensive of all options available for residential care facility in your area.” Opponents believe this would take these agencies out of strict liability for improper placement. The author may wish to strike this language.
When individuals are looking for placement for an elderly family member, it is often done under times of incredible stress and time pressures. Given these circumstances, it may be sensible to instead allow such individuals to opt-in rather than to opt-out of sharing their personal information as currently written. This was the approach taken in SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015). The ability to opt-in would protect privacy and not add additional hardships on individuals already in stressful circumstances.
This bill does address providing information in multiple languages by providing disclosures be made “in the same language in which the licensee negotiates any referral services with the person receiving services.” It is unclear whether this language is used in any other section of law and the author may wish to provide a clearer directive that the disclosures simply be provided in the language of the individual’s choosing.
SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Arguments in Support:
In support, ACT8 states, “The bill would establish a transparent process to ensure that California consumers are provided with the information that they need to make an informed decision as they find the right senior care facility for family members.”
Also in support, A Place For Mom states, “Current California law is limited to provisions that prohibit referral to a facility that is unlicensed or that cannot provide the level of care needed. SB 875 would require a referral agency to give consumers important disclosures before any referrals could be made, create regulatory safeguards, and ban certain practices. […] SB 875 is the result of nine years of legislative discussions contemplating how to provide consumer benefit-oriented notice to families without costs to the state and without undue burden to the industry, while positively changing the playing field within the industry.”
Arguments in Opposition:
In opposition, Justice in Aging states, “SB 875 would harm older adults seeking services in integrated community settings. […] SB 875 was introduced in 2023 promising to provide protection to at-risk persons and their families in crisis. Instead, SB 875 used ambiguity, weak enforcement, and confusing terms to ensure that referral agencies evade any oversight over their business practices that may exist. The bill also ensured that consumers are unaware of their rights, and are without a meaningful mechanism to enforce them. We submitted opposition letters to the previous versions of the bill on March 30, 2023, April 12, 2023, and November 20, 2023. The amendments to SB 875 fail to correct these significant shortcomings, recasting it as a weak licensing statute that again diminishes or eliminates existing protections and creates confusion and ambiguity. We continue to oppose SB 875.”
POSITIONS
Support:
A Place for Mom (Co-Sponsor)
ActEight, LLC (Co-Sponsor)
National Placement and Referral Alliance
Oppose:
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Office of The State Long-Term Care Ombudsman
Justice in Aging
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Alvarado-Gil, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | SB 875 | ||
Author: | Glazer | ||
Version: | April 11, 2023 | Hearing Date: | April 17, 2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Heather Hopkins | ||
Subject: Referral source for residential care facilities for the elderly: duties
SUMMARY
This bill creates a newly defined “referral source.” This bill requires a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. This bill additionally requires a compensated referral source to use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks and imposes criminal penalties and civil penalties for a violation of these provisions.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Establishes the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) within the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) and requires CDSS to license various community care facilities and residential facilities, including RCFEs. (HSC 1502 and 1522)
- Establishes the California RCFE Act, which requires facilities that provide personal care and supervision, protective supervision or health related services for persons 60 years of age or older who voluntarily choose to reside in that facility to be licensed by CDSS. (HSC 1569 et seq.)
