ACR 95: American Flag.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-16
This measure would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture, that it represents the values of freedom and liberty, and would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property.
This measure would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture, that it represents the values of freedom and liberty, and would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property.
This measure would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture, that it represents the values of freedom and liberty, and would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property.
This measure would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture, that it represents the values of freedom and liberty, and would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property.
WHEREAS, On June 14th, 1777, in the midst of the American Revolutionary War, the Continental Congress adopted a resolution stating that the flag of the United States be thirteen alternate stripes red and white and that the Union be thirteen stars, white in a blue field, representing a new Constellation; and
WHEREAS, On September 14th, 1814, American soldiers under siege at Fort McHenry in Baltimore, Maryland raised a huge American flag to celebrate a crucial victory over British forces during the War of 1812, inspiring Francis Scott Key to write a poem that eventually became the words of the United States National Anthem; and
WHEREAS, On June 6th, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the Stars and Stripes landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation; and
WHEREAS, On February 23rd, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 United States service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
WHEREAS, On July 20, 1969, astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first human beings to set foot on the surface of the moon, where they placed the American flag. There, the flag has stood a decades-long vigil upon the Sea of Tranquility as a gesture of peace for all mankind; and
WHEREAS, On September 11th, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; and
WHEREAS, In 2015, the United States of America will provide $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world through the efforts of over 20 different government agencies. These investments will further Americas foreign policy interests on issues ranging from expanding free markets, combating extremism, and ensuring stable democracies, to addressing the root causes of poverty, while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed image of global good will; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly of the State of California, the Senate thereof concurring, That the Legislature declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of the resolution to the author for appropriate distribution.
WHEREAS, On June 14th, 1777, in the midst of the American Revolutionary War, the Continental Congress adopted a resolution stating that the flag of the United States be thirteen alternate stripes red and white and that the Union be thirteen stars, white in a blue field, representing a new Constellation; and
WHEREAS, On September 14th, 1814, American soldiers under siege at Fort McHenry in Baltimore, Maryland raised a huge American flag to celebrate a crucial victory over British forces during the War of 1812, inspiring Francis Scott Key to write a poem that eventually became the words of the United States National Anthem; and
WHEREAS, On June 6th, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the Stars and Stripes landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation; and
WHEREAS, On February 23rd, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 United States service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
WHEREAS, On July 20, 1969, astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first human beings to set foot on the surface of the moon, where they placed the American flag. There, the flag has stood a decades-long vigil upon the Sea of Tranquility as a gesture of peace for all mankind; and
WHEREAS, On September 11th, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; and
WHEREAS, In 2015, the United States of America will provide $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world through the efforts of over 20 different government agencies. These investments will further Americas foreign policy interests on issues ranging from expanding free markets, combating extremism, and ensuring stable democracies, to addressing the root causes of poverty, while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed image of global good will; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly of the State of California, the Senate thereof concurring, That the Legislature declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of the resolution to the author for appropriate distribution.
WHEREAS, On June 14th, 1777, in the midst of the American Revolutionary War, the Continental Congress adopted a resolution stating that the flag of the United States be thirteen alternate stripes red and white and that the Union be thirteen stars, white in a blue field, representing a new Constellation; and
WHEREAS, On September 14th, 1814, American soldiers under siege at Fort McHenry in Baltimore, Maryland raised a huge American flag to celebrate a crucial victory over British forces during the War of 1812, inspiring Francis Scott Key to write a poem that eventually became the words of the United States National Anthem; and
WHEREAS, On June 6th, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the Stars and Stripes landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation; and
WHEREAS, On February 23rd, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 United States service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
WHEREAS, On July 20, 1969, astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first human beings to set foot on the surface of the moon, where they placed the American flag. There, the flag has stood a decades-long vigil upon the Sea of Tranquility as a gesture of peace for all mankind; and
WHEREAS, On September 11th, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; now, therefore, be it and
WHEREAS, In 2015, the United States of America will provide $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world through the efforts of over 20 different government agencies. These investments will further Americas foreign policy interests on issues ranging from expanding free markets, combating extremism, and ensuring stable democracies, to addressing the root causes of poverty, while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed image of global good will; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly of the State of California, the Senate thereof concurring, That the Legislature declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of the resolution to the author for appropriate distribution distribution.
