SB 262: Unmanned aircraft systems: law enforcement use.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-20
Existing federal law, the Federal Aviation Administration Modernization and Reform Act of 2012, provides for the integration of civil unmanned aircraft systems, commonly known as drones, into the national airspace system by September 30, 2015. Existing federal law requires the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration to develop and implement operational and certification requirements for the operation of public unmanned aircraft systems in the national airspace system by December 31, 2015.
Existing state law generally regulates the use of surveillance technology by a law enforcement agency.
This bill would specifically authorize a law enforcement agency to use an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with certain conditions, including, among others, protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution, federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency, and state law applicable to a law enforcement agencys use of surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system. The bill would prohibit a law enforcement agency from using an unmanned aircraft system to conduct surveillance of private property unless the law enforcement agency has obtained a search warrant, the person or entity with the legal authority to grant access to the private property grants the law enforcement agency permission to access the property, or an exigent circumstance exists. The bill would define law enforcement agency and unmanned aircraft system for these purposes. The bill would also make related findings and declarations.
Existing federal law, the Federal Aviation Administration Modernization and Reform Act of 2012, provides for the integration of civil unmanned aircraft systems, commonly known as drones, into the national airspace system by September 30, 2015. Existing federal law requires the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration to develop and implement operational and certification requirements for the operation of public unmanned aircraft systems in the national airspace system by December 31, 2015.
Existing state law generally regulates the use of surveillance technology by a law enforcement agency.
This bill would specifically authorize a law enforcement agency to use an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution, federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency, and state law applicable to a law enforcement agencys use of surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system. The bill would define law enforcement agency and unmanned aircraft system for these purposes. The bill would also make related findings and declarations.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Federal Aviation Administration currently conducts a comprehensive operational and technical review of all public agency applications to operate an unmanned aircraft system. Law enforcement agencies that wish to operate an unmanned aircraft system can do so only after receiving a certificate of authorization or waiver from the Federal Aviation Administration.
(b)Technological advancements and the utilization of new technologies are essential in supporting law enforcement agencies missions of preventing and fighting crime.
(c)The responsible use of unmanned aircraft systems by law enforcement agencies is both an efficient and effective use of emerging technology.
(d)A law enforcement agencys ability to share information acquired through the use of technology attached to unmanned aircraft systems is directly related to the professions ability to solve crimes.
(e)The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects against unreasonable searches by law enforcement agencies, including searches conducted with advanced technologies.
SEC. 2.Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11470) is added to Title 1 of Part 4 of the Penal Code, to read:4.Unmanned Aircraft Systems11470.(a)A law enforcement agency may use an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with all of the following:
(1)Protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
(2)Federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency, including, but not limited to, regulations of the Federal Aviation Administration.
(3)State law applicable to a law enforcement agencys use of surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system, including, but not limited to, Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 630) of Title 15 of Part 1.
(4)The law enforcement agency has received approval from its local governing body to use an unmanned aircraft system.
(5)The law enforcement agency has created a written policy on the use of an unmanned aircraft system and has trained the individuals using the unmanned aircraft system on the policy.
(b)A law enforcement agency shall not use an unmanned aircraft system to conduct surveillance of private property unless any of the following apply:
(1)The law enforcement agency has obtained a search warrant.
(2)The person or entity with the legal authority to grant access to the private property grants the law enforcement agency written consent to access the property.
(3)An exigent circumstance exists.
(b)
(c)For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Law enforcement agency means the police or sheriffs department of a city, county, or city and county.
(2)Unmanned aircraft means an aircraft that is operated without the possibility of direct human intervention from within or on the aircraft.
(3)Unmanned aircraft system means an unmanned aircraft and associated elements, including, but not limited to, communication links and the components that control the unmanned aircraft that are required for the pilot in command to operate safely and efficiently in the national airspace system.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Federal Aviation Administration currently conducts a comprehensive operational and technical review of all public agency applications to operate an unmanned aircraft system. Law enforcement agencies that wish to operate an unmanned aircraft system can do so only after receiving a certificate of authorization or waiver from the Federal Aviation Administration.
(b)Technological advancements and the utilization of new technologies are essential in supporting law enforcement agencies missions of preventing and fighting crime.
(c)The responsible use of unmanned aircraft systems by law enforcement agencies is both an efficient and effective use of emerging technology.
(d)A law enforcement agencys ability to share information acquired through the use of technology attached to unmanned aircraft systems is directly related to the professions ability to solve crimes.
(e)The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects against unreasonable searches by law enforcement agencies, including searches conducted with advanced technologies.
