SB 311: Correctional facilities: women’s prisons.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2025-03-26
Current Status:
Failed
(2026-02-02: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to institute certain practices to prevent sexual violence and promote inmate and ward safety in the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, including reviewing and providing handbooks regarding sexual abuse in detention to inmates and wards. Existing law establishes 2 institutions for the punishment, treatment, supervision, custody, and care of women convicted of felonies, known as the California Institution for Women and the Central California Womens Facility.
This bill would require the department to establish a secure facility at each womens prison to house transgender women, in order to protect the security needs of biological women, as specified. The bill would also prohibit certain inmates convicted of specified sexual offenses from being housed at a womens prison.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to address sexual violence in womens correctional facilities.Existing law requires the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to institute certain practices to prevent sexual violence and promote inmate and ward safety in the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, including reviewing and providing handbooks regarding sexual abuse in detention to inmates and wards.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to address sexual violence in womens correctional facilities.
(a)The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall establish a secure facility at each womens prison to house transgender women, in order to protect the security needs of biological women at birth in sleeping and other intimate areas.
(b)The secure facility would allow the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to focus on the individual needs of the transgender women and biological women at birth populations.
(c)Any inmate convicted of an offense for which they are required to register pursuant to Section 290, except for biological women at birth, shall be ineligible for housing at a womens prison.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to address sexual violence in womens correctional facilities.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to address sexual violence in womens correctional facilities.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 2, 2026 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Apr 29, 2025 | April 29 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 1. Noes 4. Page 944.) Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 11, 2025 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 2, 2025 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 26, 2025 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 19, 2025 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 11, 2025 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 13. |
| Feb 10, 2025 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 29, 2025 | [First] hearing set for [04-30-2025]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2025 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| Bakersfield Republican Women Federated | ** Support | |
| California Baptist for Biblical Values | ** Support | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Coalition for Women Prisoners | ** Against | |
| California Family Council | ** Support | |
| California Legislative LGBTQ Caucus | ** Against | |
| Californians United for a Responsible Budget | ** Against | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | |
| Cause Californians United for Sex-Based Evidence in Policy and Law | ** Support | |
| Courage California | ** Against | |
| Critical Resistance Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Against | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Against | |
| El/La Para TransLatinas | ** Against | |
| Empowerment Dess Perkins Foundation | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Against | |
| Flying Over Walls | ** Against | |
| Fresno County District Attorneys Office | ** Support | |
| GRACE- End Child Poverty in CA | ** Against | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Against | |
| Jewish Center for Justice | ** Against | |
| Justice2jobs Coalition | ** Against | |
| Kern County Supervisor Jeff Flores | ** Support | |
| LA County Public Defenders Union, Local 148 | ** Against | |
| LA Defensa | ** Against | |
| Oasis Legal Services | ** Against | |
| Orthwein Law, P.C. | ** Against | |
| PFLAG Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| PFLAG San Jose/Peninsula | ** Against | |
| Planned Parenthood Affiliates Of California | ** Against | |
| Pride At the Pier | ** Against | |
| Rainbow Families Action Bay Area | ** Against | |
| Sacramento LGBT Community Center | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Against | |
| Several individuals | ** Against | |
| Several individuals | ** Support | |
| Smart Justice California | ** Against | |
| Stand Up Sacramento County | ** Support | |
| The Open Door Network | ** Support | |
| The Translatin@ Coalition | ** Against | |
| Transgender Advocacy Group | ** Against | |
| Transgender Law Center | ** Against | |
| Valor US | ** Against | |
| Viet Rainbow of Orange County | ** Against | |
| Women Are Real | ** Support | |
| Youth Leadership Institute | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Jesse Arreguín, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: SB 311 Hearing Date: April 29, 2025
Author: | Grove | ||
Version: | March 26, 2025 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SJ | ||
Subject: Correctional facilities: women’s prisons
HISTORY
Source: Woman II Woman
Prior Legislation: SB 1069 (Menjivar), Ch. 1012, Stats. of 2024
AB 102 (Ting), Ch. 38, Stats. of 2023
SB 132 (Wiener), Ch. 182, Stats. of 2020
SB 990 (Wiener), held in Assembly Appropriations, 2018
SB 310 (Atkins), Ch. 856, Stats. of 2017
SB 179 (Atkins), Ch. 853, Stats. of 2017
AB 633 (Ammiano), vetoed, 2010
AB 382 (Ammiano), vetoed, 2009
Support: Bakersfield Republican Women, Federated; California Baptists for Biblical Values; California Catholic Conference; California Family Council; CAUSE: Californians United for Sex-Based Evidence in Policy and Law; Empowerment Dess Perkins Foundation; Fresno County District Attorney’s Office; Kern County Supervisor Jeff Flores; Stand Up Sacramento County; The Open Door Network; Women Are Real; several individuals
Opposition: ACLU California Action; California Coalition for Women Prisoners; California Legislative LGBTQ Caucus; California Public Defenders Association; Californians United for a Responsible Budget; Courage California; Critical Resistance, Los Angeles; Disability Rights California; El/La Para Translatinas; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; Equality California; Flying Over Walls; GRACE- End Child Poverty in CA; Initiate Justice; Jewish Center for Justice; Justice2Jobs Coalition; La Defensa; LA County Public Defenders Union, Local 148; Oasis Legal Services; Orthwein Law, P.C.; PFLAG Los Angeles; PFLAG San Jose/Peninsula; Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California; Pride at the Pier; Rainbow Families Action Bay Area; Sacramento LGBT Community Center; San Francisco Public Defender; Smart Justice California; The Translatin@ Coalition; Transgender Advocacy Group; Transgender Law Center; Valor US; Viet Rainbow of Orange County; Youth Leadership Institute; several individuals
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to require the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to establish a secure facility at each women’s prison to house transgender women, and prohibit an incarcerated individual convicted of a registerable sex offense, except for biological women at birth, from being housed at a women’s prison.
