SB 145: Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-10-09
Existing state law requires, for the 201516 fiscal year, the State Department of Health Care Services to provide a grant to a health benefit plan that is funded by contributions from agricultural employers, as specified, upon an appropriation of funds for this purpose. The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a nonprofit voluntary employees beneficiary association, organized under federal law, that provides payments for health care and other benefits to its members.
This bill would require, until January 1, 2021, the department to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan up to $3,000,000 per year for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. The bill would require the department to make the reimbursement payment within 60 days after it receives specified claims data from the plan.
Existing state law requires, for the 201516 fiscal year, the State Department of Health Care Services to provide a grant to a health benefit plan that is funded by contributions from agricultural employers, as specified, upon an appropriation of funds for this purpose. The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a nonprofit voluntary employees beneficiary association, organized under federal law, that provides payments for health care and other benefits to its members.
This bill would require, until January 1, 2021, the department to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan up to $3,000,000 per year for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. The bill would require the department to make the reimbursement payment within 60 days after it receives specified claims data from the plan.
Existing state law requires, for the 201516 fiscal year, the State Department of Health Care Services to provide a grant to a health benefit plan that is funded by contributions from agricultural employers, as specified, upon an appropriation of funds for this purpose. Under existing federal law, the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a nonprofit voluntary employees beneficiary association that provides payments for health care and other benefits to its members.
This bill would require require, until January 1, 2021, the department to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan up to $3,000,000 per year for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. The bill would require the department to make the reimbursement payment within 60 days after it receives specified claims data from the plan.
Existing state law requires, for the 201516 fiscal year, the State Department of Health Care Services to provide a grant to a health benefit plan that is funded by contributions from agricultural employers, as specified, upon an appropriation of funds for this purpose. Under existing federal law, the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a nonprofit voluntary employees beneficiary association that provides payments for health care and other benefits to its members.
This bill would require the department to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan up to $3,000,000 per year for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. The bill would require the department to make the reimbursement payment within 60 days after it receives specified claims data from the plan.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of health facilities by the State Department of Health Care Services. A violation of these provisions is a crime.
Existing law requires each hospital to have in effect a written discharge planning policy and process that requires appropriate arrangements for posthospital care and a process that requires that each patient be informed, orally or in writing, of the continuing care requirements following discharge from the hospital, as specified.
Existing law also prohibits a hospital from causing the transfer of homeless patients from one county to another county for the purpose of receiving supportive services from a social service agency, health care service provider, or nonprofit social service agency within the other county, without prior notice and authorization, as specified.
This bill would prohibit a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within the scope of his or her practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location except when the patient is either medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another health facility pursuant to another provision of law. The bill would authorize the department, if it determines that a hospital has violated the requirements of the bill, to determine further that the violation is an immediate jeopardy violation pursuant to specified law and regulations, and to assess penalties accordingly.
By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would result in a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of health facilities by the State Department of Health Care Services. A violation of these provisions is a crime.
Existing law requires each hospital to have in effect a written discharge planning policy and process that requires appropriate arrangements for posthospital care and a process that requires that each patient be informed, orally or in writing, of the continuing care requirements following discharge from the hospital, as specified.
Existing law also prohibits a hospital from causing the transfer of homeless patients from one county to another county for the purpose of receiving supportive services from a social service agency, health care service provider, or nonprofit social service agency within the other county, without prior notice and authorization, as specified.
This bill would prohibit a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within the scope of his or her practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location except when the patient is either medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another health facility pursuant to another provision of law. The bill would make the violation of that provision subject to civil penalties, as specified. The bill would require these civil penalties, upon appropriation, to be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless. The bill would authorize the department, if it determines that a hospital has violated the requirements of the bill, to determine further that the violation is an immediate jeopardy violation pursuant to specified law and regulations, and to assess penalties accordingly.
By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would result in a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of health facilities by the State Department of Health Care Services. A violation of these provisions is a crime.
Existing law requires each hospital to have in effect a written discharge planning policy and process that requires appropriate arrangements for posthospital care and a process that requires that each patient be informed, orally or in writing, of the continuing care requirements following discharge from the hospital, as specified.
Existing law also prohibits a hospital from causing the transfer of homeless patients from one county to another county for the purpose of receiving supportive services from a social service agency, health care service provider, or nonprofit social service agency within the other county, without prior notice and authorization, as specified.
This bill would prohibit a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.8% percent or greater who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within the scope of his or her practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location except when the patient is either medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another health facility pursuant to another provision of law. The bill would make the violation of that provision subject to civil penalties, as specified. The bill would require these civil penalties, upon appropriation, to be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would result in a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of health facilities by the State Department of Health Care Services. A violation of these provisions is a crime.
Existing law requires each hospital to have in effect a written discharge planning policy and process that requires appropriate arrangements for posthospital care and a process that requires that each patient be informed, orally or in writing, of the continuing care requirements following discharge from the hospital, as specified.
Existing law also prohibits a hospital from causing the transfer of homeless patients from one county to another county for the purpose of receiving supportive services from a social service agency, health care service provider, or nonprofit social service agency within the other county, without prior notice and authorization, as specified.
This bill would prohibit a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.8% percent or greater to be transported to another location except when the patient is either medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another health facility pursuant to another provision of law. The bill would make the violation of that provision subject to civil penalties, as specified. The bill would require these civil penalties, upon appropriation, to be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
By expanding the scope of an existing crime, this bill would result in a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a joint labor-management health plan for farmworkers organized under Section 302(c)(5) of the federal Labor Management Relations Act of 1947.
(b)This plan has been in existence for more than 45 years and has provided vital health services to farmworkers and their families, enabling them to lead healthier lives, make better use of their available income, and achieve self-sufficiency.
(c)The plan has focused on primary and preventive care and has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly funded health resources in the plans coverage areas.
(d)The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
(e)The Legislature has determined that the plan is an efficient and cost-effective means to deliver health care services to farmworkers and their families within the plans coverage areas. Thus, it is in the states interest to maintain the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plans financial viability.
SEC. 2.Section 100235 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:100235.(a)The department shall annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. This reimbursement shall not exceed three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(b)To seek reimbursement, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, the plan shall submit to the department completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive.
(c)(1)If the department receives claims data from the plan pursuant to subdivision (b), the department shall analyze that data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any single episode of care.
(2)No later than 60 days after the department receives claims data submitted by the plan, the department shall reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to paragraph (1), up to the amount of three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2021, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2021, deletes or extends that date.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a joint labor-management health plan for farmworkers organized under Section 302(c)(5) of the federal Labor Management Relations Act of 1947.
(b)This plan has been in existence for more than 45 years and has provided vital health services to farmworkers and their families, enabling them to lead healthier lives, make better use of their available income, and achieve self-sufficiency.
(c)The plan has focused on primary and preventive care and has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly funded health resources in the plans coverage areas.
(d)The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
(e)The Legislature has determined that the plan is an efficient and cost-effective means to deliver health care services to farmworkers and their families within the plans coverage areas. Thus, it is in the states interest to maintain the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plans financial viability.
SEC. 2.Section 100235 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:100235.(a)The department shall annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. This reimbursement shall not exceed three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(b)To seek reimbursement, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, the plan shall submit to the department completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive.
(c)(1)If the department receives claims data from the plan pursuant to subdivision (b), the department shall analyze that data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any single episode of care.
(2)No later than 60 days after the department receives claims data submitted by the plan, the department shall reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to paragraph (1), up to the amount of three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2021, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2021, deletes or extends that date.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a joint labor-management health plan for farm workers organized under Section 302(c)(5) of the federal Labor Management Relations Act of 1947.
(b)This plan has been in existence for more than 45 years and has provided vital health services to farm workers and their families, enabling them to lead healthier lives, make better use of their available income, and achieve self-sufficiency.
(c)The plan has focused on primary and preventive care and has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly funded health resources in the plans coverage areas.
(d)The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
(e)The Legislature has determined that the plan is the most an efficient and least expensive cost-effective means to deliver health care services to farm workers and their families within the plans coverage areas. Thus, it is in the states interest to expand maintain the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plans financial viability.
SEC. 2.Section 100235 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:100235.(a)The department shall annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. This reimbursement shall not exceed three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(b)To seek reimbursement, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, the plan shall submit to the department completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive.
(c)(1)If the department receives claims data from the plan pursuant to subdivision (b), the department shall analyze that data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate single episode of care.
(2)No later than 60 days after the department receives claims data submitted by the plan, the department shall reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to paragraph (1), up to the amount of three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2021, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted before January 1, 2021, deletes or extends that date.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan is a joint labor-management health plan for farm workers organized under Section 302(c)(5) of the federal Labor Management Relations Act of 1947.
(b)This plan has been in existence for more than 45 years and has provided vital health services to farm workers and their families, enabling them to lead healthier lives, make better use of their available income, and achieve self-sufficiency.
(c)The plan has focused on primary and preventive care and has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly funded health resources in the plans coverage areas.
(d)The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
(e)The Legislature has determined that the plan is the most efficient and least expensive means to deliver health care services to farm workers and their families within the plans coverage areas. Thus, it is in the states interest to expand the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plans financial viability.
SEC. 2.Section 100235 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:100235.(a)The department shall annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. This reimbursement shall not exceed three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
(b)To seek reimbursement, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, the plan shall submit to the department completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive.
(c)(1)If the department receives claims data from the plan pursuant to subdivision (b), the department shall analyze that data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed seventy thousand dollars ($70,000) paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate episode of care.
(2)No later than 60 days after the department receives claims data submitted by the plan, the department shall reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to paragraph (1), up to the amount of three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
SECTION 1.Section 1262.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1262.3.(a)A general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital shall not cause a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized, as defined in subdivision (j) of Section 1317.1, or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
(b)If the department determines that a hospital has violated subdivision (a), the department may determine that the violation is an immediate jeopardy violation pursuant to Section 1280.3 and regulations promulgated thereunder, and may assess penalties accordingly.
(c)Nothing in this section shall be construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)A general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital shall not cause a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized, as defined in subdivision (j) of section 1317.1, or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
(b)If the department determines that a hospital has violated subdivision (a), the department may determine that the violation is an immediate jeopardy violation pursuant to Section 1280.3 and regulations promulgated thereunder, and may assess penalties accordingly.
(b)If the department determines that a hospital has violated subdivision (a), it shall consider, at a minimum, all of the following actions:
(1)Assessment of an administrative penalty pursuant to Section 1280.1 or 1280.3.
(2)Referral to appropriate authorities for consideration of commencing an action for violation of Section 1290.
(c)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)Patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the State Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings.
(2)Patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(3)Residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the State Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500) of the Welfare and Institutions Code), and in accordance with an individual program plan, as defined in Section 4646 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, developed specifically for the resident.
(d)(1)Upon a second violation of subdivision (a), a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital, shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000). The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or a city attorney of a city and county, may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California seeking civil penalties, preventive relief, including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
(2)Any general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital criminally convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), that has been previously penalized for two separate violations of subdivision (a) may be subject to civil penalties of no less than three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000).
(3)In determining the civil penalty to be imposed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm.
(B)Whether the violation had a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient.
(C)Evidence, if any, of willfulness.
(D)The number of repeated violations.
(E)The presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
(4)Any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of this subdivision, including, but not limited to, experts and attorneys fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision shall be recoverable from the liable general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital.
(5)If the action authorized by this subdivision is brought by the Attorney General, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered. The funds described in this paragraph shall, upon appropriation, be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
(6)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law. Furthermore, nothing in this subdivision shall limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations or inspections, or implementing and enforcing restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
(e)
(c)Nothing in this section shall be construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)A general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital shall not cause a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greater who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized stabilized, as defined in subdivision (j) of section 1317.1, or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
(b)If the department determines that a hospital has violated subdivision (a), it shall consider, at a minimum, all of the following actions:
(1)Assessment of an administrative penalty pursuant to Section 1280.1 or 1280.3.
(2)Referral to appropriate authorities for consideration of commencing an action for violation of Section 1290.
(c)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)Patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the State Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings.
(2)Patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(3)Residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the State Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500) of the Welfare and Institutions Code), and in accordance with an individual program plan, as defined in Section 4646 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, developed specifically for the resident.
(d)(1)Upon a second violation of subdivision (a), a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital, shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000). The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or a city attorney of a city and county, may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California seeking civil penalties, preventive relief, including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
(2)Any general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital criminally convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), that has been previously penalized for two separate violations of subdivision (a) may be subject to civil penalties of no less than three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000).
(3)In determining the civil penalty to be imposed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm.
(B)Whether the violation had a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient.
(C)Evidence, if any, of willfulness.
(D)The number of repeated violations.
(E)The presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
(4)Any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of this subdivision, including, but not limited to, experts and attorneys fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision shall be recoverable from the liable general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital.
(5)If the action authorized by this subdivision is brought by the Attorney General, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered. The funds described in this paragraph shall, upon appropriation, be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
(6)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law. Furthermore, nothing in this subdivision shall limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations or inspections, or implementing and enforcing restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)A general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital shall not cause a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greater to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
(b)If the department determines that a hospital has violated subdivision (a), it shall consider, at a minimum, all of the following actions:
(1)Assessment of an administrative penalty pursuant to Section 1280.1 or 1280.3.
(2)Referral to appropriate authorities for consideration of commencing an action for violation of Section 1290.
(c)This section shall not apply to any of the following:
(1)Patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the State Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings.
(2)Patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the State Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(3)Residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the State Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, and in accordance with an individual program plan, as defined in Section 4646 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, developed specifically for the resident.
(d)(1)Upon a second violation of subdivision (a), a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital, shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000). The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or a city attorney of a city and county, may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California seeking civil penalties, preventive relief, including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
(2)Any general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital criminally convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), that has been previously penalized for two separate violations of subdivision (a) may be subject to civil penalties of no less than three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000).
(3)In determining the civil penalty to be imposed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm.
(B)Whether the violation had a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient.
(C)Evidence, if any, of willfulness.
(D)The number of repeated violations.
(E)The presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
(4)Any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of this subdivision, including, but not limited to, experts and attorneys fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision shall be recoverable from the liable general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital.
