SB 1244: Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2026-09-30
Current Status:
Passed
(2026-09-30: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 1020, Statutes of 2026.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health care service plan and health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between health care service plans and solicitors and health insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the solicitor represents the health care service plan or the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency, as defined, or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health care service plan and health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between health care service plans and solicitors and health insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the solicitor represents the health care service plan or the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency, as defined, or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health care service plan and health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between health care service plans and solicitors and health insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the solicitor represents the health care service plan or the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency, as defined, or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health care service plan and health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between health care service plans and solicitors and health insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the solicitor represents the health care service plan or the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency, defined to only include local entities, as defined, or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health care service plan and health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between health care service plans and solicitors and health insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the solicitor represents the health care service plan or the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency agency, defined to only include local entities, or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements. The bill would authorize the Insurance Commissioner to investigate alleged violations of these provisions and would set forth specified administrative penalties for violations.
Existing law provides for the regulation of health insurers by the Department of Insurance. Existing law requires various disclosures to be made regarding health insurance benefits and coverages. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of business between insurers and broker-agents, including requirements regarding contracts in which the broker-agent represents the insurer.
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, would require a covered service provider, defined to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that meets specified criteria, to disclose to a public agency or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services, among other information, before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. The bill would also require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan. Disclosure would be required under these provisions if the covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive $1,000 or more in compensation during the term of the contract or arrangement. The bill would require these disclosures at specified times.
This bill would prohibit a covered service provider from requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or its plan unless the compensation is disclosed, and would prohibit evasion of disclosure requirements. The bill would authorize the Insurance Commissioner to investigate alleged violations of these provisions and would set forth specified administrative penalties for violations.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.Article 3.9 (commencing with Section 53059) is added to Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:3.9.Local Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure53059.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 53059.4.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits. Public agency also includes a public joint labor management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
53059.1.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
53059.2.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 53059.3 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, public joint labor management trusts, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, public joint labor management trust, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
53059.3.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 53059.2 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)For covered plans with 100 or more employees as of the first day of the contract or arrangement, indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor. This subparagraph applies only to an individual who is an independent contractor with a firm or company, or who operates their own independent firm or company.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
53059.4.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 53059.3 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 60 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 120 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
53059.5.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority or a public joint labor management trust, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
53059.6.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations or the pricing of coverage or services, or that the terms obtained for the public agency do not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
53059.7.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
53059.8.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.Article 3.9 (commencing with Section 53059) is added to Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:3.9.Local Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure53059.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 53059.4.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits. Public agency also includes a public joint labor management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
53059.1.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
53059.2.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 53059.3 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, public joint labor management trusts, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, public joint labor management trust, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
53059.3.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 53059.2 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)For covered plans with 100 or more employees as of the first day of the contract or arrangement, indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor. This subparagraph applies only to an individual who is an independent contractor with a firm or company, or who operates their own independent firm or company.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
53059.4.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 53059.3 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 60 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 120 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
53059.5.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority or a public joint labor management trust, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
53059.6.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations or the pricing of coverage or services, or that the terms obtained for the public agency do not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
53059.7.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
53059.8.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.Article 3.9 (commencing with Section 53059) is added to Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:3.9.Local Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure53059.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 53059.4.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority. authority or public joint labor management trust.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits. Public agency also includes a public joint labor-management labor management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
53059.1.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
53059.2.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 53059.3 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, public joint labor management trusts, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, authority or public joint labor management trust, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, authority, public joint labor management trust, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, authority or public joint labor management trust, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
53059.3.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 53059.2 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)Indirect For covered plans with 100 or more employees as of the first day of the contract or arrangement, indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor. This subparagraph applies only to an individual who is an independent contractor with a firm or company, or who operates their own independent firm or company.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted. company.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:(A)All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements.(B)Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services.(C)Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.(13)(12)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
53059.4.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 53059.3 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 60 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 120 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
53059.5.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority, authority or a public joint labor management trust, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, authority or public joint labor management trust, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority or public joint labor management trust shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
53059.6.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations or the pricing of coverage or services, or that the terms obtained for the public agency do not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
53059.7.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
53059.8.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.Article 3.9 (commencing with Section 53059) is added to Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:3.9.Local Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure53059.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 53059.4.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits. Public agency also includes a public joint labor-management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
53059.1.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
53059.2.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 53059.3 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
53059.3.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 53059.2 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
(A)All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements.
(B)Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services.
(C)Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
(13)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
53059.4.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 53059.3 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
53059.5.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
53059.6.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations or the pricing of coverage or services, or that the terms obtained for the public agency do not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
53059.7.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
53059.8.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.The heading of Article 1 (commencing with Section 10600) is added to Chapter 7 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Insurance Code, to read:1.Health Insurance Disclosure Act of 1974SEC. 4.Article 2 (commencing with Section 10610) is added to Chapter 7 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Insurance Code, to read:2.Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure10610.For purposes of this article:(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 10614.(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.(3)Dental coverage.(4)Vision coverage.(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.(7)Network administration services.(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.(12)Recordkeeping services.(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.(14)Wellness services and programs.(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.(17)Disease management vendors and products.(18)Care navigation and care management services.(19)Telehealth services and platforms.(20)Compliance services.(21)Employee assistance programs.(22)Human resource information systems.(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority.(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.(m)Public agency means the state, a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits.(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.10611.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.10612.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 10613 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in such terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.10613.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 10612 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.(D)Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of such compensation.(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor.(B)Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted.(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.(12)For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:(A)All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements.(B)Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services.(C)Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.(13)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the twelve months preceding the disclosure or the twelve months following the disclosure.(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.(d)A covered service provider may satisfy this section through a standardized disclosure form adopted by the commissioner and may provide the disclosure electronically.10614.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 10613 in accordance with both of the following:(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.10615.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body.(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.(b)A joint powers authority that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.10616.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations, the pricing of coverage or services, or the terms obtained for the public agency does not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.10617.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:(1)The date the disclosure is provided.(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.(b)Upon request by the commissioner, the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.10618.(a)The commissioner may investigate alleged violations of this article by a covered service provider that provides brokerage services or consulting services.(b)(1)A covered service provider that violates this article is liable for an administrative penalty of not less than two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) for the first violation.(2)A covered service provider that violates this article a second or subsequent time, or that commits a knowing violation of this article, is liable for an administrative penalty of not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) and not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for each violation.(3)For purposes of this subdivision, each public agency to which a covered service provider failed to provide required disclosure, or to which a covered service provider provided a disclosure that failed to comply with this article, shall constitute a separate violation.(4)Administrative penalties collected pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the General Fund.(c)After a hearing conducted in accordance with Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the commissioner may suspend or revoke the license of a covered service provider licensed under this code.(d)The commissioner may adopt regulations to implement this article, including standardized disclosure forms and guidance materials.(e)The commissioner may refer violations to the Attorney General, a county counsel, or a city attorney, if appropriate.(f)This section does not affect any other authority provided by law to the commissioner or the Attorney General.10619.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.(b)The commissioner may adopt regulations necessary to implement this article.(c)The commissioner shall develop and make available standardized disclosure forms and guidance materials not later than July 1, 2027.(d)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.SEC. 3.Article 3.9 (commencing with Section 53059) is added to Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:3.9.Local Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure53059.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 53059.4.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
53059.1.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
53059.2.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 53059.3 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
53059.3.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 53059.2 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
(A)All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements.
(B)Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services.
(C)Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
(13)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
53059.4.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 53059.3 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
53059.5.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
53059.6.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations or the pricing of coverage or services, or that the terms obtained for the public agency do not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
53059.7.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
53059.8.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Public agencies expend significant public funds on employee health care benefits and health care benefits-related services and must make procurement decisions transparently and in the public interest.
(b)Public agencies frequently rely on brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors to recommend, procure, renew, and service health care employee benefits arrangements and benefits-related vendors.
(c)Compensation arrangements, including indirect, contingent, or noncash compensation paid by carriers and vendors, including compensation not solely attributable to a particular public agency contract, can create conflicts of interest that may not be visible to public purchasers and their governing bodies.
(d)Brokers, agents, consultants, and advisors currently receive compensation from multiple sources connected to their recommendations, including overrides, contingent or volume-based bonuses, retention bonuses, market-derived income, revenue sharing, referral fees, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, and noncash benefits, which may create incentives misaligned with the interests of public agencies and their plan members.
(e)Under current federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), group health plans are entitled to comprehensive broker and consultant compensation disclosure under Section 202 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Public Law 116-260). Public agencies sponsoring nonfederal governmental plans are not covered by ERISA and do not receive equivalent transparency protections, regardless of whether or not those responsible for procuring health care benefits owe fiduciary duties to plan members.
(f)Existing California law requires health care service plans and insurers to disclose broker compensation to public agency governing boards, but this plan-side disclosure does not capture the full scope of compensation that intermediaries receive from third-party sources, including vendors, pharmacy benefit managers, joint powers authorities, and other entities that may pay referral fees, revenue sharing, or other indirect compensation.
(g)It is in the public interest to require transparent, proactive disclosure of direct and indirect compensation and material financial interests so that public agencies and their governing bodies can appropriately evaluate recommendations before acting on them. Unlike federal law, which requires disclosure only upon request by the plan, public agencies should receive disclosure automatically and in advance of any recommendations.
