AB 1913: Foreign labor contractors.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-01-23
Existing law requires the Labor Commissioner to enforce and administer a program to register and supervise foreign labor contractors who perform foreign labor contracting activities to recruit or solicit foreign workers. Existing law defines terms for its purposes, including defining foreign worker to mean any person seeking employment who is not a United States citizen or permanent resident but who is authorized by the federal government to work in the United States, including a person who engages in temporary nonagricultural labor pursuant to existing federal law. Existing law requires foreign labor contractors to register under the program, as prescribed, and imposes specific requirements relating to recruitment or solicitation for employment and to work contracts. Existing law authorizes the Labor Commissioner to adopt regulations or policies and procedures to implement these provisions. A violation of these provisions is a crime. Existing law limits the application of these provisions to nonagricultural workers, as defined.
Existing law provides that these provisions apply only to nonagricultural workers, as defined, and that they do not apply to a person licensed as a farm labor contractor, as defined, to any person exempt from specified licensing requirements, or to an employer employing agricultural workers, as defined.
This bill would delete those limitations. By expanding the application of the foreign labor contractor provisions, this bill would expand an existing crime, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Refused passage. |
| May 25, 2018 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 25, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 10, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 14, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (March 14). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 5, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Jan 24, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 23. |
| Jan 23, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 31, 2018 | AB 1913 KALRA Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 14, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1913
Author:(Kalra)
As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Labor | 5-1 | Thurmond, Gonzalez Fletcher, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, McCarty | Flora |
Judiciary | 8-1 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes | Kiley |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Adds foreign labor contractors who recruit or solicit agricultural workers to coverage under the State Labor Commissioner's (LC) foreign labor contractor registration program.
EXISTING LAW:
- Exempts from regulation of foreign labor contractors those who recruit agricultural workers.
- Defines foreign labor contracting activity as recruiting or soliciting a foreign worker who resides outside the United States for paid employment in California.
- Defines foreign worker as any person seeking employment who is not a United States (U.S.) citizen or permanent resident but who is authorized by the federal government to work in the U.S.
- Defines foreign labor contractor as any person who performs foreign labor contracting activity, including activity performed wholly outside the U.S., except government entities, a person licensed as a talent agency, and a person maintaining written designation under federal law as a participant in a work-and study-based exchange visitor program.
- Directs the LC to oversee and enforce a program regulating foreign labor contractor activities.
- Obligates a foreign labor contractor to register with the LC and disclose information relating to its recruitment or solicitation of workers, as specified.
- Requires that a foreign labor contractor provide a signed work contract, including all terms and conditions of employment, to the worker as well as information about his or her rights under state and federal anti-trafficking laws.
- Prohibits retaliation against a foreign worker or a member of his or her family for the exercise of any right under this provision.
- Provides a right to enforcement by the labor commissioner or an aggrieved party, and if appropriate, injunctive and monetary remedies, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, initial special fund costs of $150,000 to $200,000 and ongoing special fund costs of $200,000 annually for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to implement and maintain the expanded foreign labor contractor registration program and to enforce foreign labor contractor provisions for an estimated 200 to 300 new contractors.
COMMENTS: Existing law, SB 477 (Steinberg), Chapter 711, Statutes of 2014, codified in Business and Professions Code Sections 9998 et seq., establishes a licensing and oversight program for foreign labor contractors. Farm labor contractors are subject to different licensing requirements under Labor Code Sections 1682-1699. Farm labor contractors include persons who employ or supervise farmworkers, recruit or solicit farmworkers, and furnish boarding, lodging or transportation for these workers. While the licensing program for farm labor contractors provides certain protections for workers, including that a contractor be bonded, pass an exam on subjects such as labor law and health and safety regulations, have knowledge of sexual harassment prevention and provide applicable training, and be civilly liable for program violations, it does not include all the protections afforded under the foreign labor contractor licensing program. Unlike the foreign labor contractor licensing program, the farm labor contractor program does not extend protection from retaliation to family members of workers exercising a right under the law, require that a signed written contract be provided to workers, or obligate the contractor to disclose to workers information about their rights under state and federal labor trafficking laws.
The author asserts that this measure provides a technical fix to SB 477. According to the author, the intent of SB 477 was to extend its registration requirements to foreign labor contractors who recruit and solicit temporary agricultural workers, known as H-2A visa holders. Further, the author asserts that the only intended exemptions were for talent agencies or J-1 visa holders. J-1 visa holders are typically designated by the federal government as participants in a work-and-study based exchange visitor program.
The author further argues that without this technical fix, unscrupulous foreign labor contractors will continue to engage in human trafficking and worker abuses. Some will use the agricultural loophole to avoid complying with key provisions of the law, such as the requirement for fair and transparent contract terms and the right of workers to be free from retaliation for alleging violations of the law.
According to the Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking, sponsors of this bill, H-2A workers are subject to systemic abuse and exploitation in the United States. They cite data from a national human trafficking hotline operated by the Polaris Project as supportive of this argument. From 2007 to 2016, in the U.S. agricultural industry, Polaris reported over 400 cases of labor trafficking and more than 1,500 cases of labor exploitation.
In support of this measure, proponents such as the California Labor Federation write, "In order to combat the recruitment abuses recognized by the Governor and the California Legislature, and to provide a model for other jurisdictions faced with similar challenges, it is essential that SB 477's legislative intent be fully realized." In addition, Service Employees International Union (SEIU) California and others state that protections for all foreign temporary workers are essential given the sheer number of workers susceptible to abuse. They write, "In 2016, California was the destination of over 150,000 temporary foreign workers admitted under the H-1B, H-2A and H-2B visa categories, accounting for 15% of the total such workers entering the United States." Also in support, Farmworker Justice notes that, "The number of H-2A workers in California has increased dramatically in recent years, jumping from 8,591 positions certified in FY 2015 to 15,232 positions certified in FY 2017- an increase of 77%."
