SB 938: Electrical and gas corporations: rate recovery: political activities and advertising.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-03-21
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-23: April 22 set for second hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 9. Noes 3. Page 3700.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory jurisdiction over public utilities, including electrical and gas corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix the rates and charges for public utilities and requires those rates and charges to be just and reasonable.
This bill would prohibit, except as provided, an electrical or gas corporation from recording various expenses associated with political influence activities, as defined, or with advertising, as defined, to accounts that contain expenses that the electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers. The bill would require an electrical or gas corporation to provide the commission with all information deemed necessary to monitor compliance with that prohibition. The bill also would require an electrical or gas corporation, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, to annually file with the commission a report containing specified information. The bill would require the commission to make the report publicly available.
The bill would require the commission to assess a civil penalty against an electrical or gas corporation that violates the prohibition described above, or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing the prohibition, as provided. The bill would require 3/4 of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the commission for a violation of the prohibition to be deposited into the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which the bill would establish in the State Treasury. The bill would authorize the moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances. The bill would require the balance of the moneys collected, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used by the commission to increase resources for enforcing the bills requirements.
Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because the above provisions would be part of the act and a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory jurisdiction over public utilities, including electrical and gas corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix the rates and charges for public utilities and requires those rates and charges to be just and reasonable.
This bill would prohibit, except as provided, an electrical or gas corporation from recording various expenses associated with political influence activities, as defined, or with advertising, as defined, to accounts that contain expenses that the electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers. The bill would require an electrical or gas corporation to provide the commission with all information deemed necessary to monitor compliance with that prohibition. The bill also would require an electrical or gas corporation, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, to annually file with the commission a report containing specified information. The bill would require the commission to make the report publicly available.
The bill would require the commission to assess a civil penalty against an electrical or gas corporation that violates the prohibition described above, or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing the prohibition, as provided. The bill would require 3/4 of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the commission for a violation of the prohibition to be deposited into the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which the bill would establish in the State Treasury. The bill would authorize the moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances. The bill would require the balance of the moneys collected, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used by the commission to increase resources for enforcing the bills requirements.
Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because the above provisions would be part of the act and a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares that it is the policy of the state to protect ratepayers from funding the political influence activities of public utilities.
SEC. 2.Section 748.3 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:748.3.(a)For purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Above-the-line account means an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers, including an account that contains expenses that the electrical or gas corporation used to calculate a revenue requirement request in its most recent general rate case.
(2)(A)Advertising has the same meaning as set forth described in subdivision (a) of Section 796 and public messages that tend primarily to build the public image of an electrical or gas corporation.
(B)Advertising does not include either of the following:
(i)Public messages that the electrical or gas corporation is directed to publish by a federal, state, or local agency.
(ii)Public messages providing information on safety measures, emergency conditions, or service interruptions.
(3)Below-the-line account means an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation does not recover from ratepayers.
(4)Expense includes a payment to an external entity, a cost incurred by a parent company or corporate affiliate and invoiced to an electrical or gas corporation, and the salary paid to an employee of an electrical or gas corporation.
(5)Political influence activity means any of the following:
(A)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing either of the following:
(i)The possible adoption of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(ii)The possible repeal or modification of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(B)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing elections or referenda, or appointments of public officials.
(C)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the approval, modification, or revocation of franchises of electrical or gas corporations.
(D)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing public opinion with respect to any of the following:
(i)Legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(ii)Elections.
(iii)Referenda.
(iv)Rate setting of the electrical or gas corporation.
(E)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the decisions of federal, state, or local government officials.
(6)Public official means a decisionmaker within an administrative agency or legislative body at the local, state, or federal level, and the staff that support the decisionmakers policy development.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), an electrical or gas corporation shall not do any of the following:
(1)Record an expense associated with political influence activities or advertising to an above-the-line account.
(2)Record to above-the-line accounts any salary, bonus, benefits, or other consideration of any value for any employee, if any portion of that salary, bonus, benefits, or other consideration of any value supports political influence activities or advertising.(3)(2)Record to above-the-line accounts the cost of an advertisement if any portion of the message is advertising.
(4)(3)Record to above-the-line accounts any expense associated with membership dues, sponsorships, or other contributions to an industry trade association, group, or related entity incorporated under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, if any portion of those contributions supports political influence activities or advertising. Fees for professional licenses necessary for employee job duties may be recorded to above-the-line accounts.
(c)Subdivision (1)Subject to paragraph (2), subdivision (b) does not prohibit an electrical or gas corporation from recovering from ratepayers either of the following costs: the costs of appearing before governmental bodies, if these appearances are directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations.
(1)(A)Subject to subparagraph (B), the costs of appearing before governmental bodies, when these appearances are directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations.(B)For purposes of subparagraph (A), costs that are not directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations include, but are not limited to, engagement with government entities on any of the following:(i)Except as provided in paragraph (2), actions, including, but not limited to, vehicle, appliance, or other equipment spending programs, incentives, or procurement requirements that would increase consumption of electricity or gas.(ii)Rules or policies related to emissions of greenhouse gases or criteria air pollutants.(iii)Appearances before regulatory bodies when the electrical or gas corporation is not the applicant or respondent in a proceeding, except in cases where the electrical or gas corporation has been specifically requested by the regulatory body to participate or the proceeding is directly related to rules or regulations regarding the safe operation of the electrical or gas system.(2)The costs of the commission-approved energy efficiency codes and standards programs or any other commission-approved public purpose program in which electrical or gas corporations advocate for more stringent greenhouse gas emissions, criteria air pollutants, or public health standards.(2)For purposes of paragraph (1), costs of appearances before regulatory or other governmental bodies are directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations if any of the following apply:
(A)The electrical or gas corporation is the applicant or respondent in the proceeding before the regulatory or other governmental body.
(B)The electrical or gas corporations appearance has been specifically requested by the regulatory or other governmental body.
(C)The electrical or gas corporations appearance directly relates to rules or regulations regarding the safe operation of the electrical or gas system.
(D)The electrical or gas corporations appearance is for Energy Commission-approved energy efficiency codes and programs or any other Energy Commission-approved public purpose program in which electrical or gas corporations advocate for more stringent greenhouse gas emissions, criteria air pollutants, or public health standards if their participation has not otherwise been prohibited by the commission.
(d)(1)An electrical or gas corporation shall clearly and conspicuously disclose in all of its public messaging and advertising whether the costs of the public messaging or advertising are being paid for by the corporations shareholders or ratepayers.
(2)A disclosure is not clear and conspicuous if the disclosure is difficult to hear or read, or if the placement of the disclosure is easily overlooked.
(e)(1)An electrical or gas corporation shall provide to the commission all information determined necessary by the commission to monitor compliance with subdivision (b), including real-time access to digital records for any above-the-line account. Moving an expense to a below-the-line account after it was booked to an above-the-line account does not protect that expense from being disclosed to the commission. disclosed.
(2)An electrical or gas corporation shall annually file with the commission, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, a report containing all of the following information:
(A)A list of each employee job title.
(B)A job description of each listed employee job title sufficient to describe the employees responsibilities.
(C)The total annual compensation provided to each employee with a listed employee job title.
(D)The Uniform System of Accounts codes to which the compensation is recorded.(D)The number of hours booked to an above-the-line account for each employee with a listed employee job title.
