SCA 1: Elections: recall of state officers.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-10
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-10: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Res. Chapter 204, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Constitution provides that voters may recall a state officer by majority vote and, in the same election, elect a successor with a plurality of the vote. The Constitution prohibits an officer who is the subject of a recall election from being a candidate for successor.
The Constitution provides that the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor, and requires the Lieutenant Governor to act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the state, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office. When a recall of the Governor is initiated, the Constitution requires the Lieutenant Governor to perform the recall duties of the Governor. The Constitution requires the Governor to fill vacancies in certain judicial and executive offices by appointment, as specified.
This measure would eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and instead provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with the Constitution and statute. The measure would repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but would prohibit the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
If the Governor is removed from office in a recall election, this measure would provide that the Lieutenant Governor will become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, the measure would provide for a special election to be held to replace the Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term, to be consolidated with the next statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. The measure would require the Secretary of State to perform the recall duties of the Governor when a recall of the Governor is initiated. The measure would require the Controller to perform the recall duties of the Governor and Secretary of State if recalls of those two officers are initiated at the same time.
If adopted by the Legislature, the measure would appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
The California Constitution provides that voters may recall a state officer by majority vote and, in the same election, elect a successor with a plurality of the vote. The Constitution prohibits an officer who is the subject of a recall election from being a candidate for successor.
The Constitution provides that the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor, and requires the Lieutenant Governor to act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the state, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office. When a recall of the Governor is initiated, the Constitution requires the Lieutenant Governor to perform the recall duties of the Governor. The Constitution requires the Governor to fill vacancies in certain judicial and executive offices by appointment, as specified.
This measure would eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and instead provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with the Constitution and statute. The measure would repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but would prohibit the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
If the Governor is removed from office in a recall election, this measure would provide that the Lieutenant Governor will become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, the measure would provide for a special election to be held to replace the Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term, to be consolidated with the next statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. The measure would require the Secretary of State to perform the recall duties of the Governor when a recall of the Governor is initiated. The measure would require the Controller to perform the recall duties of the Governor and Secretary of State if recalls of those two officers are initiated at the same time.
If adopted by the Legislature, the measure would appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
The California Constitution provides that voters may recall a state officer by majority vote and, in the same election, elect a successor with a plurality of the vote. The Constitution prohibits an officer who is the subject of a recall election from being a candidate for successor.
The Constitution provides that the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor, and requires the Lieutenant Governor to act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the state, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office. When a recall of the Governor is initiated, the Constitution requires the Lieutenant Governor to perform the recall duties of the Governor. The Constitution requires the Governor to fill vacancies in certain judicial and executive offices by appointment, as specified.
This measure would eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and instead provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with the Constitution and statute. The measure would repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but would prohibit the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
If the Governor is removed from office in a recall election, this measure would provide that the Lieutenant Governor will become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, the measure would provide for a special election to be held to replace the Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term, to be consolidated with the next statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. The measure would require the Secretary of State to perform the recall duties of the Governor when a recall of the Governor is initiated. The measure would require the Controller to perform the recall duties of the Governor and Secretary of State if recalls of those two officers are initiated at the same time.
If adopted by the Legislature, the measure would appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
The California Constitution provides that voters may recall a state officer by majority vote and, in the same election, elect a successor with a plurality of the vote. The Constitution prohibits an officer who is the subject of a recall election from being a candidate for successor.
The Constitution provides that the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor, and requires the Lieutenant Governor to act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the state, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office. When a recall of the Governor is initiated, the Constitution requires the Lieutenant Governor to perform the recall duties of the Governor. The Constitution requires the Governor to fill vacancies in certain judicial and executive offices by appointment, as specified.
This measure would eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and instead provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with the Constitution and statute. The measure would repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but would prohibit the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
If the Governor is removed from office in a recall election, this measure would provide that the Lieutenant Governor will become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, the measure would provide for a special election to be held to replace the Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term, to be consolidated with the next statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. The measure would require the Secretary of State to perform the recall duties of the Governor when a recall of the Governor is initiated. The measure would require the Controller to perform the recall duties of the Governor and Secretary of State if recalls of those two officers are initiated at the same time.
Resolved by the Senate, the Assembly concurring, That the Legislature of the State of California at its 202324 Regular Session commencing on the fifth day of December 2022, two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring, hereby proposes to the people of the State of California that the Constitution of the State be amended as follows:
(a)An election to determine whether to recall an officer shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures.
(b)A recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equal at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
(c)If the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and the office shall be vacant. The vacancy shall be filled in accordance with this Constitution and statute, provided that the officer who was the subject of the recall election shall not be appointed to fill the vacancy in that office.
If recall of the Governor or Secretary of State is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Secretary of State or Controller, respectively. If recalls of the Governor and Secretary of State are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
(a)The Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 15 of Article II, if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. If a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
(c)The Lieutenant Governor shall act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the State, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office.
(d)The Legislature shall provide an order of precedence after the Lieutenant Governor for succession to the office of Governor and for the temporary exercise of the Governors functions.
(e)The Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction to determine all questions arising under this section.
(f)Standing to raise questions of vacancy or temporary disability is vested exclusively in a body provided by statute.
This measure shall appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
Resolved by the Senate, the Assembly concurring, That the Legislature of the State of California at its 202324 Regular Session commencing on the fifth day of December 2022, two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring, hereby proposes to the people of the State of California that the Constitution of the State be amended as follows:
(a)An election to determine whether to recall an officer shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures.
(b)A recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equal at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
(c)If the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and the office shall be vacant. The vacancy shall be filled in accordance with this Constitution and statute, provided that the officer who was the subject of the recall election shall not be appointed to fill the vacancy in that office.
If recall of the Governor or Secretary of State is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Secretary of State or Controller, respectively. If recalls of the Governor and Secretary of State are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
(a)The Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 15 of Article II, if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. If a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
(c)The Lieutenant Governor shall act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the State, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office.
(d)The Legislature shall provide an order of precedence after the Lieutenant Governor for succession to the office of Governor and for the temporary exercise of the Governors functions.
(e)The Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction to determine all questions arising under this section.
(f)Standing to raise questions of vacancy or temporary disability is vested exclusively in a body provided by statute.
This measure shall appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
Resolved by the Senate, the Assembly concurring, That the Legislature of the State of California at its 202324 Regular Session commencing on the fifth day of December 2022, two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring, hereby proposes to the people of the State of California that the Constitution of the State be amended as follows:
(a)An election to determine whether to recall an officer shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures.
(b)A recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equal at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
(c)If the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and the office shall be vacant. The vacancy shall be filled in accordance with this Constitution and statute, provided that the officer who was the subject of the recall election shall not be appointed to fill the vacancy in that office.
If recall of the Governor or Secretary of State is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Secretary of State or Controller, respectively. If recalls of the Governor and Secretary of State are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
(a)The Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 15 of Article II, if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. If a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
(c)The Lieutenant Governor shall act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the State, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office.
(d)The Legislature shall provide an order of precedence after the Lieutenant Governor for succession to the office of Governor and for the temporary exercise of the Governors functions.
(e)The Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction to determine all questions arising under this section.
(f)Standing to raise questions of vacancy or temporary disability is vested exclusively in a body provided by statute.
This measure shall appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
Resolved by the Senate, the Assembly concurring, That the Legislature of the State of California at its 202324 Regular Session commencing on the fifth day of December 2022, two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring, hereby proposes to the people of the State of California that the Constitution of the State be amended as follows:
(a)An election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures.
(b)A recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equal at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
(c)If the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and, if there is a candidate, the candidate who receives a plurality is the successor. The officer may not be a candidate, nor shall there be any candidacy for an office filled pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 16 of Article VI. and the office shall be vacant. The vacancy shall be filled in accordance with this Constitution and statute, provided that the officer who was the subject of the recall election shall not be appointed to fill the vacancy in that office.
If recall of the Governor or Secretary of State is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor Secretary of State or Controller, respectively. If recalls of the Governor and Secretary of State are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
(a)The Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 15 of Article II, if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governors term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. If a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
The(c)The Lieutenant Governor shall act as Governor during the impeachment, absence from the State, or other temporary disability of the Governor or of a Governor-elect who fails to take office.
The(d)The Legislature shall provide an order of precedence after the Lieutenant Governor for succession to the office of Governor and for the temporary exercise of the Governors functions.
The(e)The Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction to determine all questions arising under this section.