Existing federal law prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. (U.S. Con., amend. VIII.)
Existing federal law, the Prison Rape Elimination Act, establishes a zero-tolerance standard for the incidence of prison rape in prisons in the United States, provides for the development and implementation of national standards for the detection, prevention, reduction, and punishment of prison rape, and mandates the review and analysis of the incidence and effects of prison rape. (34 U.S.C. § 30301 et seq.)
Existing law establishes CDCR and the state’s prisons. (Gov. Code, § 12383, subd. (a); Pen. Code, §§ 5000, 5003.)
Existing law requires CDCR to develop policies and operational practices that are designed to ensure a safe and productive institutional environment for women incarcerated in the state’s prisons. (Pen. Code, § 3430, subd. (b).)
Existing law, the Sexual Abuse in Detention Elimination Act (SADEA), provides guidance to CDCR for developing its protocols for responding to sexual abuse, requires certain standards be implemented to reduce the impact of sexual abuse on incarcerated individuals, and requires certain procedures are performed in the investigation and prosecution of sexual abuse incidents. (Pen. Code, §§ 2637-2639.)
Existing law requires that a CDCR employee, confirmed by an investigation to have sexually abused an incarcerated person, is terminated. Requires administrators to report criminal sexual abuse by staff to law enforcement authorities. (Pen. Code, § 2639, subd. (e).)
Existing law prohibits a male correctional officer from conducting a pat down search of a female incarcerated individual unless the incarcerated person presents a risk of immediate harm to herself or others or risk of escape and there is not a female correctional officer available to conduct the search. (Pen. Code, § 2644, subd. (a).)
Existing law prohibits a male correctional officer from entering into an area of the institution where female incarcerated individuals may be in a state of undress, or be in an area where they can view female incarcerated individuals in a state of undress, including, but not limited to, restrooms, shower areas, or medical treatment areas, unless an incarcerated person in the area presents a risk of immediate harm to herself or others or if there is a medical emergency in the area. Specifies that a male correctional officer cannot enter into a prohibited area if there is a female correctional officer who can resolve the situation in a safe and timely manner without his assistance. Requires staff of the opposite sex to announce their presence when entering a housing unit to prevent incidental viewing. (Pen. Code, § 2644, subd. (b).)
Existing law requires, if a male correctional officer conducts a pat down search or enters a prohibited area, the circumstances for and details of the exception to be documented within three days of the incident. Requires the documentation to be reviewed by the warden and retained by the institution for reporting purposes. (Pen. Code, § 2644, subd. (c).)
Existing law provides that any employee, officer, agent, staff, or volunteer of a detention facility, and any peace officer who engages in sexual activity with a consenting adult who is confined in a detention facility is guilty of a public offense. (Pen. Code, § 289.6, subd. (a)(2).)
Existing law establishes the independent Office of the Inspector General (OIG), provides that the Inspector General (IG) is responsible for contemporaneous oversight of internal affairs investigations and the disciplinary process of CDCR under policies to be developed by the IG. (Pen. Code, §§ 6125, 6126, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires that the IG provide contemporaneous oversight of grievances that fall within CDCR’s process for reviewing and investigating allegations of staff misconduct and other specialty grievances, examining compliance with regulations, department policy, and best practices. Requires the IG to issue annual reports on this topic. (Pen. Code, § 6126, subd. (i).)
Existing law authorizes the OIG to investigate all staff misconduct cases that involve sexual misconduct with an incarcerated person, and authorizes the OIG to monitor and investigate a complaint involving sexual misconduct with an incarcerated person. (Pen. Code, § 6133, subd. (a)(5), (6).)
Existing law requires CDCR to ask each individual entering into the custody of the department during the initial intake and classification process, and in a private setting, all of the following:
- The individual’s gender identity of female, male, or nonbinary.
