SB 26: California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-05-05
Existing law establishes health care coverage programs to provide health care to segments of the population meeting specified criteria who are otherwise unable to afford health care coverage and provides for the licensure and regulation of health insurers and health care service plans.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to establish a system to provide valid, timely, and comprehensive health care performance information that is publicly available and can be used to improve the safety, appropriateness, and medical effectiveness of health care, and to provide care that is safe, medically effective, patient-centered, timely, affordable, and equitable. The bill would require the Secretary of California Health and Human Services to, no later than January 1, 2017, enter into a contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would require the secretary to include specified terms in that contract or contracts, including, among others, that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database develop methodologies relating to the submission of health care data by health care entities. The bill would require certain health care entities, including health care service plans, to provide specified information to the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would authorize the nonprofit organization or organizations to report a health care entity that fails to comply with that requirement to the health care entitys regulating agency, and would authorize the regulating agency to enforce that requirement using its existing enforcement procedures.
The bill would require all data disclosures made pursuant to these provisions to comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data and would prohibit the public disclosure of any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information. The bill would require that certain confidentially negotiated contract terms be protected in data disclosures made pursuant to these provisions and would prohibit certain individually identifiable proprietary contract information from being disclosed in an unaggregated format. The bill would require the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from specified data sources, including, among others, disease and chronic condition registries. The bill would require, no later than January 1, 2019, the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to publicly make available a web-based, searchable database and would require that database to be updated regularly. The bill would prohibit implementation and ongoing administration costs of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database from being paid using General Fund moneys.
This bill would also require the secretary to convene a review committee composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts, as specified, to, among other things, develop the parameters for establishing, implementing, and administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would require the secretary to arrange for the preparation of an annual report to the Legislature and the Governor that examines and addresses specified issues, including, among others, containing the cost of health care services and coverage. The bill would provide that the commission not be convened until the Director of Finance has determined that sufficient private or federal funds have been received and appropriated for that purpose, and that members of the committee not receive a per diem or travel expense reimbursement, or any other expense reimbursement.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law establishes health care coverage programs to provide health care to segments of the population meeting specified criteria who are otherwise unable to afford health care coverage and provides for the licensure and regulation of health insurers and health care service plans.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to establish a system to provide valid, timely, and comprehensive health care performance information that is publicly available and can be used to improve the safety, appropriateness, and medical effectiveness of health care, and to provide care that is safe, medically effective, patient-centered, timely, affordable, and equitable. The bill would require the Secretary of California Health and Human Services to, no later than January 1, 2017, enter into a contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would require the secretary to include specified terms in that contract or contracts, including, among others, that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database develop methodologies relating to the submission of health care data by health care entities. The bill would require certain health care entities, including health care service plans, to provide specified information to the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would authorize the nonprofit organization or organizations to report a health care entity that fails to comply with that requirement to the health care entitys regulating agency, and would authorize the regulating agency to enforce that requirement using its existing enforcement procedures.
The bill would require all data disclosures made pursuant to these provisions to comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data and would prohibit the public disclosure of any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information. The bill would require that certain confidentially negotiated contract terms be protected in data disclosures made pursuant to these provisions and would prohibit certain individually identifiable proprietary contract information from being disclosed in an unaggregated format. The bill would require the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from specified data sources, including, among others, disease and chronic condition registries. The bill would require, no later than January 1, 2019, the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to publicly make available a web-based, searchable database and would require that database to be updated regularly. The bill would prohibit implementation and ongoing administration costs of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database from being paid using General Fund moneys.
This bill would also require the secretary to convene a review committee composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts, as specified, to, among other things, develop the parameters for establishing, implementing, and administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would require the secretary to arrange for the preparation of an annual report to the Legislature and the Governor that examines and addresses specified issues, including, among others, containing the cost of health care services and coverage. The bill would provide that the commission not be convened until the Director of Finance has determined that sufficient private or federal funds have been received and appropriated for that purpose, and that members of the committee not receive a per diem or travel expense reimbursement, or any other expense reimbursement.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature to establish a system to provide valid, timely, and comprehensive health care performance information that is publicly available and can be used to improve the safety, appropriateness, and medical effectiveness of health care, and to provide care that is patient-centered, timely, affordable, and equitable. It is also the intent of the Legislature to grant access to provider performance information to consumers and purchasers in order for them to understand the potential financial consequences and liabilities and obtain maximum quality and value and to minimize health disparities in health care services.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature, by making cost and quality data available, to encourage health care service plans, health insurers, and providers to develop innovative approaches, services, and programs that may have the potential to deliver health care that is both cost effective and responsive to the needs of enrollees. enrollees, including recognizing the diversity of California and the impact of social determinants of health.
127671.(a)The Secretary of California Health and Human Services shall, no later than January 1, 2017, use a competitive process to contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations in order to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. This competitive process and any requests for proposal shall be publicly posted on the agencys Internet Web site for a minimum of 30 days for public review and comment. A contract entered into pursuant to this section is exempt from Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, and is exempt from review or approval by any division of the Department of General Services.
(b)The secretary shall include as a term in the contract or contracts entered into pursuant to subdivision (a) all of the following:
(1)A requirement that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database do all of the following:
(A)Establish, implement, and administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database in accordance with parameters developed pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 127672.
(B)Develop methodologies for the collection, validation, refinement, analysis, comparison, review, reporting, and improvement of health care data, including, but not limited to, data from fee-for-service, capitated, and other alternative, value-based, payment sources, submitted by health care entities that are validated, recognized as reliable, and meet industry and research standards.
(C)Receive information, as described in this section, from health care entities and report that information in a form that allows valid comparisons across care delivery systems.
(D)Ensure that the database has the capacity to map to other data sets, including public health data sets on morbidity and mortality, including data sets from the federal Centers for Disease Control, the State Department of Public Health, and other data sets with data regarding the social determinants of health.
(D)
(E)Comply with the requirements governing provider and supplier requests for error correction established pursuant to Section 401.717 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations for all claims data received, including, but not limited to, data from sources other than Medicare.
(2)A prohibition on the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database from doing either of the following:
(A)Using the data received during the execution of the contract for any purpose not specified in this chapter or in the contract.
(B)Receiving funding from any other source to accomplish the same purposes sought to be accomplished under this chapter unless funding is received from another nonprofit or government source and is for the purpose of research or education.
(3)A requirement that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database identify, in accordance with this section, the type of data, purpose of use, and entities and individuals that are required to report to, or that may have access to, the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. An entity or individual shall not be required to report to, and shall not have access to, the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database until the review committee established pursuant to Section 127672 has approved the nonprofit organization or organizations determination.
(c)(1)For the purpose of developing information for inclusion in the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, a health care service plan, including a specialized health care service plan, an insurer licensed to provide health insurance, as defined in Section 106 of the Insurance Code, a self-insured employer, a supplier, as defined in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 1367.50, or a provider, as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 1367.50, shall, and a multiemployer self-insured plan that is responsible for paying for health care services provided to beneficiaries and the trust administrator for a multiemployer self-insured plan may, provide both all of the following to the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database:
(A)Utilization data from the health care service plans and insurers medical, dental, and pharmacy claims or, in the case of entities that do not use claims data, including, but not limited to, integrated delivery systems, encounter data consistent with the core set of data elements for data submission proposed by the APCD Council, the University of New Hampshire, and the National Association of Health Data Organizations.
(B)Pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care gathered from allowed charges for covered health care items and services or, in the case of entities that do not use or produce individual claims, price information that is the best possible proxy to pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care available in lieu of actual cost data so to allow for meaningful comparisons of provider prices and treatment costs.
(C)Information sufficient to determine the impacts of social determinants of health, including age, gender, race, ethnicity, limited English proficiency, sexual orientation and gender identity, ZIP Code, and any other factors for which there is peer-reviewed evidence.
(2)(A)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database may report an entitys failure to comply with paragraph (1) to the entitys regulating agency.
(B)The regulating agency of an entity described in paragraph (1) may enforce paragraph (1) using its existing enforcement procedures. Notwithstanding any other law, moneys collected pursuant to this authorization shall be subject to appropriation by the Legislature, and the failure to comply with paragraph (1) shall not be a crime.
