SB 99: Law enforcement agencies: military equipment.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-10
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires a law enforcement agency, as defined, to obtain approval of the applicable governing body, by adoption of a military equipment use policy prior to taking certain actions relating to the funding, acquisition, or use of military equipment, as defined. Existing law requires the governing body to approve a military equipment use policy only if it determines compliance with certain standards, including that the military equipment is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
This bill would add to those standards that the United States Armed Forces has not been prohibited by federal law or regulation from purchasing the military equipment from the manufacturer or seller of the military equipment. By adding to the duties of local governing bodies with respect to the acquisition of military equipment, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law prohibits, until January 1, 2024, a trial court from retaliating against an official court reporter or official court reporter pro tempore for notifying a judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote criminal proceeding.This bill would extend this provision until January 1, 2028.Existing law allows a defendant in a misdemeanor case to appear by counsel, except as specified. Until January 1, 2024, existing law allows a court to conduct all proceedings, except jury and court trials, remotely through the use of remote technology if a defendant agrees. Existing law requires a defendant in a felony case to be physically present at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. Existing law allows, until January 1, 2024, a defendant to be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings, unless the defendant waived their right to be physically or remotely present with leave of the court and approval by the defendants counsel.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.Existing law generally allows, until January 1, 2024, upon a defendants waiver of the right to be physically present, criminal proceedings to be conducted through the use of remote technology. Commencing on January 1, 2024, existing law authorizes a court to permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility, under specified circumstances, to be conducted by 2-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the defendants physical presence.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028, and extend the implementation of provisions that would commence on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.Existing law authorizes the court, until January 1, 2024, to direct the defendant to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding, prohibits a defendant charged with a felony from appearing remotely for sentencing, except as specified, and prohibits a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor from appearing remotely for a jury or court trial, except as specified.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.Existing law, until January 1, 2024, authorizes the court to allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology, requires a court to require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding under specified circumstances, and requires a reporter to be physically present in the courtroom when the court conducts a remote proceeding that is reported.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.Existing law authorizes, until January 1, 2024, a witness in a criminal proceeding to testify using remote technology, as provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.This bill would extend these provisions until January 1, 2028, and broaden the provisions to testifying remotely as otherwise provided by any law.Existing law requires a defendant to be personally present in a preliminary hearing unless otherwise specified. Existing law prohibits these provisions from limiting the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present. Existing law, until January 1, 2024, prohibits the defendants right to waive the right to appear through the use of remote technology from being limited by these provisions.This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.Existing law prohibits, until January 1, 2024, a trial court from retaliating against an official court reporter or official court reporter pro tempore for notifying a judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote criminal proceeding.
This bill would extend this provision until January 1, 2028.
Existing law allows a defendant in a misdemeanor case to appear by counsel, except as specified. Until January 1, 2024, existing law allows a court to conduct all proceedings, except jury and court trials, remotely through the use of remote technology if a defendant agrees. Existing law requires a defendant in a felony case to be physically present at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. Existing law allows, until January 1, 2024, a defendant to be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings, unless the defendant waived their right to be physically or remotely present with leave of the court and approval by the defendants counsel.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.
Existing law generally allows, until January 1, 2024, upon a defendants waiver of the right to be physically present, criminal proceedings to be conducted through the use of remote technology. Commencing on January 1, 2024, existing law authorizes a court to permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility, under specified circumstances, to be conducted by 2-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the defendants physical presence.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028, and extend the implementation of provisions that would commence on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.
Existing law authorizes the court, until January 1, 2024, to direct the defendant to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding, prohibits a defendant charged with a felony from appearing remotely for sentencing, except as specified, and prohibits a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor from appearing remotely for a jury or court trial, except as specified.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, authorizes the court to allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology, requires a court to require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding under specified circumstances, and requires a reporter to be physically present in the courtroom when the court conducts a remote proceeding that is reported.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.
Existing law authorizes, until January 1, 2024, a witness in a criminal proceeding to testify using remote technology, as provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses.
This bill would extend these provisions until January 1, 2028, and broaden the provisions to testifying remotely as otherwise provided by any law.
Existing law requires a defendant to be personally present in a preliminary hearing unless otherwise specified. Existing law prohibits these provisions from limiting the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present. Existing law, until January 1, 2024, prohibits the defendants right to waive the right to appear through the use of remote technology from being limited by these provisions.
This bill would extend the provisions that would expire on January 1, 2024, until January 1, 2028.
The California Constitution vests the judicial power of the state in the Supreme Court, courts of appeal, and superior courts, and establishes the Judicial Council to, among other things, adopt rules of court and perform functions prescribed by statute. Existing law authorizes a referral to collaborative courts pursuant to, among other circumstances, a pretrial diversion program for primary caregivers.This bill would require, before January 1, 2025, the Judicial Council to submit a study to the Legislature on the successes and best practices of collaborative courts in the state, as specified.The California Constitution vests the judicial power of the state in the Supreme Court, courts of appeal, and superior courts, and establishes the Judicial Council to, among other things, adopt rules of court and perform functions prescribed by statute. Existing law authorizes a referral to collaborative courts pursuant to, among other circumstances, a pretrial diversion program for primary caregivers.
This bill would require, before January 1, 2025, the Judicial Council to submit a study to the Legislature on the successes and best practices of collaborative courts in the state, as specified.
Existing law requires a court to consider alternatives to incarceration, including, without limitation, collaborative justice court programs, diversion, restorative justice, and probation. Existing law states that it is the intent of the Legislature that the disposition of any criminal case use the least restrictive means possible.This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to this provision.Existing law requires a court to consider alternatives to incarceration, including, without limitation, collaborative justice court programs, diversion, restorative justice, and probation. Existing law states that it is the intent of the Legislature that the disposition of any criminal case use the least restrictive means possible.
This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to this provision.
(a)(1)A law enforcement agency shall obtain approval of the governing body, by an ordinance adopting a military equipment use policy at a regular meeting of the governing body held pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2) or the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5), as applicable, prior to engaging in any of the following:
(A)Requesting military equipment made available pursuant to Section 2576a of Title 10 of the United States Code.
(B)Seeking funds for military equipment, including, but not limited to, applying for a grant, soliciting or accepting private, local, state, or federal funds, in-kind donations, or other donations or transfers.
(C)Acquiring military equipment either permanently or temporarily, including by borrowing or leasing.
(D)Collaborating with another law enforcement agency in the deployment or other use of military equipment within the territorial jurisdiction of the governing body.
(E)Using any new or existing military equipment for a purpose, in a manner, or by a person not previously approved by the governing body pursuant to this chapter.
(F)Soliciting or responding to a proposal for, or entering into an agreement with, any other person or entity to seek funds for, apply to receive, acquire, use, or collaborate in the use of, military equipment.
(G)Acquiring military equipment through any means not provided by this paragraph.
(2)No later than May 1, 2022, a law enforcement agency seeking to continue the use of any military equipment that was acquired prior to January 1, 2022, shall commence a governing body approval process in accordance with this section. If the governing body does not approve the continuing use of military equipment, including by adoption pursuant to this subdivision of a military equipment use policy submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), within 180 days of submission of the proposed military equipment use policy to the governing body, the law enforcement agency shall cease its use of the military equipment until it receives the approval of the governing body in accordance with this section.
