AB 2159: Financial abuse.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-15
Existing law establishes the Money Transmission Act for the purpose of protecting the interests of persons in this state who use money transmission services.
This bill would require a money transmitter to provide a consumer fraud warning on all money transmittal forms used by consumers to send money to an individual, to provide consumer fraud prevention training for its agents to monitor its agents, activities relating to consumer transmittals, and to establish a toll-free number for consumers to call to report fraud or suspected fraud. The bill would make a failure to implement the fraud prevention measures established by the bill subject to a civil penalty not to exceed $1,000, or if the violation is willful, a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, establishes procedures for the reporting, investigation, and prosecution of elder and dependent adult abuse. Existing law requires persons designated as mandated reporters of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult, as defined, to report known or suspected instances of elder or dependent adult financial abuse and makes failure to comply with these requirements subject to a civil penalty not exceeding $1,000 or if the failure to report is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding $5,000. Existing law defines mandated reporters for purposes of these requirements as all officers and employees of financial institutions.This bill would also include within the definition of mandated reporters for these purposes, a money transmitter. The bill would define money transmitter as a person or entity that sells or issues payment instruments, or that receives money for transmission, as specified, but would exclude from the definition a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function. The bill would make a violation of the reporting requirements described above by a money transmitter subject to a penalty only if the violation is willful, with a civil penalty not exceeding $5,000 and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse, to be paid by the employer of the money transmitter.Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, establishes procedures for the reporting, investigation, and prosecution of elder and dependent adult abuse. Existing law requires persons designated as mandated reporters of suspected financial abuse, abuse of an elder or dependent adult, as defined, to report known or suspected instances of elder or dependent adult financial abuse and makes failure to comply with these requirements subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) $1,000 or if the failure to report is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000). $5,000. Existing law defines mandated reporters for purposes of these requirements as all officers and employees of financial institutions.
This bill would also include within the definition of mandated reporters for these purposes, a money transmitter. The bill would define money transmitter as a person who or entity that sells or issues payment instruments, or who that receives money for transmission, as specified. Under the bill, a willful specified, but would exclude from the definition a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function. The bill would make a violation of the reporting requirements described above would result in by a money transmitter subject to a penalty only if the violation is willful, with a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) $5,000 and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. abuse, to be paid by the employer of the money transmitter.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, establishes procedures for the reporting, investigation, and prosecution of elder and dependent adult abuse. Existing law requires persons designated as mandated reporters of suspected financial abuse, as defined, to report known or suspected instances of elder or dependent adult financial abuse and makes failure to comply with these requirements subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) or if the failure to report is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000). Existing law defines mandated reporters for purposes of these requirements as all officers and employees of financial institutions.
This bill would also include within the definition of mandated reporters for these purposes, a money transmitter. The bill would define money transmitter as a person who sells or issues payment instruments, or who receives money for transmission, as specified. Under the bill, a willful violation of the reporting requirements described above would result in a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse.
Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, establishes procedures for the reporting, investigation, and prosecution of elder and dependent adult abuse. These procedures require persons, defined as mandated reporters, to report known or suspected instances of elder or dependent adult abuse, as prescribed.This bill would express the intent to the Legislature to enact legislation that would expand the definition of mandatory reporters for purposes of reporting suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult.Existing law, the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, establishes procedures for the reporting, investigation, and prosecution of elder and dependent adult abuse. These procedures require persons, defined as mandated reporters, to report known or suspected instances of elder or dependent adult abuse, as prescribed.
This bill would express the intent to the Legislature to enact legislation that would expand the definition of mandatory reporters for purposes of reporting suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult.
(a)A money transmitter shall do all of the following:
(1)Provide a clear, concise, and conspicuous consumer fraud warning on all money transmittal forms used by consumers to send money to an individual.
(2)Provide consumer fraud prevention training for its agents who process money transmittals.
(3)Monitor its agents activities relating to consumer transmittals.
(4)Establish a toll-free number for consumers to call to report fraud or suspected fraud.
(b)A money transmitter that originates money transfers in this state shall allow an individual to voluntarily disqualify himself or herself from sending or receiving money transfers. The disqualification shall last for one year, unless the individual requests that the disqualification be in effect for a period longer than one year. The individual may terminate the disqualification at any time upon written notice to the money transmitter.
(c)Failure to implement the fraud prevention measures by a money transmitter under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or if the failure to implement is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000), which shall be paid by the money transmitter to the party bringing the action.
(d)Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 does not apply to a violation of this section.
(e)The civil penalty provided for in subdivision (c) shall be recovered only in a civil action brought against the money transmitter by the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. An action shall not be brought under this section by any person other than the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. Multiple actions for a civil penalty shall not be brought for the same violation.
(f)The Financial Elder Abuse Reporting Act of 2005, enacted by Senate Bill 1018 of the 200506 Regular Session, shall not be construed to limit, expand, or otherwise modify any civil liability or remedy that may exist under this or any other law.
