SB 687: Renewable gas standard.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2015-05-05
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to adopt regulations to require the reporting and verification of statewide greenhouse gas emissions and to monitor and enforce compliance with this program. The act requires the state board to adopt a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit, as defined, to be achieved by 2020, equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990. The state board is required to adopt rules and regulations in an open public process to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective greenhouse gas emission reductions. The act authorizes the state board to adopt market-based compliance mechanisms, as defined, meeting specified requirements. Existing law requires the state board to complete a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants, as defined, in the state.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. Existing law requires the commission to adopt policies and programs that promote the in-state production and distribution of biomethane, as defined, that facilitate the development of a variety of sources of in-state biomethane. Existing law requires the commission to adopt pipeline access rules that ensure that each gas corporation provides nondiscriminatory open access to its gas pipeline system to any party for the purposes of physically interconnecting with the gas pipeline system and effectuating the delivery of gas.
The Warren-Alquist State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Act establishes the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and requires it to prepare an integrated energy policy report on or before November 1, 2003, and every 2 years thereafter. The act requires the report to contain an overview of major energy trends and issues facing the state, including, but not limited to, supply, demand, pricing, reliability, efficiency, and impacts on public health and safety, the economy, resources, and the environment. Existing law requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to hold public hearings to identify impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California, including, but not limited to, impediments to interconnection and to offer solutions to those impediments as part of the integrated energy policy report.
This bill would require the state board, on or before June 30, 2016, 2017, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard, as defined and specified, that requires all gas sellers, as defined, to provide specified percentages of renewable gas meeting certain deliverability requirements, to retail end-use customers for use in California, that increases over specified compliance periods. The bill would authorize the state board to waive enforcement of the renewable gas standard upon certain showings being made by a gas seller. The bill would require the state board, on or before January 1, 2017, to issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses.
The bill would require the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to provide the state board and the Legislature with an assessment of specified matter pertaining to renewable gas by January 1, 2018.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to adopt regulations to require the reporting and verification of statewide greenhouse gas emissions and to monitor and enforce compliance with this program. The act requires the state board to adopt a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit, as defined, to be achieved by 2020, equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990. The state board is required to adopt rules and regulations in an open public process to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective greenhouse gas emission reductions. The act authorizes the state board to adopt market-based compliance mechanisms, as defined, meeting specified requirements. Existing law requires the state board to complete a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants, as defined, in the state.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. Existing law requires the commission to adopt policies and programs that promote the in-state production and distribution of biomethane, as defined, that facilitate the development of a variety of sources of in-state biomethane. Existing law requires the commission to adopt pipeline access rules that ensure that each gas corporation provides nondiscriminatory open access to its gas pipeline system to any party for the purposes of physically interconnecting with the gas pipeline system and effectuating the delivery of gas.
The Warren-Alquist State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Act establishes the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and requires it to prepare an integrated energy policy report on or before November 1, 2003, and every 2 years thereafter. The act requires the report to contain an overview of major energy trends and issues facing the state, including, but not limited to, supply, demand, pricing, reliability, efficiency, and impacts on public health and safety, the economy, resources, and the environment. Existing law requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to hold public hearings to identify impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California, including, but not limited to, impediments to interconnection and to offer solutions to those impediments as part of the integrated energy policy report.
This bill would require the state board, on or before June 30, 2016, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard, as defined and specified, that requires all gas sellers, as defined, to provide specified percentages of renewable gas meeting certain deliverability requirements, to retail end-use customers for use in California, that increases over specified compliance periods. The bill would authorize the state board to waive enforcement of the renewable gas standard upon certain showings being made by a gas seller. The bill would require the state board, on or before January 1, 2017, to issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses.
The bill would require the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to provide the state board and the Legislature with an assessment of specified matter pertaining to renewable gas by January 1, 2018.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to adopt regulations to require the reporting and verification of statewide greenhouse gas emissions and to monitor and enforce compliance with this program. The act requires the state board to adopt a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit, as defined, to be achieved by 2020, equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990. The state board is required to adopt rules and regulations in an open public process to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective greenhouse gas emission reductions. The act authorizes the state board to adopt market-based compliance mechanisms, as defined, meeting specified requirements. Existing law requires the state board to complete a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants, as defined, in the state.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. Existing law requires the commission to adopt policies and programs that promote the in-state production and distribution of biomethane, as defined, that facilitate the development of a variety of sources of in-state biomethane. Existing law requires the commission to adopt pipeline access rules that ensure that each gas corporation provides nondiscriminatory open access to its gas pipeline system to any party for the purposes of physically interconnecting with the gas pipeline system and effectuating the delivery of gas.
The Warren-Alquist State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Act establishes the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and requires it to prepare an integrated energy policy report on or before November 1, 2003, and every 2 years thereafter. The act requires the report to contain an overview of major energy trends and issues facing the state, including, but not limited to, supply, demand, pricing, reliability, efficiency, and impacts on public health and safety, the economy, resources, and the environment. Existing law requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to hold public hearings to identify impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California, including, but not limited to, impediments to interconnection and to offer solutions to those impediments as part of the integrated energy policy report.
This bill would require the state board, on or before June 30, 2016, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard, as defined and specified, that requires all gas sellers, as defined, to provide specified percentages of renewable gas meeting certain deliverability requirements, to retail end-use customers for use in California, that increases over specified compliance periods. The bill would require the state board, on or before January 1, 2017, to issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)California has enacted numerous policies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases and to increase the use of renewable energy resources and renewable fuels, including the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code), the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), the low carbon fuel standard (Executive Order S-01-07 (January 19, 2007); Title 17 California Code of Regulations Sections 95480 to 95490, inclusive), and the states comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (Section 39730 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Use of natural gas causes more than one-quarter of all emissions of greenhouse gases in California. Wildfires cause more than one-half of all black carbon emissions, and organic waste is responsible for three of the states five largest sources of methane emissions.
(c)Capturing and using methane gas from renewable sources (renewable gas) can significantly reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from fossil fuel use, organic waste, wildfires, and petroleum-based fertilizers. Using renewable gas in place of just 10 percent of Californias fossil fuel derived gas supply would reduce emissions of greenhouse gases by tens of millions of metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions per year. Renewable gas generated from organic waste provides the lowest carbon transportation fuels in existence and can provide low carbon, flexible fuel for the generation of electricity.
(d)Increasing use of renewable gas in California will protect disadvantaged communities by reducing air and water pollution from fossil fuel refining and combustion. Renewable gas used in place of diesel in heavy-duty vehicles will protect public health by reducing toxic air contaminants.
(e)Renewable gas provides significant economic benefits to California, including job creation, an in-state source of gas, increased energy security, revenue and energy for public agencies, and revenue for dairies, farms, rural forest communities, and other areas.
(f)It is in the interest of the state to establish a renewable gas standard that will diversify and decarbonize Californias gas supply, to provide lower carbon gas for electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating, and industrial purposes.
(g)A renewable gas standard will reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from the oil and gas sector and from the solid waste, food and agriculture, water and wastewater, and forestry sectors. It will increase in-state gas supplies and provide jobs and increased energy security for California.
(h)A renewable gas standard will help California to meet the waste diversion requirements of Section 41781.3, Article 1 (commencing with Section 41780) of Chapter 6 of Part 2 of, and Chapter 12.9 (commencing with Section 42649.8) of Part 3 of, Division 30 of the Public Resources Code, by using diverted organic waste to produce renewable gas.
SEC. 2.Section 39735 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:39735.(a)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Biogas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other organic materials, through anaerobic digestion, gasification, pyrolysis, or other technology that converts organic waste to gas. Biogas may be produced from, but not limited to, any of the following sources:
(A)Agricultural waste remaining after all reasonably usable food content is extracted.
(B)Forest waste produced from sustainable forest management practices.
(C)Landfill gas.
(D)Wastewater treatment gas and biosolids.
(E)Diverted organic waste, if the waste is separated and processed to (i) enhance the recovery of recyclable materials and (ii) minimize air emissions and residual wastes in accordance with applicable standards.
(2)Eligible feedstock means organic waste or other sustainably produced organic material and electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code).
(3)Gas seller means a gas corporation, as defined by Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code, or another entity authorized to sell natural gas pursuant to natural gas restructuring (Chapter 2.2 (commencing with Section 328) of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), including sales to core and noncore customers pursuant to natural gas restructuring.
(4)Renewable gas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other renewable sources, including electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code). Renewable gas includes biogas and synthetic natural gas generated from an eligible feedstock.
(5)Renewable gas standard means the quantity of renewable gas that a gas seller is required to provide to retail end-use customers for use in California for each compliance period set forth in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)On or before June 30, 2016, 2017, the state board, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, shall adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard that requires all gas sellers to provide specified percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers for use in California. Each gas seller shall procure a minimum quantity of renewable gas for each of the following compliance periods:
(A)January 1, 2016, June 30, 2017, to December 31, 2019, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 1 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(B)January 1, 2020, to December 31, 2022, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 3 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(C)January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2024, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 5 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(D)January 1, 2025, to December 31, 2029, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(E)January 1, 2030, and thereafter. The state board shall require a gas seller to ensure that not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(2)Gas sellers shall be obligated to procure no less than the quantities associated with all intervening years by the end of each compliance period.
(c)Only renewable gas that meets any of the following conditions shall count toward meeting the procurement requirements of the renewable gas standard:
(1)The renewable gas is used onsite by an end-use customer in California.
(2)The renewable gas is used by an end-use customer in California and delivered through a dedicated pipeline.
