AB 1286: California Regulatory Reform Council.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-05-04
Existing law establishes the Milton Marks Little Hoover Commission on California State Government Organization and Economy in state government with a specified membership and independent state oversight duties.
This bill would establish, until January 1, 2022, the California Regulatory Reform Council, composed of 13 members appointed by the Governor, the Senate Committee on Rules, and the Speaker of the Assembly, as specified. This bill would require 4 of the 13 members of the council to be Members of the Legislature who are to be considered a joint committee of the 2 houses of the Legislature constituted and acting as an investigating committee. This bill would authorize the council, on its own motion, to make reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. This bill would deem the council to be within the executive branch of state government, but prohibit the council from being subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch, except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature. This bill would require the council to, council, on or before January 1, 2017, and at least annually thereafter, to post on its Internet Web site a list of its ongoing activities and its final reports. activities, specified information regarding meetings, and copies of final reports. This bill would make legislative findings in regards to these provisions.
Existing law establishes the Milton Marks Little Hoover Commission on California State Government Organization and Economy in state government with a specified membership and independent state oversight duties.
This bill would establish establish, until January 1, 2022, the Economic Growth Commission, California Regulatory Reform Council, composed of 13 members appointed by the Governor, the Senate Committee on Rules, and the Speaker of the Assembly, as specified. This bill would require 4 of the 13 members of the commission council to be Members of the Legislature who are to be considered a joint committee of the 2 houses of the Legislature constituted and acting as an investigating committee. This bill would authorize the commission, council, on its own motion, to make reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. This bill would deem the commission council to be within the executive branch of state government, but prohibit the commission council from being subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch, except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature. This bill would require the council to, on or before January 1, 2017, and at least annually thereafter, to post on its Internet Web site a list of its ongoing activities and its final reports. This bill would make legislative findings in regards to these provisions.
Existing law establishes the Milton Marks Little Hoover Commission on California State Government Organization and Economy in state government with a specified membership and independent state oversight duties.
This bill would establish the Economic Growth Commission, composed of 13 members appointed by the Governor, the Senate Committee on Rules, and the Speaker of the Assembly, as specified. This bill would require 4 of the 13 members of the commission to be Members of the Legislature who are to be considered a joint committee of the 2 houses of the Legislature constituted and acting as an investigating committee. This bill would authorize the commission, on its own motion, to make reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. This bill would deem the commission to be within the executive branch of state government, but prohibit the commission from being subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch, except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Duplicative, unnecessary, and outdated regulations have negatively impacted economic growth and job creation.
(b)State, regional, and local governments are ill-equipped to provide a holistic view of the total impact of regulatory action from all levels of state and local government on specific industries and types of businesses.
(c)The establishment of the California Regulatory Reform Council will promote economic growth and job creation by providing the Legislature and Governor with varied, but relevant, experiences and viewpoints to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state.
SEC. 2.Chapter 5.9 (commencing with Section 8490) is added to Division 1 of Title 2 of the Government Code, to read:5.9.California Regulatory Reform Council8490.There is in the state government the California Regulatory Reform Council, hereafter in this chapter referred to as the council. The council shall be composed of 13 members as follows:
(a)Five members appointed by the Governor, as follows:
(1)Two public members who reside in different regions of the state so that, collectively, these members represent a geographical balance of the state.
(2)One member with professional experience in economic modeling of public policies and economic development activities who resides in southern California.
(3)One member with professional experience in economic modeling of public policies and economic development activities who resides in northern California.
(4)One member who represents the business community.
(b)Two members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules, as follows:
(1)One member of the public.
(2)One member who represents the business community.
(c)Two members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, as follows:
(1)One member of the public.
(2)One member who represents the business community.
(d)Two Members of the Senate appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the council, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Senate Committee on Rules shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(e)Two Members of the Assembly appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the council, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Speaker of the Assembly shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(f)The members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, shall serve two-year terms and may be reappointed for additional terms.
(g)All vacancies in the council membership shall be filled in the same manner in which original appointments were made.
8490.5.For the purposes of expenditures for the support of the council, including the expenses of the members of the council, the council shall be deemed to be within the executive branch of state government, but the council shall not be subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature.
8490.10.The members of the council shall serve without compensation, but shall be reimbursed for all necessary the travel expenses actually incurred in the performance of their duties. attending meetings. Members of the Assembly or Senate shall not be reimbursed for travel expenses, except in the instance where those costs will not be paid by their respective Houses of the Legislature.