(d)(1)All uses and disclosures of data made pursuant to this section shall comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data, including, but not limited to, the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56)) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), the Information Practices Act (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 1798) of Title 1.8 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, Title 1.81 (commencing with Section 1798.80) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191) and the federal Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act, Title XIII of the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111-5), and implementing regulations.
(2)(A)All policies and protocols developed in the performance of the contract shall ensure that the privacy, security, and confidentiality of individually identifiable health information is protected. The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall not publicly disclose any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information and shall develop a protocol for assessing the risk of reidentification stemming from public disclosure of any health information that is aggregated, individually identifiable health information.
(B)For the purposes of this paragraph, individually identifiable health information has the same meaning as in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(3)Confidentially negotiated contract terms contained in a contract between a health care service plan or insurer and a provider or supplier shall be protected in any public disclosure of data made pursuant to this section. Individually identifiable proprietary contract information included in a contract between a health care service plan or insurer and a provider or supplier shall not be disclosed in an unaggregated format.
(e)(1)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from data sources, including, but not limited to, data received pursuant to subdivision (c), claims from private and public payers, disease and chronic condition registries, third-party surveys of quality and patient satisfaction, reviews by licensing and accrediting bodies, and local and regional public health data. Aggregated payer and provider performance on validated measures of clinical quality and patient experience, such as measures from the Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) and Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS), shall be collected from accrediting organizations, including, but not limited to, the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA), URAC, and the Joint Commission.
(2)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall include in an analysis performed pursuant to paragraph (1), but shall not be limited to, to including, all of the following:
(A)Population-level data on prevention, screening, and wellness utilization.
(B)Population-level data on behavioral and medical risk factors, interventions, and outcomes.
(C)Population-level data on chronic conditions, management, and outcomes.
(D)Population-level data on trends in utilization of procedures for treatment of similar conditions to evaluate medical appropriateness.
(E)Facility and physician organization risk adjusted performance information measures on the quality, efficiency, and outcomes of care that are aligned with national efforts, including, but not limited to, those of the National Quality Forum, related to defining cost and quality measures. Measures shall be publicly reported without risk adjustment for sociodemographic factors and shall also be risk adjusted for sociodemographic factors if peer-reviewed literature indicates an association between health outcomes and a sociodemographic factor or factors.
(F)Data that permits consideration of socioeconomic status and disparities in care due to race, ethnicity, gender, limited English proficiency, ZIP Code, sexual orientation, and gender identity. identity, and other factors for which there is peer-reviewed evidence of a relationship between a social determinant of health and health outcomes.
(f)No later than January 1, 2019, the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall make publicly available a web-based, searchable database. The database shall include the information and analysis described in subdivision (e). The information and analysis included in the database shall be presented in a way that facilitates comparisons of cost, quality, and satisfaction across payers, provider organizations, and other suppliers of health care services. This public database shall be regularly updated to reflect new data submissions.
(g)Implementation and ongoing administration costs of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall not be paid using General Fund moneys.
127672.(a)The Secretary of California Health and Human Services shall convene a review committee, composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts, including, but not limited to, representatives of the entities that are required to provide information pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 127671 and representatives of purchasers, including, but not limited to, businesses, organized labor, and consumers, to develop the parameters for the establishment, implementation, and ongoing administration of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, including a business plan for sustainability without using moneys from the General Fund, and to approve the determinations described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 127671. The review committee shall hold public meetings with stakeholders, solicit input, and set its own meeting agendas. Meetings of the review committee are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(b)The secretary shall arrange for the preparation of an annual report to the Legislature and the Governor, to be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, based on the findings of the review committee, including input from the public meetings, that shall, at a minimum, examine and address the following issues:
(1)Assessing California health care needs and available resources.
(2)Containing the cost of health care services and coverage.
(3)Improving the quality and medical appropriateness of health care.
(4)Reducing health disparities and addressing the social determinants of health.
(4)
(5)Increasing the transparency of health care costs and the relative efficiency with which care is delivered.
(5)
(6)Use of disease management, wellness, prevention, and other innovative programs to keep people healthy and reduce disparities and costs and improving health outcomes for all populations.
(6)
(7)Efficient utilization of prescription drugs and technology.
(7)
(8)Reducing unnecessary, inappropriate, and wasteful health care.
(8)
(9)Educating consumers in the use of health care information.
(9)
(10)Using existing data sources to build the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
(c)The review committee established pursuant to this section shall not be convened until the Director of Finance has determined that sufficient private or federal funds have been received and that the funds have been appropriated for that purpose. The review committee shall continue to function for as long as the Department of Finance has determined that the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database is established and is being administered.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, the members of the review committee shall receive no per diem or travel expense reimbursement, or any other expense reimbursement.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which adds Section 127671 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect confidential and proprietary information submitted to the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, it is necessary for that information to remain confidential.
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature to establish a system to provide valid, timely, and comprehensive health care performance information that is publicly available and can be used to improve the safety, appropriateness, and medical effectiveness of health care, and to provide care that is patient-centered, timely, affordable, and equitable. It is also the intent of the Legislature to grant access to provider performance information to consumers and purchasers in order for them to understand the potential financial consequences and liabilities and obtain maximum quality and value in health care services.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature, by making cost and quality data available, to encourage health care service plans, health insurers, and providers to develop innovative approaches, services, and programs that may have the potential to deliver health care that is both cost effective and responsive to the needs of enrollees.
127671.(a)The Secretary of California Health and Human Services shall, no later than January 1, 2017, use a competitive process to contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations in order to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. This competitive process and any requests for proposal shall be publicly posted on the agencys Internet Web site for a minimum of 30 days for public review and comment. A contract entered into pursuant to this section is exempt from Part 2 (commencing with Section 10100) of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, and is exempt from review or approval by any division of the Department of General Services.
(b)The secretary shall include as a term in the contract or contracts entered into pursuant to subdivision (a) all of the following:
(1)A requirement that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database do all of the following:
(A)Establish, implement, and administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database in accordance with parameters developed pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 127672.
(B)Develop methodologies for the collection, validation, refinement, analysis, comparison, review, reporting, and improvement of health care data, including, but not limited to, data from fee-for-service, capitated, and other alternative, value-based, payment sources, submitted by health care entities that are validated, recognized as reliable, and meet industry and research standards.
(C)Receive information, as described in this section, from health care entities and report that information in a form that allows valid comparisons across care delivery systems.
(D)Comply with the requirements governing provider and supplier requests for error correction established pursuant to Section 401.717 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations for all claims data received, including, but not limited to, data from sources other than Medicare.
(2)A prohibition on the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database from doing either of the following:
(A)Using the data received during the execution of the contract for any purpose not specified in this chapter or in the contract.
(B)Receiving funding from any other source to accomplish the same purposes sought to be accomplished under this chapter unless funding is received from another nonprofit or government source and is for the purpose of research or education.
(3)A requirement that the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database identify, in accordance with this section, the type of data, purpose of use, and entities and individuals that are required to report to, or that may have access to, the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. An entity or individual shall not be required to report to, and shall not have access to, the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database until the review committee established pursuant to Section 127672 has approved the nonprofit organization or organizations determination.
(c)(1)For the purpose of developing information for inclusion in the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, a health care service plan, including a specialized health care service plan, an insurer licensed to provide health insurance, as defined in Section 106 of the Insurance Code, a self-insured employer, a supplier, as defined in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 1367.50, or a provider, as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 1367.50, shall, and a multiemployer self-insured plan that is responsible for paying for health care services provided to beneficiaries and the trust administrator for a multiemployer self-insured plan may, provide both of the following to the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database:
(A)Utilization data from the health care service plans and insurers medical, dental, and pharmacy claims or, in the case of entities that do not use claims data, including, but not limited to, integrated delivery systems, encounter data consistent with the core set of data elements for data submission proposed by the APCD Council, the University of New Hampshire, and the National Association of Health Data Organizations.
(B)Pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care gathered from allowed charges for covered health care items and services or, in the case of entities that do not use or produce individual claims, price information that is the best possible proxy to pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care available in lieu of actual cost data so to allow for meaningful comparisons of provider prices and treatment costs.
(2)(A)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database may report an entitys failure to comply with paragraph (1) to the entitys regulating agency.