(5)If the action authorized by this subdivision is brought by the Attorney General, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney, the civil penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered. The funds described in this paragraph shall, upon appropriation, be used exclusively for the provision of posthospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
(6)Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law. Furthermore, nothing in this subdivision shall limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations or inspections, or implementing and enforcing restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 9, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 712, Statutes of 2015. |
| Oct 9, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 17, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:45 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 26. Noes 14. Page 2780.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | From committee: That the Assembly amendments be concurred in. (Ayes 7. Noes 2. Page 2787.) |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 26. Noes 14.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 51. Noes 28. Page 3181.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 26. Noes 13.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | From committee: That the Assembly amendments be concurred in. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) |
| Sep 11, 2015 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on HEALTH pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). |
| Sep 11, 2015 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 11, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 5.) (September 11). |
| Sep 11, 2015 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Sep 9, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (September 9). |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Sep 8, 2015 | Re-referred to Coms. on HEALTH and APPR. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Sep 8, 2015 | Action rescinded whereby the bill was re-referred to Com. on HEALTH pursuant to Assembly rule 77.2. |
| Sep 4, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Sep 4, 2015 | Action rescinded whereby the bill was re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read third time and amended. (Ayes 52. Noes 27. Page 2690.) |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 27, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 26, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 5.) (August 26). |
| Aug 19, 2015 | August 19 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 14, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (July 14). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 24, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 13. Noes 5.) (June 23). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 4, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| May 26, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 21. Noes 15. Page 1100.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 26, 2015 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 26, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 21. Noes 15.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 19, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2015 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 8, 2015 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 5, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 4, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 817.) (April 28). |
| Apr 24, 2015 | Set for hearing April 28. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 757.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 17, 2015 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 14, 2015 | April 15 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 12, 2015 | Set for hearing April 15. |
| Feb 5, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Jan 28, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 27. |
| Jan 27, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2015 | Unfinished Business (Supplemental File 4) SB145 Pan Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2015 | SB 145 Pan Senate Third Reading By BONTA | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2015 | That the Assembly amendments be concurred in | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2015 | SB 145 Pan Senate Third Reading By BONTA Amend By BONTA Set #1 | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 14, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 23, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2015 | Senate 3rd Reading SB145 Pan | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: September 11, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended September 10, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Health |
Vote: |
12 - 4 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to provide stop-loss coverage to a private multi-employer trust providing health care benefits to farmworkers. Specifically, this bill:
Requires DHCS to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farmworkers Medical Plan (RFK Medical Plan) for claim payments that exceed $70,000.
Requires reimbursement made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016.
Limits total reimbursement to three million dollars ($3,000,000) per year.
Requires the RFK Medical Plan to submit to the department completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive.
FISCAL EFFECT:
GF costs of up to $3 million per year to DHCS to reimburse RFK Medical Plan for episodes of high-cost care incurred by RFK Medical Plan enrollees.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, this bill will provide state funding critical to allow a particular health trust fund to continue to provide health benefits to their enrollees. Absent this funding, the author contends, the plan would cease providing benefits and individuals would either enroll in Medi-Cal or lose insurance coverage. Because Medi-Cal would incur additional costs if low-income eligible individuals enrolled in coverage, the author argues this bill actually saves the state money.
Background. The RFK Medical Plan is a self-funded, self-insured health plan that is subject to a collective bargaining agreement between the United Farm Workers (UFW) and multiple agricultural employers. According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan provided health insurance to more than 13,000 people living in California farmworker families. UFW points out that their plan had imposed a $70,000 limit on annual benefits as a cost control measure, but the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act's (ACA's) prohibits such benefit limits. This has resulted in significant cost pressure that UFW states is unrealistic to expect employers and employees to bear. UFW states there are approximately 16,000 California farmworkers covered by the plan and about 2,000 other individuals. Staff calculates the increased contribution to cover $3 million in additional costs incurred on behalf of 18,000 enrollees would be about $167 per enrollee, per year, including dependents.
Prior Budget Actions. The Legislature took two separate budget actions in recent years to provide special fund dollars to the RFK Medical Plan to purchase stop-loss coverage that covers the costs of episodes of care over $70,000. This supplemental funding has allowed the plan to maintain the annual benefit limits and comply with the ACA requirement, without passing these costs on to covered employees and employers. Specifically, the 2014 Budget Act allocated $3.2 million in one-time Proposition 99 funds, and the 2015 Budget Act allocated $2.5 million in Proposition 99 funds. The allocated funds were previously used to fund the Major Risk Medical Insurance Program, which provided coverage to enrollees who were denied coverage in the private market, prior to the federal ACA. The budget actions were intended to provide one-time funding in order to prevent insolvency and allow RFK Medical Plan to modify its business model to adapt to the federal ACA.
Comments.
Recent amendments impose a five-year sunset in order to prevent the state from becoming the default payer of high-cost claims for this plan on a permanent basis. The Health Committee policy analysis indicates a sunset date also offers the RFK Medical Plan a timeline under which it can continue to strive toward self-sustainment, and report back its progress to the Legislature. However, the bill does not specify reporting or accountability measures, nor clearly state intent language related to self-sufficiency.
This bill has intent language stating the Legislature has found it is efficient and cost-effective to provide health care through the RFK Medical Plan, and indicating the plan has saved the state significant sums of money. However, there does not appear to be a legislative analysis conclusively demonstrating savings.
According to UFW, some enrollees in the RFK Medical Plan are not California farmworkers. Therefore, it appears that this bill would authorize reimbursement for enrollees who do not work in California.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
SB 145
Page 3
(Without Reference to File)
SENATE THIRD READING
SB 145
(Pan)
As Amended September 10, 2015
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: Vote not relevant
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Health (vote not relevant) |
|
|
|
Judiciary (vote not relevant) |
|
|
|
Appropriations (vote not relevant) |
|
|
|
Health |
12-4 |
Bonta, Bonilla, Burke, Chiu, Gomez, Gonzalez, Nazarian, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Santiago, Thurmond, Wood |
Maienschein, Lackey, Patterson, Steinorth |
Appropriations |
11-5 |
Gomez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Quirk, Rendon, Weber, Wood |
Bigelow, Chang, Gallagher, Jones, Wagner |
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farmworkers Medical Plan (RFK Medical Plan) for claim payments that exceed $70,000. Specifically, this bill:
Requires DHCS to annually reimburse the RFK Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016.
Limits reimbursement to the RFK Medical Plan by the state to no more than $3 million.
Requires the RFK Medical Plan, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, to submit to DHCS completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year.
Requires DHCS to analyze the data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed $70,000 paid the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate episode of care, and reimburse the plan that amount, up to $3 million, within 60 days.
Sunsets on January 1, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill, as amended, has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS: According to the author, 15 months ago, the Legislature determined we could avoid state General Fund (GF) Medi-Cal costs by $3.6 million if we made a one-time appropriation of $3.2 million to the RFK Medical Plan, a farm worker's health trust fund, to purchase stop-loss insurance. The author states, through a second one-time appropriation to the RFK Medical Plan in this year's state budget, we saved the state's GF $4.1 million. The author states that this bill reflects a longer-term strategy that will allow the state to keep agricultural employer and farm worker contributions flowing into health care, thereby allowing 13,000 farmworkers and their families to preserve privately funded insurance. The author argues that will save the state money in avoided Medi-Cal costs. As such, the author concludes that this bill provides for good public and fiscal policy for both farm workers and taxpayers.
RFK Medical Plan. Taft-Hartley plans are subject to federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, and thus are exempt from state insurance laws. The RFK Medical Plan is a self-funded, self-insured Taft-Hartley Plan that is subject to a collective bargaining agreement between the United Farm Workers (UFW) and multiple agricultural employers. According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan provided health insurance to more than 13,000 people living in California farm worker families.
The ACA sets forth new standards for employer-sponsored health coverage, including a prohibition on annual and lifetime benefit limits. The RFK Medical Plan had previously imposed annual limits on benefits at $70,000. The purpose of the limit was to protect the financial solvency of the plan against high claims costs that exceeded $70,000. In light of the ACA's prohibition on annual limits, the RFK Medical Plan is no longer allowed to keep the $70,000 limit in place.
According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan obtained a federal waiver allowing it to keep the $70,000 limit in place until 2014. In addition to the federal waiver, the RFK Medical Plan took other steps to sustain the plan in light of the financial risk associated with the high-cost claims. Specifically, the plan worked with both union and employer partners to increase employer and employee contributions to the RFK Medical Plan within the maximum allowable limits for grandfathered Taft-Hartley plans. Additionally, UFW states that the RFK Medical Plan has continuously searched the market to try to purchase stop-loss insurance in the private market, and is building financial reserves through increasing the number of beneficiaries, increasing contributions within allowable limits, modifying benefits, and maintaining administrative costs below 5% within the goal of eventually withstanding larger claims.
Stop-loss insurance and previous budget actions. Stop-loss insurance is commonly sold to employers that self-insure their employee's health coverage. Self-insurance involves greater risk to the employer since employee health care costs could exceed expected estimates.
In order for employers to minimize the risk involved with self-insurance, insurance carriers sell stop-loss insurance which covers claims in excess of a maximum dollar amount of liability incurred by an employer for health care expenses.
The 2014-15 state budget included $3.2 million (special fund) appropriation to the RFK Medical Plan for the purchase of stop-loss insurance for any claims over the amount of $70,000. Another one-time appropriation of $2.5 million was included in the 2015/16 Budget for the same purpose. According to the Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1, to secure the budget appropriations, the RFK Medical Plan argued that there would be off-setting savings in the Medi-Cal program. These arguments were based on an assumption that the plan would not be financially viable and dissolve without financial assistance to purchase stop-loss insurance. If this occurred, the RFK Medical Plan's consultants assumed 50% of its members would be eligible for Medi-Cal at a state cost of $4.7 million. Additionally, the RFK Medical Plan argued that if it were to cease operating, those insured by the plan not eligible for Medi-Cal would become uninsured.
Rather than appropriating state funds to the RFK Medical Plan for the purchase of stop-loss insurance, this bill would require the state to instead reimburse the plan for the claims that exceed $70,000 for an individual employee or dependent for a single episode of care up to a total of $3 million. In other words, the state would act as the stop-loss insurer for the RFK Medical Plan. According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan has one year of claims experience since it began to pay claims above $70,000, and in the 2014 plan year (September 2014 to August 2015), 17 cases exceeded the $70,000 threshold. The total payments made for these 17 cases were $1.4 million.
Estimated Medi-Cal costs. According to the UFW, the California Endowment estimated that, based on the number of RFK Medical Plan enrollees eligible for Medi-Cal during the 2014 plan year, state costs to cover these enrollees would be approximately $6.6 million. According to DHCS, after reviewing the estimates, it could not validate the assertions regarding the population that would be eligible for Medi-Cal, or the overall savings projected.
The UFW is the sponsor of this bill, and states in support that it ensures farm workers and their families who are currently covered by the RFK Medical Plan continue to obtain health benefits. The UFW argues that the ACA actually reduced health care coverage for farm workers, and threatens the UFW RFK Medical Plan, which has employer and union trustees. The UFW states that by focusing on primary and preventive care, the RFK Medical Plan has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly-funded health resources in its coverage areas. The UFW also argues that the Legislature has determined that the RFK Medical Plan is the most efficient and least expensive means to deliver health services to farm workers and their families within the plan's coverage and that it is in the state's interest to ensure these health services continue.
Analysis Prepared by: Kelly Green / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0002403
SB 145
Page 4
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 145
Amended: 9/10/15
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Not available
SUBJECT: Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan
DIGEST: This bill requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan (RFK Plan) for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the RFK Plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016, and caps the total reimbursement amount at $3 million per year. Sunsets this bill’s provisions on January 1, 2021.
Assembly Amendments delete the previous version of this bill related to health facilities and patient transport and replace it with the current provisions related to the RFK Plan.
Existing law:
Provides $2.5 million in one-time funding to the RFK Plan to purchase stop-loss insurance.
Establishes under federal law, the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which among other provisions, expands eligibility for Medicaid (Medi-Cal in California), sets up health benefit exchanges, and establishes reforms on private health insurance.
This bill:
Requires DHCS to annually reimburse the RFK Plan for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. Caps the reimbursement at $3 million per year.
Requires the plan to submit to DHCS completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive, to seek reimbursement commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter.
Requires DHCS to analyze claims data if received from the plan, to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed $70,000 paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate episode of care.
Requires no later than 60 days after DHCS receives claims data submitted by the plan, DHCS to reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to 3) above up to the amount of $3 million per year.
Includes as legislative intent the following:
The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
The Legislature has determined that the plan is an efficient and cost-effective means to deliver health care services to farm workers and their families within the plan’s coverage areas. Thus, it is in the state’s interest to maintain the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plan’s financial viability.
Sunsets this bill on January 1, 2021.
Comments
Author’s statement. According to the author, this bill provides a longer-term strategy that will allow the state to keep agricultural employer and farm worker contributions flowing into health care, thereby allowing 16,000 farmworkers and their families to preserve privately funded insurance. SB 145 will save the state money in avoided Medi-Cal costs and provides good public and fiscal policy for both farm workers and taxpayers.
RFK Plan. The RFK Plan was founded in 1969. It is a self-funded, self-administered plan with an employer contribution that depends on collective-bargaining agreements. According to information provided by this bill’s sponsor, the United Farm Workers (UFW), the RFK Plan covers everything from basic office visits, out-patient diagnostic lab and x-ray to inpatient hospitalizations, including physical therapy, chiropractic and in some plans, home health care, skilled nursing and durable medical equipment. Cost sharing varies by plan design. Plan participants can have small monthly premiums based on hours worked, co-pays, and deductibles for hospitalization. Deductibles vary from $5 to $170 in the grandfathered plans. Most plans have a 20% co-insurance and cover 80% of all benefits in the particular plan.
According to UFW, in the past year, the RFK Plan provided health insurance to more than 13,000 people living in farm worker families in California. Of those covered, about 6,100 are adults and about 7,500 are children. An estimated 9,132 members are eligible for full scope Medi-Cal, 1,560 are eligible for limited scope Medi-Cal, 3,000 have income too high to qualify for Medi-Cal. The Plan has one year (Sep 2014-Aug 2015) of claim experience above $70,000. Approximately 17 cases are claims over $70,000, which total approximately $1.4 million. The $70,000 limit is based on the previous annual benefit limit the Plan had in place prior to its compliance with the ACA in 2014.
In 2014, the Plan secured a $3.2 million appropriation from California to purchase stop-loss insurance. In the 2015-16 Budget, UFW requested a lower amount of support from the state ($2.5 million) because of an enrollment increase by more than 2,300 lives in California. In the budget process, the sponsors indicated the request was a one-time funding solution for the purchase of stop-loss insurance for an additional year.
Stop-loss insurance. Stop-loss insurance is sold to purchasers (typically employers and labor trusts) that self-insure their employee’s health care coverage to limit the purchaser’s financial exposure. Stop-loss insurance is available in two forms: a) specific stop loss, where coverage is initiated when a claim for an individual employee or dependent reaches the threshold selected by the employer. After the threshold is reached, the stop-loss policy would pay claims up to the lifetime limit per employee; and, b) aggregate stop loss, where coverage is initiated when the employer’s self-insurance total group health claims reach a stipulated threshold selected by the employer. This bill will have the State of California, through DHCS, act as a stop loss insurer. Under this bill, the state would pay claims for a single episode of care that exceeds $70,000 up to a total cap across all claims over $70,000 of $3 million per year until this bill sunsets in 2021. The RFK Plan total premium for stop-loss insurance for 2014-2015, was $3.43 million. The total premium for 2015-2016 is estimated to be $3.1 million.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, General Fund costs of up to $3 million per year to DHCS to reimburse the RFK Plan for episodes of high-cost care incurred by the RFK Plan enrollees.