(b)In seeking the approval of the governing body pursuant to subdivision (a), a law enforcement agency shall submit a proposed military equipment use policy to the governing body and make those documents available on the law enforcement agencys internet website at least 30 days prior to any public hearing concerning the military equipment at issue.
(c)The governing body shall consider a proposed military equipment use policy as an agenda item for an open session of a regular meeting and provide for public comment in accordance with the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2) or the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5), as applicable.
(d)(1)The governing body shall only approve a military equipment use policy pursuant to this chapter if it determines all of the following:
(A)The military equipment is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
(B)The proposed military equipment use policy will safeguard the publics welfare, safety, civil rights, and civil liberties.
(C)If purchasing the equipment, the equipment is reasonably cost effective compared to available alternatives that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
(D)Prior military equipment use complied with the military equipment use policy that was in effect at the time, or if prior uses did not comply with the accompanying military equipment use policy, corrective action has been taken to remedy nonconforming uses and ensure future compliance.
(E)The United States Armed Forces has not been prohibited by federal law or regulation from purchasing the military equipment from the manufacturer or seller of the military equipment.
(2)In order to facilitate public participation, any proposed or final military equipment use policy shall be made publicly available on the internet website of the relevant law enforcement agency for as long as the military equipment is available for use.
(e)(1)The governing body shall review any ordinance that it has adopted pursuant to this section approving the funding, acquisition, or use of military equipment at least annually and, subject to paragraph (2), vote on whether to renew the ordinance at a regular meeting held pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2) or the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5), as applicable.
(2)The governing body shall determine, based on the annual military equipment report submitted pursuant to Section 7072, whether each type of military equipment identified in that report has complied with the standards for approval set forth in subdivision (d). If the governing body determines that a type of military equipment identified in that annual military equipment report has not complied with the standards for approval set forth in subdivision (d), the governing body shall either disapprove a renewal of the authorization for that type of military equipment or require modifications to the military equipment use policy in a manner that will resolve the lack of compliance.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (e), inclusive, if a city contracts with another entity for law enforcement services, the city shall have the authority to adopt a military equipment use policy based on local community needs.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 71651.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:71651.1.(a)Consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote proceeding pursuant to subdivisions (f) and (g) of Section 977 of the Penal Code.(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 2.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 12 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval by the defendants counsel.(2)The waiver of a defendants right to be physically or remotely present may be in writing and filed with the court or, with the courts consent, may be entered personally by the defendant or by the defendants counsel of record.(A)A defendants personal waiver of the right to be physically or remotely present shall be on the record and state that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.(B)A waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence may be entered by counsel, after counsel has stated on the record that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue, has waived that right, and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.(3)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically or remotely present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof, including upon request of a victim, to the extent required by Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.(4)A written waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence shall be substantially in the following form:Waiver of Defendants Physical or Remote PresenceThe undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives the right to be physically or remotely present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were physically or remotely present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their physical or remote presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their physical or remote appearance at that time and place.(c)(1)(A)Upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except as provided in subparagraphs (D) and (E). The defendant may withdraw the waiver at any time.(B)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding or portion thereof, including as provided in subdivision (f).(C)If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the proceeding, unless, upon request of defense counsel, the court allows the appearance without private communication. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.(D)A defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial, except as provided in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2).(E)A defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for postconviction relief proceedings and as otherwise provided by law.(F)A witness may appear at any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trial, remotely pursuant to Section 977.3.(2)(A)A felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion.(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(e)A court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology without being physically present in the courtroom and in accordance with subdivision (f).(f)Except as otherwise provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:(1)The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.(2)Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.(3)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporters ability to accurately prepare a transcript of the proceeding.(4)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.(5)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreters ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly with the defendant and the court during the proceeding.(g)(1)Before the court may proceed with a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, official reporter pro tempore, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding.(2)When the court conducts a remote proceeding that will be reported by an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore, the reporter shall be physically present in a courtroom.(h)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.(i)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 13 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be personally present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be personally present at all other proceedings unless they shall, with leave of court, execute in open court, a written waiver of their right to be personally present, as provided by paragraph (2). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).(2)The accused may execute a written waiver of their right to be personally present, approved by their counsel, and the waiver shall be filed with the court. However, the court may specifically direct the defendant to be personally present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof. The waiver shall be substantially in the following form:Waiver of Defendants Personal PresenceThe undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby waives the right to be present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were personally present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their appearance at that time and place.(c)(1)The court may permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of defendants held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges, except for those defendants who were indicted by a grand jury, to be conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall be present with the defendant at the initial court appearance and arraignment, and may enter a plea during the arraignment. However, if the defendant is represented by counsel at an arraignment on an information in a felony case, and if the defendant does not plead guilty or nolo contendere to any charge, the attorney shall be present with the defendant or if the attorney is not present with the defendant, the attorney shall be present in court during the hearing. The defendant shall have the right to make their plea while physically present in the courtroom if they request to do so. If the defendant decides not to exercise the right to be physically present in the courtroom they shall execute a written waiver of that right. A judge may order a defendants personal appearance in court for the initial court appearance and arraignment. In a misdemeanor case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom. In a felony case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom if the parties stipulate thereto.(2)(A)A defendant who does not wish to be personally present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. The court may, when a defendant has waived the right to be personally present, require a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges to be present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken, including, but not limited to, confirmation of the preliminary hearing, status conferences, trial readiness conferences, discovery motions, receipt of records, the setting of the trial date, a motion to vacate the trial date, and motions in limine, by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be personally present with the defendant for noncritical portions of the trial, if the audiovideo conferencing system or other technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the noncritical portion of trial. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2028.SEC. 4.Section 977.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:977.3.(a)A witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have a witness testify in person on the record.(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court may allow a witness to testify through the use of remote technology as otherwise provided by any law, including, but not limited to, Sections 1340, 1347.5, and 2624 of this code, Section 16519.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the holding in Maryland v. Craig (1990) 497 U.S. 836, and the holding in People v. Powell (2011) 194 Cal.App.4th 1268.(c)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.(d)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 5.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 15 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through the use of remote technology in accordance with Section 977.(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 6.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 16 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present in accordance with Section 977.(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.(f)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2028.(a)Consistent with federal and California labor law, a trial court shall not retaliate against an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore who notifies the judicial officer that technology or audibility issues are interfering with the creation of the verbatim record for a remote proceeding pursuant to subdivisions (f) and (g) of Section 977 of the Penal Code.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2024, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 12 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.
(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:
(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.
(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval by the defendants counsel.
(2)The waiver of a defendants right to be physically or remotely present may be in writing and filed with the court or, with the courts consent, may be entered personally by the defendant or by the defendants counsel of record.
(A)A defendants personal waiver of the right to be physically or remotely present shall be on the record and state that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.
