SB 1329: Property taxation: certificated aircraft.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-05-31
Existing property tax law requires the personal property of an air carrier to be taxed at its fair market value, and the California Constitution requires property subject to ad valorem property taxation to be assessed in the county in which it is situated. Existing law, for the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 fiscal year, inclusive, specifies a formula to determine the fair market value of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, and rebuttably presumes that the amount determined pursuant to this formula is the fair market value of the certificated aircraft. Under existing law, the preallocated fair market value of certificated aircraft is the lesser of the original cost for the aircraft, calculated as specified, or the value of a used aircraft, determined as provided and reduced by 10% for a fleet discount or, for certain individual aircraft, the lesser of 5% or 1/2 of the percentage decrease between the original cost and 90% of the value, as specified. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, requires the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association to designate, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in an assessment year, and requires the lead county assessor to calculate the value of the air carriers personal property and to transmit these calculations to other county assessors, but specifies that each county assessor is responsible for assessing and enrolling the taxable value of the property in his or her county, as provided. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, also requires the lead county assessors office to lead a team to audit the books and records of commercial air carriers and requires a commercial air carrier that receives a notice of the designation of a lead county assessors office to file one signed property statement with the lead county assessors office for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
This bill would apply a similar formula for determining the fair market value of certificated aircraft for the 201718 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, but would not include the above-described 10% reduction for a fleet discount, and, for valuing individual aircraft, would instead provide that the value is the lesser of 5% or 1/2of the percentage decrease between the original cost and the full value, rather than between the original cost and 90% of the full value. The bill would extend the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2021, for the above-described provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law requires courts to give precedence to actions brought under provisions governing property taxes, with the exclusion of actions to recover taxes levied on state-assessed property, over all other civil actions, except actions to which special precedence is given by law.
This bill, until January 1, 2022, would additionally exclude from this requirement property tax refund proceedings for certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law provides, with respect to suits for refund of state-assessed taxes, that the trial court is not restricted to the administrative record, but is required to consider all relevant admissible evidence.
This bill, until January 1, 2022, would extend these provisions to property tax refund proceedings involving certificated aircraft that are filed on or after January 1, 2017.
This bill would extend the 201617 fiscal year termination date to the 201718 fiscal year and the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2017, for the above-described provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
By extending the application of the aforementioned valuation process for certificated aircraft beyond the 201617 fiscal year, thereby imposing new duties upon a lead county assessors office, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing property tax law requires the personal property of an air carrier to be taxed at its fair market value, and the California Constitution requires property subject to ad valorem property taxation to be assessed in the county in which it is situated. Existing law, for the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 fiscal year, inclusive, specifies a formula to determine the fair market value of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, and rebuttably presumes that the amount determined pursuant to this formula is the fair market value of the certificated aircraft. Under existing law, the preallocated fair market value of certificated aircraft is the lesser of the original cost for the aircraft, calculated as specified, or the value of a used aircraft, determined as provided and reduced by 10% for a fleet discount or, for certain individual aircraft, the lesser of 5% or 1/2 of the percentage decrease between the original cost and 90% of the value, as specified. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, requires the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association to designate, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in an assessment year, and requires the lead county assessor to calculate the value of the air carriers personal property and to transmit these calculations to other county assessors, but specifies that each county assessor is responsible for assessing and enrolling the taxable value of the property in his or her county, as provided. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, also requires the lead county assessors office to lead a team to audit the books and records of commercial air carriers and requires a commercial air carrier that receives a notice of the designation of a lead county assessors office to file one signed property statement with the lead county assessors office for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
This bill would apply a similar formula for determining the fair market value of certificated aircraft for the 201718 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, but would not include the above-described 10% reduction for a fleet discount, and, for valuing individual aircraft, would instead provide that the value is the lesser of 5% or 1/2of the percentage decrease between the original cost and the full value, rather than between the original cost and 90% of the full value. The bill would extend the 201617 fiscal year termination date to the 202122 fiscal year and the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2021, for the above-described provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law requires courts to give precedence to actions brought under provisions governing property taxes, with the exclusion of actions to recover taxes levied on state-assessed property, over all other civil actions, except actions to which special precedence is given by law.
This bill, until January 1, 2022, would additionally exclude from this requirement property tax refund proceedings for certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law provides, with respect to suits for refund of state-assessed taxes, that the trial court is not restricted to the administrative record, but is required to consider all relevant admissible evidence.
This bill, until January 1, 2022, would extend these provisions to property tax refund proceedings involving certificated aircraft. aircraft that are filed on or after January 1, 2017.
By extending the application of the aforementioned valuation process for certificated aircraft beyond the 201617 fiscal year, thereby imposing new duties upon a lead county assessors office, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing property tax law requires the personal property of an air carrier to be taxed at its fair market value, and the California Constitution requires property subject to ad valorem property taxation to be assessed in the county in which it is situated. Existing law, for the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 fiscal year, inclusive, specifies a formula to determine the fair market value of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, and rebuttably presumes that the amount determined pursuant to this formula is the fair market value of the certificated aircraft. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, requires the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association to designate, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in an assessment year, and requires the lead county assessor to calculate the value of the air carriers personal property and to transmit these calculations to other county assessors, but specifies that each county assessor is responsible for assessing and enrolling the taxable value of the property in his or her county, as provided. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, also requires the lead county assessors office to lead a team to audit the books and records of commercial air carriers and requires a commercial air carrier that receives a notice of the designation of a lead county assessors office to file one signed property statement with the lead county assessors office for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
This bill would extend the 201617 fiscal year termination date to an unspecified the 202122 fiscal year and the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to an unspecified date, December 31, 2021, for the above-described provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law provides, with respect to suits for refund of state-assessed taxes, that the trial court is not restricted to the administrative record, but is required to consider all relevant admissible evidence.
This bill, until an unspecified date, January 1, 2022, would extend these provisions to property tax refund proceedings involving certificated aircraft.
By extending the application of the aforementioned valuation process for certificated aircraft beyond the 201617 fiscal year, thereby imposing new duties upon a lead county assessors office, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing property tax law requires the personal property of an air carrier to be taxed at its fair market value, and the California Constitution requires property subject to ad valorem property taxation to be assessed in the county in which it is situated. Existing law, for the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 fiscal year, inclusive, specifies a formula to determine the fair market value of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, and rebuttably presumes that the amount determined pursuant to this formula is the fair market value of the certificated aircraft. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, requires the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association to designate, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in an assessment year, and requires the lead county assessor to calculate the value of the air carriers personal property and to transmit these calculations to other county assessors, but specifies that each county assessor is responsible for assessing and enrolling the taxable value of the property in his or her county, as provided. Existing law, until December 31, 2016, also requires the lead county assessors office to lead a team to audit the books and records of commercial air carriers and requires a commercial air carrier that receives a notice of the designation of a lead county assessors office to file one signed property statement with the lead county assessors office for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
This bill would extend the 201617 fiscal year termination date to an unspecified year and the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to an unspecified date, for the above-described provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
Existing property tax law provides, with respect to suits for refund of state-assessed taxes, that the trial court is not restricted to the administrative record, but is required to consider all relevant admissible evidence.
This bill, until an unspecified date, would extend these provisions to property tax refund proceedings involving certificated aircraft.
By extending the application of the aforementioned valuation process for certificated aircraft beyond the 201617 fiscal year, thereby imposing new duties upon a lead county assessors office, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
With respect to state-assessed property, existing property tax law establishes a procedure by which an assessee may petition the State Board of Equalization for reassessment of unitary or nonunitary property. Existing property tax law requires the board to mail to the assessee the notice of the time and place of a hearing on the petition and the decision on the petition. Existing property tax law requires the notice of the time and place of a hearing be sent at least 10 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
This bill would require the board to send these documents to the assessees electronic mail address if the assesee requests that they be sent by electronic mail. The bill would also require that notice of the time and place of the hearing instead be sent at least 15 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
With respect to state-assessed property, existing property tax law establishes a procedure by which an assessee may petition the State Board of Equalization for reassessment of unitary or nonunitary property. Existing property tax law requires the board to mail to the assessee the notice of the time and place of a hearing on the petition and the decision on the petition. Existing property tax law requires the notice of the time and place of a hearing be sent at least 10 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
This bill would require the board to send these documents to the assessees electronic mail address if the assesee requests that they be sent by electronic mail. The bill would also require that notice of the time and place of the hearing instead be sent at least 15 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
(a)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 201718 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, and regional aircraft that has attained situs within this state is the lesser of the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (1) or the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (2). The value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner of that aircraft shall not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. The preallocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by evidence including, but not limited to, appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
(1)(A)The original cost for the aircraft, which shall be determined as follows and adjusted, as applicable, under subparagraphs (B), (C), and (D):
(i)For owned and leased aircraft, the taxpayers or lessors acquisition cost for that individual aircraft reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and to the extent not included in the acquisition cost, transportation costs and capitalized interest and the cost of improvements made before a transaction described in clause (ii). If the original cost for leased aircraft cannot be determined from information reasonably available to the taxpayer, original cost may be determined by reference to the average new prices column of the Airliner Price Guide for that model, series, and year of manufacture of aircraft. If information is not available in the average new prices column for that model, series, and year, the original cost may be determined using the best indicator of original cost plus all conversion costs and improvement costs incurred for that aircraft.
(ii)For sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction aircraft, the average of the taxpayers cost established pursuant to clause (i) and the cost established in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction for individual aircraft that transfers the benefits and burdens of ownership to the lessor for United States federal income tax purposes. In no event shall the original cost for sale/leaseback aircraft be less than the taxpayers acquisition cost.
(iii)In the event of a merger, bankruptcy, or change in accounting methods by the reporting airline, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the cost of the individual aircraft and the acquisition date reported by the acquired company, if available, or the cost reported prior to the change in accounting method, are the original cost and the applicable acquisition date.
(B)(i)For mainline jets and production freighters, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 20-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(ii)For regional aircraft, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(iii)If original cost is determined by reference to the Airliner Price Guide average new prices column, the adjustments required by this paragraph shall be made by setting the acquisition date of the aircraft to be the date of the aircrafts manufacture.
(C)(i)For mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived pursuant to subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance which shall be determined as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments, weighted as follows:
(aa)Net revenue per available seat mile shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ab)Net load factor shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ac)Yield shall be weighted 30 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(D)(i)For production freighters, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived under subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance, as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the industry average of net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor based upon the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 preceding the relevant assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the calendar year utilized for the subject year, for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments so that the net revenue per available ton mile is weighted 50 percent and the ton load factor is weighted 50 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(2)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), for each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft, the assessor shall identify the value referenced in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide by make, model, series, and year of manufacture, and deduct 10 percent from that value for a fleet discount.
(B)For each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft that is less than two years old and for which the Airliner Price Guide does not list used wholesale values, the original cost determined under paragraph (1) of subparagraph (A) shall be decreased by the lesser of 5 percent or one-half of the percentage decrease between original cost and 90 percent of the value listed in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide for a two-year-old aircraft of that same make, model, and series.
(b)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 201718 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value for each make, model, and series of converted freighters that has attained situs within this state is the amount that is determined as follows:
(1)(A)The assessor shall begin his or her appraisal of a converted freighter as of the relevant lien date by identifying the aircrafts original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion. The aircrafts original cost as a converted freighter shall be the lesser of:
(i)Its trended original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(ii)Its value described in the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column in passenger configuration, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(B)The amount determined under subparagraph (A) shall be adjusted according to the following:
(i)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is 15 years old or more, 50 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(ii)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is less than 15 years old, 75 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(iii)In addition, all other improvements, including capitalized interest, to the aircraft that are not otherwise included in the aircrafts original and conversion costs shall be added at full value.
(2)The amount determined under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table, however, the percent-good applied to the aircraft shall in no event be less than 15 percent.
(3)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the relevant lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table. In no event, however, shall the percent-good applied to the improvements and adjusted conversion costs be less than 15 percent.
(4)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), the assessor shall reduce the adjusted original cost, plus improvements, and adjusted conversion costs, derived under paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, by the obsolescence percentage adjustment calculated for production freighters under subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(B)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be reduced by the obsolescence percentage adjustment described in subparagraph (A).
(c)For purposes of this section, if the Airliner Price Guide ceases to be published or the format significantly changes, a guide or adjustment agreed to by commercial air carriers and the counties in which certificated aircraft have situs shall be substituted. If these parties do not agree on a guide or adjustment, the State Board of Equalization shall determine the guide or adjustment.
(d)The taxpayer shall, to the extent that information is reasonably available to the taxpayer, furnish the county assessor with an annual property statement that includes the aircraft original costs as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). If an air carrier that has this information reasonably available to it fails to report original cost and improvements, as required by Sections 441 and 442, an assessor may in that case make an appropriate assessment pursuant to Section 501.
(e)For purposes of this section, all of the following apply:
(1)Converted freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that, following its original manufacture, was used for passenger transportation, but was later converted to be used primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(2)Mainline jet means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by Boeing, Airbus, or McDonnell Douglas.
(B)Capable of being configured with approximately 100 seats or more.
(3)Production Freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that immediately following its manufacture is deployed primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(4)Regional aircraft means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by ATR (Avions De Transport Regional), Beech, British Aerospace Jetstream, Canadair Regional Jet, Cessna, DeHaviland, Embraer, Fairchild, or Saab.
(B)Generally configured with fewer than 100 seats.
(5)Improvements means the cost of any modifications or capital additions that materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft, or make it adaptable to a different use. Improvements include modification costs incurred during a heavy maintenance visit to the extent that they materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft. Improvements do not include repair and maintenance costs incurred for the purpose of keeping the aircraft in an ordinarily efficient operating condition.
(6)Net revenue per available seat mile means operating revenue per available seat mile less cost per available seat mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(7)Net load factor means actual passenger load factor less break-even passenger load factor, as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(8)Net revenue per available ton mile means operating revenue per ton mile less cost per available ton mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(9)Yield means average revenue per revenue passenger mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(10)Ton Load Factor means that percentage of effective use of cargo capacity as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(f)The amendments made by the act adding this subdivision shall apply with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011.
SEC. 2.Section 441 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:441.(a)Each person owning taxable personal property, other than a manufactured home subject to Part 13 (commencing with Section 5800), having an aggregate cost of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or more for any assessment year shall file a signed property statement with the assessor. Every person owning personal property that does not require the filing of a property statement or real property shall, upon request of the assessor, file a signed property statement. Failure of the assessor to request or secure the property statement does not render any assessment invalid.
(b)The property statement shall be declared to be true under the penalty of perjury and filed annually with the assessor between the lien date and 5 p.m. on April 1. The penalty provided by Section 463 applies for property statements not filed by May 7. If May 7 falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, a property statement that is mailed and postmarked on the next business day shall be deemed to have been filed between the lien date and 5 p.m. on May 7. If, on the dates specified in this subdivision, the countys offices are closed for the entire day, that day is considered a legal holiday for purposes of this section.
(c)The property statement may be filed with the assessor through the United States mail, properly addressed with postage prepaid. For purposes of determining the date upon which the property statement is deemed filed with the assessor, the date of postmark as affixed by the United States Postal Service, or the date certified by a bona fide private courier service on the envelope containing the application, shall control. This subdivision shall be applicable to every taxing agency, including, but not limited to, a chartered city and county, or chartered city.
(d)(1)At any time, as required by the assessor for assessment purposes, every person shall make available for examination information or records regarding his or her property or any other personal property located on premises he or she owns or controls. In this connection details of property acquisition transactions, construction and development costs, rental income, and other data relevant to the determination of an estimate of value are to be considered as information essential to the proper discharge of the assessors duties.
(2)(A)This subdivision shall also apply to an owner-builder or an owner-developer of new construction that is sold to a third party, is constructed on behalf of a third party, or is constructed for the purpose of selling that property to a third party.
(B)The owner-builder or owner-developer of new construction described in subparagraph (A), shall, within 45 days of receipt of a written request by the assessor for information or records, provide the assessor with all information and records regarding that property. The information and records provided to the assessor shall include the total consideration provided either by the purchaser or on behalf of the purchaser that was paid or provided either, as part of or outside of the purchase agreement, including, but not limited to, consideration paid or provided for the purchase or acquisition of upgrades, additions, or for any other additional or supplemental work performed or arranged for by the owner-builder or owner-developer on behalf of the purchaser.
(e)In the case of a corporate owner of property, the property statement shall be signed either by an officer of the corporation or an employee or agent who has been designated in writing by the board of directors to sign the statements on behalf of the corporation.
(f)In the case of property owned by a bank or other financial institution and leased to an entity other than a bank or other financial institution, the property statement shall be submitted by the owner bank or other financial institution.
(g) The assessor may refuse to accept any property statement he or she determines to be in error.
(h)If a taxpayer fails to provide information to the assessor pursuant to subdivision (d) and introduces any requested materials or information at any assessment appeals board hearing, the assessor may request and shall be granted a continuance for a reasonable period of time. The continuance shall extend the two-year period specified in subdivision (c) of Section 1604 for a period of time equal to the period of the continuance.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, every person required to file a property statement pursuant to this section shall be permitted to amend that property statement until May 31 of the year in which the property statement is due, for errors and omissions not the result of willful intent to erroneously report. The penalty authorized by Section 463 does not apply to an amended statement received prior to May 31, provided the original statement is not subject to penalty pursuant to subdivision (b). The amended property statement shall otherwise conform to the requirements of a property statement as provided in this article.
(j)This subdivision shall apply to the oil, gas, and mineral extraction industry only. Any information that is necessary to file a true, correct, and complete statement shall be made available by the assessor, upon request, to the taxpayer by mail or at the office of the assessor by February 28. For each business day beyond February 28 that the information is unavailable, the filing deadline in subdivision (b) shall be extended in that county by one business day, for those statements affected by the delay. In no case shall the filing deadline be extended beyond June 1 or the first business day thereafter.
(k)The assessor may accept the filing of a property statement by the use of electronic media. In lieu of the signature required by subdivision (a) and the declaration under penalty of perjury required by subdivision (b), property statements filed using electronic media shall be authenticated pursuant to methods specified by the assessor and approved by the board. Electronic media includes, but is not limited to, computer modem, magnetic media, optical disk, and facsimile machine.
(l)(1)After receiving the notice required by Section 1162, the manager in control of a fleet of fractionally owned aircraft shall file with the lead county assessors office one signed property statement for all of its aircraft that have acquired situs in the state, as described in Section 1161.
(2)Flight data required to compute fractionally owned aircraft allocation under Section 1161 shall be segregated by airport.
(m)(1)After receiving the notice required by paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 1153.5, a commercial air carrier whose certificated aircraft is subject to Article 6 (commencing with Section 1150) of Chapter 5 shall file with the lead county assessors office designated under Section 1153.5 one signed property statement for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
(2)Each commercial air carrier may file one schedule for all of its certificated aircraft that have acquired situs in this state under Section 1151.
(3)Flight data required to compute certificated aircraft allocation under Section 1152 and subdivision (g) of Section 202 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations shall be segregated by airport location.
(4)Beginning with the 2006 assessment year, a commercial air carrier may file a statement described in this subdivision electronically by means of the California Assessors Standard Data Record (SDR) network. If the SDR is not equipped to accept electronic filings for the 2006 assessment year, an air carrier may file a printed version of its property statement for that year with its lead county assessors office.
(5)This subdivision shall remain operative only until December 31, 2016. 2017.
SEC. 3.Section 1153.5 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:1153.5.(a)The Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association shall, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, do both of the following:
(1)On or before March 1, 2006, and on or before each March 1 thereafter, designate a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in that assessment year.
(2)Every third year thereafter, redesignate a lead county assessors office for each of these air carriers, unless an air carrier and its existing lead county assessors office concur to waive this redesignation.
(b)The lead county assessors office described in subdivision (a) shall do all of the following:
(1)Calculate, pursuant to Section 401.17, an unallocated value of the certificated aircraft of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(2)Electronically transmit to the assessor of each county in which the property described in paragraph (1) has situs for the assessment year the values determined by the lead county assessors office under paragraph (1).
(3)Receive the property statement, as described in subdivision (l) (m) of Section 441, of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(4)Lead the audit team described in subdivision (d) when that team is conducting an audit of a commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(5)Notify, in writing, each commercial air carrier for which he or she has been designated of this designation on or before the first March 15 that follows that designation.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the county assessor of each county in which the personal property of a commercial air carrier has situs for an assessment year is solely responsible for assessing that property, applying the allocation formula set forth in Section 1152, and enrolling the value of the property in that county, but, in determining the unallocated fleet value for each make, model, and series of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, the assessor may consult with the lead county assessors office designated for that commercial air carrier.
