AB 2409: Professions and vocations: occupational regulations.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-04-16
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of various professions and vocations by boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides that those boards are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities that have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. Existing law authorizes a board to deny a license if an applicant has been convicted of a crime, done any act involving dishonesty, fraud, or deceit with intent to substantially benefit himself or herself or another or substantially injure another, or does any act that, if done by a licentiate of the business or profession, would be grounds for suspension or revocation.
This bill would establish that a person has a right to engage in a lawful profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation, as defined, that imposes a substantial burden on that right, and would require each occupational regulation to be limited to what is demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective. The bill would include within this the right of a person with a criminal record to obtain a license and not to have a board use the persons criminal record used by a board as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation. The bill would also include vocation, except as specified, and the right of a person who is behind on his or her taxes or student loans to petition a board not to use these factors against that person, as prescribed. loan payments to not have a board use that fact as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation.
The bill would authorize a person who is denied a license to file a petition and appeal to the board. The bill would prescribe procedures and legal standards by which a board may determine that a persons criminal record disqualifies that person. The bill would also permit a person, following the response to an administrative petition, to file an appeal to a court for a declaratory judgment or injunctive or other equitable relief, in accordance with certain legal procedures and criteria. to petition a board to review an occupational regulation, as defined, within the boards jurisdiction for compliance with the above rights, as specified. The bill would authorize a person with a criminal record to petition a board at any time for a determination of whether the persons criminal record will automatically disqualify the person from obtaining a license from the board and would specify the criteria a board is allowed to use in making that determination. The bill would include related definitions and declare the intent of the Legislature in this regard.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of various professions and vocations by boards, bureaus, and commissions boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides that those boards, bureaus, and commissions boards are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities that have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. Existing law authorizes a board to deny a license if an applicant has been convicted of a crime, done any act involving dishonesty, fraud, or deceit with intent to substantially benefit himself or herself or another or substantially injure another, or does any act that, if done by a licentiate of the business or profession, would be grounds for suspension or revocation.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that provision. establish that a person has a right to engage in a lawful profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation, as defined, that imposes a substantial burden on that right, and would require each occupational regulation to be limited to what is demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective. The bill would include within this the right of a person with a criminal record to obtain a license and not to have a board use the persons criminal record as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation. The bill would also include the right of a person who is behind on his or her taxes or student loans to petition a board not to use these factors against that person, as prescribed.
The bill would authorize a person who is denied a license to file a petition and appeal to the board. The bill would prescribe procedures and legal standards by which a board may determine that a persons criminal record disqualifies that person. The bill would also permit a person, following the response to an administrative petition, to file an appeal to a court for a declaratory judgment or injunctive or other equitable relief, in accordance with certain legal procedures and criteria. The bill would include related definitions and declare the intent of the Legislature in this regard.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of various professions and vocations by boards, bureaus, and commissions within the Department of Consumer Affairs and provides that those boards, bureaus, and commissions are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities that have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that provision.
This act may be known as the Occupational Opportunity Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Each individual has the right to pursue a chosen profession and vocation, free from arbitrary or excessive government interference.
(b)The freedom to earn an honest living traditionally has provided the surest means for economic mobility.
(c)In recent years, many regulations of entry into professions and vocations have exceeded legitimate public purposes and have had the effect of arbitrarily limiting entry and reducing competition.
(d)The burden of excessive regulation is borne most heavily by individuals outside the economic mainstream, for whom opportunities for economic advancement are curtailed.
(e)It is in the public interest to do all of the following:
(1)Ensure the right of all individuals to pursue legitimate entrepreneurial and professional opportunities to the limits of their talent and ambition.
(2)Provide the means for the vindication of this right.
(3)Ensure that regulations of entry into professions and vocations are demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill legitimate health, safety, and welfare objectives.
SEC. 3.Section 37 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:37.(a)(1)Notwithstanding Section 480 or any other law, a person has a right to engage in a lawful profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation that imposes a substantial burden on that right. To achieve this purpose, each occupational regulation shall be limited to what is demonstrably necessary and shall be narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, the right set forth in paragraph (1) includes the right of a person with a criminal record to obtain a license to engage in a profession or vocation, and the right to not have a board use the persons criminal record as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation. to not have the persons criminal record be used by a board as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation, unless for reasons specified in this section.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the right set forth in paragraph (1) also includes the right of a person who is behind on his or her taxes or student loans loan payments to obtain a license to engage in a profession or vocation, and the right to not have the board use the persons status with respect to his or her taxes or student loans loan payments as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation.
