SB 261: Youth offender parole hearings.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-10-03
Existing law generally requires the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct youth offender parole hearings to consider the release of offenders who committed specified crimes when they were under 18 years of age and who were sentenced to state prison.
This bill would instead require the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct a youth offender parole hearing for offenders sentenced to state prison who committed those specified crimes when they were under 23 years of age. The bill would require the board to complete, by July 1, 2017, all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill. The bill would require the board to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill by July 1, 2021, and would require the board, for these individuals, to conduct a specified consultation before July 1, 2017.
Existing law generally requires the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct youth offender parole hearings to consider the release of offenders who committed specified crimes when they were under 18 years of age and who were sentenced to state prison.
This bill would instead require the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct a youth offender parole hearing for offenders sentenced to state prison who committed those specified crimes when they were under 23 years of age. The bill would require the board to complete, by July 1, 2017, all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill. The bill would require the board to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill by July 1, 2021, and would require the board, for these individuals, to conduct a specified consultation before July 1, 2017.
Existing law generally requires the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct youth offender parole hearings to consider the release of offenders who committed specified crimes when they were under 18 years of age and who were sentenced to state prison.
This bill would instead require the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct a youth offender parole hearing for offenders sentenced to state prison who committed those specified crimes when they were under 23 years of age. The bill would require the board to complete, by July 1, 2017, all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill. The bill would require the board to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill by July 1, 2021, and would require the board, for these individuals, to conduct a specified consultation before July 1, 2017.
Existing law generally requires the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct youth offender parole hearings to consider the release of offenders who committed specified crimes when they were under 18 years of age and who were sentenced to state prison.
This bill would instead require the Board of Parole Hearings to conduct a youth offender parole hearing for offenders sentenced to state prison who committed those specified crimes when they were under 23 years of age. The bill would require the board to complete, by July 1, 2017, all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the bill.
Existing law authorizes the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to contract for the establishment and operation of community correctional facilities that offer programs for the treatment of addiction to alcohol or controlled substances, based on the therapeutic community model, under certain conditions. Existing law requires each facility under contract to provide programs that prepare each inmate for successful reintegration into society.
This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.
Existing law authorizes the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to contract for the establishment and operation of community correctional facilities that offer programs for the treatment of addiction to alcohol or controlled substances, based on the therapeutic community model, under certain conditions. Existing law requires each facility under contract to provide programs that prepare each inmate for successful reintegration into society.
This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to those provisions.
(a)(1)A youth offender parole hearing is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 23 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense.
(2)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(A)Incarceration means detention in a city or county jail, a local juvenile facility, a mental health facility, a Division of Juvenile Justice facility, or a Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facility.
(B)Controlling offense means the offense or enhancement for which any sentencing court imposed the longest term of imprisonment.
(b)(1)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a determinate sentence shall be eligible for release on parole at a youth offender parole hearing by the board during his or her 15th year of incarceration, unless previously released pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(2)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of less than 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 20th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(3)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 25th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(c)An individual subject to this section shall meet with the board pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 3041.
(d)The board shall conduct a youth offender parole hearing to consider release. At the youth offender parole hearing, the board shall release the individual on parole as provided in Section 3041, except that the board shall act in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 4801.
(e)The youth offender parole hearing to consider release shall provide for a meaningful opportunity to obtain release. The board shall review and, as necessary, revise existing regulations and adopt new regulations regarding determinations of suitability made pursuant to this section, subdivision (c) of Section 4801, and other related topics, consistent with relevant case law, in order to provide that meaningful opportunity for release.
(f)(1)In assessing growth and maturity, psychological evaluations and risk assessment instruments, if used by the board, shall be administered by licensed psychologists employed by the board and shall take into consideration the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to that of adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the individual.
(2)Family members, friends, school personnel, faith leaders, and representatives from community-based organizations with knowledge about the individual before the crime or his or her growth and maturity since the time of the crime may submit statements for review by the board.
(3)Nothing in this section is intended to alter the rights of victims at parole hearings.
(g)If parole is not granted, the board shall set the time for a subsequent youth offender parole hearing in accordance with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 3041.5. In exercising its discretion pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) and subdivision (d) of Section 3041.5, the board shall consider the factors in subdivision (c) of Section 4801. No subsequent youth offender parole hearing shall be necessary if the offender is released pursuant to other statutory provisions prior to the date of the subsequent hearing.
(h)This section shall not apply to cases in which sentencing occurs pursuant to Section 1170.12, subdivisions (b) to (i), inclusive, of Section 667, or Section 667.61, or in which an individual was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. This section shall not apply to an individual to whom this section would otherwise apply, but who, subsequent to attaining 23 years of age, commits an additional crime for which malice aforethought is a necessary element of the crime or for which the individual is sentenced to life in prison.
(i)(1)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who became entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing prior to the effective date of the act that added paragraph (2) by July 1, 2015.
(2)(A)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2017.
(B)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2021. The board shall, for all individuals described in this subparagraph, conduct the consultation described in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 before July 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 4801 of the Penal Code is amended to read:4801.(a)The Board of Parole Hearings may report to the Governor, from time to time, the names of any and all persons imprisoned in any state prison who, in its judgment, ought to have a commutation of sentence or be pardoned and set at liberty on account of good conduct, or unusual term of sentence, or any other cause, including evidence of intimate partner battering and its effects. For purposes of this section, intimate partner battering and its effects may include evidence of the nature and effects of physical, emotional, or mental abuse upon the beliefs, perceptions, or behavior of victims of domestic violence if it appears the criminal behavior was the result of that victimization.
(b)(1)The board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to any information or evidence that, at the time of the commission of the crime, the prisoner had experienced intimate partner battering, but was convicted of an offense that occurred prior to August 29, 1996. The board shall state on the record the information or evidence that it considered pursuant to this subdivision, and the reasons for the parole decision. The board shall annually report to the Legislature and the Governor on the cases the board considered pursuant to this subdivision during the previous year, including the boards decisions and the specific and detailed findings of its investigations of these cases.
(2)The report for the Legislature to be submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be submitted pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(3)The fact that a prisoner has presented evidence of intimate partner battering cannot be used to support a finding that the prisoner lacks insight into his or her crime and its causes.
(c)When a prisoner committed his or her controlling offense, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 3051, prior to attaining 23 years of age, the board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law.
(a)(1)A youth offender parole hearing is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 23 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense.
(2)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(A)Incarceration means detention in a city or county jail, a local juvenile facility, a mental health facility, a Division of Juvenile Justice facility, or a Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facility.
(B)Controlling offense means the offense or enhancement for which any sentencing court imposed the longest term of imprisonment.
(b)(1)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a determinate sentence shall be eligible for release on parole at a youth offender parole hearing by the board during his or her 15th year of incarceration, unless previously released pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(2)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of less than 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 20th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(3)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 25th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(c)An individual subject to this section shall meet with the board pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 3041.
(d)The board shall conduct a youth offender parole hearing to consider release. At the youth offender parole hearing, the board shall release the individual on parole as provided in Section 3041, except that the board shall act in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 4801.
(e)The youth offender parole hearing to consider release shall provide for a meaningful opportunity to obtain release. The board shall review and, as necessary, revise existing regulations and adopt new regulations regarding determinations of suitability made pursuant to this section, subdivision (c) of Section 4801, and other related topics, consistent with relevant case law, in order to provide that meaningful opportunity for release.
(f)(1)In assessing growth and maturity, psychological evaluations and risk assessment instruments, if used by the board, shall be administered by licensed psychologists employed by the board and shall take into consideration the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to that of adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the individual.
(2)Family members, friends, school personnel, faith leaders, and representatives from community-based organizations with knowledge about the individual before the crime or his or her growth and maturity since the time of the crime may submit statements for review by the board.
(3)Nothing in this section is intended to alter the rights of victims at parole hearings.
(g)If parole is not granted, the board shall set the time for a subsequent youth offender parole hearing in accordance with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 3041.5. In exercising its discretion pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) and subdivision (d) of Section 3041.5, the board shall consider the factors in subdivision (c) of Section 4801. No subsequent youth offender parole hearing shall be necessary if the offender is released pursuant to other statutory provisions prior to the date of the subsequent hearing.
(h)This section shall not apply to cases in which sentencing occurs pursuant to Section 1170.12, subdivisions (b) to (i), inclusive, of Section 667, or Section 667.61, or in which an individual was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. This section shall not apply to an individual to whom this section would otherwise apply, but who, subsequent to attaining 23 years of age, commits an additional crime for which malice aforethought is a necessary element of the crime or for which the individual is sentenced to life in prison.
(i)(1)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who became entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing prior to the effective date of the act that added paragraph (2) by July 1, 2015.
(2)(A)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2017.
