AB 712: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2025-10-10
Current Status:
Passed
(2025-10-10: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 496, Statutes of 2025.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would extend any period of limitation for actions under any state law for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would extend any period of limitation for actions under any state law for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would extend any period of limitation for actions under any state law for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law against a public agency, as applied to the applicants housing development project, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce a housing reform law against a public agency, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law describes various reforms and incentives enacted by the Legislature to facilitate and expedite the construction of affordable housing. Existing law within the Planning and Zoning Law, in certain civil actions or proceedings against a public entity that has issued specified approvals for a housing development, authorizes a court to award all reasonably incurred costs of suit to a prevailing public entity or nonprofit housing corporation that is a real party in interest and the permit applicant of the low- or moderate-income housing if the court makes specified findings.
This bill, where the applicant for a housing development is a prevailing party in an action brought by the applicant to enforce a housing reform law against a public agency, would entitle an applicant for a housing development project to reasonable attorneys fees and costs and would require a court to impose fines on a local agency, as specified. The bill would prohibit a public agency from requiring the applicant to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any action alleging the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protection provide by a housing reform law. The bill would define housing reform law as a law that establishes or facilitates protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects or imposes limitations on a public agency for the benefit of housing development projects.
Existing law, the Planning and Zoning Law, requires the legislative body of each county and city to adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the county or city and requires that the plan include, among other mandatory elements, a housing element.Existing law states legislative findings and declarations regarding the need for affordable housing and the need to encourage development of new housing.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.Existing law, the Planning and Zoning Law, requires the legislative body of each county and city to adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the county or city and requires that the plan include, among other mandatory elements, a housing element.
Existing law states legislative findings and declarations regarding the need for affordable housing and the need to encourage development of new housing.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)(I)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of a specific housing reform law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall, consistent with subclause (II), impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5, unless the housing development projects consists of four or fewer units, in which case, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation.
(II)The court shall not impose the fine described in subclause (I) unless, after the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development sends the written communication to the local agency, the applicant provides written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action. The notice shall identify the factual elements of the dispute and the legal theory forming the basis for the allegation that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction violated the housing reform law. The notice shall be provided to the local agency at least 60 days before commencement of the action.
(III)For any action commenced or intended to be commenced under this section, any period of limitation for actions under any California law shall be extended for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice, pursuant to subclause (II), to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action.
(ii)(I)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in clause (i) multiplied by a factor of five.
(II)For the purpose of imposing a fine under subclause (I), any subsequent violation of the same housing reform law shall be considered to have occurred within the same planning period if the local agency does not have a housing element considered to be in substantial compliance, as described in Section 65585.03.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(C)Nothing in this subdivision limits the application of Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that section.
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.
(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule described in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (e) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)(I)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of a specific housing reform law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall, consistent with subclause (II), impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5, unless the housing development projects consists of four or fewer units, in which case, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation.
(II)The court shall not impose the fine described in subclause (I) unless, after the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development sends the written communication to the local agency, the applicant provides written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action. The notice shall identify the factual elements of the dispute and the legal theory forming the basis for the allegation that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction violated the housing reform law. The notice shall be provided to the local agency at least 60 days before commencement of the action.
(III)For any action commenced or intended to be commenced under this section, any period of limitation for actions under any California law shall be extended for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice, pursuant to subclause (II), to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action.
(ii)(I)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in clause (i) multiplied by a factor of five.
(II)For the purpose of imposing a fine under subclause (I), any subsequent violation of the same housing reform law shall be considered to have occurred within the same planning period if the local agency does not have a housing element considered to be in substantial compliance, as described in Section 65585.03.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(C)Nothing in this subdivision limits the application of Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that section.
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.
(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule described in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (e) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated the rights established by housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of the applicants rights established by housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicants housing development project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)(I)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of a specific housing reform law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall shall, consistent with subclause (II), impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5, unless the housing development projects consists of four or fewer units, in which case, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation.
(II)The court shall not impose the fine described in subclause (I) unless, after the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development sends the written communication to the local agency, the applicant provides written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action. The notice shall identify the factual elements of the dispute and the legal theory forming the basis for the allegation that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction violated the housing reform law. The notice shall be provided to the local agency at least 60 days before commencement of the action.
(III)For any action commenced or intended to be commenced under this section, any period of limitation for actions under any California law shall be extended for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice, pursuant to subclause (II), to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action.
(ii)(I)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute housing reform law on which the an applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in clause (i) multiplied by a factor of five.
(II)For the purpose of imposing a fine under subclause (I), any subsequent violation of the same housing reform law shall be considered to have occurred within the same planning period if the local agency does not have a housing element considered to be in substantial compliance, as described in Section 65585.03.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(C)Nothing in this subdivision limits the application of Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that section.
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.
(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period has the same meaning as in paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 65588. means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule described in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (e) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated the rights established by housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of the applicants rights established by housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agencys compliance with a housing reform law, law as applied to the applicants housing development project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5, unless the housing development projects consists of four or fewer units, in which case, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than $50,000 fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation.
(ii)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in clause (i) multiplied by a factor of five.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(C)Nothing in this subdivision limits the application of Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that section.
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)(A)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.
(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period has the same meaning as in paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated the rights established by housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of the applicants rights established by housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5. 65589.5, unless the housing development projects consists of four or fewer units, in which case, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than $50,000 per violation.
(ii)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5 clause (i) multiplied by a factor of five.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)(A)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribe, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project, including, but not limited to, all of the following: project.
(i)The provisions identified in subdivision (j) of Section 65585.(ii)The Permit Streamlining Act (Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 65920)).(iii)Section 65913.3.(iv)Section 65913.3.1.(v)Section 65913.6.(vi)Any provision under which relief is sought pursuant to Section 66020 or 66021.(B)The specific identification of any law, regulation, or provision in this paragraph shall not be interpreted to limit the scope of housing reform law as used in this section.(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period has the same meaning as in paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to do both of the following:
(1)Establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated the rights established by housing reform laws.
(2)Prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agencys own alleged violation of the applicants rights established by housing reform laws.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following shall apply:
(1)The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)(A)In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
(i)If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agencys decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5.
(ii)If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5 multiplied by a factor of five.
(B)Notwithstanding Chapter 2 (commencing with 910) of Part 3 of Division 3.6 of Title 1, the applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described in subparagraph (A).
(c)(1)A public agency shall not require an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicants rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
(2)A requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of paragraph (1) is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
(3)This subdivision shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement as described in paragraph (1) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Housing development project has the same meaning as provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 65905.5.
(2)(A)Housing reform law means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribe, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(i)The provisions identified in subdivision (j) of Section 65585.
(ii)The Permit Streamlining Act (Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 65920)).
(iii)Section 65913.3.
(iv)Section 65913.3.1.
(v)Section 65913.6.
(vi)Any provision under which relief is sought pursuant to Section 66020 or 66021.
(B)The specific identification of any law, regulation, or provision in this paragraph shall not be interpreted to limit the scope of housing reform law as used in this section.
(3)Local agency has the same meaning as used in Section 65930.
(4)Planning period has the same meaning as in paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 65588.
(5)Public agency has the same meaning as in Section 65932.
SECTION 1.Section 65913 of the Government Code is amended to read:65913.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that a severe shortage of affordable housing exists, especially for persons and families of low and moderate income, and that an immediate need exists to encourage the development of new housing, not only through the provision of financial assistance, but also through changes in law designed to do all of the following:(1)Expedite the local and state residential development process.(2)Assure that local governments zone sufficient land at densities high enough for production of affordable housing.(3)Assure that local governments make a diligent effort through the administration of land use and development controls and the provision of regulatory concessions and incentives to significantly reduce housing development costs and thereby facilitate the development of affordable housing, including housing for elderly persons and families, as defined by Section 50067 of the Health and Safety Code.These changes in the law are consistent with the responsibility of local government to adopt the program required by subdivision (c) of Section 65583.(b)The Legislature further finds and declares that the costs of new housing developments have been increased, in part, by the existing permit process and by existing land use regulations and that vitally needed housing developments have been halted or rendered infeasible despite the benefits to the public health, safety, and welfare of those developments and despite the absence of adverse environmental impacts. It is, therefore, necessary to enact this chapter and to amend existing statutes which govern housing development so as to provide greater encouragement for local and state governments to approve needed and sound housing developments.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that there exists a severe shortage of affordable housing, housing exists, especially for persons and families of low and moderate income, and that there is an immediate need exists to encourage the development of new housing, not only through the provision of financial assistance, but also through changes in law designed to do all of the following:
(1)Expedite the local and state residential development process.
(2)Assure that local governments zone sufficient land at densities high enough for production of affordable housing.
(3)Assure that local governments make a diligent effort through the administration of land use and development controls and the provision of regulatory concessions and incentives to significantly reduce housing development costs and thereby facilitate the development of affordable housing, including housing for elderly persons and families, as defined by Section 50067 of the Health and Safety Code.
These changes in the law are consistent with the responsibility of local government to adopt the program required by subdivision (c) of Section 65583.
(b)The Legislature further finds and declares that the costs of new housing developments have been increased, in part, by the existing permit process and by existing land use regulations and that vitally needed housing developments have been halted or rendered infeasible despite the benefits to the public health, safety, and welfare of those developments and despite the absence of adverse environmental impacts. It is, therefore, necessary to enact this chapter and to amend existing statutes which govern housing development so as to provide greater encouragement for local and state governments to approve needed and sound housing developments.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2025 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 496, Statutes of 2025. |
| Oct 10, 2025 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2025 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 4, 2025 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 64. Noes 2. Page 2932.). |
| Sep 4, 2025 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 3, 2025 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 35. Noes 2. Page 2462.). |
| Aug 20, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2025 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 16, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (July 15). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2025 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 2, 2025 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 10. Noes 1.) (July 1). |
| May 21, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on HOUSING and JUD. |
| May 13, 2025 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 12, 2025 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 64. Noes 2. Page 1512.) |
| May 5, 2025 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1436.) |
| May 1, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 30, 2025 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Apr 22, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 21, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 10, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 11, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Mar 10, 2025 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on H. & C.D. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 10, 2025 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2025 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2025 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 4, 2025 | AB 712 Wicks Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2025 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB712 Wicks By Caballero | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 15, 2025 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2025 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2025 | AB 712 Wicks Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2025 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2025 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2025 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Abundant Housing LA | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Horseless Carriage Club of America | ** Support | |
| BOMA California | ** Support | |
| CalChamber | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Support | |
| California Housing Consortium | ** Support | |
| California Housing Partnership | ** Support | |
| California Special Districts Association | ** Against | |
| California YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Circulate San Diego | ** Support | |
| City of Murrieta | ** Against | |
| city of yorba linda | ** Against | |
| Construction Employers' Association | ** Support | |
| Equitable Land Use Alliance | ** Against | |
| Fieldstead And Company, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Housing Action Coalition | ** Support | |
| Housing California | ** Support | |
| Inner City Law Center | ** Support | |
| League Of California Cities | ** Against | |
| Mission Street Neighbors | ** Against | |
| Naiop California | ** Support | |
| New Livable California | ** Against | |
| Southern California Leadership Council | ** Support | |
| South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth | ** Support | |
| SPUR | ** Support | |
| The Two Hundred | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 712
Author:(Wicks)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2025
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Enhances the enforcement of housing reform laws and the penalties that may be imposed on a local agency determined to have violated those laws.
Senate Amendments
- Limit the ability of a court to impose fines to situations where, after the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) sends a written communication to the local agency that their action or inaction represents a violation of a specific housing reform law, the housing development project applicant provides written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action, as specified, at least 60 days before the commencement of the action.
- Requires any period of limitation for actions under any California law to be extended for a period of 60 days beginning on the date the applicant provides written notice to the local agency indicating its intent to commence an action under this bill.
- Provides that, for purposes of calculating fines for repeated violations of a housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed within the same planning period, any subsequent violation of the same housing reform law shall be considered to have occurred within the same planning period if the local agency does not have a substantially compliant housing element.
COMMENTS
Housing Accountability Act (HAA): In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the jurisdiction's share of regional housing need or emergency shelters without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a jurisdiction's ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the locality's share of the regional housing need.
The HAA provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project.
If a locality denies approval or imposes conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial or imposition of conditions is subject to a court challenge, the burden is on the local government to show that its decision is consistent with specified written findings.
If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney's fees unless the court find that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
State Enforcement of Housing Laws: In recent years, the Legislature has implemented many policy changes to address the housing deficit, including streamlined, ministerial approval of housing and requiring local governments to plan and zone for more housing via the housing element process. For many years prior to the enactment of these and other laws, local governments often treated the housing element and other housing requirements as a "paper exercise" because the state lacked strong enforcement tools to ensure compliance.
AB 72 (Santiago), Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017 established a process for HCD to enforce many state housing laws. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government's housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action.
In addition to the expanded authority under AB 72, HCD has created and staffed a Housing Accountability Unit, which provides education and technical assistance as well as oversight and enforcement of housing element laws to ensure local governments comply with specified housing laws. Violations of these laws may lead to a variety of consequences for local governments, including referral to the AG for further civil action.
Some of these laws, similar to the HAA, also provide a mechanism for private third party actors – for example, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. In 2023, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 1485 (Haney), Chapter 763, which also granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state's interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
There have been further efforts to add more "teeth" to state law to deter bad actors from continuing to obstruct housing development, including SB 1037 (Wiener), Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024, which established minimum civil fines and attorney fee awards in cases where the AG or HCD are acting to enforce housing element law or state laws that require ministerial approval of housing development projects, and AB 1633 (Ting), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023, which expanded the definition of local agency "disapproval" of projects under the HAA.
Private Enforcement: While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD's accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full lawsuit for every single violation or possible violation.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often "repeat customers" in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney's fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
This bill would require a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney's fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. AB 712 (Wicks) would also prohibit a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies, the bill would also apply HAA fines (or for projects with four or fewer units, a minimum fine of $50,000 per violation) in cases where the applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant's lawsuit, and declined to remedy the violation during a 60-day cure period. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle (or without a compliant housing element), the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
According to the Author
"The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant's rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California."
Arguments in Support
According to the California Building Industry Association, the bill's sponsor, "With very limited exceptions, enforcement of housing reform laws relies on housing project applicants to sue the offending public agency. However, applicants are reluctant to vindicate these rights because litigation is expensive, and the applicant must maintain cordial relationships with agencies that have permitting authority over current and future housing projects. Moreover, unlike opponents of housing projects who typically are awarded attorney's fees if they successfully sue to block a housing project, project applicants generally do not recover their attorney's fees when they are the successful party, with the limited exception of suits under the Housing Accountability Act. Further undermining housing law enforcement, there are no effective penalties to deter public agencies from forcing applicants to file lawsuits over the same issue even after the public agency has consistently lost in court and committed violations after having been warned in writing by the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD)."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the California Special Districts Association, "Taken together, AB 712's attorneys' fees, costs, and fines provisions result in private enforcement of 'housing reform laws' without regard to whether private enforcement is provided for in those carefully crafted measures. Most concerning for special districts, AB 712 defines 'Housing reform law' as 'any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.' This vague definition, coupled with the bill's severe penalties, places an undue burden on local agencies, exposing them to litigation and expense concerning whether a specific law that an applicant claims to be covered by the bill's provisions is indeed a 'housing reform law.' This is especially untenable for special districts, which are not land use authorities. Although special districts do not have land-use authority, and therefore the specified applicability of the provisions of this measure remain unclear, special districts remain an essential provider of the infrastructure and critical services needed to build thriving communities."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- HCD anticipates minor and absorbable costs to provide technical assistance to developers and to inform local jurisdictions when they are out of compliance with provisions requiring them to reimburse plaintiffs who succeed in lawsuits.
