AB 1360: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-07-02
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program service operated by a transportation network company or a charter-party carrier of passengers that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the vehicle seats no more than 7 passengers, not including the driver, is operated by a participating driver, as defined, is not used to provide public transit services or carry passengers over a fixed route, and is not used to provide pupil transportation services or public paratransit services, and the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program operated by a transportation network company that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the vehicle seats no more than 7 passengers, not including the driver, is operated by a participating driver, as defined, is not used to provide public transit services or carry passengers over a fixed route, and is not used to provide pupil transportation services or public paratransit services, and the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program operated by a transportation network company that arranges a ride on a prearranged route prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the vehicle seats no more than 7 persons, passengers, not including the driver, is operated by a participating driver, as defined, is not used to provide public transit services or carry passengers over a fixed route, and is not used to provide pupil transportation services or public paratransit services, and the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program operated by a transportation network company that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the vehicle seats no more than 7 persons, including the driver, is operated by a participating driver, as defined, is not used to provide public transit services or carry passengers over a fixed route, and is not used to provide pupil transportation services or public paratransit services, and the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program operated by a transportation network company that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the vehicle seats no more than 7 persons, including the driver, is operated by a participating driver, as defined, and the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers Act generally requires charges for transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time-of-use basis, rather than on an individual-fare basis, subject to certain exemptions.
This bill would also exempt from these provisions a rideshare program operated by a transportation network company that arranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged to a single passenger traveling alone.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded, that shall be computed on an individual-fare basis, except as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)(1)A rideshare program service operated by a transportation network company or charter-party carrier of passengers subject to this chapter that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that all of the following requirements are met:
(A)The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, not including the driver.
(B)The driver is a participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431.
(C)The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
(D)The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
(E)The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
(F)The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
(2)This subdivision does not change the insurance requirements established under Section 5433 for a transportation network company and any participating driver. This subdivision does not change the insurance limitations set forth in Section 5434 or the requirements set forth in Section 5435.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded, that shall be computed on an individual-fare basis, except as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)(1)A rideshare program operated by a transportation network company subject to this chapter that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that all of the following requirements are met:
(A)The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, not including the driver.
(B)The driver is a participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431.
(C)The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
(D)The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
(E)The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
(F)The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
(2)This subdivision does not change the insurance requirements established under Section 5433 for a transportation network company and any participating driver. This subdivision does not change the insurance limitations set forth in Section 5434. 5434 or the requirements set forth in Section 5435.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded, that shall be computed on an individual-fare basis, except as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)(1)A rideshare program operated by a transportation network company subject to this chapter that arranges a ride on a prearranged route prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that all of the following requirements are met:
(1)
(A)The vehicle seats no more than seven persons, passengers, not including the driver.
(2)
(B)The driver is a participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431.
(3)
(C)The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
(4)
(D)The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
(5)
(E)The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
(6)
(F)The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
(2)This subdivision does not change the insurance requirements established under Section 5433 for a transportation network company and any participating driver. This subdivision does not change the insurance limitations set forth in Section 5434.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded, that shall be computed on an individual-fare basis, except as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)A rideshare program operated by a transportation network company subject to this chapter that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that (1) the all of the following requirements are met:
(1)The vehicle seats no more than seven persons, including the driver, (2) the driver.
(2)The driver is a participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431, and (3) the 5431.
(3)The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
(4)The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
(5)The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
(6)The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded, that shall be computed on an individual-fare basis, except as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)A rideshare program operated by a transportation network company subject to this chapter that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that (1) the vehicle seats no more than seven persons, including the driver, (2) the driver is a participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431, and (3) the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier of passengers shall be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no charter-party carrier of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract, agree, or arrange to charge, or demand or receive compensation, contract for, agree to, or demand or receive compensation in an amount, or arrange to charge an amount, for the transportation offered or afforded afforded, that shall be computed, charged, or assessed computed on an individual-fare basis, except schoolbus as follows:
(a)Schoolbus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools and except operators schools.
(b)Operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5384.
(c)A rideshare program operated by a transportation network company subject to this chapter that arranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, provided that the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 27, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 16, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 2, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E., U., & C. |
| Jul 1, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on E., U., & C. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 30). |
| Jun 15, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 4, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on T. & H. and E., U., & C. |
| May 22, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 73. Noes 0. Page 1544.) |
| May 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 14, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 12, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (May 5). |
| Apr 30, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 27, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 22, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (April 20). |
| Apr 15, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on U. & C. |
| Apr 14, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on U. & C. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on U. & C. and P. & C.P. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 30, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Energy, Utilities and Communications] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2015 | AB 1360 TING Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 5, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 20, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Commerce |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1360 Hearing Date: 6/27/2016
Author: | Ting | ||
Version: | 7/2/2015 As Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
DIGEST: This bill allows charter-party carriers of passengers, including transportation network companies, to charge individual fares, rather than a single group fare when providing carpool services.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers’ Act generally requires charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier (CPC) to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis or on a combination thereof. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. However, no CPC of passengers shall, directly or through an agent or otherwise, nor shall any broker, contract, agree, or arrange to charge, or demand or receive compensation, for the transportation offered or afforded that shall be computed, charged, or assessed on an individual-fare basis, except school bus contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools and except operators of round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted under a certificate subject to Section 5371.1, or a permit issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 5364. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
- Directs the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to issue permits or certificates to CPCs, investigate complaints against carriers, and cancel, revoke, or suspend permits and certificates for specific violations. (Public Utilities Code §5387)
- Defines “charter-party carrier of passengers” as every person engaged in the transportation of persons by motor vehicle for compensation, whether in common or contract carriage, over any public highway in the state. (Public Utilities Code §5360)
- Defines a “transportation network company (TNC)” to mean an organization, including, but not limited to, a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, sole proprietor, or any entity operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an online-enabled application or platform to connect passengers with drivers using a personal vehicle. (Public Utilities Code §5431)
- Restricts CPCs from offering the transportation computed, charged or assessed on an individual-fare basis. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
- Exempts contractors from the prohibition to assess individual fares who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools and except operators. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
- Exempts a round-trip sightseeing tour service conducted with an authorized certificate or permit from the prohibition to assess individual fares. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
This bill:
- Exempts CPCs, including TNCs, that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, from the prohibition to charge individual fares, provided that all the requirement are met:
- The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, excluding the driver.
- The driver is a participating driver of a TNC.
- The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
- The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
- The individual fare is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a traveling alone.
- States that this subdivision does not change the insurance requirements established for a TNC and any participating driver.
Background
Passenger carriers. California law has disparate regulations for different modes of passenger transportation for compensation, including taxi services, which are regulated by cities and counties, and CPC and passenger stage companies (PSC) which are regulated by the CPUC. The CPUC regulates most, but not all, passenger carriers. Passenger carriers include services, such as passenger stage corporations and CPC. PSCs are services that provide transportation to the general public on an individual fare basis, such as scheduled bus operators, which are buses that operate on a fixed route and scheduled services, or airport shuttles, which operate on an on-call door-to-door share the ride service. CPCs are services that allow a vehicle and driver to be chartered, on a prearranged basis, for the exclusive use of an individual or group. Charges are based on the mileage or time of use, or a combination of both. The CPUC does not regulate the rates for CPCs, but it is authorized to do so. Types of CPCs include limousines, tour buses, sightseeing services, and charter and party buses. The CPUC requires CPC to meet a number of requirements before an operating permit or certificate is issued. For example, the CPUC requires sufficient proof of financial responsibility, a preventative maintenance program for all vehicles, a safety education and training program, and regular checks of the driving records of all persons operating vehicles used in transportation for compensation.
Taxicab and other transportation services. Taxicabs are excluded from the definition of CPCs and are regulated by cities or counties. And additional key distinction between CPCs services and taxicab services is that CPCs services must be prearranged, while taxicabs are allowed to pick up passengers via street hails, including at curbsides. In addition to taxicabs and PSCs, other transportation services that are not considered CPCs include: transportation services licensed and operating wholly within the limits of a single city or city and county, transportation services contracted to transport school students, publicly owned transit systems, passenger vehicles carrying passengers on a noncommercial enterprise basis, vehicles used exclusively to provide medical transportation, and others.
Enter TNCs. In 2010, a new model of transportation services was introduced in San Francisco. Now known as TNCs, these original companies, including UberCab, allowed patrons to prearrange transportation services through an online application on their smartphone or computer. Patrons would request a ride to a predetermined location and the application would connect them with a TNC driver. Payment is processed through the application so that no physical financial transaction occurs during the trip itself between the patron and the driver. The TNC takes a commission on each trip. TNCs have grown dramatically, with a reported 120,000 drivers across the state for one company, according to their testimony to this committee. The entrance of TNCs into the transportation for-hire market has disrupted the sector. TNCs are successfully competing with taxi cabs, limousines, and other regulated transit operators. TNCs enjoy differing regulations as compared to taxicabs, including the ability to set their own fares, flexibility to increase supply, and, generally less stringent requirements – including those related to vehicle inspections, driver background checks, insurance coverage, driver training and others. Whereas taxicabs are regulated by locals, TNCs are regulated at the state level by the CPUC.