(b)(1)(A)A person denied a license may file a petition and appeal to the board.(B)If the person has a criminal record, the person shall include in the petition a copy of his or her criminal record or shall authorize the board to obtain a copy that record. The person may additionally include information about his or her current circumstances, including, but not limited to, the time passed since the offense, completion of the criminal sentence, other evidence of rehabilitation, testimonials, employment history, and employment aspirations.(C)Notwithstanding any other law, the board may find that the persons criminal record disqualifies that person from obtaining a license only if the persons criminal record includes a conviction for a felony or a violent misdemeanor and the board concludes that the state has an important interest in protecting public safety that is superior to the persons individual right. The board may make this conclusion only if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence at the time of the petition, all of the following:(i)The specific offense for which the person was convicted is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of the profession or vocation for which application was denied.(ii)The person, based on the nature of the specific offense for which he or she was convicted and his or her current circumstances, would be put in a position in which that person is more likely to reoffend by having the license than if the person did not obtain that license.(iii)A reoffense by the person would cause greater harm than it would if the person did not have a license and was not put in a position in which the person is more likely to reoffend.(2)Within 90 days of a petition filed pursuant to paragraph (1), the board shall make a determination on the appeal, based on the standards set forth in subdivision (a).(c)(1)Following the response to an administrative petition pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), a person may file an appeal to a court of general jurisdiction for a declaratory judgment or injunctive relief or other equitable relief for a violation of subdivision (a).(2)In such an action, the board bears the burden of proving by preponderance of the evidence that the challenged occupational regulation meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).(3)If the board fails to meet the burden of proof and the court finds by a preponderance of evidence that the challenged occupational regulation fails to meet the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), the court shall enjoin further enforcement of the occupational regulation and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs to the plaintiff. (4)A court shall liberally construe this section to protect the rights established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).(b)(1)A person may petition a board to review an occupational regulation within the boards jurisdiction for compliance with subdivision (a). The board shall respond within 90 days after the petition is submitted, and shall, in writing, inform the petitioner of the boards decision to do one of the following depending on the circumstances:
(A)Subject to the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), repeal the occupational regulation.
(B)Subject to the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), amend the occupational regulation to bring it into compliance with subdivision (a).
(C)Recommend the enactment of legislation by the Legislature.
(D)State the basis on which the board concludes the occupational regulation complies with subdivision (a).
(2)A person may appeal the boards determination in paragraph (1) by filing an action in a court of general jurisdiction for declaratory judgment, injunctive relief, or other equitable relief.
(A)In such an action, the board bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that the challenged occupational regulation is in compliance with subdivision (a).
(B)If the board fails to meet the burden of proof and the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the challenged occupational regulation does not comply with subdivision (a), the court shall enjoin further enforcement of the occupational regulation and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs to the petitioner.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a person with a criminal record may petition a board at any time for a determination of whether the persons criminal record will automatically disqualify the person from obtaining a license from the board.
(2)The person shall include in the petition the persons criminal record or authorize the board to obtain the persons criminal record.
(3)Notwithstanding any other statute or rule, the board may find the individuals criminal record disqualifies the individual from obtaining a license only if both of the following are met:
(A)The persons criminal record includes a conviction for a felony or violent misdemeanor.
(B)The board concludes the state has an important interest in protecting public safety that is superior to the persons right in subdivision (a). The board may make this conclusion only if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence at the time of the petition, that all of the following are met:
(i)The specific offense for which the person was convicted is substantially related to the states interest in protecting public safety.
(ii)The person, based on the nature of the specific offense for which he or she was convicted and the persons current circumstances, will be put in a position where the person is more likely to reoffend by having the license than if the individual did not have the license.
(iii)A reoffense will cause greater harm than if the individual did not have a license and was not put in the position where the individual is more likely to reoffend.
(4)The board shall issue its determination within 90 days after the board receives the petition. The determination shall be in writing and include, but not be limited to, the persons criminal record, findings of fact, and the boards legal conclusions.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms apply:
(1)Board has the same meaning as set forth in Section 22.
(2)License has the same meaning as set forth in Section 23.7.
(3)Occupational regulation means a regulation, rule, policy, condition, test, permit, administrative practice, or other state government-prescribed requirement for a person to engage in a lawful profession or vocation.
This act may be known as the Occupational Opportunity Act.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Each individual has the right to pursue a chosen profession and vocation, free from arbitrary or excessive government interference.