(2)The lead county assessors office is subject to Section 322 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations and Sections 408, 451, and 1606 to the same extent as the assessor described in paragraph (1).
(d)Notwithstanding Section 469, an audit of a commercial air carrier shall be conducted once every four years on a centralized basis by an audit team of auditor-appraisers from at least one, but not more than three, counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association. An audit, so conducted, shall encompass all of the California Personal Property and fixtures of the air carrier and is deemed to be made on behalf of each county for which an audit would otherwise be required under Section 469.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, 2016, 2017, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as amended in the Senate, April 26, 2016. (JR11)(a)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, and regional aircraft that has attained situs within this state is the lesser of the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (1) or the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (2). The value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner of that aircraft shall not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. The preallocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by evidence including, but not limited to, appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
(1)(A)The original cost for the aircraft, which shall be determined as follows and adjusted, as applicable, under subparagraphs (B), (C), and (D):
(i)For owned and leased aircraft, the taxpayers or lessors acquisition cost for that individual aircraft reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and to the extent not included in the acquisition cost, transportation costs and capitalized interest and the cost of improvements made before a transaction described in clause (ii). If the original cost for leased aircraft cannot be determined from information reasonably available to the taxpayer, original cost may be determined by reference to the average new prices column of the Airliner Price Guide for that model, series, and year of manufacture of aircraft. If information is not available in the average new prices column for that model, series, and year, the original cost may be determined using the best indicator of original cost plus all conversion costs and improvement costs incurred for that aircraft.
(ii)For sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction aircraft, the average of the taxpayers cost established pursuant to clause (i) and the cost established in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction for individual aircraft that transfers the benefits and burdens of ownership to the lessor for United States federal income tax purposes. In no event shall the original cost for sale/leaseback aircraft be less than the taxpayers acquisition cost.
(iii)In the event of a merger, bankruptcy, or change in accounting methods by the reporting airline, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the cost of the individual aircraft and the acquisition date reported by the acquired company, if available, or the cost reported prior to the change in accounting method, are the original cost and the applicable acquisition date.
(B)(i)For mainline jets and production freighters, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 20-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(ii)For regional aircraft, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(iii)If original cost is determined by reference to the Airliner Price Guide average new prices column, the adjustments required by this paragraph shall be made by setting the acquisition date of the aircraft to be the date of the aircrafts manufacture.
(C)(i)For mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived pursuant to subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance which shall be determined as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments, weighted as follows:
(ia)Net revenue per available seat mile shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ib)Net load factor shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ic)Yield shall be weighted 30 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(D)(i)For production freighters, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived under subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance, as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the industry average of net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor based upon the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 preceding the relevant assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the calendar year utilized for the subject year, for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments so that the net revenue per available ton mile is weighted 50 percent and the ton load factor is weighted 50 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(2)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), for each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft, the assessor shall identify the value referenced in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide by make, model, series, and year of manufacture, and deduct 10 percent from that value for a fleet discount.
(B)For each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft that is less than two years old and for which the Airliner Price Guide does not list used wholesale values, the original cost determined under paragraph (1) of subparagraph (A) shall be decreased by the lesser of 5 percent or one-half of the percentage decrease between original cost and 90 percent of the value listed in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide for a two-year-old aircraft of that same make, model, and series.
(b)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value for each make, model, and series of converted freighters that has attained situs within this state is the amount that is determined as follows:
(1)(A)The assessor shall begin his or her appraisal of a converted freighter as of the relevant lien date by identifying the aircrafts original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion. The aircrafts original cost as a converted freighter shall be the lesser of:
(i)Its trended original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(ii)Its value described in the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column in passenger configuration, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(B)The amount determined under subparagraph (A) shall be adjusted according to the following:
(i)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is 15 years old or more, 50 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(ii)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is less than 15 years old, 75 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(iii)In addition, all other improvements, including capitalized interest, to the aircraft that are not otherwise included in the aircrafts original and conversion costs shall be added at full value.
(2)The amount determined under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table, however, the percent-good applied to the aircraft shall in no event be less than 15 percent.
(3)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the relevant lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table. In no event, however, shall the percent-good applied to the improvements and adjusted conversion costs be less than 15 percent.
(4)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), the assessor shall reduce the adjusted original cost, plus improvements, and adjusted conversion costs, derived under paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, by the obsolescence percentage adjustment calculated for production freighters under subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(B)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be reduced by the obsolescence percentage adjustment described in subparagraph (A).
(c)For purposes of this section, if the Airliner Price Guide ceases to be published or the format significantly changes, a guide or adjustment agreed to by commercial air carriers and the counties in which certificated aircraft have situs shall be substituted. If these parties do not agree on a guide or adjustment, the State Board of Equalization shall determine the guide or adjustment.
(d)The taxpayer shall, to the extent that information is reasonably available to the taxpayer, furnish the county assessor with an annual property statement that includes the aircraft original costs as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). If an air carrier that has this information reasonably available to it fails to report original cost and improvements, as required by Sections 441 and 442, an assessor may in that case make an appropriate assessment pursuant to Section 501.
(e)For purposes of this section, all of the following apply:
(1)Converted freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that, following its original manufacture, was used for passenger transportation, but was later converted to be used primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(2)Mainline jet means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by Boeing, Airbus, or McDonnell Douglas.
(B)Capable of being configured with approximately 100 seats or more.
(3)Production Freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that immediately following its manufacture is deployed primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(4)Regional aircraft means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by ATR (Avions De Transport Regional), Beech, British Aerospace Jetstream, Canadair Regional Jet, Cessna, DeHaviland, Embraer, Fairchild, or Saab.
(B)Generally configured with fewer than 100 seats.
(5)Improvements means the cost of any modifications or capital additions that materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft, or make it adaptable to a different use. Improvements include modification costs incurred during a heavy maintenance visit to the extent that they materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft. Improvements do not include repair and maintenance costs incurred for the purpose of keeping the aircraft in an ordinarily efficient operating condition.
(6)Net revenue per available seat mile means operating revenue per available seat mile less cost per available seat mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(7)Net load factor means actual passenger load factor less break-even passenger load factor, as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(8)Net revenue per available ton mile means operating revenue per ton mile less cost per available ton mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(9)Yield means average revenue per revenue passenger mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(10)Ton Load Factor means that percentage of effective use of cargo capacity as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(f)The amendments made by the act adding this subdivision shall apply with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011.
SECTION 1.Section 401.18 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:401.18.(a)For the 201718 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, and regional aircraft that has attained situs within this state is the lesser of the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (1) or the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (2). The value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner of that aircraft shall not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. The preallocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by evidence including, but not limited to, appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
(1)(A) The original cost for the aircraft, which shall be determined as follows and adjusted, as applicable, under subparagraphs (B), (C), and (D):
(i)For owned and leased aircraft, the taxpayers or lessors acquisition cost for that individual aircraft reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and to the extent not included in the acquisition cost, transportation costs and capitalized interest and the cost of improvements made before a transaction described in clause (ii). If the original cost for leased aircraft cannot be determined from information reasonably available to the taxpayer, original cost may be determined by reference to the average new prices column of the Airliner Price Guide for that model, series, and year of manufacture of aircraft. If information is not available in the average new prices column for that model, series, and year, the original cost may be determined using the best indicator of original cost plus all conversion costs and improvement costs incurred for that aircraft.
(ii)For sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction aircraft, the average of the taxpayers cost established pursuant to clause (i) and the cost established in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction for individual aircraft that transfers the benefits and burdens of ownership to the lessor for United States federal income tax purposes. In no event shall the original cost for sale/leaseback aircraft be less than the taxpayers acquisition cost.
(iii)In the event of a merger, bankruptcy, or change in accounting methods by the reporting airline, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the cost of the individual aircraft and the acquisition date reported by the acquired company, if available, or the cost reported prior to the change in accounting method, are the original cost and the applicable acquisition date.
(B)(i)For mainline jets and production freighters, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 20-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(ii)For regional aircraft, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(iii)If original cost is determined by reference to the Airliner Price Guide average new prices column, the adjustments required by this paragraph shall be made by setting the acquisition date of the aircraft to be the date of the aircrafts manufacture.
(C)(i) For mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived pursuant to subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance which shall be determined as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I) The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments, weighted as follows:
(aa)Net revenue per available seat mile shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ab)Net load factor shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ac)Yield shall be weighted 30 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(D)(i) For production freighters, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived under subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance, as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the industry average of net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor based upon the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 preceding the relevant assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the calendar year utilized for the subject year, for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I) The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments so that the net revenue per available ton mile is weighted 50 percent and the ton load factor is weighted 50 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(2)(A) Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), for each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft, the assessor shall identify the value referenced in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide by make, model, series, and year of manufacture.
(B)For each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft that is less than two years old and for which the Airliner Price Guide does not list used wholesale values, the original cost determined under paragraph (1) of subparagraph (A) shall be decreased by the lesser of 5 percent or one-half of the percentage decrease between original cost and the value listed in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide for a two-year-old aircraft of that same make, model, and series.
(b)For the 201718 fiscal year to the 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value for each make, model, and series of converted freighters that has attained situs within this state is the amount that is determined as follows:
(1)(A) The assessor shall begin his or her appraisal of a converted freighter as of the relevant lien date by identifying the aircrafts original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion. The aircrafts original cost as a converted freighter shall be the lesser of:
(i)Its trended original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(ii)Its value described in the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column in passenger configuration, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(B)The amount determined under subparagraph (A) shall be adjusted according to the following:
(i)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is 15 years old or more, 50 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(ii)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is less than 15 years old, 75 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(iii)In addition, all other improvements, including capitalized interest, to the aircraft that are not otherwise included in the aircrafts original and conversion costs shall be added at full value.
(2)The amount determined under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table, however, the percent-good applied to the aircraft shall in no event be less than 15 percent.
(3)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the relevant lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table. In no event, however, shall the percent-good applied to the improvements and adjusted conversion costs be less than 15 percent.
(4)(A) Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), the assessor shall reduce the adjusted original cost, plus improvements, and adjusted conversion costs, derived under paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, by the obsolescence percentage adjustment calculated for production freighters under subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(B)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be reduced by the obsolescence percentage adjustment described in subparagraph (A).
(c)For purposes of this section, if the Airliner Price Guide ceases to be published or the format significantly changes, a guide or adjustment agreed to by commercial air carriers and the counties in which certificated aircraft have situs shall be substituted. If these parties do not agree on a guide or adjustment, the State Board of Equalization shall determine the guide or adjustment.
(d)The taxpayer shall, to the extent that information is reasonably available to the taxpayer, furnish the county assessor with an annual property statement that includes the aircraft original costs as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). If an air carrier that has this information reasonably available to it fails to report original cost and improvements, as required by Sections 441 and 442, an assessor may in that case make an appropriate assessment pursuant to Section 501.
(e)For purposes of this section, all of the following apply:
(1)Converted freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that, following its original manufacture, was used for passenger transportation, but was later converted to be used primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(2)Mainline jet means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by Boeing, Airbus, or McDonnell Douglas.
(B)Capable of being configured with approximately 100 seats or more.
(3)Production Freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that immediately following its manufacture is deployed primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(4)Regional aircraft means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by ATR (Avions De Transport Regional), Beech, British Aerospace Jetstream, Canadair Regional Jet, Cessna, DeHaviland, Embraer, Fairchild, or Saab.
(B)Generally configured with fewer than 100 seats.
(5)Improvements means the cost of any modifications or capital additions that materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft, or make it adaptable to a different use. Improvements include modification costs incurred during a heavy maintenance visit to the extent that they materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft. Improvements do not include repair and maintenance costs incurred for the purpose of keeping the aircraft in an ordinarily efficient operating condition.
(6)Net revenue per available seat mile means operating revenue per available seat mile less cost per available seat mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(7)Net load factor means actual passenger load factor less break-even passenger load factor, as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(8)Net revenue per available ton mile means operating revenue per ton mile less cost per available ton mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(9)Yield means average revenue per revenue passenger mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(10)Ton Load Factor means that percentage of effective use of cargo capacity as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
SEC. 2.Section 441 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:441.(a)Each person owning taxable personal property, other than a manufactured home subject to Part 13 (commencing with Section 5800), having an aggregate cost of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or more for any assessment year shall file a signed property statement with the assessor. Every person owning personal property that does not require the filing of a property statement or real property shall, upon request of the assessor, file a signed property statement. Failure of the assessor to request or secure the property statement does not render any assessment invalid.
(b)The property statement shall be declared to be true under the penalty of perjury and filed annually with the assessor between the lien date and 5 p.m. on April 1. The penalty provided by Section 463 applies for property statements not filed by May 7. If May 7 falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, a property statement that is mailed and postmarked on the next business day shall be deemed to have been filed between the lien date and 5 p.m. on May 7. If, on the dates specified in this subdivision, the countys offices are closed for the entire day, that day is considered a legal holiday for purposes of this section.
(c)The property statement may be filed with the assessor through the United States mail, properly addressed with postage prepaid. For purposes of determining the date upon which the property statement is deemed filed with the assessor, the date of postmark as affixed by the United States Postal Service, or the date certified by a bona fide private courier service on the envelope containing the application, shall control. This subdivision shall be applicable to every taxing agency, including, but not limited to, a chartered city and county, or chartered city.
(d)(1)At any time, as required by the assessor for assessment purposes, every person shall make available for examination information or records regarding his or her property or any other personal property located on premises he or she owns or controls. In this connection details of property acquisition transactions, construction and development costs, rental income, and other data relevant to the determination of an estimate of value are to be considered as information essential to the proper discharge of the assessors duties.
(2)(A)This subdivision shall also apply to an owner-builder or an owner-developer of new construction that is sold to a third party, is constructed on behalf of a third party, or is constructed for the purpose of selling that property to a third party.
(B)The owner-builder or owner-developer of new construction described in subparagraph (A), shall, within 45 days of receipt of a written request by the assessor for information or records, provide the assessor with all information and records regarding that property. The information and records provided to the assessor shall include the total consideration provided either by the purchaser or on behalf of the purchaser that was paid or provided either, as part of or outside of the purchase agreement, including, but not limited to, consideration paid or provided for the purchase or acquisition of upgrades, additions, or for any other additional or supplemental work performed or arranged for by the owner-builder or owner-developer on behalf of the purchaser.
(e)In the case of a corporate owner of property, the property statement shall be signed either by an officer of the corporation or an employee or agent who has been designated in writing by the board of directors to sign the statements on behalf of the corporation.
(f)In the case of property owned by a bank or other financial institution and leased to an entity other than a bank or other financial institution, the property statement shall be submitted by the owner bank or other financial institution.
(g) The assessor may refuse to accept any property statement he or she determines to be in error.
(h)If a taxpayer fails to provide information to the assessor pursuant to subdivision (d) and introduces any requested materials or information at any assessment appeals board hearing, the assessor may request and shall be granted a continuance for a reasonable period of time. The continuance shall extend the two-year period specified in subdivision (c) of Section 1604 for a period of time equal to the period of the continuance.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, every person required to file a property statement pursuant to this section shall be permitted to amend that property statement until May 31 of the year in which the property statement is due, for errors and omissions not the result of willful intent to erroneously report. The penalty authorized by Section 463 does not apply to an amended statement received prior to May 31, provided the original statement is not subject to penalty pursuant to subdivision (b). The amended property statement shall otherwise conform to the requirements of a property statement as provided in this article.
(j)This subdivision shall apply to the oil, gas, and mineral extraction industry only. Any information that is necessary to file a true, correct, and complete statement shall be made available by the assessor, upon request, to the taxpayer by mail or at the office of the assessor by February 28. For each business day beyond February 28 that the information is unavailable, the filing deadline in subdivision (b) shall be extended in that county by one business day, for those statements affected by the delay. In no case shall the filing deadline be extended beyond June 1 or the first business day thereafter.
(k)The assessor may accept the filing of a property statement by the use of electronic media. In lieu of the signature required by subdivision (a) and the declaration under penalty of perjury required by subdivision (b), property statements filed using electronic media shall be authenticated pursuant to methods specified by the assessor and approved by the board. Electronic media includes, but is not limited to, computer modem, magnetic media, optical disk, and facsimile machine.
(l)(1)After receiving the notice required by Section 1162, the manager in control of a fleet of fractionally owned aircraft shall file with the lead county assessors office one signed property statement for all of its aircraft that have acquired situs in the state, as described in Section 1161.
(2)Flight data required to compute fractionally owned aircraft allocation under Section 1161 shall be segregated by airport.
(m)(1)After receiving the notice required by paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 1153.5, a commercial air carrier whose certificated aircraft is subject to Article 6 (commencing with Section 1150) of Chapter 5 shall file with the lead county assessors office designated under Section 1153.5 one signed property statement for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
(2)Each commercial air carrier may file one schedule for all of its certificated aircraft that have acquired situs in this state under Section 1151.
(3)Flight data required to compute certificated aircraft allocation under Section 1152 and subdivision (g) of Section 202 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations shall be segregated by airport location.
(4)Beginning with the 2006 assessment year, a commercial air carrier may file a statement described in this subdivision electronically by means of the California Assessors Standard Data Record (SDR) network. If the SDR is not equipped to accept electronic filings for the 2006 assessment year, an air carrier may file a printed version of its property statement for that year with its lead county assessors office.
(5)This subdivision shall remain operative only until December 31, 2021.
SEC. 3.Section 1153.5 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:1153.5.(a)The Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association shall, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, do both of the following:
(1)On or before March 1, 2006, and on or before each March 1 thereafter, designate a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in that assessment year.
(2)Every third year thereafter, redesignate a lead county assessors office for each of these air carriers, unless an air carrier and its existing lead county assessors office concur to waive this redesignation.
(b)The lead county assessors office described in subdivision (a) shall do all of the following:
(1)Calculate, pursuant to Section 401.17, 401.18, an unallocated value of the certificated aircraft of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(2)Electronically transmit to the assessor of each county in which the property described in paragraph (1) has situs for the assessment year the values determined by the lead county assessors office under paragraph (1).
(3)Receive the property statement, as described in subdivision (m) of Section 441, of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(4)Lead the audit team described in subdivision (d) when that team is conducting an audit of a commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(5)Notify, in writing, each commercial air carrier for which he or she has been designated of this designation on or before the first March 15 that follows that designation.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the county assessor of each county in which the personal property of a commercial air carrier has situs for an assessment year is solely responsible for assessing that property, applying the allocation formula set forth in Section 1152, and enrolling the value of the property in that county, but, in determining the unallocated fleet value for each make, model, and series of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, the assessor may consult with the lead county assessors office designated for that commercial air carrier.
(2)The lead county assessors office is subject to Section 322 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations and Sections 408, 451, and 1606 to the same extent as the assessor described in paragraph (1).
(d)Notwithstanding Section 469, an audit of a commercial air carrier shall be conducted once every four years on a centralized basis by an audit team of auditor-appraisers from at least one, but not more than three, counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association. An audit, so conducted, shall encompass all of the California Personal Property and fixtures of the air carrier and is deemed to be made on behalf of each county for which an audit would otherwise be required under Section 469.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, 2021, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 5149 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:5149.(a)All courts wherein actions brought under this part (with the exclusion of actions brought under Section 5148) 5148 or actions for refund of locally-assessed property taxes valued under Section 1153.5 or a successor section) are or hereafter may be pending shall give those actions precedence over all other civil actions therein, except actions to which special precedence is given by law, in the matter of setting same for hearing or trial, and in hearing the same, to the end that all those actions shall be quickly heard and determined.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 5149 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:5149.(a)All courts wherein actions brought under this part (with the exclusion of actions brought under Section 5148) are or hereafter may be pending shall give those actions precedence over all other civil actions therein, except actions to which special precedence is given by law, in the matter of setting same for hearing or trial, and in hearing the same, to the end that all those actions shall be quickly heard and determined.
(b)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2022.
SEC. 4.SEC. 6.Section 5170 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes and taxes, or suits for the refund of locally assessed property taxes on property valued under Section 1153.5 or a successor section, section that are filed on or after January 1, 2017, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.SEC. 7.Section 5170 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2022.
SEC. 6.SEC. 8.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)For the 200506 fiscal year to the____ 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, and regional aircraft that has attained situs within this state is the lesser of the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (1) or the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (2). The value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner of that aircraft shall not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. The preallocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by evidence including, but not limited to, appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
(1)(A)The original cost for the aircraft, which shall be determined as follows and adjusted, as applicable, under subparagraphs (B), (C), and (D):
(i)For owned and leased aircraft, the taxpayers or lessors acquisition cost for that individual aircraft reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and to the extent not included in the acquisition cost, transportation costs and capitalized interest and the cost of improvements made before a transaction described in clause (ii). If the original cost for leased aircraft cannot be determined from information reasonably available to the taxpayer, original cost may be determined by reference to the average new prices column of the Airliner Price Guide for that model, series, and year of manufacture of aircraft. If information is not available in the average new prices column for that model, series, and year, the original cost may be determined using the best indicator of original cost plus all conversion costs and improvement costs incurred for that aircraft.
