SB 1265: Marital deduction trusts.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-17
Existing law regulates the interpretation and administration of wills, trusts, and estates. Existing law regulates the compliance of marital deduction gifts with the federal Internal Revenue Code. Existing law provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, certain additional conditions apply to the marital deduction trust, including, among others, that the transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. Existing law requires that in the case of qualified terminable interest property specified in certain provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, on termination of the interest of the transferors spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income pass to the transferors spouse, except as provided.
This bill would delete the provision relating to qualified terminable interest property described above and instead require that the term income, for purposes of the marital deduction property, be construed in a manner consistent with specified provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, and include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
Existing law regulates the interpretation and administration of wills, trusts, and estates. Existing law regulates the compliance of marital deduction gifts with the federal Internal Revenue Code. Existing law provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, certain additional conditions apply to the marital deduction trust, including, among others, that the transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. Existing law requires that in the case of qualified terminable interest property specified in certain provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, on termination of the interest of the transferors spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income pass to the transferors spouse, except as provided.
This bill would delete the provision relating to qualified terminable interest property described above and instead require that the term income, for purposes of the marital deduction property, be construed in a manner consistent with specified provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, and include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
Existing law regulates the interpretation and administration of wills, trusts, and estates. Existing law regulates the compliance of marital deduction gifts with the federal Internal Revenue Code. Existing law provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, certain additional conditions apply to the marital deduction trust, including, among others, that the transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. Existing law requires that in the case of qualified terminable interest property specified in certain provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, on termination of the interest of the transferors spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income pass to the transferors spouse, except as provided.
This bill would delete the provision relating to qualified terminable interest property described above and instead require that the term income, for purposes of the marital deduction property, be construed in a manner consistent with specified provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, and include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
If a marital deduction gift is made in trust, in addition to the other provisions of this chapter, each of the following provisions also applies to the marital deduction trust:
(a)The transferors spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive. Nothing in this subdivision precludes exercise by the transferors spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust.
(b) The transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. For purposes of this subdivision, income shall be construed in a manner consistent with subdivision (b) of Section 2056 and subdivision (f) of Section 2523 of the Internal Revenue Code and shall include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code and the regulations adopted pursuant to that statute.
(c)The transferors spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time.
If a marital deduction gift is made in trust, in addition to the other provisions of this chapter, each of the following provisions also applies to the marital deduction trust:
(a)The transferors spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive. Nothing in this subdivision precludes exercise by the transferors spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust.
(b) The transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. For purposes of this subdivision, income shall be construed in a manner consistent with subdivision (b) of Section 2056 and subdivision (f) of Section 2523 of the Internal Revenue Code and shall include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code and the regulations adopted pursuant to that statute.
(c)The transferors spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time.
If a marital deduction gift is made in trust, in addition to the other provisions of this chapter, each of the following provisions also applies to the marital deduction trust:
(a)The transferors spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive. Nothing in this subdivision precludes exercise by the transferors spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust.
(b)Subject to subdivision (d), the The transferors spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive. For purposes of this subdivision, income shall be construed in a manner consistent with subdivision (b) of Section 2056 and subdivision (f) of Section 2523 of the Internal Revenue Code and shall include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code and the regulations adopted pursuant to that statute.
(c)The transferors spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 16347, in the case of qualified terminable interest property under Section 2056(b)(7) or Section 2523(f) of the Internal Revenue Code, on termination of the interest of the transferors spouse in the trust all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the transferors spouse, unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 17, 2016 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 140, Statutes of 2016. |
| Aug 17, 2016 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 5, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 10:30 a.m. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 5644.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 29, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Jun 28, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| May 19, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 3849.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 12, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| May 4, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3767.) (May 3). |
| May 4, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 3). |
| Apr 21, 2016 | Set for hearing May 3. |
| Mar 3, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 1, 2016 | SB 1265 Moorlach Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2016 | Consent Calendar 2nd SB1265 Moorlach | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 3, 2016 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 28, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1265
Author:(Moorlach) – As Introduced Ver:February 18, 2016
PROPOSED CONSENT
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: MARITAL DEDUCTION TRUSTS
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO BETTER PROTECT DECEDENTS AND THEIR SURVIVING FAMILIES FROM POTENTIAL TAX LIABILITY ASSOCIATED WITH INARTFUL DRAFTING OF ESTATE PLANS, SHOULD THE MARITAL DEDUCTION TRUSTS SAVING STATUTE BE UPDATED to be CONSISTENT WITH FEDERAL LAW?
SYNOPSIS
This non-controversial and technical bill updates provisions relating to marital deduction trusts savings statute by updating its references to federal law and deleting outdated provisions limiting a qualified terminable interest property trust. This bill is sponsored by the Executive Committee of the Trust and Estates Section of the State Bar of California (TEXCOM) and has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Updates the marital deduction trusts savings statute to reflect definitions used under federal law. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that the term income shall be construed in a manner consistent with subdivision (b) of Section 2056 and subdivision (f) of Section 2523 of the Internal Revenue Code, and shall include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code and the regulations adopted pursuant to that statute.
