AB 2570: School facilities: Clean and Healthy Schools Act: environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-07-05
Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to give diligent care to the health and physical development of pupils. Existing law requires the State Department of Education, in cooperation with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health within the Department of Industrial Relations, to formulate a listing of chemical compounds used in school programs that includes the potential hazards and estimated shelf life of each compound.
This bill would create the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and would make findings and declarations regarding indoor air quality and cleaning products. The bill would require school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils, local educational agencies, defined as school districts, county offices of education, and charter schools, with more than 2,500 units of average daily attendance, by the 202122 school year, or when it is economically feasible, to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, as specified. The bill would require local educational agencies with 2,500 or fewer units of average daily attendance to comply with this requirement by the 202324 school year, or when it is economically feasible. The bill would exempt from its requirements schools of a school district or county office of education, and charter schools, with fewer than 250 pupils. The bill would require a school district or school local educational agency that determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase those products to submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase those products to the State Department of Education and the governing board or body of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, local educational agency, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements described above. The bill would also require the department to post on its Internet Web site any letter or explanation submitted to it pursuant to that requirement and information to assist school districts and schools local educational agencies in complying with these provisions. Because this bill would require school districts local educational agencies to perform new duties, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to give diligent care to the health and physical development of pupils. Existing law requires the State Department of Education, in cooperation with the Division of Occupational Safety and Health within the Department of Industrial Relations, to formulate a listing of chemical compounds used in school programs that includes the potential hazards and estimated shelf life of each compound.
This bill would create the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and would make findings and declarations regarding indoor air quality and cleaning products. The bill would require school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils, by the 202021 202122 school year, or when it is economically feasible, to purchase and use exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, as specified. The bill would require a school district or school that determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase those products to submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance those products to the State Department of Education and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements described above. The bill would also require the department to post on its Internet Web site information to assist school districts and schools in complying with these provisions. Because this bill would require school districts to perform new duties, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to give diligent care to the health and physical development of pupils.
This bill would create the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and would make findings and declarations regarding indoor air quality and cleaning products. The bill would require school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils, by the 202021 school year, or when it is economically feasible, to purchase and use exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, as specified. The bill would require a school district or school to submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the State Department of Education and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements described above. The bill would also require the department to post on its Internet Web site information to assist school districts and schools in complying with these provisions. Because this bill would require school districts to perform new duties, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Children are vulnerable to, and may be severely affected by, exposure to chemicals, hazardous waste, and other environmental hazards. The United States Environmental Protection Agency estimates that human exposure to indoor air pollutants can be two to five times, and up to 100 times, more hazardous than outdoor levels, and that one-half of schools in the United States have poor indoor air quality. The State Air Resources Board has found significant indoor air quality problems in Californias portable and traditional classrooms.
(b)Pupils, teachers, janitors, and other staff members spend a significant amount of time inside school buildings, during which time they are exposed to cleaners and cleaning maintenance products.
(c)In 2014, the State Department of Public Health published a report urging schools to switch to cleaning products that are asthma-safe. In this report, the department State Department of Public Health also warned that conventional cleaning products may contain chemicals associated with cancer, reproductive harm, and endocrine disruption. The department State Department of Public Health also asserts that green cleaning products save money or cost the same as conventional cleaning products, as well as that their use reduces health costs.
(d)Enacted in 2002, Section 12400 of the Public Contract Code defines environmentally preferable purchasing as the procurement or acquisition of goods and services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Subsequently, the Department of General Services adopted Purchasing Standard DGS_471318A: Janitorial Supplies, Cleaners, which relies exclusively on third-party certified green cleaning products to limit exposure to the states workforce.
(e)The benefits of cleaner indoor air in schools have been shown to reduce the incidence of asthma, allergies, and absenteeism in pupils, as well as increase teacher retention rates and reduce workers compensation claims. The use of environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products contributes to cleaner indoor air quality.
(f)Third-party, independent, voluntary certification programs exist that set standards for, and evaluate, environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, and current standards establish environmental requirements for industrial and institutional general purpose, restroom, glass, or carpet cleaners, floor care products, and handsoaps, intended for routine cleaning of offices, schools, and institutions, and include consideration of vulnerable populations in institutional settings, such as schools and day care facilities. Under these standards, paint is not used as a general purpose product for cleaning of school facilities. Products certified under these standards cannot contain carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxins, ingredients that cause asthma, ingredients that are corrosive to skin and eyes, heavy metals, including lead, hexavalent chromium, or selenium, either in elemental form or compounds, 2-butoxyethanol, alkylphenol ethoxylates, phthalates, ozone-depleting chemicals, or optical brighteners. The standards also establish specific limits on ingredients for acute toxicity, skin absorption, volatile organic compound content, inhalation toxicity, toxicity to aquatic life, bioaccumulating compounds, biodegradability, eutrophication, combustibility, and fragrances. The standards define requirements for concentrates, dispensing systems, packaging, recyclability, labeling, and training. Standards are revised periodically and may apply to additional categories of products. Currently, the standards do not apply to cleaners for household use, food preparation operations, or medical facilities, and do not apply to air fresheners or enzymatic or microbially active products required to be registered under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), such as those making claims as disinfectants or sanitizers.
(g)The enactment of Senate Bill 258 (Chapter 830 of the Statutes of 2017) will aid school districts in identifying products that do not contain harmful chemicals. Senate Bill 258 mandates disclosure of hazardous chemicals in a wide range of cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, even if the ingredient is part of a trade secret formula.
(h)Existing law establishes the public school system, imposes various safety requirements, and provides state funding to school districts that contribute to operating budgets that already include janitorial programs. Schools are encouraged to use the State of California Procurement Contract to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to maximize the available discounts and avoid developing their own separate bids.
SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.Clean and Healthy Schools Act17615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.
17615.1.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Economically feasible means that there is no net increase in the costs of cleaning products.
(b)Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 25249.5) of Division 20 of the Health and Safety Code). Code) or its implementing regulations.
(c)Local educational agency means a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
(c)(d)Third-party certification means certification by an established, independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
(1)Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
(2)Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay to the certification program.
(3)Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
(4)Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the programs Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
(5)Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing harmful effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, but not limited to, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
(6)Development and selection of criteria are Develops and selects criteria based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preferability.
(7)Certification standards Has certification standards that remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
(8)Monitors and enforces compliance with the standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
(9)Has a registered, legally protected certification mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
(10)If possible, is developed develops criteria by consensus among key stakeholders.
(11)Establishes a leadership level in environmental and health standards for products.
17615.2.(a)(1)By the 202122 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils a local educational agency with more than 2,500 units of average daily attendance shall purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. For antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school local educational agency shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, however, they it may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.).
(2)A local educational agency with 2,500 or fewer units of average daily attendance shall comply with paragraph (1) by the 202324 school year, or when it is economically feasible.
(3)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), a school district or county office of education is not required to comply with this section for its schools with fewer than 250 pupils.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), a charter school with fewer than 250 pupils is not required to comply with this section.
(b)A school district or school local educational agency subject to this section may deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
(c)If a school district or school local educational agency subject to this section determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 202122 school year, the school district or school year or the 202324 school year, as applicable, it shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the department and the governing board or body of the school district or the governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, local educational agency, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a). The letter shall provide the details on the detailed reasons why compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation shall be posted on the school districts or schools public feasible. The department shall post any letter or explanation submitted to it on the departments Internet Web site with a notification titled Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.
17615.3.The department shall post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools local educational agencies subject to Section 17615.2 in complying with Section 17615.2.
17615.4.This article sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing in this article prevents local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent than those defined in this article.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Children are vulnerable to, and may be severely affected by, exposure to chemicals, hazardous waste, and other environmental hazards. The United States Environmental Protection Agency estimates that human exposure to indoor air pollutants can be two to five times, and up to 100 times, more hazardous than outdoor levels, and that one-half of schools in the United States have poor indoor air quality. The State Air Resources Board has found significant indoor air quality problems in Californias portable and traditional classrooms.
