AB 2632: Packaging and labeling: containers: slack fill.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-19
Existing law, known as the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, prohibits a commodities container, or a food container subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading and provides that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents is misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Existing law provides that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for other than specified reasons. Existing law specifies 15 reasons a commodities container, and 6 reasons a food container subject to the FDCA, may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition. Existing law also provides that these state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements.
Existing law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law, establishes the same prohibition against nonfunctional slack fill as described above for commodities containers subject to that law and specifies 14 reasons that a container may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition.
This bill would revise and recast one of the reasons nonfood containers may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition, and would also make this reason applicable to food containers subject to the FDCA. The bill would specify an additional reason containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition.
Existing law, known as the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, prohibits a commodities container, or a food container subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading and provides that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents is misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Existing law provides that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for other than specified reasons. Existing law specifies 15 reasons a commodities container, and 6 reasons a food container subject to the FDCA, may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition. Existing law also provides that these state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements.
Existing law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law, establishes the same prohibition against nonfunctional slack fill as described above for commodities containers subject to that law and specifies 14 reasons that a container may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition.
This bill would revise and recast one of the reasons nonfood containers may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition, and would also make this reason applicable to food containers subject to the FDCA. The bill would specify an additional reason containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition.
Existing law, known as the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, prohibits a commodities container, or a food container subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading and provides that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents is misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Existing law provides that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for other than specified reasons. Existing law specifies 15 reasons a commodities container, and 6 reasons a food container subject to the FDCA, may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition. Existing law also provides that these state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements.
Existing law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law, establishes the same prohibition against nonfunctional slack fill as described above for commodities containers subject to that law and specifies 14 reasons that a container may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition.
This bill would revise and recast one of the reasons nonfood containers may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition, and would also make this reason applicable to food containers subject to the FDCA. The bill would specify 3 an additional reasons reason containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition.
Existing law, known as the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, prohibits a commodities container, or a food container subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading and provides that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents is misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Existing law provides that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for other than specified reasons. Existing law specifies 15 reasons a commodities container, and 6 reasons a food container subject to the FDCA, may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition. Existing law also provides that these state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements.
Existing law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law, establishes the same prohibition against nonfunctional slack fill as described above for commodities containers subject to that law and specifies 14 reasons that a container may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition.
This bill would specify 3 additional reasons containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition.
Existing law, known as the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act, prohibits a commodities container, or a food container subject to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading and provides that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents is misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Existing law provides that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for other than specified reasons. Existing law specifies 15 reasons a commodities container, and 6 reasons a food container subject to the FDCA, may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition. Existing law also provides that these state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements.
Existing law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law, establishes the same prohibition against nonfunctional slack fill as described above for commodities containers subject to that law and specifies 14 reasons that a container may contain slack fill without violating the prohibition.
This bill would specify 3 additional reasons containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition.
(a)No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b)No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size thereof before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging or immediate product container encloses computer hardware or software designed to serve a particular computer function, if the particular computer function to be performed by the computer hardware or software is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(16)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 2.Section 12606.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:12606.2.(a)This section applies to food containers subject to Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), and Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 12606 does not apply to food containers subject to this section.
(b)No food containers shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading.
(c)A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of the machines used for enclosing the contents in the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need for the package to perform a specific function, such as where packaging plays a role in the preparation or consumption of a food, if that function is inherent to the nature of the food and is clearly communicated to consumers.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the food, such as a gift product consisting of a food or foods combined with a container that is intended for further use after the food is consumed or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(8)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(d)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(e)This section shall be interpreted consistent with the comments by the United States Food and Drug Administration on the regulations contained in Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, interpreting Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), as those comments are reported on pages 64123 to 64137, inclusive, of Volume 58 of the Federal Register.
(f)If the requirements of this section do not impose the same requirements as are imposed by Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), or any regulation promulgated pursuant thereto, then this section is not operative to the extent that it is not identical to the federal requirements, and for this purpose those federal requirements are incorporated into this section and shall apply as if they were set forth in this section.