In opposition, a coalition of agricultural employers including the Western Growers Association, asserts a different understanding of the scope of SB 477. Opponents contend, "The H-2A visa program was NOT overlooked during the discussion and negotiations of SB 477 (Steinberg) in 2014 which created the foreign labor contracting registration program." They argue that the bill is unnecessary because "The H-2A visa program is already regulated by a restrictive application and enforcement program at the federal level." They further contend that California already has a farm labor contractor licensing program, noting "Farm labor contractors in California must be licensed and must take the farm labor contractor exam every two years."
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0003186
REVISED
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1913
Author:(Kalra) – As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2018
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 1 |
Judiciary | 8 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the Labor Commissioner’s (LC’s) foreign labor contractor program by applying it to temporary foreign farmworkers and farm labor contractors.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Initial costs of $150,000 to $200,000 and ongoing costs of $200,000 annually for the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement (DLSE) to implement and maintain the expanded foreign labor contractor registration program and to enforce foreign labor contractor provisions for an estimated 200 to 300 new contractors. Collected fees may offset these costs. (See Comment #4.)
COMMENTS:
- Background. SB 477 (Steinberg), Chapter 711, Statutes of 2014, established a registration program for foreign labor contractors who recruit and solicit foreign workers residing in other countries to perform temporary and seasonal work. Under this new program, foreign labor contractors must register with the LC, pay a license fee and surety bond, and make certain disclosures to workers and employers. While the registration program is not yet operating, proposed regulations do not apply to farm labor contractors or those who recruit and solicit foreign temporary farmworkers. This is because SB 477 amended parts of the Business and Professions Code that explicitly excludes temporary agricultural workers (H-2A visa holders).
- Purpose. According to the author, AB 1913 will help prevent unscrupulous foreign labor contractors from engaging in human trafficking and worker abuses by extending foreign labor contractor program to those who recruit farmworkers from abroad. The Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking contends that H-2A workers are subject to systemic abuse and exploitation in the United States.
- Disagreement over SB 477. Supporters of AB 1913 argue that H-2A visa holders were mistakenly left out of SB 477’s provisions and that AB 1913 is intended as technical cleanup. Opponents to the bill, such as Western Growers Association, argue that H-2A visa holders were left out intentionally, in part because the recruitment of those workers is already regulated by a federal enforcement program.
However, as the Assembly Committee on Judiciary’s analysis of AB 1913 notes, it does not matter why H-2A visa holders were originally excluded in SB 477. Rather, this bill should be evaluated on the merits of expanding the state’s foreign labor contractor program to California’s foreign agricultural workers and farm labor contractors and whether these additional protections are needed.
- Scope of the bill. The costs of AB 1913 depend on the number of farm labor contractors that would need to participate in the foreign labor contractor program. Unfortunately, the committee has been provided conflicting information about the extent of potential overlap between the two programs. Opponents argue that most farm labor contractors directly recruit workers through the federal H-2A process during certain seasons, while supporters contend that farm labor contractors typically use intermediaries, and these intermediaries would be the entities covered by this bill. Under the latter scenario, it is likely there would be fewer overall registrants in the foreign labor contractor program.
The cost estimates in this analysis assume significant overlap between farm labor contractors and foreign labor contractors. In order to provide a conservative estimate of the fiscal impact of this bill, cost estimates assume 200 to 300 new contractors and approximately 35,000 foreign workers would be covered by the provisions of this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1913
Author:(Kalra) – As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2018
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 1 |
Judiciary | 8 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the Labor Commissioner’s (LC’s) foreign labor contractor program by applying it to temporary foreign farmworkers and farm labor contractors.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Initial special fund costs of $1.4 million and ongoing special fund costs of $1.2 million annually for the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement (DLSE) to implement and maintain the expanded foreign labor contractor registration program and to enforce foreign labor contractor provisions for an estimated 2,000 new contractors. (See Comment #4.)
COMMENTS:
- Background. SB 477 (Steinberg), Chapter 711, Statutes of 2014, established a registration program for foreign labor contractors who recruit and solicit foreign workers residing in other countries to perform temporary and seasonal work. Under this new program, foreign labor contractors must register with the LC, pay a license fee and surety bond, and make certain disclosures to workers and employers. While the registration program is not yet operating, proposed regulations do not apply to farm labor contractors or those who recruit and solicit foreign temporary farmworkers. This is because SB 477 amended parts of the Business and Professions Code that explicitly excludes temporary agricultural workers (H-2A visa holders).
- Purpose. According to the author, AB 1913 will help prevent unscrupulous foreign labor contractors from engaging in human trafficking and worker abuses by extending foreign labor contractor program to those who recruit farmworkers from abroad. The Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking contends that H-2A workers are subject to systemic abuse and exploitation in the United States.
- Disagreement over SB 477. Supporters of AB 1913 argue that H-2A visa holders were mistakenly left out of SB 477’s provisions and that AB 1913 is intended as technical cleanup. Opponents to the bill, such as Western Growers Association, argue that H-2A visa holders were left out intentionally, in part because the recruitment of those workers is already regulated by a federal enforcement program.
However, as the Assembly Committee on Judiciary’s analysis of AB 1913 notes, it does not matter why H-2A visa holders were originally excluded in SB 477. Rather, this bill should be evaluated on the merits of expanding the state’s foreign labor contractor program to California’s foreign agricultural workers and farm labor contractors and whether these additional protections are needed.
- Scope of the bill. The costs of AB 1913 depend on the number of farm labor contractors that would need to participate in the foreign labor contractor program. Unfortunately, the committee has been provided conflicting information about the extent of potential overlap between the two programs. Opponents argue that most farm labor contractors directly recruit workers through the federal H-2A process during certain seasons, while supporters contend that farm labor contractors typically use intermediaries, and these intermediaries would be the entities covered by this bill. Under the latter scenario, it is likely there would be fewer overall registrants in the foreign labor contractor program.
