SB 1060: Postadoption contact: siblings of dependent children or wards.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-27
Existing law provides that a minor may be adjudged a dependent child or a ward of the juvenile court under specified circumstances. Existing law authorizes the court to place a minor who has been removed from the custody of his or her parent or guardian in foster care, among other placements. Existing law allows, in an adoption proceeding, for continuing contact between the birth relatives and a child if a postadoption contact agreement is entered into voluntarily and is in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
Existing law requires, if parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services to take specified steps, with exceptions, to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, including the encouragement of prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact, as specified.
This bill would instead require the county placing agency, as part of the above steps, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement if specified circumstances occur. The bill would authorize the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the meeting is not required to occur if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child and notes the determination in the court order. By requiring new duties on a county placing agency relating to meetings on postadoption sibling contact agreements, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires the court, at least every 6 months, to review the status of a dependent child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption.
This bill would require the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the time of the first review hearing conducted pursuant to the above-described provision.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
This bill would also make conforming changes to related provisions.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides that a minor may be adjudged a dependent child or a ward of the juvenile court under specified circumstances. Existing law authorizes the court to place a minor who has been removed from the custody of his or her parent or guardian in foster care, among other placements. Existing law allows, in an adoption proceeding, for continuing contact between the birth relatives and a child if a postadoption contact agreement is entered into voluntarily and is in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
Existing law requires, if parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services to take specified steps, with exceptions, to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, including the encouragement of prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact, as specified.
This bill would instead require the county placing agency, as part of the above steps, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement if specified circumstances occur. The bill would authorize the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the meeting is not required to occur if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child and notes the determination in the court order. By requiring new duties on a county placing agency relating to meetings on postadoption sibling contact agreements, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires the court, at least every 6 months, to review the status of a dependent child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption.
This bill would require the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the time of the first review hearing conducted pursuant to the above-described provision.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
This bill would also make conforming changes to related provisions.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides that a minor may be adjudged a dependent child or a ward of the juvenile court under specified circumstances. Existing law authorizes the court to place a minor who has been removed from the custody of his or her parent or guardian in foster care, among other placements. Existing law allows, in an adoption proceeding, for continuing contact between the birth relatives and a child if a postadoption contact agreement is entered into voluntarily and is in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
Existing law requires, if parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services to take specified steps, with exceptions, to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, including the encouragement of prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact, as specified.
This bill would instead require the county placing agency, as part of the above steps, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement if specified circumstances occur. The bill would authorize the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the meeting is not required to occur if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child and notes the determination in the court order. By requiring new duties on a county placing agency relating to meetings on postadoption sibling contact agreements, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified. requires the court, at least every 6 months, to review the status of a dependent child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption.
This bill would require the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the time of consideration of an adoption petition. the first review hearing conducted pursuant to the above-described provision.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
This bill would also make conforming changes to related provisions.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides that a minor may be adjudged a dependent child or a ward of the juvenile court under specified circumstances. Existing law authorizes the court to place a minor who has been removed from the custody of his or her parent or guardian in foster care, among other placements. Existing law allows, in an adoption proceeding, for continuing contact between the birth relatives and a child if a postadoption contact agreement is entered into voluntarily and is in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
Existing law requires, if parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services to take specified steps, with exceptions, to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, including the encouragement of prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact, as specified.
This bill would instead require the county placing agency, as part of the above steps, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement if specified circumstances occur. The bill would authorize the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The bill would provide that the meeting is not required to occur if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child and notes the determination in the court order. By requiring new duties on a county placing agency relating to meetings on postadoption sibling contact agreements, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified.
The
This bill would require the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the time of consideration of an adoption petition.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
This bill would also make conforming changes to related provisions.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law authorizes a juvenile court, under certain conditions, to terminate the rights of a parent or parents of a child and order that the child be placed for adoption, if the child is adjudged a dependent child of the court based on a finding that the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, specified harm or abuse. Existing law provides for the creation of a child and family team, which may include family members, certain professionals, or other individuals, who are convened by the county placing agency to provide input regarding the placement of, and services to, a dependent child, as part of his or her case plan within child welfare services. Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for the dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified.
This bill would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child. The bill would require the meeting to be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, as specified, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The bill would require the participants of the meeting to decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, as specified, before the adoption is finalized. By requiring new duties of local county officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law provides that a minor may be adjudged a dependent child or a ward of the juvenile court under specified circumstances. Existing law authorizes the court to place a minor who has been removed from the custody of his or her parent or guardian in foster care, among other placements. Existing law allows, in an adoption proceeding, for continuing contact between the birth relatives and a child if a postadoption contact agreement is entered into voluntarily and is in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
Existing law requires, if parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services to take specified steps, with exceptions, to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, including the encouragement of prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact, as specified.
This bill would instead require the county placing agency, as part of the above steps, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. By requiring new duties on a county placing agency relating to meetings on postadoption sibling contact agreements, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified.
The bill would require the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the time of consideration of an adoption petition.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
This bill would also make conforming changes to related provisions.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law authorizes a juvenile court, under certain conditions, to terminate the rights of a parent or parents of a child and order that the child be placed for adoption, if the child is adjudged a dependent child of the court based on a finding that the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, specified harm or abuse. Existing law provides for the creation of a child and family team, which may include family members, certain professionals, or other individuals, who are convened by the county placing agency to provide input regarding the placement of of, and services to to, a dependent child, as part of his or her case plan within child welfare services. Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for the dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified.
This bill would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting, meeting regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child. The bill would require the meeting to be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, as specified, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The bill would require the participants of the meeting to decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, as specified, before the adoption is finalized. By requiring new duties of local county officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law authorizes a juvenile court, under certain conditions, to terminate the rights of a parent or parents of a child and order that the child be placed for adoption, if the child is adjudged a dependent child of the court based on a finding that the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, specified harm or abuse. Existing law provides for the creation of a child and family team, which may include family members, certain professionals, or other individuals, who are convened by the county placing agency to provide input regarding the placement of and services to a dependent child, as part of his or her case plan within child welfare services. Existing law authorizes the court, in an adoption proceeding for the dependent child, with the consent of the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child, to include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive contact between the child and his or her sibling, as specified.
This bill would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting, attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, as specified, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The bill would require the participants of the meeting to decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, as specified, before the adoption is finalized. By requiring new duties of local county officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a juvenile court, in the case of a minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, and where the minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, to include in its order placing the minor in a permanent placement a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would expand this provision to also apply to visiting arrangements with siblings of the minor.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that some adoptive children may benefit from either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, after being adopted. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children of an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the children and the agreements are voluntarily executed by birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and adoptive parents. Nothing in this section requires all of the listed parties to participate in the development of a postadoption contact agreement in order for the agreement to be executed.
(b)(1)Nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents, the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child from voluntarily executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact between the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
(2)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement executed under this section shall be limited to, but need not include, all of the following:
(A)Provisions for visitation between the child and a birth parent or parents and other birth relatives, including siblings, and the childs Indian tribe if the case is governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.).
(B)Provisions for future contact between a birth parent or parents or other birth relatives, including siblings, or both, and the child or an adoptive parent, or both, and in cases governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act, the childs Indian tribe.
(C)Provisions for the sharing of information about the child in the future.
(3)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement with birth relatives, including siblings, other than the childs birth parent or parents shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the birth relative.
(c)At the time an adoption decree is entered pursuant to a petition filed pursuant to Section 8714, 8714.5, 8802, 8912, or 9000, the court entering the decree may grant postadoption privileges if an agreement for those privileges has been executed, including agreements executed pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 8620. The hearing to grant the adoption petition and issue an order of adoption may be continued as necessary to permit parties who are in the process of negotiating a postadoption agreement to reach a final agreement.
(d)The child who is the subject of the adoption petition shall be considered a party to the postadoption contact agreement. The written consent to the terms and conditions of the postadoption contact agreement and any subsequent modifications of the agreement by a child who is 12 years of age or older is a necessary condition to the granting of privileges regarding visitation, contact, or sharing of information about the child, unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement, as written, is in the best interests of the child. Any child who has been found to come within Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or who is the subject of a petition for jurisdiction of the juvenile court under Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code shall be represented by an attorney for purposes of consent to the postadoption contact agreement.
(e)A postadoption contact agreement shall contain the following warnings in bold type:
(1)After the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure of an adopting parent, a birth parent, a birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to follow the terms of this agreement or a later change to this agreement.
(2)A disagreement between the parties or litigation brought to enforce or modify the agreement shall not affect the validity of the adoption and shall not serve as a basis for orders affecting the custody of the child.
(3)A court will not act on a petition to change or enforce this agreement unless the petitioner has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings to resolve the dispute.
(f)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, juvenile court dependency jurisdiction shall be terminated. Enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement shall be under the continuing jurisdiction of the court granting the petition of adoption. The court may not order compliance with the agreement absent a finding that the party seeking the enforcement participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action, and that the enforcement is in the best interests of the child. Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision regarding enforcement. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(g)The court may not award monetary damages as a result of the filing of the civil action pursuant to subdivision (e).
(h)A postadoption contact agreement may be modified or terminated only if either of the following occurs:
(1)All parties, including the child if the child is 12 years of age or older at the time of the requested termination or modification, have signed a modified postadoption contact agreement and the agreement is filed with the court that granted the petition of adoption.
(2)The court finds all of the following:
(A)The termination or modification is necessary to serve the best interests of the child.
(B)There has been a substantial change of circumstances since the original agreement was executed and approved by the court.
(C)The party seeking the termination or modification has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings prior to seeking court approval of the proposed termination or modification.
Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(i)All costs and fees of mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings shall be borne by each party, excluding the child. All costs and fees of litigation shall be borne by the party filing the action to modify or enforce the agreement when no party has been found by the court as failing to comply with an existing postadoption contact agreement. Otherwise, a party, other than the child, found by the court as failing to comply without good cause with an existing agreement shall bear all the costs and fees of litigation.
(j)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court and forms for motions to enforce, terminate, or modify postadoption contact agreements.
(k)The court shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a birth parent, adoptive parent, birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to comply with any or all of the original terms of, or subsequent modifications to, the postadoption contact agreement, except as follows:
(1)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, in an adoption involving an Indian child, the court may, upon a petition of the birth parent, birth relative, including a sibling, or an Indian tribe, order the parties to engage in family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement if the prospective adoptive parent fails to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement, after having agreed to enter into negotiations, provided that the failure of the parties to reach an agreement is not in and of itself proof of bad faith.
(2)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, if the parties fail to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement during the negotiations entered into pursuant to, and in accordance with, paragraph (1), the court may modify prior orders or issue new orders as necessary to ensure the best interest of the Indian child is met, including, but not limited to, requiring parties to engage in further family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement, initiating guardianship proceeding in lieu of adoption, or authorizing a change of adoptive placement for the child.
(l)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
SEC. 2.Section 366.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.3.(a)If a juvenile court orders a permanent plan of adoption, tribal customary adoption, adoption of a nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31, or legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26, the court shall retain jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent until the child or nonminor dependent is adopted or the legal guardianship is established, except as provided for in Section 366.29 or, on and after January 1, 2012, Section 366.32. The status of the child or nonminor dependent shall be reviewed every six months to ensure that the adoption or legal guardianship is completed as expeditiously as possible. When the adoption of the child or nonminor dependent has been granted, or in the case of a tribal customary adoption, when the tribal customary adoption order has been afforded full faith and credit and the petition for adoption has been granted, the court shall terminate its jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent. Following establishment of a legal guardianship, the court may continue jurisdiction over the child as a dependent child of the juvenile court or may terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the legal guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. If, however, a relative of the child is appointed the legal guardian of the child and the child has been placed with the relative for at least six months, the court shall, except if the relative guardian objects, or upon a finding of exceptional circumstances, terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. Following a termination of parental rights, the parent or parents shall not be a party to, or receive notice of, any subsequent proceedings regarding the child.
(b)(1)If the court has dismissed dependency jurisdiction following the establishment of a legal guardianship, or no dependency jurisdiction attached because of the granting of a legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360, and the legal guardianship is subsequently revoked or otherwise terminated, the county department of social services or welfare department shall notify the juvenile court of this fact. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 1601 of the Probate Code, the proceedings to terminate a legal guardianship that has been granted pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26 shall be held either in the juvenile court that retains jurisdiction over the guardianship as authorized by Section 366.4 or the juvenile court in the county where the guardian and child currently reside, based on the best interests of the child, unless the termination is due to the emancipation or adoption of the child. The juvenile court having jurisdiction over the guardianship shall receive notice from the court in which the petition is filed within five calendar days of the filing. Prior to the hearing on a petition to terminate legal guardianship pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall order the county department of social services or welfare department having jurisdiction or jointly with the county department where the guardian and child currently reside to prepare a report, for the courts consideration, that shall include an evaluation of whether the child could safely remain in, or be returned to, the legal guardians home, without terminating the legal guardianship, if services were provided to the child or legal guardian. If applicable, the report shall also identify recommended family maintenance or reunification services to maintain the legal guardianship and set forth a plan for providing those services. If the petition to terminate legal guardianship is granted, either juvenile court may resume dependency jurisdiction over the child, and may order the county department of social services or welfare department to develop a new permanent plan, which shall be presented to the court within 60 days of the termination. If no dependency jurisdiction has attached, the social worker shall make any investigation he or she deems necessary to determine whether the child may be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, as provided in Section 328.
(3)Unless the parental rights of the childs parent or parents have been terminated, they shall be notified that the legal guardianship has been revoked or terminated and shall be entitled to participate in the new permanency planning hearing. The court shall try to place the child in another permanent placement. At the hearing, the parents may be considered as custodians but the child shall not be returned to the parent or parents unless they prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that reunification is the best alternative for the child. The court may, if it is in the best interests of the child, order that reunification services again be provided to the parent or parents.
(c)If, following the establishment of a legal guardianship, the county welfare department becomes aware of changed circumstances that indicate adoption or, for an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, may be an appropriate plan for the child, the department shall so notify the court. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child and order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 to determine whether adoption or continued legal guardianship is the most appropriate plan for the child. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the order. If the court orders that a hearing shall be held pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services if it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment under subdivision (b) of Section 366.22.
(d)If the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent is in a placement other than the home of a legal guardian and jurisdiction has not been dismissed, the status of the child shall be reviewed at least every six months. The review of the status of a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption shall be conducted by the court. The review of the status of a child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent for whom the court has not ordered parental rights terminated and who has not been ordered placed for adoption may be conducted by the court or an appropriate local agency. The court shall conduct the review under the following circumstances:
(1)Upon the request of the childs parents or legal guardians.
(2)Upon the request of the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent.
(3)It has been 12 months since a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 or an order that the child remain in foster care pursuant to Section 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, 366.26, or subdivision (h).
(4)It has been 12 months since a review was conducted by the court.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (g), at the review held every six months pursuant to subdivision (d), the reviewing body shall inquire about the progress being made to provide a permanent home for the child, shall consider the safety of the child, and shall determine all of the following:
(1)The continuing necessity for, and appropriateness of, the placement.
(2)Identification of individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer, and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The social worker shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer to identify individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, and may ask any other child to provide that information, as appropriate. The social worker shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests.
(3)The continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the permanent plan for the child, including efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child and efforts to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(4)The extent of the agencys compliance with the child welfare services case plan in making reasonable efforts either to return the child to the safe home of the parent or to complete whatever steps are necessary to finalize the permanent placement of the child. If the reviewing body determines that a second period of reunification services is in the childs best interests, and that there is a significant likelihood of the childs return to a safe home due to changed circumstances of the parent, pursuant to subdivision (f), the specific reunification services required to effect the childs return to a safe home shall be described.
(5)Whether there should be any limitation on the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child. That limitation shall be specifically addressed in the court order and may not exceed what is necessary to protect the child. If the court specifically limits the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child, the court shall at the same time appoint a responsible adult to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child pursuant to Section 361.
(6)The adequacy of services provided to the child. The court shall consider the progress in providing the information and documents to the child, as described in Section 391. The court shall also consider the need for, and progress in providing, the assistance and services described in Section 391.
(7)The extent of progress the parents or legal guardians have made toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating placement in foster care.
(8)The likely date by which the child may be returned to, and safely maintained in, the home, placed for adoption, legal guardianship, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or, if the child is 16 years of age or older, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, in another planned permanent living arrangement.
(9)Whether the child has any siblings under the courts jurisdiction, and, if any siblings exist, all of the following:
(A)The nature of the relationship between the child and his or her siblings.
(B)The appropriateness of developing or maintaining the sibling relationships pursuant to Section 16002. At the first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(C)If the siblings are not placed together in the same home, why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts are being made to place the siblings together, or why those efforts are not appropriate.
(D)If the siblings are not placed together, all of the following:
(i)The frequency and nature of the visits between the siblings.
(ii)If there are visits between the siblings, whether the visits are supervised or unsupervised. If the visits are supervised, a discussion of the reasons why the visits are supervised, and what needs to be accomplished in order for the visits to be unsupervised.
(iii)If there are visits between the siblings, a description of the location and length of the visits.
(iv)Any plan to increase visitation between the siblings.
(E)The impact of the sibling relationships on the childs placement and planning for legal permanence.
The factors the court may consider as indicators of the nature of the childs sibling relationships include, but are not limited to, whether the siblings were raised together in the same home, whether the siblings have shared significant common experiences or have existing close and strong bonds, whether either sibling expresses a desire to visit or live with his or her sibling, as applicable, and whether ongoing contact is in the childs best emotional interests.
(10)For a child who is 14 years of age or older, and, effective January 1, 2012, for a nonminor dependent, the services needed to assist the child or nonminor dependent to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
The reviewing body shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
Each licensed foster family agency shall submit reports for each child in its care, custody, and control to the court concerning the continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the childs permanent plan, the extent of compliance with the case plan, and the type and adequacy of services provided to the child.
(f)Unless their parental rights have been permanently terminated, the parent or parents of the child are entitled to receive notice of, and participate in, those hearings. It shall be presumed that continued care is in the best interests of the child, unless the parent or parents prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that further efforts at reunification are the best alternative for the child. In those cases, the court may order that further reunification services to return the child to a safe home environment be provided to the parent or parents up to a period of six months, and family maintenance services, as needed for an additional six months in order to return the child to a safe home environment. On and after January 1, 2012, this subdivision shall not apply to the parents of a nonminor dependent.
(g)At the review conducted by the court and held at least every six months, regarding a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child for whom parental rights are not being terminated and a tribal customary adoption is being considered, the county welfare department shall prepare and present to the court a report describing the following:
(1)The childs present placement.