- Deletes provisions relating to qualified terminable interest property that specify that on termination of the interest of the transferor’s spouse in the trust all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the transferor’s spouse, unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a marital deduction to mean the federal estate tax deduction allowed for transfers under Section 2056 of the Internal Revenue Code or the federal gift deduction allowed for transfers under Section 2523 of the Internal Revenue Code. (Probate Code Section 21520. Unless otherwise stated, all further statutory references are to the Probate Code.)
- Defines a marital deduction gift as a transfer of property that is intended to qualify for the unlimited federal estate tax deduction or the federal gift tax deduction, as provided. (Ibid.)
- Provides that if a marital deduction is made in trust, the following must apply:
- The transferor’s spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive. Further provides that nothing in this requirement precludes exercise by the transferor’s spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust.
- The transferor’s spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive except as otherwise provided.
- The transferor’s spouse has the right to require that the trustee make unproductive marital deduction productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time. (Section 21524.)
- Requires a trustee to administer the trust according to the trust or as provided by law unless the trust provides otherwise. (Section 16000.)
- Requires the trustee to administer the trust with reasonable care, skill, and caution under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent person acting in a like capacity would use in the conduct of an enterprise as provided. (Section 16040.)
- Provides that a trustee, in making and implementing investment decisions, has a duty to diversify the investments of the trust unless under the circumstances it is prudent not to do so. (Section 16048.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: When it comes to estate planning, federal tax law has a significant impact in how a decedent may transfer his or her property. A decedent seeking to minimize estate taxes on his or her gross estate upon death might consult an estate planner to maximize appropriate exclusions, deductions, and other calculations. In the other words: the lower the taxable estate, the lower the estate tax. Although California does not have an estate tax, federal law imposes an estate tax if a decedent’s gross estate is valued at more than the established filing threshold for the year of the decedent’s death. The filing threshold for 2016 is $5,450,000.
The federal marital deduction can be used to shield a decedent’s estate from tax liability. Commonly, a decedent who is married can reduce his or her gross estate by relying upon the marital deduction under federal law. The marital deduction, which is currently unlimited, allows a decedent to transfer all of his or her property to a surviving spouse without being immediately subject to wealth transfer taxes; generally, the estate tax is deferred until the death of the surviving spouse if any tax is applied at all. The policy reason behind this deduction is “based on the idea that transfers between spouses should not be subject to tax because spouses are considered one economic unit.” (See Dukeminier & Sitkoff, Wills, Trusts, and Estates Trust (9th ed. 2013) p. 959.)
Depending on the intent of the decedent, different trusts may be created. Since California is a community property state, joint trusts are common. According the sponsor, it is also common for a joint trust to have various subtrusts to help manage the assets upon the death of one of the spouses. To maximize the federal marital deduction benefit described above, a joint trust may include a marital deduction trust as a subtrust. Practically speaking, upon death of the decedent, the decedent’s property in the joint trust is divided, and the marital deduction gift flows to a marital deduction trust, where—depending on the type of marital deduction trust—income and/or principal may be distributed to support the surviving spouse during his or her life. One of the most common marital deduction trusts is a qualified terminable interest property trust (QTIP). Under a QTIP trust, income is paid to the surviving spouse for life and any remainder is directed to the other beneficiaries.
To protect decedents from problems arising out of inartful estate drafting, California has enacted a backstop to federal law for marital deduction trusts. Generally, the federal Internal Revenue Code establishes the tax rules on transferring property between spouses during life and at death. (See 26 U.S.C. Sections 2056, 2523.) Accordingly, estate planners will look to federal law to ensure that estate plans are correctly drafted to help their clients. However, since the risk of tax liability caused by potential inartful drafting is significant, California has enacted a statutory backstop that mirrors federal law aimed at guarding decedents, surviving spouses, and their families from significant tax liabilities. Consequently, Probate Code Section 21524 establishes default provisions for marital deduction gifts made in trust. However, this savings clause becomes ineffective if it is inconsistent with federal law.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
Probate Code Section 21524 (marital deduction trust savings statute) was enacted as a statutory backstop to marital deduction trusts drafted under California law. That statute grafts the federal regulatory requirements onto marital deduction trusts that may not otherwise qualify due to unartful drafting. The purpose of the statute is to rescue possibly defective marital deduction trusts and ensure their qualification for the federal estate tax marital deduction, and, thereby, reduce or eliminate the estate tax on a decedent’s estate. However, this backstop is only effective if the marital deduction trust savings statute mirrors the requirements under federal law.
Federal law regarding marital deduction gifts has changed in the nearly 25 years since the enactment of the marital deduction trust savings statute, without any substantive change to that statute. However, two important changes have been made to federal tax regulations in the interim: (1) a revised definition of income for a qualifying marital deduction trust that reflects modern portfolio theory and investment approaches; and (2) evolving case law and government announcements regarding income of a marital deduction trust that is accrued, but undistributed, prior to the death of the surviving spouse.
