SB 1063: Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act: life-sustaining services: take permit.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2026-03-25
Current Status:
Failed
(2026-04-23: April 21 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 4. Page 3981.))
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
The Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act prohibits any person or public agency from importing into the state, exporting out of the state, or taking, possessing, purchasing, or selling within the state, a western Joshua tree or any part or product of the tree, except as specified. The act authorizes the Department of Fish and Wildlife to permit the taking of a western Joshua tree if specified conditions are met, including, but not limited to, that the permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the western Joshua tree through measures that are roughly proportional in extent to the authorized taking of the western Joshua tree. The act authorizes, in lieu of completing the mitigation measures, a permittee to elect to satisfy the mitigation obligation by paying fees pursuant to a specified fee schedule, as provided.
This bill would authorize the department to permit the taking of a western Joshua tree without payment of fees or other mitigation upon demonstration to the department that the taking of a western Joshua tree is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service, as defined. service connection to a single-family residence or multifamily residence, including distribution infrastructure, as specified. The bill would require the department to grant or deny that permit within 30 days of a request, or within 10 days of a request to address a threat to health or safety. The bill would allow the permittee 60 days to complete the taking authorized by that permit and the department may extend this 60-day period at its discretion.
The Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act prohibits any person or public agency from importing into the state, exporting out of the state, or taking, possessing, purchasing, or selling within the state, a western Joshua tree or any part or product of the tree, except as specified. The act authorizes the Department of Fish and Wildlife to permit the taking of a western Joshua tree if specified conditions are met, including, but not limited to, that the permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the western Joshua tree through measures that are roughly proportional in extent to the authorized taking of the western Joshua tree. The act authorizes, in lieu of completing the mitigation measures, a permittee to elect to satisfy the mitigation obligation by paying fees pursuant to a specified fee schedule, as provided.
This bill would authorize the department to permit the taking of a western Joshua tree without payment of fees or other mitigation upon demonstration to the department that the taking of a western Joshua tree is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service, as defined. The bill would require the department to grant or deny that permit within 30 days of a request, or within 10 days of a request to address a threat to health or safety. The bill would allow the permittee 60 days to complete the taking authorized by that permit and the department may extend this 60-day period at its discretion.
For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Accessory structure means a subordinate structure, the use of which is incidental to an existing or contemporaneously constructed single-family residence, including, an accessory dwelling unit, addition to an existing single-family residence, garage, carport, swimming pool, patio, greenhouse, storage shed, gazebo, septic tank, sewer connection, solar panels, fence, or gravel or paved driveway.
(b)California Endangered Species Act means the act established pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3.
(c)Conserve or conservation means to use, and the use of, methods and procedures that are necessary to bring species listed pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 to the point at which the measures provided pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 are no longer necessary, and for species that are not listed to maintain or enhance the condition of the species so that listing will not become necessary.
(d)Dead western Joshua tree means a western Joshua tree that meets at least one of the following criteria:
(1)Has not burned and has no green leaves, no new growth on the main stem, and no basal sprouts.
(2)Has partially or fully burned at least 18 months prior and otherwise satisfies paragraph (1).
(3)Has fallen and is completely detached from its roots or has fallen and its roots are no longer in contact with the soil.
(e)Desert native plant specialist means an arborist certified by the International Society of Arborists, or an individual with at least five years of professional experience with relocation or restoration of native California desert vegetation.
(f)Fee means the elective fee described in subdivisions (d) and (e) of Section 1927.3, which is to be deposited into the fund.
(g)Fund means the Western Joshua Tree Conservation Fund as described in Section 1927.5.
(h)Life-sustaining service means activity relating to critical infrastructure, including, but not limited to, infrastructure that provides electricity, gas, water, sewer, or telecom service or work related to wildfire hardening.
(i)Multifamily residence means an apartment building, rowhouse, town house, condominium, or manufactured building that consists of two or more attached dwelling units designed for occupancy by two or more families living independently of one another.
(j)Public works project means a project involving the erection, construction, alteration, repair, or improvement of any public structure, building, road, or other public improvement of any kind.
(k)Relocated or relocation means the removal of a living western Joshua tree and a sufficient portion of its root mass from the ground and transplanting it.
(l)Single-family residence means a single detached building that has been, or will be, constructed and used as living facilities, including provisions for sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation, as required by the California Building Standards Code, for not more than one household.
(m)Western Joshua tree means Yucca brevifolia, an evergreen, tree-like plant that has been treated as a member of the asparagus family (Asparagaceae).
SEC. 2.Section 1927.2 of the Fish and Game Code is amended to read:1927.2.(a)No person or public agency shall import into this state, export out of this state, or take, possess, purchase, or sell within this state, a western Joshua tree or any part or product of the tree, except as authorized pursuant to any of the following, as applicable:
(1)This chapter.
(2)The California Endangered Species Act.
(3)The Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3).
(b)During any period in which the western Joshua tree has been designated by the commission as a candidate for listing under the California Endangered Species Act, any person or public agency seeking a take authorization for the western Joshua tree may obtain a take authorization as provided by the California Endangered Species Act or by demonstrating that the take meets the criteria in paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 1927.3, or by electing to pay the fees set forth in subdivision (d) or (e) of Section 1927.3.
(c)(1)This chapter is a change in state law, within the meaning of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 2075.5, that has a direct and significant impact on the commissions determination as to whether the petitioned action is warranted. Pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 2075.5, the commission shall reopen the administrative record for the commissions determination for the purpose of assessing the impact of the conservation program established by this chapter.
(2)In making the assessment described in paragraph (1), the commission shall consider all of the following:
(A)The effectiveness of any conservation measures funded through expenditures of fees by the department pursuant to Section 1927.5.
(B)The conservation plan developed by the department and approved by the commission pursuant to Section 1927.6.
(C)Any annual reports submitted to the commission by the department pursuant to Section 1927.7.
(D)Any recommendations submitted to the commission by the department pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1927.8.
(E)The fee adjustments, if any, adopted by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 1927.8.
(F)An updated status review to be submitted to the commission by the department no later than January 1, 2033, unless the commission directs the department to submit the updated status review sooner.
(d)If the commission determines that listing the western Joshua tree as endangered or threatened pursuant to the California Endangered Species Act is not warranted, this chapter shall remain operative and the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree shall be pursuant to this chapter.