- Whether the individual identifies as transgender, nonbinary, or intersex.
- The individual’s gender pronoun and honorific. (Pen. Code, § 2605, subd. (a).)
Existing law authorizes a person under the jurisdiction of CDCR to, at any time, inform designated facility staff of their gender identity. Requires designated facility staff to promptly repeat the process of offering the individual an opportunity to specify the gender pronoun and honorific most appropriate for staff to use in reference to that individual. (Pen. Code, § 2605, subd. (c).)
Existing law prohibits staff, contractors, and volunteers of the department from consistently failing to use the gender pronoun and honorific an individual has specified in all verbal and written communications with or regarding the individual that involve use of a pronoun and honorific. (Pen. Code, § 2605, subd. (d).)
Existing law provides the following definitions:
- “Gender pronoun” means a third-person singular personal pronoun, such as “he,” “she,” or “they.”
- “Honorific” means a form of respectful address typically combined with an individual’s surname. (Pen. Code, § 2605, subd. (e).)
Existing law requires that an individual incarcerated by CDCR who is transgender, nonbinary, or intersex, regardless of anatomy, to:
- Be addressed in a manner consistent with the incarcerated individual’s gender identity.
- If lawfully searched, be searched according to the search policy for their gender identity or according to the gender designation of the facility where they are housed, based on the individual’s search preference. Provides that if the incarcerated individual’s preference or gender identity cannot be determined, the search be conducted according to the gender designation of the facility where they are housed.
- Be housed at a correctional facility designated for men or women based on the individual’s preference, including, if eligible, at a residential program for individuals under the jurisdiction of CDCR.
- Have their perception of health and safety given serious consideration in any bed assignment, placement, or programming decision within the facility in which they are housed, including, but not limited to, granting single-cell status, housing the individual with another incarcerated person of their choice, or removing the individual or individuals who pose a threat from any location where they may have access to the individual who has expressed a safety concern. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (a)(1)-(4).)
Existing law requires CDCR, if an individual is not granted an alternative based on their perception of health and safety, to document the reasons for the denial and share them with the individual. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (a)(4).)
Existing law requires the Secretary of CDCR, or the secretary’s designee, if the department has management or security concerns with an incarcerated individual’s search preference or preferred housing placement, to certify in writing a specific and articulable basis why the department is unable to accommodate that search or housing preference before denying a search preference or housing the incarcerated individual in a manner contrary to the person’s preferred housing placement. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (b).)
Existing law prohibits CDCR from denying a search preference or a housing placement based on any discriminatory reason, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
- The anatomy, including, but not limited to, the genitalia or other physical characteristics, of the incarcerated person.
- The sexual orientation of the incarcerated person.
- For a denial of a housing preference, a factor present among other people incarcerated at the preferred type of facility. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (c).)
Existing law requires the incarcerated individual receive a copy of the written statement of the denial for a search preference or preferred housing placement. Requires CDCR to provide the individual with a meaningful opportunity to verbally raise any objections to that denial, and have those objections documented, within a reasonable time following the individual’s receipt of the statement. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (d).)
Existing law requires an incarcerated individual’s housing and placement to be reassessed if the person raises concerns for their health or safety at any time. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (e).)
Existing law prohibits consensual sodomy and oral copulation among incarcerated individuals. Provides that the increased scrutiny provided under SADEA applies only to nonconsensual sexual contact among incarcerated individuals and custodial sexual misconduct. (Pen. Code, §§ 2639, subd. (f), 286, subd. (e), 287, subd. (e).)
This bill requires CDCR to establish a secure facility at each women’s prison to house transgender women, in order to protect the security needs of biological women at birth in sleeping and other intimate areas.
This bill provides that the secure facility would allow the CDCR to focus on the individual needs of the transgender women and biological women at birth populations.
This bill provides that any incarcerated individual convicted of an offense for which they are required to register as a sex offender, except for biological women at birth, is ineligible for housing at a women’s prison.
COMMENTS
- Need For This Bill
According to the author:
SB 311 seeks to provide a balanced approach by establishing safe and secure housing for transgender women within existing women’s prisons. This measure ensures the protection of biological women at birth in shared spaces such as sleeping quarters and restrooms, while also creating a dedicated facility where CDCR can better address the specific needs of transgender women.
- Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA)
PREA was passed by Congress in 2003. It applies to all correctional facilities, including prisons, jails, and juvenile facilities. Among the many stated purposes for PREA are: to establish a zero-tolerance standard for the incidence of prison rape in prisons in the United States; to develop and implement national standards for the detection, prevention, reduction, and punishment of prison rape; to increase of the available data and information on the incidence of prison rape to improve the management and administration of correctional facilities; and to increase the accountability of prison officials who fail to detect, prevent, reduce, and punish prison rape. (34 U.S.C. § 30301 et seq.) The act also created the National Prison Rape Elimination Commission and charged it with developing standards for the elimination of prison rape.
