AB 1406: Attached residential condominium sales: liquidated damages.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2026-01-22
Current Status:
In Progress
(2026-06-29: In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes that for the initial sale of a newly constructed condominium unit, as specified, the amount actually paid to the seller in the event of a buyers default pursuant to a liquidated damages provision that exceeds 3% of the purchase price of the residential unit is subject to specified requirements, including an accounting of the sellers costs and revenues, as specified.
This bill would delete the above-specified percentage and, instead, increase that percentage to 10%. 6%.
Existing law establishes that for the initial sale of a newly constructed condominium unit, as specified, the amount actually paid to the seller in the event of a buyers default pursuant to a liquidated damages provision that exceeds 3% of the purchase price of the residential unit is subject to specified requirements, including an accounting of the sellers costs and revenues, as specified.
This bill would delete the above-specified percentage and, instead, increase that percentage to 10%.
Existing law deems a provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer constitutes liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property to be valid if certain conditions are satisfied, including, among others, whether the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3% of the purchase price.This bill would delete the above-specified percent and, instead, apply 10%.Existing law deems a provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer constitutes liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property to be valid if certain conditions are satisfied, including certain conditions pertaining to including, among others, whether the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3% of the purchase price.
This bill would, notwithstanding those provisions, permit a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed to be disbursed before closing to pay for project expenses, as specified. If the deposit is equal to or exceeds 3% of the purchase price, the bill would authorize disbursement before closing if specified conditions are met, including that the Department of Real Estate has approved the developers final public report for the project that prominently displays a specified notice. The bill would entitle the purchaser to a full refund of the deposit if the purchaser is unable to close at the time of completion of the project, as specified. The bill would also permit the amount actually paid pursuant to a liquidated damages provision to exceed 3% of the purchase price if these provisions are satisfied, in which case the bill would require that the liquidated damages equal the amount of the deposit. would delete the above-specified percent and, instead, apply 10%.
Existing law prescribes various restrictions on the sale or lease of lots in a subdivision. Existing law defines a subdivision as improved or unimproved land or lands, wherever situated within California, divided or proposed to be divided for the purpose of sale or lease or financing, whether immediate or future, into 5 or more lots or parcels, as specified. Existing law requires a person who intends to offer subdivided lands for sale or lease to file with the Department of Real Estate an application for a public report, as specified. In certain instances, existing law permits lots to be sold or leased only if the money paid or advanced by a purchaser or lessee is placed into an escrow depository or a bond is furnished for the purpose of protecting purchasers or lessees.
This bill would authorize a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed to be disbursed before closing to pay for project expenses, as specified. The bill would authorize the disbursement of a purchasers deposit before closing if specified conditions are met, including that the developer has submitted to the Department of Real Estate a project budget showing all costs required to be paid in order to complete the project.
This bill would require the developer to submit specified information to the Department of Real Estate if a purchasers funds are to be disbursed before the completion of construction of the project, including, among other things, satisfactory evidence of security for the completion of construction. The bill would permit the disbursement of a purchasers deposit before closing to pay any cost set forth in the project budget, as provided.
This bill would require a specified notice to be prominently displayed in the developers public report for the project if a purchasers deposit is to be disbursed before closing. The bill would require the Department of Real Estate to complete a review required by these provisions within 30 days of receipt of the document to be reviewed. The bill would entitle the purchaser to a full refund of the deposit if the purchaser is unable to close at the time of completion of the project, as specified. The bill would provide that these provisions do not limit or otherwise alter the selling or leasing of lots if purchaser funds are deposited into an escrow depository or bond is furnished, as described above.
Existing law deems a provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer constitutes liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property to be valid if certain conditions are satisfied, including certain conditions pertaining to whether the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3% of the purchase price.
This bill would, notwithstanding those provisions, permit a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed to be disbursed before closing to pay for project expenses, as specified. If the deposit is equal to or exceeds 3% of the purchase price, the bill would authorize disbursement before closing if specified conditions are met, including that the Department of Real Estate has approved the developers final public report for the project that prominently displays a specified notice. The bill would entitle the purchaser to a full refund of the deposit if the purchaser is unable to close at the time of completion of the project, as specified. The bill would also permit the amount actually paid pursuant to a liquidated damages provision to exceed 3% of the purchase price if these provisions are satisfied, in which case the bill would require that the liquidated damages equal the amount of the deposit.
Existing law, the Private Investigator Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of private investigators by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services. The act requires a licensee to be legally responsible for the good conduct of each of their employees or agents, as specified.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.Existing law, the Private Investigator Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of private investigators by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services. The act requires a licensee to be legally responsible for the good conduct of each of their employees or agents, as specified.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.
(a)As used in this section, residential property means real property primarily consisting of a dwelling that meets both of the following requirements:
(1)The dwelling contains not more than four residential units.
(2)At the time the contract to purchase and sell the property is made, the buyer intends to occupy the dwelling or one of its units as the buyers residence.
(b)A provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer shall constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the requirements of Sections 1677 and 1678 and either subdivision (c) or (d) of this section.
(c)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.
(d)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.
(e)For the purposes of subdivisions (c) and (d), the reasonableness of an amount actually paid as liquidated damages shall be determined by taking into account both of the following:
(1)The circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.
(2)The price and other terms and circumstances of any subsequent sale or contract to sell and purchase the same property if the sale or contract is made within six months of the buyers default.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding either subdivision (c) or (d), for the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units, as defined pursuant to Section 783, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units and the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 10 6 percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction both of the following shall occur in the event of a buyers default:
(A)The seller shall perform an accounting of its costs and revenues related to and fairly allocable to the construction and sale of the residential unit within 60 calendar days after the final close of escrow of the sale of the unit within the structure.
(B)The accounting shall include any and all costs and revenues related to the construction and sale of the residential property and any delay caused by the buyers default. The seller shall make reasonable efforts to mitigate any damages arising from the default. The seller shall refund to the buyer any amounts previously retained as liquidated damages in excess of the greater of either 10 6 percent of the originally agreed-upon purchase price of the residential property or the amount of the sellers losses resulting from the buyers default, as calculated by the accounting.
(2)The refund shall be sent to the buyers last known address within 90 days after the final close of escrow of the sale or lease of all the residential condominium units within the structure.
(3)If the amount retained by the seller after the accounting does not exceed 10 6 percent of the purchase price, the amount is valid unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages pursuant to subdivision (e).
(4)Subdivision (d) shall not apply to any dispute regarding the reasonableness of any amount retained as liquidated damages pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)Notwithstanding the time periods regarding the performance of the accounting set forth in paragraph (1), if a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase the residential property in question, the seller shall perform the accounting within 60 calendar days after a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase.
(6)As used in this subdivision, structure means either of the following:
(A)Improvements constructed on a common foundation.
(B)Improvements constructed by the same owner that must be constructed concurrently due to the design characteristics of the improvements or physical characteristics of the property on which the improvements are located.
(7)As used in this subdivision, new qualified buyer means a buyer who either:
(A)Has been issued a loan commitment, which satisfies the purchase agreement loan contingency requirement, by an institutional lender to obtain a loan for an amount equal to the purchase price less any downpayment possessed by the buyer.
(B)Has contracted to pay a purchase price that is greater than or equal to the purchase price to be paid by the original buyer.
(a)As used in this section, residential property means real property primarily consisting of a dwelling that meets both of the following requirements:
(1)The dwelling contains not more than four residential units.
(2)At the time the contract to purchase and sell the property is made, the buyer intends to occupy the dwelling or one of its units as the buyers residence.
(b)A provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer shall constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the requirements of Sections 1677 and 1678 and either subdivision (c) or (d) of this section.
(c)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 10 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.
(d)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 10 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.
(e)For the purposes of subdivisions (c) and (d), the reasonableness of an amount actually paid as liquidated damages shall be determined by taking into account both of the following:
(1)The circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.
(2)The price and other terms and circumstances of any subsequent sale or contract to sell and purchase the same property if the sale or contract is made within six months of the buyers default.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding either subdivision (c) or (d), for the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units, as defined pursuant to Section 783, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units and the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 10 percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction both of the following shall occur in the event of a buyers default:
(A)The seller shall perform an accounting of its costs and revenues related to and fairly allocable to the construction and sale of the residential unit within 60 calendar days after the final close of escrow of the sale of the unit within the structure.
(B)The accounting shall include any and all costs and revenues related to the construction and sale of the residential property and any delay caused by the buyers default. The seller shall make reasonable efforts to mitigate any damages arising from the default. The seller shall refund to the buyer any amounts previously retained as liquidated damages in excess of the greater of either 10 percent of the originally agreed-upon purchase price of the residential property or the amount of the sellers losses resulting from the buyers default, as calculated by the accounting.
(2)The refund shall be sent to the buyers last known address within 90 days after the final close of escrow of the sale or lease of all the residential condominium units within the structure.
(3)If the amount retained by the seller after the accounting does not exceed 10 percent of the purchase price, the amount is valid unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages pursuant to subdivision (e).
(4)Subdivision (d) shall not apply to any dispute regarding the reasonableness of any amount retained as liquidated damages pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)Notwithstanding the time periods regarding the performance of the accounting set forth in paragraph (1), if a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase the residential property in question, the seller shall perform the accounting within 60 calendar days after a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase.
(6)As used in this subdivision, structure means either of the following:
(A)Improvements constructed on a common foundation.
(B)Improvements constructed by the same owner that must be constructed concurrently due to the design characteristics of the improvements or physical characteristics of the property on which the improvements are located.
(7)As used in this subdivision, new qualified buyer means a buyer who either:
(A)Has been issued a loan commitment, which satisfies the purchase agreement loan contingency requirement, by an institutional lender to obtain a loan for an amount equal to the purchase price less any downpayment possessed by the buyer.