United Farm Workers (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/15)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the UFW, which writes that this bill ensures farm workers and their families can continue to obtain medical health benefits. UFW states that even with President Obama’s ACA, it is estimated that one million Californians will remain uninsured and not eligible for coverage due to immigration status. UFW indicates that the estimated Medi-Cal costs for this population for 2015 are estimated at 6.6 million if this population were enrolled in Medi-Cal. With regard to stop-loss insurance, UFW indicates that this bill reduces the potential state liability and eliminates the need for on-going reliance on an uncertain insurance market.
Prepared by: Teri Boughton / HEALTH /
9/11/15 20:15:45
**** END ****
SB 145 (Pan) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 145
AUTHOR: |
Pan |
||
VERSION: |
September 10, 2015 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
September 11, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Teri Boughton |
||
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE 29.10
SUBJECT: Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan.
SUMMARY:
Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan (RFK Plan) for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the RFK plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. Caps the reimbursement at $3 million per year. Sunsets this bill on January 1, 2021.
Existing law:
Establishes regulatory requirements for stop-loss insurance for small employers, including on or after January 1, 2016, setting an individual attachment point of $40,000 or greater and an aggregate attachment point of the greater of $5,000 times the total number of group members, 120% of expected claims, or $40,000. Exempts small employer stop-loss insurance issued prior to September 1, 2013, from these attachment point requirements.
Provides $2.5 million in one-time funding to the RFK Plan to purchase stop-loss insurance.
Establishes under federal law, the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which among other provisions, expands eligibility for Medicaid (Medi-Cal in California), sets up health benefit exchanges, and establishes reforms on private health insurance.
This bill:
Requires DHCS to annually reimburse the RFK Plan for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016. Caps the reimbursement at $3 million per year.
Requires the plan to submit to DHCS completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year from September 1 to August 31, inclusive, to seek reimbursement commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter.
Requires DHCS to analyze claims data if received from the plan, to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed $70,000 paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate episode of care.
Requires no later than 60 days after DHCS receives claims data submitted by the plan, DHCS to reimburse the plan the amount determined pursuant to 3) above up to the amount of $3 million per year.
Includes as legislative intent the following:
The RFK Plan is a joint labor-management health plan for farm workers organized under Section 302(c)(5) of the federal Labor Management Relations Act of 1947.
This plan has been in existence for more than 45 years and has provided vital health services to farm workers and their families, enabling them to lead healthier lives, make better use of their available income, and achieve self-sufficiency.
The plan has focused on primary and preventive care and has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly funded health resources in the plan’s coverage areas.
The plan has saved the state significant sums of money that would have otherwise been expended to provide health care.
The Legislature has determined that the plan is an efficient and cost-effective means to deliver health care services to farm workers and their families within the plan’s coverage areas. Thus, it is in the state’s interest to maintain the range of health care services provided by the plan without threatening the plan’s financial viability.
Sunsets this bill on January 1, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, General Fund costs of up to $3 million per year to DHCS to reimburse the RFK Plan for episodes of high-cost care incurred by the RFK Plan enrollees.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: |
46 - 28 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: |
11 - 5 |
Assembly Health Committee: |
12 - 4 |
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. According to the author, this bill provides a longer-term strategy that will allow the state to keep agricultural employer and farm worker contributions flowing into health care, thereby allowing 16,000 farmworkers and their families to preserve privately funded insurance. SB 145 will save the state money in avoided Medi-Cal costs and provides good public and fiscal policy for both farm workers and taxpayers.
CA Farmworker Health Coverage. According to background information provided at a July 10, 2014 briefing sponsored by the California Program on Access to Care, provided by Ed Kissam of the Werner-Kohnstamm Family Fund, there are approximately 600,000 farmworkers in California. Agricultural work is less seasonal in California than in other states. Approximately, 300,000 farmworkers work less than 191 days a year and might be deemed seasonal workers under the ACA. At least three-quarters of farmworkers (74%) earn less than $30,000 per year. More California farmworkers work for farm labor contractors (FLC’s) as compared to the rest of the U.S. FLC employees are younger, more recently-arrived, and typically earn less than those directly hired by growers. Based on family income alone, at least 25% of farmworkers in California would qualify for subsidized health insurance and more than half (58%) would qualify for Medi-Cal. However, about 400,000 of them lack legal status. So, they cannot purchase subsidized insurance and can qualify only for restricted-scope Medi-Cal. There are also disparities in health insurance coverage which correlate with legal status. Slightly more than one-quarter (27%) of California’s authorized farmworkers are covered by their employers but only 9% of the unauthorized farmworkers are covered by their employers. About 75% of California farmworkers who had health insurance had visited a provider in the past two years while only 43% of those without insurance did.
RFK Plan. The RFK Plan was founded in 1969. It is a self-funded, self-administered plan with an employer contribution that depends on collective-bargaining agreements. According to information provided by this bill’s sponsor, the United Farm Workers (UFW), in terms of the employer contribution: a $3.00-per-hour-per-employee contribution is common; all agreements have contributions of between $2.50 and $3.75 per hour per employee. Less than 5% of the plan budget goes to administrative costs, including legally mandated costs. The RFK plan covers everything from basic office visits, out-patient diagnostic lab and x-ray to inpatient hospitalizations, including physical therapy, chiropractic and in some plans, home health care, skilled nursing and durable medical equipment. Depending upon the benefit design, plan participants can have small monthly premiums based on hours worked, co-pays, and deductibles for hospitalization. Deductibles vary from $5 to $170 in grandfathered plans. Most plans have a 20% co-insurance and cover 80% of all benefits in the particular plan.
According to UFW, in the past year, the RFK plan provided health insurance to more than 13,000 people living in farm worker families in California. Of those covered, about 6,100 are adults and about 7,500 are children. An estimated 9,132 members are eligible for full scope Medi-Cal, 1,560 are eligible for limited scope Medi-Cal, 3,000 have income too high to qualify for Medi-Cal. The plan has one year (Sep 2014-Aug 2015) of claim experience above with claims above $70,000. Approximately 17 cases are claims over $70,000, which total approximately $1.4 million. The $70,000 limit is based on the previous annual benefit limit the plan had in place prior to its compliance with the ACA in 2014.
In 2014, the plan secured a $3.2 million appropriation from California to purchase stop-loss insurance. In the 2015-16 budget, UFW requested a lower amount of support from the state ($2.5 million) because of an enrollment increase by more than 2,300 lives in California. In the budget process, the sponsors indicated the request was a one-time funding solution for the purchase of stop-loss insurance for an additional year.
Stop-loss insurance. Stop-loss insurance is sold to purchasers (typically employers and labor trusts) that self-insure their employee’s health care coverage to limit the purchaser’s financial exposure. Stop-loss insurance is available in two forms: a) specific stop loss, where coverage is initiated when a claim for an individual employee or dependent reaches the threshold selected by the employer. After the threshold is reached, the stop-loss policy would pay claims up to the lifetime limit per employee; and, b) aggregate stop loss, where coverage is initiated when the employer’s self-insurance total group health claims reach a stipulated threshold selected by the employer. This bill would have the State of California, through DHCS; act as a stop loss insurer. Under this bill, the state would pay claims for a single episode of care that exceeds $70,000 up to a total cap across all claims over $70,000 of $3 million per year until this bill sunsets in 2021. The RFK plan total premium for stop-loss insurance for 2014-2015, was $3.43 million. The total premium for 2015-2016 is estimated to be $3.1 million.
Prior legislation. SB 75 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 18, Statutes of 2015) requires DHCS to allocate $2.5 million from the Major Risk Medical Insurance Fund, on a one-time basis, to the RFK Medical Plan for purposes of purchasing stop-loss insurance.
SB 870 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 40, Statutes of 2014) provides $3.2 million in one-time funds from the Major Risk Medical Insurance Fund to the RFK Medical Plan for purposes of purchasing stop-loss insurance.
SB 161 (Ed Hernandez, Chapter 414, Statutes of 2013) establishes regulatory requirements for stop-loss insurance for small employers, including on or after January 1, 2016, setting an individual attachment point of $40,000 or greater and an aggregate attachment point of the greater of $5,000 times the total number of group members, 120% of expected claims, or $40,000; and, exempts small employer stop-loss insurance issued prior to September 1, 2013, from these attachment point requirements.
SB 1431 (De Leon, 2012) would have set the stop-loss insurance attachment point for small employers on policies issued on or after January 1, 2012, at $45,000 for individuals and the greater of $15,000 times the total number of covered employees and dependents, 130% of expected claims, or $60,000. SB 1431 died in the inactive file on the Assembly Floor.
Support. This bill is sponsored by the UFW, which writes that this bill would ensure farm workers and their families can continue to obtain medical health benefits. UFW states that even with President Obama’s ACA, it is estimated that one million Californians will remain uninsured and not eligible for coverage due to immigration status. UFW indicates that the Medi-Cal costs for this population in 2015 are estimated at 6.6 million. With regard to stop-loss insurance, UFW indicates that this bill reduces the potential state liability and eliminates the need for on-going reliance on an uncertain insurance market.
Policy comments.
Precedent Setting. While the ACA has transformed the U.S. health care system by expanding coverage to millions, including a significant drop in the rates of uninsured in California with notable decreases in uninsured rates for low-income and African Americans according to the California HealthCare Foundation, many purchasers of health care have been affected by the changes brought about by the ACA. Other purchasers of health care for farmworkers and other industries that employ low-wage workers may also wish to have this type of assistance from the state. This proposal raises several policy questions, including whether it is appropriate for the state to assume the role of reinsurer for high cost claims, and if the state elects to do so, which entities and what criteria should make an entity eligible for this assistance. In addition, the phrase “episode of care” is not defined, and DHCS does not currently perform this type of payment function.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: United Farm Workers (sponsor)
Oppose: None received
-- END --
SB 145
Page 5
Date of Hearing: September 9, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Rob Bonta, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended August 31, 2015
SENATE VOTE: Not relevant.
SUBJECT: Robert F. Kennedy Farm Workers Medical Plan.
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to annually reimburse the Robert F. Kennedy Farmworkers Medical Plan (RFK Medical Plan) for claim payments that exceed $70,000. Specifically, this bill:
Requires DHCS to annually reimburse the RFK Medical Plan for claim payments that exceed $70,000 made by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for a single episode of care on or after September 1, 2016.
Limits reimbursement to the RFK Medical Plan by the state to no more than $3 million.
Requires the RFK Medical Plan, commencing after September 1, 2017, and annually thereafter, to submit to DHCS completed data, verified by an independent certified public accountant, for claims paid by the plan for services during the preceding year.
Requires DHCS to analyze the data to determine the aggregate amount of claims that exceed $70,000 paid the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or dependent for any separate episode of care, and reimburse the plan that amount, up to $3 million, within 60 days.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides for the regulation of health insurers by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) under provisions of the Insurance Code.
Establishes, pursuant to the state Insurance Code, regulatory requirements for stop-loss insurance for small employers, including on or after January 1, 2016, setting an individual attachment point of $40,000 or greater and an aggregate attachment point of the greater of $5,000 times the total number of group members, 120% of expected claims, or $40,000; and, exempts small employer stop-loss insurance issued prior to September 1, 2013, from these attachment point requirements.
Establishes, pursuant to federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), which sets minimum standards for most voluntarily established pension and health plans in private industry, including Taft-Hartley Multi-Employer Health and Welfare Plans (Taft-Hartley plans). Such plans are generally exempt from state insurance regulation.
Establishes, pursuant to federal law, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) numerous insurance market reforms in the individual and group markets, including prohibitions on pre-existing condition exclusions, coverage of dependents up to the age of 26, and prohibitions against health insurers imposing annual and lifetime benefit limits.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill, as amended, has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, 15 months ago, the Legislature determined we could avoid state General Fund (GF) Medi-Cal costs by $3.6 million if we made a one-time appropriation of $3.2 million to the RFK Medical Plan, a farm worker's health trust fund, to purchase stop-loss insurance. The author states, through a second one-time appropriation to the RFK Medical Plan in this year's state budget, we saved the state's GF $4.1 million. The author states that this bill reflects a longer-term strategy that will allow the state to keep agricultural employer and farm worker contributions flowing into health care, thereby allowing 13,000 farmworkers and their families to preserve privately funded insurance. The author argues that will save the state money in avoided Medi-Cal costs. As such, the author concludes that this bill provides for good public and fiscal policy for both farm workers and taxpayers.
BACKGROUND.
RFK Medical Plan. One way private sector unionized employees obtain health and other benefits is through a Taft-Hartley plan. Taft-Hartley plans are subject to the federal ERISA, and thus are exempt from state insurance laws. The RFK Medical Plan is a self-funded, self-insured Taft-Hartley Plan that is subject to a collective bargaining agreement between the United Farm Workers (UFW) and multiple agricultural employers. According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan provided health insurance to more than 13,000 people living in California farm worker families.
The ACA sets forth new standards for employer-sponsored health coverage. Plans that were in existence prior to the enactment of the ACA may be exempt from some ACA requirements. These plans are referred to as "grandfathered plans" and Taft-Hartley plans like the RFK Medical Plan may obtain grandfathered status. However, all employer-sponsored plans, including grandfathered plans, are required to comply with certain provisions of the ACA, including a prohibition on annual and lifetime benefit limits.
The RFK Medical Plan had previously imposed annual limits on benefits at $70,000. The purpose of the limit was to protect the financial solvency of the plan against high claims costs that exceeded $70,000. In light of the ACA's prohibition on annual limits, the RFK Medical Plan sought a waiver from the federal government to keep the $70,000 limit in place. A waiver was granted, allowing the plan to continue this benefit structure, but only until 2014. Without the annual limit in place, the RFK Medical Plan is at risk of claims costs that exceed $70,000.
According to the UFW, in addition to the federal waiver, the RFK Medical Plan took other steps to sustain the plan in light of the financial risk associated with the high-cost claims. Specifically, the plan worked with both union and employer partners to increase employer and employee contributions to the RFK Medical Plan within the maximum allowable limits for grandfathered Taft-Hartley plans. Additionally, UFW states that the RFK Medical Plan has continuously searched the market to try to purchase stop-loss insurance in the private market, and is building financial reserves through increasing the number of beneficiaries, increasing contributions within allowable limits, modifying benefits, and maintaining administrative costs below 5% within the goal of eventually withstanding larger claims.
Stop-loss insurance and previous budget actions. Stop-loss insurance is commonly sold to employers that self-insure their employee's health coverage. Self-insurance involves greater risk to the employer since employee health care costs could exceed expected estimates.
In order for employers to minimize the risk involved with self-insurance, insurance carriers sell stop-loss insurance which covers claims in excess of a maximum dollar amount of liability incurred by an employer for health care expenses. This maximum dollar amount of employer liability is referred to as an "attachment point." Attachment points can be based on the health care claims of an individual employee or dependent, or the aggregate health care claims for all covered employees and dependents, or both.
The 2014-15 state budget included $3.2 million (special fund) appropriation to the RFK Medical Plan for the purchase of stop-loss insurance for any claims over the amount of $70,000. Another one-time appropriation of $2.5 million was included in the 2015/16 Budget for the same purpose. According to the Assembly Budget Subcommittee #1, to secure the budget appropriations, the RFK Medical Plan argued that there would be off-setting savings in the Medi-Cal program. These arguments were based on an assumption that the plan would not be financially viable and dissolve without financial assistance to purchase stop-loss insurance. If this occurred, the RFK Medical Plan 's consultants assumed 50% of its members would be eligible for Medi-Cal at a state cost of $4.7 million. Additionally, the RFK Medical Plan argued that if it were to cease operating, those insured by the plan not eligible for Medi-Cal would become uninsured.