The cost estimates in this analysis assume significant overlap between farm labor contractors and foreign labor contractors. In order to provide a conservative estimate of the fiscal impact of this bill, cost estimates assume 2,000 new contractors and approximately 280,000 foreign workers would be covered by the provisions of this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUBJECT:
KEY ISSUE: Should the requiremeNts of california's "Foreign Labor Contractor" statute be extended to include temporARy foreign Farmworkers and licensed farm labor contractors, to the extent that the latter operate as foreign labor contractors?
SYNOPSIS
Since 1988, California has regulated "foreign labor contractors" who recruit and solicit temporary foreign workers from outside of the United States to work in California. As enacted, this law applied to temporary "non-agricultural" workers (H-2B visa holders). The original legislation expressly exempted from its provisions temporary farmworkers (H-2A visa holders) and "farm labor contractors," as defined in the Labor Code. The original law imposed fairly minimal requirements: requiring contractors to provide certain disclosures; refrain from making false or misleading claims about the nature of the work available; and not hire minors. In 2014, SB 477 (Chap. 711, Stats. 2014) strengthened this law by requiring foreign labor contractors to register with the Labor Commissioner, post a surety bond, make specified disclosures to both employers and foreign workers, and refrain from certain exploitive and discriminatory practices. SB 477 required employers to use only registered foreign labor contractors in order to recruit foreign workers and to notify the Labor Commissioner if they used a foreign labor contractor. According to its findings, SB 477 sought to protect workers from contractors who charged illegal fees, made false promises, and in the worst cases, participated in illegal human trafficking. However, when the Labor Commissioner published a notice of proposed rulemaking to implement SB 477, it became clear to the original author and supporters of SB 477 that the proposed regulations would not apply to the recruitment of temporary foreign farmworkers holding H-2A visas. That the Labor Commissioner interpreted SB 477 in this way should not have been surprising given that the provisions of SB 477 were placed within the existing chapter regulating foreign labor contractors, which expressly states that the chapter only applies to "nonagricultural" H-2B workers and expressly exempts any person licensed as a "farm labor contractor." The author and supporters of SB 477, however, claimed that the bill was never intended to be so limited in its scope. The author of the bill now under consideration contends that this bill will provide a "technical fix" to SB 477 by striking the limiting section, which is all this bill does.
Opponents of the bill, a coalition of farm and grower associations, contend that SB 477 was never intended to apply to H-2A farm workers and farm labor contractors. Opponents contend that farm labor contractors are already licensed, bonded, and regulated under the farm labor contractor law, and that recruitment of foreign farmworkers is already regulated by federal law, which establishes a process for recruiting and protecting H-2A farm workers. While this analysis takes note of the conflicting arguments about the intent of SB 477, it nonetheless concludes that the intent of SB 477 does not matter. The Legislature is free to change any statute (other than one adopted by voter initiative), regardless of its original purpose. The question before the Committee is whether it is good policy to include H-2A farmworkers under the state's foreign labor contractor law, which currently – even as amended by SB 477 – applies only to nonagricultural H-2B workers and exempts from its provisions farm labor contractors. However, the impact of extending SB 477 to H-2A workers and farm labor contractors depends, in part, upon the number of "farm labor contractors" who also meet the definition of a "foreign labor contractor." There seems to be a great deal of disagreement on this issue, but little evidence. Therefore, if the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider ways to ensure that the new requirements relating to farm workers and farm labor contractors imposed by this bill are not unnecessarily duplicative and are consistent with other laws.
SUMMARY: Extends the existing foreign labor contractor law to cover temporary foreign farm workers and farm labor contractors by deleting a section that expressly limits the law's application to "nonagricultural" workers and expressly exempts farm labor contractors
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the California Labor Commissioner (LC) to enforce and administer a program to register and supervise foreign labor contractors, as defined. Specifies that the program only applies to "nonagricultural" H-2B workers and that it does not apply to any person licensed as a "farm labor contractor," as defined. Exempts additionally foreign workers recruited by talent agencies and persons participating in economic or cultural changes with a J-1 work visa. (Business & Professions Code Section 9998 et seq.; the following code sections refer to this code unless otherwise noted.)
- Defines, for purposes of the registration program described above, the following terms:
- "Foreign labor contractor" means any person who performs "foreign labor contracting activity" wholly outside of the United States, but not including any local, state, or federal government entity.
- "Foreign labor contracting activity" means recruiting or soliciting for compensation a "foreign worker" who resides outside of the United States in furtherance of that worker's employment in California, even when that activity occurs wholly outside of the United States.
- "Foreign worker" means any person seeking employment who is not a United States citizen or permanent resident but who is authorized by the federal government to work in the United States on a temporary basis. (Section 9998.1.)
- Requires any person acting as a foreign labor contractor to register with the LC, as specified, and to pay a registration fee to be established by the LC and to post a surety bond based upon the foreign labor contractor's gross receipts. (Section 9998.1.5.)
- Requires persons who know or should know that they are using a foreign labor contractor to procure foreign workers to disclose specified information to the LC. (Section 9998.2.)
- Requires a foreign labor contractor to disclose specified information in writing to each foreign worker, in that worker's primary language. The information must include a form specified by the Labor Commissioner that informs workers about their rights, including a notice that workers cannot be forced to pay processing, placement, transportation, or legal fees, which, by law, are the responsibility of the foreign labor contractor. The statement must also inform workers of their contractual rights and protections afforded to them under the federal Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000. (Section 9998.2.5.)