(b)Pupils, teachers, janitors, and other staff members spend a significant amount of time inside school buildings, during which time they are exposed to cleaners and cleaning maintenance products.
(c)In 2014, the State Department of Public Health published a report urging schools to switch to cleaning products that are asthma-safe. In this report, the department also warned that conventional cleaning products may contain chemicals associated with cancer, reproductive harm, and endocrine disruption. The department also asserts that green cleaning products save money or cost the same as conventional cleaning products, as well as that their use reduces health costs.
(d)Enacted in 2002, Section 12400 of the Public Contract Code defines environmentally preferable purchasing as the procurement or acquisition of goods and services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Subsequently, the Department of General Services adopted Purchasing Standard DGS_471318A: Janitorial Supplies, Cleaners, which relies exclusively on third-party certified green cleaning products to limit exposure to the states workforce.
(e)The benefits of cleaner indoor air in schools have been shown to reduce the incidence of asthma, allergies, and absenteeism in pupils, as well as increase teacher retention rates and reduce workers compensation claims. The use of environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products contributes to cleaner indoor air quality.
(f)Third-party, independent, voluntary certification programs exist that set standards for, and evaluate, environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, and current standards establish environmental requirements for industrial and institutional general purpose, restroom, glass, or carpet cleaners, floor care products, and handsoaps, intended for routine cleaning of offices, schools, and institutions, and include consideration of vulnerable populations in institutional settings, such as schools and day care facilities. Under these standards, paint is not used as a general purpose product for cleaning of school facilities. Products certified under these standards cannot contain carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxins, ingredients that cause asthma, ingredients that are corrosive to skin and eyes, heavy metals, including lead, hexavalent chromium, or selenium, either in elemental form or compounds, 2-butoxyethanol, alkylphenol ethoxylates, phthalates, ozone-depleting chemicals, or optical brighteners. The standards also establish specific limits on ingredients for acute toxicity, skin absorption, volatile organic compound content, inhalation toxicity, toxicity to aquatic life, bioaccumulating compounds, biodegradability, eutrophication, combustibility, and fragrances. The standards define requirements for concentrates, dispensing systems, packaging, recyclability, labeling, and training. Standards are revised periodically and may apply to additional categories of products. Currently, the standards do not apply to cleaners for household use, food preparation operations, or medical facilities, and do not apply to air fresheners or enzymatic or microbially active products required to be registered under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), such as those making claims as disinfectants or sanitizers.
(g)The enactment of Senate Bill 258 (Chapter 830 of the Statutes of 2017) will aid school districts in identifying products that do not contain harmful chemicals. Senate Bill 258 mandates disclosure of hazardous chemicals in a wide range of cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, even if the ingredient is part of a trade secret formula.
(h)Existing law establishes the public school system, imposes various safety requirements, and provides state funding to school districts that contribute to operating budgets that already include janitorial programs. Schools are encouraged to use the State of California Procurement Contract to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to maximize the available discounts and avoid developing their own separate bids.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.Clean and Healthy Schools Act17615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.
17615.1.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(a)Children are vulnerable to, and may be severely affected by, exposure to chemicals, hazardous waste, and other environmental hazards. The United States Environmental Protection Agency estimates that human exposure to indoor air pollutants can be two to five times and up to 100 times more hazardous than outdoor levels, and that one-half of schools in the United States have poor indoor air quality. The State Air Resources Board has found significant indoor air quality problems in Californias portable and traditional classrooms.(b)Pupils, teachers, janitors, and other staff members spend a significant amount of time inside school buildings, during which time they are exposed to cleaners and cleaning maintenance products. Many cleaners and cleaning maintenance products contain known carcinogens, reproductive toxins, chemicals that cause asthma, and other hazardous ingredients.(c)Asthma is the primary cause of school absences due to chronic disease in the United States, and is the leading cause of hospitalization for children under 15 years of age in California.(d)In 2014, the State Department of Public Health published a report urging schools to switch to cleaning products that are asthma-safe. The State Department of Public Health also warned that conventional cleaning products may contain chemicals associated with cancer, reproductive harm, and endocrine disruption.(e)Section 12400 of the Public Contract Code defines environmentally preferable purchasing as the procurement or acquisition of goods and services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose.(f)The benefits of cleaner indoor air in schools have been shown to reduce the incidence of asthma, allergies, and absenteeism in pupils, as well as increase teacher retention rates and reduce workers compensation claims. The use of environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products contributes to cleaner indoor air quality.(g)Third-party, independent, voluntary certification programs exist that set standards for, and evaluate, environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, and current standards establish environmental requirements for industrial and institutional general purpose, restroom, glass, carpet cleaners, floor care products, and handsoaps, intended for routine cleaning of offices, schools, and institutions, and include consideration of vulnerable populations in institutional settings, such as schools and day care facilities. Under these standards, paint is not used as a general purpose product for cleaning of school facilities. Products certified under these standards cannot contain carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxins, ingredients that cause asthma, ingredients that are corrosive to skin and eyes, heavy metals, including lead, hexavalent chromium, or selenium, either in elemental form or compounds, 2-butoxyethanol, alkylphenol ethoxylates, phthalates, ozone-depleting chemicals, or optical brighteners. The standards also establish specific limits on ingredients for acute toxicity, skin absorption, volatile organic compound content, inhalation toxicity, toxicity to aquatic life, bioaccumulating compounds, biodegradability, eutrophication, combustibility, and fragrances. The standards define requirements for concentrates, dispensing systems, packaging, recyclability, labeling, and training. Standards are revised periodically and may apply to additional categories of products. Currently, the standards do not apply to cleaners for household use, food preparation operations, or medical facilities, and do not apply to air fresheners, enzymatic, or microbially active products required to be registered under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), such as those making claims as disinfectants or sanitizers.(h)The enactment of Senate Bill 258 (Chapter 830 of the Statutes of 2017) will aid school districts in identifying products that do not contain harmful chemicals. Senate Bill 258 mandates disclosure of hazardous chemicals in a wide range of cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, even if the ingredient is part of a trade secret formula.(i)Existing law establishes the public school system, imposes various safety requirements, and provides state funding to school districts that contribute to operating budgets that already include janitorial programs. Schools are encouraged to use the State of California Procurement Contract to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to maximize the available discounts and avoid developing their own separate bids.(j)The State Department of Public Health asserts green cleaning products save money or cost the same as conventional cleaning products, as well as reduce health costs.17615.2.17615.1.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Economically feasible means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school. cleaning products.
(b)Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product means a product product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product does not include any disinfecting cleaner, sanitizer, or any other antimicrobial product regulated by the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), until the United States Environmental Protection Agency adopts a final rule that may allow these products to make environmentally preferable claims and obtain and use environmentally preferable certifications. a product that must be labeled pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 25249.5) of Division 20 of the Health and Safety Code).
(c)Third-party certification means certification by an established, independent, nationally recognized independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
(1)Has an open, public process for setting standards that involves key stakeholders. a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
(2)Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification. to the certification program.
(3)Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
(4)Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the programs Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
(5)Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing harmful effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, but not limited to, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
(6)Development and selection of criteria are based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preferability.
(6)Requires periodic revisions and updates of the(7)Certification standards to remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
(7)(8)Monitors and reinforces enforces compliance with the standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
(8)(9)Has a registered, legally protected certification mark. mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
(9)(10)If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
(10)(11)Establishes a leadership level in environmental and health standards for products.
17615.3.17615.2.(a)By the 202021 202122 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils shall purchase and use exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. For antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, however, they may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.).
(b)A school district or school may deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
(c)If a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 202021 202122 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the department and the governing board of the school district or the governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a). The letter shall provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation shall be posted on the school districts or schools public Internet Web site with a notification titled Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.
17615.4.17615.3.The department shall post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with Section 17615.3. 17615.2.
17615.5.17615.4.This article sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing in this article prevents local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent than those defined in this article.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.
17615.1.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Children are vulnerable to, and may be severely affected by, exposure to chemicals, hazardous waste, and other environmental hazards. The United States Environmental Protection Agency estimates that human exposure to indoor air pollutants can be two to five times and up to 100 times more hazardous than outdoor levels, and that one-half of schools in the United States have poor indoor air quality. The State Air Resources Board has found significant indoor air quality problems in Californias portable and traditional classrooms.
