AB 243: California Beef Commission.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-07-03
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council, comprised of 20 members and 20 alternate members appointed by the Secretary of Food and Agriculture to perform various advisory and other duties relating to the California beef industry. The California Beef Council Law establishes a $1 fee per head on each sale of cattle and calves to administer the California Beef Council Law, and requires the fee to be collected from the seller by the operator of the stockyard, live auction market, slaughterhouse, or feedlot, or from the seller along with brand inspection fees by the Bureau of Livestock Identification. Existing law also provides that the fee from the sale of calves exempt from brand inspection that is not collected in the manner specified above is required to be collected by the purchaser, for payment to the secretary. Existing law generally provides that if a fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer.
This bill would instead require the fee from the sale of cattle or calves exempt from a brand inspection that is not collected from the seller in the manner specified above to be charged and collected from the seller in a manner determined by the Department of Food and Agriculture, and would delete the provision generally providing that if a fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer. The bill would make those provisions operative only if an implementation referendum is conducted and the California Beef Commission Law is enacted. Agriculture.
This bill would also establish the California Beef Commission Law (the law) for similar purposes for which the California Beef Council Law is established and to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council. The bill would create the California Beef Commission, which would be comprised of 11 members and 11 alternate members appointed by the secretary who may be members of the California Beef Council. The bill would provide for reimbursement of traveling and other expenses incurred by commission members in the performance of their duties, unless the expenses are incurred for discharging similar duties reimbursed by the California Beef Council. The bill would set forth the powers and duties of the commission, including administering any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industry. industry, except for administering funds and performing acts under the jurisdiction of the California Beef Council. The bill would exempt the commission or any person acting pursuant to the laws provisions from various consumer protection laws, including the Cartwright Act and the Unfair Practices Act. The bill would provide for an assessment of $1 per head of cattle to be paid on each sale of cattle and calves to carry out the laws provisions and would authorize an assessment greater than $1 to be charged if certain procedural requirements are met. provisions. The bill would authorize the commission to expend those funds for purposes of implementing the bill, thereby making an appropriation. The bill would require the secretary to conduct an initial referendum of producers to approve a mandatory fee to implement the laws provisions and would make operation of the laws provisions contingent upon approval of producers by referendum, except as specified. The bill would provide for termination of the commission by referendum of producers, as specified. require reapproval of the laws provisions by a referendum of producers every 5 years and would provide for suspension of the law if a majority of producers do not vote in favor of continuing the laws operation.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council, comprised of 20 members and 20 alternate members appointed by the Secretary of Food and Agriculture to perform various advisory and other duties relating to the California beef industry. The California Beef Council Law establishes a $1 fee per head on each sale of cattle and calves to administer the California Beef Council Law and authorizes a fee greater than $1 if approved by producers, as specified. Law, and requires the fee to be collected from the seller by the operator of the stockyard, live auction market, slaughterhouse, or feedlot, or from the seller along with brand inspection fees by the Bureau of Livestock Identification. Existing law also provides that the fee from the sale of calves exempt from brand inspection that is not collected in the manner specified above is required to be collected by the purchaser, for payment to the secretary. Existing law generally provides that if a fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer.
This bill would instead require the fee from the sale of cattle or calves exempt from a brand inspection that is not collected from the seller in the manner specified above to be charged and collected in a manner determined by the Department of Food and Agriculture, and would delete the provision generally providing that if a fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer. The bill would make those provisions operative only if an implementation referendum is conducted and the California Beef Commission Law is enacted.
This bill would also establish the California Beef Commission Law (the law) for similar purposes for which the California Beef Council Law is established and to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council. The bill would create the California Beef Commission, which would be comprised of 11 members and 11 alternate members appointed by the secretary who are also may be members of the California Beef Council. The bill would provide for reimbursement of traveling and other expenses incurred by commission members in the performance of their duties, unless the expenses are incurred for discharging similar duties reimbursed by the California Beef Council. The bill would set forth the powers and duties of the commission, including administering any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industry. The bill would exempt the commission or any person acting pursuant to the laws provisions from various consumer protection laws, including the Cartwright Act and the Unfair Practices Act. The bill would provide for an assessment of $1 per head of cattle to be paid on each sale of cattle and calves to carry out the laws provisions and would authorize a fee an assessment greater than $1 to be charged if certain procedural requirements are met. The bill would authorize the commission to expend those funds for purposes of implementing the bill, thereby making an appropriation. The bill would require the secretary to conduct an initial referendum of producers to approve a mandatory fee to implement the laws provisions and would make operation of the laws provisions contingent upon approval of producers by referendum, except as specified. The bill would provide for termination of the commission by referendum of producers, as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council, comprised of 20 members and 20 alternate members appointed by the Secretary of Food and Agriculture to perform various advisory and other duties relating to the California beef industry. The California Beef Council Law establishes a $1 fee per head on each sale of cattle and calves to administer the California Beef Council Law and authorizes a fee greater than $1 if approved by producers, as specified.
This bill would establish the California Beef Commission Law (the law) for similar purposes for which the California Beef Council Law is established and to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council. The bill would create the California Beef Commission, which would be comprised of 11 members and 11 alternate members appointed by the secretary who are also members of the California Beef Council. The bill would provide for reimbursement of traveling and other expenses incurred by commission members in the performance of their duties, unless the expenses are incurred for discharging similar duties reimbursed by the California Beef Council. The bill would set forth the powers and duties of the commission, including administering any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industry. The bill would exempt the commission or any person acting pursuant to the laws provisions from various consumer protection laws, including the Cartwright Act and the Unfair Practices Act. The bill would provide for an assessment of $1 per head of cattle to be paid on each sale of cattle and calves to carry out the laws provisions and would authorize a fee greater than $1 to be charged if certain procedural requirements are met. The bill would authorize the commission to expend those funds for purposes of implementing the bill, thereby making an appropriation. The bill would require the secretary to conduct an initial referendum of producers to approve a mandatory fee to implement the laws provisions and would make operation of the laws provisions contingent upon approval of producers by referendum, except as specified. The bill would provide for termination of the commission by referendum of producers, as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council and requires its members to be Council, comprised of 20 members and 20 alternate members appointed by the Secretary of Food and Agriculture, as specified. Agriculture to perform various advisory and other duties relating to the California beef industry. The California Beef Council Law establishes a $1 fee per head on each sale of cattle and calves to administer the California Beef Council Law and authorizes a fee greater than $1 if approved by producers, as specified.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions. establish the California Beef Commission Law (the law) for similar purposes for which the California Beef Council Law is established and to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council. The bill would create the California Beef Commission, which would be comprised of 11 members and 11 alternate members appointed by the secretary who are also members of the California Beef Council. The bill would provide for reimbursement of traveling and other expenses incurred by commission members in the performance of their duties, unless the expenses are incurred for discharging similar duties reimbursed by the California Beef Council. The bill would set forth the powers and duties of the commission, including administering any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industry. The bill would exempt the commission or any person acting pursuant to the laws provisions from various consumer protection laws, including the Cartwright Act and the Unfair Practices Act. The bill would provide for an assessment of $1 per head of cattle to be paid on each sale of cattle and calves to carry out the laws provisions and would authorize a fee greater than $1 to be charged if certain procedural requirements are met. The bill would require the secretary to conduct an initial referendum of producers to approve a mandatory fee to implement the laws provisions and would make operation of the laws provisions contingent upon approval of producers by referendum, except as specified. The bill would provide for termination of the commission by referendum of producers, as specified.
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council and requires its members to be appointed by the Secretary of Food and Agriculture, as specified.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
The fees required pursuant to Section 64691 shall be due and payable as follows:
(a)The fee for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the director secretary by each operator of any stockyard, livestock auction market, slaughterhouse, or registered feedlot in the state. The fee is due and payable to the director secretary on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees which that are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)The fee for cattle or calves for which the fee would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) and which that are also exempt from brand inspection, shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account by the purchaser and paid to the director in the manner specified in subdivision (a). in a manner determined by the department.
(c)Any fees which that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be paid to the director secretary directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
(d)A fee shall be paid for each head of cattle or calves slaughtered in the state unless specifically exempted by Section 64691 or 64702. If the fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer and is due and payable in the manner provided in this section
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 65001) is added to Part 2 of Division 22 of the Food and Agricultural Code, to read:2.5.California Beef Commission Law1.General65001.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The production, processing, manufacture, and distribution of beef and beef products constitute a paramount industry of this state that not only provides substantial revenues for the state but also furnishes essential foods that are vital to the public health and welfare.
(b)The raising of beef and dairy cattle provides a viable living for many Californians and supports rural communities that depend on the responsible use of their adjacent range and forest lands to promote their economies. Livestock producers are stewards of the resources they manage and the existence of ranching in California serves the public by providing numerous environmental and aesthetic benefits that would otherwise be lost without the use of Californias various working landscapes.
(c)The stabilization, maintenance, and expansion of the cattle industry of California and for the expansion of state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and other cattle products are necessary to ensure the consuming public an adequate supply of foods that are indispensable in a proper human diet. The essentiality of beef and beef products in proper human nutrition and to the maintenance of a high level of public health is such as to require that the public be made thoroughly aware thereof and be protected against misrepresentation and deception by disseminating accurate and scientific information relative to the healthful qualities of beef and beef products, their various classifications, and the food values and industrial and medicinal uses thereof, the methods, care, and precautions necessary to their proper production, processing, manufacture, and distribution, and the necessary costs and expenses thereof, and the necessity and desirability on the part of the public of using and consuming beef and beef products of the highest standards of quality.
(d)The commissions form of administration created by this chapter is uniquely situated to provide those engaged in the production of cattle and beef the opportunity to avail themselves of the benefits of collective action in advertising, promotion, food safety, production research, nutrition, marketing research, the collection and dissemination of production and related statistics, and public education.
65002.The purposes of this chapter are as follows:
(a)To augment and support the work conducted by the California Beef Council.
(b)To enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets.
(c)To enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry, create a more receptive environment for California cattle producers to operate, and improve the competitiveness of California cattle producers in both the national and international marketplace.
(d)To authorize and enable the secretary and the appointed governing body of the commission to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and parties, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products, public consumption patterns and trends, sales stimulation, and consumer or other educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption.
(e)To enable the commission to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.
(f)To provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner that is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to receive a refund of those funds pursuant to Section 65076.
65003.The production of beef and beef products in this state is hereby declared to be affected with a public interest. This chapter is enacted in the exercise of the police power of this state for the purposes of protecting the health, peace, safety, and general welfare of the people of this state.
65004.No action taken by the commission, or by any individual in accordance with this chapter or with the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act (Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 16700) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), the Unfair Practices Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 17000) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade.
65005.This chapter shall be liberally construed. If any provision of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any person or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the chapter that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end the provisions of this chapter are severable.
65006.It is hereby declared as a matter of legislative determination that commission members and alternates are intended to represent and further the interest of a particular industry concerned and that this representation and furtherance is intended to serve the public interest. Accordingly, the Legislature finds that with respect to persons who are elected or appointed to the commission, the particular industry concerned is tantamount to and constitutes the public generally within the meaning of Section 87103 of the Government Code.
2.Definitions65011.Unless the context otherwise requires, the definitions in this article govern the construction of this chapter.
65012.(a)Beef means the meat of cattle and includes veal.
(b)Beef packer means a person who acquires or owns cattle for the purpose of processing into beef and beef products.
(c)Beef products means edible, industrial, and medicinal products produced in whole or in part from beef or cattle including veal products.
(d)Cattle and beef cattle are synonymous and mean bovine animals of any breed, regardless of age.
(e)Cattle feeder means a producer raising cattle in confined spaces for the purposes of finishing cattle for market.
(f)Commission means the California Beef Commission.
(g)Council means the California Beef Council.
(h)Department means the Department of Food and Agriculture.
(i)Ex officio member means a nonvoting member of the commission.
(j)Fiscal year means the same fiscal year adopted by the council.
(k)Handler means a person engaged in the marketing of beef that the handler has produced, purchased, or acquired from a producer, or is marketed on behalf of a producer, whether as the owner, agent, employee, broker, or otherwise.
(k)(l)Member means any member of the commission.
(l)(m)Producer is a person who owns or acquires ownership of beef or dairy cattle, and who, upon request, provides proof of ownership of cattle or, for purposes of voting pursuant to this chapter, has owned beef or dairy cattle within the same calendar year as the vote occurs. A person is not a producer if the persons only share in the proceeds of the sale of cattle or beef is a sales commission, handling fee, or other service fee.
(m)(n)Range cattle producer means a person who owns and raises cattle for the purpose of producing beef and beef products.
(n)(o)Secretary means the Secretary of Food and Agriculture.
3.California Beef Commission65021.There is in the state government the California Beef Commission that consists of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the secretary, each of whom shall be a producer in this state who is a range cattle producer, cattle feeder, dairy producer, or beef packer, with the exception of the public member who shall be a citizen and resident of this state.
65022.Each member and alternate may also be an appointed member or appointed alternate of the council.
65023.(a)The secretary or the secretarys designee shall serve as an ex officio member.
(b)The commission may appoint other appropriate persons as ex officio members.
65024.The secretary shall appoint to the commission at least three range cattle producers, three cattle feeders, three dairy producers, one beef packer, and one public member to represent the general public. The secretary shall use the same formula in the appointment of alternates.
65025.Except as otherwise provided in this section, the public member and the public members alternate shall have all the powers, rights, and privileges of any other member or alternate, respectively, on the commission, except that the public member or the public members alternate shall not have a vote on issues regarding the assessment established pursuant to Section 65071.
65026.(a)The terms of office of the members and alternates of the commission shall be three years. At the discretion of the secretary, the first appointments made under this chapter shall be so made that the terms of three members and the three members alternates shall expire at the end of one year, three members and the three members alternates shall expire at the end of two years, and three members and the three members alternates shall expire at the end of three years.
(b)Any vacancy that occurs during the unexpired term shall be filled by the secretary for the unexpired term from eligible nominees who have been appointed to the council. nominees. No commission member or alternate shall serve more than two consecutive three-year terms. Service as an alternate does not disqualify a person to then serve two terms as a member, and a member who was appointed for a one-year or two-year term may serve two additional three-year terms.
(c)If the secretary removes a member or alternate of the council that is also a member of the commission, the member or alternate shall be deemed removed from the commission and, upon removal, the vacancy shall be filled in the manner as provided in subdivision (a).
65027.A majority of the members of the commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business, including the election of officers. The commission may continue to transact business at a meeting at which a quorum is initially present, notwithstanding the withdrawal of members, provided any action is approved by the requisite majority of the required quorum.
65028.(a)The commission shall annually select a chairperson and vice chairperson from its membership, to serve at the commissions pleasure, who, together with three other members selected annually by the commission, shall constitute an executive committee.
(b)The executive committee shall have and exercise powers of the commission as the commission may delegate to it.
(c)At the discretion of With the approval of the council and the commission, the chairperson and vice chairperson of the commission may also serve concurrently as the chairperson and vice chairperson of the council.
65029.(a)The commission shall have two regular meetings each year at times and places determined by the commission.
(b)The times for regular meetings shall be fixed so that there is an interval of at least four months between each meeting.
(c)Unless directed by the secretary or a majority of the members of the commission, the commission shall convene the two regular meetings in conjunction with the council.
(d)The commission may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairperson or upon the written request of three members of the commission.
(e)The executive committee shall have two regular meetings each year and may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairperson or on call of a majority of the members of the executive committee.
65030.(a)Members of the commission shall be reimbursed for necessary traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties.
(b)Members of the commission shall not be reimbursed for necessary travel and other expenses for discharging similar duties that have already been reimbursed by the council.
65031.An alternate member of the commission shall sit as a regular member of the commission if the member fails for any reason to attend any meeting of the commission. An alternate member shall be compensated and reimbursed in the same manner and to the same extent as a regular member when serving and has all the powers, duties, liabilities, and immunities of the member in whose place he or she is serving, except that the alternate to the chairperson or vice chairperson shall not succeed to the functions of these offices.
65032.The secretary or the secretarys representative shall be notified and may attend each meeting of the commission. However, the secretary or the secretarys representative is not permitted to attend an executive session of the commission called for the purpose of discussing potential or actual litigation against the department.
65033.No member or alternate of the commission shall receive a salary.
65034.All funds received by any person from the assessments levied under this chapter or otherwise received by the commission shall be deposited in banks designated by the commission and shall be disbursed by order of the commission through an agent or agents as it may designate for that purpose. A private agent or agents, other than the department, shall be bonded by a fidelity bond, executed by a surety company authorized to transact business in this state, in favor of the commission, in an amount of not less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
65035.All funds received by the commission shall be deposited in bank accounts created by the commission separate from those accounts established by the council containing funds received pursuant to Section 64691. Funds collected by the commission pursuant to Section 65071 shall not be commingled with funds collected by the council pursuant to Section 64691.
65036.The state is not liable for the acts of the commission or its contracts. Payments of all claims arising by reason of the administration of this chapter or acts of the commission are limited to the funds collected by the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is personally liable for the contracts of the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually in any way to any other person for errors in judgment, mistakes, or other acts, either of commission or omission, as principal, agent, or employee, except for his or her own individual acts of dishonesty or crime. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually for any act or omission of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is liable for the default of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof.
65037.The commission may sue and be sued and enter into contracts. Copies of its proceedings, records, and acts, when authenticated, shall be admissible in evidence in all courts of the state and shall be prima facie evidence of the truth of all statements therein.
4.Powers and Duties65041.The powers and duties of the commission shall include, but are not limited to, all of those contained in this article.
65042.The commission may adopt and from time to time alter, rescind, modify, and amend all proper and necessary bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders in accordance with commission procedures for purposes of carrying out this chapter, including rules for appeals from any bylaw, rule, regulation, operating procedure, or order of the commission.
65043.The commission may administer and enforce this chapter and do and perform all acts and exercise all powers incidental to, or in connection with, or deemed reasonably necessary to, promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products.
65043.5.If the commission and the council determine that a project is of mutual benefit and consistent with state and federal laws governing the council, the project may be jointly funded by the commission and the council, subject to approval by the secretary.
65044.(a)The commission may employ a person to serve at the pleasure of the commission as the executive director of the commission, and other personnel, including legal counsel of its choice, necessary to carry out this chapter. If any person employed by the commission engages in any conduct that the secretary determines is not in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter, the secretary shall notify the commission of the conduct and request that corrective and, if appropriate, disciplinary action be taken by the commission. If the commission fails or refuses to correct the situation or to take disciplinary action satisfactory to the secretary, the secretary may suspend or discharge the person.
(b)At the discretion of With the approval of the council and the commission, the executive director of the commission may be the same as the executive director of the council.
(c)The commission may retain additional staff or agents of the commission to discharge the duties outlined in this chapter.
(d)At the discretion of With the approval of the council and the commission, staff may be the same as those employed by the council.
(e)Agents serving on behalf of the commission to discharge the duties of the commission outlined in this chapter are not required to be parties also serving as agents of the council.
65045.If directed by a majority of commission members and approval is granted by the secretary, the commission may administer any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industries. industry, except administering funds and performing acts under the jurisdiction of the council.
65046.The commission may appoint committees composed of members, alternates, and nonmembers not serving with the commission in any official capacity to advise the commission in carrying out this chapter.
65047.The commission shall approve the compensation for the executive director and any agents or contractors of the commission.
65048.(a)The commission may establish offices and incur expenses, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities, develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property, including real estate for the purpose of housing the operations of the commission, and borrow funds in advance of receipt of assessments as may be necessary in the opinion of the commission for the proper administration and enforcement of this chapter and the performance of its duties.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, offices and physical property utilized by the commission may be the same as those utilized by the council.
(c)The commission may offset expenses incurred by the council to establish offices, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities, and develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property. property, so long as the expenses are consistent with state and federal law governing the council.
65049.The commission shall keep books, records, and accounts of all its transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. Those books, records, and accounts shall at all times be open to inspection and audit by the secretary. The commission shall be subject to an annual audit by an auditing firm selected by the commission with the concurrence of the secretary. The audit shall be made a part of an annual report to be posted on the commissions Internet Web site and submitted to the department. In addition, the secretary may, as he or she determines necessary, conduct, or cause to be conducted, a fiscal and compliance audit of the commission.
65050.The commission shall be charged with exercising any and all necessary duties to accomplish the objectives outlined in this chapter.
65051.The commission may accept contributions from private, state, grants from state and federal entities to carry out the duties authorized by this chapter.
65052.The commission may collect information about California beef and dairy production and publish and distribute, without charge, a bulletin or other communication to all eligible producers.
65053.The commission shall establish an assessment rate to defray operating costs of the commission.65054.(a)The commission shall establish an annual budget according to generally accepted accounting practices. The commission shall prepare annually summarized statements of the activities in which it has been engaged in the previous annual period, and of the activities in which it proposes to engage in the ensuing annual period. The statements shall be made available to all eligible producers at their request.
(b)Before the adoption of the annual budget, the commission shall submit the proposed annual budget and its statement of contemplated activities to the secretary for his or her concurrence.
(c)The annual budget and statement of contemplated activities shall be concurred in by the secretary prior to disbursement of funds.
65055.When the secretary is required to concur in a decision of the commission, the secretary shall give his or her response to the commission within 15 working days from notification of the decision. The secretary shall set forth in writing with specificity the reasons for any refusal to concur. The secretarys response may be a requirement that additional information be provided.
65056.The commission shall reimburse the secretary for all expenditures incurred by the secretary in carrying out his or her duties and responsibilities pursuant to this chapter. However, a court may, if it finds that the secretary acted arbitrarily or capriciously in restricting the activities or functions of the commission, relieve the commission of the responsibility for payment of the secretarys legal costs with regard to that action.
65057.(a)The secretary may require the commission to correct or cease any existing activity or function that is determined by the secretary not to be in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter.