- Prohibits a foreign labor contractor from engaging in certain activities, including making false or misleading claims about the terms and conditions of work, recruiting minors, intimidating or in any manner discriminating against a foreign worker or a member of the workers' family in retaliation for the foreign worker's exercising a legal right under the foreign labor contractor law, or promising workers that they will be offered an opportunity for citizenship or legal permanent residence in the United States. Subjects any person who violates provisions of the foreign labor contractor's law to civil penalties and civil actions for damages or injunctive relief. (Sections 9998.3 to 9998.9.)
- Creates a program for licensing and regulating "farm labor contractors," defined as any person who, for a fee, employs workers to render personal services in connection with the production of any farm products to, for, or under the direction of a third party, or who recruits, solicits, supplies, or hires workers on behalf of an agricultural employer and who, for a fee, provides one or more of the following services: furnishes board, lodging, or transportation for those workers; supervises, times, checks, counts, weighs, or otherwise directs or measures their work; or disburses wage payments to those workers. Prohibits a person from acting as a farm labor contractor without first meeting licensing, fee, and bonding requirements established by the LC. Permits the LC to revoke, suspend, or refuse to renew a license if the farm labor contractor fails to comply with specified state or federal laws, or has been found by a court or administrative agency to have committed sexual harassment of an employee. (Labor Code Sections 1682 to 1694.)
- Requires every licensed farm labor contractor to, among other things, make specified disclosures to employers and workers, maintain specified records, promptly pay all moneys owed to workers, conspicuously post information related to workers' rights, provide mandated training, including sexual harassment prevention training for all supervisors and farm workers, and comply with all federal law requirements, including the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Workers Protection Act. (Labor Code Section 1695 to 1695.8.)
- Prohibits a farm labor contractor from making false or misleading representations concerning the terms, places, or conditions of employment, sending workers to any place where the contractor knows a strike or lockout exists without notifying the worker of this fact, or doing any act that constitutes a crime of moral turpitude. (Labor Code Section 1696.)
- Establishes, under the federal Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSPA), employment standards for migrant and seasonal farmworkers related to wages, housing, transportation, disclosures and recordkeeping. The MSPA also requires farm labor contractors to register with the U.S. Department of Labor. (29 U.S.C. Sections 1801, et seq.; 29 CFR Part 500.)
- Authorizes, under the federal Immigration and Naturalization Act, the lawful admission of temporary foreign workers who have no intention of abandoning their country of origin or becoming citizens or legal permanent residents in the United States. Distinguishes between foreign temporary workers (H-2A workers) who perform agricultural labor or services of a temporary or seasonal nature, and foreign temporary workers who perform nonagricultural labor or services (H-2B workers) of a temporary or seasonal nature. (8 USC 1101 (a) (15) (H) (i)-(ii).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author and sponsor, this bill is intended as a "technical fix" to SB 477 (Chap. 711, Stats. 2014), which established a registration program for "foreign labor contractors" who, for compensation, recruit and solicit foreign workers residing in other countries to perform temporary and seasonal work in California. Although the SB 477 registration program is not yet operating, the Labor Commissioner's proposed regulations, as recently submitted for public comment, would exclude foreign temporary farmworkers and farm labor contractors from its provisions. The Labor Commissioner understandably reached this conclusion because the chapter in which the provisions of SB 477 were inserted expressly stated that the chapter applied only to foreign "nonagricultural" workers (H-2Bvisa holders) and expressly excluded persons who were already licensed in California as "farm labor contractors." However, the author and sponsor of the bill now before the Committee contend, for reasons discussed below, that SB 477 was always intended to protect temporary foreign farmworkers (H-2A visa holders). Therefore, this bill would simply delete the first section of the existing law that limits SB 477's application to nonagricultural workers.
Federal Law Background: the H-2A and H-2B Program: The Omnibus Immigration and Naturalization Act of 1952, or the McCarran-Walter Act, authorized non-immigrant foreign workers to work temporarily in the United States as "guest workers." Section 101(a)(15)(H(ii) of the Act (the H-2 provision) allowed admission for foreign workers who had no intention of becoming citizens or legal permanent residents to enter the United States on a temporary basis. As a condition of admission, a sponsoring employer must demonstrate to the U.S. Department of Labor that there are not a sufficient number of workers within the United States who are willing and able do the work, and that the employment of foreign workers would not adversely affect wages and working conditions of similarly employed workers already within the United States. (8 USC 1101 (a) (15) (H) (ii).) All work authorization visas issued under the program are temporary, with most work authorizations lasting less than ten months. Beginning with the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) of 1986, the H-2 program was divided into two categories: H-2A visa holders who perform agricultural labor, and H-2B visa holders who perform non-agricultural labor. Other temporary work visas allow admission of highly skilled workers (H-1 visas), as well as work visas for persons participating in educational or cultural exchange programs (J-1 visas). Of particular importance for this analysis, the H-2A program defines and recognizes a role for "H-2A Labor Contractors" who recruit, solicit, hire, employ, furnish, house, or transport H-2A workers. While federal "H-2A Labor Contractors" are considered "employers" for certain purposes under federal law – they may hire, supervise, and pay the worker – they are nonetheless distinguished from "fixed-site" employers who own the agricultural operations where workers perform the labor. In short, while the H-2A Labor Contractor may legally "employ" the worker, the contractor effectively acts as an intermediary between the farm owner, who wants the work done, and the farmworker who does the work.