(e)If the commission determines that listing the western Joshua tree as endangered or threatened pursuant to the California Endangered Species Act is warranted, this chapter shall become inoperative and the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree shall only be pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 or pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3).
(f)Upon the approval of a natural community conservation plan that provides for the conservation of the western Joshua tree as a covered species, the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree for any project or activity covered by the plan shall only be pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3.
(g)The provisions of the Native Plant Protection Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1900)), and the California Desert Native Plants Act (Division 23 (commencing with Section 80001) of the Food and Agricultural Code), shall not apply to the western Joshua tree.
(h)This section shall not preclude the department from authorizing, by permit or memorandum of understanding, the taking, possession, purchase, or sale within the state of a western Joshua tree to aid the conservation and recovery of the western Joshua tree, or entering into memoranda of understanding with California Native American tribes to provide for the taking and possession of western Joshua trees for tribal cultural purposes, or as otherwise required by applicable law.
(i)Any authorization issued by the department pursuant to Section 2081 or 2084, before the enactment of this chapter, to import, export, take, possess, purchase, or sell a western Joshua tree shall be valid and remain in effect after the enactment of this chapter pursuant to the terms of the authorization.
SEC. 3.Section 1927.3 of the Fish and Game Code is amended to read:1927.3.(a)The department may authorize, by permit, the taking of a western Joshua tree if all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The permittee submits to the department for its approval a census of all western Joshua trees on the project site, including size information and photographs, that categorize the western Joshua trees according to the following size classes:
(A)Less than one meter in height.
(B)One meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)Five meters or greater in height.
(2)The permittee avoids and minimizes impacts to, and the taking of, the western Joshua tree to the maximum extent practicable. Minimization may include trimming, encroachment on root systems, relocation, or other actions that result in detrimental but nonlethal impacts to a western Joshua tree.
(3)The permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the western Joshua tree. The measures required to meet this obligation shall be roughly proportional in extent to the impact of the authorized taking of the species. When various measures are available to meet this obligation, the measures required shall maintain the permittees objectives to the greatest extent possible. All required measures shall be capable of successful implementation. The permittee shall ensure adequate funding to implement the mitigation measures. In lieu of completing the mitigation obligation on its own, the permittee may elect to satisfy this mitigation obligation by paying fees, pursuant to the fee schedule in subdivision (d) or (e), for deposit into the fund.
(4)(A)The department may include permit conditions that require the permittee to relocate one or more of the western Joshua trees. If relocation is required, the permittee shall implement measures to assist the survival of relocated trees, and to comply with any other reasonable measures required by the department to facilitate the successful relocation and survival of the western Joshua trees. These relocation measures shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(i)A requirement that the relocated western Joshua tree is placed in a location and with proper orientation to improve its survival.
(ii)A requirement that western Joshua trees are relocated at a time that maximizes their survival when feasible.
(iii)A requirement that a desert native plant specialist be onsite to oversee relocation.
(B)The department may limit relocation to certain size classes of trees.
(C)The department shall adopt guidelines and relocation protocols, based on the best available science, to relocate western Joshua trees successfully. The department shall consult with desert native plant specialists as part of the development of these guidelines and relocation protocols. Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code shall not apply to the development, adoption, or amendment of guidelines and relocation protocols pursuant to this subparagraph.
(5)The department may issue permits pursuant to this section, without payment of fees or other mitigation, upon demonstration to the department that the taking of a western Joshua tree is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service. service connection to a single-family residence or multifamily residence, including distribution infrastructure. For purposes of this paragraph, distribution infrastructure includes, but is not limited to, an electrical pole, a gas main, a water main, and a sewer main, but does not include facilities, including, but not limited to, a power generation or storage facility, a gas production or storage facility, a water treatment plant, or a wastewater treatment plant.
(A)For a request for a permit pursuant to this paragraph, the department shall either grant or deny a permit within 30 days of receipt of the request.
(B)For a request for a permit pursuant to this paragraph to address a threat to health or safety, the department shall either grant or deny a permit within 10 days of receipt of the request.
(C)For a permit granted pursuant to this paragraph, the permittee has 60 days to complete the taking authorized by the permit. The department may extend this 60-day period at its discretion.
(b)For purposes of this section, each western Joshua tree stem or trunk arising from the ground shall be considered an individual tree requiring mitigation, regardless of its proximity to any other western Joshua tree stem or trunk.
(c)The department may enter into an agreement with any county or city to delegate to the county or city the ability to authorize the taking of a western Joshua tree associated with developing single-family residences, multifamily residences, accessory structures, and public works projects concurrent with its approval of the project, if all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The county or city adopts an ordinance that requires as a condition of any approval or permit issued under the authority of an agreement entered into pursuant to this subdivision satisfaction of the requirements of this chapter.
(2)Except as provided otherwise in this subdivision, the county or city ensures that the permittee satisfies all of the requirements of subdivision (a) of this section.
(3)The project will take no more than 10 individual western Joshua trees on the project site where the project proponent proposes to construct a single-family residence, multifamily residence, or accessory structure, or no more than 40 individual western Joshua trees on the project site on which a public agency proposes to undertake a public works project. Before authorizing the take of more than 20, but no more than 40, individual western Joshua trees for a public works project, the county or city shall obtain the departments written concurrence that the project has avoided and minimized the take of western Joshua trees to the maximum extent practicable.
(4)The county or city shall collect any fees for permits issued and remit them quarterly to the fund as directed by the department.
(5)The county or city entering into an agreement pursuant to this subdivision may impose a reasonable fee to cover the administrative costs of issuing the permit.
(6)(A)The department retains express authority to suspend or revoke the county or citys take authorization in the event the department determines the county or city has violated the terms of the agreement, or this chapter, the county or city fails to implement or enforce the terms of the agreement or this chapter, or the department determines that the local population of western Joshua trees within, or in the vicinity of, that county or city needs further protection. The county or city shall conduct an annual assessment of the status of the local population within the county or city and submit the assessment to the department. The department shall determine if the population needs further protection to provide for the conservation of the species.
(B)The department shall adopt standardized survey and assessment methods for the annual assessment required pursuant to subparagraph (A), including requiring that a desert native plant specialist conduct the assessment. Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code shall not apply to the development, adoption, or amendment of standardized survey and assessment methods pursuant to this subparagraph.
