SB 10: Climate change: plans: gender impacts.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2026-05-12
Current Status:
In Progress
(2026-08-13: August 13 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires the Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation and the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2026, and every 3 years thereafter, to update the Extreme Heat Action Plan to promote comprehensive, coordinated, and effective state and local government action on extreme heat.
This bill would require the office and the agency, on or before July 1, 2028, to conduct an assessment of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat, as provided, for purposes of integration into updates to the Extreme Heat Action Plan. The bill would require the office and the agency to post the gender assessment on their respective internet websites and to provide the assessment to the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature.
Existing law provides that it is the intent of the Legislature to prioritize the most vulnerable communities, ecosystems, and economic sectors in the state climate adaptation and resilience strategy set forth in the Safeguarding California Plan and that the Natural Resources Agency consider developing policies to address the impacts of climate change and climate adaptation with a focus on equity and that actions taken to address climate adaptation should be consistent with the plan and specifies that in developing these policies and taking these actions, the agency include the adoption of strategies that seek to address and, at a minimum, avoid worsening social and racial inequities.
This bill would additionally state the intent of the Legislature that those strategies shall seek to address and, at a minimum, avoid worsening gender inequities.
Existing law requires the office, through the Integrated Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Program, to develop the California Climate Change Assessment to provide an integrated suite of products that report the impacts and risks of climate change, based on the best available science, and identify potential solutions to inform legislative policy. Existing law requires the office to complete the assessment no less frequently than every 5 years. Existing law requires the products in the assessment to include, among other things, reports on issues of statewide significance, including, but not limited to, environmental justice considerations.
This bill would expressly require the reports on issues of statewide significance to include gender impact considerations.
The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to carry out a construction project for the State Highway Route 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility. Existing law authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided. Existing law authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.This bill would, consistent with applicable federal and state laws, authorize those toll revenues to additionally be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government. The bill would require the repayment of bond obligations to take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility located within the County of San Diego.The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to carry out a construction project for the State Highway Route 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility. Existing law authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided. Existing law authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.
This bill would would, consistent with applicable federal and state laws, authorize those toll revenues to additionally be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government. The bill would require the repayment of bond obligations to take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility located within the County of San Diego.
The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to carry out a construction project for the State Highway Route 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility. Existing law authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided. Existing law authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.
This bill would authorize those toll revenues to additionally be used for environmental mitigation and restoration of the Tijuana River Valley and adjoining lands, as specified. to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility located within the County of San Diego.
The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to carry out a construction project for the State Highway Route 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility. Existing law authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided. Existing law authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.
This bill would authorize those toll revenues to additionally be used for environmental mitigation and restoration of the Tijuana River Valley and adjoining lands, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of San Diego.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature to prioritize the most vulnerable communities, ecosystems, and economic sectors in the states climate adaptation and resilience strategy set forth in the Safeguarding California Plan by ensuring that all state departments and agencies accurately identify, collaboratively prepare for, and are sufficiently resourced to adequately respond to the impacts of climate change, such as extreme weather events, the urban heat island effect, habitat loss, wildfire, sea level rise, and drought.
(b)It also is the intent of the Legislature that the agency consider developing policies to address the impacts of climate change and climate adaptation with a focus on equity and that actions taken to address climate adaptation should be consistent with the plan. In developing these policies and taking these actions, all of the following shall occur:
(1)The creation of planning processes that are transparent, fair, and inclusive in the development phases.
(2)The prioritization of resources and investments for vulnerable communities and populations.
(3)The adoption of strategies that seek to address and, at a minimum, avoid worsening social and racial social, racial, and gender inequities.
SEC. 2.Section 71341 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:71341.The California Climate Change Assessment shall provide an integrated suite of products that report the impacts and risks of climate change, based on the best available science, and identify potential solutions to inform legislative policy. These products shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(a)Downscaled climate projections that assess climate change impacts throughout the state, including at regional and local levels, for near-term, medium-term, and long-term timescales, and under varied emissions scenarios, as appropriate and supported by the availability of the data, as determined by the Office of Planning and Research.
(b)A set of research reports that examine, but need not be limited to, all of the following:
(1)How climate change will affect built systems, natural systems, and social systems, including the welfare of vulnerable communities, and the potential fiscal and economic impacts of these effects in California.
(2)Identification of potential climate adaptation and mitigation responses, including their costs and benefits.
(c)Regionally specific reports that can inform regional and local vulnerability assessments, adaptation planning, and community resilience efforts.
(d)Reports on issues of statewide significance, including, but not limited to, environmental justice considerations, gender impact considerations, impacts on the systems identified in paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), and the unique risks posed to, and research and monitoring approaches used by, tribal communities.
(e)Decision-support tools for planners, decisionmakers, and others, including organizations that serve vulnerable communities, that allow for actionable application of assessment research findings. To the extent data is available, this shall include guidance regarding assessment of the financial and economic costs and benefits of adaptation decisions.
(f)Examples of best practices for planning for future climate conditions and approaches to building adaptation and resilience, while also meeting established greenhouse gas emission reduction goals.
SEC. 3.Section 71361 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:71361.(a)On or before July 1, 2026, and every three years thereafter, the office and the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with relevant state agencies and to be integrated into the climate adaptation strategy developed pursuant to Section 71153, shall update the Extreme Heat Action Plan to promote comprehensive, coordinated, and effective state and local government action on extreme heat. Updates to the Extreme Heat Action Plan shall include all of the following:
(1)Review of relevant actions and grants that state agencies have undertaken to mitigate extreme heat and implement the Extreme Heat Action Plan, including, but not limited to, an in-depth review of select programs and actions, including, but not limited to, the ICARP Extreme Heat and Community Resilience Grant Program, as described in Item 0650-101-0001 of the Budget Act of 2022, projects that use cool and reflective surfaces, and efforts to address extreme heat on Californias school campuses.
(2)A description of the resources, budget allocations, expenditures, and staff dedicated to addressing extreme heat.
(3)A review of state programs that address extreme heat to identify potential gaps or unmet needs in the states approach and that includes recommendations on ways to improve policies, programs, and interagency coordination.
(4)Recommendations on additional measures to protect vulnerable populations, such as pupils and students, from the impacts of extreme heat, including, but not limited to, community cooling strategies.
(b)(1)On or before July 1, 2028, the office and the Natural Resources Agency shall conduct an assessment of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat for purposes of integration into updates to the Extreme Heat Action Plan developed pursuant to subdivision (a). The assessment shall be known as the gender assessment. In conducting the gender assessment, intersectional and systemic inequities shall be considered. The gender assessment shall include all of the following:
(A)An analysis of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat to identify gaps or unmet needs in the states approach to addressing extreme heat.
(B)An analysis of sex- or gender-disaggregated data, where available, on workers in relevant sectors, including, but not limited to, health care and care workers, outdoor workers, and others, to identify those substantially responsible for protecting community health and supporting community resilience in response to extreme heat, as well as those substantially in danger of negative impacts at work from extreme heat.
(C)Recommendations on additional measures or priority actions to address the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts of extreme heat to improve policies, programs, and interagency coordination. State agencies may consider these recommendations in developing their policies and programs.
(2)The gender assessment shall be posted on the offices and the Natural Resources Agencys internet websites and shall be provided to the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature, consistent with the requirements of Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(b)(c)The Extreme Heat Action Plan and subsequent updates shall be posted on the offices and the Natural Resources Agencys internet websites and, notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, shall be provided to the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature.
(c)(d)For purposes of this section, Extreme Heat Action Plan means the April 2022 plan entitled Protecting Californians From Extreme Heat: A State Action Plan to Build Community Resilience.
