SB 582: Electrified fences.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-09-04
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications. Existing law also provides that the owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it.
This bill would amend the list of institutes and associations that may set the standards according to which the lawfulness of an electrified fence is measured and exclude from the definition of electrified fence used in that provision an electrified security fence, as defined. The bill would authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs, the height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet, the fence is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height, and the fence meets specified electrotechnical and local requirements.
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications. Existing law also provides that the owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it.
This bill would amend the list of institutes and associations that may set the standards according to which the lawfulness of an electrified fence is measured and exclude from the definition of electrified fence used in that provision an electrified security fence, as defined. The bill would authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs, the height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet, the fence is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height, and the fence meets specified electrotechnical and local requirements.
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications. Existing law also provides that the owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it.
This bill would amend the list of institutes and associations that may set the standards according to which the lawfulness of an electrified fence is measured and exclude from the definition of electrified fence used in that provision an electrified security fence, as defined. The bill would authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs, the height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet, the fence is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height, and the fence meets specified electrotechnical and local requirements.
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications. Existing law also provides that the owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it.
This bill would authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone zone, the fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs, and the fence meets specified electrotechnical and local requirements.
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications. Existing law also provides that the owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it.
This bill would express the Legislatures intent to enact legislation that would require electrified fences installed in the state to be approved for installation to confirm the installed apparatus meets a specified standard. authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone and the fence meets specified electrotechnical and local requirements.
Existing law prohibits an electrified fence to be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in the state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceeds specified standards or specifications.
This bill would express the Legislatures intent to enact legislation that would require electrified fences installed in the state to be approved for installation to confirm the installed apparatus meets a specified standard.
(a)As used in this chapter, electrified security fence means any fence, other than an electrified fence described in Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code, that meets the following requirements:
(1)The fence is powered by an electrical energizer with both of the following output characteristics:
(A)The impulse repetition rate does not exceed 1 hertz (hz).
(B)The impulse duration does not exceed 10 milliseconds, or 10/10000 of a second.
(2)The fence is used to protect and secure commercial or industrial property.
(b)An owner of real property may install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property subject to all of the following:
(1)The property is not located in a residential zone.
(2)The fence meets the 2006 international standards and specifications of the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in International Standard IEC 60335, Part 2-76.
(3)The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, the warning signs shall meet all of the following criteria:
(A)The warning signs are placed at each gate and access point, and at intervals along the fence not exceeding 30 feet.
(B)The warning signs are adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
(C)The warning signs are marked with a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol for shock, a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol to warn people with pacemakers, and a written warning or commonly recognized symbol about the danger of touching the fence in wet conditions.
(4)The height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet and is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height.
(c)An owner of real property shall not install and operate an electrified security fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, the installation and operation of the fence shall meet the requirements of that ordinance and the requirements of subdivision (b).
SEC. 2.Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17151.(a)As used in this chapter, electrified fence means any fence and appurtenant devices, including, but not limited to, fences and devices used in animal control, and including, but not limited to, a fence consisting of a single strand of wire supported by posts or other fixtures, which has an electrical charge or is connected to a source of electrical current and which is so designed or placed that a person or animal coming into contact with the conductive element of the fence receives an electrical shock.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, electrified fence does not include an electrified security fence as described in Section 835 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 3.Section 17152 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17152.No electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, international standards of the International Electrotechnical Commission, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers.
(a)As used in this chapter, electrified security fence means any fence, other than an electrified fence described in Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code, that meets the following requirements:
(1)The fence is powered by an electrical energizer with both of the following output characteristics:
(A)The impulse repetition rate does not exceed 1 hertz (hz).
(B)The impulse duration does not exceed 10 milliseconds, or 10/10000 of a second.
(2)The fence is used to protect and secure commercial or industrial property.
(b)An owner of real property may install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property subject to all of the following:
(1)The property is not located in a residential zone.
(2)The fence meets the 2006 international standards and specifications of the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in International Standard IEC 60335, Part 2-76.
(3)The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, the warning signs shall meet all of the following criteria:
(A)The warning signs are placed at each gate and access point, and at intervals along the fence not exceeding 30 feet.
(B)The warning signs are adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
(C)The warning signs are marked with a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol for shock, a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol to warn people with pacemakers, and a written warning or commonly recognized symbol about the danger of touching the fence in wet conditions.
(4)The height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet and is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height.
(c)An owner of real property shall not install and operate an electrified security fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, the installation and operation of the fence shall meet the requirements of that ordinance and the requirements of subdivision (b).
SEC. 2.Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17151.(a)As used in this chapter, electrified fence means any fence and appurtenant devices, including, but not limited to, fences and devices used in animal control, and including, but not limited to, a fence consisting of a single strand of wire supported by posts or other fixtures, which has an electrical charge or is connected to a source of electrical current and which is so designed or placed that a person or animal coming into contact with the conductive element of the fence receives an electrical shock.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, electrified fence does not include an electrified security fence as described in Section 835 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 3.Section 17152 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17152.No electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, international standards of the International Electrotechnical Commission, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers.
(a)Subject to subdivision (b), an
(a)As used in this chapter, electrified security fence means any fence, other than an electrified fence described in Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code, that meets the following requirements:
(1)The fence is powered by an electrical energizer with both of the following output characteristics:
(A)The impulse repetition rate does not exceed 1 hertz (hz).
