AB 1495: Teachers: evaluation.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-14
Existing law requires the State Board of Education to develop guidelines that school districts may use in the development of certain teach evaluation procedures and to distribute those guidelines to every school district.
This bill would require the development of those guidelines to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act.
Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that governing boards of school districts establish a uniform system of evaluation and assessment of the performance of all certificated personnel within each school district of the state. Existing law requires the governing board of each school district to establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study and to evaluate and assess certificated employee performance on a continuing basis as it reasonably relates to specified matters, including pupil progress, as provided. Existing law authorizes the governing board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
This bill would also require the governing board of each school district to evaluate and assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates to pupil achievement and pupil outcomes, if applicable, as provided. The bill would provide that evidence of actual pupil progress may include written reports from classroom observations and data from various sources, including state-adopted criterion referenced assessments. provide, if applicable, multiple measures of pupil progress, pupil academic growth, pupil achievement, and pupil outcomes as used for certain purposes of evaluating and assessing certificated employee performance may include specified sources.
The bill would require an employing authority to utilize use a minimum of 3 rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees, as provided.
By imposing additional duties on school districts, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires an evaluation to include recommendations, if necessary, as to areas of improvement in the performance of the employee. Existing law requires or authorizes certain things relating to the evaluation these evaluations to include a requirement that the employee participate in a specified program if a permanent certificated employee receives an unsatisfactory evaluation.
This bill would instead require or authorize these things relating to the evaluation require an employee, if the that employee receives one of the specified rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment. assessment, to participate in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers if the school district participates in that program. The bill would require, in order to endeavor to assess assist the employee in areas of improvement, the school district to, at minimum, consider the employees eligibility for professional development identified in the school district and applicable schools local control and accountability plan, and prioritize the employees eligibility for professional development, as provided. By expanding the duties of a school district, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that governing boards of school districts establish a uniform system of evaluation and assessment of the performance of all certificated personnel within each school district of the state. Existing law requires the governing board of each school district to establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study and to evaluate and assess certificated employee performance on a continuing basis as it reasonably relates to specified matters, including pupil progress, as provided. Existing law authorizes the governing board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
This bill would also require the governing board of each school district to evaluate and assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates to pupil achievement and pupil outcomes, if applicable, as provided. The bill would provide that evidence of actual pupil progress may include written reports from classroom observations and data from various sources, including state-adopted criterion referenced assessments.
The bill would require an employing authority to utilize a minimum of 3 rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees, as provided.
By imposing additional duties on school districts, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires an evaluation to include recommendations, if necessary, as to areas of improvement in the performance of the employee. Existing law requires or authorizes certain things relating to the evaluation if a permanent certificated employee receives an unsatisfactory evaluation.
This bill would instead require or authorize these things relating to the evaluation if the employee receives one of the rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment. The bill would require, in order to endeavor to assess the employee in areas of improvement, the school district to, at minimum, prioritize the employees eligibility for professional development, as provided. By expanding the duties of a school district, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that governing boards of school districts establish a uniform system of evaluation and assessment of the performance of all certificated personnel within each school district of the state. Existing law requires the governing board of each school district to establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study and to evaluate and assess certificated employee performance on a continuing basis as it reasonably relates to specified matters. Existing law authorizes the governing board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
The State Board of Education state board shall develop guidelines which that school districts may use in the development of teacher evaluation procedures pursuant to Article 11 (commencing with Section 44660) of Chapter 1 of Part 25 of Division 3 of this title, and shall distribute such the guidelines to every school district. The development of these guidelines shall comply with the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
SEC. 2.Article 14 (commencing with Section 44672) is added to Chapter 3 of Part 25 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code, to read:14.Common Evaluation System Provisions44672.If applicable, multiple measures of pupil progress, pupil academic growth, pupil achievement, and pupil outcomes as used in this chapter for purposes of evaluating and assessing certificated employee performance may include, but shall not be limited to, any of the following sources:
(a)State-adopted formative and summative criterion referenced assessments.
(b)School district, school, or department-developed assessments.
(c)Curriculum-based and end-of-course assessments.