(B)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2021. The board shall, for all individuals described in this subparagraph, conduct the consultation described in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 before July 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 4801 of the Penal Code is amended to read:4801.(a)The Board of Parole Hearings may report to the Governor, from time to time, the names of any and all persons imprisoned in any state prison who, in its judgment, ought to have a commutation of sentence or be pardoned and set at liberty on account of good conduct, or unusual term of sentence, or any other cause, including evidence of intimate partner battering and its effects. For purposes of this section, intimate partner battering and its effects may include evidence of the nature and effects of physical, emotional, or mental abuse upon the beliefs, perceptions, or behavior of victims of domestic violence if it appears the criminal behavior was the result of that victimization.
(b)(1)The board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to any information or evidence that, at the time of the commission of the crime, the prisoner had experienced intimate partner battering, but was convicted of an offense that occurred prior to August 29, 1996. The board shall state on the record the information or evidence that it considered pursuant to this subdivision, and the reasons for the parole decision. The board shall annually report to the Legislature and the Governor on the cases the board considered pursuant to this subdivision during the previous year, including the boards decisions and the specific and detailed findings of its investigations of these cases.
(2)The report for the Legislature to be submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be submitted pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(3)The fact that a prisoner has presented evidence of intimate partner battering cannot be used to support a finding that the prisoner lacks insight into his or her crime and its causes.
(c)When a prisoner committed his or her controlling offense, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 3051, prior to attaining 23 years of age, the board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law.
(a)(1)A youth offender parole hearing is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 23 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense.
(2)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(A)Incarceration means detention in a city or county jail, a local juvenile facility, a mental health facility, a Division of Juvenile Justice facility, or a Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facility.
(B)Controlling offense means the offense or enhancement for which any sentencing court imposed the longest term of imprisonment.
(b)(1)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a determinate sentence shall be eligible for release on parole at a youth offender parole hearing by the board during his or her 15th year of incarceration, unless previously released pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(2)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of less than 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 20th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(3)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 25th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(c)An individual subject to this section shall meet with the board pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 3041.
(d)The board shall conduct a youth offender parole hearing to consider release. At the youth offender parole hearing, the board shall release the individual on parole as provided in Section 3041, except that the board shall act in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 4801.
(e)The youth offender parole hearing to consider release shall provide for a meaningful opportunity to obtain release. The board shall review and, as necessary, revise existing regulations and adopt new regulations regarding determinations of suitability made pursuant to this section, subdivision (c) of Section 4801, and other related topics, consistent with relevant case law, in order to provide that meaningful opportunity for release.
(f)(1)In assessing growth and maturity, psychological evaluations and risk assessment instruments, if used by the board, shall be administered by licensed psychologists employed by the board and shall take into consideration the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to that of adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the individual.
(2)Family members, friends, school personnel, faith leaders, and representatives from community-based organizations with knowledge about the individual before the crime or his or her growth and maturity since the time of the crime may submit statements for review by the board.
(3)Nothing in this section is intended to alter the rights of victims at parole hearings.
(g)If parole is not granted, the board shall set the time for a subsequent youth offender parole hearing in accordance with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 3041.5. In exercising its discretion pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) and subdivision (d) of Section 3041.5, the board shall consider the factors in subdivision (c) of Section 4801. No subsequent youth offender parole hearing shall be necessary if the offender is released pursuant to other statutory provisions prior to the date of the subsequent hearing.
(h)This section shall not apply to cases in which sentencing occurs pursuant to Section 1170.12, subdivisions (b) to (i), inclusive, of Section 667, or Section 667.61, or in which an individual was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. This section shall not apply to an individual to whom this section would otherwise apply, but who, subsequent to attaining 23 years of age, commits an additional crime for which malice aforethought is a necessary element of the crime or for which the individual is sentenced to life in prison.
(i)(1)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become became entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this section prior to the effective date of the act that added paragraph (2) by July 1, 2015.
(2)(A)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to indeterminate life terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2017.
(B)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who were sentenced to determinate terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2021. The board shall, for all individuals described in this subparagraph, conduct the consultation described in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 before July 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 4801 of the Penal Code is amended to read:4801.(a)The Board of Parole Hearings may report to the Governor, from time to time, the names of any and all persons imprisoned in any state prison who, in its judgment, ought to have a commutation of sentence or be pardoned and set at liberty on account of good conduct, or unusual term of sentence, or any other cause, including evidence of intimate partner battering and its effects. For purposes of this section, intimate partner battering and its effects may include evidence of the nature and effects of physical, emotional, or mental abuse upon the beliefs, perceptions, or behavior of victims of domestic violence if it appears the criminal behavior was the result of that victimization.
(b)(1)The board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to any information or evidence that, at the time of the commission of the crime, the prisoner had experienced intimate partner battering, but was convicted of an offense that occurred prior to August 29, 1996. The board shall state on the record the information or evidence that it considered pursuant to this subdivision, and the reasons for the parole decision. The board shall annually report to the Legislature and the Governor on the cases the board considered pursuant to this subdivision during the previous year, including the boards decisions and the specific and detailed findings of its investigations of these cases.
(2)The report for the Legislature to be submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be submitted pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(3)The fact that a prisoner has presented evidence of intimate partner battering cannot be used to support a finding that the prisoner lacks insight into his or her crime and its causes.
(c)When a prisoner committed his or her controlling offense, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 3051, prior to attaining 23 years of age, the board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law.
(a)(1)A youth offender parole hearing is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 23 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense.
(2)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(A)Incarceration means detention in a city or county jail, a local juvenile facility, a mental health facility, a Division of Juvenile Justice facility, or a Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation facility.
(B)Controlling offense means the offense or enhancement for which any sentencing court imposed the longest term of imprisonment.
(b)(1)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 18 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a determinate sentence shall be eligible for release on parole at a youth offender parole hearing by the board during his or her 15th year of incarceration, unless previously released pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(2)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 18 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of less than 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 20th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(3)A person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 18 23 years of age and for which the sentence is a life term of 25 years to life shall be eligible for release on parole by the board during his or her 25th year of incarceration at a youth offender parole hearing, unless previously released or entitled to an earlier parole consideration hearing pursuant to other statutory provisions.
(c)An individual subject to this section shall meet with the board pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 3041.
(d)The board shall conduct a youth offender parole hearing to consider release. At the youth offender parole hearing, the board shall release the individual on parole as provided in Section 3041, except that the board shall act in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 4801.
(e)The youth offender parole hearing to consider release shall provide for a meaningful opportunity to obtain release. The board shall review and, as necessary, revise existing regulations and adopt new regulations regarding determinations of suitability made pursuant to this section, subdivision (c) of Section 4801, and other related topics, consistent with relevant case law, in order to provide that meaningful opportunity for release.
(f)(1)In assessing growth and maturity, psychological evaluations and risk assessment instruments, if used by the board, shall be administered by licensed psychologists employed by the board and shall take into consideration the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to that of adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the individual.
(2)Family members, friends, school personnel, faith leaders, and representatives from community-based organizations with knowledge about the individual before the crime or his or her growth and maturity since the time of the crime may submit statements for review by the board.
(3)Nothing in this section is intended to alter the rights of victims at parole hearings.
(g)If parole is not granted, the board shall set the time for a subsequent youth offender parole hearing in accordance with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 3041.5. In exercising its discretion pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) and subdivision (d) of Section 3041.5, the board shall consider the factors in subdivision (c) of Section 4801. No subsequent youth offender parole hearing shall be necessary if the offender is released pursuant to other statutory provisions prior to the date of the subsequent hearing.
(h)This section shall not apply to cases in which sentencing occurs pursuant to Section 1170.12, subdivisions (b) to (i), inclusive, of Section 667, or Section 667.61, or in which an individual was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. This section shall not apply to an individual to whom this section would otherwise apply, but who, subsequent to attaining 18 23 years of age, commits an additional crime for which malice aforethought is a necessary element of the crime or for which the individual is sentenced to life in prison.
(i)(1)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this section by July 1, 2015.
(2)The board shall complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the act that added this paragraph by July 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 4801 of the Penal Code is amended to read:4801.(a)The Board of Parole Hearings may report to the Governor, from time to time, the names of any and all persons imprisoned in any state prison who, in its judgment, ought to have a commutation of sentence or be pardoned and set at liberty on account of good conduct, or unusual term of sentence, or any other cause, including evidence of intimate partner battering and its effects. For purposes of this section, intimate partner battering and its effects may include evidence of the nature and effects of physical, emotional, or mental abuse upon the beliefs, perceptions, or behavior of victims of domestic violence if it appears the criminal behavior was the result of that victimization.
(b)(1)The board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to any information or evidence that, at the time of the commission of the crime, the prisoner had experienced intimate partner battering, but was convicted of an offense that occurred prior to August 29, 1996. The board shall state on the record the information or evidence that it considered pursuant to this subdivision, and the reasons for the parole decision. The board shall annually report to the Legislature and the Governor on the cases the board considered pursuant to this subdivision during the previous year, including the boards decisions and the specific and detailed findings of its investigations of these cases.
(2)The report for the Legislature to be submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be submitted pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(3)The fact that a prisoner has presented evidence of intimate partner battering cannot be used to support a finding that the prisoner lacks insight into his or her crime and its causes.