(B)The regulating agency of an entity described in paragraph (1) may enforce paragraph (1) using its existing enforcement procedures. Notwithstanding any other law, moneys collected pursuant to this authorization shall be subject to appropriation by the Legislature, and the failure to comply with paragraph (1) shall not be a crime.
(d)(1)All uses and disclosures of data made pursuant to this section shall comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data, including, but not limited to, the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191) and the federal Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act, Title XIII of the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111-5), and implementing regulations.
(2)(A)All policies and protocols developed in the performance of the contract shall ensure that the privacy, security, and confidentiality of individually identifiable health information is protected. The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall not publicly disclose any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information and shall develop a protocol for assessing the risk of reidentification stemming from public disclosure of any health information that is aggregated, individually identifiable health information.
(B)For the purposes of this paragraph, individually identifiable health information has the same meaning as in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(3)Confidentially negotiated contract terms contained in a contract between a health care service plan or insurer and a provider or supplier shall be protected in any public disclosure of data made pursuant to this section. Individually identifiable proprietary contract information included in a contract between a health care service plan or insurer and a provider or supplier shall not be disclosed in an unaggregated format.
(e)(1)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from data sources, including, but not limited to, data received pursuant to subdivision (c), claims from private and public payers, disease and chronic condition registries, third-party surveys of quality and patient satisfaction, reviews by licensing and accrediting bodies, and local and regional public health data. Aggregated payer and provider performance on validated measures of clinical quality and patient experience, such as measures from the Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) and Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS), shall be collected from accrediting organizations, including, but not limited to, the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA), URAC, and the Joint Commission.
(2)The nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall include in an analysis performed pursuant to paragraph (1), but shall not be limited to, all of the following:
(A)Population-level data on prevention, screening, and wellness utilization.
(B)Population-level data on behavioral and medical risk factors, interventions, and outcomes.
(C)Population-level data on chronic conditions, management, and outcomes.
(D)Population-level data on trends in utilization of procedures for treatment of similar conditions to evaluate medical appropriateness.
(E)Facility and physician organization risk adjusted performance information on the quality, efficiency, and outcomes of care that are aligned with national efforts, including, but not limited to, those of the National Quality Forum, related to defining cost and quality measures.
(F)Data that permits consideration of socioeconomic status and disparities in care due to race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and gender identity.
(f)No later than January 1, 2019, the nonprofit organization or organizations administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall make publicly available a web-based, searchable database. The database shall include the information and analysis described in subdivision (e). The information and analysis included in the database shall be presented in a way that facilitates comparisons of cost, quality, and satisfaction across payers, provider organizations, and other suppliers of health care services. This public database shall be regularly updated to reflect new data submissions.
(g)Implementation and ongoing administration costs of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall not be paid using General Fund moneys.
127672.(a)The Secretary of California Health and Human Services shall convene a review committee, composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts, including, but not limited to, representatives of the entities that are required to provide information pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 127671 and representatives of purchasers, including, but not limited to, businesses, organized labor, and consumers, to develop the parameters for the establishment, implementation, and ongoing administration of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, including a business plan for sustainability without using moneys from the General Fund, and to approve the determinations described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 127671. The review committee shall hold public meetings with stakeholders, solicit input, and set its own meeting agendas. Meetings of the review committee are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(b)The secretary shall arrange for the preparation of an annual report to the Legislature and the Governor, to be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, based on the findings of the review committee, including input from the public meetings, that shall, at a minimum, examine and address the following issues:
(1)Assessing California health care needs and available resources.
(2)Containing the cost of health care services and coverage.
(3)Improving the quality and medical appropriateness of health care.
(4)Increasing the transparency of health care costs and the relative efficiency with which care is delivered.
(5)Use of disease management, wellness, prevention, and other innovative programs to keep people healthy and reduce disparities and costs and improving health outcomes for all populations.
(6)Efficient utilization of prescription drugs and technology.
(7)Reducing unnecessary, inappropriate, and wasteful health care.
(8)Educating consumers in the use of health care information.
(9)Using existing data sources to build the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
(c)The review committee established pursuant to this section shall not be convened until the Director of Finance has determined that sufficient private or federal funds have been received and that the funds have been appropriated for that purpose. The review committee shall continue to function for as long as the Department of Finance has determined that the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database is established and is being administered.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, the members of the review committee shall receive no per diem or travel expense reimbursement, or any other expense reimbursement.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which adds Section 127671 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect confidential and proprietary information submitted to the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, it is necessary for that information to remain confidential.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 21, 2016 | January 21 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Jan 16, 2016 | Set for hearing January 21. |
| May 28, 2015 | May 28 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 23, 2015 | Set for hearing May 28. |
| May 18, 2015 | May 18 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 8, 2015 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 5, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 4, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 817.) (April 28). |
| Apr 24, 2015 | Set for hearing April 28. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 757.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 19, 2015 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Jan 15, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Dec 2, 2014 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 1. |
| Dec 1, 2014 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 18, 2015 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 26 (Hernandez) Page 3 of 3
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 26 (Hernandez) - California Health Care Cost and Quality Database
|
|
Version: May 5, 2015 |
Policy Vote: HEALTH 7 - 0, JUD. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No |
Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 18, 2015 |
Consultant: Brendan McCarthy |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 26 would require the California Health and Human Services Agency to contract with a nonprofit entity to create a health care cost and quality database.
Fiscal Impact:
The state of Colorado has developed an all payer claims database similar in functionality to the one required in this bill. The following cost estimates are informed by the actual expenditures to develop and operate the Colorado All Payer Claims Database. Due to the size and complexity of the California healthcare marketplace, staff anticipates that the cost to develop and maintain an all payer claims database is likely to be two to five times the cost incurred in Colorado.
One-time costs between $3 million and $10 million for planning and initial policy development relating to the proposed all payer claims database (unknown fund source).
One-time costs between $15 million and $30 million to create the database, including the information technology infrastructure to accept data submissions from payers, review submitted claims data, and analyze claims data (unknown fund source).
Ongoing operations and maintenance costs between $5 million and $12 million per year for operations and maintenance of the database, data analysis, and other administrative costs (unknown fund source).
Unknown potential fee revenues. The Colorado All Payer Claims Database is supported, in part, by fees charged for access to data or specific reports prepared by the staff. SB 26 does not specifically address whether this would be allowed under the bill. The bill does generally require information in the database to be searchable by the public. It may be possible to meet this requirement for public accessibility, while also developing data sets and analyses for outsider purchasers as a revenue generating mechanism.
Background:
Several other states have established all payer databases to assist in the analysis of health care markets, to increase transparency and potentially reduce health care spending over the long run. In general, an all payer claims database is used to collect claims data from some or all payers (potentially including private insurers, private health plans, employers, and state and federal health care programs such as Medicare or Medicaid programs). By collecting claims data in a central database, states hope to improve transparency by analyzing the costs for health care services and potentially tying those costs to outcomes.
Currently there are two efforts to implement all payer claims databases in California. The California Healthcare Performance Information system is a database that will include data on physician services from three health plans and Medicare. Also, the University of California, San Francisco is developing a medical cost and quality database under contract from the Department of Insurance. That database will include information on prices for care for certain chronic conditions.
Proposed Law:
SB 26 would require the Health and Human Services Agency to contract with a nonprofit entity to create a health care cost and quality database.
Specific provisions of the bill would:
Require the California Health and Human Services agency, by January 1, 2017, to use a competitive process to contract with one or more nonprofit corporations to develop the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database;
Specify the requirements for the contracting nonprofit;
Require health plans, health insurers, self-insured employers, and licensed health care providers to provide information for inclusion in the database, including utilization and pricing data;
Authorize multiemployer self-insured plans and trust administrators for multiemployer self-insured plans to report similar data;
Authorize the nonprofit to report noncompliance with reporting requirements to the appropriate regulating entity;
Authorize the regulating entity to enforce compliance;
Specify the requirements for protection of confidential information by the nonprofit;
Specify the types of data to be collected and analyzed;
Require the nonprofit to create a publicly-accessible, searchable database of information on health care costs and quality information;
Prohibit the use of General Fund for the development or operations of the system;
Require the Agency to convene a review committee to develop plans for the development and administration of the system, including a business plan;
Require annual reporting to the Legislature by the Agency;
Prohibit the establishment of the review committee until the Director of Finance determines that sufficient private funds or federal funds have been received and have been appropriated for that purpose.