(b)The freedom to earn an honest living traditionally has provided the surest means for economic mobility.
(c)In recent years, many regulations of entry into professions and vocations have exceeded legitimate public purposes and have had the effect of arbitrarily limiting entry and reducing competition.
(d)The burden of excessive regulation is borne most heavily by individuals outside the economic mainstream, for whom opportunities for economic advancement are curtailed.
(e)It is in the public interest to do all of the following:
(1)Ensure the right of all individuals to pursue legitimate entrepreneurial and professional opportunities to the limits of their talent and ambition.
(2)Provide the means for the vindication of this right.
(3)Ensure that regulations of entry into professions and vocations are demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill legitimate health, safety, and welfare objectives.
SEC. 3.Section 37 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:37.(a)(1)Notwithstanding Section 480 or any other law, a person has a right to engage in a lawful profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation that imposes a substantial burden on that right. To achieve this purpose, each occupational regulation shall be limited to what is demonstrably necessary and shall be narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, the right set forth in paragraph (1) includes the right of a person with a criminal record to obtain a license to engage in a profession or vocation, and the right to not have a board use the persons criminal record as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the right set forth in paragraph (1) also includes the right of a person who is behind on his or her taxes or student loans to obtain a license to engage in a profession or vocation, and the right to not have the board use the persons status with respect to his or her taxes or student loans as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation.
(b)(1)(A)A person denied a license may file a petition and appeal to the board.
(B)If the person has a criminal record, the person shall include in the petition a copy of his or her criminal record or shall authorize the board to obtain a copy that record. The person may additionally include information about his or her current circumstances, including, but not limited to, the time passed since the offense, completion of the criminal sentence, other evidence of rehabilitation, testimonials, employment history, and employment aspirations.
(C)Notwithstanding any other law, the board may find that the persons criminal record disqualifies that person from obtaining a license only if the persons criminal record includes a conviction for a felony or a violent misdemeanor and the board concludes that the state has an important interest in protecting public safety that is superior to the persons individual right. The board may make this conclusion only if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence at the time of the petition, all of the following:
(i)The specific offense for which the person was convicted is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of the profession or vocation for which application was denied.
(ii)The person, based on the nature of the specific offense for which he or she was convicted and his or her current circumstances, would be put in a position in which that person is more likely to reoffend by having the license than if the person did not obtain that license.
(iii)A reoffense by the person would cause greater harm than it would if the person did not have a license and was not put in a position in which the person is more likely to reoffend.
(2)Within 90 days of a petition filed pursuant to paragraph (1), the board shall make a determination on the appeal, based on the standards set forth in subdivision (a).
(c)(1)Following the response to an administrative petition pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), a person may file an appeal to a court of general jurisdiction for a declaratory judgment or injunctive relief or other equitable relief for a violation of subdivision (a).
(2)In such an action, the board bears the burden of proving by preponderance of the evidence that the challenged occupational regulation meets the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(3)If the board fails to meet the burden of proof and the court finds by a preponderance of evidence that the challenged occupational regulation fails to meet the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), the court shall enjoin further enforcement of the occupational regulation and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs to the plaintiff.
(4)A court shall liberally construe this section to protect the rights established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms apply:
(1)Board has the same meaning as set forth in Section 22.
(2)License has the same meaning as set forth in Section 23.7.
(3)Occupational regulation means a regulation, rule, policy, condition, test, permit, administrative practice, or other state government-prescribed requirement for a person to engage in a lawful profession or vocation.
SECTION 1.Section 101.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:101.6.(a)The boards, bureaus, and commissions in the department are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities that have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California.(b)To this end, they establish minimum qualifications and levels of competency and license persons desiring to engage in the occupations they regulate upon determining that such persons possess the requisite skills and qualifications necessary to provide safe and effective services to the public, or register or otherwise certify persons in order to identify practitioners and ensure performance according to set and accepted professional standards. They provide a means for redress of grievances by investigating allegations of unprofessional conduct, incompetence, fraudulent action, or unlawful activity brought to their attention by members of the public and institute disciplinary action against persons licensed or registered under the provisions of this code when such action is warranted. In addition, they conduct periodic checks of licensees, registrants, or otherwise certified persons in order to ensure compliance with the relevant sections of this code.(a)The boards, bureaus, and commissions in the department are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which that have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California.