Rather than appropriating state funds to the RFK Medical Plan for the purchase of stop-loss insurance, this bill would require the state to instead reimburse the plan for the claims that exceed the $70,000 attachment point for an individual employee or dependent for a single episode of care up to a total of $3 million. In other words, the state would act as the stop-loss insurer for the RFK Medical Plan. According to the UFW, the RFK Medical Plan has one year of claims experience since it began to pay claims above $70,000, and in the 2014 plan year (September 2014 to August 2015), 17 cases exceeded the $70,000 threshold. The total payments made for these 17 cases were $1.4 million.
Estimated Medi-Cal costs. According to the UFW, the California Endowment estimated that, based on the number of RFK Medical Plan enrollees eligible for Medi-Cal during the 2014 plan year, state costs to cover these enrollees would be approximately $6.6 million.
According to DHCS, after reviewing the estimates, it could not validate the assertions regarding the population that would be eligible for Medi-Cal, or the overall savings projected.
SUPPORT. The UFW is the sponsor of this bill, and states in support that it ensures farm workers and their families who are currently covered by the RFK Medical Plan continue to obtain health benefits. The UFW argues that the ACA actually reduced health care coverage for farm workers, and threatens the UFW RFK Medical Plan, which has employer and union trustees. The UFW states that by focusing on primary and preventive care, the RFK Medical Plan has significantly alleviated the burden on publicly-funded health resources in its coverage areas. The UFW also argues that the Legislature has determined that the RFK Medical Plan is the most efficient and least expensive means to deliver health services to farm workers and their families within the plan's coverage and that it is in the state's interest to ensure these health services continue.
PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
SB 75 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 18, Statutes of 2015, requires DHCS to allocate $2.5 million from the Major Risk Medical Insurance Fund, on a one-time basis, to the RFK Medical Plan for purposes of purchasing stop-loss insurance.
SB 870 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 40, Statutes of 2014, provides $3.2 million in one-time funds from the Major Risk Medical Insurance Fund to the RFK Medical Plan for purposes of purchasing stop-loss insurance.
SB 161 (Ed Hernandez), Chapter 414, Statutes of 2013, establishes regulatory requirements for stop-loss insurance for small employers, including on or after January 1, 2016, setting an individual attachment point of $40,000 or greater and an aggregate attachment point of the greater of $5,000 times the total number of group members, 120% of expected claims, or $40,000; and, exempts small employer stop-loss insurance issued prior to September 1, 2013, from these attachment point requirements.
SB 1431 (De Leon) of 2012 would have set the stop-loss insurance attachment point for small employers on policies issued on or after January 1, 2012, at $45,000 for individuals and the greater of $15,000 times the total number of covered employees and dependents, 130% of expected claims, or $60,000. SB 1431 died in the inactive file on the Assembly Floor.
POLICY COMMENTS
This bill sets a precedent for the state to act as a stop-loss insurer. Under this bill, the state would act as the stop-loss insurer for one single plan. This sets a new precedent for the state and raises policy questions as to whether or not it is the state's role to act as a stop-loss insurer, and whether or not this policy should extend to other plans that may be similarly situated as the RFK Medical Plan.
Should the bill have a sunset date? Unlike previous one-time budget actions appropriating funds to the RFK Medical Plan to purchase stop-loss insurance on the private market, this bill shifts the responsibility for direct payment of claims exceeding $70,000 on the state in perpetuity. The Committee may wish to amend the bill to add a sunset date, perhaps a five-year sunset date, to prevent the state from becoming the default payer of high-cost claims for this plan on a permanent basis. A sunset date also offers the RFK Medical Plan a timeline under which it can continue to strive toward self-sustainment, and report back its progress to the Legislature.
Other proposed amendments.
Amend intent language. The proposed intent language in the bill states that the Legislature has made a determination that the RFK Medical Plan is the “most efficient and least expensive means to deliver health care to farmworkers and their families…” However, while the Legislature may have evaluated previous budget actions and the current provisions proposed in this bill in terms of costs as compared to the Medi-Cal program, it is unclear that the Legislature has made this specific determination. As such, the Committee may wish to clarify the language as follows to more accurately reflect the legislative intent associated with the bill’s provisions:
Proposed Section 1 (e):
The Legislature has determined that the plan is the most
an efficient and least expensive
cost-effective means to deliver health care services to
farm workers and their families within the plan’s coverage areas.
Thus, it is in the state’s interest to expand
maintain the range of health care
services provided by the plan without threatening the plan’s
financial viability.
Technical amendment. The Committee may wish make the following technical amendment for consistency throughout the bill:
Proposed Health and Safety Section 100235 (c) (1):
If
the department receives claims data from the plan pursuant to
subdivision (b), the department shall analyze that data to determine
the aggregate amount of claims that exceed seventy thousand dollars
($70,000) paid by the plan on behalf of an eligible employee or
dependent for any separate
single
episode
of care.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
United Farm Workers
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kelly Green / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
SB 145
Page 2
SENATE THIRD READING
SB 145
(Pan)
As Amended May 5, 2015
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 21-15
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Health |
13-5 |
Bonta, Maienschein, Bonilla, Burke, Chiu, Gomez, Gonzalez, Roger Hernández, Nazarian, Rodriguez, Santiago, Thurmond, Wood |
Chávez, Lackey, Patterson, Steinorth, Waldron |
Judiciary |
8-2 |
Mark Stone, Weber, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Maienschein, Thurmond |
Wagner, Gallagher |
Appropriations |
12-5 |
Gomez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Gordon, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Quirk, Rendon, Weber, Wood |
Bigelow, Chang, Gallagher, Jones, Wagner |
SUMMARY: Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from transporting a patient, who in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to any other location including but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, unless the patient is medically stable or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility. Allows the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to determine if a violation of this bill constitutes an immediate jeopardy violation and if so, to assess penalties accordingly. Prohibits anything in this bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable fiscal impact to DPH, if any.
COMMENTS: According to the author, certain hospitals are transferring patients admitted to their ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. The author states this bill stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of the treating hospitals' emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities, and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies.
Blood alcohol concentration. The amount of alcohol in a person's body is measured by the weight of the alcohol in a certain volume of blood. This is called the blood alcohol concentration (BAC). It is illegal to drive with a BAC of 0.08 or higher. A driver also can be arrested with a BAC below 0.08 when a law enforcement officer has probable cause, based on the driver's behavior. BAC may be affected by age, gender, physical condition, amount of food consumed, and any drugs or medication.
According to information provided by the author and the Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), for the first three months of 2014, 124 emergency calls came from Shasta Regional Medical Center, a Prime Healthcare hospital in Redding, California, which averages to about 41 such calls per month. In comparison, a hospital operated by Dignity Health, about two miles away from Shasta Regional Medical Center, only made 53 emergency calls in the first nine months of 2014, or about six per month.
Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA). EMTALA is an act of the United States Congress, passed in 1986 as part of the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act. It requires hospitals that accept payments from Medicare to provide emergency health care treatment to anyone needing it regardless of citizenship, legal status, or ability to pay. There are no reimbursement provisions. Participating hospitals may not transfer or discharge patients needing emergency treatment except with the informed consent or stabilization of the patient or when their condition requires transfer to a hospital better equipped to administer the treatment. EMTALA applies to "participating hospitals." The statute defines participating hospitals as those that accept payment from the Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services under the Medicare program. Because there are very few hospitals that do not accept Medicare, the law applies to nearly all hospitals.
EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or "dumping" these patients by transferring them to county hospitals or other charity hospitals.
SEIU-UHW writes there is substantial evidence that one of California's largest hospital chains – Prime Healthcare Services – is inappropriately and dangerously transferring patients admitted to the ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. SEIU-UHW states this practice by a for-profit health care provider poses a risk to patient safety and improperly shifts costs and liabilities to the police and corrections facilities.
United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP) states that discharging patients with high blood alcohol levels and transferring them to jail in a police car is dangerous to patients. Hospitals are required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients experiencing an emergency medical condition, and in the case of patients who require emergency services because of very high BAC levels, the hospital must stabilize the patient before attempting to make any transfer. UNAC/UHCP concludes any practice or policy of transferring patients prior to stabilization is unconscionable.
The California Hospital Association (CHA) is opposed to this bill and states the current version of this bill restates a prohibition that is already in both state and federal law. CHA notes that, initially, this bill would have established prescriptive clinical criteria that would have overridden the judgment of physicians, nurses and other medical staff in California's emergency departments. CHA concludes that the current version of this bill now creates a duplicative mandate on hospitals and authorizes DPH to issue penalties it already has the authority to impose.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0001559
Date of Hearing: August 26, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended May 5, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Health |
Vote: |
13 - 5 |
|
Judiciary |
|
8 - 2 |
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a hospital from transporting a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication to any other location, including but not limited to police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, unless the patient is medically stable or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility.
It also allows the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to determine if a violation of this bill constitutes an immediate jeopardy violation and if so, to assess penalties accordingly.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable fiscal impact to CDPH, if any.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, certain hospitals are transporting patients, who are admitted to their ER for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments and correctional facilities by calling 911. The author states this bill stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies. This bill is co-sponsored by Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), and United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP).
Background. Federal law, commonly known as EMTALA (Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act), requires hospitals participating in Medicare (nearly every hospital) to provide stabilizing treatment for individuals with emergency medical conditions regardless of an individual's ability to pay. Under this law, hospitals are barred from patient transfer if the person is medically unstable, unless the patient cannot be stabilized or the patient requests a transfer. CDPH is currently permitted to assess an administrative penalty against hospitals for immediate jeopardy violations. "Immediate jeopardy” is a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient. This bill does not appear to expand existing authority.
Oppostion. The California Hospital Association opposes this bill as unnecessary. The California Nurses Association also opposes, contending the alleged problems it addresses are unsubstantiated.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: August 19, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended May 5, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Health |
Vote: |
13 - 5 |
|
Judiciary |
|
8 - 2 |
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a hospital from transporting a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication to any other location, including but not limited to police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, unless the patient is medically stable or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility.
It also allows the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to determine if a violation of this bill constitutes an immediate jeopardy violation and if so, to assess penalties accordingly.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable fiscal impact to CDPH, if any.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, certain hospitals are transporting patients, who are admitted to their ER for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments and correctional facilities by calling 911. The author states this bill stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies. This bill is co-sponsored by Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), and United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP).
Background. Federal law, commonly known as EMTALA (Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act), requires hospitals participating in Medicare (nearly every hospital) to provide stabilizing treatment for individuals with emergency medical conditions regardless of an individual's ability to pay. Under this law, hospitals are barred from patient transfer if the person is medically unstable, unless the patient cannot be stabilized or the patient requests a transfer. CDPH is currently permitted to assess an administrative penalty against hospitals for immediate jeopardy violations. "Immediate jeopardy” is a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient. This bill does not appear to expand existing authority.
Oppostion. The California Hospital Association opposes this bill as unnecessary. The California Nurses Association also opposes, contending the alleged problems it addresses are unsubstantiated.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
SB 145
Page 7
Date of Hearing: July 14, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended May 5, 2015
SENATE VOTE: 21-15
SUBJECT: HEALTH FACILITIES: PATIENT TRANSPORTING
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD state law be CLARIFIed to provide THAT A HOSPITAL THAT TRANSPORTS OUT A PATIENT who IS MEDICALLY UNSTABLE DUE TO ALCOHOL POISONING is SUBJECT TO ENHANCED ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES BY THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH FOR COMMITTING AN “IMMEDIATE JEOPARDY” VIOLATION?
SYNOPSIS
Existing federal law, the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (known as EMTALA), and state law (largely mirroring EMTALA) both require hospitals that accept payments from Medicare to provide emergency health care treatment to anyone needing it, regardless of citizenship, legal status, or ability to pay. These hospitals may not transfer or discharge patients needing emergency treatment, except after stabilization of the patient's condition, with his or her informed consent, or when the patient's condition requires transfer to another hospital that is better equipped to administer the treatment. Nevertheless, according to the author, there is evidence that Prime Healthcare, one of the largest hospital chains in California, engages in the practice of calling 911 to have some patients who are awaiting treatment for acute alcohol poisoning in its emergency rooms to be transported away to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails before the patient has been treated and stabilized.
This bill, sponsored by unions of healthcare workers, seeks to address this reported pattern of conduct by prohibiting hospitals from causing a patient, who in the judgment of the attending physician is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility. The bill also specifically permits the Department of Public Health (DPH) to determine if a violation of this prohibition constitutes an "immediate jeopardy" violation, as defined under existing law, and if so, to assess penalties accordingly. Proponents contend that this bill is helpful because it clarifies which conduct is prohibited under EMTALA, authorizes harsher penalties for these specific violations, and further deters hospitals from transporting intoxicated, unstable persons. The bill is opposed by the California Hospital Association and the California Nurses Association. These opponents contend that the bill is unnecessary because it restates a prohibition that is already in both state and federal law, and authorizes DPH to impose fines that it already has the authority to impose. They also contend that the statistics cited by the author as justification for the bill are unsubstantiated and are not suggestive of either statewide EMTALA violations, or a systematic problem of patient dumping involving unstable patients with alcohol poisoning. This bill previously passed the Assembly Health Committee by a 13-5 vote and will be referred to the Appropriations Committee should it pass this Committee.
SUMMARY: Clarifies the prohibition in existing law against hospitals transporting patients to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized, and the authority for enhanced administrative penalties against a hospital for transporting patients who are severely intoxicated and medically unstable. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility.
Allows the Department of Public Health (DPH) to determine if a violation of this prohibition constitutes an immediate jeopardy violation and if so, to assess penalties accordingly.
Clarifies that nothing in this bill should be construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention.
EXISTING LAW:
Defines “emergency medical condition” as a condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in placing the patient’s health in serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions, or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part. (Health & Safety Code Section 1317.1(b). All further references are to this code unless otherwise stated.)
Defines “stabilization” as when, in the opinion of the treating physician, the patient’s medical condition is such that, within reasonable medical probability, no material deterioration of the patient’s condition is likely to result from, or occur during, the release or transfer of the patient. (Section 1317.1(j).)
Requires that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized. (Sections 1317 and 1317.1.)
Establishes a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals determined by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to have violated the above requirement and other provisions of state law relating to the transfer and discharge of emergency patients. Further provides for penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians determined by the Medical Board of California (MBC) to have violated these same provisions of law. (Section 1317.6, subd. (a) and (c).)
Authorizes DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. (Section 1280.3(a).)
Defines "immediate jeopardy" violation to mean a violation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient. (Section 1280.3(g).)