Standing(f)Standing to raise questions of vacancy or temporary disability is vested exclusively in a body provided by statute.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 10, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Res. Chapter 204, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 10, 2024 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 11 a.m. |
| Aug 31, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 8. Page 5775.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | Read. Adopted. (Ayes 59. Noes 17. Page 6979.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Be adopted as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 3.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (June 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | Referred to Com. on ELECTIONS. |
| Feb 1, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Feb 1, 2024 | Read. Adopted. (Ayes 31. Noes 7. Page 3071.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Be adopted. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 2275.) (September 1). |
| Aug 29, 2023 | Set for hearing September 1. |
| Aug 28, 2023 | August 28 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Aug 24, 2023 | Set for hearing August 28. |
| May 9, 2023 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1. Page 1025.) (May 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Jan 31, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 2. |
| Jan 30, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2024 | Unfinished Business SCA1 Newman et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2024 | SCA 1 Newman Senate Third Reading By Bryan | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Be adopted as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2024 | Be adopted and re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections |
Passed |
|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SCA1 Newman et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Be adopted | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2023 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Common Cause | ** Support | |
| Culver City Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| Election Integrity Project California, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Indivisible Ca: Statestrong | ** Support | |
| League Of Women Voters Of California | ** Support | |
| Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Santa Monica Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D. | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SCA 1 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SCA 1
Author: Newman (D), et al.
Amended: 8/19/24
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 5/8/23
AYES: Glazer, Allen, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Umberg
NOES: Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SENATE FLOOR: 31-7, 2/1/24
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gonzalez, Portantino
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-17, 8/30/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Elections: recall of state officers
SOURCE: Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D.
California Common Cause
League of Women Voters of California
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment, if approved by voters, eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. This constitutional amendment also repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
Assembly Amendments
added a requirement that the measure will appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election if adopted by the Legislature.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- States, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the recall is the power of the voters to remove an elective officer.
- Provides that a recall of a state officer is initiated by delivering to the Secretary of State (SOS) a petition alleging reason for recall. Provides that sufficiency of reason is not reviewable.
- Provides that proponents have 160 days to file signed petitions. Provides that a petition to recall a statewide officer must be signed by electors equal in number to 12 percent of the last vote for the office, with signatures from each of five counties equal in number to one percent of the last vote for the office in the county. Requires that signatures to recall Senators, members of the Assembly, members of the Board of Equalization, and judges of courts of appeal and trial courts equal 20 percent of the last vote for the office. Requires the SOS maintain a continuous count of the signatures certified to that office.
- Provides that an election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures. Provides that a recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equals at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
- Provides that if the majority vote on the question is to recall, then the officer is removed. Provides that if there is a candidate who receives a plurality, they are the successor. Prohibits the targeted state officer from being a successor candidate. Prohibits a successor candidacy for a judicial vacancy if the judge is recalled, as specified.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for circulation, filing, certification of petitions, nomination of candidates, and the recall election.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor or SOS is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor or Controller, respectively.
- Provides that a state officer who is not recalled shall be reimbursed by the State for the officer’s recall election expenses legally and personally incurred. Prohibits another recall from being initiated against the officer until six months after the election.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for the recall of local officers unless a county or city provides for recall within their respective charters.
- Requires a local recall election to include only the question of whether the local elected officer should be removed from office, as specified. Prohibits the successor election for a local office from occurring at the same time as the recall election of a local elected officer, and requires the office, if a local officer is recalled, to become vacant until the position is filled according to existing law.
This constitutional amendment:
- Eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. Repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the SOS instead of the Lieutenant Governor. Provides that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Requires, notwithstanding a specified section in the California Constitution, the Lieutenant Governor become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term that if the Governor is removed from office by recall. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor, be consolidated with the statewide primary election, and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
- Requires this constitutional amendment to appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
- Makes corresponding formatting changes.
Background
Informational Recall Hearings. During the 2021-22 legislative session, the Assembly Elections Committee and the Senate Elections & Constitutional Amendments Committee held a series of joint informational hearings to review California’s recall process following the previous gubernatorial recall election.
At the first hearing on October 28, 2021, the committees heard from current and former elected officials, elections experts, and academics about their perspectives on the state’s recall process and different reform proposals, including increasing the number of signatures for qualifying a statewide recall and changing the method for selecting the successor to a recalled official.
At the second hearing on December 6, 2021, the committees heard from two panels of expert witnesses. The first panel of academics examined a restriction used in several states which only allows recalls to be initiated against an official for certain enumerated causes. The second panel of experts and local elected officials discussed the use of the recall at the local level, along with potential options for reform.
At the third and final recall informational hearing on February 1, 2022, the committees heard from the SOS who shared recommendations for improvements on the state recall process based on her consultation with outside experts and stakeholders.
One of the major takeaways from the committee’s first two hearings was that many of the recall reform proposals would require voter approval in order to take effect. In particular, proposals to make significant structural changes to the recall process at the state level generally require an amendment to the California Constitution. By contrast, changes to the process for recalling local elected officials and certain procedural changes to the state process can be made through statutory changes alone. The third hearing generally reinforced the importance of continuing to evaluate California’s recall processes and that California voters generally support reform of the recall process, but are against any changes to the recall procedure or process that diminish or decrease the voter’s power to recall an elected official.
Recent Changes to Local Recall Elections. In 2022, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022). AB 2582 made changes to the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall. Specifically, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office.
History of Recall Elections. According to the SOS, since 1913 there have been 179 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances. Below is a list of recall attempts of state officials that have qualified for the ballot and the outcome of the election:
Year | Officer | Outcome |
1913 | Senator Marshall Black | Recalled |
1913 | Senator Edwin E. Grant | Recalled |
1914 | Senator James C. Owens | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Senator David Roberti | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Michael Machado | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Paul Horcher | Recalled |
1995 | Assemblymember Doris Allen | Recalled |
2003 | Governor Gray Davis | Recalled |
2007 | Senator Jeffrey Denham | Unsuccessful |
2018 | Senator Josh Newman | Recalled |
2021 | Governor Gavin Newsom | Unsuccessful |
Little Hoover Commission. The Little Hoover Commission (LHC) launched a study in 2021 to consider whether the state’s system for recalling state office-holders should be changed, and if so, how. In its 2022 report, the LHC concluded that the recall system should be retained, both because it is substantively valuable – voters should be able to fire an elected official mid-term – and because it is overwhelmingly popular with voters. However, the report also concluded that substantial changes are needed in California’s recall process.
According to the report, current recall procedures breed the possibility of an undemocratic outcome since they allow a replacement candidate to win office while receiving fewer votes than the incumbent. There is also concern that the recall is subject to potential overuse or abuse. The report made various recommendations, including replacing the existing two-part recall ballot with a “snap” special election in which the official targeted for recall is placed on the ballot with all replacement candidates.
Comments
Author’s Statement. According to the author, “California’s recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022) changed the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall by removing the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer to only include the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office and, if successful, if filled by existing laws for vacated offices.
AB 2584 (Berman, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2022) increased the total number of proponents required to be included on a notice of intention to recall an elected officer, established a public display period for local recall petitions, authorized a voter to seek a writ of mandate or injunction requiring any or all of the statement of the proponents or answer of the officer to be amended or deleted on a recall petition, required a petition for the recall of a school board member to contain a fiscal estimate of the cost for conducting the recall election, and changed the timeframe for when a qualified local recall election is held.
SCA 3 (Allen, 2022) would have eliminated the first question on the recall ballot that asks whether a state official should be recalled, and instead automatically places the incumbent’s name on the recall ballot along with any potential replacement candidates running for the office. If the incumbent receives a plurality of the vote, the recall fails, and if a replacement candidate receives a plurality, the recall succeeds and that candidate is elected.
SCA 6 (Newman, 2022), substantially similar to this measure, would have eliminated the second question on the recall ballot that asks which candidate should replace the recalled official, and instead generally requires the office, if the state officer is recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time costs of approximately $203,000 to the SOS for system modifications to California’s centralized voter registration database (VoteCal) to reflect revised recall procedures (General Fund (GF)). VoteCal updates include design and coding changes to add a new contest type with unique processing and reporting requirements.
- One-time costs of approximately $738,000 to $984,000 to the SOS for printing and mailing expenses associated with placing the measure on the ballot at the next statewide election (GF). Based on the average cost per page for prior elections, the SOS estimates such costs to be approximately $123,000 per page for six to eight pages in the state voter information guide, although actual costs related to this measure will depend on the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
- Costs of an unknown, but likely minor and absorbable, amount to the SOS and Controller to assume recall duties from another office.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/26/224)
Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D. (co-source)
California Common Cause (co-source)
League of Women Voters of California (cosource)
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Culver City Democratic Club
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
Santa Monica Democratic Club
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/26/24)
Election Integrity Project California, Inc.