(B)The impulse duration does not exceed 10 milliseconds, or 10/10000 of a second.
(2)The fence is used to protect and secure commercial or industrial property.
(b)An owner of real property may install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property consistent with subject to all of the following:
(1)The property is not located in a residential zone.
(2)The fence meets the requirements specified by 2006 international standards and specifications of the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in International Standard IEC 60335-2-76. 60335, Part 2-76.
(3)The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, the warning signs shall meet all of the following criteria: be
(A)The warning signs are placed at each gate and access point, and at intervals along the fence not exceeding 10 meters, and adjacent 30 feet. to
(B)The warning signs are adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
(C)The warning signs are marked with a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol for shock, a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol to warn people with pacemakers, and a written warning or commonly recognized symbol about the danger of touching the fence in wet conditions.
(4)The height of the fence does not exceed 10 feet and is located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than 6 feet in height.
(b)
(c)An owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric electrified security fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric electrified security fence, the installation and operation of the fence shall meet the requirements of that ordinance and the requirements of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a). subdivision (b).
SEC. 2.Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17151.(a)As used in this chapter, electrified fence means any fence and appurtenant devices, including, but not limited to, fences and devices used in animal control, and including, but not limited to, a fence consisting of a single strand of wire supported by posts or other fixtures, which has an electrical charge or is connected to a source of electrical current and which is so designed or placed that a person or animal coming into contact with the conductive element of the fence receives an electrical shock.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, electrified fence does not include an electrified security fence as described in Section 835 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 3.Section 17152 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:17152.No electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, international standards of the International Electrotechnical Commission, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers.
(a)Subject to subdivision (b), an owner of real property may install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property consistent with all of the following:
(1)The property is not located in a residential zone.
(2)The fence meets the requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in International Standard IEC 60335-2-76.
(3)The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, warning signs shall be placed at each gate and access point, at intervals along the fence not exceeding 10 meters, and adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
(b)An owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric fence, the installation and operation of the fence shall meet the requirements of that ordinance and the requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
(a)Subject to subdivision (b), an owner of real property may install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property consistent with all of the following:
(1)The property is not located in a residential zone.
(2)The fence meets the requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in International Standard 60335-2-76.
(b)An owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric fence, the installation and operation of the fence shall meet the requirements of that ordinance and the requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a).
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would require electrified fences installed in the state to be approved for installations to confirm the installed apparatus meets the IEC 60335-2-76 Standard until an American Standard is established.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would require electrified fences installed in the state to be approved for installations to confirm the installed apparatus meets the IEC 60335-2-76 Standard until an American Standard is established.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 4, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 273, Statutes of 2015. |
| Sep 4, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 28, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:45 p.m. |
| Aug 27, 2015 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2206.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 27, 2015 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 25, 2015 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Aug 20, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 2533.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 20, 2015 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 20, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 18, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 16, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (July 14). |
| Jun 29, 2015 | June 30 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 11, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 22, 2015 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 1074.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2015 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 19, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 983.) (May 12). |
| May 1, 2015 | Set for hearing May 12. |
| Apr 16, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 7, 2015 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 12, 2015 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 29. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27, 2015 | Special Consent #7 SB582 Hall | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2015 | SB 582 Hall Senate Third Reading By GARCIA, C. | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 14, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2015 | Special Consent #2 SB582 Hall | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2015 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 582
Page 5
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 582
Amended: 8/17/15
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/12/15
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/22/15
AYES: Allen, Anderson, Bates, Beall, Berryhill, Block, Cannella, De León, Gaines, Galgiani, Hall, Hancock, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Huff, Jackson, Lara, Leno, Leyva, Liu, McGuire, Mendoza, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nguyen, Nielsen, Pan, Pavley, Roth, Runner, Stone, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wolk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Fuller
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 8/20/15 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Electric Guard Dog, Inc.
DIGEST: This bill authorizes an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence meets specified requirements, and a local ordinance does not prohibit its installation and operation.
Assembly Amendments specify additional requirements for authorized electrified fences, including minimum standards for warning signs, fence placement, and operating characteristics.
Existing law:
Provides that no electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.)
Provides that existing provisions of the Food and Agricultural Code pertaining to electric fences shall not be construed to preclude regulation of electrified fences by cities and counties, including, but not limited to, requiring the installation or use of electrified fences under permit, except that such regulation shall not permit the installation or use of electrified fences which do not conform to the requirements of existing law. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17153.)
This bill:
States that an owner of real property may install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property, provided the property is not located in a residential zone, and provided the fence meets the 2006 international standards and specifications of the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in “International Standard IEC 60335, Part 2-76.”
Specifies that the height of an electrified security fence may not exceed 10 feet, and that the fence must be located behind a perimeter fence that is not less than six feet in height.
Requires an electrified security fence to be identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence, and specifies, at a minimum, that the warning signs shall meet all of the following criteria:
The warning signs are placed at each gate and access point, and at intervals along the fence not exceeding 30 feet;
The warning signs are adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards; and
The warning signs are marked with a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol for shock, a written warning or a commonly recognized symbol to warn people with pacemakers, and a written warning or commonly recognized symbol about the danger of touching the fence in wet conditions.
Defines “electrified security fence” to mean any fence, except as specified, that meets the following requirements:
The fence is powered by an electrical energizer where the impulse repetition rate does not exceed one hertz and the impulse duration does not exceed 10 milliseconds; and
The fence is used to protect and secure commercial or industrial property.
