SB 1190: California Coastal Commission: ex parte communications: staff communications.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-29
The California Coastal Act of 1976, establishes the California Coastal Commission, and prescribes the membership and functions and duties of the commission. The act requires the commission to meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public.
This bill would require the commission, commencing on or before July 1, 2017, to also provide for public access to participation at all commission meeting meetings via telephone and video conferencing. the Internet, as prescribed. The bill would require the commission to include in the executive summary section of a staff report a list of references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction.
For purposes of the act, an ex parte communication is defined as any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte communication on a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, or any oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter. The bill would require a commission member to report these communications in writing, would require the report to be placed in the public record, and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported. The bill would exclude from the above provisions a project site visit by commission members and staff that meets certain requirements and communications conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official, as specified.
This bill would also require the commission to adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a policy that prohibits a commission member from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined, on commission staff. The bill would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate who willfully violates that provision from holding any position at the commission.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, establishes the California Coastal Commission, and prescribes the membership and functions and duties of the commission. The act requires the commission to meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public.
This bill would require the commission, commencing on or before July 1, 2017, to also provide public access to all commission meeting via telephone and video conferencing. The bill would require the commission to include in the executive summary section of a staff report references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction.
For purposes of the act, an ex parte communication is defined as any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte communication on a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, or any oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter. The bill would require a commission member to report these communications in writing, would require the report to be placed in the public record, and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported. The bill would exclude from the above provisions a project site visit by commission members and staff that meets certain requirements and communications conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official, as specified.
This bill would also require the commission to adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a policy that prohibits a commission member from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined, on commission staff. The bill would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate who willfully violates that provision from holding any position at the commission.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, for establishes the California Coastal Commission, and prescribes the membership and functions and duties of the commission. The act requires the commission to meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public.
This bill would require the commission, commencing on or before July 1, 2017, to also provide public access to all commission meeting via telephone and video conferencing. The bill would require the commission to include in the executive summary section of a staff report references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction.
For purposes of the act, defines an ex parte communication is defined as any oral or written communication between a member of the California Coastal Commission commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte communication or any oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter. The bill would require a commission member to report these communications in writing, would require the report to be placed in the public record, and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported. The bill would exclude from the above provisions a project site visit by commission members and staff that meets certain requirements and communications conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official, as specified.
This bill would also prohibit a commission member or alternate from attempting require the commission to adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a policy that prohibits a commission member from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the report, analysis, or recommendation applies. staff. The bill would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate who willfully violates that provision from holding any position at the commission.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, for purposes of the act, defines an ex parte communication as any oral or written communication between a member of the California Coastal Commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would require certain ex parte communications to be reported in writing, and included in the record of the applicable proceeding. The bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte communication concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission or any oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter. The bill would require a commission member to report these communications in writing, would require the report to be placed in the public record, and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported.
This bill would also prohibit a commission member or alternate from attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the report, analysis, or recommendation applies. The bill would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate who willfully violates that provision from holding any position at the commission.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, for purposes of the act, defines an ex parte communication as any oral or written communication between a member of the California Coastal Commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would require certain ex parte communications to be reported in writing, and included in the record of the applicable proceeding. The bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte communication concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission, commission and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported.
This bill would also prohibit a commission member or alternate from attempting to use his or her official position to influence commission staff or in any way alter place undue influence, as defined, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the report, analysis, or recommendation applies. The bill would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate who willfully violates that provision from holding any office in this state. position at the commission.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, for purposes of the act, defines an ex parte communication as any oral or written communication between a member of the California Coastal Commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would instead require certain ex parte communications to be reported in writing, and included in the record of the applicable proceeding. The bill would prohibit a commission member or an interested person from conducting any ex parte communication regardless of whether the communication is disclosed. The bill concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission, and would prohibit a commission member from voting on or otherwise participating in any commission proceeding to which one of these communications applies, even if the communication is reported.
This bill would also prohibit a commission member or alternate from attempting to use his or her official position to influence commission staff for purposes of changing or eliminating any information contained in a commission staff report or analysis or altering any recommendation pertaining to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction prior to the time the staff report, analysis, or recommendation is made public at a hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding. or in any way alter a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the report, analysis, or recommendation applies. The bill would make a willful violation of that prohibition punishable by fine or imprisonment in the state prison and would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate found guilty of a violation who willfully violates that provision from holding any office in this state. By creating a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Coastal Act of 1976, for purposes of the act, defines an ex parte communication as any oral or written communication between a member of the California Coastal Commission and an interested person, as defined, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined, that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter, but excludes from that definition certain communications, including communications between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person, as prescribed. The act prohibits a commission member and an interested person from conducting an ex parte communication unless the member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication, as specified, and prohibits a commission member or alternate from making, participating in making, or in any other way attempting to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported.
This bill would instead prohibit a commission member or an interested person from conducting any ex parte communication regardless of whether the communication is disclosed. The bill would also prohibit a commission member or alternate from attempting to influence commission staff for purposes of changing or eliminating any information contained in a commission staff report or analysis or altering any recommendation pertaining to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction prior to the time the staff report, analysis, or recommendation is made public at a hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding. The bill would make a willful violation of that prohibition punishable by fine or imprisonment in the state prison and would forever disqualify a commission member or alternate found guilty of a violation from holding any office in this state. By creating a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides for the regulation of a person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant, and provides that a violation of these provisions is a crime. Existing law provides that a person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when he or she gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter, as specified.
This bill would provide that a person who gives nonlegal assistance completing a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purposes of employment eligibility and verification is not engaging in the business of acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant.
Existing law authorizes the Secretary of State to appoint and commission notaries public in such number as the secretary deems necessary for the public convenience. Existing law prohibits a notary public who holds himself or herself out as being an immigration specialist, immigration consultant, or any other title that reflects an expertise in immigration matters from advertising in any manner that he or she is a notary public and authorizes a notary public who is qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant, as specified, to enter data, provided by his or her client, on immigration forms provided by a federal or state agency.
This bill would specify that a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification is not an immigration form.
Existing law provides for the regulation of a person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant, and provides that a violation of these provisions is a crime. Existing law provides that a person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when he or she gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter, as specified.
This bill would provide that a person who gives nonlegal assistance completing a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purposes of employment eligibility and verification is not engaging in the business of acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant.
Existing law authorizes the Secretary of State to appoint and commission notaries public in such number as the secretary deems necessary for the public convenience. Existing law prohibits a notary public who holds himself or herself out as being an immigration specialist, immigration consultant, or any other title that reflects an expertise in immigration matters from advertising in any manner that he or she is a notary public and authorizes a notary public who is qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant, as specified, to enter data, provided by his or her client, on immigration forms provided by a federal or state agency.
This bill would specify that a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification is not an immigration form.
(a)The commission shall meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public. Each meeting shall occur not more than 45 days after the previous meeting. All meetings of the commission shall be open to the public.
(b)A majority of the total appointed membership of the commission shall constitute a quorum. An action taken by the commission under this division requires a majority vote of the members present at the meeting of the commission, with a quorum being present, unless otherwise specifically provided for in this division.
(c)Commencing on or before July 1, 2017, the commission also shall provide for public access to participation at all commission meetings via telephone and video conferencing. the Internet. Participation shall include real-time testimony during public comment.
SEC. 2.Section 30321 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30321.(a)For purposes of this article, a matter within the commissions jurisdiction means any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
(b)Commission staff shall include in the executive summary section of a staff report a list of references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials. materials in an addendum. The addendum shall include instructions regarding the use of the information contained in these communications as a basis or influencing factor upon their decision.
SEC. 3.Section 30322 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30322.(a)For purposes of this article, except as provided in subdivision (b), an ex parte communication is any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)The following communications are not ex parte communications:
(1)Any communication between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person.
(2)Any communication limited entirely to procedural issues, including, but not limited to, the hearing schedule, location, format, or filing date.
(3)Any communication which takes place on the record during an official proceeding of a state, regional, or local agency that involves a member of the commission who also serves as an official of that agency.
(4)Any communication between a member of the commission, with regard to any action of another state agency or of a regional or local agency of which the member is an official, and any other official or employee of that agency, including any person who is acting as an attorney for the agency.
(5)Any communication between a nonvoting commission member and a staff member of a state agency where both the commission member and the staff member are acting in an official capacity.
(6)Any communication to a nonvoting commission member relating to an action pending before the commission, where the nonvoting commission member does not participate in that action, either through written or verbal communication, on or off the record, with other members of the commission.
(7)Any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the commission. This paragraph shall not be construed to mean that any other commissioner has conducted an ex parte communication on a matter if the communication occurred before the matter was pending before the commission.
(8)Any project site visit conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30324.
SEC. 4.Section 30324 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30324.(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct either of the following:
(1)An ex parte communication on a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined by Section 30321.
(2)An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), commission members and commission staff may conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the commission and with the permission of the property owner. A description of the site visit shall be a part of the public record of the matter to which the project site pertains and any communications conducted during the site visit shall be limited to those between commission members and staff.
