SB 346: Health facilities: community benefits.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-23
Existing law makes certain findings and declarations regarding the social obligation of private nonprofit hospitals to provide community benefits in the public interest, and requires these hospitals, among other responsibilities, to adopt and update a community benefits plan for providing community benefits either alone, in conjunction with other health care providers, or through other organizational arrangements. Existing law requires each private nonprofit hospital, as defined, to complete a community needs assessment, as defined, and to thereafter update the community needs assessment at least once every 3 years. Existing law also requires the hospital to file a report on its community benefits plan and the activities undertaken to address community needs with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development. Existing law requires the statewide office to make the plans available to the public. Existing law requires that each hospital include in its community benefits plan measurable objectives and specific benefits.
This bill would declare the necessity of establishing uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits a facility provides to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment, among other findings and declarations.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, as defined, to provide community benefits to the public by allocating a specified percentage of the economic value of community benefits to charity health care, as defined, and community building activities, as specified. The bill would, by January 1, 2018, require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic to develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, as established, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community. The bill would also require these entities, prior to completing the needs assessment, to develop a community benefits statement and a description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, as specified. The bill would authorize the hospital or clinic to create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input. This bill would require the hospital or clinic to make available to the public a copy of the assessment, file the assessment with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, and update the assessment at least every 3 years.
This bill would also require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, by April 1, 2018, to develop a community benefits plan that includes a summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan, and list the services, as provided, that the hospital or clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The bill would require the hospital or clinic to make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan or community health plan available to the public on its Internet Web site and would require that a copy of the assessment and plan be given free of charge to any person upon request.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, after April 1, 2018, every 2 years to annually submit a community benefits plan to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, as specified, and would allow a hospital or clinic under the common control of a single corporation or other entity to file a consolidated plan, as provided. The bill would require that the governing board of each hospital or clinic adopt the community benefits plan and make it available to the public, as specified.
This bill would make the existing law described above inoperative, and would make the new provisions described above operative, upon the certification by the Director of Statewide Health Planning and Development of the adoption of regulations that prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans, as provided. This bill would subsequently repeal the existing law described above. This The bill would require the office to develop and adopt those regulations, regulations by January 1, 2017, to provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics exempt from licensure comply with the community benefits provisions, to make public each community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans, to maintain a public calendar of community benefit plan adoption meetings, and to calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by hospitals, as specified. This bill would authorize the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development to assess a civil penalty, as provided, against any hospital or clinic that fails to comply with these provisions. This bill would make conforming changes.
Existing law makes certain findings and declarations regarding the social obligation of private nonprofit hospitals to provide community benefits in the public interest, and requires these hospitals, among other responsibilities, to adopt and update a community benefits plan for providing community benefits either alone, in conjunction with other health care providers, or through other organizational arrangements. Existing law requires each private nonprofit hospital, as defined, to complete a community needs assessment, as defined, and to thereafter update the community needs assessment at least once every 3 years. Existing law also requires the hospital to file a report on its community benefits plan and the activities undertaken to address community needs with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development. Existing law requires the statewide office to make the plans available to the public. Existing law requires that each hospital include in its community benefits plan measurable objectives and specific benefits.
This bill would declare the necessity of establishing uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits a facility provides to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment, among other findings and declarations.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, as defined, to provide community benefits to the public by allocating available a specified percentage of the economic value of community benefit moneys benefits to charity health care, as defined, and community building activities, as specified. The bill would, by January 1, 2018, require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic to develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, as established, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community. The bill would also require these entities, prior to completing the needs assessment, to develop a community benefits statement and a description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, as specified. The bill would authorize the hospital or clinic to create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input. This bill would require the hospital or clinic to make available to the public a copy of the assessment, file the assessment with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, and update the assessment at least every 3 years.
This bill would also require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, by April 1, 2018, to develop a community benefits plan that includes a summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan, and list the services, as provided, that the hospital or clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The bill would require the hospital or clinic to make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan or community health plan available to the public on its Internet Web site and would require that a copy of the assessment and plan be given free of charge to any person upon request.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, after April 1, 2018, every 2 years to submit a community benefits plan to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, as specified, and would allow a hospital or clinic under the common control of a single corporation or other entity to file a consolidated plan, as provided. The bill would require that the governing board of each hospital or clinic adopt the community benefits plan and make it available to the public, as specified.
This bill would require the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development to develop and adopt make the existing law described above inoperative, and would make the new provisions described above operative, upon the certification by the Director of Statewide Health Planning and Development of the adoption of regulations to that prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans, as provided, provided. This bill would subsequently repeal the existing law described above. This bill would require the office to develop and adopt those regulations, to provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics exempt from licensure comply with the community benefits provisions, to make public each community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans, to maintain a public calendar of community benefit plan adoption meetings, and to calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by hospitals, as specified. This bill would authorize the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development to assess a civil penalty, as provided, against any hospital or clinic that fails to comply with these provisions. This bill would make conforming changes.
Existing law makes certain findings and declarations regarding the social obligation of private nonprofit hospitals to provide community benefits in the public interest, and requires these hospitals, among other responsibilities, to adopt and update a community benefits plan for providing community benefits either alone, in conjunction with other health care providers, or through other organizational arrangements. Existing law requires each private nonprofit hospital, as defined, to complete a community needs assessment, as defined, and to thereafter update the community needs assessment at least once every 3 years. Existing law also requires the hospital to file a report on its community benefits plan and the activities undertaken to address community needs with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development. Existing law requires the statewide office to make the plans available to the public. Existing law requires that each hospital include in its community benefits plan measurable objectives and specific benefits.
This bill would declare the necessity of establishing uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits a facility provides to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment, among other findings and declarations.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, as defined, to provide community benefits to the public by allocating available community benefit moneys to charity health care, as defined, and community building activities, as specified. The bill would, by January 1, 2018, require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic to develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, as established, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community. The bill would also require these entities, prior to completing the needs assessment, to develop a community benefits statement and a description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, as specified. The bill would authorize the hospital or clinic to create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input. This bill would require the hospital or clinic to make available to the public a copy of the assessment, file the assessment with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, and update the assessment at least every 3 years.
This bill would also require a private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic, by April 1, 2018, to develop a community benefits plan that includes a summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan, and list the services, as provided, that the hospital or clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The bill would require the hospital or clinic to make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan or community health plan available to the public on its Internet Web site and would require that a copy of the assessment and plan be given free of charge to any person upon request.
This bill would require a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, after April 1, 2018, every 2 years to submit a community benefits plan to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, as specified, and would allow a hospital or clinic under the common control of a single corporation or other entity to file a consolidated plan, as provided. The bill would require that the governing board of each hospital or clinic adopt the community benefits plan and make it available to the public, as specified.
This bill would require the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development to develop and adopt regulations to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans, as provided, to provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics exempt from licensure comply with the community benefits provisions, to make public each community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans, to maintain a public calendar of community benefit plan adoption meetings, and to calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by hospitals, as specified. This bill would authorize the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development to assess a civil penalty, as provided, against any hospital or clinic that fails to comply with these provisions. This bill would make conforming changes.
(a)Every health facility licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2, except a health facility owned and operated by the state, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(b)Commencing in calendar year 2004, every freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic, as defined in Section 128700, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(c)The fee structure shall be established each year by the office to produce revenues equal to the appropriation made in the annual Budget Act or another statute to pay for the functions required to be performed by the office pursuant to this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), Article 2 (commencing with Section 127340) of Chapter 2, or Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, and to pay for any other health-related programs administered by the office. The fee shall be due on July 1 and delinquent on July 31 of each year.
(d)The fee for a health facility that is not a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(e)The fee for a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(f)The fee for a freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic shall be established at an amount equal to the number of ambulatory surgery data records submitted to the office pursuant to Section 128737 for encounters in the preceding calendar year multiplied by not more than fifty cents ($0.50).
(g)There is hereby established the California Health Data and Planning Fund within the office for the purpose of receiving and expending fee revenues collected pursuant to this chapter.
(h)Any amounts raised by the collection of the special fees provided for by subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) that are not required to meet appropriations in the Budget Act for the current fiscal year shall remain in the California Health Data and Planning Fund and shall be available to the office in succeeding years when appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act or another statute, for expenditure under the provisions of this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), Article 2 (commencing with Section 127430) of Chapter 2, and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, or for any other health-related programs administered by the office, and shall reduce the amount of the special fees that the office is authorized to establish and charge.
(i)(1)No health facility liable for the payment of fees required by this section shall be issued a license or have an existing license renewed unless the fees are paid. A new, previously unlicensed, health facility shall be charged a pro rata fee to be established by the office during the first year of operation.
(2)The license of any health facility, against which the fees required by this section are charged, shall be revoked, after notice and hearing, if it is determined by the office that the fees required were not paid within the time prescribed by subdivision (c).
(j)This section is inoperative as of the date of the written certification required by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 127487, and is repealed on January 1 of the year after the year in which it becomes inoperative.
SEC. 2.Section 127280 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:127280.(a)Every health facility licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2, except a health facility owned and operated by the state, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(b)Commencing in calendar year 2004, every freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic, as defined in Section 128700, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(c)The fee structure shall be established each year by the office to produce revenues equal to the appropriation made in the annual Budget Act or another statute to pay for the functions required to be performed by the office pursuant to this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), or Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, and to pay for any other health-related programs administered by the office. The fee shall be due on July 1 and delinquent on July 31 of each year.
(d)The fee for a health facility that is not a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(e)The fee for a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(f)The fee for a freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic shall be established at an amount equal to the number of ambulatory surgery data records submitted to the office pursuant to Section 128737 for encounters in the preceding calendar year multiplied by not more than fifty cents ($0.50).
(g)There is hereby established the California Health Data and Planning Fund within the office for the purpose of receiving and expending fee revenues collected pursuant to this chapter.
(h)Any amounts raised by the collection of the special fees provided for by subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) that are not required to meet appropriations in the Budget Act for the current fiscal year shall remain in the California Health Data and Planning Fund and shall be available to the office in succeeding years when appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act or another statute, for expenditure under the provisions of this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, or for any other health-related programs administered by the office, and shall reduce the amount of the special fees that the office is authorized to establish and charge.
(i)(1) No health facility liable for the payment of fees required by this section shall be issued a license or have an existing license renewed unless the fees are paid. A new, previously unlicensed, health facility shall be charged a pro rata fee to be established by the office during the first year of operation.
(2)The license of any health facility, against which the fees required by this section are charged, shall be revoked, after notice and hearing, if it is determined by the office that the fees required were not paid within the time prescribed by subdivision (c).
(j)This section shall be operative on the date of the written certification required by subdivision (a) of Section 127487.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 127361 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 127360, to read:127361.This article is inoperative as of the date of the written certification required by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 127487, and is repealed on January 1 of the year after the year in which it becomes inoperative.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470) is added to Part 2 of Division 107 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:2.6.Community Benefits1.Hospital Community Benefits127470.(a)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)Access to health care services is of vital concern to the people of California.
(2)Health care providers play an important role in providing essential health care services in the communities they serve.
(3)Notwithstanding public and private efforts to increase access to health care, the people of California continue to have significant unmet health needs. Studies indicate that as many as 6.9 million Californians are uninsured during a year.
(4)The state has a substantial interest in ensuring that the unmet health needs of its residents are addressed. Health care providers can help address these needs by providing charity care and community benefits to the uninsured and underinsured members of their communities.
(5)Hospitals have different roles in the community depending on their mission, governance, tax status, and articles of incorporation. Private hospitals that are investor owned and have for-profit tax status pay property taxes, corporate income taxes, and other taxes, such as unemployment insurance, on a different basis than nonprofit, district, or public hospitals. Nonprofit health facilities, including hospitals and multispecialty clinics, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, receive favorable tax treatment by the government and, in exchange, assume a social obligation to provide charity care and other community benefits in the public interest.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this chapter to provide uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits provided to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and multispecialty clinics operated by nonprofit corporations, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment.
127472.The following definitions apply for the purposes of this chapter:
(a)Community means the service area or patient population for which a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic provides health care services. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall create a health equity assessment based on the key factors relating to health and mental health disparities and inequities described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and may not define its service area to exclude vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, medically underserved, low-income, or minority populations who are part of its patient populations, live in geographic areas in which its patient populations reside, otherwise should be included based on the method the hospital facility uses to define its community, or populations described in subdivision (l).
(b)(1)Community benefits means the unreimbursed goods, services, activities, programs, and other resources provided by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that addresses community-identified health needs and concerns, and health disparities related to its healthy equity assessment, particularly for people who are uninsured, underserved, or members of a vulnerable population. Community benefits include, but are not limited to, charity care, shortfalls in all of the following:
(A)Charity care.
(B)Shortfalls in Medi-Cal, California Childrens Services Program, or county indigent programs at cost up to 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations, the organizations.
(C)The cost of community building activities, the activities for vulnerable populations.
(D)The cost of community health improvement services and community benefit operations, the operations.
(E)The cost of school health centers, as defined in Section 124174, the 124174.
(F)The cost of health professions education and training provided without charge to community members or participants, amounts participants.
(G)Amounts given, with no expectation of reimbursement or repayment, to employees from, or working among, a vulnerable population, for the purpose of satisfying or paying off, in full or in part, preemployment student educational loan obligations, subsidized obligations.
(H)Subsidized health services for vulnerable populations, research, and contributions to community groups, vaccination programs and services for low-income families, chronic populations.
(I)Vaccination programs.
(J)Chronic illness prevention programs and services, home-based services for vulnerable populations.
(K)Home-based health care programs for low-income families, or community-based vulnerable populations.
(L)Community-based mental health and outreach, the key factors described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and assessment programs for vulnerable populations.
(M)Outreach and assessment programs for low-income families. For purposes of this subdivision, low-income families means families or individuals with income less than or equal to 350 percent of the federal poverty level. vulnerable populations.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, community building activities means the cost of various kinds of community building activities, including physical improvements and housing, economic development, community support, environmental improvements, community health improvement advocacy, coalition building, workforce development, the key factors described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and leadership development and training for community members.
(3)(A)For purposes of this subdivision, charity care means the unreimbursed cost to a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic of providing services to the uninsured or underinsured, as well as providing health care services or items on an inpatient or outpatient basis to a financially qualified patient, as defined in Section 127400, with no expectation of payment.
(B)Charity care does not include any of the following:
(i)Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt.
(ii)Care provided to patients for which a public program or public or private grant funds pay for any of the charges for the care.
(iii)Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or chargemaster rates by the health care provider.
(iv)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis.
(v)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(vi)The cost to a nonprofit hospital of paying a tax or other governmental assessment.
(4)Community benefits does not include any of the following:
(A)The unreimbursed cost of providing services to those enrolled in Medicare or county indigent programs or any goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources program or activity for which there is direct offsetting revenue.
(B)Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt.
(C)Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or chargemaster rates by the health care provider.
(D)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis.
(E)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(c)(1)Community benefits planning committee means a committee, designated by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, that oversees the community needs assessment and the development of the community benefits plan implementation strategy to meet the community health needs identified through the community health needs assessment.
(2)The community benefits planning committee shall be composed of the following:
(A)One of the following:
(i)The governing board of the hospital organization that operates the hospital facility or a committee or other party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(ii)If the hospital facility has its own governing body and is recognized as an entity under state law but is a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes, the governing body of that hospital facility or other committee or party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(B)At least one individual from the local, tribal, or regional governmental public health department, or an equivalent department or agency, with knowledge, information, or expertise relevant to the health needs of that community.
(C)At least one individual from an underserved and vulnerable population.
(d)Discounted care means the cost for medical care provided consistent with Article 1 (commencing with Section 127400) of Chapter 2.5.
(e)
(d)(1)Direct offsetting revenue means revenue from goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources that offsets the total community benefit expense of the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources.
(2)Direct offsetting revenue includes revenue generated by the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, including, but not limited to, payment or reimbursement for services provided to program patients as well as restricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit, such as a restricted grant to provide financial assistance or fund research.
(3)Direct offsetting revenue does not include unrestricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit, nor payments for Medi-Cal, the California Childrens Services Program, or county indigent programs.
(f)
(e)Nonprofit multispecialty clinic means a clinic as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206.
(g)
(f)Office means the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development.
(h)
(g)Private nonprofit hospital means a private nonprofit acute care hospital operated or controlled by a nonprofit corporation, as defined in Section 5046 of the Corporations Code, that has been determined to be exempt from taxation under the Internal Revenue Code. For purposes of this chapter, private nonprofit hospital does not include any of the following:
(1)A district hospital organized and governed pursuant to the Local Health Care District Law (Division 23 (commencing with Section 32000)) or a nonprofit corporation that is affiliated with the health care district hospital owner by means of the districts status as the nonprofit corporations sole corporate member pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 14169.31 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(2)A rural general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 1250.
(3)A childrens hospital, as defined in Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)A multispecialty clinic operated by a for-profit hospital, regardless of its net revenue.
(i)
(h)Underserved population or vulnerable population means any of the following:
(1)A population that is exposed to medical or financial risk by virtue of being uninsured, underinsured, or eligible for Medi-Cal or a county indigent program.
(A)Uninsured means a self-pay patient as defined in Section 127400.