(B)Has contracted to pay a purchase price that is greater than or equal to the purchase price to be paid by the original buyer.
(a)As used in this section, residential property means real property primarily consisting of a dwelling that meets both of the following requirements:
(1)The dwelling contains not more than four residential units.
(2)At the time the contract to purchase and sell the property is made, the buyer intends to occupy the dwelling or one of its units as his or her the buyers residence.
(b)A provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer shall constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the requirements of Sections 1677 and 1678 and either subdivision (c) or (d) of this section.
(c)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 3 10 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.
(d)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 10 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.
(e)For the purposes of subdivisions (c) and (d), the reasonableness of an amount actually paid as liquidated damages shall be determined by taking into account both of the following:
(1)The circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.
(2)The price and other terms and circumstances of any subsequent sale or contract to sell and purchase the same property if the sale or contract is made within six months of the buyers default.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding either subdivision (c) or (d), for the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units, as defined pursuant to Section 783, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units and the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 10 percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction both of the following shall occur in the event of a buyers default:
(A)The seller shall perform an accounting of its costs and revenues related to and fairly allocable to the construction and sale of the residential unit within 60 calendar days after the final close of escrow of the sale of the unit within the structure.
(B)The accounting shall include any and all costs and revenues related to the construction and sale of the residential property and any delay caused by the buyers default. The seller shall make reasonable efforts to mitigate any damages arising from the default. The seller shall refund to the buyer any amounts previously retained as liquidated damages in excess of the greater of either 3 10 percent of the originally agreed-upon purchase price of the residential property or the amount of the sellers losses resulting from the buyers default, as calculated by the accounting.
(2)The refund shall be sent to the buyers last known address within 90 days after the final close of escrow of the sale or lease of all the residential condominium units within the structure.
(3)If the amount retained by the seller after the accounting does not exceed 3 10 percent of the purchase price, the amount is valid unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages pursuant to subdivision (e).
(4)Subdivision (d) shall not apply to any dispute regarding the reasonableness of any amount retained as liquidated damages pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)Notwithstanding the time periods regarding the performance of the accounting set forth in paragraph (1), if a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase the residential property in question, the seller shall perform the accounting within 60 calendar days after a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase.
(6)As used in this subdivision, structure means either of the following:
(A)Improvements constructed on a common foundation.
(B)Improvements constructed by the same owner that must be constructed concurrently due to the design characteristics of the improvements or physical characteristics of the property on which the improvements are located.
(7)As used in this subdivision, new qualified buyer means a buyer who either:
(A)Has been issued a loan commitment, which satisfies the purchase agreement loan contingency requirement, by an institutional lender to obtain a loan for an amount equal to the purchase price less any downpayment possessed by the buyer.
(B)Has contracted to pay a purchase price that is greater than or equal to the purchase price to be paid by the original buyer.
(g)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2014.SECTION 1.Section 11013.7 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:11013.7.(a)Subject to the conditions set forth in this section, a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing to pay for project construction costs, including, in the case of a conversion, for any repair necessary to cure a violation of any county zoning and building ordinance and code, for architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and for any other incidental expenses of the project.(b)The disbursement of a purchasers deposit before closing may be permitted only if all of the following conditions are met:(1)The Department of Real Estate has issued an effective date for the developers preliminary public report for the project.(2)The developer has recorded the projects declaration and bylaws.(3)The developer has submitted to the Department of Real Estate both of the following:(A)A project budget showing all costs that are required to be paid in order to complete the project, including lease payments, real property taxes, construction costs, architectural, engineering, and legal fees, and financing costs.(B)Evidence satisfactory to the Department of Real Estate of the availability of sufficient funds to pay all costs required to be paid in order to complete the project. Those funds may include purchaser funds, equity funds, interim or permanent loan commitments, and other sources of funds.(4)The Department of Real Estate has reviewed and approved the proposed disbursement, as required pursuant to subdivision (g).(5)The purchaser provides express informed consent to the disbursement, as required pursuant to subdivision (f).(c)If a purchasers funds are to be disbursed before the completion of construction of the project, the developer shall submit to the Department of Real Estate all of the following:(1)A copy of the executed construction contract.(2)A copy of the building permit for the project.(3)(A)Satisfactory evidence of security for the completion of construction, which evidence may include any of the following, in forms and content approved by the Department of Real Estate:(i)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety licensed in this state in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction or percent of construction remaining.(ii)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety or other qualified financial institution in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction.(iii)An irrevocable letter of credit issued by a federally insured financial institution in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction.(iv)Other substantially similar instrument, guaranty, or security approved by the Department of Real Estate.(B)(i)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety or other qualified financial institution, an irrevocable letter of credit, and any alternatives shall contain a provision that the Department of Real Estate shall be notified in writing before any payment is made to beneficiaries of the bond.(ii)Adequate disclosures shall be made in the developers preliminary and final public report concerning the developers use of a completion or performance bond issued by a qualified financial institution instead of a surety, and the impact of any restrictions on the developers use of purchasers funds.(4)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent, as described in subdivision (f), to the use of their deposit funds for the purposes described in subdivision (a).(d)(1)A purchasers deposit may be disbursed before closing only to pay any cost set forth in the project budget submitted pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) that is approved for payment by the project lender or an otherwise qualified, financially disinterested person.(2)A purchasers deposit may be disbursed before closing to pay construction costs of the material and work completed by the contractor, as certified by a licensed architect or engineer.(e)If a purchasers deposit is to be disbursed before closing, the following notice shall be prominently displayed in the developers preliminary and final public report for the project:Important Notice Regarding Your Deposits: Deposits that you make under your sales contract for the purchase of the unit may be disbursed, with your consent, before closing of your purchase to pay for project costs, construction costs, project architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and other incidental expenses of the project. While the developer has submitted satisfactory evidence that the project should be completed, it is possible that the project may not be completed. If your deposits are disbursed to pay project costs and the project is not completed, there is a risk that your deposits will not be refunded to you. Additionally, if your deposit is disbursed before close, and you back out of the sale or fail to complete the purchase, the developer may be allowed to keep your entire deposit pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1675 of the Civil Code. You should carefully consider this risk in deciding whether to consent to disbursement of the deposit.(f)(1)A purchasers deposit may only be disbursed before closing if the purchaser provides the developer express informed consent for the disbursement and use of the escrow funds for specified construction costs. Sufficient express informed consent requires both of the following:(A)The developer provides the purchaser with the following at the time of requesting the purchasers express informed consent:(i)The disclosures described in subdivision (e).(ii)Satisfactory evidence of the security for the completion of construction that the developer will use to ensure completion of the project or reimbursement of the deposit to the purchaser, as required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (c).(B)The purchaser provides consent, in writing, confirming that they have received the information described above, reviewed that information, and consent to disbursement of the deposit to cover the construction costs outlined in the project budget.(2)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent shall be provided to the Department of Real Estate, as required pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c), and to the appropriate escrow agent, before funds may be disbursed. (g)The Department of Real Estate shall complete a review required by this section within 30 days of receipt of the document to be reviewed.(h)The Department of Real Estate may charge a fee to complete a review required by this section, but the fee shall not exceed the reasonable costs of conducting the review.(i)If the purchaser, after making a deposit described in this section, is unable to close at the time of completion of the project and requires a refund of the deposit, the purchaser shall be refunded the full deposit, less 5 percent if the purchaser becomes insolvent because of bankruptcy or death of the purchaser or spouse. The burden of proof of the inability to close shall be on the purchaser.(j)This section does not limit or otherwise alter the alternatives to depositing purchaser funds into an escrow depository under Sections 11013.2 and 11013.4, including the right to furnish a bond to the commissioner.SEC. 2.Section 1675 of the Civil Code is amended to read:1675.(a)As used in this section, residential property means real property primarily consisting of a dwelling that meets both of the following requirements:(1)The dwelling contains not more than four residential units.(2)At the time the contract to purchase and sell the property is made, the buyer intends to occupy the dwelling or one of its units as the buyers residence.(b)A provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer shall constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the requirements of Sections 1677 and 1678 and either subdivision (c) or (d) of this section.(c)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.(d)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.(e)For the purposes of subdivisions (c) and (d), the reasonableness of an amount actually paid as liquidated damages shall be determined by taking into account both of the following:(1)The circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.(2)The price and other terms and circumstances of any subsequent sale or contract to sell and purchase the same property if the sale or contract is made within six months of the buyers default.(f)(1)Notwithstanding either subdivision (c) or (d), for the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units, as defined pursuant to Section 783, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units and the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction both of the following shall occur in the event of a buyers default:(A)The seller shall perform an accounting of its costs and revenues related to and fairly allocable to the construction and sale of the residential unit within 60 calendar days after the final close of escrow of the sale of the unit within the structure.(B)The accounting shall include any and all costs and revenues related to the construction and sale of the residential property and any delay caused by the buyers default. The seller shall make reasonable efforts to mitigate any damages arising from the default. The seller shall refund to the buyer any amounts previously retained as liquidated damages in excess of the greater of either 3 percent of the originally agreed-upon purchase price of the residential property or the amount of the sellers losses resulting from the buyers default, as calculated by the accounting.(2)The refund shall be sent to the buyers last known address within 90 days after the final close of escrow of the sale or lease of all the residential condominium units within the structure.