SB 1122: Telecommunications: small independent telephone corporations: rates: universal service: California High-Cost Fund-A.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-05-31
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges for every public utility. Existing law, with certain exceptions, prohibits a public utility from changing any rate, except upon a showing before the commission and a finding by the commission that the new rate is justified. Existing law requires the commission to exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations, as defined, in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirement, as defined, established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
This bill would revise the CHCF-A program requirements to provide that the revenue requirement of a small independent telephone corporation includes rate case expenses, as defined, and would require that rate case expenses be separately included in the revenue requirement regardless of any commission determinations regarding the reasonableness of other expenses. The defined.
This bill would require the commission to issue its final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporations filing of its general rate case application or advice letter initiating the general rate case. If the commission fails to issue a final decision by the 390th day, the bill would provide that the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter will take effect on an interim basis, subject to an accounting true-up in a final commission decision or resolution concluding the rate case, if issued within 420 days. If a final decision or resolution concluding the case has not been issued by the commission within 420 days, the bill would provide that the interim rate design that went into effect on the 390th day following the filing of the general rate case application or advice letter would become final and that rate design would remain in place until the commission issues a final decision or resolution concluding the rate case, without any true-up accounting. The bill would provide that any new rate design adopted in a final decision or resolution issued by the commission after 420 days following the filing of the application or advice letter would take effect on a prospective basis only, as of the effective date of the final decision or resolution. authorize the small independent telephone corporation to file a tariff implementing interim rates. The interim rates would generally be effective on the first day of the first test year in the general rate case application, subject to refund and adjustment upward or downward back to the interim rate effective date, consistent with the final rates adopted by the commission. The bill would provide that its these provisions may be waived at any time by mutual consent of the executive director of the commission and the small independent telephone corporation.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges. charges for every public utility. Existing law, with certain exceptions, prohibits a public utility from changing any rate, except upon a showing before the commission and a finding by the commission that the new rate is justified. Existing law requires the commission to exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations, as defined, in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements requirement, as defined, established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to revise the CHCF-A program requirements. requirements to provide that the revenue requirement of a small independent telephone corporation includes rate case expenses, as defined, and would require that rate case expenses be separately included in the revenue requirement regardless of any commission determinations regarding the reasonableness of other expenses. The bill would require the commission to issue its final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporations filing of its general rate case application or advice letter initiating the general rate case. If the commission fails to issue a final decision by the 390th day, the bill would provide that the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter will take effect on an interim basis, subject to an accounting true-up in a final commission decision or resolution concluding the rate case, if issued within 420 days. If a final decision or resolution concluding the case has not been issued by the commission within 420 days, the bill would provide that the interim rate design that went into effect on the 390th day following the filing of the general rate case application or advice letter would become final and that rate design would remain in place until the commission issues a final decision or resolution concluding the rate case, without any true-up accounting. The bill would provide that any new rate design adopted in a final decision or resolution issued by the commission after 420 days following the filing of the application or advice letter would take effect on a prospective basis only, as of the effective date of the final decision or resolution. The bill would provide that its provisions may be waived at any time by mutual consent of the executive director of the commission and the small independent telephone corporation.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law authorizes the commission to fix just and reasonable rates and charges. Existing law requires the commission to exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations, as defined, in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to the CHCF-A program requirements.
(a)The commission shall exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirement established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Carrier of last resort means a telephone corporation that is required to fulfill all reasonable requests for service within its service territory.
(2)Rate base means the value of a telephone corporations plant and equipment that is reasonably necessary to provide regulated voice services and access to advanced services, and upon which the telephone corporation is entitled to a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable rate of return.
(3)Rate case expenses mean the reasonable costs costs, as determined by the commission, incurred by a telephone corporation in preparing, initiating, and participating in any commission proceeding or advice letter process in which its rates, rate design, or revenue requirement are evaluated or adjusted.
(4)Rate design means the mix of end-user rates, high-cost support, and other revenue sources that are targeted to provide a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement of the telephone corporation.
(5)Rate-of-return regulation means a regulatory structure whereby the commission establishes a telephone corporations revenue requirement, and then fashions a rate design to provide the company a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement.
(6)Revenue requirement means the amount that is necessary for a telephone corporation to recover its reasonable expenses and tax liabilities and earn a reasonable rate of return on its rate base. Reasonable expenses include rate case expenses. Rate case expenses shall be separately included in the revenue requirement regardless of any commission determinations regarding the reasonableness of other expenses.
(7)Small independent telephone corporations are rural incumbent local exchange carriers subject to commission regulation.
(c)In administering the CHCF-A program program, the commission shall do all of the following:
(1)Continue to set rates to be charged by the small independent telephone corporations in accordance with Sections 451, 454, 455, and 728.
(2)Employ rate-of-return regulation to determine a small independent telephone corporations revenue requirement in a manner that provides revenues and earnings sufficient to allow the telephone corporation to deliver safe, reliable, high-quality voice communication service and fulfill its obligations as a carrier of last resort in its service territory, and to afford the telephone corporation a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable return on its investments, attract capital for investment on reasonable terms, and ensure the financial integrity of the telephone corporation.
(3)Ensure that the rates charged to customers of small independent telephone corporations are just and reasonable and are reasonably comparable to rates charged to customers of urban telephone corporations.
(4)Provide universal service rate support from the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund to small independent telephone corporations in an amount sufficient to supply the portion of the revenue requirement that cannot reasonably be provided by the customers of each small independent telephone corporation after receipt of federal universal service rate support.
(5)Promote customer access to advanced services and deployment of broadband-capable facilities in rural areas that is reasonably comparable to that in urban areas, consistent with national communications policy.
(6)Include all reasonable investments necessary to provide for the delivery of high-quality voice communication services and the deployment of broadband-capable facilities in the rate base of small independent telephone corporations.