(B)Underinsured means a patient with high medical costs, as defined in Section 127400.
(2)A population, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)A vulnerable community, as defined by Section 131019.5.
(B)Individuals with low educational attainment as measured by the percentage of the population over 25 years of age with less than a high school diploma.
(C)Individuals who suffer from linguistic isolation as measured by the percentage of households in which no one who is 14 years of age or older speaks English with greater than elementary proficiency.
(2)Individuals below 400 percent of the federal poverty level, unless the hospital serves a county in which the county has adopted an ordinance to provide financial assistance for health care to individuals with incomes above 400 percent of the federal poverty level, in which case the income threshold for the vulnerable population shall be the income threshold adopted by the county.
(3)Individuals with limited English proficiency.
(3)
(4)A population that meets the definition of disadvantaged community pursuant to Section 39711.
(4)Other populations that are specifically identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475.
127472.5.The provisions of this chapter, except for Section 127487, are operative on the date of the written certification required by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 127487.
2.Community Benefits Statement, Community Health Needs Assessment, and Community Benefits Plan127473.Private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics shall provide community benefits to the community as follows:
(a)A minimum of 90 percent of the total economic value of community benefits shall be allocated to community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations or that address a specific need identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475. For purposes of this paragraph, community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations may include activities, including health professions education and training, that are not provided exclusively to underserved and vulnerable populations, if the activity will improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)A minimum of 25 percent of the total economic value of community benefits shall be allocated to community building activities geographically located within underserved and vulnerable populations.
(c)To meet the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b), community benefits shall be allocated for projects that simultaneously meet both criteria.
127474.Prior to completing the community health needs assessment pursuant to Section 127475, a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, all of the following:
(a)A community benefits statement that describes the hospitals or clinics commitment to developing, adopting, and implementing a community benefits program. The hospitals or clinics governing board shall document that it has reviewed the hospitals or clinics organizational mission statement and considered amendments to it that would better align that organizational mission statement with the community benefits statement.
(b)A description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, including a declaration that the board and administrators of the hospital or clinic shall be responsible for oversight and implementation of the community benefits plan. The board may establish a community benefits implementation committee that shall include members of the board, senior administrators, and community stakeholders.
127475.(a)By January 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community it serves.
(b)In conducting its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with representatives of vulnerable populations, including diverse racial, ethnic, cultural, and LGBTQQ communities, womens health advocates, mental health advocates, health and mental health providers, community-based organizations and advocates, academic institutions, local public health departments, local government entities, low-income and vulnerable consumers, health care providers, registered nurses, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved and who work with underserved and vulnerable populations. Particular attention shall also be given to identifying local needs to address racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input.
(c)In preparing its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall use available public health data. data, including any health equity assessment conducted by the Office of Health Equity pursuant to Section 131019.5. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may collaborate with other facilities and health care institutions in conducting community health needs assessments and may make use of existing studies in completing their own needs assessments.
(d)Not later than 30 days prior to completing a community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make available to the public a copy of the assessment for review and comment.
(e)A community health needs assessment shall be filed with the office. A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall update its community needs assessment at least every three years.
127476.(a)By April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community, a community benefits plan designed to achieve all of the following outcomes:
(1)Access to health care for members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(2)Addressing of the essential health care needs of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)Creation of measurable improvements in the health of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)In developing a community benefits plan, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with health care providers, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved, who work with underserved and vulnerable populations or with populations at risk for racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes.
(c)A community benefits plan shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)A summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan.
(2)A list of the services the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The list of services shall be categorized under the following:
(A)Charity care, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 127472.
(B)Other community benefits, including community health improvement services and community benefit operations, health professions education, subsidized health services, research, and contributions to community groups.
(C)Community building activities targeting underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)A description of the target community or communities that the plan is intended to benefit.
(4)An estimate of the economic value of the community benefits at cost that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide.
(5)A summary of the process used to elicit community participation in the community health needs assessment and community benefits plan design, and a description of the process for ongoing participation of community members in plan implementation and oversight, and a description of how the assessment and plan respond to the comments received by the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic from the community.
(6)A list of individuals, organizations, and government officials consulted during the development of the plan.
(7)A description of the intended impact on health outcomes attributable to the plan, including short- and long-term measurable goals and objectives.
(8)Mechanisms to evaluate the plans effectiveness.
(9)The name and title of the individual responsible for implementing the plan.
(10)The names of individuals on the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics governing board.
(11)If applicable, a report on the community benefits efforts of the preceding year, including the amounts and types of community benefits provided, in a manner to be prescribed by the office; a statement of the plans impact on health outcomes, including a description of the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics progress toward meeting its short- and long-term goals and objectives; and an evaluation of the plans effectiveness.
(d)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may also report on bad debts and Medicare shortfalls. Reporting bad debts and Medicare shortfalls shall not be reported as community benefits and shall be calculated based on hospital costs, not charges.
(e)The governing board of a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall adopt the community benefits plan at a meeting that is open to the public. No later than 30 days prior to the plans adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make do both of the following:
(1)Make available to the public and to the office, in a printed copy and on its Internet Web site, both of the following: a draft of its community benefits plan, and notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic.
(1)A draft of its community benefits plan.
(2)Notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic.
(2)Provide for a process by which the individuals and groups listed in subdivision (b) may provide written comment on the draft community benefits plan.
(f)After April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall, every two years, shall annually submit a community benefits plan that conforms with this chapter and subdivisions (b) to (e), inclusive, to the office, no later than 120 days after the end of the hospitals or clinics fiscal year.
(g)A person or entity may file comments on a private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics community benefits plan with the office.
(h)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, under the common control of a single corporation or another entity, may file a consolidated plan if the distinct needs of the communities served by each hospital in the consolidated plan are identified, and if the plan addresses services in all of the categories listed in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) to be provided by each hospital or clinic under common control of the corporation or entity.
127477.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports community benefits to the community shall report on those community benefits in a consistent and comparable manner to all other private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics.
127478.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan available to the public on its Internet Web site. A copy of the assessment and plan shall be given free of charge to any person upon request.
3.Duties of the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development127487.(a)(1)The By January 1, 2017, the office shall develop and adopt regulations to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans pursuant to this chapter. Immediately following the adoption of those regulations, the director of the office shall certify the adoption of the regulations in writing, post the written certification to the offices Internet Web site and deliver it to the Secretary of State, the Secretary of the Senate, the Chief Clerk of the Assembly, and the Legislative Counsel.
(2)The office shall develop a standardized methodology for estimating the economic value of community benefits based on the cost to a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic. In no case shall the economic value of community benefits exceed the actual cost to a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic, nor more than 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(3)In developing standards of reporting on community benefits, the office shall, to the maximum extent possible, conform to Internal Revenue Service reporting standards for those data elements reported to the Internal Revenue Service, but shall also include those data elements required under this chapter or other state law, including charity care, as defined in Section 127400.
(4)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall annually file with the office its IRS Form 990, or its successor form, and the office shall post the form on its Internet Web site.
(b)The office shall provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics comply with this chapter.
(c)The office shall make public a community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans. The office shall make these documents available on its Internet Web site.
(d)The office shall maintain a public calendar of community benefit adoption meetings held by the governing board of each private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic. Notice that includes the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) facility number, name, parent company, date, time, and location of each meeting shall be posted no later than 14 days prior to the meeting date.
(e)For every year that a community benefits plan is submitted pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 127476, the office shall calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by each private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports pursuant to this chapter.
127488.The office may assess a civil penalty against a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that fails to comply with this article in the same manner as specified in Section 128770.
127489.This chapter chapter, except for Section 127487, shall be operative on the date of the written certification required by subdivision (a) of Section 127487.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 129050 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:129050.A loan shall be eligible for insurance under this chapter if all of the following conditions are met:
(a)The loan shall be secured by a first mortgage, first deed of trust, or other first priority lien on a fee interest of the borrower or by a leasehold interest of the borrower having a term of at least 20 years, including options to renew for that duration, longer than the term of the insured loan. The security for the loan shall be subject only to those conditions, covenants and restrictions, easements, taxes, and assessments of record approved by the office, and other liens securing debt insured under this chapter. The office may require additional agreements in security of the loan.
(b)The borrower obtains an American Land Title Association title insurance policy with the office designated as beneficiary, with liability equal to the amount of the loan insured under this chapter, and with additional endorsements that the office may reasonably require.
(c)The proceeds of the loan shall be used exclusively for the construction, improvement, or expansion of the health facility, as approved by the office under Section 129020. However, loans insured pursuant to this chapter may include loans to refinance another prior loan, whether or not state insured and without regard to the date of the prior loan, if the office determines that the amount refinanced does not exceed 90 percent of the original total construction costs and is otherwise eligible for insurance under this chapter. The office may not insure a loan for a health facility that the office determines is not needed pursuant to subdivision (k).
(d)The loan shall have a maturity date not exceeding 30 years from the date of the beginning of amortization of the loan, except as authorized by subdivision (e), or 75 percent of the offices estimate of the economic life of the health facility, whichever is the lesser.
(e)The loan shall contain complete amortization provisions requiring periodic payments by the borrower not in excess of its reasonable ability to pay as determined by the office. The office shall permit a reasonable period of time during which the first payment to amortization may be waived on agreement by the lender and borrower. The office may, however, waive the amortization requirements of this subdivision and of subdivision (g) of this section when a term loan would be in the borrowers best interest.
(f)The loan shall bear interest on the amount of the principal obligation outstanding at any time at a rate, as negotiated by the borrower and lender, as the office finds necessary to meet the loan money market. As used in this chapter, interest does not include premium charges for insurance and service charges if any. Where a loan is evidenced by a bond issue of a political subdivision, the interest thereon may be at any rate the bonds may legally bear.
(g)The loan shall provide for the application of the borrowers periodic payments to amortization of the principal of the loan.
(h)The loan shall contain those terms and provisions with respect to insurance, repairs, alterations, payment of taxes and assessments, foreclosure proceedings, anticipation of maturity, additional and secondary liens, and other matters the office may in its discretion prescribe.
(i)The loan shall have a principal obligation not in excess of an amount equal to 90 percent of the total construction cost.
(j)The borrower shall offer reasonable assurance that the services of the health facility will be made available to all persons residing or employed in the area served by the facility.
(k)The office has determined that the facility is needed by the community to provide the specified services. In making this determination, the office shall do all of the following:
(1)Require the applicant to describe the community needs the facility will meet and provide data and information to substantiate the stated needs.
(2)Require the applicant, if appropriate, to demonstrate participation in the community needs assessment required by Section 127476.
(3)Survey appropriate local officials and organizations to measure perceived needs and verify the applicants needs assessment.
(4)Use any additional available data relating to existing facilities in the community and their capacity.
(5)Contact other state and federal departments that provide funding for the programs proposed by the applicant to obtain those departments perspectives regarding the need for the facility. Additionally, the office shall evaluate the potential effect of proposed health care reimbursement changes on the facilitys financial feasibility.
(6)Consider the facilitys consistency with the Cal-Mortgage State Plan.
(l)In the case of acquisitions, a project loan shall be guaranteed only for transactions not in excess of the fair market value of the acquisition.
Fair market value shall be determined, for purposes of this subdivision, pursuant to the following procedure, that shall be utilized during the offices review of a loan guarantee application:
(1)Completion of a property appraisal by an appraisal firm qualified to make appraisals, as determined by the office, before closing a loan on the project.
(2)Evaluation of the appraisal in conjunction with the book value of the acquisition by the office. When acquisitions involve additional construction, the office shall evaluate the proposed construction to determine that the costs are reasonable for the type of construction proposed. In those cases where this procedure reveals that the cost of acquisition exceeds the current value of a facility, including improvements, then the acquisition cost shall be deemed in excess of fair market value.
(m)Notwithstanding subdivision (i), any loan in the amount of ten million dollars ($10,000,000) or less may be insured up to 95 percent of the total construction cost.
In determining financial feasibility of projects of counties pursuant to this section, the office shall take into consideration any assistance for the project to be provided under Section 14085.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or from other sources. It is the intent of the Legislature that the office endeavor to assist counties in whatever ways are possible to arrange loans that will meet the requirements for insurance prescribed by this section.
(n)The projects level of financial risk meets the criteria in Section 129051.
(a)Every health facility licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2, except a health facility owned and operated by the state, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(b)Commencing in calendar year 2004, every freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic, as defined in Section 128700, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(c)The fee structure shall be established each year by the office to produce revenues equal to the appropriation made in the annual Budget Act or another statute to pay for the functions required to be performed by the office pursuant to this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), or Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, and to pay for any other health-related programs administered by the office. The fee shall be due on July 1 and delinquent on July 31 of each year.
(d)The fee for a health facility that is not a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(e)The fee for a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(f)The fee for a freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic shall be established at an amount equal to the number of ambulatory surgery data records submitted to the office pursuant to Section 128737 for encounters in the preceding calendar year multiplied by not more than fifty cents ($0.50).
(g)There is hereby established the California Health Data and Planning Fund within the office for the purpose of receiving and expending fee revenues collected pursuant to this chapter.
(h)Any amounts raised by the collection of the special fees provided for by subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) that are not required to meet appropriations in the Budget Act for the current fiscal year shall remain in the California Health Data and Planning Fund and shall be available to the office in succeeding years when appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act or another statute, for expenditure under the provisions of this chapter, Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470), and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, or for any other health-related programs administered by the office, and shall reduce the amount of the special fees that the office is authorized to establish and charge.
(i)(1)No health facility liable for the payment of fees required by this section shall be issued a license or have an existing license renewed unless the fees are paid. A new, previously unlicensed, health facility shall be charged a pro rata fee to be established by the office during the first year of operation.
(2)The license of any health facility, against which the fees required by this section are charged, shall be revoked, after notice and hearing, if it is determined by the office that the fees required were not paid within the time prescribed by subdivision (c).
SEC. 2.Article 2 (commencing with Section 127340) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 107 of the Health and Safety Code is repealed.SEC. 2.Section 127361 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 127360, to read:127361.This article is inoperative as of the date of the written certification required by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 127487, and is repealed on January 1 of the year after the year in which it becomes inoperative.
SEC. 3.Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470) is added to Part 2 of Division 107 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:2.6.Community Benefits1.Hospital Community Benefits127470.(a)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)Access to health care services is of vital concern to the people of California.
(2)Health care providers play an important role in providing essential health care services in the communities they serve.
(3)Notwithstanding public and private efforts to increase access to health care, the people of California continue to have significant unmet health needs. Studies indicate that as many as 6.9 million Californians are uninsured during a year.
(4)The state has a substantial interest in ensuring that the unmet health needs of its residents are addressed. Health care providers can help address these needs by providing charity care and community benefits to the uninsured and underinsured members of their communities.
(5)Hospitals have different roles in the community depending on their mission, governance, tax status, and articles of incorporation. Private hospitals that are investor owned and have for-profit tax status pay property taxes, corporate income taxes, and other taxes, such as unemployment insurance, on a different basis than nonprofit, district, or public hospitals. Nonprofit health facilities, including hospitals and multispecialty clinics, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, receive favorable tax treatment by the government and, in exchange, assume a social obligation to provide charity care and other community benefits in the public interest.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this chapter to provide uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits provided to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and multispecialty clinics operated by nonprofit corporations, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment.
127472.The following definitions apply for the purposes of this chapter:
(a)Community means the service area or patient population for which a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic provides health care services. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall create a health equity assessment based on the key factors relating to health and mental health disparities and inequities described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and may not define its service area to exclude vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, medically underserved, low-income, or minority populations who are part of its patient populations, live in geographic areas in which its patient populations reside, otherwise should be included based on the method the hospital facility uses to define its community, or populations described in subdivision (l).
(b)(1)Community benefits means the unreimbursed goods, services, activities, programs, and other resources provided by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that addresses community-identified health needs and concerns, and health disparities related to its healthy equity assessment, particularly for people who are uninsured, underserved, or members of a vulnerable population. Community benefits include, but are not limited to, charity care, shortfalls in Medi-Cal, California Childrens Services Program, or county indigent programs at cost up to 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations, the cost of community building activities, the cost of community health improvement services and community benefit operations, the cost of school health centers, as defined in Section 124174, the cost of health professions education and training provided without charge to community members or participants, amounts given, with no expectation of reimbursement or repayment, to employees for the purpose of satisfying or paying off, in full or in part, preemployment student educational loan obligations, subsidized health services for vulnerable populations, research, and contributions to community groups, vaccination programs and services for low-income families, chronic illness prevention programs and services, home-based health care programs for low-income families, or community-based mental health and outreach outreach, the key factors described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and assessment programs for low-income families. For purposes of this subparagraph, subdivision, low-income families means families or individuals with income less than or equal to 350 percent of the federal poverty level.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, community building activities means the cost of various kinds of community building activities, including physical improvements and housing, economic development, community support, environmental improvements, community health improvement advocacy, coalition building, workforce development, the key factors described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 131019.5, and leadership development and training for community members.
(3)(A)For purposes of this subdivision, charity care means the unreimbursed cost to a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic of providing services to the uninsured or underinsured, as well as providing health care services or items on an inpatient or outpatient basis to a financially qualified patient, as defined in Section 127400, with no expectation of payment.