(2)The childs current physical, mental, emotional, and educational status.
(3)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or guardian, identification of individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The agency shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older to identify any individuals who are important to him or her, consistent with the childs best interest, and may ask any child who is younger than 10 years of age to provide that information as appropriate. The agency shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child.
(4)Whether the child has been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents.
(5)Whether an adoptive placement agreement has been signed and filed.
(6)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents, the efforts made to identify an appropriate prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(7)Whether the final adoption order should include provisions for postadoptive sibling contact pursuant to Section 366.29.
(8)The progress of the search for an adoptive placement if one has not been identified.
(9)Any impediments to the adoption or the adoptive placement.
(10)The anticipated date by which the child will be adopted or placed in an adoptive home.
(11)The anticipated date by which an adoptive placement agreement will be signed.
(12)Recommendations for court orders that will assist in the placement of the child for adoption or in the finalization of the adoption.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
The court shall make appropriate orders to protect the stability of the child and to facilitate and expedite the permanent placement and adoption of the child.
(h)(1)At the review held pursuant to subdivision (d) for a child in foster care, the court shall consider all permanency planning options for the child including whether the child should be returned to the home of the parent, placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or appointed a legal guardian, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, if compelling reasons exist for finding that none of the foregoing options are in the best interest of the child and the child is 16 years of age or older, whether the child should be placed in another planned permanent living arrangement. The court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26, unless it determines by clear and convincing evidence that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is being returned to the home of the parent, the child is not a proper subject for adoption, or no one is willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. If the county adoption agency, or the department when it is acting as an adoption agency, has determined it is unlikely that the child will be adopted or one of the conditions described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 366.26 applies, that fact shall constitute a compelling reason for purposes of this subdivision. Only upon that determination may the court order that the child remain in foster care, without holding a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26.
(2)When the child is 16 years of age or older and in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the child about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the child.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the child to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed for tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(3)When the child is 16 years of age or older and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the social study prepared for the hearing shall include a description of all of the following:
(A)The intensive and ongoing efforts to return the child to the home of the parent, place the child for adoption, or establish a legal guardianship, as appropriate.
(B)The steps taken to do both of the following:
(i)Ensure that the childs care provider is following the reasonable and prudent parent standard.
(ii)Determine whether the child has regular, ongoing opportunities to engage in age or developmentally appropriate activities, including consulting with the child about opportunities for the child to participate in those activities.
(4)When the child is under 16 years of age and has a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, any barriers to achieving the permanent plan and the efforts made by the agency address those barriers.
(i)If, as authorized by subdivision (h), the court orders a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment as provided for in subdivision (i) of Section 366.21 or subdivision (b) of Section 366.22. A hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the 12-month review at which it is ordered, and at that hearing the court shall determine whether adoption, tribal customary adoption, legal guardianship, placement with a fit and willing relative, or, for a child 16 years of age or older, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. At the request of the nonminor dependent who has an established relationship with an adult determined to be the nonminor dependents permanent connection, the court may order adoption of the nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31.
(j)The reviews conducted pursuant to subdivision (a) or (d) may be conducted earlier than every six months if the court determines that an earlier review is in the best interests of the child or as court rules prescribe.
SEC. 3.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 4.Section 16002 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:16002.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to maintain the continuity of the family unit, and ensure the preservation and strengthening of the childs family ties by ensuring that when siblings have been removed from their home, either as a group on one occurrence or individually on separate occurrences, the siblings will be placed in foster care together, unless it has been determined that placement together is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. The Legislature recognizes that in order to ensure the placement of a sibling group in the same foster care placement, placement resources need to be expanded.
(2)It is also the intent of the Legislature to preserve and strengthen a childs sibling relationship so that when a child has been removed from his or her home and he or she has a sibling or siblings who remain in the custody of a mutual parent subject to the courts jurisdiction, the court has the authority to develop a visitation plan for the siblings, unless it has been determined that visitation is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling.
(b)The responsible local agency shall make a diligent effort in all out-of-home placements of dependent children and wards in foster care, including those with relatives, to place siblings together in the same placement, and to develop and maintain sibling relationships. If siblings are not placed together in the same home, the social worker or probation officer shall explain why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts he or she is making to place the siblings together or why making those efforts would be contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings. When placement of siblings together in the same home is not possible, a diligent effort shall be made, and a case plan prepared, to provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is achieved, or, if parental rights are terminated, as part of developing the permanent plan for the child. If the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and interaction shall be suspended.
(c)When there has been a judicial suspension of sibling interaction, the reasons for the suspension shall be reviewed at each periodic review hearing pursuant to Section 366 or 727.3. In order for the suspension to continue, the court shall make a renewed finding that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of either child. When the court determines that sibling interaction can be safely resumed, that determination shall be noted in the court order and the case plan shall be revised to provide for sibling interaction.
(d)If the case plan for the child has provisions for sibling interaction, the child, or his or her parent or legal guardian, shall have the right to comment on those provisions. If a person wishes to assert a sibling relationship with a dependent child or ward, he or she may file a petition in the juvenile court having jurisdiction over the dependent child pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 388 or the ward in foster care pursuant to Section 778.
(e)If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1)Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2)Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3)(A)To the extent practicable, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption. The county placing agency may comply with the requirements of this paragraph by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
(B)The county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code in either of the following circumstances:
(i)The county placing agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child.
(ii)The child requests that a meeting shall not occur.
(C)The child may petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. If the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
(D)Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described in this paragraph.
(E)This paragraph shall not require attendance by a child, sibling, or other party at a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code if the child, sibling, or other party cannot be located or does not wish to attend the meeting. This paragraph shall not prohibit a county placing agency from convening a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
(f)Information regarding sibling interaction, contact, or visitation that has been authorized or ordered by the court shall be provided to the foster parent, relative caretaker, or legal guardian of the child as soon as possible after the court order is made, in order to facilitate the interaction, contact, or visitation.
(g)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
(h)The court documentation on sibling placements required under this section shall not require the modification of existing court order forms until the Child Welfare Services/Case Management System (CWS/CMS) is implemented on a statewide basis.
SEC. 5.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that some adoptive children may benefit from either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, after being adopted. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children of an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the children and the agreements are voluntarily executed by birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and adoptive parents. Nothing in this section requires all of the listed parties to participate in the development of a postadoption contact agreement in order for the agreement to be executed.
(b)(1)Nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents, the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child from voluntarily executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact between the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
(2)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement executed under this section shall be limited to, but need not include, all of the following:
(A)Provisions for visitation between the child and a birth parent or parents and other birth relatives, including siblings, and the childs Indian tribe if the case is governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.).
(B)Provisions for future contact between a birth parent or parents or other birth relatives, including siblings, or both, and the child or an adoptive parent, or both, and in cases governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act, the childs Indian tribe.
(C)Provisions for the sharing of information about the child in the future.
(3)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement with birth relatives, including siblings, other than the childs birth parent or parents shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the birth relative.
(c)At the time an adoption decree is entered pursuant to a petition filed pursuant to Section 8714, 8714.5, 8802, 8912, or 9000, the court entering the decree may grant postadoption privileges if an agreement for those privileges has been executed, including agreements executed pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 8620. The hearing to grant the adoption petition and issue an order of adoption may be continued as necessary to permit parties who are in the process of negotiating a postadoption agreement to reach a final agreement.
(d)The child who is the subject of the adoption petition shall be considered a party to the postadoption contact agreement. The written consent to the terms and conditions of the postadoption contact agreement and any subsequent modifications of the agreement by a child who is 12 years of age or older is a necessary condition to the granting of privileges regarding visitation, contact, or sharing of information about the child, unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement, as written, is in the best interests of the child. Any child who has been found to come within Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or who is the subject of a petition for jurisdiction of the juvenile court under Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code shall be represented by an attorney for purposes of consent to the postadoption contact agreement.
(e)A postadoption contact agreement shall contain the following warnings in bold type:
(1)After the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure of an adopting parent, a birth parent, a birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to follow the terms of this agreement or a later change to this agreement.
(2)A disagreement between the parties or litigation brought to enforce or modify the agreement shall not affect the validity of the adoption and shall not serve as a basis for orders affecting the custody of the child.
(3)A court will not act on a petition to change or enforce this agreement unless the petitioner has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings to resolve the dispute.
(f)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, juvenile court dependency jurisdiction shall be terminated. Enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement shall be under the continuing jurisdiction of the court granting the petition of adoption. The court may not order compliance with the agreement absent a finding that the party seeking the enforcement participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action, and that the enforcement is in the best interests of the child. Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision regarding enforcement. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(g)The court may not award monetary damages as a result of the filing of the civil action pursuant to subdivision (e).
(h)A postadoption contact agreement may be modified or terminated only if either of the following occurs:
(1)All parties, including the child if the child is 12 years of age or older at the time of the requested termination or modification, have signed a modified postadoption contact agreement and the agreement is filed with the court that granted the petition of adoption.
(2)The court finds all of the following:
(A)The termination or modification is necessary to serve the best interests of the child.
(B)There has been a substantial change of circumstances since the original agreement was executed and approved by the court.
(C)The party seeking the termination or modification has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings prior to seeking court approval of the proposed termination or modification.
Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(i)All costs and fees of mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings shall be borne by each party, excluding the child. All costs and fees of litigation shall be borne by the party filing the action to modify or enforce the agreement when no party has been found by the court as failing to comply with an existing postadoption contact agreement. Otherwise, a party, other than the child, found by the court as failing to comply without good cause with an existing agreement shall bear all the costs and fees of litigation.
(j)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court and forms for motions to enforce, terminate, or modify postadoption contact agreements.
(k)The court shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a birth parent, adoptive parent, birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to comply with any or all of the original terms of, or subsequent modifications to, the postadoption contact agreement, except as follows:
(1)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, in an adoption involving an Indian child, the court may, upon a petition of the birth parent, birth relative, including a sibling, or an Indian tribe, order the parties to engage in family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement if the prospective adoptive parent fails to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement, after having agreed to enter into negotiations, provided that the failure of the parties to reach an agreement is not in and of itself proof of bad faith.
(2)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, if the parties fail to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement during the negotiations entered into pursuant to, and in accordance with, paragraph (1), the court may modify prior orders or issue new orders as necessary to ensure the best interest of the Indian child is met, including, but not limited to, requiring parties to engage in further family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement, initiating guardianship proceeding in lieu of adoption, or authorizing a change of adoptive placement for the child.
(l)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
SEC. 2.Section 366.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.3.(a)If a juvenile court orders a permanent plan of adoption, tribal customary adoption, adoption of a nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31, or legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26, the court shall retain jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent until the child or nonminor dependent is adopted or the legal guardianship is established, except as provided for in Section 366.29 or, on and after January 1, 2012, Section 366.32. The status of the child or nonminor dependent shall be reviewed every six months to ensure that the adoption or legal guardianship is completed as expeditiously as possible. When the adoption of the child or nonminor dependent has been granted, or in the case of a tribal customary adoption, when the tribal customary adoption order has been afforded full faith and credit and the petition for adoption has been granted, the court shall terminate its jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent. Following establishment of a legal guardianship, the court may continue jurisdiction over the child as a dependent child of the juvenile court or may terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the legal guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. If, however, a relative of the child is appointed the legal guardian of the child and the child has been placed with the relative for at least six months, the court shall, except if the relative guardian objects, or upon a finding of exceptional circumstances, terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. Following a termination of parental rights, the parent or parents shall not be a party to, or receive notice of, any subsequent proceedings regarding the child.
(b)(1)If the court has dismissed dependency jurisdiction following the establishment of a legal guardianship, or no dependency jurisdiction attached because of the granting of a legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360, and the legal guardianship is subsequently revoked or otherwise terminated, the county department of social services or welfare department shall notify the juvenile court of this fact. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 1601 of the Probate Code, the proceedings to terminate a legal guardianship that has been granted pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26 shall be held either in the juvenile court that retains jurisdiction over the guardianship as authorized by Section 366.4 or the juvenile court in the county where the guardian and child currently reside, based on the best interests of the child, unless the termination is due to the emancipation or adoption of the child. The juvenile court having jurisdiction over the guardianship shall receive notice from the court in which the petition is filed within five calendar days of the filing. Prior to the hearing on a petition to terminate legal guardianship pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall order the county department of social services or welfare department having jurisdiction or jointly with the county department where the guardian and child currently reside to prepare a report, for the courts consideration, that shall include an evaluation of whether the child could safely remain in, or be returned to, the legal guardians home, without terminating the legal guardianship, if services were provided to the child or legal guardian. If applicable, the report shall also identify recommended family maintenance or reunification services to maintain the legal guardianship and set forth a plan for providing those services. If the petition to terminate legal guardianship is granted, either juvenile court may resume dependency jurisdiction over the child, and may order the county department of social services or welfare department to develop a new permanent plan, which shall be presented to the court within 60 days of the termination. If no dependency jurisdiction has attached, the social worker shall make any investigation he or she deems necessary to determine whether the child may be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, as provided in Section 328.
(3)Unless the parental rights of the childs parent or parents have been terminated, they shall be notified that the legal guardianship has been revoked or terminated and shall be entitled to participate in the new permanency planning hearing. The court shall try to place the child in another permanent placement. At the hearing, the parents may be considered as custodians but the child shall not be returned to the parent or parents unless they prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that reunification is the best alternative for the child. The court may, if it is in the best interests of the child, order that reunification services again be provided to the parent or parents.
(c)If, following the establishment of a legal guardianship, the county welfare department becomes aware of changed circumstances that indicate adoption or, for an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, may be an appropriate plan for the child, the department shall so notify the court. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child and order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 to determine whether adoption or continued legal guardianship is the most appropriate plan for the child. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the order. If the court orders that a hearing shall be held pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services if it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment under subdivision (b) of Section 366.22.
(d)If the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent is in a placement other than the home of a legal guardian and jurisdiction has not been dismissed, the status of the child shall be reviewed at least every six months. The review of the status of a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption shall be conducted by the court. The review of the status of a child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent for whom the court has not ordered parental rights terminated and who has not been ordered placed for adoption may be conducted by the court or an appropriate local agency. The court shall conduct the review under the following circumstances:
(1)Upon the request of the childs parents or legal guardians.
(2)Upon the request of the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent.
(3)It has been 12 months since a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 or an order that the child remain in foster care pursuant to Section 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, 366.26, or subdivision (h).
(4)It has been 12 months since a review was conducted by the court.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (g), at the review held every six months pursuant to subdivision (d), the reviewing body shall inquire about the progress being made to provide a permanent home for the child, shall consider the safety of the child, and shall determine all of the following:
(1)The continuing necessity for, and appropriateness of, the placement.
(2)Identification of individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer, and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The social worker shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer to identify individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, and may ask any other child to provide that information, as appropriate. The social worker shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests.
(3)The continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the permanent plan for the child, including efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child and efforts to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(4)The extent of the agencys compliance with the child welfare services case plan in making reasonable efforts either to return the child to the safe home of the parent or to complete whatever steps are necessary to finalize the permanent placement of the child. If the reviewing body determines that a second period of reunification services is in the childs best interests, and that there is a significant likelihood of the childs return to a safe home due to changed circumstances of the parent, pursuant to subdivision (f), the specific reunification services required to effect the childs return to a safe home shall be described.
(5)Whether there should be any limitation on the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child. That limitation shall be specifically addressed in the court order and may not exceed what is necessary to protect the child. If the court specifically limits the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child, the court shall at the same time appoint a responsible adult to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child pursuant to Section 361.
(6)The adequacy of services provided to the child. The court shall consider the progress in providing the information and documents to the child, as described in Section 391. The court shall also consider the need for, and progress in providing, the assistance and services described in Section 391.
(7)The extent of progress the parents or legal guardians have made toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating placement in foster care.
(8)The likely date by which the child may be returned to, and safely maintained in, the home, placed for adoption, legal guardianship, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or, if the child is 16 years of age or older, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, in another planned permanent living arrangement.
(9)Whether the child has any siblings under the courts jurisdiction, and, if any siblings exist, all of the following:
(A)The nature of the relationship between the child and his or her siblings.
(B)The appropriateness of developing or maintaining the sibling relationships pursuant to Section 16002. At the first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(C)If the siblings are not placed together in the same home, why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts are being made to place the siblings together, or why those efforts are not appropriate.
(D)If the siblings are not placed together, all of the following:
(i)The frequency and nature of the visits between the siblings.
(ii)If there are visits between the siblings, whether the visits are supervised or unsupervised. If the visits are supervised, a discussion of the reasons why the visits are supervised, and what needs to be accomplished in order for the visits to be unsupervised.
(iii)If there are visits between the siblings, a description of the location and length of the visits.
(iv)Any plan to increase visitation between the siblings.
(E)The impact of the sibling relationships on the childs placement and planning for legal permanence.
The factors the court may consider as indicators of the nature of the childs sibling relationships include, but are not limited to, whether the siblings were raised together in the same home, whether the siblings have shared significant common experiences or have existing close and strong bonds, whether either sibling expresses a desire to visit or live with his or her sibling, as applicable, and whether ongoing contact is in the childs best emotional interests.
(10)For a child who is 14 years of age or older, and, effective January 1, 2012, for a nonminor dependent, the services needed to assist the child or nonminor dependent to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
The reviewing body shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
Each licensed foster family agency shall submit reports for each child in its care, custody, and control to the court concerning the continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the childs permanent plan, the extent of compliance with the case plan, and the type and adequacy of services provided to the child.
(f)Unless their parental rights have been permanently terminated, the parent or parents of the child are entitled to receive notice of, and participate in, those hearings. It shall be presumed that continued care is in the best interests of the child, unless the parent or parents prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that further efforts at reunification are the best alternative for the child. In those cases, the court may order that further reunification services to return the child to a safe home environment be provided to the parent or parents up to a period of six months, and family maintenance services, as needed for an additional six months in order to return the child to a safe home environment. On and after January 1, 2012, this subdivision shall not apply to the parents of a nonminor dependent.
(g)At the review conducted by the court and held at least every six months, regarding a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child for whom parental rights are not being terminated and a tribal customary adoption is being considered, the county welfare department shall prepare and present to the court a report describing the following:
(1)The childs present placement.
(2)The childs current physical, mental, emotional, and educational status.
(3)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or guardian, identification of individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The agency shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older to identify any individuals who are important to him or her, consistent with the childs best interest, and may ask any child who is younger than 10 years of age to provide that information as appropriate. The agency shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child.
(4)Whether the child has been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents.
(5)Whether an adoptive placement agreement has been signed and filed.