(7)Ensure that support is not excessive so that the burden on all contributors to the CHCF-A program is limited.
(d)In order to participate in the CHCF-A program, a small independent telephone corporation shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)Be subject to rate-of-return regulation.
(2)Be subject to the commissions regulation of telephone corporations pursuant to this division.
(3)Be a carrier of last resort in their service territory.
(4)Qualify as a rural telephone company under federal law (47 U.S.C. Sec. 153(44)).
(e)Upon request from the commission, a small independent telephone corporation that receives support from the CHCF-A program shall provide information regarding revenues derived from the provision of unregulated Internet access service by that corporation or its affiliate within that corporations telephone service territory. The commission shall treat as confidential any information provided pursuant to this subdivision.
(f)The commission shall structure the CHCF-A program so that any charge imposed to promote the goals of universal service reasonably equals the value of the benefits of universal service to contributing entities and their subscribers.
(g)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2019, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 455.4 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:455.4.(a)For purposes of this section, small independent telephone corporation has the same meaning as in Section 275.6.
(b)A small independent telephone corporation may file its general rate case application or advice letter initiating a general rate case any time up to and including December 1 of the second year preceding the test year used in its rate case.
(c)The commission shall issue its final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporations filing of its general rate case application or advice letter initiating the general rate case.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 454, if the commission fails to issue a final decision as required by subdivision (c), the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter shall take effect on an interim basis beginning 390 days following the filing of the application or advice letter. That rate design shall be subject to an accounting true-up if a final commission decision or resolution concluding the rate case is issued within 420 days of the filing. The rate design adopted in a commission decision or resolution within 420 days shall be made effective as of the 390th day and the accounting true-up shall eliminate any revenue differences between the interim rate design and the rate design in the commission decision or resolution. If a final decision or resolution concluding the case has not been issued by the commission within 420 days of the filing, the interim rate design that took effect on the 390th day following the filing of the general rate case application or advice letter shall become final and that rate design shall remain in place until the commission issues a final decision or resolution concluding the rate case, without any true-up accounting. Any new rate design adopted in a final decision or resolution issued by the commission after 420 days following the filing of the application or advice letter shall take effect on a prospective basis only, as of the effective date of the final decision or resolution.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 454, if the commission fails to issue a decision as required by subdivision (c), the applicant may file a tariff implementing interim rates that may be increased by an amount equal to the rate of inflation as compared to existing rates. The interim rates shall be effective on the first day of the first test year in the general rate case application. These interim rates shall be subject to refund and shall be adjusted upward or downward back to the interim rate effective date, consistent with the final rates adopted by the commission. The commission may authorize a lesser increase in interim rates if the commission finds the rates to be in the public interest. If the presiding officer in the case determines that the commissions decision cannot become effective on the first day of the first test year due to actions by the small independent telephone corporation, the presiding officer or the commission may require a different effective date for the interim rates or final rates.
(e)The requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) may be waived at any time by mutual consent of the executive director of the commission and the small independent telephone corporation.
(a)The commission shall exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements requirement established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Carrier of last resort means a telephone corporation that is required to fulfill all reasonable requests for service within its service territory.
(2)Rate base means the value of a telephone corporations plant and equipment that is reasonably necessary to provide regulated voice services and access to advanced services, and upon which the telephone corporation is entitled to a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable rate of return.
(3)Rate case expenses mean the reasonable costs incurred by a telephone corporation in preparing, initiating, and participating in any commission proceeding or advice letter process in which its rates, rate design, or revenue requirement are evaluated or adjusted.
(3)
(4)Rate design means the mix of end-user rates, high-cost support, and other revenue sources that are targeted to provide a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement of the telephone corporation.
(4)
(5)Rate-of-return regulation means a regulatory structure whereby the commission establishes a telephone corporations revenue requirements, requirement, and then fashions a rate design to provide the company a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement.
(5)
(6)Revenue requirement means the amount that is necessary for a telephone corporation to recover its reasonable expenses and tax liabilities and earn a reasonable rate of return on its rate base. Reasonable expenses include rate case expenses. Rate case expenses shall be separately included in the revenue requirement regardless of any commission determinations regarding the reasonableness of other expenses.
(6)
(7)Small independent telephone corporations are rural incumbent local exchange carriers subject to commission regulation.
(c)In administering the CHCF-A program the commission shall do all of the following:
(1)Continue to set rates to be charged by the small independent telephone corporations in accordance with Sections 451, 454, 455, and 728.
(2)Employ rate-of-return regulation to determine a small independent telephone corporations revenue requirement in a manner that provides revenues and earnings sufficient to allow the telephone corporation to deliver safe, reliable, high-quality voice communication service and fulfill its obligations as a carrier of last resort in its service territory, and to afford the telephone corporation a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable return on its investments, attract capital for investment on reasonable terms, and ensure the financial integrity of the telephone corporation.
(3)Ensure that the rates charged to customers of small independent telephone corporations are just and reasonable and are reasonably comparable to rates charged to customers of urban telephone corporations.
(4)Provide universal service rate support from the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund to small independent telephone corporations in an amount sufficient to supply the portion of the revenue requirement that cannot reasonably be provided by the customers of each small independent telephone corporation after receipt of federal universal service rate support.
(5)Promote customer access to advanced services and deployment of broadband-capable facilities in rural areas that is reasonably comparable to that in urban areas, consistent with national communications policy.
(6)Include all reasonable investments necessary to provide for the delivery of high-quality voice communication services and the deployment of broadband-capable facilities in the rate base of small independent telephone corporations.
(7)Ensure that support is not excessive so that the burden on all contributors to the CHCF-A program is limited.
(d)In order to participate in the CHCF-A program, a small independent telephone corporation shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)Be subject to rate-of-return regulation.
(2)Be subject to the commissions regulation of telephone corporations pursuant to this division.