(3)The renewable gas is delivered to end-use customers in California through a common carrier pipeline and meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The source of renewable gas injects the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline that physically flows within California or toward the end-use customers for which the renewable gas was procured under the purchase contract.
(B)The source of renewable gas did not inject the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline prior to March 29, 2012, or the source commenced injection of sufficient incremental quantities of renewable gas after March 29, 2012, to satisfy the purchase contract requirements.
(C)The seller or purchaser of the renewable gas demonstrates that the capture and injection of renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline directly results in at least one of the following environmental benefits to California:
(i)The reduction or avoidance of the emission of any criteria air pollutant in California.
(ii)The reduction or avoidance of pollutants that could have an adverse impact on waters of the state.
(iii)The alleviation of a local nuisance within California that is associated with the emission of odors.
(d)In adopting the renewable gas standard, the state board shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify all gas sellers in California of, and how to comply with, the renewable gas standard procurement requirements. The State Board of Equalization may supply the state board with information obtained as a result of its collection of the natural gas surcharge pursuant to Article 10 (commencing with Section 890) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to assist the state board in identifying those gas sellers that are not gas corporations, as defined in Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code. The Public Utilities Commission shall notify the state board of each gas corporation that provides gas service to end-use customers in California.
(2)Maintain and publicize a list of eligible renewable gas providers. For these purposes, an eligible renewable gas provider means any person or corporation that is able to supply renewable gas meeting the deliverability requirements of subdivision (c).
(3)Adopt a flexible compliance mechanism, such as tradable renewable gas credits, to increase market flexibility and reduce costs of compliance. If the state board adopts tradable renewable gas credits, those credits shall be based on the carbon intensity of the renewable gas and shall give equal value to renewable gas that is used onsite and renewable gas that is injected into a common carrier pipeline. The flexible compliance mechanism shall also allow for credit banking and borrowing. The state board shall consult with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission in developing any system for tradable renewable gas credits.
(4)The state board shall consult with the Public Utilities Commission in the development of regulations to implement the renewable gas standard as they affect gas corporations, subject to regulation as public utilities by the commission, in order to minimize duplicative reporting or regulatory requirements.
(5)In consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, adopt a coordinated investment plan to ensure that moneys made available from revenues derived through adoption of a market-based compliance mechanism or through the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program or Air Quality Improvement Program, are used to reduce the costs to implement the renewable gas standard, including the costs of pipeline injection.
(e)The state board shall waive enforcement of this section if it finds that the gas seller has demonstrated either of the following conditions are beyond the control of the gas seller and will prevent compliance:
(1)Permitting or other circumstances that delay renewable gas projects, or there is an insufficient supply of renewable gas resources available to the gas seller. In making a finding that this condition prevents timely compliance, the state board shall consider whether the gas seller has done all of the following:
(A)Prudently managed portfolio risks, including relying on a sufficient number of viable projects.
(B)Sought to develop its own renewable gas resources, pipelines, or pipeline interconnections to secure renewable gas resources.
(C)Procured an appropriate minimum margin of procurement above the minimum procurement level necessary to comply with the renewables gas standard to compensate for foreseeable delays or insufficient supply.
(D)Taken reasonable measures, under the control of the gas seller, to procure allowable tradable renewable gas credits.
(2)There is a disproportionate impact on commodity rates. The state board, in consultation with the Public Utilities Commission, shall establish a limitation for each gas seller on the expenditures for all renewable gas used to comply with the renewable gas standard. This limitation shall be set at a level that prevents disproportionate commodity rate impacts. In determining whether commodity rate impacts are disproportionate, the state board may consider the extent to which procurement required under this section results in a reduction in compliance costs for any other state obligation and may consider the availability of other incentives and credits that reduce the costs to ratepayers and noncore customers. If the cost limitation is insufficient to support the projected costs of meeting the renewable gas standard requirements, the gas seller may refrain from procuring quantities in excess of those that can be procured within the limitation.
(f)(1)If the state board waives any compliance requirements of this section, the state board shall establish additional reporting requirements on the gas seller to demonstrate that all reasonable actions under the control of the gas seller are taken in each of the intervening years sufficient to satisfy future procurement requirements.
(2)The board shall not waive enforcement pursuant to this section, unless the gas seller demonstrates that it has taken all reasonable actions under its control, as set forth in subdivision (e), to achieve full compliance.
(g)On or before January 1, 2017, the state board shall issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses, including, but not limited to, electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating and industrial uses, and as a source of renewable hydrogen for fuel cells. The analysis shall include an assessment of other public health and environmental benefits, including benefits to disadvantaged communities, air and water quality, soil improvement, and wildfire reduction.
SEC. 3.Section 25327 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25327.(a)For purposes of this section, renewable gas has the same meaning as defined in Section 39735 of the Health and Safety Code.
(b)On or before January 1, 2018, the commission shall provide an assessment of the following to the State Air Resources Board and the Legislature:
(1)Opportunities to colocate renewable gas production with existing vehicle fleets and other transportation fueling opportunities.
(2)Renewable energy production sites that can use the renewable gas onsite to reduce fossil fuel gas consumption for generation of electricity, heating, cooling, or other purposes.
(3)Renewable energy production sites that can cost effectively interconnect to common carrier gas pipelines.
(4)Recommendations to reduce the costs of pipeline interconnection for renewable gas projects in California.
(c)The assessment to be submitted to the Legislature pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(d)Consistent with Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this Section section is repealed on January 1, 2020.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)California has enacted numerous policies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases and to increase the use of renewable energy resources and renewable fuels, including the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code), the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), the low carbon fuel standard (Executive Order S-01-07 (January 19, 2007); Title 17 California Code of Regulations Sections 95480 to 95490, inclusive), and the states comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (Section 39730 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Use of natural gas causes more than one-quarter of all emissions of greenhouse gases in California. Wildfires cause more than one-half of all black carbon emissions, and organic waste is responsible for three of the states five largest sources of methane emissions.
(c)Capturing and using methane gas from renewable sources (renewable gas) can significantly reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from fossil fuel use, organic waste, wildfires, and petroleum-based fertilizers. Using renewable gas in place of just 10 percent of Californias fossil fuel derived gas supply would reduce emissions of greenhouse gases by tens of millions of metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions per year. Renewable gas generated from organic waste provides the lowest carbon transportation fuels in existence and can provide low carbon, flexible fuel for the generation of electricity.
(d)Increasing use of renewable gas in California will protect disadvantaged communities by reducing air and water pollution from fossil fuel refining and combustion. Renewable gas used in place of diesel in heavy-duty vehicles will protect public health by reducing toxic air contaminants.
(e)Renewable gas provides significant economic benefits to California, including job creation, an in-state source of gas, increased energy security, revenue and energy for public agencies, and revenue for dairies, farms, rural forest communities, and other areas.
(f)It is in the interest of the state to establish a renewable gas standard that will diversify and decarbonize Californias gas supply, to provide lower carbon gas for electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating, and industrial purposes.
(g)A renewable gas standard will reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from the oil and gas sector and from the solid waste, food and agriculture, water and wastewater, and forestry sectors. It will increase in-state gas supplies and provide jobs and increased energy security for California.
(h)A renewable gas standard will help California to meet the waste diversion requirements of Section 41781.3, Article 1 (commencing with Section 41780) of Chapter 6 of Part 2 of, and Chapter 12.9 (commencing with Section 42649.8) of Part 3 of, Division 30 of the Public Resources Code, by using diverted organic waste to produce renewable gas.
SEC. 2.Section 39735 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:39735.(a)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Biogas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other organic materials, through anaerobic digestion, gasification, pyrolysis, or other technology that converts organic waste to gas. Biogas may be produced from, but not limited to, any of the following sources:
(A)Agricultural waste remaining after all reasonably usable food content is extracted.
(B)Forest waste produced from sustainable forest management practices.
(C)Landfill gas.
(D)Wastewater treatment gas and biosolids.
(E)Diverted organic waste, if the waste is separated and processed to (i) enhance the recovery of recyclable materials and (ii) minimize air emissions and residual wastes in accordance with applicable standards.
(2)Eligible feedstock means organic waste or other sustainably produced organic material and electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code).
(3)Gas seller means a gas corporation, as defined by Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code, or another entity authorized to sell natural gas pursuant to natural gas restructuring (Chapter 2.2 (commencing with Section 328) of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), including sales to core and noncore customers pursuant to natural gas restructuring.
(4)Renewable gas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other renewable sources, including electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code). Renewable gas includes biogas and synthetic natural gas generated from an eligible feedstock.
(5)Renewable gas standard means the quantity of renewable gas that a gas seller is required to provide to retail end-use customers for use in California for each compliance period set forth in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)On or before June 30, 2016, the state board, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, shall adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard that requires all gas sellers to provide specified percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers for use in California. Each gas seller shall procure a minimum quantity of renewable gas for each of the following compliance periods:
(A)January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 1 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(B)January 1, 2020, to December 31, 2022, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 3 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(C)January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2024, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 5 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(D)January 1, 2025, to December 31, 2029, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(E)January 1, 2030, and thereafter. The state board shall require a gas seller to ensure that not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(2)Gas sellers shall be obligated to procure no less than the quantities associated with all intervening years by the end of each compliance period.
(c)Only renewable gas that meets any of the following conditions shall count toward meeting the procurement requirements of the renewable gas standard:
(1)The renewable gas is used onsite by an end-use customer in California.
(2)The renewable gas is used by an end-use customer in California and delivered through a dedicated pipeline.