To(b)To this end, they establish minimum qualifications and levels of competency and license persons desiring to engage in the occupations they regulate upon determining that such persons possess the requisite skills and qualifications necessary to provide safe and effective services to the public, or register or otherwise certify persons in order to identify practitioners and ensure performance according to set and accepted professional standards. They provide a means for redress of grievances by investigating allegations of unprofessional conduct, incompetence, fraudulent action, or unlawful activity brought to their attention by members of the public and institute disciplinary action against persons licensed or registered under the provisions of this code when such action is warranted. In addition, they conduct periodic checks of licensees, registrants, or otherwise certified persons in order to ensure compliance with the relevant sections of this code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Mar 23, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on B. & P. and JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2409
Author:(Kiley) – As Amended Ver:April 16, 2018
SUBJECT: Professions and vocations: occupational regulations.
SUMMARY: Establishes a right to engage in a profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation that imposes a substantial burden on that right, and creates a private right of action for individuals to sue a regulatory board in court, wherein the board must prove through a preponderance of evidence that any challenged occupational regulation is limited to what is demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 100)
- Enumerates various regulatory boards, bureaus, committees, and commissions under the DCA’s jurisdiction. (BPC § 101)
- Provides that all boards, bureaus, and commissions within the DCA are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. (BPC § 101.6)
- Authorizes the Governor to remove at any time, any member of any board appointed by the Governor for continued neglect of duties required by law, or for incompetence, or unprofessional or dishonorable conduct. (BPC § 106)
- Places the DCA under the control of the Director of Consumer Affairs, who is appointed by the Governor and may investigate the work of boards under the DCA. (BPC §§ 150 et seq.)
- Allows the Director of Consumer Affairs to initiate an investigation of any allegations of misconduct in the preparation, administration, or scoring of an examination which is administered by a board, or in the review of qualifications which are a part of the licensing process of any board. (BPC § 109)
- Authorizes the Director of Consumer Affairs to audit and review, upon the director's own initiative, or upon the request of a consumer or licensee, inquiries and complaints regarding licensees, dismissals of disciplinary cases, the opening, conduct, or closure of investigations, informal conferences, and discipline short of formal accusation by the Medical Board of California, the allied health professional boards, and the California Board of Podiatric Medicine. (BPC § 116)
- Permits the Director of Consumer Affairs to require reports from any board or other agency within the DCA as he or she deems reasonably necessary on any phase of their operations. (BPC § 127)
- Prohibits any board or other agency within the DCA from instituting or joining a legal action against any other agency within the state or federal government without the permission of the Director of Consumer Affairs. (BPC § 132)
- Provides the Director of Consumer Affairs with the following powers and duties to:
- Recommend and propose the enactment of such legislation as necessary to protect and promote the interests of consumers.
- Represent the consumer’s interests before federal and state legislative hearings and executive commissions.
- Assist, advise, and cooperate with federal, state, and local agencies and officials to protect and promote the interests of consumers.
- Study, investigate, research, and analyze matters affecting the interests of consumers.
- Hold public hearings, subpoena witnesses, take testimony, compel the production of books, papers, documents, and other evidence, and call upon other state agencies for information.
- Propose and assist in the creation and development of consumer education programs.
- Promote ethical standards of conduct for business and consumers and undertake activities to encourage public responsibility in the production, promotion, sale and lease of consumer goods and services.
- Advise the Governor and Legislature on all matters affecting the interests of consumers.
- Exercise and perform such other functions, powers and duties as may be deemed appropriate to protect and promote the interests of consumers as directed by the Governor or the Legislature.
- Maintain contact and liaison with consumer groups in California and nationally.
(BPC § 310)
- Requires that the Director of Consumer Affairs be formally notified of and be provided a full opportunity to review all notices of proposed, modified, and final rulemaking actions, and provides the director with the authority to disapprove a proposed rule or regulation within 30 days on the ground that it is injurious to the public health, safety, or welfare. (BPC § 313.1)
- States in myriad practice acts enforced by boards and bureaus under the DCA that protection of the public shall be the highest priority. (BPC § 7301.1; § 2001.1; § 1601.2; § 2450.1; § 2460.1; § 2531.02; § 2570.25; § 2602.1; § 2708.1; § 2841.1; § 2920.1; § 3010.1; § 3320.1; § 3504.1; § 3710.1; § 4001.1; § 4501.1; § 4800.1; § 4928.1; § 4990.125; § 5000.1; § 5510.15; § 5620.1; § 6710.1; § 7000.6; § 7303.1; § 7501.05; § 7601.1; § 7810.1; § 8005.1; § 8520.1; § 9810.1; § 9880.3; § 18602.1; 19004.1; § 94770.1; etc.)
