AB 446: Surveillance pricing.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2025-08-29
Current Status:
In Progress
(2025-09-10: Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator McNerney.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), grants a consumer various rights with respect to personal information that is collected or sold by a business, as defined, including the right to direct a business that sells or shares personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell or share the consumers personal information, as specified. Existing law, the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, approved by the voters as Proposition 24 at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election, amended, added to, and reenacted the CCPA and establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency and vests the agency with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to enforce those provisions.
Existing law requires a retail grocery store or grocery department within a general retail merchandise store that uses a point-of-sale system to have a clearly readable price indicated on 85% of the total number of packaged consumer commodities offered for sale, subject to specified exemptions.
This bill would, subject to certain exceptions, prohibit a person grocery establishment, as defined, from engaging in surveillance pricing. The bill would define surveillance pricing to mean offering or setting a customized price increase for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology, as specified. The bill would provide that only a public prosecutor, as specified, may bring an action against a violator of these provisions to recover specified civil penalties, injunctive relief, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs, and would authorize a consumer to bring an action for injunctive relief and reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The bill would declare that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
This bill would declare that its provisions further the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
Existing law, the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), grants a consumer various rights with respect to personal information that is collected or sold by a business, as defined, including the right to direct a business that sells or shares personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell or share the consumers personal information, as specified. Existing law, the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, approved by the voters as Proposition 24 at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election, amended, added to, and reenacted the CCPA and establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency and vests the agency with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to enforce those provisions.
Existing law requires a retail grocery store or grocery department within a general retail merchandise store that uses a point-of-sale system to have a clearly readable price indicated on 85% of the total number of packaged consumer commodities offered for sale, subject to specified exemptions.
This bill would, subject to certain exceptions, prohibit a person from engaging in surveillance pricing. The bill would define surveillance pricing to mean offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology, as specified. The bill would provide that only a public prosecutor, as specified, may bring an action against a violator of these provisions to recover specified civil penalties, injunctive relief, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs, and would authorize a consumer to bring an action for injunctive relief and reasonable attorneys fees and costs. The bill would specify civil penalties that a violator of these provisions is subject to, and would declare that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
This bill would declare that its provisions further the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
Existing law, the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), grants a consumer various rights with respect to personal information that is collected or sold by a business, as defined, including the right to direct a business that sells or shares personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell or share the consumers personal information, as specified. Existing law, the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, approved by the voters as Proposition 24 at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election, amended, added to, and reenacted the CCPA and establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency and vests the agency with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to enforce those provisions.
Existing law requires a retail grocery store or grocery department within a general retail merchandise store that uses a point-of-sale system to have a clearly readable price indicated on 85% of the total number of packaged consumer commodities offered for sale, subject to specified exemptions.
This bill would, subject to certain exceptions, prohibit a person from engaging in surveillance pricing. The bill would define surveillance pricing to mean using specified information, gathered through a technological method or system of surveillance, to set the price of a commercial good or service for a consumer that differs from the standard price, as defined. offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information collected through electronic surveillance technology, as specified. The bill would specify civil penalties that a violator of these provisions is subject to, and would declare that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
This bill would declare that its provisions further the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
Existing law, the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), grants a consumer various rights with respect to personal information that is collected or sold by a business, as defined, including the right to direct a business that sells or shares personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell or share the consumers personal information, as specified. Existing law, the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, approved by the voters as Proposition 24 at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election, amended, added to, and reenacted the CCPA and establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency and vests the agency with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to enforce those provisions.
Existing law requires a retail grocery store or grocery department within a general retail merchandise store that uses a point-of-sale system to have a clearly readable price indicated on 85% of the total number of packaged consumer commodities offered for sale, subject to specified exemptions.
This bill would would, subject to certain exceptions, prohibit a person from setting a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information, as defined, gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, as defined, including electronic shelving labels. engaging in surveillance pricing. The bill would define surveillance pricing to mean using specified information, gathered through a technological method or system of surveillance, to set the price of a commercial good or service for a consumer that differs from the standard price, as defined. The bill would specify civil penalties that a violator of these provisions is subject to, and would declare that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
This bill would declare that its provisions further the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
Existing law requires a retail grocery store or grocery department within a general retail merchandise store that uses a point-of-sale system to have a clearly readable price indicated on 85% of the total number of packaged consumer commodities offered for sale, subject to specified exemptions.
This bill would prohibit a person from setting a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information, as defined, gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, as defined, including electronic shelving labels. The bill would specify civil penalties that a violator of these provisions is subject to, and would declare that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.(a)Grocery establishment shall have the same meaning as grocery establishment as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 2502 of the Labor Code.
(b)Personally identifiable information shall have the same meaning as personal information as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder.
(c)Surveillance pricing means offering or setting a customized price increase for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. Surveillance pricing includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about a consumers behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
7202.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), a person grocery establishment shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
(b)A person grocery establishment does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
(1)The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.
(2)A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event.
(3)A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, active or retired military, senior citizens, students, or residents of a certain area based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.
(4)A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in.
(5)A discounted price is offered after a consumer directly and knowingly provides specific personally identifiable information for the purpose of obtaining a discount. The nature and purpose of the consumers disclosure of personal information shall be conveyed in clear and prominent terms in such a manner that an ordinary consumer would notice and understand it.
(6)The person operates as an insurance institution as defined in Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity. Nothing in this part shall be construed to allow an insurance company to engage in conduct that violates any provision of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Insurance Code, approved by the electors on November 8, 1988, as Proposition 103, and the laws it makes applicable to insurance companies.
(c)(1)A person grocery establishment is not in violation of this part if the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined in Section 603(d) of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1681a(d)).
(2)A person grocery establishment is not in violation of this part if the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific commercial enterprise, is based on information contained in a commercial credit report, as defined in Section 1785.42.
(d)A discounted price offered pursuant to paragraph (2), (3), (4), or (5) of subdivision (b) shall comply with all both of the following conditions:
(1)The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any personally identifiable information is collected.
(2)The discount or reward shall be uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
(3)Any personally identifiable information provided for the purpose of receiving a discounted price is not augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means.(e)Any personally identifiable information collected pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including, but not limited to, profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.7204.(a)Except as provided under subdivision (b), actions pursuant to this part may only be brought by the Attorney General, by any district attorney, by any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or by a county counsel of any county within which a city has a population in excess of 750,000, by any city attorney of any city and county, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city having a full-time city prosecutor, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(1)In addition to any other remedy at law, a person grocery establishment that violates this part shall be liable for the following civil penalties, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought pursuant to this subdivision:
(A)A civil penalty not to exceed twelve thousand five hundred dollars ($12,500) for each violation, with each violation of this part constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.
(B)For a person grocery establishment that intentionally violates this part, a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subparagraph (A) and all revenues earned from the violation.
(2)A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to this subdivision shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(3)In addition to seeking civil penalties and other monetary relief, a court may award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary to enforce this part and to remedy any violation of its provisions.
(b)(1)A consumer may bring an action for injunctive relief as necessary to enforce this part and to remedy any violation of its provisions.
(2)A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to this subdivision shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
7208.Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
7209.The rights, remedies, and penalties established by this part are cumulative and shall not be construed to supersede the rights, remedies, or penalties established under other laws, including, but not limited to, Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 12940) of Part 2.8 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Section 51 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a)Aggregate consumer information means information that relates to a group or category of consumers, from which individual consumer identities have been removed, that is not linked or reasonably linkable to any consumer or household, including via a device.(b)Covered information means either personally identifiable information or aggregate consumer information. (c)(a)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(d)(b)Personally identifiable information shall have the same meaning as personal information as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder.
(e)(c)Surveillance pricing means offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. Surveillance pricing includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered personally identifiable information about a consumers behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
7202.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
(b)A person does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
(1)The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.
(2)A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event.
(3)A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, veterans, active or retired military, senior citizens, or students, or residents of a certain area based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.
(4)A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in.
(5)A discounted price is offered after a consumer directly and knowingly provides specific personally identifiable information for the purpose of obtaining a discount. The nature and purpose of the consumers disclosure of personal information shall be conveyed in clear and prominent terms in such a manner that an ordinary consumer would notice and understand it.
(5)(6)The person operates as an insurer complying with insurance institution as defined in Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity. Nothing in this part shall be construed to allow an insurance company to engage in conduct that violates any provision of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Insurance Code, approved by the electors on November 8, 1988, as Proposition 103, and the laws it makes applicable to insurance companies.
(c)(1)A person is not in violation of this part if the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined in Section 603(d) of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1681a(d)).
(2)A person is not in violation of this part if the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific commercial enterprise, is based on information contained in a commercial credit report, as defined in Section 1785.42.
(d)A discounted price offered pursuant to paragraph (2), (3), or (4) (4), or (5) of subdivision (b) shall comply with both all of the following conditions:
(1)The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any covered personally identifiable information is collected.
(2)The discount or reward shall be offered uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
(3)Any personally identifiable information provided for the purpose of receiving a discounted price is not augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means.
(e)Any covered personally identifiable information collected pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including, but not limited to, profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.
7204.(a)In Except as provided under subdivision (b), actions pursuant to this part may only be brought by the Attorney General, by any district attorney, by any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or by a county counsel of any county within which a city has a population in excess of 750,000, by any city attorney of any city and county, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city having a full-time city prosecutor, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(1)In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this part shall be liable for a the following civil penalties, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought pursuant to this subdivision:
(A)A civil penalty not to exceed twelve thousand five hundred dollars ($12,500) for each violation, with each violation of this part constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.
(b)A person(B)For a person that intentionally violates this part shall be liable for part, a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) and shall disgorge subparagraph (A) and all revenues earned from the violation.
(c)(2)A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to this part subdivision shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(d)(3)In addition to seeking civil penalties and other monetary relief, a court may award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary to enforce this part and to remedy any violation of its provisions.
(b)(1)A consumer may bring an action for injunctive relief as necessary to enforce this part and to remedy any violation of its provisions.
(2)A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to this subdivision shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
7208.Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
7209.The rights, remedies, and penalties established by this part are cumulative and shall not be construed to supersede the rights, remedies, or penalties established under other laws, including, but not limited to, Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 12940) of Part 2.8 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Section 51 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a)Aggregate consumer information means information that relates to a group or category of consumers, from which individual consumer identities have been removed, that is not linked or reasonably linkable to any consumer or household, including via a device.
(b)Covered information means either personally identifiable information or aggregate consumer information.
(c)Electronic surveillance technology means a technological method or system of surveillance used to gather covered information.(d)(c)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(e)(d)Personally identifiable information shall have the same meaning as personal information as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder.
(f)Standard price means the price of a good or service that is set for all consumers that is not based upon covered information. (g)Surveillance pricing means using covered information gathered through electronic surveillance technology to set the price of a commercial good or service for a consumer that differs from the standard price.(e)Surveillance pricing means offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information collected through electronic surveillance technology. Surveillance pricing includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered information about a consumers behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
7202.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
(b)A person may does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
(1)The difference from the standard price charged to a consumer is based solely on the cost to the person of providing the good or service to that consumer.(2)The difference from the standard price is a discount offered to all consumers on equal terms in a manner consistent with applicable antidiscrimination laws. If the person gathers personally identifiable information in connection with the provision of this discount, the person shall ensure both of the following:(A)That the consumer receives a clear and conspicuous written notice describing in readily ascertainable terms the specific intended purposes for which the person will use the personally identifiable information before the person uses the information for those purposes.(B)That the consumer provides written affirmative consent for any purpose described in subparagraph (A) before their personally identifiable information is used for that purpose.(1)The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.
(2)A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event.
(3)A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, veterans, senior citizens, or students, based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.
(4)A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively enroll in.
(3)(5)The person operates as an insurer complying with Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity. Nothing in this part shall be construed to allow an insurance company to engage in conduct that violates any provision of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Insurance Code, approved by the electors on November 8, 1988, as Proposition 103, and the laws it makes applicable to insurance companies.
(c)A person is not in violation of this part if the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined in Section 603(d) of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1681a(d)).
(d)A discounted price offered pursuant to paragraph (2), (3), or (4) of subdivision (b) shall comply with both of the following conditions:
(1)The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any covered information is collected.
(2)The discount or reward shall be offered uniformly to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
(e)Any covered information collected pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including, but not limited to, profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.
7204.(a)In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty for each violation not to exceed the jurisdiction of small claims court for individuals, where each violation means each item of tangible property or each use of a service sold in violation of Section 7202. twelve thousand five hundred dollars ($12,500) for each violation, with each violation of this part constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.
(b)A person that intentionally violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) and shall disgorge all revenues earned from the violation.
(c)A prevailing party plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to this part shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(d)In addition to seeking civil penalties and other monetary relief, a court may award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary to enforce this part and to remedy any violation of its provisions.
7208.Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
7209.The rights, remedies, and penalties established by this part are cumulative and shall not be construed to supersede the rights, remedies, or penalties established under other laws, including, but not limited to, Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 12940) of Part 2.8 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code and Section 51 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a)Aggregate consumer information means information that relates to a group or category of consumers, from which individual consumer identities have been removed, that is not linked or reasonably linkable to any consumer or household, including via a device.
(b)Covered information means either personally identifiable information or aggregate consumer information.
(a)(c)Electronic surveillance technology means a technological method or system of surveillance used to observe, monitor, or collect information related to a person and includes any of the following information about the person: gather covered information.
(1)Actions, habits, race, religion, residence, sexuality, or preferences.(2)Interests, including the individuals political, personal, or professional affiliation.(3)Web browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances, or consumer behaviors.(4)Personally identifiable information.(b)(d)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(c)(e)Personally identifiable information shall have the same meaning as personal information as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder. Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, personally identifiable information includes deidentified or aggregated consumer information.
(f)Standard price means the price of a good or service that is set for all consumers that is not based upon covered information.
(d)(g)Surveillance pricing means when a person sets a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, including electronic shelving labels. using covered information gathered through electronic surveillance technology to set the price of a commercial good or service for a consumer that differs from the standard price.
7202.It shall be unlawful for (a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), a person to shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
(b)A person may engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
(1)The difference from the standard price charged to a consumer is based solely on the cost to the person of providing the good or service to that consumer.
(2)The difference from the standard price is a discount offered to all consumers on equal terms in a manner consistent with applicable antidiscrimination laws. If the person gathers personally identifiable information in connection with the provision of this discount, the person shall ensure both of the following:
(A)That the consumer receives a clear and conspicuous written notice describing in readily ascertainable terms the specific intended purposes for which the person will use the personally identifiable information before the person uses the information for those purposes.
(B)That the consumer provides written affirmative consent for any purpose described in subparagraph (A) before their personally identifiable information is used for that purpose.
(3)The person operates as an insurer complying with Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity.
7204.(a)In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty for each violation not to exceed the jurisdiction of small claims court for individuals, where each violation means each item of tangible property or each use of a service sold in violation of Section 7202.
(b)A person that intentionally violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) and shall disgorge all revenues earned from the violation.
(c)A prevailing party in an action brought pursuant to this part shall be awarded reasonable attorneys attorneys fees and costs.