8490.15.For the purposes of this chapter, the Members of the Legislature serving as members of the council shall be considered a joint committee of the two houses of the Legislature constituted and to be acting as an investigating committee, and as such shall have the powers and duties imposed on such committees by the Joint Rules of the Senate and Assembly.
8490.20.(a)All members shall be appointed on or before March 1, 2016.
(b)The council shall hold its first meeting on or before April 1, 2016.
(c)The council shall select from among its members a chairperson and vice chairperson, who shall not be registered as members of the same political party.
8490.25.Six members of the council shall constitute a quorum.
8490.30.It is the purpose of the Legislature to establish a multibody council, composed of individuals with varied, but relevant, experiences and viewpoints to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state.
8490.35.The council, on its own motion, may, for the purpose of making reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the matters listed in Section 8490.30, examine in detail the structure, organization, operation, and impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. The council may make recommendations to the Governor and to the Legislature as the council deems necessary.
8490.40.(a)The council shall establish an Internet Web site.
(b)On or before January 1, 2017, and at least annually thereafter, the council shall post on its Internet Web site a all of the following:
(1)A list of its ongoing activities and its final reports. activities.
(2)The agenda, list of individuals who testified, and background materials distributed by the council for each meeting.
(3)Copies of final reports prepared by the council or on behalf of the council.
(c)All materials required to be posted pursuant to subdivision (b) shall remain accessible from the Internet Web site until January 1, 2022.
8490.45.This chapter shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Duplicative, unnecessary, and outdated regulations have negatively impacted economic growth and job creation.
(b)State, regional, and local governments are ill-equipped to provide a holistic view of the total impact of regulatory action from all levels of state and local government on specific industries and types of businesses.
(c)The establishment of the California Regulatory Reform Council will promote economic growth and job creation by providing the Legislature and Governor with varied, but relevant, experiences and viewpoints to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Chapter 5.9 (commencing with Section 8490) is added to Division 1 of Title 2 of the Government Code, to read:5.9.Economic Growth Commission California Regulatory Reform Council8490.There is in the state government the Economic Growth Commission, California Regulatory Reform Council, hereafter in this chapter referred to as the commission. council. The commission council shall be composed of 13 members as follows:
(a)Five members of the public shall be appointed by the Governor. Governor, as follows:
(1)Two public members who reside in different regions of the state so that, collectively, these members represent a geographical balance of the state.
(2)One member with professional experience in economic modeling of public policies and economic development activities who resides in southern California.
(3)One member with professional experience in economic modeling of public policies and economic development activities who resides in northern California.
(4)One member who represents the business community.
(b)Two members of the public shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. Rules, as follows:
(1)One member of the public.
(2)One member who represents the business community.
(c)Two members of the public shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. Assembly, as follows:
(1)One member of the public.
(2)One member who represents the business community.
(d)Two Members of the Senate appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the commission, council, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Senate Committee on Rules shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(e)Two Members of the Assembly appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the commission, council, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Speaker of the Assembly shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(f)(1)The members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, shall serve four-year two-year terms and may be reappointed for additional terms.
(2)To establish staggered terms of membership for members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, on or before March 1, 2016, the Governor shall select two of his or her five appointees, and the Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each select one of its two appointees, to serve one term of two years. Thereafter, all members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, shall serve terms in compliance with paragraph (1).
(g)All vacancies in the commission council membership shall be filled in the same manner in which original appointments were made.
8490.5.For the purposes of expenditures for the support of the commission, council, including the expenses of the members of the commission, council, the commission council shall be deemed to be within the executive branch of state government, but the commission council shall not be subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature.
8490.10.The members of the commission council shall serve without compensation, but shall be reimbursed for all necessary expenses actually incurred in the performance of their duties.
8490.15.For the purposes of this chapter, the Members of the Legislature serving as members of the commission council shall be considered a joint committee of the two houses of the Legislature constituted and to be acting as an investigating committee, and as such shall have the powers and duties imposed on such committees by the Joint Rules of the Senate and Assembly.
8490.20.The commission (a)All members shall be appointed on or before March 1, 2016.
(b)The council shall hold its first meeting on or before April 1, 2016.
(c)The council shall select from among its members a chairperson and vice chairperson, who shall not be registered as members of the same political party.
8490.25.Six members of the commission council shall constitute a quorum.
8490.30.It is the purpose of the Legislature to establish a multibody commission, council, composed of individuals with varied, but relevant, experiences and viewpoints to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state.
8490.35.The commission, council, on its own motion, may, for the purpose of making reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the matters listed in Section 8490.30, examine in detail the structure, organization, operation, and impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. The commission council may make recommendations to the Governor and to the Legislature as the commission council deems necessary.
