AB 470: Telephone corporations: carriers of last resort.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2025-07-17
Current Status:
In Progress
(2025-08-29: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for public utilities. Existing law requires the commission, on or before February 1, 1995, to issue an order initiating an investigation and open proceeding to examine the current and future definitions of universal service in telecommunications. Pursuant to that provision, the commission issued a decision involving carriers of last resort, including the withdrawal process for carriers of last resort, defined as a carrier who provides local exchange service and stands ready to provide basic service to any customer requesting basic service within a specified area.
This bill would require the commission, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, to adopt a process through which a telephone corporation acting as a carrier of last resort is authorized to seek relief from their carrier of last resort obligations in a census block where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area, and in a census block that is well-served, as defined. The bill would require the commission, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas. The bill would require that the process include specified notice and challenge requirements. The bill would require a telephone corporation to meet certain requirements during specified time periods following the date that amended status is granted by the commission, as provided.
The bill would create the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund, provide that moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the commission for purposes of public safety agency technology upgrade grants, and authorize the fund to accept donations from nongovernmental entities.
The bill would exempt specified services and locations from its provisions.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.Under existing law, a violation of an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for public utilities. Existing law requires the commission, on or before February 1, 1995, to issue an order initiating an investigation and open proceeding to examine the current and future definitions of universal service in telecommunications. Pursuant to that provision, the commission issued a decision involving carriers of last resort, including the withdrawal process for carriers of last resort, defined as a carrier who provides local exchange service and stands ready to provide basic service to any customer requesting such basic service within a specified area.
This bill would provide procedures for telephone corporations, upon approval by the commission of specified advice letters filed by the telephone corporations, to be granted require the commission, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, to adopt a process through which a telephone corporation acting as a carrier of last resort is authorized to seek relief from their carrier of last resort obligations in areas a census block where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporations provide corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within their telephone service territory, the area, and in areas a census block that are is well-served, as defined. The bill would require the commission, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible to be amended status areas, as provided, and would require a telephone corporation, when applying for amended status in areas that are well-served, to seek commission approval for amended status in its service territory based on the map. areas. The bill would require telephone corporations to fulfill specified conditions and meet certain notice requirements to be granted relief from their carrier of last resort obligations. The bill would impose additional duties on telephone corporations granted relief from their carrier of last resort obligations, including, among other things, publishing a notice that would specify a residential consumers authority to submit a request seeking independent third-party review of the assertion that an area has no population and no basic exchange service customers or that a consumer in an area is well-served, as applicable. The bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2027, to determine a transition plan to be followed before a telephone corporation amends its status as a carrier of last resort in areas other than those subject to amended status under the bill. that the process include specified notice and challenge requirements. The bill would require a telephone corporation to meet certain requirements during specified time periods following the date that amended status is granted by the commission, as provided.
The bill would create the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund, provide that moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the commission for purposes of public safety agency technology upgrade grants, and authorize the fund to accept donations from nongovernmental entities.
The bill would exempt specified services and locations from its provisions.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Under existing law, a violation of an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for public utilities. Existing law requires the commission, on or before February 1, 1995, to issue an order initiating an investigation and open proceeding to examine the current and future definitions of universal service in telecommunications. Pursuant to that provision, the commission issued a decision involving carriers of last resort, including the withdrawal process for carriers of last resort, defined as a carrier who provides local exchange service and stands ready to provide basic service to any customer requesting such service within a specified area.
This bill would provide procedures for telephone corporations corporations, upon approval by the commission of specified advice letters filed by the telephone corporations, to terminate be granted relief from their carrier of last resort obligations in areas where the United States Census Bureau reports no population, in areas population and where telephone corporations provide no basic exchange service to any customer address located within their telephone service territory, and in areas that are well-served, as defined. The bill would require the commission, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible to be amended status areas, as provided, and would require a telephone corporation, when applying for amended status in areas that are well-served, to seek commission approval for amended status in its service territory based on the map. The bill would require telephone corporations to fulfill specified conditions and meet certain notice requirements to be relieved of the granted relief from their carrier of last resort obligations. The bill would impose additional duties on telephone corporations terminating granted relief from their carrier of last resort obligations, including, among other things, publishing a notice which that would specify a residential consumers authority to submit a written request seeking independent third-party review of the assertion that an area has no population or and no basic exchange service customers or that a consumer in an area is well-served, as applicable. The bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2027, to determine a transition plan to be followed before a telephone corporation amends its status as a carrier of last resort in areas other than those subject to amended status under the bill.
The bill would create the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund, provide that moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the commission for purposes of public safety agency technology upgrade grants, and authorize the fund to accept donations from nongovernmental entities. The bill would make specified exceptions to these provisions.
The bill would exempt specified services and locations from its provisions.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Under existing law, a violation of an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for public utilities. Existing law requires the commission, on or before February 1, 1995, to issue an order initiating an investigation and open proceeding to examine the current and future definitions of universal service in telecommunications. Pursuant to that provision, the commission issued a decision involving carriers of last resort, including the withdrawal process for carriers of last resort, defined as a carrier who provides local exchange service and stands ready to provide basic service to any customer requesting such service within a specified area.
This bill would require a telephone corporation seeking to relinquish its carrier of last resort designation for an eligible area, as defined, to provide a notice to the commission, as described, and would require the telephone corporations carrier of last resort designation for the eligible area to be relinquished upon the submission of the notice. The bill would require the telephone corporation to modify its tariff for basic local exchange telephone service, as specified, and would require that the modified tariff be effective upon the submission of the notice. The bill would require the telephone corporation to administer and pay for a customer challenge process for customers who inform the telephone corporation that no alternative voice service, as defined, is available at their location, as specified. The bill would require the commission, as part of a specified rulemaking, to establish a transition plan that a telephone corporation would be required to follow before its carrier of last resort designation is relinquished for an area within its service territory other than an eligible area.This bill would provide procedures for telephone corporations to terminate their carrier of last resort obligations in areas where the United States Census Bureau reports no population, in areas where telephone corporations provide no basic exchange service to any customer address located within their telephone service territory, and in areas that are well-served, as defined. The bill would require telephone corporations to fulfill specified conditions and meet certain notice requirements to be relieved of the carrier of last resort obligations. The bill would impose additional duties on telephone corporations terminating their carrier of last resort obligations, including, among other things, publishing a notice which would specify a residential consumers authority to submit a written request seeking independent third-party review of the assertion that an area has no population or no basic exchange service customers or that a consumer in an area is well-served, as applicable. The bill would require the commission, on or before January 1, 2027, to determine a transition plan to be followed before a telephone corporation amends its status as a carrier of last resort in areas other than those subject to amended status under the bill.
The bill would create the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund, provide that moneys in the fund are continuously appropriated to the commission for purposes of public safety agency technology upgrade grants, and authorize the fund to accept donations from nongovernmental entities. The bill would make specified exceptions to these provisions.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Under existing law, a violation of an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for public utilities. Existing law requires the commission, on or before February 1, 1995, to issue an order initiating an investigation and open proceeding to examine the current and future definitions of universal service in telecommunications. Pursuant to that provision, the commission issued a decision involving carriers of last resort, including the withdrawal process for carriers of last resort, defined as a carrier who provides local exchange service and stands ready to provide basic service to any customer requesting such service within a specified area.
This bill would require a telephone corporation seeking to relinquish its carrier of last resort designation for an eligible area, as defined, to provide a notice to the commission, as described, and would require the telephone corporations carrier of last resort designation for the eligible area to be relinquished upon the submission of the notice. The bill would require the telephone corporation to modify its tariff for basic local exchange telephone service, as specified, and would require that the modified tariff be effective upon the submission of the notice. The bill would require the telephone corporation to administer and pay for a customer challenge process for customers who inform the telephone corporation that no alternative voice service, as defined, is available at their location, as specified. The bill would require the commission, as part of a specified rulemaking, to establish a transition plan that a telephone corporation would be required to follow before its carrier of last resort designation is relinquished for an area within its service territory other than an eligible area.
Under existing law, a violation of an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state, including telephone corporations.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to telecommunications.Existing law authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state, including telephone corporations.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to telecommunications.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The state encourages the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability to all Californians by utilizing regulatory forbearance measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other methods that encourage infrastructure investment.
(2)All Californians deserve reliable, affordable, fast, and safe communication options, no matter who they are, where they live, or why they need to be connected.
(3)The transition to advanced fiber optic networks is key to creating equity and positive impacts on California education, health care, agriculture, public safety, workforce development, and the economy.
(4)Californians are moving swiftly to abandon the legacy network because it does not provide the benefits of modern communication technologies, with more choosing to use advanced services every year.
(5)California must develop a responsible and equitable transition plan that ensures all Californians have access to the connectivity they need.
(6)The transition should include a phased approach that over time ensures customers have access to communication services that are equally or more reliable and affordable, before transitioning away from the old legacy network.
(7)As part of the transition, no Californian will be left without reliable voice service in their home, including the ability to contact 9-1-1.
(8)The purposes of this act are to ensure Californias longstanding commitment to universal service is not compromised by changes to the telecommunications marketplace and to ensure the public may benefit from the transition away from legacy networks. To that end, this act establishes a comprehensive and robust process for a telephone corporation to seek changes to its obligations as a carrier of last resort for eligible areas only, and requirements to ensure the public benefits from those changes.
(b)By choosing to enact legislation affecting a narrow scope of areas with robust competition or no direct impact to an existing population, it is the intent of the Legislature to allow the Public Utilities Commission to continue commission Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, for areas that are not eligible areas under this act.
SEC. 2.Article 1.5 (commencing with Section 2878) is added to Chapter 10 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to read:1.5.Carriers of Last Resort2878.For purposes of this article, all of the following definitions apply:
(a)(1)Alternative voice basic service means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
(A)Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
(B)Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
(C)Compatibility with a backup power source.
(D)A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
(E)Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to Section 2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
(F)Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
(G)Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
(2)Alternative voice basic service shall be a separate definition from basic service, as defined in commission Decision 12-12-038 (December 24, 2012), Order Instituting Rulemaking Regarding Revisions to the California High Cost Fund B Program, and does not encompass any obligations of any other service except as defined in this section.
(b)Amended status means the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
(c)Amended status area means a census block or census blocks for which a telephone corporation has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status.
(d)Broadband service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio provided to customers in the state that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including, but not limited to, any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service.
(e)Carrier of last resort has the same meaning as defined in Section 275.6.
(f)Commitment letter means an affidavit signed by an officer of a telephone corporation with legal authority to bind the telephone corporation to its obligations.
(g)Comparatively priced alternative voice basic service means an alternative voice basic service that is competitively priced in relation to the relevant telephone corporations nondiscounted basic exchange telephone service when considering all the alternatives in the amended status area and the functionalities of the alternatives.
(h)Compliance means following an applicable commission rule or order, corrective action plan, or other remedy, or completing a commission corrective action plan or other remedy, including payment of an applicable fine, for a census block subject to an application under this article.
(i)Eligible area means a census block that is either of the following:
(1)A census block that is well-served.
(2)A census block where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
(j)Eligible small business customer means a traditional landline customer with five or fewer lines, that is not subject to a separate contract for copper-based voice services and fits the microbusiness definition in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 14837 of the Government Code.
(k)Notice means a written communication.
(l)Public safety agency technology upgrade grant means a grant awarded to a law enforcement agency, as defined in Section 13670 of the Penal Code, for new technology, or an upgrade to existing copper-based systems, to transition to a modern communication system.
(m)Qualifying public assistance program means any of the following programs:
(1)The California Alternate Rates for Energy (CARE) program described in Section 739.1.
(2)The State Supplementary Payment Program for the Aged, Blind and Disabled implemented pursuant to the Burton-Moscone-Bagley Citizens Income Security Act for Aged, Blind and Disabled Californians (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 12000) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(3)The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program pursuant to Part A (commencing with Section 401) of Title IV of the federal Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 601 et seq.).
(4)The CalFresh program established pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 18900) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(5)Covered California, as described in Title 22 (commencing with Section 100500) of the Government Code.
(6)Medi-Cal, as described in the Medi-Cal Act (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 14000.4) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(7)Supplemental security income benefits pursuant to Title XVI of the Social Security Act (Section 1381 of Title 42 of the United States Code).
(n)Small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance means a voucher provided to an eligible small business customer for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services.
(o)Telephone corporation has the same meaning as defined in Section 234.
(p)Well-served means at least three different facilities-based service providers, not including the basic exchange offering over copper infrastructure from the telephone corporation that is acting as the carrier of last resort, offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area, in compliance with commission rules developed and implemented pursuant to Section 776.2, and at least one of the service providers is a wireline provider, at least one two of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, offer alternative voice basic service at prices comparable to tariffed basic service, as confirmed by the commission, at least one of the service providers participates in the lifeline telephone service program pursuant to the Moore Universal Telephone Service Act (Article 8 (commencing with Section 871) of Chapter 4 of Part 1), and an alternative voice basic service is available to all of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as those broadband-serviceable locations are set forth in the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage. coverage or in other telephone, broadband, and wireless service data available to the commission.
(q)Voice over Internet Protocol has the same meaning as defined in Section 239.
2878.1.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit a request to the commission for amended status in an eligible area, consistent with this article.
(b)(1)Subject to this article and other conditions imposed by the commission consistent with this article, the commission shall approve approve, or amend and approve, a request for amended status from a telephone corporation.
(2)Upon the commission approving a request for amended status from a telephone corporation pursuant to this article, the commission shall grant the telephone corporation relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area, consistent with Sections 2878.2 and 2878.3.
(c)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a map designating well-served areas. The map adopted by the commission shall include data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to commission Rulemaking 23-02-016 (March 1, 2023), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Rules to Implement the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program, or from the Federal Communications Commissions National Broadband Map. Map, or from other telephone, broadband, and wireless service data available to the commission.
(d)A telephone corporation shall be in compliance with General Order 133-E, Rules Governing Telecommunications Services, or a successor to that general order adopted by the commission, for the preceding 12 months in order to be eligible to request amended status.
2878.2.(a)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit to the commission a request for amended status for an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area.
(b)The process adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include, at minimum, all of the following:
(1)Authorization for a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this section to file a Tier 2 advice letter to request amended status. status and, notwithstanding any other statute or rule, to modify the basic exchange service tariff accordingly.
(2)Public notification requirements.
(3)(A)A procedure for an applicable household or a representative of that household to challenge a request for amended status, before the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area does have a population or that the telephone corporation does provide basic exchange service to a customer address within the applicable area.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third party third-party review entity.
(C)The commission shall not approve a request for amended status for an area for which there is a pending challenge.
(D)The commission shall provide 90 days for a challenge of a request for amended status.
(E)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(F)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area does have a population or that the telephone corporation does provide basic exchange service to a customer address within the applicable area. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable census block.
(G)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity to review a challenge described in this paragraph, consistent with both of the following:
(i)If the commission contracts with a third-party review entity, the telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article shall reimburse the commission for the costs of contracting with the third-party review entity.
(ii)A telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may recommend third-party review entities to the commission in a request for amended status.
(c)Upon the commission approving a request for amended status from a telephone corporation pursuant to this section, the commission shall grant the telephone corporation relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area.
2878.3.(a)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit to the commission a request for amended status for an area that is well-served, based on the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.
(b)The process adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include, at minimum, all of the following:
(1)Authorization for a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this section to file a Tier 2 advice letter to request amended status. status and, notwithstanding any other statute or rule, to modify the basic exchange service tariff accordingly.
(2)A process to notify affected customers when a request for amended status is being considered by the commission. The notice shall include a map of each proposed amended status area as described in the request for amended status.
(3)A process to notify affected customers when a request for amended status has been approved by the commission.
(4)(A)A procedure for an applicable household or a representative of that household to challenge a request for amended status, before the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area is not well-served.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third-party review entity.
(C)The commission shall not approve a request for amended status for an area for which there is a pending challenge.
(D)The commission shall provide 180 days for a challenge of a request for amended status.
(E)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(F)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area is not well-served. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable census block.
(G)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity to review a challenge described in this paragraph, consistent with both of the following:
(i)If the commission contracts with a third-party review entity, the telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article shall reimburse the commission for the costs of contracting with the third-party review entity.
(ii)A telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may recommend third-party review entities to the commission in a request for amended status.
(5)(A)A procedure for an affected customer to challenge their inclusion in an amended status area, after the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area is not well-served.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third-party review entity.
(C)The commission shall impose reasonable timeliness requirements for an affected customers challenge to their inclusion in an amended status area, which shall prohibit a challenge from being submitted more than 180 days after notification is provided pursuant to paragraph (3).
(D)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(E)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area is not well-served. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable area.
(F)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity, which may be the same third-party review entity contracted with pursuant to paragraph (4), to review a challenge described in this paragraph.
(c)The commission shall grant the telephone corporation approve, or amend and approve, a telephone corporationss advice letter requesting relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(1)The commission approves the request for amended status from the telephone corporation pursuant to this section.
(2)At least 180 days have passed since the first notification was provided to the affected customer pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
(3)All challenges received by the commission pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) have been resolved.
2878.4.(a)A telephone corporation granted relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within an amended status area that is well-served, pursuant to Section 2878.3, shall do all the following:
(1)(A)Within six years from the effective date a telephone corporation first obtains amended status, the telephone corporation shall demonstrate that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first request for amended status, one-half of which shall be in areas that are not well-served as of the effective date it first obtained amended status. The telephone corporation shall provide an annual report to the executive director of the commission certifying all of the following:
(B)The telephone corporation made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout consistent with subparagraph (A).
(C)The telephone corporation had a positive year-over-year increase in its advanced fiber optics buildout in the state and deployment in unserved and underserved areas.
(D)An annual report submitted pursuant to this section shall be subject to Section 583.(2)Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
(3)To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. For purposes of this paragraph, comparatively priced alternative voice basic service shall, in addition to meeting the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 2878, provide interoperability with legacy devices utilizing copper for alarm systems, point-of-sale devices, and medical monitoring devices.
(4)To the extent technically feasible, offer a discounted broadband plan in each amended status area to eligible consumers for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400 percent of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a qualifying public assistance program.
(5)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, offer small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance in each amended status area to eligible small business customers who transition to an alternative voice basic service by providing a voucher to eligible small business customers for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services. Vouchers shall be administered by the telephone corporation and participation in the program reported annually to the commission.
(6)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for public safety agency technology upgrade grants to be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections to public safety agencies that have at least one service connection located in an amended status area. Administrative costs incurred by the Board of State and Community Corrections shall be recouped from the grant fund.
(7)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding to the Office of Emergency Services for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments that focus on public outreach and awareness of modern communications, including, but not limited to, alternative voice basic services, for those with low incomes, disabilities, language barriers, older adults, and residents in high-risk areas, to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
(8)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
(9)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes, but is not limited to, enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmanagement employees.
(10)Conduct a minimum of one informational workshop in each legislative district that includes one or more amended status areas, and conduct a minimum of one additional informational workshop in other legislative districts upon request from the Assembly Member or Senator representing the districts.
(11)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, maintain an internet website and toll-free number dedicated to answering questions regarding the amended status process.
(12)For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
(b)A telephone corporation granted relief from its carrier of last resort status within an amended status area that is well-served pursuant to Section 2878.3, or where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area pursuant to Section 2878.2, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Any transition, construction, maintenance, or installation of communications infrastructure pursuant to this article shall not result in the involuntary elimination of existing union-represented technician positions who build and maintain the legacy copper network without first offering the displaced technicians either retention, retraining, or placement in another union-represented position. Job titles and employee classifications in a collective bargaining agreement without an existing job preservation guarantee shall not be entitled to the benefits provided for under this paragraph.
(2)For any transition, construction, maintenance, or installation of communications infrastructure pursuant to this article performed by regular full-time workers employed directly by an employer responsible for the transition, construction, maintenance, or installation, the employer shall pay the workers prevailing wages or their bargained contractual wage rates.
(3)Upon commencing any transition, construction, maintenance, or installation of communications infrastructure pursuant to this article, the telephone corporation shall submit to the commission and the relevant policy committees of the Legislature a workforce compliance plan, which shall include all of the following:
(A)Documentation of compliance with all workforce provisions.
(B)A plan for using union labor.
(C)A description of any retraining programs for existing workers.
(b)(c)The commission may impose a remedy, after notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, if the a telephone corporation fails to meet any requirement described in of subdivision (a). (a) or (b). The remedies may include those authorized in Section 1701.6 or pursuant to Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 2100) of Part 1.
2878.5.(a)(1)The requirements in this section only apply to a telephone corporation that has received amended status.
(2)The requirements in this section apply for 10 years after a telephone corporation has received amended status.
(b)(1)A telephone corporation that has received amended status shall provide alternative voice basic service to any residential consumer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served area if both of the following occur:
(A)The residential consumer notifies the telephone corporation or commission that no alternative voice basic service is available in the well-served area.
(B)The commission determines that no alternative voice basic service is available.
(2)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers notification under subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the commission shall determine whether alternative voice basic service is available in the area.
(3)When the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, that identifies an alternative voice basic service available at the residential consumers location.
2878.6.The Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, the moneys in the fund are hereby continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the commission for purposes of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4. The fund may accept donations from nongovernmental entities.
2878.7.A telephone corporation shall provide continuing service to a customer who participates in the lifeline program pursuant to the Moore Universal Telephone Service Act (Article 8 (commencing with Section 871) of Chapter 4 of Part 1) for a period of three years from the date the telephone corporation is granted amended status for the area in which the customer is located, during which time the telephone corporation shall provide to the customer transition assistance to a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service.
2878.7.2878.8.(a)This article does not apply to legacy computer-aided dispatch systems or intrastate legacy time-division multiplexing services used to directly connect land mobile radio systems used for public safety.
(b)This article does not apply to any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well-served.
(c)Upon the commissions approval of a telephone corporations amended status, the amended status area shall no longer require a carrier of last resort. In that amended status area, the commission shall not designate any other entity, including, but not limited to, providers of Voice over Internet Protocol service, wireless service, or other Internet Protocol-enabled services, as a successor carrier of last resort for that census block.
(d)This article does not modify the regulatory authority of the commission over alternative voice basic services or Voice over Internet Protocol services.
(e)This article does not modify or reduce the obligations of a telephone corporation to be the carrier of last resort in any area that is not an eligible area for amended status.
(f)This article does not authorize a telephone corporation to, as part of its advice letter requesting relief from its carrier of last resort status, modify its obligations related to either of the following:
(1)Tariffs required for the 911 or Next Generation 911 service pursuant to the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act (Article 6 (commencing with section 53100) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(2)The telephone corporations designation as an eligible telecommunications carrier pursuant to Section 54.201 of Title 47 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which adds subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 to the Public Utilities Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:In order to order to protect the confidential and proprietary information of an entity subject to Section 2 of this act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.SEC. 4.SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)(1)The state encourages the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability to all Californians by utilizing regulatory forbearance measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other methods that encourage infrastructure investment.
(b)(2)All Californians deserve reliable, affordable, fast, and safe communications communication options, no matter who they are, where they live, or why they need to be connected.
(c)(3)The transition to broadband advanced fiber optic networks is key to creating equity and positive impacts on California education, health care, agriculture, public safety, workforce development, and the economy.
(d)Outdated state laws result in continued investments in aging technology that consumers have largely abandoned because it does not meet their needs.(e)(4)Californians are moving swiftly to abandon the legacy network because it does not provide the benefits of modern communication technologies, with more choosing to use advanced services every year.
(f)(5)California must develop a responsible and equitable transition plan that ensures all Californians have access to the connectivity they need.
(g)(6)The transition should include a phased approach that over time ensures customers have access to communication services that are equally or more reliable and affordable, before transitioning away from the old legacy network.
(h)(7)As part of the transition, no Californian will be left without reliable voice service in their homes, home, including the ability to contact 9-1-1.
(8)The purposes of this act are to ensure Californias longstanding commitment to universal service is not compromised by changes to the telecommunications marketplace and to ensure the public may benefit from the transition away from legacy networks. To that end, this act establishes a comprehensive and robust process for a telephone corporation to seek changes to its obligations as a carrier of last resort for eligible areas only, and requirements to ensure the public benefits from those changes.
(b)By choosing to enact legislation affecting a narrow scope of areas with robust competition or no direct impact to an existing population, it is the intent of the Legislature to allow the Public Utilities Commission to continue commission Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, for areas that are not eligible areas under this act.
SEC. 2.Article 1.5 (commencing with Section 2878) is added to Chapter 10 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to read:1.5.Carriers of Last Resort2878.For purposes of this article, all of the following definitions apply:
(a)(1)Alternative voice basic service means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
(A)Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
(B)Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
(C)Compatibility with a backup power source.
(D)A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
(E)Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to Section 2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
(F)Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
(G)Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
(2)Alternative voice basic service shall be a separate definition from basic service, as defined in commission Decision 12-12-038 (December 24, 2012), Order Instituting Rulemaking Regarding Revisions to the California High Cost Fund B Program, and does not encompass any obligations of any other service except as defined in this section.
(b)Amended status means the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
(c)Amended status area means a census block or census blocks for which a telephone corporation has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status.
(d)Broadband service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio provided to customers in the state that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including, but not limited to, any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service.
(e)Carrier of last resort has the same meaning as defined in Section 275.6.
(e)(f)Commitment letter means an affidavit signed by an officer of a telephone corporation with legal authority to bind the telephone corporation to its obligations.
(f)(g)Comparatively priced alternative voice basic service means an alternative voice basic service that is competitively priced in relation to the relevant telephone corporations nondiscounted basic exchange telephone service when considering all the alternatives in the amended status area and the functionalities of the alternatives.
(h)Compliance means following an applicable commission rule or order, corrective action plan, or other remedy, or completing a commission corrective action plan or other remedy, including payment of an applicable fine, for a census block subject to an application under this article.
(i)Eligible area means a census block that is either of the following:
(1)A census block that is well-served.
(2)A census block where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
(g)(j)Eligible small business customer means a traditional landline customer with five or fewer lines, that is not subject to a separate contract for copper-based voice services and fits the microbusiness definition in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 14837 of the Government Code.
(h)(k)Notice means a written communication.
(i)(l)Public safety agency technology upgrade grant means a grant awarded to a law enforcement agency, as defined in Section 13670 of the Penal Code, for new technology, or an upgrade to existing copper-based systems, to transition to a modern communication system.
(j)(m)Qualifying public assistance program means any of the following programs:
(1)The California Alternate Rates for Energy (CARE) program described in Section 739.1.
(2)The State Supplementary Payment Program for the Aged, Blind and Disabled implemented pursuant to the Burton-Moscone-Bagley Citizens Income Security Act for Aged, Blind and Disabled Californians (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 12000) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(3)The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program pursuant to Part A (commencing with Section 401) of Title IV of the federal Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 601 et seq.).
(4)The CalFresh program established pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 18900) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(5)Covered California, as described in Title 22 (commencing with Section 100500) of the Government Code.
(6)Medi-Cal, as described in the Medi-Cal Act (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 14000.4) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(7)Supplemental security income benefits pursuant to Title XVI of the Social Security Act (Section 1381 of Title 42 of the United States Code).
(k)(n)Small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance means a voucher provided to an eligible small business customer for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services.
(o)Telephone corporation has the same meaning as defined in Section 234.
(l)(p)Well-served means at least three different facilities-based service providers providers, not including the basic exchange offering over copper infrastructure from the telephone corporation that is acting as the carrier of last resort, offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area, in compliance with commission rules developed and implemented pursuant to Section 776.2, and at least one of the service providers is a wireline provider, at least one of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, and at least one of the service providers participates in the lifeline telephone service program pursuant to the Moore Universal Telephone Service Act (Article 8 (commencing with Section 871) of Chapter 4 of Part 1). An 1), and an alternative voice basic service shall be is available to at least 99.9 percent all of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as such those broadband-serviceable locations are set forth in the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(q)Voice over Internet Protocol has the same meaning as defined in Section 239.