- Possible future costs to local agencies of an unknown amount to the extent they are sued and lose and must pay an applicant's reasonable attorney's fees and costs. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and lawsuits filed, the number of suits that settle, and the extent the litigation before an applicant prevails. These costs are not reimbursable by the state.
VOTES:
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 11-0-1
YES: Haney, Ávila Farías, Caloza, Gallagher, Garcia, Kalra, Lee, Quirk-Silva, Ta, Wicks, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-0-3
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Pacheco, Lee, Stefani, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Macedo, Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-0-3
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Elhawary, Fong, Mark González, Hart, Pacheco, Solache, Ta, Alanis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Pellerin
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2-13
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Ávila Farías, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Caloza, Carrillo, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Elhawary, Flora, Fong, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Jeff Gonzalez, Mark González, Hadwick, Haney, Harabedian, Hart, Hoover, Jackson, Kalra, Krell, Lee, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Ransom, Celeste Rodriguez, Michelle Rodriguez, Rogers, Blanca Rubio, Schiavo, Schultz, Sharp-Collins, Solache, Soria, Ta, Valencia, Wallis, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Zbur, Rivas
NO: DeMaio, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Castillo, Chen, Ellis, Irwin, Lackey, Macedo, Muratsuchi, Papan, Patel, Patterson, Stefani, Tangipa
SENATE FLOOR: 35-2-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Arreguín, Ashby, Becker, Blakespear, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cervantes, Cortese, Dahle, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Grove, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, McNerney, Menjivar, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Pérez, Reyes, Richardson, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Valladares, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
NO: Choi, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alvarado-Gil, Jones, Strickland
UPDATED
VERSION: July 3, 2025
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0001566
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 712 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 712
Author: Wicks (D)
Amended: 7/3/25 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 10-1, 7/1/25
AYES: Wahab, Arreguín, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla
NOES: Seyarto
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 13-0, 7/15/25
AYES: Umberg, Niello, Allen, Arreguín, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Stern, Valladares, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/12/25 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
SOURCE: California Building Industry Association
DIGEST:
This bill (1) entitles housing development applicants that prevail in an action over a local agency to reasonable attorney’s fees and (2) subjects local agencies to increased fines for violating housing reform laws under specified circumstances.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides the following pursuant to the Housing Accountability Act (HAA):
- Prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate-income households or an emergency shelter, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the project infeasible, unless it makes specific findings based upon substantial evidence in the record.
- Allows a project applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner if certain conditions are met, unless the court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA, or in certain cases concerning specified disapprovals.
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency has failed to comply with an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within the time period prescribed by the court, to impose fines on the local agency and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete. Requires the court, in determining the amount of the fine to impose, to consider the local agency’s progress in attaining its allocation of regional housing need and any prior violations of the HAA. Prohibits fines from being paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, as specified.
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the office of the Attorney General (AG), if HCD finds that:
- A housing element does not substantially comply with state law; and,
- A local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws.
- Requires HCD, prior to the AG bringing any suit for a violation of the provisions of specified housing laws, to offer the jurisdiction the opportunity for two meetings in person or via telephone to discuss the violation, and to provide the jurisdiction written findings regarding the violation, with some exceptions.
- Grants HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the AG this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from HCD.
- Provides that in any action brought by the AG or HCD to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a city, county, or local agency to ministerially approve, without discretionary review, any planning or permitting application for a housing development project, the city, county, or local agency shall be subject to the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the AG or HCD prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Other relief as the court deems appropriate, including equitable and injunctive relief, provisional or otherwise.
This bill:
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency's compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant's project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the AG or HCD that the local agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the HAA, unless the housing development project consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000 per violation; and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines under i), above, multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above; and
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, nothing in this bill limits the application of existing Code of Civil Procedure provisions that allow a court to award attorney's fees to a successfully party, as specified, nor limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that provision.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
Background
HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA, commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law.
The HAA, among other provisions, provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project. If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney’s fees unless the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines of at least $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
Comments
Author’s Statement. “The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would apply levels of enforcement that are similar to the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.”
Enforcement of Housing Laws. Over the last several years, the Legislature has strengthened the consequences for local agencies who are out of compliance or who amend their zoning after their housing element is found compliant. Local agencies cannot qualify for state funding for affordable housing, or infrastructure for affordable housing, without a compliant housing element. AB 72 (Santiago, Chapter 72, Statutes of 2017) gave HCD explicit authority to find a local agency’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local agency acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action. Both the AG and HCD have units with dedicated staff to enforce Housing Element Law and other land use laws passed by the legislature. The AG can also sue a city for non-compliance, and the court can issue fines up to $10,000 a day, after the local agency fails to comply for an additional 12 months. After an additional six months of non-compliance, the court may increase the fines by six times.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies that violate state housing laws, this bill applies HAA fines in cases where an applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant’s lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
Private Enforcement. While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD’s accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
Several state housing laws provide a mechanism for private third party actors –such as, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. AB 1485 (Haney, Chapter 763, Statutes of 2023) granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state’s interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often “repeat customers” in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney’s fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
To address these concerns, this bill requires a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney’s fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. This bill also prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
Senate Rule 28.8
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/2/25)
California Building Industry Association (source) |
Boma California |
CALchamber |
California Apartment Association |
California Association of Realtors |
California Business Properties Association |
California Housing Consortium |
California Housing Partnership |
California YIMBY |
Circulate San Diego |
Construction Employers' Association |
Fieldstead and Company, INC. |
Housing Action Coalition |
Housing California |
Inner City Law Center |
Naiop California |
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth |
Southern California Leadership Council |
SPUR |
The Two Hundred |
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/2/25)
California Special Districts Association
City of Murrieta
City of Yorba Linda
Equitable Land Use Alliance
League of California Cities
New Livable California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Building Industry Association, “In recent years, the Legislature has advanced proposals that would help alleviate the state’s housing crisis. Unfortunately, enforcement of these housing reform laws continues to be an issue, with local non-compliance negatively impacting the construction of new housing and, in turn, harming California families in need of shelter. By strengthening the enforcement of these laws, AB 712 encourages compliance and will ultimately lead to more housing being built for California’s families.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The City of Yorba Linda writes in opposition, “Instead of creating new fines and penalties and encouraging litigation, lawmakers and the Department of Housing and Community Development should provide technical assistance and resources to local governments to comply with new legislative requirements…”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/12/25
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Ávila Farías, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Caloza, Carrillo, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Elhawary, Flora, Fong, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Jeff Gonzalez, Mark González, Hadwick, Haney, Harabedian, Hart, Hoover, Jackson, Kalra, Krell, Lee, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Ransom, Celeste Rodriguez, Michelle Rodriguez, Rogers, Blanca Rubio, Schiavo, Schultz, Sharp-Collins, Solache, Soria, Ta, Valencia, Wallis, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Zbur, Rivas
NOES: DeMaio, Sanchez
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bauer-Kahan, Castillo, Chen, Ellis, Irwin, Lackey, Macedo, Muratsuchi, Papan, Patel, Patterson, Stefani, Tangipa
Prepared by: Hank Brady / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
9/2/25 11:01:17
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 712 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 712
Author: Wicks (D)
Amended: 7/3/25 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 10-1, 7/1/25
AYES: Wahab, Arreguín, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla
NOES: Seyarto
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 13-0, 7/15/25
AYES: Umberg, Niello, Allen, Arreguín, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Stern, Valladares, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/12/25 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
SOURCE: California Building Industry Association
DIGEST:
This bill (1) entitles housing development applicants that prevail in an action over a local agency to reasonable attorney’s fees and (2) subjects local agencies to increased fines for violating housing reform laws under specified circumstances.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides the following pursuant to the Housing Accountability Act (HAA):
- Prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate-income households or an emergency shelter, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the project infeasible, unless it makes specific findings based upon substantial evidence in the record.
- Allows a project applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner if certain conditions are met, unless the court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA, or in certain cases concerning specified disapprovals.
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency has failed to comply with an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within the time period prescribed by the court, to impose fines on the local agency and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete. Requires the court, in determining the amount of the fine to impose, to consider the local agency’s progress in attaining its allocation of regional housing need and any prior violations of the HAA. Prohibits fines from being paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, as specified.
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the office of the Attorney General (AG), if HCD finds that:
- A housing element does not substantially comply with state law; and,
- A local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws.
- Requires HCD, prior to the AG bringing any suit for a violation of the provisions of specified housing laws, to offer the jurisdiction the opportunity for two meetings in person or via telephone to discuss the violation, and to provide the jurisdiction written findings regarding the violation, with some exceptions.
- Grants HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the AG this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from HCD.
- Provides that in any action brought by the AG or HCD to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a city, county, or local agency to ministerially approve, without discretionary review, any planning or permitting application for a housing development project, the city, county, or local agency shall be subject to the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the AG or HCD prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Other relief as the court deems appropriate, including equitable and injunctive relief, provisional or otherwise.
This bill:
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency's compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant's project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the AG or HCD that the local agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the HAA, unless the housing development project consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000 per violation; and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines under i), above, multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above; and
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, nothing in this bill limits the application of existing Code of Civil Procedure provisions that allow a court to award attorney's fees to a successfully party, as specified, nor limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that provision.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
Background
HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA, commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law.
The HAA, among other provisions, provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project. If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney’s fees unless the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines of at least $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
Comments
Author’s Statement. “The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would apply levels of enforcement that are similar to the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.”
Enforcement of Housing Laws. Over the last several years, the Legislature has strengthened the consequences for local agencies who are out of compliance or who amend their zoning after their housing element is found compliant. Local agencies cannot qualify for state funding for affordable housing, or infrastructure for affordable housing, without a compliant housing element. AB 72 (Santiago, Chapter 72, Statutes of 2017) gave HCD explicit authority to find a local agency’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local agency acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action. Both the AG and HCD have units with dedicated staff to enforce Housing Element Law and other land use laws passed by the legislature. The AG can also sue a city for non-compliance, and the court can issue fines up to $10,000 a day, after the local agency fails to comply for an additional 12 months. After an additional six months of non-compliance, the court may increase the fines by six times.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies that violate state housing laws, this bill applies HAA fines in cases where an applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant’s lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
Private Enforcement. While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD’s accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
Several state housing laws provide a mechanism for private third party actors –such as, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. AB 1485 (Haney, Chapter 763, Statutes of 2023) granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state’s interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often “repeat customers” in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney’s fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
To address these concerns, this bill requires a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney’s fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. This bill also prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
Senate Rule 28.8
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/18/25)
California Building Industry Association (source) |
Boma California |
CALchamber |
California Apartment Association |
California Association of Realtors |
California Business Properties Association |
California Housing Consortium |
California Housing Partnership |
California YIMBY |
Circulate San Diego |
Construction Employers' Association |
Fieldstead and Company, INC. |
Housing Action Coalition |
Housing California |
Inner City Law Center |
Naiop California |
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth |
Southern California Leadership Council |
SPUR |
The Two Hundred |
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/18/25)
California Special Districts Association
City of Murrieta
City of Yorba Linda
League of California Cities
New Livable California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Building Industry Association, “In recent years, the Legislature has advanced proposals that would help alleviate the state’s housing crisis. Unfortunately, enforcement of these housing reform laws continues to be an issue, with local non-compliance negatively impacting the construction of new housing and, in turn, harming California families in need of shelter. By strengthening the enforcement of these laws, AB 712 encourages compliance and will ultimately lead to more housing being built for California’s families.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The City of Yorba Linda writes in opposition, “Instead of creating new fines and penalties and encouraging litigation, lawmakers and the Department of Housing and Community Development should provide technical assistance and resources to local governments to comply with new legislative requirements…”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/12/25
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Ávila Farías, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Caloza, Carrillo, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Elhawary, Flora, Fong, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Jeff Gonzalez, Mark González, Hadwick, Haney, Harabedian, Hart, Hoover, Jackson, Kalra, Krell, Lee, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Ransom, Celeste Rodriguez, Michelle Rodriguez, Rogers, Blanca Rubio, Schiavo, Schultz, Sharp-Collins, Solache, Soria, Ta, Valencia, Wallis, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Zbur, Rivas
NOES: DeMaio, Sanchez
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bauer-Kahan, Castillo, Chen, Ellis, Irwin, Lackey, Macedo, Muratsuchi, Papan, Patel, Patterson, Stefani, Tangipa
Prepared by: Hank Brady / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
8/20/25 23:15:54
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 712 (Author:Wicks)
Version: July 3, 2025
Hearing Date: July 15, 2025
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ID
SUBJECT
Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
DIGEST
This bill requires a court, in an action where an applicant for a housing development sues a public agency to enforce its compliance with a housing reform law, and the applicant is the prevailing party, to impose fines upon the agency, as specified, and entitles the prevailing applicant to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
California is currently experiencing a significant housing crisis, in part because of a substantial shortage in new housing. Consequently, the Legislature has passed numerous bills in the last few years aimed at streamlining the approval and construction of new housing. These laws include laws around the housing element of cities and counties’ general plans, laws meant to streamline the permitting process, laws prohibiting a local government from denying, reducing the density of, or making infeasible a housing development project, emergency shelter project, or farmworker housing development that is otherwise consistent with objective local development standards, and many other laws. While some of these laws have robust enforcement mechanisms, the author asserts that their enforcement mechanisms are not sufficient to deter local agencies from not following the laws.
AB 712 proposes a broad enforcement mechanism for when a public agency fails to comply with any housing reform law, by requiring a court in any action in which the applicant for a housing development sues the agency for noncompliance with a housing reform law, when the applicant is the prevailing party, to award the applicant reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, and impose specified fines. For these fines, AB 712 requires the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development to first notify the agency that its action is not in compliance with a relevant housing law, and also requires that the applicant then provide the agency 60 days’ notice before bringing a civil action.
AB 712 is sponsored by the California Building Industries Association, and is supported by the California Chamber of Commerce and a number of business associations and pro-housing organizations. It is opposed by the California Special District Association, New Livable California, and a number of cities. It previously passed out of the Senate Housing Committee by a vote of 10 to 1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires, as a part of the General Plan Law, local agencies to develop a housing element within their general plan that consists of an identification and analysis of existing and projected housing needs and a statement of goals, policies, quantified objectives, financial resources, and scheduled programs for the preservation, improvement, and development of housing, including identifying sites for adequate housing. (Gov. Code § 65583.)
- Prohibits, in accordance with the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), local agencies from disapproving a housing development project for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or conditioning approval in a manner that renders the project or shelter infeasible, unless the local agency makes written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record as to one of several specified justifications for the denial. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(d).)
- Authorizes a project applicant, a person eligible to live in a housing development or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Specifies that, if the court finds that an agency took an action that violated the HAA, the court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance within a time period not to exceed 60 days, including by requiring the agency to approve the development, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k).)
- Requires a court to grant a prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to 3) reasonable attorney’s costs and fees, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(1)(A)(ii).)
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency failed to comply with an order or judgment of the court mandating compliance with the HAA, to impose fines on the local agency and requires the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(1)(B).)
- Specifies that, if a court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it violated the HAA and failed to carry out the court’s order or judgment within the 60-day time period, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five, and that, if the court finds that the agency violated the HAA within the same planning period, the court must multiply the fines by an additional factor for each previous violation. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(l).)
