SBX1 2: Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-03-28
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-03-28: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 1, Statutes of 2023-24 First Extraordinary Session.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline in that month, including the gross gasoline refining margin of gasoline sold in that month. Existing law requires the commission within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website.
This bill would authorize the commission to set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require the commission, if the commission establishes the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize the commission to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin. The bill would also authorize the commission to impose an administrative civil penalty on a refiner for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require the commission to consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, the bill would expand the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the penalties collected to be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which the bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would require moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians. The bill would require the California State Auditor, no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, if set by the commission. The bill would require the California State Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, the bill would require the commission, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, except as provided.
This bill would require the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before March 1 of each year, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year, as provided. The bill would authorize the department to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the persons possession, custody, or control that the department deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the commission.
This bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2024, and every 3 years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that, among other things, identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California, as provided. The bill would require the commission to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the commission to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. The bill would require the commission and the State Air Resources Board, on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan, as provided.
This bill would establish the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight in the commission that is led by a director appointed by the Governor and subject to Senate confirmation. The bill would specify that the division operates with authority independent of the commissions authority. The bill would specify the duties of the division, including, among other duties, the duty to provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor and the commission on any issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California. The bill would establish the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee, consisting of specified members, within the commission, and would require the committee to advise the commission and the division.
This bill would require operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. The bill would require the commission to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
Existing law requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to annually submit certain information to the commission, as provided.
This bill would revise and recast the above reporting requirement to, among other things, require pipeline operators and operators of ports through which refined gasoline is imported to annually report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline, require all importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel to submit reports to the commission, as specified, require nonrefiners that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuel inventory to submit weekly reports to the commission, as provided, require refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions to submit a daily report to the commission containing certain information for each transaction occurring in the preceding day, as provided, and require refiners to report maintenance activities, both planned and unplanned, to the commission, as provided.
Existing law subjects a person who fails to provide information to the commission after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts.
This bill would increase the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law requires operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline in that month, including the gross gasoline refining margin of gasoline sold in that month. Existing law requires the commission within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website.
This bill would authorize the commission to set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require the commission, if the commission establishes the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize the commission to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin. The bill would also authorize the commission to impose an administrative civil penalty on a refiner for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require the commission to consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, the bill would expand the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the penalties collected to be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which the bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would require moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians. The bill would require the California State Auditor, no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, if set by the commission. The bill would require the California State Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, the bill would require the commission, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, except as provided.
This bill would require the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before March 1 of each year, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year, as provided. The bill would authorize the department to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the persons possession, custody, or control that the department deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the commission.
This bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2024, and every 3 years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that, among other things, identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California, as provided. The bill would require the commission to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the commission to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. The bill would require the commission and the State Air Resources Board, on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan, as provided.
This bill would establish the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight in the commission that is led by a director appointed by the Governor and subject to Senate confirmation. The bill would specify that the division operates with authority independent of the commissions authority. The bill would specify the duties of the division, including, among other duties, the duty to provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor and the commission on any issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California. The bill would establish the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee, consisting of specified members, within the commission, and would require the committee to advise the commission and the division.
This bill would require operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. The bill would require the commission to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
Existing law requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to annually submit certain information to the commission, as provided.
This bill would revise and recast the above reporting requirement to, among other things, require pipeline operators and operators of ports through which refined gasoline is imported to annually report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline, require all importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel to submit reports to the commission, as specified, require nonrefiners that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuel inventory to submit weekly reports to the commission, as provided, require refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions to submit a daily report to the commission containing certain information for each transaction occurring in the preceding day, as provided, and require refiners to report maintenance activities, both planned and unplanned, to the commission, as provided.
Existing law subjects a person who fails to provide information to the commission after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts.
This bill would increase the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law requires operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline in that month. Existing law requires the commission to notify a refiner that has failed to timely provide the required information and imposes a civil penalty on the refiner that fails to submit the required information within 5 days of being notified of the failure.
This bill would authorize the commission to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin at an unspecified amount per gallon and would authorize the commission to annually adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would require the commission, if the commission establishes the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize the commission to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin. The bill would also authorize the commission to assess impose an administrative civil penalty on a refiner for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize require the commission to grant consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin upon a showing by the refiner of reasonable cause, and to subject the refiner to alternative maximum margins or other conditions set by the commission. margin, as provided. The bill would require a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this the bill would expand the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the penalties collected to be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which the bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would require moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be returned, as refunds, to residents of the state. address the consequences of price gouging on Californians. The bill would require the California State Auditor, no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, if established by the commission. The bill would require the California State Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, the bill would require the commission, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, except as provided.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to transportation fuels, as described, including requiring the commission to conduct regular assessments of the supply and price of transportation fuels in the state, and of the impacts on production of refinery maintenance and turnarounds on fuel supply and price. Existing law establishes the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and provides that the department is the successor to, and is vested with, the duties, powers, and responsibilities of the State Board of Equalization.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would direct the department, in collaboration with the commission, to investigate and report on aspects of the gasoline market, as specified.This bill would require the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before March 1 of each year, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year, as provided. The bill would authorize the department to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the persons possession, custody, or control that the department deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the commission.
This bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2024, and every 3 years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that, among other things, identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California, as provided. The bill would require the commission to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the commission to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. The bill would also require the commission and the State Air Resources Board, on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan, as provided.
This bill would establish the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight within the commission, and would require the division to be led by a director appointed by the Governor and subject to Senate confirmation. The bill would specify that the division operates with authority independent of the commissions authority. The bill would specify the duties of the division, including, among other duties, the duty to provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor and the commission on any issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California. The bill would establish the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee, consisting of specified members, within the commission, and would require the committee to advise the commission and the division.
Existing law requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to submit certain information to the commission, as provided.
This bill would revise and recast the above reporting requirement to, among other things, require pipeline operators and operators of ports through which refined gasoline is imported to annually report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline, require all importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel to submit reports to the commission, as specified, require nonrefiners that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuel inventory to submit weekly reports to the commission, as provided, require refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions to submit a daily report to the commission containing certain information for each transaction occurring in the preceding day, as provided, and require refiners to report maintenance activities, both planned and unplanned, to the commission, as provided.
Existing law requires operators of refineries operating in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications to submit a report within 30 days of the end of each calendar month with certain information, including the gross gasoline refining margin of gasoline sold in that month. Existing law requires the commission within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website.
This bill would require operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. The bill would require the commission to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
Existing law subjects a person who fails to provide information to the commission after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts.
This bill would increase the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law requires operators of refineries in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications, within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, to submit a report to the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission containing certain information regarding its refining activities related to the production of gasoline in that month. Existing law requires the commission to notify a refiner that has failed to timely provide the required information and imposes a civil penalty on the refiner that fails to submit the required information within 5 days of being notified of the failure.
This bill would establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin at an unspecified amount per gallon and would authorize the commission to annually adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize the commission to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin. The bill would also authorize the commission to assess an administrative civil penalty on a refiner for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as provided. The bill would authorize the commission to grant a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin upon a showing by the refiner of reasonable cause, and to subject the refiner to alternative maximum margins or other conditions set by the commission. The bill would require a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this bill would expand the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the penalties collected to be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which the bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would require moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be returned, as refunds, to residents of the state.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to transportation fuels, as described, including requiring the commission to conduct regular assessments of the supply and price of transportation fuels in the state, and of the impacts on production of refinery maintenance and turnarounds on fuel supply and price.
Existing law establishes the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and provides that the department is the successor to, and is vested with, the duties, powers, and responsibilities of the State Board of Equalization.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would direct the department, in collaboration with the commission, to investigate and report on aspects of the gasoline market, as specified.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)From August to October of 2022, Californians experienced some of the highest gasoline prices ever recorded in the state, even though the price of crude oil declined, state taxes and fees remained unchanged, and gasoline prices did not increase outside the western United States.
(b)Much of this increase was caused by refiners, which increased the costs and profits they added to the price California consumers paid at the pump, leading to prices that were substantially higher per gallon than average prices in the rest of the United States.
(c)During the third and fourth quarters of 2022, the overlap in timing of planned maintenance at refiners facilities resulted in a larger decrease in crude oil processing capacity than would otherwise have occurred if planned maintenance at refiners facilities had not coincided.
(d)During this same period of time, refiners allowed gasoline inventory levels to reach decade-low levels, placing an upward pressure on gasoline prices.
(e)This refiner conduct makes clear that greater transparency into and oversight of refinery maintenance schedules and inventory is necessary, to avoid preventable supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.
(f)Historically, refinery outages and issues have created an opportunity for market participants to take advantage of naturally high prices by manipulating prices to stay higher longer, as evidenced by gasoline prices in California remaining elevated without explanation following a temporary price shock after a refinery explosion in 2015. This further demonstrates the need for greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants at all levels of the supply chain, and greater oversight by regulators empowered with the information and investigative tools needed to deter and detect anticompetitive conduct and other behavior that harms California consumers.
(g)Although preventable capacity limitations and inventory shortages played a role in the third quarter of 2022 price increases, they cannot account for all of those increases. Similar factors did not lead to extreme price spikes in prior years, suggesting that the sky-high prices Californians faced from August to October of 2022 were due in significant part to opportunistic price gouging by oil companies.
(h)Indeed, during a 90-day period in 2022, refiners earned a record $63,000,000,000 in profits, with some refiners earning more than tenfold their profits for the same period of time in 2021. Refiners annual profits for 2022 also set new record highs.
(i)Fundamental change is necessary to prevent future extreme price spikes and price gouging by oil companies, which are entitled to a reasonable return but are not entitled to reap exorbitant profits at the expense of Californians, many of whom rely on gasoline as an essential commodity or who are impacted by the increased cost of goods and services that results from the gasoline price spikes, even as the state begins to transition away from dependence on the fossil fuels that are destroying our climate.
SEC. 2.Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25354.(a)Each refiner and major marketer shall submit information each month to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. For purposes of this section, the term refiner and refinery shall include refiners and refineries as defined in Sections 25127 and 25128, and also those persons and facilities that process renewable feedstocks instead of crude oil feedstocks and otherwise meet the definitions in Sections 25127 and 25128. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period and shall include the following:
(1)Refiners shall report, by volume, price, and type, for each of their refineries, feedstock inputs, origin of petroleum receipts, imports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, including the source of those imports, exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, including the destination of those exports and the entity receiving those exports, refinery outputs, refinery stocks, finished product supply and distribution, including all gasoline sold unbranded by the refiner, blender, or importer, and all current inventories of refined and unrefined petroleum products.
(2)Major marketers shall report, by volume, price, and type, on petroleum product receipts and the sources of these receipts, inventories of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, distributions through branded and unbranded distribution networks, and exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol from the state.
(b)Each major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, oil storer, pipeline operator, or port through which refined gasoline is imported or exported, shall annually submit information to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each reporting period, and shall include the following:
(1)Major oil transporters shall report on petroleum by reporting the capacities of each major transportation system, the amount transported by each system, and inventories thereof. The commission may prescribe rules and regulations that exclude pipeline and transportation modes operated entirely on property owned by major oil transporters from the reporting requirements of this section if the data or information is not needed to fulfill the purposes of this chapter. The provision of the information shall not be construed to increase or decrease any authority the Public Utilities Commission may otherwise have.
(2)Major oil storers shall report on storage capacity, inventories, receipts and distributions, and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(3)Major oil producers shall, with respect to thermally enhanced oil recovery operations, report annually by designated oil field, the monthly use, as fuel, of crude oil and natural gas.
(4)Refiners shall report on facility capacity, and utilization and method of transportation of refinery receipts and distributions.
(5)Major oil marketers shall report on facility capacity and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(6)Pipeline operators and port operators shall report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline.
(7)All major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, oil storers, pipeline operators, or port operators submitting information under this subdivision shall include in the report for each reporting period the full names of all persons or entities that directly or indirectly own 10 percent or more of the major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, oil storer, pipeline operator, or port operator submitting the information.
(c)Each person required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) shall submit a projection each month of the information to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) for the quarter following the month in which the information is submitted to the commission.
(d)In addition to the data required under subdivision (a), each integrated oil refiner that produces, refines, transports, and markets in interstate commerce and that supplies more than 500 branded retail outlets in California shall submit to the commission an annual industry forecast for Petroleum Administration for Defense, District V, covering Arizona, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska, and Hawaii. The forecast shall include the information to be submitted under subdivision (a), and shall be submitted by March 15 of each year. The commission may require California-specific forecasts only if the commission finds them necessary to carry out its responsibilities.
(e)The commission may by order or regulation modify the reporting period as to any individual item of information setting forth in the order or regulation its reason for so doing.
(f)(1)Destination facilities shall submit to the commission, by deadlines set by the commission, the following information regarding crude oil transported to or within California via rail car or marine vessel:
(A)The route of transport within California.
(B)The marketable crude oil name.
(C)The loading facility, including the loading facility name, and the latitude, longitude, and state where the facility is located.
(D)The name of the destination facility, the type of facility, and the latitude and longitude where the facility is located.
(E)Whether the crude oil is nonfloating oil, as defined in Section 8670.3 of the Government Code.
(2)The commission shall quarterly prepare and make available to the public a report based on the data collected pursuant to paragraph (1) that shall include, at a minimum, the routes of transport of crude oil within California, the types of crude oil transported over each of those routes, and the frequency with which nonfloating oil has been transported over each of those routes during the reporting period. The commission shall aggregate information used in a report prepared under this paragraph to the extent necessary to assure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(3)The commission may require additional information to be submitted as necessary to perform its responsibilities under this chapter.
(g)Any person required to submit information or data under this chapter, in lieu thereof, may submit a report made to any other governmental agency, if:
(1)The alternate report or reports contain all of the information or data required by this chapter.
(2)The person clearly identifies the specific provision of this chapter to which the alternate report is responsive.
(h)Each refiner shall submit to the commission, within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period, all of the following information in such form and extent as the commission prescribes:
(1)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes of finished leaded regular, unleaded regular, and premium motor gasoline sold through company-operated retail outlets, to other end-users, and to wholesale customers.
(2)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for residential sales, commercial and institutional sales, industrial sales, sales through company-operated retail outlets, sales to other end-users, and wholesale sales of No. 2 diesel fuel, No. 2 fuel oil, and any renewable fuels.
(3)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for retail sales and wholesale sales of No. 1 distillate, kerosene, finished aviation gasoline, kerosene-type jet fuel, No. 4 fuel oil, residual fuel oil with 1 percent or less sulfur, residual fuel oil with greater than 1 percent sulfur, and consumer grade propane.
(i)(1)Beginning the first week after January 1, 2004, and each week thereafter, an oil refiner, oil producer, petroleum product transporter, petroleum product marketer, petroleum product pipeline operator, and terminal operator, as designated by the commission, shall submit a report in the form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The commission may determine the form and extent necessary by order or by regulation.
(2)A report may include any of the following information:
(A)Receipts and inventory levels of crude oil and petroleum products at each refinery and terminal location.
(B)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products imported and exported.
(C)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products transported intrastate by marine vessel.
(D)Amount of crude oil imported, including information identifying the source of the crude oil.
(E)The regional average of invoiced retailer buying price. This subparagraph does not either preclude or augment the current authority of the commission to collect additional data under paragraph (3) of subdivision (f).
(F)Copies of all contracts or agreements entered into, or amendments to contracts or agreements, with other oil refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of petroleum products, as designated by the commission, during the monthly reporting period, along with records of every transaction made under those contracts or agreements and the prices charged for those transactions.
(3)This subdivision is intended to clarify the commissions existing authority under subdivision (f) to collect specific information. This subdivision neither precludes nor augments the existing authority of the commission to collect information.
(j)All importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel shall report to the commission, at least 96 hours before the arrival of a marine vessel delivery to California, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the product tanker or name of the barge, including associated tug name.
(2)The loading location or locations for cargo.
(3)The volume by each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(4)The cargo landed cost, including the cost incurred to purchase, load, transport, and all other costs and fees to deliver, each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(5)The status of any transportation fuel as sold before discharge, the identity of the buyer for any presold product, and the sale price of any presold product.
(6)The planned discharge location, such as the marine berth designation, or locations.
(7)The foreign, domestic, and intrastate marine movements of the vessel from the port of origin to the port of delivery of the cargo.
(k)Nonrefiners, such as proprietary storage companies, that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable diesel fuel inventory not subject to contractual supply obligations, shall submit weekly reports to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that include the weekly inventory volume, by type, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels, for each position holder by name of company, and copies of all contracts or agreements entered into with any refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of those products, as designated by the commission.
(l)Refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions shall submit a daily report to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that includes all of the following information for each transaction occurring during the preceding day:
(1)The identity of the spot market where the transaction occurred.
(2)Whether the transaction was reported to the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS), or any other price reporting service, and the time of the reporting.
(3)The date of the transaction.
(4)The time of the transaction.
(5)The contract identification number for the transaction.
(6)The position sequence number for the transaction.
(7)The contract position identification number for the transaction.
(8)The name, or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader for the transaction.
(9)The counterparty for the transaction, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader.
(10)Whether the reporting entity is the seller or buyer.
(11)The broker, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing broker.
(12)The type of refined transportation fuel, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel.
(13)The product name for each type of refined transportation fuel.
(14)The volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(15)The invoiced volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(16)The time and date the material that is the subject of the transaction is scheduled to be delivered or was delivered.
(17)The delivery location specified in the contract for the transaction and the actual delivery location.
(18)The method of transportation for the delivery, such as pipeline, marine vessel, or truck, and the name of the transport.
(19)The actual title transfer date.
(20)The contract subcycle, including descriptors such as Any, L3, FH, BH, C1, C2, C3, or C4.
(21)The type of pricing method, including exchange of futures for physical (EFP), fixed price, fixed date range, floating date range, reference formula, OPIS close, event-related date range, such as three days on and around delivery or discharge, or any other utilized method of pricing.
(22)The contract price formula, including the differential from any contract formula and the unit of measurement for any price differential.
(23)The pricing start and end dates for each contract.
(24)The price value of the contract.
(25)For EFP contracts, the name of the futures product, the contract month of the futures product expressed as the two-digit month and the two-digit year (MM-YY), and the price value of the futures product.
(m)It is the intent of the Legislature that all refiners shall, while protecting the health and safety of the public and employees, schedule planned maintenance and turnaround in a manner that ensures minimum levels of transportation fuels in production or reserves necessary to prevent supply shortages or price spikes. To advance that purpose, refiners shall report maintenance activities for each refinery to the commission as follows:
(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a refiner shall notify the executive director of the commission of all plans to undertake turnaround and planned maintenance. A refiners notification shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information:
(A)A brief description of planned work.
(B)The scheduled start date.
(C)The scheduled return-to-service date.
(D)The individual process units involved.
(E)The name and operational capacity of each process unit.
(F)The estimated daily decrease in output of material or substance produced by the unit, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel components.
(G)The projected quantity of contractual supply obligations for finished gasoline due during the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(H)The drawdown of inventory levels of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the planned maintenance event or turnaround, the current levels of such inventories at the time notice is provided, and the anticipant levels of such inventories immediately before the commencement of the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(I)Imports of gasoline and gasoline blend components and other material or substance produced by the unit in preparation for or during the planned maintenance event.
(J)Planned purchases of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit from other market participants in California related to the planned maintenance event.
(K)Planned reductions of noncontracted sales of gasoline or other material or substance produced by the unit related to the planned maintenance event.
(2)The refiners notification shall be submitted to the executive director of the commission at least 120 days before the planned maintenance or turnaround.
(3)Before submitting its turnaround schedule notification to the Division of Occupational Safety and Health pursuant to Section 7872 of the Labor Code, each refiner shall submit its turnaround schedule to the executive director of the commission. When submitting its schedule to the division, each refiner shall indicate that, for each scheduled turnaround, the notification to the commission was submitted.
(4)For unplanned maintenance resulting in a shutdown of a refinery process of greater than 24 hours, submit initial and final reports as follows:
(A)The initial report, due within 48 hours of the initial outage, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The name and operational capacity of each process unit involved in the unplanned outage.
(ii)The initial estimated daily decrease in output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each process unit affected by the unplanned outage.
(iii)The current inventory levels of the material or substance produced by the unit affected by the unplanned outage that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(iv)A description of the reason for the unplanned maintenance or outage.
(v)The projected duration of production reduction.
(B)The final report, due within 48 hours of the completion of repairs, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The return-to-service date.
(ii)The total decreased output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each of the affected process units.
(iii)The total increased output from other process units by type of refined product to partially compensate for the reduced output from the process units affected by the unplanned outage.
(iv)The amount of material obtained from other sources that compensated for the decrease described in clause (ii) and enabled the refiner to cover for the loss of that production.
(v)The drawdown of inventory levels of any material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(5)Upon receipt of a notification under this subdivision, the executive director of the commission shall review the notification and may request any additional information from the refiner that is necessary for the commission to assess the potential effect of the planned maintenance event on the supply and prices of transportation fuels in the state.
(n)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, information in the notification provided to the commission by a refiner providing a notice or report of its planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, or turnaround schedule, including notifications under subdivision (m) shall be considered confidential information not subject to public disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). The commission may share the information with other state agencies, including the Attorney General, only if the other state agency agrees to maintain the confidentiality of the information.
(2)The commission may adopt guidelines to prescribe the manner in which the executive director of the commission shall implement subdivision (m) at a commission business meeting. The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulations, guidelines, or other standards adopted by the commission pursuant to this paragraph.
(o)Refiners shall report annually to the commission their planned production levels and schedule for turnarounds and planned maintenance for the following 12 months, by month and by finished product.
(p)(1)The operator of any refinery in this state shall report to the Commission at least 12 months in advance if that refinery operator intends to permanently shut down, shut down to reconfigure, or sell a refinery in a transaction that may result in a refinery shutting down or reconfiguring.
(2)Upon receipt of a notice pursuant to paragraph (1), the commission shall notify the Legislature in a manner that does not disclose confidential information, if applicable.
(3)After the completion of the report by the commission required by Section 25371 and its submission to the Legislature, the commission may modify the notice required under this subdivision. The commission shall not reduce the notice period to less than 12 months.
SEC. 3.Section 25354.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25354.2.The commission, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and labor and industry stakeholders, shall consider ways to manage necessary refinery turnarounds and maintenance that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses on fuel prices. The commission may, by regulation, impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations under this section.
SEC. 4.Section 25355 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25355.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin means the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the volume-weighted average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received by the refinery.
(2)Net gasoline refining margin means the gross gasoline refining margin minus the refinerys operational costs.
(3)Operational costs means costs, expressed in dollars per barrel, necessarily incurred by the operator of a refinery in the state to produce gasoline meeting California specifications, including, but not limited to, costs of labor, electricity, natural gas, chemicals, maintenance, hydrogen, and other intermediate oil products, federal renewable identification numbers, obligation costs, capital investments, logistics costs, and additive costs.
(b)Within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, the operator of each refinery operating in the state that produces gasoline meeting California specifications shall submit to the commission a report for the refinery containing all of the following information:
(1)The volume, in barrels, of crude oil received in that month, separated into domestic and foreign subtotals.
(2)The volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost paid for crude oil that is received and intended to be refined during that month, separated into domestic and foreign crude oil acquisition costs.
(3)The volume in barrels of refined gasoline received or imported in that month from entities other than the refiner.
(4)The volume-weighted average cost of any refined gasoline received or imported by a refiner during that month.
(5)The quantity, in barrels, of wholesale gasoline meeting California specifications sold and the corresponding volume-weighted average prices, less all applicable local, state, and federal taxes, separated by unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, and dealer tankwagon (DTW) sales in that month.
(6)Separate quantification of the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) and associated with the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack (CAR) program, for each volume-weighted average price for: (A) unbranded rack sales, (B) branded rack sales, (C) bulk sales, (D) spot pipeline sales, and (E) DTW sales, in that month.
(7)The gross gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(8)The operational costs per barrel of gasoline sold in that month, including a complete description and amount of each category of cost identified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any other category of cost.
(9)The net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(c)Within 45 days of the end of each calendar month, the commission shall post on its internet website all of the following:
(1)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted gross refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(2)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported for that month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within California.
(3)The net gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted net refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(4)The net gasoline refining margin data reported for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within the state.
(5)The aggregated data submitted pursuant to paragraphs (1) through (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) for that month.
SEC. 5.Section 25355.5 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.5.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs means the amount, expressed in dollars per barrel and calculated by the commission on a monthly basis, equal to the volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state, less the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all of the refiners wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low carbon fuel standard and the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack program, less the refiners volume-weighted average acquisition cost.
(2)Maximum gross gasoline refining margin means the maximum amount of gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs established under subdivision (b).
(3)Volume-weighted average acquisition cost means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost and the refiners volume-weighted cost of acquiring refined gasoline imported to California or received from an entity other than the refiner.
(4)Volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners rack price of the branded and unbranded rack sales reported under paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(5)Volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost means the amount reported as required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(b)The commission may, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(c)(1)If the commission sets a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall also establish a penalty for exceeding that maximum margin, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), that may be the same meeting described in subdivision (b).
(2)The penalty shall be a percentage of the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, converted from dollars per barrel to dollars per gallon, multiplied by the number of gallons sold by the refiner during the calendar month for all transactions described in paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(3)Subject to subdivision (j), the penalty shall be tiered, such that the penalty percentage shall increase with the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as follows:
(A)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by less than ten cents ($0.10) per gallon shall be subject to the base penalty percentage set by the commission.
(B)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin between by more than ten cents ($0.10) and less than or equal to twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the base penalty percentage.
(C)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by more than twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the penalty percentage set under subparagraph (B).
(d)In establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall consider information reported under subdivision (b) of Section 25355 and any other public data and reports that it determines will assist its analysis. The commission shall also consider confidential information submitted pursuant to Sections 25354 and 25355. A refiner may submit additional information and facts for the commission to consider under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364.
(e)The commission shall not set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin or accompanying penalty under subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, unless it finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. In making that determination, the commission shall consider all factors that in its discretion it deems relevant, including at a minimum all of the following factors, although no one factor shall be determinative:
(1)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(2)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(3)Whether case-by-case exemptions from the gross gasoline refining maximum margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
(f)Decisions of the commission under subdivision (b) to adopt a regulation or order setting a maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (c) to adopt a regulation or order establishing a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (e) regarding the benefits and costs to consumers, and under subdivision (k) regarding adjustments to, or rescission of, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin or penalty, shall be made in accordance with all of the following procedures:
(1)A notice and draft decision, regulation, or order shall be posted publicly at least 30 days before the business meeting at which adoption of the decision, regulation, or order will be considered.
(2)The commission shall receive written comments on the draft decision, regulation, or order.
(3)The commission shall hear public comment on the draft decision, regulation, or order at its business meeting.
(g)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the margin and penalty shall take effect 60 days following the commissions regulation or order establishing the margin and penalty pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively. Within 15 days of the regulation or order establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall notify refiners by a means determined by the commission that may include, but is not limited to, mail, email, or internet website posting.
(h)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall be a violation of this section for a refiner to exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(i)In addition to any other remedy that may be available, the commission may petition a court to enjoin a refiner from violating this section.
(j)The commission may impose an administrative civil penalty for a violation of this section in the amounts established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(k)The commission may, by regulation or order, at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), rescind or adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c) to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians. A refiner may submit information and facts for the commission to consider in support of any rescission or adjustment under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364. Rescission of, or adjustments to, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, pursuant to this subdivision shall be effective on the first day of the calendar month at least 15 days after the commission gives public notice of the rescission or adjustment, unless the commission orders otherwise.
(l)Notwithstanding Section 25901 and except as provided in subdivision (n), a petition for writ of mandate pursuant to Section 1085 of the Code of Civil Procedure shall be the exclusive remedy available to challenge any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, or adjudication of an exemption request adopted by the commission under this section. The courts review shall be limited exclusively to the record before the commission. Any petition shall be filed within 30 days of the commissions decision.
(m)(1)The commission shall consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and shall grant the exemption upon a showing by the refiner, based on competent and reliable evidence and subject to the commissions review, examination, and investigation of the evidence, that an application of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin would be unconstitutional as applied to the refiner. The commission may, in its discretion, grant a request for an exemption upon a showing by the refiner of good cause for an exemption, subject to alternative maximum margins or other conditions as the commission may set.
(2)Any refiner seeking an exemption shall, at a minimum, file a statement with the commission, signed under penalty of perjury, setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption. A refiner may submit information and facts under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364 to support its application for an exemption.
(n)(1)Before imposing the administrative civil penalty under subdivision (j), the executive director of the commission shall issue and serve a complaint on the refiner, and the commission shall hold a hearing, adopt a decision, and require payment of the penalty in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 25534.1.
(2)Judicial review and enforcement of an order imposing an administrative civil penalty under subdivision (j) may be had in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 25534.2.
(3)Penalties collected under this section shall be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury and shall be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
(4)The commission shall make public, on a quarterly basis, the name and address of each refiner that has exceeded the maximum gross gasoline refining margin for any month during the previous quarter, and the amount of administrative civil penalty to be assessed.
(o)The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, adjudication of an exemption request, or adjustment of the maximum gross gasoline margin, adopted by the commission under this section.
(p)The California State Auditor shall begin, no earlier than January 1, 2032, and complete, no later than March 1, 2033, an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty set pursuant to this section, if the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty. The California State Auditor shall make determinations in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether this section is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market for California consumers. Within 60 days of the issuance of the report, the commission shall hear from the California State Auditor at a business meeting of the commission. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, then the commission shall cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions no later than 180 days after the issuance of the report, unless the Legislature has enacted subsequent legislation to extend the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions in the meantime.
SEC. 6.Section 25355.7 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.7.(a)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before March 1, 2024, and March 1 of each year thereafter, the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, shall submit a report to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year.
(b)(1)(A)To facilitate the report required in subdivision (a) and to assist the commission in providing independent analysis and oversight of the market for transportation fuels, and in identifying potential market design flaws and market power abuses, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may, notwithstanding any other law, use any information that comes into its possession and may request from any person records required to be maintained pursuant to Section 7053 or 8301 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any other records in a persons possession, custody, or control that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration deems necessary for these purposes. Records that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may request, include, but are not limited to, sales prices and contracts for unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, dealer tankwagon sales, imported fuel transactions, and retail sales of gasoline meeting California specifications, including prices per gallon of gasoline charged by retailers by retail location and by grade of gasoline.
(B)Except as provided in paragraph (4), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration pursuant to this section shall constitute confidential information for purposes of Section 7056 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or Section 15570.84 of the Government Code and shall not be subject to public disclosure.
(2)(A)The records requested pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be provided in the form and manner specified by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration within 30 days of the notice of request.