(c)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(d)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 5Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)The commission shall adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a board policy that prohibits a commission member or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff. staff, including, but not limited to, the contents of staff reports.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
(a)The commission shall meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public. Each meeting shall occur not more than 45 days after the previous meeting. All meetings of the commission shall be open to the public.
(b)A majority of the total appointed membership of the commission shall constitute a quorum. An action taken by the commission under this division requires a majority vote of the members present at the meeting of the commission, with a quorum being present, unless otherwise specifically provided for in this division.
(c)Commencing on or before July 1, 2017, the commission also shall provide public access to all commission meetings via telephone and video conferencing.
SEC. 2.Section 30321 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30321.(a)For purposes of this article, a matter within the commissions jurisdiction means any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
(b)Commission staff shall include in the executive summary section of a staff report references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials.
SEC. 3.Section 30322 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30322.(a)For purposes of this article, except as provided in subdivision (b), an ex parte communication is any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)The following communications are not ex parte communications:
(1)Any communication between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person.
(2)Any communication limited entirely to procedural issues, including, but not limited to, the hearing schedule, location, format, or filing date.
(3)Any communication which takes place on the record during an official proceeding of a state, regional, or local agency that involves a member of the commission who also serves as an official of that agency.
(4)Any communication between a member of the commission, with regard to any action of another state agency or of a regional or local agency of which the member is an official, and any other official or employee of that agency, including any person who is acting as an attorney for the agency.
(5)Any communication between a nonvoting commission member and a staff member of a state agency where both the commission member and the staff member are acting in an official capacity.
(6)Any communication to a nonvoting commission member relating to an action pending before the commission, where the nonvoting commission member does not participate in that action, either through written or verbal communication, on or off the record, with other members of the commission.
(7)Any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the commission.
(8)Any project site visit conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30324.
SEC. 4.Section 30324 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30324.(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct either of the following:
(1)An ex parte communication. communication on a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, as defined by Section 30321.
(2)An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), commission members and commission staff may conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the commission and with the permission of the property owner. A description of the site visit shall be a part of the public record of the matter to which the project site pertains and any communications conducted during the site visit shall be limited to those between commission members and staff.
(c)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(d)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 5Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)The commission shall adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a policy that prohibits a commission member or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
(a)The commission shall meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public. Each meeting shall occur not more than 45 days after the previous meeting. All meetings of the commission shall be open to the public.
(b)A majority of the total appointed membership of the commission shall constitute a quorum. An action taken by the commission under this division requires a majority vote of the members present at the meeting of the commission, with a quorum being present, unless otherwise specifically provided for in this division.
(c)Commencing on or before July 1, 2017, the commission also shall provide public access to all commission meetings via telephone and video conferencing.
SEC. 2.Section 30321 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30321.(a)For purposes of this article, a matter within the commissions jurisdiction means any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
(b)Commission staff shall include in the executive summary section of a staff report references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials.
SEC. 3.Section 30322 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30322.(a)For purposes of this article, except as provided in subdivision (b), an ex parte communication is any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, about a matter within the commissions jurisdiction, which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)The following communications are not ex parte communications:
(1)Any communication between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person.
(2)Any communication limited entirely to procedural issues, including, but not limited to, the hearing schedule, location, format, or filing date.
(3)Any communication which takes place on the record during an official proceeding of a state, regional, or local agency that involves a member of the commission who also serves as an official of that agency.
(4)Any communication between a member of the commission, with regard to any action of another state agency or of a regional or local agency of which the member is an official, and any other official or employee of that agency, including any person who is acting as an attorney for the agency.
(5)Any communication between a nonvoting commission member and a staff member of a state agency where both the commission member and the staff member are acting in an official capacity.
(6)Any communication to a nonvoting commission member relating to an action pending before the commission, where the nonvoting commission member does not participate in that action, either through written or verbal communication, on or off the record, with other members of the commission.
(7)Any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the commission.
(8)Any project site visit conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30324.
SECTION 1.SEC. 4.Section 30324 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30324.(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct either of the following:
(1)An ex parte communication.
(2)An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), commission members and commission staff may conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the commission and with the permission of the property owner. A description of the site visit shall be a part of the public record of the matter to which the project site pertains and any communications conducted during the site visit shall be limited to those between commission members and staff.
(b)
(c)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(c)
(d)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 2.SEC. 5Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt The commission shall adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a policy that prohibits a commission member or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the staff report, analysis,or recommendation applies. staff.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct an either of the following:
(1)An ex parte communication concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission. communication.
(2)An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts any ex parte communication, including a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts an ex parte a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(c)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report of an ex parte communication. made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 2.Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the staff report, analysis, or recommendation applies.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct an ex parte communication concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission.
(b)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts any ex parte communication, including a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts an ex parte communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(c)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report of an ex parte communication.
SEC. 2.Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt to use his or her official position to influence or in any way alter place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff for the purpose of altering the contents or conclusions of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the staff report, analysis, or recommendation applies.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any public office in this state. position at the commission.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall conduct an ex parte communication. communication concerning an adjudicative or enforcement proceeding before the commission.
(b)(1)If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts any ex parte communication, including a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts an ex parte communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(c)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report of an ex parte communication.
SEC. 2.Section 30327 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30327.(a)No commission member or alternate shall make, participate in making, or in any other way attempt to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication.
(b)In addition to any other applicable penalty, including a civil fine imposed pursuant to Section 30824, a commission member who knowingly violates this section shall be subject to a civil fine, not to exceed seven thousand five hundred dollars ($7,500). Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, the court may award attorneys fees and costs to the prevailing party.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt to influence commission staff for purposes of changing or eliminating any information contained in a staff report or analysis or altering any recommendation pertaining to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction prior to the time the staff report, analysis, or recommendation is made public at a hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding.
(b)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is punishable by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000) or by imprisonment in the state prison, and is forever disqualified from holding any office in this state.
30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt to use his or her official position to influence or in any way alter the contents of a commission staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to a public hearing on that matter to which the staff report, analysis, or recommendation applies.
(b)This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any public office in this state.
(d)This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)No commission member, nor any interested person, shall conduct an ex parte communication unless the commission member fully discloses and makes public the ex parte communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission on the record of the proceeding at that hearing. communication.
(b)(1)The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A)The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B)(i)The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii)The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii)The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C)A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2)The executive director shall place in the public record any report of an ex parte communication.
(c)Communications shall cease to be ex parte communications when fully disclosed and placed in the commissions official record.
SEC. 2.Section 30327 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:30327.(a)No commission member or alternate shall make, participate in making, or in any other way attempt to use his or her official position to influence a commission decision about which the member or alternate has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported pursuant to Section 30324. communication.
(b)In addition to any other applicable penalty, including a civil fine imposed pursuant to Section 30824, a commission member who knowingly violates this section shall be subject to a civil fine, not to exceed seven thousand five hundred dollars ($7,500). Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, the court may award attorneys fees and costs to the prevailing party.
SEC. 3.Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:30327.2.(a)No commission member or alternate shall attempt to influence commission staff for purposes of changing or eliminating any information contained in a staff report or analysis or altering any recommendation pertaining to a matter within the commissions jurisdiction prior to the time the staff report, analysis, or recommendation is made public at a hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding.
(b)A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is punishable by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000) or by imprisonment in the state prison, and is forever disqualified from holding any office in this state.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Section 22441 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:22441.(a)A person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter. That assistance or advice includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(1)Completing a form provided by a federal or state agency but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms.
(2)Translating a persons answers to questions posed in those forms.
(3)Securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms.
(4)Submitting completed forms on a persons behalf and at their request to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.
(5)Making referrals to persons who could undertake legal representation activities for a person in an immigration matter.
(b)Immigration matter means any proceeding, filing, or action affecting the immigration or citizenship status of any person that arises under immigration and naturalization law, executive order or presidential proclamation, or action of the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services, the United States Department of State, or the United States Department of Labor.
(c)Compensation means money, property, or anything else of value.
(d)Every person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant shall only offer nonlegal assistance or advice in an immigration matter as defined in subdivision (a). Any act in violation of subdivision (a) is a violation of this chapter.
(e)A person does not engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance completing a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification.
SEC. 2.Section 8223 of the Government Code is amended to read:8223.(a)A notary public who holds himself or herself out as being an immigration specialist, immigration consultant, or any other title or description reflecting an expertise in immigration matters shall not advertise in any manner whatsoever that he or she is a notary public.
(b)A notary public qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant under Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code may enter data, provided by the client, on immigration forms provided by a federal or state agency. The fee for this service shall not exceed ten dollars ($10) per individual for each set of forms. If notary services are performed in relation to the set of immigration forms, additional fees may be collected pursuant to Section 8211. This fee limitation shall not apply to an attorney, who is also a notary public, who is rendering professional services regarding immigration matters.
