SB 1406: Construction-related accessibility: education entities.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-30
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians offices, public facilities, and other public places. Existing law requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or sends or serves a complaint containing a claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined, with respect to a place of public accommodation, to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within 5 business days of providing the demand letter or sending or serving the complaint. Existing law further requires an attorney who sends or serves that complaint to notify the commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint and other specified information within 5 business days of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
This bill, with specified exceptions, would also require an attorney who provides a prelitigation letter or sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against an education entity, as defined, to send a copy of the prelitigation letter or complaint to the commission within 5 business days of providing the prelitigation letter or sending or serving the complaint, would require the attorney to also submit information about the complaint with the copy of the complaint, and would further require the attorney to submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the commission, as described above. The bill would subject an attorney who fails to comply with these requirements to discipline and would require the commission to review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes the commission receives pursuant to these requirements, as specified.
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians offices, public facilities, and other public places. Existing law requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or sends or serves a complaint containing a claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined, with respect to a place of public accommodation, to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within 5 business days of providing the demand letter or sending or serving the complaint. Existing law further requires an attorney who sends or serves that complaint to notify the commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint and other specified information within 5 business days of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
This bill, with specified exceptions, would also require an attorney who provides a prelitigation letter or sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against an education entity, as defined, to send a copy of the prelitigation letter or complaint to the commission within 5 business days of providing the prelitigation letter or sending or serving the complaint, would require the attorney to also submit information about the complaint with the copy of the complaint, and would further require the attorney to submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the commission, as described above. The bill would subject an attorney who fails to comply with these requirements to discipline and would require the commission to review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes the commission receives pursuant to these requirements, as specified.
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians offices, public facilities, and other public places. Existing law requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or sends or serves a complaint containing a claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined, with respect to a place of public accommodation, to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within 5 business days of providing the demand letter or sending or serving the complaint. Existing law further requires an attorney who sends or serves that complaint to notify the commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint and other specified information within 5 business days of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
This bill bill, with specified exceptions, would also require an attorney who provides a demand prelitigation letter or sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against a public an education entity, as defined, to send a copy of the demand prelitigation letter or complaint to the commission within 5 business days of providing the demand prelitigation letter or sending or serving the complaint, would require the attorney to also submit information about the complaint with the copy of the complaint, and would further require the attorney to submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the commission, as described above. The bill would subject an attorney who fails to comply with these requirements to discipline and would require the commission to review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes the commission receives pursuant to these requirements, as specified.
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians offices, public facilities, and other public places. Existing law requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or sends or serves a complaint containing a claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined, with respect to a place of public accommodation, to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within 5 business days of providing the demand letter or sending or serving the complaint and complaint. Existing law further requires an attorney who sends or serves that complaint to notify the commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint and other specified information within 5 business days of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
This bill would also require an attorney who provides a demand letter or sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against a public entity entity, as defined, to send a copy of the complaint demand letter or complaint to the commission within 5 business days of providing the demand letter or sending or serving the complaint, would require the attorney to also submit information about the complaint with the copy of the complaint, and would further require the attorney to submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the commission, as described above.
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians offices, public facilities, and other public places. Existing law requires an attorney who sends or serves a complaint containing a claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined, with respect to a place of public accommodation, to send a copy of the complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within 5 business days of sending or serving the complaint and notify the commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint and other specified information within 5 business days of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
This bill would also require an attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against a public entity to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the commission, as described above.
(a)An attorney who provides a prelitigation letter to an education entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the prelitigation letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the prelitigation letter, send a copy of the prelitigation letter to the California Commission on Disability Access.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint against an education entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial prelitigation letter or complaint, unless that subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A prelitigation letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(f)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(g)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a prelitigation letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(h)Nothing in this section applies to a claim for money or damages against a public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code or makes the requirements of this section applicable to such a claim.
(i)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Complaint means a civil complaint that is filed or is to be filed with a court and is sent to or served upon a defendant on the basis of one or more construction-related accessibility claims.
(2)Construction-related accessibility claim or claim means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place of an education entity. Construction-related accessibility claim does not include a claim of interference with housing within the meaning of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 54.1, or any claim of interference caused by something other than the construction-related accessibility condition of the property, including, but not limited to, the conduct of any person.
(3)Education entity means the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges Office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
(4)Prelitigation letter means a prelitigation written document that alleges the site is in violation of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 and is provided to the education entity whether or not the attorney intends to file a complaint, or eventually files a complaint, in state or federal court. A prelitigation letter does not include a claim for money or damages against a local public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 8299.08 of the Government Code is amended to read:8299.08.The commission shall compile the following data with respect to any demand letter, prelitigation letter, or complaint sent to the commission pursuant to Section 54.27 or 55.32 of the Civil Code and post the information on its Internet Web site, pursuant to the following:
(a)The commission shall identify the various types of construction-related physical access violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and shall tabulate the number of claims alleged for each type of violation in the demand letters and complaints, respectively. For purposes of this subdivision, any demand for money letters shall be grouped as demand letters.
(b)Periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site a list, by type, of the 10 most frequent types of accessibility violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and the numbers of alleged violations for each listed type of violation for the prior two quarters.
(c)The commission shall, on a quarterly basis, identify and tabulate the number of demand letters and complaints received by the commission. The commission shall further ascertain whether a complaint was filed in state or federal court and tabulate the number of complaints filed in state or federal court, respectively. This data shall be posted on the commissions Internet Web site periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013.
(d)Commencing in 2014, and notwithstanding Section 10231.5, the commission shall make an annual report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by January 31 of each year of the tabulated data for the preceding calendar year as set forth in subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive. A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(a)An attorney who provides a prelitigation letter to an education entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the prelitigation letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the prelitigation letter, send a copy of the prelitigation letter to the California Commission on Disability Access.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint against an education entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial prelitigation letter or complaint, unless that subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A prelitigation letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(f)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(g)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a prelitigation letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(h)Nothing in this section applies to a claim for money or damages against a public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code or makes the requirements of this section applicable to such a claim.
(i)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Complaint means a civil complaint that is filed or is to be filed with a court and is sent to or served upon a defendant on the basis of one or more construction-related accessibility claims.
(2)Construction-related accessibility claim or claim means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place of an education entity. Construction-related accessibility claim does not include a claim of interference with housing within the meaning of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 54.1, or any claim of interference caused by something other than the construction-related accessibility condition of the property, including, but not limited to, the conduct of any person.