(b)If the commission refuses or fails to cease those activities or functions or to make the corrections as required by the secretary, the secretary may, upon written notice, suspend all or a portion of the activities or functions of the commission until the time that the cessation or correction of activities or functions as required by the secretary has been accomplished by the commission.
(c)Actions of the commission in violation of the written notice are without legal force or effect. The secretary, to the extent feasible, shall issue the written notice before the commission entering into any contractual relationship affecting the existing or proposed activities or functions that are the subject of the written notice.
(d)Upon service of the written notice, the secretary shall notify the commission in writing of the specific acts that the secretary determines are not in the public interest or are in violation of this chapter, his or her reasons for requiring a cessation or correction of specific existing or proposed activities or functions, and recommendations that will make the activities or functions acceptable.
65058.The secretary shall only prohibit actions by the commission that are inconsistent with the powers and duties provided to the commission by this chapter, in violation of this chapter, or not in the public interest.
65059.The commission and the secretary shall keep confidential and shall not disclose, except when required by court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding, all lists in their possession of persons subject to this chapter. However, the commission shall establish procedures to provide access to communication with other producers and handlers regarding noncommercial matters affecting the commission and persons subject to its jurisdiction. The access shall not include the actual release of the list of the names and addresses of producers and packers in the possession of the commission or the secretary. In addition, notwithstanding any other law, all proprietary or trade secret information developed or gathered pursuant to this chapter, except as provided in Section 65077, including, but not limited to, names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle or beef produced, bought, or sold, prices paid, and the products of research obtained by the commission, or by the department on behalf of the commission, from any source is confidential and shall not be considered a public record as that term is defined in Section 6252 of the Government Code.
65060.The commission may investigate and prosecute civil violations of this chapter.
5.Implementation and Suspension of Operations65061.(a)On or before June 1, 2018, the Bureau of Livestock Identification and the council shall submit to the secretary for review a list of producers who have sold or owned cattle in the last calendar year and are eligible to vote.
(b)The secretary may require auction markets and packers to submit the names and mailing addresses of all producers from whom they acquired cattle in the most recently completed fiscal year. The request for information shall be in writing and shall be filed within 10 days following receipt of the request.
(c)Any producer eligible to vote whose name does not appear on the appropriate list may have his or her name placed on the list by filing with the secretary a signed statement identifying himself or herself as a person eligible to vote. Failure to be on the list does not exempt the person from paying fees and does not invalidate any votes conducted pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Any producer eligible to vote may contact those on the list regarding the referendum in a form and manner prescribed by the secretary if all expenses associated with those contacts are paid in advance.
(e)The secretary shall determine which producers are eligible to vote consistent with the definition of producer in subdivision (m) of Section 65012.
65062.This chapter, except as necessary to conduct an implementation referendum vote, shall not become operative until the secretary finds that a majority of producers participating in the referendum approve the referendum in an initial referendum vote conducted by the secretary on or before June 1, 2019.
65063.The implementation referendum shall advertise the amount to be assessed and declare that the assessment shall be a mandatory fee. The implementation referendum shall also advertise that the commission will accept petitions to refund the fee for any producer subject to this chapter pursuant to Section 65076.
65064.The secretary shall establish a period in which to conduct the referendum, that shall not be more than 60 days in duration, and may prescribe additional procedures necessary to conduct the referendum.
65065.Nonreceipt of a ballot by an eligible handler or producer shall not invalidate a referendum.
65066.If the secretary finds that a favorable majority vote has been given, the secretary shall certify and give notice of the favorable majority vote to all producers whose names and addresses are on file with the secretary.
65067.If the secretary finds that a favorable majority vote has not been given for an initial referendum, the secretary shall certify and declare all provisions of this chapter inoperative. The secretary may conduct other implementation referendum votes one year two years or more after the previous vote has been taken upon the petition of a proponent of the commission.
65068.(a)Before the referendum vote conducted by the secretary pursuant to this article, a proponent of the establishment of the commission shall deposit with the secretary the amount that the secretary deems necessary to defray the expenses of analyzing the proposed commission and certifying the necessary list of producers submitted by the council and conducting the vote.
(b)Any funds not used in conducting the referendum established by this article shall be returned to the proponents of the commission who deposited the funds with the secretary.
(c)Upon establishment of the commission, the commission may reimburse the proponents of the commission for any funds deposited with the secretary that were used in carrying out this article, and for any legal expenses and costs incurred in establishing the commission.
65069.(a)A referendum among the states producers to terminate the commission shall be conducted by the secretary if the secretary receives a petition for a referendum signed by three thousand eligible producers.(b)If upon the count of the ballots the secretary finds that 30 percent, or more, of all producers established by the secretary have voted and a majority of the total number of producers voting have assented to the discontinuance and termination of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and declare the existence of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter discontinued and terminated at the end of the fiscal year in which the referendum is conducted.(c)On the expiration of this chapter pursuant to this article, the commission shall remain in existence for the purpose of furnishing the secretary with a complete record of its outstanding financial obligations, accrued and to accrue. The secretary shall pay from the money deposited and disbursed any outstanding obligations and any obligations incurred by the secretary and the department under the terms and provisions of this section. Any money that remains shall be retained by the secretary to defray the expenses of formulation, issuance, administration, or enforcement of any subsequent program for beef promotion. If no such program is undertaken within a period of three years from the date of termination of this chapter, the money shall be used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.(d)If upon a count of the ballots the secretary finds that less than 60 percent of the total number of producers voting have assented to discontinuance and termination, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and the commission and programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter shall continue to remain in full force and effect.65069.(a)Five years after implementation of this chapter, the secretary shall hold a public hearing after providing proper notice to persons subject to this chapter and any other persons or entities who have requested, in writing, notice of the hearing to determine whether the operation of this chapter should be continued. If, after the hearing, the secretary finds that a substantial question exists among the producers assessed under this chapter as to whether the operation of this chapter should be continued, the secretary shall conduct a reapproval referendum to be conducted among producers to determine whether the operation of this chapter shall be reapproved and continue in effect.
(b)If the secretary finds, after conducting a hearing that no substantial question exists or if a reapproval referendum is required, that a majority of eligible producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of continuing the operation of this chapter, the secretary shall certify the vote and this chapter shall remain operative. If the secretary finds that a majority vote has not been given, the secretary shall certify the vote and declare the operation of this chapter suspended and the operations of the commission concluded and funds distributed in the manner provided in subdivision (c). A bond or security shall not be required for the referendum.
(c)On the expiration of this chapter pursuant to this article, the commission shall remain in existence for the purpose of furnishing the secretary with a complete record of its outstanding financial obligations, accrued and to accrue. The secretary shall pay from the money deposited and disbursed any outstanding obligations and any obligations incurred by the secretary and the department under the terms and provisions of this section. Any money that remains shall be retained by the secretary to defray the expenses of formulation, issuance, administration, or enforcement of any subsequent program for beef promotion. If no such program is undertaken within a period of three years from the date of termination of this chapter, the money shall be used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.
(d)Following a hearing and favorable referendum, if required, the process specified in this section shall be conducted by the secretary every five years between July 1 and June 30 of the following year.
6.Financial Provisions65071.(a)In order to carry out the programs and administer the activities that are conducted pursuant to this chapter, an assessment of one dollar ($1) per head shall be paid on each sale of cattle and calves. The assessment shall be charged on all cattle and calves, except the following:
(1)Hides, skins, or the offal of animals.
(2)Any cattle that are transported for purposes other than for sale or slaughter and without a change of ownership.
(3)Any cattle custom slaughtered exclusively for the owner, members of the owners household, or the owners nonpaying guests or employees.
(4)Any cattle weighing less than 200 pounds.
(b)The assessment shall not be charged or collected more than once from each owner upon the same animal.
65072.(a)Each person who is required to pay or collect the assessment shall maintain a complete and accurate record of all transactions subject to assessments under this chapter. These records shall contain information required by the secretary relating to the payment or collection of assessments, shall be preserved for a period of two years, and shall be offered and submitted for inspection and audit at any reasonable time upon written demand by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent.
(b)All information obtained by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent from any inspection or audit of records shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required in a judicial proceeding.
65073.An assessment greater than one dollar ($1) per head on cattle and calves prescribed by Section 65071 shall not be charged pursuant to that section unless the greater assessment is approved by the producers in this state, by a referendum called for by a proponent of the commission to be submitted to the producers by the secretary. The secretary shall find that the producers have approved a greater assessment if the secretary finds that a majority of the producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of charging the greater assessment. Ballots shall be provided to producers from a list provided by the council and approved by the secretary, and to other producers who request a ballot that provide proof of eligibility.65074.(a)The assessment for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The assessment shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the commission by each operator of a stockyard, livestock auction market, or slaughter facility. The assessment is due and payable to the commission on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Assessments that are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)The assessment for cattle or calves for which the assessment would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) and that are also exempt from a brand inspection shall be charged and collected from the seller and paid to the commission in a manner determined by the department.
(c)Any assessment that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be paid to the commission directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
65075.The assessments that are collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification pursuant to this article shall be forwarded to the secretary at the same time and in the same manner as the inspection fees that are provided for in Article 9 (commencing with Section 21281) of Chapter 6 of Division 10. The secretary shall reimburse, from any money that is collected pursuant to this section, the Bureau of Livestock Identification and any other bureaus or agencies of the state for any additional expenses that are incurred by them in the administration or enforcement of this chapter.
65076.Any person who is subject to the assessment that is required by Section 65071 may obtain a refund of the assessment collected by submitting to the commission a claim for a refund. The claim shall be submitted in writing by mail, facsimile, electronic mail, or a refund request form through the departments Internet Web site within 90 days after the date of the brand inspection or the date of payment of the assessment to the secretary, assessment, whichever date is later. The claim for refund shall contain necessary information as the department may require but may not place conditions on the issuance of the refund. The refund of an assessment shall be made by the commission within 60 days of the date on which the refund request is received. The commission or the department may not place conditions on the issuance of the refund except for requiring the claim for the refund to demonstrate the fee has been paid. The secretary, department, commission, or producers, by referendum, shall not limit or inhibit a refund under this section for a person that has paid the assessment required by Section 65071.
65077.(a)All proprietary information obtained or developed pursuant to this article by the commission or the secretary from any source, including, but not limited to, the names and addresses of producers, producers and the amounts of individual refunds or the identify of a person that received a refund pursuant to Section 65076, is confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required by a court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding. Data that is aggregated from proprietary information information, including the total amount refunded by the commission annually, is not confidential, and may be disclosed, only if the data does not disclose proprietary information of an individual producer and the data cannot be used to identify an individual producer.
65078.An assessment that is levied pursuant to this chapter is a personal debt of the assessed person.
7.Actions and Penalties65081.A civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) may be levied by the commission upon a person who does any of the following:
(a)Willfully renders or furnishes a false report, statement, or record required by the commission or in any way affects the purchase or acquisition of cattle in order to avoid payment of fees.
(b)Fails to render or furnish a report, statement, or record required by the commission.
(c)When engaged in the purchase or acquisition of cattle for finishing or processing, fails or refuses to furnish to the commission or its duly authorized agents, upon request, information concerning the name and address of the persons from whom he or she has received cattle and the quantity received.
(d)Secrete, destroy, or alter records required to be kept by this chapter.
65082.The commission shall establish procedures for the purpose of according individuals aggrieved by its actions or determinations an informal hearing before the commission, or before a committee of the commission designated for this purpose. Appeals from decisions of the commission may be made to the secretary. The determination of the secretary shall be subject to judicial review upon petition filed with the appropriate superior court.
65083.(a)The commission may commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law or equity for the collection of fees and civil penalties and for obtaining injunctive relief or specific performance relating to this chapter and the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter. A court shall issue to the commission any requested writ of attachment or injunctive relief upon a prima facie showing by verified complaint that a named defendant has violated this chapter or any other rule or regulation of the commission, including, but not limited to, the nonpayment of fees. No bond shall be required to be posted by the commission as a condition for the issuance of any writ of attachment or injunctive relief.
(b)A writ of attachment shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 485.010) of Title 6.5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing specified in Section 485.010 is not required. Injunctive relief shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 525) of Title 7 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing of irreparable harm or of inadequate remedy at law specified by Section 526 or 527 is not required.
(c)Upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment.
(d)Upon a favorable judgment for the commission, the court may order that the commission be reimbursed for reasonable attorneys fees and other actual related costs. Venue for these actions is at the domicile or place of business of the defendant or in the county of the principal office of the commission. The commission may be sued only in the county of its principal office.
65084.Any action by the commission for any penalty or other remedy that is prescribed under this chapter shall be commenced within three years from the date of discovery of the alleged violation. Any action against the commission by any person shall be commenced within three years from the date of the alleged violation.
65085.The commission is not required to allege or prove that an adequate remedy at law does not exist in any action brought under this chapter.
65086.If any part of this chapter is for any reason held unconstitutional or invalid as applied to any person or as applied under certain circumstances, that decision shall not affect the remaining portions of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any other persons or under any other circumstance.
65087.The termination of this chapter shall not affect or waive any right, duty, obligation, or liability that has arisen or that may thereafter arise in connection with this chapter, release or extinguish any violation of this chapter, or affect or impair any right or remedies of the commission with respect to any violation.
65088.When the producer is a corporation or a limited liability company, all of the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this chapter shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 3 2 of this act, which adds Sections 65059, 65072, and 65077 of to the Food and Agricultural Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the personal and financial information of a person subject to the act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
(a)The fees required pursuant to Section 64691 shall be due and payable as follows:
(a)(1)The fee for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the director secretary by each operator of any stockyard, livestock auction market, slaughterhouse, or registered feedlot in the state. The fee is due and payable to the director secretary on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees which are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision paragraph shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)(2)The fee for cattle or calves for which the fee would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) paragraph (1) and which that are also exempt from brand inspection, inspection shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account by the purchaser and paid to the director secretary in the manner specified in subdivision (a). paragraph (1).
(c)(3)Any fees which that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) paragraph (1) or (2) shall be paid to the director secretary directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
(d)(4)A fee shall be paid for each head of cattle or calves slaughtered in the state unless specifically exempted by Section 64691 or 64702. If the fee is not deducted from the seller it shall be paid by the purchaser or slaughterer and is due and payable in the manner provided in this section
(b)This section shall become inoperative and is repealed on the date on which Section 64691.7, as added by Assembly Bill 243 of the 201718 Regular Session of the Legislature, becomes operative.
SEC. 2.Section 64691.7 is added to the Food and Agricultural Code, to read:64691.7.(a)The fees required pursuant to Section 64691 shall be due and payable as follows:
(1)The fee for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the secretary by each operator of any stockyard, livestock auction market, slaughterhouse, or registered feedlot in the state. The fee is due and payable to the secretary on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees which are not collected in the manner provided in this paragraph shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(2)The fee for cattle or calves for which the fee would not otherwise be collected pursuant to paragraph (1) and that are also exempt from brand inspection shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account by the purchaser and paid to the secretary in the manner determined by the department.
(3)Any fees that are not collected in the manner specified in paragraph (1) or (2) shall be paid to the secretary directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
(4)A fee shall be paid for each head of cattle or calves slaughtered in the state unless specifically exempted by Section 64691 or 64702.
(b)This section shall become operative only if an implementation referendum pursuant to Section 65062 is conducted and Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 65001) becomes operative.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 65001) is added to Part 2 of Division 22 of the Food and Agricultural Code, to read:2.5.California Beef Commission Law1.General65001.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The production, processing, manufacture, and distribution of beef and beef products constitute a paramount industry of this state that not only provides substantial revenues for the state but also furnishes essential foods that are vital to the public health and welfare.
(b)The raising of beef and dairy cattle provides a viable living for many Californians and supports rural communities that depend on the responsible use of their adjacent range and forest lands to promote their economies. Livestock producers are stewards of the resources they manage and the existence of ranching in California serves the public by providing numerous environmental and aesthetic benefits that would otherwise be lost without the use of Californias various working landscapes.
(c)The stabilization, maintenance, and expansion of the cattle industry of California and for the expansion of state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and other cattle products are necessary to ensure the consuming public an adequate supply of foods that are indispensable in a proper human diet. The essentiality of beef and beef products in proper human nutrition and to the maintenance of a high level of public health is such as to require that the public be made thoroughly aware thereof and be protected against misrepresentation and deception by disseminating accurate and scientific information relative to the healthful qualities of beef and beef products, their various classifications, and the food values and industrial and medicinal uses thereof, the methods, care care, and precautions necessary to their proper production, processing, manufacture, and distribution, and the necessary costs and expenses thereof, and the necessity and desirability on the part of the public of using and consuming beef and beef products of the highest standards of quality.
(d)The commissions form of administration created by this chapter is uniquely situated to provide those engaged in the production of cattle and beef the opportunity to avail themselves of the benefits of collective action in advertising, promotion, food safety, production research, nutrition, marketing research, the collection and dissemination of production and related statistics, and public education.
65002.The purposes of this chapter are as follows:
(a)To augment and support the work conducted by the California Beef Council.
(b)To enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets.
(c)To enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry, create a more receptive environment for California cattle producers to operate, and improve the competitiveness of California cattle producers in both the national and international marketplace.
(d)To authorize and enable the secretary and the appointed governing body of the commission to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and parties, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products, public consumption patterns and trends, sales stimulation, and consumer or other educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption.
(e)To enable the commission to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.
(f)To provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner that is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to receive a refund of those funds pursuant to Section 65076.
65003.The production of beef and beef products in this state is hereby declared to be affected with a public interest. This chapter is enacted in the exercise of the police power of this state for the purposes of protecting the health, peace, safety, and general welfare of the people of this state.
65004.No action taken by the commission, or by any individual in accordance with this chapter or with the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act (Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 16700) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), the Unfair Practices Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 17000) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade.
65005.This chapter shall be liberally construed. If any provision of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any person or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the chapter that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end the provisions of this chapter are severable.
65006.It is hereby declared as a matter of legislative determination that commission members and alternates are intended to represent and further the interest of a particular industry concerned and that this representation and furtherance is intended to serve the public interest. Accordingly, the Legislature finds that with respect to persons who are elected or appointed to the commission, the particular industry concerned is tantamount to and constitutes the public generally within the meaning of Section 87103 of the Government Code.
2.Definitions65011.Unless the context otherwise requires, the definitions in this article govern the construction of this chapter.
65012.(a)Beef means the meat of cattle and includes veal.
(b)Beef packer means a person who acquires or owns cattle for the purpose of processing into beef and beef products.
(c)Beef products means edible, industrial, and medicinal products produced in whole or in part from beef or cattle including veal products.
(d)Cattle and beef cattle are synonymous and mean bovine animals of any breed, regardless of age.
(e)Cattle feeder means a producer raising cattle in confined spaces for the purposes of finishing cattle for market.
(f)Commission means the California Beef Commission.
(g)Council means the California Beef Council.
(h)Department means the Department of Food and Agriculture.
(i)Ex officio member means a nonvoting member of the commission.
(j)Fiscal year means the same fiscal year adopted by the council.
(k)Member means any member of the commission.
(l)Producer is a person who owns or acquires ownership of beef or dairy cattle, and who, upon request, provides proof of ownership of cattle or, for purposes of voting pursuant to this chapter, has owned beef or dairy cattle within the same calendar year as the vote occurs. A person is not a producer if the persons only share in the proceeds of the sale of cattle or beef is a sales commission, handling fee, or other service fee.
(m)Range cattle producer means a person who owns and raises cattle for the purpose of producing beef and beef products.
(n)Secretary means the Secretary of Food and Agriculture.
3.California Beef Commission65021.There is in the state government the California Beef Commission that consists of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the secretary, all each of whom shall be a producer in this state who is a range cattleman, cattle producer, cattle feeder, dairyman, dairy producer, or beef packer, with the exception of the public member who shall be a citizen and resident of this state.
65022.Each member and alternate shall may also be an appointed member or appointed alternate of the council.
65023.(a)The secretary or his or her the secretarys designee shall serve as an ex officio member.
(b)The commission may appoint other appropriate persons as ex officio members.
65024.The secretary shall appoint to the commission at least three range cattlemen, cattle producers, three cattle feeders, three dairymen, dairy producers, one beef packer, and one public member to represent the general public. The secretary shall use the same formula in the appointment of alternates.
65025.Except as otherwise provided in this section, the public member and his or her the public members alternate shall have all the powers, rights, and privileges of any other member or alternate, respectively, on the commission, except that the public member or his or her the public members alternate shall not have a vote on issues regarding the fees assessment established pursuant to Section 65071.
65026.(a)The terms of office of the members and alternates of the commission shall be three years. At the discretion of the secretary, the first appointments made under this chapter shall be so made that the terms of three members and their the three members alternates shall expire at the end of one year, three members and their the three members alternates shall expire at the end of two years, and three members and their the three members alternates shall expire at the end of three years.
(b)Any vacancy that occurs during the unexpired term shall be filled by the secretary for the unexpired term from eligible nominees who have been appointed to the council. No commission member or alternate shall serve more than two consecutive three-year terms. Service as an alternate does not disqualify a person to then serve two terms as a member, and a member who was appointed for a one-year or two-year term may serve two additional three-year terms.
(c)If the secretary removes a member or alternate of the council that is also a member of the commission, the member or alternate shall be deemed removed from the commission and, upon removal, the vacancy shall be filled in the manner as provided in subdivision (a).
65027.A majority of the members of the commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business, including the election of officers. The commission may continue to transact business at a meeting at which a quorum is initially present, notwithstanding the withdrawal of members, provided any action is approved by the requisite majority of the required quorum.
65028.(a)The commission shall annually select a chairman chairperson and vice chairman chairperson from its membership, to serve at the commissions pleasure, who, together with three other members selected annually by the commission, shall constitute an executive committee.
(b)The executive committee shall have and exercise powers of the commission as the commission may delegate to it.
(c)At the discretion of the commission, the chairman chairperson and vice chairman chairperson of the commission may also serve concurrently as the chairman chairperson and vice chairman chairperson of the council.