Authorizes DPH to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations based on criteria including, but not limited to, the following:
The patient’s physical and mental condition;
The probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
The actual financial harm to patients, if any;
The nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
The facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
Factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict its ability to comply with state law;
The demonstrated willfulness of the violation;
The extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring. (Section 1280.3(b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to address a reported pattern of hospitals transporting severely intoxicated patients from hospital emergency rooms back into police or correctional authority in apparent violation of state and federal laws. According to the author:
Substantial evidence reveals that Prime Healthcare (Prime) services are transferring patients, admitted to the Emergency Room (ER) for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. Despite being one of the largest hospital chains in the state, Prime has an unusually high number of cases where the police are called on patients in the ER. Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be arrested and transferred to a jail before the patient has been treated and stabilized. Acute alcohol poisoning is a medical emergency.
This bill would prohibit hospitals from causing a patient whose blood alcohol content is at a level which, in the judgment of the attending physician, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or transferred to another licensed health facility. Penalties that are currently in statute will be activated if a patient is transferred even though they were deemed medically unstable. SB 145 stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of treating hospital's emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities, and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies.
Background on EMTALA. The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, (EMTALA) was passed by Congress in 1986, requiring hospitals that accept payments from Medicare to provide emergency health care treatment to anyone needing it, regardless of citizenship, legal status, or ability to pay. Participating hospitals may not transfer or discharge patients needing emergency treatment except with the informed consent or stabilization of the patient, or when their condition requires transfer to a hospital better equipped to administer the treatment. Hospitals are required to provide stabilizing treatment to patients with an emergency medical condition, and if a hospital is unable to stabilize a patient within its capability, or if the patient requests, the hospital may transfer the patient to an appropriate transfer to another facility should be implemented.
EMTALA applies to all hospitals that accept payment from the Department of Health and Human Services or Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services under the Medicare program. Because there are very few hospitals that do not accept Medicare, the law applies to virtually all hospitals. There are no reimbursement provisions under EMTALA.
According to the California Hospital Association: "EMTALA was enacted in response to studies that found that indigent emergency patients had been turned away from hospitals for necessary services or transferred (i.e.“dumped”) to public and charity hospitals in an unstabilized condition. Although EMTALA was passed to mandate access to emergency services by the indigent, Congress applied the EMTALA requirements to all patients regardless of their financial or insurance status. In general, both the federal regulatory agencies and the courts have defined the primary objectives of EMTALA as twofold: to enhance access by all persons to emergency services and to prohibit discrimination in the provision of emergency services to persons presenting with the same or similar types of conditions." (California Hospital Association, EMTALA—A Guide to Patient Anti-Dumping Laws. (8th ed.) September 2012.)
This bill seeks to address a reported pattern of patient transporting in California, but disputed by opponents, in apparent violation of EMTALA. According to the author, evidence indicates that Prime Healthcare (Prime), one of the largest hospital chains in California, engages in the practice of calling 911 to have some patients who are admitted to its emergency rooms for acute alcohol poisoning to be transported away to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails before the patient has been treated and stabilized. SEIU- United Healthcare Workers West (UHW), one of the co-sponsors of the bill, describes the reported evidence:
Throughout the Prime system, our research has revealed and documented significant and unusual numbers of 911 calls originating from Prime hospitals. In fact, in the first three months of 2014 alone, 124 emergency calls were placed from Shasta Regional Medical Center (41 calls/month). In the first seven months of 2014, 509 emergency calls were placed from one hospital: Desert Valley Hospital (73 calls/month). This is not a new phenomenon. Between Jan. 1, 2010 and Aug. 1, 2014, a total of 3,326 police or 911 calls were made from Desert Valley (60 calls/month). Over the first seven months of 2014, 420 calls were placed from Huntington Beach Hospital (60 calls/month).
For comparison, in the first nine months of 2014, 53 emergency calls were placed from Mercy Medical Center, a Dignity hospital less than two miles away from Shasta (6 calls/month). As another comparison point, Seton Medical Center (Daughters of Charity) made 75 emergency calls in the first seven months of 2014 (11 calls/month). And St. Vincent Medical Center (also Daughters) logged 57 calls in the first six months of 2014 (10 calls/month).
In addition to the general 911 call volume data detailed above, UHW also describes more specific evidence of calls seeking to have patients with alcohol poisoning transported and removed from Prime-owned hospitals. They contend:
More specifically, Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be booked into jail. At its Shasta facility, for example, the hospital routinely calls 911 on patients with medically dangerous levels of blood alcohol, and the Redding Police take many of those patients to the county jail. In just the first three months of 2014 alone, patients were arrested at Shasta for alcohol-related problems 11 times. In the first 6 months of 2010, Shasta did this an astonishing 59 times.
In a number of cases, the reporting party inside Shasta reports blood alcohol levels associated with death and comas but still requests an arrest be made on the patient. For example, here are some Shasta call summaries where the patient was booked after the emergency call was made and the officer responded: (1) “Subject has BAC of .48 needs to be picked up.” (2) ”Intoxicated subject cleared for release. Still has BAC of .44.” (3) ”Patient medically cleared with .40 BAC.”
By contrast, over the course of a full year, Dignity Health’s Mercy Medical Center (Mercy) patients were booked just 11 times following a call to 911 or the police department. However, many of the Mercy cases involved patients who were assaultive or violent, whereas most of the Shasta instances did not.
The Committee notes that, if these reports are true, it would appear that the conduct described above would already constitute a violation of EMTALA. The author contends, however, that such conduct is still occurring, even though EMTALA and the state law implementing EMTALA (Health & Safety Code Sections 1317 et seq.) are supposed to prevent it. According to the author, the bill simply clarifies the conduct which is prohibited under EMTALA, authorizes harsher penalties for these particular violations, and further deters transportation of intoxicated, unstable persons in violation of the law.
The California Nurses Association (CNA) opposes the bill, asserting that the bill is in response to a problem that cannot be substantiated. According to CNA:
Emergency room discharge and transfer data is reported by hospitals and collected by the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development. It is possible from this date to compare the rate of ER discharge/transfer to courts and law enforcement for any number of counties in California. The percentage of patients discharged or transferred to courts or law enforcement in Shasta County in 2013 is 0.22 % which is lower than the state average of 0.39%, and is lower than the vast majority of other counties in California. In fact, Sacramento and Yolo Counties, which are included in Senate District 6, have higher ER discharge/transfers to courts and law enforcement at 0.40% and 0.92%, respectively.
We do not believe that any of these county statistics are suggestive of either statewide EMTALA violations or of a systematic problem with patient dumping of unstable patients with alcohol poisoning. We believe this legislation is a "solution" in search of a problem. In fact, some of the highest statistics are from counties with only one hospital. We do not believe the statistics cited are evidence of any improper handling of inebriated patients in hospital emergency rooms.
In response, the United Nurses Associations of California/ Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP), co-sponsors of the bill, contend that the bill is not a restatement of existing law and is in fact needed to address a real problem of "patient dumping" that continues, despite EMTALA being in effect since 1986 and laws in 43 states that have enacted statutes mirroring or supplementing the federal EMTALA provisions. These proponents state:
Despite these laws, a four year study in the American Medical Association Journal of Ethics found violations in 527 hospitals across 46 states. Of the 527 hospitals, 117 had violated EMTALA more than once. ("Refusal of Emergency Care and Patient Dumping"; AMA Journal of Ethics, Vol. 11, No. 1: 49-53 (Jan. 2009).) Moreover, the study found that for-profit hospitals were "significantly more likely" to violate the act multiple times. It is believed that the refusal adhere to the mandates of EMTALA is due to the ambiguity of the statutory provisions, poor enforcement mechanisms, and divergent judicial interpretations of the law.
SB 145 seeks to eliminate some of that ambiguity by making it clear that alcohol intoxication is a medical issue that requires stabilization prior to transportation of patients. Whether hospitals are purposefully violating EMTALA in an effort to reduce the costs of treating uninsured or underinsured patients, or whether they are simply misinterpreting the law, SB 145 will remove all doubt and ensure that severely intoxicated patients get the care they need, and which the law demands.
Penalties for violations of EMTALA. Under existing law, a hospital may be subject to a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation of EMTALA. The Department of Public Health (DPH) is also authorized to fine a hospital up to $25,000 for each violation of EMTALA. In addition, DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines upon hospitals for any action which creates an “immediate jeopardy” to patients, defined as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause serious injury or death. The fines may be up to $75,000 for a first violation, up to $100,000 for a second violation, and up to $125,000 for a third violation. For situations that do not constitute “immediate jeopardy,” DPH may levy a fine up to $25,000 per violation.
The Committee notes that under Section 1280.3, DPH already appears to have the authority to assess enhanced penalties in cases where the conduct prohibited by this bill rises to the level of an "immediate jeopardy" violation. According to the author, this bill simply clarifies that DPH may extend these penalties in existing law to the specific practices of patient transporting prohibited by this bill, namely when a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication and is transported to another location despite being medically unstable.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The bill is supported by AFSCME and SEIU, among others, who contend the bill is needed to ensure patients receive the care they need instead of being transferred away to save the hospital costs. AFSCME writes:
AFSCME is firmly against patient dumping: a common practice among some for-profit hospital corporations. These hospitals regularly call the police on intoxicated patients in the emergency room in order to reduce their own costs, in turn placing the responsibility on our already burdened criminal justice system. Hospitals exist for the sole purpose of providing care to patients that are in need. It is common sense for a hospital to treat a patient and ensure that they are stabilized before transferring them. SB 145 works to protect patients from corporate interests that would otherwise prioritize saving a dollar to saving a life. AFSCME implores the legislature to prioritize saving lives over recklessly cutting costs.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Hospital Association (CHA) opposes the bill, arguing that the bill is unnecessary because it restates a prohibition that is already in both state and federal law, and authorizes DPH to impose fines it already has the authority to impose. CHA states:
Recent amendments now create a duplicative mandate on hospitals and authorize DPH to issue penalties it already has the authority to issue. . . SB 145 authorizes these penalties when patients diagnosed with alcohol intoxication are illegally transferred. Yet there is no evidence whatsoever to support the author's and sponsor's claim of a "rampant" statewide problem of inappropriate transfer of patients with serious alcohol intoxication. In actual practice, in fact, it is often law enforcement officers who bring intoxicated patients to emergency departments for medical clearance. CHA has been unable to substantiate allegations (against Prime Healthcare).
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
United Nurses Associations of California / Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/
UHCP) (co-sponsor)
SEIU, United Healthcare Workers (co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
Service Employees International Union (SEIU)
California Medical Association (CMA)
Opposition
California Hospital Association
California Nurses Association
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SB 145
Page 4
Date of Hearing: June 23, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Rob Bonta, Chair
SB 145
(Pan) – As Amended May 5, 2015
SENATE VOTE: 21-15
SUBJECT: Health facilities: patient transporting.
SUMMARY: Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from transporting a patient, who in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to any other location including but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, unless the patient is medically stable or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility. Allows the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to determine if a violation of this bill constitutes an immediate jeopardy violation and if so, to assess penalties accordingly. Prohibits anything in this bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
EXISTING LAW:
Establishes DPH which, among other things, licenses, inspects, and regulates health facilities.
Requires, under both the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) and also under state law, that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room (ER) be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized.
Provides for a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals who violate the state version of EMTALA, and penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians who violate these provisions.
Establishes a structure under which DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations. Requires DPH to promulgate regulations establishing the criteria to assess these administrative penalties, and requires these criteria to include, but not be limited to, the following:
The patient’s physical and mental condition;
The probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
The actual financial harm to patients, if any;
The nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
The facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
Factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict the facility’s ability to comply with state law;
The demonstrated willfulness of the violation; and,
The extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Defines “immediate jeopardy” as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, certain hospitals are transferring patients admitted to their ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. The author states this bill stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of the treating hospitals' emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities, and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies.
BACKGROUND.
Blood alcohol concentration. The amount of alcohol in a person’s body is measured by the weight of the alcohol in a certain volume of blood. This is called the blood alcohol concentration, or BAC. It is illegal to drive with a BAC of .08 or higher. A driver also can be arrested with a BAC below .08 when a law enforcement officer has probable cause, based on the driver’s behavior. BAC may be affected by age, gender, physical condition, amount of food consumed, and any drugs or medication.
According to information provided by the author and the Service
Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West
(SEIU-UHW), for the first three months of 2014, 124 emergency calls
came from Shasta Regional Medical Center, a Prime Healthcare hospital
in Redding, California, which averages to about 41 such calls per
month. In comparison, a hospital operated by Dignity Health, about
two miles away from Shasta Regional Medical Center, only made 53
emergency calls in the first nine months of 2014, or about six per
month.
SEIU-UHW also cited some Shasta emergency call
summaries that described requests for patients to be picked up with
very high BACs. According to SEIU-UHW, the following call summaries
are examples where the patient was booked after the emergency call
was made and the officer responded (these incidents occurred in
February and March of 2010):
“Subject has BAC of .48 and needs to be picked up.”
“Intoxicated subject cleared for release. Still has BAC of .44.”
“Patient medically cleared with .40 BAC.”
EMTALA. The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, (EMTALA) is an act of the United States Congress, passed in 1986 as part of the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act. It requires hospitals that accept payments from Medicare to provide emergency health care treatment to anyone needing it regardless of citizenship, legal status, or ability to pay. There are no reimbursement provisions. Participating hospitals may not transfer or discharge patients needing emergency treatment except with the informed consent or stabilization of the patient or when their condition requires transfer to a hospital better equipped to administer the treatment. EMTALA applies to "participating hospitals." The statute defines participating hospitals as those that accept payment from the Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services under the Medicare program. Because there are very few hospitals that do not accept Medicare, the law applies to nearly all hospitals.
EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or “dumping” these patients by transferring them to county hospitals or other charity hospitals.
SUPPORT. SEIU-UHW writes there is substantial evidence that one of California's largest hospital chains – Prime Healthcare Services – is inappropriately and dangerously transferring patients admitted to the ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. SEIU-UHW states this practice by a for-profit health care provider poses a risk to patient safety and improperly shifts costs and liabilities to the police and corrections facilities.
United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP) states that discharging patients with high blood alcohol levels and transferring them to jail in a police car is dangerous to patients. Hospitals are required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients experiencing an emergency medical condition, and in the case of patients who require emergency services because of very high BAC levels, the hospital must stabilize the patient before attempting to make any transfer. UNAC/UHCP concludes any practice or policy of transferring patients prior to stabilization is unconscionable.
The California State Council of the Service Employees International Union (SEIU California) writes this bill would prohibit a hospital from transporting a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician is at risk for serious injury or death as a result of alcohol intoxication until they have been medically stabilized. SEIU California concludes this important patient safety measure would uphold the hospital's duty to provide appropriate medical treatment rather than shift this responsibility onto the criminal justice system.OPPOSITION. The California Hospital Association (CHA) is opposed to this bill and states the current version of this bill restates a prohibition that is already in both state and federal law. CHA notes that, initially, this bill would have established prescriptive clinical criteria that would have overridden the judgment of physicians, nurses and other medical staff in California's emergency departments. CHA concludes that the current version of this bill now creates a duplicative mandate on hospitals and authorizes DPH to issue penalties it already has the authority to impose.
PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
SB 275 (Cedillo), of 2007, would have prohibited a hospital from causing a patient to be transported to a location other than the patient’s residence or another health facility without the patient’s written consent, and established significant penalties for doing so. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, who stated in his veto message that while he was strongly opposed to patient dumping, hospitals must already meet specific discharge planning requirements and make appropriate arrangements for post-hospital care.