(3)Education entity means the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges Office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
(4)Prelitigation letter means a prelitigation written document that alleges the site is in violation of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 and is provided to the education entity whether or not the attorney intends to file a complaint, or eventually files a complaint, in state or federal court. A prelitigation letter does not include a claim for money or damages against a local public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 8299.08 of the Government Code is amended to read:8299.08.The commission shall compile the following data with respect to any demand letter, prelitigation letter, or complaint sent to the commission pursuant to Section 54.27 or 55.32 of the Civil Code and post the information on its Internet Web site, pursuant to the following:
(a)The commission shall identify the various types of construction-related physical access violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and shall tabulate the number of claims alleged for each type of violation in the demand letters and complaints, respectively. For purposes of this subdivision, any demand for money letters shall be grouped as demand letters.
(b)Periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site a list, by type, of the 10 most frequent types of accessibility violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and the numbers of alleged violations for each listed type of violation for the prior two quarters.
(c)The commission shall, on a quarterly basis, identify and tabulate the number of demand letters and complaints received by the commission. The commission shall further ascertain whether a complaint was filed in state or federal court and tabulate the number of complaints filed in state or federal court, respectively. This data shall be posted on the commissions Internet Web site periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013.
(d)Commencing in 2014, and notwithstanding Section 10231.5, the commission shall make an annual report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by January 31 of each year of the tabulated data for the preceding calendar year as set forth in subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive. A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(a)An attorney who provides a demand prelitigation letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public to an education entity shall send do both of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the prelitigation letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the prelitigation letter, send a copy of the demand prelitigation letter to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of providing the demand letter. Access.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public against an education entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the prelitigation letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial prelitigation letter or complaint, unless that subsequent prelitigation letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A prelitigation letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(f)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(g)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a prelitigation letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(h)Nothing in this section applies to a claim for money or damages against a public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code or makes the requirements of this section applicable to such a claim.
(c)
(i)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Complaint means a civil complaint that is filed or is to be filed with a court and is sent to or served upon a defendant on the basis of one or more construction-related accessibility claims.
(1)
(2)Construction-related accessibility claim or claim means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined by in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place. place of an education entity. Construction-related accessibility claim does not include a claim of interference with housing within the meaning of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 54.1, or any claim of interference caused by something other than the construction-related accessibility condition of the property, including, but not limited to, the conduct of any person.
(2)Public
(3)Education entity means the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges Office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
(4)Prelitigation letter means a prelitigation written document that alleges the site is in violation of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 and is provided to the education entity whether or not the attorney intends to file a complaint, or eventually files a complaint, in state or federal court. A prelitigation letter does not include a claim for money or damages against a local public entity governed by Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 8299.08 of the Government Code is amended to read:8299.08.The commission shall compile the following data with respect to any demand letter letter, prelitigation letter, or complaint sent to the commission pursuant to Section 53.32 54.27 or 55.32 of the Civil Code and post the information on its Internet Web site, pursuant to the following:
(a)The commission shall identify the various types of construction-related physical access violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and shall tabulate the number of claims alleged for each type of violation in the demand letters and complaints, respectively. For purposes of this subdivision, any demand for money letters shall be grouped as demand letters.
(b)Periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site a list, by type, of the 10 most frequent types of accessibility violations alleged in the demand letters and in the complaints, respectively, and the numbers of alleged violations for each listed type of violation for the prior two quarters.
(c)The commission shall, on a quarterly basis, identify and tabulate the number of demand letters and complaints received by the commission. The commission shall further ascertain whether a complaint was filed in state or federal court and tabulate the number of complaints filed in state or federal court, respectively. This data shall be posted on the commissions Internet Web site periodically, but not less than every six months beginning July 31, 2013.
(d)Commencing in 2014, and notwithstanding Section 10231.5, the commission shall make an annual report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by January 31 of each year of the tabulated data for the preceding calendar year as set forth in subdivisions (a) to (c), inclusive. A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(a)An attorney who sends provides a demand letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public entity shall send a copy of the demand letter to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of providing the demand letter.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint to the and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
(b)
(c)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Construction-related accessibility claim or claim means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined by paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place.
(2)Public entity includes the state, means the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, a county, city, district, public authority, public agency, and any other political subdivision or public corporation in the state, except that public entity does not include state entity as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 7103 of the Public Contract Code. the California Community Colleges Office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
(a)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public entity shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Construction-related accessibility claim or claim means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined by paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place.
(2)Public entity includes the state, the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, a county, city, district, public authority, public agency, and any other political subdivision or public corporation in the state, except that public entity does not include state entity as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 7103 of the Public Contract Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 24, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 5 p.m. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 36. Noes 0. Page 5141.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 36. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 5780.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 4, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Aug 3, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (August 3). |
| Jun 23, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 21). |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 4056.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 4010.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 20, 2016 | Set for hearing May 27. |
| May 16, 2016 | May 16 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) |
| May 10, 2016 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 6, 2016 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3611.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Mar 10, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 23. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 18, 2016 | Special Consent SB1406 Mendoza | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | SB 1406 Mendoza Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 3, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass as amended, and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2016 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1406 Mendoza | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1406
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/19/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0, 5/31/16
AYES: Allen, Anderson, Bates, Beall, Berryhill, Block, Cannella, De León, Fuller, Gaines, Galgiani, Glazer, Hall, Hancock, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Huff, Jackson, Lara, Leno, Leyva, Liu, McGuire, Mendoza, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nguyen, Nielsen, Pan, Pavley, Roth, Stone, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wolk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Runner
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 8/11/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Rancho Santiago Community College District
DIGEST: This bill requires an attorney who provides a prelitigation letter or sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim, as defined, against an education entity, as defined, to send a copy of the prelitigation letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) within five business days, and requires the attorney to additionally submit information about the complaint, and further requires the attorney to submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the CCDA. This bill subjects an attorney who fails to comply with these requirements to discipline.
Assembly Amendments limit the provisions of the bill to education entities, replace “demand letter” with “prelitigation letter,” add provisions related to attorney discipline, and clarifies the duties of the CCDA with regard to the information this bill requires to be collected.
Existing law:
- Provides, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
- Declares, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, and entitles persons to $4000 minimum statutory damages for violations of Unruh. (Civ. Code Sec. 51 et seq.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code Secs. 54, 54.1.)
- Provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Sections 54 or 54.1, and entitles a prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.)
- Prohibits a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages, and provides that a violation of this provision constitutes cause for attorney discipline. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.31.)
- Requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter to the Commission and the State Bar, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the Commission, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
This bill:
- Requires an attorney, when serving a prelitigation letter or a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance by an education entity, to submit a copy of the demand letter and complaint to the CCDA within five business days and in a standard format specified by the CCDA.
- Requires the attorney to also notify and provide specified information to the CCDA within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint.
- Requires the CCDA to review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as it does, under current law, for construction-related accessibility claims against places of public accommodation.
