AB 168: Employers: salary information.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-10-12
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer an applicant employment or what salary to offer an applicant. The bill also would prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would not prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information and would not prohibit an employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining salary, as specified. The bill would apply to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature and would not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer an applicant employment or what salary to offer an applicant. The bill also would prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would not prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information and would not prohibit an employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining salary, as specified. The bill would apply to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature and would not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer an applicant employment or what salary to offer an applicant. The bill also would prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and would require an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would not prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information and would not prohibit an employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining salary, as specified. The bill would apply to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature. Legislature and would not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer, including state and local government employers, employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. The bill employment and would require an employer, except state and local government employers, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would apply to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer, including state and local government employers, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. The bill would require an employer, except state and local government employers, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to applicants for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit an employer, including state and local government employers, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. The bill would require an employer, except state and local government employers, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment. The bill would specify that a violation of its provisions would not be subject to the misdemeanor provision.
(a)An employer shall not rely on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer employment to an applicant or what salary to offer an applicant.
(b)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(c)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(d)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(e)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(f)This section applies to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature.
(g)Nothing in this section shall prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information to a prospective employer.
(h)If an applicant voluntarily and without prompting discloses salary history information to a prospective employer, nothing in this section shall prohibit that employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining the salary for that applicant.
(i)Consistent with Section 1197.5, nothing in this section shall be construed to allow prior salary, by itself, to justify any disparity in compensation.
(a)An employer shall not rely on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer employment to an applicant or what salary to offer an applicant.
(b)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(c)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(d)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(e)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(f)This section applies to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature.
(g)Nothing in this section shall prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information to a prospective employer.
(h)If an applicant voluntarily and without prompting discloses salary history information to a prospective employer, nothing in this section shall prohibit that employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining the salary for that applicant.
(i)Consistent with Section 1197.5, nothing in this section shall be construed to allow prior salary, by itself, to justify any disparity in compensation.
(a)An employer shall not, not rely on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer employment to an applicant or what salary to offer an applicant.
(b)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(b)(c)An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(c)(d)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(d)(e)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(e)(f)This section applies to all employers, including state and local government employers and the Legislature.
(g)Nothing in this section shall prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information to a prospective employer.
(h)If an applicant voluntarily and without prompting discloses salary history information to a prospective employer, nothing in this section shall prohibit that employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining the salary for that applicant.
(i)Consistent with Section 1197.5, nothing in this section shall be construed to allow prior salary, by itself, to justify any disparity in compensation.
(a)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), an An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(c)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(d)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(e)This section, except for subdivision (b), section applies to all employers, including state and local government employers, including employers and the Legislature.
(a)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including, but not limited to, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), an employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(c)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(d)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(e)This section, except for subdivision (b), applies to all state and local government employers, including, but not limited to, including the Legislature.
(a)An employer shall not, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, seek salary history information, including, but not limited to, compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (e), an employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
(c)Section 433 does not apply to this section.
(d)This section shall not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law, including but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) or the federal Freedom of Information Act (Section 552 of Title 5 of the United States Code).
(e)This section, except for subdivision (b), applies to all state and local government employers, including, but not limited to, the Legislature.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 12, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 688, Statutes of 2017. |
| Oct 12, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 25, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 12 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2017 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 14, 2017 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 57. Noes 15. Page 3363.). |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Assembly Rule 77(a) suspended. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 15 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 12, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2017 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 18, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 17, 2017 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 11, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 3. Noes 2.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on P.E. & R. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 14). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 6, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on L. & I.R. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | Referred to Com. on L. & I.R. |
| May 22, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 60. Noes 9. Page 1639.) |
| May 15, 2017 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1535.) |
| May 11, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 10, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 6, 2017 | Referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Jan 18, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 17. |
| Jan 17, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2017 | AB 168 EGGMAN Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 12, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB168 Eggman et al. By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2017 | AB 168 EGGMAN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 10, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 168
Author:(Eggman)
As Amended Ver:September 8, 2017
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 60-9 | (May 22, 2017) | SENATE: | 27-10 | (September 12, 2017) |
Original Committee Reference: L. & E.
SUMMARY: Prohibits all employers, including the Legislature, the state, and local governments, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and requires an employer to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant upon reasonable request, among other things.
The Senate amendments
- Prohibit an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer an applicant employment or what salary to offer an applicant.
- Do not prohibit an applicant from voluntarily and without prompting disclosing salary history information and would not prohibit an employer from considering or relying on that voluntarily disclosed salary history information in determining salary, as specified.
- Include state and local government employers and the Legislature and would not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to federal or state law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits, under the California Equal Pay Act, an employer from paying an employee wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex for substantially similar work requiring the same skills, effort, and responsibility when performed under similar working conditions.
- Prohibits employers from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work requiring the same skills, effort, and responsibility when performed under similar working conditions.
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition when a wage differential is based on one or more of the following:
- A seniority system,
- A merit system,
- A system that measures earnings by quantity or quality of production,
- A bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training, or experience.
- Specifies that prior salary by itself may not justify any disparity in compensation.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for any employer or person acting individually as an officer, agent, or employee of another person who willfully:
- Pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of another sex, race, or ethnicity.
- Reduces the wages of any employee to comply with the Equal Pay Act.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
Analysis Prepared by: Lorie Alvarez / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002221
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 168
: 9
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/14/17
AYES: Bradford, Atkins, Jackson, Mitchell
NOES: Stone
SENATE PUBLIC EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 3-2, 7/10/17
AYES: Pan, Leyva, Portantino
NOES: Morrell, Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-9, 5/22/17 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits all employers, including the Legislature, the state, and local governments, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and requires an employer to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant upon reasonable request.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/8/17 (1) prohibit an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant as a factor in determining whether to offer employment or what salary to offer; (2) specify that nothing in this bill prohibits an applicant from voluntarily, and without prompting, disclosing salary history information to a prospective employer, and if an applicant does, allows the employer to consider that information in determining the salary for that applicant; and (3) specify that consistent with Labor Code §1197.5, nothing in this bill shall be construed to allow prior salary, by itself, to justify any disparity in compensation.