(ii)For sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction aircraft, the average of the taxpayers cost established pursuant to clause (i) and the cost established in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction for individual aircraft that transfers the benefits and burdens of ownership to the lessor for United States federal income tax purposes. In no event shall the original cost for sale/leaseback aircraft be less than the taxpayers acquisition cost.
(iii)In the event of a merger, bankruptcy, or change in accounting methods by the reporting airline, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the cost of the individual aircraft and the acquisition date reported by the acquired company, if available, or the cost reported prior to the change in accounting method, are the original cost and the applicable acquisition date.
(B)(i)For mainline jets and production freighters, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 20-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(ii)For regional aircraft, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(iii)If original cost is determined by reference to the Airliner Price Guide average new prices column, the adjustments required by this paragraph shall be made by setting the acquisition date of the aircraft to be the date of the aircrafts manufacture.
(C)(i)For mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived pursuant to subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance which shall be determined as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments, weighted as follows:
(ia)Net revenue per available seat mile shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ib)Net load factor shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ic)Yield shall be weighted 30 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(D)(i)For production freighters, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived under subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance, as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the industry average of net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor based upon the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 preceding the relevant assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the calendar year utilized for the subject year, for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments so that the net revenue per available ton mile is weighted 50 percent and the ton load factor is weighted 50 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(2)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), for each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft, the assessor shall identify the value referenced in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide by make, model, series, and year of manufacture, and deduct 10 percent from that value for a fleet discount.
(B)For each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft that is less than two years old and for which the Airliner Price Guide does not list used wholesale values, the original cost determined under paragraph (1) of subparagraph (A) shall be decreased by the lesser of 5 percent or one-half of the percentage decrease between original cost and 90 percent of the value listed in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide for a two-year-old aircraft of that same make, model, and series.
(b)For the 200506 fiscal year to the ___ 202122 fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value for each make, model, and series of converted freighters that has attained situs within this state is the amount that is determined as follows:
(1)(A)The assessor shall begin his or her appraisal of a converted freighter as of the relevant lien date by identifying the aircrafts original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion. The aircrafts original cost as a converted freighter shall be the lesser of:
(i)Its trended original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(ii)Its value described in the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column in passenger configuration, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(B)The amount determined under subparagraph (A) shall be adjusted according to the following:
(i)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is 15 years old or more, 50 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(ii)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is less than 15 years old, 75 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(iii)In addition, all other improvements, including capitalized interest, to the aircraft that are not otherwise included in the aircrafts original and conversion costs shall be added at full value.
(2)The amount determined under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table, however, the percent-good applied to the aircraft shall in no event be less than 15 percent.
(3)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the relevant lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table. In no event, however, shall the percent-good applied to the improvements and adjusted conversion costs be less than 15 percent.
(4)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), the assessor shall reduce the adjusted original cost, plus improvements, and adjusted conversion costs, derived under paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, by the obsolescence percentage adjustment calculated for production freighters under subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(B)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be reduced by the obsolescence percentage adjustment described in subparagraph (A).
(c)For purposes of this section, if the Airliner Price Guide ceases to be published or the format significantly changes, a guide or adjustment agreed to by commercial air carriers and the counties in which certificated aircraft have situs shall be substituted. If these parties do not agree on a guide or adjustment, the State Board of Equalization shall determine the guide or adjustment.
(d)The taxpayer shall, to the extent that information is reasonably available to the taxpayer, furnish the county assessor with an annual property statement that includes the aircraft original costs as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). If an air carrier that has this information reasonably available to it fails to report original cost and improvements, as required by Sections 441 and 442, an assessor may in that case make an appropriate assessment pursuant to Section 501.
(e)For purposes of this section, all of the following apply:
(1)Converted freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that, following its original manufacture, was used for passenger transportation, but was later converted to be used primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(2)Mainline jet means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by Boeing, Airbus, or McDonnell Douglas.
(B)Capable of being configured with approximately 100 seats or more.
(3)Production Freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that immediately following its manufacture is deployed primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(4)Regional aircraft means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by ATR (Avions De Transport Regional), Beech, British Aerospace Jetstream, Canadair Regional Jet, Cessna, DeHaviland, Embraer, Fairchild, or Saab.
(B)Generally configured with fewer than 100 seats.
(5)Improvements means the cost of any modifications or capital additions that materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft, or make it adaptable to a different use. Improvements include modification costs incurred during a heavy maintenance visit to the extent that they materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft. Improvements do not include repair and maintenance costs incurred for the purpose of keeping the aircraft in an ordinarily efficient operating condition.
(6)Net revenue per available seat mile means operating revenue per available seat mile less cost per available seat mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(7)Net load factor means actual passenger load factor less break-even passenger load factor, as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(8)Net revenue per available ton mile means operating revenue per ton mile less cost per available ton mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(9)Yield means average revenue per revenue passenger mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(10)Ton Load Factor means that percentage of effective use of cargo capacity as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(f)The amendments made by the act adding this subdivision shall apply with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011.
SEC. 2.Section 441 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:441.(a)Each person owning taxable personal property, other than a manufactured home subject to Part 13 (commencing with Section 5800), having an aggregate cost of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or more for any assessment year shall file a signed property statement with the assessor. Every person owning personal property that does not require the filing of a property statement or real property shall, upon request of the assessor, file a signed property statement. Failure of the assessor to request or secure the property statement does not render any assessment invalid.
(b)The property statement shall be declared to be true under the penalty of perjury and filed annually with the assessor between the lien date and 5 p.m. on April 1. The penalty provided by Section 463 applies for property statements not filed by May 7. If May 7 falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, a property statement that is mailed and postmarked on the next business day shall be deemed to have been filed between the lien date and 5 p.m. on May 7. If, on the dates specified in this subdivision, the countys offices are closed for the entire day, that day is considered a legal holiday for purposes of this section.
(c)The property statement may be filed with the assessor through the United States mail, properly addressed with postage prepaid. For purposes of determining the date upon which the property statement is deemed filed with the assessor, the date of postmark as affixed by the United States Postal Service, or the date certified by a bona fide private courier service on the envelope containing the application, shall control. This subdivision shall be applicable to every taxing agency, including, but not limited to, a chartered city and county, or chartered city.
(d)(1)At any time, as required by the assessor for assessment purposes, every person shall make available for examination information or records regarding his or her property or any other personal property located on premises he or she owns or controls. In this connection details of property acquisition transactions, construction and development costs, rental income, and other data relevant to the determination of an estimate of value are to be considered as information essential to the proper discharge of the assessors duties.
(2)(A)This subdivision shall also apply to an owner-builder or an owner-developer of new construction that is sold to a third party, is constructed on behalf of a third party, or is constructed for the purpose of selling that property to a third party.
(B)The owner-builder or owner-developer of new construction described in subparagraph (A), shall, within 45 days of receipt of a written request by the assessor for information or records, provide the assessor with all information and records regarding that property. The information and records provided to the assessor shall include the total consideration provided either by the purchaser or on behalf of the purchaser that was paid or provided either, as part of or outside of the purchase agreement, including, but not limited to, consideration paid or provided for the purchase or acquisition of upgrades, additions, or for any other additional or supplemental work performed or arranged for by the owner-builder or owner-developer on behalf of the purchaser.
(e)In the case of a corporate owner of property, the property statement shall be signed either by an officer of the corporation or an employee or agent who has been designated in writing by the board of directors to sign the statements on behalf of the corporation.
(f)In the case of property owned by a bank or other financial institution and leased to an entity other than a bank or other financial institution, the property statement shall be submitted by the owner bank or other financial institution.
(g) The assessor may refuse to accept any property statement he or she determines to be in error.
(h)If a taxpayer fails to provide information to the assessor pursuant to subdivision (d) and introduces any requested materials or information at any assessment appeals board hearing, the assessor may request and shall be granted a continuance for a reasonable period of time. The continuance shall extend the two-year period specified in subdivision (c) of Section 1604 for a period of time equal to the period of the continuance.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, every person required to file a property statement pursuant to this section shall be permitted to amend that property statement until May 31 of the year in which the property statement is due, for errors and omissions not the result of willful intent to erroneously report. The penalty authorized by Section 463 does not apply to an amended statement received prior to May 31, provided the original statement is not subject to penalty pursuant to subdivision (b). The amended property statement shall otherwise conform to the requirements of a property statement as provided in this article.
(j)This subdivision shall apply to the oil, gas, and mineral extraction industry only. Any information that is necessary to file a true, correct, and complete statement shall be made available by the assessor, upon request, to the taxpayer by mail or at the office of the assessor by February 28. For each business day beyond February 28 that the information is unavailable, the filing deadline in subdivision (b) shall be extended in that county by one business day, for those statements affected by the delay. In no case shall the filing deadline be extended beyond June 1 or the first business day thereafter.
(k)The assessor may accept the filing of a property statement by the use of electronic media. In lieu of the signature required by subdivision (a) and the declaration under penalty of perjury required by subdivision (b), property statements filed using electronic media shall be authenticated pursuant to methods specified by the assessor and approved by the board. Electronic media includes, but is not limited to, computer modem, magnetic media, optical disk, and facsimile machine.
(l)(1)After receiving the notice required by Section 1162, the manager in control of a fleet of fractionally owned aircraft shall file with the lead county assessors office one signed property statement for all of its aircraft that have acquired situs in the state, as described in Section 1161.
(2)Flight data required to compute fractionally owned aircraft allocation under Section 1161 shall be segregated by airport.
(m)(1)After receiving the notice required by paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 1153.5, a commercial air carrier whose certificated aircraft is subject to Article 6 (commencing with Section 1150) of Chapter 5 shall file with the lead county assessors office designated under Section 1153.5 one signed property statement for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
(2)Each commercial air carrier may file one schedule for all of its certificated aircraft that have acquired situs in this state under Section 1151.
(3)Flight data required to compute certificated aircraft allocation under Section 1152 and subdivision (g) of Section 202 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations shall be segregated by airport location.
(4)Beginning with the 2006 assessment year, a commercial air carrier may file a statement described in this subdivision electronically by means of the California Assessors Standard Data Record (SDR) network. If the SDR is not equipped to accept electronic filings for the 2006 assessment year, an air carrier may file a printed version of its property statement for that year with its lead county assessors office.
(5)This subdivision shall remain operative only until December 31, ___. 2021.
SEC. 3.Section 1153.5 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:1153.5.(a)The Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association shall, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, do both of the following:
(1)On or before March 1, 2006, and on or before each March 1 thereafter, designate a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in that assessment year.
(2)Every third year thereafter, redesignate a lead county assessors office for each of these air carriers, unless an air carrier and its existing lead county assessors office concur to waive this redesignation.
(b)The lead county assessors office described in subdivision (a) shall do all of the following:
(1)Calculate, pursuant to Section 401.17, an unallocated value of the certificated aircraft of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(2)Electronically transmit to the assessor of each county in which the property described in paragraph (1) has situs for the assessment year the values determined by the lead county assessors office under paragraph (1).
(3)Receive the property statement, as described in subdivision (m) of Section 441, of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(4)Lead the audit team described in subdivision (d) when that team is conducting an audit of a commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(5)Notify, in writing, each commercial air carrier for which he or she has been designated of this designation on or before the first March 15 that follows that designation.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the county assessor of each county in which the personal property of a commercial air carrier has situs for an assessment year is solely responsible for assessing that property, applying the allocation formula set forth in Section 1152, and enrolling the value of the property in that county, but, in determining the unallocated fleet value for each make, model, and series of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, the assessor may consult with the lead county assessors office designated for that commercial air carrier.
(2)The lead county assessors office is subject to Section 322 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations and Sections 408, 451, and 1606 to the same extent as the assessor described in paragraph (1).
(d)Notwithstanding Section 469, an audit of a commercial air carrier shall be conducted once every four years on a centralized basis by an audit team of auditor-appraisers from at least one, but not more than three, counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association. An audit, so conducted, shall encompass all of the California Personal Property and fixtures of the air carrier and is deemed to be made on behalf of each county for which an audit would otherwise be required under Section 469.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, ___, 2021, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 5170 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes and locally assessed property taxes on property valued under Section 1153.5 or a successor section, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, ___, January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 5170 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall become operative on January 1, ___. 2022.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617____ fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, and regional aircraft that has attained situs within this state is the lesser of the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (1) or the sum total of the amounts determined under paragraph (2). The value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner of that aircraft shall not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. The preallocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by evidence including, but not limited to, appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
(1)(A)The original cost for the aircraft, which shall be determined as follows and adjusted, as applicable, under subparagraphs (B), (C), and (D):
(i)For owned and leased aircraft, the taxpayers or lessors acquisition cost for that individual aircraft reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and to the extent not included in the acquisition cost, transportation costs and capitalized interest and the cost of improvements made before a transaction described in clause (ii). If the original cost for leased aircraft cannot be determined from information reasonably available to the taxpayer, original cost may be determined by reference to the average new prices column of the Airliner Price Guide for that model, series, and year of manufacture of aircraft. If information is not available in the average new prices column for that model, series, and year, the original cost may be determined using the best indicator of original cost plus all conversion costs and improvement costs incurred for that aircraft.
(ii)For sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction aircraft, the average of the taxpayers cost established pursuant to clause (i) and the cost established in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction for individual aircraft that transfers the benefits and burdens of ownership to the lessor for United States federal income tax purposes. In no event shall the original cost for sale/leaseback aircraft be less than the taxpayers acquisition cost.
(iii)In the event of a merger, bankruptcy, or change in accounting methods by the reporting airline, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the cost of the individual aircraft and the acquisition date reported by the acquired company, if available, or the cost reported prior to the change in accounting method, are the original cost and the applicable acquisition date.
(B)(i)For mainline jets and production freighters, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 20-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(ii)For regional aircraft, the original cost described in subparagraph (A), plus the cost of any improvements not otherwise included in the original cost, shall be adjusted from the date of the acquisition of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table starting from the delivery date of the aircraft to the current owner or, in the case of a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights transaction, as described in this section, the current operator with a minimum combined factor of 25 percent.
(iii)If original cost is determined by reference to the Airliner Price Guide average new prices column, the adjustments required by this paragraph shall be made by setting the acquisition date of the aircraft to be the date of the aircrafts manufacture.
(C)(i)For mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived pursuant to subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance which shall be determined as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the average annual net revenue per available seat mile, the net load factor, and the yield utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the passenger airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Pax. Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments, weighted as follows:
(aa)
(ia)Net revenue per available seat mile shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ab)
(ib)Net load factor shall be weighted 35 percent.
(ac)
(ic)Yield shall be weighted 30 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(D)(i)For production freighters, the assessor shall analyze the adjusted original cost derived under subparagraph (B), for application of an economic obsolescence allowance, as follows:
(I)For the applicable year, the assessor shall calculate the industry average of net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor based upon the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation, and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors for the calendar year ending December 31 preceding the relevant assessment date.
(II)For a 10-year benchmark, the assessor shall calculate as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the applicable year, the net revenue per available ton mile and the ton load factor utilizing the Airline Quarterly Financial Review published by the United States Department of Transportation and referring to the section descriptive of the cargo airline industry, entitled System Operations, System Cargo Majors as of December 31 for each of the 10 calendar years preceding the calendar year utilized for the subject year, for the calendar year ending December 31 immediately preceding the applicable assessment date.
(ii)(I)The assessor shall compare each factor calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) with the corresponding factor calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i) to derive the percentage that each of the factors calculated under subclause (I) of clause (i) deviated from the 10-year benchmark calculated under subclause (II) of clause (i). The assessor shall then calculate a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments so that the net revenue per available ton mile is weighted 50 percent and the ton load factor is weighted 50 percent.
(II)The assessor shall reduce the adjusted original costs derived under subparagraph (B) by the percentage adjustment calculated in subclause (I), but only if the final economic obsolescence determined under that subclause exceeds 10 percent, otherwise no economic obsolescence allowance shall be provided.
(2)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), for each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft, the assessor shall identify the value referenced in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide by make, model, series, and year of manufacture, and deduct 10 percent from that value for a fleet discount.
(B)For each individual mainline jet, production freighter, or regional aircraft that is less than two years old and for which the Airliner Price Guide does not list used wholesale values, the original cost determined under paragraph (1) of subparagraph (A) shall be decreased by the lesser of 5 percent or one-half of the percentage decrease between original cost and 90 percent of the value listed in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column of the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide for a two-year-old aircraft of that same make, model, and series.
(b)For the 200506 fiscal year to the 201617 ___ fiscal year, inclusive, it shall be rebuttably presumed that the preallocated fair market value for each make, model, and series of converted freighters that has attained situs within this state is the amount that is determined as follows:
(1)(A)The assessor shall begin his or her appraisal of a converted freighter as of the relevant lien date by identifying the aircrafts original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion. The aircrafts original cost as a converted freighter shall be the lesser of:
(i)Its trended original cost as a passenger aircraft prior to conversion, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(ii)Its value described in the Winter edition of the Airliner Price Guide in the Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale column in passenger configuration, less a downward adjustment of 10 percent to reflect tear-outs.
(B)The amount determined under subparagraph (A) shall be adjusted according to the following:
(i)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is 15 years old or more, 50 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(ii)If, on the relevant lien date, the frame of the aircraft is less than 15 years old, 75 percent of the cost to convert the aircraft to a freighter shall be added to the value determined under subparagraph (A).
(iii)In addition, all other improvements, including capitalized interest, to the aircraft that are not otherwise included in the aircrafts original and conversion costs shall be added at full value.
(2)The amount determined under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table, however, the percent-good applied to the aircraft shall in no event be less than 15 percent.
(3)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be adjusted from the date of the conversion of the aircraft to the relevant lien date using the monthly United States Department of Labor Producer Price Index for aircraft and a 16-year straight-line percent-good table. In no event, however, shall the percent-good applied to the improvements and adjusted conversion costs be less than 15 percent.
(4)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (B), the assessor shall reduce the adjusted original cost, plus improvements, and adjusted conversion costs, derived under paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, by the obsolescence percentage adjustment calculated for production freighters under subparagraph (D) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(B)If the Airliner Price Guide Used Price of Avg. Acft. Wholesale is utilized under paragraph (1), only the improvements and adjusted conversion costs pertaining to the converted freighter shall be reduced by the obsolescence percentage adjustment described in subparagraph (A).
(c)For purposes of this section, if the Airliner Price Guide ceases to be published or the format significantly changes, a guide or adjustment agreed to by commercial air carriers and the counties in which certificated aircraft have situs shall be substituted. If these parties do not agree on a guide or adjustment, the State Board of Equalization shall determine the guide or adjustment.
(d)The taxpayer shall, to the extent that information is reasonably available to the taxpayer, furnish the county assessor with an annual property statement that includes the aircraft original costs as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). If an air carrier that has this information reasonably available to it fails to report original cost and improvements, as required by Sections 441 and 442, an assessor may in that case make an appropriate assessment pursuant to Section 501.
(e)For purposes of this section, all of the following apply:
(1)Converted freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that, following its original manufacture, was used for passenger transportation, but was later converted to be used primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(2)Mainline jet means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by Boeing, Airbus, or McDonnell Douglas.
(B)Capable of being configured with approximately 100 seats or more.
(3)Production Freighter means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that immediately following its manufacture is deployed primarily for cargo transportation purposes.
(4)Regional aircraft means a certificated aircraft, as defined in Section 1150, that is either of the following:
(A)Manufactured by ATR (Avions De Transport Regional), Beech, British Aerospace Jetstream, Canadair Regional Jet, Cessna, DeHaviland, Embraer, Fairchild, or Saab.
(B)Generally configured with fewer than 100 seats.
(5)Improvements means the cost of any modifications or capital additions that materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft, or make it adaptable to a different use. Improvements include modification costs incurred during a heavy maintenance visit to the extent that they materially add to the value of or substantially prolong the useful life of the aircraft. Improvements do not include repair and maintenance costs incurred for the purpose of keeping the aircraft in an ordinarily efficient operating condition.
(6)Net revenue per available seat mile means operating revenue per available seat mile less cost per available seat mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(7)Net load factor means actual passenger load factor less break-even passenger load factor, as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(8)Net revenue per available ton mile means operating revenue per ton mile less cost per available ton mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(9)Yield means average revenue per revenue passenger mile as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(10)Ton Load Factor means that percentage of effective use of cargo capacity as determined by the United States Department of Transportation.
