SB 92: Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-01
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-07-01: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 45, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA), authorizes an aggrieved employee, as defined, to bring a civil action, on behalf of that employee and other current or former employees, to enforce a violation of any provision of the Labor Code that provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees pursuant to certain notice and cure provisions, as prescribed.
This bill would, among other things, authorize, on or after October 1, 2024, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, within 33 days of receipt of the notice submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations and, upon completing the cure, provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, as prescribed.
By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the agency to verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification, as specified.
This bill would also authorize an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under PAGA, file a request and participate in, as prescribed, an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings before, or simultaneous with, that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
This bill would apply its provisions to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024, except as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This bill would become operative only if AB 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law, the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA), authorizes an aggrieved employee, as defined, to bring a civil action, on behalf of that employee and other current or former employees, to enforce a violation of any provision of the Labor Code that provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees pursuant to certain notice and cure provisions, as prescribed.
This bill would, among other things, authorize, on or after October 1, 2024, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, within 33 days of receipt of the notice submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations and, upon completing the cure, provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, as prescribed.
By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the agency to verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification, as specified.
This bill would also authorize an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under PAGA, file a request and participate in, as prescribed, an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings before, or simultaneous with, that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
This bill would apply its provisions to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024, except as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This bill would become operative only if AB 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law, the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA), authorizes an aggrieved employee, as defined, to bring a civil action, on behalf of that employee and other current or former employees, to enforce a violation of any provision of the Labor Code that provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees pursuant to certain notice and cure provisions, as prescribed.
This bill would, among other things, authorize, on or after October 1, 2024, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, within 33 days of receipt of the notice submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations and, upon completing the cure, provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, as prescribed.
By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the agency to verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification, as specified.
This bill would also authorize an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the required notice to, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under PAGA, file a request and participate in, as prescribed, an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings before, or simultaneous with, that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
This bill would apply its provisions to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024, except as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This bill would become operative only if AB 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law prohibits, until January 1, 2025, a trial court from retaliating against an official court reporter or official court reporter pro tempore for notifying a judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote criminal proceeding.This bill would extend this provision until January 1, 2026.Existing law generally allows, until January 1, 2025, upon a defendants waiver of the right to be physically present, criminal proceedings to be conducted through the use of remote technology, and prohibits a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor to appear remotely for a jury or court trial, except as specified.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2025, until January 1, 2026.Existing law authorizes, until January 1, 2025, a witness in a criminal proceeding to testify using remote technology, as provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.This bill would extend these provisions until January 1, 2026.Existing law requires a defendant to be personally present in a preliminary hearing unless otherwise specified. Existing law prohibits these provisions from limiting the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present. Existing law, until January 1, 2025, includes the defendants right to waive the right to appear through the use of remote technology from being limited by these provisions.This bill would extend the provision that would expire on January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2026.Existing law prohibits, until January 1, 2025, a trial court from retaliating against an official court reporter or official court reporter pro tempore for notifying a judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote criminal proceeding.
This bill would extend this provision until January 1, 2026.
Existing law generally allows, until January 1, 2025, upon a defendants waiver of the right to be physically present, criminal proceedings to be conducted through the use of remote technology, and prohibits a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor to appear remotely for a jury or court trial, except as specified.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2025, until January 1, 2026.
Existing law authorizes, until January 1, 2025, a witness in a criminal proceeding to testify using remote technology, as provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.
This bill would extend these provisions until January 1, 2026.
Existing law requires a defendant to be personally present in a preliminary hearing unless otherwise specified. Existing law prohibits these provisions from limiting the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present. Existing law, until January 1, 2025, includes the defendants right to waive the right to appear through the use of remote technology from being limited by these provisions.
This bill would extend the provision that would expire on January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2026.
Existing law specifies procedures to be followed in civil actions. Existing law requires the word action for these purposes to be construed, whenever it is necessary to do so, as including a special proceeding of a civil nature.This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to this provision.Existing law specifies procedures to be followed in civil actions. Existing law requires the word action for these purposes to be construed, whenever it is necessary to do so, as including a special proceeding of a civil nature.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to this provision.
(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraph (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying a defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, as well as the fact that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process need not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of this section was filed before June 19, 2024.
(h)This section shall be operative only until October 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 2699.3 is added to the Labor Code, to read:2699.3.(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraphs (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)Within 33 days of receipt of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice may submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The employer shall specify which of the alleged violations it proposes to cure.
(B)If the cure is facially sufficient or if a conference is necessary to determine if a sufficient cure is possible, then within 14 days after receipt of the employers proposal, the agency may set a conference with the parties, to be conducted no more than 30 days thereafter, to determine whether the proposed cure is sufficient, what additional information may be necessary to evaluate the sufficiency of the cure, and the deadline agreed upon by the parties for the employer to complete the cure. If the cure includes the payment of unpaid wages, the agency shall also determine at the conference whether to request the employer pay the proposed cure amount, including any wages and liquidated damages due and 7 percent interest, into escrow or shall provide such other form of security as the agency deems suitable. Any such conference may be electronic, telephonic, or in person. If the agency determines that the cure is not facially sufficient or does not act upon the employers cure proposal, the employee may proceed with a civil action under this part after 65 calendar days from sending the notice required by this subdivision, unless this time is extended by the agency, provided that such time shall not be extended to more than 120 calendar days after notice is sent. However, the employer shall be entitled to file a request for a stay and early evaluation conference as set forth in subdivision (f).
(C)On or before the agreed upon deadline to cure, but no more than 45 days after the conference, the employer shall complete the cure and provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, accompanied by a payroll audit and check register if the violation involves a payment obligation. This notification shall also include any information the parties deemed necessary to determine the sufficiency of the cure. The agency shall verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification. If the agency review procedure under this section extends beyond the 65-day period set forth in this section, the statute of limitation on the alleged violations shall remain tolled until that procedure has been completed.
(D)If the agency preliminarily determines that the alleged violation has been cured, it shall notify the aggrieved employee and, if requested by the aggrieved employee, shall set a hearing within 30 days of such determination. The agency shall issue an order no more than 20 days after the hearing providing a determination whether the cure is adequate and the reasons for its determination. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee may not proceed with a civil action. If the aggrieved employee disagrees with the cure determination, the aggrieved employee may appeal that determination to the superior court. Any amounts paid by the employer to the aggrieved employees exclusive of penalties under this section to cure the alleged violation shall be offset against any judgment later entered with respect to that violation, if the superior court concludes the agency abused its discretion in finding that the employers cure was adequate.
(E)No cure or proposal to cure pursuant to this paragraph may be deemed an admission of liability by the employer that submitted the proposed cure. Any cure proposal shall be deemed a confidential settlement proposal subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(F)Nothing in this paragraph prohibits an employer from independently remedying any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process.
(3)If the only alleged violation the employer seeks to cure is a violation of Section 226, the following procedure shall apply:
(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation of Section 226 has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer not covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, and the court shall consider that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process shall not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)This section shall become operative October 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 2699.5 of the Labor Code is amended to read:2699.5.(a)The provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 2699.3 apply to any alleged violation of the following provisions: subdivision (k) of Section 96, Sections 98.6, 201, 201.3, 201.5, 201.7, 202, 203, 203.1, 203.5, 204, 204a, 204b, 204.1, 204.2, 205, 205.5, 206, 206.5, 208, 209, and 212, subdivision (d) of Section 213, Sections 221, 222, 222.5, 223, 224, 230, 230.1, 230.2, 230.3, 230.4, 230.7, 230.8, and 231, subdivision (c) of Section 232, subdivision (c) of Section 232.5, Sections 233, 234, 351, 353, and 403, subdivision (b) of Section 404, Sections 432.2, 432.5, 432.7, 435, 450, 511, 551, 552, 601, 602, 603, 604, 750, 751.8, 800, 850, 851, 851.5, 852, 921, 922, 923, 970, 973, 976, 1021, 1021.5, 1025, 1026, 1101, 1102, 1102.5, and 1153, subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1174, Sections 1197.5, and 1198, subdivision (b) of Section 1198.3, Sections 1199, 1199.5, 1290, 1292, 1293, 1293.1, 1294, 1294.1, 1294.5, 1296, 1297, 1298, 1301, 1308, 1308.1, 1308.7, 1309, 1309.5, 1391, 1391.1, 1391.2, 1392, 1683, and 1695, subdivision (a) of Section 1695.5, Sections 1695.55, 1695.6, 1695.7, 1695.8, 1695.9, 1696, 1696.5, 1696.6, 1697.1, 1700.25, 1700.26, 1700.31, 1700.32, 1700.40, and 1700.47, Sections 1735, 1771, 1774, 1776, 1777.5, 1811, 1815, 2651, and 2673, subdivision (a) of Section 2673.1, Sections 2695.2, 2801, 2806, and 2810, subdivision (b) of Section 2929, and Sections 3073.6, 6310, 6311, and 6399.7.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 2699.3 was filed before June 19, 2024.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 2699.3 of the Labor Code, and Section 2 of this act, which adds Section 2699.3 to the Labor Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Preserving the confidentiality of statements presented during settlement negotiations, neutral evaluation of claims, or assessments of attempts to cure violations pursuant to this act is necessary to facilitate early resolution of claims and encourage employers to take prompt action to make aggrieved employees whole.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to further the purpose and intent of the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 to protect workers from labor violations and address a pending ballot measure, it is necessary for this statute to take effect immediately.
(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraph (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying a defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, as well as the fact that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process need not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of this section was filed before June 19, 2024.
(h)This section shall be operative only until October 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 2699.3 is added to the Labor Code, to read:2699.3.(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraphs (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)Within 33 days of receipt of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice may submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The employer shall specify which of the alleged violations it proposes to cure.
(B)If the cure is facially sufficient or if a conference is necessary to determine if a sufficient cure is possible, then within 14 days after receipt of the employers proposal, the agency may set a conference with the parties, to be conducted no more than 30 days thereafter, to determine whether the proposed cure is sufficient, what additional information may be necessary to evaluate the sufficiency of the cure, and the deadline agreed upon by the parties for the employer to complete the cure. If the cure includes the payment of unpaid wages, the agency shall also determine at the conference whether to request the employer pay the proposed cure amount, including any wages and liquidated damages due and 7 percent interest, into escrow or shall provide such other form of security as the agency deems suitable. Any such conference may be electronic, telephonic, or in person. If the agency determines that the cure is not facially sufficient or does not act upon the employers cure proposal, the employee may proceed with a civil action under this part after 65 calendar days from sending the notice required by this subdivision, unless this time is extended by the agency, provided that such time shall not be extended to more than 120 calendar days after notice is sent. However, the employer shall be entitled to file a request for a stay and early evaluation conference as set forth in subdivision (f).
(C)On or before the agreed upon deadline to cure, but no more than 45 days after the conference, the employer shall complete the cure and provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, accompanied by a payroll audit and check register if the violation involves a payment obligation. This notification shall also include any information the parties deemed necessary to determine the sufficiency of the cure. The agency shall verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification. If the agency review procedure under this section extends beyond the 65-day period set forth in this section, the statute of limitation on the alleged violations shall remain tolled until that procedure has been completed.
(D)If the agency preliminarily determines that the alleged violation has been cured, it shall notify the aggrieved employee and, if requested by the aggrieved employee, shall set a hearing within 30 days of such determination. The agency shall issue an order no more than 20 days after the hearing providing a determination whether the cure is adequate and the reasons for its determination. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee may not proceed with a civil action. If the aggrieved employee disagrees with the cure determination, the aggrieved employee may appeal that determination to the superior court. Any amounts paid by the employer to the aggrieved employees exclusive of penalties under this section to cure the alleged violation shall be offset against any judgment later entered with respect to that violation, if the superior court concludes the agency abused its discretion in finding that the employers cure was adequate.
(E)No cure or proposal to cure pursuant to this paragraph may be deemed an admission of liability by the employer that submitted the proposed cure. Any cure proposal shall be deemed a confidential settlement proposal subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(F)Nothing in this paragraph prohibits an employer from independently remedying any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process.
(3)If the only alleged violation the employer seeks to cure is a violation of Section 226, the following procedure shall apply:
(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation of Section 226 has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer not covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, and the court shall consider that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process shall not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)This section shall become operative October 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 2699.5 of the Labor Code is amended to read:2699.5.(a)The provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 2699.3 apply to any alleged violation of the following provisions: subdivision (k) of Section 96, Sections 98.6, 201, 201.3, 201.5, 201.7, 202, 203, 203.1, 203.5, 204, 204a, 204b, 204.1, 204.2, 205, 205.5, 206, 206.5, 208, 209, and 212, subdivision (d) of Section 213, Sections 221, 222, 222.5, 223, 224, 230, 230.1, 230.2, 230.3, 230.4, 230.7, 230.8, and 231, subdivision (c) of Section 232, subdivision (c) of Section 232.5, Sections 233, 234, 351, 353, and 403, subdivision (b) of Section 404, Sections 432.2, 432.5, 432.7, 435, 450, 511, 551, 552, 601, 602, 603, 604, 750, 751.8, 800, 850, 851, 851.5, 852, 921, 922, 923, 970, 973, 976, 1021, 1021.5, 1025, 1026, 1101, 1102, 1102.5, and 1153, subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1174, Sections 1197.5, and 1198, subdivision (b) of Section 1198.3, Sections 1199, 1199.5, 1290, 1292, 1293, 1293.1, 1294, 1294.1, 1294.5, 1296, 1297, 1298, 1301, 1308, 1308.1, 1308.7, 1309, 1309.5, 1391, 1391.1, 1391.2, 1392, 1683, and 1695, subdivision (a) of Section 1695.5, Sections 1695.55, 1695.6, 1695.7, 1695.8, 1695.9, 1696, 1696.5, 1696.6, 1697.1, 1700.25, 1700.26, 1700.31, 1700.32, 1700.40, and 1700.47, Sections 1735, 1771, 1774, 1776, 1777.5, 1811, 1815, 2651, and 2673, subdivision (a) of Section 2673.1, Sections 2695.2, 2801, 2806, and 2810, subdivision (b) of Section 2929, and Sections 3073.6, 6310, 6311, and 6399.7.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 2699.3 was filed before June 19, 2024.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 2699.3 of the Labor Code, and Section 2 of this act, which adds Section 2699.3 to the Labor Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Preserving the confidentiality of statements presented during settlement negotiations, neutral evaluation of claims, or assessments of attempts to cure violations pursuant to this act is necessary to facilitate early resolution of claims and encourage employers to take prompt action to make aggrieved employees whole.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to further the purpose and intent of the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 to protect workers from labor violations and address a pending ballot measure, it is necessary for this statute to take effect immediately.
(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (j) (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (j) (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraph (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)(i)Subject to the limitation in clause (ii), no employer may avail himself or herself of the notice and cure provisions of this subdivision more than three times in a 12-month period for the same violation or violations contained in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite.(ii)No employer may avail himself or herself of the notice and cure provisions of this subdivision with respect to alleged violations of paragraph (6) or (8) of subdivision (a) of Section 226 more than once in a 12-month period for the same violation or violations contained in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite.(3)(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(d)(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer who employed at least 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice, upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying a defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, as well as the fact that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process need not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of this section was filed before June 19, 2024.
(e)(h)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2021. be operative only until October 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 2699.3 is added to the Labor Code, to read:2699.3.(a)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(2)(A)The agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to paragraph (1), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (A) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a plaintiff may as a matter of right amend an existing complaint to add a cause of action arising under this part at any time within 60 days of the time periods specified in this part.
(b)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(2)(A)The division shall inspect or investigate the alleged violation pursuant to the procedures specified in Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300).