SB 1312 (Alquist), Chapter 895, Statutes of 2006, among other provisions, authorized DPH to assess administrative penalties on hospitals based on deficiencies constituting immediate jeopardy to the health and safety of a patient.
DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
POLICY COMMENT. After significant amendments in the Senate, the provisions of this bill now appear to essentially restate existing law regarding illegal transfer of patients, while highlighting the condition of alcohol poisoning. The Committee may wish to consider whether or not it is necessary.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
SEIU-UHW (co-sponsor)
UNAC/UHCP
(co-sponsor)
California State Council of the Service Employees
International Union
Opposition
California Hospital Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
SB 145
Page 7
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 145
Amended: 5/5/15
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/22/15
AYES: Hernandez, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Roth
NOES: Nguyen, Nielsen
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hall, Wolk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-1, 4/28/15
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Health facilities: patient transporting
DIGEST: This bill prohibits hospitals from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or transferred to another licensed health facility.
Existing law:
Requires, under both the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) and also under state law, that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room to be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized.
Defines “emergency medical condition” as a condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in placing the patient’s health in serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions, or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part.
Defines “stabilization” as when, in the opinion of the treating physician, the patient’s medical condition is such that, within reasonable medical probability, no material deterioration of the patient’s condition is likely to result from, or occur during, the release or transfer of the patient.
Provides for a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals found by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to have violated the state law version of EMTALA, and penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians whom the Medical Board of California found violated these provisions of law. Additionally, permits a person who suffers personal harm as a result of a violation of these provisions of law to recover damages and other appropriate relief in a civil action (known as a private right of action).
Establishes a structure under which DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations. Requires DPH to promulgate regulations establishing the criteria to assess these administrative penalties, and requires these criteria to include, but not be limited to, the following:
The patient’s physical and mental condition;
The probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
The actual financial harm to patients, if any;
The nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
The facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
Factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict the facility’s ability to comply with state law;
The demonstrated willfulness of the violation; and
The extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Defines “immediate jeopardy” as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy.
This bill:
Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, policy custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medical stabilized, as defined, or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
Permits DPH, if it determines that a hospital has violated the provisions of this bill, to determine that the violation is an immediate jeopardy violation, as specified, and to assess penalties accordingly.
Prohibits anything in this bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
Comments
Author’s statement. According to the author, “SB 145 stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of treating hospital's emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies. Some of the hospitals in California routinely call 911 and have patients with potentially lethal levels of alcohol in their systems taken to jail. It goes against everything we stand for in healthcare and it has to stop. Substantial evidence reveals that Prime Healthcare (Prime) services are transferring patients, admitted to the Emergency Room (ER) for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. Despite being one of the largest hospital chains in the state, Prime has an unusually high number of cases where the police are called on patients in the ER. Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be arrested and transferred to a jail before the patient has been treated and stabilized. Acute alcohol poisoning is a medical emergency.”
History of the problem. According to information provided by the author and the Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), a co-sponsor of this bill, for the first three months of 2014, 124 emergency calls came from Shasta Regional Medical Center, a Prime Healthcare hospital in Redding, California, which averages to about 41 such calls per month. In comparison, a hospital operated by Dignity Health about two miles away from Shasta Regional Medical Center only made 53 emergency calls in the first nine months of 2014, or about six per month.
SEIU-UHW also cited some Shasta emergency call summaries that described requests for patients to be picked up with very high blood alcohol concentration (BAC) levels. According to SEIU-UHW, the following call summaries are examples where the patient was booked after the emergency call was made and the officer responded (each of these incidents were from February and March of 2010):
“Subject has BAC of .48 and needs to be picked up.”
“Intoxicated subject cleared for release. Still has BAC of .44”
“Patient medically cleared with .40 BAC”
EMTALA. Sometimes referred to as the “Patient Anti-Dumping Law,” EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or “dumping” these patients by transferring them to county hospitals or other charity hospitals. According to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in 1986, Congress enacted EMTALA to ensure public access to emergency services regardless of ability to pay. Section 1867 of the Social Security Act imposes specific obligations on Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services to provide a medical screening examination when a request is made for examination or treatment for an emergency medical condition, including active labor, regardless of an individual’s ability to pay. Hospitals are then required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients with an emergency medical condition. If a hospital is unable to stabilize a patient within its capability, or if the patient requests, an appropriate transfer should be implemented. As an enforcement mechanism, EMTALA also established a private right of action.
Effects of BAC. A chart from Stanford University’s Office of Alcohol Policy and Education, which describes the physical and mental effects of various BAC levels, is typical of many such charts. At a BAC of .07 to .09, this chart states that the effect is mild impairment of balance, speech, vision and control, and that in California, you will test as legally impaired to drive. At a BAC of .16 to .20, dysphoria predominates, nausea may appear, and the drinker has the appearance of a “sloppy drunk.” At .25 to .30, the person is severely intoxicated, needs assistance walking, has mental confusion, and there is vomiting. At .35 to .40, loss of consciousness and brink of coma, and at .40 and up, onset of coma with likelihood of death due to respiratory failure. Another chart, describing wider ranges, broke BAC levels into categories such as .18 to .30 being the “confusion” stage, with various symptoms; .25 to .40 the “stupor” stage; .35 to .50 the “coma” stage (which includes possible death as a symptom); and .45 and above “death from respiratory arrest.”
In a study published in EMS World in March of 2014 entitled “Acute Alcohol Poisoning,” the authors included a similar chart, which listed “coma in the non-habituated drinker” at a BAC of .25-.30. However, this study stated that “it should be noted there is a poor correlation between BAC and clinical exam findings in patients with alcohol habituation.” According to the study, “respiratory depression and subsequent death may occur in the non-habituated patient at concentrations of 0.4-0.5, but it is not uncommon for a chronic alcoholic to appear minimally intoxicated with a BAC as high as 0.4.” The study also noted that another factor that affects a patient’s clinical exam is whether the patient’s BAC is increasing or decreasing. According to this study, it is a known phenomenon, termed the Mellanby effect, that the clinical manifestations of alcohol intoxication are more prominent when BAC is rising.
Prior Legislation
SB 275 (Cedillo, 2007) would have prohibited a hospital from causing a patient to be transported to a location other than the patient’s residence or another health facility without the patient’s written consent, and established penalties and an enforcement process that is very similar to this bill, including civil penalties of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, who stated in his veto message that while he was strongly opposed to patient dumping, hospitals must already meet specific discharge planning requirements and make appropriate arrangements for post-hospital care. Enforcement of existing laws is critical, however, additional penalties are premature.
SB 1312 (Alquist, Chapter 895, Statutes of 2006), among other provisions, authorized DPH to assess administrative penalties on hospitals based on deficiencies constituting immediate jeopardy to the health and safety of a patient.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SEIU-UHW (co-source)
United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (co-source)
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Medical Association
SEIU California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/19/15)
California Hospital Association
California Nurses Association
ARGUMENTS
IN SUPPORT: This bill is co-sponsored by SEIU-UHW, and by the
United Nurses Association of California/Union of Health Care
Professionals (UNAC/UHCP). According to SEIU-UHW, there is
substantial evidence that Prime Healthcare Services is
inappropriately and dangerously transferring patients admitted to the
ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections
facilities, and county jails by calling 911. SEIU-UHW states that
this is immoral, poses a risk to patient safety, and is an abuse of
the 911 system, which should of course be reserved purely for true
emergencies. According to SEIU-UHW, in a number of cases, the
reporting party at Shasta Regional Medical Center reported BAC levels
associated with death and comas but still requested an arrest be made
on the patient. SEIU-UHW states that discharging patients with BACs
higher than 0.3% and transferring them to jail in a police car is
dangerous, and that in the case of patients who require emergency
services because of very high BAC levels, the hospital must stabilize
the patient before attempting to make any transfer.
UNAC/UHCP
states in support that regularly calling the police on intoxicated
patients is a basic part of the Prime Healthcare business model and
helps reduce their costs by forcing these patients into the care and
custody of corrections officials, which in turn puts unnecessary
burdens on an already strained criminal justice system. SEIU
California states that discharging a patient with a BAC of .08 into
the custody of the jail, corrections, or police should only occur if
there is a compelling public safety reason, such as in cases where
other patients and hospital staff are at risk. The American
Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees states in support
that it is common sense for a hospital to treat a patient and ensure
that they are stabilized before transferring them, and that this bill
works to protect patients from corporate interests that would
otherwise prioritize saving a dollar to saving a life.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Nurses Association (CNA) states in opposition that this bill is a solution in search of a problem, and that the discharge or transfer of an unstable patient is already illegal in California. According to CNA, this bill, if passed, might lead to the unintended consequence of creating more risk of harm to healthcare workers by causing hospitals to hesitate to call law enforcement for assistance despite the presence of a violent individual who is under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The California Hospital Association (CHA) states in opposition that this bill will impede the clinical judgment of physicians, nurses and other clinical staff in California’s emergency departments. According to CHA, a physician must determine medical stability, and that this bill would compromise the important physician/patient relationship which is the foundation for all medical care and may not be in the best interest of every patient.
Prepared by: Vince Marchand / HEALTH /
5/20/15 11:58:23
**** END ****
SB 145 (Pan)
Page 7 of 7
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 145 (Pan)
Version: April 23, 2015
Hearing Date: April 28, 2015
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
NR
SUBJECT
Health facilities: patient transporting
DESCRIPTION
This bill would prohibit hospitals from causing a patient whose blood alcohol content is at a level which, in the judgment of the attending physician, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or transferred to another licensed health facility. This bill would allow the Attorney General, the city attorney, or local district attorneys to enforce the above provisions and seek civil penalty of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations.
BACKGROUND
The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) requires that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room be provided with a medical screening evaluation, regardless of that patient’s ability to pay. EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or transferring these patients to county or other charity hospitals. Hospitals are also required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients with an emergency medical condition.
SB 275 (Cedillo, 2007) was intended to address the practice known as “homeless dumping” where indigent patients were discharged and transported away from the hospital. In some cases, these patients were abandoned in an unfamiliar neighborhood. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, who explained that “hospitals already must meet specific discharge planning requirements and make appropriate arrangements for post-hospital care. Federal and state laws already provide sanctions, including potential loss of licensure and funding, against hospitals that violate licensing or certification requirements. [While] enforcement of existing laws is critical, … additional penalties are premature.”
This bill would employ similar enforcement provisions to address the issue of physicians transferring intoxicated patients into police custody rather than treating them in emergency medical facilities.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal and state law requires that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room to be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1317 et seq.; 42 U.S.C. Sec. 1395dd.)
Existing law defines “emergency medical condition” as a condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in placing the patient’s health in serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions, or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1317.1.)
Existing law defines “stabilization” as when, in the opinion of the treating physician, the patient’s medical condition is such that, within reasonable medical probability, no material deterioration of the patient’s condition is likely to result from, or occur during, the release or transfer of the patient. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1317.1.)
Existing law provides for a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals found by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to have violated the state law version of EMTALA, and penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians whom the Medical Board of California found violated these provisions of law. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1317.6.)
Existing law allows DPH to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations based on criteria including:
the patient’s physical and mental condition;
the probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
the actual financial harm to patients, if any;
the nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
the facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict the facility’s ability to comply with state law;
the demonstrated willfulness of the violation; and
the extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1280.3.)
Existing law authorizes DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, defined as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1280.3.)
Existing law authorizes DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1280.3.)
This bill would prohibit a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient who, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
This bill would require the Department of Public Health (DPH), if it determines that a hospital has violated the provisions of this bill, to consider assessment of an administrative penalty, and referral to the appropriate authorities for consideration of misdemeanor criminal penalties for a violation of any of the provisions of law governing hospitals, as specified.
This bill would subject a hospital to a civil penalty of $150,000 upon a second violation of this bill, and would authorize the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney as specified, to bring a civil action seeking civil penalties, preventive relief including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
This bill would provide that a hospital that has been criminally convicted of a violation of this bill, which has been previously penalized for two separate violations of this bill, may be subject to civil penalties of no less than $300,000.
This bill would require the court, in determining the civil penalty to be imposed upon a second or subsequent violation, to consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to:
whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm;
whether the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient;
evidence, if any, of willfulness;
the number of repeated violations; and
the presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
This bill would provide that any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of the civil penalty remedies, including, but not limited to, expert’s and attorney’s fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision, be recoverable from the hospital.
This bill would require that any civil penalty collected from an action brought by the Attorney General be paid into the General Fund of the county or city where the judgment was entered, and would require all civil penalties collected be used exclusively for the provision of post-hospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
This bill would exempt a number of situations from the provisions of the bill including:
patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings;
patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabiliation; and
residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disability Services Act, as specified.
This bill would not preclude criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law, nor does the bill limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations, inspections, or implementation/enforcement restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
This bill would prohibit anything in the bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
COMMENT
Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Substantial evidence reveals that Prime Healthcare (Prime) services are transferring patients, admitted to the Emergency Room (ER) for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. Despite being one of the largest hospital chains in the state, Prime has an unusually high number of cases where the police are called on patients in the ER. Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be arrested and transferred to a jail before the patient has been treated and stabilized. Acute alcohol poisoning is a medical emergency.
Although EMTALA and State law are supposed to prevent this, it is still occurring. Our bill is applying harsher penalties and putting stricter policies on hospitals to further deter the transportation of severely intoxicated individuals.
Enforcement penalties arguably excessive
Hospitals, under existing law may be subject to a civil penalty of up to $25,000, for violation of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA), which requires that all persons who seek emergency medical care must be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the person’s ability to pay. If a patient is indeed suffering from an emergency medical condition, EMTALA requires that the patient to be treated until medically stabilized. The Department of Public Health (DPH) is authorized to fine a hospital up to $25,000 for any violations of EMTALA. In addition, DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines upon hospitals for any action which creates an “immediate” jeopardy, defined as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause serious injury or death. The fines may be up to $75,000 for a first violation of, up to $100,000 for a second violation, and up to $125,000 for a third violation. For situations that do not constitute “immediate jeopardy,” DPH may levy a fine up to $25,000 per violation.
This bill would give enforcement authority to the Attorney General (AG), district attorneys, and city attorneys and create a penalty structure that is six times the current penalties for an EMTALA violation, and twice as much as the existing structure for immediate jeopardy situations. The author argues these heightened penalties are necessary because existing state and federal laws are not preventing the transfer of patients with life-threatening blood alcohol levels. However, giving multiple authorities the ability to penalize an organization for the same violation, could subject that organization to multiple, inconsistent judgments. Accordingly, even if DPH found that a hospital was not in violation for a particular transfer of a patient, the city attorney or district attorney may still bring an action and the court may find that the hospital impermissibly transferred the patient. Further, any penalty would be paid to the treasurer of the city or county of the jurisdiction in which the judgment was ordered. Finally, with regard to the particular situation this bill seeks to address, the author has provided no evidence that DPH has failed to investigate Prime’s transfer of intoxicated patients.