2878.1.(a)Upon approval by the commission of a Tier 1 advice letter filed by a telephone corporation seeking approval for amended status, the telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory when the telephone corporation fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.3.(b)Upon approval by the commission of a Tier 2 advice letter filed by a telephone corporation seeking approval for amended status, the telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area that is well-served when the telephone corporation fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.4.(c)In an existing proceeding, on or before December 15, 2026, the commission shall adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible to be amended status areas under Section 2878.4. The map adopted by the commission shall reflect data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to commission Rulemaking 23-02-016, Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Rules to Implement the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program, or the Federal Communications Commissions National Broadband Map, whichever is available for use to complete the map on or before December 15, 2026.(d)Subject to other provisions of this article, an area shall be eligible to be an amended status area if it is well-served or it is an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.(e)The commission shall approve a request for relief by a carrier of last resort as required by and in accordance with this article.2878.2.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under Section 2878.3 shall file a Tier 1 advice letter with the commission. A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under Section 2878.4 shall file a Tier 2 advice letter with the commission seeking approval by the commission for amended status in its service territory based on the map adopted pursuant to Section 2878.1. Notwithstanding any existing commission rule or decision, the commission shall approve the advice letter if the telephone corporation meets the requirements set forth in this article. (b)Before approving an advice letter submitted pursuant to (a), the commission shall require a telephone corporation to publish notice of its intention one time in the nonlegal section of a newspaper of general circulation throughout the relevant areas and on any social media channels the company utilizes for marketing in those areas. The notice shall provide all of the following:(1)A full explanation to residential consumers regarding the commissions process for granting amended status and the applicable timelines. The explanation shall include a map of each proposed amended status area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage or the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.(2)A provision stating that any residential consumer may oppose the telephone corporations assertion that there is no population and no basic exchange service customer if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.3, or that the area is well-served if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.4, by submitting a request to the telephone corporation or the commission seeking independent third-party review. The notice shall state that the request shall be submitted to the telephone corporation or the commission no later than 90 days from the date on the notice. The notice shall provide contact information for the commission, as determined by the commission.(c)Regarding a residential consumers request pursuant to subdivision (a), the following shall apply to the telephone corporation:(1)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers request, the telephone corporation shall identify and submit to the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review.(2)No later than 30 days after the identification and submission, the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review.(3)The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.(4)The independent third-party review shall evaluate the accuracy of the residential consumers claim and make its determination within 30 days of selection.(5)(A)If the independent third-party reviewer determines that the residential consumers claim is accurate, the telephone corporation shall offer to provide, to the extent technically feasible, the residential consumer with alternative voice basic service at that address for 24 months from the amended status effective date.(B)A residential consumers claim is accurate if there is a preponderance of evidence that a location is not well-served, or is not in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory. A residential consumer may submit evidence demonstrating that the location is not eligible to be an amended status area.2878.3.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer at a customer address, shall submit the notice described in subdivision (b) to all of the following entities:(1)The Governor.(2)The commission.(3)The Office of Emergency Services.(4)The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection.(5)Each city, county, city and county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status area.(b)(1)The notice shall be in writing and be delivered to the address of record.(2)The notice shall include both of the following:(A)A map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband or the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.(B)A copy of the tariff modification describing the telephone corporations amended status in the areas covered by the map provided pursuant to subparagraph (A).(c)The amended status and the tariff modification shall be effective upon approval by the commission of the Tier 1 advice letter. The telephone corporation shall respond in good faith to all inquiries from those entities receiving notification pursuant to subdivision (a).2878.1.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit a request to the commission for amended status in an eligible area, consistent with this article.
(b)(1)Subject to this article and other conditions imposed by the commission consistent with this article, the commission shall approve a request for amended status from a telephone corporation.
(2)Upon the commission approving a request for amended status from a telephone corporation pursuant to this article, the commission shall grant the telephone corporation relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area, consistent with Sections 2878.2 and 2878.3.
(c)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a map designating well-served areas. The map adopted by the commission shall include data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to commission Rulemaking 23-02-016 (March 1, 2023), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Rules to Implement the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program, or from the Federal Communications Commissions National Broadband Map.
(d)A telephone corporation shall be in compliance with General Order 133-E, Rules Governing Telecommunications Services, or a successor to that general order adopted by the commission, for the preceding 12 months in order to be eligible to request amended status.
2878.2.(a)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit to the commission a request for amended status for an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area.
(b)The process adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include, at minimum, all of the following:
(1)Authorization for a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this section to file a Tier 2 advice letter to request amended status.
(2)Public notification requirements.
(3)(A)A procedure for an applicable household or a representative of that household to challenge a request for amended status, before the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area does have a population or that the telephone corporation does provide basic exchange service to a customer address within the applicable area.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third party review entity.
(C)The commission shall not approve a request for amended status for an area for which there is a pending challenge.
(D)The commission shall provide 90 days for a challenge of a request for amended status.
(E)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(F)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area does have a population or that the telephone corporation does provide basic exchange service to a customer address within the applicable area. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable census block.
(G)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity to review a challenge described in this paragraph, consistent with both of the following:
(i)If the commission contracts with a third-party review entity, the telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article shall reimburse the commission for the costs of contracting with the third-party review entity.
(ii)A telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may recommend third-party review entities to the commission in a request for amended status.
(c)Upon the commission approving a request for amended status from a telephone corporation pursuant to this section, the commission shall grant the telephone corporation relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area.
2878.3.(a)In an existing proceeding, the commission shall, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article may submit to the commission a request for amended status for an area that is well-served, based on the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.
(b)The process adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include, at minimum, all of the following:
(1)Authorization for a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this section to file a Tier 2 advice letter to request amended status.
(2)A process to notify affected customers when a request for amended status is being considered by the commission. The notice shall include a map of each proposed amended status area as described in the request for amended status.
(3)A process to notify affected customers when a request for amended status has been approved by the commission.
(4)(A)A procedure for an applicable household or a representative of that household to challenge a request for amended status, before the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area is not well-served.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third-party review entity.
(C)The commission shall not approve a request for amended status for an area for which there is a pending challenge.
(D)The commission shall provide 180 days for a challenge of a request for amended status.
(E)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(F)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area is not well-served. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable census block.
(G)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity to review a challenge described in this paragraph, consistent with both of the following:
(i)If the commission contracts with a third-party review entity, the telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under this article shall reimburse the commission for the costs of contracting with the third-party review entity.
(ii)A telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may recommend third-party review entities to the commission in a request for amended status.
(5)(A)A procedure for an affected customer to challenge their inclusion in an amended status area, after the request for amended status has been approved by the commission, on the basis that the applicable area is not well-served.
(B)The commission shall provide for a process to submit a challenge to the proposal for amended status to a third-party review entity.
(C)The commission shall impose reasonable timeliness requirements for an affected customers challenge to their inclusion in an amended status area, which shall prohibit a challenge from being submitted more than 180 days after notification is provided pursuant to paragraph (3).
(D)Upon receipt of a challenge to a request for amended status, the commission or a third-party review entity, if applicable, shall review and approve, modify, or deny the challenge within 30 days.
(E)The commission or third-party review entity shall approve a challenge if there is a preponderance of evidence that the applicable area is not well-served. Upon the commission or third-party review entity approving a challenge, the commission shall not approve a request for amended status for the applicable area.
(F)The commission may contract with a third-party review entity, which may be the same third-party review entity contracted with pursuant to paragraph (4), to review a challenge described in this paragraph.
(c)The commission shall grant the telephone corporation relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within the amended status area upon the occurrence of all of the following:
(1)The commission approves the request for amended status from the telephone corporation pursuant to this section.
(2)At least 180 days have passed since the first notification was provided to the affected customer pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
(3)All challenges received by the commission pursuant to paragraph (4) or (5) of subdivision (b) have been resolved.
2878.4.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas that are well-served shall commit to the obligations described in subdivision (b) and provide the notice described in subdivision (c) to its basic exchange customers. The telephone corporations amended status in well-served areas shall be effective upon approval by the commission of the Tier 2 advice letter.(b)2878.4.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area granted relief from its carrier of last resort status and obligations within an amended status area that is well-served shall provide a commitment letter that certifies that the telephone corporation agrees to meet the obligations listed in this subdivision in well-served areas for 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area, unless specified otherwise below. The letter shall be addressed to the Governor with copies of the letter provided to the commission and each city, county, or unincorporated town or village in the amended status areas. The telephone corporation shall, and the letter shall state that the telephone corporation shall, well-served, pursuant to Section 2878.3, shall do all the following:
(1)For three (A)Within six years from the effective date a telephone corporation first obtains amended status, the telephone corporation shall demonstrate that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status. of its first request for amended status, one-half of which shall be in areas that are not well-served as of the effective date it first obtained amended status. The telephone corporation shall provide an annual report to the executive director of the commission certifying all of the following:
(A)(B)The telephone corporation made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status. consistent with subparagraph (A).
(B)(C)The telephone corporation had a positive year-over-year increase in its advanced fiber optics buildout in the state and deployment in unserved and underserved areas.
(C)(D)An annual report submitted pursuant to this section shall be subject to Section 583.
(2)Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
(3)To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service. service for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. For purposes of this paragraph, comparatively priced alternative voice basic service shall, in addition to meeting the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 2878, provide interoperability with legacy devices utilizing copper for alarm systems, point-of-sale devices, and medical monitoring devices.
(4)To the extent technically feasible, offer a discounted broadband plan in each amended status area to eligible consumers. consumers for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400 percent of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a qualifying public assistance program.
(5)Offer For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, offer small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance in each amended status area to eligible small business customers who transition to an alternative voice basic service by providing a voucher to eligible small business customers for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services. Vouchers shall be administered by the telephone corporation and participation in the program reported annually to the commission.
(6)Provide For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for public safety agency technology upgrade grants to be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections to public safety agencies that have at least one service connection located in an amended status area. Administrative costs incurred by the Board of State and Community Corrections shall be recouped from the grant fund.
(7)Provide For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding to the Office of Emergency Services for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments that focus on public outreach and awareness of modern communications, including, but not limited to, alternative voice basic services, for those with low incomes, disabilities, language barriers, older adults, and residents in high-risk areas, to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
(8)Provide For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
(9)Provide For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes, but is not limited to, enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmanagement employees.
(10)During the 90-day notice period described in subdivision (c), conduct Conduct a minimum of one informational workshop in each legislative district that includes one or more amended status areas, and conduct a minimum of one additional informational workshop in other legislative districts upon request from the Assembly Member or Senator representing the districts.
(11)Maintain For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, maintain an internet website and toll-free number dedicated to answering questions regarding the amended status process.
(12)Commit to For at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status, engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
(c)The telephone corporation shall provide three notice letters to customers in the amended areas. The letters shall be sent 30 days apart. The notice letters must comply with the commissions rules for in-language support to limited English proficient telecommunications consumers adopted pursuant to commission Decision 07-07-043 (July 26, 2007), Decision Addressing the Needs of Telecommunications Consumers Who Have Limited English Proficiency, or as subsequently revised. Each letter shall include all the following information:(1)A full explanation to customers regarding the amended status process and timing. The explanation shall include a map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.(2)A description of the alternative voice basic service available from the telephone corporation.(3)A description of the discounted broadband plans available from the telephone corporation to eligible consumers in the amended status areas.(4)Links to the internet websites and telephone numbers of alternative voice basic service providers in the amended status areas.(5)The date, time, and location of the informational workshop for the customers amended status area.(d)The telephone corporation shall provide a copy of the template used for the three customer notice letters in each amended status area to all the following entities:(1)The commission.(2)The Members of the Legislature representing districts included in the amended status areas.(3)Each city, county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status areas.(e)(b)The commission may seek impose a remedy, after notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any obligation in the commitment letter requirement described in subdivision (b). (a). The remedies may include those authorized in Section 1701.6 or pursuant to Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 2100) of Part 1.
2878.5.(a)(1)A customer in a well-served area where a telephone corporation seeks to amend its status may do either of the following during the period before the effective date of the amended status:(A)Choose an alternative voice basic service provided by the telephone corporation.(B)Choose an alternative voice basic service provided by another service provider.(2)(A)If the customer does not choose either option described in paragraph (1), the customer shall remain on their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation.(B)The telephone corporation shall provide a customer remaining on their basic exchange service with two notice letters regarding the telephone corporations transition from the current voice service, which transition shall occur no sooner than 12 months from the amended status effective date described in subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 and after all state and federal regulatory requirements have been met. The notice letters shall be sent 30 days apart. Each notice letter shall include information explaining the status of the customers existing service and, if applicable, how the customer may seek the independent third-party review described in subdivision (b).(b)(1)If a customer continues to subscribe to their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation for 12 months after the amended status effective date and, upon receipt of the notice letters required by subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), is unable to obtain a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, then the customer may submit a request, pursuant to the instructions provided by the telephone corporation in the notice letters, seeking independent third-party review. The customer shall submit this request to the telephone corporation or the commission no later than 60 days after the date of the second notice letter.(2)No later than 30 days from receipt of the customers request, the telephone corporation shall submit to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, the identities of three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review. No later than 30 days after the identification, the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review. The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.(3)The entity selected pursuant to paragraph (2) shall determine whether or not a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service is available at the customers address and shall report its determination to the customer, the telephone corporation, and the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, within 30 days after being requested to conduct a review under paragraph (2).(4)If, based on a preponderance of the evidence, the independent third-party reviewer determines that a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service is not available at the customer address, the telephone corporation shall continue to provide the customer with the customers basic exchange service at that address. If the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed at any time, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, identifying a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service at the customers address and restarting the process set forth in paragraph (2).2878.6.2878.5.(a)(1)The obligations requirements in this section only apply to a telephone corporation that has received amended status. status.
(2)The obligations requirements in this section apply for 10 years after a telephone corporation meets the requirement described in paragraph (1). has received amended status.
(b)(1)A telephone corporation that meets the requirement described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) has received amended status shall provide alternative voice basic service to any residential consumer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served area if both of the following occur:
(A)The residential consumer notifies the telephone corporation or commission that no alternative voice basic service is available in the well-served area.
(B)The commission determines that no alternative voice basic service is available.
(2)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers notification under subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the commission shall determine whether alternative voice basic service is available in the area.
(3)When the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, that identifies an alternative voice basic service available at the residential consumers location.
2878.7.(a)This article does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice basic services.(b)As part of its Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, the commission shall determine a transition plan that shall be followed before a telephone corporation may amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas not described in Section 2878.3 or not well-served by alternative voice basic services as described in Section 2878.4. The commission may consider input from stakeholders during this process, including representatives of public safety agencies. The commission shall issue its final decision on or before January 1, 2027.2878.8.2878.6.The Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant Fund is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, the moneys in the fund are hereby continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the commission for purposes of paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) (a) of Section 2878.4. The fund may accept donations from nongovernmental entities entities.
2878.9.2878.7.(a)This article shall does not apply to intrastate legacy time-division multiplexing services used to directly connect land mobile radio systems used for public safety.
(b)This article shall does not apply to any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well-served.
(c)Upon the commissions approval of a telephone corporations amended status, the amended status area shall no longer require a carrier of last resort. In that amended status area, the commission shall not designate any other entity, including, but not limited to, providers of Voice over Internet Protocol service, wireless service, or other Internet Protocol-enabled services, as a successor carrier of last resort for that census block.
(d)This article does not modify the regulatory authority of the commission over alternative voice basic services or Voice over Internet Protocol services.
(e)This article does not modify or reduce the obligations of a telephone corporation to be the carrier of last resort in any area that is not an eligible area for amended status.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which adds subparagraph (C) (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) (a) of Section 2878.4 to the Public Utilities Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to order to protect the confidential and proprietary information of an entity subject to Section 2 of this act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The state encourages the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability to all Californians by utilizing regulatory forbearance measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other methods that encourage infrastructure investment.
(b)All Californians deserve reliable, affordable, fast, and safe communications options, no matter who they are, where they live, or why they need to be connected.
(c)The transition to broadband networks is key to creating equity and positive impacts on California education, health care, agriculture, public safety, workforce development, and the economy.
(d)Outdated state laws result in continued investments in aging technology that consumers have largely abandoned because it does not meet their needs.
(e)Californians are moving swiftly to abandon the legacy network because it does not provide the benefits of modern communication technologies, with more choosing to use advanced services every year.
(f)California must develop a responsible and equitable transition plan that ensures all Californians have access to the connectivity they need.
(g)The transition should include a phased approach that over time ensures customers have access to communication services that are equally or more reliable and affordable, before transitioning away from the old legacy network.
(h)As part of the transition, no Californian will be left without reliable voice service in their homes, including the ability to contact 9-1-1.
SEC. 2.Article 1.5 (commencing with Section 2878) is added to Chapter 10 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to read:1.5.Carriers of Last Resort2878.For purposes of this article, all of the following definitions apply:
(a)(1)Alternative voice basic service means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
(1)(A)Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
(2)(B)Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
(3)(C)Compatibility with a backup power source.
(4)(D)A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
(5)(E)Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to Section 2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
(6)(F)Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
(7)(G)Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
(2)Alternative voice basic service shall be a separate definition from basic service, as defined in commission Decision 12-12-038 (December 24, 2012), Order Instituting Rulemaking Regarding Revisions to the California High Cost Fund B Program, and does not encompass any obligations of any other service except as defined in this section.
(b)Amended status means the status of a telephone corporation that relinquished has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
(c)Amended status area means a census block or census blocks for which a telephone corporation relinquished has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status.
(d)Broadband service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio provided to customers in the state that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including, but not limited to, any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service.
(e)Commitment letter means an affidavit signed by an officer of a telephone corporation with legal authority to bind the telephone corporation to its obligations.
(e)(f)Comparatively priced alternative voice basic service means an alternative voice basic service that is competitively priced in relation to the relevant telephone corporations nondiscounted basic exchange telephone service when considering all the alternatives in the amended status area and the functionalities of the alternatives.
(f)(g)Eligible small business customer means a traditional landline customer with five or fewer lines, that is not subject to a separate contract for copper-based voice services and fits the microbusiness definition in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 14837 of the Government Code.
(g)(h)Notice means a written communication.
(i)Public safety agency technology upgrade grant means a grant awarded to a law enforcement agency, as defined in Section 13670 of the Penal Code, for new technology, or an upgrade to existing copper-based systems, to transition to a modern communication system.
(h)(j)Qualifying public assistance program means any of the following programs:
(1)The California Alternate Rates for Energy (CARE) program described in Section 739.1.
(2)The State Supplementary Payment Program for the Aged, Blind and Disabled implemented pursuant to the Burton-Moscone-Bagley Citizens Income Security Act for Aged, Blind and Disabled Californians (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 12000) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(3)The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program pursuant to Part A (commencing with Section 401) of Title IV of the federal Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 601 et seq.).
(4)The CalFresh program established pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 18900) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(5)Covered California, as described in Title 22 (commencing with Section 100500) of the Government Code.
(6)Medi-Cal, as described in the Medi-Cal Act (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 14000.4) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(7)Supplemental security income benefits pursuant to Title XVI of the Social Security Act (Section 1381 of Title 42 of the United States Code).
(k)Small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance means a voucher provided to an eligible small business customer for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services.
(i)(l)Well-served means at least three different facilities-based service providers offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area, and at least one of the service providers is a wireline provider, and at least one of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice service. The basic service, and at least one of the service providers participates in the lifeline telephone service program pursuant to the Moore Universal Telephone Service Act (Article 8 (commencing with Section 871) of Chapter 4 of Part 1). An alternative voice basic service shall be available to at least 99.9 percent of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as such broadband-serviceable locations are set forth in the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
2878.1.(a)A Upon approval by the commission of a Tier 1 advice letter filed by a telephone corporation seeking approval for amended status, the telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population or and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory when it the telephone corporation fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.3 2878.3.
(b)A Upon approval by the commission of a Tier 2 advice letter filed by a telephone corporation seeking approval for amended status, the telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area that is well-served when the telephone corporation fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.4.
(c)In an existing proceeding, on or before December 15, 2026, the commission shall adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible to be amended status areas under Section 2878.4. The map adopted by the commission shall reflect data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to commission Rulemaking 23-02-016, Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Rules to Implement the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment Program, or the Federal Communications Commissions National Broadband Map, whichever is available for use to complete the map on or before December 15, 2026.
(d)Subject to other provisions of this article, an area shall be eligible to be an amended status area if it is well-served or it is an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
(e)The commission shall approve a request for relief by a carrier of last resort as required by and in accordance with this article.
2878.2.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under either Section 2878.3 or Section 2878.4 shall first publish notice Section 2878.3 shall file a Tier 1 advice letter with the commission. A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under Section 2878.4 shall file a Tier 2 advice letter with the commission seeking approval by the commission for amended status in its service territory based on the map adopted pursuant to Section 2878.1. Notwithstanding any existing commission rule or decision, the commission shall approve the advice letter if the telephone corporation meets the requirements set forth in this article.
(b)Before approving an advice letter submitted pursuant to (a), the commission shall require a telephone corporation to publish notice of its intention one time in the nonlegal section of a newspaper of general circulation throughout the relevant areas and on any social media channels the company utilizes for marketing in those areas. The notice shall provide all of the following:
(1)A full explanation to residential consumers regarding the commissions process for granting amended status process and the applicable timelines. The explanation shall include a map of each proposed amended status area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage. coverage or the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.
(2)A provision stating that any residential consumer may oppose the telephone corporations assertion that there is either no population or and no basic exchange service customer if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.3, or that the area is well-served if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.4, by submitting a written request to the telephone corporation or the commission seeking independent third-party review. The notice shall state that the written request shall be submitted to the telephone corporation or the commission no later than 90 days from the date on the notice. The notice shall provide contact information for the commission, as determined by the commission.
(b)(c)Regarding a residential consumers written request pursuant to subdivision (a), the following shall apply to the telephone corporation:
(1)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers written request, the telephone corporation shall identify and submit to the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review.
(2)No later than 30 days after the identification and submission, the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review.
(3)The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.
(4)The independent third-party review shall evaluate the merits accuracy of the residential consumers claim and make its determination within 30 days of selection.
(5)(A)If the independent third-party reviewer determines that the residential consumers claim has merit, is accurate, the telephone corporation shall offer to provide, to the extent technically feasible, the residential consumer with alternative voice basic service at that address for 24 months from the amended status effective date.
(B)A residential consumers claim is accurate if there is a preponderance of evidence that a location is not well-served, or is not in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory. A residential consumer may submit evidence demonstrating that the location is not eligible to be an amended status area.
2878.3.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area that where the United States Census Bureau reports no population, or that population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer at a customer address, shall submit the notice described in subdivision (b) to all of the following entities:
(1)The Governor.
(2)The commission.
(3)The Office of Emergency Services.
(4)The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection.
(5)Each city, county, city and county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status area.
(b)(1)The notice shall be in writing and be delivered to the address of record.
(2)The notice shall include both of the following:
(A)A map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage. or the map adopted by the commission pursuant to Section 2878.1.
(B)A copy of the tariff modification describing the telephone corporations amended status in the areas covered by the map provided pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(c)The amended status and the tariff modification shall be effective 30 days from the date of the notice. upon approval by the commission of the Tier 1 advice letter. The telephone corporation shall respond in good faith to all inquiries from those entities receiving notification pursuant to subdivision (a).
2878.4.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas that are well served well-served shall commit to the obligations described in subdivision (b) and provide the notice described in subdivision (c) to its basic exchange customers. The telephone corporations amended status in well-served areas shall be effective 30 days from date of the third customer notification letter described in subdivision (c), or 30 days from the date of the commitment letter described in subdivision (b), whichever is later. upon approval by the commission of the Tier 2 advice letter.
(b)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area that is well served well-served shall provide a commitment letter from an officer with authority to bind the telephone corporation that certifies that the telephone corporation agrees to meet the obligations listed in this subdivision in well-served areas for 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area, unless specified otherwise below. The letter shall be addressed to the Governor with copies of the letter provided to the commission and each city, county, or unincorporated town or village in the amended status areas. The telephone corporation shall, and the letter shall state that the telephone corporation shall, do all the following:
(1)For three years from the effective date a telephone corporation obtains amended status, the telephone corporation shall demonstrate that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status. The telephone corporation shall provide an annual report to the executive director of the commission certifying all of the following:
(A)The telephone corporation made accessible its advance advanced fiber optics buildout to at least the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status.
(B)The telephone corporation had a positive year-over-year increase in its advanced fiber optics buildout in the state. state and deployment in unserved and underserved areas.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any An annual report submitted pursuant to this section shall be considered confidential and protected from public disclosure in accordance with subject to Section 583.
(2)Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
(3)To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service. For purposes of this paragraph, comparatively priced alternative voice basic service shall, in addition to meeting the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 2878, provide interoperability with legacy devices utilizing copper for alarm systems, point-of-sale devices, and medical monitoring devices.
(4)Offer an affordable To the extent technically feasible, offer a discounted broadband plan in each amended status area to eligible consumers. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400 percent of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a qualifying public assistance program.
(5)Offer small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance in each amended status area to eligible small business customers who transition to an alternative voice basic service by providing a voucher to eligible small business customers for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services. Vouchers shall be administered by the telephone corporation and participation in the program reported annually to the commission.
(6)Provide funding for public safety agency technology upgrade grants to be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections to public safety agencies that have at least one service connection located in an amended status area. Administrative costs incurred by the Board of State and Community Corrections shall be recouped from the grant fund.
(7)Provide funding to the Office of Emergency Services for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments that focus on public outreach and awareness of modern communications, including, but not limited to, alternative voice basic services, for those with low incomes, disabilities, language barriers, older adults, and residents in high-risk areas, to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
(8)Provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
(9)Provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes, but is not limited to, enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmanagement employees.
(10)During the 90-day notice period described in subdivision (c), conduct a minimum of one informational workshop in each legislative district that includes one or more amended status areas, and conduct a minimum of one additional informational workshop in other legislative districts upon request from the Assembly Member or Senator representing the district. districts.
(11)Maintain an internet website and toll-free number dedicated to answering questions regarding the amended status process.
(12)Commit to engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
(c)The telephone corporation shall provide three notice letters to customers in the amended areas. The letters shall be sent 30 days apart. The notice letters must comply with the commissions rules for in-language support to limited English proficient telecommunications consumers adopted pursuant to commission Decision 07-07-043 (July 26, 2007), Decision Addressing the Needs of Telecommunications Consumers Who Have Limited English Proficiency, or as subsequently revised. Each letter shall include all the following information:
(1)A full explanation to customers regarding the amended status process and timing. The explanation shall include a map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(2)A description of the alternative voice basic service available from the telephone corporation.
(3)A description of the affordable discounted broadband plans available from the telephone corporation to eligible consumers in the amended status areas.
(4)Links to the internet websites and telephone numbers of alternative voice basic service providers in the amended status areas.
(5)The date, time, and location of the informational workshop for the customers amended status area.
(d)The telephone corporation shall provide a copy of the template used for the three customer notice letters in each amended status area to all the following entities:
(1)The commission.
(2)The Members of the Legislature representing districts included in the amended status areas.
(3)Each city, county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status areas.
(e)In addition to the customer notice template described in subdivision (d), the telephone corporation shall file a Tier 1 advice letter with the commission to be effective on the date filed that reflects the amended status areas.(e)The commission may seek a remedy, after notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any obligation in the commitment letter described in subdivision (b).
2878.5.(a)(1)A customer in a well-served area where a telephone corporation seeks to amend its status may do either of the following during the 90-day notice period before the effective date of the amended status:
(A)Choose an alternative voice basic service provided by the telephone corporation.
(B)Choose an alternative voice basic service provided by another service provider.
(2)(A)If the customer does not choose either option described in paragraph (1), the customer shall remain on their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation.