(h)Intermediaries should not be permitted to avoid disclosure obligations by restructuring compensation arrangements, relabeling services, or routing payments through affiliated or unaffiliated entities.
(i)It is the intent of the Legislature to bring parity in compensation transparency protections to California public agencies comparable to those applicable to ERISA plans under federal law, without imposing ERISA-style fiduciary duties, burdensome monitoring responsibilities, or reporting obligations on public agencies that may inadvertently raise health care costs for plan members.
(j)Transparency improves public purchasing outcomes and deters compensation structures that undermine competitive procurement for the benefit of public agencies, their plan members, and California taxpayers.
SEC. 3.The heading of Article 1 (commencing with Section 10600) is added to Chapter 7 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Insurance Code, to read:1.Health Insurance Disclosure Act of 1974SEC. 4.Article 2 (commencing with Section 10610) is added to Chapter 7 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Insurance Code, to read:2.Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure10610.For purposes of this article:
(a)Affiliate means an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, affiliate refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. Affiliate includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
(b)Brokerage services includes soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
(c)Compensation means anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
(d)Consulting services includes advising a covered plan or public agency on plan design, vendor selection, procurement strategy, benefits administration, evaluation of proposals, compliance support, or any other advisory service related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(e)Contract or arrangement means an agreement, whether written, oral, or implied, pursuant to which a covered service provider provides or agrees to provide brokerage services or consulting services, and includes a broker of record letter, agent of record designation, or any similar authorization. The effective date of a broker of record letter or similar designation shall be treated as the date of entering into a contract or arrangement for purposes of the timing requirements in Section 10614.
(f)Covered health care benefits arrangement means a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
(1)Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both.
(2)Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements.
(3)Dental coverage.
(4)Vision coverage.
(5)Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
(6)Third-party administration services, including trust or joint powers authority administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration.
(7)Network administration services.
(8)Network access vendors and rental network arrangements.
(9)Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators.
(10)Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs.
(11)Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs.
(12)Recordkeeping services.
(13)Medical management and utilization review vendors.
(14)Wellness services and programs.
(15)Transparency tools and data analytics vendors.
(16)Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels.
(17)Disease management vendors and products.
(18)Care navigation and care management services.
(19)Telehealth services and platforms.
(20)Compliance services.
(21)Employee assistance programs.
(22)Human resource information systems.
(23)Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a joint powers authority, trust fund, or cooperative.
(24)Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs.
(25)Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(26)Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms.
(27)Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs.
(28)Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs.
(29)Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services.
(30)Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services.
(31)Dependent eligibility verification and audit services.
(32)Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services.
(33)Benefits communication and employee education services.
(34)Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians.
(35)Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services.
(36)Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service providers recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, materially influence includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
(g)Covered plan means a group health plan sponsored by a public agency in this state, including a nonfederal governmental plan, without regard to if the plan is self-funded, fully insured, or a combination of funding arrangements. Covered plan includes coverage purchased through a joint powers authority.
(h)Covered service provider means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
(i)Direct compensation means compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
(j)Indirect compensation means compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractors contract or arrangement.
(k)Material change means a change to any information required to be disclosed under this article, including a new source of compensation, a new category of compensation, a change in payer or recipient, a change in formula or methodology, or a change in assumptions used to estimate compensation, that a reasonable person would consider important in evaluating potential conflicts of interest.
(l)Noncash compensation means compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
(m)Public agency means the state, a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a joint powers authority, a public authority, a public entity, or any other governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits.
(n)Related party means a covered service providers affiliate, subcontractor, or any other person or entity through which compensation is paid or received in connection with services provided to a covered plan or public agency, including entities in which the covered service provider has an ownership or financial interest.
(o)Responsible public agency official means the public agency officer, employee, or governing body with authority to cause the public agency or covered plan to enter into, extend, renew, or materially amend a contract or arrangement for services or a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(p)Subcontractor means any person or entity, or an affiliate of a person or entity, that is not an affiliate of the covered service provider and that, pursuant to a contract or arrangement with the covered service provider or an affiliate, reasonably expects compensation for performing one or more services in connection with a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(q)Technology-related compensation means fees, payments, credits, subsidies, or other consideration paid by carriers, vendors, or other third parties for use of, access to, licensing of, or integration with technology platforms, enrollment systems, benefits administration systems, eligibility management systems, data systems, or other proprietary tools owned, licensed, or operated by the covered service provider or a related party. Technology-related compensation is indirect compensation for purposes of this article, regardless of how it is characterized by the parties.
10611.(a)This article establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
(b)The purpose of this article is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
(c)(1)This article imposes disclosure obligations on covered service providers.
(2)This article does not impose a fiduciary duty, validation duty, monitoring duty, reporting duty, disclosure request duty, or any civil liability on a public agency, a covered plan, or a responsible public agency official arising from any of the receipt or acknowledgment of a disclosure under this article.
(3)This article does not alter, expand, or diminish a fiduciary duty that may exist under other provisions of state, local, or municipal law.
10612.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, the information described in Section 10613 before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
(b)A covered service provider shall disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agencys specific contract or policy. This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
(c)Disclosure is required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation shall be included in this calculation and shall be disclosed if it exceeds two hundred fifty dollars ($250) in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
(d)A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in such terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method. The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. The description shall contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
10613.(a)The written disclosure required pursuant to Section 10612 shall include, at a minimum, all of the following information, to the extent applicable:
(1)A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
(2)If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This paragraph does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
(3)A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1).
(4)A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services described in paragraph (1), including all of the following:
(A)A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid.
(B)Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable.
(C)Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation.
(D)Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agencys contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income.
(E)A disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
(5)A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finders fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of such compensation.
(6)A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
(7)A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
(8)A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
(9)Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
(10)If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
(11)For all compensation disclosed pursuant to paragraphs (3), (4), (5), and (8), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
(A)Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor.
(B)Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted.
(C)Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
(12)For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
(A)All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements.
(B)Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services.
(C)Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
(13)(A)Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement, including all of the following:
(i)Consulting, advisory, or professional services agreements pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party provides services to the carrier or vendor.
(ii)Data sharing, data licensing, or data analytics agreements.
(iii)Product development, actuarial, underwriting support, or distribution agreements.
(iv)Joint ventures, strategic partnerships, or preferred partnership arrangements.
(v)Any other arrangement pursuant to which the covered service provider or related party receives compensation from, or provides services to, a carrier or vendor that the covered service provider recommends, places, or services for the public agency.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, a business relationship is material if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the twelve months preceding the disclosure or the twelve months following the disclosure.
(b)The disclosure shall include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
(c)The disclosure shall be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signers knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements of this article.
(d)A covered service provider may satisfy this section through a standardized disclosure form adopted by the commissioner and may provide the disclosure electronically.
10614.(a)A covered service provider shall disclose the information required by Section 10613 in accordance with both of the following:
(1)For a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and shall update the disclosure before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
(2)For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
(b)If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider shall provide an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(c)A covered service provider is in compliance with subdivision (b) if the covered service provider provides a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the covered service providers contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board.
(d)A covered service provider shall disclose a material change to information required under this article as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date on which the covered service provider is informed of the material change, unless the disclosure is precluded due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the covered service providers control, in which case the information shall be disclosed as soon as practicable.
(e)For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider shall provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this subdivision, the contract year or plan year means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
(f)A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure shall provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
10615.(a)If a covered service provider provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority, the covered service provider shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the disclosures required by this article to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body.
(2)Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
(b)A joint powers authority that receives disclosures under this section may do both of the following:
(1)Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request.
(2)Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
(c)A covered service providers obligation to disclose under this article is not satisfied by disclosure solely to the joint powers authority if the covered service provider has a direct contractual relationship with a participating public agency for services related to covered health care benefits arrangements.
(d)For compensation that is pooled across multiple public agencies or that cannot be attributed solely to a single public agency, the covered service provider shall use a reasonable allocation methodology and shall disclose the methodology used.
(e)A covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agencys decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority shall disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
(1)Referral fees, finders fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement.
(2)Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement.
(3)Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement.
(4)An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
10616.(a)A covered service provider shall not do any of the following:
(1)Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed pursuant to this article.
(2)Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of this article.
(3)Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of this article. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements shall govern their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
(4)Avoid disclosure obligations under this article by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
(b)A covered service providers assertion, representation, or disclaimer that compensation does not impact, influence, or affect the covered service providers recommendations, the pricing of coverage or services, or the terms obtained for the public agency does not satisfy, reduce, or substitute for a disclosure requirement under this article and shall not be included in a disclosure as a basis for omitting information otherwise required to be disclosed.
10617.(a)A covered service provider shall retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this article for not less than three years following the later of the following:
(1)The date the disclosure is provided.
(2)The termination of the contract or arrangement.
(b)Upon request by the commissioner, the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider shall make records described in subdivision (a) available for inspection.
10618.(a)The commissioner may investigate alleged violations of this article by a covered service provider that provides brokerage services or consulting services.
(b)(1)A covered service provider that violates this article is liable for an administrative penalty of not less than two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) for the first violation.
(2)A covered service provider that violates this article a second or subsequent time, or that commits a knowing violation of this article, is liable for an administrative penalty of not less than five thousand dollars ($5,000) and not more than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for each violation.
(3)For purposes of this subdivision, each public agency to which a covered service provider failed to provide required disclosure, or to which a covered service provider provided a disclosure that failed to comply with this article, shall constitute a separate violation.