(c)This section shall not be construed to exempt a notary public who enters data on an immigration form at the direction of a client, or otherwise performs the services of an immigration consultant, as defined by Section 22441 of the Business and Professions Code, from the requirements of Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code. A notary public who is not qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant under Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code may not enter data provided by a client on immigration forms nor otherwise perform the services of an immigration consultant.
(d)A form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification shall not be considered an immigration form.
(a)A person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter. That assistance or advice includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(1)Completing a form provided by a federal or state agency but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms.
(2)Translating a persons answers to questions posed in those forms.
(3)Securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms.
(4)Submitting completed forms on a persons behalf and at their request to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.
(5)Making referrals to persons who could undertake legal representation activities for a person in an immigration matter.
(b)Immigration matter means any proceeding, filing, or action affecting the immigration or citizenship status of any person which that arises under immigration and naturalization law, executive order or presidential proclamation, or action of the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services, the United States Department of State, or the United States Department of Labor.
(c)Compensation means money, property, or anything else of value.
(d)Every person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant shall only offer nonlegal assistance or advice in an immigration matter as defined in subdivision (a). Any act in violation of subdivision (a) is a violation of this chapter.
(e)A person does not engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance completing a form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification.
SEC. 2.Section 8223 of the Government Code is amended to read:8223.(a)No A notary public who holds himself or herself out as being an immigration specialist, immigration consultant consultant, or any other title or description reflecting an expertise in immigration matters shall not advertise in any manner whatsoever that he or she is a notary public.
(b)A notary public qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant under Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code may enter data, provided by the client, on immigration forms provided by a federal or state agency. The fee for this service shall not exceed ten dollars ($10) per individual for each set of forms. If notary services are performed in relation to the set of immigration forms, additional fees may be collected pursuant to Section 8211. This fee limitation shall not apply to an attorney, who is also a notary public, who is rendering professional services regarding immigration matters.
(c)Nothing in this This section shall not be construed to exempt a notary public who enters data on an immigration form at the direction of a client, or otherwise performs the services of an immigration consultant, as defined by Section 22441 of the Business and Professions Code, from the requirements of Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code. A notary public who is not qualified and bonded as an immigration consultant under Chapter 19.5 (commencing with Section 22440) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code may not enter data provided by a client on immigration forms nor otherwise perform the services of an immigration consultant.
(d)A form provided by a federal or state agency for the purpose of employment eligibility and verification shall not be considered an immigration form.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2016 | From Assembly without further action. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 15. Noes 48. Page 6585.) |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 29, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 29, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 7.) (August 29). |
| Aug 25, 2016 | August 25 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Aug 24, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Read third time and amended. (Ayes 73. Noes 0. Page 5974.) |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (August 11). |
| Aug 3, 2016 | August 3 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 28, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 3.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 8, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 27, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on NAT. RES. and E. & R. |
| May 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 23. Noes 12. Page 3924.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 23, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 23. Noes 12.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 10, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 9, 2016 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 3, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2016 | Set for hearing May 9. |
| Apr 28, 2016 | May 2 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 22, 2016 | Set for hearing May 2. |
| Apr 12, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 3. Page 3495.) (April 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 3.) (April 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 5, 2016 | Set for hearing April 12. |
| Mar 31, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Mar 29, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 29, 2016 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | April 4 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 11, 2016 | Set for hearing April 4. |
| Mar 3, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E.D. and JUD. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2016 | SB 1190 Jackson Senate Third Reading By O'DONNELL | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| Aug 29, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2016 | SB 1190 Jackson Senate Third Reading By A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. Amendment Set #1 | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2016 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1190 Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson)
As Amended Ver:August 29, 2016
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 23-12
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Natural Resources | 6-3 | Williams, Cristina Garcia, Gomez, McCarty, Mark Stone, Wood | Jones, Hadley, Harper |
Appropriations | 11-7 | Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Quirk, Santiago, Wood, Chau | Bigelow, Calderon, Chang, Gallagher, Jones, Obernolte, Wagner |
SUMMARY: Prohibits, with some exceptions, commissioners at the Coastal Commission (Commission) from conducting ex parte communications on matters within the Commission's jurisdiction. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2017, the Commission provide for public access to all commission meetings via telephone and the Internet.
- Requires Commission staff to include in the executive summary section of a staff report a list of references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not relate to a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials in an addendum.
- Excludes from the definition of ex parte communication any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the Commission.
- Authorizes commissioner and Commission staff to conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the Commission and with the permission of the property owner.
- Requires disclosure of ex parte communications that are a violation of the law and prohibits a commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has had an ex parte communication.
- Requires the Commission to adopt a board policy that prohibits a commissioner or alternative from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff.
- Disqualifies a commissioner from holding a position at the Commission if they willfully violate the policy established by the Commission.
EXISTING LAW, pursuant to the Coastal Act:
- Permits any person to testify at a Commission hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or submit written comments for the record on a matter before the Commission.
- Requires any person who applies to the Commission for approval of a development permit to provide the Commission with the names and addresses of all persons who, for compensation, will be communicating with the Commission or its staff on the applicant's behalf or on behalf of the applicant's business partners. Requires that disclosure to be provided to the Commission prior to any such communication.
- Defines an "ex parte communication," for the purposes of communications related to actions of the Commission, as any oral or written communication between a commissioner and an interested person about a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or that is not on the record at such a proceeding.
- Prohibits an ex parte communication unless the commissioner fully discloses the communication.
- Requires commissioners to disclose and make public any ex parte communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days of the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next Commission hearing, to the Commission on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
- Requires the Commission to adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications, which shall include:
- The date, time, and location;
- Identity of the person who made the communication and the people who were present during the communication;
- A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including all material that was part of the communication.
- Defines an "interested person" as a) any applicant, applicant's agent or representative, or participant in a Commission proceeding, b) any person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission his or her agent or employee, or c) a representative acting on behalf of any civic, environmental, neighborhood, business, labor, trade, or similar organization who intends to influence the decision of a commissioner.
- Prohibits a commissioner who has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported as required from voting on the matter or influencing the Commission in any way. Provides that knowing violations of the disclosure or recusal requirements can result in fines of up to $7,500 and a court order for the Commission to revoke its action and rehear the matter.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Ex parte communications refer to any communication made in private (i.e., off the record and without notice and opportunity for all parties to participate) between an interested party in a decision-making process and any state official in a decision-making position. Ex parte communication disclosure requirements for state policy makers are intended to provide the public with information regarding a decision and to prevent bias in decision makers. Prior to 1992, there was no mention of ex parte communications in the Coastal Act. There were claims of frequent unreported ex parte communications at the Commission. Then Assemblymember Terry Friedman authored AB 3459, Chapter 1114, Statutes of 1992 and AB 909, Chapter 798, Statutes of 1993 to prohibit ex parte communications. These laws were interpreted as prohibiting ex parte communication unless they are fully disclosed.
In 2014, AB 474 (Stone), Chapter 125, Statutes of 2014, improved ex parte communications reporting requirements. The additions to the reporting requirements included the identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made; the identity of all persons present during the communication; and a complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication. However, concerns remain about ex parte communications at the Commission. Many of the ex parte communications submitted to this Committee are not comprehensive, and news accounts state some commissioners have not filed ex parte disclosure forms for their ex parte communications. There have been accounts of commissioners filing brief disclosure forms and then sending staff detailed e-mails about their ex parte communications creating a discrepancy in the public record. Commissioners also commonly disclose on the microphone at Commission meetings. The oral disclosures are usually an extremely short account of the communication. Finally, it is difficult for the public to have access to the ex parte communication disclosure forms.
The Commission voted 6-5 this year to support banning ex parte communications, and in their support letter they state, "Commissioners have expressed concerns that the practice lacks transparency, undermines due process, and erodes public trust in the commission. Some have stated that they would prefer not to conduct ex partes, but feel pressured to do so because the practice is so widespread. The general conclusion is that the current process leads to an 'uneven' level of information available to the public."
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Jarred / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0004980
Date of Hearing: August 29, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson) – As Amended Ver:August 19, 2016
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 6 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a Coastal Commissioner or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte and other communication, as specified, and requires the Commission to adopt a policy to prohibit Commissioners from unduly influencing Commission staff. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a commissioner or an interested party from intentionally conducting either an ex parte communication or an oral or written communication, regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding.
- Exempts from ex parte prohibitions, any communication conducted by a Commissioner while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official, if the communication occurred before the matter appeared before the Commission.
- Exempts from ex parte prohibitions, site visits, as specified.
- Requires a Commissioner to fully disclose and make public ex parte and other prohibited communications by providing a full report to the Executive Director within seven days after the communication, or to the Commission in writing to be included in the record of the proceeding if the communication occurred less than seven days prior to the hearing.
- Prohibits a Commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has conducted an ex parte or other prohibited communication.
- Requires the Commission to adopt a policy, in a duly noticed hearing, to prohibit a Commissioner or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff. Disqualifies a commissioner from holding any position at the Commission if they willfully attempt to place undue influence on staff.
Additionally, this bill:
- Requires the Commission to provide public access to all meetings vial telephone and video conferencing on or before July 1, 2017.