(c)When a prisoner committed his or her controlling offense, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 3051, prior to attaining 18 23 years of age, the board, in reviewing a prisoners suitability for parole pursuant to Section 3041.5, shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law.
SECTION 1.Section 6250.5 of the Penal Code is amended to read:6250.5.(a)The Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation may contract for the establishment and operation of community correctional facilities that offer programs for the treatment of addiction to alcohol or controlled substances based on the therapeutic community model, only if the cost per inmate of operating the facilities will be less than the cost per inmate of operating similar state facilities. The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of a therapeutic community program, which emphasizes alcohol and controlled substance rehabilitation, is to substantially increase the likelihood of successful parole for those inmates.
(b)Each facility under contract pursuant to this section shall provide programs that prepare each inmate for successful reintegration into society. Those programs shall involve constant counseling in drug and alcohol abuse, employment skills, victim awareness, and family responsibility, and generally shall prepare each inmate for return to society. The programs also shall emphasize literacy training and use computer-supported training so that inmates may improve their reading and writing skills. The program shall include postincarceration counseling and care in order to ensure a greater opportunity for success.
(c)The department may enter into a long-term agreement, not to exceed 20 years, for transfer of prisoners to, or placement of prisoners in, facilities under contract pursuant to this section.
(d)The department shall provide for the review of an agreement entered into under this section to determine if the contractor is in compliance with the terms of this section. The review shall be conducted at least every five years. The department may revoke any agreement if the contractor is not in compliance with this section.
(e)Notwithstanding the Public Contract Code or Article 10 (commencing with Section 1200) of Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall select an independent contractor to conduct an annual audit and cost comparison evaluation of any programs established under this section. A contract for annual audits and evaluation shall provide that the annual report, whether in final or draft form, and all working papers and data, shall be available for immediate review upon request by the department.
(a)The Director of Corrections Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation may contract for the establishment and operation of community correctional facilities that offer programs for the treatment of addiction to alcohol or controlled substances based on the therapeutic community model, only if the cost per inmate of operating the facilities will be less than the cost per inmate of operating similar state facilities. The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of a therapeutic community program, which emphasizes alcohol and controlled substance rehabilitation, is to substantially increase the likelihood of successful parole for those inmates.
(b)Each facility under contract pursuant to this section shall provide programs that prepare each inmate for successful reintegration into society. Those programs shall involve constant counseling in drug and alcohol abuse, employment skills, victim awareness, and family responsibility, and generally shall prepare each inmate for return to society. The programs also shall emphasize literacy training and use computer-supported training so that inmates may improve their reading and writing skills. The program shall include postincarceration counseling and care in order to ensure a greater opportunity for success.
(c)The department may enter into a long-term agreement, not to exceed 20 years, for transfer of prisoners to, or placement of prisoners in, facilities under contract pursuant to this section.
(d)The department shall provide for the review of any an agreement entered into under this section to determine if the contractor is in compliance with the terms of this section. The review shall be conducted at least every five years. The department may revoke any agreement if the contractor is not in compliance with this section.
(e)Notwithstanding the Public Contract Code or Article 10 (commencing with Section 1200) of Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall select an independent contractor to conduct an annual audit and cost comparison evaluation of any programs established under this section. Any A contract for annual audits and evaluation shall provide that the annual report, whether in final or draft form, and all working papers and data, shall be available for immediate review upon request by the department.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 3, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 471, Statutes of 2015. |
| Oct 3, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 3, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 5:45 p.m. |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 45. Noes 31. Page 2738.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 1, 2015 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 28, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 5.) (August 27). |
| Jul 8, 2015 | July 8 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 8, 2015 | July 8 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 1, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 15, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 21. Noes 15. Page 1256.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 21. Noes 15.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 1, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 28, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 1150.) (May 28). |
| May 28, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (May 28). |
| May 23, 2015 | Set for hearing May 28. |
| May 11, 2015 | May 11 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2015 | Set for hearing May 11. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 822.) (April 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2015 | Set for hearing April 28. |
| Apr 7, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 24, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 19, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 18, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2015 | SB 261 Hancock Senate Third Reading By QUIRK | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 30, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2015 | Senate 3rd Reading SB261 Hancock | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2015 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2015 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 261
Page 3
SENATE THIRD READING
SB 261
(Hancock)
As Amended June 1, 2015
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 21-15
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Public Safety |
5-2 |
Quirk, Jones-Sawyer, Lopez, Low, Santiago |
Melendez, Lackey |
Appropriations |
12-5 |
Gomez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Nazarian, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Quirk, Rendon, Weber, Wood |
Bigelow, Chang, Gallagher, Jones, Wagner |
SUMMARY: Expands the youth offender parole process, a parole process for persons sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to include those who have committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that those with indeterminate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
States that those with determinate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2021, and shall have their consultation with the Board of Parole (BPH) before July 1, 2017.
EXISTING LAW:
Establishes a youth offender parole hearing which is a hearing by BPH for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense.
Provides the following parole mechanism for a person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 18 years of age:
If the controlling offense was a determinate sentence the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years;
If the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years then the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and,
If the controlling offense was a life term of 25 years to life then the person is eligible for release after 25 years.
Sets a deadline of July 1, 2015, for BPH to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the statute that established youth offender parole hearings.
Provides that in reviewing a prisoner’s suitability for parole in a youthful offender parole hearing, the BPH shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
Significant one-time costs to the BPH of $1.3 million (General Fund) to complete risk assessments and conduct parole hearings for 800 inmates estimated to be eligible upon this bill’s effective date.
Significant ongoing annual costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or greater (General Fund), to conduct hearings for inmates as they become eligible. The magnitude of costs would be dependent upon the rate at which BPH conducts hearings, as there is no timeframe mandated for prospectively eligible inmates. The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation estimates an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to be within the BPH’s hearing cycle currently and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date, as specified.
One-time costs to BPH of about $100,000 to review and re-write regulations.
Unknown state trial court savings as a result of an accompanying reduction in writs of Habeas Corpus, by which inmates challenge convictions and/or sentences.
Potential incarceration cost savings of $0.2 to $0.5 million (General Fund) for every 20 to 50 inmates either released or having their sentences reduced. Over 10 years, the savings could increase to $2 to $5 million assuming the inmates would have served ten additional years.
Minor offsetting increase in parole costs.
COMMENTS: According to the author, "Much like the existing youth offender process, SB 261 holds young people accountable and responsible for what they did. They must serve a minimum of 15 to 25 years in prison depending on their offense, and must demonstrate remorse, maturity, and rehabilitation to be suitable for parole.
"This reflects science, law, and common sense. Recent neurological research shows that cognitive brain development continues well beyond age 18 and into early adulthood. For boys and young men in particular, this process continues into the mid-20s. The parts of the brain that are still developing during this process affect judgment and decision-making, and are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability. Recent United States Supreme Court cases including Roper v. Simmons, Graham v. Florida, and Miller v. Alabama recognize the neurological difference between youth and adults. The fact that youth are still developing makes them especially capable of personal development and growth.
"The State of California recognizes this as well. State law provides youth with foster care services until age 21. It extends Division of Juvenile Justice jurisdiction until age 23. It also provides special opportunities for youth in our state prison system through age 25.
"To be clear: SB 261 is by no means a ‘free ticket’ for release. There is no mandate to a reduced sentence or release on parole, only the opportunity for a parole hearing after serving at least 15 to 25 years in state prison. Even after that period there is no guarantee for a grant of parole. The Board still has to examine each inmate’s suitability for parole, the criteria for which this bill does not change.
"SB 261 will give young adults in our prisons hope and incentive to improve their lives."
Analysis Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001608
Date of Hearing: July 8, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
SB 261
(Hancock) – As Amended June 1, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Public Safety |
Vote: |
5 - 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the youth offender parole process, a parole process for persons sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to include those who have committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23. The bill requires that those with indeterminate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing have their hearing by July 1, 2017, and those with determinate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing have their hearing by July 1, 2021, and have their consultation with the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) before July 1, 2017.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Significant one-time costs to the BPH of $1.3 million (General Fund) to complete risk assessments and conduct parole hearings for 800 inmates estimated to be eligible upon the bill’s effective date.
Significant ongoing annual costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or greater (General Fund), to conduct hearings for inmates as they become eligible. The magnitude of costs would be dependent upon the rate at which BPH conducts hearings, as there is no timeframe mandated for prospectively eligible inmates. The CDCR estimates an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to be within the BPH’s hearing cycle currently and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date, as specified.
One-time costs to BPH of about $100,000 to review and re-write regulations.
Unknown state trial court savings as a result of an accompanying reduction in writs of Habeas Corpus, by which inmates challenge convictions and/or sentences.
Potential incarceration cost savings of $0.2 to $0.5 million (General Fund) for every 20 to 50 inmates either released or having their sentences reduced. Over ten years, the savings could increase to $2 to $5 million assuming the inmates would have served ten additional years.
Minor offsetting increase in parole costs.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, "Much like the existing youth offender process, SB 261 holds young people accountable and responsible for what they did. They must serve a minimum of 15 to 25 years in prison depending on their offense, and must demonstrate remorse, maturity, and rehabilitation to be suitable for parole."