12 Individuals
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-17, 8/30/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Ortega, Wilson
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
8/31/24 12:47:47
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SCA 1 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SCA 1
Author: Newman (D), et al.
Amended: 8/19/24
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 5/8/23
AYES: Glazer, Allen, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Umberg
NOES: Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SENATE FLOOR: 31-7, 2/1/24
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gonzalez, Portantino
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-15, 8/30/24
(ROLL CALL NOT AVAILABLE)
SUBJECT: Elections: recall of state officers
SOURCE: Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D.
California Common Cause
League of Women Voters of California
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment, if approved by voters, eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. This constitutional amendment also repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
Assembly Amendments
added a requirement that the measure will appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election if adopted by the Legislature.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- States, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the recall is the power of the voters to remove an elective officer.
- Provides that a recall of a state officer is initiated by delivering to the Secretary of State (SOS) a petition alleging reason for recall. Provides that sufficiency of reason is not reviewable.
- Provides that proponents have 160 days to file signed petitions. Provides that a petition to recall a statewide officer must be signed by electors equal in number to 12 percent of the last vote for the office, with signatures from each of five counties equal in number to one percent of the last vote for the office in the county. Requires that signatures to recall Senators, members of the Assembly, members of the Board of Equalization, and judges of courts of appeal and trial courts equal 20 percent of the last vote for the office. Requires the SOS maintain a continuous count of the signatures certified to that office.
- Provides that an election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures. Provides that a recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equals at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
- Provides that if the majority vote on the question is to recall, then the officer is removed. Provides that if there is a candidate who receives a plurality, they are the successor. Prohibits the targeted state officer from being a successor candidate. Prohibits a successor candidacy for a judicial vacancy if the judge is recalled, as specified.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for circulation, filing, certification of petitions, nomination of candidates, and the recall election.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor or SOS is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor or Controller, respectively.
- Provides that a state officer who is not recalled shall be reimbursed by the State for the officer’s recall election expenses legally and personally incurred. Prohibits another recall from being initiated against the officer until six months after the election.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for the recall of local officers unless a county or city provides for recall within their respective charters.
- Requires a local recall election to include only the question of whether the local elected officer should be removed from office, as specified. Prohibits the successor election for a local office from occurring at the same time as the recall election of a local elected officer, and requires the office, if a local officer is recalled, to become vacant until the position is filled according to existing law.
This constitutional amendment:
- Eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. Repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the SOS instead of the Lieutenant Governor. Provides that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Requires, notwithstanding a specified section in the California Constitution, the Lieutenant Governor become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term that if the Governor is removed from office by recall. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor, be consolidated with the statewide primary election, and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
- Requires this constitutional amendment to appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
- Makes corresponding formatting changes.
Background
Informational Recall Hearings. During the 2021-22 legislative session, the Assembly Elections Committee and the Senate Elections & Constitutional Amendments Committee held a series of joint informational hearings to review California’s recall process following the previous gubernatorial recall election.
At the first hearing on October 28, 2021, the committees heard from current and former elected officials, elections experts, and academics about their perspectives on the state’s recall process and different reform proposals, including increasing the number of signatures for qualifying a statewide recall and changing the method for selecting the successor to a recalled official.
At the second hearing on December 6, 2021, the committees heard from two panels of expert witnesses. The first panel of academics examined a restriction used in several states which only allows recalls to be initiated against an official for certain enumerated causes. The second panel of experts and local elected officials discussed the use of the recall at the local level, along with potential options for reform.
At the third and final recall informational hearing on February 1, 2022, the committees heard from the SOS who shared recommendations for improvements on the state recall process based on her consultation with outside experts and stakeholders.
One of the major takeaways from the committee’s first two hearings was that many of the recall reform proposals would require voter approval in order to take effect. In particular, proposals to make significant structural changes to the recall process at the state level generally require an amendment to the California Constitution. By contrast, changes to the process for recalling local elected officials and certain procedural changes to the state process can be made through statutory changes alone. The third hearing generally reinforced the importance of continuing to evaluate California’s recall processes and that California voters generally support reform of the recall process, but are against any changes to the recall procedure or process that diminish or decrease the voter’s power to recall an elected official.
Recent Changes to Local Recall Elections. In 2022, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022). AB 2582 made changes to the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall. Specifically, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office.
History of Recall Elections. According to the SOS, since 1913 there have been 179 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances. Below is a list of recall attempts of state officials that have qualified for the ballot and the outcome of the election:
Year | Officer | Outcome |
1913 | Senator Marshall Black | Recalled |
1913 | Senator Edwin E. Grant | Recalled |
1914 | Senator James C. Owens | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Senator David Roberti | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Michael Machado | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Paul Horcher | Recalled |
1995 | Assemblymember Doris Allen | Recalled |
2003 | Governor Gray Davis | Recalled |
2007 | Senator Jeffrey Denham | Unsuccessful |
2018 | Senator Josh Newman | Recalled |
2021 | Governor Gavin Newsom | Unsuccessful |
Little Hoover Commission. The Little Hoover Commission (LHC) launched a study in 2021 to consider whether the state’s system for recalling state office-holders should be changed, and if so, how. In its 2022 report, the LHC concluded that the recall system should be retained, both because it is substantively valuable – voters should be able to fire an elected official mid-term – and because it is overwhelmingly popular with voters. However, the report also concluded that substantial changes are needed in California’s recall process.
According to the report, current recall procedures breed the possibility of an undemocratic outcome since they allow a replacement candidate to win office while receiving fewer votes than the incumbent. There is also concern that the recall is subject to potential overuse or abuse. The report made various recommendations, including replacing the existing two-part recall ballot with a “snap” special election in which the official targeted for recall is placed on the ballot with all replacement candidates.
Comments
Author’s Statement. According to the author, “California’s recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022) changed the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall by removing the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer to only include the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office and, if successful, if filled by existing laws for vacated offices.
AB 2584 (Berman, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2022) increased the total number of proponents required to be included on a notice of intention to recall an elected officer, established a public display period for local recall petitions, authorized a voter to seek a writ of mandate or injunction requiring any or all of the statement of the proponents or answer of the officer to be amended or deleted on a recall petition, required a petition for the recall of a school board member to contain a fiscal estimate of the cost for conducting the recall election, and changed the timeframe for when a qualified local recall election is held.
SCA 3 (Allen, 2022) would have eliminated the first question on the recall ballot that asks whether a state official should be recalled, and instead automatically places the incumbent’s name on the recall ballot along with any potential replacement candidates running for the office. If the incumbent receives a plurality of the vote, the recall fails, and if a replacement candidate receives a plurality, the recall succeeds and that candidate is elected.
SCA 6 (Newman, 2022), substantially similar to this measure, would have eliminated the second question on the recall ballot that asks which candidate should replace the recalled official, and instead generally requires the office, if the state officer is recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time costs of approximately $203,000 to the SOS for system modifications to California’s centralized voter registration database (VoteCal) to reflect revised recall procedures (General Fund (GF)). VoteCal updates include design and coding changes to add a new contest type with unique processing and reporting requirements.
- One-time costs of approximately $738,000 to $984,000 to the SOS for printing and mailing expenses associated with placing the measure on the ballot at the next statewide election (GF). Based on the average cost per page for prior elections, the SOS estimates such costs to be approximately $123,000 per page for six to eight pages in the state voter information guide, although actual costs related to this measure will depend on the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
- Costs of an unknown, but likely minor and absorbable, amount to the SOS and Controller to assume recall duties from another office.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/26/224)
Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D. (co-source)
California Common Cause (co-source)
League of Women Voters of California (cosource)
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Culver City Democratic Club
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
Santa Monica Democratic Club
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/26/24)
Election Integrity Project California, Inc.
12 Individuals
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
8/30/24 17:27:14
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SCA 1
Author:(Newman)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2024
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Provides for a state recall election to include only the question of whether the elected officer sought to be recalled should be removed from office. Requires the office, if a state officer is successfully recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Repeals a provision of the California Constitution that generally requires an election to determine whether to recall a state officer to include the election of a successor if the recall is successful.
- Provides that an office is vacant and shall be filled in accordance with the California Constitution and state statute if a majority of voters vote to recall the state officer who holds that office. Prohibits the recalled officer from being appointed to fill that vacancy.
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS), rather than the Lieutenant Governor, to perform the duties of the Governor related to a recall if the recall is initiated against the Governor. Specifies that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
- Requires this measure to appear on the ballot at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
COMMENTS
According to the SOS, since 1913, there have been 180 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls, and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances.