Cease and desist orders ignored. Back in June 2010, then-UberCab was utilizing its application platform to help prearrange rides for patrons of CPUC licensed charter-party carriers, particularly limousines and towncars. However, as a new service that didn’t fit very well within the existing regulatory framework – not a taxi not a CPC – the CPUC and San Francisco Metropolitan Transportation Authority issued a “cease-and-desist” order against Uber. The order directed Uber to stop advertising and cease its operations until it had acquired a valid permit to operate from the CPUC. However, even under threat of penalties (at $1,000 per day) and potential prison time, UberCab continued to operate. In 2012, Sidecar and Lyft were launched as new app based prearranged transportation services, except that these companies used individuals who weren’t licensed with the CPUC, drove their personal vehicles, and operated on a donations basis. About a month after Lyft was launched, on September 2012, the CPUC issued “cease-and-desist” orders against Sidecar and Lyft. Once again, the companies remained on the road operating their services. In the spring of 2013, Uber transformed its business model to compete against Lyft and SideCar. In the face of protest from its existing Uber Black drivers who drove CPUC-licensed vehicles, Uber expanded to Uber-X, allowing non-CPUC licensed individuals to drive their personal vehicles to transport passengers using the Uber platform. In late 2012, both Lyft and SideCar would abandon the donations-based fees and move to a minimum fee approach.
CPUC takes a different tack. In December 2012, after its “cease and desist” orders had largely been ignored by the TNCs, the CPUC announced it would open a formal proceeding to evaluate services like Lyft, SideCar and Uber. By January 2013, about one month later, the CPUC announced it had reached an agreement with Uber whereby Uber would continue to operate as the CPUC underwent its proceeding. The CPUC would also drop its $20,000 penalty against Uber. In September 2013, the CPUC formally announced it would recognize these app-based transportations services as a new category of CPCs and TNCs. The CPUC required each TNC (not each driver) to register with the CPUC, require criminal background checks of all its drivers, and specified insurance requirements. The CPUC also acknowledged it would open a second phase to consider effects on limousines and other CPCs and the need to update transportation rules, including any direction from the legislature.
CPUC warns against fare-splitting. In 2014, Uber, Lyft and SideCar were advertising new services known as “UberPool,” “Lyft Line,” and “Shared Rides,” respectively. These services allow a rider the option to select a discounted ride where they are matched with another rider travelling to a similar destination or a destination along a similar route. When the ride is over, the ride-hailing company’s software electronically collects the fare on behalf of the driver. In response to reports and advertisement of these new services which charge individual fares for a shared ride, in September of 2014, the CPUC sent letters to the TNCs, including Uber, Lyft, and SideCar, warning against the companies’ advertisement of new services that allow for fare-splitting between riders. The CPUC warned that such activity isn’t allowed under the CPC legal framework and would require a different type of permit under a different model. The CPUC stated that such a business plan is prohibited under California law, citing Public Utilities Code §5401, which “prohibits a charter party carrier from charging passengers on an ‘individual-fare basis’” – the section of the statutes TNCs are looking to change in AB 1360. According the companies, these fare-splitting services represent a majority of the rides they provide in some metropolitan areas, including San Francisco.
Recent CPUC decision. After the warnings were issued, the TNCs responded by asserting that Public Utilities §5401 was not written to prevent the types of carpooling service offered by “uber POOL,” “Lyft Line,” and “Shared Rides.” In contrast to their earlier warning, in March, the CPUC voted, 4-1, to allow TNCs to conduct fare-splitting activities under the CPCs license. Specifically, the proposed decision states: “We acknowledge that this evolution in the passenger carrier industry is a new means of offering passengers a way to split fares while still paying for the time and distance traveled that was not possible when Public Utilities Code §5401 was enacted, and on that basis, the statute lacks clarity and would benefit from modernization.” Moreover, the proposed decision asserts that based on the record the CPUC does not find any public policy or safety objectives that would be impaired by allowing TNCs to engage in fare-splitting services. However, the CPUC also required additional reporting requirements of the TNCs in exchange for authorization to offer the fare-splitting services. Specifically, the CPUC is requiring TNCs offering a fare-splitting service to report on complaints, incidents, the cause of each incident, and the amount paid for compensation to any party in each incident via a certified, under penalty of perjury, submission to the CPUC. The CPUC requires the TNC to submit their waybills that document that the fares for the fare-splitting services are calculated on either a vehicle mileage or a time of use basis, or a combination thereof.
Environmental benefits and traffic congestion relief? The TNCs claim that the fare-splitting services help to reduce traffic congestion, and the associated air pollution and fossil fuel usage that would otherwise materialize without the fare-splitting services. On cursory review, it would seem possible that there may be some potential traffic-relief and air quality benefits to fare-splitting services. However, as was relayed by testimony from academic experts at our joint committee oversight hearing on the Ride-hailing Disruption in February, there are many variables that affect whether TNC fare-splitting services provide congestion relief and associated environmental benefits. These variables include: the pollution from the vehicle used as compared to the vehicle that would have been used, whether the TNC driver drove more miles to get a matched ride(s), whether public transit trips were forgone, whether the option for the fare-splitting rides induced more trips than would have been made, whether these rides are replacing bicycling or walking, and others. In its proposed the decision, the CPUC also stated that they lacked sufficient data and evidence to corroborate the TNC claims. Testimony from Dr. Susan Shaheen, co-director, Transportation Sustainability Research Center, University of California Berkeley, at our joint oversight committee hearing in February suggests these variables may play out differently based on a given locality and existing land use and public transit patterns. Dr. Shaheen is conducting a study of TNCs related to potential environmental and traffic impacts whose findings are expected to be released as early as late this year.
This bill was incorrectly amended by the Senate Committee on Transportation and Housing. Per the Senate Committee on Transportation and Housing: the author and committee may wish to consider striking line 26 (B) on page 2, otherwise the exemption will only apply to TNC charter-party carriers, not charter-party carriers more broadly.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 828 (Low, 2015) exempts vehicles operating in conjunction with TNCs from the definition of commercial vehicle and requires an investigation and report by the CPUC, in consultation with the DMV, on the transportation for-hire services. The bill is waiting to be considered in Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 612 (Nazarian, 2014) would have required charter-party carriers to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles Employer Pull Notice system and to submit all drivers to a Department of Justice criminal background check. The bill was held in the Assembly Committee on Transportation.
AB 1422 (Cooper, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2015) required transportation network companies to participate in the DMV employer pull-notice system to regularly check the driving records of a participating driver.
AB 1610 (Committee on Budget, 2016) would among other items, increase the annual vehicle registration fee by $10 per registration to fund state highway and local road construction, maintenance and mitigation and associated administrative costs. The bill is in the Assembly awaiting a concurrence vote.
AB 2673 (Gatto, 2016) would define a personal vehicle as a vehicle that is used by a participating driver to provide prearranged transportation services for compensation, is owned, leased, rented, or otherwise authorized for use for any period of time by the participating driver, meets all inspection and other safety requirements imposed by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), and is not a taxicab or a limousine. The bill is scheduled to be heard by this committee.
AB 2293 (Bonilla, Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014) established guidelines for insurance coverage for TNCs to ensure personal and financial safety of consumers.
SB 1035 (Hueso, 2016) would have instituted a number of public safety and consumer protection requirements on TNCs. The bill failed passage in the Senate Committee on Transportation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT:
The Internet Association (Source)
TechNet (Source)
Bay Area Council
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California League of Conservation Voters
Caltrain
City of Los Angeles
Clean Coalition
Circulate San Diego
Climate Resolve
Coalition for Clean Air
County of Orange Supervisor, 2nd District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Greenbelt Alliance
Lyft, Inc.
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Natural Resources Defense Council
Orange County Business Council
Planning and Conservation League
San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Transit Riders
Sidecar
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Southern California Association of Governments
SPUR
TransForm
Travelers United
Uber Technologies, Inc.
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
OPPOSITION:
Greater California Livery Association
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author’s office states: “currently, laws governing charter party services such as TNC’s prevent them from charging passengers individual fares for split rides. This statute was written in 1961 with the intent to protect consumers from being forced to share limousine and taxi services with other individuals. It has not been updated since 1994, before the advent of the technology utilized by TNC’s, which can now allow consumers to choose whether they want to share a ride for a reduced cost. With the advancement of the sharing economy, this outdated statute needs to be updated in order to allow flexibility for opt-in carpooling services that TNCs want to provide and consumers want to utilize.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance (SFTWA) AFL-CIO opposes this bill stating that “AB 1360 allows TNCs to encroach upon public transit, school buses, taxis and other forms of transit that serve the public as a whole. It would extend and perpetuate TNCs failure to provide adequate service to the disabled community. Fare-splitting is currently illegal in California, but Uber and Lyft show no concern about that. Passage of AB 1360 would once more sanction and reward their unlawful behavior, and encourage more of the same.”