(3)If the amount retained by the seller after the accounting does not exceed 3 percent of the purchase price, the amount is valid unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages pursuant to subdivision (e).(4)Subdivision (d) shall not apply to any dispute regarding the reasonableness of any amount retained as liquidated damages pursuant to this subdivision.(5)Notwithstanding the time periods regarding the performance of the accounting set forth in paragraph (1), if a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase the residential property in question, the seller shall perform the accounting within 60 calendar days after a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase.(6)As used in this subdivision, structure means either of the following:(A)Improvements constructed on a common foundation.(B)Improvements constructed by the same owner that must be constructed concurrently due to the design characteristics of the improvements or physical characteristics of the property on which the improvements are located.(7)As used in this subdivision, new qualified buyer means a buyer who either:(A)Has been issued a loan commitment, which satisfies the purchase agreement loan contingency requirement, by an institutional lender to obtain a loan for an amount equal to the purchase price less any downpayment possessed by the buyer.(B)Has contracted to pay a purchase price that is greater than or equal to the purchase price to be paid by the original buyer.(g)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) or (d), and subject to the requirements of paragraph (2), a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing to pay for any of the following:(A)Project construction costs.(B)In the case of the conversion of an existing structure, for any repair necessary to cure a violation of any county zoning and building ordinance or code.(C)Architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees.(D)Construction costs of the material and work completed by the contractor, as certified by a licensed architect or engineer.(E)Incidental expenses of the project.(2)A purchasers deposit, in an amount that is equal to or exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price, that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing if all of the following conditions are met:(A)The developer complies with Sections 11013.1, 11013.2, 11013.4, and 11018.5 of the Business and Professions Code.(B)The developer has recorded the projects declaration and bylaws.(C)The Department of Real Estate has approved the developers final public report for the project and adequate disclosures are made therein concerning the developers use of bond for the benefits and protection of purchasers of the lots or parcels which provides for the return of a deposit by any purchaser issued by a qualified financial institution, instead of a surety, if applicable, and the impact of any restrictions on the developers use of the purchasers funds. The developers final public report shall also prominently display the notice described in subclause (I) of clause (ii) of subparagraph (E).(D)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent, as described in subparagraph (E), to the use of their deposit funds to cover costs described in paragraph (1) is provided to the appropriate escrow agent.(E)(i)The purchaser has given their express informed consent, in writing, confirming that they have received the information described in clause (ii), reviewed that information, and consent to disbursement of the deposit to cover the specified construction costs described in paragraph (1).(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, express informed consent requires that both of following occur:(I)The developer provides the purchaser with the following notice when they request the purchasers express informed consent:Important Notice Regarding Your Deposits: Deposits that you make under your sales contract for the purchase of the unit may be disbursed, with your consent, before closing of your purchase to pay for project costs, construction costs, project architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and other incidental expenses of the project. While the developer has submitted satisfactory evidence that the project should be completed, it is possible that the project may not be completed. If your deposits are disbursed to pay project costs and the project is not completed, there is a risk that your deposits will not be refunded to you. Additionally, if your deposit is disbursed before close, and you back out of the sale or fail to complete the purchase, the developer may be allowed to keep your entire deposit pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1675 of the Civil Code. You should carefully consider this risk in deciding whether to consent to disbursement of the deposit.(II)The developer provides the purchaser with satisfactory evidence of the security for the completion of construction that the seller will use to ensure completion of the project or reimbursement of the deposit to the purchaser.(3)If the purchaser, after making a deposit described in this section, is unable to close at the time of completion of the project and requires a refund of the deposit, then the purchaser shall be refunded the full deposit, less 5 percent if the purchaser becomes insolvent because of bankruptcy or death of the purchaser or spouse. The burden of proof of the inability to close shall be on the purchaser.(h)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) or (d), the amount actually paid pursuant to a liquidated damages provision may exceed 3 percent of the purchase price if the conditions set forth in subdivision (g) are satisfied, in which case the liquidated damages shall equal the amount of the deposit.(i)Subdivision (g) does not limit or otherwise alter the alternatives to depositing purchaser funds into an escrow depository under Sections 11013.2 and 11013.4 of the Business and Professions Code, including the right to furnish a bond to the commissioner.(a)Subject to the conditions set forth in this section, a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing to pay for project construction costs, including, in the case of a conversion, for any repair necessary to cure a violation of any county zoning and building ordinance and code, for architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and for any other incidental expenses of the project.
(b)The disbursement of a purchasers deposit before closing may be permitted only if all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The Department of Real Estate has issued an effective date for the developers preliminary public report for the project.
(2)The developer has recorded the projects declaration and bylaws.
(3)The developer has submitted to the Department of Real Estate both of the following:
(A)A project budget showing all costs that are required to be paid in order to complete the project, including lease payments, real property taxes, construction costs, architectural, engineering, and legal fees, and financing costs.
(B)Evidence satisfactory to the Department of Real Estate of the availability of sufficient funds to pay all costs required to be paid in order to complete the project. Those funds may include purchaser funds, equity funds, interim or permanent loan commitments, and other sources of funds.
(4)The Department of Real Estate has reviewed and approved the proposed disbursement, as required pursuant to subdivision (g).
(5)The purchaser provides express informed consent to the disbursement, as required pursuant to subdivision (f).
(c)If a purchasers funds are to be disbursed before the completion of construction of the project, the developer shall submit to the Department of Real Estate all of the following:
(1)A copy of the executed construction contract.
(2)A copy of the building permit for the project.
(3)(A)Satisfactory evidence of security for the completion of construction, which evidence may include any of the following, in forms and content approved by the Department of Real Estate:
(i)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety licensed in this state in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction or percent of construction remaining.
(ii)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety or other qualified financial institution in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction.
(iii)An irrevocable letter of credit issued by a federally insured financial institution in an amount equal to 100 percent of the cost of construction.
(iv)Other substantially similar instrument, guaranty, or security approved by the Department of Real Estate.
(B)(i)A completion or performance bond issued by a surety or other qualified financial institution, an irrevocable letter of credit, and any alternatives shall contain a provision that the Department of Real Estate shall be notified in writing before any payment is made to beneficiaries of the bond.
(ii)Adequate disclosures shall be made in the developers preliminary and final public report concerning the developers use of a completion or performance bond issued by a qualified financial institution instead of a surety, and the impact of any restrictions on the developers use of purchasers funds.
(4)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent, as described in subdivision (f), to the use of their deposit funds for the purposes described in subdivision (a).
(d)(1)A purchasers deposit may be disbursed before closing only to pay any cost set forth in the project budget submitted pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) that is approved for payment by the project lender or an otherwise qualified, financially disinterested person.
(2)A purchasers deposit may be disbursed before closing to pay construction costs of the material and work completed by the contractor, as certified by a licensed architect or engineer.
(e)If a purchasers deposit is to be disbursed before closing, the following notice shall be prominently displayed in the developers preliminary and final public report for the project:
Important Notice Regarding Your Deposits: Deposits that you make under your sales contract for the purchase of the unit may be disbursed, with your consent, before closing of your purchase to pay for project costs, construction costs, project architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and other incidental expenses of the project. While the developer has submitted satisfactory evidence that the project should be completed, it is possible that the project may not be completed. If your deposits are disbursed to pay project costs and the project is not completed, there is a risk that your deposits will not be refunded to you. Additionally, if your deposit is disbursed before close, and you back out of the sale or fail to complete the purchase, the developer may be allowed to keep your entire deposit pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1675 of the Civil Code. You should carefully consider this risk in deciding whether to consent to disbursement of the deposit.
(f)(1)A purchasers deposit may only be disbursed before closing if the purchaser provides the developer express informed consent for the disbursement and use of the escrow funds for specified construction costs. Sufficient express informed consent requires both of the following:
(A)The developer provides the purchaser with the following at the time of requesting the purchasers express informed consent:
(i)The disclosures described in subdivision (e).
(ii)Satisfactory evidence of the security for the completion of construction that the developer will use to ensure completion of the project or reimbursement of the deposit to the purchaser, as required pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (c).
(B)The purchaser provides consent, in writing, confirming that they have received the information described above, reviewed that information, and consent to disbursement of the deposit to cover the construction costs outlined in the project budget.
(2)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent shall be provided to the Department of Real Estate, as required pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c), and to the appropriate escrow agent, before funds may be disbursed.
(g)The Department of Real Estate shall complete a review required by this section within 30 days of receipt of the document to be reviewed.
(h)The Department of Real Estate may charge a fee to complete a review required by this section, but the fee shall not exceed the reasonable costs of conducting the review.
(i)If the purchaser, after making a deposit described in this section, is unable to close at the time of completion of the project and requires a refund of the deposit, the purchaser shall be refunded the full deposit, less 5 percent if the purchaser becomes insolvent because of bankruptcy or death of the purchaser or spouse. The burden of proof of the inability to close shall be on the purchaser.
(j)This section does not limit or otherwise alter the alternatives to depositing purchaser funds into an escrow depository under Sections 11013.2 and 11013.4, including the right to furnish a bond to the commissioner.
SEC. 2.Section 1675 of the Civil Code is amended to read:1675.(a)As used in this section, residential property means real property primarily consisting of a dwelling that meets both of the following requirements:
(1)The dwelling contains not more than four residential units.
(2)At the time the contract to purchase and sell the property is made, the buyer intends to occupy the dwelling or one of its units as his or her the buyers residence.
(b)A provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer shall constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyers failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the requirements of Sections 1677 and 1678 and either subdivision (c) or (d) of this section.
(c)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.
(d)If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.
(e)For the purposes of subdivisions (c) and (d), the reasonableness of an amount actually paid as liquidated damages shall be determined by taking into account both of the following:
(1)The circumstances existing at the time the contract was made.