SECTION 1.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(a)The Tijuana River Valley has been a longstanding site of significant environmental degradation due to cross-border pollution, including untreated sewage, industrial waste, and other contaminants that flow from Tijuana, Mexico, into the United States of America.(b)According to the Department of Parks and Recreation, the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve is the largest coastal wetland and one of the few remaining salt marshes in southern California.(c)This pollution severely impacts communities in California, particularly the City of Imperial Beach, and other nearby neighborhoods in the County of San Diego. These areas are experiencing elevated rates of respiratory illnesses, gastrointestinal diseases, and skin conditions linked to exposure to contaminated water and air.(d)The rapid economic expansion in the border region, driven in part by trade agreements such as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), has resulted in increased industrial production, cross-border transportation, and waste generation, exacerbating pollution in the Tijuana River Valley.(e)The life cycle of many products manufactured in the region, including electronics, textiles, and consumer goods, contributes to environmental degradation at every stage, from raw material extraction to production, transport, use, and disposal. Many of these products are produced in factories that discharge untreated waste into the Tijuana River or adjacent lands.(f)The health and safety of residents and visitors to the Tijuana River Valley and surrounding communities are of paramount importance. The Legislature acknowledges the severe public health risks posed by ongoing pollution in the region and recognizes the need for a permanent funding source to provide resources to mitigate the crisis.(g)Pursuant to the Utilization of Waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande Treaty of 1944 between the United States of America and Mexico, the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) gained status as an international body to resolve water quality issues related to transboundary pollution from border rivers and streams.(h)In 1996, the United States Section of the IBWC (USIBWC) used funding from the United States Environmental Protection Agency to build the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). The plant is permitted to treat up to 25,000,000 gallons per day of raw sewage and other waste water.(i)Due to unchecked expansion leading to unexpectedly high flows, the SBIWTP has become overwhelmed and left only partially operational in need of critical repairs. According to the IBWC, 100 billion gallons of untreated sewage and other pollutants have been dumped into the Tijuana River in the past five years.(j)The USIBWC and the Mexico Section of the IBWC (La Comision Internacional de Limites y Aguas or CILA) entered into an agreement called the Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution, which identified targeted infrastructure projects on both sides of the border. The latest cost estimate from the IBWC for implementation of this agreement is now $900,000,000, which would repair and expand the capacity of the facility but does not include maintenance.(k)In July 2020, Congress appropriated $300,000,000 through the USMCA to mitigate the transboundary flows through expansion of the existing SBIWTP.(l)In 2024, Congress appropriated $156,000,000 as a part of the 2024 appropriations bill. However, there has been no ongoing funding source appropriated to maintain operations of the SBIWTP.(m)The appropriation of an ongoing and reliable funding source is critical to the health and safety of the residents of the southern portion of the County of San Diego.(n)Funds from the toll collected at the proposed East Otay Mesa may be used to address water and air pollution and used to offset the financial obligations to the IBWC from the federal government.SEC. 2.Section 31475 of the Streets and Highways Code is amended to read:31475.(a)Toll revenues under this chapter may be used to reimburse or finance the costs incurred in connection with the implementation, construction, maintenance, or operation of a project, including reimbursement of federal funds specifically allocated to SANDAG for a project or projects by the federal government or other funds from funding sources that are not otherwise available to state agencies for transportation-related projects. SANDAG shall be reimbursed for administrative costs in an amount that shall not exceed 3 percent of toll revenues under this chapter.(b)Toll revenues shall be used to pay for costs in the following categories:(1)Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.(2)SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.(3)Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.(4)Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.(5)Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 31476 that specifies the expenditure of toll revenues.(6)Payments pursuant to an agreement under Section 31483.(c)Consistent with applicable federal and state laws, toll revenues may be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.(d)The repayment of bond obligations shall take priority over other allocations of toll revenues under this chapter.SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need to mitigate the sewage crisis in the County of San Diego by funding the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Tijuana River Valley has been a longstanding site of significant environmental degradation due to cross-border pollution, including untreated sewage, industrial waste, and other contaminants that flow from Tijuana, Mexico, into the United States of America.
(b)According to the Department of Parks and Recreation, the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve is the largest coastal wetland and one of the few remaining salt marshes in southern California.
(c)This pollution severely impacts communities in California, particularly the City of Imperial Beach, and other nearby neighborhoods in the County of San Diego. These areas are experiencing elevated rates of respiratory illnesses, gastrointestinal diseases, and skin conditions linked to exposure to contaminated water and air.
(d)The rapid economic expansion in the border region, driven in part by trade agreements such as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), has resulted in increased industrial production, cross-border transportation, and waste generation, exacerbating pollution in the Tijuana River Valley.
(e)The life cycle of many products manufactured in the region, including electronics, textiles, and consumer goods, contributes to environmental degradation at every stage, from raw material extraction to production, transport, use, and disposal. Many of these products are produced in factories that discharge untreated waste into the Tijuana River or adjacent lands.
(f)The health and safety of residents and visitors to the Tijuana River Valley and surrounding communities are of paramount importance. The Legislature acknowledges the severe public health risks posed by ongoing pollution in the region and recognizes the need for a permanent funding source to provide resources to mitigate the crisis.
(g)Pursuant to the Utilization of Waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande Treaty of 1944 between the United States of America and Mexico, the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) gained status as an international body to resolve water quality issues related to transboundary pollution from border rivers and streams.
(h)In 1996, the United States Section of the IBWC (USIBWC) used funding from the United States Environmental Protection Agency to build the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). The plant is permitted to treat up to 25,000,000 gallons per day of raw sewage and other waste water.
(i)Due to unchecked expansion leading to unexpectedly high flows, the SBIWTP has become overwhelmed and left only partially operational in need of critical repairs. According to the IBWC, 100 billion gallons of untreated sewage and other pollutants have been dumped into the Tijuana River in the past five years.
(j)The USIBWC and the Mexico Section of the IBWC (La Comision Internacional de Limites y Aguas or CILA) entered into an agreement called the Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution, which identified targeted infrastructure projects on both sides of the boarder. border. The latest cost estimate from the IBWC for implementation of this agreement is now $900,000,000, which would repair and expand the capacity of the facility but does not include maintenance.
(k)In July 2020, Congress appropriated $300,000,000 through the USMCA to mitigate the transboundary flows through expansion of the existing SBIWTP.
(l)In 2024, Congress appropriated $156,000,000 as a part of the 2024 appropriations bill. However, there has been no ongoing funding source appropriated to maintain operations of the SBIWTP.
(m)The appropriation of an ongoing and reliable funding source is critical to the health and safety of the residents of the southern portion of the County of San Diego.
(n)Funds from the toll collected at the proposed East Otay Mesa may be used to address water and air pollution and used to offset the financial obligations to the IBWC from the federal government.
SEC. 2.Section 31475 of the Streets and Highways Code is amended to read:31475.(a)Toll revenues under this chapter may be used to reimburse or finance the costs incurred in connection with the implementation, construction, maintenance, or operation of a project, including reimbursement of federal funds specifically allocated to SANDAG for a project or projects by the federal government or other funds from funding sources that are not otherwise available to state agencies for transportation-related projects. SANDAG shall be reimbursed for administrative costs in an amount that shall not exceed 3 percent of toll revenues under this chapter.
(b)Toll revenues shall be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
(1)Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.
(2)SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
(3)Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.
(4)Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
(5)Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 31476 that specifies the expenditure of toll revenues.
(6)Payments pursuant to an agreement under Section 31483.
(c)Toll Consistent with applicable federal and state laws, toll revenues may be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.
(d)The repayment of bond obligations shall take priority over other allocations of toll revenues under this chapter.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need to mitigate the sewage crisis in the County of San Diego by funding the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Tijuana River Valley has been a longstanding site of significant environmental degradation due to cross-border pollution, including untreated sewage, industrial waste, and other contaminants that flow from Tijuana, Mexico, into the United States of America.
(b)According to the Department of Parks and Recreation, the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve is the largest coastal wetland and one of the few remaining salt marshes in southern California.
(c)This pollution severely impacts communities in California, particularly the City of Imperial Beach, and other nearby neighborhoods in the County of San Diego. These areas are experiencing elevated rates of respiratory illnesses, gastrointestinal diseases, and skin conditions linked to exposure to contaminated water and air.
(d)The rapid economic expansion in the border region, driven in part by trade agreements such as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), has resulted in increased industrial production, cross-border transportation, and waste generation, exacerbating pollution in the Tijuana River Valley.
(e)The life cycle of many products manufactured in the region, including electronics, textiles, and consumer goods, contributes to environmental degradation at every stage, from raw material extraction to production, transport, use, and disposal. Many of these products are produced in factories that discharge untreated waste into the Tijuana River or adjacent lands.
(f)The health and safety of residents and visitors to the Tijuana River Valley and surrounding communities are of paramount importance. The Legislature acknowledges the severe public health risks posed by ongoing pollution in the region and recognizes the need for a permanent funding source to provide resources to mitigate the crisis.
(g)Pursuant to the Utilization of waters Waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande Treaty of 1944 between the United States of America and Mexico, the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) gained status as an international body to resolve water quality issues related to transboundary pollution from border rivers and streams.
(h)In 1996, the United States Section of the IBWC (USIBWC) used funding from the United States Environmental Protection Agency to build the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). The plant is permitted to treat up to 25,000,000 gallons per day of raw sewage and other waste water.
(i)Due to unchecked expansion leading to unexpectedly high flows, the SBIWTP has become overwhelmed and left only partially operational in need of critical repairs. According to the IBWC, 100,000,000,000 100 billion gallons of untreated sewage and other pollutants have been dumped into the Tijuana River in the past five years.
(j)The USIBWC and the Mexico Section of the IBWC (La Comision Comision Internacional de Limites Limites y Aguas or CILA) entered into an agreement called the Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution, which identified targeted infrastructure projects on both sides of the boarder. The latest cost estimate from the IBWC for implementation of this agreement is now $900,000,000, which would repair and expand the capacity of the facility but does not include maintenance.
(k)In July 2020, Congress appropriated $300,000,000 through the USMCA to mitigate the transboundary flows through expansion of the existing SBIWTP.
(l)In 2024, Congress appropriated $156,000,000 as a part of the 2024 appropriations bill. However, there has been no ongoing funding source appropriated to maintain operations of the SBIWTP.
(m)The appropriation of an ongoing and reliable funding source is critical to the health and safety of the residents of the southern portion of the County of San Diego.
(n)Funds from the toll collected at the proposed East Otay Mesa may be used to address water and air pollution and used to offset the financial obligations to the IBWC from the federal government.
SEC. 2.Section 31475 of the Streets and Highways Code is amended to read:31475.(a)Toll revenues under this chapter may be used to reimburse or finance the costs incurred in connection with the implementation, construction, maintenance, or operation of a project, including reimbursement of federal funds specifically allocated to SANDAG for a project or projects by the federal government or other funds from funding sources that are not otherwise available to state agencies for transportation-related projects. SANDAG shall be reimbursed for administrative costs in an amount that shall not exceed 3 percent of toll revenues under this chapter.
(b)Toll revenues shall be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
(1)Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.
(2)SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
(3)Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.
(4)Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
(5)Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 31476 that specifies the expenditure of toll revenues.