WHEREAS, On June 14th, 1777, in the midst of the American Revolutionary War, the Continental Congress adopted a resolution stating that the flag of the United States be thirteen alternate stripes red and white and that the Union be thirteen stars, white in a blue field, representing a new Constellation; and
WHEREAS, On September 14th, 1814, American soldiers under siege at Fort McHenry in Baltimore, Maryland raised a huge American flag to celebrate a crucial victory over British forces during the War of 1812, inspiring Francis Scott Key to write a poem that eventually became the words of the United States National Anthem; and
WHEREAS, On June 6th, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the Stars and Stripes landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation; and
WHEREAS, On February 23rd, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 United States service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
WHEREAS, On September 11th, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly of the State of California, the Senate thereof concurring, That the Legislature declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of Californias rich history, tradition, and culture; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of the resolution to the author for appropriate distribution
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2016 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Res. Chapter 115, Statutes of 2016. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Adopted and to Assembly. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 4869.) |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Adopted and to Assembly. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jun 30, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 29, 2016 | From committee: Be adopted. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Mar 31, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 10, 2016 | Adopted and to Senate. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 3891.) |
| Mar 10, 2016 | In Senate. To Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 10, 2016 | Adopted and to Senate. |
| Mar 8, 2016 | From committee: Be adopted. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (March 8). |
| Aug 25, 2015 | In committee: Hearing cancelled at the request of author. |
| Jul 14, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Amended. |
| Jul 9, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 6, 2015 | From printer. |
| Jul 2, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Consent Calendar 2nd ACR95 Mathis | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Be adopted and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 10, 2016 | ACR 95 MATHIS Consent Calendar Second Day | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 8, 2016 | Be adopted. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | ACR |
CONSENT
Bill No: ACR 95
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 3/10/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This resolution declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture and that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty. This resolution also calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
Existing law:
- Provides as a matter of federal law that the flag should be displayed daily on or near the main administration building of every public institution and also provides that the flag should be displayed during school days in or near every schoolhouse. (4 U.S.C. Sec. 6(e), (g).)
- Requires, as a matter of state law, that the American and California State flags be prominently displayed during business hours upon or in front of the buildings or grounds of, or at specified places, including: at the entrance or upon the grounds of each campus of the University of California (UC) and at the entrance or upon the grounds or upon the administration building of every university, college, high school, and elementary school, both public and private, within the State.
- Provides that no person, private entity, or governmental agency shall adopt any rule, regulation, or ordinance, or enter into any agreement or covenant, that prevents any person or private entity that would otherwise have the legal right to display a U.S. flag on private property from exercising that right, unless it is used as, or in conjunction with, an advertising display. Existing law further provides, however, that this shall not be construed to prevent a city, county, or city and county from imposing reasonable restrictions as to the time, place, and manner of placement or display of a Flag of the United States when necessary for the preservation of the public’s health, safety, or order.
- Prohibits a local government agency from adopting any policy or regulation that prohibits or restricts an employee of that agency from displaying a U.S. flag, or a pin of that flag, on his or her person, in his or her workplace, or on a local government agency vehicle operated by that employee. Existing law further provides, however, that this shall not be construed to prevent a local government agency from imposing reasonable restrictions as to the time, place, and manner of placement or display of a U.S. flag when necessary for the preservation of the order or discipline of the workplace.
This resolution:
- States, among other things:
- On June 6, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the “Stars and Stripes” landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation;
- On February 23, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 U.S. service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
- On July 20, 1969, astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first human beings to set foot on the surface of the moon, where they placed the American flag. There, the flag has stood a decades-long vigil upon the Sea of Tranquility as a gesture of peace for all mankind;
- On September 11, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; and
- In 2015, the U.S. will provide $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world through the efforts of over 20 different government agencies. These investments will further America’s foreign policy interests on issues ranging from expanding free markets, combating extremism, and ensuring stable democracies, to addressing the root causes of poverty, while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed image of global good will.
- Declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture and represents the values of freedom and liberty, and calls upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
Background
Earlier this year, a UC campus student group narrowly passed a resolution that resolved to make the Associated Students main lobby space as inclusive as possible and, as a result, to ban the flags of any nation from the lobby area of student government offices. (See Associated Students of UC Irvine (ASUCI) R50-70 <http://www.asuci.uci.edu/legislative/legislations/R50-70.html [as of Jun. 13, 2015].) Like resolutions passed in this body, the student group’s resolution made various statements supporting the action, including that:
- Flags are a symbol of a nation, are used as decorations and have a wide range of cultural significance;
- Flags are typically viewed as patriotic symbols of a single nation, are often associated with government and military due to their history and have a wide variety of interpretations;
- Flags not only serve as symbols of patriotism or weapons for nationalism, but also construct cultural mythologies and narratives that in turn charge nationalistic sentiments;
- Flags function specifically for a nation and people are assimilated into national ideologies by deployment of this cultural artifact;
- Flags construct paradigms of conformity and sets homogenized standards for others to obtain which in this country typically are idolized as freedom, equality, and democracy;
- Symbolism is interpreted differently by different groups or persons based on individual unique experiences;
- A common ideological understanding of the United [S]tates includes American exceptionalism and superiority;
- The American flag has been flown in instances of colonialism and imperialism;
- Symbolism has negative and positive aspects that are interpreted differently by individuals;
- Displaying a flag does not express only selective aspects of its symbolism but the entire spectrum of its interpretation;
- Designing a culturally inclusive space is taken seriously by ASUCI;
- Designing a culturally inclusive space aims to remove barriers that create undue effort and separation by planning and designing spaces that enable everyone to participate equally and confidently;
- Designers should be careful about using cultural symbols as the symbols will inherently remain open for interpretation;
- A high-quality culturally inclusive space is essential in any society that embodies a dynamic and multifaceted culture;
- Freedom of speech is a valued right that ASUCI supports; and
- Freedom of speech, in a space that aims to be as inclusive as possible can be interpreted as hate speech. (Id.)