Summary of this bill: Essentially, this bill adopts the definition of income as it is defined under federal law, and also defines it to include income from a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined to be a reasonable apportionment of total investment return under the Internal Revenue Code. This bill also deletes an unnecessary provision of law relating to qualified terminable interest property that has been recognized under common law.
This bill adopts the definition of income to include income from a unitrust payment. A unitrust is a type of trust that distributes a fixed amount or percentage of the trust property to the income beneficiary. Because a unitrust does not distinguish between income and principle, it provides more flexibility to a trustee to diversify and invest for a total return. In addition to adopting the definition of income adopted under the Internal Revenue Code, this bill reasonable includes a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined to be a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code as income. Given that this definition is already recognized under federal law, this adoption would improve the state’s marital deduction savings clause.
This bill seeks to conform the current marital deduction savings statute to existing law by deleting outdated provisions. Probate Code Section 21524 (d) provides that in the case of a QTIP trust, upon the termination of the interest of the surviving spouse, all remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the surviving spouse unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. According to TEXCOM, when the statute was enacted in 1990, federal tax law was unsettled as to whether undistributed income that had accrued prior to the surviving spouse’s death had to flow to the surviving spouse’s estate in order for a trust to qualify for the marital deduction. TEXCOM states that it is now well-settled that a trust qualifies for the marital deduction without mandating distribution of that income. (See Estate of Howard v. Commissioner (9th Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 633.) Accordingly, this bill justifiably deletes the outdated reference and removes the unnecessary limitations on a QTIP trust.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 1265
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/3/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hertzberg
SOURCE: Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar California
DIGEST: This bill updates provisions relating to marital deduction trusts for cross-references to applicable federal laws relating to qualified terminable interest property and provide for a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the value of the taxable estate to be determined by deducting from the value of the gross estate an amount equal to the value of any interest in property which passes or has passed from the decedent to his surviving spouse, but only to the extent that such interest is included in determining the value of the gross estate, unless otherwise exempt as specified, for purposes of tax imposed on property transferrable from a decedent’s estate.
- Limits the application of the marital deduction in the case of a life estate or other terminable interests.
- Requires the formula to be applied to eliminate or to reduce to the maximum extent possible the federal estate tax if an instrument includes a formula intended to eliminate the federal estate tax. If an instrument includes a formula that refers to a maximum fraction or amount that will not result in a federal estate tax, the formula is construed to refer to the maximum fraction or amount that will not result in or increase the federal estate tax.
- Defines “marital deduction” to mean the federal estate tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified, or the federal gift tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified. Existing law also defines material deduction gift to mean a transfer of property that is intended to qualify for the material deduction.
- Does not apply the marital deduction trust savings statute to a trust that otherwise qualifies for the marital deduction under federal law.
- Provides that if an instrument contains a marital deduction gift:
- the provisions of the instrument, including any power, duty, or discretionary authority given to a fiduciary, shall be construed to comply with the marital deduction provisions of the Internal Revenue Code;
- the fiduciary shall not take any action or have any power that impairs the deduction as applied to the marital deduction gift; and
- the marital deduction gift may be satisfied only with property that qualifies for the marital deduction.
- Provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, and does not otherwise qualify as a marital deduction trust under federal law, each of the following provisions applies to the marital deduction trust:
- the transferor’s spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive; however, this provision does not preclude exercise by the transferor’s spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust;
- as specified, the transferor’s spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive;
- the transferor’s spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time; and
- notwithstanding the limitations on undistributed income under the Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA), in the case of qualified terminable interest property, as defined under federal law, on termination of the interest of the transferor’s spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the transferor’s spouse, unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524.)
- Requires a trust to be administered, as specified, with due regard to the respective interests of defined income beneficiaries and defined remainder beneficiaries.
- Defines “undistributed income” to mean net income received before the date on which income interest ends; however, the term does not include an item of income or expense that is due or accrued or net income that has been added or is required to be added to principal by the trust.
This bill:
- Requires the income from a marital deduction trust to which the transferor’s spouse is entitled to be construed in a manner consistent with the federal limitations on life estate or other terminable interest, as specified, and include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of federal laws and regulations, as specified.
- Deletes provisions made inoperative pursuant to changes in the Internal Revenue Code.
Background
Although California does not currently have an estate tax, current federal law imposes an estate tax on all the assets of United States citizens and residents. An estate tax at the rate of 40 percent is assessed on the value of assets above the estate exclusion ($5,340,000 for year 2014, indexed annually for inflation). Federal law allows a decedent’s estate an unlimited estate tax marital deduction for property that passes to a surviving spouse. Qualifying for the estate tax marital deduction is a primary goal of many estate plans because that qualification may reduce or eliminate the estate tax due on the death of the first spouse, and defers payment of that tax, if at all, until the death of the surviving spouse. Gifts in trust for the surviving spouse may qualify for the estate tax marital deduction, subject to the requirements in federal tax regulations.