(B)The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall provide written notification to the commission within 10 days after the failure or refusal of any person to provide information or records in the time and manner as specified pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(3)For purposes of the report required by subdivision (a), the commission may impose a civil penalty after receiving notification from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration that a person has failed or refused to provide information or records in the time and manner as required. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362, except that the maximum penalty amount shall be ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per day.
(4)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may provide any information provided to it by any person pursuant to this subdivision to the commission, to the Attorney General, to any contractor retained to prepare reports required by this section, or any entity that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may contract with for the purpose of preparing the reports required by this section. The Attorney General may request from the commission or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration any information collected pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or this section, or Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25730).
(B)Except as provided in subdivision (c), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided pursuant to this paragraph shall be confidential and shall not be subject to public disclosure by the commission, the Attorney General, any contractor retained to prepare the reports required by this section, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration or its contractors.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, the reports required by this section shall only disclose confidential taxpayer information presented in aggregate form to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
SEC. 7.Section 25362 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25362.(a)The commission shall notify those persons who have failed to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355. If, within five days after being notified of the failure to provide the specified information, the person fails to supply the specified information, the person shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) nor more than twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) per day for each day the submission of information is refused or delayed, up to a maximum penalty of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) per submission.
(b)A person who willfully makes any false statement, representation, or certification in any record, report, plan, or other document filed with the commission shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed forty thousand dollars ($40,000).
(c)The administration of civil penalties under this section shall be subject to the procedures provided in Section 25534.1, and to the procedures for judicial review under Section 25534.2.
(d)In addition to any civil penalty provided for by this section, if a person fails to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355, the commission may petition a court for an order compelling the person to provide that information.
(e)For purposes of this section, the term person shall mean, in addition to the definition contained in Section 25116, any responsible corporate officer.
SEC. 8.Section 25364 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25364.(a)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or a person making a request for exemption pursuant to Section 25355.5 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(b)Information presented to the commission pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be held in confidence by the commission or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(c)(1)Whenever the commission receives a request to publicly disclose unaggregated information, or otherwise proposes to publicly disclose information submitted pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5, notice of the request or proposal shall be provided to the person submitting the information. The notice shall indicate the form in which the information is to be released. Upon receipt of notice, the person submitting the information shall have 10 working days in which to respond to the notice to justify the claim of confidentiality on each specific item of information covered by the notice on the basis that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(2)The commission shall consider the respondents submittal in determining whether to publicly disclose the information submitted to it to which a claim of confidentiality is made. The commission shall issue a written decision which sets forth its reasons for making the determination whether each item of information for which a claim of confidentiality is made shall remain confidential or shall be publicly disclosed.
(d)The commission shall not make public disclosure of information submitted to it pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 within 10 working days after the commission has issued its written decision required in this section.
(e)No information submitted to the commission pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be deemed confidential if the person submitting the information or data has made it public.
(f)With respect to petroleum products and blendstocks reported by type pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, information provided pursuant to subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, and information provided under Section 25355, neither the commission, the State Air Resources Board, or the Attorney General, nor any employee or contractor of those entities, may do any of the following:
(1)Use the information furnished under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 for any purpose other than law enforcement or the statistical purposes for which it is supplied.
(2)Make any publication whereby the information furnished by any particular establishment or individual under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 can be identified.
(3)Permit anyone other than commission members, the State Air Resources Board, the Attorney General, and employees or contractors of those entities to examine the individual reports provided under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355.
(g)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the State Air Resources Board or the Attorney General if the state board or the Attorney General agrees to keep the information confidential. With respect to the information it receives, the state board and the Attorney General shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission shall, upon request, timely disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, or staff members of each, provided that the information shall be provided only in aggregated or otherwise anonymized form, and each individual person receiving or having access to the information shall first agree, in writing, to keep the information confidential. Any person or committee receiving information under this subdivision shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(2)Aggregated or otherwise anonymized information disclosed under paragraph (1) shall be made available by the commission to the public no more than quarterly, upon request of the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, or the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, under conditions as the commission may determine are necessary to ensure that public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or adversely affect market competition.
(i)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 25354 to the administrator for oil spill response, appointed pursuant to Section 8670.4 of the Government Code, upon request for oil spill planning and preparedness purposes, and to first responders in the event of an accident or spill. Information disclosed to the administrator or first responders pursuant to this subdivision that has been identified as confidential under subdivision (a) shall not be disclosed to any other entity except pursuant to a request in accordance with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). Upon receipt of a records request seeking information disclosed pursuant to this subdivision, the administrator or first responder receiving the request shall provide the destination facility who provided the confidential information to the commission with an opportunity to submit, within a reasonable time, a response and information in support of exemption from disclosure before making the determination whether the requested records are exempt from disclosure. No requirement or deadline contained in the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) shall be extended or waived as a result of this subdivision.
(i)This section does not apply to aggregate data that are required to be posted on the commissions internet website pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 25355.
SEC. 9.Section 25367 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25367.(a)Except as otherwise provided, the adoption of, or amendment to, regulations or orders implementing this chapter shall be considered by the Office of Administrative Law as an emergency, and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, and general welfare. Notwithstanding any other law, the emergency regulations or orders adopted to implement this chapter shall remain in effect for two years. Although the commission may adopt regulations to further define terms or prescribe reporting procedures or calculation methodologies pursuant to this chapter, or prescribe any other method of implementing this chapter, the provisions of this chapter are self-executing and shall not require any implementing regulation to be effective.
(b)The commission may enter into contracts to implement this chapter, and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
SEC. 10.Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) is added to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, to read:4.6.Petroleum Market1.General Provisions25370.For purposes of this chapter and Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 25350), the following definitions apply:
(a)Planned maintenance means regular, periodic maintenance or repair of one or more pieces of equipment within a petroleum refinery that may require the shutdown of that equipment, or that may reduce production of a petroleum refinery.
(b)Price spike means a rate of increase of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin, as defined in Section 25355, that is greater than the rate of increase of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time, or a rate of decrease of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin that is less than the rate of decrease of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time.
(c)Transportation fuels means gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels.
(d)Turnaround has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 7872 of the Labor Code.
(e)Unplanned maintenance means any maintenance or repair that requires the shutdown of any part of the petroleum refinery that will result in any reduction in production that was not scheduled as turnaround or planned maintenance.
2.Transportation Fuels Assessment25371.(a)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, the commission shall submit an assessment to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, and to the Governor that does all of the following:
(A)Identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. The assessment shall include estimates for the level of transportation fuels at the state level, and, to the extent feasible, at regional and local levels, and individual refineries if relevant, that should be held in reserve by refiners to prevent gasoline price spikes. The assessment shall consider all factors causing price fluctuation in retail gasoline prices when recommending adequate reserve levels. The commission shall consider all relevant evidence from any reasonably available source, including, but not limited to, information about imports, by amount, source, if known, and data received by the commission pursuant to existing laws, economic and business experts, and information from any local, state, and federal agencies. The commission shall transmit to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, any proposals it deems appropriate for mandatory reserve levels and the terms of a program to implement reserve levels.
(B)Evaluates the price of transportation fuels, including branded and unbranded retail prices, alternate formulations of gasoline with lower carbon impact, and other products suitable for production from refineries in California. This evaluation shall consider the market demand for these products at 3-, 7-, 10- and 20-year intervals from the date of the assessment and shall rely on the most recent transportation forecasting and assessment activities conducted pursuant to Section 25304. This evaluation shall include both of the following:
(i)An examination of whether branded fuel additives have any impact, and if so, how much, on fuel efficiency and vehicle emissions.
(ii)An assessment of the presence and availability of retail outlets, including monitoring changes in availability of retail outlets that contribute to increasing retail prices in local and regional areas.
(C)Considers different levels of supply conditions and assesses the impact of potential refinery closures in California.
(D)Includes an analysis of the impacts on production of refinery planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, and turnaround. The assessment shall evaluate ways to manage necessary maintenance among the various facilities that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses. Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Industrial Relations and Division of Occupational Safety and Health shall disclose to the commission, upon request, any information the department and division have received under Section 7872 of the Labor Code to ensure all aspects of refinery safety are incorporated into the assessment. All information designated confidential shall be treated as confidential by the commission.
(E)Evaluates the utility and feasibility of alternative methods to maintain adequate supplies of transportation fuels, including delivery alternatives for fuel and components of refined fuel, such as delivery by rail, a publicly maintained strategic fuel reserve, and other solutions beyond the activities of refineries and petroleum market participants.
(F)Proposes solutions to mitigate any impacts described in the assessment. The solutions shall include an assessment of the employment impacts and the cost and cost-effectiveness of any proposal, including cost impacts to all impacted sectors, both public and private. The assessment shall include recommendations and alternatives.
(2)The first assessment shall include the evaluation of oil and gas extraction and refining that the State Air Resources Board outlined in the most recent update to the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code.
(b)The assessment shall be separate from the report submitted pursuant to Section 25302 and shall be developed in a public process. The assessment shall be available to the public within the proceeding docket and shall be approved by a vote of the commission at its business meeting.
(c)The commission may enter into contracts to perform the assessment required by subdivision (a) and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
(d)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the assessment required by subdivision (a).
25371.1.(a)The commission shall use reasonable means necessary and available, including, but not limited to, the authority under subdivisions (e) and (f) of Section 11181 of the Government Code, to seek and obtain any facts, figures, and other information from any source for the purpose of preparing the assessment under Section 25371. The commission shall specifically report in the assessment any ongoing or unsuccessful attempts to obtain information from potential sources, including the lack of cooperation or refusal to provide information.
(b)For purposes of the assessment prepared under Section 25371, the commission may impose a civil penalty whenever a person fails to timely provide the information specified in that section and any other information the commission deems necessary to conduct the assessment. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362.
(c)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 25362 shall apply to a person who willfully submits or makes any false statement to the commission.
(d)The commission shall conduct a public meeting in December of each year to provide an opportunity for the public to provide input on transportation fuel prices.
25371.2.(a)The commission shall aggregate information used in the assessment prepared under Section 25371 to the extent necessary to ensure its confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would adversely affect market competition.
(b)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25371 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(c)For purposes of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, the commission shall comply with the disclosure of information requirements of subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, of Section 25364.
25371.3.On or before December 31, 2024, the commission and the State Air Resources Board, taking into account findings of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, shall prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan. The commission and the State Air Resources Board shall determine the contents of the report, but the report shall include, at a minimum, a discussion of how to ensure that the supply of petroleum and alternative transportation fuels is affordable, reliable, equitable, and adequate to meet the demand for those transportation fuels described in the most current scoping plan approved by the State Air Resources Board under Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code. The report shall be prepared in consultation with the states fuel producers and refiners and a multistakeholder, multiagency workgroup, including the California Environmental Protection Agency and the Natural Resources Agency, convened by the commission and the State Air Resources Board to identify mechanisms to plan for and monitor progress toward the states reliable, safe, equitable, and affordable transition away from petroleum fuels in line with declining instate petroleum demand. The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the plan.
3.Division of Petroleum Market Oversight25372.For purposes of this article and Article 4 (commencing with Section 25373), division means the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight.
25372.1.(a)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight is hereby established in the commission.
(b)Notwithstanding Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 25200), the division shall operate with authority independent of the commissions authority.
(c)The division shall be led by a director, who is appointed by the Governor and is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and holds office at the pleasure of the Governor.
(d)The annual salary of the director shall be provided for by Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 11550) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(e)The director shall employ and prescribe the duties of other staff members as necessary to carry out the provisions of this article. The staff shall include, when feasible, economists, individuals with expertise in the transportation fuels markets, and investigative staff with legal training.
25372.2.(a)The division shall do all of the following:
(1)Provide independent oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels markets for the protection of consumers by identifying market design flaws, market power abuses, and any other manner by which market participants act to harm competition or act contrary to the best interests of consumers in the state.
(2)Provide guidance and recommendations to the commission relating to the development of the assessment required by Section 25371 and the Transportation Fuels Transition Plan described in Section 25371.3.
(3)Provide guidance and recommendations to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration relating to the reports described in Section 25355.7.
(4)Provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor, members of the commission, and other divisions of the commissions on any other issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California.
(5)Report its findings and recommendations to improve market performance at least annually to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, the Governor, the commission, the Attorney General, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(b)The division may subpoena witnesses, compel their attendance and testimony, administer oaths and affirmations, take evidence and require by subpoena the production of any books, papers, records, or other items material to the performance of the divisions duties or exercise of its powers, including, but not limited to, current and historical pricing and sales data and contracts with other petroleum industry participants.
(c)The division may refer potential violations of law to the Attorney General confidentially at any time.
25372.3.The director of the division shall, when requested, appear before the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly and Senate to provide an update on the divisions performance as compared to its objectives, the status of competition in the transportation fuels markets, and any other information the committees request.
25372.4.(a)Information provided to the division shall presumptively be confidential and not subject to public disclosure. The division shall not divulge or make known in any manner any information provided to it unless it determines both of the following:
(1)Public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information.
(2)Public disclosure of the specific information would not adversely affect market competition.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the division may disclose information deemed confidential under this subdivision to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, the Attorney General, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration if the receiving entity agrees to keep the information confidential, except that the Attorney General may present the information to a court to support an enforcement action but shall submit confidential information under seal where permissible. If the Attorney General requests the assistance of the division in connection with any investigation, the division shall provide information to the Attorney General under this subdivision and any other assistance that is feasible.
(c)For purposes of the divisions annual reports under Section 25372.2, the division shall aggregate data or otherwise anonymize and generalize information as needed to mitigate the risk that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
4.Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee25373.(a)The commission and division shall be advised by the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee which is hereby established within the commission. The committee shall consist of the following members:
(1)Six members appointed by the Governor as follows:
(A)A member who holds an academic appointment and has knowledge of economics or business operations of the transportation fuels market.
(B)A member representing the California petroleum fuels industry.
(C)A member representing consumers.
(D)A member representing labor.
(E)A member with expertise in community, environmental, or environmental justice issues.
(F)A member with expertise in antitrust law.
(2)One member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(3)One member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(b)(1)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), no member of the committee shall have been employed by, contracted with, or received direct compensation from, a company that produces, refines, distributes, trades in, markets, or sells any petroleum product in the preceding 12 months.
(2)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), before accepting appointment, members of the committee shall agree, in writing, not to be employed by, contract with, or receive direct compensation from companies described in paragraph (1) for the 12 months following the completion of their service on the committee.
(c)Each member of the committee shall receive a per diem of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day actually spent in the discharge of official duties, and shall be reimbursed for traveling and other expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of official duties.
(d)The duties, organization, and schedule of meetings of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall be prescribed by the commission. The commission may delegate the authority under this subdivision to the executive director of the commission.
(e)The Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall have access to all information submitted to the commission or to the division necessary to fulfill its duties. The members of the committee shall agree, in writing, to maintain the confidentiality of all information received.
(f)The executive director of the commission shall ensure that any confidential information shared with the members of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement and is maintained in a way that protects it from inadvertent disclosure.
SEC. 11.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which amends Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code, Section 5 of this act, which adds Section 25355.5 to the Public Resources Code, and Section 6 of this act, which adds Section 25355.7 to the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25354, 25355.5, and 25355.7 of the Public Resources Code is necessary to protect sensitive business information and trade secrets from public disclosure.
SEC. 12.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 10 of this act, which adds Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25371.2 and 25372.4 are necessary to prevent adverse impacts on market competition in the transportation fuels sector and to protect the public health and safety and the environment, respectively.
SEC. 13.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 14.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)From August to October of 2022, Californians experienced some of the highest gasoline prices ever recorded in the state, even though the price of crude oil declined, state taxes and fees remained unchanged, and gasoline prices did not increase outside the western United States.
(b)Much of this increase was caused by refiners, which increased the costs and profits they added to the price California consumers paid at the pump, leading to prices that were substantially higher per gallon than average prices in the rest of the United States.
(c)During the third and fourth quarters of 2022, the overlap in timing of planned maintenance at refiners facilities resulted in a larger decrease in crude oil processing capacity than would otherwise have occurred if planned maintenance at refiners facilities had not coincided.
(d)During this same period of time, refiners allowed gasoline inventory levels to reach decade-low levels, placing an upward pressure on gasoline prices.
(e)This refiner conduct makes clear that greater transparency into and oversight of refinery maintenance schedules and inventory is necessary, to avoid preventable supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.
(f)Historically, refinery outages and issues have created an opportunity for market participants to take advantage of naturally high prices by manipulating prices to stay higher longer, as evidenced by gasoline prices in California remaining elevated without explanation following a temporary price shock after a refinery explosion in 2015. This further demonstrates the need for greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants at all levels of the supply chain, and greater oversight by regulators empowered with the information and investigative tools needed to deter and detect anticompetitive conduct and other behavior that harms California consumers.
(g)Although preventable capacity limitations and inventory shortages played a role in the third quarter of 2022 price increases, they cannot account for all of those increases. Similar factors did not lead to extreme price spikes in prior years, suggesting that the sky-high prices Californians faced from August to October of 2022 were due in significant part to opportunistic price gouging by oil companies.
(h)Indeed, during a 90-day period in 2022, refiners earned a record $63,000,000,000 in profits, with some refiners earning more than tenfold their profits for the same period of time in 2021. Refiners annual profits for 2022 also set new record highs.
(i)Fundamental change is necessary to prevent future extreme price spikes and price gouging by oil companies, which are entitled to a reasonable return but are not entitled to reap exorbitant profits at the expense of Californians, many of whom rely on gasoline as an essential commodity or who are impacted by the increased cost of goods and services that results from the gasoline price spikes, even as the state begins to transition away from dependence on the fossil fuels that are destroying our climate.
SEC. 2.Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25354.(a)Each refiner and major marketer shall submit information each month to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. For purposes of this section, the term refiner and refinery shall include refiners and refineries as defined in Sections 25127 and 25128, and also those persons and facilities that process renewable feedstocks instead of crude oil feedstocks and otherwise meet the definitions in Sections 25127 and 25128. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period and shall include the following:
(1)Refiners shall report, by volume, price, and type, for each of their refineries, feedstock inputs, origin of petroleum receipts, imports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, including the source of those imports, exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, including the destination of those exports and the entity receiving those exports, refinery outputs, refinery stocks, finished product supply and distribution, including all gasoline sold unbranded by the refiner, blender, or importer, and all current inventories of refined and unrefined petroleum products.
(2)Major marketers shall report, by volume, price, and type, on petroleum product receipts and the sources of these receipts, inventories of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol, distributions through branded and unbranded distribution networks, and exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks and ethanol from the state.
(b)Each major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, oil storer, pipeline operator, or port through which refined gasoline is imported or exported, shall annually submit information to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each reporting period, and shall include the following:
(1)Major oil transporters shall report on petroleum by reporting the capacities of each major transportation system, the amount transported by each system, and inventories thereof. The commission may prescribe rules and regulations that exclude pipeline and transportation modes operated entirely on property owned by major oil transporters from the reporting requirements of this section if the data or information is not needed to fulfill the purposes of this chapter. The provision of the information shall not be construed to increase or decrease any authority the Public Utilities Commission may otherwise have.
(2)Major oil storers shall report on storage capacity, inventories, receipts and distributions, and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(3)Major oil producers shall, with respect to thermally enhanced oil recovery operations, report annually by designated oil field, the monthly use, as fuel, of crude oil and natural gas.
(4)Refiners shall report on facility capacity, and utilization and method of transportation of refinery receipts and distributions.
(5)Major oil marketers shall report on facility capacity and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(6)Pipeline operators and port operators shall report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline.
(7)All major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, oil storers, pipeline operators, or port operators submitting information under this subdivision shall include in the report for each reporting period the full names of all persons or entities that directly or indirectly own 10 percent or more of the major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, oil storer, pipeline operator, or port operator submitting the information.
(c)Each person required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) shall submit a projection each month of the information to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) for the quarter following the month in which the information is submitted to the commission.
(d)In addition to the data required under subdivision (a), each integrated oil refiner that produces, refines, transports, and markets in interstate commerce and that supplies more than 500 branded retail outlets in California shall submit to the commission an annual industry forecast for Petroleum Administration for Defense, District V, covering Arizona, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska, and Hawaii. The forecast shall include the information to be submitted under subdivision (a), and shall be submitted by March 15 of each year. The commission may require California-specific forecasts only if the commission finds them necessary to carry out its responsibilities.
(e)The commission may by order or regulation modify the reporting period as to any individual item of information setting forth in the order or regulation its reason for so doing.
(f)(1)Destination facilities shall submit to the commission, by deadlines set by the commission, the following information regarding crude oil transported to or within California via rail car or marine vessel:
(A)The route of transport within California.
(B)The marketable crude oil name.
(C)The loading facility, including the loading facility name, and the latitude, longitude, and state where the facility is located.
(D)The name of the destination facility, the type of facility, and the latitude and longitude where the facility is located.
(E)Whether the crude oil is nonfloating oil, as defined in Section 8670.3 of the Government Code.
(2)The commission shall quarterly prepare and make available to the public a report based on the data collected pursuant to paragraph (1) that shall include, at a minimum, the routes of transport of crude oil within California, the types of crude oil transported over each of those routes, and the frequency with which nonfloating oil has been transported over each of those routes during the reporting period. The commission shall aggregate information used in a report prepared under this paragraph to the extent necessary to assure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(3)The commission may require additional information to be submitted as necessary to perform its responsibilities under this chapter.
(g)Any person required to submit information or data under this chapter, in lieu thereof, may submit a report made to any other governmental agency, if:
(1)The alternate report or reports contain all of the information or data required by this chapter.
(2)The person clearly identifies the specific provision of this chapter to which the alternate report is responsive.
(h)Each refiner shall submit to the commission, within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period, all of the following information in such form and extent as the commission prescribes:
(1)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes of finished leaded regular, unleaded regular, and premium motor gasoline sold through company-operated retail outlets, to other end-users, and to wholesale customers.
(2)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for residential sales, commercial and institutional sales, industrial sales, sales through company-operated retail outlets, sales to other end-users, and wholesale sales of No. 2 diesel fuel, No. 2 fuel oil, and any renewable fuels.
(3)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for retail sales and wholesale sales of No. 1 distillate, kerosene, finished aviation gasoline, kerosene-type jet fuel, No. 4 fuel oil, residual fuel oil with 1 percent or less sulfur, residual fuel oil with greater than 1 percent sulfur, and consumer grade propane.
(i)(1)Beginning the first week after January 1, 2004, and each week thereafter, an oil refiner, oil producer, petroleum product transporter, petroleum product marketer, petroleum product pipeline operator, and terminal operator, as designated by the commission, shall submit a report in the form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The commission may determine the form and extent necessary by order or by regulation.
(2)A report may include any of the following information:
(A)Receipts and inventory levels of crude oil and petroleum products at each refinery and terminal location.
(B)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products imported and exported.
(C)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products transported intrastate by marine vessel.
(D)Amount of crude oil imported, including information identifying the source of the crude oil.
(E)The regional average of invoiced retailer buying price. This subparagraph does not either preclude or augment the current authority of the commission to collect additional data under paragraph (3) of subdivision (f).
(F)Copies of all contracts or agreements entered into, or amendments to contracts or agreements, with other oil refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of petroleum products, as designated by the commission, during the monthly reporting period, along with records of every transaction made under those contracts or agreements and the prices charged for those transactions.
(3)This subdivision is intended to clarify the commissions existing authority under subdivision (f) to collect specific information. This subdivision neither precludes nor augments the existing authority of the commission to collect information.
(j)All importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel shall report to the commission, at least 96 hours before the arrival of a marine vessel delivery to California, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the product tanker or name of the barge, including associated tug name.
(2)The loading location or locations for cargo.
(3)The volume by each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(4)The cargo landed cost, including the cost incurred to purchase, load, transport, and all other costs and fees to deliver, each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(5)The status of any transportation fuel as sold before discharge, the identity of the buyer for any presold product, and the sale price of any presold product.
(6)The planned discharge location, such as the marine berth designation, or locations.
(7)The foreign, domestic, and intrastate marine movements of the vessel from the port of origin to the port of delivery of the cargo.
(k)Nonrefiners, such as proprietary storage companies, that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable diesel fuel inventory not subject to contractual supply obligations, shall submit weekly reports to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that include the weekly inventory volume, by type, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels, for each position holder by name of company, and copies of all contracts or agreements entered into with any refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of those products, as designated by the commission.
(l)Refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions shall submit a daily report to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that includes all of the following information for each transaction occurring during the preceding day:
(1)The identity of the spot market where the transaction occurred.
(2)Whether the transaction was reported to the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS), or any other price reporting service, and the time of the reporting.
(3)The date of the transaction.
(4)The time of the transaction.
(5)The contract identification number for the transaction.
(6)The position sequence number for the transaction.
(7)The contract position identification number for the transaction.
(8)The name, or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader for the transaction.
(9)The counterparty for the transaction, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader.
(10)Whether the reporting entity is the seller or buyer.
(11)The broker, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing broker.
(12)The type of refined transportation fuel, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel.
(13)The product name for each type of refined transportation fuel.
(14)The volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(15)The invoiced volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(16)The time and date the material that is the subject of the transaction is scheduled to be delivered or was delivered.
(17)The delivery location specified in the contract for the transaction and the actual delivery location.
(18)The method of transportation for the delivery, such as pipeline, marine vessel, or truck, and the name of the transport.
(19)The actual title transfer date.
(20)The contract subcycle, including descriptors such as Any, L3, FH, BH, C1, C2, C3, or C4.
(21)The type of pricing method, including exchange of futures for physical (EFP), fixed price, fixed date range, floating date range, reference formula, OPIS close, event-related date range, such as three days on and around delivery or discharge, or any other utilized method of pricing.
(22)The contract price formula, including the differential from any contract formula and the unit of measurement for any price differential.
(23)The pricing start and end dates for each contract.
(24)The price value of the contract.
(25)For EFP contracts, the name of the futures product, the contract month of the futures product expressed as the two-digit month and the two-digit year (MM-YY), and the price value of the futures product.
(m)It is the intent of the Legislature that all refiners shall, while protecting the health and safety of the public and employees, schedule planned maintenance and turnaround in a manner that ensures minimum levels of transportation fuels in production or reserves necessary to prevent supply shortages or price spikes. To advance that purpose, refiners shall report maintenance activities for each refinery to the commission as follows:
(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a refiner shall notify the executive director of the commission of all plans to undertake turnaround and planned maintenance. A refiners notification shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information:
(A)A brief description of planned work.
(B)The scheduled start date.
(C)The scheduled return-to-service date.
(D)The individual process units involved.
(E)The name and operational capacity of each process unit.
(F)The estimated daily decrease in output of material or substance produced by the unit, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel components.
(G)The projected quantity of contractual supply obligations for finished gasoline due during the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(H)The drawdown of inventory levels of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the planned maintenance event or turnaround, the current levels of such inventories at the time notice is provided, and the anticipant levels of such inventories immediately before the commencement of the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(I)Imports of gasoline and gasoline blend components and other material or substance produced by the unit in preparation for or during the planned maintenance event.
(J)Planned purchases of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit from other market participants in California related to the planned maintenance event.
(K)Planned reductions of noncontracted sales of gasoline or other material or substance produced by the unit related to the planned maintenance event.
(2)The refiners notification shall be submitted to the executive director of the commission at least 120 days before the planned maintenance or turnaround.
(3)Before submitting its turnaround schedule notification to the Division of Occupational Safety and Health pursuant to Section 7872 of the Labor Code, each refiner shall submit its turnaround schedule to the executive director of the commission. When submitting its schedule to the division, each refiner shall indicate that, for each scheduled turnaround, the notification to the commission was submitted.
(4)For unplanned maintenance resulting in a shutdown of a refinery process of greater than 24 hours, submit initial and final reports as follows:
(A)The initial report, due within 48 hours of the initial outage, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The name and operational capacity of each process unit involved in the unplanned outage.
(ii)The initial estimated daily decrease in output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each process unit affected by the unplanned outage.
(iii)The current inventory levels of the material or substance produced by the unit affected by the unplanned outage that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(iv)A description of the reason for the unplanned maintenance or outage.
(v)The projected duration of production reduction.
(B)The final report, due within 48 hours of the completion of repairs, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The return-to-service date.
(ii)The total decreased output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each of the affected process units.
(iii)The total increased output from other process units by type of refined product to partially compensate for the reduced output from the process units affected by the unplanned outage.
(iv)The amount of material obtained from other sources that compensated for the decrease described in clause (ii) and enabled the refiner to cover for the loss of that production.
(v)The drawdown of inventory levels of any material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(5)Upon receipt of a notification under this subdivision, the executive director of the commission shall review the notification and may request any additional information from the refiner that is necessary for the commission to assess the potential effect of the planned maintenance event on the supply and prices of transportation fuels in the state.
(n)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, information in the notification provided to the commission by a refiner providing a notice or report of its planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, or turnaround schedule, including notifications under subdivision (m) shall be considered confidential information not subject to public disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). The commission may share the information with other state agencies, including the Attorney General, only if the other state agency agrees to maintain the confidentiality of the information.
(2)The commission may adopt guidelines to prescribe the manner in which the executive director of the commission shall implement subdivision (m) at a commission business meeting. The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulations, guidelines, or other standards adopted by the commission pursuant to this paragraph.
(o)Refiners shall report annually to the commission their planned production levels and schedule for turnarounds and planned maintenance for the following 12 months, by month and by finished product.
(p)(1)The operator of any refinery in this state shall report to the Commission at least 12 months in advance if that refinery operator intends to permanently shut down, shut down to reconfigure, or sell a refinery in a transaction that may result in a refinery shutting down or reconfiguring.
(2)Upon receipt of a notice pursuant to paragraph (1), the commission shall notify the Legislature in a manner that does not disclose confidential information, if applicable.
(3)After the completion of the report by the commission required by Section 25371 and its submission to the Legislature, the commission may modify the notice required under this subdivision. The commission shall not reduce the notice period to less than 12 months.
SEC. 3.Section 25354.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25354.2.The commission, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and labor and industry stakeholders, shall consider ways to manage necessary refinery turnarounds and maintenance that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses on fuel prices. The commission may, by regulation, impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations under this section.
SEC. 4.Section 25355 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25355.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin means the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the volume-weighted average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received by the refinery.
(2)Net gasoline refining margin means the gross gasoline refining margin minus the refinerys operational costs.
(3)Operational costs means costs, expressed in dollars per barrel, necessarily incurred by the operator of a refinery in the state to produce gasoline meeting California specifications, including, but not limited to, costs of labor, electricity, natural gas, chemicals, maintenance, hydrogen, and other intermediate oil products, federal renewable identification numbers, obligation costs, capital investments, logistics costs, and additive costs.
(b)Within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, the operator of each refinery operating in the state that produces gasoline meeting California specifications shall submit to the commission a report for the refinery containing all of the following information:
(1)The volume, in barrels, of crude oil received in that month, separated into domestic and foreign subtotals.