Related Legislation:
SB 1322 (Hernandez, 2014) was substantially similar to this bill. That bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s Suspense File.
AB 1558 (R. Hernandez, 2014) would have requested the University of California to develop a cost and quality database. That bill was held on this Committee’s Suspense File.
Staff Comments:
The California Health and Human Services Agency has developed a State Health Care Innovation Plan, which is a plan to improve the state’s health care system. Among the many elements of the plan is a plan for an all payer claims database, similar to what is required in this bill. However, upon applying for federal funding for the Innovation Plan, the state received only a $3 million grant for future planning efforts and no grant funds for implementation of the Innovation Plan. At this time, the federal government has not indicated that there will be additional funds for implementation available to the state.
-- END --
SB 26 (Hernandez)
Page 12 of 12
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 26 (Hernandez)
Version: December 1, 2014
Hearing Date: April 28, 2015
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
TH
SUBJECT
California Health Care Cost and Quality Database
DESCRIPTION
This bill would require the Secretary of California Health and Human Services to enter into a contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations to develop and administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. The bill would require certain health care entities, including health care service plans, to provide medical claims, cost, and quality information to the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database in order to create a publicly available web-based, searchable database. The bill would require all data disclosures to comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data and would prohibit the public disclosure of any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information. This bill would also require the Secretary to convene a review committee to, among other things, develop the parameters for implementing and administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
BACKGROUND
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), enacted in 1996, guarantees privacy protection for individuals with regards to specific health information (Pub.L. 104–191, 110 Stat. 1936). Generally, protected health information (PHI) is any information held by a covered entity that concerns health status, provision of health care, or payment for health care that can be connected to an individual. HIPAA privacy regulations require health care providers and organizations to develop and follow procedures that ensure the confidentiality and security of PHI when it is transferred, received, handled, or shared. HIPAA further requires reasonable efforts when using, disclosing, or requesting PHI, to limit disclosure of that information to the minimum amount necessary to accomplish the intended purpose.
The California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) also protects PHI and restricts the disclosure of medical information by health care providers, and health care service plans, as specified. Under existing law, a corporation organized for the purpose of maintaining medical information in order to make that information available to the patient, or a provider at the request of the patient for purposes of diagnosis or treatment, is deemed to be a provider of health care subject to the requirements of the CMIA. The CMIA empowers adult patients in California to keep PHI confidential and decide whether and when to share that information with others.
This bill would create a new publicly available statewide health care cost and quality database, and would authorize the entity administering the database to collect and analyze PHI and other medical claims, cost, and quality information, in order to provide consumers with comparative medical pricing and quality information.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the California Constitution, provides that all people have inalienable rights, including the right to pursue and obtain privacy. (Cal. Const, Art. I, Sec. 1.)
Existing federal law, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), specifies privacy protections for patients’ protected health information and generally provides that a covered entity, as defined (health plan, health care provider, and health care clearing house), may not use or disclose protected health information except as specified or as authorized by the patient in writing. (45 C.F.R. Sec. 164.500 et seq.)
Existing law prohibits, under the State Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA), providers of health care, health care service plans, or contractors, as defined, from sharing medical information without a patient’s written authorization, subject to certain exceptions. (Civ. Code Sec. 56 et seq.)
Existing law defines “medical information” to mean any individually identifiable information, in electronic or physical form, in possession of or derived from a provider of health care, health care service plan, pharmaceutical company, or contractor regarding a patient’s medical history, mental or physical condition, or treatment. Existing law defines “individually identifiable” to mean that the medical information includes or contains any element of personal identifying information sufficient to allow identification of the individual, such as the patient’s name, address, electronic mail address, telephone number, or social security number, or other information that, alone or in combination with other publicly available information, reveals the individual’s identity. (Civ. Code Sec. 56.05(g).)
Existing law provides that any provider of health care, health care service plan, pharmaceutical company, or contractor who negligently creates, maintains, preserves, stores, abandons, destroys, or disposes of written or electronic medical records shall be subject to damages in a civil action or an administrative fine, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 56.101.)
Existing law provides that a plaintiff may bring an action against any person or entity that negligently releases his or her confidential information or records in violation of the CMIA. Existing law provides, in addition to any other available remedies, a plaintiff may receive as damages for a violation of the CMIA both nominal damages of $1,000 and the amount of actual damages. Existing law provides that any violation of the CMIA that results in economic loss or personal injury to a patient is punishable as a misdemeanor. (Civ. Code Sec. 56.36.)
This bill would, for the purpose of developing information for inclusion in a California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, require health care service plans and providers, as specified, to provide the following information to the organization administering the database:
Utilization data from the health care service plans’ and insurers’ medical, dental, and pharmacy claims or encounters, as specified; and
Pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care gathered from allowed charges for covered health care items and services or, in the case of entities that do not use or produce individual claims, price information that is the best possible proxy, so to allow for meaningful comparisons of provider prices and treatment costs.
This bill would direct the Secretary of California Health and Human Services (Secretary) to contract with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations in order to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
This bill would direct the Secretary to include as terms in the contract, requirements that the database administrator:
develop methodologies for the collection, validation, refinement, analysis, comparison, review, reporting, and improvement of health care data; and
receive information from health care entities and report that information in a form that allows valid comparisons across care delivery systems.
This bill would direct the organization administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from data sources, including, but not limited to, claims from private and public payers, disease and chronic condition registries, third-party surveys of quality and patient satisfaction, reviews by licensing and accrediting bodies, and local and regional public health data.
This bill would direct the organization administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to analyze, among other things:
population-level data on prevention, screening, and wellness utilization;
population-level data on behavioral and medical risk factors, interventions, and outcomes;
population-level data on chronic conditions, management, and outcomes;
population-level data on trends in utilization of procedures for treatment of similar conditions to evaluate medical appropriateness;
facility and physician organization risk adjusted performance information on the quality, efficiency, and outcomes of care that are aligned with national efforts, including, but not limited to, those of the National Quality Forum, related to defining cost and quality measures; and
data that permits consideration of socioeconomic status and disparities in care due to race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and gender identity.
This bill would direct the organization administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database to make its analyses publicly available via a web-based, searchable database. This bill would specify that the information and analysis included in the database shall be presented in a way that facilitates comparisons of cost, quality, and satisfaction across payers, provider organizations, and other suppliers of health care services, and that the database shall be regularly updated to reflect new data submissions.
This bill would direct the Secretary to include as terms in the contract, a prohibition on using the data received during the execution of the contract for any purpose not specified in this bill or in the contract.
This bill would specify that all uses and disclosures of data shall comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data, including, but not limited to, the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191) and the federal Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act, Title XIII of the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111-5), and implementing regulations.
This bill would specify that all policies and protocols developed in the performance of the contract shall ensure that the privacy, security, and confidentiality of individually identifiable health information is protected.
This bill would specify that the organization administering the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database shall not publicly disclose any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information and shall develop a protocol for assessing the risk of reidentification stemming from public disclosure of any health information that is aggregated, individually identifiable health information.
This bill would direct the Secretary of California Health and Human Services shall convene a review committee, composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts to develop the parameters for the establishment, implementation, and ongoing administration of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database.
COMMENT
Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Although the [Affordable Care Act] was the most fundamental legislative transformation of the US health care system in 40 years, and expanded coverage like no other program since the creation of Medicare, it did little in the way to control health care costs. Data show that the cost of health care has been rising at a slower pace in the last few years, but health care costs take up a growing portion of private and public funds, and consumers continue to feel the financial burden of health care costs. Changes in health care business practices and advances in technology and pharmaceuticals will continue to influence the price of health care in the future. According to a 2013 Action Brief by the Catalyst for Payment Reform, price information must be available to those who make decisions or those who guide consumers in making decisions. Several state and national transparency initiatives have highlighted variation in health care costs based on geographic differences. Factors that can contribute to variation can include: market power and competition, payment methodology, technology, patient mix, and cost-shifting. With the proper data, purchasers, policymakers, and stakeholders can learn more about price and payment differences.
This bill will help make available valid performance information to encourage health care providers and facilities to provide care that is safe, medically effective, patient-centered, timely, efficient, affordable and equitable. Additionally, it will put provider cost and performance information into the hands of consumers and purchasers so that they can understand their financial liability and realize the best quality and value available to them.