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to notify the local agency, and authorizes the Department to notify the Attorney General, if the Department finds any of the following:
- A local agency’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law; or
- A local agency takes an action in violation of specified housing laws. (Gov. Code § 65585(j).)
- Provides the HCD and the Attorney General the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the Attorney General this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from the Department. (Gov. Code § 65585.01.)
- Authorizes, in any action brought by the HCD or the Attorney General seeking to enforce the revision of a housing element or various discretionary review statutes, the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the Department or Attorney General prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Any other relief the court deems appropriate. (Gov. Code § 65009.1.)
This bill:
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature, in enacting this bill, to:
- establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated housing reform laws; and
- prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agency’s own alleged violation of housing reform laws.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency’s compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant’s housing development project, and the applicant is the prevailing party, the applicant is entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Specifies that, where an applicant is the prevailing party in such a suit, and the action is against a local agency, if the local agency was advised in writing by the Attorney General or HCD prior to the commencement of the action that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of a specific housing reform law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant, the court must impose a fine of not less than specified fines that equal $10,000 per housing unit, unless the housing development consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court shall impose a fine of not less than $50,000 per violation.
- Specifies that the court may not impose the above-described fines unless the applicant provides the local agency written notice of its intent to commence an action, after the Attorney General or HCD sent the agency its written communication. Requires that the applicant’s written notice identify the factual elements of the dispute and the legal theory forming the basis of the allegation that the agency violated a housing reform law, and requires that this notice be provided at least 60 days prior to the commencement of the action.
- Specifies that, for any action commenced or intended to be commenced under the bill, any statute of limitations shall be extended for a period of 60 days from when the applicant provides the agency written notice of its intent to sue.
- Specifies that, if a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the above-described fines multiplied by a factor of five. Specifies that a violation is considered to have occurred during the same planning period if the agency does not have a housing element considered to be in substantial compliance.
- Notwithstanding specified provisions, specifies that an applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described above.
- Specifies that nothing in these provisions limits the availability of attorney’s fees to a successful party under specified provisions of law.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Specifies that any requirement, condition, or approval in violation of (9) is against public policy and unenforceable.
- Specifies that the provisions of (9) and (10) may not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement described in (9) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- For the purposes of these provisions, defines the following:
- “housing development project” to have the same meaning as is provided in Government Code section 65905.5(b);
- “housing reform law” to mean any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefits of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- “local agency” to mean the same as is provided in Government Code section 65930;
- “planning period” to mean the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule described in specified housing element law;
- “public agency” to mean the same as is provided in Government code section 65932.
COMMENTS
- Author’s statement
According to the author:
The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would apply levels of enforcement that are similar to the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.
- California’s housing crisis
California is experiencing a serious affordable housing crisis. California homes are about twice as expensive as an average home across the country, and the monthly cost of home ownership of a mid-tier home in California has increased 81% since 2020.[1]
Rents also have increased dramatically in the past decade. In 2022, the median gross rent in the state was $1,870, which represented about an eight percent increase per year from the median gross rent in 2019.[2] As a result of these high rents, significant numbers of California renters pay a disproportionate amount of their income toward rent and struggle to make ends meet. In 2019, 51.8 percent of California renters were cost-burdened, in which their rent costs exceeded 30 percent of their household income, and 27.3 percent were severely cost-burdened, in which their rent costs exceeded 50 percent of their household income.[3] Moreover, 78 percent of extremely low-income households are severely cost burdened, meaning that they spend more than half of their income on housing costs, and 52 percent of low-income households are severely cost burdened.[4] Data and multiple studies also have demonstrated a strong link between homelessness and the cost of housing, suggesting that California’s increases in residential rental rates contributes directly to the state’s growing population of individuals experiencing homelessness.[5] The state’s high rents significantly affect people of color, who disproportionately account for the state’s renters.[6]
A significant contributor to these high home prices and rents is the state’s lack of affordable housing, as the state is experiencing a record shortfall of available housing. It is estimated that the state is experiencing a shortfall of 1,283,734 affordable homes.[7] At the same time, the state is currently losing affordable housing every year. Between 1997 and 2022, California lost 22,078 affordable homes due to expiring regulatory restrictions on government-assisted multifamily developments.[8] It is estimated that 31,309 affordable homes are at risk of losing their affordability restrictions in the next 10 years.[9] Although the state built more homes in the last few years than it has in many years, production is still below what the state estimates is needed to be produced every year in order to meet the state’s needs.[10] Given these numbers, the Legislature has passed a variety of laws in recent years aimed at increasing and facilitating the production of housing.
- Cities’ housing elements
State law requires each city and county to develop and adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the county or city and any lands outside that bear relation to the city or county’s planning. (Gov. Code § 65300.) This plan must include a statement of development policies and a description of the objectives, principles, standards, and plan proposals. (Gov. Code § 65302.) It must also include certain elements, including transportation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, safety, environmental justice, and land use elements. The planning agency can include additional elements to the plan, and the general plan may address each element to the extent to which that element exists in the planning area. How a city can adopt or amend a city or county’s general plan is likewise described by statute. The statute requires that the planning body drafting the general plan share it with numerous stakeholders and consult a variety of groups and related planning documents (like a groundwater sustainability plan). (Gov. Code § 65350.5.)
The housing element is an essential part of tackling housing affordability. The law specifies a variety of components that must be included in the housing element, such as a statement of the community’s goals, objectives, and policies for furthering fair housing and the maintenance, preservation, improvement, and development of housing. (Gov. Code § 65583.) The housing element must also include an assessment of the housing needs and inventory and resources of the city or county, a projection of the locality’s existing and projected housing needs, and an inventory of land suitable and available for residential development. (Gov. Code §§ 65583(a)-(c).) Housing elements must also include a schedule of actions and timelines for implementation. Housing elements must be revised on a staggered schedule, in which localities within a federally-designated metropolitan planning organization (MPO) classified as non-attainment for specified air pollutants under the federal Clean Air Act must revise their housing elements every eight years, while localities within MPO’s classified as attainment must revise their housing elements every five years.
HCD plays an essential role in cities and counties’ creation of their housing elements and the creation of affordable housing. HCD must review and approve every city and county’s housing element as in compliance with the law, and a specific schedule with specified penalties is set for this process and cities and counties’ compliance with it. If HCD finds that a city or county’s draft housing element does not substantially comply, the city or county must either change the draft element to substantially comply, or adopt the draft element with written findings explaining why it believes the draft element does substantially comply despite HCD’s findings. (Gov. Code § 65585(f).) Additionally, if HCD determines that the city or county’s housing element or an action of the city or county is in violation of the housing element law, it may notify the Attorney General, and the Attorney General may bring an enforcement action against the non-compliant city or county. (Gov. Code § 65585(j).)
- California has enacted many laws in recent years aimed at increasing the production of housing across the state
In addition to the housing elements laws, various other laws limit how a city or local agency may delay or deny housing developments. The Permit Streamlining Act, enacted in 1977, requires public agencies to act within certain, prompt timelines for reviewing development proposals for discretionary permits. (Gov. Code § 65920.) If the local agency fails to make a decision within the specified timeframes, the permits are deemed approved and the development can automatically move forward. (Gov. Code § 655956.) AB 2234 (Rivas, Ch. 651, Stats. 2022) replicated the Permit Streamlining Act timelines and automatic approval provisions to the approval of post-entitlement permits, which generally refer to building permits and other non-discretionary permits required to begin the construction of a development project that has already been approved. (Gov. Code § 65913.3.)
Another law meant to promote the production of housing is the Housing Accountability Act (HAA). The HAA prohibits a local government from denying, reducing the density of, or making infeasible a housing development project, emergency shelter project, or farmworker housing development that is otherwise consistent with objective local development standards. (Gov. Code § 65589.5.) Before a local government may do any of those things with regard to a housing development, farmworker housing, or an emergency shelter, it must make specified written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence that there would be specific adverse health or safety impacts of the development. The HAA also provides for what is called “the builder’s remedy,” in which, if a city’s housing element is not “substantially compliant” with the statutory requirements, the city cannot disapprove a housing project that meets certain affordability requirements based on the city’s zoning or general plan standards. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(h)(11).)
The HAA includes a private right of action under which the developer, a person who would be able to live in the development, or a specified housing organization may challenge the local government’s denial or severely burdensome conditions for the approval of the development project. If a court finds that the local government violated the HAA, it can compel the government to comply with the act within 60 days. If the local government fails to do so, the HAA requires the court to impose fines of a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(B).) If the court finds that the local government acted in bad faith, the court is required to multiply these fines by a factor of five. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(l).) In addition, the HAA provides a prevailing plaintiff the ability to recover reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- AB 712 would impose penalties on cities and local agencies for failing to comply with “housing reform laws”
AB 712 attempts to model the enforcement mechanism in the HAA for any noncompliance by a local government with a variety of housing laws. It would impose a fine of $10,000 per housing unit for a violation of a housing reform law when the local government has been advised in writing by HCD or the Attorney General that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would be a violation of a specific housing reform law. If the housing development consists of four or fewer units, the fine must be for an amount not less than $50,000 per violation. With recent amendments in the Senate Housing Committee, these fines also would not be able to be imposed unless, after the written notice from HCD or the Attorney General, the applicant for the housing development provides a written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action that identifies the elements of the dispute and the legal theory of the allegation that the local agency violated the housing reform law. The applicant would be required to provide this notice at least 60 days before the commencement of the action, though the notice would extend any applicable statute of limitations for at least 60 days.
In addition, AB 712 would impose a fine of five times those fine amounts when a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed within the same housing element planning period. AB 712 also would entitle an applicant of a housing development that prevails in a suit brought against a public agency to enforce the agency’s compliance with a housing reform law for that particular development project to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
Opposition expresses concern with the breadth of this bill and its definition of a housing reform law. Indeed, the bill’s definition is quite broad: it includes any law or regulation “that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or [that] restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.” Thus, any law that creates some requirement on a local government meant to benefit or promote housing can be enforced with this bill’s fines. Because this is so broad and does not specify the exact laws it encompasses, this likely will be rife for litigation. Nonetheless, the severity of the fines proposed may well make any local agency wary of any litigation, and could operate to force any local agency to comply with any request by a developer to change or adjust the agency’s action or decision. With the threat of serious, mandatory penalties, a local agency likely would feel obligated to act in any way regarding a housing development that the developer requests. Otherwise, it would expose the local agency to significant liability and costs. Whether the Legislature wishes to give that much power to a housing developer over local determinations is an important question for the Legislature to consider.
- Arguments in support
According to the California Building Industries Association, which is the sponsor of this bill:
AB 712 appropriately enhances the rights of housing applicants by guaranteeing the recovery of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs when prevailing in actions against local agencies that fail to uphold housing reform laws. By also imposing financial penalties on non-compliant agencies, this bill creates a meaningful deterrent against unlawful delays and denials that have long hindered the construction of much-needed housing.
Furthermore, AB 712’s prohibition on indemnification clauses is a necessary step in preventing local governments from shifting legal liabilities onto developers. This protection ensures that developers can pursue lawful claims without fear of financial retaliation, fostering a fairer and more transparent housing approval process.
By holding local governments accountable for non-compliance, the bill will ensure housing reform laws are respected and applied fairly. AB 712 is a responsible and necessary reform that will foster a more equitable and efficient housing development process. For these reasons, we write in support of AB 712 (Wicks). Thank you for your time and consideration.
- Arguments in opposition
According to the California Special Districts Association, which is opposed to AB 712:
AB 712 would create a right to attorneys’ fees and costs for an applicant in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency, including a special district, to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party. This one-sided right, for which indemnification is prohibited by the bill, would place local agencies legitimately defending their decisions in court at a disadvantage, with the burden shifted to taxpayers and ratepayers.
AB 712’s provisions for fines, which may be sought without regard to requirements of the Government Claims Act, based on an applicant prevailing on claims substantially the same as prior written advisements by the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) similarly exposes well intentioned local agencies, taxpayers and ratepayers, to significant financial risk while placing local agencies legitimately defending their decisions at a disadvantage. A development project is a dynamic and ongoing process. A local agency may receive adverse correspondence from the AG or HCD at the same time an applicant is advancing their project, and while the local agency is engaging in dialogue with all stakeholders in good faith. A local agency with a legitimate reason for working with the AG or HCD to resolve or challenge the adverse correspondence will be forced into an untenable situation vis-à-vis the applicant for a housing development project if the risk of delay shall result in fines, notably, without discretion by a court.
This bill’s provisions for fines when the court has previously found that the local agency “violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period” is similarly troubling. This leaves open the possibility that a local agency could be exposed to significant fines for violating a statute even based on completely different facts, circumstances and reasoning. Given the unclear applicability of AB 712, discussed below, local agencies may not have a clear understanding of their exposure. Moreover, the bill’s reference to “within the same planning period” is unworkable for special districts. Because special districts are not land use planning authorities and do not have planning periods, it is not clear how this provision would or could be applied to them. This will undoubtedly lead to disputes and litigation.
Taken together, AB 712’s attorneys’ fees, costs, and fines provisions result in private enforcement of “housing reform laws” without regard to whether private enforcement is provided for in those carefully crafted measures.
Most concerning for special districts, AB 712 defines “Housing reform law” as “any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribe, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project. This vague definition, coupled with the bill’s severe penalties, places an undue burden on local agencies, exposing them to litigation and expense concerning whether a specific law that an applicant claims to be covered by the bill’s provisions is indeed a “housing reform law.” This is especially untenable for special districts, which are not land use authorities.
Although special districts do not have land-use authority and therefore the specified applicability of the provisions of this measure remain unclear, special districts remain an essential provider of the infrastructure and critical services needed to build thriving communities. They are a vital part of the housing ecosystem and part of the affordability solution. This measure will divert precious resources away from this mission.
SUPPORT
California Building Industry Association
Abundant Housing LA
Boma California
Calchamber
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Housing Consortium
California Housing Partnership
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Commercial Real Estate Development Association, NAIOP of California
Construction Employers' Association
Fieldstead and Company, Inc.
Housing Action Coalition
Housing California
Inner City Law Center
NAIOP California
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth
Southern California Leadership Council
SPUR
The Two Hundred for Homeownership
OPPOSITION
California Special Districts Association
City of Murrieta
City of Yorba Linda
New Livable California Dba Livable California
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 838 (Durazo, 2025) revises the definition of a “housing development project” to require that no portion of the project be designated for use as a hotel, motel, or similar lodging; in the case of a mixed-use development, at least two-thirds of the new or converted square footage must be designated for residential use. SB 838 is currently pending before the Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee.
SB 457 (Becker, 2025) revises Housing Element Law to specify that a local agency’s housing element is in compliance the date it is adopted if the element is subsequently certified by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) or a court of competent jurisdiction, and changes the vesting period for builder’s remedy projects. SB 457 is currently pending before the Senate Housing Committee.
AB 660 (Wilson, 2025) prohibits a local agency from requiring or requesting more than two plan check and specification reviews in connection with an application for a building permit, revises timelines for receiving a determination from the local agency of an appeal on a permit request, and authorizes an applicant to seek a writ of mandate to compel approval of the application if the applicant’s appeal is denied. AB 660 is currently pending before the Senate Housing Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1037 (Wiener, Ch. 293, Stats. 2024) created new legal remedies that can be used by the AG to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a local government to ministerially approve any decision or application for a housing development project.
AB 1893 (Wicks, Ch. 268, Stats. 2024) revised the builder’s remedy in the HAA to provide objective standards for builder’s remedy projects, including regarding density standards and project location requirements.