65029.(a)The commission shall have two regular meetings each year at times and places determined by the commission.
(b)The times for regular meetings shall be fixed so that there is an interval of at least four months between each meeting.
(c)Unless directed by the secretary or a majority of the members of the commission, the commission shall convene the two regular meetings in conjunction with the council.
(d)The commission may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairman chairperson or upon the written request of three members of the commission.
(e)The executive committee shall have two regular meetings each year and may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairman chairperson or on call of a majority of the members of the executive committee.
65030.(a)Members of the commission shall be reimbursed for necessary traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties.
(b)Members of the commission shall not be reimbursed for necessary travel and other expenses for discharging similar duties that have already been reimbursed by the council.
65031.An alternate member of the commission shall sit as a regular member of the commission if the member fails for any reason to attend any meeting of the commission. An alternate member shall be compensated and reimbursed in the same manner and to the same extent as a regular member when so serving and when so serving has all the powers, duties, liabilities, and immunities of the member in whose place he or she is serving, except that the alternate to the chairman chairperson or vice chairman chairperson shall not succeed to the functions of these offices.
65032.The secretary or his or her the secretarys representative shall be notified and may attend each meeting of the commission. However, the secretary or his or her the secretarys representative is not permitted to attend an executive session of the commission called for the purpose of discussing potential or actual litigation against the department.
65033.No member or alternate of the commission shall receive a salary.
65034.All funds received by any person from the assessments levied under this chapter or otherwise received by the commission shall be deposited in banks designated by the commission and shall be disbursed by order of the commission through an agent or agents as it may designate for that purpose. A private agent or agents, other than the department, shall be bonded by a fidelity bond, executed by a surety company authorized to transact business in this state, in favor of the commission, in an amount of not less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
65035.All funds received by the commission shall be deposited in bank accounts created by the commission separate from those accounts established by the council containing funds received pursuant to Section 64691. Funds collected by the commission pursuant to Section 65071 shall not be commingled with funds collected by the council pursuant to Section 64691.
65036.The state is not liable for the acts of the commission or its contracts. Payments of all claims arising by reason of the administration of this chapter or acts of the commission are limited to the funds collected by the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is personally liable for the contracts of the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually in any way to any other person for errors in judgment, mistakes, or other acts, either of commission or omission, as principal, agent, or employee, except for his or her own individual acts of dishonesty or crime. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually for any act or omission of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is liable for the default of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof.
65037.The commission may sue and be sued and enter into contracts. Copies of its proceedings, records, and acts, when authenticated, shall be admissible in evidence in all courts of the state and shall be prima facie evidence of the truth of all statements therein.
4.Powers and Duties65041.The powers and duties of the commission shall include, but are not limited to, all of those contained in this article.
65042.The commission may adopt and from time to time alter, rescind, modify, and amend all proper and necessary bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders in accordance with commission procedures for purposes of carrying out this chapter, including rules for appeals from any bylaw, rule, regulation, operating procedure, or order of the commission.
65043.The commission may administer and enforce this chapter and do and perform all acts and exercise all powers incidental to, or in connection with, or deemed reasonably necessary to, promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products.
65044.(a)The commission may employ a person to serve at the pleasure of the commission as the executive director of the commission, and other personnel, including legal counsel of its choice, necessary to carry out this chapter. If any person employed by the commission engages in any conduct that the secretary determines is not in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter, the secretary shall notify the commission of the conduct and request that corrective and, if appropriate, disciplinary action, action be taken by the commission. If the commission fails or refuses to correct the situation or to take disciplinary action satisfactory to the secretary, the secretary may suspend or discharge the person.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, the executive director of the commission may be the same as the executive director of the council.
(c)The commission may retain additional staff or agents of the commission to discharge the duties outlined in this chapter.
(d)At the discretion of the commission, staff may be the same as those employed by the council.
(e)Agents serving on behalf of the commission to discharge the duties of the commission outlined in this chapter are not required to be parties also serving as agents of the council.
65045.If directed by a majority of commission members and approval is granted by the secretary, the commission may administer any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industries.
65046.The commission may appoint committees composed of both members, alternates alternates, and nonmembers not serving with the commission in any official capacity to advise the commission in carrying out this chapter.
65047.The commission shall approve the compensation for all employees and agents the executive director and any agents or contractors of the commission.
65048.(a)The commission may establish offices and incur expenses, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities, develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property, including real estate for the purpose of housing the operations of the commission, and borrow funds in advance of receipt of assessments as may be necessary in the opinion of the commission for the proper administration and enforcement of this chapter and the performance of its duties.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, offices and physical property utilized by the commission may be the same as those utilized by the council.
(c)The commission may offset expenses incurred by the council to establish offices, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities liabilities, and develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property.
65049.The commission shall keep books, records, and accounts of all its transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. Those books, records, and accounts shall at all times be open to inspection and audit by the secretary. The commission shall be subject to an annual audit by an auditing firm selected by the commission with the concurrence of the secretary. The audit shall be made a part of an annual report to be posted on the commissions Internet Web site and submitted to the department. In addition, the secretary may, as he or she determines necessary, conduct, or cause to be conducted, a fiscal and compliance audit of the commission.
65050.The commission shall be charged with exercising any and all necessary duties to accomplish the objectives outlined in this chapter.
65051.The commission may accept contributions from private, state, and federal entities to carry out the duties authorized by this chapter.
65052.The commission may collect information about California beef and dairy production and publish and distribute distribute, without charge, a bulletin or other communication to all eligible producers.
65053.The commission shall establish an assessment rate to defray operating costs of the commission.
65054.(a)The commission shall establish an annual budget according to generally accepted accounting practices. The commission shall prepare annually summarized statements of the activities in which it has been engaged in the previous annual period, and of the activities in which it proposes to engage in the ensuing annual period. The statements shall be made available to all eligible producers at their request.
(b)Prior to Before the adoption of the annual budget, the commission shall submit the proposed annual budget and its statement of contemplated activities to the secretary for his or her concurrence.
(c)The annual budget and statement of contemplated activities shall be concurred in by the secretary prior to disbursement of funds.
65055.When the secretary is required to concur in a decision of the commission, the secretary shall give his or her response to the commission within 15 working days from notification of the decision. The secretary shall set forth in writing with specificity the reasons for any refusal to concur. The secretarys response may be a requirement that additional information be provided.
65056.The commission shall reimburse the secretary for all expenditures incurred by the secretary in carrying out his or her duties and responsibilities pursuant to this chapter. However, a court may, if it finds that the secretary acted arbitrarily or capriciously in restricting the activities or functions of the commission, relieve the commission of the responsibility for payment of the secretarys legal costs with regard to that action.
65057.(a)The secretary may require the commission to correct or cease any existing activity or function that is determined by the secretary not to be in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter.
(b)If the commission refuses or fails to cease those activities or functions or to make the corrections as required by the secretary, the secretary may, upon written notice, suspend all or a portion of the activities or functions of the commission until the time that the cessation or correction of activities or functions as required by the secretary has been accomplished by the commission.
(c)Actions of the commission in violation of the written notice are without legal force or effect. The secretary, to the extent feasible, shall issue the written notice before the commission entering into any contractual relationship affecting the existing or proposed activities or functions that are the subject of the written notice.
(d)Upon service of the written notice, the secretary shall notify the commission in writing of the specific acts that the secretary determines are not in the public interest or are in violation of this chapter, his or her reasons for requiring a cessation or correction of specific existing or proposed activities or functions, and recommendations that will make the activities or functions acceptable.
65058.The secretary shall not only prohibit actions by the commission that are consistent inconsistent with the powers and duties provided to the commission by this chapter. chapter, in violation of this chapter, or not in the public interest.
65059.The commission and the secretary shall keep confidential and shall not disclose, except when required by court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding, all lists in their possession of persons subject to this chapter. However, the commission shall establish procedures to provide access to communication with other producers and handlers regarding noncommercial matters affecting the commission and persons subject to its jurisdiction. The access shall not include the actual release of the list of the names and addresses of producers and packers in the possession of the commission or the secretary. In addition, notwithstanding any other law, all proprietary or trade secret information developed or gathered pursuant to this chapter, except as provided in Section 65077, including, but not limited to, names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle and or beef produced, bought bought, or sold, prices paid, and the products of research obtained by the commission, or by the department on behalf of the commission, from any source is confidential and shall not be considered a public record as that term is defined in Section 6252 of the Government Code.
65060.The commission may investigate and prosecute civil violations of this chapter.
5.Implementation and Suspension of Operations65061.(a)On or before June 1, 2018, the council shall submit to the secretary for review a list of producers eligible to vote.
(b)The secretary may require auction markets and packers to submit the names and mailing addresses of all producers from whom they acquired cattle in the most recently completed fiscal year. The request for information shall be in writing and shall be filed within 10 days following receipt of the request.
(c)Any producer eligible to vote whose name does not appear on the appropriate list may have his or her name placed on the list by filing with the secretary a signed statement, identify statement identifying himself or herself as a person eligible to vote. Failure to be on the list does not exempt the person from paying fees and does not invalidate any votes conducted pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Any producer eligible to vote may contact those on the list regarding the referendum in a form and manner prescribed by the secretary if all expenses associated with those contacts are paid in advance.
65062.This chapter, except as necessary to conduct an implementation referendum vote, shall not become operative until the secretary finds that a majority of producers participating in the referendum approve the referendum in an initial referendum vote conducted by the secretary on or before June 1, 2019.
65063.The implementation referendum shall advertise the amount to be assessed and declare that the assessment shall be a mandatory fee. The implementation referendum shall also advertise that the commission will accept petitions to refund the fee for any producer subject to this chapter pursuant to Section 65076.
65064.The secretary shall establish a period in which to conduct the referendum, that shall not be more than 60 days in duration, and may prescribe additional procedures necessary to conduct the referendum.
65065.Nonreceipt of a ballot by an eligible handler or producer shall not invalidate a referendum.
65066.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has been given, the secretary shall certify and give notice of the favorable vote to all producers whose names and addresses are on file with the secretary.
65067.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has not been given for an initial referendum, the secretary shall certify and declare all provisions of this chapter inoperative. The secretary may conduct other implementation referendum votes one year or more after the previous vote has been taken upon the petition of a proponent of the commission.
65068.(a)Before the referendum vote conducted by the secretary pursuant to this article, a proponent of the establishment of the commission shall deposit with the secretary the amount that the secretary deems necessary to defray the expenses of analyzing the proposed commission and certifying the necessary list of producers submitted by the council and conducting the vote.
(b)Any funds not used in conducting the referendum established by this article shall be returned to the proponents of the commission who deposited the funds with the secretary.
(c)Upon establishment of the commission, the commission may reimburse the proponents of the commission for any funds deposited with the secretary that were used in carrying out this article, and for any legal expenses and costs incurred in establishing the commission.
65069.(a)A referendum among the states producers to terminate the commission shall be conducted by the secretary if the secretary receives a petition for a referendum signed by three thousand eligible producers.
(b)If upon the count of the ballots the secretary finds that 30 percent, or more, of all producers established by the secretary have voted and that 60 percent, or more, a majority of the total number of producers voting have assented to the discontinuance and termination of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and declare the existence of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter discontinued and terminated at the end of the fiscal year in which the referendum is conducted.
(c)On the expiration of this chapter pursuant to this article, the commission shall remain in existence for the purpose of furnishing the secretary with a complete record of its outstanding financial obligations, accrued and to accrue. The secretary shall pay from the money deposited and disbursed any outstanding obligations and any obligations incurred by the secretary and the department under the terms and provisions of this section. Any money that remains shall be retained by the secretary to defray the expenses of formulation, issuance, administration, or enforcement of any subsequent program for beef promotion. If no such program is undertaken within a period of three years from the date of termination of this chapter, the money shall be used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.
(d)If upon a count of the ballots the secretary finds that less than 60 percent of the total number of producers voting have assented to discontinuance and termination, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and the commission and programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter shall continue to remain in full force and effect.
6.Financial Provisions65071.(a)In order to carry out the programs and administer the activities that are conducted pursuant to this chapter, a fee an assessment of one dollar ($1) per head shall be paid on each sale of cattle and calves. The fee assessment shall be charged on all cattle and calves, except the following:
(1)Hides, skins, or the offal of animals.
(2)Any cattle that are transported for purposes other than for sale or slaughter and without a change of ownership.
(3)Any cattle custom slaughtered exclusively for the owner, members of the owners household, or the owners nonpaying guests or employees.
(4)Any cattle weighing less than 300 200 pounds.
(b)The fee assessment shall not be charged or collected more than once from each owner upon the same animal.
65072.(a)Each person who is required to pay or collect the fees assessment shall maintain a complete and accurate record of all transactions subject to fees assessments under this chapter. These records shall contain information required by the secretary relating to the payment or collection of fees, assessments, shall be preserved for a period of two years, and shall be offered and submitted for inspection and audit at any reasonable time upon written demand by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent.
(b)All information obtained by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent from any inspection or audit of records shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required in a judicial proceeding.
65073.A fee An assessment greater than one dollar ($1) per head on cattle and calves prescribed by Section 65071 shall not be charged pursuant to that section under a mandatory fee payment program, unless and until the greater fee assessment is approved by the producers in this state, by a referendum called for by a proponent of the commission to be submitted to the producers by the secretary. The secretary shall find that the producers have approved a greater fee assessment if the secretary finds that a majority of the producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of charging the greater fee. assessment. Ballots shall be provided to producers from a list provided by the council and approved by the secretary, and to other producers who request a ballot that provide proof of eligibility.
65074.(a)The fee assessment for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee assessment shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the commission by each operator of a stockyard, livestock auction market, or slaughter facility. The fee assessment is due and payable to the commission on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees Assessments that are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)The fee assessment for cattle or calves for which the fee assessment would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) and that are also exempt from a brand inspection, inspection shall be charged and collected from the seller and paid to the commission in a manner determined by the department.
(c)Any fees assessment that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be paid to the commission directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
65075.The fees assessments that are collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification pursuant to this article shall be forwarded to the secretary at the same time and in the same manner as the inspection fees that are provided for in Article 9 (commencing with Section 21281) of Chapter 6 of Division 10. The secretary shall reimburse, from any money that is collected pursuant to this section, the Bureau of Livestock Identification and any other bureaus or agencies of the state for any additional expenses that are incurred by them in the administration or enforcement of this chapter.
65076.Any person who is subject to the fee assessment that is required by Section 65071 may obtain a refund of the fee assessment collected by submitting to the commission a claim for a refund. The claim shall be submitted in writing within 90 days after the date of the brand inspection or the date of payment of the fee assessment to the secretary, whichever date is later. The claim for refund shall contain necessary information as the department may require. require but may not place conditions on the issuance of the refund.
65077.All proprietary information obtained or developed pursuant to this article by the commission or the secretary from any source, including, but not limited to, the names and addresses of producers, is confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required by a court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding. Data that is aggregated from proprietary information is not confidential, and may be disclosed, only if the data does not disclose proprietary information of an individual producer and the data cannot be used to identify an individual producer.
65078.Any fee An assessment that is levied pursuant to this chapter is a personal debt of the assessed person.
7.Actions and Penalties65081.A civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) may be levied by the commission upon a person who does any of the following:
(a)Willfully renders or furnishes a false report, statement, or record required by the commission or in any way affects the purchase or acquisition of cattle in order to avoid payment of fees.
(b)Fails to render or furnish a report, statement, or record required by the commission.
(c)When engaged in the purchase or acquisition of cattle for finishing or processing, fails or refuses to furnish to the commission or its duly authorized agents, upon request, information concerning the name and address of the persons from whom he or she has received cattle and the quantity received.
(d)Secrete, destroy, or alter records required to be kept by this chapter.
65082.The commission shall establish procedures for the purpose of according individuals aggrieved by its actions or determinations an informal hearing before the commission, or before a committee of the commission designated for this purpose. Appeals from decisions of the commission may be made to the secretary. The determination of the secretary shall be subject to judicial review upon petition filed with the appropriate superior court.
65083.(a)The commission may commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law or equity for the collection of fees and civil penalties and for obtaining injunctive relief or specific performance relating to this chapter and the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter. A court shall issue to the commission any requested writ of attachment or injunctive relief upon a prima facie showing by verified complaint that a named defendant has violated this chapter or any other rule or regulation of the commission, including, but not limited to, the nonpayment of fees. No bond shall be required to be posted by the commission as a condition for the issuance of any writ of attachment or injunctive relief.
(b)A writ of attachment shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 485.010) of Title 6.5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing specified in Section 485.010 is not required. Injunctive relief shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 525) of Title 7 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing of irreparable harm or of inadequate remedy at law specified by Section 526 or 527 is not required.
(c)Upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment.
(d)Upon a favorable judgment for the commission, the court may order that the commission be reimbursed for reasonable attorneys fees and other actual related costs. Venue for these actions is at the domicile or place of business of the defendant or in the county of the principal office of the commission. The commission may be sued only in the county of its principal office.
65084.Any action by the commission for any penalty or other remedy that is prescribed under this chapter shall be commenced within three years from the date of discovery of the alleged violation. Any action against the commission by any person shall be commenced within three years from the date of the alleged violation.
65085.The commission is not required to allege or prove that an adequate remedy at law does not exist in any action brought under this chapter.
65086.If any part of this chapter is for any reason held unconstitutional or invalid as applied to any person or as applied under certain circumstances, that decision shall not affect the remaining portions of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any other persons or under any other circumstance.
65087.The termination of this chapter shall not affect or waive any right, duty, obligation, or liability that has arisen or that may thereafter arise in connection with this chapter, release or extinguish any violation of this chapter, or affect or impair any right or remedies of the commission with respect to any violation.
65088.When the producer is a corporation or a limited liability company, all of the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this chapter shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company.
SEC. 2.SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 3 of this act, which adds Sections 65059, 65072, and 65077 of the Food and Agricultural Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the personal and financial information of a person subject to the act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The production, processing, manufacture, and distribution of beef and beef products constitute a paramount industry of this state that not only provides substantial revenues for the state but also furnishes essential foods that are vital to the public health and welfare.
(b)The raising of beef and dairy cattle provides a viable living for many Californians and supports rural communities that depend on the responsible use of their adjacent range and forest lands to promote their economies. Livestock producers are stewards of the resources they manage and the existence of ranching in California serves the public by providing numerous environmental and aesthetic benefits that would otherwise be lost without the use of Californias various working landscapes.
(c)The stabilization, maintenance, and expansion of the cattle industry of California and for the expansion of state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and other cattle products are necessary to ensure the consuming public an adequate supply of foods that are indispensable in a proper human diet. The essentiality of beef and beef products in proper human nutrition and to the maintenance of a high level of public health is such as to require that the public be made thoroughly aware thereof and be protected against misrepresentation and deception by disseminating accurate and scientific information relative to the healthful qualities of beef and beef products, their various classifications, and the food values and industrial and medicinal uses thereof, the methods, care and precautions necessary to their proper production, processing, manufacture, and distribution, and the necessary costs and expenses thereof, and the necessity and desirability on the part of the public of using and consuming beef and beef products of the highest standards of quality.
(d)The commissions form of administration created by this chapter is uniquely situated to provide those engaged in the production of cattle and beef the opportunity to avail themselves of the benefits of collective action in advertising, promotion, food safety, production research, nutrition, marketing research, the collection and dissemination of production and related statistics, and public education.
65002.The purposes of this chapter are as follows:
(a)To augment and support the work conducted by the California Beef Council.
(b)To enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets.
(c)To enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry, create a more receptive environment for California cattle producers to operate, and improve the competitiveness of California cattle producers in both the national and international marketplace.
(d)To authorize and enable the secretary and the appointed governing body of the commission to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and parties, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products, public consumption patterns and trends, sales stimulation, and consumer or other educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption.
(e)To enable the commission to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.
(f)To provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner that is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to receive a refund of those funds pursuant to Section 65076.
65003.The production of beef and beef products in this state is hereby declared to be affected with a public interest. This chapter is enacted in the exercise of the police power of this state for the purposes of protecting the health, peace, safety, and general welfare of the people of this state.
65004.No action taken by the commission, or by any individual in accordance with this chapter or with the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act (Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 16700) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), the Unfair Practices Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 17000) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade.
65005.This chapter shall be liberally construed. If any provision of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any person or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the chapter that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end the provisions of this chapter are severable.
65006.It is hereby declared as a matter of legislative determination that commission members and alternates are intended to represent and further the interest of a particular industry concerned and that this representation and furtherance is intended to serve the public interest. Accordingly, the Legislature finds that with respect to persons who are elected or appointed to the commission, the particular industry concerned is tantamount to and constitutes the public generally within the meaning of Section 87103 of the Government Code.
2.Definitions65011.Unless the context otherwise requires, the definitions in this article govern the construction of this chapter.
65012.(a)Beef means the meat of cattle and includes veal.
(b)Beef packer means a person who acquires or owns cattle for the purpose of processing into beef and beef products.
(c)Beef products means edible, industrial, and medicinal products produced in whole or in part from beef or cattle including veal products.
(d)Cattle and beef cattle are synonymous and mean bovine animals of any breed, regardless of age.
(e)Cattle feeder means a producer raising cattle in confined spaces for the purposes of finishing cattle for market.
(f)Commission means the California Beef Commission.
(g)Council means the California Beef Council.
(h)Department means the Department of Food and Agriculture.
(i)Ex officio member means a nonvoting member of the commission.
(j)Fiscal year means the same fiscal year adopted by the council.
(k)Member means any member of the commission.
(l)Producer is a person who owns or acquires ownership of beef or dairy cattle, and who, upon request, provides proof of ownership of cattle or, for purposes of voting pursuant to this chapter, has owned beef or dairy cattle within the same calendar year as the vote occurs. A person is not a producer if the persons only share in the proceeds of the sale of cattle or beef is a sales commission, handling fee, or other service fee.
(m)Range cattle producer means a person who owns and raises cattle for the purpose of producing beef and beef products.