(6)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents, the efforts made to identify an appropriate prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(7)Whether the final adoption order should include provisions for postadoptive sibling contact pursuant to Section 366.29.
(8)The progress of the search for an adoptive placement if one has not been identified.
(9)Any impediments to the adoption or the adoptive placement.
(10)The anticipated date by which the child will be adopted or placed in an adoptive home.
(11)The anticipated date by which an adoptive placement agreement will be signed.
(12)Recommendations for court orders that will assist in the placement of the child for adoption or in the finalization of the adoption.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
The court shall make appropriate orders to protect the stability of the child and to facilitate and expedite the permanent placement and adoption of the child.
(h)(1)At the review held pursuant to subdivision (d) for a child in foster care, the court shall consider all permanency planning options for the child including whether the child should be returned to the home of the parent, placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or appointed a legal guardian, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, if compelling reasons exist for finding that none of the foregoing options are in the best interest of the child and the child is 16 years of age or older, whether the child should be placed in another planned permanent living arrangement. The court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26, unless it determines by clear and convincing evidence that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is being returned to the home of the parent, the child is not a proper subject for adoption, or no one is willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. If the county adoption agency, or the department when it is acting as an adoption agency, has determined it is unlikely that the child will be adopted or one of the conditions described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 366.26 applies, that fact shall constitute a compelling reason for purposes of this subdivision. Only upon that determination may the court order that the child remain in foster care, without holding a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26.
(2)When the child is 16 years of age or older and in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the child about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the child.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the child to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed for tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(3)When the child is 16 years of age or older and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the social study prepared for the hearing shall include a description of all of the following:
(A)The intensive and ongoing efforts to return the child to the home of the parent, place the child for adoption, or establish a legal guardianship, as appropriate.
(B)The steps taken to do both of the following:
(i)Ensure that the childs care provider is following the reasonable and prudent parent standard.
(ii)Determine whether the child has regular, ongoing opportunities to engage in age or developmentally appropriate activities, including consulting with the child about opportunities for the child to participate in those activities.
(4)When the child is under 16 years of age and has a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, any barriers to achieving the permanent plan and the efforts made by the agency address those barriers.
(i)If, as authorized by subdivision (h), the court orders a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment as provided for in subdivision (i) of Section 366.21 or subdivision (b) of Section 366.22. A hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the 12-month review at which it is ordered, and at that hearing the court shall determine whether adoption, tribal customary adoption, legal guardianship, placement with a fit and willing relative, or, for a child 16 years of age or older, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. At the request of the nonminor dependent who has an established relationship with an adult determined to be the nonminor dependents permanent connection, the court may order adoption of the nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31.
(j)The reviews conducted pursuant to subdivision (a) or (d) may be conducted earlier than every six months if the court determines that an earlier review is in the best interests of the child or as court rules prescribe.
SEC. 3.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 4.Section 16002 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:16002.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to maintain the continuity of the family unit, and ensure the preservation and strengthening of the childs family ties by ensuring that when siblings have been removed from their home, either as a group on one occurrence or individually on separate occurrences, the siblings will be placed in foster care together, unless it has been determined that placement together is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. The Legislature recognizes that in order to ensure the placement of a sibling group in the same foster care placement, placement resources need to be expanded.
(2)It is also the intent of the Legislature to preserve and strengthen a childs sibling relationship so that when a child has been removed from his or her home and he or she has a sibling or siblings who remain in the custody of a mutual parent subject to the courts jurisdiction, the court has the authority to develop a visitation plan for the siblings, unless it has been determined that visitation is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling.
(b)The responsible local agency shall make a diligent effort in all out-of-home placements of dependent children and wards in foster care, including those with relatives, to place siblings together in the same placement, and to develop and maintain sibling relationships. If siblings are not placed together in the same home, the social worker or probation officer shall explain why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts he or she is making to place the siblings together or why making those efforts would be contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings. When placement of siblings together in the same home is not possible, a diligent effort shall be made, and a case plan prepared, to provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is achieved, or, if parental rights are terminated, as part of developing the permanent plan for the child. If the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and interaction shall be suspended.
(c)When there has been a judicial suspension of sibling interaction, the reasons for the suspension shall be reviewed at each periodic review hearing pursuant to Section 366 or 727.3. In order for the suspension to continue, the court shall make a renewed finding that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of either child. When the court determines that sibling interaction can be safely resumed, that determination shall be noted in the court order and the case plan shall be revised to provide for sibling interaction.
(d)If the case plan for the child has provisions for sibling interaction, the child, or his or her parent or legal guardian, shall have the right to comment on those provisions. If a person wishes to assert a sibling relationship with a dependent child or ward, he or she may file a petition in the juvenile court having jurisdiction over the dependent child pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 388 or the ward in foster care pursuant to Section 778.
(e)If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1)Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2)Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3)(A)To the extent practicable, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption. The county placing agency may comply with the requirements of this paragraph by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
(B)The county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code in either of the following circumstances:
(i)The county placing agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child.
(ii)The child requests that a meeting shall not occur.
(C)The child may petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. If the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
(D)Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described in this paragraph.
(E)This paragraph shall not require attendance by a child, sibling, or other party at a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code if the child, sibling, or other party cannot be located or does not wish to attend the meeting. This paragraph shall not prohibit a county placing agency from convening a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
(f)Information regarding sibling interaction, contact, or visitation that has been authorized or ordered by the court shall be provided to the foster parent, relative caretaker, or legal guardian of the child as soon as possible after the court order is made, in order to facilitate the interaction, contact, or visitation.
(g)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
(h)The court documentation on sibling placements required under this section shall not require the modification of existing court order forms until the Child Welfare Services/Case Management System (CWS/CMS) is implemented on a statewide basis.
SEC. 5.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that some adoptive children may benefit from either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, after being adopted. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children of an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the children and the agreements are voluntarily executed by birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and adoptive parents. Nothing in this section requires all of the listed parties to participate in the development of a postadoption contact agreement in order for the agreement to be executed.
(b)(1)Nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents, the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child from voluntarily executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact between the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
(2)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement executed under this section shall be limited to, but need not include, all of the following:
(A)Provisions for visitation between the child and a birth parent or parents and other birth relatives, including siblings, and the childs Indian tribe if the case is governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.).
(B)Provisions for future contact between a birth parent or parents or other birth relatives, including siblings, or both, and the child or an adoptive parent, or both, and in cases governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act, the childs Indian tribe.
(C)Provisions for the sharing of information about the child in the future.
(3)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement with birth relatives, including siblings, other than the childs birth parent or parents shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the birth relative.
(c)At the time an adoption decree is entered pursuant to a petition filed pursuant to Section 8714, 8714.5, 8802, 8912, or 9000, the court entering the decree may grant postadoption privileges if an agreement for those privileges has been executed, including agreements executed pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 8620. The hearing to grant the adoption petition and issue an order of adoption may be continued as necessary to permit parties who are in the process of negotiating a postadoption agreement to reach a final agreement.
(d)The child who is the subject of the adoption petition shall be considered a party to the postadoption contact agreement. The written consent to the terms and conditions of the postadoption contact agreement and any subsequent modifications of the agreement by a child who is 12 years of age or older is a necessary condition to the granting of privileges regarding visitation, contact, or sharing of information about the child, unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement, as written, is in the best interests of the child. Any child who has been found to come within Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or who is the subject of a petition for jurisdiction of the juvenile court under Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code shall be represented by an attorney for purposes of consent to the postadoption contact agreement.
(e)A postadoption contact agreement shall contain the following warnings in bold type:
(1)After the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure of an adopting parent, a birth parent, a birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to follow the terms of this agreement or a later change to this agreement.
(2)A disagreement between the parties or litigation brought to enforce or modify the agreement shall not affect the validity of the adoption and shall not serve as a basis for orders affecting the custody of the child.
(3)A court will not act on a petition to change or enforce this agreement unless the petitioner has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings to resolve the dispute.
(f)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, juvenile court dependency jurisdiction shall be terminated. Enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement shall be under the continuing jurisdiction of the court granting the petition of adoption. The court may not order compliance with the agreement absent a finding that the party seeking the enforcement participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action, and that the enforcement is in the best interests of the child. Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision regarding enforcement. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(g)The court may not award monetary damages as a result of the filing of the civil action pursuant to subdivision (e).
(h)A postadoption contact agreement may be modified or terminated only if either of the following occurs:
(1)All parties, including the child if the child is 12 years of age or older at the time of the requested termination or modification, have signed a modified postadoption contact agreement and the agreement is filed with the court that granted the petition of adoption.
(2)The court finds all of the following:
(A)The termination or modification is necessary to serve the best interests of the child.
(B)There has been a substantial change of circumstances since the original agreement was executed and approved by the court.
(C)The party seeking the termination or modification has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings prior to seeking court approval of the proposed termination or modification.
Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(i)All costs and fees of mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings shall be borne by each party, excluding the child. All costs and fees of litigation shall be borne by the party filing the action to modify or enforce the agreement when no party has been found by the court as failing to comply with an existing postadoption contact agreement. Otherwise, a party, other than the child, found by the court as failing to comply without good cause with an existing agreement shall bear all the costs and fees of litigation.
(j)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court and forms for motions to enforce, terminate, or modify postadoption contact agreements.
(k)The court shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a birth parent, adoptive parent, birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to comply with any or all of the original terms of, or subsequent modifications to, the postadoption contact agreement, except as follows:
(1)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, in an adoption involving an Indian child, the court may, upon a petition of the birth parent, birth relative, including a sibling, or an Indian tribe, order the parties to engage in family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement if the prospective adoptive parent fails to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement, after having agreed to enter into negotiations, provided that the failure of the parties to reach an agreement is not in and of itself proof of bad faith.
(2)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, if the parties fail to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement during the negotiations entered into pursuant to, and in accordance with, paragraph (1), the court may modify prior orders or issue new orders as necessary to ensure the best interest of the Indian child is met, including, but not limited to, requiring parties to engage in further family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement, initiating guardianship proceeding in lieu of adoption, or authorizing a change of adoptive placement for the child.
(l)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
SEC. 2.Section 366.29 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.29.(a)When a court, pursuant to Section 366.26, orders that a dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoption sibling contact. With the consent of the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoption sibling contact. In no event shall the continuing validity of the adoption be contingent upon the postadoption contact, nor shall the ability of the adoptive parent or parents and the child to change residence within or outside the state be impaired by the order for contact.
(b)At the time of consideration of an adoption petition, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(c)
If, following entry of an order for sibling contact pursuant to subdivision (a), it is determined by the adoptive parent or parents that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child, the adoptive parent or parents may terminate the sibling contact, provided that the adoptive parent or parents shall submit written notification to the court within 10 days after terminating the contact, which notification shall specify to the court the reasons why the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child would be threatened by continued sibling contact.
(d)
Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, the jurisdiction of the juvenile court with respect to the dependency proceedings of that child shall be terminated. Nonetheless, the court granting the petition of adoption shall maintain jurisdiction over the child for enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement. The court may only order compliance with the postadoption contact agreement upon a finding of both of the following:
(1)The party seeking the enforcement participated, in good faith, in mediation or other appropriate alternative dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action.
(2)The enforcement is in the best interest of the child.
SEC. 2.Section 366.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.3.(a)If a juvenile court orders a permanent plan of adoption, tribal customary adoption, adoption of a nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31, or legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26, the court shall retain jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent until the child or nonminor dependent is adopted or the legal guardianship is established, except as provided for in Section 366.29 or, on and after January 1, 2012, Section 366.32. The status of the child or nonminor dependent shall be reviewed every six months to ensure that the adoption or legal guardianship is completed as expeditiously as possible. When the adoption of the child or nonminor dependent has been granted, or in the case of a tribal customary adoption, when the tribal customary adoption order has been afforded full faith and credit and the petition for adoption has been granted, the court shall terminate its jurisdiction over the child or nonminor dependent. Following establishment of a legal guardianship, the court may continue jurisdiction over the child as a dependent child of the juvenile court or may terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the legal guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. If, however, a relative of the child is appointed the legal guardian of the child and the child has been placed with the relative for at least six months, the court shall, except if the relative guardian objects, or upon a finding of exceptional circumstances, terminate its dependency jurisdiction and retain jurisdiction over the child as a ward of the guardianship, as authorized by Section 366.4. Following a termination of parental rights, the parent or parents shall not be a party to, or receive notice of, any subsequent proceedings regarding the child.
(b)(1)If the court has dismissed dependency jurisdiction following the establishment of a legal guardianship, or no dependency jurisdiction attached because of the granting of a legal guardianship pursuant to Section 360, and the legal guardianship is subsequently revoked or otherwise terminated, the county department of social services or welfare department shall notify the juvenile court of this fact. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 1601 of the Probate Code, the proceedings to terminate a legal guardianship that has been granted pursuant to Section 360 or 366.26 shall be held either in the juvenile court that retains jurisdiction over the guardianship as authorized by Section 366.4 or the juvenile court in the county where the guardian and child currently reside, based on the best interests of the child, unless the termination is due to the emancipation or adoption of the child. The juvenile court having jurisdiction over the guardianship shall receive notice from the court in which the petition is filed within five calendar days of the filing. Prior to the hearing on a petition to terminate legal guardianship pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall order the county department of social services or welfare department having jurisdiction or jointly with the county department where the guardian and child currently reside to prepare a report, for the courts consideration, that shall include an evaluation of whether the child could safely remain in, or be returned to, the legal guardians home, without terminating the legal guardianship, if services were provided to the child or legal guardian. If applicable, the report shall also identify recommended family maintenance or reunification services to maintain the legal guardianship and set forth a plan for providing those services. If the petition to terminate legal guardianship is granted, either juvenile court may resume dependency jurisdiction over the child, and may order the county department of social services or welfare department to develop a new permanent plan, which shall be presented to the court within 60 days of the termination. If no dependency jurisdiction has attached, the social worker shall make any investigation he or she deems necessary to determine whether the child may be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, as provided in Section 328.
(3)Unless the parental rights of the childs parent or parents have been terminated, they shall be notified that the legal guardianship has been revoked or terminated and shall be entitled to participate in the new permanency planning hearing. The court shall try to place the child in another permanent placement. At the hearing, the parents may be considered as custodians but the child shall not be returned to the parent or parents unless they prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that reunification is the best alternative for the child. The court may, if it is in the best interests of the child, order that reunification services again be provided to the parent or parents.
(c)If, following the establishment of a legal guardianship, the county welfare department becomes aware of changed circumstances that indicate adoption or, for an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, may be an appropriate plan for the child, the department shall so notify the court. The court may vacate its previous order dismissing dependency jurisdiction over the child and order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 to determine whether adoption or continued legal guardianship is the most appropriate plan for the child. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the order. If the court orders that a hearing shall be held pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services if it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment under subdivision (b) of Section 366.22.
(d)If the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent is in a placement other than the home of a legal guardian and jurisdiction has not been dismissed, the status of the child shall be reviewed at least every six months. The review of the status of a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption shall be conducted by the court. The review of the status of a child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent for whom the court has not ordered parental rights terminated and who has not been ordered placed for adoption may be conducted by the court or an appropriate local agency. The court shall conduct the review under the following circumstances:
(1)Upon the request of the childs parents or legal guardians.
(2)Upon the request of the child or, on and after January 1, 2012, nonminor dependent.
(3)It has been 12 months since a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 or an order that the child remain in foster care pursuant to Section 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, 366.26, or subdivision (h).
(4)It has been 12 months since a review was conducted by the court.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (g), at the review held every six months pursuant to subdivision (d), the reviewing body shall inquire about the progress being made to provide a permanent home for the child, shall consider the safety of the child, and shall determine all of the following:
(1)The continuing necessity for, and appropriateness of, the placement.
(2)Identification of individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer, and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The social worker shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer to identify individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, and may ask any other child to provide that information, as appropriate. The social worker shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests.
(3)The continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the permanent plan for the child, including efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and who has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child and efforts to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(4)The extent of the agencys compliance with the child welfare services case plan in making reasonable efforts either to return the child to the safe home of the parent or to complete whatever steps are necessary to finalize the permanent placement of the child. If the reviewing body determines that a second period of reunification services is in the childs best interests, and that there is a significant likelihood of the childs return to a safe home due to changed circumstances of the parent, pursuant to subdivision (f), the specific reunification services required to effect the childs return to a safe home shall be described.
(5)Whether there should be any limitation on the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child. That limitation shall be specifically addressed in the court order and may not exceed what is necessary to protect the child. If the court specifically limits the right of the parent or guardian to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child, the court shall at the same time appoint a responsible adult to make educational decisions or developmental services decisions for the child pursuant to Section 361.
(6)The adequacy of services provided to the child. The court shall consider the progress in providing the information and documents to the child, as described in Section 391. The court shall also consider the need for, and progress in providing, the assistance and services described in Section 391.
(7)The extent of progress the parents or legal guardians have made toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating placement in foster care.
(8)The likely date by which the child may be returned to, and safely maintained in, the home, placed for adoption, legal guardianship, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or, if the child is 16 years of age or older, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, in another planned permanent living arrangement.
(9)Whether the child has any siblings under the courts jurisdiction, and, if any siblings exist, all of the following:
(A)The nature of the relationship between the child and his or her siblings.
(B)The appropriateness of developing or maintaining the sibling relationships pursuant to Section 16002. At the first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(C)If the siblings are not placed together in the same home, why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts are being made to place the siblings together, or why those efforts are not appropriate.
(D)If the siblings are not placed together, all of the following:
(i)The frequency and nature of the visits between the siblings.
(ii)If there are visits between the siblings, whether the visits are supervised or unsupervised. If the visits are supervised, a discussion of the reasons why the visits are supervised, and what needs to be accomplished in order for the visits to be unsupervised.
(iii)If there are visits between the siblings, a description of the location and length of the visits.
(iv)Any plan to increase visitation between the siblings.
(E)The impact of the sibling relationships on the childs placement and planning for legal permanence.
The factors the court may consider as indicators of the nature of the childs sibling relationships include, but are not limited to, whether the siblings were raised together in the same home, whether the siblings have shared significant common experiences or have existing close and strong bonds, whether either sibling expresses a desire to visit or live with his or her sibling, as applicable, and whether ongoing contact is in the childs best emotional interests.
(10)For a child who is 14 years of age or older, and, effective January 1, 2012, for a nonminor dependent, the services needed to assist the child or nonminor dependent to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
The reviewing body shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
Each licensed foster family agency shall submit reports for each child in its care, custody, and control to the court concerning the continuing appropriateness and extent of compliance with the childs permanent plan, the extent of compliance with the case plan, and the type and adequacy of services provided to the child.