(2)The volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost paid for crude oil that is received and intended to be refined during that month, separated into domestic and foreign crude oil acquisition costs.
(3)The volume in barrels of refined gasoline received or imported in that month from entities other than the refiner.
(4)The volume-weighted average cost of any refined gasoline received or imported by a refiner during that month.
(5)The quantity, in barrels, of wholesale gasoline meeting California specifications sold and the corresponding volume-weighted average prices, less all applicable local, state, and federal taxes, separated by unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, and dealer tankwagon (DTW) sales in that month.
(6)Separate quantification of the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) and associated with the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack (CAR) program, for each volume-weighted average price for: (A) unbranded rack sales, (B) branded rack sales, (C) bulk sales, (D) spot pipeline sales, and (E) DTW sales, in that month.
(7)The gross gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(8)The operational costs per barrel of gasoline sold in that month, including a complete description and amount of each category of cost identified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any other category of cost.
(9)The net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(c)Within 45 days of the end of each calendar month, the commission shall post on its internet website all of the following:
(1)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted gross refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(2)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported for that month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within California.
(3)The net gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted net refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(4)The net gasoline refining margin data reported for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within the state.
(5)The aggregated data submitted pursuant to paragraphs (1) through (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) for that month.
SEC. 5.Section 25355.5 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.5.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs means the amount, expressed in dollars per barrel and calculated by the commission on a monthly basis, equal to the volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state, less the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all of the refiners wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low carbon fuel standard and the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack program, less the refiners volume-weighted average acquisition cost.
(2)Maximum gross gasoline refining margin means the maximum amount of gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs established under subdivision (b).
(3)Volume-weighted average acquisition cost means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost and the refiners volume-weighted cost of acquiring refined gasoline imported to California or received from an entity other than the refiner.
(4)Volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners rack price of the branded and unbranded rack sales reported under paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(5)Volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost means the amount reported as required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(b)The commission may, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(c)(1)If the commission sets a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall also establish a penalty for exceeding that maximum margin, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), that may be the same meeting described in subdivision (b).
(2)The penalty shall be a percentage of the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, converted from dollars per barrel to dollars per gallon, multiplied by the number of gallons sold by the refiner during the calendar month for all transactions described in paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(3)Subject to subdivision (j), the penalty shall be tiered, such that the penalty percentage shall increase with the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as follows:
(A)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by less than ten cents ($0.10) per gallon shall be subject to the base penalty percentage set by the commission.
(B)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin between by more than ten cents ($0.10) and less than or equal to twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the base penalty percentage.
(C)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by more than twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the penalty percentage set under subparagraph (B).
(d)In establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall consider information reported under subdivision (b) of Section 25355 and any other public data and reports that it determines will assist its analysis. The commission shall also consider confidential information submitted pursuant to Sections 25354 and 25355. A refiner may submit additional information and facts for the commission to consider under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364.
(e)The commission shall not set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin or accompanying penalty under subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, unless it finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. In making that determination, the commission shall consider all factors that in its discretion it deems relevant, including at a minimum all of the following factors, although no one factor shall be determinative:
(1)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(2)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(3)Whether case-by-case exemptions from the gross gasoline refining maximum margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
(f)Decisions of the commission under subdivision (b) to adopt a regulation or order setting a maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (c) to adopt a regulation or order establishing a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (e) regarding the benefits and costs to consumers, and under subdivision (k) regarding adjustments to, or rescission of, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin or penalty, shall be made in accordance with all of the following procedures:
(1)A notice and draft decision, regulation, or order shall be posted publicly at least 30 days before the business meeting at which adoption of the decision, regulation, or order will be considered.
(2)The commission shall receive written comments on the draft decision, regulation, or order.
(3)The commission shall hear public comment on the draft decision, regulation, or order at its business meeting.
(g)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the margin and penalty shall take effect 60 days following the commissions regulation or order establishing the margin and penalty pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively. Within 15 days of the regulation or order establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall notify refiners by a means determined by the commission that may include, but is not limited to, mail, email, or internet website posting.
(h)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall be a violation of this section for a refiner to exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(i)In addition to any other remedy that may be available, the commission may petition a court to enjoin a refiner from violating this section.
(j)The commission may impose an administrative civil penalty for a violation of this section in the amounts established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(k)The commission may, by regulation or order, at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), rescind or adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c) to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians. A refiner may submit information and facts for the commission to consider in support of any rescission or adjustment under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364. Rescission of, or adjustments to, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, pursuant to this subdivision shall be effective on the first day of the calendar month at least 15 days after the commission gives public notice of the rescission or adjustment, unless the commission orders otherwise.
(l)Notwithstanding Section 25901 and except as provided in subdivision (n), a petition for writ of mandate pursuant to Section 1085 of the Code of Civil Procedure shall be the exclusive remedy available to challenge any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, or adjudication of an exemption request adopted by the commission under this section. The courts review shall be limited exclusively to the record before the commission. Any petition shall be filed within 30 days of the commissions decision.
(m)(1)The commission shall consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and shall grant the exemption upon a showing by the refiner, based on competent and reliable evidence and subject to the commissions review, examination, and investigation of the evidence, that an application of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin would be unconstitutional as applied to the refiner. The commission may, in its discretion, grant a request for an exemption upon a showing by the refiner of good cause for an exemption, subject to alternative maximum margins or other conditions as the commission may set.
(2)Any refiner seeking an exemption shall, at a minimum, file a statement with the commission, signed under penalty of perjury, setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption. A refiner may submit information and facts under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364 to support its application for an exemption.
(n)(1)Before imposing the administrative civil penalty under subdivision (j), the executive director of the commission shall issue and serve a complaint on the refiner, and the commission shall hold a hearing, adopt a decision, and require payment of the penalty in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 25534.1.
(2)Judicial review and enforcement of an order imposing an administrative civil penalty under subdivision (j) may be had in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 25534.2.
(3)Penalties collected under this section shall be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury and shall be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
(4)The commission shall make public, on a quarterly basis, the name and address of each refiner that has exceeded the maximum gross gasoline refining margin for any month during the previous quarter, and the amount of administrative civil penalty to be assessed.
(o)The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, adjudication of an exemption request, or adjustment of the maximum gross gasoline margin, adopted by the commission under this section.
(p)The California State Auditor shall begin, no earlier than January 1, 2032, and complete, no later than March 1, 2033, an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty set pursuant to this section, if the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty. The California State Auditor shall make determinations in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether this section is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market for California consumers. Within 60 days of the issuance of the report, the commission shall hear from the California State Auditor at a business meeting of the commission. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, then the commission shall cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions no later than 180 days after the issuance of the report, unless the Legislature has enacted subsequent legislation to extend the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions in the meantime.
SEC. 6.Section 25355.7 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.7.(a)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before March 1, 2024, and March 1 of each year thereafter, the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, shall submit a report to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year.
(b)(1)(A)To facilitate the report required in subdivision (a) and to assist the commission in providing independent analysis and oversight of the market for transportation fuels, and in identifying potential market design flaws and market power abuses, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may, notwithstanding any other law, use any information that comes into its possession and may request from any person records required to be maintained pursuant to Section 7053 or 8301 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any other records in a persons possession, custody, or control that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration deems necessary for these purposes. Records that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may request, include, but are not limited to, sales prices and contracts for unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, dealer tankwagon sales, imported fuel transactions, and retail sales of gasoline meeting California specifications, including prices per gallon of gasoline charged by retailers by retail location and by grade of gasoline.
(B)Except as provided in paragraph (4), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration pursuant to this section shall constitute confidential information for purposes of Section 7056 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or Section 15570.84 of the Government Code and shall not be subject to public disclosure.
(2)(A)The records requested pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be provided in the form and manner specified by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration within 30 days of the notice of request.
(B)The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall provide written notification to the commission within 10 days after the failure or refusal of any person to provide information or records in the time and manner as specified pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(3)For purposes of the report required by subdivision (a), the commission may impose a civil penalty after receiving notification from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration that a person has failed or refused to provide information or records in the time and manner as required. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362, except that the maximum penalty amount shall be ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per day.
(4)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may provide any information provided to it by any person pursuant to this subdivision to the commission, to the Attorney General, to any contractor retained to prepare reports required by this section, or any entity that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may contract with for the purpose of preparing the reports required by this section. The Attorney General may request from the commission or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration any information collected pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or this section, or Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25730).
(B)Except as provided in subdivision (c), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided pursuant to this paragraph shall be confidential and shall not be subject to public disclosure by the commission, the Attorney General, any contractor retained to prepare the reports required by this section, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration or its contractors.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, the reports required by this section shall only disclose confidential taxpayer information presented in aggregate form to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
SEC. 7.Section 25362 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25362.(a)The commission shall notify those persons who have failed to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355. If, within five days after being notified of the failure to provide the specified information, the person fails to supply the specified information, the person shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) nor more than twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) per day for each day the submission of information is refused or delayed, up to a maximum penalty of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) per submission.
(b)A person who willfully makes any false statement, representation, or certification in any record, report, plan, or other document filed with the commission shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed forty thousand dollars ($40,000).
(c)The administration of civil penalties under this section shall be subject to the procedures provided in Section 25534.1, and to the procedures for judicial review under Section 25534.2.
(d)In addition to any civil penalty provided for by this section, if a person fails to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355, the commission may petition a court for an order compelling the person to provide that information.
(e)For purposes of this section, the term person shall mean, in addition to the definition contained in Section 25116, any responsible corporate officer.
SEC. 8.Section 25364 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25364.(a)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or a person making a request for exemption pursuant to Section 25355.5 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(b)Information presented to the commission pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be held in confidence by the commission or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(c)(1)Whenever the commission receives a request to publicly disclose unaggregated information, or otherwise proposes to publicly disclose information submitted pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5, notice of the request or proposal shall be provided to the person submitting the information. The notice shall indicate the form in which the information is to be released. Upon receipt of notice, the person submitting the information shall have 10 working days in which to respond to the notice to justify the claim of confidentiality on each specific item of information covered by the notice on the basis that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
(2)The commission shall consider the respondents submittal in determining whether to publicly disclose the information submitted to it to which a claim of confidentiality is made. The commission shall issue a written decision which sets forth its reasons for making the determination whether each item of information for which a claim of confidentiality is made shall remain confidential or shall be publicly disclosed.
(d)The commission shall not make public disclosure of information submitted to it pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 within 10 working days after the commission has issued its written decision required in this section.
(e)No information submitted to the commission pursuant to Section 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be deemed confidential if the person submitting the information or data has made it public.
(f)With respect to petroleum products and blendstocks reported by type pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, information provided pursuant to subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, and information provided under Section 25355, neither the commission, the State Air Resources Board, or the Attorney General, nor any employee or contractor of those entities, may do any of the following:
(1)Use the information furnished under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 for any purpose other than law enforcement or the statistical purposes for which it is supplied.
(2)Make any publication whereby the information furnished by any particular establishment or individual under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 can be identified.
(3)Permit anyone other than commission members, the State Air Resources Board, the Attorney General, and employees or contractors of those entities to examine the individual reports provided under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355.
(g)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the State Air Resources Board or the Attorney General if the state board or the Attorney General agrees to keep the information confidential. With respect to the information it receives, the state board and the Attorney General shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission shall, upon request, timely disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, or staff members of each, provided that the information shall be provided only in aggregated or otherwise anonymized form, and each individual person receiving or having access to the information shall first agree, in writing, to keep the information confidential. Any person or committee receiving information under this subdivision shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(2)Aggregated or otherwise anonymized information disclosed under paragraph (1) shall be made available by the commission to the public no more than quarterly, upon request of the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, or the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, under conditions as the commission may determine are necessary to ensure that public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or adversely affect market competition.
(i)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 25354 to the administrator for oil spill response, appointed pursuant to Section 8670.4 of the Government Code, upon request for oil spill planning and preparedness purposes, and to first responders in the event of an accident or spill. Information disclosed to the administrator or first responders pursuant to this subdivision that has been identified as confidential under subdivision (a) shall not be disclosed to any other entity except pursuant to a request in accordance with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). Upon receipt of a records request seeking information disclosed pursuant to this subdivision, the administrator or first responder receiving the request shall provide the destination facility who provided the confidential information to the commission with an opportunity to submit, within a reasonable time, a response and information in support of exemption from disclosure before making the determination whether the requested records are exempt from disclosure. No requirement or deadline contained in the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) shall be extended or waived as a result of this subdivision.
(i)This section does not apply to aggregate data that are required to be posted on the commissions internet website pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 25355.
SEC. 9.Section 25367 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25367.(a)Except as otherwise provided, the adoption of, or amendment to, regulations or orders implementing this chapter shall be considered by the Office of Administrative Law as an emergency, and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, and general welfare. Notwithstanding any other law, the emergency regulations or orders adopted to implement this chapter shall remain in effect for two years. Although the commission may adopt regulations to further define terms or prescribe reporting procedures or calculation methodologies pursuant to this chapter, or prescribe any other method of implementing this chapter, the provisions of this chapter are self-executing and shall not require any implementing regulation to be effective.
(b)The commission may enter into contracts to implement this chapter, and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
SEC. 10.Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) is added to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, to read:4.6.Petroleum Market1.General Provisions25370.For purposes of this chapter and Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 25350), the following definitions apply:
(a)Planned maintenance means regular, periodic maintenance or repair of one or more pieces of equipment within a petroleum refinery that may require the shutdown of that equipment, or that may reduce production of a petroleum refinery.
(b)Price spike means a rate of increase of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin, as defined in Section 25355, that is greater than the rate of increase of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time, or a rate of decrease of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin that is less than the rate of decrease of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time.
(c)Transportation fuels means gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels.
(d)Turnaround has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 7872 of the Labor Code.
(e)Unplanned maintenance means any maintenance or repair that requires the shutdown of any part of the petroleum refinery that will result in any reduction in production that was not scheduled as turnaround or planned maintenance.
2.Transportation Fuels Assessment25371.(a)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, the commission shall submit an assessment to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, and to the Governor that does all of the following:
(A)Identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. The assessment shall include estimates for the level of transportation fuels at the state level, and, to the extent feasible, at regional and local levels, and individual refineries if relevant, that should be held in reserve by refiners to prevent gasoline price spikes. The assessment shall consider all factors causing price fluctuation in retail gasoline prices when recommending adequate reserve levels. The commission shall consider all relevant evidence from any reasonably available source, including, but not limited to, information about imports, by amount, source, if known, and data received by the commission pursuant to existing laws, economic and business experts, and information from any local, state, and federal agencies. The commission shall transmit to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, any proposals it deems appropriate for mandatory reserve levels and the terms of a program to implement reserve levels.
(B)Evaluates the price of transportation fuels, including branded and unbranded retail prices, alternate formulations of gasoline with lower carbon impact, and other products suitable for production from refineries in California. This evaluation shall consider the market demand for these products at 3-, 7-, 10- and 20-year intervals from the date of the assessment and shall rely on the most recent transportation forecasting and assessment activities conducted pursuant to Section 25304. This evaluation shall include both of the following:
(i)An examination of whether branded fuel additives have any impact, and if so, how much, on fuel efficiency and vehicle emissions.
(ii)An assessment of the presence and availability of retail outlets, including monitoring changes in availability of retail outlets that contribute to increasing retail prices in local and regional areas.
(C)Considers different levels of supply conditions and assesses the impact of potential refinery closures in California.
(D)Includes an analysis of the impacts on production of refinery planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, and turnaround. The assessment shall evaluate ways to manage necessary maintenance among the various facilities that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses. Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Industrial Relations and Division of Occupational Safety and Health shall disclose to the commission, upon request, any information the department and division have received under Section 7872 of the Labor Code to ensure all aspects of refinery safety are incorporated into the assessment. All information designated confidential shall be treated as confidential by the commission.
(E)Evaluates the utility and feasibility of alternative methods to maintain adequate supplies of transportation fuels, including delivery alternatives for fuel and components of refined fuel, such as delivery by rail, a publicly maintained strategic fuel reserve, and other solutions beyond the activities of refineries and petroleum market participants.
(F)Proposes solutions to mitigate any impacts described in the assessment. The solutions shall include an assessment of the employment impacts and the cost and cost-effectiveness of any proposal, including cost impacts to all impacted sectors, both public and private. The assessment shall include recommendations and alternatives.
(2)The first assessment shall include the evaluation of oil and gas extraction and refining that the State Air Resources Board outlined in the most recent update to the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code.
(b)The assessment shall be separate from the report submitted pursuant to Section 25302 and shall be developed in a public process. The assessment shall be available to the public within the proceeding docket and shall be approved by a vote of the commission at its business meeting.
(c)The commission may enter into contracts to perform the assessment required by subdivision (a) and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
(d)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the assessment required by subdivision (a).
25371.1.(a)The commission shall use reasonable means necessary and available, including, but not limited to, the authority under subdivisions (e) and (f) of Section 11181 of the Government Code, to seek and obtain any facts, figures, and other information from any source for the purpose of preparing the assessment under Section 25371. The commission shall specifically report in the assessment any ongoing or unsuccessful attempts to obtain information from potential sources, including the lack of cooperation or refusal to provide information.
(b)For purposes of the assessment prepared under Section 25371, the commission may impose a civil penalty whenever a person fails to timely provide the information specified in that section and any other information the commission deems necessary to conduct the assessment. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362.
(c)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 25362 shall apply to a person who willfully submits or makes any false statement to the commission.
(d)The commission shall conduct a public meeting in December of each year to provide an opportunity for the public to provide input on transportation fuel prices.
25371.2.(a)The commission shall aggregate information used in the assessment prepared under Section 25371 to the extent necessary to ensure its confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would adversely affect market competition.
(b)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25371 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(c)For purposes of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, the commission shall comply with the disclosure of information requirements of subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, of Section 25364.
25371.3.On or before December 31, 2024, the commission and the State Air Resources Board, taking into account findings of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, shall prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan. The commission and the State Air Resources Board shall determine the contents of the report, but the report shall include, at a minimum, a discussion of how to ensure that the supply of petroleum and alternative transportation fuels is affordable, reliable, equitable, and adequate to meet the demand for those transportation fuels described in the most current scoping plan approved by the State Air Resources Board under Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code. The report shall be prepared in consultation with the states fuel producers and refiners and a multistakeholder, multiagency workgroup, including the California Environmental Protection Agency and the Natural Resources Agency, convened by the commission and the State Air Resources Board to identify mechanisms to plan for and monitor progress toward the states reliable, safe, equitable, and affordable transition away from petroleum fuels in line with declining instate petroleum demand. The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the plan.
3.Division of Petroleum Market Oversight25372.For purposes of this article and Article 4 (commencing with Section 25373), division means the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight.
25372.1.(a)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight is hereby established in the commission.
(b)Notwithstanding Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 25200), the division shall operate with authority independent of the commissions authority.
(c)The division shall be led by a director, who is appointed by the Governor and is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and holds office at the pleasure of the Governor.
(d)The annual salary of the director shall be provided for by Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 11550) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(e)The director shall employ and prescribe the duties of other staff members as necessary to carry out the provisions of this article. The staff shall include, when feasible, economists, individuals with expertise in the transportation fuels markets, and investigative staff with legal training.
25372.2.(a)The division shall do all of the following:
(1)Provide independent oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels markets for the protection of consumers by identifying market design flaws, market power abuses, and any other manner by which market participants act to harm competition or act contrary to the best interests of consumers in the state.
(2)Provide guidance and recommendations to the commission relating to the development of the assessment required by Section 25371 and the Transportation Fuels Transition Plan described in Section 25371.3.
(3)Provide guidance and recommendations to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration relating to the reports described in Section 25355.7.
(4)Provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor, members of the commission, and other divisions of the commissions on any other issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California.
(5)Report its findings and recommendations to improve market performance at least annually to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, the Governor, the commission, the Attorney General, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(b)The division may subpoena witnesses, compel their attendance and testimony, administer oaths and affirmations, take evidence and require by subpoena the production of any books, papers, records, or other items material to the performance of the divisions duties or exercise of its powers, including, but not limited to, current and historical pricing and sales data and contracts with other petroleum industry participants.
(c)The division may refer potential violations of law to the Attorney General confidentially at any time.
25372.3.The director of the division shall, when requested, appear before the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly and Senate to provide an update on the divisions performance as compared to its objectives, the status of competition in the transportation fuels markets, and any other information the committees request.
25372.4.(a)Information provided to the division shall presumptively be confidential and not subject to public disclosure. The division shall not divulge or make known in any manner any information provided to it unless it determines both of the following:
(1)Public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information.
(2)Public disclosure of the specific information would not adversely affect market competition.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the division may disclose information deemed confidential under this subdivision to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, the Attorney General, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration if the receiving entity agrees to keep the information confidential, except that the Attorney General may present the information to a court to support an enforcement action but shall submit confidential information under seal where permissible. If the Attorney General requests the assistance of the division in connection with any investigation, the division shall provide information to the Attorney General under this subdivision and any other assistance that is feasible.
(c)For purposes of the divisions annual reports under Section 25372.2, the division shall aggregate data or otherwise anonymize and generalize information as needed to mitigate the risk that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
4.Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee25373.(a)The commission and division shall be advised by the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee which is hereby established within the commission. The committee shall consist of the following members:
(1)Six members appointed by the Governor as follows:
(A)A member who holds an academic appointment and has knowledge of economics or business operations of the transportation fuels market.
(B)A member representing the California petroleum fuels industry.
(C)A member representing consumers.
(D)A member representing labor.
(E)A member with expertise in community, environmental, or environmental justice issues.
(F)A member with expertise in antitrust law.
(2)One member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(3)One member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(b)(1)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), no member of the committee shall have been employed by, contracted with, or received direct compensation from, a company that produces, refines, distributes, trades in, markets, or sells any petroleum product in the preceding 12 months.
(2)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), before accepting appointment, members of the committee shall agree, in writing, not to be employed by, contract with, or receive direct compensation from companies described in paragraph (1) for the 12 months following the completion of their service on the committee.
(c)Each member of the committee shall receive a per diem of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day actually spent in the discharge of official duties, and shall be reimbursed for traveling and other expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of official duties.
(d)The duties, organization, and schedule of meetings of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall be prescribed by the commission. The commission may delegate the authority under this subdivision to the executive director of the commission.
(e)The Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall have access to all information submitted to the commission or to the division necessary to fulfill its duties. The members of the committee shall agree, in writing, to maintain the confidentiality of all information received.
(f)The executive director of the commission shall ensure that any confidential information shared with the members of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement and is maintained in a way that protects it from inadvertent disclosure.
SEC. 11.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which amends Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code, Section 5 of this act, which adds Section 25355.5 to the Public Resources Code, and Section 6 of this act, which adds Section 25355.7 to the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25354, 25355.5, and 25355.7 of the Public Resources Code is necessary to protect sensitive business information and trade secrets from public disclosure.
SEC. 12.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 10 of this act, which adds Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25371.2 and 25372.4 are necessary to prevent adverse impacts on market competition in the transportation fuels sector and to protect the public health and safety and the environment, respectively.
SEC. 13.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 14.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)From August to October of 2022, Californians experienced some of the highest gasoline prices ever recorded in the state, even though the price of crude oil declined, state taxes and fees remained unchanged, and gasoline prices did not increase outside the western United States.
(b)Much of this increase was caused by refiners, which increased the costs and profits they added to the price California consumers paid at the pump, leading to prices that were substantially higher per gallon than average prices in the rest of the United States.
(c)During the third and fourth quarters of 2022, the overlap in timing of planned maintenance at refiners facilities resulted in a larger decrease in crude oil processing capacity than would otherwise have occurred if planned maintenance at refiners facilities had not coincided.
(d)During this same period of time, refiners allowed gasoline inventory levels to reach decade-low levels, placing an upward pressure on gasoline prices.
(e)This refiner conduct makes clear that greater transparency into and oversight of refinery maintenance schedules and inventory is necessary, to avoid preventable supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.
(f)Historically, refinery outages and issues have created an opportunity for market participants to take advantage of naturally high prices by manipulating prices to stay higher longer, as evidenced by gasoline prices in California remaining elevated without explanation following a temporary price shock after a refinery explosion in 2015, which 2015. This further demonstrates the need for greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants. participants at all levels of the supply chain, and greater oversight by regulators empowered with the information and investigative tools needed to deter and detect anticompetitive conduct and other behavior that harms California consumers.
(g)Although preventable capacity limitations and inventory shortages played a role in the third quarter of 2022 price increases, they cannot account for all of those increases. Similar factors did not lead to extreme price spikes in prior years, suggesting that the sky-high prices Californians faced from August to October of 2022 were due in significant part to opportunistic price gouging by oil companies.
(h)Indeed, during the third quarter of a 90-day period in 2022, refiners earned record profits, a record $63,000,000,000 in profits, with some refiners earning more than tenfold their profits for the same period of time in 2021. Refiners annual profits for 2022 also set new record highs.
(i)Fundamental change is necessary to prevent future extreme price spikes and price gouging by oil companies, which are entitled to a reasonable return but are not entitled to reap exorbitant profits at the expense of Californians, many of whom rely on gasoline as an essential commodity or who are impacted by the increased cost of goods and services that results from the gasoline price spikes, even as the state begins to transition away from dependence on the fossil fuels that are destroying our climate.
SEC. 2.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would do all of the following:(a)Require that the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission (Energy Commission) conduct regular assessments of the supply and price of transportation fuels in the state, and of the impacts on production of refinery maintenance and turnarounds on fuel supply and price.(b)Expand the Energy Commissions authority to investigate and obtain necessary information, including information regarding pricing, supply contracts, and inventory management, from participants in the market for transportation fuels.(c)Expand the Energy Commissions authority to order that refinery maintenance and turnarounds be rescheduled in specified circumstances, when consistent with employee and public safety and necessary to avoid supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.(d)Establish an advisory committee of fuels market experts to provide the Energy Commission with independent advice and insights.(e)Require the Energy Commission and the State Air Resources Board, in consultation with the states fuel producers and refiners, to plan for and monitor progress toward the states reliable, safe, equitable, and affordable transition away from petroleum fuels, and to issue periodic reports to the Governor and the Legislature.(f)Supplement existing refinery reporting requirements by requiring more detailed reports to the Energy Commission on transportation fuel imports, inventory levels, and transactions, and on refinery maintenance and turnarounds. SEC. 3.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would direct the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, in collaboration with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, to investigate and report on the drivers of and factors affecting the price of gasoline in the refining, distribution, and retail segments of the gasoline market; to uncover pricing irregularities in the California gasoline market and their effect on tax revenue; and to report its findings to the Governor and the Legislature. SEC. 2.Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25354.(a)Each refiner and major marketer shall submit information each month to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. For purposes of this section, the term refiner and refinery shall include refiners and refineries as defined in Sections 25127 and 25128, and also those persons and facilities that process renewable feedstocks instead of crude oil feedstocks and otherwise meet the definitions in Sections 25127 and 25128. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period and shall include the following:
(1)Refiners shall report, by volume, price, and type, for each of their refineries, feedstock inputs, origin of petroleum receipts, imports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, blendstocks and ethanol, including the source of those imports, exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, blendstocks and ethanol, including the destination of those exports, exports and the entity receiving those exports, refinery outputs, refinery stocks, and finished product supply and distribution, including all gasoline sold unbranded by the refiner, blender, or importer. importer, and all current inventories of refined and unrefined petroleum products.
(2)Major marketers shall report report, by volume, price, and type, on petroleum product receipts and the sources of these receipts, inventories of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, blendstocks and ethanol, distributions through branded and unbranded distribution networks, and exports of finished petroleum products and blendstocks, by type, blendstocks and ethanol from the state.
(b)Each major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, and oil storer oil storer, pipeline operator, or port through which refined gasoline is imported or exported, shall annually submit information to the commission in such form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The information shall be submitted within 30 days after the end of each reporting period, and shall include the following:
(1)Major oil transporters shall report on petroleum by reporting the capacities of each major transportation system, the amount transported by each system, and inventories thereof. The commission may prescribe rules and regulations that exclude pipeline and transportation modes operated entirely on property owned by major oil transporters from the reporting requirements of this section if the data or information is not needed to fulfill the purposes of this chapter. The provision of the information shall not be construed to increase or decrease any authority the Public Utilities Commission may otherwise have.
(2)Major oil storers shall report on storage capacity, inventories, receipts and distributions, and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(3)Major oil producers shall, with respect to thermally enhanced oil recovery operations, report annually by designated oil field, the monthly use, as fuel, of crude oil and natural gas.
(4)Refiners shall report on facility capacity, and utilization and method of transportation of refinery receipts and distributions.
(5)Major oil marketers shall report on facility capacity and methods of transportation of receipts and distributions.
(6)Pipeline operators and port operators shall report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline.
(7)All major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, oil storers, pipeline operators, or port operators submitting information under this subdivision shall include in the report for each reporting period the full names of all persons or entities that directly or indirectly own 10 percent or more of the major oil producer, refiner, marketer, oil transporter, oil storer, pipeline operator, or port operator submitting the information.
(c)Each person required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) shall submit a projection each month of the information to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) for the quarter following the month in which the information is submitted to the commission.
(d)In addition to the data required under subdivision (a), each integrated oil refiner (produces, that produces, refines, transports, and markets in interstate commerce) who commerce and that supplies more than 500 branded retail outlets in California shall submit to the commission an annual industry forecast for Petroleum Administration for Defense, District V (covering V, covering Arizona, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska, and Hawaii). Hawaii. The forecast shall include the information to be submitted under subdivision (a), and shall be submitted by March 15 of each year. The commission may require California-specific forecasts. However, those forecasts shall be required forecasts only if the commission finds them necessary to carry out its responsibilities.
(e)The commission may by order or regulation modify the reporting period as to any individual item of information setting forth in the order or regulation its reason for so doing.
(f)(1)The commission shall request, from destination facilities, Destination facilities shall submit to the commission, by deadlines set by the commission, the following information regarding crude oil transported to or within California via rail car or marine vessel:
(A)The route of transport within California.
(B)The marketable crude oil name.
(C)The loading facility, including the loading facility name, and the latitude, longitude, and state where the facility is located.
(D)The name of the destination facility, the type of facility, and the latitude and longitude where the facility is located.
(E)Whether the crude oil is nonfloating oil, as defined in Section 8670.3 of the Government Code.
(2)The commission shall quarterly prepare and make available to the public a report based on the data collected pursuant to paragraph (1) that shall include, at a minimum, the routes of transport of crude oil within California, the types of crude oil transported over each of those routes, and the frequency with which nonfloating oil has been transported over each of those routes during the reporting period. The commission shall aggregate information used in a report prepared under this paragraph to the extent necessary to assure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. information or would adversely affect market competition.
