SB 381: Certificated school employees: reduction in workforce: deviation from order of seniority: career pathway programs.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-06
Under existing law, when certificated school employees are terminated pursuant to a reduction in workforce, a school district is required to terminate the employees in order of seniority. Existing law further provides those employees with a preferred right to reappointment and an opportunity for substitute service in order of seniority. Existing law authorizes a school district to deviate from the order of seniority for those purposes for specified reasons, including the school district demonstrating a specified need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study and the certificated employee having special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study, which others with more seniority do not possess.
This bill would authorize that the specific course or course of study, that may allow a school district to deviate from terminating certificated school employees in order of seniority, include career technical education and or career pathway programs, program, and would further authorize that a school district may deviate from the order of seniority to comply with the school districts local control and accountability plan, as specified. The bill additionally would authorize that the specific course or course of study for which a school district may deviate from the order of seniority for purposes of reappointment of permanent and probationary employees includes, but is not limited to, career technical education or career pathway program. The bill would also make numerous nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
Under existing law, when school employees are terminated pursuant to a reduction in workforce, a school district is required to terminate the employees in order of seniority. Existing law authorizes a school district to deviate from the order of seniority for those purposes for specified reasons, including the school district demonstrating a specified need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study and the certificated employee having special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study, which others with more seniority do not possess.
This bill would authorize that the course or course of study, that may allow a school district to deviate from terminating school employees in order of seniority, include career technical education and career pathway programs, and would further authorize that a school district may deviate from the order of seniority to comply with the school districts local control and accountability plan, as specified.
(a)No A permanent employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for causes other than those specified in Sections 44907 and 44923, and Sections 44932 to 44947, inclusive, and no a probationary employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for cause other than as specified in Sections 44948 to 44949, inclusive.
(b)Whenever in any (1)If in a school year the average daily attendance in all of the schools of a school district for the first six months in which that school is in session shall have has declined below the corresponding period of either of the previous two school years, whenever if the governing board of a school district determines that attendance in a the school district will decline in the following year as a result of the termination of an interdistrict tuition agreement as defined described in Section 46304, whenever if a particular kind of service is to be reduced or discontinued not later than the beginning of the following school year, or whenever if the amendment of state law requires the modification of curriculum, and when in the opinion of if the governing board of the school district it shall have become determines it necessary by reason of any of these conditions to decrease the number of permanent employees in the school district, the governing board of the school district may terminate the services of not more than a corresponding percentage of the certificated employees of the school district, permanent as well as probationary, at the close of the school year. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the services of no a permanent employee may shall not be terminated under the provisions of this section while any a probationary employee, or any other employee with less seniority, is retained to render a service which said that the permanent employee is certificated and competent to render.
In
(2)In computing a decline in average daily attendance for purposes of this section subdivision for a newly formed or reorganized school district, each school of the school district shall be deemed to have been a school of the newly formed or reorganized school district for both of the two previous school years.
As
(3)As between employees who first rendered paid service to the school district on the same date, the governing board of the school district shall determine the order of termination solely on the basis of needs of the school district and the students thereof. pupils of the school district. Upon the request of any an employee whose order of termination is so determined, the governing board of the school district shall furnish in writing writing, no later than five days prior to before the commencement of the hearing held in accordance with Section 44949, a statement of the specific criteria used in determining the order of termination and the application of the criteria in ranking each employee relative to the other employees in the group. This The requirement that the governing board of the school district provide, on request, a written statement of reasons for determining the order of termination shall not be interpreted to give affected employees any legal right or interest that would not exist without such a the requirement.
(c)(1)Notice of such the termination of services shall be given before the 15th of the manner prescribed in May 15 pursuant to Section 44949, and the services of such those employees shall be terminated in the inverse of the order in which they were employed, as determined by the governing board of the school district in accordance with the provisions of Sections 44844 and 44845. In the event that If a permanent or probationary employee is not given the notices and a right to a hearing as provided for in Section 44949, he or she shall be deemed reemployed for the ensuing school year.
The
(2)The governing board of the school district shall make assignments and reassignments in such a manner that employees shall be retained to render any service which their seniority and qualifications entitle them to render. However, prior to before assigning or reassigning any a certificated employee to teach a subject which that he or she has not previously taught, and for which he or she does not have a teaching credential or which that is not within the employees major area of postsecondary study or the equivalent thereof, the governing board of the school district shall require the employee to pass a subject matter competency test in the appropriate subject.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a school district may deviate from terminating a certificated employee in order of seniority for either of the following reasons:
(1)The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, including, but not limited to, career technical education or career pathway program, or to provide services authorized by a services credential with a specialization in either pupil personnel services or health for a school nurse, and that the certificated employee has special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study or to provide those services, which that others with more seniority do not possess.