SEC. 2.Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 11470) is added to Title 1 of Part 4 of the Penal Code, to read:4.Unmanned Aircraft Systems11470.(a)A law enforcement agency may use an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with all of the following:
(1)Protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
(2)Federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency, including, but not limited to, regulations of the Federal Aviation Administration.
(3)State law applicable to a law enforcement agencys use of surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system, including, but not limited to, Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 630) of Title 15 of Part 1.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Law enforcement agency means the police or sheriffs department of a city, county, or city and county.
(2)Unmanned aircraft means an aircraft that is operated without the possibility of direct human intervention from within or on the aircraft.
(3)Unmanned aircraft system means an unmanned aircraft and associated elements, including, but not limited to, communication links and the components that control the unmanned aircraft that are required for the pilot in command to operate safely and efficiently in the national airspace system.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 12, 2015 | May 12 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 1, 2015 | Set for hearing May 12. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | May 5 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 24, 2015 | Set for hearing May 5. |
| Apr 20, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 15, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 594.) (April 14). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 10, 2015 | Set for hearing April 14. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and JUD. |
| Feb 19, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 18, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 14, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 262 (Galgiani)
Page 11 of 11
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 262 (Galgiani)
Version: April 20, 2015
Hearing Date: May 12, 2015
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
TH
SUBJECT
Unmanned Aircraft Systems: Law Enforcement Use
DESCRIPTION
This bill would authorize law enforcement agencies to use unmanned aircraft systems provided such use complies with certain conditions, including: search and seizure protections in the U.S. and California Constitutions; federal law applicable to unmanned aircraft systems; and state law applicable to law enforcement agency use of surveillance technology. This bill would also require law enforcement agencies to receive approval from their local governing body prior to using unmanned aircraft systems, and would restrict the use of such systems for conducting surveillance of private property.
BACKGROUND
The development of small unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) – known variously as “unmanned aerial vehicles,” “remote piloted aircraft,” or simply “drones” – promises to transform the way Californians interact with each other and their environment. Just a few decades ago, small aircraft of this type were the exclusive domain of hobbyists. Within the last decade or so, the public has become familiar with the military’s use of unmanned aircraft to accomplish certain mission objectives. However, in December 2013 when Amazon.com, FedEx, and UPS announced their plans to integrate unmanned aircraft into their logistics and delivery services, the possibility of widespread adoption of this technology became clear.
Along with a variety of businesses, law enforcement agencies across the country are also starting to look at how to leverage unmanned aerial vehicle technology. According to one report:
As drones become cheaper and more capable, more police departments across the country are asking for and getting federal approval to use them for law enforcement. But the Federal Aviation Administration only takes safety into consideration when it grants a law enforcement agency approval to use drones, leaving privacy protections to legislation—which, depending on the state in question, may or may not exist. Agencies as large as the Michigan State Police and as small as the Grand Forks County [N.D.] Sheriff's Department have received FAA approval to use drones. Most departments use them for missions like search-and-rescue or for photographing a crime scene or an accident site. But unless a law enforcement agency is within one of the 14 states that have passed privacy legislation limiting how police can use drones, there's little in theory keeping it from using a drone for a less innocuous end—such as surveillance without a warrant. (Kaveh Waddell, Few Privacy Limitations Exist on How Police Use Drones, National Journal (Feb. 5, 2105) <http://www.nationaljournal.com/tech/few-privacy-limitations-exist-on-how-police-use-drones-20150205> [as of May 6, 2015].)
At present, the use of unmanned aerial vehicles of any kind in the skies over California is fairly restricted. Congress effectively closed the national airspace to commercial drone use in the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Modernization and Reform Act of 2012.1 That Act established a framework for safely integrating unmanned aircraft into the national airspace no later than September 30, 2015. The Act does, however, permit certain commercial unmanned aircraft operations to take place before the integration framework is implemented. Section 333 of the Act authorizes the Secretary of Transportation to establish special interim requirements for the operation of these aircraft by designated operators, provided the aircraft and their operators meet certain minimum standards and have applied for a commercial use exemption. To date, a handful of commercial operators have applied for, and received, permission to fly commercial drones, including several film production companies, construction, surveying, and inspection companies, and a number of real estate firms. The Act also sets out a separate interim operation exemption for “public unmanned aircraft,” allowing public agencies like police departments to operate drones upon application, provided the aircraft and their operators meet certain minimum standards.2 According to recent media reports, several California law enforcement agencies and other public entities have acquired drones, but very few – if any – have put them into service.