- Defines a “residential care facility for the elderly” as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or older, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided, based upon the resident’s varying needs, as determined in order to be admitted and to remain in the facility. (HSC 1569.2(o))
- Requires that reports on the results of each inspection, evaluation, or consultation be kept on file at CDSS, and all inspection reports, consultation reports, lists of deficiencies, and plans of correction be open to public inspection. (HSC 1569.33(g)(1))
- Requires CDSS to post on its internet website how to obtain an inspection report. (HSC 1569.33(g)(2(A))
- Defines a “placement agency” as any county welfare department; county social service department; county mental health department; county public guardian; general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator; state-funded program or private agency providing placement or referral services; conservator, as specified; and, regional center for persons with developmental disabilities which is engaged in finding homes or other places for the placement of elderly persons for temporary or permanent care. (HSC 1569.47(a))
- Prohibits a placement agency from placing individuals in licensed RCFEs when the individual, because of his or her health condition, cannot be cared for within the limits of the license or requires inpatient care in a health facility. Further provides that a violation of this provision is a misdemeanor. (HSC 1569.47(b))
- Prohibits a placement agency or employee of a placement agency from placing, referring, or recommending placement of a person in a facility providing care and supervision, or protective supervision, unless the facility is licensed as an RCFE or is exempt from licensing. Further provides that a violation of this provision is a misdemeanor. (HSC 1569.47(c))
- Requires any employee of a placement agency who knows, or reasonably suspects, that a facility which is not exempt from licensing is operating without a license to report the name and address of the facility to CDSS. Further provides that failure to report as required by this provision is a misdemeanor. (HSC 1569.47(d))
- Requires CDSS to investigate any report filed, and if the CDSS has probable cause to believe that the facility which is the subject of the report is operating without a license, requires the department to investigate the facility within 10 days after receipt of the report. (HSC 1569.47(e))
- Requires a placement agency to notify the appropriate licensing agency of any known or suspected incidents which would jeopardize the health or safety of residents in a RCFE. Reportable incidents include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
- Incidents of physical abuse;
- Any violation of personal rights;
- Any situation in which a facility is unclean, unsafe, unsanitary, or in poor condition;
- Any situation in which a facility has insufficient personnel or incompetent personnel on duty; and/or,
- Any situation in which residents experience mental or verbal abuse. (HSC 1569.47(f))
This Bill:
- Defines “compensated referral” to mean a referral by a private, for-profit or nonprofit entity that refers persons to RCFEs in exchange for any consideration or thing of value, including a fee, commission, gift, or any reciprocal benefit.
- Defines “referral” to mean notifying a RCFE that a person seeking senior housing or that person’s representative has consented to having the facility or the referral source contact them to facilitate the further evaluation of whether that facility is a suitable senior housing option for that person.
- Defines a “referral source” to mean a person or entity that provides a referral to an RCFE on behalf of a county welfare department, county social service department, county mental health department, county public guardian, general acute care hospital discharge planner or coordinator, state-funded program or private, for-profit, or nonprofit entity providing referral services, conservator, as defined, and regional center for persons with developmental disabilities that is engaged in identifying senior housing options at RCFEs.
- Provides that a referral source does not include a licensee of an RCFE, or any professional services staff member of an RCFE, who on behalf of that facility makes a referral, even if they have received a discount or other remuneration from the facility.
- Requires a referral source to, before sending a compensated referral to a RCFE located in California, provide the person or their representative with information that includes all of the following disclosures, in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers:
- A description of the referral source’s service;
- The referral source’s contact information, including business address, email address, and telephone number;
- A referral source’s privacy policy, or if the referral source maintains an internet website, a link or URL to the privacy policy on the internet website;
- A statement regarding whether and under what circumstances the referral source will be paid a fee by the RCFE to which the senior is referred;
- A statement that the senior or representative may request in writing that the referral source cease contact with the senior or the senior’s representative at points of contact they designate, such as telephone numbers and email addresses, and that the referral source will cease contact in response to that request and also cease making additional referrals on behalf of the senior or the senior’s representative; and,
- The following language: “Information regarding inspections, evaluations, complaints, and citations associated with any of California’s residential care facilities for the elderly, also known as assisted living facilities, can be viewed at the State Department of Social Services Community Care Licensing website at: www.cdss.ca.gov. Additionally, during a health-related state of emergency, information about the active cases within residential care facilities for the elderly may also be posted on this website.”
- A link to callongtermcarecompare.org maintained by the California Department of Aging.