(d)Pretest and posttest data.
(e)Interim, periodic, benchmark, and formative assessments.
(f)English language proficiency assessments.
(g)Assessments measuring progress in an individualized education program.
(h)Advance placement, international baccalaureate, and college preparedness examinations.
(i)A-G coursework completion.
(j)Industry-recognized career technical education assessments and program completion.
(k)Portfolios of pupils work, projects, and performances redacted of personally identifiable pupil information.
(l)Surveys from parents, if approved in advance by the certificated employee.
(m)Surveys from pupils, if approved in advance by the certificated employee.
(n)Written reports from classroom observations.
(o)Progress on outcomes described in the local control and accountability plan pursuant to paragraphs (4) and (8) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060.
44673.(a)The employing authority shall use a minimum of three rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees pursuant to this chapter.
(b)At least two rating levels shall identify certificated employees who meet either of the following:
(1)Require more development and growth to achieve a rating of satisfactory or meeting standards, and who are required to participate and receive appropriate additional support, training, and assistance.
(2)Demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct, unsuccessfully participated in mandatory corrective action, refused to participate in required additional support and training, or are subject to mandatory reassignment, suspension, or adverse action resulting from charges pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4. This rating level shall be applicable to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 44932.
44674.(a)If a school district participates in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established pursuant to Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500), a certificated employee who receives a rating in either of the levels described by subdivision (b) of Section 44673 on an evaluation performed pursuant to Section 44664 shall participate in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in endeavoring to assist the employee as mandated by Article 11 (commencing with Section 44660) and Article 13 (commencing with Section 44670), the school district shall, at a minimum, consider the employees eligibility for professional development identified in the school district and applicable schools local control and accountability plan, and prioritize the employees eligibility for any professional development supported by one-time or ongoing funds appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act, including professional development in the state academic content standards adopted by the state board, and training on services to English learners to access the common core academic content standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605.8 and the English language development standards adopted pursuant to former Section 60811.3, as that section read on June 30, 2013, or Section 60811.4.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 44662 of the Education Code is amended to read:44662.(a)The governing board of a school district shall establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study.
(b)The governing board of a school district shall evaluate and assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates to:
(1)The progress of pupils toward the standards established pursuant to subdivision (a) and, if applicable, pupil achievement and pupil outcomes described in the local control and accountability plan pursuant to paragraphs (4) and (8) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060, and the state adopted academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion referenced assessments.
(2)The instructional techniques and strategies used by the employee.
(3)The employees adherence to curricular objectives.
(4)The establishment and maintenance of a suitable learning environment, within the scope of the employees responsibilities.
(c)The governing board of a school district shall establish and define job responsibilities for certificated noninstructional personnel, including, but not limited to, supervisory and administrative personnel, whose responsibilities cannot be evaluated appropriately under the provisions of subdivision (b) and shall evaluate and assess the performance of those noninstructional certificated employees as it reasonably relates to the fulfillment of those responsibilities.
(d)Results of an employees participation in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established by Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500) shall be made available as part of the evaluation conducted pursuant to this section.
(e)The evaluation and assessment of certificated employee performance pursuant to this section shall not include the use of publishers norms established by standardized tests.
(f)Nothing in this section shall be construed as in any way limiting the authority of the governing board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
(g)For purposes of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), evidence of actual pupil progress may include, but shall not be limited to, written reports from classroom observations and data from any or all of the following:
(1)State-adopted criterion referenced assessments.
(2)District, school, or department-developed assessments.
(3)Curriculum-based and end-of-course assessments.
(4)Pretest and posttest data.
(5)Interim, periodic, benchmark, and formative assessments.
(6)English language proficiency assessments.
(7)Assessments measuring progress in an individualized education program.
(8)Advance placement, international baccalaureate and college preparedness examinations.
(9)A-G coursework completion.
(10)Industry-recognized career technical education assessments and program completion.
(11)Portfolios of pupils work and projects and of live and recorded pupil performances.
(12)Surveys from parents.
SEC. 2.Section 44663 of the Education Code is amended to read:44663.(a)The employing authority shall utilize a minimum of three rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees pursuant to this article.