(2)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws.
(3)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school districts local control and accountability plan.
SEC. 2.Section 44956 of the Education Code is amended to read:44956.Any permanent employee whose services have been terminated as provided in Section 44955 shall have the following rights:
(a)For the period of 39 months from the date of the termination, any an employee who in the meantime has not attained the age of 65 years shall have the preferred right to reappointment, in the order of original employment as determined by the governing board of the school district in accordance with Sections 44831 to 44855, inclusive, if the number of employees is increased or the discontinued service is reestablished, with no requirements that were not imposed upon other employees who continued in service; provided, that no probationary or other employee with less seniority shall be employed to render a service that the employee is certificated and competent to render. However, prior to before reappointing any employee to teach a subject that he or she has not previously taught, and for which he or she does not have a teaching credential or that is not within the employees major area of postsecondary study or the equivalent thereof, the governing board of the school district shall require the employee to pass a subject matter competency test in the appropriate subject.
(b)The right to reappointment described in subdivision (a) may be waived by the employee, without prejudice, for not more than one school year, unless the governing board of the school district extends this right, but the that waiver shall not deprive the employee of his or her right to subsequent offers of reappointment.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a school district may deviate from reappointing a certificated employee in order of seniority for either of the following reasons:
(1)The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, including, but not limited to, career technical education or career pathway program, or to provide services authorized by a services credential with a specialization in either pupil personnel services or health for a school nurse, and that the employee has special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study, or to provide those services, that others with more seniority do not possess.
(2)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws.
(d)As to any an employee who is reappointed, the period of his or her absence shall be treated as a leave of absence and shall not be considered as a break in the continuity of his or her service, he or she shall retain the classification and order of employment he or she had when his or her services were terminated, and credit for prior service under any state or school district retirement system shall not be affected by such the termination, but the period of his or her absence shall not count as a part of the service required for retirement.
(e)During the period of his or her preferred right to reappointment, an the employee shall, in the order of original employment, be offered prior opportunity for substitute service during the absence of any other employee who has been granted a leave of absence or who is temporarily absent from duty; provided, that his or her services may be terminated upon the return to duty of the other employee and that the substitute service shall not affect the retention of his or her previous classification and rights. If, in any school year the employee serves as a substitute in any position requiring certification for 21 days or more within a period of 60 schooldays, the compensation the employee receives for substitute service in that 60-day period, including his or her first 20 days of substitute service, shall be not be less than the amount the employee would receive if he or she were being reappointed.
(f)(1)During the period of the employees preferred right to reappointment, the governing board of the school district, if it is also the governing board of one or more other school districts, may assign him or her to service, which he or she is certificated and competent to render, in another said other school district or districts; provided, that the compensation he or she receives therefor for the service may, in the discretion of the governing board, board of the school district, be the same as he or she would have received had he or she been serving in the school district from which his or her services were terminated, that his or her service in the other school district or districts shall be counted toward the period required for both state and local retirement as though rendered in the school district from which his or her services were terminated, and that no permanent employee in the other school district or districts shall be displaced by him or her.
(2)It is the intent of this subdivision that the employees of a school district, the governing board of which is also the governing board of one or more other school districts, shall not be at a disadvantage as compared with employees of a unified school district.
(g)At any time prior to before the completion of one year after his or her return to service, he or she may continue or make up, with interest, his or her own contributions to any state or school district retirement system, system for the period of his or her absence, but it shall not be obligatory on state or school district to match those contributions.
(h)Should he or she become disabled or reach retirement age at any time before his or her return to service, he or she shall receive, in any state or school district retirement system of which he or she was a member, all benefits to which he or she would have been entitled had such event occurred at the time of his or her termination of service, plus any benefits he or she may have qualified for thereafter, after his or her termination of service, as though still employed.