The California Hospital Association (CHA) writes in opposition “there is no evidence whatsoever of a rampant statewide problem of inappropriate transfers of patients with serious alcohol intoxication… In actual practice, however, it is often law enforcement officers who bring intoxicated patients to EDs for medical clearance. ... It appears that the only purpose of the bill is to increase penalties and punish hospitals if the judgment of a physician regarding a particular intoxicated patient is deemed incorrect by regulators or lawyers. CHA believes the established, well-functioning penalty process works well as is. ”
Staff notes that this bill would create enforcement authority in the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney, by authorizing these individuals to bring a civil action for alleged violations of the bill. Under existing law, the Department of Public Health (DPH) has the authority to assess administrative fines and civil penalties for these same violations. By not precluding prosecution or action under any other law, this bill could make hospitals vulnerable to simultaneous penalties and fines from multiple entities, which could have the unintended effect of compromising, through financial hardship, the quality of services the hospital can provide to the community.
In addition, arguably, as a matter of public policy, setting higher penalties for the impermissible transfer of intoxicated patients over the impermissible transfer of all other types of patients suffering from an emergency medical condition could imply that the Legislature views the transfer of an intoxicated patient more egregious than the impermissible transfer of a patient who is suffering from any other life-threatening condition. This is further exacerbated by the fact that a family, whose loved one died after an impermissible transfer, could have their non-economic damages capped at only $250,000 in a wrongful death suit under Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA), but under this bill the community could recover far more than that amount.
In opposition, the California Nurses Association writes that “this bill is a solution in search of a problem, [because] the discharge or transfer of an unstable patient is already illegal in California. If passed, [this bill] might lead to the unintended consequence of creating more risk of harm to healthcare workers by causing hospitals to hesitate to call law enforcement for assistance despite the presence of a violent individual who is under the influence of alcohol or drugs.”
Support: American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO; California State Council of the Service Employees International Union
Opposition: California Hospital Association; California Nurses Association
HISTORY
Source: United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals; SEIU-UHW
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: SB 275 (Cedillo, 2007) would have prohibited a hospital from causing a patient to be transported to a location other than the patient’s residence or another health facility without the patient’s written consent, and established penalties and an enforcement process. This bill was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger.
Prior Vote: Senate Health Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
**************
SB 145 (Pan) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 145
AUTHOR: |
Pan |
||
VERSION: |
January 27, 2015 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
April 22, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Vince Marchand |
||
SUBJECT: Health facilities: patient transporting
SUMMARY:
Prohibits hospitals from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greater to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or transferred to another licensed health facility, and provides for enforcement of repeat violators by the Attorney General or by local district attorneys, including civil penalties of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations.
Existing law:
Requires, under both the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) and also under state law, that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room to be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized.
Defines “emergency medical condition” as a condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in placing the patient’s health in serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions, or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part.
Defines “stabilization” as when, in the opinion of the treating physician, the patient’s medical condition is such that, within reasonable medical probability, no material deterioration of the patient’s condition is likely to result from, or occur during, the release or transfer of the patient.
Provides for a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals found by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to have violated the state law version of EMTALA, and penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians whom the Medical Board of California found violated these provisions of law. Additionally, permits a person who suffers personal harm as a result of a violation of these provisions of law to recover damages and other appropriate relief in a civil action (known as a private right of action).
Establishes a structure under which DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations. Requires DPH to promulgate regulations establishing the criteria to assess these administrative penalties, and requires these criteria to include, but not be limited to, the following:
The patient’s physical and mental condition;
The probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
The actual financial harm to patients, if any;
The nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
The facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
Factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict the facility’s ability to comply with state law;
The demonstrated willfulness of the violation; and
The extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Defines “immediate jeopardy” as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy.
This bill:
Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of 0.08 percent or greater to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, policy custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medical stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
Requires DPH, if it determines that a hospital has violated the provisions of this bill, to consider, at a minimum, all of the following actions:
Assessment of an administrative penalty, as provided for in specified provisions of existing law; and,
Referral to the appropriate authorities for consideration of commencing an action to enforce misdemeanor criminal penalties for a violation of any of the provisions of law governing hospitals, as specified.
Requires a hospital to be subject to a civil penalty of $150,000 upon a second violation of this bill, and permits the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or a city attorney of a city and county, to bring a civil action seeking civil penalties, preventive relief, including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
Specifies that a hospital that has been criminally convicted of a violation of this bill, which has been previously penalized for two separate violations of this bill, may be subject to civil penalties of no less than $300,000.
Requires the court, in determining the civil penalty to be imposed upon a second or subsequent violation, to consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
Whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm;
Whether the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient;
Evidence, if any, of willfulness;
The number of repeated violations; and,
The presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
Requires any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of the civil penalty remedies, including, but not limited to, expert’s and attorney’s fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision, to be recoverable from the liable hospital.
Requires the civil penalty collected to be paid into the General Fund for any action brought by the Attorney General, to the county treasurer where the judgment was entered for any action brought by a district attorney, and to the city treasurer for any action brought by a city attorney. Requires all civil penalties collected to be used exclusively for the provision of post-hospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
Specifies that this bill does not apply to any of the following:
Patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings;
Patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation; and,
Residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disability Services Act, and in accordance with an individual program plan, as defined, developed specifically for the resident.
Specifies that nothing in this bill precludes criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law, nor does anything in the bill limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations or inspections, or implementing and enforcing restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
Prohibits anything in this bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. According to the author, SB 145 stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of treating hospital's emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies. Some of the hospitals in California routinely call 911 and have patients with potentially lethal levels of alcohol in their systems taken to jail. It goes against everything we stand for in healthcare and it has to stop. Substantial evidence reveals that Prime Healthcare (Prime) services are transferring patients, admitted to the Emergency Room (ER) for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. Despite being one of the largest hospital chains in the state, Prime has an unusually high number of cases where the police are called on patients in the ER. Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be arrested and transferred to a jail before the patient has been treated and stabilized. Acute alcohol poisoning is a medical emergency.
Background on problem. According to information provided by the author and the Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), a co-sponsor of this bill, for the first three months of 2014, 124 emergency calls came from Shasta Regional Medical Center, a Prime Healthcare hospital in Redding, California, which averages to about 41 such calls per month. In comparison, a hospital operated by Dignity Health about two miles away from Shasta Regional Medical Center only made 53 emergency calls in the first nine months of 2014, or about 6 per month.
SEIU-UHW also cited some Shasta emergency call summaries that described requests for patients to be picked up with very high BAC levels. According to SEIU-UHW, the following call summaries are examples where the patient was booked after the emergency call was made and the officer responded (each of these incidents were from February and March of 2010):
“Subject has BAC of .48 and needs to be picked up.”
“Intoxicated subject cleared for release. Still has BAC of .44”
“Patient medically cleared with .40 BAC”
EMTALA. Sometimes referred to as the “Patient Anti-Dumping Law,” EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or “dumping” these patients by transferring them to county hospitals or other charity hospitals. According to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in 1986, Congress enacted EMTALA to ensure public access to emergency services regardless of ability to pay. Section 1867 of the Social Security Act imposes specific obligations on Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services to provide a medical screening examination when a request is made for examination or treatment for an emergency medical condition, including active labor, regardless of an individual's ability to pay. Hospitals are then required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients with an emergency medical condition. If a hospital is unable to stabilize a patient within its capability, or if the patient requests, an appropriate transfer should be implemented. As an enforcement mechanism, EMTALA also established a private right of action.
Effects of BAC. A chart from Stanford University’s Office of Alcohol Policy and Education, which describes the physical and mental effects of various blood alcohol concentration levels, is typical of many such charts. At a BAC of .07 to .09, this chart states that the effect is mild impairment of balance, speech, vision and control, and that in California, you will test as legally impaired to drive. At a BAC of .16 to .20, dysphoria predominates, nausea may appear, and the drinker has the appearance of a “sloppy drunk.” At .25 to .30, the person is severely intoxicated, needs assistance walking, has mental confusion, and there is vomiting. At .35 to .40, loss of consciousness and brink of coma, and at .40 and up, onset of coma with likelihood of death due to respiratory failure. Another chart, describing wider ranges, broke BAC levels into categories such as .18 to .30 being the “confusion” stage, with various symptoms; .25 to .40 the “stupor” stage; .35 to .50 the “coma” stage (which includes possible death as a symptom); and .45 and above “death from respiratory arrest.”
In a study published in EMS World in March of 2014 entitled “Acute Alcohol Poisoning,” the authors included a similar chart, which listed “coma in the non-habituated drinker” at a BAC of .25-.30. However, this study stated that “it should be noted there is a poor correlation between BAC and clinical exam findings in patients with alcohol habituation.” According to the study, “respiratory depression and subsequent death may occur in the non-habituated patient at concentrations of 0.4-0.5, but it is not uncommon for a chronic alcoholic to appear minimally intoxicated with a BAC as high as 0.4.” The study also noted that another factor that affects a patient’s clinical exam is whether the patient’s BAC is increasing or decreasing. According to this study, it is a known phenomenon, termed the Mellanby effect, that the clinical manifestations of alcohol intoxication are more prominent when BAC is rising.
Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior legislation. SB 275 (Cedillo), of 2007, would have prohibited a hospital from causing a patient to be transported to a location other than the patient’s residence or another health facility without the patient’s written consent, and established penalties and an enforcement process that is very similar to this bill, including civil penalties of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, who stated in his veto message that while he was strongly opposed to patient dumping, hospitals must already meet specific discharge planning requirements and make appropriate arrangements for post-hospital care. Enforcement of existing laws is critical, however, additional penalties are premature.
SB 1312 (Alquist), Chapter 895, Statutes of 2006, among other provisions, authorized DPH to assess administrative penalties on hospitals based on deficiencies constituting immediate jeopardy to the health and safety of a patient.
Support. This bill is co-sponsored by SEIU-UHW, and by the United Nurses Association of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP). According to SEIU-UHW, there is substantial evidence that Prime Healthcare Services is inappropriately and dangerously transferring patients admitted to the ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. SEIU-UHW states that this is immoral, poses a risk to patient safety, and is an abuse of the 911 system, which should of course be reserved purely for true emergencies. According to SEIU-UHW, in a number of cases, the reporting party at Shasta Regional Medical Center reported BAC levels associated with death and comas but still requested an arrest be made on the patient. SEIU-UHW states that discharging patients with BACs higher than 0.3 percent and transferring them to jail in a police car is dangerous, and that in the case of patients who require emergency services because of very high BAC levels, the hospital must stabilize the patient before attempting to make any transfer.
UNAC/UHCP states in support that regularly calling the police on intoxicated patients is a basic part of the Prime Healthcare business model and helps reduce their costs by forcing these patients into the care and custody of corrections officials, which in turn puts unnecessary burdens on an already strained criminal justice system. SEIU California states that discharging a patient with a BAC of .08 into the custody of the jail, corrections, or police should only occur if there is a compelling public safety reason, such as in cases where other patients and hospital staff are at risk. The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees states in support that it is common sense for a hospital to treat a patient and ensure that they are stabilized before transferring them, and that this bill works to protect patients from corporate interests that would otherwise prioritize saving a dollar to saving a life.
Opposition. This bill is opposed by the California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians (CalACEP), which states that this bill seeks to legislate the practice of medicine with a standard that has no basis in science. The benchmark of a .08 BAC has no basis in medicine, and that BAC and its medical significance differs depending on each patient’s physiology. According to CalACEP, there can be no “bright line” in statute that is medically meaningful for all patients, and that this bill is an arbitrary and inappropriate practice of medicine by the Legislature. CalACEP states that a uniform standard would likely lead to life-threatening outcomes for some patients, as disease process or events that accompany acute alcohol withdrawal can cause significant illness and death. CalACEP states that emergency departments routinely treat chronic inebriates for other medical conditions and the requirement in this bill to abruptly sober these patients would threaten their health. According to CalACEP, police officers routinely bring inebriated patients to the emergency department, such as drivers involved in an alcohol-related traffic accident, to be treated and medically cleared before they are taken to jail. This bill would turn the emergency department into a sobering center for these patients, which is an inappropriate use of scarce emergency department resources and would jeopardize the safety of other patients waiting for life-saving care. The California Medical Association also opposes this bill, stating that a patient’s BAC may not be relevant to their diagnosis or treatment, yet this bill would require BAC tests on these patients despite the fact it is not necessary, which is both unethical and an inappropriate invasion of the patient’s privacy. The California Nurses Association (CNA) states in opposition that this bill is a solution in search of a problem, and that the discharge or transfer of an unstable patient is already illegal in California. According to CNA, this bill, if passed, might lead to the unintended consequence of creating more risk of harm to healthcare workers by causing hospitals to hesitate to call law enforcement for assistance despite the presence of a violent individual who is under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The California Hospital Association (CHA) states in opposition that this bill will impede the clinical judgment of physicians, nurses and other clinical staff in California’s emergency departments. According to CHA, a physician must determine medical stability, and that this bill would compromise the important physician/patient relationship which is the foundation for all medical care and may not be in the best interest of every patient.
Policy comments.
Are the penalties in this bill too high? The enforcement and penalty provisions of this bill are based on the enforcement provisions contained in SB 275 (Cedillo), which was passed by the Legislature in 2007, but vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger. SB 275 was intended to address health facilities that were engaged in a practice known as “homeless dumping,” where patients who were indigent were discharged and transported away from the hospital and in some cases left on a sidewalk in a foreign neighborhood. The penalties in this bill are the same as those proposed in SB 275: $150,000 for the second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations. Also, just as in SB 275, this bill authorizes the Attorney General, local district attorneys, and some city attorneys to bring civil enforcement actions.
The underlying contention with this bill is that certain hospitals are violating EMTALA by not ensuring that patients who present with an emergency medical condition (elevated BAC levels) are stabilized before being transferred to a non-healthcare setting. However, current law provides that hospitals that violate EMTALA are subject to a $25,000 fine. Violations of any other hospital requirement that is likely to cause serious injury or death to a patient (immediate jeopardy violations) are subject to a maximum penalty of $125,000, which is reserved for repeat violators. This bill establishes penalties that are six times the current penalty for an EMTALA violation, and have a maximum level that is more than twice as much as the next highest penalty for a hospital violation that could cause serious injury or death to the patient.
Proposed amendments to remove the BAC level. In response to concerns from CalACEP and CMA regarding the appropriateness of setting a specific BAC threshold and interfering with physician judgment, the author will offer the following amendment in committee:
On Page 2, beginning on line 3:A general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital shall not cause a patient
with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greaterwho, in the judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care professional acting within his or her scope of practice, is at risk of serious injury or death as a result of clinical alcohol intoxication, to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized, as defined in Section 1317.1(j), or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (co-sponsor)
SEIU-UHW (co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California State Council of the Service Employees International Union
Oppose: California Chapter American College of Emergency Physicians
California Hospital Association
California Medical Association
California Nurses Association
-- END --
SB 145 (Pan) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 145
AUTHOR: |
Pan |
||
VERSION: |
January 27, 2015 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
April 15, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Vince Marchand |
||
SUBJECT: Health facilities: patient transporting
SUMMARY:
Prohibits hospitals from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greater to be transported to another location, except when the patient is medically stabilized or transferred to another licensed health facility, and provides for enforcement of repeat violators by the Attorney General or by local district attorneys, including civil penalties of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations.