(2)The price and other terms and circumstances of any subsequent sale or contract to sell and purchase the same property if the sale or contract is made within six months of the buyers default.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding either subdivision (c) or (d), for the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units, as defined pursuant to Section 783, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units and the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction both of the following shall occur in the event of a buyers default:
(A)The seller shall perform an accounting of its costs and revenues related to and fairly allocable to the construction and sale of the residential unit within 60 calendar days after the final close of escrow of the sale of the unit within the structure.
(B)The accounting shall include any and all costs and revenues related to the construction and sale of the residential property and any delay caused by the buyers default. The seller shall make reasonable efforts to mitigate any damages arising from the default. The seller shall refund to the buyer any amounts previously retained as liquidated damages in excess of the greater of either 3 percent of the originally agreed-upon purchase price of the residential property or the amount of the sellers losses resulting from the buyers default, as calculated by the accounting.
(2)The refund shall be sent to the buyers last known address within 90 days after the final close of escrow of the sale or lease of all the residential condominium units within the structure.
(3)If the amount retained by the seller after the accounting does not exceed 3 percent of the purchase price, the amount is valid unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages pursuant to subdivision (e).
(4)Subdivision (d) shall not apply to any dispute regarding the reasonableness of any amount retained as liquidated damages pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)Notwithstanding the time periods regarding the performance of the accounting set forth in paragraph (1), if a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase the residential property in question, the seller shall perform the accounting within 60 calendar days after a new qualified buyer has entered into a contract to purchase.
(6)As used in this subdivision, structure means either of the following:
(A)Improvements constructed on a common foundation.
(B)Improvements constructed by the same owner that must be constructed concurrently due to the design characteristics of the improvements or physical characteristics of the property on which the improvements are located.
(7)As used in this subdivision, new qualified buyer means a buyer who either:
(A)Has been issued a loan commitment, which satisfies the purchase agreement loan contingency requirement, by an institutional lender to obtain a loan for an amount equal to the purchase price less any downpayment possessed by the buyer.
(B)Has contracted to pay a purchase price that is greater than or equal to the purchase price to be paid by the original buyer.
(g) This section shall become operative on July 1, 2014.(g)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) or (d), and subject to the requirements of paragraph (2), a purchasers deposit that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing to pay for any of the following:
(A)Project construction costs.
(B)In the case of the conversion of an existing structure, for any repair necessary to cure a violation of any county zoning and building ordinance or code.
(C)Architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees.
(D)Construction costs of the material and work completed by the contractor, as certified by a licensed architect or engineer.
(E)Incidental expenses of the project.
(2)A purchasers deposit, in an amount that is equal to or exceeds 3 percent of the purchase price, that is held in escrow pursuant to a binding sales contract for a lot or parcel within a subdivision that is not yet constructed or developed may be disbursed before closing if all of the following conditions are met:
(A)The developer complies with Sections 11013.1, 11013.2, 11013.4, and 11018.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(B)The developer has recorded the projects declaration and bylaws.
(C)The Department of Real Estate has approved the developers final public report for the project and adequate disclosures are made therein concerning the developers use of bond for the benefits and protection of purchasers of the lots or parcels which provides for the return of a deposit by any purchaser issued by a qualified financial institution, instead of a surety, if applicable, and the impact of any restrictions on the developers use of the purchasers funds. The developers final public report shall also prominently display the notice described in subclause (I) of clause (ii) of subparagraph (E).
(D)A copy of the purchasers express informed consent, as described in subparagraph (E), to the use of their deposit funds to cover costs described in paragraph (1) is provided to the appropriate escrow agent.
(E)(i)The purchaser has given their express informed consent, in writing, confirming that they have received the information described in clause (ii), reviewed that information, and consent to disbursement of the deposit to cover the specified construction costs described in paragraph (1).
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, express informed consent requires that both of following occur:
(I)The developer provides the purchaser with the following notice when they request the purchasers express informed consent:
Important Notice Regarding Your Deposits: Deposits that you make under your sales contract for the purchase of the unit may be disbursed, with your consent, before closing of your purchase to pay for project costs, construction costs, project architectural, engineering, finance, and legal fees, and other incidental expenses of the project. While the developer has submitted satisfactory evidence that the project should be completed, it is possible that the project may not be completed. If your deposits are disbursed to pay project costs and the project is not completed, there is a risk that your deposits will not be refunded to you. Additionally, if your deposit is disbursed before close, and you back out of the sale or fail to complete the purchase, the developer may be allowed to keep your entire deposit pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1675 of the Civil Code. You should carefully consider this risk in deciding whether to consent to disbursement of the deposit.
(II)The developer provides the purchaser with satisfactory evidence of the security for the completion of construction that the seller will use to ensure completion of the project or reimbursement of the deposit to the purchaser.
(3)If the purchaser, after making a deposit described in this section, is unable to close at the time of completion of the project and requires a refund of the deposit, then the purchaser shall be refunded the full deposit, less 5 percent if the purchaser becomes insolvent because of bankruptcy or death of the purchaser or spouse. The burden of proof of the inability to close shall be on the purchaser.
(h)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) or (d), the amount actually paid pursuant to a liquidated damages provision may exceed 3 percent of the purchase price if the conditions set forth in subdivision (g) are satisfied, in which case the liquidated damages shall equal the amount of the deposit.
(i)Subdivision (g) does not limit or otherwise alter the alternatives to depositing purchaser funds into an escrow depository under Sections 11013.2 and 11013.4 of the Business and Professions Code, including the right to furnish a bond to the commissioner.
SECTION 1.Section 7531 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:7531.A licensee shall at all times be legally responsible for the good conduct in the business of each of their employees or agents, including their qualified manager.A licensee shall at all times be legally responsible for the good conduct in the business of each of his or her their employees or agents, including his or her their qualified manager.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 29, 2026 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 6, 2026 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 29, 2026 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 29, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 41. Noes 15. Page 3880.) |
| Jan 22, 2026 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 3816.) |
| Jan 15, 2026 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 14, 2026 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Jan 13, 2026 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (January 13). |
| Jan 6, 2026 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 5, 2026 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 21, 2025 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 2, 2025 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 25, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 24, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 24, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and B. & P. |
| Feb 24, 2025 | Read first time. |
| Feb 22, 2025 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2025 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 29, 2026 | AB 1406 Ward Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 13, 2026 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Abundant Housing LA | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Council | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Coalition for Affordable Housing | ** Support | |
| California community builders | ** Support | |
| California Council For Affordable Housing | ** Support | |
| California Escrow Association | ** Against | |
| California Home Building Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Land Title Association | ** Against | |
| California YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Circulate San Diego | ** Support | |
| downtown sacramento partnership | ** Support | |
| Housing Action Coalition | ** Support | |
| Housing Trust Silicon Valley | ** Support | |
| Lighthouse Public Affairs LLC | ** Support | |
| Mayor Matt Mahan, City of San Jose | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association | ** Support | |
| The Two Hundred | ** Support |
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1406
Author:(Ward, et al.)
As Amended Ver:January 22, 2026
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Increases the permissible amount of liquidated damages that may be imposed on a buyer who breaches a contract for the purchase of a newly constructed condominium from three to six percent of the purchase price.
Major Provisions
- Provides that, for the initial sale of a newly constructed attached condominium unit, as defined, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of ten or more residential condominium units, the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision cannot exceed six percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction.
- Requires a seller to refund any retained liquidated damages in excess of six percent of the purchase price unless the buyer can demonstrate the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages, as specified.
COMMENTS
There is little question that finding an affordable home is growing increasingly difficult for many Californians. A 2022 report by the state Department of Housing and Community Development noted that the state needs to produce approximately 2.5 million housing units over the next eight years, with roughly one million of those units being set aside for lower income households, in order to meet the anticipated demand for housing over the same time period. (Dept. of Housing and Community Development, California Statewide Housing Plan: A Home for Every Californian (Mar. 2022) available at: https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/94729ab1648d43b1811c1698a748c136.) However, as a result of persistently high interest rates in recent years, many housing developers are now noting that obtaining adequate financing to construct new homes is becoming increasingly difficult. This is especially true for condominium development which, unlike single family homes projects that can be built in phases, must obtaining funding for the entire project upfront.
The author and proponents of this measure note that one of the main obstacles to obtaining funding for condominium development is the fact that the developer must demonstrate sufficient and legitimate interest from buyers. One means of demonstrating such interest is to obtain security deposits from would-be buyers to indicate that the eventual sale of the condominium units will be sufficient to repay construction loans. The proponents of this measure note that the existing security deposit limits are no longer sufficient to satisfy many lenders. Thus this bill would increase the amount of a deposit a developer may retain if a buyer backs out of a purchase agreement from three to six percent of the purchase price.
The Subdivided Lands Act guides the purchase of newly constructed properties in California. Broadly speaking, there are two primary types of homes available for purchase in California: single-family homes and multifamily developments. Although new developments of both types of homes are typically governed by a homeowner association, single family homes are standalone units that developers can build in phases to meet financing needs and projected sales. Conversely, multifamily housing developments including condominiums, townhomes, stock cooperatives, limited-equity housing cooperatives, and other similar types of dwellings are frequently joined together in one physical structure. Given the unitary structure, these developments must be built at the same time, regardless of sales demand. These types of dwellings are typically considered a subdivision, which California law defines as improved or unimproved land that is divided or proposed to be divided for sale, lease, or financing into five or more lots or parcels. (Business and Professions Code Section 11000, 11004.5.) Seeking to protect would-be purchasers of subdivided interests from fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, the Subdivided Lands Act adopts an extensive series of consumer protections. Most notably, the Act requires a developer seeking to sell subdivided properties to obtain a subdivision public report from the Department of Real Estate prior to offering any property for sale. The Department′s public report includes information and disclosures regarding the subdivision and the developer′s commitments regarding facilities and improvements for the subdivision. A developer of the subdivision must meet certain requirements and provide documentation of sufficient financial arrangements for the completion of the improvements and facilities that will be included in the subdivision.