(n)Secretary means the Secretary of Food and Agriculture.
3.California Beef Commission65021.There is in the state government the California Beef Commission that consists of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the secretary, all of whom shall be citizens and residents of this state. a producer in this state who is a range cattleman, cattle feeder, dairyman, or beef packer, with the exception of the public member who shall be a citizen and resident of this state.
65022.Each member and alternate shall be an appointed member or appointed alternate of the council.
65023.(a)The secretary or his or her designee shall serve as an ex officio member.
(b)The commission may appoint other appropriate persons as ex officio members.
65024.The secretary shall appoint to the commission at least three range cattlemen, three cattle feeders, three dairymen, one beef packer, and one public member to represent the general public. The secretary shall use the same formula in the appointment of alternates.
65025.Except as otherwise provided in this section, the public member and his or her alternate shall have all the powers, rights, and privileges of any other member or alternate, respectively, on the commission, except that the public member or his or her alternate shall not have a vote on issues regarding the fees established pursuant to Section 65071.
65026.(a)The terms of office of the members and alternates of the commission shall be three years. At the discretion of the secretary, the first appointments made under this chapter shall be so made that the terms of three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of one year, three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of two years, and three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of three years.
(b)Any vacancy that occurs during the unexpired term shall be filled by the secretary for the unexpired term from eligible nominees who have been appointed to the council. No commission member or alternate shall serve more than two consecutive three-year terms. Service as an alternate does not disqualify a person to then serve two terms as a member, and a member who was appointed for a one-year or two-year term may serve two additional three-year terms.
(c)If the secretary removes a member or alternate of the council that is also a member of the commission, the member or alternate shall be deemed removed from the commission and, upon removal, the vacancy shall be filled in the manner as provided in subdivision (a).
65027.A majority of the members of the commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business, including the election of officers. The commission may continue to transact business at a meeting at which a quorum is initially present, notwithstanding the withdrawal of members, provided any action is approved by the requisite majority of the required quorum.
65028.(a)The commission shall annually select a chairman and vice chairman from its membership, to serve at the commissions pleasure, who, together with three other members selected annually by the commission, shall constitute an executive committee.
(b)The executive committee shall have and exercise powers of the commission as the commission may delegate to it.
(c)At the discretion of the commission, the chairman and vice chairman of the commission may also serve concurrently as the chairman and vice chairman of the council.
65029.(a)The commission shall have two regular meetings each year at times and places determined by the commission.
(b)The times for regular meetings shall be fixed so that there is an interval of at least four months between each meeting.
(c)Unless directed by the secretary or a majority of the members of the commission, the commission shall convene the two regular meetings in conjunction with the council.
(d)The commission may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairman or upon the written request of three members of the commission.
(e)The executive committee shall have two regular meetings each year and may hold additional meetings any time and place at the call of the chairman or on call of a majority of the members of the executive committee.
65030.(a)Members of the commission shall be reimbursed for necessary traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties.
(b)Members of the commission shall not be reimbursed for necessary travel and other expenses for discharging similar duties that have already been reimbursed by the council.
65031.An alternate member of the commission shall sit as a regular member of the commission if the member fails for any reason to attend any meeting of the commission. An alternate member shall be compensated and reimbursed in the same manner and to the same extent as a regular member when so serving and when so serving has all the powers, duties, liabilities, and immunities of the member in whose place he or she is serving, except that the alternate to the chairman or vice chairman shall not succeed to the functions of these offices.
65032.The secretary or his or her representative shall be notified and may attend each meeting of the commission. However, the secretary or his or her representative is not permitted to attend an executive session of the commission called for the purpose of discussing potential or actual litigation against the department.
65033.No member or alternate of the commission shall receive a salary.
65034.All funds received by any person from the assessments levied under this chapter or otherwise received by the commission shall be deposited in banks or accounts established by the department that the commission may designate and may designated by the commission and shall be disbursed by order of the commission through an agent or agents as it may designate for that purpose. A private agent or agents, other than the department, shall be bonded by a fidelity bond, executed by a surety company authorized to transact business in this state, in favor of the commission, in an amount of not less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
65035.All funds received by the commission shall be deposited in bank accounts or government accounts created by the department commission separate from those accounts established by the council containing funds received pursuant to Section 64691. Funds collected by the commission pursuant to Section 65071 shall not be commingled with funds collected by the council pursuant to Section 64691.
65036.The state is not liable for the acts of the commission or its contracts. Payments of all claims arising by reason of the administration of this chapter or acts of the commission are limited to the funds collected by the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is personally liable for the contracts of the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually in any way to any other person for errors in judgment, mistakes, or other acts, either of commission or omission, as principal, agent, or employee, except for his or her own individual acts of dishonesty or crime. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually for any act or omission of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is liable for the default of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof.
65037.The commission may sue and be sued and enter into contracts. Copies of its proceedings, records, and acts, when authenticated, shall be admissible in evidence in all courts of the state and shall be prima facie evidence of the truth of all statements therein.
4.Powers and Duties65041.The powers and duties of the commission shall include, but are not limited to, all of those contained in this article.
65042.The commission may adopt and from time to time alter, rescind, modify, and amend all proper and necessary bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders in accordance with commission procedures for purposes of carrying out this chapter, including rules for appeals from any bylaw, rule, regulation, operating procedure, or order of the commission.
65043.The commission may administer and enforce this chapter and do and perform all acts and exercise all powers incidental to, or in connection with, or deemed reasonably necessary to, promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products.
65044.(a)The commission may employ a person to serve at the pleasure of the commission as the executive director of the commission, and other personnel, including legal counsel of its choice, necessary to carry out this chapter. If any person employed by the commission engages in any conduct that the secretary determines is not in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter, the secretary shall notify the commission of the conduct and request that corrective and, if appropriate, disciplinary action, be taken by the commission. If the commission fails or refuses to correct the situation or to take disciplinary action satisfactory to the secretary, the secretary may suspend or discharge the person.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, the executive director of the commission may be the same as the executive director of the council.
(c)The commission may retain additional staff or agents of the commission to discharge the duties outlined in this chapter.
(d)At the discretion of the commission, staff may be the same as those employed by the council.
(e)Agents serving on behalf of the commission to discharge the duties of the commission outlined in this chapter are not required to be parties also serving as agents of the council.
65045.If directed by a majority of commission members and approval is granted by the secretary, the commission may administer any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industries.
65046.The commission may appoint committees composed of both members, alternates and nonmembers not serving with the commission in any official capacity to advise the commission in carrying out this chapter.
65047.The commission shall approve the compensation for all employees and agents of the commission.
65048.(a)The commission may establish offices and incur expenses, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities, develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property, and borrow funds in advance of receipt of assessments as may be necessary in the opinion of the commission for the proper administration and enforcement of this chapter and the performance of its duties.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, offices and physical property utilized by the commission may be the same as those utilized by the council.
(c)The commission may offset expenses incurred by the council to establish offices, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities and develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property.
65049.The commission shall keep books, records, and accounts of all its transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. Those books, records, and accounts shall at all times be open to inspection and audit by the secretary. The commission shall be subject to an annual audit by an auditing firm selected by the commission with the concurrence of the secretary. The audit shall be made a part of an annual report to be posted on the commissions Internet Web site and submitted to the department. In addition, the secretary may, as he or she determines necessary, conduct, or cause to be conducted, a fiscal and compliance audit of the commission.
65050.The commission shall be charged with exercising any and all necessary duties to accomplish the objectives outlined in this chapter.
65051.The commission may accept contributions from private, state, and federal entities to carry out the duties authorized by this chapter.
65052.The commission may collect information about California beef and dairy production and publish and distribute without charge, a bulletin or other communication to all eligible producers.
65053.The commission shall establish an assessment rate to defray operating costs of the commission. Actions taken by the secretary, at the request of the commission, shall be reimbursed by the commission.
65054.(a)The commission shall establish an annual budget according to generally accepted accounting practices. The commission shall prepare annually summarized statements of the activities in which it has been engaged in the previous annual period, and of the activities in which it proposes to engage in the ensuing annual period. The statements shall be made available to all eligible producers at their request.
(b)Prior to the adoption of the annual budget, the commission shall submit the proposed annual budget and its statement of contemplated activities to the secretary for his or her concurrence.
(c)The annual budget and statement of contemplated activities shall be concurred in by the secretary prior to disbursement of funds.
65055.When the secretary is required to concur in a decision of the commission, the secretary shall give his or her response to the commission within 15 working days from notification of the decision. The secretary shall set forth in writing with specificity the reasons for any refusal to concur. The secretarys response may be a requirement that additional information be provided.
65055.65056.The commission shall reimburse the secretary for all expenditures incurred by the secretary in carrying out his or her duties and responsibilities pursuant to this chapter. However, a court may, if it finds that the secretary acted arbitrarily or capriciously in restricting the activities or functions of the commission, relieve the commission of the responsibility for payment of the secretarys legal costs with regard to that action.
65056.65057.(a)The secretary may require the commission to correct or cease any existing activity or function that is determined by the secretary not to be in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter.
(b)If the commission refuses or fails to cease those activities or functions or to make the corrections as required by the secretary, the secretary may, upon written notice, suspend all or a portion of the activities or functions of the commission until the time that the cessation or correction of activities or functions as required by the secretary has been accomplished by the commission.
(c)Actions of the commission in violation of the written notice are without legal force or effect. The secretary, to the extent feasible, shall issue the written notice before the commission entering into any contractual relationship affecting the existing or proposed activities or functions that are the subject of the written notice.
(d)Upon service of the written notice, the secretary shall notify the commission in writing of the specific acts that the secretary determines are not in the public interest or are in violation of this chapter, his or her reasons for requiring a cessation or correction of specific existing or proposed activities or functions, and recommendations that will make the activities or functions acceptable.
65057.65058.The secretary shall not prohibit actions by the commission that are consistent with the powers and duties provided to the commission by this chapter.
65058.65059.The commission and the secretary shall keep confidential and shall not disclose, except when required by court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding, all lists in their possession of persons subject to this chapter. However, the commission shall establish procedures to provide access to communication with other producers and handlers regarding noncommercial matters affecting the commission and persons subject to its jurisdiction. The access shall not include the actual release of the list of the names and addresses of producers and packers in the possession of the commission or the secretary. In addition, notwithstanding any other law, all proprietary or trade secret information developed or gathered pursuant to this chapter, except as provided in Section 65077, including, but not limited to, names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle and or beef produced, bought or sold, prices paid, and the products of research obtained by the commission, or by the department on behalf of the commission, from any source is confidential and shall not be considered a public record as that term is defined in Section 6252 of the Government Code.
65059.65060.The commission may investigate and prosecute civil violations of this chapter.
5.Suspension of Operations65061.(a)On or before June 1, 2018, the council shall submit to the secretary for review a list of producers eligible to vote.
(b)If the secretary finds the list submitted by the council to be insufficient, the The secretary may require auction markets and packers to submit the names and mailing addresses of all producers from whom they acquired cattle in the most recently completed fiscal year. The request for information shall be in writing and shall be filed within 10 days following receipt of the request.
(c)Any producer eligible to vote whose name does not appear on the appropriate list may have his or her name placed on the list by filing with the secretary a signed statement, identify himself or herself as a person eligible to vote. Failure to be on the list does not exempt the person from paying fees and does not invalidate any votes conducted pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Any producer eligible to vote may contact those on the list regarding the referendum in a form and manner prescribed by the secretary if all expenses associated with those contacts are paid in advance.
65062.This chapter, except as necessary to conduct an implementation referendum vote, shall not become operative until the secretary finds that a majority of producers participating in the referendum approve the referendum in an initial referendum vote conducted by the secretary on or before June 1, 2019.
65063.The implementation referendum shall advertise the amount to be assessed and declare that the assessment shall be a mandatory fee. The implementation referendum shall also advertise that upon collection of the assessment, the department commission will accept petitions to refund the fee for any producer subject to this chapter pursuant to Section 65076.
65064.The secretary shall establish a period in which to conduct the referendum, that shall not be more than 60 days in duration, and may prescribe additional procedures necessary to conduct the referendum.
65065.Nonreceipt of a ballot by an eligible handler or producer shall not invalidate a referendum.
65066.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has been given, the secretary shall certify and give notice of the favorable vote to all producers whose names and addresses are on file with the secretary.
65067.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has not been given for an initial referendum, the secretary shall certify and declare all provisions of this chapter inoperative. The secretary may conduct other implementation referendum votes one year or more after the previous vote has been taken upon the petition of a proponent of the commission.
65068.(a)Before the referendum vote conducted by the secretary pursuant to this article, a proponent of the establishment of the commission shall deposit with the secretary the amount that the secretary deems necessary to defray the expenses of analyzing the proposed commission and certifying the necessary list of producers submitted by the council and conducting the vote.
(b)Any funds not used in conducting the referendum established by this article shall be returned to the proponents of the commission who deposited the funds with the secretary.
(c)Upon establishment of the commission, the commission may reimburse the proponents of the commission for any funds deposited with the secretary that were used in carrying out this article, and for any legal expenses and costs incurred in establishing the commission.
65069.(a)A referendum among the states producers to terminate the commission shall be conducted by the secretary if the secretary receives a petition for a referendum signed by three thousand eligible producers.
(b)If upon the count of the ballots the secretary finds that 30 percent, or more, of all producers established by the secretary have voted and that 60 percent, or more, of the total number of producers voting have assented to the discontinuance and termination of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and declare the existence of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter discontinued and terminated at the end of the fiscal year in which the referendum is conducted.
(c)After the effective date of suspension of this chapter and of the commission, the operations of the commission shall be concluded and all moneys held by the commission and moneys collected by assessment and not required to defray the expenses of concluding and terminating operations of the commission shall be withdrawn from the approved depository and paid into an appropriate state or federal program or used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.(d)Pursuant to Section 65076, the commission shall refund an assessment paid by a producer so long as the request for reimbursement is made before the effective date of suspension of the commission and the assessment was paid within 90 days of the request for reimbursement.(e)Upon suspension of the operation of this chapter and of the commission, the commission shall post a notice of suspension on the commissions or councils Internet Web site. The department shall also post the notice of suspension on the departments Internet Web site.(c)On the expiration of this chapter pursuant to this article, the commission shall remain in existence for the purpose of furnishing the secretary with a complete record of its outstanding financial obligations, accrued and to accrue. The secretary shall pay from the money deposited and disbursed any outstanding obligations and any obligations incurred by the secretary and the department under the terms and provisions of this section. Any money that remains shall be retained by the secretary to defray the expenses of formulation, issuance, administration, or enforcement of any subsequent program for beef promotion. If no such program is undertaken within a period of three years from the date of termination of this chapter, the money shall be used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.
(f)(d)If upon a count of the ballots the secretary finds that less than 60 percent of the total number of producers voting have assented to discontinuance and termination, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and the commission and programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter shall continue to remain in full force and effect.
6.Financial Provisions65071.(a)In order to carry out the programs and administer the activities that are conducted pursuant to this chapter, a fee of one dollar ($1) per head shall be paid on each sale of cattle and calves. The fee shall be charged on all cattle and calves, except the following:
(1)Hides, skins, or the offal of animals.
(2)Any cattle that are transported for purposes other than for sale or slaughter and without a change of ownership.
(3)Any cattle custom slaughtered exclusively for the owner, members of the owners household, or the owners nonpaying guests or employees.
(4)Any cattle weighing less than 300 pounds.
(b)The fee shall not be charged or collected more than once from each owner upon the same animal.
65072.(a)Each person who is required to pay or collect the fees shall maintain a complete and accurate record of all transactions subject to fees under this chapter. These records shall contain information required by the secretary relating to the payment or collection of fees, shall be preserved for a period of two years, and shall be offered and submitted for inspection and audit at any reasonable time upon written demand by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent.
(b)All information obtained by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent from any inspection or audit of records shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required in a judicial proceeding.
65073.A fee greater than one dollar ($1) per head on cattle and calves prescribed by Section 65071 shall not be charged pursuant to that section under a mandatory fee payment program, unless and until the greater fee is approved by the producers in this state, by a referendum called for by a proponent of the commission to be submitted to the producers by the secretary. The secretary shall find that the producers have approved a greater fee if the secretary finds that a majority of the producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of charging the greater fee. Ballots shall be provided to producers from a list provided by the council and approved by the secretary, and to other producers who request a ballot that provide proof of eligibility.
65074.(a)The fee for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the secretary commission by each operator of a stockyard, livestock auction market, or slaughter facility. The fee is due and payable to the secretary commission on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees that are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)The fee for cattle for which the fee would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) and that are also exempt from a brand inspection, shall be charged and collected from the seller and paid to the secretary commission in a manner determined by the department.
(c)Any fees that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be paid to the secretary commission directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
65075.The fees that are collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification pursuant to this article shall be forwarded to the secretary at the same time and in the same manner as the inspection fees that are provided for in Article 9 (commencing with Section 21281) of Chapter 6 of Division 10. The secretary shall reimburse, from any money that is collected pursuant to this section, the Bureau of Livestock Identification and any other bureaus or agencies of the state for any additional expenses that are incurred by them in the administration or enforcement of this chapter.
65076.Any person who is subject to the fee that is required by Section 65071 may obtain a refund of the fee collected by submitting to the secretary commission a claim for a refund. The claim shall be submitted in writing within 90 days after the date of the brand inspection or the date of payment of the fee to the secretary, whichever date is later. The claim for refund shall contain necessary information as the department may require.
65077.All proprietary information obtained or developed pursuant to this article by the commission or the secretary from any source, including, but not limited to, the names and addresses of producers, is confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required by a court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding. Data that is aggregated from proprietary information is not confidential, and may be disclosed, only if the data does not disclose proprietary information of an individual producer and the data cannot be used to identify an individual producer.
65078.Any fee that is levied pursuant to this chapter is a personal debt of the assessed person.
7.Actions and Penalties65081.A civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) may be levied by the commission upon a person who does any of the following:
(a)Willfully renders or furnishes a false report, statement, or record required by the commission or in any way affects the purchase or acquisition of cattle in order to avoid payment of fees.
(b)Fails to render or furnish a report, statement, or record required by the commission.
(c)When engaged in the purchase or acquisition of cattle for finishing or processing, fails or refuses to furnish to the commission or its duly authorized agents, upon request, information concerning the name and address of the persons from whom he or she has received cattle and the quantity received.
(d)Secrete, destroy, or alter records required to be kept by this chapter.
65082.The commission shall establish procedures for the purpose of according individuals aggrieved by its actions or determinations an informal hearing before the commission, or before a committee of the commission designated for this purpose. Appeals from decisions of the commission may be made to the secretary. The determination of the secretary shall be subject to judicial review upon petition filed with the appropriate superior court.
65083.(a)The commission may commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law or equity for the collection of fees and civil penalties and for obtaining injunctive relief or specific performance relating to this chapter and the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter. A court shall issue to the commission any requested writ of attachment or injunctive relief upon a prima facie showing by verified complaint that a named defendant has violated this chapter or any other rule or regulation of the commission, including, but not limited to, the nonpayment of fees. No bond shall be required to be posted by the commission as a condition for the issuance of any writ of attachment or injunctive relief.
(b)A writ of attachment shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 485.010) of Title 6.5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing specified in Section 485.010 is not required. Injunctive relief shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 525) of Title 7 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing of irreparable harm or of inadequate remedy at law specified by Section 526 or 527 is not required.
(c)Upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment.
(d)Upon a favorable judgment for the commission, the court may order that the commission be reimbursed for reasonable attorneys fees and other actual related costs. Venue for these actions is at the domicile or place of business of the defendant or in the county of the principal office of the commission. The commission may be sued only in the county of its principal office.
65084.Any action by the commission for any penalty or other remedy that is prescribed under this chapter shall be commenced within three years from the date of discovery of the alleged violation. Any action against the commission by any person shall be commenced within three years from the date of the alleged violation.
65085.The commission is not required to allege or prove that an adequate remedy at law does not exist in any action brought under this chapter.
65086.If any part of this chapter is for any reason held unconstitutional or invalid as applied to any person or as applied under certain circumstances, that decision shall not affect the remaining portions of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any other persons or under any other circumstance.
65087.The termination of this chapter shall not affect or waive any right, duty, obligation, or liability that has arisen or that may thereafter arise in connection with this chapter, release or extinguish any violation of this chapter, or affect or impair any right or remedies of the commission with respect to any violation.
65088.When the producer is a corporation or a limited liability company, all of the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this chapter shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Sections 65059, 65072, and 65077 of the Food and Agricultural Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the personal and financial information of a person subject to the act, it is necessary that this act limit the publics right of access to that information.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The production, processing, manufacture, and distribution of beef and beef products constitute a paramount industry of this state that not only provides substantial revenues for the state but also furnishes essential foods that are vital to the public health and welfare.
(b)The raising of beef and dairy cattle provides a viable living for many Californians and supports rural communities that depend on the responsible use of their adjacent range and forest lands to promote their economies. Livestock producers are stewards of the resources they manage and the existence of ranching in California serves the public by providing numerous environmental and aesthetic benefits that would otherwise be lost without the use of Californias various working landscapes.
(c)The stabilization, maintenance, and expansion of the cattle industry of California and for the expansion of state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and other cattle products are necessary to ensure the consuming public an adequate supply of foods that are indispensable in a proper human diet. The essentiality of beef and beef products in proper human nutrition and to the maintenance of a high level of public health is such as to require that the public be made thoroughly aware thereof and be protected against misrepresentation and deception by disseminating accurate and scientific information relative to the healthful qualities of beef and beef products, their various classifications, and the food values and industrial and medicinal uses thereof, the methods, care and precautions necessary to their proper production, processing, manufacture, and distribution, and the necessary costs and expenses thereof, and the necessity and desirability on the part of the public of using and consuming beef and beef products of the highest standards of quality.