PREA Standards
The PREA standards developed by the National Prison Rape Elimination Commission were issued as a final rule by the U.S. Department of Justice in 2012. (77 Fed. Reg. 37106 (Jun. 20, 2012).) Among other things, the standards require each agency and facility to: designate a PREA point person to coordinate compliance efforts; develop and document a staffing plan, taking into account a set of specified factors, that provides for adequate levels of staffing, and, where applicable, video monitoring, to protect incarcerated individuals against sexual abuse; and train staff on key topics related to preventing, detecting, and responding to sexual abuse. In addition, the standards provide requirements regarding the avenues for reporting sexual abuse, investigation of sexual abuse, and access to medical and mental health care for incarcerated individuals who are the victims of sexual abuse.
The PREA standards account in various ways for the particular vulnerabilities of incarcerated individuals who identify as LGBTI or whose appearance or manner does not conform to traditional gender expectations. (Id. at pp. 37149-37154.) The standards require training in effective and professional communication with LGBTI and gender nonconforming individuals and require the screening process to consider whether the incarcerated individual is, or is perceived to be, LGBTI or gender nonconforming. The standards also require that post-incident reviews consider whether the incident was motivated by the incarcerated individual’s LGBTI identification, status, or perceived status. In addition, the standards do not allow placement of incarcerated individuals who identify as LGBTI in dedicated facilities, units, or wings in adult prisons, jails, or community confinement facilities solely on the basis of such identification or status, unless such placement is in a dedicated facility, unit, or wing established in connection with a consent decree, legal settlement, or legal judgment for the purpose of protecting such individuals. Such placement is not allowed at all in juvenile facilities.
CDCR PREA Policy
AB 550 (Goldberg), Chapter 303, Statutes of 2005, established SADEA which required CDCR to adopt specified policies, practices, and protocols related to the placement of incarcerated individuals, physical and mental health care of victims who are incarcerated individuals, and investigation of sexual abuse.
CDCR’s PREA policy provides guidelines for the prevention, detection, response, investigation, and tracking of sexual violence, staff sexual misconduct, and sexual harassment against individuals incarcerated in CDCR facilities. (DOM §§ 54040.1-54040.22.) The policy applies to all incarcerated individuals and individuals employed by CDCR, including volunteers and independent contractors assigned to an institution, community correctional facility, conservation camp, or parole.
- The Transgender Respect, Agency, and Dignity Act
SB 132, also known as the Transgender, Respect, Agency, and Dignity Act (TRADA), was enacted in response to the violence, harassment, and discrimination faced by transgender individuals incarcerated in the state’s prisons. Among its many provisions, SB 132 requires CDCR to ask each individual their gender identity, whether the person identifies as transgender, non-binary, or intersex, and their gender pronoun and honorific during the initial intake and classification, and allows an individual to update this information with the department at any time. SB 132 also requires that a transgender, non-binary, or intersex (TNI) incarcerated individual is searched according to the search policy for their gender identity or according to the gender designation of the facility where they are housed, based on the individual’s search preference. SB 132 additionally requires that a TNI incarcerated individual is housed at a correctional facility designated for men or women based on the individual’s preference, and that their perception of health and safety is given serious consideration in any bed assignment, placement, or programming decision within the facility in which they are housed. CDCR may deny a TNI incarcerated person’s search or housing preference, if it has management or security concerns, but must provide a specific and articulable basis for the denial in writing. Finally, CDCR is prohibited from denying a search preference or a housing preference based on any discriminatory reason, including, but not limited to, the person’s anatomy or sexual orientation, and with respect to a housing preference denial, CDCR is prohibited from denying the housing preference based on a factor present among other people incarcerated at the preferred type of facility.
- OIG Report
SB 132 went into effect on January 1, 2021. Following the law’s initial implementation, the OIG conducted a review of CDCR’s policies, practices, and procedures pertaining to the requirement to house TNI individuals at prisons consistent with their self-designated gender identities. (OIG, Special Review: The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s Implementation of the Transgender, Respect, Agency, and Dignity Act (Aug. 2023), Report No. 22-01, p. 1, available at <https//www.oig.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Special-Review-No.-22-01.pdf>.) Specifically, the OIG reviewed and evaluated policies and procedures related to the transfer process and the protection of the safety and security of the incarcerated populations of the California Institute for Women (CIW) and the Central California Women’s Facility (CCWF) (Ibid.) The OIG also reviewed incidents, including sexual and physical assault allegations, involving incarcerated people who had transferred to the women’s prisons. (Ibid.) The report is limited to the first two calendar years after SB 132 went into effect.