(6)Payments pursuant to an agreement under Section 31483.
(7)Costs associated with environmental mitigation and restoration of the Tijuana River Valley and adjoining lands by way of wastewater infrastructure and related projects to address the sewage crisis and benefit of the residents of the southern portion of the County of San Diego.(c)Toll revenues may be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the County of San Diego in addressing the sewage crisis in the Tijuana River Valley. to mitigate the sewage crisis in the County of San Diego by funding the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Tijuana River Valley has been a longstanding site of significant environmental degradation due to cross-border pollution, including untreated sewage, industrial waste, and other contaminants that flow from Tijuana, Mexico, into the United States of America.
(b)According to the Department of Parks and Recreation, the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve is the largest coastal wetland and one of the few remaining salt marshes in southern California.
(c)This pollution severely impacts communities in California, particularly the City of Imperial Beach, and other nearby neighborhoods in the County of San Diego. These areas are experiencing elevated rates of respiratory illnesses, gastrointestinal diseases, and skin conditions linked to exposure to contaminated water and air.
(d)The rapid economic expansion in the border region, driven in part by trade agreements such as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), has resulted in increased industrial production, cross-border transportation, and waste generation, exacerbating pollution in the Tijuana River Valley.
(e)The life cycle of many products manufactured in the region, including electronics, textiles, and consumer goods, contributes to environmental degradation at every stage, from raw material extraction to production, transport, use, and disposal. Many of these products are produced in factories that discharge untreated waste into the Tijuana River or adjacent lands.
(f)The health and safety of residents and visitors to the Tijuana River Valley and surrounding communities are of paramount importance. The Legislature acknowledges the severe public health risks posed by ongoing pollution in the region and recognizes the need for a permanent funding source to provide resources to mitigate the crisis.
(g)Pursuant to the Utilization of waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande Treaty of 1944 between the United States of America and Mexico, the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) gained status as an international body to resolve water quality issues related to transboundary pollution from border rivers and streams.
(h)In 1996, the United States Section of the IBWC (USIBWC) used funding from the United States Environmental Protection Agency to build the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). The plant is permitted to treat up to 25,000,000 gallons per day of raw sewage and other waste water.
(i)Due to unchecked expansion leading to unexpectedly high flows, the SBIWTP has become overwhelmed and left only partially operational in need of critical repairs. According to the IBWC, 100,000,000,000 gallons of untreated sewage and other pollutants have been dumped into the Tijuana River in the past five years.
(j)The USIBWC and the Mexico Section of the IBWC (La Comision Internacional de Limites y Aguas or CILA) entered into an agreement called the Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution, which identified targeted infrastructure projects on both sides of the boarder. The latest cost estimate from the IBWC for implementation of this agreement is now $900,000,000, which would repair and expand the capacity of the facility but does not include maintenance.
(k)In July 2020, Congress appropriated $300,000,000 through the USMCA to mitigate the transboundary flows through expansion of the existing SBIWTP.
(l)In 2024, Congress appropriated $156,000,000 as a part of the 2024 appropriations bill. However, there has been no ongoing funding source appropriated to maintain operations of the SBIWTP.
(m)The appropriation of an ongoing and reliable funding source is critical to the health and safety of the residents of the southern portion of the County San Diego.
(n)Funds from the toll collected at the proposed East Otay Mesa may be used to address water and air pollution and used to offset the financial obligations to the IBWC from the federal government.
SEC. 2.Section 31475 of the Streets and Highways Code is amended to read:31475.(a)Toll revenues under this chapter may be used to reimburse or finance the costs incurred in connection with the implementation, construction, maintenance, or operation of a project, including reimbursement of federal funds specifically allocated to SANDAG for a project or projects by the federal government or other funds from funding sources that are not otherwise available to state agencies for transportation-related projects. SANDAG shall be reimbursed for administrative costs in an amount that shall not exceed 3 percent of toll revenues under this chapter.
(b)Toll revenues shall be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
(1)Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.
(2)SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
(3)Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.
(4)Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
(5)Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 31476 that specifies the expenditure of toll revenues.
(6)Payments pursuant to an agreement under Section 31483.
(7)Costs associated with environmental mitigation and restoration of the Tijuana River Valley and adjoining lands by way of wastewater infrastructure and related projects to address the sewage crisis and benefit of the residents of the southern portion of the County of San Diego.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the County of San Diego in addressing the sewage crisis in the Tijuana River Valley.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 13, 2026 | August 13 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Jun 24, 2026 | June 24 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 9, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 3.) (June 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 14, 2026 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| May 12, 2026 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Jun 27, 2025 | July 14 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 9, 2025 | Referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Jun 4, 2025 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 3, 2025 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 29. Noes 10. Page 1472.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 23, 2025 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 23, 2025 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 1187.) (May 23). |
| May 16, 2025 | Set for hearing May 23. |
| Apr 21, 2025 | April 21 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 4, 2025 | Set for hearing April 21. |
| Apr 3, 2025 | April 7 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 28, 2025 | Set for hearing April 7. |
| Mar 26, 2025 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 3. Page 534.) (March 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 13, 2025 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Mar 11, 2025 | Set for hearing March 25. |
| Feb 13, 2025 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Jan 29, 2025 | Referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Dec 3, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 2. |
| Dec 2, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 8, 2026 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 3, 2025 | Senate 3rd Reading SB10 Padilla | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2025 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 21, 2025 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 25, 2025 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 4 Walls International | ** Support | |
| Alliance San Diego | ** Support | |
| Audubon California | ** Support | |
| Azul | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Justice Alliance Action, a Project of Tides Advocacy | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice | ** Support | |
| California Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Chula Vista Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| City Of Chula Vista | ** Support | |
| City of National City | ** Support | |
| Climate Resolve | ** Support | |
| Coalition of Clean Air | ** Support | |
| Coronado City Of | ** Support | |
| CORONADO; CITY OF | ** Support | |
| Coronado Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| County of San Diego Third District Supervisor Terra Lawson-remer | ** Support | |
| Dake Landscape | ** Support | |
| Environmental Health Coalition | ** Support | |
| Friends of International Friendship Park, INC. | ** Support | |
| Gender Equity Policy Institute | ** Support | |
| Gender Equity Policy Institute (sponsor) | ** Support | |
| GRID Alternatives, Southern California | ** Support | |
| LAANE | ** Support | |
| Lideres Campesinas | ** Support | |
| Lift To Rise | ** Support | |
| Los Amigos De LA Comunidad, INC. | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator | ** Support | |
| National Council of Jewish Women, Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Outdoor Outreach | ** Support | |
| SanDiego350 | ** Support | |
| San Diego Audubon Society | ** Support | |
| San Diego Coastkeeper | ** Support | |
| SAN DIEGO; COUNTY OF | ** Support | |
| San Diego for Every Child | ** Support | |
| San Diego Natural History Museum | ** Support | |
| Sierra Club | ** Support | |
| Stop the Sewage | ** Support | |
| The San Diego Mountain Biking Association | ** Support | |
| The Women’s Building | ** Support | |
| Un Mar De Colores | ** Support | |
| Wildcoast | ** Support | |
| Worksafe | ** Support | |
| YMCA of San Diego County | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: June 24, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 10
Author:(Padilla) – As Amended Ver:May 12, 2026
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 10 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) and the Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation (LCI) to incorporate the gender impacts of climate change in specified state climate-related planning documents.
Specifically, this bill, among other things:
- Revises legislative intent in existing state law so that gender inequities are among the issues to be addressed by the Safeguarding California Plan.
- Requires LCI to include gender impact considerations in its reports on issues of statewide significance prepared as part of the California Climate Change Assessment.
- Requires LCI and CNRA, on or before July 1, 2028, to conduct an assessment of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat (gender assessment) for purposes of integration into updates to the Extreme Heat Action Plan (Action Plan), as specified. Requires the gender assessment to include:
- An analysis of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat to identify gaps or unmet needs in the state’s approach to addressing extreme heat.
- An analysis of sex- or gender-disaggregated data, where available, on workers in relevant sectors, including health care and care workers, outdoor workers, and others, to identify those substantially responsible for protecting community health and supporting community resilience in response to extreme heat, as well as those substantially in danger of negative impacts at work from extreme heat.
- Recommendations on additional measures or priority actions to address the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts of extreme heat to improve policies, programs, and interagency coordination.
- Authorizes state agencies to consider the recommendations described in item 3, above, in developing their programs and policies.
- Requires LCI and CNRA to post the assessment on their websites and provide the assessment to the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature.
FISCAL EFFECT:
1) LCI estimates a one-time General Fund cost of approximately $1.1 million in fiscal year (FY) 2027-28 – comprised of $750,000 in contracting costs to support LCI’s role in the Action Plan gender assessment (LCI asserts the specialized technical expertise needed to prepare the assessment is not available within its existing staff resources) and $300,000 to implement and support the new requirements for the California Climate Change Assessment (specifically for contracting for external expertise, research development, technical review, stakeholder engagement, report production, and communications activities). After FY 2027-28, LCI anticipates General Fund costs of $300,000 every five years; LCI is legally required to update the California Climate Change Assessment at least every five years.
The administration is scheduled to release the Fifth California Climate Change Assessment this fall. As part of the Governor’s FY 2026-27 budget, LCI, CNRA, and the California Energy Commission have requested $9.9 million (Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund) over five years to implement the Sixth California Climate Change Assessment. This request is being considered as part of this year’s budget negotiations.