(f)Unless their parental rights have been permanently terminated, the parent or parents of the child are entitled to receive notice of, and participate in, those hearings. It shall be presumed that continued care is in the best interests of the child, unless the parent or parents prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that further efforts at reunification are the best alternative for the child. In those cases, the court may order that further reunification services to return the child to a safe home environment be provided to the parent or parents up to a period of six months, and family maintenance services, as needed for an additional six months in order to return the child to a safe home environment. On and after January 1, 2012, this subdivision shall not apply to the parents of a nonminor dependent.
(g)At the review conducted by the court and held at least every six months, regarding a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child for whom parental rights are not being terminated and a tribal customary adoption is being considered, the county welfare department shall prepare and present to the court a report describing the following:
(1)The childs present placement.
(2)The childs current physical, mental, emotional, and educational status.
(3)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or guardian, identification of individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child and actions necessary to maintain the childs relationship with those individuals, provided that those relationships are in the best interest of the child. The agency shall ask every child who is 10 years of age or older to identify any individuals who are important to him or her, consistent with the childs best interest, and may ask any child who is younger than 10 years of age to provide that information as appropriate. The agency shall make efforts to identify other individuals who are important to the child.
(4)Whether the child has been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents.
(5)Whether an adoptive placement agreement has been signed and filed.
(6)If the child has not been placed with a prospective adoptive parent or parents, the efforts made to identify an appropriate prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment efforts and listing on an adoption exchange.
(7)Whether the final adoption order should include provisions for postadoptive sibling contact pursuant to Section 366.29.
(8)The progress of the search for an adoptive placement if one has not been identified.
(9)Any impediments to the adoption or the adoptive placement.
(10)The anticipated date by which the child will be adopted or placed in an adoptive home.
(11)The anticipated date by which an adoptive placement agreement will be signed.
(12)Recommendations for court orders that will assist in the placement of the child for adoption or in the finalization of the adoption.
The court shall determine whether or not reasonable efforts to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child have been made.
The court shall make appropriate orders to protect the stability of the child and to facilitate and expedite the permanent placement and adoption of the child.
(h)(1)At the review held pursuant to subdivision (d) for a child in foster care, the court shall consider all permanency planning options for the child including whether the child should be returned to the home of the parent, placed for adoption, or, for an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, placed for tribal customary adoption, or appointed a legal guardian, placed with a fit and willing relative, or, if compelling reasons exist for finding that none of the foregoing options are in the best interest of the child and the child is 16 years of age or older, whether the child should be placed in another planned permanent living arrangement. The court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26, unless it determines by clear and convincing evidence that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is being returned to the home of the parent, the child is not a proper subject for adoption, or no one is willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. If the county adoption agency, or the department when it is acting as an adoption agency, has determined it is unlikely that the child will be adopted or one of the conditions described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 366.26 applies, that fact shall constitute a compelling reason for purposes of this subdivision. Only upon that determination may the court order that the child remain in foster care, without holding a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26.
(2)When the child is 16 years of age or older and in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the child about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the child.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the child to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed for tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(3)When the child is 16 years of age or older and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the social study prepared for the hearing shall include a description of all of the following:
(A)The intensive and ongoing efforts to return the child to the home of the parent, place the child for adoption, or establish a legal guardianship, as appropriate.
(B)The steps taken to do both of the following:
(i)Ensure that the childs care provider is following the reasonable and prudent parent standard.
(ii)Determine whether the child has regular, ongoing opportunities to engage in age or developmentally appropriate activities, including consulting with the child about opportunities for the child to participate in those activities.
(4)When the child is under 16 years of age and has a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, any barriers to achieving the permanent plan and the efforts made by the agency address those barriers.
(i)If, as authorized by subdivision (h), the court orders a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, the court shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment as provided for in subdivision (i) of Section 366.21 or subdivision (b) of Section 366.22. A hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the 12-month review at which it is ordered, and at that hearing the court shall determine whether adoption, tribal customary adoption, legal guardianship, placement with a fit and willing relative, or, for a child 16 years of age or older, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. At the request of the nonminor dependent who has an established relationship with an adult determined to be the nonminor dependents permanent connection, the court may order adoption of the nonminor dependent pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 366.31.
(j)The reviews conducted pursuant to subdivision (a) or (d) may be conducted earlier than every six months if the court determines that an earlier review is in the best interests of the child or as court rules prescribe.
SEC. 3.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 4.Section 16002 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:16002.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to maintain the continuity of the family unit, and ensure the preservation and strengthening of the childs family ties by ensuring that when siblings have been removed from their home, either as a group on one occurrence or individually on separate occurrences, the siblings will be placed in foster care together, unless it has been determined that placement together is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. The Legislature recognizes that in order to ensure the placement of a sibling group in the same foster care placement, placement resources need to be expanded.
(2)It is also the intent of the Legislature to preserve and strengthen a childs sibling relationship so that when a child has been removed from his or her home and he or she has a sibling or siblings who remain in the custody of a mutual parent subject to the courts jurisdiction, the court has the authority to develop a visitation plan for the siblings, unless it has been determined that visitation is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling.
(b)The responsible local agency shall make a diligent effort in all out-of-home placements of dependent children and wards in foster care, including those with relatives, to place siblings together in the same placement, and to develop and maintain sibling relationships. If siblings are not placed together in the same home, the social worker or probation officer shall explain why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts he or she is making to place the siblings together or why making those efforts would be contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings. When placement of siblings together in the same home is not possible, a diligent effort shall be made, and a case plan prepared, to provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is achieved, or, if parental rights are terminated, as part of developing the permanent plan for the child. If the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and interaction shall be suspended.
(c)When there has been a judicial suspension of sibling interaction, the reasons for the suspension shall be reviewed at each periodic review hearing pursuant to Section 366 or 727.3. In order for the suspension to continue, the court shall make a renewed finding that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of either child. When the court determines that sibling interaction can be safely resumed, that determination shall be noted in the court order and the case plan shall be revised to provide for sibling interaction.
(d)If the case plan for the child has provisions for sibling interaction, the child, or his or her parent or legal guardian, shall have the right to comment on those provisions. If a person wishes to assert a sibling relationship with a dependent child or ward, he or she may file a petition in the juvenile court having jurisdiction over the dependent child pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 388 or the ward in foster care pursuant to Section 778.
(e)If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1)Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2)Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3)(A)To the extent practicable, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption. The county placing agency may comply with the requirements of this paragraph by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
(B)The county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code in either of the following circumstances:
(i)The county placing agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child.
(ii)The child requests that a meeting shall not occur.
(C)The child may petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. If the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
(D)Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described in this paragraph.
(E)This paragraph shall not require attendance by a child, sibling, or other party at a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code if the child, sibling, or other party cannot be located or does not wish to attend the meeting. This paragraph shall not prohibit a county placing agency from convening a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
(f)Information regarding sibling interaction, contact, or visitation that has been authorized or ordered by the court shall be provided to the foster parent, relative caretaker, or legal guardian of the child as soon as possible after the court order is made, in order to facilitate the interaction, contact, or visitation.
(g)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
(h)The court documentation on sibling placements required under this section shall not require the modification of existing court order forms until the Child Welfare Services/Case Management System (CWS/CMS) is implemented on a statewide basis.
SEC. 5.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that some adoptive children may benefit from either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, after being adopted. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children of an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the children and the agreements are voluntarily executed by birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and adoptive parents. Nothing in this section requires all of the listed parties to participate in the development of a postadoption contact agreement in order for the agreement to be executed.
(b)(1)Nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents, the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child from voluntarily executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact between the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
(2)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement executed under this section shall be limited to, but need not include, all of the following:
(A)Provisions for visitation between the child and a birth parent or parents and other birth relatives, including siblings, and the childs Indian tribe if the case is governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.).
(B)Provisions for future contact between a birth parent or parents or other birth relatives, including siblings, or both, and the child or an adoptive parent, or both, and in cases governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act, the childs Indian tribe.
(C)Provisions for the sharing of information about the child in the future.
(3)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement with birth relatives, including siblings, other than the childs birth parent or parents shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the birth relative.
(c)At the time an adoption decree is entered pursuant to a petition filed pursuant to Section 8714, 8714.5, 8802, 8912, or 9000, the court entering the decree may grant postadoption privileges if an agreement for those privileges has been executed, including agreements executed pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 8620. The hearing to grant the adoption petition and issue an order of adoption may be continued as necessary to permit parties who are in the process of negotiating a postadoption agreement to reach a final agreement.
(d)The child who is the subject of the adoption petition shall be considered a party to the postadoption contact agreement. The written consent to the terms and conditions of the postadoption contact agreement and any subsequent modifications of the agreement by a child who is 12 years of age or older is a necessary condition to the granting of privileges regarding visitation, contact, or sharing of information about the child, unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement, as written, is in the best interests of the child. Any child who has been found to come within Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or who is the subject of a petition for jurisdiction of the juvenile court under Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code shall be represented by an attorney for purposes of consent to the postadoption contact agreement.
(e)A postadoption contact agreement shall contain the following warnings in bold type:
(1)After the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure of an adopting parent, a birth parent, a birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to follow the terms of this agreement or a later change to this agreement.
(2)A disagreement between the parties or litigation brought to enforce or modify the agreement shall not affect the validity of the adoption and shall not serve as a basis for orders affecting the custody of the child.
(3)A court will not act on a petition to change or enforce this agreement unless the petitioner has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings to resolve the dispute.
(f)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, juvenile court dependency jurisdiction shall be terminated. Enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement shall be under the continuing jurisdiction of the court granting the petition of adoption. The court may not order compliance with the agreement absent a finding that the party seeking the enforcement participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action, and that the enforcement is in the best interests of the child. Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision regarding enforcement. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(g)The court may not award monetary damages as a result of the filing of the civil action pursuant to subdivision (e).
(h)A postadoption contact agreement may be modified or terminated only if either of the following occurs:
(1)All parties, including the child if the child is 12 years of age or older at the time of the requested termination or modification, have signed a modified postadoption contact agreement and the agreement is filed with the court that granted the petition of adoption.
(2)The court finds all of the following:
(A)The termination or modification is necessary to serve the best interests of the child.
(B)There has been a substantial change of circumstances since the original agreement was executed and approved by the court.
(C)The party seeking the termination or modification has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings prior to seeking court approval of the proposed termination or modification.
Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(i)All costs and fees of mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings shall be borne by each party, excluding the child. All costs and fees of litigation shall be borne by the party filing the action to modify or enforce the agreement when no party has been found by the court as failing to comply with an existing postadoption contact agreement. Otherwise, a party, other than the child, found by the court as failing to comply without good cause with an existing agreement shall bear all the costs and fees of litigation.
(j)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court and forms for motions to enforce, terminate, or modify postadoption contact agreements.
(k)The court shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a birth parent, adoptive parent, birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to comply with any or all of the original terms of, or subsequent modifications to, the postadoption contact agreement, except as follows:
(1)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, in an adoption involving an Indian child, the court may, upon a petition of the birth parent, birth relative, including a sibling, or an Indian tribe, order the parties to engage in family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement if the prospective adoptive parent fails to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement, after having agreed to enter into negotiations, provided that the failure of the parties to reach an agreement is not in and of itself proof of bad faith.
(2)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, if the parties fail to negotiate in good faith to execute a postadoption contact agreement during the negotiations entered into pursuant to, and in accordance with, paragraph (1), the court may modify prior orders or issue new orders as necessary to ensure the best interest of the Indian child is met, including, but not limited to, requiring parties to engage in further family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement, initiating guardianship proceeding in lieu of adoption, or authorizing a change of adoptive placement for the child.
(l)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
SEC. 2.Section 366.29 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.29.(a)When a court, pursuant to Section 366.26, orders that a dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoption sibling contact. With the consent of the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoption sibling contact. In no event shall the continuing validity of the adoption be contingent upon the postadoption contact, nor shall the ability of the adoptive parent or parents and the child to change residence within or outside the state be impaired by the order for contact.
(b)At the time of consideration of an adoption petition, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(c)If, following entry of an order for sibling contact pursuant to subdivision (a), it is determined by the adoptive parent or parents that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child, the adoptive parent or parents may terminate the sibling contact, provided that the adoptive parent or parents shall submit written notification to the court within 10 days after terminating the contact, which notification shall specify to the court the reasons why the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child would be threatened by continued sibling contact.
(d)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, the jurisdiction of the juvenile court with respect to the dependency proceedings of that child shall be terminated. Nonetheless, the court granting the petition of adoption shall maintain jurisdiction over the child for enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement. The court may only order compliance with the postadoption contact agreement upon a finding of both of the following:
(1)The party seeking the enforcement participated, in good faith, in mediation or other appropriate alternative dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action.
(2)The enforcement is in the best interest of the child.
SEC. 3.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 4.Section 16002 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:16002.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to maintain the continuity of the family unit, and ensure the preservation and strengthening of the childs family ties by ensuring that when siblings have been removed from their home, either as a group on one occurrence or individually on separate occurrences, the siblings will be placed in foster care together, unless it has been determined that placement together is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. The Legislature recognizes that in order to ensure the placement of a sibling group in the same foster care placement, placement resources need to be expanded.
(2)It is also the intent of the Legislature to preserve and strengthen a childs sibling relationship so that when a child has been removed from his or her home and he or she has a sibling or siblings who remain in the custody of a mutual parent subject to the courts jurisdiction, the court has the authority to develop a visitation plan for the siblings, unless it has been determined that visitation is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling.
(b)The responsible local agency shall make a diligent effort in all out-of-home placements of dependent children and wards in foster care, including those with relatives, to place siblings together in the same placement, and to develop and maintain sibling relationships. If siblings are not placed together in the same home, the social worker or probation officer shall explain why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts he or she is making to place the siblings together or why making those efforts would be contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings. When placement of siblings together in the same home is not possible, a diligent effort shall be made, and a case plan prepared, to provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is achieved, or, if parental rights are terminated, as part of developing the permanent plan for the child. If the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and interaction shall be suspended.
(c)When there has been a judicial suspension of sibling interaction, the reasons for the suspension shall be reviewed at each periodic review hearing pursuant to Section 366 or 727.3. In order for the suspension to continue, the court shall make a renewed finding that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of either child. When the court determines that sibling interaction can be safely resumed, that determination shall be noted in the court order and the case plan shall be revised to provide for sibling interaction.
(d)If the case plan for the child has provisions for sibling interaction, the child, or his or her parent or legal guardian, shall have the right to comment on those provisions. If a person wishes to assert a sibling relationship with a dependent child or ward, he or she may file a petition in the juvenile court having jurisdiction over the dependent child pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 388 or the ward in foster care pursuant to Section 778.
(e)If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1)Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2)Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3)(A)To the extent practicable, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. Counsel Code on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption. The county placing agency may comply with the requirements of this paragraph by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
(B)The county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code in either of the following circumstances:
(i)The county placing agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child.
(ii)The child requests that a meeting shall not occur.
(C)The child may petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. If the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
(D)Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, the meeting. both the meeting and the hearing described in this paragraph.
(E)This paragraph shall not require attendance by a child, sibling, or other party at a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code if the child, sibling, or other party cannot be located or does not wish to attend the meeting. This paragraph shall not prohibit a county placing agency from convening a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
(f)Information regarding sibling interaction, contact, or visitation that has been authorized or ordered by the court shall be provided to the foster parent, relative caretaker, or legal guardian of the child as soon as possible after the court order is made, in order to facilitate the interaction, contact, or visitation.
(g)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
(h)The court documentation on sibling placements required under this section shall not require the modification of existing court order forms until the Child Welfare Services/Case Management System (CWS/CMS) is implemented on a statewide basis.
SEC. 5.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that some adoptive children may benefit from either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, after being adopted. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children of an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the children and the agreements are voluntarily entered into executed by birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and adoptive parents. Nothing in this section requires all of the listed parties to participate in the development of a postadoption contact agreement in order for the agreement to be entered into. executed.
(b)(1)Nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents, the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child from voluntarily entering into executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact between the birth relatives, including the birth parent or parents or any siblings, or an Indian tribe, and the child if the agreement is found by the court to have been entered into executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
(2)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement executed under this section shall be limited to, but need not include, all of the following:
(A)Provisions for visitation between the child and a birth parent or parents and other birth relatives, including siblings, and the childs Indian tribe if the case is governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.).
(B)Provisions for future contact between a birth parent or parents or other birth relatives, including siblings, or both, and the child or an adoptive parent, or both, and in cases governed by the Indian Child Welfare Act, the childs Indian tribe.
(C)Provisions for the sharing of information about the child in the future.
(3)The terms of any postadoption contact agreement with birth relatives relatives, including siblings, other than the childs birth parent or parents shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the birth relative.
(c)At the time an adoption decree is entered pursuant to a petition filed pursuant to Section 8714, 8714.5, 8802, 8912, or 9000, the court entering the decree may grant postadoption privileges if an agreement for those privileges has been entered into, executed, including agreements entered into executed pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 8620. The hearing to grant the adoption petition and issue an order of adoption may be continued as necessary to permit parties who are in the process of negotiating a postadoption agreement to reach a final agreement.
(d)The child who is the subject of the adoption petition shall be considered a party to the postadoption contact agreement. The written consent to the terms and conditions of the postadoption contact agreement and any subsequent modifications of the agreement by a child who is 12 years of age or older is a necessary condition to the granting of privileges regarding visitation, contact, or sharing of information about the child, unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement, as written, is in the best interests of the child. Any child who has been found to come within Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or who is the subject of a petition for jurisdiction of the juvenile court under Section 300 of the Welfare and Institutions Code shall be represented by an attorney for purposes of consent to the postadoption contact agreement.
(e)A postadoption contact agreement shall contain the following warnings in bold type:
(1)After the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure of an adopting parent, a birth parent, a birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to follow the terms of this agreement or a later change to this agreement.
(2)A disagreement between the parties or litigation brought to enforce or modify the agreement shall not affect the validity of the adoption and shall not serve as a basis for orders affecting the custody of the child.
(3)A court will not act on a petition to change or enforce this agreement unless the petitioner has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings to resolve the dispute.
(f)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, juvenile court dependency jurisdiction shall be terminated. Enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement shall be under the continuing jurisdiction of the court granting the petition of adoption. The court may not order compliance with the agreement absent a finding that the party seeking the enforcement participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action, and that the enforcement is in the best interests of the child. Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision regarding enforcement. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(g)The court may not award monetary damages as a result of the filing of the civil action pursuant to subdivision (e) of this section. (e).
(h)A postadoption contact agreement may be modified or terminated only if either of the following occurs:
(1)All parties, including the child if the child is 12 years of age or older at the time of the requested termination or modification, have signed a modified postadoption contact agreement and the agreement is filed with the court that granted the petition of adoption.