7208.Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares as follows:
(1)A recent study documented how businesses are aggressively and secretly engaging in surveillance of their customers and secretly varying prices between customers or groups accordingly. For example, the study documented the following surveillance-based pricing practices:
(A)Orbitz learned that Mac users spend more money to stay at hotels and charged them more than non-Mac users.
(B)Hotel booking sites charged people in certain ZIP Codes more money to stay at hotels than other ones across the country. In one example, a person in the bay area was charged by Hotels.com $80 more to stay in a New York City hotel than someone browsing for the same room in Kansas City.
(C)Staples.com charged people more for the same stapler if they knew a person had fewer options, such as not being physically near a competitor.
(D)Target charged people more for its products when they were in a Target parking lot versus when they were in another location because the company determined people who were near a store entrance were willing to pay more. As a result, prices spiked for a television, a smart watch, a vacuum, and a child car seat once consumers were in a store parking lot.
(E)The test prep company Princeton Review charged customers more money when it found they lived in ZIP Codes that contained a higher number of Asians.
(2)Corporate consultants have told clients that surveillance-based pricing strategies have become a cornerstone of modern business strategy. Profit margins are improved by 2 to 7 percentage points when surveillance pricing is implemented, according to McKinsey and Company. A Yale study found surveillance-based pricing increased profits for airlines by 4 to 5 percent.
(3)Other studies document that surveillance pricing impacts lower income people the most. A study of broadband internet offers to 1,100,000 residential addresses showed the worst deals given to the poorest people. Areas with discounted prices tended to have a higher average income than areas that tended to see higher prices. Lower income people also pay higher prices for food, and lower credit scores have been associated with higher prices for various consumer products.
(4)(A)Recent reports have raised the possibility that publicly traded grocery store chains, including the dozens of grocery brands under Krogers corporate umbrella, are concurrently installing facial recognition and other biometric technologies and adopting electronic shelving labels. Together, these technologies will allow grocery retailers to distinguish between customers based on race, gender, disability, distance traveled to the store, age, and electronically stored personal information in real time and price food differently based on individualized profiling.
(B)Personalized or surveillance-based pricing technologies will permit large grocery store chains to impose unfair and discriminatory prices on their customers for basic food necessities in ways that might increase the economic burdens of those already subject to discrimination or economic hardships.
(b)For these reasons, legislation is required to fairly and compassionately restrain the deployment and use of unfair, discriminatory, privacy-invading technologies that, if deployed in ways contrary to the public interest and welfare, will dramatically exacerbate gaps between wealthy and working families, to the unneeded benefit of the former and the enduring, unjust harm of the latter.
SEC. 2.Part 5.6 (commencing with Section 7200) is added to Division 4 of the Civil Code, to read:5.6.SURVEILLANCE PRICING7200.For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a)Electronic surveillance technology means a technological method or system of surveillance used to observe, monitor, or collect information related to a person and includes any of the following information about the person:
(1)Actions, habits, race, religion, residence, sexuality, or preferences.
(2)Interests, including the individuals political, personal, or professional affiliation.
(3)Web browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances, or consumer behaviors.
(4)Personally identifiable information.
(b)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(c)Personally identifiable information shall have the same meaning as personal information as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder. Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, personally identifiable information includes deidentified or aggregated consumer information.
(d)Surveillance pricing means when a person sets a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, including electronic shelving labels.
7202.It shall be unlawful for a person to engage in surveillance pricing.
7204.(a)In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty for each violation not to exceed the jurisdiction of small claims court for individuals, where each violation means each item of tangible property or each use of a service sold in violation of Section 7202.
(b)A person that intentionally violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) and shall disgorge all revenues earned from the violation.
(c)A prevailing party in an action brought pursuant to this part shall be awarded reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
7208.Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 10, 2025 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator McNerney. |
| Sep 2, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 29, 2025 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Aug 29, 2025 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (August 29). |
| Aug 18, 2025 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jul 17, 2025 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 16, 2025 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 2.) (July 15). |
| May 21, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and APPR. |
| May 13, 2025 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 12, 2025 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 47. Noes 20. Page 1516.) |
| May 7, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 6, 2025 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (May 6). |
| May 6, 2025 | Coauthors revised. |
| May 5, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 1, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 28, 2025 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 24, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 20, 2025 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2025 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 10. Noes 3.) (March 18). |
| Feb 18, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on P. & C.P. and JUD. |
| Feb 7, 2025 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2025 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2025 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 18, 2025 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 15, 2025 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2025 | AB 446 Ward Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2025 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 18, 2025 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Airlines for America | ** Against | |
| american advertising federation | ** Against | |
| American Association Of Advertising Agencies | ** Against | |
| American Economic Liberties Project | ** Support | |
| American Federation of Musicians, Local 47 | ** Support | |
| American Property Casualty Insurance Association | ** Against | |
| Associated Equipment Distributors | ** Against | |
| Association of National Advertisers | ** Against | |
| Athena Coalition | ** Support | |
| Black Women For Wellness Action Project | ** Support | |
| Brea Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Building Owners and Managers Association of California | ** Against | |
| CalBroadband | ** Against | |
| California Attractions And Parks Association | ** Against | |
| California Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Civil Liberties Advocacy | ** Support | |
| California Credit Union League | ** Against | |
| California Federation of Labor Unions, Afl-cio | ** Support | |
| California Food and Farming Network | ** Support | |
| California Grocers Association | ** Against | |
| California Hotel & Lodging Association | ** Against | |
| California Low-Income Consumer Coalition | ** Support | |
| California National Organization For Women | ** Support | |
| California New Car Dealers Association | ** Against | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Support | |
| California Retailers Association | ** Against | |
| California Safety and Legislative Board, Smart – Transportation Division (SMART – TD) | ** Support | |
| California School Employees Association | ** Support | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Support | |
| California Travel Association | ** Against | |
| Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Center for Democracy and Technology | ** Support | |
| Center on Policy Initiatives | ** Support | |
| CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, Aft, Afl-cio | ** Support | |
| Chamber Of Progress | ** Against | |
| Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Consumer Federation Of California | ** Support | |
| Consumer Watchdog | ** Support | |
| Corona Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Courage California | ** Support | |
| CTIA | ** Against | |
| Cupertino Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Digital Advertising Alliance | ** Against | |
| Economic Security California Action | ** Support | |
| Electronic Privacy Information Center | ** Support | |
| Equal Rights Advocates | ** Support | |
| Folsom Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Interactive Advertising Bureau | ** Against | |
| LA Cañada Flintridge Chamber of Commerce and Community Association | ** Against | |
| Lake Elsinore Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy | ** Support | |
| Mission Viejo Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Naiop California | ** Against | |
| National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies | ** Against | |
| National Consumer Law Center, INC. | ** Support | |
| National Federation Of Independent Business | ** Against | |
| Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Orange County Business Council | ** Against | |
| Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Paso Robles and Templeton Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Personal Insurance Federation Of California | ** Against | |
| Powerswitch Action | ** Support | |
| Privacy Rights Clearinghouse | ** Support | |
| Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| San Juan Capistrano Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Software & Information Industry Association | ** Against | |
| Southwest California Legislative Council | ** Against | |
| Techequity Action | ** Support | |
| Technet | ** Against | |
| Tech Oversight California | ** Support | |
| the greater coachella valley chamber of commerce | ** Against | |
| The Travel Technology Association | ** Against | |
| Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| UFCW - Western States Council | ** Support | |
| United Domestic Workers/AFSCME, Local 3930 | ** Support | |
| USTelecom - the Broadband Association | ** Against | |
| VALLEY INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| western center on law & poverty | ** Support | |
| Working Partnerships USA | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 446 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 446
Author: Ward (D), et al.
Amended: 8/29/25 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-2, 7/15/25
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Arreguín, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Stern, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
NOES: Niello, Valladares
NO VOTE RECORDED: Ashby
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 8/29/25
AYES: Caballero, Cabaldon, Grayson, Wahab
NOES: Seyarto, Dahle
NO VOTE RECORDED: Richardson
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 47-20, 5/12/25 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Surveillance pricing
SOURCE: United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council
Consumer Watchdog
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits grocery establishments from engaging in “surveillance pricing,” as defined, except as provided.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civil (Civ.) Code § 1798.100 et seq.) Establishes the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020 (CPRA), which amends the CCPA. (Civ. Code § 798.100 et seq.; Proposition 24 (2020).)
- Provides that these provisions do not restrict a business’ ability to collect, use, retain, sell, share, or disclose consumers’ personal information that is deidentified or aggregate consumer information. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(a)(6).)
- Defines “personal information” as information that identifies, relates to, describes, is reasonably capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(v).)
- Establishes a prohibition on unfair competition, known as the Unfair Competition Law, which covers any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, and any act prohibited under the False Advertising Law. (Business (Bus.) & Professions (Prof.) Code § 17200.)
This bill:
- Prohibits grocery establishments from engaging in “surveillance pricing,” defined as offering or setting a customized price increase for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. “Surveillance pricing” includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Provides that a grocery establishment does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
- The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.
- A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event.
- A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, active or retired military, senior citizens, residents of a certain area, or students, based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.
- A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in.
- A discounted price is offered after a consumer directly and knowingly provides specific personally identifiable information for the purpose of obtaining a discount. The nature and purpose of the consumer’s disclosure of personal information shall be conveyed in clear and prominent terms in such a manner that an ordinary consumer would notice and understand it.
- The person operates as an insurance institution as defined in Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity, as provided.
- Requires the discounted price offered in b), c), d), or e) above to comply with the following:
- The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any personally identifiable information is collected.
- The discount or reward shall be uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
- Subjects a grocery establishment in violation to liability for civil penalties. Intentional violations are subject to trebling, and a grocery establishment in violation shall be required to disgorge all revenues earned thereby. A prevailing plaintiff shall be awarded reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. A court may also award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary. Such actions can only be brought by specified public prosecutors. This bill authorizes a consumer to bring an action for injunctive relief and for reasonable fees and costs.
- Provides that a person is not in violation if the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined.
- Makes any waiver void and unenforceable and clarifies that the rights, remedies, and penalties are cumulative to any others.
Background
Companies regularly and systematically collect, analyze, share, and sell the personal information of consumers. While this data collection provides consumers various benefits, public fears about the widespread, unregulated amassing of personal information have only grown since privacy was made a part of California’s Constitution. One particularly troubling area of this systematic data collection is utilization of this information to engage in differential pricing for consumers based on various elements of that information.
This bill prohibits this practice of “surveillance pricing,” defined as offering or setting a customized price increase for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based on consumers’ personal information collected through electronic surveillance technology. However, the bill has been recently amended to limit the application to grocery establishments. The bill applies to information gathered through sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection. The bill provides a series of limitations on the offering of discounted pricing, such as requiring transparency about the basis for such discounts. Violations are subject to civil penalties and other relief to be sought in a civil action by specified public prosecutors. Consumers are authorized to bring actions for injunctive relief and to recover reasonable fees and costs.
This bill is sponsored by the United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) Western States Council and Consumer Watchdog. It is supported by a wide array of labor, advocacy, and low-income services groups. It is opposed by various industry groups, including TechNet and Chamber of Progress.
Comment
According to the author:
With the rise of artificial intelligence and data collection, businesses increasingly use personal data to set prices, often leading to unfair and discriminatory pricing practices. This legislation aims to establish safeguards that ensure transparency, fairness, and consumer protections in pricing algorithms. AB 446 will prohibit the practice of surveillance pricing by making it unlawful for businesses to use personal data when charging different prices for the same product, or service whether online or during in-store checkout.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates a fiscal impact of approximately $1 million or less (Unfair Competition Law Fund). DOJ notes that implementation of this bill will be dependent upon the appropriation of funds. DOJ will be unable to absorb the costs to comply with or implement the requirements of the bill within existing budgeted resources. DOJ reports that the Consumer Protection Section (CPS) within the Public Rights Division anticipates increased workloads in enforcing AB 446 beginning on January 1, 2026, and ongoing. The workload includes enforcement AB 446. CPS will require additional resources consisting of 2.0 Deputy Attorneys General (DAGs), 1.0 Associate Governmental Program Analysts (AGPA), 1.0 Special Investigator, and 1.0 Legal Secretary.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the state funded trial court system (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to adjudicate civil actions. Creating a new private cause of action that allows for the recovery of attorney’s fees, and authorizing a new civil penalty with significant statutory damages, may lead to additional case filings that otherwise would not have been commenced. Expanding civil penalties and creating new causes of action could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings with attendant workload and resource costs to the court. The fiscal impact of this bill to the courts will depend on many unknowns, including the number of cases filed and the factors unique to each case. An eight-hour court day costs approximately $10,500 in staff in workload. If court days exceed 10, costs to the trial courts could reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources and to increase the amount appropriated to backfill for trial court operations.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/29/25)
Consumer Watchdog (source)
UFCW - Western States Council (source)
American Economic Liberties Project
American Federation of Musicians, Local 7
Black Women for Wellness Action Project
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO
California Food and Farming Network
California Low-income Consumer Coalition
California National Organization for Women
California Nurses Association
California Safety and Legislative Board, Smart – Transportation Division (SMART – TD)
California School Employees Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (SEIU California)
Center for Democracy and Technology
Center on Policy Initiatives
CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT, AFL-CIO
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Courage California
Economic Security California Action
Equal Rights Advocates
Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy
National Consumer Law Center, INC.
Oakland Privacy
Powerswitch Action
Tech Oversight California
Techequity Action
United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Working Partnerships USA
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/29/25)
Airlines for America
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Equipment Distributors
Association of National Advertisers
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association of California
CalBroadband
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Grocers Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Retailers Association
California Travel Association
Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce
Chamber of Progress
Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce
Corona Chamber of Commerce
CTIA
Cupertino Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
LA Cañada Flintridge Chamber of Commerce and Community Association
Lake Elsinore Valley Chamber of Commerce
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Mission Viejo Chamber of Commerce
Naiop California
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Paso Robles and Templeton Chamber of Commerce
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce
San Juan Capistrano Chamber of Commerce
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Software Information Industry Association
TechNet
The Travel Technology Association
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
USTelecom - the Broadband Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: UFCW Western States Council, a sponsor of the bill, explains:
Surveillance Pricing Should Be Prohibited Because It Exacerbates Inequality, Especially as Applied To Necessities Like Food.
In October 2024, an explosive news report found that Kroger, one of the largest grocery store chains in the United States,[1] was exploring the use of facial recognition technology in its stores. Immediately, shoppers and public officials worried that consumers’ faces might be used, along with other intimate data, to deliver different prices for different consumers.