8490.40.(a)The council shall establish an Internet Web site.
(b)On or before January 1, 2017, and at least annually thereafter, the council shall post on its Internet Web site a list of its ongoing activities and its final reports.
8490.45.This chapter shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
There is in the state government the Economic Growth Commission, hereafter in this chapter referred to as the commission. The commission shall be composed of 13 members as follows:
(a)Five members of the public shall be appointed by the Governor.
(b)Two members of the public shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(c)Two members of the public shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(d)Two Members of the Senate appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the commission, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Senate Committee on Rules shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(e)Two Members of the Assembly appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. These members shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing authority but shall not be registered with the same political party. If a member, while serving on the commission, registers with the same political party as the other member, the Speaker of the Assembly shall replace one of the members with a new member who is not registered with the same political party as the remaining member.
(f)(1)The members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, shall serve four-year terms and may be reappointed for additional terms.
(2)To establish staggered terms of membership for members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, on or before March 1, 2016, the Governor shall select two of his or her five appointees, and the Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each select one of its two appointees, to serve one term of two years. Thereafter, all members appointed pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive, shall serve terms in compliance with paragraph (1).
(g)All vacancies in the commission membership shall be filled in the same manner in which original appointments were made.
8490.5.For the purposes of expenditures for the support of the commission, including the expenses of the members of the commission, the commission shall be deemed to be within the executive branch of state government, but the commission shall not be subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature.
8490.10.The members of the commission shall serve without compensation, but shall be reimbursed for all necessary expenses actually incurred in the performance of their duties.
8490.15.For the purposes of this chapter, the Members of the Legislature serving as members of the commission shall be considered a joint committee of the two houses of the Legislature constituted and to be acting as an investigating committee, and as such shall have the powers and duties imposed on such committees by the Joint Rules of the Senate and Assembly.
8490.20.The commission shall select from among its members a chairperson and vice chairperson, who shall not be registered as members of the same political party.
8490.25.Six members of the commission shall constitute a quorum.
8490.30.It is the purpose of the Legislature to establish a multibody commission, composed of individuals with varied, but relevant, experiences and viewpoints to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state.
8490.35.The commission, on its own motion, may, for the purpose of making reports and recommendations to assist the Legislature and Governor in respect to the matters listed in Section 8490.30, examine in detail the structure, organization, operation, and impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. The commission may make recommendations to the Governor and to the Legislature as the commission deems necessary.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 28, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| May 13, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 5, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 4, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 21). |
| Apr 14, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on J., E.D., & E. |
| Apr 13, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on J., E.D., & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | Referred to Com. on J., E.D., & E. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 21, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1286
Page 2
Date of Hearing: May 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1286
(Mayes) – As Amended May 4, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy |
Vote: |
9 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes the California Regulatory Reform Council (Council) to make reports and recommendations to the Legislature and the Governor related to the structure, organization, operation, and impact of all levels of state and local regulations on industries operating within the state. Repeals the council on January 1, 2022. Specifically, this bill:
Establishes the 13 member council under the executive branch for the purposes of expenditures for the support of the council, including the expenses of the members of the council, but specifies the council shall not be subject to the control or direction of any officer or employee of the executive branch, except in connection with the appropriation of funds approved by the Legislature.
Specifies the functions and makeup of the board, including five appointed by the Governor, two appointed by the Senate, two appointed by the Assembly, two members of the Senate, two members of the Assembly, to serve two-year terms without compensation, except for travel. Requires members to be appointed by March 1, 2016 and hold their first meeting by April 1, 2016.
Requires, by January 1, 2017, the council to establish a website and post the following: a list of its ongoing activities; the agenda, list of individuals who testified, and background materials distributed by the council for each meeting; copies of final reports prepared by the council or on behalf of the council. Requires all materials required to be posted to remain accessible from the Internet Web site until January 1, 2022.
FISCAL EFFECT:
General Fund administrative costs, likely in excess of $1 million, for seven positions, through January 1, 2022. This bill creates a new council to provide recommendations on structure, organization, operation, and impact of all levels of state and local regulations on "specific" industries operating within the state. However, the "specific" industries are not identified. The council will need staff to research thousands of regulations, produce meeting agendas, facilitate meetings, and draft a final report. Technical expertise will also be needed to create, monitor and update a new website.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This measure proposes the establishment of a Council to provide additional review of selected regulations as to their impact on specific industry sectors. The bill does not define "specific" industry sectors.