Probate Code Section 21524 (marital deduction trust savings statute) was enacted as a statutory backstop to marital deduction trusts drafted under California law. That statute grafts the federal regulatory requirements onto marital deduction trusts that may not otherwise qualify due to unartful drafting. The purpose of the statute is to rescue possibly defective marital deduction trusts and ensure their qualification for the federal estate tax marital deduction, and, thereby, reduce or eliminate the estate tax on a decedent’s estate. To accomplish this rescue mission, the marital deduction trust savings statute should mirror the requirements for marital deduction trusts in federal tax regulations.
Federal law regarding marital deduction gifts has changed in the nearly 25 years since the enactment of the marital deduction trust savings statute, without any substantive change to that statute. Two important changes have been made to federal tax regulations in the interim: (1) a revised definition of income for a qualifying marital deduction trust that reflects modern portfolio theory and investment approaches; and (2) evolving case law and government announcements regarding income of a marital deduction trust that is accrued, but undistributed, prior to the death of the surviving spouse.
Federal regulations now allow a marital deduction trust to pay a unitrust amount, which may be less than actual net income, but still qualify for the estate tax marital deduction. This bill updates the marital deduction trust savings statute in accordance with federal tax laws and regulations.
Comments
The author writes:
Probate Code [S]ection 21524 was originally enacted in 1990 as a savings clause. If a marital trust in a document fails to meet the federal requirements, perhaps due to outdated or unartful drafting, [S]ection 21524 will import those requirements and give the surviving spouse this important tax benefit.
Since 1990 changes in federal law have made qualification for the [marital] trust more flexible. This bill updates Probate Code [S]ection 21524 for two changes in federal law since the time of its enactment. The first change is to allow trusts that give the surviving spouse a unitrust payment to qualify for the marital deduction. The bill makes a second technical change to conform [S]ection 21524 to existing federal law. Subsection (d) regarding the payment of undistributed income is deleted because it does not reflect current federal estate tax law and the California Principal and Income Act. This change will clarify the law and bring the statute up to date.
A unitrust is a type of trust in which a fixed percentage of the trust property is paid annually to the trust’s income beneficiary. The California Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA) provides trust accounting rules regarding distributions of principal and income to trust beneficiaries and, among other things, provides limitations on unitrust conversions and payouts. (Prob. Code Sec. 16320 et seq.) Under California’s marital deduction trust savings statute, the surviving spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property transferred from the deceased spouse at least once a year. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524(b).) This bill would define “income” to include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified, and require the income to be construed in a manner consistent with federal law, as specified.
As noted by the author, Treasury Regulation Section 20.2056(b)-5(f) defines when the surviving spouse is deemed to be entitled to the entire income of a trust, thereby qualifying that trust or interest in a trust for the estate tax marital deduction. The author further notes that regulation was modified on January 2, 2004, by Treasury Decision 9102 to reflect changes in the definition of trust accounting income under state laws, and the concurrent change in federal income tax law under Internal Revenue Code Section 643 and applicable federal regulations. That modified regulation allows the income payment determined under the trustee’s adjustment power or a unitrust payment to qualify as a marital deduction gift.
Existing law, with respect to qualified terminable interest property and subject to limitations on undistributed income under the UPIA, requires all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income to pass to the surviving spouse’s estate, unless the transferring spouse’s testamentary instrument provided for a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. This bill repeals those provisions.
A qualified terminable interest property trust (QTIP trust) is one established by the transferring spouse for the benefit of beneficiaries (other than the surviving spouse) to receive assets from a marital deduction trust after the surviving spouse dies. An example of the use of a QTIP trust is where the transferor spouse is married to a second spouse, who is the surviving spouse. The transferor spouse had children from his or her first marriage. The transferor spouse wants to provide for the surviving spouse, as well as the transferor’s children from the first marriage. The transferor spouse establishes a marital deduction trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse until his or her death, at which time the assets in the marital deduction trust are transferred to a QTIP trust for the benefit of the children.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 846 (Ackerman, Chapter 145, Statutes of 1999) enacted the Uniform Principal and Income Act, and, among other things, revised the cross-reference to the new Act under the marital deduction trust savings statute.
AB 759 (Friedman, Chapter 79, Statutes of 1990) revised and recast the Probate Code, and, among other things, continued the marital deduction gifts and trust provisions under prior law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California (source)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar (TEXCOM), sponsor, contends that since the original intent of the marital deduction trust savings statute appears to be to preserve the marital deduction, it should mirror the definition of income in current federal tax regulations. The marital deduction trust savings statute currently provides a default rule that a trustee must distribute all of the income, without reference to unitrust payments. TEXCOM asserts that without specific reference to unitrust payments, “income” under the existing statute may be construed in accordance with the definition of income in Probate Code Section 16324, or traditional notions of income. Accordingly, this bill, by incorporating unitrust payments and other allocations of income into the meaning of “income” under the marital deduction trust savings statute, seeks to harmonize the savings statute with current federal tax regulations and the UPIA.