(4)Administrative penalties collected pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the General Fund.
(c)After a hearing conducted in accordance with Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) and Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the commissioner may suspend or revoke the license of a covered service provider licensed under this code.
(d)The commissioner may adopt regulations to implement this article, including standardized disclosure forms and guidance materials.
(e)The commissioner may refer violations to the Attorney General, a county counsel, or a city attorney, if appropriate.
(f)This section does not affect any other authority provided by law to the commissioner or the Attorney General.
10619.(a)This article applies to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
(b)The commissioner may adopt regulations necessary to implement this article.
(c)The commissioner shall develop and make available standardized disclosure forms and guidance materials not later than July 1, 2027.
(d)Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2026 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 1020, Statutes of 2026. |
| Sep 30, 2026 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 31, 2026 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 6 p.m. |
| Aug 26, 2026 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 1. Page 5831.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 26, 2026 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 1.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 25, 2026 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 25, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 58. Noes 2. Page 6521.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 25, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 19, 2026 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2026 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 6, 2026 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 5, 2026 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (August 5). |
| Aug 5, 2026 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jul 1, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (June 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 11, 2026 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 8, 2026 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 19, 2026 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 18, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 30. Noes 0. Page 4317.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 18, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 30. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 5, 2026 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 4, 2026 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Apr 24, 2026 | Set for hearing May 4. |
| Apr 22, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 3979.) (April 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2026 | Set for hearing April 21. |
| Apr 8, 2026 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 26, 2026 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 26, 2026 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Mar 25, 2026 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 4, 2026 | Referred to Coms. on INS. and HEALTH. |
| Feb 20, 2026 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2026 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 26, 2026 | Unfinished Business SB1244 Allen et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 25, 2026 | SB 1244 Allen Senate Third Reading By Patel | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 5, 2026 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 30, 2026 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2026 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1244 Allen | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 21, 2026 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AFSCME California | ** Support | |
| Association Of California School Administrators | ** Support | |
| Benecia Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Benicia Unified School District | ** Support | |
| California Agents And Health Insurance Professionals | ** Against | |
| California Federation of Labor Unions AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Support | |
| California School Boards Association | ** Support | |
| California School Employees Association | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Support | |
| California Teachers Association | ** Support | |
| Faculty Association Of California Community Colleges | ** Support | |
| Health Access California | ** Support | |
| Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of California | ** Against | |
| National Association Of Insurance And Financial Advisors - California | ** Against | |
| Orange County Employees Association | ** Support | |
| Purchaser Business Group on Health | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| SEIU California | ** Support | |
| SMART - Transportation Division | ** Support | |
| The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers | ** Against | |
| Urban Counties of California | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-4171 | SB 1244 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1244
Author: Allen (D), et al.
Amended: 8/19/26
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/21/26
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Reyes, Stern, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Niello, Valladares
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 30-0, 5/18/26
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Arreguín, Ashby, Becker, Blakespear, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cervantes, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, McNerney, Menjivar, Ochoa Bogh, Pérez, Reyes, Richardson, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alvarado-Gil, Choi, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Niello, Padilla, Seyarto, Strickland, Valladares
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Passed, 8/ 25/26
SUBJECT: Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
Assembly Amendments
include a public joint labor-management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees under the definition of “public agency,” extends the days for disclosure, and makes other clarifying changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing state law requires a health care service plan or a health insurer to annually disclose to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy specified information, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy. (Health & Safety Code § 1367.08; Insurance Code § 10604.5.)
This bill:
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, specified information before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
- The disclosure must include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
- The disclosure must be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signer’s knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements under this bill.
- The disclosures are required for a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and must be updated before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
- The disclosures are required for an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider is required to provide the disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
- If the covered service provider delivers ongoing services, the covered service provider shall give an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
- For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider must provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this requirement, the “contract year” or “plan year” means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
- A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure must provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
- Requires the disclosure in 1) to include the following information listed below.
- A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
- If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
- A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services.
- A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services, including all of the following:
- a description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid;
- identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable;
- Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation;
- For covered plans with 100 or more employees as of the first day of the contract or arrangement, indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agency’s contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income; and
- disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
- A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finder’s fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
- A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
- A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
- A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
- Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
- If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
- For all compensation disclosed pursuant to (c), (d), (e), and (h), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
- compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor;
- compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted; and
- compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
- Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement. A business relationship is “material” if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding $10,000 in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy.
- This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
- Requires disclosure under 1) and 3) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, $1,000 or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation must be included in this calculation and must be disclosed if it exceeds $250 in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
- Requires a covered service provider that provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority (JPA) or public joint labor management trust to do all of the following:
- provide the disclosures described above to the responsible official of the JPA or public joint labor management trust and governing body; and
- make the disclosures available, either directly or through the JPA or public joint labor management trust, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
- Authorizes a JPA or public joint labor management trust that receives disclosures under this bill to do both of the following:
- maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request; and
- include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a JPA or public joint labor management trust to disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, as specified.
- Prohibits a covered service provider from doing certain acts.
- Requires a covered service provider to retain records sufficient to support the required disclosures for not less than three years following the later of the following:
- the date the disclosure is provided; or
- the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make these records available for inspection.
- Provides that these provisions apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028. Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
Comments
Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not.
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services. In order to effectuate this policy, this bill places disclosure requirements on a covered service provider related to monetary compensation over $1,000 and any non-monetary compensation over $250 for covered health care benefits arrangements. A ”covered service provider” means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services. A “covered health care benefit” arrangement includes numerous types of services ranging from medical, dental, and vision coverage to pharmacy benefit managers, employee assistance programs, and other service providers.
The disclosure requirements apply to any extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, and is to be provided no later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment. If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider is required to provide an updated disclosure annually, and an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure for any compensation previously disclosed as an estimate.
A covered service provider would be required to retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this bill for not less than three years following the later of the following: (1) the date the disclosure is provided; or (2) the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make the records available for inspection. This bill’s provisions would apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028; however, this bill encourages public agencies and covered service providers to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/25/26)
AFSCME California
Association of California School Administrators
Benecia Unified School District
California Federation of Labor Unions AFL-CIO
California Federation of Teachers
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
California State Association of Counties
California Teachers Association
Faculty Association of California Community Colleges
Health Access California
Orange County Employees Association
Purchaser Business Group on Health
Rural County Representatives of California
SEIU California
SMART - Transportation Division
Urban Counties of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/25/26)
California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals
Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of California
National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors - California
The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
Healthcare premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. Public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees’ benefits package. Private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them.
SB 1244 will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
SEIU California, a supporter of this bill, writes in support stating:
[…] Public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits. They rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors. However, these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. It is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a general disclosure that they may receive either direct or indirect compensation that may be based on the premium charged by the insurer with little to no other details. These hidden compensation arrangements can create misaligned incentives, steering public agencies toward more expensive vendors because the compensation for the insurance broker is greater if that option is chosen. These costs are ultimately borne by taxpayers and employees.
Commissions can be as high as 50 percent of the premium for some supplemental products, which are built into the premiums that the employers and employees pay. Base commissions can be between three to six percent of the total premium for an entire health insurance plan and bonuses could be as high as $150,000 for a single employer group. In addition, they are often treated to trips and other experiences, such as going to the Super Bowl or a luxury resort. Insurance plan costs have tripled in the last 20 years, which makes added opaque forms of compensation a serious issue compounding the affordability problems for public agencies.[…]
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of opposition writes:
[…] Despite the characterization that this bill is federal parity, SB 1244 goes well beyond the established federal structure by significantly expanding the scope of covered vendors and services. The bill identifies a wide-ranging list of 36 entities, including network access vendors, provider aggregators, telehealth platforms, human resource information system providers, actuarial services, retiree exchanges, enrollment platforms, digital health vendors, reference-based pricing entities, onsite clinics, claims repricing and subrogation firms, dependent audit vendors, patient advocacy and medical bill negotiation services, banking and custodial services, captive feasibility consultants, and a broad catch-all for any service materially influenced by an intermediary. This expansion introduces substantial complexity and raises serious concerns about the cost, availability and reliability of the required data.
Critically, carriers, vendors, and other service providers are not subject to corresponding obligations to furnish the necessary data. Covered Service Providers—agents and brokers—often do not have access to much of this information, nor is it consistently available in a consolidated, user-friendly, or timely manner. As a result, SB 1244 creates an untenable framework in which agents and brokers are held accountable for disclosures involving information they do not control and may be unable to obtain.
Additionally, SB 1244 requires brokers to disclose compensation “whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy.” This language should be amended to mirror ERISA, which requires disclosure of “compensation from a vendor to a brokerage firm based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the contract with the covered plan,” to harmonize state and federal reporting requirements and ease the administrative burden for firms that are already complying with ERISA requirements for private sector clients.
Moreover, SB 1244 requires a level of compensation reporting that exceeds federal standards. While the CAA requires disclosure of direct and indirect compensation expected to be received by insurers, affiliates, and subcontractors, it does not mandate separate, itemized reporting across three tiers— individual advisor, firm, and affiliates or related parties—as proposed in this bill. In practice, this level of granularity may not be operationally feasible and would likely require significant restructuring of current reporting systems without a clearly defined or proportionate public benefit. […]
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/25/26 16:23:32
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1244
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2026
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires a covered service provider, including brokers, agents, and consultants, to disclose to a public agency or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan, as specified.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
Brokers and agents are licensed professionals who offer insurance products. They can service individuals seeking coverage or employers looking for group insurance. Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not.