(f)The amendments made by the act adding this subdivision shall apply with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011.
SEC. 2.Section 441 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:441.(a)Each person owning taxable personal property, other than a manufactured home subject to Part 13 (commencing with Section 5800), having an aggregate cost of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or more for any assessment year shall file a signed property statement with the assessor. Every person owning personal property that does not require the filing of a property statement or real property shall, upon request of the assessor, file a signed property statement. Failure of the assessor to request or secure the property statement does not render any assessment invalid.
(b)The property statement shall be declared to be true under the penalty of perjury and filed annually with the assessor between the lien date and 5 p.m. on April 1. The penalty provided by Section 463 applies for property statements not filed by May 7. If May 7 falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, a property statement that is mailed and postmarked on the next business day shall be deemed to have been filed between the lien date and 5 p.m. on May 7. If, on the dates specified in this subdivision, the countys offices are closed for the entire day, that day is considered a legal holiday for purposes of this section.
(c)The property statement may be filed with the assessor through the United States mail, properly addressed with postage prepaid. For purposes of determining the date upon which the property statement is deemed filed with the assessor, the date of postmark as affixed by the United States Postal Service, or the date certified by a bona fide private courier service on the envelope containing the application, shall control. This subdivision shall be applicable to every taxing agency, including, but not limited to, a chartered city and county, or chartered city.
(d)(1)At any time, as required by the assessor for assessment purposes, every person shall make available for examination information or records regarding his or her property or any other personal property located on premises he or she owns or controls. In this connection details of property acquisition transactions, construction and development costs, rental income, and other data relevant to the determination of an estimate of value are to be considered as information essential to the proper discharge of the assessors duties.
(2)(A)This subdivision shall also apply to an owner-builder or an owner-developer of new construction that is sold to a third party, is constructed on behalf of a third party, or is constructed for the purpose of selling that property to a third party.
(B)The owner-builder or owner-developer of new construction described in subparagraph (A), shall, within 45 days of receipt of a written request by the assessor for information or records, provide the assessor with all information and records regarding that property. The information and records provided to the assessor shall include the total consideration provided either by the purchaser or on behalf of the purchaser that was paid or provided either, as part of or outside of the purchase agreement, including, but not limited to, consideration paid or provided for the purchase or acquisition of upgrades, additions, or for any other additional or supplemental work performed or arranged for by the owner-builder or owner-developer on behalf of the purchaser.
(e)In the case of a corporate owner of property, the property statement shall be signed either by an officer of the corporation or an employee or agent who has been designated in writing by the board of directors to sign the statements on behalf of the corporation.
(f)In the case of property owned by a bank or other financial institution and leased to an entity other than a bank or other financial institution, the property statement shall be submitted by the owner bank or other financial institution.
(g) The assessor may refuse to accept any property statement he or she determines to be in error.
(h)If a taxpayer fails to provide information to the assessor pursuant to subdivision (d) and introduces any requested materials or information at any assessment appeals board hearing, the assessor may request and shall be granted a continuance for a reasonable period of time. The continuance shall extend the two-year period specified in subdivision (c) of Section 1604 for a period of time equal to the period of the continuance.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, every person required to file a property statement pursuant to this section shall be permitted to amend that property statement until May 31 of the year in which the property statement is due, for errors and omissions not the result of willful intent to erroneously report. The penalty authorized by Section 463 does not apply to an amended statement received prior to May 31, provided the original statement is not subject to penalty pursuant to subdivision (b). The amended property statement shall otherwise conform to the requirements of a property statement as provided in this article.
(j)This subdivision shall apply to the oil, gas, and mineral extraction industry only. Any information that is necessary to file a true, correct, and complete statement shall be made available by the assessor, upon request, to the taxpayer by mail or at the office of the assessor by February 28. For each business day beyond February 28 that the information is unavailable, the filing deadline in subdivision (b) shall be extended in that county by one business day, for those statements affected by the delay. In no case shall the filing deadline be extended beyond June 1 or the first business day thereafter.
(k)The assessor may accept the filing of a property statement by the use of electronic media. In lieu of the signature required by subdivision (a) and the declaration under penalty of perjury required by subdivision (b), property statements filed using electronic media shall be authenticated pursuant to methods specified by the assessor and approved by the board. Electronic media includes, but is not limited to, computer modem, magnetic media, optical disk, and facsimile machine.
(l)(1)After receiving the notice required by Section 1162, the manager in control of a fleet of fractionally owned aircraft shall file with the lead county assessors office one signed property statement for all of its aircraft that have acquired situs in the state, as described in Section 1161.
(2)Flight data required to compute fractionally owned aircraft allocation under Section 1161 shall be segregated by airport.
(m)(1)After receiving the notice required by paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 1153.5, a commercial air carrier whose certificated aircraft is subject to Article 6 (commencing with Section 1150) of Chapter 5 shall file with the lead county assessors office designated under Section 1153.5 one signed property statement for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations.
(2)Each commercial air carrier may file one schedule for all of its certificated aircraft that have acquired situs in this state under Section 1151.
(3)Flight data required to compute certificated aircraft allocation under Section 1152 and subdivision (g) of Section 202 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations shall be segregated by airport location.
(4)Beginning with the 2006 assessment year, a commercial air carrier may file a statement described in this subdivision electronically by means of the California Assessors Standard Data Record (SDR) network. If the SDR is not equipped to accept electronic filings for the 2006 assessment year, an air carrier may file a printed version of its property statement for that year with its lead county assessors office.
(5)This subdivision shall remain operative only until December 31, 2016. ___.
SEC. 3.Section 1153.5 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:1153.5.(a)The Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association shall, after soliciting input from commercial air carriers operating in the state, do both of the following:
(1)On or before March 1, 2006, and on or before each March 1 thereafter, designate a lead county assessors office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in this state in that assessment year.
(2)Every third year thereafter, redesignate a lead county assessors office for each of these air carriers, unless an air carrier and its existing lead county assessors office concur to waive this redesignation.
(b)The lead county assessors office described in subdivision (a) shall do all of the following:
(1)Calculate, pursuant to Section 401.17, an unallocated value of the certificated aircraft of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(2)Electronically transmit to the assessor of each county in which the property described in paragraph (1) has situs for the assessment year the values determined by the lead county assessors office under paragraph (1).
(3)Receive the property statement, as described in subdivision (l) (m) of Section 441, of each commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(4)Lead the audit team described in subdivision (d) when that team is conducting an audit of a commercial air carrier to which he or she is designated.
(5)Notify, in writing, each commercial air carrier for which he or she has been designated of this designation on or before the first March 15 that follows that designation.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the county assessor of each county in which the personal property of a commercial air carrier has situs for an assessment year is solely responsible for assessing that property, applying the allocation formula set forth in Section 1152, and enrolling the value of the property in that county, but, in determining the unallocated fleet value for each make, model, and series of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier, the assessor may consult with the lead county assessors office designated for that commercial air carrier.
(2)The lead county assessors office is subject to Section 322 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations and Sections 408, 451, and 1606 to the same extent as the assessor described in paragraph (1).
(d)Notwithstanding Section 469, an audit of a commercial air carrier shall be conducted once every four years on a centralized basis by an audit team of auditor-appraisers from at least one, but not more than three, counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors Association. An audit, so conducted, shall encompass all of the California Personal Property and fixtures of the air carrier and is deemed to be made on behalf of each county for which an audit would otherwise be required under Section 469.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, 2016, ___, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 5170 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes, taxes and locally assessed property taxes on property valued under Section 1153.5 or a successor section, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until December 31, ___, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 5170 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:5170.(a)In suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes, the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it.
(b)This section shall become operative on January 1, ___.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 742 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:742.Upon receipt of a timely petition for reassessment, the board shall set a time and place within the state for hearing on the petition. Notice of the time and place of the hearing shall be mailed and, if requested by the assessee, electronically mailed to the assessee at its address, electronic mail address, or both, as shown in the records of the board, not less than 15 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
SEC. 2.Section 744 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:744.(a)The board shall notify the petitioner of its decision on a petition for reassessment by mail and, if requested by the assessee, by electronic mail and shall make written findings and conclusions if requested at or prior to the commencement of the hearing. The board shall send a periodic report of its decisions and any written findings and conclusions thereon to each county in which affected state-assessed property is situated. The findings shall fairly disclose the boards determination of material factual issues and shall contain a statement of the method or methods of valuation used by the board in valuing the property. Notwithstanding the requirement for a statement of method or methods, the boards approval of a settlement of a lawsuit contesting the value of state-assessed property shall be sufficient disclosure when value is determined in accordance with a board-approved settlement. Decisions of the board on petitions for reassessment of state-assessed property shall be completed on or before December 31.
(b)When the value of an assessees state-assessed property is determined, after a hearing on a petition for reassessment, to be different from the value originally adopted by the board, the board shall determine the year in which the corrected value is to be entered on the roll. The correct value may be entered on the roll for the fiscal year in which the determination is made, or the difference between the original and the corrected value may be entered as an increase or decrease in the assessment for the succeeding fiscal year. If the corrected value is entered on the roll for the fiscal year in which it is determined, and the board roll has been transmitted to the county auditors, the board shall make the corresponding changes in allocations and transmit the roll corrections to the county auditor.
(c)If the amount of the correction is to be entered on the roll for the succeeding fiscal year, an amount is to be added in lieu of interest. If the correction results in a reduction in assessed value, there shall be added to the reduction, in lieu of interest, 9 percent of the difference between the original assessed value and the reduced assessed value. If the correction results in an increase in assessed value, there shall be added to the increase, in lieu of interest, 9 percent of the difference between the original assessed value and the increased assessed value.
Upon receipt of a timely petition for reassessment, the board shall set a time and place within the state for hearing on the petition. Notice thereof of the time and place of the hearing shall be mailed and, if requested by the assessee, electronically mailed to the assessee at its address address, electronic mail address, or both, as shown in the records of the board, not less than 10 15 working days in advance of the date of the hearing.
SEC. 2.Section 744 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:744.(a)The board shall notify the petitioner of its decision on a petition for reassessment by mail and, if requested by the assessee, by electronic mail and shall make written findings and conclusions if requested at or prior to the commencement of the hearing. The board shall send a periodic report of its decisions and any written findings and conclusions thereon to each county in which affected state-assessed property is situated. The findings shall fairly disclose the boards determination of material factual issues and shall contain a statement of the method or methods of valuation used by the board in valuing the property. Notwithstanding the requirement for a statement of method or methods, the boards approval of a settlement of a lawsuit contesting the value of state-assessed property shall be sufficient disclosure when value is determined in accordance with a board-approved settlement. Decisions of the board on petitions for reassessment of state-assessed property shall be completed on or before December 31.
(b)When the value of an assessees state-assessed property is determined, after a hearing on a petition for reassessment, to be different from the value originally adopted by the board, the board shall determine the year in which the corrected value is to be entered on the roll. The correct value may be entered on the roll for the fiscal year in which the determination is made, or the difference between the original and the corrected value may be entered as an increase or decrease in the assessment for the succeeding fiscal year. If the corrected value is entered on the roll for the fiscal year in which it is determined, and the board roll has been transmitted to the county auditors, the board shall make the corresponding changes in allocations and transmit the roll corrections to the county auditor.
(c)If the amount of the correction is to be entered on the roll for the succeeding fiscal year, an amount is to be added in lieu of interest. If the correction results in a reduction in assessed value, there shall be added to the reduction, in lieu of interest, 9 percent of the difference between the original assessed value and the reduced assessed value. If the correction results in an increase in assessed value, there shall be added to the increase, in lieu of interest, 9 percent of the difference between the original assessed value and the increased assessed value.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 23, 2016 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Nazarian. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 3, 2016 | August 3 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2016 | June 20 set for first hearing. Placed on REV. & TAX. suspense file. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 1. Page 4109.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 1.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 4008.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 20, 2016 | Set for hearing May 27. |
| May 16, 2016 | May 16 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) |
| May 10, 2016 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 9, 2016 | May 9 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 29, 2016 | Set for hearing May 9. |
| Apr 26, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2. Page 3611.) (April 19). |
| Apr 25, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 19). |
| Apr 18, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 15, 2016 | Set for hearing April 19 in JUD. pending receipt. |
| Apr 14, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Apr 13, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 3518.) (April 13). |
| Apr 13, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 13). |
| Apr 5, 2016 | Set for hearing April 13. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Mar 3, 2016 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 23. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2016 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1329 Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 13, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1329
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 37-1
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Revenue & Taxation | 9-0 | Ridley-Thomas, Brough, Dababneh, Gipson, Mullin, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Wagner | |
Appropriations | 15-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Chang, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Weber, Wood, McCarty |
|
SUMMARY: Extends the Centralized Fleet Calculation Program for statewide assessment of certificated aircraft for property tax purposes for one year, until fiscal year (FY) 2017-18. Specifically, this bill:
- Extends, until FY 2017-18, the application of the current assessment methodology for determining the fair market value (FMV) of certificated aircraft owned by commercial air carriers for property tax purposes and the rebuttable presumption that the pre-allocated FMV of certificated aircraft, as calculated, is correct.
- Extends, until December 31, 2017, the application of the following provisions of law that otherwise are scheduled to sunset on December 31, 2016:
- Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 441(m), which requires a commercial air carrier to file one annual property statement with a designated "lead" county, as provided; and,
- R&TC Section 1153.5, which establishes the procedure for selecting a lead county to calculate an airline's fleet value and a coordinated multi-county audit team to perform mandatory audits of commercial air carriers.
- Imposes a state-mandated local program and provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs will be made as required by statute.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the California Constitution or federal law. Limits ad valorem taxes on real property to 1% of the full cash value of that property as set forth in the California Constitution.
- Requires that real and personal property be taxed at the same rate (California Constitution Article XIII Section 2). Personal property, which generally is defined as property other than real property, is subject to property tax of 1% of the assessed value of the taxable personal property. The property tax applicable to personal property, however, is calculated based on the market value of that property, rather than its "full cash value."
- Requires each county to impose an ad valorem property tax rate of 1% of the assessed value of the taxable property located in that county. Certificated aircraft are subject to property taxation when in service in California. Typically, certificated aircraft are commercial aircraft operated by air carriers for passenger and freight service, while general aircraft are typically privately owned aircraft. General aircraft are assessed on an aircraft-by-aircraft basis and an assessment is made only in a single county where the aircraft is habitually situated. Certificated aircraft are valued for purposes of property taxation under a "fleet" concept, which means that the basis of the assessed value is not the value of any single aircraft owned by an air carrier, but the value of all aircraft of each particular fleet type flown into California. Types are grouped by make and model. Only an allocated portion of the entire fleet's value is ultimately taxed to reflect actual presence in California's counties. Because certificated aircraft are movable, they are often located in more than one county during an assessment year, and assessments are made for each county in which the aircraft in the fleet land during the year.
- Prescribes a centralized assessment methodology for valuing certificated aircraft for FYs 2005-06 through 2016-17, with the methodology repealed as of December 31, 2016. This methodology allows a commercial air carrier to file a single, consolidated property statement with a designated "lead" county for all certificated aircraft with a tax situs in California. The centralized assessment methodology is based on a formula to be used by the "lead" county in determining the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, converted freighters, and regional aircraft with a tax situs within California for property tax purposes. The preallocated value is the lesser of:
- A historical cost less depreciation basis with no individual aircraft value exceeding the original price paid; or,
- The value referenced in the Winter edition of the "Airline Price Guide," a commercially-prepared value guide for aircraft, less 10%.
Once the "lead" county calculates the preallocated value of the aircraft, the information is transmitted to all other counties within which the airline has acquired a tax nexus. Each individual county then determines its allocated portion of the fleet based on the flight data for that particular county. R&TC Section 1152 provides an allocation formula to determine the frequency and the amount of time that an air carrier's aircraft makes contact and maintains situs within a county during a representative period. An allocation ratio is the sum of two factors:
- A ground and flight time factor, which accounts for 75% of the ratio; and,
- An arrivals-and-departures factor, which accounts for 25% of the ratio. [Property Tax Rule 202 (c)].
The sum of these factors yields the allocation ratio, which is applied to the full cash value of a fleet of a particular type of aircraft operated by an air carrier. The sum of the assessed allocated values for each make and model used by an air carrier results in the total assessed value of the aircraft for that air carrier for a particular county.
- Requires the State Board of Equalization (BOE), upon consultation with assessors, to designate for each assessment year the representative period of an air carrier's ground and flight time and arrival and departure activity used in the allocation formula.
- Specifies that, with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011, the value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner may not exceed its original cost and that the pre-allocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by certain evidence, including appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
- Requires the "lead" county to transmit the property statement related to an airport location to the situs county, and provides that each county is responsible for valuing personal property and fixtures at its particular airport locations.
- Requires assessors to audit once every four years the personal property holdings of any property owner with an assessed value of more than $400,000. (R&TC Section 469).
- Allows an audit team comprised of staff from one to three counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors' Association, to perform a mandatory audit of a commercial air carrier once every four years on a centralized basis. The work performed by the audit team is deemed to have been made on behalf of each county for which a mandatory audit would otherwise be required under R&TC Section 469. (R&TC Section 1153.5).
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown revenue impact relative to current law. Property tax revenues for the additional year utilizing the lead assessor methodology could be higher or lower than what would have occurred absent this bill.
- Minor administrative and implementation costs to the BOE.
COMMENTS:
- Background: Prior to 1999, no specific assessment methodology procedure for valuing certificated aircraft or the carrier's possessory interest in the publicly owned airport existed in California. In 1998, a group of counties and airline industry representatives entered into a written settlement agreement to dispose of outstanding litigation and appeals over the valuation of possessory interest assessments in airports and the valuation of certificated aircraft. The settlement agreement created a new assessment methodology for valuing aircraft that applied to FY 1998–99 to FY 2002–03 and was codified in a three-piece legislative package [AB 1807 (Takasugi), Chapter 86, Statutes of 1998; AB 2318 (Knox), Chapter 85, Statutes of 1998; and SB 30 (Kopp), Chapter 87, Statutes of 1998].
- The 2005 Settlement Agreement: In 2005, the representatives of the airline industry and a county assessors working group jointly refined that valuation methodology, recognizing the need to distinguish between different types of aircraft and to detail the specific calculation of the variable components that were previously lacking. For instance, with respect to calculating the historical cost basis of the aircraft, each variable component is specified and taken into account: a) acquisition cost, b) price index, c) percent good factor, and d) economic obsolescence. With respect to Aircraft Performance Group (APG), a "blue book" value guide for aircraft, the use of values referenced in that guide is delineated, recognizing that airlines generally receive a fleet discount that is not reflected in prices listed in the guide. The 2005 revisions to the valuation methodology of certificated aircraft were codified by AB 964 (Horton), Chapter 699, Statutes of 2005. However, AB 964 specified that the revised formula for determining the FMV of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier applied only for FYs 2005-06 through 2010-11. AB 964 also included repeal dates for the provisions prescribing the procedures for designating a lead county assessor's office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in California, allowing a commercial air carrier to file one property statement with the lead county, and permitting an audit of those carriers on a centralized basis.
In 2010, AB 384 (Ma), Chapter 228, Statutes of 2010, extended the valuation methodology and centralized assessment provisions temporarily to FY 2015-16. AB 384 also revised the valuation provisions to create a rebuttable presumption of correctness for the FMV of certificated aircraft determined under the assessment methodology. AB 384 specified that the FMV may be rebutted by evidence including appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony. Finally, AB 384 provided that the value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner may not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer.
- Centralized Assessment System: Under existing law, which this bill proposes to extend, a "lead" county is designated by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors' Association for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in California. The "lead" county is required to calculate an unallocated fleet value of the carrier's certificated aircraft for each make, model, and series, as provided. Once the fleet value is calculated, it is transmitted to other counties, which in turn determine their allocated portions of the fleet value based on the flight data for each county. The allocation process limits each county's assessment to reflect the aircraft's physical presence in that county.
Existing law also allows commercial air carriers operating in multiple California airports to file a single consolidated property statement with a "lead" county. In turn, the "lead" county must transmit return information related to non-aircraft personal property and fixtures to other counties where the air carrier operates. The audit procedures are also centralized: an audit team directed by the "lead" county will audit the air carrier once every four years on a centralized basis.
