AB 1616: Alarm companies: liability: false alarm.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-07-31
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or an alarm agent from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or an alarm agent from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or an alarm agent from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or contractor an alarm agent from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator. operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or contractor from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or contractor from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error or error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or an alarm company operator.
The Alarm Company Act provides for the regulation, by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services within the Department of Consumer Affairs, of alarm company operators and alarm agents. The act provides that it does not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county from, among other things, enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
This bill would prohibit an alarm company operator or contractor from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error or improper installation by a contractor or an alarm company operator.
The Optometry Practice Act provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of optometry by the 11-member State Board of Optometry within the Department of Consumer Affairs. Under the act, members of the board hold office for a term of 4 years and serve until the appointment and qualification of a successor or until a year after the expiration of the term for which the member was appointed, whichever occurs first.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that term of office provision.The Optometry Practice Act provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of optometry by the 11-member State Board of Optometry within the Department of Consumer Affairs. Under the act, members of the board hold office for a term of 4 years and serve until the appointment and qualification of a successor or until a year after the expiration of the term for which the member was appointed, whichever occurs first.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that term of office provision.
(a)The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(1)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(2)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(3)(A)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(B)An alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
(4)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
(b)This section shall not be construed to affect the authority of a city, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce ordinances requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
(c)Except as otherwise required to comply with this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance enacted by the city, county, or city and county.
(a)The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(1)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(2)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(3)(A)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(B)An alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
(4)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
(b)This section shall not be construed to affect the authority of a city, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce ordinances requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
(c)Except as otherwise required to comply with this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance enacted by the city, county, or city and county.
(a)The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(1)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(2)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(3)(A)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(B)An alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
(4)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
(b)This section shall not be construed to affect the authority of a local government city, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce policies ordinances requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
(c)Except as otherwise required to comply with this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance enacted by the city, county, or city and county.
(a)The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(1)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(2)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(3)(A)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(B)An alarm company operator or a contractor an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor provided or installed by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator. operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
(4)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
(b)This section shall not be construed to affect the authority of a local government to adopt and enforce policies requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
(b)(c)Except as otherwise required to comply with this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance enacted by the city, county, or city and county.
CORRECTIONS: HeadingLast amended date.(a)The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(a)(1)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(b)(2)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(c)(1)(3)(A)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(2)(B)An alarm company operator or a contractor shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or an alarm company operator.
(d)(4)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
(b)Except as otherwise required to comply with this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance enacted by the city, county, or city and county.
The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(a)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(b)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(c)(1)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(2)An alarm company operator or a contractor shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error or error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or an alarm company operator.
(d)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
The provisions of this chapter shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
(a)Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit.
(b)Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration.
(c)(1)Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses.
(2)An alarm company operator or a contractor shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error or improper installation by a contractor or alarm company operator.
(d)Requiring persons who own, lease, rent, or otherwise possess an alarm system to obtain a permit to operate the alarm system.
SECTION 1.Section 3013 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:3013.(a)Each member of the board shall hold office for a term of four years and serve until the appointment and qualification of his or her successor, or until one year has elapsed since the expiration of the term for which the member was appointed, whichever occurs first.(b)Vacancies occurring shall be filled by appointment for the unexpired term.(c)The Governor shall appoint three of the public members, five members qualified as provided in Section 3011, and the registered dispensing member as provided in Section 3010.5. The Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each appoint a public member.(d)No board member serving between January 1, 2000, and June 1, 2002, inclusive, shall be eligible for reappointment.(e)For initial appointments made on or after January 1, 2003, one of the public members appointed by the Governor and two of the professional members shall serve terms of one year. One of the public members appointed by the Governor and two of the professional members shall serve terms of three years. The remaining public member appointed by the Governor and the remaining two professional members shall serve terms of four years. The public members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each serve for a term of four years.(f)The initial appointment of a registered dispensing optician, spectacle lens dispenser, or contact lens dispenser member shall replace the optometrist member whose term expired on June 1, 2015.(g)The amendments to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to appointments made on or after January 1, 2016.(a)Each member of the board shall hold office for a term of four years, years and shall serve until the appointment and qualification of his or her successor successor, or until one year shall have has elapsed since the expiration of the term for which he or she the member was appointed, whichever first occurs. occurs first.
(b)Vacancies occurring shall be filled by appointment for the unexpired term.
(c)The Governor shall appoint three of the public members, five members qualified as provided in Section 3011, and the registered dispensing member as provided in Section 3010.5. The Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each appoint a public member.
(d)No board member serving between January 1, 2000, and June 1, 2002, inclusive, shall be eligible for reappointment.
(e)For initial appointments made on or after January 1, 2003, one of the public members appointed by the Governor and two of the professional members shall serve terms of one year. One of the public members appointed by the Governor and two of the professional members shall serve terms of three years. The remaining public member appointed by the Governor and the remaining two professional members shall serve terms of four years. The public members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly shall each serve for a term of four years.
(f)The initial appointment of a registered dispensing optician, spectacle lens dispenser, or contact lens dispenser member shall replace the optometrist member whose term expired on June 1, 2015.