Federal disclosure requirements. The No Surprises Act, part of the 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act, added several provisions regarding health plan cost transparency, including requiring disclosures of covered service provider compensation. Specifically, section 202(a) requires disclosure of direct and indirect compensation before an employer-sponsored health plan enters into a contract or arrangement for services. Section 202(a) became effective December 27, 2021, for contracts entered, renewed, or extended on or after the effective date. These provisions apply to private employer sponsored small and large group health plans and require the employer-sponsored health plans to obtain written disclosure of compensation for broker and consulting services from their broker and/or consultant prior to entering a contract to assess the reasonableness of the compensation to be paid to such broker and/or consultant and any potential conflicts of interest. Under the federal law, disclosures are required for arrangements that are expected to result in $1,000 or more in compensation, including non-monetary compensation. The covered service provider is required to make the disclosure regarding direct and indirect compensation to the group health plan or its fiduciary in a timely manner. The employer-sponsored health plan is required to review broker compensation for reasonableness and any potential conflicts of interest prior to entering the contract.
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive similar transparent disclosures of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
According to the Author
Health care premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. The author states that public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees' benefits package. The author notes that private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them. The author concludes that this bill will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
Arguments in Support
A coalition of labor groups representing public sector workers support this bill, stating that public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits and rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend carriers and negotiate rates. However, the supporters note that these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. The supporters continue that it is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a vague disclosure that the broker may receive indirect compensation. The supporters argue that these opaque arrangements create a clear conflict of interest, which potentially steers local agencies toward more expensive vendors simply because the broker's compensation is higher for those options. The supporters state that the stakes for their members are significant. Commissions can be as high as 50% of the premium for some supplemental products, while base commissions for entire health plans often range from 3% - 6% of the total premium. With insurance costs having tripled over the last 20 years, the supporters argue that these hidden costs compound the affordability crisis facing local government employers and their workforce. The supporters conclude that their members deserve to know that their health care dollars are being spent on care, not on undisclosed incentives for intermediaries.
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of associations representing insurance agents and brokers oppose this bill, stating that the bill would create significant compliance challenges and unintended consequences. To address these concerns, the opposition has suggested targeted amendments to align this bill with federal standards. The opposition notes that despite the characterization that this bill is federal parity, the bill goes well beyond the established federal structure by significantly expanding the scope of covered vendors, services, level of compensation reporting, and doesn't align with existing data reporting systems. The opposition continues that in its current form, this bill risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies. This would not be because agents are uninterested in providing transparency, but because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency that this bill requires – which simply means that agents would be putting themselves in legal jeopardy for participating in the marketplace for governmental plans. The opposition argues this could ultimately limit competition, reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect. The opposition notes that this bill comes at a time when securing affordable coverage for their clients has never been more critical or more difficult. As drafted, the opposition asserts that their members will be unable to comply with the overreaching complexities of the bill, and the anti-competitive nature of the legislation will discourage competitive participation in the public entity market. The opposition requests for this bill to be amended to true federal parity which would advance transparency while remaining aligned with operational realities.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, there are no state costs.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 30-0-10
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Arreguín, Ashby, Becker, Blakespear, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cervantes, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, McNerney, Menjivar, Ochoa Bogh, Pérez, Reyes, Richardson, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alvarado-Gil, Choi, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Niello, Padilla, Seyarto, Strickland, Valladares
ASM HEALTH: 12-0-4
YES: Bonta, Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Caloza, Carrillo, Mark González, Patel, Celeste Rodriguez, Schiavo, Sharp-Collins, Stefani
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Jeff Gonzalez, Johnson, Patterson
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Fong, Mark González, Krell, Pacheco, Pellerin, Sharp-Collins, Solache
ABS, ABST OR NV: Hoover, Dixon, Ta, Tangipa
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2026
CONSULTANT: Riana King / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0003788
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1244
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:June 11, 2026
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires a covered service provider, including brokers, agents, and consultants, to disclose to a public agency or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan, as specified.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
Brokers and agents are licensed professionals who offer insurance products. They can service individuals seeking coverage or employers looking for group insurance. Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not.
Federal disclosure requirements. The No Surprises Act, part of the 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act, added several provisions regarding health plan cost transparency, including requiring disclosures of covered service provider compensation. Specifically, section 202(a) requires disclosure of direct and indirect compensation before an employer-sponsored health plan enters into a contract or arrangement for services. Section 202(a) became effective December 27, 2021, for contracts entered, renewed, or extended on or after the effective date. These provisions apply to private employer sponsored small and large group health plans and require the employer-sponsored health plans to obtain written disclosures of compensation for broker and consulting services from their broker and/or consultant prior to entering a contract to assess the reasonableness of the compensation to be paid to such broker and/or consultant and any potential conflicts of interest. Under the federal law, disclosures are required for arrangements that are expected to result in $1,000 or more in compensation, including non-monetary compensation. The covered service provider is required to make the disclosure regarding direct and indirect compensation to the group health plan or its fiduciary in a timely manner. The employer-sponsored health plan is required to review broker compensation for reasonableness and any potential conflicts of interest prior to entering the contract.
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive similar transparent disclosures of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
According to the Author
Health care premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. The author states that public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees' benefits package. The author notes that private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them. The author concludes that this bill will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
Arguments in Support
A coalition of labor groups representing public sector workers support this bill, stating that public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits and rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend carriers and negotiate rates. However, the supporters note that these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. The supporters continue that it is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a vague disclosure that the broker may receive indirect compensation. The supporters argue that these opaque arrangements create a clear conflict of interest, which potentially steers local agencies toward more expensive vendors simply because the broker's compensation is higher for those options. The supporters state that the stakes for their members are significant. Commissions can be as high as 50% of the premium for some supplemental products, while base commissions for entire health plans often range from 3% - 6% of the total premium. With insurance costs having tripled over the last 20 years, the supporters argue that these hidden costs compound the affordability crisis facing local government employers and their workforce. The supporters conclude that their members deserve to know that their health care dollars are being spent on care, not on undisclosed incentives for intermediaries.
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of associations representing insurance agents and brokers oppose this bill, stating that the bill would create significant compliance challenges and unintended consequences. To address these concerns, the opposition has suggested targeted amendments to align this bill with federal standards. The opposition notes that despite the characterization that this bill is federal parity, the bill goes well beyond the established federal structure by significantly expanding the scope of covered vendors, services, level of compensation reporting, and doesn't align with existing data reporting systems. The opposition continues that in its current form, this bill risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies. This would not be because agents are uninterested in providing transparency, but because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency that this bill requires – which simply means that agents would be putting themselves in legal jeopardy for participating in the marketplace for governmental plans. The opposition argues this could ultimately limit competition, reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect. The opposition notes that this bill comes at a time when securing affordable coverage for their clients has never been more critical or more difficult. As drafted, the opposition asserts that their members will be unable to comply with the overreaching complexities of the bill, and the anti-competitive nature of the legislation will discourage competitive participation in the public entity market. The opposition requests for this bill to be amended to true federal parity which would advance transparency while remaining aligned with operational realities.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, there are no state costs.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 30-0-10
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Arreguín, Ashby, Becker, Blakespear, Cabaldon, Caballero, Cervantes, Cortese, Durazo, Gonzalez, Grayson, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, McNerney, Menjivar, Ochoa Bogh, Pérez, Reyes, Richardson, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alvarado-Gil, Choi, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Niello, Padilla, Seyarto, Strickland, Valladares
ASM HEALTH: 12-0-4
YES: Bonta, Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Ahrens, Caloza, Carrillo, Mark González, Patel, Celeste Rodriguez, Schiavo, Sharp-Collins, Stefani
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Jeff Gonzalez, Johnson, Patterson
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Caloza, Fong, Mark González, Krell, Pacheco, Pellerin, Sharp-Collins, Solache
ABS, ABST OR NV: Hoover, Dixon, Ta, Tangipa
UPDATED
VERSION: June 11, 2026
CONSULTANT: Riana King / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0003346
Date of Hearing: August 5, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1244
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2026
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill, the Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act, requires service providers such as brokers, agents, and consultants, to disclose to a public agency or its group health plan the compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services before providing such services to the public agency or its health plan.
Please refer to the Assembly Health Committee analysis for a detailed enumeration of the provisions of this bill. Major provisions of this bill:
- Define “covered service provider” to mean a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a group health plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this article, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
- Require a covered service provider to disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency, in writing, specified information related to compensation arrangements before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered health plan.
- Require a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, regardless of whether the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy.
- Applies the above disclosure requirements to a covered service provider providing services to a joint powers authority.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Health care premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. Public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees’ benefits package. Private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contract with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them.
[This bill] will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
- Background. Public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The federal Employee Retirement Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) requires some retirement and health plans to provide participants with certain information, but generally does not apply to plans maintained by government entities. The federal Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA) requires comprehensive broker, agent, and consultant compensation disclosure for ERISA-covered group health plans for arrangements that are expected to result in $1,000 or more in compensation, including nonmonetary compensation. State statutes require a health plan or a health insurer to annually disclose specified information to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy.