-- END --
AB 1360 (Ting) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1360 Hearing Date: 7/13/2015
Author: |
Ting |
||
Version: |
7/2/2015 As Amended |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Nidia Bautista |
||
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
DIGEST: This bill allows charter-party carriers of passengers, including transportation network companies, to charge individual fares, rather than a single group fare when providing carpool services.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers’ Act generally requires charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis or on a combination therefore. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
Directs the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to issue permits or certificates to charter-party carriers, investigate complaints against carriers, and cancel, revoke, or suspend permits and certificates for specific violations. (Public Utilities Code §5387)
Defines “charter-party carrier of passengers” as every person engaged in the transportation of persons by motor vehicle for compensation, whether in common or contract carriage, over any public highway in the state. (Public Utilities Code §5360)
Defines a “transportation network company” to mean an organization, including, but not limited to, a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, sole proprietor, or any entity operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an online-enabled application or platform to connect passengers with drivers using a personal vehicle. (Public Utilities Code §5431)
Restricts charter-party carriers from offering the transportation computed, charged or assessed on an individual-fare basis. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
Exempts contractors from the prohibition to assess individual fares who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools and except operators. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
Exempts a round-trip sightseeing tour service conducted with an authorized certificate or permit from the prohibition to assess individual fares. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
This bill:
Exempts charter-party carriers, including transportation network companies (TNCs), that prearranges a ride among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, from the prohibition to charge individual fares, provided that all the requirement are met:
The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, excluding the driver.
The driver is a participating driver of a TNC.
The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
The individual fare is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a traveling alone.
States that this subdivision does not change the insurance requirements established for a TNC and any participating driver.
Background
California law regulates different modes of passenger transportation for compensation, including taxi services, which are regulated by cities and counties, and charter-party carriers and passenger stage companies which are regulated by the CPUC. Beginning as early as 2009, a new model of transportation services began springing up in cities across the United States. Now known as TNCs, these original companies, including UberCab, allowed patrons to prearrange transportation services through an online application on their smartphone or computer. Patrons would request a ride to a predetermined location and the application would connect them with a TNC driver. Payment is processed through the application so that no physical financial transaction occurs during the trip itself between the patron and the driver. The TNC takes a commission on each trip. The development of the TNCs has made the ability for passengers seeking transportation for compensation more readily available to the general public.
Passenger carriers. The CPUC is in charge of regulating passenger carriers. Passenger carriers include services, such as passenger stage corporations and charter-party carriers. Passenger stage corporations are services that provide transportation to the general public on an individual fare basis, such as scheduled bus operators, which are buses that operate on a fixed route and scheduled services, or airport shuttles, which operate on an on-call door-to-door share the ride service.
Charter-party carriers are services that charter a vehicle, on a prearranged basis, for the exclusive use of an individual or group. Charges are based on the mileage or time of use, or a combination of both. The CPUC does not regulate the level of charges for charter-party carriers. Types of charter-party carriers include limousines, tour buses, sightseeing services, and charter and party buses.
The CPUC requires charter-party carriers to meet a number of requirements before an operating permit or certificate is issued. For example, the CPUC requires sufficient proof of financial responsibility, a preventative maintenance program for all vehicles, a safety education and training program, and regular checks of the driving records of all persons operating vehicles used in transportation for compensation.
Taxis and other transportation. Taxis are excluded from the definition of charter-party carriers and are regulated by cities or counties. The key distinction between charter-party carrier rides and taxis is that charter-party carrier rides must be prearranged, while taxis are allowed to pick up passengers via street hails. In addition to taxis, other transportation services that are not considered charter party carriers include: transportation services licensed and operating wholly within the limits of a single city or city and county, transportation services contracted to transport school students, publicly owned transit systems, passenger vehicles carrying passengers on a noncommercial enterprise basis, vehicles used exclusively to provide medical transportation, and others.
Cease and desist orders ignored. Back in June 2010, then-UberCab was utilizing its application platform to help prearrange rides for patrons of CPUC licensed charter-party carriers, particularly limousines and towncars. However, as a new service that didn’t fit very well within the existing regulatory framework – not a taxi not a charter-party carrier – the CPUC and San Francisco Metropolitan Transportation Authority issued a “cease-and-desist” order against Uber. The order directed Uber to stop advertising and cease its operations until it had acquired a valid permit to operate from the CPUC. However, even under threat of penalties (at $1,000 per day) and potential prison time, UberCab continued to operate. In 2012, Sidecar and Lyft were launched as new app based prearranged transportation services, except that these companies used individuals who weren’t licensed with the CPUC, drove their personal vehicles, and operated on a donations basis. About a month after Lyft was launched, on September 2012, the CPUC issued “cease-and-desist” orders against Sidecar and Lyft. Once again, the companies remained on the road operating their services. In the spring of 2013, Uber transformed its business model to compete with the Lyft and SideCar. In the face of protest from its existing Uber Black drivers who drove CPUC licensed vehicles, Uber expanded to Uber-X, allowing non-CPUC licensed individuals to drive their personal vehicles to transport passengers using the Uber platform. In late 2012, both Lyft and SideCar would abandon the donations-based fees and move to a minimum fee approach.
CPUC takes a different tack. In December 2012, after its “cease and desist” orders had largely been ignored by the TNCs, the CPUC announced it would open a formal proceeding to evaluate services like Lyft, SideCar and Uber. By January 2013, about one month later, the CPUC announced it had reached an agreement with Uber whereby Uber would continue to operate as the CPUC underwent its proceeding. The CPUC would also drop its $20,000 penalty against Uber. In September 2013, the CPUC formally announced it would recognize these app-based transportations services as a new category of charter-party carriers, transportation network companies. The CPUC required each TNC (not each driver) to register with the CPUC, require criminal background checks of all its drivers, and specified insurance requirements. The CPUC also acknowledged it would open a second phase to consider effects on limousines and other charter party carriers and the need to update transportation rules, including any direction from the legislature.
Locals issue cease and desist orders. 2014 was marked by growing tensions between local governments, including airports, and TNCs. First, the City of San Francisco cracked down on unauthorized entry into airports by TNCs. In June, the City of Los Angeles Department of Transportation issued cease and desist orders against Lyft and SideCar. In the fall of 2014, both San Francisco and Los Angeles County District Attorneys sent letters to the TNCs, Uber, Lyft and Sidecar, claiming they are operating illegally and warning them that legal action could follow if they don’t make major changes. The DA’s offices had conducted a joint investigation and found a number of practices that violate California law. The CPUC also issued letters to the TNCs, based on the investigations and claims of local airports, which expressed “personal disappointment” by then- CPUC President Peevey regarding the violations by TNCs and stipulated the CPUC’s ability to revoke permits.
Legislature adopts new insurance requirements. The Legislature passed AB 2293 (Bonilla) Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014, which codified the CPUC’s definition of TNCs and imposed certain liability and other insurance coverage for TNCs and their participating drivers. The bill defines when personal and commercial auto insurance requirements come into effect, and at what levels, when the driver logs onto the application until the driver accepts a ride request, and for when a ride request is accepted until the passenger exists the vehicle. The CPUC subsequently strengthened its insurance requirements in-line with the requirements of AB 2293. The CPUC established 28 rules and regulations, including requiring a minimum of $1 million per-incident, primary commercial insurance coverage, for incidents involving TNC vehicles and drivers in transit to or during a TNC trip. The rules also provide for personal auto insurance requirements when the app is off or open for a match.
More of the same? In September of 2014, the CPUC sent letters to Uber regarding Uber’s advertisement and news reports about a new service, Uber Pool, that allows for fare splitting. The CPUC warned Uber that such activity would require a different type of permit to provide service under a different model. The CPUC further stated that such a business plan is prohibited under California law, citing Public Utilities Code Section 5401, the section TNCs are now looking to change in AB 1360.
Employee or Independent Contractor? The question about whether TNC drivers are employees or independent contractors has become a growing debate in recent years. Most recently, the California Labor Commission ruled that a former Uber driver was, in fact, an employee and ordered Uber to pay over $4,000 for expenses incurred while driving. As employees, Uber drivers in the state would qualify for minimum wage, overtime, and worker’s compensation. Uber has maintained that its drivers are independent contractors. The Ruling became public when Uber filed an appeal in a state court on June 16th. Uber’s appeal is one of several cases currently up for consideration in the courts that could decide whether TNC drivers are employees or independent contractors. Two other cases – O’Connor, et al., v. Uber Technologies, Inc. et al. (Case No. C-13-3826 EMC) and Cotter, et al., v. Uber Technologies, Inc. et al. (Case No. 13-cv-04065-VC) – are both to be heard in the U.S. District Court in San Francisco. Both lawsuits were filed by drivers who claim that, although the TNCs classify them as independent contractors, they are actually employees and are therefore owed certain benefits, reimbursements, and protections. The drivers are seeking class action status in both cases.
The bill was incorrectly amended by the Senate Committee onTransportation and Housing. Per the Senate Committee on Transportation and Housing, the author and committee may wish to consider striking line 26 (B) on page 2, otherwise the exemption will only apply to TNC charter-party carriers, not charter-party carriers more broadly.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 828 (Low, 2015) exempts vehicles operating in conjunction with TNCs from the definition of commercial vehicle. The bill is pending in the Senate Rules Committee.