Existing law:
Requires, under both the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) and also under state law, that anyone who comes into a hospital emergency room to be provided with a medical screening examination, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay, to determine if the patient is suffering from an emergency medical condition, and if so, requires the patient to be treated until the patient is medically stabilized.
Defines “emergency medical condition” as a condition manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity that the absence of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in placing the patient’s health in serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions, or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or part.
Defines “stabilization” as when, in the opinion of the treating physician, the patient’s medical condition is such that, within reasonable medical probability, no material deterioration of the patient’s condition is likely to result from, or occur during, the release or transfer of the patient.
Provides for a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for hospitals found by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to have violated the state law version of EMTALA, and penalties of up to $5,000 for physicians whom the Medical Board of California found violated these provisions of law. Additionally, permits a person who suffers personal harm as a result of a violation of these provisions of law to recover damages and other appropriate relief in a civil action (known as a private right of action).
Establishes a structure under which DPH is permitted to assess administrative fines to general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and special hospitals for violation of any of their licensing laws and regulations. Requires DPH to promulgate regulations establishing the criteria to assess these administrative penalties, and requires these criteria to include, but not be limited to, the following:
The patient’s physical and mental condition;
The probability and severity of the risk that the violation presents to the patient;
The actual financial harm to patients, if any;
The nature, scope, and severity of the violation;
The facility’s history of compliance with related state and federal statutes and regulations;
Factors beyond the facility’s control that restrict the facility’s ability to comply with state law;
The demonstrated willfulness of the violation; and
The extent to which the facility detected the violation and took steps to immediately correct the violation and prevent the violation from recurring.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty against a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, and special hospital, for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Defines “immediate jeopardy” as a situation in which the licensee’s noncompliance with one or more requirements of licensure has caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury or death to the patient.
Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy.
This bill:
Prohibits a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital from causing a patient with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of 0.08 percent or greater to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, policy custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medical stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
Requires DPH, if it determines that a hospital has violated the provisions of this bill, to consider, at a minimum, all of the following actions:
Assessment of an administrative penalty, as provided for in specified provisions of existing law; and,
Referral to the appropriate authorities for consideration of commencing an action to enforce misdemeanor criminal penalties for a violation of any of the provisions of law governing hospitals, as specified.
Requires a hospital to be subject to a civil penalty of $150,000 upon a second violation of this bill, and permits the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, or a city attorney of a city and county, to bring a civil action seeking civil penalties, preventive relief, including an application for a permanent or temporary injunction, restraining order, or other order against the health facility.
Specifies that a hospital that has been criminally convicted of a violation of this bill, which has been previously penalized for two separate violations of this bill, may be subject to civil penalties of no less than $300,000.
Requires the court, in determining the civil penalty to be imposed upon a second or subsequent violation, to consider all relevant facts, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
Whether the violation exposed the patient to a risk of death or serious physical harm;
Whether the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of the patient;
Evidence, if any, of willfulness;
The number of repeated violations; and,
The presence or absence of good faith efforts by the defendant to prevent the violation.
Requires any investigative costs incurred in the enforcement of the civil penalty remedies, including, but not limited to, expert’s and attorney’s fees incurred by the Attorney General, district attorney, or city attorney in carrying out this subdivision, to be recoverable from the liable hospital.
Requires the civil penalty collected to be paid into the General Fund for any action brought by the Attorney General, to the county treasurer where the judgment was entered for any action brought by a district attorney, and to the city treasurer for any action brought by a city attorney. Requires all civil penalties collected to be used exclusively for the provision of post-hospital recuperative beds, transitional housing, and mental health counseling programs for the homeless.
Specifies that this bill does not apply to any of the following:
Patients in state hospitals operated and administered by the Department of State Hospitals who are civilly or criminally committed and subject to transfer to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, the Forensic Conditional Release Program, or to a court for further proceedings;
Patients who remain under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabiliation; and,
Residents of state developmental centers operated and administered by the Department of Developmental Services who are discharged to the community pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disability Services Act, and in accordance with an individual program plan, as defined, developed specifically for the resident.
Specifies that nothing in this bill precludes criminal prosecution or civil action under any other law, nor does anything in the bill limit or abridge the authority of any city or county to adopt an ordinance authorizing investigations or inspections, or implementing and enforcing restrictions dealing with patient transportation.
Prohibits anything in this bill from being construed to contradict any other law related to workplace violence prevention, including, but not limited to, workplace violence standards adopted by the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. According to the author, SB 145 stops a practice that poses a risk to patient safety, prevents the cost and liabilities of treating hospital's emergency patients from being wrongly shifted to the police and correction facilities and preserves 911 calls for true emergencies. Some of the hospitals in California routinely call 911 and have patients with potentially lethal levels of alcohol in their systems taken to jail. It goes against everything we stand for in healthcare and it has to stop. Substantial evidence reveals that Prime Healthcare (Prime) services are transferring patients, admitted to the Emergency Room (ER) for acute alcohol poisoning, to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. Despite being one of the largest hospital chains in the state, Prime has an unusually high number of cases where the police are called on patients in the ER. Prime calls the police on patients with acute alcohol poisoning and requests the patients be arrested and transferred to a jail before the patient has been treated and stabilized. Acute alcohol poisoning is a medical emergency.
Background on problem. According to information provided by the author and the Service Employees International Union – United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), a co-sponsor of this bill, for the first three months of 2014, 124 emergency calls came from Shasta Regional Medical Center, a Prime Healthcare hospital in Redding, California, which averages to about 41 such calls per month. In comparison, a hospital operated by Dignity Health about two miles away from Shasta Regional Medical Center only made 53 emergency calls in the first nine months of 2014, or about 6 per month.
SEIU-UHW also cited some Shasta emergency call summaries that described requests for patients to be picked up with very high BAC levels. According to SEIU-UHW, the following call summaries are examples where the patient was booked after the emergency call was made and the officer responded (each of these incidents were from February and March of 2010):
“Subject has BAC of .48 and needs to be picked up.”
“Intoxicated subject cleared for release. Still has BAC of .44”
“Patient medically cleared with .40 BAC”
EMTALA. Sometimes referred to as the “Patient Anti-Dumping Law,” EMTALA was passed to address the problem of hospitals refusing to treat indigent, uninsured, or Medicaid patients, or “dumping” these patients by transferring them to county hospitals or other charity hospitals. According to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in 1986, Congress enacted EMTALA to ensure public access to emergency services regardless of ability to pay. Section 1867 of the Social Security Act imposes specific obligations on Medicare-participating hospitals that offer emergency services to provide a medical screening examination when a request is made for examination or treatment for an emergency medical condition, including active labor, regardless of an individual's ability to pay. Hospitals are then required to provide stabilizing treatment for patients with an emergency medical condition. If a hospital is unable to stabilize a patient within its capability, or if the patient requests, an appropriate transfer should be implemented. As an enforcement mechanism, EMTALA also established a private right of action.
Effects of BAC. A chart from Stanford University’s Office of Alcohol Policy and Education, which describes the physical and mental effects of various blood alcohol concentration levels, is typical of many such charts. At a BAC of .07 to .09, this chart states that the effect is mild impairment of balance, speech, vision and control, and that in California, you will test as legally impaired to drive. At a BAC of .16 to .20, dysphoria predominates, nausea may appear, and the drinker has the appearance of a “sloppy drunk.” At .25 to .30, the person is severely intoxicated, needs assistance walking, has mental confusion, and there is vomiting. At .35 to .40, loss of consciousness and brink of coma, and at .40 and up, onset of coma with likelihood of death due to respiratory failure. Another chart, describing wider ranges, broke BAC levels into categories such as .18 to .30 being the “confusion” stage, with various symptoms; .25 to .40 the “stupor” stage; .35 to .50 the “coma” stage (which includes possible death as a symptom); and .45 and above “death from respiratory arrest.”
In a study published in EMS World in March of 2014 entitled “Acute Alcohol Poisoning,” the authors included a similar chart, which listed “coma in the non-habituated drinker” at a BAC of .25-.30. However, this study stated that “it should be noted there is a poor correlation between BAC and clinical exam findings in patients with alcohol habituation.” According to the study, “respiratory depression and subsequent death may occur in the non-habituated patient at concentrations of 0.4-0.5, but it is not uncommon for a chronic alcoholic to appear minimally intoxicated with a BAC as high as 0.4.” The study also noted that another factor that affects a patient’s clinical exam is whether the patient’s BAC is increasing or decreasing. According to this study, it is a known phenomenon, termed the Mellanby effect, that the clinical manifestations of alcohol intoxication are more prominent when BAC is rising.
Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior legislation. SB 275 (Cedillo), of 2007, would have prohibited a hospital from causing a patient to be transported to a location other than the patient’s residence or another health facility without the patient’s written consent, and established penalties and an enforcement process that is very similar to this bill, including civil penalties of $150,000 for a second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, who stated in his veto message that while he was strongly opposed to patient dumping, hospitals must already meet specific discharge planning requirements and make appropriate arrangements for post-hospital care. Enforcement of existing laws is critical, however, additional penalties are premature.
SB 1312 (Alquist), Chapter 895, Statutes of 2006, among other provisions, authorized DPH to assess administrative penalties on hospitals based on deficiencies constituting immediate jeopardy to the health and safety of a patient.
Support. This bill is co-sponsored by SEIU-UHW, and by the United Nurses Association of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (UNAC/UHCP). According to SEIU-UHW, there is substantial evidence that Prime Healthcare Services is inappropriately and dangerously transferring patients admitted to the ER for acute alcohol poisoning to police departments, corrections facilities, and county jails by calling 911. SEIU-UHW states that this is immoral, poses a risk to patient safety, and is an abuse of the 911 system, which should of course be reserved purely for true emergencies. According to SEIU-UHW, in a number of cases, the reporting party at Shasta Regional Medical Center reported BAC levels associated with death and comas but still requested an arrest be made on the patient. SEIU-UHW states that discharging patients with BACs higher than 0.3 percent and transferring them to jail in a police car is dangerous, and that in the case of patients who require emergency services because of very high BAC levels, the hospital must stabilize the patient before attempting to make any transfer.
UNAC/UHCP states in support that regularly calling the police on intoxicated patients is a basic part of the Prime Healthcare business model and helps reduce their costs by forcing these patients into the care and custody of corrections officials, which in turn puts unnecessary burdens on an already strained criminal justice system. SEIU California states that discharging a patient with a BAC of .08 into the custody of the jail, corrections, or police should only occur if there is a compelling public safety reason, such as in cases where other patients and hospital staff are at risk. The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees states in support that it is common sense for a hospital to treat a patient and ensure that they are stabilized before transferring them, and that this bill works to protect patients from corporate interests that would otherwise prioritize saving a dollar to saving a life.
Opposition. This bill is opposed by the California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians (CalACEP), which states that this bill seeks to legislate the practice of medicine with a standard that has no basis in science. The benchmark of a .08 BAC has no basis in medicine, and that BAC and its medical significance differs depending on each patient’s physiology. According to CalACEP, there can be no “bright line” in statute that is medically meaningful for all patients, and that this bill is an arbitrary and inappropriate practice of medicine by the Legislature. CalACEP states that a uniform standard would likely lead to life-threatening outcomes for some patients, as disease process or events that accompany acute alcohol withdrawal can cause significant illness and death. CalACEP states that emergency departments routinely treat chronic inebriates for other medical conditions and the requirement in this bill to abruptly sober these patients would threaten their health. According to CalACEP, police officers routinely bring inebriated patients to the emergency department, such as drivers involved in an alcohol-related traffic accident, to be treated and medically cleared before they are taken to jail. This bill would turn the emergency department into a sobering center for these patients, which is an inappropriate use of scarce emergency department resources and would jeopardize the safety of other patients waiting for life-saving care. The California Medical Association also opposes this bill, stating that a patient’s BAC may not be relevant to their diagnosis or treatment, yet this bill would require BAC tests on these patients despite the fact it is not necessary, which is both unethical and an inappropriate invasion of the patient’s privacy. The California Nurses Association (CNA) states in opposition that this bill is a solution in search of a problem, and that the discharge or transfer of an unstable patient is already illegal in California. According to CNA, this bill, if passed, might lead to the unintended consequence of creating more risk of harm to healthcare workers by causing hospitals to hesitate to call law enforcement for assistance despite the presence of a violent individual who is under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The California Hospital Association (CHA) states in opposition that this bill will impede the clinical judgment of physicians, nurses and other clinical staff in California’s emergency departments. According to CHA, a physician must determine medical stability, and that this bill would compromise the important physician/patient relationship which is the foundation for all medical care and may not be in the best interest of every patient.
Policy comments.
Are the penalties in this bill too high? The enforcement and penalty provisions of this bill are based on the enforcement provisions contained in SB 275 (Cedillo), which was passed by the Legislature in 2007, but vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger. SB 275 was intended to address health facilities that were engaged in a practice known as “homeless dumping,” where patients who were indigent were discharged and transported away from the hospital and in some cases left on a sidewalk in a foreign neighborhood. The penalties in this bill are the same as those proposed in SB 275: $150,000 for the second violation, and $300,000 for subsequent violations. Also, just as in SB 275, this bill authorizes the Attorney General, local district attorneys, and some city attorneys to bring civil enforcement actions.
The underlying contention with this bill is that certain hospitals are violating EMTALA by not ensuring that patients who present with an emergency medical condition (elevated BAC levels) are stabilized before being transferred to a non-healthcare setting. However, current law provides that hospitals that violate EMTALA are subject to a $25,000 fine. Violations of any other hospital requirement that is likely to cause serious injury or death to a patient (immediate jeopardy violations) are subject to a maximum penalty of $125,000, which is reserved for repeat violators. This bill establishes penalties that are six times the current penalty for an EMTALA violation, and have a maximum level that is more than twice as much as the next highest penalty for a hospital violation that could cause serious injury or death to the patient.
Proposed amendments to address the BAC level. In response to concerns that setting the threshold for whether a patient is medically stable to be transferred at a BAC of .08 is too low and would turn emergency departments into sobering centers, committee staff worked with the author to establish a higher “bright line,” while applying physician judgment to BACs below this line. The author has agreed to the following amendment:
On Page 2, beginning on line 3:
(a) A
general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special
hospital shall not cause a patient
with a blood alcohol content of 0.08 percent or greater to
be transported to another location, including, but not limited to,
police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, when
that patient’s blood alcohol content is at a level which, in the
judgment of the attending physician or other licensed health care
professional acting within his or her scope of practice, places the
patient at risk of serious injury or death, except
when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred
to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
(b) Notwithstanding subdivision (a), in no event shall a general acute care hospital, acute psychiatric hospital, or special hospital cause a patient with a blood alcohol content of 0.30 or greater to be transported to another location, including, but not limited to, police custody, a correctional facility, or a county jail, except when the patient is medically stabilized or appropriately transferred to another licensed health facility pursuant to another law.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (co-sponsor)
SEIU-UHW (co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California State Council of the Service Employees International Union
Oppose: California Chapter American College of Emergency Physicians
California Hospital Association
California Medical Association
California Nurses Association
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Senate Floor
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):