(B)The telephone corporation shall provide a customer remaining on their basic exchange service with two notice letters regarding the telephone corporations transition from the current voice service, which transition shall occur no sooner than 12 months from the amended status effective date described in subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 and after all state and federal regulatory requirements have been met. The notice letters shall be sent 30 days apart. Each notice letter shall include information explaining the status of the customers existing service and, if applicable, how the customer may seek the independent third-party review described in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)If a customer continues to subscribe to their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation for 12 months after the amended status effective date described in subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 and, upon receipt of the notice letters required by subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), is unable to obtain a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, then the customer may submit a written request, pursuant to the instructions provided by the telephone corporation in the notice letters, seeking independent third-party review. The customer shall submit this written request to the telephone corporation or the commission no later than 60 days after the date of the second notice letter.
(2)No later than 30 days from receipt of the customers written request, the telephone corporation shall submit to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, the identities of three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review. No later than 30 days after the identification, the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review. The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.
(3)The entity selected pursuant to paragraph (2) shall determine whether or not a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service is available at the customers address and shall report its determination to the customer, the telephone corporation, and to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, within 30 days after being requested to conduct a review under paragraph (2).
(4)If If, based on a preponderance of the evidence, the independent third-party reviewer determines that a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service is not available at the customer address, the telephone corporation shall continue to provide the customer with the customers basic exchange service at that address. If the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed at any time, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, identifying a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service at the customers address and restarting the process set forth in paragraph (2).
2878.6.(a)(1)The obligations in this section only apply only to a telephone corporation that has received amended status.
(2)The obligations in this section apply for 10 years after a telephone corporation meets the requirements requirement described in paragraph (1).
(b)(1)A telephone corporation that meets the requirements requirement described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall provide alternative voice basic service to any residential consumer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served area if both of the following occur:
(A)The residential consumer notifies the telephone corporation in writing or commission that no alternative voice basic service is available in the well-served area.
(B)An independent third-party reviewer approved by the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee The commission determines that no alternative voice basic service is available in the well-served area. available.
(2)(A)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers written notification under subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the telephone corporation shall identify and submit to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review. commission shall determine whether alternative voice basic service is available in the area.
(B)No later than 30 days after the identification and submission, the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review.(C)The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.(D)The entity selected pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall determine whether or not an alternative voice service is available at the residential consumers address and shall report its determination to the residential consumer, the telephone corporation, and to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, within 30 days after being requested to conduct a review under subparagraph (B).(3)(A)When the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, that identifies an alternative voice basic service available at the residential consumers location.
(B)The telephone corporation shall be relieved of the obligations under paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) if an independent third-party reviewer that is approved by the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, determines that there is an alternative voice service available to the residential consumer.2878.7.(a)This article does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice basic services.
(b)As part of its Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, the commission shall determine a transition plan that shall be followed before a telephone corporation may amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas not described in Section 2878.3 or not well served well-served by alternative voice basic services as described in Section 2878.4. The commission may consider input from stakeholders during this process, including representatives of public safety agencies. The commission shall issue its final decision on or before January 1, 2027.
2878.8.The Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant fund Fund is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, the moneys in the fund are hereby continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the commission for purposes of paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) of Section 2878.4. The fund may accept donations from nongovernmental entities
2878.9.(a)This article shall not apply to intrastate legacy time-division multiplexing services used to directly connect land mobile radio systems used for public safety.
(b)This article shall not apply to any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well served. well-served.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 2 of this act, which adds subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2878.4 of to the Public Utilities Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to order to protect the confidential and proprietary information of an entity subject to Section 1 2 of this act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)All The state encourages the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability to all Californians by utilizing regulatory forbearance measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other methods that encourage infrastructure investment.
(b)All Californians deserve reliable, affordable, fast, and safe communications options, no matter who they are, where they live, or why they need to be connected.
(b)(c)The transition to broadband networks is key to creating equity and positive impacts on California education, health care, agriculture, public safety, workforce development, and the economy.
(c)(d)Outdated state laws result in continued investments in aging technology that consumers are increasingly abandoning have largely abandoned because it does not meet their needs.
(d)(e)Californians are moving swiftly to abandon the old copper legacy network because it does not provide the benefits of modern communication technologies, with more choosing to use wireless or internet-based advanced services every year.
(e)(f)California must develop a responsible and equitable transition plan that ensures all Californians have access to the connectivity they need.
(f)(g)The transition should include a phased approach that over time ensures customers have access to communication services that are equally or more reliable and affordable, before transitioning away from the old legacy network.
(g)(h)As part of the transition, no Californian will be left without reliable voice service in their homes, including the ability to contact 9-1-1 and to receive critical emergency alerts. 9-1-1.
SEC. 2.Article 1.5 (commencing with Section 2878) is added to Chapter 10 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to read:1.5.Carriers of Last Resort2878.For purposes of this article, all of the following definitions apply:
(a)Alternative voice service means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
(1)Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
(2)Access to emergency 9-1-1 service. service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
(3)Compatibility with a backup power source.
(b)Area means census block.(c)Available means the service provider provides coverage to at least 99 percent of the population of the area, according to the most recent federal census population estimates.(d)Carrier of last resort has the same meaning as defined in Section 275.6.(e)Eligible area means either of the following:(1)An area that meets both of the following criteria:(A)The United States Bureau of the Census reports no population in the area.(B)The telephone corporation does not provide basic local exchange telephone service to a customer address in the area.(2)An area that is well-served by alternative voice service.(4)A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
(5)Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to Section 2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
(6)Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
(7)Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
(b)Amended status means the status of a telephone corporation that relinquished carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
(c)Amended status area means a census block or census blocks for which a telephone corporation relinquished carrier of last resort status.
(d)Broadband service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio provided to customers in the state that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including, but not limited to, any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service.
(e)Comparatively priced alternative voice service means an alternative voice service that is competitively priced in relation to the relevant telephone corporations nondiscounted basic exchange telephone service when considering all the alternatives in the amended status area and the functionalities of the alternatives.
(f)Eligible small business customer means a traditional landline customer with five or fewer lines, that is not subject to a separate contract for copper-based voice services and fits the microbusiness definition in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 14837 of the Government Code.
(f)(g)Notice means a written communication.
(h)Qualifying public assistance program means any of the following programs:
(1)The California Alternate Rates for Energy (CARE) program described in Section 739.1.
(2)The State Supplementary Payment Program for the Aged, Blind and Disabled implemented pursuant to the Burton-Moscone-Bagley Citizens Income Security Act for Aged, Blind and Disabled Californians (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 12000) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(3)The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program pursuant to Part A (commencing with Section 401) of Title IV of the federal Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 601 et seq.).
(4)The CalFresh program established pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 18900) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(5)Covered California, as described in Title 22 (commencing with Section 100500) of the Government Code.
(6)Medi-Cal, as described in the Medi-Cal Act (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 14000.4) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(7)Supplemental security income benefits pursuant to Title XVI of the Social Security Act (Section 1381 of Title 42 of the United States Code).
(g)Telephone corporation has the same meaning as defined in Section 234.(h)(i)Well-served means at least three different facilities-based service providers, providers offer alternative voice service in the relevant area, and at least one of which the service providers is a wireline provider, offer alternative voice service to customers in the relevant area, and at least one of the alternative voice services offered by a service provider is reasonably comparable in price or value to the telephone corporations current nondiscounted rate for basic local exchange telephone service. and at least one of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice service. The alternative voice service shall be available to at least 99.9 percent of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as such broadband-serviceable locations are set forth in the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
2878.1.(a)A telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population or where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory when it fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.3
(b)A telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort, or have any carrier of last resort obligations, in an area that is well-served when the telephone corporation fulfills the obligations set forth in Section 2878.4.
2878.2.(a)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort under either Section 2878.3 or Section 2878.4 shall first publish notice of its intention one time in the nonlegal section of a newspaper of general circulation throughout the relevant areas and on any social media channels the company utilizes for marketing in those areas. The notice shall provide all of the following:
(1)A full explanation to residential consumers regarding the amended status process and applicable timelines. The explanation shall include a map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(2)A provision stating that any residential consumer may oppose the telephone corporations assertion that there is either no population or no basic exchange service customer if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.3, or that the area is well-served if the telephone corporation seeks amended status under Section 2878.4, by submitting a written request to the telephone corporation seeking independent third-party review. The notice shall state that the written request shall be submitted to the telephone corporation no later than 90 days from the date on the notice.
(b)Regarding a residential consumers written request pursuant to subdivision (a), the following shall apply to the telephone corporation:
(1)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers written request, the telephone corporation shall identify and submit to the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review.
(2)No later than 30 days after the identification and submission, the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review.
(3)The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.
(4)The independent third-party review shall evaluate the merits of the residential consumers claim and make its determination within 30 days of selection.
(5)If the independent third-party reviewer determines that the residential consumers claim has merit, the telephone corporation shall offer to provide, to the extent technically feasible, the residential consumer with alternative voice service at that address for 24 months from the amended status effective date.
2878.3.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area that the United States Census Bureau reports no population, or that a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer at a customer address, shall submit the notice described in subdivision (b) to all of the following entities:
(1)The Governor.
(2)The commission.
(3)The Office of Emergency Services.
(4)The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection.
(5)Each city, county, city and county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status area.
(b)(1)The notice shall be in writing and be delivered to the address of record.
(2)The notice shall include both of the following:
(A)A map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(B)A copy of the tariff modification describing the telephone corporations amended status in the areas covered by the map provided pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(c)The amended status and the tariff modification shall be effective 30 days from the date of the notice. The telephone corporation shall respond in good faith to all inquiries from those entities receiving notification pursuant to subdivision (a).
2878.4.(a)Subject to completion of the process set forth in Section 2878.2, a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas that are well served shall commit to the obligations described in subdivision (b) and provide the notice described in subdivision (c) to its basic exchange customers. The telephone corporations amended status in well-served areas shall be effective 30 days from date of the third customer notification letter described in subdivision (c), or 30 days from the date of the commitment letter described in subdivision (b), whichever is later.
(b)A telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area that is well served shall provide a commitment letter from an officer with authority to bind the telephone corporation that certifies that the telephone corporation agrees to meet the obligations listed in this subdivision in well-served areas for 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area, unless specified otherwise below. The letter shall be addressed to the Governor with copies of the letter provided to the commission and each city, county, or unincorporated town or village in the amended status areas. The telephone corporation shall, and the letter shall state that the telephone corporation shall, do all the following:
(1)For three years from the effective date a telephone corporation obtains amended status, the telephone corporation shall demonstrate that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status. The telephone corporation shall provide an annual report to the executive director of the commission certifying the following:
(A)The telephone corporation made accessible its advance fiber optics buildout to at least the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its obtaining amended status.
(B)The telephone corporation had a positive year-over-year increase in its advanced fiber optics buildout in the state.
(C)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any annual report submitted pursuant to this section shall be considered confidential and protected from public disclosure in accordance with Section 583.
(2)Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status in the area if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice service.
(3)To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice service. For purposes of this paragraph, comparatively priced alternative voice service shall, in addition to meeting the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 2878, provide interoperability with legacy devices utilizing copper for alarm systems, point-of-sale devices, and medical monitoring devices.
(4)Offer an affordable broadband plan in each amended status area to eligible consumers. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400 percent of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a qualifying public assistance program.
(5)Offer small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance in each amended status area to eligible small business customers who transition to an alternative voice service by providing a voucher to eligible small business customers for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services. Vouchers shall be administered by the telephone corporation and participation in the program reported annually to the commission.
(6)Provide funding for public safety agency technology upgrade grants to be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections to public safety agencies that have at least one service connection located in an amended status area. Administrative costs incurred by the Board of State and Community Corrections shall be recouped from the grant fund.
(7)Provide funding to the Office of Emergency Services for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments that focus on public outreach and awareness of modern communications, including, but not limited to, alternative voice services, for those with low incomes, disabilities, language barriers, older adults, and residents in high-risk areas, to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
(8)Provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
(9)Provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes, but is not limited to, enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmanagement employees.
(10)During the 90-day notice period described in subdivision (c), conduct a minimum of one informational workshop in each legislative district that includes one or more amended status areas, and conduct a minimum of one additional informational workshop in other legislative districts upon request from the Assembly Member or Senator representing the district.
(11)Maintain an internet website and toll-free number dedicated to answering questions regarding the amended status process.
(c)The telephone corporation shall provide three notice letters to customers in the amended areas. The letters shall be sent 30 days apart. The notice letters must comply with the commissions rules for in-language support to limited English proficient telecommunications consumers adopted pursuant to commission Decision 07-07-043 (July 26, 2007), Decision Addressing the Needs of Telecommunications Consumers Who Have Limited English Proficiency, or as subsequently revised. Each letter shall include all the following information:
(1)A full explanation to customers regarding the amended status process and timing. The explanation shall include a map of each area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(2)A description of the alternative voice service available from the telephone corporation.
(3)A description of the affordable broadband plans available from the telephone corporation to eligible consumers in the amended status areas.
(4)Links to the internet websites and telephone numbers of alternative voice service providers in the amended status areas.
(5)The date, time, and location of the informational workshop for the customers amended status area.
(d)The telephone corporation shall provide a copy of the template used for the three customer notice letters in each amended status area to all the following entities:
(1)The commission.
(2)The Members of the Legislature representing districts included in the amended status areas.
(3)Each city, county, or unincorporated town or village included in the amended status areas.
(e)In addition to the customer notice template described in subdivision (d), the telephone corporation shall file a Tier 1 advice letter with the commission to be effective on the date filed that reflects the amended status areas.
2878.5.(a)(1)A customer in a well-served area where a telephone corporation seeks to amend its status may do either of the following during the 90-day notice period before the effective date of the amended status:
(A)Choose an alternative voice service provided by the telephone corporation.
(B)Choose an alternative voice service provided by another service provider.
(2)(A)If the customer does not choose either option described in paragraph (1), the customer shall remain on their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation.
(B)The telephone corporation shall provide a customer remaining on their basic exchange service with two notice letters regarding the telephone corporations transition from the current voice service, which transition shall occur no sooner than 12 months from the amended status effective date described in subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 and after all state and federal regulatory requirements have been met. The notice letters shall be sent 30 days apart. Each notice letter shall include information explaining the status of the customers existing service and, if applicable, how the customer may seek the independent third-party review described in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)If a customer continues to subscribe to their basic exchange service with the telephone corporation for 12 months after the amended status effective date described in subdivision (a) of Section 2878.4 and, upon receipt of the notice letters required by subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), is unable to obtain a comparatively priced alternative voice service, then the customer may submit a written request, pursuant to the instructions provided by the telephone corporation in the notice letters, seeking independent third-party review. The customer shall submit this written request no later than 60 days after the date of the second notice letter.
(2)No later than 30 days from receipt of the customers written request, the telephone corporation shall submit to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, the identities of three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review. No later than 30 days after the identification, the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review. The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.
(3)The entity selected pursuant to paragraph (2) shall determine whether or not a comparatively priced alternative voice service is available at the customers address and shall report its determination to the customer, the telephone corporation, and to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, within 30 days after being requested to conduct a review under paragraph (2).
(4)If the independent third-party reviewer determines that a comparatively priced alternative voice service is not available at the customer address, the telephone corporation shall continue to provide the customer with the customers basic exchange service at that address. If the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed at any time, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, identifying a comparatively priced alternative voice service at the customers address and restarting the process set forth in paragraph (2).
2878.6.(a)(1)The obligations in this section apply only to a telephone corporation that has received amended status.
(2)The obligations in this section apply for 10 years after a telephone corporation meets the requirements described in paragraph (1).
(b)(1)A telephone corporation that meets the requirements described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall provide alternative voice service to any residential consumer that is unable to obtain alternative voice service from any provider in the well-served area if both of the following occur:
(A)The residential consumer notifies the telephone corporation in writing that no alternative voice service is available in the well-served area.
(B)An independent third-party reviewer approved by the executive director of the commission or the executive directors designee determines that no alternative voice service is available in the well-served area.
(2)(A)No later than 30 days after the receipt of the residential consumers written notification under subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the telephone corporation shall identify and submit to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, three entities qualified to conduct the independent third-party review.
(B)No later than 30 days after the identification and submission, the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, shall select one of the three identified entities to conduct the independent third-party review.
(C)The telephone corporation shall contract with the selected entity and pay for the independent third-party review.
(D)The entity selected pursuant to subparagraph (B) shall determine whether or not an alternative voice service is available at the residential consumers address and shall report its determination to the residential consumer, the telephone corporation, and to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, within 30 days after being requested to conduct a review under subparagraph (B).
(3)(A)When the telephone corporation can demonstrate that circumstances have changed, the telephone corporation may submit a notice to the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, that identifies an alternative voice service available at the residential consumers location.
(B)The telephone corporation shall be relieved of the obligations under paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) if an independent third-party reviewer that is approved by the executive director of the commission, or the executive directors designee, determines that there is an alternative voice service available to the residential consumer.
2878.7.(a)This article does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice services.
(b)As part of its Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, the commission shall determine a transition plan that shall be followed before a telephone corporation may amend its status as a carrier of last resort in areas not described in Section 2878.3 or not well served by alternative voice services as described in Section 2878.4. The commission may consider input from stakeholders during this process, including representatives of public safety agencies. The commission shall issue its final decision on or before January 1, 2027.
2878.8.The Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant fund is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, the moneys in the fund are hereby continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the commission for purposes of paragraph (6) of subdivision (b) of Section 2878.4. The fund may accept donations from nongovernmental entities
2878.9.(a)This article shall not apply to intrastate legacy time-division multiplexing services used to directly connect land mobile radio systems used for public safety.
(b)This article shall not apply to any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well served.
2878.1.(a)(1)A telephone corporation seeking to relinquish its carrier of last resort designation for an eligible area within its service territory shall submit to the commission a notice. The telephone corporations carrier of last resort designation for the eligible area shall be relinquished upon the submission of the notice.(2)A notice submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include both of the following:(A)A map of the eligible area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission or commission map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.(B)A copy of the modified tariff described in subdivision (b).(b)Notwithstanding any other law or commission decision, a telephone corporation, before submitting a notice pursuant to subdivision (a), shall modify its tariff for basic local exchange telephone service to align with its relinquishment of its carrier of last resort designation. The modified tariff shall be effective upon the submission of the notice pursuant to subdivision (a).(c)(1)The telephone corporation shall administer and pay for a customer challenge process available to a customer who informs the telephone corporation that no alternative voice service is available at their location.(2)The telephone corporation shall notify its customers of its customer challenge process.(3)If a customer successfully challenges the availability of alternative voice service at their location, the telephone corporation shall continue to provide basic local exchange telephone service to the customer for at least two years after the challenge process is complete.(d)This section does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice service.(e)As part of its Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, the commission shall establish a transition plan that a telephone corporation shall be required to follow before its carrier of last resort designation is relinquished for an area within its service territory other than an eligible area. The commission may consider input from stakeholders, including representatives of public safety agencies, during that portion of the rulemaking.SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 2878.4 of the Public Utilities Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to order to protect the confidential and proprietary information of an entity subject to Section 1 of this act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)All Californians deserve reliable, affordable, fast, and safe communications options, no matter who they are, where they live, or why they need to be connected.
(b)The transition to broadband networks is key to creating equity and positive impacts on California education, health care, public safety, workforce development, and the economy.
(c)Outdated state laws result in continued investments in aging technology that consumers are increasingly abandoning because it does not meet their needs.
(d)Californians are moving swiftly to abandon the old copper network because it does not provide the benefits of modern communication technologies, with more choosing to use wireless or internet-based services every year.
(e)California must develop a responsible and equitable transition plan that ensures all Californians have access to the connectivity they need.
(f)The transition should include a phased approach that over time ensures customers have access to communication services that are equally or more reliable and affordable, before transitioning away from the old legacy network.
(g)As part of the transition, no Californian will be left without reliable voice service in their homes, including the ability to contact 9-1-1 and to receive critical emergency alerts.
SEC. 2.Article 1.5 (commencing with Section 2878) is added to Chapter 10 of Part 2 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to read:1.5.Carriers of Last Resort2878.For purposes of this article, all of the following definitions apply:
(a)Alternative voice service means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
(1)Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
(2)Access to emergency 9-1-1 service.
(3)Compatibility with a backup power source.
(b)Area means census block.
(c)Available means the service provider provides coverage to at least 99 percent of the population of the area, according to the most recent federal census population estimates.
(d)Carrier of last resort has the same meaning as defined in Section 275.6.
(e)Eligible area means either of the following:
(1)An area that meets both of the following criteria:
(A)The United States Bureau of the Census reports no population in the area.
(B)The telephone corporation does not provide basic local exchange telephone service to a customer address in the area.
(2)An area that is well-served by alternative voice service.
(f)Notice means a written communication.
(g)Telephone corporation has the same meaning as defined in Section 234.
(h)Well-served means at least three different service providers, at least one of which is a wireline provider, offer alternative voice service to customers in the relevant area, and at least one of the alternative voice services offered by a service provider is reasonably comparable in price or value to the telephone corporations current nondiscounted rate for basic local exchange telephone service.
2878.1.(a)(1)A telephone corporation seeking to relinquish its carrier of last resort designation for an eligible area within its service territory shall submit to the commission a notice. The telephone corporations carrier of last resort designation for the eligible area shall be relinquished upon the submission of the notice.
(2)A notice submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include both of the following:
(A)A map of the eligible area covered by the notice, including the source and date for all data reflected in the map. The telephone corporation may use the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission or commission map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
(B)A copy of the modified tariff described in subdivision (b).
(b)Notwithstanding any other law or commission decision, a telephone corporation, before submitting a notice pursuant to subdivision (a), shall modify its tariff for basic local exchange telephone service to align with its relinquishment of its carrier of last resort designation. The modified tariff shall be effective upon the submission of the notice pursuant to subdivision (a).
(c)(1)The telephone corporation shall administer and pay for a customer challenge process available to a customer who informs the telephone corporation that no alternative voice service is available at their location.
(2)The telephone corporation shall notify its customers of its customer challenge process.
(3)If a customer successfully challenges the availability of alternative voice service at their location, the telephone corporation shall continue to provide basic local exchange telephone service to the customer for at least two years after the challenge process is complete.
(d)This section does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice service.
(e)As part of its Rulemaking 24-06-012 (June 20, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking Proceeding to Consider Changes to the Commissions Carrier of Last Resort Rules, the commission shall establish a transition plan that a telephone corporation shall be required to follow before its carrier of last resort designation is relinquished for an area within its service territory other than an eligible area. The commission may consider input from stakeholders, including representatives of public safety agencies, during that portion of the rulemaking.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to telecommunications.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to telecommunications.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2025 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 18, 2025 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jul 17, 2025 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jul 17, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 17, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 16, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (July 15). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 10, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on E., U & C. and JUD. |
| Jun 27, 2025 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 27, 2025 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 58. Noes 2. Page 2340.) |
| Jun 25, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 24, 2025 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 23). |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. (Ayes 54. Noes 11. Page 2223.) |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 2223.) |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Assembly Rule 96 suspended. (Page 2223.) |
| May 23, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (May 23). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| May 21, 2025 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1627.) |
| May 21, 2025 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 14, 2025 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 6, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 5, 2025 | Read second time and amended. |
| May 1, 2025 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (April 30). |
| Apr 23, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Apr 22, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on C. & C. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 18, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Mar 17, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on C. & C. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 17, 2025 | Referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Feb 7, 2025 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2025 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 18, 2025 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 15, 2025 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2025 | AB 470 McKinnor Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 23, 2025 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2025 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2025 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 101 Enterprises Foundation | ** Support | |
| AARP | ** Against | |
| African American Community Services Agency | ** Support | |
| Alameda County Latina Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Alliance for A Better Community | ** Against | |
| American, California Asian Pacific, California Hispanic, Carlsbad, Greater | ** Support | |
| American Indian Chamber Of Commerce Of California | ** Support | |
| Anaheim Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Angeles Area, Newport Beach, North Orange County, Oceanside, Orange | ** Support | |
| Apapa Solano County | ** Support | |
| Arts for LA | ** Against | |
| Asian Pacific American advocates | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific American Community Center | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific American Leadership Institute | ** Support | |
| Asian Pacific Islander American Vote | ** Support | |
| At&T | ** Support | |
| Bakersfield, Greater Los Angeles African American, Greater Riverside, Los | ** Support | |
| Barona Band Of Mission Indians | ** Support | |
| BEVERLY HILLS; CITY OF | ** Against | |
| Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians | ** Support | |
| Black Business Association | ** Support | |
| Black Chamber of Orange County | ** Support | |
| Black Education Expo | ** Support | |
| Boss - Business of Student Success | ** Support | |
| Boys and Girls Club of Central Orange Coast | ** Support | |
| Boys & Girls Club of Central Orange Coast | ** Support | |
| Boys & Girls Club of Kern County | ** Support | |
| Boys & Girls Clubs of Carson | ** Support | |
| Boys & Girls Clubs of Fresno County | ** Support | |
| Bridge the Digital Divide | ** Against | |
| Business Council San Joaquin County | ** Support | |
| Business of Student Success | ** Support | |
| BUTTE; COUNTY OF | ** Against | |
| CalAsian Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| CalBroadband | ** Against | |
| California African Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Alliance for Digital Equity | ** Against | |
| California Alliance For Retired Americans | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Chapter National Emergency Number Association | ** Against | |
| California Community Foundation | ** Against | |
| California Farm Bureau Federation | ** Against | |
| California Federation of Labor Unions, Afl-cio | ** Against | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Against | |
| California-Hawaii State Conference Of The Naacp | ** Support | |
| California Hispanic Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Indian Nations College | ** Support | |
| California LULAC | ** Support | |
| California Nations Indian Gaming Association | ** Support | |
| California Partnership To End Domestic Violence | ** Against | |
| California Public Policy Group | ** Against | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Against | |
| California Tennis Association for Underprivileged Youth | ** Support | |
| California Valley Miwok Tribe | ** Support | |
| California Valley Miwok Tribe Aka Sheep Ranch Rancheria | ** Support | |
| Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Carson Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| CDP Rural Caucus | ** Against | |
| Center for Accessible Technology | ** Against | |
| Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research | ** Against | |
| Chemehuevi Indian Tribe | ** Support | |
| City of Agoura Hills | ** Against | |
| City of Hidden Hills | ** Against | |
| Coalition for Responsible Community Development | ** Support | |
| Communication Workers of America, District 9 | ** Against | |
| Communities in Schools of Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| Community Coalition of The Antelope Valley | ** Against | |
| Community Tech Network | ** Support | |
| concerned black men of los angeles | ** Support | |
| Concerned Citizens Community Involvement | ** Support | |
| Consejo de Federaciones Mexicanas | ** Against | |
| Councilmember Courtney Walsh, City of Emeryville | ** Support | |
| County Black, Orange County Hispanic, Palos Verdes Peninsula, San Diego | ** Support | |
| County Hispanic, Santa Ana, Santa Clarita Valley, Torrance Area, Tulare Kings | ** Support | |
| County Of Alameda | ** Against | |
| County of Butte | ** Against | |
| County of Fresno | ** Against | |
| County of Humboldt | ** Against | |
| County of Imperial | ** Against | |
| County of Inyo | ** Against | |
| County Of Kern | ** Against | |
| County of Marin | ** Against | |
| County of Mendocino | ** Against | |
| County of Monterey | ** Against | |
| County of Napa | ** Against | |
| County of Nevada | ** Against | |
| County of San Joaquin | ** Against | |
| County of Santa Clara | ** Against | |
| County of Santa Cruz | ** Against | |
| County of Shasta | ** Against | |
| County of Siskiyou | ** Against | |
| County of Solano | ** Against | |
| County of Sonoma | ** Against | |
| County of Yolo | ** Against | |
| County of Yuba | ** Against | |
| Curry Senior Center | ** Support | |
| Destination Crenshaw | ** Against | |
| Digital Equity LA | ** Against | |
| digitalLift | ** Support | |
| Digital LIFT | ** Support | |
| Diversity in Leadership Institute | ** Against | |
| East Bay Leadership Council | ** Support | |
| El Camino Community College District | ** Support | |
| Electronic Frontier Foundation | ** Against | |
| El Segundo Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Empowerment | ** Support | |
| Empowerment Dess Perkins Foundation | ** Support | |
| Enterprise Rancheria | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| EveryoneOn | ** Against | |
| Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians | ** Support | |
| EXP – the Opportunity Engine | ** Support | |
| Families In Schools | ** Against | |
| Fiber-up My Neighborhood | ** Against | |
| Filipino American Chamber of Commerce of Solano County, INC. | ** Support | |
| Fresno Coalition for Digital Inclusion | ** Against | |
| Fresno County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| GPSN | ** Against | |
| Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Hack the Hood | ** Against | |
| Haven Neighborhood Services | ** Support | |
| Healing and Justice Center | ** Against | |
| Hispanic, and Ventura | ** Support | |
| Hopland Band Of Pomo Indians | ** Support | |
| Iipay Nation Of Santa Ysabel | ** Support | |
| Innovate Public Schools | ** Against | |
| Institute for Local Self-Reliance | ** Against | |
| Insure the Uninsured Project | ** Against | |
| Jamul Indian Village of California | ** Support | |
| Janet Goeske Foundation | ** Support | |
| Japanese American Citizen's League | ** Support | |
| Jawhara Mcclinton | ** Against | |
| Kapor Center | ** Against | |
| Kern Economic Development Foundation | ** Support | |
| KidSTREAM Children's Museum | ** Support | |
| Kings County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| La Jolla Band of Luiseno Indians | ** Support | |
| las virgenes-malibu council of governments | ** Against | |
| Latino Education and Advocacy Days | ** Support | |
| latino equality alliance | ** Against | |
| League of California Cities-Los Angeles County | ** Against | |
| lime foundation | ** Support | |
| Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Los Altos Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Mission | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Unified School District | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Urban League | ** Against | |
| Luisa Calumpong, Broadband Manager, City of Oakland | ** Against | |
| MAAC Project | ** Support | |
| MAC CONSTRUCTION | ** Support | |
| Media Alliance | ** Against | |
| mesa grande band of mission indians | ** Support | |
| Metro Area Advisory Committee Project | ** Support | |
| Mission Bit | ** Support | |
| Mono County Bos | ** Against | |
| Monterey County Hospitality Association | ** Support | |
| Morongo Band Of Mission Indians | ** Support | |
| Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises Inc. | ** Support | |
| Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| NextGen California | ** Against | |
| North Orange County Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| #OaklandUndivided | ** Against | |
| OCA - Asian Pacific American Advocates | ** Support | |
| Oceanside Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| ONEgeneration | ** Support | |
| Orange County Business Council | ** Support | |
| Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Orange County Labor Federation, AFL-CIO | ** Against | |
| Our Voice: Communities for Quality Education | ** Against | |
| Pacoima Beautiful | ** Against | |
| Pala Band Of Mission Indians | ** Support | |
| Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Para Los Ninos | ** Against | |
| Parent Engagement Academy | ** Against | |
| Parent Institute for Quality Education | ** Against | |
| Pauma Band of Luiseno Indians | ** Support | |
| Pinoleville Pomo Nation | ** Support | |
| Porterville Sheltered Workshop | ** Support | |
| Public Advocates Office | ** Against | |
| Puente Learning Center | ** Against | |
| Rancho Cienega Tennis Shop | ** Support | |
| Reality Changers | ** Support | |
| Redding Rancheria | ** Support | |
| Rincon Band of Luiseo Indians | ** Support | |
| RISE San Diego | ** Support | |
| Robinson Rancheria Pomo Indians of California | ** Support | |
| Rural Bonny Doon Association | ** Against | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Against | |
| Salef | ** Support | |
| Salvadoran American Leadership & Education Fund | ** Support | |
| san diego county hispanic chamber of commerce | ** Support | |
| San Diego North Economic Development Council | ** Support | |
| San Diego Regional Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Gabriel Valley Conservation and Service Corps | ** Support | |
| San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership | ** Support | |
| San Manuel Band Of Mission Indians | ** Support | |
| San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians | ** Support | |
| Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Sheriff John Zanoni, Fresno County | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Leadership Group | ** Support | |
| Small Business Diversity Network | ** Support | |
| Soboba Band Of Luiseno Indians | ** Support | |
| South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Southeast Community Development Corporation | ** Against | |
| Supervisor Doug Verboon, Kings County | ** Support | |
| Supervisor Joel Anderson, San Diego County | ** Support | |
| Supervisor Jose Medina, Riverside County | ** Support | |
| Supervisor Rich Desmond, Sacramento County District 3 | ** Support | |
| Tejon Indian Tribe | ** Support | |
| The Arc Of California | ** Support | |
| The Fresno Center | ** Support | |
| The Utility Reform Network | ** Against | |
| Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Town of Hillsborough | ** Against | |
| Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations | ** Support | |
| Trio Plus | ** Against | |
| tulare kings hispanic chamber of commerce | ** Support | |
| United Parents and Schools | ** Against | |
| United Parents and Students | ** Against | |
| UNITED STATES TELECOM ASSOCIATION DBA USTELECOM - THE BROADBAND ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| united way bay area | ** Support | |
| Unite-LA | ** Against | |
| Urban Counties of California | ** Against | |
| Ventura Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Vermont Slauson Economic Development Corporation | ** Support | |
| Vision y Compromiso | ** Against | |
| Walking Shield | ** Support | |
| Weave Inc. | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular Session
AB 470 (McKinnor) - Telephone corporations: carriers of last resort
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), in coordination with the Office of Emergency Services (OES), to adopt a process for telephone corporations to petition the CPUC to amend their status as a carrier of last resort (COLR) in designated areas by December 15, 2026, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The CPUC estimates ongoing costs of $5.5 million annually (ratepayer funds) and 13 permanent positions to adopt the specified process and revise its existing service maps.