- Defines “board” as also inclusive of “bureau,” “commission,” “committee,” “department,” “division,” “examining committee,” “program,” and “agency.” (BPC § 22)
THIS BILL:
- Finds and declares that each individual has the right to pursue a chosen profession and vocation, free from arbitrary or excessive government interference; that the freedom to earn an honest living traditionally has provided the surest means for economic mobility; that in recent years, many regulations of entry into professions and vocations have exceeded legitimate public purposes and have had the effect of arbitrarily limiting entry and reducing competition; that the burden of excessive regulation is borne most heavily by individuals outside the economic mainstream, for whom opportunities for economic advancement are curtailed; and that it is in the public interest to establish a private right of action to protect the right of all individuals to pursue legitimate entrepreneurial and professional opportunities to the limits of their talent and ambition.
- Establishes a right for every person to engage in a lawful profession or vocation without being subject to an occupational regulation that imposes a substantial burden of that right. States that to achieve this purpose, each occupational regulation shall be limited to what is demonstrably necessary and shall be narrowly tailored to fulfill a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective.
- States that a person with a criminal record shall have the right to not have their record used by a board as an automatic or mandatory permanent bar to engaging in a lawful profession or vocation, unless for specified reasons.
- Clarifies that a person who is simply behind on his or her taxes or student loan payments may not be denied an occupational license.
- Allows any person to petition a board to review an occupational regulation within the board’s jurisdiction alleged to be substantially burdensome and not demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to a legitimate public health, safety, or welfare objective.
- Provides a board with 90 days to respond to any challenge to an occupational regulation by repealing or amending the regulation, recommending statutory changes by the Legislature, or stating the basis on which the board concludes that the occupational regulation is not substantially burdensome without justification.
- Establishes a private right of action wherein a person may appeal the board’s response to a challenge to an occupational regulation by suing in a court of general jurisdiction for declaratory judgment, injunctive relief, or other equitable relief.
- Places the burden of proof on the board in any litigated challenge to an occupational regulation, requiring the board to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the regulation is justified.
- States that if a board fails to meet its burden of proof in litigation relating to an occupational regulation, the court shall enjoin further enforcement of the occupational regulation and shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to the petitioner.
- Permits a person with a criminal record to petition a board for a determination of whether the person’s criminal record will automatically disqualify the person from obtaining a license.
- Limits the discretion of a board to disqualify a license applicant due to their criminal history to cases where the conviction was for a felony or violent misdemeanor and the board has concluded that the state has an important interest in protecting public safety that is superior to the person’s right to engage in a profession without government interference.
- Allows a board to disqualify a license applicant with a criminal record only when the conviction is substantially related to the state’s interest in protecting public safety; the person is more likely to reoffend if they are provided a license; and the re-offense will cause greater harm than if the applicant was not given a license.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author:
Assembly Bill 2409 would address systemic issues with how California licenses occupations and governs its regulatory process by creating a statutory right to challenge unfair licensing requirements that pose unnecessary barriers to work. Additionally, it creates a petition for criminal review and prohibits a board or agency from barring licensure of an individual that is behind on student loan and/or tax payments. This bill would restore the proper balance between freedom and legitimate government regulation.
Background.
Overview of Licensure in California. California has provided for the licensure of regulated professionals since the early days of statehood. In 1876, the Legislature enacted the original Medical Practice Act, which was revised two years later to delegate licensing authority to the first three regulatory boards: the Medical Board, Eclectic Board, and Homeopathic Board. By the end of the 1920s, seven additional boards had been established to regulate pharmacists, dentists, optometrists, veterinarians, barbers, accountants, and embalmers. These boards were placed under the oversight of a Department of Vocational and Professional Standards, which would become the Department of Consumer Affairs in 1965. Today, the DCA oversees 38 boards, bureaus, and other regulatory bodies.
As a department within an agency of the state government, the DCA is led by a director appointed by the Governor. While the regulatory boards under the DCA’s oversight are considered semi-autonomous, the Director of Consumer Affairs does wield considerable influence over board policymaking. For example, the director has the power to review and disapprove formal rulemaking, may conduct audits and reviews of board activities, and approves budget change proposals prior to their submission to the Department of Finance. The powers of the director are then further subject to the authority of the Secretary of the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency and, ultimately, the Governor.
