SB 94: Recall and resentencing: special circumstances.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-09-07
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-13: Ordered to third reading.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 25 years in custody. The bill would exempt individuals from relief under these provisions under certain circumstances, including if the individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer, as specified. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that dismissal of the special circumstance is not appropriate. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
The California Constitution, as amended by Proposition 9, the Victims Bill of Rights Act of 2008: Marsys Law, at the November 4, 2008, statewide general election, entitles the victim of a crime to specified rights, including to reasonable notice of all public proceedings, including all parole or other postconviction release proceedings.
The bill would clarify that these proceedings constitute a post-conviction release proceeding under Marsys Law.
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 25 years in custody. The bill would exempt individuals from relief under these provisions under certain circumstances, including if the individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer, as specified. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined. dismissal of the special circumstance is not appropriate. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
The California Constitution, as amended by Proposition 9, the Victims Bill of Rights Act of 2008: Marsys Law, at the November 4, 2008, statewide general election, entitles the victim of a crime to specified rights, including to reasonable notice of all public proceedings, including all parole or other postconviction release proceedings.
The bill would clarify that these proceedings constitute a post-conviction release proceeding under Marsys Law.
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 25 years in custody. The bill would exempt individuals from relief under these provisions under certain circumstances, including if the individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer, as specified. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
The California Constitution, as amended by Proposition 9, the Victims Bill of Rights Act of 2008: Marsys Law, at the November 4, 2008, statewide general election, entitles the victim of a crime to specified rights, including to reasonable notice of all public proceedings, including all parole or other postconviction release proceedings.
The bill would clarify that these proceedings constitute a post-conviction release proceeding under Marsys Law.
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual sentenced to death or serving a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 20 25 years in custody. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual sentenced to death or life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 20 years in custody. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
Existing law provides for various specified special circumstances, including murder committed for financial gain or committed during the commission or attempted commission of certain felonies, which, if found true as specified, require a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree to be sentenced to death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole. Existing law, added by Proposition 115 of the June 5, 1990, statewide primary election, prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance that is admitted by plea or found true by a jury or court, as specified. Existing law generally authorizes a court to dismiss an action or to strike or dismiss an enhancement in the furtherance of justice, except if dismissal of that enhancement is prohibited by any initiative statute.
This bill would authorize an individual sentenced to death or life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 20 years in custody. The bill would authorize the court to modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or to vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense, as specified. The bill would require a court to consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present. The bill would provide that proof of the presence of one or more specified mitigating circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing a special circumstance, unless the court finds that petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined. The bill would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel for an indigent petitioner.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole for offenses before June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1170.02 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1170.02.A prisoner is not eligible for resentence or recall pursuant to Section 1172.2 or 1172.5 if they were convicted of first-degree murder if the victim was a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.1, 830.2, 830.3, 830.31, 830.32, 830.33, 830.34, 830.35, 830.36, 830.37, 830.4, 830.5, 830.6, 830.10, 830.11, or 830.12, who was killed while engaged in the performance of their duties, and the individual knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties, or the victim was a peace officer or a former peace officer under any of the above-enumerated sections, and was intentionally killed in retaliation for the performance of their official duties.
SEC. 3.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
(b)An individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing pursuant to this section if any of the following circumstances apply:
(1)Recall and resentencing relief is prohibited by Section 1170.02.
(2)The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people.
(3)The individual was convicted of a sexual offense committed in conjunction with the homicide for which the petitioner is serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole. As used in this paragraph, sexual offense means a violation of Section 261, 286, 288, 289, or former Section 262 or 288a.(3)The individual was convicted of a sexual offense that requires registration pursuant to Section 290, or the facts of the offense for which the petitioner is serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole as reflected in the jury verdict or admitted by the individual involved the commission of a sexual offense that would require registration pursuant to Section 290.
(c)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(d)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(e)A resentencing hearing ordered under this section constitutes a post-conviction release proceeding under paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution (Marsys Law). Consistent with Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution, the prosecutor shall provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court shall provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim. As used in this subdivision, victim means the same as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall only result in a minimum sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 3040) of Chapter 8 of Title 1 of Part 3. 3, and shall not result in a sentence greater than the initial sentence.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(g)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act of 2020).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court, in its discretion, finds in the interest of justice that dismissing the special circumstance is not appropriate.
(h)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(i)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(j)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions pursuant to this section may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(k)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole for offenses before June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1170.02 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1170.02.A prisoner is not eligible for resentence or recall pursuant to Section 1172.2 or 1172.5 if they were convicted of first-degree murder if the victim was a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.1, 830.2, 830.3, 830.31, 830.32, 830.33, 830.34, 830.35, 830.36, 830.37, 830.4, 830.5, 830.6, 830.10, 830.11, or 830.12, who was killed while engaged in the performance of their duties, and the individual knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties, or the victim was a peace officer or a former peace officer under any of the above-enumerated sections, and was intentionally killed in retaliation for the performance of their official duties.
SEC. 3.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
(b)An individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing pursuant to this section if any of the following circumstances apply:
(1)Recall and resentencing relief is prohibited by Section 1170.02.
(2)The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people.
(3)The individual was convicted of a sexual offense committed in conjunction with the homicide for which the petitioner is serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole. As used in this paragraph, sexual offense means a violation of Section 261, 286, 288, 289, or former Section 262 or 288a.
(c)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(d)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(e)A resentencing hearing ordered under this section constitutes a post-conviction release proceeding under paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution (Marsys Law). Consistent with Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution, the prosecutor shall provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court shall provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim. As used in this subdivision, victim means the same as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 3040) of Chapter 8 of Title 1 of Part 3.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(g)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act of 2020).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1170.18. court, in its discretion, finds in the interest of justice that dismissing the special circumstance is not appropriate.
(h)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(i)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(j)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions pursuant to this section may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(k)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole for offenses before June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1170.02 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1170.02.A prisoner is not eligible for resentence or recall pursuant to Section 1172.2 or 1172.5 if they were convicted of first-degree murder if the victim was a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.1, 830.2, 830.3, 830.31, 830.32, 830.33, 830.34, 830.35, 830.36, 830.37, 830.4, 830.5, 830.6, 830.10, 830.11, or 830.12, who was killed while engaged in the performance of their duties, and the individual knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties, or the victim was a peace officer or a former peace officer under any of the above-enumerated sections, and was intentionally killed in retaliation for the performance of their official duties.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
(b)An individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing pursuant to this section if any of the following circumstances apply:
(1)Recall and resentencing relief is prohibited by Section 1170.02.
(2)The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people.
(3)The individual was convicted of a sexual offense committed in conjunction with the homicide for which the petitioner is serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole. As used in this paragraph, sexual offense means a violation of Section 261, 286, 288, 289, or former Section 262 or 288a.
(b)(c)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(c)(d)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(e)A resentencing hearing ordered under this section constitutes a post-conviction release proceeding under paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution (Marsys Law). Consistent with Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution, the prosecutor shall provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court shall provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim. As used in this subdivision, victim means the same as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(d)(f)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 3040) of Chapter 8 of Title 1 of Part 3.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(e)(g)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act of 2020).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1170.18.
(f)(h)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(g)(i)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(h)(j)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions pursuant to this section may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(i)(k)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole or death do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole or death for offenses before June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual who has been sentenced to death or serving a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 20 25 years in custody.
(b)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(c)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(d)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall not result in the imposition of a term longer than the original sentence. only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 3040) of Chapter 8 of Title 1 of Part 3.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(e)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act). Act of 2020).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1170.18.
(f)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(g)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(h)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, a subsequent petition two subsequent petitions pursuant to this section may be filed if at least two three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(i)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole or death do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole or death for offenses prior to before June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 20 years in custody.
(b)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(c)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(d)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall not result in the imposition of a term longer than the original sentence.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(e)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1170.18.
(f)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(g)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(h)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, a subsequent petition pursuant to this section may be filed if at least two years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(i)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has enacted numerous reforms to require judges to consider mitigating factors in sentencing, including: whether the individual to be sentenced is or was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence (AB 124 enacted in 2021); whether the individual was young, meaning under 26 years of age, at the time of the offense (AB 124 enacted in 2021, SB 260 enacted in 2013, SB 261 enacted in 2015); whether the individual was a veteran and the conduct was related to trauma experienced in the military (AB 2098 enacted in 2014, AB 865 enacted in 2018, SB 1209 enacted in 2022); whether the individual suffers from cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness (AB 2512 enacted in 2020, SB 215 enacted in 2018); and whether there was racial bias in the proceedings (AB 2542 enacted in 2021, AB 256 enacted in 2022).
(b)In the last 10 years, the Legislature has also enacted reforms recognizing that individuals are capable of redemption and requiring judges, when reviewing previously imposed sentences, to consider changed circumstances such as an individuals rehabilitation while in custody, that the passage of time may significantly change the relevance of factors previously considered in sentencing, and that other changed circumstances may mean that an originally imposed sentence is no longer in the interest of justice (AB 1812 enacted in 2018, AB 2942 enacted in 2018, AB 1540 enacted in 2021, AB 960 enacted in 2022).
(c)It is necessary to correct sentences that would not be imposed today because of legal reforms enacted since an individuals conviction. Judges should have the opportunity to take a second look at these sentences in light of evolving standards of decency and reforms that mandate the consideration of mitigating factors at sentencing such as youth, childhood trauma, victimization, race, military service and mental illness, and in light of changed circumstances, including an individuals rehabilitation.
(d)While individuals sentenced to parole-eligible sentences have an opportunity for some of these mitigating factors and changed circumstances to be considered in the parole process, individuals sentenced to life without parole or death do not.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that judges be given an opportunity to review sentences of life without parole or death for offenses prior to June 5, 1990, to exercise their discretion in sentencing, considering mitigating factors and changed circumstances as now required in sentencing.
SEC. 2.Section 1172.5 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1172.5.(a)An individual who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more of the special circumstances enumerated in Section 190.2 has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
(1)The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
(2)The individual has served at least 20 years in custody.
(b)(1)The petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition. The petition shall include all of the following:
(A)A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief pursuant to subdivision (a).
(B)The superior court case number and date of the petitioners offense and conviction.
(C)Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
(2)If any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(c)The court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements set forth in subdivision (a). If the subject of the petition does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual. If counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
(d)(1)Within 60 days after the reply is filed, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
(2)The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
(A)May modify the petitioners sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
(B)May vacate the petitioners conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
(3)The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
(4)A petitioner who is resentenced pursuant to this section shall be given credit for time served.
(5)Resentencing under this subdivision shall not result in the imposition of a term longer than the original sentence.
(6)The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
(e)(1)In considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
(A)The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
(B)The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
(C)The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
(D)The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
(E)The petitioner was a youth, as defined under subdivision (b) of Section 1016.7 at the time of offense.
(F)The sentence violates Section 745 (the California Racial Justice Act).
(G)The petitioners age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioners risk for future violence.
(2)Proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1170.18.