- Requires the information and disclosures required by number 5 (above) to be provided to the senior or their representative in a clear and conspicuous manner designed to give actual notice of its contents and permits that it may be provided, together or separately, in any the following methods:
- A written disclosure at least in 12-point Arial-equivalent bold font either in hardcopy form or by electronic means;
- A link to an electronic disclosure displayed prominently on a web page in a larger font than the surrounding text; or
- Verbally, as specified.
- Requires the referral source to maintain records of the disclosures for a period of three years and shall to provide a copy of the disclosures provided to the senior, representative, or the residential care facility for the elderly, upon written request.
- Requires a compensated referral source to comply with all of the following:
- Use a nationally accredited service provider to perform background checks on referral sources who have direct contact with seniors or their representatives;
- Maintain liability insurance coverage in an amount of at least one million dollars per occurrence and two million dollars in total annual aggregate for negligent acts or omissions by the referral source or any of its employees;
- Accept remuneration only from RCFEs with which the referral source has a written contract;
- Post a privacy policy on every internet website it operates, as specified, or, if the referral source does not maintain an internet website, then it shall provide the senior or the senior’s representative with a written copy of the privacy policy;
- Refrain from holding any power of attorney for a resident or potential resident or from holding that person’s property in any capacity;
- Cease making referrals on behalf of the senior or the senior’s representative within 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request to do so; and
- Cease contacting a person or their representative within 10 days after receipt of an oral, electronic, or written request to do so.
- Obtain the affirmative consent – verbally, electronically, or in writing – of the person or representative for making referrals on a person’s behalf.
- Provides that the person or the person’s representative shall have the right, at any time, to direct the referral source not to sell or share their personal information for any purpose other than those necessary to make an authorized referral.
- Provides that a referral source that violates the disclosure requirements shown in numbers 8 and 9 (above) is subject to a civil penalty of between $250 and $1,000 for each violation.
- Permits a district attorney or a city attorney to institute a proceeding in superior court to recover the civil penalty and to restrain and enjoin a violation of the disclosure requirements required in this bill.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “Navigating the process of finding an appropriate setting for an aging family member or friend can be stressful and is often done under pressing circumstances. Referral agencies are a crucial part of placement decisions for families and friends trying to find residential care facilities for aging loved ones. This bill creates consumer protections for families and friends using referral services to find a RCFE. However, the provisions in current law only minimally regulate referral sources by imposing misdemeanors for referrals to unlicensed facilities or the wrong level of care and for failure to report unlicensed facilities or potentially harmful conditions at an RCFE. This bill seeks to establish a set of best consumer protection practices to govern the interaction between the referral source and the consumer.”
Residential Care Facilities for the Elderly (RCFEs)
RCFEs, also known as assisted living facilities, are residential facilities that provide 24-hour nonmedical care and supervision for persons in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living (ADLs) or for the protection of the individual who is 60 years of age or older.
RCFEs provide housing, housekeeping, supervision, and personal care assistance with ADLs to individuals who need that level of care. These are nonmedical facilities that are designed for individuals who are unable to live by themselves, but who do not need 24-hour nursing care. As such, these facilities are not required to have nurses, certified nursing assistants or doctors on staff. RCFEs usually centrally store and distribute medications for residents to self-administer. Residents of RCFEs may have mental, behavioral, or physical health needs or a developmental disability that results in their inability to live independently. These facilities range in size from small facilities operating out of single family homes serving a handful of residents to larger buildings that can house over a 100 residents.
RCFEs are licensed and regulated by CDSS’s Community Care Licensing Division. The Division protects the health and safety of persons residing in RCFEs through its regulatory and enforcement programs. In addition to its licensing requirements, the Division conducts regular inspections of facilities to assess compliance with applicable laws and regulations. Violations can result in citations, fines and, in extreme cases, loss of a license to operate a facility.
Unregulated Referral Agencies
When a person can no longer live independently due to age or disability, locating appropriate housing and support can be an overwhelming endeavor. It is especially challenging if the person doing the searching is not familiar with the various types of assisted living services and settings.