2) With LCI taking the lead on development of the required gender assessment, CNRA anticipates its costs to be minor and absorbable. LCI and CNRA are in the process of finalizing the 2026 Action Plan by July of this year. For its part, to date, CNRA has absorbed the workload associated with updating the Action Plan within existing resources.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the author:
Equity is a pillar of California’s climate adaptation and resilience strategy, and gender is one of several vulnerabilities to climate change. Yet despite the state’s commitment to climate equity, the different and disparate impacts of climate change on women have previously been largely overlooked in the state’s climate policy and planning. SB 10 ensures that future planning will address women’s distinct vulnerability in the face of worsening climate impacts., as well as the distinct gendered impacts faced by men and LGBTQ+ people.
2) Background. Action Plan. In 2022, the state released the Action Plan outlining a strategic and comprehensive set of state actions to adapt and strengthen resilience to extreme heat. Stakeholder input highlighted the need for the Action Plan to drive coordination and collaboration across federal, regional, and local efforts, support localized action through funding and technical assistance, and maximize multi-benefit strategies that advance the state’s climate and public health goals.
California Climate Change Assessment. Since 2006, the state has undertaken four comprehensive climate change assessments, designed to assess the impacts and risks from climate change and to identify potential solutions to inform policy actions. The climate change assessments directly inform state policies, plans, programs, and guidance to promote effective and integrated action to safeguard California from climate change.
Gender and Climate. According to the Gender Equity Policy Institute (GEPI), the impacts of climate change fall disproportionately on women. For example, in California, women – especially women of color – face more affordability challenges than men. Data shows women are significantly more likely than men to spend unaffordable shares of income on housing or home energy costs. According to GEPI, women are underrepresented in the construction and energy sectors and therefore less likely to benefit from public climate investments. GEPI further argues there are distinct biophysical vulnerabilities to climate change by age and sex that have disparate gendered impacts; women, on average, possess fewer resources to prepare for, adapt, and respond to climate change; and, at the same time, women play a critical role in protecting the health and safety of Californians in the face of climate-driven extreme events.
GEPI contends this bill “mandates a process for the state to assess the gendered impacts of climate change and to recommend evidence-based policy solutions to advance climate resilience for everyone and ensure that no one is left out of the many benefits of the state’s investment in a climate-ready economy.” Specifically, the bill mandates an assessment of the gendered impacts and risks of extreme heat in the Action Plan and the inclusion of gendered impact considerations in reports on issues of statewide significance in the California Climate Change Assessment.
Analysis Prepared by: Nikita Koraddi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 8, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 10
Author:(Padilla) – As Amended Ver:May 12, 2026
SENATE VOTE: Not relevant
SUBJECT: Climate change: plans: gender impacts
SUMMARY: Requires the Natural Resources Agency (NRA) and the Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation (LCI) to incorporate the gender impacts of climate change in specified state climate-related planning documents.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires NRA to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy (Safeguarding California Plan) every three years. Requires NRA to coordinate with relevant state agencies and requires the plan to include vulnerabilities to climate change by sector, as specified, vulnerabilities to climate change for vulnerable communities, a definition of “climate resilience,” priority actions needed to reduce risks and achieve climate resilience, special protections of vulnerable communities and specified industries, opportunities to improve policy and budget coordination, and timetables and metrics to measure and evaluate the state’s progress in implementing the Safeguarding California Plan. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 71153)
- States the intent of the Legislature to prioritize the most vulnerable communities, ecosystems, and economic sectors in the state’s climate adaptation and resilience strategy set forth in the Safeguarding California Plan by ensuring that all state departments and agencies accurately identify, collaboratively prepare for, and are sufficiently resourced to adequately respond to the impacts of climate change, such as extreme weather events, the urban heat island effect, habitat loss, wildfire, sea level rise, and drought. Requires the adoption of strategies that seek to address worsening social and racial inequities. (PRC 71152)
- Requires LCI, formerly the Office of Planning and Research, to develop the California Climate Change Assessment (Assessment), in coordination with NRA, the California Energy Commission, and the Strategic Growth Council, and in consultation with partner public agencies. Requires LCI to conduct the Assessment at least every five years. (PRC 71340)
- Requires LCI and NRA, on or before July 1, 2026, and every three years thereafter, to update the Extreme Heat Action Plan (Action Plan) to promote comprehensive, coordinated, and effective state and local government action on extreme heat. (PRC 71361)
THIS BILL:
- Revises legislative intent regarding the Safeguarding California Plan to include the adoption of strategies that seek to address and, at a minimum, avoid worsening, social, racial, and gender inequities.
- Requires LCI to include gender impacts considerations in its reports on issues of statewide significance prepared as part of the Assessment.
- Requires LCI and NRA, on or before July 1, 2028, to conduct an assessment of the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts and risk of extreme heat for purposes of integration into updates to the Action Plan. Requires LCI and NRA to consider intersectional and systemic inequities. Requires the assessment to be posted on LCI’s and NRA’s websites and provided to the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature. Requires the assessment to include:
- An analysis of the disparate and differentiated gender impacts and risks of extreme heat to identify gaps or unmet needs in the state’s approach to addressing extreme heat;
- An analysis of sex- or gender-disaggregated data, where available, on workers in relevant sectors, including health care and care workers, outdoor workers, and others, to identify those substantially responsible for protecting community health and supporting community resilience in response to extreme heat, as well as those substantially in danger of negative impacts at work from extreme heat; and,
- Recommendations on additional measures or priority actions to address the disparate and differentiated gendered impacts of extreme heat to improve policies, programs, and interagency coordination. Authorizes state agencies to consider the recommendations in developing their programs and policies.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Climate change and gender. Climate change does not affect all people equally. It can act as a “threat multiplier,” by amplifying the threats already facing vulnerable communities. This includes impacts on women and girls. According to the United Nationals Human Rights Commission, “climate change affects women, men, boys and girls, and gender-diverse people in different ways. Entrenched and systemic discrimination can lead to gender-differentiated impacts of climate change with respect to health and well-being, food security, livelihoods, and human mobility, among other issues.” The Gender Snapshot 2024 estimates that by 2050, climate change may drive over 150 million more women and girls into poverty (16 million more than men and boys), and that nearly 50 million more women face food insecurity and hunger than men.
According to the Gender Equity Policy Institute, women bear the brunt of climate change, including in California. The Institute cites more acute affordability challenges facing women and disproportionate responsibility for caregiving. Further, during climate-caused events and emergencies, women are more likely to protect vulnerable individuals, such as children, the elderly, and those with disabilities.
In response to these challenges, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change adopted a Gender Action Plan in 2019 to provide guidance on policies and measures to mainstream gender and achieve gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls. The objectives of the plan are:
- To enhance women’s role as agents of change by addressing the gender inequalities they face;
- To build the capacities of women and girls to access the resources they need to improve their livelihoods, manage land sustainably and become resilient to drought;
- To build the technical capacities of stakeholders at all levels to design and implement gender-responsive plans and programs; and,
- To develop a baseline on gender-related issues in land degradation and desertification, and monitor, report and regularly review progress in the implementation and achievement of objectives; and,
- To mobilize adequate resources to achieve these objectives.
- This bill. SB 10 is intended to ensure that gender perspective is integrated into California’s climate work. This bill requires NRA and LCI to include an assessment of gender impacts into climate planning to avoid exacerbating gender inequities associated with climate change.
- Author’s statement:
Women bear the brunt of the effects of climate change. Global climate agreements include commitments to analyze and address how climate change affects women, men, and gender diverse people differently, in order to mitigate the gendered impacts of climate change, support more effective climate solutions, and advance resilience. Equity is a pillar of California’s climate adaptation and resilience strategy, and gender is one of several vulnerabilities to climate change. Yet despite the state’s commitment to climate equity, the different and disparate impacts of climate change on women have previously been largely overlooked in the state’s climate policy and planning. SB 10 ensures that future planning will address women’s distinct vulnerability in the face of worsening climate impacts., as well as the distinct gendered impacts faced by men and LGBTQ+ people. Integrating gender impact analysis in California’s climate plans will strengthen the state’s ability to design effective and accountable programs, allocate resources where they are most needed, and ensure that all Californians benefit from the significant public investments made by the state to build a climate-ready economy and climate resilient communities.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Environmental Voters
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
Climate Resolve
Coalition of Clean Air
Dake Landscape
Gender Equity Policy Institute (sponsor)
GRID Alternatives, Southern California
LAANE
Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator
National Council of Jewish Women, Los Angeles
The Women’s Building
Worksafe
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 10 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 10
Author: Padilla (D)
Amended: 3/13/25
Vote: 21
SENATE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE: 11-3, 3/25/25
AYES: Cortese, Archuleta, Arreguín, Blakespear, Cervantes, Gonzalez, Grayson, Limón, Menjivar, Richardson, Umberg
NOES: Strickland, Seyarto, Valladares
NO VOTE RECORDED: Dahle
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/23/25
AYES: Caballero, Cabaldon, Grayson, Richardson, Wahab
NOES: Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Dahle
SUBJECT: Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act: toll revenues
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to utilize toll revenues from the State Route (SR) 11/Otay Mesa Port of Entry (POE) to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and other infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Restricts the use of toll revenues received from operation of a toll facility constructed with federal transportation funds. Specifically, requires a public authority with jurisdiction over a toll facility to ensure that all toll revenues are used only for:
- Debt service with respect to the projects on or for which the tolls are authorized, including funding of reasonable reserves and debt service on refinancing;
- A reasonable return on investment of any private person financing the project, as determined by the State or interstate compact of States concerned;
- Any costs necessary for the improvement and proper operation and maintenance of the toll facility, including reconstruction, resurfacing, restoration, and rehabilitation;
- Payments that the party holding the right to toll revenues owes to the other party under the public-private partnership agreement; and
- If the public authority certifies annually that the tolled facility is being adequately maintained, any other purpose for which federal funds may be obligated by a state under Title 23 United States Code.