Opposition. The California Labor Federation is opposed to this bill, stating it would add unnecessary layers of bureaucracy to a regulatory system that currently adequately meets the needs of the public and the Legislature. They note the exhaustive regulatory review process under the Administrative Procedures Act and AB 617 (2011) which further requires a rigorous economic impact analysis to be completed for regulations with significant costs.
Related legislation.
AB 19 (Chang), pending in this committee, requires the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz), in consultation with the Office of the Small Business Advocate, to establish a process for the ongoing review of existing regulations adopted prior to January 1, 2016, primarily those affecting small businesses, to determine whether the regulations could be less administratively burdensome or costly to affected sectors.
AB 2723 (Medina) of 2014 proposed a review of costs associated with regulations on the small business be considered when state agencies undertake their economic impact assessment for major regulations. The Governor's veto message of this bill is as follows:
This bill would require the economic analysis for major regulations to include a separate assessment of the impact on sole proprietorships and small businesses. I signed legislation in 2011 to require a comprehensive economic analysis of proposed major regulations. The analysis must assess whether, and to what extent, the proposed regulations will affect all California jobs and businesses. Agencies must also identify alternatives that would lessen any adverse impact on small businesses. I am not convinced that an additional layer of specificity based solely on the legal structure of a business would add value to the comprehensive economic analysis already required.
SB 617 (Calderon), Chapter 496, Statutes of 2011, revises the state Administrative Procedure Act to require each state agency adopting a major regulation to prepare an economic impact analysis and requires state agencies to implement ongoing monitoring of internal auditing and financial controls and other best practices in financial accounting
Analysis Prepared by: Misty Feusahrens / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1286
Page 9
Date of Hearing: April 21, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JOBS, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, AND THE ECONOMY
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
AB 1286
Mayes – As Amended April 13, 2015
SUBJECT: California Regulatory Reform Council
SUMMARY: Establishes the California Regulatory Reform Council (Council) for the purpose of analyzing the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state. The Council's recommendations may be made to the Governor and the Legislature, as appropriate. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that the legislature finds and declares that duplicative, unnecessary, and outdated regulations have negatively impacted economic growth and job creation. The Legislature further finds and declares that state agencies and local governments are ill-equipped to provide a holistic view of the total impact of regulatory action from all levels and agencies of state and local government on specific industries and types of businesses. With a view to developing recommendations for the Legislature and regulators that will promote economic growth and job creation, the Legislature has created the California Regulatory Reform Council.
Establishes an independent 13-member Council comprised of:
Five members appointed by the Governor;
Two members each appointed by Senate Rules Committee and the Speaker of the Assembly;
Two members of the Senate, appointed by the Senate Rules Committee, each registered in a different political party, as specified; and
Two members of the Assembly appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, each registered in a different political party, as specified.
Specifies that the purpose of the Council is to analyze the holistic impact of all levels of state and local regulations on specific industries operating within the state
Provides the following relative to the Membership of the Council:
One member appointed by each of the Governor, the Senate Rules Committee, and the Assembly is required to be a representative of the business community;
Two of the members appointed by the Governor are required to have professional experience in econmic modeling of public policies and economic development activities with one living in northern and one southern California;
Members of the Council shall serve two-year terms with the option of one additional term;
All Members are required to be appointed by March 1, 2016.
All vacancies will be filled in the same manner in which they were appointed.
Specifies that for the sole purpose of funding that the Council is to be considered part of the executive branch.
Provides that the members of the Council will serve without compensation, but will be reimbursed for the necessary expenses actually incurred in the performance of their duty.
Directs the Council to select from among its members a chair and vice chair, who are prohibited from being registered in the same political party.
Provides that six members constitute a quorum and requires the first meeting of the Council to be held no later than April 1, 2016.
Requires the Council to establish a website and to, at least annually, post a list of its activities and final reports.
Sunsets the Council on January 1, 2022.
EXISTING LAW:
Finds and declares that it is in the public interest to aid, counsel, assist, and protect the interests of small business concerns in order to maintain a healthy state economy.
Finds and declares that there has been an unprecedented growth in the number of administrative regulations in recent years and that correcting the problems requires the direct involvement of the Legislature, as well as that of the executive branch of the state government. Further, statute finds and declares that the complexity and lack of clarity in many regulations put small businesses, which do not have the resources to hire experts to assist them, at a distinct disadvantage.
Establishes basic minimum procedural requirements for the adoption, amendment, or repeal of administrative regulations, including assessing the potential adverse impact of an action on California businesses and individuals with the purpose of avoiding the imposition of unreasonable and unnecessary regulations, reporting, recordkeeping, or compliance requirements. Among other requirements, an agency is required to:
Base decisions on adequate information;
Consider the impact of a proposed rule on an industry's ability to compete with businesses in other states; and
Assess its impact on the creation or elimination of jobs and new and expanding businesses.