(b)Pupils, teachers, janitors, and other staff members spend a significant amount of time inside school buildings, during which time they are exposed to cleaners and cleaning maintenance products. Many cleaners and cleaning maintenance products contain known carcinogens, reproductive toxins, chemicals that cause asthma, and other hazardous ingredients.
(c)Asthma is the primary cause of school absences due to chronic disease in the United States, and is the leading cause of hospitalization for children under 15 years of age in California.
(d)In 2014, the State Department of Public Health published a report urging schools to switch to cleaning products that are asthma-safe. The State Department of Public Health also warned that conventional cleaning products may contain chemicals associated with cancer, reproductive harm, and endocrine disruption.
(e)Section 12400 of the Public Contract Code defines environmentally preferable purchasing as the procurement or acquisition of goods and services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose.
(f)The benefits of cleaner indoor air in schools have been shown to reduce the incidence of asthma, allergies, and absenteeism in pupils, as well as increase teacher retention rates and reduce workers compensation claims. The use of environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products contributes to cleaner indoor air quality.
(g)Third-party, independent, voluntary certification programs exist that set standards for, and evaluate, environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, and current standards establish environmental requirements for industrial and institutional general purpose, restroom, glass, carpet cleaners, floor care products, and handsoaps, intended for routine cleaning of offices, schools, and institutions, and include consideration of vulnerable populations in institutional settings, such as schools and day care facilities. Under these standards, paint is not used as a general purpose product for cleaning of school facilities. Products certified under these standards cannot contain carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxins, ingredients that cause asthma, ingredients that are corrosive to skin and eyes, heavy metals, including lead, hexavalent chromium, or selenium, either in elemental form or compounds, 2-butoxyethanol, alkylphenol ethoxylates, phthalates, ozone-depleting chemicals, or optical brighteners. The standards also establish specific limits on ingredients for acute toxicity, skin absorption, volatile organic compound content, inhalation toxicity, toxicity to aquatic life, bioaccumulating compounds, biodegradability, eutrophication, combustibility, and fragrances. The standards define requirements for concentrates, dispensing systems, packaging, recyclability, labeling, and training. Standards are revised periodically and may apply to additional categories of products. Currently, the standards do not apply to cleaners for household use, food preparation operations, or medical facilities, and do not apply to air fresheners, enzymatic, or microbially active products required to be registered under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), such as those making claims as disinfectants or sanitizers.
(h)The enactment of Senate Bill 258 (Chapter 830 of the Statutes of 2017) will aid school districts in identifying products that do not contain harmful chemicals. Senate Bill 258 mandates disclosure of hazardous chemicals in a wide range of cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, even if the ingredient is part of a trade secret formula.
(i)Existing law establishes the public school system, imposes various safety requirements, and provides state funding to school districts that contribute to operating budgets that already include janitorial programs. Schools are encouraged to use the State of California Procurement Contract to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to maximize the available discounts and avoid developing their own separate bids.
(j)The State Department of Public Health asserts green cleaning products save money or cost the same as conventional cleaning products, as well as reduce health costs.
17615.2.As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Economically feasible means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
(b)Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product means a product that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product does not include any disinfecting cleaner, sanitizer, or any other antimicrobial product regulated by the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (7 U.S.C. Sec. 136 et seq.), until the United States Environmental Protection Agency adopts a final rule that may allow these products to make environmentally preferable claims and obtain and use environmentally preferable certifications.
(c)Third-party certification means certification by an established, independent, nationally recognized program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
(1)Has an open, public process for setting standards that involves key stakeholders.
(2)Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification.
(3)Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
(4)Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the programs Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
(5)Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for reducing effects on human health and safety, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, but not limited to, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
(6)Requires periodic revisions and updates of the standards to remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
(7)Monitors and reinforces the standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
(8)Has a registered, legally protected certification mark.
(9)If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
(10)Establishes a leadership level in standards for products.
17615.3.(a)By the 202021 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils shall purchase and use exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists.
(b)A school district or school may deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
(c)If a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 202021 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase and use environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the department and the governing board of the school district or the governing body of the nonpublic elementary or secondary school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of subdivision (a).
17615.4.The department shall post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with Section 17615.3.
17615.5.This article sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing in this article prevents local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent than those defined in this article.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 5, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (June 27). |
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on ED. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and ED. |
| Jun 4, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 10, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 9, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 5.) (May 9). |
| Apr 26, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Apr 17, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 8, 2018 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 6, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Education] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2018 | AB 2570 NAZARIAN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 2570 (Nazarian) - School facilities: Clean and Healthy Schools Act: environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products
Version: July 5, 2018 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 2, ED. 5 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 6, 2018 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
This bill requires local educational agencies (LEAs) to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning products when available.
Fiscal Impact:
- This bill could also result in additional costs for school districts to provide detailed rationale for non-compliance to the California Department of Education (CDE) and their local school governing boards. A precise amount would depend on the number of districts that are unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so, but these costs could be in tens of thousands of dollars each year. School districts may incur additional costs to the extent that training for staff would be required in using the new cleaning products.
- By requiring school districts to exclusively use cleaning products that are “environmentally preferable”, they may incur additional local costs to purchase these materials which may be more expensive. The extent of these costs is unknown.
Background:
Existing law requires every public and private school maintaining any combination of classes from kindergarten to grade 12, inclusive, to provide that every restroom at all times be maintained and cleaned regularly, fully operational, except for public safety or repair purposes, and stocked at all times with toilet paper, soap, and paper towels or functional hand dryers. Existing law also requires schools to keep all restrooms open during school hours when pupils are not in classes, and shall keep a sufficient number of restrooms open during school hours when pupils are in classes.
An increasing number of school districts and county offices of education are taking steps to establish and maintain “green schools” to provide healthier school environments, save money, and model environmentally responsible behavior. Green schools minimize the impact of their operations on the environment through more efficient use of energy and other natural resources, reduced use of toxic materials and efforts to improve indoor/outdoor air quality.
Proposed Law:
This bill establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, requiring by 2021-22, or when economically feasible, LEAs with 2,500 or more units of average daily attendance (ADA) to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. An LEA with 2,500 or fewer units of ADA shall comply with these requirements by the 2023-24 school year, or when it is economically feasible. A charter school or a school district or county office of education is not required to comply for its schools with fewer than 250 pupils.
This bill establishes several definitions for the purposes of this bill, including “economically feasible” which means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school and “environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” which means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to current law.
This bill specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the LEA shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act.
This bill authorizes an LEA to deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
This bill specifies that if an LEA determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021-22 school year (or 2023-24 school year as applicable), the LEA shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the CDE and the governing board or body of the LEA, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of this bill. The letter shall provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation to be posted on the LEA’s public Internet Web site with a notification titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.”
This bill requires the CDE to post information on its Internet Web site to assist LEAs in complying with the provisions of this bill.
This bill specifies that it sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in LEAs and nothing shall prevent local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Benjamin Allen, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 2570 Hearing Date: June 27, 2018
Author: | |||
Version: | April 17, 2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Ian Johnson | ||
Subject: School facilities: Clean and Healthy Schools Act: environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products.
SUMMARY
This bill establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, requiring school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning products when available.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Required the Office of Public School Construction, by January 1, 2007, to develop a school facility inspection and evaluation instrument, including a system for evaluating whether each school facility is in “good repair”.
- Defines “good repair” as maintained in a manner that assures that it is clean, safe, and functional, as determined pursuant to a school facility inspection.
- Requires every public and private school maintaining any combination of classes from kindergarten to grade 12, inclusive, to comply with all of the following:
- Every restroom shall at all times be maintained and cleaned regularly, fully operational, except for public safety or repair purposes, and stocked at all times with toilet paper, soap, and paper towels or functional hand dryers.
- The school shall keep all restrooms open during school hours when pupils are not in classes, and shall keep a sufficient number of restrooms open during school hours when pupils are in classes.