(g)The amendments to this section by the act adding this subdivision shall apply to appointments made on or after January 1, 2016.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 31, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 157, Statutes of 2017. |
| Jul 31, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 21, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Jul 17, 2017 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 2569.). |
| Jul 13, 2017 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after July 15 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Jul 13, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jul 6, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jul 5, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 5). |
| Jun 20, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 15, 2017 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Measure version as amended on June 12 corrected. |
| Jun 12, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 8, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| May 18, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 18, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 71. Noes 0. Page 1613.) |
| May 9, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 4, 2017 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (May 2). |
| Apr 27, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Apr 26, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 22, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Mar 21, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 20, 2017 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 19, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 21. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 17, 2017 | AB 1616 NAZARIAN Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 13, 2017 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB1616 Nazarian | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 5, 2017 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2017 | AB 1616 NAZARIAN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2017 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1616
Author:(Nazarian)
As Amended Ver:June 20, 2017
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 71-0 | (May 18, 2017) | SENATE: | 39-0 | (July 13, 2017) |
Original Committee Reference: B. & P.
SUMMARY: Specifies that an alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator, defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or alarm company operator, or defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
The Senate amendments:
- Clarify that the provisions of this bill shall not be construed to affect the authority of a local government to adopt and enforce policies requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
- Make technical and clarifying changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by ADT Security Services. According to the author, "False alarm fees assigned to the user are an effective way to encourage responsible use of alarm equipment. [This bill] aims to ensure consistency in the imposition of false alarm fees throughout California by codifying current practice. It provides that local jurisdictions apply false alarm fees and penalties on the permittee, not on the alarm system monitoring company, except in cases where the false alarm is attributed to error by the alarm system monitoring company or its installer. This bill would not affect the discretion of local governments in choosing what false alarm fee they adopt. It is simply a measure to ensure that emergency resources are directed to actual emergencies."
Background. Existing law authorizes cities and counties to enact ordinances governing false alarms generated by security alarm systems. This bill seeks to prohibit local governments from imposing a false alarm fee on the alarm company operator or a contractor unless the false alarm is attributable to alarm company error or improper installation by a contractor.
Alarm Systems. A security alarm system is a set of devices arranged to detect an intruder or other hazard, such as fire or flood. Generally, there are two types of security alarm systems available to consumers and businesses, local and monitored alarms.
A local alarm is limited to onsite sirens or lights, mainly designed to deter intruders and alert anyone in the area. A local alarm does not send a signal to law enforcement or other responders, but may still be subject to public nuisance ordinances limiting noise and length of time. For example, some ordinances prohibit sirens that sound like emergency responders or disaster warning systems.
A monitored alarm system is typically a local alarm that is also connected to a central (or monitoring) station. A central station is usually an alarm provider who monitors the system and signals a responder if a hazard is detected (such as local law enforcement). A signal from an alarm system or central station to local law enforcement is similar to a 911 call — the signal indicates an ongoing emergency requiring immediate assistance. Therefore, frequent false alarms strain the resources of local governments.
False Alarm Ordinances. In an effort to reduce false alarms, many cities, counties, and cities and counties, enact ordinances regulating false alarms. According to the author, "False alarms trigger an emergency response when in fact no emergency has occurred. They tax the resources of police, fire, and emergency personnel, keeping them from responding to actual emergencies. Excessive false alarms increase costs for taxpayers, security service providers, and users, requiring additional personnel to respond to alarms."
While many false alarm ordinances contain similar elements, specific details vary by locality. In the City and County of San Francisco, The Police Emergency Alarm Ordinance requires, among other things, alarm system users to obtain an alarm system license by registering their systems with the City and County (San Francisco, Police Code Article 37, Sections 3700-3722). The ordinance also imposes various duties and penalties on the alarm user and the alarm company designed to deter false alarms.
For example, the San Francisco ordinance requires alarm users to utilize various preventive measures (such as proper maintenance). It also establishes an escalating false alarm fee schedule. The schedule assesses no penalty for the first false alarm, but penalizes the user $100 for the second and adds $50 to the previous penalty for each additional false alarm in a calendar year.
San Francisco also requires the companies to attempt to verify most types alarm signals before requesting a law enforcement response (such as calling the alarm user to determine the existence of an emergency). If the alarm company fails to verify an alarm, the alarm company must pay a fee to the Tax Collector.
The City of Los Angeles has a similar ordinance (Los Angeles Municipal Code, Chapter 10, Article 3, Division 8, Section 103.206), except that it does not waive the first false alarm penalty and makes it a misdemeanor for an alarm company operator to request service from the Los Angeles Police Department unless it has made two attempts to verify the need for service.
Fines for Failure to Verify. Like the City and County San Francisco and the City of Los Angeles, many local governments require an alarm company to at least attempt to verify an emergency before calling the local police department. While some local governments choose to impose heavier penalties on the alarm users for false alarms, others may choose to require greater diligence from the alarm companies.
Currently, the city of Fontana requires actual verification and establishes fines for alarm companies that call before verifying false alarms or call under the pretense of a verified call (Fontana Municipal Code, Chapter 22, Article 4, Sections 22-116—22-132). The City of Chico enacted a similar ordinance in 2014. However, "the adopted ordinance was immediately challenged by legal [counsel] representing the alarm system industry" (Ashley Gebb, Chico City Council to consider changes to false alarm ordinance (2015), Chico Enterprise-Record). The ordinance now allows for attempted verification and fines the user instead of the alarm company (Chico Municipal Code, Title 5, Chapter 5.40, Section 5.40.10-5.40.150).
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
ADT Security Services (sponsor) writes in support, "ADT supports efforts to meaningfully reduce false alarms, including the establishment of false alarm reduction programs created at the local level that encourage proper use of alarm systems and fine users for excessive false alarms. Studies have shown that, in general, 80% of false alarms are generated by 20% of alarm users. Fining chronic misusers of alarm systems can dramatically reduce the number of false alarms."
