AB 1571: Vehicles: driving under the influence: alcohol abuse programs.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-04-25
Existing law requires the court to impose as a condition of probation for a conviction for a first violation of driving under the influence, in a county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a driving-under-the-influence program, that the driver successfully complete the program in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. Existing law provides that enrollment and participation in, and completion of, an approved program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Existing law requires a county alcohol program administrator to coordinate court-established reporting requirements with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would require that enrollment in an approved program take place within 30 days of conviction, unless an extension of no longer than 30 days is granted by the court, as specified. The bill would also require the court, for first time offenders, to consider a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined, except for marijuana or a controlled substance prescribed by a licensed physician or dentist, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation, as specified. The bill would require the county alcohol program administrator to additionally coordinate court referral and tracking documents with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services. By imposing new duties on a county employee, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law authorizes a court, as a condition of probation, to refer a person convicted for driving under the influence to a licensed program, as specified, even though the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. Existing law requires a clerk of the court to indicate the duration of the treatment program the judge has ordered a person to participate in the abstract of the court record that is forwarded to the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would instead require a court to refer a person with a 2nd or subsequent driving under the influence driving-under-the-influence conviction to a licensed program as a condition of probation even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. The bill would require the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law requires the court to impose as a condition of probation for a conviction for a first violation of driving under the influence, in a county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a driving-under-the-influence program, that the driver successfully complete the program in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. Existing law provides that enrollment and participation in, and completion of, an approved program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Existing law requires a court to refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20% or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test to participate in a licensed program, as specified, for at least 9 months or longer. Existing law requires a county alcohol program administrator to coordinate court-established reporting requirements with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would require that enrollment in an approved program take place within 30 days of conviction. The bill would also require the court to refer a first offender whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15% or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined, to the 9-month program described above. conviction, unless an extension of no longer than 30 days is granted by the court, as specified. The bill would also require the court, for first time offenders, to consider a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation, as specified. The bill would require the county alcohol program administrator to additionally coordinate court referral and tracking documents with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services. By imposing new duties on a county employee, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law provides that if a person is convicted of a driving-under-the-influence violation, the court is required to consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15% or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, whether to grant probation, and if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
This bill would additionally require the court to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined, as a special factor for purposes of these provisions.
Existing law authorizes a court, as a condition of probation, to refer a person convicted for driving under the influence to a licensed program, as specified, even though the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. Existing law requires a clerk of the court to indicate the duration of the treatment program the judge has ordered a person to participate in the abstract of the court record that is forwarded to the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would instead require a court to refer a person with a 2nd or subsequent driving under the influence conviction to a licensed program as a condition of probation even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. The bill would require the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents. The bill would make other conforming changes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law requires the court to impose as a condition of probation for a conviction for a first violation of driving under the influence, in a county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a driving-under-the-influence program, that the driver successfully complete the program in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. Existing law provides that enrollment and participation in, and completion of, an approved program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Existing law requires a court to refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20% or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test to participate in a licensed program, as specified, for at least 9 months or longer. Existing law requires a county alcohol program administrator to coordinate court-established reporting requirements with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would require that enrollment in an approved program take place within 30 days of conviction. The bill would also require the court to refer a first offender whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15% or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined, to the 9-month program described above. The bill would require the county alcohol program administrator to additionally coordinate court referral and tracking documents with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services. By imposing new duties on a county employee, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law provides that if a person is convicted of a driving-under-the-influence violation, the court is required to consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15% or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, whether to grant probation, and if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
This bill would additionally require the court to consider a any blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined, as a special factor for purposes of the these provisions.
Existing law authorizes a court, as a condition of probation, to refer a person convicted for driving under the influence to a licensed program, as specified, even though the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. Existing law requires a clerk of the court to indicate the duration of the treatment program the judge has ordered a person to participate in the abstract of the court record that is forwarded to the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would instead require a court to refer a person with a 2nd or subsequent driving under the influence conviction to a licensed program as a condition of probation even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. The bill would require the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents. The bill would make other conforming changes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law requires the court to impose as a condition of probation for a conviction for a first violation of driving under the influence, in a county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a driving-under-the-influence program, that the driver successfully complete the program in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. Existing law provides that enrollment and participation in, and completion of, an approved program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Existing law requires a court to refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20% or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test to participate in a licensed program, as specified, for at least 9 months or longer. Existing law requires a county alcohol program administrator to coordinate court-established reporting requirements with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would require that enrollment in an approved program take place within 30 days of conviction. The bill would also require the court to refer a first offender whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15% or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined, to the 9-month program described above. The bill would require the county alcohol program administrator to additionally coordinate court referral and tracking documents with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services. By imposing new duties on a county employee, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law provides that if a person is convicted of a driving-under-the-influence violation, the court is required to consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15% or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, whether to grant probation, and if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
This bill would additionally require the court to consider a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined, as a special factor for purposes of the these provisions.
Existing law authorizes a court, as a condition of probation, to refer a person to a licensed program, as specified, even though the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. Existing law requires a clerk of the court to indicate the duration of the treatment program the judge has ordered a person to participate in the abstract of the court record that is forwarded to the State Department of Health Care Services.
This bill would instead require a court to refer a person to a licensed program as a condition of probation. The bill would require the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents. The bill would make other conforming changes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
(a)Pursuant to the provisions of law relating to suspension of a persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle upon conviction for driving while under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and any drug, as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 of the Vehicle Code, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall restrict the driving privilege pursuant to Section 13352.5 of the Vehicle Code, if the person convicted of that offense participates for at least 18 months in a driving-under-the-influence program that is licensed pursuant to this chapter.
(b)In determining whether to refer a person, who is ordered to participate in a program pursuant to Section 668 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, in a licensed alcohol and other drug education and counseling services program pursuant to Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code, or, pursuant to Section 23542, 23548, 23552, 23556, 23562, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code, in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program, the court may consider any relevant information about the person made available pursuant to a presentence investigation, that is permitted but not required under Section 23655 of the Vehicle Code, or other screening procedure. That information shall not be furnished, however, by any person who also provides services in a privately operated, licensed program or who has any direct interest in a privately operated, licensed program. In addition, the court shall obtain from the Department of Motor Vehicles a copy of the persons driving record to determine whether the person is eligible to participate in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program pursuant to this chapter. When preparing a presentence report for the court, the probation department may consider the suitability of placing the defendant in a treatment program that includes the administration of nonscheduled nonaddicting medications to ameliorate an alcohol or controlled substance problem. If the probation department recommends that this type of program is a suitable option for the defendant, the defendant who would like the court to consider this option shall obtain from his or her physician a prescription for the medication, and a finding that the treatment is medically suitable for the defendant, prior to consideration of this alternative by the court.
(c)(1)The court shall, as a condition of probation pursuant to Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code, refer a first offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in granting probation to a first offender described in this subdivision whose concentration of alcohol in the persons blood was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall order the person to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(d)(1)The State Department of Health Care Services may specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)Any program licensed pursuant to this chapter may provide treatment services to participants receiving at least six months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)The court shall, subject to Section 11837.2, and as a condition of probation, refer a person with a second or subsequent violation to a licensed program, even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. An 18-month program described in Section 23542 or 23562 of the Vehicle Code or a 30-month program described in Section 23548, 23552, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code may include treatment of family members and significant other persons related to the convicted person with the consent of those family members and others as described in this chapter, if there is no increase in the costs of the program to the convicted person.
(f)The clerk of the court shall indicate the duration of the program in which the judge has ordered the person to participate in the abstract of the record of the court and on the court referral and tracking documents forwarded to the department.
SEC. 2.Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23538.(a)(1)If the court grants probation to a person punished under Section 23536, in addition to the provisions of Section 23600 and any other terms and conditions imposed by the court, the court shall impose as a condition of probation that the person pay a fine of at least three hundred ninety dollars ($390), but not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000). The court may also impose, as a condition of probation, that the person be confined in a county jail for at least 48 hours, but not more than six months.
(2)The persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle shall be suspended by the department under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1. The court shall require the person to surrender the drivers license to the court in accordance with Section 13550.
(3)Whenever, when considering the circumstances taken as a whole, the court determines that the person punished under this section would present a traffic safety or public safety risk if authorized to operate a motor vehicle during the period of suspension imposed under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1, the court may disallow the issuance of a restricted drivers license required under Section 13352.4.
(b)In any county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a program or programs described in Section 11837.3 of the Health and Safety Code, the court shall also impose as a condition of probation that the driver shall enroll and participate in, and successfully complete a driving-under-the-influence program, licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code, in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. For the purposes of this subdivision, enrollment in an approved program shall take place within 30 days of conviction and participation in, and completion of, the program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Credit may not be given for any program activities completed prior to the date of the current violation. If a person is unable to enroll in a program within 30 days of conviction, the court may grant that person an extension of no longer than 30 days upon the request of the program provider. Extensions may be requested or granted by telephone or by other electronic means.