(2)The court finds all of the following:
(A)The termination or modification is necessary to serve the best interests of the child.
(B)There has been a substantial change of circumstances since the original agreement was executed and approved by the court.
(C)The party seeking the termination or modification has participated, or attempted to participate, in good faith in mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings prior to seeking court approval of the proposed termination or modification.
Documentary evidence or offers of proof may serve as the basis for the courts decision. No testimony or evidentiary hearing shall be required. The court shall not order further investigation or evaluation by any public or private agency or individual absent a finding by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child may be protected or advanced only by that inquiry and that the inquiry will not disturb the stability of the childs home to the detriment of the child.
(i)All costs and fees of mediation or other appropriate dispute resolution proceedings shall be borne by each party, excluding the child. All costs and fees of litigation shall be borne by the party filing the action to modify or enforce the agreement when no party has been found by the court as failing to comply with an existing postadoption contact agreement. Otherwise, a party, other than the child, found by the court as failing to comply without good cause with an existing agreement shall bear all the costs and fees of litigation.
(j)The Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court and forms for motions to enforce, terminate, or modify postadoption contact agreements.
(k)The court may shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a birth parent, adoptive parent, birth relative, including a sibling, an Indian tribe, or the child to comply with any or all of the original terms of, or subsequent modifications to, the postadoption contact agreement, except as follows:
(1)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, in an adoption involving an Indian child, the court may, upon a petition of the birth parent, birth relative, including a sibling, or an Indian tribe, order the parties to engage in family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement if the prospective adoptive parent fails to negotiate in good faith to enter into execute a postadoption contact agreement, after having agreed to enter into negotiations, provided that the failure of the parties to reach an agreement is not in and of itself proof of bad faith.
(2)Prior to issuing the order of adoption, if the parties fail to negotiate in good faith to enter into execute a postadoption contact agreement during the negotiations entered into pursuant to to, and in accordance with with, paragraph (1), the court may modify prior orders or issue new orders as necessary to ensure the best interest of the Indian child is met, including, but not limited to, requiring parties to engage in further family mediation services for the purpose of reaching a postadoption contact agreement, initiating guardianship proceeding in lieu of adoption, or authorizing a change of adoptive placement for the child.
(l)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 366.29 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.29.(a)When a court, pursuant to Section 366.26, orders that a dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoptive postadoption sibling contact. With the consent of the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive postadoption sibling contact. In no event shall the continuing validity of the adoption be contingent upon the postadoptive postadoption contact, nor shall the ability of the adoptive parent or parents and the child to change residence within or outside the state be impaired by the order for contact.
(b)Unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child, the court shall order the convening of a meeting of a child and family team, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 16501, regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, including, but not limited to, siblings under the courts jurisdiction. A sibling 12 years of age or older may represent himself or herself at the meeting. A sibling under 12 years of age shall be represented by his or her caregiver. The meeting shall be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers on the basis of age, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The participants of the meeting shall decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, pursuant to this section and Section 8616.5 of the Family Code, before the adoption is finalized.
(b)At the time of consideration of an adoption petition, the court shall inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 16002.
(c)If, following entry of an order for sibling contact pursuant to subdivision (a), it is determined by the adoptive parent or parents that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child, the adoptive parent or parents may terminate the sibling contact, provided that the adoptive parent or parents shall submit written notification to the court within 10 days after terminating the contact, which notification shall specify to the court the reasons why the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child would be threatened by continued sibling contact.
(d)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, the jurisdiction of the juvenile court with respect to the dependency proceedings of that child shall be terminated. Nonetheless, the court granting the petition of adoption shall maintain jurisdiction over the child for enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement. The court may only order compliance with the postadoption contact agreement upon a finding of both of the following:
(1)The party seeking the enforcement participated, in good faith, in mediation or other appropriate alternative dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action.
(2)The enforcement is in the best interest of the child.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 4.Section 16002 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:16002.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature to maintain the continuity of the family unit, and ensure the preservation and strengthening of the childs family ties by ensuring that when siblings have been removed from their home, either as a group on one occurrence or individually on separate occurrences, the siblings will be placed in foster care together, unless it has been determined that placement together is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. The Legislature recognizes that in order to ensure the placement of a sibling group in the same foster care placement, placement resources need to be expanded.
(2)It is also the intent of the Legislature to preserve and strengthen a childs sibling relationship so that when a child has been removed from his or her home and he or she has a sibling or siblings who remain in the custody of a mutual parent subject to the courts jurisdiction, the court has the authority to develop a visitation plan for the siblings, unless it has been determined that visitation is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling.
(b)The responsible local agency shall make a diligent effort in all out-of-home placements of dependent children and wards in foster care, including those with relatives, to place siblings together in the same placement, and to develop and maintain sibling relationships. If siblings are not placed together in the same home, the social worker or probation officer shall explain why the siblings are not placed together and what efforts he or she is making to place the siblings together or why making those efforts would be contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings. When placement of siblings together in the same home is not possible, a diligent effort shall be made, and a case plan prepared, to provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is achieved, or, if parental rights are terminated, as part of developing the permanent plan for the child. If the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of any of the siblings, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and interaction shall be suspended.
(c)When there has been a judicial suspension of sibling interaction, the reasons for the suspension shall be reviewed at each periodic review hearing pursuant to Section 366 or 727.3. In order for the suspension to continue, the court shall make a renewed finding that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of either child. When the court determines that sibling interaction can be safely resumed, that determination shall be noted in the court order and the case plan shall be revised to provide for sibling interaction.
(d)If the case plan for the child has provisions for sibling interaction, the child, or his or her parent or legal guardian, shall have the right to comment on those provisions. If a person wishes to assert a sibling relationship with a dependent child or ward, he or she may file a petition in the juvenile court having jurisdiction over the dependent child pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 388 or the ward in foster care pursuant to Section 778.
(e)If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1)Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2)Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3)Encourage prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact between the child who is the subject of a petition for adoption and any siblings of this child.
(3)To the extent practicable, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, the meeting.
(f)Information regarding sibling interaction, contact, or visitation that has been authorized or ordered by the court shall be provided to the foster parent, relative caretaker, or legal guardian of the child as soon as possible after the court order is made, in order to facilitate the interaction, contact, or visitation.
(g)As used in this section, sibling means a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
(h)The court documentation on sibling placements required under this section shall not require the modification of existing court order forms until the Child Welfare Services/Case Management System (CWS/CMS) is implemented on a statewide basis.
SEC. 3.SEC. 5.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)When a court, pursuant to Section 366.26, orders that a dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoptive sibling contact. With the consent of the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive sibling contact. In no event shall the continuing validity of the adoption be contingent upon the postadoptive contact, nor shall the ability of the adoptive parent or parents and the child to change residence within or outside the state be impaired by the order for contact.
(b)The Unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child, the court shall order the convening of a meeting of a child and family team, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 16501, regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, including, but not limited to, siblings under the courts jurisdiction. A sibling 12 years of age or older may represent himself or herself at the meeting. A sibling under 12 years of age shall be represented by his or her caregiver. The meeting shall be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers on the basis of age, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The participants of the meeting shall decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, pursuant to this section and Section 8616.5 of the Family Code, before the adoption is finalized.
(c)If, following entry of an order for sibling contact pursuant to subdivision (a), it is determined by the adoptive parent or parents that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child, the adoptive parent or parents may terminate the sibling contact, provided that the adoptive parent or parents shall submit written notification to the court within 10 days after terminating the contact, which notification shall specify to the court the reasons why the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child would be threatened by continued sibling contact.
(d)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, the jurisdiction of the juvenile court with respect to the dependency proceedings of that child shall be terminated. Nonetheless, the court granting the petition of adoption shall maintain jurisdiction over the child for enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement. The court may only order compliance with the postadoption contact agreement upon a finding of both of the following:
(1)The party seeking the enforcement participated, in good faith, in mediation or other appropriate alternative dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action.
(2)The enforcement is in the best interest of the child.
SEC. 2.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents, legal guardians, or parents or legal guardians and, if any, the siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, which are, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing to provide, and capable of providing providing, the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a petition filed in accordance with Section 778 petition or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 3.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
(a)When a court, pursuant to Section 366.26, orders that a dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoptive sibling contact. With the consent of the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive sibling contact. In no event shall the continuing validity of the adoption be contingent upon the postadoptive contact, nor shall the ability of the adoptive parent or parents and the child to change residence within or outside the state be impaired by the order for contact.
(b)The court shall order the convening of a meeting of a child and family team, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 16501, regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, including, but not limited to, siblings under the courts jurisdiction. A sibling 12 years of age or older may represent himself or herself at the meeting. A sibling under 12 years of age shall be represented by his or her caregiver. The meeting shall be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers on the basis of age, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The participants of the meeting shall decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement, pursuant to this section and Section 8616.5 of the Family Code, before the adoption is finalized.
(b)
(c)If, following entry of an order for sibling contact pursuant to subdivision (a), it is determined by the adoptive parent or parents that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child, the adoptive parent or parents may terminate the sibling contact, provided that the adoptive parent or parents shall submit written notification to the court within 10 days after terminating the contact, which notification shall specify to the court the reasons why the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child would be threatened by continued sibling contact.
(c)
(d)Upon the granting of the adoption petition and the issuing of the order of adoption of a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, the jurisdiction of the juvenile court with respect to the dependency proceedings of that child shall be terminated. Nonetheless, the court granting the petition of adoption shall maintain jurisdiction over the child for enforcement of the postadoption contact agreement. The court may only order compliance with the postadoption contact agreement upon a finding of both of the following:
(1)The party seeking the enforcement participated, in good faith, in mediation or other appropriate alternative dispute resolution proceedings regarding the conflict, prior to the filing of the enforcement action.
(2)The enforcement is in the best interest of the child.
SEC. 2.Section 727.3 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:727.3.The purpose of this section is to provide a means to monitor the safety and well-being of every minor in foster care who has been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to Section 601 or 602 and to ensure that everything reasonably possible is done to facilitate the safe and early return of the minor to his or her own home or to establish an alternative permanent plan for the minor.
(a)(1)For every minor declared a ward and ordered to be placed in foster care, a permanency planning hearing shall be conducted within 12 months of the date the minor entered foster care, as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 727.4. Subsequent permanency planning hearings shall be conducted periodically, but no less frequently than once every 12 months thereafter during the period of placement. It shall be the duty of the probation officer to prepare a written social study report including an updated case plan and a recommendation for a permanent plan, pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 706.5, and submit the report to the court prior to each permanency planning hearing, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.4.
(2)Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving a minor in the physical custody of a community care facility or foster family agency, the facility or agency may file with the court a report containing its recommendations, in addition to the probation officers social study. Prior to any permanency planning hearing involving the physical custody of a foster parent, relative caregiver, preadoptive parent, or legal guardian, that person may present to the court a report containing his or her recommendations. The court shall consider all reports and recommendations filed pursuant to this subdivision.
(3)If the minor has a continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, the parents or legal guardians shall be involved in the planning for a permanent placement. The court order placing the minor in a permanent placement shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians. parents, legal guardians, or siblings.
(4)At each permanency planning hearing, the court shall order a permanent plan for the minor, as described in subdivision (b). The court shall also make findings, as described in subdivision (e) of Section 727.2. In the case of a minor who has reached 16 years of age or older, the court shall, in addition, determine the services needed to assist the minor to make the transition from foster care to successful adulthood. The court shall make all of these determinations on a case-by-case basis and make reference to the probation officers report, the case plan, or other evidence relied upon in making its decisions.
(5)When the minor is 16 years of age or older, and is in another planned permanent living arrangement, the court, at each permanency planning hearing, shall do all of the following:
(A)Ask the minor about his or her desired permanency outcome.
(B)Make a judicial determination explaining why, as of the hearing date, another planned permanent living arrangement is the best permanency plan for the minor.
(C)State for the record the compelling reason or reasons why it continues not to be in the best interest of the minor to return home, be placed for adoption, be placed with a legal guardian, or be placed with a fit and willing relative.
(b)At all permanency planning hearings, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the minor. The court shall order one of the following permanent plans, which are, in order of priority:
(1)Return of the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the minor to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian unless:
(A)Reunification services were not offered, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.2.
(B)The court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the minor to his or her parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor. The probation department shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social study report and recommendations pursuant to Section 706.5, the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed for the minor in the case, and any other reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the minor and family and the extent to which the minor availed himself or herself of the services provided.
(2)Order that the permanent plan for the minor will be to return the minor to the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian, order further reunification services to be provided to the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian for a period not to exceed six months and continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency planning hearing, provided that the subsequent hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find that there is a substantial probability that the minor will be returned to the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian, the court shall be required to find that the minor and his or her parent or legal guardian have demonstrated the capacity and ability to complete the objectives of the case plan.
The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the minor cannot be returned home by the next permanency planning hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 727.31 may be initiated.
The court shall not continue the case for further reunification services if it has been 18 months or more since the date the minor was originally taken from the physical custody of his or her parent or legal guardian.
(3)Identify adoption as the permanent plan and order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to the procedures described in Section 727.31. The court shall only set a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31 if there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents. When the court sets a hearing pursuant to Section 727.31, it shall order that an adoption assessment report be prepared, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 727.31.
(4)Order a legal guardianship, pursuant to procedures described in subdivisions (c) to (f), inclusive, of Section 728.
(5)Place the minor with a fit and willing relative. Placement with a fit and willing relative means placing the minor with an appropriate approved relative who is willing to provide a permanent and stable home for the minor, but is unable or unwilling to become the legal guardian. When a minor is placed with a fit and willing relative, the court may authorize the relative to provide the same legal consent for the minors medical, surgical, and dental care, and education as the custodial parent of the minor.
(6)(A)If he or she is 16 years of age or older, place the minor in another planned permanent living arrangement. For purposes of this section, planned permanent living arrangement means any permanent living arrangement described in Section 11402 that is ordered by the court for a minor 16 years of age or older when there is a compelling reason or reasons to determine that it is not in the best interest of the minor to have any permanent plan listed in paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive. These plans include, but are not limited to, placement in a specific, identified foster family home, program, or facility on a permanent basis, or placement in a transitional housing placement facility. When the court places a minor in a planned permanent living arrangement, the court shall specify the goal of the placement, which may include, but shall not be limited to, return home, emancipation, guardianship, or permanent placement with a relative.
The court shall only order that the minor remain in a planned permanent living arrangement if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor.
(B)If the minor is under 16 years of age and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, that there is a compelling reason, as defined in subdivision (c), for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor as of the hearing date, the court shall order the minor to remain in a foster care placement with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date.
(c)A compelling reason for determining that a plan of termination of parental rights and adoption is not in the best interest of the minor is any of the following:
(1)Documentation by the probation department that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor and is not an appropriate permanency goal. That documentation may include, but is not limited to, documentation that:
(A)The minor is 12 years of age or older and objects to termination of parental rights.
(B)The minor is 17 years of age or older and specifically requests that transition to independent living with the identification of a caring adult to serve as a lifelong connection be established as his or her permanent plan. On and after January 1, 2012, this includes a minor who requests that his or her transitional independent living case plan include modification of his or her jurisdiction to that of dependency jurisdiction pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 607.2 or subdivision (i) of Section 727.2, or to that of transition jurisdiction pursuant to Section 450, in order to be eligible as a nonminor dependent for the extended benefits pursuant to Section 11403.
(C)The parent or guardian and the minor have a significant bond, but the parent or guardian is unable to care for the minor because of an emotional or physical disability, and the minors caregiver has committed to raising the minor to the age of majority and facilitating visitation with the disabled parent or guardian.
(D)The minor agrees to continued placement in a residential treatment facility that provides services specifically designed to address the minors treatment needs, and the minors needs could not be served by a less restrictive placement.
The probation departments recommendation that adoption is not in the best interest of the minor shall be based on the present family circumstances of the minor and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the minors family circumstances change.
(2)Documentation by the probation department that no grounds exist to file for termination of parental rights.
(3)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is an unaccompanied refugee minor, or there are international legal obligations or foreign policy reasons that would preclude terminating parental rights.
(4)A finding by the court that the probation department was required to make reasonable efforts to reunify the minor with the family pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 727.2, and did not make those efforts.
(5)Documentation by the probation department that the minor is living with a relative who is unable or unwilling to adopt the minor because of exceptional circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the minor, but who is willing and capable of providing the minor with a stable and permanent home environment, and the removal of the minor from the physical custody of his or her relative would be detrimental to the minors emotional well-being.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the ability of a parent to voluntarily relinquish his or her child to the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or to a county adoption agency at any time while the minor is a ward of the juvenile court if the department or county adoption agency is willing to accept the relinquishment.
(e)Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed with a fit and willing relative or in a planned permanent living arrangement shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a Section 778 petition or at a regularly scheduled and noticed status review hearing or permanency planning hearing. Any change in the permanent plan of a minor placed in a guardianship shall be made only by order of the court pursuant to a motion filed in accordance with Section 728.
SEC. 3.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state nor otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 1:30 p.m. |
| Aug 24, 2016 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 5908.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 3, 2016 | August 3 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 29, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Jun 21, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HUM. S. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 21). |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and HUM. S. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 7. Page 4098.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 7.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 4002.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (May 27). |
| May 20, 2016 | Set for hearing May 27. |
| May 9, 2016 | May 9 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 29, 2016 | Set for hearing May 9. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3519.) (April 12). |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (April 12). |
| Apr 1, 2016 | Set for hearing April 12. |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 24, 2016 | Unfinished Business SB1060 Leno Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 18, 2016 | SB 1060 Leno Senate Third Reading By WILLIAMS | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Human Services] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2016 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1060 Leno | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1060
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/12/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
SENATE FLOOR: 31-7, 6/1/16
AYES: Allen, Bates, Block, Cannella, De León, Fuller, Galgiani, Glazer, Hall, Hancock, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Huff, Jackson, Lara, Leno, Leyva, Liu, McGuire, Mendoza, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Nguyen, Pan, Pavley, Roth, Wieckowski, Wolk
NOES: Anderson, Berryhill, Gaines, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Vidak
NO VOTE RECORDED: Beall, Runner
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 8/18/16 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Youth Connection
DIGEST: This bill requires the county placing agency, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, siblings of the child, prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. This bill provides that the meeting is not required to occur if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child and notes the determination in the court order.
Assembly Amendments require the court to review the status of a dependent child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, and require the court to inquire into the into the status of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement at the first review hearing.