- Provides that a violation of the provisions above shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney, as specified.
Background
Since 1969, persons with disabilities have enjoyed protection under Civil Code Sections 54 and 54.1, which entitle individuals with disabilities and medical conditions to full and free access to and use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. After Congress enacted the ADA in 1990, the state made a violation of the ADA also constitute a violation of Section 54 or 54.1 and of California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act, either of which subject a person to actual damages incurred by an injured party, plus treble actual damages, but in no event less than $4,000.
The California Legislature has taken further steps to ensure disability access laws are complied with. SB 262 (Kuehl, Chapter 872, Statutes of 2003) established in the Division of the State Architect, a voluntary “access specialist certification program” in order to assist business and property owners in complying with ADA and state access laws. Since that time, several bills have been introduced that would have precluded an action for damages for a de minimus violation, allowing only injunctive relief and attorney’s fees. All of those bills failed passage in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses.
In 2012, Senators Steinberg and Dutton authored SB 1186 (Chapter 383, Statutes of 2012) which sought to comprehensively address continued issues with disability litigation. SB 1186 created a number of protections for small businesses and defendants who had, prior to a claim being filed, sought out a Certified Access Specialist inspection. These protections included reduced minimum statutory damages, early evaluation conferences, and mandatory stays of court proceedings while the violations were corrected. That bill also prevented the stacking of multiple claims to increase damages, banned pre-litigation demands for money, and increased data collection regarding alleged access violations. SB 1406, seeking to better understand the number and type of construction-related accessibility claims that are being brought against public schools, requires that an attorney who sends a prelitigation letter to an education entity must include specified information and send a copy to the CCDA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill mirrors similar duties already imposed on the CCDA and will likely involve a relatively small number of notifications, as there is a much smaller universe of potential defendants that could receive such claims. Any costs directly related to this bill should therefore be minor.
Rancho Santiago Community College District (source)
Civil Justice Association of California
Coast Community College District
Community College League of California
Foothill-De Anza Community College District
Kings Canyon Unified School District
Los Rios Community College District
Orange County Community College Legislative Task Force
Riverside Community College District
San Diego Community College District
San Joaquin Delta College
San Mateo Community College District
South Orange Community College District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Rancho Santiago Community College District, sponsor, argues that “public entities, such as RSCCD, receive funding from the State, local tax revenue, and fees paid by the students. Therefore, the cost [of these law suits] is ultimately burdened by the classroom, students, and day-to-day teaching necessities.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Roger Hernández, Low
8/15/16 10:02:14
**** END ****
Date of Hearing: August 3, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1406
Author:(Mendoza) – As Amended Ver:June 23, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill:
- Requires an attorney, when serving a prelitigation letter or a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance by an education entity, to submit a copy of the demand letter and complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) within five business days and in a standard format specified by the commission.
- Requires the attorney to also notify and provide specified information to the CCDA within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint.
- Requires the CCDA to review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as it does, under current law, for construction-related accessibility claims against places of public accommodation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill mirrors similar duties already imposed on the CCDA and will likely involve a relatively small number of notifications, as there is a much smaller universe of potential defendants that could receive such claims. Any costs directly related to this bill should therefore be minor. (See #3 below regarding the CCDA's apparent budget challenges.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) was signed into law on July 26, 1990, by President George H.W. Bush. As part of the 1992 reformation of state disability law, the Legislature amended the state's Unruh Civil Rights Act to incorporate by reference the ADA, making violations of the ADA also violations of the Unruh Civil Rights Act. Title III of the ADA is therefore applicable via the Unruh Civil Rights Act because it applies to businesses and nonprofit service providers that are public accommodations, such as restaurants, retail stores, hotels, movie theatres, private schools, convention centers, doctors' offices, and recreation facilities.
Claims against government services, programs and activities, or “Title II cases,” which are governed by different rules, regulations, and enforcement mechanisms than the Title III cases involving private businesses, are the subject of this bill. Title II of the ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in all services, programs, and activities provided to the public by state and local governments, and is expressly incorporated into state law pursuant to the California Disabled Persons Act (DPA). A violation of the DPA is punishable by “up to a maximum of three times the amount of actual damages but in no case less than $1,000, and attorney’s fees as may be determined by the court.
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill is necessary to address a recent rise in the number of lawsuits filed against educational institutions, specifically community colleges. The author notes that, "These types of lawsuits can result in facility modifications and upgrades that are not in alignment with existing facilities transition plans, ignore the availability of funding for repairs, and instead put a strain on a district’s general fund, thereby affecting programs and services offered to students. In addition to the cost associated with the repairs, community colleges have incurred significant costs from the legal fees associated with these lawsuits."
There is currently a lack of statewide data, however, regarding the frequency of such claims. In order to obtain such data, this bill is modeled after current law, which requires attorneys who send demand letters or complaints to business owners regarding violations of construction-related accessibility claims in places of public accommodation to provide specific notifications and information to the CCDA.
CCDA Workload and Budget.
- In 2015, the CCDA received approximately 3,000 demand letters and complaints alleging construction-related accessibility violations against places of public accommodation. As a result of AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2015, the commission has also begun receiving notifications of judgments, settlements, and dismissals; it received 124,171, and 243 notices in October, November, and December of 2015, respectively. Commission workload has been impacted by the passage of AB 1521, as the CCDA is required to do additional research and analysis to match resolution notices with original alleged violations, and compile and report the collective data. In the recently enacted 2016-17 Budget Act, the CCDA received a $100,000 budget augmentation for one position to manage the increased workload associated with AB 1521.
The commission asserts that SB 1406 would further increase workload and drive additional automation costs to move from a manual data processing to a digital capture format. The CCDA also believes it would require at least one additional staff position plus administrative support, at a cost of approximately $150,000, and may need two positions plus part-time legal staff assistance, if the Legislature intends the Commission to be a true research and analysis operation, rather than performing simple data reporting functions. Much of the CCDA’s current work is performed with the assistance of volunteer support for its projects, which is neither reliable nor sustainable. Finally, the commission indicates that the bill creates cost pressures to move to a larger office space, at estimated additional costs of $80,000 (one-time) to move and $160,000 ongoing for increased rent.
As discussed above, given the relatively small additional workload associated with this bill, especially in relation to the commission's existing responsibilities, the costs described above appear to reflect possible deficiencies in the commission's existing budget.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 21, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1406
Author:(Mendoza) – As Amended Ver:May 10, 2016
PROPOSED CONSENT (Proposed to be Amended)
SENATE VOTE: 39-0
SUBJECT: CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY: EDUCATION ENTITIES
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO GATHER INFORMATION ABOUT THE NUMBER OF COMPLAINTS AND prelitigation LETTERS ALLEGing VIOLATIONS OF CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY STANDARDS that are SENT TO EDUCATION ENTITIES, SHOULD ATTORNEYS be required to report information about such COMPLAINTS and LETTERS TO the california commission on disability access?