Existing law:
- Bars an employer from requiring an employee to refrain from disclosing the amount of his or her wages, requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that denies the employee the right to disclose the amount of his or her wages or discharge, or formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses the amount of his or her wages. (Labor Code §232)
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex for substantially similar work, when viewed as a composite of skill, effort, and responsibility, and performed under similar working conditions. (Labor Code §1197.5(a))
- Prohibits an employer from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work. (Labor Code §1197.5(b))
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the employer demonstrates the payment is made pursuant to:
- a seniority system;
- a merit system;
- a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production;
- a bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training, or experience which applies only if the employer demonstrates the factor is not based on or derived from a sex-based differential in compensation, is job related, and is consistent with a business necessity, as defined. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Specifies that an employer who violates these provisions is liable to the affected employee in the amount of the wages, and interest thereon, and an additional equal amount as liquidated damages, administered and enforced by the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) which may supervise the payment of wages owed. (Labor Code §1197.5(c) and (d))
- Authorizes any employee to file a complaint with the DLSE of wages owed, and authorizes the Department of Industrial Relations or the DLSE to commence and prosecute a civil action on behalf of the employee and on behalf of similarly affected group of employees to recover unpaid wages, liquidated damages, and costs of the suit. (Labor Code §1197.5(g))
- Makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $10,000 and/or by imprisonment, or both, for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with wage protections for an employee of the opposite sex per Section 1197.5. (Labor Code §1199.5)
This bill:
- Prohibits an employer, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, from seeking salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
- Prohibits an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer employment to an applicant or what salary to offer an applicant.
- Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
- Specifies that these provisions apply to all employers, including the state and local government employers and the Legislature.
- Specifies that a violation of these provisions would not be subject to a misdemeanor.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill prohibits an applicant from voluntarily, and without prompting, disclosing salary history information to a prospective employer.
- Specifies that if an applicant voluntarily, and without prompting, discloses salary history information to a prospective employer, nothing in this bill prohibits that employer from considering or relying on that information in determining the salary for that applicant.
- Specifies that consistent with Labor Code §1197.5, nothing in this bill shall be construed to allow prior salary, by itself, to justify any disparity in compensation.
- Specifies that these provisions do not apply to salary history information that is disclosable to the public pursuant to specified federal and state law.
Background
Research on Gender Pay Disparity
There have been numerous studies dedicated to calculating disparities in earnings between men and women in the workplace over the last fifty years. In 1963, women who worked full-time year-round made 59 cents on average for every dollar earned by a man according to the American Association of University Women (AAUW). Today, women working full-time in the United States typically are paid just 80 percent of what men are paid, a gap of 20 cents. (The Simple Truth about the Gender Pay Gap, 2017 Edition, AAUW)
The wage gap is even larger for women of color. According to the National Partnership for Women & Families, among women who hold full-time, year-round jobs in the United States, Black women are typically paid 63 cents for every dollar paid to white men, while Latinas are paid just 54 cents for every dollar. Asian women are paid 85 cents for every dollar paid to white men, although some ethnic subgroups of Asian women fare much worse. (America’s Women and the Wage Gap, National Partnership for Women & Families, April 2017)
Research finds that the gender pay gap has lifelong financial effects including contributing to women’s poverty. Additionally, the pay gap follows women even after they leave the workforce where you will see the impact in lower retirement benefits as well as lower benefits for other programs based on earnings. The wage gap has narrowed since the 1960s largely due to women’s progress in education and participation in the workforce and to men’s wages rising at a slower rate. However, that slow progress has stalled in recent years and at this rate women will not reach pay equity with men until 2152.
Need for this bill?
The persistent gender pay gap has resulted in significant state efforts to curb wage discrimination. In 1949, California enacted the California Equal Pay Act, which targeted wage discrimination against women by prohibiting an employer from paying an employee a wage rate that is less than the rate of an employee of the opposite sex who does comparable work. SB 358 (Jackson, Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015) proposed a number of procedural and substantive changes to the California Equal Pay Act in order to make it easier for a victim of wage discrimination to identify an unlawful wage disparity and seek remedy.
Additionally, in 2016, AB 1676 (Campos) was enacted which specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law. Existing law, however, does not prohibit employers from inquiring about prior salary information. According to the author, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy and closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated. This bill prohibits an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1209 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) requires employers with 500 or more employees to submit to the Secretary of State’s Office information on gender pay differentials for online posting.
AB 46 (Cooper, 2017) specifies that the Equal Pay Act provisions which prohibit employers from paying a lower wage rate to employees on the basis of gender, race, or ethnicity apply to both public and private employers.
AB 1676 (Campos, Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016) specified that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law.
SB 1063 (Hall, Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016) expanded the prohibitions in the Equal Pay Act to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson, Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015) required that men and women doing substantially similar work under similar working conditions be paid equally, unless the pay differential is based on certain enumerated factors, as specified.