(i)If the division issues a citation, the employee may not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699. The division shall notify the aggrieved employee and employer in writing within 14 calendar days of certifying that the employer has corrected the violation.
(ii)If by the end of the period for inspection or investigation provided for in Section 6317, the division fails to issue a citation and the aggrieved employee disputes that decision, the employee may challenge that decision in the superior court. In such an action, the superior court shall follow precedents of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. If the court finds that the division should have issued a citation and orders the division to issue a citation, then the aggrieved employee may not commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(iii)A complaint in superior court alleging a violation of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) other than those listed in Section 2699.5 shall include therewith a copy of the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1).
(iv)The superior court shall not dismiss the action for nonmaterial differences in facts or theories between those contained in the notice of violation provided to the division and employer pursuant to paragraph (1) and the complaint filed with the court.
(B)If the division fails to inspect or investigate the alleged violation as provided by Section 6309, the provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply to the determination of the alleged violation.
(3)(A)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to alter the authority of the division to permit long-term abatement periods or to enter into memoranda of understanding or joint agreements with employers in the case of long-term abatement issues.
(B)Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to authorize an employee to file a notice or to commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 during the period that an employer has voluntarily entered into consultation with the division to ameliorate a condition in that particular worksite.
(C)An employer who has been provided notice pursuant to this section may not then enter into consultation with the division in order to avoid an action under this section.
(4)The superior court shall review and approve any proposed settlement of alleged violations of the provisions of Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) to ensure that the settlement provisions are at least as effective as the protections or remedies provided by state and federal law or regulation for the alleged violation. The provisions of the settlement relating to health and safety laws shall be submitted to the division at the same time that they are submitted to the court. This requirement shall be construed to authorize and permit the division to comment on those settlement provisions, and the court shall grant the divisions commentary the appropriate weight.
(c)A civil action by an aggrieved employee pursuant to subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699 alleging a violation of any provision other than those listed in Section 2699.5 or Division 5 (commencing with Section 6300) shall commence only after the following requirements have been met:
(1)(A)The aggrieved employee or representative shall give written notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions of this code alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation.
(B)A notice filed with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency pursuant to subparagraph (A) and any employer response to that notice shall be accompanied by a filing fee of seventy-five dollars ($75). The fees required by this subparagraph are subject to waiver in accordance with the requirements of Sections 68632 and 68633 of the Government Code.
(C)The fees paid pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall be paid into the Labor and Workforce Development Fund and used for the purposes specified in subdivision (n) of Section 2699.
(D)If the employer is not eligible for the processes in paragraphs (2) or (3) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the agency shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to paragraph (1). Upon receipt of that notice or if no notice is provided within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice given pursuant to subparagraph (A), the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(E)If the agency intends to investigate the alleged violation, it shall notify the employer and the aggrieved employee or representative by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received pursuant to subparagraph (A). Within 120 calendar days of that decision, the agency may investigate the alleged violation and issue any appropriate citation. If the agency determines that no citation will be issued, it shall notify the employer and aggrieved employee of that decision within five business days thereof by certified mail. Upon receipt of that notice or if no citation is issued by the agency within the time limits prescribed by subparagraph (D) and this subparagraph or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(2)(A)Within 33 days of receipt of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative, an employer that employed fewer than 100 employees in total during the period covered by the notice may submit to the agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The employer shall specify which of the alleged violations it proposes to cure.
(B)If the cure is facially sufficient or if a conference is necessary to determine if a sufficient cure is possible, then within 14 days after receipt of the employers proposal, the agency may set a conference with the parties, to be conducted no more than 30 days thereafter, to determine whether the proposed cure is sufficient, what additional information may be necessary to evaluate the sufficiency of the cure, and the deadline agreed upon by the parties for the employer to complete the cure. If the cure includes the payment of unpaid wages, the agency shall also determine at the conference whether to request the employer pay the proposed cure amount, including any wages and liquidated damages due and 7 percent interest, into escrow or shall provide such other form of security as the agency deems suitable. Any such conference may be electronic, telephonic, or in person. If the agency determines that the cure is not facially sufficient or does not act upon the employers cure proposal, the employee may proceed with a civil action under this part after 65 calendar days from sending the notice required by this subdivision, unless this time is extended by the agency, provided that such time shall not be extended to more than 120 calendar days after notice is sent. However, the employer shall be entitled to file a request for a stay and early evaluation conference as set forth in subdivision (f).
(C)On or before the agreed upon deadline to cure, but no more than 45 days after the conference, the employer shall complete the cure and provide a sworn notification to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, accompanied by a payroll audit and check register if the violation involves a payment obligation. This notification shall also include any information the parties deemed necessary to determine the sufficiency of the cure. The agency shall verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employers notification. If the agency review procedure under this section extends beyond the 65-day period set forth in this section, the statute of limitation on the alleged violations shall remain tolled until that procedure has been completed.
(D)If the agency preliminarily determines that the alleged violation has been cured, it shall notify the aggrieved employee and, if requested by the aggrieved employee, shall set a hearing within 30 days of such determination. The agency shall issue an order no more than 20 days after the hearing providing a determination whether the cure is adequate and the reasons for its determination. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrieved employee may not proceed with a civil action. If the aggrieved employee disagrees with the cure determination, the aggrieved employee may appeal that determination to the superior court. Any amounts paid by the employer to the aggrieved employees exclusive of penalties under this section to cure the alleged violation shall be offset against any judgment later entered with respect to that violation, if the superior court concludes the agency abused its discretion in finding that the employers cure was adequate.
(E)No cure or proposal to cure pursuant to this paragraph may be deemed an admission of liability by the employer that submitted the proposed cure. Any cure proposal shall be deemed a confidential settlement proposal subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(F)Nothing in this paragraph prohibits an employer from independently remedying any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process.
(3)If the only alleged violation the employer seeks to cure is a violation of Section 226, the following procedure shall apply:
(A)The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative. The employer shall give written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken, and no civil action pursuant to Section 2699 may commence. If the alleged violation is not cured within the 33-day period, the employee may commence a civil action pursuant to Section 2699.
(B)If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation of Section 226 has been cured, the aggrieved employee or representative shall provide written notice by online filing with the agency and by certified mail to the employer, including specified grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency. Within 17 calendar days of the receipt of that notice, the agency shall review the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer. The agency may grant the employer three additional business days to cure the alleged violation. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action pursuant to Section 2699. If the agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, but the employee still disagrees, the employee may appeal that determination to the superior court.
(d)No employer shall avail itself of the notice and cure provisions of this section more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice pursuant to this part alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
(e)The periods specified in this section are not counted as part of the time limited for the commencement of the civil action to recover penalties under this part.
(f)(1)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, an employer not covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting a claim under subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 2699, may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendants responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
(B)The purpose of the evaluation conference shall include, but not be limited to, evaluation of all of the following, as applicable:
(i)Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations.
(ii)The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiffs claims and the defendants defenses.
(iii)Whether plaintiffs claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part.
(iv)Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
(2)A request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
(3)Upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court shall stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying defendants request in whole or in part:
(A)Schedules a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order.
(B)Directs a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employers proposed plan to cure those violations.
(C)Directs a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations.
(D)Directs the parties to appear at the time set for the conference.
(E)Directs the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendants proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes, to the extent reasonably known, for use solely for the purpose of the early evaluation conference, all of the following:
(i)The factual basis for each of the alleged violations.
(ii)The amount of penalties claimed for each violation if any, and the basis for that calculation.
(iii)The amount of attorneys fees and costs incurred to date, if any, that are being claimed.
(iv)Any demand for settlement of the case in its entirety.
(v)The basis for accepting or not accepting the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations.
(4)If the neutral evaluator accepts the employers proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant shall present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished. If the defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
(5)If the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties shall jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
(6)If no other alleged violations remain in dispute, the parties and the court shall treat the parties submission as a proposed settlement pursuant to the terms and procedures set forth in subdivision (l) of Section 2699.
(7)If other alleged violations remain in dispute, the court shall have discretion to defer consideration of the parties agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
(8)In calculating any penalties owed under this part for any violations that the employer promptly cured pursuant to this section, the court shall determine the applicability of subdivision (j), paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), paragraph (1) of subdivision (g), and paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 2699, and the court shall consider that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
(9)If the neutral evaluator or plaintiff does not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations. The court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
(10)All statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference shall be subject to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code.
(11)The early evaluation process shall not extend beyond 30 days unless parties mutually agree to extend time.
(12)Early evaluation conferences shall be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with issues arising under the code whom the court shall designate.
(13)Nothing in this subdivision affects or modifies the inadmissibility of evidence regarding offers of compromise pursuant to Section 1152 of the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, inadmissibility to prove injury or damage.
(14)Nothing in this subdivision prohibits an employer from independently curing any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process. Nor does anything in this section prohibit an employer covered by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) from requesting an early evaluation conference under such other terms and conditions as the court makes available to other litigants.
(15)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 2699.
(16)Nothing in this subdivision limits the courts obligation to approve settlements under this part.
(g)This section shall become operative October 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 2699.5 of the Labor Code is amended to read:2699.5.(a)The provisions of subdivision (a) of Section 2699.3 apply to any alleged violation of the following provisions: subdivision (k) of Section 96, Sections 98.6, 201, 201.3, 201.5, 201.7, 202, 203, 203.1, 203.5, 204, 204a, 204b, 204.1, 204.2, 205, 205.5, 206, 206.5, 208, 209, and 212, subdivision (d) of Section 213, Sections 221, 222, 222.5, 223, and 224, paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, (7), and (9) of subdivision (a) of Section 226, Sections 226.7, 227, 227.3, 230, 230.1, 230.2, 230.3, 230.4, 230.7, 230.8, and 231, subdivision (c) of Section 232, subdivision (c) of Section 232.5, Sections 233, 234, 351, 353, and 403, subdivision (b) of Section 404, Sections 432.2, 432.5, 432.7, 435, 450, 510, 511, 512, 513, 551, 552, 601, 602, 603, 604, 750, 751.8, 800, 850, 851, 851.5, 852, 921, 922, 923, 970, 973, 976, 1021, 1021.5, 1025, 1026, 1101, 1102, 1102.5, and 1153, subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1174, Sections 1194, 1197, 1197.1, 1197.5, and 1198, subdivision (b) of Section 1198.3, Sections 1199, 1199.5, 1290, 1292, 1293, 1293.1, 1294, 1294.1, 1294.5, 1296, 1297, 1298, 1301, 1308, 1308.1, 1308.7, 1309, 1309.5, 1391, 1391.1, 1391.2, 1392, 1683, and 1695, subdivision (a) of Section 1695.5, Sections 1695.55, 1695.6, 1695.7, 1695.8, 1695.9, 1696, 1696.5, 1696.6, 1697.1, 1700.25, 1700.26, 1700.31, 1700.32, 1700.40, and 1700.47, Sections 1735, 1771, 1774, 1776, 1777.5, 1811, 1815, 2651, and 2673, subdivision (a) of Section 2673.1, Sections 2695.2, 2800, 2801, 2802, 2806, and 2810, subdivision (b) of Section 2929, and Sections 3073.6, 6310, 6311, and 6399.7.
(b)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
(2)The amendments made to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall not apply to a civil action with respect to which the notice required by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 2699.3 was filed before June 19, 2024.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 2699.3 of the Labor Code, and Section 2 of this act, which adds Section 2699.3 to the Labor Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
Preserving the confidentiality of statements presented during settlement negotiations, neutral evaluation of claims, or assessments of attempts to cure violations pursuant to this act is necessary to facilitate early resolution of claims and encourage employers to take prompt action to make aggrieved employees whole.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 2288 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to further the purpose and intent of the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 to protect workers from labor violations and address a pending ballot measure, it is necessary for this statute to take effect immediately.
SECTION 1.Section 71651.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:71651.1.(a)Consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote proceeding pursuant to subdivisions (f) and (g) of Section 977 of the Penal Code.(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 2.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval by defendants counsel.(2)The waiver of a defendants right to be physically or remotely present may be in writing and filed with the court or, with the courts consent, may be entered personally by the defendant or by the defendants counsel of record.(A)A defendants personal waiver of the right to be physically or remotely present shall be on the record and state that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.(B)A waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence may be entered by counsel, after counsel has stated on the record that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue, has waived that right, and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.(3)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically or remotely present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof, including upon request of a victim, to the extent required by Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.(4)A written waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence shall be substantially in the following form:Waiver of Defendants Physical or Remote PresenceThe undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives the right to be physically or remotely present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were physically or remotely present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their physical or remote presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their physical or remote appearance at that time and place.(c)(1)(A)Upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except as provided in subparagraphs (D) and (E). The defendant may withdraw the waiver at any time.(B)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding or portion thereof, including as provided in subdivision (f).(C)If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the proceeding, unless, upon request of defense counsel, the court allows the appearance without private communication. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.(D)A defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial, except as provided in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2).(E)A defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for postconviction relief proceedings and as otherwise provided by law.(F)A witness may appear at any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trial, remotely pursuant to section 977.3.(2)(A)A felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion.(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(e)A court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology without being physically present in the courtroom and in accordance with subdivision (f).(f)Except as otherwise provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:(1)The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.(2)Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.(3)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporters ability to accurately prepare a transcript of the proceeding.(4)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.(5)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreters ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly with the defendant and the court during the proceeding.(g)(1)Before the court may proceed with a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, official reporter pro tempore, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding.(2)When the court conducts a remote proceeding that will be reported by an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore, the reporter shall be physically present in a courtroom.(h)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.(i)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 4 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be personally present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be personally present at all other proceedings unless they shall, with leave of court, execute in open court, a written waiver of their right to be personally present, as provided by paragraph (2). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)The accused may execute a written waiver of their right to be personally present, approved by their counsel, and the waiver shall be filed with the court. However, the court may specifically direct the defendant to be personally present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof. The waiver shall be substantially in the following form:Waiver of Defendants Personal PresenceThe undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby waives the right to be present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were personally present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their appearance at that time and place.(c)(1)The court may permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of defendants held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges, except for those defendants who were indicted by a grand jury, to be conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall be present with the defendant at the initial court appearance and arraignment, and may enter a plea during the arraignment. However, if the defendant is represented by counsel at an arraignment on an information in a felony case, and if the defendant does not plead guilty or nolo contendere to any charge, the attorney shall be present with the defendant or if the attorney is not present with the defendant, the attorney shall be present in court during the hearing. The defendant shall have the right to make their plea while physically present in the courtroom if they request to do so. If the defendant decides not to exercise the right to be physically present in the courtroom they shall execute a written waiver of that right. A judge may order a defendants personal appearance in court for the initial court appearance and arraignment. In a misdemeanor case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom. In a felony case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom if the parties stipulate thereto.(2)(A)A defendant who does not wish to be personally present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. The court may, when a defendant has waived the right to be personally present, require a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges to be present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken, including, but not limited to, confirmation of the preliminary hearing, status conferences, trial readiness conferences, discovery motions, receipt of records, the setting of the trial date, a motion to vacate the trial date, and motions in limine, by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be personally present with the defendant for noncritical portions of the trial, if the audiovideo conferencing system or other technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the noncritical portion of trial. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2026.SEC. 4.Section 977.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:977.3.(a)A witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have a witness testify in person on the record.(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court may allow a witness to testify through the use of remote technology as otherwise provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.(c)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.(d)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 5.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 6 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through the use of remote technology in accordance with Section 977.(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 6.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 7 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present in accordance with Section 977.(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.(f)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2026.(a)Consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote proceeding pursuant to subdivisions (f) and (g) of Section 977 of the Penal Code.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.