Existing state law:
- Establishes SANDAG as the transportation planning agency for the San Diego County region.
- The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act (Act) authorizes SANDAG to carry out a construction project for the SR 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility. Authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided.
- Authorizes SANDAG to issue bonds payable from and secured by a pledge of all or any part of the revenues of SANDAG to finance the activities authorized by the Act, and to pledge all or any part of the toll revenues to secure bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG.
- Authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.
- Requires toll revenues to be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
- Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.
- SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
- Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.
- Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
- Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board.
- Payments pursuant to an agreement with the federal government of Mexico or a governmental agency or unit thereof to collect tolls and operate and maintain toll facilities.
This bill:
- Contains a number of findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
- Authorizes, consistent with applicable federal and state law, toll revenues to be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.
- Requires that the repayment of bond obligations take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
- Finds and Declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution, because of the unique need to mitigate the sewage crisis in the County of San Diego by funding the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The crisis at the Tijuana River stems from decades of neglect. We must explore every source of funding and every option available to us to finally put an end to the poison in the very air we breathe. We will no longer accept anything less than the justice this community deserves. SB 10 would authorize funds from the new toll road to be used to help address the worsening crisis in the Tijuana River Valley and ensure that there is an ongoing revenue stream to fund the overdue environmental mitigation of cross-border trade and manufacturing.”
- SR 11 and Otay Mesa East Port of Entry. SR 11 – Otay Mesa East POE project is a joint venture between the SANDAG and the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), in collaboration with state and federal partners in the United States (U.S.) and Mexico, to create a new border crossing for the San Diego-Baja California region that will help enhance regional mobility and fuel economic growth and binational trade.
A combination of federal, state, and local funds totaling $635 million have already been secured to construct the roadway facilities leading to the POE and acquire the right-of-way needed for the site, which has been completed. Approximately $699 million in capital costs are needed to complete the remaining structures. Some of the funding has been secured including $71 million in federal formula funds, $192 million from the Trade Corridor Enhancement Program, $150 million from the U.S. Department of Transportation's Infrastructure for Rebuilding America (INFRA) program, and $15 million in local funds. However, the primary funding, $271 million, will come from the use of toll revenue bonds, with debt obligations being secured by future toll revenues. Additionally, SANDAG estimates that toll revenues over the next 40 years will total roughly $7.4 billion. The tolling agreement with Mexico would provide on overall 50-50 split of the funds. SANDAG’s portion of the funds, roughly $3.7 billion, would be obligated to be used first for debt payments on the bonds issued, the future operations and maintenance of the facilities, and the eventual modernization project.
- Tijuana River Watershed and the South Bay International Water Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). The Tijuana River watershed is a large binational watershed of approximately 1,750 square miles that lies across the California-Mexico border. A large portion of the watershed (approximately 75%) is within Mexico and encompasses the densely urbanized city of Tijuana, Mexico. The watershed drains into the Tijuana River Estuary in the U.S. and ultimately to the Pacific Ocean in the city of Imperial Beach.
In light of continued cross-border sanitation issues, the U.S. and Mexico created a binational interagency "Clean Water Partnership." In 1990, the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) authorized construction of a treatment plant on the Tijuana River, north of the border. The SBIWTP has current capability of treating 25 million gallons per day (MGD), but has an expansion capability of up to 100 MGD. Once treated, water from the plant flows through a pipe leading to the South Bay Ocean Outfall.
Unfortunately, sewage has been spilling from Mexico into the coastal waters of the southernmost coast of California for decades because of inadequate and failing infrastructure and the rapid growth of Tijuana. The IBWC has documented 35 billion gallons of wastewater entering the U.S. through the Tijuana River since December 2022, and over 100 billion since 2018. Beaches have been closed since December 2021 due to poor water quality. The SBIWTP has been in dire need of updates and repairs.
- U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement and plan to try to fix the problem. When Congress approved the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement in 2019, California Congressional representatives succeeded in adding $300 million to identify infrastructure solutions to address the significant negative impacts of water pollution in cross-border rivers on water quality, public health, and the environment. In 2020, the U.S. government committed funding to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) to be used to address Tijuana River water quality problems. In fall 2021, the U.S. EPA completed an evaluation of the problem and developed a set of project proposals known as the “Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution.”
According to the U.S. EPA, the estimated costs of the plan are $627 million to repair and expand the capacity of the SBIWTP. Additionally, it is estimated that approximately $23 million is needed for annual operations and maintenance growing to $46 million annually after the expansion. The Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution has yet to be completed. Last year, $156 million in additional funding for the IBWC was secured in the bipartisan Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 appropriations package. The funding will help repair the SBIWTP to address trans-border water pollution. SB 10 authorizes SANDAG to use toll revenues generated by the SR 11/Otay Mesa POE to assist in the maintenance of SBIWTP and the development of additional infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River.
- It’s complicated. There are a number of complicated issues with the proposed use of toll revenues collected at the SR 11/POE for the SBIWTP. The first is federal law. Title 23 of the U.S. Code, which governs the nation’s highway program, dictates the requirements for federal participation in any toll project, including the limitation on the use of toll revenues. Specifically, the toll operator must ensure that all toll revenue received by operation of the toll facility be used to pay debt service, operations and maintenance of the toll facility, and payments to private investors as part of a public-private partnership. If the toll operator certifies annually that the tolled facility is being adequately maintained, any excess toll revenues can only be used for other Title 23 eligible projects.
It is unclear whether funding for the SBIWTP and related sanitation efforts would be eligible for Title 23 funding. SB 10 requires any use of toll revenue to be consistent with applicable federal and state law and subject to an agreement with the federal government. SANDAG would need approval from the U.S. Department of Transportation to pursue any use of toll revenues outside of the SR 11/POE project. It is also unclear if the toll uses authorized in SB 10 would be allowable by state law as the project is a partnership with Caltrans and is partially funded by state transportation revenues.
Second, as previously detailed, the final construction of the full POE facilities and the ongoing operations and maintenance will be funded through toll revenue bonds with an estimated 40 years of repayment. The toll revenue will also be split 50-50 with Mexico. For the bond issuance to be successful and attractive to the bond market, SANDAG must be able to ensure that the proceeds of the tolls will be first used to pay any debt service. For this reason, recent amendments to SB 10 include language requiring the repayment of bond obligations take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- To the extent the use of toll revenues for sewage treatment facility maintenance and other sanitation projects is consistent with federal and state law, this bill would result in unknown, major cost pressures, likely in the millions annually. Diversion of toll revenues for purposes specified in the bill that are not directly related to the new Port of Entry would reduce amounts currently planned for expenditure on transportation facilities associated with the state highway system in the SR 11 corridor, including the Intelligent Transportation System (ITS), tolling facilities, and the California Highway Patrol’s Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Facility. To the extent there are insufficient remaining toll revenues to pay for ongoing operations, maintenance, repair/replacement, and improvements to those facilities, it may be necessary to expend state transportation revenues for those purposes. (various transportation funds)
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/23/25)
4 Walls International
Alliance San Diego
Audubon California
Azul
California Environmental Justice Alliance Action, a Project of Tides Advocacy
Chula Vista Democratic Club
City of Chula Vista
City of National City
Coronado Democratic Club
Coronado; City of
County of San Diego Third District Supervisor Terra Lawson-remer
Environmental Health Coalition
Friends of International Friendship Park, INC.
Lideres Campesinas
Lift to Rise
Los Amigos De LA Comunidad, INC.
Outdoor Outreach
San Diego Audubon Society
San Diego Coastkeeper
San Diego for Every Child
San Diego Natural History Museum
San Diego; County of
Sandiego350
Sierra Club
Stop the Sewage
The San Diego Mountain Biking Association
Un Mar De Colores
Wildcoast
YMCA of San Diego County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/23/25)
California Taxpayers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Environmental Health Coalition states, “For years, the communities of South San Diego County have endured the worst effects of transboundary pollution from Mexico. Ongoing trans-border flows have a severe impact on the economy and environment of the region, but most importantly, billions of gallons of raw sewage have created an untenable and serious public health threat to local communities. There is a growing body of evidence that shows dangerous water quality has caused tens of thousands of illnesses in the region.
“By providing a portion of the proceeds made from this border crossing to help rectify the worsening crisis in the Tijuana River Valley, we can ensure that there is an ongoing revenue stream available to finally begin overdue environmental mitigation of cross-border trade and manufacturing. This would be a significant step in mitigating the decades of air, water and health impacts experienced by communities on both sides of the U.S.-Mexico Border.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Taxpayer Association states, “In 2010, California voters approved Proposition 26, which creates a clear distinction between taxes and fees and establishes a transparent process for government to use when adopting new levies. CalTax played a leading role in developing this initiative in response to Californians’ growing concerns over affordability and the rise of fees and hidden charges.