- Certainty and Predictability of the Existing Assessment Methodology: Prior to 1998, the valuation of aircraft had been contentious and challenging for both county assessors and commercial air carriers, but the codified valuation methodology has reduced those conflicts.[1] The existing centralized assessment of certificated aircraft provides certainty and predictability for both assessors and airlines. Further, the current procedure of designating a lead county assessor's office to calculate the preallocated fleet value ensures that airlines report the same information to every county, resulting in a uniform statewide assessment. Absent a codified methodology, there is no guarantee that the values determined by each individual county assessor would be the same since property appraisal is subjective and opinions of value differ. Finally, the centralized assessment of aircraft greatly reduces administrative costs for both parties. Unless the existing methodology for valuing aircraft is extended, both the assessors and airlines will have to deal with multiple tax returns reporting the same information, multiple audits and multiple county assessment appeals. Furthermore, assessors would be able to use any valid method to determine FMV, such as, for example, cost, income, comparable sales, and published market value guides.
- The Rebuttable Presumption of Value: The assessment of certificated aircraft is a difficult and complex task. As such, the potential for litigation and assessment appeals is significant. It is presumed by both the assessor and taxpayer that the existing methodology will result in a fair and reasonable assessment. However, since appraisal is not an exact science, there may be instances where one of the parties believes, and has clear evidence, that the assessment resulting from the prescribed methodology is wrong. In these instances, the issue is usually settled by an assessment appeals board. Consistent with the existing law, this bill would allow taxpayers and assessors to appeal a value established by following a legally prescribed methodology. The practical result of "rebuttably presumed" language is that it clearly recognizes that an assessment appeals board has the discretion to set a fair market value where the facts presented clearly overcome the presumption of correctness in any given methodology. If the existing centralized assessment provisions are not extended, then the burden of proof regarding the correctness of the assessment will shift to the air carrier challenging the assessed value.
- One More Year: Certificated aircraft valuation is complex and contentious, and has given rise to litigation and appeals challenging assessments. Although the statutory methodology has narrowed the scope of issues, it has not eliminated conflict. Last year, AB 1157 (Nazarian), Chapter 440, Statutes of 2015, extended the current assessment methodology for certificated aircraft, that was otherwise set to expire, for one year in hopes that the airline industry and county assessors could reach consensus on how the methodology could be reformed during the interim. Although the parties have not yet reached consensus, talks remain ongoing.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0004015
In 2013, several air carriers commenced legal action challenging the calculations of economic obsolescence under R&TC Section 401.17(a)(1)(C) and (D). The lawsuits have been consolidated into one case pending in Orange County Superior Court. This bill, however, does not propose to modify the economic obsolescence provisions. ↑
Date of Hearing: August 3, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1329
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the Centralized Fleet Calculation Program for statewide assessment of certificated aircraft for property tax purposes for one year, until fiscal year (FY) 2017-18.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown revenue impact relative to current law. Property tax revenues for the additional year utilizing the lead assessor methodology could be higher or lower than what would have occurred absent this bill.
- Minor administrative and implementation costs to the Board of Equalization (BOE).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. SB 1329 will maintain the status quo in terms of how commercial aircraft are assessed for the purposes of property taxation for an additional year. According to a recent letter of support from Southwest Airlines, SB 1329 provides additional time for negotiations between local county assessors and the airline industry as the two parties continue to negotiate possible changes to the commercial property tax assessment process.
- Background. Prior to 1999, the state did not have a single or specific assessment methodology for valuing certificated commercial aircraft. Valuation was left to each county assessor, leading to significant problems and conflicts over inconsistent valuations, property tax apportionment, and administrative cost and complexity. In 1998, a group of counties and airline industry representatives agreed to dispose of outstanding litigation and appeals over the valuation of certificated aircraft and create a new assessment methodology. That methodology was further refined by county assessors and industry representatives in 2005, resulting in the current method for valuing aircraft.
In addition to specifying the component metrics used to value fleets, the methodology prescribes procedures for designating a lead county assessor's office for each commercial air carrier operating in California, allowing an airline to file one property statement with the lead county, and prescribing a centralized audit process. The lead county is designated by Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors' Association. The lead county calculates the fleet fair market value (FMV) of the airlines certificated aircraft and transmits the valuation to other counties. Those counties then determine their allocated portions of the fleet value based on physical presence.
Unless the existing methodology for valuing aircraft is extended, both the assessors and airlines will have to deal with multiple tax returns reporting the same information, multiple audits and multiple county assessment appeals. Furthermore, assessors would be able to use any valid method to determine FMV, such as, for example, cost, income, comparable sales, and published market value guides.
- Appellate process. Earlier versions of this bill contained language related to how a taxpayer (such as an airline) could appeal a local assessor’s valuation of commercial aircraft. Under current law, any taxpayers seeking to appeal a local assessment must contact the assessor to request reconsideration. If this informal process fails to produce a solution, then the taxpayer starts a formal appeals process with the county’s board of equalization. When a taxpayer continues to disagree with a county’s decision, the taxpayer can file suit with the Superior Court, but the court can only review the existing record to determine whether substantial evidence supports the appeals board’s decision. In these cases, the court generally acts as the appellate court and only grants review for “arbitrariness, abuse of discretion, or failure to follow the standards prescribed by the Legislature,” as they see the county assessment appeals process as performing the same fact-finding function as trial courts.
Prior versions of this bill contained a provision that granted airlines a right to a “trial de novo.” This would have allowed courts to receive and consider new evidence in the case of an appeal of the local assessment of commercial aircraft.
- Related legislation. AB 2622 (Nazarian) of 2016 extends the sunset date for the current lead county system for an additional three years as well as modifies the “representative period” that is used when calculating an aircraft’s assessed value. That bill is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Sebastian Ridley-Thomas, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1329
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 37-1
SUBJECT: Property taxation: certificated aircraft
SUMMARY: Extends the Centralized Fleet Calculation Program for statewide assessment of certificated aircraft for property tax purposes for one year, until fiscal year (FY) 2017-18. Specifically, this bill:
- Extends, until FY 2017-18, the application of the current assessment methodology for determining the fair market value (FMV) of certificated aircraft owned by commercial air carriers for property tax purposes and the rebuttable presumption that the pre-allocated FMV of certificated aircraft, as calculated, is correct.
- Extends, until December 31, 2017, the application of the following provisions of law that otherwise are scheduled to sunset on December 31, 2016:
- Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 441(m), which requires a commercial air carrier to file one annual property statement with a designated "lead" county, as provided; and,
- R&TC Section 1153.5, which establishes the procedure for selecting a lead county to calculate an airline's fleet value and a coordinated multi-county audit team to perform mandatory audits of commercial air carriers.
- Imposes a state-mandated local program and provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs will be made as required by statute.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the California Constitution or federal law. Limits ad valorem taxes on real property to 1% of the full cash value of that property as set forth in the California Constitution.
- Requires that real and personal property be taxed at the same rate (Section 2 of Article XIII of the California Constitution). Personal property, which generally is defined as property other than real property, is subject to property tax of 1% of the assessed value of the taxable personal property. The property tax applicable to personal property, however, is calculated based on the market value of that property, rather than its "full cash value."
- Requires each county to impose an ad valorem property tax rate of 1% of the assessed value of the taxable property located in that county. Certificated aircraft are subject to property taxation when in service in California. Typically, certificated aircraft are commercial aircraft operated by air carriers for passenger and freight service, while general aircraft are typically privately owned aircraft. General aircraft are assessed on an aircraft-by-aircraft basis and an assessment is made only in a single county where the aircraft is habitually situated. Certificated aircraft are valued for purposes of property taxation under a "fleet" concept, which means that the basis of the assessed value is not the value of any single aircraft owned by an air carrier, but the value of all aircraft of each particular fleet type flown into California. Types are grouped by make and model. Only an allocated portion of the entire fleet's value is ultimately taxed to reflect actual presence in California's counties. Because certificated aircraft are movable, they are often located in more than one county during an assessment year, and assessments are made for each county in which the aircraft in the fleet land during the year.
- Prescribes a centralized assessment methodology for valuing certificated aircraft for FYs 2005-06 through 2016-17, with the methodology repealed as of December 31, 2016. This methodology allows a commercial air carrier to file a single, consolidated property statement with a designated "lead" county for all certificated aircraft with a tax situs in California. The centralized assessment methodology is based on a formula to be used by the "lead" county in determining the preallocated fair market value of each make, model, and series of mainline jets, production freighters, converted freighters, and regional aircraft with a tax situs within California for property tax purposes. The preallocated value is the lesser of:
- A historical cost less depreciation basis with no individual aircraft value exceeding the original price paid; or,
- The value referenced in the Winter edition of the "Airline Price Guide," a commercially-prepared value guide for aircraft, less 10%.
- A historical cost less depreciation basis with no individual aircraft value exceeding the original price paid; or,
Once the "lead" county calculates the preallocated value of the aircraft, the information is transmitted to all other counties within which the airline has acquired a tax nexus. Each individual county then determines its allocated portion of the fleet based on the flight data for that particular county. R&TC Section 1152 provides an allocation formula to determine the frequency and the amount of time that an air carrier's aircraft makes contact and maintains situs within a county during a representative period. An allocation ratio is the sum of two factors:
- A ground and flight time factor, which accounts for 75% of the ratio; and,
- An arrivals-and-departures factor, which accounts for 25% of the ratio. [Property Tax Rule 202 (c)].
- A ground and flight time factor, which accounts for 75% of the ratio; and,
The sum of these factors yields the allocation ratio, which is applied to the full cash value of a fleet of a particular type of aircraft operated by an air carrier. The sum of the assessed allocated values for each make and model used by an air carrier results in the total assessed value of the aircraft for that air carrier for a particular county.
- Requires the State Board of Equalization (BOE), upon consultation with assessors, to designate for each assessment year the representative period of an air carrier's ground and flight time and arrival and departure activity used in the allocation formula.
- Specifies that, with respect to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2011, the value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner may not exceed its original cost and that the pre-allocated fair market value of an aircraft may be rebutted by certain evidence, including appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony.
- Requires the "lead" county to transmit the property statement related to an airport location to the situs county, and provides that each county is responsible for valuing personal property and fixtures at its particular airport locations.
- Requires assessors to audit once every four years the personal property holdings of any property owner with an assessed value of more than $400,000. (R&TC Section 469).
- Allows an audit team comprised of staff from one to three counties, as determined by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors' Association, to perform a mandatory audit of a commercial air carrier once every four years on a centralized basis. The work performed by the audit team is deemed to have been made on behalf of each county for which a mandatory audit would otherwise be required under R&TC Section 469. (R&TC Section 1153.5).
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the BOE, unknown costs, although the status quo is maintained.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
This bill extends the sunset provisions contained in the "Lead County System" by one year. Both the Senate and Assembly, along with the airline industry and county assessors, are seeking a long-term solution.
- Arguments in Support: Proponents of this bill state that "the airlines and the county assessors, along with legislative staff have been involved in fruitful negotiations" and "are cautiously optimistic a compromise can be reached that will make the local assessment of aircraft better for the county assessors and the airlines." This bill "is an important element of these current negotiations."
- Background: Prior to 1999, no specific assessment methodology procedure for valuing certificated aircraft or the carrier's possessory interest in the publicly owned airport existed in California. In 1998, a group of counties and airline industry representatives entered into a written settlement agreement to dispose of outstanding litigation and appeals over the valuation of possessory interest assessments in airports and the valuation of certificated aircraft. The settlement agreement created a new assessment methodology for valuing aircraft that applied to FY 1998–99 to FY 2002–03 and was codified in a three-piece legislative package [AB 1807 (Takasugi), Chapter 86, Statutes of 1998; AB 2318 (Knox), Chapter 85, Statutes of 1998; and SB 30 (Kopp), Chapter 87, Statutes of 1998].
- The 2005 Settlement Agreement: In 2005, the representatives of the airline industry and a county assessors working group jointly refined that valuation methodology, recognizing the need to distinguish between different types of aircraft and to detail the specific calculation of the variable components that were previously lacking. For instance, with respect to calculating the historical cost basis of the aircraft, each variable component is specified and taken into account: (a) acquisition cost, (b) price index, (c) percent good factor, and (d) economic obsolescence. With respect to APG, a "blue book" value guide for aircraft, the use of values referenced in that guide is delineated, recognizing that airlines generally receive a fleet discount that is not reflected in prices listed in the guide. The 2005 revisions to the valuation methodology of certificated aircraft were codified by AB 964 (Horton), Chapter 699, Statutes of 2005. However, AB 964 specified that the revised formula for determining the FMV of certificated aircraft of a commercial air carrier applied only for FYs 2005-06 through 2010-11. AB 964 also included repeal dates for the provisions prescribing the procedures for designating a lead county assessor's office for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in California, allowing a commercial air carrier to file one property statement with the lead county, and permitting an audit of those carriers on a centralized basis.
In 2010, AB 384 (Ma), Chapter 228, Statutes of 2010, extended the valuation methodology and centralized assessment provisions temporarily to FY 2015-16. AB 384 also revised the valuation provisions to create a rebuttable presumption of correctness for the FMV of certificated aircraft determined under the assessment methodology. AB 384 specified that the FMV may be rebutted by evidence including appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony. Finally, AB 384 provided that the value of an individual aircraft assessed to the original owner may not exceed its original cost from the manufacturer. - Centralized Assessment System: Under existing law, which this bill proposes to extend, a "lead" county is designated by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors' Association for each commercial air carrier operating certificated aircraft in California. The "lead" county is required to calculate an unallocated fleet value of the carrier's certificated aircraft for each make, model, and series, as provided. Once the fleet value is calculated, it is transmitted to other counties, which in turn determine their allocated portions of the fleet value based on the flight data for each county. The allocation process limits each county's assessment to reflect the aircraft's physical presence in that county.
Existing law also allows commercial air carriers operating in multiple California airports to file a single consolidated property statement with a "lead" county. In turn, the "lead" county must transmit return information related to non-aircraft personal property and fixtures to other counties where the air carrier operates. The audit procedures are also centralized: an audit team directed by the "lead" county will audit the air carrier once every four years on a centralized basis. - Certainty and Predictability of the Existing Assessment Methodology: Prior to 1998, the valuation of aircraft had been contentious and challenging for both county assessors and commercial air carriers, but the codified valuation methodology has reduced those conflicts.[1] The existing centralized assessment of certificated aircraft provides certainty and predictability for both assessors and airlines. Further, the current procedure of designating a lead county assessor's office to calculate the preallocated fleet value ensures that airlines report the same information to every county, resulting in a uniform statewide assessment. Absent a codified methodology, there is no guarantee that the values determined by each individual county assessor would be the same since property appraisal is subjective and opinions of value differ. Finally, the centralized assessment of aircraft greatly reduces administrative costs for both parties. Unless the existing methodology for valuing aircraft is extended, both the assessors and airlines will have to deal with multiple tax returns reporting the same information, multiple audits and multiple county assessment appeals. Furthermore, assessors would be able to use any valid method to determine FMV, such as, for example, cost, income, comparable sales, and published market value guides.
- The Rebuttable Presumption of Value: The assessment of certificated aircraft is a difficult and complex task. As such, the potential for litigation and assessment appeals is significant. It is presumed by both the assessor and taxpayer that the existing methodology will result in a fair and reasonable assessment. However, since appraisal is not an exact science, there may be instances where one of the parties believes, and has clear evidence, that the assessment resulting from the prescribed methodology is wrong. In these instances, the issue is usually settled by an assessment appeals board. Consistent with the existing law, this bill would allow taxpayers and assessors to appeal a value established by following a legally prescribed methodology. The practical result of "rebuttably presumed" language is that it clearly recognizes that an assessment appeals board has the discretion to set a fair market value where the facts presented clearly overcome the presumption of correctness in any given methodology. If the existing centralized assessment provisions are not extended, then the burden of proof regarding the correctness of the assessment will shift to the air carrier challenging the assessed value.
- One More Year: Certificated aircraft valuation is complex and contentious, and has given rise to litigation and appeals challenging assessments. Although the statutory methodology has narrowed the scope of issues, it has not eliminated conflict. Last year, AB 1157 (Nazarian), Chapter 440, Statutes of 2015, extended the current assessment methodology for certificated aircraft, that was otherwise set to expire, for one year in hopes that the airline industry and county assessors could reach consensus on how the methodology could be reformed during the interim. Although the parties have not yet reached consensus, talks remain ongoing.
- Related Legislation:
- AB 2622 (Nazarian) would extend the sunset date for the centralized assessment methodology for three years to FY 2019-2020, require the representative period used by assessors in assessing the certificated aircraft to be a week or group of weeks in both January and July, and makes other administrative changes. AB 2622 is pending hearing by the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
- AB 1157 (Nazarian), Chapter 440, Statutes of 2015, extended the sunset date for the centralized assessment methodology from FY 2015-16 to FY 2016-17.
- SB 661 (Hill) would have transferred assessment jurisdiction for commercial air carrier personal property, including certificated aircraft, to the BOE. SB 661 was held by the Senate Appropriations Committee and subsequently amended for a different purpose.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Airlines for America (Sponsor)
Alaska Airlines
American Airlines
Southwest Airlines
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
In 2013, several air carriers commenced legal action challenging the calculations of economic obsolescence under R&TC Section 401.17(a)(1)(C) and (D). The lawsuits have been consolidated into one case pending in Orange County Superior Court. This bill, however, does not propose to modify the economic obsolescence provisions. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1329
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 4/13/16
AYES: Hertzberg, Beall, Hernandez, Lara, Pavley
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Moorlach
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-2, 4/19/16
AYES: Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Leno, Monning
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jackson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
DIGEST: This bill extends for one year the lead assessor methodology to value certificated aircraft.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law.
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and precludes reassessment unless the property is newly constructed or changes ownership; however, assessors value personal property, such as certificated aircraft, each year.
- Allows assessors to value certificated aircraft with “situs” in California on a fleet basis, defined as all aircraft owned by the taxpayer by make and model.
- Apportions value among counties based on a weighted average of the fleet’s ground and flight time (75%), and arrivals and departures (25%) measured only during the “representative period,” currently designated by the Board of Equalization (BOE) as the second full in week in January.
- Creates a lead assessor methodology for valuing certificated aircraft, and sets forth a methodology to calculate aircraft value (AB 964, Horton, Chapter 699, Statutes of 2006). The methodology:
- Requires owners of certificated aircraft to file one signed property statement for the taxpayer’s personal property with a single assessor, which the owner can file using the Standard Data Record network.
- Allows owners to file one schedule for its certificated aircraft.
- Limits audits of certificated aircraft to one, led performed by a multi-county team.
- Establishes categories for mainline jets, regional aircraft, production freighters, and converted freighters, and sets forth a valuation methodology for each.
- States as a rebuttable presumption the aircraft value as the lesser of a historical cost basis, or 10% off (for a fleet adjustment) the wholesale price listed in the Airline Price Guide.
- However, in no case may this value exceed the aircraft’s original cost, and owners of certificated aircraft may rebut the presumption using appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony (AB 384, Ma, Chapter 228, Statutes of 2010).
- Provides for an economic obsolescence adjustment, where assessors analyze the change in three variables to determine whether larger economic forces are diminishing the aircraft’s value.
- Requires the California Assessors’ Association to designate a lead assessor for each airline to calculate the unallocated value of the fleet, transmit that value to non-lead counties, receive the consolidated property statement, and lead the audit team.
- Sunsets after the 2016-17 fiscal year, after which certificated aircraft will revert to local assessment.
This bill extends the current provisions of the lead assessor methodology to value certificated aircraft until the 2017-18 fiscal year.
Background
Until 1998, state law did not prescribe a specific method for assessors to determine the value of aircraft, resulting in years of disagreements and litigation between assessors and airlines. In 1998, the Legislature detailed a valuation methodology for certificated aircraft which was presumed to equal the fair market value of the aircraft for those years, enacting three bills to codify a settlement agreement between several counties and airline industry representatives. In 2003, the agreement expired, and assessors again locally valued aircraft without specific guidance from the Revenue and Taxation Code.
In 2006, assessors and the airlines again agreed on a new valuation methodology, which sunset in the 2010-11 fiscal year. Under the agreement, a “lead assessor” values each airline’s fleet. Instead of filing property statements with each county, airlines may instead file a single consolidated statement with a single assessor designated by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors’ Association. AB 964 (2006) also directed the lead assessor to audit the airline every four years.
After Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed the first bill that extended the sunset (AB 311, Ma, 2009), he signed a similar bill the next year, which extended the lead assessor model and the valuation methodology until the 2015-16 fiscal year, but differed from AB 311 by:
- Replacing language specifying value with a rebuttable presumption,
- Allowing the taxpayer to rebut the presumption with appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony, and
- Capping an aircraft’s value at its original cost.