Surveillance pricing exacerbates economic inequality. “Higher-income consumers may receive discounts, while those with less disposable income might face higher prices. Surveillance pricing can further entrench these inequalities, like how credit scores impact loan rates or zip codes affect insurance premiums. Marginalized communities, including people of color and low-income individuals, are particularly vulnerable to higher prices due to algorithmic biases[.]”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A large coalition of industry associations, including the Association of National Advertisers, writes in opposition:
AB 446 conflicts with the approach of the CCPA because it treats “aggregate consumer information” as if it were “personal information,” in explicit contradiction of Civil Code 1798.140. As a policy matter, we believe this is incorrect; information that has been deidentified and aggregated is not personal information under the CCPA, nor should it be here. Such data is not a risk of individual profiling or discrimination exactly because it is deidentified or aggregated. That is why, as a matter of public policy, aggregated data and personal data are not treated the same because they neither implicate the same rights for consumers nor pose the same risks in the event of a data leak.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 47-20, 5/12/25
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Alvarez, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Caloza, Carrillo, Connolly, Elhawary, Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Mark González, Haney, Harabedian, Hart, Jackson, Kalra, Krell, Lee, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Ortega, Papan, Pellerin, Quirk-Silva, Ransom, Celeste Rodriguez, Rogers, Schiavo, Schultz, Sharp-Collins, Solache, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Zbur, Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Castillo, Davies, DeMaio, Dixon, Ellis, Flora, Gallagher, Jeff Gonzalez, Hadwick, Hoover, Lackey, Macedo, Patterson, Ramos, Sanchez, Ta, Tangipa, Valencia, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Ávila Farías, Bains, Chen, Irwin, Nguyen, Pacheco, Patel, Petrie-Norris, Michelle Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Soria, Stefani
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/2/25 17:56:30
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular Session
AB 446 (Ward) - Surveillance pricing
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
Prohibits surveillance pricing by grocery establishments, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 29, 2025
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates a fiscal impact of approximately $1 million or less (Unfair Competition Law Fund). DOJ notes that implementation of this bill will be dependent upon the appropriation of funds. DOJ will be unable to absorb the costs to comply with or implement the requirements of the bill within existing budgeted resources. DOJ reports that the Consumer Protection Section (CPS) within the Public Rights Division anticipates increased workloads in enforcing AB 446 beginning on January 1, 2026, and ongoing. The workload includes enforcement AB 446. CPS will require additional resources consisting of 2.0 Deputy Attorneys General (DAGs), 1.0 Associate Governmental Program Analysts (AGPA), 1.0 Special Investigator, and 1.0 Legal Secretary.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the state funded trial court system (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to adjudicate civil actions. Creating a new private cause of action that allows for the recovery of attorney’s fees, and authorizing a new civil penalty with significant statutory damages, may lead to additional case filings that otherwise would not have been commenced. Expanding civil penalties and creating new causes of action could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings with attendant workload and resource costs to the court. The fiscal impact of this bill to the courts will depend on many unknowns, including the number of cases filed and the factors unique to each case. An eight-hour court day costs approximately $10,500 in staff in workload. If court days exceed 10, costs to the trial courts could reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources and to increase the amount appropriated to backfill for trial court operations.
Committee Amendments:
- Provide that “Grocery establishment” has the same meaning as “grocery establishment” as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 2502 of the Labor Code.
- Define “Surveillance pricing” as offering or setting a customized price increase for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. “Surveillance pricing” includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Prohibit a grocery establishment from engaging in surveillance pricing.
- Make conforming changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular Session
AB 446 (Ward) - Surveillance pricing
Version: July 17, 2025 | Policy Vote: JUD. 10 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 18, 2025 | Consultant: Liah Burnley |
Bill Summary:
AB 446 prohibits surveillance pricing.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates a fiscal impact of approximately $1 million or less (Unfair Competition Law Fund). DOJ notes that implementation of this bill will be dependent upon the appropriation of funds. DOJ will be unable to absorb the costs to comply with or implement the requirements of the bill within existing budgeted resources. DOJ reports that the Consumer Protection Section (CPS) within the Public Rights Division anticipates increased workloads in enforcing AB 446 beginning on January 1, 2026, and ongoing. The workload includes enforcement AB 446. CPS will require additional resources consisting of 2.0 Deputy Attorneys General (DAGs), 1.0 Associate Governmental Program Analysts (AGPA), 1.0 Special Investigator, and 1.0 Legal Secretary.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the state funded trial court system (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to adjudicate civil actions. Creating a new private cause of action that allows for the recovery of attorney’s fees, and authorizing a new civil penalty with significant statutory damages, may lead to additional case filings that otherwise would not have been commenced. Expanding civil penalties and creating new causes of action could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings with attendant workload and resource costs to the court. The fiscal impact of this bill to the courts will depend on many unknowns, including the number of cases filed and the factors unique to each case. An eight-hour court day costs approximately $10,500 in staff in workload. If court days exceed 10, costs to the trial courts could reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources and to increase the amount appropriated to backfill for trial court operations.
Background:
As explained in further detail in the Senate Judiciary Committee Analysis of this bill, companies regularly and systematically collect, analyze, share, and sell the personal information of consumers. This systematic data collection is particularly troubling when companies use it to engage in differential pricing for consumers.
Proposed Law:
- Defines “Surveillance pricing” as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. “Surveillance pricing” includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Provides that a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
- Clarifies that a person does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
- The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers;
- A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event;
- A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, active or retired military, senior citizens, students, or residents of a certain area based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria;
- A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in; or,
- A discounted price is offered after a consumer directly and knowingly provides specific personally identifiable information for the purpose of obtaining a discount. The nature and purpose of the consumer’s disclosure of personal information shall be conveyed in clear and prominent terms in such a manner that an ordinary consumer would notice and understand it; or,
- The person operates as an insurance institution, as defined, and the pricing is in connection with that activity.
- Provides that a person is not in violation if:
- The pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined; or,
- The pricing or specific terms of extending credit, the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific commercial enterprise, is based on information contained in a commercial credit report.
- Provides that a discounted price shall comply with all of the following conditions:
- The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any personally identifiable information is collected;
- The discount or reward shall be uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria;
- Any personally identifiable information provided for the purpose of receiving a discounted price is not augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means; and,
- Any personally identifiable information shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including, but not limited to, profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.
- Authorizes the Attorney General, any district attorney, any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or by a county counsel of any county within which a city has a population in excess of 750,000, any city attorney of any city and county, or, with the consent of the district attorney, by a city prosecutor in any city having a full-time city prosecutor, to bring an enforcement action in any court of competent jurisdiction.
- Provides that, in addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates these provisions shall be liable for the following civil penalties:
- A civil penalty not to exceed twelve $12,500 for each violation, with each violation of this part constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved;
- For an intentional violation, a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed and all revenues earned from the violation;
- Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs; and,
- Injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary.
- Authorizes a consumer to bring an action for injunctive relief as necessary to enforce and to remedy any violation. A prevailing plaintiff shall be awarded reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Provides that any waiver of these provisions is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 446 (Author:Ward)
Version: May 1, 2025
Hearing Date: July 15, 2025
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Surveillance pricing
DIGEST
This bill prohibits “surveillance pricing,” as defined, except as provided.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Companies regularly and systematically collect, analyze, share, and sell the personal information of consumers. While this data collection provides consumers various benefits, public fears about the widespread, unregulated amassing of personal information have only grown since privacy was made a part of California’s Constitution. One particularly troubling area of this systematic data collection is utilization of this information to engage in differential pricing for consumers based on various elements of that information.
This bill prohibits this practice of “surveillance pricing,” defined as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based on consumers’ personal information collected through electronic surveillance technology. This includes information gathered through sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection. The bill provides a series of exceptions for the offering of discounted pricing, such as through loyalty programs, where certain conditions are met, such as ensuring transparency about the basis for such discounts. Violations are subject to civil penalties and other relief to be sought in a civil action.
This bill is sponsored by the United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) Western States Council and Consumer Watchdog. It is supported by a wide array of labor, advocacy, and low-income services groups, including the Western Center on Law and Poverty, Equal Rights Advocates, and the California Federation of Labor Unions. It is opposed by various industry groups, including TechNet and Chamber of Progress.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020 (CPRA), which amends the CCPA. (Civ. Code § 798.100 et seq.; Proposition 24 (2020).)
- Grants a consumer the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information it has collected about that consumer;
- the categories of sources from which the personal information is collected;
- the business or commercial purpose for collecting, selling, or sharing personal information;
- the categories of third parties with whom the business shares personal information; and
- the specific pieces of personal information it has collected about that consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.110.)
- Provides that these provisions do not restrict a business’ ability to collect, use, retain, sell, share, or disclose consumers’ personal information that is deidentified or aggregate consumer information. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(a)(6).)
- Defines “personal information” as information that identifies, relates to, describes, is reasonably capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. The CCPA provides a nonexclusive series of categories of information deemed to be personal information, including biometric information, geolocation data, and “sensitive personal information.” It does not include publicly available information or lawfully obtained, truthful information that is a matter of public concern. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(v).)
- Establishes the Unfair Practices Act (UPA), which is intended to safeguard the public against the creation or perpetuation of monopolies and to foster and encourage competition by prohibiting unfair, dishonest, deceptive, destructive, fraudulent, and discriminatory practices by which fair and honest competition is destroyed or prevented. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17000 et seq.)
- Provides that the secret payment of allowances of rebates, refunds, commissions, or unearned discounts, whether in the form of money or otherwise, or secretly extending to certain purchasers special services or privileges not extended to all purchasers upon like terms and conditions, to the injury of a competitor and where such payment or allowance tends to destroy competition, is unlawful. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17045.)
- Establishes a general prohibition on unfair competition, known as the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which covers any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, and any act prohibited under the False Advertising Law. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200.)
This bill:
- Prohibits “surveillance pricing,” defined as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information collected through electronic surveillance technology. “Surveillance pricing” includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Defines “covered information” as both aggregate consumer information and personally identifiable information, as defined in the CCPA.
- Provides that a person does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
- The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.
- A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to, signing up for a mailing list, registering for promotional communications, or participating in a promotional event.
- A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group, including, but not limited to, teachers, veterans, senior citizens, or students, based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.
- A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program that consumers affirmatively enroll in.
- The person operates as an insurer complying with Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code and the pricing is in connection with that activity, as provided.
- Requires the discounted price offered in b), c), or d) above to comply with the following:
- The eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any covered information is collected.
- The discount or reward shall be offered uniformly to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
- Provides that any covered information collected pursuant to the exceptions above shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.
- Subjects a person that violates these provisions, in addition to any other remedy at law, to liability for a civil penalty not to exceed $12,500 for each violation, with each violation constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved. Intentional violations are subject to trebling, and a person in violation shall be required to disgorge all revenues earned thereby. A prevailing plaintiff shall be awarded reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. A court may also award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary.
- Provides that a person is not in violation if the refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific consumer, is based on information contained in a consumer report, as defined.
- Makes any waiver void and unenforceable.
- Clarifies that the rights, remedies, and penalties are cumulative to any others.
- Finds and declares that it furthers the purposes of the CPRA.
COMMENTS
- Surveillance pricing
Surveillance pricing is a practice where companies collect extensive personal data about consumers to implement individualized pricing strategies. Instead of charging everyone the same price, businesses utilize collected data, often using algorithms to analyze personal information, and set different prices for different customers based on their perceived willingness or ability to pay.
Companies gather data through multiple channels including purchase history, browsing behavior, location tracking, demographic information, social media activity, and even biometric data. This information gets fed into sophisticated algorithms that create detailed consumer profiles. These profiles predict how much each individual might be willing to pay for a product or service, enabling companies to charge personalized prices that maximize revenue extraction from each customer.
The practice extends beyond simple demographic targeting. Companies can factor in real-time data like current location, the device a consumer is using, shopping patterns, and even a consumer’s emotional state inferred from online behavior.
The mass collection of consumer data as an asset is not new, but has rapidly expanded beyond just targeted advertising. This commodification of personal information has been dubbed “surveillance capitalism” by social psychologist, Shoshana Zuboff:
As we move into the third decade of the 21st century, surveillance capitalism is the dominant economic institution of our time. In the absence of countervailing law, this system successfully mediates nearly every aspect of human engagement with digital information. The promise of the surveillance dividend now draws surveillance economics into the “normal” economy, from insurance, retail, banking and finance to agriculture, automobiles, education, health care and more. . . .
An economic order founded on the secret massive-scale extraction of human data assumes the destruction of privacy as a nonnegotiable condition of its business operations. With privacy out of the way, ill-gotten human data are concentrated within private corporations, where they are claimed as corporate assets to be deployed at will.[1]
Surveillance pricing creates several significant problems for consumers. Most fundamentally, it enables price discrimination that can be both unfair and exploitative. People may pay vastly different amounts for identical goods or services based on algorithmic assessments of their personal circumstances rather than the actual value of what they are purchasing.
This system particularly harms vulnerable populations. Consumers with limited mobility, those in underserved areas with fewer alternatives, or people facing urgent needs may be charged premium prices precisely when they have the least ability to shop around. The elderly, disabled individuals, and those with chronic health conditions often face higher prices for essential goods and services.
The practice also creates market inefficiencies and reduces genuine price competition. When companies can extract maximum revenue through personalized pricing rather than competing on value, it reduces incentives for innovation and quality improvements. Consumers lose the benefit of competitive markets driving prices down.
Perhaps most concerning is how opaque these practices are. Companies rarely disclose when and how they are using surveillance pricing, let alone explain what data they are collecting or how their algorithms work. Consumers typically have no way to know whether they are receiving a fair price or being charged a premium based on their personal profile.
This lack of transparency extends to the data collection itself. Many consumers are unaware of the extent to which their online and offline activities are being monitored and monetized. Companies often collect data through data brokers, making it nearly impossible for individuals to understand what information exists about them or how it is being used to determine prices.
The algorithmic nature of these systems adds another layer of opacity. Even when companies acknowledge using personalized pricing, they typically claim their algorithms are proprietary trade secrets. This makes it extremely difficult for consumers, regulators, or researchers to understand how pricing decisions are made or to identify discriminatory practices. A 2021 study from George Washington University found that Uber and Lyft charged, on average, higher prices for pickups and drop-offs in predominantly non-white neighborhoods or neighborhoods with lower incomes.[2] The opacity of the pricing model makes it impossible to determine whether there are legitimate bases for the disparities or whether unlawful discrimination is being carried out.
The practice has prompted the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to conduct a market study:
“Initial staff findings show that retailers frequently use people’s personal information to set targeted, tailored prices for goods and services—from a person's location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage,” said FTC Chair Lina M. Khan. “The FTC should continue to investigate surveillance pricing practices because Americans deserve to know how their private data is being used to set the prices they pay and whether firms are charging different people different prices for the same good or service.”
. . .
The staff perspective found that some [] respondents can determine individualized and different pricing and discounts based on granular consumer data, like a cosmetics company targeting promotions to specific skin types and skin tones. The perspective also found that the intermediaries the FTC examined can show higher priced products based on consumers’ search and purchase activity. As one hypothetical outlined, a consumer who is profiled as a new parent may intentionally be shown higher priced baby thermometers on the first page of their search results.
The FTC staff found that the intermediaries worked with at least 250 clients that sell goods or services ranging from grocery stores to apparel retailers. The FTC found that widespread adoption of this practice may fundamentally upend how consumers buy products and how companies compete.
Recently, an investigation led to Target agreeing to pay $5 million in civil penalties and to change its pricing practices:
The lawsuit and judgement come after a KARE 11 investigation uncovered certain prices in the Target app switching when customers walked into the store.