The ASUCI resolution triggered enormous controversy and widespread news coverage, and even resulted in security concerns for the students involved, prompting the cancellation of the school’s legislative council meeting in the immediate aftermath. According to reports, by the next day, it had formed a trending topic on Twitter and many students and faculty members across the campus denounced the idea. Notably, the resolution has never taken effect as the Executive Cabinet of the student government promptly vetoed the ban on the display of flags within two days of its passage. (See Shine and McGreevy, Does UC Irvine Hate the American Flag? Not Exactly, Los Angeles Times (Mar. 10, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-does-uc-irvine-hate-the-american-flag-not-exactly-20150310-story.html [as of Jun. 13, 2016].)
Last year, two days after the ASUCI resolution was vetoed, a Senate Constitutional Amendment, SCA 2 (Nguyen, 2015) was introduced in this Legislature, seeking to put forth a constitutional amendment for consideration by voters, which would make the prohibition of a display of the U.S. flag on the grounds of a UC, California State University, or California Community College campus unconstitutional. That measure was ultimately heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee, but was held without a vote, pursuant to the author’s request.
This resolution now seeks to enact a concurrent resolution declaring that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture, represents the values of freedom and liberty, and calling upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from certain public property, including not only schools, but also state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
Comments
As stated by the author:
In March 2015, the Legislative Council of the Associated Students of the University of California, Irvine (ASUCI) passed a resolution aimed at removing the American flag from the lobby of a building housing the offices of student government by banning all flags from the lobby. The vote caused a public uproar, and the executive cabinet of ASUCI vetoed the action days later. [ACR 95:]
- Resolves that the American Flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture; additionally, it declares that the American Flag represents the values of freedom and liberty.
- Resolves that the Legislature calls upon the State and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American Flag from public property, to include but not limited to: public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
In support, a coalition of veterans groups writes that their members “put their lives on the line serving this country under the Red, White & Blue and do not believe that governmental entities should disrespect or ban our nation’s colors! Too many lives have been lost fighting for this nation, for our freedom and liberty under that flag.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Local: No
American G.I. Forum of California
American Legion, Department of California
AMVETS, Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California State Commanders Veterans Council
Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters
Veterans of Foreign Wars, Department of California
Vietnam Veterans of America, California State Council
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 3/10/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chiu, Gallagher, Roger Hernández, O'Donnell
Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
7/29/16 10:50:10
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: ACR 95 (Author:Mathis)
Version: July 13, 2015
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: RD
SUBJECT
American Flag
DESCRIPTION
This concurrent resolution would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture and that the Legislature declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty. This measure would also call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
BACKGROUND
Earlier this year, a University of California (UC) campus student group narrowly passed a resolution that resolved to make the Associated Students main lobby space as inclusive as possible and, as a result, to ban the flags of any nation from the lobby area of student government offices. (See Associated Students of UC Irvine (ASUCI) R50-70 <http://www.asuci.uci.edu/legislative/legislations/R50-70.html> [as of Jun. 13, 2015].) Like resolutions passed in this body, the student group’s resolution made various statements supporting the action. The statements included:
- flags are a symbol of a nation, are used as decorations and have a wide range of cultural significance;
- flags are typically viewed as patriotic symbols of a single nation, are often associated with government and military due to their history and have a wide variety of interpretations;
- flags not only serve as symbols of patriotism or weapons for nationalism, but also construct cultural mythologies and narratives that in turn charge nationalistic sentiments;
- flags function specifically for a nation and people are assimilated into national ideologies by deployment of this cultural artifact;
- flags construct paradigms of conformity and sets homogenized standards for others to obtain which in this country typically are idolized as freedom, equality, and democracy;
- symbolism is interpreted differently by different groups or persons based on individual unique experiences;
- a common ideological understanding of the United [S]tates includes American exceptionalism and superiority;
- the American flag has been flown in instances of colonialism and imperialism;
- symbolism has negative and positive aspects that are interpreted differently by individuals;
- displaying a flag does not express only selective aspects of its symbolism but the entire spectrum of its interpretation;
- designing a culturally inclusive space is taken seriously by ASUCI;
- designing a culturally inclusive space aims to remove barriers that create undue effort and separation by planning and designing spaces that enable everyone to participate equally and confidently;
- designers should be careful about using cultural symbols as the symbols will inherently remain open for interpretation;
- a high-quality culturally inclusive space is essential in any society that embodies a dynamic and multifaceted culture;
- freedom of speech is a valued right that ASUCI supports; and
- freedom of speech, in a space that aims to be as inclusive as possible can be interpreted as hate speech. (Id.)
The ASUCI resolution triggered enormous controversy and widespread news coverage, and even resulted in security concerns for the students involved, prompting the cancellation of the school’s legislative council meeting in the immediate aftermath. According to reports, by the next day, it had formed a trending topic on Twitter and many students and faculty members across the campus denounced the idea. Notably, the resolution has never taken effect as the Executive Cabinet of the student government promptly vetoed the ban on the display of flags within two days of its passage. (See Shine and McGreevy, Does UC Irvine Hate the American Flag? Not Exactly, Los Angeles Times (Mar. 10, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-does-uc-irvine-hate-the-american-flag-not-exactly-20150310-story.html> [as of Jun. 13, 2016].)