ANALYSIS
This bill establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, requiring by 2021-22, or when economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for the purposes of this bill:
- “Economically feasible” means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
- “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to current law.
- “Third-party certification” means certification by an established, independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
- Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
- Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification.
- Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
- Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the program's Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
- Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, at a minimum, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
- Development and selection of criteria are based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preferability.
- Certification standards remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
- Monitors and enforces compliance with standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
- Has a registered, legally protected certification mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
- If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
- Establishes a leadership level in standards for products.
- Specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act.
- Authorizes a school district or school to deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
- Specifies that if a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021-22 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the California Department of Education (CDE) and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of this bill. Requires the letter to provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation to be posted on the school district’s or school’s public Internet Web site with a notification titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.”
- Requires CDE to post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with the provisions of this bill.
- Specifies that this bill sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing shall prevent local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “More than 1 in 5 Californians–including over 6 million children–spend their day in a school. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body's nervous system and internal organs. While more and more school districts have switched to less-toxic, environmentally preferable cleaning products (or "green" cleaners), conventional cleaning products are still widely used.”
“Of particular concern is the link between cleaning products and asthma, since asthma is the leading cause of absenteeism from a chronic illness among California's school children, and is the primary cause of hospitalization for children under the age of 15. In California, nearly 1 million children have asthma (about 1 in 6).”
- Green schools. An increasing number of school districts and county offices of education are taking steps to establish and maintain “green schools” to provide healthier school environments, save money, and model environmentally responsible behavior. Green schools minimize the impact of their operations on the environment through more efficient use of energy and other natural resources, reduced use of toxic materials and efforts to improve indoor/outdoor air quality.
- Health and academic benefits. Exposure to indoor air pollutants and toxic chemicals has been linked to problems such as asthma, respiratory tract infection and disease, allergic reactions, headaches, nasal congestion, eye and skin irritations, coughing, sneezing, fatigue, dizziness, and nausea. Children are especially vulnerable to contaminants because their smaller and immature body systems accumulate greater amounts of toxic substances per pound of body weight and are less able to handle toxins.
These negative health effects can result in lower student attendance, teacher productivity, and student achievement. For example, asthma is the leading cause of school absenteeism attributed to chronic conditions nationwide. According to the American Lung Association, American children miss more than ten million school days a year because of asthma exacerbated by poor indoor air quality. Further, schools serving low-income communities suffer disproportionately from poor indoor air quality.
- Financial impacts. Some local educational agencies have been reluctant to build green schools or institute green school practices because of concerns about costs. Research has demonstrated that construction costs for a new green school are about two percent higher than a conventionally designed school; however, green schools also tend to yield financial benefits that outweigh the initial investment over the life of the school. Green schools provide additional financial benefits due to increased student attendance, staff productivity, higher student achievement, lower workers’ compensation costs, property loss prevention, and other factors that are harder to quantify.
This bill requires public and nonpublic schools to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021–22 school year, or when it is economically feasible. For schools that determine it is not economically feasible to comply by 2021-22, a letter must be submitted to the Department of Education and the school’s governing board annually, detailing the reasons compliance is not feasible.
- Third party certification. There are several independent organizations that review products based on specified standards. Green Seal is based in the United States, EcoLogo is a Canadian program, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency certifies products through Safer Choice. Most public agencies that have adopted policies to use green cleaners use products certified by one or more of those three entities.
The Occupational Health Branch of the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) advises that "there are many 'green' claims being made to sell cleaning products. Product labels claim that the ingredients are 'natural', 'organic', and 'Earth-friendly.' But how can buyers sort out which claims are meaningful and which aren't? The best way is to seek out products that have been certified by third-party organizations that issue openly published standards developed in a process that involves all types of stakeholders."
The CDPH guide for schools also recommends buying products certified by a third party. The guide further states that the products that are certified meet stringent guidelines and not every company that applies succeeds in getting its products certified.
California’s Department of General Services has a policy requiring state purchases to meet environmentally preferable (EPP) or green standards. Under the policy, all janitorial supply products must be certified by at least one Third-Party Environmental Certification program. State agencies purchase EPP approved products through the CalPIA (the California Prison Industry). Public agencies, including school districts, can also purchase environmentally preferable products through the CalPIA.
For purposes of this bill, authorized products are those that have been certified by a third-party organization that meets eleven criteria specified in the bill. According to the author, Green Seal, EcoLogo and Safer Choice meet the criteria.
Opponents of the use of third party certifications claim that it is little more than a “pay to play” scheme as manufacturers must pay for the review of their products. As an alternative, these opponents suggest directing a state agency to develop a state-authorized cleaning products list.
- Commitment to continue working with the Senate Environmental Quality Committee. This bill was passed out of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee (EQ) on June 20, 2018. As part of the discussion in EQ, concerns were raised that as currently drafted, the bill does not require disinfectants to meet the new environmentally preferable standard. Further, opponents of the bill argue that the certifying entities described in the bill may not be appropriate. The author has committed to continue working with the opposition and EQ on this issue.
- Committee amendments. Those representing local educational agencies (LEAs) have raised concerns that (1) excluding schools with fewer than 50 pupils is arbitrarily low, (2) requiring districts to post noncompliance letters on their Internet Web sites creates additional workload, and (3) small LEAs may need additional time to comply. Further, as currently drafted, this bill would apply to private schools, even though the California Department of Education has no statutory authority to regulate or monitor them. If it is the desire of the Committee to pass this measure, staff recommends that the bill be amended to: (1) apply to local educational agencies (LEAs), defined as school districts, charter schools, and county offices of education, (2) exclude schools with fewer than 250 pupils, (3) require LEAs to send noncompliance letters to the California Department of Education to be posted on its Internet Web site, and (4) allow small LEAs, defined as having an average daily attendance of fewer than 2,500, until 2023-24 to comply.
SUPPORT
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Teachers Association
Clean Water Action
Educate. Advocate.
Empower California
Environmental Working Group
Regional Asthma Management Program
San Francisco Unified School District
Service Employees International Union
Seventh Generation Advisors
OPPOSITION
Action Now
American Chemistry Council
American Cleaning Institute
American Legion Post 6
Apostolic Faith Center
California Chamber of Commerce
California Kids IAQ
California Safe Schools
California Communities Against Toxics
Coalition for a Safe Environment
Comite Pro Uno
Community Dreams
Del Amo Action Committee
EMERGE
Exide Worker Community Committee
Green Action
Grocery Manufacturers Association
Healthy Building and Indoor Environmental Consultant
Household & Commercial Products Association
Los Angeles Environmental Justice Network
Mujeres por Maywood
Our Right to Know
Padres Unidos De Maywood
Philippine Action Group for the Environment
Randall Enterprises
RISE
The Paramount Community Coalition Against Toxics
Tobias Avenue Homeowners
Western Plant Health Association
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 2570
Author: | Nazarian | ||
Version: | 4/17/2018 | Hearing Date: | 6/20/2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: School facilities: Clean and Healthy Schools Act: environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Requires, pursuant to the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to create a regulatory framework to collect data on chemicals in order to evaluate, assess, mitigate, and control risks that may be posed by their manufacture, processing, and use.
- Under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), regulates pesticide (which includes antimicrobial and disinfectant cleaning and personal care products) distribution, sale, and use. All pesticides distributed or sold in the United States must be registered (licensed) by US EPA. Before EPA may register a pesticide under FIFRA, the applicant must show, among other things, that using the pesticide according to specifications “will not generally cause unreasonable adverse effects on the environment.”
Existing state law:
- Under the Healthy Schools Act (HSA) of 2000, encourages the adoption of effective, lower risk pest management practices, also known as Integrated Pest Management (IPM). The goals of the HSA are to address the health and environmental concerns associated with the use of pesticides at schools and child care centers, and to assure healthy learning environments for California children.
- Provides that the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) is charged with carrying out the HSA.
- Requires schools to provide notice of pesticide use, as specified.
- Prohibits the use of a pesticide that has been granted conditional registration, an interim registration, or an experimental use permit.
- Requires the DPR to promote and facilitate the voluntary adoption of IPM programs for schools and child daycare facilities.