The practice act for each profession licensed by a regulatory board under the DCA typically includes sunset provisions providing for regular review by the Legislature. At staggered intervals averaging four years, the Senate and Assembly Business and Professions Committees prepare a comprehensive background paper for each entity, hold public hearings, recalculate the balance of consumer protection and regulatory burden, and make recommendations to enact any necessary reforms. In rare instances, entities are abolished, reduced, or consolidated when inefficiencies are identified or when public benefit is deemed insufficient to justify regulation. For example, in 2017 the Legislature allowed the State Board of Guide Dogs for the Blind to sunset, replacing its licensing program with less intrusive title protections.
Criticisms of the DCA. In recent years, a number of published reports have called for reforms to California’s licensure scheme, criticizing the state’s regulation of occupations and professions as needlessly burdensome and complex. These reports typically follow a libertarian philosophy in favor of smaller government, arguing that regulation should only exist in situations where clear consumer harm is likely absent government intervention. Barriers to entry such as licensing fees, education requirements, examinations, criminal history disqualifications, and other prerequisites are all then presumed undesirable unless proven necessary for the public interest.
The Little Hoover Commission’s Jobs for Californians: Strategies to Ease Occupational Licensing Barriers refers to the boards and bureaus under the DCA as a “nearly impenetrable thicket of bureaucracy for Californians” and advocates for the state to “review its licensing requirements and determine whether those requirements are overly broad or burdensome to labor market entry or labor mobility.” The Institute for Justice’s License to Work: A National Study of Burdens from Occupational Licensing, now in its second edition, ranks California as the “most burdensome state” when accounting for both the number of lower-income occupations licensed and the average burden of licensing requirements. Other reports published by both public and private research institutions are less aggressively critical in tone, but offer similar assessments as to the possibility that California may arguably overregulate in its licensure of professions and occupations.
Board Discretion to Deny Applications for Licensure. Due to the unique nature of each individual profession licensed and regulated by entities under the DCA, the various professional practice acts contain their own standards and enforcement criteria for individuals applying for or in receipt of special occupational privileges from the state. There are some umbrella statutes that govern the discretion of these regulatory bodies generally. For example, BPC § 480 governs the authority of regulatory boards to deny applicants for licensure.
Under BPC § 480, a board may deny a license within the purview of the DCA on the grounds that the applicant has one of the following:
- Been convicted of a crime; boards may disqualify based on criminal history if the time for appeal has elapsed, or the judgment of conviction has been affirmed on appeal, or when an order granting probation is made suspending the imposition of sentence.
- Done any act involving dishonesty, fraud, or deceit with the intent to substantially benefit himself or herself or another, or substantially injure another.
- Done any act that if done by a licentiate of the business or profession in question, would be grounds for suspension or revocation of license.
§ 480 specifies that a license may only be denied for prior misconduct if the disqualifying crime or act is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of the business or profession for which application is made. The statute also states that a person may not be denied a license solely based on a conviction if he or she possesses a certificate of rehabilitation. Statute further clarifies that a dismissed conviction may not be grounds for disqualification for licensure.
These provisions are echoed in BPC § 490, which deals with the discretion of a board to take disciplinary action against a current licensee for subsequent criminal activity. This code section makes specific reference to Petropoulos v. Department of Real Estate (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 554, a court decision dealing with licensees convicted of criminal misconduct. The Legislature has found and declared the holding in that case has “placed a significant number of statutes and regulations in question, resulting in potential harm to the consumers of California from licensees who have been convicted of crimes.” The Legislature therefore further found and declared that “this section establishes an independent basis for a board to impose discipline upon a licensee.”
Criticism has been made over statute’s allowance for boards and bureaus to deny a license to an individual who has “done any act involving honesty, fraud, or deceit” for self-benefit or harm to others. This broad discretion goes beyond criminal convictions, as well as non-criminal activity that is nevertheless afforded an element of due process, such as regulatory discipline. A number of hypothetical “acts” have been proposed as eligible for disqualification, and in some cases – including instances occurring outside of California – boards or bureaus have made decisions based on certain debtor statuses.
There are no recent instances in which an individual has been denied a license due simply to owing taxes or being behind on student loans. AB 508 (Santiago) of 2017 repealed an authority for a board to deny licensure to a healing arts license applicant in default of specified federal medical education loans. It was revealed during this legislative session that no healing arts board had utilized this authority in recent history prior to its repeal. No known authority similarly exists to expressly deny licensure to applicants who owe taxes.