(B)A waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence may be entered by counsel, after counsel has stated on the record that the defendant has been advised of the right to be physically or remotely present for the hearing at issue, has waived that right, and agrees that notice to the attorney that the defendants physical or remote presence in court at a future date and time is required is notice to the defendant of that requirement.
(3)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically or remotely present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof, including upon request of a victim, to the extent required by Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(4)A written waiver of the defendants physical or remote presence shall be substantially in the following form:
Waiver of Defendants Physical or Remote Presence
The undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives the right to be physically or remotely present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this
cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were physically or remotely present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their physical or remote presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their physical or remote appearance at that time and place.
(c)(1)(A)Upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except as provided in subparagraphs (D) and (E). The defendant may withdraw the waiver at any time.
(B)The court may specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel, to be physically present at any particular felony proceeding or portion thereof, including as provided in subdivision (f).
(C)If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the proceeding, unless, upon request of defense counsel, the court allows the appearance without private communication. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.
(D)A defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial, except as provided in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2).
(E)A defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for postconviction relief proceedings and as otherwise provided by law.
(F)A witness may appear at any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trial, remotely pursuant to section Section 977.3.
(2)(A)A felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion.
(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(e)A court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney or defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding through the use of remote technology without being physically present in the courtroom and in accordance with subdivision (f).
(f)Except as otherwise provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
(1)The court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
(2)Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
(3)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporters ability to accurately prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
(4)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
(5)The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreters ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly with the defendant and the court during the proceeding.
(g)(1)Before the court may proceed with a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, official reporter pro tempore, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding.
(2)When the court conducts a remote proceeding that will be reported by an official reporter or official reporter pro tempore, the reporter shall be physically present in a courtroom.
(h)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.
(i)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2024, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.Section 977 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 13 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:977.(a)(1)In all cases in which the accused is charged with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code, or a misdemeanor violation of Section 273.6, the accused shall be present for arraignment and sentencing, and at any time during the proceedings when ordered by the court for the purpose of being informed of the conditions of a protective order issued pursuant to Section 136.2.
(3)If the accused is charged with a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence, in an appropriate case, the court may order a defendant to be present for arraignment, at the time of plea, or at sentencing. For purposes of this paragraph, a misdemeanor offense involving driving under the influence shall include a misdemeanor violation of any of the following:
(A)Subdivision (b) of Section 191.5.
(B)Section 23103 as specified in Section 23103.5 of the Vehicle Code.
(C)Section 23152 of the Vehicle Code.
(D)Section 23153 of the Vehicle Code.
(b)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (c), in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be personally present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during those portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of the imposition of sentence. The accused shall be personally present at all other proceedings unless they shall, with leave of court, execute in open court, a written waiver of their right to be personally present, as provided by paragraph (2). If the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, and plea may be by video, as provided by subdivision (c).
(2)The accused may execute a written waiver of their right to be personally present, approved by their counsel, and the waiver shall be filed with the court. However, the court may specifically direct the defendant to be personally present at any particular proceeding or portion thereof. The waiver shall be substantially in the following form:
Waiver of Defendants Personal Presence
The undersigned defendant, having been advised of their right to be present at all stages of the proceedings, including, but not limited to, presentation of and arguments on questions of fact and law, and to be confronted by and cross-examine all witnesses, hereby waives the right to be present at the hearing of any motion or other proceeding in this cause. The undersigned defendant hereby requests the court to proceed during every absence of the defendant that the court may permit pursuant to this waiver, and hereby agrees that their interest is represented at all times by the presence of their attorney the same as if the defendant were personally present in court, and further agrees that notice to their attorney that their presence in court on a particular day at a particular time is required is notice to the defendant of the requirement of their appearance at that time and
place.
(c)(1)The court may permit the initial court appearance and arraignment of defendants held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges, except for those defendants who were indicted by a grand jury, to be conducted by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall be present with the defendant at the initial court appearance and arraignment, and may enter a plea during the arraignment. However, if the defendant is represented by counsel at an arraignment on an information in a felony case, and if the defendant does not plead guilty or nolo contendere to any charge, the attorney shall be present with the defendant or if the attorney is not present with the defendant, the attorney shall be present in court during the hearing. The defendant shall have the right to make their plea while physically present in the courtroom if they request to do so. If the defendant decides not to exercise the right to be physically present in the courtroom they shall execute a written waiver of that right. A judge may order a defendants personal appearance in court for the initial court appearance and arraignment. In a misdemeanor case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom. In a felony case, a judge may, pursuant to this subdivision, accept a plea of guilty or no contest from a defendant who is not physically in the courtroom if the parties stipulate thereto.
(2)(A)A defendant who does not wish to be personally present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. The court may, when a defendant has waived the right to be personally present, require a defendant held in any state, county, or local facility within the county on felony or misdemeanor charges to be present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken, including, but not limited to, confirmation of the preliminary hearing, status conferences, trial readiness conferences, discovery motions, receipt of records, the setting of the trial date, a motion to vacate the trial date, and motions in limine, by two-way electronic audiovideo communication between the defendant and the courtroom in lieu of the physical presence of the defendant in the courtroom. If the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be personally present with the defendant for noncritical portions of the trial, if the audiovideo conferencing system or other technology allows for private communication between the defendant and the attorney prior to and during the noncritical portion of trial. Any private communication shall be confidential and privileged pursuant to Section 952 of the Evidence Code.
(B)This paragraph does not expand or limit the right of a defendant to be personally present with their counsel at a particular proceeding as required by Section 15 of Article 1 of the California Constitution.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel on that day, at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding, with or without a written waiver, if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the trial, hearing, or other proceeding will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the trial, hearing, or other proceeding lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any trial, hearing, or other proceeding in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the trial, hearing, or other proceeding.
(e)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024. 2028.
SEC. 4.Section 977.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:977.3.(a)A witness may testify in any misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for felony trials, through the use of remote technology with the written or oral consent of the parties on the record and with the consent of the court. The defendant shall waive the right to have a witness testify in person on the record.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court may allow a witness to testify through the use of remote technology as otherwise provided by statutes regarding the examination of victims of sexual crimes and conditional examinations of witnesses. any law, including, but not limited to, Sections 1340, 1347.5, and 2624 of this code, Section 16519.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the holding in Maryland v. Craig (1990) 497 U.S. 836, and the holding in People v. Powell (2011) 194 Cal.App.4th 1268.
(c)The court shall make findings on the record that any waiver entered into pursuant to this section is knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently made by the defendant.
(d)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules and standards that are necessary to implement the policies and provisions of this section and the intent of the Legislature.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2024, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 15 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.
(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:
(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.
(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.
(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.
(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be physically present or to appear through the use of remote technology in accordance with Section 977.
(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2024, 2028, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 1043.5 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 16 of Chapter 57 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1043.5.(a)Except as otherwise provided in this section, the defendant in a preliminary hearing shall be personally present.
(b)The absence of the defendant in a preliminary hearing after the hearing has commenced in their physical presence shall not prevent continuing the hearing to, and including, holding to answer, filing an information, or discharging the defendant in any of the following cases:
(1)Any case in which the defendant, after being warned by the judge that they will be removed if they continued their disruptive behavior, nevertheless insists on acting in a manner so disorderly, disruptive, and disrespectful of the court that the hearing cannot be carried on with the defendant present in the courtroom.