SECTION 1.Section 15630.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:15630.1.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:(1)Financial abuse means financial abuse as defined in Section 15610.30.(2)Financial institution means any of the following:(A)A depository institution, as defined in Section 3(c) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(c)).(B)An institution-affiliated party, as defined in Section 3(u) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(u)).(C)A federal credit union or state credit union, as defined in Section 101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1752), including, but not limited to, an institution-affiliated party of a credit union, as defined in Section 206(r) of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1786(r)).(3)Mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult means either of the following:(A)An officer or employee of a financial institution.(B)A money transmitter.(4)(A)Money transmitter means a person or entity engaged in either of the following:(i)Selling or issuing payment instruments, as defined in subdivision (s) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.(ii)Receiving money for transmission, as defined in subdivision (u) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.(B)Money transmitter does not include a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function.(b)(1)A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult who has direct contact with the elder or dependent adult or who reviews or approves the elder or dependent adults financial documents, records, or transactions, in connection with providing financial services with respect to an elder or dependent adult, and who, within the scope of his or her employment or professional practice, has observed or has knowledge of an incident, that is directly related to the transaction or matter that is within that scope of employment or professional practice, that reasonably appears to be financial abuse, or who reasonably suspects that abuse, based solely on the information before him or her at the time of reviewing or approving the document, record, or transaction in the case of mandated reporters who do not have direct contact with the elder or dependent adult, shall report the known or suspected instance of financial abuse by telephone or through a confidential Internet reporting tool, as authorized pursuant to Section 15658, immediately, or as soon as practicably possible. If reported by telephone, a written report shall be sent, or an Internet report shall be made through the confidential Internet reporting tool established in Section 15658, within two working days to the local adult protective services agency or the local law enforcement agency.(2)When two or more mandated reporters jointly have knowledge or reasonably suspect that financial abuse of an elder or a dependent adult for which the report is mandated has occurred, and when there is an agreement among them, the telephone report or Internet report, as authorized by Section 15658, may be made by a member of the reporting team who is selected by mutual agreement. A single report may be made and signed by the selected member of the reporting team. A member of the team who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make that report.(3)If the mandated reporter knows that the elder or dependent adult resides in a long-term care facility, as defined in Section 15610.47, the report shall be made to the local ombudsman or local law enforcement agency.(c)An allegation by the elder or dependent adult, or any other person, that financial abuse has occurred is not sufficient to trigger the reporting requirement under this section if both of the following conditions are met:(1)The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is aware of no other corroborating or independent evidence of the alleged financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult. The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is not required to investigate any accusations.(2)In the exercise of his or her professional judgment, the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult reasonably believes that financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult did not occur.(d)(1)Failure to report financial abuse by an officer or employee of a financial institution under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) or if the failure to report is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000), which shall be paid by the financial institution that is the employer of the mandated reporter to the party bringing the action.(2)Willful failure to report financial abuse by a money transmitter under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. The civil penalty and full reimbursement shall be paid by the employer of the money transmitter to the party bringing the action.(3)Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 does not apply to a violation of this section.(e)(1)The civil penalty provided for in subdivision (d) shall be recovered only in a civil action brought against the financial institution or the employer of the money transmitter, by the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. An action shall not be brought under this section by any person other than the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. Multiple actions for the civil penalty shall not be brought for the same violation.(2)The Financial Elder Abuse Reporting Act of 2005 shall not be construed to limit, expand, or otherwise modify any civil liability or remedy that may exist under this or any other law.(f)As used in this section, suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult occurs when a person who is required to report under paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) observes or has knowledge of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, or a pattern of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, that would lead an individual with like training or experience, based on the same facts, to form a reasonable belief that an elder or dependent adult is the victim of financial abuse.(g)Reports of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult made by an employee or officer of a financial institution or by a money transmitter pursuant to this section are covered under subdivision (b) of Section 47 of the Civil Code.(h)(1)A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is authorized to not honor a power of attorney described in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code as to an attorney-in-fact, if the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult makes a report to an adult protective services agency or a local law enforcement agency of any state that the principal may be subject to financial abuse, as described in this chapter or as defined in similar laws of another state, by that attorney-in-fact or person acting for or with that attorney-in-fact.(2)If a mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult does not honor a power of attorney as to an attorney-in-fact pursuant to paragraph (1), the power of attorney shall remain enforceable as to every other attorney-in-fact also designated in the power of attorney about whom a report has not been made.(3)For purposes of this subdivision, the terms principal and attorney-in-fact have the same meanings as those terms are used in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code.(i)This section does not apply to a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function, unless that business entity is a financial institution as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a).(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Financial abuse means financial abuse as defined in Section 15610.30.
(2)Financial institution means any of the following:
(A)A depository institution, as defined in Section 3(c) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(c)).
(B)An institution-affiliated party, as defined in Section 3(u) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(u)).
(C)A federal credit union or state credit union, as defined in Section 101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1752), including, but not limited to, an institution-affiliated party of a credit union, as defined in Section 206(r) of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1786(r)).
(3)Mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult means either of the following:
(A)An officer or employee of a financial institution.
(B)A money transmitter.
(4)(A)Money transmitter means a person or entity engaged in either of the following:
(A)(i)Selling or issuing payment instruments, as defined in subdivision (s) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.
(B)(ii)Receiving money for transmission, as defined in subdivision (u) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.
(B)Money transmitter does not include a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function.
(b)(1)A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult who has direct contact with the elder or dependent adult or who reviews or approves the elder or dependent adults financial documents, records, or transactions, in connection with providing financial services with respect to an elder or dependent adult, and who, within the scope of his or her employment or professional practice, has observed or has knowledge of an incident, that is directly related to the transaction or matter that is within that scope of employment or professional practice, that reasonably appears to be financial abuse, or who reasonably suspects that abuse, based solely on the information before him or her at the time of reviewing or approving the document, record, or transaction in the case of mandated reporters who do not have direct contact with the elder or dependent adult, shall report the known or suspected instance of financial abuse by telephone or through a confidential Internet reporting tool, as authorized pursuant to Section 15658, immediately, or as soon as practicably possible. If reported by telephone, a written report shall be sent, or an Internet report shall be made through the confidential Internet reporting tool established in Section 15658, within two working days to the local adult protective services agency or the local law enforcement agency.