Additional protections for buyers can be found in both the Civil Code and the Subdivided Lands Act′s requirements that many downpayments or deposits provided by a buyer in advance of a final purchase of a newly constructed property must remain in an escrow account managed by a neutral third party. The role of the escrow account is to ensure that the buyer has a stake in completing the purchase while simultaneously protecting the deposit should the developer be unable to complete a project. Under the existing law, unless the developer follows existing procedures and obtains permission from the Department of Real Estate, the escrow money cannot be utilized to fund construction of the project. Nonetheless, the existence of the escrow money is a critical component of loan applications utilized by developers to borrow the funds necessary to finance the development.
California maintains one of the lowest permissible liquidated damage levels in the nation when buyers breach property sale agreements. Under existing law (Civil Code Section 1675), California law caps the amount of liquidated damages a property seller may recoup from a defaulting buyer at three percent of the purchase price. The author and proponents of this bill note that this is significantly less than many other states, including other large, urbanized states like New York or Washington. For example, a combination of case law and statutory provisions in the State of New York, of which condominiums make up a comparatively large share of the housing stock, maintains a ten percent cap on liquidated damages for breaching buyers. (NY-RPP Chap. 50, Art. 9-b et seq.) Despite the statutory provisions, however, New York state case law prohibits the developer from recovering the full ten percent if the liquidated damages are sought to punish buyers and not reimburse sellers (Atlantis Management Group II LLC v. Nabe (2023) N.Y. Slip Op. 02737). Notably, California case law has established a similar prohibition on punitive liquidated damages provisions in real estate contracts. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc. (1993) 13 Cal.App.4th 949.)
This bill would increase the liquidated damage caps for downpayments on new condominiums only. Seeking to align California law with the laws of other large states, this bill would increase the liquidated damage cap imposed on buyers breaching property sale contracts for the purchase of new condominiums from three percent of the purchase price to six percent of the purchase price. The bill maintains the existing law′s requirement that the money be held in escrow and similarly maintains the law′s general prohibition on the use of such funds to finance construction and other related costs. Additionally, as proposed to be amended, this bill does not impact any single family home sales, for new or existing properties, and this bill does not apply to the sale of existing condominiums. This bill only raises the liquidated damages cap on new constriction condominiums in order to provide developers and their lenders sufficient financial assurances in the event a buyer breaches a sales contract.
Although the opposition raises valid concerns, the scope of this bill is limited and market forces may negate many of the potential impacts. This bill, as currently in print and as proposed to be amended, is vociferously opposed by a coalition of stakeholders in the property sales industry. Writing jointly in opposition, the California Association of Realtors and the California Land Title Association argue the bill, ″will expose homebuyers to extraordinary financial risk while serving to dismantle strong consumer safeguards enacted specifically to protect California homebuyers.″ They also argue the bill does, ″nothing to address the home affordability crisis and in fact likely put the dream of homeownership more at risk as buyers could lose so much money in one transaction they could be forced out of the market for years.″
The opposition is certainly correct in noting that the bill does expose a larger percentage of a downpayment to loss should a buyer breach a sales contract. However, it should be noted that, as proposed to be amended, this bill only make such an adjustment to a relatively small portion of California′s housing market. Indeed, based on current trends, by limiting this bill to new condominiums only, the measure impacts a part of the housing market typically found in large urban areas and purchased by affluent professionals. While this does not wholly relieve the risk that such an individual may lose a sizable security deposit, these buyers tend to be relatively sophisticated, capable of weighing the risk, and are more likely to be able to retain any professional services necessary to vindicate their rights. Additionally, the damage provisions are only triggered if the buyer defaults or otherwise violates their contractual obligations.
Furthermore, the bill does not require a liquidated damage level of six percent but simply permits such damages. Indeed, although existing law sets a three percent cap on liquidated damages, many real estate contracts presently do not impose the maximum level of damages. Moreover, should, as the opposition also contends, market forces prevent many Californians from being able to afford a six percent downpayment, condominium developers will have no choice but to apply lower liquidated damages in actual sales agreements if the developer actually wants to generate a market for the units. Nothing in the bill overrides the terms of a contract and nothing permits a developer to seek higher liquidated damages then originally agreed to in the sales contract. For example, if market conditions drive a developer to impose a five percent damage amount in contract, nothing in this bill authorizes the developer to subsequently seek additional damages should the seller breach the agreement. A final safeguard, as noted above, can be found in the case law interpreting Civil Code Section 1671 which prevents punitive liquidated damages provisions. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc., supra.) While the opposition is correct that invoking these provisions of law is likely to require the employment of legal counsel and the potential for litigation, beyond raising the permissible level of non-punitive liquidated damages, nothing in this bill changes the existing statutory or common law protections for potential condominium buyers.
This bill remains a work in progress. The original version of this measure was substantially broader than the current version of the bill. Indeed, that version of the bill contained provisions that significantly undermined existing consumer protections, most notably the elimination of the escrow provisions that prevented a developer from accessing a buyer′s downpayment to pay for construction costs. The author and the Judiciary Committee agreed to significantly narrow the bill to only include the increased liquidated damages provisions and to restore all other existing consumer protections. Unfortunately, as discussed above, these significant amendments did not ameliorate the opposition′s concerns. Nonetheless, the author is committing to ongoing engagement with all stakeholders to achieve their mutual goal of spurring much needed housing development while protecting everyday Californians. The Judiciary Committee will continue to monitor these discussions, and as always, reserves the right to recall the bill for additional consideration should existing consumer protections not be maintained. Nonetheless, the bill appears to strike an appropriate balance between spurring new housing construction and protecting the hard-earned savings of prospective California homeowners.
According to the Author
As California embraces pro-housing and environmentally responsible policy, the share of multifamily housing in the state continues to grow. However, only a small fraction of this housing is available for purchase. Between 2011 and 2021, an estimated 3 percent of newly built housing in California consisted of multifamily condominiums. AB 1406 would align California with best practices from states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada, by raising the liquidated damages cap in current statue from 3% to 6%. This change would unlock financing for condo projects and increase the supply of more affordable, for sale housing.
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by a coalition of developers and affordable housing advocates under the umbrella of the California Home Building Alliance. A coalition letter from organizations that include the California Building Industry Association, the California Coalition for Affordable Housing, the San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association, and the Abundant Housing LA argue in support of the bill:
Condominiums have proven to be an effective path to affordable, entry-level homeownership for first-time buyers. California lags when compared to other states, like Hawaii and Washington, who produce condominiums at roughly ten times the annual rate in California. We have seen that this limited production significantly restricts pathways to homeownership especially in dense urban areas where land is scarce, and costs of single-family homes put them financially out of reach for most Californians. Additionally, despite significant growth in multifamily housing, very little of this new housing is available for ownership.
One major barrier we have identified is that in California, there is a de facto three percent earnest money deposit cap, requiring any funds over three percent to be fully refunded to the buyer if they decide to terminate the deal. AB 1406 would incentivize condominium development by increasing the existing liquidated damages cap from 3% of the sale price to 6%, aligning California with other states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada that have a higher cap. This change would reduce lender risk, unlock financing for condo projects, and increase the supply of more affordable, entry level for-sale housing.
Arguments in Opposition
As noted a coalition of property sales professionals including the California Association of Realtors oppose this measure. In opposition the coalition jointly argues:
California′s liquidated-damages framework for owner-occupant buyers exists to protect homebuyers from disproportionate financial loss. In Guthman v. Moss, 150 Cal. App. 3d 502 (1984), the Second District Court of Appeal held that ″…the purpose of enacting section 1675 et seq. was to protect buyers who fail to complete the purchase of real property and not sellers.″ The proposed language in AB 1406 (Ward) would turn that that purpose on its head by forcing buyers to forfeit unreasonable sums that bear little relationship to any actual harm.
At today′s statewide median home price of approximately $887,000, a 10-percent liquidated-damages provision would allow a seller to retain nearly $89,000 from a defaulting buyer, an amount that in most transactions bears no reasonable relationship to foreseeable damages. Liquidated damages are intended to substitute for proof of actual damages by setting a reasonable, good-faith estimate of what a seller is likely to lose if a buyer defaults, not to create a windfall untethered to real economic harm, but this proposal does just that.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 7-3-2
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Papan, Stefani
NO: Dixon, Macedo, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco, Zbur
UPDATED
VERSION: January 22, 2026
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002250
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1406
Author:(Ward, et al.)
As Amended Ver:January 5, 2026
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Increases the permissible amount of liquidated damages that may be imposed on a buyer who breaches a contract for the purchase of a newly constructed condominium from three to ten percent of the purchase price.
Major Provisions
- Provides that, for the initial sale of a newly constructed attached condominium unit, as defined, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of ten or more residential condominium units, the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision cannot exceed ten percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction.
- Requires a seller to refund any retained liquidated damages in excess of ten percent of the purchase price unless the buyer can demonstrate the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages, as specified.
COMMENTS
There is little question that finding an affordable home is growing increasingly difficult for many Californians. A 2022 report by the state Department of Housing and Community Development noted that the state needs to produce approximately 2.5 million housing units over the next eight years, with roughly one million of those units being set aside for lower income households, in order to meet the anticipated demand for housing over the same time period. (Dept. of Housing and Community Development, California Statewide Housing Plan: A Home for Every Californian (Mar. 2022) available at: https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/94729ab1648d43b1811c1698a748c136.) However, as a result of persistently high interest rates in recent years, many housing developers are now noting that obtaining adequate financing to construct new homes is becoming increasingly difficult. This is especially true for condominium development which, unlike single family homes projects that can be built in phases, must obtaining funding for the entire project upfront.