(7)The county or city shall be required to submit to the department quarterly reports documenting the number of permits issued, photographs and other evidence demonstrating that take and other impacts were avoided and minimized to the maximum extent practicable, the number and size class of western Joshua trees authorized to be taken, the number of western Joshua trees encroached upon, the number of western Joshua trees lethally removed, the number and location of western Joshua trees relocated, the amount of fees collected, and other information required by the department in the agreement.
(d)Any person or public agency receiving a take authorization pursuant to this chapter for a project that meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) may elect, in lieu of satisfying the mitigation obligation provided for in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), to pay fees in the amounts provided in paragraph (2) for deposit into the fund.
(1)(A)Any project in the area bounded by the intersection of Highway 99 and Highway 58, then east along Highway 58 to the intersection of Interstate 15, then north along Interstate 15 to the intersection of Highway 247, then south along Highway 247 to the intersection of Highway 18, then west along Highway 18 to the intersection of Highway 138, then west and north along Highway 138 to the intersection of Interstate 5, then north along Interstate 5 to the intersection of Highway 99, then north along Highway 99 to Highway 58.
(B)Any project receiving a permit issued by a county or city pursuant to an agreement with the department pursuant to subdivision (c), regardless of location.
(2)(A)One thousand dollars ($1,000) for each western Joshua tree five meters or greater in height.
(B)Two hundred dollars ($200) for each western Joshua tree one meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)One hundred fifty dollars ($150) for each western Joshua tree less than one meter in height.
(e)Any person or public agency receiving a take authorization pursuant to this chapter for a project that meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) may elect, in lieu of satisfying the mitigation obligation provided for in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), to pay fees in the amounts provided in paragraph (2) for deposit into the fund.
(1)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), any project within two miles of Joshua Tree National Park, or any unit of the state park system.
(B)Any project that does not meet the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d).
(2)(A)Two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) for each western Joshua tree five meters or greater in height.
(B)Five hundred dollars ($500) for each western Joshua tree one meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)Three hundred forty dollars ($340) for each western Joshua tree less than one meter in height.
(f)Upon request, the department may authorize a reduction in the amount of the fees prescribed by subdivisions (d) and (e) for any western Joshua tree conserved by a project proponent through the acquisition of compensatory habitat mitigation land otherwise required by law for the project.
(g)(1)The permittee shall bear responsibility for implementing measures to assist the survival of western Joshua trees relocated pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a).
(2)Unless specifically required by written agreement, a landowner that agrees in writing to allow western Joshua trees to be relocated onto land it owns shall not be liable for the continued survival of the western Joshua trees, shall not be required to manage or maintain the translocated western Joshua trees, and shall not be required to change existing land use practices, provided that the land use practices do not result in the taking, possession, sale, or further translocation of the western Joshua trees.
For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Accessory structure means a subordinate structure, the use of which is incidental to an existing or contemporaneously constructed single-family residence, including, an accessory dwelling unit, addition to an existing single-family residence, garage, carport, swimming pool, patio, greenhouse, storage shed, gazebo, septic tank, sewer connection, solar panels, fence, or gravel or paved driveway.
(b)California Endangered Species Act means the act established pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3.
(c)Conserve or conservation means to use, and the use of, methods and procedures that are necessary to bring species listed pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 to the point at which the measures provided pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 are no longer necessary, and for species that are not listed to maintain or enhance the condition of the species so that listing will not become necessary.
(d)Dead western Joshua tree means a western Joshua tree that meets at least one of the following criteria:
(1)Has not burned and has no green leaves, no new growth on the main stem, and no basal sprouts.
(2)Has partially or fully burned at least 18 months prior and otherwise satisfies paragraph (1).
(3)Has fallen and is completely detached from its roots or has fallen and its roots are no longer in contact with the soil.
(e)Desert native plant specialist means an arborist certified by the International Society of Arborists, or an individual with at least five years of professional experience with relocation or restoration of native California desert vegetation.
(f)Fee means the elective fee described in subdivisions (d) and (e) of Section 1927.3, which is to be deposited into the fund.
(g)Fund means the Western Joshua Tree Conservation Fund as described in Section 1927.5.
(h)Life-sustaining service means activity relating to critical infrastructure, including, but not limited to, infrastructure that provides electricity, gas, water, sewer, or telecom service or work related to wildfire hardening.
(h)(i)Multifamily residence means an apartment building, rowhouse, town house, condominium, or manufactured building that consists of two or more attached dwelling units designed for occupancy by two or more families living independently of one another.
(i)(j)Public works project means a project involving the erection, construction, alteration, repair, or improvement of any public structure, building, road, or other public improvement of any kind.
(j)(k)Relocated or relocation means the removal of a living western Joshua tree and a sufficient portion of its root mass from the ground and transplanting it.
(k)(l)Single-family residence means a single detached building that has been, or will be, constructed and used as living facilities, including provisions for sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation, as required by the California Building Standards Code, for not more than one household.
(l)(m)Western Joshua tree means Yucca brevifolia, an evergreen, tree-like plant that has been treated as a member of the asparagus family (Asparagaceae).
SEC. 2.Section 1927.2 of the Fish and Game Code is amended to read:1927.2.(a)No person or public agency shall import into this state, export out of this state, or take, possess, purchase, or sell within this state, a western Joshua tree or any part or product of the tree, except as authorized pursuant to any of the following, as applicable:
(1)This chapter.
(2)The California Endangered Species Act.
(3)The Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3).
(b)During any period in which the western Joshua tree has been designated by the commission as a candidate for listing under the California Endangered Species Act, any person or public agency seeking a take authorization for the western Joshua tree may obtain a take authorization as provided by the California Endangered Species Act or by demonstrating that the take meets the criteria in paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 1927.3, or by electing to pay the fees set forth in Section 1927.3. subdivision (d) or (e) of Section 1927.3.
(c)(1)This chapter is a change in state law, within the meaning of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 2075.5, that has a direct and significant impact on the commissions determination as to whether the petitioned action is warranted. Pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 2075.5, the commission shall reopen the administrative record for the commissions determination for the purpose of assessing the impact of the conservation program established by this chapter.
(2)In making the assessment described in paragraph (1), the commission shall consider all of the following:
(A)The effectiveness of any conservation measures funded through expenditures of fees by the department pursuant to Section 1927.5.
(B)The conservation plan developed by the department and approved by the commission pursuant to Section 1927.6.