AB 1017 (Campos, 2015) would have prohibited an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. AB 1017 was very similar to this bill (AB 168); however, it did not include the pay scale provision and applied only to private employers. AB 1017 was vetoed by the Governor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Federation of Teachers
California Legislative Women’s Caucus
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Equal Rights Advocates
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
American Insurance Association
Association of California School Administrators
California Ambulance Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
California Travel Association
Chambers of Commerce Alliance Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
Greater Irvine Chamber of Commerce
League of California Cities`
National Federation of Independent Business
Rural County Representatives of California
San Jose Unified School District
Vacaville Chamber of Commerce
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Western Growers Association
Western States Trucking Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to proponents, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. The author argues that wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. According to the author, in California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn $39 billion more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of this bill argue that this bill exposes all employers to unnecessary litigation, creates hurdles in the hiring process and is already addressed by existing law. They note that last year the business community negotiated language on a similar proposal (AB 1676, Campos) to ensure that employers could not base compensation solely on prior salary; they believe this new law should be allowed to have an impact before banning any inquiry into an applicant’s salary history. Additionally, opponents argue that there are several legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons why employers seek this information including that employers do not necessarily have accurate wage information on what the current market is for all potential positions.
Opponents are also concerned with the pay scale provision arguing that a pay scale could artificially limit an applicant’s interest in a position. They argue that the appropriate wage and salary to pay an applicant is based upon various factors and employers may feel compelled to enlarge the pay scale in order to create sufficient room to adjust that rate depending on these factors and varied candidates for the job. Such a broad pay scale will not assist an applicant in negotiations.
Additionally, opponents argue that as part of the Labor Code, this bill exposes employers to costly litigation under the Private Attorneys General Act even when the employer pays an applicant equal wages as other employees. Overall, opponents argue that this bill effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-9, 5/22/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Dahle, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Mullin, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Travis Allen, Brough, Choi, Gallagher, Gray, Harper, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chen, Daly, Fong, Irwin, Kiley, Mayes, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell
9/9/17 16:06:26
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 168
:
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/14/17
AYES: Bradford, Atkins, Jackson, Mitchell
NOES: Stone
SENATE PUBLIC EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 3-2, 7/10/17
AYES: Pan, Leyva, Portantino
NOES: Morrell, Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-9, 5/22/17 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits all employers, including the Legislature, the state, and local governments, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and requires an employer to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant upon reasonable request.
Existing law:
- Bars an employer from requiring an employee to refrain from disclosing the amount of his or her wages, requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that denies the employee the right to disclose the amount of his or her wages or discharge, or formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses the amount of his or her wages. (Labor Code §232)
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex for substantially similar work, when viewed as a composite of skill, effort, and responsibility, and performed under similar working conditions. (Labor Code §1197.5(a))
- Prohibits an employer from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work. (Labor Code §1197.5(b))
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the employer demonstrates the payment is made pursuant to:
- a seniority system;
- a merit system;
- a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production;
- a bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training, or experience which applies only if the employer demonstrates the factor is not based on or derived from a sex-based differential in compensation, is job related, and is consistent with a business necessity, as defined. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Specifies that an employer who violates these provisions is liable to the affected employee in the amount of the wages, and interest thereon, and an additional equal amount as liquidated damages, administered and enforced by the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) which may supervise the payment of wages owed. (Labor Code §1197.5(c) and (d))
- Authorizes any employee to file a complaint with the DLSE of wages owed, and authorizes the Department of Industrial Relations or the DLSE to commence and prosecute a civil action on behalf of the employee and on behalf of similarly affected group of employees to recover unpaid wages, liquidated damages, and costs of the suit. (Labor Code §1197.5(g))
- Makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $10,000 and/or by imprisonment, or both, for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with wage protections for an employee of the opposite sex per Section 1197.5. (Labor Code §1199.5)
This bill:
- Prohibits an employer, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, from seeking salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
- Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
- Specifies that these provisions apply to all employers, including the state and local government employers and the Legislature.
- Specifies that a violation of these provisions would not be subject to a misdemeanor.
- Specifies that these provisions do not apply to salary history information that is disclosable to the public pursuant to specified federal and state law.
Background
Research on Gender Pay Disparity
There have been numerous studies dedicated to calculating disparities in earnings between men and women in the workplace over the last fifty years. In 1963, women who worked full-time year-round made 59 cents on average for every dollar earned by a man according to the American Association of University Women (AAUW). Today, women working full-time in the United States typically are paid just 80 percent of what men are paid, a gap of 20 cents. (The Simple Truth about the Gender Pay Gap, 2017 Edition, AAUW)
The wage gap is even larger for women of color. According to the National Partnership for Women & Families, among women who hold full-time, year-round jobs in the United States, Black women are typically paid 63 cents for every dollar paid to white men, while Latinas are paid just 54 cents for every dollar. Asian women are paid 85 cents for every dollar paid to white men, although some ethnic subgroups of Asian women fare much worse. (America’s Women and the Wage Gap, National Partnership for Women & Families, April 2017)
Research finds that the gender pay gap has lifelong financial effects including contributing to women’s poverty. Additionally, the pay gap follows women even after they leave the workforce where you will see the impact in lower retirement benefits as well as lower benefits for other programs based on earnings. The wage gap has narrowed since the 1960s largely due to women’s progress in education and participation in the workforce and to men’s wages rising at a slower rate. However, that slow progress has stalled in recent years and at this rate women will not reach pay equity with men until 2152.
Need for this bill?
The persistent gender pay gap has resulted in significant state efforts to curb wage discrimination. In 1949, California enacted the California Equal Pay Act, which targeted wage discrimination against women by prohibiting an employer from paying an employee a wage rate that is less than the rate of an employee of the opposite sex who does comparable work. SB 358 (Jackson, Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015) proposed a number of procedural and substantive changes to the California Equal Pay Act in order to make it easier for a victim of wage discrimination to identify an unlawful wage disparity and seek remedy.
Additionally, in 2016, AB 1676 (Campos) was enacted which specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law. Existing law, however, does not prohibit employers from inquiring about prior salary information. According to the author, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy and closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated. This bill prohibits an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment.