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0001130
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 1616
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/5/17
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara, Moorlach
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/18/17 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill provides that an alarm company operator or agent is not liable for false alarms not caused by their own error.
Existing law:
- Allows a city to "make and enforce within its limits, all local, police, sanitary and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws."
- Regulates alarm systems and alarm companies under the Alarm Company Act (SB 673, Sieroty, 1982), as follows:
- Creates the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (bureau) within the Department of Consumer Affairs to oversee alarm companies by issuing licenses to alarm company operators and alarm agents (persons that sell, maintain, or operate alarm systems on behalf of an alarm company operator) to ensure that they meet minimum standards and qualifications.
- Allows a city or county, under its police power, to enact ordinances that govern false alarm activations and responses or that require:
- Alarm company operators to obtain a business license,
- Alarm agents or alarm company operators to register with the jurisdiction, or
- Alarm system users to obtain a permit to operate the system.
This bill:
- Provides that an alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to:
- Alarm company operator error;
- Improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator;
- Defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or alarm company operator, or;
- Defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
- States that the provisions of this bill shall not be construed to require the bureau to adjudicate a cause of action between a city, county, or city and county regarding liability for penalties, except as otherwise provided by law.
- States that this bill shall not be construed to affect the authority of a city, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce ordinances requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
Background
Alarm company regulation. A security alarm system is a set of devices arranged to detect an intruder or other hazard, such as fire or flood. Generally, there are two types of security alarm systems available to consumers and businesses, local and monitored alarms. A local alarm is limited to onsite sirens or lights, mainly designed to deter intruders and alert anyone in the area. A local alarm does not send a signal to law enforcement or other responders, but may still be subject to public nuisance ordinances limiting noise and length of time. A monitored alarm system is typically a local alarm that is also connected to a central (or monitoring) station. A central station is usually an alarm provider who monitors the system and signals a responder if a hazard is detected (such as local law enforcement). A signal from an alarm system or central station to local law enforcement is similar to a 911 call—the signal indicates an ongoing emergency requiring immediate assistance. Therefore, frequent false alarms can strain the resources of local governments.
False alarm ordinances. As allowed by state law, many cities and counties have enacted ordinances regulating false alarms. While many false alarm ordinances contain similar elements, specific details vary by locality. For example, in the City and County of San Francisco, alarm system users must obtain an alarm system license by registering their systems. The ordinance also imposes various duties and penalties on the alarm user and the alarm company designed to deter false alarms. The San Francisco ordinance requires alarm users to utilize various preventive measures, such as proper maintenance of the alarm system. It also establishes an escalating false alarm fee schedule. The schedule assesses no penalty for the first false alarm, but penalizes the user $100 for the second and adds $50 to the previous penalty for each additional false alarm in a calendar year.
Many local governments also require an alarm company to at least attempt to verify an emergency before calling the local police department. While some local governments choose to impose heavier penalties on the alarm users for false alarms, others may choose to require greater diligence from the alarm companies. For example, San Francisco requires the companies to attempt to verify most types of alarm signals before requesting a law enforcement response (such as calling the alarm user to determine the existence of an emergency). If the alarm company fails to verify an alarm, the alarm company must pay a fine.
In 2006, several police departments in San Bernardino County commissioned a study on police response to false alarms. The report, “Police Response to Burglar Alarms Study: San Bernardino County,” concluded that 99% of burglary alarm calls were false alarms and made several recommendations on how to reduce false alarms. Subsequently, the City of Fontana enacted an ordinance that fined alarm companies $200 for false alarms. It also required alarm companies to verify alarm notifications with specific evidence of an actual or impending break-in before police would respond to a call. The ordinance also authorized the city to levy fines against alarm companies that signaled for police without verifying.
The Inland Empire Alarm Association filed suit, seeking to overturn the ordinance (Inland Empire Alarm Assn. v. City of Fontana, CIVDS908092 (2009)). The trial court overturned as unconstitutional those portions of the ordinance that fined alarm companies even if they had not been shown to commit wrongful conduct, but upheld the authority of the city to require verification of alarms. Both parties appealed, but then settled while the case was on appeal. The City agreed to pay attorney fees and revised its ordinance to remove the fine on alarm companies for false alarms. The current Fontana ordinance, which was adopted on September 22, 2010, still requires actual verification and still establishes fines for alarm companies that call before verifying alarm notifications.
The City of Chico also enacted an ordinance that fined alarm companies for false alarms in 2014. However, according to news reports, the adopted ordinance was immediately challenged by alarm companies and the ordinance was subsequently amended to fine the user instead of the alarm company. Alarm companies want to further ensure that they are not penalized for false alarms that are caused by alarm system users.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. Studies have shown that nationwide, anywhere from 8%-25% of calls to police are due to alarm systems that have been falsely triggered, and many jurisdictions have found that the majority of their burglary alarm calls are false. These alarms are costly to local governments and divert needed police resources unnecessarily. User error is a major source of false alarms: according to the United States Department of Justice, one study has found that 20% of alarm systems trigger 80% of false alarms, indicating that particular users may disproportionately drive false alarms. False alarm fees assigned to the user are an effective way to encourage responsible use of alarm equipment. AB 1616 aims to ensure consistency in the imposition of false alarm fees throughout California by codifying current practice—in line with recent court decisions. AB 1616 ensures that alarm system users are penalized for false alarms, except in cases where the false alarm is attributed to error by the alarm system monitoring company, alarm system operator, alarm system equipment or its installer. Local governments can continue to impose false alarm fees; it simply prevents alarm companies from being penalized for false alarms that they have no control over.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
ADT Security Services (source)
California Alarm Association
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/18/17
AYES: Acosta, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Cervantes, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood
NO VOTE RECORDED: Aguiar-Curry, Calderon, Chau, Frazier, Friedman, Gipson, Holden, Mullin, Rendon
7/7/17 14:25:35
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1616 | Hearing Date: | 7/5/17 |
Author: | Nazarian | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/20/17 | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
Alarm companies: liability: false alarm
Provides that an alarm company operator or agent is not liable for false alarms not caused by their own error.