Last year, two days after the ASUCI resolution was vetoed, a Senate Constitutional Amendment, SCA 2 (Nguyen, 2015) was introduced in this Legislature, seeking to put forth a constitutional amendment for consideration by voters, which would make the prohibition of a display of the U.S. flag on the grounds of a UC, California State University, or California Community College campus unconstitutional. That measure was ultimately heard in this Committee, but was held without a vote, pursuant to the author’s request.
This measure now seeks to enact a concurrent resolution declaring that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture, represents the values of freedom and liberty, and calling upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from certain public property, including not only schools, but also state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law provides that the flag should be displayed daily on or near the main administration building of every public institution and also provides that the flag should be displayed during school days in or near every schoolhouse. (4 U.S.C. Sec. 6(e), (g).)
Existing California law requires the American and California State flags be prominently displayed during business hours upon or in front of the buildings or grounds of, or at specified places, including: at the entrance or upon the grounds of each campus of the University of California and at the entrance or upon the grounds or upon the administration building of every university, college, high school, and elementary school, both public and private, within the State. (Gov. Code Sec. 431(c), (d).)
Existing law provides that no person, private entity, or governmental agency shall adopt any rule, regulation, or ordinance, or enter into any agreement or covenant, that prevents any person or private entity that would otherwise have the legal right to display a U.S. flag on private property from exercising that right, unless it is used as, or in conjunction with, an advertising display. Existing law further provides, however, that this shall not be construed to prevent a city, county, or city and county from imposing reasonable restrictions as to the time, place, and manner of placement or display of a Flag of the United States when necessary for the preservation of the public’s health, safety, or order. (Gov. Code Sec. 434.5(b).)
Existing law prohibits a local government agency from adopting any policy or regulation that prohibits or restricts an employee of that agency from displaying a U.S. flag, or a pin of that flag, on his or her person, in his or her workplace, or on a local government agency vehicle operated by that employee. Existing law further provides, however, that this shall not be construed to prevent a local government agency from imposing reasonable restrictions as to the time, place, and manner of placement or display of a U.S. flag when necessary for the preservation of the order or discipline of the workplace. (Gov. Code Sec. 434.5(c).)
This resolution would state, among other things:
- on June 6th, 1944, more than 160,000 American and Allied troops carrying the “Stars and Stripes” landed along a 50-mile stretch of heavily fortified French coastline in Normandy to liberate Europe from the forces of Nazi Germany. More than 9,000 Allied soldiers were killed or wounded on D-Day to free Europe from fascist occupation;
- on February 23rd, 1945, five Marines and a Navy Corpsman raised the American flag atop Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima. It was a hard-fought victory over imperialism at the cost of 5,900 U.S. service members killed and 17,400 wounded against 23,000 Japanese army and naval forces fighting from an entrenched network of caves, dugouts, tunnels and underground installations; and
- on July 20, 1969, astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first human beings to set foot on the surface of the moon, where they placed the American flag. There, the flag has stood a decades-long vigil upon the Sea of Tranquility as a gesture of peace for all mankind;
- on September 11th, 2001, in the aftermath of the terrorist attack which destroyed the World Trade Center, three New York City firefighters, George Johnson of Rockaway Beach, Ladder 157, Dan McWilliams of Long Island, Ladder 157, and Billy Eisengrein of Staten Island, Rescue 2, raised the American flag over the smoldering ruins of Ground Zero where the Twin Towers once stood. It was an act of defiance against those who sought to break the unconquerable values of freedom and liberty which the American flag represents; and
- in 2015, the U.S. will provide $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world through the efforts of over 20 different government agencies. These investments will further America’s foreign policy interests on issues ranging from expanding free markets, combating extremism, and ensuring stable democracies, to addressing the root causes of poverty, while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed image of global good will.
This measure would declare that the American flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture and represents the values of freedom and liberty. This measure would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
In March 2015, the Legislative Council of the Associated Students of the University of California, Irvine (ASUCI) passed a resolution aimed at removing the American flag from the lobby of a building housing the offices of student government by banning all flags from the lobby. The vote caused a public uproar, and the executive cabinet of ASUCI vetoed the action days later. [ACR 95:]
- Resolves that the American Flag is an inseparable part of California’s rich history, tradition, and culture; additionally, it declares that the American Flag represents the values of freedom and liberty.
- Resolves that the Legislature calls upon the State and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American Flag from public property, to include but not limited to: public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
3. First Amendment implications of potential laws passed in furtherance of this bill
Though it is unclear whether governmental entities are actively banning the flag on public grounds in California, this concurrent resolution would call upon the state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from certain public property, including not only schools, but also state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
At the outset, it should be noted that not all government properties are treated the same for First Amendment analysis. Some types of property are considered traditional public forums; some, limited public forums; and yet others, nonpublic forums. A public park, for example, is considered the most traditional public forum. There, while government can impose reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions, it cannot impose content-based restrictions.