(f)The court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
(g)This section does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
(h)If the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, a subsequent petition pursuant to this section may be filed if at least two years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
(i)The petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 13, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 13, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Aug 12, 2024 | Notice of intention to remove from inactive file given by Assembly Member Kalra. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Kalra. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Read third time and amended. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 5.) (September 1). |
| Aug 16, 2023 | August 16 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 28, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 25, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 24, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 22. Noes 12. Page 1263.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1160.) (May 18). |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | April 24 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 14, 2023 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 658.) (April 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Set for hearing April 11. |
| Jan 25, 2023 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Jan 19, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 18. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 24, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB94 Cortese et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 8th Amendment Project | ** Support | |
| Aclu California Action | ** Support | |
| Alliance for Boys and Men of Color | ** Support | |
| American Friends Service Committee | ** Support | |
| Amnesty International USA | ** Support | |
| A New Way of Life Reentry Project | ** Support | |
| Anti-Recidivism Coalition | ** Support | |
| Arcadia Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Asian Americans Advancing Justice Southern California | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific Islander Re-entry and Inclusion Through Support and Empowerment | ** Support | |
| Asian Prisoner Support Committee | ** Support | |
| Bend the Arc California | ** Support | |
| Bend the Arc: Jewish Action California | ** Support | |
| Bend the Arc San Luis Obispo | ** Support | |
| Black Women Organized for Political Action | ** Support | |
| Blameless and Forever Free Ministries | ** Support | |
| Burbank Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Highway Patrolmen | ** Against | |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | ** Support | |
| California Calls | ** Support | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Coalition for Women Prisoners | ** Support | |
| California Coalition of School Safety Professionals | ** Against | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Against | |
| California Families Against Solitary Confinement | ** Support | |
| California Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| California Immigrant Policy Center | ** Support | |
| California Native Vote Project | ** Support | |
| Californians for Safety and Justice | ** Support | |
| Californians United for a Responsible Budget | ** Support | |
| California Police Chiefs Association | ** Against | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Support | |
| California Reserve Peace Officers Association | ** Against | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Against | |
| Center for Employment Opportunities | ** Support | |
| Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice | ** Support | |
| City of Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao | ** Support | |
| CLAREMONT POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice | ** Support | |
| Community Agency For Resources Advocacy And Services | ** Support | |
| Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto | ** Support | |
| Corona Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Courage California | ** Support | |
| Crime Victims United | ** Against | |
| Culver City Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Cure California | ** Support | |
| Death Penalty Focus | ** Support | |
| Decarcerate Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Democrats of Rossmoor | ** Support | |
| Deputy Sheriffs Association of Monterey County | ** Against | |
| Drop Lwop Coalition | ** Support | |
| Drug Policy Alliance | ** Support | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Support | |
| Empowering Pacific Islander Communities Fiscally Sponsored by Community Partners | ** Support | |
| Empowering Women Impacted by Incarceration | ** Support | |
| End Solitary Santa Cruz County | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| Fair Chance Project | ** Support | |
| Faith in Action, East Bay | ** Support | |
| Families Against Mandatory Minimums Foundation | ** Support | |
| Felony Murder Elimination Project | ** Support | |
| Foundation Aussergewöhnlich Berlin | ** Support | |
| Friends Committee On Legislation Of California | ** Support | |
| F.u.e.l.- Families United to End Lwop | ** Support | |
| Fullerton Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Ground Game LA | ** Support | |
| Group 137 of Amnesty International | ** Support | |
| Holy Cross Lutheran Church, Livermore, CA | ** Support | |
| Housing and Economic Rights Advocates | ** Support | |
| Human Rights Watch | ** Support | |
| If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| Immigrant Legal Resource Center | ** Support | |
| Individual | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Ca Statestrong | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Indivisible San Francisco | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Yolo | ** Support | |
| Inglewood Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Support | |
| Inland Equity Partnership | ** Support | |
| Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity | ** Support | |
| Islamic Shura Council of Southern California | ** Support | |
| John Burton Advocates for Youth | ** Support | |
| Justice2jobs Coalition | ** Support | |
| LA Defensa | ** Support | |
| LatinoJustice PRLDEF | ** Support | |
| Law Enforcement Action Partnership | ** Support | |
| Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area | ** Support | |
| League Of Women Voters Of California | ** Support | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Support | |
| Long Beach Immigrant Rights Coalition | ** Support | |
| los angeles school police officers association | ** Against | |
| milpa | ** Support | |
| Monterey County District Attorney's Office | ** Against | |
| Monterey County District Attorney's Office - ODA - Salinas, CA | ** Against | |
| Murrieta Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| NARAL Pro-Choice California | ** Support | |
| National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter | ** Support | |
| National Center for Lesbian Rights | ** Support | |
| National Harm Reduction Coalition | ** Support | |
| Newport Beach Police Association | ** Against | |
| North Bay Jobs with Justice | ** Support | |
| Novato Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Orange County District Attorney | ** Against | |
| Palos Verdes Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Peace Officers Research Association Of California | ** Against | |
| Peninsula Multifaith Coalition | ** Support | |
| PLACER COUNTY DEPUTY SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Pomona Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Prosecutors Alliance California | ** Support | |
| Restore Oakland, Inc. | ** Support | |
| RIVERSIDE POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Against | |
| Root & Rebound | ** Support | |
| Safe Return Project | ** Support | |
| San Diegans Against Crime | ** Against | |
| San Diego County District Attorney's Office | ** Against | |
| San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Support | |
| Santa Ana Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos INC. | ** Support | |
| Secure Justice | ** Support | |
| Showing Up for Racial Justice At Sacred Heart in San Jose | ** Support | |
| Showing Up For Racial Justice - Bay Area | ** Support | |
| Showing Up for Racial Justice Santa Cruz County | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley De-Bug | ** Support | |
| Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition | ** Support | |
| Smart Justice California | ** Support | |
| Social Change | ** Support | |
| South Asian Network | ** Support | |
| Starting Over, Inc. | ** Support | |
| SURJ Marin - Showing Up for Racial Justice | ** Support | |
| Survived & Punished | ** Support | |
| TechEquity Collaborative | ** Support | |
| The Place4grace | ** Support | |
| The Resistance Northridge-indivisible | ** Support | |
| the san diego lgbt community center | ** Support | |
| The Transformative In-prison Workgroup | ** Support | |
| Together We Will/Indivisible - Los Gatos | ** Support | |
| Unapologetically Hers | ** Support | |
| Uncommon Law | ** Support | |
| Underground Grit | ** Support | |
| Underground Scholars Initiative At the University of California, Irvine | ** Support | |
| United Core Alliance | ** Support | |
| Universidad Popular | ** Support | |
| Upland Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Urban Peace Movement | ** Support | |
| Voices for Progress | ** Support | |
| Vt CitizenS United for The Rehabilitation of Errant | ** Support | |
| White People 4 Black Lives | ** Support | |
| Witness to Innocence | ** Support | |
| Women'S Foundation California | ** Support | |
| Young Women's Freedom Center | ** Support |
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 94
Author:(Cortese)
As Amended Ver:September 7, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Creates a process for a person who has been sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) before June 5, 1990, and has served at least 25 years in custody, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
Major Provisions
- Provides that, except as specified, an individual serving LWOP for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990; and,
- The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
- Specifies that an individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing if any of the following circumstances apply:
- The individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer engaged in performance of their duties or of a peace officer or former peace officer in retaliation for the performance of their official duties;
- The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people; or
- The individual was convicted of a registerable sex offense, or the facts of the offense for which the petitioner is serving a sentence of LWOP as reflected in the jury verdict or admitted by the individual involved the commission of a registerable sex offense.
- Requires the petition to be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition.
- Requires the petition to include all of the following:
- A declaration by the petitioner that they are eligible for relief;
- The superior court case number and date of the petitioner's offense and conviction; and,
- Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
- Requires the court to review the petition and determine if it alleges the eligibility elements. Allows the court to deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition if any of the required information is missing and cannot be readily ascertained and to advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
- Requires the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual, if the petitioner does not have counsel and is indigent.
- Provides that if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
- Requires the court to hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner within 60 days after the reply is filed. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
- Allows the resentencing court, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, to do the following:
- Modify the petitioner's sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion; or
- Vacate the petitioner's conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Allows the parties to waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
- Provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served.
- States that resentencing shall result in a minimum sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings, as specified.
- Prohibits a greater sentence than that initially imposed on resentencing.
- Requires the court to state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
- Provides that in considering a petition, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
- The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking;
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence;
- The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military;
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness;
- The petitioner was under 26 years of age at the time of offense;
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act; or,
- The petitioner's age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner's risk for future violence.
- Provides that proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court, in its discretion, finds in the interests of justice that dismissing the special circumstance is not appropriate.
- Requires the court to consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
- States that this process does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
- Allows the petitioner to appear remotely, and the court to conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
- States that a resentencing hearing constitutes a "post-conviction release proceeding" under Marsy's Law and consistent with that law requires the prosecutor to provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court to provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim.
- Makes findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
According to the Author
"The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)'s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent. Based on CDCR data, an analysis from the Special Circumstances Conviction Project of UCLA Center for the Study of Women, estimates that this reform might qualify 600 LWOP cases for review. These cases represent a very narrow population that consists of the most elderly individuals behind bars. Many of these individuals have shown decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. This bill does not automatically let anyone out of prison. It does not guarantee resentencing. This bill simply creates a process for the judicial review of cases that have not been looked at in decades."
Arguments in Support
According to Ella Baker Center for Human Rights, a co-sponsor of this bill, "There are people languishing in state prisons that if they were in court today, would receive a more just sentence. In the last ten years, the Legislature has enacted several reforms to restore judicial discretion and to allow judges to consider mitigating factors at sentencing, including whether the person was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking or had experienced childhood trauma, exploitation or sexual abuse.
"Although individuals sentenced to LWOP have no path to parole today, many have exhibited decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming, have come to understand the contributing factors which led to their incarceration, and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's risk assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole in California who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent.
"This bill does not guarantee resentencing or release. Any individual who is granted resentencing by a judge will then need to go before the parole board, who will make a determination about their suitability for release.
"This bill allows courts to consider old cases in light of changes in law, thereby applying the law more fairly. This will mean that individuals that deserve a second chance won't have to die behind bars. For these reasons, the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights supports SB 94 and urges the legislature to pass this important bill."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association, "By enacting Proposition 115, the voters of this state have told us they want to keep the worst of the worst in prison where they belong. If they feel differently, Penal Code section 1385.1 should be amended by them in a future initiative or legislatively referred ballot proposition. Dragging these murderers back into court will be prohibitively expensive, tie up judicial resources, and inflict further pain upon their victims. By creating presumptions favoring the release of these murderers, SB 94 will create unjustifiable risks to public safety.