Provides that an owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric fence, the installation and operation of the electric fence shall meet the requirements of the ordinance, as well as the requirements listed above.
Makes other technical and conforming changes to existing law.
Background
Generally speaking, an electric fence is a fence that has an electrical charge that is designed or placed so that a person or animal coming into contact with the fence receives an electric shock. It operates by sending a high voltage pulse of electricity at regular intervals through conductive materials in the fence. Unlike other physical boundaries like barbed wire or razor wire, commercial electric fences do not physically harm things that come into contact with them. Electric fences do not cause physical harm to animals or people because the length of electric shock delivered by the fence is very brief. According to one scholar:
“[e]ven when the voltage is high, when the current flows for only a very short duration we cannot be electrocuted. . . . A large enough current can cause ventricular fibrillation,” during which “the pumping action of the heart ceases and death occurs within minutes unless treated. In the United States, approximately 1000 deaths per year occur in accidents that involve cord-connected appliances in kitchens, bathrooms, and other wet locations . . . shock durations longer than 1 second are the most dangerous . . . [e]lectric security fences have taken advantage of this fact by shortening their shock duration to an even shorter duration of about 0.0003 seconds . . . electric fences are safe and do not lead to ventricular fibrillation due to the short 0.0003 second shock duration. (John Webster, Safety of Electric Security Fences, University of Wisconsin - Madison, <http://intelligentfencing.com/schematics/Safety/ Safety%20of%20electric%20security%20fences.pdf [as of May 8, 2015].)
The sale of electric fences is currently prohibited in California unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed specified standards. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.) This bill further codifies that a property owner may install and operate an electrified fence if: (1) the property is not in a residential zone; (2) the fence meets requirements specified in designated international standards, and (3) the fence is marked at regular intervals with warning signs. This bill specifies that an owner would not be permitted to install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits its installation and operation, and would require the electric fence to be secured behind a perimeter fence.
Comments
According to the author:
Many California-based companies that are in the cargo transportation, inventory storage and containment shipping business have, at any given time, millions of dollars worth of products and service-related equipment on their premises. Storage is often held overnight for several days or weeks awaiting transport. The primary protection of valuable goods and equipment is a security fence, designed to prevent criminal trespass and theft. The installation of an electric security fence in a jurisdiction is subject to permitting and approval. Current state law on the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-agricultural zones is vague. There is no consensus among local jurisdictions whether or not they can allow the installation of electric security fences.
SB 582 provides clear guidelines for the installation of electric security fences, based on international standards ensuring their safe and reliable installation in non-residential zones. Existing international standards require the installation of a perimeter fence at least six feet tall separating the public from the electrified fence. Additionally, to ensure the safety of the public, warning signs must be visibly posted in at least two languages (English and Spanish) and access for emergency responders must be available. This bill helps the permitting process in local ordinances by clarifying state law, and regulating the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-residential zones.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Electric Guard Dog, Inc. (source)
ABF Freight System, Inc
Copart, Inc
Old Dominion Freight
SA Recycling, LLC
SAIA Freight, LTL
Westward Liberty
YRC Freight Worldwide
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/21/15)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 8/20/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chu
Prepared by: Tobias Halvarson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/21/15 13:20:15
**** END ****
SB 582
Page 2
SENATE THIRD READING
SB 582
(Hall)
As Amended August 17, 2015
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Judiciary |
10-0 |
Mark Stone, Weber, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Maienschein, Thurmond |
|
SUMMARY: Allows a property owner to install an electrified security fence on his or her real property that is located in a non-residential zone as long as the fence meets certain specified requirements. Specifically, this bill:
Defines an electrified security fence as any fence, other than an electrified fence described in the Food and Agricultural Code Section 17151, that is used to protect and secure commercial property, and is powered by an electrical energizer with the following output characteristics: a) the impulse repetition rate shall not exceed 1 hertz; and b) the impulse duration shall not exceed 10 milliseconds, or 10/10000/seconds.
Requires an electrified security fence to be identified by prominently displayed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence and, at a minimum, placed at each gate and access point, at intervals along the fence not exceeding 30 feet, and adjacent to any other signs on the fence relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
Requires, in the event that a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, an owner of real property with an electrified security fence to comply with the installation and operation requirements of that local ordinance, as well as the requirements set forth above.
EXISTING LAW:
States that the Legislature finds and declares that improperly designed and installed electrified fences have caused injuries and in some instances have resulted in the deaths of persons, particularly children, coming into contact with the conductive elements thereof and that in order to prevent further such accidents, it is the intent of the Legislature to provide for the study and development and enforcement of safety standards for electrified fences.
Provides that "electrified fence" means any fence and appurtenant devices, including, but not limited to, fences and devices used in animal control, and including, but not limited to, a fence consisting of a single strand of wire supported by posts or other fixtures, which has an electrical charge or is connected to a source of electrical current and which is so designed or placed that a person or animal coming into contact with the conductive element of the fence receives an electrical shock.
Prohibits the sale or installation of electrified fences in California, unless the electric current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers.
Provides that cities and counties may regulate the installation and use of electrified fences, as long as local ordinances are consistent with state law.