“We learned of your news story that showed changes on the app depending on the location,” said Steve Spinella, deputy district attorney for San Diego County. “We conducted our own independent investigation to see if this was also occurring in California.”
Spinella joined six other county prosecutors in California and recently sued target, accusing the chain of charging customers higher prices than advertised.
According to the civil complaint, prosecutors found prices posted for various items on Target.com or the Target app that then switched when a customer entered the perimeter of the store without “clearly and conspicuously disclosing the sales channel.”[3]
- Prohibiting surveillance pricing
This bill prohibits surveillance pricing. According to the author:
With the rise of artificial intelligence and data collection, businesses increasingly use personal data to set prices, often leading to unfair and discriminatory pricing practices. This legislation aims to establish safeguards that ensure transparency, fairness, and consumer protections in pricing algorithms. AB 446 will prohibit the practice of surveillance pricing by making it unlawful for businesses to use personal data when charging different prices for the same product, or service whether online or during in-store checkout.
The bill defines “surveillance pricing” as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information collected through electronic surveillance technology. This includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments. This does not include situations where the difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the goods or services to different consumers.
The bill also provides a number of discounting practices that do not fall within this ban. For instance, discounted prices can be provided under certain circumstances and when sufficient transparency and fairness is ensured. This includes offering reduced prices through loyalty, membership, or rewards programs when consumers affirmatively enroll in them. In addition, where the eligibility criteria is publicly disclosed, discounts can be offered to members of broadly defined groups, such as veterans or students, or through mailing lists that consumers sign up for.
To ensure consumers are protected and made aware of the schemes, the eligibility criteria, available discounts, and any conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward shall be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any covered information is collected. The discount or reward must be offered uniformly to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
To protect the privacy of consumers, any covered information collected shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program, and shall not be used for any other purpose, including, but not limited to, profiling, targeted advertising, or individualized price setting.
The bill provides carve outs for certain insurance pricing or financial transactions that comply with specified laws.
Violations are subject to civil penalties of up to $12,500 for each violation. Damages are trebled for intentional violations.
- Stakeholder positions
UFCW Western States Council, a sponsor of the bill, explains the need for the bill:
Surveillance Pricing Should Be Prohibited Because It Exacerbates Inequality, Especially as Applied To Necessities Like Food.
In October 2024, an explosive news report found that Kroger, one of the largest grocery store chains in the United States,[4] was exploring the use of facial recognition technology in its stores. Immediately, shoppers and public officials worried that consumers’ faces might be used, along with other intimate data, to deliver different prices for different consumers.
Surveillance pricing exacerbates economic inequality. “Higher-income consumers may receive discounts, while those with less disposable income might face higher prices. Surveillance pricing can further entrench these inequalities, like how credit scores impact loan rates or zip codes affect insurance premiums. Marginalized communities, including people of color and low-income individuals, are particularly vulnerable to higher prices due to algorithmic biases[.]”
Consumer Watchdog, the other sponsor of the bill, writes:
Unfortunately, the FTC shelved public comment into surveillance pricing, which makes the work of California legislators that much more important. A.B. 446 aims to address these concerns by prohibiting businesses from setting prices based on personally identifiable information gathered through electronic surveillance. The bill seeks to bar companies from using race, religion, residence, sexuality, political interests, web browsing and purchase history, financial circumstances, and consumer behaviors in setting prices. The bill also outlines civil penalties for violations, ensuring that consumers are protected from such practices.
With prices for essential goods such as groceries up 30 percent since the beginning of the decade, and Kroger’s plan to roll out digital price tags and facial recognition technology, the time to act is now.
Plain and simple: Companies shouldn’t have to surveil us in order to sell products. Companies are sitting on mountains of personal data—much of it incorrect—that feed this digital auction of exploitation and e-commerce algorithms. By supporting A.B. 446, you can put California on the road to being the first state in the country to address surveillance pricing. AB 446 demonstrates a commitment to consumer rights and privacy, ensuring that all Californians are treated fairly in the marketplace. One product, one price.
A broad coalition of groups, including Economic Security CA Action and the Black Women for Wellness Action Project, write in support:
This bill will prevent companies from exploiting consumers' personal data to maximize profits at a time when average households are struggling with the rising costs of basic necessities. According to the U.S. Labor Department’s Bureau of Labor Statistics, current average consumer prices are up 23% since 2019, with some categories even higher, like food, rising about 30% over the same period.
AB 446 will protect consumers' privacy and their right to fair and equitable pricing.
A large coalition of industry associations, including the Association of National Advertisers and the California New Car Dealers Association, write in opposition:
AB 446 conflicts with the approach of the CCPA because it treats “aggregate consumer information” as if it were “personal information,” in explicit contradiction of Civil Code 1798.140. As a policy matter, we believe this is incorrect; information that has been deidentified and aggregated is not personal information under the CCPA, nor should it be here. Such data is not a risk of individual profiling or discrimination exactly because it is deidentified or aggregated. That is why, as a matter of public policy, aggregated data and personal data are not treated the same because they neither implicate the same rights for consumers nor pose the same risks in the event of a data leak.
An example helps illustrate how “aggregate consumer information” is used, and how non-problematic it is. Supermarket #1, who is planning on selling pumpkin pie mix in October, is concerned they may have too much pumpkin pie mix on hand in late September, and they have a new shipment coming on October 1. Under present law, they can look at their past aggregate purchase history of all their consumers from last year during October (from which all their customer names and other identifying data has been removed) to see how much pumpkin pie mix was purchased last October (which would qualify as aggregate data under the CCPA and does not require consumer opt-in to utilize) to determine whether they are overstocked and should offer a sale this year. After reviewing their supply, and last year’s aggregate sale volume, they can decide whether to offer a quick sale to get rid of soon-to-be-excess inventory. However, under AB 446, Supermarket #1 could not review last year’s sales data because it would qualify as “covered information” and Supermarket #1 had not met the new consent requirements that AB 446 will require for every customer who shopped at their store last year. Without such consent from every shopper, even totally anonymous data such as the date, items, and price of their purchases would necessitate opt-in by consumers. Because AB 446 treats personal data and aggregate data the same, merging them as “covered information,” the same onerous (and CCPA-conflicting) disclosure requirements applicable to personal information would apply to aggregate data.
The bill does include within its surveillance pricing definition “covered information,” which includes both “personally identifiable information” and “aggregate consumer information.” The former borrows its meaning from the CCPA, but as stated, aggregated data is carved out in the CCPA.
In response to the concerns of opposition, the author has agreed to an amendment that removes aggregate consumer information from the definition of “covered information,” focusing solely on personally identifiable information.
The opposition coalition also strongly objects to the private right of action in the bill:
[E]mployers will need to consider whether their present discounts fit into the listed permissible exceptions and even if they believe that their discounts could qualify the company still has to weigh the costs and risks of litigation to defend their discounts. We expect this to cause many businesses to: (a) stop offering discounts which do not fit AB 446’s terms; (b) choose to cancel even potentially compliant discounts because the cost of potential litigation and shakedown demand letters is too great.
In response to these concerns, the author has agreed to an amendment that limits enforcement actions for civil penalties to public prosecutors. Consumers may only bring actions for injunctive relief along with costs and reasonable attorney’s fees.
To ensure consumers can still receive discounts, where there is clear transparency about the information being used and meaningful consent, the author has agreed to an amendment that allows offering a discounted price after a consumer directly and knowingly provides specific personally identifiable information for the purpose of obtaining a discount. The nature and purpose of the consumer’s disclosure of personal information must be conveyed in clear and prominent terms in such a manner that an ordinary consumer would notice and understand it. To ensure consumers are fully aware of the basis for the differential pricing allowed by the bill, the author’s amendment will require that any personally identifiable information provided for the purpose of receiving a discounted price is not augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means.
Additional amendments have also been agreed to that respond to other opposition concerns. This includes extending the exceptions to cover consumer programs that consumers purchase and to allow for discounts to residents of a certain area. In addition, the amendments expand the lending exemption and provide that a person is not in violation if the pricing or specific terms of extending credit, refusal to extend credit on specific terms, or the refusal to enter into a transaction with a specific commercial enterprise, is based on information contained in a commercial credit report, defined under Civil Code Section 1785.42. An amendment requested by the insurance industry is also being taken to clarify that the insurer exception applies to a person that operates as an insurer as defined by relevant law.
SUPPORT
Consumer Watchdog (sponsor)
UFCW - Western States Council (sponsor)
American Economic Liberties Project
American Federation of Musicians, Local 7
Black Women for Wellness Action Project
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO
California Food and Farming Network
California Low-income Consumer Coalition
California National Organization for Women
California Nurses Association
California Safety and Legislative Board, Smart – Transportation Division (SMART – TD)
California School Employees Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (SEIU California)
Center on Policy Initiatives
CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT, AFL-CIO
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Courage California
Economic Security California Action
Equal Rights Advocates
LAANE (Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy)
National Consumer Law Center, INC.
Oakland Privacy
Powerswitch Action
Techequity Action
United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Working Partnerships USA
OPPOSITION
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Equipment Distributors
Association of National Advertisers
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association of California
CalBroadband
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Grocers Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Retailers Association
California Travel Association
Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce
Chamber of Progress
Chino Valley Chamber of Commerce
Corona Chamber of Commerce
CTIA
Cupertino Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
LA Cañada Flintridge Chamber of Commerce and Community Association
Lake Elsinore Valley Chamber of Commerce
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Mission Viejo Chamber of Commerce
Naiop California
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Paso Robles and Templeton Chamber of Commerce
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Mirage Chamber of Commerce
San Juan Capistrano Chamber of Commerce
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Software Information Industry Association
TechNet
The Travel Technology Association
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
USTelecom - the Broadband Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: SB 259 (Wahab, 2025) establishes the Fair Online Pricing Act, which prohibits a price offered to a consumer through the consumer’s online device, as defined, from being generated in whole, or in part, based on any of certain input data, including the presence or absence of any software on the online device or its geolocation data. SB 259 is currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation: None known.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 47, Noes 20)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 3)
**************
Zuboff, Shoshana, You Are the Object of a Secret Extraction Operation (November 12, 2021) The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/12/opinion/facebook-privacy.html. All internet citations are current as of July 9, 2025. ↑
Akshat Pandey and Aylin Caliskan, Disparate Impact of Artificial Intelligence Bias in Ridehailing Economy's Price Discrimination Algorithms (May 3, 2021) arXiv, https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.04599. ↑
Chris Hrapsky, Target settles lawsuit alleging false advertising, overpricing; fined $5M (April 27, 2022) KARE 11 News, https://www.kare11.com/article/news/local/kare11-extras/target-settles-ca-lawsuit-alleging-false-advertising-overpricing-fined-5m/89-ba4a5441-c38e-4c9f-b524-b0d13414042f. ↑
https://therecord.media/kroger-facial-recognition-lawmakers-concerns. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 446
Author:(Ward)
As Amended Ver:May 1, 2025
Majority vote
SUMMARY
This bill prohibits the use of surveillance-derived data to set or offer a price to a consumer based on information collected through various electronic surveillance technologies. This bill makes exceptions to using collected information for price setting including for group discounts and loyalty programs as well as exempts insurers and creditors from this prohibition. The bill also establishes a private right of action to pursue violators.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits a person from engaging in surveillance pricing which is defined as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on personal or aggregate information, as defined in the California Consumer Privacy Act, collected through electronic surveillance technology.
- Clarifies that "surveillance pricing" includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered information about a consumer's behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Exempts price setting that is based solely on the cost of providing the service or good to different consumers, discounts offered for broadly defined groups (e.g., teachers, seniors, students), discounts for loyalty programs, and other discounts that are the result of publically disclosed eligibility requirements. This bill also exempts insurers and financial institutions that vary loan terms based on contents of a consumer report governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act.
- Establishes that all eligibility criteria for qualifying discounts be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any data is collected and that such discounts be offered uniformly to similarly situated consumers.
- Establishes a civil penalty of up to $12,500 for a person who violates this bill, further stipulates that in the case of intentional violations the penalties may be trebled and the businesses must disgorge revenues earned from the violation, and provides for injunctive and declaratory relief and attorney's fees for prevailing plaintiffs.
COMMENTS
Surveillance pricing, also known as individualized pricing, uses AI or other technology for the real-time processing of personal information about a consumer to set a price specific to that consumer. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has described surveillance pricing as "an ecosystem designed to use large-scale data collection to help sellers maximize their revenues by customizing the pricing, as well as the selection of products and services, offered to each consumer."[1]
It is important to distinguish surveillance pricing from dynamic pricing, which adjusts prices in response to market demand. For example, Ticketmaster uses dynamic pricing to increase ticket prices for all consumers when demand rises.[2] In contrast, surveillance pricing treats each consumer as their own economy, using algorithms to assess their willingness to pay based on personal information such as browsing history, purchase behavior, and location.
In 2022, Target was found to have used an algorithm to adjust the price of a TV once a customer entered the parking lot, leading to a $5 million settlement with the City of San Diego for false advertising and unfair business practices related to surveillance pricing.[3] Similarly, an investigative journalist from the SF Gate recently reported that Bay Area consumers are offered a higher price than users in either Phoenix or Kansas City for the same exact hotel reservations on various hotel booking websites, suggesting that geolocation information was used to inform the price setting.[4]
Moreover, the use of AI to set prices raises concerns regarding biases within the algorithms that may disadvantage different groups. A 2021 study from George Washington University found that Uber and Lyft charged, on average, higher prices for pickups and drop-offs in predominantly non-white neighborhoods or neighborhoods with lower incomes.[5] While it is unclear whether these disparities stem from market forces or algorithmic bias because these companies use opaque algorithms to set prices, a possible conclusion is that algorithmic price setting could reinforce structural inequities.
Because businesses often operate without transparency, the extent of surveillance pricing remains uncertain. In the summer of 2024, the Federal Trade Commission launched a study to investigate how companies leverage AI, other technologies, and consumer data to set individualized prices. A preliminary report released in January revealed that at least 250 businesses have adopted technologies capable of implementing surveillance pricing. Lina Khan, former FTC Chair, concludes in this report:
"Initial staff findings show that retailers frequently use people's personal information to set targeted, tailored prices for goods and services—from a person's location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage. The FTC should continue to investigate surveillance pricing practices because Americans deserve to know how their private data is being used to set the prices they pay and whether firms are charging different people different prices for the same good or service."[6]
For a full discussion of surveillance pricing please see the policy committees' analyses of this bill.
According to the Author
AB 446 will prohibit the practice of surveillance pricing by making it unlawful for businesses to use personal data when charging different prices for the same product, or service whether online or during in-store checkout. This will ensure that consumers have the right to the price that would have been offered if no personal data was used in generating the price. At a time when prices for basic necessities are rising across the board, it is more critical than ever to ensure that people are not being unfairly charged higher prices due to their actual or perceived characteristics. [This] disproportionately affects lower-income individuals and those with fewer shopping alternatives. Ensuring fairness in pricing is not just about economic justice—it is about preventing a new form of digital exploitation. Without legal protections and stronger regulations, companies will continue to use these opaque practices to maximize profits at the expense of ordinary people, making essential goods and services even more inaccessible. The right to fair pricing should not be a privilege for the few but a fundamental protection for all.