"We strongly urge you to consider the unintended consequences to the families of victims and the public who potentially will lose faith in the judicial process and the finality of judgments."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing costs (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) of an unknown but potentially significant amount to the courts to adjudicate petitions authorized by this bill. The author's office estimates that approximately 550 people would be eligible to file petitions for recall and resentencing authorized by this bill. If an initial petition is denied, the bill permits the petitioner to file two subsequent petitions after a specified waiting period. It generally costs approximately $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. If 225 petitions are filed and each takes one hour to adjudicate, the resulting workload costs to the court would be about $225,000. Actual costs will depend on the number of petitions filed and the amount of court time required to handle each petition. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The 2023-24 budget includes $105 million from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
- Potential staffing costs (General Fund) to the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD), possibly in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to represent people serving LWOP who file petitions for resentencing. Because only people who have served 25 years in custody are eligible to file a petition, all or nearly all eligible petitioners will be indigent and qualify for legal representation appointed by the court. Some of this workload may be handled by county public defender offices, but OSPD may require additional staffing to handle its appointments.
- Costs (General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ), potentially in the hundreds of thousands to low millions of dollars annually, to litigate appeals from petitions for recall and resentencing that are denied. DOJ estimates needing additional staff to handle these appeals, which would each take approximately 40 attorney hours to resolve. DOJ anticipates this workload would begin in fiscal year 2024-25 and continue for five years. Actual workload costs to DOJ will depend on the number of petitions denied, the number of appeals filed, and the amount of time needed to litigate each appeal.
- Potentially significant savings (General Fund) to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) in reduced incarceration costs. According to a 2022 estimate by the Legislative Analyst's Office, the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in state prison is $106,000. People eligible for resentencing under this bill are sentenced to LWOP; without resentencing, they will likely remain in prison until they die. Incarceration costs for elderly and infirm inmates tend to be higher than incarceration costs for other inmates. To the extent this bill ultimately results in release of incarcerated people on parole, rather than continued incarceration for the rest of their lives, CDCR will experience significant cost savings, potentially in the millions to tens of millions of dollars. Actual savings will depend on the number of petitions granted and the amount of time each petitioner would have spent in prison if not for their resentencing. If two people are released on parole rather than spending 15 additional years in prison, the resulting savings to CDCR would be approximately $3.2 million.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 22-12-6
YES: Allen, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Padilla, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Dahle, Dodd, Glazer, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Eggman, Min, Portantino, Roth, Umberg
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 6-2-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Bonta, Bryan, Ortega, Santiago, Jackson
NO: Alanis, Lackey
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-5-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez, Soria
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon
UPDATED
VERSION: September 7, 2023
CONSULTANT: Cheryl Anderson / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001883
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 94
Author:(Cortese)
As Amended Ver:September 1, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Creates a process for a person who has been sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) before June 5, 1990, and has served at least 25 years in custody, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
Major Provisions
- Provides that, except as specified, an individual serving LWOP for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990; and,
- The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
- Specifies that an individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing if any of the following circumstances apply:
- The individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer engaged in performance of their duties or of a peace officer or former peace officer in retaliation for the performance of their official duties;
- The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people; or
- The individual was convicted of a sexual offense committed in conjunction with the homicide for which the petitioner is serving an LWOP sentence. Defines "sexual offense" as rape, sodomy, lewd and lascivious acts on a child under 14 years of age, rape by instrument; and oral copulation.
- Requires the petition to be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition.
- Requires the petition to include all of the following:
- A declaration by the petitioner that they are eligible for relief;
- The superior court case number and date of the petitioner's offense and conviction; and,
- Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
- Requires the court to review the petition and determine if it alleges the eligibility elements. Allows the court to deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition if any of the required information is missing and cannot be readily ascertained and to advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
- Requires the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual, if the petitioner does not have counsel and is indigent.
- Provides that if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
- Requires the court to hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner within 60 days after the reply is filed. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
- Allows the resentencing court, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, to do the following:
- Modify the petitioner's sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion; or
- Vacate the petitioner's conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Allows the parties to waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
- Provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served.
- States that resentencing shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings, as specified.
- Requires the court to state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
- Provides that in considering a petition, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
- The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking;
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence;
- The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military;
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness;
- The petitioner was under 26 years of age at the time of offense;
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act; or,
- The petitioner's age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner's risk for future violence.
- Provides that proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court, in its discretion, finds in the interests of justice that dismissing the special circumstance is not appropriate.
- Requires the court to consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
- States that this process does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
- Allows the petitioner to appear remotely, and the court to conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
- States that a resentencing hearing constitutes a "post-conviction release proceeding" under Marsy's Law and consistent with that law requires the prosecutor to provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court to provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim.
- Makes findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
According to the Author
"The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)'s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent. Based on CDCR data, an analysis from the Special Circumstances Conviction Project of UCLA Center for the Study of Women, estimates that this reform might qualify 600 LWOP cases for review. These cases represent a very narrow population that consists of the most elderly individuals behind bars. Many of these individuals have shown decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. This bill does not automatically let anyone out of prison. It does not guarantee resentencing. This bill simply creates a process for the judicial review of cases that have not been looked at in decades."
Arguments in Support
According to Ella Baker Center for Human Rights, a co-sponsor of this bill, "There are people languishing in state prisons that if they were in court today, would receive a more just sentence. In the last ten years, the Legislature has enacted several reforms to restore judicial discretion and to allow judges to consider mitigating factors at sentencing, including whether the person was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking or had experienced childhood trauma, exploitation or sexual abuse.
"Although individuals sentenced to LWOP have no path to parole today, many have exhibited decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming, have come to understand the contributing factors which led to their incarceration, and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's risk assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole in California who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent.
"This bill does not guarantee resentencing or release. Any individual who is granted resentencing by a judge will then need to go before the parole board, who will make a determination about their suitability for release.
"This bill allows courts to consider old cases in light of changes in law, thereby applying the law more fairly. This will mean that individuals that deserve a second chance won't have to die behind bars. For these reasons, the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights supports SB 94 and urges the legislature to pass this important bill."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association, "By enacting Proposition 115, the voters of this state have told us they want to keep the worst of the worst in prison where they belong. If they feel differently, Penal Code section 1385.1 should be amended by them in a future initiative or legislatively referred ballot proposition. Dragging these murderers back into court will be prohibitively expensive, tie up judicial resources, and inflict further pain upon their victims. By creating presumptions favoring the release of these murderers, SB 94 will create unjustifiable risks to public safety.
"We strongly urge you to consider the unintended consequences to the families of victims and the public who potentially will lose faith in the judicial process and the finality of judgments."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing costs (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) of an unknown but potentially significant amount to the courts to adjudicate petitions authorized by this bill. The author's office estimates that approximately 550 people would be eligible to file petitions for recall and resentencing authorized by this bill. If an initial petition is denied, this bill permits the petitioner to file two subsequent petitions after a specified waiting period. It generally costs approximately $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. If 225 petitions are filed and each takes one hour to adjudicate, the resulting workload costs to the court would be about $225,000. Actual costs will depend on the number of petitions filed and the amount of court time required to handle each petition. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The 2023-24 budget includes $105 million from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
- Potential staffing costs (General Fund) to the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD), possibly in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to represent people serving LWOP who file petitions for resentencing. Because only people who have served 25 years in custody are eligible to file a petition, all or nearly all eligible petitioners will be indigent and qualify for legal representation appointed by the court. Some of this workload may be handled by county public defender offices, but OSPD may require additional staffing to handle its appointments.
- Costs (General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ), potentially in the hundreds of thousands to low millions of dollars annually, to litigate appeals from petitions for recall and resentencing that are denied. DOJ estimates needing additional staff to handle these appeals, which would each take approximately 40 attorney hours to resolve. DOJ anticipates this workload would begin in fiscal year 2024-25 and continue for five years. Actual workload costs to DOJ will depend on the number of petitions denied, the number of appeals filed, and the amount of time needed to litigate each appeal.
- Potentially significant savings (General Fund) to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) in reduced incarceration costs. According to a 2022 estimate by the Legislative Analyst's Office, the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in state prison is $106,000. People eligible for resentencing under this bill are sentenced to LWOP; without resentencing, they will likely remain in prison until they die. Incarceration costs for elderly and infirm inmates tend to be higher than incarceration costs for other inmates. To the extent this bill ultimately results in release of incarcerated people on parole, rather than continued incarceration for the rest of their lives, CDCR will experience significant cost savings, potentially in the millions to tens of millions of dollars. Actual savings will depend on the number of petitions granted and the amount of time each petitioner would have spent in prison if not for their resentencing. If two people are released on parole rather than spending 15 additional years in prison, the resulting savings to CDCR would be approximately $3.2 million.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 22-12-6
YES: Allen, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Padilla, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Dahle, Dodd, Glazer, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Eggman, Min, Portantino, Roth, Umberg
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 6-2-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Bonta, Bryan, Ortega, Santiago, Jackson
NO: Alanis, Lackey
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-5-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez, Soria
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon
UPDATED
VERSION: September 1, 2023
CONSULTANT: Cheryl Anderson / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001562
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 94
Author:(Cortese) – As Amended Ver:June 20, 2023
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 6 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows a person serving a prison sentence of life without the possibility of parole (LWOP) who meets certain requirements to file a petition in court seeking resentencing to a lesser sentence.
Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, except as specified, a person serving LWOP for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if both of the following apply:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
- The person has served at least 25 years in custody.
- Exempts from eligibility people convicted of certain crimes, including first degree murder of a peace officer engaged in performance of their duties and specified sexual offenses committed in conjunction with homicide.
- Establishes procedural requirements for the original petition, supplementary and responsive filings, hearings, and review of a petition for recall and resentencing.
- Requires the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual, if the petitioner does not have counsel and is indigent.
- States that resentencing shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings, as specified.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, the petitioner may file two subsequent petitions if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior petition.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing costs (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) of an unknown but potentially significant amount to the courts to adjudicate petitions authorized by this bill. The author’s office estimates that approximately 550 people would be eligible to file petitions for recall and resentencing authorized by this bill. If an initial petition is denied, the bill permits the petitioner to file two subsequent petitions after a specified waiting period. It generally costs approximately $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. If 225 petitions are filed and each takes one hour to adjudicate, the resulting workload costs to the court would be about $225,000. Actual costs will depend on the number of petitions filed and the amount of court time required to handle each petition. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The 2023-24 budget includes $105 million from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
- Potential staffing costs (General Fund) to the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD), possibly in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to represent people serving LWOP who file petitions for resentencing. Because only people who have served 25 years in custody are eligible to file a petition, all or nearly all eligible petitioners will be indigent and qualify for legal representation appointed by the court. Some of this workload may be handled by county public defender offices, but OSPD may require additional staffing to handle its appointments.
- Costs (General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ), potentially in the hundreds of thousands to low millions of dollars annually, to litigate appeals from petitions for recall and resentencing that are denied. DOJ estimates needing additional staff to handle these appeals, which would each take approximately 40 attorney hours to resolve. DOJ anticipates this workload would begin in fiscal year 2024-25 and continue for five years. Actual workload costs to DOJ will depend on the number of petitions denied, the number of appeals filed, and the amount of time needed to litigate each appeal.
