AB 2220: College Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-25
Existing law, known as the Student Athlete Bill of Rights, requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law requires these institutions to rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Existing law defines student athlete for purposes of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Existing law provides for a scholarship to be provided by the institution to an injured student athlete for up to 5 academic years.
This bill would instead require all intercollegiate athletic programs at private postsecondary educational institutions, independent institutions of higher education, or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes to comply with the prescribed requirements. The bill would rename the Student Athlete Bill of Rights as the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights and would redesignate student athlete as college student athlete for purposes of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would delete the provisions requiring an institution to exclusively use revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would provide the require a scholarship to be provided to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the five-year 5-year limit upon showing of cause for need. The bill would require the provision of an equivalent scholarship to an athletic scholarship to a college student athlete who has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility under certain circumstances. The bill would exempt, from certain of these requirements, institutions that receive, as an average over the most recent 3-year period, less than $10,000,000 in annual revenue as reported pursuant to federal law. The bill would provide a private right of action, as specified, to college student athletes for a violation of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined. require an institution of higher education to provide each of its college student athletes with a copy of their rights established under the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights and designate an individual at the institution to receive complaints from college student athletes for violations of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would establish a process by which a suspected violation of a college student athletes rights under the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights can be investigated and remedied.
Existing law, known as the Student Athlete Bill of Rights, requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law requires these institutions to rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Existing law defines student athlete for purposes of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Existing law provides for a scholarship to be provided by the institution to an injured student athlete for up to 5 academic years.
This bill would instead require all intercollegiate athletic programs at private postsecondary educational institutions, independent institutions of higher education, or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes to comply with the prescribed requirements. The bill would rename the Student Athlete Bill of Rights as the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights and would redesignate student athlete as college student athlete for purposes of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would delete the provisions requiring an institution to exclusively use revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would provide for an equivalent scholarship to be provided by the institution to an injured athlete for up to 6 years rather than up to 5 years. provide the scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the five-year limit upon showing of cause for need. The bill would provide a private right of action, as specified, to college student athletes for a violation of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined.
Existing law, known as the Student Athlete Bill of Rights, requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law requires these institutions to rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Existing law defines student athlete for purposes of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
This bill would would instead require all intercollegiate athletic programs at private postsecondary educational institutions, independent institutions of higher education, or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that provide athletic scholarships for student college athletes to comply with these the prescribed requirements. The bill would rename the Student Athlete Bill of Rights as the College Athlete Bill of Rights and would redesignate student athlete as college athlete for purposes of the College Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would delete the provisions requiring an institution to exclusively use revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray certain costs accrued under the College Athlete Bill of Rights. The bill would provide for an equivalent scholarship to be provided by the institution to an injured athlete for up to 6 years rather than up to 5 years. The bill would provide a private right of action, as specified, to student college athletes who claim to have had any rights established under the Student for a violation of the College Athlete Bill of Rights violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined.
Existing law, known as the Student Athlete Bill of Rights, requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights.
This bill would instead require all intercollegiate athletic programs at private postsecondary educational institutions, independent institutions of higher education, or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that provide athletic scholarships for student athletes to comply with these requirements. The bill would provide a private right of action, as specified, to student athletes who claim to have had any rights established under the Student Athlete Bill of Rights violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Meeting the educational needs of college student athletes should be a priority for intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Californias institutions of higher education that participate in Division I and Division II intercollegiate athletics collectively generate millions of dollars annually in media contracts, and this revenue would not exist without the efforts of college student athletes.
(c)College student athletes generate large revenues for many athletic programs, spend approximately 20 hours per week participating in their respective sports, and suffer current and historically low graduation rates.
(d)Providing adequate health and safety protection for college student athletes can help prevent serious injury and death.
(e)Current and former college student athletes can be left to pay for medical expenses incurred from injuries suffered while participating in intercollegiate athletics.
(f)Institutions of higher education should provide their college student athletes with the same due process protection afforded to students who do not participate in athletics.
(g)Athletic programs in this state are subject to federal gender equity requirements under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(h)An institution of higher education should not punish any college student athlete for transferring to another institution of higher education.
(i)An institution of higher education should not use funds for purposes of this part that are dedicated for the benefit of the general student body.
SEC. 3.Section 67451 of the Education Code is amended to read:67451.For purposes of this part:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of college student athletes who graduate from that institution of higher education within six years of their initial enrollment, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for college student athletes.
(e)College student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes college student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 4.Section 67452 of the Education Code is amended to read:67452.Commencing with the 201314 academic year, an athletic program shall comply with all of the following:
(a)(1)If an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a college student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the institution of higher educations medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, the institution of higher education shall provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the college student athlete, will be provided for a total of up to five academic years or until the college student athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter. A college student athlete shall be granted one additional academic year beyond the five academic years upon showing of cause for need. Additional years may be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education.
(2)If a college student athlete takes a temporary leave of absence from an institution of higher education, the duration of that leave of absence shall not count against the five-year limit on eligibility for an equivalent scholarship imposed by paragraph (1).
(3)An athletic program shall provide an equivalent scholarship to a college student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing, but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year or until the college student athlete completes his or her primary undergraduate degree, whichever is shorter, except that an athletic program with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team, shall not be subject to the requirements of this paragraph.(4)(3)A college student athlete whose athletic scholarship is not renewed for cause by an athletic program shall receive no benefits under this part, but may appeal this decision within the institution of higher education attended by the student or within the athletic conference or association of which that institution of higher education is a member, as appropriate.
(b)Each athletic program shall conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all of its first-year and third-year college student athletes at the beginning of the academic year. This workshop shall include, but not be limited to, information concerning financial aid, debt management, and a recommended budget for full- and partial-scholarship college student athletes living on or off campus during the academic year and the summer term based on the current academic years cost of attendance. The workshop shall also include information on time management skills necessary for success as a college student athlete, and academic resources available on campus.
(c)An institution of higher education shall grant a college student athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid.
(d)An athletic program shall respond within seven business days with an answer to a college student athletes written request to transfer to another institution of higher education.
SEC. 5.Section 67452.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:67452.5.(a)An athletic program shall provide an equivalent scholarship to a college student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing, but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year or until the college student athlete completes his or her primary undergraduate degree, whichever is shorter.
(b)An athletic program with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team, shall not be subject to the requirements of subdivision (a).
(c)An institution of higher education that receives, as an average over the most recent three-year period, less than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual revenue as reported to the Office of Postsecondary Education of the United States Department of Education pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act shall not be subject to the requirements of subdivision (a).
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 67453 of the Education Code is amended to read:67453.(a)(1)Unless a college student athlete declines the payment of premiums, an athletic program shall be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its college student athletes whose household has an income and asset level that does not exceed the level for Cal Grant A recipients set forth in Section 69432.7 for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
(2)An athletic program shall be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any college student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program and makes a claim relating to that injury.
(3)If a college student athlete suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, the athletic program shall provide, for a minimum of two years following the college student athletes graduation or separation from the institution of higher education, one of the following:
(A)The necessary medical treatment.
(B)Health insurance that covers the injury and the resulting deductible amounts.
(4)This subdivision shall not apply to preexisting medical conditions that predate the college student athletes participation in the athletic program.
(b)An athletic program shall adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration. In addition, an athletic program shall adopt and implement exercise and supervision guidelines for any college student athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
(c)An institution of higher education that receives, as an average, less than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual revenue as reported to the Office of Postsecondary Education of the United States Department of Education pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act shall not be subject to the requirements of this section.
SEC. 6.SEC. 7.Section 67453.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:67453.5.(a)A67453.5.(a)A institution of higher education shall provide a copy of the rights established for college student athletes under this chapter to each of its college student athletes, at least once per academic year, at the start of the season of the college student athletes sport. The institution of higher education shall designate an individual to receive complaints for violations of this chapter and include the contact information of that designated individual for each of its college student athletes.
(b)A college student athlete may report a violation of this chapter to the individual designated at the institution of higher education pursuant to subdivision (a). The institution shall have 60 days from the filing of that report to conduct an investigation of the complaint, conclude that investigation, and provide an appropriate remedy for each violation determined pursuant to the investigation.
(c)If a violation of this chapter is not remedied by an institution of higher education within 60 days of the filing of a report described in subdivision (b), the college student athlete may submit a civil action claim against the institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, to the Attorney General, or the appropriate district attorney or county counsel.
(d)If the Attorney General, or the appropriate district attorney or county counsel, does not pursue legal action within 60 days of the filing of a civil action claim pursuant to subdivision (c), the college student athlete may pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief from his or her institution of higher education, the institution, including any of its personnel, for a violation of this chapter. A college student athlete who prevails in an action brought pursuant to this section subdivision may recover reasonable attorneys fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief, against the institution and its personnel.
(b)(e)For purposes of this section, personnel means one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Meeting the educational needs of college student athletes should be a priority for intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Californias institutions of higher education that participate in Division I and Division II intercollegiate athletics collectively generate millions of dollars annually in media contracts, and this revenue would not exist without the efforts of college student athletes.