(1)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)The court shall consider, for first time offenders, a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08 percent or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, except marijuana, as defined in paragraph (16) of Section 802 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or a controlled substance prescribed by a licensed physician or dentist, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation with regards to referrals and participation in licensed programs and program activities described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)The court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a driving-under-the-influence program of the length required under this code that is licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code has been received in the departments headquarters.
(c)(1)The court shall revoke the persons probation pursuant to Section 23602, except for good cause shown, for the failure to enroll in, participate in, or complete a program specified in subdivision (b).
(2)The court, in establishing reporting requirements, shall consult with the county alcohol program administrator. The county alcohol program administrator shall coordinate the reporting requirements and court referral and tracking documents with the department and with the State Department of Health Care Services. That reporting shall ensure that all persons who, after being ordered to attend and complete a program, may be identified for either (A) failure to enroll in, or failure to successfully complete, the program, or (B) successful completion of the program as ordered.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Pursuant to the provisions of law relating to suspension of a persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle upon conviction for driving while under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and any drug, as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 of the Vehicle Code, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall restrict the driving privilege pursuant to Section 13352.5 of the Vehicle Code, if the person convicted of that offense participates for at least 18 months in a driving-under-the-influence program that is licensed pursuant to this chapter.
(b)In determining whether to refer a person, who is ordered to participate in a program pursuant to Section 668 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, in a licensed alcohol and other drug education and counseling services program pursuant to Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code, or, pursuant to Section 23542, 23548, 23552, 23556, 23562, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code, in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program, the court may consider any relevant information about the person made available pursuant to a presentence investigation, that is permitted but not required under Section 23655 of the Vehicle Code, or other screening procedure. That information shall not be furnished, however, by any person who also provides services in a privately operated, licensed program or who has any direct interest in a privately operated, licensed program. In addition, the court shall obtain from the Department of Motor Vehicles a copy of the persons driving record to determine whether the person is eligible to participate in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program pursuant to this chapter. When preparing a presentence report for the court, the probation department may consider the suitability of placing the defendant in a treatment program that includes the administration of nonscheduled nonaddicting medications to ameliorate an alcohol or controlled substance problem. If the probation department recommends that this type of program is a suitable option for the defendant, the defendant who would like the court to consider this option shall obtain from his or her physician a prescription for the medication, and a finding that the treatment is medically suitable for the defendant, prior to consideration of this alternative by the court.
(c)(1)The court shall, as a condition of probation pursuant to Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code, refer a first offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in granting probation to a first offender described in this subdivision whose concentration of alcohol in the persons blood was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall order the person to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(d)(1)The State Department of Health Care Services may specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)Any program licensed pursuant to this chapter may provide treatment services to participants receiving at least six months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)The court shall, subject to Section 11837.2, and as a condition of probation, refer a person with a second or subsequent violation to a licensed program, even program even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. An 18-month program described in Section 23542 or 23562 of the Vehicle Code or a 30-month program described in Section 23548, 23552, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code may include treatment of family members and significant other persons related to the convicted person with the consent of those family members and others as described in this chapter, if there is no increase in the costs of the program to the convicted person.
(f)The clerk of the court shall indicate the duration of the program in which the judge has ordered the person to participate in the abstract of the record of the court and on the court referral and tracking documents forwarded to the department.
SEC. 2.Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23538.(a)(1)If the court grants probation to a person punished under Section 23536, in addition to the provisions of Section 23600 and any other terms and conditions imposed by the court, the court shall impose as a condition of probation that the person pay a fine of at least three hundred ninety dollars ($390), but not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000). The court may also impose, as a condition of probation, that the person be confined in a county jail for at least 48 hours, but not more than six months.
(2)The persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle shall be suspended by the department under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1. The court shall require the person to surrender the drivers license to the court in accordance with Section 13550.
(3)Whenever, when considering the circumstances taken as a whole, the court determines that the person punished under this section would present a traffic safety or public safety risk if authorized to operate a motor vehicle during the period of suspension imposed under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1, the court may disallow the issuance of a restricted drivers license required under Section 13352.4.
(b)In any county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a program or programs described in Section 11837.3 of the Health and Safety Code, the court shall also impose as a condition of probation that the driver shall enroll and participate in, and successfully complete a driving-under-the-influence program, licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code, in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. For the purposes of this subdivision, enrollment in an approved program shall take place within 30 days of conviction and participation in, and completion of, the program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Credit may not be given for any program activities completed prior to the date of the current violation. If a person is unable to enroll in a program within 30 days of conviction, the court may grant that person an extension of no longer than 30 days upon the request of the program provider. Extensions may be requested or granted by telephone or by other electronic means.
(1)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or who refused to take a chemical test, test to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)The court shall consider, for first time offenders, a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08 percent or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation with regards to referrals and participation in licensed programs and program activities described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)
(4)The court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a driving-under-the-influence program of the length required under this code that is licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code has been received in the departments headquarters.
(c)(1)The court shall revoke the persons probation pursuant to Section 23602, except for good cause shown, for the failure to enroll in, participate in, or complete a program specified in subdivision (b).
(2)The court, in establishing reporting requirements, shall consult with the county alcohol program administrator. The county alcohol program administrator shall coordinate the reporting requirements and court referral and tracking documents with the department and with the State Department of Health Care Services. That reporting shall ensure that all persons who, after being ordered to attend and complete a program, may be identified for either (A) failure to enroll in, or failure to successfully complete, the program, or (B) successful completion of the program as ordered.
SEC. 3.Section 23578 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23578.In addition to any other provision of this code, if a person is convicted of a violation of Section 23152 or 23153, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Pursuant to the provisions of law relating to suspension of a persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle upon conviction for driving while under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and any drug, as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 of the Vehicle Code, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall restrict the driving privilege pursuant to Section 13352.5 of the Vehicle Code, if the person convicted of that offense participates for at least 18 months in a driving-under-the-influence program that is licensed pursuant to this chapter.
(b)In determining whether to refer a person, who is ordered to participate in a program pursuant to Section 668 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, in a licensed alcohol and other drug education and counseling services program pursuant to Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code, or, pursuant to Section 23542, 23548, 23552, 23556, 23562, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code, in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program, the court may consider any relevant information about the person made available pursuant to a presentence investigation, that is permitted but not required under Section 23655 of the Vehicle Code, or other screening procedure. That information shall not be furnished, however, by any person who also provides services in a privately operated, licensed program or who has any direct interest in a privately operated, licensed program. In addition, the court shall obtain from the Department of Motor Vehicles a copy of the persons driving record to determine whether the person is eligible to participate in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program pursuant to this chapter. When preparing a presentence report for the court, the probation department may consider the suitability of placing the defendant in a treatment program that includes the administration of nonscheduled nonaddicting medications to ameliorate an alcohol or controlled substance problem. If the probation department recommends that this type of program is a suitable option for the defendant, the defendant who would like the court to consider this option shall obtain from his or her physician a prescription for the medication, and a finding that the treatment is medically suitable for the defendant, prior to consideration of this alternative by the court.
(c)(1)The court shall, as a condition of probation pursuant to Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code, refer a first offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in granting probation to a first offender described in this subdivision whose concentration of alcohol in the persons blood was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall order the person to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(d)(1)The State Department of Health Care Services may specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)Any program licensed pursuant to this chapter may provide treatment services to participants receiving at least six months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)The court shall, subject to Section 11837.2, and as a condition of probation, refer a person with a second or subsequent violation to a licensed program, even though program even if the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. An 18-month program described in Section 23542 or 23562 of the Vehicle Code or a 30-month program described in Section 23548, 23552, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code may include treatment of family members and significant other persons related to the convicted person with the consent of those family members and others as described in this chapter, if there is no increase in the costs of the program to the convicted person.
(f)The clerk of the court shall indicate the duration of the program in which the judge has ordered the person to participate in the abstract of the record of the court and on the court referral and tracking documents forwarded to the department.
SEC. 2.Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23538.(a)(1)If the court grants probation to a person punished under Section 23536, in addition to the provisions of Section 23600 and any other terms and conditions imposed by the court, the court shall impose as a condition of probation that the person pay a fine of at least three hundred ninety dollars ($390), but not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000). The court may also impose, as a condition of probation, that the person be confined in a county jail for at least 48 hours, but not more than six months.
(2)The persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle shall be suspended by the department under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1. The court shall require the person to surrender the drivers license to the court in accordance with Section 13550.
(3)Whenever, when considering the circumstances taken as a whole, the court determines that the person punished under this section would present a traffic safety or public safety risk if authorized to operate a motor vehicle during the period of suspension imposed under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1, the court may disallow the issuance of a restricted drivers license required under Section 13352.4.