SYNOPSIS
Existing law requires an attorney, when serving a letter demanding money or a complaint that alleges the violation of a construction-related accessibility standard by a public accommodation, to submit a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) and the State Bar, and also to submit information about the demand letter and complaint to the CCDA. Failure to comply with these requirements subjects the attorney to disciplinary action by the State Bar. This bill would impose similar requirements on attorneys who serve prelitigation letters or complaints that allege the violation of a construction-related accessibility standard by education entities.
The author asserts that there has been a recent increase in prelitigation letters demanding money and civil complaints served on education entities. It is difficult to know whether this is true because there is no statewide data about the number of these letters and complaints. The lack of data is likely related to the fact that compliance with construction-related accessibility standards (commonly called “ADA compliance”) by public entities, including schools, has not been the subject of either media or Legislative attention. To the extent that issues and problems with ADA compliance have come to the attention of the public and the Legislature, including the fact that an extremely small number of highly litigious attorneys makes a business practice out of filing complaints and sending demand letters to small businesses, those issues and problems have involved a type of cases covered by Title III of the ADA, which establishes compliance rules for businesses that are open to and serve the public, referred to as “public accommodations.” The ADA compliance rules that apply to public entities, on the other hand, are governed by a different title of the ADA: Title II cases (government services and programs). Title II cases are the subject of this bill.
Because of this lack of statewide data regarding prelitigation letters and complaints filed in Title II cases, it is also impossible to verify whether there has been, in fact, any increase in the numbers of prelitigation letters and complaints against education entities in recent months or past years. As the author correctly observes: “Currently, accessibility lawsuits filed against community colleges and K-12 institutions are not collected by one entity. As a result, it is difficult to understand the magnitude of these cases and to understand the common types of violations schools are sued over.” In order to assist policy makers understand the trends of complaints in Title II cases, it makes sense for attorneys who serve prelitigation letters or complaints against education entities to also report the information about those complaints to the CCDA and to report it in a consistent and understandable manner. Given that the CCDA currently collects similar information about construction-related accessibility claims against public accommodations (private businesses that are open to the public), it makes sense for CCDA to also collect information from education entities and to collect and report on it in the same manner.
The bill uses Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, which imposes specific reporting requirements on attorneys who send demand letters or complaints to business owners regarding violations of construction-related accessibility claims as a model for its provisions. However, the bill does not include a number of provisions that are in Section 55.32 which seem appropriate to include in this bill. Also, a number of definitions in the bill, as it is currently in print, should be revised for clarity. Finally, it is necessary and important to clarify that the definitions and reporting requirements for prelitigation letters and complaints in the bill do not apply to presentations and claims that are made under a different provision of law, the Government Claims Act. The author proposes to amend the bill to address all of these issues and those amendments are reflected in this analysis. The bill is sponsored by the Rancho Santiago Community College District and supported by a large number of education entities, as well as the Civil Justice Association of California. It has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Requires an attorney, when serving a prelitigation letter or a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance by an education entity to submit a copy of the demand letter and complaint and information to the California Commission on Disability Access. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires an attorney who provides a “prelitigation letter” to an educational entity to do all of the following: (a) Include the attorney’s State Bar license number in the demand letter; (b) Within five business days of providing the prelitigation letter, send a copy of the prelitigation letter to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA).
- Requires an attorney who sends or serves a complaint against an “educational entity” to send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the CCDA to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
- Requires an attorney who sends or serves a complaint against an “educational entity” to notify the CCDA within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
- The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
- Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint.
- If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint.
- Provides that failure by an attorney to comply with 2) or 3), above, shall constitute cause for discipline of the attorney by the State Bar.
- Requires the CCDA to review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner as it does for demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes regarding construction-related accessibility claims against places of public accommodation.
- Exempts a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center from the reporting requirements of the bill.
- Clarifies that the bill does not apply to claims for money or damages filed pursuant to the Government Claims Act.
- Defines relevant terms, including the following:
- “Construction-related accessibility claim” or “claim” means any claim of a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, as defined by paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52, with respect to a public building, public facility, or other public place of an education entity.
- “Education entity” means the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges Office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
- “Prelitigation letter” means a prelitigation written document that alleges the site is in violation of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, as defined in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 and is provided to the education entity whether or not the attorney intends to file a complaint, or eventually files a complaint, in state or federal court. A prelitigation letter does not include a claim for money or damages against local public entities governed by Division 3.6 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits, pursuant to federal law, discrimination on the basis of disability in all services, programs, and activities provided to the public by state and local governments (e.g. public education, employment, transportation, recreation, health care, social services, courts, voting, and town meetings). (42 U.S. C. 12131.)
- Provides that no person in the State of California shall, on the basis of race, national origin, ethnic group identification, religion, age, sex, sexual orientation, color, genetic information, or disability, be unlawfully denied full and equal access to the benefits of, or be unlawfully subjected to discrimination under, any program or activity that is conducted, operated, or administered by the state or by any state agency, is funded directly by the state, or receives any financial assistance from the state. (Gov. Code Section 11135.)
- Provides the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA), an independent state agency composed of 19 members, with general responsibility for monitoring disability access compliance in California, and with authority to make recommendations to the Legislature for necessary changes in order to facilitate implementation of state and federal laws on disability access. (Gov. Code Section 8299 et seq.)
- Ensures that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places and makes a violation of the right of an individual under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-336) also constitute a violation of the Disabled Persons Act (DPA). (Civil Code Section 54. All further references are to this code unless otherwise stated.)
- Makes a violation of the DPA punishable by “up to a maximum of three times the amount of actual damages but in no case less than $1,000, and attorney’s fees as may be determined by the court.” (Section 54.3.)
- Prohibits such a demand letter alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance regarding a public accommodation from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury or special damages but allows a building owner, tenant, authorized agent or employee, after receiving a duly-provided demand letter, to request a settlement figure or specification of damages and allows an attorney to present a settlement figure or specification of damages in response. (Section 55.31.)
- Requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance regarding a public accommodation to the State Bar and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Section 55.32.)
- Requires an attorney to submit a copy of any letter demanding a payment of money and alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance regarding a public accommodation to the CCDA, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the CCDA, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Section 55.32.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) was signed into law on July 26, 1990, by President George H.W. Bush. The ADA is one of America's most comprehensive pieces of civil rights legislation that prohibits discrimination and guarantees that people with disabilities have the same opportunities as everyone else to participate in the mainstream of American life -- to enjoy employment opportunities, to purchase goods and services, and to participate in State and local government programs and services. Modeled after the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin – and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 -- the ADA is an "equal opportunity" law for people with disabilities.