(c)College student athletes generate large revenues for many athletic programs, spend approximately 40 20 hours per week participating in their respective sports, and suffer current and historically low graduation rates.
(d)Providing adequate health and safety protection for college student athletes can help prevent serious injury and death.
(e)Current and former college student athletes can be left to pay for medical expenses incurred from injuries suffered while participating in intercollegiate athletics.
(f)Institutions of higher education should provide their college student athletes with the same due process protection afforded to students who do not participate in athletics.
(g)Athletic programs in this state are subject to federal gender equity requirements under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(h)An institution of higher education should not punish any college student athlete for transferring to another institution of higher education.
(i)An institution of higher education should not use funds for purposes of this part that are dedicated for the benefit of the general student body.
SEC. 3.Section 67451 of the Education Code is amended to read:67451.For purposes of this part:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of college student athletes who graduate from that institution of higher education within six years of their initial enrollment, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for college student athletes.
(e)College student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes college student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 4.Section 67452 of the Education Code is amended to read:67452.Commencing with the 201314 academic year, an athletic program shall comply with all of the following:
(a)(1)If an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a college student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the institution of higher educations medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, the institution of higher education shall provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the college student athlete, will be provided for a total of up to six five academic years or until the college student athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter. A college student athlete shall be granted one additional academic year beyond the five academic years upon showing of cause for need. Additional years may be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education.
(2)If a college student athlete takes a temporary leave of absence from an institution of higher education, the duration of that leave of absence shall not count against the six-year five-year limit on eligibility for an equivalent scholarship imposed by paragraph (1).
(3)An athletic program shall provide an equivalent scholarship to a college student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing, but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year or until the college student athlete completes his or her primary undergraduate degree, whichever is shorter, except that an athletic program with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team, shall not be subject to the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)A college student athlete whose athletic scholarship is not renewed for cause by an athletic program shall receive no benefits under this part, but may appeal this decision within the institution of higher education attended by the student or within the athletic conference or association of which that institution of higher education is a member, as appropriate.
(b)Each athletic program shall conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all of its first-year and third-year college athletes at the beginning of the academic year. This workshop shall include, but not be limited to, information concerning financial aid, debt management, and a recommended budget for full- and partial-scholarship college student athletes living on or off campus during the academic year and the summer term based on the current academic years cost of attendance. The workshop shall also include information on time management skills necessary for success as a college student athlete, and academic resources available on campus.
(c)An institution of higher education shall grant a college student athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid.
(d)An athletic program shall respond within seven business days with an answer to a college student athletes written request to transfer to another institution of higher education.
SEC. 5.Section 67453 of the Education Code is amended to read:67453.(a)(1)Unless a college student athlete declines the payment of premiums, an athletic program shall be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its college student athletes whose household has an income and asset level that does not exceed the level for Cal Grant A recipients set forth in Section 69432.7 for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
(2)An athletic program shall be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any college student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program and makes a claim relating to that injury.
(3)If a college student athlete suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, the athletic program shall provide, for a minimum of two years following the college student athletes graduation or separation from the institution of higher education, one of the following:
(A)The necessary medical treatment.
(B)Health insurance that covers the injury and the resulting deductible amounts.
(4)This subdivision shall not apply to preexisting medical conditions that predate the college student athletes participation in the athletic program.
(b)An athletic program shall adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration. In addition, an athletic program shall adopt and implement exercise and supervision guidelines for any college student athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
SEC. 6.Section 67453.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:67453.5.(a)A college student athlete may pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief from his or her institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, for a violation of this chapter. A college student athlete who prevails in an action brought pursuant to this section may recover reasonable attorneys fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief, against the institution and its personnel.
(b)For purposes of this section, personnel means one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Meeting the educational needs of student college athletes should be a priority for intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Californias institutions of higher education that participate in Division I and Division II intercollegiate athletics collectively generate millions of dollars annually in media contracts, and this revenue would not exist without the efforts of student college athletes.
(c)Student College athletes generate large revenues for many athletic programs, spend approximately 40 hours per week participating in their respective sports, and suffer current and historically low graduation rates.
(d)Providing adequate health and safety protection for student college athletes can help prevent serious injury and death.
(e)Current and former student college athletes can be left to pay for medical expenses incurred from injuries suffered while participating in intercollegiate athletics.
(f)Institutions of higher education should provide their student college athletes with the same due process protection afforded to students who do not participate in athletics.
(g)Athletic programs in this state are subject to federal gender equity requirements under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(h)An institution of higher education should not punish any student college athlete for transferring to another institution of higher education.
(i)An institution of higher education should not use funds for purposes of this part that are dedicated for the benefit of the general student body.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 67451 of the Education Code is amended to read:67451.For purposes of this part:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student college athletes who graduate from that institution of higher education within six years of their initial enrollment, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for student college athletes.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.(f)Student(e)College athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student college athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.SEC. 4.Section 67452 of the Education Code is amended to read:67452.Commencing with the 201314 academic year, an athletic program shall comply with all of the following:
(a)(1)If an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student college athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the institution of higher educations medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, the institution of higher education shall provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the student college athlete, will be provided for a total of up to five six academic years or until the student college athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter. Additional years may be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education.
(2)If a student college athlete takes a temporary leave of absence from an institution of higher education, the duration of that leave of absence shall not count against the five-year six-year limit on eligibility for an equivalent scholarship imposed by paragraph (1).
(3)An athletic program shall provide an equivalent scholarship to a student college athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing, but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year or until the student college athlete completes his or her primary undergraduate degree, whichever is shorter, except that an athletic program with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team, shall not be subject to the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)A student college athlete whose athletic scholarship is not renewed for cause by an athletic program shall receive no benefits under this part, but may appeal this decision within the institution of higher education attended by the student or within the athletic conference or association of which that institution of higher education is a member, as appropriate.
(b)Each athletic program shall conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all of its first-year and third-year student college athletes at the beginning of the academic year. This workshop shall include, but not be limited to, information concerning financial aid, debt management, and a recommended budget for full- and partial-scholarship student college athletes living on or off campus during the academic year and the summer term based on the current academic years cost of attendance. The workshop shall also include information on time management skills necessary for success as a student college athlete, and academic resources available on campus.
(c)An institution of higher education shall grant a student college athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid.
(d)An athletic program shall respond within seven business days with an answer to a student college athletes written request to transfer to another institution of higher education.
(e)An institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section.SEC. 3.SEC. 5.Section 67453 of the Education Code is amended to read:67453.(a)(1)Unless a student college athlete declines the payment of premiums, an athletic program shall be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student college athletes whose household has an income and asset level that does not exceed the level for Cal Grant A recipients set forth in Section 69432.7 for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
(2)An athletic program shall be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any student college athlete who suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program and makes a claim relating to that injury.
(3)If a student college athlete suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, the athletic program shall provide, for a minimum of two years following the student college athletes graduation or separation from the institution of higher education, one of the following:
(A)The necessary medical treatment.
(B)Health insurance that covers the injury and the resulting deductible amounts.
(4)This subdivision shall not apply to preexisting medical conditions that predate the student college athletes participation in the athletic program.
(b)An athletic program shall adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration. In addition, an athletic program shall adopt and implement exercise and supervision guidelines for any student college athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
(c)An institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section.SEC. 4.SEC. 6.Section 67453.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:67453.5.(a)A student college athlete who claims to have had any of his or her rights established under this chapter violated by an may pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief from his or her institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, shall have a private right of action to enjoin the violation if the violation is ongoing, and to seek damages, including, but not necessarily limited to, for a violation of this chapter. A college athlete who prevails in an action brought pursuant to this section may recover reasonable attorneys fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief, against the institution and its personnel who are alleged to have been responsible the violation. personnel.
(b)For purposes of this section, personnel means one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
For purposes of this part:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from that institution of higher education within six years of their initial enrollment, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program. private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for student athletes.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452 of the Education Code is amended to read:67452.Commencing with the 201314 academic year, an athletic program shall comply with all of the following:
(a)(1)If an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the institution of higher educations medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, the institution of higher education shall provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the student athlete, will be provided for a total of up to five academic years or until the student athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter. Additional years may be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education.
(2)If a student athlete takes a temporary leave of absence from an institution of higher education, the duration of that leave of absence shall not count against the five-year limit on eligibility for an equivalent scholarship imposed by paragraph (1).
(3)An athletic program shall provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing, but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year or until the student athlete completes his or her primary undergraduate degree, whichever is shorter, except that an athletic program with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team, shall not be subject to the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)A student athlete whose athletic scholarship is not renewed for cause by an athletic program shall receive no benefits under this part, but may appeal this decision within the institution of higher education attended by the student or within the athletic conference or association of which that institution of higher education is a member, as appropriate.
(b)Each athletic program shall conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all of its first-year and third-year student athletes at the beginning of the academic year. This workshop shall include, but not be limited to, information concerning financial aid, debt management, and a recommended budget for full- and partial-scholarship student athletes living on or off campus during the academic year and the summer term based on the current academic years cost of attendance. The workshop shall also include information on time management skills necessary for success as a student athlete, and academic resources available on campus.