(2)Any prosecution for an offense which is not punishable by death in which the defendant is voluntarily absent.
(c)Any defendant who is absent from a preliminary hearing pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) may reclaim their right to be present at the hearing as soon as they are willing to act consistently with the decorum and respect inherent in the concept of courts and judicial proceedings.
(d)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall not limit the right of a defendant to waive the right to be present in accordance with Section 977.
(e)(1)For purposes of subdivision (b), a preliminary hearing shall be deemed to have commenced in the presence of the defendant if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, all of the following to be true:
(A)The defendant is in custody and is refusing, without good cause, to appear in court on that day for that preliminary hearing.
(B)The defendant has been informed of their right and obligation to be personally present in court.
(C)The defendant has been informed that the preliminary hearing will proceed without the defendant being present.
(D)The defendant has been informed that they have the right to remain silent during the preliminary hearing.
(E)The defendant has been informed that their absence without good cause will constitute a voluntary waiver of any constitutional or statutory right to confront any witnesses against them or to testify on their own behalf.
(F)The defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present.
(2)The court shall state on the record the reasons for the courts findings and shall cause those findings and reasons to be entered into the minutes.
(3)If the preliminary hearing lasts for more than one day, the court is required to make the findings required by this subdivision anew for each day that the defendant is absent.
(4)This subdivision does not apply to any preliminary hearing in which the defendant was personally present in court at the commencement of the preliminary hearing.
(f)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024. 2028.
SECTION 1.Section 68517 is added to the Government Code, to read:68517.(a)Before January 1, 2025, the Judicial Council shall submit a study to the Legislature on the successes and best practices of collaborative courts in the state.(b)(1)A study to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5, this section is repealed on January 1, 2027.(a)Before January 1, 2025, the Judicial Council shall submit a study to the Legislature on the successes and best practices of collaborative courts in the state.
(b)(1)A study to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5, this section is repealed on January 1, 2027.
SECTION 1.Section 17.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:17.2.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the disposition of a criminal case use the least restrictive means available.(b)The court presiding over a criminal matter shall consider alternatives to incarceration, including, without limitation, collaborative justice court programs, diversion, restorative justice, and probation.(c)The court shall have the discretion to determine the appropriate sentence according to relevant statutes and the sentencing rules of the Judicial Council.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that the disposition of any a criminal case use the least restrictive means available.
(b)The court presiding over a criminal matter shall consider alternatives to incarceration, including, without limitation, collaborative justice court programs, diversion, restorative justice, and probation.
(c)The court shall have the discretion to determine the appropriate sentence according to relevant statutes and the sentencing rules of the Judicial Council.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | July 2 set for second hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 3. Noes 1.) Reconsideration granted. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | July 11 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 23, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 1211.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 9, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 1, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 900.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Mar 14, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 25, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 19, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 18. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Reconsideration. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Failed |
|
| May 22, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB99 Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AFSCME California | ** Against | |
| California Association of Collaborative Courts | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Support | |
| California Judges Association | ** Support | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Against | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Against | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Against | |
| Chief Probation Officers Of California | ** Support | |
| Judicial Council of California | ** Support | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Orange County Employees Association | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Against | |
| Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara | ** Support | |
| Superior Court of Los Angeles County | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 99
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 10, 2024
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 3 - 1 |
Public Safety | 5 - 2 | ||
Public Safety | 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a local governing body from approving a military equipment use policy if it contains military equipment that federal law or regulation prohibits the United States Armed Forces from purchasing.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Ongoing costs (local funds, General Fund) of an unknown but potentially significant amount to local governing bodies to ensure previously approved military equipment and newly proposed military equipment comply with the bill’s requirement. As described in more detail below, a governing body must approve any new military equipment proposed for use and conduct an annual review of previously approved equipment to ensure it still complies with statutory requirements. Under this bill, a governing body must conduct additional research during its initial review of proposed equipment and each annual review to determine whether any equipment is or has become prohibited by federal statute or regulation for U.S. military purchase.
Local costs to comply with this measure would be subject to General Fund reimbursement to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. With more than 470 law enforcement agencies in the state that may seek approval to use military equipment, aggregate costs statewide may exceed this committee’s suspense threshold.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
If the US military deems certain equipment unsuitable for its use, state and local policy should apply the same standard when considering the procurement of military equipment for local law enforcement. SB 99 simply specifies that an applicable governing body shall not approve a military equipment policy for local law enforcement if the United States Armed Forces are prohibited from purchasing that equipment from a manufacturer or seller.
- Background. Under existing law, a law enforcement agency must obtain approval from its governing body before seeking funds for military equipment, purchasing or leasing military equipment, or taking other actions related to the acquisition of military equipment. A governing body must consider a proposed military use policy from a law enforcement agency at a public meeting, and may approve the policy only if certain required criteria are met. For example, the governing body must determine that the military equipment is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety, and that the equipment is reasonably cost effective compared to available alternatives. After approving a military use policy, the governing body must review the policy on an annual basis to confirm the required criteria are still met for each piece of military equipment included in the policy. If a piece of equipment no longer meets the requirements, the governing body must disapprove authorization of the equipment or modify its policy so the equipment complies with the requirements.
This bill adds another required criterion that must be met before a governing body may approve a military use policy: the governing body must determine the United States Armed Forces has not been prohibited by federal law or regulation from purchasing the proposed military equipment from the manufacturer or seller of the military equipment.
- Support and Opposition. According to Oakland Privacy, writing in support of the bill, some federal agencies have prohibited use of drones manufactured by DJI in China after determining the drones posed serious security risks. Oakland Privacy reports there is pending federal legislation that would codify the federal bans on use of drones manufactured by DJI. Oakland Privacy argues:
We realize that in the particular DJI use-case that there will be a certain amount of logistical difficulty since the DJI drones are in wide use by CA law enforcement agencies. That is regrettable, but there are times when threats are identified clearly at a later point. Senate Bill 99 would implement safeguards not only for this specific concern which has become acute, but for any emerging threats from military-style equipment use in the future and make sure California is aligned with the most up to date thinking of military experts on what is safe to use and what isn’t.
In opposition, the California State Sheriff’s Association writes:
We understand the stated concerns regarding data security, but the net effect of the measure will be to prohibit law enforcement’s use of certain technology, despite any security measures and data guidelines that may be in place…The effect of this bill will be to prohibit law enforcement’s acquisition and use of drones that comprise a huge portion of the current market. Local governments that use impacted drones will be forced to acquire new technology that is considerably more expensive than a lot of what is currently in use, train their staffs to use it, and likely suffer from a lack of product and feature diversity.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
Counsel: Andrew Ironside
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Kevin McCarty, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 99
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 10, 2024
SUMMARY: Prohibits a governing body from approving a military equipment use policy if it contains military equipment from a manufacturer or seller that the United States Armed Forces has been prohibited by federal law or regulation from purchasing.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a law enforcement agency to obtain approval of the governing body, by an ordinance adopting a military equipment use policy at a regular meeting of the governing body before, among other things, requesting, acquiring, or seeking funds for military equipment. (Gov. Code, § 7071, subd. (a).)