(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:
(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.
(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval by defendants counsel.
(2)The waiver of a defendants right to be physically or remotely present may be in writing and filed with the court or, with the courts consent, may be entered personally by the defendant or by the defendants counsel of record.
(A)A defendants personal waiver of the right to be physically or remotely present shall be on the record and state that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.
(B)A waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence may be entered by counsel, after counsel has stated on the record that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue, has waived that right, and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.
(3)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically or remotely present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof, including upon request of a victim, to the extent required by Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(4)A written waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence shall be substantially in the following form:
Waiver of Defendants Physical or Remote Presence
The undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives the right to be physically or remotely present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may
permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were physically or remotely present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their physical or remote presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their physical or remote appearance at that time and place.
(c)(1)(A)Upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except as provided in subparagraphs (D) and (E). The defendant may withdraw the waiver at any time.
(B)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding or portion thereof, including as provided in subdivision (f).
(C)If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the proceeding, unless, upon request of defense counsel, the court allows the appearance without private communication. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.
(D)A defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial, except as provided in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2).
(E)A defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for postconviction relief proceedings and as otherwise provided by law.
(F)A witness may appear at any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trial, remotely pursuant to section 977.3.
(2)(A)A felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion.
(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(e)A court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology without being physically present in the courtroom and in accordance with subdivision (f).
(f)Except as otherwise provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
(1)The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
(2)Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
(3)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporters ability to accurately prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
(4)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
(5)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreters ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly with the defendant and the court during the proceeding.
(g)(1)Before the court may proceed with a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, official reporter pro tempore, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding.
(2)When the court conducts a remote proceeding that will be reported by an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore, the reporter shall be physically present in a courtroom.
(h)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.
(i)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 4 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.
(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:
(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.
(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be personally present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be personally present at all other proceedings unless they shall, with leave of court, execute in open court, a written waiver of their right to be personally present, as provided by paragraph (2). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)The accused may execute a written waiver of their right to be personally present, approved by their counsel, and the waiver shall be filed with the court. However, the court may specifically direct the defendant to be personally present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof. The waiver shall be substantially in the following form:
Waiver of Defendants Personal Presence
The undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby waives the right to be present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were personally present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their appearance at that time and
place.
(c)(1)The court may permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of defendants held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges, except for those defendants who were indicted by a grand jury, to be conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall be present with the defendant at the initial court appearance and arraignment, and may enter a plea during the arraignment. However, if the defendant is represented by counsel at an arraignment on an information in a felony case, and if the defendant does not plead guilty or nolo contendere to any charge, the attorney shall be present with the defendant or if the attorney is not present with the defendant, the attorney shall be present in court during the hearing. The defendant shall have the right to make their plea while physically present in the courtroom if they request to do so. If the defendant decides not to exercise the right to be physically present in the courtroom they shall execute a written waiver of that right. A judge may order a defendants personal appearance in court for the initial court appearance and arraignment. In a misdemeanor case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom. In a felony case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom if the parties stipulate thereto.
(2)(A)A defendant who does not wish to be personally present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. The court may, when a defendant has waived the right to be personally present, require a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges to be present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken, including, but not limited to, confirmation of the preliminary hearing, status conferences, trial readiness conferences, discovery motions, receipt of records, the setting of the trial date, a motion to vacate the trial date, and motions in limine, by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be personally present with the defendant for noncritical portions of the trial, if the audiovideo conferencing system or other technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the noncritical portion of trial. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.
(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025. 2026.
SEC. 4.Section 977.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:977.3.(a)A witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have a witness testify in person on the record.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court may allow a witness to testify through the use of remote technology as otherwise provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.
(c)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.
(d)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 6 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.
(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:
(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.
(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.
(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.
(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through the use of remote technology in accordance with Section 977.
(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2025, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 7 of Chapter 190 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.
(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:
(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.
(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.
(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.
(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present in accordance with Section 977.
(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.
(f)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025. 2026.
SECTION 1.Section 363 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:363.The word action as used in this title shall be construed, whenever it is necessary so to do, as including a special proceeding of a civil nature.The word action as used in this Title is to title shall be construed, whenever it is necessary so to do, as including a special proceeding of a civil nature.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 45, Statutes of 2024. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Urgency clause adopted. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 4824.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 6082.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 21, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 4, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 4). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jan 29, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 29, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 35. Noes 1. Page 3047.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 17, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 16, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jan 10, 2024 | Set for hearing January 16. |
| Jan 9, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 2958.) (January 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 4, 2024 | Set for hearing January 9. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 25, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 19, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 18. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 27, 2024 | Unfinished Business SB92 Umberg et al. Urgency Clause Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2024 | SB 92 Umberg Third Reading Urgency By Kalra | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 4, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jan 29, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB92 Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 9, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Acclamation Insurance Management Services | ** Support | |
| African American Farmers of California | ** Support | |
| Agricultural Council Of California | ** Support | |
| Airlines for America | ** Support | |
| Allied Managed Care | ** Support | |
| American Federation of State, County & Municipal Employees of California | ** Support | |
| American Petroleum and Convenience Store Association | ** Support | |
| Associated Equipment Distributers | ** Support | |
| Associated General Contractors | ** Support | |
| Association | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Council | ** Support | |
| California Agricultural Aircraft Association | ** Support | |
| California Alliance For Retired Americans | ** Support | |
| California Alliance of Family Owned Businesses | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Licensed Security Agencies, Guards & Associates | ** Support | |
| California Association of Sheet Metal & Air Conditioning Contractors National | ** Support | |
| California Association of Winegrowers | ** Support | |
| California Beer And Beverage Distributers | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Citrus Mutual | ** Support | |
| California Conference Board Of The Amalgamated Transit Union | ** Support | |
| California Conference Of Machinists | ** Support | |
| California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association | ** Support | |
| California Credit Union League | ** Support | |
| California Employment Lawyers | ** Support | |
| California Farm Bureau | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Support | |
| California Fresh Fruit Association | ** Support | |
| California Grocers Association | ** Support | |
| California Hispanic Chambers Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Iatse Council | ** Support | |
| California Judges Association | ** Support | |
| California Labor Federation, Afl-Cio | ** Support | |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Support | |
| California Mortgage Bankers Association | ** Support | |
| California New Car Dealers Association | ** Support | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Support | |
| California Professional Firefighters | ** Support | |
| California Restaurant Association | ** Support | |
| California Retailers Association | ** Support | |
| California Rice Commission | ** Support | |
| California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation | ** Support | |
| California State University Employees Union, SEIU, Local 2579 | ** Support | |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Support | |
| California Travel Association | ** Support | |
| California Truckers Association | ** Support | |
| California Walnut Commission | ** Support | |
| CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Click here to enter text. | ** Against | |
| Coalition of Small and Disabled Veteran Businesses | ** Support | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Corona Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Engineers & Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20 | ** Support | |
| Flasher Barricade Association | ** Support | |
| Folsom Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Fresno Chamber of Commerce of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Grower-Shipper Association of Central California | ** Support | |
| Housing Contractors Of California | ** Support | |
| Industry Business Council | ** Support | |
| Judicial Council of California | ** Support | |
| LeadingAge California | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Court Reporters Association | ** Against | |
| National Association of Theater Owners of California | ** Support | |
| Nisei Farmers League | ** Support | |
| North San Diego Business Chamber | ** Support | |
| Orange County Employees Association | ** Against | |
| Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Diego Regional Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Jose Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Marcos Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| SEIU California State Council | ** Support | |
| Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| SMART - Transportation Division | ** Support | |
| Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| True Blue | ** Support | |
| united ag | ** Support | |
| United Auto Workers | ** Support | |
| United Food & Commercial Workers, Western States Council | ** Support | |
| Unite Here! | ** Support | |
| Utility Workers Union of America | ** Support | |
| Vista Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Western Agricultural Processors Association | ** Support | |
| Western Carwash Association | ** Support | |
| Western Growers Association | ** Support | |
| West Ventura County Business Alliance | ** Support | |
| Wine Institute | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 92 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 92
Author: Umberg (D), et al.
Amended: 6/21/24
Vote: 27 - Urgency
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Not available
SUBJECT: Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill codifies negotiated reforms to the California Labor Code’s Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA) to further the purpose and intent of PAGA to protect workers from labor code violations. Other negotiated reforms to PAGA are in AB 2288 (Kalra, 2024). This bill becomes operative only if AB 2288 is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025. This bill contains an urgency clause.
Assembly Amendments
create a formal right to cure process for small and mid-sized companies. If these companies cure a labor code violation to the satisfaction of the Labor and Workforce Development Agency then, generally, a PAGA suit cannot be commenced. This bill affords all businesses, including those with more than 100 employees, the ability to seek an early evaluation conference shortly after the commencement of a PAGA suit to attempt to develop a plan for redressing Labor Code violations and settling matters without protracted litigation.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004, which provides, among other things that notwithstanding any other provision of law, any provision of the Labor Code that provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by the Agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees, for a violation of the Labor Code, may, as an alternative, be recovered through a civil action brought by an aggrieved employee on behalf of the employee and other current or former employees pursuant to the procedures specified in Labor Code § 2699.3. (Labor Code §§ 2698-2699.8.)
This bill codifies negotiated reforms to the California Labor Code’s Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA) to further the purpose and intent of PAGA to protect workers from labor code violations. Other negotiated reforms to PAGA are in AB 2288 (Kalra, 2024). SB 92 will become operative only if AB 2288 is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2025. SB 92 contains an urgency clause.
Comments
According to the author:
In 2004, the California Legislature passed the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) to bolster the State’s labor enforcement capabilities. Under existing law, PAGA enables aggrieved employees to enforce the California Labor Code by pursuing lawsuits against employers to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves and other employees for violations of state law. PAGA cases are most often filed to address major labor code violations and enforce fundamental labor rights such as overtime, minimum wage, and sick leave.
Since its enactment, PAGA has served as a critical enforcement tool, reflecting the reality that the State’s labor enforcement agencies often lack the resources to investigate and take action against every violation. In addition to limited public enforcement resources, the increased use of arbitration clauses has prevented aggrieved workers from filing individual or class action lawsuits against their employer, instead requiring them to go through arbitration, which some believe historically favors employers.
However, two decades since its enactment, serious flaws in the PAGA have come to light due to some bad actors. Under the current system, the aggrieved employee often receives little compensation. Furthermore, state data shows that it takes 310 more days to resolve a PAGA case compared to a state investigated case. Additionally, family-run small businesses, non-profits, local governments, school districts, labor unions and thousands of other employers have become major targets for lawsuits, often for minor technical violations.
Some of PAGA’s structure has unintentionally created these abuses. Its $100/$200 penalty structure applies no matter the severity or duration of the violation and there are also no procedural guardrails that normally exist in civil litigation. Lastly, almost no violations may be cured – even if an employer quickly remedies the alleged violation, the same penalties apply.
In order to address these concerns, SB 92, along with its companion bill, AB 2288, will enact meaningful reforms to PAGA [ . . . ].
SB 796 established the "Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004.” It was crafted to be an alternative "private attorney general" system for labor law enforcement that allowed employees to pursue civil penalties for labor law violations. PAGA established a civil penalty where one was not specifically provided under the Labor Code of $100 for each aggrieved employee per pay period for an initial violation, and $200 for each aggrieved employee per pay period for subsequent violations. The penalty was $500 per violation for a violator who is not an employer. PAGA specified that where the Agency or any of its subdivisions has discretion to assess civil penalties, a court could exercise the same discretion with respect to the civil penalties established by PAGA. The civil penalties did not apply if the alleged violation was a failure to act by the Agency or any of its subdivisions. PAGA authorized aggrieved employees to sue to recover civil penalties under the Labor Code in an action brought on behalf of themselves and other current or former employees against whom one or more of the alleged violations was committed. However, no private action could be maintained where the Agency or any of its subdivisions initiated proceedings against the alleged violator on the same facts and theories and under the same section or sections of the Labor Code. PAGA defined an "aggrieved employee" as any person who was employed by the alleged violator and against whom one or more of the alleged violations was committed. PAGA specified that an employee would receive 25% of civil penalties recovered against a person that employs one or more employees. Civil penalties recovered against persons that did not employ one or more employees were to entirely go to the State. PAGA provided for the award of reasonable attorney's fees and costs to an aggrieved employee who prevails in such an action. PAGA also was not intended to affect the exclusive remedy provided by workers' compensation provisions of existing law.
As explained in the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis for SB 92:
[ . . . ] As noted this measure is one aspect of the broader PAGA compromise. At its core this bill addresses the business community’s objections that PAGA, as it is currently constituted, denies businesses the right to cure violations and results in protracted and costly litigation. Seeking to address these concerns this bill adopts two new procedural requirements that must be satisfied when bringing PAGA claims.
The first procedural change to PAGA proposed by this bill adopts a cure process for small and medium-sized businesses with fewer than 100 employees. This proposal authorizes a qualifying employer to submit to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, within 33 days of receiving a notice of a violation in accordance with existing law, a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The bill then outlines the timelines and procedural guidelines the Labor and Workforce Development Agency must follow when evaluating the sufficiency of the proposed cure. Generally, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines a proposed cure is sufficient, and documents that the cure has been properly implemented, then a PAGA-based civil action cannot be brought. Notably, if the Agency determines a cure is insufficient or was not properly completed, then a civil action may be filed. Additionally, should an aggrieved employee disagree with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency’s determination related to the cure, the employee may file an action in superior court challenging the Agency’s determination. Similar, but slightly modified procedures apply to the cure provisions regarding specified paystub violation claims. These provisions take effect October 1, 2024.
The second aspect of the bill applies to large employers with more than 100 employees, as well as small and mid-sized employers who wish to avail themselves of the procedure. This procedure enables an employer to seek an “early evaluation conference” at the beginning stages of PAGA litigation. The evaluation would be conducted by a judge or other neutral and would largely examine the following four aspects of a PAGA claim:
- Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations;
- The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiff’s claims and the defendant’s defenses;
- Whether plaintiff’s claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part; and
- Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
Generally, the court is required to stay the proceedings during the pendency of the early evaluation conference. The bill outlines the timelines for the various steps of the evaluation conference and outlines what evidence and other filings each party must present to the neutral at the conference. If as a result of the early evaluation conference, the parties and the neutral agree to a plan to remedy violations and the neutral and the employee are satisfied those remedies are being carried out properly, the parties are to jointly submit a statement to the judge that is to be treated as a proposed settlement. If parties cannot reach agreement, or other issues remain at dispute following the early evaluation conference, the outstanding issues may proceed pursuant to the existing law. Notably, if issues are remedied during the early evaluation conference, then a defendant may seek to avail themselves of modified penalty provisions that may expose them to fewer penalties. It should be noted that these penalties are being modified as a part of this measure’s companion bill, AB 2288.
Finally, this bill makes several technical changes to carry out the above-mentioned provisions. First, the bill provides that information discussed in cure discussions or the early evaluation conference may not necessarily be used to prove liability should a matter ultimately be forced to reach a final judgement in court. Second, the bill provides that the confidential communications shared with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency are not subject to public disclosure pursuant to the California Public Records Act and other public record statutes. This measure also modifies which provisions of the Labor Code can result in PAGA claims. The bill also explicitly makes its enactment contingent on the enactment of AB 2288. Finally, this measure adopts an urgency clause and makes needed findings and declarations.
In support of this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and employer groups write:
Together, SB 92 and AB 2288 brings long overdue reform to the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA). SB 92 and AB 2288 will ensure that workers are having claims resolved more quickly and that businesses and non-profits that comply with the law are not penalized. Those reforms include:
- Expanding which Labor Code sections may be cured, so employees are made whole quickly.