- Potentially significant savings (General Fund) to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) in reduced incarceration costs. According to a 2022 estimate by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in state prison is $106,000. People eligible for resentencing under this bill are sentenced to LWOP; without resentencing, they will likely remain in prison until they die. Incarceration costs for elderly and infirm inmates tend to be higher than incarceration costs for other inmates. To the extent this bill ultimately results in release of incarcerated people on parole, rather than continued incarceration for the rest of their lives, CDCR will experience significant cost savings, potentially in the millions to tens of millions of dollars. Actual savings will depend on the number of petitions granted and the amount of time each petitioner would have spent in prison if not for their resentencing. If two people are released on parole rather than spending 15 additional years in prison, the resulting savings to CDCR would be approximately $3.2 million.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent… This bill does not automatically let anyone out of prison. It does not guarantee resentencing. This bill simply creates a process for the judicial review of cases that have not been looked at in decades.
- Background. In California, first degree murder is generally punishable by a prison term of 25 years to life. However, if one or more special circumstances are found to be true, the defendant must be sentenced to death or LWOP instead. Special circumstances include financial gain, a prior murder conviction, lying in wait, infliction of torture, discharging a firearm from a motor vehicle, and active participation in a street gang, among others.
Generally, once a defendant’s sentence begins, the court no longer has authority over the sentence and may not change it. However, in some circumstances, the Legislature has authorized certain criminal defendants to petition the courts to recall their existing sentences and issue new sentences in the interest of justice. As detailed in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Public Safety, the Legislature has also made numerous changes to sentencing law in recent years, many of which expand judicial discretion at sentencing and allow courts to consider important factors like the defendant’s age, trauma they experienced, their veteran status, and whether racial bias impacted their original case when determining an appropriate sentence.
This bill allows a qualifying person sentenced to LWOP to submit a petition to the court for recall and resentencing. The bill sets out factors the court must consider when determining whether the interest of justice would be served by granting the petition and giving the petitioner a new sentence. If a judge determines that resentencing is warranted, the only sentence they may issue is 25 years to life. As a result, any person granted resentencing under this provision will not be released from prison until the Board of Parole Hearings has evaluated them and determined that they are suitable for release on parole.
If this bill is chaptered, there will likely be an initial surge of petitions filed, with filings and associated court and public defender costs tapering off over time. Costs to DOJ and savings to CDCR, while potentially significant, are more speculative because they depend on a number of intervening factors. That said, given the immense cost of lifetime incarceration, if this bill results in even a few people being released on parole instead of serving LWOP sentences, the savings to the state would be significant.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2023
Counsel: Cheryl Anderson
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 94
Author:(Cortese) – As Amended Ver:June 20, 2023
SUMMARY: Creates a process for a person who has been sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) before June 5, 1990, and has served at least 25 years in custody, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, except as specified, an individual serving LWOP for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990; and,
- The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
- Specifies that an individual is not eligible for recall and resentencing if any of the following circumstances apply:
- The individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace officer engaged in performance of their duties or of a peace officer or former peace officer in retaliation for the performance of their official duties;
- The individual was convicted of first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people; or
- The individual was convicted of a sexual offense committed in conjunction with the homicide for which the petitioner is serving an LWOP sentence. Defines “sexual offense” as rape, sodomy, lewd and lascivious acts on a child under 14 years of age, rape by instrument; and oral copulation.
- Requires the petition to be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney, or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner. The presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition.
- Requires the petition to include all of the following:
- A declaration by the petitioner that they are eligible for relief;
- The superior court case number and date of the petitioner’s offense and conviction; and,
- Whether the petitioner currently has counsel and, if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
- Requires the court to review the petition and determine if it alleges the eligibility elements. Allows the court to deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition if any of the required information is missing and cannot be readily ascertained and to advise the petitioner that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
- Requires the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual, if the petitioner does not have counsel and is indigent.
- Provides that if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days. The prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. These deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
- Requires the court to hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner within 60 days after the reply is filed. This deadline may be extended for good cause.
- Allows the resentencing court, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, to do the following:
- Modify the petitioner’s sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion; or
- Vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Allows the parties to waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
- Provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served.
- States that resentencing shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings, as specified.
- Requires the court to state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
- Provides that in considering a petition, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that any of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
- The petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking;
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence;
- The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military;
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness;
- The petitioner was under 26 years of age at the time of offense;
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act; or,
- The petitioner’s age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner’s risk for future violence.
- Provides that proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety – i.e., unreasonable risk that the petitioner will commit a new violent offense, as specified.
- Requires the court to consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the sentence originally imposed is no longer in the interest of justice.
- States that this process does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions may be filed if at least three years have passed from the denial of the prior application.
- Allows the petitioner to appear remotely, and the court to conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
- States that a resentencing hearing constitutes a “post-conviction release proceeding” under Marsy’s Law and consistent with that law requires the prosecutor to provide notice of the hearing to the victim, if the victim has requested to be notified, and the court to provide the victim an opportunity to be heard regarding sentencing, if requested by the victim.
- Makes findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines murder as the unlawful killing of a human being, or a fetus, with malice aforethought. (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a).)
- Defines malice for this purpose as either express or implied. It is express when there is manifested a deliberate intention unlawfully to take away the life of a fellow person. It is implied when no considerable provocation appears, or when the circumstances attending the killing show an abandoned and malignant heart. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a)(1) & (2).)
- Provides that for a conviction of murder generally, a participant in a crime must have the mental state described as malice, unless specified criteria are met. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a)(3).)
- States that malice shall not be imputed to a person based solely on their participation in a crime. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a)(3).)
- Provides that when it is shown that the killing resulted from an act with express or implied malice, no other mental state need be shown to establish the mental state of malice aforethought. Neither an awareness of the obligation to act within the general body of laws regulating society nor acting despite such awareness is included within the definition of malice. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (b).)
- Defines first degree murder, in part, as all murder that is committed in the perpetration of, or attempt to perpetrate, specified felonies. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (a).)
- States that a participant in one of the specified felonies is liable for first degree murder only if one of the following is proven:
- The person was the actual killer;
- The person was not the actual killer, but, with the intent to kill, aided, abetted, counseled, commanded, induced, solicited, requested, or assisted the actual killer in the commission of murder in the first degree; or,
- The person was a major participant in the underlying felony and acted with reckless indifference to human life, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (e).)
- Allows a defendant to be convicted of first degree murder if the victim is a peace officer who was killed in the course of duty, where the defendant was a participant in one of the specified felonies and the defendant knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duty. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (f).)
- Prescribes the penalty for first degree murder as death, LWOP, or imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 25 years to life, as provided. (Pen. Code, § 190, subd. (a).)
- Provides that when a prosecutor charges a special circumstance and it is found true, a person found guilty of first degree murder shall be punished by death or LWOP. (Pen. Code, §§ 190.2, 190.4.)
- Enumerates the special circumstances, as follows:
- The murder was intentional and carried out for financial gain;
- The defendant was convicted previously of first or second-degree murder;
- The defendant has been convicted of more than one offense of first or second-degree murder in the currentproceeding;
- The murder was committed by means of a destructive device planted, hidden or concealed in any place, area, dwelling, building or structure and the defendant knew or should have known that their act(s) would create a great risk of death;
- The murder was committed to avoid a lawful arrest or make an escape from lawful custody;
- The murder was committed by means of a destructive device that the defendant mailed or delivered, or attempted to mail or deliver and the defendant knew or reasonably should have known that their act(s) would create a great risk of death;
- The victim was a peace officer who was intentionally killed while performing their duties and the defendant knew or should have known that; or the peace officer/former peace officer was intentionally killed in retaliation for performing their duties;
- The victim was a federal law enforcement officer who was intentionally killed while performing their duties and the defendant knew or should have known that; or the federal law enforcement officer was intentionally killed in retaliation for performing their duties;
- The victim was a firefighter who was intentionally killed while performing their duties and the defendant knew or should have known that;
- The victim was a witness to a crime and was intentionally killed to prevent their testimony, or killed in retaliation for testifying;
- The victim was a local, state or federal prosecutor/former prosecutor intentionally murdered in retaliation for, or to prevent the performance of, official duties;
- The victim was a local, state, or federal judge/former judge intentionally murdered in retaliation for, or to prevent the performance of, official duties;
- The victim was an elected or appointed official/former official of local, state or federal government intentionally murdered in retaliation for, or to prevent the performance of, official duties;
- The murder was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, manifesting exceptional depravity, meaning a conscious or pitiless crime that is unnecessarily torturous to the victim.
- The defendant intentionally killed the victim while lying in wait;
- The victim was intentionally killed because of their race, color, religion, nationality, or country of origin;
- The murder was committed while the defendant was engaged in, or was an accomplice to, the commission of, attempted commission of, or immediate flight after, committing or attempting to commit the following crimes: robbery; kidnapping; rape; sodomy; lewd or lascivious act on a child under the age of 14; oral copulation; burglary; arson; train wrecking; mayhem; rape by instrument; and, carjacking (“felony-murder special circumstance”);
- The murder was intentional and involved the infliction of torture;
- The defendant intentionally killed the victim by the administration of poison;
- The victim was a juror and the murder was intentionally carried out in retaliation for, or to prevent the performance of, the victim's duties as a juror;
- The murder was intentional and committed by discharging a firearm from a motor vehicle; and,
- The defendant intentionally killed the victim while actively participating in a criminal street gang, and the murder was carried out to further the activities of the gang. (Pen. Code, § 190.2.)
- The murder was intentional and carried out for financial gain;
- Specifies that a person convicted of first degree murder, who is not the actual killer and lacked the intent to kill, is liable under the felony-murder special circumstance only where they acted with reckless indifference to human life and as a major participant, aided, abetted, counseled, commanded, induced, solicited, requested, or assisted in the commission of one of specified felonies which resulted in death. (Pen. Code, § 190.2, subd. (d).)
- Provides that the penalty for a defendant found guilty of murder in the first degree, in any case in which one or more special circumstances has been found to be true, who was 16 years of age or older and under the age of 18 years at the time of the commission of the crime, shall be confinement in the state prison for LWOP or, at the discretion of the court, 25-years-to-life. (Pen. Code, § 190.5, subd. (b).)
- Allows a court, either on its own motion or upon the application of the prosecutor, to dismiss an action in the furtherance of justice. The court must state the reasons for the dismissal orally on the record. (Pen. Code, § 1385, subd. (a).)
- Prohibits courts from striking or dismissing special circumstance allegations once they have been admitted by plea or found true by a court or jury, if the murder occurred on or after June 6, 1990. (Pen. Code, § 1385.1.)
- Entitles a victim to reasonable notice of all public proceedings, including delinquency proceedings, upon request, at which the defendant and the prosecutor are entitled to be present and of all parole or other post-conviction release proceedings, and to be present at all such proceedings. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 28, subd. (e) [Marsy’s Law].)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent. Based on CDCR data, an analysis from the Special Circumstances Conviction Project of UCLA Center for the Study of Women, estimates that this reform might qualify 600 LWOP cases for review. These cases represent a very narrow population that consists of the most elderly individuals behind bars. Many of these individuals have shown decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. This bill does not automatically let anyone out of prison. It does not guarantee resentencing. This bill simply creates a process for the judicial review of cases that have not been looked at in decades.”