(c)An institution of higher education shall grant a student athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid.
(d)An athletic program shall respond within seven business days with an answer to a student athletes written request to transfer to another institution of higher education.
(e)An institution of higher education that receives, as an average, less than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual income derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics shall not be subject to the requirements of this section.(f)(e)An institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section.
SEC. 3.Section 67453 of the Education Code is amended to read:67453.(a)(1)Unless a student athlete declines the payment of premiums, an athletic program shall be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student athletes whose household has an income and asset level that does not exceed the level for Cal Grant A recipients set forth in Section 69432.7 for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
(2)An athletic program shall be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program and makes a claim relating to that injury.
(3)If a student athlete suffers an injury resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, the athletic program shall provide, for a minimum of two years following the student athletes graduation or separation from the institution of higher education, one of the following:
(A)The necessary medical treatment.
(B)Health insurance that covers the injury and the resulting deductible amounts.
(4)This subdivision shall not apply to preexisting medical conditions that predate the student athletes participation in the athletic program.
(b)An athletic program shall adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration. In addition, an athletic program shall adopt and implement exercise and supervision guidelines for any student athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
(c)An institution of higher education that receives, as an average, less than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual income derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics shall not be subject to the requirements of this section.(d)(c)An institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section.
SEC. 4.Section 67453.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:67453.5.(a)A student athlete who claims to have had any of his or her rights established under this chapter violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, shall have a private right of action to enjoin the violation if the violation is ongoing, and to seek damages, including, but not necessarily limited to, reasonable attorneys fees and court costs, against the institution and its personnel who are alleged to have been responsible the violation.
(b)For purposes of this section, personnel means one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 28, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 4, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 29, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (May 25). |
| May 9, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 4.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Apr 10, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HIGHER ED. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 4). |
| Apr 3, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 1, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. and HIGHER ED. |
| Feb 13, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 12, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 6, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2018 | AB 2220 BONTA Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
|
| Apr 4, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Higher Education] | Assembly Standing Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 2220 (Bonta) - College Student Athlete Bill of Rights
Version: May 25, 2018 | Policy Vote: ED. 4 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 6, 2018 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
This bill extends portions of the existing Student Athlete Bill of Rights to apply to institutions of higher education that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes and allows an additional year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship for students who have been injured. This bill also requires institutions of higher education to designate one person to receive complaints and provide a remedy within 60 days.
Fiscal Impact:
- The University of California (UC) estimates that this bill could result in ongoing General Fund costs of about $1.9 million. This estimate includes $1.2 million to provide scholarships to injured college student athletes for one additional academic year and approximately $700,000 in legal costs resulting from the new private right of action.
- The California State University (CSU) estimates ongoing General Fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars each year to provide scholarships to injured student athletes. CSU also indicates there could be additional General Fund costs ranging from $1 to $2 million to hire additional staff outside the athletic departments for investigations in violations and legal activity.
- There could be additional unknown General Fund costs for the segments to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and to respond to these complaints.
- Private postsecondary institutions will likely incur significant costs for these activities.
Background:
Existing law establishes the Student Athlete Bill of Rights which applies specific requirements to a higher education institution receiving income of more than $10 million annually through media rights (contracts with television networks), and requires the institution to rely exclusively on these revenues to cover the costs of the requirements.
Existing law requires the postsecondary education institution, if a student athlete's athletic scholarship is not renewed due to incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participation in the athletic program, to provide an equivalent scholarship, that when combined with the previous athletic scholarship, provides the student with up to five academic years or until the student completes his academic degree, whichever comes first. A student's temporary leave of absence shall not count against the five-year limit.
Existing law requires an athletic program with a six-year graduation success rate, disaggregated by each team, of less than 60 percent, to provide a student athlete in good standing who has exhausted their athletic scholarship with an equivalent scholarship for up to one year.
Existing law requires each athletic program to conduct a financial and life skills workshop, as specified, for all first-year and third-year student athletes.
Existing law requires an athletic program to respond within seven business days to a student athlete's written request to transfer.
Existing law stipulates that an athletic program, unless the student athlete declines, is responsible for paying the health insurance premiums of a student athlete whose household income does not exceed the level of Cal Grant A recipients, for insurance covering claims resulting from the student's participation in the athletic program. It also stipulates that an athletic program is responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to a student who suffers injury resulting from participation in the athletic program, and if the student requires ongoing medical treatment, the program is to provide, for at least two years after the student's graduation or separation from the institution, either necessary medical treatment or health insurance covering the injury and resulting deductibles.
Proposed Law:
This bill extends to any campus of the UC or CSU, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution located in California that provides athletic scholarships for college student athletes specified rights, including an equivalent scholarship, if the athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship because the student suffers an incapacitating injury resulting from participation in the athletic program, for up to a total of five academic years (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship).
This bill extends these requirements to any of these institutions that receive, as an average over the most recent three-year period, at least $10 million in annual athletically-related revenue (existing law applies to IHEs with at least $10 million in annual media rights).
This bill also provides an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted athletic eligibility, for up to one year, but exempts athletic programs with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent (disaggregated by each team).
This bill requires all institutions that provide athletic scholarships to provide a copy of the rights established for student athletes to each of its athletes, at least once per academic year, at the start of the season of the athlete’s sport. This bill also requires each institution to designate an individual to receive complaints for violations and include the contact information of that person for each of its student athletes, and authorizes a student athlete to report a violation to the designated individual. The institution would be required to conduct and conclude an investigation, and provide an appropriate remedy within 60 days.
This bill authorizes a student athlete to submit a civil action claim against the institution, if a violation is not remedied within 60 days, to the Attorney General or appropriate district attorney or county counsel. This bill also authorizes a student athlete to pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief if the Attorney General, district attorney or county counsel does not pursue legal action within 60 days. This bill provides that a student athlete who prevails in an action may recover reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief.
Related Legislation:
AB 2747 (Holden, 2018) requires all campuses of the UC, CSU, or any four-year private university located in California that maintain an intercollegiate athletic program provide and post a notice with specified rights afforded to student athletes. AB 2747 is also scheduled to be heard by this Committee on August 6, 2018.
AB 1435 (Gonzalez Fletcher) establishes an appointed panel within the California Department of Education to create and distribute to every institution of higher education with an intercollegiate athletic program best practices to minimize injuries, develop guidelines and mandates, perform compliance inspections, exercise subpoena power, investigate complaints, and issue penalties. This bill was scheduled to be heard in the Senate Education Committee but cancelled at the author’s request.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Benjamin Allen, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 2220 Hearing Date: June 27, 2018
Author: | |||
Version: | May 25, 2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Lynn Lorber | ||
Subject: College Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
SUMMARY
This bill extends portions of the existing Student Athlete Bill of Rights to apply to additional institutions of higher education (IHE) that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes; provides an additional year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship (for students who have been injured); and, requires IHEs to designate one person to receive complaints, and requires IHEs to investigate and provide a remedy within 60 days.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
Student Athlete Bill of Rights
- Applies the requirements in # 2-8 only to a higher education institution receiving income of more than $10 million annually through media rights (contracts with television networks), and requires the institution to rely exclusively on this revenue to cover the costs of these requirements. (Education Code § 67452)
Equivalent scholarship
- Requires the postsecondary education institution, if a student athlete's athletic scholarship is not renewed due to incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participation in the athletic program, to provide an equivalent scholarship, that when combined with the previous athletic scholarship, provides the student with up to five academic years or until the student completes his academic degree, whichever comes first. A student's temporary leave of absence shall not count against the five-year limit. (EC § 67452)
- Requires an athletic program with a six-year graduation success rate, disaggregated by each team, of less than 60 percent, to provide a student athlete in good standing who has exhausted their athletic scholarship with an equivalent scholarship for up to one year. (EC § 67452)
Financial and life skills workshop
- Requires each athletic program to conduct a financial and life skills workshop, as specified, for all first-year and third-year student athletes. (EC § 67452)
Transfer
- Requires an athletic program to respond within seven business days to a student athlete's written request to transfer. (EC § 67452)
Health insurance premiums and deductible
- Stipulates that an athletic program, unless the student athlete declines, is responsible for paying the health insurance premiums of a student athlete whose household income does not exceed the level of Cal Grant A recipients, for insurance covering claims resulting from the student's participation in the athletic program. (EC § 67453)
- Stipulates that an athletic program is responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to a student who suffers injury resulting from participation in the athletic program, and if the student requires ongoing medical treatment, the program is to provide, for at least two years after the student's graduation or separation from the institution, either necessary medical treatment or health insurance covering the injury and resulting deductibles. (EC § 67453)
Guidelines
- Requires the athletic program to adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration. (EC § 67453)
General provisions related to student athletes (separate from the Student Athlete Bill of Rights)
- Requires California postsecondary educational institutions that offer athletic scholarships to provide specific information on its website, such as the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) policy on scholarship duration, the most recent cost of attendance, and the policy on athletically related medical expenses. (EC § 67365)
- Prohibits any person from giving, offering, promising or attempting to give money or other items of value to a student athlete or member of the athlete's immediate family to induce, encourage or reward a student athlete's application, enrollment or attendance at a public or private institution of higher education (IHE) to participate in intercollegiate sporting activities. Some exceptions may be granted in accordance with NCAA rules. Existing law subjects a person who violates these rules to a civil penalty of up to $10,000, or three times the amount given, offered or promised, whichever is greater. (EC § 67360)
- Prohibits student athletes and members of their immediate family from soliciting or accepting money or other items of value as an inducement, encouragement or reward, subject to the same exceptions and penalty listed above. Existing law subjects a person who violates these rules to a civil penalty of up to $1,000 or an amount equal to the amount accepted by the student athlete or family member, whichever is greater. (EC § 67361)
ANALYSIS
This bill expands the existing Student Athlete Bill of Rights to apply to additional institutions of higher education (IHE) that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes; provides an additional year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship (for students who have been injured); and, requires IHEs to designate one person to receive complaints, and requires IHEs to investigate and provide a remedy within 60 days. Specifically, this bill:
Extends to any campus of the University of California or California State University, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent IHE located in California that provides athletic scholarships for college student athletes
- Provide an equivalent scholarship, if the athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship because the student suffers an incapacitating injury resulting from participation in the athletic program, for up to a total of five academic years (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship).