5/6/16 14:26:31
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 1265
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/3/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hertzberg
SOURCE: Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California
DIGEST: This bill updates provisions relating to marital deduction trusts for cross-references to applicable federal laws relating to qualified terminable interest property and provide for a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the value of the taxable estate to be determined by deducting from the value of the gross estate an amount equal to the value of any interest in property which passes or has passed from the decedent to his surviving spouse, but only to the extent that such interest is included in determining the value of the gross estate, unless otherwise exempt as specified, for purposes of tax imposed on property transferrable from a decedent’s estate.
- Limits the application of the marital deduction in the case of a life estate or other terminable interests.
- Requires the formula to be applied to eliminate or to reduce to the maximum extent possible the federal estate tax if an instrument includes a formula intended to eliminate the federal estate tax. If an instrument includes a formula that refers to a maximum fraction or amount that will not result in a federal estate tax, the formula is construed to refer to the maximum fraction or amount that will not result in or increase the federal estate tax.
- Defines “marital deduction” to mean the federal estate tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified, or the federal gift tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified. Existing law also defines material deduction gift to mean a transfer of property that is intended to qualify for the material deduction.
- Does not apply the marital deduction trust savings statute to a trust that otherwise qualifies for the marital deduction under federal law.
- Provides that if an instrument contains a marital deduction gift:
- the provisions of the instrument, including any power, duty, or discretionary authority given to a fiduciary, shall be construed to comply with the marital deduction provisions of the Internal Revenue Code;
- the fiduciary shall not take any action or have any power that impairs the deduction as applied to the marital deduction gift; and
- the marital deduction gift may be satisfied only with property that qualifies for the marital deduction.
- Provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, and does not otherwise qualify as a marital deduction trust under federal law, each of the following provisions applies to the marital deduction trust:
- the transferor’s spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive; however, this provision does not preclude exercise by the transferor’s spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust;
- as specified, the transferor’s spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive;
- the transferor’s spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time; and
- notwithstanding the limitations on undistributed income under the Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA), in the case of qualified terminable interest property, as defined under federal law, on termination of the interest of the transferor’s spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the transferor’s spouse, unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524.)
- Requires a trust to be administered, as specified, with due regard to the respective interests of defined income beneficiaries and defined remainder beneficiaries.
- Defines “undistributed income” to mean net income received before the date on which income interest ends; however, the term does not include an item of income or expense that is due or accrued or net income that has been added or is required to be added to principal by the trust.
This bill:
- Requires the income from a marital deduction trust to which the transferor’s spouse is entitled to be construed in a manner consistent with the federal limitations on life estate or other terminable interest, as specified, and include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of federal laws and regulations, as specified.
- Deletes provisions made inoperative pursuant to changes in the Internal Revenue Code.
Background
Although California does not currently have an estate tax, current federal law imposes an estate tax on all the assets of United States citizens and residents. An estate tax at the rate of 40 percent is assessed on the value of assets above the estate exclusion ($5,340,000 for year 2014, indexed annually for inflation). Federal law allows a decedent’s estate an unlimited estate tax marital deduction for property that passes to a surviving spouse. Qualifying for the estate tax marital deduction is a primary goal of many estate plans because that qualification may reduce or eliminate the estate tax due on the death of the first spouse, and defers payment of that tax, if at all, until the death of the surviving spouse. Gifts in trust for the surviving spouse may qualify for the estate tax marital deduction, subject to the requirements in federal tax regulations.
Probate Code Section 21524 (marital deduction trust savings statute) was enacted as a statutory backstop to marital deduction trusts drafted under California law. That statute grafts the federal regulatory requirements onto marital deduction trusts that may not otherwise qualify due to unartful drafting. The purpose of the statute is to rescue possibly defective marital deduction trusts and ensure their qualification for the federal estate tax marital deduction, and, thereby, reduce or eliminate the estate tax on a decedent’s estate. To accomplish this rescue mission, the marital deduction trust savings statute should mirror the requirements for marital deduction trusts in federal tax regulations.
Federal law regarding marital deduction gifts has changed in the nearly 25 years since the enactment of the marital deduction trust savings statute, without any substantive change to that statute. Two important changes have been made to federal tax regulations in the interim: (1) a revised definition of income for a qualifying marital deduction trust that reflects modern portfolio theory and investment approaches; and (2) evolving case law and government announcements regarding income of a marital deduction trust that is accrued, but undistributed, prior to the death of the surviving spouse.
Federal regulations now allow a marital deduction trust to pay a unitrust amount, which may be less than actual net income, but still qualify for the estate tax marital deduction. This bill updates the marital deduction trust savings statute in accordance with federal tax laws and regulations.
Comments
The author writes:
Probate Code [S]ection 21524 was originally enacted in 1990 as a savings clause. If a marital trust in a document fails to meet the federal requirements, perhaps due to outdated or unartful drafting, [S]ection 21524 will import those requirements and give the surviving spouse this important tax benefit.