(3)Be a carrier of last resort in their service territory.
(4)Qualify as a rural telephone company under federal law (47 U.S.C. Sec. 153(44)).
(e)Upon request from the commission, a small independent telephone corporation that receives support from the CHCF-A program shall provide information regarding revenues derived from the provision of unregulated Internet access service by that corporation or its affiliate within that corporations telephone service territory. The commission shall treat as confidential any information provided pursuant to this subdivision.
(f)The commission shall structure the CHCF-A program so that any charge imposed to promote the goals of universal service reasonably equals the value of the benefits of universal service to contributing entities and their subscribers.
(g)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2019, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 2.Section 455.4 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:455.4.(a)For purposes of this section, small independent telephone corporation has the same meaning as in Section 275.6.
(b)A small independent telephone corporation may file its general rate case application or advice letter initiating a general rate case any time up to and including December 1 of the second year preceding the test year used in its rate case.
(c)The commission shall issue its final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporations filing of its general rate case application or advice letter initiating the general rate case.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 454, if the commission fails to issue a final decision as required by subdivision (c), the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter shall take effect on an interim basis beginning 390 days following the filing of the application or advice letter. That rate design shall be subject to an accounting true-up if a final commission decision or resolution concluding the rate case is issued within 420 days of the filing. The rate design adopted in a commission decision or resolution within 420 days shall be made effective as of the 390th day and the accounting true-up shall eliminate any revenue differences between the interim rate design and the rate design in the commission decision or resolution. If a final decision or resolution concluding the case has not been issued by the commission within 420 days of the filing, the interim rate design that took effect on the 390th day following the filing of the general rate case application or advice letter shall become final and that rate design shall remain in place until the commission issues a final decision or resolution concluding the rate case, without any true-up accounting. Any new rate design adopted in a final decision or resolution issued by the commission after 420 days following the filing of the application or advice letter shall take effect on a prospective basis only, as of the effective date of the final decision or resolution.
(e)The requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) may be waived at any time by mutual consent of the executive director of the commission and the small independent telephone corporation.
(a)The commission shall exercise its regulatory authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements established by the commission through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the states universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Carrier of last resort means a telephone corporation that is required to fulfill all reasonable requests for service within its service territory.
(2)Rate base means the value of a telephone corporations plant and equipment that is reasonably necessary to provide regulated voice services and access to advanced services, and upon which the telephone corporation is entitled to a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable rate of return.
(3)Rate design means the mix of end user rates, high-cost support, and other revenue sources that are targeted to provide a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement of the telephone corporation.
(4)Rate-of-return regulation means a regulatory structure whereby the commission establishes a telephone corporations revenue requirements, and then fashions a rate design to provide the company a fair opportunity to meet the revenue requirement.
(5)Revenue requirement means the amount that is necessary for a telephone corporation to recover its reasonable expenses and tax liabilities and earn a reasonable rate of return on its rate base.
(6)Small independent telephone corporations are rural incumbent local exchange carriers subject to commission regulation.
(c)In administering the CHCF-A program the commission shall do all of the following:
(1)Continue to set rates to be charged by the small independent telephone corporations in accordance with Sections 451, 454, 455, and 728.
(2)Employ rate-of-return regulation to determine a small independent telephone corporations revenue requirement in a manner that provides revenues and earnings sufficient to allow the telephone corporation to deliver safe, reliable, high-quality voice communication service and fulfill its obligations as a carrier of last resort in its service territory, and to afford the telephone corporation a fair opportunity to earn a reasonable return on its investments, attract capital for investment on reasonable terms, and ensure the financial integrity of the telephone corporation.
(3)Ensure that the rates charged to customers of small independent telephone corporations are just and reasonable and are reasonably comparable to rates charged to customers of urban telephone corporations.
(4)Provide universal service rate support from the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund to small independent telephone corporations in an amount sufficient to supply the portion of the revenue requirement that cannot reasonably be provided by the customers of each small independent telephone corporation after receipt of federal universal service rate support.
(5)Promote customer access to advanced services and deployment of broadband-capable facilities in rural areas that is reasonably comparable to that in urban areas, consistent with national communications policy.
(6)Include all reasonable investments necessary to provide for the delivery of high-quality voice communication services and the deployment of broadband-capable facilities in the rate base of small independent telephone corporations.
(7)Ensure that support is not excessive so that the burden on all contributors to the CHCF-A program is limited.
(d)In order to participate in the CHCF-A program, a small independent telephone corporation shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)Be subject to rate-of-return regulation.
(2)Be subject to the commissions regulation of telephone corporations pursuant to this division.
(3)Be a carrier of last resort in their service territory.
(4)Qualify as a rural telephone company under federal law (47 U.S.C. Sec. 153(44)).
(e)Upon request from the commission, a small independent telephone corporation that receives support from the CHCF-A program shall provide information regarding revenues derived from the provision of unregulated Internet access service by that corporation or its affiliate within that corporations telephone service territory. The commission shall treat as confidential any information provided pursuant to this subdivision.
(f)The commission shall structure the CHCF-A program so that any charge imposed to promote the goals of universal service reasonably equals the value of the benefits of universal service to contributing entities and their subscribers.
(g)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2019, deletes or extends that date.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 20, 2016 | June 29 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | Referred to Com. on U. & C. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 4150.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 31, 2016 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 4003.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 20, 2016 | Set for hearing May 27. |
| May 16, 2016 | May 16 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) |
| May 6, 2016 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 3593.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Apr 4, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on E., U., & C. |
| Mar 29, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 17, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 2, 2016 | Special Consent # SB1122 Cannella | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1122
:
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/19/16
AYES: Hueso, Morrell, Cannella, Gaines, Hertzberg, Hill, Lara, Leyva, McGuire, Pavley, Wolk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
SOURCE: California Communications Association
DIGEST: This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to make a final decision in a general rate case (GRC) of a small independent telephone company no later than 390 days following the company’s filing and if the deadline is missed, provides that the utility may file a tariff implementing interim rates that may be increased by an amount equal to the rate of inflation. This bill requires the interim rates to be subject to refund and adjusted consistent with the final rates adopted by the CPUC.
