SB 1110: Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-05-31
Existing law authorizes a county to establish a pretrial diversion program for defendants who have been charged with a misdemeanor offense and authorizes other diversion programs, including for defendants with cognitive developmental disabilities, defendants in nonviolent drug cases, and traffic violations.
This bill would require the Board of State and Community Corrections to approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program. The bill would require the LEAD pilot programs to authorize designated officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified controlled substances offenses, including possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance, or prostitution, to treatment programs and services in lieu of that arrest.
This bill, until January 1, 2020, would establish the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program, to be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections, to improve public safety and reduce recidivism by increasing the availability and use of social service resources while reducing costs to law enforcement agencies and courts stemming from repeated incarceration. The bill would require the board to award grants, on a competitive basis, to up to 3 jurisdictions to establish LEAD programs and would require the board to establish minimum standards, funding schedules, and procedures for awarding grants. The bill would establish requirements for referral of people who may be arrested for, or who have a history of, low-level drug offenses or prostitution, as defined, to social services in lieu of prosecution. The bill would require the board to contract with a nonprofit research entity, university, or college to evaluate the effectiveness of the LEAD program and submit a report of the findings to the Governor and the Legislature by January 1, 2020.
Existing law authorizes a county to establish a pretrial diversion program for defendants who have been charged with a misdemeanor offense and authorizes other diversion programs, including for defendants with cognitive developmental disabilities, defendants in nonviolent drug cases, and traffic violations.
This bill would require the Board of State and Community Corrections to approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program. The bill would require the LEAD pilot programs to authorize designated officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified controlled substances offenses, including possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance, or prostitution, to treatment programs and services in lieu of that arrest.
(a)The Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program is hereby established. The purpose of the LEAD program is to improve public safety and reduce recidivism by increasing the availability and use of social service resources while reducing costs to law enforcement agencies and courts stemming from repeated incarceration.
(b)LEAD pilot programs shall be consistent with the following principles, implemented to address and reflect the priorities of the community in which the program exists:
(1)Providing intensive case management services and an individually tailored intervention plan that acts as a blueprint for assisting LEAD participants.
(2)Prioritizing temporary and permanent housing that includes individualized supportive services, without preconditions of drug or alcohol treatment or abstinence from drugs or alcohol.
(3)Employing human and social service resources in coordination with law enforcement in a manner that improves individual outcomes and community safety, and promotes community wellness.
(4)Participation in LEAD services shall be voluntary throughout the duration of the program and shall not require abstinence from drug or alcohol use as a condition of continued participation.
1001.86.(a)The LEAD program shall be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections.
(b)The board shall award grants, on a competitive basis, to up to three jurisdictions as authorized by this chapter. The board shall establish minimum standards, funding schedules, and procedures for awarding grants, which shall take into consideration, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(1)Information from the applicant demonstrating a clear understanding of the programs purpose and the applicants willingness and ability to implement the LEAD program as described in this chapter.
(2)Key local partners who would be committed to, and involved in, the development and successful implementation of a LEAD program, including, but not limited to, balanced representation from law enforcement agencies, prosecutorial agencies, public defenders and defense counsel, public health and social services agencies, case management service providers, and any other entities identified by the applicant as integral to the successful implementation of a LEAD program in the jurisdiction.
(3)The jurisdictions capacity and commitment to coordinate social services, law enforcement efforts, and justice system decisionmaking processes, and to work to ensure that the discretionary decisions made by each participant in the administration of the program operates in a manner consistent with the purposes of this chapter.
(c)Successful grant applicants shall collect and maintain data pertaining to the effectiveness of the program as indicated by the board in the request for proposals.
1001.87.(a)LEAD programs funded pursuant to this chapter shall consist of a strategy of effective intervention for eligible participants consistent with the following gateways to services:
(1)Prebooking referral. As an alternative to arrest, a law enforcement officer may take or refer a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for any of the offenses in subdivision (b) to a case manager to be screened for immediate crisis services and to schedule a complete assessment intake interview. Participation in LEAD diversion shall be voluntary, and the person may decline to participate in the program at any time. Criminal charges based on the conduct for which a person is diverted to LEAD shall not be filed, provided that the person finishes the complete assessment intake interview within a period set by the local jurisdictional partners, but not to exceed 30 days after the referral.
(2)Social contact referral. A law enforcement officer may refer an individual to LEAD whom he or she believes is at high risk of arrest in the future for any of the crimes specified in subdivision (b), provided that the individual meets the criteria specified in this paragraph and expresses interest in voluntarily participating in the program. LEAD may accept these referrals if the program has capacity after responding to prebooking diversion referrals described in paragraph (1). All social contact referrals to LEAD shall meet the following criteria:
(A)Verification by law enforcement that the individual has had prior involvement with low-level drug activity or prostitution. Verification shall consist of any of the following:
(i)Criminal history records, including, but not limited to, prior police reports, arrests, jail bookings, criminal charges, or convictions indicating that he or she was engaged in low-level drug or prostitution activity.
(ii)Law enforcement has directly observed the individuals low-level drug or prostitution activity on prior occasions.
(iii)Law enforcement has a reliable basis of information to believe that the individual is engaged in low-level drug or prostitution activity, including, but not limited to, information provided by another first responder, a professional, or a credible community member.
(B)The individuals prior involvement with low-level drug or prostitution activity occurred within the LEAD pilot program area.
(C)The individuals prior involvement with low-level drug or prostitution activity occurred within 24 months of the date of referral.
(D)The individual does not have a pending case in drug court or mental health court.
(E)The individual is not prohibited, by means of an existing no-contact order, temporary restraining order, or antiharassment order, from making contact with a current LEAD participant.
(b)The following offenses are eligible for either prebooking diversion, social contact referral, or both:
(1)Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(2)Sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(3)Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(4)Being under the influence of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(5)Being under the influence of alcohol and a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(6)Prostitution pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 647.
1001.88.(a)Services provided pursuant to this chapter may include, but are not limited to, case management, housing, medical care, mental health care, treatment for alcohol or substance use disorders, nutritional counseling and treatment, psychological counseling, employment, employment training and education, civil legal services, and system navigation. Grant funding may be used to support any of the following:
(1)Project management and community engagement.
(2)Temporary services and treatment necessary to stabilize a participants condition, including necessary housing.
(3)Outreach and direct service costs for services described in this section.
(4)Civil legal services for LEAD participants.
(5)Dedicated prosecutorial resources, including for coordinating any nondiverted criminal cases of LEAD participants.
(6)Dedicated law enforcement resources, including for overtime required for participation in operational meetings and training.
(7)Training and technical assistance from experts in the implementation of LEAD in other jurisdictions.
(8)Collecting and maintaining the data necessary for program evaluation.
(b)The board shall contract with a nonprofit research entity, university, or college to evaluate the effectiveness of the LEAD program. The evaluation design shall include measures to assess the cost-benefit outcomes of LEAD programs compared to booking and prosecution, and may include evaluation elements such as comparing outcomes for LEAD participants to similarly situated offenders who are arrested and booked, the number of jail bookings, total number of jail days, the prison incarceration rate, subsequent felony and misdemeanor arrests or convictions, and costs to the criminal justice and court systems. Savings will be compared to costs of LEAD participation. By January 1, 2020 a report of the findings shall be submitted to the Governor and the Legislature pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(c)The board may contract with experts in the implementation of LEAD in other jurisdictions for the purpose of providing technical assistance to participating jurisdictions.
(d)The board shall not spend more than 5 percent annually of the moneys allocated to the program for its administrative costs, excluding the contracts authorized in subdivisions (b) and (c).
1001.89.This chapter shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2020, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date.
SECTION 1.Chapter 2.92 (commencing with Section 1001.85) is added to Title 6 of Part 2 of the Penal Code, to read:2.92.Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion1001.85.(a)The Board of State and Community Corrections shall approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program. Interested counties shall submit applications to the board, including information on the manner in which the program will operate in that county, as required by the board.