(B)Charity care does not include any of the following:
(i)Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt.
(ii)Care provided to patients for which a public program or public or private grant funds pay for any of the charges for the care.
(iii)Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or chargemaster rates by the health care provider.
(iv)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis.
(v)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(vi)The cost to a nonprofit hospital of paying a tax or other governmental assessment.
(4)Community benefits does not mean the include any of the following:
(A)The unreimbursed cost of providing services to those enrolled in Medi-Cal, Medicare, California Childrens Services Program, Medicare or county indigent programs or any goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources program or activity for which there is direct offsetting revenue.
(B)Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt.
(C)Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or chargemaster rates by the health care provider.
(D)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis.
(E)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(c)(1)Community benefits planning committee means a committee, designated by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, that oversees the community needs assessment and the development of the community benefits plan implementation strategy to meet the community health needs identified through the community health needs assessment.
(2)The community benefits planning committee shall be composed of the following:
(A)One of the following:
(i)The governing board of the hospital organization that operates the hospital facility or a committee or other party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(ii)If the hospital facility has its own governing body and is recognized as an entity under state law but is a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes, the governing body of that hospital facility or other committee or party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(B)At least one individual from the local, tribal, or regional governmental public health department, or an equivalent department or agency, with knowledge, information, or expertise relevant to the health needs of that community.
(C)At least one individual from an underserved and vulnerable population.
(d)Discounted care means the cost for medical care provided consistent with Article 1 (commencing with Section 127400) of Chapter 2.5.
(e)(1)Direct offsetting revenue means revenue from goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources that offsets the total community benefit expense of the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources.
(2)Direct offsetting revenue includes revenue generated by the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, including, but not limited to, payment or reimbursement for services provided to program patients as well as restricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit, such as a restricted grant to provide financial assistance or fund research.
(3)Direct offsetting revenue does not include unrestricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit. benefit, nor payments for Medi-Cal, the California Childrens Services Program, or county indigent programs.
(f)Nonprofit multispecialty clinic means a clinic as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206.
(g)Office means the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development.
(h)Private nonprofit hospital means a private nonprofit acute care hospital operated or controlled by a nonprofit corporation, as defined in Section 5046 of the Corporations Code, that has been determined to be exempt from taxation under the Internal Revenue Code. For purposes of this chapter, private nonprofit hospital does not include any of the following:
(1)A district hospital organized and governed pursuant to the Local Health Care District Law (Division 23 (commencing with Section 32000)) or a nonprofit corporation that is affiliated with the health care district hospital owner by means of the districts status as the nonprofit corporations sole corporate member pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 14169.31 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(2)A rural general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 1250.
(3)A childrens hospital, as defined in Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)A multispecialty clinic operated by a for-profit hospital, regardless of its net revenue.
(i)Underserved and vulnerable population or vulnerable population means any of the following:
(1)A population that is exposed to medical or financial risk by virtue of being uninsured, underinsured, or eligible for Medi-Cal or a county indigent program.
(A)Uninsured means a self-pay patient as defined in Section 127400.
(B)Underinsured means a patient with high medical costs, as defined in Section 127400.
(2)A population, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)A vulnerable community, as defined by Section 131019.5.
(A)
(B)Individuals with low educational attainment as measured by the percentage of the population over 25 years of age with less than a high school diploma.
(B)
(C)Individuals who suffer from linguistic isolation as measured by the percentage of households in which no one who is 14 years of age or older speaks English with greater than elementary proficiency.
(3)A population that meets the definition of disadvantaged community pursuant to Section 39711.
(4)Other populations that are specifically identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475.
127472.5.The provisions of this chapter, except for Section 127487, are operative on the date of the written certification required by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 127487.
2.Community Benefits Statement, Community Health Needs Assessment, and Community Benefits Plan127473.Private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics shall provide community benefits to the community as follows:
(a)A minimum of 90 percent of the available total economic value of community benefit moneys benefits shall be allocated to community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations or that address a specific need identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475. For purposes of this paragraph, community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations may include activities, including health professions education and training, that are not provided exclusively to underserved and vulnerable populations, if the activity will improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)A minimum of 25 percent of the available total economic value of community benefit moneys benefits shall be allocated to community building activities geographically located within underserved and vulnerable populations.
(c)To meet the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b), moneys community benefits shall be used allocated for projects that simultaneously meet both criteria.
127474.Prior to completing the community health needs assessment pursuant to Section 127475, a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, all of the following:
(a)A community benefits statement that describes the hospitals or clinics commitment to developing, adopting, and implementing a community benefits program. The hospitals or clinics governing board shall document that it has reviewed the hospitals or clinics organizational mission statement and considered amendments to it that would better align that organizational mission statement with the community benefits statement.
(b)A description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, including a declaration that the board and administrators of the hospital or clinic shall be responsible for oversight and implementation of the community benefits plan. The board may establish a community benefits implementation committee that shall include members of the board, senior administrators, and community stakeholders.
127475.(a)By January 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community it serves.
(b)In conducting its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with representatives of vulnerable populations, including diverse racial, ethnic, cultural, and LGBTQQ communities, womens health advocates, mental health advocates, health and mental health providers, community-based organizations and advocates, academic institutions, local public health departments, local government entities, low-income and vulnerable consumers, health care providers, registered nurses, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved and who work with underserved and vulnerable populations. Particular attention shall also be given to identifying local needs to address racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input.
(c)In preparing its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall use available public health data. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may collaborate with other facilities and health care institutions in conducting community health needs assessments and may make use of existing studies in completing their own needs assessments.
(d)Not later than 30 days prior to completing a community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make available to the public a copy of the assessment for review and comment.
(e)A community health needs assessment shall be filed with the office. A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall update its community needs assessment at least every three years.
127476.(a)By April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community, a community benefits plan designed to achieve all of the following outcomes:
(1)Access to health care for members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(2)Addressing of the essential health care needs of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)Creation of measurable improvements in the health of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)In developing a community benefits plan, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with health care providers, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved, who work with underserved and vulnerable populations or with populations at risk for racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes.
(c)A community benefits plan shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)A summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan.
(2)A list of the services the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The list of services shall be categorized under the following:
(A)Charity care, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 127472.
(B)Other community benefits, including community health improvement services and community benefit operations, health professions education, subsidized health services, research, and contributions to community groups.
(C)Community building activities targeting underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)A description of the target community or communities that the plan is intended to benefit.
(4)An estimate of the economic value of the community benefits at cost that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide.
(5)A summary of the process used to elicit community participation in the community health needs assessment and community benefits plan design, and a description of the process for ongoing participation of community members in plan implementation and oversight, and a description of how the assessment and plan respond to the comments received by the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic from the community.
(6)A list of individuals, organizations, and government officials consulted during the development of the plan.
(7)A description of the intended impact on health outcomes attributable to the plan, including short- and long-term measurable goals and objectives.
(8)Mechanisms to evaluate the plans effectiveness.
(9)The name and title of the individual responsible for implementing the plan.
(10)The names of individuals on the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics governing board.
(11)If applicable, a report on the community benefits efforts of the preceding year, including the amounts and types of community benefits provided, in a manner to be prescribed by the office; a statement of the plans impact on health outcomes, including a description of the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics progress toward meeting its short- and long-term goals and objectives; and an evaluation of the plans effectiveness.
(d)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may also report on bad debts, debts and Medicare shortfalls, Medi-Cal shortfalls, and shortfalls from any other public program. shortfalls. Reporting bad debts, debts and Medicare shortfalls, Medi-Cal shortfalls, and other shortfalls from any other public program shortfalls shall not be reported as community benefits and shall be calculated based on hospital costs, not charges.
(e)The governing board of a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall adopt the community benefits plan at a meeting that is open to the public. No later than 30 days prior to the plans adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make available to the public and to the office, in a printed copy and on its Internet Web site, both of the following:
(1)A draft of its community benefits plan.
(2)Notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic.
(f)After April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall, every two years, submit a community benefits plan that conforms with this chapter and subdivisions (b) to (e), inclusive, to the office, no later than 120 days after the end of the hospitals or clinics fiscal year.
(g)A person or entity may file comments on a private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics community benefits plan with the office.
(h)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, under the common control of a single corporation or another entity, may file a consolidated plan if the plan addresses services in all of the categories listed in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) to be provided by each hospital or clinic under common control of the corporation or entity.
127477.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports community benefits to the community shall report on those community benefits in a consistent and comparable manner to all other private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics.
127478.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan available to the public on its Internet Web site. A copy of the assessment and plan shall be given free of charge to any person upon request.
3.Duties of the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development127487.(a)(1)The office shall develop and adopt regulations to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans pursuant to this chapter. Immediately following the adoption of those regulations, the director of the office shall certify the adoption of the regulations in writing, post the written certification to the offices Internet Web site and deliver it to the Secretary of State, the Secretary of the Senate, the Chief Clerk of the Assembly, and the Legislative Counsel.
(2)The office shall develop a standardized methodology for estimating the economic value of community benefits. benefits based on the cost to a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic. In no case shall the economic value of community benefits exceed the actual cost to a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic, nor more than 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(3)In developing standards of reporting on community benefits, the office shall, to the maximum extent possible, conform to Internal Revenue Service reporting standards for those data elements reported to the Internal Revenue Service, but shall also include those data elements required under this chapter or other state law, including charity care, as defined in Section 127400.
(4)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall annually file with the office its IRS Form 990, or its successor form, and the office shall post the form on its Internet Web site.
(b)The office shall provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics comply with this chapter.
(c)The office shall make public a community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans. The office shall make these documents available on its Internet Web site.
(d)The office shall maintain a public calendar of community benefit adoption meetings held by the governing board of each private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic. Notice that includes the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) facility number, name, parent company, date, time, and location of each meeting shall be posted no later than 14 days prior to the meeting date.
(e)For every year that a community benefits plan is submitted pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 127476, the office shall calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by each private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports pursuant to this chapter.
127488.The office may assess a civil penalty against a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that fails to comply with this article in the same manner as specified in Section 128770.
127489.This chapter shall be operative on the date of the written certification required by subdivision (a) of Section 127487.
SEC. 4.Section 129050 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:129050.A loan shall be eligible for insurance under this chapter if all of the following conditions are met:
(a)The loan shall be secured by a first mortgage, first deed of trust, or other first priority lien on a fee interest of the borrower or by a leasehold interest of the borrower having a term of at least 20 years, including options to renew for that duration, longer than the term of the insured loan. The security for the loan shall be subject only to those conditions, covenants and restrictions, easements, taxes, and assessments of record approved by the office, and other liens securing debt insured under this chapter. The office may require additional agreements in security of the loan.
(b)The borrower obtains an American Land Title Association title insurance policy with the office designated as beneficiary, with liability equal to the amount of the loan insured under this chapter, and with additional endorsements that the office may reasonably require.
(c)The proceeds of the loan shall be used exclusively for the construction, improvement, or expansion of the health facility, as approved by the office under Section 129020. However, loans insured pursuant to this chapter may include loans to refinance another prior loan, whether or not state insured and without regard to the date of the prior loan, if the office determines that the amount refinanced does not exceed 90 percent of the original total construction costs and is otherwise eligible for insurance under this chapter. The office may not insure a loan for a health facility that the office determines is not needed pursuant to subdivision (k).
(d)The loan shall have a maturity date not exceeding 30 years from the date of the beginning of amortization of the loan, except as authorized by subdivision (e), or 75 percent of the offices estimate of the economic life of the health facility, whichever is the lesser.
(e)The loan shall contain complete amortization provisions requiring periodic payments by the borrower not in excess of its reasonable ability to pay as determined by the office. The office shall permit a reasonable period of time during which the first payment to amortization may be waived on agreement by the lender and borrower. The office may, however, waive the amortization requirements of this subdivision and of subdivision (g) of this section when a term loan would be in the borrowers best interest.
(f)The loan shall bear interest on the amount of the principal obligation outstanding at any time at a rate, as negotiated by the borrower and lender, as the office finds necessary to meet the loan money market. As used in this chapter, interest does not include premium charges for insurance and service charges if any. Where a loan is evidenced by a bond issue of a political subdivision, the interest thereon may be at any rate the bonds may legally bear.
(g)The loan shall provide for the application of the borrowers periodic payments to amortization of the principal of the loan.
(h)The loan shall contain those terms and provisions with respect to insurance, repairs, alterations, payment of taxes and assessments, foreclosure proceedings, anticipation of maturity, additional and secondary liens, and other matters the office may in its discretion prescribe.
(i)The loan shall have a principal obligation not in excess of an amount equal to 90 percent of the total construction cost.
(j)The borrower shall offer reasonable assurance that the services of the health facility will be made available to all persons residing or employed in the area served by the facility.
(k)The office has determined that the facility is needed by the community to provide the specified services. In making this determination, the office shall do all of the following:
(1)Require the applicant to describe the community needs the facility will meet and provide data and information to substantiate the stated needs.
(2)Require the applicant, if appropriate, to demonstrate participation in the community needs assessment required by Section 127476.
(3)Survey appropriate local officials and organizations to measure perceived needs and verify the applicants needs assessment.
(4)Use any additional available data relating to existing facilities in the community and their capacity.
(5)Contact other state and federal departments that provide funding for the programs proposed by the applicant to obtain those departments perspectives regarding the need for the facility. Additionally, the office shall evaluate the potential effect of proposed health care reimbursement changes on the facilitys financial feasibility.
(6)Consider the facilitys consistency with the Cal-Mortgage state plan. State Plan.
(l)In the case of acquisitions, a project loan shall be guaranteed only for transactions not in excess of the fair market value of the acquisition.
Fair market value shall be determined, for purposes of this subdivision, pursuant to the following procedure, that shall be utilized during the offices review of a loan guarantee application:
(1)Completion of a property appraisal by an appraisal firm qualified to make appraisals, as determined by the office, before closing a loan on the project.
(2)Evaluation of the appraisal in conjunction with the book value of the acquisition by the office. When acquisitions involve additional construction, the office shall evaluate the proposed construction to determine that the costs are reasonable for the type of construction proposed. In those cases where this procedure reveals that the cost of acquisition exceeds the current value of a facility, including improvements, then the acquisition cost shall be deemed in excess of fair market value.
(m)Notwithstanding subdivision (i), any loan in the amount of ten million dollars ($10,000,000) or less may be insured up to 95 percent of the total construction cost.
In determining financial feasibility of projects of counties pursuant to this section, the office shall take into consideration any assistance for the project to be provided under Section 14085.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or from other sources. It is the intent of the Legislature that the office endeavor to assist counties in whatever ways are possible to arrange loans that will meet the requirements for insurance prescribed by this section.
(n)The projects level of financial risk meets the criteria in Section 129051.
(a)Every health facility licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of Division 2, except a health facility owned and operated by the state, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(b)Commencing in calendar year 2004, every freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic clinic, as defined in Section 128700, shall each year be charged a fee established by the office consistent with the requirements of this section.
(c)The fee structure shall be established each year by the office to produce revenues equal to the appropriation made in the annual Budget Act or another statute to pay for the functions required to be performed by the office pursuant to this chapter, Article 2 Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127340) of Chapter 2, 127470), or Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, and to pay for any other health-related programs administered by the office. The fee shall be due on July 1 and delinquent on July 31 of each year.
(d)The fee for a health facility that is not a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(e)The fee for a hospital, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 128700, shall be not more than 0.035 percent of the gross operating cost of the facility for the provision of health care services for its last fiscal year that ended on or before June 30 of the preceding calendar year.
(f)(1)The fee for a freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic shall be established at an amount equal to the number of ambulatory surgery data records submitted to the office pursuant to Section 128737 for encounters in the preceding calendar year multiplied by not more than fifty cents ($0.50).
(2)(A)For the calendar year 2004 only, a freestanding ambulatory surgery clinic shall estimate the number of records it will file pursuant to Section 128737 for the calendar year 2004 and shall report that number to the office by March 12, 2004. The estimate shall be as accurate as possible. The fee in the calendar year 2004 shall be established initially at an amount equal to the estimated number of records reported multiplied by fifty cents ($0.50) and shall be due on July 1 and delinquent on July 31, 2004.
(B)The office shall compare the actual number of records filed by each freestanding clinic for the calendar year 2004 pursuant to Section 128737 with the estimated number of records reported pursuant to subparagraph (A). If the actual number reported is less than the estimated number reported, the office shall reduce the fee of the clinic for calendar year 2005 by the amount of the difference multiplied by fifty cents ($0.50). If the actual number reported exceeds the estimated number reported, the office shall increase the fee of the clinic for calendar year 2005 by the amount of the difference multiplied by fifty cents ($0.50) unless the actual number reported is greater than 120 percent of the estimated number reported, in which case the office shall increase the fee of the clinic for calendar year 2005 by the amount of the difference, up to and including 120 percent of the estimated number, multiplied by fifty cents ($0.50), and by the amount of the difference in excess of 120 percent of the estimated number multiplied by one dollar ($1).
(g)There is hereby established the California Health Data and Planning Fund within the office for the purpose of receiving and expending fee revenues collected pursuant to this chapter.