In implementing SB 132, CDCR developed a process to transfer TNI incarcerated individuals, beginning with the completion of a Gender Identity Questionnaire (GIQ) indicating both their gender identity and desire to be housed at a prison consistent with their gender identity. (Id. at p. 5.) The GIQ serves as the source document to identify an incarcerated person’s gender identity, and once a person identifies as TNI, the person is typically relocated to one of several hub prisons that provides specialized services and programs. (Id. at pp. 5-6) Once an incarcerated person requests a transfer, the person is placed on a list to be enrolled in the Right Person, Right Prison (RPRP) course, a mandatory eight-session course developed in spring 2021 to inform prospective transferees about cultural and rule differences between men’s and women’s prisons and prepare them for transfer. (Id. at p. 6)
After completion of the RPRP course, prospective transferees undergo an in-depth review process, culminating in a transfer hearing. (Ibid.) At the hearing, the committee determines whether transferring the person would raise “management or security concerns.” (Ibid.) If so, the transfer is denied, and the incarcerated person may file a grievance using the standard grievance process. (Ibid.) If the transfer request is approved, the department generally has 180 days to move the incarcerated person to a new prison, subject to a one-time extension. (Ibid.)
All transferees to a women’s prison are initially sent to CCWF to participate in a reception process to prepare them for life in a women’s prison, before a housing decision is made. (Id. at p. 8.) A prison may refer a transferee who subsequently raises management or security concerns to an internal review board to determine whether the person will be returned to their original prison. (Ibid.)
In the first two calendar years after SB 132 went into effect, nearly 400 incarcerated individuals requested to transfer to prisons consistent with their gender identity, and only 55 of those requests had been transferred. (Id. at p. 13.) The report observed that TNI individuals at men’s prisons requested transfer to a women’s prison at a much higher rate compared to TNI individuals at women’s prisons. (Id. at p. 13.) Safety concerns were a common reason for requesting a transfer, with many transferees and prospective transferees reporting they had been victimized, threatened, or targeted. (Id. at p. 14.) The report found that incarcerated individuals waited on average over 200 days for a transfer hearing. (Id. at p. 18.) The OIG determined that CDCR’s evolving transfer process—including moving from using staff at all hubs to review transfer requests to using fewer staff in a centralized unit—contributed to delays in processing transfer requests. (Id. at pp. 13-14.)
The report found that SB 132’s broad language had made it difficult for the department to develop specific criteria to evaluate transfer requests and to maintain consistency in its decision:
The Act’s broad language prohibiting the department from denying a transfer based on a factor present among other people incarcerated at the prison where they choose to be housed, has both made it challenging for the department to develop specific criteria to evaluate transfer requests and increased the risk of inconsistent transfer decisions. For example, if a person with a history of raping women requests to transfer to a women’s prison, this language may prohibit the department from denying the person’s transfer request based solely on the prospective transferee’s history of raping women. If people at the women’s prison have been incarcerated for crimes involving rape, this may qualify under the Act as a factor present among other people at the prison and may preclude the department from using it as the sole basis to deny the transfer request. (Id. at p. 19.)
The report included the following recommendations with respect to the transfer process:
- The department should develop specific criteria for counselors to evaluate gender-based transfer requests.
- Once specific criteria are established, the department should evaluate how long a review should take with the new criteria, develop a time line for completing the review process, and communicate those expectations to counselors.
- The department should provide training to counselors on how to complete the transfer request reviews once specific criteria are established. (Id. at p. 23.)
The report acknowledged that many incarcerated people had concerns following SB 132’s implementation. Individuals already housed at CIW and CCWF expressed concerns regarding their physical safety and privacy while transferees and prospective transferees voiced concerns over individuals misrepresenting themselves as TNI. (Id. at p. 25.) The report also noted that these concerns were likely exacerbated by the perception that staff treated transferees better than the rest of the population. (Id. at p. 26.) The report additionally highlighted the tension created by SB 132 between TNI people, whose perception of health and safety must be given serious consideration when the department assigns them a bed in a prison, and the rest of the incarcerated population, who must generally accept any bed that is assigned. (Id. at p. 31.)
Regarding sexual misconduct and allegations of sexual violence, the report summarized:
Although consensual sexual acts are reportedly common between incarcerated people at both CCWF and CIW, they are prohibited by State law and are considered sexual misconduct. We found that the department properly imposed administrative discipline against transferees and nontransferees when they were caught engaging in consensual sexual acts or other sexual misconduct. In addition, we found that the department imposed administrative discipline when consensual sexual acts between transferees and nontransferees led to violence. Finally, the department properly investigated, but did not substantiate any of the allegations of sexual assault made by or against transferees. (Id. at p. 34.)
- Proposed Regulations
On February 28, 2025, CDCR issued proposed regulations to implement SB 132. The public comment period ended on April 15, 2025. The proposed regulations, which are not final, do the following:
- Adopt new and amend existing terminology related to transgender, non-binary and intersex incarcerated persons.
- Establish that each incarcerated person shall, during intake processing upon their arrival to a state prison, or at any time upon their request, be asked to participate in a GIQ.