Requires the Department of Finance to adopt, and rulemaking agencies to follow, a specific set of regulations for undertaking an economic impact analysis for regulations that are anticipated to have an impact on businesses in excess of $50 million.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
POLICY ISSUE FRAME:
Although the state has a vigorous public process that is designed to allow the rulemaking agency to fully consider the comments, suggestions, and economic impacts of proposed regulations on all business – especially small businesses - state agencies rarely hear from the broad range of small businesses that are potentially affected. An intrinsic conflict within California's rule making process is that those businesses that may be most affected have the least ability to monitor the broad range of state rulemaking entities, recommend appropriate alternative implementation models or engage meaningfully in the often complex and highly technical rule making proceedings.
Without having a realistic process for small businesses to participate in the process, it is difficult for state agencies to adopt regulations that have flexible implementation methods that recognize the administrative capacity of small businesses, while still meeting the intended policy standards.
Given that nearly 3 million firms in California have no employees and 90% of firms with employees have less than 20, finding a means to address this challenge is important state's economic growth.
This measure proposes the establishment of a Council to provide selected regulations a second look as to their impact on specific industry sectors. The analysis includes information on the California small business economy, state rulemaking practices, and studies on the cost of regulations to small businesses. Suggested technical amendments are included in Comment 7.
COMMENTS:
Author's Purpose: According to the author's statement, "For years, forces as diverse as the Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce, The Silicon Valley Leadership Group, former Senate Pro Tempore Darrel Steinberg, and former Assembly Speaker John Perez have all argued that regulatory reform is one of the keys to expanding economic growth and creating jobs. Unfortunately, the ability to identify specific regulations that need to be updated or eliminated has proved elusive. Although previous attempts at reform have focused on the agency or department level, this approach addresses the cumulative effect of all regulations impacting on our economy. Compounding the problem, many of the effects of problematic regulations are felt by small businesses, which do not have the resources to take an active role in the rulemaking process.
AB1286 addresses these issues by creating an independent, bipartisan California Regulatory Reform Council. The Council will provide a holistic view of California's regulatory environment. Composed of 2 professional economists, 3 members from the business community, 4 legislators, and 4 members of the public, the Council ensures a diverse set of viewpoints in considering regulations as well as legitimacy for the Council's recommendations. AB1286's Regulatory Reform Council will move the needle on regulatory reform in a robust and serious way."
California's Small Business Economy: Small businesses form the core of California's $2.2 trillion economy. Research shows that net new job creation is strongest among businesses with less than 20 employees, that small businesses have historically led the state's local and regional economies out of recessions, and that these businesses are essential to the state's global competitiveness by meeting niche industry needs.
Businesses with no employees make up the single largest component of businesses in California, 2.9 million out of an estimated 3.6 million firms in 2012, representing over $149 billion in revenues with the highest number of businesses in the professional, scientific, and technical services industry sector. As these non-employer businesses grow, they continue to serve as an important component of California's dynamic economy. Even if you exclude non-employer firms, businesses with less than 20 employees comprise nearly 90% of all businesses and employ approximately 18% of all workers. Businesses with less than 100 employees represent 97% of all businesses and employ 36% of the workforce. These non-employer and small employer firms create jobs, generate taxes, and revitalize communities.
Excluding non-employer firms, businesses with less than 20 employees comprise nearly 90% of all businesses and employ approximately 18% of all workers. Businesses with less than 100 employees represent 97% of all businesses and employ 36% of the workforce. These non-employer and small employer firms create jobs, generate taxes, and revitalize communities.