- Background: Criminal Justice Reforms: Over the last several years, the Legislature has enacted several criminal justice reforms that allow judicial discretion and expressly provide for judges to consider certain mitigating factors at sentencing. The reforms include AB 124 (Kamlager), Chapter 695, Statutes of 2021, which required courts to consider whether specified trauma to a defendant and other factors, including whether the defendant was under 26 years of age at the time of the offense, contributed to the commission of the offense when making sentencing and resentencing determinations. SB 260 (Hancock), Chapter 312, Statutes of 2013, established a parole process for persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age (otherwise known as Youth Offender Parole hearings). SB 261 (Hancock), Chapter 471, Statutes 2015, expanded the youth offender parole process to include those who have committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23. AB 1308 (Stone), Chapter 675, Statutes of 2017, again expanded the youth offender parole process to include those who committed their crimes when they were 25 years of age or younger. Several bills required courts to consider a defendant’s status as a veteran or related trauma in sentencing – e.g., AB 2098 (Levine), Chapter 163, Statutes of 2014; AB 865 (Levine), Chapter 523, Statutes of 2018; SB 1209 (Eggman), Chapter 721, Statutes of 2022. AB 2542 (Kalra), Chapter 317, Statutes of 2020, and AB 256 (Kalra), Chapter 739, Statutes of 2022, the California Racial Justice Act, allowed a defendant to seek relief because their case, including sentence, was impacted by racial bias. As a result of these changes, individuals who received extreme sentences decades ago may not have been sentenced the same way today.
- First Degree Murder with Special Circumstances: Murder is the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought. (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a).) Malice may be express or implied. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a).) “Malice is express when there is manifested a deliberate intention to unlawfully take away the life of a fellow creature” – i.e., intent to kill. (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a)(1).) “Malice is implied when no considerable provocation appears, or when the circumstances attending the killing show an abandoned and malignant heart.” (Pen. Code, § 188, subd. (a)(2).)
There are three categories of first degree murder in California: [1] where the killing is willful, deliberate, and premeditated; [2] where the killing is committed by means of a destructive or explosive device, ammunition designed to penetrate armor, poison, lying in wait, or torture; and [3] where the killing occurs during the commission of a specified felony offense (known as felony murder). (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (a).) First degree murder is generally punishable by 25-years-to-life in state prison. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (a).) However, if one or more special circumstances are found to be true, the defendant becomes eligible for the death penalty and must be sentenced to either death or LWOP. (Pen. Code, § 190.2, subd. (a); People v. Banks (2015) 61 Cal.4th 788, 797.) - Striking or Dismissing a Special Circumstance: As adopted by voter initiative in Proposition 115, courts do not have the discretion to strike a special circumstance once admitted or found true by the court or a jury. (Pen. Code, § 1385.1; see Prop. 115, supra, § 26.) This is a restriction on the general discretion courts have to strike an enhancement or its punishment in the interest of justice. (Pen. Code, § 1385.) Prior to June 6, 1990, and for murders that took place prior to June 5, 1990, the judge had/has discretion to strike a special circumstance after it has been admitted or found true.
This bill would create a process for an individual serving an LWOP sentence for a conviction in which one or more special circumstances were found to be true to petition for recall and resentencing if the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and the individual has served at least 25 years in custody. However, this bill would exclude from this process convictions for murder of a peace officer, as specified, first-degree murder as the actual killer of three or more people, and murder involving specified sexual offenses.
If the eligibility requirements are met, this bill would authorize a court to, in the interests of justice, [1] modify the petitioner’s LWOP sentence to instead impose a lesser sentence and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion, or [2] to vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgment on a lesser included offense. The new sentence would have to be 25-to-life (the punishment for first degree murder in the absence of a special circumstance).
In resentencing under this bill, the court would be required to consider and afford great weight to specified circumstances including whether the petitioner was a victim of intimate partner violence, or sexual violence, human trafficking, experienced various types of trauma or abuse, was diagnosed with a cognitive impairment or mental illness, was under 26 years of age at the time of the offense, as well as the petitioner’s age, time served, or diminished physical condition reducing risk of future violence. Additionally, the court would be required to consider and give great weight to whether the petitioner’s sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act. While proof of the presence of one or more of these circumstances would weigh greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, a court finding that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety would trump this. If relief is granted, the individual would not necessarily be released, but would proceed to a hearing to determine if they are suitable for release on parole. - Plea Agreements: “Plea negotiations and agreements are an accepted and ‘integral component of the criminal justice system and essential to the expeditious and fair administration of our courts.’ [Citations.] Plea agreements benefit that system by promoting speed, economy, and the finality of judgments.” (People v. Segura (2008) 44 Cal.4th 921, 929.) “Because a ‘negotiated plea agreement is a form of contract,’ it is interpreted according to general contract principles,” and “[a]cceptance of the agreement binds the court and the parties to the agreement.” (Id. at p. 930.)
Where the plea is accepted by the prosecuting attorney in open court and is approved by the court, … the court may not proceed as to the plea other than as specified in the plea.” (§ 1192.5, italics added.) When a court accepts a plea bargain, the court must impose a sentence within the limits of that bargain. Thus, a court may not modify the terms of a plea agreement while otherwise leaving the agreement intact, nor may the court effectively withdraw its approval by later modifying the terms of the agreement it had approved. Should the court consider the plea bargain to be unacceptable, its remedy is to reject it, not to violate it, directly or indirectly. It follows that unless the Legislature intended otherwise, a retroactive resentencing statute incorporates long-standing law that a court cannot unilaterally modify an agreed-upon term by striking portions of it … .
(People v. Brooks (2020) 58 Cal.App.5th 1099, 1106-1107 [citations and quotations omitted].)
The provisions of this bill would apply regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea.
- Remote Court Appearance: Under Penal Code section 977, effective January 1, 2024, a criminal defendant convicted of a felony is required to be present at sentencing. Penal Code section 977.2, however, provides: “Notwithstanding Section 977 or any other law, in any case in which the defendant is charged with a misdemeanor or a felony and is currently incarcerated in the state prison, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation may arrange for all court appearances in superior court, except for the preliminary hearing and trial, to be conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant agrees, the preliminary hearing and trial may be held by two-way electronic audiovideo communication.” Section 977.2 further provides: “For those court appearances that are conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication, the department shall arrange for two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the superior court and any state prison facility. The department shall provide properly maintained equipment, adequately trained staff at the prison, and appropriate training for court staff to ensure that consistently effective two-way electronic audiovideo communication is provided between the prison facility and the courtroom for all appearances conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication.”
Because a petitioner under this bill would be serving an LWOP sentence, they necessarily would be incarcerated in state prison. Arguably, the provisions of Penal Code section 977.2 would apply to a recall and resentencing procedure. Nonetheless, this bill would expressly state that a petitioner may appear remotely, and the court conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests the petitioner’s physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law. - Argument in Support: According to Ella Baker Center for Human Rights, a co-sponsor of this bill, “There are people languishing in state prisons that if they were in court today, would receive a more just sentence. In the last ten years, the Legislature has enacted several reforms to restore judicial discretion and to allow judges to consider mitigating factors at sentencing, including whether the person was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking or had experienced childhood trauma, exploitation or sexual abuse.
“Although individuals sentenced to LWOP have no path to parole today, many have exhibited decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming, have come to understand the contributing factors which led to their incarceration, and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s risk assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole in California who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent.
“This bill does not guarantee resentencing or release. Any individual who is granted resentencing by a judge will then need to go before the parole board, who will make a determination about their suitability for release.
“This bill allows courts to consider old cases in light of changes in law, thereby applying the law more fairly. This will mean that individuals that deserve a second chance won’t have to die behind bars. For these reasons, the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights supports SB 94 and urges the legislature to pass this important bill.” - Argument in Opposition: According to the San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association, “By enacting Proposition 115, the voters of this state have told us they want to keep the worst of the worst in prison where they belong. If they feel differently, Penal Code section 1385.1 should be amended by them in a future initiative or legislatively referred ballot proposition. Dragging these murderers back into court will be prohibitively expensive, tie up judicial resources, and inflict further pain upon their victims. By creating presumptions favoring the release of these murderers, SB 94 will create unjustifiable risks to public safety.
“We strongly urge you to consider the unintended consequences to the families of victims and the public who potentially will lose faith in the judicial process and the finality of judgments.” - Related Legislation:
- AB 97 (Wiener), as relevant here, would provide that if the court holds an evidentiary hearing in a habeas corpus proceeding, a petitioner incarcerated in state prison may choose not to appear for the hearing with a signed or oral waiver on record, or they may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel indicates that the defendant’s presence in court is needed. AB 97 is being heard in this committee today.
- AB 1214 (Maienschein), would allow defendants to appear by remote technology for certain criminal proceedings that do not involve the presentation of testimonial evidence and provides procedural and technological guidelines for the use of remote technology. Specifies this does not authorize the use of remote technology in court or jury trials. AB 1214 is pending hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- SB 99 (Umberg), would extend the sunset on provisions related to remote criminal proceedings that were enacted in response to the Covid-19 pandemic from January 1, 2024 to January 1, 2028. SB 99 is pending hearing in this committee.
- AB 97 (Wiener), as relevant here, would provide that if the court holds an evidentiary hearing in a habeas corpus proceeding, a petitioner incarcerated in state prison may choose not to appear for the hearing with a signed or oral waiver on record, or they may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel indicates that the defendant’s presence in court is needed. AB 97 is being heard in this committee today.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 300 (Cortese), of the 2020-2021 Legislative Session, would have repealed the felony-murder special circumstance requiring punishment by death or LWOP for a person convicted of first degree murder who is not the actual killer and did not intend to kill. SB 300 was not heard on the Assembly floor.
- SB 1437 (Skinner), Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2018, limited liability for individuals based on a theory of first or second degree felony murder, and allowed individuals previously sentenced on a theory of felony murder to petition for resentencing if they meet specified qualifications.
- SCR 48 (Skinner), Chapter 175, Statutes of 2017, recognized the need for statutory changes to the felony-murder rule to more equitably sentence offenders in accordance with their involvement in the crime.