AB 1886 (Alvarez, Ch. 267, Stats. 2024) clarified that a housing element is substantially compliant with Housing Element Law, when both a local agency adopts the housing element and HCD or a court finds it in compliance.
AB 1633 (Ting, Ch. 768, Stats. 2023) expanded the definition of a “disapproval” under the HAA, and applied its provisions until 2031.
AB 215 (Chiu, Ch. 342, Stats. 2021) provided HCD with additional enforcement authority over local agency violations of specified housing laws.
SB 167 (Skinner, Ch. 368, Stats. 2017) made several changes to the HAA to require a court, upon a determination that a locality failed to comply with a court order within 60 days, to impose a minimum fine of $10,000 per housing unit, and authorized a local agency to deposit the fine in a specified state fund, to be used or returned to the state’s general fund, as specified.
AB 72 (Santiago, Ch. 370, Stats. 2017) provided HCD the authority to find a local government’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local government acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Housing Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 64, Noes 2)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
**************
Alex Bentz, “California Housing Affordability Tracker (1st Quarter 2025),” Legislative Analyst’s Office (Apr. 21, 2025) https://lao.ca.gov/LAOEconTax/Article/Detail/793. ↑
U.S. Census Bureau, Table: Median Gross Rent by Bedroom, American Community Survey (multiple years) (accessed May 29, 2024), available at https://data.census.gov/. ↑
Davalos supra note 1, p. 3. ↑
California Housing Partnership, “Housing Needs Dashboard,” Mar. 2024, available at https://chpc.net/housingneeds/. ↑
Margot Kushel et al, “California Statewide Study of People Experiencing Homelessness, UCSF Benioff Homelessness and Housing Initiative (Jun. 2023), available at https://homelessness.ucsf.edu/our-impact/studies/california-statewide-study-people-experiencing-homelessness; Alex Horowitz et al, “How housing costs drive levels of homelessness: data from metro areas highlights strong connection,” The APew Charitable Trusts (ug. 22, 2023), available at https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2023/08/22/how-housing-costs-drive-levels-of-homelessness. ↑
Davalos supra note 1, p. 6. ↑
California Housing Partnership, “Housing Needs Dashboard,” Mar. 2024, available at https://chpc.net/housingneeds/. ↑
Danielle Mazzella et al, Report 2023: Affordable Homes At Risk, California Housing Partnership (Apr. 2023), available at https://chpc.net/resources/2023-subsidized-affordable-housing-at-risk-report/. ↑
Id. ↑
Ben Christopher, “California is losing population and building new houses. When will home prices come down?” CalMatters (May 16, 2023), https://calmatters.org/housing/2023/05/california-exodus-housing-cost/. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 712 (Author:Wicks)
Version: July 3, 2025
Hearing Date: July 15, 2025
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ID
SUBJECT
Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
DIGEST
This bill requires a court, in an action where an applicant for a housing development sues a public agency to enforce its compliance with a housing reform law, and the applicant is the prevailing party, to impose fines upon the agency, as specified, and entitles the prevailing applicant to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
California is currently experiencing a significant housing crisis, in part because of a substantial shortage in new housing. Consequently, the Legislature has passed numerous bills in the last few years aimed at streamlining the approval and construction of new housing. These laws include laws around the housing element of cities and counties’ general plans, laws meant to streamline the permitting process, laws prohibiting a local government from denying, reducing the density of, or making infeasible a housing development project, emergency shelter project, or farmworker housing development that is otherwise consistent with objective local development standards, and many other laws. While some of these laws have robust enforcement mechanisms, the author asserts that their enforcement mechanisms are not sufficient to deter local agencies from not following the laws.
AB 712 proposes a broad enforcement mechanism for when a public agency fails to comply with any housing reform law, by requiring a court in any action in which the applicant for a housing development sues the agency for noncompliance with a housing reform law, when the applicant is the prevailing party, to award the applicant reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, and impose specified fines. For these fines, AB 712 requires the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development to first notify the agency that its action is not in compliance with a relevant housing law, and also requires that the applicant then provide the agency 60 days’ notice before bringing a civil action.
AB 712 is sponsored by the California Building Industries Association, and is supported by the California Chamber of Commerce and a number of business associations and pro-housing organizations. It is opposed by the California Special District Association, New Livable California, and a number of cities. It previously passed out of the Senate Housing Committee by a vote of 10 to 1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires, as a part of the General Plan Law, local agencies to develop a housing element within their general plan that consists of an identification and analysis of existing and projected housing needs and a statement of goals, policies, quantified objectives, financial resources, and scheduled programs for the preservation, improvement, and development of housing, including identifying sites for adequate housing. (Gov. Code § 65583.)
- Prohibits, in accordance with the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), local agencies from disapproving a housing development project for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or conditioning approval in a manner that renders the project or shelter infeasible, unless the local agency makes written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record as to one of several specified justifications for the denial. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(d).)
- Authorizes a project applicant, a person eligible to live in a housing development or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Specifies that, if the court finds that an agency took an action that violated the HAA, the court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance within a time period not to exceed 60 days, including by requiring the agency to approve the development, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k).)
- Requires a court to grant a prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to 3) reasonable attorney’s costs and fees, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(1)(A)(ii).)
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency failed to comply with an order or judgment of the court mandating compliance with the HAA, to impose fines on the local agency and requires the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete, as specified. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(1)(B).)
- Specifies that, if a court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it violated the HAA and failed to carry out the court’s order or judgment within the 60-day time period, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five, and that, if the court finds that the agency violated the HAA within the same planning period, the court must multiply the fines by an additional factor for each previous violation. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(l).)
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to notify the local agency, and authorizes the Department to notify the Attorney General, if the Department finds any of the following:
- A local agency’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law; or
- A local agency takes an action in violation of specified housing laws. (Gov. Code § 65585(j).)
- Provides the HCD and the Attorney General the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the Attorney General this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from the Department. (Gov. Code § 65585.01.)
- Authorizes, in any action brought by the HCD or the Attorney General seeking to enforce the revision of a housing element or various discretionary review statutes, the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the Department or Attorney General prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Any other relief the court deems appropriate. (Gov. Code § 65009.1.)
This bill:
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature, in enacting this bill, to:
- establish minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies against public agencies that are found by a court of law to have violated housing reform laws; and
- prevent public agencies from undermining these minimum uniform, transparent, fair, and effective remedies through the imposition of reimbursement and indemnification agreements on applicants for housing development approvals with respect to legal challenges involving the agency’s own alleged violation of housing reform laws.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency’s compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant’s housing development project, and the applicant is the prevailing party, the applicant is entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Specifies that, where an applicant is the prevailing party in such a suit, and the action is against a local agency, if the local agency was advised in writing by the Attorney General or HCD prior to the commencement of the action that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of a specific housing reform law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant, the court must impose a fine of not less than specified fines that equal $10,000 per housing unit, unless the housing development consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court shall impose a fine of not less than $50,000 per violation.
- Specifies that the court may not impose the above-described fines unless the applicant provides the local agency written notice of its intent to commence an action, after the Attorney General or HCD sent the agency its written communication. Requires that the applicant’s written notice identify the factual elements of the dispute and the legal theory forming the basis of the allegation that the agency violated a housing reform law, and requires that this notice be provided at least 60 days prior to the commencement of the action.
- Specifies that, for any action commenced or intended to be commenced under the bill, any statute of limitations shall be extended for a period of 60 days from when the applicant provides the agency written notice of its intent to sue.
- Specifies that, if a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the above-described fines multiplied by a factor of five. Specifies that a violation is considered to have occurred during the same planning period if the agency does not have a housing element considered to be in substantial compliance.
- Notwithstanding specified provisions, specifies that an applicant shall not be required to present a claim to seek the fine described above.
- Specifies that nothing in these provisions limits the availability of attorney’s fees to a successful party under specified provisions of law.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Specifies that any requirement, condition, or approval in violation of (9) is against public policy and unenforceable.
- Specifies that the provisions of (9) and (10) may not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement described in (9) is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- For the purposes of these provisions, defines the following:
- “housing development project” to have the same meaning as is provided in Government Code section 65905.5(b);
- “housing reform law” to mean any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefits of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- “local agency” to mean the same as is provided in Government Code section 65930;
- “planning period” to mean the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule described in specified housing element law;
- “public agency” to mean the same as is provided in Government code section 65932.
COMMENTS
- Author’s statement
According to the author:
The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would apply levels of enforcement that are similar to the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.
- California’s housing crisis
California is experiencing a serious affordable housing crisis. California homes are about twice as expensive as an average home across the country, and the monthly cost of home ownership of a mid-tier home in California has increased 81% since 2020.[1]
Rents also have increased dramatically in the past decade. In 2022, the median gross rent in the state was $1,870, which represented about an eight percent increase per year from the median gross rent in 2019.[2] As a result of these high rents, significant numbers of California renters pay a disproportionate amount of their income toward rent and struggle to make ends meet. In 2019, 51.8 percent of California renters were cost-burdened, in which their rent costs exceeded 30 percent of their household income, and 27.3 percent were severely cost-burdened, in which their rent costs exceeded 50 percent of their household income.[3] Moreover, 78 percent of extremely low-income households are severely cost burdened, meaning that they spend more than half of their income on housing costs, and 52 percent of low-income households are severely cost burdened.[4] Data and multiple studies also have demonstrated a strong link between homelessness and the cost of housing, suggesting that California’s increases in residential rental rates contributes directly to the state’s growing population of individuals experiencing homelessness.[5] The state’s high rents significantly affect people of color, who disproportionately account for the state’s renters.[6]
A significant contributor to these high home prices and rents is the state’s lack of affordable housing, as the state is experiencing a record shortfall of available housing. It is estimated that the state is experiencing a shortfall of 1,283,734 affordable homes.[7] At the same time, the state is currently losing affordable housing every year. Between 1997 and 2022, California lost 22,078 affordable homes due to expiring regulatory restrictions on government-assisted multifamily developments.[8] It is estimated that 31,309 affordable homes are at risk of losing their affordability restrictions in the next 10 years.[9] Although the state built more homes in the last few years than it has in many years, production is still below what the state estimates is needed to be produced every year in order to meet the state’s needs.[10] Given these numbers, the Legislature has passed a variety of laws in recent years aimed at increasing and facilitating the production of housing.
- Cities’ housing elements
State law requires each city and county to develop and adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the county or city and any lands outside that bear relation to the city or county’s planning. (Gov. Code § 65300.) This plan must include a statement of development policies and a description of the objectives, principles, standards, and plan proposals. (Gov. Code § 65302.) It must also include certain elements, including transportation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, safety, environmental justice, and land use elements. The planning agency can include additional elements to the plan, and the general plan may address each element to the extent to which that element exists in the planning area. How a city can adopt or amend a city or county’s general plan is likewise described by statute. The statute requires that the planning body drafting the general plan share it with numerous stakeholders and consult a variety of groups and related planning documents (like a groundwater sustainability plan). (Gov. Code § 65350.5.)
The housing element is an essential part of tackling housing affordability. The law specifies a variety of components that must be included in the housing element, such as a statement of the community’s goals, objectives, and policies for furthering fair housing and the maintenance, preservation, improvement, and development of housing. (Gov. Code § 65583.) The housing element must also include an assessment of the housing needs and inventory and resources of the city or county, a projection of the locality’s existing and projected housing needs, and an inventory of land suitable and available for residential development. (Gov. Code §§ 65583(a)-(c).) Housing elements must also include a schedule of actions and timelines for implementation. Housing elements must be revised on a staggered schedule, in which localities within a federally-designated metropolitan planning organization (MPO) classified as non-attainment for specified air pollutants under the federal Clean Air Act must revise their housing elements every eight years, while localities within MPO’s classified as attainment must revise their housing elements every five years.
HCD plays an essential role in cities and counties’ creation of their housing elements and the creation of affordable housing. HCD must review and approve every city and county’s housing element as in compliance with the law, and a specific schedule with specified penalties is set for this process and cities and counties’ compliance with it. If HCD finds that a city or county’s draft housing element does not substantially comply, the city or county must either change the draft element to substantially comply, or adopt the draft element with written findings explaining why it believes the draft element does substantially comply despite HCD’s findings. (Gov. Code § 65585(f).) Additionally, if HCD determines that the city or county’s housing element or an action of the city or county is in violation of the housing element law, it may notify the Attorney General, and the Attorney General may bring an enforcement action against the non-compliant city or county. (Gov. Code § 65585(j).)
- California has enacted many laws in recent years aimed at increasing the production of housing across the state
In addition to the housing elements laws, various other laws limit how a city or local agency may delay or deny housing developments. The Permit Streamlining Act, enacted in 1977, requires public agencies to act within certain, prompt timelines for reviewing development proposals for discretionary permits. (Gov. Code § 65920.) If the local agency fails to make a decision within the specified timeframes, the permits are deemed approved and the development can automatically move forward. (Gov. Code § 655956.) AB 2234 (Rivas, Ch. 651, Stats. 2022) replicated the Permit Streamlining Act timelines and automatic approval provisions to the approval of post-entitlement permits, which generally refer to building permits and other non-discretionary permits required to begin the construction of a development project that has already been approved. (Gov. Code § 65913.3.)
Another law meant to promote the production of housing is the Housing Accountability Act (HAA). The HAA prohibits a local government from denying, reducing the density of, or making infeasible a housing development project, emergency shelter project, or farmworker housing development that is otherwise consistent with objective local development standards. (Gov. Code § 65589.5.) Before a local government may do any of those things with regard to a housing development, farmworker housing, or an emergency shelter, it must make specified written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence that there would be specific adverse health or safety impacts of the development. The HAA also provides for what is called “the builder’s remedy,” in which, if a city’s housing element is not “substantially compliant” with the statutory requirements, the city cannot disapprove a housing project that meets certain affordability requirements based on the city’s zoning or general plan standards. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(h)(11).)
The HAA includes a private right of action under which the developer, a person who would be able to live in the development, or a specified housing organization may challenge the local government’s denial or severely burdensome conditions for the approval of the development project. If a court finds that the local government violated the HAA, it can compel the government to comply with the act within 60 days. If the local government fails to do so, the HAA requires the court to impose fines of a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(k)(B).) If the court finds that the local government acted in bad faith, the court is required to multiply these fines by a factor of five. (Gov. Code § 65589.5(l).) In addition, the HAA provides a prevailing plaintiff the ability to recover reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- AB 712 would impose penalties on cities and local agencies for failing to comply with “housing reform laws”
AB 712 attempts to model the enforcement mechanism in the HAA for any noncompliance by a local government with a variety of housing laws. It would impose a fine of $10,000 per housing unit for a violation of a housing reform law when the local government has been advised in writing by HCD or the Attorney General that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would be a violation of a specific housing reform law. If the housing development consists of four or fewer units, the fine must be for an amount not less than $50,000 per violation. With recent amendments in the Senate Housing Committee, these fines also would not be able to be imposed unless, after the written notice from HCD or the Attorney General, the applicant for the housing development provides a written notice to the local agency of its intent to commence an action that identifies the elements of the dispute and the legal theory of the allegation that the local agency violated the housing reform law. The applicant would be required to provide this notice at least 60 days before the commencement of the action, though the notice would extend any applicable statute of limitations for at least 60 days.