Under such circumstances, businesses, often referred to “referral agencies,” offer the service of identifying and referring seniors, or their representatives, to potentially suitable living arrangements, or “placements”. Referral agencies are also known as “placement agencies” and “referral sources” and they range from small local businesses to large, internet-based agencies that provide referral services across the country. By law, the referrals must be made to an appropriately licensed facility that can provide necessary care for the senior within the limits of the RCFE license.
Business models vary, but it is common that clients do not pay a fee for a referral. Clients also do not usually enter into a contract with the agency. Instead, referral agencies typically have financial arrangements with RCFEs and receive a fee, often, reportedly, the amount of one month’s rent in the facility, if an individual moves into an RCFE to which the agency has remade a referral.
California does not regulate this industry. Thus, it is difficult to estimate how many of these agencies operate in the state. However, the National Placement and Referral Alliance (NPRA), a national trade association for the senior placement industry, indicates it has about 200 members in California. NPRA has established a code of ethics and recommended set of best practices to ensure seniors and their families are cared for properly, some of which are included in this bill. For example, the bill requires disclosure of the fact that the referral agency will be compensated and that referral agencies must maintain liability insurance. However, this bill also contains provisions that are not stemming from the NPRA’s established code of ethics.
This bill represents the sixth attempt since 2015 to regulate compensated referral agencies. Broadly, these bills can be grouped into two separate efforts. First, three bills, SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015), SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017), and AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018), attempted to establish comprehensive regulatory schemes for these entities. AB 2744 was opposed by A Place for Mom and all three bills were opposed by Caring.com, the two largest referral agencies. The second group of bills, which includes this bill, AB 499 (Blanca Rubio, 2021) and AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020), are sponsored by two referral agencies.
Veto Message in AB 499
The most recent iteration of this bill was AB 499 (Blanca Rubio, 2021). That bill was vetoed by the Governor. As introduced, and prior to the recent amendments, this bill was an almost word-for-word reintroduce of SB 499.
In his veto message for AB 499 the Governor wrote, in part “It is important that individuals have access to objective, independent, comprehensive, and free information about RCFEs. The Budget Act of 2022 appropriated $1 million to the California Department of Aging to facilitate the display of this information on CalLongTermCareCompare.org. While I appreciate the author's attempts to enact consumer protections for older adults and their loved ones looking for a RCFE, I am concerned this bill may serve to reduce consumer options in instances where referral entities are only providing referrals to those RCFEs with whom they are contracted to receive compensation. While there is no cost to the consumer, there are equity concerns that the financial arrangements favor those facilities that can best afford remuneration fees, unfairly limiting consumer information, access, and choice. This bill seeks to advance some important provisions and further conversation is needed to ensure consumers and their loved ones are provided with sufficient protections. I am directing the California Elder and Disability Justice Coordinating Council within the California Health and Human Services Agency to work with the author on a revised concept that includes stronger and more equitable consumer protections.”
Related/Prior Legislation:
AB 499 (Blanca Rubio, 2021), similar to this bill, would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for RCFEs to a referral source; additionally requires a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information, as specified. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 2926 (Calderon, 2020), similar to this bill, would have recast the requirements on a placement agency for a RCFE to a referral source while requiring a referral source to provide a senior or their representative with specified disclosures and privacy information. AB 2926 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2744 (Reyes, 2018) would have required referral agencies providing referrals to RCFEs to register with CDSS, and set forth a number of requirements for these referral agencies including providing a client with a disclosure prior to providing a referral that includes certain pieces of information in clear language; displaying certain information on its internet website; and, displaying its name and registration number on all advertising, promotions, or marketing material. AB 2744 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2017) would have established requirements for private agencies that refer potential residents for a fee to adult residential facilities, including RCFEs, and would have required CDSS to track consumer complaints about private referral agencies, authorized CDSS to levy civil penalties, and required CDSS to submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of existing statutory remedies related to private referral agencies by January 1, 2023, as specified. SB 648 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 648 (Mendoza, 2015) would have added referrals to RCFEs to the body of law requiring anyone who refers someone to a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility for compensation to be licensed as a referral agency, and established new requirements on referral agencies, including disclosure of any agreement with the facilities that clients are being referred to, any commissions or fees received, and a requirement for liability insurance. SB 648 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
COMMENTS
Referral agencies are a growing industry. They provide a valuable service to clients who are seeking appropriate housing and care for themselves or for loved ones. As the number of older Californians increases, the need for these services is also likely to increase.