This bill would authorize a law enforcement agency to use unmanned aircraft systems in California, provided the agency complies with protections against unreasonable search and seizures guaranteed by the California and federal constitutions, federal law pertaining to UAS operation, and state law pertaining to law enforcement use of surveillance technology. This bill would require a law enforcement agency to receive approval from its local governing body, and to create written policies governing UAS use and employee training, before using UAS technology. This bill would also prohibit law enforcement agency use of UAS technology for conducting surveillance of private property unless the agency has obtained a search warrant or written permission from the affected landowner, or in the case of exigent circumstances.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the California Constitution, provides that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. (Cal. Const, art. I, Sec. 1.)
Existing federal and state law provide that the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. (U.S. Const., 4th Amend.; Cal. Const, art. I, Sec. 13.)
Existing federal law provides that the Federal Aviation Administration shall regulate aircraft operations conducted in the national airspace, including unmanned aircraft operations. (49 U.S.C. Sec. 40103; 49 U.S.C. Sec. 40102(a)(6).)
Existing law makes it a crime for any person to intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device, eavesdrop upon or records the confidential communication, whether the communication is carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone, or other device. (Pen. Code Sec. 632.)
Existing law provides that any person who trespasses on property for the purpose of committing any act, or attempting to commit any act, in violation of the above provision shall be punished by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year or in the state prison, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Pen. Code Sec. 634.)
Existing law provides that no person or entity in this state shall use an electronic tracking device to determine the location or movement of a person, but also provides that this section shall not apply to the lawful use of an electronic tracking device by a law enforcement agency. (Pen. Code Sec. 637.7.)
This bill would state that a law enforcement agency may use an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with all of the following:
protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution;
federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency, including, but not limited to, regulations of the Federal Aviation Administration; and
state law applicable to a law enforcement agency’s use of surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system, including, but not limited to, Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 630) of Title 15 of Part 1 of the Penal Code.
This bill would provide that before a law enforcement agency may use an unmanned aircraft system, it must first:
receive approval from its local governing body to use an unmanned aircraft system; and
create a written policy on the use of an unmanned aircraft system and has trained the individuals using the unmanned aircraft system on the policy.
This bill would specify that a law enforcement agency shall not use an unmanned aircraft system to conduct surveillance of private property unless any of the following apply:
the law enforcement agency has obtained a search warrant;
the person or entity with the legal authority to grant access to the private property grants the law enforcement agency written consent to access the property; or
an exigent circumstance exists.
COMMENT
Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
This legislation simply applies what is currently required by the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution to the use of unmanned aircraft. This allows for the utilization of plausible vantage points, in compliance with the Fourth Amendment. SB 262 applies privacy regulations that are currently applied to manned aircraft to unmanned aircraft. Because public property is the quintessential “plausible vantage point,” an observation of evidence that could have been seen from a public place is not a search, and therefore should not require a warrant. Also, [this bill] will require approval of a local legislative body prior [to] the use of a UAS. The local body will also be required to create policies and training regarding the use of a drone.
Last year, Assembly Bill 1327 (2014) required the acquisition of a warrant for UAS use over both public and private land in most instances. This bill, however, was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message, Governor Brown stated that although there are undoubtedly circumstances where a warrant is appropriate, the bill’s exceptions appear to be too narrow and could impose requirements beyond what is required by either the 4th Amendment or the privacy provisions in the California Constitution.
A search warrant for the use of electronic aerial visual surveillance, enabled by an unmanned or manned aircraft, is not required if an aircraft or UAS is flown in accordance with FAA regulations and the aircraft or UAS is not flown in a physically intrusive manner. The test as to whether or not a warrant is required is if officers utilized technology that merely permitted them to see things they could have seen from a plausible vantage point, although less clearly and with somewhat more effort. Nor is a warrant . . . required merely because a surveillance device was “sophisticated” or technologically complex.
Fundamental Right to Privacy
The California Constitution provides that all people have inalienable rights, including the right to pursue and obtain privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I, Sec. 1.) This “right of privacy is vitally important. It derives, in this state, not only from the protections against unreasonable searches and seizures guaranteed by the Fourth Amendment and article I, section 13, but also from article I, section 1, of our State Constitution. Homage to personhood is the foundation for individual rights protected by our state and national Constitutions.” (In re William G. (1985) 40 Cal.3d 550, 563.) Because of their inherent maneuverability and the ease with which they may enter spaces infeasible for manned aircraft, the growth of unmanned aerial vehicle technology presents a challenge to maintaining traditional boundaries that separate public and private spheres, and to preserving the fundamental right to privacy in California.