Federal law also provides protections for migrant and seasonal agricultural workers, whether foreign or domestic. The Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSPA) establishes employment standards for migrant and seasonal farmworkers related to wages, housing, transportation, disclosures and recordkeeping. The MSPA also requires farm labor contractors to register with the U.S. Department of Labor. Under the MSPA, a "farm labor contractor" is defined as someone who hires, recruits, solicits, employs, furnishes, or transports any migrant or seasonal worker for compensation. Although the MSPA is not part of the H-2A regulations (20 CFR Part 655), a farm labor contractor who is registered under MSPA could also register as an "H-2A Labor Contractor," at least to the extent that recruitment and solicitation efforts were directed at foreign workers residing outside of the United States. It is not entirely clear to the Committee, however, how most "farm labor contractors" acquire temporary guest workers. If they acquire them directly by recruiting and soliciting abroad, then they would seemingly be deemed to be H-2A labor contractors and thus subject to H-2A regulations. On the other hand, if the farm labor contractor obtains foreign workers from an H-2A labor contractor, then the farm labor contractor would presumably be an "employer" rather than a "contractor" for purposes of H-2A regulations. Significantly, federal law defines an H-2A labor contractor as a person who "meets the definition of an employer," but who "is not a fixed-site employer, an agricultural association, or an employee of a fixed-site employer or agricultural association." It appears, therefore, that contractors are "employers" to the extent that they "hire" foreign workers; but they are "contractors" to the extent that they hire them for the purpose of providing a labor service to "fixed-site" agricultural employers.
State Law Background: Chapter 21.5 of the B&P Code (Sections 9998 et seq.) was enacted in 1988 to provide for regulation of "foreign labor contractors," meaning persons who, for compensation, recruited or solicited persons abroad who were authorized by federal law to work as temporary guest workers in the United States. From the start, this chapter expressly provided that its terms applied only to "nonagricultural workers" (specifically H-2B visa holders as defined by federal immigration law). The chapter also expressly stated that it did not apply to a "farm labor contractor," as that term is defined in Labor Code Section 1682, or to any employer of H-2A agricultural workers.
Prior to 2014, Chapter 21.5 imposed fairly minimal requirements on anyone operating as a "foreign labor contractor" in California. It required the foreign labor contractor to disclose certain information to the State Labor Commissioner; it prohibited the contractor from making any false or misleading representations about the terms and conditions of promised employment; it prohibited the recruitment of minors; it required any person who recruited a foreign worker when there was in fact no bona fide job offer to pay the promised wages; and, finally, the law provided that no person could discriminate or retaliate against a foreign worker who exercised any rights under law.
SB 477, signed into law in 2014, made several changes to Chapter 21.5. Most notably, it required foreign labor contractors to register with the Labor Commissioner, which included payment of a licensing fee and the posting of a surety bond; required the foreign labor contractor to make certain disclosures to workers and agricultural employers; imposed penalties on any employer who used an unregistered foreign labor contractor; expanded the remedies available to foreign workers aggrieved by a violation of the law; and extended the prohibition against retaliation to include acts of retaliation against a worker's family members. According to SB 477's author and sponsor, the bill was intended to address shortcomings in then-existing law that effectively allowed foreign labor contractors to engage in, or be complicit with, the worst kinds of human trafficking. The bill expressly exempted two categories of foreign workers: foreign workers recruited by talent agencies, because talent agencies were already licensed and subject to protective regulations; and holders of J-1 visas that authorize persons participating in an educational or cultural program to work while they are in the United States.
At the time of this writing, the Labor Commissioner and the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), are still completing proposed regulations. Draft regulations were presented for public comment in October of 2017. DIR has informed the Committee that regulations are expected to be finalized by the late summer of 2018.
AB 1913, the bill presently under consideration, is intended to fix an apparent oversight in SB 477. Specifically, the author and supporters of AB 1913 contend that SB 477 was always intended to include H-2A agricultural workers, as well as nonagricultural H-2B workers and other guest workers not otherwise exempted, such as J-1 visa holders. As such, SB 477's registration and other requirements should apply to farm labor contractors, according to the author and sponsor of the bill, at least to the extent that they recruit and solicit workers from outside of the United States. Apparently, it was only after the bill became law and the Labor Commissioner circulated draft regulations for public comment that the original author of SB 477 (Senator Darrell Steinberg) and supporters noticed that the language of SB 477 had been placed in a chapter that expressly excluded H-2A workers and farm labor contractors from the chapter's provisions. AB 1913, in order to address that issue, would delete the introductory provision (B&P Code Section 9998) that limits the chapter's application to nonagricultural workers and expressly exempts farm labor contractors.
Opponents of this bill, on the other hand – most notably the Western Growers Association and the California Farm Bureau – contend that it was well understood at the time when SB 477 was pending that SB 477 did not apply to H-2A farm workers or farm labor contractors, which was one of the reasons that neither of these groups opposed SB 477. In addition to disputing the intent of SB 477, opponents also contend that AB 1913 is unnecessarily duplicative, given that farm labor contractors who employ foreign workers will have to register twice (with the same Labor Commissioner), pay both fees, post both surety bonds, and comply with both sets of regulations. Moreover, opponents contend that farm workers are already protected under the state Labor Code and that temporary H-2A farm workers are already protected under federal laws governing their recruitment and treatment. Indeed, the opponents point to an author's statement that appeared in the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of SB 477, which, quoting the author, read as follows: "Currently, California law requires licensing of farm labor contractors only. This has curtailed human trafficking-related abuses previously prevalent in California's agricultural industry."
While the letters in support and opposition of this bill devote most of their space to offering competing views of the legislative history and intent of SB 477, the analysis does not attempt to resolve that dispute, nor does it need to. Reasonable arguments have been made for both positions. But whatever the original intent of SB 477, the Legislature is free to amend the law, just as it is free to amend any law enacted by a prior Legislature. The critical question, therefore, is not the intent of SB 477, but whether, going forward, it is good policy to apply the foreign labor contractor provisions to H-2A workers and farm labor contractors.
Answering this policy question is not easy, largely because of a lack of empirical data about the extent to which "farm labor contractors" directly recruit H-2A workers and, as such, would qualify as "foreign labor contractors" under SB 477. The author's office has informed the Committee of its belief that most farm labor contractors do not recruit directly from abroad, but instead rely upon intermediaries, who would presumably qualify as either "foreign labor contractors" under California law, or as "H-2A Labor Contractors" under federal law. If that were the case, then most farm labor contractors would be deemed "employers" for purposes of SB 477 and would not be required to register with the Labor Commissioner as a foreign labor contractor; however, like all employers, they would need to use only registered foreign labor contractors and notify the Labor Commissioner if they were using a foreign labor contractor.