SEC. 3.Section 44957 of the Education Code is amended to read:44957.Any A probationary employee whose services have been terminated as provided in Section 44955 shall have the following rights:
(a)For the period of 24 months from the date of such the termination, any an employee who in the meantime has not attained the age of 65 years shall have the preferred right to reappointment, subject to the prior rights to reappointment by all permanent employees as set forth in Section 44956, in the order of original employment as determined by the governing board of the school district in accordance with the provisions of Sections 44831 to 44855, inclusive, if the number of employees is increased or the discontinued service is reestablished, with no requirements that were not imposed upon other employees who continued in service. Except as otherwise provided, no a probationary or temporary employee with less seniority shall not be employed to render a service which such that the employee is certificated and competent to render and provided that such an the employee shall be given a priority over employees whose right to a position is derived pursuant to Section 44918. However, prior to before reappointing any an employee to teach a subject which that he or she has not previously taught, and for which he or she does not have a teaching credential or which that is not within the employees major area of postsecondary study or the equivalent thereof, the governing board of the school district shall require the employee to pass a subject matter competency test in the appropriate subject.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a school district may deviate from reappointing a probationary employee in order of seniority for either of the following reasons:
(1)The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, including, but not limited to, career technical education or career pathway program, or to provide services authorized by a services credential with a specialization in either pupil personnel services or health for a school nurse, and that the employee has special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study, or to provide those services, which that others with more seniority do not possess.
(2)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws.
(c)As to any such an employee who is reappointed, the period of his or her absence shall be treated as a leave of absence and shall not be considered as a break in the continuity of his or her service, he or she shall retain the classification and order of employment he or she had when his or her services were terminated, and credit for prior service under any state or school district retirement system shall not be affected by such the termination; provided, however, that the period of his or her absence shall not be counted as a part of the service required for attaining permanent status in the school district or, except as provided in subdivision (e), for retirement purposes.
(d)During the period of his or her preferred right to reappointment, any such the employee shall, in the order of original employment, and subject to the rights of permanent employees as set forth in Section 44956, be offered prior opportunity for substitute service during the absence of any other employee who has been granted leave of absence or who is temporarily absent from duty; provided, that his or her services may be terminated upon a return to duty of such the other employee, that such substitute service shall not affect the retention of his or her previous classification and rights, and that such an employee shall be given a priority over employees whose right to a substitute position is derived pursuant to Section 44918.
(e)At any time prior to before the completion of one year after his or her return to service, an employee reappointed under the provisions of this section may elect to continue or to reinstate his or her membership and interest in any state or school district retirement system and to receive retirement benefits as if no absence from service had occurred. In the event of such that election the employee shall pay into the retirement system the amount of his or her share of contribution and the school districts share of contribution attributable to the period of absence and the amount of any contributions withdrawn, plus interest.
SECTION 1.Section 44955 of the Education Code is amended to read:44955.(a)A permanent employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for causes other than those specified in Sections 44907 and 44923, and Sections 44932 to 44947, inclusive, and a probationary employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for cause other than as specified in Sections 44948 to 44949, inclusive.
(b)(1)If in a school year the average daily attendance in all of the schools of a school district for the first six months that school is in session shall have declined below the corresponding period of either of the previous two school years, if the governing board of a school district determines that attendance in the school district will decline in the following year as a result of the termination of an interdistrict tuition agreement as described in Section 46304, if a particular kind of service is to be reduced or discontinued not later than the beginning of the following school year, or if the amendment of state law requires the modification of curriculum, and if the governing board of the school district determines it necessary by reason of any of these conditions to decrease the number of permanent employees in the school district, the governing board of the school district may terminate the services of not more than a corresponding percentage of the certificated employees of the school district, permanent as well as probationary, at the close of the school year. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the services of a permanent employee shall not be terminated under this section while a probationary employee, or any other employee with less seniority, is retained to render a service that the permanent employee is certificated and competent to render.
(2)In computing a decline in average daily attendance for purposes of this subdivision for a newly formed or reorganized school district, each school of the school district shall be deemed to have been a school of the newly formed or reorganized school district for both of the two previous school years.
(3)As between employees who first rendered paid service to the school district on the same date, the governing board of the school district shall determine the order of termination solely on the basis of needs of the school district and the pupils of the school district. Upon the request of an employee whose order of termination is so determined, the governing board of the school district shall furnish in writing, no later than five days before the commencement of the hearing held in accordance with Section 44949, a statement of the specific criteria used in determining the order of termination and the application of the criteria in ranking each employee relative to the other employees in the group. The requirement that the governing board of the school district provide, on request, a written statement of reasons for determining the order of termination shall not be interpreted to give affected employees any legal right or interest that would not exist without the requirement.
(c)(1)Notice of the termination of services shall be given before May 15 pursuant to Section 44949, and the services of those employees shall be terminated in the inverse of the order in which they were employed, as determined by the governing board of the school district in accordance with the provisions of Sections 44844 and 44845. If a permanent or probationary employee is not given the notices and a right to a hearing as provided for in Section 44949, he or she shall be deemed reemployed for the ensuing school year.