Background
Police Power. The California Constitution allows a city to "make and enforce within its limits, all local, police, sanitary and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws." It is from this fundamental power (commonly called the police power) that local governments derive their authority to regulate behavior to preserve the health, safety, and welfare of the public.
Alarm Company Regulation. A security alarm system is a set of devices arranged to detect an intruder or other hazard, such as fire or flood. Generally, there are two types of security alarm systems available to consumers and businesses, local and monitored alarms. A local alarm is limited to onsite sirens or lights, mainly designed to deter intruders and alert anyone in the area. A local alarm does not send a signal to law enforcement or other responders, but may still be subject to public nuisance ordinances limiting noise and length of time. A monitored alarm system is typically a local alarm that is also connected to a central (or monitoring) station. A central station is usually an alarm provider who monitors the system and signals a responder if a hazard is detected (such as local law enforcement). A signal from an alarm system or central station to local law enforcement is similar to a 911 call—the signal indicates an ongoing emergency requiring immediate assistance. Therefore, frequent false alarms can strain the resources of local governments.
The Alarm Company Act (SB 673, Sieroty, 1982) regulates alarm systems and alarm companies. The Alarm Company Act created the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (bureau) within the Department of Consumer Affairs to oversee alarm companies by issuing licenses to alarm company operators and alarm agents (persons that sell, maintain, or operate alarm systems on behalf of an alarm company operator) to ensure that they meet minimum standards and qualifications. The Alarm Company Act also allows a city or county, under its police power, to enact ordinances that govern false alarm activations and responses or that require: (1) alarm company operators to obtain a business license, (2) alarm agents or alarm company operators to register with the jurisdiction, or (3) require alarm system users to obtain a permit to operate the system.
False Alarm Ordinances. As allowed by state law, many cities and counties have enacted ordinances regulating false alarms. While many false alarm ordinances contain similar elements, specific details vary by locality. For example, in the City and County of San Francisco, alarm system users must obtain an alarm system license by registering their systems. The ordinance also imposes various duties and penalties on the alarm user and the alarm company designed to deter false alarms. The San Francisco ordinance requires alarm users to utilize various preventive measures, such as proper maintenance of the alarm system. It also establishes an escalating false alarm fee schedule. The schedule assesses no penalty for the first false alarm, but penalizes the user $100 for the second and adds $50 to the previous penalty for each additional false alarm in a calendar year.
Many local governments also require an alarm company to at least attempt to verify an emergency before calling the local police department. While some local governments choose to impose heavier penalties on the alarm users for false alarms, others may choose to require greater diligence from the alarm companies. For example, San Francisco requires the companies to attempt to verify most types of alarm signals before requesting a law enforcement response (such as calling the alarm user to determine the existence of an emergency). If the alarm company fails to verify an alarm, the alarm company must pay a fine.
In 2006, several police departments in San Bernardino County commissioned a study on police response to false alarms. The report, “Police Response to Burglar Alarms Study: San Bernardino County,” concluded that 99% of burglary alarm calls were false alarms and made several recommendations on how to reduce false alarms. Subsequently, the City of Fontana enacted an ordinance that fined alarm companies $200 for false alarms. It also required alarm companies to verify alarm notifications with specific evidence of an actual or impending break-in before police would respond to a call. The ordinance also authorized the city to levy fines against alarm companies that signaled for police without verifying.
The Inland Empire Alarm Association filed suit, seeking to overturn the ordinance (Inland Empire Alarm Assn. v. City of Fontana, CIVDS908092 (2009)). The trial court overturned as unconstitutional those portions of the ordinance that fined alarm companies even if they had not been shown to commit wrongful conduct, but upheld the authority of the city to require verification of alarms. Both parties appealed, but then settled while the case was on appeal. The city agreed to pay attorney fees and revised its ordinance to remove the fine on alarm companies for false alarms. The current Fontana ordinance, which was adopted on September 22, 2010, still requires actual verification and still establishes fines for alarm companies that call before verifying alarm notifications.
The City of Chico also enacted an ordinance that fined alarm companies for false alarms in 2014. However, according to news reports, the adopted ordinance was immediately challenged by alarm companies and the ordinance was subsequently amended to fine the user instead of the alarm company. Alarm companies want to further ensure that they are not penalized for false alarms that are caused by alarm system users.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 1616 provides that an alarm company operator or an alarm agent shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to:
- Alarm company operator error;
- Improper installation of the alarm system by an alarm agent or an alarm company operator;
- Defective equipment provided or installed by an alarm agent or alarm company operator, or;
- Defective equipment leased by an alarm company operator.