(b)LEAD pilot programs shall include both of the following:
(1)Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for any of the following offenses to a drug treatment facility or program for treatment, including detoxification and related services in lieu of that arrest:
(A)Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(B)Sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(C)Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(D)Being under the influence of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(E)Being under the influence of alcohol and a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(2)Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for prostitution pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 647, to an agency or entity that will provide services to that person in lieu of that arrest. Services pursuant to this paragraph may include, but are not limited to, housing, medical care, child care, treatment for alcohol or substance abuse, nutritional counseling and treatment, psychological counseling, employment, and employment training and education.
(c)The Legislature finds and declares that a program similar to the LEAD program has been demonstrated in Seattle, Washington to lower recidivism of participants, increase cooperation by participants in treatment and related programs, and significantly reduce law enforcement and court costs.
(a)The Board of State and Community Corrections shall approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program. Interested counties shall submit applications to the board, including information on the manner in which the program will operate in that county, as required by the board.
(b)LEAD pilot programs shall include both of the following:
(1)Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for any of the following offenses to a drug treatment facility or program for treatment, including detoxification and related services in lieu of that arrest:
(A)Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(B)Sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
(C)Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(D)Being under the influence of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(E)Being under the influence of alcohol and a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
(2)Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for prostitution pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 647, to an agency or entity that will provide services to that person in lieu of that arrest. Services pursuant to this paragraph may include, but are not limited to, housing, medical care, child care, treatment for alcohol or substance abuse, nutritional counseling and treatment, psychological counseling, employment, and employment training and education.
(c)The Legislature finds and declares that a program similar to the LEAD program has been demonstrated in Seattle, Washington to lower recidivism of participants, increase cooperation by participants in treatment and related programs, and significantly reduce law enforcement and court costs.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 3, 2016 | August 3 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 28, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 4. Page 4124.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 4.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 4003.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 20, 2016 | Set for hearing May 27. |
| May 9, 2016 | May 9 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 29, 2016 | Set for hearing May 9. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1. Page 3613.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2016 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 17, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2016 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1110 Hancock | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 28, 2016
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1110
Author:(Hancock) – As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
SUMMARY: Establishes the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program in up to three jurisdictions where law enforcement officers can take or refer individuals directly to services without pursuing criminal charges. Specifically, this bill:
- States that purpose of the LEAD program is to improve public safety and reduce recidivism by increasing the availability and use of social service resources while reducing costs to law enforcement agencies and courts stemming from repeated incarceration.
- Specifies that LEAD pilot programs shall be consistent with the following principles:
- Providing intensive case management services and an individually tailored intervention plan;
- Prioritizing temporary and permanent housing that includes individualized supportive services, without preconditions of drug or alcohol treatment or abstinence from drugs or alcohol;
- Employing human and social service resources in coordination with law enforcement in a manner that improves individual outcomes and community safety, and promotes community wellness; and
- Participation in LEAD services shall be voluntary throughout the duration of the program and shall not require abstinence from drug or alcohol use as a condition of continued participation.
- Providing intensive case management services and an individually tailored intervention plan;
- States that the LEAD program shall be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC).
- Specifies that BSCC shall award grants, on a competitive basis, to up to three jurisdictions.
- Provides that BSCC shall establish minimum standards, funding schedules, and procedures for awarding grants, based on specified criteria.
- Requires successful grant applicants to collect and maintain data pertaining to the effectiveness of the program as indicated by the board in the request for proposals.
- Specifies that LEAD programs funded pursuant to this bill shall provide services to individuals by one of the following options:
- Prebooking referral. As an alternative to arrest, a law enforcement officer may take or refer a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified offenses to a case manager to be screened for immediate crisis services and to schedule a complete assessment intake interview. Participation in LEAD diversion shall be voluntary, and the person may decline to participate in the program at any time. Criminal charges based on the conduct for which a person is diverted to LEAD shall not be filed, provided that the person finishes the complete assessment intake interview within a period set by the local jurisdictional partners, but not to exceed 30 days after the referral.
- Social contact referral. A law enforcement officer may refer an individual to LEAD whom he or she believes is at high risk of arrest in the future for any of the specified crimes, provided that the individual meets the criteria specified in this paragraph and expresses interest in voluntarily participating in the program. LEAD may accept these referrals if the program has capacity after responding to prebooking diversion referrals.
- Prebooking referral. As an alternative to arrest, a law enforcement officer may take or refer a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified offenses to a case manager to be screened for immediate crisis services and to schedule a complete assessment intake interview. Participation in LEAD diversion shall be voluntary, and the person may decline to participate in the program at any time. Criminal charges based on the conduct for which a person is diverted to LEAD shall not be filed, provided that the person finishes the complete assessment intake interview within a period set by the local jurisdictional partners, but not to exceed 30 days after the referral.
- Specifies that all social contact referrals to LEAD shall meet the following criteria:
- Verification by law enforcement that the individual has had prior involvement with low-level drug activity or prostitution, based on specified criteria;
- The individual’s prior involvement with low-level drug or prostitution activity occurred within the LEAD pilot program area;
- The individual’s prior involvement with low-level drug or prostitution activity occurred within 24 months of the date of referral;
- The individual does not have a pending case in drug court or mental health court; and
- The individual is not prohibited, by means of an existing no-contact order, temporary restraining order, or antiharassment order, from making contact with a current LEAD participant.
- Verification by law enforcement that the individual has had prior involvement with low-level drug activity or prostitution, based on specified criteria;
- States that the following offenses are eligible for either prebooking diversion, social contact referral, or both:
- Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption;
- Sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption;
- Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance;
- Being under the influence of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance;
- Being under the influence of alcohol and a controlled substance or other prohibited substance; or
- Prostitution.
- Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption;
- States that the services provided to those participating in LEAD diversion include, but are not limited to, case management, housing, medical care, mental health care, treatment for alcohol or substance use disorders, nutritional counseling and treatment, psychological counseling, employment, employment training and education, civil legal services, and system navigation.
- States that grant funding may be used to support any of the following:
- Project management and community engagement;
- Temporary services and treatment necessary to stabilize a participant’s condition, including necessary housing;
- Outreach and direct service costs for services described in this section;
- Civil legal services for LEAD participants;
- Dedicated prosecutorial resources, including for coordinating any nondiverted criminal cases of LEAD participants;
- Dedicated law enforcement resources, including for overtime required for participation in operational meetings and training;
- Training and technical assistance from experts in the implementation of LEAD in other jurisdictions; and
- Collecting and maintaining the data necessary for program evaluation.
- Project management and community engagement;
- Requires BSCC to contract with a nonprofit research entity, university, or college to evaluate the effectiveness of the LEAD program.
- Requires a report of the findings shall be submitted to the Governor and the Legislature, as specified, by January 1, 2020.
- States that BSCC shall not spend more than five percent annually of the moneys allocated to the program for its administrative costs, excluding specified costs.
- The provisions of this bill will sunset as of January 1, 2020.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the entry of judgment may be deferred with respect to a defendant charged with specific controlled substance offenses if they meet specific criteria, including no prior convictions for any offense involving a controlled substance and have had no prior felony convictions within five years. (Pen. Code, §1000.)
- Authorizes the presiding judge of the superior court, or a judge designated by the presiding judge, together with the district attorney and the public defender, to agree in writing to establish and conduct a preguilty plea drug court for specified drug related offenses, wherein criminal proceedings are suspended without a plea of guilty for designated defendants. (Pen. Code, § 1000.5, subd. (a).)
- States if there is no agreement in writing for a preguilty plea program by the presiding judge or his or her designee, the district attorney, and the public defender, the program shall be operated as a DEJ program as provided in this chapter. (Pen. Code, § 1000.5, subd. (a).)