- Establish that transgender, non-binary, and intersex incarcerated persons shall be addressed in a manner consistent with their gender identity.
- Establish that transgender, non-binary and intersex incarcerated persons shall have their perception of their health and safety given serious consideration in any bed assignment, placement, or programming decision within the facility in which they are housed.
- Establish that a transgender, non-binary, or intersex incarcerated person may be housed at a facility designated for men or women based on the incarcerated person’s preference. Approval for housing at an institution of a different gender designation shall be made by an Institution Classification Committee. Denial of such a housing request must be based upon specific management or security reasons and must be documented.
- Establish that an incarcerated person who is transgender, non-binary, or intersex may be searched according to the search policy for their gender identity or according to the gender designation of the facility where they are housed, unless the individual’s approved search preference dictates otherwise. (Cal. Reg. Notice Register, 25, No. 9-Z, p. 266)
Subdivision (b) of proposed section 3085.2 outlines the process for requesting to be housed at a prison of a different gender designation. Upon intake, the PREA Compliance Manager will review all GIQs they receive. If the GIQ requests housing at an institution of a different gender designation than which the incarcerated person is housed, the PREA Compliance Manager must interview the incarcerated person, document the interview, and forward the request for additional review and so that a comprehensive summary report can be completed. A person participating in a transfer must take a pre-transfer course prior to their transfer hearing. If the transfer is approved, the case is forwarded. If the transfer is not approved, the incarcerated person must be provided with a documentation of that decision and may file a grievance if they do not agree with the ICC’s decision. A similar process would be completed for a person making a housing transfer request at any time other than upon intake.
Subdivision (e) of proposed section 3085.2 provides, consistent with statute, that CDCR document and articulate the specific management or security reasons for the denial when denying a housing placement. CDCR is prohibited from denying a housing placement based on any discriminatory reason, including, but not limited to, any of the following: the anatomy, including, but not limited to, the genitalia or other physical characteristics, of the incarcerated person; the sexual orientation of the incarcerated person; or a factor present among other incarcerated persons housed at the preferred type of facility. The proposed regulation specifies that “a factor shall be considered a prohibited discriminatory reason only if that factor is relied upon as a categorical basis to deny the placement request.” The proposed regulation additionally requires that “a factor be considered on an individualized basis and weighed based on the totality of the circumstances, including any relevant mitigating factors supporting the housing placement request, in assessing whether there is a management or security reason for denying the request.” Finally, the proposed regulation provides that “the department may consider any individualized factor in assessing a housing placement request, including, but not limited to, criminal history, including commitment offenses; documented history of violence, including sexual violence; documented history of sexual harassment; risks posed to the incarcerated person by other incarcerated persons at the current and preferred facility; and risks posed by the incarcerated person to other incarcerated persons at the current and preferred facility.”
Subdivision (f) of proposed section 3085.2 delineates the process for returning a transfer to the previous institution gender designation when the transfer exhibits management or security concerns. The proposed regulation specifies the criteria that must be reviewed for an involuntary return transfer to a previous institution gender designation, including: behavior that is deemed a potential security and management threat to the incarcerated person, incarcerated person population, staff, or institution; new predatory behavior; the incarcerated person requires type of housing not available at the preferred facility; the incarcerated person is serving or pending adjudication for a Restricted Housing Unit term of a serious rules violation.
- CDCR Reports
CDCR maintains reports related to SB 132, including the number of individuals identifying as TNI, the number of housing transfer requests, and the number of approved transfer requests. In its most current report—which includes data through April 9, 2025—CDCR indicated that there were 2,148 incarcerated individuals identifying as TNI. (CDCR, Office of Research, Senate Bill 132 Report (Apr. 17, 2025), available at <https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/research/wp-content/uploads/sites/174/2025/04/SB132.pdf>.) In the more than four years since SB 132 was enacted, 898 TNI incarcerated individuals requested to transfer to house at a women’s prison or community facility. (Ibid.) Of those 898 requests to transfer, 45 were approved, 109 were denied, 128 people changed their mind while awaiting review, 208 requests were pending, nine individuals transferred back voluntarily, and three transferred back involuntarily. (Ibid.) During the same time period, 67 TNI incarcerated individuals requested to transfer to house at a men’s prison or community facility, four were approved for transfer, 11 were denied, eight changed their mind pending review, and four requests were pending. (Ibid.) To provide context to these numbers, the total in-custody population across the state’s prisons and camps was 89,424 as of April 16, 2025. (CDCR, Office of Research, Weekly Report of Population (Apr. 16, 2025), available at <http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/ research/wp-content/uploads/sites/174/2025/04/Tpop4_d250416.pdf>.) In other words, the entire TNI population is approximately 2.4% of the entire prison population.