According to information from the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), 19 states allow voters to recall state officials and at least 30 states provide a recall process for local officials. The procedures for qualifying and conducting a recall differ significantly between those 19 states. Based on information from NCSL, the Little Hoover Commission, and Assembly Elections Committee staff research, California is one of only two states (along with Colorado) that hold the recall and replacement elections simultaneously for any recall of a state official, with both questions appearing on the same ballot. (New Jersey holds recall elections in this manner for state offices other than Governor and state Legislature, but has different rules for gubernatorial and legislative recalls.) Five states (Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, North Dakota, and Wisconsin) conduct recall elections using a “snap election” process, under which the public official who is the target of the recall is listed on the ballot along with all replacement candidates. If the incumbent receives the most votes in the election, the recall fails and the incumbent remains in office. If a replacement candidate receives the most votes, the recall succeeds and that candidate takes office. (Michigan does not use a "snap election" process for gubernatorial recalls. Instead, for gubernatorial recalls, Michigan voters are asked whether they want to recall the Governor; if a majority vote "yes," then the Governor is removed and replaced in accordance with the state’s succession rules.) The remaining states that permit recalls of elective state officers generally conduct an election where voters are asked a single question of whether they want to recall the officer in question. If that recall is successful, the resulting vacancy is filled either in accordance with relevant succession rules, by appointment, or by a subsequent special election.
Until last year, local recall elections held in California generally were conducted in a similar manner to how state recall elections are conducted: namely, as a two-part election where voters were asked (1) whether the targeted official should be recalled, and (2) if the recall is successful, who should replace the recalled officer. In 2022, however, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett), Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022. For local jurisdictions that do not have a charter provision that provides for recall, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office. Any vacancy created as the result of a successful recall election under AB 2582 is filled in the same manner as a vacancy in that office otherwise would be filled.
If this constitutional amendment is approved by voters, it generally would align the process for recalls of elected state officials with the process that now applies to recalls for elected local officials under AB 2582.
As a constitutional amendment, this measure requires the approval of the voters to take effect. One provision of this measure requires it to be submitted to the voters at the November 3, 2026, statewide general election.
When a legislative measure qualifies for the ballot, Section 9040 of the Elections Code generally requires it to appear on the ballot at the first statewide election that is at least 131 days after the Legislature approves it. In light of that statutory provision, if this measure is approved during the current legislative session, existing law would require it to appear on the ballot before November 2026.
However, SB 863 (Allen) of the current legislative session, which is pending in the Senate, would allow a legislative constitutional amendment to specify the statewide election at which it will appear on the ballot. If SB 863 becomes law, it likely will go into effect before the SOS designates the election at which this measure will be submitted to the voters. In that situation, the provision of this measure requiring it to appear on the November 2026 statewide general election ballot may be operative when the SOS designates the election at which this measure will appear on the ballot.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this measure.
According to the Author
"California's recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason."
Arguments in Support
In a joint letter of support for this measure, the League of Women Voters of California and California Common Cause (two of the co-sponsors of this measure) write, "Under current law, an off-cycle special election may be held for a recall, in which voters are presented with two questions - whether an officer should be recalled and who should replace the officeholder. While the first question requires a majority vote to remove the elected official, the second question allows a replacement candidate to be chosen by a slim plurality. Our state's most important leaders can therefore be picked at low-turnout elections with non-representative electorates, and replacements can be put into office with low plurality support, rather than a majority of voters in the election. Furthermore, voters have expressed deep confusion as to whether they are permitted to vote for a replacement candidate if they vote "no" on the first question. The perplexing system can cause people to refrain from answering the second question, thereby disenfranchising voters, and contributing to an undervote for replacement candidates…SCA 1…would retain access to the recall, but in a way that should ensure recall outcomes are democratic and broadly supported and will help to eliminate recalls that are frivolous or degrade democratic legitimacy."
Arguments in Opposition
In opposition to this measure, Election Integrity Project California, Inc., writes, "On the rare occasion when a recall of a sitting state Governor is qualified, it is the people's right not only to vote to oust the person in question, but to choose a replacement… The Lieutenant Governor is almost always on the same partisan and ideological 'page' as the Governor, and as such would be just as unacceptable to the citizenry as the person they are 'firing.' The proposal of SCA 1 that the Lieutenant Governor simply assume the governorship in the event of a successful recall would make a gubernatorial recall effort a 'frying pan vs the fire' situation, and monumentally suppress not only the people's right to self-govern but their eagerness to participate in government at all. Every step should be taken to encourage full participation of all eligible voters in making the decisions and choices that affect their lives and keep our Republic not only strong but also responsive to its constituents. SCA 1 is definitely a step in the wrong direction."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time costs of approximately $203,000 to the SOS for system modifications to California's centralized voter registration database (VoteCal) to reflect revised recall procedures (General Fund (GF)). VoteCal updates include design and coding changes to add a new contest type with unique processing and reporting requirements.
- One-time costs of approximately $738,000 to $984,000 to the SOS for printing and mailing expenses associated with placing the measure on the ballot at the next statewide election (GF). Based on the average cost per page for prior elections, the SOS estimates such costs to be approximately $123,000 per page for six to eight pages in the state voter information guide, although actual costs related to this measure will depend on the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
- Costs of an unknown, but likely minor and absorbable, amount to the SOS and Controller to assume recall duties from another office.
According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 31-7-2
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gonzalez, Portantino
ASM ELECTIONS: 6-2-0
YES: Pellerin, Bennett, Berman, Cervantes, Low, Weber
NO: Lackey, Essayli
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-3-1
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jim Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2024
CONSULTANT: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0004076
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SCA 1
Author:(Newman) – As Introduced Ver:January 30, 2023
Policy Committee: | Elections | Vote: | 6 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This measure revises the recall process for elected state officers.
Specifically, this measure:
- Requires, instead of a successor election for a recalled state officer, the office to remain vacant upon recall of the officer, until the office is filled pursuant to the applicable process.
- Prohibits the recalled officer from being appointed to fill the vacant office.
- Provides that if the Governor is recalled from office, the Lieutenant Governor (LG) becomes the Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. If the removal occurs during the first two years of the Governor’s term, before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election, a special election must be called to replace the Governor. The special election must be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, because no candidate initially receives a majority of votes, the subsequent statewide general election for the top two vote-getters.
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS), instead of the LG, to perform duties associated with a recall of the Governor, and provides that if a recall of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, duties associated with the recall of both offices shift to the Controller.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time costs of approximately $203,000 to the SOS for system modifications to California’s centralized voter registration database (VoteCal) to reflect revised recall procedures (General Fund (GF)). VoteCal updates include design and coding changes to add a new contest type with unique processing and reporting requirements.
- One-time costs of approximately $738,000 to $984,000 to the SOS for printing and mailing expenses associated with placing the measure on the ballot at the next statewide election (GF). Based on the average cost per page for prior elections, the SOS estimates such costs to be approximately $123,000 per page for six to eight pages in the state voter information guide, although actual costs related to this measure will depend on the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
- Costs of an unknown, but likely minor and absorbable, amount to the SOS and Controller to assume recall duties from another office.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.
- Support and Opposition. This measure is co-sponsored by SOS Shirley N. Weber, League of Women Voters of California, and California Common Cause, with SOS Weber citing a Public Policy Institute of California survey finding 78% of likely voters believe the recall process is in need of changes, and arguing this measure “updates the process for recalling state officers to enhance the direct democracy power of voters.” This bill is also supported by LG Eleni Kounalakis, Indivisible California: StateStrong, and community groups.
This measure is opposed by Election Integrity Project California, which argues the proposal that “the [LG] simply assume the governorship in the event of a successful recall would make a gubernatorial recall effort a ‘frying pan vs the fire’ situation, and monumentally suppress not only the people’s right to self-govern but their eagerness to participate in government at all.”
- Recall Elections. According to the SOS, there have been 180 recall attempts of state elected officials since 1913, with eleven efforts collecting enough signatures to qualify for the ballot and the eventual recall of the official in six instances. 19 states allow voters to recall state officials, but California is one of only two states (along with Colorado) to hold a recall and replacement election simultaneously, with both questions appearing on the same ballot. Five other states utilize a “snap election” recall process, under which the public official subject to recall is listed on the ballot along with all replacement candidates. If the incumbent receives the most votes in the election, the recall fails and the incumbent remains in office. If a replacement candidate receives the most votes, the recall succeeds and that candidate takes office. The remaining states generally conduct a recall election by asking voters a single question of whether they want to recall the officer in question, and if that recall is successful, the resulting vacancy is either filled in accordance with relevant succession rules, by appointment, or by a subsequent special election.