(2)When two or more mandated reporters jointly have knowledge or reasonably suspect that financial abuse of an elder or a dependent adult for which the report is mandated has occurred, and when there is an agreement among them, the telephone report or Internet report, as authorized by Section 15658, may be made by a member of the reporting team who is selected by mutual agreement. A single report may be made and signed by the selected member of the reporting team. A member of the team who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make that report.
(3)If the mandated reporter knows that the elder or dependent adult resides in a long-term care facility, as defined in Section 15610.47, the report shall be made to the local ombudsman or local law enforcement agency.
(c)An allegation by the elder or dependent adult, or any other person, that financial abuse has occurred is not sufficient to trigger the reporting requirement under this section if both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is aware of no other corroborating or independent evidence of the alleged financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult. The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is not required to investigate any accusations.
(2)In the exercise of his or her professional judgment, the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult reasonably believes that financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult did not occur.
(d)(1)Failure to report financial abuse by an officer or employee of a financial institution under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) or if the failure to report is willful, both a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. The civil penalty and full reimbursement, if applicable, ($5,000), which shall be paid by the financial institution that is the employer of the mandated reporter, by the money transmitter, or, as applicable, by the employer of the money transmitter, reporter to the party bringing the action. Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 does not apply to violations of this section.
(2)Willful failure to report financial abuse by a money transmitter under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. The civil penalty and full reimbursement shall be paid by the employer of the money transmitter to the party bringing the action.
(3)Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 does not apply to a violation of this section.
(e)(1)The civil penalty provided for in subdivision (d) shall be recovered only in a civil action brought against the financial institution, the money transmitter, institution or the employer of the money transmitter, by the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. An action shall not be brought under this section by any person other than the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. Multiple actions for the civil penalty shall not be brought for the same violation.
(2)The Financial Elder Abuse Reporting Act of 2005 shall not be construed to limit, expand, or otherwise modify any civil liability or remedy that may exist under this or any other law.
(f)As used in this section, suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult occurs when a person who is required to report under paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) observes or has knowledge of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, or a pattern of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, that would lead an individual with like training or experience, based on the same facts, to form a reasonable belief that an elder or dependent adult is the victim of financial abuse.
(g)Reports of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult made by an employee or officer of a financial institution or by a money transmitter pursuant to this section are covered under subdivision (b) of Section 47 of the Civil Code.
(h)(1)A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is authorized to not honor a power of attorney described in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code as to an attorney-in-fact, if the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult makes a report to an adult protective services agency or a local law enforcement agency of any state that the principal may be subject to financial abuse, as described in this chapter or as defined in similar laws of another state, by that attorney-in-fact or person acting for or with that attorney-in-fact.
(2)If a mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult does not honor a power of attorney as to an attorney-in-fact pursuant to paragraph (1), the power of attorney shall remain enforceable as to every other attorney-in-fact also designated in the power of attorney about whom a report has not been made.
(3)For purposes of this subdivision, the terms principal and attorney-in-fact have the same meanings as those terms are used in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code.
(i)This section does not apply to a business entity in which money transmission is not a primary function, unless that business entity is a financial institution as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a).
(a)As used in this section, mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult means all officers and employees of financial institutions. For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(b)As used in this section, the term financial institution means any of the following:(1)Financial abuse means financial abuse as defined in Section 15610.30.
(2)Financial institution means any of the following:
(1)(A)A depository institution, as defined in Section 3(c) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(c)).
(2)(B)An institution-affiliated party, as defined in Section 3(u) of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1813(u)).
(3)(C)A federal credit union or state credit union, as defined in Section 101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1752), including, but not limited to, an institution-affiliated party of a credit union, as defined in Section 206(r) of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. Sec. 1786(r)).
(c)As used in this section, financial abuse has the same meaning as in Section 15610.30.(3)Mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult means either of the following:
(A)An officer or employee of a financial institution.
(B)A money transmitter.
(4)Money transmitter means a person or entity engaged in either of the following:
(A)Selling or issuing payment instruments, as defined in subdivision (s) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.
(B)Receiving money for transmission, as defined in subdivision (u) of Section 2003 of the Financial Code.
(d)(b)(1)Any A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult who has direct contact with the elder or dependent adult or who reviews or approves the elder or dependent adults financial documents, records, or transactions, in connection with providing financial services with respect to an elder or dependent adult, and who, within the scope of his or her employment or professional practice, has observed or has knowledge of an incident, that is directly related to the transaction or matter that is within that scope of employment or professional practice, that reasonably appears to be financial abuse, or who reasonably suspects that abuse, based solely on the information before him or her at the time of reviewing or approving the document, record, or transaction in the case of mandated reporters who do not have direct contact with the elder or dependent adult, shall report the known or suspected instance of financial abuse by telephone or through a confidential Internet reporting tool, as authorized pursuant to Section 15658, immediately, or as soon as practicably possible. If reported by telephone, a written report shall be sent, or an Internet report shall be made through the confidential Internet reporting tool established in Section 15658, within two working days to the local adult protective services agency or the local law enforcement agency.