(b)In any county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a program or programs described in Section 11837.3 of the Health and Safety Code, the court shall also impose as a condition of probation that the driver shall enroll and participate in, and successfully complete a driving-under-the-influence program, licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code, in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. For the purposes of this subdivision, enrollment in an approved program shall take place within 30 days of conviction and participation in, and completion of, the program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Credit may not be given for any program activities completed prior to the date of the current violation.
(1)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or who refused to take a chemical test, to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)The court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a driving-under-the-influence program of the length required under this code that is licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code has been received in the departments headquarters.
(c)(1)The court shall revoke the persons probation pursuant to Section 23602, except for good cause shown, for the failure to enroll in, participate in, or complete a program specified in subdivision (b).
(2)The court, in establishing reporting requirements, shall consult with the county alcohol program administrator. The county alcohol program administrator shall coordinate the reporting requirements and court referral and tracking documents with the department and with the State Department of Health Care Services. That reporting shall ensure that all persons who, after being ordered to attend and complete a program, may be identified for either (A) failure to enroll in, or failure to successfully complete, the program, or (B) successful completion of the program as ordered.
SEC. 3.Section 23578 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23578.In addition to any other provision of this code, if a person is convicted of a violation of Section 23152 or 23153, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, a any blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08 percent or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, test as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Pursuant to the provisions of law relating to suspension of a persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle upon conviction for driving while under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and any drug, as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 of the Vehicle Code, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall restrict the driving privilege pursuant to Section 13352.5 of the Vehicle Code, if the person convicted of that offense participates for at least 18 months in a driving-under-the-influence program that is licensed pursuant to this chapter.
(b)In determining whether to refer a person, who is ordered to participate in a program pursuant to Section 668 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, in a licensed alcohol and other drug education and counseling services program pursuant to Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code, or, pursuant to Section 23542, 23548, 23552, 23556, 23562, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code, in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program, the court may consider any relevant information about the person made available pursuant to a presentence investigation, that is permitted but not required under Section 23655 of the Vehicle Code, or other screening procedure. That information shall not be furnished, however, by any person who also provides services in a privately operated, licensed program or who has any direct interest in a privately operated, licensed program. In addition, the court shall obtain from the Department of Motor Vehicles a copy of the persons driving record to determine whether the person is eligible to participate in a licensed 18-month or 30-month program pursuant to this chapter. When preparing a presentence report for the court, the probation department may consider the suitability of placing the defendant in a treatment program that includes the administration of nonscheduled nonaddicting medications to ameliorate an alcohol or controlled substance problem. If the probation department recommends that this type of program is a suitable option for the defendant, the defendant who would like the court to consider this option shall obtain from his or her physician a prescription for the medication, and a finding that the treatment is medically suitable for the defendant, prior to consideration of this alternative by the court.
(c)(1)The court shall, as a condition of probation pursuant to Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code, refer a first offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in granting probation to a first offender described in this subdivision whose concentration of alcohol in the persons blood was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or the person who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall order the person to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in this chapter.
(d)(1)The State Department of Health Care Services may specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)Any program licensed pursuant to this chapter may provide treatment services to participants receiving at least six months of licensed program services under Section 23538 or 23556 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)The court may, shall, subject to Section 11837.2, and as a condition of probation, refer a person to a licensed program, even though the persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle is restricted, suspended, or revoked. An 18-month program described in Section 23542 or 23562 of the Vehicle Code or a 30-month program described in Section 23548, 23552, or 23568 of the Vehicle Code may include treatment of family members and significant other persons related to the convicted person with the consent of those family members and others as described in this chapter, if there is no increase in the costs of the program to the convicted person.
(f)The clerk of the court shall indicate the duration of the program in which the judge has ordered the person to participate in the abstract of the record of the court that is and on the court referral and tracking documents forwarded to the department.
SEC. 2.Section 23538 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23538.(a)(1)If the court grants probation to person punished under Section 23536, in addition to the provisions of Section 23600 and any other terms and conditions imposed by the court, the court shall impose as a condition of probation that the person pay a fine of at least three hundred ninety dollars ($390), but not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000). The court may also impose, as a condition of probation, that the person be confined in a county jail for at least 48 hours, but not more than six months.
(2)The persons privilege to operate a motor vehicle shall be suspended by the department under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1. The court shall require the person to surrender the drivers license to the court in accordance with Section 13550.
(3)Whenever, when considering the circumstances taken as a whole, the court determines that the person punished under this section would present a traffic safety or public safety risk if authorized to operate a motor vehicle during the period of suspension imposed under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or Section 13352.1, the court may disallow the issuance of a restricted drivers license required under Section 13352.4.
(b)In any county where the board of supervisors has approved, and the State Department of Health Care Services has licensed, a program or programs described in Section 11837.3 of the Health and Safety Code, the court shall also impose as a condition of probation that the driver shall enroll and participate in, and successfully complete a driving-under-the-influence program, licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code, in the drivers county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. For the purposes of this subdivision, enrollment in, in an approved program shall take place within 30 days of conviction and participation in, and completion of an approved of, the program shall be subsequent to the date of the current violation. Credit may not be given for any program activities completed prior to the date of the current violation.
(1)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)The court shall refer a first offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, and a controlled substance, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or who refused to take a chemical test, to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, including those education, group counseling, and individual interview sessions described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 11836) of Part 2 of Division 10.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)The court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a driving-under-the-influence program of the length required under this code that is licensed pursuant to Section 11836 of the Health and Safety Code has been received in the departments headquarters.
(c)(1)The court shall revoke the persons probation pursuant to Section 23602, except for good cause shown, for the failure to enroll in, participate in, or complete a program specified in subdivision (b).
(2)The court, in establishing reporting requirements, shall consult with the county alcohol program administrator. The county alcohol program administrator shall coordinate the reporting requirements and court referral and tracking documents with the department and with the State Department of Health Care Services. That reporting shall ensure that all persons who, after being ordered to attend and complete a program, may be identified for either (A) failure to enroll in, or failure to successfully complete, the program, or (B) successful completion of the program as ordered.
SEC. 3.Section 23578 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23578.In addition to any other provision of this code, if a person is convicted of a violation of Section 23152 or 23153, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the persons blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08 percent or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the persons blood, as defined in Section 812 of Chapter 13 of Title 21 of the United States Code, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 27, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 18, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2016 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 21, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (April 20). |
| Apr 5, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 29, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 15, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Feb 24, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 23, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 1, 2016 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jan 5, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 4. |
| Jan 4, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 20, 2016 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 18, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1571
Author:(Lackey) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2016
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the court to consider a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 or more, in combination with the presence of specified drugs, excluding marijuana and drugs prescribed by a physician, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation and referral to a licensed program, for first time driving-under-the-influence (DUI) offenders. It also requires the court to refer a person with a second or subsequent DUI conviction to a program, as specified, as a condition of probation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Cost to DOJ in the $400,000 to $500,000 range. Bureau of Forensics Services has identified a need for three Senior Criminalists to handle the increase in toxicology screening of samples for controlled substances. Along with these positions, $75,000 one-time costs would be needed for a Dynex screening instrument along with $25,000 of ongoing costs for reagent supplies.
Absorbable cost to the courts.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Under current law, courts have the power to increase punishments in situations when the combined use of alcohol and drugs warrant such an increase. Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendant. Courts may impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice, make amends to society and individuals injured by the defendant’s unlawful conduct, and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation of the probationer.” A condition of probation is valid if it is reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future.
If the facts demonstrate that the type or level of drugs in the individual’s system increased the dangerousness of conduct resulting in a DUI, the court can require the defendant to attend a longer DUI program. Under existing law, the court could also impose additional probation conditions such as substance abuse treatment or testing for drugs, as long as the conditions were reasonably related to the offense. - Purpose. According to the author, “Drugged-driving has seen a dramatic increase in the past several years. According to the DMV’s annual report of the DUI Management Information System (MIS), the number of drug-involved crash fatalities increased by 15.4% in 2012. Drug-involved fatalities represent 28.7% of the total number of deaths associated with car crashes…., this bill allows the courts to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with a controlled substance as special factor that may justify enhancing the terms of a DUI treatment program.”
Research has established that there is a close relationship between BAC level and impairment. However, the behavioral effects of other drugs are not as well understood compared to the behavioral effects of alcohol. Certain generalizations can be made: high doses generally have a larger effect than small doses; well-learned tasks are less affected than novel tasks; and certain variables, such as prior exposure to a drug, can either reduce or accentuate expected effects, depending on circumstances. Also, the presence of a drug metabolite in a biological fluid may or may not reflect consumption of the drug recently enough to impair driving performance. Furthermore, there are individual differences in absorption, distribution, and metabolism. Some individuals will show evidence of impairment at drug concentrations that are not associated with impairment in others. Thus, the ability to predict an individual’s performance at a specific dosage of drugs other than alcohol is limited.
This bill requires the court to consider specified drug consumption as an aggravating factor in sentencing even if there was no corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive.