- Requires DPR to maintain a website with specific information, and requires DPR to ensure that adequate resources are available to respond to inquiries from schools regarding the use of IPM practices.
- Requires DPR to establish an IPM training program to facilitate the adoption of a model integrated pest management program and least-hazardous pest control practices by schools.
- Provides that the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) is charged with carrying out the HSA.
- Beginning with the 1987-88 school year, prohibits schools, school districts, or the governing authority of a private school from purchasing or ordering art or craft material that is deemed by the State Department of Health Services to contain a toxic substance or a toxic substance causing chronic illness, for use by students in kindergarten through grade 6. (Education Code (EC) §32064)
- Beginning June 1, 1987, prohibits schools, school districts, or the governing authority of a private school from purchasing or ordering any substance that is deemed by the State Department of Health Services to contain a toxic substance or a toxic substance causing chronic illness, for use by students in grades 7 through 12, unless it meets specified labeling standards. (EC §32064)
- Under the Cleaning Product Right To Know Act of 2017 (Act), requires manufacturers of cleaning products to disclose specified chemical ingredients on a product label and on the manufacturers Web site.
This bill: establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and requires, by the 2021-22 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for the purposes of this bill:
- “Economically feasible” means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
- “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Health and Safety Code, Division 20, Chapter 6, commencing with Section 25249.5).
- “Third-party certification” means certification by an established, independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
- Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
- Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification.
- Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
- Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the program’s Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
- Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, at a minimum, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
- Development and selection of criteria are based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preference.
- Certification standards remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
- Monitors and enforces compliance with standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
- Has a registered, legally protected certification mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
- If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
- Establishes a leadership level in standards for products.
- Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
- “Economically feasible” means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
- Specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials regulated under FIFRA.
- Authorizes a school district or school to deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
- Specifies that if a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021-22 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the California Department of Education (CDE) and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of this bill. Requires the letter to provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation to be posted on the school district’s or school's public Internet Web site with a notification titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.”
- Requires the CDE to post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with the provisions of this bill.
- Specifies that this bill sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing shall prevent local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent.
Background
- Chemicals are ubiquitous. Chemicals are in nearly everything: from cleaning products to plastics to the chemicals that make touch-screen cellphones possible, chemicals are used to make 96% of products and materials in the United States. There are currently more than 80,000 chemicals approved under federal law for use in the United States. Each day, a total of more than 40 billion pounds of chemical substances are produced or imported in the US for commercial and industrial uses. An additional 1,000 new chemicals are introduced into US commerce each year. Approximately one new chemical comes to market every 2.6 seconds and global chemical production is projected to double every 25 years. The US chemicals industry generated over $811 billion in 2013, and it produced over 70,000 types of organic and inorganic chemicals. The average US consumer today comes into contact with at least 100 chemicals per day.
- Exposure to Hazardous Chemicals in Schools. US EPA reports that all building occupants are potentially exposed to the volatile components of cleaning products. Choosing less hazardous products that have positive environmental attributes (e.g., biodegradability, low toxicity, low volatile organic compound content, reduced packaging, low life-cycle energy use) and taking steps to reduce exposure can minimize harmful impacts to custodial workers and building occupants, improve indoor air quality, and reduce water and ambient air pollution, while also ensuring the effectiveness of cleaning in removing biological and other contaminants from the building’s interior.
The California Department of Public Health’s (DPH) Occupational Health Branch, which tracks asthma and chemical exposures related to work, found that 12.5% of the work-related asthma cases in its surveillance database were related to cleaning products.
A guide titled “Healthy Cleaning and Asthma-Safer Schools” published by the DPH in 2014 states that “a paradox exists for how most of our schools are cleaned. While we’re trying to get rid of dirt and germs to keep students and staff healthy, we may unintentionally expose them to harmful chemicals in cleaning products, sanitizers, and disinfectants. Some conventional products like floor strippers and bathroom cleaners, or ingredients like ammonia and bleach, can pose avoidable risks for our health, our environment, and our equipment.”
According to the report, a number of states, including Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Missouri, Nevada, New York, and Vermont, and California school districts, including San Diego Unified School District, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District, and Elk Grove Unified School District, have moved to using green cleaning products. - What are “environmentally preferable” products? This bill defines environmentally preferable products as institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meet independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose, and excludes any product that must contain a Proposition 65 label indicating that the product contains a chemical that is known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. Antimicrobial products include disinfectants and sanitizers that are regulated only by the US EPA.
- DGS “environmentally preferable” products. DGS purchasing standards provide the minimum criteria purchases must meet to be considered Environmentally Preferable Purchasing (EPP), aka “green”, by the State of California. They establish a mechanism for incorporating performance and environmental requirements that meet the state’s environmentally preferable goals, into procurements and policy.
DGS’s purchasing standard establishes minimum EPP requirements for janitorial cleaners. Janitorial cleaners encompass a wide variety of products, which include but are not limited to: bathroom cleaners, carpet and upholstery cleaners, degreasers, floor care products, all-purpose and glass cleaners, laundry detergents, sanitizers and disinfectants, specialty cleaners and polishes, and dish washing products.
While this policy is a valuable resource, it does not fully contemplate the health impacts of chemicals, especially on children.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. The author states, “more than 1 in 5 Californians – including over 6 million children – spend their day in a school. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body’s nervous system and internal organs. While more and more school districts have switched to less-toxic, environmentally preferable cleaning products (or “green” cleaners), conventional cleaning products are still widely used.
“Of particular concern is the link between cleaning products and asthma, since asthma is the leading cause of absenteeism from a chronic illness among California’s school children, and is the primary cause of hospitalization for children under the age of 15. In California, nearly 1 million children have asthma (about 1 in 6).” - Cost. State and local public agencies that have transitioned to green cleaning products report that there is either little or no cost increase between conventional cleaners and green certified cleaners. Green cleaners come in concentrate. Automatic dilution equipments provide the proper measurement of cleaning solution. Many entities that use these products have been able to eliminate duplicative and unnecessary products. According to the Healthy Schools Network, Inc., a New York environmental health organization, New York’s Office of General Services’ Environmental Unit report that “the price point for conventional and certified green products are virtually the same. Any increase in the initial purchase of green products is more than offset by the ease of use, reduction in number of products to buy, and the use of ‘dilution stations’ that control the actual volume of chemical use automatically and effectively.”
Other examples include:- The San Diego Unified School District reduced its budget by 20% by using one line of chemicals and eliminating unnecessary cleaning products.
- The City of Santa Monica documented a 5% price savings after the switch to green cleaners.
- The Novato Unified School District negotiated a contract for purchasing green cleaners at the same prices as the conventional cleaners.
- The City and County of San Francisco replaced 13 out of 14 janitorial cleaning products at no increased cost.
- The San Diego Unified School District reduced its budget by 20% by using one line of chemicals and eliminating unnecessary cleaning products.
Additionally, this bill addresses cost by authorizing a school district or school to delay implementation of the bill if it determines that it not economically feasible to do so. Economically feasible is defined as resulting in no net increase to the cleaning costs of a school. A school district or school that chooses to delay implementation must submit a letter to the governing board or governing body of the private school annually until it complies with the requirement. The letter must be titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act” and provide the reasons compliance is not feasible.
- Third party certification. There are several independent organizations that review products based on specified standards. Green Seal is based in the United States, EcoLogo is a Canadian program, and the U.S. EPA certifies products through Safer Choice. Most public agencies that have adopted policies to use green cleaners use products certified by one or more of those three entities.
For purposes of this bill, authorized products are those that have been certified by a third-party organization that meets eleven criteria specified in the bill. According to the author, Green Seal, EcoLogo, and Safer Choice meet the criteria.
Despite reliance on these three organizations, there are criticisms that one or more of the organizations certify products with toxic chemicals, including products that would be required to post a Proposition 65 warning label. This bill excludes cleaners that must post a Proposition 65 label. However, the author may wish to consider how school districts or schools will determine which products are eligible to be used under this bill if a product certified by a third-party contains a chemical that falls under a Proposition 65 list.