(C)Any annual reports submitted to the commission by the department pursuant to Section 1927.7.
(D)Any recommendations submitted to the commission by the department pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1927.8.
(E)The fee adjustments, if any, adopted by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 1927.8.
(F)An updated status review to be submitted to the commission by the department no later than January 1, 2033, unless the commission directs the department to submit the updated status review sooner.
(d)If the commission determines that listing the western Joshua tree as endangered or threatened pursuant to the California Endangered Species Act is not warranted, this chapter shall remain operative and the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree shall be pursuant to this chapter.
(e)If the commission determines that listing the western Joshua tree as endangered or threatened pursuant to the California Endangered Species Act is warranted, this chapter shall become inoperative and the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree shall only be pursuant to Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 or pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3).
(f)Upon the approval of a natural community conservation plan that provides for the conservation of the western Joshua tree as a covered species, the authorization of take of a western Joshua tree for any project or activity covered by the plan shall only be pursuant to Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3.
(g)The provisions of the Native Plant Protection Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1900)), and the California Desert Native Plants Act (Division 23 (commencing with Section 80001) of the Food and Agricultural Code), shall not apply to the western Joshua tree.
(h)This section shall not preclude the department from authorizing, by permit or memorandum of understanding, the taking, possession, purchase, or sale within the state of a western Joshua tree to aid the conservation and recovery of the western Joshua tree, or entering into memoranda of understanding with California Native American tribes to provide for the taking and possession of western Joshua trees for tribal cultural purposes, or as otherwise required by applicable law.
(i)Any authorization issued by the department pursuant to Section 2081 or 2084, before the enactment of this chapter, to import, export, take, possess, purchase, or sell a western Joshua tree shall be valid and remain in effect after the enactment of this chapter pursuant to the terms of the authorization.
SEC. 3.Section 1927.3 of the Fish and Game Code is amended to read:1927.3.(a)The department may authorize, by permit, the taking of a western Joshua tree if all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The permittee submits to the department for its approval a census of all western Joshua trees on the project site, including size information and photographs, that categorize the western Joshua trees according to the following size classes:
(A)Less than one meter in height.
(B)One meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)Five meters or greater in height.
(2)The permittee avoids and minimizes impacts to, and the taking of, the western Joshua tree to the maximum extent practicable. Minimization may include trimming, encroachment on root systems, relocation, or other actions that result in detrimental but nonlethal impacts to a western Joshua tree.
(3)The permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the western Joshua tree. The measures required to meet this obligation shall be roughly proportional in extent to the impact of the authorized taking of the species. When various measures are available to meet this obligation, the measures required shall maintain the permittees objectives to the greatest extent possible. All required measures shall be capable of successful implementation. The permittee shall ensure adequate funding to implement the mitigation measures. In lieu of completing the mitigation obligation on its own, the permittee may elect to satisfy this mitigation obligation by paying fees, pursuant to the fee schedule in subdivision (d) or (e), for deposit into the fund.
(4)(A)The department may include permit conditions that require the permittee to relocate one or more of the western Joshua trees. If relocation is required, the permittee shall implement measures to assist the survival of relocated trees, and to comply with any other reasonable measures required by the department to facilitate the successful relocation and survival of the western Joshua trees. These relocation measures shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(i)A requirement that the relocated western Joshua tree is placed in a location and with proper orientation to improve its survival.
(ii)A requirement that western Joshua trees are relocated at a time that maximizes their survival when feasible.
(iii)A requirement that a desert native plant specialist be onsite to oversee relocation.
(B)The department may limit relocation to certain size classes of trees.
(C)By July 1, 2024, the The department shall adopt guidelines and relocation protocols, based on the best available science, to relocate western Joshua trees successfully. The department shall consult with desert native plant specialists as part of the development of these guidelines and relocation protocols. Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code shall not apply to the development, adoption, or amendment of guidelines and relocation protocols pursuant to this subparagraph.
(5)The department may issue permits pursuant to this section, without payment of fees or other mitigation, upon demonstration to the department that the taking of a western Joshua tree is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service.
(A)For a request for a permit pursuant to this paragraph, the department shall either grant or deny a permit within 30 days of receipt of the request.
(B)For a request for a permit pursuant to this paragraph to address a threat to health or safety, the department shall either grant or deny a permit within 10 days of receipt of the request.
(C)For a permit granted pursuant to this paragraph, the permittee has 60 days to complete the taking authorized by the permit. The department may extend this 60-day period at its discretion.
(b)For purposes of this section, each western Joshua tree stem or trunk arising from the ground shall be considered an individual tree requiring mitigation, regardless of its proximity to any other western Joshua tree stem or trunk.
(c)The department may enter into an agreement with any county or city to delegate to the county or city the ability to authorize the taking of a western Joshua tree associated with developing single-family residences, multifamily residences, accessory structures, and public works projects concurrent with its approval of the project, if all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The county or city adopts an ordinance that requires as a condition of any approval or permit issued under the authority of an agreement entered into pursuant to this subdivision satisfaction of the requirements of this chapter.
(2)Except as provided otherwise in this subdivision, the county or city ensures that the permittee satisfies all of the requirements of subdivision (a) of this section.
(3)The project will take no more than 10 individual western Joshua trees on the project site where the project proponent proposes to construct a single-family residence, multifamily residence, or accessory structure, or no more than 40 individual western Joshua trees on the project site on which a public agency proposes to undertake a public works project. Before authorizing the take of more than 20, but no more than 40, individual western Joshua trees for a public works project, the county or city shall obtain the departments written concurrence that the project has avoided and minimized the take of western Joshua trees to the maximum extent practicable.
(4)The county or city shall collect any fees for permits issued and remit them quarterly to the fund as directed by the department.
(5)The county or city entering into an agreement pursuant to this subdivision may impose a reasonable fee to cover the administrative costs of issuing the permit.
(6)(A)The department retains express authority to suspend or revoke the county or citys take authorization in the event the department determines the county or city has violated the terms of the agreement, or this chapter, the county or city fails to implement or enforce the terms of the agreement or this chapter, or the department determines that the local population of western Joshua trees within, or in the vicinity of, that county or city needs further protection. The county or city shall conduct an annual assessment of the status of the local population within the county or city and submit the assessment to the department. The department shall determine if the population needs further protection to provide for the conservation of the species.