(3)The commission may request require additional information to be submitted as necessary to perform its responsibilities under this chapter.
(g)Any person required to submit information or data under this chapter, in lieu thereof, may submit a report made to any other governmental agency, if:
(1)The alternate report or reports contain all of the information or data required by specific request under this chapter.
(2)The person clearly identifies the specific request provision of this chapter to which the alternate report is responsive.
(h)Each refiner shall submit to the commission, within 30 days after the end of each monthly reporting period, all of the following information in such form and extent as the commission prescribes:
(1)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes of finished leaded regular, unleaded regular, and premium motor gasoline sold through company-operated retail outlets, to other end-users, and to wholesale customers.
(2)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for residential sales, commercial and institutional sales, industrial sales, sales through company-operated retail outlets, sales to other end-users, and wholesale sales of No. 2 diesel fuel and fuel, No. 2 fuel oil. oil, and any renewable fuels.
(3)Monthly California weighted average prices and sales volumes for retail sales and wholesale sales of No. 1 distillate, kerosene, finished aviation gasoline, kerosene-type jet fuel, No. 4 fuel oil, residual fuel oil with 1 percent or less sulfur, residual fuel oil with greater than 1 percent sulfur sulfur, and consumer grade propane.
(i)(1)Beginning the first week after the effective date of the act that added this subdivision, January 1, 2004, and each week thereafter, an oil refiner, oil producer, petroleum product transporter, petroleum product marketer, petroleum product pipeline operator, and terminal operator, as designated by the commission, shall submit a report in the form and extent as the commission prescribes pursuant to this section. The commission may determine the form and extent necessary by order or by regulation.
(2)A report may include any of the following information:
(A)Receipts and inventory levels of crude oil and petroleum products at each refinery and terminal location.
(B)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products imported and exported.
(C)Amount of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, blending components, and other petroleum products transported intrastate by marine vessel.
(D)Amount of crude oil imported, including information identifying the source of the crude oil.
(E)The regional average of invoiced retailer buying price. This subparagraph does not either preclude or augment the current authority of the commission to collect additional data under paragraph (3) of subdivision (f).
(F)Copies of all contracts or agreements entered into, or amendments to contracts or agreements, with other oil refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of petroleum products, as designated by the commission, during the monthly reporting period, along with records of every transaction made under those contracts or agreements and the prices charged for those transactions.
(3)This subdivision is intended to clarify the commissions existing authority under subdivision (f) to collect specific information. This subdivision does not either preclude or augment neither precludes nor augments the existing authority of the commission to collect information.
(j)All importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel shall report to the commission, at least 96 hours before the arrival of a marine vessel delivery to California, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the product tanker or name of the barge, including associated tug name.
(2)The loading location or locations for cargo.
(3)The volume by each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(4)The cargo landed cost, including the cost incurred to purchase, load, transport, and all other costs and fees to deliver, each type of transportation fuel, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, renewable diesel fuel, jet fuel, sustainable aviation fuel, biodiesel, and ethanol.
(5)The status of any transportation fuel as sold before discharge, the identity of the buyer for any presold product, and the sale price of any presold product.
(6)The planned discharge location, such as the marine berth designation, or locations.
(7)The foreign, domestic, and intrastate marine movements of the vessel from the port of origin to the port of delivery of the cargo.
(k)Nonrefiners, such as proprietary storage companies, that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable diesel fuel inventory not subject to contractual supply obligations, shall submit weekly reports to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that include the weekly inventory volume, by type, such as gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels, for each position holder by name of company, and copies of all contracts or agreements entered into with any refiners, oil producers, petroleum product transporters, petroleum product marketers, petroleum product pipeline operators, terminal operators, or any other entity that trades in petroleum products whether or not those entities take possession of those products, as designated by the commission.
(l)Refiners and nonrefiners that consummate spot market transactions shall submit a daily report to the commission, starting 30 days after the effective date of the act adding this subdivision, that includes all of the following information for each transaction occurring during the preceding day:
(1)The identity of the spot market where the transaction occurred.
(2)Whether the transaction was reported to the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS), or any other price reporting service, and the time of the reporting.
(3)The date of the transaction.
(4)The time of the transaction.
(5)The contract identification number for the transaction.
(6)The position sequence number for the transaction.
(7)The contract position identification number for the transaction.
(8)The name, or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader for the transaction.
(9)The counterparty for the transaction, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing trader.
(10)Whether the reporting entity is the seller or buyer.
(11)The broker, including company name and name or nonanonymized identification of the executing broker.
(12)The type of refined transportation fuel, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel.
(13)The product name for each type of refined transportation fuel.
(14)The volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(15)The invoiced volume of each transaction in thousands of barrels, or specified unit of measurement if unable to be indicated in thousands of barrels.
(16)The time and date the material that is the subject of the transaction is scheduled to be delivered or was delivered.
(17)The delivery location specified in the contract for the transaction and the actual delivery location.
(18)The method of transportation for the delivery, such as pipeline, marine vessel, or truck, and the name of the transport.
(19)The actual title transfer date.
(20)The contract subcycle, including descriptors such as Any, L3, FH, BH, C1, C2, C3, or C4.
(21)The type of pricing method, including exchange of futures for physical (EFP), fixed price, fixed date range, floating date range, reference formula, OPIS close, event-related date range, such as three days on and around delivery or discharge, or any other utilized method of pricing.
(22)The contract price formula, including the differential from any contract formula and the unit of measurement for any price differential.
(23)The pricing start and end dates for each contract.
(24)The price value of the contract.
(25)For EFP contracts, the name of the futures product, the contract month of the futures product expressed as the two-digit month and the two-digit year (MM-YY), and the price value of the futures product.
(m)It is the intent of the Legislature that all refiners shall, while protecting the health and safety of the public and employees, schedule planned maintenance and turnaround in a manner that ensures minimum levels of transportation fuels in production or reserves necessary to prevent supply shortages or price spikes. To advance that purpose, refiners shall report maintenance activities for each refinery to the commission as follows:
(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a refiner shall notify the executive director of the commission of all plans to undertake turnaround and planned maintenance. A refiners notification shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information:
(A)A brief description of planned work.
(B)The scheduled start date.
(C)The scheduled return-to-service date.
(D)The individual process units involved.
(E)The name and operational capacity of each process unit.
(F)The estimated daily decrease in output of material or substance produced by the unit, such as gasoline, diesel, or jet fuel components.
(G)The projected quantity of contractual supply obligations for finished gasoline due during the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(H)The drawdown of inventory levels of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the planned maintenance event or turnaround, the current levels of such inventories at the time notice is provided, and the anticipant levels of such inventories immediately before the commencement of the planned maintenance event or turnaround.
(I)Imports of gasoline and gasoline blend components and other material or substance produced by the unit in preparation for or during the planned maintenance event.
(J)Planned purchases of gasoline and gasoline blending components and other material or substance produced by the unit from other market participants in California related to the planned maintenance event.
(K)Planned reductions of noncontracted sales of gasoline or other material or substance produced by the unit related to the planned maintenance event.
(2)The refiners notification shall be submitted to the executive director of the commission at least 120 days before the planned maintenance or turnaround.
(3)Before submitting its turnaround schedule notification to the Division of Occupational Safety and Health pursuant to Section 7872 of the Labor Code, each refiner shall submit its turnaround schedule to the executive director of the commission. When submitting its schedule to the division, each refiner shall indicate that, for each scheduled turnaround, the notification to the commission was submitted.
(4)For unplanned maintenance resulting in a shutdown of a refinery process of greater than 24 hours, submit initial and final reports as follows:
(A)The initial report, due within 48 hours of the initial outage, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The name and operational capacity of each process unit involved in the unplanned outage.
(ii)The initial estimated daily decrease in output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each process unit affected by the unplanned outage.
(iii)The current inventory levels of the material or substance produced by the unit affected by the unplanned outage that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(iv)A description of the reason for the unplanned maintenance or outage.
(v)The projected duration of production reduction.
(B)The final report, due within 48 hours of the completion of repairs, shall include all of the following information:
(i)The return-to-service date.
(ii)The total decreased output of gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel components from each of the affected process units.
(iii)The total increased output from other process units by type of refined product to partially compensate for the reduced output from the process units affected by the unplanned outage.
(iv)The amount of material obtained from other sources that compensated for the decrease described in clause (ii) and enabled the refiner to cover for the loss of that production.
(v)The drawdown of inventory levels of any material or substance produced by the unit that are controlled by the refiner at the refinery and at other storage locations in California during the unplanned maintenance event.
(5)Upon receipt of a notification under this subdivision, the executive director of the commission shall review the notification and may request any additional information from the refiner that is necessary for the commission to assess the potential effect of the planned maintenance event on the supply and prices of transportation fuels in the state.
(n)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, information in the notification provided to the commission by a refiner providing a notice or report of its planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, or turnaround schedule, including notifications under subdivision (m) shall be considered confidential information not subject to public disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). The commission may share the information with other state agencies, including the Attorney General, only if the other state agency agrees to maintain the confidentiality of the information.
(2)The commission may adopt guidelines to prescribe the manner in which the executive director of the commission shall implement subdivision (m) at a commission business meeting. The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulations, guidelines, or other standards adopted by the commission pursuant to this paragraph.
(o)Refiners shall report annually to the commission their planned production levels and schedule for turnarounds and planned maintenance for the following 12 months, by month and by finished product.
(p)(1)The operator of any refinery in this state shall report to the Commission at least 12 months in advance if that refinery operator intends to permanently shut down, shut down to reconfigure, or sell a refinery in a transaction that may result in a refinery shutting down or reconfiguring.
(2)Upon receipt of a notice pursuant to paragraph (1), the commission shall notify the Legislature in a manner that does not disclose confidential information, if applicable.
(3)After the completion of the report by the commission required by Section 25371 and its submission to the Legislature, the commission may modify the notice required under this subdivision. The commission shall not reduce the notice period to less than 12 months.
SEC. 3.Section 25354.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25354.2.The commission, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and labor and industry stakeholders, shall consider ways to manage necessary refinery turnarounds and maintenance that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses on fuel prices. The commission may, by regulation, impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations under this section.
SEC. 4.Section 25355 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25355.(a)For purposes of this section, gross the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin means the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the volume-weighted average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received by the refinery.
(2)Net gasoline refining margin means the gross gasoline refining margin minus the refinerys operational costs.
(3)Operational costs means costs, expressed in dollars per barrel, necessarily incurred by the operator of a refinery in the state to produce gasoline meeting California specifications, including, but not limited to, costs of labor, electricity, natural gas, chemicals, maintenance, hydrogen, and other intermediate oil products, federal renewable identification numbers, obligation costs, capital investments, logistics costs, and additive costs.
(b)Within 30 days of the end of each calendar month, the operator of each refinery operating in the state that produces gasoline meeting California specifications shall submit to the commission a report for the refinery containing all of the following information:
(1)The volume volume, in barrels, of crude oil received in that month, separated into domestic and foreign subtotals.
(2)The volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost paid for crude oil that is received and intended to be refined during that month, separated into domestic and foreign crude oil acquisition costs.
(3)The volume in barrels of refined gasoline received or imported in that month from entities other than the refiner.
(4)The volume-weighted average cost of any refined gasoline received or imported by a refiner during that month.
(3)(5)The quantity quantity, in barrels, of wholesale gasoline meeting California specifications sold and the corresponding volume-weighted average prices, less all applicable local, state, and federal taxes, separated by unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, and dealer tankwagon (DTW) sales in that month.
(4)(6)Separate quantification of the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) and associated with the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack (CAR) program, for each volume-weighted average price for: (A) unbranded rack sales, (B) branded rack sales, (C) bulk sales, (D) spot pipeline sales, and (E) DTW sales, in that month.
(5)(7)The gross gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(8)The operational costs per barrel of gasoline sold in that month, including a complete description and amount of each category of cost identified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any other category of cost.
(9)The net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month.
(c)Within 45 days of the end of each calendar month, the commission shall post on its internet website all of the following:
(1)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted gross refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(2)The gross gasoline refining margin data reported for that month month, and any gross gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within California.
(3)The net gasoline refining margin data reported pursuant to this section for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, as a volume-weighted net refining margin in aggregate for all the combined refineries in the state.
(4)The net gasoline refining margin data reported for that month, and any net gasoline refining margin independently calculated by the commission, in aggregate for each refiner with more than one refinery operating within the state.
(3)(5)The aggregated data submitted pursuant to paragraphs (1) through (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) for that month.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 25355.5 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.5.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs means the amount, expressed in dollars per barrel and calculated by the commission on a monthly basis, equal to the volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline sold by the refiner, a refiner in the state, less the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all of the refiners wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low carbon fuel standard and the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack program, less the refiners volume-weighted average acquisition cost.
(2)Maximum gross gasoline refining margin means the maximum amount of gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs established or adjusted under subdivision (c). (b).
(3)Volume-weighted average acquisition cost is means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost and the refiners volume-weighted cost of acquiring refined gasoline imported to California or acquired received from another an entity other than the refiner.
(4)Volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners rack price of the branded and unbranded rack sales reported under paragraph (3) (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(5)Volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost is means the amount reported as required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(b)Reports required under subdivision (b) of Section 25355 shall also include the volume weighted average cost of any refined gasoline acquired by a refiner during the calendar month, and the volume in barrels of refined gasoline acquired.(c)(1)(A)On and after the effective date of this section, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin shall be ____ cents per gallon.(B)On July 1, 2024, and on July 1 of each year thereafter, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin shall automatically be adjusted annually to reflect the changes in the Consumer Price Index.(2)Beginning ____, the commission may, at a publicly noticed meeting, adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin based on market data as necessary to fulfill the intent and purposes of the section and to ensure that a full and affordable supply of gasoline is available to Californians.(3)Within 15 days of an adjustment to the maximum gross gasoline refining margin pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) or paragraph (2), the commission shall notify refiners of the new maximum gross gasoline refining margin by a means determined by the commission that may include, but is not limited to, mail, email, or internet website postings.(4)Adjustments to the maximum gross gasoline refining margin pursuant to this subdivision shall be effective on the first day of the calendar month at least 15 days after the commission gives public notice of the adjustment, unless the commission orders otherwise.(d)On and after ____, it is a violation of this section for a refiner to exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin.(e)The commission may petition a court to enjoin a refiner from violating subdivision (d).(f)The commission may impose an administrative civil penalty for a violation of subdivision (d). The amount of the penalty shall presumptively be set based on the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, converted from barrels to gallons and multiplied by the number of gallons sold by the refiner during the calendar month through all transactions described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355, as follows:(1)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by less than ____ cents per gallon.(2)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin between ____ and ____ cents, inclusive, per gallon.(3)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by more than ____ cents per gallon.(b)The commission may, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(c)(1)If the commission sets a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall also establish a penalty for exceeding that maximum margin, by regulation or order at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), that may be the same meeting described in subdivision (b).
(2)The penalty shall be a percentage of the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, converted from dollars per barrel to dollars per gallon, multiplied by the number of gallons sold by the refiner during the calendar month for all transactions described in paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(3)Subject to subdivision (j), the penalty shall be tiered, such that the penalty percentage shall increase with the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, as follows:
(A)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by less than ten cents ($0.10) per gallon shall be subject to the base penalty percentage set by the commission.
(B)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin between by more than ten cents ($0.10) and less than or equal to twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the base penalty percentage.
(C)Amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by more than twenty cents ($0.20) per gallon shall be subject to a penalty percentage higher than the penalty percentage set under subparagraph (B).
(d)In establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall consider information reported under subdivision (b) of Section 25355 and any other public data and reports that it determines will assist its analysis. The commission shall also consider confidential information submitted pursuant to Sections 25354 and 25355. A refiner may submit additional information and facts for the commission to consider under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364.
(e)The commission shall not set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin or accompanying penalty under subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, unless it finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. In making that determination, the commission shall consider all factors that in its discretion it deems relevant, including at a minimum all of the following factors, although no one factor shall be determinative:
(1)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(2)Whether it is likely that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
(3)Whether case-by-case exemptions from the gross gasoline refining maximum margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
(f)Decisions of the commission under subdivision (b) to adopt a regulation or order setting a maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (c) to adopt a regulation or order establishing a penalty for exceeding the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, under subdivision (e) regarding the benefits and costs to consumers, and under subdivision (k) regarding adjustments to, or rescission of, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin or penalty, shall be made in accordance with all of the following procedures:
(1)A notice and draft decision, regulation, or order shall be posted publicly at least 30 days before the business meeting at which adoption of the decision, regulation, or order will be considered.
(2)The commission shall receive written comments on the draft decision, regulation, or order.
(3)The commission shall hear public comment on the draft decision, regulation, or order at its business meeting.
(g)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the margin and penalty shall take effect 60 days following the commissions regulation or order establishing the margin and penalty pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively. Within 15 days of the regulation or order establishing a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty, the commission shall notify refiners by a means determined by the commission that may include, but is not limited to, mail, email, or internet website posting.
(h)If the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin under subdivision (b), it shall be a violation of this section for a refiner to exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(i)In addition to any other remedy that may be available, the commission may petition a court to enjoin a refiner from violating this section.
(j)The commission may impose an administrative civil penalty for a violation of this section in the amounts established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(k)The commission may, by regulation or order, at a business meeting, subject to the requirements of subdivision (f), rescind or adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c) to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians. A refiner may submit information and facts for the commission to consider in support of any rescission or adjustment under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364. Rescission of, or adjustments to, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and the penalty percentages and amounts specified in subdivisions (b) and (c), respectively, pursuant to this subdivision shall be effective on the first day of the calendar month at least 15 days after the commission gives public notice of the rescission or adjustment, unless the commission orders otherwise.
(l)Notwithstanding Section 25901 and except as provided in subdivision (n), a petition for writ of mandate pursuant to Section 1085 of the Code of Civil Procedure shall be the exclusive remedy available to challenge any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, or adjudication of an exemption request adopted by the commission under this section. The courts review shall be limited exclusively to the record before the commission. Any petition shall be filed within 30 days of the commissions decision.
(g)(m)(1)The commission shall consider a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and shall grant the exemption upon a showing by the refiner, based on competent and reliable evidence and subject to the commissions review, examination, and investigation of the evidence, that an application of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin would be unconstitutional as applied to the refiner. The commission may, in its discretion, grant a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin upon a showing by the refiner of reasonable cause, and good cause for an exemption, subject to alternative maximum margins or other conditions as the commission may set.
(2)Any refiner seeking an exemption shall shall, at a minimum, file a statement with the commission, signed under penalty of perjury, setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption. A refiner may submit information and facts under an application for confidential designation pursuant to Section 25364 to support its application for an exemption.
(3)The commission shall by regulation develop procedures for considering and adjudicating requests made pursuant to this subdivision.(h)(1)The commission shall identify, on a quarterly basis, the name and address of each refiner that has exceeded the maximum gross gasoline refining margin for any month during the previous quarter, and the amount of administrative civil penalty to be assessed.(2)(n)(1)Before imposing the administrative civil penalty under subdivision (f), (j), the executive director of the commission shall issue and serve a complaint on the refiner, and the commission shall hold a hearing, adopt a decision, and require payment of the penalty in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 25534.1.
(2)Judicial review and enforcement of an order imposing an administrative civil penalty under subdivision (j) may be had in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 25534.2.
(3)All penalties Penalties collected under this section, less refunds and reimbursement to the commission for expenses incurred in the collection of the penalties, section shall be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury and, and shall be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, shall be returned as refunds to residents of the state. to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
(4)The commission shall make public, on a quarterly basis, the name and address of each refiner that has exceeded the maximum gross gasoline refining margin for any month during the previous quarter, and the amount of administrative civil penalty to be assessed.
(4)(o)The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulation, order, decision, rule, guideline, adjudication of an exemption request, or adjustment of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin margin, adopted by the commission under this chapter. section.
(p)The California State Auditor shall begin, no earlier than January 1, 2032, and complete, no later than March 1, 2033, an audit and performance review of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty set pursuant to this section, if the commission has set a maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty. The California State Auditor shall make determinations in a report to the Legislature and the commission, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether this section is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market for California consumers. Within 60 days of the issuance of the report, the commission shall hear from the California State Auditor at a business meeting of the commission. If the California State Auditor concludes that the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty should be terminated, then the commission shall cease implementing the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions no later than 180 days after the issuance of the report, unless the Legislature has enacted subsequent legislation to extend the maximum gross gasoline refining margin and penalty provisions in the meantime.
SEC. 6.Section 25355.7 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.7.(a)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before March 1, 2024, and March 1 of each year thereafter, the commission, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, shall submit a report to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year.
(b)(1)(A)To facilitate the report required in subdivision (a) and to assist the commission in providing independent analysis and oversight of the market for transportation fuels, and in identifying potential market design flaws and market power abuses, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may, notwithstanding any other law, use any information that comes into its possession and may request from any person records required to be maintained pursuant to Section 7053 or 8301 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or any other records in a persons possession, custody, or control that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration deems necessary for these purposes. Records that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may request, include, but are not limited to, sales prices and contracts for unbranded rack sales, branded rack sales, bulk sales, spot pipeline sales, dealer tankwagon sales, imported fuel transactions, and retail sales of gasoline meeting California specifications, including prices per gallon of gasoline charged by retailers by retail location and by grade of gasoline.
(B)Except as provided in paragraph (4), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration pursuant to this section shall constitute confidential information for purposes of Section 7056 of the Revenue and Taxation Code or Section 15570.84 of the Government Code and shall not be subject to public disclosure.
(2)(A)The records requested pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be provided in the form and manner specified by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration within 30 days of the notice of request.
(B)The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall provide written notification to the commission within 10 days after the failure or refusal of any person to provide information or records in the time and manner as specified pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(3)For purposes of the report required by subdivision (a), the commission may impose a civil penalty after receiving notification from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration that a person has failed or refused to provide information or records in the time and manner as required. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362, except that the maximum penalty amount shall be ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per day.
(4)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may provide any information provided to it by any person pursuant to this subdivision to the commission, to the Attorney General, to any contractor retained to prepare reports required by this section, or any entity that the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may contract with for the purpose of preparing the reports required by this section. The Attorney General may request from the commission or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration any information collected pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or this section, or Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25730).
(B)Except as provided in subdivision (c), the information, including, but not limited to, business affairs or trade secrets, provided pursuant to this paragraph shall be confidential and shall not be subject to public disclosure by the commission, the Attorney General, any contractor retained to prepare the reports required by this section, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration or its contractors.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law, the reports required by this section shall only disclose confidential taxpayer information presented in aggregate form to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
SEC. 7.Section 25362 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25362.(a)The commission shall notify those persons who have failed to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355. If, within five days after being notified of the failure to provide the specified information, the person fails to supply the specified information, the person shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than five hundred dollars ($500) thousand dollars ($5,000) nor more than two thousand dollars ($2,000) twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) per day for each day the submission of information is refused or delayed, unless the person has timely filed objections with the commission regarding the information and the commission has not yet held a hearing on the matter, or the commission has held a hearing and the person has properly submitted the issue to a court of competent jurisdiction for review. up to a maximum penalty of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) per submission.
(b)A person who willfully makes any false statement, representation, or certification in any record, report, plan, or other document filed with the commission shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed two thousand dollars ($2,000). forty thousand dollars ($40,000).
(c)The administration of civil penalties under this section shall be subject to the procedures provided in Section 25534.1, and to the procedures for judicial review under Section 25534.2.
(d)In addition to any civil penalty provided for by this section, if a person fails to timely provide the information specified in Section 25354 or 25355, the commission may petition a court for an order compelling the person to provide that information.
(c)(e)For purposes of this section, the term person shall mean, in addition to the definition contained in Section 25116, any responsible corporate officer.
SEC. 8.Section 25364 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:25364.(a)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 or a person making a request for exemption pursuant to Section 25355.5 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(b)Information presented to the commission pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be held in confidence by the commission or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. information or would adversely affect market competition.
(c)(1)Whenever the commission receives a request to publicly disclose unaggregated information, or otherwise proposes to publicly disclose information submitted pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355, 25354, 25355, or 25355.5, notice of the request or proposal shall be provided to the person submitting the information. The notice shall indicate the form in which the information is to be released. Upon receipt of notice, the person submitting the information shall have 10 working days in which to respond to the notice to justify the claim of confidentiality on each specific item of information covered by the notice on the basis that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. information or would adversely affect market competition.
(2)The commission shall consider the respondents submittal in determining whether to publicly disclose the information submitted to it to which a claim of confidentiality is made. The commission shall issue a written decision which sets forth its reasons for making the determination whether each item of information for which a claim of confidentiality is made shall remain confidential or shall be publicly disclosed.
(d)The commission shall not make public disclosure of information submitted to it pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 within 10 working days after the commission has issued its written decision required in this section.
(e)No information submitted to the commission pursuant to Section 25354 or 25355 25354, 25355, or 25355.5 shall be deemed confidential if the person submitting the information or data has made it public.
(f)With respect to petroleum products and blendstocks reported by type pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354 and 25354, information provided pursuant to subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, and information provided under Section 25355, neither the commission, the State Air Resources Board, or the Attorney General, nor any employee or contractor of those entities, may do any of the following:
(1)Use the information furnished under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 for any purpose other than law enforcement or the statistical purposes for which it is supplied.
(2)Make any publication whereby the information furnished by any particular establishment or individual under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355 can be identified.
(3)Permit anyone other than commission members, the State Air Resources Board, the Attorney General, and employees or contractors of those entities to examine the individual reports provided under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 25354, under subdivision (h) or (i) of Section 25354, or under Section 25355.
(g)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the State Air Resources Board or the Attorney General if the state board or the Attorney General agrees to keep the information confidential. With respect to the information it receives, the state board and the Attorney General shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission shall, upon request, timely disclose confidential information received pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25304, or Section 25354 or 25355 to the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, or staff members of each, provided that the information shall be provided only in aggregated or otherwise anonymized form, and each individual person receiving or having access to the information shall first agree, in writing, to keep the information confidential. Any person or committee receiving information under this subdivision shall be subject to all pertinent provisions of this section.
(2)Aggregated or otherwise anonymized information disclosed under paragraph (1) shall be made available by the commission to the public no more than quarterly, upon request of the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, or the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate, under conditions as the commission may determine are necessary to ensure that public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or adversely affect market competition.
(h)(i)Notwithstanding any other law, the commission may disclose confidential information received pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 25354 to the administrator for oil spill response, appointed pursuant to Section 8670.4 of the Government Code, upon request for oil spill planning and preparedness purposes, and to first responders in the event of an accident or spill. Information disclosed to the administrator or first responders pursuant to this subdivision that has been identified as confidential under subdivision (a) shall not be disclosed to any other entity except pursuant to a request in accordance with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code). Upon receipt of a records request seeking information disclosed pursuant to this subdivision, the administrator or first responder receiving the request shall provide the destination facility who provided the confidential information to the commission with an opportunity to submit, within a reasonable time, a response and information in support of exemption from disclosure before making the determination whether the requested records are exempt from disclosure. No requirement or deadline contained in the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) shall be extended or waived as a result of this subdivision.
(i)This section does not apply to aggregate data that are required to be posted on the commissions internet website pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 25355.
SEC. 9.Section 25367 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25367.(a)Except as otherwise provided, the adoption of, or amendment to, regulations or orders implementing this chapter shall be considered by the Office of Administrative Law as an emergency, and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, and general welfare. Notwithstanding any other law, the emergency regulations or orders adopted to implement this chapter shall remain in effect for two years. Although the commission may adopt regulations to further define terms or prescribe reporting procedures or calculation methodologies pursuant to this chapter, or prescribe any other method of implementing this chapter, the provisions of this chapter are self-executing and shall not require any implementing regulation to be effective.
(b)The commission may enter into contracts to implement this chapter, and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
SEC. 10.Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) is added to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, to read:4.6.Petroleum Market1.General Provisions25370.For purposes of this chapter and Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 25350), the following definitions apply:
(a)Planned maintenance means regular, periodic maintenance or repair of one or more pieces of equipment within a petroleum refinery that may require the shutdown of that equipment, or that may reduce production of a petroleum refinery.
(b)Price spike means a rate of increase of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin, as defined in Section 25355, that is greater than the rate of increase of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time, or a rate of decrease of a refinerys gross gasoline refining margin that is less than the rate of decrease of the average price of crude oil received by the refinery, for the same period of time.
(c)Transportation fuels means gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuels.
(d)Turnaround has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 7872 of the Labor Code.
(e)Unplanned maintenance means any maintenance or repair that requires the shutdown of any part of the petroleum refinery that will result in any reduction in production that was not scheduled as turnaround or planned maintenance.
2.Transportation Fuels Assessment25371.(a)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, the commission shall submit an assessment to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, and to the Governor that does all of the following:
(A)Identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. The assessment shall include estimates for the level of transportation fuels at the state level, and, to the extent feasible, at regional and local levels, and individual refineries if relevant, that should be held in reserve by refiners to prevent gasoline price spikes. The assessment shall consider all factors causing price fluctuation in retail gasoline prices when recommending adequate reserve levels. The commission shall consider all relevant evidence from any reasonably available source, including, but not limited to, information about imports, by amount, source, if known, and data received by the commission pursuant to existing laws, economic and business experts, and information from any local, state, and federal agencies. The commission shall transmit to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, any proposals it deems appropriate for mandatory reserve levels and the terms of a program to implement reserve levels.
(B)Evaluates the price of transportation fuels, including branded and unbranded retail prices, alternate formulations of gasoline with lower carbon impact, and other products suitable for production from refineries in California. This evaluation shall consider the market demand for these products at 3-, 7-, 10- and 20-year intervals from the date of the assessment and shall rely on the most recent transportation forecasting and assessment activities conducted pursuant to Section 25304. This evaluation shall include both of the following:
(i)An examination of whether branded fuel additives have any impact, and if so, how much, on fuel efficiency and vehicle emissions.
(ii)An assessment of the presence and availability of retail outlets, including monitoring changes in availability of retail outlets that contribute to increasing retail prices in local and regional areas.
(C)Considers different levels of supply conditions and assesses the impact of potential refinery closures in California.
(D)Includes an analysis of the impacts on production of refinery planned maintenance, unplanned maintenance, and turnaround. The assessment shall evaluate ways to manage necessary maintenance among the various facilities that would protect the health and safety of employees and the public, and minimize the impact of maintenance-related production losses. Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Industrial Relations and Division of Occupational Safety and Health shall disclose to the commission, upon request, any information the department and division have received under Section 7872 of the Labor Code to ensure all aspects of refinery safety are incorporated into the assessment. All information designated confidential shall be treated as confidential by the commission.