Until last year, local recall elections in California were generally conducted in a similar manner to state recall elections. However, for local jurisdictions that do not have charter provisions regarding a recall, AB 2582 (Bennett), Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022, separated the successor candidate question from the recall question, so the recall election includes only the question of whether the officer subject to recall should be removed from office, with an ensuing vacancy filled in the same manner a vacancy for that office would otherwise be filled. If approved by voters, this measure would generally align the recall process for state officials with the new recall process for local officials.
- Prior Measures. SCA 6 (Newman), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, was similar to this measure. SCA 6 was referred to, but not heard by, the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SCA 2 (Allen), of the 2019-2020 Legislative Session, if approved by voters, would have provided for a “snap election” recall process, but was subsequently amended after referral to the Assembly Elections Committee to address an issue relating to property tax assessment.
SCA 18 (Allen), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, if approved by voters, would have increased, from a majority to 55%, the vote threshold required to recall a state officer. SCA 18 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
Gail Pellerin, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SCA 1
Author:(Newman) – As Introduced Ver:January 30, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 31-7
SUBJECT: Elections: recall of state officers.
SUMMARY: Provides for a state recall election to include only the question of whether the elected officer sought to be recalled should be removed from office. Requires the office, if a state officer is successfully recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law, as specified. Specifically, this measure:
- Repeals a provision of the California Constitution that generally requires an election to determine whether to recall a state officer to include the election of a successor if the recall is successful.
- Provides that an office is vacant and shall be filled in accordance with the California Constitution and state statute if a majority of voters vote to recall the state officer who holds that office. Prohibits the recalled officer from being appointed to fill that vacancy.
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS), rather than the Lieutenant Governor, to perform the duties of the Governor related to a recall if the recall is initiated against the Governor. Specifies that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall, the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor and shall be consolidated with the statewide primary election and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that recall is the power of the electors to remove an elective officer. (California Constitution, Article II, §13) Provides that the recall of a state officer is initiated by delivering to the SOS a petition alleging reason for recall that is signed by a specified number of electors. (California Constitution, Article II, §14)
- Requires an election to determine whether to recall a state officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor to be called by the Governor, as specified. Provides that if the majority vote on the question is to recall, the officer is removed and, if there is a candidate, the candidate who receives a plurality is the successor. Prohibits the officer who is the subject of the recall from being a candidate in the election to choose a successor. (California Constitution, Article II, §15)
- Provides that if the recall of the Governor or SOS is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor or Controller, respectively. (California Constitution, Article II, §17)
- Provides that the Lieutenant Governor shall become Governor when a vacancy occurs in the office of Governor. (California Constitution, Article V, §10)
- Requires the Governor to nominate a person to fill any vacancy in the office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction, the Lieutenant Governor, SOS, Controller, Treasurer, or Attorney General, or on the State Board of Equalization, and provides that the nominee shall take office upon confirmation by a majority of the membership of the Senate and a majority of the membership of the Assembly and shall hold office for the balance of the unexpired term, as specified. (California Constitution, Article V, §5) Provides that a vacancy in the office of Insurance Commissioner shall be filled in the same manner. (Insurance Code §12900)
- Requires the Governor to call an election to fill a vacancy in the Legislature, as specified. (California Constitution, Article IV, §2(d); Elections Code §§10700-10707; Government Code §1773)
- Requires the Governor to fill vacancies in the office of judge of the Supreme Court or judge of a court of appeal by appointment, as specified. Provides that an appointment by the Governor is effective when confirmed by the Commission on Judicial Appointments. (California Constitution, Article VI, §16(d))
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this measure would result in one-time General Fund costs to the SOS in the range of $738,000 to $984,000, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Measure: According to the author:
California’s recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.
- Recall Informational Hearings: In late-2021 and early-2022, this committee held a series of joint informational hearings with the Senate Elections & Constitutional Amendments Committee to review California’s recall process following the September 2021 gubernatorial recall election.
At the first hearing, on October 28, 2021, the committees heard from current and former elected officials, elections experts, and academics about their perspectives on the state’s recall process and different reform proposals, including increasing the number of signatures for qualifying a statewide recall and changing the method for selecting the successor to a recalled official.
At the second hearing, on December 6, 2021, the committees heard from two panels of expert witnesses. The first panel of academics examined a limitation, used in several states, which only allows recalls to be initiated against an official for certain enumerated causes. The second panel of experts and local elected officials discussed the use of the recall at the local level, along with potential options for reform.
At the third and final recall informational hearing, on February 1, 2022, the committees heard from the SOS, who shared recommendations for improvements on the state recall process based on her consultation with outside experts and stakeholders. The committees also received an overview from Dr. Mark Baldassare, the President and Chief Executive Officer of the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), regarding its January 2022 statewide survey in which the PPIC asked Californians about their views on the recall process. Dr. Baldassare presented new data from their statewide survey, and discussed whether and how the views of California voters about the recall process have changed over time.
One of the major takeaways from the committee’s first two hearings was that many of the recall reform proposals would require voter approval in order to take effect. In particular, proposals to make significant structural changes to the recall process at the state level generally require an amendment to the California Constitution. By contrast, changes to the process for recalling local elected officials and certain procedural changes to the state process can be made through statutory changes alone. The third hearing generally reinforced the importance of continuing to evaluate California’s recall processes and that California voters generally support reform of the recall process, but are against any changes to the recall procedure or process that diminish or decrease the voter’s power to recall an elected official.
- State Recall History: According to the SOS, since 1913, there have been 180 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls, and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances. Below is a list of recall attempts of state officials that have qualified for the ballot and the outcome of the election:
Year | Officer | Outcome |
1913 | Senator Marshall Black | Recalled |
1913 | Senator Edwin E. Grant | Recalled |
1914 | Senator James C. Owens | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Senator David Roberti | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Michael Machado | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Paul Horcher | Recalled |
1995 | Assemblymember Doris Allen | Recalled |
2003 | Governor Gray Davis | Recalled |
2007 | Senator Jeffrey Denham | Unsuccessful |
2018 | Senator Josh Newman | Recalled |
2021 | Governor Gavin Newsom | Unsuccessful |
The Governor and members of the Legislature have been the most frequent targets of attempts to recall elected state officials. The following information, also from the SOS, details the number of recall attempts initiated against elected state officials by position held since 1913:
Office | Recall Attempts |
Governor | 55 |
Lieutenant Governor | 2 |
Attorney General | 7 |
Secretary of State | 1 |
State Treasurer | 1 |
State Controller | 1 |
Insurance Commissioner | 2 |
Member of the Board of Equalization | 2 |
Member of the State Senate | 31 |
Member of the State Assembly | 50 |
Supreme Court (entire membership) | 1 |
Supreme Court (individual justices) | 27 |
- Other States: According to information from the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), 19 states allow voters to recall state officials and at least 30 states provide a recall process for local officials. The procedures for qualifying and conducting a recall differ significantly between those 19 states.
Based on information from NCSL, the Little Hoover Commission, and committee staff research, California is one of only two states (along with Colorado) that hold the recall and replacement elections simultaneously for any recall of a state official, with both questions appearing on the same ballot. (New Jersey holds recall elections in this manner for state offices other than Governor and state Legislature, but has different rules for gubernatorial and legislative recalls.) Five states (Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, North Dakota, and Wisconsin) conduct recall elections using a “snap election” process, under which the public official who is the target of the recall is listed on the ballot along with all replacement candidates. If the incumbent receives the most votes in the election, the recall fails and the incumbent remains in office. If a replacement candidate receives the most votes, the recall succeeds and that candidate takes office. (Michigan does not use a “snap election” process for gubernatorial recalls. Instead, for gubernatorial recalls, Michigan voters are asked whether they want to recall the Governor; if a majority vote “yes,” then the Governor is removed and replaced in accordance with the state’s succession rules.) The remaining states that permit recalls of elective state officers generally conduct an election where voters are asked a single question of whether they want to recall the officer in question. If that recall is successful, the resulting vacancy is filled either in accordance with relevant succession rules, by appointment, or by a subsequent special election. - Local Recalls and Previous Legislation: Until last year, local recall elections held in California generally were conducted in a similar manner to how state recall elections are conducted: namely, as a two-part election where voters were asked (1) whether the targeted official should be recalled, and (2) if the recall is successful, who should replace the recalled officer. In 2022, however, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett), Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022. For local jurisdictions that do not have a charter provision that provides for recall, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office. Any vacancy created as the result of a successful recall election under AB 2582 is filled in the same manner as a vacancy in that office otherwise would be filled.