Existing law:
- Requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless it is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
- States the intent of the Legislature to ensure that siblings who are removed from the home will be placed in foster care together, unless the placement is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling, including requiring the state or county to do the following after parental rights are terminated and the court orders the dependent child to be placed for adoption:
- Include in training for prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of maintaining sibling relationships;
- Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about the child’s siblings, as specified; and
- Encourage the prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact between the child and any siblings. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 16002.)
- Requires, when the court has ordered removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, the court to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 361.2.)
- Requires any order placing a child in foster care to provide for visitation between a child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 362.1.)
- Allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement. (Welf. & Inst. Code Secs. 366.26 and 366.29.)
- Authorizes a parent to terminate a postadoptive sibling contact agreement if it is determined by the parent that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 366.26.)
This bill:
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the benefit of continuing contact between some adoptive children and their siblings and the importance of postadoption contact agreements, which can be beneficial to adoptive children under certain circumstances.
- States that nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents of a child from entering into a voluntary agreement with the child's birth relatives, including any siblings of the child, to permit continuing contact between the child and the birth relatives, including any siblings if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
- Requires that any court order permanently placing the minor shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the sibling.
- Requires a court, at its first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- Requires, to the extent practicable, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption.
- Allows the agency to comply with the requirement in 5) above, by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- Provides that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement in one of the following two circumstances: a) if the agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or b) the child requests that a meeting does not occur.
- Allows the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting and provides that if the court determines by a preponderence of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
- Clarifies that no child, sibling, or other party is required to attend a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Family Code Section 8616.5 and that a county placing agency may convene a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
- Requires counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court to be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described above.
- Clarifies that after the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure to comply with a postadoption sibling contact agreement.
Background
In October 2008, Congress passed, and President Bush signed, the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act) to promote permanent families for children and youth in foster care by providing greater assistance to relative caregivers and improving incentives for adoption. The Act also extends assistance for foster children to age 21 and improves education and health care for children and youth in foster care. Further, the Act requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740, Chapter 805, Statutes of 1999.) Since then California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships. Creating another mechanism by which the court may further protect sibling relationships, SB 1099 (Steinberg, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2014) gave dependency courts the authority to order visitation between dependent and non-dependent siblings in specified circumstances. This bill seeks to further protect sibling relationships by requiring the county, as soon as parental rights are terminated and the court orders the dependent child to be placed for adoption, to convene a meeting with the relevant parties for the purpose of discussing a postadoption sibling contact agreement. This bill also, at the adoption proceeding, requires the court to inquire into the status of the postadoption sibling contact agreement.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor state costs (General Fund* (GF)) for potential additional meetings to determine whether to execute postadoption sibling contact agreements.
- Unknown, but potentially significant state costs (GF*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration), among other factors.
- Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the child and family team meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
Proposition 30*: Exempts the state from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for "public safety services" including the provision of child welfare services. However, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the state.
California Youth Connection (source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
California Alliance of Child and Family Services
California CASA Association
Children Now
Children’s Law Center
County Welfare Directors Association of California
Families Now
Hillsides
National Association of Social Workers
Public Counsel
The John Burton Foundation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/17/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the California Alliance of Child and Family Services:
Approximately 20 percent of foster youth exit to adoption each year in California. Every child deserves a permanent family that provides a safe, enriching and loving home, not just for a few months but forever. When reunification with biological parents is no longer possible, adoption by a relative or a nonrelative family gives our foster youth the chance to grow up in a loving and permanent family. Findings have found that healthy relationships with an adopted youth’s biological siblings are critical to the success of the adoption being permanent. SB 1060 strengthens the efforts of continued sibling connections by requiring a facilitated meeting to create a post adoption sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized between the adoptive parents, the prospective adoptive child/children and the siblings who will not be living together. All parties will be allowed to decide whether to voluntarily enter into this agreement. This meeting will elevate the importance of sibling relationships within the adoption process and will improve the lives of foster youth.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 8/18/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Roger Hernández, Kim
8/19/16 19:29:31
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1060
Author:(Leno)
As Amended Ver:August 1, 2016
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 31-7
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Holden, Maienschein, Ting |
|
Human Services | 7-0 | Bonilla, Grove, Arambula, Lopez, Maienschein, Mark Stone, Thurmond |
|
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood, McCarty |
|
SUMMARY: Requires a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the benefit of continuing contact between some adoptive children and their siblings and the importance of postadoption contact agreements, which can be beneficial to adoptive children under certain circumstances.
- States that nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents of a child from entering into a voluntary agreement with the child's birth relatives, including any siblings of the child, to permit continuing contact between the child and the birth relatives, including any siblings if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
- Requires that any court order permanently placing the minor shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the sibling.
- Requires a court, at its first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- Requires, to the extent practicable, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption.
- Allows the agency to comply with the requirement in 5) above, by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- Provides that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement in one of the following two circumstances: a) If the agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or b) The child requests that a meeting does not occur.
- Allows the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting and provides that if the court determines by a preponderence of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
- Clarifies that no child, sibling, or other party is required to attend a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Family Code Section 8616.5 and that a county placing agency may convene a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
- Requires counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court to be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described above.
- Clarifies that after the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure to comply with a postadoption sibling contact agreement.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor state costs (General Fund* (GF)) for potential additional meetings to determine whether to execute postadoption sibling contact agreements.
- Unknown, but potentially significant state costs (GF*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration), among other factors.
- Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the child and family team (CFT) meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
Proposition 30*: Exempts the State from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for "public safety services" including the provision of child welfare services. However, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the State.
COMMENTS: In 2008, Congress passed the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act), which, among other things, made it a priority that siblings entering the foster care system be placed together by requiring states to use "reasonable efforts" to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, the Act requires that visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being.
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740 (Steinberg), Chapter 805, Statutes of 1999.) Since then California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships. These laws have served to promote sibling relationships when both children are in the dependency system, but recent, unpublished cases indicate that courts will not grant visitation in the rare case where one sibling is in the foster system and the other remains in the legal custody of the parent.
California Law has Long Recognized the Importance of Maintaining Sibling Relationships, but California's Foster Care System Continues to Separate Siblings in Too Many Cases. California law has repeatedly recognized the importance of maintaining and developing sibling relationships for children in foster care. Key legislation in this area includes AB 743 (Portantino), Chapter 560, Statutes of 2010, which required greater notice if siblings are to be separated; AB 705 (Steinberg), Chapter 747, Statutes of 2001, which ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate; AB 1987 (Steinberg), Chapter 909, Statutes of 2000, which recognized the importance of sibling relationships and required the court to consider the existence, nature and impact of a dependent child's sibling relationships on the child's placement and planning for legal permanence; and AB 740 (Steinberg), Chapter 805, Statutes of 1999, which expedited the procedure for permanent placement of a sibling group.
Nevertheless, recent data reveal that children in foster care are often not placed with all their siblings. Foster children in California are placed together with all their siblings in only slightly over half of all cases. Slightly older data reveal that in only about 29% of cases, foster youth have been separated from all of their siblings. (Legislative Analyst's Office, Protecting Children From Abuse and Neglect: Trends and Issues 29 (Aug. 2013); B. Needell et al., Child Welfare Services Reports for California (2008).)
This Bill Seeks to Further Ensure that Courts Protect a Foster Child's Relationship With His or Her Siblings, Including After the Child is Adopted. When siblings are not or cannot be placed together, existing law requires visitation between a foster child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. Finally, existing law allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement.
This bill requires a county placing agency, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption. Recent amendments also do the following:
- Specify that any hearing must take place at the first review conducted for a child for whom the court has ordered parental rights terminated and who has been ordered placed for adoption.
- Allow the county placing agency to delegate the responsibility for convening a meeting to a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- Specify that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Family Code Section 8616.5 for two specific reasons: a) The county placing agency determines that a meeting or a postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or b) The child requests that a meeting does not occur.
- Allow the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Family Code Section 8616.5.
- Require counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court to be notified of, and allows them to attend, both the meeting and the hearing.
- Provide that no child, sibling, or other party is required to attend a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Family Code Section 8616.5.
These new provisions will help ensure that sibling interaction and contact, and the agreements to facilitate such relationships, occur when appropriate. By specifying the two reasons why a county agency is not required to convene a meeting, the bill as proposed to be amended implies that a county placing agency is required to convene a meeting except in the case of one or both of those circumstances. This amendment significantly furthers the purpose of this bill and ensures that the mechanism to further that purpose, the meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, is likely to occur in appropriate circumstances (and not in circumstances where a meeting would be inappropriate, such as when a child objects to it).
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003989
Date of Hearing: August 3, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1060
Author:(Leno) – As Amended Ver:August 1, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
Human Services | 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY: This bill requires the court, when considering an adoption petition, to inquire about development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement, and requires the county placing agency, when parental rights are terminated and the court orders a child be placed for adoption, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting for the purpose of determining whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Adds direct reference to siblings in a number of provisions related to postadoption contact between an adoptive child and his or her birth relatives.
- Requires the court, at the time of the first review hearing, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified.
- Requires the court order for the permanent placement of a ward of the court, as specified, to include specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with any siblings.
- Requires, when parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, sibling(s) of the child, prospective adoptive parent(s), and a facilitator for the purpose of determining whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- States that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to determine whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement if it determines that such a meeting or agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or the child requests that a meeting not occur.
- Permits a child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting regarding a postadoption sibling contact agreement, and further states that if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence, such a meeting or agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for that determination must be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Potentially significant state costs (GF*) for additional meetings to the extent the meetings consist of child and family team (CFT) members. Estimated costs assuming only 50% of the 6,400 annual dependent adoptions require a CFT meeting could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million annually based on the average duration of 3.7 hours per CFT meeting and the attendance of one or two local agency representatives. These costs do not include any additional time CFT members may incur to identify and notify non-dependent siblings to coordinate these meetings. Actual costs could be substantially higher to the extent the proportion of dependents with siblings is higher than assumed above, or more than two CFT members representing local agencies are in attendance at the meeting.
- Unknown, but potentially significant state costs (GF*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration), among other factors.
- Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the CFT meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
Proposition 30*: Exempts the State from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “public safety services” including the provision of child welfare services. However, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the State.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, “For an adoption to establish a lasting commitment between the child and adopting parents, elements of healing and support are essential. Research confirms that sustaining relationships with the biological family, especially siblings, is effective in overcoming any negative effects of being removed from one's family and placed into foster care. This bill will maintain sibling relationships through the adoption process by elevating the function of the post adoption contact agreement between siblings and prospective adoptive children prior to adoption finalization.”
- Background. In 2008, Congress passed the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act), which, among other things, made it a priority that siblings entering the foster care system be placed together by requiring states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, the Act requires that visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being.
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740 (Steinberg), Chap. 805, Stats. 1999.) Since then, California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships.
State law recognizes the benefits often derived from adoptive children having either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives after being adopted, and provides for the development of postadoption contact agreements. These agreements are intended to establish ongoing contact between a child who has been adopted and his or her birth relatives; they are voluntarily entered into by birth relatives and adoptive parents. The purview of these agreements is limited to, but does not need to include, provisions for visitation, future contact, and sharing of information about the child in the future.
California state law requires a social worker, to the extent that it is practical and appropriate, to place a minor together with any siblings or half-siblings who are also detained or include in the case report a statement of his or her continuing efforts to place the siblings together or why those efforts are not appropriate.
- Related Legislation. AB 1997 (Stone), 2016, pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee, adopts changes to further facilitate implementation of Continuum of Care Reform (CCR) recommendations to better serve children and youth in California's child welfare services system.
- Prior Legislation.
- AB 403 (Stone), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015, implemented CCR recommendations to better serve children and youth in California’s child welfare services system.
- SB 1099 (Steinberg), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2014, encouraged visitation with siblings for children in the dependency and juvenile justice systems.
- AB 743 (Portantino), Chapter 560, Statutes of 2010, made changes to the standards for sibling visitation, interaction, and placement for children who are placed out-of-home, in foster care, or adoption, to conform with language in the federal Fostering Connections Act.
- AB 705 (Steinberg), Chapter 747, Statutes of 2001, ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate.
- AB 1987 (Steinberg), Chapter 909, Statutes of 2000, required the juvenile court to consider the existence and nature of sibling relationships in all placement, visitation and permanency hearings.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 28, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Susan Bonilla, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1060
Author:(Leno) – As Amended Ver:June 22, 2016
SENATE VOTE: 31-7
SUBJECT: Postadoption contact: siblings of dependent children or wards
SUMMARY: Requires the court, when considering an adoption petition, to inquire about development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement, and requires the county placing agency, when parental rights are terminated and the court orders a child be placed for adoption, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting for the purpose of determining whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified.
Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “sibling” to mean a person related to the identified child by blood, adoption, or affinity through a common legal or biological parent.
- Adds direct reference to siblings in a number of provisions related to postadoption contact between an adoptive child and his or her birth relatives, including:
- Legislative findings and declarations regarding the benefits for some adoptive children of having contact with siblings and regarding voluntary postadoption contact agreements with siblings;
- The prohibition that nothing in the adoption laws of California shall be construed to prevent any siblings and a child from voluntarily executing a written agreement to permit continuing contact if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interest of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted;
- The requirement that the terms of any postadoption contact agreement with siblings shall be limited to the sharing of information about the child, unless the child has a preexisting relationship with the sibling;
- The prohibition that the court shall not set aside a decree of adoption, rescind a relinquishment, or modify an order to terminate parental rights or any other prior court order because of the failure of a sibling to comply with the postadoption contact agreement, as specified; and
- Other requirements regarding postadoption contact agreements, as specified.
- Requires the court, at the time of consideration of an adoption petition, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified.
- Requires the court order for the permanent placement of a ward of the court, as specified, to include specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with any siblings.
- Requires, when parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county placing agency, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, sibling(s) of the child, prospective adoptive parent(s), and a facilitator for the purpose of determining whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified. Further, authorizes the county placing agency to comply with this requirement by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation, as specified, to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- States that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to determine whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- It determines that such a meeting or agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child; or
- The child requests that a meeting not occur.
- Permits a child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to determine whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified, and further states that if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that such a meeting or agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for that determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
- Requires both counsel to the child and to the sibling(s) who are dependents of the court to be notified, and permitted to attend, both the meeting and the hearing, as specified.
- Stipulates that attendance by a child, sibling, or other party shall not be required at a meeting to determine whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified, if the child, sibling, or other party cannot be located or does not wish to attend. Further, states that this shall not prohibit a county placing agency from convening a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Permits the juvenile court to adjudge a child a dependent of the court for specified reasons, including, but not limited to, if a child has suffered or is at substantial risk of suffering serious physical harm, emotional damage, or sexual abuse, as specified. (WIC 300)
- States that the purpose of foster care law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected, or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. (WIC 300.2)
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to, whenever possible, preserve and strengthen a child’s family ties and, when a child must be removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, to give preferential consideration to placement with relatives. States the intent of the Legislature to reaffirm its commitment to children who are in out-of-home placement to live in the least restrictive family setting and as close to the child’s family as possible, as specified. Further states the intent of the Legislature that all children live with a committed, permanent, nurturing family and states that services and supports should be tailored to meet the specific needs of the individual child and family being served, as specified. (WIC 16000)
- Requires out-of-home placement of a child in foster care to be based upon selection of a safe setting that is the least restrictive family setting that promotes normal childhood experiences and the most appropriate setting that meets the child’s individual needs, as specified. Further requires the selection of placement to consider, in order of priority, placement with: relatives, nonrelated extended family members, and tribal members; foster family homes, resource families, and nontreatment certified homes of foster family agencies; followed by treatment and intensive treatment certified homes of foster family agencies or multidimensional treatment foster care homes or therapeutic foster care homes; group care placements in the order of short-term residential treatment centers, group homes, community treatment facilities, and out-of-state residential treatment, as specified. (WIC 16501.1(d)(1))
- States Legislative intent to preserve and strengthen a child’s sibling relationship when that child or sibling has been removed from the home, such that the court has authority to develop a visitation plan for siblings, as specified, and further delineates steps to be taken by various entities to facilitate continued sibling contact. (WIC 16002)
- Requires a social worker, to the extent that it is practical and appropriate, place a minor together with any siblings or half-siblings who are also detained or include in the case report, as specified, a statement of his or her continuing efforts to place the siblings together or why those efforts are not appropriate. (WIC 306.5)
- Provides for postadoption contact agreements to facilitate direct or indirect contact between adoptive children and their birth relatives. (FAM 8616.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis from May 27, 2016, this bill may result in the following costs:
- Team meetings: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for additional meetings to the extent the meetings consist of child and family team (CFT) members. Estimated costs assuming only 50% of the 6,400 annual dependent adoptions require a CFT meeting could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million annually based on the average duration of 3.7 hours per CFT meeting and the attendance of one or two local agency representatives. These costs do not include any additional time CFT members may incur to identify and notify non-dependent siblings to coordinate these meetings. Actual costs could be substantially higher to the extent the proportion of dependents with siblings is higher than assumed above, or more than two CFT members representing local agencies are in attendance at the meeting.
- Sibling visitation: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on numerous factors that are unknown at this time, including but not limited to the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration).
- Court impact: Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the CFT meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
- Proposition 30*: Exempts the State from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “public safety services” including the provision of child welfare services, however, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the State.
COMMENTS:
Child Welfare Services: The purpose of California’s Child Welfare Services (CWS) system is to protect children from abuse and neglect and provide for their health and safety. When children are identified as being at risk of abuse, neglect or abandonment, county juvenile courts hold legal jurisdiction and children are served by the CWS system through the appointment of a social worker. Through this system, there are multiple opportunities for the custody of the child, or his or her placement outside of the home, to be evaluated, reviewed and determined by the judicial system, in consultation with the child's social worker, to help provide the best possible services to the child. The CWS system seeks to help children who have been removed from their homes reunify with their parents or guardians, whenever appropriate, or unite them with other individuals they consider to be family. There are currently over 62,000 children and youth in California’s child welfare system.
Postadoption contact agreements: State law recognizes the benefits often derived from adoptive children having either direct or indirect contact with birth relatives after being adopted, and provides for the development of postadoption contact agreements. These agreements are intended to establish ongoing contact between a child who has been adopted and his or her birth relatives; they are voluntarily entered into by birth relatives and adoptive parents. The purview of these agreements is limited to, but does not need to include, provisions for visitation, future contact, and sharing of information about the child in the future.
Foster youth and sibling relationships: The importance of maintaining relationships between siblings who have been separated from each other due to involvement with the child welfare system is well-recognized. According to the Child Welfare Information Gateway:
“Sibling relationships are emotionally powerful and critically important not only in childhood but over the course of a lifetime. As children, siblings form a child’s first peer group, and they typically spend more time with each other than with anyone else. Children learn social skills, particularly in sharing and managing conflict, from negotiating with brothers and sisters. Sibling relationships can provide a significant source of continuity throughout a child’s lifetime and are likely to be the longest relationships that most people experience.”