Existing law:
- Provides federal universal service funding to providers serving rural, high-cost areas to help pay for facilities that provide customers both voice and broadband service for customers in rural, insular and high-cost areas to ensure they have access to telecommunications services that are reasonably comparable to those services provided in urban areas and that are available at rates that are reasonably comparable to rates charged for similar services. (47 U.S.C. 254)
- Requires the CPUC to regulate utilities, including telephone corporations and to establish just and reasonable rates for service, with corporations proposing rates either through a GRC application or an advice letter. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Requires the CPUC to exercise its legal authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements established by the CPUC through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the state’s universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state. (Public Utilities Code §275.6)
- Requires the CPUC to resolve GRC proceeding within 18 months of the date the scoping memo is issued, unless the CPUC makes a written determination that the deadline cannot be met and provides that no single order can extend the deadline for more than 60 days. Provides that the CPUC may specify in a scoping memo a resolution date later than 18 months if the memo includes specific reasons for the later date and the assigned commissioner approves the date. (Public Utilities Code §1701.5)
- Requires the CPUC to issue a final decision on a GRC application of a large (Class A) water corporation within one year and requires interim rates that may be increased by an amount equal to the rate of inflation as compared to existing rates to take effect if the CPUC misses the deadline. Provides the presiding officer determines the water corporation’s actions have delayed resolution, the presiding officer or the CPUC may require a different date for interim rates. (Public Utilities Code §455.2)
- Requires the CPUC to submit an annual report to the Legislature on the number of cases where resolution exceeded prescribed time periods in scoping memos. (Public Utilities Code §910.1)
This bill:
- Revises the CHCF-A program requirements to provide that the revenue requirement of a small independent telephone corporation includes rate expenses defined as the reasonable costs, as determined by the CPUC, incurred by a telephone corporation in preparing, initiating, and participating in any CPUC proceeding or advice letter process in which its rates, rate design, or revenue requirement are evaluated or adjusted.
- Requires the CPUC to issue a final decision on a GRC of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporation’s filing of its general case application or advice letter.
- Provides that if the CPUC fails to issue a final decision as required, the telephone corporation may file a tariff implementing interim rates that may be increased by an amount equal to the rate of inflation as compared to existing rates.
- Requires that the interim rates to be subject to refund and must be adjusted upward or downward to the interim rate effective date, consistent with the final rates adopted by the CPUC. The CPUC may authorize a lesser increase in interim rates if the CPUC finds the rates to be in the public interest.
- Provides that if the presiding officer in the rate case determines that the CPUC’s decision can’t become effective on the first day of the first test year due to actions by the small independent telephone corporation, the presiding officer or CPUC may require a different effective date for the interim rates or final rates.
- Provides that the deadlines established by this bill can be waived by mutual consent of the executive director of the CPUC and the small independent telephone corporation.
Background
Small independent telephone companies. There are 13 small independent telephone companies that provide local exchange telecommunications service in rural areas of the state. These include: Calaveras Telephone located in Calaveras County, Cal-Ore Telephone in Doris near Shasta, Ducor Telephone in the Southern San Joaquin Valley, Foresthill Telephone located in northeast Sacramento, Kerman Telephone in western Fresno County, Pinnacles Telephone in San Benito Valley, Ponderosa Telephone in Madera/Fresno/San Bernardino, Sierra Telephone serving Madera/Mariposa, Siskiyou Telephone in northern California, and Volcano Telephone in Amador County. The small companies operate as monopoly providers under traditional rate of return regulation with rates set by the CPUC. Rates are determined through a GRC proceeding with evidentiary hearings before an administrative law judge (ALJ) in which other parties participate, or through a less formal advice letter process administered by the CPUC staff. As part of the rate case, the CPUC determines a revenue requirement necessary to cover the company’s expenses, a return on capital investment, and a profit. However, since these areas are a high cost to serve, the revenue from rates is supplemented with support from the CHCF-A.
California High-Cost A-Fund. Public Utilities Section 275.6 requires the CPUC to minimize telephone rate disparities between rural and metropolitan areas to keep rates affordable in areas with lower population densities. This fund supports the 13 small independent telephone companies to allow rural residents to stay connected to essential services to maintain public safety and public health. In the current fiscal year, the CPUC has budgeted 43.3 million dollars from the A-Fund.
Federal High-Cost Program. In addition to the revenue from rates and the A-Fund, the small telephone companies receive support from the federal universal service program as cost recovery for the portion of their facilities that are deemed to be for interstate services. Although originally designed to only be for voice service, the Federal Communications Commission in November 2011 issued a major decision revamping the former Universal Service Fund into the Connect America Fund (CAF) to provide subsidies for facilities that provide broadband and voice service. Carriers that accept the CAF funding must meet broadband build-out requirements and demonstrate that their networks provide minimum broadband speeds.
The poster child – Kerman Telephone. Kerman Telephone Company filed a GRC application in December 2011. The CPUC issued its first scoping memo six months later. In December 2012, the CPUC rejected a settlement agreement between the two main parties, Kerman Telephone and the Office of Ratepayer Advocates. Eight months later the CPUC issues a revised scoping memo. Eventually, Kerman filed for interim rate relief, which the CPUC denied. In October 2013, the CPUC adopted a stay of the rate case. The decision provided for an additional six month stay. Kerman filed a court appeal challenging the CPUC’s delay. Kerman has not had a rate change in nine years which has left the company operating under a “cloud of regulatory uncertainty.” Recently, on March 29th, the CPUC released a proposed decision for Kerman.