(E)The percent of total annual compensation booked to an above-the-line account for each employee with a listed job title.
(3)The commission shall make all reports filed with the commission pursuant to paragraph (2) publicly available.
(4)An electrical or gas corporation shall not recover through rates any costs associated with preparing the report filed with the commission pursuant to paragraph (2).
(f)(1)In addition to any refunds that the commission orders an electrical or gas corporation to pay ratepayers, the commission shall assess a civil penalty in accordance with paragraph (2) against an electrical or gas corporation that violates subdivision (b) or fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing subdivision (b).
(2)(A)An electrical or gas corporation that violates subdivision (b) or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing subdivision (b) is subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and not more than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation.
(B)Each expense improperly recorded to an above-the-line account in violation of subdivision (b) is a separate and distinct violation. Violations of subdivision (b) are continuing violations. Each day that an expense remains in an above-the-line account in violation of subdivision (b) shall be a separate and distinct violation.
(3)Pursuant to Section 748.1, an electrical or gas corporation shall not recover any penalty assessed pursuant to this subdivision from ratepayers.
(g)(1)(A)Notwithstanding Section 2104, three-fourths of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the commission for violations of subdivision (b) shall be deposited in into the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which is hereby established in the State Treasury.
(B)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund may be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances.
(2)One-fourth of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected for violations of subdivision (b) shall, upon appropriation by the Legislature, be used by the commission for purposes of increasing resources for the enforcement of this section.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares that it is the policy of the state to protect ratepayers from funding the political influence activities of public utilities.
SEC. 2.Section 748.3 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:748.3.(a)For purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Above-the-line account means an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers, including an account that contains expenses that the electrical or gas corporation used to calculate a revenue requirement request in its most recent general rate case.
(2)(A)Advertising has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 796 and public messages that tend primarily to build the public image of an electrical or gas corporation.
(B)Advertising does not include either of the following:
(i)Public messages that the electrical or gas corporation is directed to publish by a federal, state, or local agency.
(ii)Public messages providing information on safety measures, emergency conditions, or service interruptions.
(3)Below-the-line account means an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation does not recover from ratepayers.
(4)Expense includes a payment to an external entity, a cost incurred by a parent company or corporate affiliate and invoiced to an electrical or gas corporation, and the salary paid to an employee of an electrical or gas corporation.
(5)Political influence activity means any of the following:
(A)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing either of the following:
(i)The possible adoption of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(ii)The possible repeal or modification of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(B)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing elections or referenda, or appointments of public officials.
(C)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the approval, modification, or revocation of franchises of electrical or gas corporations.
(D)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing public opinion with respect to any of the following:
(i)Legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
(ii)Elections.
(iii)Referenda.
(iv)Rate setting of the electrical or gas corporation.
(E)An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the decisions of federal, state, or local government officials.
(6)Public official means a decisionmaker within an administrative agency or legislative body at the local, state, or federal level, and the staff that support the decisionmakers policy development.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), an electrical or gas corporation shall not do any of the following:
(1)Record an expense associated with political influence activities or advertising to an above-the-line account.
(2)Record to above-the-line accounts any salary, bonus, benefits, or other consideration of any value for any employee, if any portion of that salary, bonus, benefits, or other consideration of any value supports political influence activities or advertising.
(3)Record to above-the-line accounts the cost of an advertisement if any portion of the message is advertising.
(4)Record to above-the-line accounts any expense associated with membership dues, sponsorships, or other contributions to an industry trade association, group, or related entity incorporated under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, if any portion of those contributions supports political influence activities or advertising.
(c)Subdivision (b) does not prohibit an electrical or gas corporation from recovering from ratepayers either of the following costs:
(1)(A)Subject to subparagraph (B), the costs of appearing before governmental bodies, when these appearances are directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations.
(B)For purposes of subparagraph (A), costs that are not directly related to the electrical or gas corporations existing or proposed operations include, but are not limited to, engagement with government entities on any of the following:
(i)Except as provided in paragraph (2), actions, including, but not limited to, vehicle, appliance, or other equipment spending programs, incentives, or procurement requirements that would increase consumption of electricity or gas.
(ii)Rules or policies related to emissions of greenhouse gases or criteria air pollutants.
(iii)Appearances before regulatory bodies when the electrical or gas corporation is not the applicant or respondent in a proceeding, except in cases where the electrical or gas corporation has been specifically requested by the regulatory body to participate or the proceeding is directly related to rules or regulations regarding the safe operation of the electrical or gas system.
(2)The costs of the commission-approved energy efficiency codes and standards programs or any other commission-approved public purpose program in which electrical or gas corporations advocate for more stringent greenhouse gas emissions, criteria air pollutants, or public health standards.
(d)(1)An electrical or gas corporation shall clearly and conspicuously disclose in all of its public messaging and advertising whether the costs of the public messaging or advertising are being paid for by the corporations shareholders or ratepayers.
(2)A disclosure is not clear and conspicuous if the disclosure is difficult to hear or read, or if the placement of the disclosure is easily overlooked.
(e)(1)An electrical or gas corporation shall provide to the commission all information determined necessary by the commission to monitor compliance with subdivision (b), including real-time access to digital records for any above-the-line account. Moving an expense to a below-the-line account after it was booked to an above-the-line account does not protect that expense from being disclosed to the commission.
(2)An electrical or gas corporation shall annually file with the commission, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, a report containing all of the following information:
(A)A list of each employee job title.
(B)A job description of each listed employee job title sufficient to describe the employees responsibilities.
(C)The total annual compensation provided to each employee with a listed employee job title.
(D)The Uniform System of Accounts codes to which the compensation is recorded.
(3)The commission shall make all reports filed with the commission pursuant to paragraph (2) publicly available.
(4)An electrical or gas corporation shall not recover through rates any costs associated with preparing the report filed with the commission pursuant to paragraph (2).
(f)(1)In addition to any refunds that the commission orders an electrical or gas corporation to pay ratepayers, the commission shall assess a civil penalty in accordance with paragraph (2) against an electrical or gas corporation that violates subdivision (b) or fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing subdivision (b).
(2)(A)An electrical or gas corporation that violates subdivision (b) or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission related to implementing subdivision (b) is subject to a civil penalty of not less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and not more than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation.
(B)Each expense improperly recorded to an above-the-line account in violation of subdivision (b) is a separate and distinct violation. Violations of subdivision (b) are continuing violations. Each day that an expense remains in an above-the-line account in violation of subdivision (b) shall be a separate and distinct violation.
(3)Pursuant to Section 748.1, an electrical or gas corporation shall not recover any penalty assessed pursuant to this subdivision from ratepayers.
(g)(1)(A)Notwithstanding Section 2104, three-fourths of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the commission for violations of subdivision (b) shall be deposited in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which is hereby established in the State Treasury.
(B)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund may be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances.