(2)The governing board of the school district shall make assignments and reassignments in a manner that employees shall be retained to render any service their seniority and qualifications entitle them to render. However, before assigning or reassigning a certificated employee to teach a subject that he or she has not previously taught, and for which he or she does not have a teaching credential or that is not within the employees major area of postsecondary study or the equivalent thereof, the governing board of the school district shall require the employee to pass a subject matter competency test in the appropriate subject.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a school district may deviate from terminating a certificated employee in order of seniority for either of the following reasons:
(1)The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, including, but not limited to, career technical education or career pathway programs, or to provide services authorized by a services credential with a specialization in either pupil personnel services or health for a school nurse, and that the certificated employee has special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study or to provide those services, that others with more seniority do not possess.
(2)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws.
(3)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school districts local control and accountability plan.
(a)No A permanent employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for causes other than those specified in Sections 44907 and 44923, and Sections 44932 to 44947, inclusive, and no a probationary employee shall not be deprived of his or her position for cause other than as specified in Sections 44948 to 44949, inclusive.
(b)Whenever (1)If in any a school year the average daily attendance in all of the schools of a school district for the first six months in which that school is in session shall have declined below the corresponding period of either of the previous two school years, whenever if the governing board of a school district determines that attendance in a the school district will decline in the following year as a result of the termination of an interdistrict tuition agreement as defined described in Section 46304, whenever if a particular kind of service is to be reduced or discontinued not later than the beginning of the following school year, or whenever if the amendment of state law requires the modification of curriculum, and when in the opinion of if the governing board of the school district determines it shall have become necessary by reason of any of these conditions to decrease the number of permanent employees in the school district, the governing board of the school district may terminate the services of not more than a corresponding percentage of the certificated employees of the school district, permanent as well as probationary, at the close of the school year. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the services of no a permanent employee may shall not be terminated under the provisions of this section while any a probationary employee, or any other employee with less seniority, is retained to render a service which said that the permanent employee is certificated and competent to render.
In
(2)In computing a decline in average daily attendance for purposes of this section subdivision for a newly formed or reorganized school district, each school of the school district shall be deemed to have been a school of the newly formed or reorganized school district for both of the two previous school years.
As
(3)As between employees who first rendered paid service to the school district on the same date, the governing board of the school district shall determine the order of termination solely on the basis of needs of the school district and the students thereof. pupils of the school district. Upon the request of any an employee whose order of termination is so determined, the governing board of the school district shall furnish in writing writing, no later than five days prior to before the commencement of the hearing held in accordance with Section 44949, a statement of the specific criteria used in determining the order of termination and the application of the criteria in ranking each employee relative to the other employees in the group. This The requirement that the governing board of the school district provide, on request, a written statement of reasons for determining the order of termination shall not be interpreted to give affected employees any legal right or interest that would not exist without such a the requirement.
(c)(1)Notice of such the termination of services shall be given before the 15th of May in the manner prescribed in May 15 pursuant to Section 44949, and the services of such those employees shall be terminated in the inverse of the order in which they were employed, as determined by the governing board of the school district in accordance with the provisions of Sections 44844 and 44845. In the event that If a permanent or probationary employee is not given the notices and a right to a hearing as provided for in Section 44949, he or she shall be deemed reemployed for the ensuing school year.
The
(2)The governing board of the school district shall make assignments and reassignments in such a manner that employees shall be retained to render any service which their seniority and qualifications entitle them to render. However, prior to before assigning or reassigning any a certificated employee to teach a subject which that he or she has not previously taught, and for which he or she does not have a teaching credential or which that is not within the employees major area of postsecondary study or the equivalent thereof, the governing board of the school district shall require the employee to pass a subject matter competency test in the appropriate subject.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a school district may deviate from terminating a certificated employee in order of seniority for either of the following reasons:
(1)The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, including, but not limited to, career technical education or career pathway programs, or to provide services authorized by a services credential with a specialization in either pupil personnel services or health for a school nurse, and that the certificated employee has special training and experience necessary to teach that course or course of study or to provide those services, which that others with more seniority do not possess.
(2)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws.
(3)For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school districts local control and accountability plan.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 5, 2016 | January 13 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jan 4, 2016 | Set for hearing January 13. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | April 29 set for first hearing. Held in committee without recommendation. |
| Apr 17, 2015 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 5, 2015 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 25, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 24, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 381 (Huff) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Carol Liu, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 381
Author: |
Huff |
||
Version: |
April 6, 2015 Hearing Date: April 29, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Lenin Del Castillo |
||
Subject: Certificated school employees: reduction in workforce: deviation from order of seniority: career pathway programs
SUMMARY
This bill allows school districts to exempt teachers in career technical education or career pathways programs, and also for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school district’s local control and accountability plan, from the seniority-based staffing provisions in current law.