Similar Efforts in San Francisco and Other States
In 2016, Massachusetts and Philadelphia enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants about their salary history. In 2017, New York City and Puerto Rico joined the effort and passed similar laws. In California, San Francisco is currently considering Ordinance No. 170350 which would, among other things, ban employers from considering the current or past salary of an applicant in determining what salary to offer and from asking applicants about their current or past salary. According to the legislative digest, the Ordinance is intended to prevent the perpetuation of historical patterns of gender bias and discrimination. Currently pending in the Government Audit and Oversight Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1209 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) requires employers with 500 or more employees to submit to the Secretary of State’s Office information on gender pay differentials for online posting. Pending in Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 46 (Cooper, 2017) specifies that the Equal Pay Act provisions which prohibit employers from paying a lower wage rate to employees on the basis of gender, race, or ethnicity apply to both public and private employers.
AB 1676 (Campos, Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016) specified that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law.
SB 1063 (Hall, Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016) expanded the prohibitions in the Equal Pay Act to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson, Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015) required that men and women doing substantially similar work under similar working conditions be paid equally, unless the pay differential is based on certain enumerated factors, as specified.
AB 1017 (Campos, 2015) would have prohibited an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. AB 1017 was very similar to this bill (AB 168); however, it did not include the pay scale provision and applied only to private employers. AB 1017 was vetoed by the Governor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
OPPOSITION: (Verified 7/17/17)
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
California Travel Association
Chambers of Commerce Alliance Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Western Growers Association
Western States Trucking Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to proponents, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. The author argues that wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. According to the author, in California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn $39 billion more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of this bill argue that this bill exposes all employers to unnecessary litigation, creates hurdles in the hiring process and is already addressed by existing law. They note that last year the business community negotiated language on a similar proposal (AB 1676, Campos) to ensure that employers could not base compensation solely on prior salary; they believe this new law should be allowed to have an impact before banning any inquiry into an applicant’s salary history. Additionally, opponents argue that there are several legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons why employers seek this information including that employers do not necessarily have accurate wage information on what the current market is for all potential positions.
Opponents are also concerned with the pay scale provision arguing that a pay scale could artificially limit an applicant’s interest in a position. According to opponents, the appropriate wage and salary to pay an applicant is based upon various factors and employers may feel compelled to enlarge the pay scale in order to create sufficient room to adjust that rate depending on these factors and varied candidates for the job. Such a broad pay scale will not assist an applicant in negotiations.
Additionally, opponents argue that as part of the Labor Code, this bill exposes employers to costly litigation under the Private Attorneys General Act even when the employer pays an applicant equal wages as other employees. Overall, opponents argue that this bill effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-9, 5/22/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Dahle, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Mullin, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Travis Allen, Brough, Choi, Gallagher, Gray, Harper, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chen, Daly, Fong, Irwin, Kiley, Mayes, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell
7/19/17 15:19:51
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 168 Hearing Date: 7/10/17
Author: | Eggman | ||
Version: | 6/6/17 As amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Korinne Sugasawara | ||
Subject: Employers: salary information
SOURCE: Author
ASSEMBLY VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 60 - 9 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 6 |
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee: | 5 - 2 |
DIGEST: This bill prohibits all employers, including the Legislature, the state, and local governments, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment and requires an employer to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant upon reasonable request.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Prohibits, under the California Equal Pay Act, an employer from paying an employee wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex for substantially similar work requiring the same skills, effort, and responsibility when performed under similar working conditions.
- Prohibits employers from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work requiring the same skills, effort, and responsibility when performed under similar working conditions.
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition when a wage differential is based on one or more of the following:
- A seniority system,
- A merit system,
- A system that measures earnings by quantity or quality of production,
- A bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training, or experience.
- Specifies that prior salary by itself may not justify any disparity in compensation.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for any employer or person acting individually as an officer, agent, or employee of another person who willfully:
- Pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of another sex, race, or ethnicity.
- Reduces the wages of any employee to comply with the Equal Pay Act.
- Provides that no one shall be imprisoned for the above misdemeanor except for an offense committed after conviction of a prior Equal Pay Act offence.
- Requires the California Department of Human Resources (CalHR) to review information relevant to the setting of salaries for female-dominated occupations, with the intent of establishing a foundation for salaries based on comparability of the value of work to other civil service classifications.
- Requires, under the State Employee-Employer Relations Act (the Ralph C. Dills Act), that the State, represented by CalHR, collectively bargain with exclusive employee representatives over all aspects related to wages and working conditions, and that agreements be formalized in MOUs.
- Charges the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) with administering the eight collective bargaining statutes covering employees in California’s public schools, colleges, and universities; employees of the State of California; employees of local public agencies; trial court employees and interpreters; and supervisory employees of the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
This bill:
- Prohibits all employers, including the Legislature, the state, or local governments from seeking salary history about an applicant for employment, as specified.
- Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide to an applicant the pay scale for a position.
- Specifies that a violation of these provisions would not be a misdemeanor.
- Specifies that these provisions do not apply to salary history information disclosable to the public pursuant to specified federal and state law.
Background
Every year the United States Census Bureau and the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics provide an estimate of the national gender wage gap using annual earnings data from the Current Population Survey Annual Social and Economic Supplement. Although the wage gap has narrowed since the passage of the federal Equal Pay Act of 1963 (EPA), in 2015 women made 80 cents for every dollar earned by a male counterpart.
According to 2015 U.S. Census Bureau data, California women earn 84 cents on the dollar compared to men, although the wage gap can be larger for women of color, with African American woman earning 63 cents, Latinas 43 cents, and Asian American women 72 cents on every dollar a male earns. Together these pay disparities result in a $39 billion annual loss for full-time working women.