- Requires Commission staff to include references to any materials submitted for the public record determined not to relate to a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction in the staff report executive summary.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Increased ongoing annual staffing costs associated with providing video teleconferencing, likely in the range of $200,000 to $300,000 for each location that is made available for the public to attend and conference-in to the Commission meeting.
- Increased one-time equipment costs, likely in the $50,000 range for each video conference site.
- Potential unknown cost pressures to hire staff advisors to assist the six public Commissioners with gathering and analyzing information to inform decisions.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill will help restore the public’s trust in the Commission, ensure decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision making or the perception that it is happening. The author further states that this bill will level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources.
- Prior Hearing. This Committee heard and passed amendments on August 11, 2016. Following that action, the bill was amended on the floor, and returned to this Committee pursuant to Rule 77.2.
- Further Amendments. The author, in consultation with the Committee and others, is proposing the following revisions and clarifications:
- A revision to specify all Commission meetings provide for public participation, including public testimony, through telephone and the internet.
- A clarification regarding the use of information determined not to relate to matters within the Commission's jurisdiction.
- A clarification regarding communications that occurred prior to the time matters were pending before the Commission.
- A technical clarification regarding the requirement for the Commission to adopt a Board policy regarding the use of undue influence on staff.
A mock-up of the proposed amendments is attached.
Amendments Mock-up for 2015-2016 SB-1190 (Jackson (S))
Amended Assembly 8/19/16
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 30315 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30315. (a) The commission shall meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public. Each meeting shall occur not more than 45 days after the previous meeting. All meetings of the commission shall be open to the public.
(b) A majority of the total appointed membership of the commission shall constitute a quorum. An action taken by the commission under this division requires a majority vote of the members present at the meeting of the commission, with a quorum being present, unless otherwise specifically provided for in this division.
(c) Commencing on or before July 1, 2017, the commission also shall provide for public access to participation at all commission meetings via telephone and the internet.video conferencing. Participation shall include real time testimony during public comment.
SEC. 2. Section 30321 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30321. (a) For purposes of this article, “a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction” means any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
(b) Commission staff shall include in the executive summary section of a staff report a list of references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials in an addendum. The addendum shall include instructions regarding the use of the information contained in these communications as a basis or influencing factor upon their decision.
SEC. 3. Section 30322 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30322. (a) For purposes of this article, except as provided in subdivision (b), an “ex parte communication” is any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, about a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b) The following communications are not ex parte communications:
(1) Any communication between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person.
(2) Any communication limited entirely to procedural issues, including, but not limited to, the hearing schedule, location, format, or filing date.
(3) Any communication which takes place on the record during an official proceeding of a state, regional, or local agency that involves a member of the commission who also serves as an official of that agency.
(4) Any communication between a member of the commission, with regard to any action of another state agency or of a regional or local agency of which the member is an official, and any other official or employee of that agency, including any person who is acting as an attorney for the agency.
(5) Any communication between a nonvoting commission member and a staff member of a state agency where both the commission member and the staff member are acting in an official capacity.
(6) Any communication to a nonvoting commission member relating to an action pending before the commission, where the nonvoting commission member does not participate in that action, either through written or verbal communication, on or off the record, with other members of the commission.
(7) Any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the commission. This paragraph shall not be construed to mean that any other commissioner has conducted an ex parte communication on a matter if the communication occurred before the matter was pending before the commission.
(8) Any project site visit conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30324.
SEC. 4. Section 30324 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30324. (a) No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct either of the following:
(1) An ex parte communication. communication on a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, as defined by Section 30321.
(2) An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b) Notwithstanding subdivision (a), commission members and commission staff may conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the commission and with the permission of the property owner. A description of the site visit shall be a part of the public record of the matter to which the project site pertains and any communications conducted during the site visit shall be limited to those between commission members and staff.
(c) (1) If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2) Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(d) (1) The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A) The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B) (i) The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii) The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii) The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C) A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2) The executive director shall place in the public record any report made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 5 Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:
30327.2. (a) The commission shall adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a board policy that prohibits a commission member or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff, including, but not limited to, the contents of staff reports.
(b) This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c) A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d) This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: August 25, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson) – As Amended Ver:August 19, 2016
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 6 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a Coastal Commissioner or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte and other communication, as specified, and requires the Commission to adopt a policy to prohibit Commissioners from unduly influencing Commission staff. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a commissioner or an interested party from intentionally conducting either an ex parte communication or an oral or written communication, regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding.
- Exempts from ex parte prohibitions, any communication conducted by a Commissioner while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official, if the communication occurred before the matter appeared before the Commission.
- Exempts from ex parte prohibitions, site visits, as specified.
- Requires a Commissioner to fully disclose and make public ex parte and other prohibited communications by providing a full report to the Executive Director within seven days after the communication, or to the Commission in writing to be included in the record of the proceeding if the communication occurred less than seven days prior to the hearing.
- Prohibits a Commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has conducted an ex parte or other prohibited communication.
- Requires the Commission to adopt a policy, in a duly noticed hearing, to prohibit a Commissioner or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff. Disqualifies a commissioner from holding any position at the Commission if they willfully attempt to place undue influence on staff.
Additionally, this bill:
- Requires the Commission to provide public access to all meetings vial telephone and video conferencing on or before July 1, 2017.
- Requires Commission staff to include references to any materials submitted for the public record determined not to relate to a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction in the staff report executive summary.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Increased ongoing annual staffing costs associated with providing video teleconferencing, likely in the range of $200,000 to $300,000 for each location that is made available for the public to attend and conference-in to the Commission meeting.
- Increased one-time equipment costs, likely in the $50,000 range for each video conference site.
- Potential unknown cost pressures to hire staff advisors to assist the six public Commissioners with gathering and analyzing information to inform decisions.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill will help restore the public’s trust in the Commission, ensure decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision making or the perception that it is happening. The author further states that this bill will level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources.
- Prior Hearing. This Committee heard and passed amendments on August 11, 2016. Following that action, the bill was amended on the floor, and returned to this Committee pursuant to Rule 77.2.
- Further Amendments. The author, in consultation with the Committee and others, is proposing the following revisions and clarifications:
- A revision to specify all Commission meetings provide for public participation, including public testimony, through telephone and the internet.
- A clarification regarding the use of information determined not to relate to matters within the Commission's jurisdiction.
- A clarification regarding communications that occurred prior to the time matters were pending before the Commission.
- A technical clarification regarding the requirement for the Commission to adopt a Board policy regarding the use of undue influence on staff.
A mock-up of the proposed amendments is attached.
Amendments Mock-up for 2015-2016 SB-1190 (Jackson (S))
Amended Assembly 8/19/16
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 30315 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30315. (a) The commission shall meet at least 11 times annually at a place convenient to the public. Each meeting shall occur not more than 45 days after the previous meeting. All meetings of the commission shall be open to the public.
(b) A majority of the total appointed membership of the commission shall constitute a quorum. An action taken by the commission under this division requires a majority vote of the members present at the meeting of the commission, with a quorum being present, unless otherwise specifically provided for in this division.
(c) Commencing on or before July 1, 2017, the commission also shall provide for public access to participation at all commission meetings via telephone and the internet.video conferencing. Participation shall include real time testimony during public comment.
SEC. 2. Section 30321 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30321. (a) For purposes of this article, “a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction” means any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
(b) Commission staff shall include in the executive summary section of a staff report a list of references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not to relate to a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials in an addendum. The addendum shall include instructions regarding the use of the information contained in these communications as a basis or influencing factor upon their decision.
SEC. 3. Section 30322 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30322. (a) For purposes of this article, except as provided in subdivision (b), an “ex parte communication” is any oral or written communication between a member of the commission and an interested person, about a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b) The following communications are not ex parte communications:
(1) Any communication between a staff member acting in his or her official capacity and any commission member or interested person.
(2) Any communication limited entirely to procedural issues, including, but not limited to, the hearing schedule, location, format, or filing date.
(3) Any communication which takes place on the record during an official proceeding of a state, regional, or local agency that involves a member of the commission who also serves as an official of that agency.
(4) Any communication between a member of the commission, with regard to any action of another state agency or of a regional or local agency of which the member is an official, and any other official or employee of that agency, including any person who is acting as an attorney for the agency.
(5) Any communication between a nonvoting commission member and a staff member of a state agency where both the commission member and the staff member are acting in an official capacity.
(6) Any communication to a nonvoting commission member relating to an action pending before the commission, where the nonvoting commission member does not participate in that action, either through written or verbal communication, on or off the record, with other members of the commission.
(7) Any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the commission. This paragraph shall not be construed to mean that any other commissioner has conducted an ex parte communication on a matter if the communication occurred before the matter was pending before the commission.
(8) Any project site visit conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30324.
SEC. 4. Section 30324 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:
30324. (a) No commission member, nor any interested person, shall intentionally conduct either of the following:
(1) An ex parte communication. communication on a matter within the commission’s jurisdiction, as defined by Section 30321.