As a practical matter, flags convey messages and, in that regard, can be as expressive as artwork or clothing. While the state, as the speaker, can decide which speech to engage in, or not engage in, when it picks what flag to fly upon public property, this resolution calls for state and local laws that would prohibit the banning of the American flag on certain public property. First, it is not clear that the ultimate “speaker” subject to any prohibition of flag banning would necessarily be the government entity itself or might somehow affect private individuals as well. By its terms, the resolution calls for laws prohibiting “government entities” from banning the flag. However, given that the author cites the activities of a student group at a public university as the impetus for this bill, the resolution could feasibly be interpreted to call for broader application. Second, it is not clear if this resolution seeks to encourage blanket prohibitions against the banning of the flag, would include a prohibition of any reasonable time, place and manner restrictions, or if this resolution seeks to encourage limited prohibitions of blanket bans. Lastly, it is not entirely clear that any law adopted could lawfully prohibit the banning of the U.S. flag, and the U.S. flag alone.
The U.S. Supreme Court has held on numerous occasions that at the very core of the First Amendment is the principle that the government may not regulate speech based on its content, and that content-based restrictions are presumptively invalid. (See RAV v. City of St. Paul (1992) 505 U.S. 377, 382.) A law regulating speech is content-neutral if it applies to all speech regardless of the message. A law making all picketing, except labor picketing, unconstitutional, would be content-based. A law prohibiting anti-war protests would be both content-based and a viewpoint regulation. So, too, would a law that prohibits any speech about war (subject matter regulation). In contrast, a law prohibiting the posting of all signs on public utility poles would be content and viewpoint neutral. For example, a problem could arise if a public park had to allow one group to display the American flag (because of a law prohibiting the banning of the flag), but deny another group’s request to display a different flag, which is feared to potentially incite anger, violence, or political controversy. Whereas a policy prohibiting the display of all flags in a public park by users of the park would be an example of a content-neutral and viewpoint neutral restriction, a policy prohibiting the display of all flags except the American flag, would not.
Staff notes that it remains unclear whether a state or local law prohibiting a government entity from banning the U.S. flag from public property would have addressed the ASUCI example cited by the author. (See Comment 1; see also Background for more on that incident.) Moreover, consistent with the principles outlined, above, it should be noted that the student resolution that this measure is brought in response to, prohibited the display of all flags, not just the American flag, in what appears to be a content-neutral and viewpoint neutral manner, from a specific area on the campus (a main lobby space in the student union.
Ultimately, this resolution is, in some ways, more limited in application and scope than SCA 2, which this Committee heard and held last year at the author’s request. SCA 2 sought to enact a constitutional amendment that would provide that the display of the U.S. flag shall not be prohibited on the grounds of a campus of the University of California, the California State University, or the California Community Colleges. In contrast, this resolution is, by its nature, more of a symbolic statement, setting forth a legislative aspiration to enact laws prohibiting government entities from banning the flag on public properties.
3. First Amendment principles embodied by the American Flag
Aside from First Amendment implications discussed above, this measure raises a question as to the need to address what the marketplace of free ideas has already corrected. Indeed, the fundamental rationale underlying principles of free speech and free expression, which are embodied by the flag that this measure seeks to defend, is that the free marketplace of ideas can do a better job than the government in weeding out the good ideas from the bad; that free and open public discourse will allow those ideas based in truth to rise to the top, and cause false ideas to falter. In the words of Chief Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes in his famous Abrams v. United States dissent:
Persecution for the expression of opinions seems to me perfectly logical. If you have no doubt of your premises or your power and want a certain result with all your heart you naturally express your wishes in law and sweep away all opposition. To allow opposition by speech seems to indicate that you think the speech impotent, as when a man says that he has squared the circle, or that you do not care whole-heartedly for the result, or that you doubt either your power or your premises. But when men have realized that time has upset many fighting faiths, they may come to believe even more than they believe the very foundations of their own conduct that the ultimate good desired is better reached by free trade in ideas -- that the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market, and that truth is the only ground upon which their wishes safely can be carried out. That at any rate is the theory of our Constitution. (Abrams v. United States (1919) 205 U.S. 616, 629-630 (J. Holmes, dissenting) (emphasis added).)
In the instance of the ASUCI resolution, it in fact appears that this free speech theory has prevailed, given that the resolution was vetoed within two days of its passage. Allowing for open discourse to continue on college campuses and correct itself as it did at this university, is consistent with the ideals that the American Flag symbolizes. Schools, and particularly public universities, are in many ways intended to provide a safe environment for young people to form and challenge their ideas of the world and of right and wrong.
In support, a coalition of veterans groups writes that their members “put their lives on the line serving this country under the Red, White & Blue and do not believe that governmental entities should disrespect or ban our nation’s colors! Too many lives have been lost fighting for this nation, for our freedom and liberty under that flag.”
Support: American G.I. Forum of California; American Legion, Department of California; AMVETS, Department of California; California Association of County Veterans Service Officers; California State Commanders Veterans Council; Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters; Veterans of Foreign Wars, Department of California; Vietnam Veterans of America, California State Council
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SCA 2 (Nguyen, 2015) See Background.
SB 1359 (Haynes, Ch. 73, Stats. 2002) prohibited a local government agency from adopting any policy or regulation that prohibits or restricts an employee of that agency from displaying any emblem or depiction of the American flag on his or her person, in the workplace, or an agency vehicle. This bill included a time, place, and manner exception, specifically stating that nothing in this provision shall be construed to prevent a local government agency from imposing reasonable restrictions as to the time, place, and manner of placement or display of a U.S. flag when necessary for the preservation of the order or discipline of the workplace.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 75, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing: March 8, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:ACR 95
Author:(Mathis) – As Amended Ver:July 13, 2015
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: American Flag
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE CALL UPON STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO PROHIBIT ANY GOVERNMENT ENTITY FROM BANNING THE AMERICAN FLAG ON PUBLIC PROPERTY?