If this constitutional amendment is approved by voters, it generally would align the process for recalls of elected state officials with the process that now applies to recalls for elected local officials under AB 2582. - Little Hoover Commission Report: The Little Hoover Commission launched a study in 2021 to consider whether the state’s system for recalling state officeholders should be changed, and if so, how. The study resulted in its February 2022 report, “Reforming the Recall.” In its report, the commission concluded that the recall system should be retained, both because it is substantively valuable—voters should be able to fire an elected official mid-term—and because it is overwhelmingly popular with voters. However, the report also concluded that substantial changes are needed in California’s recall process.
According to the report, current recall procedures breed the possibility of an undemocratic outcome since they allow a replacement candidate to win office while receiving fewer votes than the incumbent. The report also concluded that California’s threshold for qualifying a recall election no longer provides an adequate barrier against potential abuse or overuse of the recall. The report made various recommendations, including replacing the existing two-part recall ballot with a “snap” special election in which the official targeted for recall is placed on the ballot with all replacement candidates.
- Previous Legislation: SCA 18 (Allen) of 2018 (March 6, 2018 version) proposed to repeal the constitutional prohibition on a recall target appearing on the same ballot as a successor candidate to their own recall, among other provisions. SCA 18 was not heard in a policy committee in that form.
SCA 18 (Allen) of 2018 (May 8, 2018 version) proposed to increase the vote required to recall a state officer from a majority to 55 percent. SCA 18 in this form was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
SCA 2 (Allen) of 2019 proposed to eliminate the ballot question of whether or not a candidate should be recalled, except for judicial officers. Instead, SCA 2 would have provided that if a recall qualifies against an officer, other than a judicial officer, the name of the officer would be placed on the ballot as a successor candidate, unless the officer resigned, as specified. If the recall target received a plurality of the vote, the recall would fail. If a different successor candidate received the most votes, the recall would succeed and that successor candidate would be elected. SCA 2 was approved by the Senate, but was not heard in a policy committee in the Assembly in that form, and instead was amended and used for unrelated purposes.
SCA 3 (Allen) of 2021 was identical to SCA 2 (Allen) of 2019. SCA 3 was never heard in a policy committee.
SCA 6 (Newman) of 2022 was similar to this measure. SCA 6 was not heard in a policy committee.
- Arguments in Support: In a joint letter of support for this measure, the League of Women Voters of California and California Common Cause (two of the co-sponsors of this measure) write:
Under current law, an off-cycle special election may be held for a recall, in which voters are presented with two questions - whether an officer should be recalled and who should replace the officeholder. While the first question requires a majority vote to remove the elected official, the second question allows a replacement candidate to be chosen by a slim plurality. Our state’s most important leaders can therefore be picked at low-turnout elections with non-representative electorates, and replacements can be put into office with low plurality support, rather than a majority of voters in the election. Furthermore, voters have expressed deep confusion as to whether they are permitted to vote for a replacement candidate if they vote “no” on the first question. The perplexing system can cause people to refrain from answering the second question, thereby disenfranchising voters, and contributing to an undervote for replacement candidates…
SCA 1…would retain access to the recall, but in a way that should ensure recall outcomes are democratic and broadly supported and will help to eliminate recalls that are frivolous or degrade democratic legitimacy.
- Arguments in Opposition: In opposition to this measure, Election Integrity Project California, Inc., writes:
On the rare occasion when a recall of a sitting state Governor is qualified, it is the people’s right not only to vote to oust the person in question, but to choose a replacement…
The Lieutenant Governor is almost always on the same partisan and ideological “page” as the Governor, and as such would be just as unacceptable to the citizenry as the person they are “firing”.
The proposal of SCA 1 that the Lieutenant Governor simply assume the governorship in the event of a successful recall would make a gubernatorial recall effort a “frying pan vs the fire” situation, and monumentally suppress not only the people’s right to self-govern but their eagerness to participate in government at all.
Every step should be taken to encourage full participation of all eligible voters in making the decisions and choices that affect their lives and keep our Republic not only strong but also responsive to its constituents. SCA 1 is definitely a step in the wrong direction.
- Approval by Voters: As a constitutional amendment, this measure requires the approval of the voters to take effect.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Common Cause (Co-sponsor)
League of Women Voters of California (Co-sponsor)
Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D. (Co-sponsor)
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Santa Monica Democratic Club
Opposition
Election Integrity Project California, Inc.
One individual
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SCA 1 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SCA 1
Author: Newman (D), et al.
Introduced: 1/30/23
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 5/8/23
AYES: Glazer, Allen, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Umberg
NOES: Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Elections: recall of state officers
SOURCE: Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D
California Common Cause
League of Women Voters of California
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment, if approved by voters, eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and provides, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. This constitutional amendment also repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- States, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the recall is the power of the voters to remove an elective officer.
- Provides that a recall of a state officer is initiated by delivering to the Secretary of State (SOS) a petition alleging reason for recall. Provides that sufficiency of reason is not reviewable.
- Provides that proponents have 160 days to file signed petitions. Provides that a petition to recall a statewide officer must be signed by electors equal in number to 12 percent of the last vote for the office, with signatures from each of five counties equal in number to one percent of the last vote for the office in the county. Requires that signatures to recall Senators, members of the Assembly, members of the Board of Equalization, and judges of courts of appeal and trial courts equal 20 percent of the last vote for the office. Requires the SOS maintain a continuous count of the signatures certified to that office.
- Provides that an election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures. Provides that a recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equals at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
- Provides that if the majority vote on the question is to recall, then the officer is removed. Provides that if there is a candidate who receives a plurality, they are the successor. Prohibits the targeted state officer from being a successor candidate. Prohibits a successor candidacy for a judicial vacancy if the judge is recalled, as specified.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for circulation, filing, certification of petitions, nomination of candidates, and the recall election.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor or SOS is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor or Controller, respectively.
- Provides that a state officer who is not recalled shall be reimbursed by the State for the officer’s recall election expenses legally and personally incurred. Prohibits another recall from being initiated against the officer until six months after the election.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for the recall of local officers unless a county or city provides for recall within their respective charters.
- Requires a local recall election to include only the question of whether the local elected officer should be removed from office, as specified. Prohibits the successor election for a local office from occurring at the same time as the recall election of a local elected officer, and requires the office, if a local officer is recalled, to become vacant until the position is filled according to existing law.
This constitutional amendment:
- Eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. Repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the SOS instead of the Lieutenant Governor. Provides that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Requires, notwithstanding a specified section in the California Constitution, the Lieutenant Governor become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term that if the Governor is removed from office by recall. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor, be consolidated with the statewide primary election, and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
- Makes corresponding formatting changes.
Background
Informational Recall Hearings. During the 2021-22 legislative session, the Assembly Committee on Elections and the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee held a series of joint informational hearings to review California’s recall process following the previous gubernatorial recall election.
At the first hearing on October 28, 2021, the committees heard from current and former elected officials, elections experts, and academics about their perspectives on the state’s recall process and different reform proposals, including increasing the number of signatures for qualifying a statewide recall and changing the method for selecting the successor to a recalled official.
At the second hearing on December 6, 2021, the committees heard from two panels of expert witnesses. The first panel of academics examined a limitation used in several states which only allows recalls to be initiated against an official for certain enumerated causes. The second panel of experts and local elected officials discussed the use of the recall at the local level, along with potential options for reform.
At the third and final recall informational hearing on February 1, 2022, the committees heard from the SOS who shared recommendations for improvements on the state recall process based on her consultation with outside experts and stakeholders. The committees also received an overview from Dr. Mark Baldassare, President and Chief Executive Officer of the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), regarding its January 2022 statewide survey in which the PPIC asked Californians about their views on the recall process. Dr. Baldassare presented new data from their statewide survey and discussed whether and how the views of California voters about the recall process have changed since statewide surveys that PPIC conducted in July and November of last year.
One of the major takeaways from the committee’s first two hearings was that many of the recall reform proposals would require voter approval in order to take effect. In particular, proposals to make significant structural changes to the recall process at the state level generally require an amendment to the California Constitution. By contrast, changes to the process for recalling local elected officials and certain procedural changes to the state process can be made through statutory changes alone. The third hearing generally reinforced the importance of continuing to evaluate California’s recall processes and that California voters generally support reform of the recall process, but are against any changes to the recall procedure or process that diminish or decrease the voter’s power to recall an elected official.
Recent Changes to Local Recall Elections. In 2022, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022). AB 2582 made changes to the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall. Specifically, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office.