(2) An oral or written communication regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
(b) Notwithstanding subdivision (a), commission members and commission staff may conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the commission and with the permission of the property owner. A description of the site visit shall be a part of the public record of the matter to which the project site pertains and any communications conducted during the site visit shall be limited to those between commission members and staff.
(c) (1) If a commission member, or any interested person, conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), the commission member shall fully disclose and make public the communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days after the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next commission hearing, to the commission in writing to be included on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
(2) Notwithstanding Section 30327, if a commission member conducts a communication that is in violation of subdivision (a), he or she shall not vote on or otherwise participate in any commission proceeding to which the communication applies.
(d) (1) The commission shall adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting communications that are in violation of subdivision (a), which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
(A) The date, time, and location of the communication.
(B) (i) The identity of the person or persons initiating and the person or persons receiving the communication.
(ii) The identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made.
(iii) The identity of all persons present during the communication.
(C) A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication.
(2) The executive director shall place in the public record any report made pursuant to this section.
SEC. 5 Section 30327.2 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:
30327.2. (a) The commission shall adopt, at a duly noticed public hearing, a board policy that prohibits a commission member or alternate from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence, as defined by Section 1575 of the Civil Code, on commission staff, including, but not limited to, the contents of staff reports.
(b) This section shall not be construed to prohibit a commissioner or alternate from communicating with, or providing information to, commission staff members about matters before the commission.
(c) A commission member or alternate who willfully violates subdivision (a) is forever disqualified from holding any position at the commission.
(d) This section is intended to protect the public interest by ensuring that commission members and alternates do not unduly influence the contents of a staff report, analysis, or recommendation.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson)
As Amended Ver:August 17, 2016
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 23-12
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Natural Resources | 6-3 | Williams, Cristina Garcia, Gomez, McCarty, Mark Stone, Wood | Jones, Hadley, Harper |
Appropriations | 11-4 | Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Santiago, Weber, Wood, McCarty | Bigelow, Chang, Jones, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Prohibits, with some exceptions, commissioners at the Coastal Commission (Commission) from conducting ex parte communications on matters within the Commission's jurisdiction. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2017, the Commission to provide public access to all commission meetings via telephone and video conferencing.
- Requires Commission staff to include in the executive summary section of a staff report references to any materials submitted for the public record that are determined not relate to a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction, including information about how to locate copies of those materials.
- Excludes from the definition of ex parte communication any communication conducted by a commission member while acting in his or her capacity as a local government official and prior to the time the matter to which the communication applies was pending before the Commission.
- Authorizes commissioner and Commission staff to conduct a project site visit if the proposed site visit is approved by a majority vote of the Commission and with the permission of the property owner.
- Requires disclosure of ex parte communications that are a violation of the law and prohibits a commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has had an ex parte communication.
- Requires the Commission to adopt a policy that prohibits a commissioner or alternative from using or attempting to use his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff.
- Disqualifies a commissioner from holding a position at the Commission if they willfully violate the policy established by the Commission.
EXISTING LAW, pursuant to the Coastal Act:
- Permits any person to testify at a Commission hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or submit written comments for the record on a matter before the Commission.
- Requires any person who applies to the Commission for approval of a development permit to provide the Commission with the names and addresses of all persons who, for compensation, will be communicating with the Commission or its staff on the applicant’s behalf or on behalf of the applicant's business partners. Requires that disclosure to be provided to the Commission prior to any such communication.
- Defines an "ex parte communication," for the purposes of communications related to actions of the Commission, as any oral or written communication between a commissioner and an interested person about a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or that is not on the record at such a proceeding.
- Prohibits an ex parte communication unless the commissioner fully discloses the communication.
- Requires commissioners to disclose and make public any ex parte communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days of the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next Commission hearing, to the Commission on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
- Requires the Commission to adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications, which shall include:
- The date, time, and location;
- Identity of the person who made the communication and the people who were present during the communication;
- A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including all material that was part of the communication.
- Defines an "interested person" as a) any applicant, applicant's agent or representative, or participant in a Commission proceeding, b) any person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission his or her agent or employee, or c) a representative acting on behalf of any civic, environmental, neighborhood, business, labor, trade, or similar organization who intends to influence the decision of a commissioner.
- Prohibits a commissioner who has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported as required from voting on the matter or influencing the Commission in any way. Provides that knowing violations of the disclosure or recusal requirements can result in fines of up to $7,500 and a court order for the Commission to revoke its action and rehear the matter.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Ex parte communications refer to any communication made in private (i.e., off the record and without notice and opportunity for all parties to participate) between an interested party in a decision-making process and any state official in a decision-making position. Ex parte communication disclosure requirements for state policy makers are intended to provide the public with information regarding a decision and to prevent bias in decision makers. Prior to 1992, there was no mention of ex parte communications in the Coastal Act. There were claims of frequent unreported ex parte communications at the Commission. Then Assemblymember Terry Friedman authored AB 3459, Chapter 1114, Statutes of 1992 and AB 909, Chapter 798, Statutes of 1993 to prohibit ex parte communications. These laws were interpreted as prohibiting ex parte communication unless they are fully disclosed.
In 2014, AB 474 (Stone), Chapter 125, Statutes of 2014, improved ex parte communications reporting requirements. The additions to the reporting requirements included the identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made; the identity of all persons present during the communication; and a complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication. However, concerns remain about ex parte communications at the Commission. Many of the ex parte communications submitted to this Committee are not comprehensive, and news accounts state some commissioners have not filed ex parte disclosure forms for their ex parte communications. There have been accounts of commissioners filing brief disclosure forms and then sending staff detailed e-mails about their ex parte communications creating a discrepancy in the public record. Commissioners also commonly disclose on the microphone at Commission meetings. The oral disclosures are usually an extremely short account of the communication. Finally, it is difficult for the public to have access to the ex parte communication disclosure forms.
The Commission voted 6-5 this year to support banning ex parte communications, and in their support letter they state, "Commissioners have expressed concerns that the practice lacks transparency, undermines due process, and erodes public trust in the commission. Some have stated that they would prefer not to conduct ex partes, but feel pressured to do so because the practice is so widespread. The general conclusion is that the current process leads to an ‘uneven’ level of information available to the public."
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Jarred / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0004389
Date of Hearing: August 3, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson) – As Amended Ver:June 8, 2016
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 6 - 3 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a Coastal Commissioner or an interested person from intentionally conducting any ex parte and other communication, as specified, and prohibits Commissioners from unduly influencing Commission staff reports. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a commissioner or an interested party from intentionally conducting either an ex parte communication or an oral or written communication, regarding a pending enforcement investigation that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding.
- Requires a Commissioner to fully disclose and make public ex parte and other prohibited communications by providing a full report to the Executive Director within seven days after the communication, or to the Commission in writing to be included in the record of the proceeding if the communication occurred less than seven days prior to the hearing.
- Prohibits a Commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has conducted an ex parte or other prohibited communication.
- Prohibits a commissioner from using his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff to alter their staff report. Disqualifies a commissioner from holding any position at the Commission if they willfully attempt to place undue influence on staff.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The fiscal impact of this bill is unknown. According to the Coastal Commission, this bill does not increase costs, and may provide savings. However, there may be potential unknown cost pressures, possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, to hire staff advisors to assist the six public Commissioners by attending site visits and gathering information from interested parties.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill will help restore the public’s trust in the Commission, ensure decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision making or the perception that it is happening. The author further states that this bill will level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources.
- The Coastal Commission. The California Coastal Commission has 12 voting members and three non-voting members. Six of the voting members are "public members," and six are local elected officials who come from specific coastal districts. All voting members are appointed either by the Governor, Senate Rules Committee, or the Speaker of the Assembly; each appoints four commissioners, two public members and two elected officials. Each Commissioner may appoint an alternate to serve in his or her absence. The Secretaries of the Resources Agency, the Business and Transportation Agency, and the Chair of the State Lands Commission serve as non-voting members and may appoint a designee to serve in their place.
The Commission voted 6-5 this year to support banning ex parte communication.
- Existing Ex Parte Communication Laws. The California Coastal Act of 1976 prohibits, with specified exceptions, ex parte communications between a member of the Commission and an interested person about a matter within the jurisdiction of the Commission. Such communications, by definition, do not occur in a public hearing or other official proceeding or on the record.
When proper disclosure of such communications is made, ex parte communications are lawful. Existing law also prohibits commissioners or alternates from trying to influence a commission decision in circumstances in which an ex parte communication has not been reported. A civil fine of up to $7,500 may be imposed, plus attorney's fees, and the Commission action may be revoked.
The Commission's jurisdiction for matters that are subject to the prohibition on ex parte communications and the disclosure requirements include any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.
Commissioners must disclose to the public an ex parte communication on the prescribed form within 7 days of the communication. If the communication occurs within 7 days of the next Commission meeting, the disclosure must be made on the record of the proceeding in that hearing.
According to the Natural Resources Agency, the California Attorney General has opined that Commissioners may not engage in ex parte communications in the context of enforcement proceedings because enforcement proceedings are not expressly called out in the law. This advice letter does not have the effect of law.