SYNOPSIS
This author-sponsored resolution calls upon state and local governments to prohibit government entities from banning the American flag on public property. According to the author, this resolution responds to a recent incident in which a committee of the Associated Students of the University of California (ASUC) at the Irvine campus voted to exclude all national flags, including the American flag, from the lobby of a complex that housed student government offices. (The legislative committee’s proposal would not have banned the display of the flag anywhere else on the campus.) The legislative committee apparently reasoned that flying national flags was contrary to efforts to create a more "inclusive" environment at the student government offices. The committee's decision was subsequently overturned by a vote of all members of the ASUC at Irvine. Not only has the issue that prompted this resolution been resolved, it appears that this resolution would never have applied to the situation at U.C. Irvine. That is, ACR 95 calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any "government entity" from banning the American flag from public property. While the complex that housed student government offices at UC Irvine is public property, ASUC is not a "government entity." Instead, ASUC is organized under federal law as a private, non-profit 501 (c) corporation for the purpose of representing student interests to the university administration. In addition, while this resolution calls upon state and local governments to prohibit government entities, including public schools, from prohibiting the display of the American flag, it would not, under existing case law, prohibit a school from implementing a dress code or otherwise prohibiting the display of a flag by students under circumstances that would cause substantial disruption to school operations. There does not appear to be any registered support or opposition to the resolution at this time.
SUMMARY: Resolves that the Legislature should call upon state and local governments to prohibit a government entity from banning the American flag on public property. Specifically, this measure:
- Makes several declarations relating to the significance of the presence of the American flag at critical moments in American history, from the American Revolution to the September 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center.
- States that the United States provides $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world and that these investments further America's foreign policy interest while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed symbol of global good will.
- Resolves that the California Legislature:
- Declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of California's rich history, tradition, and culture.
- Declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty.
- Calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
EXISTING LAW prohibits any law that restrains or abridges liberty of speech or press. (Article I Section 2 of the California Constitution.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this resolution is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, ACR 95 was prompted by a recent incident in which a committee of the Associated Students of the University of California (ASUC) at the Irvine campus voted to exclude all national flags, including the American flag, from the lobby of a complex that housed student government offices. (The legislative committee’s proposal would not have banned the display of the flag anywhere else on the campus.) The student committee apparently reasoned that flying national flags was contrary to its effort to create a more "inclusive" environment at the student government offices. The committee's decision was subsequently overturned by a vote of all members of the ASUC at Irvine. Not only has the issue that prompted this resolution already been resolved, but more curiously, it appears that the resolution would never have applied to the situation at U.C. Irvine. ACR 95, that is, calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any "government entity" from banning the American flag from public property. While the complex that housed student government offices at UC Irvine is public property, ASUC is not a "government entity." Instead, it is organized under federal law as a private, non-profit 501 (c) corporation for the purpose of representing student interests to the university administration and giving students a voice on selected committees.
Is There a Problem That this Resolution Seeks to Address? Given that the U.C. Irvine issue has been resolved – and, in any event, ASUC is not a "government entity" that would be subject to the provisions of this resolution – it is not entirely clear what problem, if any, the resolution seeks to address. The Committee is not aware of any government entity that has banned the display of the American flag or any government entity that has expressed intent to do so in the future. Not only do virtually all public entities fly the American flag somewhere on their premises, many of them (such as schools, city councils, boards of supervisors, and the state legislature) begin their days or proceedings with the Pledge of Allegiance. The vote at U.C. Irvine was made by a committee that was apparently not representative of the larger student government association, much less the university or the student body as a whole. This single action does not constitute evidence that, absent a resolution by the state legislature, government entities throughout the state are inclined to remove the American flag from public property.
Resolution Should Not Affect School Dress Codes: ACR 95 defines a "government entity" to include "a public school." As the United States Supreme Court famously noted in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969) 393 U.S. 503, students do not shed their First Amendment rights at the school house gates. However, while students indisputably enjoy First Amendment rights, Tinker also held that student speech could be limited if it interferes with the school's essential educational functions. Specifically, the majority in Tinker held that schools may prohibit speech that "might reasonably [lead] school authorities to forecast substantial disruption of or material interference with school activities," or that would interfere "with the rights of other students to be secure and to be let alone." (Id. at 508, 514.) Although the Tinker majority found that the students wearing black armbands to express opposition to the Vietnam War did not create such a disruption, subsequent case law has identified several instances in which a school may constitutionally prohibit some forms of student expression, especially when it comes to implementing and enforcing dress codes or prohibiting forms of expression that the school reasonably believes could cause disruption.