In recent years, there have been several attempts to regulate referral agencies with varying approaches. While this bill does not establish a formal regulatory structure for the industry, it does create industry standards, such as requiring the agencies to maintain liability insurance and privacy polies, which would provide added protections to the consumers of the referral services.
As a result of the somewhat unique business model, in which the financial relationship is between referral agencies and RCFEs, consumers often do not fully comprehend that the “free” referral service is being compensated by the facilities to which they are being referred. This bill provides consumer disclosures intended to facilitate a better understanding of referral agencies’ business practices. Additionally, because there is no formal agreement or contract between consumers and the referral agencies, consumers do not necessarily have the option to terminate their relationship with these agencies. This bill requires referral agencies to stop contacting the consumer and stop making referrals within 10 days of the consumer making that request.
The veto message of AB 499 notes that a future version of the policy set forth in that bill needs to include stronger and more equitable consumer protections. It is unclear if this bill does this, as its language is very similar to AB 499, and as introduced was the version of AB 499 that went to the Governor last year. Stakeholders note two major consumer protections concern in the bill – first the “opt-out” rather than “opt-in” structure of the selling of private information and two the lack of a private right of action. Regarding the first concern, the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) does have opt-out language, but it is unclear if the language in this bill mirrors all the protections outlined in the CCPA. Regarding the second concern, stakeholders are unsure if the mechanism of enforcement in the bill – by a district attorney or city attorney – would actually provide a viable option of enforcement as it is unclear if those offices would have the capacity or desire to pursue such enforcement cases. Further, there is only a civil penalty in the amount of between $250 and $1000 per violation.
The sponsors indicate that the most recent amendments are in response to the opposition’s concerns and that much of the language is taken from the CCPA. For example, on page 5, lines 2-3 it reads “includes all of the following disclosures, in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers.” The “reasonably accessible to consumers” language is indeed in the CCPA, but in the CCPA that language is followed by very detailed language about, for example, specific links on the business’ homepage where the information is contained. This bill appears to be more vague regarding the manner in which this information should be made “reasonably accessible to consumers.” Further, this bill is focused on referrals for care, which are often made under times of extreme stress, and it may be that in light of that the consumer protections should be as strong as possible. Opposition notes that none of the recent amends alleviate their concerns.
SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Arguments in Support:
A Place for Mom and Caring.Com writes, “SB 875 adds new consumer protection to California law to create a transparent process for families utilizing referral agencies to find an assisted living facility for a family member or loved one… SB 875 would require compensated referral sources to give consumers important disclosures before any referrals could be made, create regulatory safeguards, and ban certain practices.”
Arguments in Opposition:
Justice in Aging writes, “In the guise of providing protection to at-risk persons and their families in crisis, SB 875 would in fact both weaken current regulations under California Health & Safety Code Section 1569.47 holding referral agencies accountable for improper referrals, and impose a high burden on consumers to enforce their rights.”
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Committee: |
|
Assembly Floor: |
|
Assembly Appropriations Committee: |
|
Assembly Committee: |
|
POSITIONS
Support:
6beds, INC.
A Place for Mom
Act8, LLC
California Assisted Living Association
Leadingage California
Oppose:
California Commission on Aging
California Long-term Care Ombudsman Association
California Office of the State Long-term Care Ombudsman
Canhr
Justice in Aging
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Human Services
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):