- Related Legislation. AB 2002 (Stone, 2016) provides that communicating with the Coastal Commission in order to influence specified actions can result in a person being considered a "lobbyist" under the Political Reform Act (PRA) and prohibits an ex parte communication with a member of the Commission regarding a matter during the 24 hours before that matter will be discussed at a Commission hearing. This bill is pending in Senate Appropriations.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Das Williams, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1190
Author:(Jackson) – As Amended Ver:June 8, 2016
SENATE VOTE: 23-12
SUBJECT: California Coastal Commission: ex parte communications: staff communications
SUMMARY: Prohibits commissioners at the Coastal Commission (Commission) from conducting ex parte communications on matters within the Commission’s jurisdiction or unduly influencing a Commission staff report.
EXISTING LAW, pursuant to the Coastal Act:
- Permits any person to testify at a Commission hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or submit written comments for the record on a matter before the Commission.
- Requires any person who applies to the Commission for approval of a development permit to provide the Commission with the names and addresses of all persons who, for compensation, will be communicating with the Commission or its staff on the applicant’s behalf or on behalf of the applicant’s business partners. Requires that disclosure to be provided to the Commission prior to any such communication.
- Defines an "ex parte communication," for the purposes of communications related to actions of the Commission, as any oral or written communication between a commissioner and an interested person about a matter within the Commission's jurisdiction which does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other official proceeding, or that is not on the record at such a proceeding.
- Prohibits an ex parte communication unless the commissioner fully discloses the communication.
- Requires commissioners to disclose and make public any ex parte communication by providing a full report of the communication to the executive director within seven days of the communication or, if the communication occurs within seven days of the next Commission hearing, to the Commission on the record of the proceeding at that hearing.
- Requires the Commission to adopt standard disclosure forms for reporting ex parte communications, which shall include:
- The date, time, and location;
- Identity of the person who made the communication and the people who were present during the communication;
- A complete, comprehensive description of the content of the communication, including all material that was part of the communication.
- Defines an "interested person" as (a) any applicant, applicant's agent or representative, or participant in a Commission proceeding, (b) any person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission his or her agent or employee, or (c) a representative acting on behalf of any civic, environmental, neighborhood, business, labor, trade, or similar organization who intends to influence the decision of a commissioner.
- Prohibits a commissioner who has knowingly had an ex parte communication that has not been reported as required from voting on the matter or influencing the Commission in any way. Provides that knowing violations of the disclosure or recusal requirements can result in fines of up to $7,500 and a court order for the Commission to revoke its action and rehear the matter.
THIS BILL:
- Prohibits a commissioner from conducting an ex parte communication with an interested person.
- Requires disclosure of ex parte communications that are a violation of the law and prohibits a commissioner from voting or participating in a Commission matter if he or she has had an ex parte communication.
- Prohibits a commissioner from using his or her official position to place undue influence on Commission staff to alter their staff report.
- Disqualifies a commissioner from holding a position at the Commission if they willfully attempt to place undue influence on staff.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
Established by initiative in 1972 and indefinitely extended in 1976, the California Coastal Commission plans and regulates land use and public access on the California coast. In matters before the Commission, ex parte communications are defined as any private oral or written communications between a decision-maker and an interested party that do not occur in a public meeting. Interested parties include, but are not limited to, project applicants, people with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission, and any representative of a civic, environmental, neighborhood, business, labor, trade, or similar organization who intends to influence the decision of a commissioner on a matter before the Commission.
The Supreme Court has found that ex parte communications can significantly bias decision-makers in adjudicative government actions by allowing one party to influence a decision maker outside the presence of other parties and off the record. The court found that this is a violation of procedural due process. As such, although current law allows ex parte communications with commissioners, it requires that such communications be cursorily disclosed on a form or, if they occurred seven days prior to a meeting, verbally in a public meeting.
Unlike other government agencies, commission staff works independently of decision-makers, interpreting the California Coastal Act free from political influence. In a public hearing, the commissioners may vote to accept the independent staff analysis, but they may also reject staff recommendations. The independence of commission staff is intended to ensure the law is interpreted impartially and fairly.
In February, the California Coastal Commission voted to fire their executive director behind closed doors despite being advised by their Counsel that doing so was not necessary. This controversial action has led to public accusations of undue political influence by commissioners on Commission staff and a lack of transparency in the decision-making process at the Commission.
- Coastal Commission. The Commission was established by voter initiative in 1972 (Proposition 20) and later made permanent by the Legislature through adoption of the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Coastal Act). In partnership with coastal cities and counties, the Commission plans and regulates the use of land and water in the coastal zone. Development activities, which are broadly defined by the Coastal Act to include construction of buildings, divisions of land, and activities that change the intensity of use of land or public access to coastal waters, generally require a Coastal Development Permit (CDP) from either the Commission or the local government with a certified Local Coastal Program (LCP).
The Commission is an independent, quasi-judicial state agency, and is composed of 12 voting members, appointed equally (4 each) by the Governor, the Senate Rules Committee, and the Speaker of the Assembly. Six of the voting commissioners are locally elected officials and six are appointed from the public at large. Three ex officio (non-voting) members represent the Natural Resources Agency, the Transportation Agency, and the State Lands Commission.
According to the Commission’s mission statement:
The Commission is committed to protecting and enhancing California’s coast and ocean for present and future generations. It does so through careful planning and regulation of environmentally-sustainable development, rigorous use of science, strong public participation, education, and effective intergovernmental coordination.
- Ex parte communications. Ex parte communications refer to any communication made in private (i.e., off the record and without notice and opportunity for all parties to participate) between an interested party in a decision-making process and any state official in a decision-making position. Ex parte communication disclosure requirements for state policy makers are intended to provide the public with information regarding a decision and to prevent bias in decision makers. Prior to 1992, there was no mention of ex parte communications in the Coastal Act. There were claims of frequent unreported ex parte communications at the Commission. Then Assemblymember Terry Friedman authored AB 3459, Chapter 1114, Statutes of 1992 and AB 909, Chapter 798, Statutes of 1993 to prohibit ex parte communications. These laws were interpreted as prohibiting ex parte communication unless they are fully disclosed.
In 2014, AB 474 (Stone), Chapter 125, Statutes of 2014, improved ex parte communications reporting requirements. The additions to the reporting requirements included the identity of the person on whose behalf the communication was made; the identity of all persons present during the communication; and a complete, comprehensive description of the content of the ex parte communication, including a complete set of all text and graphic material that was part of the communication. However, concerns remain about ex parte communications at the Commission. Many of the ex parte communications submitted to this Committee are not comprehensive, and news accounts state some commissioners have not filed ex parte disclosure forms for their ex parte communications. There have been accounts of commissioners filing brief disclosure forms and then sending staff detailed e-mails about their ex parte communications creating a discrepancy in the public record. Commissioners also commonly disclose on the microphone at Commission meetings. The oral disclosures are usually an extremely short account of the communication. Finally, it is difficult for the public to have access to the ex parte communication disclosure forms.
The Commission voted 6-5 this year to support banning ex parte communications, and in their support letter they state, “Commissioners have expressed concerns that the practice lacks transparency, undermines due process, and erodes public trust in the commission. Some have stated that they would prefer not to conduct ex partes, but feel pressured to do so because the practice is so widespread. The general conclusion is that the current process leads to an ‘uneven’ level of information available to the public.”
On April 18, this Committee passed AB 2002 (Stone) which also contained provisions on ex parte communications. AB 2002 prohibits commissioners or an interested person in a Commission action from conducting an ex parte communication within 24 hours before a hearing regarding a matter that the Commission will discuss at that hearing. AB 2002 also requires written disclosure of all ex parte disclosure forms. The Commission also supports AB 2002.
Opponents of this legislation believe the Commission should be accessible to the public and that public comment periods at the Commission are limited. The Commission’s support letter asserts, “Nothing in this bill would limit in any way the ability of interested parties to share or convey information with the Commission as an agency. There are no limits on submitting information, provided that it is provided equally to all commissioners, staff and the public.”
- Staff reports. Commission staff reports serve as independent analysis for a CDP or LCP review. Staff reports include a scientific analysis of all impacts and identification of any inconsistency with the Coastal Act. Staff reports can be a hundred pages and include staff’s recommendations on how the Commission should act. Commissioners may follow, modify, or reject staff’s recommendation in the Commission meeting based on their review of the material and testimony provided. This bill seeks to prohibit commissioners from unduly influencing staff’s recommendations prior to a public hearing on the matter.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Audubon California
California Coastal Commission
California Coastal Protection Network
California League of Conservation Voters
Courage Campaign
Endangered Habitats League
Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks
Malibu Coalition for Slow Growth
Organization of Regional Coastal Activists
Planning and Conservation League
Resources Legacy Fund
Sierra Club California
SoCal 350 Climate Action
The Wildlands Conservancy
Western Alliance for Nature
24 Individuals
Opposition
CalChamber
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of United Latin American Citizens
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Commercial Real Estate Development Association - NAIOP
Department of the Navy
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local Union No. 6
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local No. 47
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local Union No. 180
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local Union No. 340
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local Union No. 441
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local Union 477
National Federation of Independent Business
Sheet Metal, Air, Rail, Transportation Workers Local Union 105
Sheet Metal Workers’ Local Union No. 104
The Environmental Center of San Diego
UA Local Union 345
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Plant Health Association
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Jarred / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1190
:
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 6-3, 4/12/16
AYES: Pavley, Allen, Hertzberg, Jackson, Monning, Wolk
NOES: Stone, Hueso, Vidak
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
DIGEST: This bill prohibits coastal commissioners and interested persons from conducting ex parte communications on adjudicative or enforcement proceedings before the California Coastal Commission (Commission), requires disclosure of ex parte communications (including those that violated the prohibition), bans a commissioner from voting or participating on that item, and provides for communications between commissioners and Commission staff but prohibits attempts by commissioners to influence staff.