(3)The renewable gas is delivered to end-use customers in California through a common carrier pipeline and meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The source of renewable gas injects the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline that physically flows within California or toward the end-use customers for which the renewable gas was procured under the purchase contract.
(B)The source of renewable gas did not inject the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline prior to March 29, 2012, or the source commenced injection of sufficient incremental quantities of renewable gas after March 29, 2012, to satisfy the purchase contract requirements.
(C)The seller or purchaser of the renewable gas demonstrates that the capture and injection of renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline directly results in at least one of the following environmental benefits to California:
(i)The reduction or avoidance of the emission of any criteria air pollutant in California.
(ii)The reduction or avoidance of pollutants that could have an adverse impact on waters of the state.
(iii)The alleviation of a local nuisance within California that is associated with the emission of odors.
(d)In adopting the renewable gas standard, the state board shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify all gas sellers in California of, and how to comply with, the renewable gas standard procurement requirements. The State Board of Equalization may supply the state board with information obtained as a result of its collection of the natural gas surcharge pursuant to Article 10 (commencing with Section 890) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to assist the state board in identifying those gas sellers that are not gas corporations, as defined in Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code. The Public Utilities Commission shall notify the state board of each gas corporation that provides gas service to end-use customers in California.
(2)Maintain and publicize a list of eligible renewable gas providers. For these purposes, an eligible renewable gas provider means any person or corporation that is able to supply renewable gas meeting the deliverability requirements of subdivision (c).
(3)Adopt a flexible compliance mechanism, such as tradable renewable gas credits, to increase market flexibility and reduce costs of compliance. If the state board adopts tradable renewable gas credits, those credits shall be based on the carbon intensity of the renewable gas and shall give equal value to renewable gas that is used onsite and renewable gas that is injected into a common carrier pipeline. The flexible compliance mechanism shall also allow for credit banking and borrowing. The state board shall consult with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission in developing any system for tradeable renewable gas credits.
(4)The state board shall consult with the Public Utilities Commission in the development of regulations to implement the renewable gas standard as they affect gas corporations, subject to regulation as public utilities by the commission, in order to minimize duplicative reporting or regulatory requirements.
(5)In consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, adopt a coordinated investment plan to ensure that moneys made available from revenues derived through adoption of a market-based compliance mechanism or through the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program or Air Quality Improvement Program, are used to reduce the costs to implement the renewable gas standard, including the costs of pipeline injection.
(e)The state board shall waive enforcement of this section if it finds that the gas seller has demonstrated either of the following conditions are beyond the control of the gas seller and will prevent compliance:
(1)Permitting or other circumstances that delay renewable gas projects, or there is an insufficient supply of renewable gas resources available to the gas seller. In making a finding that this condition prevents timely compliance, the state board shall consider whether the gas seller has done all of the following:
(A)Prudently managed portfolio risks, including relying on a sufficient number of viable projects.
(B)Sought to develop its own renewable gas resources, pipelines, or pipeline interconnections to secure renewable gas resources.
(C)Procured an appropriate minimum margin of procurement above the minimum procurement level necessary to comply with the renewables gas standard to compensate for foreseeable delays or insufficient supply.
(D)Taken reasonable measures, under the control of the gas seller, to procure allowable tradable renewable gas credits.
(2)There is a disproportionate impact on commodity rates. The state board, in consultation with the Public Utilities Commission, shall establish a limitation for each gas seller on the expenditures for all renewable gas used to comply with the renewable gas standard. This limitation shall be set at a level that prevents disproportionate commodity rate impacts. In determining whether commodity rate impacts are disproportionate, the state board may consider the extent to which procurement required under this section results in a reduction in compliance costs for any other state obligation and may consider the availability of other incentives and credits that reduce the costs to ratepayers and noncore customers. If the cost limitation is insufficient to support the projected costs of meeting the renewable gas standard requirements, the gas seller may refrain from procuring quantities in excess of those that can be procured within the limitation.
(f)(1)If the state board waives any compliance requirements of this section, the state board shall establish additional reporting requirements on the gas seller to demonstrate that all reasonable actions under the control of the gas seller are taken in each of the intervening years sufficient to satisfy future procurement requirements.
(2)The board shall not waive enforcement pursuant to this section, unless the gas seller demonstrates that it has taken all reasonable actions under its control, as set forth in subdivision (e), to achieve full compliance.
(e)
(g)On or before January 1, 2017, the state board shall issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses, including, but not limited to, electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating and industrial uses, and as a source of renewable hydrogen for fuel cells. The analysis shall include an assessment of other public health and environmental benefits, including benefits to disadvantaged communities, air and water quality, soil improvement, and wildfire reduction.
SEC. 3.Section 25327 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:25327.(a)For purposes of this section, renewable gas has the same meaning as defined in Section 39735 of the Health and Safety Code.
(b)On or before January 1, 2018, the commission shall provide an assessment of the following to the State Air Resources Board and the Legislature:
(1)Opportunities to colocate renewable gas production with existing vehicle fleets and other transportation fueling opportunities.
(2)Renewable energy production sites that can use the renewable gas onsite to reduce fossil fuel gas consumption for generation of electricity, heating, cooling, or other purposes.
(3)Renewable energy production sites that can cost-effectively interconnect to common carrier gas pipelines.
(4)Recommendations to reduce the costs of pipeline interconnection for renewable gas projects in California.
(c)The assessment to be submitted to the Legislature pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(d)Consistent with Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this Section is repealed on January 1, 2020.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)California has enacted numerous policies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases and to increase the use of renewable energy resources and renewable fuels, including the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code), the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), the low carbon fuel standard (Executive Order S-01-07 (January 19, 2007); Title 17 California Code of Regulations Sections 95480 to 95490, inclusive), and the states comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (Section 39730 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Use of natural gas causes more than one-quarter of all emissions of greenhouse gases in California. Wildfires cause more than one-half of all black carbon emissions, and organic waste is responsible for three of the states five largest sources of methane emissions.
(c)Capturing and using methane gas from renewable sources (renewable gas) can significantly reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from fossil fuel use, organic waste, wildfires, and petroleum-based fertilizers. Using renewable gas in place of just 10 percent of Californias fossil fuel derived gas supply would reduce emissions of greenhouse gases by tens of millions of metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions per year. Renewable gas generated from organic waste provides the lowest carbon transportation fuels in existence and can provide low carbon, flexible fuel for the generation of electricity.
(d)Increasing use of renewable gas in California will protect disadvantaged communities by reducing air and water pollution from fossil fuel refining and combustion. Renewable gas used in place of diesel in heavy-duty vehicles will protect public health by reducing toxic air contaminants.
(e)Renewable gas provides significant economic benefits to California, including job creation, an in-state source of gas, increased energy security, revenue and energy for public agencies, and revenue for dairies, farms, rural forest communities, and other areas.
(f)It is in the interest of the state to establish a renewable gas standard that will diversify and decarbonize Californias gas supply, to provide lower carbon gas for electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating, and industrial purposes.
(g)A renewable gas standard will reduce emissions of greenhouse gases from the oil and gas sector and from the solid waste, food and agriculture, water and wastewater, and forestry sectors. It will increase in-state gas supplies and provide jobs and increased energy security for California.
(h)A renewable gas standard will help California to meet the waste diversion requirements of Section 41781.3, Article 1 (commencing with Section 41780) of Chapter 6 of Part 2 of, and Chapter 12.9 (commencing with Section 42649.8) of Part 3 of, Division 30 of the Public Resources Code, by using diverted organic waste to produce renewable gas.
SEC. 2.Section 39735 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:39735.(a)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Biogas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other organic materials, through anaerobic digestion, gasification, pyrolysis, or other technology that converts organic waste to gas. Biogas may be produced from, but not limited to, any of the following sources:
(A)Agricultural waste remaining after all reasonably usable food content is extracted.
(B)Forest waste produced from sustainable forest management practices.
(C)Landfill gas.
(D)Wastewater treatment gas and biosolids.
(E)Diverted organic waste, if the waste is separated and processed to (i) enhance the recovery of recyclable materials and (ii) minimize air emissions and residual wastes in accordance with applicable standards.
(2)Eligible feedstock means organic waste or other sustainably produced organic material and electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code).
(3)Gas seller means a gas corporation, as defined by Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code, or another entity authorized to sell natural gas pursuant to natural gas restructuring (Chapter 2.2 (commencing with Section 328) of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code), including sales to core and noncore customers pursuant to natural gas restructuring.
(4)Renewable gas means gas that is generated from organic waste or other renewable sources, including electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting the requirements of the California Renewables Portfolio Standard Program (Article 16 (commencing with Section 399.11) of Chapter 2.3 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code). Renewable gas includes biogas and synthetic natural gas generated from an eligible feedstock.
(5)Renewable gas standard means the quantity of renewable gas that a gas seller is required to provide to retail end-use customers for use in California for each compliance period set forth in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)On or before June 30, 2016, the state board, in consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, shall adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard that requires all gas sellers to provide specified percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers for use in California. Each gas seller shall procure a minimum quantity of renewable gas for each of the following compliance periods:
(A)January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 1 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(B)January 1, 2020, to December 31, 2022, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 3 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(C)January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2024, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 5 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(D)January 1, 2025, to December 31, 2029, inclusive. The state board shall require a gas seller to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(E)January 1, 2030, and thereafter. The state board shall require a gas seller to ensure that not less than 10 percent of the gas supplied to retail end-use customers for use in California is renewable gas.
(2)Gas sellers shall be obligated to procure no less than the quantities associated with all intervening years by the end of each compliance period.