AB 1616 also states that the provisions of the bill shall not be construed to require the bureau to adjudicate a cause of action between a city, county, or city and county regarding liability for penalties, except as otherwise provided by law, and that the bill shall not be construed to affect the authority of a city, county, or city and county to adopt and enforce ordinances requiring alarm companies to attempt to verify alarm events before requesting dispatch.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. Studies have shown that nationwide, anywhere from 8%-25% of calls to police are due to alarm systems that have been falsely triggered, and many jurisdictions have found that the majority of their burglary alarm calls are false. These alarms are costly to local governments and divert needed police resources unnecessarily. User error is a major source of false alarms: according to the United States Department of Justice (USDOJ), one study has found that 20% of alarm systems trigger 80% of false alarms, indicating that particular users may disproportionately drive false alarms. False alarm fees assigned to the user are an effective way to encourage responsible use of alarm equipment. AB 1616 aims to ensure consistency in the imposition of false alarm fees throughout California by codifying current practice—in line with recent court decisions. AB 1616 ensures that alarm system users are penalized for false alarms, except in cases where the false alarm is attributed to error by the alarm system monitoring company, alarm system operator, alarm system equipment or its installer. Local governments can continue to impose false alarm fees; it simply prevents alarm companies from being penalized for false alarms that they have no control over.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Business and Professions Committee: 14-0
Assembly Floor: 71-0
Support and Opposition
(6/28/17)
Support: ADT Security Services (sponsor); California Alarm Association.
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:
Author:(Nazarian)
As Amended Ver:May 4, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Business & Professions | 14-0 | Low, Brough, Arambula, Baker, Bloom, Chiu, Cunningham, Gipson, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Mullin, Steinorth, Ting |
SUMMARY: Specifies that an alarm company operator or a contractor shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or alarm company operator.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by ADT Security Services. According to the author, "False alarm fees assigned to the user are an effective way to encourage responsible use of alarm equipment. [This bill] aims to ensure consistency in the imposition of false alarm fees throughout California by codifying current practice. It provides that local jurisdictions apply false alarm fees and penalties on the permittee, not on the alarm system monitoring company, except in cases where the false alarm is attributed to error by the alarm system monitoring company or its installer. This bill would not affect the discretion of local governments in choosing what false alarm fee they adopt. It is simply a measure to ensure that emergency resources are directed to actual emergencies."
Background. Existing law authorizes cities and counties to enact ordinances governing false alarms generated by security alarm systems. This bill seeks to prohibit local governments from imposing a false alarm fee on the alarm company operator or a contractor unless the false alarm is attributable to alarm company error or improper installation by a contractor.
Alarm Systems. A security alarm system is a set of devices arranged to detect an intruder or other hazard, such as fire or flood. Generally, there are two types of security alarm systems available to consumers and businesses, local and monitored alarms.
A local alarm is limited to onsite sirens or lights, mainly designed to deter intruders and alert anyone in the area. A local alarm does not send a signal to law enforcement or other responders, but may still be subject to public nuisance ordinances limiting noise and length of time. For example, some ordinances prohibit sirens that sound like emergency responders or disaster warning systems.
A monitored alarm system is typically a local alarm that is also connected to a central (or monitoring) station. A central station is usually an alarm provider who monitors the system and signals a responder if a hazard is detected (such as local law enforcement). A signal from an alarm system or central station to local law enforcement is similar to a 911 call—the signal indicates an ongoing emergency requiring immediate assistance. Therefore, frequent false alarms strain the resources of local governments.
False Alarm Ordinances. In an effort to reduce false alarms, many cities, counties, and cities and counties, enact ordinances regulating false alarms. According to the author, "False alarms trigger an emergency response when in fact no emergency has occurred. They tax the resources of police, fire, and emergency personnel, keeping them from responding to actual emergencies. Excessive false alarms increase costs for taxpayers, security service providers, and users, requiring additional personnel to respond to alarms."
While many false alarm ordinances contain similar elements, specific details vary by locality. In the City and County of San Francisco, The Police Emergency Alarm Ordinance requires, among other things, alarm system users to obtain an alarm system license by registering their systems with the City and County (San Francisco, Police Code Article 37, Sections 3700-3722). The ordinance also imposes various duties and penalties on the alarm user and the alarm company designed to deter false alarms.
For example, the San Francisco ordinance requires alarm users to utilize various preventive measures (such as proper maintenance). It also establishes an escalating false alarm fee schedule. The schedule assesses no penalty for the first false alarm, but penalizes the user $100 for the second and adds $50 to the previous penalty for each additional false alarm in a calendar year.
San Francisco also requires the companies to attempt to verify most types alarm signals before requesting a law enforcement response (such as calling the alarm user to determine the existence of an emergency). If the alarm company fails to verify an alarm, the alarm company must pay a fee to the Tax Collector.
The City of Los Angeles has a similar ordinance (Los Angeles Municipal Code, Chapter 10, Article 3, Division 8, Section 103.206), except that it does not waive the first false alarm penalty and makes it a misdemeanor for an alarm company operator to request service from the Los Angeles Police Department unless it has made two attempts to verify the need for service.
Fines for Failure to Verify. Like the City and County San Francisco and the City of Los Angeles, many local governments require an alarm company to at least attempt to verify an emergency before calling the local police department. While some local governments choose to impose heavier penalties on the alarm users for false alarms, others may choose to require greater diligence from the alarm companies.