Improving Healthcare Cost Transparency
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation:
Health care accounts for a remarkably large slice of the U.S. economic pie. Each year health-related spending grows, virtually always outpacing spending on other goods and services, meaning that the size of that slice increases. These cost increases have a significant effect on households, businesses, and federal, state, and local governments. Among other things, rising health care costs make health insurance less affordable for individuals, families, and businesses; put pressure on businesses that offer insurance coverage to their employees; can be a major financial burden to families, even those that have insurance; and can result in individuals not receiving the health care services they need. For taxpayers, government programs such as Medicare and Medicaid are major parts of federal and state budgets, and increasing costs require either additional revenue or reductions in benefits, eligibility, or payment rates.
. . .
Health care investment and spending are influenced by federal and state programs with differing payment systems, incentives, and reimbursement levels; by numerous private health insurers, each with their own payment policies and practices; and by direct family payments for services that are covered or not covered by public or private insurance. (Kaiser Family Foundation, Health Care Costs: A Primer (May 2012) <https://kaiserfamilyfoundation.files.wordpress.com/2013/01/7670-03.pdf>[as of Apr. 25, 2015].)
This bill is intended to increase cost and quality transparency in California’s healthcare marketplace. According to United Ways of California, this bill would:
make available to the public valid, timely, and comprehensive health care performance information. Our coalition believes that every child and family should have access to high-quality, affordable, and safe health care. Currently, families shopping for health insurance and selecting health care providers have a difficult time assessing the quality and value of the options available to them due to insufficient information and a wide variety of options that can greatly impact out-of-pocket spending. SB 26 would help address this problem by requiring the construction of a web-based, searchable database containing comprehensive health care cost, quality, and satisfaction information that will be designed to help families navigate the complex choices that they face . . . New data will show utilization, risk factors, outcomes, and disparities. The database will help provide the basis for payers, providers, policymakers, advocates, and other stakeholders to seek further changes to improve the quality, efficiency, timeliness, and equity of California’s health care system.
Ensuring Confidentiality of Personal Information
California’s Confidentiality of Medical Information Act generally restricts the sharing or disclosure of a person’s medical information without first obtaining their written consent. The act states that “a provider of health care, health care service plan, or contractor shall not disclose medical information regarding a patient of the provider of health care or an enrollee or subscriber of a health care service plan without first obtaining an authorization,” unless a particular exception allows the disclosure. (Civ. Code Sec. 56.10.) Some exceptions that do not require prior authorization include when information disclosure is “otherwise specifically required by law” (Civ. Code Sec. 56.10(b)(9).), or when information is “disclosed to a third party for purposes of encoding, encrypting, or otherwise anonymizing data“(Civ. Code Sec. 56.10(c)(16).).
Without such an exception, any person or entity that wishes to obtain medical information must first obtain a valid authorization, which must be either handwritten by the person who signs it or in a typeface no smaller than 14-point type; be clearly separate from any other language present on the same page and executed by a signature which serves no other purpose than to execute the authorization; and be signed and dated by an authorized person. Additionally, in order to be valid, an authorization must also:
state the specific uses and limitations on the types of medical information to be disclosed;
state the name or functions of the provider of health care, health care service plan, pharmaceutical company, or contractor that may disclose the medical information;
state the name or functions of the persons or entities authorized to receive the medical information;
state the specific uses and limitations on the use of the medical information by the persons or entities authorized to receive the medical information;
state a specific date after which the provider of health care, health care service plan, pharmaceutical company, or contractor is no longer authorized to disclose the medical information; and
advise the person signing the authorization of the right to receive a copy of the authorization. (Civ. Code Sec. 56.11.)
Several stakeholders have raised concerns that, though they support the goals of the bill, the new database may undermine the confidentiality of sensitive medical information. The Consumer Federation of California (CFC), for example, states:
CFC agrees that greater analysis and transparency of the cost, quality and utilization of various health services will enable healthcare consumers, purchasers and policymakers to contain costs and make better treatment choices. However, the more information is shared, the more opportunities exist for sensitive personal medical information to fall into the wrong hands . . . SB 26 is vague regarding which state privacy and security laws will apply. SB 26 is silent regarding the application of CMIA to the entity that the bill would empower to gather and disseminate health care information. This lack of specificity creates a concern that a court or a regulator may find that CMIA, its definitions, its scope of coverage and its enforcement regime, do not apply to this new entity, it agents, employees and contractors. SB 26 should be amended to explicitly apply CMIA to the entity that administers the new California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, and to its employees, agents and contractors.
To remove any ambiguity concerning the application of CMIA to data collected, used, or disclosed by either the administrator of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database or any other person acting pursuant to this bill, the author offers the following amendment:
Author’s Amendment:
On page 6, line 12, following “to,” insert “the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Civil Code Section 56 et seq.),”
Staff notes that this bill contains three other provisions that help to ensure the confidentiality of medical information collected, used, or disclosed in furtherance of establishing and operating the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. First, this bill explicitly requires the Secretary of Health and Human Services to include in the contract with the administrator of the database a prohibition on using data received during the execution of the contract for any other purpose. Second, the bill requires that all policies and protocols developed in the performance of the contract must ensure that the privacy, security, and confidentiality of individually identifiable health information is protected. Third, the bill requires the organization administering the database to not publicly disclose any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information, and also to develop a protocol for assessing the risk of reidentification of individually identifiable health information stemming from public disclosure of any health information that is aggregated.
Data Security
Stakeholders have also raised concerns regarding the consequences of a data breach of the information collected or stored by the administrator of the database. For example, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) states:
[W]e believe that if the state wishes to compile a database containing such sensitive information, it should adopt the most rigorous standards of security protection to ensure as nearly as possible that this information is not compromised. In addition, we believe SB 26 should be amended to explicitly require appropriate notice and remedies for patients whose information will inevitably be subject to data breaches. The worthy goal of SB 26 is not inconsistent with the goal of protecting personal medical information.
Under California’s Data Breach Notification Law, the administrator of this database, like any other agency, person, or business that owns or licenses computerized data that includes personal information, would be required to disclose a breach of its security if unencrypted personal information was, or is reasonably believed to have been, acquired by an unauthorized person. The definition of “personal information” in the Data Breach Notification Law includes both “medical information” -- information regarding an individual’s medical history, mental or physical condition, or medical treatment or diagnosis by a health care professional -- and “health insurance information” -- an individual’s health insurance policy number or subscriber identification number, any unique identifier used by a health insurer to identify the individual, or any information in an individual’s application and claims history, including any appeals records. (Civ. Code Secs. 1798.29(h) and 1798.82(i).) If the database neither owns nor licenses the breached data but instead maintains it on behalf of another, it still would have an obligation to notify the owner or licensee of the information of any security breach immediately following discovery if personal information was, or is reasonably believed to have been, acquired by an unauthorized person. (Civ. Code Secs. 1798.29(b), 1798.82(b).) Additionally, the administrator of this database, like any other business that owns, licenses, or maintains personal information about California residents, would have a duty under the Civil Code to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices appropriate to the nature of the information, and to protect personal information from unauthorized access, destruction, use, modification, or disclosure. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.81.5.) As noted in Comment 3, this bill also contains specific data security safeguards to ensure the confidentiality and integrity of medical information collected or stored by the database.
To remove any ambiguity concerning the application of California’s Data Breach Notification Law to data collected or stored by the administrator of the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database, the author offers the following amendment:
Author’s Amendment:
On page 6, line 12, following “to,” insert “the Data Breach Notification Law (Civil Code Sections 1798.29 et seq. and 1798.82 et seq.),”
Other Author’s Amendments
The author states:
Consumer groups urge adding a greater focus on health equity to the bill. They believe the databank can be a rich source of actionable information to help reduce disparities, but only if those goals are specified in the bill. Categories of data elements they seek to have specified include race, ethnicity, primary language spoken, and sexual orientation in order to ensure these elements are gathered and to allow tracking impacts. Integrating more explicit health equity provisions for such data, they assert, would allow for mapping cost and quality patterns regionally, and even by neighborhood, to make the database a more accurate and meaningful tool for reducing disparities and improving population health.