Distinction between the ADA’s application privately owned “public accommodations” (Title III) and public “services, programs, and activities” (Title II). The Unruh Civil Rights Act broadly outlaws arbitrary discrimination in public accommodations and includes disability as one among many prohibited bases. (Section 51, subd. (b).) As part of the 1992 reformation of state disability law, the Legislature amended the Unruh Civil Rights Act to incorporate by reference the ADA, making violations of the ADA per se violations of the Unruh Civil Rights Act. Title III of the ADA is therefore applicable via the Unruh Civil Rights Act because it applies to businesses and nonprofit service providers that are public accommodations, specifically private entities who own, lease, lease to, or operate facilities such as restaurants, retail stores, hotels, movie theatres, private schools, convention centers, doctors' offices, homeless shelters, transportation depots, zoos, funeral homes, day care centers, and recreation facilities. The California Legislature’s incorporation of Title III of the ADA into the Unruh Civil Rights Act was intended to extend to disabled individuals aggrieved by an ADA violation “the full panoply of Unruh Civil Rights Act remedies.” (Jankey v. Lee (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1038, 1044 [150 Cal.Rptr.3d 191, 290 P.3d 187].)
As a result of the 1992 amendment of the Unruh Civil Rights Act, a plaintiff who prevails in a construction-related accessibility claim, like all plaintiffs in other civil rights cases, is now entitled to minimum statutory damages of $4,000 per violation (although later amendments were made to Unruh, affecting only disabled plaintiffs in only construction-related disability claims (though minimum statutory damages can be reduced to $1,000 in some cases, such as when a small business has obtained a CASp inspection)). However, these provisions apply only to “public accommodations,” and do not apply to construction-related accessibility claims against government services, programs, and activities. Claims against government services, programs and activities, or “Title II cases,” which are governed by different rules, regulations, and enforcement mechanisms than the Title III cases involving private businesses, are the subject of this bill.
Title II of the ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in all services, programs, and activities provided to the public by state and local governments (e.g. public education, employment, transportation, recreation, health care, social services, courts, voting, and town meetings). (42 U.S.C. 12131.) Regulations promulgated by the U.S. Department of Justice to interpret the ADA provide that facilities that are constructed or altered by, on behalf of, or for the use of a public entity shall be designed, constructed, or altered to be readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities. (28 C.F.R. 35.151 (a)(1).) The regulations also provide that full compliance with accessibility standards is not required where an entity can demonstrate that it is structurally impracticable to meet the requirements. (28 C.F.R. 35.151 (a)(2).) Most significantly for the purposes of compliance with Title II by education entities, according to technical assistance from the U.S. Department of Justice, Title II “may not necessarily mandate physical access to all parts of all facilities. Provision of services to individuals with disabilities in a different location, for example, is one method of achieving program accessibility.” (https://www.ada.gov/taman2.html#II-3.4200.)
Title II of the ADA is expressly incorporated into state law pursuant to the California Disabled Persons Act (DPA) in Civil Code Section 54, which provides:
Individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. . . . A violation of the right of an individual under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-336) also constitutes a violation of this section. (Section 54.)
A violation of the DPA is punishable by “up to a maximum of three times the amount of actual damages but in no case less than $1,000, and attorney’s fees as may be determined by the court.” (Section 54.3.)
To the extent that issues and problems with ADA compliance have come to the attention of the public and the Legislature, including the fact that an extremely small number of highly litigious attorneys makes a business practice out of filing complaints and sending demand letters to small businesses, those issues and problems have involved Title III of the ADA, which establishes compliance rules for businesses that are open to and serve the public, referred to as “public accommodations.” Those high-profile issues and problems have not involved Title II cases (government services and programs), which are the subject of this bill.
Author’s statement regarding the necessity of the bill. According to the author, this bill is necessary to address a recent rise in the number of lawsuits filed against educational institutions, specifically community colleges. The author states the following regarding the problem that the bill seeks to address:
In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of lawsuits against community colleges citing construction-related accessibility violations. These types of lawsuits can result in facility modifications and upgrades that are not in alignment with existing facilities transition plans, ignore the availability of funding for repairs, and instead put a strain on a district’s general fund, thereby affecting programs and services offered to students. In addition to the cost associated with the repairs, community colleges have incurred significant costs from the legal fees associated with these lawsuits.
Likewise, supporters also state, in letters that are virtually identical to the author’s statement, that there has been an increase in lawsuits against community colleges. It is noteworthy that the author and supporters do not say that the lawsuits are frivolous or without merit. Instead, to the extent that “facility modifications and upgrades” are necessary to comply with construction-related accessibility standards in existing law, the author and supporters state that those improvements “are not in alignment with existing facilities transition plans, ignore the availability of funding for repairs, and instead put a strain on a district’s general fund.” Basically, community colleges have longer term plans to correct violations of construction-related accessibility standards and it is not convenient or financially wise to do so in response to a lawsuit. While this may be true, it ignores the reality that persons with limited disability have the right of full and equal access to all public buildings, including schools and community colleges, under existing law. They should not have to wait for a school or community college to correct violations of construction-related accessibility standards until it is optimal from the college’s perspective to do so in order to exercise their rights.
Furthermore, it is difficult to confirm or deny the author’s (and supporters) claims about an increase in the number of lawsuits against education entities because no statewide data appears to be available about the number of complaints filed in the state. Because of this lack of statewide data, it is also impossible to verify whether there is, in fact, any trend of more complaints being filed against education entities in recent months or past years. As the author correctly observes:
Currently, accessibility lawsuits filed against community colleges and K-12 institutions are not collected by one entity. As a result, it is difficult to understand the magnitude of these cases and to understand the common types of violations schools are sued over.
In order to assist policy makers, it makes sense for attorneys who serve prelitigation letters or complaints against education entities to also report the information in a consistent and understandable manner. Given that the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) currently collects similar information about construction-related accessibility claims against public accommodations (private businesses that are open to the public), it makes sense for CCDA to also collect information for education entities.
This bill furthers recent legislative efforts to collect more information about ADA claims and to collect the information in a more efficient manner. Last year the Legislature approved and the Governor signed into law AB 1521, authored by this Committee, which, among other things, requires attorneys in disability access cases to notify the Commission, within five business days of any judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint, of certain information in a standard format specified by the Commission. Specifically, the information required to be reported to the Commission includes: (1) the date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal; (2) whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter; (3) if the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter; and (4) whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Civil Code Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection. (See Civil Code Section 55.32 (b)(2).)