(c)Only renewable gas that meets any of the following conditions shall count toward meeting the procurement requirements of the renewable gas standard:
(1)The renewable gas is used onsite by an end-use customer in California.
(2)The renewable gas is used by an end-use customer in California and delivered through a dedicated pipeline.
(3)The renewable gas is delivered to end-use customers in California through a common carrier pipeline and meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The source of renewable gas injects the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline that physically flows within California or toward the end-use customers for which the renewable gas was procured under the purchase contract.
(B)The source of renewable gas did not inject the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline prior to March 29, 2012, or the source commenced injection of sufficient incremental quantities of renewable gas after March 29, 2012, to satisfy the purchase contract requirements.
(C)The seller or purchaser of the renewable gas demonstrates that the capture and injection of renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline directly results in at least one of the following environmental benefits to California:
(i)The reduction or avoidance of the emission of any criteria air pollutant in California.
(ii)The reduction or avoidance of pollutants that could have an adverse impact on waters of the state.
(iii)The alleviation of a local nuisance within California that is associated with the emission of odors.
(d)In adopting the renewable gas standard, the state board shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify all gas sellers in California of, and how to comply with, the renewable gas standard procurement requirements. The State Board of Equalization may supply the state board with information obtained as a result of its collection of the natural gas surcharge pursuant to Article 10 (commencing with Section 890) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 1 of the Public Utilities Code, to assist the state board in identifying those gas sellers that are not gas corporations, as defined in Section 222 of the Public Utilities Code. The Public Utilities Commission shall notify the state board of each gas corporation that provides gas service to end-use customers in California.
(2)Maintain and publicize a list of eligible renewable gas providers. For these purposes, an eligible renewable gas provider means any person or corporation that is able to supply renewable gas meeting the deliverability requirements of subdivision (c).
(3)Adopt a flexible compliance mechanism, such as tradable renewable gas credits, to increase market flexibility and reduce costs of compliance. If the state board adopts tradable renewable gas credits, those credits shall be based on the carbon intensity of the renewable gas and shall give equal value to renewable gas that is used onsite and renewable gas that is injected into a common carrier pipeline. The flexible compliance mechanism shall also allow for credit banking and borrowing. The state board shall consult with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission in developing any system for tradeable renewable gas credits.
(4)The state board shall consult with the Public Utilities Commission in the development of regulations to implement the renewable gas standard as they affect gas corporations, subject to regulation as public utilities by the commission, in order to minimize duplicative reporting or regulatory requirements.
(5)In consultation with the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission and the Public Utilities Commission, adopt a coordinated investment plan to ensure that moneys made available from revenues derived through adoption of a market-based compliance mechanism or through the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program or Air Quality Improvement Program, are used to reduce the costs to implement the renewable gas standard, including the costs of pipeline injection.
(e)On or before January 1, 2017, the state board shall issue an analysis of the lifecycle emissions of greenhouse gases and reductions for different biogas types and end uses, including, but not limited to, electricity generation, transportation fuels, heating and industrial uses, and as a source of renewable hydrogen for fuel cells. The analysis shall include an assessment of other public health and environmental benefits, including benefits to disadvantaged communities, air and water quality, soil improvement, and wildfire reduction.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 28, 2015 | May 28 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 23, 2015 | Set for hearing May 28. |
| May 18, 2015 | May 18 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 8, 2015 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 5, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 4, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 859.) (April 29). |
| May 4, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 29). |
| Apr 21, 2015 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 16, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Apr 15, 2015 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 7. Noes 3. Page 509.) (April 7). |
| Mar 24, 2015 | Set for hearing April 7. |
| Mar 19, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on E., U., & C. and E.Q. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after April 1. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 18, 2015 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Apr 7, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SB 687 (Allen) Page 4 of 4
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
SB 687 (Allen) - Renewable gas standard.
|
|
Version: May 5, 2015 |
Policy Vote: E., U., & C. 7 - 3, E.Q. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No |
Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 18, 2015 |
Consultant: Marie Liu |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 687 would require the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to develop a carbon-based renewable gas standard (RGS) that requires each gas seller to provide specified percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers.
Fiscal Impact:
First year costs of $1.5 million and ongoing costs of $2.0 million from the Cost of Implementation Account (special) to the Air Resources Board to develop and implement the RGS.
Annual ongoing costs of $270,000 from the Energy Resources Program Account (General Fund) to the California Energy Commission (CEC) to develop and implement the RGS and to assist in the development of the lifecycle biogas emissions analysis.
One-time contract of $100,000 from the Energy Resources Program Account (General Fund) to the CEC to provide technical assistance with the renewable gas study.
Ongoing costs of $350,000 annually to the Public Utilities Reimbursement Account (special) to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) for implementation of the RGS.
On-time costs of $160,000 to the Public Utilities Reimbursement Account (special) in FY 2015-16 to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to develop the information necessary for the ARB to develop the RGS.
Unknown impacts to the General Fund and various special funds to the state as a natural gas customer.
Background:
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (referred to as AB 32, HSC §38500 et seq.) requires the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to determine the 1990 statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions level, to approve a statewide GHG emissions limit equivalent to that level that will be achieved by 2020, and to adopt GHG emissions reductions measures by regulation. ARB is authorized to include the use of market-based mechanisms to comply with the regulations. All monies, except for fines and penalties, collected pursuant to a market-based mechanism are deposited in the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF) (Government Code §16428.8).
Existing law requires that the GGRF only be used to facilitate the achievement of reductions of GHG emissions consistent with AB 32 (HSC §39710 et seq.). To this end, the Department of Finance, in consultation with the ARB and any other relevant state agencies, is required to develop, as specified, a three-year investment plan for the moneys deposited in the GGRF. The investment plan must allocate a minimum of 25% of the funds to projects that benefit disadvantaged communities and to allocate 10% of the funds to projects located within disadvantaged communities. Additionally, the ARB, in consultation with CalEPA, is required to develop funding guidelines for administering agencies receiving allocations of GGRF funds that include a component for how agencies should maximize benefits to disadvantaged communities.
Existing law requires all retail sellers of electricity – investor-owned utilities (IOU), community choice aggregators (CCAs), and energy service providers (ESPs) – and publicly-owned utilities (POU) to increase purchases of renewable energy such that at least 33 percent of retail sales are procured from renewable energy resources by December 31, 2020. This is known as the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS). The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) is explicitly authorized to require retail sellers of electricity to procure renewable energy resources in excess of the 33-percent RPS requirement. (Public Utilities Code §399.11 et seq.). The CPUC oversees RPS compliance with IOUs while the California Energy Commission (CEC) oversees POUs.
Existing law sets specific eligibility requirements for biomethane contracted after March 29, 2012 in order to qualify as an RPS-eligible source.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require gas sellers to provide an increasing percentage of renewable gas by a specified schedule. Specifically, this bill would:
Define “renewable gas” as gas generated from organic waste or other renewable sources, including electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting RPS requirements.
Require the ARB, on or before June 30, 2017, and in consultation with CEC and CPUC, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard (RGS) that requires each gas seller to provide certain percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers.
Requires ARB to require gas sellers to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period, the following percentages of renewable gas supplied to retail end-use customers are met:
1% by 2019;
3% by 2022;
5% by 2024;
10% by 2029;
Requires that renewable gas, to be eligible to count towards the procurement requirements in the bill, must meet at least one of the following conditions:
the renewable gas is used onsite by an end-use customer in the state;
the renewable gas is used by an end-use customer in the state and delivered through a dedicated pipeline;
the renewable gas is delivered to end-use customers in the state through a common carrier pipeline and meets specified requirements.
Requires ARB to notify all gas sellers in California of how to comply with the renewable gas standard procurement requirements, and authorizes the State Board of Equalization to supply ARB with specified information to assist in the identification of gas sellers that are not gas corporations.
Requires PUC to notify ARB of each gas corporation that provides gas service to end-use customers in the state.
Requires ARB to maintain and publicize a list of eligible renewable gas providers.
Requires ARB, in consultation with CEC, to adopt a flexible compliance mechanism, such as tradable renewable gas credits, and specifies that if ARB adopts tradable credits, those credits are to be based on the carbon intensity of the renewable gas, give equal value to renewable gas used onsite and renewable gas injected into a common carrier pipeline, and allow for credit banking and borrowing.
Requires ARB to consult with CPUC in development of regulations, as they affect gas corporations subject to regulations by CPUC, to implement the RGS, in order to minimize duplicative reporting and regulatory requirements.
Require ARB, in consultation with CPUC and CEC, to develop a coordinated investment plan to ensure that moneys made available through the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, or from the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program, or the Air Quality Improvement Program, are used to reduce the costs to implement the RGS.
Requires ARB waive the enforcement of the RGS if it finds that a gas seller has demonstrated specified conditions beyond the control of the gas seller and that prevent compliance.
Requires ARB to issue a lifecycle GHG emissions analysis for various biogas types and end uses, and that also includes an assessment of other public health and environmental benefits.
Requires CEC to provide an assessment to ARB and the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2018, on the following:
Opportunities to colocate renewable gas production with existing vehicle fleets and other transportation fueling opportunities;
Renewable energy production sites that can use renewable gas onsite to reduce fossil fuel gas consumption for electricity generation, heating or cooling, or other purposes;
Recommendations to reduce the costs of pipeline interconnection for renewable gas projects in the state.
Staff Comments:
This bill would require significant ARB activity including identifying market and regulatory barriers to implementation, evaluating technical feasibility of biomethane availability, developing life-cycle analysis, and to develop and implement regulations. In all, the ARB anticipates first year costs of $1.5 million followed by on-going costs of $2.0 million. As these activities further the reduction of GHG emissions, ARB anticipates paying for these costs from the Cost of Implementation account which receives revenues from a fee on industries subject to AB 32.