Opponents, on the other hand, have informed the Committee that most farm labor contractors, especially at times of increased demand, directly recruit H-2A workers themselves through the federal H-2A process. If that is the case, then the farm labor contractors will be deemed "foreign labor contractors" under this bill and will be subject to both sets of requirements, fees, and surety bonds. Committee inquiries submitted to the DIR and the staff responsible for drafting regulations did not resolve this question. To the best of the Committee's knowledge, there is no data on how many licensed farm labor contractors would also qualify as foreign labor contractors and, as such, would be subject to the additional regulations of SB 477.
Protections provided by existing state and federal laws: Under the farm labor contractor law (Labor Code Sections 1682-1699), farm labor contractors are already required to obtain a license from the Labor Commissioner, which in turn requires passing character background checks, paying a $600 licensing fee, passing a written examination, and posting a surety bond, the amount of which depends upon the size of the contractor's payroll. The law also imposes certain requirements on licensees, including making specified disclosures to both employers and workers, and prohibiting false or misleading representations to workers about the existence, terms or conditions of employment. In addition, existing law specifies that these requirements are in addition to any requirements under federal law, including the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Protection Act (MSAP). MSAP is supposed to protect migrant and seasonal workers (both foreign and domestic) by establishing standards relating to wages, housing, transportation, required disclosures, and recordkeeping. (29 USC Section 1801 et seq.; see also U.S. Dept. of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Fact Sheet #49.) As noted above, federal immigration law already guarantees certain rights for H-2A temporary foreign workers and, like MSAP, establishes certain minimum requirements relating to wages, transportation, and housing for foreign workers. Federal immigration law also requires that H-2A workers receive any state workers' compensation benefits. Federal law prohibits employers or recruiters from receiving fees or payment for any costs relating to H-2A certification, and it prohibits retaliation against any workers for filing complaints, consulting with an attorney or legal assistance program, or exercising or asserting any rights or protections afforded by law. (29 CFR Section 501 et seq.) Employers and recruiters are required to conspicuously post notices informing workers of their rights, and the farm labor contractor law entitles an aggrieved worker to bring a civil action for any violation of law.
Opponents are correct, therefore, in their claim that existing state and federal laws already provide many protections similar to those afforded by SB 477, and they claim that this is one reason why H-2A workers and farm labor contractors were excluded from the original foreign labor contractor law. The author and supporters of this bill, on the other hand, while acknowledging these existing protections, nonetheless contend that those protections are not as great as the opposition claims, and that extending the state foreign labor contractor requirements to H-2A farmworkers will add protections not provided by federal or state law. A chart provided to the Committee by the sponsor does indeed point out additional protections. For example, SB 477 requires disclosures at the point of solicitation or recruitment, whereas the farm labor contractor law imposes no disclosure requirements at this point and, federal H-2A requirements require disclosures at the time of visa application. The chart also indicates that only SB 477 prohibits discrimination, intimidation, or retaliation against a foreign worker or family member because of the worker's exercise of a legal right. Federal law prohibits such discrimination, intimidation, or retaliation against the worker, but this does not extend to the worker's family members. (29 CFR Section 501.4.)
Potential New Fee and Bond Requirements for Farm Labor Contractors: If the farm labor contractors are deemed to be foreign labor contractors, they will be subject to dual fee and bonding requirements. Under existing law, farm labor contractors must obtain a license from the Labor Commissioner. This process includes paying a $600 license fee (recently increased from $500 to fund enforcement activities), passing an examination, and posting a surety bond, ranging from $25,000 to $75,000, depending upon the dollar amount of the contractor's annual payroll. Under AB 1913, a farm labor contractor who also meets the definition of a "foreign labor contractor" (by recruiting H-2A workers from outside the country) would also need to register with the Labor Commissioner as a "foreign labor contractor." In addition to the $600 licensing fee and surety bond required under the Labor Code, the farm labor contractor who qualifies as a foreign labor contractor would additionally be required to pay a yet to be determined licensing fee and post a surety bond ranging from $50,000 to $150,000, depending upon the contractor's "gross receipts as a foreign labor contractor."
The dual bond requirements could create a potential hardship for some farm labor contractors. For example, foreign temporary agricultural workers (those with H-2A status) make up a small percentage of all agricultural workers. A relatively small farm labor contracting operation with a payroll that did not exceed $500,000 dollars would post the minimum $25,000 bond in order to obtain a license. While the farm labor contractor bond is based on payroll, the foreign labor contractor bond is based on "gross receipts from operations as a foreign labor contractor." If a farm labor contractor directly recruited only one temporary foreign worker, that contractor would need to post an additional bond of $50,000 under SB 477, which is the minimal amount, even if the gross receipts were quite small for that single worker. In addition, it is not entirely clear what will constitute "gross receipts." For example, SB 477 provides that "gross receipts" are based upon annual gross receipts from "operation as a foreign labor contractor," suggesting it would only include the amount of money the farm labor contractor made by directly recruiting a foreign worker. However, the Labor Commissioner's draft regulations defined "gross receipts" to mean "all amounts of income received by the applicant, in the form of money, promissory notes, credit, or any other items of value, for the sale or transfer of goods, or for services provided by the applicant or its employees." This seems broader than the money made just for recruiting and providing the foreign labor. Given that the number of H-2A workers will constitute only a portion of the farm labor contractor's total workforce, and only for parts of the year, it is not clear how one would calculate what portion of gross receipts were attributable to the recruitment of H-2A workers.