- Support. According to the California Police Chiefs Association, DUI Treatment programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders. AB 1571 will significantly reduce the number of repeat concurrent use offenders in California.
- Opposition. The Drug Policy Alliance, is opposed on three grounds: there is poor correlation between the presence of drugs and impairment; drug testing is technical and imperfect; and AB 1571 cross references federal law that may or may not be aligned with California law.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail time to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1487 (Berryhill), of the 2007-2008 Legislative Session, would have decreased the blood alcohol content (BAC) of a person convicted of DUI for referral to a lengthier driving under the influence program, as specified. AB 1487 died in the Senate Public Safety Committee,
- AB 1352 (Liu), Chapter 164, Statutes of 2005, requires a first time DUI offender with blood alcohol content .20 or more to attend a 9 month DUI educational program.
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail time to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2016
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
As Proposed to be Amended in Committee
SUMMARY:
Requires the court to consider a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 or more, in combination with the presence of specified drugs, excluding marijuana and drugs prescribed by a physician, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation, for first time driving under the influence (DUI) offenders. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the court to consider a BAC of 0.08 percent or more, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined the United States Code, except marijuana, as specified, or a controlled substance prescribed by a licensed physician or dentist, as an aggravating factor in sentencing for first time DUI offenders.
- Specifies that the mandatory consideration of such an aggravating factor, may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation with regards to participation in specified DUI programs.
- Requires that enrollment in an approved DUI program for first offenders take place within 30 days of conviction.
- Allows the court to grant an extension of no longer than 30 days upon the request of the program provider.
- Allows an extension to be requested or granted by telephone or by other electronic means.
- Requires a court to refer a person with a second or subsequent DUI conviction to a program, as specified, as a condition of probation.
- Requires the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test, to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(2).)
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(1).)
- Specifies that if a person is convicted of a violation of Section DUI or DUI with injury, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the person's blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation. (Veh. Code § 23578.)
- States that the court shall also impose as a condition of probation, upon conviction of a first DUI, that the driver shall complete a DUI program, licensed as specified, in the driver's county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b).)
- In lieu of the DUI education program, a court may impose, as a condition of probation, that the person complete, subsequent to the underlying conviction, a residential live in program dealing with substance abuse, if the person consents and has been accepted into that program. (Veh. Code, § 23598.)
- States that the court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a DUI program of the length required under this code that is licensed, as specified, has been received in the department's headquarters. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(3).)
- Requires the court to refer a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as a condition of probation, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(1).)
- Requires the court to order a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in the person's blood was 0.20 percent or more, or the person refused to take a chemical test, to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, as a condition of probation. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(2).)
- Allows the State Department of Health Care Services to specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (d).)
- Specifies that "probation" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of conditional and revocable release in the community under the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Specifies that "conditional sentence" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of revocable release in the community subject to conditions established by the court without the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Provides that the court, in granting probation, may suspend the imposing or the execution of the sentence and may direct that the suspension may continue for a period of time not exceeding the maximum possible term of the sentence, except as specified, and upon those terms and conditions as it shall determine. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.)
- States that the court may impose and require any or all of the terms of imprisonment, fine, and conditions, and other reasonable conditions, as it may determine are fitting and proper to the end that justice may be done and for the rehabilitation of the probationer, and that should the probationer violate any of the terms or conditions imposed by the court in the matter, it shall have authority to modify and change any and all the terms and conditions and to reimprison the probationer in the county jail, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1, subd. (j).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "Drugged-driving has seen a dramatic increase in the past several years. According to the DMV’s annual report of the DUI Management Information System (MIS), the number of drug-involved crash fatalities increased by 15.4% in 2012. Drug-involved fatalities represent 28.7% of the total number of deaths associated with car crashes. We should treat the issue of drunk-and drugged-driving as a health issue rather than a criminal one. DUI Treatment Programs include educational group counseling sessions as well as individual interviews that showcase the severity of mixing alcohol with drugs while driving.
“Effective January 1st, 2014, California statute made it explicitly clear that it is unlawful for a person to drive under the combined influence of drugs and alcohol. This bill requires all first DUI offenders convicted with a blood-alcohol concentration of .15 and above and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9 month program (Current law requires 6 month). Furthermore, this bill allows the courts to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with a controlled substance as special factor that may justify enhancing the terms of a DUI treatment program.
“DUI Treatment Programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders through sessions that focus on alcohol and drug abuse. These programs are affordable and in cases of financial hardship some or all fees associated with the program can be waived. This bill narrowly targets first-offenders and will serve as a deterrent for anyone who might get behind the wheel while intoxicated under a mixture of alcohol and drugs.” - The Effect of Drugs On an Individual’s Ability to Drive is Not Well Understood: Research has established that there is a close relationship between BAC level and impairment. Some effects are detectable at very low BACs (e.g., .02 grams per deciliter, or g/dL) and as BAC rises, the types and severity of impairment increase. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The behavioral effects of other drugs are not as well understood compared to the behavioral effects of alcohol. Certain generalizations can be made: high doses generally have a larger effect than small doses; well-learned tasks are less affected than novel tasks; and certain variables, such as prior exposure to a drug, can either reduce or accentuate expected effects, depending on circumstances. However, the ability to predict an individual’s performance at a specific dosage of drugs other than alcohol is limited. Most psychoactive drugs are chemically complex molecules whose absorption, action, and elimination from the body are difficult to predict. Further, there are considerable differences between individuals with regard to the rates with which these processes occur. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The presence of a drug in a person’s blood sample might indicate a drug that was affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken, or it might indicate a drug that was consumed at some point in the past and was no longer affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken. The length of time that a drug or its metabolite is present in a given biological sample is often called its detection time. This may vary depending on the dose (amount), route of administration (injected, inhaled etc.) and elimination rate (how long it takes the body to get rid of the substance). The presence of a drug metabolite in a biological fluid may or may not reflect consumption of the drug recently enough to impair driving performance. (Drug Toxicology for Prosecutors, American Prosecutors Research Institute (2004), p. 8.)
There are additional factors that complicate the determination of the effects on drugs on driving impairment. There are individual differences in absorption, distribution, and metabolism. Some individuals will show evidence of impairment at drug concentrations that are not associated with impairment in others. Wide ranges of drug concentrations in different individuals have been associated with equivalent levels of impairment. In certain instances drugs can be detected in the blood because of accumulation. Blood levels of some drugs or their metabolites may accumulate with repeated administrations if the time-course of elimination is insufficient. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, p. 3.) Because of these factors, specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with effects on driver performance. - Requiring Consideration of an Aggravating Factor in Situations Where There is Not Necessarily a Corresponding Increase in the Seriousness of the Criminal Behavior: Generally, under California criminal law, an individual only faces increased penalties for conduct that made the nature of the crime more serious. When evaluating the seriousness of a DUI, the most common measure is the impairment level of the driver. The higher the impairment of the driver, the bigger danger the driver represents to the public. As discussed above, the presence of a controlled substance in an individual’s blood does not necessarily reflect a corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive. This bill requires the court to consider specified drug consumption as an aggravating factor in sentencing even if there was no corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive.
- Existing Judicial Discretion: Courts have the power under existing law to increase punishments in situations when the combined use of alcohol and drugs warrant such an increase. Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendant. (People v. Smith (2007) 152, Cal.App.4th 1245, 1249.) Courts may impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice, make amends to society and individuals injured by the defendant’s unlawful conduct, and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation of the probationer.” (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.) A condition of probation is valid if it is reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114, 1121.)
If the facts demonstrate that the type or level of drugs in the individual’s system increased the dangerousness of conduct resulting in a DUI, the court can require that defendant to attend a longer DUI program. Under existing law, the court could also impose additional probation conditions such as substance abuse treatment or testing for drugs, as long as the conditions were reasonably related to the offense. - Requiring an Individual to Enroll in DUI Education Program Specified Time from Conviction May Create Additional Work for Courts: This bill requires that enrollment in a DUI education program for a first time DUI offender, take place within 30 days of the conviction (possibly extended to 60 days). That requirement may create additional workload for the courts.
Under existing law, DMV suspends an individual’s driver’s license for six months upon conviction of a first DUI (Veh. Code, § 13352.). In order to get full license privileges back, the individual must complete the DUI education program. If the individual wants to get a restricted license, allowing them to drive to work during the suspension period, the person must be enrolled in the DUI education program. Existing law provides incentives and penalties to enter and complete the program in order to drive. In addition, the DUI education program is a condition of probation. So failure to enroll and complete the program exposes the individual to additional sanctions by the court. Arguably, those are sufficient incentives for an individual to enroll and complete the DUI program.
Under this bill, if an individual fails to enroll within 30 days he will have violated the law. If the individual then attempts to enroll in the program beyond 30 days, it is likely they will not be allowed to enroll by a DUI education program provider. That individual will then have to schedule a court date and make an appearance in front of the judge to be re-referred to the DUI program. This may create additional volume for the courts.