History of Recall Elections. According to the SOS, since 1913 there have been 179 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances. Below is a list of recall attempts of state officials that have qualified for the ballot and the outcome of the election:
Year | Officer | Outcome |
1913 | Senator Marshall Black | Recalled |
1913 | Senator Edwin E. Grant | Recalled |
1914 | Senator James C. Owens | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Senator David Roberti | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Michael Machado | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Paul Horcher | Recalled |
1995 | Assemblymember Doris Allen | Recalled |
2003 | Governor Gray Davis | Recalled |
2007 | Senator Jeffrey Denham | Unsuccessful |
2018 | Senator Josh Newman | Recalled |
2021 | Governor Gavin Newsom | Unsuccessful |
Little Hoover Commission. The Little Hoover Commission (LHC) launched a study in 2021 to consider whether the state’s system for recalling state office-holders should be changed, and if so, how. The study resulted in its 2022 report, “Reforming the Recall.” In the report, the LHC concluded that the recall system should be retained, both because it is substantively valuable – voters should be able to fire an elected official mid-term – and because it is overwhelmingly popular with voters. However, the report also concluded that substantial changes are needed in California’s recall process.
According to the report, current recall procedures breed the possibility of an undemocratic outcome since they allow a replacement candidate to win office while receiving fewer votes than the incumbent. There is also concern that the recall is subject to potential overuse or abuse. The report made various recommendations, including replacing the existing two-part recall ballot with a “snap” special election in which the official targeted for recall is placed on the ballot with all replacement candidates.
Comments
According to the author, California’s recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022) changed the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall by removing the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer to only include the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office and, if successful, if filled by existing laws for vacated offices.
AB 2584 (Berman, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2022) increased the total number of proponents required to be included on a notice of intention to recall an elected officer, established a public display period for local recall petitions, authorized a voter to seek a writ of mandate or injunction requiring any or all of the statement of the proponents or answer of the officer to be amended or deleted on a recall petition, required a petition for the recall of a school board member to contain a fiscal estimate of the cost for conducting the recall election, and changed the timeframe for when a qualified local recall election is held.
SCA 3 (Allen, 2022) would have eliminated the first question on the recall ballot that asks whether a state official should be recalled, and instead automatically places the incumbent’s name on the recall ballot along with any potential replacement candidates running for the office. If the incumbent receives a plurality of the vote, the recall fails, and if a replacement candidate receives a plurality, the recall succeeds and that candidate is elected. SCA 3 was referred to the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendment Committee, but was not heard.
SCA 6 (Newman, 2022), substantially similar to this measure, would have eliminated the second question on the recall ballot that asks which candidate should replace the recalled official, and instead generally requires the office, if the state officer is recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law. SCA 6 was referred to the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendment Committee, but was not heard.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 1/3/24)
Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D (co-source)
California Common Cause (co-source)
League of Women Voters of California (co-source)
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/3/24)
Election Integrity Project California, Inc.
Seven Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In a letter co-sponsoring SCA 1, the League of Women Voters and California Common Cause stated, in part, the following:
The League of Women Voters of California and California Common Cause are co-sponsoring the constitutional amendment proposed by SCA 1 because it would retain access to the recall, but in a way that should ensure recall outcomes are democratic and broadly supported and will help to eliminate recalls that are frivolous or degrade democratic legitimacy.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In a letter opposing SCA 1, Election Integrity Project California, Inc., stated, in part, the following:
The proposal of SCA 1 that the Lieutenant Governor simply assume the governorship in the event of a successful recall would make a gubernatorial recall effort a “frying pan vs the fire” situation, and monumentally suppress not only the people’s right to self-govern but their eagerness to participate in government at all.
Every step should be taken to encourage full participation of all eligible voters in making the decisions and choices that affect their lives and keep our Republic not only strong but also responsive to its constituents. SCA 1 is definitely a step in the wrong direction.
The current system of having a ballot with both a YES or NO choice regarding recall and a slate of potential replacements to select from in the event the recall is successful is effective, streamlined, fiscally responsible and fair to the voters.
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
1/3/24 11:06:33
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SCA 1 (Newman) - Elections: recall of state officers
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SCA 1, if approved by the voters, would (1) eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office would remain vacant until it is filled, as specified, and (2) repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibit the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
Fiscal Impact:
This measure would result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $738,000 to $984,000, likely in 2024-25, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
Background:
SOS data indicate that since 1913, there have been 179 recall attempts of state elected officials in California. Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of those 11, the elected official was recalled in six instances.
Proposed Law:
This measure, if approved by the voters, would do the following:
- Eliminate the successor election for a recalled state officer and provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. Repeal the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
- Provide that if a recall of the Governor is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the SOS instead of the Lieutenant Governor. Provide that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Require, notwithstanding a specified section in the California Constitution, the Lieutenant Governor become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term that if the Governor is removed from office by recall. Provide that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor, be consolidated with the statewide primary election, and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provide that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provide that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
Related Legislation:
- AB 2582 (Bennett, Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022) changed the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall by removing the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer to only include the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office and, if successful, if filled by existing laws for vacated offices.
- AB 2584 (Berman, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2022) increased the total number of proponents required to be included on a notice of intention to recall an elected officer, established a public display period for local recall petitions, authorized a voter to seek a writ of mandate or injunction requiring any or all of the statement of the proponents or answer of the officer to be amended or deleted on a recall petition, required a petition for the recall of a school board member to contain a fiscal estimate of the cost for conducting the recall election, and changed the timeframe for when a qualified local recall election is held.
- SCA 3 (Allen, 2022) would have eliminated the first question on the recall ballot that asks whether a state official should be recalled, and instead automatically places the incumbent’s name on the recall ballot along with any potential replacement candidates running for the office. If the incumbent receives a plurality of the vote, the recall fails, and if a replacement candidate receives a plurality, the recall succeeds and that candidate is elected. The measure was not heard in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
- SCA 6 (Newman, 2022), substantially similar to this measure, would have eliminated the second question on the recall ballot that asks which candidate should replace the recalled official, and instead generally requires the office, if the state officer is recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law. The measure was not heard in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
Staff Comments:
SOS indicates that printing and mailing costs associated with placing a measure on the statewide ballot are approximately $123,000 per page, depending on the length of the ballot. The fiscal estimates noted above reflect the addition of 6-8 pages in the Voter Information Guide. Actual costs would depend upon the length of the title and summary, analysis by the LAO, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SCA Hearing Date: 5/8/23
Author: | |||
Version: | 1/30/23 | ||
Urgency: |
| Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Scott Matsumoto | ||
Subject: Elections: recall of state officers
DIGEST
This measure, if approved by voters, eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. This measure also repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- States, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the recall is the power of the voters to remove an elective officer.
- Provides that a recall of a state officer is initiated by delivering to the Secretary of State (SOS) a petition alleging reason for recall. Provides that sufficiency of reason is not reviewable.
- Provides that proponents have 160 days to file signed petitions. Provides that a petition to recall a statewide officer must be signed by electors equal in number to 12 percent of the last vote for the office, with signatures from each of five counties equal in number to one percent of the last vote for the office in the county. Requires that signatures to recall Senators, members of the Assembly, members of the Board of Equalization, and judges of courts of appeal and trial courts equal 20 percent of the last vote for the office. Requires the SOS maintain a continuous count of the signatures certified to that office.
- Provides that an election to determine whether to recall an officer and, if appropriate, to elect a successor shall be called by the Governor and held not less than 60 days nor more than 80 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures. Provides that a recall election may be conducted within 180 days from the date of certification of sufficient signatures in order that the election may be consolidated with the next regularly scheduled election occurring wholly or partially within the same jurisdiction in which the recall election is held, if the number of voters eligible to vote at that next regularly scheduled election equals at least 50 percent of all the voters eligible to vote at the recall election.
- Provides that if the majority vote on the question is to recall, then the officer is removed. Provides that if there is a candidate who receives a plurality, they are the successor. Prohibits the targeted state officer from being a successor candidate. Prohibits a successor candidacy for a judicial vacancy if the judge is recalled, as specified.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for circulation, filing, certification of petitions, nomination of candidates, and the recall election.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor or SOS is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the Lieutenant Governor or Controller, respectively.
- Provides that a state officer who is not recalled shall be reimbursed by the State for the officer’s recall election expenses legally and personally incurred. Prohibits another recall from being initiated against the officer until six months after the election.
- Requires the Legislature to provide for the recall of local officers unless a county or city provides for recall within their respective charters.