To address these concerns and add a greater focus on health equity, the author offers the following amendments:
Author’s Amendments:
On page 3, line 20, after “value” insert “and to minimize health disparities”
On page 3, line 25, strike “enrollees.” and insert “enrollees, including recognizing the diversity of California and the impact of social determinants of health.”
On page 4, between lines 26 and 27, insert “Provide that the database shall have the capacity to map to other datasets, including public health data sets on morbidity and mortality, including from the Centers for Disease Control as well the Department of Public Health as well as other datasets with data regarding the social determinants of health.”
On page 5, line 12, strike “both of”
On page 5, between lines 38 and 39, insert “(C) Information sufficient to determine the impacts of the social determinants of health, including age, gender, race, ethnicity, limited English proficiency, sexual orientation and gender identity, zip code, and any other factors for which there is peer-reviewed evidence.”
On page 7, strike lines 25 through 29 and insert “(E) Facility and physician organization risk adjusted performance measures on the quality, efficiency, and outcomes of care that are aligned with national efforts, including, but not limited to, those of the National Quality Forum, related to defining cost and quality measures. Measures shall be publicly reported without risk adjustment for sociodemographic factors and shall also be risk adjusted for sociodemographic factors, where the peer-reviewed literature indicates an association between health outcomes and a sociodemographic factor or factors.”
On page 7, strike lines 30 through 32 and insert “(F) Data that permits consideration of socioeconomic status and disparities in care due to race, ethnicity, gender, limited English proficiency, zip code, sexual orientation, and gender identity and other factors for which there is peer-reviewed evidence of a relationship between a social determinant of health and health outcomes.”
On page 8, between lines 34 and 35, insert “Reducing health disparities and addressing the social determinants of health.”
Support: AARP California; American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO; California Coverage and Health Initiatives; California Primary Care Association; California Teacher’s Association; Children’s Defense Fund, California; Children Now; Kaiser Permanente; National Multiple Sclerosis Society; Professional and Technical Engineers, Local 21; United Ways of California
Opposition: American Civil Liberties Union of California; Consumer Federation of California; Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SB 1322 (Hernandez, 2014) was substantially similar to SB 26. This bill was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1558 (Hernandez, 2014) would have requested the University of California to establish the California Health Data Organization to collect data from payers and establish an all-payer claims database. This bill would have required certain private payers to submit claims data to the organization on utilization, payment, and cost sharing for services delivered to beneficiaries, and would have requested the organization to design and maintain an Internet Web site that allowed consumers to compare the prices paid by payers for procedures. This bill was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 746 (Leno, 2013) would have required health care service plans and insurers to disclose specified aggregate data for products and for rate filings, as specified, in the large group market on an annual basis. The bill also would have required a health plan or health insurer that exclusively contracts with no more than two medical groups in the state to provide claims or other data to large group purchasers that request the data and demonstrate the ability to comply with privacy laws, as specified, and would have required the health care service plan or health insurer to use only deidentified data in that disclosure to protect the privacy rights of individuals. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown.
Prior Vote: Senate Health Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
SB 26 (Hernandez) Page 10 of 10
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 26
AUTHOR: |
Hernandez |
||
VERSION: |
December 1, 2014 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
April 22, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Melanie Moreno |
||
SUBJECT: California Health Care Cost and Quality Database
SUMMARY:
Requires the Secretary of California Health and Human Services Agency to, no later than January 1, 2017, use a competitive process to contract, as specified, with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations in order to administer the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database. Requires the nonprofit organization, no later than January 1, 2019, to make a publicly available, web-based, searchable database, as specified. Requires the information and analysis included in the database to be presented in a way that facilitates comparisons of cost, quality, and patient satisfaction across payers, provider organizations, and other suppliers of health care services.
Existing law:
Establishes the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) as the single state agency responsible for collecting specified health facility and clinic data for use by all agencies. Requires hospitals to make and file with OSHPD certain specified reports, including a Hospital Discharge Abstract Data Record with data elements for each admission, such as diagnoses and disposition of the patient.
Requires OSHPD, to publish annually risk-adjusted outcome reports on medical, surgical and obstetric conditions or procedures, and others selected by OSHPD in accordance with specified criteria.
Requires OSHPD, to publish a risk-adjusted outcome report for coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery for all CABG surgeries performed in the state. Requires the reports to compare risk-adjusted outcomes by hospital in every year, and by cardiac surgeon in every other year, but permits information on individual hospitals and surgeons to be excluded from the reports based upon the recommendation of a clinical panel for statistical and technical considerations.
Requires a hospital to make a written or electronic copy of its charge description master available at the hospital location. Requires the hospital to post a notice that the hospital’s charge description master is available, and requires any information about charges provided to include information about where to obtain information regarding hospital quality, including hospital outcome studies available from OSHPD and hospital survey information available from the Joint Commission for Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations.
Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans and the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health insurers. Requires specified health plans and insurers to submit reports to state and federal regulators on medical loss ratios, rate filings, enrollment data, as specified.
Prohibits contracts between carriers and a licensed hospital or health care facility owned by a licensed hospital from containing any provision that restricts the ability of the carrier from furnishing information to enrollees or insureds concerning the cost range of procedures or the quality of services. Provides hospitals at least 20 days in advance to review the methodology and data, requires risk adjustment factors for quality data, and requires an opportunity for a hospital to provide a link on the carrier’s Website where the hospital’s response to the data can be accessed.
Makes, under federal law, Medicare data available for the evaluation of the performance of providers of services and suppliers, to qualified entities, defined as a public or private entity that is qualified as determined by the Secretary of the federal Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), to use to evaluate the performance of providers of services and suppliers on measures of quality, efficiency, effectiveness, and resource use, and applies other requirements to qualified entities as the HHS Secretary may specify, such as ensuring security of data.
Prohibits a health plan from releasing any information to an employer that would directly or indirectly indicate to the employer that an employee is receiving or has received services from a health care provider covered by the plan unless authorized to do so by the employee.
Establishes Covered California as a state-based health care benefit exchange in state government to make available selectively contracted qualified health plans (QHPs) for individual and small group purchasers. Requires QHPs to submit data to Covered California.
Establishes, under federal law, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), which among various provisions, mandates industry-wide standards for health care information on electronic billing and other processes; and, requires the protection and confidential handling of protected health information.
Establishes the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, which prohibits providers of healthcare, health care service plans, their contractors, and any business organized for the purpose of maintaining medical information, from using medical information for any purpose other than providing health care services, except as expressly authorized by the patient or as otherwise required or authorized by law.
This bill:
Creates the California Health Care Cost and Quality Database (database) and requires the Secretary of California Health and Human Services Agency (CHHS) to, no later than January 1, 2017, use a competitive process to contract, as specified, with one or more independent, nonprofit organizations in order to administer it. Requires the competitive process and any requests for proposal to be publicly posted on CHHS’ Web site for a minimum of 30 days for public review and comment.
Requires CHHS to include, as terms in the contract or contracts:
A requirement that the nonprofit organization administering the database establish it with parameters as specified in 13) below; develop methodologies for the collection, validation, refinement, analysis, comparison, review, reporting, and improvement of health care data, as specified; receive information from health care entities and report that information in a form that allows valid comparisons across care delivery systems, as specified; and, comply with the requirements governing provider and supplier requests for error correction established pursuant specified federal regulations.
A prohibition on the nonprofit from using data received for any purpose not specified in this bill or in the contract, or receiving funding from any other source to accomplish the same purposes sought under this bill unless that funding is received from another nonprofit or government source and is for the purpose of research or education.
A requirement that the nonprofit identify the type of data, purpose of use, and entities and individuals that are required to report to, or that may have access to, the database. Prohibits an entity or individual from being required to report to, and from having access to, the database until the review committee established under 13) below has approved the nonprofit determination.
Requires, for the purpose of developing information for inclusion in the database, health plans, insurers, self-insured employers, and suppliers and providers, as defined, to provide the nonprofit organization:
Utilization data from medical, dental, and pharmacy claims. In the case of entities that do not use claims data (including, but not limited to, integrated delivery systems), encounter data consistent with the core set of data elements for data submission proposed by the APCD Council, the University of New Hampshire, and the National Association of Health Data Organizations; and,
Pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care gathered from allowed charges for covered health care items and services. In the case of entities that do not use or produce individual claims, price information that is the best possible proxy to pricing information for health care items, services, and medical and surgical episodes of care available in lieu of actual cost data to allow for meaningful comparisons of provider prices and treatment costs.