(2)One-fourth of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected for violations of subdivision (b) shall, upon appropriation by the Legislature, be used by the commission for purposes of increasing resources for the enforcement of this section.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2024 | April 22 set for second hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 9. Noes 3. Page 3700.) |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | April 16 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 8. Noes 4. Page 3631.) Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Set for hearing April 16. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 17. |
| Jan 17, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 22, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Failed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | [First] hearing set for [04-16-2024]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350: Bay Area Action, Conejo, So Cal, San Diego, South Bay LA, Southland | ** Support | |
| Acterra: Action for A Healthy Planet | ** Support | |
| All Rise Alameda | ** Support | |
| An individual | ** Support | |
| Ballona Institute | ** Support | |
| Ban SUP | ** Support | |
| Building the Base Face to Face | ** Support | |
| California Alliance for Community Energy | ** Support | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Climate Voters | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Justice Alliance Action | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| Californians for Energy Choice | ** Support | |
| California Public Interest Research Group | ** Support | |
| California Solar & Storage Association | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Electrical Workers | ** Against | |
| California State Council Of Laborers | ** Support | |
| Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice | ** Support | |
| Central, San Jose, San Pedro, Santa Barbara, Santa Cruz County, Sausalito, | ** Support | |
| Central Valley Air Quality Coalition | ** Support | |
| Change Begins With Me | ** Support | |
| Clean Coalition | ** Support | |
| cleanearth4kids.org | ** Support | |
| Cloverdale, Colusa County, East Bay, East Valley, El Dorado Hills, Elmwood, | ** Support | |
| Coalition of California Utility Employees | ** Against | |
| Coastal Lands Action Network | ** Support | |
| Contra Costa Move On | ** Support | |
| Courageous Resistance | ** Support | |
| Custom Power Solar | ** Support | |
| Defend Ballona Wetlands | ** Support | |
| Democrats of Rossmoor | ** Support | |
| Earthjustice | ** Support | |
| East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice | ** Support | |
| El Cerrito Progressives | ** Support | |
| Euclid, Hillcrest, Indian Valley, Livermore, Lorin, Los Angeles, Manteca, | ** Support | |
| Evergreen Action | ** Support | |
| Extinction Rebellion | ** Support | |
| Feminists In Action Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Glendale Environmental Coalition | ** Support | |
| Hammond Climate Solutions | ** Support | |
| Hang Out Do Good | ** Support | |
| Indivisibles: 30/Keep Sherman Accountable, 36, 41, Alta-Pasadena, Auburn CA, | ** Support | |
| Institute Of Governmental Advocates | ** Against | |
| Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub | ** Support | |
| Local Clean Energy Alliance | ** Support | |
| Long Beach Alliance for Clean Energy | ** Support | |
| Long Beach Environmental Alliance | ** Support | |
| Marin, Media City Burbank, Mendocino, Normal Heights, North Oakland | ** Support | |
| mill valley community action network | ** Support | |
| Mountain Progressives | ** Support | |
| Nothing Rhymes With Orange | ** Support | |
| Orinda Progressive Action Alliance | ** Support | |
| our revolution, long beach | ** Support | |
| Pacific Gas And Electric Company | ** Against | |
| Progressive Democrats of America, California | ** Support | |
| Progressive Democrats Of Santa Monica Mountains | ** Support | |
| Récolte Energy | ** Support | |
| Resistance, North San Diego County, OC 46, OC 48, Orchard City, Petaluma, | ** Support | |
| Resisters Walnut Creek, Ross Valley, Sacramento, San Bernardino, San Diego | ** Support | |
| Riseup | ** Support | |
| Rooted in Resistance | ** Support | |
| San Diego Gas and Electric Company | ** Against | |
| San Joaquin Valley Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| San Jose Community Energy Advocates | ** Support | |
| San Lorenzo Valley Women’s Club Environmental Committee | ** Support | |
| San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action | ** Support | |
| Sonoma County Democratic Party | ** Support | |
| Southern California Edison | ** Against | |
| Southern California Gas Company | ** Against | |
| Sustainable Rossmoor | ** Support | |
| Sustainable Systems Research Foundation | ** Support | |
| The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County | ** Support | |
| The Climate Reality Project California | ** Support | |
| The Climate Reality Project, Silicon Valley | ** Support | |
| The Resistance Northridge | ** Support | |
| The Utility Reform Network | ** Support | |
| Together We Will Contra Costa | ** Support | |
| Union Of Concerned Scientists | ** Support | |
| Vallejo-Benicia, Ventura, Westside LA, Windsor, Yalla, and Yolo | ** Support | |
| Venice Resistance | ** Support | |
| Women's Alliance Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Women'S Energy Matters | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 4/22/2024
Author: | |||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
RECONSIDERATION—FOR VOTE ONLY
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill expands the types of activities an electrical or gas corporation is prohibited from recovering in rates by expanding the definitions of political activities and advertising, and requires specified reporting of related activities. The bill would also require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to assess specified civil penalties for any violations of the proposed prohibition and require ¾ of the monies to be deposited in a new Zero-Emission Equity Fund within the State Treasury.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes and vests the CPUC with regulatory jurisdiction over public utilities, including electrical and gas corporations. (Article XII of the California Constitution)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for public utilities and requires those rates and charges to be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Prohibits a public utility from including any bill for services or commodities furnished by any customer or subscriber any advertising or literature designed or intended (1) to promote the passage or defeat of a measure appearing on the ballot at an election, (2) promote or defeat of a candidate to any public office, (3) to promote or defeat the appointment of any person to any administrative or executive positions in government, or (4) to promote or defeat any change in legislation or regulations. (Public Utilities Code §453 (d))
- Provides the CPUC with general, broad authority to regulate every public utility in the state. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Prohibits an electrical or gas corporation, except for Golden State Energy, from recovering a fine or penalty through a rate approved by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code §748.1)
- Authorizes the CPUC to require a public utility to correct any rates, practices, equipment or behavior that is unjust, unreasonable, unsafe, improper, inadequate, or insufficient. (Public Utilities Code §761)
- Prohibits the CPUC from prescribing a system of accounts and form of accounts, records, and memoranda for corporations subject to the regulatory authority of the United States that is inconsistent with that established and updated by or under the authority of the United States. (Public Utilities Code §793)
- Requires the CPUC to disallow all expenses for advertising which encourage increased consumption in rates charged by electrical or gas corporations for the services or commodities furnished by the utility. Allows the CPUC to include in rates charges for services, expenses for advertising which encourage the more efficient operation of the electric, or gas plant, or for advertising which encourage the more efficient use of electricity or gas, or the conservation of energy or natural resources, or presents accurate information on the economical purchase, maintenance, or effective use of electrical or gas appliances and devices. (Public Utilities Code §796)
- Provides the CPUC authority to levy fines against regulated entities for violation of law. Generally prevents the CPUC from distributing, expending, or encumbering any moneys received by the CPUC as a result of any CPUC proceeding or judicial action until the CPUC has notified the Director of Finance and the Director of Finance provides notice to the chairpersons of the appropriate legislative budget subcommittees, except where statute expressly provides how the monies are to be paid or used. Requires penalties to be deposited in the State’s General Fund. (Public Utilities Code §2100 et seq.)