Provides that local jurisdictions have the authority to make and enforce ordinances that protect the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare within its boundaries.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Electrified security fences are designed to protect commercial and industrial property. These fences are generally constructed of metal with attached wires that run along the width of the fence, carrying pulses of electric current to deter potential trespassers. Most electrified security fences are rigged with an alarm system to signal the property owner or the security company when the fence is touched. These fences are designed to provide a physical and psychological deterrent to potential intruders.
Existing law prohibits the sale or installation of electrified fences in California, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed the standards or specifications for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or Underwriters Laboratories. Existing law regarding electrified fences is in the Food and Agricultural Code and was clearly written to address electrified fences that are designed to contain livestock, which use a much higher voltage than what is allowed for and used by electrified security fences. Furthermore, the Food and Agricultural Code provisions, last amended in 1979, are so outdated that two of the four standards in the relevant code section are no longer in effect, and the remaining standards are inapplicable to electrified security fences.
Some municipalities have their own zoning and permitting ordinances that specifically allow electrified security fences, despite the fact that such ordinances may conflict with the provisions of the Food and Agricultural Code, but many others do not. As a result, municipalities across the state are unsure what state laws, if any, apply to electrified security fences.
This bill establishes standards for the installation and operation of electrified security fences, which outline the zoning, voltage, signage warnings, physical barrier clearance, and access requirements that are appropriate for electrified security fences. This bill does not impede local jurisdictions’ authority to allow, prohibit or restrict the installation and operation of electrified security fences within their boundaries. However, this bill does require that if a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, the installation and operation must meet the ordinance requirements, as well as the requirements contained in this bill. Also, if a jurisdiction does not have an ordinance in place to prohibit or limit the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, this bill would allow for the installation and operation of such a fence.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001289
SB 582
Page 7
Date of Hearing: July 14, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SB 582
(Hall) – As Amended May 19, 2015
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: ELECTRIFIED SECURITY FENCES
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE STATE ALLOW PROPERTY OWNERS TO INSTALL AND OPERATE ELECTRIFIED SECURITY FENCES ON REAL PROPERTY IN NON-RESIDENTIAL ZONES AS LONG AS THE FENCES MEET SPECIFIED ELECTRICAL STANDARDS, HEIGHT LIMITS, AND WARNING REQUIREMENTS AND ARE NOT PROHIBITED BY LOCAL ORDINANCE?
SYNOPSIS
This bill, as proposed to be amended, seeks to allow the installation and operation of electrified security fences in all non-residential zones of the state, as long as the fences meet specified electrical standards, height requirements, and are posted with adequate warning signs and are not prohibited by local ordinance. Existing law provides that the sale or installation of electrified fences is prohibited in California, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed the standards or specifications for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or Underwriters Laboratories. There is currently no state law regarding the specific installation and operation of electrified security fences. Existing law regarding electrified fences is in the Food and Agricultural Code and was clearly written to address electrified fences that are designed to contain livestock, which use a much higher voltage than what is allowed for and used by electrified security fences. Furthermore, the Food and Agricultural Code provisions, last amended in 1979, are so outdated that two of the four standards in the relevant code section are no longer in effect, and the remaining standards are inapplicable to electrified security fences.
Some municipalities have their own zoning and permitting ordinances that specifically allow electrified security fences, despite the fact that such ordinances may conflict with the provisions of the Food and Agricultural Code, but many others do not. As a result, municipalities across the state are unsure what state laws, if any, apply to electrified security fences. This bill establishes standards for the installation and operation of electrified security fences, which outline the zoning, voltage, signage warnings, physical barrier clearance, and access requirements that are appropriate for electrified security fences. This bill does not impede local jurisdictions’ authority to allow, prohibit or restrict the installation and operation of electrified security fences within their boundaries. However, the bill does require that if a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, the installation and operation must meet the ordinance requirements, as well as the requirements contained in this bill. Also, if a jurisdiction does not have an ordinance in place to prohibit or limit the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, this bill would allow for the installation and operation of such a fence. This bill, which passed the Senate by a vote of 38-0, is sponsored by a supplier of electrified security fences, supported by several large-equipment businesses and freight companies, and has no opposition.
SUMMARY: Allows a property owner to install an electrified security fence on his or her real property that is located in a non-residential zone as long as the fence meets certain specified requirements. Specifically, this bill:
Defines an electrified security fence as any fence, other than an electrified fence described in Section 17151 of the Food and Agricultural Code, that is used to protect and secure commercial property, and is powered by an electrical energizer with the following output characteristics: (a) the impulse repetition rate shall not exceed 1 hertz (hz); and (b) the impulse duration shall not exceed 0.0003 or 0.8 times per second.
Allows an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified security fence on his or her property as long as the real property is located in a non-residential zone and the electrified security fence meets specified requirements.
Prohibits an owner of real property from installing and operating an electrified security fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation.
Requires an electrified security fence to be identified by prominently displayed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence, and at a minimum placed at each gate and access point, and at intervals along the fence not exceeding 30 feet, and adjacent to any other signs on the fence relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
Requires, in the event that a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electrified security fence, an owner of real property with an electrified security fence to comply with the installation and operation requirements of that local ordinance, as well as the requirements set forth above in #1-4.
EXISTING LAW:
States that the Legislature finds and declares that improperly designed and installed electrified fences have caused injuries and in some instances have resulted in the deaths of persons, particularly children, coming into contact with the conductive elements thereof. In order to prevent further such accidents, it is the intent of the Legislature to provide for the study and development and enforcement of safety standards for electrified fences. (Food & Agricultural Code 17150. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to that code.)