Existing law also requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or who sends or serves a complaint in a construction-related accessibility case to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the Commission within five business days. (Existing law also requires a copy of the demand letter to be sent to the State Bar, but only until January 1, 2019.) This bill would require attorneys who submit pre-litigation letters and complaints alleging construction-related accessibility violations by education entities to submit information about those letters or complaints to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission, so that data about accessibility claims can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature.
Author’s amendments to conform this bill more closely to the section of existing law on which it is modeled and make a number of important clarifications. The bill uses Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, which imposes certain requirements on attorneys who send demand letters or complaints to business owners regarding violations of construction-related accessibility claims in “public accommodations,” as a model for its requirements. However, the bill does not include a number of provisions that are in Section 55.32--including the requirement for the attorney to include his or her State Bar license number in any prelitigation letter; a penalty for violating the requirements of the bill constitutes cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney; clarification that duplicate letters or complaints do not have to be sent to CCDA and that the requirements of the bill do not apply to legal services attorneys; and a requirement for CCDA to review and report on the prelitigation letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives in the same manner that it does for demand letters and complaints regarding public accommodations—in its provisions.
Also, a number of definitions in the bill, as it is currently in print, would appropriately be revised. For example, the bill in print uses the term “public entity” even though it only applies to educational institutions and the term “public entity” is widely used to refer to entities other than schools. The term “demand letter” used in the bill as in print is defined elsewhere in the Civil Code to apply to letters sent to public accommodations. To clarify the meaning of these terms, the terms are given new names and revised definitions.
Finally, it is necessary and important to clarify that the definitions and reporting requirements for prelitigation letters and complaints in the bill do not apply to presentations and claims made under the Government Claims Act (Government Code Section 900 et seq.), which requires the claimant to submit (or “present”) a claim, asking for money damages, to a government entity prior to filing a civil suit. (Gov. Code Section 905.) The bill is not intended to apply to such cases. The author reasonably proposes to amend the bill to address all of the above issues.
PENDING SIMILAR LEGISLATION. AB 54 (Olsen) requires demand letters and information about complaints to be submitted to the Commission on Disability Access in a standard format specified by the Commission. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Rancho Santiago Community College District (sponsor)
Civil Justice Association of California
Coast Community College District
Community College League of California
Foothill-De Anza Community College District
Kings Canyon Unified School District
Los Rios Community College District
Orange County Community College Legislative Task Force
Riverside Community College District
San Diego Community College District
San Joaquin Delta College
San Mateo Community College District
South Orange Community College District
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1406
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/19/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPRORIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/27/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
SOURCE: Rancho Santiago Community College District
DIGEST: This bill requires an attorney who sends a demand letter or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility violation against specified school entities to send a copy of the complaint and notification of the results of the claim to the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission), as specified.
Existing law:
- Provides, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
- Declares, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, and entitles persons to $4000 minimum statutory damages for violations of Unruh. (Civ. Code Sec. 51 et seq.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code Secs. 54, 54.1.)
- Provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Sections 54 or 54.1, and entitles a prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.)
- Prohibits a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages, and provides that a violation of this provision constitutes cause for attorney discipline. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.31.)
- Requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter to the Commission and the State Bar, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the Commission, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
This bill requires an attorney who sends a demand letter or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency, to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the Commission within five business days.
Background
Since 1969, persons with disabilities have enjoyed protection under Civil Code Sections 54 and 54.1, which entitle individuals with disabilities and medical conditions to full and free access to and use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. After Congress enacted the ADA in 1990, the state made a violation of the ADA also constitute a violation of Section 54 or 54.1 and of California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act, either of which subject a person to actual damages incurred by an injured party, plus treble actual damages, but in no event less than $4,000.
The California Legislature has taken further steps to ensure disability access laws are complied with. SB 262 (Kuehl, Chapter 872, Statutes of 2003) established in the Division of the State Architect, a voluntary “access specialist certification program” in order to assist business and property owners in complying with ADA and state access laws. Since that time, several bills have been introduced that would have precluded an action for damages for a de minimus violation, allowing only injunctive relief and attorney’s fees. All of those bills failed passage in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses.
In 2012, Senators Steinberg and Dutton authored SB 1186 (Chapter 383, Statutes of 2012) which sought to comprehensively address continued issues with disability litigation. SB 1186 created a number of protections for small businesses and defendants who had, prior to a claim being filed, sought out a Certified Access Specialist inspection. These protections included reduced minimum statutory damages, early evaluation conferences, and mandatory stays of court proceedings while the violations were corrected. That bill also prevented the stacking of multiple claims to increase damages, banned pre-litigation demands for money, and increased data collection regarding alleged access violations. SB 1406, seeking to better understand the number and type of construction-related accessibility claims that are being brought against public schools, requires that an attorney who sends a demand letter or serves a complaint against specified school entities also send a copy of the complaint and notification of the results of the claim to the Commission.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Automation costs of $40,000 to $60,000 to develop and implement a digital data capture format necessary to conduct analysis of reported information. (General Fund)
- Estimated Commission staffing costs of approximately $150,000 for 1 PY of new staff, plus administrative support, to compile and track additional data regarding disability access complaints against public school entities. (General Fund)
- Cost pressures of approximately $242,000 in 2017-18 and $162,000 ongoing to move to an expanded office space to accommodate additional staff.
Rancho Santiago Community College District (source)
Coast Community College District
Community College League of California
De Anza Community College District
Kings Canyon Unified School District
Los Rios Community College District
Orange County Community College District
Orange County Community Colleges Legislative Task Force
Riverside Community College District
San Diego Community College District
San Joaquin Delta College
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/27/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Rancho Santiago Community College District, sponsor, argues that “public entities, such as RSCCD, receive funding from the State, local tax revenue, and fees paid by the students. Therefore, the cost [of these law suits] is ultimately burdened by the classroom, students, and day-to-day teaching necessities.”
Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/30/16 19:25:17
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 1406 (Mendoza) - Construction-related accessibility: public entities
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 1406 would require an attorney who sends a demand letter or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility violation against specified school entities to send a copy of the complaint and notification of the results of the claim to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA), as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Automation costs of $40,000 to $60,000 to develop and implement a digital data capture format necessary to conduct analysis of reported information. (General Fund)
- Estimated CCDA staffing costs of approximately $150,000 for 1 PY of new staff, plus administrative support, to compile and track additional data regarding disability access complaints against public school entities. (General Fund)
-----see staff comments----- - Cost pressures of approximately $242,000 in 2017-18 and $162,000 ongoing to move to an expanded office space to accommodate additional staff.
-----see staff comments-----
Background:
Individuals with disabilities and medical conditions have legal protections to ensure full and free access to and the use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. Additionally, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments. After Congress enacted the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in 1990, the Legislature provided that violations of the ADA are also violations of the Unruh Act.