This bill contains a provision that would allow the court to extend the 30 day deadline to 60 days and allows requests to be made by a treatment provider through electronic or telephonic means. The procedure to extend the deadline is not consistent with the standard judicial process.
Generally, when a court makes decisions and issues orders, the case on which the action is being taken is on calendar, the parties, or their legal representatives are present, and the hearing is open to the public. This framework is in place to ensure that parties have notice and an opportunity to be heard. It also ensures that one party is not communicating with the judge about the case outside presence of the other party. The framework ensures that the judicial process is conducted in an open and public forum.
This bill would be a significant departure from the normal judicial process by having a 3rd party (program provider) communicate informally to obtain an extension. Is it anticipated that the program provider will be calling up the judge responsible for the case to ask permission to extend? Are the parties required to be notified? If the timeframe is extended, who is responsible for notifying the defendant? It is not clear that this bill provides a workable procedure to extend the deadline to enroll in the DUI program. - Argument in Support: According to The California Police Chiefs Association, “The California Police Chiefs Association is pleased to support AB 1571, which updates the California DUI treatment program structure to reflect the prevalence of concurrent drug and alcohol use by California drivers. In addition to other changes, AB 1571 allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC of .08 to .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 6-month program and allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC above .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9-month program.
“The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA's) 2013-2014 National Roadside Survey found that more than 22 percent of drivers tested positive for illegal, prescription, or over-the-counter drugs. In fact, the National Roadside Survey of Alcohol and Drug Use by Drivers, a nationally representative survey by NHTSA, found that in 2007, approximately one in eight nighttime weekend drivers tested positive for illicit drugs. Equally disturbing are the 2011 results from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health indicating that 9.9 million Americans 12 or older reported driving under the influence of illicit drugs in the past year. Using a health-based treatment approach, AB 1571 will reduce this upward trend.
“DUI Treatment programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders. AB 1571 will significantly reduce the number of repeat concurrent use offenders in California. Thank you for your leadership on this matter.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Drug Policy Alliance, “First, while we do not advocate for anyone to drive while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, no one should receive sentencing enhancements or additional terms of probation based on arbitrary data. Not enough is known about the effects of drugs, or the combination of drugs and alcohol, on driver safety. Because of the paucity of information on this topic, the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) noted in 2015 report that “specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with a specific degree of driver impairment.” The report explained that, unlike alcohol – where there is a strong correlation between blood alcohol levels and the degree of driver impairment – there is a poor correlation between the presence of drugs in the blood and the impairing effects of the drugs. This can be explained, in part, by variations in the level of drug use over time, the metabolism of the user, and the user’s sensitivity or tolerance to a drug. Moreover, the presence of a drug may persist in the blood long after the impairment effects have worn off. Thus, requiring courts to consider the presence of any alcohol in combination with a drug in the blood as a special factor will unnecessarily result in harsher punishments for more people who are no less safe to drive.
“Second, drug testing, like many other forensic disciplines, is highly technical and imperfect. There are a host of problems with drug testing techniques and analyses, including: the substantial risk of false positive test results; false negative test results; specimen contamination; and chain of custody, storage, and re-testing issues. As the toxicological literature makes clear, “a number of routinely prescribed medications have been associated with triggering false-positive results.” In the context of marijuana, for example, research demonstrates that drug tests may return false positives for THC. Studies have found that false positive THC tests results have been associated with the passive ingestion (i.e. second-hand) of marijuana smoke. Similarly, other studies have demonstrated that heavy marijuana users who abstain from marijuana use for at least a week have returned positive THC tests. In addition, the use of some pharmaceutical drugs, like Marinol and Sativex, typically returns positive THC test results. It, therefore, does not make sense to increase a person’s sentence or terms and conditions of parole based on test results that are unreliable and often incorrect.
“Finally, the March 28, 2016 amendments to AB 1571 inappropriately tie California penalties to federal laws, made by the U.S. Congress, despite inconsistencies between California and federal laws. The bill now cross-references federal code sections that define marijuana and other drugs as Schedule I and Schedule II substances. Yet, because our state legislature has not always concurred with the conclusions of the U.S. Congress, the California code definitions for Schedule I and Schedule II substances do not mirror the definitions in the federal code. Furthermore, through direct democracy ballot measures, or future legislation, the differences may become even more pronounced.” - Prior Legislation:
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1487 (Berryhill), of the 2007-2008 Legislative Session, would have decreased the blood alcohol content (BAC) of a person convicted of DUI for referral to a lengthier driving under the influence program, as specified. AB 1487 died in the Senate Public Safety Committee,
- AB 1352 (Liu), Chapter 164, Statutes of 2005, requires a first time DUI offender with blood alcohol content .20 or more to attend a 9 month DUI educational program.
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of DUI Treatment Programs (Sponsor)
A Better Citizen Foundation
Alcohol Drug Council
Alcohol Justice
California Association of Code Enforcement Officers
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California College and University Police Chiefs Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Peace Officers Association
California Narcotic Officers’ Association
Fresno County Hispanic Commission on Alcohol & Drug Abuse Services
Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility
Health Net
Lifesafer of Northern California
Janus of Santa Cruz
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Riverside Sheriffs Association
Safety Center
We Save Lives
Zona Seca
16 private individuals
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Drug Policy Alliance
Analysis Prepared by:
Date of Hearing: April 5, 2016
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Requires the court to consider a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 or more, in combination with the presence of specified drugs, as an aggravating factor that may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation, for first time driving under the influence (DUI) offenders. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the court to consider a BAC of 0.08 percent or more, in combination with the presence of a Schedule I or II controlled substance, as defined the United States Code, as an aggravating factor in sentencing for first time DUI offenders.
- Specifies that the mandatory consideration of such an aggravating factor, may justify enhancing the terms and conditions of probation with regards to participation in specified DUI programs.
- Requires that enrollment in an approved DUI program for first offenders take place within 30 days of conviction.
- Allows the court to grant an extension of no longer than 30 days upon the request of the program provider.
- Allows an extension to be requested or granted by telephone or by other electronic means.
- Requires a court to refer a person with a second or subsequent DUI conviction to a program, as specified, as a condition of probation.
- Requires the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test, to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(2).)
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(1).)
- Specifies that if a person is convicted of a violation of Section DUI or DUI with injury, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the person's blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation. (Veh. Code § 23578.)
- States that the court shall also impose as a condition of probation, upon conviction of a first DUI, that the driver shall complete a DUI program, licensed as specified, in the driver's county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b).)
- In lieu of the DUI education program, a court may impose, as a condition of probation, that the person complete, subsequent to the underlying conviction, a residential live in program dealing with substance abuse, if the person consents and has been accepted into that program. (Veh. Code, § 23598.)
- States that the court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a DUI program of the length required under this code that is licensed, as specified, has been received in the department's headquarters. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(3).)
- Requires the court to refer a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as a condition of probation, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(1).)
- Requires the court to order a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in the person's blood was 0.20 percent or more, or the person refused to take a chemical test, to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, as a condition of probation. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(2).)
- Allows the State Department of Health Care Services to specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (d).)
- Specifies that "probation" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of conditional and revocable release in the community under the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Specifies that "conditional sentence" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of revocable release in the community subject to conditions established by the court without the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Provides that the court, in granting probation, may suspend the imposing or the execution of the sentence and may direct that the suspension may continue for a period of time not exceeding the maximum possible term of the sentence, except as specified, and upon those terms and conditions as it shall determine. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.)
- States that the court may impose and require any or all of the terms of imprisonment, fine, and conditions, and other reasonable conditions, as it may determine are fitting and proper to the end that justice may be done and for the rehabilitation of the probationer, and that should the probationer violate any of the terms or conditions imposed by the court in the matter, it shall have authority to modify and change any and all the terms and conditions and to reimprison the probationer in the county jail, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1, subd. (j).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "Drugged-driving has seen a dramatic increase in the past several years. According to the DMV’s annual report of the DUI Management Information System (MIS), the number of drug-involved crash fatalities increased by 15.4% in 2012. Drug-involved fatalities represent 28.7% of the total number of deaths associated with car crashes. We should treat the issue of drunk-and drugged-driving as a health issue rather than a criminal one. DUI Treatment Programs include educational group counseling sessions as well as individual interviews that showcase the severity of mixing alcohol with drugs while driving.
“Effective January 1st, 2014, California statute made it explicitly clear that it is unlawful for a person to drive under the combined influence of drugs and alcohol. This bill requires all first DUI offenders convicted with a blood-alcohol concentration of .15 and above and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9 month program (Current law requires 6 month). Furthermore, this bill allows the courts to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with a controlled substance as special factor that may justify enhancing the terms of a DUI treatment program.