Provides that, “electrified fence” means any fence and appurtenant devices, including, but not limited to, fences and devices used in animal control, and including, but not limited to, a fence consisting of a single strand of wire supported by posts or other fixtures, which has an electrical charge or is connected to a source of electrical current and which is so designed or placed that a person or animal coming into contact with the conductive element of the fence receives an electrical shock. (Section 17151.)
Provides that the sale or installation of electrified fences is prohibited in California, unless the electric current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers. (Section 17152.)
Provides that state law pertaining to electrified fences shall not be construed to preclude regulation of electrified fences by cities and counties, including, but not limited to, requiring the installation or use of electrified fences under permit, except that such regulation shall not permit the installation or use of electrified fences which do not conform to existing state law. (Section 17153.)
Provides that local jurisdictions have the authority to make and enforce ordinances that protect the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare within its boundaries. (Cal. Const., art. XI, Section 11.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Electrified security fences are designed to serve as a non-lethal security measure for the perimeter of real property. These fences are generally constructed of metal with attached wires that run along the width of the fence, carrying pulses of electric current that provide an unpleasant, yet non-lethal shock to deter potential trespassers. Most electrified security fences are rigged with an alarm system that is setup to signal the property owner or the security company when the fence is being tampered with. These fences are designed to provide a physical and psychological deterrent to potential intruders, and generally have visible warning signs that provide alerts of existing hazards about which the security fence owner or property owner are required to warn others. Currently, most electrified security fences in the U.S. are used in industrial and commercial zones to protect property located within the perimeter of the fence, such as in an equipment yard or commercial storage facility.
According to the author:
Current state law on the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-agricultural zones is vague. There is no consensus among local jurisdictions whether or not they can allow the installation of electric security fences. The problem stems from the fact that there is no American standard or guidelines for the installation of electrified fences specifically directed to municipalities. Municipalities across the state sometimes default to the current law regarding electrified fences in the Agricultural Code and claim that it is not clear that electrified fences can be installed outside of Agricultural zones. SB 582 will resolve this issue by providing clear guidelines for the installation of electric security fences, based on international standards insuring [their] safe and reliable installation in non-residential zones.
Zoning Authority Belongs to Local Governments. The California Constitution grants a local jurisdiction the power to make and enforce ordinances that affect all local, police, sanitary and other regulations within its boundaries. (Cal. Const., art. XI, Section 11.) According to a 1925 California Supreme Court case, “[A]ny zoning regulation is a valid exercise of the police power which is necessary to subserve the ends for which the police power exists, namely, the promotion of the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare.” (Miller v. Board of Public Works (1925) 195 Cal. 477, 481.)
Municipalities use their zoning power to draft ordinances to signify what is and is not permissible within their boundaries. In regards to this bill, if a municipality has an ordinance that prohibits the installation and operation of electrified security fences, the provisions of this bill will not affect that ordinance. The purpose of this bill is to provide standards for installation and operation of electrified security fences in non-residential areas where the municipality lacks an ordinance but desires to allow these types of fences, and to make sure that existing ordinances are compatible with state law. If a jurisdiction does not have an ordinance excluding electrified security fences, this bill would allow for the installation and operation of such fences until that jurisdiction establishes an ordinance to exclude them.
History of Legislative Intervention in Local Control of Electrified Fencing Standards. The California Constitution delegates power to the Legislature to make laws. When there is a threat to the health and safety of persons, the Legislature can and has stepped in to establish safety standards and procedures on a statewide basis. It is in the state’s interest to ensure the proper installation and operation of electric security fences by creating standards that are consistent in every non-residential zone in California. The entire basis, for which legislation was initially sought for electrified fences back in 1976, was to ensure that these fences were installed properly in order to protect the public from the harms and injuries that had occurred. In order to ensure the continual protection of the public, it seems prudent to ensure that when an electrified security fence is installed, it meets the requirements of any applicable local ordinance as well as the requirements of state law. Local ordinances may differ based on the environment and needs of a particular community. State law will have a minimum standard that is required for the installation and operation of such fences statewide, but only in jurisdictions that allow such installation and operation.
In 1979, in an effort to protect the public, especially children, from the danger of coming into contact with improperly designed and installed electrified fences, which had resulted in injuries and even deaths; the Legislature usurped local control and provided statewide safety standards for electrified fences. That legislation (SB 1726 (Nejedly), Ch. 873, Stats. of 1976) required a study of electrified fences and the development of a number of requirements for the standards to be used when selling, installing, using and connecting an electrified fence. Those standards developed by subsequent legislation (AB 645 (Chappie), Ch. 89, Stats. of 1979), are the same four standards that currently exists Section 17152.
However, since the time when the Legislature passed (and the governor signed) SB 1726 and AB 645, two of the four standards mentioned in the statutes (the New Zealand Standards Institute and the Standards Association of Australia) have been combined into a single standard and updated to conform with the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) standard 60335-2-76, which is the exact standard required by the provisions of this bill. The two other standards outlined in the Food and Agricultural Code, the National Electric Code and Underwriters Laboratories (UL), are limited to the regulation of higher voltage fencing (50 volts or more) and livestock containment (UL 69 is specific to electric fence-controllers for livestock containment only) respectively, and are not applicable to electrified security fences under this bill’s provisions.