In addition, AB 712 would impose a fine of five times those fine amounts when a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same housing reform law on which an applicant prevailed within the same housing element planning period. AB 712 also would entitle an applicant of a housing development that prevails in a suit brought against a public agency to enforce the agency’s compliance with a housing reform law for that particular development project to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
Opposition expresses concern with the breadth of this bill and its definition of a housing reform law. Indeed, the bill’s definition is quite broad: it includes any law or regulation “that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or [that] restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.” Thus, any law that creates some requirement on a local government meant to benefit or promote housing can be enforced with this bill’s fines. Because this is so broad and does not specify the exact laws it encompasses, this likely will be rife for litigation. Nonetheless, the severity of the fines proposed may well make any local agency wary of any litigation, and could operate to force any local agency to comply with any request by a developer to change or adjust the agency’s action or decision. With the threat of serious, mandatory penalties, a local agency likely would feel obligated to act in any way regarding a housing development that the developer requests. Otherwise, it would expose the local agency to significant liability and costs. Whether the Legislature wishes to give that much power to a housing developer over local determinations is an important question for the Legislature to consider.
- Arguments in support
According to the California Building Industries Association, which is the sponsor of this bill:
AB 712 appropriately enhances the rights of housing applicants by guaranteeing the recovery of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs when prevailing in actions against local agencies that fail to uphold housing reform laws. By also imposing financial penalties on non-compliant agencies, this bill creates a meaningful deterrent against unlawful delays and denials that have long hindered the construction of much-needed housing.
Furthermore, AB 712’s prohibition on indemnification clauses is a necessary step in preventing local governments from shifting legal liabilities onto developers. This protection ensures that developers can pursue lawful claims without fear of financial retaliation, fostering a fairer and more transparent housing approval process.
By holding local governments accountable for non-compliance, the bill will ensure housing reform laws are respected and applied fairly. AB 712 is a responsible and necessary reform that will foster a more equitable and efficient housing development process. For these reasons, we write in support of AB 712 (Wicks). Thank you for your time and consideration.
- Arguments in opposition
According to the League of California Cities, which is opposed to AB 712:
We respectfully suggest that the bill begins with a faulty premise: That housing reform laws establish “applicant’s rights.” There are no “rights” established by housing reform law. Rather, “housing reform laws” impose certain procedural and substantive requirements on cities and counties when acting within the Constitution’s grant of the police power.
Under existing law, cities are subject to significant fines and penalties for violating certain housing laws. However, if a city violates the law, it is provided the opportunity to correct the violation before fines are imposed, additionally; enhanced fines are not imposed unless the city fails to follow a court’s order or acts in bad faith. AB 712 goes beyond existing law and fails to recognize that there can be reasonable differences of opinion on the meaning and implementation of state housing laws. Providing cities with the opportunity to correct a violation – under court supervision – is ultimately a better way to achieve the goal of approving more housing.
AB 712 would increase the fines for violations of state law to include “any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise impose any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project”. This overly broad and vague definition can be interpreted in numerous ways, leading to inconsistent enforcement and unpredictable legal outcomes. Most importantly, it fails to give cities and counties adequate notice of what statutes are included. In order for fines to deter unlawful conduct, the range of the laws included must be clear. This lack of clarity could result in frequent legal challenges as cities attempt to navigate the uncertain parameters set forth by the measure. Consequently, local governments may be entangled in costly legal disputes, diverting resources from providing essential services to the community and local housing development efforts.
Instead of creating new fines and penalties and encouraging litigation, lawmakers and the Department of Housing and Community Development should provide technical assistance and resources to local governments to comply with new legislative requirements.
Cal Cities encourages the author to consider providing a specific list of violations that would qualify for fines or, at the minimum, providing local governments with the opportunity – under court supervision - to correct a violation before fines commence.
Finally, the measure should clarify that the prohibition on indemnification and defense only applies if the applicant challenges a disapproval of a housing development project.
SUPPORT
California Building Industry Association
Abundant Housing LA
Boma California
Calchamber
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Housing Consortium
California Housing Partnership
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Commercial Real Estate Development Association, NAIOP of California
Construction Employers' Association
Fieldstead and Company, Inc.
Housing Action Coalition
Housing California
Inner City Law Center
NAIOP California
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth
Southern California Leadership Council
SPUR
The Two Hundred for Homeownership
OPPOSITION
California Special Districts Association
City of Murrieta
City of Yorba Linda
New Livable California Dba Livable California
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 838 (Durazo, 2025) revises the definition of a “housing development project” to require that no portion of the project be designated for use as a hotel, motel, or similar lodging; in the case of a mixed-use development, at least two-thirds of the new or converted square footage must be designated for residential use. SB 838 is currently pending before the Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee.
SB 457 (Becker, 2025) revises Housing Element Law to specify that a local agency’s housing element is in compliance the date it is adopted if the element is subsequently certified by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) or a court of competent jurisdiction, and changes the vesting period for builder’s remedy projects. SB 457 is currently pending before the Senate Housing Committee.
AB 660 (Wilson, 2025) prohibits a local agency from requiring or requesting more than two plan check and specification reviews in connection with an application for a building permit, revises timelines for receiving a determination from the local agency of an appeal on a permit request, and authorizes an applicant to seek a writ of mandate to compel approval of the application if the applicant’s appeal is denied. AB 660 is currently pending before the Senate Housing Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1037 (Wiener, Ch. 293, Stats. 2024) created new legal remedies that can be used by the AG to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a local government to ministerially approve any decision or application for a housing development project.
AB 1893 (Wicks, Ch. 268, Stats. 2024) revised the builder’s remedy in the HAA to provide objective standards for builder’s remedy projects, including regarding density standards and project location requirements.
AB 1886 (Alvarez, Ch. 267, Stats. 2024) clarified that a housing element is substantially compliant with Housing Element Law, when both a local agency adopts the housing element and HCD or a court finds it in compliance.
AB 1633 (Ting, Ch. 768, Stats. 2023) expanded the definition of a “disapproval” under the HAA, and applied its provisions until 2031.
AB 215 (Chiu, Ch. 342, Stats. 2021) provided HCD with additional enforcement authority over local agency violations of specified housing laws.
SB 167 (Skinner, Ch. 368, Stats. 2017) made several changes to the HAA to require a court, upon a determination that a locality failed to comply with a court order within 60 days, to impose a minimum fine of $10,000 per housing unit, and authorized a local agency to deposit the fine in a specified state fund, to be used or returned to the state’s general fund, as specified.
AB 72 (Santiago, Ch. 370, Stats. 2017) provided HCD the authority to find a local government’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local government acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Housing Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 64, Noes 2)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
**************
Alex Bentz, “California Housing Affordability Tracker (1st Quarter 2025),” Legislative Analyst’s Office (Apr. 21, 2025) https://lao.ca.gov/LAOEconTax/Article/Detail/793. ↑
U.S. Census Bureau, Table: Median Gross Rent by Bedroom, American Community Survey (multiple years) (accessed May 29, 2024), available at https://data.census.gov/. ↑
Davalos supra note 1, p. 3. ↑
California Housing Partnership, “Housing Needs Dashboard,” Mar. 2024, available at https://chpc.net/housingneeds/. ↑
Margot Kushel et al, “California Statewide Study of People Experiencing Homelessness, UCSF Benioff Homelessness and Housing Initiative (Jun. 2023), available at https://homelessness.ucsf.edu/our-impact/studies/california-statewide-study-people-experiencing-homelessness; Alex Horowitz et al, “How housing costs drive levels of homelessness: data from metro areas highlights strong connection,” The APew Charitable Trusts (ug. 22, 2023), available at https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2023/08/22/how-housing-costs-drive-levels-of-homelessness. ↑
Davalos supra note 1, p. 6. ↑
California Housing Partnership, “Housing Needs Dashboard,” Mar. 2024, available at https://chpc.net/housingneeds/. ↑
Danielle Mazzella et al, Report 2023: Affordable Homes At Risk, California Housing Partnership (Apr. 2023), available at https://chpc.net/resources/2023-subsidized-affordable-housing-at-risk-report/. ↑
Id. ↑
Ben Christopher, “California is losing population and building new houses. When will home prices come down?” CalMatters (May 16, 2023), https://calmatters.org/housing/2023/05/california-exodus-housing-cost/. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: AB 712 Hearing Date: 7/1/2025
Author: | Wicks | ||
Version: | 5/5/2025 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Hank Brady | ||
SUBJECT: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
DIGEST: This bill entitles applicants that prevail in an action over a local agency to reasonable attorney’s fees and subjects local agencies to increased fines for violating housing reform laws under specified circumstances.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a housing element, to guide the future growth of a community. The housing element shall consist of an identification and analysis of existing and projected housing needs and a statement of goals, policy objectives, financial resources, and scheduled programs for the preservation, improvement, and development of housing. Requires the housing element to contain an assessment of housing needs and an inventory of resources and constraints relevant to meeting those needs.
- Provides the following pursuant to the Housing Accountability Act (HAA):
- Prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate-income households or an emergency shelter, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the project infeasible, unless it makes specific findings based upon substantial evidence in the record.
- Allows a project applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner if certain conditions are met, unless the court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA, or in certain cases concerning specified disapprovals.
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency has failed to comply with an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within the time period prescribed by the court, to impose fines on the local agency and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete. Requires the court, in determining the amount of the fine to impose, to consider the local agency’s progress in attaining its allocation of regional housing need and any prior violations of the HAA. Prohibits fines from being paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, as specified.
- Requires a court, if it finds that a local agency acted in bad faith when it violated the HAA and failed to carry out the court’s order or judgment in the time period prescribed by the court, to multiply the fine in c) above by a factor of five. If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the HAA within the same planning period, requires the court to multiply the fines by an additional factor for each previous violation.
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the office of the Attorney General (AG), if HCD finds that:
- A housing element does not substantially comply with state law; and,
- A local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws.
- Requires HCD, prior to the AG bringing any suit for a violation of the provisions of specified housing laws, to offer the jurisdiction the opportunity for two meetings in person or via telephone to discuss the violation, and to provide the jurisdiction written findings regarding the violation, with some exceptions.
- Grants HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the AG this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from HCD.
- Provides that in any action brought by the AG or HCD to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a city, county, or local agency to ministerially approve, without discretionary review, any planning or permitting application for a housing development project, the city, county, or local agency shall be subject to the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the AG or HCD prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Other relief as the court deems appropriate, including equitable and injunctive relief, provisional or otherwise.
This bill:
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency's compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant's project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the AG or HCD that the local agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the HAA, unless the housing development project consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000 per violation; and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines under i), above, multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above; and
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, nothing in this bill limits the application of existing Code of Civil Procedure provisions that allow a court to award attorney's fees to a successfully party, as specified, nor limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that provision.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Declares that a requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of 2) above, is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
- Provides that 2) and 3) above shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement in 2) above is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- Defines for the purpose of this bill the following:
- "Housing development project" means a use consisting of residential unit developments, mixed unit developments, as specified, transitional or supportive housing, or farmworker housing;
- "Housing reform law" means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- "Local agency" means any public agency other than a state agency;
- "Planning period" means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule, as specified; and,
- "Public agency" means any state agency, county, city and county, city, regional agency, public district, redevelopment agency, or other political subdivision.
Background
Housing Elements. Cities and counties are required to develop a housing element as part of the general plan every eight years (every five years for some rural areas). Cities must submit their housing element to HCD for approval by a specified date and currently most local governments should have adopted, or be in the process of finalizing, their sixth housing element. Each local agency receives a total number of housing units to plan for broken down by income category. The housing element must identify programs to increase the supply of housing, address inequities in the housing market, reduce barriers to producing housing, and identify an inventory of sites that are zoned for housing at the density necessary to result in housing sufficient to meet the locality’s regional housing needs for the housing element cycle.
HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA, commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the housing need determined pursuant to the Housing Element Law without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a city’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects.
The HAA provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project. If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney’s fees unless the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines of at least $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
Comments
- Author’s Statement. “The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would apply levels of enforcement that are similar to the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.”
- Enforcement of Housing Laws. Over the last several years, the Legislature has strengthened the consequences for local agencies who are out of compliance or who amend their zoning after their housing element is found compliant. Local agencies cannot qualify for state funding for affordable housing, or infrastructure for affordable housing, without a compliant housing element. AB 72 (Santiago, Chapter 72, Statutes of 2017) gave HCD explicit authority to find a local agency’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local agency acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action. Both the AG and HCD have units with dedicated staff to enforce Housing Element Law and other land use laws passed by the legislature. The AG can also sue a city for non-compliance, and the court can issue fines up to $10,000 a day, after the local agency fails to comply for an additional 12 months. After an additional six months of non-compliance, the court may increase the fines by six times.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies that violate state housing laws, this bill applies HAA fines in cases where an applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant’s lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
- Private Enforcement. While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD’s accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
Several state housing laws provide a mechanism for private third party actors –such as, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. AB 1485 (Haney, Chapter 763, Statutes of 2023) granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state’s interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often “repeat customers” in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney’s fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
To address these concerns, this bill requires a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney’s fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. This bill also prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
- Compliance before enforcement. The enhanced penalties proposed in this bill create a powerful deterrent to prevent local agencies from violating state housing laws. Compelling compliance through enforcement, especially litigation, is an expensive means of achieving compliance for all parties involved. Achieving compliance voluntarily can achieve the desired outcome more expeditiously at a fraction of the cost of litigation. This bill specifies that if a local agency receives a notification from the AG or HCD stating that the local agency’s actions violates a state housing reform law, the local agency is immediately subject to enhanced penalties if an applicant brings litigation to compel compliance with the statute identified by the state. The threat of enhanced penalties associated with a warning letter may be enough to compel compliance in many cases. If the intent of this bill is to achieve an expeditious remedy to noncompliance with state housing reform laws, the committee may wish to consider amending the bill to provide a period of time for local agency to cure a violation prior to being subject to enhance penalties following litigation.
- Housing element planning periods. The bill provides that if a court finds that a local agency violated the same statute more than once in the same planning period, the court shall increase the fines imposed on the local agency by a factor of five. This is intended to deter local agencies from repeatedly violating the same statute. Each Council of Government (COG) is subject to a housing element cycle that is defined in statute. This planning cycle determines when each local agency must adopt a new housing element. For example the current housing element cycle for the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) began on January 31, 2023 the deadline for local agencies in that COG to adopt a certified housing element. It is reasonable to place a limitation on how long an original violation can enhance the penalties associated with subsequent violations of the same statute; however, in the current housing element cycle many local agencies failed adopt a housing element prior to the deadline. For example, the city of Palo Alto did not adopt a compliant housing element until May 2024, more than one year after the deadline. Under this bill, a city that has repeatedly violated the same statute will no longer be subject to enhanced penalties as of the date they are required to submit a compliant housing element, regardless of whether or not the city has adopted a compliant housing element. The penalty enhancement timeline should be linked to the date a local agency actually adopts a compliant housing element, rather than the date they were supposed to adopt a compliant housing element.
- Rights and rules. The bill specifies that the legislature intends to establish effective remedies against public agencies that are found to violate “rights” established by housing reform laws. The bill additionally notes legislative intent to prevent public agencies from undermining effective remedies through imposition of indemnification agreements on applications involving an applicant’s “rights” established by housing reform laws. The operative language of the bill employs a broad definition of housing reform laws. The intent language suggests that the focus of the bill is solely on protecting “rights” established by housing reform laws, when in fact the bill is focused on addressing violations of housing reform laws broadly. Most housing reform laws place conditions on local agencies, rather than establish “rights” for applicants. To ensure the bill is not narrowly interpreted to only apply to a narrow set of housing reform laws the committee may wish to amend the intent language to clarify that the legislative intent is for the bill to apply to housing reform laws generally.