- Oppose Unless Amended. A coalition of associations representing insurance agents and brokers argues this bill would create significant compliance challenges and unintended consequences, and suggests amendments to align this bill with federal standards. The coalition contends this bill goes well beyond the established federal structure by significantly expanding the scope of covered vendors, services, and level of compensation reporting, and doesn’t align with existing data reporting systems. The coalition states this bill risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency this bill requires, which could ultimately limit competition, reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 30, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1244
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2026
SENATE VOTE: 30-0
SUBJECT: Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act.
SUMMARY: Requires a covered service provider, including brokers, agents, and consultants, to disclose to a public agency or its group health plan the direct and indirect compensation it expects to receive for providing brokerage or consulting services before it enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or its plan. Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for the public agency or its group health plan, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, specified information before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrations, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities (JPAs), captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy. Includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a JPA, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the JPA, a vendor contracting with the JPA, or any other source.
- Requires disclosure pursuant to 1) and 2) above if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract arrangement, $1,000 or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Requires noncash compensation to be included in this calculation and disclosed if it exceeds $250 in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
- Permits a description of compensation or cost to be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured. Permits, if the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it to be described by any other reasonable method. Allows the description to include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate. Requires the description to contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
- Requires the disclosure pursuant to 1) and 2) above to include the following information:
- A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided;
- If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. Does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law;
- A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services;
- A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services, including all of the following:
- A description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid;
- Identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable;
- Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation;
- Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agency’s contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income; and,
- Disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this bill. States that general descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. Requires the disclosure to state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
- A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finder’s fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation;
- A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination;
- A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this bill will be received;
- A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value;
- Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement;
- If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients;
- For all compensation disclosed pursuant to c), d), e), and h), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
- Compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor;
- Compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted; and,
- Compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
- For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
- All compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements;
- Whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services; and
- Any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
- Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement. States that a business relationship is “material” if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding $10,000 in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
- Requires the covered service provider to disclose information in accordance with both of the following:
- For a prospective contract or arrangement, to provide the disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and to be updated before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation;
- For an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, to provide the disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment;
- Requires, if the covered service provider delivers ongoing services, the covered service provider to give an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services;
- Specifies that a covered service provider is in compliance with i) above if they provide a comprehensive disclosure covering all covered health care benefits arrangements not later than 60 days before the annual renewal date of the contract or arrangement with the responsible public agency official or governing board;
- Requires, for any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider to provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this requirement, the “contract year” or “plan year” means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract; and,
- Requires, if the covered service provider discovers an error or omission in a disclosure, to provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
- Requires a covered service provider that provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a JPA to do both of the following:
- Provide the disclosures described above to the responsible official of the JPA and governing body; and,
- Make the disclosures available, either directly or through the JPA, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
- Authorizes a JPA that receives disclosures under this bill to do both of the following:
- Maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request; and,
- Include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a JPA to disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
- Referral fees, finder’s fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement;
- Commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement;
- Administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement; and,
- An ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
- Prohibits a covered service provider from doing any of the following:
- Requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed;
- Structuring, routing, recharacterizing, allocating, or otherwise arranging compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements;
- Relabeling, renaming, or recharacterizing compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements; and,
- Avoiding disclosure obligations by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider to retain records sufficient to support the required disclosures for not less than three years following the later of the following:
- The date the disclosure is provided; or,
- The termination of the contract or arrangement.
- Requires, upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider to make these records available for inspection.
- Provides that these provisions apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028. States that public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
- Defines “covered service provider” as a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services described in this bill, regardless of if those services will be performed, or the compensation received, by the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party.
- Defines “covered health care benefits arrangement” as a contract, policy, program, or arrangement for health care employee benefits or health care benefits-related services that is recommended, placed, renewed, extended, or materially influenced by a covered service provider for a covered plan or public agency, including all of the following:
- Medical coverage, whether insured, self-funded, or both;
- Stop-loss, captive, or reinsurance arrangements;
- Dental coverage;
- Vision coverage;
- Voluntary or worksite benefits, including life insurance, disability insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance;
- Third-party administration services, including trust or JPA administration, health reimbursement arrangements, health savings accounts, flexible spending accounts, continuation coverage, and leave administration;
- Network administration services;
- Network access vendors and rental network arrangements;
- Provider aggregators, including centers of excellence and direct contract aggregators;
- Pharmacy benefit management services and related rebate programs;
- Pharmacy benefit cost containment programs;
- Recordkeeping services;
- Medical management and utilization review vendors;
- Wellness services and programs;
- Transparency tools and data analytics vendors;
- Group purchasing organization preferred vendor panels;
- Disease management vendors and products;
- Care navigation and care management services;
- Telehealth services and platforms;
- Compliance services;
- Employee assistance programs;
- Human resource information systems;
- Benefits or coverages purchased through a multiemployer purchasing arrangement, such as a JPA, trust fund, or cooperative;
- Benefits or coverage for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, and other retiree coverage programs;
- Actuarial services, including actuarial valuations, ratesetting analysis, reserve certifications, and other actuarial consulting related to covered health care benefits arrangements;
- Enrollment services and benefit enrollment platforms;
- Digital health and specialty condition management programs, including mental health, musculoskeletal, fertility and family-building, diabetes management, weight management, and substance use disorder programs;
- Reference-based pricing and direct contracting programs;
- Onsite, near-site, or shared-site clinic services;
- Claims auditing, claims repricing, and subrogation services;
- Dependent eligibility verification and audit services;
- Patient advocacy, health care concierge, and medical bill negotiation services;
- Benefits communication and employee education services;
- Banking and custodial services for health-related accounts, including health reimbursement arrangement, health savings account, and flexible spending account custodians;
- Captive insurance management and captive feasibility consulting services; and,
- Any other product, service, or vendor recommended if compensation is paid, directly or indirectly, because of the covered service provider’s recommendation, placement, renewal, or material influence. For purposes of this paragraph, “materially influence” includes providing advice, analysis, recommendations, or other input that was relied upon or adopted by the public agency in making a procurement, renewal, or vendor selection decision.
- Defines “affiliate” to mean an entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity, or is an officer, director, or employee of, or partner in, that entity. Unless otherwise specified, “affiliate” refers to an affiliate of the covered service provider. “Affiliate” includes a person or entity created, recruited, or designated with the intent to avoid the disclosure requirements of this article.
- Defines “brokerage services” to include soliciting, recommending, placing, arranging, enrolling, renewing, extending, or otherwise materially influencing the selection of a covered health care benefits arrangement or vendor for a covered plan or public agency, and related assistance with procurement, marketing, negotiation, or implementation of those arrangements.
- Defines “compensation” as anything of monetary value paid in cash or noncash form, including money, fees, commissions, consulting payments, retainers, overrides, contingent or volume-based compensation, bonuses including retention bonuses, referral fees, revenue sharing, marketing allowances, administrative allowances, rebates, technology subsidies, gifts, awards, trips, profit sharing, data access or data monetization payments, and any other remuneration or economic benefit received in connection with services provided to a public agency or covered plan, including credits, allowances, expense reimbursements, and expense offset.
- Defines “direct compensation” as compensation received directly from the covered plan or from the public agency plan sponsor.
- Defines “indirect compensation” as compensation received from any source other than the covered plan, the public agency plan sponsor, the covered service provider, or an affiliate. Compensation received from a subcontractor is indirect compensation unless it is received in connection with services performed under the subcontractor’s contract or arrangement.
- Defines “noncash compensation” as compensation that is not paid in cash, including travel, lodging, meals, entertainment, gifts, conference sponsorships, lead lists, technology, preferred access, or other items of value.
- Defines “public agency” as a county, a city, a city and county, a school district, a community college district, a special district, a JPA, a public authority, a public entity, or any other local governmental entity in this state that is authorized to sponsor, purchase, or administer employee health care benefits. “Public agency” also includes a public joint labor-management trust or similar entity that provides or administers health or welfare benefits for public employees or retirees.
- Defines other terms and makes legislative findings and declarations.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Requires, under the Employee Retirement Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), certain retirement and health plans to provide participants with certain information. ERISA generally does not cover plans maintained by governmental entities. [29 U.S.C. § 1001, et seq.]
- Requires, under the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA), comprehensive broker, agent, and consultant compensation disclosure for ERISA-covered group health plans. [§ 202, Pub. L. No 116-260 (Dec. 27, 2020).]
EXISTING STATE LAW: Requires a health plan or a health insurer to annually disclose to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy specified information, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy. [Health & Safety Code § 1367.08 and Insurance Code § 10604.5.]
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, healthcare premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. The author states that public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees’ benefits package. The author notes that private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them. The author concludes that this bill will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
- BACKGROUND. Brokers and agents are licensed professionals who offer insurance products. They can service individuals seeking coverage or employers looking for group insurance. Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not.