California’s constitutional right to privacy restricts the government and others from infringing upon legally protected privacy interests of California residents. The California Supreme Court has found that “[l]egally recognized privacy interests are generally of two classes: (1) interests in precluding the dissemination or misuse of sensitive and confidential information (informational privacy); and (2) interests in making intimate personal decisions or conducting personal activities without observation, intrusion, or interference (autonomy privacy). (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35 [internal quotation marks omitted].) The latter of these – informational privacy – is “the core value” furthered by the constitutional right of privacy. (Id.) “A particular class of information is private when well-established social norms recognize the need to maximize individual control over its dissemination and use to prevent unjustified embarrassment or indignity. Such norms create a threshold reasonable expectation of privacy in the data at issue.” (Id.) The Court has held that “the usual sources of positive law governing the right to privacy -- common law development, constitutional development, [and] statutory enactment”-- illuminate “[w]hether established social norms safeguard a particular type of information . . . from public or private intervention.” (Id. at 36.)
Recent Fourth Amendment jurisprudence strongly suggests that information subject to collection by unmanned aircraft operated by law enforcement agencies, such as locational information and surveillance data, falls within the class of information safeguarded by established social norms. In United States v. Jones (2012) 132 S. Ct. 945, for example, the U.S. Supreme Court examined the significant privacy concerns raised by locational tracking technology. The Jones case considered whether the attachment of a Global Positioning System (GPS) tracking device to an individual’s vehicle, and the subsequent use of that device to track the vehicle’s movements on public streets, constituted a search within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment. In her concurring opinion, Justice Sotomayor made the following observations:
Awareness that the Government may be watching chills associational and expressive freedoms. And the Government’s unrestrained power to assemble data that reveal private aspects of identity is susceptible to abuse. The net result is that GPS monitoring--by making available at a relatively low cost such a substantial quantum of intimate information about any person whom the Government, in its unfettered discretion, chooses to track--may alter the relationship between citizen and government in a way that is inimical to democratic society.
I would take these attributes of GPS monitoring into account when considering the existence of a reasonable societal expectation of privacy in the sum of one's public movements. I would ask whether people reasonably expect that their movements will be recorded and aggregated in a manner that enables the Government to ascertain, more or less at will, their political and religious beliefs, sexual habits, and so on. (United States v. Jones (2012) 132 S. Ct. 945, 955-956 [internal citations and quotation marks omitted].)
Use of unmanned aircraft to track the location of individuals and gather surveillance data is arguably more invasive than GPS tracking of a vehicle’s movements on public streets. Unlike GPS tracking, unmanned aircraft can collect data on a wide range of individuals at the same time, and in areas far removed from public streets. As the Electronic Frontier Foundation notes in its opposition letter:
Small, surreptitious drones can have significant surveillance capacity and can collect data not only about law enforcement targets, but also other persons in a potentially large area, ranging from the drone flight path to crowds at lawful protests. Such expansive surveillance must be justified to a court on a probable cause standard and carefully cabined in order to protect non-targets from unjustified surveillance.
Similarly, the American Civil Liberties Union of California (ACLU), in opposition, notes that “because they are small, quiet, maneuverable, and capable of remaining airborne for long periods, drones allow for surreptitious surveillance that has never before been achievable. This new type of data collection raises privacy concerns not only for the target of the search, but also for third parties who may be impacted by the operation of drones.”
This bill seeks to provide some regulation of unmanned aircraft system (UAS) use by law enforcement, stating that such use must comply with California and federal search and seizure requirements as well as Penal Code provisions related to specific forms of electronic monitoring. However, these provisions alone may not give law enforcement agencies guidance to ensure that the use of UAS technology does not violate the constitutional right to privacy. As the ACLU notes:
[this] bill states only that law enforcement must comply with the state and federal constitutions, federal law, regarding the use of unmanned aircraft systems, and state law regarding surveillance technology. This statement is unnecessary and unhelpful. Police are of course already required to conduct searches in accordance with constitutional requirements, and otherwise comply with federal and state law.
Unfortunately, this bill leaves unanswered many important policy questions regarding drone use that go beyond mere compliance with existing law. What protections, for example, should be put in place to ensure the privacy of bystanders who are monitored because of their proximity to an intended surveillance target? What additional protections are needed to ensure that law enforcement use of UAS technology on or near private property does not violate the fundamental right to privacy? Should law enforcement use of drones be authorized only for specific purposes? Should the weaponization of drones be permitted? What kind of public oversight should be put in place to ensure that drones are used in a manner that respects civil liberties?
The addition of “privacy” to the list of unalienable rights in the California Constitution “was intended to strengthen the right of privacy, “and “[t]he elevation of the right to be free from invasions of privacy to constitutional stature was apparently intended to be an expansion of the [existing] privacy right.” (Cent. Valley Ch. 7th Step Found. v. Younger (Cal.App.1st Dist. 1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 145, 160.) “[The] principal ‘mischiefs’ at which the amendment is directed are: (1) ‘government snooping’ and the secret gathering of personal information; (2) the overbroad collection and retention of unnecessary personal information by government and business interests; (3) the improper use of information properly obtained for a specific purpose, for example, the use of it for another purpose or the disclosure of it to some third party; and (4) the lack of a reasonable check on the accuracy of existing records.” (Id.) The policy question for this Committee to consider is, without more, does this bill provide enough guidance to law enforcement agencies to avoid the “mischiefs” the privacy amendment sought to curtail?