Since 1990 changes in federal law have made qualification for the [marital] trust more flexible. This bill updates Probate Code [S]ection 21524 for two changes in federal law since the time of its enactment. The first change is to allow trusts that give the surviving spouse a unitrust payment to qualify for the marital deduction. The bill makes a second technical change to conform [S]ection 21524 to existing federal law. Subsection (d) regarding the payment of undistributed income is deleted because it does not reflect current federal estate tax law and the California Principal and Income Act. This change will clarify the law and bring the statute up to date.
A unitrust is a type of trust in which a fixed percentage of the trust property is paid annually to the trust’s income beneficiary. The California Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA) provides trust accounting rules regarding distributions of principal and income to trust beneficiaries and, among other things, provides limitations on unitrust conversions and payouts. (Prob. Code Sec. 16320 et seq.) Under California’s marital deduction trust savings statute, the surviving spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property transferred from the deceased spouse at least once a year. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524(b).) This bill would define “income” to include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified, and require the income to be construed in a manner consistent with federal law, as specified.
As noted by the author, Treasury Regulation Section 20.2056(b)-5(f) defines when the surviving spouse is deemed to be entitled to the entire income of a trust, thereby qualifying that trust or interest in a trust for the estate tax marital deduction. The author further notes that regulation was modified on January 2, 2004, by Treasury Decision 9102 to reflect changes in the definition of trust accounting income under state laws, and the concurrent change in federal income tax law under Internal Revenue Code Section 643 and applicable federal regulations. That modified regulation allows the income payment determined under the trustee’s adjustment power or a unitrust payment to qualify as a marital deduction gift.
Existing law, with respect to qualified terminable interest property and subject to limitations on undistributed income under the UPIA, requires all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income to pass to the surviving spouse’s estate, unless the transferring spouse’s testamentary instrument provided for a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. This bill repeals those provisions.
A qualified terminable interest property trust (QTIP trust) is one established by the transferring spouse for the benefit of beneficiaries (other than the surviving spouse) to receive assets from a marital deduction trust after the surviving spouse dies. An example of the use of a QTIP trust is where the transferor spouse is married to a second spouse, who is the surviving spouse. The transferor spouse had children from his or her first marriage. The transferor spouse wants to provide for the surviving spouse, as well as the transferor’s children from the first marriage. The transferor spouse establishes a marital deduction trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse until his or her death, at which time the assets in the marital deduction trust are transferred to a QTIP trust for the benefit of the children.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 846 (Ackerman, Chapter 145, Statutes of 1999) enacted the Uniform Principal and Income Act, and, among other things, revised the cross-reference to the new Act under the marital deduction trust savings statute.
AB 759 (Friedman, Chapter 79, Statutes of 1990) revised and recast the Probate Code, and, among other things, continued the marital deduction gifts and trust provisions under prior law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California (source)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar (TEXCOM), sponsor, contends that since the original intent of the marital deduction trust savings statute appears to be to preserve the marital deduction, it should mirror the definition of income in current federal tax regulations. The marital deduction trust savings statute currently provides a default rule that a trustee must distribute all of the income, without reference to unitrust payments. TEXCOM asserts that without specific reference to unitrust payments, “income” under the existing statute may be construed in accordance with the definition of income in Probate Code Section 16324, or traditional notions of income. Accordingly, this bill, by incorporating unitrust payments and other allocations of income into the meaning of “income” under the marital deduction trust savings statute, seeks to harmonize the savings statute with current federal tax regulations and the UPIA.
Prepared by: Margie Estrada / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/6/16 14:59:00
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1265 (Author:Moorlach)
Version: February 18, 2016
Hearing Date: May 3, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TMW
SUBJECT
Marital deduction trusts
DESCRIPTION
This bill would update provisions relating to marital deduction trusts for cross-references to applicable federal laws relating to qualified terminable interest property and provide for a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified.
BACKGROUND
Although California does not currently have an estate tax, current federal law imposes an estate tax on all the assets of United States citizens and residents. An estate tax at the rate of 40 percent is assessed on the value of assets above the estate exclusion ($5,340,000 for year 2014, indexed annually for inflation). Federal law allows a decedent’s estate an unlimited estate tax marital deduction for property that passes to a surviving spouse. Qualifying for the estate tax marital deduction is a primary goal of many estate plans because that qualification may reduce or eliminate the estate tax due on the death of the first spouse, and defers payment of that tax, if at all, until the death of the surviving spouse. Gifts in trust for the surviving spouse may qualify for the estate tax marital deduction, subject to the requirements in federal tax regulations.
Probate Code Section 21524 (marital deduction trust savings statute) was enacted as a statutory backstop to marital deduction trusts drafted under California law. That statute grafts the federal regulatory requirements onto marital deduction trusts that may not otherwise qualify due to unartful drafting. The purpose of the statute is to rescue possibly defective marital deduction trusts and ensure their qualification for the federal estate tax marital deduction, and, thereby, reduce or eliminate the estate tax on a decedent’s estate. To accomplish this rescue mission, the marital deduction trust savings statute should mirror the requirements for marital deduction trusts in federal tax regulations.