(b)At least two rating levels shall identify certificated employees who meet either of the following:
(1)Require more development and growth to achieve a rating of satisfactory or meeting standards, and who are to participate and receive appropriate additional support, training, and assistance pursuant to Section 44664.
(2)Demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct, unsuccessfully participated in mandatory corrective action, refused to participate in required additional support and training pursuant to Section 44664, or are subject to mandatory reassignment, suspension, or adverse action resulting from charges pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4.
(c)The evaluation and assessment made pursuant to this article shall be reduced to writing and a copy of the evaluation and assessment shall be transmitted to the certificated employee not later than 30 days before the last schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the governing board for the school year in which the evaluation takes place. The certificated employee shall have the right to initiate a written reaction or response to the evaluation. This response shall become a permanent attachment to the employees personnel file. Before the last schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the governing board for the school year, a meeting shall be held between the certificated employee and the evaluator to discuss the evaluation.
(d)In the case of a certificated noninstructional employee, who is employed on a 12-month basis, the evaluation and assessment made pursuant to this article shall be reduced to writing and a copy of the evaluation and assessment shall be transmitted to the certificated employee no later than June 30 of the year in which the evaluation and assessment is made. A certificated noninstructional employee, who is employed on a 12-month basis shall have the right to initiate a written reaction or response to the evaluation. This response shall become a permanent attachment to the employees personnel file. Before July 30 of the year in which the evaluation and assessment takes place, a meeting shall be held between the certificated employee and the evaluator to discuss the evaluation and assessment.
SEC. 3.Section 44664 of the Education Code is amended to read:44664.(a)Evaluation and assessment of the performance of each certificated employee shall be made on a continuing basis as follows:
(1)At least once each school year for probationary personnel.
(2)At least every other year for personnel with permanent status.
(3)At least every five years for personnel with permanent status who have been employed at least 10 years with the school district, are highly qualified, if those personnel occupy positions that are required to be filled by a highly qualified professional by the federal No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 6301 et seq.), as defined in Section 7801 of Title 20 of the United States Code, and whose previous evaluation rated the employee as meeting or exceeding standards, if the evaluator and certificated employee being evaluated agree. The certificated employee or the evaluator may withdraw consent at any time.
(b)The evaluation shall include recommendations, if necessary, as to areas of improvement in the performance of the employee. If an employee is not performing his or her duties in a satisfactory manner according to the standards prescribed by the governing board, the employing authority shall notify the employee in writing of that fact and describe the unsatisfactory performance. The employing authority shall thereafter confer with the employee making specific recommendations as to areas of improvement in the employees performance and endeavor to assist the employee in his or her performance. If a permanent certificated employee has received an evaluation rating in either of the levels described in subdivision (b) of Section 44663, the employing authority shall annually evaluate the employee until the employee achieves a positive evaluation or is separated from the district.
(c)An evaluation performed pursuant to this article that contains a rating of an employees performance described in subdivision (b) of Section 44663 in the area of teaching methods, instruction, or progress of pupils towards standards of expected pupil achievement, may include the requirement that the certificated employee shall, as determined necessary by the employing authority, participate in a program designed to improve appropriate areas of the employees performance and to further pupil achievement and the instructional objectives of the employing authority.
(d)If a district participates in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established pursuant to Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500), any certificated employee who receives a rating in either of the levels described by subdivision (b) of Section 44663 on an evaluation performed pursuant to this section shall participate in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers.
(e)Notwithstanding any other law, in endeavoring to assist the employee pursuant to subdivision (b), the district shall, at a minimum, prioritize the employees eligibility for professional development identified in the district and applicable schools local control and accountability plan, and any professional development supported by one time or ongoing funds appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act, including professional development in the state academic content standards adopted by the state board, and training on services to English learners to access the common core academic content standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605.8 and the English language development standards adopted pursuant to former Section 60811.3, as that section read on June 30, 2013, or Section 60811.4.
(f)Hourly and temporary hourly certificated employees, other than those employed in adult education classes who are excluded by the provisions of Section 44660, and substitute teachers may be excluded from this section at the discretion of the governing board.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)The governing board of a school district shall establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study.