- Provides upon successful completion of a DEJ program, the arrest upon which the judgment was deferred shall be deemed to have never occurred. The defendant may indicate in response to any question concerning his or her prior criminal record that he or she was not arrested or granted DEJ for the offense, except as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1000.4, subd. (a).)
- Authorizes the District Attorney to approve pretrial diversion programs within the county of their jurisdiction.(Pen. Code, § 1001.2.)
- Specifies that pretrial diversion refers to the procedure of postponing prosecution of an offense filed as a misdemeanor either temporarily or permanently at any point in the judicial process from the point at which the accused is charged until adjudication. (Pen. Code, § 1001.1.)
- States that at no time shall a defendant be required to make an admission of guilt as a prerequisite for placement in a pretrial diversion program. (Pen. Code, § 1001.3.)
- Provides that a divertee is entitled to a hearing, as set forth by law, before his or her pretrial diversion can be terminated for cause. (Pen. Code, § 1001.4.)
- States that if the divertee has performed satisfactorily during the period of pretrial diversion, the criminal charges shall be dismissed at the end of the period of diversion. (Pen. Code, § 1001.7.)
- Specifies that upon successful completion of a pretrial diversion program, the arrest upon which the diversion was based shall be deemed to have never occurred. The divertee may indicate in response to any question concerning his or her prior criminal record that he or she was not arrested or diverted for the offense, except as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1001.9, subd. (a).)
- States that a record pertaining to an arrest resulting in successful completion of a pretrial diversion program shall not, without the divertee's consent, be used in any way that could result in the denial of any employment, benefit, license, or certificate. (Pen. Code, § 1001.9, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that the divertee shall be advised that, regardless of his or her successful completion of pretrial diversion, the arrest upon which the diversion was based may be disclosed by the Department of Justice in response to any peace officer application request. (Pen. Code, § 1001.9, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that pretrial diversion shall not apply in the following situations (Pen. Code, § 1001.51, subd. (a)):
- The defendant's record does not indicate that probation or parole has ever been revoked without thereafter being completed;
- The defendant's record does not indicate that he has been diverted pursuant to this chapter within five years prior to the filing of the accusatory pleading which charges the divertible offense; and,
- The defendant has never been convicted of a felony, and has not been convicted of a misdemeanor within five years prior to the filing of the accusatory pleading which charges the divertible offense.
- The defendant's record does not indicate that probation or parole has ever been revoked without thereafter being completed;
- Specifies that pretrial diversion shall not apply if the defendant is charged with a specified misdemeanor. (Pen. Code, § 1001.51, subd. (c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "As the United States addresses the urgent crisis of mass criminalization and incarceration, there is a clear need to find viable, effective alternatives. Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) is an effort to prevent people from entering the criminal justice system unnecessarily. LEAD uses police diversion and community-based, trauma-informed care systems to improve public safety and reduce law violations by people who participate in the program.
“In a LEAD program, police officers exercise discretionary authority at point of contact to divert individuals to a community-based, harm-reduction intervention. When officers encounter individuals who have violated the law due to unmet behavioral health needs, the officers refer the individuals to a trauma-informed intensive case management program. In lieu of the normal criminal justice system cycle – booking, detention, prosecution, conviction and incarceration – the case management program provides a wide range of support services for the individual, often including transitional and permanent housing and/or drug treatment.
“After three years of operation in Seattle, a 2015 independent, non-randomized controlled outcome study found that LEAD participants were 58% less likely to be arrested after enrollment in the program compared to a control group that went through the usual criminal justice processing. With significant reductions in recidivism, LEAD functions as a public safety program that has the potential to decrease the number of those arrested as well as improve the health and well-being of people struggling at the intersection of poverty and drug and mental health problems.”
“Therefore SB 1110 seeks to respond to unaddressed public health and human service needs – addiction, untreated mental illness, homelessness, and extreme poverty – through a public health framework that reduces reliance on the formal criminal justice system. The bill would approve three counties for the establishment of a LEAD pilot program and would create a sunset date of 3 years.”
- Pretrial Diversion and Deferred Entry of Judgment: Existing law provides avenues for diversion on misdemeanor charges through the court system. The statutory framework allows for diversion by means of deferred entry of judgment or pretrial diversion.
In deferred entry of judgment, a defendant determined by the prosecutor to be eligible for deferred entry of judgment must plead guilty to the underlying drug possession charge. The court then defers entry of judgment and places the defendant in a rehabilitation and education program. If he or she successfully completes the program, the guilty plea is withdrawn and the arrest is deemed to have not occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, the court immediately imposes judgment and sentences the defendant.
In pretrial diversion, the criminal charges against an eligible defendant are set aside and the defendant is placed in a rehabilitation and education program treatment. If the defendants successfully complete the program, the arrest is dismissed and deemed to not have occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, criminal charges are reinstated. Existing law provides that counties can set up a misdemeanor pretrial diversion program if the District Attorney, Courts and the Public Defender agree.
This bill would establish a pilot diversion program where the diversion would take place before an individual went to court. An individual’s initial contact with the criminal justice system is with law enforcement. A LEAD program would provide an opportunity for diversion at that first contact with the criminal justice system, as opposed to later in the process once criminal charges have been filed.
This bill would provide that the pilot project would be administered by the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC). BSSC would be authorized to provide grant money for up to three jurisdictions to establish a LEAD program with specific guidelines. - LEAD Program in Seattle: In 2011, LEAD program was developed and launched in Seattle, Washington. The program was a new harm-reduction oriented process for responding to low-level offenses such as drug possession, sales and prostitution.
The LEAD program in Seattle was collaboration between police, prosecutors, civil rights advocates, public defenders, political leaders, mental health and drug treatment providers, housing providers, other service agencies and business and neighborhood leaders.
In a LEAD program, police officers exercise discretionary authority at point of contact to divert individuals to a community-based, harm-reduction intervention. When officers encounter individuals who have violated the law due to unmet behavioral health needs, the officers refer the individuals to a trauma-informed intensive case management program. In lieu of the normal criminal justice system cycle – booking, detention, prosecution, conviction and incarceration – the case management program provides a wide range of support services for the individual, often including transitional and permanent housing and/or drug treatment.
The LEAD program in Seattle has similar guidelines to the LEAD program proposed in this bill.
- Evaluation of the LEAD Program in Seattle: A team from University of Washington’s Harborview Medical Center prepared two reports evaluating the efficacy of Seattle’s LEAD Program.
The first report described findings from a quantitative analysis comparing outcomes for LEAD participants versus “system-as-usual” control participants on shorter- and longer-term changes on recidivism outcomes, including arrests (i.e., being taken into custody by legal authority) and criminal charges (i.e., filing of a criminal case in court). (LEAD Program Evaluation: Recidivism Report, University of Washington, March, 2015.)
The first report made the following specific findings regarding recidivism (Id.):
Shorter-term outcomes: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 60% lower odds (likelihood) of arrest during the six months subsequent to evaluation entry.
Longer-term outcomes: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 58% lower odds of at least one arrest subsequent to evaluation entry.
Analyses indicated that, compared to control participants, LEAD participants had 34% lower odds of being arrested at least once when warrant-related arrests were removed.
Although there was no statistically significant effect for total charges, the LEAD group had 39% lower odds of being charged with a felony subsequent to evaluation entry compared to the control group.
The proportion of LEAD participants charged with at least one felony decreased by 52% subsequent to evaluation entry. The proportion of control group participants receiving felony charges decreased by 18%.
The second report describes findings from a quantitative analysis comparing outcomes for LEAD participants versus “system-as-usual” control participants on criminal justice and legal system utilization (i.e., jail, prison, prosecution, defense) and associated costs. (Criminal Justice and Legal System Utilization and Associated Costs, University of Washington, June, 2015.)
The team observed statistically significant reductions for the LEAD group compared to the control group on average yearly criminal justice and legal system utilization and associated costs, across nearly all outcomes.