The International Electrotechnical Commission Standard for Electric Fence Energizers. According to their website (http://www.iec.ch/), the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) is a not-for-profit, non-governmental organization founded in 1906. The IEC’s members are national committees that appoint experts and delegates from industry, government bodies, associations, and academia to participate in the technical and conformity assessment work of the organization. The work of the Commission is carried out through technical committees and subcommittees, composed of representatives of the national committees, and each committee deals with a particular subject. These committees develop international standards for a specific area of electrotechnology and then publish those standards. The IEC standard relevant to electrified fencing is entitled, IEC 60335 “Household and similar electrical appliances-safety,” part 2-76, and provides particular requirements for electric fence energizers.
Zareba Systems’ website, which claims to be “the largest electric fence systems manufacturer in North America,” defines an electric fence energizer as follows:
An electric fence energizer provides the source for the electric current that flows through the electric fence wire. They vary by the amount of current they output and their power source. The size of the required fence energizer is based upon three main factors: the length of the fence, number of wires, and the power source. (http://www.zarebasystems.com)
The IEC standard that is appropriate for an electrified security fence, is not an appropriate standard for other types of electrical fencing, such as that used for prisons or nuclear power plants, because those fences utilize a stronger power source to generate larger currents of electricity which are designed to keep detainees inside or intruders outside of the installed fence. Part 2-76 of the IEC is limited to an energizer with an impulse repetition rate that does not exceed 1 Hz or one pulse per second.
Non-Lethal Nature of Electrified Security Fences. Unlike other physical boundaries like barbed wire or razor wire, electrified security fences generally do not physically harm things that come into contact with them and do not cause physical harm to animals or people. The duration of the electric shock delivered by the fence is very brief, even if the existing conditions are wet. According to one scholar:
[E]ven when the voltage is high, when the current flows for only a very short duration we cannot be electrocuted. . . . A large enough current can cause ventricular fibrillation,” during which “the pumping action of the heart ceases and death occurs within minutes unless treated. In the United States, approximately 1000 deaths per year occur in accidents that involve cord-connected appliances in kitchens, bathrooms, and other wet locations . . . shock durations longer than 1 second are the most dangerous . . . [e]lectric security fences have taken advantage of this fact by shortening their shock duration to an even shorter duration of about 0.0003 seconds . . . electric fences are safe and do not lead to ventricular fibrillation due to the short 0.0003 second shock duration. However, this author did say, “When our skin is wet, our skin resistance is low and permits large electric current to flow through the body”, but only when wet skin is exposed for 1 to 3 seconds and the electrical current is 60 Hz or more. … (John Webster, Safety of Electric Security Fences, University of Wisconsin - Madison, http://intelligentfencing.com)
The energizer power required by the provisions of this bill, as contained in Part 2-76 of IEC Standard may not exceed 1 Hz per second.
Delegation of Legislative Authority. It is a general premise that the Legislature is prohibited from delegating its general legislative authority to another entity or body, but it may authorize that things specified by the Legislature be done by others, especially things that affect local or individual interest. (5 Cal. Jur. Constitution Law, Section 94.) The Legislature has the authority to specify the task to be accomplished, but may leave the actual task of setting standards, drafting regulations, and other tasks to those who are more knowledgeable or capable of accomplishing the task. It is very common for the Legislature to authorize a study, or to require the implementation of certain standards, and then to delegate the authority for providing the study or creating standards to a body, commission, state department or other body with the required expertise. The provisions of this bill propose to have a standard adopted by the IEC be the standard for electrification of security fences. Based upon the fact that the IEC is an international commission, comprised of industry professionals, state government officials, and scholars in the field of electrotechnology, delegating to the Commission’s standards for electric fence energizers seems an appropriate delegation of legislative authority. Also, this bill is not a permanent delegation of authority to the IEC (i.e. whenever the IEC standard is updated it would become the new law of the state) because the standard is specified as the IEC adopted in 2006 and therefore frozen in time.
Author’s Amendments. As currently in print, the bill provides that its provisions apply to electrified fences, but makes no effort to distinguish them from the electrified fences which are described in the Food and Agricultural Code. To avoid confusion regarding various types of electrified fencing that may be obtained in the market place, the author proposes amendments to clarify that this bill’s provisions are intended to apply to electrified security fences and provides a definition of such fences. This will help to distinguish electrified security fences which are designed for commercial security purposes to protect items such as large equipment and inventory, from the electrified fences that are defined in the Food and Agricultural Code and are designed for animal containment and rural environments. Also, because electrified security fences have been determined to be non-lethal under normal, dry conditions, but, according to a study published by professors at the University at Wisconsin and mentioned earlier in this analysis, unsafe when exposed to an electrical current under wet conditions, the author proposes an amendment to address this concern by requiring the inclusion of a warning sign or symbol to this effect on electrified security fences installed in the state. Further, based on the advice and warnings of the American Heart Association for persons with pace makers and the possible interference of the device’s function by close proximity to an electric fence, the author proposes an amendment to warn of this possibility by requiring the inclusion of a warning sign or symbol to this effect on electrified security fences installed in the state.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the sponsor, Electric Guard Dog:
Many California-based companies that are in the cargo transportation, inventory storage and containment shipping business have, at any given time, millions of dollars’ worth of products and service-related equipment on their premises. Storage is often held overnight for several days or weeks awaiting transport.