(h)Any amounts raised by the collection of the special fees provided for by subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) that are not required to meet appropriations in the Budget Act for the current fiscal year shall remain in the California Health Data and Planning Fund and shall be available to the office in succeeding years when appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act or another statute, for expenditure under the provisions of this chapter, Article 2 Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127340) of Chapter 2, 127470), and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 128675) of Part 5, or for any other health-related programs administered by the office, and shall reduce the amount of the special fees that the office is authorized to establish and charge.
(i)(1)No health facility liable for the payment of fees required by this section shall be issued a license or have an existing license renewed unless the fees are paid. A new, previously unlicensed, health facility shall be charged a pro rata fee to be established by the office during the first year of operation.
(2)The license of any health facility, against which the fees required by this section are charged, shall be revoked, after notice and hearing, if it is determined by the office that the fees required were not paid within the time prescribed by subdivision (c).
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2002.
SEC. 2.Article 2 (commencing with Section 127340) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 107 of the Health and Safety Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 127470) is added to Part 2 of Division 107 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:2.6.Community Benefits1.Hospital Community Benefits127470.(a)The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(1)Access to health care services is of vital concern to the people of California.
(2)Health care providers play an important role in providing essential health care services in the communities they serve.
(3)Notwithstanding public and private efforts to increase access to health care, the people of California continue to have significant unmet health needs. Studies indicate that as many as 6.9 million Californians are uninsured during a year.
(4)The state has a substantial interest in ensuring that the unmet health needs of its residents are addressed. Health care providers can help address these needs by providing charity care and community benefits to the uninsured and underinsured members of their communities.
(5)Hospitals have different roles in the community depending on their mission, governance, tax status, and articles of incorporation. Private hospitals that are investor owned and have for-profit tax status pay property taxes, corporate income taxes, and other taxes, such as unemployment insurance, on a different basis than nonprofit, district, or public hospitals. Nonprofit health facilities, including hospitals and multispecialty clinics, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, receive favorable tax treatment by the government and, in exchange, assume a social obligation to provide charity care and other community benefits in the public interest.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this chapter to provide uniform standards for reporting the amount of charity care and community benefits provided to ensure that private nonprofit hospitals and multispecialty clinics operated by nonprofit corporations, as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206, actually meet the social obligations for which they receive favorable tax treatment.
127472.The following definitions apply for the purposes of this chapter:
(a)Community means the service area or patient population for which a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic provides health care services. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may not define its service area to exclude medically underserved, low-income, or minority populations who are part of its patient populations, live in geographic areas in which its patient populations reside, otherwise should be included based on the method the hospital facility uses to define its community, or populations described in subdivision (l).
(b)(1)Community benefits means the unreimbursed goods, services, activities, programs, and other resources provided by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that addresses community-identified health needs and concerns, particularly for people who are uninsured, underserved, or members of a vulnerable population. Community benefits include, but are not limited to, charity care, the cost of community building activities, the cost of community health improvement services and community benefit operations, the cost of school health centers, as defined in Section 124174, the cost of health professions education and training provided without charge to community members or participants, subsidized health services for vulnerable populations, research, and contributions to community groups, vaccination programs and services for low-income families, chronic illness prevention programs and services, home-based health care programs for low-income families, or community-based mental health and outreach and assessment programs for low-income families. For purposes of this subparagraph, low-income families means families or individuals with income less than or equal to 350 percent of the federal poverty level.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, community building activities means the cost of various kinds of community building activities, including physical improvements and housing, economic development, community support, environmental improvements, community health improvement advocacy, coalition building, workforce development, and leadership development and training for community members.
(3)(A)For purposes of this subdivision, charity care means the unreimbursed cost to a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic of providing services to the uninsured or underinsured, as well as providing health care services or items on an inpatient or outpatient basis to a financially qualified patient, as defined in Section 127400, with no expectation of payment.
(B)Charity care does not include any of the following:
(i)Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt.
(ii)Care provided to patients for which a public program or public or private grant funds pay for any of the charges for the care.
(iii)Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or chargemaster rates by the health care provider.
(iv)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis.
(v)Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other nonprofit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
(vi)The cost to a nonprofit hospital of paying a tax or other governmental assessment.
(4)Community benefits does not mean the unreimbursed cost of providing services to those enrolled in Medi-Cal, Medicare, California Childrens Services Program, or county indigent programs or any goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources program or activity for which there is direct offsetting revenue.
(c)(1)Community benefits planning committee means a committee, designated by a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, that oversees the community needs assessment and the development of the community benefits plan implementation strategy to meet the community health needs identified through the community health needs assessment.
(2)The community benefits planning committee shall be composed of the following:
(A)One of the following:
(i)The governing board of the hospital organization that operates the hospital facility or a committee or other party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(ii)If the hospital facility has its own governing body and is recognized as an entity under state law but is a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes, the governing body of that hospital facility or other committee or party authorized by that governing body to the extent that the committee or other party is permitted under state law to act on behalf of the governing body.
(B)At least one individual from the local, tribal, or regional governmental public health department, or an equivalent department or agency, with knowledge, information, or expertise relevant to the health needs of that community.
(C)At least one individual from an underserved and vulnerable population.
(d)Discounted care means the cost for medical care provided consistent with Article 1 (commencing with Section 127400) of Chapter 2.5.
(e)(1)Direct offsetting revenue means revenue from goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources that offsets the total community benefit expense of the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources.
(2)Direct offsetting revenue includes revenue generated by the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, including, but not limited to, payment or reimbursement for services provided to program patients as well as restricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit, such as a restricted grant to provide financial assistance or fund research.
(3)Direct offsetting revenue does not include unrestricted grants or contributions that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic uses to provide a community benefit.
(f)Nonprofit multispecialty clinic means a clinic as described in subdivision (l) of Section 1206.
(g)Office means the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development.
(h)Private nonprofit hospital means a private nonprofit acute care hospital operated or controlled by a nonprofit corporation, as defined in Section 5046 of the Corporations Code, that has been determined to be exempt from taxation under the Internal Revenue Code. For purposes of this chapter, private nonprofit hospital does not include any of the following:
(1)A district hospital organized and governed pursuant to the Local Health Care District Law (Division 23 (commencing with Section 32000)) or a nonprofit corporation that is affiliated with the health care district hospital owner by means of the districts status as the nonprofit corporations sole corporate member pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 14169.31 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(2)A rural general acute care hospital, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 1250.
(3)A childrens hospital, as defined in Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)A multispecialty clinic operated by a for-profit hospital, regardless of its net revenue.
(i)Underserved and vulnerable population means any of the following:
(1)A population that is exposed to medical or financial risk by virtue of being uninsured, underinsured, or eligible for Medi-Cal or a county indigent program.
(A)Uninsured means a self-pay patient as defined in Section 127400.
(B)Underinsured means a patient with high medical costs, as defined in Section 127400.
(2)A population, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Individuals with low educational attainment as measured by the percentage of the population over 25 years of age with less than a high school diploma.
(B)Individuals who suffer from linguistic isolation as measured by the percentage of households in which no one who is 14 years of age or older speaks English with greater than elementary proficiency.
(3)A population that meets the definition of disadvantaged community pursuant to Section 39711.
(4)Other populations that are specifically identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475.
2.Community Benefits Statement, Community Health Needs Assessment, and Community Benefits Plan127473.Private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics shall provide community benefits to the community as follows:
(a)A minimum of 90 percent of the available community benefit moneys shall be allocated to community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations or that address a specific need identified in the community health needs assessment required pursuant to Section 127475. For purposes of this paragraph, community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations may include activities, including health professions education and training, that are not provided exclusively to underserved and vulnerable populations, if the activity will improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)A minimum of 25 percent of the available community benefit moneys shall be allocated to community building activities geographically located within underserved and vulnerable populations.
(c)To meet the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b), moneys shall be used for projects that simultaneously meet both criteria.
127474.Prior to completing the community health needs assessment pursuant to Section 127475, a private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, all of the following:
(a)A community benefits statement that describes the hospitals or clinics commitment to developing, adopting, and implementing a community benefits program. The hospitals or clinics governing board shall document that it has reviewed the hospitals or clinics organizational mission statement and considered amendments to it that would better align that organizational mission statement with the community benefits statement.
(b)A description of the process for approval of the community benefits plan by the hospitals or clinics governing board, including a declaration that the board and administrators of the hospital or clinic shall be responsible for oversight and implementation of the community benefits plan. The board may establish a community benefits implementation committee that shall include members of the board, senior administrators, and community stakeholders.
127475.(a)By January 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community it serves.
(b)In conducting its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with health care providers, registered nurses, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved and who work with underserved and vulnerable populations. Particular attention shall also be given to identifying local needs to address racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input.
(c)In preparing its community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall use available public health data. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may collaborate with other facilities and health care institutions in conducting community health needs assessments and may make use of existing studies in completing their own needs assessments.
(d)Not later than 30 days prior to completing a community health needs assessment, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make available to the public a copy of the assessment for review and comment.
(e)A community health needs assessment shall be filed with the office. A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall update its community needs assessment at least every three years.
127476.(a)By April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall develop, in collaboration with the community, a community benefits plan designed to achieve all of the following outcomes:
(1)Access to health care for members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(2)Addressing of the essential health care needs of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)Creation of measurable improvements in the health of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
(b)In developing a community benefits plan, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall solicit comments from and meet with local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments. A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall also solicit comments from and meet with health care providers, community groups representing, among others, patients, labor, seniors, and consumers, and other health-related organizations. Particular attention shall be given to persons who are themselves underserved, who work with underserved and vulnerable populations or with populations at risk for racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes.
(c)A community benefits plan shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)A summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan.
(2)A list of the services the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments. The list of services shall be categorized under the following:
(A)Charity care, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 127472.
(B)Other community benefits, including community health improvement services and community benefit operations, health professions education, subsidized health services, research, and contributions to community groups.
(C)Community building activities targeting underserved and vulnerable populations.
(3)A description of the target community or communities that the plan is intended to benefit.
(4)An estimate of the economic value of the community benefits that the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic intends to provide.
(5)A summary of the process used to elicit community participation in the community health needs assessment and community benefits plan design, and a description of the process for ongoing participation of community members in plan implementation and oversight, and a description of how the assessment and plan respond to the comments received by the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic from the community.
(6)A list of individuals, organizations, and government officials consulted during the development of the plan.
(7)A description of the intended impact on health outcomes attributable to the plan, including short- and long-term measurable goals and objectives.
(8)Mechanisms to evaluate the plans effectiveness.
(9)The name and title of the individual responsible for implementing the plan.
(10)The names of individuals on the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics governing board.
(11)If applicable, a report on the community benefits efforts of the preceding year, including the amounts and types of community benefits provided, in a manner to be prescribed by the office; a statement of the plans impact on health outcomes, including a description of the private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics progress toward meeting its short- and long-term goals and objectives; and an evaluation of the plans effectiveness.
(d)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic may also report on bad debts, Medicare shortfalls, Medi-Cal shortfalls, and shortfalls from any other public program. Reporting bad debts, Medicare shortfalls, Medi-Cal shortfalls, and other shortfalls from any other public program shall not be reported as community benefits and shall be calculated based on hospital costs, not charges.
(e)The governing board of a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall adopt the community benefits plan at a meeting that is open to the public. No later than 30 days prior to the plans adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make available to the public and to the office, in a printed copy and on its Internet Web site, both of the following:
(1)A draft of its community benefits plan.
(2)Notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption by the governing board of the private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic.
(f)After April 1, 2018, a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall, every two years, submit a community benefits plan that conforms with this chapter and subdivisions (b) to (e), inclusive, to the office, no later than 120 days after the end of the hospitals or clinics fiscal year.
(g)A person or entity may file comments on a private nonprofit hospitals or nonprofit multispecialty clinics community benefits plan with the office.
(h)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic, under the common control of a single corporation or another entity, may file a consolidated plan if the plan addresses services in all of the categories listed in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) to be provided by each hospital or clinic under common control of the corporation or entity.
127477.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports community benefits to the community shall report on those community benefits in a consistent and comparable manner to all other private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics.
127478.A private nonprofit hospital or a nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan available to the public on its Internet Web site. A copy of the assessment and plan shall be given free of charge to any person upon request.
3.Duties of the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development127487.(a)(1)The office shall develop and adopt regulations to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans pursuant to this chapter.
(2)The office shall develop a standardized methodology for estimating the economic value of community benefits.
(3)In developing standards of reporting on community benefits, the office shall, to the maximum extent possible, conform to Internal Revenue Service reporting standards for those data elements reported to the Internal Revenue Service, but shall also include those data elements required under this chapter or other state law, including charity care, as defined in Section 127400.
(4)A private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic shall annually file with the office its IRS Form 990, or its successor form, and the office shall post the form on its Internet Web site.
(b)The office shall provide technical assistance to help private nonprofit hospitals and nonprofit multispecialty clinics comply with this chapter.
(c)The office shall make public a community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans. The office shall make these documents available on its Internet Web site.
(d)The office shall maintain a public calendar of community benefit adoption meetings held by the governing board of each private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic. Notice that includes the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) facility number, name, parent company, date, time, and location of each meeting shall be posted no later than 14 days prior to the meeting date.
(e)For every year that a community benefits plan is submitted pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 127476, the office shall calculate and make public the total value of community benefits provided by each private nonprofit hospital and nonprofit multispecialty clinic that reports pursuant to this chapter.
127488.The office may assess a civil penalty against a private nonprofit hospital or nonprofit multispecialty clinic that fails to comply with this article in the same manner as specified in Section 128770.
SEC. 4.Section 129050 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:129050.A loan shall be eligible for insurance under this chapter if all of the following conditions are met:
(a)The loan shall be secured by a first mortgage, first deed of trust, or other first priority lien on a fee interest of the borrower or by a leasehold interest of the borrower having a term of at least 20 years, including options to renew for that duration, longer than the term of the insured loan. The security for the loan shall be subject only to those conditions, covenants and restrictions, easements, taxes, and assessments of record approved by the office, and other liens securing debt insured under this chapter. The office may require additional agreements in security of the loan.
(b)The borrower obtains an American Land Title Association title insurance policy with the office designated as beneficiary, with liability equal to the amount of the loan insured under this chapter, and with additional endorsements that the office may reasonably require.
(c)The proceeds of the loan shall be used exclusively for the construction, improvement, or expansion of the health facility, as approved by the office under Section 129020. However, loans insured pursuant to this chapter may include loans to refinance another prior loan, whether or not state insured and without regard to the date of the prior loan, if the office determines that the amount refinanced does not exceed 90 percent of the original total construction costs and is otherwise eligible for insurance under this chapter. The office may not insure a loan for a health facility that the office determines is not needed pursuant to subdivision (k).
(d)The loan shall have a maturity date not exceeding 30 years from the date of the beginning of amortization of the loan, except as authorized by subdivision (e), or 75 percent of the offices estimate of the economic life of the health facility, whichever is the lesser.
(e)The loan shall contain complete amortization provisions requiring periodic payments by the borrower not in excess of its reasonable ability to pay as determined by the office. The office shall permit a reasonable period of time during which the first payment to amortization may be waived on agreement by the lender and borrower. The office may, however, waive the amortization requirements of this subdivision and of subdivision (g) of this section when a term loan would be in the borrowers best interest.
(f)The loan shall bear interest on the amount of the principal obligation outstanding at any time at a rate, as negotiated by the borrower and lender, as the office finds necessary to meet the loan money market. As used in this chapter, interest does not include premium charges for insurance and service charges if any. Where a loan is evidenced by a bond issue of a political subdivision, the interest thereon may be at any rate the bonds may legally bear.
(g)The loan shall provide for the application of the borrowers periodic payments to amortization of the principal of the loan.
(h)The loan shall contain those terms and provisions with respect to insurance, repairs, alterations, payment of taxes and assessments, foreclosure proceedings, anticipation of maturity, additional and secondary liens, and other matters the office may in its discretion prescribe.
(i)The loan shall have a principal obligation not in excess of an amount equal to 90 percent of the total construction cost.
(j)The borrower shall offer reasonable assurance that the services of the health facility will be made available to all persons residing or employed in the area served by the facility.
(k)The office has determined that the facility is needed by the community to provide the specified services. In making this determination, the office shall do all of the following:
(1)Require the applicant to describe the community needs the facility will meet and provide data and information to substantiate the stated needs.
(2)Require the applicant, if appropriate, to demonstrate participation in the community needs assessment required by Section 127350. 127476.
(3)Survey appropriate local officials and organizations to measure perceived needs and verify the applicants needs assessment.
(4)Use any additional available data relating to existing facilities in the community and their capacity.
(5)Contact other state and federal departments that provide funding for the programs proposed by the applicant to obtain those departments perspectives regarding the need for the facility. Additionally, the office shall evaluate the potential effect of proposed health care reimbursement changes on the facilitys financial feasibility.
(6)Consider the facilitys consistency with the Cal-Mortgage state plan.
(l)In the case of acquisitions, a project loan shall be guaranteed only for transactions not in excess of the fair market value of the acquisition.
Fair market value shall be determined, for purposes of this subdivision, pursuant to the following procedure, that shall be utilized during the offices review of a loan guarantee application:
(1)Completion of a property appraisal by an appraisal firm qualified to make appraisals, as determined by the office, before closing a loan on the project.