Existing law establishes the CCDA, an independent state agency composed of 17 members, to monitor disability access compliance and make recommendations to the Legislature for necessary changes in order to facilitate implementation of state and federal laws on disability access. The Commission receives copies of demand letters and complaints from attorneys alleging construction-related physical access violations in places of public accommodation. These complaints are primarily filed against small businesses, and oftentimes seek expedited cash payments rather than correction of the accessibility violation. Existing law, AB 1521 (Judiciary Committee), Chapter 755/2015, also requires attorneys in disability access cases to also notify CCDA within five business days of any judgment, settlement, or dismissal of any claims alleged in the complaint, of certain information regarding the resolution of the complaints in a standard format specified by the Commission. The CCDA is required to compile and upload the data on its website at specified quarterly and semi-annual intervals, and annually report tabulated data to the Legislature.
Proposed Law:
SB 1406 would require an attorney who sends a demand letter or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a “public entity” to do the following:
- Send a copy of the demand letter or complaint, and information about the complaint, to the CCDA within five days of serving the letter or complaint, in a format specified by the CCDA.
- Notify the CCDA within five days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of any claims, as specified, including the date of the resolution, whether the alleged violations were remedied, and if the violations were not fully remedied, whether another favorable result was achieved.
The bill would apply to demand letters and complaints alleging claims against the following “public entities:” the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University and the California State University, the California Community Colleges office of the Chancellor and the California Community Colleges, a K-12 school district, or any local education agency.
Related Legislation:
AB 54 (Olsen), currently pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee, would require an attorney who provides copies of a demand letter or complaint to the CCDA to also submit information about the demand letter or complaint in a standard format as specified by the commission.
Staff Comments:
In 2015, the CCDA received approximately 3,000 demand letters and complaints alleging construction-related accessibility violations against places of public accommodation. As a result of AB 1521 requirements, the CCDA has also begun receiving notifications of judgments, settlements, and dismissals; the Commission received 124, 171, and 243 notices in October, November, and December of 2015, respectively. Commission workload has been impacted by the passage of AB 1521, such that the CCDA is required to do additional research and analysis to match resolution notices with original alleged violations, and compile and report the collective data. Staff notes that the Governor’s proposed 2016-17 Budget includes an augmentation of $100,000 for the CCDA for the addition of 1 PY of staff (including benefits and OE&E costs) to manage the increased workload following the passage of AB 1521. The Budget Subcommittees in both houses have approved the budget change proposal for the additional staff.
The CCDA indicates that SB 1406 would further increase workload, and drive additional automation costs to move from a manual data processing to a digital capture format. Initial information technology systems and associated costs would be approximately $40,000, with future build outs of approximately $20,000 as needs grow. Staff estimates that the bill would also require the addition of at least 1 PY of staff plus administrative support, at a cost of approximately $150,000, but CCDA indicates it may need 2 PY, plus part-time legal staff assistance, if the Legislature intends the Commission to be a true research and analysis operation, rather than performing simple data reporting functions. It should also be noted that much of the CCDA’s current work is performed with the assistance of volunteer support for its projects, which is neither reliable nor sustainable.
The CCDA also notes that its current office configuration, which is a shared space sub-leased from the Department of Rehabilitation, is insufficient to support additional staff that would be required to implement the bill. As such, the bill creates cost pressures to move to a larger office space. One-time moving costs would be approximately $80,000, according to a Department of General Services estimate, and annual office space leasing costs would be approximately $200,000. The amount of CCDA’s current lease, which expires at the end of this fiscal year, is nearly $38,000, so the bill would impose ongoing cost pressures of approximately $162,000.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1406 (Author:Mendoza)
Version: February 19, 2016
Hearing Date: April 19, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: NR
SUBJECT
Construction-related accessibility: public entities
DESCRIPTION
This bill would require an attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility violation against a public entity to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the California Commission on Disability Access, as specified.
BACKGROUND
Since 1969, persons with disabilities have enjoyed protection under Civil Code Sections 54 and 54.1, which entitle individuals with disabilities and medical conditions to full and free access to and use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. After Congress enacted the ADA in 1990, the state made a violation of the ADA also constitute a violation of Section 54 or 54.1 and of California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act, either of which subject a person to actual damages incurred by an injured party, plus treble actual damages, but in no event less than $4,000.
The California Legislature has taken further steps to ensure disability access laws are complied with. SB 262 (Kuehl, Ch. 872, Stats. 2003) established in the Division of the State Architect, a voluntary “access specialist certification program” in order to assist business and property owners in complying with ADA and state access laws. Since that time, several bills have been introduced that would have precluded an action for damages for a de minimus violation, allowing only injunctive relief and attorney’s fees. All of those bills failed passage in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses.
In 2012, Senators Steinberg and Dutton authored SB 1186 (Ch. 383, Stats. 2012) which sought to comprehensively address continued issues with disability litigation. SB 1186 created a number of protections for small businesses and defendants who had, prior to a claim being filed, sought out a Certified Access Specialist (CASp) inspection. These protections included reduced minimum statutory damages, early evaluation conferences, and mandatory stays of court proceedings while the violations were corrected. That bill also prevented the stacking of multiple claims to increase damages, banned pre-litigation demands for money, and increased data collection regarding alleged access violations.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, declares that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, and entitles persons to $4000 minimum statutory damages for violations of Unruh. (Civ. Code Sec. 51 et seq.)
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code Secs. 54, 54.1.)
Existing law provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Sections 54 or 54.1, and entitles a prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.)
Existing law prohibits a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages, and provides that a violation of this provision constitutes cause for attorney discipline. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.31.)
Existing law requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter to the Commission and the State Bar, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the Commission, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
This bill would require an attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public entity to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the Commission within five business days.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of lawsuits against community colleges citing construction-related accessibility violations. These types of lawsuits can result in facility modifications and upgrades that are not in alignment with existing facilities transition plans, ignore the availability of funding for repairs, and instead put a strain on a district’s general fund, thereby affecting programs and services offered to students. In addition to the cost associated with the repairs, community colleges have incurred significant costs from the legal fees associated with these lawsuits.
SB 1406 seeks to accurately track the number of lawsuits that impact the California Community Colleges and K-12 school districts to better understand the problem, and the outcome of the lawsuits. This bill requires an attorney who serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility claim against a public entity, to send a copy of the complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access. The attorney would also be required to submit the notification of judgement, settlement, or dismissal to the Commission.