(E)Evaluates the utility and feasibility of alternative methods to maintain adequate supplies of transportation fuels, including delivery alternatives for fuel and components of refined fuel, such as delivery by rail, a publicly maintained strategic fuel reserve, and other solutions beyond the activities of refineries and petroleum market participants.
(F)Proposes solutions to mitigate any impacts described in the assessment. The solutions shall include an assessment of the employment impacts and the cost and cost-effectiveness of any proposal, including cost impacts to all impacted sectors, both public and private. The assessment shall include recommendations and alternatives.
(2)The first assessment shall include the evaluation of oil and gas extraction and refining that the State Air Resources Board outlined in the most recent update to the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code.
(b)The assessment shall be separate from the report submitted pursuant to Section 25302 and shall be developed in a public process. The assessment shall be available to the public within the proceeding docket and shall be approved by a vote of the commission at its business meeting.
(c)The commission may enter into contracts to perform the assessment required by subdivision (a) and the contracts shall not require the review, consent, or approval of the Department of General Services or any other state department or agency and do not need to comply with requirements under the State Contracting Manual or the Public Contract Code.
(d)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the assessment required by subdivision (a).
25371.1.(a)The commission shall use reasonable means necessary and available, including, but not limited to, the authority under subdivisions (e) and (f) of Section 11181 of the Government Code, to seek and obtain any facts, figures, and other information from any source for the purpose of preparing the assessment under Section 25371. The commission shall specifically report in the assessment any ongoing or unsuccessful attempts to obtain information from potential sources, including the lack of cooperation or refusal to provide information.
(b)For purposes of the assessment prepared under Section 25371, the commission may impose a civil penalty whenever a person fails to timely provide the information specified in that section and any other information the commission deems necessary to conduct the assessment. A civil penalty under this subdivision shall be imposed under the procedures set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 25362.
(c)Subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 25362 shall apply to a person who willfully submits or makes any false statement to the commission.
(d)The commission shall conduct a public meeting in December of each year to provide an opportunity for the public to provide input on transportation fuel prices.
25371.2.(a)The commission shall aggregate information used in the assessment prepared under Section 25371 to the extent necessary to ensure its confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific information or data would adversely affect market competition.
(b)A person required to present information to the commission pursuant to Section 25371 may request that specific information be held in confidence. Information requested to be held in confidence shall be presumed to be confidential.
(c)For purposes of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, the commission shall comply with the disclosure of information requirements of subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, of Section 25364.
25371.3.On or before December 31, 2024, the commission and the State Air Resources Board, taking into account findings of the assessment conducted under Section 25371, shall prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan. The commission and the State Air Resources Board shall determine the contents of the report, but the report shall include, at a minimum, a discussion of how to ensure that the supply of petroleum and alternative transportation fuels is affordable, reliable, equitable, and adequate to meet the demand for those transportation fuels described in the most current scoping plan approved by the State Air Resources Board under Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code. The report shall be prepared in consultation with the states fuel producers and refiners and a multistakeholder, multiagency workgroup, including the California Environmental Protection Agency and the Natural Resources Agency, convened by the commission and the State Air Resources Board to identify mechanisms to plan for and monitor progress toward the states reliable, safe, equitable, and affordable transition away from petroleum fuels in line with declining instate petroleum demand. The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight shall provide input to and otherwise support other divisions of the commission in preparation of the plan.
3.Division of Petroleum Market Oversight25372.For purposes of this article and Article 4 (commencing with Section 25373), division means the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight.
25372.1.(a)The Division of Petroleum Market Oversight is hereby established in the commission.
(b)Notwithstanding Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 25200), the division shall operate with authority independent of the commissions authority.
(c)The division shall be led by a director, who is appointed by the Governor and is subject to confirmation by the Senate, and holds office at the pleasure of the Governor.
(d)The annual salary of the director shall be provided for by Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 11550) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(e)The director shall employ and prescribe the duties of other staff members as necessary to carry out the provisions of this article. The staff shall include, when feasible, economists, individuals with expertise in the transportation fuels markets, and investigative staff with legal training.
25372.2.(a)The division shall do all of the following:
(1)Provide independent oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels markets for the protection of consumers by identifying market design flaws, market power abuses, and any other manner by which market participants act to harm competition or act contrary to the best interests of consumers in the state.
(2)Provide guidance and recommendations to the commission relating to the development of the assessment required by Section 25371 and the Transportation Fuels Transition Plan described in Section 25371.3.
(3)Provide guidance and recommendations to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration relating to the reports described in Section 25355.7.
(4)Provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor, members of the commission, and other divisions of the commissions on any other issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California.
(5)Report its findings and recommendations to improve market performance at least annually to the Legislature, in accordance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, the Governor, the commission, the Attorney General, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(b)The division may subpoena witnesses, compel their attendance and testimony, administer oaths and affirmations, take evidence and require by subpoena the production of any books, papers, records, or other items material to the performance of the divisions duties or exercise of its powers, including, but not limited to, current and historical pricing and sales data and contracts with other petroleum industry participants.
(c)The division may refer potential violations of law to the Attorney General confidentially at any time.
25372.3.The director of the division shall, when requested, appear before the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly and Senate to provide an update on the divisions performance as compared to its objectives, the status of competition in the transportation fuels markets, and any other information the committees request.
25372.4.(a)Information provided to the division shall presumptively be confidential and not subject to public disclosure. The division shall not divulge or make known in any manner any information provided to it unless it determines both of the following:
(1)Public disclosure of the specific information would not result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information.
(2)Public disclosure of the specific information would not adversely affect market competition.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the division may disclose information deemed confidential under this subdivision to members of the commission, other divisions of the commission, the Attorney General, or the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration if the receiving entity agrees to keep the information confidential, except that the Attorney General may present the information to a court to support an enforcement action but shall submit confidential information under seal where permissible. If the Attorney General requests the assistance of the division in connection with any investigation, the division shall provide information to the Attorney General under this subdivision and any other assistance that is feasible.
(c)For purposes of the divisions annual reports under Section 25372.2, the division shall aggregate data or otherwise anonymize and generalize information as needed to mitigate the risk that public disclosure of the specific information would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information or would adversely affect market competition.
4.Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee25373.(a)The commission and division shall be advised by the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee which is hereby established within the commission. The committee shall consist of the following members:
(1)Six members appointed by the Governor as follows:
(A)A member who holds an academic appointment and has knowledge of economics or business operations of the transportation fuels market.
(B)A member representing the California petroleum fuels industry.
(C)A member representing consumers.
(D)A member representing labor.
(E)A member with expertise in community, environmental, or environmental justice issues.
(F)A member with expertise in antitrust law.
(2)One member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(3)One member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(b)(1)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), no member of the committee shall have been employed by, contracted with, or received direct compensation from, a company that produces, refines, distributes, trades in, markets, or sells any petroleum product in the preceding 12 months.
(2)Except for the member described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of, or subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of, subdivision (a), before accepting appointment, members of the committee shall agree, in writing, not to be employed by, contract with, or receive direct compensation from companies described in paragraph (1) for the 12 months following the completion of their service on the committee.
(c)Each member of the committee shall receive a per diem of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day actually spent in the discharge of official duties, and shall be reimbursed for traveling and other expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of official duties.
(d)The duties, organization, and schedule of meetings of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall be prescribed by the commission. The commission may delegate the authority under this subdivision to the executive director of the commission.
(e)The Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee shall have access to all information submitted to the commission or to the division necessary to fulfill its duties. The members of the committee shall agree, in writing, to maintain the confidentiality of all information received.
(f)The executive director of the commission shall ensure that any confidential information shared with the members of the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement and is maintained in a way that protects it from inadvertent disclosure.
SEC. 11.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which amends Section 25354 of the Public Resources Code, Section 5 of this act, which adds Section 25355.5 to the Public Resources Code, and Section 6 of this act, which adds Section 25355.7 to the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25354, 25355.5, and 25355.7 of the Public Resources Code is necessary to protect sensitive business information and trade secrets from public disclosure.
SEC. 12.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 10 of this act, which adds Chapter 4.6 (commencing with Section 25370) to Division 15 of the Public Resources Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
The restrictions on information prescribed in Sections 25371.2 and 25372.4 are necessary to prevent adverse impacts on market competition in the transportation fuels sector and to protect the public health and safety and the environment, respectively.
SEC. 13.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.SEC. 14.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)From August to October of 2022, Californians experienced some of the highest gasoline prices ever recorded in the state, even though the price of crude oil declined, state taxes and fees remained unchanged, and gasoline prices did not increase outside the western United States.
(b)Much of this increase was caused by refiners, which increased the costs and profits they added to the price California consumers paid at the pump, leading to prices that were substantially higher per gallon than average prices in the rest of the United States.
(c)During the third and fourth quarters of 2022, the overlap in timing of planned maintenance at refiners facilities resulted in a larger decrease in crude oil processing capacity than would otherwise have occurred if planned maintenance at refiners facilities had not coincided.
(d)During this same period of time, refiners allowed gasoline inventory levels to reach decade-low levels, placing an upward pressure on gasoline prices.
(e)This refiner conduct makes clear that greater transparency into and oversight of refinery maintenance schedules and inventory is necessary, to avoid preventable supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.
(f)Historically, refinery outages and issues have created an opportunity for market participants to take advantage of naturally high prices by manipulating prices to stay higher longer, as evidenced by gasoline prices in California remaining elevated without explanation following a temporary price shock after a refinery explosion in 2015, which further demonstrates the need for greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants.
(g)Although preventable capacity limitations and inventory shortages played a role in the third quarter of 2022 price increases, they cannot account for all of those increases. Similar factors did not lead to extreme price spikes in prior years, suggesting that the sky-high prices Californians faced from August to October of 2022 were due in significant part to opportunistic price gouging by oil companies.
(h)Indeed, during the third quarter of 2022, refiners earned record profits, with some refiners earning more than tenfold their profits for the same period of time in 2021.
(i)Fundamental change is necessary to prevent future extreme price spikes and price gouging by oil companies, which are entitled to a reasonable return but are not entitled to reap exorbitant profits at the expense of Californians, many of whom rely on gasoline as an essential commodity or who are impacted by the increased cost of goods and services that results from the gasoline price spikes, even as the state begins to transition away from dependence on the fossil fuels that are destroying our climate.
SEC. 2.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would do all of the following:
(a)Require that the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission (Energy Commission) conduct regular assessments of the supply and price of transportation fuels in the state, and of the impacts on production of refinery maintenance and turnarounds on fuel supply and price.
(b)Expand the Energy Commissions authority to investigate and obtain necessary information, including information regarding pricing, supply contracts, and inventory management, from participants in the market for transportation fuels.
(c)Expand the Energy Commissions authority to order that refinery maintenance and turnarounds be rescheduled in specified circumstances, when consistent with employee and public safety and necessary to avoid supply shocks in the market for transportation fuels.
(d)Establish an advisory committee of fuels market experts to provide the Energy Commission with independent advice and insights.
(e)Require the Energy Commission and the State Air Resources Board, in consultation with the states fuel producers and refiners, to plan for and monitor progress toward the states reliable, safe, equitable, and affordable transition away from petroleum fuels, and to issue periodic reports to the Governor and the Legislature.
(f)Supplement existing refinery reporting requirements by requiring more detailed reports to the Energy Commission on transportation fuel imports, inventory levels, and transactions, and on refinery maintenance and turnarounds.
SEC. 3.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation that would direct the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, in collaboration with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, to investigate and report on the drivers of and factors affecting the price of gasoline in the refining, distribution, and retail segments of the gasoline market; to uncover pricing irregularities in the California gasoline market and their effect on tax revenue; and to report its findings to the Governor and the Legislature.
SEC. 4.Section 25355.5 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25355.5.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs means the amount, expressed in dollars per barrel and calculated on a monthly basis, equal to the volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline sold by the refiner, less the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all of the refiners wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low carbon fuel standard and the cap and trade cap-at-the-rack program, less the refiners volume-weighted average acquisition cost.
(2)Maximum gross gasoline refining margin means the maximum amount of gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs established or adjusted under subdivision (c).
(3)Volume-weighted average acquisition cost is the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost and the refiners volume-weighted cost of acquiring refined gasoline imported to California or acquired from another refiner.
(4)Volume-weighted average rack price of wholesale gasoline means the combined volume-weighted average of the refiners rack price of branded and unbranded rack sales reported under paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(5)Volume-weighted average crude oil acquisition cost is the amount reported as required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355.
(b)Reports required under subdivision (b) of Section 25355 shall also include the volume weighted average cost of any refined gasoline acquired by a refiner during the calendar month, and the volume in barrels of refined gasoline acquired.
(c)(1)(A)On and after the effective date of this section, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin shall be ____ cents per gallon.
(B)On July 1, 2024, and on July 1 of each year thereafter, the maximum gross gasoline refining margin shall automatically be adjusted annually to reflect the changes in the Consumer Price Index.
(2)Beginning ____, the commission may, at a publicly noticed meeting, adjust the maximum gross gasoline refining margin based on market data as necessary to fulfill the intent and purposes of the section and to ensure that a full and affordable supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
(3)Within 15 days of an adjustment to the maximum gross gasoline refining margin pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) or paragraph (2), the commission shall notify refiners of the new maximum gross gasoline refining margin by a means determined by the commission that may include, but is not limited to, mail, email, or internet website postings.
(4)Adjustments to the maximum gross gasoline refining margin pursuant to this subdivision shall be effective on the first day of the calendar month at least 15 days after the commission gives public notice of the adjustment, unless the commission orders otherwise.
(d)On and after ____, it is a violation of this section for a refiner to exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin.
(e)The commission may petition a court to enjoin a refiner from violating subdivision (d).
(f)The commission may impose an administrative civil penalty for a violation of subdivision (d). The amount of the penalty shall presumptively be set based on the amount by which the refiners gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs exceeds the maximum gross gasoline refining margin, converted from barrels to gallons and multiplied by the number of gallons sold by the refiner during the calendar month through all transactions described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 25355, as follows:
(1)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by less than ____ cents per gallon.
(2)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin between ____ and ____ cents, inclusive, per gallon.
(3)____ percent on amounts earned by a refiner that exceed the maximum gross gasoline refining margin by more than ____ cents per gallon.
(g)(1)The commission may, in its discretion, grant a refiners request for an exemption from the maximum gross gasoline refining margin upon a showing by the refiner of reasonable cause, and subject to alternative maximum margins or other conditions as the commission may set.
(2)Any refiner seeking an exemption shall file a statement with the commission, signed under penalty of perjury, setting forth the facts that form the basis for the request for exemption.
(3)The commission shall by regulation develop procedures for considering and adjudicating requests made pursuant to this subdivision.
(h)(1)The commission shall identify, on a quarterly basis, the name and address of each refiner that has exceeded the maximum gross gasoline refining margin for any month during the previous quarter, and the amount of administrative civil penalty to be assessed.
(2)Before imposing the administrative civil penalty under subdivision (f), the executive director of the commission shall issue and serve a complaint on the refiner, and the commission shall hold a hearing, adopt a decision, and require payment of the penalty in accordance with the procedures described in subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 25534.1.
(3)All penalties collected under this section, less refunds and reimbursement to the commission for expenses incurred in the collection of the penalties, shall be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury and, upon appropriation by the Legislature, shall be returned as refunds to residents of the state.
(4)The Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) does not apply to any regulation, guideline, or adjustment of the maximum gross gasoline refining margin adopted by the commission under this chapter.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Mar 28, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 1, Statutes of 2023-24 First Extraordinary Session. |
| Mar 28, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Ordered to the Senate. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | (Ayes 56. Noes 16. Page 54.) |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 58. Noes 19. Page 53.) |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Amendments by Assembly Member Joe Patterson tabled on motion by Assembly Member Reyes. (Ayes 59. Noes 19. Page 53.) |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Read second time. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | (Ayes 60. Noes 18. Page 51.) |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Assembly Rules suspended. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (March 27). |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Referred to Com. on U.& E. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Joint Rule 37.4 suspended. (Ayes 59. Noes 16. Page 44.) |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Article IV Section 8(b) of the Constitution Invoked. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 30. Noes 8. Page 23.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | (Ayes 30. Noes 8. Page 23.) |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Senate Rules suspended |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Joint Rule 37.4 suspended. (Ayes 30. Noes 8. Page 23.) |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 24.) (March 23). |
| Mar 22, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 2. Page 20.) (March 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Set for hearing March 23 in APPR pending receipt. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Set for hearing March 22. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. Referred to Com. on RLS. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 27, 2023 | SB 2 Skinner Senate Third Reading By IRWIN First Extraordinary Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2023 | SB 2 Skinner Senate Third Reading By IRWIN Amend By PATTERSON, JOE Set #1 Lay on the Table By REYES First Extraordinary Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
|
| Mar 23, 2023 | Senate 2nd Reading SB2 Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 23, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 23, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Failed |
|
| Mar 22, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 1000 Grandmothers for Future Generations | ** Support | |
| 350: Bay Area Action, Butte County, Conejo, San Fernando Valley, Humboldt, Sacramento, San Diego, SoCal Climate Action, South Bay Los Angeles, Southland Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Clima | ** Support | |
| Action for the Climate Emergency | ** Support | |
| Action, South Bay Los Angeles, | ** Support | |
| African American Farmers of California | ** Against | |
| Alameda County Democratic Party | ** Support | |
| American Chemistry Council | ** Against | |
| American Federation Of State County And Municipal Employees, Afl-Cio | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific Environmental Network | ** Against | |
| Ballona Wetlands Institute | ** Support | |
| Battle Creek Alliance & Defiance Canyon Raptor | ** Support | |
| Battle Creek Alliance & Defiance Canyon Raptor Rescue | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Planning Coalition | ** Against | |
| Bay Planning Coalition | ** Against | |
| Beach Huddle | ** Support | |
| BeniSolSolar | ** Support | |
| Biofuelwatch | ** Support | |
| Breast Cancer Action | ** Support | |
| Brightline | ** Support | |
| Building Owners and Managers Association | ** Against | |
| Businesses for a Livable Climate | ** Support | |
| California Alliance For Retired Americans | ** Support | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Roundtable | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Climate Voters | ** Support | |
| California Delivery Association | ** Against | |
| California Environmental Justice Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Fuels And Convenience Alliance | ** Against | |
| California Green New Deal Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Against | |
| California Nurses for Environmental Health & Justice | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Electrical Workers | ** Support | |
| California Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| California Working Families Party | ** Support | |
| CALPIRG, California Public Interest Research Group | ** Support | |
| Carson Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| CatholicNetwork US | ** Support | |
| CA Youth Vs Big Oil | ** Support | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Support | |
| Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice | ** Support | |
| Center for Environmentally Recycled Alternatives | ** Support | |
| Center for Race, Poverty, and the Environment | ** Against | |
| Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment | ** Support | |
| Central California Asthma Collaborative | ** Support | |
| Central California Environmental Justice Network | ** Support | |
| Central Valley Business Federation | ** Against | |
| Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Santa Cruz | ** Support | |
| City of Mountain View | ** Support | |
| Clean Power Campaign | ** Support | |
| Climate Action Campaign | ** Support | |
| Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas | ** Support | |
| Climate Hawks Vote | ** Support | |
| Coalition of California Utility Employees | ** Support | |
| Coastal Energy Alliance | ** Against | |
| Comite Civico Del Valle | ** Support | |
| Communities for a Better Environment | ** Against | |
| Consumers For Auto Reliability And Safety | ** Support | |
| Consumer Watchdog | ** Support | |
| Corvallis Interfaith Climate Justice Committee | ** Support | |
| County Of Kern | ** Against | |
| Defend Ballona Wetlands | ** Support | |
| Dorado County, El Dorado Hills, Elk Grove, | ** Against | |
| Drawdown Bay Area | ** Support | |
| Ecology Center | ** Support | |
| Economic Security Project Action | ** Support | |
| El Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Elders Climate Action, NorCal & SoCal Chapters | ** Support | |
| El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Elected Officials to Protect America | ** Support | |
| Elected Officials to Protect America - California | ** Support | |
| Elk Grove Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Employees, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Environmental & Public Health Consulting | ** Support | |
| Environmental Working Group | ** Support | |
| Environment California | ** Support | |
| Equity Transit | ** Support | |
| Feminists In Action Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Folsom Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Folsom, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater | ** Against | |
| Food & Water Watch | ** Support | |
| Fossil Free CA | ** Support | |
| FracTracker Alliance | ** Support | |
| Francisco Bay | ** Support | |
| Friends of Harbors Beaches and Parks | ** Support | |
| Friends Of The Earth | ** Support | |
| Fullerton City Of | ** Support | |
| Gemini Energy Solutions, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Glendale Environmental Coalition | ** Support | |
| Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California, | ** Support | |
| Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Green Building Architects | ** Support | |
| Greenlining | ** Support | |
| Greenpeace Usa | ** Support | |
| Health Justice Commons | ** Support | |
| Indivisible East Bay | ** Support | |
| Inland Empire Economic Partnership | ** Against | |
| International Warehouse Logistics Association | ** Against | |
| Kern Citizens For Energy | ** Against | |
| Kern County Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Let’s Go Farm | ** Support | |
| Let’s Green CA! | ** Support | |
| lincoln area chamber of commerce | ** Against | |
| Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Long Beach Gray Panthers | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator - Manhattan Beach Huddle | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Latino Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Marin Interfaith Climate Action | ** Support | |
| Menlo Spark | ** Support | |
| Milk Producers Council | ** Against | |
| Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Murrieta Wildomar, Rancho Cordova Area, | ** Against | |
| Naiop California | ** Against | |
| NextGen CA | ** Support | |
| Northridge Indivisible | ** Support | |
| Novasutras | ** Support | |
| Ocean Conservation Research | ** Support | |
| Oil and Gas Action Network | ** Support | |
| Oil Change International | ** Support | |
| Orange County Business Council | ** Against | |
| Pacific Environment | ** Support | |
| Pci West-chapter of The Precast/prestressed Concrete Institute | ** Against | |
| PCI West Precast Prestressed Concrete Institute | ** Against | |
| Pelican Media | ** Support | |
| Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay Area Chapter | ** Against | |
| Progressive Democrats of America-California | ** Support | |
| Project Green Home | ** Support | |
| Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Rocklin Area, Roseville Area, Santa Barbara | ** Against | |
| RootsAction.org | ** Support | |
| Roseville Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Climate Coalition | ** Support | |
| Sacramento, San Diego, SoCal Climate | ** Support | |
| San Fernando Valley, Humboldt, | ** Support | |
| Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Barbara Standing Rock Coalition | ** Support | |
| Santa Cruz Climate Action Network | ** Support | |
| Save the Environmental Protection Agency | ** Support | |
| SEIU California | ** Support | |
| Shingle Springs/cameron Park Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Against | |
| Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action | ** Support | |
| Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Small Business Alliance | ** Support | |
| South Coast, Shingle Springs/Cameron Park, | ** Against | |
| Southern California Leadership Council | ** Against | |
| Southland Legislative Alliance, and | ** Support | |
| Southwest California Legislative Council | ** Against | |
| Spottswoode Winery, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Stand.earth | ** Support | |
| State Building And Construction Trades Council Of Ca | ** Against | |
| State of California Attorney General | ** Support | |
| Sunflower Alliance | ** Support | |
| Sunrise SLO | ** Support | |
| Sustainable Ag and Energy Monterey | ** Against | |
| Sustainable Mill Valley | ** Support | |
| System Change Not Climate Change | ** Support | |
| The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County | ** Support | |
| The Climate Center | ** Support | |
| Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Transformative Wealth Management, LLC | ** Support | |
| Tri County Chamber Alliance | ** Against | |
| UFCW Western States Council | ** Support | |
| Undaunted California | ** Support | |
| Union Of Concerned Scientists | ** Against | |
| United Chamber Advocacy Network | ** Against | |
| ventura county climate hub | ** Support | |
| Ventura County Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Voices in Solidarity Against Oil in Neighborhoods | ** Support | |
| Western Independent Refiners Association | ** Against | |
| Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail And Transportation | ** Support | |
| Western States Petroleum Association | ** Against | |
| West Ventura County Business Alliance | ** Against | |
| Women’s March Santa Barbara | ** Support | |
| Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce | ** Against |
(Without Reference to File)
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 2 X1
Author:(Skinner)
As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Mandates extensive data reporting to the California Energy Commission (CEC) from various specified entities along California's oil and gasoline supply chain. Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (max margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state, pursuant to certain findings. Establishes a new division and advisory committee at the CEC, and requires various reports and assessments by the CEC to be submitted to the Legislature regarding the current status and future managed decline of transportation fuels.
Major Provisions
- Expands and significantly updates both the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA) and the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act of 2022, which include reporting requirements to the CEC for all participants in the oil production supply chain, including refiners, marketers, importers, oil transporters, oil storers, oil producers, pipeline and port operators, and destination facilities. These reports are mandated to be generated annually, monthly, weekly, and daily, depending on the market participant and the specific data requested. Specifies reporting from processes in the oil production supply chain that use renewable feedstock and fuels shall be included.
- Increases the civil penalty the CEC can levy against a person that fails to supply the specified data from $500-$2,000 per day to $5,000-$20,000 per day, up to a maximum of $500,000 per submission. Additionally allows the CEC to petition a court for an order compelling the person to provide the information.
- Requires the CEC, upon request, to share confidential information to the Assembly Speaker, Senate Rules Committee, and the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate and their staff members, so long as the information is provided in aggregated or other anonymized form, and each person receiving the information agrees in writing to keep the information confidential. Requires that aggregated or otherwise anonymized information disclosed to the Legislature shall be made available to the public no more than quarterly, if requested by the Legislature.
- Authorizes the CEC to establish a max margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin. The gross gasoline refining margin is defined as the average wholesale rack price of gasoline minus the low carbon fuel standard and cap-at-the-rack program costs minus the refiner's crude oil acquisition costs and refined gasoline import costs; simplistically, it's a measure of the refiner's profit. The max margin would then be the maximum amount a California refiner could earn without incurring the penalty.
- Requires if the CEC sets a max margin, it must set a penalty for any refiner exceeding that max margin. Establishes three tiers of penalty depending on how egregiously the refiner exceeds the max margin.
- Prohibits the CEC from establishing a max margin and penalty, unless the CEC finds that "the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers." Requires the CEC to consider, at a minimum:
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether case-by-case exemptions from the max margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
- Authorizes the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the max margin.
- Requires that collected penalties shall be deposited in the Price Gouging Penalty Fund in the State Treasury to be used, upon legislative appropriation, to "address any consequences of price gouging on Californians."
- Authorizes the CEC to rescind or adjust the max margin and penalty to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Requires the CEC to consider a refiner's request for an exemption from the max margin, as provided. Requires a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Requires the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the max margin and penalty. Requires the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the max margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. Requires the CEC, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the max margin and penalty, if the Auditor concludes that the max margin and penalty should be terminated.
- Requires the CEC, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year. Authorizes CDTFA to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the person's possession, custody, or control that the CDTFA deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the CEC. Mandates CDTFA records requests shall be provided within 30 days of notice; failure to provide records may result in the CEC imposing a civil penalty, up to a maximum of $10,000 per day.
- Authorizes the Attorney General (AG) to request from the CEC or CDTFA, or for the agencies to provide, any information collected pursuant to the oil production supply chain data reporting and CDTFA records collection provided in this bill. Specifies any data shared shall be treated confidentially by the AG.
- Requires the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. Requires the CEC to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the CEC to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. Requires the CEC and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establishes the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight, within the CEC, as an independent authority whose director is appointed by the Governor, confirmed by the Senate, and staffed with economists, experts in the fuels market, and legal investigators. The Division shall provide oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels market, and provide guidance and recommendations to the CEC on the various reports and data gathering it will conduct pursuant to this bill. Empowers the Division with subpoena power, and allows confidential referrals of potential violations of law to the AG at any time. Treats data provided to the Division as presumptively confidential and not subject to public disclosure. The Division shall publish an annual (aggregated and anonymized) report on recommendations to improve market performance, and the director shall appear, when requested, before the appropriate Legislative policy committees.
- Establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. This bill requires the Committee to advise the CEC and the Division. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Establishes revolving door protections for members of the Committee where no member – except the representatives from labor and the petroleum fuels industry – shall have been employed or otherwise received direct compensation from any oil market participant within a year both preceding and following their appointment. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Requires the operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
- Requires refiners to report maintenance activities to the CEC under specified timelines, including turnaround, planned, and unplanned maintenance, and specifies that information shall be treated confidentially.
- Authorizes the CEC to regulate – in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor, and industry stakeholders – the timing of turnaround and maintenance, if such a regulation can protect worker and public health and safety while also minimizing the risk of maintenance-driven supply shortages or price shocks.
- Requires any in-state refineries to report to the CEC at least a year in advance if the refinery intends to permanently shut down, shut down to reconfigure, or sell a refinery.
COMMENTS
For comments on the impacts of this measure on gasoline prices, and potential drafting refinements for future consideration see the Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee analysis from the March 27, 2023, hearing of this bill.
Additionally, for information on California's oil and gasoline market and recent price fluctuations see the background document prepared for the First Extraordinary Session Informational Hearing by the Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee on March 22, 2023.
According to the Author
According to the author, "In 2022, oil companies hauled in more than $200 billion in profits. And while oil companies were raking it in, Californians were paying for it in record high gas prices – $2.61 per gallon higher than the national average. We were charged those sky-high prices even though the cost of crude oil was down and there were no changes to state taxes, fees, or regulations. To push oil companies to treat California consumers fairly, [SB 2 X1] includes the strongest, most effective transparency and oversight measures in the nation so we can look under the hood and hold oil companies accountable for high gas prices. [SB 2 X1] includes a first-of-its-kind independent watchdog that would monitor California's petroleum market to ensure the industry plays by the rules. The division would have access to new information required by law, subpoena power to compel data and records that would reveal shady practices, and direction to refer violations of law to the Attorney General for prosecution. Additionally, the bill includes a price-gouging penalty that would fine oil companies for making excessive profits off the backs of Californians. Ideally, the penalty will never even be used — like with other good policy, its existence may motivate oil companies to keep prices down to avoid being penalized. But if oil companies do engage in price gouging, then [SB 2 X1] will protect Californians from fossil fuel businesses that pad their profits at our expense."
Arguments in Support
Attorney General Rob Bonta expresses strong support for this bill stating: "At great hardship, California consumers have been paying too much at the pump, while oil companies continue to report record profits at their expense. This is unacceptable and unsustainable. I stand with the Governor in supporting financial penalties to deter profiteering, and new measures to increase transparency in the price of gas in the retail market."
A coalition of over 100 environmental, environmental justice, consumer, faith, labor, and clean energy organizations writes to express strong support for [SB 2 X1]stating: "We support a windfall profits cap to rein in refiners' unconscionable price-gouging and provide greater transparency for California's gasoline market. Additionally, given that [SB 2 X1]also notes the legislature's intent to establish a multi-agency process "to plan for and monitor progress towards the state's… transition away from petroleum fuels," we urge you to partner with environmental justice groups to ensure that transition is rapid, equitable, and just."