- Conduct a financial and life skills workshop, as specified, for all first-year and third-year student athletes.
- Respond within seven business days with an answer to a student athlete’s written request to transfer to another IHE.
Extends to any of the IHEs described in # 1 that receive, as an average over the most recent three-year period, at least $10 million in annual athletically-related revenue (existing law applies to IHEs with at least $10 million in annual media rights)
- Provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted athletic eligibility, for up to one year, but exempts athletic programs with a graduation success rate that is above 60 percent (disaggregated by each team).
- Be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student athletes with eligible household income levels.
- Be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program.
- Provide, for at least two years following the student’s separation from the IHE, ongoing medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductible amounts.
- Adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration.
- Adopt and implement exercise and supervision guidelines for any athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions.
Establishes a new requirement that applies to all institutions of higher education (IHEs) that provide athletic scholarships (described above # 1)
- Requires that a student athlete with an incapacitating injury be granted one additional academic year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship upon showing of cause for need (one year beyond the existing five-year limit on eligibility for an equivalent scholarship).
Establishes new notification of rights, point of contact for complaints, 60-day timeline that applies to all IHEs (described in # 1)
- Requires all IHEs that provide athletic scholarships to provide a copy of the rights established for student athletes pursuant to this bill to each of its athletes, at least once per academic year, at the start of the season of the athlete’s sport.
- Requires each IHE to designate an individual to receive complaints for violations and include the contact information of that person for each of its student athletes.
- Authorizes a student athlete to report a violation to the designated individual, and requires the IHE to conduct and conclude an investigation, and provide an appropriate remedy within 60 days.
- Authorize a student athletes to submit a civil action claim against the IHE, if a violation is not remedied within 60 days, to the Attorney General or appropriate district attorney or county counsel.
- Authorizes a student athlete to pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief if the Attorney General, district attorney or county counsel does not pursue legal action within 60 days. This bill provides that a student athlete who prevails in an action may recover reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief.
Miscellaneous
- Defines “personnel” as one or more representatives of an athletic program, including but not limited to any employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated healthcare professional.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Currently, most schools in California have the autonomy to determine whether to pay for an athlete’s medical expenses. Additionally, college athletes who get injured during practice or a game are not protected from losing their athletic scholarship. The existing Student Athlete Bill of Rights is only applicable to four of California’s 47 Division I and Division II schools (University of Southern California, University of California at Los Angeles, University of California at Berkeley, and Stanford). This means thousands of college athletes across California have no guaranteed protection if they are injured on the field.”
- Additional universities subject to the existing Student Athlete Bill of Rights. This bill expands the number of colleges and universities that are required to comply, beyond the four universities that are currently required to comply, with the Student Athlete Bill of Rights; the main points of expansion are as follows:
- Any institution of higher education (IHE) that provides athletic scholarships is required to provide an equivalent scholarship if the IHE does not renew an athletic scholarship because the student suffers an incapacitating injury, for up to a total of five academic years (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship). Is it reasonable and appropriate to require an additional 42 IHEs, regardless of the amount of revenue generated from athletic activities, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five years?
- Any IHE that provides athletic scholarships and receives a three-year average of at least $10 million in annual athletically-related revenue (23 additional IHEs) is required to:
- Provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted athletic eligibility, for up to one year (an IHE is exempt if it has a graduation rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team). This affects 11 of the 23 additional universities.
- Be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student athletes with eligible household income levels.
- Be responsible for paying the insurance deductible amount applicable to the claim of any athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program.
- Provide, for at least two years following the student’s separation from the IHE, ongoing medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductible amounts.
Is this expansion reasonable and appropriate?
- Provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted athletic eligibility, for up to one year (an IHE is exempt if it has a graduation rate that is above 60 percent, disaggregated by team). This affects 11 of the 23 additional universities.
- Any institution of higher education (IHE) that provides athletic scholarships is required to provide an equivalent scholarship if the IHE does not renew an athletic scholarship because the student suffers an incapacitating injury, for up to a total of five academic years (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship). Is it reasonable and appropriate to require an additional 42 IHEs, regardless of the amount of revenue generated from athletic activities, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five years?
Staff notes that “revenue” is defined, for purposes of the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act, as all “revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities. This includes revenues from appearance guarantees and options, athletic conference tournaments or bowl games, concessions, contributions from alumni and others, institutional support, program advertising and sales, radio and television, royalties, signage and other sponsorships, sports camps, governmental support, student activity fees, ticket sales, and any other revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities.
- Additional year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship. Existing law requires the four IHEs subject to the Student Athlete Bill of Rights to provide an equivalent scholarship if the IHE does not renew an athletic scholarship because the student suffers an incapacitating injury, for up to a total of five academic years (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship). Existing law authorizes additional years to be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education (IHE). This bill requires any IHE that provide athletics scholarships to grant an additional academic year of eligibility for an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete with an incapacitating injury, upon a showing of cause for need (increasing the maximum eligibility to six years). Is it reasonable to require IHEs to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to six years? Is it reasonable to extend eligibility to a sixth year to universities that currently are not required to provide this equivalent scholarship at all?
- Investigate and remedy within 60 days. This bill requires IHEs to conduct and conclude a report of a violation, and provide an appropriate remedy within 60 days. Is it reasonable to require the conclusion and remedy within 60 days? Would it be reasonable to require IHEs to begin conducting an investigation and notify the complainant within 60 days of the status of the investigation, and require the conclusion and remedy on a later timeframe?
- Fiscal impact. According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would impose:
- Ongoing General Fund (GF) or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to the California State University, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures for insurance and treatment, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures in the tens of thousands to low hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and respond to complaints.
- Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures to the University of California, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures for medical insurance and treatment, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures in the tens of thousands to low hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and respond to complaints.
- Ongoing General Fund (GF) or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to the California State University, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures for insurance and treatment, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures in the tens of thousands to low hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and respond to complaints.
- Related legislation. AB 1435 (Gonzalez Fletcher) establishes an appointed panel within the California Department of Education to create and distribute to every IHE with an intercollegiate athletic program best practices to minimize injuries, develop guidelines and mandates, perform compliance inspections, exercise subpoena power, investigate complaints, and issue penalties. This bill requires every institution of education education with an intercollegiate athletic program to pay an annual fee for the administration and activities of this panel. AB 1435 is scheduled to be heard by this Committee on June 27.
AB 2747 (Holden, 2018) requires all campuses of the University of California, California State University, or any four-year private university located in California that maintain an intercollegiate athletic program to prepare, provide and post a notice with specified rights afforded to student athletes, prohibits these institutions of higher education from retaliating against a student athlete for making a complaint in good faith, and authorizes the establishment of a degree completion fund. AB 2747 was passed by this Committee on June 20, and is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SUPPORT
National College Players Association (sponsor)
California Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance
California State Student Association
United Steelworkers
OPPOSITION
Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities
Azusa Pacific University
Biola University
California Baptist University
California State University
Dominican University of California
Fresno Pacific University
Loyola Marymount University
Pacific West Conference
Pepperdine University
Point Loma Nazarene University
Santa Clara University
Simpson University
Stanford University
University of California
University of San Diego
University of Southern California
University of the Pacific
William Jessup University
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2220
Author:( and Gonzalez Fletcher)
As AmendedVer:May 25, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Arts | 4-2 | Chu, Chiu, Friedman, Medina | Waldron, Acosta |
Higher Education | 8-4 | Medina, Arambula, Bloom, Levine, Low, Quirk-Silva, Santiago, Weber | Baker, Chávez, Kiley, Patterson |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: This bill would expand the Student Athlete Bill of Rights (SABR) and would rename SABR as the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights (CSABR). Specifically, this bill:
- Applies the following to an Institution of Higher Education (IHE), defined as any campus of the University of California (UC) or the California State University (CSU), or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for student athletes.