- SB 878 (Hayden), of the 1999-2000 Legislative Session, would have required the court in a case involving felony murder with a defendant who did not physically or directly commit the murder, to determine whether imposition of a sentence of first degree murder is proportionate to the offense committed and to the defendant’s culpability in committing that offense by considering specified criteria and to state its reasons on the record. SB 878 failed passage on the Senate Floor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
8th Amendment Project
A New Way of Life Reentry Project
ACLU California Action
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Friends Service Committee
Amnesty International USA
Anti-recidivism Coalition (UNREG)
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Asian Pacific Islander Re-entry and Inclusion Through Support and Empowerment
Asian Prisoner Support Committee
Bend the Arc California
Bend the Arc San Luis Obispo
Bend the Arc: Jewish Action California
Black Women Organized for Political Action (BWOPA)
Blameless and Forever Free Ministries
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Calls
California Catholic Conference
California Coalition for Women Prisoners
California Families against Solitary Confinement
California Federation of Teachers Afl-cio
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (seiu California)
Californians for Safety and Justice
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Center for Employment Opportunities
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
City of Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice (CURYJ)
Community Agency for Resources, Advocacy and Services
Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto
Courage California
Cure California
Death Penalty Focus
Decarcerate Sacramento
Democrats of Rossmoor
Drop Lwop Coalition
Drug Policy Alliance
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Empowering Pacific Islander Communities (EPIC) Fiscally Sponsored by Community Partners
Empowering Women Impacted by Incarceration
End Solitary Santa Cruz County
Equality California
F.u.e.l.- Families United to End Lwop
Fair Chance Project
Faith in Action East Bay
Families against Mandatory Minimums Foundation
Felony Murder Elimination Project
Foundation Aussergewöhnlich Berlin
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Ground Game LA
Group 137 of Amnesty International
Holy Cross Lutheran Church, Livermore, CA
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Human Rights Watch
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Immigrant Legal Resource Center (UNREG)
Indivisible CA Statestrong
Indivisible Sacramento
Indivisible San Francisco
Indivisible Yolo
Initiate Justice
Inland Equity Partnership
Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity
Islamic Shura Council of Southern California
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Justice2jobs Coalition
LA Defensa
Latinojustice Prldef
Law Enforcement Action Partnership
Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of The San Francisco Bay Area
League of Women Voters of California
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
Long Beach Immigrant Rights Coalition
Milpa (motivating Individual Leadership for Public Advancement)
Naral Pro-choice California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Center for Lesbian Rights
National Harm Reduction Coalition
North Bay Jobs With Justice
Peninsula Multifaith Coalition
Prosecutors Alliance California
Restore Oakland, INC.
Root & Rebound
Safe Return Project
San Francisco Public Defender
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos INC.
Secure Justice
Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) At Sacred Heart in San Jose
Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) Bay Area
Showing Up for Racial Justice Santa Cruz County
Silicon Valley De-bug
Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition
Smart Justice California
Social Change
South Asian Network
Starting Over, INC.
Surj Marin - Showing Up for Racial Justice
Survived & Punished
Techequity Collaborative
The Place4grace
The Resistance Northridge-indivisible
The San Diego Lgbt Community Center
The Transformative In-prison Workgroup
Together We Will/indivisible - Los Gatos
Unapologetically Hers
Uncommon Law
Underground Grit
Underground Scholars Initiative At the University of California, Irvine
United Core Alliance
Universidad Popular
Urban Peace Movement
Voices for Progress
Vt CitizenS United for The Rehabilitation of Errant (S)
White People 4 Black Lives
Witness to Innocence
Women's Foundation California
Young Women's Freedom Center
167 Private Individuals
Opposition
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Coalition of School Safety Professionals
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Reserve Peace Officers Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Crime Victims United
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
Inglewood Police Officers Association
Los Angeles School Police Officers Association
Monterey County District Attorney's Office - ODA - Salinas, CA
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Novato Police Officers Association
Orange County District Attorney
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC)
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Association
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Diegans against Crime
San Diego County District Attorney's Office
San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
1 Private Individual
Analysis Prepared by: Cheryl Anderson / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 94 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 94
Author: Cortese (D), et al.
Amended: 5/18/23
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 4-1, 4/11/23
AYES: Wahab, Bradford, Skinner, Wiener
NOES: Ochoa Bogh
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Recall and resentencing: special circumstances
SOURCE: Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
DIGEST:
This bill sets up a process for a person who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment before June 5, 1990 can seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines murder as the unlawful killing of a human being, or a fetus, with malice aforethought. (Penal Code, § 187(a))
- Defines malice for this purpose as either express or implied and defines those terms.
- It is express when there is manifested a deliberate intention unlawfully to take away the life of a fellow creature.
- It is implied, when no considerable provocation appears, or when the circumstances attending the killing show an abandoned and malignant heart. (Penal Code § 188)
- Defines first degree murder, in part, as all murder that is committed in the perpetration of, or attempt to perpetrate, specified felonies. (Penal Code § 189.)
- Prescribes, as enacted by Proposition 7, approved by the voters at the November 7, 1978, statewide general election, a penalty for that crime of death, imprisonment in the state prison for life without the possibility of parole, or imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 25 years to life. (Penal Code § 190)
- Provides that the penalty for a defendant who is found guilty of murder in the first degree is death or imprisonment in the state prison for life without the possibility of parole if one or more of 22 special circumstances are found to be true. (Penal Code § 190.2)
This bill:
- Provides that an individual who has been sentenced to life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstance has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
- The individual has served at least 25 years in custody.
- Provides that the petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner.
- Provides that the presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition.
- Provides that the petition shall include all the following:
- A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief.
- The superior court case number and date of the petitioner’s offense and conviction.
- Whether the petitioner currently has counsel, and if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
- Provides that if any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
- Provides that he court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements required.
- Provides that if the court does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual.
- Provides if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days.
- Provides that the prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served.
- Provides that the deadlines may be extended for good cause.
- Provides that within 60 days after the reply is filed, the courts hall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner.
- Provides that the resentencing court may in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
- May modify the petitioner’s sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
- May vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgment on a necessarily included lesser offense, wither or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Provides that the parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
- Provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served.
- Provides that resentencing under this subdivision shall only result in a sentence of 25 years of life with the possibility of parole followed by a review by the Board of Parole hearings.
- Provides that the court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
- Provides that in considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that nay of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
- The petitioner was the victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking;
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
- The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairments, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
- The petitioner was under the age of 26 at the time of the offense.
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act.
- The petitioner’s age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner’s risk for future violence.
- Provides that proof of the presence of one or more of the above circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety.
- Provides that the court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentence so that the sentence originally imposed I no longer in the interest of justice.
- Provides that it does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, two subsequent petitions may be filed if at least three years have passed since the denial of the prior petition.
- Provides that the petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
- Contains uncodified Legislative findings and declarations.
Background
According to the author:
Existing law provides that when a prosecutor charges a special circumstance enhancement and it is found true, a person found guilty of first degree murder with special circumstances shall be punished by death or LWOP. (Pen. Code, § 190.2.)
Prop 115, passed by the voters on June 5, 1990, removed from judges the discretion to dismiss a special circumstance finding after it has been found true. Judges retain the power to dismiss special circumstances after they have been found true for offenses that occurred before June 5, 1990.
Penal Code section 1172.1 permits a judge, prosecutor or CDCR to recall a sentence for reconsideration. This code section does not permit an individual to petition for recall and reconsideration of a sentence.
The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent. Based on CDCR data, an analysis from the Special Circumstances Conviction Project of UCLA Center for the Study of Women, estimates that this reform might qualify 200 death penalty cases, and 600 LWOP cases for review.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Judicial Branch: Unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate review petitions for recall and resentencing and hold additional review and resentencing hearings (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
- OSPD: Staff notes potential ongoing costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds thousands, as a result of additional staff workload for the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD) (General Fund).
- DOJ: Staff notes ongoing costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ), likely in the hundreds of thousands for additional staff resources in the Appeals, Writs, and Trials division (General Fund). Actual costs will depend on how many petitions are filed under SB 94 and how many are the responsibility of the Attorney General (AG) as opposed to the district attorney who originally handled the case.
- Incarceration Savings: Unknown, potential annual savings in reduced state incarceration costs as a result of inmates being resentenced and possibly being released on parole (General Fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/18/23)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights (source)
8th Amendment Project
A New Way of Life Reentry Project
ACLU California Action
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Friends Service Committee
Amnesty International USA
Asian Pacific Islander Re-entry and Inclusion Through Support and Empowerment
Asian Prisoner Support Committee
Bend the Arc California
Bend the Arc: Jewish Action California
Black Women Organized for Political Action
Blameless and Forever Free Ministries
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Calls
California Catholic Conference
California Coalition for Women Prisoners
California Families Against Solitary Confinement
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
Californians for Safety and Justice
Californians United for A Responsible Budget
Center for Employment Opportunities
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
City of Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Agency for Resources, Advocacy and Services
Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto
Courage California
Cure California
Decarcerate Sacramento
Democrats of Rossmoor
Drop Lwop Coalition
Drug Policy Alliance
Empowering Pacific Islander Communities, Fiscally Sponsored by Community Partners
End Solitary Santa Cruz County
F.u.e.l.- Families United to End LWOP
Fair Chance Project
Faith in Action East Bay
Families Against Mandatory Minimums Foundation
Felony Murder Elimination Project
Foundation Aussergewöhnlich Berlin
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Holy Cross Lutheran Church, Livermore, CA
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Human Rights Watch
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Individual
Indivisible CA Statestrong
Indivisible Sacramento
Indivisible San Francisco
Indivisible Yolo
Initiate Justice
Inland Equity Partnership
Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity
Islamic Shura Council of Southern California
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Justice2jobs Coalition
LA Defensa
Latinojustice Prldef
Law Enforcement Action Partnership
Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
Long Beach Immigrant Rights Coalition
MILPA
NARAL Pro-Choice California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Center for Lesbian Rights
National Harm Reduction Coalition
North Bay Jobs With Justice
Peninsula Multifaith Coalition
Prosecutors Alliance California
Restore Oakland, Inc.
Root & Rebound
Safe Return Project
San Francisco Public Defender
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos Inc.
Secure Justice
Showing Up for Racial Justice Bay Area
Showing Up for Racial Justice Santa Cruz County
Silicon Valley De-Bug
Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition
Smart Justice California
Social Change
Starting Over, Inc.
Survived & Punished
Techequity Collaborative
The Place4grace
The Resistance Northridge-indivisible
The San Diego LGBT Community Center
The Transformative In-Prison Workgroup
Unapologetically Hers
Uncommon Law
Underground Grit
Underground Scholars Initiative at the University of California, Irvine
United Core Alliance
Urban Peace Movement
Voices for Progress
White People 4 Black Lives
Witness to Innocence
Young Women's Freedom Center
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/18/23)
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Coalition of School Safety Professionals
California District Attorneys Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Crime Victims United
Crime Victims United of California
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
Inglewood Police Officers Association
Los Angeles School Police Officers Association
Monterey County District Attorney's Office
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Association
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Diegans Against Crime
San Diego County District Attorney's Office
San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters of this bill note that nothing in this bill guarantees a person will be resentenced or leave prison, but it is consistent with some of the other recent criminal justice reforms in recognizing that people may change while incarcerated and may no longer pose a threat to society. Specifically the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color states:
There are people languishing in state prisons, that were they in court today, would receive a more just sentence. In the last ten years, the Legislature has enacted several reforms to restore judicial discretion and to allow judges to consider mitigating factors at sentencing, including whether the person was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking or had experienced childhood trauma, exploitation or sexual abuse.
Although individuals sentenced to LWOP or death have no path to parole today, many have exhibited decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming, have come to understand the contributing factors which led to their incarceration, and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole in California who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent.