AB 1693 (Perea, 2014). AB 1693 was passed unanimously by the Legislature in 2014. The bill was very similar to this bill, as it would have required a date certain for small telephone companies on their GRCs. However, the bill was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message of the bill, Governor Brown stated: “this bill sets inflexible time limits for the completion of small telephone company rate cases and potentially harm ratepayers. I am directing the CPUC to address the concerns of the proponents and to create a Rate Case Plan to encourage timely completion of these rate cases.” Through Decision 15-06-04 in June 2015, the CPUC adopted a plan that set forth a timeline for how the CPUC will conduct GRCs for the small independent telephone companies going forward. The timelines adopted as guidelines for resolving rate cases are those that are included in this bill as a requirement. (Timeline table below)
Table below sets forth benchmarks and associated timelines for the GRC applications. (R. 11-11-007) | |
Benchmark/Timeline | Day (Count) |
Applicant submits Notice of Intent to CD | -60 |
Applicant provides initial proposals, basic ratemaking and summary calculations to ORA, CD, and other interested parties. Parties make good faith effort to reach agreement on procedural, discovery and confidentiality protocols. | From -60 to -30 |
ORA sends Master Data Request to Applicant | -55 |
Applicant responds to ORA’s Master Data Request (MDR) | -41 |
CD provides deficiency or compliance letter to the Applicant any dispute between the Applicant and ORA on the MDRs is to be resolved by the Director of CD. | -30 |
Applicant resolves deficiencies | ASAP: -30 but by -20 |
At request of any party, CD convenes informal workshop for parties to meet and confer, and to address any potential application deficiencies/matters. | From -20 to -5 |
GRC Application Filed and Testimony served | 0 |
Protest/Intervenor Deadline | 30 |
Reply to protest | 40 |
Prehearing Conference | 60 |
Parties perform discovery (including supplemental data requests and field visits); Public Participation Hearings held | 0-150 |
Intervenor Testimony Due | 150 |
Rebuttal Testimony Due | 180 |
Evidentiary Hearings | 210-220 |
Opening Briefs | 250 |
Reply Briefs/ALJ closes record | 271 |
Proposed Decision | 331 |
Comments on PD | 351 |
Commission Meeting/Decision | 361-390 |
Implement new GRC rate structure | 390-420 |
Rate case expenses. In the attempts to resolve the Kerman Telephone GRC, the CPUC essentially started anew, restarting the case using a 2016 test year. As a result, Kerman, as well as, the other parties, namely ORA, had to conduct new analysis and provide new testimony. According to CalCom, the original expenses had to be absorbed. The changes in this bill reflect that experience and provide telephone corporations the opportunity to include rate case expenses resulting from preparing and participating in a rate-related proceeding.
Is a bill needed? While the Kerman Telephone GRC may be an anomaly. The CPUC has struggled with adhering to the recommended timelines for resolving proceedings. In recent years, there’s been an effort by the agency to better account for the proceedings and their status. The focused commitment from the Executive Director, Commissioners and staff is showing some measurable improvement. However, there are also challenges with the manner that some cases are closed and reopened as new proceedings. Proponents of this bill refer to the statute and the deadlines included for water corporations as a model for how timelines should be required for small telephone companies. However, in the case of water corporations, the interim rates are based on the existing rates with some accounting for inflation. Additionally, the water corporation statute related to proceeding timelines provides the ALJ and CPUC additional discretion, particularly if it is determined the delays in the proceeding have been caused by the corporation.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 1693 (Perea, 2014) a bill very similar to the one being proposes. AB 1693 would have required the CPUC to complete a GRC of a small independent telephone corporation within 390 days. If the deadline was not met, the bill would have established procedures for interim rates. The bill was vetoed.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, approximately $184,000 (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account) to the CPUC for one full-time ALJs to ensure that the codified deadlines are met.
California Communications Association (source)
California’s Independent Telecommunications Companies
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/31/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author states: “A core function of the CPUC is rate-setting. Utilities subject to rate regulations, like the member telephone companies of CalCom, cannot change any rate without CPUC review and approval through a General Rate Setting Application. As such, the efficient operation and economic health of rate-regulated utilities, and ultimately their ability to make investments and upgrades to ensure they are meeting the needs of their communities and customers. If the CPUC fails to timely process a telephone company’s rate case, there is no mechanism by which the company can compel the Commission to act. Plus, the current generic California statutory requirement on the CPUC for the timely completion of its proceedings is easily circumvented and even ignored by the CPUC. Over the past 20 years, the CPUC has processed more than two dozen small telephone company rate cases, resolving most of them within 13 months. Kerman’s rate cases filing was straightforward, containing no matter that would justify additional time. Although Kerman could be considered an anomaly, the fact that five years can go by and have no resolution should give any company regulated by the CPUC pause.”
5/31/16 21:31:38
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1122 (Cannella) - Telecommunications: small independent telephone corporations: rates: universal service: California High-Cost Fund-A
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 1122 requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to make a final decision in a general rate case of a small independent telephone company no later than 390 days following the company’s filing and, if the deadline is missed, provides that the proposed rates will take effect on an interim basis subject to an accounting true-up if a decision is issued within 420 days of the filing. If a final decision is made after 420th day, the new rate will take effect prospectively with no true-up to the interim rates. This bill also allows rate case expenses to be an eligible expense within the California High-Cost Fund-A Program that provides universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 27, 2016
Fiscal Impact:
- Approximately $184,000 (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account) to the CPUC for one full-time Administrative Law Judges to ensure that the codified deadlines are met.
Committee Amendments:
- Amends the definition of rate case expense to allow reasonable costs to be determined by the CPUC.
- Strikes provision allowing rate case expenses to be separately included in the revenue requirement regardless of any CPUC determinations regarding the reasonableness of other expenses.