(b)The governing board of a school district shall evaluate and assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates to:
(1)The progress of pupils toward the standards established pursuant to subdivision (a) and, if applicable, pupil achievement and pupil outcomes described in the local control and accountability plan pursuant to paragraphs (4) and (8) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060, and the state adopted academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion referenced assessments.
(2)The instructional techniques and strategies used by the employee.
(3)The employees adherence to curricular objectives.
(4)The establishment and maintenance of a suitable learning environment, within the scope of the employees responsibilities.
(c)The governing board of a school district shall establish and define job responsibilities for certificated noninstructional personnel, including, but not limited to, supervisory and administrative personnel, whose responsibilities cannot be evaluated appropriately under the provisions of subdivision (b) and shall evaluate and assess the performance of those noninstructional certificated employees as it reasonably relates to the fulfillment of those responsibilities.
(d)Results of an employees participation in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established by Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500) shall be made available as part of the evaluation conducted pursuant to this section.
(e)The evaluation and assessment of certificated employee performance pursuant to this section shall not include the use of publishers norms established by standardized tests.
(f)Nothing in this section shall be construed as in any way limiting the authority of the governing board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
(g)For purposes of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), evidence of actual pupil progress may include, but shall not be limited to, written reports from classroom observations and data from any or all of the following:
(1)State-adopted criterion referenced assessments.
(2)District, school, or department-developed assessments.
(3)Curriculum-based and end-of-course assessments.
(4)Pretest and posttest data.
(5)Interim, periodic, benchmark, and formative assessments.
(6)English language proficiency assessments.
(7)Assessments measuring progress in an individualized education program.
(8)Advance placement, international baccalaureate and college preparedness examinations.
(9)A-G coursework completion.
(10)Industry-recognized career technical education assessments and program completion.
(11)Portfolios of pupils work and projects and of live and recorded pupil performances.
(12)Surveys from parents.
SEC. 2.Section 44663 of the Education Code is amended to read:44663.(a)The employing authority shall utilize a minimum of three rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees pursuant to this article.
(b)At least two rating levels shall identify certificated employees who meet either of the following:
(1)Require more development and growth to achieve a rating of satisfactory or meeting standards, and who are to participate and receive appropriate additional support, training, and assistance pursuant to Section 44664.
(2)Demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct, unsuccessfully participated in mandatory corrective action, refused to participate in required additional support and training pursuant to Section 44664, or are subject to mandatory reassignment, suspension, or adverse action resulting from charges pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4.
(a)Evaluation
(c)The evaluation and assessment made pursuant to this article shall be reduced to writing and a copy thereof of the evaluation and assessment shall be transmitted to the certificated employee not later than 30 days before the last schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the governing board for the school year in which the evaluation takes place. The certificated employee shall have the right to initiate a written reaction or response to the evaluation. This response shall become a permanent attachment to the employees personnel file. Before the last schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the governing board for the school year, a meeting shall be held between the certificated employee and the evaluator to discuss the evaluation.
(b)
(d)In the case of a certificated noninstructional employee, who is employed on a 12-month basis, the evaluation and assessment made pursuant to this article shall be reduced to writing and a copy thereof of the evaluation and assessment shall be transmitted to the certificated employee no later than June 30 of the year in which the evaluation and assessment is made. A certificated noninstructional employee, who is employed on a 12-month basis shall have the right to initiate a written reaction or response to the evaluation. This response shall become a permanent attachment to the employees personnel file. Before July 30 of the year in which the evaluation and assessment takes place, a meeting shall be held between the certificated employee and the evaluator to discuss the evaluation and assessment.
SEC. 3.Section 44664 of the Education Code is amended to read:44664.(a)Evaluation and assessment of the performance of each certificated employee shall be made on a continuing basis as follows:
(1)At least once each school year for probationary personnel.
(2)At least every other year for personnel with permanent status.