Federal law regarding marital deduction gifts has changed in the nearly 25 years since the enactment of the marital deduction trust savings statute, without any substantive change to that statute. Two important changes have been made to federal tax regulations in the interim: (1) a revised definition of income for a qualifying marital deduction trust that reflects modern portfolio theory and investment approaches; and (2) evolving case law and government announcements regarding income of a marital deduction trust that is accrued, but undistributed, prior to the death of the surviving spouse.
Federal regulations now allow a marital deduction trust to pay a unitrust amount, which may be less than actual net income, but still qualify for the estate tax marital deduction. This bill would update the marital deduction trust savings statute in accordance with federal tax laws and regulations.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, unless otherwise exempt as specified, for purposes of tax imposed on property transferrable from a decedent’s estate, authorizes the value of the taxable estate to be determined by deducting from the value of the gross estate an amount equal to the value of any interest in property which passes or has passed from the decedent to his surviving spouse, but only to the extent that such interest is included in determining the value of the gross estate. (26 U.S.C Sec. 2056(a).)
Existing federal law limits the application of the marital deduction in the case of a life estate or other terminable interests. (26 U.S.C. Sec. 2056(b).)
Existing law, if an instrument includes a formula intended to eliminate the federal estate tax, requires the formula to be applied to eliminate or to reduce to the maximum extent possible the federal estate tax. (Prob. Code Sec. 21503(a).) If an instrument includes a formula that refers to a maximum fraction or amount that will not result in a federal estate tax, the formula is construed to refer to the maximum fraction or amount that will not result in or increase the federal estate tax. (Prob. Code Sec. 21503(b).)
Existing law defines “marital deduction” to mean the federal estate tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified, or the federal gift tax deduction allowed for transfers, as specified. (Prob. Code Sec. 21520(a).) Existing law also defines material deduction gift to mean a transfer of property that is intended to qualify for the material deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21520(b).)
Existing law does not apply the marital deduction trust savings statute to a trust that otherwise qualifies for the marital deduction under federal law. (Prob. Code Sec. 21521.)
Existing law provides that if an instrument contains a marital deduction gift:
- the provisions of the instrument, including any power, duty, or discretionary authority given to a fiduciary, shall be construed to comply with the marital deduction provisions of the Internal Revenue Code;
- the fiduciary shall not take any action or have any power that impairs the deduction as applied to the marital deduction gift; and
- the marital deduction gift may be satisfied only with property that qualifies for the marital deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21522.)
Existing law provides that if a marital deduction gift is made in trust, and does not otherwise qualify as a marital deduction trust under federal law, each of the following provisions applies to the marital deduction trust:
- the transferor’s spouse is the only beneficiary of income or principal of the marital deduction property as long as the spouse is alive; however, this provision does not preclude exercise by the transferor’s spouse of a power of appointment included in a trust that qualifies as a general power of appointment marital deduction trust;
- as specified, the transferor’s spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property not less frequently than annually, as long as the spouse is alive;
- the transferor’s spouse has the right to require that the trustee of the trust make unproductive marital deduction property productive or to convert it into productive property within a reasonable time; and
- notwithstanding the limitations on undistributed income under the Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA), in the case of qualified terminable interest property, as defined under federal law, on termination of the interest of the transferor’s spouse in the trust, all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income shall pass to the estate of the transferor’s spouse, unless the instrument provides a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524.)
Existing law, the UPIA, requires a trust to be administered, as specified, with due regard to the respective interests of defined income beneficiaries and defined remainder beneficiaries. (Prob. Code Sec. 16320 et seq.)
Existing law defines “undistributed income” to mean net income received before the date on which income interest ends; however, the term does not include an item of income or expense that is due or accrued or net income that has been added or is required to be added to principal by the trust. (Prob. Code Sec. 16347.)
This bill would require the income from a marital deduction trust to which the transferor’s spouse is entitled to be construed in a manner consistent with the federal limitations on life estate or other terminable interest, as specified, and would include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return that meets the requirements of federal laws and regulations, as specified.
This bill would delete provisions made inoperative pursuant to changes in the Internal Revenue Code.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
Probate Code [S]ection 21524 was originally enacted in 1990 as a savings clause. If a marital trust in a document fails to meet the federal requirements, perhaps due to outdated or unartful drafting, [S]ection 21524 will import those requirements and give the surviving spouse this important tax benefit.
Since 1990 changes in federal law have made qualification for the [marital] trust more flexible. This bill updates Probate Code [S]ection 21524 for two changes in federal law since the time of its enactment. The first change is to allow trusts that give the surviving spouse a unitrust payment to qualify for the marital deduction. The bill makes a second technical change to conform [S]ection 21524 to existing federal law. Subsection (d) regarding the payment of undistributed income is deleted because it does not reflect current federal estate tax law and the California Principal and Income Act. This change will clarify the law and bring the statute up to date.