- Defines “military equipment” to include specialized firearms and ammunition of less than .50 caliber, including assault weapons, as specified, with the exception of standard issue service weapons and ammunition of less than .50 caliber that are issued to officers, agents, or employees of a law enforcement agency or a state agency. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (c)(10).)
- Defines “governing body” as the elected body that oversees a law enforcement agency or, if there is no elected body that directly oversees the law enforcement agency, the appointed body that oversees a law enforcement agency. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (a).)
- Defines “law enforcement agency” as a police department, sheriff’s department, district attorney’s office, or county probation department. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (b)(1)-(4).)
- Requires a law enforcement agency to submit a proposed military equipment use policy to the governing body and make those documents available on the law enforcement agency’s internet website at least 30 days prior to any public hearing concerning the military equipment at issue. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (b).)
- Provides that the governing body shall only approve a military equipment use policy if it determines all of the following:
- The military equipment is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
- The proposed military equipment use policy will safeguard the public’s welfare, safety, civil rights, and civil liberties.
- If purchasing the equipment, the equipment is reasonably cost effective compared to available alternatives that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
- Prior military equipment use complied with the military equipment use policy that was in effect at the time, or if prior uses did not comply with the accompanying military equipment use policy, corrective action has been taken to remedy nonconforming uses and ensure future compliance. (Gov. Code, § 7071, subd. (d)(1).)
- The military equipment is necessary because there is no reasonable alternative that can achieve the same objective of officer and civilian safety.
- Requires, in order to facilitate public participation, any proposed or final military equipment use policy to be made publicly available on the internet website of the relevant law enforcement agency for as long as the military equipment is available for use. (Gov. Code, § 7071, subd. (d)(2).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “SB 99 would prevent local law enforcement agencies from purchasing or obtaining certain military equipment if the United States Armed Forces is also prohibited from obtaining the same equipment.
“Law enforcement agencies must obtain approval from an elected body to purchase and acquire military equipment. The definition of military equipment is broad, and state law requires the requesting agency to justify the purchase. However, the list of requirements fails to consider developing Department of Defense policies pertaining to prohibited foreign-made equipment.
“One example of evolving prohibition policies is the increased domestic sale and use of Chinese drones manufactured by DJI. The company accounted for 58 percent of the US commercial market in 2022, with a large percentage of sales going to law enforcement agencies. However, many policymakers and the Department of Defense consider DJI drones a national security threat. The New York Times recently reported that cybersecurity researchers have found that Beijing could potentially exploit vulnerabilities in an app that controls the drone to gain access to large amounts of personal information. The Pentagon has banned the use of DJI drones, and in January, the Interior Department decided to continue grounding its fleet of drones over security fears. Federal legislation has also been introduced to ban all domestic sales.
“If the US military deems certain equipment unsuitable for its use, state and local policy should apply the same standard when considering the procurement of military equipment for local law enforcement. SB 99 simply specifies that an applicable governing body shall not approve a military equipment policy for local law enforcement if the United States Armed Forces are prohibited from purchasing that equipment from a manufacturer or seller.” - Need for the Bill: Current law requires a law enforcement agency to obtain approval from the governing body that oversees it before acquiring or using military equipment. (Gov. Code, § 7071, subd. (a), et seq.) Military equipment includes, among other things, Taser Shockwave, microwave weapons, water cannons, Long Range Acoustic Device (LRAD), battering rams, command and control vehicles, tracked armored vehicles that provide ballistic protection to their occupants, and firearms and firearm accessories that can launch explosive projectiles. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (c).) It also includes unmanned, remotely piloted, powered aerial or ground vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 7070, subd. (c)(11).)
Under existing law, law enforcement may only approve a military equipment use policy if the local governing body determines that there is no reasonable alternative that could achieve officer and civilian safety; the use policy will safeguard the public’s welfare, safety, civil rights and civil liberties; the equipment is reasonably cost effective compared to available alternatives; and prior military equipment use complied with the use policy in place at the time or, if the use did not comply, corrective actions have been taken to ensure future compliance. (Gov. Code, § 7071, subd. (d)(1).)
This bill would add that a governing body may not approve of a military equipment use policy that includes military equipment from a manufacturer or seller that the United States Armed Forces has been prohibited by federal law or regulation from purchasing. - Argument in Support: According to Oakland Privacy, “Synthesizing military equipment usage guidelines between agencies of the state and agencies of the federal government makes sense. Security issues know no jurisdictional boundaries, and the State should benefit from the risk identification and analysis performed on the federal level to keep Californians safe from threats, both now and in the future as new threats emerge.
“One current application of this principle is unmanned aerial vehicles (commonly known as drones). In the context of unmanned aircraft, the direct and immediate impact of the bill would be on the usage and purchasing of drones manufactured by DJI. DJI is a privately-owned company located in Shenzen, China. They are the largest manufacturer of drones with a wide variety of unmanned aircraft models ranging in size, speed and capability and their products are in wide use among California governmental agencies.
“Security researchers have identified serious vulnerabilities in DJI-made unmanned aircraft. These vulnerabilities, which include inadequate encryption of location data, log insecurity, and potential for unauthorized remote operation, seriously impact the security and integrity of the video data captured by the manufacturer’s drones and have disturbing implications for the Californians who live in communities where they are in use by their government. It is a major project for California government to decommission all DJI unmanned aircraft currently in use. But growing security concerns make it necessary, just as the government has re-evaluated the use of some telecom and surveillance technology equipment from Huawei, Hikvision, Dahua and ZTE.
“DJI has more than a 70 percent market share of drone sales, and such market concentration makes them a significant security risk as DJI is a product of China with ties to the CCP. In fact, a security researcher was able to access highly sensitive customer data on DJI’s servers, including passport and driver’s license information, photos, and flight logs from military and government workers accounts.
“Furthermore, many federal agencies have found DJI to be a national security risk and have prohibited their use:
- The U.S. Commerce Department blacklisted DJI in 2017.
- The U.S. Department of the Interior grounded its DJI drone fleet in 2019.
- The Department of Defense issued a list of approved U.S. and European drone makers, known as the Blue drone list where DJI is notably absent.
- The U.S. General Services Administration announced it would only buy drones from the Blue UAS list for government purposes in 2021.
- The Pentagon stated that DJI drones still constitute a threat to national security and blacklisted the company in 2022.
“All of this federal activity establishes that the Pentagon has identified DJI drones as a particularized threat that they are removing from the operations of the U.S. military. In addition, Congress has pending legislation under consideration including the American Security Drone Act of 2023 (bipartisan legislation from Senators Warner D-VA and Scott R-FL) and the Stop Illicit Drones Act (Senators Warner – D-VA and Blackburn R-TN). These bills basically codify the administrative actions taken by the Pentagon.