Assessment of personal property, especially certificated aircraft, is inherently difficult. Not only are planes valuable, which leads to a larger range of disagreement, but the economic condition of the airline industry can change rapidly due to terrorist attacks, economic recessions, and mergers, all of which have occurred in recent years. The Legislature initially codified an assessment methodology after years of litigation resulted in settlement agreements. AB 964’s methods of assessment were supposed to establish a very detailed methodology based on either an easily knowable cost basis or a well-known price index. However, that bill also created a safety valve that would reduce values due to obsolescence whenever a weighted average of three metrics fell 10% below its average for the past 10 years. Some airlines appealed assessors’ valuations over different issues, including arguing that assessors erred by using an incorrect period to calculate the 10-year average, incorrect comparison information, and applied the incorrect base year. Assessors disagreed, and assessment appeals boards subsequently upheld the assessor’s valuations. However, airlines subsequently filed suit in several counties to challenge that determination, and to preserve legal standing.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2622 (Nazarian, 2016) extends the lead assessor methodology until the 2019-2020 fiscal year, and makes other procedural changes to the methodology. The bill is currently on the Assembly Floor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The precise revenue impact of this bill relative to current law is unknown. Property tax revenues for the additional year utilizing the lead assessor methodology could higher or lower than what would have occurred absent the bill. Approximately 50 percent of property tax revenues statewide accrue to schools, which generally offsets state General Fund obligations pursuant to Proposition 98. Consequently, any change in the school share of property tax revenues that is attributable to the bill’s impact on assessed values would, in turn, impact General Fund expenditures.
- Implementation costs for the BOE would be minor and absorbable.
Airlines for America
Alaska Airlines
American Airlines
Southwest Airlines
United Airlines
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/31/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “The provisions outlined in current law relating to the centralized assessment of aircraft will sunset December 31, 2016. Unless extended, airlines would be required to file separate property statements and submit duplicative aircraft fleet information in every county in which they operated. In addition each county will be required to audit each carrier, if the air carrier’s assessment qualifies as a mandatory audit in that county. Absent a uniform codified methodology, each county would have to calculate the total aircraft fleet value. Airlines would inevitable face uncertainty and delays on the valuation of their aircraft. A centralized process simplifies the valuation and taxation of certified aircraft, ensures statewide consistency in the base value of an aircraft fleet and promotes administrative efficiency for both carriers and counties. In extending the sunset date for the assessment of certified aircraft, SB 1329 continues to eliminate the need for multiple tax returns reporting the same information, and allows assessors to carry out their mandated responsibility to fairly assess all taxable property, within their jurisdiction, in an efficient manner. It is imperative that counties continue to assess aircraft in an administratively efficient manner as these assessments translate into approximately $30 million in local revenue.”
5/31/16 22:15:37
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1329 (Hertzberg) - Property taxation: certificated aircraft
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 1329 would (1) extend for five years the existing methodology for valuing certificated aircraft, excluding a 10 percent fleet reduction discount, and (2) permit trial de novo for suits for refunds of locally-assessed property taxes on certificated aircraft.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 27, 2016
Fiscal Impact:
- The precise revenue impact of this bill relative to current law is unknown. Property tax revenues for the additional year utilizing the lead assessor methodology could higher or lower than what would have occurred absent the bill. Approximately 50 percent of property tax revenues statewide accrue to schools, which generally offsets state General Fund obligations pursuant to Proposition 98. Consequently, any change in the school share of property tax revenues that is attributable to the bill’s impact on assessed values would, in turn, impact General Fund expenditures.
- Implementation costs for the Board of Equalization would be minor and absorbable.
Committee Amendments:
Delete trial de novo, reinstate the 10 percent fleet reduction discount, and extend the lead assessor methodology to value certificated aircraft for one additional year, through fiscal year 2017-18.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1329 (Hertzberg) - Property taxation: certificated aircraft
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill may meet the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 1329 would (1) extend for five years the existing methodology for valuing certificated aircraft, excluding a 10 percent fleet reduction discount, and (2) permit trial de novo for suits for refunds of locally-assessed property taxes on certificated aircraft.
Fiscal Impact: The aggregate fiscal impact of this bill is unknown and subject to considerable uncertainty. First, the bill’s removal of the 10 percent fleet reduction discount would increase revenue by an unknown amount, up to several million dollars annually. Next, the bill’s extension of “trial de novo” provisions to property tax refund litigation involving certificated aircraft could lead to court-determined property tax reductions of an unknown amount that potentially exceed the aforementioned revenue increase. Changes in local property tax revenues, in turn, affect General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors. Ultimately, the bill could result in an increase or a decrease in annual General Fund spending through 2021-22 relative to current law (See Staff Comments).
Finally, the Board of Equalization (BOE) would incur minor and absorbable costs related to updating publications and its internet site, and possible witness subpoenas or amicus briefs related to litigation over valuation issues as a result of the bill.
Background:
All property, real and personal, is subject to property tax, unless a specific constitutional or statutory exemption applies. The Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1 percent of full cash value, and precludes reassessment unless the property is newly constructed or changes ownership; in contrast, county assessors value personal property, such as certificated aircraft, annually. The Legislature first directed county assessors in 1850 to tax property; however, assessors in different counties often applied different tax rates and methods of assessment. The inconsistencies were especially acute between counties dominated by mining and agriculture. As a response, the California Constitution of 1879 created BOE to equalize property tax rates and assessment practices among counties. In 1910, voters amended the Constitution to direct BOE to tax certain property that crossed county lines, including that owned by railways, firms selling gas and electricity, or telephone companies. The taxes were exclusively levied for state purposes on a gross receipts taxation basis. In 1933, the constitution was amended again and the 'in lieu" gross receipts taxation on public utilities was substituted with the ad valorem assessment by BOE that was allocated to the local jurisdictions according to situs.
Valuing Certificated Aircraft. Generally, assessors value business personal property, such as aircraft, by multiplying the taxpayer’s cost of acquiring it by an inflation adjustment to estimate the cost to replace the property at current market prices. This “reproduction cost new” is then multiplied by a “percent good factor” (a depreciation factor) to provide an estimate of the depreciated reproduction cost of the property, which becomes the taxable value of the property for the fiscal year.
Certificated aircraft used by air carriers is subject to property tax when in revenue service in the State. Assessors may only value certificated aircraft (defined as aircraft operated by a domestic or foreign air carrier engaged in passenger or fleet service) with “situs” in California on a fleet basis. This means that the assessed value basis is not the value of any single aircraft owned by an air carrier, but rather the value of all aircraft of each type that is flown into the State. Aircraft regularly fly in and out of California and the various California counties with major airports; typically no single or particular aircraft remains located in the State on a permanent basis. Under the "fleet" concept, aircraft types that have gained situs in California by their entry into revenue service in this state are valued as a fleet, while only an allocated portion of the entire fleet's value is ultimately taxed to reflect actual presence in California’s counties. For example, assessors must value an airlines’ entire A380 fleet if only one enters the State, but doesn’t value any of its 747’s if none of them do so, regardless of the total number or value of A380s or 747s the airline owns. Once assessors calculate value, they must apportion it among counties based on a weighted average of (1) the fleet’s ground and flight time (75 percent), and (2) arrivals and departures (25 percent) measured only during the “representative period,” currently designated by BOE as one full week in January, with the selected week varying. This apportioned fleet value is then multiplied by the appropriate rate for the tax rate area in that county.
Prior to January 1, 1999, California law did not specify an assessment methodology for valuing certificated aircraft, or for valuing the carrier's taxable possessory interest in the publicly owned airport in which the aircraft operated. In 1997-98, a group of counties and air carrier industry representatives met to resolve property tax issues associated with air carrier-owned and -used property. The end result was a written settlement agreement to dispose of outstanding litigation and appeals over the valuation of airport possessory interest assessments and certificated aircraft. The Legislature codified the settlement agreement in a three-piece package:
- Aircraft Valuation Methodology and Monetary Settlement. AB 1807 (Takasugi, Chapter 86, Statutes of 1998) outlined the valuation procedures for certificated aircraft until 2003 and provided $50 million in tax credits against future tax liabilities, as well as extensive uncodified legislative findings and declarations.
- Airport Possessory Interests. AB 2318 (Knox, Chapter 85, Statutes of 1998) specified the assessment methodology for valuing the air carrier’s taxable possessory interest in publicly-owned airports.
- Tax Credits. SB 30 (Kopp, Chapter 87, Statutes of 1998) added general purpose provisions to allow counties and taxpayers to enter into written settlement agreements granting taxpayers tax credits.
In 2003, the agreement expired, and assessors again locally valued aircraft without specific guidance from state law. In 2006, assessors and the airlines again agreed on a new valuation methodology (AB 964, Horton, Chapter 699, Statutes of 2005), and directed a “lead assessor” to value each airline’s fleet. Instead of filing property statements with each county, airlines filed a single consolidated statement with a single assessor designated by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors’ Association, which rotates generally every three years. AB 964 established categories for various types of aircraft (passenger aircraft and freighter aircraft), and set forth a valuation methodology for each. The bill also directed the lead assessor to audit the airline every four years. The new methodology provided that the aircraft value was the lesser of:
- A historical cost basis, including transportation and improvement costs, as well as capitalized interest, with specific provisions for leased aircraft, aircraft in a sale/leaseback or assignment of purchase rights, or aircraft acquired in bankruptcy, with specified adjustments, or
- 10 percent off (for a fleet adjustment) on the wholesale prices listed in the “Airliner Pricing Guide,” If the APG ceases to exist, BOE determines the guide or adjustment.
AB 964 also included an adjustment factor to account for economic obsolescence, where assessors analyze the change in three variables to determine whether larger economic forces are diminishing the aircraft’s value. To determine economic obsolescence for mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor calculates three factors for both the previous calendar year and the past ten years: average net revenue per seat mile, net load factor, and yield. The assessor then compares each factor’s previous calendar year value with its value for the past ten years to determine the amount of difference. Next, the assessor applies a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments: net revenue per available seat mile (35 percent), net load (35 percent), and yield (30 percent). The assessor must reduce the original cost by the percentage, but only if the final economic obsolescence exceeds 10 percent.
In 2009, AB 311 (Ma), as introduced, would have made the valuation methodology and centralized provisions permanent and, as amended, would have extended the effective date. However, Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed the bill because one airline disagreed with extending the valuation methodology, and the timing of AB 964’s sunset allowed another year for all the parties to reach consensus. The Governor signed a similar bill the following year (AB 384, Ma, 2010). AB 384 extended the lead assessor model and the valuation methodology until 2015-16, but differed from AB 311 by (1) replacing language specifying value with a rebuttable presumption (previously, the methodology-produced value was deemed to be the aircraft’s fair market value), (2) allowing the taxpayer to rebut the presumption with appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony, and (3) allowing aircraft to be valued lower than the APG guide value by capping an aircraft’s value at its original cost. The maximum value cap provision was added to appease the airline that opposed AB 311 in the prior year. In calculating total fleet values, this provision requires the county to substitute the original price paid when it is lower than wholesale price less 10 percent for any individual aircraft in the fleet. This reduces the total fleet value for any airline able to purchase new planes at deeper discounts.
In 2015, the Legislature enacted AB 1157 (Nazarian), which extended the sunset date of the lead county methodology by one year, through 2016-17. Thus, under current law absent legislation, beginning in 2017-18 each county would once again value certificated aircraft based on its fair market value without statutory guidance.
Trial De Novo. Under current law, in a refund action for locally assessed property taxes, where the issue is a question of law, the taxpayer has a right to a trial de novo; the court is able to receive and consider new evidence. However, where the issue is a question of fact, the court is restricted to a review of the assessment appeals board findings and decisions (i.e., the administrative record). With respect to factual issues, the superior court’s level of review is limited to determining whether “substantial evidence” in the record exists to support the appeals board’s decision.
Thus, taxpayers seeking to appeal an assessor’s valuation of locally-assessed property generally contact the assessor initially informally to request a reconsideration of the value. If this avenue proves unsuccessful, taxpayers begin the formal appeal process (which can include a claim for refund) with the county's board of equalization (i.e., the assessment appeals board). For taxes on locally-assessed property, the Constitution places the appellate authority for locally-assessed property taxes with the county board of equalization, and requires this appeals board to equalize the value of all property by adjusting individual assessments. Seventeen county boards of supervisors, primarily smaller counties, hear appeals directly, sitting as the county board of equalization, while all other county boards of supervisors create one or more assessment appeals boards to perform the quasi-judicial role to hold a hearing to determine value of the taxpayer’s property when there is a dispute. Assessment appeals board members must complete a training program, and possess five years' professional experience in California as a certified public accountant or public accountant, licensed real estate broker, attorney, or property appraiser. However, in smaller counties, someone “possessed of competent knowledge of property appraisal and taxation,” can be appointed by board of supervisor members without professional experience.
Taxpayers who continue to disagree with the assessment appeal board's value after the appellate process can file suit in Superior Court within six months of the board’s final determination; however, for suits that aren’t posing a question of law, the court can only review the existing administrative record to determine whether substantial evidence supports the appeals board’s decision, and cannot substitute its own independent judgment. In these cases, the trial court generally acts as the appellate court, and only grants review for "arbitrariness, abuse of discretion, or failure to follow the standards prescribed by the Legislature," as they see the county assessment appeals process as performing the same fact-finding functions as trial courts.
In contrast, current law provides state assessees with a right to a trial de novo in a suit for the refund of state-assessed property taxes. In these refund actions, the trial court is not restricted to a “substantial evidence” review of the administrative record, but is required to consider all admissible evidence relating to the valuation of the subject property. This law requires the trial court to base its decision on the "preponderance of the evidence" before it. In the case of local-assessee refund actions, the courts are required to give these cases special precedence. However, in the case of state-assessee actions seeking a refund of property taxes, courts are not required to give precedence to these actions over all other civil actions in the matter of setting for hearing or trial, unless special precedence is granted by another section of law.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend for five fiscal years (through 2021-22) the commercial air carrier administrative provisions (the extension of the lead county methodology), otherwise set to expire, with one exception: the removal of the provision that allows a 10 percent fleet discount from the Airliner Price Guide and a related adjustment for aircraft that is less than two years old. Additionally, the bill would extend the current state assessee “trial de novo” provisions to a suit for the refund of locally assessed property taxes exclusively for commercial air carriers. Specifically, the trial court “may not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all the evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence. The court shall base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence.” The bill would repeal these trial de novo provisions on January 1, 2022, consistent with the sunset of the aircraft assessment valuation methodology and the lead county system. These airline-related suits would not be given precedence in the court scheduling.
Related Legislation: Among other things, AB 2622 (Nazarian) also proposes to extend the sunset date for the certificated aircraft assessment methodology and lead county system. That bill extends the provisions for three more fiscal years. The bill is currently in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
BOE indicates that in 2015-16, counties reported certificated aircraft valuation totaling $8.0 billion. Thus, at the basic one percent property tax rate, local property tax revenues were $80 million. The bill’s removal of the 10 percent fleet discount reduction would lead to an increase in assessed valuation, and in turn, an increase in property tax revenue. The magnitude of the increase, however, is unknown. The reason for this is, to the extent that airlines exert monoposy power when purchasing aircraft from manufacturers such as Boeing, it is possible that they could negotiate a price below “the wholesale price listed in the Airliner Price Guide less 10 percent”. In other words, they may make their purchases at a price such they cannot take the full 10 percent discount that the bill proposes to remove. Thus, the upper bound of the annual increase in property tax revenue would be $8 million.
The bill’s extension of “trial de novo” provisions to property tax refund litigation involving certificated aircraft would have an unknown impact on aircraft assessments and resulting property tax revenue. Because under trial de novo, the court shall consider “all evidence,” it is possible that the court would determine an assessed value higher than what was determined by the local assessor. More likely, however, the court could determine assessed value to be lower than that calculated by an assessor. Thus, the specific revenue impact of the bill’s proposed provisions relative to current practice (the lead county system) cannot be determined.
However, under the rules of this Committee, the bill’s revenue impacts must be scored relative to current law, not current practice. As was discussed previously, the lead county system under current law is scheduled to sunset at the end of 2016-17. Consequently, the Committee must compare the estimated revenue impacts of the bill vis-à-vis what certificated aircraft assessments and resulting property tax collections would be if the lead county system expired and assessors instead resumed valuing certificated aircraft based on its fair market value without statutory guidance. Because total property tax revenue under that regime is unknown, estimating the revenue impact of this bill cannot be done with any degree of certainty.
Likewise, because of the linkage between local property taxes and General Fund Proposition 98 spending, the impact of this bill on state spending is unknown.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1329 (Author:Hertzberg)
Version: April 14, 2016
Hearing Date: April 19, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TMW
SUBJECT
Property taxation: certificated aircraft
DESCRIPTION
This bill, in suits for the refund of locally assessed property taxes relating to certificated aircraft, would require a trial court to consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property under the rules of evidence and require the court to base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it. This bill would also extend the 2016–17 fiscal year termination date to fiscal year 2021-22 and the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2021, for provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
BACKGROUND
Under current case, law county boards of equalization are quasi-judicial agencies, and their decisions regarding the valuation of property are equivalent to the determination of a trial court, which may be reviewed only for arbitrariness, abuse of discretion, or failure to follow the standards prescribed by law. Generally, however, current law provides that the scope of review of quasi-judicial administrative agencies is limited to whether the agency acted within its jurisdiction, and, whether, if it is alleged that the agency abused its discretion, the findings of the agency are not supported by substantial evidence based on the administrative record.
In 1988, SB 2601 (Garamendi, Chapter 1372, Statutes of 1988) would have expressly set forth the scope of superior court jurisdiction in reviewing any action for a refund of property taxes assessed by local counties or the State Board of Equalization (BOE). The court would not be limited to a substantial review of the administrative record on which to base its decision, but would be required to hear all evidence, which could include expert testimony excluded by the local county board or BOE, requiring independent judicial review relating to the valuation of property admissible under the rules of evidence. SB 2601 also required the court to base its decision on the preponderance of the evidence before it. The stated purpose of that measure was to enable taxpayers to have evidence of property valuation that has been conclusively determined by a county board re-weighed by the Superior Court in a trial de novo (new trial). Prior to its passage, SB 2601 was subsequently scaled back to only authorize independent judicial review in actions for a refund of state-assessed property taxes. Unlike local county property assessments where the local county assessor establishes the property tax and an appeal of that assessment is reviewed by a separate local county board of equalization, the BOE is both the state assessing agency and the administrative reviewer.
SB 657 (Maddy, Chapter 498, Statutes of 1995) initially extended to all local county tax refund actions the trial de novo established for BOE refund actions established in SB 2601. This provision was subsequently amended out of that bill. This bill contains the same provision but would only apply to actions relating to certificated aircraft, which are aircraft authorized under federal law to engage in air transportation.
SB 1903 (Maddy, 1996), among other things, also contained a provision similar to this bill and authorized suits for the refund of locally assessed property taxes to require trial courts to independently review all evidence. While SB 1903 was in this Committee, the bill failed passage with that provision. The bill was amended in this Committee to strike that provision and instead provide independent judicial review of specified evidence submitted by a taxpayer to rebut the presumption that the county board’s findings are correct, after the trial judge determines that a preponderance of the evidence in the record supports a different factual finding. SB 1903 passed out of the Committee but was subsequently held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 1293 (Schiff, 1999) also initially contained a provision similar to this bill but was amended in this Committee to instead, in a suit for refund of locally assessed property taxes, require the trial court to exercise its independent judgment on the evidence, as specified. SB 1293 was ultimately gutted and amended for a new author and restricted the labeling of wine originated in Napa County. (SB 1293 (Chesbro, Ch. 831, Stats. 2000).)
AB 934 (Hertzberg, 2001) initially contained an independent judicial review provision substantially similar to this bill but was amended in the Senate Local Government Committee to instead require the trial court to exercise independent judgment on the evidence, as specified, in a suit for refund of locally assessed property taxes or a judicial action filed by the assessor challenging the findings of the county board. If the county prevailed in the suit for refund of locally assessed property taxes, AB 934 also required the taxpayer to reimburse the county for the full amount of both its attorney’s fees, and the assessor staff time necessary for litigation support incurred in litigating the factual issues in the action. After passing out of the Senate Local Government Committee, AB 934 was held in the Senate Rules Committee.
This bill, until January 2, 2022, would expand independent judicial review to local county property tax refund actions for certificated aircraft.
This bill was heard by the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance on April 13, 2016, and passed out on a vote of 5-0. This bill was double-referred to the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance because it contains provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the California Constitution, requires all property taxed by local government to be assessed in the county, city, and district in which it is situated. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, sec. 14.)
Existing law specifies that the county board of supervisors, or one or more assessment appeals boards created by the county board of supervisors, shall constitute the county board of equalization for a county, and two or more county boards of supervisors may jointly create one or more assessment appeals boards which shall constitute the county board of equalization for each of the participating counties. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, sec. 16.)
Existing law provides that after payment of a tax claimed to be illegal, an action may be maintained to recover the tax paid, with interest, in such manner as may be provided by the Legislature. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, sec. 32.)