Data Use and Security
As discussed in Comment 2, the type of information collected through the use of an unmanned aircraft system (UAS) could be highly sensitive. For example, locational data gathered by a UAS, especially over time, can be used to determine the owner’s political and religious beliefs, known associates, frequented places, and even their medical conditions. Other recent bills regulating law enforcement’s use of surveillance technologies considered by this Committee have included provisions addressing security and operational protocols to ensure that collected data remains confidential and is protected from unauthorized access or use. (See e.g. Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of Sen. Bill No. 34 (2015–2016 Reg. Sess.) as introduced, [for hearing on Apr. 14, 2015].) However, the bill does not impose any direct requirements to ensure that collected data is protected from misuse or data breach, or that the permissible use of collected data is restricted by appropriate safeguards to ensure respect for individual privacy and civil liberties.
Insufficient data security and use protocols for UAS collected information may risk infringing upon an individual’s constitutional right to privacy in much the same way as improper “front-end” collection practices. Under this bill, law enforcement agencies will be confronted with determining such things as what purposes images, footage, or data obtained through the use of a UAS should be used for, whether this information should be used for purposes other than that for which they were originally collected, and whether it should be shared with other public and private entities. Similarly, law enforcement agencies will have to determine how such information should be protected from misuse or improper access, whether this information should be subject to set retention periods, and who should have access to it. The policy question for this Committee to consider is whether the Legislature ought to provide more direct guidance to law enforcement agencies faced with these critical issues of data security and privacy protection.
Support: Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs; Association of Deputy District Attorneys; California Association of Code Enforcement Officers; California College and University Police Chiefs Association; California Correctional Supervisors Organization; California District Attorneys Association; California Narcotic Officers Association; California Peace Officers’ Association; California State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police; CSAC Excess Insurance Authority; Long Beach Police Officers Association; Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association; Los Angeles Police Protective League; Riverside Sheriffs Association; Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association; Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Opposition: American Civil Liberties Union of California; Electronic Frontier Foundation; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
HISTORY
Source: California Police Chiefs Association
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 170 (Gaines, 2015) would provide that a person who knowingly and intentionally operates an unmanned aircraft system below “navigable airspace,” as defined in federal law, overlaying a state prison is guilty of a misdemeanor, except as specified. This bill would also double existing fines and penalties for unlawfully using an unmanned aircraft system to deliver contraband to, or communicate with, an inmate of a prison or jail. This bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 142 (Jackson, 2015) would clarify that the operation of an unmanned aerial vehicle below the navigable airspace overlying the property of another, or less than 350 feet above the property of another, without permission constitutes trespass. This bill would also provide that using such a vehicle in trespass to capture images or recordings of individuals engaged in personal or familial activities constitutes physical invasion of privacy. This bill is awaiting referral in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 271 (Gaines, 2015) would make it an infraction to operate an unmanned aircraft on or above the grounds of a public school providing instruction in kindergarten or grades 1 to 12 during school hours and without permission of school officials. This bill would exempt specified media and news personnel unless they receive a request from school officials to cease using an unmanned aircraft above a school, and would also exempt law enforcement. This bill is pending on the Senate Floor.
AB 14 (Waldron, 2015) would create the Unmanned Aircraft Systems Task Force, which would be required to research, develop, and formulate a comprehensive policy for unmanned aircraft systems in California. The task force would be required to submit, among other things, a policy draft and suggested legislation pertaining to unmanned aircraft systems to the Legislature and the Governor on or before January 1, 2018. This bill is pending reconsideration in the Assembly Transportation Committee.