The discretion for boards and bureaus to deny licensure to applicants with criminal histories has also been criticized, despite the guarantee of due process afforded to these applicants prior to a crime being reflected on their record. In its report Unlicensed & Untapped: Removing Barriers to State Occupational Licenses for People with Records, the National Employment Law Project (NELP) discusses the arguably draconian nature of barriers to occupational entry based on criminal history. NELP’s report refers to “a lack of transparency and predictability in the licensure decision-making process and confusion caused by a labyrinth of different restrictions” in regulatory schemes across the country. California is specifically graded as “Needs Improvement,” with recommendations including:
- Expand blanket ban prohibition to all occupations with one overarching law.
- Expand occupation-relatedness requirement to all.
- Require consideration of the time elapsed since conviction.
- Prohibit consideration of certain record information (e.g., arrests, lesser offenses, older offenses).
- Require consideration of the applicant’s rehabilitation.
In 2017, the Assembly Business and Professions Committee discussed barriers to licensure generally in its sunset background paper for the DCA. Specifically, the committee considered how criminal convictions eligible for license disqualification in California are limited in the sense that they must be “substantially related” to the profession into which the license allows entry. Concern was expressed that there is a “serious lack of clarity for applicants as to what ‘substantially related’ means and this determination is often left to the discretion of individual boards.” The committee staff recommendation was for the DCA to take steps to improve transparency and consistency in the use of applicants’ criminal histories by boards and bureaus.
Current Related Legislation. AB 2138 (Chiu/Low) would limit the authority of a board to deny, revoke, or suspend a license to instances where an applicant or licensee has been convicted of a crime within the preceding 5 years (except for violent felonies) or been subjected to formal discipline within the preceding 5 years for professional misconduct that would have been cause for discipline before the board for which the present application is made, and requires both types of misconduct to be directly and adversely related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of the business or profession for which licensure is sought or held.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 269 (Correa, Chapter 107, Statutes of 2002) stated that the highest priority for licensing boards, commissions, and bureaus, in performing their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions, is the protection of the public.
AB 508 (Santiago, Chapter 195, Statutes of 2017) repealed provisions authorizing a healing arts board to deny a license to an applicant if he or she is in default of certain student loans.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The Goldwater Institute, a conservative and libertarian think tank, supports this bill. The institute states that the bill represents “a responsible reform to occupational regulation that restores the proper balance between legitimate government regulation and the protection of economic opportunity.” The institute specifically calls out “occupations such as tree trimmers, landscapers, funeral attendants, and farm labor contractors” as examples of license types that “do not serve a legitimate public safety need, but rather exist to protect existing industries from competition.”
The Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) also supports the bill, referring to occupational licensing as “a civil rights issue.” PLF claims that studies show “that licensure does little to serve the public; instead, it serves to enrich industry insiders who benefit from reduced competition.” PLF states that the time and fees taken to become an occupational licensee in California is to the detriment of “honest and hardworking Californians.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The California Nurses Association (CNA) opposes this bill, referring to it as “an assault on regulatory protections” and “an example of the anti-regulatory ‘Trumpism’ coming out of the nation’s Capitol at this time.” CNA notes that the findings and declarations in the bill are taken directly from the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), which CNA regards as an “anti-regulatory, corporate-friendly group that proposes legislative ideas in line with its anti-government principles.” CNA disputes what it considers to be the “underlying premise” of this bill, which it characterizes as declaring “that occupational regulations are bad.” CNA states that “this is simply a fallacy. These regulations are protections which safeguard the health and safety of the public, workers, and communities in California.”
The Professional Beauty Federation of California (PBFC), which represents professionals licensed by the Board of Barbering and Cosmetology, also opposes the bill. PBFC believes that the bill is a “piecemeal chipping away at certain beauty practices that run afoul of the preference of any particular Court. For industries such as ours that have been regulated and licensed by the State of California for nearly a century, sudden and unpredictable changes in our licensed scope of practice could topple long-established businesses and derail long-term careers overnight.” PBFC urges the author to focus on appeals of criminal convictions, not patchwork deregulation.
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
This bill proposes to fundamentally recast the currently recognized role of regulation by the government in the context of occupational licensing. Since 2002, the overwhelming majority of practice acts enforced by boards under the DCA have included the following language: “Protection of the public shall be the highest priority.” In effect, this bill would codify a deprioritization of public protection in favor of a mandate that boards must regulate as little as possible, allowing only for occupational regulations that are “demonstrably necessary and narrowly tailored to fulfill legitimate health, safety, and welfare objectives.”