- As it relates to Community Choice Aggregator (CCA) programs, the CPUC has explicit authority over other matters they determine necessary or advisable to protect a ratepayer’s right to be free from forced speech or to implement portions of the of the federal Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 that establishes the federal standard that no electric utility may recover from any person other than the shareholders or other owners of the utility, any direct or indirect expenditure by the electric utility for promotional or political advertising. (16 U.S.C. Sec. §2623(b)(5)) (Public Utilities Codes §707(a)(5))
- Provides under the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act, that no electric utility may recover from any person other than the shareholders (or other owners) of the utility any direct or indirect expenditure by such utility for political advertising. This is defined to include advertising intended to influence public opinion with respect to legislative, administrative, or electoral matters, or with respect to any controversial issue of public importance. (16 U.S. Code §2623(b)(5))
This bill:
- Finds and declares it is the policy of the state to protect ratepayers from funding the political influence activities of public utilities.
- Defines “above-the-line account” as an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers, including an account that contains expenses that the electrical or gas corporation used to calculate a revenue requirement request in its most recent general rate case (GRC).
- Defines “advertising” as those actions described in Public Utilities Code §796, and public messages that tend primarily to build the public image of an electrical or gas corporation. Does not include public messages:
- the electrical or gas corporation is directed to publish by a federal, state, or local agency.
- providing information on safety measures, emergency conditions, or service interruptions.
- Defines “below-the-line account” as an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation does not recover from ratepayers.
- Provides that “expense” includes a payment to an external entity, a costs incurred by a parent company or corporate affiliate and invoiced to an electrical or gas corporation, and the salary paid to an employee of an electrical or gas corporation.
- Defines “political influence activity” as any of the following:
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing:
- The possible adoption of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
- The possible repeal or modification of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing elections or referenda, or appointments of public officials.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the approval, modification, or revocation of franchises of electrical or gas corporations.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing:
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing public opinion with respect to any of the following: legislation, elections, referenda, or rate setting of the electrical or gas corporation.
- An activity for the purposes of directly or indirectly influencing decisions of federal, state, or local government officials.
- Defines “public official” to mean a decisionmaker within an administrative agency or legislative body at the local, state, or federal level, and the staff that support the decisionmaker’s policy development.
- Prohibits, except as provided, an electrical or gas corporation from recording to accounts that contain expenses that the electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers various expenses associated with political influence activities, with advertising, or expenses associated with membership dues, sponsorships, or other contributions to an industry trade association or group. Provides that fees for professional licenses necessary for employee job duties may be recorded to accounts that contain expenses to be recovered from ratepayers.
- Requires an electrical or gas corporation, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, to annually file with the CPUC a report containing specified information, including the list of employee job titles, job description, total compensation, number of hours booked to an account for expenses, percent of total annual compensation. Requires the CPUC to make the report publicly available.
- Requires the CPUC to assess a civil penalty against an electrical or gas corporation that violates the prohibition described in this bill, or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the CPUC related to implementing the prohibition. Provides that the civil penalty is not less than $10,000 and not more than $100,000 for each violation.
- Requires three-quarters of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the CPUC for a violation of the prohibition to be deposited into the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which this bill would establish in the State Treasury.
- Authorizes the moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances.
- Requires the balance, one-quarter, of the moneys collected, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used by the CPUC to increase resources for enforcing this bill’s requirements.
Background
Cost recovery of expenses by investor-owned utilities (IOUs). CPUC-regulated utilities routinely submit requests for cost recovery related to their operations, including expanding their infrastructure, paying for operation expenses, etc. As required by statute in Public Utilities Code §451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for cost recovery that is deemed just and reasonable. Review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the principal purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator. Statutory authority also authorizes the CPUC to disallow expenses that are not deemed just and reasonable or prudent. The review of a utility’s expenses is largely, although not exclusively, conducted through the utility’s GRC. Most utilities regulated by the CPUC are required to undergo a GRC whereby the utility requests funding for distribution, generation and operation costs associated with their service. The GRCs are major regulatory proceedings and provide the CPUC an opportunity to perform an exhaustive examination of a utility’s operations and costs with input from all stakeholders. Usually performed every three (now four) years and conducted over roughly 18 months, the GRC allows the CPUC to conduct a broad and detailed review of a utility’s revenues, expenses, and investments in plant and equipment to establish an approved revenue requirement.
Statute disallows recovery of certain expenses. Statute prohibits IOUs from recovering from ratepayers certain expenses, including activities related to elections of candidates, legislation, bonuses paid to executives of the IOU under specified conditions, activities marketing against CCAs, as well as, any situation where the IOU has failed to sufficiently maintain records to enable the CPUC to completely evaluate any relevant issues related to the prudence of any expense relating to the planning, construction, or operation of the IOU’s plant. Under the requirements of the Federal Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 and subsequent state statute, IOUs are also prohibited from recovering from any person other than shareholders direct and indirect expenditures for promotional or political advertising. Additionally, IOUs must abide by CPUC orders.
FERC accounting and financial reporting. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) jurisdiction Account 426.4 of the Uniform System of Accounts (USofA) requires that utility shareholders pay for expenditures for the purpose of influencing public opinion or the decisions of public offices. FERC has established regulatory accounting and financial reporting requirements for its jurisdictional entities in the electric, natural gas, and oil pipeline industries. These requirements play a vital role in FERC’s strategy of setting just and reasonable cost-of-service rates. The foundation of the FERC’s accounting program is the USofA codified in the agency’s regulations. In addition, FERC issues accounting rulings relating to specific transactions and applications through orders and Chief Accountant guidance letters. This body of accounting regulations, orders, and guidance letters comprises the FERC’s accounting and financial reporting requirements which promote consistent, transparent, and decision-useful accounting information for the FERC and other stakeholders. These accounting and financial reporting requirements take into consideration the FERC’s ratemaking policies, past FERC actions, industry trends, and external factors (e.g., economic, environmental, and technological changes, and mandates from other regulatory bodies) that impact the industries under the agency’s jurisdiction. Electric Public Utilities & Licensees, Natural Gas, and Oil Pipeline companies within FERC jurisdiction are required to maintain their books and records in accordance with the USofA. The USofA provides basic account descriptions, instructions, and accounting definitions that are useful in understanding the information reported in the Annual Report.
Comments
Need for this bill. The supporters of this bill state Californians should only pay their utilities to provide them with safe and reliable service. They contend that alongside the costs to provide service, such as the costs of utility infrastructure, utilities have been including the costs of their political influence in customers’ bills. The supporters cite recent news reports and CPUC actions that identified utilities booking some costs to ratepayers that should have been booked to shareholders. These costs include those in relation to paying speakers and funding organizations to advocate against energy efficiency codes and standards, after a CPUC order prohibited the utility from doing so, and which subsequently resulted in the CPUC taking enforcement action.
Moreover, the supporters of this bill argue that California law needs to be strengthen to better define the expenses that utilities must charge their shareholders and are not recoverable from their customers. They suggest that this bill simply incorporates into state law the FERC USofA accounting and reporting requirements for electric and natural gas utilities, along with additional clarifications on their applicability, in order to stop utilities from continuing to attempt to charge political influence expenses to their customers. The supporters cite the continual need for intervenors in utility GRC proceedings to invest significant time and resources ensuring customers are protected from bearing these costs. Supporters cite various incidents where Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) used or attempted to use ratepayer funds to influence regulatory and local ordinances that supporters of this bill contend are not directly related to the safe operation of the system. Specifically, they list SoCalGas’ involvement in the development of air quality State Implementation Plans at the California Air Resources Board and South Coast Air Quality Management District’s Indirect Source Rule where the utility argued for policies to support the use of natural gas vehicles. As well as, the utility’s funding for legal expenses for the California Restaurant Association’s challenge of the City of Berkeley’s ban on natural gas hookups in new construction. Additionally, the supporters push to limit the ability of utilities to collect from ratepayers the memberships to trade associations where those associations are engaged in lobbying activity. They point to similar restrictions adopted by Colorado, New York, Connecticut, and Maine.