AB 56 (Quirk, 2015) would prohibit public agencies from using unmanned aircraft systems, or contracting for the use of these systems, with certain exceptions for law enforcement agencies acting pursuant to a warrant and in certain other cases, including when the use or operation of the unmanned aircraft system achieves the core mission of the agency and the purpose for use is unrelated to the gathering of criminal intelligence. The bill would also require notice by public agencies intending to deploy unmanned aircraft, would require images, footage, or data obtained through the use of such aircraft to be permanently destroyed within one year except as specified, and would prohibit equipping unmanned aircraft with weapons. This bill is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1327 (Gorell, 2014) would have prohibited public agencies from using unmanned aircraft systems, or contracting for the use of these systems, with certain exceptions for law enforcement agencies acting pursuant to a warrant and in certain other cases, including when the use or operation of the unmanned aircraft system achieves the core mission of the agency and the purpose of use is unrelated to the gathering of criminal intelligence. The bill would have also required notice by public agencies intending to deploy unmanned aircraft, would have required images, footage, or data obtained through the use of such aircraft to be permanently destroyed within one year except as specified, and would have prohibited equipping unmanned aircraft with weapons. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 15 (Padilla, 2013) would have, among other things, required law enforcement agencies to obtain search warrants when using unmanned aircraft, and would have required that an application for the search warrant specify the intended purpose for which the unmanned aircraft would be used. The bill would have also restricted data collection by unmanned aircraft and would have prohibited equipping unmanned aircraft with weapons. This bill died in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
AB 1524 (Waldron, 2013) would have required any entity that owns or operates an unmanned aircraft to place identifying information or digitally store identifying information on the aircraft. The bill would have exempted model aircraft, and would have made a person or entity that violates its provisions liable for a civil fine not to exceed $2,500. This bill was set for hearing in the Assembly Transportation Committee, but the hearing was cancelled at the author’s request.
Prior Vote: Senate Public Safety Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 1)
**************
1 H.R. 658, 112th Congress (2011-2012). In general, the FAA is tasked with regulating aircraft operations conducted in the national airspace under 49 U.S.C. Sec. 40103. This authority extends to unmanned aircraft operations, which, by definition, are considered to be “aircraft.” (See 49 U.S.C. Sec. 40102(a)(6), which defines an “aircraft” as “any contrivance invented, used, or designed to navigate, or fly in, the air.”)
2 See Section 334 of the FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012.
SB 262 (Galgiani ) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 262 Hearing Date: April 14, 2015
Author: |
Galgiani |
||
Version: |
February 18, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
MK |
||
Subject: Unmanned Aircraft Systems: Law Enforcement Use
HISTORY
Source: California Police Chiefs Association
Prior Legislation: SB 15 (Padilla) failed Assembly Public Safety 2014
AB 1327 (Gorell) Vetoed 2014
Support: California District Attorneys Association; California Peace Officers Association; Peace Officers Research Association
Opposition: None known
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to allow a law enforcement agency to use an unmanned aircraft system if the agency complies with: (1) protections against unreasonable searches and seizures; (2) Federal Law applicable to the use of unmanned aircraft systems; and, (3) state law applicable to the use of surveillance technology.
Existing federal law, the Aviation Administration Modernization and Reform Act of 2012 requires the Secretary of Transportation to develop a comprehensive plan to safely accelerate the integration of civil unmanned aircraft systems into the national airspace system. The plan is required to provide for safe integration of civil unmanned aircraft systems into national airspace as soon as practicable, not later than September 30, 2015. (112 P.L. 95, 332.)
Existing law authorizes the Attorney General, chief deputy attorney general, chief assistant attorney general, district attorney or the district attorney’s designee to apply to the presiding judge of the superior court for an order authorizing the interception of wire or electronic communications under specified circumstances. (Penal Code §§ 629.50 et. seq.)
Existing law prohibits wiretapping or eavesdropping on confidential communications. (Penal Code § 630.)
Existing law makes it a crime for a person, intentionally, and without requisite consent, to eavesdrop on a confidential communication by means of any electronic amplifying or recording device. (Penal Code § 632.)
Existing law exempts the Attorney General, any district attorney, specified peace officers such as city police and county sheriffs, and a person acting under the direction of an exempt agency from the prohibitions against wiretapping and other related activities to the extent that they may overhear or record any communication that they were lawfully authorized to overhear or record prior to the enactment of the prohibitions. Existing law provides that any evidence so obtained is admissible in any judicial, administrative, or legislative proceeding. (Penal Code § 633.)
The US Constitution provides that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.” (4th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.)
The California Constitution provides that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects against unreasonable seizures and searches may not be violated; and a warrant may not issue except on probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons and things to be seized.” (Article I, Section 13 of the California Constitution.)
Existing law defines a “search warrant” as an order in writing in the name of the People, signed by a magistrate, directed to a peace officer, commanding him or her to search for a person or persons, a thing or things, or personal property, and in the case of a thing or things or personal property, bring the same before the magistrate. (Penal Code § 1523.)