Permits a multiemployer self-insured plan that is responsible for paying for health care services provided to beneficiaries and the trust administrator for a multiemployer self-insured plan to provide the information in 3) above.
Permits the nonprofit organization to report an entity’s failure to comply with 3) above to the entity’s regulating agency. Permits the regulating agency to enforce the requirement in 3) above using its existing enforcement procedures. Requires moneys collected pursuant to the authorization to enforce to be subject to appropriation by the Legislature. Specifies that the failure to comply with 3) above is not a crime.
Requires all uses and disclosures of data made pursuant to this bill to comply with all applicable state and federal laws for the protection of the privacy and security of data, including, but not limited to, HIPAA and the federal Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act and implementing regulations.
Requires all policies and protocols developed in the performance of the contract to ensure that the privacy, security, and confidentiality of individually identifiable health information is protected. Prohibits the nonprofit organization from publicly disclosing any unaggregated, individually identifiable health information, as defined, and requires the nonprofit to develop a protocol for assessing the risk of reidentification stemming from public disclosure of any health information that is aggregated, individually identifiable health information.
Requires confidentially negotiated contract terms contained in a contract between a health plan or insurer and a provider or supplier to be protected in any public disclosure of data made pursuant to this bill. Prohibits individually identifiable proprietary contract information included in a contract between a health plan or insurer and a provider or supplier from being disclosed in an unaggregated format.
Requires the nonprofit organization to receive, process, maintain, and analyze information from data sources, including, but not limited to, data received pursuant to subdivision #3 above, claims from private and public payers, disease and chronic condition registries, third-party surveys of quality and patient satisfaction, reviews by licensing and accrediting bodies, and local and regional public health data. Requires aggregated payer and provider performance on validated measures of clinical quality and patient experience, such as measures from the Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) and Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS), to be collected from accrediting organizations, including, but not limited to, the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA), URAC, and the Joint Commission.
Requires the nonprofit organization to include in an analysis, performed pursuant to 9) above, to include all of the following:
Population-level data on prevention, screening, and wellness utilization;
Population-level data on behavioral and medical risk factors, interventions, and outcomes;
Population-level data on chronic conditions, management, and outcomes;
Population-level data on trends in utilization of procedures for treatment of similar conditions to evaluate medical appropriateness;
Facility and physician organization risk adjusted performance information on the quality, efficiency, and outcomes of care that are aligned with national efforts, including, but not limited to, those of the National Quality Forum, related to defining cost and quality measures; and,
Data that permits consideration of socioeconomic status and disparities in care due to race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and gender identity.
Requires the nonprofit organization, no later than January 1, 2019, to make publicly available a web-based, searchable database, as specified. Requires the information and analysis included in the database to be presented in a way that facilitates comparisons of cost, quality, and satisfaction across payers, provider organizations, and other suppliers of health care services. Requires the database to be regularly updated to reflect new data submissions.
Prohibits the implementation and ongoing administration costs of the database from being paid using General Fund (GF) moneys.
Requires CHHS to convene a review committee, composed of a broad spectrum of health care stakeholders and experts, including, but not limited to, representatives of the entities that are required to provide information pursuant to 3) above and representatives of purchasers, including, but not limited to, businesses, organized labor, and consumers, to develop the parameters for the establishment, implementation, and ongoing administration of the database, including a business plan for sustainability without using GF moneys, as specified. Requires the review committee to hold public meetings with stakeholders, solicit input, and set its own meeting agendas. Makes review committee meetings subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
Requires CHHS to arrange for the preparation of an annual report to the Legislature and the Governor, as specified, based on the findings of the review committee, including input from the public meetings, that shall, at a minimum, examine and address the following issues:
Assessing California health care needs and available resources;
Containing the cost of health care services and coverage;
Improving the quality and medical appropriateness of health care;
Increasing the transparency of health care costs and the relative efficiency with which care is delivered;
Use of disease management, wellness, prevention, and other innovative programs to keep people healthy and reduce disparities and costs and improving health outcomes for all populations;
Efficient utilization of prescription drugs and technology;
Reducing unnecessary, inappropriate, and wasteful health care;
Educating consumers in the use of health care information; and,
Using existing data sources to build the database.
Prohibits the review committee from being convened until the Director of Finance (DOF) has determined that sufficient private or federal funds have been received and that the funds have been appropriated for that purpose. Requires the review committee to continue to function for as long as DOF has determined that the database is established and is being administered.
Prohibits the members of the review committee from receiving per diem or travel expense reimbursement, or any other expense reimbursement.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. According to the author, beginning in March 2014, the Senate Committee on Health convened several health care experts to discuss factors that contribute to the growing cost of health care in California and efforts to make care more affordable. At a second hearing in February of this year, the Committee heard testimony related to some major cost drivers in the health care system, including pharmaceuticals, hospital costs, and the effects of geographic location on contracting. The third, held in March of this year, served to educate members and the public about the effect of health care costs on consumers. This series of hearings examined policy solutions to control health care costs as millions of Californians obtain coverage under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA). Testimony presented at the hearings illustrated the complexity of the health care market and the array of approaches to containing costs. In addition to expanded coverage, the author believes that, like past health care reform efforts, a long-term, comprehensive action agenda for California policymakers is necessary to ensure that health care costs are appropriate and health care premiums are affordable, especially given that the ACA contains a mandate for individuals to purchase coverage. The author states this bill is intended to help make available valid performance information to promote care that is safe, medically effective, patient-centered, timely, efficient, affordable and equitable. This bill seeks to put provider cost and performance information into the hands of consumers and purchasers so that they are able to understand their financial liability and realize the best quality and value available to them.
All-Payer Claims Databases. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, several states have established databases that collect health insurance claims information from all health care payers into a statewide information repository, referred to as “all-payer claims databases.” An all-payer claims database is designed to inform cost containment and quality improvement efforts. Payers include private health insurers, Medicaid, children’s health insurance and state employee health benefit programs, prescription drug plans, dental insurers, self-insured employer plans and Medicare. The databases contain eligibility and claims data (medical, pharmacy and dental) and are used to report cost, use and quality information. The data consist of “service-level” information based on valid claims processed by health payers. Service-level information includes charges and payments, the provider(s) receiving payment, clinical diagnosis and procedure codes, and patient demographics. To mask the identity of patients and ensure privacy, states usually encrypt, aggregate and suppress patient identifiers. Colorado, Kansas, Minnesota, Tennessee, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Utah and Vermont all have APCDs. Most of these states have chosen to house their APCDs at a state agency (either an existing agency or a newly created entity); one state (Colorado) has its APCD run by a nonprofit organization. The papers emphasize the importance of engaging key stakeholders early and often, including payers, health care providers, employers, state agencies, and consumers. The papers note that for most states, legislation creating an APCD usually articulates broad reporting goals which are further refined in rules or regulations for data collection or data use.
Existing California initiatives. In California, the California Healthcare Performance Information System (CHPI) is a voluntary physician performance database with statistical analysis that will eventually publish information online. According to the CHPI website, starting in 2015, output will be an analysis of claims data aggregated from more than 12 million patients enrolled in CHPI’s three participating California health plans- Blue Shield, Anthem Blue Cross and United Healthcare, as well as Medicare. CHPI was federally certified to include data from Medicare’s five million California beneficiaries, and became the first Qualified Entity to receive Medicare data.
The University of California, San Francisco is working with the California Department of Insurance (CDI) on a medical cost and quality transparency website. According to CDI, the website will report average prices paid for episodes of care or annual costs for chronic conditions, as well as quality measures where available. Prices will be aggregated across payers and providers, and shown at the regional level based on the 19 California rating regions (some regions may need to be consolidated pursuant to the terms of the data license agreement). The website is expected to provide price information for 95 to 99 episodes of care or conditions. Five to 15 of those episodes or conditions will have both price and quality information as well as consumer education content created by Consumers Union. Quality information will consist of existing performance, appropriateness, and outcome measures.
Double referral. This bill has been double referred. Should it pass out of this Committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Related legislation. SB 275 (Hernandez), requires OSHPD to adopt a regulation that adds physician identifiers to the patient level data elements that are required to be collected and reported by hospitals and surgical clinics. SB 275 passed out of the Senate Health Committee by a vote of 7-0.