- Double referral. This bill is also referred to the Judiciary Committee.
- Committee Amendments. To address the items raised in Comments 4 - 6 and address technical and clarifying issues the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments.
- Require the written notification from the AG or HCD to identify the specific statute a local agency is violating.
- Require that in order for a violation by a local agency to be subject to enhanced penalties specified in the bill, an applicant must first provide a local agency 60-days’ notice prior to filing a lawsuit to associated with a violation identified in a letter filed by HCD or the AG. If the 60-day timeframe will exceed the statute of limitations for bringing an action, specify that the statute of limitations is tolled until the 60-day timeframe expires.
- Specify that a local agency may still be subject to enhanced penalties for repeat violations that occurred in a prior planning period until the local agency adopts a compliant housing element for the new planning period.
- Remove erroneous intent language related to applicant’s rights.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1886 (Alvarez, Chapter 267, Statutes of 2024) — clarified that a housing element is substantially compliant with Housing Element Law, when both a local agency adopts the housing element and HCD or a court finds it in compliance.
SB 1037 (Wiener, Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024) — created new legal remedies that can be used by the AG to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a local government to ministerially approve any decision or application for a housing development project.
AB 1633 (Ting, Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023) — expanded the definition of a “disapproval” under the HAA, until 2031.
AB 215 (Chiu, Chapter 342, Statutes of 2021) — provided HCD with additional enforcement authority over local agency violations of specified housing laws.
AB 72 (Santiago, Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017) — provided HCD the authority to find a local government’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local government acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 25, 2025.)
SUPPORT:
California Building Industry Association (Sponsor)
Abundant Housing LA
Boma California
CALchamber
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Housing Consortium
California Housing Partnership
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Construction Employers' Association
Fieldstead and Company, INC.
Housing Action Coalition
Housing California
Inner City Law Center
Naiop California
Southern California Leadership Council
SPUR
The Two Hundred
OPPOSITION:
California Special Districts Association
City of Yorba Linda
League of California Cities
New Livable California DBA Livable California
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 712
Author:(Wicks)
As Amended Ver:May 05, 2025
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Enhances the enforcement of housing reform laws and the penalties that may be imposed on a local agency determined to have violated those laws.
Major Provisions
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce the public agency's compliance with a housing reform law as applied to the applicant's project, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) that the local agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), unless the housing development project consists of four of fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000 per violation; and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines under i), above, multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above; and
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, nothing in this bill limits the application of existing Code of Civil Procedure provisions that allow a court to award attorney's fees to a successfully party, as specified, nor limits the availability of fees to a successful party under that provision.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Declares that a requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of 2), above, is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
- Provides that 2) and 3), above, shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement in 2) above is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- Defines for the purpose of this bill the following:
- "Housing development project" means a use consisting of residential unit developments, mixed unit developments, as specified, transitional or supportive housing, or farmworker housing;
- "Housing reform law" means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- "Local agency" means any public agency other than a state agency.
- "Planning period" means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule, as specified; and
- "Public agency" means any state agency, any county, city and county, city, regional agency, public district, redevelopment agency, or other political subdivision.
COMMENTS
Housing Accountability Act (HAA): In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the jurisdiction's share of regional housing need or emergency shelters without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a jurisdiction's ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the locality's share of the regional housing need.
The HAA provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project.
If a locality denies approval or imposes conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial or imposition of conditions is subject to a court challenge, the burden is on the local government to show that its decision is consistent with specified written findings.
If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney's fees unless the court find that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
State Enforcement of Housing Laws: In recent years, the Legislature has implemented many policy changes to address the housing deficit, including streamlined, ministerial approval of housing and requiring local governments to plan and zone for more housing via the housing element process. For many years prior to the enactment of these and other laws, local governments often treated the housing element and other housing requirements as a "paper exercise" because the state lacked strong enforcement tools to ensure compliance.
AB 72 (Santiago), Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017 established a process for HCD to enforce many state housing laws. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action.
In addition to the expanded authority under AB 72, HCD has created and staffed a Housing Accountability Unit (HAU), which provides education and technical assistance as well as oversight and enforcement of housing element laws to ensure local governments comply with specified housing laws. Violations of these laws may lead to a variety of consequences for local governments, including referral to the AG for further civil action.
Some of these laws, similar to the HAA, also provide a mechanism for private third party actors – for example, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. In 2023, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 1485 (Haney), Chapter 763, which also granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state's interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
There have been further efforts to add more "teeth" to state law to deter bad actors from continuing to obstruct housing development, including SB 1037 (Wiener), Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024, which established minimum civil fines and attorney fee awards in cases where the AG or HCD are acting to enforce housing element law or state laws that require ministerial approval of housing development projects, and AB 1633 (Ting), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023, which expanded the definition of local agency "disapproval" of projects under the HAA.
Private Enforcement: While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD's accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often "repeat customers" in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney's fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
This bill would require a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney's fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. AB 712 (Wicks) would also prohibit a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant's rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies, the bill would also apply HAA fines (or for projects with four or fewer units, a minimum fine of $50,000 per violation) in cases where the applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency's decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant's lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
According to the Author
"The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant's rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California."
Arguments in Support
According to the California Building Industry Association, the bill’s sponsor, "With very limited exceptions, enforcement of housing reform laws relies on housing project applicants to sue the offending public agency. However, applicants are reluctant to vindicate these rights because litigation is expensive, and the applicant must maintain cordial relationships with agencies that have permitting authority over current and future housing projects. Moreover, unlike opponents of housing projects who typically are awarded attorney's fees if they successfully sue to block a housing project, project applicants generally do not recover their attorney's fees when they are the successful party, with the limited exception of suits under the Housing Accountability Act. Further undermining housing law enforcement, there are no effective penalties to deter public agencies from forcing applicants to file lawsuits over the same issue even after the public agency has consistently lost in court and committed violations after having been warned in writing by the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD)."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the League of California Cities, "We respectfully suggest that the bill begins with a faulty premise: That housing reform laws establish 'applicant's rights.' There are no 'rights' established by housing reform law. Rather, 'housing reform laws' impose certain procedural and substantive requirements on cities and counties when acting within the Constitution's grant of the police power. Under existing law, cities are subject to significant fines and penalties for violating certain housing laws. However, if a city violates the law, it is provided the opportunity to correct the violation before fines are imposed, Additionally, enhanced fines are not imposed unless the city fails to follow a court's order or acts in bad faith. AB 712 goes beyond existing law and fails to recognize that there can be reasonable differences of opinion on the meaning and implementation of state housing laws. Providing cities with the opportunity to correct a violation – under court supervision – is ultimately a better way to achieve the goal of approving more housing."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) anticipates minor and absorbable costs to provide technical assistance to developers and to inform local jurisdictions when they are out of compliance with provisions requiring them to reimburse plaintiffs who succeed in lawsuits.
- Possible future costs to local agencies of an unknown amount to the extent they are sued and lose and must pay an applicant's reasonable attorney's fees and costs. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and lawsuits filed, the number of suits that settle, and the extent the litigation before an applicant prevails. These costs are not reimbursable by the state.
VOTES
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 11-0-1
YES: Haney, Ávila Farías, Caloza, Gallagher, Garcia, Kalra, Lee, Quirk-Silva, Ta, Wicks, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-0-3
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Pacheco, Lee, Stefani, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Macedo, Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-0-3
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Elhawary, Fong, Mark González, Hart, Pacheco, Solache, Ta, Alanis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Pellerin
UPDATED
VERSION: May 05, 2025
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0000335
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 712
Author:(Wicks)
As Amended Ver:April 10, 2025
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Enhances the enforcement of housing reform laws and the penalties that may be imposed on a local agency determined to have violated those laws.
Major Provisions
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney′s fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) that the local agency′s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), unless the housing development project consists of four of fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000 per violation; and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines under i) above multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant′s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Declares that a requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of 2) above is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
- Provides that 2) and 3) above shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement in 2) above is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- Defines for the purpose of this bill the following:
- ″Housing development project″ means a use consisting of residential unit developments, mixed unit developments, as specified, transitional or supportive housing, or farmworker housing;
- ″Housing reform law″ means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- ″Local agency″ means any public agency other than a state agency.
- ″Planning period″ means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule, as specified; and
- ″Public agency″ means any state agency, any county, city and county, city, regional agency, public district, redevelopment agency, or other political subdivision.
COMMENTS
Housing Accountability Act (HAA): In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the jurisdiction′s share of regional housing need or emergency shelters without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a jurisdiction′s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the locality′s share of the regional housing need.
The HAA provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project.
If a locality denies approval or imposes conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial or imposition of conditions is subject to a court challenge, the burden is on the local government to show that its decision is consistent with specified written findings.
If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney′s fees unless the court find that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
State Enforcement of Housing Laws: In recent years, the Legislature has implemented many policy changes to address the housing deficit, including streamlined, ministerial approval of housing and requiring local governments to plan and zone for more housing via the housing element process. For many years prior to the enactment of these and other laws, local governments often treated the housing element and other housing requirements as a ″paper exercise″ because the state lacked strong enforcement tools to ensure compliance.
AB 72 (Santiago), Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017 established a process for HCD to enforce many state housing laws. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government′s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action.
In addition to the expanded authority under AB 72, HCD has created and staffed a Housing Accountability Unit (HAU), which provides education and technical assistance as well as oversight and enforcement of housing element laws to ensure local governments comply with specified housing laws. Violations of these laws may lead to a variety of consequences for local governments, including referral to the AG for further civil action.
Some of these laws, similar to the HAA, also provide a mechanism for private third party actors – for example, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. In 2023, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 1485 (Haney), Chapter 763, which also granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state′s interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
There have been further efforts to add more ″teeth″ to state law to deter bad actors from continuing to obstruct housing development, including SB 1037 (Wiener), Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024, which established minimum civil fines and attorney fee awards in cases where the AG or HCD are acting to enforce housing element law or state laws that require ministerial approval of housing development projects, and AB 1633 (Ting), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023, which expanded the definition of local agency ″disapproval″ of projects under the HAA.
Private Enforcement: While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD′s accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often ″repeat customers″ in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney′s fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
This bill would require a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney′s fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. AB 712 (Wicks) would also prohibit a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant′s rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies, the bill would also apply HAA fines (or for projects with four or fewer units, a minimum fine of $50,000 per violation) in cases where the applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency′s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant′s lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
According to the Author
″The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant′s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.″
Arguments in Support
According to the California Building Industry Association, the bill′s sponsor, ″With very limited exceptions, enforcement of housing reform laws relies on housing project applicants to sue the offending public agency. However, applicants are reluctant to vindicate these rights because litigation is expensive, and the applicant must maintain cordial relationships with agencies that have permitting authority over current and future housing projects. Moreover, unlike opponents of housing projects who typically are awarded attorney′s fees if they successfully sue to block a housing project, project applicants generally do not recover their attorney′s fees when they are the successful party, with the limited exception of suits under the Housing Accountability Act. Further undermining housing law enforcement, there are no effective penalties to deter public agencies from forcing applicants to file lawsuits over the same issue even after the public agency has consistently lost in court and committed violations after having been warned in writing by the Attorney General or Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD).″
Arguments in Opposition
According to the League of California Cities, ″We respectfully suggest that the bill begins with a faulty premise: That housing reform laws establish ′applicant′s rights.′ There are no ′rights′ established by housing reform law. Rather, ′housing reform laws′ impose certain procedural and substantive requirements on cities and counties when acting within the Constitution′s grant of the police power. Under existing law, cities are subject to significant fines and penalties for violating certain housing laws. However, if a city violates the law, it is provided the opportunity to correct the violation before fines are imposed, Additionally, enhanced fines are not imposed unless the city fails to follow a court′s order or acts in bad faith. AB 712 goes beyond existing law and fails to recognize that there can be reasonable differences of opinion on the meaning and implementation of state housing laws. Providing cities with the opportunity to correct a violation – under court supervision – is ultimately a better way to achieve the goal of approving more housing.″
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) anticipates minor and absorbable costs to provide technical assistance to developers and to inform local jurisdictions when they are out of compliance with provisions requiring them to reimburse plaintiffs who succeed in lawsuits.
- Possible future costs to local agencies of an unknown amount to the extent they are sued and lose and must pay an applicant′s reasonable attorney′s fees and costs. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and lawsuits filed, the number of suits that settle, and the extent the litigation before an applicant prevails. These costs are not reimbursable by the state.
VOTES
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 11-0-1
YES: Haney, Ávila Farías, Caloza, Gallagher, Garcia, Kalra, Lee, Quirk-Silva, Ta, Wicks, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-0-3
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bryan, Connolly, Harabedian, Pacheco, Lee, Stefani, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Macedo, Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-0-3
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Elhawary, Fong, Mark González, Hart, Pacheco, Solache, Ta, Alanis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Pellerin
UPDATED
VERSION: April 10, 2025
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0000315
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 712
Author:(Wicks) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2025
Policy Committee: | Housing and Community Development | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
Judiciary | 9 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill enhances the enforcement of housing reform laws and increases the penalties a court may impose on a local agency that violates those laws.
Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following applies:
- The applicant is entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same way as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine of at least $10,000, unless the project consists of four or fewer units, in which case the court must impose a fine of at least $50,000.
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, then the fines specified in item b, above, are to be multiplied by a factor of five.
- Clarifies that an applicant need not present a claim in accordance with the Government Claims Act in order to seek the fines specified in item 1, above.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Deems any indemnity agreement entered into in violation of item 3, above, to be against public policy and thus void and unenforceable.
- Defines “housing reform law” to mean any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or that restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) anticipates minor and absorbable costs to provide technical assistance to developers and to inform local jurisdictions when they are out of compliance with provisions requiring them to reimburse plaintiffs who succeed in lawsuits.
- Possible future costs to local agencies of an unknown amount to the extent they are sued and lose and must pay an applicant’s reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and lawsuits filed, the number of suits that settle, and the extent the litigation before an applicant prevails. These costs are not reimbursable by the state.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author seeks to further strengthen the enforcement of state housing laws. According to the author:
The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. [This bill] would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, [this bill] would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.
- Background. The Housing Accountability Act (HAA) ensures that local agencies do not reject or make infeasible housing development projects considered necessary to meet the locality’s share of the regional housing need. The HAA restricts a jurisdiction’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees or requiring a project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies.
The HHA contains a private right of action that authorizes the developer (project applicant), a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing project.
If a court finds a local public agency has violated the HAA, the court may compel the local agency to comply with the HAA within 60 days. If the local agency fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose a minimum fine of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the local agency acted in bad faith, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five, in addition to any other remedies the court applies. The HAA also provides a prevailing plaintiff the right to recover their attorney’s costs and fees.
In 2017, the Legislature authorized HCD to unilaterally enforce most state housing laws without requiring the intervention of the AG. Similarly, in 2023, the Legislature provided HCD and the AG an unconditional right to intervene in private litigation to enforce state housing laws whenever the state’s interests were at issue in the case. Last year, the Legislature dramatically strengthened the fines and fee recovery provisions of the housing element law whenever actions are brought by HCD or the AG. However, advocates claim many project developers still lack the tools to meaningfully enforce housing laws outside of the HHA.
To further strengthen private enforcement of state housing laws, this bill authorizes project applicants, typically the project’s developer, to sue to enforce housing reform laws, broadly defined. Similar to the HAA, the bill authorizes fines ranging between $10,000 and $50,000 per violation, in addition to the award of attorney’s costs and fees to a prevailing applicant.