2011 Business Profile By Size (excludes non-employer firms) |
|||||||
Area Description |
Employment Size |
Number of Firms |
Percent of Firms |
Employees |
Percent of Jobs |
Annual Payroll ($1,000) |
|
United States |
Total |
5,684,424 |
|
113,425,965 |
|
$5,164,897,905 |
|
California |
Total |
689,568 |
12% of U.S. Firms |
12,698,427 |
11% of all U.S. Jobs |
$663,570,657 |
|
|
|||||||
United States |
0-4 |
3,532,058 |
62% of U.S. Firms |
5,857,662 |
5% of U.S. Jobs |
$230,422,086 |
|
California |
0-4 |
429,139 |
62% of CA Firms |
702,508 |
5.5% of CA Jobs |
$35,472,447 |
|
|
|||||||
United States |
<20 |
5,104,014 |
89.7% of U.S. Firms |
20,250,874 |
17.8% of U.S. Jobs |
$732,759,369 |
|
California |
<20 |
614,538 |
89.1% of CA Firms |
2,386,296 |
18.7% of CA Jobs |
$99,417,066 |
|
|
|||||||
United States |
0-99 |
5,585,510 |
98.2% of U.S. Firms |
39,130,875 |
34% of U.S. Jobs |
1,478,844,420 |
|
California |
0-99 |
672,360 |
97% of CA Firms |
4,587,628 |
36.1% of CA Jobs |
194,611,832 |
|
|
|||||||
United States |
<500 |
5,666,753 |
99.6% of U.S Firms |
54,998,312 |
48.4% of U.S. Jobs |
$2,169,353,973 |
|
California |
<500 |
683,999 |
99.1% of CA Firms |
6,331,871 |
49.8% of CA Jobs |
$280,857,823 |
|
|
|||||||
United States |
500+ |
17,671 |
0.3% of U.S. Firms |
58,427,653 |
51.5% of U.S. Jobs |
$2,995,543,932 |
|
California |
500+ |
5,569 |
0.8% of CA Firms |
6,366,556 |
50.1% of CA Jobs |
$382,712,834 |
|
Source: U.S. Census http://www.census.gov/econ/susb/index.html |
|||||||
Reflective of their important role, the JEDE Committee members regularly hear about the challenges small businesses face meeting the implementation requirements of state, local, and federal regulations. While opponents of regulatory reform accuse small businesses of trying to avert their responsibilities, businesses that have testified before the Committee have repeatedly stated that their goal is to achieve a regulatory environment that encourages small business development, while still maintaining public health and safety standards. AB 1286 does not authorize the lowering of any regulatory standard. The bill provides for a second review of regulations and the development of recommendations for consideration and action by the Governor and Legislature.
Cost of Regulations on Business: There are two major sources of data on the cost of regulatory compliance on businesses, the federal SBA and the Office of the Small Business Advocate (OSBA). For the last 10 years, the federal SBA has conducted a peer reviewed study that analyzes the cost of federal government regulations on different size businesses. This research shows that small businesses continue to bear a disproportionate share of the federal regulatory burden. On a per employee basis, it costs about $2,400, or 45% more, for small firms to comply with federal regulations than their larger counterparts.
The first study on the impact of California regulations on small businesses was released by the OSBA in 2009. This first in-the-nation study found that the total cost of regulations to small businesses averaged about $134,000 per business in 2007. Of course, no one would advocate that there should be no regulations in the state. The report, however, importantly identifies that the cost of regulations can provide a significant cost to the everyday operations of California businesses and should therefore be a consideration among the state's economic development policies.
Regulatory costs are driven by a number of factors including multiple definitions of small business in state and federal law, the lack of e-commerce solutions to address outdated paperwork requirements, procurement requirements that favor larger size bidders, and the lack of technical assistance to alleviate such obstacles that inhibit small business success.
Different Approaches to Regulatory Reform: In general, the Legislature's engagement on regulatory reforms has taken two basic approaches. One set of policies have addressed specific regulatory challenges on a case-by-case basis. The other approach makes systemic change to the way in which rules are adopted, often adding a supplemental more targeted review pre- or post-adoption. Recommendations for systemic change have included:
Dynamic Fiscal Analysis in Appropriations Committee: These bills required an analysis of bills before the Legislature on their impact on business and the economy. Currently, the Legislature's fiscal committee reviews focus on the bill's direct impact on state funds, and most specifically on the General Fund. The fiscal committee's analysis is not intended to include legislations' potential economic impact on the state.
Substantive Administrative Review: These bills shifted the review of the Office of Administrative Law from a procedural review of the regulation package to a substantive review of its impact on business and the economy, including the sufficiency of the assessment of alternatives. Alternatively, legislation has suggested that another state entity, such as the State Auditor or Legislative Analyst's Office, could be designated to undertake an expanded review of proposed regulations.
Enhanced Analysis of Alternatives: These bills required a more meaningful consideration of alternative implementation models, which could lower costs or reduce the implementation burden on small businesses.
Post Implementation Analysis: These bills required a review of a regulation's impact five-years after its implementation. Alternatively, legislation has been suggested that all regulations have a sunset date, which would allow for full review once the actual impacts could be identified.
Until now, the first approach has been the most successful, although by its nature it has had very limited overall impact on California's regulatory business climate. Due to their potential implementation costs, a majority of the bills advancing the systemic approach to regulatory reform have failed to move from the fiscal committees - as illustrated in the comment on related legislation.