- Allows small independent telephone corporation to file a tariff implementing interim rates equal to the current rate plus inflation if the CPUC does not meet the deadlines for approving rate cases.
- Specifies that the interim rates become effective on the first day of the first test year in the general rate case application, unless the presiding officer or the CPUC determine that the decision cannot become effective on the first day of the first test year due to actions by the small independent telephone corporation.
- Specifies that interim rates must be adjusted upward or downward back to the interim rate effective date to reflect the final rates adopted by the CPUC.
- Allows the CPUC to authorize a lesser increase in interim rates if the CPUC finds the rates to be in the public interest.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1122 (Cannella) - Telecommunications: small independent telephone corporations: rates: universal service: California High-Cost Fund-A
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 1122 requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to make a final decision in a general rate case of a small independent telephone company no later than 390 days following the company’s filing and if the deadline is missed, provides that the proposed rates will take effect on an interim basis subject to an accounting true-up if a decision is issued within 420 days of the filing. If a final decision is made after 420th day, the new rate will take effect prospectively with no true-up to the interim rates. This bill also allows rate case expenses to be an eligible expense within the California High-Cost Fund-A Program that provides universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations.
Fiscal Impact:
- Up to $367,320 (Public Utilities Commission Utilities Reimbursement Account) to the Public Utilities Commission for up to two full-time Administrative Law Judges to ensure that the codified deadlines are met.
Background:
Small Independent Telephone Companies. There are 13 small independent telephone companies that provide local exchange telecommunications service in rural areas of the state. The small companies operate as monopoly providers under traditional rate of return regulation with rates set by the CPUC. Rates are determined through a general rate case (GRC) proceeding with evidentiary hearings before an administrative law judge (ALJ) in which other parties participate, or through a less formal advice letter process administered by the CPUC staff. As part of the rate case, the CPUC determines a revenue requirement necessary to cover the company’s expenses, a return on capital investment, and a profit. However, since these areas are a high cost to serve, the revenue from rates is supplemented with support from the CHCF-A.
California High-Cost A-Fund. Public Utilities §275.6 requires the CPUC to minimize telephone rate disparities between rural and metropolitan areas to keep rates affordable in areas with lower population densities. This fund supports the 13 small independent telephone companies to allow rural residents to stay connected to essential services to maintain public safety and public health. In the current fiscal year, the CPUC has budgeted 43.3 million dollars from the A-Fund.
Federal High-Cost Program. In addition to the revenue from rates and the A-Fund, the small telephone companies receive support from the federal universal service program as cost recovery for the portion of their facilities that are deemed to be for interstate services. Although originally designed to only be for voice service, the FCC in November 2011 issued a major decision revamping the former Universal Service Fund into the Connect America Fund (CAF) to provide subsidies for facilities that provide broadband and voice service. Carriers that accept the CAF funding must meet broadband build-out requirements and demonstrate that their networks provide minimum broadband speeds.
AB 1693 (Perea). AB 1693 was passed unanimously by the Legislature in 2014. The bill was very similar to this bill, as it would have required a date certain for small telephone companies on their GRCs. However, the bill was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message of the bill, Governor Brown stated: “this bill sets inflexible time limits for the completion of small telephone company rate cases and potentially harm ratepayers. I am directing the CPUC to address the concerns of the proponents and to create a Rate Case Plan to encourage timely completion of these rate cases.”
Through Decision 15-06-04 in June 2015, the CPUC adopted a plan that set forth a timeline for how the CPUC will conduct general rate cases for the small independent telephone companies going forward. The timelines adopted as guidelines for resolving rate cases are those that are included in this bill as a requirement.
The poster child – Kerman Telephone. Kerman Telephone Company filed a general rate case application in December 2011. The CPUC issued its first scoping memo six months later. In December 2012, the CPUC rejected a settlement agreement between the two main parties, Kerman Telephone and the Office of Ratepayer Advocates. Eight months later the CPUC issues a revised scoping memo. Eventually, Kerman filed for interim rate relief, which the CPUC denied. In October 2013, the CPUC adopted a stay of the rate case. The decision provided for an additional six month stay. Kerman filed a court appeal challenging the CPUC’s delay. Kerman has not had a rate change in nine years which has left the company operating under a “cloud of regulatory uncertainty.” Recently, on March 29th, the CPUC released a proposed decision for Kerman.
Proposed Law:
This bill:
- Revises the CHCF-A program requirements to provide that the revenue requirement of a small independent telephone corporation includes rate expenses defined as the reasonable costs incurred by a telephone corporation in preparing and participating in any CPUC proceeding or advice letter process related to its rates.
- Requires the CPUC to issue a final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporation’s filing of its general case application or advice letter.
- Provides that if the CPUC fails to issue a final decision as required, the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter shall take effect on an interim basis beginning 390 days from the filing.
- Requires that the interim rate design will be subject to an accounting true-up if a final CPUC decision or resolution concluding the rate case is issued within 420 days. The new rate will be applied retroactively to the 390th day and the accounting true-up will eliminate any revenue differences.
- Requires that if a final decision has not been made by the 420th day, the interim rate shall become final until the CPUC issues a final decision without any true-up accounting.
- Provides that the deadlines established by this bill can be waived by mutual consent of the executive director of the CPUC and the small independent telephone corporation.
Related Legislation:
AB 1693 (Perea, 2014) a bill very similar to the one being proposes. AB 1693 would have required the CPUC to complete a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation within 390 days. If the deadline was not met, the bill would have established procedures for interim rates. Vetoed by the Governor.