"This reflects science, law, and common sense. Recent neurological research shows that cognitive brain development continues well beyond age 18 and into early adulthood. For boys and young men in particular, this process continues into the mid-20s. The parts of the brain that are still developing during this process affect judgment and decision-making, and are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability. Recent US Supreme Court cases including Roper v. Simmons, Graham v. Florida, and Miller v. Alabama recognize the neurological difference between youth and adults. The fact that youth are still developing makes them especially capable of personal development and growth."
"The State of California recognizes this as well. State
law provides youth with foster care services until age 21. It extends
Division of Juvenile Justice jurisdiction until age 23. It also
provides special opportunities for youth in our state prison system
through age 25.
"To be clear: SB 261 is by no means a ‘free ticket’ for release. There is no mandate to a reduced sentence or release on parole, only the opportunity for a parole hearing after serving at least 15 to 25 years in state prison. Even after that period there is no guarantee for a grant of parole. The Board still has to examine each inmate’s suitability for parole, the criteria for which this bill does not change.
"SB 261 will give young adults in our prisons hope and incentive to improve their lives."
Background. Current law establishes a process for youth offender parole hearing by BPH for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. Current law sets a deadline of July 1, 2015, for BPH to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the statute that established youth offender parole hearings, SB 260 (Hancock), Chapter 312, Statutes of 2013.
This bill seeks to expand those eligible for a youth offender parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23. The rationale, as expressed by the author and supporters of this bill, is that research shows that cognitive brain development continues well beyond age 18 and into early adulthood. The parts of the brain that are still developing during this process affect judgment and decision-making, and are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability.
Argument in Support: According to the Anti-Recidivism Coalition (ARC), a sponsor of this bill, "The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) estimates there are just over 16,000 people who were between 18-22 years old at the time of their crimes and sentenced to prison terms of 15 years or more. This bill has the potential to affect a much larger population, while continuing to move toward a system of rehabilitation. There is no question that people who commit crimes should be held accountable, but punishment should also reflect an individual’s capacity for personal growth and maturity. To do otherwise disregards the potential for young adults to change and the dramatic physical and psychological differences between young people and older adults."
Argument in Opposition: According to the California District Attorneys Association, "The California Supreme Court ruled in People v. Caballero (2012) 55 Cal.4th 262, 282 that a juvenile offender sentenced to a de facto term of life imprisonment must be afforded a 'meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation.' The court additionally urged the Legislature to 'enact legislation establishing a parole mechanism that provides a defendant serving a de facto life sentence without the possibility of parole for nonhomicide crimes that he or she committed as a juvenile with the opportunity to obtain release on a showing of rehabilitation and maturity."
"The key phrase in that opinion is 'committed as a juvenile.'… We are unaware of any case law under which courts have considered someone a juvenile for an offense committed after they turned 18, but before they reached 23 years of age."
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro R. Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
SB 261
Page 6
Date of Hearing: June 30, 2015
Counsel: Stella Choe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Bill Quirk, Chair
SB 261
(Hancock) – As Amended June 1, 2015
SUMMARY:
Expands the youth offender parole process, a parole process for
persons sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed before
attaining 18 years of age, to include those who have committed their
crimes before attaining the age of 23. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that those with indeterminate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
States that those with determinate sentences who are eligible for a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2021, and shall have their consultation with the Board of Parole (BPH) before July 1, 2017.
EXISTING LAW:
Establishes a youth offender parole hearing which is a hearing by BPH for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. (Pen. Code, § 3051.)
Provides the following parole mechanism for a person who was convicted of a controlling offense that was committed before the person had attained 18 years of age:
If the controlling offense was a determinate sentence the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years;
If the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years then the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and,
If the controlling offense was a life term of 25 years to life then the person is eligible for release after 25 years. (Pen. Code, § 3051, subd. (b).)
Sets a deadline of July 1, 2015, for BPH to complete all youth offender parole hearings for individuals who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing on the effective date of the statute that established youth offender parole hearings. (Pen. Code, § 3051, subd. (i).)
Provides that in reviewing a prisoner’s suitability for parole in a youthful offender parole hearing, the BPH shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law. (Penal Code § 4801 (c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: According to the author, "Much like the existing youth offender process, SB 261 holds young people accountable and responsible for what they did. They must serve a minimum of 15 to 25 years in prison depending on their offense, and must demonstrate remorse, maturity, and rehabilitation to be suitable for parole.
"This reflects science, law, and common sense. Recent neurological research shows that cognitive brain development continues well beyond age 18 and into early adulthood. For boys and young men in particular, this process continues into the mid-20s. The parts of the brain that are still developing during this process affect judgment and decision-making, and are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability. Recent US Supreme Court cases including Roper v. Simmons, Graham v. Florida, and Miller v. Alabama recognize the neurological difference between youth and adults. The fact that youth are still developing makes them especially capable of personal development and growth.
"The State of California recognizes this as well. State
law provides youth with foster care services until age 21. It extends
Division of Juvenile Justice jurisdiction until age 23. It also
provides special opportunities for youth in our state prison system
through age 25.
"To be clear: SB 261 is by no means a ‘free ticket’ for release. There is no mandate to a reduced sentence or release on parole, only the opportunity for a parole hearing after serving at least 15 to 25 years in state prison. Even after that period there is no guarantee for a grant of parole. The Board still has to examine each inmate’s suitability for parole, the criteria for which this bill does not change.
"SB 261 will give young adults in our prisons hope and incentive
to improve their lives."
Review of Case Law: Juvenile Sentencing: In 2010, the United States Supreme Court ruled that it is unconstitutional to sentence a youth who did not commit homicide to a sentence of life without the possibility of parole (LWOP). (Graham v. Florida (2010) 130 S.Ct. 2011.) The Court discussed the fundamental differences between a juvenile and adult offender and reasserted its earlier findings from Roper v. Simmons (2005) 543 U.S. 551, that juveniles have lessened culpability than adults due to those differences. The Court stated that "life without parole is an especially harsh punishment for a juvenile,” noting that a juvenile offender “will on average serve more years and a greater percentage of his life in prison than an adult offender.” (Graham, supra, 130 S.Ct. at 2016.) However, the Court stressed that "while the Eighth Amendment forbids a State from imposing a life without parole sentence on a juvenile nonhomicide offender, it does not require the State to release that offender during his natural life. Those who commit truly horrifying crimes as juveniles may turn out to be irredeemable, and thus deserving of incarceration for the duration of their lives. The Eighth Amendment does not foreclose the possibility that persons convicted of nonhomicide crimes committed before adulthood will remain behind bars for life. It does forbid States from making the judgment at the outset that those offenders never will be fit to reenter society." (Id. at pg. 2031.)
In 2012, the California Supreme Court ruled that sentencing a juvenile offender for a non-homicide offense to a term of years with a parole eligibility date that falls outside the juvenile offender's natural life expectancy constitutes cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment. (People v. Caballero (2012) 55 Cal. 4th 262, 268.) The Court stated that "the state may not deprive [juveniles] at sentencing of a meaningful opportunity to demonstrate their rehabilitation and fitness to reenter society in the future." (Ibid.) Citing Graham, supra, the Court stated "the sentencing court must consider all mitigating circumstances attendant in the juvenile's crime and life, including but not limited to his or her chronological age at the time of the crime, whether the juvenile offender was a direct perpetrator or an aider and abettor, and his or her physical and mental development, so that it can impose a time when the juvenile offender will be able to seek parole from the parole board." (Id. at pp. 268-269.) In Caballero, the defendant was convicted of three counts of attempted murder and received a sentence of 110-years-to-life. Relying on the reasoning in the Graham case, the Court found that while the juvenile did not receive a sentence of LWOP, trial court's sentence effectively deprives the defendant of any "realistic opportunity to obtain release" from prison during his or her expected lifetime, thus the sentence is a de facto LWOP sentence and violates the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. (Id. at pg. 268.)
The court in Caballero, supra, advised that "[d]efendants who were sentenced for crimes they committed as juveniles who seek to modify life without parole or equivalent de facto sentences already imposed may file petitions for writs of habeas corpus in the trial court in order to allow the court to weigh the mitigating evidence in determining the extent of incarceration required before parole hearings." (Id. at p. 269.) The Court did not provide a precise timeframe for setting these future parole hearings, but stressed that "the sentence must not violate the defendant's Eighth Amendment rights and must provide [the defendant with] a 'meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation' under Graham's mandate." (Ibid.)
While the court in Caballero pointed out that these inmates may file petitions for writs of habeas corpus in the trial court, the court also urged the Legislature to establish a parole eligibility mechanism for an individual sentenced to a de facto life term for crimes committed as a juvenile. SB 260 (Hancock), Chapter 312, Statutes of 2013, established a parole process for inmates who were sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed when they were under the age of 18, rather than requiring the inmate to file a writ of habeas corpus and appear before the trial court for resentencing.