The CEC anticipates needing two positions to consult with the ARB in developing the RGS and to assist in the development of lifecycle biogas emissions analysis. The CEC would also have one-time contract costs for technical assistance.
Staff notes that the CEC is likely to have additional costs to provide the assessment required by the bill regarding colocation opportunities, certain renewable energy production sites, renewable energy production sites, and recommendations to reduce the cost of pipeline interconnection for renewable gas. Some of this information is addressed in existing CEC reports, but other elements may require additional workload.
This bill would require the CPUC to coordinate with the ARB on several fronts and specifically would be required to develop information necessary to assist the ARB in adopting a RGS. The CPUC anticipates needing a new proceeding for this process at a one-time cost of approximately $160,000 in FY 2015-16. Once the information is developed, the CPUC would anticipate ongoing costs to coordinate with the ARB and CEC in implementing the standard. As this bill would intersect with the CPUC’s RPS program, it’s regulation of natural gas utility service, and CPUC’s oversight of AB 32 compliance by electric and natural gas utilities, the CPUC anticipates ongoing costs to be $350,000 annually.
The state, as a customer of natural gas and electricity produced from natural gas, may experience additional fiscal impacts depending on how this bill ultimately impacts gas rates, which is unknown and speculative at this time.
-- END --
SB 687 (Allen) Page 15 of 15
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Bob Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 687 Hearing Date: 4/29/15
Author: |
Allen |
||
Version: |
4/16/2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Rebecca Newhouse |
||
Subject: Renewable gas standard
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, requires the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to determine the 1990 statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions level and approve a statewide GHG emissions limit that is equivalent to that level, to be achieved by 2020, and to adopt GHG emissions reductions measures by regulation. ARB is authorized to include the use of market-based mechanisms to comply with these regulations. (Health and Safety Code §38500 et seq.)
Provides that eligible renewable electrical generation facilities must use biomass, solar thermal, photovoltaic, wind, geothermal, renewable fuel cells, small hydroelectric, digester gas, limited non-combustion municipal solid waste conversion, landfill gas, ocean wave, ocean thermal, and tidal current to generate electricity, and requires that renewable electrical generation facilities must meet certain requirements, as specified (Public Resources Code §25741).
Under the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) requires investor-owned utilities (IOUs), publicly owned utilities (POUs) and certain other retail sellers of electricity to achieve 33% of their energy sales from an eligible renewable electrical generation facility by December 31, 2020, and establishes portfolio requirements and a timeline for procurement quantities of three product categories. (Public Utilities Code §399.11 et seq.).
Sets specific eligibility requirements for biomethane contracted after March 29, 2012, in order to qualify as an RPS-eligible resource. (PUC §399.12.6)
Requires the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA), in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, and other specified agencies, to compile a list of constituents of concern that could pose risks to human health and that are found in biogas at concentrations that significantly exceed the concentrations of those constituents in natural gas and requires OEHHA to determine the health protective levels for that list, as specified, and requires ARB to identify realistic exposure scenarios and the health risks associated with those scenarios, as specified and the acceptable threshold concentrations of those constituents. (HSC §25421)
Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to adopt standards for biomethane to be injected into a common carrier pipeline that specify constituent concentrations that are reasonably necessary to ensure the protection of human health, giving due deference to the findings by OEHHA, ARB, and other specified agencies. (HSC §25421)
Requires California Energy Commission (CEC) to hold public hearings to identify impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California, including, but not limited to, impediments to interconnection, and requires CEC to offer solutions to those impediments as part of the integrated energy policy. (PRC §25326)
Requires PUC to adopt policies and programs that promote the in-state production and distribution of biomethane. (PUC §399.24 )
Requires PUC to adopt pipeline access rules that ensure that each gas corporation provides nondiscriminatory open access to its gas pipeline system to any party for the purposes of physically interconnecting with the gas pipeline system and effectuating the delivery of gas. (PUC §784)
Requires businesses that generate specified amounts of organic waste to arrange for recycling services for that material. (PRC §42649.81)
This bill:
Defines “renewable gas” as gas generated from organic waste or other renewable sources, including electricity generated by an eligible renewable energy resource meeting RPS requirements.
Requires the ARB, on or before June 30, 2016, and in consultation with CEC and PUC, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard (RGS) that requires each gas seller to provide certain percentages of renewable gas to retail end-use customers.
Requires ARB to require gas sellers to make reasonable progress sufficient to ensure that by the end of the compliance period, the following percentages of renewable gas supplied to retail end-use customers are met:
1% by 2019;
3% by 2022;
5% by 2024;
10% by 2029;
Requires that renewable gas, to be eligible to count towards the procurement requirements in the bill, must meet at least one of the following conditions:
the renewable gas is used onsite by an end-use customer in the state;
the renewable gas is used by an end-use customer in the state and delivered through a dedicated pipeline;
the renewable gas is delivered to end-use customers in the state through a common carrier pipeline and meets specified requirements.
Requires ARB to notify all gas sellers in California of how to comply with the renewable gas standard procurement requirements, and authorizes the State Board of Equalization to supply ARB with specified information to assist in the identification of gas sellers that are not gas corporations.
Requires PUC to notify ARB of each gas corporation that provides gas service to end-use customers in the state.
Requires ARB to maintain and publicize a list of eligible renewable gas providers.
Requires ARB, in consultation with CEC, to adopt a flexible compliance mechanism, such as tradable renewable gas credits, and specifies that if ARB adopts tradable credits, those credits are to be based on the carbon intensity of the renewable gas, give equal value to renewable gas used onsite and renewable gas injected into a common carrier pipeline, and allow for credit banking and borrowing.
Requires ARB to consult with PUC in development of regulations, as they affect gas corporations subject to regulations by PUC, to implement the RGS, in order to minimize duplicative reporting and regulatory requirements.
Require ARB, in consultation with PUC and CEC, ensure that moneys made available through cap-and-trade auction revenue, or from the Alternative and Renewable Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program, or the Air Quality Improvement Program, are used to reduce the costs to implement the RGS.
Requires ARB waive the enforcement of the RGS if it finds that a gas seller has demonstrated specified conditions beyond the control of the gas seller and that prevent compliance.
Requires ARB to issue a lifecycle GHG emissions analysis for various biogas types and end uses, and that also includes an assessment of other public health and environmental benefits.
Requires CEC to provide an assessment to ARB and the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2018, on the following:
Opportunities to colocate renewable gas production with existing vehicle fleets and other transportation fueling opportunities;
Renewable energy production sites that can use renewable gas onsite to reduce fossil fuel gas consumption for electricity generation, heating or cooling, or other purposes;
Recommendations to reduce the costs of pipeline interconnection for renewable gas projects in the state;
Background
Methane and Short-Lived Climate Pollutants.
Methane is the principal component of natural gas and is termed a short-lived climate pollutant, as it has a much shorter lifetime in the atmosphere than CO2, but has a much higher global warming potential. According to the US EPA, methane is over 24 times more effective than CO2 in trapping heat in the atmosphere over a 100-year period.
Atmospheric methane concentrations have been increasing as a result of human activities related to agriculture, fossil fuel extraction and distribution, and waste generation and processing. Many emissions sources of methane are unregulated and recent scientific reports indicate that the US EPA has underestimated methane emissions by as much as 50%.
A 2012 study published in the journal Nature Climate Change found that reducing emissions of short-lived climate pollutants, including methane and soot, by 30 to 60% by 2050 would slow the annual rate of sea level rise by about 18% by 2050. In addition, the study found that, compared to just cutting CO2 emissions, reducing the release of short-lived climate pollutants would do more to slow sea level rise before 2050. However, the study noted that lowering CO2 emissions would be required to limit warming and warming-related impacts beyond that point.
SB 605 (Lara), Chapter 523, Statutes of 2014, directs ARB to develop a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy by January 1, 2016. In developing the strategy, ARB is required to complete an inventory of sources and emissions of short-lived climate pollutants in the state based on available data, identify research needs to address data gaps and existing and potential new control measures to reduce emissions.
Biogas and Biomethane.
Through a series of steps involving the bacterial breakdown of organics, carbon-based material can be converted to methane in oxygen-deprived conditions. This process occurs naturally, and is often uncontrolled in landfills and dairy farms, contributing to significant GHG emissions. However, capturing and utilizing the gas is facilitated through the use of anaerobic digesters, which operate with various temperatures, pH and bacteria types, can break down organic wastes, dramatically speeding up the natural decomposition process, and produce primarily methane, significant quantities of carbon dioxide and trace amounts of other gasses including hydrogen, carbon monoxide, nitrogen, oxygen, and hydrogen sulfide, which, all together, is termed “biogas.” The biogas can be processed further to produce high purity, or “pipeline” quality methane, and is termed biomethane to differentiate it from natural gas. In addition to landfills and dairy, biomethane is generated from digestion processes at wastewater treatment plants.
Burning biomethane results in CO2, however the process is considered carbon neutral since the CO2 was recently removed from the atmosphere. There are very significant climate benefits associated with capturing the methane, and preventing its release into the atmosphere, where it is almost 25 times more powerful climate forcer than CO2.
Additionally, energy produced through burning biomethane can displace energy consumption from fossil-fuels.
AB 32, Cap and Trade and Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS).
ARB has broad authority to regulate methane as a GHG under AB 32 and create programs and implement measures to reduce GHGs in the state to achieve the statewide 2020 GHG emissions goal.