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of 50 organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, several local chambers, business associations, and the Western States Petroleum Association, strongly opposes SB 2 X1 stating that this bill is "unlikely to provide any price relief for consumers or businesses and in fact, will make matters worse." They further contend that "[SB 2 X1]will result in numerous disruptive unintended consequences," including: potential gasoline supply reduction that means higher costs for consumers and businesses, likely job losses, reduced funding for schools and local governments and likely increase the frequency and duration of volatile price spikes given California's isolated market.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in significant ongoing costs to the CEC, in the millions of dollars annually, to develop rules and review data submissions; to establish and administer the Advisory Committee and the Division; to exercise its new authority to set a maximum margin; and to administer a penalty, if created. The CEC estimates some of these responsibilities to require 34 new positions and contracting, at an annual cost of $9.4 million. (General Fund or special fund).
Additionally, significant ongoing costs to CDTFA to develop a processes to request information from taxpayers involved in gasoline sales, collect and analyze the information, and share the information with other agencies. CDTFA estimates annual costs of $50,000 to $250,000 related to these activities (General Fund). One-time cost to CARB, working with the CEC, to complete the Transportation Fuels Plan. CARB estimates this work will entail contracting costs of $1 million to complete this work (Cost of Implementation Account). Absorbable costs to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to consult with the CEC on its consideration of ways to manage refinery turnarounds and maintenance and, possibly, develop related regulations. One-time cost in 2032-33 of an unknown, but significant amount, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, for the State Auditor to conduct a performance review of the maximum gross refining margin and penalty, only if the CEC sets such a margin and establishes such a penalty (General Fund).
Finally, penalty revenue of an unknown, but potentially significant amount to the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, only if the CEC sets a maximum gross refining margin penalty.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 30-8-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Stern, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: March 20, 2023
CONSULTANT: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0000170
Date of Hearing: March 27, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SBX1 2
Author:(Skinner) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 30-8
SUBJECT: Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin
SUMMARY: Mandates extensive data reporting to the California Energy Commission (CEC) from various specified entities along California’s oil and gasoline supply chain. Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (max margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state, pursuant to certain findings. Establishes a new division and advisory committee at the CEC, and requires various reports and assessments by the CEC to be submitted to the Legislature regarding the current status and future managed decline of transportation fuels. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands and significantly updates both the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA) and the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act of 2022, which include reporting requirements to the CEC for all participants in the oil production supply chain, including refiners, marketers, importers, oil transporters, oil storers, oil producers, pipeline and port operators, and destination facilities. These reports are mandated to be generated annually, monthly, weekly, and daily, depending on the market participant and the specific data requested. Specifies reporting from processes in the oil production supply chain that use renewable feedstock and fuels shall be included.
- Increases the civil penalty the CEC can levy against a person that fails to supply the specified data from $500-$2,000 per day to $5,000-$20,000 per day, up to a maximum of $500,000 per submission. Additionally allows the CEC to petition a court for an order compelling the person to provide the information.
- Requires the CEC, upon request, to share confidential information to the Assembly Speaker, Senate Rules Committee, and the appropriate policy committees in the Assembly or the Senate and their staff members, so long as the information is provided in aggregated or other anonymized form, and each person receiving the information agrees in writing to keep the information confidential. Requires that aggregated or otherwise anonymized information disclosed to the Legislature shall be made available to the public no more than quarterly, if requested by the Legislature.
- Authorizes the CEC to establish a max margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin. The gross gasoline refining margin is defined as the average wholesale rack price of gasoline minus the low carbon fuel standard and cap-at-the-rack program costs minus the refiner’s crude oil acquisition costs and refined gasoline import costs; simplistically, it’s a measure of the refiner’s profit. The max margin would then be the maximum amount a California refiner could earn without incurring the penalty.
- Requires if the CEC sets a max margin, it must set a penalty for any refiner exceeding that max margin. Establishes three tiers of penalty depending on how egregiously the refiner exceeds the max margin.
- Prohibits the CEC from establishing a max margin and penalty, unless the CEC finds that “the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers.” Requires the CEC to consider, at a minimum:
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether case-by-case exemptions from the max margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
- Authorizes the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the max margin.
- Requires that collected penalties shall be deposited in the Price Gouging Penalty Fund in the State Treasury to be used, upon legislative appropriation, to “address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.”
- Authorizes the CEC to rescind or adjust the max margin and penalty to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Requires the CEC to consider a refiner’s request for an exemption from the max margin, as provided. Requires a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Requires the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the max margin and penalty. Requires the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the max margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. Requires the CEC, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the max margin and penalty, if the Auditor concludes that the max margin and penalty should be terminated.
- Requires the CEC, in cooperation with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year. Authorizes CDTFA to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the person’s possession, custody, or control that the CDTFA deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the CEC. Mandates CDTFA records requests shall be provided within 30 days of notice; failure to provide records may result in the CEC imposing a civil penalty, up to a maximum of $10,000 per day.
- Authorizes the Attorney General (AG) to request from the CEC or CDTFA, or for the agencies to provide, any information collected pursuant to the oil production supply chain data reporting and CDTFA records collection provided in this bill. Specifies any data shared shall be treated confidentially by the AG.
- Requires the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. Requires the CEC to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the CEC to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. Requires the CEC and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establishes the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight, within the CEC, as an independent authority whose director is appointed by the Governor, confirmed by the Senate, and staffed with economists, experts in the fuels market, and legal investigators. The Division shall provide oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels market, and provide guidance and recommendations to the CEC on the various reports and data gathering it will conduct pursuant to this bill. Empowers the Division with subpoena power, and allows confidential referrals of potential violations of law to the AG at any time. Treats data provided to the Division as presumptively confidential and not subject to public disclosure. The Division shall publish an annual (aggregated and anonymized) report on recommendations to improve market performance, and the director shall appear, when requested, before the appropriate Legislative policy committees.
- Establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. This bill requires the Committee to advise the CEC and the Division. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Establishes revolving door protections for members of the Committee where no member—except the representatives from labor and the petroleum fuels industry—shall have been employed or otherwise received direct compensation from any oil market participant within a year both preceding and following their appointment. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Requires the operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
- Requires refiners to report maintenance activities to the CEC under specified timelines, including turnaround, planned, and unplanned maintenance, and specifies that information shall be treated confidentially.
- Authorizes the CEC to regulate—in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor, and industry stakeholders—the timing of turnaround and maintenance, if such a regulation can protect worker and public health and safety while also minimizing the risk of maintenance-driven supply shortages or price shocks.
- Requires any in-state refineries to report to the CEC at least a year in advance if the refinery intends to permanently shut down, shut down to reconfigure, or sell a refinery.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, also known as the CEC, consisting of five members appointed by the governor, and specifies the duties of the CEC. Requires the CEC to assess trends in energy consumption and analyze the social, economic, and environmental consequences of these trends. (Public Resources Code § 25200 et. seq.)
- Establishes CDTFA, as of July 1, 2017, within the Government Operations Agency, vested with duties, powers, and responsibilities of the Board of Equalization, except those established by, and specified in, the California Constitution. (Government Code § 15570 et seq.)
- Establishes the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA). (Public Resources Code §§ 25350 et seq.)
- Requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to submit certain information to the CEC, as provided. (Public Resources Code § 25354)
- Requires operators of refineries operating in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications to submit a report within 30 days of the end of each calendar month with certain information, including the max margin of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website. The section is known as the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act of 2022. (Public Resources Code § 25355)
- Subjects a person who fails to provide information to the CEC, after being notified of the failure, to civil penalties in specified amounts. (Public Resources Code § 25362)
- Requires that information presented to the CEC is held in confidence by the CEC or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. (Public Resources Code § 25364)
- Requires every petroleum refinery employer to provide to the Division of Occupational Health and Safety (Cal/OSHA) a full schedule of planned turnarounds for all affected units for the following calendar year, and defines the schedule submitted to be treated as a “trade secret.” Defines “turnaround” to mean a planned, periodic shutdown, total or partial, of a refinery process unit or plant to perform maintenance, overhaul, and repair operations and to inspect, test, and replace process materials and equipment. (Labor Code §§ 7872, 7873)
- Defines “writ of mandate” as a document issued by any court to any inferior body or person, including an administrative agency, to compel the performance of an act which the law specially enjoins. (Code of Civil Procedure § 1085)
- Requires that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (California Constitution Article I, § 3)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, this bill will result in significant ongoing costs to the CEC, in the millions of dollars annually, to develop rules and review data submissions; to establish and administer the Advisory Committee and the Division; to exercise its new authority to set a maximum margin; and to administer a penalty, if created. The CEC estimates some of these responsibilities to require 34 new positions and contracting, at an annual cost of $9.4 million. (General Fund or special fund).
Additionally, significant ongoing costs to CDTFA to develop a processes to request information from taxpayers involved in gasoline sales, collect and analyze the information, and share the information with other agencies. CDTFA estimates annual costs of $50,000 to $250,000 related to these activities (General Fund). One-time cost to CARB, working with the CEC, to complete the Transportation Fuels Plan. CARB estimates this work will entail contracting costs of $1 million to complete this work (Cost of Implementation Account). Absorbable costs to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to consult with the CEC on its consideration of ways to manage refinery turnarounds and maintenance and, possibly, develop related regulations. One-time cost in 2032-33 of an unknown, but significant amount, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, for the State Auditor to conduct a performance review of the maximum gross refining margin and penalty, only if the CEC sets such a margin and establishes such a penalty (General Fund).
Finally, penalty revenue of an unknown, but potentially significant amount to the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, only if the CEC sets a maximum gross refining margin penalty.
BACKGROUND: For information on California’s oil and gasoline market and recent price fluctuations see the background document prepared for the First Extraordinary Session Informational Hearing by this committee on March 22, 2023.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “In 2022, oil companies hauled in more than $200 billion in profits. And while oil companies were raking it in, Californians were paying for it in record high gas prices — $2.61 per gallon higher than the national average. We were charged those sky-high prices even though the cost of crude oil was down and there were no changes to state taxes, fees, or regulations. To push oil companies to treat California consumers fairly, SBX 1-2 includes the strongest, most effective transparency and oversight measures in the nation so we can look under the hood and hold oil companies accountable for high gas prices. SBX 1-2 includes a first-of-its-kind independent watchdog that would monitor California’s petroleum market to ensure the industry plays by the rules. The division would have access to new information required by law, subpoena power to compel data and records that would reveal shady practices, and direction to refer violations of law to the Attorney General for prosecution. Additionally, the bill includes a price-gouging penalty that would fine oil companies for making excessive profits off the backs of Californians. Ideally, the penalty will never even be used — like with other good policy, its existence may motivate oil companies to keep prices down to avoid being penalized. But if oil companies do engage in price gouging, then SBX 1-2 will protect Californians from fossil fuel businesses that pad their profits at our expense.”
- Ensuring Confidentiality in Tracking the Supply Chain. Gasoline begins its journey to consumers as crude oil at petroleum refineries and then moves through stages of refining, transport, storage, and blending until final delivery to retail fueling stations. The inputs into the system could be imported or domestic crude; or, when refinery operations are down, imported finished gasoline. The refined or imported product then travels along various transit—pipeline, barge, ship, rail or truck—before reaching fuel terminals and eventually the end consumer. The oil and gasoline market consists of an assortment of entities, some vertically integrated companies, global shippers, marketers, traders, and retailers that vary in size from small operations to national chains. But what seems to universally characterize the market is its limited transparency.
This bill proposes to provide significantly more data reporting from what seems like the entire ecosystem of the transportation fuels market. Expanding access to data by experts, especially those in the new Division at the CEC, the AG, and other state agencies, should help ensure the state has enough transparency to better address supply and pricing inconsistencies. However, there is some dispute as to the terms of the data that is required to be reported.
Should this bill pass, the Legislature should continue to monitor its implementation to ensure the data requested and the expanded list of reporting entities in this bill are proving beneficial. More importantly, the Administration and Legislature will need to monitor the use of confidential data and whether its use is resulting in harm to consumers. PIIRA confidentiality provisions require limited access to aggregate data by the public in order to protect against competitive disadvantage and market manipulation. With a declining number of refineries (now down to 11 that refine California-specific gasoline)—and as recently demonstrated by the AG’s pending litigation against two market traders who are alleged to have manipulated the spot market to their benefit—there is a great need to proceed with caution in divulging confidential data. While this bill attempts to strike the appropriate balance, the expanded reporting requirements, public disclosure, and expanded access to the data (including with nondisclosure agreements) likely require future scrutiny.
- An Independent Division? This bill establishes a new Division of Petroleum Market Oversight, within the CEC, as an independent authority whose director is appointed by the Governor, confirmed by the Senate, and which is staffed with economists, experts in the fuels market, and legal investigators. This Division is characterized by the proponents of this bill as a new “watchdog” over the oil and gasoline industry. Such a Division has been called for during many state reviews of oil and gasoline price volatility, most recently under the Petroleum Market Advisory Committee, which highlighted the need for more expert analysis (via dedicated staff) of the transportation fuels market. However, it is unclear the meaning—or even the implications of—the Division’s designation as an “independent authority” within the CEC.
Perhaps an analogous administrative office is the Public Advocate’s Office (PAO), established decades ago as a ratepayer advocate within the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).[1] Current statute list PAO as “independent” of the CPUC, but it took decades of statutory changes to establish its independence and separate its operating budget from the CPUC’s. It is unclear what the intention or implications of designating the new Division as “independent” might be, and it remains to be determined how independent they will be, or how independent the Legislature wishes them to be.
Additionally, the new Division is meant to be staffed with competitive market economists and experts in the fuels supply chain. While the Administration has noted its commitment to stand the Division up as quickly as possible, it is likely to take some time for the Division to be staffed given the pace of state hiring. Moreover, it is unclear how successful such a Division might be at recruiting and retaining such a specialized workforce within the constraints of civil service hiring, when the skillsets the employees would have would be very attractive, and likely garner higher wages, in the oil and gasoline industry. The Legislature should be mindful of these challenges as they undertake review of subsequent budget authorizations for this new Division.
- Limitations and Exemptions Aplenty. This bill considers any regulations, or amendments to regulations, adopted to implement all the reporting by oil market participants, CEC and CDTFA data acquisitions, max margin and penalty determinations, and all other provisions of the Chapter as emergency regulations, remaining in effect for 2 years. The bill additionally specifies those provisions are self-executing, and do not require any regulation to be in effect. The bill also exempts all CEC contracts to implement the Chapter from Department of General Services’ review, and State Contracting Manual or Public Contract Code compliance.
It is common for the Legislature to authorize, and for state agencies to adopt, emergency regulations in response to a situation that calls for immediate action to avoid serious harm to public peace, health, safety, or general welfare. Because of this, the emergency rulemaking process is substantially abbreviated compared to the regular rulemaking process. Emergency regulations still require an Office of Administrative Law review, however the overall regulation development and public participation requirements are much reduced. Emergency regulations do not exempt an agency from the regular rulemaking process; rather, regular rulemaking is required to be completed while the emergency regulations are in place.
The Administrative Procedures Act (APA) was created by the Legislature to increase public participation in the rulemaking process, provide public access to agency written rules, and to increase clarity and reduce the complexity of regulations. While there are certainly situations that call for APA exemptions or emergency regulations—including, many would argue, quickly acting to protect Californian consumers from rising gasoline prices—the Legislature should consider whether such regulatory action imposes a significant requirement on the public. This bill, in not only requiring extensive confidential reporting from entities in the oil supply chain but also in developing a max margin and penalty, does establish rules that impact the livelihood and welfare of most Californians. The Legislature should be mindful of the limited public participation inherent in the emergency regulation development, especially in light of the abbreviated timeline for legislative action on this bill, and consider opportunities to provide for additional public engagement on this measure’s impact.
- Definitional Mismatch. The definition of “gross gasoline refining margin” as currently defined in statute equals the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received by the refinery.[2] This bill does not propose changing this definition. Rather, this bill adds a second definition, the “gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs” which equals the difference, expressed in dollars per barrel, between the average price of wholesale gasoline sold by a refiner in the state and the average price of crude oil received and refined gasoline imported by the refinery, less state program costs (low carbon fuel standard and cap-at-the rack costs). The first measure of “gross gasoline refining margin” is reported to the CEC by refineries; while the second is calculated by the CEC on a monthly basis based on data received. It is unclear why imported gasoline costs are part of the equation for the CEC calculation of “gross gasoline refining margin,” but not the value as reported by the refiners. Such a difference feels easily resolvable, but without clean-up could lead to confusion; especially since both gross gasoline refining margins, as reported by the refineries and the one calculated by the CEC, are required pursuant to this bill to be published on the CEC’s website within 45 days of the end of each calendar month. Without adjusting these definitions, the two values may be inaccurately represented as divergent.
- Missing Public Data? This bill amends provisions of the California Oil Refinery Cost Disclosure Act of 2022, which mandates aggregation and public release of some of the refinery data reported to the CEC.[3] However, this bill amends the subdivision of the Disclosure Act that lists the various refinery reporting requirements, without making a similar change to the subdivision that lists which of those reporting requirements should be aggregated and publicized. The consequence of this is to limit public release of information that was just recently required to be public through a measure chaptered last year. It is unclear whether this omission is intentional or inadvertent, but should require additional consideration regarding the merits of limiting public access to these data.
- How to Evaluate Consumer Benefits? This bill authorizes the CEC to establish a “max margin,” which, simplistically, is the maximum amount a California refiner could earn without incurring the penalty. This bill requires if the CEC sets a max margin, it must set a penalty for any refiner exceeding that max margin; and establishes three tiers of penalty depending on how egregiously the refiner exceeds the max margin.
However, the bill does attempt to provide some guardrails against the CEC setting of the max margin and penalty, by prohibiting the CEC from establishing a max margin and penalty unless the CEC finds that “the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers.” Which “benefits” the CEC will weigh in determining this calculation are unclear, as the bill authorizes the CEC to consider “all factors it deems relevant.” But the CEC has three criteria it must consider, at minimum, in such an evaluation:
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in the California transportation fuels market than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether it is likely that the max margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the max margin and penalty.
- Whether case-by-case exemptions from the max margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
For some of these metrics, the barrier to an affirmative conclusion appears low. For instance, the CEC evaluating whether the case-by-case exemptions from the max margin will be sufficient. This is asking the regulatory agency that produced the regulations to likewise determine whether those regulations are sufficient; this seems to almost guarantee a positive finding. It is also unclear how effective the evaluation for “higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis” will be at ensuring real-time or regional prices at the pump aren’t impacted by the max margin and penalty, as this metric would permit very high prices during certain parts of the year (such as the summer) or locations, so long as the prices are low enough in other months or locations to average out. The Legislature may wish to review these factors earlier than called for by the State Auditor evaluation, as the impacts of the penalty on Californians would be largely determined by what the CEC considers.
- What is the Advisory Committee’s Purpose? This bill establishes an Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee within the CEC, consisting of eight members some with specified backgrounds. This bill requires the Committee to advise the CEC and the Division, and provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. However this bill prescribes no duties or functions to the Committee, except to note the CEC will prescribe them…eventually. It is unclear how the CEC hopes to utilize this Committee, which may make appointments to the Committee either challenging or unfocused. This bill reasonably establishes revolving door protections for members of the Committee where no member shall have been employed or otherwise received direct compensation from any oil market participant within a year both preceding and following their appointment. Concerning, the representatives of the oil industry and labor are not subject to these protections. It is fair to be concerned about the reduced likelihood of stakeholder appointments from industry, if those representatives are required to give up their careers for years at a time to serve on the Committee. However, it is worth scrutinizing whether confidential information related to competitors should be disclosed to oil industry experts who happen to be serving on the Committee. Even with air-tight nondisclosure agreements, there is potential for information disclosed to the Committee to influence future business decisions, to the financial benefit of some.
It may be worth the Legislature weighing splitting the Committee into two distinct groups: an academic (and other) expert committee to provide rigorous market analysis and data crunching for the Division, with unrestricted access to data, confidential treatment of all data, and revolving door policies for all its members; and a stakeholder panel that includes all the representatives outlined for the Committee in this bill, without revolving door policies, and with access to more aggregated and anonymized data that can still provide insight and ground-truthing to Division decisionmaking. Such a split in Committee makeup was suggested[4] at the recent informational hearing on the oil and gasoline market held by this committee on March 22, 2023, and bears further Legislative consideration.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO
California State Association of Electrical Workers
CalPIRG, California Public Interest Research Group
Center for Biological Diversity
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
City of Mountain View
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Comite Civico Del Valle
Consumer Watchdog
Elected Officials to Protect America - California
Environment California
Fullerton; City of
State of California Attorney General
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Oppose
African American Farmers of California
American Chemistry Council
Bay Planning Coalition
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Delivery Association
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Taxpayers Association (CALTAX)
Carson Chamber of Commerce
Central Valley Business Federation
Coastal Energy Alliance
County of Kern
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
International Warehouse Logistics Association
Kern Citizens for Energy
Kern County Taxpayers Association
Lincoln Area Chamber of Commerce
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED)
Los Angeles Latino Chamber of Commerce
Milk Producers Council
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP California
Orange County Business Council
PCI West-chapter of The Precast/prestressed Concrete Institute
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association
Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce
Shingle Springs/Cameron Park Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Leadership Council
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Building and Construction Trades Council of Ca
Sustainable Ag and Energy (SAGE) Monterey
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tri County Chamber Alliance
Ventura County Taxpayers Association
West Ventura County Business Alliance
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce
Other
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Center for Race, Poverty, and The Environment
Communities for A Better Environment
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Physicians for Social Responsibility - San Francisco Bay Area Chapter
Sierra Club California
Union of Concerned Scientists
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SBX1 2 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SBX1 2
Author: Skinner (D)
Amended: 3/20/23
Vote: 21
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 13-2, 3/22/23
AYES: Bradford, Ashby, Becker, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Gonzalez, McGuire, Min, Newman, Rubio, Skinner
NOES: Dahle, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove, Stern, Wilk
SUBJECT: Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin
SOURCE: Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California
Attorney General Rob Bonta, State of California
DIGEST:
This bill proposes several policies to address gasoline supply and pricing, including authorizing the California Energy Commission (CEC) to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (maximum margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA). (Public Resources Code §§25350 et seq.)
- Requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to submit certain information to the CEC, as provided. (Public Resources Code §25354)
- Requires operators of refineries operating in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications to submit a report within 30 days of the end of each calendar month with certain information, including the maximum margin of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website. (Public Resources Code §25355)
- Subjects a person who fails to provide information to the CEC after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts. (Public Resources Code §25362)
- Requires that information presented to the CEC is held in confidence by the CEC or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. (Public Resources Code §25364)
- Requires every petroleum refinery employer to provide to the Division of Occupational Health and Safety (Cal/OSHA) a full schedule of planned turnarounds for all affected units for the following calendar year, and defines the schedule submitted to be treated as a “trade secret.” Defines “turnaround” to mean a planned, periodic shutdown, total or partial, of a refinery process unit or plant to perform maintenance, overhaul, and repair operations and to inspect, test, and replace process materials and equipment. (Labor Code §§7872, 7873)
This bill:
- Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs (essentially a refiner’s profit). If the CEC establishes the maximum margin, this bill requires the CEC to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum margin and requires the penalty to be a percentage of the amount the refiner exceeds the maximum margin, to be tiered and increase with the amount the refiner’s gross margin exceeds the maximum gross margin, as specified.
- Prohibits the CEC from establishing a maximum margin and penalty, unless the CEC finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. Authorizes the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum margin. Authorizes the CEC to rescind or adjust the maximum margin and the penalty percentages to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Requires the CEC to consider a refiner’s request for an exemption from the maximum margin, as provided. Requires a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Requires depositing the penalties collected into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, created by this bill in the State Treasury. Requires the moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, address the consequences of price gouging on Californians.
- Requires the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum margin and penalty. Requires the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. Requires the CEC, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum margin and penalty, if the Auditor concludes that the maximum margin and penalty should be terminated.
- Requires the CEC, in cooperation with the CDTFA, to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year.
- Requires the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California.
- Requires the CEC and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establishes the Division within the CEC, and requires the Division to be led by a director appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation, and specifies that the Division operates with authority independent of the CEC’s authority. Authorizes the Division to subpoena witnesses and require by subpoena any books, papers, records, or other items.
- Establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Revises, recasts, and expands the existing reporting requirements to the CEC.
- Authorizes the CEC to impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor and industry stakeholders.
- Increases the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
Background
Gasoline prices trend higher in California compared to the rest of the nation.
Californians, generally, pay higher prices for gasoline compared to the rest of the country. According to the CEC, there are five main reasons why California retail gasoline prices are higher than the average price in the United States, specifically: higher taxes on gasoline, higher gasoline production costs, environmental program costs, California’s shorter winter season, and the isolated nature of the California fuels market. California’s unique, cleaner-burning gasoline blend costs more to produce than other types of gasoline, accounting for an additional 10 to 15 cents per gallon (according to the CEC). The summer-blend gasoline is designed to evaporate at a higher temperature than winter-blend gasoline so as to minimize its contribution to unhealthy ground-level ozone (also known as smog). However, the summer-blend gasoline is more expensive to produce and tends to be used for longer stretches of the year, given California’s warm climate.
California gasoline fuels market is isolated. California’s gasoline fuels market is geographically isolated from other locations in the U.S. that produce refined fuel products. California has 11 refineries that refine crude oil into gasoline fuel; the majority are located in and around the South Bay region in the Los Angeles Basin, some in the East Bay region of the Bay Area, and the smallest by volume produced is located in Bakersfield. The state’s refineries process over 1.6 billion barrels of crude oil per day. In 2021, 88 percent of gasoline production was used in state and 12 percent was exported. These refiners produce transportation fuels that meet California standards, including the specially formulated gasoline to meet California’s air quality standards mandated by the CARB, known as California Reformulated Gasoline Blendstock for Oxygenated Blending (CARBOB) gasoline. In addition to providing in-state supply, California refiners provide the majority of transportation fuels to neighboring states and to other countries. However, the gasoline sent to neighboring states and countries is not the CARBOB gasoline, and is, generally, less expensive to produce. [See Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee analysis for more information]
Governor Newsom officially calls an Extraordinary Session of the Legislature. The Governor formally issued a proclamation on December 5, 2022, the first day of the 2023-24 Legislative Session, when Senators and Assembly members were sworn into office. On that same day, SBX1-2 (Skinner) was introduced containing the concept and general framework for the Governor’s Petroleum Windfall Profits Penalty proposal, but with an acknowledgement that this bill would need to be further developed, given the blanks on the proposed profit margins and the construct of this bill noting the intent for future legislation to operationalize aspects of the proposal.
Need for the profit cap. Supporters of this bill argue that oil companies are gouging consumers and raking in excessive profits. They contend that a windfall profits cap on refining gasoline will save consumers billions of dollars in overcharges. The Governor’s Office argues that the maximum margin and penalty are needed as a deterrent to prevent oil companies from creating price spikes, which hurt consumers. They also note the CEC will only establish a margin, if and when, the agency determines the benefits outweigh the costs to consumers. The opponents of this bill express concerns that there are many factors that contribute to gasoline price volatility. They express concerns that the sponsors of this bill will attribute any price increases to excess profit, and not consider the many other factors of the market – especially supply and demand and cyclical fluctuations in profits. This bill provides the CEC with flexibility to establish, rescind, and adjust a maximum margin, as needed. The flexibility afforded to the CEC may be both reassuring and concerning for both supporters and opponents. However, given the unknowns about instituting a maximum margin and penalty policy, such flexibility may be warranted to ensure the CEC is able to respond to changing market conditions and to new information as it becomes available – of which there will be an abundance given the extensive and expanded reporting requirements in this bill! Additionally, the Auditor will be required to audit the performance of the maximum margin and penalty by March 2033 and issue a report by June 2033. Should the Auditor find the margin and penalty are not meeting their intended goals, the CEC will be required to cease implementation within 180 days of the date of issuance of the Auditor’s Report.
Need to proceed with caution. Unlike other consumer goods, gasoline is ubiquitous in our lives and largely needed by most everyone, every day. Consumers are not able to postpone gasoline purchases in the same way they can wait out higher prices of other goods. Additionally, California’s air quality and climate change-related policies are transitioning the state away from fossil fuel uses, most notably Governor Newsom’s Executive Order (N-79-20) to require 100 percent of in-state sales of new passenger cars and trucks to be zero-emission by 2035, thereby prohibiting the sale of new gasoline-fueled vehicles by 2035. This combination of factors, along with the isolated nature of the California transportation fuels market, creates a challenge for the state to ensure consumers are protected with adequate gasoline supply at affordable prices, all while advancing California’s climate policies that shift demand away from petroleum fuels. The balancing act of providing adequate supply with uncertain demand is no small feat. Yet, the implications to Californians can be significant to their health, well-being, and quality of life, if policies do not achieve the intended relief. In this regard, the elements of this bill that require fuel assessments every three years and a fuel transition study will likely be very beneficial to inform changes in future policies and efforts to address supply and affordability for transportation fuels. This includes more information about retail aspects of the market and its effects on price and supply.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) required the CEC to collect specified pricing data from each oil refinery operating in the state.
SB 448 (Leno, 2013) would have required the CEC to collect and analyze specific information regarding petroleum pricing, establish the Motor Vehicle Fuel Market Advisory Committee to provide subject matter expertise on fuel pricing, and include specified recommendations regarding its findings, including an analysis of potential market manipulation in the Integrated Energy Policy Report. The bill was vetoed.
SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statutes of 1980) established the PIIRA which requires specified monthly and annual reporting requirements for certain members of the petroleum industry and quarterly and annual reporting of the CEC. The bill includes confidentiality protections for the data submitted so as to prevent unfair competitive disadvantage.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The CEC estimates ongoing costs of approximately $4.4 million annually (General Fund or special fund), including contracting costs, and 14 PY of staff to fulfill the requirements of this bill. In addition, the CEC anticipates annual costs of $2.5 million (General Fund or special fund) and 10 PY of staff to establish and support the new independent Division of Petroleum Market Oversight within the CEC.
- The California Air Resources Control Board (CARB) estimates one-time contracting costs of approximately $1 million (Cost of Implementation Account) to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan by December 31, 2024.
- The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates ongoing costs of $50,000 - $250,000 annually (General Fund) to develop processes to request the necessary information from taxpayers involved in gasoline sales, collect and analyze data, share information with other agencies, and prepare the annual reports required by this bill.