Arguments in Support
UFCW Western States Council, a cosponsor of this bill, argues:
A too-often overlooked aspect of functioning markets is how they permit personal autonomy and freedom. Rather than only being able to build personal wealth by working for a giant company, an individual armed with a good idea, some savings or modest capital, and grit, can in a competitive market choose to earn a living by profitably working for themselves.
But, if a pre-requisite to being able to compete profitably in every market is access to the world's biggest computers, the richest repositories of personal behavioral data, and most powerful AI, such entrepreneurial individual choices and freedoms become either impossible or restrained only to tiny, Etsy-like, boutique ambitions.
And then there is the loss of freedom that is caused by a person becoming a product themselves against their will or knowledge, with the insult-to-injury result that the unwitting person-product is financially poorer than they would have been otherwise. As Harvard Professor Shoshana Zuboff has passionately written:
"Right now, [] the extreme asymmetries of knowledge and power that have accrued to unilaterally rendered as data, expropriated, and repurposed in new forms of social control, all of it in the service of others' interests and in the absence of our awareness8 or means of combat."
Arguments in Opposition
>: A coalition of industry groups, led by the Chamber of Commerce, argue:
To be clear: we do not support any targeting of consumers based on protected characteristics. Price changes based on race, religion, sexuality, or political beliefs have no place in our democratic, individual rights-based capitalist system. However, we are very concerned that AB 446 will place civil penalties on non-problematic and widely-accepted practices (such as membership rewards programs, local discounts, or appropriate advertising) because of its overbroad language.
[…]
AB 446's broad language prohibits "surveillance pricing," which it defines as "offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information …" AB 446 uses civil penalties and a private right of action to enforce this prohibition. Notably, AB 446's broad definition of surveillance pricing prohibits not just cost increases, but also any discounts offered to consumers based on any aggregate or personal data
[…]
While we appreciate and support the intention of this bill—to ensure California consumers are treated fairly and without discrimination—we are very concerned by its infringement upon the CCPA, and the collateral damage that its broad language will have for California businesses. We have shared amendments to address our concerns, while maintaining the core of the bill (prohibiting the use of personal information to target prices at consumers), but they have not been accepted as of the date of this letter.
FISCAL COMMENTS
No Fiscal Impact
VOTES
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 10-3-2
YES: Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Irwin, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Ortega, Pellerin, Ward, Wicks, Wilson
NO: Dixon, DeMaio, Ellis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson, Petrie-Norris
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-1
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Papan, Stefani, Zbur
NO: Dixon, Macedo, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco
UPDATED
VERSION: May 1, 2025
CONSULTANT: John Bennett / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000355
Federal Trade Commission, "Issue Spotlight: The Rise of Surveillance Pricing" (January 17, 2025), https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-surveillance-pricing-study-indicates-wide-range-personal-data-used-set-individualized-consumer. ↑
Cody Mello-Klein, "What is dynamic pricing and why is it hiking ticket prices for Oasis, Taylor Swift and your favorite artist?" Northeastern Global News (Oct. 2, 2024), https://news.northeastern.edu/2024/10/02/dynamic-pricing-ticketmaster-oasis-taylor-swift/. ↑
Chris Hrapsky, "Target settles lawsuit alleging false advertising, overpricing; fined $5M", KARE (Apr. 27, 2022), https://www.kare11.com/article/news/local/kare11-extras/target-settles-ca-lawsuit-alleging-false-advertising-overpricing-fined-5m/89-ba4a5441-c38e-4c9f-b524-b0d13414042f. ↑
Keith A. Spencer, "Hotel booking sites show higher prices to travelers from Bay Area," SFGATE (Feb. 3, 2025), https://www.sfgate.com/travel/article/hotel-booking-sites-overcharge-bay-area-travelers-20025145.php. ↑
Akshat Pandey and Aylin Caliskan, "Disparate Impact of Artificial Intelligence Bias in Ridehailing Economy's Price Discrimination Algorithms" arXiv (May 3, 2021), https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.04599. ↑
Federal Trade Commission, "FTC Surveillance Pricing Study Indicates Wide Range of Personal Data Used to Set Individualized Consumer Prices" (Mar. 10, 2025), https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-surveillance-pricing-study-indicates-wide-range-personal-data-used-set-individualized-consumer. ↑
Date of Hearing: May 6, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 446
Author:(Ward) – As Amended Ver:May 1, 2025
SUBJECT: Surveillance pricing
KEY ISSUE: Should California prohibit businesses from using surveillance-derived data to vary prices between consumers for the same good or service—unless the price difference is based on cost, disclosed and uniformly available discount criteria, group status, or other narrowly defined exceptions—in order to prevent opaque and discriminatory pricing practices?
SYNOPSIS
This bill prohibits the practice of “surveillance pricing,” whereby a business offers or sets a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers based on personal or aggregate data collected through electronic surveillance technology. The bill targets a growing pricing model that uses data such as location, browser history, device usage, or behavioral profiling to infer a consumer’s willingness or ability to pay and adjust prices accordingly—often without the consumer’s knowledge. In response to stakeholder concerns, recent amendments to this bill significantly restructure the measure. AB 446 now expressly exempts from the surveillance pricing prohibition: (1) price differences based solely on actual cost differentials; (2) publicly disclosed promotional discounts; (3) group-based discounts (e.g., for seniors, students, or veterans); (4) discounts offered through loyalty or membership programs affirmatively joined by the consumer; (5) pricing by insurers regulated under the Insurance Code; and (6) pricing decisions based solely on consumer reports governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). The bill requires that eligibility criteria for qualifying discounts be clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any data is collected and that such discounts be offered uniformly to similarly situated consumers. Covered information collected under an exemption may only be used to administer the discount or program and may not be repurposed for profiling, targeted advertising, or further individualized price setting. Civil penalties of up to $12,500 per violation apply, with treble penalties and disgorgement for intentional violations. The bill also provides for injunctive and declaratory relief and attorney’s fees for prevailing plaintiffs. Opponents continue to raise concerns about the bill’s necessity and scope, but the recent amendments appear designed to meaningfully narrow its impact and respond to the core objections.
This measure is co-sponsored by Consumer Watchdog and United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council, and is supported by numerous consumer rights and labor organizations, including the California Nurses Association, Oakland Privacy, and California Federation of Labor Unions. The bill is opposed by a variety of business trade associations, including the California Chamber of Commerce and the American Advertising Federation. This measure previously passed the Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection by a 10-3 vote.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the practice of “surveillance pricing” and establishes enforcement provisions. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “aggregate information” as data about groups or categories of consumers, from which individual identities have been removed and which is not linkable to a particular consumer or household, including via a device.
- Defines “covered information” as either personally identifiable information or aggregate consumer information.
- Defines “surveillance pricing” as offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers, based, in whole or in part, on covered information collected through electronic surveillance technology.
- Clarifies that “surveillance pricing” includes the use of technological methods, systems, or tools, including, but not limited to, sensors, cameras, device tracking, biometric monitoring, or other forms of observation or data collection, that are capable of gathering covered information about a consumer’s behavior, characteristics, location, or other personal attributes, whether in physical or digital environments.
- Incorporates the definition of “personally identifiable information” from the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and also provides that, for purposes of the bill, this term includes deidentified or aggregated consumer information.
- Prohibits a person from engaging in surveillance pricing.
- Exempts the following from prohibition:
- Price differences based solely on costs of providing the good or service to different consumers.
- Discounts based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, such as signing up for a mailing list or participating in promotions.
- Discounts for members of broadly defined groups (e.g., teachers, seniors, students) based on publicly disclosed criteria.
- Discounts offered through loyalty, membership, or rewards programs that consumers affirmatively enroll in.
- Insurance companies whose pricing practices are governed by existing insurance law.
- Clarifies that a refusal to extend credit or enter into a transaction based solely on information in a consumer report governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is not a violation.
- Establishes that a discounted price offered pursuant to 7b-d) must:
- Have eligibility criteria, discount terms, and conditions clearly and conspicuously disclosed before any covered information is collected.
- Be applied uniformly to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.
- Provides that any covered information collected for the purposes described in 7) must be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing, or loyalty program.
- Prohibits the use of covered information for any purpose, including, but not limited to profiling, targeted advertising, or individualizes price setting.
- Subjects violators to a civil penalty not to exceed $12,500 for each violation, with each violation of this part constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.
- Subjects intentional violators to a civil penalty no greater than three times the civil penalty, and disgorgement of all revenues earned from the violation.
- Provides a prevailing plaintiff in an action with reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Provides for injunctive or declaratory relief.
- Provides that waivers of the bill are against public policy and are void and unenforceable.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that, among other rights, all people have an inalienable right to pursue and obtain privacy. (California Constitution, Article 1, Section 1.)
- Establishes the Unruh Civil Rights Act. (Civil Code Section 51.)
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. Places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civil Code Section 1798.100 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency and vests it with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the CCPA. (Civil Code Section 1798.199.10.)
- Establishes the Unfair Practices Act (UPA), which is intended to safeguard the public against the creation or perpetuation of monopolies and to foster and encourage competition, by prohibiting unfair, dishonest, deceptive, destructive, fraudulent and discriminatory practices by which fair and honest competition is destroyed or prevented. (Business and Professions Code Section 17000 et seq.)
- Prohibits, under the UPA, a range of behavior that reduces competition in pricing, including specified locality discrimination in pricing, sales under costs or loss leaders made with the intent of injuring competitors or destroying competition, and contracts for the performance of warranty service and repair below the cost of the service or repair. (Business and Professions Code Sections 17040-17051.)
- For purposes of investigating potential violations of the UPA, extends all of the investigative powers granted to the Attorney General to the district attorney of any county when the district attorney reasonably believes that a violation has occurred. (Business and Professions Code Section 16759 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Over the past decade, advances in artificial intelligence, machine learning, and data collection technologies have given rise to a new and largely unregulated pricing model known as surveillance pricing—a form of individualized price discrimination in which businesses use real-time consumer data to set different prices for the same good or service based on a consumer’s perceived willingness or ability to pay. This data may include the consumer’s location, device type, browsing history, financial characteristics, or behavioral profile. The price is then algorithmically adjusted to maximize the seller’s profit from that individual consumer.
While California law provides some of the strongest privacy protections in the nation through the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), existing law does not restrict businesses from using lawfully collected consumer data to change their internal pricing. The CCPA was designed to increase transparency and give consumers control over their data—but it does not prohibit a business from using that data to charge a consumer more, as long as that practice is disclosed or purportedly tied to the “value provided” by the data. In practice, this creates a loophole that permits forms of digital economic discrimination. This measure seeks to address that problem.
As explained by the author:
AB 446 will prohibit the practice of surveillance pricing by making it unlawful for businesses to use personal data when charging different prices for the same product, or service whether online or during in-store checkout. This will ensure that consumers have the right to the price that would have been offered if no personal data was used in generating the price. At a time when prices for basic necessities are rising across the board, it is more critical than ever to ensure that people are not being unfairly charged higher prices due to their actual or perceived characteristics. [This] disproportionately affects lower-income individuals and those with fewer shopping alternatives. Ensuring fairness in pricing is not just about economic justice—it is about preventing a new form of digital exploitation. Without legal protections and stronger regulations, companies will continue to use these opaque practices to maximize profits at the expense of ordinary people, making essential goods and services even more inaccessible. The right to fair pricing should not be a privilege for the few but a fundamental protection for all.
Supporters of AB 446 argue that the bill addresses a pressing and underregulated form of algorithmic manipulation in modern commerce. They assert that surveillance pricing allows companies to exploit invisible data asymmetries to extract higher prices from those perceived as desperate, isolated, or wealthy—often without the consumer’s knowledge that they are being charged more than others for the same product. This pricing model, they argue, threatens to entrench economic inequality and undermine the principle of market fairness. By preventing the use of surveillance-derived data in price setting and requiring pricing programs to operate on transparent, uniform terms, AB 446 seeks to ensure that consumers pay fair prices based on real value—not on algorithmic predictions of how much they can be squeezed.
The problem & legal background. Surveillance pricing—the practice of using real-time consumer data to adjust the price of goods or services for specific individuals—has emerged as a pervasive and largely unregulated feature of the digital economy. Enabled by advances in artificial intelligence, biometric surveillance, and algorithmic profiling, this pricing model allows businesses to extract maximum profit from each consumer based not on market conditions or product costs, but on a predictive assessment of the consumer’s personal habits, financial capacity, or perceived willingness to pay.
Surveillance pricing is distinct from traditional dynamic pricing, in which prices change uniformly for all consumers based on time, demand, or inventory. Instead, surveillance pricing relies on individualized inputs such as browsing history, ZIP code, geolocation, device type, demographic data, purchase patterns, and even biometric characteristics. These data points—collected through cookies, mobile apps, facial recognition, or sensor-equipped shelves—are analyzed to generate behavioral profiles and assign different prices to different consumers for the same product or service.
Real-world examples illustrate the risks. In 2022, the County of San Diego settled a $5 million lawsuit against Target Corporation for using consumers’ location data to increase online prices when a customer physically entered a store’s parking lot—without clear disclosure. (Associated Press, Target pays $5 million to settle California pricing lawsuit, Dec. 6, 2022, available at https://apnews.com/article/technology-business-lawsuits-california-target-corp-35db1e4f1ea1d43ef7a1f7f2b4630c41.) In January 2025, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) released findings from its surveillance pricing inquiry, revealing that over 250 businesses had adopted systems capable of using personal data to algorithmically tailor prices. (FTC Press Release, FTC Surveillance Pricing Study Indicates Wide Range of Personal Data Used to Set Individualized Consumer Prices, Jan. 29, 2025 available at https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-surveillance-pricing-study-indicates-wide-range-personal-data-used-set-individualized-consumer.) Former FTC Chair Lina Khan noted that retailers routinely rely on “a person’s location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage,” to determine individualized prices. (Id.) Investigative reporting from SF Gate further confirmed that major hotel booking websites offered Bay Area consumers rates up to $500 higher than identical listings shown to users in less affluent cities—despite identical booking parameters. (SF Gate, Hotel sites quietly raising prices based on your location, January 12, 2025, available at https://www.sfgate.com/travel/article/hotel-booking-sites-overcharge-bay-area-travelers-20025145.php.)
While companies claim that such models improve pricing efficiency, critics argue that surveillance pricing redistributes consumer surplus entirely to the seller—leaving buyers with diminished bargaining power and no visibility into the pricing algorithm. The result is a non-transparent and inequitable digital marketplace in which consumers may unknowingly pay more based on private inferences drawn from their data profiles.
Despite California’s strong consumer privacy framework under the CCPA and the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020, existing law does not prohibit surveillance pricing. The CCPA provides consumers with rights to opt out of the sale or sharing of their personal information (Civil Code Section 1798.120) and mandates notice at collection (Civil Code Section 1798.100). However, it also permits businesses to charge different prices to consumers based on the “value provided to the business by the consumer’s data” (Civil Code Section 1798.125 (b)), a provision that may inadvertently authorize surveillance pricing as long as the practice is disclosed.