This bill does not guarantee resentencing or release. Any individual who is granted resentencing by a judge will then need to go before the parole board, who will make a determination about their suitability for release. This bill allows courts to consider old cases in light of changes in law, thereby applying the law more fairly. This will mean that individuals that deserve a second chance won’t have to die behind bars. For these reasons, our organization strongly supports SB 94 (Cortese).
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California District Attorneys oppose this bills stating:
First, SB 94 subverts the will of The People of the State of California, who voted to prohibit the dismissal of special circumstances in 1990 via Proposition 115. Your bill acknowledges this fact. However, the bill then seeks to avoid this declaration by providing dismissal of special circumstances to sentences not covered by the Proposition. While this is technically legal, it is in direct conflict with the will of the People. Rather than govern through technicality, we suggest you bring the issue back to the voters to see if they agree with you, or abide by the conditions in their initiative–specifically a ⅔ vote in both houses. As it stands, we must oppose.
Second, your bill would impose a substantial and unwarranted burden on the judicial system, limiting access and extending wait times for individuals in order to allow individuals who have committed the most egregious offenses to seek resentencing. This measure makes no distinction between those who have demonstrated some indicators of redemption or rehabilitation and those who have not. Instead, it would burden the state’s already overburdened judicial system and retraumatize the families of murder victims with resentencing hearings for individuals who have shown few or no signs of redemption, and who jurors did not believe were worthy of the opportunity for parole based on the nature of their crimes.
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
5/23/23 11:55:27
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 94 (Cortese) - Recall and resentencing: special circumstances
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 94 would create a process for a person who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) for an offense that occurred before June 5, 1990, and who has spent at least 20 years in prison, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 18, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
- Judicial Branch: Unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate review petitions for recall and resentencing and hold additional review and resentencing hearings (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
- OSPD: Staff notes potential ongoing costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds thousands, as a result of additional staff workload for the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD) (General Fund).
- DOJ: Staff notes ongoing costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ), likely in the hundreds of thousands for additional staff resources in the Appeals, Writs, and Trials division (General Fund). Actual costs will depend on how many petitions are filed under SB 94 and how many are the responsibility of the Attorney General (AG) as opposed to the district attorney who originally handled the case.
- Incarceration Savings: Unknown, potential annual savings in reduced state incarceration costs as a result of inmates being resentenced and possibly being released on parole (General Fund).
Author Amendments:
- Remove eligibility for resentencing for persons who have been sentenced to death.
- Require a person to have served 25 years in order to be eligible to petition for resentencing.
- Specify that resentencing under these provisions shall only result in a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, followed by review by the Board of Parole Hearings as specified.
- Provide that a person who is denied resentencing may only submit two subsequent petitions, for a total of three.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 94 (Cortese) - Recall and resentencing: special circumstances
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 94 would create a process for a person who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) for an offense that occurred before June 5, 1990, and who has spent at least 20 years in prison, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
Fiscal Impact:
- Judicial Branch: Unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate review petitions for recall and resentencing and hold additional review and resentencing hearings (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).*
- OSPD: Staff notes potential ongoing costs, likely in the hundreds thousands, as a result of additional staff workload for the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD) (General Fund).*
- DOJ: Staff notes potential ongoing costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ), possibly in the hundreds of thousands for additional staff resources in the Appeals, Writs, and Trials division (General Fund). Actual costs will depend on how many petitions are filed under SB 94 and how many are the responsibility of the Attorney General (AG) as opposed to the district attorney who originally handled the case; should the number of cases assigned to the AG be few in number, then costs would likely be minor and absorbable.
- Incarceration Savings: Unknown, potential annual savings in reduced state incarceration costs as a result of inmates being resentenced and possibly being released (General Fund).*
*See Staff Comments for additional detail.
Background:
In California, first-degree murder is punished in one of three ways. A person convicted of first-degree murder can be sentenced to death, given a life sentence without the possibility of parole (LWOP), or an indeterminate life sentence of 25 years to life. In order to receive a death sentence or an LWOP sentence, one or more “special circumstances” must be found true by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt. Special circumstances murder includes murders carried out for financial gain, the defendant was convicted of a prior murder or murders, the murder was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, manifesting exceptional depravity, and many others.
Proposition 115, approved by California voters on June 6, 1990, made a number of procedural changes to criminal law in California. Notably, it expanded the first degree murder definition, expanded special circumstance murders subject to capital punishment and LWOP, and increased the penalty for minors convicted of first degree murder to life imprisonment without parole. Prop 115 also removed from judges the discretion to dismiss a special circumstance finding after it has been found true. However, judges retained the power to dismiss special circumstances after they have been found true for offenses that occurred before June 5, 1990. This bill sets up a process for people who were sentenced to death or life without the possibility of parole when the offense occurred prior to June 5, 1990 to petition a court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence. The person must have served at least 20 years in custody in order to be eligible.
Proposed Law:
- Provides that an individual who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstance has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if 1) the offense occurred before June 5, 1990, and 2) the individual has served at least 20 years in custody.
- Provides that the petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner.
- Provides that the petition shall include a declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief, the case number and date of the petitioner’s offense and conviction, and whether the petitioner currently has counsel, and if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
- Provides that if any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court, the court may deny the petition without prejudice and advise the petitioner that matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
- Provides that if the court does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual.
- Provides that if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days.
- Provides that the prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served. Provides that these deadlines shall be extended for good cause.
- Provides that within 60 days after the reply is filed, the courts hall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner. Provides that this deadlines may be extended for good cause.
- Provides that the resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
- May modify the petitioner’s sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
- May vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgment on a necessarily included lesser offense, wither or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Provides that the parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
- Provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served and that resentencing under this subdivision shall not result in the imposition of a term longer than the original sentence.
- Provides that the court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
- Provides that in considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that specified mitigating circumstances are present.
- Provides that proof of the presence of one or more of the above circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety.
- Provides that the court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentence so that the sentence originally imposed I no longer in the interest of justice.
- Provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, a subsequent petition pursuant to this section may be filed if at least two years have passed for the denial of the prior application.
- Provides that the petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
Related Legislation:
- SB 300 (Cortese, 2022) would have repealed the felony-murder special circumstance requiring punishment by death or imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole (LWOP) for a person convicted of first degree murder who is not the actual killer and did not intend to kill. SB 300 was ordered to the inactive file on the Assembly Floor.
- SB 1437 (Skinner) Ch. 1015, Stats. 2018, limited felony murder liability and allowed individuals previously sentenced on a theory of felony murder to petition for resentencing if they meet specified qualifications.
Staff Comments:
- Judicial Branch: It is unknown how many petitions for recall and resentencing would be filed under SB 94, nor how many review and resentencing hearings would be required. However, there are approximately 191 prisoners who have been sentenced to death for more than 230 offenses that were committed prior to June 5, 1990. According to CDCR there are currently 817 prisoners serving LWOP sentences for offenses that were committed prior to June 5, 1990. Provided that each of these persons has spent at least 20 years in prison, SB 94 would likely authorize each of them the opportunity to immediately file one or more petitions for their sentence to be recalled, and to be resentenced. Petitions that are denied could be refiled after two years. It generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Consequently, if the additional petitions and hearings required by SB 94 combined to take 50 or more hours of court involvement across the State, the cost pressures of this measure would surpass the Suspense File threshold. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased staff time and resources may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. Numerous trial court operations are funded through the imposition and collection of criminal fines and fees. However, the Legislature has reduced and eliminated criminal fines and fees over the past decade. As a result, the 2023-24 proposed budget anticipates an ongoing annual allocation of $109.3 million from the GF to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
- OSPD: SB 94 would require the court to appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to an eligible petitioner who is indigent. Having spent at least 20 years in custody, most, if not all eligible petitioners will qualify for appointed counsel. There are currently over 1,000 petitioners who are likely to be eligible for relief under this bill. Many of these appointments, especially in more rural counties where the resources for entities such as the county public defender are scarce, may require appointment of the State Public Defender. Staff notes that OSPD would likely require at least 1.0 additional Deputy State Public Defender, and potentially 1.0 legal secretary in order to absorb additional workload.
- Incarceration Savings: The proposed FY 2023 - 2024 per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $127,716 annually, with an annual marginal rate per person of approximately $13,000. It is more expensive to incarcerate prisoners on death row than those who are serving other sentences due to, among other things, increased security for condemned inmates. In addition, older prisoners, such as the ones who are most likely to be eligible for relief under SB 94, are typically more expensive than younger ones due to their susceptibility to costly medical conditions. Actual savings from SB 94 would depend on several factors, including how many persons successfully petition for recall and resentencing, and whether those persons are eventually released on parole.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 94 Hearing Date: April 11, 2023
Author: | Cortese | ||
Version: | March 23, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Recall and resentencing: special circumstances
HISTORY
Source: Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Prior Legislation: SB 300 (Cortese) not heard Assembly floor 2021-2022
SB 1437 (Skinner) Chapter 105, Stats. 2018
SCR 48 (Skinner) Chapter 175, Stats. 2017
SB 878 (Hayden) Failed Senate Floor 1999
Support: 8th Amendment Project; A New Way of Life Reentry Project; Alliance for Boys and Men of Color; American Friends Service Committee; Amnesty International USA; Asian Pacific Islander Re-entry and Inclusion Through Support and Empowerment; Asian Prisoner Support Committee; Bend the Arc: Jewish Action California; Black Women Organized for Political Action (BWOPA); Blameless and Forever Free Ministries; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Catholic Conference; California Coalition for Women Prisoners; California Families Against Solitary Confinement; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Native Vote Project; California Public Defenders Association (CPDA); Californians for Safety and Justice; Californians United for A Responsible Budget; Center for Employment Opportunities; Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice; City of Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao; Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice (CURYJ); Community Agency for Resources, Advocacy and Services; Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto; Courage California; Cure California; Decarcerate Sacramento; Drop LWOP Coalition; Drug Policy Alliance; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; Empowering Pacific Islander Communities (EPIC) Fiscally Sponsored by Community Partners; End Solitary Santa Cruz County; FUEL - Families United to End LWOP; Fair Chance Project; Faith in Action East Bay; Families Against Mandatory Minimums Foundation; Felony Murder Elimination Project; Foundation Aussergewöhnlich Berlin; Friends Committee on Legislation of California; Holy Cross Lutheran Church, Livermore, CA; Housing and Economic Rights Advocates; Human Rights Watch; If/When/How: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice; Individual; Indivisible CA Statestrong; Indivisible Sacramento; Indivisible San Francisco; Indivisible Yolo; Initiate Justice; Inland Equity Partnership; Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity; Islamic Shura Council of Southern California; John Burton Advocates for Youth; Justice2jobs Coalition; La Defensa; Latinojustice Prldef; Law Enforcement Action Partnership; Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of The San Francisco Bay Area; Legal Services for Prisoners With Children; Long Beach Immigrant Rights Coalition; Milpa (motivating Individual Leadership for Public Advancement); National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter; National Center for Lesbian Rights; National Harm Reduction Coalition; North Bay Jobs With Justice; Peninsula Multifaith Coalition; Prosecutors Alliance California; Restore Oakland, INC.; Root & Rebound; Safe Return Project; San Francisco Public Defender; Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos INC.; Secure Justice; Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) Bay Area; Showing Up for Racial Justice Santa Cruz County; Silicon Valley De-bug; Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition
Smart Justice California; Social Change; Starting Over, INC.; Survived & Punished; Techequity Collaborative; The Place4grace; The Resistance Northridge-indivisible; The San Diego Lgbt Community Center; The Transformative In-prison Workgroup; Unapologetically Hers; Uncommon Law; Underground Grit; Underground Scholars Initiative At the University of California, Irvine; United Core Alliance; White People 4 Black Lives; Young Women's Freedom Center
Opposition: California Association of Highway Patrolman; California District Attorneys Association; California State Sheriffs' Association; Crime Victims United of California; San Diegans Against Crime; San Diego County District Attorney's Office; San Diego Deputy District Attorneys Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to set up a process for a person who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment before June 5, 1990 can seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence.