Opponents of the use of third party certifications also charge a “pay to play” scheme as manufacturers must pay for the review of their products. As an alternative, those in the anti-third-party certification camp suggest directing a state agency to develop a state-authorized cleaning products list. - Industry Suggested Amendments. A coalition of industry groups has suggested the amendments to: (1) Make Clear Antimicrobials are allowed in Schools, (2) Include US EPA Safer Choice Certification, and (3) Recognize other programs like the Sustainable Purchasing Leadership Council (a non-profit contributed to by cleaning product manufacturers.)
- Exempting antimicrobials (including disinfectants). Opposition has suggested an amendment that would exempt antimicrobial products from the requirements of this bill. It is unclear why that would be necessary or beneficial: (1) these are the primary products used in schools that present the greatest risk to children, and (2) there are certified antimicrobial products that can be used. This amendment would nullify the value of this certification.
- Ensuring Certification Integrity and Provides Substantive Safety for Children and Workers. Any kind of third party certification presents the risk of inconsistent standards and the potential for a certifier that allows or requires paying to be on the list. This bill has specified 3 certifiers that have a record of trusted certification and expansion of this list would call into question a new certifiers validity. Further, it may make sense to incorporate concepts from the framework used in California’s HSA the current education code requirements for art supplies and the department of general services policy for environmentally preferably purchases.
This bill should be amended to be restructured to look more like the HSA and reflect children’s health considerations for an EPP policy.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 821 (Brownley, 2009), was substantially similar to this bill. It was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
AB 2808 (Garcia, 2008) was also a similar bill. The bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file in 2008.
SOURCE:
Environmental Working Group
SUPPORT:
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
American Academy of Pediatrics
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Teachers Association
Clean Water Action
Educate. Advocate.
Empower Family California
Regional Asthma Management and Prevention
San Francisco Unified School District
Service Emplyees International Union
Seventh Generation Advisors
Women’s Voices for the Earth
OPPOSITION:
Action Now
American Chemistry Council
American Cleaning Institute
American Legion Post 6
Apostolic Faith Center
California Chamber of Commerce
California Communities Against Toxics
California Kids IAQ
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Safe Schools
Coalition for a Safe Environment
Comite Pro Uno
Community Dreams
Del Amo Action Committee
EMERGE
Exide Worker Community Committee
Green Action
Grocery Manufacturers Association
Household & Commercial Products Association
Los Angeles Environmental Justice Network
Mujeres por Maywood
Our Right to Know
Padres Unidos De Maywood
Paramount Community Coalition Against Toxics
Philippine Action Group for the Environment
Randall Enterprises
Responsible Industry for a Sound Environment
RISE
Western Plant Health Association
5 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) states, “SEIU represents classified employees in some of the most populous school districts. Our members provide vital educational support, school safety services, maintenance and operations, technical, administrative, language support and cafeteria services. Our members are dedicated to supporting their schools and their students. This bill would help protect the health of our members and their students. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body’s nervous system and internal organs. And janitorial staff are exposed to these hazardous chemicals every day they are used.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
A joint letter submitted by the opposition states that they support the goal of improving environmental health indoors, but have concerns that the bill contains inconsistencies, may not provide sufficient product certification alternatives, and contains misleading legislative intent language. The coalition has suggested the following amendments: make clear antimicrobials are allowed in schools, include US EPA Safer Choice Certification, and recognize other programs like the Sustainable Purchasing Leadership Council.
California Safe Schools and its coalition raise concerns that certified products may also contain toxic chemicals that cause harm to children. They also assert that this bill would mandate certified products, which would prohibit alternatives like baking soda and vinegar from being used.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2570
Author:(Nazarian)
As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Education | 5-0 | O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Thurmond, Weber | |
Appropriations | 11-5 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Flora |
SUMMARY: Establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and requires, by the 2021-22 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for the purposes of this bill:
- "Economically feasible" means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
- "Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product" means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. "Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product" does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Health and Safety Code, Division 20, Chapter 6, commencing with Section 25249.5).
- "Third-party certification" means certification by an established, independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
- Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
- Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification.
- Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
- Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the program's Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
- Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, at a minimum, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
- Development and selection of criteria are based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preferability.
- Certification standards remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
- Monitors and enforces compliance with standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
- Has a registered, legally protected certification mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
- If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
- Establishes a leadership level in standards for products.
- Specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act.
- Authorizes a school district or school to deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
- Specifies that if a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021-22 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the California Department of Education (CDE) and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of this bill. Requires the letter to provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation to be posted on the school district's or school's public Internet Web site with a notification titled "Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act."
- Requires the CDE to post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with the provisions of this bill.
- Specifies that this bill sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing shall prevent local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs, likely totaling the low thousands to tens of thousands of dollars, for school districts to submit a letter outlining reasons for noncompliance to CDE and their local governing board. Costs would depend on the number of school districts that are unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so. (California has over 1,000 school districts.) If the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill's requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate, the state would need to reimburse these costs to schools or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant, described in more detail below.
- Ongoing costs to nonpublic schools that are unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so to submit a letter outlining reasons for noncompliance to CDE and their local governing board. These costs would not be reimbursed by the state because nonpublic schools are private entities.
- Minor costs to CDE to post information its website and collect and file letters.
COMMENTS: The author states, "More than 1 in 5 Californians – including over 6 million children – spend their day in a school. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body's nervous system and internal organs. While more and more school districts have switched to less-toxic, environmentally preferable cleaning products (or "green" cleaners), conventional cleaning products are still widely used.
"Of particular concern is the link between cleaning products and asthma, since asthma is the leading cause of absenteeism from a chronic illness among California's school children, and is the primary cause of hospitalization for children under the age of 15. In California, nearly 1 million children have asthma (about 1 in 6)."
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) reports that all building occupants are potentially exposed to the volatile components of cleaning products. Choosing less hazardous products that have positive environmental attributes (e.g., biodegradability, low toxicity, low volatile organic compound content, reduced packaging, low life cycle energy use) and taking steps to reduce exposure can minimize harmful impacts to custodial workers and building occupants, improve indoor air quality, and reduce water and ambient air pollution while also ensuring the effectiveness of cleaning in removing biological and other contaminants from the building's interior. The California Department of Public Health's (CDPH) Occupational Health Branch, which tracks asthma and chemical exposures related to work, found that 12.5% of the work-related asthma cases in its surveillance database were related to cleaning products.
A guide titled "Healthy Cleaning and Asthma-Safer Schools" published by the CDPH in 2014 states that "a paradox exists for how most of our schools are cleaned. While we're trying to get rid of dirt and germs to keep students and staff healthy, we may unintentionally expose them to harmful chemicals in cleaning products, sanitizers, and disinfectants. Some conventional products like floor strippers and bathroom cleaners, or ingredients like ammonia and bleach, can pose avoidable risks for our health, our environment, and our equipment." According to the report, a number of states, including Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Missouri, Nevada, New York, and Vermont, and California school districts, including San Diego Unified School District, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District, and Elk Grove Unified School District, have moved to using green cleaning products.
This bill requires all school districts and private elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. The bill authorizes a school district to deplete its existing supply and purchase environmentally preferable products in the next procurement cycle.
What are "environmentally preferable" products? This bill defines environmentally preferable products as institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose, and excludes any product that must contain a Proposition 65 label indicating that the product contains a chemical that is known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. The bill specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials that are regulated by the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act. Antimicrobial products include disinfectants and sanitizers that are regulated only by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
Cost. State and local public agencies that have transitioned to green cleaning products report that there is either little or no cost increase between conventional cleaners and green certified cleaners. Green cleaners come in concentrate. Automatic dilution equipments provide the proper measurement of cleaning solution. Many entities that use these products have been able to eliminate duplicative and unnecessary products. According to the Healthy Schools Network, Inc., a New York environmental health organization, New York's Office of General Services' Environmental Unit report that "the price point for conventional and certified green products are virtually the same. Any increase in the initial purchase of green products is more than offset by the ease of use, reduction in number of products to buy, and the use of 'dilution stations' that control the actual volume of chemical use automatically and effectively."
Other examples include:
- The San Diego Unified School District reduced its budget by 20% by using one line of chemicals and eliminating unnecessary cleaning products.