- Requires an IHE, if an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a college student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participating in the athletic program and is determined to be medically ineligible, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five academic years, and offer one additional academic year of scholarship support beyond the five academic years upon showing of cause for need.
- Provides the following, subject to an exemption for any IHE that receives less than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual revenue, as specified:
- Requires an athletic program to provide an equivalent scholarship to a college student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, as specified.
- Requires each athletic program to be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its college student athletes whose household has an income and asset level at or below the level for Cal Grant A recipients for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program to be responsible for paying the insurance deductible for a claim of any college student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program, if a college student suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, to provide for at least two years following the student's graduation or separation from the IHE either the necessary medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductibles.
- Requires an IHE to provide each of its college student athletes with a copy of their rights established under the CSABR.
- Establishes a process for investigation of any suspected violation of a student athlete's rights established under the CSABR,
- Contains various findings and declarations.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis there are:
- Ongoing General Fund (GF) or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to CSU, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures for insurance and treatment, in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures in the tens of thousands to low hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and respond to complaints.
- Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures to UC, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures for medical insurance and treatment, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually. Ongoing GF or other fund cost pressures in the tens of thousands to low hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide information to student athletes, establish procedures for complaints, and respond to complaints.
COMMENTS: According to the author, "Currently, most schools in California have the autonomy to determine whether to pay for an athlete's medical expenses. Additionally, college athletes who get injured during practice or a game are not protected from losing their athletic scholarship. AB 2220 will require institutions to pay the deductibles for college athletes who suffer sports-related injuries and for the cost of ongoing medical treatment for at least two years after a student has graduated or left the university. Further, AB 2220 will require schools provide an equivalent scholarship, if the student's athletic scholarship is not renewed due to an injury. It is important for us to remember that student-athletes are students first and athletes second. Regardless of their performance on the field or any injury they may incur, our academic institutions should stand by them and encourage them to complete their academic degrees."
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of the measure.
Analysis Prepared by: Dana Mitchell/ A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. / (916) 319-3450 FN: 0003294
Date of Hearing: May 9, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2220
Author:(Bonta) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2018
Policy Committee: | Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media | Vote: | 4 - 2 |
Higher Education | 8 - 4 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY: This bill requires all intercollegiate athletic programs at private institutions of higher education or campuses of the University of California (UC) or the California State University (CSU) that provide athletic scholarships for college student athletes to comply with the Student Athlete Bill of Rights and expands the requirements of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights. It also renames the Student Athlete Bill of Rights as the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires institutions to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the current five-year limit.
- Requires institutions to provide a private right of action to college student athletes for a violation of the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel.
- Deletes provisions requiring an institution to use revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics exclusively to defray certain costs resulting from the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
- Requires an institution to pay health insurance premiums for low-income student athletes and requires institutions to pay insurance deductibles for all student athletes who suffer injuries resulting from participation in the institution’s athletic program.
- Requires an institution to cover, for a minimum of two years after a student athlete’s separation from the institution, ongoing costs for necessary medical treatment resulting from participation in the institution’s athletic program.
- Requires an institution to provide a financial and life skills workshop to all of its first-year and third-year student athletes, including information concerning financial aid and debt management.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to CSU, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the current five-year limit across all 22 CSU campuses with athletics programs. Costs would depend on the number of injured student athletes who would enroll for an additional year at CSU. CSU has about 8,000 student athletes. CSU may provide scholarships for full or partial tuition costs ($5,742 annually in the 2017-18 school year) and other costs of living.
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to CSU, potentially in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, for legal costs to defend against claimed violations damage awards for right of action and for potential damage award to student athletes. Costs would depend on the number of claimed violations and damages awarded.
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to CSU for medical insurance and treatment, potentially in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Costs would depend on the number of injured students and their treatment costs.
- Ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to CSU to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually.
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to UC, potentially in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the current five-year limit across all nine campuses. Costs would depend on the number of injured student athletes who would enroll for an additional year at UC. UC has about 2,000 student athletes. UC may provide scholarships for full or partial tuition costs ($12,630 annually in the 2017-18 school year) and other costs of living.
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to UC, potentially in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, for legal costs to defend against claimed violations damage awards for right of action and for potential damage award to student athletes. Costs would depend on the number of claimed violations and damages awarded.
- Unknown, ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to UC for medical insurance and treatment, potentially in the high hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. Costs would depend on the number of injured students and their treatment costs.
- Ongoing GF or other fund (such as athletic fund) cost pressures to UC to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the thousands of dollars annually.
- Unknown, ongoing cost pressures to the private institutions, potentially in the low millions of dollars annually, to provide a scholarship to an injured college student athlete for one additional academic year beyond the current five-year limit across about 25 private institutions with athletics programs. Costs would depend on the number of injured student athletes who would enroll for an additional year. Private institutions have about 14,000 student athletes. Private institutions may provide scholarships for full or partial tuition costs (tuition varies by campus, but is generally in the $40,000 range annually) and other costs of living. The state would not be required to reimburse these costs because these institutions are private.
- Unknown, ongoing cost pressures to private institutions, potentially in the low millions of dollars annually, for legal costs to defend against claimed violations damage awards for right of action and for potential damage award to student athletes. Costs would depend on the number of claimed violations and damages awarded. The state would not be required to reimburse these costs because these institutions are private.
- Unknown, ongoing costs for medical insurance and treatment, potentially in the low millions of dollars annually. Costs would depend on the number of injured students and their treatment costs. The state would not be required to reimburse these costs because these institutions are private.
- Ongoing cost pressures to private institutions to offer financial workshops to student athletes, likely in the tens of thousands of dollars annually. The state would not be required to reimburse these costs because these institutions are private.
COMMENTS:
- Student Athlete Bill of Rights. SB 1525 (Padilla), Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012, created the Student Athlete Bill of Rights in California. It requires intercollegiate athletic programs at four-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10 million or more in annual revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with certain requirements related to student athlete rights. These requirements include, a scholarship of up to five academic years if a student athlete's athletic scholarship is not renewed due to incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participation in the athletic program, payment of insurance premiums of low-income student athletes and their deductibles should they become insured participating in the college’s athletic program, as well as ongoing medical treatment for at least two years after a student athlete leaves the college. Current law requires these institutions to use only revenue from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray costs of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
Because of the requirement that only institutions with media rights revenues of $10 million adhere to the Student Athlete Bill of Rights, it currently only applies to four institutions of higher education: UC Berkeley, UC Los Angeles, Stanford University, and the University of Southern California.
- Student Athlete. Current law defines a student athlete as any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education.
- Media Rights. Sports media rights are the contracts university athletic departments have with television networks and online platforms to air their sporting events, which generate payments to individual institutions of higher education. This bill removes the requirement that an institutions rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs resulting from the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights. According to the author, the intent of this change is to "give universities who do not have large media rights revenue the ability to use alternative methods such as fundraising to pay for any of the provisions of the bill."
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2220 (
Author:Bonta) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2018
SUBJECT: College Student Athlete Bill of Rights
SUMMARY: This bill would expand the Student Athlete Bill of Rights (SABR) from four universities to all intercollegiate athletic programs that provide athletic scholarships, as defined, and would remove the limitation in existing law for funding of SABR provisions to media rights revenues derived from the university athletic department. It would rename SABR as the College Student Athlete Bill of Rights (CSABR). It would further provide a private right of action, as specified, to college athletes who claim to have had any rights established under the CSABR violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined, and change references from "student athlete" to "college student athlete." Specifically, this bill:
- Applies the following to an Institution of Higher Education (IHE), defined as any campus of the University of California (UC) or the California State University (CSU), or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for student athletes.
- Strikes the $10 million dollar media rights revenue threshold for application of CSABR, and requirement that CSABR may only be funded from proceeds of media rights contracts.
- Requires an IHE, if an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a college student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participating in the athletic program and is determined to be medically ineligible, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five academic years.
- Requires a college student athlete to be granted one additional academic year of scholarship support beyond the five academic years upon showing of cause for need.
- Requires an athletic program to provide an equivalent scholarship to a college student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year.
- Requires each athletic program to be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its college student athletes whose household has an income and asset level at or below the level for Cal Grant A recipients for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program to be responsible for paying the insurance deductible for a claim of any college student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program, if a college student suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, to provide for at least two years following the student’s graduation or separation from the IHE either the necessary medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductibles.
- Establishes that a college student athlete may pursue a civil action for damages or equitable relief from his or her institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, for a violation of this legislation. A college student athlete who prevails in an action brought pursuant to this section may recover reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs, in addition to any damages or equitable relief, against the institution and its personnel.