- Protecting small employers by providing a more robust right to cure processes through the agency.
- Providing an opportunity for early resolution in court.
- Codifying that the court may limit evidence presented or the scope of the claim to ensure the claim can be effectively tried.
We are also supportive of efforts to give the California Department of Industrial Relations the ability to expedite hiring and fill vacancies to improve enforcement and implement the cure process for small employers.
The California Labor Federation and organizations that support workers write the following in support of the bill:
This package expands PAGA remedies by adding injunctive relief. It will also make it easier to hold bad actors accountable, with new ways to get to a higher penalty tier and additional judicial discretion to increase penalties where the outcome would otherwise be unjust.
This bill also preserves broader standing for non-profit legal services so that a worker need only have suffered one or more of the alleged violations.
The Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyers Association write the following in support of this bill:
These reforms are aimed at incentivizing compliance and ensuring workers are made whole for wage theft. With these reforms, PAGA will not only allow for penalties when employers break the law, but it will also increase a worker’s ability to get back wages with interest, stop illegal practices, and get a bigger share of civil penalties.
This bill, and AB 2288, requires that an employer seeking to cure must come into compliance, pay all wages back with interest for previous three years, plus liquidated damages and reasonable attorney’s fees.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/25/24)
California Chamber of Commerce
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Airlines for America
Allied Managed Care
American Federation of State, County, & Municipal Employees, California
American Petroleum and Convenience Store Association
Associated Equipment Distributers
Associated General Contractors
Bay Area Council
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Alliance of Family Owned Businesses
California Apartment Association
California Association of Licensed Security Agencies, Guards & Associates
California Association of Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors National
Association
California Association of Winegrowers
California Beer and Beverage Distributers
California Building Industry Association
California Citrus Mutual
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Credit Unions League
California Employment Lawyers
California Federation of Teachers
California IATSE Council
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State University Employees Union, SEIU, Local 2579
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Farm Bureau
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grocers Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Rice Commission
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California Travel Association
California Truckers Association
California Walnut Commission
CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO
Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce
Coalition of Small and Disabled Veteran Businesses
Consumer Attorneys of California
Corona Chamber of Commerce
Engineers & Scientists of California, IFPTE, Local 20
Flasher Barricade Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Grower-Shipper Association of Central California
Housing Contractors of California
Industry Business Council
LeadingAge California
National Association of Theater Owners of California
Nisei Farmers League
North San Diego Business Chamber
Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Jose Chamber of Commerce
San Marcos Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
SEIU, California State Council
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
SMART – Transportation Division
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
True Blue
United Ag
UNITE HERE!
United Auto Workers
United Food & Commercial Workers, Western State Council
Utility Workers Union of America
Vista Chamber of Commerce
West Ventura County Business Alliance
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/24)
None received
Click here to enter text.
Prepared by: Margie Estrada / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/27/24 10:49:38
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 92
Author:(Umberg)
As Amended Ver:June 21, 2024
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY
Expands the right to cure Labor Code violations for businesses with fewer than one hundred employees and offers businesses with more than one hundred employees the ability to seek an early resolution of Labor Code claims pending in court.
Major Provisions
- Provides that an employer who employed at least 100 employees upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting specified claims under the Labor Code may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim, conducted pursuant to the specified procedures, and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendant's responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
- Provides that the purpose of the evaluation conference is to evaluate issues related to the merits of a labor related claim.
- Requires, if the neutral evaluator accepts the employer's proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant to present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished.
- Provides that if a defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations in accordance with 3), and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to the neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
- Requires, if the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties to jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement which may be treated as a proposed settlement, as specified.
- Requires a court when calculating penalties owed for any violations promptly cured by an employer to consider the following:
- The degree to which a defendant took all reasonable steps to remedy a violation prior to receiving the notice of violation or a request for records, as specified;
- The degree to which a defendant took all reasonable steps to remedy a violation within 60 days after receiving the notice of violation, as specified;
- The court's ability to modify the specified levels of civil penalties if, based on the facts and circumstances of the particular case, awarding the statutory penalty otherwise would result in an award that is unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory, as specified; and
- The fact that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
- Proivdes that if the neutral evaluator or plaintiff do not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations, and the court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
- Provides, commencing October 1, 2024, that within 33 days of the receipt of a notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative, in accordance with the notice procedures of existing law, an employer with fewer than 100 employees may submit to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations, as specified.
- Provides that if a cure proposed pursuant to 8) is facially sufficient or if a conference is necessary to determine if a sufficient cure is possible, then within 14 days after receipt of the employer's proposal, the Labor and Workforce development Agency may set a conference with the parties, to be conducted no more than 30 days thereafter, to determine whether the proposed cure is sufficient, what additional information may be necessary to evaluate the sufficiency of the cure, and the deadline agreed upon by the parties for the employer to complete the cure.
- Provides that if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines that the cure is not facially sufficient or does not act upon the employer's cure proposal, the employee may proceed with a civil action, in accordance with existing law, after 65 calendar days from sending the notice required by law, unless that time is extended by the Agency, provided that such time cannot be extended to more than 120 calendar days after notice is sent, and subject to the employer's ability to request a stay and early evaluation conference pursuant to 1).
- Requires, that on or before the agreed upon deadline to cure, but no more than 45 days after the conference, the employer to complete the cure and provide a sworn notification, including all information the parties deemed necessary to determine the sufficiency of the cure, to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, accompanied by a payroll audit and check register if the violation involves a payment obligation.
- Requires the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employer's notification.
- Provides a modified procedure from that specified in 8) through 12) if violations sought to be cured by an employer are related to specified paystub violations the following provisions apply:
- Limits an employer to availing itself of the notice and cure provisions of this bill no more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same Labor Code provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice existing law alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
- Modifies which provisions of the Labor Code are subject to specific notice and civil action provisions.
- Provides that this bill only applies to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
- Adopts an urgency clause such that all provisons of this bill, except those subject to the October 1, 2024 enactment date specified in 16), are to take effect immediately.
- Makes the enactment of this measure contingent of the enactment of AB 2288 (Kalra) of the current legislative session.
COMMENTS
The California Labor Code's Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) took effect in 2004 to address the state's labor enforcement entities' lack of resources sufficient to enforce the state's Labor Code. PAGA authorizes individual workers to step into the role of the state's labor enforcement entity, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, and bring a lawsuit against their employer. Notably, a PAGA action is intended, not to make the affected worker or workers whole, but rather to recover civil penalties on behalf of the State.
Nonetheless, for the better part of PAGA's 20-year existence, the business community has vociferously objected to the law. The business community believes the law lacks procedural safeguards, denies businesses the right to cure violations of the Labor Code, and provides an unreasonable financial boon for attorneys. This bill is part of a package of reforms to PAGA that was agreed to by all stakeholders. Specifically, this measure adopts two pro-business reforms. First, the bill offers all employers, including those with 100 or more employees, a process to seek an early evaluation of claims subject to litigation. Secondly, this bill offers small and midsized employers an opportunity to cure specified Labor Code violations through a process with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency. Other measures in this package focus on the penalty amounts awarded in PAGA cases, including those involving legal aid organizations, and outline that curing a violation must be effectuated pursuant to the processes established by the reforms proposed in this package.
This bill is one aspect of a broader PAGA compromise. At its core this bill addresses the business community's objections that PAGA, as it is currently constituted, denies businesses the right to cure violations and results in protracted and costly litigation. Seeking to address these concerns this bill adopts two new procedural requirements that must be satisfied when bringing PAGA claims.
The first procedural change to PAGA proposed by this bill adopts a cure process for small and medium-sized businesses with fewer than 100 employees. This proposal authorizes a qualifying employer to submit to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, within 33 days of receiving a notice of a violation in accordance with existing law, a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The bill then outlines the timelines and procedural guidelines the Labor and Workforce Development Agency must follow when evaluating the sufficiency of the proposed cure. Generally, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines a proposed cure is sufficient, and documents that the cure has been properly implemented, then a PAGA-based civil action cannot be brought. Notably, if the Agency determines a cure is insufficient or was not properly completed, then a civil action may be filed. Additionally, should an aggrieved employee disagree with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency's determination related to the cure, the employee may file an action in superior court challenging the Agency's determination. Similar, but slightly modified procedures apply to the cure provisions regarding specified paystub violation claims. These provisions take effect October 1, 2024.
The second aspect of the bill applies to large employers with more than 100 employees, as well as small and mid-sized employers who wish to avail themselves of the procedure. This procedure enables an employer to seek an "early evaluation conference" at the beginning stages of PAGA litigation. The evaluation would be conducted by a judge or other neutral and would largely examine various aspects of the PAGA claim.
Generally, the court is required to stay the proceedings during the pendency of the early evaluation conference. The bill outlines the timelines for the various steps of the evaluation conference and outlines what evidence and other filings each party must present to the neutral at the conference. If as a result of the early evaluation conference, the parties and the neutral agree to a plan to remedy violations and the neutral and the employee are satisfied those remedies are being carried out properly, the parties are to jointly submit a statement to the judge that is to be treated as a proposed settlement. If parties cannot reach agreement, or other issues remain at dispute following the early evaluation conference, the outstanding issues may proceed pursuant to the existing law. Notably, if issues are remedied during the early evaluation conference, then a defendant may seek to avail themselves of modified penalty provisions that may expose them to fewer penalties. It should be noted that these penalties are being modified as a part of this measure's companion bill, AB 2288.
Finally, this bill makes several technical changes to carry out the above-mentioned provisions. First, the bill provides that information discussed in cure discussions or the early evaluation conference may not necessarily be used to prove liability should a matter ultimately be forced to reach a final judgement in court. Second, the bill provides that the confidential communications shared with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency are not subject to public disclosure pursuant to the California Public Records Act and other public record statutes. This measure also modifies which provisions of the Labor Code can result in PAGA claims. The bill also explicitly makes its enactment contingent on the enactment of AB 2288. Finally, this measure adopts an urgency clause and makes needed findings and declarations.
According to the Author
In 2004, the California Legislature passed the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) to bolster the State's labor enforcement capabilities. Under existing law, PAGA enables aggrieved employees to enforce the California Labor Code by pursuing lawsuits against employers to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves and other employees for violations of state law. Under the current system, plaintiff's lawyers receive 33% or more of the total recovery, leaving very little for workers. Furthermore, state data shows that it takes 310 more days to resolve a PAGA case compared to a state investigated case. Additionally, family-run small businesses, non-profits, local governments, school districts, labor unions and thousands of other employers have become major targets for predatory lawsuits, often for minor technical violations. Some of PAGA's structure has unintentionally created these abuses. Its $100/$200 penalty structure applies no matter the severity or duration of the violation and there are also no procedural guardrails that normally exists in civil litigation. Lastly, almost no violations may be cured – even if an employer quickly remedies the alleged violation, the same penalties apply.
In order to address these concerns, SB 92, along with its companion bill, AB 2288, will enact meaningful reforms to PAGA to ensure workers retain a strong tool to resolve labor claims and receive fair compensation while simultaneously curtailing abuses and unjust lawsuits that hurt employers.
Arguments in Support
The PAGA reform package, including the provisions of this bill are supported by a sweeping coalition of business advocates including the California Chamber of Commerce. Additionally, advocates for California workers including the California Labor Federation and associated labor organizations, the Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyer's Association also support the package. In support of this bill, and the package overall, the California Chamber of Commerce and its coalition of business advocates jointly write:
Together, SB 92 and AB 2288 brings long overdue reform to the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA). SB 92 and AB 2288 will ensure that workers are having claims resolved more quickly and that businesses and non-profits that comply with the law are not penalized. Those reforms include:
- Expanding which Labor Code sections may be cured, so employees are made whole quickly.
- Protecting small employers by providing a more robust right to cure processes through the agency.
- Providing an opportunity for early resolution in court.
- Codifying that the court may limit evidence presented or the scope of the claim to ensure the claim can be effectively tried.
We are also supportive of efforts to give the California Department of Industrial Relations the ability to expedite hiring and fill vacancies to improve enforcement and implement the cure process for small employers.
Additionally, a coalition of labor organizations including the California Labor Federation write:
This package expands PAGA remedies by adding injunctive relief. It will also make it easier to hold bad actors accountable, with new ways to get to a higher penalty tier and additional judicial discretion to increase penalties where the outcome would otherwise be unjust.
This bill also preserves broader standing for non-profit legal services so that a worker need only have suffered one or more of the alleged violations.
Finally, legal advocates including the Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyers Association jointly write:
These reforms are aimed at incentivizing compliance and ensuring workers are made whole for wage theft. With these reforms, PAGA will not only allow for penalties when employers break the law, but it will also increase a worker's ability to get back wages with interest, stop illegal practices, and get a bigger share of civil penalties.
This bill, and AB 2288, requires that an employer seeking to cure must come into compliance, pay all wages back with interest for previous three years, plus liquidated damages and reasonable attorney's fees.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
Unknown
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 35-1-4
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Min
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta, Durazo, Gonzalez, Smallwood-Cuevas
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 6-0-2
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Stephanie Nguyen, Holden, Ting, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Zbur
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Joe Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: June 21, 2024
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003592
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 92
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 21, 2024
SENATE VOTE: NOT RELEVANT
SUBJECT: Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004
KEY ISSUES:
- Should an employer with fewer than 100 employees be entitled to submit a confidential proposal to cuRe specified labor code violations to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, and upon cure of the violation, submit a statement to the agency attesting that the violations were cured?
- Should all employers, including those with 100 or more employees, be entitled to participate in an early evaluation conference and be granted a stay in the court proceedings, so that a neutral can evaluate the merits of the case?
SYNOPSIS
Originally taking effect in 2004, the California Labor Code’s Private Attorney General Act (SB 796 (Dunn) Chap. 906, Stats. 2003) was designed to relieve pressure on understaffed state-level labor law enforcement officials. To ensure that state labor laws were enforced, the Private Attorney General Act (now commonly referred to simply as PAGA) authorized individual employees to file labor claims on behalf of the state in the event state officials would not take action. Given that the original law was designed to supplement state enforcement, employees were not provided a standalone remedy, but rather 25 percent of the civil penalties imposed on their employer, with the remaining 75 percent of those penalties being directed to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency for enforcement and educational purposes. In the 20 years since PAGA took effect, it has become the bane of the business community who argue that the law unfairly prevents them from curing Labor Code violations (although violations of labor laws, arguably, should never occur in the first place), promotes protracted litigation, and puts the interests of attorneys over employees. In fact, the business community’s frustrations with PAGA grew so severe they placed a measure on the 2024 ballot to wholly gut the law.
This measure, and its companion bill AB 2288 (Kalra, 2024), represent a compromise between all of the stakeholders interested in PAGA, including the Chamber of Commerce, organized labor, and labor law litigators that will remove the above mentioned ballot measure from the November 2024 ballot. This measure includes two critical components of the compromise proposal. First, this bill creates a formal right to cure process for small and mid-sized companies. So long as these companies cure a labor code violation to the satisfaction of the Labor and Workforce Development Agency then, generally, a PAGA suit cannot be commenced. Secondly, this measure affords all businesses, including those with more than 100 employees, the ability to seek an early evaluation conference shortly after the commencement of a PAGA suit to attempt to develop a plan for redressing Labor Code violations and settling matters without protracted litigation.