(2)Evaluation of the appraisal in conjunction with the book value of the acquisition by the office. When acquisitions involve additional construction, the office shall evaluate the proposed construction to determine that the costs are reasonable for the type of construction proposed. In those cases where this procedure reveals that the cost of acquisition exceeds the current value of a facility, including improvements, then the acquisition cost shall be deemed in excess of fair market value.
(m)Notwithstanding subdivision (i), any loan in the amount of ten million dollars ($10,000,000) or less may be insured up to 95 percent of the total construction cost.
In determining financial feasibility of projects of counties pursuant to this section, the office shall take into consideration any assistance for the project to be provided under Section 14085.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or from other sources. It is the intent of the Legislature that the office endeavor to assist counties in whatever ways are possible to arrange loans that will meet the requirements for insurance prescribed by this section.
(n)The projects level of financial risk meets the criteria in Section 129051.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | April 29 set for second hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 4. Noes 2. Page 860.) Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | April 29 set for second hearing. Failed passage in committee. Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 22, 2015 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | April 22 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 9, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 7, 2015 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Mar 5, 2015 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 25, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 24, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 29, 2015 | [Second] hearing set for [04-30-2015]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 346 (Wieckowski) Page 16 of 16
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 346
AUTHOR: |
Wieckowski |
||
VERSION: |
April 23, 2015 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
April 29, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Vince Marchand |
||
SUBJECT: Health facilities: community benefits.
SUMMARY: Repeals the existing hospital community benefit law, and establishes a new hospital community law to require private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment, followed by a community benefits plan. Defines “community benefit” and other terms for purposes of this bill, and requires 90 percent of a private non-profit hospital’s community benefit moneys to be allocated to charity care and projects that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations, as defined.
Existing law:
Establishes the hospital community benefit law (existing CBL), which establishes requirements on private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment and adopt a community benefits plan, to annually submit this community benefit plan to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD), along with a report of the economic value of community benefits provided in furtherance of the plan.
Defines “community benefit plan,” for purposes of the existing CBL, as a written document prepared for annual submission to OSHPD, that includes a description of the activities that the hospital has undertaken in order to address identified community needs within its mission and financial capacity, and the process by which the hospital developed the plan in consultation with the community.
Defines “community benefit,” for the purposes of the existing CBL, as a hospital’s activities that are intended to address community needs and priorities primarily through disease prevention and improvement of health status, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
Health care services rendered to vulnerable populations, including charity care and the unreimbursed cost of providing services to the uninsured, underinsured, and those eligible for Medi-Cal, Medicare, California Children’s Services Program, or county indigent programs;
The unreimbursed cost of services provided related to community-oriented wellness and health promotion, prevention services such as health screenings and immunizations, adult day care, child care, medical research, medical education, nursing and other professional training, home-delivered meals to the homebound, sponsorship of free food and shelter to the homeless, and outreach clinics in socioeconomically depressed areas;
Financial or in-kind support of public health programs;
Donation of funds, property, or other resources that contribute to a community priority;
Health care cost containment;
Enhancement of access to health care or related services that contribute to a healthier community;
Services offered without regard to financial return because they meet a need in the service area of the hospital; and,
Food, shelter, clothing, education, transportation, and other goods or services that help maintain a person’s health.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to complete, either alone or in conjunction with other health care providers, a community needs assessment evaluating the health needs of the community serviced by the hospital, that includes a process for consulting with community groups and local government officials, and to update the community needs assessment at least once every three years.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to annually adopt and update a community benefits plan for providing community benefits either alone, or in conjunction with other health care providers, or through other organizational arrangements. Requires the community benefits plan to include the following elements:
Mechanisms to evaluate the plan’s effectiveness, including a method for soliciting the views of the community served by the hospital;
Measurable objectives to be achieved within specified timeframes;
Community benefits categorized into the following categories: medical care services, other benefits for vulnerable populations, other benefits for the broader community, health research and training programs, and nonquantifiable benefits.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to annually submit its community benefit plan, including activities the hospital has undertaken in order to address community needs, to OSHPD, and to the extent practicable, assign and report the economic value of community benefits provided in furtherance of its plan.
This bill:
Repeals the existing CBL law, and establishes a new CBL for private non-profit hospitals and non-profit multispecialty clinics (collectively, non-profit facilities), as these facilities are defined. Makes the repeal of the old CBL law, and the operative date of the new CBL law, effective as of the date of the adoption of regulations by OSHPD prescribing a new standardized format for community benefits plans,
Requires, by January 1, 2018, each private non-profit facility to develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community it serves. Requires facilities, prior to completing this assessment, to develop a community benefits statement that describes the facility’s commitment to developing, adopting, and implementing a community benefits program. Requires private non-profit facilities to file the community health needs assessment with OSHPD, and to update its community needs assessment at least every three years.
Requires, by April 1, 2018, each private non-profit facility to develop, in collaboration with the community, a community benefits plan designed to achieve all of the following outcomes:
Access to health care for members of underserved and vulnerable populations;
Addressing of the essential health care needs of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations;
Creation of measurable improvements in the health of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
Defines “community” as the service area or patient population for which a non-profit facility provides health care services. Prohibits a non-profit facility from defining its service area to exclude vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, medically underserved, low-income, or minority populations who are part of its patient populations, live in geographic areas in which its patient populations reside, or otherwise should be included based on the method the hospital facility uses to define its community.
Defines “community benefits” as the unreimbursed goods, services, activities, programs, and other resources provided by a non-profit facility that addresses community-identified health needs and concerns, particularly for people who are uninsured, underserved, or members of a vulnerable population, including, but not limited to, the following:
Charity care;
Shortfalls in Medi-Cal, the California Children’s Program, or county indigent programs at a cost up to 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or healthcare organizations;
The cost of community building activities for vulnerable populations;
The cost of community health improvement services and community benefit operations;
The cost of school health centers as defined;
The cost of health professions education and training provided without charge;
Amounts given, with no expectation of repayment, to employees from, or working among, a vulnerable population, for student loan repayment;
Subsidized health services for vulnerable populations;
Vaccination programs;
Chronic illness prevention programs and services for vulnerable populations;
Home-based health care programs for vulnerable populations;
Community-based mental health programs for vulnerable populations; and,
Outreach and assessment programs for vulnerable populations.
Excludes the following from the definition of “community benefits:”
The unreimbursed cost of providing services to those enrolled in Medicare or any goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources program or activity for which there is direct offsetting revenue;
Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt;
Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or “chargemaster” rates by the health care provider.
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires a private non-profit facility, beginning after April 1, 2018, to annually submit to OSHPD a community benefits plan that conforms to this bill no later than 120 days after the end of the facility’s fiscal year. Requires the plan to include, if applicable, a report on the community benefits efforts of the preceding year, including the amounts and types of benefits provided, a description of the facility’s progress toward meeting its goals and objectives, and an evaluation of the plan’s effectiveness.
Defines “community building activities,” for purposes of the community benefit definition, as the cost of various kinds of community building activities, including physical improvements and housing, economic development, community support, environmental improvements, community health improvement advocacy, coalition building, workforce development, and leadership development and training for community members.
Defines “charity care,” for purposes of the community benefit definition, as the unreimbursed cost to a non-profit facility of providing services to the uninsured or underinsured, as well as providing health care services or items on an inpatient or outpatient basis to a financially qualified patient, as defined, with no expectation of payment.
Excludes from the definition of “charity care” any of the following:
Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt;
Care provided to patients for which a public program or public or private grant funds pay for any of the charges for the care;
Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or “chargemaster” rates by the health care provider;
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis; and,
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires the community benefits planning committee, as defined, to be composed of the following:
One of either the governing board of the hospital organization that operates the facility or other party authorized by that governing body, or the governing body of the hospital facility if the facility has its own governing body;
At least one individual from the local, tribal, or regional governmental public health department, or an equivalent department, with knowledge, information, or expertise relevant to the health needs of that community;
At least one individual from an underserved and vulnerable population, as defined;
Defines “direct offsetting revenue” as the revenue from goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, which offsets the total community benefit expense of the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, and excludes from this definition payments for Medi-Cal, the California Children’s Services Program, or county indigent programs.
Defines “non-profit multispecialty clinic” as a clinic, defined in existing law, that is operated by a non-profit corporation exempt from federal income taxation, as specified, that conducts medical research and health education and provides health care to its patients through a group of 40 or more physicians, who are independent contracts representing not less than 10 board-certified specialties, and not less than two-thirds of whom practice on a full-time basis at the clinic.
Defines “private non-profit hospital” as a private non-profit acute care hospital that has been determined to be exempt from taxation under the Internal Revenue Code, and exempts the following from this definition:
A district hospital organized and governed pursuant to the Local Health Care District Law, as specified, or a non-profit corporation that is affiliated with the health care district hospital owner by means of the district’s status as the nonprofit corporation’s sole corporate member;
A rural general acute care hospital, as defined;
A children’s hospital, as defined; and,
A multispecialty clinic operated by a for-profit hospital, regardless of its net revenue.
Defines “underserved population” or “vulnerable population” as any of the following:
A population that is exposed to medical or financial risk by virtue of being uninsured or underinsured, as defined, or eligible for Medi-Cal or county indigent programs;
Individuals below 400 percent of the federal poverty level, unless the hospital serves a county in which the county has adopted an ordinance to provide financial assistance for health care to individuals with incomes above 400 percent of the federal poverty level, in which case the income threshold for the vulnerable population shall be the income threshold adopted by the county;
Individuals with limited English proficiency; or
A population that meets the definition of disadvantaged community pursuant to a provision of law that requires the California Environmental Protection Agency to identify communities based on certain criteria, including areas disproportionately affected by environmental pollution and other hazards;
Requires a private non-profit facility, in conducting its community health needs assessment, to solicit comments from, and meet with, local government officials, as well as representatives of vulnerable populations, including diverse racial, ethnic, cultural, and LGBTQQ communities, women’s health advocates, mental health advocates, health and mental health providers, community-based organizations and advocates, academic institutions, low-income and vulnerable consumers, health care providers, registered nurses, and community groups representing specified constituencies such as patients, labor, and seniors. Permits a facility to create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input.
Requires a private non-profit facility, in preparing its community health needs assessment, to use available public health data, including any health equity assessment conducted by the Office of Health Equity, as specified, and permits the facility to collaborate with other facilities and health care institutions in conducting community health needs assessments and to make use of exiting studies.
Requires private non-profit facilities, not later than 30 days prior to completing a community health needs assessment, to make a copy of the assessment available to the public for review and comment.
Requires private non-profit facilities to provide community benefits to the community as follows:
Requires a minimum of 90 percent of the total economic value of community benefits to be allocated to community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations or that address a specific need identified in the community health needs assessment. Permits, for purposes of this 90 percent allocation, community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations to include activities, such as health professions education and training, which are not provided exclusively to underserved and vulnerable populations, if the activity will improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations.
Requires a minimum of 25 percent of the total economic value of community benefits to be allocated to community building activities geographically located within underserved and vulnerable populations.
Permits community benefits to be allocated for projects that simultaneously meet both of the above criteria.
Requires private non-profit facilities, in developing a community benefits plan, to solicit comments from, and meet with, local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments, and to also solicit comments from, and meet with, health care providers, registered nurses, and community groups representing specified constituencies.
Requires a community benefits plan to include, at a minimum, all of the following:
A summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan;
A list of the services the private non-profit facility intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments, categorized under the following: charity care, as defined; other community benefits, as specified; and, community building activities;
A description of the target community or communities that the plan is intended to benefit;
An estimate of the economic value of the community benefits at cost that the private non-profit facility intends to provide;
A summary of the process used to elicit community participation in the community health needs assessment and community benefits plan design, and a description of the process for ongoing participation of community members in plan implementation and oversight;
A list of individuals, organizations, and government official consulted during the development of the plan;
A description of the intended impact on health outcomes attributable to the plan, including short- and long-term measurable goals and objectives;
Mechanisms to evaluate the plan’s effectiveness;
The name and title of the individual responsible for implementing the plan; and,
The names of individuals on the private non-profit facility’s governing board;
Permits a private non-profit facility to also report on bad debts and Medicare shortfalls, but prohibits these reports from being reported as community benefits and to be calculated based on hospital costs, not charges.
Requires the governing board of a private non-profit facility to adopt the community benefits plan at a meeting that is open to the public. Requires the governing board, no later than 30 days prior to the plan’s adoption, to make a draft of the plan available to the public, including on its Internet Web site, as well as a notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption.
Requires the governing board of a private non-profit facility, no later than 30 days prior to the plan’s adoption, to provide for a process by which individuals and groups may provide written comment on the draft community plan.
, local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments, and to also solicit comments from, and meet with, health care providers, registered nurses, and community groups representing specified constituencies.
Permits a person or entity to file comments on a facility’s community benefits plan with OSHPD.
Requires a private non-profit facility to make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan available to the public on its Internet Web site, and requires a copy of the assessment and plan to be given free of charge to any person upon request.
Permits a private non-profit facility, under the common control of a single corporation or another entity, to file a consolidated plan if the distinct needs of the communities served by each hospital in the consolidated plan are identified, and if the plan addresses services in all the categories specified in this bill to be provided by each hospital or clinic under common control of the corporation or entity.
Requires a private non-profit facility to report community benefits in a consistent and comparable manner to all other private non-profit facilities.
Requires OSHPD to develop and adopt regulations by January 1, 2017, to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans required under this bill, and requires the director of OSHPD, immediately following the adoption of these regulations, to certify the adoption of the regulations in writing, post the written certification to OSHPD’s Internet Web site, and deliver it to the Secretary of State, the Secretary of the Senate, the Chief Clerk of the Assembly, and the Legislative Counsel.
Requires OSHPD to develop a standardized methodology for estimating the economic value of community benefits based on the cost to a private non-profit facility. Prohibits the economic value of community benefits to exceed the actual cost to a private non-profit facility, nor more than 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires OSHPD, in developing standards of reporting on community benefits, to conform, to the maximum extent possible, to Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reporting standards for those data elements reported to the IRS, but to also include those data elements required under this bill or other state laws, including charity care.
Requires a private non-profit facility to annually file with OSHPD its IRS Form 990, or its successor form, and requires OSHPD to post the form on its Internet Web site.
Requires OSHPD to make public, including on their Internet Web site, a community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans.
Requires OSHPD to maintain a public calendar of community benefit adoption meetings held by the governing board of each private non-profit facility, and requires notice of these meetings to be posted no later than 14 days prior to the meeting date.
Requires OSHPD to calculate and make public, for every year that a community benefits plan is submitted, the total value of community benefits provided by each facility.
Provides OSHPD the same ability to assess civil penalties for failure to comply with the reporting provisions of this bill as it already has for a facility’s failure to file other required reports.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. In exchange for their significant tax exemptions, California’s private non-profit hospitals are required to provide community benefits and charity care through programs and services aimed at improving community health and promoting wellness such as free nutrition classes, mobile health clinics, health screenings, and disease counseling. However, charity care and community benefits are not uniformly defined or measured. This ambiguity prevents California communities from determining if these hospitals are adequately serving their communities, a duty non-profit hospitals are required to fulfill under state and federal law. The Legislative Analyst’s Office found that there is currently no uniform definition or standard for “charity care” in state or federal statute. This lack of a clear benchmark has yielded inconsistent methodologies and incomplete reporting. Consequently, we cannot accurately measure nonprofit hospitals’ required financial investments in our communities. We give these hospitals favorable tax treatment, so it makes sense that we come together to establish an appropriate and transparent way to calculate the amount of community benefits we are getting in return. This bill makes no changes to how many community benefits a hospital provides, but it will increase accountability and provide a clearer picture of the level of community benefits invested back into our communities.
Background on non-profit hospitals and community benefit requirements. Non-profit hospitals have traditionally been exempt from federal income taxes based on the IRS’ definition of charity, with the IRS stating that, “the promotion of health is considered to be a charitable purpose. A non-profit organization whose purpose and activity are providing hospital care is promoting health and may, therefore, qualify as organized and operated in furtherance of a charitable purpose.” For purposes of California taxes, property owned by a non-profit organization that is used exclusively for religious, hospital, charitable, or scientific purposes is exempt from propriety taxes under what is known as the Welfare Exemption. State law also allows non-profit hospitals to be exempt from state income tax.
When the Legislature enacted the existing CBL in 1996, the Legislature found and declared that private non-profit hospitals meet certain needs of their communities through the provision of essential health care and other services, and that public recognition of their unique status has led to favorable tax treatment by the government. In exchange, the Legislature declared, non-profit hospitals assume a social obligation to provide community benefits in the public interest. The CBL enacted in 1996 requires non-profit hospitals to annually submit a “community benefits plan” to OSHPD, based on a “community needs assessment” that is required to be updated every three years. This CBL includes a definition of “community benefit,” which included charity care and the unreimbursed cost of providing services, but does not specifically exclude anything from the definition of community benefit, nor does it define “charity care” itself. While the law requires the plan to be submitted to OSHPD, it does require OSHPD to review the plans to ensure that hospitals are reporting data consistently, and OSHPD does not attempt to standardize these reports.