(d)The commissions form of administration created by this chapter is uniquely situated to provide those engaged in the production of cattle and beef the opportunity to avail themselves of the benefits of collective action in advertising, promotion, food safety, production research, nutrition, marketing research, the collection and dissemination of production and related statistics, and public education.
65002.The purposes of this chapter are as follows:
(a)To augment and support the work conducted by the California Beef Council.
(b)To enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets.
(c)To enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry, create a more receptive environment for California cattle producers to operate, and improve the competitiveness of California cattle producers in both the national and international marketplace.
(d)To authorize and enable the secretary and the appointed governing body of the commission to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and parties, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products, public consumption patterns and trends, sales stimulation, and consumer or other educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption.
(e)To enable the commission to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.
(f)To provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner that is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to receive a refund of those funds pursuant to Section 65076.
65003.The production of beef and beef products in this state is hereby declared to be affected with a public interest. This chapter is enacted in the exercise of the police power of this state for the purposes of protecting the health, peace, safety, and general welfare of the people of this state.
65004.No action taken by the commission, or by any individual in accordance with this chapter or with the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act (Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 16700) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), the Unfair Practices Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 17000) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade.
65005.This chapter shall be liberally construed. If any provision of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any person or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the chapter that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end the provisions of this chapter are severable.
65006.It is hereby declared as a matter of legislative determination that commission members and alternates are intended to represent and further the interest of a particular industry concerned and that this representation and furtherance is intended to serve the public interest. Accordingly, the Legislature finds that with respect to persons who are elected or appointed to the commission, the particular industry concerned is tantamount to and constitutes the public generally within the meaning of Section 87103 of the Government Code.
2.Definitions65011.Unless the context otherwise requires, the definitions in this article govern the construction of this chapter.
65012.(a)Beef means the meat of cattle and includes veal.
(b)Beef packer means a person who acquires or owns cattle for the purpose of processing into beef and beef products.
(c)Beef products means edible, industrial, and medicinal products produced in whole or in part from beef or cattle including veal products.
(d)Cattle and beef cattle are synonymous and mean bovine animals of any breed, regardless of age.
(e)Cattle feeder means a producer raising cattle in confined spaces for the purposes of finishing cattle for market.
(f)Commission means the California Beef Commission.
(g)Council means the California Beef Council.
(h)Department means the Department of Food and Agriculture.
(i)Ex officio member means a nonvoting member of the commission.
(j)Fiscal year means the same fiscal year adopted by the council.
(k)Member means any member of the commission.
(l)Producer is a person who owns or acquires ownership of beef or dairy cattle, and who, upon request, provides proof of ownership of cattle or, for purposes of voting pursuant to this chapter, has owned beef or dairy cattle within the same calendar year as the vote occurs. A person is not a producer if the persons only share in the proceeds of the sale of cattle or beef is a sales commission, handling fee, or other service fee.
(m)Range cattle producer means a person who owns and raises cattle for the purpose of producing beef and beef products.
(n)Secretary means the Secretary of Food and Agriculture.
3.California Beef Commission65021.There is in the state government the California Beef Commission that consists of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the secretary, all of whom shall be citizens and residents of this state.
65022.Each member and alternate shall be an appointed member or appointed alternate of the council.
65023.(a)The secretary or his or her designee shall serve as an ex officio member.
(b)The commission may appoint other appropriate persons as ex officio members.
65024.The secretary shall appoint to the commission at least three range cattlemen, three cattle feeders, three dairymen, one beef packer, and one public member to represent the general public. The secretary shall use the same formula in the appointment of alternates.
65025.Except as otherwise provided in this section, the public member and his or her alternate shall have all the powers, rights, and privileges of any other member or alternate, respectively, on the commission, except that the public member or his or her alternate shall not have a vote on issues regarding the fees established pursuant to Section 65071.
65026.(a)The terms of office of the members and alternates of the commission shall be three years. At the discretion of the secretary, the first appointments made under this chapter shall be so made that the terms of three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of one year, three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of two years, and three members and their alternates shall expire at the end of three years.
(b)Any vacancy that occurs during the unexpired term shall be filled by the secretary for the unexpired term from eligible nominees who have been appointed to the council. No commission member or alternate shall serve more than two consecutive three-year terms. Service as an alternate does not disqualify a person to then serve two terms as a member, and a member who was appointed for a one-year or two-year term may serve two additional three-year terms.
(c)If the secretary removes a member or alternate of the council that is also a member of the commission, the member or alternate shall be deemed removed from the commission and, upon removal, the vacancy shall be filled in the manner as provided in subdivision (a).
65027.A majority of the members of the commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business, including the election of officers. The commission may continue to transact business at a meeting at which a quorum is initially present, notwithstanding the withdrawal of members, provided any action is approved by the requisite majority of the required quorum.
65028.(a)The commission shall annually select a chairman and vice chairman from its membership, to serve at the commissions pleasure, who, together with three other members selected annually by the commission, shall constitute an executive committee.
(b)The executive committee shall have and exercise powers of the commission as the commission may delegate to it.
(c)At the discretion of the commission, the chairman and vice chairman of the commission may also serve concurrently as the chairman and vice chairman of the council.
65029.(a)The commission shall have two regular meetings each year at times and places determined by the commission.
(b)The times for regular meetings shall be fixed so that there is an interval of at least four months between each meeting.
(c)Unless directed by the secretary or a majority of the members of the commission, the commission shall convene the two regular meetings in conjunction with the council.
(d)The commission may hold additional meetings at any time and place at the call of the chairman or upon the written request of three members of the commission.
(e)The executive committee shall have two regular meetings each year and may hold additional meetings any time and place at the call of the chairman or on call of a majority of the members of the executive committee.
65030.(a)Members of the commission shall be reimbursed for necessary traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties.
(b)Members of the commission shall not be reimbursed for necessary travel and other expenses for discharging similar duties that have already been reimbursed by the council.
65031.An alternate member of the commission shall sit as a regular member of the commission if the member fails for any reason to attend any meeting of the commission. An alternate member shall be compensated and reimbursed in the same manner and to the same extent as a regular member when so serving and when so serving has all the powers, duties, liabilities, and immunities of the member in whose place he or she is serving, except that the alternate to the chairman or vice chairman shall not succeed to the functions of these offices.
65032.The secretary or his or her representative shall be notified and may attend each meeting of the commission. However, the secretary or his or her representative is not permitted to attend an executive session of the commission called for the purpose of discussing potential or actual litigation against the department.
65033.No member or alternate of the commission shall receive a salary.
65034.All funds received by any person from the assessments levied under this chapter or otherwise received by the commission shall be deposited in banks or accounts established by the department that the commission may designate and may be disbursed by order of the commission through an agent or agents as it may designate for that purpose. A private agent or agents, other than the department, shall be bonded by a fidelity bond, executed by a surety company authorized to transact business in this state, in favor of the commission, in an amount of not less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
65035.All funds received by the commission shall be deposited in bank accounts or government accounts created by the department separate from those accounts established by the council containing funds received pursuant to Section 64691. Funds collected by the commission pursuant to Section 65071 shall not be commingled with funds collected by the council pursuant to Section 64691.
65036.The state is not liable for the acts of the commission or its contracts. Payments of all claims arising by reason of the administration of this chapter or acts of the commission are limited to the funds collected by the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is personally liable for the contracts of the commission. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually in any way to any other person for errors in judgment, mistakes, or other acts, either of commission or omission, as principal, agent, or employee, except for his or her own individual acts of dishonesty or crime. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is responsible individually for any act or omission of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof. No member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof, is liable for the default of any other member or alternate of the commission, or any employee or agent thereof.
4.Powers and Duties65041.The powers and duties of the commission shall include, but are not limited to, all of those contained in this article.
65042.The commission may adopt and from time to time alter, rescind, modify, and amend all proper and necessary bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders in accordance with commission procedures for purposes of carrying out this chapter, including rules for appeals from any bylaw, rule, regulation, operating procedure, or order of the commission.
65043.The commission may administer and enforce this chapter and do and perform all acts and exercise all powers incidental to, or in connection with, or deemed reasonably necessary to, promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products.
65044.(a)The commission may employ a person to serve at the pleasure of the commission as the executive director of the commission, and other personnel, including legal counsel of its choice, necessary to carry out this chapter. If any person employed by the commission engages in any conduct that the secretary determines is not in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter, the secretary shall notify the commission of the conduct and request that corrective and, if appropriate, disciplinary action, be taken by the commission. If the commission fails or refuses to correct the situation or to take disciplinary action satisfactory to the secretary, the secretary may suspend or discharge the person.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, the executive director of the commission may be the same as the executive director of the council.
(c)The commission may retain additional staff or agents of the commission to discharge the duties outlined in this chapter.
(d)At the discretion of the commission, staff may be the same as those employed by the council.
(e)Agents serving on behalf of the commission to discharge the duties of the commission outlined in this chapter are not required to be parties also serving as agents of the council.
65045.If directed by a majority of commission members and approval is granted by the secretary, the commission may administer any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industries.
65046.The commission may appoint committees composed of both members, alternates and nonmembers not serving with the commission in any official capacity to advise the commission in carrying out this chapter.
65047.The commission shall approve the compensation for all employees and agents of the commission.
65048.(a)The commission may establish offices and incur expenses, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities, develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property, and borrow funds in advance of receipt of assessments as may be necessary in the opinion of the commission for the proper administration and enforcement of this chapter and the performance of its duties.
(b)At the discretion of the commission, offices and physical property utilized by the commission may be the same as those utilized by the council.
(c)The commission may offset expenses incurred by the council to establish offices, enter into any and all contracts and agreements, create liabilities and develop, own, and control the use of any intellectual or physical property.
65049.The commission shall keep books, records, and accounts of all its transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. Those books, records, and accounts shall at all times be open to inspection and audit by the secretary.
65050.The commission shall be charged with exercising any and all necessary duties to accomplish the objectives outlined in this chapter.
65051.The commission may accept contributions from private, state, and federal entities to carry out the duties authorized by this chapter.
65052.The commission may collect information about California beef and dairy production and publish and distribute without charge, a bulletin or other communication to all eligible producers.
65053.The commission shall establish an assessment rate to defray operating costs of the commission. Actions taken by the secretary, at the request of the commission, shall be reimbursed by the commission.
65054.The commission shall establish an annual budget according to generally accepted accounting practices. The commission shall prepare annually summarized statements of the activities in which it has been engaged in the previous annual period, and of the activities in which it proposes to engage in the ensuing annual period. The statements shall be made available to all eligible producers at their request.
65055.The commission shall reimburse the secretary for all expenditures incurred by the secretary in carrying out his or her duties and responsibilities pursuant to this chapter. However, a court may, if it finds that the secretary acted arbitrarily or capriciously in restricting the activities or functions of the commission, relieve the commission of the responsibility for payment of the secretarys legal costs with regard to that action.
65056.(a)The secretary may require the commission to correct or cease any existing activity or function that is determined by the secretary not to be in the public interest or that is in violation of this chapter.
(b)If the commission refuses or fails to cease those activities or functions or to make the corrections as required by the secretary, the secretary may, upon written notice, suspend all or a portion of the activities or functions of the commission until the time that the cessation or correction of activities or functions as required by the secretary has been accomplished by the commission.
(c)Actions of the commission in violation of the written notice are without legal force or effect. The secretary, to the extent feasible, shall issue the written notice before the commission entering into any contractual relationship affecting the existing or proposed activities or functions that are the subject of the written notice.
(d)Upon service of the written notice, the secretary shall notify the commission in writing of the specific acts that the secretary determines are not in the public interest or are in violation of this chapter, his or her reasons for requiring a cessation or correction of specific existing or proposed activities or functions, and recommendations that will make the activities or functions acceptable.
65057.The secretary shall not prohibit actions by the commission that are consistent with the powers and duties provided to the commission by this chapter.
65058.The commission and the secretary shall keep confidential and shall not disclose, except when required by court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding, all lists in their possession of persons subject to this chapter. However, the commission shall establish procedures to provide access to communication with other producers and handlers regarding noncommercial matters affecting the commission and persons subject to its jurisdiction. The access shall not include the actual release of the list of the names and addresses of producers and packers in the possession of the commission or the secretary. In addition, notwithstanding any other law, all proprietary or trade secret information developed or gathered pursuant to this chapter, including, but not limited to, names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle and or beef produced, bought or sold, prices paid, and the products of research obtained by the commission, or by the department on behalf of the commission, from any source is confidential and shall not be considered a public record as that term is defined in Section 6252 of the Government Code.
65059.The commission may investigate and prosecute civil violations of this chapter.
5.Suspension of Operations65061.(a)On or before June 1, 2018, the council shall submit to the secretary for review a list of producers eligible to vote.
(b)If the secretary finds the list submitted by the council to be insufficient, the secretary may require auction markets and packers to submit the names and mailing addresses of all producers from whom they acquired cattle in the most recently completed fiscal year. The request for information shall be in writing and shall be filed within 10 days following receipt of the request.
(c)Any producer eligible to vote whose name does not appear on the appropriate list may have his or her name placed on the list by filing with the secretary a signed statement, identify himself or herself as a person eligible to vote. Failure to be on the list does not exempt the person from paying fees and does not invalidate any votes conducted pursuant to this chapter.
65062.This chapter, except as necessary to conduct an implementation referendum vote, shall not become operative until the secretary finds that a majority of producers participating in the referendum approve the referendum in an initial referendum vote conducted by the secretary on or before June 1, 2019.
65063.The implementation referendum shall advertise the amount to be assessed and declare that the assessment shall be a mandatory fee. The implementation referendum shall also advertise that upon collection of the assessment, the department will accept petitions to refund the fee for any producer subject to this chapter pursuant to Section 65076.
65064.The secretary shall establish a period in which to conduct the referendum, that shall not be more than 60 days in duration, and may prescribe additional procedures necessary to conduct the referendum.
65065.Nonreceipt of a ballot by an eligible handler or producer shall not invalidate a referendum.
65066.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has been given, the secretary shall certify and give notice of the favorable vote to all producers whose names and addresses are on file with the secretary.
65067.If the secretary finds that a favorable vote has not been given for an initial referendum, the secretary shall certify and declare all provisions of this chapter inoperative. The secretary may conduct other implementation referendum votes one year or more after the previous vote has been taken upon the petition of a proponent of the commission.
65068.(a)Before the referendum vote conducted by the secretary pursuant to this article, a proponent of the establishment of the commission shall deposit with the secretary the amount that the secretary deems necessary to defray the expenses of certifying the necessary list of producers submitted by the council and conducting the vote.
(b)Any funds not used in conducting the referendum established by this article shall be returned to the proponents of the commission who deposited the funds with the secretary.
(c)Upon establishment of the commission, the commission may reimburse the proponents of the commission for any funds deposited with the secretary that were used in carrying out this article, and for any legal expenses and costs incurred in establishing the commission.
65069.(a)A referendum among the states producers to terminate the commission shall be conducted by the secretary if the secretary receives a petition for a referendum signed by three thousand eligible producers.
(b)If upon the count of the ballots the secretary finds that 30 percent, or more, of all producers established by the secretary have voted and that 60 percent, or more, of the total number of producers voting have assented to the discontinuance and termination of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and declare the existence of the commission and the programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter discontinued and terminated at the end of the fiscal year in which the referendum is conducted.
(c)After the effective date of suspension of this chapter and of the commission, the operations of the commission shall be concluded and all moneys held by the commission and moneys collected by assessment and not required to defray the expenses of concluding and terminating operations of the commission shall be withdrawn from the approved depository and paid into an appropriate state or federal program or used to fund activities related to the subject matter of this chapter at the discretion of the secretary.
(d)Pursuant to Section 65076, the commission shall refund an assessment paid by a producer so long as the request for reimbursement is made before the effective date of suspension of the commission and the assessment was paid within 90 days of the request for reimbursement.
(e)Upon suspension of the operation of this chapter and of the commission, the commission shall post a notice of suspension on the commissions or councils Internet Web site. The department shall also post the notice of suspension on the departments Internet Web site.
(f)If upon a count of the ballots the secretary finds that less than 60 percent of the total number of producers voting have assented to discontinuance and termination, the secretary shall make a finding to that effect and the commission and programs that are established and maintained pursuant to this chapter shall continue to remain in full force and effect.
6.Financial Provisions65071.(a)In order to carry out the programs and administer the activities that are conducted pursuant to this chapter, a fee of one dollar ($1) per head shall be paid on each sale of cattle and calves. The fee shall be charged on all cattle and calves, except the following:
(1)Hides, skins, or the offal of animals.
(2)Any cattle that are transported for purposes other than for sale or slaughter and without a change of ownership.
(3)Any cattle custom slaughtered exclusively for the owner, members of the owners household, or the owners nonpaying guests or employees.
(4)Any cattle weighing less than 300 pounds.
(b)The fee shall not be charged or collected more than once from each owner upon the same animal.
65072.(a)Each person who is required to pay or collect the fees shall maintain a complete and accurate record of all transactions subject to fees under this chapter. These records shall contain information required by the secretary relating to the payment or collection of fees, shall be preserved for a period of two years, and shall be offered and submitted for inspection and audit at any reasonable time upon written demand by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent.
(b)All information obtained by the secretary or his or her duly authorized agent from any inspection or audit of records shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required in a judicial proceeding.
65073.A fee greater than one dollar ($1) per head on cattle and calves prescribed by Section 65071 shall not be charged pursuant to that section under a mandatory fee payment program, unless and until the greater fee is approved by the producers in this state, by a referendum called for by a proponent of the commission to be submitted to the producers by the secretary. The secretary shall find that the producers have approved a greater fee if the secretary finds that a majority of the producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of charging the greater fee. Ballots shall be provided to producers from a list provided by the council and approved by the secretary, and to other producers who request a ballot that provide proof of eligibility.
65074.(a)The fee for cattle or calves, whether originating in the state or out-of-state, shall be paid by the seller. The fee shall be charged and collected from the seller or from the sellers account and paid to the secretary by each operator of a stockyard, livestock auction market, or slaughter facility. The fee is due and payable to the secretary on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the cattle and calves are sold. Fees that are not collected in the manner provided in this subdivision shall be collected from the seller by the Bureau of Livestock Identification at the time that brand inspection fees are collected.
(b)The fee for cattle for which the fee would not otherwise be collected pursuant to subdivision (a) and that are also exempt from a brand inspection, shall be charged and collected from the seller and paid to the secretary in a manner determined by the department.
(c)Any fees that are not collected in the manner specified in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be paid to the secretary directly by the seller on or before the 15th day of the month next succeeding the month in which the sale occurs.
65075.The fees that are collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification pursuant to this article shall be forwarded to the secretary at the same time and in the same manner as the inspection fees that are provided for in Article 9 (commencing with Section 21281) of Chapter 6 of Division 10. The secretary shall reimburse, from any money that is collected pursuant to this section, the Bureau of Livestock Identification and any other bureaus or agencies of the state for any additional expenses that are incurred by them in the administration or enforcement of this chapter.
65076.Any person who is subject to the fee that is required by Section 65071 may obtain a refund of the fee collected by submitting to the secretary a claim for a refund. The claim shall be submitted in writing within 90 days after the date of the brand inspection or the date of payment of the fee to the secretary, whichever date is later. The claim for refund shall contain necessary information as the department may require.
65077.All proprietary information obtained or developed pursuant to this article by the commission or the secretary from any source, including, but not limited to, the names and addresses of producers, is confidential and shall not be disclosed except when required by a court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding.
65078.Any fee that is levied pursuant to this chapter is a personal debt of the assessed person.
7.Actions and Penalties65081.A civil penalty not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) may be levied by the commission upon a person who does any of the following:
(a)Willfully renders or furnishes a false report, statement, or record required by the commission or in any way affects the purchase or acquisition of cattle in order to avoid payment of fees.
(b)Fails to render or furnish a report, statement, or record required by the commission.
(c)When engaged in the purchase or acquisition of cattle for finishing or processing, fails or refuses to furnish to the commission or its duly authorized agents, upon request, information concerning the name and address of the persons from whom he or she has received cattle and the quantity received.
(d)Secrete, destroy, or alter records required to be kept by this chapter.
65082.The commission shall establish procedures for the purpose of according individuals aggrieved by its actions or determinations an informal hearing before the commission, or before a committee of the commission designated for this purpose. Appeals from decisions of the commission may be made to the secretary. The determination of the secretary shall be subject to judicial review upon petition filed with the appropriate superior court.
65083.(a)The commission may commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law or equity for the collection of fees and civil penalties and for obtaining injunctive relief or specific performance relating to this chapter and the rules and regulations adopted under this chapter. A court shall issue to the commission any requested writ of attachment or injunctive relief upon a prima facie showing by verified complaint that a named defendant has violated this chapter or any other rule or regulation of the commission, including, but not limited to, the nonpayment of fees. No bond shall be required to be posted by the commission as a condition for the issuance of any writ of attachment or injunctive relief.
(b)A writ of attachment shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 485.010) of Title 6.5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing specified in Section 485.010 is not required. Injunctive relief shall be issued pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 525) of Title 7 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing of irreparable harm or of inadequate remedy at law specified by Section 526 or 527 is not required.
(c)Upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment.
(d)Upon a favorable judgment for the commission, the court may order that the commission be reimbursed for reasonable attorney's fees and other actual related costs. Venue for these actions is at the domicile or place of business of the defendant or in the county of the principal office of the commission. The commission may be sued only in the county of its principal office.
65084.Any action by the commission for any penalty or other remedy that is prescribed under this chapter shall be commenced within three years from the date of discovery of the alleged violation. Any action against the commission by any person shall be commenced within three years from the date of the alleged violation.
65085.The commission is not required to allege or prove that an adequate remedy at law does not exist in any action brought under this chapter.
65086.If any part of this chapter is for any reason held unconstitutional or invalid as applied to any person or as applied under certain circumstances, that decision shall not affect the remaining portions of this chapter or the application of this chapter to any other persons or under any other circumstance.
