AB 2446: Courts: judgeships.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-02-14
Existing law specifies the number of judges for the superior court of each county and for each division of each district of the court of appeal. Existing law provides that the Court of Appeal for the 4th Appellate District consists of 3 divisions. Existing law requires that one of these divisions hold its regular sessions in the San Bernardino/Riverside area and further requires this division to have 7 judges.
This bill would increase the number of judges in the division of the Court of Appeal for the 4th Appellate District located in the San Bernardino/Riverside area to 8 judges. The bill would appropriate $1,202,000 from the General Fund to the judicial branch for the purpose of funding the cost of that new appellate court justice and accompanying staff.
Existing law allocates additional judgeships to the various counties in accordance with uniform standards for factually determining additional need in each county, as approved by the Judicial Council. Existing law requires the Judicial Council to report biennially to the Legislature and the Governor on the factually determined need for new judgeships in each superior court using those uniform criteria for allocation of judgeships. Existing law authorizes 50 additional judges, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to be allocated to the various county superior courts, pursuant to uniform criteria approved by the Judicial Council.
This bill would appropriate $14,813,000 from the General Fund to the judicial branch for the purpose of funding the cost of 10 of those 50 judgeships and accompanying staff.
The Court of Appeal for the Fourth Appellate District consists of three divisions. One division shall hold its regular sessions at San Diego and shall have 10 judges. One division shall hold its regular sessions in the San Bernardino/Riverside area and shall have seven eight judges. One division shall hold its regular sessions in Orange County and shall have eight judges.
SEC. 2.The sum of sixteen million fifteen thousand dollars ($16,015,000) is hereby appropriated from the General Fund to the judicial branch for the following purposes:
(a)The sum of one million two hundred two thousand dollars ($1,202,000) shall be used by the judicial branch to fund the cost of a new appellate court justice and accompanying staff pursuant to Section 69104 of the Government Code.
(b)The sum of fourteen million eight hundred thirteen thousand dollars ($14,813,000) shall be used by the judicial branch to fund the cost of 10 of the 50 new judgeships, and accompanying staff, pursuant to Section 69614.2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 25, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 2, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 17, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 5, 2018 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 2, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2446
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2018
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill appropriates $16.015 million from the General Fund to pay for one additional appellate court justice in the San Bernardino/Riverside area and ten additional judges and supporting staff statewide.
FISCAL EFFECT:
$16.015 million appropriation from the General Fund.
COMMENTS:
The courts have been chronically underfunded. As statute requires, Judicial Council reports to the Legislature an assessment of its workload needs. In November of 2016, the council had identified “critical need” for judges statewide, particularly in the San Bernardino region. Specifically, the assessment identified a need for 189 judges statewide.
Recently, the Legislature has responded, modestly, to this need for judgeships. In 2014, Senator Roth introduced SB 229, which would have appropriated $5 million from the General Fund to pay for 12 superior court judge positions. The bill passed the Legislature but was vetoed by Governor Brown. The governor acknowledged the need for additional judges in many courts. However, he expressed his intention to work with the Judicial Council before authorizing additional funding.
Four years later, and the need for judges remains.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2446
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2018
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Courts: judgeships
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE APPROPRIATE $16,015,000 FROM THE GENERAL FUND TO FUND ONE APPELLATE AND TEN SUPERIOR COURT JUDICIAL POSITIONS, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL’S 2018 JUDICIAL NEEDS STUDY?
SYNOPSIS
This non-controversial bill is the latest in a series of bills seeking to appropriate the funding for some or all of the 50 new judgeship positions authorized by the Legislature in 2007. Since 2011, there have been several bills seeking to fund these positions that have all failed passage or been vetoed by Governor Brown due to budget constraints. Although the budget constraints facing the state over the past decade have been serious and required the prioritization of General Fund resources, the lack of investment in new judges is straining California’s court system and creating significant delays in many civil law proceedings. In light of California’s approximately $6 billion budget surplus, this modest proposal seeks just over $16 million to fund the eleven most critically needed judicial positions in some of California’s fastest growing regions. Specifically, this bill seeks to provide funding for one appellate judge in the Inland Empire region of Southern California and an additional ten Superior Court judges to be allocated pursuant to the Judicial Council’s bi-annual Update of Judicial Needs Study, which is scheduled to be updated in November of this year.