- Unknown but likely significant costs in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars annually (General Fund) for the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to coordinate with the CPUC, as specified.
Background:
A Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) is a telecommunications company that is required to provide service to any customer in a service area that requests it, even if serving that customer would not be economically viable at prevailing rates. Traditionally, telephone companies have satisfied their COLR obligations by providing basic telephone service through copper network wirelines, which are beneficial to customers in rural locations where alternative communication means through fiber-optic broadband internet, voice over internet protocol (VoIP), and reliable wireless cellar service is scarce. Telecommunication companies have noted that it is expensive to maintain cooper wire lines. Customers who reside in rural areas where there is no other provider of reliable, affordable telephone service are most at risk of experiencing service abandonment if COLR requirements are not enforced.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Define “Alternative voice basic service” means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
- Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
- Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
- Compatibility with a backup power source.
- A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
- Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to §2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
- Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
- Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
- Define an area of the state “well-served” by telecommunications service as an area where at least three different facilities-based service providers (not including the basic exchange copper telephone corporation acting as the COLR) offer alternative voice basic service in compliance with CPUC rules regarding emergency plans and backup power requirements. At least one of these providers must be a wireline provider. At least two providers must offer alternative voice basic service at prices comparable to tariffed basic service, as confirmed by the commission, and at least one provider must be a participant in the Lifeline telephone program. A well-served area must have alternative voice basic service at all the serviceable locations in the area, based on the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
- Authorizes a telephone corporation to submit an application to the CPUC to change its COLR status and requires the CPUC to approve the application if the applicant complies with this bill and other conditions that the CPUC may impose that are consistent with this bill.
- Requires the CPUC to adopt a map designating well-served areas of the state by December 15, 2026. This bill requires the CPUC to include data from existing maps used for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program or the FCC’s National Broadband Map.
- Requires a telephone corporation to demonstrate compliance with service quality rules for at least 12 months prior to submitting a request to amend its COLR status.
- Requires the CPUC to work with the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to adopt a process by December 15, 2026, enabling a telephone corporation to use a Tier 2 advice letter to change its COLR status for portions of the state where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any address located within the area. This bill specifies the components that must be included this process, including, but not limited to a 90-day period in which households in an area can submit challenges to the application.
- Require the CPUC to work with the OES to adopt a process by December 15, 2026, enabling a telephone corporation to use a Tier 2 advice letter to change its COLR status for portions of the state that are well-served based on maps adopted by the CPUC. This bill specifies the components that must be included this process, including, but not limited to a 180-day period in which households in an area can submit challenges to the application.
- Require a telephone corporation that has changed its COLR status pursuant to this bill to do all the following:
- Demonstrate within six years that it has built out fiber optic facilities to at least three times the number of households in the state as the number of basic telephone customers served by the telephone corporation at the time its COLR status changed. Half of the buildout must occur in areas of the state that are not well-served, as specified.
- Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation COLR relief if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
- To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains COLR relief.
- To the extent technically feasible, offer a discounted broadband plan in each area where the corporation has received COLR relief. This plan must be offered to eligible consumers for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400% of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a specified qualifying public assistance program.
- Provide specified assistance for alarm system migration, public safety technology upgrade grants, public outreach assistance, labor and workforce development, and digital literacy support for 24 months after obtaining COLR relief.
- Conduct workshops in legislative districts as specified, including at the request of an Assembly Member or Senator.
- Establish a fund in the State Treasury to finance public safety technology upgrade grants provided after a telephone corporation obtains COLR relief.
- Authorize the CPUC to assess penalties if a telephone corporation granted COLR relief violates any conditions of its relief specified in this bill. This bill stipulates that these penalties may include a civil money penalty up to $50,000 for each violation.
- Specify that for a 10-year period after a telephone corporation is granted COLR relief, the telephone corporation must provide alternative basic service to a household that is unable to obtain this service from any other provider in the area. The household must submit a specified notice regarding the absence of alternative basic service and the CPUC must determine if no alternative provider exists within 30 days. This obligation may be terminated if the telephone corporation can demonstrate that alternative basic service is available at the residential customer’s location.
- Exempt the following from the bill’s requirements:
- Certain islands off the California coast that contain at least one area that is well-served.
- Specified legacy telecommunication systems used for public safety from the bill’s requirements.
- Specify that once the CPUC relieves a telephone corporation from its COLR obligations, the CPUC cannot establish a new COLR for the area in which COLR relief is granted.
- Clarify that nothing in this bill affects the CPUC’s authority over other voice services or COLR obligations in areas of the state where a telephone corporation cannot change its COLR status.
Related Legislation:
AB 2797 (McKinnor) of 2024, contained certain provisions substantially similar to this bill. The bill would have required the CPUC to relieve a telephone corporation of its COLR duties if certain criteria existed. The bill died in the Senate.
AB 1366 (Daly) of 2019, expanded the authority of the OES to regulate provision of next generation 9-1-1 services. A prior version of the bill heard by this committee would have extended laws prohibiting state and local governments from regulating VoIP services and other internet-based communications. The bill died in the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
AB 2395 (Low) of 2016, would have established a process by which a telecommunications provider could cease offering traditional telephone services. The bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
This bill would require the CPUC, in coordination with OES, to adopt a process for telephone corporations to petition the CPUC to amend their status as a COLR in designated areas by December 15, 2026, as specified. In March 2023, a telephone company petitioned the CPUC to withdraw from its COLR obligations. The CPUC denied the request on June 20, 2024, and initiated a rulemaking proceeding to revise its COLR rules. The CPUC anticipates issuing a decision in 2026, and the provisions of this measure conflict with the CPUC’s ongoing rulemaking.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Josh Becker, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 7/15/2025
Author: | |||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill establishes a process that requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to allow a telephone corporation to relinquish its status as a “carrier of last resort” (COLR). This bill also establishes certain requirements for a COLR seeking to relinquish its obligation to provide telephone service and requires the CPUC to cease imposing certain rate and regulatory requirements on a telephone corporation that relinquishes its COLR designation.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes the CPUC to supervise and regulate every public utility in the state and permits the CPUC to do anything that is necessary and convenient to exercise its power and jurisdiction. (Public Utilities Code §701)
- Makes various statements about California’s telecommunications policy, including supporting the continuance of the state’s commitment to universal service by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications to all Californians. (Public Utilities Code §709)
- Defines a “carrier of last resort” as a telephone corporation that is required to fulfill all reasonable requests for service within its service territory. (Public Utilities Code §275.6)
- Establishes the California High Cost funds (CHCF-A and CHCF-B) to provide subsidies to COLRs in high-cost areas of the state to ensure residents’ access to basic telephone services. (Public Utilities Code §§276 and 276.5)
- Requires the CPUC, when administering CHCF-A subsidies and setting telephone rates, to ensure that rates charged to customers of small independent telephone corporations are just and reasonable and are reasonably comparable to rates charged to customers of urban telephone corporations. (Public Utilities Code §276.5)
This bill:
- Defines “Alternative voice basic service” means a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following:
- Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
- Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
- Compatibility with a backup power source.
- A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
- Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to §2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
- Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
- Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
- Defines an area of the state “well-served” by telecommunications service as an area where at least three different facilities-based service providers (not including the basic exchange copper telephone corporation acting as the COLR) offer alternative voice basic service in compliance with CPUC rules regarding emergency plans and backup power requirements. At least one of these providers must be a wireline provider. At least one provider must offer a comparatively priced alternative basic voice service, and at least one provider must be a participant in the Lifeline telephone program. A well-served area must have alternative voice basic service at all the serviceable locations in the area, based on the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
- Authorizes a telephone corporation to submit an application to the CPUC to change its COLR status and requires the CPUC to approve the application if the applicant complies with this bill and other conditions that the CPUC may impose that are consistent with this bill.
- Requires the CPUC to adopt a map designating well-served areas of the state by December 15, 2026. This bill requires the CPUC to include data from existing maps used for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program or the FCC’s National Broadband Map.
- Requires a telephone corporation to demonstrate compliance with service quality rules for at least 12 months prior to submitting a request to amend its COLR status.
- Requires the CPUC to work with the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to adopt a process by December 15, 2026, enabling a telephone corporation to use a Tier 2 advice letter to change its COLR status for portions of the state where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any address located within the area. This bill specifies the components that must be included this process, including, but not limited to a 90-day period in which households in an area can submit challenges to the application.
- Requires the CPUC to work with the OES to adopt a process by December 15, 2026, enabling a telephone corporation to use a Tier 2 advice letter to change its COLR status for portions of the state that are well-served based on maps adopted by the CPUC. This bill specifies the components that must be included this process, including, but not limited to a 180-day period in which households in an area can submit challenges to the application.
- Requires a telephone corporation that has changed its COLR status pursuant to this bill to do all the following:
- Demonstrate within six years that it has built out fiber optic facilities to at least three times the number of households in the state as the number of basic telephone customers served by the telephone corporation at the time its COLR status changed. Half of the buildout must occur in areas of the state that are not well-served, as specified.
- Provide continuing service to a customer who subscribes to basic exchange service for at least 12 months from the date the telephone corporation COLR relief if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
- To the extent technically feasible, offer an existing residential customer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains COLR relief.
- To the extent technically feasible, offer a discounted broadband plan in each area where the corporation has received COLR relief. This plan must be offered to eligible consumers for at least 24 months from the date the telephone corporation obtains amended status. To qualify, a household shall have an income that is at or below 400% of the federal poverty guidelines or at least one member of the household shall participate in a specified qualifying public assistance program.
- Provide specified assistance for alarm system migration, public safety technology upgrade grants, public outreach assistance, labor and workforce development, and digital literacy support for 24 months after obtaining COLR relief.
- Conduct workshops in legislative districts as specified, including at the request of an Assembly Member or Senator.
- Establishes a fund in the State Treasury to finance public safety technology upgrade grants provided after a telephone corporation obtains COLR relief.
- Authorizes the CPUC to assess penalties if a telephone corporation granted COLR relief violates any conditions of its relief specified in this bill. This bill stipulates that these penalties may include a civil money penalty up to $50,000 for each violation.
- Specifies that for a 10-year period after a telephone corporation is granted COLR relief, the telephone corporation must provide alternative basic service to a household that is unable to obtain this service from any other provider in the area. The household must submit a specified notice regarding the absence of alternative basic service and the CPUC must determine if no alternative provider exists within 30 days. This obligation may be terminated if the telephone corporation can demonstrate that alternative basic service is available at the residential customer’s location.
- Exempts the following from the bill’s requirements:
- Certain islands off the California coast that contain at least one area that is well-served.
- Specified legacy telecommunication systems used for public safety from the bill’s requirements.
- Specifies that once the CPUC relieves a telephone corporation from its COLR obligations, the CPUC cannot establish a new COLR for the area in which COLR relief is granted.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill affects the CPUC’s authority over other voice services or COLR obligations in areas of the state where a telephone corporation cannot change its COLR status.
Background
COLR is the obligation to provide service. Provider of last resort obligations are considered cornerstones of utility regulation. The principle that an entity must be designated to guarantee service stems from the “common carrier” precedent established in Munn v. Illinois (1876). In this case, the United States Supreme Court determined that certain industries affect the common good and are subject to regulation by the state to ensure that the interests of the public are protected. Common carriers must serve all customers who request service. This bill establishes a process by which telecommunications companies can terminate their COLR status, which ends the requirement that the company provide service to all customers within their jurisdiction upon request.
COLR = POLR. Consistent with federal common carrier laws, California’s electric and telecommunications sectors have requirements to ensure that an entity exists to provide customers with service in the event that newer competitors are unable or unwilling to do so. In the regulated electric utility sector, the state’s investor-owned utilities (IOUs) serve as providers of last resort (POLRs). In the telecommunications sector, those incumbent telecommunications companies that grew from the monopoly telephone system were designated as COLR. The establishment of POLRs and COLRs were necessary to ensure that consumers retained access to services while electric utility and telecommunications competition increased. In both the electric and telecommunications sectors, the providers of last resort are legacy facilities-based incumbent utilities.
Unlike POLR, California’s COLR requirements are established entirely in CPUC regulation. In 1996, the CPUC adopted a decision (D. 96-10-066), requiring incumbent local exchange carriers to serve as COLRs in their service territories until other carriers could be designated as COLRs. The CPUC established COLR obligations to ensure that consumers always have a POLR to supply basic telephone service as deregulation in the telecommunications sector accelerated. In both the electric and telecommunications sectors, bankruptcies have led to the dissolution of competitive providers. In these circumstances, the state has relied on POLRs and COLRs to provide electric and telephone service to those customers whose providers ceased operation.
In 2012, the CPUC updated its basic telephone service requirements. This update clarified the process by which a carrier can withdraw from COLR obligations. Under the CPUC’s rules, if a COLR is the only carrier remaining in a designated geographic area, it must file an application at the CPUC to withdraw as a COLR, and it must continue to act as the COLR until the application is approved or a new COLR is designated.
Historically, providers of last resort exist as a safeguard to ensure consumers’ access to essential utility services while facilitating competitions between existing incumbent providers and new competitive entrants to the market. Since the expansion of internet and wireless communications, traditional telephone corporations have faced significant challenges maintaining legacy networks while customers migrate to new, unregulated services. Two companies, AT&T and Frontier, serve as COLRs for 99% of the state, with AT&T serving as the COLR for the vast majority of the state.
Maintaining COLR and expanding broadband are not necessarily mutually exclusive. The CPUC’s COLR requirements are technology neutral; a COLR can provide basic telephone service through wireline telephone service or other technologies, including Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP). Whatever service a COLR uses to meet its basic service requirements becomes subject to certain CPUC regulations to ensure the reliability and affordability of basic telephone service. A COLR may provide other, unregulated telecommunications services in addition to their basic service offering. Historically, COLRs have used their legacy copper telephone network to meet COLR obligations. During the period in which VoIP overtook legacy telephone service as the dominant home and business telephone service, California statute limited the CPUC’s ability to set requirements on internet-enabled communications. In 2020, that statute sunset, providing the CPUC with greater authority to regulate internet-based communications to the degree that federal law permits such actions.
Bill follows CPUC’s denial of AT&T’s application to terminate COLR obligations. In March 2023, AT&T submitted an application (A.23-03-003) to the CPUC to obtain relief for its COLR obligations. Multiple parties, including a variety of counties and cities, submitted comments opposing the application. On June 20, 2024, the CPUC rejected AT&T’s application for COLR relief with prejudice. This ruling prohibits AT&T from filing another COLR relief application until at least one year after the CPUC has issued a decision in a proceeding the CPUC intends to open to modify COLR rules. On June 20, 2024, the CPUC simultaneously opened a rulemaking (R. 24-06-012) to consider change to update COLR rules. The CPUC expects to render a decision in this proceeding in early 2026. This bill follows the CPUC’s rejection of AT&T’s application by establishing a framework by which AT&T can relinquish its COLR obligations outside the CPUC’s application process. As a result, this bill may conflict with the CPUC’s ongoing rulemaking to update COLR rules and require the CPUC to re-scope this proceeding.
Ending COLR obligations may have far-reaching consequences, necessitating additional statutory and regulatory changes. While this bill follows the rejection of AT&T’s application at the CPUC, this bill applies more broadly to all COLRs and may establish a process by which the obligation to provide basic telephone service could cease to exist as a regulatory concept in California. Many aspects of the state’s universal service programs are intertwined with COLR obligations. For example, the administration of the state’s High Cost Funds are directly linked to those companies’ COLR designation. The High Cost Funds help subsidize the rate of basic telephone service in areas of the state where the cost to provide this service is uniquely expensive, which tend to be rural regions of the state with challenging terrain and limited economies of scale. The High Cost Fund – B (CHCF-B) program provides subsidies to large telephone corporations that serve these areas. The High Cost Fund – A (CHCF-A) program provides subsidies to the small independent telephone corporations that are largely fully rate-regulated. Existing law requires the CPUC to administer the CHCF-A program in a manner that ensures that rates for the small independent telephone corporations are consistent with rates for regulated telephone service in urban areas. To the extent that this bill enables the deregulation of urban telephone rates through de-tariffing and shifts towards unregulated services, this bill may limit the extent to which the CPUC can use urban rates as a benchmark for ensuring rate fairness between urban and rural telephone customers. It may be necessary to adopt additional legislation to address the extent to which de-tariffing of large portions of the state would impact other telecommunications policies, including the High Cost Funds.
Some of this bill’s safeguards may not sufficiently protect access to services. This bill establishes a process by which the CPUC must relieve a telephone corporation of its obligation to serve customers pursuant to COLR. While some areas may have multiple providers and could meet this bill’s definition of “well-served,” only COLRs are obligated to actually provide telephone service upon request by a consumer. All other providers may offer services in the area without actually guaranteeing service to each household in that area. As a result, households in well-served areas may face difficulty compelling any providers to serve specific addresses. This bill establishes a process by which a former COLR must provide phone service to a household that cannot obtain service from any other provider during a 10-year period after the company has been relieved of its COLR duties. However, the process established by this bill requires a customer to submit a specified request to the CPUC and provides the CPUC up to 30 days to make a determination about whether the former COLR is obligated to provide phone service. This bill does not identify a timeline by which the former COLR must actually provide the service to an unserved household. It is not clear that waiting in excess of 30 days for a remedy would sufficiently safeguard against public safety risks posed to a household that lacks any telephone service.
Bill would also release a telephone corporation from other obligations if it abandons COLR. In the event that the CPUC provides COLR relief to a telephone corporation under this bill, this bill also requires the CPUC to release the COLR from other obligations. These obligations are not currently defined in this bill; however, they may include certain tariffs for basic telephone services, other tariffs associated with certain requirements for meeting specific service obligations, and other regulatory requirements that apply to telephone services. If a telephone corporation is relieved of COLR duties, a certain amount of de-tariffing is likely necessary; however, certain tariffs on telecommunications services are necessary – regardless of COLR status. For example, 9-1-1 services, including Next Generation 9-1-1 (NG 911) are tariffed to ensure the reliability and accessibility of the 9-1-1 system.
Potential impacts to affordability. Once a company is no longer required to serve as a COLR, this bill would allow that company to de-tariff its services in the area where it has obtained COLR relief. Tariffs are a regulatory mechanism that enables the CPUC to oversee, and in the case of utility services like telephone service, regulate the cost, terms, and conditions of providing service. While this bill stipulates that a COLR may seek relief from its COLR duties in a well-served area where at least 1 of 3 alternative voice providers in the area offers voice service at comparable prices to the former COLR’s rates, it is not clear that the CPUC would have a mechanism to ensure that such a provider exists. Additionally, if the sole affordable voice alternative ceases operation in the area, a community may be left with no affordable telephone services. The majority of alternative voice providers will likely be internet-based and wireless telephone providers. These providers do not have any rate oversight for their services and do not file tariffs with the CPUC for their basic telephone offerings. Since the CPUC does not have rate control over alternative voice providers, nothing limits these providers from raising their rates after a telephone corporation relinquishes its COLR duties.
De-tariffing telephone services may not inherently raise rates; however, it will remove oversight and controls for telephone rates and the terms and conditions on which telephone services are offered. While this bill sets up a framework in which COLR relief may only be granted in areas that are well-served by alternative providers, providers that are not COLRs can generally choose the conditions under which they will offer service. If an internet service provider (ISP) offers VoIP as part of a bundled service, the ISP may require a household to subscribe to its internet service as a condition of obtaining telephone service. Paying for a bundled plan would substantially increase the cost of obtaining telephone service that may otherwise be offered as a standalone product. While this bill requires at least one of the three providers in a well-served area to be a Lifeline provider, it is likely that wireless providers will be the only Lifeline option in the vast majority of areas. For households that rely on Lifeline wireline service, no other providers may exist. To the extent that removing COLR obligations reduces the availability of basic telephone service in areas of the state, the lower amount of competition and lack of tariffed benchmarks for telephone service may also encourage providers to raise rates for any voice services.
Bill requires the CPUC to use certain existing maps pertaining to broadband to map access to telephone service. Several portions of this bill require the CPUC to use data from existing FCC and state maps pertaining to broadband infrastructure access. While these maps may be beneficial for identifying addresses where broadband infrastructure is accessible to an address, these maps may not provide a sufficient picture of whether telephone service can be provided to a specific address in a manner that meets all the obligations in this bill. For example, this bill partly defines a well-served area as an area where all the broadband serviceable locations (BSLs) in the area have voice service based on broadband maps by the FCC that identify BSLs. However, the FCC’s definition of a BSL is not the same as an address. Since these maps are intended to identify the extent to which broadband infrastructure is sufficiently accessible to a building to support the installation of broadband, the map does not count each address as a separate serviceable location. For apartment complexes, a building comprised of many apartments may be a serviceable location, but individual units within the complex are not counted as separate service locations. The FCC’s website notes: “Individual units within an apartment or condo building are not considered BSLs, but each building in an apartment or condo complex is typically counted as a single BSL.” Additionally, designation as a BSL does not mean that services already exist at that location. Instead, a BSL is a location where services already exist or can be installed within 10 business days. The gap between the BSLs in the FCC maps and the lack of service at specific addresses has led to a number of disputes about the accuracy of these maps. The CPUC vetted a number of challenges to broadband maps as part of its efforts to ensure that BEAD and FCC maps included the most accurate information about unserved California households; however, not all challenges may have been addressed and neither the BEAD or FCC broadband maps address the extent to which voice service is sufficiently reliable at a specific address. BEAD maps are also established a specific point-in-time for the BEAD program, and may be several years old by the time a telephone corporation submits a successful application for COLR relief under this bill.
Need for amendments. As currently written, this bill may not provide sufficient protections for households that use Lifeline for wireline service. While this bill creates a broadband buildout obligation for a company relieved of COLR duties, it does not set a speed standard for that internet buildout. This bill also requires the CPUC to relieve a company of other obligations once its COLR status has changed without clarifying which obligations or tariffs should be relieved. This bill also requires the CPUC to use certain maps that may not have sufficient data to fully reflect service needs that influence the ability to provide COLR relief under this bill. While this bill requires the CPUC to approve a COLR application that meets certain criteria, it does not clarify whether the CPUC can amend a COLR application to reflect any verified challenges or limitations that occur as part of the review process. This bill also prohibits the CPUC from designating a new COLR for an area while also authorizing the CPUC to exercise regulatory authority over alternative voice basic service, potentially raising the possibility that alternative voice basic service obligations could replace COLR obligations. This bill requires a telephone corporation granted COLR relief to offer certain labor and workforce development support in response to the termination of COLR; however, if the termination of COLR services also contributes to greater migration to digital services, additional support for workers may be needed. To the extent that the author and committee wish to establish a process by which company will be relieved of its COLR duties as laid out in this bill, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to do the following:
- Exempt households enrolled in Lifeline from the locations where a telephone corporation may be relieved of its COLR duties.