This bill seeks to expand those eligible for a youth offender parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23. The rationale, as expressed by the author and supporters of this bill, is that research shows that cognitive brain development continues well beyond age 18 and into early adulthood. The parts of the brain that are still developing during this process affect judgment and decision-making, and are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability. (See Johnson, et al., Adolescent Maturity and the Brain: The Promise and Pitfalls of Neuroscience Research in Adolescent Health Policy, Journal of Adolescent Health (Sept. 2009); National Institute of Mental Health, The Teen Brain: Still Under Construction (2011).)
Youth Offender Parole Hearings Status Update: According to the State's most recent status report on measures being taken to reduce the prison population pursuant to the three-judge panel's February 10, 2014 order:
"The State continues to implement Senate Bill 260 (2013), which
allows inmates whose crimes were committed as minors to appear before
the Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to demonstrate their
suitability for release after serving at least fifteen years of their
sentence. From January 1, 2014 through May 31, 2015, the Board held
664 youth offender hearings, resulting in 189 grants, 410 denials, 63
stipulations to unsuitability, and 2 split votes that required
referral to the full Board for further consideration. An additional
318 were scheduled during this time period, but were waived,
postponed, continued, or cancelled. All available inmates who were
immediately eligible for a hearing when the law took effect on
January 1, 2014 have had a hearing date or have one scheduled on or
before July 1, 2015, as required by the terms of Senate Bill 260. In
addition, all youth offenders who received a grant prior to January
1, 2014, have reached their minimum eligible parole dates and have
been processed for release from their life term by the Board."
(Defendants’ April 2015 Status Report In Response to February 10,
2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v.
Brown, Plata v. Brown.)
Argument in Support: According to the Anti-Recidivism Coalition (ARC), a sponsor of this bill, "In 2013, the Governor signed SB 260 recognizing that young people are different from adults and deserve a special consideration in the parole process. This law codified California Penal Code §3051, providing individuals who were under the age of 18 at the time of their crime and have served between 15 and 25 years in prison, the opportunity to demonstrate accountability and rehabilitation to the parole board. This law was based on the research and evidence that the brain is still developing into early adulthood, particularly in the regions of the brain affecting judgment, emotion regulation, decision-making, and long-term consequences. While pointing out the vulnerabilities that stem from this developmental stage, SB 260 also points out the unique opportunity for personal growth and rehabilitation. SB 261 makes this same recognition, while also noting that young adults are still developing neurologically and emotionally past the age of 18.
"With the passage of SB 260, motivation to focus on rehabilitation is incentivized. The ARC communicates with over 500 inmates currently incarcerated and receives calls and letters daily about the impact of this legislation. One inmate wrote, 'I never thought this bill was real until I met you guys. There are always rumors about different bills in here, but no one ever believes it. This bill has given so many of us hope for the first time since being here.' Another ARC Member, currently home on SB 260, also explains the increased safety caused by this bill, 'you don’t understand—this bill spread hope to people who had lost all. You had guys who were dropping out of gangs and enrolling into school, because now they had something to work toward.' SB 260 increases motivation to focus on rehabilitation and gives individuals a meaningful chance at parole.
"The California Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation (CDCR) estimates there are
just over 16,000 people who were between 18-22 years old at the time of their crimes and
sentenced to prison terms of 15 years or more. This bill has the potential to affect a
much larger population, while continuing to move toward a system of rehabilitation.
There is no question that people who commit crimes should be held accountable, but
punishment should also reflect an individual’s capacity for personal growth and maturity.
To do otherwise disregards the potential for young adults to change and the dramatic
physical and psychological differences between young people and older
adults."
Argument in Opposition: According to the California District Attorneys Association, "Two years ago, we opposed SB 260 (Chapter 312, Statutes of 2013), which established the youth offender parole process for individuals who were under 18 years of age at the time of their controlling offense. We renew our opposition to this bill, which seeks to expand that process to anyone under 23 at the time of their offense.
"The California Supreme Court ruled in People v.
Caballero (2012) 55 Cal.4th 262, 282 that a juvenile offender
sentenced to a de facto term of like imprisonment must be afforded a
'meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated
maturity and rehabilitation.' The court additionally urged the
Legislature to 'enact legislation establishing a parole mechanism
that provides a defendant serving a de facto life sentence without
the possibility of parole for nonhomicide crimes that he or she
committed as a juvenile with the opportunity to obtain release on a
showing of rehabilitation and maturity.
"The key
phrase in that opinion is 'committed as a juvenile.' All of the
major existing case law on juveniles who receive long sentences
(Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. __ (2012); Graham v. Florida,
560 U.S. __ (2010); and Caballero itself) involves individuals
who were under 18 at the time of their offense, and received a
lengthy prison sentence. We are unaware of any case law under which
courts have considered someone a juvenile for an offense committed
after they turned 18, but before they reached 23 years of age."
Prior Legislation:
SB 260 (Hancock), Chapter 312, Statutes of 2013, established a youth offender parole hearing which is a hearing by BPH for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his/her controlling offense.
SB 9 (Yee), Chapter 828, Statutes of 2012, authorizes a prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of committing an offense for which the prisoner was sentenced to LWOP to submit a petition for recall and resentencing to the sentencing court, and to the prosecuting agency, as specified.
SB 399 (Yee), of the 2009-10 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to SB 9. SB 399 failed passage on Assembly Floor.
SB 999 (Yee), of the 2007-08 Legislative Session, would have eliminated the LWOP sentence thus making the sentence for first-degree murder with special circumstances by a defendant under 18 years of age 25-years-to-life. SB 999 failed passage on Senate Floor.
SB 1223 (Kuehl), of the 2003-04 Legislative Session, would have authorized a court to review the sentence of a person convicted as a minor in adult criminal court and sentenced to state prison after the person has either served 10 years or attained the age of 25. SB 1223 failed passage in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Ant-Recidivism Coalition (Sponsor)
Human Rights Watch (Sponsor)
Friends Committee on Legislation of California (Co-Sponsor)
Youth Justice Coalition (Co-Sponsor)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Catholic
Conference, Inc.
Californians for Safety and Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children's Defense Fund – California
Drug Policy Alliance
Everychild Foundation
Islamic Shura
Council of Southern California
Justice Not Jails
Kehillat Israel Synagogue
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Life Support
Alliance
Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
National Center for Youth Law
National Council on Crime and Delinquency
Newt Gingrich, Former Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives
PolicyLink
Prison Law Office
Project Kinship
Public Counsel
Revolutionary Releasing
Root & Rebound
San Francisco
District Attorney's Office
Violence Prevention Coalition of
Greater Los Angeles
Youth ALIVE!
Youth Law Center
Opposition
California District Attorneys' Association
Crime Victims Action Alliance
San Diego District Attorney's Office
Analysis Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
SB 261
Page 7
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 261
Amended: 6/1/15
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/28/15
AYES: Hancock, Leno, Liu, McGuire, Monning
NOES: Anderson, Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/28/15
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, Leyva, Mendoza
NOES: Nielsen
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SUBJECT: Youth offender parole hearings
SOURCE: Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Human Rights Watch
National Center for Youth Law
DIGEST: This bill expands the youth offender parole process, a parole process for persons sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to include those who have committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23.
Existing law:
Creates the youth offender parole hearing, which is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings (Board) for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. (Penal Code § 3051)
Provides that the timing for the youth offender parole hearing depends on the sentence: if the controlling offense was a determinate sentence the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years; if the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years then the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and, if the controlling offense was 25 years or more then the person is eligible for release after 25 years. (Penal Code § 3051 (b).)
Provides that if the youth offender is found suitable for parole at the youthful offender parole hearing then the youth offender shall be released on parole. (Penal Code § 3051 (e).)
Provides that in reviewing a prisoner’s suitability for parole in a youthful offender parole hearing, the Board shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law. (Penal Code § 4801 (c).)
This bill:
Expands those eligible for a youthful parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23.
Provides that those with indeterminate sentences who are eligible for a youthful offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
Provides that those with determinate sentences who are eligible for youthful offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2021, and shall have their consultation with the Board before July 1, 2017.
Background
On April 15, 2015, the State filed its most recent status report in response to the Three-Judge panel. The report set forth the status of cases brought under SB 260 (Hancock) which created youthful offender parole hearings:
The State continues to implement Senate Bill 260 (2013), which allows inmates whose crimes were committed as minors to appear before the Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to demonstrate their suitability for release after serving at least fifteen years of their sentence. From January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2015, the Board held 534 youth offender hearings, resulting in 158 grants, 328 denials, 46 stipulations to unsuitability, and 2 split votes that required referral to the full Board for further consideration. An additional 225 were scheduled during this time period, but were waived, postponed, continued, or cancelled. All available inmates who were immediately eligible for a hearing when the law took effect on January 1, 2014, have had a hearing date or have one scheduled on or before July 1, 2015, as required by the terms of Senate Bill 260. In addition, nearly all youth offenders who received a prior to January 1, 2014, have reached their minimum eligible parole dates and have been processed for release from their life term by the Board.” (Defendants’ April 2015 Status Report In Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown).