Currently, the city of Fontana requires actual verification and establishes fines for alarm companies that call before verifying false alarms or call under the pretense of a verified call (Fontana Municipal Code, Chapter 22, Article 4, Sections 22-116—22-132). The City of Chico enacted a similar ordinance in 2014. However, "the adopted ordinance was immediately challenged by legal [counsel] representing the alarm system industry" (Ashley Gebb, Chico City Council to consider changes to false alarm ordinance (2015), Chico Enterprise-Record). The ordinance now allows for attempted verification and fines the user instead of the alarm company (Chico Municipal Code, Title 5, Chapter 5.40, Section 5.40.10-5.40.150).
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
ADT Security Services (sponsor) writes in support, "ADT supports efforts to meaningfully reduce false alarms, including the establishment of false alarm reduction programs created at the local level that encourage proper use of alarm systems and fine users for excessive false alarms. Studies have shown that, in general, 80% of false alarms are generated by 20% of alarm users. Fining chronic misusers of alarm systems can dramatically reduce the number of false alarms."
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file.
POLICY ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION:
Self-Policing. The purpose of the various requirements and penalties is to encourage self-policing by the alarm user and the alarm company. There are benefits to imposing requirements on either party. Both can take steps to reduce the occurrence of false alarms. For example, potential duties on the consumers of alarm systems include: being aware of impact on local police; diligent use and maintenance of system; accepting possibility of penalties; and being available in case of contact by the alarm company.
Potential duties on alarm companies include: thoroughly educating consumers (e.g. limitations of pet-friendly motion sensors); verification of false alarm (e.g. phone, camera, motion sensor, private patrol operator); proper installation and maintenance of sensors and monitoring system; proper collection of contact information from consumers; and accurate record keeping.
Shifting the Burden. Ordinances like those enacted by the City of Fontana may shift the burden of avoiding false alarms and proving emergency situations from the user to the company. One consideration when shifting the burden is whether one party may be better situated to appeal a false alarm determination than the other.
For example, if the alarm company is the one making the call (or sending a responder to verify before making the call), it can be difficult for a consumer to know the facts leading up to a false alarm. One traditional selling point for monitored alarm systems is the ability for the central station to quickly summon local authorities. Where a consumer relies on the expertise and advice of an alarm company or the alarm company affirmatively makes a call without actual contact or verification, the alarm company may have better first-hand knowledge of the facts.
The reverse would apply when it is the consumer making the call. Newer technologies like image-capture motion sensors and live video streams can provide users with real-time updates through web browsers and phone applications (although these systems tend to be more expensive). Even with unmonitored local systems, many newer systems notify the user as to which sensors have been tripped, provide the ability to disarm/rearm remotely, and can activate cameras to capture images. Since an alarm user can always call the police directly, it is therefore possible for the consumer to verify the alarm (and may remember which door latches are most troublesome). If an alarm company defers to the consumer's informed choice to summon the police, the consumer may be better situated.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
Definitions. The author may wish to: 1) define "excessive false alarms" and 2) explore additional conditions which can be attributed to an alarm company for purposes of liability (situations where an alarm company may be at fault).
Local Control. The author and sponsor have noted that the intent of this bill is not to limit a city's, county's, or city and county's ability to require verification of a false alarm by the alarm company. The author may wish to continue to work with interested stakeholders to ensure the language under the bill is not overbroad or otherwise unintentionally restricting a city, county, or city and county from enacting requirements that work best for the local jurisdiction.
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0000275
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1616
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:April 26, 2017
SUBJECT: Alarm companies: liability: false alarm.
SUMMARY: Prohibits an alarm company operator or contractor from being liable for civil penalties and fines assessed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error or improper installation by a contractor or an alarm company operator, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a city, county, or city and county to make and enforce ordinances not in conflict with the Constitution, laws of the State, or the United States. (California Constitution, Article XI, § 7; Government Code (GOV) § 37100)
- Authorizes a city, county, or city and county in the exercise of its police power, and for the purpose of regulation, as specified, license any kind of business not prohibited by law transacted and carried on within the limits of its jurisdiction, including all shows, exhibitions and lawful games, and may fix the rates of the license fee and provide for its collection by suit or otherwise, as specified. (BPC §§ 16000-16004, 16100-16105; GOV § 37101)
- Establishes the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (BSIS) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA). (BPC §§ 101(r), 6980.1, 7501, 7591)
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of alarm company operators and alarm agents under the Alarm Company Act and requires the BSIS to administer and enforce the act. (BPC §§ 7590-7599.80)
- Provides that the provisions of the Alarm Company Act shall not prevent the local authorities of any city, county, or city and county, by ordinance and within the exercise of the police power of the city, county, or city and county from:
- Requiring alarm company operator licensees to meet the requirements for and obtain a business permit. (BPC § 7592.8(a))
- Requiring alarm agents or alarm company operators, or both, to register their name and file a copy of their state issued identification card with the city, county, or city and county. No fee, other than a fee for a business license permit, may be charged nor may any application be required by the city, county, or city and county for that registration. (BPC § 7592.8(b))
- Enacting ordinances governing false alarm activations and responses. (BPC § 7592.8(c))
THIS BILL:
- Specifies that an alarm company operator or a contractor shall not be liable for civil penalties and fines assessed or imposed by a city, county, or city and county for excessive false alarms not attributed to alarm company operator error, improper installation of the alarm system by a contractor or an alarm company operator, or defective equipment provided, installed, or leased by a contractor or alarm company operator.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by ADT Security Services. According to the author, "False alarm fees assigned to the user are an effective way to encourage responsible use of alarm equipment. [This bill] aims to ensure consistency in the imposition of false alarm fees throughout California by codifying current practice. It provides that local jurisdictions apply false alarm fees and penalties on the permittee, not on the alarm system monitoring company, except in cases where the false alarm is attributed to error by the alarm system monitoring company or its installer. This bill would not affect the discretion of local governments in choosing what false alarm fee they adopt. It is simply a measure to ensure that emergency resources are directed to actual emergencies."