- Sexual Assault Response and Prevention Working Group
Sexual harassment, misconduct, and abuse is a serious and ongoing issue in the state’s prisons. In acknowledgment of the systemic issues related to sexual harassment, misconduct, and abuse in prisons, the 2023-2024 Budget Act established “a sexual assault response and prevention working group and ambassador program” and allocated funds to CDCR as well as the Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition to support the working group in identifying best practices for whistleblower protections and trauma-informed care and support to survivors. The working group consisted of CDCR leadership and staff, correctional officers, community-based organizations led by formerly incarcerated people, representatives from the Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition, and individuals who have survived sexual assault while in custody. The working group met over a six-month period. Two reports were produced as a result of the working group: one authored by CDCR required by the Budget Act and one authored by the community-based organizations that were members of the working group.
The community report on the working group primarily focused on the women’s prisons, CIW and CCWF.[1] The report made several recommendations fitting into five categories: expedited release of survivors, culture shifting, services for survivors, the investigation and reporting process, and accountability. (Id. at p. 6.) Notably, the report observed that community-building opportunities had not been restored following the pandemic, leading to tension among groups:
One example of tension between communities within the incarcerated population was between cisgender and transgender communities. During our outreach, we heard many concerns around the implementation of SB 132, the targeting and mistreatment of transgender people, and a feeling of being unsafe across the population. We witnessed directly that the majority of people in restrictive housing are trans people, despite many detained there having no active or pending disciplinary violations. … We also heard that staff often stoke or contribute to this tension among the population, in which case we recommend that staff are investigated and held accountable. In terms of supporting and not further dividing the population, we recommend intentional conversations and mediation between cisgender and transgender communities within CIW and CCWF, with community-based facilitators and a commitment to ongoing education and conversations that produce solutions for the whole population.
Tensions within the incarcerated population can lead people to misuse of PREA policies as a tool to get housing changes or retaliate against peers. … We recommend reviewing the process for requests of housing transfers to create more confidence in the process and remove the need to misuse PREA for this purpose. (Id. at p. 26.)
- Constitutional Concerns
The Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. Under the Eighth Amendment, prison officials have a duty to provide humane conditions of confinement, including protecting the incarcerated population from violence by other incarcerated individuals and staff. (Hudson v. Palmer (1984) 468 U.S. 517, 527.) A prison official’s “deliberate indifference” to a substantial risk of serious harm to an incarcerated person violates the Eighth Amendment. (Helling v. McKinney (1993) 509 U.S. 25.) If prison officials know of a substantial risk of harm to an individual, they must take reasonable steps to reduce the risk. (Farmer v. Brennan (1994) 511 U.S. 825, 832-833 (“Having incarcerated ‘persons [with] demonstrated proclivit[ies] for antisocial criminal, and often violent, conduct’ having stripped them of virtually every means of self-protection and foreclosed their access to outside aid, the government and its officials are not free to let the state of nature take its course.”)
The rights of individuals as they relate to the person’s gender identity is an evolving area of law. In the employment context, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that discrimination on the basis of gender identity is a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. (Bostock v. Clayton County (2020) 590 U.S. 644). In so holding, the Court found that “[b]ecause discrimination on the basis of … transgender status requires an employer to intentionally treat individual employees differently because of their sex, an employer who intentionally penalizes an employee for being … transgender also violates Title VII.” (Id. at p. 645.) Last December, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in U.S. v. Skrmetti, a case challenging Tennessee’s ban on minors’ access to gender-affirming health care as a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The challenge alleges that the Tennessee law is a sex-based distinction, and as a result subject to heightened scrutiny. A decision in Skrmetti is expected later this year.
A successful equal protection claim must demonstrate that the government has engaged in a discriminatory action by treating the person or group differently than similarly situated individuals or groups without a valid justification. (San Antonio Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Rodriguez (1973) 411 U.S. 1.) In the case of a sex-based distinction, the government’s action is subject to intermediate scrutiny, requiring the government to demonstrate that the discrimination is substantially related to achieving an important governmental objective. (U.S. v. Virginia (1996) 518 U.S. 515.)
Current litigation related to SB 132
Last year, a federal court dismissed a lawsuit filed by a group of women incarcerated at CCWF. (Chandler v. Cal. Dep’t of Corr. & Rehabs. (2024) U.S. Dist. LEXIS 87164.) The plaintiffs alleged that SB 132—specifically, the approved housing transfers—violated their rights under the First, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments of the U.S. Constitution. The court dismissed the case on procedural grounds, finding that the Eleventh Amendment generally immunizes states from suit in federal court unless the state waives immunity, and the failure of the plaintiffs to bring their claims pursuant to 42 U.S. § 1983 which the court stated is “the exclusive vehicle for claims brought by state prisoners that are not within the core of habeas corpus.” (Id. at p. *27-28, *37.) The court also questioned the plaintiffs’ standing because they had not shown that the alleged harms were likely to be redressed by the court even in the face of a favorable outcome. (Id. at p. *36.) The plaintiffs were granted leave to amend their complaint against state officials. The amended complaint was filed in July 2024.