“Senate Bill 99 implements its mandate by building upon existing law, Assembly Bill 481 (Chiu 2021), which created an oversight mechanism for the use of military-style equipment by local agencies. SB 99 simply adds that in addition to considering usage guidelines for appropriate use, financial implications and human and civil rights, local governments also must refrain from approving the purchase and use of types of military equipment that have been judged as unsuitable or too dangerous for use in the United States military. It is hard to come up with a scenario where what is prohibited for use in a battlefield would be safe or desirable for use on Main Street.
“We realize that in the particular DJI use-case that there will be a certain amount of logistical difficulty since the DJI drones are in wide use by CA law enforcement agencies. That is regrettable, but there are times when threats are identified clearly at a later point. Senate Bill 99 would implement safeguards not only for this specific concern which has become acute, but for any emerging threats from military-style equipment use in the future and make sure California is aligned with the most up to date thinking of military experts on what is safe to use and what isn’t.
“As the U.S. military is the origin source of much, but not all, of the military equipment in use by local agencies through the military surplus 1033 program run by the Defense Logistics Agency, it makes perfect sense that California should abide by any prohibitions the U.S. military adopts.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to the California State Sheriffs’ Association, “We understand the stated concerns regarding data security, but the net effect of the measure will be to prohibit law enforcement’s use of certain technology, despite any security measures and data guidelines that may be in place. Specifically, this bill appears to target unmanned aerial vehicles or drones that are manufactured in certain foreign countries. The standards for technology use by the military are not necessarily the same as standards for law enforcement use but this bill conflates them.
“The effect of this bill will be to prohibit law enforcement’s acquisition and use of drones that comprise a huge portion of the current market. Local governments that use impacted drones will be forced to acquire new technology that is considerably more expensive than a lot of what is currently in use, train their staffs to use it, and likely suffer from a lack of product and feature diversity. For law enforcement agencies, this translates into difficulty completing their missions at much higher prices with threats to public safety.” - Related Legislation:
- AB 2014 (S. Nguyen), would change law enforcement’s duty to seek approval from the local governing body before funding, acquiring or using drones or robots to only require approval if the drone or robot were weaponized. The hearing on AB 2014 was canceled at the request of the author.
- AB 2546 (Rendon), would clarify that the definition of “military equipment” includes area denial electroshock devices generally and not just the Taser Shockwave system; and that the definition also includes long-range acoustic devices, acoustic hailing devices, and sound cannons rather than just the Long-Range Acoustic Device (LRAD) manufactured by the Genasys Corporation.
- AB 2014 (S. Nguyen), would change law enforcement’s duty to seek approval from the local governing body before funding, acquiring or using drones or robots to only require approval if the drone or robot were weaponized. The hearing on AB 2014 was canceled at the request of the author.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1486 (Jones-Sawyer), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have clarified that an assault weapon is not a “standard issue service weapon” and therefore falls under the definition of “military equipment,” which requires approval from the local governing body before a law enforcement agency may acquire it. AB 1486 was placed on the inactive file in the Senate.
- AB 79 (Weber), would prohibit a peace officer from using deadly force against or intending to injure, intimidate, or disorient a person by utilizing any unmanned, remotely piloted, powered ground or flying equipment except under specified circumstances. AB 79 is pending hearing in this committee.
- AB 421 (Chiu), Chapter 406, Statutes of 2021, requires local law enforcement agencies to follow specific procedures to obtain approval from local government prior to the acquisition or use of federal surplus military equipment.
- AB 3131 (Gloria), of the 2017 – 2018 Legislative Session, was similar to AB 421. AB 3131 was vetoed.
- AB 36 (Campos), of the 2015 – 2016 Legislative Session, would have prohibited local agencies, except local law enforcement agencies that are directly under the control of an elected officer, from applying to receive specified surplus military equipment from the federal government, unless the legislative body of the local agency approves the acquisition at a regular meeting. AB 36 was vetoed.
- SB 242 (Monning), Chapter 79, Statutes of 2015, requires a school district's police department to obtain approval from its governing board prior to receiving federal surplus military equipment.
- AB 1486 (Jones-Sawyer), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have clarified that an assault weapon is not a “standard issue service weapon” and therefore falls under the definition of “military equipment,” which requires approval from the local governing body before a law enforcement agency may acquire it. AB 1486 was placed on the inactive file in the Senate.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Oakland Privacy
Opposition
California State Sheriffs' Association
Analysis Prepared by: Andrew Ironside / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 99 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 99
Author: Umberg (D)
Amended: 4/10/23
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 4/25/23
AYES: Wahab, Ochoa Bogh, Bradford, Skinner, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Courts: remote proceedings for criminal cases
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends the sunset to provisions relating to remote proceedings in criminal cases.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that in all cases in which the accused is charges with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except in domestic violence or driving under the influence cases. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
- Provides that, in a misdemeanor, if the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
- Provides that in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during the portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval of defendant’s counsel. (Penal Code § 977(b)(1))
- Provides that upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial and a defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for post-conviction relief proceedings. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1) (A)(D)(E)))
- Provides that the court my specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel to be present at a particular felony proceeding or portion thereof. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(B))
- Provides that if the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and attorney prior to and during the proceedings, unless, upon the request of defense counsel the court allows the appearance without private communication. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(C))
- Provides that a witness may appear at a misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for a felony trial, remotely. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(F))
- Provides that a felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. (Penal Code § 977(c)(2))
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel at trial or any other proceeding, if the court finds that: the defendant is in custody and refusing, without good cause, to appear; the defendant has been informed of their right to be personally present; the defendant has been informed that the trial or other proceeding will go on without them; the defendant has been informed of their right to remain silent; the defendant has been informed their absence will constitute a voluntary waiver of their constitutional rights; and, the defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present. (Penal Code § 977(d)(1))
- Provides that a court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney and defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding without being physically present. (Penal Code § 977(e))
- Provides that except as provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
- The Court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
- Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporter’s ability to prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly the defendant and the court during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(f))
- Provides that before the court conducts a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(g)(1))
- Provides that the official court reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom when remote proceedings are conducted. (Penal Code § 977(g)(2))
- Provides that the provisions allowing remote proceedings in criminal cases shall sunset on January 1, 2024.
This bill extends the sunset until January 1, 2028.
Background
Prior to COVID-19, with the exception of appearances that could be waived, defendants in criminal cases generally appeared in person, with the option of remote appearances limited to in-custody defendants. The Emergency Rules generally allowed defendants and attorneys to appear remotely in proceedings with the consent of the defendant. Prior to the June 30, 2022, sunset of the Emergency Rules and through the budget process, discussions were had amongst interested parties to continue remote appearances in criminal cases. The Courts, Public Defenders, District Attorneys, Probation, Sheriffs, and various criminal justice groups were supportive of the final version of the legislation. The result was a continuation of remote proceedings with some changes to what had been in place during the Emergency Rules. The new provisions, which are currently in place, provide:
- Misdemeanors: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials, it is up to the defendant and they cannot be required to appear remotely. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Felonies: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials and sentencing, unless the court allows a waiver for non-critical, non-testimonial portions of the trial. It is up to the defendant and they cannot be required to appear remotely. Remote proceedings are allowed for post-conviction relief proceedings. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Witnesses: may testify remotely except for felony trials, and only with the consent of both parties and the court.