65087.The termination of this chapter shall not affect or waive any right, duty, obligation, or liability that has arisen or that may thereafter arise in connection with this chapter, release or extinguish any violation of this chapter, or affect or impair any right or remedies of the commission with respect to any violation.
65088.When the producer is a corporation or a limited liability company, all of the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this chapter shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company.
SECTION 1.Section 64591 of the Food and Agricultural Code is amended to read:64591.(a)There is in the state government the California Beef Council which consists of 20 members and 20 alternates, all of whom shall be citizens and residents of this state who are producers, packers, or processors.(b)The secretary shall appoint to the council six range cattlemen, six cattle feeders, and six dairymen nominated as producers and two packers or processors as hereinafter provided for, giving due regard to proper geographic distribution. This requirement shall not operate to remove from office any member of the council. Subject to the provisions of this section and Section 64592, present members of the council shall be eligible for reappointment.(a)There is in the state government the California Beef Council which consists of 20 members and 20 alternates, all of whom shall be citizens and residents of this state and who are producers, packers, or processors.
The(b)The secretary shall appoint to the council six range cattlemen, six cattle feeders, and six dairymen nominated as producers and two packers or processors as hereinafter provided for, giving due regard to proper geographic distribution. This requirement shall not, however, not operate to remove from office any member of the council. Subject to the provisions of this section and of Section 64592, present members of the council shall be eligible for reappointment.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 11, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 3, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 13, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on AGRI. |
| May 24, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on AGRI. and JUD. |
| May 15, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 15, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 3. Page 1536.) |
| May 11, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 10, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (May 10). |
| Apr 27, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 19, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on AGRI. |
| Apr 18, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on AGRI. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 22, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on AGRI. |
| Mar 21, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on AGRI. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 20, 2017 | Referred to Com. on AGRI. |
| Jan 31, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 2. |
| Jan 30, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 20, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Agriculture |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2017 | AB 243 COOPER Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 10, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Agriculture |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 243 (Author:Cooper)
Version: July 3, 2017
Hearing Date: July 11, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
California Beef Commission
DESCRIPTION
This bill would establish the California Beef Commission. It would provide the Commission with broad authority, including authorization to negotiate directly with governmental agencies and to educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.
BACKGROUND
California law provides for a wide variety of commissions and councils that represent various agricultural and seafood industries pursuant to the Food and Agricultural Code. These entities are deemed duly constituted authorities of this state and are mandated to enhance and preserve the economic interests of the State of California and intended to provide benefits to the entire industry represented as well as all of the people of this state.
Relevant here, the California Beef Council (the Council) serves as the promotion, research and education arm of the California beef industry, financed by a one dollar mandatory assessment on every head of cattle sold in California, as specified, pursuant to Food and Agricultural Code Section 64691 and the federal Beef Promotion and Research Act, 7 U.S.C. Section 2901 et seq. Half of this assessment goes to the federal government and the other half is credited toward the state program.
The stated purposes of the Council are to enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state, for human consumption; to authorize and enable the Secretary of the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) to formulate and effectuate research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products and public consumption patterns and trends, and sales stimulation and consumer, or other, educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption; and to provide funds for the administration and enforcement of the California Beef Council Law, Section 64501 et seq., by mandatory fees.
In order to be a “qualified state beef council” that is eligible to benefit from half of the one dollar charged by the federal government, the Council cannot use the funds “for the purpose of influencing governmental policy or action, or to fund plans or projects which make use of any unfair or deceptive acts or practices including unfair or deceptive acts or practices with respect to the quality, value or use of any competing product.” (7 C.F.R. Section 1260.181.)
Of particular relevance here, existing California Beef Council Law provides referendum procedures to increase the assessment. The secretary is required to provide all eligible producers with ballots for such a proposed referendum and must find that 60 percent of the producers voting in the referendum voted in favor of charging the greater fee. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 64691.5.)
In 2012, the Council conducted such a referendum of the state’s producers on the issue of increasing the mandatory fee by one dollar. The producers in California voted against raising the fee.
This bill would provide for the California Beef Commission (the Commission). This bill would ostensibly serve the same purposes as the Council and would in fact be permitted to share staff, an executive director, an executive committee, and even office space and physical property. The Commission would also be authorized to charge an additional one dollar assessment on every head of cattle sold. The Commission and the fee would require a vote of the producers in this state to be implemented. However, this vote would only require a majority of the voters in the referendum to vote in favor.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the California Beef Council Law, establishes the California Beef Council (the Council) as a state level entity and details the structure, membership, and operation of the Council. The Council is financed by a one dollar per head fee on each sale of cattle and calves weighing 300 pounds or more, as specified. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 64501 et seq.)
Existing law provides that the Council’s purposes are the following:
- to enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets;
- to authorize and enable the director to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and instrumentalities which are specified in this chapter, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products and public consumption patterns and trends, and sales stimulation and consumer, or other, educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption; and
- to provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner which is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to provide those funds through voluntary contributions. (Food & Agr. Code Sec. 64532.)
Existing law prohibits a member, alternate agent, or employee of the council from appearing before any legislative committee of the state or federal government as a representative of the council unless requested to do so by such committee or to lobby in any manner as a representative of the council. None of the funds collected by the Council can be used for political contributions. (Food & Agr. Code Secs. 64633, 64634.)
Existing law provides that the director shall conduct, or may cause the Council to conduct, programs of education, research, or public information, which are designed to accomplish the following purposes, among others:
- increase the consumption of beef and beef products;
- gather, publicize, and disseminate accurate and scientific information which shows the importance of the use and consumption of beef and beef products in relation to the public health, economy, and diet, and proper nutrition of children and adults;
- study means and methods which are employed in producing, processing, manufacturing, marketing, and distributing beef and beef products in order to comply with the sanitary and other regulations which are imposed by municipalities, this state, and the United States;
- gather and disseminate information regarding the high standards which are observed and imposed to ensure pure and wholesome beef and beef products;
- gather and disseminate information regarding the harmful effects on the public health resulting from the breakdown or instability of the cattle industry, the factors and conditions peculiar to the cattle industry which tend to cause an unbalanced production, the price of beef and beef products in relation to the cost of other items of food in a balanced diet; and
- gather and disseminate information regarding the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products and public consumption patterns and trends, and the factors which tend to promote increased consumption of beef and beef products, stabilize the industry, and foster a better understanding and more efficient cooperation among producers and slaughterers and the consuming public. (Food & Agr. Code § 64661.)
Existing law prohibits any programs or activities, which are conducted or sponsored by or through the Beef Council, from making false or unwarranted claims, or disparage the quality, value, use, or sale of any commodity authorized by law to be marketed in this state. Such programs are also prohibited from being conducted with reference to a private brand or trade name which refers to beef or a beef product, unless the expenditures for that are authorized by a two-thirds vote of the Council with the concurrence of the Secretary. (Food & Agr. Code Secs. 64662, 64663.)
This bill would provide for the establishment of the California Beef Commission (the Commission), made up of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the CDFA secretary, each of whom is a producer in the state who is a range cattle producer, cattle feeder, dairy producer, or beef packer, along with one public member. The Commission, along with the provisions of this bill, would only take effect after an implementation referendum vote in which a majority of the producers voting in the referendum vote in favor of implementation. If a majority of the producers voting do not vote in favor of implementation, the secretary would be required to declare the provisions of this bill inoperative, but would be authorized to conduct other implementation referendum votes every two years thereafter upon petition.
This bill would provide that every five years after successful implementation, the CDFA Secretary would be required to hold a noticed public hearing to determine the merit of continuing the operation of the Commission. If the secretary finds that a substantial question exists among producers as to whether the Commission should continue to exist, a reapproval referendum would be held in line with the original implementation referendum.
This bill would provide the procedures for forming an executive committee and holding annual meetings. It would provide that a majority of the members of the commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business.
This bill would state the purposes of the Commission are the following:
- to augment and support the work conducted by the Council;
- to enable the cattle industry, with the aid of the state, to develop, maintain, and expand the state, nationwide, and foreign markets for beef and beef products produced, processed, manufactured, sold, or distributed in this state for human consumption, and the use and consumption of these beef and beef products in those markets;
- to enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry, create a more receptive environment for California cattle producers to operate, and improve the competitiveness of California cattle producers in both the national and international marketplace;
- to authorize and enable the secretary and the appointed governing body of the Commission to formulate and effectuate, directly or in cooperation with other agencies and parties, research relating to the nutritional qualities of beef and beef products, public consumption patterns and trends, sales stimulation, and consumer or other educational programs designed to increase the use and consumption of beef and beef products for human consumption;
- to enable the Commission to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products;
- to provide funds for the administration and enforcement of this chapter by mandatory fees to be collected in the manner that is prescribed in this chapter, unless producers elect to receive a refund of those funds.
This bill would define “producer” as a person who owns or acquires ownership of beef or dairy cattle, and who, upon request, provides proof of ownership of cattle or, for purposes of voting pursuant to this bill, has owned beef or dairy cattle within the same calendar year as the vote occurs. A person is not a producer if the person’s only share in the proceeds of the sale of cattle or beef is a sales commission, handling fee, or other service fee.
This bill would authorize the Commission to adopt and from time to time alter, rescind, modify, and amend all proper and necessary bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders in accordance with commission procedures for purposes of carrying out this bill’s purposes, including rules for appeals from any bylaw, rule, regulation, operating procedure, or order of the commission. It would further authorize the Commission to administer and enforce the bill’s provisions, and do and perform all acts and exercise all powers incidental to, or in connection with, or deemed reasonably necessary to, promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products. The Commission would be authorized to administer any governmental program related to the California cattle, beef, and beef products industries, if directed by a majority of Commission members and approved by the secretary, except administering funds and performing acts under the jurisdiction of the Council.
This bill would provide that when the secretary is required to concur in a decision of the Commission, the secretary shall give a response to the Commission within 15 working days from notification of the decision. The secretary would be required to set forth in writing with specificity the reasons for any refusal to concur.
This bill would authorize the secretary to require the Commission to correct or cease any existing activity or function that is determined by the secretary not to be in the public interest or that is in violation of, or is inconsistent with, this bill. If the Commission refuses or fails to cease those activities or functions or to make the corrections as required by the secretary, the secretary would be permitted to, upon written notice, suspend all or a portion of the activities or functions of the Commission until the time that the cessation or correction of activities or functions as required by the secretary has been accomplished by the commission. Upon service of the written notice, the secretary would be required to notify the Commission in writing of the specific acts that the secretary determines are not in the public interest or are in violation of this bill, the reasons for requiring a cessation or correction of specific existing or proposed activities or functions, and recommendations that will make the activities or functions acceptable.
This bill would authorize the Commission to employ an executive director, whom may also serve as executive director of the Council and whom would be eligible to receive a salary approved by the Commission.
This bill would authorize the Commission to levy civil penalties not exceeding $1,000 upon any persons falsifying documents, affecting cattle acquisition in a way to avoid fees, failing to render or furnish various required documents or information, and secreting, destroying, or altering records required to be kept by this bill. The Commission would be required to establish procedures for the purpose of according individuals aggrieved by its actions or determinations an informal hearing. Appeals from decisions of the Commission would be allowed to be made to the secretary. The determination of the secretary would be subject to judicial review upon petition filed with the appropriate superior court.
This bill would provide that the commission shall keep books, records, and accounts of all its transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. Those books, records, and accounts shall at all times be open to inspection and audit by the secretary. The commission shall be subject to an annual audit by an auditing firm selected by the commission with the concurrence of the secretary.
This bill would provide that when a producer is a corporation or a limited liability company, all of the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this chapter shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company.
This bill would provide that the Commission may sue and be sued, and all claims against the Commission are payable only through the funds collected by the Commission. It would also provide that no member of the Commission is responsible individually in any way to any other person for errors in judgment, mistakes, or other acts, either of commission or omission, as principal, agent, or employee, except for his or her own individual acts of dishonesty or crime.
This bill would authorize the Commission to investigate and prosecute civil violations of this bill and to commence civil actions and utilize all remedies in law for the collection of fees and civil penalties and for obtaining injunctive relief. This bill would require a court to issue any request writ of attachment or injunctive relief to the Commission upon a prima facie showing by verified complaint that a named defendant has violated this bill’s provisions or any other rule or regulation of the Commission, including, but not limited to, the nonpayment of fees. The court would not be permitted to require a bond be posted by the Commission as a condition for the issuance of any writ of attachment or injunctive relief. Any such writ of attachment would be required to be issued pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 485.010) of Title 6.5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing specified in Section 485.010 is not required, and injunctive relief would be required to be issued pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 525) of Title 7 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, except that the showing of irreparable harm or of inadequate remedy at law specified by Section 526 or 527 is not required. The Commission would not be required to allege or prove that an adequate remedy at law does not exist in any action brought pursuant to this bill.
This bill would provide that upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment. The court would also be permitted to order the Commission be reimbursed for reasonable attorney’s fees and other actual related costs. Venue for these actions would be at the domicile or place of business of the defendant or in the county of the principal office of the Commission; however, the Commission could be sued only in the county of its principal office.
This bill would provide that no action taken by the commission, or by any individual in accordance with this bill or with the rules and regulations adopted under this bill, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act (Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 16700) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), the Unfair Practices Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 17000) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code), or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade.
This bill would require the Commission and the secretary to keep confidential and not disclose, except when required by court order after a hearing in a judicial proceeding, all lists in their possession of persons subject to this bill. However, the Commission would be required to establish procedures to provide access to communication with other producers and handlers regarding noncommercial matters affecting the commission and persons subject to its jurisdiction. In addition, notwithstanding any other law, this bill would provide that all proprietary or trade secret information developed or gathered pursuant to this chapter, except as provided, including, but not limited to, names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle or beef produced, bought, or sold, prices paid, and the products of research obtained by the commission, or by the department on behalf of the commission, from any source is confidential and shall not be considered a public record as that term is defined in Section 6252 of the Government Code. This bill would also exempt the amounts of individual refunds provided pursuant to this bill and the identity of producers receiving refunds.
This bill would provide that in order to finance the operation of the Commission, an assessment of one dollar per head shall be paid on each sale of cattle and calves weighing at least 200 pounds. Those required to pay or collect such assessment would be required to maintain complete and accurate records of all transactions and provide them for inspection and audit at any reasonable time upon written demand by the secretary or the secretary’s agent. The Commission would also be permitted to accept grants from state and federal entities.
This bill would provide that any person who is subject to the mandatory assessment may obtain a refund of the assessment collected by submitting to the commission a claim for a refund. The claim would be required to be submitted by mail, facsimile, electronic mail, or a refund request form through the CDFA’s Internet Web site within 90 days after the date of the brand inspection or the date of payment of the assessment, whichever date is later. The Commission would be required to issue the refund within 60 days of receipt of the refund request. Conditions would not be allowed to be placed on the issuance of a refund, except for requiring the claim to demonstrate the fee has been paid. Neither the secretary, CDFA, the Commission, nor the producers by referendum would be permitted to limit or inhibit a refund for a person that has paid the assessment.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
. . . AB 243 will establish the California Beef Commission which will function solely as a California marketing and promotional agency and will have no official association with [the] national Act. Supporters state the [California Beef Commission], under the oversight of CDFA, will serve as a partner of the Council, capitalizing on the use of joint resources between the two agencies, but will also maintain a clear separation in the collection and allocation of funds dispersed by the [California Beef Commission].
Writing in support, the Western United Dairymen state:
In establishing the California Beef Commission, AB 243 ensures any money collected under a voter-approved increase in the beef checkoff remains distinctly separate from funds collected under the current mandatory assessment by the California Beef Council. Like other commodity commissions in the state, AB 243 outlines specific research, promotion and educational efforts that can be funded by the California Beef Commission.
2. Deciphering the need for the Council and the Commission
As discussed above, California currently has a Beef Council (the Council). The Council operates like many commissions in California, functioning as an administrative and promotional body for its particular segment of California’s economy, beef. This bill would establish the California Beef Commission (the Commission), a second state level entity that would serve nearly identical purposes as the Council. No precedent has been found for multiple state-established commissions or councils in California representing the exact same industry and the exact same commodity. In fact, this bill would fuse the two governmental agencies together in nearly all respects.
The stated purposes for the Commission would parallel those of the existing Council. The executive director, chairperson, vice chairperson, and staff for the Commission may also serve in such capacity with the Council. The annual meetings of the Commission would be encouraged to take place in conjunction with the meetings of the Council. The offices and physical property utilized by the Commission would also be permitted to be the same as those utilized by the Council. With the approval of the secretary, the Commission and the Council would be permitted to jointly fund projects. And this bill expressly states the Commission’s first purpose would be to augment and support the work conducted by the Council.
The question therefore becomes why does California need yet another commission to serve an industry already represented by a state level council. Those in opposition argue there is no compelling reason, and arguably, a sufficient reason has not been presented.
According to the author and the sponsor, the California Cattlemen’s Association (CCA), an organization representing a portion of California’s $1.78 billion beef industry on legislative and regulatory issues, this bill is a response to the expressed interest of the cattle producers in the state to raise the mandatory assessment on the sale of cattle in California. In addition, CCA stresses that the Commission, rather than the Council, needs to collect these fees so that the funds will not be subject to federal rules and regulations. Writing in support, the Butte County Cattlemen’s Association states:
AB 243 is a bill that will enable ranchers and dairy producers to address the needs of the beef cattle industry while ensuring proper oversight, transparency and the ability for all ranchers to control, shape[,] and mold the direction of the California Beef Commission including determining the need to increase the beef checkoff.
This bill would, in fact, pave the way for an additional one dollar assessment to be charged on each head of cattle sold in the state by the Commission, which would not be directly governed by the federal Beef Promotion and Research Act. However, as pointed out by many of those in opposition, cattle producers already weighed in against these changes, as the issue of raising the assessment by one dollar was recently put to a vote. Additionally, nothing would have stopped the Council, had it voted for the additional fees, from using those funds as it saw fit, subject only to California Beef Council law.
Ranchers in opposition to this bill contend that this bill is effectively an end-run around that failed 2012 effort to increase the beef checkoff by one dollar. The California Farmers Union writes in opposition: “In 2012, California beef producers voted against an increase in the beef checkoff in a statewide referendum, and AB 243 would invalidate that critical vote by lowering the threshold for passage of an additional one dollar checkoff. We urge California lawmakers to vote against AB 243 because beef producers have already voted against an increase in the beef checkoff and that vote should be upheld.” This sentiment is echoed by the letters in opposition submitted by the Kern County Cattlemen’s Association and Snedden Ranch who believe this bill would subvert the expressed will of the cattle producers and the established procedures of the Council, which were utilized to put the issue to a vote.
This bill would in essence be utilizing the Legislature to put this issue back up for a vote, but with new rules. Now, only a majority vote of those producers voting in any given referendum would be necessary to authorize the additional one dollar assessment. This arguably subverts the will of the producers and diminishes the voice smaller ranching operations are given in the process.
As to the second interest driving the creation of the Commission, this bill would allow for the funds to be used in entirely different ways, not subject to the Council law. However, many of the new rules that would apply raise concerns.
- Lobbying, educating, and negotiating
This bill would state one of its purposes as the enabling of the Commission “to present facts to and negotiate with local, state, federal, and foreign agencies on matters that affect the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products as well as educate those effecting policy likely to impact California cattle producers or beef and beef products.” The language of this section would provide broad authority to the Commission to influence policy and policymakers. Given the concerns both within the industry and from environmental and animal-rights groups, these powers may require some closer scrutiny and possibly circumscription.
Food and Water Watch, a national advocacy group, opposes this bill, arguing “the supplemental checkoff funds would effectively subsidize the lobbying efforts of the largest, industrialized cattle operations and meatpackers that have historically opposed policies supporting local, sustainable production and fair marketing and contracting protections for cattle producers.”
The California Farmers Union writes: “AB 243 would in effect authorize the appointed ‘California Beef Commission’ to lobby lawmakers which is in complete conflict with our view that not a single dime in checkoff funds should be used to engage in lobbying. The important research, promotion, and marketing functions of the checkoff must be divorced from politics.”
The California Dairy Campaign, a coalition of dairy producers, writes that it is “greatly concerned that there would be little ability for dairy farmers paying into the beef checkoff to have input about the messaging and apparent lobbying activities of the proposed ‘California Beef Commission.’ . . . Federal law prohibits commodity checkoff programs from influencing any legislation or governmental policy and California state checkoff law should do the same.”
These concerns are borne out to a certain extent by looking at CCA’s own policy goals. CCA has published its own resolutions addressing a wide range of issue areas and proposing policy positions that they believe are necessary to promote and protect the beef industry in California. Many of these resolutions run counter to the public policy of California and of many of the cattle producers and dairy farmers the Commission would ostensibly represent.
In its 2016-2017 resolutions, the Commission declared that “the survival of the beef industry and agriculture depend upon positive changes occurring in both the exploration, development and refining capacities for crude oil here in the United States to increase both the supply of fossil fuel based energy sources and the refining capacity for that oil.” In response, it resolved to support “the lawful exploration, development and mining of domestic oil and gas supplies located in California, including advanced drilling techniques such as hydraulic fracturing [(“fracking”)].” Furthermore, they advocate against “the establishment of commercial-scale solar production on lands that are zoned for agriculture.” In addition, the resolutions talk of “defending against environmental, animal welfare, and nutritional attacks from anti-beef activists” through an increase in the beef checkoff. Promotion and research is generally the purpose of California commissions and councils.
CCA has also resolved to “use the most effective approach to oppose the legislative enactment or promotion of initiatives to the voters which unreasonably curtail agricultural practices or the use of land and water for agricultural purposes.” This is a clear departure from the promotion of beef generally, which lifts the entire industry up. Opposing certain bills and voter-driven initiatives could operate to undermine the interests of cattle producers in the state and the interests of the public at large.