The author and proponents of this measure note that one of the main obstacles to obtaining funding for condominium development is the fact that the developer must demonstrate sufficient and legitimate interest from buyers. One means of demonstrating such interest is to obtain security deposits from would-be buyers to indicate that the eventual sale of the condominium units will be sufficient to repay construction loans. The proponents of this measure note that the existing security deposit limits are no longer sufficient to satisfy many lenders. Thus this bill would increase the amount of a deposit a developer may retain if a buyer backs out of a purchase agreement from three to ten percent of the purchase price.
The Subdivided Lands Act guides the purchase of newly constructed properties in California. Broadly speaking, there are two primary types of homes available for purchase in California: single-family homes and multifamily developments. Although new developments of both types of homes are typically governed by a homeowner association, single family homes are standalone units that developers can build in phases to meet financing needs and projected sales. Conversely, multifamily housing developments including condominiums, townhomes, stock cooperatives, limited-equity housing cooperatives, and other similar types of dwellings are frequently joined together in one physical structure. Given the unitary structure, these developments must be built at the same time, regardless of sales demand. These types of dwellings are typically considered a subdivision, which California law defines as improved or unimproved land that is divided or proposed to be divided for sale, lease, or financing into five or more lots or parcels. (Business and Professions Code Section 11000, 11004.5.) Seeking to protect would-be purchasers of subdivided interests from fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, the Subdivided Lands Act adopts an extensive series of consumer protections. Most notably, the Act requires a developer seeking to sell subdivided properties to obtain a subdivision public report from the Department of Real Estate prior to offering any property for sale. The Department’s public report includes information and disclosures regarding the subdivision and the developer’s commitments regarding facilities and improvements for the subdivision. A developer of the subdivision must meet certain requirements and provide documentation of sufficient financial arrangements for the completion of the improvements and facilities that will be included in the subdivision.
Additional protections for buyers can be found in both the Civil Code and the Subdivided Lands Act’s requirements that many downpayments or deposits provided by a buyer in advance of a final purchase of a newly constructed property must remain in an escrow account managed by a neutral third party. The role of the escrow account is to ensure that the buyer has a stake in completing the purchase while simultaneously protecting the deposit should the developer be unable to complete a project. Under the existing law, unless the developer follows existing procedures and obtains permission from the Department of Real Estate, the escrow money cannot be utilized to fund construction of the project. Nonetheless, the existence of the escrow money is a critical component of loan applications utilized by developers to borrow the funds necessary to finance the development.
California maintains one of the lowest permissible liquidated damage levels in the nation when buyers breach property sale agreements. Under existing law (Civil Code Section 1675), California law caps the amount of liquidated damages a property seller may recoup from a defaulting buyer at three percent of the purchase price. The author and proponents of this bill note that this is significantly less than many other states, including other large, urbanized states like New York or Washington. For example, a combination of case law and statutory provisions in the State of New York, of which condominiums make up a comparatively large share of the housing stock, maintains a ten percent cap on liquidated damages for breaching buyers. (NY-RPP Chap. 50, Art. 9-b et seq.) Despite the statutory provisions, however, New York state case law prohibits the developer from recovering the full ten percent if the liquidated damages are sought to punish buyers and not reimburse sellers (Atlantis Management Group II LLC v. Nabe (2023) N.Y. Slip Op. 02737). Notably, California case law has established a similar prohibition on punitive liquidated damages provisions in real estate contracts. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc. (1993) 13 Cal.App.4th 949.)
This bill would increase the liquidated damage caps for downpayments on new condominiums only. Seeking to align California law with the laws of other large states, this bill would increase the liquidated damage cap imposed on buyers breaching property sale contracts for the purchase of new condominiums from three percent of the purchase price to ten percent of the purchase price. The bill maintains the existing law’s requirement that the money be held in escrow and similarly maintains the law’s general prohibition on the use of such funds to finance construction and other related costs. Additionally, as proposed to be amended, this bill does not impact any single family home sales, for new or existing properties, and this bill does not apply to the sale of existing condominiums. This bill only raises the liquidated damages cap on new constriction condominiums in order to provide developers and their lenders sufficient financial assurances in the event a buyer breaches a sales contract.
Although the opposition raises valid concerns, the scope of this bill is limited and market forces may negate many of the potential impacts. This bill, as currently in print and as proposed to be amended, is vociferously opposed by a coalition of stakeholders in the property sales industry. Writing jointly in opposition, the California Association of Realtors and the California Land Title Association argue the bill, “will expose homebuyers to extraordinary financial risk while serving to dismantle strong consumer safeguards enacted specifically to protect California homebuyers.” They also argue the bill does, “nothing to address the home affordability crisis and in fact likely put the dream of homeownership more at risk as buyers could lose so much money in one transaction they could be forced out of the market for years.”
The opposition is certainly correct in noting that the bill does expose a larger percentage of a downpayment to loss should a buyer breach a sales contract. However, it should be noted that, as proposed to be amended, this bill only make such an adjustment to a relatively small portion of California’s housing market. Indeed, based on current trends, by limiting this bill to new condominiums only, the measure impacts a part of the housing market typically found in large urban areas and purchased by affluent professionals. While this does not wholly relieve the risk that such an individual may lose a sizable security deposit, these buyers tend to be relatively sophisticated, capable of weighing the risk, and are more likely to be able to retain any professional services necessary to vindicate their rights. Additionally, the damage provisions are only triggered if the buyer defaults or otherwise violates their contractual obligations.
Furthermore, the bill does not require a liquidated damage level of ten percent but simply permits such damages. Indeed, although existing law sets a three percent cap on liquidated damages, many real estate contracts presently do not impose the maximum level of damages. Moreover, should, as the opposition also contends, market forces prevent many Californians from being able to afford a ten percent downpayment, condominium developers will have no choice but to apply lower liquidated damages in actual sales agreements if the developer actually wants to generate a market for the units. Nothing in the bill overrides the terms of a contract and nothing permits a developer to seek higher liquidated damages then originally agreed to in the sales contract. For example, if market conditions drive a developer to impose a five percent damage amount in contract, nothing in this bill authorizes the developer to subsequently seek additional damages should the seller breach the agreement. A final safeguard, as noted above, can be found in the case law interpreting Civil Code Section 1671 which prevents punitive liquidated damages provisions. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc., supra.) While the opposition is correct that invoking these provisions of law is likely to require the employment of legal counsel and the potential for litigation, beyond raising the permissible level of non-punitive liquidated damages, nothing in this bill changes the existing statutory or common law protections for potential condominium buyers.
This bill remains a work in progress. The original version of this measure was substantially broader than the current version of the bill. Indeed, that version of the bill contained provisions that significantly undermined existing consumer protections, most notably the elimination of the escrow provisions that prevented a developer from accessing a buyer’s downpayment to pay for construction costs. The author and the Judiciary Committee agreed to significantly narrow the bill to only include the increased liquidated damages provisions and to restore all other existing consumer protections. Unfortunately, as discussed above, these significant amendments did not ameliorate the opposition’s concerns. Nonetheless, the author is committing to ongoing engagement with all stakeholders to achieve their mutual goal of spurring much needed housing development while protecting everyday Californians. The Judiciary Committee will continue to monitor these discussions, and as always, reserves the right to recall the bill for additional consideration should existing consumer protections not be maintained. Nonetheless, the bill appears to strike an appropriate balance between spurring new housing construction and protecting the hard-earned savings of prospective California homeowners.
According to the Author
As California embraces pro-housing and environmentally responsible policy, the share of multifamily housing in the state continues to grow. However, only a small fraction of this housing is available for purchase. Between 2011 and 2021, an estimated 3 percent of newly built housing in California consisted of multifamily condominiums. AB 1406 would align California with best practices from states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada, by raising the liquidated damages cap in current statue from 3% to 10%. This change would unlock financing for condo projects and increase the supply of more affordable, for sale housing.
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by a coalition of developers and affordable housing advocates under the umbrella of the California Home Building Alliance. A coalition letter from organizations that include the California Building Industry Association, the California Coalition for Affordable Housing, the San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association, and the Abundant Housing LA argue in support of the bill:
Condominiums have proven to be an effective path to affordable, entry-level homeownership for first-time buyers. California lags when compared to other states, like Hawaii and Washington, who produce condominiums at roughly ten times the annual rate in California. We have seen that this limited production significantly restricts pathways to homeownership especially in dense urban areas where land is scarce, and costs of single-family homes put them financially out of reach for most Californians. Additionally, despite significant growth in multifamily housing, very little of this new housing is available for ownership.
One major barrier we have identified is that in California, there is a de facto three percent earnest money deposit cap, requiring any funds over three percent to be fully refunded to the buyer if they decide to terminate the deal. AB 1406 would incentivize condominium development by increasing the existing liquidated damages cap from 3% of the sale price to 10%, aligning California with other states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada that have a higher cap. This change would reduce lender risk, unlock financing for condo projects, and increase the supply of more affordable, entry level for-sale housing.
Arguments in Opposition
As noted a coalition of property sales professionals including the California Association of Realtors oppose this measure. In opposition the coalition jointly argues:
California’s liquidated-damages framework for owner-occupant buyers exists to protect homebuyers from disproportionate financial loss. In Guthman v. Moss, 150 Cal. App. 3d 502 (1984), the Second District Court of Appeal held that “…the purpose of enacting section 1675 et seq. was to protect buyers who fail to complete the purchase of real property and not sellers.” The proposed language in AB 1406 (Ward) would turn that that purpose on its head by forcing buyers to forfeit unreasonable sums that bear little relationship to any actual harm.