2. Providing for unitrust payments
A unitrust is a type of trust in which a fixed percentage of the trust property is paid annually to the trust’s income beneficiary. The California Uniform Principal and Income Act (UPIA) provides trust accounting rules regarding distributions of principal and income to trust beneficiaries and, among other things, provides limitations on unitrust conversions and payouts. (Prob. Code Sec. 16320 et seq.) Under California’s marital deduction trust savings statute, the surviving spouse is entitled to all of the income of the marital deduction property transferred from the deceased spouse at least once a year. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524(b).) This bill would define “income” to include a unitrust payment or other allocation of income determined pursuant to a reasonable apportionment of total investment return, as specified, and require the income to be construed in a manner consistent with federal law, as specified.
As noted by the author, Treasury Regulation Section 20.2056(b)-5(f) defines when the surviving spouse is deemed to be entitled to the entire income of a trust, thereby qualifying that trust or interest in a trust for the estate tax marital deduction. The author further notes that regulation was modified on January 2, 2004, by Treasury Decision 9102 to reflect changes in the definition of trust accounting income under state laws, and the concurrent change in federal income tax law under Internal Revenue Code Section 643 and applicable federal regulations. That modified regulation allows the income payment determined under the trustee’s adjustment power or a unitrust payment to qualify as a marital deduction gift.
The Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar (TEXCOM), sponsor, contends that since the original intent of the marital deduction trust savings statute appears to be to preserve the marital deduction, it should mirror the definition of income in current federal tax regulations. The marital deduction trust savings statute currently provides a default rule that a trustee must distribute all of the income, without reference to unitrust payments. TEXCOM asserts that without specific reference to unitrust payments, “income” under the existing statute may be construed in accordance with the definition of income in Probate Code Section 16324, or traditional notions of income. Accordingly, this bill, by incorporating unitrust payments and other allocations of income into the meaning of “income” under the marital deduction trust savings statute, seeks to harmonize the savings statute with current federal tax regulations and the UPIA.
3. Updating marital deduction trust provisions to reflect changes in federal tax law
Existing law, with respect to qualified terminable interest property and subject to limitations on undistributed income under the UPIA, requires all of the remaining accrued or undistributed income to pass to the surviving spouse’s estate, unless the transferring spouse’s testamentary instrument provided for a different disposition that qualifies for the marital deduction. (Prob. Code Sec. 21524(d).) This bill would repeal those provisions.
A qualified terminable interest property trust (QTIP trust) is one established by the transferring spouse for the benefit of beneficiaries (other than the surviving spouse) to receive assets from a marital deduction trust after the surviving spouse dies. An example of the use of a QTIP trust is where the transferor spouse is married to a second spouse, who is the surviving spouse. The transferor spouse had children from his or her first marriage. The transferor spouse wants to provide for the surviving spouse, as well as the transferor’s children from the first marriage. The transferor spouse establishes a marital deduction trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse until his or her death, at which time the assets in the marital deduction trust are transferred to a QTIP trust for the benefit of the children.
According to TEXCOM, when the marital deduction trust savings statute was enacted in 1990, federal tax law was unsettled as to whether a surviving spouse’s estate had to receive income that was accrued or undistributed prior to the surviving spouse’s death to qualify a marital deduction trust for the estate tax marital deduction. TEXCOM asserts that the savings statute took the conservative approach to avoid inadvertent disqualification, and mandated distribution of such “stub” income (income accumulated between the last income payment and the surviving spouse’s death). TEXCOM notes that Section 21524(d) appears to be a relic that attempted to address the decision in Estate of Howard (1988) 91 T.C. No. 26, that a QTIP trust did not qualify for the estate tax marital deduction because the trust provisions did not provide for payment of accumulated income to the surviving spouse’s estate.
TEXCOM states that the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Estate of Howard v. Commr. (1990) 910 F.2d 633, ruled that an income interest does not fail to constitute a qualifying marital interest solely because undistributed income is not paid to the estate of the surviving spouse. TEXCOM argues that this case and subsequent acquiescence by the government effectively overrule Section 21524(d).
As such, TEXCOM contends that the law is now settled in the Ninth Circuit that a trust qualifies for the marital deduction without a mandatory distribution of that income. Additionally, TEXCOM argues that the UPIA provides for a default distribution of undistributed income to the beneficiary’s estate. Accordingly, this bill seeks to conform the marital deduction trust savings statute to current federal law by removing outdated limitations on qualified terminable interest property.
Staff notes that Probate Code Section 21521, which, in effect, defines the types of marital deduction trusts that require the application of the marital deduction trust savings statute, also appears to be outdated due to its cross-reference to a subdivision that no longer exists in the code of federal regulations. Accordingly, the author may wish to consider amending this bill to update the cross-reference to current federal law.
Support: None Known
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Executive Committee of the Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
AB 846 (Ackerman, Chapter 145, Statutes of 1999) enacted the Uniform Principal and Income Act, and, among other things, revised the cross-reference to the new Act under the marital deduction trust savings statute.
AB 759 (Friedman, Chapter 79, Statutes of 1990) revised and recast the Probate Code and, among other things, continued the marital deduction gifts and trust provisions under prior law.
**************
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):