Considerations for the Author if the Bill Moves Forward: At some point, the author may consider making the bond requirements more equitable. Because the foreign labor contractor's bond amount is twice as much as the bond required of farm labor contractors, a farm labor contractor's bond requirement could increase threefold. For example, a small operator with a relatively small payroll must currently post the minimum bond amount of $25,000. If this bill became law, however, the same person would pay the same $25,000 farm labor contractor bond as well as, at a minimum, the $50,000 foreign labor contractor bond.
In addition, the author may wish to consider whether "gross receipts" is the best method of calculating the bond amount. Under federal law, the H-2A contractor is also required to post a surety bond, but the bond amount is not based on gross receipts, but perhaps more logically upon the number of workers recruited. According to the USCIS website, the H-2A bonds are currently as follows: $5,000 for less than 25 workers; $10,000 for 25 to 49 workers; $20,000 for 50-74 workers; $50,000 for 75-99 workers; and $75,000 for 100 or more workers. By comparison, while the maximum bond under federal law is $75,000, the maximum bond under the state farm labor contractor law is also $75,000, and the maximum bond under the state foreign labor contractor law is $150,000. Because a full assessment of the impact of the bill would require more information than is presently available to the Committee – and seemingly unavailable to the proponents, opponents, and the Labor Commissioner as well – the author may wish to consider amending the bill, if necessary, as more information becomes available.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Coalition to Abolish Slavery and Trafficking (CAST), AB 1913 "provides a technical fix to SB 477 (Steinberg) to ensure implementation of the legislature's intent that all foreign labor contractors (FLCs) recruiting individuals for work in California, with two narrow exceptions, are subject to SB 477's requirements." CAST quotes its testimony in support of SB 477 as still relevant: "While one often thinks that undocumented immigrants are the most susceptible to human trafficking, our caseload is showing that labor trafficking is flourishing in the context of documented visa programs. In fact, of our current legal caseload of 126 clients, almost 50% of these individuals came to the United States on lawful visas." CAST contends that when it sponsored and testified on SB 477 (as well as for an earlier version by the same author, SB 516), "it was with the understanding that the legislation would provide a strong framework for protecting the estimated 130,000 temporary workers coming to California annually in 2013 and working in a broad spectrum of occupations under all visa categories." CAST did not assume that agricultural workers would or should be carved out of the bill, because H-2A is "one of the visa categories traffickers exploit most frequently." Nationally, CAST contends, H-2A workers constitute "the second largest category of reported cases."
CAST asserts that the opposition's claims that "regulations under SB 477 are duplicative or unnecessary are simply in error," and that the opponents "fail to acknowledge . . . any of the substantive provisions of SB 477 that provide protections for workers in addition to those included" in existing laws.
CAST writes that it was "a technical drafting error at the place where the bill was inserted into the statute, and not errors within the text of the bill itself" that makes the "technical fix" in AB 1913 necessary. Despite this error, CAST contends, the intent of SB 477 was always to protect all temporary workers in California against human trafficking and labor exploitation. "These protections," CAST concludes, "are even more necessary today given the difficult political climate immigrants are currently facing."
Several other labor, immigrant rights, social justice, and religious organizations support this bill for substantially the same reasons as those set forth by CAST. The bill is also supported by Senator (and now Mayor) Darrell Steinberg, the author of SB 477.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by a large coalition of agricultural and farm associations. Opponents argue that AB 1913 "unnecessarily expands the provisions of California's impending foreign labor contracting regulations to now include agricultural workers under the H-2A visa program. The H-2A visa program was NOT overlooked during the discussion and negotiations of SB 477 . . . [H-2A visa holders] were simply not intended to be covered by the program because of the lack of necessity to do so." Opponents claim that the H-2A visa program "is already regulated by a restrictive application and enforcement program at the federal level. . . In addition [to these federal regulations] California also has a unique farm labor contractor licensing program that is managed and enforced by the California Labor Commissioner's Office. This program was referenced as a model in the Assembly Judiciary Committee Analysis for SB 477, 'currently California law requires licensing of farm labor contractors only. This has curtailed human trafficking-related abuses.'" Finally, the opponents note that the fact sheet for AB 1913 notes that talent agency recruiters are exempt from the provisions of SB 477 because "they are already subject to a more restrictive licensing program. The same is and should hold true for the H-2A program."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
Asian Pacific Islander Legal Outreach
CA Labor Federation
CA Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Centro de los Derechos del Migrante
Centro Legal de la Raza
City of Sacramento
Coalition Against Slavery and Trafficking
Economic Policy Institute Policy Center
Equal Rights Advocates
Farmworker Justice
Filipino Bar Association of Northern CA
Filipino Community Center
International Labor Recruitment Working Group
Justice at Work
Justice in Motion
Koreatown Immigrant Workers Alliance
Lissette Marquez
Loma Linda University Church
National Alliance for Filipino Concerns
Pilipino Association of Workers and Immigrants - Silicon Valley
Plumbers, Steamfitters, Pipefitters & HVAC Service Technicians Local 393
Plumbers, Pipe, & Refrigeration Fitters Local 246
Religious Sisters of Charity
Santa Clara Valley Contractors Association
Santa Clara County Wage Theft Coalition
SEIU CA
SF Day Labor Program & Women's Collective
Sylvana Jacome
UC Davis Dept. of Asian American Studies
United Farm Workers
Worksafe
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Pistachio Growers
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Wine Grape Growers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Bean Shippers Association
California Blueberry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Seed Association
California State Floral Association
California Strawberry Association
Family Winemakers of California
Nisei Farmers League
Pacific Egg and Poultry Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by:
Date of Hearing: March 14, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Tony Thurmond, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1913 (
Author:Kalra) – As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2018
SUBJECT: Foreign labor contractors
SUMMARY: Adds foreign labor contractors who recruit or solicit agricultural workers to coverage under the State Labor Commissioner’s (LC) foreign labor contractor registration program.