This bill expands those eligible for a youthful parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23.
Comments
According to the author:
Science, law, and common sense support the appropriateness of SB 260 youth offender parole hearings for young adults between the age of 18 and 23.
Recent scientific evidence on adolescent and young adult development and neuroscience shows that certain areas of the brain—particularly those affecting judgment and decision-making — do not fully develop until the early - to mid-20s. Various studies by researchers from Stanford University (2009), University of Alberta (2011), and the National Institute of Mental Health (2011) all confirm that the process of brain development continues well beyond age 18.
This research has been relied on by judges and lawmakers. The US and California Supreme Courts have recognized in several recent opinions that adolescents are still developing in ways relevant to their culpability for criminal behavior and their special capacity to turn their lives around.
California already recognizes the uniqueness of young adults in its Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ). DJJ is mandated to detain and provide services and programming to some young adults until age 23. The state has recognized early adulthood as a vulnerable period in other arenas as well, for example, extending foster care support beyond age 18 to age 21 in AB 12 (Beall, 2010). As recently as 2013, the Legislature passed AB 1276 (Bloom), which provided special protections and opportunities for young adults through age 22 entering prison.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
Immediately eligible caseload: Significant one-time costs to the Board of $1.3 million (General Fund) to complete risk assessments and conduct parole hearings for 800 inmates estimated to be eligible upon this bill’s effective date.
Future caseload: Significant future annual costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or greater (General Fund), to conduct hearings for inmates as they become eligible. The magnitude of costs would be dependent upon the rate at which the Board conducts hearings, as there is no timeframe mandated for prospectively eligible inmates. The CDCR estimates an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the Board’s hearing calendar over the next several years. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to be within the Board’s hearing cycle currently and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date, as specified.
Regulations: One-time costs of about $100,000 to review and re-write regulations.
Reduced writs: Potential offset to an unknown degree by state trial court savings as a result of an accompanying reduction in writs of Habeas Corpus, by which inmates challenge convictions and/or sentences.
Future incarceration savings: Potential cost savings of $0.2 to $0.5 million (General Fund) for every 20 to 50 inmates released or sentences reduced. Savings would grow as the years they otherwise would have served compound. Over 10 years, the savings could increase to $2 to $5 million assuming the inmates would have served 10 additional years. Minor offsetting increase in parole costs.
Anti-Recidivism Coalition (co-source)
Human Rights Watch (co-source)
National Center for Youth Law (co-source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Catholic Conference
California Public Defenders Association
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Drug Policy Alliance
Everychild Foundation
Islamic Shura Council of Southern California
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Life Support Alliance
Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership
National Council on Crime & Delinquency
Newt Gingrich, former U.S. House Speaker
PolicyLink
Prison Law Office
Project Kinship
Public Counsel
Puente Project Chabot College
Revolutionary Releasing
San Francisco District Attorney George Gascón
Youth ALIVE!
Youth Law Center
Numerous individuals
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Former U.S. Speaker of the House of Representatives Newt Gingrich echoes the argument of the author and sponsors that these offenders have a capacity for growth both in his letter in support and in an editorial in the Huffington Post on April 13, 2015. He states:
It's only fair to recognize the difference between young- and full-grown adults in sentencing, just as we draw a distinction between juveniles and adults. People who commit offenses before their capacities are fully formed deserve a second chance -- an opportunity for a parole hearing if they mature, rehabilitate, and pay serious restitution to their victims and to the community.
SB 261 is compassionate, fair, and backed up by the latest scientific understanding of brain development. But it is also by no means lenient. To be eligible for a hearing, the bill would require that a young person must have served at least 15 years of his or her sentence, and even longer for more serious crimes. This is no small amount of time for young adult -- it means spending a period of potentially more than half their lives at sentencing behind bars.
If young adults demonstrate real personal growth, rehabilitation, and remorse, they should have the opportunity to be eligible for a parole hearing after spending a very long period of time in prison. The California legislature should pass SB 261 to give them this opportunity -- and other states across the country should look to it as a model for making the criminal-justice system more fair, as well as more efficient.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California District Attorneys Association opposes this bill stating:
The California Supreme Court ruled in People v. Caballero (2012) 55 Cal.4th 262, 282 that a juvenile offender sentenced to a de facto term of life imprisonment must be afforded a “meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation.” The Court additionally urged the Legislature to “enact legislation establishing a parole eligibility mechanism that provides a defendant serving a de facto life sentence without possibility of parole for non-homicide crimes that he or she committed as a juvenile with the opportunity to obtain release on a showing of rehabilitation and maturity.”
The key phrase in that opinion is “committed as a juvenile.” All of the major existing case law on juveniles who receive long sentences (Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. ____ (2012); Graham v. Florida, 560 U.S. ____ (2010); and Caballero itself) involves individuals who were under 18 at the time of their offense, and received a lengthy prison sentence. We are unaware of any case law under which courts have considered someone a juvenile for an offense committed after they turned 18, but before they reached 23 years of age.
We believe that it is wholly inappropriate to expand this expedited parole process to include individuals who were adults when they committed their offenses. This bill isn’t aimed at instances where a juvenile offender is charged as an adult – that was taken care of in SB 260. Instead, these are adults prosecuted in adult court, for very serious offenses that result in lengthy state prison commitments.
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
6/1/15 17:12:04
**** END ****
SB 261 (Hancock) Page 4 of 4
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 261 (Hancock) - Youth offender parole hearings
|
|
Version: March 24, 2015 |
Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No |
Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 28, 2015 |
Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
SUSPENSE FILE. AS AMENDED.
Bill Summary:
SB 261 would expand the youth offender parole process to include persons who committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23, as specified. This bill requires the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) to complete all parole hearings for eligible individuals as of the effective date of this measure by July 1, 2017.
Fiscal Impact (as approved May 28, 2015):
Immediately eligible caseload: Significant one-time costs to the BPH of $1.3 million (General Fund) to complete risk assessments and conduct parole hearings for 800 inmates estimated to be eligible upon the bill’s effective date.
Future caseload: Significant future annual costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or greater (General Fund), to conduct hearings for inmates as they become eligible. The magnitude of costs would be dependent upon the rate at which BPH conducts hearings, as there is no timeframe mandated for prospectively eligible inmates. The CDCR estimates an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to be within the BPH’s hearing cycle currently and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date, as specified.
Regulations: One-time costs of about $100,000 to review and re-write regulations.
Reduced writs: Potential offset to an unknown degree by state trial court savings as a result of an accompanying reduction in writs of Habeas Corpus, by which inmates challenge convictions and/or sentences.
Future incarceration savings: Potential cost savings of $0.2 to $0.5 million (General Fund) for every 20 to 50 inmates released or sentences reduced. Savings would grow as the years they otherwise would have served compound. Over ten years, the savings could increase to $2 to $5 million assuming the inmates would have served ten additional years. Minor offsetting increase in parole costs.
Background:
Existing law creates the youth offender parole hearing, which is administered by the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any inmate who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. (Penal Code (PC) § 3051.)
Existing law provides that the timing for the youth offender parole hearing is dependent on the sentence: if the controlling offense was a determinate sentence, the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years; if the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years, the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and, if the controlling offense was 25 years or more, the person is eligible for release after 25 years. (PC § 3051(b).)
Existing law provides that if the youth offender is found suitable for parole at the youthful offender parole hearing, then the youth offender shall be released on parole. (PC § 3051 (e).)
According to the CDCR April 2015 Status and Benchmark Report to the Three-Judge Court:
The State continues to implement Senate Bill 260 (2013), which allows inmates whose crimes were committed as minors to appear before the Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to demonstrate their suitability for release after serving at least fifteen years of their sentence. From January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2015, the Board held 534 youth offender hearings, resulting in 158 grants, 328 denials, 46 stipulations to unsuitability, and 2 split votes that required referral to the full Board for further consideration. An additional 225 were scheduled during this time period, but were waived, postponed, continued, or cancelled. All available inmates who were immediately eligible for a hearing when the law took effect on January 1, 2014, have had a hearing date or have one scheduled on or before July 1, 2015, as required by the terms of Senate Bill 260. In addition, nearly all youth offenders who received a grant prior to January 1, 2014, have reached their minimum eligible parole dates and have been processed for release from their life term by the Board.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend the existing parole process for persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 23 years of age, as specified. This bill provides that those eligible for a youthful offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
Prior Legislation:
SB 260 (Hancock) Chapter 312/2013 established a parole process for persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age.
AB 1276 (Bloom) Chapter 590/2014 requires the CDCR to conduct a youth offender Institutional Classification Committee (ICC) review at reception to provide special classification consideration for every youth offender.
SB 9 (Yee) Chapter 828/2012 authorizes a person who was under 18 years of age at the time of committing an offense for which the person was sentenced to LWOP to submit a petition for recall and re-sentencing to the sentencing court, as specified.