Background. Existing law authorizes cities and counties to enact ordinances governing false alarms generated by security alarm systems. This bill seeks to prohibit local governments from imposing a false alarm fee on the alarm company operator or a contractor unless the false alarm is attributable to alarm company error or improper installation by a contractor.
Alarm Systems. A security alarm system is a set of devices arranged to detect an intruder or other hazard, such as fire or flood. Generally, there are two types of security alarm systems available to consumers and businesses, local and monitored alarms.
A local alarm is limited to onsite sirens or lights, mainly designed to deter intruders and alert anyone in the area. A local alarm does not send a signal to law enforcement or other responders, but may still be subject to public nuisance ordinances limiting noise and length of time. For example, some ordinances prohibit sirens that sound like emergency responders or disaster warning systems.
A monitored alarm system is typically a local alarm that is also connected to a central (or monitoring) station. A central station is usually an alarm provider who monitors the system and signals a responder if a hazard is detected (such as local law enforcement). A signal from an alarm system or central station to local law enforcement is similar to a 911 call—the signal indicates an ongoing emergency requiring immediate assistance. Therefore, frequent false alarms strain the resources of local governments.
False Alarm Ordinances. In an effort to reduce false alarms, many cities, counties, and cities and counties, enact ordinances regulating false alarms. According to the author, "False alarms trigger an emergency response when in fact no emergency has occurred. They tax the resources of police, fire, and emergency personnel, keeping them from responding to actual emergencies. Excessive false alarms increase costs for taxpayers, security service providers, and users, requiring additional personnel to respond to alarms."
While many false alarm ordinances contain similar elements, specific details vary by locality. In the City and County of San Francisco, The Police Emergency Alarm Ordinance requires, among other things, alarm system users to obtain an alarm system license by registering their systems with the City and County (San Francisco, Police Code art. 37, §§ 3700-3722). The ordinance also imposes various duties and penalties on the alarm user and the alarm company designed to deter false alarms.
For example, the San Francisco ordinance requires alarm users to utilize various preventive measures (such as proper maintenance). It also establishes an escalating false alarm fee schedule. The schedule assesses no penalty for the first false alarm, but penalizes the user $100 for the second and adds $50 to the previous penalty for each additional false alarm in a calendar year.
San Francisco also requires the companies to attempt to verify most types alarm signals before requesting a law enforcement response (such as calling the alarm user to determine the existence of an emergency). If the alarm company fails to verify an alarm, the alarm company must pay a fee to the Tax Collector.
The City of Los Angeles has a similar ordinance (Los Angeles Municipal Code, ch. 10, art. 3, div. 8, § 103.206), except that it does not waive the first false alarm penalty and makes it a misdemeanor for an alarm company operator to request service from the Los Angeles Police Department unless it has made two attempts to verify the need for service.
Fines for Failure to Verify. Like the City and County San Francisco and the City of Los Angeles, many local governments require an alarm company to at least attempt to verify an emergency before calling the local police department. While some local governments choose to impose heavier penalties on the alarm users for false alarms, others may choose to require greater diligence from the alarm companies.
In 2006, several police departments in San Bernardino County commissioned a study on police response to false alarms. The study was conducted by the California State University, San Bernardino, Center for Criminal Justice Research and the report was submitted to the San Bernardino County Police Chiefs and Sheriffs Association (Gaines, Famegla, and Bichler, Police Response to Burglar Alarms Study: San Bernardino County (2006)). The report concluded that there were four areas where action could reduce false alarms. The first three areas were: “1) better recordkeeping for false alarms, 2) levying fines on the second false alarm and increasing the amounts of the fines, and 3) public education” (page 16).
On the fourth issue, the report noted, “At this junction we do not know the percentage of cases where alarm companies are actually attempting to contact alarm owners prior to notifying the police. There may be a percentage of cases where the alarm company notifies the police without attempting to call the alarm owner” (pages 16-17). The study concluded that, if police departments determine that alarm companies do not attempt to verify an emergency, “stringent enforcement of alarm company procedures may lead to a reduction in calls” (Id.).
Subsequently, in October 2007, the Fontana Police Department amended its alarm response policy to stop responding to alarms that were not actually verified (as opposed to attempted verification). Specifically, police would not respond to alarm notification calls from alarm companies unless there was specific evidence of a break-in, including audio, video, or eyewitness verification. According to the department, the purpose of the policy was to deal with high false alarm rates: “During fiscal year 2005 - 2006, the Fontana Police Department responded to 8,529 burglar alarms. 99.72% of these alarms were false, costing taxpayers approximately a quarter of a million dollars in wasted police manpower and resources” (https://www.fontana.org/382/Verified-Response).
In response, the Inland Empire Alarm Association filed for a Writ of Mandate in San Bernadino Superior Court, arguing that, unless the city passes a new ordinance, the Fontana Police Department must continue to respond to unverified alarm calls (Inland Empire Alarm Assn. v. City Of Fontana Police Dept., CIVSS706505 (2007)). While the judge found for the alarm association, the City of Fontana subsequently enacted an ordinance authorizing the use of the new policy and authorized the city to levy fines against alarm companies that signaled for police without verifying.