- Effect of This Bill
This bill requires CDCR to establish a secure facility at each women’s prison to house transgender women, and prohibits any incarcerated individual convicted of a registerable sex offense from being housed in a women’s prison, except for those who were biological women at birth.
This bill directly conflicts with existing law. As stated above, Penal Code section 2606 requires that a TNI individual is housed at a correctional facility based on the individual’s preference, and that their perception of health and safety is given serious consideration in any bed assignment, placement, or programming decision within the facility in which they are housed. Penal Code section 2606 further provides:
The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall not deny … a housing placement … based on any discriminatory reason, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
- The anatomy, including, but not limited to, the genitalia or other physical characteristics, of the incarcerated person.
- The sexual orientation of the incarcerated person.
- For a denial of a housing preference …, a factor present among other people incarcerated at the preferred type of facility. (Pen. Code, § 2606, subd. (c).)
This bill also conflicts with the PREA standards which do not allow the placement of incarcerated individuals who identify as LGBTI in dedicated facilities, units, or wings in adult prisons, jails, or community confinement facilities solely on the basis of such identification or status, unless such placement is in a dedicated facility, unit, or wing established in connection with a consent decree, legal settlement, or legal judgment for the purpose of protecting such individuals. (28 C.F.R. 115, § 115.42(g).)
Proponents of the bill assert that the transfer process adopted after the passage of SB 132 has led to an increase in violence and the fear of violence, as well as concerns over lack of privacy, in the women’s prisons. Some of those concerns may be addressed in the regulations that CDCR is in the process of developing. It should be noted that the bill’s requirement to house transgender women in separate housing units, and the outright ban on the housing of a transgender woman at a women’s prison on the basis of a conviction that is not also applicable to incarcerated cisgender women, raises questions about the constitutionality of this bill and whether it violates the Eighth or Fourteenth Amendments. In addition, this bill raises questions about the protection of TNI individuals housed at the men’s prisons who are vulnerable to victimization.
- Argument in Support
Woman II Woman, the bill’s sponsor writes:
SB 311 offers a compassionate and necessary approach to addressing the growing concern among incarcerated women regarding safety and privacy, especially in sleeping and intimate spaces. By requiring the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to establish a secure facility at each women’s prison to house transgender women, this bill achieves two crucial goals:
It protects the physical and psychological safety of biological women at birth who have voiced serious concerns over shared housing assignments.
It ensures that transgender women are not neglected, but rather provided housing appropriate to their unique needs, with targeted resources and care.
Importantly, SB 311 also strengthens accountability by prohibiting housing in women’s facilities for individuals—except biological women—convicted of offenses requiring registration under Section 290. This common-sense provision prioritizes trauma prevention and acknowledges the long-standing vulnerabilities of women in custody.
Our organization recognizes the humanity of all incarcerated individuals and supports policies that reflect fairness and compassion. However, those policies must also respect the specific trauma histories, safety needs, and rights of women—especially those who have already experienced violence, abuse, or exploitation.
Woman II Woman supports SB 311 a balanced and thoughtful legislative effort that honors the dignity of both biological and transgender women while maintaining clear, protective boundaries within correctional facilities.
- Argument in Opposition
The ACLU California Action writes:
CDCR has a demonstrated record of failing to protect the most vulnerable people in its custody. Transgender women housed in CDCR facilities for men face extreme physical and sexual violence, routine harassment and humiliation, and forced isolation. Researchers have consistently found that transgender women housed in facilities for men, in California and nationwide, are sexually assaulted with horrifying frequency.
This pattern of violence and abuse toward transgender people was the impetus for Senator Wiener’s SB 132 (the Transgender Respect, Agency, and Dignity Act), which was enacted in 2020. SB 132 gave incarcerated transgender people the agency to identify whether they would feel safer in a men’s or women’s facility and paved the way for people to be housed in accordance with their gender identity. SB 132 should be strengthened and fully implemented — not repealed or weakened.
CDCR is responsible for protecting everyone in its custody - regardless of their gender, regardless of the facility in which they are housed, and regardless of their conviction history. SB 311 denies housing options to transgender people based solely on their gender and conviction histories, and, as such, is discriminatory and should be rejected. By preventing a transgender woman, but not a cisgender woman, from being housed in a facility designated for women because of the crimes for which she was convicted is discrimination.
There is no evidence that discriminatory, involuntary, separate facilities for transgender women will increase safety inside prisons for any one.
-- END --
(Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition et al., California Women’s Prisons—Sexual Abuse Response and Prevention Working Group, Community Report to the Legislature (Mar. 2024) available at <https://assets.nationbuilder.com/swactionfund/pages/342/attachments/original/1709747546/CA_Women’s_Prisons_—_Sexual_Abuse_Response_and_Prevention_Working_Group.pdf?1709747546>.) ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):