- Defines, “personnel” to mean one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
EXISTING LAW:
- Applies the following to an IHE that receives, as an average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. (Education Code (EDC) Section 67452)
- Requires an IHE, if an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participating in the athletic program and is determined to be medically ineligible, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five academic years as specified. (EDC Section 67452)
- Requires an athletic program to provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year. (EDC Section 67452)
- Requires each athletic program to be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student athletes whose household has an income and asset level at or below the level for Cal Grant A recipients for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program. (EDC Section 67453)
- Requires an athletic program to be responsible for paying the insurance deductible for a claim of any student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program. (EDC Section 67453)
- Requires an athletic program, if a student suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, to provide for at least two years following the student’s graduation or separation from the IHE either the necessary medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductibles. (EDC Section 67453)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Need for the bill. According to the author, "Currently, most schools in California have the autonomy to determine whether to pay for an athlete’s medical expenses. Additionally, college athletes who get injured during practice or a game are not protected from losing their athletic scholarship. AB 2220 will require institutions to pay the deductibles for college athletes who suffer sports-related injuries and for the cost of ongoing medical treatment for at least two years after a student has graduated or left the university. Further, AB 2220 will require schools provide an equivalent scholarship, if the student’s athletic scholarship is not renewed due to an injury.”
"It is important for us to remember that student-athletes are students first and athletes second. Regardless of their performance on the field or any injury they may incur, our academic institutions should stand by them and encourage them to complete their academic degrees."
The California Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance supports this measure, "because it requires schools that offer athletic scholarships to encourage those athletes who cannot fulfill their scholarship agreement, because of injury or other reasons, to complete their degree program."
Opposition and concerns. The opposition of the Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities (AICCU) is typical of that expressed by other Universities. They write the Committee with three major points of opposition. First, is in regards to the new private right of action to student athletes for a violation of SABR. According to AICCU, "Creating a new private right of action creates additional potential cost burdens for our campuses, which are largely tuition dependent. There is nothing in law now that would prevent a student from taking action should they feel the campus treated them unfairly, nor do we understand there to be a large need for such action, we therefore do not understand the need for an additional and new private right of action."
USC builds upon this concern with their reading of the language that would allow any athlete on a college campus to assert rights under the SABR, including clubs and even intramurals. "Given the continued academic and graduation improvements since the passage of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights in 2012, the large number of non-athletic department entities and individuals at USC that are charged with monitoring and overseeing the health, welfare and rights of student-athletes, and the significant resources that USC already commits to athletics, it is unclear why AB 2220 expands the scope of those to be covered under the legislation (e.g., club sports) and includes a provision authorizing a private right of action for a violation of the Act. USC believes the bill will only increase the number of lawsuits filed in civil court and redirect university resources that our institution could instead use toward services for its current intercollegiate student-athletes."
The second point of opposition is the extension of time allotted, from 5 to a potential 6 years, of equivalent scholarship funds for an injured athlete unable to complete his or her athletic scholarship. This change is of concern to all segments who wrote the Committee. As AICCU states, "…this bill would extend the equivalent scholarship provision for an injured student from 5 to a potential 6 years. For students who are on a partial scholarship and who are Cal Grant eligible, their Cal Grant eligibility is only 4-years. Our campuses have a high 4-year graduation rate for our students, and Cal Grant students graduate at a higher rate than their peers. We work hard to encourage all of our students, including student athletes, to graduate in as timely a manner as possible so that they maximize the use of grant monies.”
Finally, AICCU also is concerned about their schools' ability to generate funds to comply with the bill, and the additional requirement for their campuses which compete in the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA). "While this bill makes reference to the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) rules, and all 4 campuses who currently fall under the SABR play in the NCAA, it is important to note, there are California private (and a few public) universities who provide athletic scholarships for their student athletes to play in the NAIA. While the rules are often the same or similar, we question applying the NCAA rules to campuses, which for any variety of reasons, chose to play in the NAIA. NAIA campuses tend to be much smaller than NCAA campuses, their budgets tend to be smaller, and there are fewer sales of sports paraphernalia and other revenue than those belonging to the NCAA. The impact of this increase to revenue generating sports (generally football and men’s basketball) will be felt by women’s sports, as well as non-revenue generating men’s sports. The potential increased costs associated with expanding the scope of SABR, will very likely result in fewer athletic programs. If campuses have to reduce offerings, they will be forced to eliminate commensurate women and men’s sports in order to remain Title IX compliant."
Student Athlete Bill of Rights. California's student athlete bill of rights only applies to 4 universities. The protections for California student athletes contained in the SABR (discussed in the Existing Law section above) are limited to universities that receive, as an average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. Based on annual revenues from media rights, the Student Athlete Bill of Rights currently only applies to four institutions of higher education: the University of California (UC) at Berkeley and Los Angeles, Stanford University, and the University of Southern California (USC).
Student athletics are governed by many different sanctioning bodies with different rules. In California, we have at last count 58,000 student athletes competing at the collegiate level. The welfare of these student-athletes are overseen by a variety of athletic sanctioning bodies, whose rules and oversight ability differ depending on the size, location and course offering of the various institutions of higher education.
The major sanctioning organizations include the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), the National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA), the California Community College Athletic Association, and the National Christian College Athletic Association (NCCAA). Even within these major sanctioning bodies, rules differ. For instance, the NCAA rules governing Division I, II and III institutions of higher education are not necessarily the same across divisions.
National Collegiate Athletic Association and Pac-12 Conference rules. According to the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s (NCAA) Web site, “NCAA full scholarships cover tuition and fees, room, board and course-related books. Most student-athletes who receive athletic scholarships receive an amount covering a portion of these costs. Division I schools may provide student-athletes with multiyear scholarships. Additionally, Division I schools may pay for student-athletes to finish their bachelor's or master's degrees after they finish playing NCAA sports. If a school plans to reduce or not renew a student-athlete’s aid, the school must notify the student-athlete in writing by July 1 and provide an opportunity to appeal. In most cases, coaches decide who receives a scholarship, the scholarship amount and whether it will be renewed.”
“NCAA bylaws require that member institutions verify student-athletes have insurance coverage for athletically related injuries, with limits up to the deductible of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Catastrophic Injury Insurance Program (currently $90,000), before they can practice or play. Members are permitted to provide that coverage, but they are not required to do so. Coverage can be provided through the school, a parent/guardian policy or a policy student-athletes have on their own. If coverage by some source is not in place, the student-athlete cannot practice or play. The NCAA provides all student-athletes at all active member institutions coverage under the catastrophic program. This program provides $20 million in lifetime benefits to student-athletes who become totally disabled while practicing or playing. These benefits include medical expenses as well as disability benefits. An injured student-athlete is eligible to receive medical benefits after the policy deductible (currently $90,000) is met.”
According to the Pac-12 Conference’s Web site, rules adopted in 2014, which apply to all Pac-12 student-athletes across all sports, include:
- Athletic scholarships are guaranteed for four years for student-athletes in all sports.
- Student-athletes who leave school before graduating can use the remainder of their educational expenses later to earn their degrees.
- Medical expenses for student-athletes who are injured during their college athletic careers are covered for up to four years after a student-athlete leaves the institution.
- Student-athletes who transfer between Pac-12 institutions are able to receive athletic scholarships immediately.
- Student-athletes are represented in the Conference governance structure.
Media Rights. AB 2220 removes the requirement that an institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section. According to the author, this change was made to, "give universities who do not have large media rights revenue the ability to use alternative methods such as fundraising to pay for any of the provisions of the bill."
Recast private right of action. The language providing a private right of action for an aggrieved college student athlete under the SABR was rewritten by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, which provided the author and this Committee with a request to include their amended language into the bill in lieu of a hearing.
Additional Time to Graduate. According to the author, granting additional time for an injured student to complete their degree made sense because, "…only about 38.7% of CA students at public 4-year universities complete their degree in 4 years, this number rises to 59.2% in 6 years. The graduation rates for private colleges are 61.3% in 4 years and 73.9% in 6 years. Expanding the number of years…will help ensure that students are able to complete their educational degree on a timeline that more accurately reflects the completion rate for students in California."
While the segments of higher education impacted by this bill acknowledge that a "4-year degree" often takes longer than 4 years to achieve, they questioned the need for this change, given there are no known incidents of students being denied an extension of time upon request as is allowed under existing SABR, and the potential expense of a blanket extension of time. In addition, they claim that they are working toward returning to a four year degree completion model. The author and segments agreed that a one year extension would be granted to a student upon a showing of need, such as injury, illness, lack of space in impacted programs, or university schedule conflicts with a student's major course requirements, e.g. they don't offer needed classes.
Prior and Related legislation. AB 2747 (Holden), would add to the SABR provisions by: declaring that college athletes have the right to self-organization and requiring institutions of higher education, as defined, to provide student athletes with designated information; require institutions of higher education to establish a process by which the complaints of student athletes about violations of the NCAA Bill of Rights, the SABR, and institutional policies may be reported and investigated; require institutions of higher education to appoint student athlete liaisons with duties and responsibilities that would include being available to all student athletes of the institution and to record and investigate the complaints of student athletes, as specified; that student athletes have the right to enforce a provision of this SABR in the superior court through a civil action for injunctive relief or money damages, or both; and would require the court to award court costs and reasonable reimbursement for attorneys’ fees to a student athlete who is the prevailing party in such an action. The bill would prohibit a student athlete, institution of higher education, or athletic conference, as defined, from being required to agree to adjudication, in another state, of a claim or controversy that arises in California. Finally, the bill would authorize the Civil Rights Enforcement Section of the State Department of Justice to have specified powers and responsibilities for the investigation of complaints, and the prosecution of violations, of the SABR. Currently pending before the Assembly Committee on Higher Education.