(3)At least every five years for personnel with permanent status who have been employed at least 10 years with the school district, are highly qualified, if those personnel occupy positions that are required to be filled by a highly qualified professional by the federal No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 6301, 6301 et seq.), as defined in 20 U.S.C. Sec. 7801, Section 7801 of Title 20 of the United States Code, and whose previous evaluation rated the employee as meeting or exceeding standards, if the evaluator and certificated employee being evaluated agree. The certificated employee or the evaluator may withdraw consent at any time.
(b)The evaluation shall include recommendations, if necessary, as to areas of improvement in the performance of the employee. If an employee is not performing his or her duties in a satisfactory manner according to the standards prescribed by the governing board, the employing authority shall notify the employee in writing of that fact and describe the unsatisfactory performance. The employing authority shall thereafter confer with the employee making specific recommendations as to areas of improvement in the employees performance and endeavor to assist the employee in his or her performance. If any a permanent certificated employee has received an unsatisfactory evaluation an evaluation rating in either of the levels described in subdivision (b) of Section 44663, the employing authority shall annually evaluate the employee until the employee achieves a positive evaluation or is separated from the district.
(c)Any An evaluation performed pursuant to this article which that contains an unsatisfactory a rating of an employees performance described in subdivision (b) of Section 44663 in the area of teaching methods or methods, instruction, or progress of pupils towards standards of expected pupil achievement, may include the requirement that the certificated employee shall, as determined necessary by the employing authority, participate in a program designed to improve appropriate areas of the employees performance and to further pupil achievement and the instructional objectives of the employing authority. If
(d)If a district participates in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established pursuant to Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500), any certificated employee who receives an unsatisfactory a rating in either of the levels described by subdivision (b) of Section 44663 on an evaluation performed pursuant to this section shall participate in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers.
(e)Notwithstanding any other law, in endeavoring to assist the employee pursuant to subdivision (b), the district shall, at a minimum, prioritize the employees eligibility for professional development identified in the district and applicable schools local control and accountability plan, and any professional development supported by one time or ongoing funds appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act, including professional development in the state academic content standards adopted by the state board, and training on services to English learners to access the common core academic content standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605.8 and the English language development standards adopted pursuant to former Section 60811.3, as that section read on June 30, 2013, or Section 60811.4.
(d)
(f)Hourly and temporary hourly certificated employees, other than those employed in adult education classes who are excluded by the provisions of Section 44660, and substitute teachers may be excluded from the provisions of this section at the discretion of the governing board.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)The governing board of each a school district shall establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level in each area of study.
(b)The governing board of each a school district shall evaluate and assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates to:
(1)The progress of pupils toward the standards established pursuant to subdivision (a) and, if applicable, the state adopted academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion referenced assessments.
(2)The instructional techniques and strategies used by the employee.
(3)The employees adherence to curricular objectives.
(4)The establishment and maintenance of a suitable learning environment, within the scope of the employees responsibilities.
(c)The governing board of each a school district shall establish and define job responsibilities for certificated noninstructional personnel, including, but not limited to, supervisory and administrative personnel, whose responsibilities cannot be evaluated appropriately under the provisions of subdivision (b) and shall evaluate and assess the performance of those noninstructional certificated employees as it reasonably relates to the fulfillment of those responsibilities.
(d)Results of an employees participation in the California Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers established by Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 44500) shall be made available as part of the evaluation conducted pursuant to this section.
(e)The evaluation and assessment of certificated employee performance pursuant to this section shall not include the use of publishers norms established by standardized tests.
(f)Nothing in this section shall be construed as in any way limiting the authority of school district the governing boards board of a school district to develop and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or criteria.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Apr 15, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Apr 14, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 29, 2015 | Reconsideration. | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1495
Page 6
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
AB 1495
Weber – As Amended April 14, 2015
SUBJECT: Teachers: evaluation
SUMMARY: Adds new requirements to the certificated employee evaluation system, known as the Stull Act. Specifically, this bill:
Specifies, if applicable, multiple measures of pupil progress, pupil academic growth, pupil achievement, and pupil outcomes for purposes of evaluating and assessing certificated employee performance may include, but shall not be limited to, any of the following sources:
State-adopted formative and summative criterion referenced assessments.
School district, school, or department-developed assessments.