- Increased data collection
Existing law requires attorneys who serve demand letters and/or file complaints alleging violations of any construction-related accessibility standard, to send a copy of the complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission) within five business days of sending or serving the complaint. Additionally, the attorney must notify the Commission of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint within five business days. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.) This bill would additionally require an attorney who files a complaint alleging any violation of a construction-related accessibility standard against a public entity to send a copy of that complaint to the Commission within five days, and additionally report to the Commission: (1) the date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal; (2) whether or not the violations alleged in the complaint were remedied after the plaintiff filed a complaint; and (3) if the violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied, whether or not another favorable result was achieved.
The Rancho Santiago Community College District (RSCCD), sponsor, argues that “public entities, such as RSCCD, receive funding from the State, local tax revenue, and fees paid by the students. Therefore, the cost [of these law suits] is ultimately burdened by the classroom, students, and day-to-day teaching necessities.”
A number of groups from the disability community, expressing concern over this bill, write:
First, CCDA was set up to be a bridge between business and disability community and to deal with alleged attorney and plaintiff “abuse” of mom and pop businesses; particularly on the part of high frequency filing plaintiffs. Though we believe that the CCDA is doing its job, we are concerned that their data has occasionally been used to bolster claims that are not supported by the data or to suggest that CCDA has collected data points with respect to the alleged motives of civil rights plaintiffs.
Governmental entities have had generations old obligations to make their programs, services and activities accessible; including the duty to undertake the steps required to provide physical access in existing facilities, when required. Many in the disability community believe that far too many public entities have failed to discharge these duties.
Unlike small businesses, governmental entities have long standing self-evaluation requirements. For instance, under section 35.150 of 28 CFR part 35, governmental entities had to complete self-evaluations (an internal audit) of their programs, services and activities and were supposed to develop transition plans by 1993. All the physical alterations to existing facilities required in order to meet the “program access standard” was supposed to have been set forth in the transition plan and work required to remove barriers was supposed to be completed by 1995. The ADA’s requirements in this reflected similar requirements going all the way back to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.
Unlike mom and pop businesses, public entities clearly have the resources and sophistication to discharge their duties under the Americans with Disabilities Act, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and State law. Additionally, for decades, public entities have had to appoint a designated a responsible party for ADA and Section 504 compliance (often known as and ADA coordinator).
So, though we do not oppose gathering data about access litigation, we do not believe that merely counting lawsuits will provide a window to help determine whether or not school districts and community college districts have been complying with their long standing obligations. Perhaps, any law that addresses data collection from attorneys representing persons with disabilities should also require school districts and community college districts to lodge their active (or most recent) transition plans with the CCDA.
We can’t think of another area of civil rights law where merely looking at the number of lawsuits filed by those allegedly aggrieved by the acts or omissions of a public entity would allow a person to make reasonable conclusions as to whether that entity is complying with its duties and obligations.
The Orange County Community College Legislative Task Force (OCCLTF), in support, argues that the state has an interest in the data collection required under this bill. OCCLTF writes, “with the ability to track and collect data on these types of lawsuits, the State, interested stakeholders, and other public education facilities will be able to better understand the problem of construction-related accessibility claims and the final outcomes.”
Support: Civil Justice Association of California; Foothill (De Anza, Los Rios, South Orange County, and San Diego Community College Districts); Orange County Community College Legislative Task Force
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Rancho Santiago Community College District
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 269 (Roth) is substantially similar to SB 251 (see below), with the exception of the tax credit, which the author removed to address the Governor’s concerns. This bill is currently in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 54 (Olsen) would require that demand letters and complaints are sent to the Commission on Disability Access in a standard format specified by the Commission. This bill is currently in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 52 (Gray, 2015) would have provided that the defendant’s maximum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is $1,000 for each offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations within 180 days of being served with the complaint. This bill was never heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1230 (Gomez, Ch. 787, Stats. 2015) establishes the California Americans with Disabilities Act Small Business Compliance Finance Act to provide loans to assist small businesses with financing the costs of projects that alter or retrofit existing small business facilities to comply with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.
AB 1342 (Steinorth, 2015) would have provided additional revenue to the California Commission on Disability Access. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated that it was “something more appropriately addressed in the annual budget process.”
AB 1468 (Baker, 2015) would have provided that a public entity’s possession of a close out letter from the State Architect certifying that the buildings, facilities, and other places meet the applicable construction-related accessibility standards of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act, serves as presumptive evidence of compliance with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act. This bill was never heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee. See Background; Comments 2, 4, and 6.
AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 755, Stats. 2015) See Background.
SB 67 (Galgiani, 2015) would have limited recovery against a small business for construction-related accessibility claims to injunctive relief and reasonable attorney’s fees, and would allow businesses who have undergone a CASp inspection 120 days to correct violations in order to qualify for reduced statutory minimum damages. This bill was never heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 251 (Roth, 2015) would have made various changes to access laws, including: exempting a defendant from liability for minimum statutory damages if corrections were made within 120 days of receiving a CASp report; requiring the State Architect to publish a list of CASp inspected businesses; and providing a tax credit for elibible access expenditures, as specified. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who argued that tax credits are more appropriately addressed in the annual budget process.
SB 1186 (Steinberg and Dutton, Ch. 383, Stats. 2012) reduced statutory damages and provided litigation protections for specified defendants who timely correct construction-related accessibility violations of the Unruh Civil Rights Act. That bill also banned prelitigation “demands for money” and created rules for demand letters and complaints in claims involving construction-related accessibility violations.
AB 2282 (Berryhill, 2012) would have authorized an aggrieved person to bring a disability access suit only if: (1) the person has suffered an injury in fact; (2) the injury in fact was caused by the violation; and (3) the violation is redressable. This bill was held under submission in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1878 (Gaines, 2011) which is substantially similar to SB 1163 but applies to “microbusinesses,” defined by the bill, failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SB 1163 (Walters, 2012) would have established notice requirements for an aggrieved party to follow before he or she can bring a disability access suit and would have given the business owner a 120-day time period to remedy the violation. If the property owner cured the violation, this bill would have prohibited the plaintiff from receiving any damages or attorney’s fees, except for special damages. This bill failed passage in this Committee.
SB 783 (Dutton, 2011), which was identical to SB 1163, failed passage in this Committee.
SB 384 (Evans, Ch. 419, Stats. 2011) clarified that attorneys who file complaints or send demand letters related to disability access violations must provide a written notice of legal rights and obligations, regardless of whether the attorney intends to file an action in state or federal court.
SB 209 (Corbett & Harman, Ch. 569, Stats. 2009) required a CASp inspection report to remain confidential rather than be under seal and subject to protective order.
SB 1608 (Corbett et al., Ch. 549, Stats. 2008) See Background; Comment 6.
SB 1766 (McClintock, 2008) See Background.
AB 2533 (Keene, 2008) See Background.
SB 855 (Poochigian, 2005) See Background.
**************
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):