According to ARB’s updated scoping plan, the state’s largest anthropogenic methane-producing sources are enteric fermentation (belching by animals), manure management, landfills, natural gas transmission, and wastewater treatment. Methane emissions also come from non-anthropogenic sources such as wetlands, oceans, and forests. Methane gas from production and distribution is a growing source of emissions in many countries, including the United States, due to increased exploration and use of natural gas for energy.
In order to address these emissions, ARB has implemented several programs that target methane emissions, or provide incentives for the use of renewably generated methane.
Methane from landfills: Effective June 17, 2010, ARB approved a regulatory measure as an AB 32 discrete early action measure that requires owners and operators of certain uncontrolled municipal solid waste landfills to install gas collection and control systems, and requires existing and newly installed gas and control systems to operate in an optimal manner.
Cap-and-Trade Program. Pursuant to AB 32, ARB adopted a cap-and-trade program that places a “cap” on aggregate GHG emissions from large GHG emitters, which are responsible for approximately 85% of the state’s GHG emissions. The cap declines over time, eventually reaching the target emission level in 2020. Large emitters must obtain compliance instruments equal to their emissions in that period. Compliance instruments include allowances and offsets, where allowances are generated by the state in an amount equal to the cap, and offsets result from emissions reductions achieved in an uncapped sector and are quantified and verified using an ARB approved compliance offset protocol. To date, ARB has adopted offset protocols for four project types including dairy digesters to capture fugitive methane emissions.
LCFS: Pursuant to their authority under AB 32, ARB adopted the LCFS in 2009, which requires transportation fuel suppliers in the state to meet certain average annual carbon limitations. The program ultimately requires a 10% reduction in the carbon intensity of a particular fuel by 2020. The carbon intensity measures the net carbon emissions of the entire life-cycle of the fuel, including carbon emitted during production, refining, and transportation, and conversion of the fuel to useable energy. Fuel suppliers can meet the standard by reducing the carbon intensity of their fuels, or by purchasing credits from other suppliers of other fuels that have carbon intensities below state requirements.
As renewable gas, or biomethane, already meets the 10% reduction requirement in 2020, the fuel qualifies for credits under the program.
Budget allocations: The 2014-15 Budget allocates $832 million in cap-and-trade auction revenue to a variety of transportation, energy, and resources programs aimed at reducing GHG emissions. Specifically, $15 million was appropriated to California Department of Food and Agriculture to fund agricultural energy and operational efficiency programs, with $12 million directed for financial assistance for the installation of dairy digesters, and $3 million to support deployment and use of renewable natural gas, its analogues, and other low-carbon renewable biofuels derived from agricultural waste, for use in the transportation sector.
Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) was also awarded $25 million of cap-and-trade auction funds in 2014-15. They have established multiple programs for some of these funds to reduce GHG emissions through providing financial assistance to expand existing capacity or establish new facilities to process California-generated organic waste through composting or anaerobic digestion to produce low-carbon fuel.
This year’s 2015-16 Budget proposes identical appropriations for those two programs at the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) and CalRecycle.
Statewide Waste Diversion Goals.
CalRecycle is tasked with diverting at least 75% of solid waste statewide by 2020. Currently, organic materials, including green waste, make up one-third of the waste stream (approximately 11 million tons) and food waste continues to be the highest single category of disposal at over 15%. Green materials, such as lumber, cardboard, and leaves and grass comprise over 20%.
CalRecycle is also charged with implementing its Strategic Directive 6.1, which calls for reducing organic waste disposal by 50% by 2020. According to CalRecycle, significant gains in organic waste diversion (through recycling technologies for organic waste including composting and anaerobic digestion) are necessary to meet the 75% goal and to implement Strategic Directive 6.1. Anaerobic digestion, which produces biogas that can be processed to biomethane fuel, is particularly suited to handle food waste.
As previously noted, organic waste that ends up in landfills generates landfill gas, 50% of which is methane, from the anaerobic decomposition of organic materials such as food, paper, wood, and green material.
In order to address the large percentage of organic waste disposed of in landfills, AB 1826 (Chesbro), Chapter 727, Statutes of 2014, requires businesses that generate specified amounts of organic and greenwaste to arrange for recycling services of that waste. In addition to diverting organics to higher and better uses, the bill has the added benefit of reducing GHG emission from landfills, since even landfills with methane-control technologies can produce significant fugitive methane emissions.
Landfill Gas and AB 1900.
More than 20 years ago, concern arose regarding the emission of vinyl chloride at a particular Class I hazardous waste landfill, where dangerously high levels of the carcinogen were measured. Because Class II landfills do not accept hazardous waste, the emissions from these landfills were assumed to be free of hazardous chemicals, however, subsequent analysis of Class II landfills biogas detected vinyl chloride and other toxics in non-hazardous waste gas emissions as well, and a 1987 report from the South Coast Air Quality Management District identified vinyl chloride and benzene in 90% of the Class II landfills tested. The study concluded that the presence of the toxins resulted from either illegal dumping, or as an intermediate of microbial digestion of chlorinated chemicals. In response, California adopted strict requirements regarding the allowable levels of vinyl chloride and the required testing protocols for vinyl chloride for the legal sale, supply or transport of landfill gas to a gas corporation in the state. Prior to 2013, the Southern California Gas Company prohibited the use of landfill gas in its natural gas pipelines.
In 2012, the Gas Technology Institute (GTI) released results of analytical tests on 27 landfill gas samples processed using one of three gas clean-up technologies. Based on their results, GTI concluded that landfill gas can be processed to meet typical gas quality standards, or tariffs, to be introduced with natural gas supplies. GTI data indicates that vinyl chloride was undetectable in all samples of post-processed landfill gas.
In an effort to encourage the production and use of biomethane in California, including methane produced from landfill biogas, the Legislature passed AB 1900 (Gatto), Chapter 602, Statutes of 2012, which required PUC to adopt health and safety standards for biomethane for pipeline injection based on recommendations from the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment and the ARB.
In response to AB 1900, PUC issued a decision in February 2013 opening a rulemaking to create rules for how gas utilities and producers should process biomethane, and how it can be safely injected into utility pipelines. On January 16, 2014, PUC issued a Decision adopting health and safety standards that limit the amounts of certain constituents determined to be harmful to either human health or pipeline integrity in pipeline injected biomethane.
AB 1900 also requires utilities adopt rules allowing non-discriminatory pipeline injection of biomethane and calls for PUC to “adopt policies and programs that promote the in-state production and distribution of biomethane.”
CEC is required by AB 1900 to hold public hearings to identify impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California and offer solutions as part of the integrated energy policy.
Biomethane under RPS.
Current law identifies electrical generation facilities that use digester gas, municipal solid waste conversion, or landfill gas, among other fuels, as renewable electrical generation facilities and can be certified, if they meet specific requirements, by CEC as RPS-eligible, and therefore may be used by retail sellers of electricity, and publicly-owned utilities (POUs) to satisfy their renewable portfolio standard (RPS) procurement goals. Changes to the RPS law by SB 2X (Simitian), Chapter 1, Statutes of 2011, established three portfolio content categories within which new RPS procurement is classified and sets quantitative procurement limits for each category and places the highest value on renewable energy that is directly delivered into California.
Biomethane, upgraded from landfill gas or digester gas, may be claimed as a fuel source for a natural gas power plant near, or in California in order to be certified by CEC, and therefore be RPS-eligible. However, because this gas is often delivered from sources distant to California, it is not clear that the biomethane injected into a natural gas pipeline system for delivery to a designated power plant actually displaces in-state fossil fuel consumption because the biomethane may not be physically delivered to the purchasing electric generation facility for a variety of reasons. These reasons include the extensive commingling of the biomethane with natural gas, inconsistent direction of gas flow and multiple extraction points on the pipeline system before the gas reaches the electric generation facility. This issue is unique to biomethane as a renewable resource, since other RPS-eligible facilities have the fuel source and generating facility at the same site.
AB 2196 (Chesbro), Chapter 605, Statutes of 2012, clarified RPS eligibility for pipeline biomethane with requirements comparable to other renewable energy sources. AB 2196 grandfathered biomethane contracts prior to March 29, 2012, but required that injection of biomethane into common carrier pipelines meet specific requirements to ensure that renewable gas displaces natural gas in the pipeline, and ultimately for electricity generation, and that in-state environmental benefits are achieved, in order to be RPS-eligible for biomethane contracts executed after that date.
Some of these requirements include that the source of biomethane injects the biomethane into a common carrier pipeline that physically flows within California or toward the generating facility for which the biomethane was procured under the original contract and that the seller or purchaser of the biomethane demonstrates that the capture and injection of biomethane into a common carrier pipeline directly results in at least one of several specified environmental benefits to California, including avoidance of criteria air pollutants, or pollutants that could have an adverse impact on waters of the state.
In order for “renewable gas” to qualify under the procurement
requirements specified in AB 687, the bill specifies requirements for
that renewable gas similar to the requirements of AB 2196 for
biomethane RPS eligibility.
Comments
Purpose of Bill.
According to the author, “California is a leader in efforts to combat climate change— one of the most daunting challenges facing humanity. Currently, California’s gas sector causes one-quarter of the state’s greenhouse gas emissions, and is a major contributor to global warming.
“California uses more than 2 trillion cubic feet of natural gas per year and that amount is going up. Natural gas is used to generate more than half of the state’s electricity, the majority of its home heating and hot water, and a growing share of transportation fuels. Although cleaner and cheaper than other fossil fuels, natural gas is a major source of greenhouse gas emissions and air and water pollution. In addition, California imports 91 percent of its gas, making the state vulnerable to supply and price fluctuations and costing more than $9 billion per year in lost revenues and jobs as those jobs are outsourced to other states and to Canada.