This measure is supported by a broad coalition of business, labor, and attorney groups including the California Chamber of Commerce, the California Labor Federation and associated labor organizations, the Consumer Attorneys of California, and the California Employment Lawyers Association. The supporters, particularly those in the business community, highlight this measure’s ability to promote early resolution of PAGA disputes. This measure has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Expands the right to cure Labor Code violations for businesses with fewer than one hundred employees and offers businesses with more than one hundred employees the ability to seek an early resolution of Labor Code claims pending in court. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an employer who employed at least 100 employees upon being served with a summons and complaint asserting specified claims under the Labor Code may file a request for an early evaluation conference in the proceedings of the claim, conducted pursuant to the procedures specified in 2) through 15), and a request for a stay of court proceedings prior to or simultaneous with that defendant’s responsive pleading or other initial appearance in the action that includes the claim.
- Provides that the purpose of the evaluation conference is to evaluate issues that include, but are not exclusively limited to, the following:
- Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations;
- The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiff’s claims and the defendant’s defenses;
- Whether plaintiff’s claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part; and
- Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
- Requires a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant to include a statement regarding whether the defendant intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations, specify the alleged violations it will cure, if applicable, and identify the allegations it disputes.
- Requires, upon the filing of a request for an early evaluation conference by a defendant and, if requested, a stay of proceedings, a court to stay the proceedings and issue an order that does the following, absent good cause for denying a defendant’s request in whole or in part:
- Schedule a mandatory early evaluation conference for a date as soon as possible from the date of the order but in no event later than 70 days after issuance of the order;
- Direct a defendant that has filed a statement that it intends to cure any or all of the alleged violations to submit confidentially to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff, within 21 days after issuance of the order, the employer’s proposed plan to cure those violations;
- Direct a defendant that is disputing any alleged violations to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the plaintiff a confidential statement that includes, for use solely for the early evaluation conference, the basis and evidence for disputing those alleged violations;
- Direct the parties to appear at the time set for the conference; and
- Direct the plaintiff to submit to the neutral evaluator and serve on the defendant no more than 21 days after service of defendant’s proposed cure plan, a confidential statement that includes the factual basis for the alleged violations, the amount of penalties claims and the basis for those penalties, the amount of attorney’s fees incurred to date, any demand to settle the case in its entirety, and the basis for accepting or not accepting the employer’s proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, as specified.
- Requires, if the neutral evaluator accepts the employer’s proposed plan for curing any or all alleged violations, the defendant to present evidence within 10 calendar days or such longer period as agreed by the parties or set by the neutral evaluator, demonstrating that the cure has been accomplished.
- Provides that if a defendant indicated it would cure any alleged violations in accordance with 5), and fails to timely submit the required evidence showing correction of the violation or violations to the neutral evaluator and plaintiff, the early evaluation process and any stay may be terminated by the court.
- Requires, if the neutral evaluator and the parties agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the parties to jointly submit a statement to the court setting forth the terms of their agreement.
- Requires the court, if no additional violations remain in dispute, to treat the statement specified in 7) as a proposed settlement.
- Provides that if additional issues remain in dispute, at the courts discretion, the court may defer consideration of the parties’ agreement until after further litigation proceedings.
- Requires a court when calculating penalties owed for any violations promptly cured by an employer to consider the following:
- The degree to which a defendant took all reasonable steps to remedy a violation prior to receiving the notice of violation or a request for records, as specified;
- The degree to which a defendant took all reasonable steps to remedy a violation within 60 days after receiving the notice of violation, as specified;
- The court’s ability to modify the specified levels of civil penalties if, based on the facts and circumstances of the particular case, awarding the statutory penalty otherwise would result in an award that is unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory, as specified; and
- The fact that the violations were cured without the need for extended litigation.
- Proivdes that if the neutral evaluator or plaintiff do not agree that the employer has cured the alleged violations that it stated an intention to cure, the employer may file a motion to request the court to approve the cure and submit evidence showing correction of the alleged violations, and the court may request further briefing and evidentiary submissions from the parties in response to that motion and evidence.
- Requires that all statements or evidence submitted for purposes of the early evaluation conference and all discussions at the early evaluation conference be subject to Evidence Code provisions limiting the admissibility of certain statements and actions in negotiations from being admissible to later prove liability.
- Limits the early evaluation process to 30 days unless all parties mutually agree to extend the timeline.
- Provides that the early evaluation process is to be conducted by a judge or commissioner or such other person knowledgeable about and experienced with labor issues and designated by the court.
- Provides that nothing in 1) through 15) is to be construed to do any of the following:
- Prohibit an employer from independently curing any violations or preventing the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process;
- Prohibit an employer with fewer than 100 employees from using the early evaluation process;
- Preclude a court from ordering appropriate injunctive relief; or
- Limit the courts obligation to approve settlements.
- Provides, commencing October 1, 2024, that within 33 days of the receipt of a notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative, in accordance with the notice procedures of existing law, an employer with fewer than 100 employees may submit to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations, as specified.
- Provides that if a cure proposed pursuant to 16) is facially sufficient or if a conference is necessary to determine if a sufficient cure is possible, then within 14 days after receipt of the employer’s proposal, the Labor and Workforce development Agency may set a conference with the parties, to be conducted no more than 30 days thereafter, to determine whether the proposed cure is sufficient, what additional information may be necessary to evaluate the sufficiency of the cure, and the deadline agreed upon by the parties for the employer to complete the cure.
- Requires that if a cure proposed in accordance with 16) is for unpaid wages, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to determine at the conference whether to request the employer pay the proposed cure amount, including any wages and liquidated damages due and 7 percent interest, into escrow or provide such other form of security as the Agency deems suitable.
- Provides that if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines that the cure is not facially sufficient or does not act upon the employer’s cure proposal, the employee may proceed with a civil action, in accordance with existing law, after 65 calendar days from sending the notice required by law, unless that time is extended by the Agency, provided that such time cannot be extended to more than 120 calendar days after notice is sent, and subject to the employer’s ability to request a stay and early evaluation conference pursuant to 1).
- Requires, that on or before the agreed upon deadline to cure, but no more than 45 days after the conference, the employer to complete the cure and provide a sworn notification, including all information the parties deemed necessary to determine the sufficiency of the cure, to the employee and agency that the cure is completed, accompanied by a payroll audit and check register if the violation involves a payment obligation.
- Requires the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to verify whether the cure is complete within 20 days of receiving the employer’s notification.
- Provides that if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency’s review of the sufficiency of a cure extends beyond 65 days, the statute of limitations regarding the alleged violation is tolled until the Agency completes its work.
- Requires that if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency preliminarily determines that the alleged violation has been cured, the Agency to notify the aggrieved employee and, if requested by the aggrieved employee, set a hearing within 30 days of such determination.
- Requires the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to issue a final order no more than 20 days after the hearing speicified in 23) providing a determination as to whether the cure is adequate and the reasons for its determination.
- Prohibits, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrevied employee from filing a civil action, however, the employee may appeal the Agency’s determination in superior court.
- Provides that any amounts paid by the employer to the aggrieved employees to cure the alleged violation be offset against any judgment later entered with respect to that violation, if the superior court concludes the agency abused its discretion in finding that the employer’s cure was adequate.
- Prohibits a cure or cure proposal from being deemed an admission of liability in accordance with applicable Evidence Code provisons.
- Provides that nothing in 16) though 27) prohibits an employer from independently remedying any violations or prevents the parties from agreeing to their own mediation process.
- Provides that if the only violations sought to be cured by an employer are related to specified paystub violations the following provisions apply:
- The employer may cure the alleged violation within 33 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice sent by the aggrieved employee or representative and provide written notice within that period of time by certified mail to the aggrieved employee or representative and by online filing with the agency if the alleged violation is cured, including a description of actions taken;
- Prohibits the commncement of a civil action if the employer complies with a);
- If the aggrieved employee disputes that the alleged violation has been cured, the aggrevied employee must provide written notice to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the employer, as specified, and include the specific grounds to support that dispute, to the employer and the agency;
- Requires the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to review, within 17 days of receiving the notice pursuant to c), the actions taken by the employer to cure the alleged violation, and provide written notice of its decision by certified mail to the aggrieved employee and the employer;
- Authorizes, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines a violation has not been cured, the Agency to provide the employer three business days to cure the violation; and
- If the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines that the alleged violation has not been cured or if the agency fails to provide timely or any notification, the employee may proceed with the civil action, and if the employee disagrees with the Agency’s decision the employee may appeal that decision in superior court.
- Limits an employer to availing itself of the notice and cure provisions of this bill no more than one time in a 12-month period for violations of the same Labor Code provisions set forth in the notice, regardless of the location of the worksite or if it has been served with a prior notice existing law alleging the same violation that it did not cure.
- Requires, if an employer is not eligible to avail themselves of the cure processes specified in 16) through 29) or chooses not to utilize those processes, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to notify the employer and the aggrieved employee by certified mail that it does not intend to investigate the alleged violation within 60 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice.
- Provides an aggrevied empployee the right to file a civil action upon receipt of the notice from the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or if the employee receives no notice within 65 days of the postmark date of their original notice given to the Agency.
- Requires, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency intends to investigate an alleged violation, the Agency to notify the employer and the aggrieved employee by certified mail of its decision within 65 calendar days of the postmark date of the notice received, and that the Agency must make a determination regarding the alleged violation within 120 days of deciding to investigate the allegation.
- Requires the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to notify the employer and aggrevied employee within five busienss days of making a determination that no citiations will be issued by the Agency, and upon receipt of the notice the aggrieved employee may commence a civil action, as specified.
- Provides that the above described confidential correspondence with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency are confidential and makes necessary findings to impose a limitation on the public’s right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies.
- Modifies which provisions of the Labor Code are subject to specific notice and civil action provisions.
- Provides that this bill only applies to a civil action brought on or after June 19, 2024.
- Adopts an urgency clause such that all provisons of this bill, except those subject to the October 1, 2024 enactment date specified in 16), are to take effect immediately.
- Makes the enactment of this measure contingent of the enactment of AB 2288 (Kalra, 2024).
- Makes various findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004. (Labor Code Section 2698.)
- Authorizes a provision of this code that provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees, for a violation of the Labor Code, to be alternatively recovered through a civil action brought by an aggrieved employee on behalf of themselves and other current or former employees pursuant to specified procedures. (Labor Code Section 2699 (a).)
- Defines the following for purposes of Private Attorneys General Act:
- “Person” means any person, association, organization, partnership, business trust, limited liability company, or corporation;
- “Aggrieved employee” means any person who was employed by the alleged violator and against whom one or more of the alleged violations was committed;
- “Cure” means that the employer abates each violation alleged by any aggrieved employee, the employer is in compliance with the underlying statutes as specified in the notice required by this part, and any aggrieved employee is made whole. Specifies certain violations can only be considered cured upon a showing that the employer has provided a fully compliant, itemized wage statement to each aggrieved employee for each pay period for the three-year period prior to the date of the written notice sent pursuant to the specified section. (Labor Code Section 2699 (b) – (d).)
- Establishes that, for purposes of Private Attorneys General Act, whenever the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees, has discretion to assess a civil penalty, a court is authorized to exercise the same discretion, subject to the same limitations and conditions, to assess a civil penalty. (Section 2699 (e)(1).)
- Grants a court, in an action by an aggrieved employee seeking recovery of a civil penalty pursuant to 2) or 6), the discretion to award a lesser amount than the maximum civil penalty amount specified if, based on the facts and circumstances of the particular case, to do otherwise would result in an award that is unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory. (Labor Code Section 2699 (e)(2).)
- Establishes the following civil penalties for all provisions of the Labor Code except those for which a civil penalty is specifically provided:
- If, at the time of the alleged violation, the person does not employ one or more employees, the civil penalty is $500;
- If, at the time of the alleged violation, the person employs one or more employees, the civil penalty is $100 for each aggrieved employee per pay period for the initial violation and $200 for each aggrieved employee per pay period for each subsequent violation;
- If the alleged violation is a failure to act by the Labor and Workplace Development Agency, or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees, there shall be no civil penalty. (Labor Code Section 2699 (f).)
- Except as provided in 8), an aggrieved employee may recover the civil penalty described in 6) in a civil action pursuant to the procedures specified in 10), 11), or 12), whichever applies, filed on behalf of himself or herself and other current or former employees against whom one or more of the alleged violations was committed. Any employee who prevails in any action is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including any filing fee paid pursuant to 10), 11), or 12), whichever applies. Prohibits anything in the Private Attorneys General Act from operating to limit an employee’s right to pursue or recover other remedies available under state or federal law, either separately or concurrently with an action taken under the Act. (Labor Code Section 2699 (g)(1).)
- Prohibits an action from being brought under Private Attorneys General Act by an aggrieved employee if the agency or any of its departments, divisions, commissions, boards, agencies, or employees, on the same facts and theories, cites a person within the timeframes set forth in 13) or 14), whichever applies for a violation of the same section or sections of the Labor Code under which the aggrieved employee is attempting to recover a civil penalty on behalf of himself or herself or others or initiates proceedings pursuant to 9). (Labor Code Section 2699 (h).)
- Requires the aggrieved employee or representative provide the Agency with a file-stamped copy of the complaint that includes the case number assigned in court within 10 days following commencement of a civil action brought under the Private Attorneys General Act. (Labor Code Section 2699 (l).)
- Identifies notice requirements a plaintiff must complete prior to initiating a Private Attorneys General Act claim for specified violations of the Labor Code, including giving written notice by online filing to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and by certified mail to the employer of the specific provisions alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation. (Labor Code Section 2699.3 (a).)
- Identifies notice requirements a plaintiff must complete prior to initiating a Private Attorneys General Act claim for specified violations of the Labor Code, including giving notice by online filing with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH) and by certified mail to the employer, with a copy to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, of the specific provisions alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation. (Labor Code Section 2699.3 (b).)
- Identifies notice requirements a plaintiff must complete prior to initiating a Private Attorneys General Act claim for violations of the Labor Code not specified in 10) or 11), including giving notice by online filing with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, and by certified mail to the employer, of the specific provisions alleged to have been violated, including the facts and theories to support the alleged violation. (Labor Code Section 2699.3 (c).)
- Specifies the provisions of the Labor Code giving rise to the requirements specified in 10). (Labor Code Section 2699.5.)
- Provides that evidence that a person has, in compromise or from humanitarian motives, furnished or offered or promised to furnish money or any other thing, act, or service to another who has sustained or will sustain or claims that he or she has sustained or will sustain loss or damage, as well as any conduct or statements made in negotiation thereof, is inadmissible to prove his or her liability for the loss or damage or any part of it. (Evidence Code Section 1152 (a).)
- Provides that nothing in 14) affects the admissibility of evidence of any of the following:
- Partial satisfaction of an asserted claim or demand without questioning its validity when such evidence is offered to prove the validity of the claim; and
- A debtor’s payment or promise to pay all or a part of his or her preexisting debt when such evidence is offered to prove the creation of a new duty on his or her part or a revival of his or her preexisting duty. (Evidence Code Section 1152 (c).)
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the California Public Records Act. (Government Code Sections 7920.00 et seq.)
- Provides that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure. (Government Code Section 7922.525.)
- Defines “public records” as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Government Code Section 7920.530.)
- Defines “public agency” as any state or local agency. (Government Code Section 7920.525.)
- Defines “state agency” as every state office, officer, department, division, bureau, board, and commission or other state body or agency, except those agencies provided for in Article IV (except Section 20 thereof) or Article VI of the California Constitution. (Government Code Section 7920.540.)
- Provides that nothing in the California Public Records Act requires the disclosure of specified personal information including but not limited to the following:
- The residence or mailing address of any person in any record of the Department of Motor Vehicles (Government Code Section 7924.405.);
- The name, credit history, utility usage data, home address, or telephone number of a utility customer of a local agency (Government Code Section 7927.410.); and
- Records related to statements of personal worth or personal financial data, including, but not limited to, wills, trusts, account statements, earnings statements, dates of birth, social security numbers, bank account numbers, or other similar records. (Government Code Section 7927.425.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The California Labor Code’s Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) took effect in 2004 to address the state’s labor enforcement entities’ lack of resources sufficient to enforce the state’s Labor Code. PAGA authorizes individual workers to step into the role of the state’s labor enforcement entity, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, and bring a lawsuit against their employer. Notably, a PAGA action is intended, not to make the affected worker or workers whole, but rather to recover civil penalties on behalf of the State.