(B)The department shall adopt standardized survey and assessment methods for the annual assessment required pursuant to subparagraph (A), including requiring that a desert native plant specialist conduct the assessment. Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code shall not apply to the development, adoption, or amendment of standardized survey and assessment methods pursuant to this subparagraph.
(7)The county or city shall be required to submit to the department quarterly reports documenting the number of permits issued, photographs and other evidence demonstrating that take and other impacts were avoided and minimized to the maximum extent practicable, the number and size class of western Joshua trees authorized to be taken, the number of western Joshua trees encroached upon, the number of western Joshua trees lethally removed, the number and location of western Joshua trees relocated, the amount of fees collected, and other information required by the department in the agreement.
(d)Any person or public agency receiving a take authorization pursuant to this chapter for a project that meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) may elect, in lieu of satisfying the mitigation obligation provided for in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), to pay fees in the amounts provided in paragraph (2) for deposit into the fund.
(1)(A)Any project in the area bounded by the intersection of Highway 99 and Highway 58, then east along Highway 58 to the intersection of Interstate 15, then north along Interstate 15 to the intersection of Highway 247, then south along Highway 247 to the intersection of Highway 18, then west along Highway 18 to the intersection of Highway 138, then west and north along Highway 138 to the intersection of Interstate 5, then north along Interstate 5 to the intersection of Highway 99, then north along Highway 99 to Highway 58.
(B)Any project receiving a permit issued by a county or city pursuant to an agreement with the department pursuant to subdivision (c), regardless of location.
(2)(A)One thousand dollars ($1,000) for each western Joshua tree five meters or greater in height.
(B)Two hundred dollars ($200) for each western Joshua tree one meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)One hundred fifty dollars ($150) for each western Joshua tree less than one meter in height.
(e)Any person or public agency receiving a take authorization pursuant to this chapter for a project that meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) may elect, in lieu of satisfying the mitigation obligation provided for in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), to pay fees in the amounts provided in paragraph (2) for deposit into the fund.
(1)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), any project within two miles of Joshua Tree National Park, or any unit of the state park system.
(B)Any project that does not meet the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d).
(2)(A)Two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) for each western Joshua tree five meters or greater in height.
(B)Five hundred dollars ($500) for each western Joshua tree one meter or greater but less than five meters in height.
(C)Three hundred forty dollars ($340) for each western Joshua tree less than one meter in height.
(f)Upon request, the department may authorize a reduction in the amount of the fees prescribed by subdivisions (d) and (e) for any western Joshua tree conserved by a project proponent through the acquisition of compensatory habitat mitigation land otherwise required by law for the project.
(g)(1)The permittee shall bear responsibility for implementing measures to assist the survival of western Joshua trees relocated pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a).
(2)Unless specifically required by written agreement, a landowner that agrees in writing to allow western Joshua trees to be relocated onto land it owns shall not be liable for the continued survival of the western Joshua trees, shall not be required to manage or maintain the translocated western Joshua trees, and shall not be required to change existing land use practices, provided that the land use practices do not result in the taking, possession, sale, or further translocation of the western Joshua trees.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2026 | April 21 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 4. Page 3981.) |
| Apr 23, 2026 | April 21 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 4.) |
| Apr 10, 2026 | Set for hearing April 21. |
| Apr 8, 2026 | April 14 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 2, 2026 | Set for hearing April 14. |
| Mar 25, 2026 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Feb 26, 2026 | Referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Feb 13, 2026 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 15. |
| Feb 12, 2026 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 21, 2026 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Bighorn-Desert View Water Agency | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Native Plant Society | ** Against | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Against | |
| City of Big Bear Lake | ** Support | |
| Community Water Systems Alliance | ** Support | |
| Defenders Of Wildlife | ** Against | |
| Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Hi-Desert Water District | ** Support | |
| Joshua Basin Water District | ** Support | |
| Mission Springs Water District | ** Support | |
| Mojave Desert Land Trust | ** Against | |
| Mojave Water Agency | ** Support | |
| Morongo Basin Residents for Reasonable Joshua Tree Regulations | ** Support | |
| native american land conservancy | ** Against | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Against | |
| Town of Apple Valley | ** Support | |
| town of yucca valley | ** Support | |
| Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Josh Becker, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: SB Hearing Date: April 21, 2026
Author: | |||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act: life-sustaining services: take permit
SUMMARY
This bill would authorize the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), under the Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act, to permit the taking of a Western Joshua tree without payment of fees or other mitigation, upon demonstration to CDFW that the taking of the Western Joshua tree is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service, as defined, including through a service connection to a single-family residence or multifamily residence, including distribution infrastructure, as specified. The bill would also require CDFW to grant or deny that permit within 30 days of a request, or within 10 days of a request to address a threat to health or safety, among other provisions.
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
The western Joshua tree (Yucca brevifolia)[1]
The western Joshua tree (WJT) is a member of the agave family. The WJT is a monocot in the subgroup of flowering plants that also includes grasses and orchids. Many birds, mammals, reptiles, and insects depend on the WJT for food and shelter, and it is both culturally and ecologically important.
WJT seeds germinate rarely, and young WJTs may grow quickly in the first five years, then slow down considerably thereafter. WJT grow at rates between 0.5 – 3 inches annually, and the tallest WJT can be more than forty feet high. Some researchers think an average lifespan for a WJT is about 150 years, but some of the largest trees may be older.
WJTs are widely distributed in the Mojave Desert region of California. According to CDFW’s Status Review of the species, estimates indicate that the abundance of the WJT is currently relatively high, but there is considerable uncertainty in population size estimates.
Threats to the WJT
WJT populations within the state declined following European settlement of the Mojave Desert region, primarily due to habitat loss and degradation related to agricultural conversion and development. CDFW estimates that approximately 30% of the habitat occupied by WJT in California may have been modified between European settlement and the present. Habitat loss, wildfires, aridification, and other climate change effects are major threats to the WJT. For example, in 2020, the Dome Fire incinerated 1.3 million Joshua trees in a part of the Mojave National Preserve called the Cima Dome.