“DUI Treatment Programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders through sessions that focus on alcohol and drug abuse. These programs are affordable and in cases of financial hardship some or all fees associated with the program can be waived. This bill narrowly targets first-offenders and will serve as a deterrent for anyone who might get behind the wheel while intoxicated under a mixture of alcohol and drugs.” - Criminalizing the Otherwise Legal Use of Lawful Prescription Medication: This bill requires courts to consider it an aggravating factor in sentencing when a person convicted of a first DUI was driving with a specified amount of alcohol in their blood, and any amount of drugs as defined in Schedule I and II of the Federal Code. (21 U.S.C. § 812.) That means individuals who have lawfully taken prescription drugs, can find that behavior criminalized as an aggravated sentencing factor and face increased penalties, even if the prescription medication did not contribute to the impairment of their driving.
Marijuana is a drug which is included in the Schedule I list controlled substances of the Federal Code. However, in California marijuana is a drug which, if prescribed, is allowed for medical used.
There are a large number of Schedule II drugs which are common prescription medications.
Examples of Schedule II narcotics include: hydromorphone (Dilaudid), methadone (Dolophine, meperidine (Demerol), oxycodone (OxyContin, Percocet), and fentanyl (Sublimaze, Duragesic). Other Schedule II narcotics include: morphine, opium, codeine, and hydrocodone. (http://www.deadiversion.usdoj.gov/schedules/)
Examples of Schedule II stimulants include: amphetamine (Dexedrine, Adderall), and methylphenidate (Ritalin). (Id.)
Lawful consumption of the drugs listed require the court to evaluate such consumption as an aggravating factor in sentencing under this bill if any amount of the drug was found in the individual’s blood in conjunction with specified alcohol levels. As a result, this bill mandates the consideration of an aggravating factor even if the drug(s) contained in the individual’s blood does not increase the impairment level of the individual to drive. The increased penalties would result even if the effect of the drug had worn off, but the drug was still contained in the individual’s blood. - The Effect of Drugs On an Individual’s Ability to Drive is Not Well Understood: Research has established that there is a close relationship between BAC level and impairment. Some effects are detectable at very low BACs (e.g., .02 grams per deciliter, or g/dL) and as BAC rises, the types and severity of impairment increase. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The behavioral effects of other drugs are not as well understood compared to the behavioral effects of alcohol. Certain generalizations can be made: high doses generally have a larger effect than small doses; well-learned tasks are less affected than novel tasks; and certain variables, such as prior exposure to a drug, can either reduce or accentuate expected effects, depending on circumstances. However, the ability to predict an individual’s performance at a specific dosage of drugs other than alcohol is limited. Most psychoactive drugs are chemically complex molecules whose absorption, action, and elimination from the body are difficult to predict. Further, there are considerable differences between individuals with regard to the rates with which these processes occur. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The presence of a drug in a person’s blood sample might indicate a drug that was affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken, or it might indicate a drug that was consumed at some point in the past and was no longer affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken. The length of time that a drug or its metabolite is present in a given biological sample is often called its detection time. This may vary depending on the dose (amount), route of administration (injected, inhaled etc.) and elimination rate (how long it takes the body to get rid of the substance). The presence of a drug metabolite in a biological fluid may or may not reflect consumption of the drug recently enough to impair driving performance. (Drug Toxicology for Prosecutors, American Prosecutors Research Institute (2004), p. 8.)
There are additional factors that complicate the determination of the effects on drugs on driving impairment. There are individual differences in absorption, distribution, and metabolism. Some individuals will show evidence of impairment at drug concentrations that are not associated with impairment in others. Wide ranges of drug concentrations in different individuals have been associated with equivalent levels of impairment. In certain instances drugs can be detected in the blood because of accumulation. Blood levels of some drugs or their metabolites may accumulate with repeated administrations if the time-course of elimination is insufficient. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, p. 3.) Because of these factors, specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with effects on driver performance. - Requiring Consideration of an Aggravating Factor in Situations Where There is Not Necessarily a Corresponding Increase in the Seriousness of the Criminal Behavior: Generally, under California criminal law, an individual only faces increased penalties for conduct that made the nature of the crime more serious. When evaluating the seriousness of a DUI, the most common measure is the impairment level of the driver. The higher the impairment of the driver, the bigger danger the driver represents to the public. As discussed above, the presence of a controlled substance in an individual’s blood does not necessarily reflect a corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive. This bill requires the court to consider specified drug consumption as an aggravating factor in sentencing even if there was no corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive.
- Existing Judicial Discretion: Courts have the power under existing law to increase punishments in situations when the combined use of alcohol and drugs warrant such an increase. Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendant. (People v. Smith (2007) 152, Cal.App.4th 1245, 1249.) Courts may impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice, make amends to society and individuals injured by the defendant’s unlawful conduct, and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation of the probationer.” (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.) A condition of probation is valid if it is reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114, 1121.)
If the facts demonstrate that the type or level of drugs in the individual’s system increased the dangerousness of conduct resulting in a DUI, the court can require that defendant to attend a longer DUI program. Under existing law, the court could also impose additional probation conditions such as substance abuse treatment or testing for drugs, as long as the conditions were reasonably related to the offense. - Requiring an Individual to Enroll in DUI Education Program Specified Time from Conviction May Create Additional Work for Courts: This bill requires that enrollment in a DUI education program for a first time DUI offender, take place within 30 days of the conviction (possibly extended to 60 days). That requirement may create additional workload for the courts.
Under existing law, DMV suspends an individual’s driver’s license for six months upon conviction of a first DUI (Veh. Code, § 13352.). In order to get full license privileges back, the individual must complete the DUI education program. If the individual wants to get a restricted license, allowing them to drive to work during the suspension period, the person must be enrolled in the DUI education program. Existing law provides incentives and penalties to enter and complete the program in order to drive. In addition, the DUI education program is a condition of probation. So failure to enroll and complete the program exposes the individual to additional sanctions by the court. Arguably, those are sufficient incentives for an individual to enroll and complete the DUI program.
Under this bill, if an individual fails to enroll within 30 days he will have violated the law. If the individual then attempts to enroll in the program beyond 30 days, it is likely they will not be allowed to enroll by a DUI education program provider. That individual will then have to schedule a court date and make an appearance in front of the judge to be re-referred to the DUI program. This may create additional volume for the courts.
This bill contains a provision that would allow the court to extend the 30 day deadline to 60 days and allows requests to be made by a treatment provider through electronic or telephonic means. The procedure to extend the deadline is not consistent with the standard judicial process.
Generally, when a court makes decisions and issues orders, the case on which the action is being taken is on calendar, the parties, or their legal representatives are present, and the hearing is open to the public. This framework is in place to ensure that parties have notice and an opportunity to be heard. It also ensures that one party is not communicating with the judge about the case outside presence of the other party. The framework ensures that the judicial process is conducted in an open and public forum.
This bill would be a significant departure from the normal judicial process by having a 3rd party (program provider) communicate informally to obtain an extension. Is it anticipated that the program provider will be calling up the judge responsible for the case to ask permission to extend? Are the parties required to be notified? If the timeframe is extended, who is responsible for notifying the defendant? It is not clear that this bill provides a workable procedure to extend the deadline to enroll in the DUI program. - Argument in Support: According to The California Police Chiefs Association, “The California Police Chiefs Association is pleased to support AB 1571, which updates the California DUI treatment program structure to reflect the prevalence of concurrent drug and alcohol use by California drivers. In addition to other changes, AB 1571 allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC of .08 to .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 6-month program and allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC above .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9-month program.
“The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA's) 2013-2014 National Roadside Survey found that more than 22 percent of drivers tested positive for illegal, prescription, or over-the-counter drugs. In fact, the National Roadside Survey of Alcohol and Drug Use by Drivers, a nationally representative survey by NHTSA, found that in 2007, approximately one in eight nighttime weekend drivers tested positive for illicit drugs. Equally disturbing are the 2011 results from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health indicating that 9.9 million Americans 12 or older reported driving under the influence of illicit drugs in the past year. Using a health-based treatment approach, AB 1571 will reduce this upward trend.
“DUI Treatment programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders. AB 1571 will significantly reduce the number of repeat concurrent use offenders in California. Thank you for your leadership on this matter.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Drug Policy Alliance, “First, while we do not advocate for anyone to drive while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, no one should receive sentencing enhancements or additional terms of probation based on arbitrary data. Not enough is known about the effects of drugs, or the combination of drugs and alcohol, on driver safety. Because of the paucity of information on this topic, the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) noted in 2015 report that “specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with a specific degree of driver impairment.” The report explained that, unlike alcohol – where there is a strong correlation between blood alcohol levels and the degree of driver impairment – there is a poor correlation between the presence of drugs in the blood and the impairing effects of the drugs. This can be explained, in part, by variations in the level of drug use over time, the metabolism of the user, and the user’s sensitivity or tolerance to a drug. Moreover, the presence of a drug may persist in the blood long after the impairment effects have worn off. Thus, requiring courts to consider the presence of any alcohol in combination with a drug in the blood as a special factor will unnecessarily result in harsher punishments for more people who are no less safe to drive.