The bill would also prohibit a student athlete from being penalized for receiving any gift or income that can be demonstrated to be generally available to the students of the institution of higher education who are not athletes or for being accused of a noncriminal violation the investigation or adjudication of which has not been completed, as specified.
AB 1435 (Gonzales-Fletcher), would establish the College Athlete Protection Act under the administration of the College Athlete Protection Commission, which would be established by the bill, for the protection of college or university athletes participating in intercollegiate athletic programs offered by institutions of higher education located in California. Currently pending before the Senate Committee on Business and Professions.
AB 735 (Ridley-Thomas), Chapter 220, Statutes of 2016, removed the sunset form the SABR.
SB 1525 (Padilla), Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012, created the original SABR discussed as "Existing Law" above.
AB 1743 (Campos), Chapter 16, Statutes of 2012, clarified that the online scholarship disclosures required of a California postsecondary educational institution only apply to institutions that offer athletic scholarships to "student athletes."
AB 2079 (Torlakson-Davis), Chapter 592, Statutes of 2010 provided that all California postsecondary educational institutions that offer athletic scholarships are required to provide specified scholarship information on their websites.
AB 95 (Torlakson) of 2008-09, would have required athletic recruiters to provide student athletes with specified information relating to the college athletic program within one week of initiating personal contact with the student athlete for purposes of athletic recruiting. Status: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec.10(c) of the Constitution.
SB 193 (Murray) of 2002-03, would have prohibited California institutions of higher education from participating in any organizations that regulates student athletic scholarships, including the NCAA. Status: Held in the Assembly Higher Education Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance
National College Players Association (Sponsor)
Opposition
Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities
California State University
University of California
University of Southern California
Analysis Prepared by: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Date of Hearing: April 4, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ARTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SPORTS, TOURISM, AND INTERNET MEDIA
Kansen Chu, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2220 (
Author:Bonta) – As Amended Ver:April 2, 2018
SUBJECT: Student Athlete Bill of Rights.
SUMMARY: This bill would expand the Student Athlete Bill of Rights (SABR) from four universities to all intercollegiate athletic programs that provide athletic scholarships, as defined, and would remove the limitation in existing law for funding of SABR provisions to media rights revenues derived from the university athletic department. It would further provide a private right of action, as specified, to college athletes who claim to have had any rights established under the SABR violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel, as defined, and change references from "student athlete" to "college athlete."
Specifically, this bill:
- Applies the following to an Institution of Higher Education (IHE), defined as any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any private postsecondary educational institution or independent institution of higher education located in California, that provides athletic scholarships for student athletes.
- Strikes the $10 million dollar media rights revenue threshold for application of SABR, and requirement that SABR may only be funded from proceeds of media rights contracts.
- Requires an IHE, if an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a college athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participating in the athletic program and is determined to be medically ineligible, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to six academic years as specified.
- Requires an athletic program to provide an equivalent scholarship to a college athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year.
- Requires each athletic program to be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its college athletes whose household has an income and asset level at or below the level for Cal Grant A recipients for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program to be responsible for paying the insurance deductible for a claim of any college athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program.
- Requires an athletic program, if a student suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, to provide for at least two years following the student’s graduation or separation from the IHE either the necessary medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductibles.
- Provides a private right of action, as specified, for any college athlete who claims to have had any of his or her rights established under this chapter violated by an institution of higher education, including any of its personnel.
- Defines, “personnel” to mean one or more representatives of an athletic program, including, but not necessarily limited to, an employee, coach, assistant, or affiliated health care professional.
EXISTING LAW:
- Applies the following to an IHE that receives, as an average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. (EC Section 67452)
- Requires an IHE, if an athletic program does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from participating in the athletic program and is determined to be medically ineligible, to provide an equivalent scholarship for up to five academic years as specified. (EC Section 67452)
- Requires an athletic program to provide an equivalent scholarship to a student athlete who was on an athletic scholarship and is in good standing but has exhausted his or her athletic eligibility, for up to one year. (EC Section 67452)
- Requires each athletic program to be responsible for paying the premiums of each of its student athletes whose household has an income and asset level at or below the level for Cal Grant A recipients for insurance covering claims resulting from their participation in the athletic program. (EC Section 67453)
- Requires an athletic program to be responsible for paying the insurance deductible for a claim of any student athlete who suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program. (EC Section 67453)
- Requires an athletic program, if a student suffers an injury resulting from participation in the athletic program that requires ongoing medical treatment, to provide for at least two years following the student’s graduation or separation from the IHE either the necessary medical treatment or health insurance that covers the injury and resulting deductibles. (EC Section 67453)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Author's statement of need for legislation: According to the author, "Currently, most schools in California have the autonomy to determine whether to pay for an athlete’s medical expenses. Additionally, college athletes who get injured during practice or a game are not protected from losing their athletic scholarship. AB 2220 will require institutions to pay the deductibles for college athletes who suffer sports-related injuries and for the cost of ongoing medical treatment for at least two years after a student has graduated or left the university. Further, AB 2220 will require schools provide an equivalent scholarship, if the student’s athletic scholarship is not renewed due to an injury.
"It is important for us to remember that student-athletes are students first and athletes second. Regardless of their performance on the field or any injury they may incur, our academic institutions should stand by them and encourage them to complete their academic degrees."
The California Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance support this measure, "because it requires schools that offer athletic scholarships to encourage those athletes who cannot fulfill their scholarship agreement, because of injury or other reasons, to complete their degree program."
- Opposition and concerns: The opposition of the Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities (AICCU) is typical of that expressed by other Universities. They write the Committee with four major points of opposition. First, is that, as amended, "this bill would remove the word Student from Student Athlete Bill of Rights and replace it with College. First, and foremost, these are students. Students whom we strive to get to graduation in a timely manner, and who should always be thought of first as students, as that is their purpose – seeking to learn and grow in knowledge -- while they are on our campuses." In addition, they add, "there is a definition in code for Student Athlete, whereas there is no definition for the new proposed term. There is also significant case law around student athletes that would be disrupted by the changing terminology." This line of opposition is also shared by the University of Southern California and Stanford University.
The second point of concern is the new private right of action to student athletes for a violation of SABR. According to AICCU, "Creating a new private right of action creates additional potential cost burdens for our campuses, which are largely tuition dependent. There is nothing in law now that would prevent a student from taking action should they feel the campus treated them unfairly, nor do we understand there to be a large need for such action, we therefore do not understand the need for an additional and new private right of action."
USC builds upon this concern with their reading of the language that would allow any athlete on a college campus to assert rights under the SABR, including clubs and even intramurals. "Given the continued academic and graduation improvements since the passage of the Student Athlete Bill of Rights in 2012, the large number of non-athletic department entities and individuals at USC that are charged with monitoring and overseeing the health, welfare and rights of student-athletes, and the significant resources that USC already commits to athletics, it is unclear why AB 2220 expands the scope of those to be covered under the legislation (e.g., club sports) and includes a provision authorizing a private right of action for a violation of the Act. USC believes the bill will only increase the number of lawsuits filed in civil court and redirect university resources that our institution could instead use toward services for its current intercollegiate student-athletes."
The third point of opposition is the extension of time allotted, from 5 to 6 years, of equivalent scholarship funds for an injured athlete unable to complete his or her athletic scholarship. This change is of concern to all segments who wrote the committee. As AICCU states, "This bill would extend the equivalent scholarship provision for an injured student from 5 to 6 years. For students who are on a partial scholarship and who are Cal Grant eligible, their Cal Grant eligibility is only 4-years. Our campuses have a high 4-year graduation rate for our students, and Cal Grant students graduate at a higher rate than their peers. We work hard to encourage all of our students, including student athletes, to graduate in as timely a manner as possible so that they maximize the use of grant monies. In addition, students on partial scholarships may not have the financial means to finish a year 5 or 6, and this will further stress limited financial aid funds."
Finally, AICCU also is concerned about their schools' ability to generate funds to comply with the bill, and additional requirement for their campuses which compete in the NAIA. "While this bill makes reference to the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) rules, and all 4 campuses who currently fall under the SABR play in the NCAA, it is important to note, there are California private (and a few public) universities who provide athletic scholarships for their student athletes to play in the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA). While the rules are often the same or similar, we question applying the NCAA rules to campuses, which for any variety of reasons, chose to play in the NAIA. NAIA campuses tend to be much smaller than NCAA campuses, their budgets tend to be smaller, and there are fewer sales of sports paraphernalia and other revenue than those belonging to the NCAA." The impact of this increase to revenue generating sports (generally football and men’s basketball) will be felt by women’s sports, as well as non-revenue generating men’s sports. The potential increased costs associated with expanding the scope of SABR, will very likely result in fewer athletic programs. If campuses have to reduce offerings, they will be forced to eliminate commensurate women and men’s sports in order to remain Title IX compliant."