The absence of substantive legal limits on these practices leaves consumers with little recourse. Surveillance pricing often operates invisibly, making it difficult for consumers to detect that they are being charged more than others. There is no obligation for companies to disclose individualized pricing, no way for consumers to compare prices offered to others, and no regulatory mechanism to prevent price discrimination based on income, race, geography, or inferred behavior.
In the absence of legislative intervention, surveillance pricing risks becoming the industry default—deepening inequality, normalizing digital redlining, and undermining consumer trust in fair market practices.
How this bill works. AB 446 establishes a high-level prohibition on the use of surveillance-derived data to set or offer different prices to a consumer, making it unlawful for a business to vary the price of a good or service based in whole or in part on information collected through electronic surveillance technologies.
By prohibiting the use of covered information—defined as personally identifiable information or aggregate information—to individualize prices, AB 446 eliminates the core mechanism that enables opaque and discriminatory pricing models. The bill defines “surveillance pricing” to include that which uses both physical and digital surveillance technologies—such as facial recognition, sensors, geolocation tracking, and behavioral monitoring—ensuring that the law applies across both online platforms and brick-and-mortar retail environments.
AB 446 prohibits businesses from using surveillance-derived data—such as a consumer’s location, browser history, or behavioral profile—to set individualized prices, but it preserves a range of common, legitimate pricing practices through narrowly drawn exemptions. Specifically, AB 446 does not interfere with:
- Cost-based pricing differentials;
- Publicly disclosed discounts based on promotional events or mailing list sign-ups;
- Group discounts (e.g., for students, seniors, veterans);
- Loyalty or membership programs that consumers affirmatively opt into;
- Lawful insurance underwriting practices under the Insurance Code;
- Credit denials or transaction refusals based solely on information from a consumer report governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. Section 1681a(d)).
So, for example, under these exemptions, a furniture retailer may lawfully charge $75 to deliver a couch to a home in the Sierra Foothills, while charging only $25 for delivery to a central Sacramento address, because the price difference reflects actual cost differentials in transportation and logistics—not profiling based on personal attributes. Similarly, a skincare company may offer 10% off to anyone who signs up for its mailing list, or offer 50% off to customers who recently unsubscribed in an effort to win them back—as long as the reason for the discount is clearly disclosed and available to all consumers in the same situation. Group discounts, such as a movie theater offering $3 off tickets to seniors age 65 and older or $2 off for college students with a valid student ID, are also allowed under the bill, provided that the eligibility criteria are made public and applied uniformly. A grocery chain may run a loyalty program that gives members one free item for every 10 purchases, so long as the program is opt-in and the benefits are consistent across all participants, regardless of their individual purchasing behavior. AB 446 also exempts insurance companies whose pricing practices are governed by existing insurance law. This is meant to allow the continuation of risk-based insurance underwriting practices that comply with the Insurance Code and Proposition 103—for example, allowing a car insurer to lawfully, and reasonably, charge higher premiums to drivers with recent DUI convictions than to those with clean records. Finally, the bill preserves the ability of financial institutions to deny credit or vary loan terms based solely on the contents of a consumer report governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, such as a FICO score or credit history reported by a credit bureau.
These real-world examples illustrate how AB 446 draws a clear line between exploitative price discrimination based on surveillance data and lawful, transparent, pricing practices based on cost, consent, regulation, potential risk, or group status.
Enforcement. Under Civil Code Section 7204, a person who violates the Act is subject to civil penalties up to $12,500 per violation. In the case of intentional violations, the penalty may be trebled, and the business must disgorge revenues earned from the violation. The bill authorizes injunctive and declaratory relief, and awards attorney’s fees and costs to prevailing plaintiffs, in order to ensure that large-scale, low-value violations can be properly enjoined by courts. To ensure the broadest possible enforcement of this bill, the author may wish to add public prosecutor enforcement.
Opposition. Opponents of AB 446, including the California Chamber of Commerce and a coalition of business, advertising, and retail associations, oppose the bill as amended May 1, 2025.
Scope, definitions, and pricing concerns. Opponents argue that the bill’s definition of “surveillance pricing” remains overly broad and risks prohibiting widely accepted, pro-consumer pricing practices. They contend that the bill could unintentionally capture routine promotional strategies such as personalized coupons, re-engagement offers to returning subscribers, or regional price variations that reflect differences in delivery costs or local demand. These models, they argue, often rely on general consumer behavior or location data—not for exploitation, but to extend savings or enhance accessibility—and are central to the functioning of modern retail and e-commerce platforms.
In response, the author and sponsors emphasize that AB 446 does not prohibit dynamic pricing, cost-based price variation, or general promotional offers. The bill targets only the use of surveillance-derived data—such as biometric signals, real-time location tracking, or inferred behavioral profiles—to generate individualized prices that are not transparently available to similarly situated consumers. The bill’s scope has been narrowed through amendments to preserve legitimate practices, and includes six explicit exemptions: 1) for pricing based on cost to serve, 2) group-based discounts, 3) opt-in loyalty programs, 4) disclosed promotional incentives, 5) insurance pricing regulated under Proposition 103, and 6) decisions based solely on consumer reports under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act.
For example, it would remain fully lawful under AB 446 for a grocery chain to offer 10% off to any consumer who signs up for a mailing list, so long as the eligibility condition—signing up—is clearly and conspicuously disclosed in advance, and the offer is uniformly available to all who qualify. Similarly, it would remain lawful to offer regional pricing based on cost differentials, such as charging $25 for delivery in Sacramento and $75 for delivery to a more remote or distant area like the Sierra Foothills, if those price differences reflect actual logistical costs. In contrast, it would be prohibited for a business to use real-time GPS data to detect when a customer is near a competitor and raise or lower prices accordingly, or to increase prices based on a shopper’s browsing history, device type, or inferred purchasing power—because those practices rely on surveillance data to personalize prices, typically upward, without consumer awareness.
Opponents also express concern with the bill’s use of the term “publicly disclosed” in the exemption provisions. They argue that the term is not defined and could expose businesses to litigation over whether a discount for a specific group (e.g., teachers, veterans) was sufficiently public. They note that “publicly disclosed” appears infrequently in California law and is subject to inconsistent judicial interpretation. In response, the author explains that the term is intended to ensure that qualifying discounts are available on equal terms and not secretly personalized. Nonetheless, the author may wish to revise the language to clarify what constitutes adequate public disclosure, and to reduce ambiguity for businesses seeking to comply in good faith.
CCPA. Opponents also raise concerns that AB 446 may conflict with or duplicate provisions of the CCPA, as amended by Proposition 24 in 2020. First, they argue that the bill treats aggregate data as equivalent to personal data, contrary to Civil Code Section 1798.140 (v), which expressly excludes aggregate and deidentified information from the CCPA’s definition of “personal information.” They caution that by including aggregate data within the bill’s definition of “covered information,” AB 446 could unintentionally sweep in low-risk, internal business uses—such as analyzing prior-year, anonymized sales data to plan future promotions—and subject them to disclosure obligations designed for individualized, surveillance-based profiling.
AB 446 does not amend, reinterpret, or conflict with the CCPA. Rather, it establishes a separate regulatory framework aimed at pricing conduct, not data privacy rights. The bill defines “covered information” more broadly for the specific purpose of addressing discriminatory pricing practices that may result from surveillance-based data inputs, whether or not the information directly identifies a consumer. This approach reflects concern that even aggregate or deidentified data, when processed through modern surveillance technologies and algorithmic pricing systems, can be used to generate individualized price variations that are invisible to consumers.
Opponents further argue that AB 446 introduces a disclosure requirement that may conflict with the CCPA’s standards for financial incentive and loyalty programs. Under Civil Code Section 1798.125 (b)(3), the CCPA permits such programs only if the consumer provides prior opt-in consent after receiving a notice that “clearly describes” the program’s material terms. By contrast, AB 446 requires that certain discount eligibility criteria be “clearly and conspicuously disclosed” before any covered information is collected. Opponents contend that this language could introduce ambiguity or inconsistent compliance obligations for businesses already subject to the CCPA.
AB 446’s disclosure requirement is not a privacy notice under the CCPA, but rather a condition tied to one of the bill’s pricing exemptions. It applies only when a business seeks to offer a discount that would otherwise be prohibited under the surveillance pricing ban, and ensures that the basis for the discount is transparent and uniformly applied. The bill does not appear to alter consumers’ rights to access, delete, or opt out of the sale of personal information, nor does it regulate how information is collected, shared, or stored.
As noted by the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee, even if the disclosure requirement in AB 446 overlaps with privacy-related concepts, the CCPA operates as a regulatory floor—not a ceiling. Section 25(a) of Proposition 24 expressly grants the Legislature the authority to amend the CCPA by a majority vote, provided that the amendments are consistent with and further the purpose and intent of the CCPA. In this regard, Section 3 of the Proposition provides “it is the purpose and intent of the people of the State of California to further protect consumers’ rights, including the constitutional right privacy.” Since the passage of Proposition 24, the Legislature has amended the CCPA to expand privacy protections in several bills.
Enforcement and liability concerns. Opponents further argue that AB 446’s enforcement structure—particularly the inclusion of a private right of action and civil penalties—could expose businesses to excessive litigation, even when they are engaged in lawful or consumer-friendly conduct. They note that businesses bear the burden of proving that any pricing differential qualifies under one of the bill’s exemptions and must also demonstrate compliance with requirements such as uniform application and public disclosure. The enforcement mechanisms in AB 446, including statutory penalties and fee-shifting, mirror those found in other consumer protection statutes, and are intended to deter unfair or discriminatory price-setting practices that are difficult for consumers to detect or challenge without meaningful recourse.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Consumer Watchdog, a co-sponsor of this bill, writes:
Unfortunately, the FTC has appeared to shelve its investigation into surveillance pricing, which makes the work of California legislators that much more important. AB 446 aims to address these concerns by prohibiting businesses from setting prices based on personally identifiable information gathered through electronic surveillance. The bill seeks to bar companies from using race, religion, residence, sexuality, political interests, web browsing and purchase history, financial circumstances, and consumer behaviors in setting prices. The bill also outlines civil penalties for violations, ensuring that consumers are protected from such exploitative practices.
As you’ve [Assemblymember Ward] said, “At a time when prices for basic necessities are rising across the board, it is more critical than ever to ensure that people are not being unfairly charged higher prices due to their actual or perceived characteristics.”
AB 446 demonstrates a commitment to consumer rights and privacy, ensuring that all Californians are treated fairly in the marketplace. One product, one price.
The UFCW Western States Council, a co-sponsor of this bill, writes:
Surveillance pricing also pre-ordains that today’s Big Tech hegemons will be able inevitably to extend their dominance even further over every aspect of commerce. Under a surveillance pricing-dominant regime, the few companies with the most data, the world’s most powerful computers, and the most state-of-the-art AI will have a permanent and ever-increasing advantage over their homely, better mousetrap-manufacturing competitors.
The cost for an innovator to enter a surveillance-dominated market will just be too high. If an innovator does somehow gain a market share, the company’s investors will prefer selling to the hegemons over trying to compete with them; already standard operating procedure for today’s internet and pharmaceutical start-ups. This may now be common but it is not how competitively functioning markets are supposed to work.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of industry groups, led by the Chamber of Commerce, continue to oppose the most recently amended version AB 446. In addition to the concerns discussed supra in the Opposition section, they raise the following concerns:
To be clear: we do not support any targeting of consumers based on protected characteristics. Price changes based on race, religion, sexuality, or political beliefs have no place in our democratic, individual rights-based capitalist system. However, we are very concerned that AB 446 will place civil penalties on non-problematic and widely-accepted practices (such as membership rewards programs, local discounts, or appropriate advertising) because of its overbroad language.
…
AB 446’s May 1st amendments create the following three process:
- Step (1) - any difference in price (including discounts) is presumptively banned as “surveillance pricing”, and subject to a private right of action and penalties (Section 7200(e));
- Step (2) – Companies must prove that their price meets one of three listed exceptions in order to be offered (Section 7202(b)(2))
- Step (3) – Each of the three allowable types of discounts must then meet three additional qualifications in order to be acceptable. (Section 7202(d)(1),(d)(2), and (e).)
Speaking broadly, we are greatly concerned with having to go to court to defend discounts offered under a private right of action. Forcing companies to litigate their ability to offer discounts seems unlikely to improve affordability in California and seems like a strange priority for the legislature.
…
As noted above, AB 446 fails to define what price might be considered “customized” and therefore be considered an example of “surveillance pricing.” We are concerned that this is further litigation bait, as companies will need to defend perfectly normal differences in price across our great state.
By way of example: California’s Central Valley produces more fresh fruits and vegetables than almost anywhere in the world−and this fresh produce is sold across the state. However, these fruits and vegetables are not necessarily sold for the same price everywhere, as a myriad of factors will influence price. An incomplete list of obvious factors would include: supply (was the harvest plentiful), transportation cost (farther away stores might need to charge more to justify the cost of transport), freshness of the product, present demand (whether consumers have been buying it or not), anticipated demand (built on aggregate data from last year’s consumers), when the next shipment is due to arrive (might lower price if need to clear inventory) … and more. With all these factors in mind, even a single chain of stores might have different prices on a particular good across the state. Also notably: many of these factors would apply to non-perishable goods just the same as produce−meaning that prices may differ in different locations.
A coalition of organizations representing the advertising industry, likewise oppose the introduced version of this measure:
AB 446 would also create unnecessary limitations by restricting businesses from setting prices based on collected, personally identifiable information including web browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances, or consumer behaviors.5 AB 446 overreaches by broadly limiting lawful and beneficial uses of personal information in ways that are non-discriminatory and bring value to both consumers and businesses. By tailoring offers and discounts to match individual interests or habits, businesses can ensure that consumers see relevant options rather than random, irrelevant promotions. This personalization not only saves time and money for consumers—such as a restaurant app offering a repeat customer discount to a person who has ordered from the restaurant many times before—but also helps consumers to discover new products or services that they might not have encountered otherwise. Using data and technology to inform discounting often leads to exclusive deals, enabling consumers to save money on items they were already planning to buy.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Watchdog (co-sponsor)
UFCW - Western States Council (co-sponsor)
American Economic Liberties Project
American Federation of Musicians, Local 7
Athena Coalition
California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO
California Nurses Association
California School Employees Association
California State Legislative Board of Smart – Transportation Division (smart – Td)
CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFL-CIO
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of America
Consumer Federation of California
Economic Security California Action
Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC)
Oakland Privacy
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
SEIU California
Smart - Transportation Division
Techequity Action
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Opposition
American Advertising Federation (AAF)
American Association of Advertising Agencies (4A's)
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Equipment Distributors
Association of National Advertisers
Calbroadband
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Retailers Association
California Travel Association
Digital Advertising Alliance
Interactive Advertising Bureau
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Software Information Industry Association
Southwest California Legislative Council
TechNet
The Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
The Travel Technology Association
USTelecom - the Broadband Association
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
Opposition Unless Amended
California Credit Union League
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 18, 2025
Fiscal: No
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 446 (
Author:Ward) – As Introduced Ver:February 6, 2025
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
SUBJECT: Surveillance pricing
SYNOPSIS
AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018), the California Consumer Privacy Act, established a framework for transparency regarding consumer data collection. In 2020, voters expanded these protections by passing Proposition 24, which created the California Privacy Protection Agency and strengthened consumer data rights. Despite these efforts, businesses continue to collect vast amounts of personally identifiable information to develop personalized experiences, sometimes to the detriment of consumers.