“Second, drug testing, like many other forensic disciplines, is highly technical and imperfect. There are a host of problems with drug testing techniques and analyses, including: the substantial risk of false positive test results; false negative test results; specimen contamination; and chain of custody, storage, and re-testing issues. As the toxicological literature makes clear, “a number of routinely prescribed medications have been associated with triggering false-positive results.” In the context of marijuana, for example, research demonstrates that drug tests may return false positives for THC. Studies have found that false positive THC tests results have been associated with the passive ingestion (i.e. second-hand) of marijuana smoke. Similarly, other studies have demonstrated that heavy marijuana users who abstain from marijuana use for at least a week have returned positive THC tests. In addition, the use of some pharmaceutical drugs, like Marinol and Sativex, typically returns positive THC test results. It, therefore, does not make sense to increase a person’s sentence or terms and conditions of parole based on test results that are unreliable and often incorrect.
“Finally, the March 28, 2016 amendments to AB 1571 inappropriately tie California penalties to federal laws, made by the U.S. Congress, despite inconsistencies between California and federal laws. The bill now cross-references federal code sections that define marijuana and other drugs as Schedule I and Schedule II substances. Yet, because our state legislature has not always concurred with the conclusions of the U.S. Congress, the California code definitions for Schedule I and Schedule II substances do not mirror the definitions in the federal code. Furthermore, through direct democracy ballot measures, or future legislation, the differences may become even more pronounced.” - Prior Legislation:
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1487 (Berryhill), of the 2007-2008 Legislative Session, would have decreased the blood alcohol content (BAC) of a person convicted of DUI for referral to a lengthier driving under the influence program, as specified. AB 1487 died in the Senate Public Safety Committee,
- AB 1352 (Liu), Chapter 164, Statutes of 2005, requires a first time DUI offender with blood alcohol content .20 or more to attend a 9 month DUI educational program.
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of DUI Treatment Programs (Sponsor)
A Better Citizen Foundation
Alcohol Drug Council
Alcohol Justice
California Association of Code Enforcement Officers
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California College and University Police Chiefs Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Peace Officers Association
California Narcotic Officers’ Association
Fresno County Hispanic Commission on Alcohol & Drug Abuse Services
Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility
Health Net
Lifesafer of Northern California
Janus of Santa Cruz
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Riverside Sheriffs Association
We Save Lives
Zona Seca
16 private individuals
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Drug Policy Alliance
Analysis Prepared by:
Date of Hearing: March 15, 2016
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Requires the court to refer a driving under the influence (DUI) first offender whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15% or more and a controlled substance to a 9 month DUI program. Also requires the court to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the person’s blood, as defined, as a special factor for purposes of sentencing. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the court to refer a first offender whose blood contained a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.15% or more, and a controlled substance, as defined under federal law, to a DUI program of at least nine months, with at least 60 hours of program activities.
- Requires that enrollment in an approved DUI program take place within 30 days of conviction.
- Requires the county alcohol program administrator to coordinate court referral and tracking documents with the Department of Motor Vehicles and the State Department of Health Care Services.
- Requires the court to consider a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% or more, by weight, in combination with the presence of a controlled substance in the person’s blood, as defined under federal law, as a factor that may justify enhancing the penalties and determining conditions of probation.
- Requires a court to refer a person to a licensed program as a condition of probation.
- Requires the clerk of the court to also indicate the duration of the treatment program ordered on court referral and tracking documents.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was 0.20 percent or more, by weight, or who refused to take a chemical test, to participate for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(2).)
- Requires the court to order a first DUI offender whose blood-alcohol concentration was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(1).)
- Specifies that if a person is convicted of a violation of Section DUI or DUI with injury, the court shall consider a concentration of alcohol in the person's blood of 0.15 percent or more, by weight, or the refusal of the person to take a chemical test, as a special factor that may justify enhancing the penalties in sentencing, in determining whether to grant probation, and, if probation is granted, in determining additional or enhanced terms and conditions of probation. (Veh. Code § 23578.)
- States that the court shall also impose as a condition of probation, upon conviction of a first DUI, that the driver shall complete a DUI program, licensed as specified, in the driver's county of residence or employment, as designated by the court. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b).)
- In lieu of the DUI education program, a court may impose, as a condition of probation, that the person complete, subsequent to the underlying conviction, a residential live in program dealing with substance abuse, if the person consents and has been accepted into that program. (Veh. Code, § 23598.)
- States that the court shall advise the person at the time of sentencing that the driving privilege shall not be restored until proof satisfactory to the department of successful completion of a DUI program of the length required under this code that is licensed, as specified, has been received in the department's headquarters. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(3).)
- Requires the court to refer a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in his or her blood was less than 0.20 percent, by weight, to participate for at least three months or longer, as a condition of probation, in a licensed program that consists of at least 30 hours of program activities. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(1).)
- Requires the court to order a first time DUI offender whose concentration of alcohol in the person's blood was 0.20 percent or more, or the person refused to take a chemical test, to participate, for at least nine months or longer, as ordered by the court, in a licensed program that consists of at least 60 hours of program activities, as a condition of probation. (Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (c)(2).)
- Allows the State Department of Health Care Services to specify in regulations the activities required to be provided in the treatment of participants receiving nine months of licensed program services. Health & Saf. Code § 11837, subd. (d).)
- Specifies that "probation" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of conditional and revocable release in the community under the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Specifies that "conditional sentence" means "the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the order of revocable release in the community subject to conditions established by the court without the supervision of a probation officer." (Pen. Code, § 1203(a).)
- Provides that the court, in granting probation, may suspend the imposing or the execution of the sentence and may direct that the suspension may continue for a period of time not exceeding the maximum possible term of the sentence, except as specified, and upon those terms and conditions as it shall determine. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.)
- States that the court may impose and require any or all of the terms of imprisonment, fine, and conditions, and other reasonable conditions, as it may determine are fitting and proper to the end that justice may be done and for the rehabilitation of the probationer, and that should the probationer violate any of the terms or conditions imposed by the court in the matter, it shall have authority to modify and change any and all the terms and conditions and to reimprison the probationer in the county jail, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1, subd. (j).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "Drugged-driving has seen a dramatic increase in the past several years. According to the DMV’s annual report of the DUI Management Information System (MIS), the number of drug-involved crash fatalities increased by 15.4% in 2012. Drug-involved fatalities represent 28.7% of the total number of deaths associated with car crashes. We should treat the issue of drunk-and drugged-driving as a health issue rather than a criminal one. DUI Treatment Programs include educational group counseling sessions as well as individual interviews that showcase the severity of mixing alcohol with drugs while driving.
“Effective January 1st, 2014, California statute made it explicitly clear that it is unlawful for a person to drive under the combined influence of drugs and alcohol. This bill requires all first DUI offenders convicted with a blood-alcohol concentration of .15 and above and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9 month program (Current law requires 6 month). Furthermore, this bill allows the courts to consider any blood-alcohol concentration in combination with a controlled substance as special factor that may justify enhancing the terms of a DUI treatment program.
“DUI Treatment Programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders through sessions that focus on alcohol and drug abuse. These programs are affordable and in cases of financial hardship some or all fees associated with the program can be waived. This bill narrowly targets first-offenders and will serve as a deterrent for anyone who might get behind the wheel while intoxicated under a mixture of alcohol and drugs.” - Criminalizing the Otherwise Legal Use of Lawful Prescription Medication: This bill increases penalties for those individuals with a specified amount of alcohol in their blood and any amount of drugs as defined in the Federal Code. (21 U.S.C. § 812.) That means individuals who have lawfully taken prescription drugs, can find that behavior criminalized and face increased penalties, even if the prescription medication did not contribute to the impairment of their driving.
Examples of drugs that are included in the Federal Schedules of Controlled Substances which are commonly used in a lawful manner are Xanax, Ativan, Ambien, anabolic steroids, Valium, cough suppressants containing codeine (Robitussin AC), and Tylenol with codeine. (http://www.deadiversion.usdoj.gov/schedules/, http://www.drugs.com/schedule-4-drugs.html)
Lawful consumption of the drugs listed above would result increased penalties under this bill if any amount of the drug was found in the individual’s blood in conjunction with specified alcohol levels. As a result, this bill would increase penalties even if the drug(s) contained in the individual’s blood does not increase the impairment level of the individual to drive. The increased penalties would result even if the effect of the drug had worn off, but the drug was still contained in the individual’s blood. - The Effect of Drugs On an Individual’s Ability to Drive is Not Well Understood: Research has established that there is a close relationship between BAC level and impairment. Some effects are detectable at very low BACs (e.g., .02 grams per deciliter, or g/dL) and as BAC rises, the types and severity of impairment increase. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The behavioral effects of other drugs are not as well understood compared to the behavioral effects of alcohol. Certain generalizations can be made: high doses generally have a larger effect than small doses; well-learned tasks are less affected than novel tasks; and certain variables, such as prior exposure to a drug, can either reduce or accentuate expected effects, depending on circumstances. However, the ability to predict an individual’s performance at a specific dosage of drugs other than alcohol is limited. Most psychoactive drugs are chemically complex molecules whose absorption, action, and elimination from the body are difficult to predict. Further, there are considerable differences between individuals with regard to the rates with which these processes occur. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, pp. 2-3.)