Women in State Civil Service
Generally CalHR sets salaries and other terms and conditions of employment through the collective bargaining process. CalHR adjusts the salaries for employee classifications excluded from collective bargaining by taking into consideration a number of factors, including local market needs, recruitment and retention issues, the employer’s ability to pay, and the state salary structure.
Data from a 2014 CalHR report finds that the state civil workforce employs more women in management, legal, science, technology, engineering, and mathematics careers than the California and United States workforces. However, women in the state workforce also experience a larger gender pay gap compared to federal civil service, the rest of California, and the U.S. workforce due in part from a larger proportion of women in lower paying occupations. As of 2014 women in the state workforce earned approximately 79.5 cents on the dollar.
Prior Salary
Current law prohibits private sector employers from basing compensation solely on prior salary as relying on previous compensation can perpetuate wage discrimination or unfairly penalize those who leave the job market for an extended period.
In a recent pay discrimination case in California, a female math consultant challenged her employer’s policy of basing salary on prior earnings plus a five percent raise, which resulted in her compensation being $20,000 less than a male counterpart doing the same work. The trial court stated that the employer’s pay structure was “so inherently fraught with the risk…that it will perpetuate a discriminatory wage disparity between men and women [such] that it cannot stand, even if motivated by a legitimate business purpose.”
Additionally, in July 2015 the acting director of the Federal Office of Personnel Management provided guidance on pay equity to the federal government, including that reliance on salary history “could potentially adversely affect a candidate who is returning to the workplace after having taken extended time off from his or her career or for whom an existing rate of pay is not reflective of the candidate’s current qualifications or existing labor market conditions.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 46 (Cooper, 2017), would expand California’s pay equity laws for women and minorities to encompass all employees in both the public and private sector.
AB 1209 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017), requires employers to collect specified information on gender pay differentials and for the employer to publish the information online.
AB 1676 (Campos, Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016), stipulates that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
SB 1063 (Hall, Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016), expanded the prohibitions in the California Equal Pay Act related to gender to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson, Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015), strengthened the California Equal Pay Act by, among other provisions, clarifying the relative burdens of proof and prohibiting retaliation against employees for disclosing or discussing their wages with co-workers.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would have:
- Absorbable costs for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement to enforce the provisions of the bill.
- Unknown impact on the wages of public sector employees, particularly those not part of the state civil service, to the extent that this bill leads to higher wages for those employees.
SUPPORT:
California Federation of Teachers
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Equal Rights Advocates
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Service Employees International Union, Local 1000
Women’s Foundation of California
OPPOSITION:
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Delivery Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association, Oppose Unless Amended
California State Association of Counties
California Travel Association
Chambers of Commerce Alliance Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
San Jose Unified School District, Oppose Unless Amended
Vacaville Chamber of Commerce
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the author’s office, “gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. Closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated…In California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn 39 billion dollars more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. For each woman in our state that is a difference of about $8,000 per year…[and] mothers are the primary breadwinners in nearly 40 percent of families. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The San Jose Unified School District states, “California is experiencing a teacher shortage, especially in high need areas such as STEM and special education. San Jose Unified is in a highly competitive educator recruitment area surrounded by districts that are able to offer higher salaries. San Jose Unified wants to be able to develop compensation packages to attract and retain educators…in order to [do] so, it needs the ability to ask applicants about their salary history.”
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 168 Hearing Date: June 14, 2017
Author: | Eggman | ||
Version: | June 6, 2017 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
Subject: Employers: salary information
KEY ISSUES
Should the Legislature prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information from an applicant for employment?
Should the Legislature require an employer to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment that requests it?
Should these provisions apply to both private and public employers and the Legislature?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Bars an employer from requiring an employee to refrain from disclosing the amount of his or her wages, requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that denies the employee the right to disclose the amount of his or her wages or discharge, or formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses the amount of his or her wages. (Labor Code §232)
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex in the same establishment for equal work on jobs the performance of which requires equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and which are performed under similar working conditions. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Prohibits an employer from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work.
(Labor Code §1197.5)
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the employer demonstrates the payment is made pursuant to:
- a seniority system;
- a merit system;
- a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production;
- a bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training, or experience which applies only if the employer demonstrates the factor is not based on or derived from a sex-based differential in compensation, is job related, and is consistent with a business necessity, as defined. (Labor Code §1197.5)
- Specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
(Labor Code §1197.5)
- Makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $10,000 and/or by imprisonment, or both, for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with wage protections for an employee of the opposite sex per Section 1197.5. (Labor Code §1199.5)
This Bill:
- Prohibits an employer, orally or in writing, personally or through an agent, from seeking salary history information, including compensation and benefits, about an applicant for employment.
- Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
- Specifies that these provisions apply to all employers, including the state and local government employers and the Legislature.
- Specifies that a violation of these provisions would not be subject to a misdemeanor.
- Specifies that these provisions do not apply to salary history information that is disclosable to the public pursuant to specified federal and state law.