SB 1223 (Kuehl) 2004 would have authorized a court to review and suspend or reduce the sentence of a person convicted as a minor in adult criminal court and sentenced to state prison after the person has either served 10 years in prison or attained the age of 25. This bill was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
The CDCR has indicated one-time near term costs of approximately $4.6 million assuming approximately 800 inmates would immediately be eligible for a parole hearing. The CDCR estimates that an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. The BPH would be required to give these inmates a consultation about five years prior to their initial parole hearing. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to already be within the BPH’s hearing cycle and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date based on the requirement for the BPH to give “great weight” to the factors of youth, their growth and maturity since the crime.
Components of the one-time $4.6 million cost for the 800 immediately eligible inmates:
Risk Assessments: The BPH would need to complete 800 comprehensive risk assessments for the backlog of hearings over the course of eight months at an estimated cost of $2.7 million.
Interpreters: Minor costs of less than $40,000 to provide this service for a small percentage of the 800 hearings.
Transcripts: At an average cost of $570 per hearing, and assuming 10 percent of the 800 cases will be postponed or continued, transcription services would cost approximately $400,000.
State-appointed counsel: The BPH is required to provide each inmate with counsel. State-appointed attorneys receive $400 per hearing. For 800 hearings, the cost would be $320,000.
Commissioners and Deputy Commissioners: To handle an additional 100 hearings per month, it is estimated the BPH would require additional resources at a cost of about $1.1 million.
Attorney III: To dedicate one staff, for six months, to review each possible youth offender scheduled for a hearing for eligibility as a youth offender and to respond to inmate counsel on individual cases in which the inmate’s status as a youth offender is in question. In many cases, determining eligibility requires the BPH to obtain birth certificates and additional court sentencing documents. The BPH would, therefore, request funding for six months to handle this additional workload at a cost of $85,000.
CDCR indicates this bill would create substantial ongoing workload due to the increase in consultations the BPH would be required to conduct and additional hearings added to the BPH hearing calendar in the future as a result. Other ongoing costs would include increases in processing inmate petitions to advance hearing dates, conducting administrative reviews to advance hearing dates, and correctional counselor duties for parole hearings. Finally, the BPH and CDCR indicate the need to modify existing automation systems to process offenders under the provisions of this bill. While the total costs could not be quantified at the time of this analysis, they would likely be substantial.
The costs of this measure would be offset in whole or in part by potentially significant future costs savings to the extent a number of offenders are granted parole and released as a result of this measure, resulting in reduced incarceration costs that otherwise would have been incurred under existing law.
Author amendments (as adopted May 28, 2015):
Extend the time period within which parole hearings may be completed for individuals sentenced to determinate terms to July 1, 2021.
Require BPH to conduct the consultation by July 1, 2017, for all individuals sentenced to determinate terms and who become entitled to have their parole suitability considered at a youth offender parole hearing.
-- END --
SB 261 (Hancock) Page 4 of 4
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 261 (Hancock) - Youth offender parole hearings
|
|
Version: March 24, 2015 |
Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No |
Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 11, 2015 |
Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 261 would expand the youth offender parole process to include persons who committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23, as specified. This bill requires the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) to complete all parole hearings for eligible individuals as of the effective date of this measure by July 1, 2017.
Fiscal Impact:
Immediately eligible caseload: Major one-time costs to the BPH of $4.6 million (General Fund) to complete risk assessments and conduct parole hearings by July 1, 2017, for 800 inmates estimated to be eligible upon the bill’s effective date.
Future caseload: Significant future annual costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars or greater (General Fund), to conduct hearings for inmates as they become eligible. The magnitude of costs would be dependent upon the rate at which BPH conducts hearings, as there is no timeframe mandated for prospectively eligible inmates. The CDCR estimates an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to be within the BPH’s hearing cycle currently and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date, as specified.
Regulations: One-time costs of about $100,000 to review and re-write regulations.
Reduced writs: Potential offset to an unknown degree by state trial court savings as a result of an accompanying reduction in writs of Habeas Corpus, by which inmates challenge convictions and/or sentences.
Future incarceration savings: Potential cost savings of $0.2 to $0.5 million (General Fund) for every 20 to 50 inmates released or sentences reduced. Savings would grow as the years they otherwise would have served compound. Over ten years, the savings could increase to $2 to $5 million assuming the inmates would have served ten additional years. Minor offsetting increase in parole costs.
Background:
Existing law creates the youth offender parole hearing, which is administered by the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any inmate who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. (Penal Code (PC) § 3051.)
Existing law provides that the timing for the youth offender parole hearing is dependent on the sentence: if the controlling offense was a determinate sentence, the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years; if the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years, the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and, if the controlling offense was 25 years or more, the person is eligible for release after 25 years. (PC § 3051(b).)
Existing law provides that if the youth offender is found suitable for parole at the youthful offender parole hearing, then the youth offender shall be released on parole. (PC § 3051 (e).)
According to the CDCR April 2015 Status and Benchmark Report to the Three-Judge Court:
The State continues to implement Senate Bill 260 (2013), which allows inmates whose crimes were committed as minors to appear before the Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to demonstrate their suitability for release after serving at least fifteen years of their sentence. From January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2015, the Board held 534 youth offender hearings, resulting in 158 grants, 328 denials, 46 stipulations to unsuitability, and 2 split votes that required referral to the full Board for further consideration. An additional 225 were scheduled during this time period, but were waived, postponed, continued, or cancelled. All available inmates who were immediately eligible for a hearing when the law took effect on January 1, 2014, have had a hearing date or have one scheduled on or before July 1, 2015, as required by the terms of Senate Bill 260. In addition, nearly all youth offenders who received a grant prior to January 1, 2014, have reached their minimum eligible parole dates and have been processed for release from their life term by the Board.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend the existing parole process for persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 23 years of age, as specified. This bill provides that those eligible for a youthful offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
Prior Legislation:
SB 260 (Hancock) Chapter 312/2013 established a parole process for persons sentenced to prison for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age.
AB 1276 (Bloom) Chapter 590/2014 requires the CDCR to conduct a youth offender Institutional Classification Committee (ICC) review at reception to provide special classification consideration for every youth offender.
SB 9 (Yee) Chapter 828/2012 authorizes a person who was under 18 years of age at the time of committing an offense for which the person was sentenced to LWOP to submit a petition for recall and re-sentencing to the sentencing court, as specified.
SB 1223 (Kuehl) 2004 would have authorized a court to review and suspend or reduce the sentence of a person convicted as a minor in adult criminal court and sentenced to state prison after the person has either served 10 years in prison or attained the age of 25. This bill was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
The CDCR has indicated one-time near term costs of approximately $4.6 million assuming approximately 800 inmates would immediately be eligible for a parole hearing. The CDCR estimates that an additional 5,600 inmates would be added to the BPH’s hearing calendar over the next several years. The BPH would be required to give these inmates a consultation about five years prior to their initial parole hearing. An additional 3,000 inmates are estimated to already be within the BPH’s hearing cycle and would be eligible to request to advance their next hearing date based on the requirement for the BPH to give “great weight” to the factors of youth, their growth and maturity since the crime.
Components of the one-time $4.6 million cost for the 800 immediately eligible inmates:
Risk Assessments: The BPH would need to complete 800 comprehensive risk assessments for the backlog of hearings over the course of eight months at an estimated cost of $2.7 million.
Interpreters: Minor costs of less than $40,000 to provide this service for a small percentage of the 800 hearings.
Transcripts: At an average cost of $570 per hearing, and assuming 10 percent of the 800 cases will be postponed or continued, transcription services would cost approximately $400,000.
State-appointed counsel: The BPH is required to provide each inmate with counsel. State-appointed attorneys receive $400 per hearing. For 800 hearings, the cost would be $320,000.
Commissioners and Deputy Commissioners: To handle an additional 100 hearings per month, it is estimated the BPH would require additional resources at a cost of about $1.1 million.
Attorney III: To dedicate one staff, for six months, to review each possible youth offender scheduled for a hearing for eligibility as a youth offender and to respond to inmate counsel on individual cases in which the inmate’s status as a youth offender is in question. In many cases, determining eligibility requires the BPH to obtain birth certificates and additional court sentencing documents. The BPH would, therefore, request funding for six months to handle this additional workload at a cost of $85,000.
CDCR indicates this bill would create substantial ongoing workload due to the increase in consultations the BPH would be required to conduct and additional hearings added to the BPH hearing calendar in the future as a result. Other ongoing costs would include increases in processing inmate petitions to advance hearing dates, conducting administrative reviews to advance hearing dates, and correctional counselor duties for parole hearings. Finally, the BPH and CDCR indicate the need to modify existing automation systems to process offenders under the provisions of this bill. While the total costs could not be quantified at the time of this analysis, they would likely be substantial.
The costs of this measure would be offset in whole or in part by potentially significant future costs savings to the extent a number of offenders are granted parole and released as a result of this measure, resulting in reduced incarceration costs that otherwise would have been incurred under existing law.