- Requires a local recall election to include only the question of whether the local elected officer should be removed from office, as specified. Prohibits the successor election for a local office from occurring at the same time as the recall election of a local elected officer, and requires the office, if a local officer is recalled, to become vacant until the position is filled according to existing law.
This measure:
- Eliminates the successor election for a recalled state officer and would provide, in the event an officer is removed in a recall election, that the office will remain vacant until it is filled in accordance with existing law. Repeals the prohibition against the officer subject to the recall from being a candidate to fill the office in a special election, but prohibits the appointment of the officer subject to the recall election to fill the vacancy.
- Provides that if a recall of the Governor is initiated, the recall duties of that office shall be performed by the SOS instead of the Lieutenant Governor. Provides that if recalls of the Governor and SOS are initiated at the same time, the recall duties of both offices shall be performed by the Controller.
- Requires, notwithstanding a specified section in the California Constitution, the Lieutenant Governor become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term that if the Governor is removed from office by recall. Provides that if the Governor is removed from office by recall before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the Governor’s term, a special election shall be called to replace the Governor, be consolidated with the statewide primary election, and, if necessary, the subsequent statewide general election. Provides that if a candidate receives a majority of the votes in the special election that is consolidated with the statewide primary election, that candidate shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term. Provides that if no candidate receives a majority of the votes, the top two vote-getters shall compete in a special election consolidated with the subsequent statewide general election, and the winner of that election shall become Governor for the remainder of the unexpired term.
- Makes corresponding formatting changes.
BACKGROUND
Informational Recall Hearings. During the 2021-22 legislative session, the Assembly Committee on Elections and the Senate Committee on Elections & Constitutional Amendments held a series of joint informational hearings to review California’s recall process following the previous gubernatorial recall election.
At the first hearing on October 28, 2021, the committees heard from current and former elected officials, elections experts, and academics about their perspectives on the state’s recall process and different reform proposals, including increasing the number of signatures for qualifying a statewide recall and changing the method for selecting the successor to a recalled official.
At the second hearing on December 6, 2021, the committees heard from two panels of expert witnesses. The first panel of academics examined a limitation used in several states which only allows recalls to be initiated against an official for certain enumerated causes. The second panel of experts and local elected officials discussed the use of the recall at the local level, along with potential options for reform.
At the third and final recall informational hearing on February 1, 2022, the committees heard from the SOS who shared recommendations for improvements on the state recall process based on her consultation with outside experts and stakeholders. The committees also received an overview from Dr. Mark Baldassare, President and Chief Executive Officer of the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), regarding its January 2022 statewide survey in which the PPIC asked Californians about their views on the recall process. Dr. Baldassare presented new data from their statewide survey and discussed whether and how the views of California voters about the recall process have changed since statewide surveys that PPIC conducted in July and November of last year.
One of the major takeaways from the committee’s first two hearings was that many of the recall reform proposals would require voter approval in order to take effect. In particular, proposals to make significant structural changes to the recall process at the state level generally require an amendment to the California Constitution. By contrast, changes to the process for recalling local elected officials and certain procedural changes to the state process can be made through statutory changes alone. The third hearing generally reinforced the importance of continuing to evaluate California’s recall processes and that California voters generally support reform of the recall process, but are against any changes to the recall procedure or process that diminish or decrease the voter’s power to recall an elected official.
Recent Changes to Local Recall Elections. In 2022, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed AB 2582 (Bennett), Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022. AB 2582 made changes to the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall. Specifically, AB 2582 removed the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer only includes the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office.
History of Recall Elections. According to the SOS, since 1913 there have been 179 recall attempts of state elected officials in California (trial court judges are considered local officials for the purposes of state statutes governing recalls and are not included in these figures). Eleven recall efforts collected enough signatures to qualify for the ballot. Of the 11 recall elections, the elected official was recalled in six instances. Below is a list of recall attempts of state officials that have qualified for the ballot and the outcome of the election:
Year | Officer | Outcome |
1913 | Senator Marshall Black | Recalled |
1913 | Senator Edwin E. Grant | Recalled |
1914 | Senator James C. Owens | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Senator David Roberti | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Michael Machado | Unsuccessful |
1994 | Assemblymember Paul Horcher | Recalled |
1995 | Assemblymember Doris Allen | Recalled |
2003 | Governor Gray Davis | Recalled |
2007 | Senator Jeffrey Denham | Unsuccessful |
2018 | Senator Josh Newman | Recalled |
2021 | Governor Gavin Newsom | Unsuccessful |
Little Hoover Commission. The Little Hoover Commission (LHC) launched a study in 2021 to consider whether the state’s system for recalling state office-holders should be changed, and if so, how. The study resulted in its 2022 report, “Reforming the Recall.” In the report, the LHC concluded that the recall system should be retained, both because it is substantively valuable – voters should be able to fire an elected official mid-term – and because it is overwhelmingly popular with voters. However, the report also concluded that substantial changes are needed in California’s recall process.
According to the report, current recall procedures breed the possibility of an undemocratic outcome since they allow a replacement candidate to win office while receiving fewer votes than the incumbent. There is also concern that the recall is subject to potential overuse or abuse. The report made various recommendations, including replacing the existing two-part recall ballot with a “snap” special election in which the official targeted for recall is placed on the ballot with all replacement candidates.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: California’s recall provisions were conceived of and enacted more than 110 years ago. Obviously, the world has changed quite a bit since then, and sadly, politics is no exception. The system in its current form offers bad actors an incentive to target an elected official with whom they disagree and to have the official replaced by someone who otherwise would not enjoy the support of a majority of voters. SCA 1 will ensure that statewide and legislative recalls in California are democratic, fair, and not subject to political gamesmanship. This constitutional amendment will adjust how state-level recall elections are conducted, so that only one question will appear on a recall ballot, asking a voter to decide whether or not an elected official should be recalled from office. If a recall is successful, the official will be replaced in the manner consistent with existing law if the official were to leave office for any other reason.
- Argument in Support. In a letter co-sponsoring SCA 1, the League of Women Voters and California Common Cause stated, in part, the following:
The League of Women Voters of California and California Common Cause are co-sponsoring the constitutional amendment proposed by SCA 1 because it would retain access to the recall, but in a way that should ensure recall outcomes are democratic and broadly supported and will help to eliminate recalls that are frivolous or degrade democratic legitimacy.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing SCA 1, Election Integrity Project California, Inc., stated, in part, the following:
The proposal of SCA 1 that the Lieutenant Governor simply assume the governorship in the event of a successful recall would make a gubernatorial recall effort a “frying pan vs the fire” situation, and monumentally suppress not only the people’s right to self-govern but their eagerness to participate in government at all.
Every step should be taken to encourage full participation of all eligible voters in making the decisions and choices that affect their lives and keep our Republic not only strong but also responsive to its constituents. SCA 1 is definitely a step in the wrong direction.
The current system of having a ballot with both a YES or NO choice regarding recall and a slate of potential replacements to select from in the event the recall is successful is effective, streamlined, fiscally responsible and fair to the voters.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 2582 (Bennett), Chapter 790, Statutes of 2022, changed the two-question process for the recall of local officers in jurisdictions that do not have a charter providing for recall by removing the successor candidate question from the recall question, so that the election for a local officer to only include the question of whether the officer sought to be recalled shall be removed from office and, if successful, if filled by existing laws for vacated offices.
AB 2584 (Berman), Chapter 791, Statutes of 2022, increased the total number of proponents required to be included on a notice of intention to recall an elected officer, established a public display period for local recall petitions, authorized a voter to seek a writ of mandate or injunction requiring any or all of the statement of the proponents or answer of the officer to be amended or deleted on a recall petition, required a petition for the recall of a school board member to contain a fiscal estimate of the cost for conducting the recall election, and changed the timeframe for when a qualified local recall election is held.
SCA 3 (Allen) of 2022 would have eliminated the first question on the recall ballot that asks whether a state official should be recalled, and instead automatically places the incumbent’s name on the recall ballot along with any potential replacement candidates running for the office. If the incumbent receives a plurality of the vote, the recall fails, and if a replacement candidate receives a plurality, the recall succeeds and that candidate is elected. SCA 3 was referred to this committee, but was not heard.
SCA 6 (Newman) of 2022, substantially similar to this measure, would have eliminated the second question on the recall ballot that asks which candidate should replace the recalled official, and instead generally requires the office, if the state officer is recalled, to become vacant and to be filled in accordance with existing law. SCA 6 was referred to this committee, but was not heard.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber, Ph.D.
California Common Cause
League of Women Voters of California
Support: None received
Oppose: Election Integrity Project California, Inc.
Three Individuals
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Elections
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):