Staff Comments:
At the direction of the Governor’s veto message, the CPUC adopted the Rate Case Plan Schedule in 2015. This plan outlines timelines for the completion of rate case proceedings (the same as those outlined in the bill) as well as deadlines for submission of rate cases to normalize workload. This cost estimate assumes that the CPUC’s historical inability to close general rate proceedings expeditiously was, at least in part, the result of staff capacity issues. Given that the schedule would be codified if this bill is enacted, the CPUC would need to redirect staff from other activities or hire new staff to ensure the statutory deadline is met.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 1122 Hearing Date: 4/19/2016
Author: | Cannella | ||
Version: | 3/29/2016 As Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Telecommunications: small independent telephone corporations: rates: universal service: California High-Cost Fund-A
DIGEST: This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to make a final decision in a general rate case of a small independent telephone company no later than 390 days following the company’s filing and if the deadline is missed, provides that the proposed rates will take effect on an interim basis subject to an accounting true-up if a decision is issued within 420 days of the filing. If a final decision is made after 420th day, the new rate will take effect prospectively with no true-up to the interim rates. This bill also allows rate case expenses to be an eligible expense within the California High-Cost Fund-A Program that provides universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides federal universal service funding to providers serving rural, high-cost areas to help pay for facilities that provide customers both voice and broadband service for customers in rural, insular and high-cost areas to ensure they have access to telecommunications services that are reasonably comparable to those services provided in urban areas and that are available at rates that are reasonably comparable to rates charged for similar services. (47 U.S.C. 254)
- Requires the CPUC to regulate utilities, including telephone corporations and to establish just and reasonable rates for service, with corporations proposing rates either through a general rate case application or an advice letter. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Requires the CPUC to exercise its legal authority to maintain the California High-Cost Fund-A Administrative Committee Fund program (CHCF-A program) to provide universal service rate support to small independent telephone corporations in amounts sufficient to meet the revenue requirements established by the CPUC through rate-of-return regulation in furtherance of the state’s universal service commitment to the continued affordability and widespread availability of safe, reliable, high-quality communications services in rural areas of the state. (Public Utilities Code §275.6)
- Requires the CPUC to resolve general rate case proceeding within 18 months of the date the scoping memo is issued, unless the CPUC makes a written determination that the deadline cannot be met and provides that no single order can extend the deadline for more than 60 days. Provides that the CPUC may specify in a scoping memo a resolution date later than 18 months if the memo includes specific reasons for the later date and the assigned commissioner approves the date. (Public Utilities Code §1701.5)
- Requires the CPUC to issue a final decision on a general rate case application of a large (Class A) water corporation within one year and requires interim rates that may be increased by an amount equal to the rate of inflation as compared to existing rates to take effect if the CPUC misses the deadline. Provides the presiding officer determines the water corporation’s actions have delayed resolution, the presiding officer or the CPUC may require a different date for interim rates. (Public Utilities Code §455.2)
- Requires the CPUC to submit an annual report to the Legislature on the number of cases where resolution exceeded prescribed time periods in scoping memos. (Public Utilities Code §910.1)
This bill:
- Revises the CHCF-A program requirements to provide that the revenue requirement of a small independent telephone corporation includes rate expenses defined as the reasonable costs incurred by a telephone corporation in preparing and participating in any CPUC proceeding or advice letter process related to its rates.
- Requires the CPUC to issue a final decision on a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation no later than 390 days following the corporation’s filing of its general case application or advice letter.
- Provides that if the CPUC fails to issue a final decision as required, the rate design proposed by the small independent telephone corporation in its application or advice letter shall take effect on an interim basis beginning 390 days from the filing.
- Requires that the interim rate design will be subject to an accounting true-up if a final CPUC decision or resolution concluding the rate case is issued within 420 days. The new rate will be applied retroactively to the 390th day and the accounting true-up will eliminate any revenue differences.
- Requires that if a final decision has not been made by the 420th day, the interim rate shall become final until the CPUC issues a final decision without any true-up accounting.
- Provides that the deadlines established by this bill can be waived by mutual consent of the executive director of the CPUC and the small independent telephone corporation.
Background
Small Independent Telephone Companies. There are 13 small independent telephone companies that provide local exchange telecommunications service in rural areas of the state. These include: Calaveras Telephone located in Calaveras County, Cal-Ore Telephone in Doris near Shasta, Ducor Telephone in the Southern San Joaquin Valley, Foresthill Telephone located in northeast Sacramento, Kerman Telephone in western Fresno County, Pinnacles Telephone in San Benito Valley, Ponderosa Telephone in Madera/Fresno/San Bernardino, Sierra Telephone serving Madera/Mariposa, Siskiyou Telephone in northern California, and Volcano Telephone in Amador County. The small companies operate as monopoly providers under traditional rate of return regulation with rates set by the CPUC. Rates are determined through a general rate case (GRC) proceeding with evidentiary hearings before an administrative law judge (ALJ) in which other parties participate, or through a less formal advice letter process administered by the CPUC staff. As part of the rate case, the CPUC determines a revenue requirement necessary to cover the company’s expenses, a return on capital investment, and a profit. However, since these areas are a high cost to serve, the revenue from rates is supplemented with support from the CHCF-A.
California High-Cost A-Fund. Public Utilities §275.6 requires the CPUC to minimize telephone rate disparities between rural and metropolitan areas to keep rates affordable in areas with lower population densities. This fund supports the 13 small independent telephone companies to allow rural residents to stay connected to essential services to maintain public safety and public health. In the current fiscal year, the CPUC has budgeted 43.3 million dollars from the A-Fund.
Federal High-Cost Program. In addition to the revenue from rates and the A-Fund, the small telephone companies receive support from the federal universal service program as cost recovery for the portion of their facilities that are deemed to be for interstate services. Although originally designed to only be for voice service, the FCC in November 2011 issued a major decision revamping the former Universal Service Fund into the Connect America Fund (CAF) to provide subsidies for facilities that provide broadband and voice service. Carriers that accept the CAF funding must meet broadband build-out requirements and demonstrate that their networks provide minimum broadband speeds.