BACKGROUND
Existing law requires school districts to provide preliminary notification to a permanent employee that his or her services will not be required for the ensuing year no later than March 15th and provide final notification of termination of his or her services by May 15th. Permanent employees that receive a preliminary layoff notice are allowed to request a hearing to determine if there is cause for not reemploying him or her for the ensuing year. The hearing is to be conducted by an administrative law judge who shall prepare a proposed decision, containing findings of fact and a determination as to whether the charges sustained by the evidence are related to the welfare of the schools and students. Copies of the proposed decision, which is not binding on the governing board, shall be submitted to the governing board and to the employee on or before May 7th. (Education Code § 44949)
Existing
law requires districts to terminate employees in the inverse of the
order in which they were employed. School districts may deviate from
the order of seniority if:
The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, or to provide services authorized by certain specialized services credentials and the retained individual has the specific experience or training required to meet that need or to provide those services, which others with more seniority do not possess.
For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws. (EC § 44955)
These seniority-based provisions also apply to the preferred rights to reappointment for permanent and probationary employees whose services have been terminated as outlined in EC § 44956 and EC § 44957.
Existing law defines linked learning programs as multi-year, comprehensive high school programs of integrated academic and technical study that are organized around a broad theme, interest area, or industry sector, and provide curriculum choices that prepare participating pupils for a range of postsecondary options, including two and four-year colleges, apprenticeships, and formal employment training. Current law specifies that linked learning programs are comprised, among other things, of an integrated core curriculum that meets the eligibility requirements for admission to the University of California and the California State University and is delivered through project-based learning and other engaging instructional strategies. (Education Code § 52372.5)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
Specifies that career technical education or a career pathways program is included as a specific course or course of study for which a school district may deviate from terminating a permanent certificated employee or reappointing a permanent certificated or probationary employee in order of seniority.
Provides that a school district may deviate from terminating a certificated employee in order of seniority for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school district’s local control and accountability plan.
STAFF
COMMENTS
Need for the bill. According to the author’s office, the side effects of seniority on career pathways programs can cause problems for teachers and students. These programs typically require a more stable teaching staff because not only must the teacher be proficient in teaching the subject matter, but he or she must also be knowledgeable about the specific career pathway central to his or her school. Learning the elements of a particular theme takes time, and consistency among staff is critical. The author’s office indicates that seniority rules undermine this because teachers may get “bumped” based on the date of hire rather than school academic priorities, making it difficult to maintain a stable faculty that can deliver the unique educational experience provided in career pathway programs. Further, there may be unnecessary cost pressures on school districts with career pathway schools to retrain new teachers every year due to seniority bumping.
Priority. Career technical education (CTE) and career pathways programs may provide valuable benefits of combining academics, technical training, and workplace experiences potentially leading to higher graduation rates. However, do teachers in career pathways programs or those that teach CTE courses deserve more protection in staffing decisions than other teachers? It is unclear whether the impacts of teacher layoffs for these courses are more severe than instructors for high school graduation course requirements such as English, math, and science that are not affiliated with CTE or career pathways programs. Additionally, opponents of the bill argue that seniority is a way to objectively release employees and to preserve the most experienced teaching professionals.
The bill also allows school districts to deviate from seniority with layoffs for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with a school district’s local control and accountability plan (LCAP). The LCAP is a comprehensive planning document that reflects a school district’s annual goals (and actions to achieve those goals) in each of the eight state priorities which are intended to encompass the key features of high-quality educational programs. School districts are required to include associated data in their LCAPs and as well as both district-wide goals and goals for each numerically significant student subgroup in the district. Further, school district LCAPs can include annual goals in self-selected areas of local priority in addition to the specified state priorities. While school districts are required to use a template developed by the State Board of Education to create consistency across the state, each school district has discretion in the development of its LCAP and can tailor it to meet the specific needs of its local community. As such, it appears that the bill would allow school districts significant flexibility in determining how to terminate employees.
Is the bill necessary? Current law allows a school district to deviate from seniority if it demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, or to provide services authorized by certain specialized services credentials and the retained individual has the specific experience or training required to meet that need or to provide those services, which others with more seniority do not possess. To the extent that a school district can demonstrate that career technical education (CTE) or a career pathways program meets these criteria, school districts may already be able to deviate from seniority for these programs under current law.