- Support and Opposition. This measure is supported by a broad coalition of housing reform advocates and developers, including the California Building Industry Association. The proponents of the bill stress the need for more enforcement of state housing laws, especially by those most impacted by local agencies that ignore existing mandates.
This measure is opposed by several local governments and their statewide representatives including the League of California Cities and the California Special Districts Association. The opponents assert that the bill overreaches and is unclear and are concerned that the bill authorizes non-governmental actors to file lawsuits.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 712
Author:(Wicks) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2025
SUBJECT: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
KEY ISSUE: should project applicants be authorized to file suit to enforce various housing reform laws; and if the project applicant prevails in such an action, shoud they be authorized to collect attorney’s fees and costs?
SYNOPSIS
As California’s chronic shortage of available and affordable housing have worsened over the past decade, the Legislature has aggressively moved to bolster enforcement of the state’s housing laws. Although the Housing Accountability Act provides broad standing to enforce some housing laws, most of the new enforcement authority has been vested in the Department of Housing and Community Development and the Attorney General. While the Department and Attorney General have aggressively utilized their new authority, private parties, especially project developers, still lack the ability to meaningfully enforce many state housing reform laws.
This bill would authorize project applicants, typically the project’s developer, to sue to enforce housing reform laws and seek enhanced fines and cost recovery from recalcitrant local agencies. The bill authorizes fines ranging between $10,000 and $50,000 per violation, in addition to the award of attorney’s costs and fees to a prevailing applicant. Although this bill does not create any new mandates for local agencies to comply with, the bill significantly enhances the ability of the private parties most impacted by a local agency’s decision to enforce the requirements of existing law.
This measure is supported by a broad coalition of housing reform advocates and developers, including the California Building Industry Association. The proponents of the bill stress the need for more enforcement of state housing laws, especially by those most impacted by local agencies that ignore existing mandates. Several local governments and their statewide representatives including the League of California Cities and the California Special Districts Association oppose the bill. The opponents lament the bill’s scope and provisions waiving the claims presentation provisions of the Government Claims Act, as well as the bill’s authorization for lawsuits by non-governmental actors. The bill was previously heard and approved by the Committee on Housing and Community Development by a vote of 11- 0.
SUMMARY: Enhances the enforcement of housing reform laws and the penalties that may be imposed on a local agency determined to have violated those laws. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following applies:
- The prevailing applicant is entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs;
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit the court must impose a fine not less than $10,000 unless the project consists of four or fewer units in which case the court must impose a fine not less than $50,000;
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, then the fines specified in b) are to be multiplied by a factor of five.
- Clarifies that an applicant need not present a claim in accordance with the Government Claims Act in order to seek the fines specified in b) and c) of 1).
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Deems any indemnity agreement entered into in violation of 3) to be against public policy and thus void and unenforceable.
- Provides that nothing in the bill is to be interpreted as to derogate any claim that a provision of an agreement specified in 3) is or was unlawful under existing law.
- Defines for the purpose of this bill the following:
- “Housing development project” means a use consisting of residential unit developments, mixed unit developments, as specified, transitional or supportive housing, or farmworker housing;
- “Housing reform law” means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project;
- “Local agency” means any public agency other than a state agency.
- “Planning period” means the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule, as specified; and
- “Public agency” means any state agency, any county, city and county, city, regional agency, public district, redevelopment agency, or other political subdivision.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, as a part of the General Plan Law, local agencies to develop a housing element within their general plan that consists of an identification and analysis of existing and projected housing needs and a statement of goals, policies, quantified objectives, financial resources, and scheduled programs for the preservation, improvement, and development of housing, including identifying sites for adequate housing. (Government Code Section 65583.)
- Prohibits, in accordance with the Housing Accountability Act, local agencies from disapproving a housing development project for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or conditioning approval in a manner that renders the project or shelter infeasible unless the local agency makes written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record as to one of several specified justifications for the denial. (Government Code Section 65589.5 (d).)
- Authorizes a project applicant, a person eligible to live in a housing development or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the Housing Accountability Act. (Government Code Section 65589 (k).)
- Requires a court to grant a prevailing plaintiff in an action brought pursuant to 3) reasonable attorney’s costs and fees, as specified. (Government Code Section 65589 (k)(1)(A)(ii).)
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency failed to comply with an order or judgment of the court mandating compliance with the Housing Accountability Act, to impose fines on the local agency and requires the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete, as specified. (Government Code Section 65589 (k)(1)(B).)
- Requires the Department of Housing and Community Development to notify the local agency, and authorizes the Department to notify the Attorney General, if the Department finds any of the following:
- A local agency’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law; or
- A local agency takes an action in violation of specified housing laws. (Government Code Section 65585 (j).)
- Provides the Department of Housing and Community Development and the Attorney General the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the Attorney General this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from the Department. (Government Code section 65585.01.)
- Authorizes, in any action brought by the Department of Housing and Community Development or the Attorney General seeking to enforce the revision of a housing element or various discretionary review statutes, the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the Department or Attorney General prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Any other relief the court deems appropriate. (Government Code 65009.1.)
- Requires a claim against a public agency to be presented by the claimant or by a person acting on their behalf to the government entity and show all of the following:
- The name and post office address of the claimant;
- The post office address to which the person presenting the claim desires notices to be sent;
- The date, place and other circumstances of the occurrence or transaction which gave rise to the claim asserted;
- A general description of the indebtedness, obligation, injury, damage or loss incurred so far as it may be known at the time of presentation of the claim;
- The name or names of the public employee or employees causing the injury, damage, or loss, if known; and
- The amount claimed if it totals less than ten thousand dollars ($10,000) as of the date of presentation of the claim, including the estimated amount of any prospective injury, damage, or loss, insofar as it may be known at the time of the presentation of the claim, together with the basis of computation of the amount claimed. (Government Code Section 910.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Seeking to address California’s ongoing housing shortage, in recent years the Legislature has enacted a flurry of new laws aimed at compelling local agencies to follow through on their commitments to construct new housing as identified in the local agency’s general plan. Some of the new statutes, most notably the “builders remedy” found in the Housing Accountability Act (AB 1893 (Wicks) Chap. 268, Stats. 2024), contain strong enforcement provisions while other statutes lack clear tools for enforcement. Although the Legislature has broadly permitted the Department of Housing and Community Development and the Attorney General to enforce state housing laws (see, e.g. SB 1037 (Wiener) Chap. 293, Stats. 2024), some statutes still lack opportunities for private enforcement. Seeking to further strengthen the enforcement of state housing laws, this bill strengthens a project applicant’s ability to enforce housing reform laws. In support of this measure, the author states:
The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.
The Housing Accountability Act authorizes broad public authority to enforce some state housing laws. Originally enacted in 1982, the Housing Accountability Act sought to ensure that local agencies did not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that were considered necessary to meet the locality’s share of the regional housing need. (SB 2011 (Greene) Chap. 1438, Stats. 1982.) In the intervening 40 years, the statute has been updated to turn it into one of the most potent tools available to enforce state housing laws. The Housing Accountability Act now contains a private right of action that authorizes parties, including the developer (project applicant); a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development; or a housing organization to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project. Furthermore, if a court determines that a local government denied approvals, or imposed conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low, or moderate-income households, the law shifts the burden to local governments to show that the agency’s decision is consistent with specified written findings.
After these updates to the Housing Accountability Act, the law now authorizes a court to impose an order compelling a local agency to comply with the Housing Accountability Act within 60 days of a court order finding the locality out of compliance with state law. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five. Furthermore, seeking to encourage private enforcement of the law, the Housing Accountability Act provides prevailing plaintiffs with the right to recover their attorney’s costs and fees.
In recent years, the Legislature has focused on expanding enforcement of other state housing laws. The Housing Accountability Act is not the only statute to promote local compliance with housing laws the Legislature sought to strengthen in recent years. In 2017, the Legislature authorized the Department of Housing and Community Development to unilaterally enforce most state housing laws without requiring the intervention of the Attorney General. (AB 72 (Santiago) Chap. 370, Stats. 2017.) Similarly, in 2023, the Legislature provided the Department of Housing and Community Development and the Attorney General with an unconditional right to intervene in private litigation to enforce state housing laws whenever the state’s interests were at issue in the case. (AB 1485 (Haney) Chap. 762, Stats. 2023.) Finally, last year, the Legislature dramatically strengthened the fines and fee recovery provisions of the housing element law whenever actions are brought by the Department of Housing and Community Development or the Attorney General. (SB 1037 (Wiener) Chap. 293, Stats. 2024.) While these efforts have significantly strengthened the state’s ability to enforce housing laws, many project developers still lack the tools to meaningfully enforce housing laws outside of the Housing Accountability Act.
This bill enhances a project applicant’s ability to enforce housing reform laws on their own behalf. Seeking to bolster private enforcement of state housing laws, this bill would authorize a project applicant to file suit to enforce “housing reform laws.” The bill provides that a local agency found to have violated the law is subject to fines ranging from $10,000 to $50,000 per violation depending on the nature of the project underlying the violation. The bill, much like the Housing Accountability Act, authorizes the award of attorney costs and fees to the prevailing plaintiff. Recent amendments to the measure left the bill to apply to a broadly defined set of “housing reform laws.” However, by tying the measure to only those laws in which the project applicant has standing as an aggrieved party, the broad definition appears appropriate as a means of authorizing the widest scope of enforcement of state housing laws, while still requiring the plaintiff to have a clear nexus to the underlying claim.
Despite some stakeholder concerns about the attorney cost and fee provisions, this bill appears appropriately focused. Several advocates for lower income Californians have reached out to informally express concerns regarding the bill’s existing attorney fee and cost provisions. These advocates worry that the bill may inadvertently limit cost recovery for actions brought under the Housing Accountability Act. As noted above, the Housing Accountability Act provides for cost recovery to prevailing plaintiffs, including public interest groups suing to enforce housing laws. However, these public interest advocates note that many judicial officers are not awarding costs and fees even when a party prevails in a Housing Accountability Act suit, and they worry that the provisions of this bill would provide judicial officers legal cover to further limit fee recovery.
While it is unfortunate that the existing law, especially one as critical as the Housing Accountability Act, is not being enforced properly by the courts, it is unclear how this statute would exacerbate the problem. Indeed, the subdivision of this bill that authorizes cost recovery explicitly states, “notwithstanding any other law…” The notwithstanding phrasing should be sufficient to cabin this bill from the provisions of the Housing Accountability Act, and for that matter, all other enforcement schemes. Nonetheless, given that broad enforcement of the state’s housing laws is critical, the author is encouraged to work with stakeholders to ensure nothing in this bill may have unintended consequences for the enforcement of other critical housing laws.
The scope of this bill may implicate local agencies without land use of development permitting authority. As currently in print, this bill applies to a large swatch of public agencies, essentially any governmental entity that is not a part of state government. The California Special Districts Association contends that this definition is overly broad and exposes local agencies without land use authority (notably most special districts) to liability under the bill. While the scope of what governmental agencies make a sufficient amount of local land use and housing permitting decisions to warrant inclusion in this bill is largely outside the jurisdiction of this Committee, the Special Districts’ argument is valid. Accordingly, should this bill advance the author may wish to consider narrowing the scope of entities subject to liability under this measure to focus on the agencies with significant land use and housing permitting authority.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is supported by a coalition of housing advocates and developers, led by the California Building Industry Association. A coalition letter in support of the bill states:
AB 712 appropriately enhances the rights of housing applicants by guaranteeing the recovery of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs when prevailing in actions against local agencies that fail to uphold housing reform laws. By also imposing financial penalties on non-compliant agencies, this bill creates a meaningful deterrent against unlawful delays and denials that have long hindered the construction of much-needed housing.
Furthermore, AB 712’s prohibition on indemnification clauses is a necessary step in preventing local governments from shifting legal liabilities onto developers. This protection ensures that developers can pursue lawful claims without fear of financial retaliation, fostering a fairer and more transparent housing approval process.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The measure is opposed by a coalition of local government agencies including the League of California Cities, the California Special Districts Association, and several local housing advocates. In opposition, unless amended, the League of California Cities writes:
We respectfully suggest that the bill begins with a faulty premise: That housing reform laws establish “applicant’s rights.” There are no “rights” established by housing reform law. Rather, “housing reform laws” impose certain procedural and substantive requirements on cities and counties when acting within the Constitution’s grant of the police power.
Under existing law, cities are subject to significant fines and penalties for violating certain housing laws. However, if a city violates the law, it is provided the opportunity to correct the violation before fines are imposed, Additionally, enhanced fines are not imposed unless the city fails to follow a court’s order or acts in bad faith. AB 712 goes beyond existing law and fails to recognize that there can be reasonable differences of opinion on the meaning and implementation of state housing laws. Providing cities with the opportunity to correct a violation – under court supervision – is ultimately a better way to achieve the goal of approving more housing.
AB 712 would increase the fines for violations of state law to include “any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribes, prohibits, or otherwise impose any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project”. This overly broad and vague definition can be interpreted in numerous ways, leading to inconsistent enforcement and unpredictable legal outcomes. Most importantly, it fails to give cities and counties adequate notice of what statutes are included. In order for fines to deter unlawful conduct, the range of the laws included must be clear. This lack of clarity could result in frequent legal challenges as cities attempt to navigate the uncertain parameters set forth by the measure. Consequently, local governments may be entangled in costly legal disputes, diverting resources from providing essential services to the community and local housing development efforts.
Instead of creating new fines and penalties and encouraging litigation, lawmakers and the Department of Housing and Community Development should provide technical assistance and resources to local governments to comply with new legislative requirements.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Abundant Housing LA
Bay Area Horseless Carriage Club of America
BOMA California
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Housing Action Coalition
NAIOP California
San Francisco Bay Area Planning & Urban Research Association
South Pasadena Residents for Responsible Growth
Southern California Leadership Council
The Two Hundred
Opposition
California Special Districts Association
City of Murrieta
League of California Cities (unless amended)
Livable California (unless amended)
Mission Street Neighbors
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2025
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Matt Haney, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 712 (
Author:Wicks) – As Amended Ver:March 10, 2025
SUBJECT: Housing reform laws: enforcement actions: fines and penalties
SUMMARY: Establishes additional financial penalties that must be imposed by a court in actions brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a “housing reform law,” as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other law, and in addition to any other available remedies, in any action brought by an applicant for a housing development project against a public agency to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party, the following apply:
- The applicant shall be entitled to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs;
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency:
- If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the Housing Accountability Act (HAA); and
- If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court must impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in the HAA multiplied by a factor of five.
- In the case of an action against a public agency that is a local agency, notwithstanding existing law governing the presentation and consideration of claims against public entities, the applicant is not required to present a claim to seek the fines in 1) b) above.
- Prohibits a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing development project to indemnify, defend, or hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant, or any other person, alleging that the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of the benefits or protections provided by a housing reform law.
- Declares that a requirement, condition of approval, or agreement in violation of 2) above is against public policy and void and unenforceable.
- Provides that 2) and 3) above shall not be construed to derogate any claim that a requirement in 2) above is or was unlawful under previously existing law.
- Defines, for purposes of the bill, “housing development project” to mean a use consisting of residential units only, mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses that meet specified square footage ratios, transitional or supportive housing, or farmworker housing.