(2)When two or more mandated reporters jointly have knowledge or reasonably suspect that financial abuse of an elder or a dependent adult for which the report is mandated has occurred, and when there is an agreement among them, the telephone report or Internet report, as authorized by Section 15658, may be made by a member of the reporting team who is selected by mutual agreement. A single report may be made and signed by the selected member of the reporting team. Any A member of the team who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make that report.
(3)If the mandated reporter knows that the elder or dependent adult resides in a long-term care facility, as defined in Section 15610.47, the report shall be made to the local ombudsman or local law enforcement agency.
(e)(c)An allegation by the elder or dependent adult, or any other person, that financial abuse has occurred is not sufficient to trigger the reporting requirement under this section if both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is aware of no other corroborating or independent evidence of the alleged financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult. The mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is not required to investigate any accusations.
(2)In the exercise of his or her professional judgment, the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult reasonably believes that financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult did not occur.
(f)(d)Failure to report financial abuse under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) or if the failure to report is willful, both a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000), which ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. The civil penalty and full reimbursement, if applicable, shall be paid by the financial institution that is the employer of the mandated reporter reporter, by the money transmitter, or, as applicable, by the employer of the money transmitter, to the party bringing the action. Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 shall does not apply to violations of this section.
(g)(e)(1)The civil penalty provided for in subdivision (f) (d) shall be recovered only in a civil action brought against the financial institution institution, the money transmitter, or the employer of the money transmitter, by the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. No An action shall not be brought under this section by any person other than the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. Multiple actions for the civil penalty may shall not be brought for the same violation.
(2)Nothing in the The Financial Elder Abuse Reporting Act of 2005 shall not be construed to limit, expand, or otherwise modify any civil liability or remedy that may exist under this or any other law.
(h)(f)As used in this section, suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult occurs when a person who is required to report under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) (b) observes or has knowledge of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, or a pattern of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, that would lead an individual with like training or experience, based on the same facts, to form a reasonable belief that an elder or dependent adult is the victim of financial abuse as defined in Section 15610.30. abuse.
(i)(g)Reports of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult made by an employee or officer of a financial institution or by a money transmitter pursuant to this section are covered under subdivision (b) of Section 47 of the Civil Code.
(j)(h)(1)A mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult is authorized to not honor a power of attorney described in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code as to an attorney-in-fact, if the mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult makes a report to an adult protective services agency or a local law enforcement agency of any state that the principal may be subject to financial abuse, as described in this chapter or as defined in similar laws of another state, by that attorney-in-fact or person acting for or with that attorney-in-fact.
(2)If a mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult does not honor a power of attorney as to an attorney-in-fact pursuant to paragraph (1), the power of attorney shall remain enforceable as to every other attorney-in-fact also designated in the power of attorney about whom a report has not been made.
(3)For purposes of this subdivision, the terms principal and attorney-in-fact shall have the same meanings as those terms are used in Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4000) of the Probate Code.
SECTION 1.It is the intent to the Legislature to enact legislation that would expand the definition of mandatory reporters for purposes of reporting suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult.It is the intent to the Legislature to enact legislation that would expand the definition of mandatory reporters for purposes of reporting suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 15, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 26, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 24, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on AGING & L.T.C. |
| Mar 21, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on AGING & L.T.C. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on AGING & L.T.C. and JUD. |
| Feb 13, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 12, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Aging and Long-Term Care |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2159
Author:(Chu) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2018
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Elder and dependent adult financial abuse
KEY ISSUE: Should "money Transmitters" be mandatory reporters of suspected elder financial abuse, just as banks and credit unions are TODAY?
SYNOPSIS
Existing law requires officers and certain employees of banks and credit unions to report suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult to an Adult Protective Services agency or a law enforcement agency. As a "mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult," an officer or employee of a financial institution who fails to make a report as required is subject to a civil penalty not exceeding $1,000, or if the failure is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding $5,000. This bill would additionally make "money transmitters" mandatory reporters of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult. The bill defines "money transmitter" to mean any person or entity engaging in the business of selling or issuing "payment instruments" (e.g. money orders, traveler's checks) or "receiving money transmissions" by "electronic or other means." The bill is sponsored by the California Senior Legislature. Earlier versions of the bill were opposed by the Money Services Roundtable and the California Retailers Association. These groups argued, persuasively, that money transmitters, who generally engage in a one-time transaction, with a person they have no other relationship with, are quite unlike banks and credit unions who have established relationships with the depositors and borrowers. Simply put, the person behind a counter who conducts the money transmission, unlike the bank or credit union officer, is generally not in a position to have actual or constructive knowledge of financial abuse. In response to these concerns, the author agreed in the prior Committee to amend the bill in this Committee. Those amendments – which exempt retailers, clarify an employer's liability for fines, and require that a money transmitter's failure to report be "willful" in order to be fined – appear to have lessened if not entirely removed the opposition to the bill. Though the Committee is uncertain at the time of this writing if the California Retailers Association and the Money Services Roundtable are still opposed.
SUMMARY: Makes "money transmitters," as defined, mandatory reporters of elder and dependent adult financial abuse. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a "mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult" includes a "money transmitter," as defined.
- Defines a "money transmitter" to mean a person or entity engaged in either of the selling or issuing of payment instruments or the receiving of money for transmission, as those activities are defined in Section 2003 of the Financial Code.