Existing law permits a search warrant to be issued for any of the following grounds:
When the property subject to search was stolen or embezzled;
When property or things were used as the means to commit a felony;
When the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered;
When the property or things to be seized consist of any item or constitute any evidence that tends to show a felony has been committed, or tends to show that a particular person has committed a felony;
When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show that sexual exploitation of a child or possession of matter depicting sexual conduct of a person under the age of 18 years has occurred or is occurring;
When there is a warrant to arrest a person;
When a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence, as specified, showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing their discovery;
When the property or things to be seized include an item or any evidence that tends to show a violation of a specified section of the Labor Code, or tends to show that a particular person has violated that section;
When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon at the scene of, or at the premises occupied or under the control of the person arrested in connection with, a domestic violence incident involving a threat to human life or a physical assault, as specified;
When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, specified persons;
When the property or things to be seized include a firearm that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person who is subject to the prohibitions regarding firearms, as specified, if a prohibited firearm is possessed, owned, in the custody of, or controlled by a person against whom a specified protective order has been issued, the person has been lawfully served with that order, and the person has failed to relinquish the firearm as required by law; or when the person is subject tot a gun violence restraining order,
When the information to be received from the use of a tracking device constitutes evidence that tends to show that either a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code has been committed or is being committed, tends to show that a particular person has committed a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code, or is committing a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code, or will assist in locating an individual who has committed or is committing a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code; and
When a sample of the blood of a person constitutes evidence of a DUI. (Penal Code §1524(a).)
This bill provides that a law enforcement agency may an unmanned aircraft system if the use of the unmanned aircraft system complies with all the following:
Protections against unreasonable searches guaranteed by the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
Federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by law enforcement agency, including but not limited to, regulations of the Federal Aviation Administration.
State Law applicable to a law enforcement agency’s use surveillance technology that can be attached to an unmanned aircraft system.
This bill defines law enforcement agency as the police or sheriff’s department of a city, county or city and county.
This bill defines unmanned aircraft as an aircraft that is operated without the possibility of direct human intervention from within or on the aircraft.
This bill defines unmanned aircraft system as an unmanned aircraft and associated elements, including, but not limited to, communication links and the components that control the unmanned aircraft that are required for the pilot in command to operate safely and efficiently in the national airspace system.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past eight years, this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In February of this year the administration reported that as “of February 11, 2015, 112,993 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.6% of design bed capacity, and 8,828 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. This current population is now below the court-ordered reduction to 137.5% of design bed capacity.”( Defendants’ February 2015 Status Report In Response To February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state now must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
As the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) prepares to open the skies to regulated public and private use of unmanned aircraft systems, clear guidelines for law enforcement use of this new technology is absolutely imperative.
The FAA has jurisdiction over specific policy requirements of the operation of both unmanned and manned aircraft. The FAA recently issued proposed unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) regulations for public review. It would be preemptive and confusing to propose legislation that could potentially conflict with the upcoming FAA regulations for the public use of unmanned aircraft systems. Thus, this legislation addresses broad privacy concerns and the responsible use of unmanned aircraft systems by law enforcement in respect to the privacy of our state’s citizens without creating policy that could conflict with future FAA regulations.
This legislation simply applies what is currently required by the Fourth Amendment (U.S. Constitution) to the use of unmanned aircraft. This allows for the utilization of plausible vantage points, in compliance with the Fourth Amendment. SB 262 apples privacy regulations that are currently applied to manned aircraft to unmanned aircraft.
AB 1327 required the acquisition of a warrant for the use of unmanned aircraft systems over both public and private land in most instances. Because public property is the quintessential “plausible vantage point,” an observation of evidence that could have been seen from a public place is not a search, and therefore should not require a warrant. A search warrant for the use of electronic aerial visual surveillance, enabled by an unmanned or manned aircraft is not required if an aircraft or UAS is flown in accordance with FAA regulations and the aircraft or UAS in not flown in a physically intrusive manner. The test to whether or not a warrant is required if the officers utilized technology that merely permitted them to see things they could have seen from a plausible vantage point, although less clearly and with somewhat more effort. Nor is a warrant required merely because a surveillance device was “sophisticated” or technologically complex.
2. Unmanned Aircraft Systems
This bill would use the term “unmanned aircraft systems,” as defined, to reference what are commonly known as drones. That term, also used by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), would be defined to include the unmanned aircraft itself (the drone) and the associated elements (which include the components that control the aircraft). Regarding the types of aircraft that may be considered unmanned aircraft systems, the FAA’s fact sheet notes:
Unmanned Aircraft Systems (UAS) come in a variety of shapes and sizes and serve diverse purposes. They may have a wingspan as large as a Boeing 737 or smaller than a radio-controlled model airplane. Regardless of size, the responsibility to fly safely applies equally to manned and unmanned aircraft operations.
Because they are inherently different from manned aircraft, introducing UAS into the nation’s airspace is challenging for both the FAA and aviation community. UAS must be integrated into a National Airspace System (NAS) that is evolving from ground-based navigation aids to a GPS-based system in NextGen. Safe integration of UAS involves gaining a better understanding of operational issues, such as training requirements, operational specifications and technology considerations.