Senate Office of Research Report. In a report prepared by the Senate Office of Research (SOR) for an August 15, 2012 hearing of the Senate Select Committee on Charity Care and Non-profit Hospitals, about 247 of California's 387 private hospitals may be eligible for certain tax exemptions due to their non-profit status in exchange for providing various community benefits, such as charity care. However, these community benefits are not uniformly defined or measured. This ambiguity makes it challenging to hold hospitals accountable for the special tax benefits they receive and determine if they are providing meaningful community benefits. Furthermore, some studies show many investor-owned hospitals and public hospitals provide charity care and other community benefits similar to or greater than their non-profit counter parts. The SOR points out that the California Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO), in an analysis of the Charity Care Act of 2012, indicates that there is currently no uniform definition of charity care nor a requirement in State or federal law for non-profit hospitals to provide a certain amount of charity care or community benefit in order to maintain their tax exempt status. According to the LAO, of the private hospitals in California, about 30 percent are for-profits and about 70 percent are non-profits. The for-profit hospitals pay corporate income taxes to the state. Non-profit hospitals are exempt from State corporate income taxes, local sales taxes, and property taxes. The tax exemptions are intended to allow non-profit hospitals to use the funds that would have been paid in taxes to provide patient care, invest in their facilities and equipment, and implement other measures that would be beneficial to their delivery of healthcare services. The SOR report indicates that controversy exists in how charity care and community benefits are quantified. Some hospitals use a cost accounting methodology while others use a ratio that converts a hospital's listed charges to the actual cost of the services provided. SOR also reports that in 2008 the IRS revised Form 990 in an effort to provide transparency and accountability and keep pace with changes in the law with regard to the tax exempt sector. The new form requires non-profit hospitals to report their bad debt expenses and Medicare shortfalls, but separates these from community benefits.
ACA imposed new federal requirements on non-profit hospitals. With the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a new provision was added to Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code specific to hospitals. This new provision (subsection r), imposed new requirements that hospitals must meet in order to maintain their tax exempt status. Among the new requirements (temporary guidelines have been in place since the 2012 tax year, and the final regulations were just adopted in December 2014), are a requirement for hospitals to complete a community health needs assessment, and a requirement to establish a financial assistance policy. Generally speaking, the community health needs assessment is similar to California’s existing CBL. The community health needs assessment, along with an implementation strategy for meeting the health needs identified in the assessment, must be completed once every three years, and hospitals face a $50,000 federal excise tax for failure to comply with this requirement.
State Auditor Reports. In December of 2007, and then again in August of 2012, the Bureau of State Audits (BSA) published reports concerning whether non-profit hospitals were providing a public benefit that justifies their tax-exempt status. In the 2007 report, BSA concluded that when taken as a percentage of net patient revenues, the uncompensated care provided by non-profit and for-profit hospitals were not significantly different, both including and excluding Medi-Cal costs. BSA noted that benefits provided to the community, which only non-profit hospitals are required to report, differentiate non-profit hospitals from for-profit hospitals, but the categories of services and the associated economic value are not consistently reported among non-profit hospitals. BSA stated that although state law requires non-profit hospitals to submit a community benefit plan that describes the activities undertaken to address community needs and assign and report economic values to those benefits, state law does not mandate a uniform reporting standard, and as a result, hospitals are reporting their community benefits using different categories and methods for calculating their economic value. In its 2007 recommendations, BSA stated that, “If the Legislature expects plans to contain comparable and consistent data, it should consider enacting statutory requirements that prescribe a mandatory format and methodology for tax-exempt non-profit hospitals to follow when presenting community benefits in their plans.” In its 2012 report, BSA reiterated its conclusions regarding the lack of a statutory standard or methodology for hospitals to follow when calculating community benefits.
Charity Care Act of 2012. This initiative would have required certain non-profit hospitals to provide a minimum amount of charity care equal to at least five percent of net patient revenue, impose new data reporting requirements on certain non-profit hospitals, impose new administrative responsibilities on the Attorney General (AG) and give the AG authority to oversee and enforce the provisions of the measure. This measure would have gone into effect January 1, 2013, and been repealed on December 31, 2017. The initiative would have exempted non-profit hospitals that are part of an integrated non-profit health system or part of a safety-net non-profit health system as defined by the measure (Dignity Health and Kaiser Permanente) and it did not include multispecialty clinics. According to the LAO, about 36 percent of the State's non-profit hospitals would have been exempted from the requirements of the initiative. On May 2, 2012, the Los Angeles Times reported that the Service Employees International Union dropped the initiative along with another health care initiative as part of an agreement with California Hospital Association.
In
its analysis of the Charity Care Act of 2012, the LAO indicated the
measure could have resulted in both costs and savings to State and
local governments, depending on how the hospitals subject to the
measure responded to it. Their analysis finds that most of the
non-profit hospitals subject to the measure would have to increase
the amount of charity care they provide in order to meet its
requirements. To offset the additional costs of providing greater
amounts of charity care, hospitals subject to the measure could
employ a mix of different strategies.
Related legislation. AB 1046 (Dababneh), recasts California's hospital community benefits law to more closely align with federal community benefit reporting requirements. AB 1046 is scheduled to be heard in Assembly Health Committee on April 28, 2015.
Prior legislation. AB 503 (Wieckowski), of 2014, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 503 proposed to repeal the existing hospital community benefit law, and establishes a new hospital community law to require private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment, followed by a community benefits plan. Defined “community benefit” and other terms for purposes of this bill, and requires 90 percent of a private non-profit hospital’s community benefit moneys to be allocated to charity care and projects that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations, as defined. AB 503 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 1952 (Pan), of 2014, would have required non-profit hospitals to annually provide charity care amounting to five percent of the hospital's net patient revenue. AB 1952 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 1276 (Hernandez), Chapter 758, Statutes of 2014, revised the hospital fair billing program by making individuals who meet the income requirements eligible, even if they have received a discounted rate from the hospital as a result of third-party coverage. Defined “reasonable payment plan,” for purposes of both the hospital and emergency physician fair billing policies, as monthly payments that do not exceed 10 percent of a patient’s family income.
AB 975 (Wieckowski), of
2013, would have revised California's non-profit community benefits
requirements to include multispecialty clinics, narrowed the
activities that constitute community benefits, created a definition
of charity care, and required OSHPD to develop a standardized
methodology for calculating community benefits and to issue civil
penalties for noncompliance with filing requirements. AB
975 failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AB
1503 (Lieu), Chapter 445, Statutes of 2010, required emergency
physicians who provide emergency medical services in a hospital to
provide discounts to uninsured patients, established limits on the
expected payment for emergency medical services as specified, limited
debt-collection activities, and required hospitals to include a
written description of the hospital discount policy.
AB
2942 (Ma), of 2008, would have implemented the State Auditor’s 2007
recommendation for a standardized format and methodology to be used
when presenting community benefit information, among other
requirements. AB 2942
was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 350 (Runner), Chapter
347, Statutes of 2007, required the submission of hospital charity
care and discount-payment policies to OSHPD.
AB
774 (Chan), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2006, established Hospital Fair
Pricing Policies, which required every hospital to offer reduced
rates to uninsured and underinsured patients who may have low or
moderate income, and to provide policies that clearly state the
qualifications for free care and discounted payments.
AB
1045 (Frommer), Chapter 532, Statutes of 2005, revised the Payers’
Bill of Rights to require hospitals to provide information about
their financial assistance and charity care policies, as well as
contact information for a hospital employee or office to obtain
additional information.
SB 610 (Machado), of 2005, would
have clarified existing law regarding hospitals entitled to claim the
welfare exemption for property tax purposes by indicating a hospital
organization is deemed to be organized or operated for-profit if
operating revenues exceed operating expenses by more than 10 percent.
SB 610 was vetoed by
the Governor.
SB 24 (Ortiz), of 2005, would
have established charity care and reduced payment policies and
requirements as a condition for hospitals to maintain their
tax-exempt status.
SB 24 was held
on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB
379 (Ortiz), of 2004, would have required every hospital to have a
charity care policy and to provide that policy to patients and would
have required OSHPD to develop a uniform charity care application to
be used by all hospitals. SB
610 was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1627 (Frommer), Chapter 582, Statutes of 2003,
established the Payers’ Bill of Rights, which generally requires
certain hospitals to provide written or electronic copies of their
chargemaster, as specified.
SB 697 (Torres), Chapter 812,
Statutes of 1994, required non-profit hospitals to conduct community
needs assessments and develop community benefit plans and submit
those plans to OSHPD.
Support. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Nurses Association (CNA), the Greenling Institute, the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, and the California National Organization for Women. According to CNA, in 2010 alone, California’s cities and counties lost revenue and racked up expenses totaling more than $1 billion as a result of non-profit hospital tax exemptions and direct payments to hospitals in their geographic area for indigent care to compensate for the non-profit hospitals’ inadequate provision of charity care. CNA states this bill is a first step in holding non-profit hospitals accountable for the tremendous tax benefits they receive through their non-profit status. CHA states that this bill ensure that non-profit hospitals are providing, and accurately reporting, the charity care and community benefits they provide, a benefit far exceeding any additional oversight costs to OSHPD. CNA states that the goal of this bill is to end the questionable characterization of certain expenditures as charity care and community benefits, and will solve the problem of inconsistent accounting practices regarding charity care and create a standard definition. CNA quotes a Time Magazine article from February 2013 that stated “the 2,900 non-profit hospitals across the country, which are exempt from income taxes, actually end up averaging higher operating profit margins than the 1,000 for-profit hospitals after the for-profits’ income tax obligations are deducted. In health care, being non-profit produces more profit.” The Greenlining Institute states in support that various reports have separately concluded that the community benefit standard is vague and opaque, and that it is unclear whether these tax-exempt institutions are meeting their federal and state mandates to improve community health. The Greenlining Institute argues that this bill will create important opportunities to address issues of health equity through community benefit spending by requiring that hospitals locate a significant portion of their community benefit activities geographically within underserved and vulnerable communities. The California Rural Legal Assistance Fund and the California National Organization for Women both state in support that articles in the New England Journal of Medicine and Time Magazine found that a very small percentage of so-called community benefit spending actually goes to community health improvement programs and charity care once you deduct spending on public program shortfall from what nonprofit hospitals are totaling as community benefit, yet for-profit hospitals face similar shortfalls without the benefit of tax-exempt status.
Support if amended. (Both Health Access California and the California Pan-Ethnic Health Network submitted these letters prior to the most recent set of amendments, which address some of the issues raised in these letters. It is unknown how these amendments have affected the positions of these organizations.) Health Access California states that it supports this bill if it is further amended to provide greater clarity to the requirements for hospital community benefit plans. Health Access states that it strongly supports the intent of this bill that hospitals be required to spend a high proportion of community benefit moneys on the needs of underserved communities, and to involve the community in the development of community benefit plans. Health Access states that unfortunately, there are a number of drafting problems that need to be resolved before it will be able to fully support this bill. First, Health Access states that the way that community benefit is defined, it could be construed to include community benefits provided to affluent populations. Health Access also has concerns with the definition of charity care, and offers an alternative definition of charity care, which it believes would better align this bill with existing California law. Additionally, Health Access argues that the definition of underserved and vulnerable populations is overly broad and needs further specificity, and that by including a definition of vulnerable population used by the Office of Health Equity worsens the problem by counting all women as a “vulnerable” population, even if the woman is affluent, well-educated and of an ethnicity where women have better health outcomes. With regard to this bill’s requirement that 90 percent of community benefit moneys be allocated to serve either underserved and vulnerable populations “ or that address a specific need identified in the community needs assessment” could inadvertently allow a hospital to spend the entire amount on a “specific need” that is not targeted to the underserved or vulnerable. Health Access also points out that while both this bill and existing law require a community needs assessment every three years, this bill requires a community benefit plan be done every two years, while existing law requires the plan to be updated annually. Health Access suggests that for at least the next decade, as the transformation brought about by the ACA continues to play out, hospitals should continue to be required to update their plan every year. Finally, Health Access states that while it does not object to allowing a hospital under common control of a corporation to file a consolidated plan, the current language should be amended to ensure that each hospital covered by the consolidated plan identify the distinct needs of its own community and how the community benefit plan serves those needs.
The California Pan-Ethnic Health Network (CPEHN) also supports this bill if amended to provide greater clarity on the definition of underserved and vulnerable communities. CPEHN requests that the definition of vulnerable populations applies to those communities who are facing exposure to financial risk, and that in addition to including the use of “linguistic isolation,” that limited English proficiency be considered. Finally, CPEHN states that it is concerned that the bill as drafted provides too much flexibility for participants of a community health needs assessment to fund special projects outside of the needs of underserved and vulnerable populations. CPEHN states that it appreciates allowing participants some flexibility to identify specific community needs, but would urge the language be amended to guarantee that projects funded would target underserved and vulnerable populations that are facing financial risk.
Opposition. This bill is opposed by the California Hospital Association (CHA), which states it is concerned about the impact this bill would have on a hospital’s ability to determine and support organizations and community efforts to address the needs of vulnerable populations. According to CHA, California’s CBL has been in place and working since 1994, serves as a model for the ACA, and that this unnecessary legislation conflicts with provisions of the ACA and will increase costs for the state and for hospitals by creating inconsistent federal and state reporting requirements. Dignity Health states in opposition that in 2014, it provided $1.3 billion in community benefit, absorbed a Medicare shortfall of $674 million from cost, a Medi-Cal shortfall of $864 million (from cost even after the hospital provider fee), and provided $176 million in charity care. According to Dignity Health, as they are located in various communities throughout the state, they are keenly aware of the diversity of each community and are at the pulse of what makes each one so unique. Dignity states that it is proud of California’s leadership in the area of community benefit requirements, but believes this bill takes us backwards by creating inconsistent federal and state reporting requirements, increasing costs for both the state and for hospitals. Kaiser Permanente states in opposition that this bill defines “community benefit” in ways that were relevant before the ACA, but may not be now, and that the traditional view that “community benefit” should be comprised of free health care services to the uninsured is being reconsidered in light of the large number of people who will have health coverage. Kaiser also states that this bill does nothing to increase transparency, and that it disregards current state and federal laws that require hospitals to report detailed planning and charitable spending. Stanford Health Care states in opposition that hospitals work collaboratively with communities and stakeholders to assess local health needs and tailor services and investments to address each community’s specific needs. According to Stanford, this bill does nothing to strengthen successful community benefit partnerships, and could lead to program cutbacks throughout California, impacting the diverse and vulnerable populations they serve. In addition to numerous hospitals and hospital systems, this bill is also opposed by WEAVE, which states that it receives funding from its non-profit hospital partners, which provides funding to support their crisis stabilization programs for victims of domestic violence and sexual assault in the community. WEAVE states that without this funding it would be forced to turn away families seeking safe shelter, counseling services, and legal assistance.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Nurses Association (co-sponsor)
Greenlining
Institute (co-sponsor)
California
Rural Legal Assistance Foundation (co-sponsor)
California National Organization for Women (co-sponsor)
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association
Campaign for a Healthy California
Congress of California Seniors
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Guam Communications Network
National Union of Healthcare Workers
PolicyLink
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Six individuals
Oppose: Adventist Health
Alliance of Catholic Health Care
Arroyo Grande Community Hospital
Barlow Respiratory Hospital
Beverly Hospital
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hospital Association
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center
Central Valley General Hospital
Coalinga Regional Medical Center
Corona Regional Medical Center
Dignity Health
Dominican Hospital
Enloe Medical Center
Fairchild Medical Center
Family Service of Napa Valley
Feather River Hospital
French Hospital Medical Center
Health Education Council
Healthy Smiles for Kids of Orange County
Hemet Valley Medical Center
Kaiser Permanente
La Clinica de la Raza
Loma Linda University Health
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Mad River Community Hospital
Madera Community Hospital
Maple Counseling Center
Menifee Valley Medical Center
Mercy General Hospital
Methodist Hospital of Sacramento
Methodist Hospital of Southern California
North Bay Healthcare
O’Connor Hospital
Petaluma Valley Hospital
Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center
Providence Health and Services Southern California
Queen of the Valley Medical Center
Ravenswood Family Health Center
Redlands Community Hospital
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital
Santa Rosa Memorial Health
Sharp HealthCare
Simi Valley Hospital
St. Helena Hospital Napa Valley
St. Joseph Hospital in Orange
St. Louise Regional Hospital
St. Mary Medical Center in Fullerton
Stanford Health Care
Southern Mono Healthcare District dba Mammoth Hospital
Sutter Delta Medical Center
Sutter Health
Ukiah Valley Medical Center
ValleyCare Health System
WEAVE, Inc.
White Memorial Medical Center
Woodland Healthcare
-- END --
SB 346 (Wieckowski) Page 17 of 17
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 346
AUTHOR: |
Wieckowski |
||
VERSION: |
April 9, 2015 |
||
HEARING DATE: |
April 22, 2015 |
|
|
CONSULTANT: |
Vince Marchand |
||
SUBJECT: Health facilities: community benefits
SUMMARY: Repeals the existing hospital community benefit law, and establishes a new hospital community law to require private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment, followed by a community benefits plan. Defines “community benefit” and other terms for purposes of this bill, and requires 90 percent of a private non-profit hospital’s community benefit moneys to be allocated to charity care and projects that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations, as defined.