- Court reporters: must be physically present in a courtroom when remote proceedings occur and cannot be retaliated against for reporting technology and audibility issues.
- Courts must have a process for participants to alert the court of audibility or technology issues before and during a proceeding and shall require a person to appear in person if the issues cannot resolved.
The statutes authorizing these remote appearances in criminal cases are set to sunset on January 1, 2024. This bill will extend that sunset to January 1, 2028.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/8/23)
California Association of Collaborative Courts
California District Attorneys Association
California Judges Association
Chief Probation Officers' of California
Judicial Council of California
Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara
Superior Court of Los Angeles County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/8/23)
AFSCME California
California Labor Federation
California Public Defenders Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
Orange County Employees Association
San Francisco Public Defender
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Judicial Council of California supports this bill stating in part:
The Judicial Council has seen the many benefits of giving people the option to participate remotely in criminal proceedings. The remote option helps preserve access to justice for many Californians and vulnerable court users by reducing time and expense for them when they are hospitalized or would otherwise lose time from work or childcare, and would incur travel and parking costs for short hearings and appearances. It also preserves equal access to justice and increases the efficiency of court services by continuing to allow courts the flexibility to require in-person court proceedings when it is more appropriate.
Further, participants in collaborative justice court programs and diversion programs especially benefit from the ability to appear remotely. Unlike other courts, collaborative courts and diversion courts meet on a frequent basis, making remote proceedings very helpful, while at the same time allowing judicial officers the discretion to balance the benefits of in-person participation with the efficiencies of remote proceedings for more routine matters. Program participants are not in custody, and remote appearances allow them to participate in court proceedings while not interrupting programming, schooling, or work obligations. Remote proceedings are also helpful to the many justice partners (behavioral health experts, probation, etc.) that help participants successfully graduate from collaborative court programs and diversion programs.
Moreover, the remote option is helpful for witness testimony in criminal proceedings, making appearances more affordable and efficient for court participants when the defendant consents.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: AFSCME California; California Labor Federation; California State Council Service Employees International Union; and, Orange County Employees Association oppose this bill stating:
We are not inherently opposed to remote proceedings and recognize that the option can sometimes benefit the court and its users. However, we cannot ignore the limitations of remote technology when an individual’s liberty or right to justice is at stake. Proponents of remote proceedings tout its convenience -- but our justice system can never be allowed to prioritize convenience over equitable access to justice.
Access to remote technology is inequitable, and even those with access are not always comfortable using it. We must consider the digital divide, which disproportionately impacts indigent youth, families, and communities of color. Not everyone has a personal computer or space in their homes or elsewhere to safely and privately participate in remote proceedings. A party should not be prejudiced by lack of access or inability to use remote technology effectively.
Additionally, the frequency of internet disconnections, glitches, microphone issues, and background noise during remote proceedings threatens the integrity of verbatim transcripts, which are integral to the justice system. Court reporters are keenly aware of every glitch and interruption, even if they seem insignificant to other parties, because court reporters are solely responsible for maintaining an accurate verbatim transcript. An inaccurate or incomplete transcript can deny someone justice or wrongly strip someone’s liberty.
This is precisely why some proceedings must be conducted in person. In-person proceedings ensure the reporter can capture everything said in court, substantially diminish issues such as witness tampering, and allows jurors and attorneys to physically see witnesses to assess their credibility and demeanor.
Finally, there have been documented incidents of unknown parties infiltrating remote proceedings and using the chat function to masquerade as lawyers or court employees requesting fees from unsuspecting litigants. Unknown parties have also entered remote proceedings and played pornographic content or, in at least one instance, committed a sexual act on camera. This raises serious issues regarding the security of these proceedings and those participating in them. The Legislature must establish thoughtful guidelines on when and how remote proceedings should be used, and how to ensure the security of the proceedings.
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
5/10/23 15:29:05
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 99 Hearing Date: April 25, 2023
Author: | Umberg | ||
Version: | April 10, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Courts: remote proceedings for criminal cases
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: AB 199 (Budget) Chapter 57, Stats. 2022
SB 848 (Umberg) failed on concurrence 2022
SB 241 (Umberg) Chapter 214, Stats. 2021
Support: Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles
Opposition: None known
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to extend the sunset for remote proceedings in a criminal court.
Existing law provides that in all cases in which the accused is charges with a misdemeanor only, they may appear by counsel only, except in domestic violence or driving under the influence cases. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
Existing law provides that, in a misdemeanor, if the accused agrees, the initial court appearance, arraignment, plea, and all other proceedings, except jury and court trials, may be conducted remotely through the use of technology. (Penal Code § 977(a)(1))
Existing law provides that in all cases in which a felony is charged, the accused shall be physically present at the arraignment, at the time of plea, during the preliminary hearing, during the portions of the trial when evidence is taken before the trier of fact, and at the time of imposition of sentence. The accused shall be physically or remotely present at all other proceedings unless they waive their right to be physically or remotely present, with leave of court and with approval of defendant’s counsel. (Penal Code § 977(b)(1))
Existing law provides that upon waiver of the right to be physically present by the defendant, criminal proceedings may be conducted through the use of remote technology, except a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor shall not appear remotely for a jury trial or court trial and a defendant charged with a felony shall not appear remotely at sentencing, except for post-conviction relief proceedings. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1) (A)(D)(E)))
Existing law provides that the court my specifically direct the defendant, either personally or through counsel to be present at a particular felony proceeding or portion thereof. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(B))
Existing law provides that if the defendant is represented by counsel, the attorney shall not be required to be physically present with the defendant if remote technology allows for private communication between the defendant and attorney prior to and during the proceedings, unless, upon the request of defense counsel the court allows the appearance without private communication. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(C))
Existing law provides that a witness may appear at a misdemeanor or felony criminal proceeding, except for a felony trial, remotely. (Penal Code § 977(c)(1)(F))
Existing law provides that a felony defendant who does not wish to be physically or remotely present for noncritical portions of the trial when no testimonial evidence is taken may make an oral waiver in open court prior to the proceeding, or may submit a written request to the court, which the court may grant in its discretion. (Penal Code § 977(c)(2))
Existing law provides that notwithstanding any other provision, the court may allow a defendant to appear by counsel at trial or any other proceeding, if the court finds that: the defendant is in custody and refusing, without good cause, to appear; the defendant has been informed of their right to be personally present; the defendant has been informed that the trial or other proceeding will go on without them; the defendant has been informed of their right to remain silent; the defendant has been informed their absence will constitute a voluntary waiver of their constitutional rights; and, the defendant has been informed whether or not defense counsel will be present. (Penal Code § 977(d)(1))
Existing law provides that a court may, as appropriate and practicable, allow a prosecuting attorney and defense counsel to participate in a criminal proceeding without being physically present. (Penal Code § 977(e))
Existing law provides that except as provided by law, the court shall require a prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, defendant, or witness to appear in person at a proceeding, if any of the following conditions are present and cannot be resolved in a reasonable amount of time:
- The Court does not have the technology necessary to conduct the proceeding remotely.