“Renewable gas made from organic waste can significantly cut
greenhouse gas emissions and landfilling. Increasing the use of
renewable gas will create jobs and economic productivity, and
strengthen California’s energy security.”
How Much Renewable Gas is Available?
The sponsor states that California could generate more than 10% of its total gas consumption, 284 billion cubic feet of gas per year, from organic waste, if all technically available organic waste were converted to biogas.
However, “technically available organic waste” does not equate to readily available. Although, the passage of AB 1826 (Chesbro, 2014), by requiring businesses recycle their organic waste, may help ensure that increasing amounts of organic and greenwaste feedstock are available for conversion into renewable fuels.
In an effort to address potential issues with limited renewable gas supply, SB 687 was amended out of the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communication Committee to include cost-containment provisions that allow the requirements of the RGS to be waived for a gas seller that demonstrates specified conditions beyond the control of the gas seller that prevent compliance.
Not all Renewable Gas is Created Equal.
Depending on how the renewable gas is created, there may be variations in the carbon intensity of the fuel, as well as the amount of energy required to treat and purify the gas for use. The bill specifies percentages that must be procured by gas sellers by various dates; however, it is unclear whether those percentages correspond to volumes of renewable gas or other characteristics, such as reductions in carbon intensity.
If a volumetric approach is taken, two fuels that meet the requirements of a renewable gas specified in SB 687, but that have different GHG emissions impacts based on life-cycle assessments, would count identically under the program toward meeting the procurement requirements specified in the bill.
Procurement requirements based on a carbon intensity score take GHG life- cycle emissions into account, and rank fuels more fairly based on their overall GHG emissions reductions.
As the bill moves forward, the author is planning on amending the bill to clarify that the percentage requirements in the bill correspond to reductions in carbon intensity of the fuel.
Definition.
AB 1900 defined “biomethane” as biogas that meets PUCs health and safety concentration standards. However, SB 687 refers to procurement requirements of “renewable gas” defined as biogas, as specified, or synthetic natural gas. However, the bill does not define “synthetic natural gas.”
The bill also never refers to “biomethane.”
As the bill moves forward, the relationship between biomethane and “renewable gas” should be clarified. Additionally, the term “synthetic natural gas” should be defined.
Timing.
The bill requires ARB to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard by June 30, 2016. As the bill is not an urgency statute, this only leaves 6 months for ARB to implement a completely new program.
Additionally, the bill specifies that ARB is required to ensure a gas seller is making reasonable progress to meeting the compliance periods, but the bill requires them to begin doing this on January 1, 2016, before they are required to adopt the RGS program.
The committee may wish to amend the bill to move the date of
adoption of the program out until June 30, 2017, and make that the
date they are required to begin ensuring gas sellers make reasonable
progress to meet their first compliance procurement deadline.
A Complicated, Shifting Policy Mix.
SB 687 intends to spur growth in the in-state production of renewable gas through renewable gas procurement requirements.
However, there are currently several environmental statutes designed at reducing the state’s GHG emissions and increasing renewable energy procurement, which affect biogas, including AB 32 (Núñez, Pavley), Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006, and the RPS.
AB 32 grants ARB broad authority to adopt regulations to reduce GHGs, including methane.
As noted, through AB 32’s cap-and-trade program, offset generated from dairy digesters can be purchased by entities to fulfill their compliance obligation.
Also pursuant to authority under AB 32, ARB adopted the Low Carbon Fuel Standard which requires a 10% reduction in carbon intensity of transportation fuels in California by 2020. Biogas, or biomethane, produced renewably already meets the 10% carbon intensity reduction, and therefore generates LCFS credits under the program. These credits can be sold through the LCFS market to fuel supplies that do not meet the carbon intensity target. In this way, LCFS provides an incentive to develop the renewable gas market.
And finally, the RPS also includes biomethane as an eligible renewable resource for electricity generation, and, if the gas meets certain requirements, it qualifies for the most valuable procurement category, or “bucket one.” As utilities are required to serve 33% of their retail sales with renewable energy by 2020, with 75% of that coming from the “bucket one” category, demand for biomethane generated in-state will most likely continue to increase.
Additionally, two measures being heard by this committee today, including SB 350 (De León), which would codify ambitious 2030 goals for petroleum use, RPS procurement, and energy efficiency, as well as SB 32 (Pavley), which sets a GHG emissions reduction target of 80% below 1990 levels by 2050, if enacted, will also change the state’s greenhouse gas emissions and clean energy landscape.
Driving the market for renewable gas in California, as SB 687 intends to do, could provide significant GHG emission reductions, and help the state make important strides toward a statewide 75% waste diversion goal. However, the bill would also add an additional level of complexity to the state’s GHG emission reduction measures and clean energy portfolio, and it is worth considering how this bill fits with already established programs affecting renewable gas, as well as additional GHG emission reduction and clean energy proposals currently before the Legislature.
SOURCE:
Bioenergy Association of California
SUPPORT:
Alternative Fuels Advocates, LLC
American Biogas Council
Anaergia
Biosynthetic Technologies, Inc.
California Association of Sanitation Agencies
Calysta
City Of Fresno
Clean Energy and Clean Energy Renewable Fuels
County of Sanitation Districts of Los Angeles County
CR&R
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Eisenmann Corporation
Harvest Power, Inc.
Hitachi Zosen Inova U.S.A. LLC
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Organic Waste Systems
Phoenix Energy
TSS Consultants
UPS
Waste Management
OPPOSITION:
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Poultry Federation
Foster Farms
Milk Producers Council
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Supporters state that SB 687 will help California diversify and decarbonize its gas supply, and that the RGS will produce thousands of clean energy jobs, improve air and water quality, reduce landfilling, cut the risk of catastrophic wildfires, as well as help the state reduce its heavy dependence on out of state natural gas which costs the state billions of dollars each year.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
Opponents state that SB 687’s new mandate could significantly increase costs, has considerable technological challenges, may not treat all sellers equally, and may not be the most efficient way to achieve the state’s objectives. The Agricultural Energy Consumers Association (AECA) also states that not all biogas can, or should be placed in the state natural gas pipeline system, and that the highest and best use of biogas is transportation. The AECA also states that there are still significant barriers to biomethane production, and that SB 687 does nothing to address these barriers.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee on April 7, 2015, and passed out of committee with a vote of 7-3.
-- END –
SB 687 (Allen) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: SB 687 Hearing Date: 4/7/2015
Author: |
Allen |
||
Version: |
2/27/2015 As Introduced |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Jay Dickenson |
||
SUBJECT: Renewable gas standard.
DIGEST: This bill establishes the renewable gas standard (RGS). The RGS requires all sellers of natural gas to provide to retail end-use customers in California increasing amounts of “renewable gas,” so that, by January 1, 2030, at least ten percent of the natural gas supplied is “renewable gas.”
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Directs the California Air Resource Board (ARB) to monitor and regulate sources of emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) that cause global warming in order to reduce GHG emissions to 1990 levels by 2020. (Health & Safety Code §38510 et seq.) ARB instituted a low-carbon fuel standard as one element of achieving the GHG emission reduction goal.
Requires investor-owned utilities (IOU), community choice aggregators (CCAs), and electric service providers (ESPs) (collectively referred to as retail sellers) and local publicly-owned utilities (POU) to increase purchases of renewable energy such that at least 33 percent of total retail sales are procured from renewable energy resources by December 31, 2020. This is known as the Renewables Portfolio Standard (RPS).
Defines a renewable electrical generation facility and includes in that definition a facility that uses landfill gas or digester gas delivered through a common carrier pipeline if the source and delivery of the fuel can be verified by the California Energy Commission (CEC).
Requires the CPUC to adopt standards that specify the concentrations of constituents of concern that are found in biomethane, and to adopt monitoring, testing, reporting, and recordkeeping protocols, to ensure the protection of human health and the integrity and safety of pipelines and pipeline facilities. (Health & Safety Code §25421 et seq.)
Requires the CPUC to adopt pipeline access rules that ensure that each gas corporation provides nondiscriminatory open access to its gas pipeline system to any party for the purposes of physically interconnecting with the gas pipeline system and effectuating the delivery of gas. (Public Utilities Code §784.)
Requires the CEC to hold public hearings to identify in its Integrated Energy Policy Report impediments that limit procurement of biomethane in California, including, but not limited to, impediments to interconnection, and to offer solutions. (Public Resources Code §25326.)
This bill:
Requires the ARB, on or before June 30, 2016, and in consultation with the CEC and the CPUC, to adopt a carbon-based renewable gas standard (RGS) that requires each gas seller to provide a certain percentages of “renewable gas” to retail end-use customers. The requirement adopted by ARB will conform to a compliance schedule so that, by December 31, 2029, and thereafter, each gas seller supplies at least 10 percent “renewable gas” to retail end-use customers.
Limits “renewable gas” that qualifies under the RGS to gas that is:
Used onsite by an end-use customer in California.
Used by an end-use customer in California and delivered through a dedicated pipeline.
Delivered to end-use customers in California through a common carrier pipeline and: (1) the source of renewable gas injects the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline that physically flows within California or toward the end-use customers for which the renewable gas was procured under the purchase contract; and (2) the source of renewable gas did not inject the renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline prior to March 29, 2012, or the source commenced injection of sufficient incremental quantities of renewable gas after March 29, 2012, to satisfy the purchase contract requirements; and (3) the seller or purchaser of the renewable gas demonstrates that the capture and injection of renewable gas into a common carrier pipeline directly results in specified environmental benefits in California.