Existing law:
Establishes the hospital community benefit law (existing CBL), which establishes requirements on private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment and adopt a community benefits plan, to annually submit this community benefit plan to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD), along with a report of the economic value of community benefits provided in furtherance of the plan.
Defines “community benefit plan,” for purposes of the existing CBL, as a written document prepared for annual submission to OSHPD, that includes a description of the activities that the hospital has undertaken in order to address identified community needs within its mission and financial capacity, and the process by which the hospital developed the plan in consultation with the community.
Defines “community benefit,” for the purposes of the existing CBL, as a hospital’s activities that are intended to address community needs and priorities primarily through disease prevention and improvement of health status, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
Health care services rendered to vulnerable populations, including charity care and the unreimbursed cost of providing services to the uninsured, underinsured, and those eligible for Medi-Cal, Medicare, California Children’s Services Program, or county indigent programs;
The unreimbursed cost of services provided related to community-oriented wellness and health promotion, prevention services such as health screenings and immunizations, adult day care, child care, medical research, medical education, nursing and other professional training, home-delivered meals to the homebound, sponsorship of free food and shelter to the homeless, and outreach clinics in socioeconomically depressed areas;
Financial or in-kind support of public health programs;
Donation of funds, property, or other resources that contribute to a community priority;
Health care cost containment;
Enhancement of access to health care or related services that contribute to a healthier community;
Services offered without regard to financial return because they meet a need in the service area of the hospital; and,
Food, shelter, clothing, education, transportation, and other goods or services that help maintain a person’s health.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to complete, either alone or in conjunction with other health care providers, a community needs assessment evaluating the health needs of the community serviced by the hospital, that includes a process for consulting with community groups and local government officials, and to update the community needs assessment at least once every three years.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to annually adopt and update a community benefits plan for providing community benefits either alone, or in conjunction with other health care providers, or through other organizational arrangements. Requires the community benefits plan to include the following elements:
Mechanisms to evaluate the plan’s effectiveness, including a method for soliciting the views of the community served by the hospital;
Measurable objectives to be achieved within specified timeframes;
Community benefits categorized into the following categories: medical care services, other benefits for vulnerable populations, other benefits for the broader community, health research and training programs, and nonquantifiable benefits.
Requires private, non-profit hospitals, under the existing CBL, to annually submit its community benefit plan, including activities the hospital has undertaken in order to address community needs, to OSHPD, and to the extent practicable, assign and report the economic value of community benefits provided in furtherance of its plan.
This bill:
Repeals the existing CBL law, and establishes a new CBL for private non-profit hospitals and non-profit multispecialty clinics (collectively, non-profit facilities), as these facilities are defined. Makes the repeal of the old CBL law, and the operative date of the new CBL law, effective as of the date of the adoption of regulations by OSHPD prescribing a new standardized format for community benefits plans,
Requires, by January 1, 2018, each private non-profit facility to develop, in collaboration with the community benefits planning committee, a community health needs assessment that evaluates the health needs and resources of the community it serves. Requires facilities, prior to completing this assessment, to develop a community benefits statement that describes the facility’s commitment to developing, adopting, and implementing a community benefits program. Requires private non-profit facilities to file the community health needs assessment with OSHPD, and to update its community needs assessment at least every three years.
Requires, by April 1, 2018, each private non-profit facility to develop, in collaboration with the community, a community benefits plan designed to achieve all of the following outcomes:
Access to health care for members of underserved and vulnerable populations;
Addressing of the essential health care needs of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations;
Creation of measurable improvements in the health of the community, with particular attention to the needs of members of underserved and vulnerable populations.
Defines “community” as the service area or patient population for which a non-profit facility provides health care services. Prohibits a non-profit facility from defining its service area to exclude vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, medically underserved, low-income, or minority populations who are part of its patient populations, live in geographic areas in which its patient populations reside, or otherwise should be included based on the method the hospital facility uses to define its community.
Requires non-profit facilities, as part of the definition of “community” above, to create a health equity assessment based on a specified existing law list of 14 key factors relating to health and mental health disparities and inequities upon which the Office of Health Equity is required to base its demographic reports of health and mental health disparities and inequities.
Defines “community benefits” as the unreimbursed goods, services, activities, programs, and other resources provided by a non-profit facility that addresses community-identified health needs and concerns, and disparities related to its healthy equity assessment, particularly for people who are uninsured, underserved, or members of a vulnerable population, including, but not limited to, the following:
Charity care;
Shortfalls in Medi-Cal, the California Children’s Program, or county indigent programs at a cost up to 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or healthcare organizations;
The cost of community building activities, community health improvement services and community benefit operations, school health centers as defined, and health professions education and training provided without charge;
Amounts given, with no expectation of repayment, to employees for student loan repayment;
Subsidized health services for vulnerable populations;
Research;
Contributions to community groups;
Vaccination programs and services for low-income families;
Chronic illness prevention programs and services;
The 14 key factors relating to health and mental health disparities and inequities upon which the Office of Health Equity is required to base its demographic reports of health and mental health disparities and inequities; and,
Home-based health care programs or community-based mental health and outreach and assessment programs for low-income families (families with income less than or equal to 350 percent of the federal poverty level).
Excludes the following from the definition of “community benefits:”
The unreimbursed cost of providing services to those enrolled in Medicare or county indigent programs or any goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources program or activity for which there is direct offsetting revenue;
Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt;
Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or “chargemaster” rates by the health care provider.
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires a private non-profit facility, beginning after April 1, 2018, to submit to OSHPD a community benefits plan that conforms to this bill every two years, no later than 120 days after the end of the facility’s fiscal year. Requires the plan to include, if applicable, a report on the community benefits efforts of the preceding year, including the amounts and types of benefits provided, a description of the facility’s progress toward meeting its goals and objectives, and an evaluation of the plan’s effectiveness.
Defines “community building activities,” for purposes of the community benefit definition, as the cost of various kinds of community building activities, including physical improvements and housing, economic development, community support, environmental improvements, community health improvement advocacy, coalition building, workforce development, the 14 key factors relating to health and mental health disparities and inequities upon which the Office of Health Equity is required to base its demographic reports of health and mental health disparities and inequities, and leadership development and training for community members.
Defines “charity care,” for purposes of the community benefit definition, as the unreimbursed cost to a non-profit facility of providing services to the uninsured or underinsured, as well as providing health care services or items on an inpatient or outpatient basis to a financially qualified patient, as defined, with no expectation of payment.
Excludes from the definition of “charity care” any of the following:
Uncollected fees or accounts written off as bad debt;
Care provided to patients for which a public program or public or private grant funds pay for any of the charges for the care;
Contractual adjustments in the provision of health care services below the amount identified as gross charges or “chargemaster” rates by the health care provider;
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient or outpatient basis; and,
Any amount over 125 percent of the Medicare rate for providing, funding, or otherwise financially supporting health care services or items with no expectation of payment provided to financially qualified patients through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires the community benefits planning committee, as defined, to be composed of the following:
One of either the governing board of the hospital organization that operates the facility or other party authorized by that governing body, or the governing body of the hospital facility if the facility has its own governing body;
At least one individual from the local, tribal, or regional governmental public health department, or an equivalent department, with knowledge, information, or expertise relevant to the health needs of that community;
At least one individual from an underserved and vulnerable population, as defined;
Defines “direct offsetting revenue” as the revenue from goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, which offsets the total community benefit expense of the goods, services, activities, programs, or other resources, and excludes from this definition payments for Medi-Cal, the California Children’s Services Program, or county indigent programs.
Defines “non-profit multispecialty clinic” as a clinic, defined in existing law, that is operated by a non-profit corporation exempt from federal income taxation, as specified, that conducts medical research and health education and provides health care to its patients through a group of 40 or more physicians, who are independent contracts representing not less than 10 board-certified specialties, and not less than two-thirds of whom practice on a full-time basis at the clinic.
Defines “private non-profit hospital” as a private non-profit acute care hospital that has been determined to be exempt from taxation under the Internal Revenue Code, and exempts the following from this definition:
A district hospital organized and governed pursuant to the Local Health Care District Law, as specified, or a non-profit corporation that is affiliated with the health care district hospital owner by means of the district’s status as the nonprofit corporation’s sole corporate member;
A rural general acute care hospital, as defined;
A children’s hospital, as defined; and,
A multispecialty clinic operated by a for-profit hospital, regardless of its net revenue.
Defines “underserved population” or “vulnerable population” as any of the following:
A population that is exposed to medical or financial risk by virtue of being uninsured or underinsured, as defined, or eligible for Medi-Cal or county indigent programs;
A population including, but not limited to: a vulnerable community, as defined in a provision of existing law establishing the Office of Health Equity that includes women, racial or ethnic groups, incarcerated individuals, children, and lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and questioning communities, among others; individuals with low educational attainment, as measured by the percentage of the population with less than a high school diploma; and individuals who suffer from linguistic isolation, as measured by the percentage of households in which no one who is 14 years of age or older speaks English with greater than elementary proficiency;
A population that meets the definition of disadvantaged community pursuant to a provision of law that requires the California Environmental Protection Agency to identify communities based on certain criteria, including areas disproportionately affected by environmental pollution and other hazards; or
Other populations that are specifically identified in the community health needs assessment required under this bill.
Requires a private non-profit facility, in conducting its community health needs assessment, to solicit comments from, and meet with, local government officials, as well as representatives of vulnerable populations, including diverse racial, ethnic, cultural, and LGBTQQ communities, women’s health advocates, mental health advocates, health and mental health providers, community-based organizations and advocates, academic institutions, low-income and vulnerable consumers, health care providers, registered nurses, and community groups representing specified constituencies such as patients, labor, and seniors. Permits a facility to create a community benefits advisory committee for the purpose of soliciting community input.
Requires a private non-profit facility, in preparing its community health needs assessment, to use available public health data, and permits the facility to collaborate with other facilities and health care institutions in conducting community health needs assessments and to make use of exiting studies.
Requires private non-profit facilities, not later than 30 days prior to completing a community health needs assessment, to make a copy of the assessment available to the public for review and comment.
Requires private non-profit facilities to provide community benefits to the community as follows:
Requires a minimum of 90 percent of the total economic value of community benefits to be allocated to community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations or that address a specific need identified in the community health needs assessment. Permits, for purposes of this 90 percent allocation, community benefits that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations to include activities, such as health professions education and training, which are not provided exclusively to underserved and vulnerable populations, if the activity will improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations.
Requires a minimum of 25 percent of the total economic value of community benefits to be allocated to community building activities geographically located within underserved and vulnerable populations.
Permits community benefits to be allocated for projects that simultaneously meet both of the above criteria.
Requires private non-profit facilities, in developing a community benefits plan, to solicit comments from, and meet with, local government officials, including representatives of local public health departments, and to also solicit comments from, and meet with, health care providers, registered nurses, and community groups representing specified constituencies.
Requires a community benefits plan to include, at a minimum, all of the following:
A summary of the needs assessment and a statement of the community health care needs that will be addressed by the plan;
A list of the services the private non-profit facility intends to provide in the following year to address community health needs identified in the community health needs assessments, categorized under the following: charity care, as defined; other community benefits, as specified; and, community building activities;
A description of the target community or communities that the plan is intended to benefit;
An estimate of the economic value of the community benefits at cost that the private non-profit facility intends to provide;
A summary of the process used to elicit community participation in the community health needs assessment and community benefits plan design, and a description of the process for ongoing participation of community members in plan implementation and oversight;
A list of individuals, organizations, and government official consulted during the development of the plan;
A description of the intended impact on health outcomes attributable to the plan, including short- and long-term measurable goals and objectives;
Mechanisms to evaluate the plan’s effectiveness;
The name and title of the individual responsible for implementing the plan; and,
The names of individuals on the private non-profit facility’s governing board;
Permits a private non-profit facility to also report on bad debts and Medicare shortfalls, but prohibits these reports from being reported as community benefits and to be calculated based on hospital costs, not charges.
Requires the governing board of a private non-profit facility to adopt the community benefits plan at a meeting that is open to the public. Requires the governing board, no later than 30 days prior to the plan’s adoption, to make a draft of the plan available to the public, including on its Internet Web site, as well as a notice of the date, time, and location of the meeting at which the community benefits plan is to be voted on for adoption.
Permits a person or entity to file comments on a facility’s community benefits plan with OSHPD.
Requires a private non-profit facility to make its community health needs assessment and community benefits plan available to the public on its Internet Web site, and requires a copy of the assessment and plan to be given free of charge to any person upon request.
Permits a private non-profit facility, under the common control of a single corporation or another entity, to file a consolidated plan if the plan addresses services in all the categories specified in this bill to be provided by each hospital or clinic under common control of the corporation or entity.
Requires a private non-profit facility to report community benefits in a consistent and comparable manner to all other private non-profit facilities.
Requires OSHPD to develop and adopt regulations to prescribe a standardized format for community benefits plans required under this bill, and requires the director of OSHPD, immediately following the adoption of these regulations, to certify the adoption of the regulations in writing, post the written certification to OSHPD’s Internet Web site, and deliver it to the Secretary of State, the Secretary of the Senate, the Chief Clerk of the Assembly, and the Legislative Counsel.
Requires OSHPD to develop a standardized methodology for estimating the economic value of community benefits based on the cost to a private non-profit facility. Prohibits the economic value of community benefits to exceed the actual cost to a private non-profit facility, nor more than 125 percent of the Medicare rate for the health care services or items provided on an inpatient basis, an outpatient basis, or through other non-profit or public outpatient clinics, hospitals, or health care organizations.
Requires OSHPD, in developing standards of reporting on community benefits, to conform, to the maximum extent possible, to Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reporting standards for those data elements reported to the IRS, but to also include those data elements required under this bill or other state laws, including charity care.
Requires a private non-profit facility to annually file with OSHPD its IRS Form 990, or its successor form, and requires OSHPD to post the form on its Internet Web site.
Requires OSHPD to make public, including on their Internet Web site, a community health needs assessment and community benefits plan and any comments received regarding those assessments and plans.
Requires OSHPD to maintain a public calendar of community benefit adoption meetings held by the governing board of each private non-profit facility, and requires notice of these meetings to be posted no later than 14 days prior to the meeting date.
Requires OSHPD to calculate and make public, for every year that a community benefits plan is submitted, the total value of community benefits provided by each facility.
Provides OSHPD the same ability to assess civil penalties for failure to comply with the reporting provisions of this bill as it already has for a facility’s failure to file other required reports.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s statement. In exchange for their significant tax exemptions, California’s private non-profit hospitals are required to provide community benefits and charity care through programs and services aimed at improving community health and promoting wellness such as free nutrition classes, mobile health clinics, health screenings, and disease counseling. However, charity care and community benefits are not uniformly defined or measured. This ambiguity prevents California communities from determining if these hospitals are adequately serving their communities, a duty non-profit hospitals are required to fulfill under state and federal law. The Legislative Analyst’s Office found that there is currently no uniform definition or standard for “charity care” in state or federal statute. This lack of a clear benchmark has yielded inconsistent methodologies and incomplete reporting. Consequently, we cannot accurately measure nonprofit hospitals’ required financial investments in our communities. We give these hospitals favorable tax treatment, so it makes sense that we come together to establish an appropriate and transparent way to calculate the amount of community benefits we are getting in return. This bill makes no changes to how many community benefits a hospital provides, but it will increase accountability and provide a clearer picture of the level of community benefits invested back into our communities.
Background on non-profit hospitals and community benefit requirements. Non-profit hospitals have traditionally been exempt from federal income taxes based on the IRS’ definition of charity, with the IRS stating that, “the promotion of health is considered to be a charitable purpose. A non-profit organization whose purpose and activity are providing hospital care is promoting health and may, therefore, qualify as organized and operated in furtherance of a charitable purpose.” For purposes of California taxes, property owned by a non-profit organization that is used exclusively for religious, hospital, charitable, or scientific purposes is exempt from propriety taxes under what is known as the Welfare Exemption. State law also allows non-profit hospitals to be exempt from state income tax.
When the Legislature enacted the existing CBL in 1996, the Legislature found and declared that private non-profit hospitals meet certain needs of their communities through the provision of essential health care and other services, and that public recognition of their unique status has led to favorable tax treatment by the government. In exchange, the Legislature declared, non-profit hospitals assume a social obligation to provide community benefits in the public interest. The CBL enacted in 1996 requires non-profit hospitals to annually submit a “community benefits plan” to OSHPD, based on a “community needs assessment” that is required to be updated every three years. This CBL includes a definition of “community benefit,” which included charity care and the unreimbursed cost of providing services, but does not specifically exclude anything from the definition of community benefit, nor does it define “charity care” itself. While the law requires the plan to be submitted to OSHPD, it does require OSHPD to review the plans to ensure that hospitals are reporting data consistently, and OSHPD does not attempt to standardize these reports.