Nonetheless, for the better part of PAGA’s 20-year existence, the business community has vociferously objected to the law. The business community believes the law lacks procedural safeguards, denies businesses the right to cure violations of the Labor Code, and provides an unreasonable financial boon for attorneys. This bill is part of a package of reforms to PAGA that was agreed to by all stakeholders. Specifically, this measure adopts two pro-business reforms. First, the bill offers all employers, including those with 100 or more employees, a process to seek an early evaluation of claims subject to litigation. Secondly, this bill offers small and midsized employers an opportunity to cure specified Labor Code violations through a process with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency. The other measure in this package focuses on the penalty amounts awarded in PAGA cases, including those involving legal aid organizations, and outline that curing a violation must be effectuated pursuant to the processes established by the reforms proposed in this package. In support of this bill the author states:
In 2004, the California Legislature passed the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) to bolster the State’s labor enforcement capabilities. Under existing law, PAGA enables aggrieved employees to enforce the California Labor Code by pursuing lawsuits against employers to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves and other employees for violations of state law. PAGA cases are most often filed to address major labor code violations and enforce fundamental labor rights such as overtime, minimum wage, and sick leave. Since its enactment, PAGA has served as a critical enforcement tool, reflecting the reality that the State’s labor enforcement agencies often lack the resources to investigate and take action against every violation. In addition to limited public enforcement resources, the increased use of arbitration clauses has prevented aggrieved workers from filing individual or class action lawsuits against their employer, instead requiring them to go through arbitration, which some believe historically favors employers.
However, two decades since its enactment, serious flaws in the PAGA have come to light due to some bad actors. Under the current system, the aggrieved employee often receives little compensation. Furthermore, state data shows that it takes 310 more days to resolve a PAGA case compared to a state investigated case. Additionally, family-run small businesses, non-profits, local governments, school districts, labor unions and thousands of other employers have become major targets for lawsuits, often for minor technical violations. Some of PAGA’s structure has unintentionally created these abuses. Its $100/$200 penalty structure applies no matter the severity or duration of the violation and there are also no procedural guardrails that normally exist in civil litigation. Lastly, almost no violations may be cured – even if an employer quickly remedies the alleged violation, the same penalties apply.
In order to address these concerns, SB 92, along with its companion bill, AB 2288, will enact meaningful reforms to PAGA to ensure workers retain a strong tool to resolve labor claims and receive fair compensation while simultaneously curtailing abuses and unjust lawsuits that hurt employers.
Background on the Private Attorneys General Act of 2004. In 2003, the Legislature determined that insufficient staffing within the Labor Commissioner’s office was undermining the enforcement of critical state labor laws. To that end, the Legislature deputize private employees to enforce labor laws on behalf of the state. Indeed, the original intent of PAGA was for individual workers to step into the role of the state’s labor enforcement entity, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency. Accordingly, when the Legislature passed SB 796 (Dunn) Chap. 906, Stats. 2003, the penalty scheme was crafted to provide most of the recovery to the state. In fact, a plaintiff is not authorized to collect damages or back pay, and is limited instead to collection of 25% of the civil penalty imposed, with the remaining 75% being directed to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency for enforcement and educational purposes.
Given that the employee is deputized to act on behalf of state regulators, the PAGA scheme requires state involvement. To institute a claim, an aggrieved employee must file a notice with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency detailing Labor Code violations and, depending on the violations alleged, the Agency or a responsible division within the Department of Industrial Relations must act within statutory time limits to determine whether or not the state itself will pursue the claim. If the state declines to take action or fails to notify an employee of their intentions within set timelines, the existing law authorizes the employee to proceed with a PAGA lawsuit. This statutory scheme of notifying the state and then proceeding with a private right of action in the absence of state litigation is not unique to PAGA, in fact, the enforcement of the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, better known as Proposition 65, adopts a nearly identical enforcement scheme. Although it should be noted in fairness to the business community that, much like PAGA, businesses frequently express dissatisfaction with the provisions of Proposition 65.
One aspect of PAGA that businesses find particularly troublesome is the ability for an individual employee to easily seek and retain class status for their claims. Indeed, the business groups supporting this measure have provided the Committee a significant body of case law outlining the unique rules for representative actions under PAGA. For example, businesses object to PAGA’s special discovery rules (Williams v. Superior Court (2017) 3 Cal. 5th 531.), class settlement rules (Kim v. Reins (2020) 9 Cal. 5th 73.), and procedures impacting representative actions and arbitration agreements. (Adolph v. Uber (2023) 14 Cal. 5th 1104.)
The ballot measure-sized elephant in the room. Given the business community’s above-mentioned consternation with PAGA, it is unsurprising that multiple attempts to repeal and reform the Act have been introduced in the Legislature over the last 20 year. However, given PAGA’s important role in protecting California’s workforce from egregious abuses by employers, it is also unsurprising that over a half-dozen attempts to impose procedural barriers to pursuing PAGA claims have failed in the Legislature since 2020.
In light of the Legislature’s unwillingness to undermine PAGA’s worker protection provisions, beginning in 2021, the business community began the steps to ask California’s voters to weigh in on the merits of PAGA. On July 22, 2022, the Secretary of State certified that the California Employee Civil Action Law Initiative (Initiative No. 21-0027) had garnered sufficient signatures to qualify for the November 2024 ballot. (https://ballotpedia.org/California_Employee_Civil_Action_Law_and_PAGA_Repeal_Initiative_(2024).)
This measure, and its companion bill (AB 2288 (Kalra, 2024)), represent a compromise between the business community, labor organizations, private attorneys, and other stakeholders designed to replace the California Employee Civil Action Law Initiative. Stakeholders have agreed that should this measure and AB 2288 be enacted the ballot initiative would be removed from the November 2024 ballot.
This bill. As noted this measure is one aspect of the broader PAGA compromise. At its core this bill addresses the business community’s objections that PAGA, as it is currently constituted, denies businesses the right to cure violations and results in protracted and costly litigation. Seeking to address these concerns this bill adopts two new procedural requirements that must be satisfied when bringing PAGA claims.
The first procedural change to PAGA proposed by this bill adopts a cure process for small and medium-sized businesses with fewer than 100 employees. This proposal authorizes a qualifying employer to submit to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, within 33 days of receiving a notice of a violation in accordance with existing law, a confidential proposal to cure one or more of the alleged violations. The bill then outlines the timelines and procedural guidelines the Labor and Workforce Development Agency must follow when evaluating the sufficiency of the proposed cure. Generally, if the Labor and Workforce Development Agency determines a proposed cure is sufficient, and documents that the cure has been properly implemented, then a PAGA-based civil action cannot be brought. Notably, if the Agency determines a cure is insufficient or was not properly completed, then a civil action may be filed. Additionally, should an aggrieved employee disagree with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency’s determination related to the cure, the employee may file an action in superior court challenging the Agency’s determination. Similar, but slightly modified procedures apply to the cure provisions regarding specified paystub violation claims. These provisions take effect October 1, 2024.
The second aspect of the bill applies to large employers with more than 100 employees, as well as small and mid-sized employers who wish to avail themselves of the procedure. This procedure enables an employer to seek an “early evaluation conference” at the beginning stages of PAGA litigation. The evaluation would be conducted by a judge or other neutral and would largely examine the following four aspects of a PAGA claim:
- Whether any of the alleged violations occurred and if so, whether the defendant has cured the alleged violations;
- The strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiff’s claims and the defendant’s defenses;
- Whether plaintiff’s claims, including any claim for penalties or injunctive relief, can be settled in whole or in part; and
- Whether the parties should share other information that may facilitate early evaluation and resolution of the dispute.
Generally, the court is required to stay the proceedings during the pendency of the early evaluation conference. The bill outlines the timelines for the various steps of the evaluation conference and outlines what evidence and other filings each party must present to the neutral at the conference. If as a result of the early evaluation conference, the parties and the neutral agree to a plan to remedy violations and the neutral and the employee are satisfied those remedies are being carried out properly, the parties are to jointly submit a statement to the judge that is to be treated as a proposed settlement. If parties cannot reach agreement, or other issues remain at dispute following the early evaluation conference, the outstanding issues may proceed pursuant to the existing law. Notably, if issues are remedied during the early evaluation conference, then a defendant may seek to avail themselves of modified penalty provisions that may expose them to fewer penalties. It should be noted that these penalties are being modified as a part of this measure’s companion bill, AB 2288.
Finally, this bill makes several technical changes to carry out the above-mentioned provisions. First, the bill provides that information discussed in cure discussions or the early evaluation conference may not necessarily be used to prove liability should a matter ultimately be forced to reach a final judgement in court. Second, the bill provides that the confidential communications shared with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency are not subject to public disclosure pursuant to the California Public Records Act and other public record statutes. This measure also modifies which provisions of the Labor Code can result in PAGA claims. The bill also explicitly makes its enactment contingent on the enactment of AB 2288. Finally, this measure adopts an urgency clause and makes needed findings and declarations.
The one issue that both sides of the PAGA debate seem to agree upon: timing is everything. The underlying rationale for both this measure and AB 2288 appears to be a goal of resolving PAGA disputes in a timelier manner. The cure and early evaluation conference provisions of this bill are designed to promote resolution of PAGA claims without protracted litigation. The amended penalty provisions being adopted are designed to promote the expedient adoption of remedies to Labor Code violations. While this Committee has long held that any violations of the Labor Code are unacceptable, as these violations result in harm to California’s workforce, remedying these violations in a timely manner is a laudable goal. That is why the new penalty provisions are designed to only apply when an employer successfully remedies violations in good faith in accordance with the early action provisions of this bill and complies with the framework for curing a violation provided in AB 2288. Should an employer seek to use the provisions of this bill, or AB 2288, as a tactic for prolonging litigation and delaying the remediation of Labor Code violations then the full scope of remedies provided by PAGA should still apply.
Accordingly, to the extent that this bill and AB 2288 help redress Labor Code violations in a timely manner, and forestall action on a draconian ballot measure designed to wholly undermine the enforcement of California’s labor laws, these bills represent a worthy and hard-fought compromise between stakeholders. Indeed, given the acrimony surrounding PAGA in recent years, the stakeholders should be lauded for reaching an agreement that gives California’s business community new legal clarity while protecting the well-deserved rights and protections of California’s workforce.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The PAGA reform package, including the provisions of this bill are supported by a sweeping coalition of business advocates including the California Chamber of Commerce. Additionally, advocates for California workers including the California Labor Federation and associated labor organizations, the Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyer’s Association also support the package. In support of this bill, and the package overall, the California Chamber of Commerce and its coalition of business advocates jointly write:
Together, SB 92 and AB 2288 brings long overdue reform to the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA). SB 92 and AB 2288 will ensure that workers are having claims resolved more quickly and that businesses and non-profits that comply with the law are not penalized. Those reforms include:
- Expanding which Labor Code sections may be cured, so employees are made whole quickly.
- Protecting small employers by providing a more robust right to cure processes through the agency.
- Providing an opportunity for early resolution in court.
- Codifying that the court may limit evidence presented or the scope of the claim to ensure the claim can be effectively tried.
We are also supportive of efforts to give the California Department of Industrial Relations the ability to expedite hiring and fill vacancies to improve enforcement and implement the cure process for small employers.
Additionally, a coalition of labor organizations including the California Labor Federation write:
This package expands PAGA remedies by adding injunctive relief. It will also make it easier to hold bad actors accountable, with new ways to get to a higher penalty tier and additional judicial discretion to increase penalties where the outcome would otherwise be unjust.
This bill also preserves broader standing for non-profit legal services so that a worker need only have suffered one or more of the alleged violations.
Finally, legal advocates including the Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyers Association jointly write:
These reforms are aimed at incentivizing compliance and ensuring workers are made whole for wage theft. With these reforms, PAGA will not only allow for penalties when employers break the law, but it will also increase a worker’s ability to get back wages with interest, stop illegal practices, and get a bigger share of civil penalties.
This bill, and AB 2288, requires that an employer seeking to cure must come into compliance, pay all wages back with interest for previous three years, plus liquidated damages and reasonable attorney’s fees.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
African-American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Airlines for America (A4A)
Allied Managed Care
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
American Petroleum and Convenience Store Association
Associated Equipment Distributors
Associated General Contractors
Bay Area Council
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Alliance of Family Owned Businesses
California Apartment Association
California Association of Licensed Security Agencies, Guards & Associates
California Association of Sheet Metal & Air Conditioning Contractors National Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Citrus Mutual
California Conference Board of The Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Cotton Ginners & Growers Association
California Credit Union League
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Farm Bureau
California Federation of Teachers
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grocers Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California IATSE Council
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Rice Commission
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State University Employees Union, SEIU Local 2579
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Travel Association
California Trucking Association
California Walnut Commission
Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce
Coalition of Small & Disabled Veteran Business Owners
Consumer Attorneys of California
Corona Chamber of Commerce
Engineers Society - IFPTE, Local 21
Flasher Barricade Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Grower-shipper Association of Central California
Housing Contractors of California
Industry Business Council
LeadingAge California
National Association of Theatre Owners of California
Nisei Farmers League
North San Diego Business Chamber
Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Jose Chamber of Commerce
San Marcos Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
SEIU California State Council
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
True Blue
UNITE HERE!
United Ag
United Auto Workers
United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Western States Council
Utility Workers Union of America
Vista Chamber of Commerce
West Ventura County Business Alliance
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Car Wash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 4, 2024
Counsel: Ilan Zur
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Kevin McCarty, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 92
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:January 3, 2024
SUMMARY: Extends the sunset dates for provisions allowing remote proceedings in criminal cases. Specifically, this bill:
- Extends the sunset date from January 1, 2025 to January 1, 2026 for the following provisions that:
- Prohibit trial courts from retaliating against official reporters who notify judicial officers that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote proceeding.
- Authorize defendants, in misdemeanor proceedings other than domestic violence and driving under influence (DUI) cases, to appear remotely for their initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except for jury and court trials.
- Authorize defendants, in felony cases, to file a written waiver with the court to appear remotely during criminal proceedings, except for jury trials, court trials, and sentencing hearings other than post-conviction relief hearings.
- Authorize defendants, in misdemeanor or felony cases, to appear remotely for a jury or court trial for noncritical portions of the trial where no testimonial evidence is taken.
- Permit attorneys representing defendants to appear remotely if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and their attorney, unless otherwise requested by defense counsel.
- Permit courts to allow defendants to appear by counsel at trial or other proceedings if the court makes specified findings by clear and convincing evidence.
- Permit a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding remotely, unless technological issues are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time.
- Permit witnesses to appear remotely at any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, with the consent of the parties and the court, and provided that the defendant’s waiver was made knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently.
- Permit witnesses to testify remotely, as otherwise provided in statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.
- Provide that the provision of law permitting hearings to continue in the defendant’s absence in a preliminary hearing where the defendant is voluntarily absent, and in specified instances of disruptive behavior by the defendant, does not restrict the defendant’s right to appear remotely.
- Provides that when a court conducts remote proceedings that will be reported by an official reporter, the official court reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom.
- Requires courts to have a process for specified persons to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the hearing.
- Extends the effective date of specified statutory provisions that will take effect when the above provisions sunset, from January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2026.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that persons charged with a misdemeanor only may appear by counsel, except in cases involving domestic violence or DUIs. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (a)(1).)