AB 1422 (Cooper, 2015) requires TNCs to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles program for notifying employers of the driving records of their drivers. This bill will be considered on July 14th in the Senate Committee on Transportation and Housing.
AB 612 (Nazarian, 2014) would have required charter-party carriers to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles Employer Pull Notice system and to submit all drivers to a Department of Justice criminal background check. AB 612 was held in the Assembly Committee on Transportation.
AB 2293 (Bonilla, Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014) established guidelines for insurance coverage for TNCs to ensure personal and financial safety of consumers.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Transportation and Housing Committee (11-0)
Assembly Floor (73-0)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (11-0)
Assembly Utilities and Commerce Committee (14-0)
SUPPORT:
Internet Association (source)
TechNet (source)
Bay Area Council
California League of Conservation Voters
Circulate San Diego
City of Los Angeles
Clean Coalition
Climate Resolve
Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Greenbelt Alliance
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Lyft, Inc.
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Natural Resources Defense Council
Orange County Business Council
Planning and Conservation League
SF Transit Riders
San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce
Sidecar
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Southern California Association of Governments
TransForm
Uber Technologies, Inc.
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
OPPOSITION:
Greater California Livery Association
Los Angeles Taxi Workers Alliance
Sacramento Taxi Cab Union
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance AFL-CIO
San Jose Taxi Drivers Association
United Taxi Workers of San Diego
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author’s office states: “currently, laws governing charter party services such as TNC’s prevent them from charging passengers individual fares for split rides. This statute was written in 1961 with the intent to protect consumers from being forced to share limousine and taxi services with other individuals. It has not been updated since 1994, before the advent of the technology utilized by TNC’s, which can now allow consumers to choose whether they want to share a ride for a reduced costs. With the advancement of the sharing economy, this outdated statute needs to be updated in order to allow flexibility for opt-in carpooling services that TNCs want to provide and consumers want to utilize.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance (SFTWA) AFL-CIO opposes this bill stating that “AB 1360 allows TNCs to encroach upon public transit, school buses, taxis and other forms of transit that serve the public as a whole. It would extend and perpetuate TNCs failure to provide adequate service to the disabled community. Fare-splitting is currently illegal in California, but Uber and Lyft show no concern about that. Passage of AB 1360 would once more sanction and reward their unlawful behavior, and encourage ore of the same.”
-- END --
AB 1360 (Ting) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1360 Hearing Date: 6/30/2015
Author: |
Ting |
||
Version: |
5/13/2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Randy Chinn |
||
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
DIGEST: This bill allows transportation network companies (TNCs) to charge individual fares, rather than a single group fare, when providing carpool services.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law requires that fares charged by TNCs and other similar transportation companies be computed either on distance traveled or the amount of time the vehicle is in use.
This bill allows TNCs, when providing prearranged rides for multiple passengers, to instead charge individual fares, provided that the following are met:
The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, excluding the driver.
The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
The individual fare is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, current laws governing services such as TNCs prevent them from charging passengers individual fares for split rides. This statute was written in 1961 and has not been updated since 1994, before the advent of the technology utilized by TNCs, which can now allow consumers to choose whether they want to share a ride for a reduced cost. With the advancement of the sharing economy, this outdated statute needs to be updated in order to allow flexibility for carpooling services that TNCs want to provide and customers want to utilize, according to the author. The author further notes that the carpooling and ridesharing fostered by this bill will help address California’s traffic congestion problems and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Need for the bill. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over much of the transportation industry, including TNCs. (However, the CPUC does not have regulatory authority over taxis.) In September 2014, the CPUC notified a TNC that state law prohibited it from offering a shared ride service where each individual was charged a fixed price. Until that law is changed, as this bill proposes, the TNC could not offer such a service under that fare structure.
The growing TNC industry. In California, the TNC business is large and growing rapidly. A January 2015 report from Uber1, the largest TNC, reports 20,000 active Uber drivers in Los Angeles, 16,000 in the San Francisco area, and almost 5,000 each in San Diego and Orange County, up from zero in July 2012. TNCs are successfully competing with taxi cabs, limousines, and other regulated transit operators.
An unlevel playing field. The different types of transportation companies (e.g., TNCs, limousines, Super Shuttles, taxis) are all regulated differently. Rates, routes, insurance requirements, vehicle inspections, and driver requirements vary. State law has begun to address the biggest differences between TNCs, but there’s little dispute that big differences remain. In an ideal world, companies would compete based on the differences in their business models and competence, not on the differences in how they are regulated.
Creating a level playing field slowly. The laws and regulations governing the provision of transportation services are many decades old. These laws and regulations have evolved slowly, as evidenced by the arcane and complicated carrier classifications. At least over the last several decades, the few new laws have focused on safety issues. The rapid growth of TNCs has disrupted this relatively quiet corner of our economy, changing the economics of transportation and challenging the economic models of the traditional transportation providers. This has upended the lives of many people in the transportation industry, while at the same time providing many benefits to transportation consumers.
Regulators are struggling to keep up with the rapidly evolving transportation industry, a bit hamstrung by laws which never anticipated the different ways that TNCs operate. In September 2013, the CPUC, which has regulatory authority over much, though not all, of the passenger transportation industry, issued its first set of rules2 intended to foster the growth of TNCs, without compromising public safety. These rules started the process of establishing a level playing field so that all transportation companies would have similar regulatory obligations, allowing them to compete based on their business models. Among the rules were requirements for obtaining an operating permit from the CPUC, requiring criminal background checks for drivers, establishing driver training programs, implementing zero-tolerance policies on drugs and alcohol, and minimum insurance requirements.
The CPUC has initiated a second phase of its investigation to look more closely at the regulation of TNCs and the traditional transportation companies, known as charter-party carriers3. A set of issues has been proposed and comments on the scope of those issues are due in June. As the state’s expert agency over transportation matters, the CPUC is in the best position to consider whether its current regulations provide for a fair and competitive market. It can recommend specific changes to law and, in some cases, can implement changes to its own regulations to achieve the goal of a level playing field.
Good for one, good for all? This bill limits the flexibility to charge individual fares to TNCs; it does not allow other charter-party carriers (e.g., limousines) that same flexibility. The author has agreed to accept amendments to broaden the bill to apply to all charter-party carriers.
Technical Amendments.
On page 2, line 19, replace “rideshare program” with “service”
On page 3, line 2, delete “single”
Double-referred. This bill has also been referred to the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
Related Legislation:
AB 828 (Low) — exempts vehicles operating in conjunction with TNCs from the definition of commercial vehicle. This bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1422 (Cooper) — requires transportation network companies to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles program for notifying employers of the driving records of their drivers. This bill is pending in the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
Assembly Votes:
Floor: 73-7
P&CP: 11-0
U&C: 14-1
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 24, 2015.)
SUPPORT:
Bay Area Council
California League of Conservation Voters
Circulate San Diego
City of Los Angeles
Clean Coalition
Climate Resolve
EDF/Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Internet Association
Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
Lyft
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Orange County Business Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Planning and Conservation League
San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Transit Riders
Sidecar
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Southern California Association of Governments
SPUR
Tech Net
Transform
Uber
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
OPPOSITION:
Airport Ground Transportation Association
California Bus Association
Greater California Livery Association
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance
SuperShuttle
Taxicab Paratransit Association of California
One individual
-- END --
1 “An Analysis of the Labor Market for Uber’s Driver-Partners in the United States,” by Jonathan V. Hall and Alan B. Kreuger; January 22, 2015.
2 D.13-09-045; issued September 23, 2013.
3 Assigned Commissioner and Administrative Law Judge’s Ruling Amending the Scoping Memo and Ruling for Phase II of Proceeding; Rulemaking 12-12-011; April 28, 2015.
AB 1360 (Ting) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1360 Hearing Date: 6/16/2015
Author: |
Ting |
||
Version: |
5/13/2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Randy Chinn |
||
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
DIGEST: This bill allows transportation network companies to charge individual fares, rather than a single group fare, when providing carpool services.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law requires that fares charged by transportation network companies (TNCs) and other similar transportation companies be computed either on distance traveled or the amount of time the vehicle is in use.
This bill allows TNCs, when providing prearranged rides for multiple passengers, to instead charge individual fares, provided that the following are met:
The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, excluding the driver.
The vehicle is not used to provide public transit services or to carry passengers over a fixed route.
The vehicle is not used to provide pupil transportation services.
The vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services.
The individual fare is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, current laws governing services such as TNCs prevent them from charging passengers individual fares for split rides. This statute was written in 1961 and has not been updated since 1994, before the advent of the technology utilized by TNCs, which can now allow consumers to choose whether they want to share a ride for a reduced cost. With the advancement of the sharing economy, this outdated statute needs to be updated in order to allow flexibility for carpooling services that TNCs want to provide and customers want to utilize, according to the author. The author further notes that the carpooling and ridesharing fostered by this bill will help address California’s traffic congestion problems and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Need for the bill. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over much of the transportation industry, including TNCs. (However, the CPUC does not have regulatory authority over taxis.) In September 2014, the CPUC notified a TNC that state law prohibited it from offering a shared ride service where each individual was charged a fixed price. Until that law was changed, as this bill proposes, the TNC could not offer such a service under that fare structure.