Vergara v. California. The Vergara case was filed here in California by nine public school children from around the state in May 2012. The case challenges various provisions of the education code related to the way the teacher workforce is managed, including seniority and last in, first statutes. The plaintiffs argue that these laws play out in classrooms and schools in ways that violate students’ rights to access equal education under the California constitution. In June 2014, the Los Angeles Superior Court issued a final judgment in favor of the students on all three issues in August 2014. In September 2014, Governor Brown and Attorney General Harris filed an appeal of the decision. The California Teachers Association and the California Federation of Teachers, formal interveners in the case, also filed an appeal of the decision. The appeal is awaiting hearing at the appellate court level and a decision is expected in the Fall of 2015. Depending on the outcome, the Vergara case could potentially impact the same seniority provisions of the education code that this bill proposes to amend.
Linked learning. As defined in statute, linked learning programs integrate academic instruction with technical curriculum and work-based learning within the context of industry sectors identified in the model curriculum standards for career technical education adopted by the State Board of Education. These programs connect learning in the classroom with real-world applications outside of school. Whether the linked learning occurs within a program, is employed as a strategy in an individual course, or is utilized as a methodology by one or more high school departments, the underlying premise is to “link” academic constructs with opportunities for project-based “learning.”
AB 790 (Furutani, Chapter 616, Statutes of 2011) established the Linked Learning Pilot Program for the purpose of implementing districtwide linked learning programs. In January of 2013, the State Department of Education chose twenty participants that include individual school districts, consortia of districts, and county offices of education to take part in the Linked Learning Pilot Program, based on competitive criteria. The program, contingent upon the availability of funding, is scheduled to become inoperative on July 1, 2017.
Career Pathways Trust Program. AB 86 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 48, Statutes of 2013) created the California Career Pathways Trust and provided $250 million on a one-time basis to school districts, county superintendents of schools, charter schools, and community college districts in the form of one-time competitive grants. The 2014-15 Budget Act provided an additional $250 million for a program total of $500 million. Grants were available for K-14 career pathways programs to build stronger connections between businesses, schools, and community colleges to better prepare students for the 21st century workplace and place a greater emphasis on career-based learning.
Unlike “linked learning”, it does not appear that “career pathways” is defined in statute. There are similarities with the purposes of the Career Pathways Trust and the Linked Learning Pilot programs, but absent a clear definition of “career pathways”, it is unclear if the bill’s provisions apply only to those grant recipients under the Career Pathways Trust Program or whether it applies to the Linked Learning Pilot Program as well. Due to the similarities of the programs, the bill could reasonably be interpreted to apply to both programs. The bill could also be interpreted to apply to any school that is implementing similar educational models in terms of putting teams of faculty together to deliver their specific pathways program and curriculum, but is not funded pursuant to those programs. In the latter case, this bill could have broader implications.
Related and prior legislation.
AB 1044 (Baker) proposes to repeal the various seniority-based staffing provisions in current law and instead require school districts to adopt policies regarding the dismissal of employees when reductions in workforce are necessary. This bill is pending before the Assembly Education Committee.
SB 1185 (Huff, 2014), similar to this bill, would have allowed school districts to exempt career pathways program teachers from the seniority-based staffing provisions in current law. SB 1185 failed passage in this Committee.
AB 86 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 48, Statutes of 2013, established the California Career Pathways Trust and appropriated $250 million in one-time competitive grants for its purposes.
SB 1070 (Steinberg), Chapter 433, Statutes of 2012, modified the Career Technical Education Pathways Program to improve linkages and career technical education pathways between high schools and community colleges.
SB 355 (Huff, 2011) proposed to authorize school districts to evaluate and assess the performance of certificated employees using a multiple-measures evaluation system, make specified employment decisions based on teacher performance, and expand the reasons districts may deviate from the order of seniority in terminating and reappointing teachers. SB 355 failed passage in this Committee.
SB 1285 (Steinberg, 2010) proposed various changes to the procedures school districts are required to follow when hiring, terminating, and reappointing teachers, including criteria to deviate from seniority. This bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 955 (Huff, 2010) would have made various changes to statutes governing staffing notification deadlines, layoff and dismissal procedures, and reemployment preferences pertaining to certificated educators. This bill was heard and passed by this Committee and subsequently held by the Senate Rules Committee.
SUPPORT
California Chamber of Commerce
School Employers Association of California
OPPOSITION
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
California Federation of Teachers
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
-- END --
SB 381 (Huff) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Carol Liu, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 381
Author: |
Huff |
||
Version: |
April 6, 2015 Hearing Date: April 29, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Lenin Del Castillo |
||
Subject: Certificated school employees: reduction in workforce: deviation from order of seniority: career pathway programs
SUMMARY
This bill allows school districts to exempt teachers in career technical education or career pathways programs, and also for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school district’s local control and accountability plan, from the seniority-based staffing provisions in current law.