- The City of Santa Monica documented a 5% price savings after the switch to green cleaners.
- The Novato Unified School District negotiated a contract for purchasing green cleaners at the same prices as the conventional cleaners.
- The City and County of San Francisco replaced 13 out of 14 janitorial cleaning products at no increased cost.
This bill authorizes a school district or school to delay implementation of the bill if it determines that it not economically feasible to do so. Economically feasible is defined as resulting in no net increase to the cleaning costs of a school. A school district or school that chooses to delay implementation must submit a letter to the governing board or governing body of the private school annually until it complies with the requirement. The letter must be titled "Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act" and provide the reasons compliance is not feasible.
Third party certification. There are several independent organizations that review products based on specified standards. Green Seal is based in the United States, EcoLogo is a Canadian program, and the U.S. EPA certifies products through Safer Choice. Most public agencies that have adopted policies to use green cleaners use products certified by one or more of those three entities.
For purposes of this bill, authorized products are those that have been certified by a third-party organization that meets eleven criteria specified in the bill. According to the author, Green Seal, EcoLogo and Safer Choice meet the criteria.
Despite reliance on these three organizations, there are criticisms that one or more of the organizations certify products with toxic chemicals, including products that would be required to post a Proposition 65 warning label. This bill excludes cleaners that must post a Proposition 65 label. However, the author may wish to consider how school districts or schools will determine which products are eligible to be used under this bill if a product certified by a third-party contains a chemical that falls under a Proposition 65 list.
Opponents of the use of third party certifications also charge a "pay to play" scheme as manufacturers must pay for the review of their products. As an alternative, those in the anti-third-party certification camp suggest directing a state agency to develop a state-authorized cleaning products list.
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0002913
Date of Hearing: May 9, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2570
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
Policy Committee: | Education | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY: This bill requires, by the 2021-22 school year, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. It also allows a school to deplete its existing supply of cleaning products and purchase environmentally preferable products in the next procurement cycle. If a school is unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so, it must submit a letter outlining reasons for noncompliance to the California Department of Education (CDE) and its local governing board annually. It also requires CDE to post information about environmentally preferable cleaning products on its website.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing Proposition 98 GF costs, likely totaling the low thousands to tens of thousands of dollars, for school districts to submit a letter outlining reasons for noncompliance to CDE and their local governing board. Costs would depend on the number of school districts that are unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so. (California has over 1,000 school districts.) If the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill’s requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate, the state would need to reimburse these costs to schools or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant, described in more detail below.
- Ongoing costs to nonpublic schools that are unable to comply because it is not economically feasible to do so to submit a letter outlining reasons for noncompliance to CDE and their local governing board. These costs would not be reimbursed by the state because nonpublic schools are private entities.
- Minor costs to CDE to post information its website and collect and file letters.
COMMENTS:
- Environmentally Preferable. This bill defines “environmentally preferable” products as institutional cleaners that meet independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. Environmentally preferable also excludes any product that must contain a Proposition 65 label indicating that the product contains a chemical that is known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. The bill specifies that schools may use antimicrobials that are regulated by the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act. (Antimicrobial products include disinfectants and sanitizers.)
Three primary independent organizations review cleaning products based on specified standards. They are Green Seal, EcoLogo, and Safer Choice (the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s product certification organization).
- Economically Feasible. This bill defines economically feasible as resulting in no net increase to the cleaning costs of a school.
- K-12 Mandate Block Grant. To address various concerns with the traditional mandate claims process, such as the disincentive for LEAs to perform mandated tasks efficiently, the state created the K-12 Mandate Block Grant in the 2012-13 budget. The amount of funding available in the block grant annually is tied to the number of mandates the CSM has found to be reimbursable and the mandate’s statewide cost. (Typically, when the CSM has determined a claim filed by an LEA to be reimbursable, it has developed a statewide cost estimate for performing the mandate and the state has added the estimated amount or a portion of the estimated amount to the block grant as part of its annual budget process.) School districts that choose to participate in the block grant program receive per-student funding to cover the cost of state-mandated activities in lieu of submitting ongoing mandate claims for reimbursement. School districts receive from the block grant a per-student funding rate for K-8 students of about $30, with about $60 provided for high school students.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2570 (
Author:Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2018
SUBJECT: School facilities: Clean and Healthy Schools Act: environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products
SUMMARY: Establishes the Clean and Healthy Schools Act, and requires, by the 2021-22 school year, or when it is economically feasible, school districts and nonpublic elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase exclusively environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products, if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for the purposes of this bill:
- “Economically feasible” means that there is no net increase in the cleaning costs of a school.
- “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” means a product, including, but not limited to, institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose. “Environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product” does not include a product that must be labeled pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 25249.5) of Division 20 of the Health and Safety Code).
- “Third-party certification” means certification by an established, independent program developed for the purpose of identifying environmentally preferable products and that meets, at a minimum, all of the following criteria:
- Has a formal process of open participation and consultation among interested parties.
- Clearly defines the fees a manufacturer must pay for certification.
- Clearly avoids conflicts of interest in the standard setting and product evaluation process.
- Has the criteria and standards for certification published and publicly available and easily accessible to purchasers, manufacturers, and the general public, such as through the program's Internet Web site, and includes a list of certified products that meet the standards.
- Bases certification of the product and its packaging on criteria for product performance and efficacy, reducing effects on human health and safety, including effects on children, ecological toxicity, other environmental impacts, and resource conservation, including, at a minimum, consideration of chemicals that cause cancer, mutagenic and reproductive harm, organ and nervous system damage, asthma, smog, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, bioaccumulation, and eutrophication.
- Development and selection of criteria are based on sound scientific and engineering principles and data that support the claim of environmental preferability.
- Certification standards remain consistent with current research about the potential impact of chemicals on human health and the environment.
- Monitors and enforces compliance with standards, provides for the authority to inspect the manufacturing facilities, and periodically does so.
- Has a registered, legally protected certification mark or a mark protected by other means so that it may not be misappropriated.
- If possible, is developed by consensus among key stakeholders.
- Establishes a leadership level in standards for products.
- Specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials regulated under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act.
- Authorizes a school district or school to deplete its existing cleaning and maintenance supply stocks and implement the new requirements in the next procurement cycle.
- Specifies that if a school district or school determines that it is not economically feasible to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products by the 2021-22 school year, the school district or school shall submit a letter indicating that it will not purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products to the California Department of Education (CDE) and the governing board of the school district or governing body of the nonpublic school, annually, until it determines that it is economically feasible to comply with the requirements of this bill. Requires the letter to provide the details on the reasons compliance is not feasible and the letter or the explanation to be posted on the school district’s or school’s public Internet Web site with a notification titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act.”
- Requires the CDE to post information on its Internet Web site to assist school districts and schools in complying with the provisions of this bill.
- Specifies that this bill sets minimum standards for cleaning products used in schools. Nothing shall prevent local jurisdictions from adopting guidelines that are more stringent.
- Makes a number of findings and declarations, including the following:
- The vulnerability of children to exposure to chemicals, hazardous waste, and other environmental hazards.
- The benefits of clean indoor air quality, including reduction in the incidence of asthma, allergies, and absenteeism in pupils, increased teacher retention rates, and reduced worker compensation claims.
- Third-party, independent, voluntary certification programs exist that set standards for, and evaluate, environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products. The current standards establish environmental requirements for industrial and institutional general-purpose, restroom, glass, carpet cleaners, floor care products, and handsoaps, intended for routine cleaning of offices, schools, and institutions, and include consideration of vulnerable populations in institutional settings, such as schools and day-care facilities.