The growing TNC industry. In California the TNC business is large and growing rapidly. A January 2015 report from Uber1, the largest TNC, reports 20,000 active Uber drivers in Los Angeles, 16,000 in the San Francisco area, and almost 5,000 each in San Diego and Orange County, up from zero in July 2012. TNCs are successfully competing with taxi cabs, limousines, and other regulated transit operators.
An unlevel playing field. The different types of transportation companies (e.g., TNCs, limousines, Super Shuttles, taxis) are all regulated differently. Rates, routes, insurance requirements, vehicle inspections, and driver requirements vary. State law has begun to address the biggest differences between TNCs, but there’s little dispute that big differences remain. In an ideal world, companies would compete based on the differences in their business models and competence, not on the differences in how they are regulated.
Creating a level playing field slowly. The laws and regulations governing the provision of transportation services are many decades old. These laws and regulations have evolved slowly, as evidenced by the arcane and complicated carrier classifications. At least over the last several decades, the few new laws have focused on safety issues. The rapid growth of TNCs has disrupted this relatively quiet corner of our economy, changing the economics of transportation and challenging the economic models of the traditional transportation providers. This has upended the lives of many people in the transportation industry, while at the same time providing many benefits to transportation consumers.
Regulators are struggling to keep up with the rapidly evolving transportation industry, a bit hamstrung by laws which never anticipated the different ways that TNCs operate. In September 2013, the CPUC, which has regulatory authority over much, though not all, of the passenger transportation industry, issued its first set of rules2 intended to foster the growth of TNCs, without compromising public safety. These rules started the process of establishing a level playing field so that all transportation companies would have similar regulatory obligations, allowing them to compete based on their business models. Among the rules were requirements for obtaining an operating permit from the CPUC, requiring criminal background checks for drivers, establishing driver training programs, implementing zero-tolerance policies on drugs and alcohol, and minimum insurance requirements.
The CPUC has initiated a second phase of their investigation to look more closely at the regulation of TNCs and the traditional transportation companies, known as charter party carriers3. A set of issues has been proposed and comments on the scope of those issues are due in June. As the state’s expert agency over transportation matters, the CPUC is in the best position to consider whether its current regulations provide for a fair and competitive market. It can recommend specific changes to law and, in some cases, can implement changes to its own regulations to achieve the goal of a level playing field.
Good for one, good for all? This bill limits the flexibility to charge individual fares to TNCs; it does not allow other charter-party carriers (e.g., limousines) that same flexibility. As there is no policy reason to limit the flexibility to TNCs, the author and committee may wish to consider broadening the flexibility in this bill to all charter-party carriers.
Technical Amendments
On page 2, line 19, replace “rideshare program” with “service”
On page 3, line 2, delete “single”
Double-referral. This bill has been double-referred to the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
Related Legislation:
AB 828 (Low) — exempts vehicles operating in conjunction with TNCs from the definition of commercial vehicle. This bill is pending in the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee.
AB 1422 (Cooper) — requires transportation network companies to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles program for notifying employers of the driving records of their drivers. This bill is pending in the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee.
Assembly votes:
Floor: 73-7
P&CP: 11-0
U&C: 14-1
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 10, 2015.)
SUPPORT:
Bay Area Council
California League of Conservation Voters
Circulate San Diego
City of Los Angeles
Clean Coalition
Climate Resolve
EDF/Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Internet Association
Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
Lyft
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Orange County Business Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Planning and Conservation League
San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Transit Riders
Sidecar
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Southern California Association of Governments
SPUR
Tech Net
Transform
Uber
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
OPPOSITION:
Greater California Livery Association
Los Angeles Taxi Workers Alliance
Sacramento Taxi Cab Union
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance
San Jose Taxi Drivers Association
United Taxi Workers of San Diego
One individual
-- END --
1 An Analysis of the Labor Market for Uber’s Driver-Partners in the United States, by Jonathan V. Hall and Alan B. Kreuger; January 22, 2015.
2 D.13-09-045; issued September 23, 2013.
3 Assigned Commissioner and Administrative Law Judge’s Ruling Amending the Scoping Memo and Ruling for Phase II of Proceeding; Rulemaking 12-12-011; April 28, 2015.
AB 1360
Page 2
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 1360
(Ting)
As Amended May 13, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Utilities |
14-0 |
Rendon, Patterson, Achadjian, Bonilla, Burke, Dahle, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Hadley, Jones, Quirk, Santiago, Ting, Williams |
|
Privacy |
11-0 |
Gatto, Wilk, Baker, Calderon, Chang, Chau, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Gordon, Low |
|
SUMMARY: Exempts ridesharing programs operated by transportation network companies (TNC) that arrange rides among multiple passengers who share the ride, in whole or in part, from transportation charges computed and assessed on charter-party carriers. Specifically, this bill:
Exempts a ridesharing program operated by a TNC that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride, in whole or in part, from offering passengers charges computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination of the two.
Specifies that the exemption applies provided that:
The vehicle seats no more than seven passengers, including the driver;
The driver is a participating driver, as defined; and
The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Specifies that TNCs may not use vehicles to provide transit service or to carry passengers over a fixed route, provide school pupil transportation services, or provide public paratransit services.
Specifies that the insurance requirement and limitations, as specified, for a TNC and any participating driver does not change.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: "The primary cause of traffic congestion originates from nearly 80% of commuters traveling to work alone. Traffic results in 5.5 billion hours of productivity at a cost of $818 to the average commuter, with increased congestion generating nearly 4 billion gallons of excess fuel wasted and 56 billion pounds of greenhouse gasses. This contributes to California's transportation sector functioning as the greatest source of pollution, accounting for 40% of the state's greenhouse gas emissions. TNC's such as Lyft, Uber, and Sidecar have been extremely innovative in creating models that empower consumers and allow more ease and access to transportation alternatives. They have recently started services that allow riders with similar pick up locations and destinations to share a driver and carpool for a decreased fare. Shared rides such as carpooling decrease traffic and congestion, and ultimately cut pollution."
Background: California law regulates different modes of passenger transportation for compensation, including taxi services, which are regulated by cities and/or counties, and charter party carriers (CPC) and passenger stage companies, which are regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).
What are CPCs? CPCs are services that charter a vehicle, on a prearranged basis, for the exclusive use of an individual or group. Charges are based on the mileage, or time of use, or a combination of both. The CPUC does not regulate the level of charges for CPCs. Types of CPCs include limos, tour buses, sightseeing services, and charter and party buses.
What are TNCs? Beginning as early as 2009, a new model of transportation service began springing up in cities across the United States. Known as TNCs, these companies work by allowing patrons to prearrange transportation services through an online application on their smartphone or computer. Patrons would request a ride to a predetermined location and the application would connect them with a TNC driver. Payment is processed through the application so that no physical financial transaction occurs during the trip itself between the patron and the driver. The TNC takes a commission on each trip.
Although TNCs do not neatly fall into the conventional definition of either taxis or limousines, the CPUC does believe that TNCS are currently providing passenger's transportation for compensation, and reasonably concludes that TNCs are CPCs, therefore, falling under the CPUC’s existing jurisdiction over these services.
CPUC Letter to TNCs: In September 2014, the CPUC sent letters to the three major TNCs, Uber, Lyft, and Sidecar, regarding their intent to add carpooling service to their transportation service. The CPUC stated that this model is in violation of existing law that prohibits CPCs from calculating charges on an individual-fare basis. The CPUC found that CPCs "cannot change an individual fare when carrying multiple persons in a vehicle, and therefore, a person chartering a [CPC] vehicle must have exclusive use of the vehicle."
This bill would permit a rideshare program operated by a TNC to charge individual fares, provided that the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / U. & C. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0000386
AB 1360
Page 7
Date of Hearing: May 5, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Mike Gatto, Chair
AB 1360
(Ting) – As Amended April 29, 2015
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
SUMMARY:
Authorizes transportation network companies (TNCs) to charge split
fares between multiple occupants for up to seven passengers, provided
that the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare
that would be charged for the same ride if a single passenger
traveled alone. Specifically, this
bill:
Exempts a ridesharing program operated by a TNC from the current law prohibition fare-splitting, which applies to charter party carriers regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).
Specifies that the exemption applies provided that:
The vehicle seats no more than seven persons, including the driver,
The driver is a participating driver, as defined, and
The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Specifies that TNCs may not use vehicles to provide transit service or to carry passengers over a fixed route, provide school pupil transportation services, or provide public paratransit services.