Definitions of political influence activity clarified and expanded. This bill attempts to clarify and expand the definitions of political influence activities that would not be recoverable from ratepayers to include: an activity to influence rate-setting by the utility; the portion of a utility employee’s salary/bonus/benefits that supports political influence activity; membership dues or other contributions to an industry trade association, group, or related entity incorporated under Section 501 of the IRS Code; costs directly related to appearing before governmental bodies to influence vehicle, appliance, or other equipment spending programs, incentives, or procurement requirements that would increase consumption of electricity or gas, or rules related to greenhouse gas emissions, or where the utility is not the applicant or respondent in a proceeding, or CPUC codes and standards/energy efficiency programs. This bill would require specified accounting and reporting of these activities, delineated as below-the-line activities.
Utilities argue that the proposals in this bill are too far reaching and could hurt customers. They argue that the limitations imposed by this bill go beyond those in the FERC USofA accounting and reporting and could conflict. They suggest that the current law already protects ratepayers from funding political influence, including advertising of a political nature. They, generally, point to the GRC proceedings as the venues where these issues should be appropriately resolved and where dozens of intervenors can review, along with the CPUC. They believe the limitations imposed by the bill, particularly those in relation to limiting participation in regulatory proceedings unless they are a respondent or have been requested to participate, limits the ability of the utility to represent ratepayer interests. They note the need to participate in FERC proceedings on behalf of their customers, as well as, other proceedings where they are not the respondent. San Diego Gas & Electric notes their involvement in proceedings related to San Onofre Nuclear Generation Station (SONGS) which is jointly-owned with Southern California Edison (SCE), but where expense are booked to SCE’s GRC.
CPUC General Order (GO) 77 requires specified annual reporting by IOUs. Specifically, GO-77 requires electric and gas IOUs annually report by May 31 list of officers and employees (with employee names are not disclosed in the public report) with the amount paid directly or indirectly to each employee and the proportion paid by ratepayers. The general order also requires electric and gas IOUs to each IOU to report by March 31 the total dues, donations, subscriptions, contributions, payments to attorneys. In this regard, much of the required reporting in SB 938 is required by GO-77. However, SB 938 requires specified accounting for these expenses and prohibits some that would otherwise be authorized, including those to fund associations where a portion of funds may contribute towards political influencing activities.
First Amendment Constitutional issues? In 2019 the Sierra Club alleged that an association, known as California for Balanced Energy Solutions (C4BES), which moved to obtain party status within a building decarbonization proceeding was actually funded by SoCalGas. Subsequently the Public Advocates Office (PAO) began investigating the allegation which culminated in efforts to compel discovery by the utility, including of contracts funded by shareholders. Ultimately, the CPUC sided with PAO and rejected the utility’s claim to First Amendment infringement on freedom of speech. SoCalGas then appealed to the court. The court sided with SoCalGas, Southern California Gas Co. v. Public Utilities Com. (2023) 87 Cal. App. 5th 324. SoCalGas was successful in its argument to the court that the Public Advocates Office’s inquiries were an infringement on the utility’s First Amendment rights. The decision distinguished between the statutory authority of PAO, as more narrow, to that of the CPUC, while also acknowledging that SoCalGas has shown that disclosure of contracts funded by shareholders would impact its First Amendment rights. Furthermore, the court was convinced that disclosure of such information could result in a chilling effect on SoCalGas’ ability to contract for services and that impact outweighs the interest to view the contracts paid by shareholders. However, it is unclear whether the courts would find a similar decision if the CPUC compels this information directly, as opposed to PAO, but a challenge by the utilities could be likely.
Need for amendments. The author and committee may wish to make amendments to:
- Preserve the ability of the CPUC to determine the appropriate penalty amount for violations in connection to the requirements proposed in this bill.
- Authorize a grace period that provides if an IOU adjusts the line-item the expense is booked to there would be no penalty of such an adjustment.
- Require that any moneys collected by fines and penalties are deposited into the state’s General Fund, consistent with other CPUC fines and penalties.
- Additional clarifying changes.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 562 (Santiago, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2019) required that any expense incurred by an IOU in assisting or deterring union organizing, as defined, is not recoverable either directly or indirectly in the utility’s rates and is required to be borne exclusively by the shareholders of the IOU.
AB 874 (Williams, 2013) would have prohibited any expense incurred by an IOU in assisting or deterring union organizing to be recoverable either directly or indirectly in the utility’s rates. The bill died in the Assembly.
SB 790 (Leno, Chapter 599, Statutes of 2012) revised and expanded the definition of CCA, requires the CPUC to initiate a Code of Conduct rulemaking, and allows CCAs to receive public purpose funds to administer energy efficiency programs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
Earthjustice, Co-sponsor
The Utility Reform Network, Co-sponsor
350: Bay Area Action, Conejo, SoCal, San Diego, South Bay LA, Southland
Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub
Acterra Action for A Healthy Planet
All Rise Alameda
Ballona Institute
Ban SUP
Building the Base Face to Face
California Alliance for Community Energy
California Climate Voters
California Environmental Justice Alliance Action
California Environmental Voters
California Solar & Storage Association
California State Council of Laborers
Californians for Energy Choice
California Public Interest Research Group
Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Change Begins With Me
Clean Coalition
CleanEarth 4Kids.org
Coastal Lands Action Network
Contra Costa MoveOn
Courageous Resistance
Custom Power Solar
Defend Ballona Wetlands
Democrats of Rossmoor
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
El Cerrito Progressives
Evergreen Action
Extinction Rebellion
Feminists in Action Los Angeles
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Hammond Climate Solutions
Hang Out Do Good
Indivisibles: 30/Keep Sherman Accountable, 36, 41, Alta-Pasadena, Auburn CA,
Beach Cities, CA-7, CA-39, CA-43, CA-45, CA: StateStrong, CA-25 Simi
Valley-Porter Ranch, California Green Team, Claremont/Inland Valley,
Cloverdale, Colusa County, East Bay, East Valley, El Dorado Hills, Elmwood,
Euclid, Hillcrest, Indian Valley, Livermore, Lorin, Los Angeles, Manteca,
Marin, Media City Burbank, Mendocino, Normal Heights, North Oakland
Resistance, North San Diego County, OC 46, OC 48, Orchard City, Petaluma,
Resisters Walnut Creek, Ross Valley, Sacramento, San Bernardino, San Diego
Central, San Jose, San Pedro, Santa Barbara, Santa Cruz County, Sausalito,
Sebastopol, SF, SF Peninsula and CA-14, SFV, Sherman Oaks, Sonoma
County, South Bay LA, Stanislaus, Suffragist, Tehama, TWW - Los Gatos,
Vallejo-Benicia, Ventura, Westside LA, Windsor, Yalla, and Yolo
Local Clean Energy Alliance
Long Beach Alliance for Clean Energy
Long Beach Environmental Alliance
Mill Valley Community Action Network
Mountain Progressives
Nothing Rhymes with Orange
Orinda Progressive Action Alliance
Our Revolution Long Beach
Progressive Democrats of America, California
Progressive Democrats of Santa Monica Mountains
Récolte Energy
RiseUp
Rooted in Resistance
San Joaquin Valley Democratic Club
San Jose Community Energy Advocates
San Lorenzo Valley Women’s Club Environmental Committee
San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Sonoma County Democratic Party
Sustainable Rossmoor
Sustainable Systems Research Foundation
The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County
The Climate Reality Project, California
The Climate Reality Project: Silicon Valley
The Resistance Northridge
Together We Will Contra Costa
Union of Concerned Scientists
Venice Resistance
Women's Energy Matters
Women's Alliance Los Angeles
Three Individuals
OPPOSITION:
California Chamber of Commerce
California State Association of Electrical Workers
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Institute of Governmental Advocates
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Southern California Edison
Southern California Gas Company