A recent example of the limits of student expression and displays of the flag occurred in California. In Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified School District (2014), the United States Court of Appeal for the Ninth Circuit upheld the decision of school administrators to prohibit students from wearing shirts with the American flag under conditions where the wearing of the shirts was apparently intended to provoke a confrontation with other students celebrating Cinco de Mayo. Indeed, the year before this prohibition, a Cinco de Mayo celebration at another Morgan Hill school led to a confrontation between one group of students carrying an American flag and another group of students carrying a Mexican flag. Therefore, in an effort to stave off the violent confrontation that occurred the year before, administrators asked students who wore shirts emblazoned with American flags on Cinco de Mayo to remove them or turn them inside out. The Ninth Circuit concluded that, in light of the totality of the circumstances, the experience of the previous year, and reports that confrontations seemed likely to be repeated, the school's action did not violate the students' free speech rights under either the California or the federal constitutions. The Ninth Circuit stressed, as did the U.S. Supreme Court in Tinker, that expression could not be prohibited merely because some students found it offensive, since offensive expressions are precisely the ones that need First Amendment protection. But the Ninth Circuit found that, in this particular case, school administrators appropriately cited evidence that the expression could cause substantial disruption and possibly even violence. The United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case on appeal. (Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified Sch. Dist. (2014) 767 F.3d 764; cert. denied in Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified Sch. Dist., 2015 U.S. LEXIS 2190 (U.S., Mar. 30, 2015).)
Comparison with SCA 2: This resolution is both similar to, yet significantly different from, SCA 2 (Nguyen 2015). SCA 2 was referred to, but never heard by, the Senate Judiciary Committee. Like the resolution under review, SCA 2 responded to the now-reversed student action at U.C. Irvine. However, SCA 2 differs significantly from ACR 95 in that it proposes a binding constitutional amendment and conceivably applies to private entities as well as government entities. Specifically, SCA 2 would have added Section 10 to Article IX of the California Constitution to read as follows:
Display of the Flag of the United States of America shall not be prohibited on the grounds of a campus of the University of California, the California State University, or the California Community Colleges.
The passive construction of SCA 2 makes its intended application ambiguous and problematic. That is, SCA 2 states that display of the flag "shall not be prohibited" – but prohibited by whom? Presumably, therefore, SCA 2 could prohibit any person or entity, private or public, from banning the display of the flag on areas of the campus under its purview or control. It could, for example, apply to a student association organized as a private association or even to a private concessionaire that operated a restaurant or coffee shop on campus. SCA 2, therefore, would interfere with the free expression of private entities, and thus raises potential First Amendment issues. ACR 95, on the other hand, is simply a statement of legislative aspiration that calls upon state and local governments to prohibit "government entities" within its jurisdiction from banning the American Flag.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
As we celebrate the Nation’s 239th birthday this month, this resolution honors the symbol of our country’s great heritage, the American Flag.
An enduring image of democracy and freedom, Old Glory has been the banner under which brave men and women have sacrificed their lives to defeat fascism, communism, and terrorism.
The Stars and Stripes has also been at the forefront of America’s peacetime endeavors as well. Whether it be in humanitarian relief efforts in every corner of the world, or at the vanguard of exploration, with the flag still standing vigil upon the surface of the Moon.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
ACR 95
Page 4
Date of Hearing: August 25, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ACR 95 (
Mathis) – As Amended July 13, 2015
SUBJECT: DISPLAY OF THE American Flag
KEY ISSUE: Should the Legislature call upon state and local governments to prohibit any government entity from banning the American flag on public property?
SYNOPSIS
This resolution calls upon state and local governments to prohibit government entities from banning the American flag on public property. According to the author, this resolution responds to a recent incident in which a legislative committee of the Associated Students of the University of California (ASUC) at the Irvine campus voted to exclude all national flags, including the American flag, from the lobby of a complex that housed student government offices. (The legislative committee’s proposal would not have banned the display of the flag anywhere else on the campus.) The legislative committee apparently reasoned that flying national flags was contrary to efforts to create a more "inclusive" environment at the student government offices. The committee's decision was subsequently overturned by a vote of all members of the ASUC at Irvine. Not only has the issue that prompted this resolution been resolved, it appears that the resolution would never have applied to the situation at U.C. Irvine. That is, ACR 95 calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any "government entity" from banning the American flag from public property. While the complex that housed student government offices at U.C. Irvine is public property, ASUC is not a "government entity." Instead, ASUC is organized under federal law as a private, non-profit 501 (c) corporation for the purpose of representing student interests to the university administration. Furthermore, while this resolution calls upon state and local governments to prohibit government entities, including public schools, from prohibiting the display of the American flag, it would not, under existing case law, prohibit a school from implementing a dress code or otherwise prohibiting the display of a flag by students under circumstances that would cause substantial disruption to school operations. There does not appear to be any registered support or opposition to the resolution at this time.
SUMMARY: Resolves that the Legislature should call upon state and local governments to prohibit a government entity from banning the American flag on public property. Specifically, this measure:
Makes several declarations relating to the significance of the presence of the American flag at critical moments in American history, from the American Revolution to the September 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center.
States that whereas the United States provides $35.4 billion in foreign assistance programs to more than 100 countries around the world and that these investments further America's foreign policy interest while simultaneously establishing the American flag as the undisputed symbol of global good will.
Resolves that the California Legislature:
Declares that the American flag is an inseparable part of California's rich history, tradition, and culture.
Declares that the American flag represents the values of freedom and liberty.
Calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any government entity in the state from banning the American flag from public property, including, but not limited to, public schools, public colleges, public universities, state beaches, public parks, public monuments, museums, and government offices.
EXISTING LAW prohibits any law that restrains or abridges liberty of speech or press. (Article I Section 2 of the California Constitution.)
FISCAL EFFECT: This resolution is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, ACR 95 was prompted by a recent incident in which a legislative committee of the Associated Students of the University of California (ASUC) at the Irvine campus voted to exclude all national flags, including the American flag, from the lobby of a complex that housed student government offices. (The legislative committee’s proposal would not have banned the display of the flag anywhere else on the campus.) The student committee apparently reasoned that flying national flags was contrary to its effort to create a more "inclusive" environment at the student government offices. The committee's decision was subsequently overturned by a vote of all members of the ASUC at Irvine. Not only has the issue that prompted this resolution already been resolved, but more curiously, it appears that the resolution would never have applied to the situation at U.C. Irvine. ACR 95, that is, calls upon state and local governments to prohibit any "government entity" from banning the American flag from public property. While the complex that housed student government offices at UC Irvine is public property, ASUC is not a "government entity." Instead, it is organized under federal law as a private, non-profit 501 (c) corporation for the purpose of representing student interests to the university administration and giving students a voice on selected committees.
Is There any Evidence of a Problem That Would be Addressed by this Resolution? Given that the U.C. Irvine issue has already been resolved – and the fact ASUC is not a "government entity" that would be subject to the provisions of this resolution – it is not entirely clear what problem, if any, the resolution seeks to address. The Committee is not aware of any government entity that has banned the display of the American flag or any government entity that has expressed an intent to do so in the future. Not only do virtually all public entities fly the American flag somewhere on their premises, many of them (such as schools, city councils, boards of supervisors, and the state legislature) begin their days or proceedings with the Pledge of Allegiance to the American flag. The vote at U.C. Irvine was made by a committee that was apparently not representative of the larger student government association, much less the university or the student body as a whole. This single action does not seem to be evidence that, absent a resolution by the state legislature, government entities across the state are likely to start removing the American flag from public property.
Resolution Should Not Affect School Dress Codes. ACR 95 specifies that the government entities barred from banning the American flag includes "a public school." As the United States Supreme Court famously noted in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969) 393 U.S. 503, students do not shed their First Amendment rights at the school house gates. However, while students clearly enjoy First Amendment rights, Tinker also held this right of students to free speech could be limited by a school's need to carry out its essential educational functions. Specifically, the majority in Tinker held that schools may prohibit speech that "might reasonably [lead] school authorities to forecast substantial disruption of or material interference with school activities" or that would interfere "with the rights of other students to be secure and to be let alone." (Id. at 508, 514.) Although the Tinker majority found that the students wearing black armbands to express opposition to the Vietnam War did not constitute such a disruption, subsequent decisions have identified several instances in which a school may constitutionally prohibit some forms of student expression, especially when it comes to implementing and enforcing dress codes or prohibiting forms of expression that the school reasonably believes could cause disruption.
A recent example of the limits of student expression occurred in California. In Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified School District (2014), the United States Court of Appeal for the Ninth Circuit upheld the decision of school administrators to prohibit students from wearing shirts with the American flag under conditions where the wearing of the shirts was apparently intended to provoke a confrontation with other students celebrating Cinco de Mayo. Indeed, the year before this prohibition, a Cinco de Mayo celebration at another Morgan Hill school led to a confrontation between one group of students carrying an American flag and another group of students carrying a Mexican flag. Therefore, in an effort to stave off the violent confrontation that occurred the year before, administrators asked students who wore shirts emblazoned with American flags on Cinco de Mayo to remove them or turn them inside out. The Ninth Circuit concluded that, in light of the totality of the circumstances, the experience of the previous year, and reports that confrontations seemed likely to be repeated, the school's action did not violate the students' free speech rights under either the California or the federal constitutions. The Ninth Circuit stressed, as did the U.S. Supreme Court in Tinker, that expression could not be prohibited merely because some students found it offensive, since offensive expressions are precisely the ones that need First Amendment protection. But the Ninth Circuit found that, in this particular case, school administrators appropriately cited evidence that the expression could cause substantial disruption and possibly even violence. The United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case on appeal. (Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified Sch. Dist. (2014) 767 F.3d 764; cert. denied in Dariano v. Morgan Hill Unified Sch. Dist., 2015 U.S. LEXIS 2190 (U.S., Mar. 30, 2015.)
In sum, while this resolution calls upon state and local governments to prohibit government entities, including public schools, from prohibiting the display of the American flag, it would not, under existing case law, prohibit a school from implementing a dress code or otherwise prohibit the display of a flag by students under circumstances that would cause substantial disruption to school operations.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
As we celebrate the Nation’s 239th birthday this month, this resolution honors the symbol of our country’s great heritage, the American Flag.
An enduring image of democracy and freedom, Old Glory has been the banner under which brave men and women have sacrificed their lives to defeat fascism, communism, and terrorism.
The Stars and Stripes has also been at the forefront of America’s peacetime endeavors as well. Whether it be in humanitarian relief efforts in every corner of the world, or at the vanguard of exploration, with the flag still standing vigil upon the surface of the Moon.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):