The presence of a drug in a person’s blood sample might indicate a drug that was affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken, or it might indicate a drug that was consumed at some point in the past and was no longer affecting the individual at the time the sample was taken. The length of time that a drug or its metabolite is present in a given biological sample is often called its detection time. This may vary depending on the dose (amount), route of administration (injected, inhaled etc.) and elimination rate (how long it takes the body to get rid of the substance). The presence of a drug metabolite in a biological fluid may or may not reflect consumption of the drug recently enough to impair driving performance. (Drug Toxicology for Prosecutors, American Prosecutors Research Institute (2004), p. 8.)
There are additional factors that complicate the determination of the effects on drugs on driving impairment. There are individual differences in absorption, distribution, and metabolism. Some individuals will show evidence of impairment at drug concentrations that are not associated with impairment in others. Wide ranges of drug concentrations in different individuals have been associated with equivalent levels of impairment. In certain instances drugs can be detected in the blood because of accumulation. Blood levels of some drugs or their metabolites may accumulate with repeated administrations if the time-course of elimination is insufficient. (Drug Impaired Driving Understanding the Problem & Ways to Reduce It (2009), National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, p. 3.) Because of these factors, specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with effects on driver performance. - Increasing Penalties in Situations Where There is Not Necessarily a Corresponding Increase in the Seriousness of the Criminal Behavior: Generally, under California criminal law, an individual only faces increased penalties for conduct that made the nature of the crime more serious. When evaluating the seriousness of a DUI, the most common measure is the impairment level of the driver. The higher the impairment of the driver, the bigger danger the driver represents to the public. Existing law mandates increased penalties in the form of an extended (nine month) DUI program for individuals convicted when their blood is two and a half times (.20) the legal limit, or more. (Veh. Code § 23538, subd. (b)(1).) That increase in penalty is consistent with an increased seriousness of the criminal behavior because there is a strong correlation between higher levels of blood alcohol level and the impairment of drivers. As discussed above, the presence of a controlled substance in an individual’s blood does not necessarily reflect a corresponding impairment in the individual’s ability to drive.
This bill seeks to increase penalties by imposing a significantly longer DUI school for first time DUI offenders with any level of controlled substance in their blood stream. “Any level” of a controlled substance includes extremely low levels of drugs that do not impair ability to drive. “Any level” of a controlled substance includes drugs consumed at some point in the past that are no longer affecting the individual at the time the blood sample is taken. As a result, this bill doesn’t require any showing that the presence of the controlled substance contributed to impairment beyond the impairment caused by the amount of alcohol in the individual’s system. This bill mandates a punishment for behavior that does not necessarily correspond to a higher level of criminality. - Reducing Judicial Discretion: Courts have the power under existing law to increase punishments in situations when the combined use of alcohol and drugs warrant such an increase. Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendant. (People v. Smith (2007) 152, Cal.App.4th 1245, 1249.) Courts may impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice, make amends to society and individuals injured by the defendant’s unlawful conduct, and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation of the probationer.” (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.) A condition of probation is valid if it is reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114, 1121.)
If the facts demonstrate that the type or level of drugs in the individual’s system increased the dangerousness of conduct resulting in a DUI, the court can require that defendant to attend a longer DUI program. Under existing law, the court could also impose additional probation conditions such as substance abuse treatment or testing for drugs, as long as the conditions were reasonably related to the offense. - Requiring an Individual to Enroll in DUI Education Program Within 30 Days of Conviction May Create Additional Work for Courts: This bill requires that enrollment in a DUI education program for a first time DUI offender, take place within 30 days of the conviction. That requirement may create additional workload for the courts.
Under existing law, DMV suspends an individual’s driver’s license for six months upon conviction of a first DUI (Veh. Code, § 13352.). In order to get full license privileges back, the individual must complete the DUI education program. If the individual wants to get a restricted license, allowing them to drive to work during the suspension period, the person must be enrolled in the DUI education program. Existing law provides incentives and penalties to enter and complete the program in order to drive. In addition, the DUI education program is a condition of probation. So failure to enroll and complete the program exposes the individual to additional sanctions by the court. Arguably, those are sufficient incentives for an individual to enroll and complete the DUI program.
Under this bill, if an individual fails to enroll within 30 days he will have violated the law. If the individual then attempts to enroll in the program beyond 30 days, it is likely they will not be allowed to enroll by a DUI education program provider. That individual will then have to schedule a court date and make an appearance in front of the judge to be re-referred to the DUI program. This may create additional volume for the courts. - Argument in Support: According to The California Police Chiefs Association, “The California Police Chiefs Association is pleased to support AB 1571, which updates the California DUI treatment program structure to reflect the prevalence of concurrent drug and alcohol use by California drivers. In addition to other changes, AB 1571 allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC of .08 to .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 6-month program and allows a judge to require all first DUI offenders with a BAC above .15 and a controlled substance in their system to attend a 9-month program.
“The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA's) 2013-2014 National Roadside Survey found that more than 22 percent of drivers tested positive for illegal, prescription, or over-the-counter drugs. In fact, the National Roadside Survey of Alcohol and Drug Use by Drivers, a nationally representative survey by NHTSA, found that in 2007, approximately one in eight nighttime weekend drivers tested positive for illicit drugs. Equally disturbing are the 2011 results from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health indicating that 9.9 million Americans 12 or older reported driving under the influence of illicit drugs in the past year. Using a health-based treatment approach, AB 1571 will reduce this upward trend.
“DUI Treatment programs have been proven to significantly reduce DUI recidivism for first and repeat offenders. AB 1571 will significantly reduce the number of repeat concurrent use offenders in California. Thank you for your leadership on this matter.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Drug Policy Alliance, “First, while we do not advocate for anyone to drive while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, no one should receive sentencing enhancements or additional terms of probation based on arbitrary data. Not enough is known about the effects of drugs, or the combination of drugs and alcohol, on driver safety. Because of the paucity of information on this topic, the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) noted in 2015 report that “specific drug concentration levels cannot be reliably equated with a specific degree of driver impairment.” The report explained that, unlike alcohol – where there is a strong correlation between blood alcohol levels and the degree of driver impairment – there is a poor correlation between the presence of drugs in the blood and the impairing effects of the drugs. This can be explained, in part, by variations in the level of drug use over time, the metabolism of the user, and the user’s sensitivity or tolerance to a drug. Moreover, the presence of a drug may persist in the blood long after the impairment effects have worn off. Thus, requiring courts to consider the presence of any alcohol in combination with a drug in the blood as a special factor will unnecessarily result in harsher punishments for more people who are no less safe to drive.
“Second, drug testing, like many other forensic disciplines, is highly technical and imperfect. There are a host of problems with drug testing techniques and analyses, including: the substantial risk of false positive test results; false negative test results; specimen contamination; and chain of custody, storage, and re-testing issues. As the toxicological literature makes clear, “a number of routinely prescribed medications have been associated with triggering false-positive results.” In the context of marijuana, for example, research demonstrates that drug tests may return false positives for THC. Studies have found that false positive THC tests results have been associated with the passive ingestion (i.e. second-hand) of marijuana smoke. Similarly, other studies have demonstrated that heavy marijuana users who abstain from marijuana use for at least a week have returned positive THC tests. In addition, the use of some pharmaceutical drugs, like Marinol and Sativex, typically returns positive THC test results. It, therefore, does not make sense to increase a person’s sentence or terms and conditions of parole based on test results that are unreliable and often incorrect.” - Prior Legislation:
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1487 (Berryhill), of the 2007-2008 Legislative Session, would have decreased the blood alcohol content (BAC) of a person convicted of DUI for referral to a lengthier driving under the influence program, as specified. AB 1487 died in the Senate Public Safety Committee,
- AB 1352 (Liu), Chapter 164, Statutes of 2005, requires a first time DUI offender with blood alcohol content .20 or more to attend a 9 month DUI educational program.
- SB 780 (Emmerson), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have increased minimum county jail to 180 days upon conviction of a third DUI. SB 780 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of DUI Treatment Programs (Sponsor)
Alcohol Drug Council
California Police Chiefs Association
California Peace Officers Association
California Narcotic Officers’ Association
Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility
Health Net
Lifesafer of Northern California
We Save Lives
Zona Seca
3 individuals
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Drug Policy Alliance
Analysis Prepared by:
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):