Existing law requires all taxable property, except State assessed property, to be assessed by the assessing agency of the taxing agency where the property is situated. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 404.)
Existing law, for the 2005-06 fiscal year to the 2016-17 fiscal year, inclusive, provides a method for determining the preallocated fair market value of certificated aircraft. (Rev. & Tax Sec. 401.17.)
Existing law defines “certificated aircraft” to mean aircraft operated by an air carrier or foreign air carrier engaged in air transportation, as defined under federal law, while there is in force a certificate or permit issued by the Federal Aviation Administration, or its successor, authorizing such air carrier to engage in such transportation. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 1150.)
Existing law, until December 31, 2016, requires a commercial air carrier whose certificated aircraft is subject to tax assessment, as specified, to file with the lead county assessor’s office, as specified, one signed property statement for its personal property at all airport locations and fixtures at all airport locations. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 441.) Existing law, until December 31, 2016, allows each commercial air carrier to file one schedule for all of its certificated aircraft that have acquired situs in California, allows flight data required to compute certificated aircraft allocation to be segregated by airport location, and authorizes a commercial air carrier to file the property statement electronically through the California Assessor’s Standard Data Record (SDR) network. (Id.)
Existing law, for purposes of determining the assessing agency of taxable property, deems certificated aircraft to be situated only in those taxing agencies in which the aircraft normally make physical contact with sufficient regularity to entitle such agencies to tax the aircraft under the laws and Constitution of the United States. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 1155.) Flight time within the state is allocated as follows:
- if the aircraft takes off in one taxing agency which is entitled to tax (within the meaning of the preceding sentence) and lands in another agency which is entitled to tax, the flight time between such taxing agencies shall be allocated one-half to each such agency; and
- if the aircraft arrives from out of state or leaves the state, the flight time from or to the state boundary shall be allocated to the taxing agency entitled to tax in which the aircraft first lands or last takes off, as the case may be. (Id.)
Existing law requires taxpayers to file a claim for refund before a civil action can be commenced. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5142.)
Existing law requires all courts where actions are brought regarding tax corrections, cancellations, and refunds (with the exclusion of actions regarding state annual assessments of pipelines, flumes, canals, ditches, and aqueducts lying within two or more counties and property, except franchises, owned or used by regulated railway, telegraph, telephone companies, or car companies) to give those actions precedence over all other civil actions, except actions to which special precedence is given by law, in the matter of setting the same for hearing or trial, and in hearing the same, to the end that all those actions shall be quickly heard and determined. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5149.)
Existing law, in suits for the refund of state-assessed property taxes, provides that the trial court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but shall consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence, and requires the court to base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence before it. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5170.)
This bill would extend the method for determining the preallocated fair market value of certificated aircraft from fiscal year 2005-06 to fiscal year 2021-22.
This bill would extend from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2021, the commercial air carrier property statement provisions.
This bill, until January 1, 2022, would extend to taxpayer refund civil actions regarding certificated aircraft the requirement that a trial court consider all evidence relating to the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence and require the court to base its decision upon the preponderance of evidence before it.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
Section One of Article XIII of the California Constitution provides that all property is taxable and shall be assessed at the same percentage of fair market value, unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. While the Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1 [percent] of full cash value, and precludes reassessment unless the property is newly constructed or changes ownership, assessors value personal property like certificated aircraft each year. The Constitution requires that property be assessed … in the county, city, or district, in which it is situated. While the Legislature first directed county assessors to tax property in 1849, assessors in different counties often applied different tax rates and methods of assessment. To remedy the lack of uniformity, the California Constitution of 1879 created the Board of Equalization (BOE) to equalize rates and assessment practices among counties. In 1910, voters amended the Constitution to direct BOE to value property owned by railways, companies selling gas and electricity, or telephone companies, as these companies own property that crosses county lines. The Constitution additionally allows the Legislature to authorize BOE assessment of property owned or used as “public utilities.”
I. Valuing Certificated Aircraft. The lead assessor methodology will sunset for the 2017-18 fiscal year unless the Legislature extends it, in which case assessors will again value certificated aircraft based on its fair market value without specific guidance from state law.
II. Trial De Novo. The locally-assessed property tax is the only one in California where the assessor as prosecutor can be the same as the assessment appeals board sitting in judgment. This process is fundamentally unfair to taxpayers, which is why it is so rare both in California and in other states. Tax experts have often recommended trial de novo for local property taxes in various forms, arguing that a judicial process will determine more accurate values than assessment appeals boards. These experts argue that assessment appeals boards or county boards of supervisors sitting as the county board of equalization can have an interest in the revenue consequences of appeals, can be too deferential to assessors, or lack the experience and expertise necessary to set appropriate value, especially for more complex property like certificated aircraft. While setting a precedent by applying de novo review to only one form of locally-assessed personal property, certificated aircraft is already unique, as it is currently the only form of personal property with its own, distinct valuation methodology set in state law. Aircraft is also distinct from other locally-assessed property because it travels between jurisdictions, and can have its economic value change due to forces beyond the control of its owners, like economic recessions and terrorist attacks.
Senate Bill 1329 extends the lead-assessor model of valuing certificated aircraft to [fiscal year 2021-22] . . ., and directs that court[s] must consider suits for the refund of locally assessed property taxes on certificated aircraft de novo by adding these valuations into the statute that currently applies only to state assessments conducted by [the State Board of Equalization (BOE)]. Where a taxpayer challenges a lead assessor’s valuation of certificated aircraft, the court shall not be restricted to the administrative record, but must consider all evidence relating to the valuation under the rules of evidence, and base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence. The bill’s trial de novo authorization sunsets . . ., at which time the law reverts to its current state.
2. Standard of review and trial de novo
Article XIII of the California Constitution provides the framework for the assessment of property taxes by local governments. Section 16 of that Article provides that the county board of supervisors, or one or more appeals boards created by the county board of supervisors, shall constitute the county board of equalization for the county. The county board of equalization is solely responsible for equalizing the values of all property on the local assessment role by adjusting individual assessments. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, sec. 16.) Most counties with any sizable population exercise their right under this constitutional provision to appoint an assessment appeals board, or boards, to act as the county board of equalization.
No judicial action challenging a property tax assessment or requesting a refund may be brought unless a claim has first been brought and refused by the county board of equalization, and no recovery shall be allowed in judicial action for refund upon any ground not specified in the original refund claim. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5142.) A county board is not bound by technical rules of evidence. (Norby Lumber Co. v. County of Madera (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 1352, 1362.) The duty of conclusively determining the value of the property and the fairness of the assessment is conferred upon the local county board of equalization, which bases its determination upon the merits of the controversy. (Ibid.) As such, the taxpayer has no right to a trial de novo in the superior court to resolve conflicting issues of fact as to the taxable value of the property. (Ibid.) The decision of a county board of equalization is equivalent to the determination of a trial court and may be reviewed only for arbitrariness, abuse of discretion, or failure to follow the standards prescribed by law. (Bret Harte Inn, Inc. v. City & County of San Francisco (1976) 16 Cal.3d 14.)
Accordingly, the court must uphold the county board’s decision on an issue of fact if it is supported by “substantial evidence,” which means merely that the decision must be supported by “credible” evidence in the administrative record. The court has no power to exercise its independent judgment on the evidence, and the “trial” is confined to the record presented by the board, with no new evidence introduced. The standard of review is to be distinguished from a “weight of the evidence” test, which would require a finding, based on independent evaluation of the evidence, that the board’s decision was supported by a preponderance of the evidence. This restricted standard of review applies only to issues of fact, which generally means the issue of whether the assessment method used was applied correctly. A challenge to the validity of the method itself would be an issue of law.
Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.5 provides for both an independent judgment and a substantial evidence review of administrative decisions. Where it is claimed that the findings are not supported by the evidence, in cases in which the court is authorized by law to exercise its independent judgment on the evidence, abuse of discretion is established if the court determines that the findings are not supported by the weight of the evidence, and in all other cases, abuse of discretion is established if the court determines that the findings are not supported by substantial evidence in the light of the whole record. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1094.5(c).)
If the administrative decision does not involve, or substantially affect, any fundamental vested right, the trial court must still review the entire administrative record to determine whether the findings are supported by substantial evidence and whether the agency committed any errors of law, but the trial court need not look beyond that whole record of the administrative proceedings. (Bixby v. Pierno (1971) 4 Cal. 3d 130, 144.) Courts can carefully scrutinize administrative decisions which substantially affect vested, fundamental rights, particularly the right to protect one’s trade or profession. (Id., p. 143.) If the decision of an administrative agency will substantially affect such a right, the trial court not only examines the administrative record for errors of law but also exercises its independent judgment upon the evidence disclosed in a limited trial de novo. (Ibid.)
Notably, this Committee’s analysis of the legislation that enacted SB 2601 (Garamendi, Chapter 1372, Statutes of 1988) and authorized independent judicial review of BOE determinations noted that the arguments in favor of that bill emphasized “the need for the hearing of appropriate evidence by the superior courts is especially great in the case of state assesses, because the SBE (State Board of Equalization) is both the assessing agency and the administrative reviewer. The sponsor, therefore, is concerned about the fact that the SBE reviews its own assessments. It suggests that a more favorable arrangement is found in the case of locally assessed property where the assessor and the assessment appeals board which review the assessor’s assessment are at least separate.” (Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of Sen. Bill No. 2601 (1987-1988 Reg. Sess.) as amended Apr. 4, 1988; emphasis added.) However, this bill now seeks to expand independent judicial review and a trial de novo to apply to locally assessed property, requiring full review of the administrative case, as well as potential expert valuation testimony or other evidence that may have been excluded by the appeals board or not provided by the taxpayer, but only for commercial airlines with certificated aircraft.
According to the California Taxpayers Association (CTA), in support:
In 1910, the California Constitution was amended to transfer industries with significant impacts on critical statewide functions that owned property across county lines from local assessment to central state assessment under the State Board of Equalization. These industries include utilities, railroads and telecommunications, and as state assessees they are granted trial de novo. The first commercial passenger airline did not exist until 1914 -- 4 years after the constitutional amendment. Had the airlines existed in 1910, they would have been covered by the constitutional amendment, and therefore afforded trial de novo as state assessees.
Airlines for America (A4A), sponsor, contends that certificated aircraft should be treated like public utilities for purposes of local county tax assessments because aircraft are transported to multiple jurisdictions. Indeed, public utilities cross multiple county lines but are assessed by the BOE, not local counties, and, thus, receive independent judicial review by trial courts. A4A asserts that certificated aircraft should not be assessed at the local level, but, instead, have a centralized assessment at the state level, like public utilities. According to A4A, an effort last year attempted to move local assessment of certificated aircraft to the state level, but that effort was unsuccessful. Since commercial airlines were unable to get centralized state assessments, they are now attempting to obtain independent judicial review of local county assessments of certificated aircraft.
3. Providing fairness to commercial airlines in tax disputes
The author asserts that the locally-assessed property tax is the only one in California where the assessor as prosecutor can be the same as the assessment appeals board sitting in judgment. The author argues that this process is fundamentally unfair to taxpayers, which is why it is so rare both in California and in other states. The author contends that “tax experts have often recommended trial de novo for local property taxes in various forms, arguing that a judicial process will determine more accurate values than assessment appeals boards. These experts argue that assessment appeals boards or county boards of supervisors sitting as the county board of equalization can have an interest in the revenue consequences of appeals, can be too deferential to assessors, or lack the experience and expertise necessary to set appropriate value, especially for more complex property like certificated aircraft.”
The author points to a recent audit performed by the Santa Clara Management Audit Division, which determined that conflicts of interest existed in the local county appeals board process. That audit found that although Santa Clara County’s Local Rules require the Clerk to schedule assessment appeals, “[i]n practice, however, the Office of the Assessor and individual appraisers have significant influence over when an appeal will be heard, and by which board, through the development of proposed hearing agendas that are generally accepted by the Clerk’s office.” (Management Audit Division of Santa Clara County, Management Audit of the County of Santa Clara Assessment Appeals Process (July 15, 2015) <https://www.sccgov.org/sites/bos/ Management%20Audit/Documents/Management-Audit-of-Assessment-Appeals-071515.pdf> [as of Apr. 14, 2016] p. ii.) The audit stated that because the specific dates on which each of the three boards are scheduled to hear cases are known in advance, preparing these proposed agendas allows the Office of the Assessor influence over which appeals board will hear a particular case. (Id., p. 43.) Further, this problem had an adverse effect and “[t]he lack of adequate controls on the agenda-setting process, including any formal tracking of the distribution of appeals, raises concerns about the appearance of potential conflicts of interest.” (Id., p. 42.)
Additionally, the audit concluded that “[c]urrent County practice does not appear to follow California constitutional requirements which mandate ‘uniformity in the processing and decision of assessment appeals applications,’ . . . .” (Supra, p. 51.) That audit recommended amending the current administrative procedures to require the Clerk of the Board to establish assessment appeals board agendas based on receiving a “notice of readiness” from the Office of the Assessor for each appeal to place the Clerk of the Board in full compliance with the California Constitution and the County’s Local Rules governing the appeals process. (Id., p. 42.)
The author argues that while setting a precedent by applying de novo review to only one form of locally-assessed personal property, certificated aircraft is already unique, as it is currently the only form of personal property with its own, distinct valuation methodology set in state law. The author notes that aircraft is also distinct from other locally-assessed property because it travels between jurisdictions, and can have its economic value change due to forces beyond the control of its owners, like economic recessions and terrorist attacks.
Opponents of the bill argue that the shifting of duties and responsibilities of the county board of equalization to the trial courts for air carrier assessment appeals is troubling because judges lack expertise on property valuation methods, whereas an assessment appeals board member is appointed to his or her position based on career experience in relevant fields. Opponents point out that each board member is required by law to successfully pass State BOE training on valuation methods, procedures, and property conduct, which is not required of trial court judges.
4. Constitutionality concerns
The opposition notes that the California Constitution confers quasi-judicial powers and duties upon local county boards of equalization in connection with their assessments and review of contested assessments of locally assessed property. As such, legislation providing for a departure from the “substantial evidence” standard of review, whereby the trial court would not be restricted to the administrative record but instead would be required to independently consider all admissible evidence regarding contested local assessments, would, if enacted, be unconstitutional. The assessment of property for the purpose of taxation is a function of the executive branch of the government and the judiciary has no power or jurisdiction to inquire as to the actual value of property to determine whether or not it has been properly assessed. (Domenghini v. County of San Luis Obispo (1974) 40 Cal.App.3d 689, 696.)
In response, the author states that “[c]ounties and assessors argue that the Legislature can’t Constitutionally delegate authority to courts to review local assessments, citing a Legislative Counsel Enrolled Bill Report from 1988 on SB 2601, and Legislative Counsel Opinion #14821 from 2001, which argue that case law precludes the Legislature from enacting a statute that usurps the constitutionally-based fact finding authority of an administrative body. Counsel states that this same reasoning applies to any bill that would allow a trial court to consider evidence outside the county board of equalization’s administrative record. However, SB 1329 adopts a more positive view of legislative power, instead arguing that the Legislature can enact statutes directing courts to consider new facts because the Constitution contains no specific language prohibiting it from doing so, and the Constitution explicitly allows the Legislature to provide a manner for taxpayers to maintain an action to recover taxes paid illegally. A trial court affirmed SB 2601 in 1989, for which the Third District Court of Appeals rejected a writ of mandate the year after, despite the Legislative Counsel guidance.”
5. Effect on administrative hearings
Opponents assume that the intent of the bill is to permit the trial court to re-try the determinations made by county boards as to factual and valuation questions. Opponents assert that if a complete trial de novo is granted as provided by this bill, the importance of the administrative review function of the county boards would be lessened. Commercial airlines would still be required to exhaust administrative remedies before going to court, but the exhaustion principle would be undermined. The administrative hearing would become more of a formality than an effective means of resolving disputes. Both parties by the nature of the system would tend to save their best evidence for the courts.
Furthermore, the opposition notes that while this bill is targeted just to benefit commercial airlines, other industries may demand a similar special property reduction if this bill becomes law. Opponents note that during the last two decades, the California Legislature has rejected this assault on a fair and equitable property tax system four times. Opponents note that each time trial de novo has been rejected on the merits, as it is fundamentally inconsistent with previous initiatives to reform government by improving efficiency, productivity and performance. Opponents contend that this bill does just the opposite by adding another layer of bureaucracy to benefit a single industry.
6. Priority of taxpayer refund cases
Existing law provides that taxpayer refund actions enjoy priority over all other civil actions. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5149.) Excluded from this special priority are actions regarding annual state assessments of property made pursuant to Section 19 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, which requires the BOE to annually assess water conduits and property, except franchises, owned or used by regulated railway, telegraph, or telephone companies, car companies operating on railways in the State, and companies transmitting or selling gas or electricity. (Rev. & Tax Code Secs. 5148, 721; Cal. Const., art. XIII, Sec. 19.) This property is subject to taxation to the same extent and in the same manner as other property. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, sec. 19.)
As discussed in Comment 2, public utilities are multijurisdictional and cross county lines. The BOE assesses the value of the assets of a utility using a unitary value of the property, which is then transmitted to each county through a “roll,” and each county taxes the utility according to the Board-adopted value of the property that is in that county. (Verizon California Inc. v. Board of Equalization (2014) 230 Cal.App.4th 666, 672.) The BOE makes a formulary allocation that has little or no relationship to the actual fair market value of the particular assets situated within the jurisdiction. (Ibid.) This formulary allocation system sets up a complex case for courts to analyze under an independent judicial review, especially when both sides to the action submit conflicting expert testimony.
As noted by A4A, certificated aircraft are currently assessed using a “lead county” system, where a single county recommends a value for an air carrier’s fleet of planes to the assessors of all of the counties in which that carrier operates. A4A asserts that “SB 1329 represents a ‘middle ground’ alternative, in which for a 5-year period, industry agrees to abandon its call for centralized assessment at the state level, and agree to continue the current lead county system and valuation methodology. However, SB 1329 would modify the worst element of that existing system by treating commercial aircraft fleets the same as other types of property held by multi-jurisdictional quasi-public utilities with regard to judicial review of lead county assessments.”
A4A contends that certificated aircraft should be treated like public utilities for purposes of local county tax assessments because, like public utilities, certificated aircraft traverse multiple jurisdictions. Public utilities are assessed by the BOE and receive independent judicial review by trial courts. On the other hand, certificated aircraft are assessed at the local level, so those refund actions challenging the assessments receive only substantial review of the administrative record.
Existing law provides trial court priority for commercial airline tax refund cases; however, public utilities are expressly exempt from trial court priority, presumably due to the complexity of valuation of those types of actions. Certificated aircraft refund actions regarding local county assessments only require the court to review the administrative record to make a determination, so the current priority given to these actions is not especially problematic. However, this bill would significantly extend the court’s time spent hearing these actions because the court would have to consider more evidence, such as expert witnesses testimony presented by the parties. As such, maintaining the priority for these refund actions, with independent judicial review, would result in courts taking even longer to resolve other civil actions that were set aside in favor of these taxpayer refund actions.
On the other hand, A4A argues that this bill, “by opening the possibility of real court review of assessments of commercial aircraft, will have the effect of requiring assessors to more carefully consider all evidence of value prior to making the assessment, and require assessment appeals boards to more carefully consider appraisals and expert testimony bearing on value in appeals hearings. The result will be more thorough, well thought out and better assessment practices, ultimately resulting in less litigation.”
The Committee may wish to consider whether the bill should be amended to exclude locally-assessed certificated aircraft tax refund cases from receiving priority status in trial courts.
7. Burden on the courts
Existing law requires independent judicial review for taxpayer refund actions involving state-assessed property. (Rev. & Tax Code Sec. 5170.) This bill, until January 1, 2022, would extend that requirement to locally-assessed certificated aircraft tax refund actions. Although this bill would affect a significantly smaller number of taxpayer cases than prior bills to expand trial de novo review to only those involving certificated aircraft, this bill would require the court to hear and review more evidence than provided in the administrative record.
Opponents contend that this bill would increase the case load, cost and complexity of civil cases, and impair the courts’ ability to conduct civil trials in a timely manner, a significant change in California’s established property tax system. Opponents also assert that the Legislature should be working to reduce the caseloads in California courts, not increasing their workloads as the trial de novo provision would unquestionably do.