- Provides that, in misdemeanor cases, if the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (a)(1).)
- Provides that in cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during the portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of imposition of the sentence, unless the defendant waives their right to be physically present and opts for the use of remote technology. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(1).)
- Provides in felony cases, the accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of the court and with approval of defendant’s counsel. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(1).)
- Provides that a defendant’s waiver of their right to be physically or remotely present may be made in writing and filed with the court, or, with the court’s consent, may be entered personally by the defendant or by their counsel. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(2).)
- Provides a defendant’s personal waiver of the right to be physically or remotely present shall be on the record and state that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendant’s physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(2)(A).)
- Provides that a waiver of the defendant’s physical or remote presence may be entered by counsel, after counsel has stated on the record that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue, has waived that right, and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendant’s physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(2)(B).)
- Authorizes a court to direct the defendant to be physically or remotely present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof, including upon request of a victim, to the extent required by the Victim’s Bill of Rights in the California Constitution. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(2)(C).)
- Specifies the applicable format and content of a defendant’s waiver of physical or remote presence. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (b)(3.)
- Provides that upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial and a defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for post-conviction relief proceedings. The defendant may withdraw the waiver at any time (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (c)(1) (A)(D)(E)))
- Provides that the court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel to be present at a particular felony proceeding or portion thereof. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (c)(1)(B).)
- Provides that if the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and attorney prior to and during the proceedings, unless, upon the request of defense counsel, the court allows the appearance without private communication. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (c)(1)(C).)
- Provides that a witness may appear remotely at a misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, with the consent of the parties and the court, except for a felony trial. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (c)(1)(F).)
- Provides that a felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (c)(2)(A).)
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other provision, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel at trial or any other proceeding, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that:
- The defendant is in custody and refusing, without good cause, to appear;
- The defendant has been informed of their right to be personally present;
- The defendant has been informed that the trial or other proceeding proceed without them;
- The defendant has been informed of their right to remain silent;
- The defendant has been informed their absence, without good cause, will constitute a voluntary waiver of their right to testify or confront witnesses against them; and
- The defendant has been informed whether defense counsel will be present. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (d)(1).)
- Provides that a court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney and defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology without being physically present in the courtroom. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (e).)
- Provides that except as provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
- The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
- Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporter’s ability to accurately prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly with the defendant and the court during the proceeding. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (f).)
- Provides that before the court conducts a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977, subd. (g)(1).)
- Provides that when a court conducts remote proceedings that will be reported, the reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (g)(2).)
- Requires the court to make findings on the record that any waiver entered is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (h.)
- Provides that the above provisions authorizing remote proceedings in criminal cases shall sunset on January 1, 2025. (Pen. Code, § 977, subd. (j.)
- Provides a witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have the witness testify in person on the record. (Pen. Code, § 977.3, subd. (a).)
- Provides that the court may allow a witness to testify through the use of remote technology as otherwise provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses. (Pen. Code, § 977.3, subd. (b).)
- Provides that the court shall make findings on the record that any waiver is made knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently by the defendant. (Pen. Code, § 977.3, subd. (c.)
- Provides that the above provisions allowing remote witness testimony for certain criminal proceedings shall sunset on January 1, 2025. (Pen. Code, § 977.3, subd. (e.)
- Requires, generally, a defendant to be personally present at a preliminary hearing. (Pen. Code, § 1043.5., subd. (a).)
- Provides that the absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence, as specified, shall not prevent continuing the hearing for prosecutions for offenses not punishable by death where the defendant is voluntarily absent, and in specified instances of disruptive behavior by the defendant. (Pen. Code, § 1043.5., subd. (b).)
- Provides this does not limit the right of the defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through the use of remote technology. (Pen. Code, § 1043.5., subd. (d).)
- Provides that the above provisions permitting defendant’s to appear remotely in preliminary hearings, shall sunset on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of a verbatim record for a remote proceeding. This provision is repealed effective January 1, 2025. (Gov. Code, § 71651.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “[t]he use of remote proceedings in state court was not a novel development during the Covid-19 pandemic. Remote access to the courts has existed for many years through platforms like Court Call, which have increased access to justice for Californians. In fact, the benefits of remote access are undeniable. Four years removed from the 2020 pandemic, courts have studied their continuous use of remote options in court and have found that the reception is almost unanimously positive. Remote options have led to an easier access to the courts for vulnerable litigants, reduction of case backlog, trial length, and cost reductions for litigants and the court.
“The legislature has authorized the use of remote access in criminal proceeding again and again. Most recently, in last year’s SB 135 with sunsets at the end of 2024. Therefore, SB 92 simply continues to extend the use of remote technology for certain proceedings in state court for one more year.”
- Background: Prior to COVID-19, with the exception of appearances that could be waived, defendants in criminal cases generally appeared in person, with the option of remote appearances limited to in-custody defendants. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, Judicial Council adopted Emergency Rules to the California Rules of Court in April 2020, to allow defendants and attorneys to appear remotely in proceedings with the consent of the defendant. These rules were set to sunset on June 30, 2022. The Legislature has since extended this sunset date for remote criminal proceedings on two separate occasions via the budget. AB 199 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 57, Statutes of 2022, extended remote court hearings in specified criminal proceedings until January 1, 2024 with some additional changes to the Emergency Rules. SB 135 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 190, Statutes of 2023, further extended the sunset date to January 1, 2025. Remote civil proceedings have similarly been re-authorized and extended.[1]
- Effect of this Bill: This bill will extend the sunset date of the below proceedings permitting remote appearances in criminal proceedings from January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2026. The most notable provisions, currently in place, that will be extended by SB 92, are summarized below:
- Defendants charged with misdemeanors may appear remotely for their initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials.
- Defendants charged with felonies may appear remotely during criminal proceedings if they waive the right to be physically present, except for jury and court trials, and sentencing hearings other than post-conviction relief.
- Defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases may appear remotely for a jury or court trial for noncritical portions of the trial where no testimonial evidence is taken.
- Defendants’ attorneys may appear remotely as long as the technology allows for private communication between the defendant and their attorney.
- Attorneys may participate in a criminal proceeding remotely, unless specified technological issues are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time.
- Witnesses may appear remotely, except for felony trials, with the consent of the parties and the court.
- Requires court reporters to be physically present in a courtroom during remote proceedings and prohibits retaliation against reporters for reporting technology and audibility issues.
- Remote Criminal Proceedings in the COVID-19 Pandemic: As previously mentioned, during the COVID-19 pandemic Judicial Council adopted Emergency Rules to the California Rules of Court to allow defendants and attorneys to appear remotely in proceedings with the consent of the defendant. A Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC) report on the use of remote court proceedings during the Covid-19 pandemic provides some helpful insight into how remote criminal proceedings may impact conviction and sentencing trends, and how these outcomes differ by race. The most notable findings are summarized below:
- Uneven adoption of policies, coupled with geographic differences in where people live, meant that Black and Latino defendants had greater potential than people of other races to experience pandemic policies.
- When remote hearing policies were in place, courts were less likely to convict defendants within 6 months of arrest.
- Misdemeanor convictions, under remote hearings, were more likely to result noncustodial sentences such as probation and money sanctions, rather than jail, primarily for white, Latino, and Black people.
- Felony convictions, under remote hearings, were more likely to lead to jail than prison time for Black people.[2]
This indicates that remote criminal proceedings may impact whether a person is convicted and how they are sentenced. That being said, these outcomes must be considered in the broader context of the COVID-19 pandemic and other court pandemic policies that were implemented at this time (e.g. arraignment extension policies and zero bail policies), making it uncertain if these trends will hold true for post-pandemic remote criminal proceedings.
- Benefits of Remote Criminal Proceedings: Permitting defendants, witnesses, and attorneys to appear remotely in criminal cases has several advantages. This includes increasing access to courts for under-resourced defendants by reducing the time and financial costs associated with attending court proceedings.[3] For example, appearing remotely, an out-of-custody defendant can avoid the financial costs associated with paying for transportation to the courthouse, or associated parking costs. [4] Further, time saved avoiding travelling to a courthouse and waiting for their case to be called allows defendants to avoid paying for child care or risk losing their employment or housing by taking work off.[5]
The option for witnesses to appear remotely can also increase party access to expert witnesses, who otherwise would not be available or whose appearance is a significant financial burden. Allowing for remote appearances for routine criminal proceedings may improve judicial efficiency and court availability. Research from the pandemic suggests that utilizing remote proceedings helps courts improve their case clearance rates and reduce case backlog.[6]
As noted in Judicial Council’s letter of support, a survey from Judicial Council of California indicates that court users and court workers have had a very positive experience utilizing remote technology. A survey of 64,369 court users and court workers from September 1, 2022 and August 31, 2023, found that 90% of court users and 98.3% of court workers have had a positive experience with remote proceedings.[7] However, this survey was limited to experiences of remote technology civil proceedings. Given that this bill would expand the sunset date for use of remote technology in criminal proceedings and some concerns with this bill specifically pertain to the rights of criminal defendants, the findings of this survey, as applied to informing the merits of SB 92, should be taken with a grain of salt.
- Racial and Geographic Inequities in Access to Internet and Remote Technology: SB 92 provides misdemeanor and felony defendants to appear remotely except during jury and court trials, and other than noncritical portions of the trial where no testimonial evidence is taken. However, disparities in access to the technologies (e.g. high speed internet, computers, etc.) that allow for effective remote participation in court proceedings may exacerbate existing racial inequities in court access. Research has found that only 62% of Americans in households making under $30,000 a year use the internet, compared with 90% of persons making between $50,000 and $74,999, and 97% of those making more than $75,000.[8] Research from a 2011 survey further indicates that approximately 66% of white Americans have access to high speed internet at home, compared with 49% of African Americans and 51% of Hispanics.[9] Therefore, the above-mentioned benefits of remote proceedings in criminal cases may disproportionately advantage wealthier white defendants.
Additionally, technological issues associated with remote participation may interfere with meaningful participation in a hearing or create sound-quality issues that can interfere with the official record and the right of parties to appeal their cases.[10] These issues can be expected to negatively impact under-resourced defendants with less sophisticated remote technology (e.g. poor internet access), elderly defendants unfamiliar with remote technology, and those in shared living spaces that do not have access to private spaces free of background noise.
- Right to Confront Witnesses: SB 92 authorizes remote witness testimony in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, with the consent of the parties and the court, and provided that the defendant’s waiver was made knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently. The Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides defendants with the right to confront witnesses against them. (U.S. Const., 6th Amendment). This right may be undermined by the continuous re-authorization of remote witness testimony. Specifically, it may be more difficult to assess the authenticity and credibility of a witness who is providing remote, rather than in-person, testimony. It may also be easier for witnesses to be coached or coerced by third parties when their immediate surroundings are not visible, which can reduce the reliability of the evidence being presented.
SB 92 attempts to protect this constitutional right by prohibiting remote witness testimony in felony trials, and by only permitting remote witness testimony with “the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court” and by providing that defendants must “waive this right to have a witness testify in person on the record.” Additionally, this waiver must be made knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently by the defendant. While defendants are permitted to waive their right to confront witnesses against them,[11] and SB 92 only permits remote witness testimony with a defendant’s consent, it is very easy to imagine a defendant being encouraged or pressured into consenting to hostile remote witness testimony for the purpose of facilitating judicial efficiency. As once noted by the late Justice Scalia in 2002 in response to proposed changes to Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, “[v]irtual confrontation might be sufficient to protect virtual constitutional rights; I doubt whether it is sufficient to protect real ones.”[12] Although SB 92 may avoid clear constitutional violations by requiring defendants to consent to remote witness testimony, continuing to re-authorize remote witness testimony in criminal cases might undermine the Confrontation Clause’s purpose of ensuring reliable evidence by subjecting witness testimony to cross examination.
The author might consider adding additional protections for defendants, by giving defendants the options to have in-person court proceedings with all parties present (including and especially witnesses) unless extenuating circumstances demand otherwise.
- Court Reporters and Interpreters: SB 92 re-authorizes remote appearances for defendants, attorneys, and witnesses, but court reporters, for remote proceedings that will be reported, must still be physically present in a courtroom. As noted earlier, technological issues (e.g. background noise, cross-talking, etc.) associated with remote technology can interfere with the creation of accurate verbatim transcripts and accurately recording the nuances of communication between parties. SB 92 attempts to protect against this concern by requiring a court to require parties to appear in person if remote technologies issues “inhibits a reporter’s ability to accurately prepare a transcript…” That being said, it is reasonable to expect that an occasional glitch, freeze, or cross-talking in an otherwise well-functioning remote appearance (that nonetheless reduces the accuracy of the official record) will not necessarily result in the court ordering a shift to in-person proceedings.
These same concerns exist for court interpreters. SB 92 similarly allows for courts to require in person proceedings where technology issues “inhibit[] a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access.” However, the inability for interpreters to be present with a person requiring translation and have one-on-one conversations with the participant may inhibit court access and meaningful engagement for persons requiring translation.[13]
- Argument in Support: According to Judicial Council of California “The Judicial Council has seen the many benefits of giving people the option to participate remotely in criminal proceedings. The remote option helps preserve access to justice for many Californians and vulnerable court users by reducing time and expense for them when they are hospitalized or would otherwise lose time from work or childcare and would incur travel and parking costs for short hearings and appearances. It also preserves equal access to justice and increases the efficiency of court services by continuing to allow courts the flexibility to require in-person court proceedings when it is more appropriate.
Further, participants in collaborative justice court programs and diversion programs especially benefit from the ability to appear remotely. Unlike other courts, collaborative courts and diversion courts meet on a frequent basis, making remote proceedings very helpful, while at the same time allowing judicial officers the discretion to balance the benefits of in-person participation with the efficiencies of remote proceedings for more routine matters. Program participants are not in custody, and remote appearances allow them to participate in court proceedings while not interrupting programming, schooling, or work obligations. Remote proceedings are also helpful to the many justice partners (behavioral health experts, probation, etc.) that help participants successfully graduate from collaborative court programs and diversion programs.
Moreover, the remote option is helpful for witness testimony in criminal proceedings, making appearances more affordable and efficient for court participants when the defendant consents.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to SEIU California “Remote technology offers convenience and flexibility. However, it cannot adequately replicate the essential components of in-person proceedings. The inherent risks of technical issues, the reliability of evidence, and the lack of secure and private environments can undermine the fairness and accuracy of the legal process. These factors must be considered when determining whether remote proceedings do not compromise the judicial process's integrity. However, SB 92 would extend procedures intended to navigate an emergency without any modifications to account for the shortcomings of remote technology.
“Technical glitches, unstable internet connections, audio distortions, video lag, and background noise impede clear communication during remote proceedings. These issues also hinder the assessment of witness credibility, which requires close observation of subtle nuances in voice and body language. When witnesses participate in remote locations, our justice system becomes more vulnerable to witness tampering and false impersonation. Moreover, remote technology lacks the necessary safeguards to ensure confidentiality and privacy during sensitive proceedings. The risk of unauthorized access or interception of confidential information poses a significant threat to the integrity and trustworthiness of the legal process. All of these issues interfere with the ability to determine the truth and maintain accurate verbatim transcripts.
“Accurate verbatim transcripts are essential to ensuring fairness and due process. One wrong word can irreversibly impact someone’s life during a criminal proceeding. Disruptions caused by technical issues, background noise, overlapping speech, and cross-talk increase the potential for errors. Additionally, verbatim transcripts also capture the nuances of communication, including pauses, tone, emphasis, and non-verbal cues. During a remote proceeding, video quality and cameras limit a court reporter’s ability to capture these details in transcripts.”
- Related Legislation:
- SB 135 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 190, Statutes of 2023, extended specified remote court proceedings for criminal matters set to expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2025.