“Proposition 26 states that a charge is a tax if it provides funding for a specific benefit or privilege to someone who does not pay the charge. In the case of SB 10, drivers commuting through the California-Baja California corridor would pay a toll that would support sewage treatment in Southern California – an unrelated issue. Many commuters do not live in the area and would receive no benefits from increased wastewater treatment. Thus, the charge imposed by SB 10 is a tax because the payors do not necessarily receive a direct, specific, and proportional benefit.”
Prepared by: Melissa White / TRANS. / (916) 651-4121
5/24/25 23:30:18
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular Session
SB 10 (Padilla) - Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act: toll revenues
Version: March 13, 2025 | Policy Vote: TRANS. 11 - 3 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 21, 2025 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
SB 10 would authorize the use of toll revenues collected at the State Route (SR) 11/Otay Mesa East Port of Entry international border crossing to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) sewage treatment facility and other sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River.
Fiscal Impact:
- To the extent the use of toll revenues for sewage treatment facility maintenance and other sanitation projects is consistent with federal and state law, this bill would result in unknown, major cost pressures, likely in the millions annually. Diversion of toll revenues for purposes specified in the bill that are not directly related to the new Port of Entry would reduce amounts currently planned for expenditure on transportation facilities associated with the state highway system in the SR 11 corridor, including the Intelligent Transportation System (ITS), tolling facilities, and the California Highway Patrol’s Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Facility. To the extent there are insufficient remaining toll revenues to pay for ongoing operations, maintenance, repair/replacement, and improvements to those facilities, it may be necessary to expend state transportation revenues for those purposes. See Staff Comments. (various transportation funds)
Background:
SR 11/ Otay Mesa East Port of Entry:
The SR 11/Otay Mesa East Port of Entry (POE) project is a joint venture between the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) and Caltrans, in collaboration with state and federal partners in the United States (U.S.) and Mexico, to create a new border crossing for the San Diego-Baja California region that will help enhance regional mobility and fuel economic growth and binational trade. SB 1486 (Ducheny), Chap. 720/2008, enacted the Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act (Act), which authorized SANDAG to construct and operate the SR 11 and a new federal POE by charging tolls, and issuing bonds secured by those toll revenues to finance the cost of acquiring or operating transportation facilities, international ports of entry, international border crossing facilities and other necessary and related facilities. The Act was further updated through the enactment of SB 985 (Hueso), Chap.422/2022, following the completion of construction of highway facilities approaching the POE, to authorize SANDAG to enter into an agreement and contracts, as specified, with the government of Mexico or a government agency for the purposes of imposing and collecting tolls, and for acquiring, operating, and maintaining tolling facilities at the POE. Once completed, the project is expected to reduce the border-crossing wait time that are currently averaging 2-4 hours down to 20 minutes. The new POE is also expected to serve as a relief valve for other border crossings in the area, decreasing peak wait times at regional existing land ports of entry by 50% on opening day. In addition to reduced wait times, the new capacity will improve air quality and mobility throughout the cross border region.
Existing law authorizes SANDAG to only impose tolls for entrance to or use of the corridor, and specifies that toll revenues collected pursuant to the Act may be used to reimburse or finance the costs incurred in connection with the implementation, construction, maintenance, or operation of a project. The Act defines a “project” as any property and related facilities acquired or constructed to facilitate the movement of goods and people along the corridor or at the POE, including: (1) property suitable for international ports of entry; (2) international border crossing facilities; (3) transportation facilities, including highway and roadway, public transit, and nonmotorized facilities, and other projects supporting any transportation facility; and (4) a bridge or tunnel, overpasses, underpasses, entrance plazas, toll houses, administration, storage and other buildings and facilities, as specified. The Act requires toll revenues to be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
- Payments pursuant to bond resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments, as well as any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG, as specified.
- SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
- Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred or payable by those agencies for specified purposes related to a project.
- Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
- Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the POE, including public transit and nonmotorized options that would reduce vehicle miles traveled, as specified.
- Payments pursuant to an agreement with the federal government of Mexico or a governmental agency or unit thereof to collect tolls and operate and maintain toll facilities.
According to SANDAG, Caltrans construction on the final segment of the future SR 11 toll road, which terminates at the future POE site, is complete. Additionally, in December 2021, Caltrans and SANDAG celebrated the opening of the SR 125 and SR 905/SR 11 southbound connectors. To date, a total of $602 million has been spent for right-of-way acquisition, SR 11 improvements, and the connectors, including $278 million in federal funds, $49 million in local funds, and $275 million in state funds. Approximately $608 million in capital funding is needed to complete the remaining structures, the POE, the Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) and tolling, and the Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Facility. Some of the funding has been secured including $32 million in federal formula funds, $140 million from the SB 1 Trade Corridor Enhancement Program, $150 million from the U.S. Department of Transportation's Infrastructure for Rebuilding America (INFRA) program, and $15 million in local funds. However, the primary funding, $271 million, will come from the use of toll revenue bonds, with debt obligations being secured by future toll revenues.
The POE officially broke ground in August 2022 to begin design and construction. In October of 2022, a toll agreement was reached between the U.S., Mexico, and SANDAG that specifies a 50/50 split of toll revenues with Mexico. In April 2024, the project reached 30% design and a Memorandum of Understanding was executed in June 2024 to complete final design and procure Construction Manager/General Contractor contracts. As of January 2025, SANDAG and Caltrans negotiated a Federal Project Agreement (FPA) with the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) and the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) outlining the roles of all agencies involved in the POE's design, construction, commissioning, operation, ownership, management, and future sharing of toll revenue.
Tijuana River pollution: The Tijuana River flows north from Tijuana into the Tijuana River and Estuary (TJRE) in the U.S., emptying into the Pacific Ocean at Imperial Beach. The TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage, industrial waste, and urban run-off due to inadequate infrastructure and urbanization and the watershed is classified as an impaired water body according to the U.S. Clean Water Act. This contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat with major economic, legal, social, and health implications for nearby communities such as San Ysidro and Imperial Beach.
In light of continued cross-border sanitation issues, the U.S. and Mexico created a binational interagency "Clean Water Partnership." In 1990, IBWC authorized construction of a treatment plant on the Tijuana River, north of the border, called the South Bay International Water Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). This treatment plant was constructed in 1996 and has current capability of treating 25 million gallons per day (MGD) when fully operational, but has an expansion capability of up to 100 MGD. Once treated, water from the plant flows through a pipe leading to the South Bay Ocean Outfall. Over time, however, and as a result of growth and major storm events, the plant has been overwhelmed and is only partially operational and in need of critical repairs, resulting in untreated sewage and stormwater discharges into the South Bay Ocean Outfall and directly to the ocean.
In 2020, the U.S. government committed funding to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) to be used to address Tijuana River water quality problems. In fall 2021, the U.S. EPA completed an evaluation of the problem and developed a set of project proposals known as the “Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution.” According to the U.S. EPA, the estimated costs of the plan are $627 million to repair and expand the capacity of the SBIWTP. Additionally, it is estimated that approximately $23 million is needed for annual operations and maintenance growing to $46 million annually after the expansion. The Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution has yet to be completed. Last year, $156 million in additional funding for the IBWC was secured in the federal bipartisan FY 2024 appropriations package. The funding will help repair the SBIWTP to address trans-border water pollution, but large funding gaps remain.
Proposed Law:
SB 10 would authorize, consistent with federal and state laws, toll revenues collected for entrance or use of the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry to be used to assist in the maintenance of the IBWC sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government. The bill specifies that the repayment of bond obligations shall take priority over all other allocations of toll revenues.
Related Legislation:
AB 427 (Alvarez), Chap. 163/2023, explicitly authorized SANDAG to use the Construction Manager/General Contractor project delivery method on the SR 11/ Otay Mesa East Port of Entry project, as specified.
SB 985 (Hueso), Chap. 422/2022, made various changes to the Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act, including authorizing the SANDAG to enter into an agreement and contracts, as specified, with the government of Mexico or a government agency for the purposes of imposing and collecting tolls, and for acquiring, operating, and maintaining tolling facilities at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry.
SB 1486 (Ducheny), Chap. 720/2008, the Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act, authorized SANDAG to construct and operate the SR 11 and a new federal Otay Mesa East Port of Entry by charging tolls, and issuing bonds secured by those toll revenues to finance the cost of acquiring or operating transportation facilities, international ports of entry, international border crossing facilities and other necessary and related facilities.
Staff Comments:
SANDAG and Caltrans are expecting that tolls will generate approximately $7.2 billion in net revenues over 40 years, half of which will account for Mexico’s share pursuant to the toll agreement, leaving $3.6 billion do divide up as follows, according to the negotiated agreement with the federal government (FPA):
- $1.3 billion to service bond debt.
- $497 million to the U.S. GSA for operations, maintenance, and repairs/replacement costs.
- $540 million to the U.S. GSA for modernization costs.
- $564 million to the U.S. CBP for operations, maintenance, and repairs/replacement costs.
- $343 million for a dedicated reserve.
- $439 million to SANDAG for costs associated with the CVEF, ITS, and SR 11 operations, maintenance, repairs/replacement, and improvements.
The toll revenues anticipated to be collected upon operation of this POE facility are already fully spoken for under these existing agreements. As noted above, the expenditure of toll revenues for ongoing maintenance of the IBWC sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects would divert toll revenues from other transportation-related purposes, thereby creating state cost pressures. Since the FPA requires dedicated funding for bond debt service, the U.S. GSA, the U.S. CBP, and a dedicated reserve, any diversion of toll revenues for the purposes specified in this bill would come out of the amount specified in the agreements that is dedicated to operations, maintenance, repairs/replacement, and improvements to SR 11, the CVEF, and ITS facilities. To the extent remaining funds are not sufficient for those purposes, this bill creates cost pressures to backfill the diverted toll revenues from other state transportation funding sources.