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, Earthjustice and TURN state utilities:
…have been lobbying against the state’s climate and clean air goals and improperly passing the costs of doing so onto their customers. SB 938 addresses these abuses by clearly defining the political and advertising activities which utility shareholders – and not ratepayers – are responsible for funding, creating strong transparency and penalty provisions to deter non-compliance, and prohibiting utilities from charging ratepayers for costly memberships to trade groups engaged in political influence activities.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Many of the organizations opposed to this bill state that SB 938’s provisions are not needed as the CPUC already has the ability to enforce and assess penalties for any violation of its order. Many of the utilities opposed also state that SB 938 is duplicative to existing FERC accounting guidance and CPUC oversight. They contend that the CPUC can, has, and does order modifications to update their guidelines. The opponents also raise concerns that this bill hurts ratepayers by prohibiting utilities from engaging in activities that increase consumption of electricity, even if those policies would help the state achieve its clean energy and greenhouse gas reduction goals.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 938 Hearing Date: 4/16/2024
Author: | Min | ||
Version: | 3/21/2024 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Electrical and gas corporations: rate recovery: political activities and advertising
DIGEST: This bill expands the types of activities an electrical or gas corporation is prohibited from recovering in rates by expanding the definitions of political activities and advertising, and requires specified reporting of related activities. The bill would also require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to assess specified civil penalties for any violations of the proposed prohibition and require ¾ of the monies to be deposited in a new Zero-Emission Equity Fund within the State Treasury.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes and vests the CPUC with regulatory jurisdiction over public utilities, including electrical and gas corporations. (Article XII of the California Constitution)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for public utilities and requires those rates and charges to be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Prohibits a public utility from including any bill for services or commodities furnished by any customer or subscriber any advertising or literature designed or intended (1) to promote the passage or defeat of a measure appearing on the ballot at an election, (2) promote or defeat of a candidate to any public office, (3) to promote or defeat the appointment of any person to any administrative or executive positions in government, or (4) to promote or defeat any change in legislation or regulations. (Public Utilities Code §453 (d))
- Provides the CPUC with general, broad authority to regulate every public utility in the state. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Prohibits an electrical or gas corporation, except for Golden State Energy, from recovering a fine or penalty through a rate approved by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code §748.1)
- Authorizes the CPUC to require a public utility to correct any rates, practices, equipment or behavior that is unjust, unreasonable, unsafe, improper, inadequate, or insufficient. (Public Utilities Code §761)
- Prohibits the CPUC from prescribing a system of accounts and form of accounts, records, and memoranda for corporations subject to the regulatory authority of the United States that is inconsistent with that established and updated by or under the authority of the United States. (Public Utilities Code §793)
- Requires the CPUC to disallow all expenses for advertising which encourage increased consumption in rates charged by electrical or gas corporations for the services or commodities furnished by the utility. Allows the CPUC to include in rates charges for services, expenses for advertising which encourage the more efficient operation of the electric, or gas plant, or for advertising which encourage the more efficient use of electricity or gas, or the conservation of energy or natural resources, or presents accurate information on the economical purchase, maintenance, or effective use of electrical or gas appliances and devices. (Public Utilities Code §796)
- Provides the CPUC authority to levy fines against regulated entities for violation of law. Generally prevents the CPUC from distributing, expending, or encumbering any moneys received by the CPUC as a result of any CPUC proceeding or judicial action until the CPUC has notified the Director of Finance and the Director of Finance provides notice to the chairpersons of the appropriate legislative budget subcommittees, except where statute expressly provides how the monies are to be paid or used. Requires penalties to be deposited in the State’s General Fund. (Public Utilities Code §2100 et seq.)
- As it relates to Community Choice Aggregator (CCA) programs, the CPUC has explicit authority over other matters they determine necessary or advisable to protect a ratepayer’s right to be free from forced speech or to implement portions of the of the federal Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 that establishes the federal standard that no electric utility may recover from any person other than the shareholders or other owners of the utility, any direct or indirect expenditure by the electric utility for promotional or political advertising. (16 U.S.C. Sec. §2623(b)(5)) (Public Utilities Codes §707(a)(5))
- Provides under the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act, that no electric utility may recover from any person other than the shareholders (or other owners) of the utility any direct or indirect expenditure by such utility for political advertising. This is defined to include advertising intended to influence public opinion with respect to legislative, administrative, or electoral matters, or with respect to any controversial issue of public importance. (16 U.S. Code §2623(b)(5))
This bill:
- Finds and declares it is the policy of the state to protect ratepayers from funding the political influence activities of public utilities.
- Defines “above-the-line account” as an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers, including an account that contains expenses that the electrical or gas corporation used to calculate a revenue requirement request in its most recent general rate case (GRC).
- Defines “advertising” as those actions described in Public Utilities Code §796, and public messages that tend primarily to build the public image of an electrical or gas corporation. Does not include public messages:
- the electrical or gas corporation is directed to publish by a federal, state, or local agency.
- providing information on safety measures, emergency conditions, or service interruptions.
- Defines “below-the-line account” as an account that contains expenses that an electrical or gas corporation does not recover from ratepayers.
- Provides that “expense” includes a payment to an external entity, a costs incurred by a parent company or corporate affiliate and invoiced to an electrical or gas corporation, and the salary paid to an employee of an electrical or gas corporation.
- Defines “political influence activity” as any of the following:
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing:
- The possible adoption of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
- The possible repeal or modification of federal, state, or local legislation, regulations, or ordinances.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing elections or referenda, or appointments of public officials.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing the approval, modification, or revocation of franchises of electrical or gas corporations.
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing:
- An activity for the purpose of directly or indirectly influencing public opinion with respect to any of the following: legislation, elections, referenda, or rate setting of the electrical or gas corporation.
- An activity for the purposes of directly or indirectly influencing decisions of federal, state, or local government officials.
- Defines “public official” to mean a decisionmaker within an administrative agency or legislative body at the local, state, or federal level, and the staff that support the decisionmaker’s policy development.
- Prohibits, except as provided, an electrical or gas corporation from recording to accounts that contain expenses that the electrical or gas corporation recovers from ratepayers various expenses associated with political influence activities, with advertising, or expenses associated with membership dues, sponsorships, or other contributions to an industry trade association or group. Provides that fees for professional licenses necessary for employee job duties may be recorded to accounts that contain expenses to be recovered from ratepayers.