EXISTING LAW:
Authorizes the CPUC to regulate various transportation services, including charter-party carriers (CPCs) of passengers, defined as persons engaged in the transportation of others by motor vehicle for compensation on a prearranged basis over any public highway, but not including taxicabs regulated by local agencies. (Public Utilities (PU) Code Sections 5360 and 5360.5)
Establishes the TNC as a new category of CPCs subject to its jurisdiction and defines a TNC as an organization operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an online-enabled application or platform to connect passengers with drivers using their personal vehicles (PU 5431 and CPUC Decision 13-09-045)
Generally requires charges for transportation to be offered or afforded by CPCs to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or a combination thereof. Charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle or the size of the group to be transported. (PU 5401)
Directs the CPUC to issue permits or certificates to CPCs, investigate complaints against carriers, and cancel, revoke, or suspend permits and certificates for specific violations. (PU 5387)
Defines CPCs as every person engaged in the transportation of persons by motor vehicle for compensation, whether in common or contract carriage, over any public highway in the state. (PU 5360)
Defines a “transportation network company” to mean an organization, including, but not limited to, a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, sole proprietor, or any entity operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an app or platform to connect passengers with drivers using a personal vehicle. (PU 5431)
Prohibits CPCs from charging individual fares (i.e., fare-splitting) when more than one passenger is being transported at one time. (PU 5401)
Makes two exceptions to the prohibition on fare-splitting: 1) Schoolbus contractors who are paid by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools; and 2) Round-trip sightseeing tour services conducted with an authorized certificate or permit. (PU 5401)
Authorizes cities and counties to regulate taxicabs with seating capacity for up to eight passengers that are operating in their jurisdictions, including setting maximum fare rates and permitting fare-splitting. (Government Code Section 53075.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill. This bill is intended to reduce the fares consumers pay to TNCs by permitting TNCs to offer individual fares, i.e., fare-splitting, to TNC carpool customers. This bill is sponsored by the Internet Association and TechNet.
Author’s statement. “Lyft has found that every day, 90% of Lyft rides in San Francisco have someone else taking the same trip within five minutes. An MIT study has also found that 95% of cab rides could be shared. By sharing rides, we contribute to a greener economy by taking more cars off the road and decreasing emissions."
“The primary cause of traffic congestion
originates from nearly 80% of commuters traveling to work alone.
Traffic results in 5.5 billion hours of productivity at a cost of
$818 to the average commuter, with increased congestion generating
nearly 4 billion gallons of excess fuel wasted and 56 billion pounds
of greenhouse gasses. This contributes to California’s
transportation sector functioning as the greatest source of
pollution, accounting for 40% of the state’s greenhouse gas
emissions.
“TNC’s such as Lyft, Uber, and Sidecar
have been extremely innovative in creating models that empower
consumers and allow more ease and access to transportation
alternatives. They have recently started services that allow riders
with similar pick up locations and destinations to share a driver and
carpool for a decreased fare. Shared rides such as carpooling
decrease traffic and congestion, and ultimately cut pollution.”
What are TNCs? A new model of transportation service has sprung up in cities across the United States, including California. Patrons can prearrange transportation services utilizing an app on their smart phone device. In doing so, small start-up companies such as Lyft, SideCar, and Uber, among others, have begun competing with traditional CPCs and taxicab services in select cities in California. TNCs generally send drivers in either luxury vehicles or personal vehicles to pick up passengers whose credit cards are automatically charged flat fees or fares calculated by GPS. Fares for are calculated based on distance or by the amount a consumer wishes to pay.
How does the state regulate TNCs? Prior to 2013, California law recognized and regulated three modes of passenger transportation for compensation: 1) taxi services, regulated by cities and/or counties; 2) CPCs, i.e., limousines, regulated by the CPUC; and 3) passenger stage companies, i.e., charter busses and shuttles, which are also regulated by the CPUC. Before 2013, TNCs operated without regulatory oversight in California.
However, in December 2012 the CPUC initiated a rulemaking to determine whether and how services arranged through apps might affect public safety. The CPUC sought comment on issues including: how the CPUC's existing jurisdiction should be applied to businesses such as Uber, SideCar, and Lyft; the consumer protection and safety implications of these new methods for arranging transportation services; whether and how the new transportation business models differ from longstanding forms of ridesharing; and the new transportation business models' potential effect on insurance and transportation access.
In a September 2013 Decision, the CPUC established a new transportation business model called TNCs and required those companies to:
Register with the CPUC;
Meet safety requirements, including insurance, background checks, vehicle inspections;
Meet CPUC regulatory requirements;
Only operate at airports with permission granted by the airport;
Submit a report on addressing services to the disabled community; and
Submit an annual report to the CPUC.
TNCs currently permitted by the CPUC are Lyft, Uber-X (aka Rasier), Wingz (formerly Tickengo), and Summon (formerly InstantCab). The 2013 CPUC Decision empowers the CPUC to exercise its safety and enforcement authority against TNCs that violate any regulatory or safety requirements.
Vehicle requirements for TNCs. The CPUC only allows TNCs to use street legal coupes, sedans, or light-duty vehicles, including vans, minivans, SUVs, pickup trucks, as well as hatchbacks and convertibles. TNC vehicles must not be significantly modified from factory specifications. TNCs are allowed to operate vehicles with a seating capacity of up to seven passengers, including the driver, if they have a $1 million commercial liability insurance on file. They are allowed to operate a vehicle with a seating capacity of up to ten passengers, including the driver, if they carry a $1.5 million commercial liability insurance on file. TNCs are not allowed to operate vehicles with a seating capacity of more than 10 passengers, including the driver, which is legally defined as a bus.
CPUC letter to TNCs regarding individual fares for carpools: Current law prohibits CPCs from charging individual fares to passengers with two exceptions: 1) school buses compensated by parents of children attending public, private or parochial schools, and 2) certified operators of roundtrip sightseeing tour services.
In September 2014, the CPUC sent letters to the three major TNCs, Uber, Lyft, and Sidecar, regarding their intent to add carpooling service to their transportation service. The CPUC stated that this model is in violation of existing law that prohibits CPCs from calculating charges on an individual-fare basis. The CPUC found that CPCs “cannot change an individual fare when carrying multiple persons in a vehicle, and therefore, a person chartering a [CPC] vehicle must have exclusive use of the vehicle.”
This bill would permit a rideshare program operated by a TNC to charge individual fares, provided that the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.Consumers benefit from fare-splitting. This bill would give consumers more ridesharing options and allow consumers to save money by choosing to carpool, and therefore pay a reduced fare, when they use a TNC to travel. Some consumers may prefer to carpool and save money rather than travel as a single passenger in a TNC vehicle. As ridesharing becomes more convenient and inexpensive, more consumers will likely turn to ridesharing instead of purchasing and owning vehicles. Falling demand for new and used vehicles would then place downward pressure on vehicle prices – another consumer benefit.
TNC carpooling also benefits consumers, because carpooling theoretically reduces the overall the number of vehicles on the road, which in turn reduces traffic, overall travel times, and air pollution. However, a recent study conducted by the University of California, Berkeley, found that the actual impact of TNCs on overall vehicle miles traveled is ambiguous. According to the study, of the consumers who participated in the survey, 92% said they still would have made the trip even if TNC services were not available, and of that number “39% said they would have used a taxi, while 33% said bus or rail, and 6% drive.” (“App-Based, On-Demand Ride Services: Comparing Taxi and Ridesourcing Trips and User Characteristics in San Francisco,” UC Berkeley, UC Transportation Center, August 2014.) If consumers choose a TNC over bus or rail in significant numbers, and if TNC vehicles circulate on city streets while waiting for customers, then consumers may not ultimately see an overall reduction in traffic, travel times, or air pollution under this bill.The effect of “surge pricing” on TNC fares. While this bill would reduce TNC fares for consumers who choose to carpool when they use TNC services, there is a critical difference between fare-splitting in the taxicab service industry and fare-splitting in the TNC service industry. Unlike TNCs, taxicab companies are regulated by cities and counties, which impose requirements such as workers’ compensation insurance, training, vehicle inspection, and vehicle safety rules, such as requiring security cameras on taxicabs for the protection of consumers. Cities and counties also regulate taxicab fares. In San Francisco, for example, the City and County of San Francisco have established maximum taxicab fares.
By contrast, TNCs are not regulated by local governments, and are therefore not subject to the local maximum fare restrictions placed on taxis. The CPUC does not set maximum fares on CPCs, and only requires passenger stage companies to submit their tariffs to the CPUC. As a result, some TNCs charge consumers significantly higher fares at peak times and locations, known as “surge pricing.” Surge pricing may quickly erase any savings a consumer would achieve by carpooling with a TNC, as compared to a taxicab fare.
According to a San Francisco Examiner news report, “Uber sent a mass email warning riders that New Year's Eve would see a spike in passenger demand, potentially skyrocketing prices to over $100 for a ride after midnight. ” (“Uber drivers say rideshare surge pricing backfired on New year’s Eve,” The Examiner, January 2, 2015.)
This bill allows TNCs to use fare-splitting so that consumers who carpool with a TNC pay a lower fare than the fare they would pay if they rode alone in a TNC car. However, neither the Legislature nor local governments have imposed any restrictions on TNCs that would limit the overall fares TNCs charge consumers.Recent amendments address labor union and insurance industry concerns. The author recently accepted amendments to address insurance industry concerns that the bill might inadvertently change TNC insurance requirements established in current law. As amended, the bill now clarifies that the bill does not change TNC insurance requirements.