EXISTING LAW:
- Expresses declarations and findings regarding the danger of art supplies containing toxic substances. (Education Code (EC) Section 32060)
- Beginning with the 1987-88 school year, prohibits schools, school districts or governing authority of a private school from purchasing or ordering art or craft material that is deemed by the State Department of Health Services to contain a toxic substance or a toxic substance causing chronic illness, for use by students in kindergarten through grade 6. (EC Section 32064)
- Beginning June 1, 1987, prohibits schools, school districts or governing authority of a private school from purchasing or ordering any substance that is deemed by the State Department of Health Services to contain a toxic substance or a toxic substance causing chronic illness, for use by students in grades 7 through 12, unless it meets specified labeling standards. (EC Section 32064)
- Establishes the Healthy Schools Act and specifies that it is the policy of the state that effective least toxic pest management practices should be the preferred method of managing pests at schoolsites, and that the state shall take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective least toxic pest management practices at schools. (EC Section 17610)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: The author states, “More than 1 in 5 Californians – including over 6 million children – spend their day in a school. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body's nervous system and internal organs. While more and more school districts have switched to less-toxic, environmentally preferable cleaning products (or "green" cleaners), conventional cleaning products are still widely used.
“Of particular concern is the link between cleaning products and asthma, since asthma is the leading cause of absenteeism from a chronic illness among California's school children, and is the primary cause of hospitalization for children under the age of 15. In California, nearly 1 million children have asthma (about 1 in 6).”
The United States Environmental Protection Agency reports that all building occupants are potentially exposed to the volatile components of cleaning products. Choosing less hazardous products that have positive environmental attributes (e.g., biodegradability, low toxicity, low volatile organic compound content, reduced packaging, low life cycle energy use) and taking steps to reduce exposure can minimize harmful impacts to custodial workers and building occupants, improve indoor air quality, and reduce water and ambient air pollution while also ensuring the effectiveness of cleaning in removing biological and other contaminants from the building's interior. The California Department of Public Health's (CDPH) Occupational Health Branch, which tracks asthma and chemical exposures related to work, found that 12.5% of the work-related asthma cases in its surveillance database were related to cleaning products.
A guide titled “Healthy Cleaning and Asthma-Safer Schools” published by the CDPH in 2014 states that “a paradox exists for how most of our schools are cleaned. While we’re trying to get rid of dirt and germs to keep students and staff healthy, we may unintentionally expose them to harmful chemicals in cleaning products, sanitizers, and disinfectants. Some conventional products like floor strippers and bathroom cleaners, or ingredients like ammonia and bleach, can pose avoidable risks for our health, our environment, and our equipment.” According to the report, a number of states, including Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Missouri, Nevada, New York, and Vermont, and California school districts, including San Diego Unified School District, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District, and Elk Grove Unified School District, have moved to using green cleaning products.
This bill requires all school districts and private elementary and secondary schools with 50 or more pupils to purchase environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance products if an environmentally preferable cleaning and cleaning maintenance product exists. The bill authorizes a school district to deplete its existing supply and purchase environmentally preferable products in the next procurement cycle.
What are “environmentally preferable" products? The federal government, through Executive Order 13101, defines "environmentally preferable" as "products or services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing products or services that serve the same purpose. This comparison may consider raw materials acquisition, production, manufacturing, packaging, distribution, reuse, operation, maintenance or disposal of the product or service."
This bill defines environmentally preferable products as institutional cleaners for furniture, counters, restrooms, glass, carpets, or floors, that meets independent, third-party certification criteria for lesser or reduced effects on human health and the environment compared with competing goods or services that serve the same purpose, and excludes any product that must contain a Proposition 65 label indicating that the product contains a chemical that is known to cause cancer or birth defects or other reproductive harm. The bill specifies that for antimicrobial cleaning products, the school district or school shall strive to use environmentally preferable products, but may use other antimicrobials that are regulated by the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act. Antimicrobial products include disinfectants and sanitizers that are regulated only by the U.S. EPA.
Cost. State and local public agencies that have transitioned to green cleaning products report that there is either little or no cost increase between conventional cleaners and green certified cleaners. Green cleaners come in concentrate. Automatic dilution equipments provide the proper measurement of cleaning solution. Many entities that use these products have been able to eliminate duplicative and unnecessary products. According to the Healthy Schools Network, Inc., a New York environmental health organization, New York's Office of General Services' Environmental Unit report that "the price point for conventional and certified green products are virtually the same. Any increase in the initial purchase of green products is more than offset by the ease of use, reduction in number of products to buy, and the use of 'dilution stations' that control the actual volume of chemical use automatically and effectively."
Other examples include:
- The San Diego Unified School District reduced its budget by 20% by using one line of chemicals and eliminating unnecessary cleaning products.
- The City of Santa Monica documented a 5% price savings after the switch to green cleaners.
- The Novato Unified School District negotiated a contract for purchasing green cleaners at the same prices as the conventional cleaners.
- The City and County of San Francisco replaced 13 out of 14 janitorial cleaning products at no increased cost.
This bill authorizes a school district or school to delay implementation of the bill if it determines that it not economically feasible to do so. Economically feasible is defined as resulting in no net increase to the cleaning costs of a school. A school district or school that chooses to delay implementation must submit a letter to the governing board or governing body of the private school annually until it complies with the requirement. The letter must be titled “Reasons for Noncompliance with the Clean and Healthy Schools Act” and provide the reasons compliance is not feasible.
Third party certification. There are several independent organizations that review products based on specified standards. Green Seal is based in the United States, EcoLogo is a Canadian program, and the U.S. EPA certifies products through Safer Choice. Most public agencies that have adopted policies to use green cleaners use products certified by one or more of those three entities.
The Occupational Health Branch of the CDPH advises that "there are many 'green' claims being made to sell cleaning products. Product labels tout that the ingredients are 'natural', 'organic', and 'Earth-friendly.' But how can buyers sort out which claims are meaningful and which aren't? The best way is to seek out products that have been certified by third-party organizations that issue openly published standards developed in a process that involves all types of stakeholders."
The CDPH guide for schools also recommends buying products certified by a third party. The guide further states that the products that are certified meet stringent guidelines and that not every company that applies succeeds in getting its products certified.
California’s Department of General Services has a policy requiring state purchases to meet environmentally preferable (EPP) or green standards. Under the policy, all janitorial supply products must be certified by at least one Third-Party Environmental Certification program. State agencies purchase EPP approved products through the CalPIA (the California Prison Industry). Public agencies, including school districts, can also purchase environmentally preferable products through the CalPIA.
For purposes of this bill, authorized products are those that have been certified by a third-party organization that meets eleven criteria specified in the bill. According to the author, Green Seal, EcoLogo and Safer Choice meet the criteria.
Despite the reliance on these three organizations, there are criticisms that one or more of the organizations certify products with toxic chemicals, including products that would be required to post a Proposition 65 warning label. This bill excludes cleaners that must post a Proposition 65 label. However, the author may wish to consider how school districts or schools will determine which products are eligible to be used under this bill if a product certified by a third-party contains a chemical that falls under a Proposition 65 list.
Opponents of the use of third party certifications also charge a “pay to play” scheme as manufacturers must pay for the review of their products. As an alternative, those in the anti-third-party certification camp suggest directing a state agency to develop a state-authorized cleaning products list.
Arguments in support. The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) states, “SEIU represents classified employees in some of the most populous school districts. Our members provide vital educational support, school safety services, maintenance and operations, technical, administrative, language support and cafeteria services. Our members are dedicated to supporting their schools and their students. This bill would help protect the health of our members and their students. Cleaning products used in schools contain a wide variety of hazardous chemicals that can cause asthma, allergies, cancer, reproductive harm, and damage to the body's nervous system and internal organs. And janitorial staff are exposed to these hazardous chemicals every day they are used.”
Arguments in opposition. A joint letter submitted by the opposition states that they support the goal of improving environmental health indoors, but have concerns that the bill contains inconsistencies, may not provide sufficient product certification alternatives, and contains misleading legislative intent language.
Previous legislation. AB 821 (Brownley), introduced in 2009, is substantially similar to this bill. The bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
AB 2808 (Garcia) is also a similar bill. The bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's suspense file in 2008.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Environmental Working Group (sponsor)
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
California Teachers Association
Clean Water Action
Educate. Advocate.
Empower Family California
Regional Asthma Management and Prevention Program
SEIU
Seventh Generation Advisors
Women’s Voices for the Earth
Opposition
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Grocery Manufacturers Association
Household & Commercial Products Association
RISE
Western Plant Health Association
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):