- SB 97 (Wiener), Chapter 381, Statutes of 2023, refines the process by which those who are wrongfully convicted can prove their innocence and have their convictions reversed, including clarifying that petitioners incarcerated in state prison may chose not to appear in person and may appear remotely.
- SB 99 (Umberg), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have extended the sunset for provisions relating to remote proceedings in criminal cases from January 1, 2024, to January 1, 2028. SB 99 was held in Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1214 (Maienschein), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, among other things, provides that a trial court shall not retaliate or threaten to retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are impeding the creation of the verbatim records of a proceeding that includes participation through remote technology. AB 1214 was not heard in Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 199 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 57, Statutes of 2022, extends remote court hearings until January 1, 2024 with specified limitations, including but not limited to, requiring consent of the court user or defendant and limiting remote hearings to noncritical portions of a felony trial.
- SB 241 (Umberg) Chapter 214, Statutes of 2021, establishes a framework for conducting court proceedings in civil cases through the use of remote technology, and requires courts to electronically transmit documents issued by the court where parties have consented to, or are required to use, electronic service; and requires courts to hear minors’ compromise petitions within 30 days of filing and to issue a decision at the conclusion of the hearing if the petition is uncontested.
- SB 133 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 34, Statutes of 2023, extended the sunset on remote civil court proceedings from July 1, 2023 to January 1, 2026, among other things.)
- SB 848 (Umberg) of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have extended, to January 1, 2026, the sunset on the statutory authorization for specified remote appearances in specified civil court proceedings, extended the use of remote appearances to adoption finalization hearings, prohibited the use of remote appearances for testimony, hearings, and proceedings in juvenile justice cases and specified commitment proceedings. SB 848 failed passage on concurrence.
- AB 700 (Cunningham) Chapter 196, Statutes of 2021, allows a defendant who is in custody to appear by counsel in criminal proceedings, with or without a written waiver, if the court makes specified findings on the record by clear and convincing evidence.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Judges Association
Judicial Council of California
Oppose
Los Angeles County Court Reporters Association
Orange County Employees Association
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Court Reporters Association
California Public Defenders Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (seiu California)
San Francisco Public Defender
Analysis Prepared by: Ilan Zur
See SB 241 (Umberg), Chapter 214, Statutes of 2021 (extending remote proceedings in civil and juvenile dependency proceedings until July 1, 2023). See also SB 133 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 34, Statutes of 2023 (extending the sunset on remote civil court proceedings to January 1, 2026). ↑
Harris and Barton, Pandemic Policymaking and Changed Outcomes in Criminal Courts, Public Policy Institute of California (April 2023), available at: https://www.ppic.org/publication/policy-brief-pandemic-policymaking-and-changed-outcomes-in-criminal-courts/ ↑
Senate Public Safety Committee, 2023-2024 Informational/Oversight Hearings, March 7, 2023, available at: https://spsf.senate.ca.gov/hearings/2023-2024-informational-oversight-hearings ↑
Id. ↑
Id. ↑
Merril Balasson, Study shows remote proceedings increase efficiency, access, California Courts Newsroom (Sept. 20, 2021), available at: https://newsroom.courts.ca.gov/news/study-shows-remote-proceedings-increase-efficiency-access ↑
Report on the Use of Remote Technology in Civil Actions by the Trial Courts, Judicial Council of California (Dec. 22, 2023), available at: https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/lr-2023-tc-remote-technology-civil-actions-civ367.8.pdf ↑
Zickuhr and Smith, Digital differences, Pew Research Center (April 13, 2012), available at: https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2012/04/13/digital-differences/#:~:text=Currently%2C%2088%25%20of%20American%20adults%20age%2018%20and%20older%20have,with%20one%20of%20those%20devices. ↑
Id. ↑
Senate Public Safety Committee, 2023-2024 Informational/Oversight Hearings, March 7, 2023, available at: https://spsf.senate.ca.gov/hearings/2023-2024-informational-oversight-hearings ↑
In re Hannie (1970) 3 Cal.3d 520, 526. ↑
Order of the Supreme Court, 207 F.R.D. 89, 94 (2002). ↑
Senate Public Safety Committee, 2023-2024 Informational/Oversight Hearings, March 7, 2023, available at: https://spsf.senate.ca.gov/hearings/2023-2024-informational-oversight-hearings ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 92 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 92
Author: Umberg (D)
Amended: 1/3/24
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 1/9/24
AYES: Wahab, Seyarto, Bradford, Skinner, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Courts: remote proceedings for criminal cases
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends the sunset on provisions relating to remote proceedings in criminal cases.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that in all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except in domestic violence or driving under the influence cases. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
- Provides that, in a misdemeanor, if the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
- Provides that in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during the portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval of defendant’s counsel. (Penal Code § 977(b)(1))
- Provides that upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial and a defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for post-conviction relief proceedings. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1) (A)(D)(E)))
- Provides that the court my specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel to be present at a particular felony proceeding or portion thereof. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(B))
- Provides that, if the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and attorney prior to and during the proceedings, unless, upon the request of defense counsel the court allows the appearance without private communication. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(C))
- Provides that a witness may appear at a misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for a felony trial, remotely. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(F))
- Provides that a felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. (Penal Code § 977(c)(2))
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other provision, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel at trial or any other proceeding, if the court finds that: the defendant is in custody and refusing, without good cause, to appear; the defendant has been informed of their right to be personally present; the defendant has been informed that the trial or other proceeding will go on without them; the defendant has been informed of their right to remain silent; the defendant has been informed their absence will constitute a voluntary waiver of their constitutional rights; and, the defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present. (Penal Code § 977(d)(1))
- Provides that a court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney and defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding without being physically present. (Penal Code § 977(e))
- Provides that except as provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
- The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
- Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporter’s ability to prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly the defendant and the court during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(f))
- Provides that before the court conducts a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(g)(1))
- Provides that the official court reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom when remote proceedings are conducted. (Penal Code §977(g)(2))
- Provides that a witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have the witness testify in person on the record. (Penal Code §977.3)
- Requires, generally, a defendant to be personally present at a preliminary hearing. (Penal Code § 1043.5)
- Does not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through remote technology. (Penal Code § 1043.5(d))
- Provides that the provisions allowing remote proceedings in criminal cases shall sunset on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that, consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of a verbatim record for a remote proceeding. This provision sunsets January 1, 2025.
This bill extends the sunsets to January 1, 2026.
Background
According to the author:
The use of remote proceedings in state court was not a novel development during the Covid-19 pandemic. Remote access to the courts has existed for many years through platforms like Court Call, which have increased access to justice for Californians. In fact, the benefits of remote access are undeniable. Four years removed from the 2020 pandemic, courts have studied their continuous use of remote options in court and have found that the reception is almost unanimously positive. Remote options have led to an easier access to the courts for vulnerable litigants, reduction of case backlog, trial length, and cost reductions for litigants and the court.
The legislature has authorized the use of remote access in criminal proceeding again and again. Most recently, in last year’s SB 135 with sunsets at the end of 2024. Therefore, SB 92 simply continues to extend the use of remote technology for certain proceedings in state court for one more year.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 1/16/24)
California Judges Association
Judicial Council of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/16/24)
Los Angeles County Court Reporters Association
Orange County Employees Association
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. / (916) 651-4118
1/17/24 14:34:06
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 92 Hearing Date: January 9, 2024
Author: | Umberg | ||
Version: | January 3, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Courts: remote proceedings for criminal casess
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: SB 135 (Budget) Chapter 135, Stats. 2023
SB 99 (Umberg) In Assembly Public Safety
AB 199 (Budget) Chapter 57, Stats. 2022
SB 848 (Umberg) failed on concurrence 2022
SB 241 (Umberg) Chapter 214, Stats. 2021
Support: Unknown
Opposition: California Public Defenders Association (oppose unless amended); California State Council of Service Employees International Union – SEIU California (oppose unless amended)
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to extend the sunset on provisions relating to remote proceedings in criminal cases.
Existing law provides that in all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except in domestic violence or driving under the influence cases. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
Existing law provides that, in a misdemeanor, if the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
Existing law provides that in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during the portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval of defendant’s counsel. (Penal Code § 977(b)(1))
Existing law provides that upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial and a defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for post-conviction relief proceedings. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1) (A)(D)(E)))
Existing law provides that the court my specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel to be present at a particular felony proceeding or portion thereof. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(B))
Existing law provides that if the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and attorney prior to and during the proceedings, unless, upon the request of defense counsel the court allows the appearance without private communication. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(C))
Existing law provides that a witness may appear at a misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for a felony trial, remotely. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(F))
Existing law provides that a felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. (Penal Code § 977(c)(2))
Existing law provides that notwithstanding any other provision, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel at trial or any other proceeding, if the court finds that: the defendant is in custody and refusing, without good cause, to appear; the defendant has been informed of their right to be personally present; the defendant has been informed that the trial or other proceeding will go on without them; the defendant has been informed of their right to remain silent; the defendant has been informed their absence will constitute a voluntary waiver of their constitutional rights; and, the defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present. (Penal Code § 977(d)(1))
Existing law provides that a court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney and defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding without being physically present. (Penal Code § 977(e))
Existing law provides that except as provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
- The Court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
- Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporter’s ability to prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly the defendant and the court during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(f))
Existing law provides that before the court conducts a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(g)(1))
Existing law provides that the official court reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom when remote proceedings are conducted. (Penal Code § 977(g)(2))
Existing law provides that a witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have the witness testify in person on the record. (Penal Code §977.3)
Existing law generally requires a defendant to be personally present at a preliminary hearing. (Penal Code § 1043.5)
Existing law does not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through remote technology. (Penal Code § 1043.5(d))
Existing law provides that the provisions allowing remote proceedings in criminal cases shall sunset on January 1, 2025
This bill extends the sunset to January 1, 2026.
Existing law provides a that Consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of a verbatim record for a remote proceeding. This provision sunsets January 1, 2025.
This bill extends the sunset to January 1, 2026.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
The use of remote proceedings in state court was not a novel development during the Covid-19 pandemic. Remote access to the courts has existed for many years through platforms like Court Call, which have increased access to justice for Californians. In fact, the benefits of remote access are undeniable. Four years removed from the 2020 pandemic, courts have studied their continuous use of remote options in court and have found that the reception is almost unanimously positive. Remote options have led to an easier access to the courts for vulnerable litigants, reduction of case backlog, trial length, and cost reductions for litigants and the court.
The legislature has authorized the use of remote access in criminal proceeding again and again. Most recently, in last year’s SB 135 with sunsets at the end of 2024. Therefore, SB 92 simply continues to extend the use of remote technology for certain proceedings in state court for one more year.
2. Remote Proceedings in Criminal Cases
Prior to COVID-19, with the exception of appearances that could be waived, defendants in criminal cases generally appeared in person, with the option of remote appearances limited to in-custody defendants. The Emergency Rules generally allowed defendants and attorneys to appear remotely in proceedings with the consent of the defendant. Prior to the June 30, 2022, sunset of the Emergency Rules and through the budget process, discussions were had amongst interested parties to continue remote appearances in criminal cases. The Courts, Public Defenders, District Attorneys, Probation, Sheriffs, and various criminal justice groups were supportive of the final version of the legislation. The result was a continuation of remote proceedings with some changes to what had been in place during the Emergency Rules. The new provisions, which are currently in place, provide:
- Misdemeanors: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Felonies: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials and sentencing, unless the court allows a waiver for non-critical, non-testimonial portions of the trial. Remote proceedings are allowed for post-conviction relief proceedings. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Witnesses: may testify remotely except for felony trials, and only with the consent of both parties and the court.
- Court reporters: must be physically present in a courtroom when remote proceedings occur and cannot be retaliated against for reporting technology and audibility issues.
- Courts must have a process for participants to alert the court of audibility or technology issues before and during a proceeding and shall require a person to appear in person if the issues cannot resolved.
The statutes authorizing these remote appearances in criminal cases were extend to January 1, 2025 in the Budget last year when discussion about changes to the existing processes came to a halt with the understanding that they would continue this year. This bill will extend that sunset to January 1, 2026.
3. Some Concerns Raised by Opponents to Last Year’s Bill
While all parties seem to see some value in having remote appearances there are still some concerns. A few of them are:
- The current law and this bill require the court reporter to be present in “a courtroom” during the proceedings. Court reporters have raised concerns that they want to be not in any courtroom but in the courtroom with the judges so they can more accurately monitor how any issues with the technology and the judge will also be aware of the issues. Judicial Council has noted that, even pre-covid, there may be emergency situations where the court reporter can’t physically get to the courtroom—the most common example is a big snow storm in the Tahoe area. Speedy trial rights may not allow for continuances in this situation. The author may wish to consider amending the bill to provide that generally the court reporter should be with the judge but allow for extraordinary circumstances to create an exception.
- Court interpreters have similar concerns but they would like whenever possible to be with the person for whom they are interpreting.
- Court reporters would like some way to put on the record when they raise an objection to problems with the technology and the court orders the proceedings to continue.
- There is a question as to whether habeas and other post-conviction proceedings should fall under the same rules and criminal trials.
4. Diversion Courts
While the in general, in courts allowing remote proceedings it will be up to the defendant whether or not to appear remotely, should diversion courts have different policies? Should it be clear that a judge in a drug or mental health diversion court, for example, can order a defendant appear in person?
5. Unavailability of Court Reporters
With a shortage of court reporters, especially in some of the less populated counties, should there be come alternative way to keep a record so that a defendant’s right to a speedy trial is not infringed upon if there is no reporter available?
6. PPIC Report
In April 2023, the Public Policy Institute of California released a report on remote proceedings during COVID. Among the findings were the fact that conviction rates decreased and sentencing resulted in less prison sentences under remote hearing procedures during the pandemic. Specifically the reports key takeaways were:
This report chronicles how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the courts in 2020, describes policy responses, and assesses the impact of remote hearing policies on conviction and sentencing outcomes within six months of arrest.
- Pandemic conditions challenged the courts’ capacity to resolve cases. An estimated 55,000 criminal cases that would have completed within six months remained unresolved at the end of 2020.
- Courts acted swiftly to adapt to pandemic conditions. Three main strategies included modifying pretrial release to reduce jail populations, permitting remote hearings, and extending case timelines.
- Uneven adoption of policies, coupled with geographic differences in where people live, meant that Black and Latino defendants had greater potential than people of other races to experience pandemic policies.
- Remote hearing policies reinforced pandemic trends for lower conviction rates, but counteracted trends in sentencing. When remote hearing policies were in place, rates of conviction within six months of arrest fell, with outcomes for white, Latino, and Black people driving this result. Misdemeanor convictions were less likely to lead to jail and more likely to receive noncustodial sentences such as probation and money sanctions, mainly for white, Latino, and Black people. Felony convictions were less likely to result in prison and more likely to lead to jail, and outcomes for Black people dominated this result.
- Remote hearing policies contributed to racial differences in criminal case outcomes. Inequity in conviction and jail sentence rates narrowed between white and Latino defendants and between white and Black defendants. By contrast, racial inequity widened in the likelihood of being sentenced to money sanctions and probation.
Arguably, whether a criminal proceeding is conducted virtually or in person should not influence whether a person is convicted or how they are sentenced; yet remote hearing policies have affected both. Before Assembly Bill 199 expires, policymakers will need to determine whether these outcomes are desirable and how to factor them into decisions about whether to allow criminal cases to proceed remotely. (Harris, Heather, PPIC “Public Policymaking and Changed Outcomes in Criminal Courts, April 2023. https://www.ppic.org/publication/pandemic-policymaking-and-changed-outcomes-in-criminal-courts/)
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):