The reforms proposed by this bill align with libertarian principles advocated for by those in favor of small government. Numerous studies aimed at providing data-driven analysis to California’s anecdotal reputation for being “overregulated” do suggest that state lawmakers should continue to explore opportunities to rebalance consumer safeguards and access to licensure. The solutions proposed by this bill, however, represent a drastic approach to ensuring that occupational regulations don’t exceed their public value.
Much of government regulation exists to provide individuals with a right to presume that certain products and services will not unexpectedly cause them harm. Whenever a tragedy is reported in the news involving an individual in possession of professional privileges, state laws and regulations are immediately scrutinized for deficiencies, with an assumption that greater oversight could have prevented the occurrence. Whether it is seeking treatment from a health professional, entrusting a contractor with the construction of a home, or authorizing the sale and distribution of controlled products like prescription drugs or cannabis, the average consumer trusts that government regulation exists to keep the state’s population safe.
It is reasonable to state that not all regulated professions pose the same potential harm to the public. As an example, the privileges afforded to barbers are not on the same level as those given to physicians and surgeons, who archetypically require significant trust from the public to provide essential services. However, this distinction is already fully recognized in California’s laws and regulations. The Institute for Justice report cited by the author outlines how in the instant example, those seeking to become barbers in California must pay a total of $125 and prove an estimated 1,500 hours of education. Physicians and surgeons, meanwhile, pay over ten times that amount in fees and at least 4,000 hours of medical school education.
Furthermore, California’s sunrise and sunset review process already provides a mechanism for the value of barriers to occupational licensure to be weighed against their public protection function. Government Code §§ 9148 et seq. prescribes the legislative “sunrise” process through which the statutory creation of any new state board of licensing requirement must be analyzed. The process requires that a plan be created that includes all of the following:
- A description of the problem that the creation of the specific state board or new category of licensed professional would address, including the specific evidence of need for the state to address the problem.
- The reasons why this proposed state board or new category of licensed professional was selected to address this problem, including the full range of alternatives considered and the reason why each of these alternatives was not selected.
- The specific public benefit or harm that would result from the establishment of the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional, the specific manner in which the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional would achieve this benefit, and the specific standards of performance which shall be used in reviewing the subsequent operation of the board or category of licensed professional.
- The specific source or sources of revenue and funding to be utilized by the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional in achieving its mandate.
- The necessary data and other information required in this section shall be provided to the Legislature with the initial legislation and forwarded to the policy committees in which the bill will be heard.
In essence, the balancing of public benefit and occupational restriction sought by this bill exists already as a required process for any new professional regulation by the state. This is in combination with the ongoing “sunset” review process, in which nearly every category of occupational licensure is statutorily repealed after a predetermined period of time (averaging four years) absent deliberate extension by the Legislature. The Government Code refers extensively to the process by which the Assembly and Senate policy committees review the necessity of state licensure and make any reforms necessary to preserve a balance of access and public protection.
Supplanting this consistent and thoroughly researched analytical process with a private right of action is certainly an effective way to prevent boards from placing unnecessarily onerous restrictions on those who seek to engage in a regulated profession. However, the inevitable result would be uncertainty and irregularity in state regulation. Creating an opportunity to challenge any occupational regulation – not limited under the bill to formal rulemaking under the Administrative Procedure Act – would place every applicable limitation on a profession in doubt, subjected to specific litigation by anyone who believes the limitation to be unjustified.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
The practical effect of the private right of action created by this bill would be that every board or bureau would need to be prepared to defend any of its practice act provisions, administrative rulemakings, enforcement priorities, or other occupational regulations in superior court. The capacity of licensing entities to efficiently resolve litigation has already been raised as a persistent concern by the Legislature, with the Consumer Protection Enforcement Initiative (CPEI) enacted as part of a larger effort to expedite legal processes undertaken by the DCA and the boards it oversees. Adding a new private right of action against these entities – which would likely result in voluminous litigation considering the breadth of the cause of action and the promise of attorney’s fees – would arguably exacerbate the timeline issues already encountered by legal staff under the DCA and the Office of the Attorney General.
It is also very likely that the provisions of this bill would have a significant chilling effect on boards seeking to take action on behalf of public protection. By creating a private right of action that may be brought against a board for any occupational regulation and by placing the burden of proof on the board with a preponderance standard, many necessary protections may not be implemented in a timely fashion out of concern for potentially having to defend them in court. While this chilling effect may be deemed desirable by the author, it may ultimately be considered detrimental as boards become discouraged from swiftly responding to risks of public harm.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
Goldwater Institute
Pacific Legal Foundation
R Street Institute
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
California Nurses Association
Professional Beauty Federation of California
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):