- Clarify that the only additional obligations relieved at the time that COLR relief is granted are solely those tariffs pertaining to COLR telephone service.
- Clarify that nothing in this bill modifies other duties and obligations established separately from COLR, including a corporation’s eligible telecommunications carrier status.
- Allow the CPUC to use additional data sources for the purpose of creating maps pursuant to this bill and identifying areas that are well-served.
- Clarify that the CPUC can amend and approve a COLR application based on the Tier 2 advice letter process established in the bill.
- Prohibit de-tariffing of 9-1-1 or NG 9-1-1 services.
- Establish additional guarantees of labor obligation for the workforce of a telephone corporation that obtains COLR relief.
- Clarify that the termination of COLR in an area does not enable the CPUC to designate an alternative voice basic service provider as the COLR.
- Technical and conforming changes.
This bill specifies that a well-served area is one in which at least 1 of 3 alternative voice providers offers voice service at prices comparable to COLR service. However, this bill does not specify a mechanism for the CPUC to verify that these conditions exist and no mechanism exists to ensure that affordable offers continue to exist if the lone affordable alternative ceases to offer voice service in an area where COLR relief is granted. To the extent that the author and committee wish to also ensure that the CPUC can verify that alternative voice offerings are comparably priced to the tariffed COLR offering and prevent the removal of COLR from areas where there are an insufficient number of affordable alternatives, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to clarify that a well-served area must be a location in which at least 2 providers offer alternative voice basic service at prices comparable to tariffed basic service, as confirmed by CPUC.
Dual Referral. Should this bill be approved by this committee, it will be re-referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 2797 (McKinnor) of 2024, contained certain provisions substantially similar to this bill. The bill would have required the CPUC to relieve a telephone corporation of its COLR duties if certain criteria existed. The bill died in the Senate.
AB 1366 (Daly) of 2019, expanded the authority of the OES to regulate provision of next generation 9-1-1 services. A prior version of the bill heard by this committee would have extended laws prohibiting state and local governments from regulating VoIP services and other internet-based communications. The bill died in the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
AB 2395 (Low) of 2016, would have established a process by which a telecommunications provider could cease offering traditional telephone services. The bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
Mayor James T. Butts, City of Inglewood
Mayor Scott Donaldson, City of Del Rey Oaks
Mayor Dennis Donohue, City of Salinas
Mayor Matt Mahan, City of San Jose
Mayor Kevin McCarty, City of Sacramento
Mayor Ian N. Oglesby, City of Seaside
Supervisor Joel Anderson, San Diego County
Supervisor Rich Desmond, Sacramento County District 3
Supervisor Jose Medina, Riverside County
Supervisor Doug Verboon, Kings County
Councilmember Courtney Walsh, City of Emeryville
Sheriff John Zanoni, Fresno County
101 Enterprises Foundation
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Vote
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians
Black Business Association
Black Education Expo
Boys & Girls Club of Central Orange Coast
Boys & Girls Club of Kern County
Boys & Girls Clubs of Carson
Boys & Girls Clubs of Fresno County
Business Council San Joaquin County
Business of Student Success
California LULAC
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
California Tennis Association for Underprivileged Youth
California Valley Miwok Tribe
California-Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
Chamber of Commerce: Alameda County Latina, California, California African
American, California Asian Pacific, California Hispanic, Carlsbad, Greater
Bakersfield, Greater Los Angeles African American, Greater Riverside, Los
Angeles Area, Newport Beach, North Orange County, Oceanside, Orange
County Black, Orange County Hispanic, Palos Verdes Peninsula, San Diego
County Hispanic, Santa Ana, Santa Clarita Valley, Torrance Area, Tulare Kings
Hispanic, and Ventura
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Digital LIFT
East Bay Leadership Council
EMAC Construction
Empowerment Dess Perkins Foundation
Enterprise Rancheria
Equality California
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
EXP – the Opportunity Engine
Hopland Band of Pomo Indians
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Jamul Indian Village of California
Janet Goeske Foundation
Japanese American Citizens League
Kern Economic Development Foundation
kidSTREAM Children's Museum
La Jolla Band of Luiseño Indians
Latino Education and Advocacy Days
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Los Angeles Mission
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Metro Area Advisory Committee Project
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Morongo Band of Mission Indians
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises Inc.
OCA- Asian Pacific American Advocates
ONEgeneration
Orange County Business Council
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Pauma Band of Luiseño Indians
Pinoleville Pomo Nation
Porterville Sheltered Workshop
Rancho Cienega Tennis Shop
Reality Changers
Redding Rancheria
Rincon Band of Luiseño Indians
RISE San Diego
Robinson Rancheria Pomo Indians of California
Salvadoran American Leadership & Educational Fund
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Gabriel Valley Conservation and Service Corps
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Small Business Diversity Network
Soboba Band of Luiseño Indians
Tejon Indian Tribe
The Arc of California
The Fresno Center
United Way Bay Area
Vermont-Slauson Economic Development Corporation
Weave Inc.
OPPOSITION:
#OaklandUndivided
AARP
Alliance for a Better Community
Arts for LA
Bridge the Digital Divide
California Alliance for Digital Equity
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Chapter National Emergency Number Association
California Community Foundation
California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO
California Federation of Teachers
Center for Accessible Technology
Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research
Communication Workers of America, District 9
Communities in Schools of Los Angeles
Community Coalition of the Antelope Valley
Consejo De Federaciones Mexicanas
County of Humboldt
County of Kern
County of Marin, unless amended
County of San Joaquin
County of Shasta
Destination Crenshaw
Digital Equity LA
Diversity in Leadership Institute
Electronic Frontier Foundation
EveryoneOn
Families in Schools
Fiber-Up My Neighborhood
Fresno Coalition for Digital Inclusion
GPSN
Hack the Hood
Healing and Justice Center
Innovate Public Schools
Institute for Local Self-reliance
Insure the Uninsured Project
Kapor Center
Las Virgenes-Malibu Council of Governments
Latino Equality Alliance
League of California Cities-Los Angeles County
Los Angeles Unified School District
Los Angeles Urban League
Media Alliance
NextGen California
Our Voice: Communities for Quality Education
Pacoima Beautiful
Para Los Ninos
Parent Engagement Academy
Parent Institute for Quality Education
Public Advocates Office, unless amended
PUENTE Learning Center
Southeast Community Development Corporation
The Utility Reform Network
TRiO Plus
UNITE-LA
United Parents and Students
Vision y Compromiso
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VOIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents argue that the elimination of COLR could leave households without reliable telecommunications service and result in higher consumer costs without a mechanism to remedy service gaps. In opposition, a coalition of labor organizations, including the California Federation of Labor Unions, Communications Workers of America, California Federation of Teachers, and California Alliance for Retired Americans states:
AB 470 would allow carriers to shed their COLR obligations but not mandate any other carrier in the territory to assume that obligation. It would leave the duty to provide universal access to safe, reliable, and affordable service to the market. This would put current and future customers at risk of losing service and grant companies the ability to decide what communities to serve and which to ignore. It would also put union jobs across the state at risk, accelerating a loss of good jobs in the industry. For phone and broadband service to be available to all who ask for it, the COLR rule must be maintained and enforced.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 470
Author:(McKinnor)
As Amended Ver:June 19, 2025
Majority vote
SUMMARY
This bill would require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to adopt a process, as specified, for a telephone corporation to request relief from carrier of last resort (COLR) obligations in eligible areas, as specified. This bill would require the process to include specified public notice and challenge requirements, and oblige the telephone corporation that has been granted amended to meet specified requirements, as provided. This bill would require the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, only as provided.
Major Provisions
- Defines "eligible areas" as a census block that is well-served, as defined, or where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides line no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
- Defines "well-served" to mean at least three different facilities-based service providers, not including the copper infrastructure from the relevant telephone corporation, offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area in compliance with existing law. At least one of those service providers must be a wireline provider, at least one of the service providers must offer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, and at least one of the service providers must participate in the lifeline telephone service program. The alternative voice basic service must be available to all of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as specified.
- Defines "amended status" to mean the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
- Requires the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, subject to the requirements of this bill and other conditions imposed by the CPUC that are consistent with this bill.
- Requires the CPUC, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas, and specifies that the map shall include data from the wireless coverage maps previously adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services (OES), to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area, as provided.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area that is well-served, based on the map adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires a telephone corporation that has been granted amended status to meet specified requirements including, among other requirements, the following:
- Making accessible, within six years, its advance fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential unit in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first request for amended status, one-half of which shall be in areas that are not well-served as of the effective date it first obtained amended status.
- Provide continuing service to a customer for at least 12 months if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for public safety technology upgrade grants.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding to OES for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmangement employees.
- For at least 24 months, engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
- Authorizes the CPUC to impose a remedy, after notice and reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any requirement specified.
- For a period of 10 years after a telephone corporation has received amended status, require a telephone corporation to provide alternative voice basic service to any residential customer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served areas, as provided.
COMMENTS
- What is a carrier of last resort? A carrier of last resort (COLR) is a designated telephone corporation that has a legal obligation to provide access to basic telephone service to any household in its service territory who requests it. Across the state, every census block has a specified carrier that is designated as the COLR by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), even in areas where there may be multiple providers offering telephone service. The legal obligations placed on a COLR have been a tenant of universal service for decades, to ensure that everyone has guaranteed access to safe, reliable, and affordable telephone service. According to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), there are 16 COLR-designated companies across California with distinct service territories. AT&T is the designated COLR in many parts of the State and is the largest COLR in California; Frontier is the second largest COLR in the State.
- This bill mandates a process for eligible areas, to be administered by the CPUC. This bill requires the CPUC to adopt a process for a telephone corporation to seek amended status in eligible areas, by December 15, 2026. Eligible areas are those areas that are either well-served, as defined, or where there is no population and a telephone customer has no customers. The bill provides some guidance and requirements that the CPUC must include in whatever process is adopted for each eligible area, including requirements for customer notifications, a challenge process, and other guardrails to ensure no household is left without telephone service. Provided that a telephone corporation meets the requirements set forth by this bill and the requirements set forth by the CPUC, the CPUC would be required to approve a request for amended status. This requirement on the CPUC serves to ensure regulatory certainty for telephone corporations that opt to participate in the process, and also to ensure the CPUC has the legal authority to grant the relief required by this bill. In regulatory filings and public meetings the CPUC has questioned whether it has the legal authority to relieve an area of a carrier of last resort when there is no alternative that steps in.
- Risks and benefits. Given that a COLR is a designated company that is required to provide basic telephone service to any customer that requests it in that service territory, relieving a company of such an obligation potentially risks the public's access to telephone service. This inherently puts at risk the public's access to 911, which may negatively impact the public safety and welfare. On the other hand, households in well-served areas have access to multiple providers from which they can receive service, thus reducing their reliance on a single provider to meet their needs. Nonetheless, that single provider maintains the obligation to serve, which most COLR's choose to meet through their outdated copper telephone networks that are costly and inefficient to maintain. This bill attempts to balance the need to ensure universal access to telephone service by establishing multiple guardrails to ensure households indeed have alternative options where a telephone corporation is requesting relief. Additionally, this bill would require a telephone corporation to make investments in their network to expand access to advanced infrastructure, such as fiber optics.
According to the Author
"AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VoIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world."
Arguments in Support
Supporters of this bill argue that it would implement needed changes to the state's outdated COLR regulatory framework, which was developed in decades past to ensure universal access to telephone service in a telecommunications marketplace that looked much different the competitive market that exists today in some parts of the state. The supporters argue that these changes would accelerate investment in modern communications options, with sufficient guardrails to ensure no community or household is left behind during the transition.
Arguments in Opposition
Opponents of this bill argue that this bill turns a longstanding mandate to ensure universal service and consumer protection into a choice subject to the whims of business decisions, thus putting public safety and welfare at risk. The opponents have also raised concerns about the inaccuracies of the broadband coverage maps required to be utilized in the process, and called into question their usefulness in representing voice coverage. Lastly, the opponents have also criticized whether the infrastructure investments required by this bill are sufficient and pointed out that those investments do not preference or specify whether the work would be undertaken by workers in unions subject to collective bargaining agreements.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of a similar version of this bill, it would create significant new analytical work for the CPUC to complete tasks such as adopting a map of well-served areas, reviewing advice letters submitted pursuant to this bill, and ensuring a telephone corporation fulfills other obligations pursuant to this bill.
The CPUC estimates costs resulting from the mapping obligation to be approximately $200,000, one time, for a data analyst position and contracting and equipment costs of $172,000 in the first year and $57,000 annually thereafter (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account (PUCURA)). In addition, the CPUC estimates it will need twelve new positions, at a cost of approximately $2.5 million (PUCURA) to review COLR advice letters and undertake consequent obligations required by bill. The CPUC did not explicitly tie its estimated number of positions needed to the number of COLR advice letters it expects to receive as a result of the authority provided by this bill. The Appropriations Committee cost estimate does not reflect costs resulting from additional work newly required by the current version of the bill.
VOTES
ASM COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE: 8-1-1
YES: Boerner, Hoover, Ahrens, Bonta, Caloza, Castillo, Lowenthal, Blanca Rubio
NO: Garcia
ABS, ABST OR NV: Rogers
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-0-3
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Dixon, Elhawary, Fong, Mark González, Hart, Pacheco, Solache, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Pellerin, Tangipa
ASM COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE: 7-0-2
YES: Boerner, Hoover, Ahrens, Castillo, Lowenthal, Rogers, Blanca Rubio
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bonta, Caloza
UPDATED
VERSION: June 19, 2025
CONSULTANT: Emilio Perez / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637 FN: 0001016
Date of Hearing: June 23, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Tasha Boerner, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 470 (
Author:McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:June 19, 2025
SUBJECT: Telephone corporations: carriers of last resort
SUMMARY: This bill would require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to adopt a process, as specified, for a telephone corporation to request relief from carrier of last resort (COLR) obligations in eligible areas, as specified. This bill would require the process to include specified public notice and challenge requirements, and oblige the telephone corporation that has been granted amended to meet specified requirements, as provided. This bill would require the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, only as provided. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “eligible areas” as a census block that is well-served, as defined, or where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides line no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
- Defines “well-served” to mean at least three different facilities-based service providers, not including the copper infrastructure from the relevant telephone corporation, offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area in compliance with existing law. At least one of those service providers must be a wireline provider, at least one of the service providers must offer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, and at least one of the service providers must participate in the lifeline telephone service program. The alternative voice basic service must be available to all of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as specified.
- Defines “amended status” to mean the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
- Requires the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, subject to the requirements of this bill and other conditions imposed by the CPUC that are consistent with this bill.
- Requires the CPUC, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas, and specifies that the map shall include data from the wireless coverage maps previously adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services (OES), to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area, as provided.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area that is well-served, based on the map adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from its carrier of last resort obligations to meet specified requirements, including among other requirements:
- Making accessible, within six years, its advance fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential unit in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first request for amended status, one-half of which shall be in areas that are not well-served as of the effective date it first obtained amended status.
- Provide continuing service to a customer for at least 12 months if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for public safety technology upgrade grants.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding to OES for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmangement employees.
- For at least 24 months, engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
- Authorizes the CPUC to impose a remedy, after notice and reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any requirement specified.
- For a period of 10 years after a telephone corporation has received amended status, require a telephone corporation to provide alternative voice basic service to any residential customer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served areas, as provided.
- Exempts from this bill any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well-served.
- Prohibits the CPUC from designating any other entity as a successor carrier of last resort for any census block wherein the CPUC has approved amended status.
- Specifies that this bill does not modify or reduce the obligations of a telephone corporation to be the carrier of last resort in any area that is not an eligible area for amended status.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes that telephone corporations are public utilities subject to control by the Legislature. (California Constitution Article XI § 3)
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to, among other things, establish rules for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution Article XI § 6)
- Defines "telephone corporation" to include every corporation or person owning, controlling, operating, or managing any telephone line for compensation within this state. (Public Utilities Code Section 234)
- Defines "service area" for purposes of the operations of a telephone corporation, to mean a local access and transport area as defined and approved by the United States District Court for the District of Columbia circuit in the case of the United States v. Western Electric Co., Inc., and American Telephone and Telegraph Co., CA 82-0192, April 20, and July 8, 1983, and in a Memorandum and Order of August 5, 1983. (Public Utilities Code Section 230.3)
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that public utilities furnish and maintain such adequate, efficient, just and reasonable service, instrumentalities, equipment, and facilities as are necessary to promote the safety, health, comfort, and convenience of its patrons, employees, and the public. (Public Utilities Code § 701)
- Requires a telephone corporation, before it exits the business of providing interexchange services to all of its customers or to an entire class of its customers, to provide those affected customers with a written notice at least 30 days prior to the proposed transfer of those customers to another telephone corporation, as specified. (Public Utilities Code § 2889.3)
- Requires the CPUC to require telephone corporations to provide customer service to telecommunication customers that includes, but is not limited to, sufficient information upon which to make informed choices among telecommunications services and providers, ability to access a live operator by dialing “0”, reasonable statewide service quality standards, and information concerning the regulatory process. (Public Utilities Code § 2896)
- Defines “telecommunications service” to mean voice communication provided by a telephone corporation, voice communication provided by a provider of satellite telephone service, voice communication provided by a provider of mobile telephone service, and voice communication provided by a commercially available facilities-based provider of voice communication services utilizing Voice over Inter Protocol (VoIP). (Public Utilities Code § 2892.1)
- Establishes the California High Cost Funds (CHCF) A, CHCF B, Universal Lifeline Telephone Service Trust, the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program, and the California TeleConnect Fund. (Public Utilities Code Sections 270 to 281)
- Requires the CPUC to require every telephone corporation providing telephone service within a service area to file a schedule of rates and charges providing a class of lifeline telephone service. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Requires every telephone corporation providing service within a service area to inform all eligible subscribers of the availability of lifeline telephone service, and how they may qualify for and obtain service, and shall accept applications for lifeline telephone service according to procedures specified by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Authorizes the CPUC to annually determine user fees to be paid by every electrical, gas, telephone, telegraph, water, sewer system, and heat corporation and every other public utility providing service directly to customers or subscribers and subject to the jurisdiction of the commission, as specified. (Public Utilities Code Sections 431 to 435)
- Declares that the policies for telecommunications in California are as follows:
- To continue our universal service commitment by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications services to all Californians.
- To focus efforts on providing educational institutions, health care institutions, community-based organizations, and governmental institutions with access to advanced telecommunications services in recognition of their economic and societal impact.
- To encourage the development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.
- To assist in bridging the "digital divide" by encouraging expanded access to state-of-the-art technologies for rural, inner-city, low-income, and disabled Californians.
- To promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits that will result from the rapid implementation of advanced information and communications technologies by adequate long-term investment in the necessary infrastructure.
- To promote lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.
- To remove the barriers to open and competitive markets and promote fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.
- To encourage fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (Public Utilities Code Section 709)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of a similar version of this bill, it would create significant new analytical work for the CPUC to complete tasks such as adopting a map of well-served areas, reviewing advice letters submitted pursuant to this bill, and ensuring a telephone corporation fulfills other obligations pursuant to this bill.
The CPUC estimates costs resulting from the mapping obligation to be approximately $200,000, one time, for a data analyst position and contracting and equipment costs of $172,000 in the first year and $57,000 annually thereafter (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account (PUCURA)). In addition, the CPUC estimates it will need twelve new positions, at a cost of approximately $2.5 million (PUCURA) to review COLR advice letters and undertake consequent obligations required by bill. The CPUC did not explicitly tie its estimated number of positions needed to the number of COLR advice letters it expects to receive as a result of the authority provided by this bill.
The Appropriations Committee cost estimate does not reflect costs resulting from additional work newly required by the current version of the bill.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author: “AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VoIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world.”
- What is a Carrier of Last Resort (COLR)? Under state and federal laws, an entity that owns, operates, or manages a telephone line for compensation is a public utility, specifically a telephone corporation. A carrier of last resort (COLR) is a designated telephone corporation that has a legal obligation to provide access to basic telephone service to any household in its service territory who requests it. In a competitive market environment that exists across much of the state today, where consumers have multiple options to meet their voice communications needs, the COLR is literally the last-resort if no other carrier is willing or able to offer service. Across the state, every census block has a specified carrier that is designated as the COLR by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), even in areas where there may be multiple providers offering telephone service. In areas where there are multiple providers in the market, which this bill designates as a “well-served” area, it is still only one carrier that is designated to hold the legal obligations of the COLR. The legal obligations placed on a COLR have been a tenant of universal service for decades, to ensure that everyone has guaranteed access to safe, reliable, and affordable telephone service. According to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), there are 16 COLR-designated companies across California with distinct service territories. AT&T is the designated COLR in many parts of the State and is the largest COLR in California; Frontier is the second largest COLR in the State.
For much of the 20th century a single company, the American Telephone & Telegraph (now AT&T), owned and operated essentially all of the telephone infrastructure in the country as a regulated monopoly granted by government. Along with that market power, utility regulatory bodies such as the CPUC were vested with the authority to regulate the rates of telephone service to ensure just and reasonable prices for customers, control against unreasonable profits, and enforce the obligations to serve all customers in a discriminatory manner. In that context, it was clearly not unreasonable to require the single company with a monopoly on service to be expected to serve all the households in its service territory as a carrier of last resort. In that non-competitive context, the telephone corporation could recoup their costs from other customers during their rate cases before the CPUC, essentially spreading the cost of service to all households across their entire customer base. However, this dynamic began to change in the 1980’s with the introduction of competition into the telephone market. In 1982, the United State Department of Justice succeeded in its antitrust litigation against AT&T, resulting in a breakup of the company into smaller regional entities. The breakup of AT&T also paved the way for further innovation of telecommunications and other competitors to enter the telephone services market. For example, mobile telephone service first began to become commercially available in the 1980s. Subsequently, Congress passed the Telecommunications Act of 1996, which further incentivized competition in telecommunications service market as a means to reduce prices, and increase quality and innovation. Despite the proliferation of competition in the telecommunications marketplace over decades, COLR requirements have remained in California as a means to ensure there is a guaranteed provider of basic telephone service regardless of the status of the market. However, unlike in the era of a monopoly, no company is guaranteed a particular revenue from their customers or profit. Even if a COLR loses customers to competitors, they retain the legal obligation of a COLR and the according costs. The perspective of this bill, which opponents continue to take issue with, is that such COLR requirements are no longer required and may actually hinder further investment and competition in the market. Accordingly, this bill proposes to require the CPUC to adopt a process telephone corporations to seek relief from their obligations as a carrier of last resort in eligible areas as a way to incentivize further investment and access to advance technologies.
- The transition from plain old telephone service is happening on its own, regardless of this bill. Just as the preferred type of telecommunications technologies transitioned at the turn of the 20th century from telegraph to telephone, consumers today are once again increasingly transitioning towards more modern telecommunications services such as mobile telephone and broadband internet service when those options are available. This bill would classify those other types of services as “alternative voice basic services”. To put this transition in context, consider several data points from the Center for Disease Control (CDC) National Center of Health Statistics, which has measured the availability of telephone service in households for decades. In 1999 the CDC estimated that about 95% of California households had a household telephone, while in 2007 nationwide figures showed that only about 16% of households relied on wireless phone service only. Data from 2023 show that 76% of adults lived in households that did not have landline telephone but did have at least one wireless telephone, a stark difference since the late 90s and early 2000s. Beyond telephone service, data from the California Statewide Digital Equity Survey published in 2023 show that 91% of households also subscribe to high-speed internet access at home. In summary, most consumers today have more options to meet their communications needs, from more providers utilizing different types of technologies, than ever before. The perspective of this bill is that, because of competition, the requirement for one company to hold the entire legal obligation to serve an area is no longer necessary and is a barrier to investment and competition. However, it must be noted that the public benefits of competition have not been realized equally across the state.
Whereas in the monopoly era, it was essentially one company that had an obligation to provide telephone service to households as the COLR and only carrier; today’s market is different. There is no carrier of last resort for mobile telephone service or broadband internet access, and those industries have resisted regulation of their services. In fact, under state or federal law broadband internet service providers are not a public utilities or common carriers at all. Even mobile telephone providers, although they are common carriers, are not subject to the same requirements as a COLR. Unlike the monopoly era, regulators are not empowered to require a mobile telephone or broadband internet provider to expand their network to unserved households and providers are not currently required to meet baseline quality of service requirements[1]. As a result, in areas where there is little economic incentive for providers to enter the market, households remain unserved and underserved by more advanced telecommunications technologies or wireless reception can be unreliable. In those areas where there is no competition, the COLR might be the only reliable provider. The areas of the state which have not benefited from competition in the market generally are disproportionately rural and lower-income, and may never be served by advanced technologies regardless of COLR or without government intervention. The dichotomy, between well-served areas with robust competition for telecommunications services, and less well-served areas where the market is not meeting consumers’ needs for advanced communications services, like broadband internet access, illustrates a bright line of the digital divide.
Acknowledging that alternative services are not available to all corners of this state, this bill is drafted in a manner that attempts to respect that bright lines, by establishing a process for relinquishment only in those areas that are well-served and in areas where there is no population or no customers. This bill defines these areas as “eligible areas”. Areas that are not eligible areas would not be subject to the process that would be established by the commission pursuant to this bill. Recent amendments clarify the scope of this bill.
- The bill requires the CPUC to establish a process for COLR relief, including a challenge process. Previous versions of this bill provided a limited role for the CPUC, however this version of the bill requires the CPUC to establish the process that a telephone corporation must follow in order to seek and obtain amended status. “Amended status” is defined by this bill as the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort in a census block or census blocks. In particular, this bill requires the CPUC to adopt processes for both well-served areas, and areas with no population and no customers each by December 15, 2026. Each area will of course have different considerations that the CPUC would be able to take into account when developing those requirements. For example, in no population areas and no customer areas there are not customers to notify, therefore the CPUC would not be required to adopt customer notice requirements but may instead require notifications to local elected officials, emergency responders, and other interested parties. To ensure a robust process, this bill establishes some guidelines that each process should include. For example, the process for each area shall include a Tier 2 Advice letter process for a telephone corporation to request relief, public notification requirements, a challenge process, and timelines for when the amended status shall be in effect after approval of a request. Under each process, the CPUC would be prohibited from granting relief if there are pending challenges in that census block.
Where the processes will differ among the two eligible areas is particularly on the timelines for when the amended status takes affect and also the timelines for a challenge. In a no population and no customer area, the CPUC is required to allow 90 days for a challenge to a request for amended status. After those 90 days have elapsed and when the CPUC approves the request, the amended status takes effect immediately. In a well-served area, given the potential customer impact or disruption of service, the public is given more time to challenge for a total of 180 days. Additionally, at least 180 days must have passed from the last customer notification before amended status can take effect. The additional time is a safeguard to ensure no area that is not legitimately well-served, as defined, is capable of being granted relief from COLR requirements.
Ultimately, once each process is complete and a telephone corporation has met its obligations, the CPUC is required to approve the request for amended status. The CPUC would also maintain the authority to deny or modify requests that do not meet the requirements of this bill or other conditions it imposes on the process. Providing certainty to the telephone corporation seeking amended status is reasonable given that the process the CPUC will establish will be comprehensive and intensive on the part of the telephone corporation and provides guardrails to ensure universal service. Without this certainty, it is possible the CPUC may utilize its discretion in a manner that results in no request for relief being approved, thus undermining the process the legislature would be directing the agency to follow pursuant to this bill. Most importantly, given that in public statements the CPUC has cast doubt as to whether the agency has the legal authority to grant relief of COLR obligations if there is no replacement, this provision ensures the CPUC has the authority needed to implement this bill.