Existing law defines murder as the unlawful killing of a human being, or a fetus, with malice aforethought. (Penal Code, § 187(a))
Existing law defines malice for this purpose as either express or implied and defines those terms.
- It is express when there is manifested a deliberate intention unlawfully to take away the life of a fellow creature.
- It is implied, when no considerable provocation appears, or when the circumstances attending the killing show an abandoned and malignant heart. (Penal Code § 188)
Existing law defines first degree murder, in part, as all murder that is committed in the perpetration of, or attempt to perpetrate, specified felonies. (Penal Code § 189.)
Existing law, as enacted by Proposition 7, approved by the voters at the November 7, 1978, statewide general election, prescribes a penalty for that crime of death, imprisonment in the state prison for life without the possibility of parole, or imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 25 years to life. (Penal Code § 190)
Existing law provides that the penalty for a defendant who is found guilty of murder in the first degree is death or imprisonment in the state prison for life without the possibility of parole if one or more of 22 special circumstances are found to be true. (Penal Code § 190.2)
This bill provides that an individual who has been sentenced to death or life imprisonment without possibility of parole for a conviction in which one or more special circumstance has been found true, may petition the court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence if:
- The offense occurred before June 5, 1990.
- The individual has served at least 20 years in custody.
This bill provides that the petition shall be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney or on the agency that prosecuted the petitioner.
This bill provides that the presiding judge shall designate a judge to rule on the petition.
This bill provides that the petition shall include all the following:
- A declaration by the petitioner that the petitioner is eligible for relief.
- The superior court case number and date of the petitioner’s offense and conviction.
- Whether the petitioner currently has counsel, and if not, whether the petitioner is indigent.
This bill provides that if any of the information required by this subdivision is missing from the petition and cannot be readily ascertained by the court may deny the petition without prejudice to the filing of another petition and advise the petitioner that matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
This bill provides that he court shall review the petition and determine if it alleges the elements required.
This bill provides that if the court does not have counsel and is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the individual.
This bill provides if counsel is newly appointed, they may file a supplementary petition within 60 days.
This bill provides that the prosecutor may file and serve a response within 60 days of service of the petition or supplementary petition and the petitioner may file and serve a reply within 30 days after the prosecutor response is served.
This bill provides that the deadlines may be extended for good cause.
This bill provides that within 60 days after the reply is filed, the courts hall hold a hearing to determine whether to recall the sentence and resentence the petitioner.
This bill provides that the resentencing court may in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
- May modify the petitioner’s sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
- May vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgment on a necessarily included lesser offense, wither or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
This bill provides that the parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible for recall and resentencing.
This bill provides that a petitioner who is resentenced shall be given credit for time served.
This bill provides that resentencing under this subdivision shall not result in the imposition of a term longer than the original sentence.
This bill provides that the court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing.
This bill provides that in considering a petition pursuant to this section, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove that nay of the following mitigating circumstances are present:
- The petitioner was the victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking;
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
- The petitioner is a veteran and the conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairments, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
- The petitioner was under the age of 26 at the time of the offense.
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act.
- The petitioner’s age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner’s risk for future violence.
This bill provides that proof of the presence of one or more of the above circumstances weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety.
This bill provides that the court shall consider postconviction factors, including, but not limited to, the disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentence so that the sentence originally imposed I no longer in the interest of justice.
This bill provides that it does not diminish or abrogate any rights or remedies otherwise available to the subject of the petition.
This bill provides that if the judge declines to impose a reduced sentence, a subsequent petition pursuant to this section may be filed if at least two years have passed for the denial of the prior application.
This bill provides that the petitioner may appear remotely, and the court may conduct the hearing through the use of remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence in court and if not otherwise prohibited by state law.
This bill contains uncodified Legislative findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Existing law provides that when a prosecutor charges a special circumstance enhancement and it is found true, a person found guilty of first degree murder with special circumstances shall be punished by death or LWOP. (Pen. Code, § 190.2.)
Prop 115, passed by the voters on June 5, 1990, removed from judges the discretion to dismiss a special circumstance finding after it has been found true. Judges retain the power to dismiss special circumstances after they have been found true for offenses that occurred before June 5, 1990.
Penal Code section 1172.1 permits a judge, prosecutor or CDCR to recall a sentence for reconsideration. This code section does not permit an individual to petition for recall and reconsideration of a sentence.
The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR)’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent. Based on CDCR data, an analysis from the Special Circumstances Conviction Project of UCLA Center for the Study of Women, estimates that this reform might qualify 200 death penalty cases, and 600 LWOP cases for review.
2. Proposition 115
Existing law, as enacted by Proposition 115, approved by California voters on June 6, 1990, made a number of procedural changes to criminal law in California including changes to discovery and the allowance of hearsay testimony by peace officers at preliminary hearings. It also added additional special circumstances to those for which the death penalty applies and removed from judges the discretion to dismiss a special circumstance finding after it has been found true. Judges retain the power to dismiss special circumstances after they have been found true for offenses that occurred before June 5, 1990.
3. Recall and resentence for cases before June 5, 1990.
Because Judges retain the power to dismiss special circumstances after they have been found true for offenses that occurred before June 5, 1990, this bill sets up a process for people who were sentenced to death or life without the possibility of parole and the offense occurred prior to June 5, 1990 to petition a court to recall the sentence and resentence to a lesser sentence. The person must also have already served at least 20 years in custody.
- Petition Filed in sentencing court
The petition is to be filed with the court that sentenced the petitioner and served on the district attorney. The presiding judge shall assign a judge to hear a petition, it has been over 20 years so it is unlikely, but not impossible, that the judge who originally heard the case is still on the bench. If the petition does not include required information it can be denied without prejudice.
If the petition is denied, without prejudice, because of something lacking in the petition, should this only occur after an indigent defendant has been appointed counsel?
- Indigent defendants.
The petition shall include a statement as to whether the petitioner has counsel or if the petitioner is indigent. If the petitioner is indigent, the court shall appoint the State Public Defender or other qualified counsel to represent the defendant. The newly appointed counsel may have 60 days to file a supplementary petition and the district attorney has 60 days to respond to the original or supplementary petition.
- Actions the court may take
The resentencing court may, in the interest of justice do any of the following:
- Modify the petitioner’s sentence to impose a lesser sentence, and apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion.
- Vacate the petitioner’s conviction and impose judgement on any necessarily included lesser offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, and then resentence the petitioner to a lesser sentence.
- Considerations by the court
In considering the petion, the court shall consider and afford great weight to evidence offered by the petitioner to prove any of the following mitigating circumstances are present
- The petitioner was victim of intimate partner violence, sexual violence, or human trafficking.
- The petitioner experienced childhood trauma, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence.
- The petitioner is a veteran and conduct involved in the offense related to trauma experienced in the military.
- The petitioner has been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, intellectual disability, or mental illness.
- The petitioner was under the age of 26 at the time of the offense.
- The sentence violates the California Racial Justice Act.
- The petitioner’s age, time served, or diminished physical condition reduces the petitioner’s risk for future violence.
The bill provides that proof of one of the above weighs greatly in favor of dismissing the special circumstance, unless the court finds that the petitioner is currently at risk to public safety.
The court shall also consider postconviction factors including disciplinary record while incarcerated, rehabilitation of the petitioner while incarcerated, and evidence that reflects the circumstances have changed.
- Procedural issues
This bill also sets forth a number of procedural considerations:
- The parties may waive a resentencing hearing and stipulate that the petitioner is eligible.
- The petitioner may appear remotely and the court may conduct the hearing using remote technology, unless counsel requests their physical presence.
- A petitioner who is resentence shall be given credit for time served.
- Resentencing under this section should not result in a longer sentence.
- The court shall state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and sentencing.
4. Argument in Support
Supporters of this bill note that nothing in this bill guarantees a person will be resentenced or leave prison, but it is consistent with some of the other recent criminal justice reforms in recognizing that people may change while incarcerated and may no longer pose a threat to society. Specifically the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color states:
There are people languishing in state prisons, that were they in court today, would receive a more just sentence. In the last ten years, the Legislature has enacted several reforms to restore judicial discretion and to allow judges to consider mitigating factors at sentencing, including whether the person was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking or had experienced childhood trauma, exploitation or sexual abuse.
Although individuals sentenced to LWOP or death have no path to parole today, many have exhibited decades of exemplary behavior, participated in extensive positive programming, have come to understand the contributing factors which led to their incarceration, and have devoted themselves to becoming positive members of society. The majority of people serving a life without parole sentence are classified as low risk according to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s own California Static Risk Assessment tool - 88% of people serving life without parole have been assessed with the lowest risk score on that scale. Research also conclusively demonstrates that there is little risk for elderly individuals to re-offend or recidivate upon release. For individuals previously sentenced to life without parole in California who were granted a commutation and released, the recidivism rate is zero percent.
This bill does not guarantee resentencing or release. Any individual who is granted resentencing by a judge will then need to go before the parole board, who will make a determination about their suitability for release. This bill allows courts to consider old cases in light of changes in law, thereby applying the law more fairly. This will mean that individuals that deserve a second chance won’t have to die behind bars. For these reasons, our organization strongly supports SB 94 (Cortese).
5. Argument in Opposition
The California District Attorneys oppose this bills stating:
First, SB 94 subverts the will of The People of the State of California, who voted to prohibit the dismissal of special circumstances in 1990 via Proposition 115. Your bill acknowledges this fact. However, the bill then seeks to avoid this declaration by providing dismissal of special circumstances to sentences not covered by the Proposition. While this is technically legal, it is in direct conflict with the will of the People. Rather than govern through technicality, we suggest you bring the issue back to the voters to see if they agree with you, or abide by the conditions in their initiative–specifically a ⅔ vote in both houses. As it stands, we must oppose.
Second, your bill would impose a substantial and unwarranted burden on the judicial system, limiting access and extending wait times for individuals in order to allow individuals who have committed the most egregious offenses to seek resentencing. This measure makes no distinction between those who have demonstrated some indicators of redemption or rehabilitation and those who have not. Instead, it would burden the state’s already overburdened judicial system and retraumatize the families of murder victims with resentencing hearings for individuals who have shown few or no signs of redemption, and who jurors did not believe were worthy of the opportunity for parole based on the nature of their crimes.
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):