SB 546 (Leno), establishes a rate approval process for large group health insurance products prior to the implementation of any rate change that equals or exceeds certain triggers, or at the request of a large group purchaser. Establishes a rate review process of a health plan’s or insurer’s entire aggregated large group market products and requires DMHC and CDI to conduct a public meeting regarding large group rate changes for each plan or insurer that offers coverage in the large group market on or before November 1, 2016 and annually thereafter. SB 546 is set to be heard in this Committee on April 22, 2015.
Prior legislation. SB 1322 (Hernandez), of 2014, was substantially similar to this bill. SB 1322 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 1182 (Leno) Chapter 577, Statutes of 2014, requires health plans and insurers to share specified data with purchasers that have 1,000 or more enrollees or that are multiemployer trusts.
SB 1340 (Hernandez), Chapter 83, Statutes of 2014, expands provisions related to gag clauses in contracts between health plans or insurers and providers.
AB 1558 (Roger Hernández), of 2014, would have created the California Health Data Organization within the University of California to organize data provided by health plans and insurers on a website to allow consumers to compare the prices paid for procedures, as specified. AB 1558 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 746 (Leno), of 2013, would have established new data reporting requirements on all health plans applicable to products sold in the large group market and established new specific data reporting requirements related to annual medical trend factors by service category, as well as claims data or de-identified patient-level data, as specified, for a health plan that exclusively contracts with no more than two medical groups in the state to provide or arrange for professional medical services for the enrollees of the plan (referring to Kaiser Permanente). SB 746 was vetoed by the Governor, who urged all parties to work together in the effort to make health care costs more transparent.
SB 1196 (Hernandez), Chapter 869, Statutes of 2011, prohibits a contract between a health plan insurer and a provider or supplier, from prohibiting, conditioning, or in any way restricting the disclosure of claims data related to health care services provided to an enrollee or subscriber of the health plan or carrier, or beneficiaries of any self-funded health coverage arrangement administered by the carrier to a qualified entity, as defined.
SB 751 (Gaines and Hernandez), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2011, prohibits contracts between carriers and hospitals from containing any provision that restricts the ability of the carrier from furnishing information to enrollees or insureds concerning cost range of procedures or the quality of services.
AB 2389 (Gaines), of 2009, would have prohibited a contract between a health facility and a carrier from containing a provision that restricts the ability of the carrier to furnish information on the cost of procedures or health care quality information to carrier enrollees. AB 2389 died in the Assembly on Concurrence.
AB 2967 (Lieber), of 2008, would have established a Health Care Cost and Quality Transparency Committee to develop and recommend to the CHHS Secretary a health care cost and quality transparency plan, and would have made the Secretary responsible for the timely implementation of the transparency plan. AB 2967 died on the Senate Inactive File.
SB 1300 (Corbett), of 2008, would have prohibited a contract between a health care provider and a health plan from containing a provision that restricts the ability of the health plan to furnish information on the cost of procedures or health care quality information to plan enrollees. SB 1300 died on the Senate Floor.
AB 1296 (Torrico), Chapter 698, Statutes of 2007, requires a health plan or contractor offering health benefits to California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) members and annuitants to disclose to CalPERS the cost, utilization, actual claim payments, and contract allowance amounts for health care services rendered by participating hospitals to each member and annuitant.
AB 1 X1 (Nuñez) of 2007, among many other provisions relating to health care reform, contained nearly identical language as that contained in AB 2967. AB1 X1 failed passage in the Senate Health Committee.
Support. The California Primary Care Association writes that stakeholders across California begin to work together to develop the framework of this new and improved delivery system, it has become increasingly clear that a single trustworthy, accurate clearinghouse of claims and quality data is necessary to move us in the direction we seek. The National Multiple Sclerosis Society – California Action Network states that there is no cure for MS and therefore, individuals living with the disease manage it through medical care and a myriad of prescription medications. This bill will provide an important resource for people living with a chronic condition such as MS as it will address price transparency and education consumers about health related expenses. AARP states that information about the performance of our health care system should be collected, analyzed, and made publicly available, addressing safety, effectiveness, patient-centered responsiveness, timeliness, equity, and efficiency. The California Teachers Association states that making better health care decisions requires a level of transparency that has been a challenge within an industry that systematically opposes transparency. Kaiser Permanente writes that as a growing proportion of care is paid for through capitated, bundled and value-based arrangements, health care data that is based only on claims will provide an increasingly incomplete and inaccurate picture of statewide costs and quality. Kaiser believes that this bill will advance the critical conversation in California about the best way to collect, measure, and compare health care data toward achieving key policy goas of improving health and the quality of care and reducing cost trends over the long term.
Support if amended. Consumers Union (CU), Health Access California, SEIU California, California Labor Federation, and CALPIRG suggest amendments to create a public governance body with a spectrum of viewpoints (including consumer advocates, labor, and other purchasers) that would be responsible for developing a plan to ensure comprehensive and efficient collection of data from physicians, hospitals and other sources. CU states that these provisions would ensure greater public accountability for the design, implementation, and oversight of the database and better ensure it develops the information consumers want to choose the best-value care and give providers the information and incentives they need to improve their performance. CU contends that contracting out certain data collection functions could still be undertaken, but the parameters and prioritization would remain in the public domain in a fully transparent way. Such a body should have participation from diverse and varying points of view, including consumer advocates, labor and other purchasers.
These groups urge a greater focus on health equity to be added to the bill, so that disparities among different communities can be monitored and ultimately reduced. Categories of data elements need to be specified (such as race, ethnicity, primary language spoken, ZIP code, and sexual orientation). Integrating stronger, more explicit health equity provisions would make the database a more accurate and meaningful tool for the critical task of reducing disparities and improving community health.
Finally, these groups urge closing a loophole in section 127672(d)(3) that would prevent full transparency by allowing providers to broadly deem contract information “proprietary” and to require contract language that would allow information required in other sections of the bill to be kept confidential.
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network (CPEHN) also urges inclusion of language to ensure a greater focus on health equity and to ensure that the governance is responsive to the needs of consumers. In addition, CPEHN proposes amendments that would require the database to include the capability to map data on mortality and morbidity rates as well as other relevant data on the social and environmental factors that impact health to better pinpoint areas with disparities and highlight potential problems or incongruities in access and quality of care.
Support in concept. CAPG writes that they support policy measures that encourage the implementation of the Triple Aim (decreased costs, improved patient experience and development of population health management), appreciates the stakeholder meetings conducted by the author, and look forward to working together on the creation of such a database in the Golden State.
Concerns. The California Association of Health Plans (CAHP) are concerned that the database should be “searchable” by the public when confidential and proprietary information is included in the data submitted because it is unclear what will be made public and how the information will be shared. CAHP believes it is critical that specific contractual payment arrangements remain confidential as proprietary information. CAHP agrees that a neutral third party should be responsible for the database; however, they recommend that the organization convene a technical workgroup tasked with developing the data elements to be collected rather than specifying what should be initially included in the database in statute. CAHP states that for the purposes of the initial implementation it is recommended to use a phased-in plan approach based on enrollment size and that claims data should begin with medical and pharmacy data, which would help to identify coding and other data issues prior to including the smaller and specialty plans that could be added after implementation. If Medicare data is to be included, then the database administer should apply to the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to be a Medicare Data Sharing for Performance Program. Finally, CAHP writes that the use of existing informational sources such HEDIS, OSHPD, and the Department of Health Care Services should be included to avoid the repetitious reporting of data and that these items could be identified in the technical workgroup mentioned above and the workgroup could be responsible for extracting the data from these sources or could ensure that the database is capable of receiving the data as currently extracted for these systems.
Oppose. The California Right to Life Committee (CRLC) states that heath care data will include patients requiring end of life care and various groups are actively promoting end of life plans, and they assume that one of these groups would be involved in the process as a non-profit agency. CRLC also states that these groups could be invited to the review committee created under this bill and it foresees these groups working in tandem with any statewide POLST registry or similar end of life mandated health care form that removes the patient from the decision making.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: AARP
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees
California Primary Care Association
California Teachers Association
Kaiser Permanente
National Multiple Sclerosis Society – California Action Network
Oppose: California Right to Life Committee, Inc.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):