The Inland Empire Alarm Association again filed suit, seeking to overturn the ordinance and require the department to respond to unverified calls (Inland Empire Alarm Assn. v. City of Fontana, CIVDS908092 (2009)). The trial court overturned portions of the ordinance and upheld others, and both parties appealed. While the case was on appeal, the parties settled, with the city agreeing to pay attorney fees.
In a 2010 statement to the San Bernadino Sun, the department noted that “Verified response has helped reduce alarm calls by 78 percent from 2008-09, which saved 636 hours in officer response time” (Josh Dulaney, Fontana agrees to pay $173,284 to alarm group, San Bernadino Sun (2010))
The current Fontana ordinance, which was adopted on September 22, 2010, still requires actual verification and still establishes fines for alarm companies that call before verifying false alarms or making the call under the pretense of a verified call (Fontana Municipal Code, ch. 22, art. 4, §§ 22-116—22-132). The methods an alarm company may use to verify an alarm are as follows:
- At-the-site verification.
- Through the use of a remote audio or video system monitored by an alarm company operator.
- For a commercial alarm system, separate alarm activations monitored by an alarm company operator from the same premises within a ten minute period, which activations are triggered from separate devices, and must be two distinct activations
- For a residential alarm system, two separate alarm activations monitored by an alarm company operator from the same premises within a ten minute period, which activations are triggered from the same or different motion sensors.
- Any other form of verification as may from time to time be adopted as policy by the police department and published on its website.
Verification methods 3) and 4) were added as part of the compromise. However, the ordinance limits the use of 3) and 4) for verification three times in a six month period for the same premises.
The City of Chico enacted a similar ordinance in 2014. However, “the adopted ordinance was immediately challenged by legal [counsel] representing the alarm system industry” (Ashley Gebb, Chico City Council to consider changes to false alarm ordinance (2015), Chico Enterprise-Record). The ordinance now allows for attempted verification and fines the user instead of the alarm company (Chico Municipal Code, tit. 5, ch. 5.40, §§ 5.40.10-5.40.150).
Prior Related Legislation. SB 673 (Sieroty) Statutes of 1982, Chapter 1210, enacted the Alarm Company Act.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
ADT Security Services (sponsor) writes in support, “ADT supports efforts to meaningfully reduce false alarms, including the establishment of false alarm reduction programs created at the local level that encourage proper use of alarm systems and fine users for excessive false alarms. Studies have shown that, in general, 80% of false alarms are generated by 20% of alarm users. Fining chronic misusers of alarm systems can dramatically reduce the number of false alarms.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file.
POLICY ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION:
Self-Policing. The purpose of the various requirements and penalties is to encourage self-policing by the alarm user and the alarm company. There are benefits to imposing requirements on either party. Both can take steps to reduce the occurrence of false alarms. For example, potential duties on the consumers of alarm systems include: being aware of impact on local police; diligent use and maintenance of system; accepting possibility of penalties; and being available in case of contact by the alarm company.
Potential duties on alarm companies include: thoroughly educating consumers (e.g. limitations of pet-friendly motion sensors); verification of false alarm (e.g. phone, camera, motion sensor, private patrol operator); proper installation and maintenance of sensors and monitoring system; proper collection of contact information from consumers; and accurate record keeping.
Shifting the Burden. Ordinances like those enacted by the City of Fontana may shift the burden of avoiding false alarms and proving emergency situations from the user to the company. One consideration when shifting the burden is whether one party may be better situated to appeal a false alarm determination than the other.
For example, if the alarm company is the one making the call (or sending a responder to verify before making the call), it can be difficult for a consumer to know the facts leading up to a false alarm. One traditional selling point for monitored alarm systems is the ability for the central station to quickly summon local authorities. Where a consumer relies on the expertise and advice of an alarm company or the alarm company affirmatively makes a call without actual contact or verification, the alarm company may have better first-hand knowledge of the facts.
The reverse would apply when it is the consumer making the call. Newer technologies like image-capture motion sensors and live video streams can provide users with real-time updates through web browsers and phone applications (although these systems tend to be more expensive). Even with unmonitored local systems, many newer systems notify the user as to which sensors have been tripped, provide the ability to disarm/rearm remotely, and can activate cameras to capture images. Since an alarm user can always call the police directly, it is therefore possible for the consumer to verify the alarm (and may remember which door latches are most troublesome). If an alarm company defers to the consumer's informed choice to summon the police, the consumer may be better situated.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
Definitions. If this bill passes this Committee, the author may wish to: 1) define “excessive false alarms” and 2) explore additional conditions which can be attributed to an alarm company for purposes of liability (situations where an alarm company may be at fault).
Local Control. The author and sponsor have noted that the intent of this bill is not to limit a city’s, county’s, or city and county’s ability to require verification of a false alarm by the alarm company. If this bill passes this Committee, the author may wish to continue to work with interested stakeholders to ensure the language under the bill is not overbroad or otherwise unintentionally restricting a city, county, or city and county from enacting requirements that work best for the local jurisdiction.
AMENDMENTS:
The author should, as noted below, amend the bill to clarify that the BSIS will not be required to adjudicate matters or appeals between an alarm company and city, county, or city and county (which will be handled through the local jurisdiction's system):
Except as otherwise required to comply with the provisions of this chapter, this section shall not be construed to require the bureau to investigate, hear, or adjudicate a cause of action between an alarm company and a city, county, or city and county that pertains to liability for penalties imposed under an ordinance by the city, county, or city and county.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
ADT Security Services (sponsor)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / 916-319-3301
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):