At today’s statewide median home price of approximately $887,000, a 10-percent liquidated-damages provision would allow a seller to retain nearly $89,000 from a defaulting buyer, an amount that in most transactions bears no reasonable relationship to foreseeable damages. Liquidated damages are intended to substitute for proof of actual damages by setting a reasonable, good-faith estimate of what a seller is likely to lose if a buyer defaults, not to create a windfall untethered to real economic harm, but this proposal does just that.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 7-3-2
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Papan, Stefani
NO: Dixon, Macedo, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco, Zbur
UPDATED
VERSION: January 5, 2026
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002209
Date of Hearing: January 13, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1406
Author:(Ward) – As Amended Ver:January 5, 2026
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Residential property contracts: liquidated damages
KEY ISSUE: should the statutorily established cap on liquidated damages imposed on buyers of newly constructed condominium who breach sales contracts be increased from three percent of the purchase price to ten?
SYNOPSIS
It is no secret that California continues to be mired in a housing affordability crisis. Nearly every stakeholder and advocate involved in home sales and construction agrees that this crisis is rooted in California’s decades-long failure to build sufficient housing units to meet the state’s population growth. However, that is about all stakeholders in the housing development and sales space agree upon. While many blame land use policies and local opposition to new construction for the crisis, others cite market conditions as the primary deterrence to new construction. Indeed, the stubbornly high interest rates of recent years has further complicated the housing crisis plaguing this state. Many developers now cite limited access to affordable construction capital as a primary factor deterring new housing starts. The author and proponents of this measure contend this issue is particularly acute for new condominium construction which requires significant capital when compared to single family home developments that can be constructed over an extended period of time.
Seeking to address the issues plaguing the condominium construction industry, this bill aims to provide condominium developers with additional financial guarantees in order to improve these developers’ odds of obtaining construction financing. As proposed to be amended, this bill would increase the amount of liquidated damages a developer can seek from a prospective buyer of a newly constructed condominium who breaches a home sale contract from three percent of the sales price to ten. This provision essentially permits a developer to pledge to a lender that they will be guaranteed up to ten percent of a potential unit’s cost should the buyer back out of the sale. The author and the housing developers that constitute the proponents of this measure hope that the increased monetary recovery in the event a would-be buyer breaches a sales contract provides the necessary financial guarantees to lenders to unlock the construction loans necessary to fund these critical housing projects.
This bill is stridently opposed by a coalition of property sales organizations, including the California Association of Realtors and the California Land Title Association. Although this measure does not impact the vast majority of existing law’s consumer protections, including strong escrow requirements and the prohibition on liquidated damages provisions being needlessly punitive, the opposition contends this bill significantly undermines consumer protections and puts condominium buyers at significant risk for financial losses.
Should this bill advance, it remains a work in progress and the author has committed to working with all stakeholders to find an amicable resolution that promotes condominium development and preserves consumer protections.
SUMMARY: Increases the permissible amount of liquidated damages that may be imposed on a buyer who breaches a contract for the purchase of a newly constructed condominium from three to ten percent of the purchase price. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, for the initial sale of a newly constructed attached condominium unit, as defined, that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of ten or more residential condominium units, the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision cannot exceed ten percent of the purchase price of the residential unit in the transaction.
- Requires a seller to refund any retained liquidated damages in excess of ten percent of the purchase price unless the buyer can demonstrate the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Department of Real Estate within the Business, Consumer Services and Housing Agency. (Business and Professions Code Section 10000 et seq.)
- Establishes the Subdivided Lands Act to regulate the sale of subdivided lands in California. (Business and Professions Code Section 11000 et seq.)
- Defines, pursuant to the Subdivided Lands Act, “subdivided lands” and “subdivision” as improved or unimproved land in California that is divided, or proposed to be divided, into five or more lots or parcels for sale, lease, or financing, with narrow exemptions. (Business and Professions Code Sections 11000 & 11000.1.)
- Defines “escrow” as any transaction in which one person, for the purpose of effecting the sale, transfer, encumbering, or leasing of real or personal property to another person, delivers any written instrument, money, evidence of title to real or personal property, or other thing of value to a third person to be held by that third person until the happening of a specified event or the performance of a prescribed condition, when it is then to be delivered by that third person to a grantee, grantor, promisee, promisor, obligee, obligor, bailee, bailor, or any agent or employee of any of the latter. (Financial Code Section 17003.)
- Provides that it is unlawful for an escrow agent to disburse or cause the disbursal of escrow funds other than in accordance with the Escrow Law. (Financial Code Section 17414(a).)
- Requires, pursuant to the Subdivided Lands Act, that any person intending to offer subdivided lands for sale or lease must file an application for a public report with the Department of Real Estate. (Business and Professions Code Section 11010.)
- Requires, upon receipt of an application pursuant to 6), the Department of Real Estate to issue the public report after examination of the subdivision, unless there are grounds for denial, as specified. (Business and Professions Code Section 11018.1.)
- Prohibits selling, leasing, or offering for sale or lease of any lot or parcel within a subdivision without obtaining a public report from the Department of Real Estate. (Business and Professions Code Section 11018.2.)
- Prohibits a subdivider, owner, or agent from selling or leasing lots or parcels in a subdivision when an encumbrance on the subdivision does not have a release clause, unless any of the following occur:
- The entire deposit advanced by the purchaser or lessee is deposited into an escrow account;
- The title to the subdivision is held in trust under an agreement of trust acceptable to the Commissioner of the Department of Real Estate, until a release from the encumbrance is obtained;
- A bond to the state is furnished to the Commissioner for the benefit and protection of purchasers or lessees of such lots or parcels, which shall provide for the return of the moneys paid or advanced by the purchaser or lessee; or
- There is conformance to such other alternative requirement or method which the Commissioner deems acceptable as provided. (Business and Professions Code Section 11013.2.)
- Defines “condominium” as an estate in real property that is an undivided interest in common in a portion of real property coupled with a separate interest in space called a unit, the boundaries of which are described on a recorded final map, parcel map, or condominium plan in sufficient detail to locate all boundaries thereof, as specified. (Civil Code Section 783.)
- Provides that a provision in a contract to purchase and sell residential property that provides that all or any part of a payment made by the buyer is to constitute liquidated damages to the seller upon the buyer’s failure to complete the purchase of the property is valid to the extent that payment in the form of cash or check, including a postdated check, is actually made if the provision satisfies the following requirements:
- The liquidated damages provision is separately signed or initialed by each party to the contract and drafted in specified sized text; and
- The amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed three percent of the purchase price unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages. (Civil Code Section 1675(b).)
- For the initial sale of newly constructed attached condominium units that involves the sale of an attached residential condominium unit located within a structure of 10 or more residential condominium units, the amount actually paid to the seller pursuant to the liquidated damages provision cannot exceed three percent of the purchase price. (Civil Code Section 1675(f).)
- Provides that a provision in a contract liquidating the damages for the breach of the contract is valid unless the party seeking to invalidate the provision establishes that the provision was unreasonable under the circumstances existing at the time the contract was made. (Civil Code Section 1671(b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: There is little question that finding an affordable home is growing increasingly difficult for many Californians. A 2022 report by the state Department of Housing and Community Development noted that the state needs to produce approximately 2.5 million housing units over the next eight years, with roughly one million of those units being set aside for lower income households, in order to meet the anticipated demand for housing over the same time period. (Dept. of Housing and Community Development, California Statewide Housing Plan: A Home for Every Californian (Mar. 2022) available at: https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/94729ab1648d43b1811c1698a748c136.) However, as a result of persistently high interest rates in recent years, many housing developers are now noting that obtaining adequate financing to construct new homes is becoming increasingly difficult. This is especially true for condominium development which, unlike single family homes projects that can be built in phases, must obtaining funding for the entire project upfront.
The author and proponents of this measure note that one of the main obstacles to obtaining funding for condominium development is the fact that the developer must demonstrate sufficient and legitimate interest from buyers. One means of demonstrating such interest is to obtain security deposits from would-be buyers to indicate that the eventual sale of the condominium units will be sufficient to repay construction loans. The proponents of this measure note that the existing security deposit limits are no longer sufficient to satisfy many lenders. Thus this bill would increase the amount of a deposit a developer may retain if a buyer backs out of a purchase agreement from three to ten percent of the purchase price. In support of this relatively modest measure, the author states:
As California embraces pro-housing and environmentally responsible policy, the share of multifamily housing in the state continues to grow. However, only a small fraction of this housing is available for purchase. Between 2011 and 2021, an estimated 3 percent of newly built housing in California consisted of multifamily condominiums. AB 1406 would align California with best practices from states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada, by raising the liquidated damages cap in current statue from 3% to 10%. This change would unlock financing for condo projects and increase the supply of more affordable, for sale housing.
The Subdivided Lands Act guides the purchase of newly constructed properties in California. Broadly speaking, there are two primary types of homes available for purchase in California: single-family homes and multifamily developments. Although new developments of both types of homes are typically governed by a homeowner association, single family homes are standalone units that developers can build in phases to meet financing needs and projected sales. Conversely, multifamily housing developments including condominiums, townhomes, stock cooperatives, limited-equity housing cooperatives, and other similar types of dwellings are frequently joined together in one physical structure. Given the unitary structure, these developments must be built at the same time, regardless of sales demand. These types of dwellings are typically considered a subdivision, which California law defines as improved or unimproved land that is divided or proposed to be divided for sale, lease, or financing into five or more lots or parcels. (Business and Professions Code Section 11000, 11004.5.) Seeking to protect would-be purchasers of subdivided interests from fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, the Subdivided Lands Act adopts an extensive series of consumer protections. Most notably, the Act requires a developer seeking to sell subdivided properties to obtain a subdivision public report from the Department of Real Estate prior to offering any property for sale. The Department’s public report includes information and disclosures regarding the subdivision and the developer’s commitments regarding facilities and improvements for the subdivision. A developer of the subdivision must meet certain requirements and provide documentation of sufficient financial arrangements for the completion of the improvements and facilities that will be included in the subdivision.