- Should the CEC exercise authority that would be established by this bill to set a margin and accompanying penalty, there would be several fiscal effects:
- Unknown, potentially significant one-time costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC to make a finding that the likely benefits of establishing a margin and penalty would outweigh potential costs for consumers and promulgate regulations establishing the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC administer, oversee, and enforce the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs for the Attorney General to bring enforcement actions against any refiners in violation.
- The California State Auditor estimates one-time costs of up to $800,000 in 2032-33 (General Fund) to conduct an audit and performance review of the margin and penalty, make determinations regarding the effectiveness of the margin and penalty in meeting specified goals, provide a report on its determinations to the Legislature and CEC, and subsequently participate in a CEC business meeting.
- To the extent that refiners exceed the maximum margin established by the CEC, there would be potential ongoing revenue increases of an unknown amount from the collection of penalties imposed on refiners for exceeding the margin. The bill would require penalty revenues be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund and used to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
SUPPORT: (Verified 3/22/23)
Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California (co-source)
Attorney General Rob Bonta, State of California (co-source)
1000 Grandmothers for Future Generations
350: Bay Area Action, Butte County, Conejo, San Fernando Valley, Humboldt, Sacramento, San Diego, SoCal Climate Action, South Bay Los Angeles, Southland Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub
Action for the Climate Emergency
Alameda County Democratic Party
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Ballona Wetlands Institute
Battle Creek Alliance & Defiance Canyon Raptor Rescue
BeniSolSolar
Biofuelwatch
Breast Cancer Action
Brightline
Businesses for a Livable Climate
CA Youth Vs Big Oil
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Climate Voters
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Environmental Voters
California Green New Deal Coalition
California Nurses for Environmental Health & Justice
California Public Interest Research Group
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California Working Families Party
CatholicNetwork US
Center for Biological Diversity
Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice
Center for Environmentally Recycled Alternatives
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Central California Asthma Collaborative
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Sacramento
Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Santa Cruz
City of Fullerton
City of Mountain View
Clean Power Campaign
Climate Action Campaign
Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas
Climate Hawks Vote
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Comite Civico del Valle, Inc.
Consumer Watchdog
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Corvallis Interfaith Climate Justice Committee
Defend Ballona Wetlands
Drawdown Bay Area
Ecology Center
Economic Security Project Action
Elders Climate Action, NorCal & SoCal Chapters
Elected Officials to Protect America
Environment California
Environmental & Public Health Consulting
Environmental Working Group
Equity Transit
Feminists in Action Los Angeles
Food & Water Watch
Fossil Free CA
FracTracker Alliance
Friends of Harbors Beaches and Parks
Friends of the Earth
Gemini Energy Solutions, Inc.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Green Building Architects
Greenlining
Greenpeace USA
Health Justice Commons
Indivisible East Bay
Let’s Go Farm
Let’s Green CA!
Long Beach Gray Panthers
Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator - Manhattan Beach Huddle
Marin Interfaith Climate Action
Menlo Spark
NextGen CA
Northridge Indivisible
Novasutras
Ocean Conservation Research
Oil and Gas Action Network
Oil Change International
Pacific Environment
Pelican Media
Physicians for Social Responsibility-Sacramento
Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay
Progressive Democrats of America-California
Project Green Home
RootsAction.org
Sacramento Climate Coalition
Santa Barbara Standing Rock Coalition
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
Save the Environmental Protection Agency
SEIU California
Sierra Club California
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Small Business Alliance
Spottswoode Winery, Inc.
Stand.earth
Sunflower Alliance
Sunrise SLO
Sustainable Mill Valley
System Change Not Climate Change
The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County
The Climate Center
Transformative Wealth Management, LLC
UFCW Western States Council
Undaunted California
Voices in Solidarity Against Oil in Neighborhoods
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Women’s March Santa Barbara
74 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 3/22/23)
African American Farmers of California
American Chemistry Council
Bay Area Planning Coalition
Building Owners & Managers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Delivery Association
California Fuels & Convenience Alliance
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Taxpayers Association
Central Valley Business Federation
Chamber of Commerce: California, Carson, El Dorado County, El Dorado Hills, Elk Grove, Folsom, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater Conejo Valley, Lincoln Area, Long Beach Area, Los Angeles Area, Los Angeles Latino, Murrieta Wildomar, Rancho Cordova Area, Rocklin Area, Roseville Area, Santa Barbara South Coast, Shingle Springs/Cameron Park, Simi Valley, Torrance Area, and Yuba Sutter
Coastal Energy Alliance
Federation & Kern Citizens for Energy
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
International Warehouse Logistics Association
Kern County Board of Supervisors
Kern County Taxpayers Association
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Milk Producers Council
National Association of Industrial & Office Properties
Orange County Business Council
PCI West Precast Prestressed Concrete Institute
Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association
Southern California Leadership Council
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Sustainable Ag & Energy Monterey County
Tri County Chamber Alliance
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Ventura County Taxpayers Association
West Ventura County Business Alliance
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Attorney General Rob Bonta expresses strong support for the bill stating:
At great hardship, California consumers have been paying too much at the pump, while oil companies continue to report record profits at their expense. This is unacceptable and unsustainable. I stand with the Governor in supporting financial penalties to deter profiteering, and new measures to increase transparency in the price of gas in the retail market.
A coalition of over 100 environmental, environmental justice, consumer, faith, labor, and clean energy organizations writes to express strong support for SBX1-2 stating:
We support a windfall profits cap to rein in refiners’ unconscionable price-gouging and provide greater transparency for California’s gasoline market. Additionally, given that SBX1 2 also notes the legislature’s intent to establish a multi-agency process “to plan for and monitor progress towards the state’s… transition away from petroleum fuels,” we urge you to partner with environmental justice groups to ensure that transition is rapid, equitable, and just.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of 50 organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, several local chambers, business associations, and the Western States Petroleum Association, strongly opposes SBX1-2 stating that the bill is “unlikely to provide any price relief for consumers or businesses and in fact, will make matters worse.” They further contend that “SBX1-2 will result in numerous disruptive unintended consequences,” including: potential gasoline supply reduction that means higher costs for consumers and businesses, likely job losses, reduced funding for schools and local governments and likely increase the frequency and duration of volatile price spikes given California’s isolated market.
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U. & C. /
3/23/23 7:57:24
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SBX1 2 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SBX1 2
Author: Skinner (D)
Amended: 3/20/23
Vote: 21
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 13-2, 3/22/23
AYES: Bradford, Ashby, Becker, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Gonzalez, McGuire, Min, Newman, Rubio, Skinner
NOES: Dahle, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove, Stern, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/23/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin
SOURCE: Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California
Attorney General Rob Bonta, State of California
DIGEST:
This bill proposes several policies to address gasoline supply and pricing, including authorizing the California Energy Commission (CEC) to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (maximum margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA). (Public Resources Code §§25350 et seq.)
- Requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to submit certain information to the CEC, as provided. (Public Resources Code §25354)
- Requires operators of refineries operating in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications to submit a report within 30 days of the end of each calendar month with certain information, including the maximum margin of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website. (Public Resources Code §25355)
- Subjects a person who fails to provide information to the CEC after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts. (Public Resources Code §25362)
- Requires that information presented to the CEC is held in confidence by the CEC or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. (Public Resources Code §25364)
- Requires every petroleum refinery employer to provide to the Division of Occupational Health and Safety (Cal/OSHA) a full schedule of planned turnarounds for all affected units for the following calendar year, and defines the schedule submitted to be treated as a “trade secret.” Defines “turnaround” to mean a planned, periodic shutdown, total or partial, of a refinery process unit or plant to perform maintenance, overhaul, and repair operations and to inspect, test, and replace process materials and equipment. (Labor Code §§7872, 7873)
This bill:
- Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs (essentially a refiner’s profit). If the CEC establishes the maximum margin, this bill requires the CEC to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum margin and requires the penalty to be a percentage of the amount the refiner exceeds the maximum margin, to be tiered and increase with the amount the refiner’s gross margin exceeds the maximum gross margin, as specified.
- Prohibits the CEC from establishing a maximum margin and penalty, unless the CEC finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. Authorizes the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum margin. Authorizes the CEC to rescind or adjust the maximum margin and the penalty percentages to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Requires the CEC to consider a refiner’s request for an exemption from the maximum margin, as provided. Requires a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Requires depositing the penalties collected into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, created by this bill in the State Treasury. Requires the moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, address the consequences of price gouging on Californians.
- Requires the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum margin and penalty. Requires the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. Requires the CEC, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum margin and penalty, if the Auditor concludes that the maximum margin and penalty should be terminated.
- Requires the CEC, in cooperation with the CDTFA, to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year.
- Requires the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California.
- Requires the CEC and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establishes the Division within the CEC, and requires the Division to be led by a director appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation, and specifies that the Division operates with authority independent of the CEC’s authority. Authorizes the Division to subpoena witnesses and require by subpoena any books, papers, records, or other items.
- Establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Revises, recasts, and expands the existing reporting requirements to the CEC.
- Authorizes the CEC to impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor and industry stakeholders.
- Increases the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
Background
Gasoline prices trend higher in California compared to the rest of the nation.
Californians, generally, pay higher prices for gasoline compared to the rest of the country. According to the CEC, there are five main reasons why California retail gasoline prices are higher than the average price in the United States, specifically: higher taxes on gasoline, higher gasoline production costs, environmental program costs, California’s shorter winter season, and the isolated nature of the California fuels market. California’s unique, cleaner-burning gasoline blend costs more to produce than other types of gasoline, accounting for an additional 10 to 15 cents per gallon (according to the CEC). The summer-blend gasoline is designed to evaporate at a higher temperature than winter-blend gasoline so as to minimize its contribution to unhealthy ground-level ozone (also known as smog). However, the summer-blend gasoline is more expensive to produce and tends to be used for longer stretches of the year, given California’s warm climate.
California gasoline fuels market is isolated. California’s gasoline fuels market is geographically isolated from other locations in the U.S. that produce refined fuel products. California has 11 refineries that refine crude oil into gasoline fuel; the majority are located in and around the South Bay region in the Los Angeles Basin, some in the East Bay region of the Bay Area, and the smallest by volume produced is located in Bakersfield. The state’s refineries process over 1.6 billion barrels of crude oil per day. In 2021, 88 percent of gasoline production was used in state and 12 percent was exported. These refiners produce transportation fuels that meet California standards, including the specially formulated gasoline to meet California’s air quality standards mandated by the CARB, known as California Reformulated Gasoline Blendstock for Oxygenated Blending (CARBOB) gasoline. In addition to providing in-state supply, California refiners provide the majority of transportation fuels to neighboring states and to other countries. However, the gasoline sent to neighboring states and countries is not the CARBOB gasoline, and is, generally, less expensive to produce. [See Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee analysis for more information]
Governor Newsom officially calls an Extraordinary Session of the Legislature. The Governor formally issued a proclamation on December 5, 2022, the first day of the 2023-24 Legislative Session, when Senators and Assembly members were sworn into office. On that same day, SBX1-2 (Skinner) was introduced containing the concept and general framework for the Governor’s Petroleum Windfall Profits Penalty proposal, but with an acknowledgement that this bill would need to be further developed, given the blanks on the proposed profit margins and the construct of this bill noting the intent for future legislation to operationalize aspects of the proposal.
Need for the profit cap. Supporters of this bill argue that oil companies are gouging consumers and raking in excessive profits. They contend that a windfall profits cap on refining gasoline will save consumers billions of dollars in overcharges. The Governor’s Office argues that the maximum margin and penalty are needed as a deterrent to prevent oil companies from creating price spikes, which hurt consumers. They also note the CEC will only establish a margin, if and when, the agency determines the benefits outweigh the costs to consumers. The opponents of this bill express concerns that there are many factors that contribute to gasoline price volatility. They express concerns that the sponsors of this bill will attribute any price increases to excess profit, and not consider the many other factors of the market – especially supply and demand and cyclical fluctuations in profits. This bill provides the CEC with flexibility to establish, rescind, and adjust a maximum margin, as needed. The flexibility afforded to the CEC may be both reassuring and concerning for both supporters and opponents. However, given the unknowns about instituting a maximum margin and penalty policy, such flexibility may be warranted to ensure the CEC is able to respond to changing market conditions and to new information as it becomes available – of which there will be an abundance given the extensive and expanded reporting requirements in this bill! Additionally, the Auditor will be required to audit the performance of the maximum margin and penalty by March 2033 and issue a report by June 2033. Should the Auditor find the margin and penalty are not meeting their intended goals, the CEC will be required to cease implementation within 180 days of the date of issuance of the Auditor’s Report.
Need to proceed with caution. Unlike other consumer goods, gasoline is ubiquitous in our lives and largely needed by most everyone, every day. Consumers are not able to postpone gasoline purchases in the same way they can wait out higher prices of other goods. Additionally, California’s air quality and climate change-related policies are transitioning the state away from fossil fuel uses, most notably Governor Newsom’s Executive Order (N-79-20) to require 100 percent of in-state sales of new passenger cars and trucks to be zero-emission by 2035, thereby prohibiting the sale of new gasoline-fueled vehicles by 2035. This combination of factors, along with the isolated nature of the California transportation fuels market, creates a challenge for the state to ensure consumers are protected with adequate gasoline supply at affordable prices, all while advancing California’s climate policies that shift demand away from petroleum fuels. The balancing act of providing adequate supply with uncertain demand is no small feat. Yet, the implications to Californians can be significant to their health, well-being, and quality of life, if policies do not achieve the intended relief. In this regard, the elements of this bill that require fuel assessments every three years and a fuel transition study will likely be very beneficial to inform changes in future policies and efforts to address supply and affordability for transportation fuels. This includes more information about retail aspects of the market and its effects on price and supply.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) required the CEC to collect specified pricing data from each oil refinery operating in the state.
SB 448 (Leno, 2013) would have required the CEC to collect and analyze specific information regarding petroleum pricing, establish the Motor Vehicle Fuel Market Advisory Committee to provide subject matter expertise on fuel pricing, and include specified recommendations regarding its findings, including an analysis of potential market manipulation in the Integrated Energy Policy Report. The bill was vetoed.
SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statutes of 1980) established the PIIRA which requires specified monthly and annual reporting requirements for certain members of the petroleum industry and quarterly and annual reporting of the CEC. The bill includes confidentiality protections for the data submitted so as to prevent unfair competitive disadvantage.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The CEC estimates ongoing costs of approximately $4.4 million annually (General Fund or special fund), including contracting costs, and 14 PY of staff to fulfill the requirements of this bill. In addition, the CEC anticipates annual costs of $2.5 million (General Fund or special fund) and 10 PY of staff to establish and support the new independent Division of Petroleum Market Oversight within the CEC.
- The California Air Resources Control Board (CARB) estimates one-time contracting costs of approximately $1 million (Cost of Implementation Account) to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan by December 31, 2024.
- The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates ongoing costs of $50,000 - $250,000 annually (General Fund) to develop processes to request the necessary information from taxpayers involved in gasoline sales, collect and analyze data, share information with other agencies, and prepare the annual reports required by this bill.
- Should the CEC exercise authority that would be established by this bill to set a margin and accompanying penalty, there would be several fiscal effects:
- Unknown, potentially significant one-time costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC to make a finding that the likely benefits of establishing a margin and penalty would outweigh potential costs for consumers and promulgate regulations establishing the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC administer, oversee, and enforce the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs for the Attorney General to bring enforcement actions against any refiners in violation.
- The California State Auditor estimates one-time costs of up to $800,000 in 2032-33 (General Fund) to conduct an audit and performance review of the margin and penalty, make determinations regarding the effectiveness of the margin and penalty in meeting specified goals, provide a report on its determinations to the Legislature and CEC, and subsequently participate in a CEC business meeting.
- To the extent that refiners exceed the maximum margin established by the CEC, there would be potential ongoing revenue increases of an unknown amount from the collection of penalties imposed on refiners for exceeding the margin. The bill would require penalty revenues be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund and used to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
SUPPORT: (Verified 3/22/23)
Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California (co-source)
Attorney General Rob Bonta, State of California (co-source)
1000 Grandmothers for Future Generations
350: Bay Area Action, Butte County, Conejo, San Fernando Valley, Humboldt, Sacramento, San Diego, SoCal Climate Action, South Bay Los Angeles, Southland Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub
Action for the Climate Emergency
Alameda County Democratic Party
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Ballona Wetlands Institute
Battle Creek Alliance & Defiance Canyon Raptor Rescue
BeniSolSolar
Biofuelwatch
Breast Cancer Action
Brightline
Businesses for a Livable Climate
CA Youth Vs Big Oil
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Climate Voters
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Environmental Voters
California Green New Deal Coalition
California Nurses for Environmental Health & Justice
California Public Interest Research Group
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California Working Families Party
CatholicNetwork US
Center for Biological Diversity
Center for Community Action & Environmental Justice
Center for Environmentally Recycled Alternatives
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Central California Asthma Collaborative
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Sacramento
Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Santa Cruz
City of Fullerton
City of Mountain View
Clean Power Campaign
Climate Action Campaign
Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas
Climate Hawks Vote
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Comite Civico del Valle, Inc.
Consumer Watchdog
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Corvallis Interfaith Climate Justice Committee
Defend Ballona Wetlands
Drawdown Bay Area
Ecology Center
Economic Security Project Action
Elders Climate Action, NorCal & SoCal Chapters
Elected Officials to Protect America
Environment California
Environmental & Public Health Consulting
Environmental Working Group
Equity Transit
Feminists in Action Los Angeles
Food & Water Watch
Fossil Free CA
FracTracker Alliance
Friends of Harbors Beaches and Parks
Friends of the Earth
Gemini Energy Solutions, Inc.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Green Building Architects
Greenlining
Greenpeace USA
Health Justice Commons
Indivisible East Bay
Let’s Go Farm
Let’s Green CA!
Long Beach Gray Panthers
Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator - Manhattan Beach Huddle
Marin Interfaith Climate Action
Menlo Spark
NextGen CA
Northridge Indivisible
Novasutras
Ocean Conservation Research
Oil and Gas Action Network
Oil Change International
Pacific Environment
Pelican Media
Physicians for Social Responsibility-Sacramento
Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay
Progressive Democrats of America-California
Project Green Home
RootsAction.org
Sacramento Climate Coalition
Santa Barbara Standing Rock Coalition
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
Save the Environmental Protection Agency
SEIU California
Sierra Club California
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Small Business Alliance
Spottswoode Winery, Inc.
Stand.earth
Sunflower Alliance
Sunrise SLO
Sustainable Mill Valley
System Change Not Climate Change
The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County
The Climate Center
Transformative Wealth Management, LLC
UFCW Western States Council
Undaunted California
Voices in Solidarity Against Oil in Neighborhoods
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Women’s March Santa Barbara
74 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 3/22/23)
African American Farmers of California
American Chemistry Council
Bay Area Planning Coalition
Building Owners & Managers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Delivery Association
California Fuels & Convenience Alliance
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Taxpayers Association
Central Valley Business Federation
Chamber of Commerce: California, Carson, El Dorado County, El Dorado Hills, Elk Grove, Folsom, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater Conejo Valley, Lincoln Area, Long Beach Area, Los Angeles Area, Los Angeles Latino, Murrieta Wildomar, Rancho Cordova Area, Rocklin Area, Roseville Area, Santa Barbara South Coast, Shingle Springs/Cameron Park, Simi Valley, Torrance Area, and Yuba Sutter
Coastal Energy Alliance
Federation & Kern Citizens for Energy
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
International Warehouse Logistics Association
Kern County Board of Supervisors
Kern County Taxpayers Association
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Milk Producers Council
National Association of Industrial & Office Properties
Orange County Business Council
PCI West Precast Prestressed Concrete Institute
Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association
Southern California Leadership Council
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Sustainable Ag & Energy Monterey County
Tri County Chamber Alliance
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Ventura County Taxpayers Association
West Ventura County Business Alliance
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Attorney General Rob Bonta expresses strong support for the bill stating:
At great hardship, California consumers have been paying too much at the pump, while oil companies continue to report record profits at their expense. This is unacceptable and unsustainable. I stand with the Governor in supporting financial penalties to deter profiteering, and new measures to increase transparency in the price of gas in the retail market.
A coalition of over 100 environmental, environmental justice, consumer, faith, labor, and clean energy organizations writes to express strong support for SBX1-2 stating:
We support a windfall profits cap to rein in refiners’ unconscionable price-gouging and provide greater transparency for California’s gasoline market. Additionally, given that SBX1 2 also notes the legislature’s intent to establish a multi-agency process “to plan for and monitor progress towards the state’s… transition away from petroleum fuels,” we urge you to partner with environmental justice groups to ensure that transition is rapid, equitable, and just.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of 50 organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, several local chambers, business associations, and the Western States Petroleum Association, strongly opposes SBX1-2 stating that the bill is “unlikely to provide any price relief for consumers or businesses and in fact, will make matters worse.” They further contend that “SBX1-2 will result in numerous disruptive unintended consequences,” including: potential gasoline supply reduction that means higher costs for consumers and businesses, likely job losses, reduced funding for schools and local governments and likely increase the frequency and duration of volatile price spikes given California’s isolated market.
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U. & C. /
3/23/23 9:12:31
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 1st Ext.
Bill No: SBX1 2 Hearing Date: 3/22/2023
Author: | Skinner | ||
Version: | 3/20/2023 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin
DIGEST: This bill proposes several policies to address gasoline supply and pricing, including authorizing the California Energy Commission (CEC) to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (maximum margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state. This bill also establishes a new independent division at the CEC, the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight (Division), to provide independent oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels markets. Additionally, this bill establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee) for the Division; expands and recasts the existing reporting requirements on refiners; and requires the CEC, by January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Legislature and Governor that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, also known as the California Energy Commission (CEC), consisting of five members appointed by the governor, and specifies the duties of the CEC. Requires the CEC to assess trends in energy consumption and analyze the social, economic, and environmental consequences of these trends. (Public Resources Code §25200 et. seq.)
- Establishes the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), as of July 1, 2017, within the Government Operations Agency, vested with duties, powers, and responsibilities of the Board of Equalization, except those established by, and specified in, the California Constitution. (Government Code §15570 et seq.)
- Establishes the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 (PIIRA). (Public Resources Code §§25350 et seq.)
- Requires major oil producers, refiners, marketers, oil transporters, and oil storers to submit certain information to the CEC, as provided. (Public Resources Code §25354)
- Requires operators of refineries operating in the state that produce gasoline meeting California specifications to submit a report within 30 days of the end of each calendar month with certain information, including the maximum margin of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC within 45 days of the end of each calendar month to post certain information on its internet website. (Public Resources Code §25355)
- Subjects a person who fails to provide information to the CEC after being notified of the failure to civil penalties in specified amounts. (Public Resources Code §25362)
- Requires that information presented to the CEC is held in confidence by the CEC or aggregated to the extent necessary to ensure confidentiality if public disclosure of the specific data would result in unfair competitive disadvantage to the person supplying the information. (Public Resources Code §25364)
- Requires every petroleum refinery employer to provide to the Division of Occupational Health and Safety (Cal/OSHA) a full schedule of planned turnarounds for all affected units for the following calendar year, and defines the schedule submitted to be treated as a “trade secret.” Defines “turnaround” to mean a planned, periodic shutdown, total or partial, of a refinery process unit or plant to perform maintenance, overhaul, and repair operations and to inspect, test, and replace process materials and equipment. (Labor Code §§7872, 7873)
- Requires that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (California Constitution Article I, §3)
- Requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement. (California Constitution Article XIII B, §6 and Government Code §17500 et seq.)
This bill:
- Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs (essentially a refiner’s profit). If the CEC establishes the maximum margin, this bill requires the CEC to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum margin and requires the penalty to be a percentage of the amount the refiner exceeds the maximum margin, to be tiered and increase with the amount the refiner’s gross margin exceeds the maximum gross margin, as specified.
- Prohibits the CEC from establishing a maximum margin and penalty, unless the CEC finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. Requires the CEC to consider, at a minimum:
- Whether it is likely that the maximum margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in California transportation fuels market than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
- Whether it is likely that maximum margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
- Whether case-by-case exemptions from the maximum margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
- Authorizes the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum margin.
- Authorizes the CEC to rescind or adjust the maximum margin and the penalty percentages to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Requires the CEC to consider a refiner’s request for an exemption from the maximum margin, as provided. Requires a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Requires depositing the penalties collected into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, created by this bill in the State Treasury. Requires the moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, address the consequences of price gouging on Californians.
- Requires the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum margin and penalty. Requires the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by no later than June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. Requires the CEC, within 180 days after the issuance of the report, to cease implementing the maximum margin and penalty, if the Auditor concludes that the maximum margin and penalty should be terminated.
- Requires the CEC, in cooperation with the CDTFA, to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year. Authorizes the CDTFA to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the person’s possession, custody, or control that the CDTFA deems necessary to facilitate the report or to assist the CEC.
- Requires the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. Requires the CEC to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment and would authorize the CEC to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment. Requires the CEC and the California Air Resources Board (CARB), on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establishes the Division within the CEC, and requires the Division to be led by a director appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation, and specifies that the Division operates with authority independent of the CEC’s authority. Specifies the duties of the Division, including, the duty to provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor and the CEC on any issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California. Authorizes the Division to subpoena witnesses and require by subpoena any books, papers, records, or other items.
- Establishes the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. This bill requires the Committee to advise the CEC and the Division. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Revises, recasts, and expands the existing reporting requirements to the CEC to, among other things:
- Require pipeline operators and operators of ports through which refined gasoline is imported to annually report their capacities for all pipelines and ports used to transport refined gasoline.
- Require all importers of refined products and renewable fuels via marine vessel to submit reports to the CEC, as specified.
- Require non-refiners that commercially trade in gasoline, gasoline blending components, diesel fuel, or renewable fuel inventory to submit weekly reports to the CEC.
- Require refiners and non-refiners that consummate spot market transactions to submit a daily report to the CEC containing certain information for each transaction occurring in the preceding day, as provided, and require refiners to report maintenance activities, both planned and unplanned, to the CEC, as provided.
- Requires refiners to notify the executive director of the CEC of all plans to undertake turnaround and planned maintenance, and to include specified information, including the drawdown of inventory levels of gasoline and gasoline blending components controlled by the refiner and at other storage locations.
- Requires the operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month. Requires the CEC to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin.
- Authorizes the CEC to impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor and industry stakeholders.
- Increases the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed.
- Makes legislative findings to that the restrictions on the public’s right to information, as specified, is needed prevent adverse impacts on market competition in the transportation fuels sector.
- Provides that that no reimbursement is required by this act because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency because the bill creates, changes, or eliminates a new crime.
- Includes numerous findings and declarations concerning recent gasoline prices, refinery outages, and the desire for more transparency into refinery operations and greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants.
Background
Gasoline prices trend higher in California compared to the rest of the nation.
Californians, generally, pay higher prices for gasoline compared to the rest of the country. According to the CEC, there are five main reasons why California retail gasoline prices are higher than the average price in the United States, specifically: higher taxes on gasoline, higher gasoline production costs, environmental program costs, California’s shorter winter season, and the isolated nature of the California fuels market. California’s unique, cleaner-burning gasoline blend costs more to produce than other types of gasoline, accounting for an additional 10 to 15 cents per gallon (according to the CEC). The summer-blend gasoline is designed to evaporate at a higher temperature than winter-blend gasoline so as to minimize its contribution to unhealthy ground-level ozone (also known as smog). However, the summer-blend gasoline is more expensive to produce and tends to be used for longer stretches of the year, given California’s warm climate.
California gasoline fuels market is isolated. California’s gasoline fuels market is geographically isolated from other locations in the U.S. that produce refined fuel products. California has 11 refineries that refine crude oil into gasoline fuel; the majority are located in and around the South Bay region in the Los Angeles Basin, some in the East Bay region of the Bay Area, and the smallest by volume produced is located in Bakersfield. The state’s refineries process over 1.6 billion barrels of crude oil per day. In 2021, 88 percent of gasoline production was used in state and 12 percent was exported. These refiners produce transportation fuels that meet California standards, including the specially formulated gasoline to meet California’s air quality standards mandated by the CARB, known as California Reformulated Gasoline Blendstock for Oxygenated Blending (CARBOB) gasoline. In addition to providing in-state supply, California refiners provide the majority of transportation fuels to neighboring states – sending the equivalent of 10 percent of California’s consumption of gasoline to Nevada and Arizona via pipeline from Southern California. California refiners also export gasoline via marine shipments, including to western Mexico and Central America. However, the gasoline sent to neighboring states and countries is not the CARBOB gasoline, and is, generally, less expensive to produce.
Unexpected disruptions and facility outages can result in reduced supply and price spikes. California has no ability to deliver gasoline into the state via pipelines, as the existing pipelines deliver gasoline and other refined fuels out of the state. Gasoline imports, generally, provide a smaller portion of overall supply. However, when needed, California imports gasoline via marine shipments, which can take three to four weeks to deliver and with prices that account for the additional costs of transporting via international marine vessel. As a result of California’s isolated gasoline fuels market, unexpected and unplanned disruptions on the system, including unplanned refinery outages, can impact the supply and often result in price spikes. This was the situation after the unexpected outage at the then-Exxon Mobil Torrance Refinery in February 2015 due to an explosion of the facility that resulted in an extended outage. Gasoline prices were immediately affected, as prices increased $0.25 per gallon within a week of the outage.
California has a 40-plus year history of attempting to address gasoline prices. Most notably, following the 1979 energy crisis, when the nation (and much of the Western world) faced petroleum shortages and high prices, California established the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 via SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statues of 1980). Often referred to as PIIRA, the statute requires the CEC to collect and analyze specified data reported by petroleum industry companies on a weekly, monthly, and annual basis. The CEC analyzes the data to understand the operations of the petroleum industry in California. The Legislature enacted PIIRA as an acknowledgement that the petroleum industry is “an essential element of the California economy and is therefore vital to the importance to the health and welfare of all Californians.” The Legislature also stated that; “A complete and thorough understanding of the operation of the petroleum industry is required by state government to enable it to respond to possible shortages or other disruptions.” Under PIIRA’s provisions, much of the data collected by the CEC must remain confidential as to specific entities in the market. The CEC utilizes the data to help establish public reports based on aggregated data. The confidentiality provisions of PIIRA are intended to encourage timely reporting and prevent companies from gaining access to pricing data that would allow them to manipulate the market. Since the passage of PIIRA, California policymakers have responded to significant gasoline price increases several times. (See Background of Extraordinary Session Informational Hearing by this committee on February 22, 2023)
Legislation to require more data of petroleum industry. SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) requires the CEC to publicly post oil refining margins on a refiner basis for those refiners with more than one refinery in the state. Additionally, the bill expands the types of data that the CEC must collect on a monthly basis to include refinery-specific data, and extends existing confidentiality requirements to the data reported by the bill. While the CEC reports aggregated industry data on refining margins, it is based on self-reported data provided through the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS). SB 1322 requires specified refinery specific data regarding costs paid for crude oil, quantity of wholesale gasoline sold that meets California specifications and corresponding volume-weighted average prices, reduced by all applicable local, state, and federal taxes, separated by type of sale, and separate quantification of the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) and associated with cap-and-trade cap-at-the-rack program. The Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) petitioned for a rulemaking to provide clarification for some of the new reporting requirements in SB 1322. However, the CEC declined to proceed with a rulemaking, citing the recently called First Extraordinary Session as reason to not proceed with a rulemaking. Based on conversations with CEC staff, absent the rulemaking, the CEC is directing refiners to provide the required information to the best of their ability. At a CEC business meeting this month, the CEC noted that only one refiner had not submitted the data required, with the refiner citing a lack of clarity on the requested data.