Curriculum-based and end-of-course assessments.
Pretest and posttest data.
Interim, periodic, benchmark, and formative assessments.
English language proficiency assessments.
Assessments measuring progress in an individualized education program.
Advance placement, international baccalaureate, and college preparedness examinations.
A-G coursework completion.
Industry-recognized career technical education assessments and program completion.
Portfolios of pupils’ work, projects, and performances redacted of personally identifiable pupil information.
Surveys from parents, if approved in advance by the certificated employee.
Surveys from pupils, if approved in advance by the certificated employee.
Written reports from classroom observations.
Progress on outcomes described in the local control and accountability plan.
Requires the employing authority to use a minimum of three rating levels of professional achievement for evaluation and assessment of certificated employees and requires at least two rating levels to identify certificated employees who meet either of the following:
Require more development and growth to achieve a rating of satisfactory or meeting standards, and who are required to participate and receive appropriate additional support, training, and assistance.
Demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct, unsuccessfully participated in mandatory corrective action, refused to participate in required additional support and training, or are subject to mandatory reassignment, suspension, or adverse action resulting from charges pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4. This rating level shall be applicable to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 44932.
Requires, if a school district participates in the California Peer Assistance and Review (PAR) Program for Teachers, a certificated employee who receives a rating in either of the levels described (#2 above) on an evaluation shall participate in PAR.
Specifies, notwithstanding any other law, in endeavoring to assist the employee as mandated, the school district shall, at a minimum, consider the employee’s eligibility for professional development identified in the school district and applicable school’s local control and accountability plan (LCAP), and prioritize the employee’s eligibility for any professional development supported by one-time or ongoing funds appropriated by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act, including professional development in the state academic content standards adopted by the state board, and training on services to English learners to access the common core academic content standards and the English language development standards.
Requires the guidelines developed by the State Board of Education (SBE) to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act.
EXISTING LAW:
Establishes the Stull Act, enacted in 1971, which governs certificated employee evaluations and requires school districts to evaluate and assess teacher performance as it reasonability relates to pupil performance on criterion referenced tests, teacher technique and strategies, curricular objectives, and the maintenance of a suitable learning environment. Specifies that in the development and adoption of evaluation guidelines and procedures, the governing board shall avail itself of the advice of the certificated instructional personnel in the district's organization of certificated personnel pursuant to collective bargaining statutes. Specifies that a school district may, by mutual agreement between the exclusive representative of the certificated employees of the school district and the governing board of the school district, include any objective standards from the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards or any objective standards from the California Standards for the Teaching Profession. Specifies that teacher evaluations shall be made on a continuing basis at least once each school year for probationary personnel; at least every other year for personnel with permanent status; and, at least every five years for personnel with permanent status who have been employed at least 10 years with the school district, are highly qualified, if those personnel occupy positions that are required to be filled by a highly qualified professional, and whose previous evaluation rated the employee as meeting or exceeding standards, if the evaluator and certificated employee being evaluated agree. Specifies that an employee who receives an unsatisfactory rating in the area of teaching methods or instruction may be required to participate in a program designed to improve appropriate areas of the employee's performance; and, requires if a school district participates in the Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers (PAR), employees who receive an unsatisfactory rating shall participate in PAR. (Education Code 44660 et. seq.)
Establishes the Peer Assistance and Review Program for Teachers (PAR) by authorizing school districts and the exclusive representative of the certificated employees to develop and implement the program locally. Specifies that assistance and review shall include multiple observations of a teacher during periods of classroom instruction. Specifies the program shall expect and strongly encourage a cooperative relationship between the consulting teacher and the principal with respect to the process of peer assistance and review. Specifies the school district shall provide sufficient staff development activities to assist a teacher to improve his or her teaching skills and knowledge. Specifies the final evaluation of a teacher's participation in the program shall be made available for placement in the personnel file of the teacher receiving assistance. (Education Code 44505)
FISCAL EFFECT: Legislative counsel has keyed this bill a state mandated local program.
COMMENTS: This bill adds requirements to the certificated employee evaluation system, known as the Stull Act.