- Requires an electrical or gas corporation, for each business unit of the corporation that performs work associated with political influence activities or advertising, to annually file with the CPUC a report containing specified information, including the list of employee job titles, job description, total compensation, number of hours booked to an account for expenses, percent of total annual compensation. Requires the CPUC to make the report publicly available.
- Requires the CPUC to assess a civil penalty against an electrical or gas corporation that violates the prohibition described in this bill, or that fails or neglects to comply with any part or provision of any order, decision, decree, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the CPUC related to implementing the prohibition. Provides that the civil penalty is not less than $10,000 and not more than $100,000 for each violation.
- Requires three-quarters of the moneys collected pursuant to any settlement or penalties collected by the CPUC for a violation of the prohibition to be deposited into the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, which this bill would establish in the State Treasury.
- Authorizes the moneys in the Zero-Emission Equity Fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be allocated for purposes of assisting low-income households in transitioning to zero-emission appliances to mitigate air quality and public health impacts of using combustion appliances.
- Requires the balance, one-quarter, of the moneys collected, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used by the CPUC to increase resources for enforcing this bill’s requirements.
Background
Cost recovery of expenses by investor-owned utilities (IOUs). CPUC-regulated utilities routinely submit requests for cost recovery related to their operations, including expanding their infrastructure, paying for operation expenses, etc. As required by statute in Public Utilities Code §451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for cost recovery that is deemed just and reasonable. Review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the principal purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator. Statutory authority also authorizes the CPUC to disallow expenses that are not deemed just and reasonable or prudent. The review of a utility’s expenses is largely, although not exclusively, conducted through the utility’s GRC. Most utilities regulated by the CPUC are required to undergo a GRC whereby the utility requests funding for distribution, generation and operation costs associated with their service. The GRCs are major regulatory proceedings and provide the CPUC an opportunity to perform an exhaustive examination of a utility’s operations and costs with input from all stakeholders. Usually performed every three (now four) years and conducted over roughly 18 months, the GRC allows the CPUC to conduct a broad and detailed review of a utility’s revenues, expenses, and investments in plant and equipment to establish an approved revenue requirement.
Statute disallows recovery of certain expenses. Statute prohibits IOUs from recovering from ratepayers certain expenses, including activities related to elections of candidates, legislation, bonuses paid to executives of the IOU under specified conditions, activities marketing against CCAs, as well as, any situation where the IOU has failed to sufficiently maintain records to enable the CPUC to completely evaluate any relevant issues related to the prudence of any expense relating to the planning, construction, or operation of the IOU’s plant. Under the requirements of the Federal Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 and subsequent state statute, IOUs are also prohibited from recovering from any person other than shareholders direct and indirect expenditures for promotional or political advertising. Additionally, IOUs must abide by CPUC orders.
FERC accounting and financial reporting. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) jurisdiction Account 426.4 of the Uniform System of Accounts (USofA) requires that utility shareholders pay for expenditures for the purpose of influencing public opinion or the decisions of public offices. FERC has established regulatory accounting and financial reporting requirements for its jurisdictional entities in the electric, natural gas, and oil pipeline industries. These requirements play a vital role in FERC’s strategy of setting just and reasonable cost-of-service rates. The foundation of the FERC’s accounting program is the USofA codified in the agency’s regulations. In addition, FERC issues accounting rulings relating to specific transactions and applications through orders and Chief Accountant guidance letters. This body of accounting regulations, orders, and guidance letters comprises the FERC’s accounting and financial reporting requirements which promote consistent, transparent, and decision-useful accounting information for the FERC and other stakeholders. These accounting and financial reporting requirements take into consideration the FERC’s ratemaking policies, past FERC actions, industry trends, and external factors (e.g., economic, environmental, and technological changes, and mandates from other regulatory bodies) that impact the industries under the agency’s jurisdiction. Electric Public Utilities & Licensees, Natural Gas, and Oil Pipeline companies within FERC jurisdiction are required to maintain their books and records in accordance with the USofA. The USofA provides basic account descriptions, instructions, and accounting definitions that are useful in understanding the information reported in the Annual Report.
Comments
Need for this bill. The supporters of this bill state Californians should only pay their utilities to provide them with safe and reliable service. They contend that alongside the costs to provide service, such as the costs of utility infrastructure, utilities have been including the costs of their political influence in customers’ bills. The supporters cite recent news reports and CPUC actions that identified utilities booking some costs to ratepayers that should have been booked to shareholders. These costs include those in relation to paying speakers and funding organizations to advocate against energy efficiency codes and standards, after a CPUC order prohibited the utility from doing so, and which subsequently resulted in the CPUC taking enforcement action.
Moreover, the supporters of this bill argue that California law needs to be strengthen to better define the expenses that utilities must charge their shareholders and are not recoverable from their customers. They suggest that this bill simply incorporates into state law the FERC USofA accounting and reporting requirements for electric and natural gas utilities, along with additional clarifications on their applicability, in order to stop utilities from continuing to attempt to charge political influence expenses to their customers. The supporters cite the continual need for intervenors in utility GRC proceedings to invest significant time and resources ensuring customers are protected from bearing these costs. Supporters cite various incidents where Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) used or attempted to use ratepayer funds to influence regulatory and local ordinances that supporters of this bill contend are not directly related to the safe operation of the system. Specifically, they list SoCalGas’ involvement in the development of air quality State Implementation Plans at the California Air Resources Board and South Coast Air Quality Management District’s Indirect Source Rule where the utility argued for policies to support the use of natural gas vehicles. As well as, the utility’s funding for legal expenses for the California Restaurant Association’s challenge of the City of Berkeley’s ban on natural gas hookups in new construction. Additionally, the supporters push to limit the ability of utilities to collect from ratepayers the memberships to trade associations where those associations are engaged in lobbying activity. They point to similar restrictions adopted by Colorado, New York, Connecticut, and Maine.
Definitions of political influence activity clarified and expanded. This bill attempts to clarify and expand the definitions of political influence activities that would not be recoverable from ratepayers to include: an activity to influence rate-setting by the utility; the portion of a utility employee’s salary/bonus/benefits that supports political influence activity; membership dues or other contributions to an industry trade association, group, or related entity incorporated under Section 501 of the IRS Code; costs directly related to appearing before governmental bodies to influence vehicle, appliance, or other equipment spending programs, incentives, or procurement requirements that would increase consumption of electricity or gas, or rules related to greenhouse gas emissions, or where the utility is not the applicant or respondent in a proceeding, or CPUC codes and standards/energy efficiency programs. This bill would require specified accounting and reporting of these activities, delineated as below-the-line activities.
Utilities argue that the proposals in this bill are too far reaching and could hurt customers. They argue that the limitations imposed by this bill go beyond those in the FERC USofA accounting and reporting and could conflict. They suggest that the current law already protects ratepayers from funding political influence, including advertising of a political nature. They, generally, point to the GRC proceedings as the venues where these issues should be appropriately resolved and where dozens of intervenors can review, along with the CPUC. They believe the limitations imposed by the bill, particularly those in relation to limiting participation in regulatory proceedings unless they are a respondent or have been requested to participate, limits the ability of the utility to represent ratepayer interests. They note the need to participate in FERC proceedings on behalf of their customers, as well as, other proceedings where they are not the respondent. San Diego Gas & Electric notes their involvement in proceedings related to San Onofre Nuclear Generation Station (SONGS) which is jointly-owned with Southern California Edison (SCE), but where expense are booked to SCE’s GRC.