BACKGROUND
Existing law requires school districts to provide preliminary notification to a permanent employee that his or her services will not be required for the ensuing year no later than March 15th and provide final notification of termination of his or her services by May 15th. Permanent employees that receive a preliminary layoff notice are allowed to request a hearing to determine if there is cause for not reemploying him or her for the ensuing year. The hearing is to be conducted by an administrative law judge who shall prepare a proposed decision, containing findings of fact and a determination as to whether the charges sustained by the evidence are related to the welfare of the schools and students. Copies of the proposed decision, which is not binding on the governing board, shall be submitted to the governing board and to the employee on or before May 7th. (Education Code § 44949)
Existing
law requires districts to terminate employees in the inverse of the
order in which they were employed. School districts may deviate from
the order of seniority if:
The school district demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, or to provide services authorized by certain specialized services credentials and the retained individual has the specific experience or training required to meet that need or to provide those services, which others with more seniority do not possess.
For purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with constitutional requirements related to equal protection of the laws. (EC § 44955)
These seniority-based provisions also apply to the preferred rights to reappointment for permanent and probationary employees whose services have been terminated as outlined in EC § 44956 and EC § 44957.
Existing law defines linked learning programs as multi-year, comprehensive high school programs of integrated academic and technical study that are organized around a broad theme, interest area, or industry sector, and provide curriculum choices that prepare participating pupils for a range of postsecondary options, including two and four-year colleges, apprenticeships, and formal employment training. Current law specifies that linked learning programs are comprised, among other things, of an integrated core curriculum that meets the eligibility requirements for admission to the University of California and the California State University and is delivered through project-based learning and other engaging instructional strategies. (Education Code § 52372.5)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
Specifies that career technical education or a career pathways program is included as a specific course or course of study for which a school district may deviate from terminating a permanent certificated employee or reappointing a permanent certificated or probationary employee in order of seniority.
Provides that a school district may deviate from terminating a certificated employee in order of seniority for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with the school district’s local control and accountability plan.
STAFF
COMMENTS
Need for the bill. According to the author’s office, the side effects of seniority on career pathways programs can cause problems for teachers and students. These programs typically require a more stable teaching staff because not only must the teacher be proficient in teaching the subject matter, but he or she must also be knowledgeable about the specific career pathway central to his or her school. Learning the elements of a particular theme takes time, and consistency among staff is critical. The author’s office indicates that seniority rules undermine this because teachers may get “bumped” based on the date of hire rather than school academic priorities, making it difficult to maintain a stable faculty that can deliver the unique educational experience provided in career pathway programs. Further, there may be unnecessary cost pressures on school districts with career pathway schools to retrain new teachers every year due to seniority bumping.
Priority. Career technical education (CTE) and career pathways programs may provide valuable benefits of combining academics, technical training, and workplace experiences potentially leading to higher graduation rates. However, do teachers in career pathways programs or those that teach CTE courses deserve more protection in staffing decisions than other teachers? It is unclear whether the impacts of teacher layoffs for these courses are more severe than instructors for high school graduation course requirements such as English, math, and science that are not affiliated with CTE or career pathways programs. Additionally, opponents of the bill argue that seniority is a way to objectively release employees and to preserve the most experienced teaching professionals.
The bill also allows school districts to deviate from seniority with layoffs for purposes of maintaining or achieving compliance with a school district’s local control and accountability plan (LCAP). The LCAP is a comprehensive planning document that reflects a school district’s annual goals (and actions to achieve those goals) in each of the eight state priorities which are intended to encompass the key features of high-quality educational programs. School districts are required to include associated data in their LCAPs and as well as both district-wide goals and goals for each numerically significant student subgroup in the district. Further, school district LCAPs can include annual goals in self-selected areas of local priority in addition to the specified state priorities. While school districts are required to use a template developed by the State Board of Education to create consistency across the state, each school district has discretion in the development of its LCAP and can tailor it to meet the specific needs of its local community. As such, it appears that the bill would allow school districts significant flexibility in determining how to terminate employees.
Is the bill necessary? Current law allows a school district to deviate from seniority if it demonstrates a specific need for personnel to teach a specific course or course of study, or to provide services authorized by certain specialized services credentials and the retained individual has the specific experience or training required to meet that need or to provide those services, which others with more seniority do not possess. To the extent that a school district can demonstrate that career technical education (CTE) or a career pathways program meets these criteria, school districts may already be able to deviate from seniority for these programs under current law.