- Specifies that a willful failure to report financial abuse by a money transmitter under this section shall result in a civil penalty not exceeding $5,000 and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. Requires the civil penalty and full reimbursement, if applicable, to be paid by the employer of the money transmitter to the party bringing the action.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill do not apply to business entities in which money transmission is not a primary function.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult who has direct contact with the elder or dependent adult or who reviews or approves the elder's or dependent adult's financial documents, records, or transactions, or who has observed or has knowledge of an incident that reasonably appears to be financial abuse, or who reasonably suspects that abuse, as specified, to report the known or suspected financial abuse to an adult protective services agency or law enforcement agency as soon as practicably possible. Specifies the manner of reporting when two or more mandated reporters jointly have knowledge or reasonable suspicion of financial abuse. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15630.1.)
- Defines "mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult" to mean all officers and employees of financial institutions, including banks, credit unions, and other depository institutions. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15630.1 (a)-(b).)
- Specifies that an allegation by the elder or dependent adult, or any other person, that financial abuse has occurred is not sufficient to trigger the reporting requirement if the mandated reporter is aware of no other corroborating evidence, or, if in the exercise of his or her professional judgment, financial abuse did not occur. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15630.1 (e).)
- Subjects a mandated reporter of elder and dependent adult financial abuse who fails to make a report, as required, to a civil penalty not exceeding $1000, or if the failure is willful, a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000, which shall be paid by the financial institution to the Attorney General, district attorney, or county attorney bringing the action. Specifies that no action shall be brought by any person other than the Attorney General, district attorney, or county counsel. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15630.1 (f)-(g).)
- Provides that a mandated reporter of elder and dependent adult financial abuse is authorized to refuse to honor a power-of-attorney if the reporter reports or suspects, as specified, that the elder or dependent adult may be subject to abuse by the attorney-in-fact. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 15630.1 (h).)
- Defines a "payment instrument" as a check, draft, money order, traveler's check, or other instrument for the transmission or payment of money or monetary value, whether or not negotiable. Specifies that a payment instrument does not include a credit card voucher, letter of credit, or any instrument that is redeemable by the issuer for goods or services. Defines "receiving money for transmission" to mean receiving money or monetary value in the United States for transmissions within or outside the United States by electronic or other means. Specifies that the term does not include the sale or issuance of payment instruments and stored value, meaning monetary value representing a claim against the issuer that is stored on an electronic or digital record, and that is intended to and accepted for use as a means of redemption of money or monetary value or payment for goods or services. (Financial Code Section 2003 (s), (u), and (x).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The Elder and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act was enacted to prevent elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect – both physical and financial – and to prosecute those who commit abuse or neglect of elders and dependent adults. Existing law defines “financial abuse” of an elder or dependent adult as appropriating the real or personal property of the elder or dependent adult for a wrongful use or with intent to defraud, or both, or assisting another person to do the same. In order to combat this problem, existing law designates certain persons as "mandated reporters" who are required to report suspected cases of elder and dependent adult abuse to an adult protective services agency or law enforcement. Mandated reporters are generally those whose occupations place them in a position to observe, or otherwise have knowledge of, elder or dependent adult abuse, including health care providers, clergy, employees of county adult protective services, or members of local law enforcement. This bill concerns a more specialized group of "mandated reporter[s] of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult,” which is defined to include officers and employees of banks and credit unions who have the opportunity to review an elder or dependent adult's financial records and documents. A mandated reporter of financial abuse who fails to make a report as required is subject to a civil penalty not exceeding $1,000, or if the failure is willful, a civil penalty not exceeding $5,000.
This bill would extend the mandatory reporting requirements that currently apply to the employees and officers of financial institutions to money transmitters. The bill defines "money transmitters" as persons or entities engaged in selling "payment instruments" or "receiving money transmissions," as these terms are defined in the Financial Code. Payment instruments are defined there to include money orders, traveler's checks, and the like, while "receiving money transmissions" is defined as receiving money or monetary value "by electronic or other means." Although the classic model of the "money transmitter" appears to be a money-wiring service like Western Union, the reach of the term has become considerably more complicated in the age of Pay Pal, online banking, or even retailers like Amazon that, in theory, only provide a "platform" for the exchange for money and goods.
The Western Union Case. Based on the background information provided by the author, the primary concern of this bill appears to be with the more conventional money-wiring services like Western Union, or at least Western Union is offered as the face of the problem that the bill seeks to address. In particular, the background material refers to a $586 million settlement in 2017 that Western Union reached with the U.S. Department of Justice, the Federal Trade Commission, and several federal U.S. attorney offices for aiding and abetting wire fraud. Apparently, as part of the scheme, fraudsters contacted victims within the United States and instructed them to transmit money through Western Union offices. The money was sent to go to family members supposedly in need, to claim prizes, or to be pilfered in some other manner. According to the admissions contained in the agreement, some of the Western union agents in certain locations were complicit in these schemes. Western Union allegedly failed to take corrective actions or terminate the corrupt agents. In addition to paying the $586 million fine, Western Union also agreed to adopt policies and procedures that might better detect and eliminate suspicious or illegal activity among its agents.
However, it is not entirely clear how the provisions and premise of this bill would address the Western Union situation. In that case, the Western Union agents were participating in the fraud, whereas this bill would require agents to act as mandatory reporters of financial abuse committed by others. In short, this bill does not anticipate a corrupt agent; it anticipates an honest agent that pays attention to signs of potential elder financial abuse and reports it to Adult Protective Services. This is not to say that this bill will not help to combat abuse, it is only to say that it has little bearing on the problem in the Western Union case. There is also no evidence in reports on the Western Union case that the victims were disproportionately elders or dependent adults.