Existing law:
- Prohibits, with specified exceptions, “ex parte” communications between a member of the Coastal Commission and an interested person about a matter within the jurisdiction of the Commission pursuant to the California Coastal Act of 1976. Such communications, by definition, do not occur in a public hearing or other official proceeding or on the record.
- Authorizes, provided proper disclosure of such communications is made, ex parte communications.
- Prohibits commissioners or alternates from trying to influence a Commission decision in circumstances in which an ex parte communication has not been reported. A civil fine of up to $7500 may be imposed, plus attorney’s fees, and the Commission action may be revoked pursuant to various provisions in the Public Resources Code.
- Establishes that the Commission’s procedures for prohibiting ex parte communications unless they are disclosed extends to “any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring Commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the Commission.
- Defines an “interested person” to be “any applicant, an agent or an employee of the applicant, or a person receiving any consideration for representing the applicant, or a participant in a proceeding in any matter before the Commission.” An “interested person” also includes “a person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission and their agents as well as organizational representatives who intend to influence Commission decisions.”
- Requires commissioners to disclose to the public an ex parte communication on a prescribed form within 7 days of the communication. If the communication occurs within 7 days of the next Commission meeting, the disclosure must be made on the record of the proceeding in that hearing.
- Exempts enforcement proceedings from the prohibition on ex parte communications which are not specifically included in the statutory ban, pursuant to an opinion of the California Attorney General, which does not have the effect of law.
This bill:
- Bans ex parte communications concerning adjudicative or enforcement proceedings before the Commission.
- Requires disclosure even of banned communications within seven days of the ex parte communication or, on the record if the communication occurred within 7 days of the next Commission meeting and specifies the elements of the disclosure.
- Bans a commissioner from voting on a matter that was the subject of an ex parte communication.
- Authorizes commissioners to communicate to Commission staff provided no attempt is made to influence a Commission staff report or recommendation and bans commissioners who violate this provision from other public office in California.
Comments
Amendments in the Senate Appropriations Committee narrowed the prohibition on ex parte communications to adjudicative and enforcement matters, and exempts legislative and policy determinations made by the commission. This was an option discussed in policy committee but it did not remove the opposition from the coalition that opposes the bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Audubon California
California Coastal Commission
California Coastal Protection Network
Courage Campaign
Endangered Habitats League
Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks
Malibu Coalition for Slow Growth
Organization of Regional Coastal Activists
Sierra Club California
SoCal 350 Climate Action
The Wildlands Conservancy
Western Alliance for Nature
5 individuals
17 former California Coastal Commissioners
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/16)
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Material Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Plant Health Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, the recent firing of the executive director of the Coastal Commission has resulted in a high degree of public uncertainty, accusations of a lack of transparency in the decision-making process, and generated concerns of undue political influence by commissioners on commission staff. The author stated that the bill will help restore the public’s trust in the commission, ensure that decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision-making or the perception that it is happening. She added that SB 1190 would level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources. By protecting the independence of commission staff, she believes that the bill adds to coastal protection from threats related to climate change, pollution, and unchecked development.
The California Coastal Commission (Commission) letter indicated that recent news coverage has revealed inconsistencies in conducting and reporting these private [ex parte] communications, some of which may raise legal questions that could affect Commission actions. At this point, the Commission concluded that there is no feasible means of oversight or realistic enforcement mechanisms to ensure consistent compliance with the law. The Commission prefers that information from applicants and others be submitted uniformly through the Commission to all commissioners which would ensure that there are no limits on sharing or conveying information and that all such information is also available to the public.
All of the supporters stress the importance not only of the ban on ex parte communications but also the importance of clarifying the independence of staff. Most are sharply critical of the existing practice of “reporting” ex parte communications which they characterize as inadequate and cursory. Many suggest that ex parte communications are handled unevenly by commissioners such that certain viewpoints are often not able to have an audience with certain commissioners. Others note that the ability to travel to ex parte meetings is not something that individuals or small non-profits are able to do. Instead, that is a perk for those who can afford to do so and it is often done by those with very expensive and potentially lucrative development applications pending before the commission.
The Sierra Club noted that many of its members have successfully worked with commissioners using ex parte communications, but this group nevertheless supports the proposed ban because “the recent firing of Dr. Charles Lester [as the executive director of the commission] has shown the ability of other groups to use ex parte communications far more effectively with terrible results for the coast.”
Almost all of the supporters would agree with another Sierra Club statement that “ex parte communication restrictions are common for other judicial and quasi-judicial bodies, from courts to most state agencies. This protects the public who does not have the same access and is not able to wine and dine with commissioners before meetings, with little disclosure. Developers and other interests that would prefer a privatized coast have more resources available that makes leveling the field necessary.”
Almost all of the supporters also stressed the importance of the independence of staff. As said by the Western Alliance for Nature (Sara Wan, a long time former coastal commissioner is the Executive Director), “the commission staff must be free to work independently of the decision-makers and provide their professional and scientific analysis free from political influence and pressure. Commissioners should enter the hearing process with an independent staff report and written correspondence from all interested parties. Then they should listen to the public hearing with an open mind taking into consideration the input from all. It is important to also recognize that there are 12 voting commissioners, each with their own personal biases. They are free to express and act accordingly in casting their votes, but they should not be allowed to taint the staff report with those biases. If allowed, it would mean that those in the majority would be, in essence, slanting the staff recommendation in advance of the hearing. This is contrary to a fair and open process.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The opposition coalition headed by the California Chamber sent in a revised letter subsequent to the recent amendments. The coalition objects to a ban on ex parte communications even when limited to adjudicative or enforcement proceedings. It also objects to the proposed limitations on communications between commissioners and staff.
According to the coalition headed by the California Chamber, citizen participation and communication should be encouraged, and that principle should extend not only to commissioners, but to staff.
5/16/16 10:42:26
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1190
:
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 6-3, 4/12/16
AYES: Pavley, Allen, Hertzberg, Jackson, Monning, Wolk
NOES: Stone, Hueso, Vidak
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
DIGEST: This bill prohibits coastal commissioners and interested persons from conducting ex parte communications on adjudicative or enforcement proceedings before the California Coastal Commission (Commission), requires disclosure of ex parte communications (including those that violated the prohibition), bans a commissioner from voting or participating on that item, and provides for communications between commissioners and Commission staff but prohibits attempts by commissioners to influence staff.
Existing law:
- Prohibits, with specified exceptions, “ex parte” communications between a member of the Coastal Commission and an interested person about a matter within the jurisdiction of the Commission pursuant to the California Coastal Act of 1976. Such communications, by definition, do not occur in a public hearing or other official proceeding or on the record.
- Authorizes, provided proper disclosure of such communications is made, ex parte communications.
- Prohibits commissioners or alternates from trying to influence a Commission decision in circumstances in which an ex parte communication has not been reported. A civil fine of up to $7500 may be imposed, plus attorney’s fees, and the Commission action may be revoked pursuant to various provisions in the Public Resources Code.
- Establishes that the Commission’s procedures for prohibiting ex parte communications unless they are disclosed extends to “any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring Commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the Commission.
- Defines an “interested person” to be “any applicant, an agent or an employee of the applicant, or a person receiving any consideration for representing the applicant, or a participant in a proceeding in any matter before the Commission.” An “interested person” also includes “a person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission and their agents as well as organizational representatives who intend to influence Commission decisions.”
- Requires commissioners to disclose to the public an ex parte communication on a prescribed form within 7 days of the communication. If the communication occurs within 7 days of the next Commission meeting, the disclosure must be made on the record of the proceeding in that hearing.
- Exempts enforcement proceedings from the prohibition on ex parte communications which are not specifically included in the statutory ban, pursuant to an opinion of the California Attorney General, which does not have the effect of law.
This bill:
- Bans ex parte communications concerning adjudicative or enforcement proceedings before the Commission.
- Requires disclosure even of banned communications within seven days of the ex parte communication or, on the record if the communication occurred within 7 days of the next Commission meeting and specifies the elements of the disclosure.
- Bans a commissioner from voting on a matter that was the subject of an ex parte communication.
- Authorizes commissioners to communicate to Commission staff provided no attempt is made to influence a Commission staff report or recommendation and bans commissioners who violate this provision from other public office in California.