Vergara v. California. The Vergara case was filed here in California by nine public school children from around the state in May 2012. The case challenges various provisions of the education code related to the way the teacher workforce is managed, including seniority and last in, first statutes. The plaintiffs argue that these laws play out in classrooms and schools in ways that violate students’ rights to access equal education under the California constitution. In June 2014, the Los Angeles Superior Court issued a final judgment in favor of the students on all three issues in August 2014. In September 2014, Governor Brown and Attorney General Harris filed an appeal of the decision. The California Teachers Association and the California Federation of Teachers, formal interveners in the case, also filed an appeal of the decision. The appeal is awaiting hearing at the appellate court level and a decision is expected in the Fall of 2015. Depending on the outcome, the Vergara case could potentially impact the same seniority provisions of the education code that this bill proposes to amend.
Linked learning. As defined in statute, linked learning programs integrate academic instruction with technical curriculum and work-based learning within the context of industry sectors identified in the model curriculum standards for career technical education adopted by the State Board of Education. These programs connect learning in the classroom with real-world applications outside of school. Whether the linked learning occurs within a program, is employed as a strategy in an individual course, or is utilized as a methodology by one or more high school departments, the underlying premise is to “link” academic constructs with opportunities for project-based “learning.”
AB 790 (Furutani, Chapter 616, Statutes of 2011) established the Linked Learning Pilot Program for the purpose of implementing districtwide linked learning programs. In January of 2013, the State Department of Education chose twenty participants that include individual school districts, consortia of districts, and county offices of education to take part in the Linked Learning Pilot Program, based on competitive criteria. The program, contingent upon the availability of funding, is scheduled to become inoperative on July 1, 2017.
Career Pathways Trust Program. AB 86 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 48, Statutes of 2013) created the California Career Pathways Trust and provided $250 million on a one-time basis to school districts, county superintendents of schools, charter schools, and community college districts in the form of one-time competitive grants. The 2014-15 Budget Act provided an additional $250 million for a program total of $500 million. Grants were available for K-14 career pathways programs to build stronger connections between businesses, schools, and community colleges to better prepare students for the 21st century workplace and place a greater emphasis on career-based learning.
Unlike “linked learning”, it does not appear that “career pathways” is defined in statute. There are similarities with the purposes of the Career Pathways Trust and the Linked Learning Pilot programs, but absent a clear definition of “career pathways”, it is unclear if the bill’s provisions apply only to those grant recipients under the Career Pathways Trust Program or whether it applies to the Linked Learning Pilot Program as well. Due to the similarities of the programs, the bill could reasonably be interpreted to apply to both programs. The bill could also be interpreted to apply to any school that is implementing similar educational models in terms of putting teams of faculty together to deliver their specific pathways program and curriculum, but is not funded pursuant to those programs. In the latter case, this bill could have broader implications.
Related and prior legislation.
AB 1044 (Baker) proposes to repeal the various seniority-based staffing provisions in current law and instead require school districts to adopt policies regarding the dismissal of employees when reductions in workforce are necessary. This bill is pending before the Assembly Education Committee.
SB 1185 (Huff, 2014), similar to this bill, would have allowed school districts to exempt career pathways program teachers from the seniority-based staffing provisions in current law. SB 1185 failed passage in this Committee.
AB 86 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 48, Statutes of 2013, established the California Career Pathways Trust and appropriated $250 million in one-time competitive grants for its purposes.
SB 1070 (Steinberg), Chapter 433, Statutes of 2012, modified the Career Technical Education Pathways Program to improve linkages and career technical education pathways between high schools and community colleges.
SB 355 (Huff, 2011) proposed to authorize school districts to evaluate and assess the performance of certificated employees using a multiple-measures evaluation system, make specified employment decisions based on teacher performance, and expand the reasons districts may deviate from the order of seniority in terminating and reappointing teachers. SB 355 failed passage in this Committee.
SB 1285 (Steinberg, 2010) proposed various changes to the procedures school districts are required to follow when hiring, terminating, and reappointing teachers, including criteria to deviate from seniority. This bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 955 (Huff, 2010) would have made various changes to statutes governing staffing notification deadlines, layoff and dismissal procedures, and reemployment preferences pertaining to certificated educators. This bill was heard and passed by this Committee and subsequently held by the Senate Rules Committee.
SUPPORT
California Chamber of Commerce
School Employers Association of California
OPPOSITION
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
California Federation of Teachers
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Asociation
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):