The bill requires the ARB notify all gas sellers in California how to comply with the RGS; maintain a list of eligible “renewable gas” providers; and adopt “flexible compliance mechanisms,” such as tradable “renewable gas” credits.
Background
What Is Renewable Gas? Bioenergy is renewable energy produced from biomass wastes including forest and other wood waste, agriculture and food processing wastes, organic urban waste, waste and emissions from water treatment facilities, landfill gas and other organic waste sources. Biomass waste can be used to generate renewable electricity, liquid fuels and biogas.
Biogas is a gas produced by converting biomass to a gaseous mixture of carbon dioxide and methane. Depending on where it is produced, biogas can be categorized as landfill gas or digester gas. Landfill gas is produced by decomposition of organic waste in a municipal solid waste landfill. Digester gas is typically produced from livestock manure, sewage treatment or food waste. Biogas can be used directly to produce electricity or can be converted to biomethane by removing carbon dioxide and other impurities. Biomethane can replace fossil sources of natural gas in homes and factories and compressed or liquefied natural gas used in vehicles. Biomethane can also be used to produce renewable hydrogen in fuel cells. 1
This bill defines “renewable gas” as biogas produced from organic waste or other renewable resources organic waste or organic materials.
Why is Biogas Considered Low Carbon? Combustion of biogas produces carbon dioxide (CO2), just like the combustion of natural gas. However, the combustion of biogas destroys methane, a gas which is a much more potent GHG than is CO2. In addition, biogas can be used to displace the use of fossil fuels, such as natural gas, thereby further decreasing its carbon intensity.
Mind the Gap. There are many state programs that, directly or indirectly, encourage or the use of “renewable gas.” Utilities can meet the RPS through the use of biogas if produced from qualifying renewable resources. Recently enacted statute (SB 1122, Rubio, 2012) requires IOUs to collectively procure at least 250 MW of generation eligible for the RPS from bioenergy generation projects, including biogas projects. The CEC has invested more than $49 million in 13 biomethane feasibility, demonstration and production projects throughout the state. And biogas can be used to help satisfy the requirements of the ARB’s Low-Carbon Fuels Mandate, which requires a reduction of at least 10 percent in the carbon intensity of California's transportation fuels by 2020.
In addition, efforts are underway that should ease the further development and commercialization of “renewable gas.” The IOUs have been wary of injecting biogas into their natural gas pipelines for fear of introduction of contaminants that could damage the pipelines or harm human health. In response, the Legislature in 2012 enacted AB 1900 (Gatto). That bill directs the CPUC to identify landfill gas constituents, develop testing protocols for landfill gas injected into common carrier pipelines, adopt standards for biomethane to ensure pipeline safety and integrity, and adopt rules to ensure open access to the gas pipeline system. The CPUC is still in the process of completing this work.
The Legislature, also in 2012, enacted related legislation (AB 2196, Chesbro). That bill ensures that biogas qualifies for RPS credit, provided its production, delivery and use meet certain conditions.
The bill’s proponents, despite these various state programs supporting and encouraging biogas development and use, contend there is a gap in the state’s clean energy and climate policies. As evidence of that gap, the proponents point to the continued low use of renewable natural gas as a proportion of the state’s overall natural gas use, which produces about one-quarter of the state’s emissions of GHG. Proponents further contend that the state needs a statewide policy commitment that provides long-term certainty to the biogas market. The author intends this bill to provide that certainty.
Using the RPS as a model, this bill, in its current form, would establish a RGS that would require “gas sellers” to provide specific percentages of “renewable gas” to end use customers in California, according to the following schedule:
January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2019 – not less than 1 percent.
January 1, 2020, to December 31, 2022 – not less than 3 percent.
January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2024 – not less than 5 percent.
January 1, 2025, to December 31, 2029, and thereafter – not less than 10 percent.
The bill would task the ARB, in consultation with the CEC and CPUC, to adopt the RGS. The bill also includes language similar to existing statute, contained in 2012’s AB 2196, to ensure the environmental and economic benefits of the use of “renewable gas” accrue to California. The bill further directs ARB to adopt flexible compliance mechanisms and to develop an investment plan that directs any resulting monies to the state’s alternative fuel and energy program (the CEC-administered Alternative Fuel and Vehicle Technology Program) and related air-quality program (the ARB-administered Air Quality Improvement Program).
Proponents cite numerous benefits that they conclude will flow from successful implementation of the RGS. Those benefits include:
Additional reduction of GHG emissions.
Reduced landfilling of organic wastes.
Improved air quality and public health.
Reduction of wildfires and burning of agricultural waste.
Job creation.
Reduced dependence on fossil fuels, especially out-of-state natural gas.
Market certainty that drives down the cost of “renewable gas.”
The author has proposed amendments that recast the RGS from a relative-volume-based standard to a “carbon-intensity standard.” The main difference between the current version of the bill and the proposed amendments is a change in the compliance obligation. Under the amendments, a gas seller would be required to reduce the average carbon intensity of its natural gas sales, rather than provide specific percentages of “renewable gas” as part of its natural gas sales.
Too Much? According to the CEC, 358 megawatts (MW) is potentially available from new biogas development. Despite this potential, it is not clear there will be enough “renewable gas” available to meet the admittedly modest schedule required by this bill. Proponents believe the RGS will drive down the cost of “renewable gas” just as the bill’s model – the RPS – has driven down the cost of renewable electricity. However, shortages of “renewable gas” could drive up the cost of compliance significantly.
The RPS legislation includes numerous cost-containment “off ramps”. These off ramps allow RPS-covered entities to be excused from their RPS obligations if the cost of procuring electricity from renewable resources exceeds statutorily defined limits. The author and the committee may wish to amend the bill to include similar cost-containment “off ramps” to the RGS.
Too Soon? The bill directs ARB to adopt the RGS by June 30, 2016. Depending upon when the bill were to be signed by the Governor, that schedule might provide the ARB less than one year to develop and adopt the RGS. The author and committee may wish to delay the bill’s implementation schedule to allow ARB and the other state agencies sufficient time to comply with the implementation deadlines.
A Complicated, Shifting Policy Mix. California has robust clean-energy policies. For example, current statute requires the state to receive at least 33 percent of its electricity from renewable sources by 2020, and tasks the ARB with reducing the emissions of GHG from most economic sectors of the state, including electricity generation. Those policies are likely to morph and expand. Governor Brown has called for generating half of the state’s electricity from renewable resources and cutting petroleum use in cars and trucks by half, a goal many presume would be achieved by shifting a large portion of transportation fuel from petroleum-based sources to electricity. The Senate pro tem has proposed to codify these goals in SB 350, a bill under consideration in this committee. And Senator Pavley has introduced SB 32, which would require ARB to adopt a very ambitious GHG emissions limit for 2050. It is worth considering how this bill fits in to this complex, evolving clean-energy context.
The author and proponents accurately note that California cannot meet its GHG reduction targets, especially the targets envisioned in the Senate’s climate package, without significantly reducing GHG emissions from the natural gas sector. However, the ARB has, under existing law, broad authority to require a wide variety of GHG reduction measures, including, presumably a biogas standard like the RGS proposed by this bill. The committee should consider this bill in the context of that existing authority, as well as any expanded authority it is contemplating, as it evaluates the necessity and use of this bill.
Double Referral. Should this bill be approved by the committee, it will be re-referred to the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality for its consideration.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 360 (Cannella) would authorize the CPUC to consider providing the option to all gas corporations to engage in competitive bidding and direct investment in ratepayer financed biomethane collection equipment in California. The bill has been referred to this committee for consideration.
AB 1900 (Gatto, Chapter 602, Statutes of 2012) directs the CPUC to identify landfill gas constituents, develop testing protocols for landfill gas injected into common carrier pipelines, adopt standards for biomethane to ensure pipeline safety and integrity, and adopt rules to ensure open access to the gas pipeline system.
AB 2196 (Chesbro, Chapter 605, Statutes of 2012) ensures that biogas qualifies for RPS credit, provided its production, delivery and use meet certain conditions.
SB 1122 (Rubio, Chapter 612, Statutes of 2012) requires IOUs to collectively procure at least 250 MW of generation eligible for the RPS from bioenergy generation project, including biogas projects.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT:
American Biogas Council
Bioenergy Association of California
Biosynthetic Technologies
Clean Energy and Clean Energy Renewable Fuels
Eisenmann Corporation
Harvest Power, Inc.
Hitachi Zosen Inova U.S.A. LLC
Las Gallinas Valley Sanitary District
Organic Waste Systems
Phoenix Energy
TSS Consultants
OPPOSITION:
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Associations
California Dairies Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California League of Food Processors
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Poultry Federation
California Tomato Growers Association
Milk Producers Council
Nisei Farmers League
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Proponents contend the state needs a statewide “renewable gas” policy to provide certainty to the market. Such certainty will incentivize “renewable gas” development and innovation to bring down costs. Ultimately, proponents argue, expanded use of “renewable gas” will help to state meet it GHG reduction goals, improve public health through cleaner air, reduce the state’s dependence on fossil fuels, keep billions of dollars in state, and create jobs
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents primarily argue that this bill will increase industrial costs – such as the cost to process foods – by requiring the purchase of relatively expensive “renewable gas.” Opponents note that the state already has a robust clean-energy policy that encourages the use of biogas. Some opponents also contend that the RGS represents “double taxation,” in that they would pay a premium for “renewable gas” in addition to the premium they already must pay as part of the AB 32 cap-and-trade program to offset their natural gas use.
-- END --
1 2012 Bioenergy Action Plan (
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):