According to the author, although California law has required the consideration of evidence of actual pupil progress in the evaluation and assessment of certificated staff job performance for over four decades, school district personnel continue to struggle with what measures of pupil progress are appropriate especially with the lack of state tests in specific grade levels or content areas. As a result of this confusion, a majority of California’s largest school districts do not comply with the law and fail to include any actual data from state or local measures or observations of actual pupil progress in the performance evaluations of certificated staff. Student learning is the most important outcome of the public education system and determining whether or not the system is successful and effective. What is at stake is every individual child’s constitutional right to an education and an equal educational opportunity to learn. Struggling teachers have classes with children struggling to learn. While focusing on student performance, the system must identify and help teachers needing improvement, which is not consistently done. With the recent major revisions to the public school finance system, it is important to have consistency in the evaluation and assessment of certificated staff job performance and add pupil achievement and pupil outcome goals delineated in the school’s LCAP to provide consistency with the Stull Act and resources available to help struggling staff.
SBE Guidelines: This bill requires the SBE guidelines on teacher evaluation to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). According to the SBE, the last known SBE guidelines on the Stull Act were created in 1972 and sent out to districts at that time. These guidelines created in 1972 pre-dated the APA. Essentially, this bill requires the SBE to re-draft the guidelines to comply with the APA. Existing law requires the SBE to distribute the guidelines to all districts in the state, but it is unclear whether the SBE would then be required to distribute the new guidelines to all districts in the state.
Research on Evaluation: Several research studies detail the essential principals and components of a strong teacher evaluation system. The National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality argues a strong evaluation system must: "involve teachers and stakeholders in developing the system; use multiple indicators; and give teachers opportunities to improve in the areas in which they score poorly." Likewise, the New Teacher Project states "evaluations should provide all teachers with regular feedback that helps them grow as professionals, no matter how long they have been in the classroom. The primary purpose of evaluations should not be punitive. Good evaluations identify excellent teachers and help teachers of all skill levels understand how they can improve."
Performance Bands: This bill requires the state prescribed evaluation system to use three performance bands and the bottom two levels are identified as:
Require more development and growth to achieve a rating of satisfactory or meeting standards, and who are required to participate and receive appropriate additional support, training, and assistance.
Demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct, unsuccessfully participated in mandatory corrective action, refused to participate in required additional support and training, or are subject to mandatory reassignment, suspension, or adverse action resulting from charges pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4. This rating level shall be applicable to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 44932," which is unsatisfactory performance in the dismissal process.
The committee should consider whether the two bottom levels specified in the bill are the most effective performance level descriptors that should be used state-wide.
Unsatisfactory Conduct: This bill uses a new term "unsatisfactory conduct," which is not used in the current evaluation or dismissal process. Although the bill states that this rating level shall be applicable to the term "unsatisfactory performance," it is unclear what this new term means, how it relates to unprofessional conduct or how it is "applicable" to unprofessional conduct. The existing dismissal process refers to terms such as unsatisfactory performance, unprofessional conduct and immoral conduct but does not use the term unsatisfactory conduct. The committee should consider whether creating a new term could cause confusion in the existing dismissal process and how the evaluation system aligns to the dismissal process.
It is also unclear whether an employee who is included in the definition of unsatisfactory performance or conduct because they were suspended or served with dismissal charges would be ranked in the bottom ranking forever. It is unclear from the bill language whether suspensions from 10 years ago would require an employee to be designated "unsatisfactory performance or conduct." The committee should consider whether this definition is appropriate for the bottom ranking of the evaluation system.
Peer Assistance and Review (PAR): This bill specifies that teachers who receive one of the two lowest ratings on their evaluation (those requiring more development and those who demonstrate unsatisfactory performance or conduct), if a school district has a PAR program in place, they must refer those teachers to the PAR program for improvement. The bill does not specify the process if a teacher continues to receive unsatisfactory evaluations after the PAR program is complete. It is unclear whether school districts should begin dismissal proceedings, or provide further instructional support for the teacher.