Caltrans notes that this bill could disrupt existing funding agreements for the Otay Mesa East POE, as toll revenues previously designated for specified transportation purposes could be redirected to address environmental concerns beyond what existing international toll revenue agreements stipulate. This could lead to a reassessment of current financial plans and obligations associated with the POE’s development and operation. Staff notes that renegotiation of multi-lateral agreements could result in project delays and in increased project costs, as well as a risk of losing federal grant funds as current agreements require federal funds to be obligated by the end of this year.
Caltrans also indicates that the Otay Mesa East POE project does not impact the Tijuana River Valley, and no mitigation measures were proposed as part of the project to address any environmental issues in association with the Tijuana River Valley.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION
Senator Dave Cortese, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: SB 10 Hearing Date: 3/25/2025
Author: | Padilla | ||
Version: | 3/13/2025 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Melissa White | ||
SUBJECT: Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act: toll revenues
DIGEST: This bill authorizes the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) to utilize toll revenues from the State Route (SR) 11/Otay Mesa Port of Entry (POE) to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and other infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Restricts the use of toll revenues received from operation of a toll facility constructed with federal transportation funds. Specifically, requires a public authority with jurisdiction over a toll facility to ensure that all toll revenues are used only for:
- Debt service with respect to the projects on or for which the tolls are authorized, including funding of reasonable reserves and debt service on refinancing;
- A reasonable return on investment of any private person financing the project, as determined by the State or interstate compact of States concerned;
- Any costs necessary for the improvement and proper operation and maintenance of the toll facility, including reconstruction, resurfacing, restoration, and rehabilitation;
- Payments that the party holding the right to toll revenues owes to the other party under the public-private partnership agreement; and
- If the public authority certifies annually that the tolled facility is being adequately maintained, any other purpose for which federal funds may be obligated by a state under Title 23 United States Code.
Existing state law:
- Establishes SANDAG as the transportation planning agency for the San Diego County region.
- The Otay Mesa East Toll Facility Act (Act) authorizes SANDAG to carry out a construction project for the State Route (SR) 11 corridor, including, among other things, highway improvements and international border crossing facilities, to be operated as a toll facility.
- Authorizes SANDAG to fix and revise from time to time and charge and collect tolls and other charges for entrance to or the use of the corridor, as provided.
- Authorizes SANDAG to issue bonds payable from and secured by a pledge of all or any part of the revenues of SANDAG to finance the activities authorized by the Act, and to pledge all or any part of the toll revenues to secure bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG.
- Authorizes toll revenues to be used for specified costs, including, among other things, payments of a cooperative tolling agreement with the federal government of Mexico.
- Requires toll revenues to be used to pay for costs in the following categories:
- Payments pursuant to bonds and resolutions, indentures, and other constituent instruments defining the rights of the holders of bonds and any repayment or reimbursement obligations of SANDAG to any providers of bond insurance or letters of credit or lines of credit related to bonds.
- SANDAG costs for operations, toll collection, and administration of the projects.
- Reimbursement or payment to federal, state, and local agencies for costs incurred by or payable to those agencies for services, equipment, goods, fixtures, operation, maintenance, personnel, or software provided to or in furtherance of a project that are reimbursable pursuant to a written agreement between SANDAG and the respective agency.
- Costs for capital improvements to repair or rehabilitate a project, to expand project capacity, to improve project operations, or to increase public transit and nonmotorized options in the corridor.
- Costs for projects that increase transportation options along the corridor or at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry, including, but not limited to, public transit and nonmotorized transportation that would result in reduced vehicle miles traveled, pursuant to the plan approved by the board.
- Payments pursuant to an agreement with the federal government of Mexico or a governmental agency or unit thereof to collect tolls and operate and maintain toll facilities.
This bill:
- Contains a number of findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
- Authorizes, consistent with applicable federal and state law, toll revenues to be used to assist in the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility and the development of additional sanitation infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River pursuant to an agreement with the federal government.
- Requires that the repayment of bond obligations take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
- Finds and Declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution, because of the unique need to mitigate the sewage crisis in the County of San Diego by funding the maintenance of the South Bay International Boundary and Water Commission sewage treatment facility.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The crisis at the Tijuana River stems from decades of neglect. We must explore every source of funding and every option available to us to finally put an end to the poison in the very air we breathe. We will no longer accept anything less than the justice this community deserves. SB 10 would authorize funds from the new toll road to be used to help address the worsening crisis in the Tijuana River Valley and ensure that there is an ongoing revenue stream to fund the overdue environmental mitigation of cross-border trade and manufacturing.”
- SR 11 and Otay Mesa East Port of Entry. The State Route 11 -- Otay Mesa East Port of Entry (POE) project is a joint venture between the SANDAG and the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), in collaboration with state and federal partners in the United States (U.S.) and Mexico, to create a new border crossing for the San Diego-Baja California region that will help enhance regional mobility and fuel economic growth and binational trade.
SB 1486 (Ducheny, Chapter 720, Statutes of 2008), originally authorized SANDAG to construct and operate the SR 11 and a new federal POE by charging tolls, and issuing bonds secured by those toll revenues to finance the cost of acquiring or operating transportation facilities, international ports of entry, international border crossing facilities and other necessary and related facilities.
SB 985 (Hueso, Chapter 422, Statutes of 2022), made various changes to the Act, including authorizing SANDAG to enter into an agreement and contracts with the government of Mexico or a government agency for the purposes of imposing and collecting tolls; and acquiring, operating, and maintaining tolling facilities at POE.
As the U.S.-Mexico border region grows, there is a need to improve the commercial movement of goods, services, and passengers through an efficient, integrated system to support the local, state, federal, and international economies. For example, in 2019, the existing Otay Mesa and Tecate ports of entry processed a combined $48.3 billion in total bilateral trade, and that number is expected to grow over the coming years. Additionally, wait times for personal and commercial vehicles to cross the border is an average of 2-4 hours.
According to the SANDAG Business Case for the new POE, this back up contributes to $3.4 billion in lost economic output due to delays experienced by the 1.3 million trucks that cross the border annually; 88,000 jobs lost in the U.S. due to border delays; and over 19,000 tons of GHG emissions are released annually due to idling vehicles. According to SANDAG, the new POE will help accommodate growing demands on border crossings by increasing capacity. The new capacity will help to reduce wait times at all regional POEs, improving air quality and mobility throughout the cross border region. The new SR 11/POE is expected to reduce wait times to a 20-minute average.
- How will the tolls work? The U.S. and Mexico are currently coordinating the design of the POE tolling system on both sides of the border. Primary Toll Collection readers will be placed on the Mexican side of the border for northbound and southbound travelers. Secondary or redundant toll readers will be located on the U.S. side for both northbound and southbound travelers (to be activated in case Mexican readers are not working properly). The toll revenue will be allocated equitably between the U.S. and Mexico under a revenue allocation agreement. The new POE will have dynamic toll rates that change on an hourly basis, based on demand, to ensure travelers’ wait times do not exceed 20-30 minutes, on average. Higher tolls will be charged during peak periods to help manage throughput. Additionally, the new POE will feature state-of-the-art scanning equipment for passenger and commercial vehicles to maximize throughput. An advanced traveler information system will inform border crossers about toll rates, wait times, lane conditions, and incidents. An integrated operations system will link traffic operations.
- What’s the current status? According to SANDAG, Caltrans construction on the final segment of the future SR 11 toll road, which terminates at the future POE site, is complete. Additionally, in December 2021, Caltrans and SANDAG celebrated the opening of the SR 125 and SR 905/SR 11 southbound connectors. The POE officially broke ground in August 2022 to begin design and construction.
In October of 2022, a toll agreement was reached between the U.S., Mexico, and SANDAG. In April 2024, the project reached 30% design and a Memorandum of Understanding was executed in June 2024 to complete final design and procure Construction Manager/General Contractor contracts.
As of January 2025, SANDAG and Caltrans negotiated an Federal Project Agreement (FPA) with the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) and the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) outlining the roles of all agencies involved in the POE's design, construction, commissioning, operation, ownership, management, and future sharing of toll revenue.
- How does the funding work? A combination of federal, state, and local funds totaling $635 million have already been secured to construct the roadway facilities leading to the POE and acquire the right-of-way needed for the site, which has been completed. Approximately $699 million in capital costs are needed to complete the remaining structures, the POE, the Intelligent Transportation System and tolling, and the Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Facility. Some of the funding has been secured including $71 million in federal formula funds, $192 million from the SB 1 Trade Corridor Enhancement Program, $150 million from the U.S. Department of Transportation's Infrastructure for Rebuilding America (INFRA) program, and $15 million in local funds. However, the primary funding, $271 million, will come from the use of toll revenue bonds, with debt obligations being secured by future toll revenues.
Additionally, SANDAG estimates that toll revenues over the next 40 years will total roughly $7.4 billion. The tolling agreement with Mexico would provide on overall 50-50 split of the funds. SANDAG’s portion of the funds, roughly $3.7 billion, would be obligated to be used first for debt payments on the bonds issued, the future operations and maintenance of the facilities, and the eventual modernization project.