The Judicial Council’s most recent judicial needs study, issued in November 2016, suggested that California needs an additional 180 judges in order to adequately staff the courts and ensure that Californians can seek justice in a timely manner. Although this bill provides far fewer judges than are needed to fully address the statewide needs of California’s courts, this bill is a modest first step to authorize additional judges to alleviate the most pressing judicial shortages and begin to alleviate the backlogs that plague California’s court system. This bill has strong support from the Judicial Council of California, the California Judges Association, and the County of San Bernardino, and has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Appropriates $16,015,000 from the General Fund to the judicial branch to create 11 new judgeships and provide the necessary funding for associated judicial staff. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases the number of judges on the Court of Appeal for the Fourth District from 25 to 26, assigns the additional judge to the division in the San Bernardino/ Riverside area, and appropriates $1,202,000 to provide for the additional judge and associated staff.
- Appropriates $14,813,000 to the judicial branch to fund ten judgeships, and associated staff, in accordance with priorities established in the bi-annual Update of Judicial Needs Study.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the Legislature shall prescribe the number of judges and provide for the officers and employees of each superior court. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 4.)
- Provides that the Legislature may provide for the trial courts to appoint officers such as commissioners to perform subordinate judicial duties. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 22.)
- Authorizes the courts to appoint subordinate judicial officers, and sets forth their duties and titles. (Government Code Section 71622.)
- Sets forth the specific number of trial court judges in each county. (Government Code Section 9580 et seq.)
- Authorizes 50 new trial court judgeships pursuant to appropriation by the Legislature in 2006-07. Also requires the Judicial Council to update its Judicial Needs Study every other year, based on the most recent prior three years’ filings data, and report that information to the Legislature. (Government Code Section 69614.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Since the Great Recession in 2008, California has not authorized any meaningful new funding for judgeships across the state. As a result, the caseloads of sitting judges have increased significantly, resulting in significant delays in most civil cases, including family court. To begin to remedy the need for additional judges, and in light of the state’s current budget surplus, the author introduced this bill as a scaled back version of prior judicial funding measures. In support of this bill the author notes:
This bill is crucial to addressing the extreme justice shortage throughout the state. In 2006, there was a plan to create and fund 150 judgeships in California. The 2007 Budget Act funded 50 judges but every attempt since then has failed. AB 2446 would provide funding for 10 new trial court judgeships statewide and will also increase the number of appellate justices (with funding) from seven to eight in the San Bernardino/ Riverside Division of the 4th Appellate District Court of Appeal. Due to the delay in authorization and funding of judgeships, growth in population, and the growth in court workload the number of trial court judges needed has continued to increase.
Even though this bill wouldn’t solve California’s justice shortage, it would be a huge step in the right direction. We need to ensure that the public has a timely access to justice.
Historically, Courts Were County-Funded Entities and Funding Levels Varied Enormously Across the State: Until the late 1990s, trial courts in California were county entities, funded by the counties. Accordingly, funding levels varied dramatically between counties resulting in different levels of court services across the state. While visiting all 58 county courts, then-Chief Justice Ronald George discovered that chronic under-funding of many courts in the county-based court system substantially impaired access to justice, including “woefully inadequate facilities, insufficient staff, unavailable interpreter services, and antiquated information processing systems.” In his first year as chief justice, Chief Justice George twice had to seek emergency funding from the Legislature in order to prevent the shutdown of some county trial court operations. In 1997, after significant problems came to light with the county-based court funding model, the Legislature passed the Lockyer-Isenberg Trial Court Funding Act, AB 233 (Escutia & Pringle, Chap. 850, Stats. 1997.), requiring the state to assume responsibility for funding the courts and helping to ensure equal access to a quality judicial system statewide.
After the state took over funding, the courts received significant funding increases and the historically underfunded counties began to see infusions of new funding from the state. However, most of the state funding continued to be distributed based on the courts' historical allocations, so courts that had been better funded by their counties remained better funded by the state, and courts that had been underfunded by their counties still struggled to generate enough revenue to maintain full access to legal services.
Early success in providing judges to courts to address California’s growing population. Beginning in 2005, the Judicial Council began seeking legislative authorization and funding for additional trial court judges to address judicial shortfalls resulting from population growth. At that time, the Judicial Council reported that the state faced a "judicial gap" that portended a number of troubling long term consequences: a significant decrease in Californians' access to the courts; compromised public safety; an unstable business environment; and, in some courts, enormous backlogs that inhibit fair, timely, and equitable justice. According to the Judicial Council, that judicial gap arose because the number of trial court judges has not kept pace with population growth, and the resulting increased demand on the courts. At the time the Judicial Council noted that, between 1990 and 2000, for example, California's population grew by over 16 percent; yet at the time the number of new judgeships created by the Legislature grew by less than three percent.