In addition, it is hard to decipher how some of the policy resolutions of the CCA are tied to the interests of California cattle producers and dairy producers. CCA also resolves to see greater tax exemptions in order to accomplish the “larger and more important objective of fully eliminating the federal estate tax.” It also has resolved to “oppose any further legislation aimed at strengthening the requirements for the registration of firearms.” Are these the types of objectives that the Commission would be funded to accomplish? Are these objectives in the interests of the entire industry and the public?
- Loosened restrictions
This bill would also remove some important restraints that currently apply to the activities and speech of the Council. Existing law prohibits any programs or activities conducted or sponsored by or through the Council from making false or unwarranted claims. Such programs are also prohibited from being conducted with reference to a private brand or trade name which refers to beef or a beef product, unless the expenditures for that are authorized by a two-thirds vote of the Council with the concurrence of the Secretary. They are also restricted from disparaging “the quality, value, use, or sale of any commodity authorized by law to be marketed in this state.” None of these restrictions would be placed on the Commission by this bill.
Federal regulations also indirectly restrict some uses as the California Beef Council is a “qualified state beef council” that can participate in the federal checkoff if it does not use Council funds “for the purpose of influencing governmental policy or action, or to fund plans or projects which make use of any unfair or deceptive acts or practices including unfair or deceptive acts or practices with respect to the quality, value or use of any competing product.” (7 C.F.R. Sections 1260.181.) It should be noted that nothing in the Beef Council Law restricts the use of its own funds, including funds drawn from additional fees charged to its producers, to research or promote issues important to California so long as the uses abide by California law, such as the restrictions discussed herein, including the restrictions on false claims, disparagement, and lobbying. Therefore, if the producers had voted in favor of an extra one dollar fee in 2012, the funds collected from that fee could have been used as the Council saw fit so long as it abided by California Beef Council law.
Existing law also prohibits a member, agent, or employee of the Council from appearing before any legislative committee of the state or federal government as a representative of the council unless requested to do so by such committee or to lobby in any manner as a representative of the council. None of the funds collected by the Council are allowed to be used for political contributions. None of these restrictions are included in this bill.
Therefore, the Commission, unlike the Council, would be granted unguided authority to attack environmental, animal-welfare, and nutritional research that the Commission feels is overly negative toward certain practices within the beef industry. This would also open the door for the Commission to disparage other commodities that it feels compete with beef, despite the benefits the other commodities might provide the public. There is also limited control over the Commission’s ability to represent the interests of the large cattle producers in the state to the detriment of smaller producers in California. The Commission could also directly engage with and attempt to “educate” policymakers on these fronts. These provisions therefore have the ability to undermine the stated Legislative purpose for enacting commissions and councils, which is to “[p]rovide benefit to the entire industry and all of the people of this state.”
These issues are specifically contemplated by the national Beef Promotion and Research Act and the regulations address them by restricting funds from being used “for the purpose of influencing governmental policy or action, or to fund plans or projects which make use of any unfair or deceptive acts or practices including unfair or deceptive acts or practices with respect to the quality, value or use of any competing product.” (7 C.F.R. Sec. 1260.181.) Food and Water Watch expresses concern on this point: “Doubling the California beef checkoff would create a slush fund that would likely be used to advocate against the interests of California’s independent farmers and the consumers who are more interested than ever in knowing where their food comes from and how it was produced.”
These concerns are amplified when put in the context of the other provisions. For instance, this bill would provide that no action taken by the Commission, or by any individual in accordance with this bill or with the rules and regulations adopted under this bill, shall be deemed a violation of the Cartwright Act, the Unfair Practices Act, or any rule of statutory or common law against monopolies or combinations in restraint of trade. Although this has become standard boilerplate in the enabling statutes for commissions and councils in this state, there does not seem to be a justification here. The sponsor of this bill has failed to provide an example of an activity authorized by this bill that would necessitate these types of broad legal exemptions. Every concern addressed above, and the concerns of those in opposition, is heightened when the Commission and its leadership is statutorily insulated from claims it engaged in improper conduct and activities pursuant to these laws.
In addition, although existent in some other commissions, such as the Rice Commission (Section 71089 of the Food and Agricultural Code) and the Nursery Producers Commission (Section 79505 of the Food and Agricultural Code), this bill’s provision that would restrict public access to the “products of research obtained by the Commission” also exacerbates concerns about the operation of the Commission. If the ultimate goal of the Commission is to serve the public interest, then, arguably, the products of research should not be exempt from the California Public Records Act. Along these lines, the bill would also make confidential information about the persons subject to the Commission’s jurisdiction. It would also restrict from public disclosure any proprietary or trade secret information, including the names and addresses of packers and producers, cattle or beef produced, bought, or sold, and the prices paid. The California Public Records Act generally requires the disclosure of public records absent a specific exemption or an interest in nondisclosure that outweighs the public’s right of access.
The structure that would be put in place for the Commission also shifts the power of the state to control operations. Currently, the Council is effectively an advisory entity, subject to pre-approval from the CDFA secretary. The Commission would have more independent authority and would place the burden on the secretary to prohibit actions by the commission. The secretary would be able to challenge the Commission only when the actions are inconsistent with the powers and duties provided to the Commission by this bill, are in violation of the provisions of this bill, or not in the public interest. This provision, taken with other such provisions such as the legal exemptions discussed above, chip away at the ability of the secretary to take control of the Commission.
3. Troubling precedent and abuses in similar programs nationwide
Writing in opposition, the Kern County Cattlemen’s Association points to the various instances of fraud in other state level beef councils and argues that this background should result in “heightened scrutiny, not an increase in scope and power, as in this current proposal from the [California Cattlemen’s Association].”
A coalition of groups including family farm associations, grass-fed beef producers, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Pesticide Action Network, the Center for Food Safety, and the Consumer Federation of California write in strong opposition to this bill. On this point, they write: “Beef checkoff programs and associated commissions in some of the most beef-centric states in the country have been found to be operating dubiously, and some even illegally.”
Several letters in opposition reference a very recent occurrence in Oklahoma. In that case, the Oklahoma Beef Council staff was found guilty of embezzling $2.6 million. In addition, there is already widespread concern and suspicion about the strong connections between state beef councils and the national program and politically-oriented beef industry lobbying groups, which critics say results in a “push for issues that favor large operations.” (McGraw and Lowe, Ranchers take on the beef industry over mandatory checkoff payments (Jan. 17, 2015) The Kansas City Star <http://www.kansas city.com/news/business/article7245926.html> (as of July 2, 2017).) In response to complaints regarding lax government oversight over beef checkoff funds and improper relationships between the national beef board and industry groups, the Office of the Inspector General recently conducted an audit of the federal program and concluded that oversight as an internal control function needed improvement as the deficiencies have reduced assurance that beef checkoff funds were collected, distributed, and expended in accordance with the Beef Research and Information Act. (See Office of Inspector General, Agricultural Marketing Service Oversight of the Beef Promotion and Research Board’s Activities (Jan. 2014) <https://www.usda.gov/oig/webdocs/01099-0001-21.pdf> (as of July 2, 2017).)
This bill would massively deregulate the operation of the Commission rather than place the types of internal controls that guide the federal and other state beef programs. These concerns have driven producers in various other states to vote down new beef assessments.
These problems also abound in other contexts. A recent scandal came to light involving the American Egg Board, an industry-funded promotion group overseen by the United States Department of Agriculture. Investigations uncovered a board-funded “secret two-year war against a vegan mayonnaise competitor.” (Mohan, The egg industry launched a secret two-year war against a vegan mayonnaise competitor (Oct. 7, 2016) Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-egg-board-investigation-20161007-snap-story.html> (as of July 2, 2017).) It was discovered the board improperly wielded its power to attack Hampton Creek, a California-based sustainable food company with 150 employees, because its products competed against the egg industry and even found emails where the board’s leadership joked about killing the owner, Josh Tetrick. (Thielman, USDA scrambles to investigate egg lobby as CEO resigns (Oct. 23, 2015) <https://www.the guardian.com/business/2015/oct/23/usda-investigate-american-egg-board-hampton-creek-just-mayo> (as of July 2, 2017).)
Jordan Tetrick, director of retail for Hampton Creek, writes on behalf of the company in strong opposition to this bill: “The industrial meat industry shouldn’t be provided special privileges in a free market system, especially when it’s specifically designed to harm other businesses in our state that are working to create more efficient, sustainable, and healthy products for consumers.” Hampton Creek points out that checkoff dollars were directly devoted to harming his California-based company.
Food and Water Watch also points out these issues: “Conflicts of interest between the checkoff programs and commodity trade associations have abounded. Today, there is federal, bipartisan legislation in the U.S. Senate to convert mandatory checkoffs into voluntary programs, due to the checkered history of financial irregularities and conflicts of interest in federally-administered checkoff programs.”
The federal legislation cited was introduced by Senators Cory Booker and Mike Lee, entitled the Commodity Checkoff Program Improvement Act of 2016. In support of that legislation, New Jersey Democratic Senator Cory Booker stated: “When checkoff programs engage in anticompetitive activity, it is a threat to a dynamic and informed free marketplace.” Utah Republican Senator Mike Lee cited the egg scandal as an impetus for the bill, calling it a “classic case of Big Government and Big Business working together to squeeze out smaller rivals and squelch innovation.” Relevant provisions of the legislation would prohibit employees and agents of the checkoff boards from engaging in activities that may involve a conflict of interest; prohibit checkoff programs from contracting with any organization that lobbies on agricultural policy; and prohibit the programs from engaging in anticompetitive activity, unfair or deceptive acts or practices, or any act that may be disparaging to another agricultural commodity or product.
Given the “checkered history” of checkoff programs and the national movement away from expansion and toward tighter regulation to ensure more transparency and protection from anticompetitive conduct, it is arguably the wrong direction to create a Beef Commission with expanded powers to use checkoff funds to influence policymakers, allow that commission to keep the products of research and other public records from public view, and explicitly exempt that entity from antitrust and unfair practices laws.
4. Other provisions
There are other provisions of the bill that warrant some scrutiny for possibly unintended consequences.
- Implementation of operations
The Commission, as with other commissions and councils, would only come into being upon a successful implementation referendum vote. Other commissions have generally required participation in the implementation referendum vote of at least 40 percent of the eligible producers. In addition, implementation of most commissions has required either:
- 65 percent of the producers who voted in the referendum voted in favor of implementation and those in support made up a majority of the production or marketing of the commodity in the preceding year by all of the producers who voted in the referendum; or
- a majority of the producers who voted in the referendum voted in favor of implementation and comprised at least 65 percent of the production or marketing of the commodity in the preceding year by all of the producers who voted in the referendum.
(See e.g., Section 76312 (Sheep Commission); Section 79262 (Blueberry Commission); Section 76952 (Salmon Council).) These requirements ensure that the enactment of an advisory and promotional body is supported by a sufficient proportion of those working in the industry affected.
For implementation of the Commission, this bill would require the CDFA secretary to compile a list of eligible producers for such a vote. However, unlike other commissions, there would be no required threshold quorum required for the vote to be valid. Furthermore, only a majority of the producers who voted in the referendum would need to vote in favor of implementation in order to create the Commission and activate the new, mandatory fee.[1] This bill also would not set any minimum threshold for the percentage of the beef produced or marketed being represented in the vote in favor of implementation.
These aberrant standards leave open the possibility that cattle producers and dairy producers would be subject to a mandatory fee and the oversight of a new commission with only the approval of a small minority of the industry, both in terms of number of producers and share of the market.
- Civil Actions
This bill would authorize the Commission to bring actions against producers for nonpayment of fees and other violations of this bill. One provision reads: “Upon entry of any final judgment on behalf of the commission against any defendant, the court shall enjoin the defendant from conducting any type of business regarding cattle or beef until there is full compliance with, and satisfaction of, the judgment.” Although this provision is in the statutes governing other commissions, it appears overly harsh to enjoin a producer in the state from engaging in the producer’s livelihood immediately upon judgment. It is also counterproductive to the extent it restrains a defendant from earning income that may be necessary to satisfy the relevant judgment.
- Personal liability
This bill would provide that when a producer is formed as a corporation or limited liability company, the directors, officers, managers, and members of the corporation or limited liability company in their capacity as individuals shall be included, and any liability for failure to collect or make payment of fees to which a corporate handler or a handler that is a limited liability company may be subject pursuant to this bill shall include identical liability upon each individual director, officer, manager, or member of the corporation or limited liability company. As indicated by the large coalition in opposition to this bill:
AB 243 would subject business owners and operators to personal liability for assessment debts of the business. Such extraordinary terms would obliterate those corporate protections that are essential to entrepreneurship and a robust marketplace. Instead, a farmer’s personal and family belongings could be vulnerable, a threat that would be particularly hard-felt by small, family farming operations.
- Appointment of members
This bill would provide that the CDFA secretary shall appoint all of the members of the Commission. This distinguishes it from other commissions where members are generally elected by the producers or other persons in the industry subject to the commission’s jurisdiction. Nearly every other commission also ensures that various geographic regions within California are represented on a commission by electing members in distinct regional votes. This bill would not receive the benefits and safeguards that come with such a representative leadership structure.
- Codified legislative findings
This bill would also codify a series of legislative findings. Many of these findings indicate the benefits a strong beef industry provide California. However, some findings may overstate the findings and public policy of California. Specifically, this bill would codify that it is the finding of the Legislature that beef is “indispensable in a proper human diet” and declares the “essentiality of beef and beef products in proper human nutrition and to the maintenance of a high level of public health.”
5. Beef checkoff and the refund provision
The sponsor of this bill points to the refund provision, which would allow cattle producers and dairy farmers to seek a refund if they did not want to finance the Commission. However, if the goal is truly to enable cattle producers and dairy farmers who do not agree with the strategy, political activity, or other conduct of the Commission to opt out of the checkoff, a more meaningful mechanism would be to allow them to opt out at the point of payment, either in lieu of or in addition to the refund option. Especially for smaller ranching and dairy operations, the lag time for a refund and the record keeping necessary to seek the refund could be unduly onerous.
Support: Absher Land and Livestock Company; Butte County Cattlemen’s Association; California Teamsters Public Affairs Council; San Joaquin-Stanislaus Cattlemen’s Association; Ventura County Cattlemen’s Association; Western United Dairymen; eight individuals
Opposition: American Grassfed; California Dairy Campaign; California Farmers Union; Center for Food Safety; Center on Race, Poverty, and the Environment; Community Alliance for Agroecology; Community Alliance with Family Farmers; Consumer Federation of California; Ecological Farming Association; Food & Water Watch; Hampton Creek; Humane Society of the United States; Kern County Cattlemen’s Association; Markegard Family Grass-Fed LLC; National Family Farm Coalition; New Hope Farms; NRDC; Occidental Arts and Ecology Center; Organization for Competitive Markets; Paicines Ranch; Pesticide Action Network; Roots of Change; Sacramento Food Policy Council; Slow Food California; Snedden Ranch; Socially Responsible Agriculture Project; T.O. Cattle Company; TomKat Ranch; two individuals
HISTORY
Source: California Cattlemen’s Association
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: SB 866 (Costa, Ch. 291, Stats. 2001) eliminated the outright prohibition on funding brand name advertising by the California Beef Council, exempted from the checkoff assessment cattle under 300 pounds, and replaced the referendum approval procedures for increasing an assessment.
Prior Vote:
Senate Agriculture Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 3)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 17, Noes 0)
Assembly Agriculture Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Despite some contentions otherwise by those writing in support, upon a successful referendum vote to establish the Commission, a mandatory one dollar fee would go into effect to fund the Commission’s operations. It would be assessed on all heads of cattle, as specified. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE
Senator Cathleen Galgiani, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 243 Hearing Date: 6/20/17
Author: | Cooper | ||
Version: | 6/13/17 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Anne Megaro | ||
Subject: California Beef Commission
SUMMARY
:
This bill would create the California Beef Commission to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council, expand beef markets and improve competitiveness, conduct research, and negotiate with government agencies. This bill would prescribe membership, powers and duties, fees, actions and penalties, and implementation, continuation, and termination voting procedures. The commission would not become operative unless a favorable producer referendum vote occurs before June 1, 2019.
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
:
California marketing programs were created to provide a means for an agricultural industry, working within a defined organizational structure and under government oversight, to collectively address production, marketing, research, and educational issues of a particular agricultural commodity. There are three types of marketing programs: marketing orders, councils, and commissions. Although similar, each program functions in a slightly different way, such as the degree of autonomy and program authority. However, each marketing program is created at the request of the affected industry and requires an industry referendum vote before the program can operate.
Specific to commissions, there are currently 19 active commissions in California, all of which are governed by boards of directors and overseen by the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA). These commissions were created to enhance their industries by investing in promotion, advertising, education, marketing research, scientific research, and the creation and regulation of quality standards.
Commissions are industry-funded programs funded through grower and/or handler assessment fees. The industry pays for all costs of the commission, including all costs for governmental oversight. The fee rate may be prescribed in statute with the potential to be increased by a referendum vote of the commission.
California Beef Council. The California Beef Council (council) was established by law in 1954 to enable the cattle industry to develop, maintain, and expand markets for California beef and beef products, conduct research and educational programs, and to provide funds to administer the council. The council is comprised of 20 members and 20 alternates. Members are producers of feeder cattle, range cattle, and dairy cattle; packers and processors; and one public member.
In the 1985 federal Farm Bill, the national Beef Checkoff Program was established, which assesses $1 per head every time cattle are sold. Of that amount, 50 cents is used for the Cattlemen’s Beef Promotion and Research Board, and the remaining 50 cents is returned to the state to be used by the council only for activities approved by USDA. These activities do not include the use of any checkoff dollars for lobbying or to influence government policies or actions.
PROPOSED LAW
:
This bill:
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the production, processing, manufacture, and distribution of beef and beef products in California.
- Defines terms such as beef packer, beef products, and range cattle producer.
- Establishes the California Beef Commission consisting of 11 members and 11 alternates appointed by the secretary. Commission members may also be members of the California Beef Council and shall be California producers where at least three are range cattle producers, three are cattle feeders, three are dairy producers, one is a beef packer, and one is a public member.
- States the purpose of the commission is to augment and support the work of the California Beef Council; develop, maintain, and expand California beef in national and international markets; enhance the reputation of the California cattle industry and create a more receptive environment for producers to operate and improve competitiveness; conduct research relating to nutrition, consumption trends, sales stimulation, as well as educational programs designed to increase beef consumption; present facts and negotiate with government agencies and those effecting policy; and to provide funds to administer the commission.
- Restricts the public member and the member’s alternate from casting a vote on issues regarding assessment fees.
- Limits the terms of office for members and their alternates to no more than two consecutive three-year terms and provides the manner in which members are appointed or removed from the commission.
- Requires the commission to annually select a chair and vice chair, along with three other members selected by the commission, to serve on the executive committee. Allows the chair and the vice chair to also serve concurrently as the chair and vice chair of the California Beef Council, and allows the commission meetings to coincide with meetings of the California Beef Council.
- Provides for the reimbursement of travel expenses but does not provide a salary for commission members. Provides for reimbursement to the secretary for all expenses incurred in carrying out CDFA’s duties and responsibilities.
- Requires all funds to be deposited in a bank that meets specified requirements. Prohibits the commingling of commission and council funds.
- Authorizes the commission to sue and be sued and to enter into contracts. Exempts the state from liability from commission actions or contracts.
- Authorizes the commission to adopt and amend bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders, and to administer and enforce laws and regulations to promote, maintain, and enhance the California cattle industry and the production of beef and beef products.
- Authorizes the commission to employ an executive director and other personnel, which may be the same as those working for the council.
- Authorizes the commission, with approval of the secretary, to administer any governmental program related to California cattle, beef, and beef products industries.
- Authorizes the commission to create an advisory committee.
- Authorizes the commission to incur expenses, enter into contracts, create liabilities, control intellectual or physical property including real estate, and borrow funds. Allows these expenses to offset the expenses incurred by the council.
- Requires the commission to keep records and accounts of all transactions, dealings, contracts, agreements, funds, and expenditures as it deems necessary. These records shall be audited annually and be open to inspection and audited by the secretary as deemed necessary.
- Requires the commission to establish an annual budget and a statement of activities, in concurrence with the secretary, which shall be made available to all eligible producers upon request.
- Authorizes the commission to accept contributions from private, state and federal entities.
- Maintains the confidentiality of all proprietary information obtained or developed by the commission or the secretary, including names and addresses of producers, with exceptions.
- Authorizes the secretary to require that the commission correct or cease any activity that is not in the public interest or that is unlawful. The secretary shall only prohibit actions that are inconsistent with the powers and duties of the commission or that are not in the public interest.
- Requires that an implementation referendum vote be conducted before the commission becomes operative. A majority of eligible producers participating in the referendum must vote to approve the referendum before June 1, 2019.
- Prescribes implementation referendum procedures. Authorizes the secretary to hold additional implementation referendum votes one year or more after the previous vote has been taken upon the petition of a proponent of the commission.
- Provides that a termination referendum be held if 3,000 eligible producers send a petition to the secretary requesting the commission be terminated.
- Requires that 30% or more of all producers participate in a termination referendum and that a majority of those producers vote to terminate the commission in order for the secretary to declare the commission terminated at the end of the fiscal year.
- Requires that an assessment of $1 be paid on each head of cattle and calves sold, except for the sale of hides, cattle transported without a change of ownership, cattle slaughtered for the exclusive use of the owner, and any cattle weighing less than 200 pounds. The assessment shall not be charged more than once per owner of the same animal, and the assessment can only be raised by a majority referendum vote of the producers.
- Requires that all transactions subject to the assessment be recorded and made available to the secretary for inspection and audit.
- Requires the seller to pay the assessment fee, as specified, and provides for the collection of the assessment.
- Authorizes any person subject to the assessment to obtain an unconditional refund by submitting a claim to the commission within 90 days of the brand inspection or date the assessment was paid, whichever is later.
- Levies a civil penalty of $1,000 for any person who willfully falsifies, destroys, or fails to provide documents or records required by the commission.
- Authorizes the commission to establish procedures for individuals aggrieved by its actions, including appeals and judicial review.