3. Fourth Amendment
Both the United States and the California constitutions guarantee the right of all persons to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures. (U.S. Const., amend. IV; Cal. Const., art. 1, sec. 13.) This protection applies to all unreasonable government intrusions into legitimate expectations of privacy. (United States v. Chadwick (1977) 433 U.S. 1, 7, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo (1991) 500 U.S. 565.) In general, a search is not valid unless it is conducted pursuant to a warrant where a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy. The mere reasonableness of a search, assessed in light of the surrounding circumstances, is not a substitute for the warrant required by the Constitution. (Arkansas v. Sanders (1979) 442 U.S. 753, 758, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo, supra.) There are exceptions to the warrant requirement, but the burden of establishing an exception is on the party seeking one. [Arkansas v. Sanders (1979) 442 U.S. 753, 760, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo, supra.]
4. Use of Unmanned Aircraft System by Law Enforcement
This bill would permit a police or sheriff’s department to use an unmanned aircraft system (drone) if they comply with all of the following:
Protections against unreasonable search and seizures;
Federal law applicable to the use of an unmanned aircraft system by a law enforcement agency; and
State law applicable to a law enforcement agency’s use of surveillance technology.`
The sponsor states that this bill:
[W]ould allow law enforcement agencies to utilize and deploy new life-saving technology while respecting the privacy of California citizens.
5. Use of Drones on Public Property
The author’s statement talks about a warrant not being necessary for a “plausible vantage point.” While this is true, are drones the same as a police car driving by or a person watching from a window across the street or a helicopter flying overhead? If technology were such that a drone could be small enough to hover over a street corner amongst the trees and watch what is going on below, is that the same as a police officer walking or driving by? Is a quiet drone flying over a yard the same as a helicopter flying overhead? Does the fact that a drone can fly lower than a helicopter or airplane differentiate it from a helicopter?
6. Approval of Legislative Body?
This bill permits a police or sheriff’s department to use a drone without an specific requirement that the local governing agency approve the use. In 2013, in Alameda County, the sheriff attempted to request funding for a drone. Ultimately, public backlash and concern led to the sheriff to abandon his pursuit of the drones. (Woodall, War on terror money funding drones, surveillance in the Bay Area, Oakland Tribune (April 7, 2013).) More recently, the Berkeley City Council passed a one year moratorium on the use of drones by their police department, while still allowing the fire department to use drones. (Shuttlesworth, Jeff, Berkeley Bans Police Drones for One Year SFbay.ca February 25, 2015) Two drones acquired by LAPD were “grounded” until the Police commission approves a policy for their use. (Palmer and Mester, LAPD’s Two Drones Will Remain Grounded During Policy Review, Police Commission Says Among Protest, KTLA 5 News, September 15, 2014)
Should this bill require approval by the appropriate legislative body before a police or sheriff’s department acquires or uses a drone?
7. Policy and Training
This bill allows a police or sheriff’s department to use a drone without requiring that the department creates a policy on the use of a drone. Should the bill require a policy be established before drones are used? A policy should include when the drone is to be used; what is to be done with the data that is collected, including how long it will be stored and how a member of the public can get access to the data and any limits that are to be placed on the use of the drone. As noted in the previous comment, LAPD is already in the process of crafting policies for the use of their drones. “Having rules in place may not be much comfort to the person who looks up from his backyard and sees an LAPD drone overhead. But it could, at least, ensure that the devices are used to fight crime, not to spy or harass. “(Newton, Jim Drones and the LAPD Los Angeles Times, November 16, 2014
Should the bill also require those who are to be using the drones to be trained in the policies adopted by the agency? If an agency must adopt a policy before using a drone it may make sense to require those charged with operating the drone to be trained in the policy.
8. Weapons
Drones have the capability of being armed with weapons, lethal and nonlethal. The United States has used armed drones to target militants in military operations abroad. (Christopher Drew, Drones Are Weapons of Choice in Fighting Qaeda, New York Times (Mar. 17, 2009).) Domestically, there has been a push by some law enforcement agencies to arm drones to fire rubber bullets and tear gas. (See Drones over US to get weaponized – so far, non-lethally, RT.com (May 24, 2012).) Should this bill prohibit the weaponization of drones or should that be part of the policies established locally?
9. Other Similar Bills
AB 56 (Quirk) prohibits the use of a drone by a public agency, including a law enforcement agency, unless under specified circumstances including with a warrant; in an emergency where there is a threat to life; by a first responder to a traffic accident; to check for wilderness fires; and, to determine appropriate response to a disaster. This bill is very similar to AB 1327 (Gorell) which was vetoed last year. AB 56 (Quirk) is scheduled for a hearing in Assembly Public Safety on April 14th.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):