The team made the following specific findings (Id.):
Jail bookings: Compared to the control group, LEAD program participants had 1.4 fewer jail bookings on average per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
Jail days: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group spent 39 fewer days in jail per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
Prison incarceration: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 87% lower odds of at least one prison incarceration subsequent to evaluation entry.
Misdemeanor and felony cases: There were no statistically significant LEAD effects on the average yearly number of misdemeanor cases. Compared to control participants, however, LEAD participants showed significant reductions in felony cases.
Costs associated with criminal justice and legal system utilization: From pre- to postevaluation entry, LEAD participants showed substantial cost reductions (-$2100), whereas control participants showed cost increases (+$5961).
- Argument in Support: According to Drug Policy Alliance, “SB 1110 (Hancock) would authorize pre-booking diversion pilot programs for certain non-violent offenses, in particular subsistence level drug selling and sex work, modeled after LEAD (Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion), which was pioneered in Seattle in 2011. The program has since been replicated in Santa Fe, New Mexico and Albany, New York and is being considered by jurisdictions across the United States. LEAD has been proven to reduce criminal behavior and improve public safety by allowing law enforcement to connect low level offenders directly with community-based treatment and supportive services.
“LEAD was created as a response to repeated legal challenges to racially biased arrest practices in Seattle, and its implementation initiated what has become a remarkable renewal of the relationship between the police and the communities they serve. SB 1110 (Hancock) paves the way to affect real change within law enforcement agencies: police officers not only become accustomed to the idea that these offenses do not belong in the criminal justice system, but they also become invested in truly helping those whom they divert.
“SB 1110 (Hancock) will foster significant reductions in recidivism and at a fraction of the cost, and helps California along its path towards a durable solution to prison overcrowding. LEAD is an effective way to decrease the number of those arrested, incarcerated, and otherwise caught up in the criminal justice system and reduce recidivism. Furthermore, LEAD introduces members of the criminal justice system to a health-based harm reduction approach, and a focus on individual and community wellness, rather than an unproductive focus on sobriety and punishment.” - Argument in Opposition: According to The US Prostitutes Collective, “While those who put forward SB 1110 may be well-meaning, the legislation was written without input from sex workers. It goes against the demands of the sex worker movement internationally which is for decriminalization, because it treats sex work not as a job but as a disease and sex workers not as workers but as offenders in need of treatment and rehabilitation. Amnesty International, Open Society Foundation and other key organizations support decriminalization.
"Similar programs to those proposed in SB 1110 have been extremely problematic. For example, in Seattle (which is used as an example of good practice for SB 1110) hundreds of people were swept off the street and into LEAD by a four-month police and FBI undercover operation to clean-up downtown.
"LEAD is law enforcement led. It gives the police the power to decide who gets arrested or not and who goes into the program, and puts women’s access to services in police hands. If sex workers refuse LEAD they will be charged. If they accept LEAD, charges still stay open on their file -- if they don’t meet all the conditions the program dictates, want out or are kicked out, they will be charged with what they were arrested for. Given institutional racism and sexism, sex workers disproportionately impacted include trans, women of color and immigrants.
"Seattle’s LEAD program speaks of being inspired by “arrest-referral” projects in the UK. But sex workers there complain that these programs have not stopped criminalization. Instead they have: increased police powers over sex workers; cut into the ability of sex workers to earn a living; undermined the independence of the few sex worker services that do exist, turning them into an arm of law enforcement.
"Rising poverty is increasing the numbers of women, particularly mothers, going into sex work. For those of us who want to get out of prostitution we need money and resources not punitive rehabilitation programs. The bill includes a diversion program for drug users, which is not being opposed, so anyone who wants drug treatment has this option.” - Prior Legislation:
- SB 513 (Hancock), Chapter 798, Statutes of 2013, provides that two years after successfully completing a prefiling diversion program administered by a prosecuting attorney, an individual may petition the court for an order sealing the records of arrest and related court files and records, as specified.
- AB 994 (Lowenthal), of the 2013-14 Legislative Session, would have required each county to establish and maintain a postplea misdemeanor diversion program, to be administered by the district attorney of that county, and authorizes either the district attorney or the superior court to offer diversion to a defendant. AB 994 was vetoed by the Governor.
- AB 2199 (Harman), of the 2005-06 Legislative Session, would have established a pretrial diversion education program for persons arrested for nonviolent misdemeanor or felony firearms offenses. AB 2199 was never heard by the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- SB 513 (Hancock), Chapter 798, Statutes of 2013, provides that two years after successfully completing a prefiling diversion program administered by a prosecuting attorney, an individual may petition the court for an order sealing the records of arrest and related court files and records, as specified.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Drug Policy Alliance (Sponsor)
Alameda County Board of Supervisors
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Public Defenders Association
Californians for Safety and Justice
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Crime Victims United of California
County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California
Opposition
Erotic Service Providers Union
US Prostitutes Collective
1 private individual
Analysis Prepared by: David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1110
:
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/19/16
AYES: Hancock, Anderson, Glazer, Leno, Liu, Monning
NOES: Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-0, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Nielsen
DIGEST: This bill authorizes the establishment of three pilot projects for the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) in which a law enforcement officer takes a low-level drug seller or possessor, or a prostitution offender, for evaluation for a program of harm-reduction services that bypass the court system in that matter, as specified.
Existing law:
1) Includes deferred entry of judgment (DEJ) and true diversion programs for rehabilitation and treatment of drug offenders. (Pen. Code §§ 1000 and 1000.5.)
a) In DEJ, a defendant determined by the prosecutor to be eligible for DEJ must plead guilty to the underlying drug possession charge. The court then defers entry of judgment and places the defendant in a rehabilitation and education program. If he or she successfully completes the program, the guilty plea is withdrawn and the arrest is deemed to have not occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, the court immediately imposes judgment and sentences the defendant.
b) In true diversion, the criminal charges against an eligible defendant are set aside and the defendant is placed in a rehabilitation and education program treatment. If the defendants successfully complete the program, the arrest is dismissed and deemed to not have occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, criminal charges are reinstated.
2) Includes the Substance Abuse and Crime Prevention Act (Proposition 36 of the 2000 General Election.) Defendants convicted of a non-violent drug possession offense must be offered treatment on probation without incarceration, if not disqualified by prior violent or serious felony convictions, commission of a non-drug offense or a history establishing that he or she is no amenable to treatment. (Pen. Code § 1210 and 1210.1.)
3) Includes a limited number of pre-trial diversion programs for non-drug offenses. In these programs, criminal charges are reinstated if the defendant fails in the program.
a) Misdemeanor diversion, excluding driving under the influence, crimes requiring registration as a sex offender, crimes involving violence, as specified. (Pen. Code §§ 1001, 1001.50-1001.55.)
b) Bad check diversion. (Pen. Code §1001.60.)
4) Defines misdemeanor diversion thus: “[P]retrial diversion refers to the procedure of postponing prosecution of an offense filed as a misdemeanor either temporarily or permanently at any point in the judicial process from the point at which the accused is charged until adjudication.” (Pen. Code § 1001.1.)
5) Excludes specified driving under the influence offenses from pretrial diversion eligibility. (Pen. Code § 1001.2, subd. (a).)
6) Provides that the district attorney of each county shall review annually any diversion program adopted by the county. The district attorney must approve the program and each participant. (Pen. Code § 1001.2, subd. (b).)
This bill:
1) States that a LEAD program shall be consistent with the following principles:
a) Intensive case management.
b) Priority for housing with supportive services, without preconditions of abstinence from alcohol or drugs.
c) Coordination of human services and law enforcement in a manner to improve community safety and individual outcomes.
d) Participation in a LEAD program is voluntary and is not conditioned on abstinence from alcohol or drugs.