The most significant systemic change in recent years was approved in SB 617 (Calderon), Chapter 496, Statutes of 2011, which required an enhanced economic impact analysis for regulations anticipated to have an impact of $50 million or more. The SB 617 process follows the federal regulatory model (described below), however, it should be noted that the state process is silent as to the assessment of costs based on size of business.
The Legislature heard several bills to refine the SB 617 process in 2013-14 session including AB 2723 (Medina), which would have required rulemaking entities to consider the specific impact of major regulations on sole proprietorships, and AB 1711 (Cooley) which moved up the economic impact assessment to the initial statement of reasons for all regulations. Ultimately, the Governor signed AB 1711 (Cooley), Chapter 779, Statutes of 2014 and vetoed AB 2723 (veto message below).
Federal and State Small Business Advocacy: In 1976, the federal government established the Federal Office of Advocacy (FOA) within the Small Business Administration for the purpose of protecting and effectively representing the nation's small businesses within the federal government's legislative and rule-making processes. A few years later, the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 was enacted, which provided a specific process for assessing and mitigating the potential impact of federal regulations on small businesses. The federal process, which has been updated over the years, includes the annual publication of a regulatory agenda, an initial and final regulatory flexibility analysis, a mandatory periodic review of adopted rules, and direction for a possible judicial review of regulations. The FOA serves as the "watchdog" agency for the Federal Regulatory Flexibility Act.
In carrying out its duties, the FOA regularly reviews federal regulations and makes recommendations on how to reduce the burden on small firms and maximize small business participation within the federal government. In 2013, the FOA issued 19 letters to federal agencies requesting alternative implementation methods and encouraging better technical review of proposed regulations.
Another FOA activity is the convening of issue-specific Small Business Advocacy Review Panels. Utilizing the FOA as a facilitator has proven to be particularly useful in developing more detailed comments and making specific and technical recommendations to assist the rulemaking entity in modifying a rule to lessen its impact on small businesses, without reducing its policy objective.
California law currently has several but not all of the key elements of the federal model. As an example, existing state law sets forth an extensive process for the development and adoption of regulations, including requiring the identification of potential adverse impacts on small businesses and individuals, as well as the consideration of alternative.
The process, however, places the primary responsibility for developing alternative implementation methods on the impacted parties. As noted above, small businesses do not have the capacity in terms of time nor expertise to follow every rulemaking process that the state is undertaking in a given year, nor the expertise to offer alternatives.
While California has an Office of the Small Business Advocate, the state advocate does not currently have the staff to formally comment on pending state regulations. On a case-by-case basis, the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development has been able to engage with other agencies on current and proposed regulatory proposals through its Office of Permit Assistance, but again, state statutory direction is permissive and not mandatory.
Proposed Amendments: Below is a list of amendments the author may wish to consider in bringing the measure forward.
Limit reimbursement to travel expenses related to meeting attendance.
Limit reimbursement to Legislative members to travel expenses not paid for by their respective Houses.
Delete the provision regarding a joint committee of the two houses.
Require the agenda, meeting background materials distributed by the Council, and a list of people who testified from the meeting to be posted on the Council website.
Require final reports to be posted on the Council website.
Related Legislation: Below is a list of bills from the current and prior sessions.
Current Session
AB 19 (Chang) Review of Regulations by Advocate: This bill requires the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development, under the direction of the Small Business Advocate, to review all regulations affecting small businesses adopted on or after January 1, 2016, in order to determine whether the regulations need to be amended in order to become more effective, less burdensome, or to decrease the cost impact to affected sectors. Status: Scheduled to be heard on April 21, 2015, in the Assembly Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy.
AB 419 (Kim) Compilation of Regulations: This bill requires the Governor's Office of Business and Econmic Development to annually compile all regulations adopted by the state that affect small businesses and report this information to the Legislature, as specified. Status: Scheduled to be heard on April 21, 2015, in the Assembly Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy.
AB 582 (Calderon) Professionals in Public Services Act of 2015: This bill establishes the Professionals in Public Service (PPS) Program, under the administrative oversight of the Board of Equalization (BOE), for the purpose of utilizing the expertise of private sector professionals to help make BOE practices more accessible to small businesses. Status: Scheduled to be heard on April 21, 2015, in the Assembly Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy.
AB 866 (E. Garcia) Small Business Impact Data: This bill expands the duties of the Small Business Advocate to include assisting state rulemaking agencies in identifying the aggregate number and size of business which may be affected by a proposed new or amended regulation. Status: Scheduled to be heard on April 21, 2015, in the Assembly Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy.