The primary protection of valuable goods and equipment is a security fence, designed to prevent criminal trespass and theft. The installation of an electric security fence by the local jurisdiction is subject to permitting and approval.
This bill helps the permitting process in local ordinances by clarifying state law, and regulating the use and installation of an electric [security] fence in non-residential zones.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Electric Guard Dog, Inc. (sponsor)
ABF Freight System, Inc.
Copart, Inc.
Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc.
SA Recycling, LLC
SAIA LTL Freight
Westward Liberty
YRC Worldwide, Inc.
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Khadijah Hargett / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SB 582
Page 4
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 582
Amended: 5/19/15
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/12/15
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SOURCE: Electric Guard Dog, Inc.
DIGEST: This bill authorizes an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence meets specified requirements, and a local ordinance does not prohibit its installation and operation.
Existing law:
Provides that no electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.)
Provides that existing provisions of the Food and Agricultural Code pertaining to electric fences shall not be construed to preclude regulation of electrified fences by cities and counties, including, but not limited to, requiring the installation or use of electrified fences under permit, except that such regulation shall not permit the installation or use of electrified fences which do not conform to the requirements of existing law. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17153.)
This bill:
Provides that an owner of real property may install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property consistent with all of the following:
The property is not located in a residential zone;
The fence meets the requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in “International Standard IEC 60335-2-76;” and
The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, warning signs shall be placed at each gate and access point, at intervals along the fence not exceeding 10 meters, and adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.
Provides that an owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric fence, the installation and operation of the electric fence shall meet the requirements of the ordinance, as well as the requirements listed above.
Background
Generally speaking, an electric fence is a fence that has an electrical charge that is designed or placed so that a person or animal coming into contact with the fence receives an electric shock. It operates by sending a high voltage pulse of electricity at regular intervals through conductive materials in the fence. Unlike other physical boundaries like barbed wire or razor wire, commercial electric fences do not physically harm things that come into contact with them. Electric fences do not cause physical harm to animals or people because the length of electric shock delivered by the fence is very brief. According to one scholar:
“[e]ven when the voltage is high, when the current flows for only a very short duration we cannot be electrocuted. . . . A large enough current can cause ventricular fibrillation,” during which “the pumping action of the heart ceases and death occurs within minutes unless treated. In the United States, approximately 1000 deaths per year occur in accidents that involve cord-connected appliances in kitchens, bathrooms, and other wet locations . . . shock durations longer than 1 second are the most dangerous . . . [e]lectric security fences have taken advantage of this fact by shortening their shock duration to an even shorter duration of about 0.0003 seconds . . . electric fences are safe and do not lead to ventricular fibrillation due to the short 0.0003 second shock duration. (John Webster, Safety of Electric Security Fences, University of Wisconsin - Madison, <http://intelligentfencing.com/schematics/Safety/ Safety%20of%20electric%20security%20fences.pdf> [as of May 8, 2015].)
The sale of electric fences is currently prohibited in California unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed specified standards. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.) This bill further codifies that a property owner may install and operate an electrified fence if: (1) the property is not in a residential zone; (2) the fence meets requirements specified in designated international standards, and (3) the fence is marked at regular intervals with warning signs. This bill specifies that an owner would not be permitted to install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits its installation and operation.
Comments
According to the author:
Many California-based companies that are in the cargo transportation, inventory storage and containment shipping business have, at any given time, millions of dollars worth of products and service-related equipment on their premises. Storage is often held overnight for several days or weeks awaiting transport. The primary protection of valuable goods and equipment is a security fence, designed to prevent criminal trespass and theft. The installation of an electric security fence in a jurisdiction is subject to permitting and approval. Current state law on the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-agricultural zones is vague. There is no consensus among local jurisdictions whether or not they can allow the installation of electric security fences.
SB 582 provides clear guidelines for the installation of electric security fences, based on international standards ensuring their safe and reliable installation in non-residential zones. Existing international standards require the installation of a perimeter fence at least six feet tall separating the public from the electrified fence. Additionally, to ensure the safety of the public, warning signs must be visibly posted in at least two languages (English and Spanish) and access for emergency responders must be available. This bill helps the permitting process in local ordinances by clarifying state law, and regulating the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-residential zones.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Electric Guard Dog, Inc. (source)
ABF Freight System, Inc.
Copart, Inc.
Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc.
SA Recycling LLC
Saia LTL Freight
YRC Worldwide, Inc.
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/12/15)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Copart, Inc. states that SB 582 clarifies the standards and installation protocols for electric security fences in California, and provides guidance and clarity that allows municipalities to permit the installation of electric security fences within their jurisdictions.
Prepared by: Tobias Halvarson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/19/15 13:09:54
**** END ****
SB 582 (Hall)
Page 4 of 4
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
SB 582 (Hall)
Version: April 7, 2015
Hearing Date: May 12, 2015
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
TH:jt
SUBJECT
Electrified Fences
DESCRIPTION
This bill would authorize an owner of real property to install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property if the property is not in a residential zone, the fence meets specified requirements, and a local ordinance does not prohibit its installation and operation.