CPUC General Order (GO) 77 requires specified annual reporting by IOUs. Specifically, GO-77 requires electric and gas IOUs annually report by May 31 list of officers and employees (with employee names are not disclosed in the public report) with the amount paid directly or indirectly to each employee and the proportion paid by ratepayers. The general order also requires electric and gas IOUs to each IOU to report by March 31 the total dues, donations, subscriptions, contributions, payments to attorneys. In this regard, much of the required reporting in SB 938 is required by GO-77. However, SB 938 requires specified accounting for these expenses and prohibits some that would otherwise be authorized, including those to fund associations where a portion of funds may contribute towards political influencing activities.
First Amendment Constitutional issues? In 2019 the Sierra Club alleged that an association, known as California for Balanced Energy Solutions (C4BES), which moved to obtain party status within a building decarbonization proceeding was actually funded by SoCalGas. Subsequently the Public Advocates Office (PAO) began investigating the allegation which culminated in efforts to compel discovery by the utility, including of contracts funded by shareholders. Ultimately, the CPUC sided with PAO and rejected the utility’s claim to First Amendment infringement on freedom of speech. SoCalGas then appealed to the court. The court sided with SoCalGas, Southern California Gas Co. v. Public Utilities Com. (2023) 87 Cal. App. 5th 324. SoCalGas was successful in its argument to the court that the Public Advocates Office’s inquiries were an infringement on the utility’s First Amendment rights. The decision distinguished between the statutory authority of PAO, as more narrow, to that of the CPUC, while also acknowledging that SoCalGas has shown that disclosure of contracts funded by shareholders would impact its First Amendment rights. Furthermore, the court was convinced that disclosure of such information could result in a chilling effect on SoCalGas’ ability to contract for services and that impact outweighs the interest to view the contracts paid by shareholders. However, it is unclear whether the courts would find a similar decision if the CPUC compels this information directly, as opposed to PAO, but a challenge by the utilities could be likely.
Need for amendments. The author and committee may wish to make amendments to:
- Preserve the ability of the CPUC to determine the appropriate penalty amount for violations in connection to the requirements proposed in this bill.
- Authorize a grace period that provides if an IOU adjusts the line-item the expense is booked to there would be no penalty of such an adjustment.
- Require that any moneys collected by fines and penalties are deposited into the state’s General Fund, consistent with other CPUC fines and penalties.
- Additional clarifying changes.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 562 (Santiago, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2019) required that any expense incurred by an IOU in assisting or deterring union organizing, as defined, is not recoverable either directly or indirectly in the utility’s rates and is required to be borne exclusively by the shareholders of the IOU.
AB 874 (Williams, 2013) would have prohibited any expense incurred by an IOU in assisting or deterring union organizing to be recoverable either directly or indirectly in the utility’s rates. The bill died in the Assembly.
SB 790 (Leno, Chapter 599, Statutes of 2012) revised and expanded the definition of CCA, requires the CPUC to initiate a Code of Conduct rulemaking, and allows CCAs to receive public purpose funds to administer energy efficiency programs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT:
Earthjustice, Co-sponsor
The Utility Reform Network, Co-sponsor
350: Bay Area Action, Conejo, So Cal, San Diego, South Bay LA, Southland
Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub
Acterra Action for A Healthy Planet
All Rise Alameda
Ballona Institute
Ban SUP
Building the Base Face to Face
California Alliance for Community Energy
California Climate Voters
California Environmental Justice Alliance Action
California Environmental Voters
California Solar & Storage Association
California State Council of Laborers
Californians for Energy Choice
California Public Interest Research Group
Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Change Begins With Me
Clean Coalition
CleanEarth4Kids.org
Coastal Lands Action Network
Contra Costa MoveOn
Courageous Resistance
Custom Power Solar
Defend Ballona Wetlands
Democrats of Rossmoor
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
El Cerrito Progressives
Evergreen Action
Extinction Rebellion
Feminists in Action Los Angeles
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Hammond Climate Solutions
Hang Out Do Good
Indivisibles: 30/Keep Sherman Accountable, 36, 41, Alta-Pasadena, Auburn CA,
Beach Cities, CA-7, CA-39, CA-43, CA-45, CA: StateStrong, CA-25 Simi
Valley-Porter Ranch, California Green Team, Claremont/Inland Valley,
Cloverdale, Colusa County, East Bay, East Valley, El Dorado Hills, Elmwood,
Euclid, Hillcrest, Indian Valley, Livermore, Lorin, Los Angeles, Manteca,
Marin, Media City Burbank, Mendocino, Normal Heights, North Oakland
Resistance, North San Diego County, OC 46, OC 48, Orchard City, Petaluma,
Resisters Walnut Creek, Ross Valley, Sacramento, San Bernardino, San Diego
Central, San Jose, San Pedro, Santa Barbara, Santa Cruz County, Sausalito,
Sebastopol, SF, SF Peninsula and CA-14, SFV, Sherman Oaks, Sonoma
County, South Bay LA, Stanislaus, Suffragist, Tehama, TWW-Los Gatos,
Vallejo-Benicia, Ventura, Westside LA, Windsor, Yalla, and Yolo
Local Clean Energy Alliance
Long Beach Alliance for Clean Energy
Long Beach Environmental Alliance
Mill Valley Community Action Network
Mountain Progressives
Nothing Rhymes with Orange
Orinda Progressive Action Alliance
Our Revolution Long Beach
Progressive Democrats of America, California
Progressive Democrats of Santa Monica Mountains
Récolte Energy
RiseUp
Rooted in Resistance
San Joaquin Valley Democratic Club
San Jose Community Energy Advocates
San Lorenzo Valley Women’s Club Environmental Committee
San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Sonoma County Democratic Party
Sustainable Rossmoor
Sustainable Systems Research Foundation
The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County
The Climate Reality Project: California Coalition
The Climate Reality Project: Silicon Valley
The Resistance Northridge
Together We Will Contra Costa
Union of Concerned Scientists
Venice Resistance
Women's Energy Matters
Women's Alliance Los Angeles
An Individual
OPPOSITION:
California Chamber of Commerce
California State Association of Electrical Workers
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Institute of Governmental Advocates
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Southern California Edison
Southern California Gas Company
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, Earthjustice and TURN state utilities:
…have been lobbying against the state’s climate and clean air goals and improperly passing the costs of doing so onto their customers. SB 938 addresses these abuses by clearly defining the political and advertising activities which utility shareholders – and not ratepayers – are responsible for funding, creating strong transparency and penalty provisions to deter non-compliance, and prohibiting utilities from charging ratepayers for costly memberships to trade groups engaged in political influence activities.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Many of the organizations opposed to this bill state that SB 938’s provisions are not needed as the CPUC already has the ability to enforce and assess penalties for any violation of its order. Many of the utilities opposed also state that SB 938 is duplicative to existing FERC accounting guidance and CPUC oversight. They contend that the CPUC can, has, and does order modifications to update their guidelines. The opponents also raise concerns that this bill hurts ratepayers by prohibiting utilities from engaging in activities that increase consumption of electricity, even if those policies would help the state achieve its clean energy and greenhouse gas reduction goals.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):