- Federal disclosure requirements. The No Surprises Act, part of the 2021 CAA, added several provisions regarding health plan cost transparency, including requiring disclosures of covered service provider compensation. Specifically, section 202(a) requires disclosure of direct and indirect compensation before an employer-sponsored health plan enters into a contract or arrangement for services. Section 202(a) became effective December 27, 2021, for contracts entered, renewed, or extended on or after the effective date. These provisions apply to private employer sponsored small and large group health plans and require the employer-sponsored health plans to obtain written disclosure of compensation for broker and consulting services from their broker and/or consultant prior to entering a contract to assess the reasonableness of the compensation to be paid to such broker and/or consultant and any potential conflicts of interest. Under the federal law, disclosures are required for arrangements that are expected to result in $1,000 or more in compensation, including nonmonetary compensation. The covered service provider is required to make the disclosure regarding direct and indirect compensation to the group health plan or its fiduciary in a timely manner. The employer-sponsored health plan is required to review broker compensation for reasonableness and any potential conflicts of interest prior to entering the contract.
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive similar transparent disclosures of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services.
- SUPPORT. A coalition of labor groups representing public sector workers support this bill, stating that public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits and rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend carriers and negotiate rates. However, the supporters note that these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. The supporters continue that it is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a vague disclosure that the broker may receive indirect compensation. The supporters argue that these opaque arrangements create a clear conflict of interest, which potentially steers local agencies toward more expensive vendors simply because the broker’s compensation is higher for those options. The supporters state that the stakes for their members are significant. Commissions can be as high as 50% of the premium for some supplemental products, while base commissions for entire health plans often range from 3% - 6% of the total premium. With insurance costs having tripled over the last 20 years, the supporters argue that these hidden costs compound the affordability crisis facing local government employers and their workforce. The supporters conclude that their members deserve to know that their health care dollars are being spent on care, not on undisclosed incentives for intermediaries.
- OPPOSSED UNLESS AMENDED. A coalition of associations representing insurance agents and brokers oppose this bill, stating that the bill would create significant compliance challenges and unintended consequences. To address these concerns, the opposition has suggested targeted amendments to align this bill with federal standards. The opposition notes that despite the characterization that this bill is federal parity, the bill goes well beyond the established federal structure by significantly expanding the scope of covered vendors, services, level of compensation reporting, and doesn’t align with existing data reporting systems. The opposition continues that in its current form, this bill risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies. This would not be because agents are uninterested in providing transparency, but because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency that this bill requires – which simply means that agents would be putting themselves in legal jeopardy for participating in the marketplace for governmental plans. The opposition argues this could ultimately limit competition, reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect. The opposition notes that this bill comes at a time when securing affordable coverage for their clients has never been more critical or more difficult. As drafted, the opposition asserts that their members will be unable to comply with the overreaching complexities of the bill, and the anti-competitive nature of the legislation will discourage competitive participation in the public entity market. The opposition requests for this bill to be amended to true federal parity which would advance transparency while remaining aligned with operational realities.
- POLICY QUESTIONS. While the overarching goal of this legislation is to ensure that public employers have parity in transparency on broker/agent compensation, this bill does exceed the federal standards in ways that raise questions about feasibility. Many of these questions exceed the jurisdiction of this committee, but if this bill is to move forward the Legislature may wish to contemplate the following questions:
- Expanded scope beyond federal framework. This bill identifies 36 categories of covered vendors and service providers from which compensation needs to be reported, extending well beyond the health plan-focused entities covered under the federal framework. This expansion pulls in a wide range of ancillary vendors including telehealth platforms, actuarial services, human resource information system providers, retiree exchanges, enrollment platforms, digital health vendors, reference-based pricing entities, onsite clinics, claims repricing and subrogation firms, and patient advocacy services. The opposition notes that these additional service providers are not subject to corresponding obligations to furnish necessary compensation or financial data to agents and brokers, leaving them without access to much of the data necessary to comply with the disclosure requirements of this bill. The author argues that since the passage of federal law, more compensation forms have been identified including technology-related compensation routed through enrollment platforms and benefits administration systems, hidden commissions related to voluntary insurance products and payments related to digital point solution vendors. The author believes it is critical to ensure that public agencies receive as much of a full picture as possible when they are considering a contract for services. While maximum transparency is a laudable goal, what is the feasibility of an individual broker or agent truly being able to realistically disclose the information requested under this bill?
- Individual broker responsibility. In addition to the issues raised in the question above, the opposition has noted that oftentimes brokers and agents are part of larger consulting firms or agencies and aren’t privy to the full scope of compensation to those entities. However, this bill would make the brokers and agents responsible for reporting compensation to such affiliated entities. Is it appropriate to place this level of compliance and reporting burden for compensation disclosure directly on individual brokers and agents, given that they are often one participant in a complex, multi-party benefits arrangement involving carriers, larger consulting firms, TPAs, and vendors, many of whom control compensation data the broker may not have direct access to? Should disclosure responsibility instead be assigned to the entity with the most complete visibility into the full compensation structure? If disclosure responsibility is left with the broker, are protections in the bill sufficient to ensure a broker isn’t fully liable for disclosing accurate data that they may not have access to?
- Parity for other employers and agents. Health insurance brokers would face new disclosure and reporting obligations under this bill. Are brokers operating in other lines of business with public or private agencies subject to comparable requirements? Given that this bill goes beyond federal requirements, what is the benefit or policy rationale for creating different standards for health insurance brokers supporting public agencies vs. other employers?
With broad questions about implementation and feasibility lingering, the Legislature should ponder what the policy justification is for going beyond the federal standard that has already been successfully implemented nationally. If the goal is transparency and parity, should the Legislature begin by aligning this bill with federal law and take time to expand disclosures to meaningfully encompass the expanded entities that the author and supporters are aiming to capture?
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AFSCME California
Association of California School Administrators
Benicia Unified School District
California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO
California Federation of Teachers
California School Employees Association
California State Association of Counties
California Teachers Association
Faculty Association of California Community Colleges
Health Access California
Orange County Employees Association
Rural County Representatives of California
SEIU California
SMART - Transportation Division
Urban Counties of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Riana King / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-4171 | SB 1244 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1244
Author: Allen (D)
Amended: 3/25/26
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/21/26
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Reyes, Stern, Wahab, Weber Pierson, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Niello, Valladares
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state.
ANALYSIS:
Existing state law requires a health care service plan or a health insurer to annually disclose to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy specified information, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy. (Health & Safety Code § 1367.08; Insurance Code § 10604.5.)
This bill:
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, specified information before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
- The disclosure must include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
- The disclosure must be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signer’s knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements under this bill.
- The disclosures are required for a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and must be updated before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
- The disclosures are required for an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider is required to provide the disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
- If the covered service provider delivers ongoing services, the covered service provider shall give an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
- For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider must provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this requirement, the “contract year” or “plan year” means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
- A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure must provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
- Requires the disclosure in 1) to include the following information listed below.
- A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
- If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
- A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services.
- A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services, including all of the following:
- a description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid;
- identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable;
- Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation;
- Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agency’s contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income; and
- disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
- A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finder’s fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
- A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
- A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
- A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
- Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
- If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
- For all compensation disclosed pursuant to (c), (d), (e), and (h), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
- compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor;
- compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted; and
- compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
- For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
- all compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements;
- whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services; and
- any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
- Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement. A business relationship is “material” if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding $10,000 in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy.
- This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
- Requires disclosure under 1) and 3) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, $1,000 or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation must be included in this calculation and must be disclosed if it exceeds $250 in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
- Requires a covered service provider that provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority (JPA) to do all of the following:
- provide the disclosures described above to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body; and
- make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
- Authorizes a JPA that receives disclosures under this bill to do both of the following:
- maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request; and
- include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority to disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, as specified.
- Prohibits a covered service provider from doing certain acts.
- Requires a covered service provider to retain records sufficient to support the required disclosures for not less than three years following the later of the following:
- the date the disclosure is provided; or
- the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make these records available for inspection.
- Provides that these provisions apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028. Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
Comments
Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not.
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services. In order to effectuate this policy, this bill places disclosure requirements on a covered service provider related to monetary compensation over $1,000 and any non-monetary compensation over $250 for covered health care benefits arrangements. A ”covered service provider” means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services. A “covered health care benefit” arrangement includes numerous types of services ranging from medical, dental, and vision coverage to pharmacy benefit managers, employee assistance programs, and other service providers.
The disclosure requirements apply to any extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, and is to be provided no later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment. If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider is required to provide an updated disclosure annually, and an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure for any compensation previously disclosed as an estimate.
A covered service provider would be required to retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by this bill for not less than three years following the later of the following: (1) the date the disclosure is provided; or (2) the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make the records available for inspection. This bill’s provisions would apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028; however, this bill encourages public agencies and covered service providers to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/4/26)
AFSCME California
Association of California School Administrators
California Federation of Labor Unions AFL-CIO
California Federation of Teachers
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
SEIU California
California Teachers Association
Health Access California
Orange County Employees Association
Purchaser Business Group on Health
SMART - Transportation Division
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/4/26)
California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
Healthcare premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. Public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees’ benefits package. Private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them.
SB 1244 will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
SEIU California, a supporter of this bill, writes in support stating:
[…] Public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits. They rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors. However, these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. It is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a general disclosure that they may receive either direct or indirect compensation that may be based on the premium charged by the insurer with little to no other details. These hidden compensation arrangements can create misaligned incentives, steering public agencies toward more expensive vendors because the compensation for the insurance broker is greater if that option is chosen. These costs are ultimately borne by taxpayers and employees.