Amendments accepted in the prior committee addressed concerns expressed by labor organizations that the bill could ultimately reduce ridership on public transit. The amended version of the bill now clarifies that TNCs may not use vehicles to provide transit service or to carry passengers over a fixed route, to provide school pupil transportation services, or to provide public paratransit services.Arguments in support. Uber Technologies, Inc. states in support that “AB 1360 clarifies that TNC’s may offer less expensive ridesharing services to customers with similar pick-up locations and destinations…Uber’s carpooling service “UberPOOL” which is currently available in San Francisco and Los Angeles allows passengers…to share a ride and save money. Because Uber does not involve any in-person payment, cash or otherwise, passengers are billed through Uber’s online platform based on their individual share of the ride. This leads to cheaper rides and increased carpooling while retaining the convenience and flexibility of ridesharing.”
According to the Internet Association, “this measure is squarely in line with well-established California public policy that broadly encourages carpooling to reduce traffic congestion and air pollution. AB 1360 also furthers California’s commitment to the environment on other fronts, such as by enhancing our State’s greenhouse gas reduction efforts. Consumers also benefit from greater transportation options. Multiple passenger ride sharing services provide greater affordability and flexibility for consumers.”
The Clean Coalition states in support of this bill that “new technologies offer enormous promise to meet our energy needs while addressing global and regional environmental problems and creating new economic opportunities across California – all at costs that continue to drop as these technologies are brought to scale.”Arguments in opposition. According to the San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance, “AB 1360 (Ting) would allow transportation network companies (TNCs) to charge passengers on an individual (split-fare) basis, while other charter-party carriers are prohibited from doing the same. This special favored treatment is founded on the false premise that these operations – which are currently conducted in open defiance of the law – bring environmental benefits. Quite the opposite is true. A year ago Uber stated that it has some 16,000 vehicles operating in San Francisco alone…According to GPS developer TomTom, in the two years that TNCs have been allowed to operate, San Francisco has become the second most congested city in the U.S. (after Los Angeles)."
“AB 1360 would promote an unjustified expansion of TNC services that will draw even more passengers away from public transportation…The same holds true for their effects on the taxi industry and taxi drivers. San Francisco has the greenest taxi fleet in the country. Nearly all SF cabs must be hybrids or other low-emissions vehicles. In contrast, CPUC rules allow all sorts of vehicles to perform TNC services, including non-hybrid vans, minivans, SUVs and pick up trucks.
“[The fare-split provision] is meaningless in light of the practice of 'surge pricing,' where the fare at peak times may be as much as eight times the normal charge. Cities strictly regulate maximum taxi charges to keep them non-discriminatory and affordable, but for TNCs the sky’s the limit, with no oversight at all.”
Technical amendment. Committee staff recommend the following technical amendment to the bill to clean up a drafting error in the bill:
On Page 3, line 10, after “Section 5434” add: or the requirements set forth in Section 5435
Related legislation. AB 24 (Nazarian) would require drivers hired or initially retained by either a charter-party carrier of passengers or a TNC to be subject to background checks and mandatory drug and alcohol testing prior to employment or retention. The bill would also require a TNC to register any vehicle used in the transportation of passengers for compensation with the commission and display the identifying decal issued by the commission on the vehicle. AB 24 is currently pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 828 (Low) would exempt a motor vehicle operated in connection with a TNC, as defined in Section 5431 of the Public Utilities Code, from the definition “commercial vehicle.” AB 828 is currently pending in on the Assembly Floor.
AB 886 (Chau) would establish new privacy protections for passengers of TNCs and taxicabs. AB 886 failed passage in the Assembly Utilities and Commerce Committee on a 4-6 vote.
AB 1422 (Cooper) would authorize a TNC to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles pull-notice system to regularly check the driving records of a participating driver regardless of whether the participating driver is an employee or an independent contractor of the TNC. AB 1422 is currently pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Prior legislation.
AB 612 (Nazarian) of 2014 would have required charter party carriers to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles Employer Pull Notice system and to submit all drivers to a Department of Justice criminal background check . AB 612 was held in the Assembly Transportation Committee.
AB 2293 (Bonilla), Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014, established guidelines for insurance coverage for TNCs to ensure personal and financial safety of consumers.
Double referral. This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Utilities and Commerce Committee, where it was heard on April 20, 2015, and passed on a 14-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Internet Association (Co-sponsor)
TechNet (Co-sponsor)
Bay Area Council
City of Los Angeles
Clean Coalition
Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Lyft, Inc.
Natural Resources Defense Council
Orange County Business Council
Planning and Conservation League
San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce
Sidecar
SPUR
TransForm
Uber Technologies, Inc.
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Opposition
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance
Greater Livery Association
Analysis Prepared by: Jennie Bretschneider / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
AB 1360
Page 6
Date of Hearing: April 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND COMMERCE
Anthony Rendon, Chair
AB 1360
(Ting) – As Amended April 14, 2015
SUBJECT: Charter-party carriers of passengers: individual fare exemption
SUMMARY: This bill would exempt ridesharing programs operated by transportation network companies (TNC) that arrange rides among multiple passengers who share the ride in whole or in part, from transportation charges computed and assessed on charter-party carriers. Specifically, this bill:
Exempts a ridesharing program operated by a TNC that arranges a ride on a prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride, in whole or in part, from offering passengers charges computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination of the two.
Specifies that the exemption applies provided that:
The vehicle seats no more than seven persons, including the driver,
The driver is a participating driver, as defined, and
The individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
EXISTING LAW:
The Passenger Charter-Party Carriers’ Act generally requires charges for the transportation to be offered or afforded by a charter-party carrier to be computed and assessed on a vehicle mileage or time of use basis, or on a combination therefor. These charges may vary in accordance with the passenger capacity of the vehicle, or the size of the group to be transported. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
Directs the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to issue permits or certificates to charter party carriers (CPC), investigate complaints against carriers, and cancel, revoke, or suspend permits and certificates for specific violations. (Public Utilities Code §5387)
Defines “charter-party carrier of passengers” as every person engaged in the transportation of persons by motor vehicle for compensation, whether in common or contract carriage, over any public highway in the state. (Public Utilities Code §5360)
Defines a “transportation network company” to mean an organization, including, but not limited to, a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, sole proprietor, or any entity operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an online-enabled application or platform to connect passengers with drivers using a personal vehicle. (Public Utilities Code §5431)
Restricts charter-party carriers from directly, or through an agent or otherwise, nor any broker, contract, agree, or arrange to change, or demand or receive compensation, for the transportation offered or afforded, be computed, charged or assessed on an individual-fare basis. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
Exempts contractors who are compensated by parents of children attending public, private, or parochial schools and except operators. (Public Utilities Code§ 5401)
Exempts a round-trip sightseeing tour service conducted with an authorized certificate or permit. (Public Utilities Code §5401)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: “The primary cause of traffic congestion originates from nearly 80% of commuters traveling to work alone. Traffic results in 5.5 billion hours of productivity at a cost of $818 to the average commuter, with increased congestion generating nearly 4 billion gallons of excess fuel wasted and 56 billion pounds of greenhouse gasses. This contributes to California’s transportation sector functioning as the greatest source of pollution, accounting for 40% of the state’s greenhouse gas emissions. TNC’s such as Lyft, Uber, and Sidecar have been extremely innovative in creating models that empower consumers and allow more ease and access to transportation alternatives. They have recently started services that allow riders with similar pick up locations and destinations to share a driver and carpool for a decreased fare. Shared rides such as carpooling decrease traffic and congestion, and ultimately cut pollution.”
Background: California law regulates different modes of passenger transportation for compensation, including taxi services, which are regulated by cities and/or counties, and CPCs and passenger stage companies (PSC), which are regulated by the PUC. Beginning as early as 2009, a new model of transportation service began springing up in cities across the United States. Known as TNCs, these companies work by allowing patrons to prearrange transportation services through an online application on their smartphone or computer. Patrons would request a ride to a predetermined location and the application would connect them with a TNC driver. Payment is processed through the application so that no physical financial transaction occurs during the trip itself between the patron and the driver. The TNC takes a commission on each trip. The development of TNCs has made the ability for passengers seeking transportation for compensation more readily available to the general public.
What are Passenger Carriers? The CPUC is in charge of regulating passenger carriers. Passenger carriers include services such as PSCs and CPCs. PSCs are services that provide transportation to the general public on an individual fare basis, such as scheduled bus operators, which are buses that operate on a fixed route and scheduled services, or airport shuttles, which operate on an on-call door-to-door share the ride service.
CPCs are services that charter a vehicle, on a prearranged basis, for the exclusive use of an individual or group. Charges are based on the mileage or time of use, or a combination of both. The CPUC does not regulate the level of charges for CPCs. Types of CPCs include limos, tour buses, sightseeing services, and charter and party buses.