Money Transmitters vs. Bank Officers. The primary objection raised by those who oppose or have concerns about this bill is that employees who conduct the money transmission are nothing like officers or employees of bank or credit unions. Bank and credit union officers, including not only tellers but loan officers or account managers, have an established, ongoing relationship with customers, depositors, and borrowers. By the terms of existing law, the mandatory reporters in the financial institution are persons who have "direct contact" with elders and "review or approve" the elder's "financial documents, records, or transactions" in the course of providing an array of financial services, from taking deposits to approving loans. Because they directly interact with elderly customers on an ongoing basis and review financial documents or records, bank and credit union employees are more much likely to notice patterns or changes that might indicate financial abuse than the person who performs the perfunctory service of selling a money order or taking the address of the intended recipient of the money transfer. In some cases, as the California Retailers Association points out, the person who performs the transaction may be a store clerk who only handles transactions as they arise, and who otherwise has no particular knowledge or experience in identifying financial abuse. In some retail establishments, such as drug stores, money transmissions are offer as a distinctly secondary service. Clerks of the store, not agents or employees of the money-wiring service, conduct the transaction.
Under existing law, bank and credit union employees or officers who are mandatory reporters are only required to report financial abuse that they observe or have actual knowledge of an incident that, in relation to the transaction, "reasonably appears to be financial abuse." The mandatory reporter in the financial institutions is one who "observes or has knowledge of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, or a pattern of behavior or unusual circumstances or transactions, that would lead an individual with like training or experience, based on the same facts, to form a reasonable belief that an elder or dependent adult is the victim of financial abuse." Existing law provides that even where the elder or dependent adult has made an allegation that abuse has occurred, the reporter is not required to report it if he or she "is aware of no other corroborating or independent evidence of the" alleged abuse and, if in the mandated reporter's "professional judgment," she reasonably believes that abuse did not occur. It would appear that only in rare circumstances would the clerk who performs a money transmission would have any opportunity to acquire knowledge of "patterns" of behavior or unusual circumstances that would indicate abuse. In sum, it appears that both proponents and opponents may overstate the bill's impact. The opposition fears that clerks and agents, or more accurately their employers, will be fined for failure to report. However, this fear may be overstated, because only in rare circumstances will employees have knowledge of sufficient facts and patterns that would trigger the reporting requirement and, therefore, a fine for failure to report. Proponents of this bill may overstate the bill's benefits for the same reason: clerks and agents will rarely be in a position to have sufficient knowledge of abuse to trigger reporting. In another Western Union case where agents and clerks are complicit, a reporting requirement will not help because the corrupt agents are unlikely to report themselves. Nonetheless, in the likely few instances where a clerk or agent has a sufficient and reasonable belief that abuse may be occurring, then the bill may help to prevent those few incidents of abuse.
Proposed Author Amendments. Based on discussions and concerns that arose in the prior Committee, the author will take amendments in this Committee that address some of the opposition, though the Committee is not certain if these amendments will remove all opposition. The amendments below do the following: (1) clarify that it is the employer and not the employee who is subject to penalties; (2) exempt retailers from the bill by specifying that its provisions do not apply to a business or entity that is not primarily engaged in money transmission; and (3) specify that a money transmitter is only liable for a fine for a "willful" failure to report. Specifically, the amendments restructure and revise subdivision (d) on page 4, lines 24-35, as follows:
(d) (1) Failure to report financial abuse by a money transmitter under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) or if the A willful failure to report is willful, both financial abuse by a money transmitter under this section shall be subject results in a civil penalty not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000) and full reimbursement to the victim for the financial loss suffered as a result of the financial abuse. The civil penalty and full reimbursement, if applicable, shall be paid by the money transmitter, or, as applicable, by the employer of the money transmitter, to the party bringing the action. Subdivision (h) of Section 15630 does not apply to violations of this section.
(2): Section 15630.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code does not apply to business entities in which money transmission is not a primary function.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, AB 2159 "is a sound approach to protect seniors from falling victim to financial fraud by requiring money transmitters to report suspicious activity to law enforcement or an adult protective services agency." The author points out that while existing law requires financial institutions to act as mandated reporters, "money transmitters are not required to provide information related to suspected fraud targeting seniors." Filling this gap, the author believes, will add "a layer of protection for seniors during the occasions in which business transactions are conducted through money wiring services. With California’s senior population set to increase by four million by the year 2030, it is imperative to take legislative action and strengthen law to protect this growing segment in the state."
According to the California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association (CLTCOA), recent reports have highlighted a growing problem of fraud against older adults and suggest that this problem will only worsen as the older adult population grows. CLTCOA contends that "money transmitters are often in a position to have knowledge or reasonable suspicions when an older adult is being financially victimized. By adding 'money transmitters' as mandated financial abuse reporters, AB 2159 provides additional oversight for a vulnerable population during these financial transactions. In addition, AB 2159 will mandate that such persons receive appropriate training on when and how they should report."