The federal Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008 (Public Law 110-351) was the first recognition in federal law of the importance of keeping siblings together, and it required states to make reasonable efforts to maintain sibling connections, stating that reasonable efforts shall be made:
- “To place siblings removed from their home in the same foster care, kinship, guardianship, or adoptive placement, unless the State documents that such a joint placement would be contrary to the safety or well-being of any of the siblings; and
- In the case of siblings removed from their home who are not so jointly placed, to provide for frequent visitation or other ongoing interaction between the siblings, unless the State documents that frequent visitation or other ongoing interaction would be contrary to the safety or well-being of any of the siblings.” (42 U.S.C. §671(a)(31))
California state law requires a social worker, to the extent that it is practical and appropriate, place a minor together with any siblings or half-siblings who are also detained or include in the case report a statement of his or her continuing efforts to place the siblings together or why those efforts are not appropriate.
Need for this bill: According to the author:
“For an adoption to establish a lasting commitment between the child and adopting parents, elements of healing and support are essential. Research confirms that sustaining relationships with the biological family, especially siblings, is effective in overcoming any negative effects of being removed from one's family and placed into foster care. [This bill] will maintain sibling relationships through the adoption process by elevating the function of the post adoption contact agreement between siblings and prospective adoptive children prior to adoption finalization.”
PRIOR AND RELATED LEGISLATION:
AB 1997 (Stone), 2016, would adopt changes to further facilitate implementation of Continuum of Care Reform (CCR) recommendations to better serve children and youth in California's child welfare services system. It will be heard in the Senate Human Services Committee on June 28, 2016.
AB 403 (Stone), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015, implemented CCR recommendations to better serve children and youth in California’s child welfare services system.
SB 1099 (Steinberg), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2014, encouraged visitation with siblings for children in the dependency and juvenile justice systems.
AB 743 (Portantino), Chapter 560, Statutes of 2010, made changes to the standards for sibling visitation, interaction, and placement for children who are placed out-of-home, in foster care, or adoption, to conform with language in the federal Fostering Connections Act.
AB 705 (Steinberg), Chapter 747, Statutes of 2001, ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate.
AB 1987 (Steinberg), Chapter 909, Statutes of 2000, required the juvenile court to consider the existence and nature of sibling relationships in all placement, visitation and permanency hearings.
SECOND COMMITTEE OF REFERENCE. This bill was previously heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee on June 21, 2016 and was approved on a 10-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Youth Connection – sponsor
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
California Alliance
California CASA Association
Children Now
Children’s Law Center
County Welfare Directors Association of CA (CWDA)
Families Now
Hillsides
The John Burton Foundation
National Association of Social Workers
Public Counsel
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Daphne Hunt / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Date of Hearing: June 21, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1060
Author:(Leno) – As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 31-7
SUBJECT: POSTADOPTION CONTACT: SIBLINGS OF DEPENDENT CHILDREN OR WARDS
KEY ISSUE: GIVEN THE IMPORTANCE OF SIBLING RELATIONSHIPS FOR CHILDREN IN FOSTER CARE, INCLUDING THOSE WHO ARE ADOPTED, SHOULD ADDITIONAL EFFORTS BE MADE TO FACILITATE POSTADOPTION SIBLING CONTACT?
SYNOPSIS
The bond between siblings, especially those in foster care, cannot be underestimated. In 2008, Congress passed the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act, which, among other things, made it a priority that siblings entering the foster care system be placed together by requiring states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, the Act requires that visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being. Likewise, California law has repeatedly recognized the importance of maintaining and developing sibling relationships for children in foster care, as reflected in numerous legislative efforts to maintain and facilitate those relationships. Existing law seeks to ensure that social workers and courts protect the relationship between siblings throughout the foster care process. For example, a social worker is required to place a foster child together with his or her siblings or half-siblings who are also removed from parental custody, whenever possible and appropriate. If not possible or appropriate, the social worker is required to describe continuing efforts to place the siblings together, or to explain why placing them together is inappropriate. Existing law also requires a court, after ordering removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. When siblings are not or cannot be placed together, existing law requires visitation between a foster child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. Finally, existing law allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement.
In its original form, this bill required a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to convene a child and family team meeting to determine whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized. As most recently amended, however, the bill is more narrow in scope. As currently in print, the bill requires a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to do the following: (1) Inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized; and (2) Include, in any court order permanently placing the minor, a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the sibling. Finally, as currently in print, the bill requires, to the extent practicable, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement and allows counsel for the child to attend such a meeting. As explained in the analysis, this “requirement” is not really a requirement at all and county placing agencies are free to ignore it. The author proposes clarifying amendments that would, among other things, leave that language in place, but specify two reasons why a county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting and allow a child to petition the court to order the county placing agency to convene a meeting. Those amendments are reflected in this analysis. A large number of foster care, youth advocacy, and civil rights organizations support the bill, either as now in print, or in its former iterations. Sponsored by California Youth Connection, the bill has no opposition on file. Should this bill be approved by this Committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Human Services Committee.
SUMMARY: Requires a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the benefit of continuing contact between some adoptive children and their siblings and the importance of postadoption contact agreements, which can be beneficial to adoptive children under certain circumstances.
- States that nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be construed to prevent the adopting parent or parents of a child from entering into a voluntary agreement with the child’s birth relatives, including any siblings of the child, to permit continuing contact between the child and the birth relatives, including any siblings if the agreement is found by the court to have been executed voluntarily and to be in the best interests of the child at the time the adoption petition is granted.
- Requires that any court order permanently placing the minor shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the sibling.
- Requires a court, at the time when it considers an adoption petition, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- Requires, to the extent practicable, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement on a date after termination of parental rights and prior to finalization of the adoption.
- Allows the agency to comply with the requirement in #5, above, by allowing a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- Provides that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement in one of the following two circumstances: (a) If the agency determines that such a meeting or postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or (b) The child requests that a meeting does not occur.
- Allows the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting and provides that if the court determines by a preponderence of the evidence that a postadoption sibling contact agreement or a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute such an agreement is contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, the reasons for the determination shall be noted in the court order, and the meeting is not required to occur.
- Clarifies that no child, sibling, or other party is required to attend a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code and that a county placing agency may convene a meeting if not all of the parties are secured to attend.
- Requires counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court to be notified of, and may attend, both the meeting and the hearing described above.
- Clarifies that after the adoption petition has been granted by the court, the adoption cannot be set aside due to the failure to comply with a postadoption sibling contact agreement.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, pursuant to federal law, states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being; if the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless it is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671 (a).)
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that siblings who are removed from the home will be placed in foster care together, unless the placement is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. (Welfare & Inst. Code Section 16002. All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Requires a social worker, where possible and appropriate, to place a child, who has been removed from his or her parents or guardian because of abuse or neglect, together with his or her siblings or half-siblings also being removed, or to describe continuing efforts to place them together if they are not initially placed together, or to explain why placing them together is inappropriate. (Section 306.5.)
- Requires, when the court has ordered removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, the court to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. (Section 361.2.)
- Requires any order placing a child in foster care to provide for visitation between a child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. (Section 362.1.)
- Allows any person to petition the juvenile court to assert a sibling relationship by blood, adoption, or through affinity with a legal or biological parent with a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, and to request visitation with that child. (Section 388.)
- Allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement. (Sections 366.26, 366.29.)
- Authorizes a parent to terminate a postadoptive sibling contact agreement if it is determined by the parent that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child. (Section 366.26.)
- Requires that if a minor has continuing involvement with a parent or legal guardian, that the parent or legal guardian shall be involved in the planning for permanent placement and that any court order permanently placing the minor shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parent or legal guardian. (Section 727.3.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 2008, Congress passed the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act), which, among other things, made it a priority that siblings entering the foster care system be placed together by requiring states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, the Act requires that visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being.
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740 (Steinberg), Chap. 805, Stats. 1999.) Since then California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships. These laws have served to promote sibling relationships when both children are in the dependency system, but recent, unpublished cases indicate that courts will not grant visitation in the rare case where one sibling is in the foster system and the other remains in the legal custody of the parent.
California Law has Long Recognized the Importance of Maintaining Sibling Relationships. California law has repeatedly recognized the importance of maintaining and developing sibling relationships for children in foster care. Key legislation in this area includes AB 743 (Portantino), Chap. 560, Stat. 2010, which required greater notice if siblings are to be separated; AB 705 (Steinberg), Chap. 747, Stats. 2001, which ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate; AB 1987 (Steinberg), Chap. 909, Stats. 2000, which recognized the importance of sibling relationships and required the court to consider the existence, nature and impact of a dependent child's sibling relationships on the child's placement and planning for legal permanence; and AB 740 (Steinberg), Chap. 805, Stats. 1999, which expedited the procedure for permanent placement of a sibling group.
The bond between siblings, especially those in foster care, cannot be underestimated:
Sibling relationships are emotionally powerful and critically important not only in childhood but over the course of a lifetime. As children, siblings form a child’s first peer group, and they typically spend more time with each other than with anyone else. Children learn social skills, particularly in sharing and managing conflict, from negotiating with brothers and sisters. Sibling relationships can provide a significant source of continuity throughout a child’s lifetime and are likely to be the longest relationships that most people experience. . . .
In many families involved with child welfare, sibling relationships take on more importance because they can provide the support and nurture that are not consistently provided by parents. For children entering care, siblings can serve as a buffer against the worst effects of harsh circumstances. While sibling relationships in particular families experiencing adverse situations do not always compensate for other deficits, research has validated that, for many children, sibling relationships do promote resilience. (Child Welfare Information Gateway, Sibling Issues in Foster Care and Adoption 4-5 (Jan. 2013).)
Despite Legal Recognition of the Importance of Sibling Relationships, California’s Foster Care System Continues to Separate Siblings in Too Many Cases: Recent data reveal that children in foster care are often not placed with all their siblings. Foster children in California are placed together with all their siblings in only slightly over half of all cases. Slightly older data reveal that in only about 29 percent of cases, foster youth have been separated from all of their siblings. (Legislative Analyst’s Office, Protecting Children From Abuse and Neglect: Trends and Issues 29 (Aug. 2013); B. Needell et al., Child Welfare Services Reports for California (2008).)
This Bill Seeks to Further Ensure that Courts Protect a Foster Child's Relationship With His or Her Siblings, Including After the Child is Adopted. Existing law seeks to ensure that social workers and courts protect the relationship between siblings throughout the foster care process. For example, a social worker is required to place a foster child together with his or her siblings or half-siblings who are also removed from parental custody, whenever possible and appropriate. (Section 306.5.) If not possible or appropriate, the social worker is required to describe continuing efforts to place the siblings together, or to explain why placing them together is inappropriate. (Ibid.) Existing law also requires a court, after ordering removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. (Section 361.2.)
When siblings are not or cannot be placed together, existing law requires visitation between a foster child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. (Section 362.1.) Finally, existing law allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement. (Sections 366.26, 366.29.)
In its original form, this bill required a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to convene a child and family team meeting to determine whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized. As most recently amended, however, the bill is far more narrow in its scope. As currently in print, the bill would make a number of changes in exiting law to ensure that sibling relationships are considered and facilitated, even after a foster child is adopted. It would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized. The bill also requires a court to include, in any court order permanently placing the minor, a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the sibling. Finally, as currently in print, the bill requires, to the extent practicable, the county placing agency to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement. The language for this “requirement” is very weak because of the phrase “to the extent practicable,” which is reasonably read to allow a county placing agency to convene a meeting if it wished to do so or not convene a meeting for any reason (or no reason at all). Also, the current language provides no exceptions to the meeting “requirement” in situations where it may not be in a child’s best interest to have contact with his or her sibling(s), perhaps because of abuse or the child’s preference. Nor is there a mechanism for a child (and a court) to review a county placing agency’s failure to convene a meeting, or to ensure that counsel to the child or siblings may attend both the meeting and the hearing.
Therefore, the author proposes a number of clarifying amendments (on Page 16, starting at line 26) that leave the weak “requirement” language in place, but make the following clarifications and improvements to the bill:
- Allow the county placing agency to delegate the responsibility for convening a meeting to a nonprofit organization authorized to provide permanency placement and postadoption mediation for adoptive and birth families to facilitate the meeting and develop the agreement.
- Specify that the county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code for two specific reasons: (1) The county placing agency determines that a meeting or a postadoption sibling contact agreement would be contrary to the safety and well-being of the child, or (2) The child requests that a meeting does not occur.
- Allow the child to petition the court for an order requiring the county placing agency to convene a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code.
- Require counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court to be notified of, and allows them to attend, both the meeting and the hearing.
- Provide that no child, sibling, or other party is required to attend a meeting to decide whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement pursuant to Section 8616.5 of the Family Code.
These new provisions, especially the specific parameters for when a county placing agency is not required to convene a meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, will help ensure that sibling interaction and contact, and the agreements to facilitate such relationships, occur when appropriate. By specifying the two reasons why a county agency is not required to convene a meeting, the bill as proposed to be amended implies that a county placing agency is required to convene a meeting except in the case of one or both of those circumstances. This amendment significantly furthers the purpose of the bill and ensures that the mechanism to further that purpose, the meeting for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, is likely to occur in appropriate circumstances (and not in circumstances where a meeting would be inappropriate, such as when a child objects to it).
Author’s Statement Regarding the Need for the Bill. According to the author:
Despite the clear intent of federal law, advocates have observed that implementation of programs to maintain sibling relationships are ultimately a function of state and local agencies. These agencies sometimes allow adoptions to move forward without full consideration of how best to maintain sibling connections in each specific case.
. . .
For an adoption to establish a lasting commitment between the child and adopting parents, these elements of healing and support are essential. Research also confirms that sustaining some of the relationships with the biological family, especially siblings, is most effective in combating the negative effects of being removed from one's family and placed into foster care.
SB 1060 (Leno) will maintain sibling relationships through the adoption process by elevating the function of the post adoption contact agreement between siblings and prospective adoptive children prior to adoption finalization.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: California Youth Connection, the sponsor of SB 1060, writes the following in support of the bill:
Despite the protections already in statute meant to encourage and strengthen sibling connections within the foster care system, we see a shocking decline of urgency as a child or youth approaches the adoption process. Consequently, siblings in foster care are being separated. By no fault of their own, older siblings who do not live with their younger siblings are being shut out of the adoption process. This gap in the system is reflective of both poor communication and a lack of coordinated services for the adoptee and where many sibling relationships are severed.
Specifically, SB 1060 (Leno) will address this gap and elevate the importance of sibling relationships within the adoption process. This is vital to support the well-being for both the adoptee and siblings involved. SB1060 will maintain sibling relationships throughout the adoption process by empowering the child welfare counties to convene a meeting to negotiate the creation of a post adoption contact.
RECENT SIMILAR LEGISLATION: SB 1099 (Steinberg, Ch. 773, Stats. 2014) required the court to consider relationships between dependent and non-dependent siblings, required additional documentation related to sibling relationships in social workers’ reports, and authorized a dependent child to request sibling visitation, as specified.
AB 743 (Portantino, Ch. 560, Stats. 2010) made changes to the standards for sibling visitation, interaction, and placement for children in foster care to conform with the federal Fostering Connections to Success Act.
AB 408 (Steinberg, Ch. 813, Stats. 2003) made changes in dependency law to help achieve permanency for older children, including authorizing the court to make orders to ensure that sibling relationships are maintained.
AB 705 (Steinberg, Ch. 747, Stats. of 2001) ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate.
AB 1987 (Steinberg, Ch. 909, Stats. 2000) recognized the importance of sibling relationships and required the court to consider the existence, nature, and impact of a dependent child’s sibling relationships on the child’s placement and planning for legal permanence.
AB 740 (Steinberg, Ch. 805, Stats. 1999) expedited the procedure for permanent placement of a sibling group.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support – as amended May 31, 2016
California Youth Connection (sponsor)
California Alliance of Child and Family Services
Children Now
County Welfare Directors Association of California
John Burton Foundation
National Association of Social Workers
Support – as introduced (February 16, 2019) or amended April 19, 2016
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
California CASA Association
Children’s Law Center of California
Families Now
Public Counsel
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1060
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/12/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
SOURCE: California Youth Connection
DIGEST: This bill requires the county placing agency, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling of the child, the prospective adoptive parent, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, and requires, at the time of consideration of an adoption petition, the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement.
Existing law:
- Requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless it is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
- States the intent of the Legislature to ensure that siblings who are removed from the home will be placed in foster care together, unless the placement is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling, including requiring the state or county to do the following after parental rights are terminated and the court orders the dependent child to be placed for adoption:
- Include in training for prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of maintaining sibling relationships;
- Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about the child’s siblings, as specified; and
- Encourage the prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact between the child and any siblings. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 16002.)
- Requires, when the court has ordered removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, the court to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 361.2.)
- Requires any order placing a child in foster care to provide for visitation between a child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 362.1.)
- Allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement. (Welf. & Inst. Code Secs. 366.26 and 366.29.)
- Authorizes a parent to terminate a postadoptive sibling contact agreement if it is determined by the parent that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 366.26.)
This bill:
- Requires, when parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption placing agency, to the extent practicable, to convene a meeting with the child, the sibling of the child, the prospective adoptive parent, and a facilitator for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily execute a postadoption sibling contact agreement, as specified.
- Requires, at the time of consideration of an adoption petition, the court to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- Makes other conforming and technical changes.
Background
In October 2008, Congress passed, and President Bush signed, the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act) to promote permanent families for children and youth in foster care by providing greater assistance to relative caregivers and improving incentives for adoption. The Act also extends assistance for foster children to age 21 and improves education and health care for children and youth in foster care. Further, the Act requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740, Chapter 805, Statutes of 1999.) Since then California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships. Creating another mechanism by which the court may further protect sibling relationships, SB 1099 (Steinberg, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2014) gave dependency courts the authority to order visitation between dependent and non-dependent siblings in specified circumstances. This bill seeks to further protect sibling relationships by requiring the county, as soon as parental rights are terminated and the court orders the dependent child to be placed for adoption, to convene a meeting with the relevant parties for the purpose of discussing a postadoption sibling contact agreement. This bill also, at the adoption proceeding, requires the court to inquire into the status of the postadoption sibling contact agreement.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Team meetings: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for additional meetings to the extent the meetings consist of child and family team (CFT) members. Estimated costs assuming only 50 percent of the 6,400 annual dependent adoptions require a CFT meeting could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million annually based on the average duration of 3.7 hours per CFT meeting and the attendance of one or two local agency representatives. These costs do not include any additional time CFT members may incur to identify and notify non-dependent siblings to coordinate these meetings. Actual costs could be substantially higher to the extent the proportion of dependents with siblings is higher than assumed above, or more than two CFT members representing local agencies are in attendance at the meeting.