Comments
Amendments in the Senate Appropriations Committee narrowed the prohibition on ex parte communications to adjudicative and enforcement matters, and exempts legislative and policy determinations made by the commission. This was an option discussed in policy committee but it did not remove the opposition from the coalition that opposes the bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Audubon California
California Coastal Protection Network
Courage Campaign
Endangered Habitats League
Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks
Malibu Coalition for Slow Growth
Organization of Regional Coastal Activists
Sierra Club California
SoCal 350 Climate Action
Western Alliance for Nature
5 individuals
17 former California Coastal Commissioners
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/10/16)
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Material Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Plant Health Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, the recent firing of the executive director of the Coastal Commission has resulted in a high degree of public uncertainty, accusations of a lack of transparency in the decision-making process, and generated concerns of undue political influence by commissioners on commission staff. The author stated that the bill will help restore the public’s trust in the commission, ensure that decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision-making or the perception that it is happening. She added that SB 1190 would level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources. By protecting the independence of commission staff, she believes that the bill adds to coastal protection from threats related to climate change, pollution, and unchecked development.
All of the supporters stress the importance not only of the ban on ex parte communications but also the importance of clarifying the independence of staff. Most are sharply critical of the existing practice of “reporting” ex parte communications which they characterize as inadequate and cursory. Many suggest that ex parte communications are handled unevenly by commissioners such that certain viewpoints are often not able to have an audience with certain commissioners. Others note that the ability to travel to ex parte meetings is not something that individuals or small non-profits are able to do. Instead, that is a perk for those who can afford to do so and it is often done by those with very expensive and potentially lucrative development applications pending before the commission.
The Sierra Club noted that many of its members have successfully worked with commissioners using ex parte communications, but this group nevertheless supports the proposed ban because “the recent firing of Dr. Charles Lester [as the executive director of the commission] has shown the ability of other groups to use ex parte communications far more effectively with terrible results for the coast.”
Almost all of the supporters would agree with another Sierra Club statement that “ex parte communication restrictions are common for other judicial and quasi-judicial bodies, from courts to most state agencies. This protects the public who does not have the same access and is not able to wine and dine with commissioners before meetings, with little disclosure. Developers and other interests that would prefer a privatized coast have more resources available that makes leveling the field necessary.”
Almost all of the supporters also stressed the importance of the independence of staff. As said by the Western Alliance for Nature (Sara Wan, a long time former coastal commissioner is the Executive Director), “the commission staff must be free to work independently of the decision-makers and provide their professional and scientific analysis free from political influence and pressure. Commissioners should enter the hearing process with an independent staff report and written correspondence from all interested parties. Then they should listen to the public hearing with an open mind taking into consideration the input from all. It is important to also recognize that there are 12 voting commissioners, each with their own personal biases. They are free to express and act accordingly in casting their votes, but they should not be allowed to taint the staff report with those biases. If allowed, it would mean that those in the majority would be, in essence, slanting the staff recommendation in advance of the hearing. This is contrary to a fair and open process.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The opposition coalition headed by the California Chamber sent in a revised letter subsequent to the recent amendments. The coalition objects to a ban on ex parte communications even when limited to adjudicative or enforcement proceedings. It also objects to the proposed limitations on communications between commissioners and staff.
According to the coalition headed by the California Chamber, citizen participation and communication should be encouraged, and that principle should extend not only to commissioners, but to staff.
5/11/16 15:12:47
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Fran Pavley, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 1190 Hearing Date: April 12, 2016
Author: | |||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: California Coastal Commission: ex parte communications: staff communications
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
The California Coastal Act of 1976 prohibits, with specified exceptions, “ex parte” communications between a member of the Coastal Commission and an interested person about a matter within the jurisdiction of the commission. Such communications, by definition, do not occur in a public hearing or other official proceeding or on the record. When proper disclosure of such communications is made, ex parte communications are lawful. Existing law also prohibits commissioners or alternates from trying to influence a commission decision in circumstances in which an ex parte communication has not been reported. A civil fine of up to $7500 may be imposed, plus attorney’s fees, and the commission action may be revoked. Public Resources Code Sections 30324 (a), 30327, and 30824.
Public Resources Code Section 30321 establishes the commission’s jurisdiction for matters that are subject to the above prohibition on ex parte communications and the disclosure requirements. These include “any permit action, federal consistency review, appeal, local coastal program, port master plan, public works plan, long-range development plan, categorical or other exclusions from coastal development permit requirements, or any other quasi-judicial matter requiring commission action, for which an application has been submitted to the commission.”
Section 30323 defines an “interested person” to be “any applicant, an agent or an employee of the applicant, or a person receiving any consideration for representing the applicant, or a participant in a proceeding in any matter before the Commission.” An “interested person” also includes “a person with a financial interest in a matter before the Commission and their agents as well as organizational representatives who intend to influence commission decisions.”
Commissioners must disclose to the public an ex parte communication on the prescribed form within 7 days of the communication. If the communication occurs within 7 days of the next commission meeting, the disclosure must be made on the record of the proceeding in that hearing.
The California Attorney General has opined that commissioners may not engage in ex parte communications in the context of enforcement proceedings because enforcement proceedings are not contained in Section 30321. This advice letter does not have the effect of law.
The policy of the Coastal Act is to “ensure full and adequate participation by all interested groups and the public at large.” Public Resources Code Section 30339.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill would ban ex parte communications. It would also amend the Coastal Act to ensure that commissioners or alternates do not attempt to influence, change, or alter a staff report, analysis, or recommendation prior to the time the staff report is made public at a hearing or other official proceeding. Violations of this provision would be subject to a fine of $1000 or imprisonment and a violator would be disqualified forever from holding any office in California.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, the recent firing of the executive director of the Coastal Commission has resulted in a high degree of public uncertainty, accusations of a lack of transparency in the decision-making process, and generated concerns of undue political influence by commissioners on commission staff. The author stated that the bill will help restore the public’s trust in the commission, ensure that decisions are made more openly and transparently, and remove the possibility of back-room decision-making or the perception that it is happening. She added that SB 1190 would level the playing field between big-moneyed interests and those without such financial resources. By protecting the independence of commission staff, she believes that the bill adds to coastal protection from threats related to climate change, pollution, and unchecked development.
All of the supporters stress the importance not only of the ban on ex parte communications but also the importance of clarifying the independence of staff. Most are sharply critical of the existing practice of “reporting” ex parte communications which they characterize as inadequate and cursory. Many suggest that ex parte communications are handled unevenly by commissioners such that certain viewpoints are often not able to have an audience with certain commissioners. Others note that the ability to travel to ex parte meetings is not something that individuals or small non-profits are able to do. Instead, that is a perk for those who can afford to do so and it is often done by those with very expensive and potentially lucrative development applications pending before the commission.
The Sierra Club noted that many of its members have successfully worked with commissioners using ex parte communications, but this group nevertheless supports the proposed ban because “the recent firing of Dr. Charles Lester [as the executive director of the commission] has shown the ability of other groups to use ex parte communications far more effectively with terrible results for the coast.”
Almost all of the supporters would agree with another Sierra Club statement that
“ex parte communication restrictions are common for other judicial and quasi-judicial bodies, from courts to most state agencies. This protects the public who does not have the same access and is not able to wine and dine with commissioners before meetings, with little disclosure. Developers and other interests that would prefer a privatized coast have more resources available that makes leveling the field necessary.”
Almost all of the supporters also stressed the importance of the independence of staff. As said by the Western Alliance for Nature (Sara Wan, a long time former coastal commissioner is the Executive Director), “the commission staff must be free to work independently of the decision-makers and provide their professional and scientific analysis free from political influence and pressure. Commissioners should enter the hearing process with an independent staff report and written correspondence from all interested parties. Then they should listen to the public hearing with an open mind taking into consideration the input from all. It is important to also recognize that there are 12 voting commissioners, each with their own personal biases. They are free to express and act accordingly in casting their votes, but they should not be allowed to taint the staff report with those biases. If allowed, it would mean that those in the majority would be, in essence, slanting the staff recommendation in advance of the hearing. This is contrary to a fair and open process.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received
COMMENTS
Commentators and court decisions have noted that ex parte communications introduce an improper element of bias into decision-making but providing, in this context, a coastal commissioner with information that can’t be challenged by an adverse party.
Court decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court and California courts have established the procedural due process requires a meaningful opportunity to participate in the process as well as decision makers who are as unbiased as possible. As said in a California decision, “One adversary should not be permitted to bend the ear of the ultimate decision maker or the decision maker’s advisors in private.” Department of Beverage Control v Alcoholic Beverage Control Appeals Board.
Agencies subject to the California Administrative Procedure Act (APA) prohibit ex parte communications. Most of the state’s adjudicative agencies, such as the coastal commission, have their own provisions. The Coastal Commission is exempted from the prohibition on ex parte communications contained in the APA.
SUPPORT
Endangered Habitats League
Ex-Commissioner Phyllis Faber
Friends of Harbors Beaches and Parks
Sierra Club California
SoCal 350 Climate Action
Western Alliance for Nature
3 individuals
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):