Prior Sessions
AB 393 (Cooley) GO-Biz Website: This bill requires the Director of GO-Biz to ensure that the GO-Biz website contains information on the fee requirements and fee schedules of state agencies. Status: Signed by the Governor, Chapter 124, Statutes of 2013.
AB 1098 (Quirk-Silva) Small Business Regulation Report: As passed by JEDE, this bill would have directed the Office of the Small Business Advocate within GO-Biz to commission a study of the costs of state regulations on small businesses every five years. Amendments taken in the Senate deleted the content of the bill and added language relating to legal documents provided over the internet with Assemblymember Gray as the author. Status: Died in the Senate Committee on Rules, 2014.
AB 1400 (Assembly Committee on Jobs, Economic Development, and the Economy) Export Document Certificates: This bill modifies the state’s Export Document Program to accept requests electronically, expedite approval of existing labels, and extend the term of the export labels from 180 days to 365 days, in order to alleviate backlog of exports of food, drug, and medical devices. Status: Signed by the Governor, Chapter 539, Statutes of 2013.
AB 1711 (Cooley) Economic Impact Assessment: This bill requires an economic impact assessment to be included in the Initial Statement of Reasons that a state agency submits to the Office of Administrative Law when adopting, amending, or repealing a non-major regulation. Status: Signed by the Governor, Chapter 779, Statutes of 2014.
AB 2723 (Medina) Small Businesses and Major Regulations: This bill would have added statutory protections to ensure that the costs of major regulations on the state's smallest size businesses are considered when state agencies undertake their economic impact assessment for major regulations. Status: Vetoed by the Governor, 2014. The veto message reads: " This bill would require the economic analysis for major regulations to include a separate assessment of the impact on sole proprietorships and small businesses. I signed legislation in 2011 to require a comprehensive economic analysis of proposed major regulations. The analysis must assess whether, and to what extent, the proposed regulations will affect all California jobs and businesses. Agencies must also identify alternatives that would lessen any adverse impact on small businesses. I am not convinced that an additional layer of specificity based solely on the legal structure of a business would add value to the comprehensive economic analysis already required."
SB 176 (Galgiani) Outreach on Administrative Procedures: This bill would have amended the Administrative Procedure Act by requiring state agencies to make a reasonable effort to outreach and provide notice to affected entities when developing regulations. Statutes: Held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, 2013.
SB 560 (Wright) Small Business Regulations: This bill would have made a number of reforms to help small businesses grow encouraging more realistic regulations and a real assessment of the actual costs of regulations to the business community. The bill would have: (1) authorized a state agency to consult with “parties who would be subject to the proposed regulations” rather than “interested persons.” It also would have required the agency to notify in writing the Office of Small Business Advocate and the Department of Finance (DOF) if the agency does not, or is unable to, consult with parties subject to the regulation and reasons for not consulting the impacted businesses; (2) revised the economic impact assessment to include a small business economic impact statement as specified; (3) required the notice of proposed adoption, amendment, or repeal of a regulation to also include the small business impact statement and removes the requirement for an agency to make a specified statement in the notice of proposed adoption, amendment, or repeal of a regulation if the agency is not aware of any cost impacts that a representative private person or business would incur in compliance with the regulation, and instead required the agency to include a statement describing how a private person or business could comply with the proposed regulation without incurring a cost; (4) required Office of Administrative Law to also return any regulation to the adopting agency if the adopting agency has not provided the above cost estimate and small business economic statement; and (5) added restrictions for regulations relating to a new or emerging technology, as specified. Status: Held in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality, 2012.
SB 617 (Calderon) State Government and Financial and Administrative Accountability: This bill revises the state Administrative Procedure Act to require each state agency adopting a major regulation to prepare an economic impact analysis and requires state agencies to implement ongoing monitoring of internal auditing and financial controls and other best practices in financial accounting. Status: Signed by the Governor, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2011.
SB 981 (Huff) Review of Prior Regulations: This bill would have required each state agency to review each regulation adopted prior to January 1, 2014, and to develop a report to the Legislature containing prescribed information. Among other information, the report would have included the regulations purpose, identification of impacted sectors, direct costs by sector, and an assessment as to whether the regulation needs updating. Status: Died in Senate Committee on Governmental Organization, 2014.
SB 1099 (Wright) Streamline Implementation of Regulations: This bill requires new regulations to become effective on one of four dates in any given year. This limitation is designed to create a regulatory environment that is more predictable. In addition, the bill requires regulations to be posted on the internet website in an easily identifiable location for a minimum of six months. Status: Signed by the Governor, Chapter 295, Statutes of 2012.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Opposition
None received
Analysis Prepared by: Toni Symonds / J., E.D., & E. / (916) 319-2090
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):