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION (to the bill in print): The Money Services Roundtable (MSR) points out, in opposition to this bill, that the mandated reporting requirements for elder financial abuse "were designed for the business model of banks and credit unions" and imposing these same requirements "on money transmitters who offer services through an entirely different model is not practical. The individual store clerks who actually deliver money transmitters' services – at the point-of-sale through licensees' retail agent networks such as grocery stores or pharmacies – should not be expected to be sophisticated financial services providers and, accordingly, reporters of activity that meets a complex statutory definition of elder or dependent financial abuse." MSR also argues that the bill "has the potential to subject money transmitter licensees to substantial civil penalties for acts that are out of the licensee's control, significantly increase the risks and costs of doing business in California, and significantly disrupt the ability of these licensees to offer their services to California residents."
The California Retailers Association (CRA) opposes the bill because it believes it is inappropriate to apply mandatory reporting requirements that currently and sensibly apply to banks and credit unions to money transmitters. CRA agrees that banks and credit unions should be mandatory reporters of financial elder abuse because "they are depository institutions that have an ongoing relationship with their customers. Conversely, money transmissions are typically single transactions, lacking many of the customer details that exist in financial institution transactions. Without these details, like the age of the customer, a money transmitter may not know whether a customer is an elder or dependent adult, or whether any type of abuse has occurred." Of particular import to the retail industry, CRA points out that, when a money transmission service is provided through a retailer, the person performing the transmission is an employee of the retailer, who spends most of his or her work day performing retail duties unrelated to money transmission. Given the limited, relatively infrequent, usually one-time nature of the transaction, CRA concludes that it is "unreasonable to expect these retail employees to notice and flag elder and dependent adult financial abuse."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Senior Legislature (sponsor)
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Opposition (to the bill in print)
California Retailers Association
Money Services Round Table
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON AGING AND LONG-TERM CARE
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2159 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2018
SUBJECT: Elder and dependent adult financial abuse.
SUMMARY: Includes money transmitters as mandated reporters of suspected elder and dependent financial abuse. Specifically, this bill:
1) Adds “money transmitter” to the definition of a mandated reporter of suspected elder and dependent adult financial abuse, and requires them to report known or suspected elder or dependent adult financial abuse to county adult protective services (APS) agencies or local law enforcement.
2) Defines money transmitter as a person or entity engaged in selling or issuing payment instruments, or receiving money for transmission.
3) Makes a money transmitter, and the employer of a money transmitter, subject to civil penalties for failure to report suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult.
EXISTING LAW:
1) The Elder and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, was enacted to prevent elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect, and to prosecute those that inflict that abuse or neglect on elders and dependent adults.
2) Defines “financial abuse” of an elder or dependent adult as the taking, secreting, appropriation or retention of real or personal property of the elder or dependent adult to a wrongful use or with intent to defraud, or both, or assisting another person in the above activities, and deems the taking, secreting, appropriating, or retaining of property for a wrongful use, if it is done in bad faith.
3) Requires mandated reporters who observe or have knowledge of elder or dependent adult physical or financial abuse or neglect, or is told by the elder or dependent adult that he/she has experienced abuse, to immediately report the known or suspected abuse.
4) Defines “mandated reporter” as any person who is a provider of care to the elder or dependent adult, a health practitioner, clergy member, employee of county adult protective services or a member of local law enforcement.
5) Defines “mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult” as all officers and employees of financial institutions, and defines “financial institution” as a depository institution, an institution-affiliated party, or a federal, state, or institution-affiliated party credit union.
6) Provides that a mandated reporter of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult who fails to report financial abuse shall be subject to a civil penalty not exceeding $1,000. If the failure to report is willful, the civil penalty may be up to $5,000.
7) Specifies that the civil penalty shall be paid by the financial institution who is the employer of the mandated reporter to the party bringing the action.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: “This bill is a sound approach to protect seniors from falling victim to financial fraud by requiring money transmitters to report suspicious activity to law enforcement or an adult protective services agency.
“Current law requires financial institutions to act as mandated reporters. However, money transmitters are not required to provide information related to suspected fraud targeting seniors.
“By filling this gap in law, AB 2159 adds a layer of protection for seniors during the occasions in which business transactions are conducted through money wiring services.
“With California’s senior population set to increase by four million by the year 2030, it is imperative to take legislative action and strengthen law to protect this growing segment in the state.”
Note: The author intends to clarify that the money transmitter, or the employer of the money transmitter shall be subject to any civil penalties and not an employee.
BACKGROUND:
The Elder and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act was enacted to prevent elder and dependent adult abuse and neglect – both physical and financial – and to prosecute those who commit abuse or neglect on elders and dependent adults. Existing law defines “financial abuse” of an elder or dependent adult as appropriating the real or personal property of the elder or dependent adult for a wrongful use or with intent to defraud, or both, or assisting another person to do the same. In order to combat this problem, existing law designates certain persons as “mandated reporters” who are required to report suspected cases of elder and dependent adult abuse to an adult protective services agency or law enforcement. Mandated reporters are generally those whose occupations place them in a position to observe, or otherwise have knowledge of, elder or dependent adult abuse, including health care providers, clergy, employees of county adult protective services, or members of local law enforcement.
Elder Financial Abuse: The California Department of Social Services reports that for fiscal year 2015/16 Adult Protective Services received 12,177 reports of financial abuse from financial institutions. This represented 7% of all reports of abuse and neglect and an average of 1,014 reports from financial institutions per month. There was an average of 756 reports of abuse confirmed each month in fiscal year 2015/16. There were an additional 1,556 inconclusive financial abuses cases each month. Inconclusive means that the Department had reason to believe that the abuse occurred but, no proof. Bank officers and employees are regularly presented with situations that require them to honor a power of attorney despite having knowledge that a financial elder abuse report has been filed on the holder of the power of attorney. According to the True Link Report on Elder Financial Abuse 2015, $16.99 billion is lost to financial exploitation annually, $12.76 billion is lost to criminal fraud or identity theft annually, and $6.67 billion is lost to deceit or theft enabled by a trusting relationship annually.