Commissions can be as high as 50 percent of the premium for some supplemental products, which are built into the premiums that the employers and employees pay. Base commissions can be between three to six percent of the total premium for an entire health insurance plan and bonuses could be as high as $150,000 for a single employer group. In addition, they are often treated to trips and other experiences, such as going to the Super Bowl or a luxury resort. Insurance plan costs have tripled in the last 20 years, which makes added opaque forms of compensation a serious issue compounding the affordability problems for public agencies.[…]
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals (CAHIP) writes in opposition unless amended. They raise several concerns with bill, including that it goes beyond requirements required at the federal level, applies to a broader category of providers and services than at the federal level, places burdensome requirements that could be operationally difficult to comply with, and may discourage agents and brokers from working with public agencies. CAHIP states they welcome an opportunity to work with the author to address their concerns and writes:
[…] In its current form, SB 1244 risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies. This would not be because agents are uninterested in providing transparency, but because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency that this bill requires – which simply means that agents would be putting themselves in legal jeopardy for participating in the marketplace for governmental plans. This could ultimately limit competition,
reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect.[…]
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/5/26 15:55:45
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1244 (Author:Allen)
Version: March 25, 2026
Hearing Date: April 21, 2026
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Public Agency Benefits Intermediary Compensation Disclosure Act
DIGEST
This bill establishes disclosure requirements for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits, regardless of whether the covered service provider is domiciled, headquartered, or maintains a principal place of business within or outside of this state
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Brokers and agents can help employers, including public entities, navigate the process of purchasing heath care plans and other benefits for their employees. Generally, these brokers are paid for their services by the industry. There is currently little to no transparency into what compensation brokers receive when working with public entities as there are no disclosure requirements under existing law. Existing federal law places disclosure requirements on broker compensation for private health plans, but governmental entities are exempted from the federal law. This bills seeks to address this issue by establishing disclosure requirements for agents, brokers, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits. The purpose of the bill is to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services. This bill requires similar disclosures as under federal law; however, it is broader than federal law as it requires more stringent disclosures and applies to more service providers. The bill is author sponsored and supported by various labor organizations and Health Access California. The bill is opposed by the California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Requires, under the Employee Retirement Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), certain retirement and health plans to provide participants with certain information. ERISA generally does not cover plans maintained by governmental entities. (29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.)
- Requires, under the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA), comprehensive broker, agent, and consultant compensation disclosure for ERISA-covered group health plans. (§ 202, Pub. L. No 116-260 (Dec. 27, 2020).)
Existing state law:
- Requires a health care service plan or a health insurer to annually disclose to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy specified information, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy. (Health & Saf. Code § 1367.08; Ins. Code § 10604.5.)
This bill:
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose to the responsible public agency official, and to the governing body of the public agency or the clerk or other designee identified by the governing body, in writing, specified information before the covered service provider enters into, extends, renews, or materially amends a contract or arrangement for brokerage services or consulting services with the public agency or covered plan.
- The disclosure must include sufficient detail to permit the responsible public agency official and the governing body to understand the nature and potential magnitude of compensation and to identify potential conflicts of interest.
- The disclosure must be signed by an authorized representative of the covered service provider and shall include a certification that the disclosure is true, correct, and complete to the best of the signer’s knowledge and that the covered service provider will comply with the update and true-up requirements under the bill.
- The disclosures are required for a prospective contract or arrangement, the covered service provider shall provide the required disclosure with the first written communication to the responsible public agency representative or governing board that contains a formal offer, proposal, or solicitation to provide brokerage, agent, advisory, or consulting services, and must be updated before execution if there is any material change to the expected compensation.
- The disclosures are required for an extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, the covered service provider is required to provide the disclosure not later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment.
- If the covered service provider delivers ongoing services, the covered service provider shall give an updated disclosure annually, not later than 60 days before the renewal date of each covered health care benefits arrangement for which the covered service provider provides brokerage services or consulting services.
- For any compensation disclosed as an estimate, the covered service provider must provide an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure not later than 90 days after the end of the contract year or plan year, as applicable. For purposes of this requirement, the “contract year” or “plan year” means the 12-month period used for coverage under the covered health care benefits arrangement, or, if that period is not specified, the 12-month period following the effective date or renewal date of the contract.
- A covered service provider that discovers an error or omission in a disclosure must provide corrected information as soon as practicable, but not later than 30 days after the date the covered service provider knows of the error or omission.
- Requires the disclosure in 1) to include the following information listed below.
- A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
- If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law. This does not create or expand fiduciary status under state law.
- A description of all direct compensation, either in the aggregate or by service, that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services.
- A description of all indirect compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, a subcontractor, or a related party reasonably expects to receive in connection with the services, including all of the following:
- a description of the arrangement pursuant to which the indirect compensation is paid;
- identification of the services for which the indirect compensation will be received, if applicable;
- Identification of the payer of the indirect compensation;
- Indirect compensation includes compensation from a carrier, vendor, or third party based on a structure of incentives not solely related to the public agency’s contract or policy, including book-of-business incentives, volume bonuses, retention bonuses, and other market-derived income; and
- disclosure that identifies categories, types, or sources of compensation without providing corresponding amounts, good-faith estimates, or formulas for calculating amounts for each identified category, type, or source does not satisfy the requirements of this article. General descriptions of compensation arrangements that may exist or that the covered service provider may from time to time receive are insufficient. The disclosure shall state if the covered service provider reasonably expects to receive the compensation in connection with the specific public agency or covered plan during the applicable contract period.
- A description of any compensation that will be paid among the covered service provider, an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party in connection with the services described in paragraph (1) if the compensation is set on a transaction basis, such as commissions, finder’s fees, placement fees, or other similar incentive compensation based on business placed or retained, including identification of the services for which the compensation will be paid and identification of the payers and recipients of that compensation.
- A description of any compensation that the covered service provider, an affiliate, related party, or a subcontractor reasonably expects to receive in connection with termination of the contract or arrangement, and how any prepaid amounts will be calculated and refunded upon termination.
- A description of the manner in which the compensation described in this section will be received.
- A description of noncash compensation, including the nature of the noncash compensation and a reasonable good faith estimate of fair market value.
- Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
- If any compensation cannot reasonably be expressed as a monetary amount at the time of disclosure, a reasonable and good faith estimate and an explanation of the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate, including any reasonable allocation methodology for compensation that is pooled across multiple clients.
- For all compensation disclosed pursuant to (c), (d), (e), and (h), a breakdown showing all of the following separately:
- compensation to the individual broker, agent, consultant, or advisor;
- compensation to the firm or company by which the individual is employed or contracted; and
- compensation to an affiliate, subcontractor, or related party, regardless of whether the compensation is paid directly or routed through a third party or other entity.
- For covered service providers that recommend, place, or service benefits arrangements for retirees, including Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage, a separate statement disclosing all of the following:
- all compensation related to retiree benefits arrangements, broken out separately from compensation related to active employee arrangements;
- whether compensation for retiree-related services is considered by the covered service provider in determining or offsetting fees for active employee services; and
- any arrangement pursuant to which retiree-related compensation subsidizes, offsets, or is otherwise connected to the pricing of services for active employee benefits.
- Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement. A business relationship is “material” if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding $10,000 in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider to disclose compensation and material financial interests related to a covered health care benefits arrangement that the covered service provider recommends, places, renews, services, or materially influences for a public agency or covered plan, including compensation paid by carriers, vendors, third-party administrators, pharmacy benefit managers, enrollment firms, joint powers authorities, captives, and other sources, whether or not the compensation is solely attributable to the public agency’s specific contract or policy.
- This includes compensation received for recommending, facilitating, or influencing a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority, regardless of whether the compensation is paid by the joint powers authority, a vendor contracting with the joint powers authority, or any other source.
- Requires disclosure under 1) and 3) if a covered service provider reasonably expects it would receive, during the term of the contract or arrangement, $1,000 or more in compensation, direct or indirect, including compensation received by a related party. Noncash compensation must be included in this calculation and must be disclosed if it exceeds $250 in the aggregate during the term of the contract or arrangement, or if a reasonable person would consider it material.
- A description of compensation or cost may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, percentage, or a per capita charge for each participant, beneficiary, enrollee, or insured.
- If the compensation or cost cannot reasonably be expressed in those terms, it may be described by any other reasonable method.
- The description may include a reasonable and good faith estimate if the covered service provider cannot otherwise readily describe compensation or cost, if the covered service provider explains the methodology and assumptions used to prepare the estimate.
- The description must contain sufficient information to permit the public agency to understand the nature and potential magnitude of the compensation or cost and identify potential conflicts of interest.
- Requires a covered service provider that provides brokerage services, consulting services, or administrative services to a joint powers authority (JPA) to do all of the following:
- provide the disclosures described above to the responsible official of the joint powers authority and governing body; and
- make the disclosures available, either directly or through the joint powers authority, to the governing body or responsible official of each public agency that participates in the pooled arrangement, upon request and at least annually.