More recent actions to address gasoline price volatility. More recently, the Newsom Administration, including the CEC, have sent letters to oil industry executives and held an informational hearing on the issue of recent gasoline price increases, in particular regarding concerns about the record-setting price differential of $2.50 per gallon of gasoline between California prices and the national average. The correspondence occurred around the time some refineries were taken off-line for maintenance. When gasoline prices spiked in late summer/early fall, Governor Newsom, as previous Governors have at times done, directed CARB to make an early transition to winter-blend gasoline to help increase supply and also noted a desire for a special session of the Legislature to address windfall profits in the oil industry. On November 29, 2022, the CEC held an informational hearing on the California Gasoline Price Spikes, Refinery Operations, and Transitioning to a Clean Transportation Fuels Future. The hearing discussed possible causes of the price spikes, including concerns about the Mystery Surcharge – the price differential at the retailer end – and the need for more data to better understand the causes between branded and unbranded fuels. Additionally, the CEC staff relayed plans for a Fuels Transition Study, to “understand the impact of climate goals on the demand, reliability, safety, and affordability of petroleum fuels under a variety of scenarios.”
Governor Newsom officially calls an Extraordinary Session of the Legislature. The Governor formally issued a proclamation on December 5, 2022, the first day of the 2023-24 Legislative Session, when Senators and Assembly members were sworn into office. On that same day, SBX1-2 (Skinner) was introduced containing the concept and general framework for the Governor’s Petroleum Windfall Profits Penalty proposal, but with an acknowledgement that this bill would need to be further developed, given the blanks on the proposed profit margins and the construct of this bill noting the intent for future legislation to operationalize aspects of the proposal.
The proclamation noted: Governor Newsom called for a Special Session of the Legislature:
To consider and act upon legislation necessary to:
- Deter price gouging by oil companies by imposing a financial penalty on excessive margins, with any penalties collected to be returned to Californians.
- Empower the CEC and the CDTFA to more closely review and evaluate costs, profits, and pricing in the refining, distribution, and retail segments of the market for gasoline in California.
- Provide for greater regulatory oversight of the refining, distribution, and retail segments of the market to prevent avoidable supply shortages and excessive price increases.
- Make conforming changes to existing law consistent with paragraphs (a), (b), and (c).
SBX1-2 (Skinner). This bill proposes several policies to address gasoline supply and pricing, including:
- Excess Profit Cap and Penalty. Authorizes the CEC to establish a maximum margin and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state. Prohibits the CEC from setting the maximum margin unless it finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. Authorizes the CEC to adjust or rescind the maximum margin and penalty.
- State Auditor Review. Requires the Auditor to complete, by March 1, 2033, an audit and performance review of the maximum margin to determine whether the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market for California consumers is being achieved. Requires the CEC to cease implementing the maximum margin and penalty by 180 days from the date the Auditor issues the report and finds the margin and penalty are not meeting the goal.
- Division of Petroleum Market Oversight. Establishes a new independent division at the CEC, the Division, to provide independent oversight and analysis of the transportation fuels markets. Provides the Division with subpoena power.
- Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee. Establishes an advisory Committee for the Division with six members appointed by the Governor, one by the Speaker of the Assembly and one by the Senate Committee on Rules. Establishes revolving door protections for members of the Committee, except for the labor and industry representatives.
- Significantly Expanded Reporting Requirements. Expands and recasts the existing reporting requirements on refiners to include many other entities in the market, including pipeline and port operators, oil transporters, oil storers, facilities that process renewable feedstocks, and others. The expanded reporting includes daily, weekly, monthly, and annual reporting to the CEC. Explicit reporting of contracts and details of transactions in the spot market.
- Assessment on Transportation Fuels Supply. Requires the CEC, by January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Legislature and Governor that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California.
- Transportation Fuels Study. Requires the CEC and CARB to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan by December 31, 2024.
- Data Disclosure to the Legislature. Requires the CEC, upon request, to share confidential information in aggregate or anonymized form to the Assembly Speaker, Senate Committee on Rules, and appropriate policy committee, with each person agreeing in writing to maintain the information confidential.
- Refinery Turnarounds and Maintenance. This bill would require advance reporting to the CEC of scheduled planned maintenance and notifications of unplanned maintenance. This bill also authorizes the CEC to impose the timing of planned maintenance, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency.
Need for the profit cap. Supporters of this bill cite argue that oil companies are gouging consumers and raking in excessive profits. They contend that a windfall profits cap on refining gasoline will save consumers billions of dollars in overcharges. The Governor’s Office argues that the maximum margin and penalty are needed as a deterrent to prevent oil companies from creating price spikes, which hurt consumers. They also note the CEC will only establish a margin, if and when, the agency determines the benefits outweigh the costs to consumers. The opponents of this bill express concerns that there are many factors that contribute to gasoline price volatility. They express concerns that the sponsors of this bill will attribute any price increases to excess profit, and not consider the many other factors of the market – especially supply and demand and cyclical fluctuations in profits. This bill provides the CEC with flexibility to establish, rescind, and adjust a maximum margin, as needed. The flexibility afforded to the CEC may be both reassuring and concerning for both supporters and opponents. However, given the unknowns about instituting a maximum margin and penalty policy, such flexibility may be warranted to ensure the CEC is able to respond to changing market conditions and to new information as it becomes available – of which there will be an abundance given the extensive and expanded reporting requirements in this bill! Additionally, the Auditor will be required to audit the performance of the maximum margin and penalty by March 2033 and issue a report by June 2033. Should the Auditor find the margin and penalty are not meeting their intended goals, the CEC will be required to cease implementation within 180 days of the date of issuance of the Auditor’s Report.
Need to proceed with caution. Unlike other consumer goods, gasoline is ubiquitous in our lives and largely needed by most everyone, every day. Consumers are not able to postpone gasoline purchases in the same way they can wait out higher prices of other goods. Additionally, California’s air quality and climate change-related policies are transitioning the state away from fossil fuel uses, most notably Governor Newsom’s Executive Order (N-79-20) to require 100 percent of in-state sales of new passenger cars and trucks to be zero-emission by 2035, thereby prohibiting the sale of new gasoline-fueled vehicles by 2035. This combination of factors, along with the isolated nature of the California transportation fuels market, creates a challenge for the state to ensure consumers are protected with adequate gasoline supply at affordable prices, all while advancing California’s climate policies that shift demand away from petroleum fuels. The balancing act of providing adequate supply with uncertain demand is no small feat. Yet, the implications to Californians can be significant to their health, well-being, and quality of life, if policies do not achieve the intended relief. In this regard, the elements of this bill that require fuel assessments every three years and a fuel transition study will likely be very beneficial to inform changes in future policies and efforts to address supply and affordability for transportation fuels. This includes more information about retail aspects of the market and its effects on price and supply.
Petroleum market oversight. Among the main findings of the Petroleum Market Advisory Committee (PMAC), and many of its members (including the former Chair Severin Borenstein), is the need for more expert analysis of the transportation fuels market. The PMAC members noted the difficulty of coming to any clear conclusions from voluntary efforts, but raised concerns about the price differential for Californians at the gas pump – citing the growing “mystery surcharge.” This bill establishes an independent Division of Petroleum Market Oversight at the CEC with a director appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate. As noted above, the Division will have subpoena authority of witnesses and books. It is likely to take some time for the Division to be staffed given the pace of state hiring. However, the Administration has noted its commitment to standup the Division as quickly as possible, should this bill be enacted.
Ensuring worker and public safety. This bill requires refineries to provide the CEC with their planned schedule for turnarounds and maintenance. This bill also authorizes the CEC, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor and industry, to issue a regulation governing the timing of the maintenance in a way that protects health and safety of workers and the public, while minimizing production losses. However, it is not clear the CEC has or will have much knowledge, beyond the supply of fuels, to inform such a regulation. They will need to lean heavily on the Labor and Workforce Development Agency to ensure safety is not undermined. Unfortunately, California has experienced explosions at refineries, including where workers have been harmed. As such, the need for safety – especially for workers and the local community – are imperative.
So much data! Need to protect against unfair competitive disadvantage and market manipulation. From the wellhead to the consumer, gasoline supply and pricing is a complicated market with varied players, some vertically integrated companies, marketers, traders, limited transparency, and affected by both a global crude oil market and regional market for refined gasoline. SBX1-2 proposes to provide significantly more reporting of an abundance of data from what seems like the entire ecosystem of the transportation fuels market. Expanding access to data by experts, especially those in the new independent Division at the CEC, the Attorney General, and other state agencies, should help ensure the state has enough transparency to better address supply and pricing challenges. However, it should be noted that SB 1322 was just recently enacted and CEC is in the process of reviewing the first set of required data submissions by refiner. As noted above, there is some dispute as to the terms of the data that is required to be reported. The Legislature has not received the required aggregate information. Should this bill pass, the Legislature should continue to monitor implementation of this bill to ensure the data requested and the expanded list of reporting entities in this bill are proving beneficial. More importantly, the Administration and Legislature will need to monitor against the use of confidential data in a manner that could result in harm to consumers. PIIRA confidentiality provisions require limited access to aggregate data by the public in order to protect against competitive disadvantage and market manipulation. With a declining number of refineries (now down to 11 that refine CARBOB gasoline), the Attorney General’s pending litigation against two market traders who are alleged to have manipulated the spot market to their benefit and to the detriment of consumers, there is a great need to proceed with caution in divulging confidential data. While this bill attempts to strike the appropriate balance, the expanded reporting requirements, public disclosure, and expanded access to the data (including with nondisclosure agreements) may require future tweaking.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) required the CEC to collect specified pricing data from each oil refinery operating in the state.
SB 448 (Leno, 2013) would have required the CEC to collect and analyze specific information regarding petroleum pricing, establish the Motor Vehicle Fuel Market Advisory Committee to provide subject matter expertise on fuel pricing, and include specified recommendations regarding its findings, including an analysis of potential market manipulation in the Integrated Energy Policy Report. The bill was vetoed.
SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statues of 1980) established the PIIRA which requires specified monthly and annual reporting requirements for certain members of the petroleum industry and quarterly and annual reporting of the CEC. The bill includes confidentiality protections for the data submitted so as to prevent unfair competitive disadvantage.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT:
Governor Gavin Newsom, State of California, Co-sponsor Attorney General Rob Bonta, State of California, Co-sponsor San Fernando Valley, Humboldt, Sacramento, San Diego, SoCal Climate Action, South Bay Los Angeles, Southland Legislative Alliance, and Ventura County Climate Hub 1000 Grandmothers for Future Generations Action for the Climate Emergency Alameda County Democratic Party American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO Ballona Wetlands Institute Battle Creek Alliance & Defiance Canyon Raptor Rescue BeniSolSolar Biofuelwatch Breast Cancer Action Brightline Businesses for a Livable Climate CA Youth Vs Big Oil California Alliance for Retired Americans California Climate Voters California Environmental Justice Alliance California Environmental Voters California Green New Deal Coalition California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice California Public Interest Research Group California Working Families Party CatholicNetwork US Center for Biological Diversity Justice Center for Environmentally Recycled Alternatives Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment Central California Asthma Collaborative Central California Environmental Justice Network Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Sacramento Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Santa Cruz City of Mountain View City of Fullerton Clean Power Campaign Climate Action Campaign Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas Climate Hawks Vote Coalition of California Utility Employees Corvallis Interfaith Climate Justice Committee Defend Ballona Wetlands Drawdown Bay Area Ecology Center Economic Security Project Action Elders Climate Action, NorCal & SoCal Chapters Elected Officials to Protect America Environment California | Environmental Working Group Equity Transit Feminists in Action Los Angeles Food & Water Watch Fossil Free CA FracTracker Alliance Friends of Harbors Beaches and Parks Friends of the Earth Gemini Energy Solutions, Inc. Glendale Environmental Coalition Green Building Architects Greenlining Greenpeace USA Health Justice Commons Indivisible East Bay Let’s Go Farm Let’s Green CA! Long Beach Gray Panthers Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator -Manhattan Beach Huddle Marin Interfaith Climate Action Menlo Spark NextGen CA Northridge Indivisible Novasutras Ocean Conservation Research Oil and Gas Action Network Oil Change International Pacific Environment Pelican Media Physicians for Social Responsibility- Sacramento Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay Progressive Democrats of America-California Project Green Home RootsAction.org Sacramento Climate Coalition Santa Barbara Standing Rock Coalition Santa Cruz Climate Action Network Save the Environmental Protection Agency SEIU California Sierra Club California Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action Small Business Alliance Spottswoode Winery, Inc. Stand.earth Sunflower Alliance Sunrise SLO Sustainable Mill Valley System Change Not Climate Change The Climate Alliance of Santa Cruz County The Climate Center Transformative Wealth Management, LLC UFCW Western States Council Undaunted California Voices in Solidarity Against Oil in Neighborhoods Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Women’s March Santa Barbara 21 Individuals |
OPPOSITION:
African American Farmers of California California Taxpayers Association Dorado County, El Dorado Hills, Elk Grove, Folsom, Greater Coachella Valley, Greater Conejo Valley, Lincoln Area, Long Beach Area, Los Angeles Area, Los Angeles Latino, Murrieta Wildomar, Rancho Cordova Area, Rocklin Area, Roseville Area, Santa Barbara South Coast, Shingle Springs/Cameron Park, Simi Valley, Torrance Area, and Yuba Sutter | Federation & Kern Citizens for Energy Inland Empire Economic Partnership Los Angeles County Business Federation Milk Producers Council Properties Orange County Business Council Ventura County Taxpayers Association |
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
California Attorney General Rob Bonta expresses strong support for the bill stating:
At great hardship, California consumers have been paying too much at the pump, while oil companies continue to report record profits at their expense. This is unacceptable and unsustainable. I stand with the Governor in supporting financial penalties to deter profiteering, and new measures to increase transparency in the price of gas in the retail market.
A coalition of over 100 environmental, environmental justice, consumer, faith, labor, and clean energy organizations writes to express strong support for SBX1-2 stating:
We support a windfall profits cap to rein in refiners’ unconscionable price-gouging and provide greater transparency for California’s gasoline market. Additionally, given that SBX1 2 also notes the legislature’s intent to establish a multi-agency process “to plan for and monitor progress towards the state’s… transition away from petroleum fuels,” we urge you to partner with environmental justice groups to ensure that transition is rapid, equitable, and just.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of 50 organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, several local chambers, business associations, and the Western States Petroleum Association, strongly opposes SBX1-2 stating that the bill is “unlikely to provide any price relief for consumers or businesses and in fact, will make matters worse.” They further contend that “SBX1-2 will result in numerous disruptive unintended consequences,” including: potential gasoline supply reduction that means higher costs for consumers and businesses, likely job losses, reduced funding for schools and local governments and likely increase the frequency and duration of volatile price spikes given California’s isolated market.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 1st Ext. Session
SBX1 2 (Skinner) - Energy: transportation fuels: supply and pricing: maximum gross gasoline refining margin
Version: March 20, 2023 | Policy Vote: E., U. & C. 13 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: March 23, 2023 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would enact several policies to address gasoline supply and pricing, including authorizing the California Energy Commission (CEC) to establish a maximum gross gasoline refining margin (margin) and penalty on gasoline sold by refiners in the state as well as establishing a new independent division within the CEC, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The CEC estimates ongoing costs of approximately $4.4 million annually (General Fund or special fund), including contracting costs, and 14 PY of staff to fulfill the requirements of this bill. In addition, the CEC anticipates annual costs of $2.5 million (General Fund or special fund) and 10 PY of staff to establish and support the new independent Division of Petroleum Market Oversight within the CEC.
- The California Air Resources Control Board (CARB) estimates one-time contracting costs of approximately $1 million (Cost of Implementation Account) to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan by December 31, 2024.
- The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates ongoing costs of $50,000 - $250,000 annually (General Fund) to develop processes to request the necessary information from taxpayers involved in gasoline sales, collect and analyze data, share information with other agencies, and prepare the annual reports required by this bill.
- Should the CEC exercise authority that would be established by this bill to set a margin and accompanying penalty, there would be several fiscal effects:
- Unknown, potentially significant one-time costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC to make a finding that the likely benefits of establishing a margin and penalty would outweigh potential costs for consumers and promulgate regulations establishing the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs (General Fund or special fund) for the CEC administer, oversee, and enforce the margin and penalty.
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs for the Attorney General to bring enforcement actions against any refiners in violation.
- The California State Auditor estimates one-time costs of up to $800,000 in 2032-33 (General Fund) to conduct an audit and performance review of the margin and penalty, make determinations regarding the effectiveness of the margin and penalty in meeting specified goals, provide a report on its determinations to the Legislature and CEC, and subsequently participate in a CEC business meeting.
- To the extent that refiners exceed the maximum margin established by the CEC, there would be potential ongoing revenue increases of an unknown amount from the collection of penalties imposed on refiners for exceeding the margin. The bill would require penalty revenues be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund and used to address any consequences of price gouging on Californians.
Background:
Gasoline prices trend higher in California compared to the rest of the nation.
Californians, generally, pay higher prices for gasoline compared to the rest of the country. According to the CEC, there are five main reasons why California retail gasoline prices are higher than the average price in the United States, specifically: higher taxes on gasoline, higher gasoline production costs, environmental program costs, California’s shorter winter season, and the isolated nature of the California fuels market. California’s unique, cleaner-burning gasoline blend costs more to produce than other types of gasoline, accounting for an additional 10 to 15 cents per gallon (according to the CEC). The summer-blend gasoline is designed to evaporate at a higher temperature than winter-blend gasoline so as to minimize its contribution to unhealthy ground-level ozone (also known as smog). However, the summer-blend gasoline is more expensive to produce and tends to be used for longer stretches of the year, given California’s warm climate.
California gasoline fuels market is isolated. California’s gasoline fuels market is geographically isolated from other locations in the U.S. that produce refined fuel products. California has 11 refineries that refine crude oil into gasoline fuel; the majority are located in and around the South Bay region in the Los Angeles Basin, some in the East Bay region of the Bay Area, and the smallest by volume produced is located in Bakersfield. The state’s refineries process over 1.6 billion barrels of crude oil per day. In 2021, 88 percent of gasoline production was used in state and 12 percent was exported. These refiners produce transportation fuels that meet California standards, including the specially formulated gasoline to meet California’s air quality standards mandated by the CARB, known as California Reformulated Gasoline Blendstock for Oxygenated Blending (CARBOB) gasoline. In addition to providing in-state supply, California refiners provide the majority of transportation fuels to neighboring states – sending the equivalent of 10 percent of California’s consumption of gasoline to Nevada and Arizona via pipeline from Southern California. California refiners also export gasoline via marine shipments, including to western Mexico and Central America. However, the gasoline sent to neighboring states and countries is not the CARBOB gasoline, and is, generally, less expensive to produce.
Unexpected disruptions and facility outages can result in reduced supply and price spikes. California has no ability to deliver gasoline into the state via pipelines, as the existing pipelines deliver gasoline and other refined fuels out of the state. Gasoline imports, generally, provide a smaller portion of overall supply. However, when needed, California imports gasoline via marine shipments, which can take three to four weeks to deliver and with prices that account for the additional costs of transporting via international marine vessel. As a result of California’s isolated gasoline fuels market, unexpected and unplanned disruptions on the system, including unplanned refinery outages, can impact the supply and often result in price spikes. This was the situation after the unexpected outage at the then-Exxon Mobil Torrance Refinery in February 2015 due to an explosion of the facility that resulted in an extended outage. Gasoline prices were immediately affected, as prices increased $0.25 per gallon within a week of the outage.
California has a 40-plus year history of attempting to address gasoline prices. Most notably, following the 1979 energy crisis, when the nation (and much of the Western world) faced petroleum shortages and high prices, California established the Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act of 1980 via SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statues of 1980). Often referred to as PIIRA, the statute requires the CEC to collect and analyze specified data reported by petroleum industry companies on a weekly, monthly, and annual basis. The CEC analyzes the data to understand the operations of the petroleum industry in California. The Legislature enacted PIIRA as an acknowledgement that the petroleum industry is “an essential element of the California economy and is therefore vital to the importance to the health and welfare of all Californians.” The Legislature also stated that; “A complete and thorough understanding of the operation of the petroleum industry is required by state government to enable it to respond to possible shortages or other disruptions.” Under PIIRA’s provisions, much of the data collected by the CEC must remain confidential as to specific entities in the market. The CEC utilizes the data to help establish public reports based on aggregated data. The confidentiality provisions of PIIRA are intended to encourage timely reporting and prevent companies from gaining access to pricing data that would allow them to manipulate the market. Since the passage of PIIRA, California policymakers have responded to significant gasoline price increases several times.
Legislation to require more data of petroleum industry. SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) requires the CEC to publicly post oil refining margins on a refiner basis for those refiners with more than one refinery in the state. Additionally, the bill expands the types of data that the CEC must collect on a monthly basis to include refinery-specific data, and extends existing confidentiality requirements to the data reported by the bill. While the CEC reports aggregated industry data on refining margins, it is based on self-reported data provided through the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS). SB 1322 requires specified refinery specific data regarding costs paid for crude oil, quantity of wholesale gasoline sold that meets California specifications and corresponding volume-weighted average prices, reduced by all applicable local, state, and federal taxes, separated by type of sale, and separate quantification of the volume-weighted fees or estimated valuations of costs embedded in all wholesale gasoline sales associated with the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) and associated with cap-and-trade cap-at-the-rack program. The Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) petitioned for a rulemaking to provide clarification for some of the new reporting requirements in SB 1322. However, the CEC declined to proceed with a rulemaking, citing the recently called First Extraordinary Session as reason to not proceed with a rulemaking. Based on conversations with CEC staff, absent the rulemaking, the CEC is directing refiners to provide the required information to the best of their ability. At a CEC business meeting this month, the CEC noted that only one refiner had not submitted the data required, with the refiner citing a lack of clarity on the requested data.
More recent actions to address gasoline price volatility. More recently, the Newsom Administration, including the CEC, have sent letters to oil industry executives and held an informational hearing on the issue of recent gasoline price increases, in particular regarding concerns about the record-setting price differential of $2.50 per gallon of gasoline between California prices and the national average. The correspondence occurred around the time some refineries were taken off-line for maintenance. When gasoline prices spiked in late summer/early fall, Governor Newsom, as previous Governors have at times done, directed CARB to make an early transition to winter-blend gasoline to help increase supply and also noted a desire for a special session of the Legislature to address windfall profits in the oil industry. On November 29, 2022, the CEC held an informational hearing on the California Gasoline Price Spikes, Refinery Operations, and Transitioning to a Clean Transportation Fuels Future. The hearing discussed possible causes of the price spikes, including concerns about the Mystery Surcharge – the price differential at the retailer end – and the need for more data to better understand the causes between branded and unbranded fuels. Additionally, the CEC staff relayed plans for a Fuels Transition Study, to “understand the impact of climate goals on the demand, reliability, safety, and affordability of petroleum fuels under a variety of scenarios.”
2019-20 Budget Funded Studies on Transportation Fossil Fuel. The budget provided $1.5 million from the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF) for “a study to identify strategies to significantly reduce emissions from vehicles and to achieve carbon neutrality in the sector, including the transition to zero-emission light-duty vehicles, in particular, passenger vehicles, the transition to zero-emission heavy vehicles, and the adoption of other technology to significantly reduce emissions from heavy vehicles; the role of alternative fuels; and the impact of land use policy.” Two studies conducted by University of California researchers under contract with CalEPA resulted, one identifying strategies to reduce transportation-related fossil fuel demand and emissions and the other examining ways to responsibly manage the decline of transportation-related fossil fuel supply.
Governor Newsom officially calls an Extraordinary Session of the Legislature. The Governor formally issued a proclamation on December 5, 2022, the first day of the 2023-24 Legislative Session, when Senators and Assembly members were sworn into office. On that same day, SBX1-2 (Skinner) was introduced containing the concept and general framework for the Governor’s Petroleum Windfall Profits Penalty proposal, but with an acknowledgement that this bill would need to be further developed, given the blanks on the proposed profit margins and the construct of this bill noting the intent for future legislation to operationalize aspects of the proposal.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Authorize the CEC to establish a maximum margin, which is the maximum amount of the gross gasoline refining margin excluding state program costs (essentially a refiner’s profit). If the CEC establishes the maximum margin, this bill would require the CEC to establish a penalty for exceeding the maximum margin and require the penalty to be a percentage of the amount the refiner exceeds the maximum margin, to be tiered and increased with the amount the refiner’s gross margin exceeds the maximum gross margin, as specified.
- Prohibit the CEC from establishing a maximum margin and penalty, unless it finds that the likely benefits to consumers outweigh the potential costs to consumers. At a minimum, the bill would require the CEC to consider the following:
- Whether it is likely that the maximum margin and penalty will lead to a greater imbalance between supply and demand in California transportation fuels market than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
- Whether it is likely that maximum margin and penalty will lead to higher average prices at the pump on an annual basis than would exist without the maximum margin and penalty.
- Whether case-by-case exemptions from the maximum margin will be sufficient to ensure that individual refiners have an opportunity to demonstrate the need for a greater margin before they make decisions about production.
- Authorize the CEC to petition the court to enjoin a refiner from exceeding the maximum margin.
- Authorize the CEC to rescind or adjust the maximum margin and the penalty percentages to ensure that a sufficient, affordable, and fairly priced supply of gasoline is available to Californians.
- Require the CEC to consider a refiner’s request for an exemption from the maximum margin, as provided. The bill would require a refiner seeking an exemption to file a statement under the penalty of perjury setting forth the basis of the request for exemption. By requiring the statement to be filed under the penalty of perjury, this bill expands the scope of the crime of perjury, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
- Require penalties collected to be deposited into the Price Gouging Penalty Fund, created by this bill in the State Treasury, and require the moneys in the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used to address the consequences of price gouging on Californians.
- Require the California State Auditor (Auditor), no later than March 1, 2033, to complete an audit and performance review of the maximum margin and penalty. The bill would also require the Auditor to make a determination in a report to the Legislature and the CEC, by June 1, 2033, as to whether the maximum margin and penalty is achieving the intended goal to reduce gasoline price spikes and stabilize the gasoline fuel supply market. If the Auditor concludes that the maximum margin and penalty are not achieving the intended goal and should be terminated, the CEC must cease implementing a margin and penalty within 180 days after the issuance of the report.
- Require the CEC, in cooperation with the CDTFA, to submit a report to the Legislature, by March 1 of each year that includes a review of the price of gasoline in California and its impact on state revenues for the previous calendar year. The bill would authorize CDTFA to request from any person certain records required to be maintained and any records in the person’s possession, custody, or control that CDTFA deems necessary to facilitate the report or assist the CEC.
- Require the CEC, on or before January 1, 2024, and every three years thereafter, to submit an assessment to the Governor and the Legislature that identifies methods to ensure a reliable supply of affordable and safe transportation fuels in California. The bill would require the CEC to use reasonable means necessary and available to seek and obtain information from any sources for purposes of preparing the assessment, and would authorize the CEC to impose a civil penalty if a person fails to timely provide information necessary for preparing the assessment.
- Require the CEC and CARB, on or before December 31, 2024, and taking into account the assessment, to prepare a specified Transportation Fuels Transition Plan.
- Establish the Division of Petroleum Market Oversight (Division) within the CEC that operates with independent authority within the CEC, and require the Division to be led by a director appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation. The bill would specify the duties of the Division, including the duty to provide guidance and recommendations to the Governor and the CEC on any issues related to transportation fuels pricing and transportation decarbonization in California. The Division would be authorized to subpoena witnesses and require by subpoena any books, papers, records, or other items, as specified.
- Establish the Independent Consumer Fuels Advisory Committee (Committee), within the CEC, consisting of six members appointed by the Governor, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. This bill would require the Committee to advise the CEC and the Division. Provides the Committee with access to all the information provided to the CEC and Division. Requires the executive director of the CEC to ensure any confidential information shared with the members of the Committee is subject to a nondisclosure agreement.
- Revise, recast, and expand the existing reporting requirements to the CEC, as specified.
- Require the operators of refineries to report additional information, including the net gasoline refining margin per barrel of gasoline sold in that month, and require the CEC to post on its internet website certain information related to the net gasoline refining margin, as specified.
- Authorize the CEC to impose requirements governing the timing of turnaround and maintenance developed through consultations with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, labor and industry stakeholders.
- Increase the amount of civil penalties that may be imposed on refinery operators for failure to provide specified information to the CEC.
- Make legislative findings to that the restrictions on the public’s right to information, as specified, is needed prevent adverse impacts on market competition in the transportation fuels sector.
- Provide that that no reimbursement is required by this act because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency are a result of the bill’s expansion of the scope of the crime of perjury, as specified.
- Include numerous findings and declarations concerning recent gasoline prices, refinery outages, and the desire for more transparency into refinery operations and greater visibility into the pricing, contracting, and marketing practices of industry participants.
Related Legislation:
SB 1322 (Allen, Chapter 374, Statutes of 2022) required the CEC to collect specified pricing data from each oil refinery operating in the state.
SB 448 (Leno, 2013) would have required the CEC to collect and analyze specific information regarding petroleum pricing, establish the Motor Vehicle Fuel Market Advisory Committee to provide subject matter expertise on fuel pricing, and include specified recommendations regarding its findings, including an analysis of potential market manipulation in the Integrated Energy Policy Report. The bill was vetoed.
SB 1444 (Holmdahl, Chapter 1055, Statues of 1980) established the PIIRA which requires specified monthly and annual reporting requirements for certain members of the petroleum industry and quarterly and annual reporting of the CEC. The bill includes confidentiality protections for the data submitted so as to prevent unfair competitive disadvantage.
Staff Comments:
Transportation Fuels Transition Plan and initial implementation costs. Given the timing of this special session bill, it is unclear when budgetary resources for implementation would become available. If funding is not included in the 2023-24 budget, it would be difficult for the CEC, CARB, and other state entities to effectively implement the bill, including the requirement for the CEC and CARB to prepare a Transportation Fuels Transition Plan by the end of 2024, without impacting current workload and responsibilities.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Floor
Senate Extraordinary Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):