- The bill does not grant blanket COLR relinquishment across the state. Many of the organizations opposed to this bill have expressed concerns about the impact of this bill for all Californians, and especially those in rural communities or where reliable access to telephone service has not been consistently available except through the carrier of last resort. Certainly those areas are worthy of special consideration, and this bill is limited to eligible areas. Eligible areas as defined by this bill are well-served areas and those areas with no population or where the telephone corporation has no customers on basic exchange service. Areas will be measured on a census block basis.
This bill only requires the CPUC to establish a process for relinquishment of COLR obligations in eligible areas. Well-served areas, as defined by this bill, are areas where there are at least three other alternative voice service providers, at least one of which must be a wireline provider and at least one of which is a Lifeline provider. In well-served areas, the public already has various choices for providers and many have willingly chosen to subscribe to services from carriers that are not carriers of last resort. Still, it is undeniable that relinquishing the obligation of a carrier of last resort to serve all customers poses an inherent risk to the public’s universal access to telephone service. Nonetheless, short of a market collapse, it is likely that residents of well-served areas will continue to have access to reliable voice communication services even despite relinquishment of COLR. This is evidenced by the fact that most consumers in well-served areas purchase services other than COLR basic service, such as broadband, VoIP, or mobile wireless telephone service. Additionally, in recent history large providers have rarely gone out of business, although there has been market consolidation. Notably, the CPUC is required to approve mergers of telecommunications providers and this bill does not change that.
Beyond well-served areas, this bill also requires the CPUC to adopt a process for a telephone corporation to seek amended status in census blocks with no population and no customers. In these areas, there is obviously a smaller risk for public impact because of the nature of those areas having no population. However, to the extent that those areas may be developed in the future, there is a risk that no provider would be willing to serve new developments. Again, here the actual risk of a stranded customer is unlikely because a local government would have to approve new development and likely would know the area is not covered by COLR before doing so. Even so, for a period of 10 years, this bill would require a telephone corporation that has been granted amended status as carrier of last resort to be required to offer alternative voice service if there are truly no other providers.
- This bill requires the CPUC to adopt a map of well-served areas. As stated above, one eligible area for relief under this bill are well-served areas. Well-served areas are defined in reference to the number of alternative providers that meet particular criteria, particularly the availability of three alternatives offering alternative voice basic service, including one wireline provider and one provider that offers Lifeline. Moreover, every household in such a census block would need to meet this criteria in order to be considered well-served. Although the availability of multiple providers reduces the possibility that an individual would not be able to access reliable and affordable alternative voice service, it is imperative that these areas are accurately represented as part of the COLR relief process. To ensure the most robust set of data currently available, this bill directs the CPUC to adopt a map that includes data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to implementation of the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program[2] or from the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) National Broadband Map[3]. The BEAD program map and the FCC National Broadband Map were objectively the most robust and comprehensive mapping effort ever undertaken by the state and federal government. The maps include layers that demonstrate fixed and mobile broadband service availability by broadband serviceable location address.
In well-served areas, it likely that the availability of wireless services will be heavily relied on to meet the minimum requirements of the definition, as it is not uncommon that a household would only have one alternative wireline option available, often from a cable company. Given that the availability of wireless coverage may be spotty in some parts of the state, especially at the peripheries of wireless coverage areas, there exists a need to ensure all the available alternatives are actually available. Towards that end, this version of the bill continues to require the CPUC to adopt a map of well-served areas that will then serve as the basis for where a telephone corporation can seek amended status. In other words, if an area is not represented on this map, even if there are some alternatives, then it is not well-served as established by this bill and in turn would not be eligible for amended status. This mapping requirement will offer additional discretion to the CPUC in the public’s interest, to ensure everyone in a well-served area is truly well-served.
Despite the additional assurance that such a map can provide, a number of the opponents of this bill point out that the BEAD map and the National Broadband Map are imperfect nonetheless. For example, the Public Advocates Office of the CPUC points out that the national broadband map has had over 2 million errors discovered across the nation. Additionally, the CPUC ran a separate challenge process for the state BEAD map and accepted their own challenges. Although the number of errors addressed on the map may cast doubt on their reliability or usefulness, on the other hand, that robust challenge process is also exactly why these maps are the most accurate broadband maps ever produced. Furthermore, by requiring the CPUC to utilize these maps as the starting point for a well-served map, it ensures there will be yet another opportunity for the public and stakeholders to ensure the accuracy of these previously vetted maps. The alternative would seem to be starting from scratch, which is not exactly an efficient use of resources given the amount of effort and funding that went into producing the FCC National Broadband Map and the state BEAD map. Lastly, and importantly, after the maps are adopted on the front end the public will still maintain the right to challenge their well-served designation based on the challenge process on the back end. In a nutshell, although the maps are imperfect, there are multiple mechanisms in this bill to provide additional assurance about a household’s or census block’s designation as well-served.
The CPUC will not be required to adopt a map of no population and no customer areas because it is fairly obvious, based on census data, where there is a population.
- This bill imposes obligations on a telephone corporation seeking amended status. As was established in the previous section, there is an inherent risk in this bill to the public’s continued universal access to telephone service. However, that risk is not guaranteed to be realized, and this bill includes robust guardrails for challenges. Further, those risks ought to be considered alongside the potential public benefits that this bill may enable. For example, in order to receive an amended status as a carrier of last resort, a telephone corporation must meet various ongoing requirements after obtaining amended status. The commitments include demonstrating that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to a minimum number of residential units and year-over-year increase in fiber buildout. Other commitment include offering an affordable broadband plan, benefits for small business customers, funding for public safety technology upgrades, funding for community-based digital literacy resources, and workforce development. This bill would also establish the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant program, to be administered by the CPUC and funded by donations. This bill also provides that the CPUC may seek a remedy if a provider fails to meet their commitments.
Among the most robust requirements of this bill that a telephone corporation will be required to follow is a commitment to make accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first amended status request. Moreover, this bill requires that half of that investment would be in areas of the state that are not well served. In effect, this provisions encourages investment in areas of the state that might otherwise not see investment.
- The public in affected areas would still have access to Lifeline under this bill. As has been established, the concept of a COLR exists to ensure universal access to telephone service consistent with federal and state law. While the most obvious element of universal access is merely ensuring that an individual is capable of utilizing the telephone network for their communications needs, another element is ensuring affordable access. Without a guarantee of affordable access, universal access cannot be achieved because cost would otherwise be a barrier to low-income residents. Thus, in order to advance the public policy goal of universal access to telephone service, COLR regulations require a carrier of last resort to participate in the Lifeline program. The Lifeline program offers subsidies to eligible low-income households to assist with affording the cost of basic telephone service. Historically, Lifeline service had been provided through landline telephones, but as technology advanced the program has also supported access to mobile telephone. In fact, based on today’s enrollment there are about 1.4 million Lifeline participants in the state, with only about 133,000 of those utilizing the benefit for wireline service.
To ensure continued access to affordable telephone service, the bill’s definition of well-served includes a requirement that at least one of the providers in a well-served areas is a Lifeline provider. This provision will ensure that any customer or member of the public in a well-served area will have access to Lifeline benefits, and therefore affordable telephone service. However, it should be noted that the Lifeline provider does not necessarily need to be a wireline provider. Therefore, it is possible that some customers who currently utilize their Lifeline benefit for wireline telephone service may be required to transition their benefit to a wireless plan. Nonetheless, they will retain access to an affordable voice service plan.
- Are COLR regulations technology-neutral? The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has asserted that its COLR rules are technology neutral, thus inferring that existing carriers of last resort may meet their COLR obligations through any technology. Taken a step further, this assertion implies that a COLR is not required to maintain a copper network, as is claimed by supporters. This is all technically an accurate statement, but in practice the answer is more complicated.
Under CPUC regulations, a COLR is required to offer what is referred to as “basic service” to any customer that requests it. Basic service must include several elements that are determined by the commission including: the ability to place and receive voice-grade calls over all distances, free access to 911 and enhanced-911 service, access to directory services, specified billing provisions, access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services, access to telephone relay services for disabled users, access to customer service information about Lifeline, one-time bill adjustments for certain charges, and access to operator services. Many of these elements are clearly necessary and basic services for consumers, while some may be more outdated or unnecessary given today’s consumer preferences and practices. Importantly to an evaluation of whether current COLR rules are technology neutral, it is absolutely possible to meet those basic service requirements through other technologies like wireless or fiber, and basic service does not require a copper connection.
However, in addition to these basic service elements, a basic service provider is also required to file and maintain tariffs, or schedules of rates, with the commission that include basic service rates, charges, terms and conditions. The tariffs are required to be filed through a Tier 2 advice letter that is subject to review and approval by CPUC staff. Herein lies the complication when evaluating whether the CPUC’s COLR rules are actually technology-neutral in practice. While it is true that a carrier of last resort could meet its COLR obligation through any technology, if it were to meet those obligations through alternatives technologies beyond copper (such as broadband) it would be subjecting those otherwise non-tariffed services to CPUC tariffing requirements. In effect then, the COLR’s alternative services would necessarily be regulated differently than their competitors merely because their status as a COLR. Therefore, in practice the CPUC’s COLR requirements are not as neutral in practice as may have been represented.
- Could the CPUC designate a new COLR for areas that have been granted amended status? Under the California Constitution and the Public Utilities Code, the CPUC has broad authority over telephone corporations and the authority to establish its own procedures to regulate those entities. Generally speaking and consistent with the law, the CPUC has near plenary power to impose certain requirements on telephone corporations, unless otherwise prohibited by law. While this bill is intended to establish a process to effectuate the relinquishment of COLR obligations in some targeted areas, there is concern among non-COLR providers that the CPUC may seek to reassign COLR obligations to other entities. While there is not a specific statute that would authorize the CPUC taking this action, it is not a far-fetched concern that the CPUC would utilize the full extent of its other constitutional and statutory authority to attempt to unilaterally designate a new COLR in amended status areas despite passage of this bill. For example, existing Commission rules currently require the CPUC to find a replacement COLR in areas that have been granted in relief. Under existing law, nothing would explicitly prohibit the CPUC from designating another entity or re-designating a telephone corporation that has been granted relief as a COLR in the future. Therefore, to prevent the CPUC from utilizing the breadth of its constitutional authority to undermine the intent of this bill, it is reasonable to explicitly prohibit the CPUC from designating a replacement COLR in areas that have been granted relief pursuant to this bill.
- The CPUC has an open rulemaking to consider changes to COLR. In June 2024, the CPUC initiated a new rulemaking to review and possibly update the rules for COLR. The rulemaking was initiated, in part, because the CPUC was required by its own precedent to deny a previous AT&T application requesting COLR relief on a technicality, not on its merits. That previous decisions adopted a process for COLR relief that required a replacement COLR be identified before the CPUC could grant relief. Relying on that past decision as rationale, the CPUC denied that application with prejudice and prohibited AT&T from submitting similar request until at least one year after a decision to close the new rulemaking that was just opened. Eight months after opening the rulemaking, the assigned Commissioner eventually issued a scoping ruling outlining the issues that would be considered in the rulemaking. Among those issues within the scope of the rulemaking include whether the CPUC should adopt revisions to its current process for COLR relief and under conditions a COLR should be allowed to withdraw. The rulemaking also has other issues within its scope, such as updating existing COLR rules and revising the definition of “basic service”. To the extent this bill would require the CPUC to adopt a process to effectuate COLR relief, it would answer some of the questions within the scope of the proceeding and require the CPUC to grant COLR relief as provided in this bill. The CPUC would retain the discretion to the design the process, consistent with his bill. Afterwards following adoption of the processes and the map required pursuant to this bill, the CPUC would be permitted to return to the other issues within the rulemaking such as updating the definition of “basic service” and other COLR requirements in areas where COLR obligations will persist indefinitely.
- Similar/related legislation.
- AB 2797 (McKinnor), 2024, was similar to the provisions of this bill. The bill was referred to the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
- AB 2395 (Low), 2016, would have established a process for a telephone corporation to withdraw legacy public switched telephone network services and transition to Internet Protocol (IP) enabled services and networks, beginning January 1, 2020. The bill was held in Assembly Appropriations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alameda County Latina Chamber of Commerce
Asian Pacific American Advocates
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific Islander American Vote (APIAVOTE)
At&t
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians
Black Business Association
Black Chamber of Orange County
Black Education Expo
Boss - Business of Student Success
Boys & Girls Clubs of Carson
Boys & Girls Clubs of Fresno County
Boys and Girls Club of Central Orange Coast
Boys and Girls Club of Kern County
Business Council San Joaquin County
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
Calasian Chamber of Commerce
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Tennis Association for Underprivileged Youth
California Valley Miwok Tribe
Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Cniga - California Nations Indian Gaming Association
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Digitallift
East Bay Leadership Council
Emac Construction
Empowerment (dess Perkins Foundation)
Enterprise Rancheria
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Exp – the Opportunity Engine
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Haven Neighborhood Services
Hopland Band of Pomo Indians
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Jamul Indian Village of California
Janet Goeske Foundation
Japanese American Citizens League (JACL)
Kern Economic Development Foundation
Kidstream Children's Museum
LA Jolla Band of Luiseno Indians
Latino Education and Advocacy Days (LEAD)
Los Angeles Mission
Maac Project
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Morongo Band of Mission Indians
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises INC. (MORE)
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Onegeneration
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Pauma Band of Luiseno Indians
Pinoleville Pomo Nation
Reality Changers
Redding Rancheria
Rincon Band of Luiseno Indians
Rise San Diego
Robinson Rancheria Pomo Indians of California
Salef
San Diego County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Gabriel Valley Conservation and Service Corps
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Small Business Diversity Network
Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians
Tejon Indian Tribe
The Arc California
The Fresno Center
Tulare Kings Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom - the Broadband Association
Ventura Chamber of Commerce
Vermont-slauson Economic Development Corporation
Weave
Opposition
#oaklandundivided
Alliance for a Better Community (UNREG)
Arts for LA
Bridge the Digital Divide
California Alliance for Digital Equity
California Community Foundation
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Federation of Labor Unions, Afl-cio
Cdp Rural Caucus
Center for Accessible Technology
Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research (CLEAR)
City of Hidden Hills
Communications Workers of America Local 9410
Communications Workers of America Local 9510
Communications Workers of America Local 9511
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Communities in Schools of Los Angeles (CISLA)
Community Coalition of the Antelope Valley
Consejo De Federaciones Mexicanas (COFEM)
Cwa Southern California Council
Destination Crenshaw
Digital Equity LA
Diversity in Leadership Institute
Everyoneon
Families in Schools
Fiber-up My Neighborhood
Fresno Coalition for Digital Inclusion
Gpsn
Hack the Hood
Healing and Justice Center
Innovate Public Schools
Institute for Local Self-reliance
Insure the Uninsured Project
Jawharah Mcclinton
Kapor Center
Las Virgenes-malibu Council of Governments
Latino Equality Alliance
Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities
Los Angeles Unified School District
Los Angeles Urban League
Luisa Calumpong, Broadband Manager, City of Oakland
Media Alliance
Nextgen California
Orange County Labor Federation, Afl-cio
Our Voice: Communities for Quality Education
Pacoima Beautiful
Para Los Ninos
Parent Engagement Academy
Parent Institute for Quality Education
Puente Learning Center
Southeast Community Development Corporation
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Trio Plus
Unite-la
United Parents and Schools
Vision Y Compromiso
Oppose Unless Amended
CalBroadband
County of Marin
Public Advocates Office
Analysis Prepared by: Emilio Perez / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
In April 2025 the CPUC issued a proposed decision to implement service quality standards on wireline Voice over Internet-Protocol (VoIP) and mobile voice communications. ↑
CPUC BEAD Challenge Map. https://register.challenge.cpuc.ca.gov/register/bead/map ↑
Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map. https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/home ↑
Date of Hearing: June 23, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Tasha Boerner, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 470 (
Author:McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:June 19, 2025
SUBJECT: Telephone corporations: carriers of last resort
SUMMARY: This bill would require the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to adopt a process, as specified, for a telephone corporation to request relief from carrier of last resort (COLR) obligations in eligible areas, as specified. This bill would require the process to include specified public notice and challenge requirements, and oblige the telephone corporation that has been granted amended to meet specified requirements, as provided. This bill would require the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, only as provided. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “eligible areas” as a census block that is well-served, as defined, or where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides line no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
- Defines “well-served” to mean at least three different facilities-based service providers, not including the copper infrastructure from the relevant telephone corporation, offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area in compliance with existing law. At least one of those service providers must be a wireline provider, at least one of the service providers must offer a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, and at least one of the service providers must participate in the lifeline telephone service program. The alternative voice basic service must be available to all of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as specified.
- Defines “amended status” to mean the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort status in a census block or census blocks.
- Requires the CPUC to approve a request for amended status, subject to the requirements of this bill and other conditions imposed by the CPUC that are consistent with this bill.
- Requires the CPUC, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas, and specifies that the map shall include data from the wireless coverage maps previously adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services (OES), to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where the telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within the area, as provided.
- Requires the CPUC, in consultation with the Office of Emergency Services, to on or before December 15, 2026, adopt a process through which a telephone corporation seeking to amend its status as a carrier of last resort may submit a request for amended status for an area that is well-served, based on the map adopted by the CPUC.
- Requires a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from its carrier of last resort obligations to meet specified requirements, including among other requirements:
- Making accessible, within six years, its advance fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential unit in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first request for amended status, one-half of which shall be in areas that are not well-served as of the effective date it first obtained amended status.
- For at least 24 months, provide continuing service to a customer for at least 12 months if the customer elects not to transition to an alternative voice basic service.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for public safety technology upgrade grants.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding to OES for grants and programs to tribal governments, community-based organizations, and local governments to help them prepare for, respond to, and recover from emergencies.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for programs to develop community-based digital literacy resources in amended status areas.
- For at least 24 months, provide funding for a workforce development program in amended status areas that includes enhanced skills training, mentoring, education reimbursement, and career development programs for nonmangement employees.
- For at least 24 months, engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
- Authorizes the CPUC to impose a remedy, after notice and reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any requirement specified.
- For a period of 10 years after a telephone corporation has received amended status, require a telephone corporation to provide alternative voice basic service to any residential customer that is unable to obtain alternative voice basic service from any provider in the well-served areas, as provided.
- Exempts from this bill any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well-served.
- Prohibits the CPUC from designating any other entity as a successor carrier of last resort for any census block wherein the CPUC has approved amended status.
- Specifies that this bill does not modify or reduce the obligations of a telephone corporation to be the carrier of last resort in any area that is not an eligible area for amended status.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes that telephone corporations are public utilities subject to control by the Legislature. (California Constitution Article XI § 3)
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to, among other things, establish rules for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution Article XI § 6)
- Defines "telephone corporation" to include every corporation or person owning, controlling, operating, or managing any telephone line for compensation within this state. (Public Utilities Code Section 234)
- Defines "service area" for purposes of the operations of a telephone corporation, to mean a local access and transport area as defined and approved by the United States District Court for the District of Columbia circuit in the case of the United States v. Western Electric Co., Inc., and American Telephone and Telegraph Co., CA 82-0192, April 20, and July 8, 1983, and in a Memorandum and Order of August 5, 1983. (Public Utilities Code Section 230.3)
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that public utilities furnish and maintain such adequate, efficient, just and reasonable service, instrumentalities, equipment, and facilities as are necessary to promote the safety, health, comfort, and convenience of its patrons, employees, and the public. (Public Utilities Code § 701)
- Requires a telephone corporation, before it exits the business of providing interexchange services to all of its customers or to an entire class of its customers, to provide those affected customers with a written notice at least 30 days prior to the proposed transfer of those customers to another telephone corporation, as specified. (Public Utilities Code § 2889.3)
- Requires the CPUC to require telephone corporations to provide customer service to telecommunication customers that includes, but is not limited to, sufficient information upon which to make informed choices among telecommunications services and providers, ability to access a live operator by dialing “0”, reasonable statewide service quality standards, and information concerning the regulatory process. (Public Utilities Code § 2896)
- Defines “telecommunications service” to mean voice communication provided by a telephone corporation, voice communication provided by a provider of satellite telephone service, voice communication provided by a provider of mobile telephone service, and voice communication provided by a commercially available facilities-based provider of voice communication services utilizing Voice over Inter Protocol (VoIP). (Public Utilities Code § 2892.1)
- Establishes the California High Cost Funds (CHCF) A, CHCF B, Universal Lifeline Telephone Service Trust, the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program, and the California TeleConnect Fund. (Public Utilities Code Sections 270 to 281)
- Requires the CPUC to require every telephone corporation providing telephone service within a service area to file a schedule of rates and charges providing a class of lifeline telephone service. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Requires every telephone corporation providing service within a service area to inform all eligible subscribers of the availability of lifeline telephone service, and how they may qualify for and obtain service, and shall accept applications for lifeline telephone service according to procedures specified by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Authorizes the CPUC to annually determine user fees to be paid by every electrical, gas, telephone, telegraph, water, sewer system, and heat corporation and every other public utility providing service directly to customers or subscribers and subject to the jurisdiction of the commission, as specified. (Public Utilities Code Sections 431 to 435)
- Declares that the policies for telecommunications in California are as follows:
- To continue our universal service commitment by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications services to all Californians.
- To focus efforts on providing educational institutions, health care institutions, community-based organizations, and governmental institutions with access to advanced telecommunications services in recognition of their economic and societal impact.
- To encourage the development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.
- To assist in bridging the "digital divide" by encouraging expanded access to state-of-the-art technologies for rural, inner-city, low-income, and disabled Californians.
- To promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits that will result from the rapid implementation of advanced information and communications technologies by adequate long-term investment in the necessary infrastructure.
- To promote lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.
- To remove the barriers to open and competitive markets and promote fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.
- To encourage fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (Public Utilities Code Section 709)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of a similar version of this bill, it would create significant new analytical work for the CPUC to complete tasks such as adopting a map of well-served areas, reviewing advice letters submitted pursuant to this bill, and ensuring a telephone corporation fulfills other obligations pursuant to this bill.
The CPUC estimates costs resulting from the mapping obligation to be approximately $200,000, one time, for a data analyst position and contracting and equipment costs of $172,000 in the first year and $57,000 annually thereafter (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account (PUCURA)). In addition, the CPUC estimates it will need twelve new positions, at a cost of approximately $2.5 million (PUCURA) to review COLR advice letters and undertake consequent obligations required by bill. The CPUC did not explicitly tie its estimated number of positions needed to the number of COLR advice letters it expects to receive as a result of the authority provided by this bill.
The Appropriations Committee cost estimate does not reflect costs resulting from additional work newly required by the current version of the bill.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author: “AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VoIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world.”
- What is a Carrier of Last Resort (COLR)? Under state and federal laws, an entity that owns, operates, or manages a telephone line for compensation is a public utility, specifically a telephone corporation. A carrier of last resort (COLR) is a designated telephone corporation that has a legal obligation to provide access to basic telephone service to any household in its service territory who requests it. In a competitive market environment that exists across much of the state today, where consumers have multiple options to meet their voice communications needs, the COLR is literally the last-resort if no other carrier is willing or able to offer service. Across the state, every census block has a specified carrier that is designated as the COLR by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), even in areas where there may be multiple providers offering telephone service. In areas where there are multiple providers in the market, which this bill designates as a “well-served” area, it is still only one carrier that is designated to hold the legal obligations of the COLR. The legal obligations placed on a COLR have been a tenant of universal service for decades, to ensure that everyone has guaranteed access to safe, reliable, and affordable telephone service. According to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), there are 16 COLR-designated companies across California with distinct service territories. AT&T is the designated COLR in many parts of the State and is the largest COLR in California; Frontier is the second largest COLR in the State.
For much of the 20th century a single company, the American Telephone & Telegraph (now AT&T), owned and operated essentially all of the telephone infrastructure in the country as a regulated monopoly granted by government. Along with that market power, utility regulatory bodies such as the CPUC were vested with the authority to regulate the rates of telephone service to ensure just and reasonable prices for customers, control against unreasonable profits, and enforce the obligations to serve all customers in a discriminatory manner. In that context, it was clearly not unreasonable to require the single company with a monopoly on service to be expected to serve all the households in its service territory as a carrier of last resort. In that non-competitive context, the telephone corporation could recoup their costs from other customers during their rate cases before the CPUC, essentially spreading the cost of service to all households across their entire customer base. However, this dynamic began to change in the 1980’s with the introduction of competition into the telephone market. In 1982, the United State Department of Justice succeeded in its antitrust litigation against AT&T, resulting in a breakup of the company into smaller regional entities. The breakup of AT&T also paved the way for further innovation of telecommunications and other competitors to enter the telephone services market. For example, mobile telephone service first began to become commercially available in the 1980s. Subsequently, Congress passed the Telecommunications Act of 1996, which further incentivized competition in telecommunications service market as a means to reduce prices, and increase quality and innovation. Despite the proliferation of competition in the telecommunications marketplace over decades, COLR requirements have remained in California as a means to ensure there is a guaranteed provider of basic telephone service regardless of the status of the market. However, unlike in the era of a monopoly, no company is guaranteed a particular revenue from their customers or profit. Even if a COLR loses customers to competitors, they retain the legal obligation of a COLR and the according costs. The perspective of this bill, which opponents continue to take issue with, is that such COLR requirements are no longer required and may actually hinder further investment and competition in the market. Accordingly, this bill proposes to require the CPUC to adopt a process telephone corporations to seek relief from their obligations as a carrier of last resort in eligible areas as a way to incentivize further investment and access to advance technologies.
- The transition from plain old telephone service is happening on its own, regardless of this bill. Just as the preferred type of telecommunications technologies transitioned at the turn of the 20th century from telegraph to telephone, consumers today are once again increasingly transitioning towards more modern telecommunications services such as mobile telephone and broadband internet service when those options are available. This bill would classify those other types of services as “alternative voice basic services”. To put this transition in context, consider several data points from the Center for Disease Control (CDC) National Center of Health Statistics, which has measured the availability of telephone service in households for decades. In 1999 the CDC estimated that about 95% of California households had a household telephone, while in 2007 nationwide figures showed that only about 16% of households relied on wireless phone service only. Data from 2023 show that 76% of adults lived in households that did not have landline telephone but did have at least one wireless telephone, a stark difference since the late 90s and early 2000s. Beyond telephone service, data from the California Statewide Digital Equity Survey published in 2023 show that 91% of households also subscribe to high-speed internet access at home. In summary, most consumers today have more options to meet their communications needs, from more providers utilizing different types of technologies, than ever before. The perspective of this bill is that, because of competition, the requirement for one company to hold the entire legal obligation to serve an area is no longer necessary and is a barrier to investment and competition. However, it must be noted that the public benefits of competition have not been realized equally across the state.
Whereas in the monopoly era, it was essentially one company that had an obligation to provide telephone service to households as the COLR and only carrier; today’s market is different. There is no carrier of last resort for mobile telephone service or broadband internet access, and those industries have resisted regulation of their services. In fact, under state or federal law broadband internet service providers are not a public utilities or common carriers at all. Even mobile telephone providers, although they are common carriers, are not subject to the same requirements as a COLR. Unlike the monopoly era, regulators are not empowered to require a mobile telephone or broadband internet provider to expand their network to unserved households and providers are not currently required to meet baseline quality of service requirements[1]. As a result, in areas where there is little economic incentive for providers to enter the market, households remain unserved and underserved by more advanced telecommunications technologies or wireless reception can be unreliable. In those areas where there is no competition, the COLR might be the only reliable provider. The areas of the state which have not benefited from competition in the market generally are disproportionately rural and lower-income, and may never be served by advanced technologies regardless of COLR or without government intervention. The dichotomy, between well-served areas with robust competition for telecommunications services, and less well-served areas where the market is not meeting consumers’ needs for advanced communications services, like broadband internet access, illustrates a bright line of the digital divide.
Acknowledging that alternative services are not available to all corners of this state, this bill is drafted in a manner that attempts to respect that bright lines, by establishing a process for relinquishment only in those areas that are well-served and in areas where there is no population or no customers. This bill defines these areas as “eligible areas”. Areas that are not eligible areas would not be subject to the process that would be established by the commission pursuant to this bill. Recent amendments clarify the scope of this bill.