- Background:
- Student Athlete Bill of Rights:
California's student athlete bill of rights only applies to 4 universities. The protections for California student athletes contained in the SABR (discussed in the Existing Law section above) are limited to universities that receive, as an average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. Based on annual revenues from media rights, the Student Athlete Bill of Rights currently only applies to four institutions of higher education: the University of California (UC) at Berkeley and Los Angeles, Stanford University, and the University of Southern California (USC).
Student athletics are governed by many different sanctioning bodies with different rules. In California, we have at last count 58,000 student athletes competing at the collegiate level. The welfare of these student-athletes are overseen by a variety of athletic sanctioning bodies, whose rules and oversight ability differ depending on the size, location and course offering of the various institutions of higher education.
The major sanctioning organizations include the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA), the National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA), the California Community College Athletic Association, and the National Christian College Athletic Association (NCCAA). Even within these major sanctioning bodies, rules differ. For instance, the NCAA rules governing Division I, II and III institutions of higher education are not necessarily the same across divisions.
- National Collegiate Athletic Association and Pac-12 Conference rules. According to the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s (NCAA) Web site, “NCAA full scholarships cover tuition and fees, room, board and course-related books. Most student-athletes who receive athletic scholarships receive an amount covering a portion of these costs. Division I schools may provide student-athletes with multiyear scholarships. Additionally, Division I schools may pay for student-athletes to finish their bachelor's or master's degrees after they finish playing NCAA sports. If a school plans to reduce or not renew a student-athlete’s aid, the school must notify the student-athlete in writing by July 1 and provide an opportunity to appeal. In most cases, coaches decide who receives a scholarship, the scholarship amount and whether it will be renewed.”
“NCAA bylaws require that member institutions verify student-athletes have insurance coverage for athletically related injuries, with limits up to the deductible of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Catastrophic Injury Insurance Program (currently $90,000), before they can practice or play. Members are permitted to provide that coverage, but they are not required to do so. Coverage can be provided through the school, a parent/guardian policy or a policy student-athletes have on their own. If coverage by some source is not in place, the student-athlete cannot practice or play. The NCAA provides all student-athletes at all active member institutions coverage under the catastrophic program. This program provides $20 million in lifetime benefits to student-athletes who become totally disabled while practicing or playing. These benefits include medical expenses as well as disability benefits. An injured student-athlete is eligible to receive medical benefits after the policy deductible (currently $90,000) is met.”
- According to the Pac-12 Conference’s Web site, rules adopted in 2014, which apply to all Pac-12 student-athletes across all sports, include:
- Athletic scholarships are guaranteed for four years for student-athletes in all sports.
- Student-athletes who leave school before graduating can use the remainder of their educational expenses later to earn their degrees.
- Medical expenses for student-athletes who are injured during their college athletic careers are covered for up to four years after a student-athlete leaves the institution.
- Student-athletes who transfer between Pac-12 institutions are able to receive athletic scholarships immediately.
- Student-athletes are represented in the Conference governance structure.
- According to the Pac-12 Conference’s Web site, rules adopted in 2014, which apply to all Pac-12 student-athletes across all sports, include:
- Recent amendments: This measure was recently amended and major changes are summarized as follows:
- Strike "media rights" as the sole source of funding permitted under the SABR. Amendments remove the requirement that an institution of higher education to which this section applies shall rely exclusively on revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to defray any costs accrued under this section. According to the author, this change was made to, "give universities who do not have large media rights revenue the ability to use alternative methods such as fundraising to pay for any of the provisions of the bill."
- Recast private right of action. The language providing a private right of action for an aggrieved college student athlete under the SABR was rewritten by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, who provided the author and this Committee with a request to include their amended language into the bill in lieu of hearing.
- Committee requested amendments would recast recent changes:
- Change references from "college athlete" to "college student athlete."
AB 2220 was recently amended in part to change the references in the bill from "student athletes" to "college athletes." The author states that this change is needed because the SABR, "only applies to college athletes, not students who participate at the high school and middle school level. This change is to better reflect the applicability of the bill."
However, use of the term "Student Athlete" is not exclusive to K-12, and is in fact a long standing term of art used by the NCAA and others to distinguish those athletes who participate in institution sanctioned intercollegiate athletics, as opposed to professional athletes who attend college, or students in intermural or club sports on campus. In speaking with representative of the various higher education segments, it was agreed that the term "college student athlete" would not conflict with existing laws or regulations, and would provide the distinction from high school student athletes the author wishes to clarify.
- Page 3, line 8 strike the reference to "six" and insert "five." Strike lines 10 & 11 and insert: "A student athlete shall be granted one additional year beyond the five years upon showing of cause for need. Additional years may be provided at the discretion of the institution of higher education."
According to the author, the proposed change from 5 to 6 years was made because, "only about 38.7% of CA students at public 4-year universities complete their degree in 4 years, this number rises to 59.2% in 6 years. The graduation rates for private colleges are 61.3% in 4 years and 73.9% in 6 years. Expanding the number of years to six will help ensure that students are able to complete their educational degree on a timeline that more accurately reflects the completion rate for students in California."
While the segments of higher education impacted by this bill acknowledge that a "4-year degree" often takes longer than 4 years to achieve, they questioned the need for this change, given there are no known incidents of students being denied an extension of time upon request as is allowed under existing SABR, and the potential expense of a blanket extension of time. In addition, they claim that they are working toward returning to a four year degree completion model. The author and segments agreed that a one year extension would be granted to a student upon a showing of need, such as injury, illness, lack of space in impacted programs, or university schedule conflicts with a student's major course requirements, e.g. they don't offer needed classes.
- Page 2, Section 67450 (c), strike "40" and insert "20" to read: (c) Student athletes generate large revenues for many athletic programs, spend approximately 20 hours per week participating in their respective sports, and suffer current and historically low graduation rates.
This is a technical change suggested by the Committee and reflects current NCAA policy which restricts student athletes to 20 hours per week for team activities during their season and limits them to 8 hours in the off season. (NCAA Bylaw 17)
5) Prior and Related legislation:
- AB 2747 (Holden), would add to the SABR provisions by: declaring that college athletes have the right to self-organization and requiring institutions of higher education, as defined, to provide student athletes with designated information; require institutions of higher education to establish a process by which the complaints of student athletes about violations of the NCAA Bill of Rights, the SABR, and institutional policies may be reported and investigated; require institutions of higher education to appoint student athlete liaisons with duties and responsibilities that would include being available to all student athletes of the institution and to record and investigate the complaints of student athletes, as specified; that student athletes have the right to enforce a provision of this SABR in the superior court through a civil action for injunctive relief or money damages, or both; and would require the court to award court costs and reasonable reimbursement for attorneys’ fees to a student athlete who is the prevailing party in such an action. The bill would prohibit a student athlete, institution of higher education, or athletic conference, as defined, from being required to agree to adjudication, in another state, of a claim or controversy that arises in California. Finally, the bill would authorize the Civil Rights Enforcement Section of the State Department of Justice to have specified powers and responsibilities for the investigation of complaints, and the prosecution of violations, of the SABR. Currently pending before the Assembly Committee on Higher Education.
The bill would also prohibit a student athlete from being penalized for receiving any gift or income that can be demonstrated to be generally available to the students of the institution of higher education who are not athletes or for being accused of a noncriminal violation the investigation or adjudication of which has not been completed, as specified.
- AB 1435 (Gonzales-Fletcher), would establish the College Athlete Protection Act under the administration of the College Athlete Protection Commission, which would be established by the bill, for the protection of college or university athletes participating in intercollegiate athletic programs offered by institutions of higher education located in California. Currently pending before the Senate Committee on Business and Professions.
c) AB 735 (Ridley-Thomas), Chapter 220, Statutes of 2016, removed the sunset form the SABR.
d) SB 1525 (Padilla), Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012, created the original SABR discussed as "Existing Law" above.
e) AB 1743 (Campos), Chapter 16, Statutes of 2012, clarified that the online scholarship disclosures required of a California postsecondary educational institution only apply to institutions that offer athletic scholarships to "student athletes."
f) AB 2079 (Torlakson-Davis), Chapter 592, Statutes of 2010 provided that all California postsecondary educational institutions that offer athletic scholarships are required to provide specified scholarship information on their websites.
g) AB 95 (Torlakson) of 2008-09, would have required athletic recruiters to provide student athletes with specified information relating to the college athletic program within one week of initiating personal contact with the student athlete for purposes of athletic recruiting. Status: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec.10(c) of the Constitution.
h) SB 193 (Murray) of 2002-03, would have prohibited California institutions of higher education from participating in any organizations that regulates student athletic scholarships, including the NCAA. Status: Held in the Assembly Higher Education Committee.
6) Double referral: Should this measure pass out of this committee it will be re-referred to the Committee on Higher Education.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
National College Players Association
California Association for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance
Opposition
Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities
University of Southern California
The California State University
Analysis Prepared by: Dana Mitchell / A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. / (916) 319-3450
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):