COMMENTS
1. Research on Gender Pay Disparity
There have been numerous studies dedicated to calculating disparities in earnings between men and women in the workplace over the last fifty years. In 1963, women who worked full-time year-round made 59 cents on average for every dollar earned by a man according to the American Association of University Women (AAUW). Today, women working full time in the United States typically are paid just 80 percent of what men are paid, a gap of 20 cents. AAUW also ranked the wage gap for individual states in the US for 2015, California ranking 7th with the median annual earnings being $50,562 for males and $43,335 for females, an earnings ratio of 86 percent. New York ranked number one, with an 89% earnings ratio. (The Simple Truth about the Gender Pay Gap, 2017 Edition, AAUW)
The wage gap is even larger for women of color. According to the National Partnership for Women & Families, among women who hold full-time, year-round jobs in the United States, Black women are typically paid 63 cents for every dollar paid to white men, while Latinas are paid just 54 cents for every dollar. Asian women are paid 85 cents for every dollar paid to white men, although some ethnic subgroups of Asian women fare much worse. (America’s Women and the Wage Gap, National Partnership for Women & Families, April 2017)
Research finds that the gender pay gap has lifelong financial effects including contributing to women’s poverty. According to the AAUW, at a time when 40 percent of mothers with children under the age of 18 are their families’ primary or sole breadwinners, the gender pay gap has direct impact on men and children as well. Additionally, the pay gap follows women even after they leave the workforce where you will see the impact in lower retirement benefits as well as lower benefits for other programs based on earnings. The wage gap has narrowed since the 1960s largely due to women’s progress in education and participation in the workforce and to men’s wages rising at a slower rate. However, that slow progress has stalled in recent years and at this rate women will not reach pay equity with men until 2152.
2. Need for this bill?
The persistent gender pay gap has resulted in significant state efforts to curb wage discrimination. In 1949, California enacted the California Equal Pay Act, which targeted wage discrimination against women by prohibiting an employer from paying an employee a wage rate that is less than the rate of an employee of the opposite sex who does comparable work. SB 358 (Jackson) Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015, proposed a number of procedural and substantive changes to the California Equal Pay Act in order to make it easier for a victim of wage discrimination to identify an unlawful wage disparity and seek an appropriate remedy.
Additionally, in 2016 AB 1676 (Campos) was enacted which specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law. Existing law, however, does not prohibit employers from inquiring about prior salary information.
According to the author, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy and closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated. This bill would prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment. Additionally, this bill requires that employers provide a salary range to a job applicant upon request.
3. Similar Efforts in San Francisco and Other States:
In 2016, Massachusetts and Philadelphia enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants about their salary history. In 2017, New York City and Puerto Rico joined the effort and passed similar laws. Similar salary history bans have been introduced in other states including New Jersey.
In California, San Francisco is currently considering Ordinance No. 170350 which would, among other things, ban employers from considering the current or past salary of an applicant in determining what salary to offer the applicant and from asking applicants about their current or past salary. According to the legislative digest on the Ordinance, the Ordinance is intended to prevent the perpetuation of historical patterns of gender bias and discrimination. The Ordinance is currently pending committee action in the Government Audit and Oversight Committee.
4. Proponent Arguments:
According to proponents, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. The author argues that wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. According to the author, in California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn 39 billion dollars more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
5. Opponent Arguments:
Opponents of the measure argue that this bill exposes all employers to unnecessary litigation, creates hurdles in the hiring process and is already addressed by existing law. They note that last year the business community negotiated language on a similar proposal (AB 1676 Campos) to ensure that employers could not base compensation solely on prior salary; they believe this new law should be allowed to have an impact before banning any inquiry into an applicant’s salary history. Additionally, opponents argue that there are several legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons why employers seek this information including that employers do not necessarily have accurate wage information on what the current market is for all potential positions. By requesting salary information, employers can adjust any unrealistic expectations or salary ranges to match the current market rate for the job. Further, requiring the applicant and employer to waste time on the interview process to ultimately learn that the employee would never consider taking the compensation offered is unnecessary.
Opponents are also concerned with the pay scale provision arguing that a pay scale could artificially limit an applicant’s interest in a position. According to opponents, the appropriate wage and salary to pay an applicant is based upon various factors and employers may feel compelled to enlarge the pay scale in order to create sufficient room to adjust that rate depending on these factors and varied candidates for the job. Such a broad pay scale will not assist an applicant in negotiations. Further, they argue that disclosure of wage rates or pay scales has not been proven to address gender equity pay. The California Retailers Association believes that a more productive approach would be to allow for discussions around salary expectations ensuring that all parties are making the best use of one another’s time.
Additionally, opponents argue that current protections exist to address pay disparity and this bill creates an additional avenue of litigation when there is no harm. They argue that as part of the Labor Code, this bill exposes employers to costly litigation under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) even when the employer pays an applicant equal wages as other employees. For example, if an employer asks an employee about his or her prior salary, yet ultimately pays the applicant a higher salary than any of the applicant’s male colleagues, that employer could still be sued under PAGA for penalties and attorney’s fees. Overall, opponents argue that this measure effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
6. Prior and Related Legislation:
AB 1209 (Gonzalez Fletcher) of 2017: requires employers with 250 or more employees to submit to the Secretary of State’s Office, and post on a public internet site, information on gender pay differentials. AB 1209 is currently pending referral in Senate Rules Committee.
AB 46 (Cooper) of 2017: specifies that the Equal Pay Act provisions which prohibit employers from paying a lower wage rate to employees on the basis of gender, race, or ethnicity apply to both public and private employers.
AB 1676 (Campos), Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016: specifies that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation under the bona fide factor exception in the existing Equal Pay Act law.
SB 1063 (Hall) Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016: expands the prohibitions in the Equal Pay Act regarding gender, to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015, requires that men and women doing substantially similar work under similar working conditions be paid equally, unless the employer can demonstrate that the pay differential is based on certain enumerated factors.
AB 1017 (Campos) of 2015, Vetoed: would have prohibit an employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, except as otherwise provided. AB 1017 was very similar to this bill (AB 168); however, it did not include the pay scale provision and applied only to private employers.
SUPPORT
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
OPPOSITION
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
California Travel Association
Chambers of Commerce Alliance Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Western Growers Association
Western States Trucking Association
Wine Institute
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 168
Author:(Eggman)
As Amended Ver:May 15, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Labor | 5-2 | Thurmond, Chiu, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, McCarty | Flora, Harper |
Appropriations | 11-6 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Muratsuchi, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer, state and local government employers, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, as provided.
Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment, exempts state and local government employers from this requirement.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex in the same establishment for equal work on jobs the performance of which requires equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and which are performed under similar working conditions.
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the payment is made pursuant to a seniority system, a merit system, a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or a differential based on any bona fide factor other than sex.
- Amends the Equal Pay Act to prohibit employers from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex as required by these provisions, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with these provisions.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, absorbable costs for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce the provisions of this bill.
Unknown impact on the wages of public sector employees, particularly those not part of the state civil service, to the extent that this bill leads to higher wages for those employees.
COMMENTS: According to the author's office, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. Closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated.
Across the country, women still make roughly $0.80 for every dollar earned by their male counterparts. In California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn 39 billion dollars more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. [1]
For each woman in our state that is a difference of about $8,000 per year. The disparity is even larger for women of color. African American women are paid $0.63 and Latinas are paid $0.43 on the dollar.[2]
Additionally the author states that, currently in California mothers are the primary breadwinners in nearly 40% of families. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth.
Finally the author points out that in 2016 Massachusetts and Philadelphia enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants about their salary history. These new laws are the toughest in the nation in fighting wage discrimination. Similar salary history bans are being introduced other states as well, New Jersey, New York City, and Philadelphia.
Arguments in Support
The Consumer Federation of California supports this measure stating, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
Arguments in Opposition
The Association of California Water Agencies argues against this bill that it could result in unintended consequences and not actually close the wage gap for many applicants because most employers offer positions with a salary range in which new hires typically begin at the bottom of the range, unless they can negotiate a higher pay due to skill or previous salary history.
The Western States Trucking Association opposes this measure stating this bill effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
Prior and Related Legislation
AB 46 (Cooper) of the current legislative session expands California's pay equity laws for women and minorities to encompass all employees in both the public and private sector.
AB 1676 (Campos), Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016, requires that prior salary shall not, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
SB 1063 (Hall), Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016, expands the prohibitions in the California Equal Pay Act regarding gender, to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015, strengthens the California Equal Pay Act by, among other things, clarifying the relative burdens of proof and prohibiting retaliation against employees for disclosing or discussing their wages with co-workers.
AB 1017 (Campos) of 2015 was similar but not identical to this bill. AB 1017 was vetoed by Governor Brown. The Governor's veto message stated:
I agree with the sponsors that we must endeavor to ensure that all workers are paid fairly and do not receive a lower wage because of their gender or any other immutable characteristic that has no bearing on how they will perform in their job. This year, I signed SB 358 [(Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015] that gives California the strongest equal pay law in the nation. This bill, however, broadly prohibits employers from obtaining relevant information with little evidence that this would assure more equitable wages. Let's give SB 358 a chance to work before making further changes
Analysis Prepared by: Lorie Alvarez / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000371
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 168
Author:(Eggman)
As Introduced Ver:January 17, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Labor | 5-2 | Thurmond, Chiu, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, McCarty | Flora, Harper |
Appropriations | 11-6 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Muratsuchi, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer, state and local government employers, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, as provided.
Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment, exempts state and local government employers from this requirement.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex in the same establishment for equal work on jobs the performance of which requires equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and which are performed under similar working conditions.
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the payment is made pursuant to a seniority system, a merit system, a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or a differential based on any bona fide factor other than sex.
- Amends the Equal Pay Act to prohibit employers from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex as required by these provisions, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with these provisions.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, absorbable costs for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce the provisions of this bill.
Unknown impact on the wages of public sector employees, particularly those not part of the state civil service, to the extent that this bill leads to higher wages for those employees.
COMMENTS: According to the author's office, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. Closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated.
Across the country, women still make roughly $0.80 for every dollar earned by their male counterparts. In California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn 39 billion dollars more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. [1]
For each woman in our state that is a difference of about $8,000 per year. The disparity is even larger for women of color. African American women are paid $0.63 and Latinas are paid $0.43 on the dollar.[2]
Additionally the author states that, currently in California mothers are the primary breadwinners in nearly 40% of families. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth.
Finally the author points out that in 2016 Massachusetts and Philadelphia enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants about their salary history. These new laws are the toughest in the nation in fighting wage discrimination. Similar salary history bans are being introduced other states as well, New Jersey, New York City, and Philadelphia.
Arguments in Support
The Consumer Federation of California supports this measure stating, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
Arguments in Opposition
The Association of California Water Agencies argues against this bill that it could result in unintended consequences and not actually close the wage gap for many applicants because most employers offer positions with a salary range in which new hires typically begin at the bottom of the range, unless they can negotiate a higher pay due to skill or previous salary history.
The Western States Trucking Association opposes this measure stating this bill effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
Prior and Related Legislation
AB 46 (Cooper) of the current legislative session expands California's pay equity laws for women and minorities to encompass all employees in both the public and private sector.
AB 1676 (Campos), Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016 requires that prior salary shall not, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
SB 1063 (Hall), Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016 expands the prohibitions in the California Equal Pay Act regarding gender, to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015 strengthens the California Equal Pay Act by, among other things, clarifying the relative burdens of proof and prohibiting retaliation against employees for disclosing or discussing their wages with co-workers.
AB 1017 (Campos) of 2015 was similar but not identical to this bill. AB 1017 was vetoed by Governor Brown. The Governor's veto message stated:
I agree with the sponsors that we must endeavor to ensure that all workers are paid fairly and do not receive a lower wage because of their gender or any other immutable characteristic that has no bearing on how they will perform in their job. This year, I signed SB 358 [(Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015] that gives California the strongest equal pay law in the nation. This bill, however, broadly prohibits employers from obtaining relevant information with little evidence that this would assure more equitable wages. Let's give SB 358 a chance to work before making further changes
Analysis Prepared by: Lorie Alvarez / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000291
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 168
Author:(Eggman) – As Introduced Ver:January 17, 2017
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a public or private sector employer from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, as provided. Additionally, a private sector employer, upon reasonable request, must also provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Absorbable costs for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce the provisions of this bill.