- The bill requires the CPUC to establish a process for COLR relief, including a challenge process. Previous versions of this bill provided a limited role for the CPUC, however this version of the bill requires the CPUC to establish the process that a telephone corporation must follow in order to seek and obtain amended status. “Amended status” is defined by this bill as the status of a telephone corporation that has been granted relief from carrier of last resort in a census block or census blocks. In particular, this bill requires the CPUC to adopt processes for both well-served areas, and areas with no population and no customers each by December 15, 2026. Each area will of course have different considerations that the CPUC would be able to take into account when developing those requirements. For example, in no population areas and no customer areas there are not customers to notify, therefore the CPUC would not be required to adopt customer notice requirements but may instead require notifications to local elected officials, emergency responders, and other interested parties. To ensure a robust process, this bill establishes some guidelines that each process should include. For example, the process for each area shall include a Tier 2 Advice letter process for a telephone corporation to request relief, public notification requirements, a challenge process, and timelines for when the amended status shall be in effect after approval of a request. Under each process, the CPUC would be prohibited from granting relief if there are pending challenges in that census block.
Where the processes will differ among the two eligible areas is particularly on the timelines for when the amended status takes affect and also the timelines for a challenge. In a no population and no customer area, the CPUC is required to allow 90 days for a challenge to a request for amended status. After those 90 days have elapsed and when the CPUC approves the request, the amended status takes effect immediately. In a well-served area, given the potential customer impact or disruption of service, the public is given more time to challenge for a total of 180 days. Additionally, at least 180 days must have passed from the last customer notification before amended status can take effect. The additional time is a safeguard to ensure no area that is not legitimately well-served, as defined, is capable of being granted relief from COLR requirements.
Ultimately, once each process is complete and a telephone corporation has met its obligations, the CPUC is required to approve the request for amended status. The CPUC would also maintain the authority to deny or modify requests that do not meet the requirements of this bill or other conditions it imposes on the process. Providing certainty to the telephone corporation seeking amended status is reasonable given that the process the CPUC will establish will be comprehensive and intensive on the part of the telephone corporation and provides guardrails to ensure universal service. Without this certainty, it is possible the CPUC may utilize its discretion in a manner that results in no request for relief being approved, thus undermining the process the legislature would be directing the agency to follow pursuant to this bill. Most importantly, given that in public statements the CPUC has cast doubt as to whether the agency has the legal authority to grant relief of COLR obligations if there is no replacement, this provision ensures the CPUC has the authority needed to implement this bill.
- The bill does not grant blanket COLR relinquishment across the state. Many of the organizations opposed to this bill have expressed concerns about the impact of this bill for all Californians, and especially those in rural communities or where reliable access to telephone service has not been consistently available except through the carrier of last resort. Certainly those areas are worthy of special consideration, and this bill is limited to eligible areas. Eligible areas as defined by this bill are well-served areas and those areas with no population or where the telephone corporation has no customers on basic exchange service. Areas will be measured on a census block basis.
This bill only requires the CPUC to establish a process for relinquishment of COLR obligations in eligible areas. Well-served areas, as defined by this bill, are areas where there are at least three other alternative voice service providers, at least one of which must be a wireline provider and at least one of which is a Lifeline provider. In well-served areas, the public already has various choices for providers and many have willingly chosen to subscribe to services from carriers that are not carriers of last resort. Still, it is undeniable that relinquishing the obligation of a carrier of last resort to serve all customers poses an inherent risk to the public’s universal access to telephone service. Nonetheless, short of a market collapse, it is likely that residents of well-served areas will continue to have access to reliable voice communication services even despite relinquishment of COLR. This is evidenced by the fact that most consumers in well-served areas purchase services other than COLR basic service, such as broadband, VoIP, or mobile wireless telephone service. Additionally, in recent history large providers have rarely gone out of business, although there has been market consolidation. Notably, the CPUC is required to approve mergers of telecommunications providers and this bill does not change that.
Beyond well-served areas, this bill also requires the CPUC to adopt a process for a telephone corporation to seek amended status in census blocks with no population and no customers. In these areas, there is obviously a smaller risk for public impact because of the nature of those areas having no population. However, to the extent that those areas may be developed in the future, there is a risk that no provider would be willing to serve new developments. Again, here the actual risk of a stranded customer is unlikely because a local government would have to approve new development and likely would know the area is not covered by COLR before doing so. Even so, for a period of 10 years, this bill would require a telephone corporation that has been granted amended status as carrier of last resort to be required to offer alternative voice service if there are truly no other providers.
- This bill requires the CPUC to adopt a map of well-served areas. As stated above, one eligible area for relief under this bill are well-served areas. Well-served areas are defined in reference to the number of alternative providers that meet particular criteria, particularly the availability of three alternatives offering alternative voice basic service, including one wireline provider and one provider that offers Lifeline. Moreover, every household in such a census block would need to meet this criteria in order to be considered well-served. Although the availability of multiple providers reduces the possibility that an individual would not be able to access reliable and affordable alternative voice service, it is imperative that these areas are accurately represented as part of the COLR relief process. To ensure the most robust set of data currently available, this bill directs the CPUC to adopt a map that includes data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to implementation of the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program[2] or from the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) National Broadband Map[3]. The BEAD program map and the FCC National Broadband Map were objectively the most robust and comprehensive mapping effort ever undertaken by the state and federal government. The maps include layers that demonstrate fixed and mobile broadband service availability by broadband serviceable location address.
In well-served areas, it likely that the availability of wireless services will be heavily relied on to meet the minimum requirements of the definition, as it is not uncommon that a household would only have one alternative wireline option available, often from a cable company. Given that the availability of wireless coverage may be spotty in some parts of the state, especially at the peripheries of wireless coverage areas, there exists a need to ensure all the available alternatives are actually available. Towards that end, this version of the bill continues to require the CPUC to adopt a map of well-served areas that will then serve as the basis for where a telephone corporation can seek amended status. In other words, if an area is not represented on this map, even if there are some alternatives, then it is not well-served as established by this bill and in turn would not be eligible for amended status. This mapping requirement will offer additional discretion to the CPUC in the public’s interest, to ensure everyone in a well-served area is truly well-served.
Despite the additional assurance that such a map can provide, a number of the opponents of this bill point out that the BEAD map and the National Broadband Map are imperfect nonetheless. For example, the Public Advocates Office of the CPUC points out that the national broadband map has had over 2 million errors discovered across the nation. Additionally, the CPUC ran a separate challenge process for the state BEAD map and accepted their own challenges. Although the number of errors addressed on the map may cast doubt on their reliability or usefulness, on the other hand, that robust challenge process is also exactly why these maps are the most accurate broadband maps ever produced. Furthermore, by requiring the CPUC to utilize these maps as the starting point for a well-served map, it ensures there will be yet another opportunity for the public and stakeholders to ensure the accuracy of these previously vetted maps. The alternative would seem to be starting from scratch, which is not exactly an efficient use of resources given the amount of effort and funding that went into producing the FCC National Broadband Map and the state BEAD map. Lastly, and importantly, after the maps are adopted on the front end the public will still maintain the right to challenge their well-served designation based on the challenge process on the back end. In a nutshell, although the maps are imperfect, there are multiple mechanisms in this bill to provide additional assurance about a household’s or census block’s designation as well-served.
The CPUC will not be required to adopt a map of no population and no customer areas because it is fairly obvious, based on census data, where there is a population.
- This bill imposes obligations on a telephone corporation seeking amended status. As was established in the previous section, there is an inherent risk in this bill to the public’s continued universal access to telephone service. However, that risk is not guaranteed to be realized, and this bill includes robust guardrails for challenges. Further, those risks ought to be considered alongside the potential public benefits that this bill may enable. For example, in order to receive an amended status as a carrier of last resort, a telephone corporation must meet various ongoing requirements after obtaining amended status. The commitments include demonstrating that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to a minimum number of residential units and year-over-year increase in fiber buildout. Other commitment include offering an affordable broadband plan, benefits for small business customers, funding for public safety technology upgrades, funding for community-based digital literacy resources, and workforce development. This bill would also establish the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant program, to be administered by the CPUC and funded by donations. This bill also provides that the CPUC may seek a remedy if a provider fails to meet their commitments.
Among the most robust requirements of this bill that a telephone corporation will be required to follow is a commitment to make accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to at least three times the number of residential units in the state as the number of basic exchange customers the telephone corporation had as of the effective date of its first amended status request. Moreover, this bill requires that half of that investment would be in areas of the state that are not well served. In effect, this provisions encourages investment in areas of the state that might otherwise not see investment.
- The public in affected areas would still have access to Lifeline under this bill. As has been established, the concept of a COLR exists to ensure universal access to telephone service consistent with federal and state law. While the most obvious element of universal access is merely ensuring that an individual is capable of utilizing the telephone network for their communications needs, another element is ensuring affordable access. Without a guarantee of affordable access, universal access cannot be achieved because cost would otherwise be a barrier to low-income residents. Thus, in order to advance the public policy goal of universal access to telephone service, COLR regulations require a carrier of last resort to participate in the Lifeline program. The Lifeline program offers subsidies to eligible low-income households to assist with affording the cost of basic telephone service. Historically, Lifeline service had been provided through landline telephones, but as technology advanced the program has also supported access to mobile telephone. In fact, based on today’s enrollment there are about 1.4 million Lifeline participants in the state, with only about 133,000 of those utilizing the benefit for wireline service.
To ensure continued access to affordable telephone service, the bill’s definition of well-served includes a requirement that at least one of the providers in a well-served areas is a Lifeline provider. This provision will ensure that any customer or member of the public in a well-served area will have access to Lifeline benefits, and therefore affordable telephone service. However, it should be noted that the Lifeline provider does not necessarily need to be a wireline provider. Therefore, it is possible that some customers who currently utilize their Lifeline benefit for wireline telephone service may be required to transition their benefit to a wireless plan. Nonetheless, they will retain access to an affordable voice service plan.
- Are COLR regulations technology-neutral? The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has asserted that its COLR rules are technology neutral, thus inferring that existing carriers of last resort may meet their COLR obligations through any technology. Taken a step further, this assertion implies that a COLR is not required to maintain a copper network, as is claimed by supporters. This is all technically an accurate statement, but in practice the answer is more complicated.
Under CPUC regulations, a COLR is required to offer what is referred to as “basic service” to any customer that requests it. Basic service must include several elements that are determined by the commission including: the ability to place and receive voice-grade calls over all distances, free access to 911 and enhanced-911 service, access to directory services, specified billing provisions, access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services, access to telephone relay services for disabled users, access to customer service information about Lifeline, one-time bill adjustments for certain charges, and access to operator services. Many of these elements are clearly necessary and basic services for consumers, while some may be more outdated or unnecessary given today’s consumer preferences and practices. Importantly to an evaluation of whether current COLR rules are technology neutral, it is absolutely possible to meet those basic service requirements through other technologies like wireless or fiber, and basic service does not require a copper connection.
However, in addition to these basic service elements, a basic service provider is also required to file and maintain tariffs, or schedules of rates, with the commission that include basic service rates, charges, terms and conditions. The tariffs are required to be filed through a Tier 2 advice letter that is subject to review and approval by CPUC staff. Herein lies the complication when evaluating whether the CPUC’s COLR rules are actually technology-neutral in practice. While it is true that a carrier of last resort could meet its COLR obligation through any technology, if it were to meet those obligations through alternatives technologies beyond copper (such as broadband) it would be subjecting those otherwise non-tariffed services to CPUC tariffing requirements. In effect then, the COLR’s alternative services would necessarily be regulated differently than their competitors merely because their status as a COLR. Therefore, in practice the CPUC’s COLR requirements are not as neutral in practice as may have been represented.
- Could the CPUC designate a new COLR for areas that have been granted amended status? Under the California Constitution and the Public Utilities Code, the CPUC has broad authority over telephone corporations and the authority to establish its own procedures to regulate those entities. Generally speaking and consistent with the law, the CPUC has near plenary power to impose certain requirements on telephone corporations, unless otherwise prohibited by law. While this bill is intended to establish a process to effectuate the relinquishment of COLR obligations in some targeted areas, there is concern among non-COLR providers that the CPUC may seek to reassign COLR obligations to other entities. While there is not a specific statute that would authorize the CPUC taking this action, it is not a far-fetched concern that the CPUC would utilize the full extent of its other constitutional and statutory authority to attempt to unilaterally designate a new COLR in amended status areas despite passage of this bill. For example, existing Commission rules currently require the CPUC to find a replacement COLR in areas that have been granted in relief. Under existing law, nothing would explicitly prohibit the CPUC from designating another entity or re-designating a telephone corporation that has been granted relief as a COLR in the future. Therefore, to prevent the CPUC from utilizing the breadth of its constitutional authority to undermine the intent of this bill, it is reasonable to explicitly prohibit the CPUC from designating a replacement COLR in areas that have been granted relief pursuant to this bill.
- The CPUC has an open rulemaking to consider changes to COLR. In June 2024, the CPUC initiated a new rulemaking to review and possibly update the rules for COLR. The rulemaking was initiated, in part, because the CPUC was required by its own precedent to deny a previous AT&T application requesting COLR relief on a technicality, not on its merits. That previous decisions adopted a process for COLR relief that required a replacement COLR be identified before the CPUC could grant relief. Relying on that past decision as rationale, the CPUC denied that application with prejudice and prohibited AT&T from submitting similar request until at least one year after a decision to close the new rulemaking that was just opened. Eight months after opening the rulemaking, the assigned Commissioner eventually issued a scoping ruling outlining the issues that would be considered in the rulemaking. Among those issues within the scope of the rulemaking include whether the CPUC should adopt revisions to its current process for COLR relief and under conditions a COLR should be allowed to withdraw. The rulemaking also has other issues within its scope, such as updating existing COLR rules and revising the definition of “basic service”. To the extent this bill would require the CPUC to adopt a process to effectuate COLR relief, it would answer some of the questions within the scope of the proceeding and require the CPUC to grant COLR relief as provided in this bill. The CPUC would retain the discretion to the design the process, consistent with his bill. Afterwards following adoption of the processes and the map required pursuant to this bill, the CPUC would be permitted to return to the other issues within the rulemaking such as updating the definition of “basic service” and other COLR requirements in areas where COLR obligations will persist indefinitely.
- Similar/related legislation.
- AB 2797 (McKinnor), 2024, was similar to the provisions of this bill. The bill was referred to the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
- AB 2395 (Low), 2016, would have established a process for a telephone corporation to withdraw legacy public switched telephone network services and transition to Internet Protocol (IP) enabled services and networks, beginning January 1, 2020. The bill was held in Assembly Appropriations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
101 Enterprises Foundation
African American Community Services Agency
Alameda County Latina Chamber of Commerce
American Indian Chamber of Commerce of California
Anaheim Chamber of Commerce
Apapa Solano County
Asian Pacific American Advocates
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific American Leadership Institute
Asian Pacific Islander American Vote (APIAVOTE)
At&t
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians
Black Business Association
Black Chamber of Orange County
Black Education Expo
Boss - Business of Student Success
Boys & Girls Clubs of Carson
Boys & Girls Clubs of Fresno County
Boys and Girls Club of Central Orange Coast
Boys and Girls Club of Kern County
Business Council San Joaquin County
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
Calasian Chamber of Commerce
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Indian Nations College
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
California Tennis Association for Underprivileged Youth
California Valley Miwok Tribe
California Valley Miwok Tribe Aka Sheep Ranch Rancheria
California-hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce
Carson Chamber of Commerce
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Cniga - California Nations Indian Gaming Association
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Tech Network
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Curry Senior Center
Digitallift
East Bay Leadership Council
El Camino Community College District
El Segundo Chamber of Commerce
Emac Construction
Empowerment (dess Perkins Foundation)
Enterprise Rancheria
Equality California
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Exp – the Opportunity Engine
Filipino American Chamber of Commerce of Solano County, INC.
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Haven Neighborhood Services
Hopland Band of Pomo Indians
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Jamul Indian Village
Jamul Indian Village of California
Janet Goeske Foundation
Japanese American Citizens League
Japanese American Citizens League (JACL)
Kern Economic Development Foundation
Kidstream Children's Museum
LA Jolla Band of Luiseno Indians
Latino Education and Advocacy Days (LEAD)
Lime Foundation
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Altos Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Mission
Maac Project
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Mission Bit
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Morongo Band of Mission Indians
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises INC. (MORE)
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Onegeneration
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber of Commerce
Pauma Band of Luiseno Indians
Pinoleville Pomo Nation
Reality Changers
Redding Rancheria
Rincon Band of Luiseno Indians
Rise San Diego
Robinson Rancheria Pomo Indians of California
Salef
San Diego County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Conservation and Service Corps
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Manuel Band of Mission Indians
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Small Business Diversity Network
Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Tejon Indian Tribe
The Arc California
The Arc of California
The Fresno Center
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations
Tulare Kings Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom - the Broadband Association
United Way Bay Area
Ventura Chamber of Commerce
Vermont-slauson Economic Development Corporation
Walking Shield
Weave
Opposition
#oaklandundivided
AARP
Alliance for a Better Community
Arts for LA
Beverly Hills; City of
Bridge the Digital Divide
Butte; County of
California Alliance for Digital Equity
California Community Foundation
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Federation of Labor Unions, Afl-cio
California Partnership to End Domestic Violence
California Public Policy Group
California State Association of Counties (CSAC)
Cdp Rural Caucus
Center for Accessible Technology
Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research (CLEAR)
City of Agoura Hills
City of Hidden Hills
Communications Workers of America Local 9410
Communications Workers of America Local 9510
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Communities in Schools of Los Angeles (CISLA)
Community Coalition of the Antelope Valley
Consejo De Federaciones Mexicanas (COFEM)
County of Alameda
County of Butte
County of Fresno
County of Humboldt
County of Imperial
County of Inyo
County of Kern
County of Mendocino
County of Monterey
County of Napa
County of Nevada
County of Santa Clara
County of Siskiyou
County of Solano
County of Sonoma
County of Yolo
County of Yuba
Destination Crenshaw
Digital Equity LA
Diversity in Leadership Institute
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Everyoneon
Families in Schools
Fiber-up My Neighborhood
Fresno Coalition for Digital Inclusion
Gpsn
Hack the Hood
Healing and Justice Center
Innovate Public Schools
Institute for Local Self-reliance
Insure the Uninsured Project
Jawhara Mcclinton
Jawharah Mcclinton
Kapor Center
Kings County Board of Supervisors
Las Virgenes-malibu Council of Governments
Latino Equality Alliance
Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities
Los Angeles Unified School District
Los Angeles Urban League
Luisa Calumpong, Broadband Manager, City of Oakland
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Media Alliance
Mono County Bos
Nextgen California
Orange County Labor Federation, Afl-cio
Our Voice: Communities for Quality Education
Pacoima Beautiful
Para Los Ninos
Parent Engagement Academy
Parent Institute for Quality Education
Puente Learning Center
Rural Bonny Doon Association
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors
San Joaquin; County of
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
Southeast Community Development Corporation
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Town of Hillsborough
Trio Plus
Unite-la
United Parents and Schools
Urban Counties of California (UCC)
Vision Y Compromiso
Oppose Unless Amended
Calbroadband
County of Santa Cruz
Fresno County Board of Supervisors
Public Advocates Office
Analysis Prepared by: Emilio Perez / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
In April 2025 the CPUC issued a proposed decision to implement service quality standards on wireline Voice over Internet-Protocol (VoIP) and mobile voice communications. ↑
CPUC BEAD Challenge Map. https://register.challenge.cpuc.ca.gov/register/bead/map ↑
Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map. https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/home ↑
Date of Hearing: May 21, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 470
Author:(McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:May 5, 2025
Policy Committee: | Communications and Conveyance | Vote: | 8 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill provides procedures by which a telephone corporation may end its status as a “carrier of last resort.”
Specifically, this bill, among many other things:
- Directs the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to approve a request by a telephone corporation to “amend its status” as a carrier of last resort (COLR) if either of the following is true:
- The area is “well served,” meaning (i) at least three different facilities-based service providers offer alternative voice basic service in the relevant area, and at least one of the service providers is a wireline provider, at least one of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice basic service, and at least one of the service providers participates in the lifeline telephone service program, as specified, and (ii) an alternative voice basic service shall be available to at least 99.9% of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as specified.
- The area for which the telephone corporation seeks the amend its COLR status is an area where the United States Census Bureau reports no population and where a telephone corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer address located within its telephone service territory.
- Provides numerous obligations on a telephone corporation that is requesting to amend its COLR status regarding notification to the public, affected customers and governmental agencies and service obligations to customers during the telephone company’s attempt to amend its COLR status and following its having amended its COLR status.
- Provides a process via which a customer who opposes a telephone corporation’s request to amend its COLR status may protest and seek third-party review of the telephone corporation’s request.
- Directs the CPUC, in an existing proceeding, on or before December 15, 2026, to adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible to be amended status areas.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill creates significant new analytical work for the CPUC (1) to adopt a map of well-served areas, (2) to review any advice letters submitted by an existing COLR requesting the CPUC’s permission to no longer be a COLR and (3), to ensure a COLR that has submitted an advice letter to CPUC is fulfilling its obligations, pursuant to this bill. Cost to the CPUC will depend, to some extent, on the number of advice letters the CPUC receives pursuant to this bill and the complexity of those letters. In any case, costs to the CPUC will be significant, even if it receives no advice letters from an entity seeking relief from its COLR obligations.
The CPUC estimates costs resulting from the mapping obligation to be approximately $200,000, one time, for a data analyst position and contracting and equipment costs of $172,000 in the first year and $57,000 annually thereafter (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account (PUCURA)).
In addition, the CPUC estimates it will need twelve new positions, at a cost of approximately $2.5 million (PUCURA) to review COLR advice letters and undertake consequent obligations required by bill. The CPUC did not explicitly tie its estimated number of positions needed to the number of COLR advice letters it expects to receive as a result of the authority provided by this bill.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VoIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world.
- COLR Obligation and the CPUC. According to the CPUC, a COLR is a telecommunications company that is required to offer basic telephone service to anyone who asks for it in a certain area — no matter where they live or what their income is.
State law, established in 1994, directs the CPUC to ensure universal telecommunications service includes “essential telecommunications services” that are “provided at affordable prices to all Californians regardless of linguistic, cultural, ethnic, physical, geographic, or income considerations.” To that end, in 1996, the CPUC established the COLR obligation. That is, the CPUC required that each of the incumbent Local Exchange Carriers (LECs, meaning, generally, a telephone company) be designated the COLR in their respective service areas until such time that another carrier or carriers are designated to be COLRs in those areas.
The CPUC reports that, today, there are 16 COLRs in California. AT&T is the biggest COLR, covering large parts of the state, and Frontier is the second biggest.
Telecommunications technology has changed dramatically since 1996. COLR obligations, however, have not.
In March of 2023, AT&T requested the CPUC to relive it of its COLR obligation in many areas of the state where “voice alternatives” offer voice service. AT&T argues that COLR obligation made sense during an era of monopolies, but makes no sense today, given the current marketplace, asserting that AT&T’s COLR customers have a number of alternatives for voice services, including voice-over-internet protocol (VoIP) service from cable companies and mobile voice service from other providers, making the COLR obligation unnecessary. AT&T also asserts its COLR responsibilities unfairly discriminate against AT&T because it has to compete with other voice service providers that are “unburdened by COLR requirements, are able to innovate and otherwise respond to market forces.”
Despite these arguments, the CPUC ruled against AT&T, “with prejudice.” The CPUC noted that, according the CPUC’s established rules, the CPUC may grant a COLR withdrawal application in one of two ways:
- Another carrier is identified and is willing to serve as a COLR.
- A reverse auction is held, the result of which another carrier comes forward and is willing (and able) to serve as a COLR.
Central to the CPUC’s reasoning was the following conclusion: the commission cannot grant an application to withdraw as a COLR if there is no replacement COLR. And the CPUC’s decision was highly critical of AT&T’s argument: “It is not clear why AT&T filed this Application, under existing rules, and then attempted to convince the Commission that it should ignore its rules, based on flawed and erroneous assertions regarding the law and regulatory policy.”
Nonetheless, the CPUC expressed its intent to revisit its COLR rules in a proceeding separate from the one in which it considered AT&T’s request. Last year, the CPUC began that proceeding.
This bill steps in front of the CPUC proceeding in that it establishes, in detail, considerations the CPUC is to rely on in determining COLR obligations and procedures a COLR is to follow in relinquishing its COLR obligations. AT&T contends this action is appropriate, given the CPUC decision, “with prejudice,” against AT&T, and describes this bill as a “carefully designed proposal to modernize California’s legacy communications regulations, while implementing robust consumer protections, improving public safety, and prioritizing affordability.” And a very long, diverse list of supporters agrees with AT&T.
A similarly long list of bill opponents disagrees. For example the Rural Counties Representatives of California and the California State Association of Counties together write:
This measure would dismantle essential public responsibilities and accelerate the erosion of reliable, affordable telephone service for all Californians. Rather than establishing a responsible transition plan from basic telephone service provided on an outdated network to a higher quality fiber-based service, AB 470 adds regulatory complexity while shielding telephone corporations from any accountability for providing essential utility services…the CPUC is currently engaged in a public, transparent, holistic review of COLR policies with a robust stakeholder process to alleviate rules without abandoning customers, especially those in areas where market forces alone do not guarantee quality, competitive service. The CPUC is a neutral, accountable state venue to fulfil California’s priorities of basic service while still ensuring equitable, universal access to modern, essential infrastructure. AB 470’s defective procedures for a telephone corporation to relinquish its COLR obligations could not possibly achieve the bill’s stated objective of regulatory forbearance.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Tasha Boerner, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 470 (
Author:McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:March 17, 2025
SUBJECT: Telephone corporations: carriers of last resort
SUMMARY: This bill would provide procedures for telephone corporations to terminate their carrier of last resort obligations only in specified areas that are well-served, as defined, and also in areas where the United States Census Bureau reports no population or in areas where telephone corporations provide no basic exchange service to any customer. This bill would require telephone corporations to fulfill specified conditions and meet certain notice requirements to be relieved of the carrier of last resort obligations.
Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes findings and declarations of the Legislature.
- Establishes that a telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort in areas with no population or where the telephone corporation providers no basic exchange service to any customer, when it fulfills specified obligations as specified.
- Establishes that a telephone corporation shall no longer be a carrier of last resort in well-served areas, when it fulfills specified obligations as specified.
- Defines “well-served” to mean at least three different facilities-based service providers, providers offer alternative voice service in the relevant area, and at least one of the service providers is a wireline provider and at least one of the service providers offers a comparatively priced alternative voice service. The alternative voice service shall be available to at least 99.9% of the broadband-serviceable locations in the area, as such broadband-serviceable locations are set forth in the most recent publicly available Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map showing fixed and wireless broadband coverage.
- Defines “alternative voice service” to mean a retail service made available through a technology or service arrangement by a provider that provides, as a stand-alone service or as part of a bundled service, all of the following
- Voice access interconnected with the public switched telephone network.
- Access to emergency 9-1-1 service and E-9-1-1 service in compliance with current state and federal laws and regulations.
- Compatibility with a backup power source.
- A billing option with monthly rates and without contract or early termination penalties.
- Access to the California Relay Service pursuant to Section 2881 for deaf or hearing-impaired persons or individuals with speech disabilities.
- Access to customer service for information about service termination, repair, and billing inquiries.
- Free access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services with no additional usage charges for such calls.
- Requires a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort to first publish its notice of intention one time in the nonlegal section of a newspaper of general circulation throughout the relevant areas and on any social media channels the company utilizes for marketing in those areas, as specified.
- Establishes a process for a residential consumer that may oppose an assertion by a telephone corporation that there is no population or no customer in area, or that an area is well-served, as specified. The process includes independent third-party review of the claim by a third-party selected by the CPUC and paid for by the telephone corporation.