While potentially less immediate than other threats, climate change could represent an existential threat to the WJT. CDFW anticipates that some of the impacts of climate change (e.g., increased temperatures and decreased total water availability locally) is likely to render much of the WJT’s existing range to no longer be viable habitat by 2100. In addition, CDFW estimates that over 7% of the WJT range has been developed for other uses.[2]
Proposed WJT listing under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA)
In response to these threats, the WJT was proposed for listing as threatened under CESA at the Fish and Game Commission (commission) in late 2019. The commission accepted the WJT as a candidate species in 2020, and the WJT remains a candidate species today. While a candidate for listing, the WJT has similar protections to those of a listed species. This includes take prohibitions and take authorization through permits obtained from CDFW. Since becoming a candidate, take permits for WJTs were issued under Fish and Game Code (FGC) §2081 and §2084, and, as applicable, via permits under the WJTCA. The commission is expected to postpone final consideration of the petition to list the WJT until CDFW submits an updated status review to the commission no later than January 1, 2033, as required by the WJTCA.
The Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act (WJTCA)
The WJTCA was enacted to conserve WJT and its habitat while providing pathways for development with appropriate permitting and mitigation, including in-lieu fees for the take of WJT. The WJTCA provides a carefully circumscribed additional and alternative permitting mechanism for “take” of the species. The WJTCA prohibits the import, export, take, possession, purchase, or sale of any WJT in California unless authorized by CDFW. WJTCA authorizes CDFW to issue permits for the incidental take of one or more WJTs if the permittee meets certain conditions. These include that the permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the WJT, and avoids and minimizes impacts to, and the taking of, the WJT to the maximum extent practicable. Permittees may pay specified fees in lieu of conducting mitigation activities.[3] WJTCA also authorizes CDFW to issue permits for the removal of dead WJTs and the trimming of live WJTs under certain circumstances. These two permits are the WJTCA incidental take permit (ITP), and the Hazard Management Permit, respectively.
Pursuant to the WJTCA, CDFW may enter into an agreement with any county or city to delegate limited authority to permit WJT take associated with developing single-family residences, multifamily residences, accessory structures, and public works projects. These so-called delegation agreements limit the number of WJTs that may be taken depending on the type of project. CDFW may similarly enter into delegation agreements with any county or city to permit the removal of dead WJTs and the trimming of live WJTs. The goal of the delegation agreements was to provide a single permitting process for project applicants. No delegation agreements have yet been executed to Committee staff knowledge.
Under WJTCA, all in-lieu fees collected will be deposited into the WJT Conservation Fund (Conservation Fund) for appropriation to CDFW solely for the purposes of acquiring, conserving, and managing WJT conservation lands and completing other activities to conserve the WJT. Additionally, WJTCA requires CDFW to develop and implement a WJT conservation plan, as provided. The final conservation plan was approved by the commission in June 2025. CDFW must also compile annual reports assessing WJT conservation status and submit them to the commission and Legislature annually.
WJTCA implementation status
As of the end of Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-2024, CDFW had issued 9 ITPs under the WJTCA and 249 Hazard Management permits authorizing the take of 3,175 WJTs. Most of the authorized take was under the ITPs which provided for the development of 2,888 acres of WJT habitat. In-lieu mitigation fees totaling $3,075,570 were collected which funded the acquisition of 283 acres of “ecologically core” lands for conservation over 3 parcels. Only 5 WJTs were relocated during FY 2023-2024 as the relocation guidelines had not yet been released.
In addition, as required by the WJTCA, two processes are currently underway:
- The commission is required to review the status of the WJT and the effectiveness of the WJT conservation plan by August 31, 2026 and every two years thereafter. CDFW is required to make recommendations to amend the conservation plan, if needed. A public meeting was held in January 2026, CDFW is currently reviewing comments received and new information, and CDFW is anticipated to provide its recommendations to the commission this summer.
- In addition to authorized indexing, CDFW is authorized, beginning this year, to adopt regulations to adjust the in-lieu mitigation fees to ensure WJT conservation. An informational public forum was held in January and CDFW is currently drafting the Initial Statement of Reasons for a regulatory change which is anticipated to be released by the Spring. The fee adjustment costs will consider restoration, monitoring, land acquisition, conservation easements, and endowments for stewardship of land acquisitions or conservation easements, and do not include CDFW staffing costs. According to its presentation, “CDFW is looking for opportunities to make fees more proportionate to impacts,” and notes that revenues will likely need to increase to ensure WJT conservation.
Additionally, although not required by the WJTCA, CDFW has begun the preparation of a WJTCA Permitting Programmatic Environmental Impact Report (PEIR). WJTCA permitting requires compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and applicants are generally responsible for CEQA documentation which can cause a disproportionately high financial strain and time delays on homeowners and small projects. The goal of the PEIR preparation is to reduce the time and cost of CEQA compliance for applicants with qualifying projects. Types of qualifying projects include single- and multi-family residences and accessory structures; commercial, industrial, institutional or religious structures; utilities, infrastructure, facilities and buildings; and defensible space and on-site safety actions. Qualifying projects may include a limitation on habitat acreage involved and the number of WJTs to be removed. Non-qualifying projects include land development including subdivisions, utility-scale energy generation, transmission or storage projects; or mining operations. Certification of the PEIR is anticipated by the end of the year.
State-mandated conservation and permitting for WJT – either as a candidate species under CESA or through the WJTCA – has been controversial.
Existing law:
- Establishes CDFW and the commission in the California Natural Resources Agency. In general, CDFW implements and enforces the regulations set by the commission and provides data and expertise to inform the commission’s decision making.
- Specifies that CDFW has jurisdiction over the conservation, protection, and management of fish, wildlife, native plants, and habitat necessary for biologically sustainable populations of those species. (FGC §1802).
- Defines “take” as hunt, pursue, catch, capture, or kill, or attempt to hunt, pursue, catch, capture, or kill. (FGC §86).
- Prohibits the taking of an endangered or threatened species, except in certain situations. Provides that a candidate species receives CESA protections while its status is pending. (FGC §§2070 et seq.).
- Allows CDFW to authorize the taking of listed species pursuant to an ITP if the taking is incidental to an otherwise lawful activity, the impacts are minimized and fully mitigated, and the issuance of the permit would not jeopardize the continued existence of the species. (FGC §§2081; 2084).
- Establishes the WJTCA that enacts the following (FGC §§1927 et seq.):
- Prohibits any person or public agency from importing into the state, exporting out of the state, or taking, possessing, purchasing, or selling within the state, a WJT or any part or product of the WJT, except pursuant to the WJTCA, CESA, or the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (NCCP Act).