- Defines, for purposes of the bill, “housing reform law” to mean any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribe, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The requirement for local governments to have a substantially compliant housing element and to not take actions or fail to act in a manner inconsistent with an adopted housing element;
- The HAA;
- Requirements in housing element law for local governments to maintain adequate sites to accommodate their remaining share of regional housing needs and “no net loss” provisions;
- Density bonus law;
- Provisions of law that prohibit jurisdictions from discriminating against developments and shelters or imposing more burdensome requirements due to the characteristics of residents or the method of financing;
- The Housing Crisis Act (HCA) of 2019;
- Requirements for public agencies to affirmatively further fair housing;
- The streamlined, ministerial approval process for mixed-income housing established by SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017);
- The streamlined, ministerial approval process for supportive housing established by AB 2162 (Chiu, Chapter 753, Statutes of 2018);
- The streamlined, ministerial approval process for Low Barrier Navigation Centers, as specified;
- Minimum standards relating to Floor Area Ratios and lot sizes, as specified;
- Annual Progress Report (APR) requirements;
- Minimum parking requirements;
- The Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act of 2022;
- The five-hearing maximum rule and reasonable person standard for consistency with local standards under the HCA of 2019;
- Accessory dwelling unit and junior accessory dwelling unit law;
- Provisions allowing duplexes and lot splits established by SB 9 (Atkins), Chapter 162, Statutes of 2021;
- The Middle Class Housing Act of 2022;
- The Affordable Housing on Faith and Higher Education Lands Act of 2023;
- Provisions prohibiting the demolition of housing units under the HCA of 2019;
- Provisions requiring issuance of building permits for certain projects of 10 units or fewer with tentative subdivision maps established by SB 684 (Caballero), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2023;
- The streamlined, ministerial approval process for certain subdivided lots established by SB 684 (Caballero);
- The Starter Home Revitalization Act of 2021;
- The Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention program;
- The Encampment Resolution Funding program;
- The Family Homelessness Challenge Grants and Technical Assistance Program;
- The Permit Streamlining Act;
- Postentitlement phase permit timelines and standards, as specified;
- Postentitlement phase permit and service request standards for special districts, as specified;
- Limitations on replacement of religious-use parking spaces in housing development projects, as specified;
- Provisions allowing parties to challenge the imposition of fees, dedications, reservations, or exactions on housing development projects, as specified; and
- Provisions allowing parties to challenge the imposition of fees, taxes, assessments, dedications, reservations, or other exactions, as specified.
- Provides that the specific identification of any law, regulation, or provision in the definition of “housing reform law” under 6) above shall not be interpreted to limit the scope of “housing reform law” under the bill.
- Defines, for purposes of the bill, “local agency” to mean any public agency other than a state agency;
- Defines, for purposes of the bill, “planning period” to mean the time period between the due date for one housing element and the due date for the next housing element for each revision according to the applicable schedule, as specified;
- Defines, for purposes of the bill, “public agency” to mean any state agency, any county, city and county, city, regional agency, public district, redevelopment agency, or other political subdivision.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the HAA, which prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or conditioning approval in a manner that renders the project or shelter infeasible unless it makes written findings based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record as to one of several specified justifications for the denial. (Government Code (GOV) Section 65589.5(d))
- Allows the project applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce the HAA. Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner if certain conditions are met, unless the court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA, or in certain cases concerning specified disapprovals. (GOV 65589.5(k)(1)(A))
- Requires a court, upon a determination that a local agency has failed to comply with an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within the time period prescribed by the court, to impose fines on the local agency and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied into a local housing trust fund or the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. Requires the fine to be in a minimum amount of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete. Requires the court, in determining the amount of the fine to impose, to consider the local agency’s progress in attaining its allocation of regional housing need and any prior violations of the HAA. Prohibits fines from being paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, as specified. (GOV 65589.5(k)(1)(B))
- Requires a court, if it finds that a local agency acted in bad faith when it violated the HAA and failed to carry out the court’s order or judgment in the time period prescribed by the court, to multiply the fine in 3) above by a factor of five. If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the HAA within the same planning period, requires the court to multiply the fines by an additional factor for each previous violation. (GOV 65589.5(l))
- Requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the office of the AG, if HCD finds that:
- A housing element does not substantially comply with state law; and
- Any local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. (GOV 65585(j))
- Requires HCD, prior to the AG bringing any suit for a violation of the provisions of specified housing laws, to offer the jurisdiction the opportunity for two meetings in person or via telephone to discuss the violation, and to provide the jurisdiction written findings regarding the violation, with some exceptions. (GOV 65585(k))
- Grants HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, and grants the AG this unconditional right whether intervening in an independent capacity or pursuant to a notice or referral from HCD. (GOV 65585.01)
- Provides that in any action brought by the AG or HCD to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a city, county, or local agency to ministerially approve, without discretionary review, any planning or permitting application for a housing development project, the city, county, or local agency shall be subject to the following remedies:
- A civil penalty of, at minimum, $10,000 per month, and not exceeding $50,000 per month, for each violation, accrued from the date of the violation until the violation is cured;
- All costs of investigating and prosecuting the action, including expert fees, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs, whenever the AG or HCD prevails in a civil action to enforce any state laws under this provision; and
- Other relief as the court deems appropriate, including equitable and injunctive relief, provisional or otherwise. (GOV 65009.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “The Legislature has successfully passed a variety of housing laws to make it easier to build in California. However, these laws need to be enforceable, and have real consequences when they are broken. Some of our housing laws (notably the Housing Accountability Act) have strong enforcement provisions, but others do not. AB 712 would extend the enforcement provisions of the Housing Accountability Act to other state laws, thereby encouraging local agencies to act in compliance with existing state housing laws. Additionally, AB 712 would end the practice of public agencies asking housing development applicants to indemnify the local government against lawsuits when the local government violates the applicant’s rights. This will result in more certainty for all parties, and more housing in California.”
Housing Accountability Act (HAA): In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the HAA. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the jurisdiction’s share of regional housing need or emergency shelters without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a jurisdiction’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the locality’s share of the regional housing need.
The HAA provides a private right of action to parties, including the development proponent, a person who would be eligible to live in the proposed development, or a housing organization, who wish to challenge a local government that denied approval or imposed severely burdensome conditions for approval on a housing development project.
If a locality denies approval or imposes conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial or imposition of conditions is subject to a court challenge, the burden is on the local government to show that its decision is consistent with specified written findings.
If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff is entitled to attorney’s fees unless the court find that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court must impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which must be deposited in a local housing trust fund or the state Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The court may also directly approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court must multiply the fine by a factor of five.
State Enforcement of Housing Laws: In recent years, the Legislature has implemented many policy changes to address the housing deficit, including streamlined, ministerial approval of housing and requiring local governments to plan and zone for more housing via the housing element process. For many years prior to the enactment of these and other laws, local governments often treated the housing element and other housing requirements as a “paper exercise” because the state lacked strong enforcement tools to ensure compliance.
AB 72 (Santiago), Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017 established a process for HCD to enforce many state housing laws. The law requires HCD to notify a local government, and allows HCD to notify the AG, if HCD finds that a local government’s housing element does not substantially comply with state law, or if a local government has taken an action in violation of specified housing laws. HCD must offer verbal and written consultations and technical assistance to the jurisdiction before referring them for enforcement action.
In addition to the expanded authority under AB 72, HCD has created and staffed a Housing Accountability Unit (HAU), which provides education and technical assistance as well as oversight and enforcement of housing element laws to ensure local governments comply with specified housing laws. Violations of these laws may lead to a variety of consequences for local governments, including referral to the AG for further civil action.
Some of these laws, similar to the HAA, also provide a mechanism for private third party actors – for example, developers and project applicants, housing advocacy organizations, and members of the public – to file their own lawsuits to challenge local land use planning and permitting decisions. In 2023, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 1485 (Haney), Chapter 763, which also granted HCD and the AG the unconditional right to intervene in any suit brought to enforce specified housing laws, to ensure that the state’s interests are heard as a matter of right in private litigation dealing with the application of those laws.
There have been further efforts to add more “teeth” to state law to deter bad actors from continuing to obstruct housing development, including SB 1037 (Wiener), Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024, which established minimum civil fines and attorney fee awards in cases where the AG or HCD are acting to enforce housing element law or state laws that require ministerial approval of housing development projects, and AB 1633 (Ting), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023, which expanded the definition of local agency “disapproval” of projects under the HAA.
Private Enforcement: While the AG and HCD have enforcement authority over and have stepped up efforts to monitor compliance with a number of housing laws, they do not have infinite resources with which to monitor the extremely high volume of regional and local public agency meetings and thousands of different development applications that may be proceeding in any given month or year. This necessarily leads to some targeting of the most egregious or flagrant violations of law, or actions that could be precedent-setting or otherwise resolve a question of law. HCD’s accountability unit works to provide technical assistance as much as possible and intakes complaints from members of the public and developers about potential violations of housing laws, but is not in the practice of bringing a full legal case for every single violation or possible violation.
However, housing developers face a difficult set of circumstances at the local or regional level when they are faced with a recalcitrant agency. Because they are often “repeat customers” in a jurisdiction and are reliant on an agency for essential approvals of the project in question and future projects they might wish to bring forward, they are reluctant to sue and possibly damage their relationships with these entities in cases where the agency is not following the law. The author and sponsor also point out that some agencies have begun requiring developers to indemnify them from the lawsuits the developers may end up deciding to bring if those agencies break housing laws, and even requiring developers to pay for the legal fees incurred by the agency. At the same time, only a limited number of housing statutes (like the HAA) allow an applicant who is a prevailing party to recoup attorney’s fees, making the prospect of litigation even less appealing to a project proponent.
This bill would require a court to award a housing developer reasonable attorney’s fees in cases where they are the prevailing party over a public agency in an action brought to enforce a housing reform law. Importantly, this bill would not create or expand standing for any developer or housing organization where it does not already exist in statute. AB 712 (Wicks) would also prohibit a public agency from requiring an applicant for a housing project to indemnify, defend, or otherwise hold harmless the public agency in any manner with respect to an action brought by the applicant or any other person alleging the public agency violated the applicant’s rights or deprived the applicant of benefits or rights established by housing laws.
In order to create a more effective deterrent for recalcitrant local agencies, the bill would also apply HAA fines in cases where the applicant prevails over a local agency and the agency was advised in writing by either the AG or HCD prior to the lawsuit that the agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in the same manner that is alleged in the applicant’s lawsuit. If the local agency has violated the same statute more than once in the same housing element cycle, the court must multiply the HAA fine by a factor of five.
Arguments in Support: According to the California Building Industry Association, the bill’s sponsor, “With very limited exceptions, enforcement of housing reform laws relies on housing project applicants to sue the offending public agency. However, applicants are reluctant to vindicate these rights because litigation is expensive, and the applicant must maintain cordial relationships with agencies that have permitting authority over current and future housing projects. Moreover, unlike opponents of housing projects who typically are awarded attorney’s fees if they successfully sue to block a housing project, project applicants generally do not recover their attorney’s fees when they are the successful party, with the limited exception of suits under the Housing Accountability Act. Further undermining housing law enforcement, there are no effective penalties to deter public agencies from forcing applicants to file lawsuits over the same issue even after the public agency has consistently lost in court and committed violations after having been warned in writing by the Attorney General or [HCD]. […] AB 712 would address these problems and significantly increase the enforcement and effectiveness of housing reform laws…”
Arguments in Opposition: According to the California Special Districts Association, “AB 712 would create a right to attorneys’ fees and costs for an applicant in any action brought by the applicant for a housing development project against a public agency, including a special district, to enforce a housing reform law, where the applicant is the prevailing party. This one-sided right, for which indemnification is prohibited by the bill, would place local agencies legitimately defending their decisions in court at a disadvantage, with the burden shifted to taxpayers and ratepayers. AB 712’s provisions for fines, which may be sought without regard to requirements of the Government Claims Act, based on an applicant prevailing on claims substantially the same as prior written advisements by the Attorney General (AG) or the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) similarly exposes well intentioned local agencies, taxpayers and ratepayers, to significant financial risk while placing local agencies legitimately defending their decisions at a disadvantage.”
Committee Amendments: Staff recommends the following amendments:
- The HAA’s fine structure is a minimum of $10,000 per unit in the proposed development. For smaller projects, like an individual ADU or SB 9 duplex, the minimum fine of $10,000 multiplied by one or two units may not provide a significant enough deterrent to dissuade bad actors from disregarding the written advice of HCD or the AG regarding the violation of law. Staff recommend the following amendment in Section 1 of the bill to create a $50,000 minimum fine for violations involving projects of four units or fewer:
GOV 65914.2. (b) (2) (A) (i) If the local agency was advised in writing prior to the commencement of the action by either the Attorney General or the Department of Housing and Community Development that the local agency’s decision, action, or inaction would represent a violation of law in substantially the same manner as alleged by the applicant in its lawsuit, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5, unless the housing development project consists of four units or fewer, in which case the court shall impose a minimum fine of $50,000 per violation.
(ii) If a court has previously found that the local agency violated the same statute on which the applicant prevailed in its lawsuit, within the same planning period, the court shall impose a fine in an amount not less than the minimum fines described in subparagraph (i) subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) of Section 65589.5 multiplied by a factor of five.
- The bill’s proposed definition of “housing reform law” references the list of statutes in subdivision (j) of GOV 65585 which HCD and the AG have enforcement authority over and which establishes certain practices HCD must undertake in notifying local governments of possible violations of those statutes. However, not all of the statutes identified in that subdivision are statutes that establish or facilitate rights for applicants for housing development projects – for example, the list also includes Annual Progress Report requirements and certain homelessness funding programs. In addition, enumerating a list of statutes that fall into the proposed “housing reform law” bucket means the Legislature may have to revisit the list of included statutes as additional laws are enacted or sunset, possibly very frequently. Staff recommends striking the listing of statutes from the definition and instead leaving the applicant to identify the specific alleged statutory violations in question in the action itself, as follows:
GOV 65914.2. (d) (2) (A) “Housing reform law” means any law or regulation, or provision of any law or regulation, that establishes or facilitates rights, safeguards, streamlining benefits, time limitations, or other protections for the benefit of applicants for housing development projects, or restricts, proscribe, prohibits, or otherwise imposes any procedural or substantive limitation on a public agency for the benefit of a housing development project., including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(i) The provisions identified in subdivision (j) of Section 65585.
(ii) The Permit Streamlining Act (Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 65920)).
(iii) Section 65913.3.
(iv) Section 65913.3.1.
(v) Section 65913.6.
(vi) Any provision under which relief is sought pursuant to Section 66020 or 66021.
(B) The specific identification of any law, regulation, or provision in this paragraph shall not be interpreted to limit the scope of “housing reform law” as used in this section.
Related Legislation:
SB 1037 (Wiener), Chapter 293, Statutes of 2024: Created new legal remedies that can be used by the AG to enforce the adoption of housing element revisions or to enforce any state law that requires a local government to ministerially approve any decision or application for a housing development project.
AB 1633 (Ting), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023: Expanded the definition of a “disapproval” under the HAA, until 2031.
AB 215 (Chiu), Chapter 342, Statutes of 2021: Provided HCD with additional enforcement authority over local agency violations of specified housing laws.
AB 72 (Santiago), Chapter 370, Statutes of 2017: Provided HCD the authority to find a local government’s housing element out of substantial compliance if it determines that the local government acts or fails to act in compliance with its housing element, and allows HCD to refer violations of law to the AG.
Double-referred: This bill was also referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary where it will be heard should it pass out of this committee
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Building Industry Association (Sponsor)
Abundant Housing LA
BOMA California
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
Housing Action Coalition
NAIOP California
SPUR
The Two Hundred
Opposition
California Special Districts
Oppose Unless Amended
Livable California
Analysis Prepared by: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):