The poster child – Kerman Telephone. Kerman Telephone Company filed a general rate case application in December 2011. The CPUC issued its first scoping memo six months later. In December 2012, the CPUC rejected a settlement agreement between the two main parties, Kerman Telephone and the Office of Ratepayer Advocates. Eight months later the CPUC issues a revised scoping memo. Eventually, Kerman filed for interim rate relief, which the CPUC denied. In October 2013, the CPUC adopted a stay of the rate case. The decision provided for an additional six month stay. Kerman filed a court appeal challenging the CPUC’s delay. Kerman has not had a rate change in nine years which has left the company operating under a “cloud of regulatory uncertainty.” Recently, on March 29th, the CPUC released a proposed decision for Kerman.
AB 1693 (Perea). AB 1693 was passed unanimously by the Legislature in 2014. The bill was very similar to this bill, as it would have required a date certain for small telephone companies on their GRCs. However, the bill was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message of the bill, Governor Brown stated: “this bill sets inflexible time limits for the completion of small telephone company rate cases and potentially harm ratepayers. I am directing the CPUC to address the concerns of the proponents and to create a Rate Case Plan to encourage timely completion of these rate cases.” Through Decision 15-06-04 in June 2015, the CPUC adopted a plan that set forth a timeline for how the CPUC will conduct general rate cases for the small independent telephone companies going forward. The timelines adopted as guidelines for resolving rate cases are those that are included in this bill as a requirement. (Timeline table below)
Table below sets forth benchmarks and associated timelines for the GRC applications. (R. 11-11-007) | |
Benchmark/Timeline | Day (Count) |
Applicant submits Notice of Intent to CD | -60 |
Applicant provides initial proposals, basic ratemaking and summary calculations to ORA, CD, and other interested parties. Parties make good faith effort to reach agreement on procedural, discovery and confidentiality protocols. | From -60 to -30 |
ORA sends Master Data Request to Applicant | -55 |
Applicant responds to ORA’s Master Data Request (MDR) | -41 |
CD provides deficiency or compliance letter to the Applicant any dispute between the Applicant and ORA on the MDRs is to be resolved by the Director of CD. | -30 |
Applicant resolves deficiencies | ASAP: -30 but by -20 |
At request of any party, CD convenes informal workshop for parties to meet and confer, and to address any potential application deficiencies/matters. | From -20 to -5 |
GRC Application Filed and Testimony served | 0 |
Protest/Intervenor Deadline | 30 |
Reply to protest | 40 |
Prehearing Conference | 60 |
Parties perform discovery (including supplemental data requests and field visits); Public Participation Hearings held | 0-150 |
Intervenor Testimony Due | 150 |
Rebuttal Testimony Due | 180 |
Evidentiary Hearings | 210-220 |
Opening Briefs | 250 |
Reply Briefs/ALJ closes record | 271 |
Proposed Decision | 331 |
Comments on PD | 351 |
Commission Meeting/Decision | 361-390 |
Implement new GRC rate structure | 390-420 |
Rate case expenses. In the attempts to resolve the Kerman Telephone general rate case, the CPUC essentially started anew, restarting the case using a 2016 test year. As a result, Kerman, as well as, the other parties, namely ORA, had to conduct new analysis and provide new testimony. According to CalCom, the original expenses had to be absorbed. The changes in this bill reflect that experience and provide telephone corporations the opportunity to include rate case expenses resulting from preparing and participating in a rate-related proceeding. However, it is unclear exactly what expenses are covered and which would not be covered. The author and committee may wish to require the CPUC to determine what are considered rate case expenses.
Is a bill needed? While the Kerman Telephone general rate case may be an anomaly. The CPUC has struggled with adhering to the recommended timelines for resolving proceedings. In recent years, there’s been an effort by the agency to better account for the proceedings and their status. The focused commitment from the Executive Director, Commissioners and staff is showing some measurable improvement. However, there are also challenges with the manner that some cases are closed and reopened as new proceedings. Proponents of this bill refer to the statute and the deadlines included for water corporations as a model for how timelines should be required for small telephone companies. However, in the case of water corporations, the interim rates are based on the existing rates with some accounting for inflation, whereas this bill is proposing to adopt the corporation’s proposed rates as the interim rates. Generally, a utility will propose higher rates than what is usually found to be just and reasonable. Additionally, the water corporation statute related to proceeding timelines provides the administrative law judge and CPUC additional discretion, particularly if it is determined the delays in the proceeding have been caused by the corporation. The author and committee may wish to add language to this bill in order to mirror the provisions that exist for water corporations that establish the interim rates based on the existing rate plus inflation and allow the CPUC some discretion when it is determined the corporation has caused the delay in the proceeding.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 1693 (Perea, 2014) a bill very similar to the one being proposes. AB 1693 would have required the CPUC to complete a general rate case of a small independent telephone corporation within 390 days. If the deadline was not met, the bill would have established procedures for interim rates.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT:
California Communications Association (Source)
California’s Independent Telecommunications Companies
OPPOSITION:
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author states: “A core function of the CPUC is rate-setting. Utilities subject to rate regulations, like the member telephone companies of CalCom, cannot change any rate without CPUC review and approval through a General Rate Setting Application. As such, the efficient operation and economic health of rate-regulated utilities, and ultimately their ability to make investments and upgrades to ensure they are meeting the needs of their communities and customers. If the CPUC fails to timely process a telephone company’s rate case, there is no mechanism by which the company can compel the Commission to act. Plus, the current generic California statutory requirement on the CPUC for the timely completion of its proceedings is easily circumvented and even ignored by the CPUC. Over the past 20 years, the Commission has processed more than two dozen small telephone company rate cases, resolving most of them within 13 months. Kerman’s rate cases filing was straightforward, containing no matter that would justify additional time. Although Kerman could be considered an anomaly, the fact that five years can go by and have no resolution should give any company regulated by the CPUC pause.”
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):