- Unknown impact on the wages of public sector employees, particularly those not part of the state civil service, to the extent that this bill leads to higher wages for those employees.
COMMENTS:
- Background and Purpose. Across a variety of measures, women earn less than their male counterparts. The most commonly cited number shows that women are paid 80 cents for every dollar men are paid. This gap persists across age groups and education levels. For example, women with a college degree make $4 less per hour than their male peers.
According to supporters, AB 168 will ensure that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
- Past state efforts. The persistent gender pay gap has resulted in significant state efforts to curb wage discrimination. In 1949, California enacted the California Equal Pay Act, which targeted wage discrimination against women by prohibiting an employer from paying an employee a wage rate that is less than the rate of an employee of the opposite sex who does comparable work. SB 358 (Jackson) Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015, proposed a number of procedural and substantive changes to the California Equal Pay Act in order to make it easier for a victim of wage discrimination to identify an unlawful wage disparity and seek an appropriate remedy.
- Recent Legislation. AB 1676 (Campos) Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016, requires that prior salary shall not, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
- Related Legislation. AB 168 is related to a number of bills pending in this committee that strive to reduce the pay gap between workers. AB 46 (Cooper) applies California’s equal pays laws to the public sector, and AB 1209 (Gonzalez Fletcher) requires employers to collect specified information on gender pay differentials and for the employer to publish the information on its publicly accessible website. Both AB 46 and AB 1209 will be heard today.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Tony Thurmond, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 168 (
Author:Eggman) – As Introduced Ver:January 17, 2017
SUBJECT: Employers: salary information
SUMMARY:
- Prohibits an employer, state and local government employers, from seeking salary history information about an applicant for employment, as provided.
- Requires an employer, upon reasonable request, to provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant for employment, exempts state and local government employers from this requirement.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
- Prohibits an employer from paying an employee at wage rates less than the rates paid to employees of the opposite sex in the same establishment for equal work on jobs the performance of which requires equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and which are performed under similar working conditions.
- Establishes exceptions to this prohibition where the payment is made pursuant to a seniority system, a merit system, a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or a differential based on any bona fide factor other than sex.
- Amends the Equal Pay Act to prohibit employers from paying employees a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of a different race or ethnicity for substantially similar work.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person to pay or cause to be paid to any employee a wage less than the rate paid to an employee of the opposite sex as required by these provisions, or who reduces the wages of any employee in order to comply with these provisions.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: According to the author's office, gender wage discrimination is destructive not only for female workers but for our entire economy. Closing the wage gap starts with barring employers from asking questions about salary history so that previous salary discrimination is not perpetuated.
Across the country, women still make roughly 80¢ for every dollar earned by their male counterparts. In California alone, women who are employed full-time would earn 39 billion dollars more per year if they were paid equal to their male colleagues. [1]
For each woman in our state that is a difference of about $8,000 per year. The disparity is even larger for women of color. African American women are paid 63 cents and Latinas are paid 43 cents on the dollar.[2]
Additionally the author states that, currently in California mothers are the primary breadwinners in nearly 40 percent of families. These lost wages mean families have less money to spend on goods and services that help drive economic growth.
Finally the author points out that in 2016 Massachusetts and Philadelphia enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants about their salary history. These new laws are the toughest in the nation in fighting wage discrimination. Similar salary history bans are being introduced other states as well, New Jersey, New York City, and Philadelphia.
Arguments in Support
The Consumer Federation of California supports this measure stating, the wage gap is present regardless of industry, occupation or education level and the disparity is even larger for women of color. This bill ensures that job applicants, who have historically been victims of lower wages, will not continue to be plagued by unequal wages throughout their career.
Arguments in Opposition
The Association of California Water Agencies argues against this bill that it could result in unintended consequences and not actually close the wage gap for many applicants because most employers offer positions with a salary range in which new hires typically begin at the bottom of the range, unless they can negotiate a higher pay due to skill or previous salary history.
The Western States Trucking Association opposes this measure stating this bill effectively eliminates an employer's ability to negotiate wages and creates a new reason to sue.
Prior and Related Legislation
AB 46 (Cooper) of 2017 expands California’s pay equity laws for women and minorities to encompass all employees in both the public and private sector.
AB 1676 (Campos) Chapter 856, Statutes of 2016 requires that prior salary shall not, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
SB 1063 (Hall) Chapter 866, Statutes of 2016 expands the prohibitions in the California Equal Pay Act regarding gender, to include discrimination based on race or ethnicity.
SB 358 (Jackson) Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015 strengthens the California Equal Pay Act by, among other things, clarifying the relative burdens of proof and prohibiting retaliation against employees for disclosing or discussing their wages with co-workers.
AB 1017 (Campos) of 2015 was similar but not identical to this bill. AB 1017 was vetoed by Governor Brown. The Governor's veto message stated:
I agree with the sponsors that we must endeavor to ensure that all workers are paid fairly and do not receive a lower wage because of their gender or any other immutable characteristic that has no bearing on how they will perform in their job. This year, I signed SB 358 [(Jackson), Chapter 546, Statutes of 2015] that gives California the strongest equal pay law in the nation. This bill, however, broadly prohibits employers from obtaining relevant information with little evidence that this would assure more equitable wages. Let's give SB 358 a chance to work before making further changes
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Federation of California
Opposition
Association of California Water Agencies
Western States Trucking Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lorie Alvarez / L. & E. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):