-- END --
SB 261 (Hancock ) Page 6 of 6
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 261 Hearing Date: April 28, 2015
Author: |
Hancock |
||
Version: |
March 24, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
MK |
||
Subject: Youth Offender Parole Hearings
HISTORY
Source: Human Rights Watch
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Youth Justice Coalition
Prior Legislation: SB 260 (Hancock) - Chapter 312, Stats. 2013
Support: Newt Gingrich; San Francisco District Attorney’s Office; California Catholic Conference, Inc.; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; The California Public Defenders Association; Life Support Alliance; The Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership; Islamic Shura Council of Southern California; National Compadres Network; Public Counsel; Project Kinship; Youth Law Center; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice; Taxpayers for Improving Public Safety; Post-Conviction Justice Project; Office of Restorative Justice
Opposition: California District Attorneys Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to expand the youth offender parole process, a parole process for persons sentenced to lengthy prison terms for crimes committed before attaining 18 years of age, to include those who have committed their crimes before attaining the age of 23.
Existing law creates the youth offender parole hearing which is a hearing by the Board of Parole Hearings for the purpose of reviewing the parole suitability of any prisoner who was under 18 years of age at the time of his or her controlling offense. (Penal Code § 3051)
Existing law provides that the timing for the youth offender parole hearing depends on the sentence: if the controlling offense was a determinate sentence the offender shall be eligible for release after 15 years; if the controlling offense was a life term less than 25 years then the person is eligible for release after 20 years; and, if the controlling offense was 25 years or more then the person is eligible for release after 25 years. (Penal Code § 3051 (b).)
Existing law provides that if the youth offender is found suitable for parole at the youthful offender parole hearing then the youth offender shall be released on parole. (Penal Code § 3051 (e).)
Existing law provides that in reviewing a prisoner’s suitability for parole in a youthful offender parole hearing, the Board of Parole Hearings shall give great weight to the diminished culpability of juveniles as compared to adults, the hallmark features of youth, and any subsequent growth and increased maturity of the prisoner in accordance with relevant case law. (Penal Code § 4801 (c).)
This bill expands those eligible for a youthful parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23.
This bill provides that those eligible for a youthful offender parole hearing on the effective date of this bill shall have their hearing by July 1, 2017.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past eight years, this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In February of this year the administration reported that as “of February 11, 2015, 112,993 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.6% of design bed capacity, and 8,828 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. This current population is now below the court-ordered reduction to 137.5% of design bed capacity.”( Defendants’ February 2015 Status Report In Response To February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state now must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Science, law, and common sense support the appropriateness of SB 260 youth offender parole hearings for young adults between the age of 18 and 23.
Recent scientific evidence on adolescent and young adult development and neuroscience shows that certain areas of the brain—particularly those affecting judgment and decision-making — do not fully develop until the early - to mid-20s. Various studies by researchers from Stanford University (2009), University of Alberta (2011), and the National Institute of Mental Health (2011) all confirm that the process of brain development continues well beyond age 18.
This research has been relied on by judges and lawmakers. The US and California Supreme Courts have recognized in several recent opinions that adolescents are still developing in ways relevant to their culpability for criminal behavior and their special capacity to turn their lives around.1
California already recognizes the uniqueness of young adults in its Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ). DJJ is mandated to detain and provide services and programming to some young adults until age 23. The state has recognized early adulthood as a vulnerable period in other arenas as well, for example, extending foster care support beyond age 18 to age 21 in AB 12 (Beall, 2010). As recently as 2013, the Legislature passed AB 1276 (Bloom), which provided special protections and opportunities for young adults through age 22 entering prison.
2. Youthful Offender Parole Hearings
On April 15, 2015 the State filed its most recent status report in response to the Three-Judge panel. The report set forth the status of cases brought under SB 260 (Hancock) which created youthful offender parole hearings:
The State continues to implement Senate Bill 260 (2013), which allows inmates whose crimes were committed as minors to appear before the Board of Parole Hearings (the Board) to demonstrate their suitability for release after serving at least fifteen years of their sentence. From January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2015, the Board held 534 youth offender hearings, resulting in 158 grants, 328 denials, 46 stipulations to unsuitability, and 2 split votes that required referral to the full Board for further consideration. An additional 225 were scheduled during this time period, but were waived, postponed, continued, or cancelled. All available inmates who were immediately eligible for a hearing when the law took effect on January 1, 2014, have had a hearing date or have one scheduled on or before July 1, 2015, as required by the terms of Senate Bill 260. In addition, nearly all youth offenders who received a prior to January 1, 2014, have reached their minimum eligible parole dates and have been processed for release from their life term by the Board.” (Defendants’ April 2015 Status Report In Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown).
3. Crimes Committed Before The Offender Was 23
This bill expands those eligible for a youthful parole hearing to those whose committing offense occurred before they reached the age of 23.
Human Rights Watch, the co-sponsors of this bill, argues that:
Neuro-scientific research finds that the process of cognitive brain development continues into early adulthood — well beyond the age 18. For boys and young men especially this development process continues into the mid-20s. The still-developing areas of the brain, particularly those that affect judgment and decision-making, are highly relevant to criminal behavior and culpability.
Supporter National Center for Youth Law further argues this point stating:
The latest scientific evidence on adolescent development supports justification for SB 261. Research shows that certain areas of the brain, in particularly those that affect judgment and decision-making, do not fully develop until the early 20’s. This is confirmed in studies by Stanford University (2009), University of Alberta (2011), and the National Institute of Mental Health (2011). The Fact that young adults are still developing means they are uniquely situated for personal growth. SB 261 would continue the SB 260 trend towards reflecting the latest scientific evidence on young adult development by recognizing that young adults who were under the age of 23 at the time of their crime have an especially strong ability to grow.
Former US Speaker of the House of Representatives Newt Gingrich echoes the argument that these offenders have a capacity for growth both in his letter in support and in an editorial in the Huffington Post on April 13, 2015. He states:
It's only fair to recognize the difference between young- and full-grown adults in sentencing, just as we draw a distinction between juveniles and adults. People who commit offenses before their capacities are fully formed deserve a second chance -- an opportunity for a parole hearing if they mature, rehabilitate, and pay serious restitution to their victims and to the community.
SB 261 is compassionate, fair, and backed up by the latest scientific understanding of brain development. But it is also by no means lenient. To be eligible for a hearing, the bill would require that a young person must have served at least 15 years of his or her sentence, and even longer for more serious crimes. This is no small amount of time for young adult -- it means spending a period of potentially more than half their lives at sentencing behind bars.
If young adults demonstrate real personal growth, rehabilitation, and remorse, they should have the opportunity to be eligible for a parole hearing after spending a very long period of time in prison. The California legislature should pass SB 261 to give them this opportunity -- and other states across the country should look to it as a model for making the criminal-justice system more fair, as well as more efficient.
The District of San Francisco has also recognized that these young offenders are not quite juveniles but not adults. In his support of this bill he states:
In the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office, our Alternative Sentencing Planner — the first of its kind in the nation — takes a deep look at our cases to understand the risks and needs of the individual defendants. One theme that has emerged in this work is the difficulty of developing appropriate case dispositions for young adults, who have one leg in adolescence and one in adulthood. These young men and women are disproportionately represented in our adult justice system — and often fare poorly in that system, which lacks developmentally responsive interventions. As a result, I and other local criminal justice leaders have begun the essential work of developing a Young Adult Court that will handle criminal cases for individuals ages 18-25. We recognize that in many ways our current criminal system is not well suited to this unique age group and that we must implement reforms to improve outcomes for both the individuals themselves and the safety of our communities.
Even though arguably the neurological development continues to age 25 or beyond, the author expands youthful parole hearings in this bill to the age of 23 because that is the age in which a person can remain in the Youth Authority in California.
4. Opposition
The California District Attorneys Association opposes this bill stating:
The California Supreme Court ruled in People v. Caballero (2012) 55 Cal.4th 262, 282 that a juvenile offender sentenced to a de facto term of life imprisonment must be afforded a “meaningful opportunity to obtain release based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation.” The Court additionally urged the Legislature to “enact legislation establishing a parole eligibility mechanism that provides a defendant serving a de facto life sentence without possibility of parole for non-homicide crimes that he or she committed as a juvenile with the opportunity to obtain release on a showing of rehabilitation and maturity.”
The key phrase in that opinion is “committed as a juvenile.” All of the major existing case law on juveniles who receive long sentences (Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. ____ (2012); Graham v. Florida, 560 U.S. ____ (2010); and Caballero itself) involves individuals who were under 18 at the time of their offense, and received a lengthy prison sentence. We are unaware of any case law under which courts have considered someone a juvenile for an offense committed after they turned 18, but before they reached 23 years of age.
We believe that it is wholly inappropriate to expand this expedited parole process to include individuals who were adults when they committed their offenses. This bill isn’t aimed at instances where a juvenile offender is charged as an adult – that was taken care of in SB 260. Instead, these are adults prosecuted in adult court, for very serious offenses that result in lengthy state prison commitments.
-- END –
1 See: Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551, 569 (2005); Miller v. Alabama, 567 US __ (2012); People v. Caballero, 55 Cal. 4th 262 (Cal. 2012); People v. Gutierrez, 58 Cal. 4th 1354 (Cal. 2014).
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):