BACKGROUND
Generally speaking, an electric fence is a fence that has an electrical charge that is designed or placed so that a person or animal coming into contact with the fence receives an electric shock. It operates by sending a high voltage pulse of electricity at regular intervals through conductive materials in the fence. Unlike other physical boundaries like barbed wire or razor wire, commercial electric fences do not physically harm things that come into contact with them. Electric fences do not cause physical harm to animals or people because the length of electric shock delivered by the fence is very brief. According to one scholar:
“[e]ven when the voltage is high, when the current flows for only a very short duration we cannot be electrocuted. . . . A large enough current can cause ventricular fibrillation,” during which “the pumping action of the heart ceases and death occurs within minutes unless treated. In the United States, approximately 1000 deaths per year occur in accidents that involve cord-connected appliances in kitchens, bathrooms, and other wet locations . . . shock durations longer than 1 second are the most dangerous . . . [e]lectric security fences have taken advantage of this fact by shortening their shock duration to an even shorter duration of about 0.0003 seconds . . . electric fences are safe and do not lead to ventricular fibrillation due to the short 0.0003 second shock duration. (John Webster, Safety of Electric Security Fences, University of Wisconsin - Madison, <http://intelligentfencing.com/ schematics/Safety/Safety%20of%20electric%20security%20fences.pdf> [as of May 8, 2015].)
The sale of electric fences is currently prohibited in California unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller that meets or exceed specified standards. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.)
This bill would further codify that a property owner may install and operate an electrified fence if: (1) the property is not in a residential zone; and (2) the fence meets requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers. This bill would specify that an owner would not be allowed to install and operate a fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that no electrified fences shall be offered for sale, sold, installed, or used in this state, or otherwise connected to a source of electrical current, unless the electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.)
Existing law provides that existing provisions of the Food and Agricultural Code pertaining to electric fences shall not be construed to preclude regulation of electrified fences by cities and counties, including, but not limited to, requiring the installation or use of electrified fences under permit, except that such regulation shall not permit the installation or use of electrified fences which do not conform to the requirements of this chapter. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17153.)
This bill would provide that an owner of real property may install and operate an electrified fence on his or her property consistent with all of the following: (1) the property is not located in a residential zone; and (2) the fence meets the requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in “International Standard 60335-2-76.”
This bill would further provide that an owner of real property shall not install and operate an electric fence where a local ordinance prohibits that installation and operation. If a local ordinance allows the installation and operation of an electric fence, the installation and operation of the electric fence shall meet the requirements of the ordinance, as well as the requirements listed above.
COMMENT
Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Many California-based companies that are in the cargo transportation, inventory storage and containment shipping business have, at any given time, millions of dollars worth of products and service-related equipment on their premises. Storage is often held overnight for several days or weeks awaiting transport. The primary protection of valuable goods and equipment is a security fence, designed to prevent criminal trespass and theft. The installation of an electric security fence in a jurisdiction is subject to permitting and approval. Current state law on the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-agricultural zones is vague. There is no consensus among local jurisdictions whether or not they can allow the installation of electric security fences.
SB 582 provides clear guidelines for the installation of electric security fences, based on international standards [e]nsuring [their] safe and reliable installation in non-residential zones. Existing international standards require the installation of a perimeter fence at least six feet tall separating the public from the electrified fence. Additionally, to [e]nsure the safety of the public, warning signs must be visibly posted in at least two languages (English and Spanish) and access for emergency responders must be available. This bill helps the permitting process in local ordinances by clarifying state law, and regulating the use and installation of an electric security fence in non-residential zones.
Ensuring Safety and Local Control
Existing law imposes certain safety standards for the installation and use of electric fences by prohibiting their sale or installation unless the fence’s electrical current is limited and regulated by an electrical controller which meets or exceeds the standards or specifications of the National Electrical Code of the National Fire Protection Association, the New Zealand Standards Institute, the Standards Association of Australia, or the Underwriters Laboratories for intermittent type electric fence or electrified fence controllers. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 17152.) This bill would clarify that electric fences may be installed and used in non-agricultural settings provided they also conform to the requirements specified by the International Electrotechnical Commission for electric fence energizers in “International Standard 60335-2-76.”
As in existing law, this bill preserves the authority of local agencies to regulate the installation or use of electric fences within their jurisdictions, provided such regulations meet the safety requirements established in state law. This bill would specify that local agencies may regulate or prohibit by ordinance the installation and operation of electric fences within their jurisdictions. However, this bill would prohibit outright the use or operation of electric fences in residential zones. Allowing local agencies to maintain control over the installation and use of electric fences empowers those jurisdictions to weigh such issues as whether or not electric fence use should be permitted in mixed use zones adjacent to residential areas, or whether they should be permitted in areas near to where children play or other areas with high pedestrian traffic.
Despite their non-lethality, coming into contact with an electric fence is unpleasant. In order to protect individuals from unintentionally coming into contact with an electric fence, International Standard IEC 60335-2-76 contains provisions specifying the size and placement of warning signs. To ensure that warning signs are appropriately placed on electric fence installations governed by this bill, the author offers the following amendment that would codify part of the IEC’s warning sign standard:
Author’s Amendment:
On page 2, between lines 7 and 8, insert: “(3) The fence is identified by prominently placed warning signs that are legible from both sides of the fence. At a minimum, warning signs shall be placed at each gate and access point, at intervals along the fence not exceeding 10 meters, and adjacent to any other signs relating to chemical, radiological, or biological hazards.”
Support: ABF Freight System, Inc.; Copart, Inc.; Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc.; SA Recycling LLC; SAIA LTL Freight; YRC Worldwide, Inc.
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Electric Guard Dog, Inc.
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: None Known
**************
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):