- Authorizes WJT take under CESA or by paying certain in-lieu fees specified by the WJTCA when the WJT is a candidate species under CESA.
- Requires the WJTCA to remain operative if the commission determines that listing the WJT under CESA is not warranted. Requires WJT take permitting under CESA or pursuant to the NCCP Act if the commission determines that listing the WJT under CESA is warranted, which would render the WJTCA inoperative.
- Authorizes CDFW to issue a permit for the taking of a WJT if specified conditions are met, including, that the permittee mitigates all impacts to, and taking of, the WJT. Authorizes CDFW to include in its permit conditions the requirement that the permittee relocate one or more WJTs. Requires permittees to bear responsibility for implementing measures to assist the survival of relocated WJTs.
- Authorizes a permittee, in lieu of completing the mitigation measures on its own, to elect to satisfy the mitigation obligation by paying a fee pursuant to a specified fee schedule.
- Requires CDFW to annually adjust the fees for inflation, and to review the fees by December 31, 2026, and every three years thereafter, to ensure the conservation of WJT.
- Requires all fees remitted to CDFW to be deposited into the Conservation Fund, as provided, and requires the moneys in the Conservation Fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be used solely for the purposes of acquiring, conserving, and managing WJT conservation lands and completing other activities to conserve the WJT.
- Authorizes CDFW to enter into an agreement with any county or city to delegate to the county or city the ability to authorize the taking of a WJT associated with developing single-family residences, accessory structures, and public works projects, as defined, concurrent with the city’s or county’s approval of the project. Limits the number of WJTs taken associated with single-family residences, multifamily residences, or accessory structures projects to 10 under this delegation.
- Authorizes CDFW or its designee to issue a permit to authorize the removal or trimming of a dead WJT or the trimming of a live WJT, as provided.
- Requires CDFW to develop and implement a WJT conservation plan, as provided. Specifies that CDFW shall present the final conservation plan at a public meeting of the commission, for its review and approval, by December 31, 2024, and requires the commission to take final action on the plan by June 30, 2025.
- Requires CDFW to submit an annual report to the commission and the Legislature addressing the conservation status of the WJT, as provided.
- Requires the commission, beginning in 2026, and at least every two years thereafter, to, at a public meeting, review the status of the WJT and the effectiveness of the conservation plan, as specified.
- Requires CDFW to submit to the commission an update of the status review required under CESA that incorporates any new scientific information and includes an evaluation of conservation efforts under the WJTCA by January 1, 2033.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill would:
- Define “life-sustaining service” to mean an activity related to critical infrastructure, including, but not limited to, infrastructure that provides electricity, gas, water, sewer, or telecom service or work related to wildfire hardening.
- Define “distribution infrastructure” to include, but not be limited to, an electrical pole, a gas main, a water main, and a sewer main, but excludes facilities, including, but not limited to, a power generation or storage facility, a gas production or storage facility, a water treatment plant, or a wastewater treatment plant.
- Authorize CDFW to issue permits to take WJT, without payment of fees or other mitigation, upon demonstration to CDFW that the take of WJT is related to the maintenance, operation, or construction of a life-sustaining service connection to a single-family residence or multifamily residence, including distribution infrastructure.
- Require CDFW to approve or deny a permit within 30 days of receipt of the request. Require CDFW to approve or deny a permit within 10 days of receipt of the request where the permit is to address a threat to health or safety.
- Require the permittee to complete the WJT take authorized by a permit issued pursuant to (3) within 60 days. Authorize CDFW to extend the 60 day period at its discretion.
- Make additional minor and technical changes.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “The Western Joshua tree is a native plant species found throughout California’s high desert, including in communities where residents rely on wells, septic systems, overhead powerlines, and other infrastructure to maintain safe and habitable homes. In recent years, state law has established new protections for the species, requiring permits before certain activities can occur near Western Joshua trees.”
“Under current law, homeowners must obtain permission from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) if they intend to perform any kind of activity that would require the removal or trimming of a Western Joshua tree, even if the tree is dead.”
“This process requires an applicant to submit forms, wait for approval, and pay mitigation fees, even for routine projects like connecting electricity, repairing septic systems, or maintaining water lines. In many cases, homeowners may also be required to pay for and coordinate the relocation and care of a living tree for the remainder of its life. This level of government involvement in basic property maintenance has created costly delays, added financial burdens, and limited homeowners’ ability to maintain safe and functional living conditions on their own land.”
“While these protections serve an important conservation purpose, they have also created unintended consequences for homeowners attempting to install or maintain critical infrastructure, such as connecting to the electrical grid, repairing septic systems, or replacing damaged utility lines. Residents can face lengthy permitting timelines, unmanageable fees, and regulatory uncertainty, and in some cases, these obstacles can prevent or significantly postpone access to life-sustaining utilities, jeopardizing public health and safety.”
“By allowing a permit to be issued without fee collection or complex mitigation measures and requiring CDFW to grant or deny a permit within 30 days, SB 1063 improves equity and access for rural homeowners, and ensures they can obtain essential utility services without facing disproportionate financial burdens or indefinite regulatory delays.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
The Center for Biological Diversity, in a joint sign-on opposition letter, writes that this bill “would significantly alter the Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act (WJTCA) by weakening critical protections for the western Joshua Tree and undermining the delicate and carefully negotiated compromise that led to the Act’s passage.”
[…]
SB 1063 “would substantially alter this structure by authorizing CDFW to reduce or waive mitigation fees, or otherwise relax or generalize avoidance, minimization, and mitigation requirements, for projects associated with so-called ‘life sustaining activities.’”
[…]
“The breadth of the activities encompassed by the bill’s definition of ‘life sustaining activities,’ together with the absence of statutory limits on the scope or frequency of mitigation reduction or waivers, raises serious concerns about cumulative impacts. Over time, repeated use of this authority could substantially diminish mitigation funding and weaken the WJTCA’s ability to achieve its conservation objectives.”
[…]
With respect to the PEIR they note, “Because the planned PEIR is intended to streamline permitting for infrastructure and wildfire-related activities while maintaining the WJTCA’s conservation safeguards, the proposed statutory amendments are both unnecessary and premature.”
[…]
“Appropriate mitigation is essential to achieving the central goal of the WJTCA: conserving the western Joshua tree and its habitat such that listing under CESA will not be warranted. By weakening avoidance, minimization, and mitigation requirements – and by creating broad exemptions and uncertainty – [this bill] undermine[s] this objective and jeopardize[s] the long-term effectiveness of the law, which may result in the need to finalize the listing of the Western Joshua tree under the California Endangered Species Act.”