- Establishes specific requirements for a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in an area with no population or where the corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer. The requirements include a notice to specified entities.
- Establishes that amended status as a carrier of last resort in an area with no population or where the corporation provides no basic exchange service to any customer shall be effective 30 days from the date of the notice.
- Requires a telephone corporation that seeks to amend its status as a carrier of last resort in well-served areas shall commit to certain obligations, as specified, and provide notice to customers in that area, as specified.
- Establishes that a telephone corporation’s amended status as a carrier of last resort shall be effective 30 days from the final customer notice or 30 days from the date of the commitment letter, whichever is later.
- Provides that a customer in a well-served area has certain rights to choose an alternative voice service provider, or remain on their basic exchange service for a period of 12 months.
- Establishes an obligation, for a period of 10 years, for a telephone corporations that has received amended status to provide alternative voice service to any residential consumer that is unable to obtain alternative voice service for another provider, as specified.
- Establishes that this bill does not confer regulatory authority to the commission over alternative voice services.
- Requires the CPUC, as part of an existing proceeding, to determine a transition plan that shall be followed for areas that are not well-served or have no population or no customers.
- Establishes the The Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant fund, subject to continuous appropriation without regard to fiscal year. Specified that the fund may accept donations from nongovernmental entities.
- Specifies that this bill does not apply to intrastate legacy time-division multiplexing services used to directly connect land mobile radio systems used for public safety.
- Specifies that this bill does not apply to any inhabited island that is not part of the mainland area of the state and is not accessible by bridge or road, if any part of the island is well served.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes that telephone corporations are public utilities subject to control by the Legislature. (California Constitution Article XI § 3)
- Authorizes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to, among other things, establish rules for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution Article XI § 6)
- Defines "telephone corporation" to include every corporation or person owning, controlling, operating, or managing any telephone line for compensation within this state. (Public Utilities Code Section 234)
- Defines "service area" for purposes of the operations of a telephone corporation, to mean a local access and transport area as defined and approved by the United States District Court for the District of Columbia circuit in the case of the United States v. Western Electric Co., Inc., and American Telephone and Telegraph Co., CA 82-0192, April 20, and July 8, 1983, and in a Memorandum and Order of August 5, 1983. (Public Utilities Code Section 230.3)
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that public utilities furnish and maintain such adequate, efficient, just and reasonable service, instrumentalities, equipment, and facilities as are necessary to promote the safety, health, comfort, and convenience of its patrons, employees, and the public. (Public Utilities Code § 701)
- Requires a telephone corporation, before it exits the business of providing interexchange services to all of its customers or to an entire class of its customers, to provide those affected customers with a written notice at least 30 days prior to the proposed transfer of those customers to another telephone corporation, as specified. (Public Utilities Code § 2889.3)
- Requires the CPUC to require telephone corporations to provide customer service to telecommunication customers that includes, but is not limited to, sufficient information upon which to make informed choices among telecommunications services and providers, ability to access a live operator by dialing “0”, reasonable statewide service quality standards, and information concerning the regulatory process. (Public Utilities Code § 2896)
- Defines “telecommunications service” to mean voice communication provided by a telephone corporation, voice communication provided by a provider of satellite telephone service, voice communication provided by a provider of mobile telephone service, and voice communication provided by a commercially available facilities-based provider of voice communication services utilizing Voice over Inter Protocol (VoIP). (Public Utilities Code § 2892.1)
- Establishes the California High Cost Funds (CHCF) A, CHCF B, Universal Lifeline Telephone Service Trust, the Deaf and Disabled Telecommunications Program, and the California TeleConnect Fund. (Public Utilities Code Sections 270 to 281)
- Requires the CPUC to require every telephone corporation providing telephone service within a service area to file a schedule of rates and charges providing a class of lifeline telephone service. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Requires every telephone corporation providing service within a service area to inform all eligible subscribers of the availability of lifeline telephone service, and how they may qualify for and obtain service, and shall accept applications for lifeline telephone service according to procedures specified by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code Section 876)
- Authorizes the CPUC to annually determine user fees to be paid by every electrical, gas, telephone, telegraph, water, sewer system, and heat corporation and every other public utility providing service directly to customers or subscribers and subject to the jurisdiction of the commission, as specified. (Public Utilities Code Sections 431 to 435)
- Declares that the policies for telecommunications in California are as follows:
- To continue our universal service commitment by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications services to all Californians.
- To focus efforts on providing educational institutions, health care institutions, community-based organizations, and governmental institutions with access to advanced telecommunications services in recognition of their economic and societal impact.
- To encourage the development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.
- To assist in bridging the "digital divide" by encouraging expanded access to state-of-the-art technologies for rural, inner-city, low-income, and disabled Californians.
- To promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits that will result from the rapid implementation of advanced information and communications technologies by adequate long-term investment in the necessary infrastructure.
- To promote lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.
- To remove the barriers to open and competitive markets and promote fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.
- To encourage fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (Public Utilities Code Section 709)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has been tagged fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Intent of bill. The intent of this bill is to encourage the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability, such as high-speed broadband, by establishing a process for regulatory forbearance of legal obligations on telephone corporations that are designated as a carriers of last resort. In doing so, the author intent is to promote competition in the market and encourage infrastructure investment, while balancing those benefits with ensuring continued universal access to telecommunications service. According to the author: “AB 470 will incentivize investment in more advanced and affordable communications for all Californians. Modern network services are more innovative, reliable, fast and generally meet the twenty-first-century needs of Californians. In addition to superior services and reliability, the cost of VoIP and wireless services have been steadily decreasing for the past two decades, while during the same period, copper landline services have drastically increased in cost. With affordable modern internet-based and wireless-based phone services, consumers benefit from greater affordability and additional features that will keep all Californians connected to each other and people around the world.”
- What is a Carrier of Last Resort (COLR)? Under state and federal laws, an entity that owns, operates, or manages a telephone line for compensation is a public utility, specifically a telephone corporation. A carrier of last resort (COLR) is a designated telephone corporation that has a legal obligation to provide access to basic telephone service to any household in its service territory who requests it. In a competitive market environment that exists across much of the state today, where consumers have multiple options to meet their voice communications needs, the COLR is literally the last-resort if no other carrier is willing or able to offer service. Across the state, every census block has a specified carrier that is designated as the COLR by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), even in areas where there may be multiple providers offering telephone service. In areas where there are multiple providers in the market, it is typically only one carrier that is designated to hold the legal obligations of the COLR. The legal obligations placed on a COLR have been a tenant of universal service for decades, to ensure that everyone has guaranteed access to safe, reliable, and affordable telephone service. According to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), there are 16 COLR-designated companies across California with distinct service territories. AT&T is the designated COLR in many parts of the State and is the largest COLR in California; Frontier is the second largest COLR in the State.
For much of the 20th century a single company, the American Telephone & Telegraph (now AT&T), owned and operated essentially all of the telephone infrastructure in the country as a regulated monopoly granted by government. Along with that market power, utility regulatory bodies such as the CPUC were vested with the authority to regulate the rates of telephone service to ensure just and reasonable prices for customers, control against unreasonable profits, and enforce the obligations to serve all customers in a discriminatory manner. In that market context, it was clearly not unreasonable to require that the only telephone carrier available in the marketplace would be expected to serve all the households in its service territory, rural and urban, as a carrier of last resort. However, this scheme began to change in the 1980’s with the introduction of competition into the telephone market. In 1982, the United State Department of Justice succeeded in its antitrust litigation against AT&T, resulting in a breakup of the company into smaller regional entities. The breakup of AT&T also paved the way for further innovation of telecommunications and other competitors to enter the telephone services market. For example, mobile telephone service first began to become commercially available in the 1980s. Subsequently, Congress passed the Telecommunications Act of 1996, which further incentivized competition in telecommunications service market as a means to reduce prices, and increase quality and innovation. Despite the proliferation of competition in the telecommunications marketplace over decades, COLR requirements have remained as a means to ensure there is a guaranteed provider of basic telephone service regardless of the status of the market. The perspective of this bill is that such COLR requirements are no longer required, and may actually hinder further investment and competition in the market. Accordingly, this bill proposes a process for automatically forbearing telephone corporations of their COLR obligations in some areas that meet the criteria established by this bill.
- In some areas consumer preferences have shifted beyond landline voice communications. Just as the preferred type of telecommunications technologies transitioned at the turn of the 20th century from telegraph to telephone, consumers today are once again increasingly transitioning towards more modern telecommunications services such as mobile telephone and broadband internet service when those options are available. For example, consider several data points from the Center for Disease Control (CDC) National Center of Health Statistics, which has measured the availability of telephone service in households for decades. In 1999 the CDC estimated that about 95% of California households had a household telephone, while in 2007 nationwide figures showed that only about 16% of households relied on wireless phone service only. Data from 2023 show that 76% of adults lived in households that did not have landline telephone but did have at least one wireless telephone, a stark difference since the late 90s and early 2000s. Beyond telephone service, data from the California Statewide Digital Equity Survey published in 2023 show that 91% of households also subscribe to high-speed internet access at home. In summary, most consumers today have more options for telecommunications service, from more providers utilizing different types of technologies, than ever before. The perspective of this bill is that, because of competition, the regulatory requirements for one company to hold the entire legal obligation to serve an area is no longer necessary and is a barrier to investment and competition. However, the public benefits of competition have not been realized equally across the state.
Whereas in the monopoly era, it was essentially one company that had an obligation to provide telephone service to households as the COLR and only carrier; today’s market is different. There is no carrier of last resort for mobile telephone service or broadband internet access. In fact, under state or federal law broadband internet service providers are not a public utilities or common carriers at all. Even mobile telephone providers, although they are common carriers, are not subject to the same requirements as a COLR. Unlike the monopoly era, regulators are not empowered to require a mobile telephone or broadband internet provider to expand their network to unserved households or meet baseline quality of service requirements[1]. As a result, in areas where there is little market incentive for providers to enter, households remain unserved and underserved by more advanced telecommunications technologies or wireless reception can be spotty. The areas of the state which have not benefited from competition in the market generally are disproportionately rural and lower-income, and may never be served by advanced technologies regardless of COLR or without government intervention. The dichotomy, between well-served areas with robust competition for telecommunications services, and less well-served areas where the market is not meeting consumers’ needs for advanced communications services like broadband internet access illustrates a bright line. This bill is drafted in a manner that attempts to respect that bright lines, by establishing a process for relinquishment only in those areas that are well-served and in areas where there is no population or no customers. Areas that do not fall into those categories would be subject to a process that would be established by the commission at a date in the future.
- Are COLR regulations technology-neutral? The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has asserted that its COLR rules are technology neutral, thus inferring that existing carriers of last resort may meet their COLR obligations through any technology. Taken a step further, this assertion implies that a COLR is not required to maintain a copper network, as is claimed by supporters. This is all technically an accurate statement, but in practice the answer is more complicated.
Under CPUC regulations, a COLR is required to offer what is referred to as “basic service” to any customer that requests it. Basic service must include several elements that are determined by the commission including: the ability to place and receive voice-grade calls over all distances, free access to 911 and enhanced-911 service, access to directory services, specified billing provisions, access to 800 and 8YY toll-free services, access to telephone relay services for disabled users, access to customer service information about Lifeline, one-time bill adjustments for certain charges, and access to operator services. Many of these element are clearly necessary and basic services for consumers, while some may be more outdated or unnecessary given today’s consumer preferences and practices. Importantly to an evaluation of whether current COLR rules are technology neutral, it is absolutely possible to meet those basic service requirements through other technologies like wireless or fiber, and basic service does not require a copper connection.
However, in addition to these basic service elements, a basic service provider is also required to file and maintain tariffs, or schedules of rates, with the commission that include basic service rates, charges, terms and conditions. The tariffs are required to be filed through a Tier 2 advice letter that is subject to review and approval by CPUC staff. Herein lies the complication when evaluating whether the CPUC’s COLR rules are actually technology-neutral in practice. While it is true that a carrier of last resort could meet its COLR obligation through any technology, if it were to meet those obligations through alternatives technologies beyond copper (such as broadband) it would be subjecting those otherwise non-tariffed services to CPUC tariffing requirements. In effect then, the COLR’s alternative services would necessarily be regulated differently than their competitors merely because their status as a COLR. Therefore, in practice the CPUC’s COLR requirements are not as neutral in practice as may have been represented.
- The bill does not grant blanket COLR relinquishment across the state. Many of the organizations opposed to this bill have expressed concerns about the impact of this bill for all Californians, and especially those in rural communities or where reliable access to telephone service has not been consistently available except through the carrier of last resort. Certainly those areas are worthy of special consideration, and this bill does distinguish among various areas of the state. In general, this bill’s provisions apply to three separate buckets, or groups, of areas: well-served areas, areas with no population or where the telephone corporation has no customers on basic exchange service, and what will be referred to as “other” areas.
This bill only proposes to establish a specific process for relinquishment of COLR obligations in the first two buckets, which are those areas that are well-served or where there are no population or no customers. Well-served areas, as defined by this bill, are areas where there are at least three other alternative voice service providers, at least one of which must be a wireline provider. In well-served areas, the public benefits from various choices of providers and many have willingly chosen to subscribe to services from carriers that are not carriers of last resort. Still, it is undeniable that relinquishing the obligation of a carrier of last resort to serve all customers poses an inherent risk to the public’s universal access to telephone service. Nonetheless, short of a market collapse, it is likely that residents of well-served areas will continue to have access to reliable voice communication services even despite relinquishment of COLR. This is evidenced by the fact that most consumers in well-served areas purchase services other than COLR basic service, such as broadband, VoIP, or mobile wireless telephone service. Additionally, in recent history large providers have rarely gone out of business, although there has been market consolidation. Notably, the CPUC is required to approve mergers of telecommunications providers and this bill does not change that.
Beyond well-served areas, this bill establishes procedures for amended status in no population or no customer areas. In these areas, there is obviously a smaller risk for public impact because of the nature of those areas having no population. However, to the extent that those areas may be developed in the future, there is a risk that no provider would be willing to serve new developments. Again, here the actual risk of a stranded customer is unlikely because a local government would have to approve new development and likely would know the area is not covered by COLR before doing so. Even so, for a period of 10 years, this bill would require a telephone corporation that has been granted amended status as carrier of last resort to be required to offer alternative voice service if there are truly no other providers.
For the other areas, which are necessarily not well served by alternative providers, this bill proposes that the CPUC should determine a transition plan that shall be followed before a telephone corporation may amend its status as a carrier of last resort in those areas. Lastly, this bill also exempts some specific areas and facilities from this bill, including Catalina Island.
- This bill imposes obligations on a telephone corporation seeking amended status. As was established in the previous section, there is an inherent risk in this bill to the public’s continued universal access to telephone service. However, that risk is not guaranteed to be realized, and this bill includes guardrails. Further, those risks ought to be considered alongside the potential public benefits that this bill may enable. For example, in order to receive an amended status as a carrier of last resort, a telephone corporation must make various commitments through a commitment letter. The commitments include demonstrating that it has made accessible its advanced fiber optics buildout to a minimum number of residential units and year-over-year increase in fiber buildout. Other commitment include offering an affordable broadband plan, benefits for small business customers, funding for public safety technology upgrades, funding for community-based digital literacy resources, and workforce development. This bill would also establish the Public Safety Agency Technology Upgrade Grant program, to be administered by the CPUC and funded by donations. While this bill does require the commitment letter is signed by an offer of the corporation, the committee may wish to ensure that the commitments are enforceable through remedies sought by the CPUC.
- Changes to COLR would likely impact the availability of Lifeline telephone service. As has been established, the concept of a COLR exists to ensure universal access to telephone service consistent with federal and state law. While the most obvious element of universal access is merely ensuring that an individual is capable of utilizing the telephone network for their communications needs, another element is ensuring affordable access. Without a guarantee of affordable access, universal access cannot be achieved because cost would otherwise be a barrier to low-income residents. Thus, in order to advance the public policy goal of universal access to telephone service, COLR regulations require a carrier of last resort to participate in the Lifeline program. The Lifeline program offers subsidies to eligible low-income households to assist with affording the cost of basic telephone service. Historically, Lifeline service had been provided through landline telephones, but as technology advanced the program has also supported access to mobile telephone. In fact, based on today’s enrollment there are about 1.4 million Lifeline participants in the state, with only about 133,000 of those utilizing the benefit for wireline service.
While the wireline population of Lifeline participants may be small, this bill would likely have a direct impact on their service. Particularly, if a carrier of resort is granted amended status as proposed by this bill, a low-income consumer may lose access to their only wireline Lifeline option. Conceivably some of these wireline participants could migrate to wireless Lifeline service, but it would be a forced transition. Further, this bill’s definition of well-served does not ensure there is a wireless Lifeline option available. The committee may wish to consider amendments to ensure the public in well-served areas maintain access to Lifeline.
- The bill would grant automatic COLR relinquishment with little oversight. While this bill does establish a public notification process that must be followed in order for a telephone corporation to gain relinquishment of their COLR obligations, the legal relief is otherwise automatic. For example, in areas where there is no population or a telephone corporation has no basic exchange service customers, a telephone corporation would automatically be granted relief after sending a notice to specified entities. Those entities - which include the Governor, the Legislature, local elected officials, and the commission - are not provided with any authority to question the accuracy of the notice. In effect, the public or regulators would have little or no legal basis to pause or deny relinquishment even if there are irregularities or disputes as to whether an area is eligible for amended status under this bill. The potential impact of this section poses a stark risk to the public. To minimize potential negative risks to the public, the committee may wish to amend this bill to provide a role to the CPUC in administering the approval of requests for relinquishment of COLR obligations, with sufficient guardrails to ensure timely and efficient processing of those requests.
- Could the CPUC designate a new COLR for areas that have been granted amended status? Under the California Constitution and the Public Utilities Code, the CPUC has broad authority over telephone corporations and the authority to establish its own procedures to regulate those entities. Generally speaking and consistent with the law, the CPUC has near plenary power to impose certain requirements on telephone corporations, unless otherwise prohibited by law. While this bill is intended to establish a process to effectuate the relinquishment of COLR obligations in some targeted areas, there is concern among non-COLR telephone corporations that the CPUC may still seek to reassign COLR obligations to other entities. While little legal basis has been provided to support the claim, it is not a far-fetched concern that the CPUC would utilize the full extent of its other constitutional and statutory authority to attempt to unilaterally designate a new COLR in amended status areas. Nonetheless, addressing this concern at this stage may be premature given the lack of further legal analysis. Moving forward, the author may wish to consider whether placing constraints on the CPUC’s ability to take such an action ought to be limited or prohibited.
- Similar/related legislation.
- AB 2797 (McKinnor), 2024, was similar to the provisions of this bill. The bill was referred to the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
- AB 2395 (Low), 2016, would have established a process for a telephone corporation to withdraw legacy public switched telephone network services and transition to Internet Protocol (IP) enabled services and networks, beginning January 1, 2020. The bill was held in Assembly Appropriations.
- Committee Amendments.
Section 2878 – Definitions:
- Revise “alternative voice service” to “alternative voice basic service”
- Revise “amended status” to reflect that the area must be granted relief.
- Revise “amended status area” to reflect that area must be granted relief.
- Define “commitment letter” to mean an affidavit signed by an officer of the telephone corporation
- Define “public safety agency technology upgrade grant” to mean a grant for law enforcement agencies, as defined under Penal Code Section 13670(1), for new technologies or upgrades to existing copper-based systems to transition to modern communication systems.
- Define “small business security and alarm system technology migration assistance” to mean a voucher provided to eligible small business customers for costs associated with transitioning alarm system services. Vouchers shall be administered by the company and participation in the program reported annually to the commission.
Section 2878.1 – Regulatory Process and Well-Served Map
- Require a Tier 1 Advice Letter subject to approval by the CPUC for COLR relinquishment in no population and no customer areas.
- Change “or” to “and” for no-population/no-customer areas.
- Require a Tier 2 Advice Letter subject to approval by the CPUC for COLR relinquishment in well-served areas.
- Require the CPUC by December 15, 2026 to adopt a map designating well-served areas that are eligible for amended status pursuant to this bill. Specify that the maps adopted by the CPUC shall reflect data from the wireless coverage maps adopted pursuant to Rulemaking 23-02-016 or the Federal Communications Commission National Broadband Map, whichever is available for use to complete the map designating areas that are eligible for amended status by December 15, 2026.
- Specify that an area shall be eligible for amended status if it well-served or it is an area with no population and no customers.
- Require the CPUC to approve a request for amended status in accordance with this bill.
- Other minor and conforming technical changes.
Section 2878.2 – Advice Letter Process and Public Notices
- Require a Tier 1 Advice Letter to be filed with the commission to seek approval by the commission for amended status in no population and no customer area.
- Require a Tier 2 Advice Letter to be filed with the CPUC to seek approval by the commission for amended status in well-served areas.
- Require that notwithstanding any existing commission rule or decision, the commission shall approve an advice letter if the telephone corporation meets the requirements set forth this in this bill.
- Require the CPUC to require public notices, as provided in this bill, before approving an advice letter and prohibit the CPUC from imposing additional notice requirements.
- Specify that the notice may also be based on a map adopted by the Commission pursuant to Section 2871.1.
- Strike the requirement that a consumer opposition request must be in writing.
- Authorize the commission to accept opposition requests from consumers.
- Specify that the independent third-party review shall evaluate the accuracy of a customer’s claim, not the merits of their claim.
- Specify that a claim is accurate if there is a preponderance of evidence that an area is not well-served, or does not have no-population/no-customers.
- Specify that a consumer shall be given the opportunity to submit evidence demonstrating that an area is not eligible for amended status.
- Other minor and conforming technical changes.
Section 2878.3 – Requirements for No Population and No Customer Areas
- “Or” to “and” for no population and no customer areas.
- Specify that the telephone corporation may use the national broadband map, or a map adopted by the Commission pursuant to Section 2871.1 for the customer notice.
- Strike the declaration that amended status shall be effective 30 days from the date of the notice, and instead require the amended status to be effective upon approval by the commission of the Tier 1 Advice Letter.
- Other minor and confirming technical changes.
Section 2878.4 – Requirement for Well-Served Areas
- Strike the declaration that amended status shall be effective in well served areas 30 days from the third notice, and instead specify that relief effective upon approval by the commission of a Tier 2 advice letter.
- Require that the telephone corporation must demonstrate deployment in unserved and underserved areas.
- Specify that the annual report submitted pursuant to this section shall be subject to Public Utilities Code 583.
- Revise the requirement to offer an affordable broadband plan, to instead require a discounted broadband plan.
- Require a commitment to engage in fair labor practices and workforce training for employees that may be impacted by carrier of last resort relief.
- Strike the requirement that a telephone corporation shall file a Tier 1 Advice letter and the letter shall be effective on the date filed that reflects the amended status area; this is a confirming change.
- Authorize the CPUC to seek a remedy, after notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, if the telephone corporation fails to meet any obligation in the commitment letter.
- Other minor and conforming technical changes.
Section 2878.5 – Options for Existing Customers in Well-Served Areas
- Strike the reference to 90-day period before effective date of amended status.
- Strike the requirement that a request to the telephone corporation must be written.
- Authorize a customer to make a request directly to the commission.
- Require the independent third-party review to be based on a preponderance of evidence.
Section 2878.6 – Obligations after Amended Status is Granted
- Specify that the request for service can be made to the commission and does not need to be in writing.
- Require the commission to determine if voice service is available, not an independent third party reviewer.
- Require the CPUC to determine that no alternative voice basic service is available.
- Strike other references to process for the independent third party verifier.
- Strike the declaration that a telephone corporation shall be relieved of this section if an independent third party reviewer determines there is alternative voice service available.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
101 Enterprises Foundation
African American Community Services Agency
Alameda County Latina Chamber of Commerce
American Indian Chamber of Commerce of California
Anaheim Chamber of Commerce
Apapa Solano County
Asian Pacific American Advocates
Asian Pacific American Community Center
Asian Pacific American Leadership Institute
Asian Pacific Islander American Vote (APIAVOTE)
At&t
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Big Valley Band of Pomo Indians
Black Business Association
Black Chamber of Orange County
Black Education Expo
Boss - Business of Student Success
Boys & Girls Clubs of Carson
Boys & Girls Clubs of Fresno County
Boys and Girls Club of Central Orange Coast
Boys and Girls Club of Kern County
Business Council San Joaquin County
CA League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
Calasian Chamber of Commerce
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Indian Nations College
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
California Tennis Association for Underprivileged Youth
California Valley Miwok Tribe Aka Sheep Ranch Rancheria
California-hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
Carlsbad Chamber of Commerce
Carson Chamber of Commerce
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Tech Network
Concerned Black Men of Los Angeles
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Curry Senior Center
East Bay Leadership Council
El Camino Community College District
El Segundo Chamber of Commerce
Emac Construction
Empowerment (dess Perkins Foundation)
Enterprise Rancheria
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Exp – the Opportunity Engine
Filipino American Chamber of Commerce of Solano County, INC.
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Haven Neighborhood Services
Hopland Band of Pomo Indians
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Jamul Indian Village
Janet Goeske Foundation
Japanese American Citizens League
Kern Economic Development Foundation
Kidstream Children's Museum
LA Jolla Band of Luiseno Indians
Latino Education and Advocacy Days (LEAD)
Lime Foundation
Los Altos Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Mission
Maac Project
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Mission Bit
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Morongo Band of Mission Indians
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises INC. (MORE)
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Onegeneration
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Palos Verdes Peninsula Chamber of Commerce
Pauma Band of Luiseno Indians
Pinoleville Pomo Nation
Reality Changers
Redding Rancheria
Rincon Band of Luiseno Indians
Rise San Diego
Salef
San Diego County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Conservation and Service Corps
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Manuel Band of Mission Indians
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Small Business Diversity Network
Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Tejon Indian Tribe
The Arc of California
The Fresno Center
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations
Tulare Kings Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom - the Broadband Association
United Way Bay Area
Ventura Chamber of Commerce
Vermont-slauson Economic Development Corporation
Walking Shield
Opposition
#oaklandundivided
AARP
Alliance for a Better Community
Arts for LA
Bridge the Digital Divide
Butte; County of
Calbroadband
California Alliance for Digital Equity
California Community Foundation
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Public Policy Group
California State Association of Counties (CSAC)
Center for Accessible Technology
Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research (CLEAR)
City of Agoura Hills
City of Hidden Hills
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Communities in Schools of Los Angeles (CISLA)
Community Coalition of the Antelope Valley
Consejo De Federaciones Mexicanas (COFEM)
County of Butte
County of Fresno
County of Humboldt
County of Inyo
County of Kern
County of Mendocino
County of Monterey
County of Napa
County of Nevada
County of Santa Clara
County of Santa Cruz
County of Siskiyou
County of Solano
County of Sonoma
County of Yolo
County of Yuba
Destination Crenshaw
Digital Equity LA
Diversity in Leadership Institute
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Everyoneon
Families in Schools
Fresno Coalition for Digital Inclusion
Gpsn
Hack the Hood
Healing and Justice Center
Innovate Public Schools
Institute for Local Self-reliance
Insure the Uninsured Project
Jawhara Mcclinton
Kapor Center
Las Virgenes-malibu Council of Governments
Latino Equality Alliance
Los Angeles Urban League
Luisa Calumpong, Broadband Manager, City of Oakland
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Media Alliance
Mono County Bos
Nextgen California
Our Voice: Communities for Quality Education
Pacoima Beautiful
Para Los Ninos
Parent Engagement Academy
Parent Institute for Quality Education
Puente Learning Center
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors
San Joaquin; County of
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
Southeast Community Development Corporation
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Town of Hillsborough
Trio Plus
Unite-la
United Parents and Schools
Urban Counties of California (UCC)
Vision Y Compromiso
Analysis Prepared by: Emilio Perez / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
In April 2025 the CPUC issued a proposed decision to implement service quality standards on wireline Voice over Internet-Protocol (VoIP) and mobile voice communications. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):