- Although the court has the requisite technology, the quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents the effective management or resolution of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits the court reporter’s ability to prepare a transcript of the proceeding.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding prevents defense counsel from being able to provide effective representation to the defendant.
- The quality of the technology or audibility at a proceeding inhibits a court interpreter’s ability to provide language access, including the ability to communicate and translate directly the defendant and the court during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(f))
Existing law provides that before the court conducts a remote proceeding, the court shall have a process for a defendant, defense counsel, prosecuting attorney, witness, official reporter, court interpreter, or other court personnel to alert the judicial officer of technological or audibility issues that arise during the proceeding. (Penal Code § 977(g)(1))
Existing law provides that the official court reporter shall be physically present in the courtroom when remote proceedings are conducted. (Penal Code § 977(g)(2))
Existing law provides that the provisions allowing remote proceedings in criminal cases shall sunset on January 1, 2024.
This bill extends the sunset until January 1, 2028.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
In 2022, Governor Newsom signed AB 199, which, among other things, authorizes, until January 2024, a party to appear remotely and a court to conduct criminal proceedings through the use of remote technology, though with certain exceptions, such as prohibiting a defendant charged with a felony to appear remotely for sentencing, except as specified, and a defendant charged with a felony or misdemeanor to appear remotely for a jury or court trial, except as specified. In People v. Lujan, the court ruled that trial courts have an “inherent authority to implement a plethora of alternate procedures for witness testimony”, such as allowing for remote testimonies. This has been reaffirmed in other cases such as People v. Whitmore, Chaparro v. State, United States v. Rosenschein, People v. Lindsey, Maryland v. Craig, and more.
2. Remote proceedings in Criminal cases
Prior to COVID-19, with the exception of appearances that could be waived, defendants in criminal cases generally appeared in person, with the option of remote appearances limited to in-custody defendants. The Emergency Rules generally allowed defendants and attorneys to appear remotely in proceedings with the consent of the defendant. Prior to the June 30, 2022, sunset of the Emergency Rules and through the budget process, discussions were had amongst interested parties to continue remote appearances in criminal cases. The Courts, Public Defenders, District Attorneys, Probation, Sheriffs, and various criminal justice groups were supportive of the final version of the legislation. The result was a continuation of remote proceedings with some changes to what had been in place during the Emergency Rules. The new provisions, which are currently in place, provide:
- Misdemeanors: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Felonies: Defendants may appear remotely in all proceedings except trials and sentencing, unless the court allows a waiver for non-critical, non-testimonial portions of the trial. Remote proceedings are allowed for post-conviction relief proceedings. Attorneys may appear remotely if the court finds it appropriate and practicable.
- Witnesses: may testify remotely except for felony trials, and only with the consent of both parties and the court.
- Court reporters: must be physically present in a courtroom when remote proceedings occur and cannot be retaliated against for reporting technology and audibility issues.
- Courts must have a process for participants to alert the court of audibility or technology issues before and during a proceeding and shall require a person to appear in person if the issues cannot resolved.
The statutes authorizing these remote appearances in criminal cases are set to sunset on January 1, 2024. This bill will extend that sunset to January 1, 2028.
3. Some concerns raised by opponents.
While all parties seem to see some value in having remote appearances there are still some concerns. A few of them are:
- The current law and this bill require the court reporter to be present in “a courtroom” during the proceedings. Court reporters have raised concerns that they want to be not in any courtroom but in the courtroom with the judges so they can more accurately monitor how any issues with the technology and the judge will also be aware of the issues. Judicial Council has noted that, even pre-covid, there may be emergency situations where the court reporter can’t physically get to the courtroom—the most common example is a big snow storm in the Tahoe area. Speedy trial rights may not allow for continuances in this situation. The author may wish to consider amending the bill to provide that generally the court reporter should be with the judge but allow for extraordinary circumstances to create an exception.
- Court interpreters have similar concerns but they would like whenever possible to be with the person for whom they are interpreting.
- Court reporters would like some way to put on the record when they raise an objection to problems with the technology and the court orders the proceedings to continue.
- There is a question as to whether habeas and other post-conviction proceedings should fall under the same rules and criminal trials.
4. Diversion Courts
While the in general, in courts allowing remote proceedings it will be up to the defendant whether or not to appear remotely, should diversion courts have different policies? Should it be clear that a judge in a drug or mental health diversion court, for example, can order a defendant appear in person?
5. Unavailability of court reporters
With a shortage of court reporters, especially in some of the less populated counties, should there be come alternative way to keep a record so that a defendant’s right to a speedy trial is not infringed upon if there is no reporter available?
6. PPIC report
The Public Policy Institute of California recently released a report on remote proceedings during COVID. Among the findings were the fact that conviction rates decreased and sentencing resulted in less prison sentences under remote hearing procedures during the pandemic. Specifically the reports key takeaways were:
This report chronicles how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the courts in 2020, describes policy responses, and assesses the impact of remote hearing policies on conviction and sentencing outcomes within six months of arrest.
- Pandemic conditions challenged the courts’ capacity to resolve cases. An estimated 55,000 criminal cases that would have completed within six months remained unresolved at the end of 2020.
- Courts acted swiftly to adapt to pandemic conditions. Three main strategies included modifying pretrial release to reduce jail populations, permitting remote hearings, and extending case timelines.
- Uneven adoption of policies, coupled with geographic differences in where people live, meant that Black and Latino defendants had greater potential than people of other races to experience pandemic policies.
- Remote hearing policies reinforced pandemic trends for lower conviction rates, but counteracted trends in sentencing. When remote hearing policies were in place, rates of conviction within six months of arrest fell, with outcomes for white, Latino, and Black people driving this result. Misdemeanor convictions were less likely to lead to jail and more likely to receive noncustodial sentences such as probation and money sanctions, mainly for white, Latino, and Black people. Felony convictions were less likely to result in prison and more likely to lead to jail, and outcomes for Black people dominated this result.
- Remote hearing policies contributed to racial differences in criminal case outcomes. Inequity in conviction and jail sentence rates narrowed between white and Latino defendants and between white and Black defendants. By contrast, racial inequity widened in the likelihood of being sentenced to money sanctions and probation.
Arguably, whether a criminal proceeding is conducted virtually or in person should not influence whether a person is convicted or how they are sentenced; yet remote hearing policies have affected both. Before Assembly Bill 199 expires, policymakers will need to determine whether these outcomes are desirable and how to factor them into decisions about whether to allow criminal cases to proceed remotely. (Harris, Heather, PPIC “Public Policymaking and Changed Outcomes in Criminal Courts, April 2023. https://www.ppic.org/publication/pandemic-policymaking-and-changed-outcomes-in-criminal-courts/)
6. SB 22 (Umberg)
This Committee heard this bill within SB 22 on March 21. These Penal Code provisions were separated from the Juvenile and commitment proceedings to ease the discussions of all provisions and because the sunset date on these provisions was later. This Committee passed SB 22 with a vote of 5-0 with an understanding that the author would continue to work with all interested parties to fine tune the use of remote proceedings in all matters.
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):