The CPUC requires CPCs to meet a number of requirements until an operating permit or certificate is issued. These requirements include providing sufficient proof of financial responsibility, maintain a preventative maintenance program for all vehicles, possessing a safety education and training program, and regularly checking the driving records of all persons operating vehicles used in transportation for compensation.
What are Not Passenger Carriers? Taxis are excluded from the definition of CPCs and are regulated by cities or counties. The key distinction between CPC rides and taxis is that CPC rides must be prearranged, while taxis are allowed to pick up passengers via street hails. Other examples of transportation services that are not considered charter party carriers include: transportation services licensed and operating wholly within the limits of a single city or city and county, transportation services contracted to transport school pupils, publicly owned transit systems, passenger vehicles carrying passengers on a noncommercial enterprise basis, vehicles used exclusively to provide medical transportation, among others.
What are Transportation Network Companies? In September 2013, a CPUC decision put TNCs under the purview of the CPUC, allowing it to exercise and enforce regulatory and safety requirements against TNCs. The CPUC defined TNCs as an “organization, including, but not limited to, a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, sole proprietor, or any entity, operating in California that provides prearranged transportation services for compensation using an online-enabled application or platform to connect passengers with drivers using a personal vehicle.” The CPUC decision requires TNCs to obtain a permit from the CPUC, conduct criminal background checks of drivers, establish a driver training program, implement a zero-tolerance policy on drugs and alcohol, conduct vehicle inspections, and obtain authorization from airports before conducting any operations on or into airport property.
Subsequently, the legislature passed AB 2293 (Bonilla) Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014, which codified the CPUC’s definition of TNCs and imposed certain liability and other insurance coverage for TNCs and their participating drivers. The bill defines when personal and commercial auto insurance come into effect, and at what levels, when the driver logs onto the application until the driver accepts a ride request, and for when a ride request is accepted until the passenger exits the vehicle. The bill sought to make a clear distinction between when a vehicle is being used for TNC business activities and must require commercial insurance, and when a vehicle is not being used for TNC business activities at which time the driver’s personal auto insurance is in effect.
CPC Permits: The CPUC authorizes six types of certificates and permits for CPCs. The CPUC authorizes three types of transferable certificates: Class A certificates allows charter service between any point in the state, such as roundtrip sightseeing service, Class B certificates allows charter service between any point within a 125 miles of the carrier’s home terminal, Class C certificates transportation services that apply to commercial balloon operations, and commercial river rafting or skiing.
The CPUC also authorizes three types of nontransferable permits. These permits include: P permits which allows charter services using only vehicles that can seat under 15 passengers, S permits which authorizes vehicles to provide round-trip sightseeing services, and Z permits which authorizes specialized services not offered to the general public; namely, transportation incidental to another business, transportation under contact with specific entities, and transportation of agricultural works to and from farms.
Transportation Network Companies & Charter Party Carriers: Although TNCs do not neatly fall into the conventional definition of either taxis or limousines, the CPUC does believe that TNCS are currently providing passenger’s transportation for compensation, and reasonably concludes that TNCs are charter party passenger carriers, therefore, falling under the CPUC’s existing jurisdiction over these services.
Because the CPUC considers TNCs as a form of CPC under its regulatory purview, a company who wishes to operate as a TNC must apply for a TNC subclass of a CPC – P permit. These CPC – P permits are only granted to companies utilizing smartphone technology application that facilitate transportation passengers in the drivers’ personal vehicle. TNCs are not permitted to own vehicles used in their operations or own fleets of vehicles. However, there is no limit to the number of drivers a TNC can have under one permit. Individual TNC drivers do not have to apply for their own CPC permit, but would need to complete the TNCs process to be enrolled as a driver under a TNC.
Vehicle Requirements for TNCs: The CPUC only allows TNCs to use street legal coupes, sedans, or light-duty vehicles, including vans, minivans, SUVs, pickup trucks, as well as hatchbacks and convertibles. TNC vehicles must not be significantly modified from factory specifications. TNCs are allowed to operate vehicles with a seating capacity of up to seven passengers, including the driver, if they have a $1 million commercial liability insurance on file. They are allowed to operate a vehicle with a seating capacity of up to ten passengers, including the driver, if they carry a $1.5 million commercial liability insurance on file. TNCs are not allowed to operate vehicles with a seating capacity of more than 10 passengers, including the driver, which is legally defined as a bus.
The author may wish to consider an amendment to further clarify that TNCs may not use vehicles to provide transit service or to carry passengers over a fixed route, provide school pupil transportation services, and provide public paratransit services.
Exemptions: Current law provides two types of exemptions from the prohibition against CPC vehicles from charging individual-fares. These exemptions include, school buses who are contacted and compensated by parents of children attending public, private or parochial schools, and certified operators of roundtrip sightseeing tour services.
This bill would include a rideshare program operated by a TNC to this list of exemptions, provided that the individual fare for each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the same ride to a single passenger traveling alone. The distinction between the current list of exemptions and TNCs is the fact that for school buses and sightseeing tour services, the stop locations are dictated by the driver or the company in advance. Whereas for TNCs, the passenger dictates the stop locations, which can change each time a TNC driver picks up a new patron.
CPUC Letter to TNCs: In September 2014, the CPUC sent letters to the three major TNCs, Uber, Lyft, and Sidecar, regarding their intent to add carpooling service to their transportation service. The CPUC stated that this model is in violation of existing law that prohibits CPCs from calculating charges on an individual-fare basis. The CPUC found that CPCs “cannot change an individual fare when carrying multiple person in a vehicle, and therefore, a person chartering a [CPC] vehicle must have exclusive use of the vehicle.”
TNCs and Carpooling: As the number of TNC drivers continue to increase, offering carpooling services may be beneficial for patrons because it allows them to share and reduce the cost of a single ride for each passenger because TNC fares for the most part are dictated by the demand during a specific time or location. TNC carpooling services may also have the added benefit of reducing the number of vehicles on the road. However, if this service serves to provide an additional incentive for more drivers to join TNCs, it is unclear whether or not carpooling will have the desired effects of reducing emissions as it might have the contrary effect of adding more TNC drivers on the road who otherwise would not be driving, instead of reducing the number of drivers on the road.
Suggested Amendments:
5401. (c) A rideshare program operated by a transportation
network company subject to this chapter that arranges a ride on a
prearranged route among multiple passengers who share the ride in
whole or in part, provided that (1) the vehicle seats no more than
seven persons, including the driver, (2) the driver is a
participating driver as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 5431,
(3) the vehicle is not used to provide public transit
services or to carry passengers over a fixed route, (4) the vehicle
is not used to provide school pupil transportation services, (5) the
vehicle is not used to provide public paratransit services,
and (3) (4) the individual fare for
each passenger is less than the fare that would be charged for the
same ride to a single passenger traveling alone.
Arguments in Support: According to the Internet Association, “this measure is squarely in line with well-established California public policy that broadly encourages carpooling to reduce traffic congestion and air pollution. AB 1360 also furthers California’s commitment to the environment on other fronts, such as by enhancing our State’s greenhouse gas reduction efforts. Consumers also benefit from greater transportation options. Multiple passenger ride sharing services provide greater affordability and flexibility for consumers.”
Arguments in Opposition: According to the California Teamsters Public Affairs Council, “under current law, when a person engages a ‘charter party carrier,’ they rent the entire vehicle for a set period for a single, undivided cost. If rates splitting is allowed, … the transportation agreement effectively ceases to be a charter and patrons are charged an individual rate. Thus, unlike a ‘common carrier,’ such as a public transit operator, they will be able to serve the public but be able to get away with rate discrimination, geographical discrimination, and constantly changing costs of service.”
Related Legislation:
AB 24 (Nazarian) 2015: This bill would require charter-party carriers and transportation network companies to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles Employer Pull Notice System and submit all drivers to a Department of Justice criminal background check.
AB 828 (Low) 2015: This bill would exclude from the definition of “commercial vehicle,” for purposes of the Vehicle Code, any motor vehicle operated in connection with a transportation network company.
AB 1422 (Cooper) 2015: Authorizes TNCs to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicle Employer Pull Notice System.
Prior Legislation:
AB 612 (Nazarian) 2014: Requires charter party carriers to participate in the Department of Motor Vehicles Employer Pull Notice system and submit all drivers to a Department of Justice criminal background check. Held in Assembly Committee on Transportation.
AB 2293 (Bonilla) 2014: Establishes guidelines for insurance coverage for Transportation Network Companies to ensure personal and financial safety of consumers. Chaptered by the Secretary of State – Chapter 389, Statutes of 2014.
Double Referred: This bill is double referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The Internet Association (Co-Sponsor)
TechNet (Co-Sponsor)
Bay Area Council
Clean Coalition
Coalition for Clean Air
Environment California
Environmental Defense Fund
Orange County Business Council
Planning & Conservation League
San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR)
TransForm
Uber Technologies, Inc.
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Opposition
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists (IAM)
California State Council of the Service Employees International Union (SEIU)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council (ATU)
San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / U. & C. / (916) 319-2083
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Commerce
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):