Additional protections for buyers can be found in both the Civil Code and the Subdivided Lands Act’s requirements that many downpayments or deposits provided by a buyer in advance of a final purchase of a newly constructed property must remain in an escrow account managed by a neutral third party. The role of the escrow account is to ensure that the buyer has a stake in completing the purchase while simultaneously protecting the deposit should the developer be unable to complete a project. Under the existing law, unless the developer follows existing procedures and obtains permission from the Department of Real Estate, the escrow money cannot be utilized to fund construction of the project. Nonetheless, the existence of the escrow money is a critical component of loan applications utilized by developers to borrow the funds necessary to finance the development.
California maintains one of the lowest permissible liquidated damage levels in the nation when buyers breach property sale agreements. Under existing law (Civil Code Section 1675), California law caps the amount of liquidated damages a property seller may recoup from a defaulting buyer at three percent of the purchase price. The author and proponents of this bill note that this is significantly less than many other states, including other large, urbanized states like New York or Washington. For example, the State of New York, of which condominiums make up a comparatively large share of the housing stock, maintains a ten percent cap on liquidated damages for breaching buyers. (NY-RPP Chap. 50, Art. 9-b et seq.) Despite the statutory provisions, however, New York state case law prohibits the developer from recovering the full ten percent if the liquidated damages are sought to punish buyers and not reimburse sellers (Atlantis Management Group II LLC v. Nabe (2023) N.Y. Slip Op. 02737). Notably, California case law has established a similar prohibition on punitive liquidated damages provisions in real estate contracts. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc. (1993) 13 Cal.App.4th 949.)
This bill would increase the liquidated damage caps for downpayments on new condominiums only. Seeking to align California law with the laws of other large states, this bill would increase the liquidated damage cap imposed on buyers breaching property sale contracts for the purchase of new condominiums from three percent of the purchase price to ten percent of the purchase price. The bill maintains the existing law’s requirement that the money be held in escrow and similarly maintains the law’s general prohibition on the use of such funds to finance construction and other related costs. Additionally, as proposed to be amended, this bill does not impact any single family home sales, for new or existing properties, and this bill does not apply to the sale of existing condominiums. This bill only raises the liquidated damages cap on new constriction condominiums in order to provide developers and their lenders sufficient financial assurances in the event a buyer breaches a sales contract.
Proposed amendments remedy a drafting error and narrow the measure to only apply to newly constructed condominiums. As currently in print this bill would apply the increased damage cap to all property sales. The author notes this was a drafting error and does not reflect the original agreement between this Committee and the author regarding the scope of the bill, nor reflects the intent of the bill’s proponents. To fix this drafting error and ensure that only new condominium developments are subject to the new liquidated damage provisions the author is proposing to amend the bill to reinsert the existing three percent liquidated damage cap for all other property transactions. Accordingly, subdivisions (c) and (d) of Civil Code Section will be amended to reflect the existing law and will, once again, read as follows:
(c) If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision does not exceed 3 10 percent of the purchase price, the provision is valid to the extent that payment is actually made unless the buyer establishes that the amount is unreasonable as liquidated damages.
(d) If the amount actually paid pursuant to the liquidated damages provision exceeds 3 10 percent of the purchase price, the provision is invalid unless the party seeking to uphold the provision establishes that the amount actually paid is reasonable as liquidated damages.
Although the opposition raises valid concerns, the scope of this bill is limited and market forces may negate many of the potential impacts. This bill, as currently in print and as proposed to be amended, is vociferously opposed by a coalition of stakeholders in the property sales industry. Writing jointly in opposition, the California Association of Realtors and the California Land Title Association argue the bill, “will expose homebuyers to extraordinary financial risk while serving to dismantle strong consumer safeguards enacted specifically to protect California homebuyers.” They also argue the bill does, “nothing to address the home affordability crisis and in fact likely put the dream of homeownership more at risk as buyers could lose so much money in one transaction they could be forced out of the market for years.”
The opposition is certainly correct in noting that the bill does expose a larger percentage of a downpayment to loss should a buyer breach a sales contract. However, it should be noted that, as proposed to be amended, this bill only make such an adjustment to a relatively small portion of California’s housing market. Indeed, based on current trends, by limiting this bill to new condominiums only, the measure impacts a part of the housing market typically found in large urban areas and purchased by affluent professionals. While this does not wholly relieve the risk that such an individual may lose a sizable security deposit, these buyers tend to be relatively sophisticated, capable of weighing the risk, and are more likely to be able to retain any professional services necessary to vindicate their rights. Additionally, the damage provisions are only triggered if the buyer defaults or otherwise violates their contractual obligations.
Furthermore, the bill does not require a liquidated damage level of ten percent but simply permits such damages. Indeed, although existing law sets a three percent cap on liquidated damages, many real estate contracts presently do not impose the maximum level of damages. Moreover, should, as the opposition also contends, market forces prevent many Californians from being able to afford a ten percent downpayment, condominium developers will have no choice but to apply lower liquidated damages in actual sales agreements if the developer actually wants to generate a market for the units. Nothing in the bill overrides the terms of a contract and nothing permits a developer to seek higher liquidated damages then originally agreed to in the sales contract. For example, if market conditions drive a developer to impose a five percent damage amount in contract, nothing in this bill authorizes the developer to subsequently seek additional damages should the seller breach the agreement. A final safeguard, as noted above, can be found in the case law interpreting Civil Code Section 1671 which prevents punitive liquidated damages provisions. (Myers Building Industries, Ltd. v. Interface Technology, Inc., supra.) While the opposition is correct that invoking these provisions of law is likely to require the employment of legal counsel and the potential for litigation, beyond raising the permissible level of non-punitive liquidated damages, nothing in this bill changes the existing statutory or common law protections for potential condominium buyers.
This bill remains a work in progress. The original version of this measure was substantially broader than the version of the bill presently before the Committee. Indeed, that version of the bill contained provisions that significantly undermined existing consumer protections, most notably the elimination of the escrow provisions that prevented a developer from accessing a buyer’s downpayment to pay for construction costs. The author and this Committee agreed to significantly narrow the bill to only include the increased liquidated damages provisions and to restore all other existing consumer protections. Unfortunately, as discussed above, these significant amendments did not ameliorate the opposition’s concerns. Nonetheless, the author is committing to ongoing engagement with all stakeholders to achieve their mutual goal of spurring much needed housing development while protecting everyday Californians. The Committee will continue to monitor these discussions, and as always, reserves the right to recall the bill for additional consideration should existing consumer protections not be maintained. Nonetheless, as proposed to be amended, the bill appears to strike an appropriate balance between spurring new housing construction and protecting the hard-earned savings of prospective California homeowners.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by a coalition of developers and affordable housing advocates under the umbrella of the California Home Building Alliance. A coalition letter from organizations that include the California Building Industry Association, the California Coalition for Affordable Housing, the San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association, and the Abundant Housing LA argue in support of the bill:
Condominiums have proven to be an effective path to affordable, entry-level homeownership for first-time buyers. California lags when compared to other states, like Hawaii and Washington, who produce condominiums at roughly ten times the annual rate in California. We have seen that this limited production significantly restricts pathways to homeownership especially in dense urban areas where land is scarce, and costs of single-family homes put them financially out of reach for most Californians. Additionally, despite significant growth in multifamily housing, very little of this new housing is available for ownership.
One major barrier we have identified is that in California, there is a de facto three percent earnest money deposit cap, requiring any funds over three percent to be fully refunded to the buyer if they decide to terminate the deal. AB 1406 would incentivize condominium development by increasing the existing liquidated damages cap from 3% of the sale price to 10%, aligning California with other states such as New York, Colorado, and Nevada that have a higher cap. This change would reduce lender risk, unlock financing for condo projects, and increase the supply of more affordable, entry level for-sale housing.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted a coalition of property sales professionals including the California Association of Realtors oppose this measure. In opposition the coalition jointly argues:
California’s liquidated-damages framework for owner-occupant buyers exists to protect homebuyers from disproportionate financial loss. In Guthman v. Moss, 150 Cal. App. 3d 502 (1984), the Second District Court of Appeal held that “…the purpose of enacting section 1675 et seq. was to protect buyers who fail to complete the purchase of real property and not sellers.” The proposed language in AB 1406 (Ward) would turn that that purpose on its head by forcing buyers to forfeit unreasonable sums that bear little relationship to any actual harm.
At today’s statewide median home price of approximately $887,000, a 10-percent liquidated-damages provision would allow a seller to retain nearly $89,000 from a defaulting buyer, an amount that in most transactions bears no reasonable relationship to foreseeable damages. Liquidated damages are intended to substitute for proof of actual damages by setting a reasonable, good-faith estimate of what a seller is likely to lose if a buyer defaults, not to create a windfall untethered to real economic harm, but this proposal does just that.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Abundant Housing LA
Bay Area Council
California Building Industry Association
California Community Builders
California Council for Affordable Housing
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Downtown Sacramento Partnership
Housing Action Coalition
Housing Trust Silicon Valley
Lighthouse Public Affairs, LLC
Mayor Matt Mahan, City of San Jose
San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association
The Two Hundred
Opposition
California Association of Realtors
California Escrow Association
California Land Title Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):