Lengthening the Dismissal Process: This bill requires that all employees who receive an "unsatisfactory performance or conduct" rating on the evaluation system to be referred to PAR, if the district has a PAR program. Because the definition of "unsatisfactory performance or conduct" includes suspension or adverse action brought from dismissal charges, it appears that this bill would require employees who have been served with dismissal charges to be referred to PAR. This would lengthen the dismissal process quite substantially and it is unclear whether PAR is the appropriate type of intervention needed for an employee who has been suspended or has had dismissal charges brought against them.
Parent and Student Surveys: This bill authorizes the use of surveys from parents and pupils in certificated employee evaluations, if approved in advance by the employee. The committee should consider whether it is appropriate to include surveys from parents and students in certificated employee evaluations. The committee should consider whether it is possible for a particularly "tough" teacher that assigns robust homework to receive negative survey comments, when they are a very effective teacher and how this would impact the overall evaluation of that teacher. Likewise, if an administrator recently suspended students, could their surveys from parents and students be skewed?
Professional Development: This bill requires districts, when assisting teachers determined to be in need of improvement, to consider the employees eligibility for professional development (PD) in the district's LCAP and prioritize the employees eligibility for PD funded in the Budget Act. This includes PD in the state academic content standards adopted by the SBE, and training on services to English learners to access the common core academic content standards and the English language development (ELD) standards. The committee should consider whether prioritizing specific types of PD that is funded in the Budget act is the most efficient way to improve educational practice for all struggling teachers. For example, if a teacher needs assistance with classroom management, would training related to the academic content standards and ELD standards be the highest priority for this teacher?
Charter Schools: This bill requires all traditional public schools in the state to adopt the changes to the teacher evaluation system, but the committee should note that the Stull Act and the changes made in this bill do not apply to charter schools. The committee should consider whether charter schools teachers should be left out of this opportunity for evaluations and support.
Arguments in Support: EdVoice supports the bill and states, "AB 1495 requires at least three rating levels and de-links the simply “needs more development” rating level from the “unsatisfactory” level that could lead to adverse action. And, in requiring two rating bands below “satisfactory,” AB 1495 helps provide opportunity to more carefully identify struggling employees and offer appropriate remedial development and assistance, including professional development already identified in a district’s LCAP, without fear of adverse action and possible dismissal. AB 1495 also establishes priority eligibility for support from professional development resources appropriated in the annual state Budget Act, thereby connecting local evaluation system outcomes with available resources in a meaningful way to support employees who can benefit the most from professional growth to become truly effective educators and support the academic achievement of all of their students."
Arguments in Opposition: California Teachers Association opposes the bill and states, "CTA believes a mutually designed comprehensive ongoing personnel evaluation system with procedural guarantees and due process in every school system should be supported. Evaluations should provide all teachers with regular feedback that helps them grow as professionals, no matter how long they have been in the classroom. Evaluations should give schools the information they need to build the strongest possible instructional teams, and help districts hold school leaders accountable for supporting each teacher's development. Most importantly, they should focus everyone in a school system, from teachers to the superintendent, on what matters most: keeping every student on track to graduate from high school ready for success in college or a career....AB 1495 (Weber) proposes changes to the Stull Act which do not address these complex issues."
Related Legislation: AB 575 (O'Donnell & Atkins) from 2015, which is pending in the Assembly, would require the governing board of each school district and the governing body of each charter school to adopt and implement a best practices teacher and administrator evaluation system by July 1, 2018.
AB 1078 (Olsen) from 2015, which is pending in the Assembly, would make changes to the certificated employee evaluation system, known as the Stull Act.
SB 499 (Liu & DeLeon) from 2015, which is pending in the Senate, would require the governing board of each school district to adopt and implement a best practices teacher and administrator evaluation system by July 1, 2016.
AB 430 (Olsen) from 2013, which was held by the author in the Assembly Education Committee, would have established the Teacher Professional Growth Plan, as specified.
AB 5 (Fuentes) from 2009, which was held by the author on the Senate Floor, would have required the governing board of each school district to adopt and implement a best practices teacher evaluation system, as specified.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CalChamber
Children Now
Educators 4 Excellence
EdVoice
Students Matter
StudentsFirst
Teach Plus
Opposition
California Teachers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):