At that time, the Judicial Council pointed out that its uniform and objective assessment criteria contained in its 2001 and 2004 Judicial Needs Studies identified a statewide need for 355 new trial court judgeships. However, in consideration of the state's ongoing budget woes, the Council initially suggested a need for 150 new judgeships over that next three years. In response to the need, the Legislature passed SB 56 (Dunn, Chap. 390, Stats. 2006), which authorized, upon appropriation, 50 new trial court judgeships. Funding for those positions was provided in the budget that year. The next 50 trial court judges were authorized in AB 159 (Jones), Chap. 722, Stats. 2007, however, the requisite funding for those 50 positions was not part of AB 159 and was not included in that fiscal year’s budget.
Ten years later and it’s still the Great Recession’s fault. Shortly after the passage of AB 159, the financial markets crashed, the Great Recession took hold, and California’s budget woes became a full blown crisis. Faced with billions of dollars of budget cuts, the funding of the 50 judicial positions authorized by AB 159, and the authorization and funding of the next 50 positions, became luxuries the state could not afford.
As California’s economy and budget improved new attempts funding judicial positions began. Since 2011, several bills have attempted to fund or authorize additional judicial positions including, AB 1313 (Donnelly, 2013), SB 1190 (Jackson, 2014), and SB 229 (Roth, 2015). All of those measures have failed in the Legislature or been vetoed by the Governor due to cost or failure to adhere to the Judicial Council’s needs assessment process.
Another, smaller, bite at the judicial funding apple. This bill seeks to capitalize on California’s improved budget outlook, while recognizing ongoing budget constraints will limit the state’s ability to commit to significant ongoing expenditures. In recognition of the constant constraints on California’s budget, this bill seeks to fund the fewest number of judges, eleven, of any of its predecessors. However, this bill also recognizes that California must address its current shortfall in judicial needs. California courts are experiencing many of the pitfalls the Judicial Council warned about in the mid-2000’s including overburdened judges, delayed proceedings, and an unstable business environment as civil litigation languishes for years without resolution. Although criminal courts remain functioning, as of November 2016, the Judicial Council reports an additional 180 judges are needed to handle current caseloads across California’s 58 county court systems.
To strike a balance between budget constraints and judicial needs this bill authorizes one additional appellate judge for the Inland Empire area of Southern California, an area the Judicial Council notes will be the 10th largest metro area in the nation by 2046, and ten new judges to be allocated in accordance with the Judicial Council’s bi-annual Update of Judicial Needs Study. Assuming this bill takes effect on January 1, 2019; those judges would be allocated in accordance with an updated Judicial Needs Study, set to be released in November 2018. Based on the 2016 update these judges would be allocated to Superior Courts in Kern, Riverside and San Bernardino Counties, based on then-existing population and needs data. Given the sizable need for additional judges in the Inland Empire counties; the Judicial Council does not anticipate a significant change from the 2016 allocation of the first ten judges.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the Judicial Council of California argues that the additional judgeships are necessary to meet the workload currently handled by the courts. The Judicial Council notes:
A detailed analysis required by state law of judicial workload conducted in 2016 identified a need for more than 180 additional judges statewide…In that report six of the first ten judges are needed in the Inland Empire counties of Riverside and San Bernardino.
Additionally, the County of San Bernardino notes that the San Bernardino County Superior Court processes one of the highest caseloads of any court statewide and has one of the largest judicial staffing shortages of any court. They note that this bill will begin to address this staffing shortage and provide greater access to justice for the residents of the County.
Prior Related Legislation: SB 229 (Roth, 2015) would have appropriated $5,000,000 from the General Fund for the purpose of funding 12 superior court judge positions in judgeships currently authorized by the Legislature. That bill was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 1190 (Jackson, 2014) would have provided an unspecified appropriation from the General Fund for an additional judge for the Court of Appeal for the Fourth District in the San Bernardino/ Riverside and an unspecified number of judges previously authorized by AB 159. That bill was held on the Suspense File in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1313 (Donnelly, 2013) would have allocated up to 12 additional judges each fiscal year to those counties in which the current judicial position allocations are disproportionate to the Judicial Council’s recommendation of assessed judicial need. That bill failed passage in this Committee as it did not follow the existing process for basing judgeships on the Judicial Council’s Update of Judicial Needs Study.
SB 377 (Corbett, 2009), would have, upon appropriation in the Budget Act, established 50 new superior court judgeships. This bill was held under submission in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1150 (Corbett, 2008), would have, upon appropriation by the Legislature, established 50 new superior court judgeships in the 2009-10 fiscal year. This bill was held under submission in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 159 (Jones, Ch. 722, Stats. 2007), authorized 50 additional superior court judgeships and enacted additional reporting requirements regarding the diversity of the applicant pool for judgeships.
SB 56 (Dunn, Ch. 390, Stats. 2006), authorized 50 additional superior court judgeships and required reporting on the diversity of judges and the applicant pool for judgeships.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Judges Association
County of San Bernardino
Judicial Council of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):