- Authorizes the commission to commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law for the collection of fees and civil penalties.
- Repeals the requirement that a purchaser pay the $1 checkoff fee if the fee is not deducted from the seller.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the author, “A majority of California cattle producers have expressed their interest in increasing the mandatory assessment on the sale of cattle in California, but want to ensure that any increase in fees benefits California ranchers and is not subject to rules and regulations under national Beef Research and Promotion Act. To address this issue, AB 243 will establish the California Beef Commission [CBC] which will function solely as a California marketing and promotional agency and will have no official association with national Act.”
The author continues, “Supporters state the CBC, under the oversight of CDFA, will serve as a partner of the Council, capitalizing on the use of joint resources between the two agencies, but will also maintain a clear separation in the collection and allocation of funds dispersed by the CBC. AB 243 respects the rights of ranchers to formerly [sic] levy an assessment on themselves to fund promotion, educational and research efforts that benefit everyone in the industry. AB 243 will not increase the beef checkoff. In turn, the bill establishes an open and transparent process by CDFA to conduct a vote of beef and dairy producers in California to approve the formation of the CBC and an increase in the beef checkoff. Simply stated, any increase in the beef checkoff will be done by a vote of California’s producers, not the legislature. In addition, AB 243 provides the ability for a producer not wishing to contribute funds to the CBC to receive a full refund without prejudice.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the Kern County Cattlemen’s Association, the sponsor of this bill represents a small percentage of the state’s cattle producers, and in 2012, producers voted to reject a state beef checkoff increase, which should signal that cattle producers no longer want to be forced to have the government serve as the ad agency for beef products. “AB 243 would establish a state agency called the California Beef Commission, appointed by the CDFA Secretary, that would be given power and money without an effective system of accountability or transparency. […] AB 243 empowers the unelected Commission to access producers’ private information, commence civil actions against producers and levy assessments as well as civil penalties of up to $1,000 and make determinations regarding refunds of assessments to producers.”
According to a coalition letter including many of those in opposition, concerns include a weakening of the democratic process and failure to cap fees; allowing the commission to control the state’s checkoff program; exempting all commission activities from antitrust and unfair practices laws; weakening the secretary’s control of the checkoff program; making farmers personally liable for corporate debts; requiring small-scale beef producers providing non-commodity beef products to pay into a marketing program that does not serve their business interests, ethics, or values; creating the illusion of a voluntary checkoff program; corruptibility of similar programs in other states, lack of transparency and accountability; use of funds for promoting beef raised outside of California; and failure of other states to continue or start checkoff programs.
COMMENTS
:
Commissions vs. councils. Under the California Marketing Act, commodity-specific councils and commissions are created to conduct activities related to promotion, advertising, education, and research. Although fairly similar, marketing commissions and councils differ in that councils are advisory to CDFA, and all actions are subject to CDFA’s approval. On the other hand, commissions do not serve an advisory function and need only CDFA’s concurrence in their annual budget and proposed activities. However, CDFA can issue cease and desist orders if the commission is not acting in the public’s interest. Commissions are not authorized to participate in lobbying efforts but they can provide informational materials and position letters on specific pieces of legislation.
Refundable assessment. The California Beef Commission would differ from every other California commission in three key ways. First, it would allow the assessment to be fully refundable, meaning that if affected parties wish to not participate in the commission they can request and will receive a full refund. Second, this bill would require a majority of producers, rather than 65%, as the minimum threshold vote required for the affirmative implementation and termination of the commission. Third, this bill would not require an automatic continuation hearing or referendum vote every five years. Such a hearing or vote offers a formal process for members’ concerns to be heard and gives them the opportunity to request that the commission be continued or terminated. As the bill is currently written, the commission can be terminated only by a petition of 3,000 or more members requesting that a termination referendum vote be held. The committee is working with the author to add an amendment that would require a hearing every five years; however, negotiations could not be completed in time for the bill’s hearing in the Senate Agriculture Committee. These amendments will be further discussed in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Checkoff increase. In 2012, a vote was held to determine whether the checkoff rate of $1 should be increased to $2. The rate had not increased since 1985, and it was therefore argued that an increase was needed to keep pace with inflation. The affirmative vote threshold was 60%, and the final vote resulted in 55% in favor and 45% opposed.
Commissions. Several existing commissions have been successful in achieving goals of improving product quality, expanding markets, funding research, and establishing product grades and standards. However, there have been, and are currently pending, lawsuits against the department and marketing programs for violations of free speech rights in regards to mandatory assessments used for commodity marketing and advertising. In short, the argument is that these assessment fees could be used by individual farms/ranches to promote their brand and individual product rather than the commodity in general.
Double referral. The Senate Rules Committee has double referred this bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee as the second committee of referral. Therefore, if this measure is approved by this committee, the motion should include an action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Committee on Judiciary.
RELATED LEGISLATION
:
AB 944 (Limón) of 2017. Would create the California Spiny Lobster Commission to maintain the spiny lobster commercial fishing industry through research, promotion, and education. Currently in the Senate Agriculture Committee.
SB 250 (Wolk), Chapter 344, Statutes of 2013. Creates the Olive Oil Commission of California to engage in olive oil quality and nutritional research and to recommend grades and labeling standards. The commission does not become operative until a favorable producer referendum vote.
AB 2695 (Hernandez), Chapter 605, Statutes of 2010. Creates the California Nursery Producers Commission with prescribed membership, powers, duties, and responsibilities. Authorized the commission to engage in outreach, education, promotion, marketing, and research relating to nursery products.
PRIOR ACTIONS
:
Assembly Floor: | 76 - 3 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 17 - 0 |
Assembly Agriculture Committee: | 10 - 0 |
SUPPORT
:
California Cattlemen’s Association (sponsor)
Absher Land & Livestock Co.
Butte County Cattlemen’s Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
San Joaquin – Stanislaus Cattlemen’s Association
Ventura County Cattlemen’s Association
Western United Dairymen
8 individual ranchers and beef cattle producers
OPPOSITION
:
American Grassfed
California Dairy Campaign
California Farmers Union
Center for Food Safety
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Community Alliance for Agroecology
Community Alliance with Family Farmers
Consumer Federation of California
Ecological Farming Association
Food and Water Watch
Humane Society of the United State, The
Kern County Cattlemen’s Association
Markegard Family Grass-Fed LLC
Morris Grassfed Beef
National Family Farm Coalition
Natural Resources Defense Council
Occidental Arts & Ecology Center
Organization for Competitive Markets
Paicines Ranch
Pesticide Action Network, North America
Roots of Change
Sacramento Food Policy Council
Slow Food California
Snedden Ranch
Socially Responsible Agriculture Project
T.O. Cattle Company
TomKat Ranch
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 243
Author:(Cooper)
As Amended Ver:April 18, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Agriculture | 10-0 | Caballero, Mathis, Aguiar-Curry, Flora, Gallagher, Gray, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Quirk, Salas | |
Appropriations | 17-0 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bigelow, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Fong, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Muratsuchi, Obernolte, Reyes, Gonzalez Fletcher, Bigelow, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Fong, Friedman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Muratsuchi, Obernolte, Reyes |
|
SUMMARY: This bill creates the California Beef Commission (CBC) for the purposes of marketing, public information and research related to California beef. Specifically, this bill:
- States the purpose of the CBC is to:
- Support and enhance to work of the California Beef Council (Council);
- Help California beef producers develop, maintain and expand beef markets;
- Enhance the reputation and improve the competiveness of California beef producers, both nationally and internationally;
- Allow the Secretary (Secretary) of the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) and the CBC board to develop and implement research related to beef production and consumption;
- Allow CBC to produce and distribute information related to beef to public and private agencies, groups and individuals; and,
- Provide funds to administer the work of the CBC from mandatory fees on beef producers, as specified.
- Creates a CBC board of directors (board) composed of 11 members as follows: at least three range cattlemen, three cattle feeders, three dairymen, one beef packer, and one public member appointed by the Secretary of CDFA. Provides for duties of the board, as specified.
- Allows the Secretary to require CBC to correct or cease any activity or function that is determined not to be in the public interest or is in violation of this chapter. Upon CBC refusal or failure to comply, the Secretary may, upon written notice, suspend CBC activities or functions. Allows either party to seek judicial relief in court.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill has modest ongoing costs of approximately $24,000 to CDFA as a result of their involvement in the operations of CBC. These costs would be reimbursed by the Commission.
COMMENT: The Council was created by the Legislature more than 50 years ago to serve as a marketing advisory and promotional agency for California beef and cattle producers. The Council is also in charge of implementing the National Beef Promotion and Research Act (NBPRA) enacted under the 1985 Farm Bill. California and federal law established a mandatory $1 assessment that is collected at the point of sale for all cattle changing ownership in California.
According to the author, a majority of California cattle producers have expressed their interest in increasing the mandatory assessment on the sale of cattle in California, but want to ensure that any increase in fees benefits California ranchers and is not subject to rules and regulations under NBPRA.
To address this issue, this bill will establish the CBC, which will function solely as a California marketing and promotional agency, and will have no official association with NBPRA. Supporters state CBC, under the oversight of CDFA, will serve as a partner of the Council, capitalizing on the use of joint resources between the two agencies, but will also maintain a clear separation in the collection and allocation of funds dispersed by the CBC.
The proposed CBC has two main differences from the way most recent marketing commissions operate. The first is that CBC can be established with a majority vote in a referendum, while most commissions need a 65% vote to be established. The second way it is different is the ability of those who have to pay the CBC fee to petition for a refund if they do not want to pay the fee. These two unique features make it easier for CBC to be formed, but give fee payers a way to "opt-out" if they object to the fees.
Opponents state that this bill would have a direct negative impact on their constitutional rights and their businesses. The opponents state that the fee charged by the Council and by the proposed CBC is a tax and unconstitutional. Furthermore, they state that CBC would be an unelected body with the power to levy fees, access private information and implement other duties.
Supporters state that "AB 243 respects the rights of ranchers to formerly levy an assessment on themselves to fund promotion, educational and research efforts that benefit everyone in the industry. AB 243 will not increase the beef checkoff. In turn, the bill establishes an open and transparent process by CDFA to conduct a vote of beef and dairy producers in California to approve the formation of the CBC and an increase in the beef checkoff. Simply stated, any increase in the beef checkoff will be done by a vote of California’s producers, not the legislature. In addition, AB 243 provides the ability for a producer not wishing to contribute funds to the CBC to receive a full refund without prejudice."
For accomplishing the purposes stated by the author for this industry, a commission may be an appropriate entity. Current commissions and marketing orders have been successful in expanding markets, improving product quality, and providing more research for pests and disease prevention. In recent years, one commission was terminated by the industry and another had an audit by the Secretary, which revealed potential misuse of funds. This bill has language requiring annual audits, and upon determination of the need, the Secretary may conduct a fiscal and administrative audit of CBC.
Analysis Prepared by: Victor Francovich / AGRI. / (916) 319-2084 FN: 0000308
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 243
Author:(Cooper) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2017
Policy Committee: | Agriculture | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill creates the California Beef Commission (Commission), defines its organizational structure and intended purpose, and allows the Commission to assess fees from members.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Modest ongoing costs of approximately $24,000 to the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) as a result of their involvement in the operations of the Commission. These costs would be reimbursed by the Commission.
COMMENTS:
Background and Purpose. The California Beef Council (Council) was created by the Legislature more than 50 years ago to serve as a marketing advisory and promotional agency for California beef and cattle producers. The Council is also in charge of implementing the National Beef Promotion and Research Act (NBPRA) enacted under the 1985 Farm Bill. California and federal law establish a mandatory one dollar ($1) assessment that is collected at the point of sale for all cattle changing ownership in California.
According to the author, a majority of California cattle producers have expressed their interest in increasing the mandatory assessment on the sale of cattle in California, but want to ensure that any increase in fees benefits California ranchers and is not subject to rules and regulations under NBPRA. AB 243 will establish the Commission, which will function solely as a California marketing and promotional agency. Supporters state that under the oversight of CDFA, the Commission will be a partner of the Council.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE
Anna Caballero, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 243
Author:Cooper – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2017
SUBJECT: California Beef Commission.
SUMMARY: This bill creates the California Beef Commission (CBC) for the purposes of marketing, public information and research related to California beef. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes findings and declarations related to beef production important to California, the impact of beef production on the state's economy, the importance of informing consumers of the benefits of beef and the need for rigorous scientific research related to health and safety related to beef production.
- States the purpose of the CBC is to:
- Support and enhance to work of the California Beef Council (Council);
- Help California beef producers develop, maintain and expand beef markets;
- Enhance the reputation and improve the competiveness of California beef producers, both nationally and internationally;
- Allow the Secretary (Secretary) of the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) and the CBC board to develop and implement research related to beef production and consumption;
- Allow CBC to produce and distribute information related to beef to public and private agencies, groups and individuals; and,
- Provide funds to administer the work of the CBC from mandatory fees on beef producers, as specified.
- States that action taken by the CBC, under authority of the CBC law, is not a violation of restraints on competition laws, unfair practices laws or other laws related to monopolies or restraint of trade, as specified.
- Defines beef, beef packers, beef products, cattle and beef cattle, producer and range cattle producer, for the purposes of the CBC.
- Creates a CBC board of directors (board) composed of 11 members as follows: at least three range cattlemen, three cattle feeders, three dairymen, one beef packer and one public member appointed by the Secretary of CDFA. Provides for alternate members and an ex-officio member.
- Prohibits the public member and their alternate from voting on issues related to fees.
- Prohibits the public member and their alternate from voting on issues related to fees.
- Requires the CBC board terms are for three years and can serve no more than two consecutive terms.
- Requires a majority of the board to conduct any CBC business, as specified.
- Requires the board to annually select a chair and vice chair, who with three other board members act as an executive committee.
- Requires the executive committee to have the full powers of the CBC, as specified.
- Allows the chair and vice chair to concurrently serve as the chair and vice chair of the Council, at the CBC discretion.
- Requires the CBC to have two regular meetings a year, as specified, in concurrence with the Council, as specified.
- Allows for additional CBC meetings called for by the chair or upon written request by three CBC members.
- Requires the CBC executive committee to hold at least two meetings per year, as specified.
- Requires members of the commission to be reimbursed for traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties, unless they have been reimbursed by the Council for the same expenses. Provides for alternate members' reimbursements, as specified.
- Requires the Secretary, or a representative, to be notified and allowed to attend meetings of the board, except for executive sessions called for the purpose of discussing litigation against CDFA.
- Provides that no member of the board or any committee shall receive a salary. Except for ex-officio members, members may receive reasonable and necessary traveling expenses and meal allowances for attendance at meetings or a special assignment.
- Requires that all monies received by any person from assessments levied under this chapter be deposited in bank(s) of the board’s choosing.
- Relieves the state of any liability for actions of CBC or its contracts. No member, employee or agent of CBC shall be personally liable for contracts or responsible individually for any error except for their own acts of dishonesty or crime.
- Allows the CBC to sue and be sued and enter into contracts.
- Allows, but does not limit, the board to perform the following powers and duties:
- Adopt and amend bylaws, rules, regulations, and orders;
- Administer and enforce this chapter;
- Appoint officers and employ persons to serve as executive officer, legal counsel, or other personnel;
- Allows the executive officer and CBC staff to serve in the same positon on the Council, at the CBC discretion;
- Administer any governmental program related to California beef production, as specified.
- Appoint committees;
- Fix compensation for employees;
- Establish offices and incur expenses, invest funds, enter into contracts and agreements, and create liabilities and borrow funds;
- Allows these offices to be in the same location as the Council.
- Record and keep accurate books and accounts which are subject to CDFA inspection and annual audit, as specified, and include the audit in the CBC annual report to CDFA;
- Present facts and negotiate with state, federal and foreign agencies;
- Accept contributions from private, state, and federal entities to carry out CBC duties;
- Collect information on California beef and dairy production, and distribute periodic communications to producers;
- Establish an assessment rate;
- Establish an annual budget which shall be concurred in by the Secretary; and,
- Submit an annual statement of activities for concurrence by the Secretary.
- Allows the Secretary to require CBC to correct or cease any activity or function that is determined not to be in the public interest or is in violation of this chapter. Upon CBC refusal or failure to comply, the Secretary may, upon written notice, suspend CBC activities or functions. Allows either party to seek judicial relief in court.
- Requires CBC to reimburse CDFA for all expenditures incurred in carrying out this chapter, as specified.
- Requires on or before June 1, 2018, the Council to provide a list of producers eligible for a referendum vote to the Secretary.
- Allows the Secretary to require auction yards and beef packers to submit all the names and addresses for all persons from whom they received cattle in the previous fiscal year, to further ensure a list of those eligible to vote in the referendum.
- Requires a majority vote of participating producers, in a referendum operated by the Secretary on or before June 1, 2019, for the CBC to become operative.
- Requires the Secretary to hold a referendum to suspend the CBC, if the Secretary receives a petition for referendum to dissolve the CBC signed by 3,000 eligible producers.
- Requires, upon the passage of a referendum to dissolve the CBC, for the Secretary to terminate the CBC.
- Establishes a fee of one dollar ($1) per head on each sale of cattle or calves, as specified.
- Prohibits the fee to be charged or collected more than once from each owner of the same animal.
- Requires persons who pay or collect the fee to maintain records of all transactions for two years and have the records available for inspection or audit.
- Allows for a fee of more than one dollar ($1), if CBC members call for and approve a referendum to raise the fee, as specified.
- Requires the fee to be to be paid by the seller, collected by the stockyard, auctions house or slaughter facility, and then be given to the CBC by the 15th of the month following the sale, as specified.
- Fees not paid in this manner will be collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification from the seller.
- Fees not paid in this manner will be collected by the Bureau of Livestock Identification from the seller.
- Allows any person subject to the CBC fee may obtain a refund of the fee by filing a request for refund within 90 days of paying the fee.
- Provides that all proprietary information be confidential.
- Allows CBC to levy civil penalties not exceeding $1,000 for persons who furnish false documents to avoid paying assessment fees and for persons who destroy, alter, refuse, or fail to furnish reports or records required to be kept by this chapter.
- Establishes procedures for individuals aggrieved by its actions, including appeals and judicial review.
- Allows CBC to commence civil actions and utilize all remedies provided in law for collection of assessments and civil penalties.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Council, to perform promotion, research and education duties relating to the California beef industry. The Council Law establishes a one dollar ($1) fee per head on each sale of cattle and calves to administer the Council. Half of this fee stays in state, with the rest going to the Cattlemen's Beef Promotion and Research Board.
- Authorizes various marketing and promotion commissions (commissions) to promote the production and marketing of California agricultural commodities. Commissions have a variety of powers covering promotion, advertising, education, production or post-harvest research, and quality standards and inspections. Commissions cover a variety of commodities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: The Council was created by the Legislature more than 50 years ago to serve as a marketing advisory and promotional agency for California beef and cattle producers. The Council is also in charge of implementing the National Beef Promotion and Research Act (NBPRA) enacted under the 1985 Farm Bill. California and federal law establish a mandatory one dollar ($1) assessment that is collected at the point of sale for all cattle changing ownership in California.
Fifty cents ($.50) is retained in California for use by the Council and fifty cents ($.50) is appropriated to the Cattlemen’s Beef Board which administers the national Beef Checkoff Program. As such, the use of the funds currently allocated to the Council is subject to oversight and regulation by USDA
According to the author, a majority of California cattle producers have expressed their interest in increasing the mandatory assessment on the sale of cattle in California, but want to ensure that any increase in fees benefits California ranchers and is not subject to rules and regulations under NBPRA.
To address this issue, AB 243 will establish the CBC which will function solely as a California marketing and promotional agency and will have no official association with NBPRA. Supporters state the CBC, under the oversight of CDFA, will serve as a partner of the Council, capitalizing on the use of joint resources between the two agencies, but will also maintain a clear separation in the collection and allocation of funds dispersed by the CBC.
The proposed CBC has two main differences from the way most recent marketing commission operate. The first is that the CBC can be established with a majority vote in a referendum, while most commissions need a 65% vote to be established. The second way it is different is the ability of these who have to pay the CBC fee to petition for a refund if they do not want to pay the fee. These two unique features make it easier for the CBC to be formed, but give fee payers a way to "opt-out" if they object to the fees.
Opponents state that this bill would have direct negative impact on their constitutional right and their businesses. The opponents state that the fee charged by the Council and by the proposed CBC is a tax and unconstitutional. Furthermore they state that the commission is an unelected body with the power to levy fees, access private information and implement other duties.
Supporters state that "AB 243 respects the rights of ranchers to formerly levy an assessment on themselves to fund promotion, educational and research efforts that benefit everyone in the industry. AB 243 will not increase the beef checkoff. In turn, the bill establishes an open and transparent process by CDFA to conduct a vote of beef and dairy producers in California to approve the formation of the CBC and an increase in the beef checkoff. Simply stated, any increase in the beef checkoff will be done by a vote of California’s producers, not the legislature. In addition, AB 243 provides the ability for a producer not wishing to contribute funds to the CBC to receive a full refund without prejudice".
The purpose of marketing programs is to provide agricultural producers and handlers an organizational structure, operating under government sanction, which allows them to solve production and marketing problems collectively that could not be addressed individually. Current marketing programs’ activities include commodity promotion, research, and maintenance of quality standards. Commissions provide a structure for solving problems and also provide a vehicle for collecting funds to support activities.
For accomplishing the purposes stated by the author for this industry, a commission may be an appropriate entity. Current commissions and marketing orders have been successful in expanding markets, improving product quality, and providing more research for pests and disease prevention. In recent years, one commission was terminated by the industry and another had an audit by the Secretary, which revealed potential misuse of funds. This bill has language requiring annual audits, and upon determination of the need, the Secretary may conduct a fiscal and administrative audit of CBC.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Cattlemen's Association (Sponsor)
Individual Cattle Ranchers (8)
Opposition
Kern County Cattlemen Association
Snedden Ranch
Analysis Prepared by: Victor Francovich / AGRI. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Agriculture
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):