2) Provides that the Board of State and Community Corrections (board) shall set funding schedules and procedures for awarding competitive grants to applicants in three jurisdictions. Applications should include:
a) A clear understanding of LEAD and the willingness and ability to implement the program.
b) Local partners for the LEAD program that include balanced participation from law enforcement, a prosecutor’s office, defense counsel, public health and social service entities and other entities integral to a successful LEAD program.
c) Capacity and commitment to coordinate decisions and actions of LEAD partners
3) Requires LEAD programs to collect and maintain data, as specified.
4) Provides that a LEAD program shall include the following:
a) Prebooking referral by law enforcement of a potential participant to a case manager to be screened for crisis services and a full LEAD assessment.
b) Participation shall be voluntary.
c) Criminal charges will not be filed for a LEAD participant for the offense or conduct for which a person was referred to LEAD, provided that the person completes a complete assessment within 30 days.
5) Provides that LEAD officers may refer a person for LEAD through social contact, not because of the commission of a criminal offense. The social contact participant must meet qualifications and the program may accept the person if the program has resources not needed for prebooking participants.
6) Provides that social contacts referrals shall include law enforcement verification of the person’s prior involvement in eligible drug and prostitution offenses within the LEAD area. Social contact participants must meet other specified criteria, including that the person does not have a pending criminal case or be subject to a restraining order.
7) Provides that the following offenses are eligible for LEAD referral:
a) Sale or transfer, or possession for sale or transfer, of a controlled substances where the sale or transfer is intended to provide subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain drugs for his or her own consumption.
b) Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
c) Being under the influence of a controlled substance, other prohibited drug or alcohol.
8) Provides that LEAD services may include case management, housing, medical and mental health care, drug and alcohol abuse treatment, nutritional counseling, education, employment training and “civil legal system navigations.
9) Specifies that LEAD funding may support the following:
a) Project management and community engagement.
b) Temporary services and treatment necessary to stabilize the participant’s life, including housing.
c) Civil legal services for participants.
d) Dedicated law enforcement and prosecutorial resources, as specified.
e) Training and technical services from LEAD experts.
f) Data collection.
10) Provides that the board shall contract with a non-profit research entity to evaluate the effectiveness of the program, including comparing outcomes of LEAD and non-LEAD cases, cost-benefit analysis, recidivism and specified other measures. The report shall be submitted by January 1, 2020, as specified.
11) Authorizes the board to contract with LEAD experts and cap board administrative expenses at 5%
12) Sunsets the grant program as of January 1, 2020.
Background
According to the author:
In 2011, Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) was developed and launched in Seattle, Washington. The program was a new harm-reduction oriented process for responding to low-level offenses such as drug possession, sales and prostitution. It was the result of an unprecedented collaboration between police, prosecutors, civil rights advocates, public defenders, political leaders, mental health and drug treatment providers, housing providers, other service agencies and business and neighborhood leaders.
In a LEAD program, police officers exercise discretionary authority at point of contact to divert individuals to a community-based, harm-reduction intervention. When officers encounter individuals who have violated the law due to unmet behavioral health needs, the officers refer the individuals to a trauma-informed intensive case management program. In lieu of the normal criminal justice system cycle – booking, detention, prosecution, conviction and incarceration – the case management program provides a wide range of support services for the individual, often including transitional and permanent housing and/or drug treatment.
After three years of operation in Seattle, a 2015 independent, non-randomized controlled outcome study by the University of Washington found that LEAD participants were 58% less likely to be arrested after enrollment in the program compared to a control group that went through the usual criminal justice processing. With significant reductions in recidivism, LEAD functions as a public safety program that has the potential to decrease the number of those arrested as well as improve the health and well-being of participants.
This bill would approve three jurisdictions for the establishment of a LEAD pilot program. This bill would also require the LEAD pilot programs to authorize designated officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified controlled substances offenses, including possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance, or prostitution to treatment programs and services in lieu of arrest.
It is sometimes stated that LEAD referrals are made at the time of arrest. In an interaction that is not social, it appears that the officer would detain, not formally arrest, a potential participant. The person would then essentially have the option to either accept referral for LEAD or submit to arrest and prosecution. If the person refuses referral or does not qualify for LEAD after screening, the arrest would formally occur and the person would be booked and prosecuted.
The core of the LEAD program is case management. A LEAD officer brings the participant to a social services case manager. The case manager determines the best program for the participant. Social workers involved in the program can maintain direct contact with participants in the community or at appointments. The core goals of LEAD are harm reduction and housing stability. The participant can engage in treatment, but ongoing treatment is not a condition of participation. As noted above, once the participant is accepted into LEAD, there will be no prosecution of the underlying offense.
A very detailed description of how LEAD was created and implemented in Seattle can be found in the University of Washington evaluations. The link to the evaluations pages of the Seattle LEAD Web site is the following: http://leadkingcounty.org/lead-evaluation/.
The University of Washing evaluation of the Seattle LEAD program sets out findings from a quantitative analysis comparing outcomes for LEAD participants versus “system-as-usual” control participants on criminal justice and legal system utilization (i.e., jail, prison, prosecution, and defense) and associated costs. Findings include:
- The cost of the LEAD program averaged $899 per person per month. However, these costs included program start-up and decreased to $532 per month towards the end of the evaluation.
- Across nearly all outcomes, we observed statistically significant reductions for the LEAD group compared to the control group on average yearly criminal justice and legal system utilization and associated costs.
- Jail bookings: Compared to the control group, LEAD program participants had 1.4 fewer jail bookings on average per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
- Jail days: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group spent 39 fewer days in jail per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
- Prison incarceration: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 87% lower odds of at least one prison incarceration subsequent to evaluation entry.
- Misdemeanor and felony cases: There were no statistically significant LEAD effects on the average yearly number of misdemeanor cases. Compared to control participants, however, LEAD participants showed significant reductions in felony cases.
- Costs associated with criminal justice and legal system utilization: From pre- to post-evaluation entry, LEAD participants showed substantial cost reductions (-$2100), whereas control participants showed cost increases (+$5961).
- Interpretation of findings:
- LEAD program costs were commensurate with another supportive program for homeless individuals in King County. It should be noted that LEAD program costs LEAD Evaluation: Utilization and Cost Report 6/24/15 UW LEAD Evaluation Team 3 will vary widely across communities depending on LEAD participant characteristics (e.g., prevalence of homelessness) and community factors (e.g., cost of living, Medicaid coverage).
- Compared to system-as-usual controls, LEAD participants evinced meaningful and statistically significant reductions in criminal justice and legal system utilization and associated costs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- BSCC: One-time costs of approximately $65,000 (General Fund) to support activities related to the review and approval of applications for pilot participation.
- Local agencies: Major costs potentially in excess of $7 million (Local Funds/General Fund/General Fund*) annually for three years (total costs of $21 million) to provide the necessary treatment, services, and collaborative case management activities for three counties. The pilot program is limited to three jurisdictions.
- CSEC program: Potential increase in Commercially Sexually Exploited Children program costs (General Fund**) for services, treatment, and case management activities for juvenile LEAD program participants that otherwise may have been charged with the specified prostitution offense. Costs would be dependent on the specific counties approved for the pilot, the number of LEAD participants in each county, and the existing infrastructure and service capacity available to serve LEAD participants in these counties.
- Medi-Cal services: Potentially significant increase in Medi-Cal program costs (Federal Fund/General Fund) for greater provision of alcohol/substance abuse treatment and mental health services to LEAD participants.
- Criminal justice system: Potentially major future cost savings in the millions of dollars (General Fund/Local Funds) to numerous state and local agencies, including but not limited to the courts, state prisons, local correctional facilities, law enforcement agencies, and human services agencies to the extent LEAD participation results in reduced recidivism of LEAD participants.
- Proposition 47: Staff notes the funds to be disbursed annually to the board under the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act (65 percent of Proposition 47 calculated savings) for mental health services, substance abuse treatment, and diversion programs for people in the criminal justice system, with emphasis on programs that reduce recidivism of people convicted of less serious crimes may potentially be used for the purposes specified in this bill.
* Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Fund (annual transfer from the General Fund)
** Proposition 30 General Fund
American Civil Liberties Union
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California
Crime Victims United of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/31/16)
California District Attorneys Association
5/31/16 21:52:02
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1110 (Hancock) - Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion
Version: February 17, 2016 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 6 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 27, 2016 | Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
Bill Summary:
SB 1110 would require the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC) to approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 27, 2016
Fiscal Impact:
- BSCC: One-time costs of approximately $65,000 (General Fund) to support activities related to the review and approval of applications for pilot participation.
- Local agencies: Major costs potentially in excess of $7 million (Local Funds/General Fund/General Fund*) annually for three years (total costs of $21 million) to provide the necessary treatment, services, and collaborative case management activities for three counties. The pilot program is limited to three jurisdictions.
- CSEC program: Potential increase in Commercially Sexually Exploited Children (CSEC) program costs (General Fund**) for services, treatment, and case management activities for juvenile LEAD program participants that otherwise may have been charged with the specified prostitution offense. Costs would be dependent on the specific counties approved for the pilot, the number of LEAD participants in each county, and the existing infrastructure and service capacity available to serve LEAD participants in these counties.
- Medi-Cal services: Potentially significant increase in Medi-Cal program costs (Federal Fund/General Fund) for greater provision of alcohol/substance abuse treatment and mental health services to LEAD participants.
- Criminal justice system: Potentially major future cost savings in the millions of dollars (General Fund/Local Funds) to numerous state and local agencies, including but not limited to the courts, state prisons, local correctional facilities, law enforcement agencies, and human services agencies to the extent LEAD participation results in reduced recidivism of LEAD participants.
- Proposition 47*: Staff notes the funds to be disbursed annually to the BSCC under the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act (65 percent of Proposition 47 calculated savings) for mental health services, substance abuse treatment, and diversion programs for people in the criminal justice system, with emphasis on programs that reduce recidivism of people convicted of less serious crimes may potentially be used for the purposes specified in this measure.
*Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Fund (annual transfer from the General Fund)
**Proposition 30 General Fund
Author Amendments:
Specify LEAD program details for the pilot program in up to three jurisdictions.
Committee Amendments:
Add a sunset date of January 1, 2020, for the pilot program.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1110 (Hancock) - Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 1110 would require the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC) to approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- BSCC: One-time costs of approximately $65,000 (General Fund) to support activities related to the review and approval of applications for pilot participation.
- Local agencies: Major local costs potentially in excess of $7 million (Local Funds/General Fund/General Fund*) annually (assuming $2.5 million per mid-size county) to provide the necessary treatment, services, and collaborative case management activities for three counties. The pilot program is limited to three counties, however, a sunset date for the pilot program is not specified. Consequently, costs are estimated to be ongoing. Costs per county would vary by county size and size of the targeted population. To the extent Los Angeles County is selected, for example, annual costs could be much greater.
- CSEC program: Potential increase in Commercially Sexually Exploited Children (CSEC) program costs (General Fund**) for services, treatment, and case management activities for juvenile LEAD program participants that otherwise may have been charged with the specified prostitution offense. Costs would be dependent on the specific counties approved for the pilot, the number of LEAD participants in each county, and the existing infrastructure and service capacity available to serve LEAD participants in these counties.
- Medi-Cal services: Potentially significant increase in Medi-Cal program costs (Federal Fund/General Fund) for greater provision of alcohol/substance abuse treatment and mental health services to LEAD participants.
- Criminal justice system: Potentially major future cost savings in the millions of dollars (General Fund/Local Funds) to numerous state and local agencies, including but not limited to the courts, state prisons, local correctional facilities, law enforcement agencies, and human services agencies to the extent LEAD participation results in reduced recidivism of LEAD participants.
- Proposition 47*: Staff notes the funds to be disbursed annually to the BSCC under the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act (65 percent of Proposition 47 calculated savings) for mental health services, substance abuse treatment, and diversion programs for people in the criminal justice system, with emphasis on programs that reduce recidivism of people convicted of less serious crimes may potentially be used for the purposes specified in this measure.
*Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Fund (annual transfer from the General Fund)
**Proposition 30 General Fund
Background:
LEAD Concept, Participants and Goals[1]
Law enforcement assisted diversion (LEAD) is a program in which law enforcement officers contact a low-level drug offender or a person engaged in prostitution and offer the person treatment and services without a criminal prosecution arising out of that contact. If the person agrees to engage in the program, prosecution is not deferred, it is never instigated.
In Seattle, the referral to services and participation can also be done through a social contact between an officer and a potential participant. In this context, “social” means the contact is not initiated by or through the commission of a crime by the participant. An officer can interact with a person that the officer knows is drug dependent, involved in low-level drug sales, or involved in prostitution, without evidence of a particular offense, and offer LEAD assistance.
It is sometimes stated that LEAD referrals are made at the time of arrest. In an interaction that is not social, it appears that the officer would detain, not formally arrest, a potential participant. The person would then essentially have the option to either accept referral for LEAD or submit to arrest and prosecution. If the person refuses referral or does not qualify for LEAD after screening, the arrest would formally occur and the person would be booked and prosecuted.
The core of the LEAD program is case management. A LEAD officer brings the participant to a social services case manager. The case manager determines the best program for the participant. Social workers involved in the program can maintain direct contact with participants in the community or at appointments. The core goals of LEAD are harm reduction and housing stability. The participant can engage in treatment, but ongoing treatment is not a condition of participation. As noted above, once the participant is accepted into LEAD, there will be no prosecution of the underlying offense.
A more detailed description of how LEAD was created and implemented in Seattle can be found in the University of Washington (UW) evaluations. The description in the UW evaluations is particularly illuminating because it reflects the full scope of what the study considered. (http://leadkingcounty.org/lead-evaluation).
Proposed Law:
This bill requires the BSCC to approve three counties for the establishment of a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires interested counties to submit applications to the BSCC, including information on the manner in which the program will operate in that county, as required by the BSCC.
- Provides that LEAD pilot programs shall include both of the following:
- Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for any of the following offenses to a drug treatment facility or program for treatment, including detoxification and related services in lieu of that arrest:
- Possession for sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
- Sale or transfer of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance where the circumstances indicate that the sale or transfer is intended to provide a subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain or afford drugs for his or her own consumption.
- Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
- Being under the influence of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
- Being under the influence of alcohol and a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
- Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for prostitution pursuant to PC § 647(b), to an agency or entity that will provide services to that person in lieu of that arrest. Services pursuant to this paragraph may include, but are not limited to, housing, medical care, child care, treatment for alcohol or substance abuse, nutritional counseling and treatment, psychological counseling, employment, and employment training and education.
- Authorization for designated peace officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for any of the following offenses to a drug treatment facility or program for treatment, including detoxification and related services in lieu of that arrest:
- Includes legislative findings and declarations stating that a program similar to the LEAD program has been demonstrated in Seattle, Washington, to lower recidivism of participants, increase cooperation by participants in treatment and related programs, and significantly reduce law enforcement and court costs.
Related Legislation:
SB 1322 (Mitchell) 2016 would decriminalize the misdemeanor offenses of loitering with the intent to commit prostitution and soliciting or engaging in prostitution if the offense was committed by a minor. This bill is scheduled to be heard today by this Committee.
Recommended Amendments:
The author may wish to consider the inclusion of a sunset date for the three county pilot program. Additionally, the author may wish to consider making pilot county participation contingent upon specified program reporting requirements, and include a report to the Legislature on the outcomes experienced by each of the pilot counties.