Over the past decade, consumer rights groups have documented instances of real-time price changes based on consumer data. These examples have raised concerns about businesses’ ability to analyze a consumer’s willingness to pay and adjust prices accordingly without consumer knowledge or consent.
This bill, sponsored by Consumer Watchdog and United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council, would impose a blanket ban on personalized price discrimination – “surveillance pricing” – based in whole or in part on the consumer’s personally identifying information. The bill provides consumers with recourse against businesses that violate this prohibition.
The bill is supported by numerous consumer rights and labor organizations, including the California Nurses Association, Oakland Privacy, and California Federation of Labor Unions. The bill is opposed by a variety of business trade associations, including the California Chamber of Commerce and the American Advertising Federation.
Some of their principal concerns are addressed in Committee amendments, set forth in Comment 5, which refine the bill’s scope, exempting common pricing practices such as differences of cost of business, loyalty programs, and discounts for specific groups, such as teachers, active service members, and senior citizens. Committee amendments also clarify definitions of personally identifiable information, exempt insurers, and remove the bill’s findings and declarations.
If passed by this Committee, the bill will next be heard by Assembly Judiciary Committee.
THIS BILL:
- Prohibits a person from engaging in surveillance pricing.
- Defines “surveillance pricing” as when a person sets a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, including electronic shelving labels.
- Defines “electronic surveillance technology” as a technological method or system of surveillance used to observe, monitor, or collect information related to a person and includes any of the following information about the person:
- Actions, habits, race, religion, residence, sexuality, or preferences.
- Interests, including the individual’s political, personal, or professional affiliation.
- Web browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances, or consumer behaviors.
- Personally identifiable information.
- Incorporates the definition of “personally identifiable information” from the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and also provides that, for purposes of the bill, this term includes deidentified or aggregated consumer information.
- Subjects violators to a civil penalty for violations, treble damages and disgorgement of revenues earned for intentional violations, and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Provides that waivers of the bill are against public policy and are void and unenforceable.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that, among other rights, all people have an inalienable right to pursue and obtain privacy. (Cal. Const., art.1, § 1.)
- Establishes the Unruh Civil Rights Act. (Civil Code § 51.)
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. Places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Privacy Protection Agency (Privacy Agency) and vests it with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the CCPA. (Civ. Code § 1798.199.10.)
- Establishes the Unfair Practices Act (UPA), which is intended to safeguard the public against the creation or perpetuation of monopolies and to foster and encourage competition, by prohibiting unfair, dishonest, deceptive, destructive, fraudulent and discriminatory practices by which fair and honest competition is destroyed or prevented. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17000 et seq.)
- Prohibits, under the UPA, a range of behavior that reduces competition in pricing, including specified locality discrimination in pricing, sales under costs or loss leaders made with the intent of injuring competitors or destroying competition, and contracts for the performance of warranty service and repair below the cost of the service or repair. (Bus. & Prof. Code, §§ 17040-17051.)
- For purposes of investigating potential violations of the UPA, extends all of the investigative powers granted to the Attorney General pursuant to 7) to the district attorney of any county when the district attorney reasonably believes that a violation has occurred. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 16759(a).)
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author:
With the rise of artificial intelligence and data collection, businesses increasingly use personal data to set prices, often leading to unfair and discriminatory pricing practices. This legislation aims to establish safeguards that ensure transparency, fairness, and consumer protections in pricing algorithms. AB 446 will prohibit the practice of surveillance pricing by making it unlawful for businesses to use personal data when charging different prices for the same product, or service whether online or during in-store checkout.
2) The Commodification of Personal Data. Enshrined in the state constitution by a ballot initiative in 1972, the unalienable right to privacy is guaranteed to all Californians and is enforceable against both the public and private sectors. However, for the past 20 years, experts have been warning us about the erosion of our private lives. They note that this erosion is happening one small bit at a time, likely without people even noticing. With the advent of the internet and advances in technology, it is no longer easy for people to decide which aspects of their lives should be publicly disclosed. As Alex Preston noted in The Guardian a decade ago:
We have come to the end of privacy; our private lives, as our grandparents would have recognised them, have been winnowed away to the realm of the shameful and secret. . . . Insidiously, through small concessions that only mounted up over time, we have signed away rights and privileges that other generations fought for, undermining the very cornerstones of our personalities in the process. While outposts of civilisation fight pyrrhic battles, unplugging themselves from the web. . . the rest of us have come to accept that the majority of our social, financial and even sexual interactions take place over the internet and that someone, somewhere, whether state, press or corporation, is watching.[1]
Since this piece was published, it has become increasingly clear that not only is our right to privacy significantly eroded, but our private information and activities are now being harvested and sold for a profit. This commodification of personal information has been dubbed “surveillance capitalism” by social psychologist, Shoshana Zuboff. In an opinion piece for The New York Times, in 2021, Dr. Zuboff warned:
As we move into the third decade of the 21st century, surveillance capitalism is the dominant economic institution of our time. In the absence of countervailing law, this system successfully mediates nearly every aspect of human engagement with digital information. The promise of the surveillance dividend now draws surveillance economics into the “normal” economy, from insurance, retail, banking and finance to agriculture, automobiles, education, health care and more. . . .
An economic order founded on the secret massive-scale extraction of human data assumes the destruction of privacy as a nonnegotiable condition of its business operations. With privacy out of the way, ill-gotten human data are concentrated within private corporations, where they are claimed as corporate assets to be deployed at will.[2]
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence over the past five years has significantly accelerated data collection and processing. AI agents can be deployed to extract data, also known as scraping, from websites. Inevitably this includes personal information of consumers which data brokers compile and sell to businesses. These businesses then integrate the acquired data with their own consumer information to create detailed consumer profiles. With AI, these profiles can be updated in real time to personalize user experiences and target advertisements more effectively.
3) Background. For much of history, deals at marketplaces were made via bartering, and consumers and producers alike would try to haggle a deal that would align with the buyer’s willingness, or ability, to pay for a good. This system enabled some consumers to cut deals; however, others would be taken advantage of because of the lack of transparency in how much a product actually cost. The bartering system was upended in mid 1800s when a Wanamaker’s department store in Philadelphia began to include price tags on their goods. John Wanamaker believed that customers would trust their retailers more if they could see the prices and, therefore, make informed decisions about their purchasing options.[3] He incorporated these prices into advertisements, and when customers found them to be accurate, it strengthened their confidence in the retailer. This innovation helped drive the expansion of department stores and set the standard for pricing practices for the next 150 years.
Surveillance pricing, also known as individualized pricing, uses AI or other technology for the real-time processing of personal information about a consumer to set a price specific to that consumer. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has described surveillance pricing as “an ecosystem designed to use large-scale data collection to help sellers maximize their revenues by customizing the pricing, as well as the selection of products and services, offered to each consumer.”[4]
It is important to distinguish surveillance pricing from dynamic pricing, which adjusts prices in response to market demand. For example, Ticketmaster uses dynamic pricing to increase ticket prices for all consumers when demand rises.[5] In contrast, surveillance pricing treats each consumer as their own economy, using algorithms to assess their willingness to pay based on personal information such as browsing history, purchase behavior, and location.
Surveillance Pricing has already impacted consumers. In 2012, The Wall Street Journal reported that the retailer Staples used an algorithm that set higher prices for consumers who lived further from a rival store.[6] Target also used an algorithm to adjust the price of a TV once a customer entered the parking lot, leading to a $5 million settlement with the City of San Diego for false advertising and unfair business practices related to surveillance pricing.[7] The SF Gate recently reported that Bay Area consumers are offered a higher price than users in either Phoenix or Kansas City for the same exact hotel reservations on various hotel booking websites.[8] California Chamber of Commerce, along with multiple trade organizations, argues that these differences in pricing are a result of California laws regarding transparency:
This discrepancy is because California law recently changed to require all included fees for any hotel rooms to be included in the up-front price. AB 537 (Berman) compelled online travel sites to list their prices including all fees up front – and Cal Chamber (along with other opposition groups) repeatedly testified that such a process would confuse consumers by making it appear that prices were actually different for California consumers and out-of-state consumers. Now, it appears consumer groups are indeed confused and are alleging that businesses’ appropriate compliance with recent law is actually something nefarious.
While it is likely that some differences in prices could be due to the compelled fee disclosures, the difference per night for an SF resident compared to a Phoenix resident at the same hotel for the same booking was $511 higher – which simply cannot be due solely to discrepancies from transparency. This is appears to have been tacitly acknowledged by Booking in its response to this investigation:
In an email, Angela Cavis, spokesperson for Booking, said that the rates users see were “determined by our accommodation partners, who have full control over the rates they choose to list on the site.” Cavis explained that, “Partners also have the flexibility to create specific promotional rates, such as country rates or mobile rates, which are designed to offer discounts, not charge higher prices.”[9]
Moreover, the use of AI to set prices raises concerns regarding biases within the algorithms that may disadvantage different groups. A 2021 study from George Washington University found that Uber and Lyft charged, on average, higher prices for pickups and drop-offs in predominantly non-white neighborhoods or neighborhoods with lower incomes.[10] While it is unclear whether these disparities stem from market forces or algorithmic bias because these companies use opaque algorithms to set prices, a possible conclusion is that algorithmic price setting could reinforce structural inequities.
Because businesses often operate without transparency, the extent of surveillance pricing remains uncertain. In the summer of 2024, the Federal Trade Commission launched a study to investigate how companies leverage AI, other technologies, and consumer data to set individualized prices. A preliminary report released in January revealed that at least 250 businesses have adopted technologies capable of implementing surveillance pricing. Lina Khan, former FTC Chair, concludes in this report:
“Initial staff findings show that retailers frequently use people’s personal information to set targeted, tailored prices for goods and services—from a person’s location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage. The FTC should continue to investigate surveillance pricing practices because Americans deserve to know how their private data is being used to set the prices they pay and whether firms are charging different people different prices for the same good or service.”[11]
More efficient markets vs competition. Surveillance pricing has the potential to create more efficient markets. By accurately scaling prices to a consumer’s willingness to pay, businesses can sell more goods and services to a broader customer base. Underserved populations could benefit from greater discounts, increasing their access to markets that were previously unavailable to them. In theory, this could enhance overall consumer welfare.
However, this would also suggest that someone with a high willingness to pay would be charged a higher price to offset those discounts. This raises concerns about fairness and could have a chilling effect on those high willingness consumers, making them less likely to participate in the marketplace.
Surveillance pricing is an example of perfect price discrimination. Under perfect price discrimination, consumer surplus, the difference between what a consumer is willing to pay and the actual price they pay, disappears as each consumer is charged exactly what they are willing to pay.[12] Therefore, all surplus in the market is captured by the producer, which can reduce consumer welfare. The FTC has reported on this phenomena finding that businesses that had implemented surveillance pricing had already seen 1-5% increases in revenue.[13] In contrast, traditional competitive pricing exerts downward pressure on prices, increasing consumer surplus and overall consumer welfare, though at the cost of some inefficiency, or deadweight loss, for producers.
Research suggests that surveillance pricing, under highly competitive pressures, could lead to aggressive pricing strategies taken by all firms that result in lower prices.[14] However, this outcome depends on consumer data being used solely for pricing, data is equally available, and the data is not used for other strategic purposes. In less competitive markets, or where one firm has superior access to consumer data, surveillance pricing can instead be used to target specific consumers with personalized discounts, ads, and product recommendations. This strategy fosters customer loyalty, making those consumers less price-sensitive and increasing the cost for competitors to attract them. Competition then softens which leads to higher costs for consumers. Smaller firms that cannot afford to collect, purchase, or process vast consumer datasets will face increasing disadvantages if surveillance pricing becomes widespread. This imbalance could further entrench market power among large corporations, reducing competition and ultimately harming consumers.
The UCFW Western States Council summarizes:
“A too-often overlooked aspect of functioning markets is how they permit personal autonomy and freedom. Rather than only being able to build personal wealth by working for a giant company, an individual armed with a good idea, some savings or modest capital, and grit, can in a competitive market choose to earn a living by profitably working for themselves.
But, if a pre-requisite to being able to compete profitably in every market is access to the world’s biggest computers, the richest repositories of personal behavioral data, and most powerful AI, such entrepreneurial individual choices and freedoms become either impossible or restrained only to tiny, Etsy-like, boutique ambitions.”
Surveillance pricing raises concerns for price-setting collusion. Market-wide implementation of surveillance pricing may raise antitrust concerns due to the risk of tacit algorithmic collusion. Though many firms may create their own models for personalized price setting, others may outsource their price-setting to a third party. If these third parties use private data supplied by multiple firms, price collusion could result, raising questions of antitrust enforcement. Legislative efforts regarding algorithmic price collusion are currently underway.
Last session, SB 1154 (Hurtado, 2024) would have prohibited the use of algorithms to set or recommend prices or commercial terms that incorporate nonpublic competitor data. This bill died in Senate Judiciary. This session, there are currently three bills, AB 325 (Aguiar-Curry), SB 295 (Hurtado), and SB 384 (Wahab) seeking to prohibit the use of algorithms to set or recommend prices that incorporate nonpublic competitor data. SB 52 (Perez) similarly would prohibit the use of algorithms that incorporate nonpublic competitor data concerning local and statewide rents or occupancy levels for the purpose of setting rent prices. The prohibition of surveillance pricing would likely not impact the implementation of any of these bills focusing on algorithmic price collusion, though this serves to highlight the extent to which the legislature views algorithmic price setting as a pertinent issue.
3) What this bill would do. As noted above, many businesses collect, collate, and process large amounts of data about their consumers, including data about the consumer’s employment, shopping habits, and browser history. Companies with access to this data can implement surveillance pricing, a practice of setting individualized prices based on a consumer's perceived willingness to pay. One argument for this practice is that real-time, personalized pricing could expand market access by allowing more consumers to purchase goods and services at prices tailored to them. Willingness to pay, though, does not necessarily correspond with ability to pay or value. A parent may be more willing to pay for cold medicine when their child is sick, but should that willingness justify higher prices? In a bartering system, the consumer at least had the ability to negotiate for a better deal, with surveillance pricing, the consumer may not even know that the price has been adjusted.
Additionally, surveillance pricing incentivizes the continual collection of consumer data, raising privacy concerns, and gives advantages to larger firms with access to more information and better technology for price setting, targeted deals, and advertisements. These practices could further disadvantage small businesses that lack the resources to compete. Ultimately, this bill’s prohibition of surveillance pricing seeks to ensure fairness and transparency in competition and pricing.