EXISTING LAW:
- Exempts from regulation of foreign labor contractors those who recruit agricultural workers.
- Defines foreign labor contracting activity as recruiting or soliciting a foreign worker who resides outside the United States for paid employment in California.
- Defines foreign worker as any person seeking employment who is not a U.S. citizen or permanent resident but who is authorized by the federal government to work in the U.S.
- Defines foreign labor contractor as any person who performs foreign labor contracting activity, including activity performed wholly outside the U.S., except government entities, a person licensed as a talent agency, and a person maintaining written designation under federal law as a participant in a work-and study-based exchange visitor program.
- Directs the LC to oversee and enforce a program regulating foreign labor contractor activities.
- Obligates a foreign labor contractor to register with the LC and disclose information relating to its recruitment or solicitation of workers, as specified.
- Requires that a foreign labor contractor provide a signed work contract, including all terms and conditions of employment, to the worker as well as information about his or her rights under state and federal anti-trafficking laws.
- Prohibits retaliation against a foreign worker or a member of his or her family for the exercise of any right under this provision.
- Provides a right to enforcement by the labor commissioner or an aggrieved party, and if appropriate, injunctive and monetary remedies, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Existing law, SB 477 (Steinberg), Chapter 711, Statutes of 2014, codified in Business and Professions Code Sections 9998 et seq., establishes a licensing and oversight program for foreign labor contractors. Farm labor contractors are subject to different licensing requirements under Labor Code Sections 1682-1699. Farm labor contractors include persons who employ or supervise farmworkers, recruit or solicit farmworkers, and furnish boarding, lodging or transportation for these workers. While the licensing program for farm labor contractors provides certain protections for workers, including that a contractor be bonded, pass an exam on subjects such as labor law and health and safety regulations, have knowledge of sexual harassment prevention and provide applicable training, and be civilly liable for program violations, it does not include all the protections afforded under the foreign labor contractor licensing program. Unlike the foreign labor contractor licensing program, the farm labor contractor program does not extend protection from retaliation to family members of workers exercising a right under the law, require that a signed written contract be provided to workers, or obligate the contractor to disclose to workers information about their rights under state and federal labor trafficking laws.
The author asserts that this measure provides a technical fix to SB 477. According to the author, the intent of SB 477 was to extend its registration requirements to foreign labor contractors who recruit and solicit temporary agricultural workers, known as H-2A visa holders. Further, the author asserts that the only intended exemptions were for talent agencies or J-1 visa holders. J-1 visa holders are typically designated by the federal government as participants in a work-and-study based exchange visitor program.
The author further argues that without this technical fix, unscrupulous foreign labor contractors will continue to engage in human trafficking and worker abuses. Some will use the agricultural loophole to avoid complying with key provisions of the law, such as the requirement for fair and transparent contract terms and the right of workers to be free from retaliation for alleging violations of the law.
According to the Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking, sponsors of this bill, H-2A workers are subject to systemic abuse and exploitation in the United States. They cite data from a national human trafficking hotline operated by the Polaris Project as supportive of this argument. From 2007 to 2016, in the U.S. agricultural industry, Polaris reported over 400 cases of labor trafficking and more than 1,500 cases of labor exploitation.
In support of this measure, proponents such as the California Labor Federation write, “In order to combat the recruitment abuses recognized by the Governor and the California Legislature, and to provide a model for other jurisdictions faced with similar challenges, it is essential that SB 477’s legislative intent be fully realized.” In addition, SEIU California and others state that protections for all foreign temporary workers are essential given the sheer number of workers susceptible to abuse. They write, “In 2016, California was the destination of over 150,000 temporary foreign workers admitted under the H-1B, H-2A and H-2B visa categories, accounting for 15% of the total such workers entering the United States.” Also in support, Farmworker Justice notes that, “The number of H-2A workers in California has increased dramatically in recent years, jumping from 8,591 positions certified in FY 2015 to 15,232 positions certified in FY 2017- an increase of 77%.”
In opposition, a coalition of agricultural employers including the Western Growers Association, asserts a different understanding of the scope of SB 477. Opponents contend, “The H-2A visa program was NOT overlooked during the discussion and negotiations of SB 477 (Steinberg) in 2014 which created the foreign labor contracting registration program.” They argue that the bill is unnecessary because “The H-2A visa program is already regulated by a restrictive application and enforcement program at the federal level.” They further contend that California already has a farm labor contractor licensing program, noting “Farm labor contractors in California must be licensed and must take the farm labor contractor exam every two years.”
This bill is double referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
Related and Prior Legislation
SB 477 (Steinberg), Chapter 711, Statutes of 2014, established a registration and oversight process for foreign labor contractors including enumerated protections for temporary foreign workers who are recruited to work in California.
SB 516 (Steinberg) 2013 was nearly identical to SB 477 but specified a contractor registration fee of $500. The bill passed the Legislature but was vetoed by Governor Brown on the grounds that the fee was insufficient to cover the ongoing costs of the proposed program.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking (sponsor)
Farmworker Justice
Filipino Community Center
Justice at Work Law Group, LLP
Koreatown Immigrant Workers Alliance
National Alliance for Filipino Concerns
Pilipino Association of Workers and Immigrants-Silicon Valley
Plumbers, Steamfitters, Pipefitters & HVAC Service Technicians, UA Local 393
Robyn Magalit Rodriguez, PhD, Professor UC Davis, Asian American Studies
Santa Clara Valley Contractors Association
Service Employees International Union (SEIU) California
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Pistachio Growers
Association of California Egg Farmers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Association of Wheat Growers
California Bean Shippers Association
California Blueberry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Seed Association
California State Floral Association
California Strawberry Association
Family Winemakers of California
Nisei Farmers League
Pacific Egg and Poultry Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):