These cases are complex by nature and require significant amounts of time to resolve. A Statement of Decision received by the Committee in AT&T Communications of California, et al. v. State Board of Equalization, et al., Superior Court of California, County of Sacramento, No. 50082 and 50083 (Consolidated), February 1, 1991, at pp. 3-5, demonstrates the burden on the courts in requiring independent review for this type of multijurisdictional property. In that Decision, the court noted:
By enacting Revenue & Taxation Code section 5170, effective January 1, 1989, the Legislature imposed on already overburdened trial courts the complex subject of valuation of public utilities. Before the enactment of Section 5170, the function of the Court was to review the administrative record to determine whether or not the market value of property, as determined by the [BOE], was supported by substantial evidence. After the enactment of Section 5170, the function of the court is to make an independent determination of market value based on a preponderance of the evidence. The Court, by the terms of Section 5170, is not restricted by the administrative record, but is to consider all evidence relating to valuation which is admissible under the Rules of Evidence. The burden of proof is upon the plaintiff property owner. As is to be expected, the trial of such actions takes substantially longer than the administrative hearing, as each side not only presents those portions of the administrative record which are favorable to its position but presents testimony from experts and others to fortify its position.
The inevitable result of a trial of such actions is that the Court, by its decision, imposes on the Board the judgment of the trial judge as to how market value is to be determined. If the trial judge determines that the [BOE’s] methods of valuation are incorrect, then it sends a message to the [BOE] to change those methods of valuation to those the judge believes to be appropriate, regardless of how difficult, time-consuming, or expensive it may be to implement those methods. In the usual situation, the Court must choose which method of valuation is the one most likely to lead to the correct value, unless it elects to pick and choose from the expert testimony to arrive at a market value which the Court determines is fair and reasonable under the evidence in the case.
. . .
By virtue of hearing a case on valuation, a trial judge ostensibly becomes an expert on valuation, whose opinion is to be accepted over experts who have devoted their lives to the subject. . . . If this Court has learned anything in this trial, it is that determining the fair market value of a public utility is a most difficult task. It is an issue over which reasonable minds – both judges and experts on valuation – may differ markedly.
Notably, this preliminary comment by the court was made 25 years ago and long before the recent Recession and resulting budget crises of the courts from which courts are still digging out.
The author states that “[c]ounties argue that assessment appeals board[s], and not courts have more expertise at valuing property, and allowing trial de novo would only increase assessors’ costs and workloads without any commensurate benefit of more accurate assessments. However, allowing a court to review new evidence only ensures additional review that assessments are fair and correct, and would only be brought in truly justified circumstances given the cost of litigation. The bill merely allow[s] appeals of aircraft assessment to be treated in the same way as state-assessed utilities, whose property is more like airlines’ than land, improvements, and buildings that make up most of an assessor’s workload. With a universe of fewer than 60 taxpayers being assessed under current law’s system for certificated aircraft, any impact on county or court workload would likely be small.”
8. Effect on pending litigation
A recent poll of several county civil courts revealed 43 open commercial airlines cases in Alameda, 31 open cases in Kern County, 73 open appeals in San Diego with another 13 lawsuits consolidated with similar complex cases being heard in Orange County, 19 open cases in San Mateo County. San Mateo County also noted that from 2009-2014, there were 172 commercial airline cases filed. Although the author asserts that the universe of commercial airlines who would file a civil action for a refund is under 60 taxpayers, those taxpayers can file multiple actions, for multiple assessed years, in multiple counties across the state.
Further, last year, A4A was quoted as saying in a Los Angeles Times news article that there were at least “45 pending lawsuits relating to county assessors misapplying the applicable property tax statute. (M. Hiltzik, Los Angeles Times, Airlines are Looking for a Big Tax Break in California (May 1, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/ la-fi-hiltzik-20150503-column.html> [as of Apr. 2, 2016].) That article also noted that “the lawsuits appear to be largely identical, filed in 12 counties by the same Los Angeles law firm on behalf of seven airlines. The cases all concern tax year 2009, and typically claim the same 70 [percent] reduction American and United sought from the L.A. assessor. Some of these claims already have been heard twice — first by the assessors’ office and then by county assessment appeals boards — and rejected twice.”
The author contends that the bill’s de novo review would only apply to claims for refunds for taxes paid in fiscal years on or after the effective date of the bill. However, the author notes that “some of the same unresolved issues raised in this previous litigation could be part of a suit reviewed de novo should the measure be enacted.”
The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to clarify that the trial de novo provisions in the bill would only apply to civil actions filed on or after the effective date of the bill.
9. Remaining details under the jurisdiction of the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance
The remaining sections of this bill relate to extending the unique methodology for assessing certificated aircraft and are within the jurisdiction of the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance. That committee passed this bill on April 13, 2016.
Support: Alaska Airlines; American Airlines; California Chamber of Commerce; California Taxpayers Association; Southwest Airlines; United Airlines
Opposition: California Assessors’ Association; California Association of Clerks and Election Officials; California State Association of Counties; Office of the Assessor, County of Los Angeles; Office of the Assessor, County of Santa Clara
HISTORY
Source: Airlines for America
Related Pending Legislation:
AB 2622 (Nazarian, 2016), among other things, would extend the 2016–17 fiscal year termination date to the 2019–20 fiscal year and extend the December 31, 2016, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2019, for provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
SB 661 (Hill, 2015), among other things, would have transferred assessment of personal property owned by commercial air carriers to the Board of Equalization, including certificated aircraft, commencing in 2017-18 fiscal year and would have extended the lead assessor model one year to 2016-17. SB 661 was subsequently gutted and amended to modify the “call before you dig” laws governing excavations near subsurface installations and is in the Assembly pending referral.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1157 (Nazarian, Chapter 440, Statutes of 2015) extended the 2015–16 fiscal year termination date to the 2016-17 fiscal year and the December 31, 2015, inoperative or repeal date to December 31, 2016, for provisions relating to the determination of the fair market value and taxation of certificated aircraft.
AB 384 (Ma, Chapter 228, Statutes of 2010) extended the 2010-11 fiscal year methodology for property tax assessment of certificated aircraft to the 2015-16 fiscal year.
AB 964 (Horton, Chapter 699, Statutes of 2005) established the unique methodology for fiscal years 2005-06 through 2010-11 that would be extended indefinitely in this bill for the property tax assessment of certificated aircraft in order to address the special circumstances that befell this type of property and the airline industry following the September 11, 2001, attacks.
AB 934 (Hertzberg, 2001) See Background.
SB 1293 (Chesbro, Chapter 831, Statutes of 2000) See Background.
SB 1293 (Schiff, 1999) See Background.
SB 1903 (Maddy, 1996) See Background.
SB 657 (Maddy, Chapter 498, Statutes of 1995) See Background.
SB 2601 (Garamendi, Chapter 1372, Statutes of 1988) See Background.
Prior Vote: Senate Committee on Governance and Finance (Ayes 5, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Robert M. Hertzberg, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: | SB 1329 | Hearing Date: | 4/13/16 |
Author: | Hertzberg | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 3/28/16 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Property taxation: certificated aircraft
Extends the methodology for valuing certificated aircraft; allows trial de novo for suits for refunds of locally-assessed property taxes on certificated aircraft.
Background
Section One of Article XIII of the California Constitution provides that all property is taxable and shall be assessed at the same percentage of fair market value, unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. While the Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and precludes reassessment unless the property is newly constructed or changes ownership, assessors value personal property like certificated aircraft each year. The Constitution requires that property be assessed in the county in the county, city, or district, in which it is situated. While the Legislature first directed county assessors to tax property in 1849, assessors in different counties often applied different tax rates and methods of assessment. To remedy the lack of uniformity, the California Constitution of 1879 created the Board of Equalization (BOE) to equalize rates and assessment practices among counties. In 1910, voters amended the Constitution to direct BOE to value property owned by railways, companies selling gas and electricity, or telephone companies, as these companies own property that crosses county lines. The Constitution additionally allows the Legislature to authorize BOE assessment of property owned or used as “public utilities.”
I. Valuing Certificated Aircraft. Defined as aircraft operated by a domestic or foreign air carrier engaged in passenger or freight service, assessors may only value certificated aircraft with situs in California on a fleet basis, defined as all aircraft owned by the taxpayer by make and model. For example, assessors must value an airlines’ entire A380 fleet if only one enters the state, but doesn’t include any of its 747’s if none of them do, regardless of the total number or value of a specific model the taxpayer owns. Once assessors calculate value, they must apportion it among counties based on a weighted average of the fleet’s ground and flight time (75%) and arrivals and departures (25%) measured only during the “representative period,” currently designated by BOE as the second full in week in January. This apportioned fleet value is then multiplied by the appropriate rate for the tax rate area in that county to determine tax due. Certificated aircraft doesn’t include personal planes.
Until 1998, state law did not prescribe a specific method for assessors to determine the value of aircraft, resulting in years of disagreements and litigation between assessors and airlines. In 1998, the Legislature detailed a valuation methodology for certificated aircraft which was presumed to equal the fair market value of the aircraft for those years, enacting three bills to codify a settlement agreement between several counties and airline industry representatives (AB 1807, Takasugi; AB 2318, Knox; and SB 30, Kopp). In 2003, the agreement expired, and assessors again valued aircraft without specific guidance from the Revenue and Taxation Code.
In 2006, assessors and the airlines again agreed on a new valuation methodology. Under the agreement, a “lead assessor” values each airline’s fleet (AB 964, Horton). Instead of filing property statements with each county, airlines can instead file a single consolidated statement with one lead assessor designated by the Aircraft Advisory Subcommittee of the California Assessors’ Association, which usually rotates every three years. The bill also limited audits to one performed by a multi-county audit team. Currently, assessors from ten counties (Alameda, Fresno, Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, Sacramento, San Bernardino, San Diego, San Mateo, and Santa Clara) assess the aircraft of each airline, and lead the appropriate audit teams.
To establish value, AB 964 established categories for mainline jets, regional aircraft, production freighters, and converted freighters, and detailed a valuation methodology for each. The new methodology provided that the aircraft value was the lesser of:
- A historical cost basis, or
- 10% off (for a fleet adjustment) on the wholesale prices listed in the “Airliner Pricing Guide.” If the APG ceases to exist, the Board of Equalization (BOE) must determine the guide or adjustment.
AB 964 also included a safety valve to account for economic obsolescence, where assessors analyze the change in three variables to determine whether larger economic forces are diminishing the aircraft’s value. To determine economic obsolescence for mainline jets and regional aircraft, the assessor calculates three factors for both the previous calendar year and the past ten years: average net revenue per seat mile, net load factor, and yield. The assessor then compares each factor’s previous calendar year value with its value for the past ten years to determine the amount of difference. The assessor then applies a weighted average of the indicated percentage adjustments: net revenue per available seat mile (35%), net load (35%), and yield (30%). The assessor must reduce the original cost by the percentage, but only if the final economic obsolescence exceeds 10%.
AB 964 sunset after the 2010-11 fiscal year. After Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed the first bill that extended the sunset (AB 311, Ma, 2009), he signed a similar bill the next year (AB 384, Ma, 2010). AB 384 extended the lead assessor model and the valuation methodology until the 2015-16 fiscal year, but differed from AB 311 by:
- Replacing language specifying value with a rebuttable presumption,
- Allowing the taxpayer to rebut the presumption with appraisals, invoices, and expert testimony, and
- Capping an aircraft’s value at its original cost.
Last year, the Legislature enacted AB 1157 (Nazarian), which extended the sunset by one year to the 2016-17 fiscal year. However, the lead assessor methodology will sunset for the 2017-18 fiscal year unless the Legislature extends it, in which case assessors will again value certificated aircraft based on its fair market value without specific guidance from state law.
II. Trial De Novo. Taxpayers seeking to appeal an assessor’s valuation of locally-assessed property generally contact the assessor to request a change in value, but if unsuccessful, can file an appeal (which can include a claim for refund) with the county. For taxes on locally-assessed property, the Constitution places the appellate authority for locally-assessed property taxes with county boards of supervisors sitting as the county board of equalization, and requires the board to equalize the value of all property by adjusting individual assessments. Some county boards hear appeals directly, while others create one or more assessment appeals boards to perform the quasi-judicial role to hold a hearing to determine value of the taxpayer’s property. Assessment appeals board members must complete a training program, and possess five years' professional experience in California as a certified public accountant or public accountant, licensed real estate broker, attorney, or property appraiser. However, in smaller counties, someone “possessed of competent knowledge of property appraisal and taxation,” can be appointed without professional experience. Instead of assessment appeals boards, other counties appoint hearing officers, who hold less formal hearings to review evidence presented by both the assessor and the taxpayer. In some counties, a hearing officer’s decision can final, while in others, the office recommends a value, which the taxpayers can dispute in a proceeding before the board.
Should the taxpayer continue to disagree with the county’s value after the appellate process, he or she can file suit in Superior Court within six months of the board’s final determination; however, for suits that aren’t posing a question of law, the court can only review the existing administrative record to determine whether substantial evidence supports the appeals board’s decision, and cannot substitute its own independent judgment. In these cases, the trial court generally acts as the appellate court, and only grants review for "arbitrariness, abuse of discretion, or failure to follow the standards prescribed by the Legislature," as they see the county assessment appeals process as performing the same fact-finding functions as trial courts.
Unlike local assessment, state-assessed taxpayers can appeal BOE valuations to superior court for trial de novo (SB 2601, Garamendi, 1988). Courts must consider all evidence relating the valuation of the property admissible under the rules of evidence, and base its decision of the preponderance of the evidence before it. Just like almost all other actions seeking a refund of property taxes, courts must give precedence to these actions over all other civil actions in the matter of setting for hearing or trial, unless special precedence is granted by another section of law. The airline industry wants to allow superior courts to consider valuations of certificated aircraft derived under the lead-assessor model.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 1329 extends the current lead assessor system for valuing certificated aircraft, including the valuation methodology, and the ability of an owner of certificated aircraft to file a single property statement with a lead assessor, among others, to an unspecified date. The measure also provides that the court must consider suits for the refund of locally assessed property taxes on certificated aircraft de novo. It does this by adding these valuations into the statute that currently applies only to state assessments conducted by BOE. Where a taxpayer challenges a lead assessor’s valuation of certificated aircraft, the court would not be restricted to the administrative record, but would consider all evidence relating to the valuation under the rules of evidence, and base its decision upon the preponderance of the evidence. The bill’s trial de novo authorization sunsets after an unspecified date, at which time the law reverts to its current state.
State Revenue Impact
BOE states that SB 1329’s revenue impact from extending the existing methodology for valuing certificated aircraft is unknown, and indeterminable for its trial de novo provisions.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The locally-assessed property tax is the only one in California where the assessor as prosecutor can be the same as the assessment appeals board sitting in judgment. This process is fundamentally unfair to taxpayers, which is why it is so rare both in California and in other states. While I have authored legislation in the past that would have offered trial de novo for all local assessments, SB 1329 only affords this treatment for aircraft, because the airlines face fundamentally more complex assessments than almost all other locally-assessed property: aircraft is both extremely valuable and travels every day from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and can have its value drastically changed by larger forces, like economic recessions and terrorist attacks. Allowing a court to review new evidence only ensures additional review that assessments are fair and correct, and would only be brought in truly justified circumstances given the cost of litigation. SB 1329 would allow appeals of aircraft assessment to be treated in the same way as state-assessed utilities, whose property is more like airlines’ than land, improvements, and buildings that make up most of an assessor’s workload.”
2. Can it be done? Legal experts dispute whether the Legislature can constitutionally delegate to trial courts the quasi-judicial fact finding authority the Constitution currently places with county boards of equalization, as SB 1329 would for locally-assessed certificated aircraft. A Legislative Counsel Enrolled Bill Report from 1988 on SB 2601, and Legislative Counsel Opinion #14821 from 2001 argue that such a delegation is unconstitutional, stating that case law precludes the Legislature from enacting a statute that usurps the constitutionally-based fact finding authority of an administrative body. Counsel states that this same reasoning applies to any bill that would allow a trial court to consider evidence outside the county board of equalization’s administrative record. However, other legal experts have a more positive view of legislative power, instead arguing that the Legislature can enact statutes directing courts to consider new facts because the Constitution contains no specific language prohibiting it from doing so, and add that the Constitution explicitly allows the Legislature to provide a manner for taxpayers to maintain an action to recover taxes paid illegally. These experts also point out that a trial court affirmed SB 2601 in 1989, for which the Third District Court of Appeals rejected a writ of mandate the year after, despite the Legislative Counsel guidance.
3. Should it be done? Since the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee’ 1966 report, tax experts have often recommended trial de novo for local property taxes in various forms, arguing that a judicial process will determine more accurate values than assessment appeals boards. These experts argue that assessment appeals boards or county boards of supervisors sitting as the county board of equalization can have an interest in the revenue consequences of appeals, can be too deferential to assessors, or lack the experience and expertise necessary to set appropriate value, especially for more complex property. However, counties argue that assessment appeals board are independent and impartial, and fairly value properties according to the law. Counties add that allowing courts to consider new evidence when determining value would significantly increase workloads and costs, especially for those without the legal resources necessary to compete in court with sophisticated taxpayers like airlines. Additionally, trial de novo already exists for state assessed property taxes, and for other state taxpayers when BOE decides against their appeal (but not for the state when BOE sides with the taxpayer). SB 1329 would set a precedent in locally-assessed taxes for certificated aircraft, which other taxpayers with complex valuation issues may want themselves should the measure be enacted. However, certificated aircraft is already unique, as it is currently the only form of personal property with its own, distinct valuation methodology set in state law, and is distinct from other locally-assessed property because it travels between jurisdictions. On the other hand, it’s difficult to identify the specific issues in which assessment appeals boards may have treated airlines unfairly, other than the ongoing economic obsolescence litigation discussed below, raising the question whether changing a long-standing process without specific instances of unjust treatment is justified. The Committee may wish to consider the merits of trial de novo for taxes generally, and for locally-assessed certificated aircraft specifically.
4. Valuation. Assessment of personal property, especially certificated aircraft, is inherently difficult. Not only are planes valuable, which leads to a larger range of disagreement, but the economic condition of the airline industry can change rapidly due to terrorist attacks, economic recessions, and mergers, among others, all of which have occurred in recent years. The Legislature initially codified an assessment methodology after years of litigation resulted in settlement agreements, and AB 964’s methods of assessment were supposed to eliminate or reduce disagreements because they rely on either a knowable cost basis or a well-known price index, with a safety valve that would reduce values due to economic obsolescence. However, disagreements continue: some airlines appealed some lead assessors’ valuations, arguing that assessors didn’t apply the economic obsolescence formula correctly. Assessors disagreed, and assessment appeals boards subsequently upheld the assessor’s valuations. However, airlines subsequently filed suit in several counties to challenge that determination, and to preserve legal standing, with no court yet rendering a decision. Additionally, some assessors argue that the current methodology undervalues aircraft, and propose instead to eliminate the 10% discount from the Airline Price Guide, or change the representative period from the currently designated one week period in January to a year-round measure that more accurately captures airlines’ presence in this state. Notwithstanding this ongoing dispute, SB 1329 proposes to extend the current methodology, but doesn’t specify for how long. The Committee may wish to consider whether the current methodology accurately values certificated aircraft, and if so, for how many years should the Legislature extend it.
5. Location, location. In addition to placing the appellate authority for locally-assessed property taxes with county boards of supervisors sitting as the county board of equalization (Article XIII, Section 16), the Constitution also requires that property be assessed in the jurisdiction in which it’s situated (Article XIII, Section 14). Under the lead assessor model for certificated aircraft, one assessor values one airline’s fleet, then transmits this value to assessors in other counties where the aircraft has situs. The non-lead county assessor is still solely responsible for enrolling the value for that county, and is not required to use this value, but almost always do. In discussing the current lead assessor model, Legislative Counsel Opinion #1523620 from 2015 confirms that the official appraisal of a property’s value must be performed by the city, county, or district where the property has situs. While SB 1329 would allow for trial de novo for these assessments, airline taxpayers would still have to file suits in each county where their aircraft has situs due to this constitutional requirement. The Committee may wish to consider the Constitution’s location requirements when crafting an appellate process for lead assessor valuations of certificated aircraft.
6. Double-referral. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered that should the Committee approve a Do Pass motion for SB 1329, that the measure be returned to Rules Committee for it to consider a request from the Judiciary Committee to hear the bill.
7. Related legislation. Last year, the Committee approved SB 661 (Hill), which required BOE to assess airline personal property, including certificated aircraft, but the measure was subsequently held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file. The Legislature subsequently enacted AB 1157 (Nazarian), which extended the current valuation methodology until the 2016-17 fiscal year. Last autumn, Assemblymember Nazarian convened several meetings to discuss this issue; however, disagreements between assessors and airlines continue. This year, Asm. Nazarian introduced AB 2622, which extends the current valuation methodology until the 2019-2020 fiscal year, and implements several procedural changes to the lead county assessment process. That measure is currently awaiting hearing in the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee.
Support and Opposition
(4/7/16)
Support: Airlines for America; Alaska Airlines, American Airlines, California Taxpayers Association; Southwest Airlines, United Airlines.
Opposition: California Assessors’ Association, California State Association of Counties.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):