- Authorizes a JPA that receives disclosures under this bill to do both of the following:
- maintain the disclosures and make them available to its member public agencies upon request; and
- include in its annual reporting to member agencies a summary of compensation disclosed by covered service providers or provide a copy of the full disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider that recommends, facilitates, or materially influences a public agency’s decision to join, remain with, or purchase coverage through a joint powers authority to disclose to that public agency all compensation received or reasonably expected to be received, directly or indirectly, in connection with that recommendation, including all of the following:
- referral fees, finder’s fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement;
- commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement;
- administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement; and
- an ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
- Prohibits a covered service provider from doing any of the following:
- requesting, accepting, or receiving direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed;
- structuring, routing, recharacterizing, allocating, or otherwise arranging compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements;
- relabeling, renaming, or recharacterizing compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements; and
- avoiding disclosure obligations by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
- Requires a covered service provider to retain records sufficient to support the required disclosures for not less than three years following the later of the following:
- the date the disclosure is provided; or
- the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make these records available for inspection.
- Provides that these provisions apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.
- Public agencies and covered service providers are encouraged to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
Healthcare premiums have more than tripled over the past 20 years. Public agencies have been grappling with these rising prices that are, in some cases, compounded by compensation paid to insurance intermediaries who advise employers on health care options to select for their employees’ benefits package. Private employers receive compensation disclosures from these intermediaries, which can help guide decisions on which benefits to select and which intermediaries to contact with. Public agencies, however, currently receive no such transparency, and thus have to make large financial decisions with less information available to them.
SB 1244 will close this gap in the law and help public agencies make more fiscally sound decisions when selecting employee benefits options by requiring insurance intermediaries to proactively disclose the compensation they earn for advising these agencies to select certain health care options.
- This bill requires disclosures for brokers, agents, consultants, advisors, and other service providers that provide brokerage services or consulting services to California public agencies in connection with health care employee benefits
Public agencies, including school districts, cities, counties, community colleges, and special districts, spend billions annually on employee health benefits. Just like private employers, public agencies often rely on brokers and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors for benefits. These brokers generally receive compensation directly from the carriers. The fact that they are being compensated is usually disclosed; however, the exact amount of compensation is not. The author of the bill provided the Committee with an example of a brokerage services contract from EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants that states:
[…] EPIC is compensated in a variety of ways for the services it provides to its clients, and a particular placement may involve one or a combination of such arrangements. Primarily, EPIC is compensated through commission payments that are based on (and a part of) the premium charged and collected by Insurers for each insurance policy secured for EPIC’s clients. In some cases, EPIC may receive specific fees from clients in lieu of or in addition to such commissions for the placement of coverage and/or for other services or projects. […]
This bill is intended to ensure that public agencies receive transparent disclosure of compensation and potential conflicts of interest on a reasonable timeframe to inform procurement and renewal decisions regarding health care benefits and benefits-related services. In order to effectuate this policy, the bill places disclosure requirements on a covered service provider related to monetary compensation over $1,000 and any non-monetary compensation over $250 for covered health care benefits arrangements. A ”covered service provider” means a broker, agent, consultant, or advisor that enters into a contract or arrangement with a covered plan or public agency and reasonably expects, knew, or should have known it would receive, compensation, direct or indirect, to be received in connection with providing brokerage services or consulting services. A “covered health care benefit” arrangement includes numerous types of services ranging from medical, dental, and vision coverage to pharmacy benefit managers, employee assistance programs, and other service providers.
The disclosure requirements apply to any extension, renewal, or material amendment of an existing contract or arrangement, and is to be provided no later than 60 days before the effective date of the extension, renewal, or material amendment. If the covered service provider provides ongoing services, the covered service provider is required to provide an updated disclosure annually, and an annual true-up that includes revised disclosure for any compensation previously disclosed as an estimate.
Other disclosure requirements under the bill include the following listed below:
- Identification of a material business relationship between the covered service provider, or any related party, and a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement. A business relationship is considered “material” if the covered service provider or related party received or expects to receive compensation exceeding $10,000 in the aggregate from the carrier or vendor during the 12 months preceding the disclosure or the 12 months following the disclosure.
- Separate information regarding retiree coverage, including for Medicare supplement plans, Medicare Advantage plans, retiree health exchanges, or other retiree coverage.
- Identification of an ownership interest, equity stake, or other financial interest, including a pending or proposed interest under negotiation or under consideration, that the covered service provider or any related party holds in a carrier, vendor, or other entity that is a party to, or is recommended in connection with, a covered health care benefits arrangement.
- A description of the brokerage services or consulting services to be provided.
- If applicable, a statement that the covered service provider, an affiliate, or a subcontractor will provide, or reasonably expects to provide, services pursuant to the contract or arrangement directly to the public agency or covered plan as a fiduciary under applicable law.
Under the bill, a covered service provider would be prohibited from doing any of the following listed below.
- Request, accept, or receive direct or indirect compensation in connection with brokerage services or consulting services provided to a public agency or covered plan unless the compensation is disclosed as required under the bill.
- Structure, route, recharacterize, allocate, or otherwise arrange compensation, including through an affiliate, subcontractor, or other related party, for the purpose of evading the disclosure requirements of the bill.
- Relabel, rename, or recharacterize compensation as fees, consulting payments, administrative charges, service fees, or any other designation for the purpose of circumventing the disclosure requirements of the bill. The substance and economic reality of compensation arrangements governs their treatment under this article, regardless of the terminology used by the parties.
- Avoid disclosure obligations under this bill by entering into a separate consulting agreement or advisory agreement for substantially similar services that would otherwise require disclosure.
The bill provides that its provisions apply to a JPA and that the following information must also be disclosed if a covered service provider is providing services to a JPA:
- referral fees, finder’s fees, or placement fees paid by the pooling arrangement or an entity affiliated with the pooling arrangement;
- commissions, overrides, or other compensation paid by a carrier, vendor, or third party contracting with or through the pooling arrangement;
- administrative fees, marketing allowances, or other payments received for maintaining or increasing membership in the pooling arrangement; and
- an ownership interest, board position, governance role, or profit-sharing arrangement the covered service provider or a related party holds with respect to the pooling arrangement.
A covered service provider would be required to retain records sufficient to support the disclosures required by the bill for not less than three years following the later of the following: (1) the date the disclosure is provided; or (2) the termination of the contract or arrangement. Upon request by the Attorney General, a county counsel, a city attorney, or an authorized local prosecutor, a covered service provider is to make the records available for inspection. The bill’s provisions would apply to contracts or arrangements entered into, extended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2028; however, the bill encourages public agencies and covered service providers to voluntarily comply with this article before January 1, 2028.
- Stakeholder statements
SEIU California, a supporter of the bill, writes in support stating:
[…] Public entities spend billions of dollars annually on employee health benefits. They rely on insurance brokers, agents, and consultants to recommend insurance carriers, negotiate rates, and select vendors. However, these intermediaries often receive compensation from insurers and third parties that public agencies never see. It is common for the service contracts between public agencies and intermediaries to contain a general disclosure that they may receive either direct or indirect compensation that may be based on the premium charged by the insurer with little to no other details. These hidden compensation arrangements can create misaligned incentives, steering public agencies toward more expensive vendors because the compensation for the insurance broker is greater if that option is chosen. These costs are ultimately borne by taxpayers and employees.
Commissions can be as high as 50 percent of the premium for some supplemental products, which are built into the premiums that the employers and employees pay. Base commissions can be between three to six percent of the total premium for an entire health insurance plan and bonuses could be as high as $150,000 for a single employer group. In addition, they are often treated to trips and other experiences, such as going to the Super Bowl or a luxury resort. Insurance plan costs have tripled in the last 20 years, which makes added opaque forms of compensation a serious issue compounding the affordability problems for public agencies.[…]
The California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals (CAHIP) writes in opposition unless amended. They raise several concerns with bill, including that it goes beyond requirements required at the federal level, applies to a broader category of providers and services than at the federal level, places burdensome requirements that could be operationally difficult to comply with, and may discourage agents and brokers from working with public agencies. CAHIP states they welcome an opportunity to work with the author to address their concerns and writes:
[…] In its current form, SB 1244 risks creating a system in which compliance is impractical, liability is misaligned, and administrative burdens may discourage qualified agents and brokers from serving public agencies. This would not be because agents are uninterested in providing transparency, but because there is no effective way of delivering the transparency that this bill requires – which simply means that agents would be putting themselves in legal jeopardy for participating in the marketplace for governmental plans. This could ultimately limit competition,
reduce choice, and negatively impact the public entities the bill seeks to protect.[…]
The California Association of Joint Powers Authority writes that it would support the bill if amended to extend the requirements of the bill to public joint labor-management trusts (JLMTs) arguing these entities function in a manner substantially similar to JPAs. They write:
[…] many public entities including school districts, cities, and counties use the joint powers authority mechanism to effectively self-fund their healthcare in a non-profit, public entity risk pool. Public joint labor-management trusts are also commonly used to provide and administer health and welfare benefits for public employees and retirees. […]
This creates a risk of inconsistent regulatory treatment across entities performing equivalent functions and may result in uneven transparency requirements depending solely on the governance structure of the public benefit arrangement.
SUPPORT
California Federation of Labor Unions
California Federation of Teachers
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
Health Access California
Orange County Employees Association
SEIU California
SMART-Transportation Division
OPPOSITION
California Agents and Health Insurance Professionals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation: AB 2589 (Solorio, Ch. 331, Stats. 2008) required a health care service plan or a health insurer to annually disclose to the governing board of a public agency that is the subscriber of a group contract or the policyholder of a group health insurance policy specified information, including, but not limited to, any fees or commissions paid to any agent, broker, or other individual related to the public agency’s group contract or policy.
**************
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):