-- END --
Senate Committee on Public Safety analysis of SB 1110 (April 19, 2016) ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 1110 Hearing Date: April 19, 2016
Author: | Hancock | ||
Version: | February 17, 2016 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | JM | ||
Subject: Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: None
Support: American Civil Liberties Union; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association; Crime Victims United of California
Opposition: California District Attorneys Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to authorize the establishment of three pilot projects for the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) in which a law enforcement officer takes a low-level drug seller or possessor, or a prostitution offender, directly to treatment and services, bypassing the court system in that matter; as specified.
Existing law includes deferred entry of judgment (DEJ) and true diversion programs for rehabilitation and treatment of drug offenders. (Pen. Code §§ 1000 and 1000.5.)
- In DEJ, a defendant determined by the prosecutor to be eligible for DEJ must plead guilty to the underlying drug possession charge. The court then defers entry of judgment and places the defendant in a rehabilitation and education program. If he or she successfully completes the program, the guilty plea is withdrawn and the arrest is deemed to have not occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, the court immediately imposes judgment and sentences the defendant.
- In true diversion, the criminal charges against an eligible defendant are set aside and the defendant is placed in a rehabilitation and education program treatment. If the defendants successfully complete the program, the arrest is dismissed and deemed to not have occurred. If the defendant fails in the program, criminal charges are reinstated.
Existing law includes the Substance Abuse and Crime Prevention Act (SACPA – Proposition 36 of the 2000 General Election.) Defendants convicted of a non-violent drug possession offense must be offered treatment on probation without incarceration, if not disqualified by prior violent or serious felony convictions, commission of a non-drug offense or a history establishing that he or she is no amenable to treatment. (Pen. Code § 1210 and 1210.1.)
Existing law includes a limited number of pre-trial diversion programs for non-drug offenses. In these programs, criminal charges are reinstated if the defendant fails in the program.
- Misdemeanor diversion, excluding driving under the influence, crimes requiring registration as a sex offender, crimes involving violence, as specified. (Pen. Code §§ 1001, 1001.50-1001.55.)
- Bad check diversion. (Pen. Code §1001.60.)
Existing law defines misdemeanor diversion thus: “[P]retrial diversion refers to the procedure of postponing prosecution of an offense filed as a misdemeanor either temporarily or permanently at any point in the judicial process from the point at which the accused is charged until adjudication.” (Pen. Code § 1001.1.)
Existing law excludes specified driving under the influence offenses from pretrial diversion eligibility. (Pen. Code § 1001.2, subd. (a).)
Existing law provides that the district attorney of each county shall review annually any diversion program adopted by the county. The district attorney must approve the program and each participant. (Pen. Code § 1001.2, subd. (b).)
This bill provides that the Board of State and Community Corrections shall approve three counties to establish a Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) pilot program.
This bill provides that an interested county shall apply to the board and state how the program would operate in that county.
This bill provides that a LEAD pilot program shall include the following:
- Authorization for designated peace officers to take persons subject to arrest for specified offenses to a drug treatment facility or program. The specified offenses include:
- Sale or transfer, or possession for sale or transfer, of a controlled substances where the sale or transfer is intended to provide subsistence living or to allow the person to obtain drugs for his or her own consumption.
- Possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance.
- Being under the influence of a controlled substance, other prohibited drug or alcohol.
- Authorization for designated officers to take persons subject to arrest for prostitution to an agency or entity that will provide a broad range of services to the person in lieu of arrest. Examples of services include medical, psychological, drug or alcohol treatment, child care and employment-related services.
This bill includes legislative findings that a LEAD program has been demonstrated in Seattle, Washington to lower recidivism, increase cooperation of participants in treatment and related programs and has significantly reduced law enforcement and court costs.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past several years this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
- 143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
- 141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
- 137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In December of 2015 the administration reported that as “of December 9, 2015, 112,510 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.0% of design bed capacity, and 5,264 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. The current population is 1,212 inmates below the final court-ordered population benchmark of 137.5% of design bed capacity, and has been under that benchmark since February 2015.” (Defendants’ December 2015 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).) One year ago, 115,826 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounted to 140.0% of design bed capacity, and 8,864 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. (Defendants’ December 2014 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).)
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
- Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
- Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
- Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
- Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
- Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author:
In 2011, Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) was developed and launched in Seattle, Washington. The program was a new harm-reduction oriented process for responding to low-level offenses such as drug possession, sales and prostitution. It was the result of an unprecedented collaboration between police, prosecutors, civil rights advocates, public defenders, political leaders, mental health and drug treatment providers, housing providers, other service agencies and business and neighborhood leaders.
In a LEAD program, police officers exercise discretionary authority at point of contact to divert individuals to a community-based, harm-reduction intervention. When officers encounter individuals who have violated the law due to unmet behavioral health needs, the officers refer the individuals to a trauma-informed intensive case management program. In lieu of the normal criminal justice system cycle – booking, detention, prosecution, conviction and incarceration – the case management program provides a wide range of support services for the individual, often including transitional and permanent housing and/or drug treatment.
After three years of operation in Seattle, a 2015 independent, non-randomized controlled outcome study by the University of Washington found that LEAD participants were 58% less likely to be arrested after enrollment in the program compared to a control group that went through the usual criminal justice processing. With significant reductions in recidivism, LEAD functions as a public safety program that has the potential to decrease the number of those arrested as well as improve the health and well-being of people struggling at the intersection of poverty and drug and mental health problems.
This bill would approve three counties for the establishment of a LEAD pilot program. This bill would also require the LEAD pilot programs to authorize designated officers to take a person for whom the officer has probable cause for arrest for specified controlled substances offenses, including possession of a controlled substance or other prohibited substance, or prostitution to treatment programs and services in lieu of arrest.
2. General Background – LEAD Concept, Participants and Goals
Law enforcement assisted diversion (LEAD) is a program in which law enforcement officers who contact a low-level drug offender, or a person engaged in prostitution, and offer the person treatment and services without a criminal prosecution arising out of that contact. If the person agrees to engage in the program, prosecution is not deferred, it is never instigated.
In Seattle, the referral to services and participation can also be done through a social contact between an officer and a potential participant. In this context, “social” means the contact is not initiated by or through the commission of a crime by the participant. An officer can interact with a person that the officer knows is drug dependent, involved in low-level drug sales, or involved in prostitution, without evidence of a particular offense, and offer LEAD assistance.
It is sometimes stated that LEAD referrals are made at the time of arrest. In an interaction that is not social, it appears that the officer would detain, not formally arrest, a potential participant. The person would then essentially have the option to either accept referral for LEAD or submit to arrest and prosecution. If the person refuses referral or does not qualify for LEAD after screening, the arrest would formally occur and the person would be booked and prosecuted.
The core of the LEAD program is case management. A LEAD officer brings the participant to a social services case manager. The case manager determines the best program for the participant. Social workers involved in the program can maintain direct contact with participants in the community or at appointments. The core goals of LEAD are harm reduction and housing stability. The participant can engage in treatment, but ongoing treatment is not a condition of participation. As noted above, once the participant is accepted into LEAD, there will be no prosecution of the underlying offense.
A more detailed description of how LEAD was created and implemented in Seattle can be found in the University of Washington evaluations. The description in the UW evaluations is particularly illuminating because it reflects the full scope of what the study considered. The link to the evaluations pages of the Seattle LEAD website is the following: http://leadkingcounty.org/lead-evaluation/.
3. Seattle LEAD Memorandum of Understanding Participants
LEAD is governed by a Policy Coordinating Group that operates pursuant to a memorandum of understanding (MOU) among the following:
- Seattle Office of the Mayor
- King County Executive Office
- Seattle City Council
- King County Council
- Seattle City Attorney’s Office
- King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office
- Seattle Police Department
- King County Sheriff’s Office
- Washington Department of Corrections
- Belltown LEAD Community Advisory Board
- Skyway LEAD Community Advisory Board
- The Defender Association, Racial Disparity Project
- ACLU of Washington, Drug Policy Project
4. Executive Summary of the University of Washington LEAD Participant Recidivism Evaluation – Released March 27, 2015
This report describes findings from a quantitative analysis comparing outcomes for LEAD participants versus “system-as-usual” control participants on shorter- and longer-term changes on recidivism outcomes, including arrests (i.e., being taken into custody by legal authority) and criminal charges (i.e., filing of a criminal case in court). Arrests and criminal charges were chosen as the recidivism outcomes because they likely reflect individual behavior more than convictions, which are more heavily impacted by criminal justice system variables external to the individual. Findings:
- Analyses indicated statistically significant recidivism improvement for the LEAD group compared to the control group on some shorter- and longer-term outcomes. o Shorter-term outcomes were assessed for the six months prior and subsequent to participants’ entry into the evaluation.
- Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 60% lower odds (likelihood) of arrest during the six months subsequent to evaluation entry. The effect of LEAD on getting arrested during the 6-month follow-up was statistically significant (p = .03).
- This finding reflected the fact that—comparing the six months prior and subsequent to entry into the evaluation—the proportion of control participants who were arrested increased by 51%, whereas the proportion of LEAD participants who were arrested plateaued (+6%).
- Inclusion of warrant-related arrests could either a) inflate apparent recidivism by reflecting nonappearance for prior violations or b) accurately represent new criminal activity that triggered prior warrants to be served even if there was no booking on a new crime. Thus, we examined the arrest data both with and without warrant arrests. Analyses of exclusively nonwarrant-related arrests indicated no significant LEAD effects.
- Further, there were no statistically significant LEAD effects on total charges or felony charges filed over this shorter-term period. LEAD Evaluation: Recidivism Report 3/27/15 UW LEAD Evaluation Team 3 o Longer-term outcomes were assessed during the entirety of the LEAD evaluation time frame, ranging from October 2009 through July 2014. Analyses took into account the fact that participants had been in the program for differing amounts of time by statistically controlling for this factor.
- Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 58% lower odds of at least one arrest subsequent to evaluation entry. The LEAD effect on arrests over time was statistically significant (p = .001).
- This finding reflected the fact that the proportion of control participants who were arrested at least once subsequent to evaluation entry increased by 4%, whereas the proportion of LEAD participants who were arrested subsequent to evaluation entry decreased by 30%.
- Analyses indicated that, compared to control participants, LEAD participants had 34% lower odds of being arrested at least once when warrant-related arrests were removed. This effect was marginally significant (p = .09).
- Although there was no statistically significant effect for total charges, the LEAD group had 39% lower odds of being charged with a felony subsequent to evaluation entry compared to the control group. This effect was statistically significant (p = .03).
- The proportion of LEAD participants charged with at least one felony decreased by 52% subsequent to evaluation entry. The proportion of control group participants receiving felony charges decreased by 18%.
- Interpretation of findings: These statistically significant reductions in arrests and felony charges for LEAD participants compared to control participants indicated positive effects of the LEAD program on recidivism.
5. Executive Summary of the University of Washington Lead Evaluation of Criminal Justice and Legal System Utilization and Associated Costs – Released June 24, 2015
The University of Washing evaluation released on sets out findings from a quantitative analysis comparing outcomes for LEAD participants versus “system-as-usual” control participants on criminal justice and legal system utilization (i.e., jail, prison, prosecution, and defense) and associated costs. Findings include:
- The cost of the LEAD program averaged $899 per person per month. However, these costs included program start-up and decreased to $532 per month towards the end of the evaluation.
- Across nearly all outcomes, we observed statistically significant reductions for the LEAD group compared to the control group on average yearly criminal justice and legal system utilization and associated costs.
- Jail bookings: Compared to the control group, LEAD program participants had 1.4 fewer jail bookings on average per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
- Jail days: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group spent 39 fewer days in jail per year subsequent to their evaluation entry.
- Prison incarceration: Compared to the control group, the LEAD group had 87% lower odds of at least one prison incarceration subsequent to evaluation entry.
- Misdemeanor and felony cases: There were no statistically significant LEAD effects on the average yearly number of misdemeanor cases. Compared to control participants, however, LEAD participants showed significant reductions in felony cases.
- Costs associated with criminal justice and legal system utilization: From pre- to post-evaluation entry, LEAD participants showed substantial cost reductions (-$2100), whereas control participants showed cost increases (+$5961).
- Interpretation of findings:
- LEAD program costs were commensurate with another supportive program for homeless individuals in King County. It should be noted that LEAD program costs LEAD Evaluation: Utilization and Cost Report 6/24/15 UW LEAD Evaluation Team 3 will vary widely across communities depending on LEAD
participant characteristics (e.g., prevalence of homelessness) and community factors (e.g., cost of living, Medicaid coverage).
- Compared to system-as-usual controls, LEAD participants evinced meaningful and statistically significant reductions in criminal justice and legal system utilization and associated costs.
6. Seattle LEAD Funding Sources, Processes and Recommendations
The Seattle LEAD program has garnered interest from around the country. To respond to inquiries about the program, LEAD opened a National Assistance Bureau. Kris Nyrop, the National Assistance Bureau Director explained the LEAD funding history.
- Foundation Funding
- LEAD received about 800,000 the first year and a little more than that the second. Those were the two years we operated without any public funds.
- LEAD was dependent on foundation money from the beginning of the program in October, 2011 through 2013
In 2014, 2015, and 2016 LEAD used a 50-50% mix of private and public funds.
- LEAD anticipates being entirely publicly funded by 2017.
- Affordable Care Act and Medicaid Issues:
- LEAD began prior to the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Washington State is a Medicaid expansion state. LEAD is now using Medicaid money to pay for many of the costs and services that were initially funded by foundation grants. These included health and dental care, drug treatment and mental health care.
- LEAD managers have discovered that Washington State's Medicaid expansion is not as broad as it could be. For example, New York Medicaid reimburses some case management costs.
- LEAD national assistance would recommend that other states or local entities implementing a LEAD program determine what can be funded through Medicaid.
7. PBS Frontline Documentary on LEAD in the Context of the Opioid Addiction Epidemic
On February 23, 2016, the PBS Frontline program broadcast and released on-line a detailed documentary about LEAD and the history of the prescription drug opioid addiction epidemic. The documentary explained how the prescription opioid abuse epidemic led to a great increase in the use of heroin, particularly by people who could no longer obtain prescription opioids. The documentary was released on with the title, “Chasing Heroin.” The URL for the documentary on-line is: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/chasing-heroin/
8. Drug Dependence as a Disease of Chronic Relapse; Effectiveness of Treatment and Punishment in the Court System
It has been widely emphasized by experts in drug abuse and treatment that drug dependence or addiction is a chronically relapsing condition, similar to obesity or diabetes in this respect.[1] It is to be expected that a person in treatment for drug dependence will relapse and use the drug of dependence or another drug. Such relapses do not mean that the person is not benefiting from treatment. It appears that treatment is cumulative, such that what appear to be initial failures in treatment contribute to success or substantial progress over time. For example, a history of less frequent relapses with success or progress by the treatment participant in employment, training, education or family responsibilities and relations would indicate that treatment is beneficial. The likelihood of chronic relapse by LEAD participants in Seattle is expected. Relapse does not limit a LEAD participant’s involvement in the program.
Recent research has considered the effectiveness of varying forms of court-based drug treatment with other forms or sources of treatment demand. UCLA studies of the effectiveness of SACPA – Proposition 36 of 2000 were released in 2003 and 2006.[2] SACPA requires drug treatment without incarceration for non-violent drug possession. UCLA found that the SACPA model was as effective as drug court or voluntary treatment models and produced $2.50 in savings from every dollar spent. Improvements in funding allocations and programs would have produced better results.
An extensive 2007 study of 474 drug offenders in drug court in Maricopa County Arizona (the Phoenix area) compared the outcomes in drug court treatment for persons who were subject to jail sanctions against those who were not subject to sanctions. The study found that the threat of jail sanctions did not affect the participant’s rate of retention in or completion of the program.
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):