COMMENTS
Fundamentally undermines the WJTCA. This bill, as written, essentially removes infrastructure maintenance, operation, or construction of a “life sustaining service” from paying any in lieu- mitigation fees with the exception of the associated facility so long as there is an arguable connection to a single- or multi-family home. In other words, a power generating facility would have to pay in-lieu mitigation fees, but any distribution line and associated infrastructure, so long as there is a connection to a residence at some point, would be exempt from in-lieu mitigation fees. Given the likely size of the proposed exemption, it is unlikely the conservation goals of the WJTCA would be met.
The AB 1089 veto message. Opponents make a fair point that the WJTCA represented a heavily negotiated balance between competing interests, and changes to the WJTCA have the potential to either delay further implementation or upset the perceived balance between interests.
Last year, Governor Newsom in his veto message for AB 1089 (Carillo, 2025) which would have added no fee WJT take for defensible space to the WJTCA, among other provisions, stated:
I am returning Assembly Bill 1089 without my signature.
This bill authorizes the Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to enter into an agreement with any city to delegate to the city the taking of a Western Joshua Tree associated with commercial and industrial projects. In addition, this bill revises CDFW's authority to issue a permit for the removal of a Western Joshua Tree around single-family homes.
The Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act (Act) of 2023 was carefully crafted to balance the need to develop housing and clean energy projects in the Mojave Desert region, while creating a robust but practical permitting process aimed at protecting one of California's most iconic species. The Act currently authorizes CDFW to enter into an agreement with any county or city and delegate limited authority to permit the taking of a Western Joshua Tree associated with developing single-family residences, multifamily residences, accessory structures, and public works projects.
While I recognize the desire to expand this delegated authority to include the taking of these trees where commercial and industrial projects are sited, this bill goes too far in authorizing the blanket removal of these trees near single-family homes that will ultimately undermine Western Joshua Tree protections and conservation requirements under the Act. Furthermore, this bill would increase the complexity and time required to manage the permitting process as modified by this measure.
For these reasons, I cannot sign this bill.
While AB 1089 (Carillo, 2025) is a different WJTCA bill than this one, the veto message highlights the reticence of the Newsom Administration to make substantive changes to the WJTCA when it is still in the beginning phases of implementation.
The author may wish to continue working closely with CDFW on this bill’s scope.
Three bills and one author. Acknowledging the importance of the topic to the author, it remains unusual to have three bills on the same topic by one author. This is particularly true when the bills seek to modify the same code section in multiple ways. The author may wish to consolidate language as the bills move forward.
Recent related legislation
SB 1061 (Ochoa Bogh, 2026) would exempt from WJTCA the relocation of a WJT that is relocated to a site within the same parcel or a contiguous parcel owned by the same owner, and would specify that take under the WJTCA does not include unintentionally or accidentally causing the death of a WJT, as provided. (This bill is pending before this Committee.)
SB 1062 (Ochoa Bogh, 2026) would authorize CDFW to, upon the request from a state or local public agency, establish project-specific conditions for a WJT project related to a life-sustaining service, as defined, and would provide that project-specific conditions may include, but are not limited to, the creation of projectwide standards for avoidance, minimization, or mitigation measures, a reduction or waiver of in-lieu mitigation fees, or other compliance flexibility or concession the department deems appropriate to facilitate timely and cost-effective maintenance, operation, or construction of a project. (This bill is pending before this Committee.)
AB 1808 (Carillo, 2026) would authorize CDFW to enter into an agreement with any city to delegate to the city the taking of a WJT associated with commercial and industrial projects, and would authorize CDFW to permit, without payment of fees or other mitigation, the removal or trimming of a WJT by the owner of an existing single-family residence or by the developer of a public works project, under certain circumstances, as provided. (This bill is pending before the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee.)
AB 1663 (Wallis, 2026) would exempt from the WJTCA a project or activity located within a parcel that contains, or will contain, a single-family residence that has been continuously owned by the same person, as specified, on or before July 10, 2023, and the parcel owner complies with applicable local ordinances regarding WJTs as those local ordinances read on July 10, 2023, as provided. (This bill is pending before the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee.)
AB 1089 (Carillo, 2025) would have authorized CDFW to enter into an agreement with any city to delegate to the city the taking of a WJT associated with commercial and industrial projects in certain conditions, and would have revised CDFW’s authority to issue a permit for the removal of WJT, including to meet defensible space requirements, among other provisions, as specified. (This bill was vetoed by Governor Newsom.)
AB 2443 (Carillo, 2024) would have addressed commercial and industrial projects under the WJTCA in a similar fashion to this bill. (This bill was subsequently amended into a bill about transaction and use tax.)
SB 122 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 51, Statutes of 2023), a public resources budget trailer bill, establishes the WJTCA.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS: none
SUPPORT
Bighorn-Desert View Water Agency
California Building Industry Association
City of Big Bear Lake
Community Water Systems Alliance
Greater High Desert Chamber of Commerce
Hi-Desert Water District
Joshua Basin Water District
Mission Springs Water District
Mojave Water Agency
Morongo Basin Residents for Reasonable Joshua Tree Regulations
Town of Apple Valley
Town of Yucca Valley
Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association
A few individuals
OPPOSITION
California Native Plant Society
Center for Biological Diversity
Defenders of Wildlife
Mojave Desert Land Trust
Native American Land Conservancy
Sierra Club California
One individual
-- END --
The eastern Joshua tree (Yucca jaegeriana) is a distinct variety of Joshua tree found mostly in the eastern Mojave Desert. It is not considered in this bill analysis. ↑
California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW). 2025. Western Joshua Tree Conservation Plan. Presented to the California Fish and Game Commission, June 12, 2025. ↑
The in-lieu fees in the “standard” fee area are currently $2,609 for a WJT taller than 5 meters, $521.75 for a WJT between 1 and 5 meters in height, and $354.75 for WJTs shorter than 1 meter in height. The in-lieu fees for each WJT in the reduced fee area are $1,043.50, $208.75, and $156.50, respectively, for the same size classes. The total in-lieu fee would be the number of WJTs in each size class to be taken multiplied by the fee for that size class summed over all applicable size classes. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):