Money transmitters operate in a variety of commercial retail settings. For instance, Money Gram operates out of 98 outlets in the City of Sacramento alone, including, among others, some
Bel Air grocery outlets, Longs Drugs stores, 7-11s, Advance America outlets, and Ace Cash Express outlets. The Money Transmitter Division of the Department of Business Oversight licenses and regulates money transmitters, which includes issuers of payment instruments (money orders), traveler’s checks and stored value. The California money transmission laws are found in the California Financial Code and are cited as the Money Transmission Act. The legislature finds and declares in the Money Transmission Act that to protect the interests of consumers of money transmission businesses in this state, to maintain public confidence in financial institutions doing business in this state, and to preserve the health, safety, and general welfare of the people of this state, it is necessary to regulate money transmission businesses in this state.
MoneyGram International, Inc., the second-largest money transfer service in the United States, will pay $18 million in consumer redress to settle FTC charges that the company allowed its money transfer system to be used by fraudulent telemarketers to bilk U.S. consumers out of tens of millions of dollars. MoneyGram also will be required to implement a comprehensive anti-fraud and agent-monitoring program.
The FTC charged that between 2004 and 2008, MoneyGram agents helped fraudulent telemarketers and other con artists who tricked U.S. consumers into wiring more than $84 million within the United States and to Canada – after these consumers were falsely told they had won a lottery, were hired for a secret shopper program, or were guaranteed loans. The $84 million in losses is based on consumer complaints to MoneyGram – actual consumer losses likely are much higher.
The FTC charged that MoneyGram knew that its system was being used to defraud people but did very little about it. According to the FTC’s complaint, MoneyGram knew, or avoided knowing, that about 131 of its more than 1,200 agents accounted for more than 95 percent of the fraud complaints it received in 2008 regarding money transfers to Canada; a similarly small number of agents was responsible for more than 96 percent of all fraud complaints to the company in 2006.
The Western Union Company (Western Union), a global money services business headquartered in Englewood, Colorado, has agreed to forfeit $586 million and enter into agreements with the Justice Department, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the U.S. Attorney’s Offices for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, the Central District of California, the Eastern District of Pennsylvania and the Southern District of Florida. In its agreement with the Justice Department, Western Union admits to criminal violations including willfully failing to maintain an effective anti-money laundering (AML) program and aiding and abetting wire fraud.
According to admissions contained in the deferred prosecution agreement (DPA) and the accompanying statement of facts, between 2004 and 2012, Western Union violated U.S. laws—the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and anti-fraud statutes—by processing hundreds of thousands of transactions for Western Union agents and others involved in an international consumer fraud scheme.
As part of the scheme, fraudsters contacted victims in the U.S. and falsely posed as family members in need or promised prizes or job opportunities. The fraudsters directed the victims to send money through Western Union to help their relative or claim their prize. Various Western Union agents were complicit in these fraud schemes, often processing the fraud payments for the fraudsters in return for a cut of the fraud proceeds.
Western Union knew of but failed to take corrective action against Western Union agents involved in or facilitating fraud-related transactions. Beginning in at least 2004, Western Union recorded customer complaints about fraudulently induced payments in what are known as consumer fraud reports (CFRs). In 2004, Western Union’s Corporate Security Department proposed global guidelines for discipline and suspension of Western Union agents that processed a materially elevated number of fraud transactions. In these guidelines, the Corporate Security Department effectively recommended automatically suspending any agent that paid 15 CFRs within 120 days. Had Western Union implemented these proposed guidelines, it could have prevented significant fraud losses to victims and would have resulted in corrective action against more than 2,000 agents worldwide between 2004 and 2012.
Argument in Support: “On behalf of the Congress of California Seniors, I am writing to urge your support for AB 2159 (Chu). This bill expands the definition of abuse contained in California’s Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act to include abusive actions made by a money transmitter. State law already criminalizes financial abuse committed by employees of financial institutions. Money transmitters are a specific category of independent actors who include issuers of payment instruments (money orders), traveler’s checks and stored value. They are licensed by the Money Transmitter Division of the state Department of Business Oversight.
“Money transmitters often see elderly and dependent adults in intimate personal situations with their close family and associates. They may witness heartbreaking episodes of financial abuse, and, as such, should be required to report such abuse to authorities.”
Argument in Opposition: The California Retailers Association states, “While we appreciate the author’s desire to mitigate elder and dependent adult financial abuse, we do not believe that the mandatory reporting requirements applicable to financial institutions can reasonably be applied to money transmitters. The reporting scheme designed for traditional financial institutions is not congruous with the money transmitter business model. Financial institutions are depository entities that have ongoing relationships with their customers. Conversely, money transmissions are typically single transactions, lacking many of the customer details that exist in financial institution transactions. Without these details, like the age of the customer, a money transmitter may not know whether a customer is an elder or dependent adult, nor whether any type of abuse has occurred.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Senior Legislature – Sponsor
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
Congress of California Seniors
Opposition
California Bankers Association (CBA)
California Retailers Association
The Money Services Round Table
Analysis Prepared by: Barry Brewer / AGING & L.T.C. / (916) 319-3990
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Aging and Long-Term Care
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):