4) Concerns with the bill in print. Price discrimination itself is neither illegal nor is it necessarily harmful for consumers. Surveillance pricing is a form of first-degree price discrimination, in which prices are based on the willingness of the consumer to pay, meaning some consumers pay more or less for the same good or service. Public perception of this practice is largely negative. When consumers were asked if they felt this was a fair practice in 2018, only 8% of respondents responded positively.[15] In contrast, second-degree price discrimination, the practice of offering discounts based on bulk purchases or loyalty programs, or third-degree price discrimination, the practice of offering discounts based on unique demographics such as veterans, students, and retired people, are much more popular. Loyalty programs often offer personalized coupons for products a consumer purchases frequently, necessitating some use and retention of personally identifiable information about a consumer to offer such coupons. Similarly, discount programs targeting specific demographic groups also require consumers to provide personally identifiable information to receive discounts. Both second- and third-degree price discrimination appear to give advantages to consumers.
In opposition, the American Advertising Federation, on behalf of the advertising industry, argues that AB 446 fails to recognize that not all pricing discrimination is bad:
AB 446 fails to acknowledge the value of these everyday occurrences to consumers and does not draw a distinction between discriminatory practices and personalized pricing strategies that enhance consumer experiences. For example, when a business uses personal data such as IP addresses or browsing activity to infer consumer preferences and offers a 15% discount pop-up during the consumer’s visit to the brand’s website, this is a legitimate and consumer-friendly use of data. This interaction would be illegal if AB 446 becomes law. Tailored discounts offered to specific consumers at the right time and in the right place reflect a business’s ability to understand its customer base and helps drive economic activity. By outlawing such practices, AB 446 would deprive consumers of personalized deals and discounts they value.
[…]
AB 446 would undermine loyalty programs and other incentives that many Californians rely on for savings and convenience. Grocery store loyalty programs and associated mobile apps, which use shopper data to offer tailored deals, coupons and other savings, would no longer be allowed to provide the same benefits to consumers in California if AB 446 becomes law. In these times of economic uncertainty, families who depend on these types of programs for budgeting would be negatively impacted by such a dramatic change in loyalty program practices. Similarly, whole industries, such as the automobile industry, would enter a new era where extremely popular car buyback programs could face restrictions. For instance, dealerships would no longer be able to use information known about a vehicle’s age and owner to offer a buyback deal, beneficial to both the consumer and the business. AB 446 would reduce the ability of businesses to interact meaningfully with their customers, curbing personalization, stifling options for consumer engagement, and ultimately harming families across California.
Recognizing these concerns, the author has agreed to amend the bill to allow consumers to provide informed consent for businesses to collect and use covered information solely for the purpose of receiving discounts on goods and services.
Another form of price discrimination that must be considered is pricing based on differences in business costs. For example, a plumber performing the same job at two different homes may charge different prices due to accessibility, one home may be in the plumber’s neighborhood, while the other is on a remote hill, requiring additional travel time and expenses. As industry opponents state: “Because AB 446 lists ‘residence’ among its broad list of protected areas, it would appear that setting a price differently for customers who are harder to reach (for example, in a remote and hard-to-reach area) would qualify as ‘surveillance pricing.’” Since business costs often require the use of personally identifiable information to set prices, the author has agreed to amend the bill to exempt personalized prices based solely on the cost of providing the good or service to the consumer.
Insurers use personal information to set prices. Finally, opponents note that insurers would likely fall under the umbrella of surveillance pricing, as they use personally identifiable information in their risk-based assessment to set insurance rates. The author has agreed to amend the bill to exclude insurers.
Definition of personally identifiable information. Industry opponents state:
AB 446 creates ambiguity around what is covered by the CCPA’s term of “personal information” by both relying on that definition and ignoring what is covered under it. In Proposed Section 7200 (a)(4), AB 446 identifies the types of data that will be unusable in pricing with a list of categories of data. Among that list is “Personally identifiable information,” which is defined by reference to the CCPA’s similar term, and includes basically any consumer information. Despite this broad term already encompassing virtually all consumer data, AB 446 also lists a number of items that are already implicitly included in this definition as separate types of data. In other words: AB 446 suggests that “actions, habits, …web browsing history, purchase history … [and] consumer behaviors” need to be listed separately because they are not already included by the CCPA’s definition of “personal information” … when, in fact, they are already included.
The definition of personally identifiable information covers all activities prescribed in “Electronic surveillance technology” and the author has agreed to amend the bill to address this redundancy.
CalChamber also argues that the inclusion of deidentified or aggregated consumer information in personal information is inherently not personal information. As defined in the CCPA, “deidentified consumer information” is defined to mean information that cannot reasonably be used to infer information about, or otherwise be linked to, a particular consumer. “Aggregate consumer information” is the information that relates to a group or category of consumers, from which individual consumer identities have been removed, that is not linked or reasonably linkable to any consumer or household, including via a device. However, as the Victorian Information Commissioner in Australia argues, even though aggregate consumer information cannot be used to identify a consumer, it can be used to make general assumptions about a consumer’s characteristics:
In the commercial sphere, for example, if an individual is classified into a group that is considered affluent, a business can potentially charge more for the same service in the knowledge that prospective customer is likely to be able to pay. The classification need not be 100% accurate, it only needs to be right a sufficient number of times to result in increased profits. Coarse location information can be derived from the user’s IP address. Even though not personally identifiable on its own, it is sufficient to allow classification of the customer, and for them to be treated differently, potentially to their detriment.[16]
Industry opponents’ argument regarding deidentified information has merit, as that information cannot be used to make any assumptions about a consumer. However, aggregate consumer information can be used to set different prices based on general assumptions about groups of people, as discussed above. Therefore, the author has agreed to amend the bill to remove deidentified information and clarify that aggregated consumer information is not personally identifiable information, but continues to be captured under the bill’s definition of “surveillance pricing”.
Accuracy of findings and declarations. CalChamber raises issues with the breadth and extent of the findings and declarations of this bill, stating that “these allegations appear either incorrect or out-dated.” The author has agreed to amend the bill to remove the findings and declarations.
5) Amendments. As set forth above, the author has agreed to remove the findings and declarations and to amend the bill to allow for beneficial pricing schemes such as loyalty programs, clarify the definitions and scope of the bill, exclude insurers, and make other clean-up changes. In its entirety, the bill will read as follows:
7200. For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
- (a) “Electronic surveillance technology” means a technological method or system of surveillance
used to observe, monitor, or collect information related to a person and includes any of the following information about the person:used to gather covered information.
(b) “Person” means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(c) “Personally identifiable information” shall have the same meaning as “personal information” as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code and any regulations promulgated thereunder. Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of subdivision (v) of Section 1798.140 of the Civil Code, “personally identifiable information” includes deidentified or aggregated consumer information.
(d)“Aggregate consumer information” means information that relates to a group or category of consumers, from which individual consumer identities have been removed, that is not linked or reasonably linkable to any consumer or household, including via a device.
(e) “Covered information” means either personally identifiable information or aggregate consumer information.
(f) “Surveillance pricing” means when a person sets a price offered to a consumer based, in whole or in part, upon personally identifiable information gathered through an electronic surveillance technology, including electronic shelving labels. using covered information gathered through electronic surveillance technology to set the price of a commercial good or service for a consumer that differs from the standard price.
(g) “Standard price” means the price of a good or service that is set for all consumers that is not based upon covered information.
7202. It shall be unlawful for a person to engage in surveillance pricing. (a) Except as provided in (b), a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.
(b) A person may engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:
(1) The difference from the standard price charged to a consumer is based solely on the cost to the person of providing the good or service to that consumer.
(2) The difference from the standard price is a discount offered to all consumers on equal terms in a manner consistent with applicable anti-discrimination laws. If the person gathers covered information in connection with the provision of this discount, the person shall ensure both of the following:
That the consumer receives a clear and conspicuous written notice describing in readily ascertainable terms the specific intended purposes for which the person will use the information before the person uses the information for any such purpose.
That the consumer provides written affirmative consent for any purpose described in paragraph (1) before their personally identifiable information is used for that purpose.
(3) The person operates as an insurer complying with Section 791.02 of the Insurance Code.
7204. (a) In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty for each violation not to exceed the jurisdiction of small claims court for individuals, where each violation means each item of tangible property or each use of a service sold in violation of Section 7202.
(b) A person that intentionally violates this part shall be liable for a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) and shall disgorge all revenues earned from the violation.
(c) A prevailing party in an action brought pursuant to this part shall be awarded reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs.
7208. Any waiver of this part is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.
SEC. 3. The Legislature finds and declares that this act furthers the purposes and intent of the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Consumer Watchdog, a co-sponsor of this bill, writes:
Unfortunately, the FTC has appeared to shelve its investigation into surveillance pricing, which makes the work of California legislators that much more important. AB 446 aims to address these concerns by prohibiting businesses from setting prices based on personally identifiable information gathered through electronic surveillance. The bill seeks to bar companies from using race, religion, residence, sexuality, political interests, web browsing and purchase history, financial circumstances, and consumer behaviors in setting prices. The bill also outlines civil penalties for violations, ensuring that consumers are protected from such exploitative practices.
As you’ve [Assemblymember Ward] said, “At a time when prices for basic necessities are rising across the board, it is more critical than ever to ensure that people are not being unfairly charged higher prices due to their actual or perceived characteristics.”
AB 446 demonstrates a commitment to consumer rights and privacy, ensuring that all Californians are treated fairly in the marketplace. One product, one price.
The UCFW Western States Council, a co-sponsor of this bill, writes:
Surveillance pricing also pre-ordains that today’s Big Tech hegemons will be able inevitably to extend their dominance even further over every aspect of commerce. Under a surveillance pricing-dominant regime, the few companies with the most data, the world’s most powerful computers, and the most state-of-the-art AI will have a permanent and ever-increasing advantage over their homely, better mousetrap-manufacturing competitors.
The cost for an innovator to enter a surveillance-dominated market will just be too high. If an innovator does somehow gain a market share, the company’s investors will prefer selling to the hegemons over trying to compete with them; already standard operating procedure for today’s internet and pharmaceutical start-ups. This may now be common but it is not how competitively functioning markets are supposed to work.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, a coalition of trade groups, including California Chamber of Commerce, states:
The California Consumer Privacy Act (“CCPA”) is the definitive statute related to consumers’ privacy and their personal data – whether that data is collected online, in brick-and-mortar stores, by technological means, on paper, or by powers of observation. In other words, it is a broad, technology-neutral, industry-neutral, and comprehensive consumer data protection law, which was also voter-approved via Proposition 24 in 2020. Substantively, the CCPA governs how a company may collect data related to a customer’s behavior (buying certain products, for example) and utilize that data. The CCPA also already addresses permissible and impermissible business uses of consumer data for activities such as targeted advertising, loyalty and rewards programs, and the like. In fact, the CCPA places limits on the sharing of customers’ data, allowing customers to opt-out of allowing a business to share such data.
AB 446 also seeks to control how businesses collect and use a consumer’s data—an aim that squarely falls under the jurisdiction of the voter-approved CCPA. In doing so, AB 446 completely ignores the CCPA’s voter-endorsed provisions and its careful balancing of the complex policy issues around online marketplaces … and simply bans the use of such data in pricing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Watchdog (Co-Sponsor)
Ufcw - Western States Council (Co-Sponsor)
American Federation of Musicians, Local 7
Athena Coalition
California Federation of Labor Unions, Afl-cio
California Nurses Association
California School Employees Association
California State Legislative Board of Smart – Transportation Division (smart – Td)
Cft- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, Aft, Afl-cio
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of America
Consumer Federation of California
Economic Security California Action
Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC)
Oakland Privacy
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
Techequity Action
Udw/afscme Local 3930
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Opposition
American Advertising Federation (AAF)
American Association of Advertising Agencies (4A's)
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Equipment Distributors
Association of National Advertisers
Calbroadband
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Retailers Association
California Travel Association
Digital Advertising Alliance
Interactive Advertising Bureau
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Software Information Industry Association
Technet
The Travel Technology Association
Analysis Prepared by: John Bennett / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Preston, Alex. “The death of privacy.” The Guardian (Aug. 3, 2014), https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/03/internet-death-privacy-google-facebook-alex-preston. ↑
Zuboff, Shoshana. “You Are the Object of a Secret Extraction Operation.” The New York Times (Nov. 12, 2021) available at https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/12/opinion/facebook-privacy.html. ↑
PBS, “John Wanamaker” (Mar. 10, 2025), https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/theymadeamerica/whomade/wanamaker_hi.html. ↑
Federal Trade Commission, “Issue Spotlight: The Rise of Surveillance Pricing” (January 17, 2025), https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-surveillance-pricing-study-indicates-wide-range-personal-data-used-set-individualized-consumer. ↑
Cody Mello-Klein, “What is dynamic pricing and why is it hiking ticket prices for Oasis, Taylor Swift and your favorite artist?”, Northeastern Global News (Oct. 2, 2024), https://news.northeastern.edu/2024/10/02/dynamic-pricing-ticketmaster-oasis-taylor-swift/. ↑
Jennifer Valentino-DeVries, Jeremy Singer-Vine and Ashkan Soltani, “Websites Vary Prices, Deals Based on Users’ Information,” Wall Street Journal (Dec. 24, 2012), https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323777204578189391813881534. ↑
Chris Hrapsky, “Target settles lawsuit alleging false advertising, overpricing; fined $5M”, KARE (Apr. 27, 2022), https://www.kare11.com/article/news/local/kare11-extras/target-settles-ca-lawsuit-alleging-false-advertising-overpricing-fined-5m/89-ba4a5441-c38e-4c9f-b524-b0d13414042f. ↑
Keith A. Spencer, “Hotel booking sites show higher prices to travelers from Bay Area,” SFGATE (Feb. 3, 2025), https://www.sfgate.com/travel/article/hotel-booking-sites-overcharge-bay-area-travelers-20025145.php. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Akshat Pandey and Aylin Caliskan, “Disparate Impact of Artificial Intelligence Bias in Ridehailing Economy's Price Discrimination Algorithms” arXiv (May 3, 2021), https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.04599. ↑
Federal Trade Commission, “FTC Surveillance Pricing Study Indicates Wide Range of Personal Data Used to Set Individualized Consumer Prices” (Mar. 10, 2025), https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-surveillance-pricing-study-indicates-wide-range-personal-data-used-set-individualized-consumer. ↑
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development “Personalised Pricing in the Digital Era” (Mar. 10, 2025), https://web-archive.oecd.org/temp/2022-02-22/494784-personalised-pricing-in-the-digital-era.htm ↑
Federal Trade Commission, “FTC Surveillance Pricing 6(b) Study: Research Summaries A Staff Perspective” (Jan. 17, 2025), p. 10. ↑
Zhijun Chen, Chongwoo Choe, Noriaki Matsushima, “Competitive Personalized Pricing”, Management science, vol. 66, No. 9, September 2020, p. 3799 ↑
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development “Personalised Pricing in the Digital Era” (Mar. 10, 2025), https://web-archive.oecd.org/temp/2022-02-22/494784-personalised-pricing-in-the-digital-era.htm. ↑
Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner, “The Limitations of De-Identification – Protecting Unit-Record Level Personal Information”, (Mar. 13, 2025), https://ovic.vic.gov.au/privacy/resources-for-organisations/the-limitations-of-de-identification-protecting-unit-record-level-personal-information/. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):