- Tijuana River Watershed. The Tijuana River watershed is a large binational watershed of approximately 1,750 square miles that lies across the California-Mexico border. A large portion of the watershed (approximately 75%) is within Mexico and encompasses the densely urbanized city of Tijuana, Mexico. The watershed drains into the Tijuana River Estuary in the U.S. and ultimately to the Pacific Ocean in the city of Imperial Beach.
While significant improvements in wastewater treatment have, in recent years, improved water quality on both sides of the border, stormwater flows continue to bring substantial amounts of sediment, trash, and other contaminants into the
Valley. The sediment and trash pollutants cause water quality impairments, threaten life and property from flooding, degrade valuable habitats, and impact recreational opportunities for residents and visitors.
- International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC). Bi-national concerns about Tijuana River water quality date back to 1934, when the United States and Mexican governments instructed the International Boundary Commission (predecessor to IBWC) to prepare a report on the Tijuana sewage problem. When the U.S. and Mexico signed the Water Treaty of 1944, Article III made the use of cross-border waters subject to "sanitary measures or works." The two governments also agreed to give preferential attention to the solution of all border sanitation problems.
In light of continued cross-border sanitation issues, the U.S. and Mexico created a binational interagency "Clean Water Partnership." In 1990, IBWC authorized construction of a treatment plant on the Tijuana River, north of the border, called the South Bay International Water Treatment Plant (SBIWTP). This treatment plant has current capability of treating 25 million gallons per day (MGD), but has an expansion capability of up to 100 MGD. Once treated, water from the plant flows through a pipe leading to the South Bay Ocean Outfall.
- What is the problem? Sewage has been spilling from Mexico into the coastal waters of the southernmost coast of California for decades because of inadequate and failing infrastructure and the rapid growth of Tijuana. The IBWC has documented 35 billion gallons of wastewater entering the U.S. through the Tijuana River since December 2022, and over 100 billion since 2018. Beaches have been closed since December 2021 due to poor water quality.
The SBIWTP has been in dire need of updates and repairs. Major storm events have caused an influx of water that exceeded the plant's capacity, resulting in untreated sewage and stormwater discharges into the South Bay Ocean Outfall and directly to the ocean.
Tropical Storm Hilary in 2023 accelerated damage to the already strained plant. The recovery plan to restore the SBIWTP's ability to fully treat 25 MGD of wastewater and restore compliance with discharge water quality permit parameters has been estimated to cost $8 million.
- U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement and plan to try to fix the problem. When Congress approved the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement in 2019, California Congressional representatives succeeded in adding $300 million to identify infrastructure solutions to address the significant negative impacts of water pollution in cross-border rivers on water quality, public health, and the environment. In 2020, the U.S. government committed funding to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) to be used to address Tijuana River water quality problems. In fall 2021, the U.S. EPA completed an evaluation of the problem and developed a set of project proposals known as the “Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution.” According to the U.S. EPA, the estimated costs of the plan are $627 million to repair and expand the capacity of the SBIWTP. Additionally, it is estimated that approximately $23 million is needed for annual operations and maintenance growing to $46 million annually after the expansion. The Comprehensive Infrastructure Solution has yet to be completed.
Last year, $156 million in additional funding for the IBWC was secured in the bipartisan FY 2024 appropriations package. The funding will help repair the SBIWTP to address trans-border water pollution.
- Legislature’s work on border river water quality. The California Legislature has been working to address water quality in its border rivers for the last 20 years. It has passed bills to support state agency projects to improve water quality and held informational hearings on efforts to improve border river water quality. State budgets since 2017 have included appropriations for border river water quality, as follows:
- 2017: Reappropriated $2.1 million from the 2014 California Wildlife, Coastal, and Park Land Conservation Fund of 1988 for acquisition of lands in the Tijuana River Valley;
- 2019: Appropriated $15 million for Tijuana River pollution control;
- 2020: Appropriated $18 million from the General Fund and $10 million from Proposition 68 water bond funds for the New River Project;
- 2021: Appropriated $20 million to improve water quality in border rivers; and,
- 2022: Appropriated $15 million for border rivers cleanup.
- Trying to find a dedicated source of funding. SB 10 would authorize SANDAG to use toll revenues generated by the SR 11/Otay Mesa POE to assist in the maintenance of SBIWTP and the development of additional infrastructure projects related to the Tijuana River. As noted above, there are funds appropriated for the rehab and expansion of the SBIWTP facility, but there is no funding stream for ongoing operations and maintenance. As both the SR 11/POE and the SBIWTP projects are being undertaken in partnership with and with funding from the federal government, the bill also requires an agreement with the federal government for use of the toll revenues. Finally, the bill states that the repayment of any bond obligations must take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
- It’s complicated. There are a number of complicated issues with the proposed use of toll revenues collected at the SR 11/POE for the SBIWTP. The first is federal law. Title 23 of the U.S. Code, which governs the nation’s highway program, dictates the requirements for federal participation in any toll road project, including the limitation on the use of toll revenues. Specifically, the toll operator must ensure that all toll revenue received by operation of the toll facility be used to pay debt service, operations and maintenance of the toll facility, and payments to private investors as part of a public-private partnership. If the toll operator certifies annually that the tolled facility is being adequately maintained, any excess toll revenues can only be used for other Title 23 eligible projects.
It is unclear whether funding for the SBIWTP and related sanitation efforts would be eligible for Title 23 funding. SB 10 requires any use of toll revenue to be consistent with applicable federal and state law and subject to an agreement with the federal government. SANDAG would need approval from the U.S. Department of Transportation to pursue any use of toll revenues outside of the SR 11/POE project. It is also unclear if the toll uses authorized in SB 10 would be allowable by state law as the project is a partnership with Caltrans and is partially funded by state transportation revenues.
Second, as previously detailed, the final construction of the full POE facilities and the ongoing operations and maintenance will be funded through toll revenue bonds with an estimated 40 years of repayment. The toll revenue will also be split 50-50 with Mexico. For the bond issuance to be successful and attractive to the bond market, SANDAG must be able to ensure that the proceeds of the tolls will be first used to pay any debt service. For this reason, recent amendments to SB 10 include language requiring the repayment of bond obligations take priority over other allocations of toll revenues.
Finally, the toll amounts would be a consideration. As noted, the SR 11/POE will have dynamic toll rates that change on an hourly basis based on demand, with higher tolls being charged during peak periods to help manage throughput. SANDAG has estimated the gross toll revenues expected and will revisit tolls based on the need to repay debt and fund operations and maintenance of the POE facility. It is unclear whether any additional revenues would be available for uses outside the POE facility.
- Support and Opposition. Writing in support, the Environmental Health Coalition states, “For years, the communities of South San Diego County have endured the worst effects of transboundary pollution from Mexico. Ongoing trans-border flows have a severe impact on the economy and environment of the region, but most importantly, billions of gallons of raw sewage have created an untenable and serious public health threat to local communities. There is a growing body of evidence that shows dangerous water quality has caused tens of thousands of illnesses in the region.
“By providing a portion of the proceeds made from this border crossing to help rectify the worsening crisis in the Tijuana River Valley, we can ensure that there is an ongoing revenue stream available to finally begin overdue environmental mitigation of cross-border trade and manufacturing. This would be a significant step in mitigating the decades of air, water and health impacts experienced by communities on both sides of the U.S.-Mexico Border.”
Writing in opposition, the California Taxpayer Association states, “In 2010, California voters approved Proposition 26, which creates a clear distinction between taxes and fees and establishes a transparent process for government to use when adopting new levies. CalTax played a leading role in developing this initiative in response to Californians’ growing concerns over affordability and the rise of fees and hidden charges.
“Proposition 26 states that a charge is a tax if it provides funding for a specific benefit or privilege to someone who does not pay the charge. In the case of SB 10, drivers commuting through the California-Baja California corridor would pay a toll that would support sewage treatment in Southern California – an unrelated issue. Many commuters do not live in the area and would receive no benefits from increased wastewater treatment. Thus, the charge imposed by SB 10 is a tax because the payors do not necessarily receive a direct, specific, and proportional benefit.”
Related/PREVIOUS Legislation:
SB 985 (Hueso, Chapter 422, Statutes of 2022) -- Made various changes to the Act, including authorizing the SANDAG to enter into an agreement and contracts, as specified, with the government of Mexico or a government agency for the purposes of imposing and collecting tolls; and acquiring, operating, and maintaining tolling facilities at the Otay Mesa East Port of Entry.
SB 1486 (Ducheny, Chapter 720, Statutes of 2008) – Authorized SANDAG to construct and operate the SR 11 and a new federal Otay Mesa East Port of Entry by charging tolls, and issuing bonds secured by those toll revenues to finance the cost of acquiring or operating transportation facilities, international ports of entry, international border crossing facilities and other necessary and related facilities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
March 19, 2025.)
SUPPORT:
4 Walls International
Alliance San Diego
Azul
Chula Vista Democratic Club
City of Chula Vista
City of National City
Coronado Democratic Club
City of Coronado
County of San Diego, Third District Supervisor Terra Lawson-Remer
Environmental Health Coalition
Friends of International Friendship Park, INC.
Lideres Campesinas
Lift to Rise
Los Amigos De LA Comunidad, INC.
Outdoor Outreach
San Diego Audubon Society
San Diego Coastkeeper
San Diego for Every Child
San Diego Natural History Museum
Sandiego350
Sierra Club
Stop the Sewage
The San Diego Mountain Biking Association
Un Mar De Colores
Wildcoast
YMCA of San Diego County
OPPOSITION:
California Taxpayers Association
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):