- Sibling visitation: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on numerous factors that are unknown at this time, including but not limited to the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration).
- Court impact: Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the CFT meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
- Proposition 30*: Exempts the state from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “public safety services” including the provision of child welfare services, however, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the state.
California Youth Connection (source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
California Alliance of Child and Family Services
California Court Appointed Special Advocates for Children
Children Now
Children’s Law Center of California
Families NOW
Hillsides
John Burton Foundation
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Public Counsel
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/31/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the California Alliance of Child and Family Services:
“Approximately 20 percent of foster youth exit to adoption each year in California. Every child deserves a permanent family that provides a safe, enriching and loving home, not just for a few months but forever. When reunification with biological parents is no longer possible, adoption by a relative or a nonrelative family gives our foster youth the chance to grow up in a loving and permanent family. Findings have found that healthy relationships with an adopted youth’s biological siblings are critical to the success of the adoption being permanent. SB 1060 strengthens the efforts of continued sibling connections by requiring a facilitated meeting to create a post adoption sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized between the adoptive parents, the prospective adoptive child/children and the siblings who will not be living together. All parties will be allowed to decide whether to voluntarily enter into this agreement. This meeting will elevate the importance of sibling relationships within the adoption process and will improve the lives of foster youth”
5/31/16 21:31:43
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1060 (Leno) - Postadoption contact: siblings of dependent children
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 1060 would require a court in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child to order the convening of a child and family team (CFT) meeting, unless otherwise specified by the court, regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child. This bill would require the court to additionally include in its order for permanent placement of a ward of the juvenile court, a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with siblings of the ward.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 27, 2016
Fiscal Impact:
- Team meetings: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for additional meetings to the extent the meetings consist of CFT members. Estimated costs assuming only 50 percent of the 6,400 annual dependent adoptions require a CFT meeting could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million annually based on the average duration of 3.7 hours per CFT meeting and the attendance of one or two local agency representatives. These costs do not include any additional time CFT members may incur to identify and notify non-dependent siblings to coordinate these meetings. Actual costs could be substantially higher to the extent the proportion of dependents with siblings is higher than assumed above, or more than two CFT members representing local agencies are in attendance at the meeting.
- Sibling visitation: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on numerous factors that are unknown at this time, including but not limited to the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration).
- Court impact: Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the CFT meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
- Proposition 30*: Exempts the State from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “public safety services” including the provision of child welfare services, however, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the State.
Author Amendments:
Define “sibling” and make other technical changes, including the addition of a coauthor.
Committee Amendments:
Move the requirement to convene a meeting, which is not specified as a CFT meeting, to consider postadoption sibling contact earlier in the process under WIC § 16002, as follows:
16002 (e) If parental rights are terminated and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact, except in those cases provided in subdivision (b) where the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety or well-being of the child:
(1) Include in training provided to prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling relationships to the adopted child and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships.
(2) Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child, except the address where the siblings of the children reside. However, this address may be disclosed by court order for good cause shown.
(3) Encourage prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating postadoptive contact between the child who is the subject of a petition for adoption and any siblings of this child. To the extent practical, the county placing agency shall convene a meeting, with the child, sibling or siblings of the child, the prospective adoptive parent or parents, and a facilitator, for the purpose of deciding whether to execute a voluntary postadoption sibling contact agreement, as defined in Section 8616.5 of the Family Code. Counsel to the child and counsel to the siblings who are dependents of the court shall be notified of, and may attend, the meeting.
Additionally, committee amendments require the court, at the time of consideration of an adoption petition under WIC § 366.29, to inquire into the status of the development of a voluntary postadoption contact agreement as described in WIC § 16002(e).
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1060 (Leno) - Postadoption contact: siblings of dependent children
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 1060 would require a court in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child to order the convening of a child and family team (CFT) meeting, unless otherwise specified by the court, regarding postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child. This bill would require the court to additionally include in its order for permanent placement of a ward of the juvenile court, a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with siblings of the ward.
Fiscal Impact:
- CFT meetings: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for additional CFT meetings. Estimated costs assuming only 50 percent of the 6,400 annual dependent adoptions require a CFT meeting could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million annually based on the average duration of 3.7 hours per CFT meeting and the attendance of one or two local agency representatives. These costs do not include any additional time CFT members may incur to identify and notify non-dependent siblings to coordinate these meetings. Actual costs could be substantially higher to the extent the proportion of dependents with siblings is higher than assumed above, or more than two CFT members representing local agencies are in attendance at the meeting.
- Sibling visitation: Potentially significant increase in state costs (General Fund*) for local agencies to facilitate additional sibling visits for dependent siblings of adopted minors resulting from postadoptive sibling contact agreements. Annual costs would be dependent on numerous factors that are unknown at this time, including but not limited to the number of adopted children with dependent siblings for which postadoptive sibling contact agreements will be ordered, the frequency of visits provided for in the agreements, and the time involved for the social worker to provide for this sibling visitation in each case (distance and duration).
- Court impact: Minor workload impact and potentially future cost savings to the extent the CFT meetings result in less time spent during the court hearing on sibling visitation issues.
- Proposition 30*: Exempts the State from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “public safety services” including the provision of child welfare services, however, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services apply to local agencies only to the extent that the State provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been interpreted through the formal court process to date, however, to the extent the local agency costs resulting from this measure are determined to be applicable under the provisions of Proposition 30 could result in additional costs to the State.
Background:
Existing law provides for the formation of “child and family teams,” convened by the placing agency to engage the child, the child’s family, and other people important to the family and child in meeting the goals of safety, permanency, and well-being of the child. The CFT provides input into the development of a child and family plan that is strengths-based, needs-driven, and culturally relevant. The CFT additionally provides input into the placement decision made by the placing agency and the services to be provided in order to support the child or youth. (Welfare and Institutions Code § 16501.)
This bill would require the court, in adoption proceedings for a dependent child, to order the convening of a CFT meeting with attendance at a minimum to include the prospective adoptive parent(s), the siblings (or their caretakers) of the child, and an adoption facilitator, to decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized.
A postadoptive contact agreement provides for contact between a child and his or her birth parents and other birth relatives, including siblings. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children maintain an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the child, and the agreements are voluntarily entered into by the parties. (Family Code § 8616.5.)
Proposed Law:
This bill would require a court in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child to order the convening of a CFT meeting, unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child, to consider postadoptive contact with the siblings of the child, including but not limited to siblings under the court’s jurisdiction. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the CFT meeting to be attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, and the prospective adoptive parent(s), for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized.
- With regard to minors in foster care who have been declared a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to WIC §§ 601 or 602, requires the court order placing the minor in a permanent placement to include specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the minor’s siblings, if any.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1099 (Steinberg) Chapter 773/2014 required the court to consider relationships between dependent and non-dependent siblings, required additional documentation related to sibling relationships, and authorized a dependent child to request sibling visitation, as specified.
Staff Comments:
The provisions of this bill requiring courts to order the convening of a CFT meeting will likely not pose a significant fiscal burden on the courts, and could, in fact, result in cost savings to the extent the CFT meeting facilitates the time spent in hearing on these matters.
The requirement to add in its orders for permanent placement of wards of the court to include specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the siblings of the minor would be an expansion of existing procedures already in place for visiting arrangements with parents/guardians, and are not estimated to incur significant new costs on the courts.
This bill requires the court to order CFT meetings in adoption proceedings of dependent children unless the meeting would be detrimental to the child. By imposing additional duties on local agencies that participate as CFT members, this bill could result in significant ongoing increases in case management costs.
Based on the number of annual adoptions reported on the Department of Social Services report, Agency Adoption Program Quarterly Statistical Report (AD 56A), over 6,400 agency adoptions were finalized in 2015. It is unknown how many of the dependents to be adopted will have siblings that would prompt a CFT meeting under the provisions of this bill. It is estimated there are over 30,000 dependents with siblings in out-of-home care. Additionally, some dependents will have non-dependent siblings that would additionally prompt a CFT meeting to be convened. Assuming 50 percent of the adoptions require a CFT meeting, estimated costs based on the average CFT meeting duration of 3.7 hours (2016-17 Governor’s Budget assumption) for over 3,200 cases could cost in the range of $850,000 to over $1.7 million.
This estimate assumes one or two CFT members representing local agencies attend the meeting. However, to the extent additional CFT members representing local agencies attend the meeting, costs could be significantly greater. Staff notes that as defined, WIC §16501(a)(4)(B) provides that the CFT includes representatives who provide formal supports to the child or youth and family when appropriate, including, but not limited to, the caregiver, the placing agency caseworker, a representative from a foster family agency or short-term residential treatment center with which a child or youth is placed, a county mental health representative, a representative from the regional center when the child is eligible for regional center service, and a representative of the child’s or youth’s tribe or Indian custodian, as applicable. As appropriate, the CFT may also include other formal supports, such as substance use disorder treatment professionals and educational professionals.
Proposition 30 was passed by the voters in November 2012, and among other provisions, eliminated any potential mandate funding liability for any new program or higher level of service mandated on the counties related to realigned programs, including child welfare services. Rather, legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by 2011 Realignment only apply to local agencies to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Local agencies are not obligated to provide programs or levels of service required by legislation above the level for which funding has been provided. To the extent it is determined that the provisions of this bill result in an increase in overall costs already borne by counties for the provision of child welfare services, the state could potentially elect to, but not be required to, provide funding for the cost increase.
Although the participation of the dependent child in the CFT meeting may be implied, staff notes the bill is silent on the issue of the dependent child’s attendance at the meeting. Attendance of the dependent child may or may not be appropriate at this meeting, depending on the age of the dependent child.
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1060 (Author:Leno)
Version: February 16, 2016
Hearing Date: April 12, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: NR
SUBJECT
Postadoption contact: siblings of dependent children
DESCRIPTION
This bill would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting, attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, and the prospective adoptive parent or parents. The bill would require the participants of the meeting to decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized, and make other conforming changes.
BACKGROUND
In October 2008, Congress passed, and President Bush signed, the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act (Act) to promote permanent families for children and youth in foster care by providing greater assistance to relative caregivers and improving incentives for adoption. The Act also extends assistance for foster children to age 21 and improves education and health care for children and youth in foster care. Further, the Act requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless the visitation is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
Prior to passage of the Act, California was one of the first states to pass legislation promoting sibling visitation for foster children as early as 1999. (See AB 740, Ch. 805, Stats. 1999.) Since then California has enacted several additional statutes to expand legal protections for sibling relationships. Creating another mechanism by which the court may further protect sibling relationships, SB 1099 (Steinberg, Ch. 773, Stats. 2014) gave dependency courts the authority to order visitation between dependent and non-dependent siblings in specified circumstances. This bill seeks to further protect sibling relationships by requiring the court, in an adoption proceeding regarding a dependent child, to order the prospective adoptive parents, the facilitator, the child, and any siblings not party to the adoption, to attend a meeting where the group will decide whether to enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law requires states to use “reasonable efforts” to place siblings together, unless such placement is contrary to their safety or well-being. If the siblings are not placed together, visitation between them must occur frequently, unless it is contrary to their safety or well-being. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 671(a).)
Existing law states the intent of the Legislature to ensure that siblings who are removed from the home will be placed in foster care together, unless the placement is contrary to the safety or well-being of any sibling. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 16002.)
Existing law requires a social worker, where possible and appropriate, to place a child, who has been removed from his or her parents or guardian because of abuse or neglect, together with his or her siblings or half-siblings also being removed, or to describe continuing efforts to place them together if they are not initially placed together, or to explain why placing them together is inappropriate. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 306.5.)
Existing law requires, when the court has ordered removal of a child from the physical custody of a parent, the court to consider whether there are any siblings under the court’s jurisdiction, and the appropriateness of maintaining those sibling relationships. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 361.2.)
Existing law requires any order placing a child in foster care to provide for visitation between a child and any siblings, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that sibling interaction is contrary to the safety and well-being of either child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 362.1.)
Existing law allows any person to petition the juvenile court to assert a sibling relationship by blood, adoption, or through affinity with a legal or biological parent with a child who is a dependent of the juvenile court, and to request visitation with that child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 388.)
Existing law allows a court to include in a final adoption order a postadoptive sibling contact agreement. (Welf. & Inst. Code Secs. 366.26 and 366.29.)
Existing law authorizes a parent to terminate a postadoptive sibling contact agreement if it is determined by the parent that sibling contact poses a threat to the health, safety, or well-being of the adopted child. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 366.26.)
Existing law requires that if a minor has continuing involvement with a parent or legal guardian, that the parent or legal guardian shall be involved in the planning for permanent placement and that any court order permanently placing the minor shall include a specification of the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parent or legal guardian. (Welf. & Inst. Code Sec. 727.3.)
This bill would additionally require siblings to be included in the court order described immediately above.
This bill would require a court, in an adoption proceeding for a dependent child, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting, attended by at least a facilitator, the siblings or their respective caregivers, and the prospective adoptive parent, for the purpose of deciding whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
For California’s foster children and youth, adoption is one of the desired outcomes that the state child welfare system strives to achieve. Unfortunately, siblings in foster care sometimes are separated through the adoption process. For an adoption to establish a lasting commitment between the child and adopting parents, these elements of healing and support are essential. Research also confirms that sustaining some of the relationships with the biological family, especially siblings, is most effective in combating the negative effects of being removed from one’s family and placed into foster care.
- Would require the court, in certain adoption proceedings, to order the convening of a child and family team meeting to discuss future sibling contact
The dependency process utilizes “family teams” to identify the strengths and needs of a dependent child and his or her family, and to help achieve positive outcomes for the safety, permanency, and well-being. Family teams are comprised of individuals convened by the placing agency, including but not limited to the child, family, caregiver, caseworker, and mental health representatives. (See Welf. & Inst. Code Secs. 16501 and 16501.1.)
This bill would require that the court, in adoption proceedings regarding a dependent child, order the convening of a family team meeting with the prospective adoptive parent or parents, the prospective adoptive child, his or her siblings (or their caretakers), and the adoption facilitator. At the meeting, this bill would require that the participants decide whether to voluntarily enter into a postadoptive sibling contact agreement before the adoption is finalized.
A postadoptive contact agreement provides for contact between a child and his or her birth parents and other birth relatives, including siblings. These agreements can also provide for how the adoptive family and birth family will share information about the child in the future. Postadoption contact agreements are intended to ensure children maintain an achievable level of continuing contact when contact is beneficial to the child, and the agreements are voluntarily entered into by the parties. (See Fam. Code Sec. 8616.5.) This bill would necessarily maintain the voluntary nature of these agreements, and would not eliminate the ability of a parent to invalidate agreements that compromise the safety or well-being of their adoptive child, but by requiring that parents, siblings, and facilitators attend a family team meeting, this bill will arguably help facilitate more postadoption contact agreements and thereby fulfill the Legislature’s stated goal of maintaining beneficial sibling relationships.
Staff notes that this bill would require the court to issue orders over parties over whom the court may not have jurisdiction. For example, if a prospective adoptive child had a half sibling who was not in the dependency system, that sibling would not be subject to the court’s jurisdiction, and therefore would not have to follow any orders issued by the court. While it remains to be seen how often jurisdictional issues will arise, this bill will, at the very least, ensure that persons who do fall within the court’s jurisdiction are required to have a conversation about a postadoption sibling contact agreement.
- Would require the court to specifically include siblings in court orders permanently placing a dependent child in a home
To maintain beneficial contact with a child’s birth family, if a dependent minor has continuing involvement with his or her parents or legal guardians, existing law requires that the parents or legal guardians are involved in the planning for a permanent placement. Existing law also requires that the court order placing the minor in a permanent home must include details about the nature and frequency of visiting arrangements with the parents or legal guardians.
This bill would add to the above requirement that the court order must include details regarding the visiting arrangements with siblings. This requirement is consistent with the stated intent of the Legislature to maintain sibling relationships unless contrary to the safety or well-being of the child. This requirement is also consistent with existing considerations the court must take into account with regard to sibling relationships and dependent children.
- Maintaining judicial discretion to ensure the dependent child’s safety
This bill would require the court, in every situation, to order the convening of a family team meeting. Recognizing that there are potential situations where a dependent child would not benefit from any contact with a sibling, the author has agreed to amend the bill to allow a court to exercise discretion. The Executive Committee of the Family Law Section of the State Bar of California (FLEXCOM), among other concerns, expresses concern that this bill would make attendance at the meeting mandatory. FLEXCOM writes, “the bill does not include any exceptions for opting out, such as for cases of sibling abuse, or cases where siblings have been privately adopted outside the dependency system and who may not be interested in participating. In addition, there is no clarifying language that any child attending regardless of age shall be there with their respective caregiver and/or counsel.”
The language below would permit a court to bypass the ordering of the meeting only if the court determined that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child. This arguably strikes the correct balance and will ensure that families are meeting to discuss postadoption contact agreements, in all but the rarest cases, where the court finds that sibling contact may be harmful to the child.
Author’s amendment:
On page 2, line 15, after “(b)” insert “Unless the court finds that such a meeting may be detrimental to the child,”
Support: California Alliance of Child and Family Services; Children Now; Families NOW; Hillsides; National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Opposition: None known
HISTORY
Source: California Youth Connection
Related Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 1099 (Steinberg, Ch. 773, Stats. 2014) required the court to consider relationships between dependent and non-dependent siblings, required additional documentation related to sibling relationships in social workers’ reports, and authorized a dependent child to request sibling visitation, as specified.
AB 743 (Portantino, Ch. 560, Stats. 2010) made changes to the standards for sibling visitation, interaction, and placement for children in foster care to conform with the federal Fostering Connections to Success Act.
AB 408 (Steinberg, Ch. 813, Stats. 2003) made changes in dependency law to help achieve permanency for older children, including authorizing the court to make orders to ensure that sibling relationships are maintained.
AB 705 (Steinberg, Ch. 747, Stats. of 2001) ensured that sibling relationships are considered at all appropriate hearings and siblings are placed together when appropriate.
AB 1987 (Steinberg, Ch. 909, Stats. 2000) recognized the importance of sibling relationships and required the court to consider the existence, nature, and impact of a dependent child’s sibling relationships on the child’s placement and planning for legal permanence.
AB 740 (Steinberg, Ch. 805, Stats. 1999) expedited the procedure for permanent placement of a sibling group.
**************
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Floor
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):