Senate Office of Research Report. In a report prepared by the Senate Office of Research (SOR) for an August 15, 2012 hearing of the Senate Select Committee on Charity Care and Non-profit Hospitals, about 247 of California's 387 private hospitals may be eligible for certain tax exemptions due to their non-profit status in exchange for providing various community benefits, such as charity care. However, these community benefits are not uniformly defined or measured. This ambiguity makes it challenging to hold hospitals accountable for the special tax benefits they receive and determine if they are providing meaningful community benefits. Furthermore, some studies show many investor-owned hospitals and public hospitals provide charity care and other community benefits similar to or greater than their non-profit counter parts. The SOR points out that the California Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO), in an analysis of the Charity Care Act of 2012, indicates that there is currently no uniform definition of charity care nor a requirement in State or federal law for non-profit hospitals to provide a certain amount of charity care or community benefit in order to maintain their tax exempt status. According to the LAO, of the private hospitals in California, about 30 percent are for-profits and about 70 percent are non-profits. The for-profit hospitals pay corporate income taxes to the state. Non-profit hospitals are exempt from State corporate income taxes, local sales taxes, and property taxes. The tax exemptions are intended to allow non-profit hospitals to use the funds that would have been paid in taxes to provide patient care, invest in their facilities and equipment, and implement other measures that would be beneficial to their delivery of healthcare services. The SOR report indicates that controversy exists in how charity care and community benefits are quantified. Some hospitals use a cost accounting methodology while others use a ratio that converts a hospital's listed charges to the actual cost of the services provided. SOR also reports that in 2008 the IRS revised Form 990 in an effort to provide transparency and accountability and keep pace with changes in the law with regard to the tax exempt sector. The new form requires non-profit hospitals to report their bad debt expenses and Medicare shortfalls, but separates these from community benefits.
ACA imposed new federal requirements on non-profit hospitals. With the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a new provision was added to Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code specific to hospitals. This new provision (subsection r), imposed new requirements that hospitals must meet in order to maintain their tax exempt status. Among the new requirements (temporary guidelines have been in place since the 2012 tax year, and the final regulations were just adopted in December 2014), are a requirement for hospitals to complete a community health needs assessment, and a requirement to establish a financial assistance policy. Generally speaking, the community health needs assessment is similar to California’s existing CBL. The community health needs assessment, along with an implementation strategy for meeting the health needs identified in the assessment, must be completed once every three years, and hospitals face a $50,000 federal excise tax for failure to comply with this requirement.
State Auditor Reports. In December of 2007, and then again in August of 2012, the Bureau of State Audits (BSA) published reports concerning whether non-profit hospitals were providing a public benefit that justifies their tax-exempt status. In the 2007 report, BSA concluded that when taken as a percentage of net patient revenues, the uncompensated care provided by non-profit and for-profit hospitals were not significantly different, both including and excluding Medi-Cal costs. BSA noted that benefits provided to the community, which only non-profit hospitals are required to report, differentiate non-profit hospitals from for-profit hospitals, but the categories of services and the associated economic value are not consistently reported among non-profit hospitals. BSA stated that although state law requires non-profit hospitals to submit a community benefit plan that describes the activities undertaken to address community needs and assign and report economic values to those benefits, state law does not mandate a uniform reporting standard, and as a result, hospitals are reporting their community benefits using different categories and methods for calculating their economic value. In its 2007 recommendations, BSA stated that, “If the Legislature expects plans to contain comparable and consistent data, it should consider enacting statutory requirements that prescribe a mandatory format and methodology for tax-exempt non-profit hospitals to follow when presenting community benefits in their plans.” In its 2012 report, BSA reiterated its conclusions regarding the lack of a statutory standard or methodology for hospitals to follow when calculating community benefits.
Charity Care Act of 2012. This initiative would have required certain non-profit hospitals to provide a minimum amount of charity care equal to at least five percent of net patient revenue, impose new data reporting requirements on certain non-profit hospitals, impose new administrative responsibilities on the Attorney General (AG) and give the AG authority to oversee and enforce the provisions of the measure. This measure would have gone into effect January 1, 2013, and been repealed on December 31, 2017. The initiative would have exempted non-profit hospitals that are part of an integrated non-profit health system or part of a safety-net non-profit health system as defined by the measure (Dignity Health and Kaiser Permanente) and it did not include multispecialty clinics. According to the LAO, about 36 percent of the State's non-profit hospitals would have been exempted from the requirements of the initiative. On May 2, 2012, the Los Angeles Times reported that the Service Employees International Union dropped the initiative along with another health care initiative as part of an agreement with California Hospital Association.
In
its analysis of the Charity Care Act of 2012, the LAO indicated the
measure could have resulted in both costs and savings to State and
local governments, depending on how the hospitals subject to the
measure responded to it. Their analysis finds that most of the
non-profit hospitals subject to the measure would have to increase
the amount of charity care they provide in order to meet its
requirements. To offset the additional costs of providing greater
amounts of charity care, hospitals subject to the measure could
employ a mix of different strategies.
Related legislation. AB 1046 (Dababneh), recasts California's hospital community benefits law to more closely align with federal community benefit reporting requirements. AB 1046 is scheduled to be heard in Assembly Health Committee on April 28, 2015.
Prior legislation. AB 503 (Wieckowski), of 2014, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 503 proposed to repeal the existing hospital community benefit law, and establishes a new hospital community law to require private non-profit hospitals to complete a community needs assessment, followed by a community benefits plan. Defined “community benefit” and other terms for purposes of this bill, and requires 90 percent of a private non-profit hospital’s community benefit moneys to be allocated to charity care and projects that improve community health for underserved and vulnerable populations, as defined. AB 503 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 1952 (Pan), of 2014, would have required non-profit hospitals to annually provide charity care amounting to five percent of the hospital's net patient revenue. AB 1952 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 1276 (Hernandez), Chapter 758, Statutes of 2014, revised the hospital fair billing program by making individuals who meet the income requirements eligible, even if they have received a discounted rate from the hospital as a result of third-party coverage. Defined “reasonable payment plan,” for purposes of both the hospital and emergency physician fair billing policies, as monthly payments that do not exceed 10 percent of a patient’s family income.
AB 975 (Wieckowski), of
2013, would have revised California's non-profit community benefits
requirements to include multispecialty clinics, narrowed the
activities that constitute community benefits, created a definition
of charity care, and required OSHPD to develop a standardized
methodology for calculating community benefits and to issue civil
penalties for noncompliance with filing requirements. AB
975 failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AB
1503 (Lieu), Chapter 445, Statutes of 2010, required emergency
physicians who provide emergency medical services in a hospital to
provide discounts to uninsured patients, established limits on the
expected payment for emergency medical services as specified, limited
debt-collection activities, and required hospitals to include a
written description of the hospital discount policy.
AB
2942 (Ma), of 2008, would have implemented the State Auditor’s 2007
recommendation for a standardized format and methodology to be used
when presenting community benefit information, among other
requirements. AB 2942
was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 350 (Runner), Chapter
347, Statutes of 2007, required the submission of hospital charity
care and discount-payment policies to OSHPD.
AB
774 (Chan), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2006, established Hospital Fair
Pricing Policies, which required every hospital to offer reduced
rates to uninsured and underinsured patients who may have low or
moderate income, and to provide policies that clearly state the
qualifications for free care and discounted payments.
AB
1045 (Frommer), Chapter 532, Statutes of 2005, revised the Payers’
Bill of Rights to require hospitals to provide information about
their financial assistance and charity care policies, as well as
contact information for a hospital employee or office to obtain
additional information.
SB 610 (Machado), of 2005, would
have clarified existing law regarding hospitals entitled to claim the
welfare exemption for property tax purposes by indicating a hospital
organization is deemed to be organized or operated for-profit if
operating revenues exceed operating expenses by more than 10 percent.
SB 610 was vetoed by
the Governor.
SB 24 (Ortiz), of 2005, would
have established charity care and reduced payment policies and
requirements as a condition for hospitals to maintain their
tax-exempt status.
SB 24 was held
on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB
379 (Ortiz), of 2004, would have required every hospital to have a
charity care policy and to provide that policy to patients and would
have required OSHPD to develop a uniform charity care application to
be used by all hospitals. SB
610 was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1627 (Frommer), Chapter 582, Statutes of 2003,
established the Payers’ Bill of Rights, which generally requires
certain hospitals to provide written or electronic copies of their
chargemaster, as specified.
SB 697 (Torres), Chapter 812,
Statutes of 1994, required non-profit hospitals to conduct community
needs assessments and develop community benefit plans and submit
those plans to OSHPD.
Support. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Nurses Association (CNA), the Greenling Institute, the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, and the California National Organization for Women. According to CNA, in 2010 alone, California’s cities and counties lost revenue and racked up expenses totaling more than $1 billion as a result of non-profit hospital tax exemptions and direct payments to hospitals in their geographic area for indigent care to compensate for the non-profit hospitals’ inadequate provision of charity care. CNA states this bill is a first step in holding non-profit hospitals accountable for the tremendous tax benefits they receive through their non-profit status. CHA states that this bill ensure that non-profit hospitals are providing, and accurately reporting, the charity care and community benefits they provide, a benefit far exceeding any additional oversight costs to OSHPD. CNA states that the goal of this bill is to end the questionable characterization of certain expenditures as charity care and community benefits, and will solve the problem of inconsistent accounting practices regarding charity care and create a standard definition. CNA quotes a Time Magazine article from February 2013 that stated “the 2,900 non-profit hospitals across the country, which are exempt from income taxes, actually end up averaging higher operating profit margins than the 1,000 for-profit hospitals after the for-profits’ income tax obligations are deducted. In health care, being non-profit produces more profit.” The Greenlining Institute states in support that various reports have separately concluded that the community benefit standard is vague and opaque, and that it is unclear whether these tax-exempt institutions are meeting their federal and state mandates to improve community health. The Greenlining Institute argues that this bill will create important opportunities to address issues of health equity through community benefit spending by requiring that hospitals locate a significant portion of their community benefit activities geographically within underserved and vulnerable communities. The California Rural Legal Assistance Fund and the California National Organization for Women both state in support that articles in the New England Journal of Medicine and Time Magazine found that a very small percentage of so-called community benefit spending actually goes to community health improvement programs and charity care once you deduct spending on public program shortfall from what nonprofit hospitals are totaling as community benefit, yet for-profit hospitals face similar shortfalls without the benefit of tax-exempt status.
Support if amended. Health Access California states that it supports this bill if it is further amended to provide greater clarity to the requirements for hospital community benefit plans. Health Access states that it strongly supports the intent of this bill that hospitals be required to spend a high proportion of community benefit moneys on the needs of underserved communities, and to involve the community in the development of community benefit plans. Health Access states that unfortunately, there are a number of drafting problems that need to be resolved before it will be able to fully support this bill. First, Health Access states that the way that community benefit is defined, it could be construed to include community benefits provided to affluent populations. Health Access also has concerns with the definition of charity care, and offers an alternative definition of charity care, which it believes would better align this bill with existing California law. Additionally, Health Access argues that the definition of underserved and vulnerable populations is overly broad and needs further specificity, and that by including a definition of vulnerable population used by the Office of Health Equity worsens the problem by counting all women as a “vulnerable” population, even if the woman is affluent, well-educated and of an ethnicity where women have better health outcomes. With regard to this bill’s requirement that 90 percent of community benefit moneys be allocated to serve either underserved and vulnerable populations “ or that address a specific need identified in the community needs assessment” could inadvertently allow a hospital to spend the entire amount on a “specific need” that is not targeted to the underserved or vulnerable. Health Access also points out that while both this bill and existing law require a community needs assessment every three years, this bill requires a community benefit plan be done every two years, while existing law requires the plan to be updated annually. Health Access suggests that for at least the next decade, as the transformation brought about by the ACA continues to play out, hospitals should continue to be required to update their plan every year. Finally, Health Access states that while it does not object to allowing a hospital under common control of a corporation to file a consolidated plan, the current language should be amended to ensure that each hospital covered by the consolidated plan identify the distinct needs of its own community and how the community benefit plan serves those needs.
The California Pan-Ethnic Health Network (CPEHN) also supports this bill if amended to provide greater clarity on the definition of underserved and vulnerable communities. CPEHN requests that the definition of vulnerable populations applies to those communities who are facing exposure to financial risk, and that in addition to including the use of “linguistic isolation,” that limited English proficiency be considered. Finally, CPEHN states that it is concerned that the bill as drafted provides too much flexibility for participants of a community health needs assessment to fund special projects outside of the needs of underserved and vulnerable populations. CPEHN states that it appreciates allowing participants some flexibility to identify specific community needs, but would urge the language be amended to guarantee that projects funded would target underserved and vulnerable populations that are facing financial risk.
Opposition. This bill is opposed by the California Hospital Association (CHA), which states it is concerned about the impact this bill would have on a hospital’s ability to determine and support organizations and community efforts to address the needs of vulnerable populations. According to CHA, California’s CBL has been in place and working since 1994, serves as a model for the ACA, and that this unnecessary legislation conflicts with provisions of the ACA and will increase costs for the state and for hospitals by creating inconsistent federal and state reporting requirements. Dignity Health states in opposition that in 2014, it provided $1.3 billion in community benefit, absorbed a Medicare shortfall of $674 million from cost, a Medi-Cal shortfall of $864 million (from cost even after the hospital provider fee), and provided $176 million in charity care. According to Dignity Health, as they are located in various communities throughout the state, they are keenly aware of the diversity of each community and are at the pulse of what makes each one so unique. Dignity states that it is proud of California’s leadership in the area of community benefit requirements, but believes this bill takes us backwards by creating inconsistent federal and state reporting requirements, increasing costs for both the state and for hospitals. Kaiser Permanente states in opposition that this bill defines “community benefit” in ways that were relevant before the ACA, but may not be now, and that the traditional view that “community benefit” should be comprised of free health care services to the uninsured is being reconsidered in light of the large number of people who will have health coverage. Kaiser also states that this bill does nothing to increase transparency, and that it disregards current state and federal laws that require hospitals to report detailed planning and charitable spending. Stanford Health Care states in opposition that hospitals work collaboratively with communities and stakeholders to assess local health needs and tailor services and investments to address each community’s specific needs. According to Stanford, this bill does nothing to strengthen successful community benefit partnerships, and could lead to program cutbacks throughout California, impacting the diverse and vulnerable populations they serve. In addition to numerous hospitals and hospital systems, this bill is also opposed by WEAVE, which states that it receives funding from its non-profit hospital partners, which provides funding to support their crisis stabilization programs for victims of domestic violence and sexual assault in the community. WEAVE states that without this funding it would be forced to turn away families seeking safe shelter, counseling services, and legal assistance.
Policy comments and drafting concerns
Health equity assessment. Within the definition of the term “community,” recent amendments require nonprofit facilities to “create a health equity assessment” based on certain factors that are specified in a provision of existing law that established the Office of Health Equity. As drafted, this appears to be an entirely new assessment, in addition to the requirement to conduct a health needs assessment. The author has indicated this was not the intent of this amendment, and is willing to either revise or remove this language.
Definition of “community benefits” is confusing. As drafted, the definition of community benefits states that it includes, but is not limited to, a long list of various services and costs. Some of these costs are limited to those provided to low-income families, but because of the way this sentence is structured, it is unclear to which costs and services this limitation applies. This sentence should probably be re-drafted to be in the form of a numbered list, so that what is included as a community benefit is more clearly articulated.
Implementation date depends on OSHPD. While this bill requires non-profit facilities to conduct a community needs assessment by January 1, 2018, other provisions of this bill state that the new CBL does not go into effect until OSHPD adopts regulations establishing a standardized format for community benefit plans. As there is no date certain for OSHPD to adopt these new regulations, the author may wish to either delay the requirement for the new community needs assessment until the January following the adoption of the regulations, or place a date certain on OSHPD to complete these regulations in advance of January 1, 2018.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Nurses Association (co-sponsor)
Greenlining
Institute (co-sponsor)
California
Rural Legal Assistance Foundation (co-sponsor)
California National Organization for Women (co-sponsor)
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
National Union of Healthcare Workers
PolicyLink
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Six individuals
Oppose: Adventist Health
Alliance of Catholic Health Care
Arroyo Grande Community Hospital
Barlow Respiratory Hospital
Beverly Hospital
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hospital Association
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center
Central Valley General Hospital
Coalinga Regional Medical Center
Corona Regional Medical Center
Dignity Health
Dominican Hospital
Fairchild Medical Center
Feather River Hospital
French Hospital Medical Center
Health Education Council
Healthy Smiles for Kids of Orange County
Hemet Valley Medical Center
Kaiser Permanente
Loma Linda University Health
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Madera Community Hospital
Maple Counseling Center
Menifee Valley Medical Center
Mercy General Hospital
Methodist Hospital of Sacramento
Methodist Hospital of Southern California
North Bay Healthcare
O’Connor Hospital
Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center
Providence Health and Services Southern California
Queen of the Valley Medical Center
Ravenswood Family Health Center
Redlands Community Hospital
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital
Sharp HealthCare
Simi Valley Hospital
St. Helena Hospital Napa Valley
St. Joseph Hospital in Orange
St. Louise Regional Hospital
St. Mary Medical Center in Fullerton
Stanford Health Care
Southern Mono Healthcare District dba Mammoth Hospital
Sutter Delta Medical Center
Sutter Health
Ukiah Valley Medical Center
ValleyCare Health System
WEAVE, Inc.
White Memorial Medical Center
Woodland Healthcare
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):