(g)Any sealer may seize any container that is in violation of this section and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any conditions that the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 3.Section 110375 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:110375.(a) No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b) No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size of the container before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any condition as the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return.
(a)No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b)No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size thereof before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging or immediate product container encloses computer hardware or software designed to serve a particular computer function, if the particular computer function to be performed by the computer hardware or software is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(16)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 2.Section 12606.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:12606.2.(a)This section applies to food containers subject to Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), and Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 12606 does not apply to food containers subject to this section.
(b)No food containers shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading.
(c)A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of the machines used for enclosing the contents in the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need for the package to perform a specific function, such as where packaging plays a role in the preparation or consumption of a food, if that function is inherent to the nature of the food and is clearly communicated to consumers.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the food, such as a gift product consisting of a food or foods combined with a container that is intended for further use after the food is consumed or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(8)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(d)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(e)This section shall be interpreted consistent with the comments by the United States Food and Drug Administration on the regulations contained in Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, interpreting Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), as those comments are reported on pages 64123 to 64137, inclusive, of Volume 58 of the Federal Register.
(f)If the requirements of this section do not impose the same requirements as are imposed by Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), or any regulation promulgated pursuant thereto, then this section is not operative to the extent that it is not identical to the federal requirements, and for this purpose those federal requirements are incorporated into this section and shall apply as if they were set forth in this section.
(g)Any sealer may seize any container that is in violation of this section and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any conditions that the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 3.Section 110375 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:110375.(a) No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b) No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size of the container before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any condition as the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return.
(a)No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b)No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size thereof before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging or immediate product container encloses computer hardware or software designed to serve a particular computer function, if the particular computer function to be performed by the computer hardware or software is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(16)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.(17)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.(18)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.(16)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 2.Section 12606.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:12606.2.(a)This section applies to food containers subject to Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), and Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 12606 does not apply to food containers subject to this section.
(b)No food containers shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading.
(c)A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of the machines used for enclosing the contents in the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need for the package to perform a specific function, such as where packaging plays a role in the preparation or consumption of a food, if that function is inherent to the nature of the food and is clearly communicated to consumers.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the food, such as a gift product consisting of a food or foods combined with a container that is intended for further use after the food is consumed or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.(8)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.(9)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.(7)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(8)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(d)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(e)This section shall be interpreted consistent with the comments by the United States Food and Drug Administration on the regulations contained in Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, interpreting Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), as those comments are reported on pages 64123 to 64137, inclusive, of Volume 58 of the Federal Register.
(f)If the requirements of this section do not impose the same requirements as are imposed by Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), or any regulation promulgated pursuant thereto, then this section is not operative to the extent that it is not identical to the federal requirements, and for this purpose those federal requirements are incorporated into this section and shall apply as if they were set forth in this section.
(g)Any sealer may seize any container that is in violation of this section and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any conditions that the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 3.Section 110375 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:110375.(a) No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b) No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.(8)One or more of the following:
(A)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
(B)The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the actual size of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one actual size depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
(C)A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as Fill Line, both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size of the container before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.(16)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.(17)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.(15)The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any condition as the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return.
(a)No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b)No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size thereof before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging or immediate product container encloses computer hardware or software designed to serve a particular computer function, if the particular computer function to be performed by the computer hardware or software is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(16)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(17)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(18)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions the court may impose to insure ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 2.Section 12606.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:12606.2.(a)This section applies to food containers subject to Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), and Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 12606 does not apply to food containers subject to this section.
(b)No food containers shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading.
(c)A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of the machines used for enclosing the contents in the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need for the package to perform a specific function, such as where packaging plays a role in the preparation or consumption of a food, if that function is inherent to the nature of the food and is clearly communicated to consumers.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the food, such as a gift product consisting of a food or foods combined with a container that is intended for further use after the food is consumed or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(8)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(9)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(d)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(e)This section shall be interpreted consistent with the comments by the United States Food and Drug Administration on the regulations contained in Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, interpreting Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), as those comments are reported on pages 64123 to 64137, inclusive, of Volume 58 of the Federal Register.
(f)With the exception of paragraphs (7), (8), and (9) of subdivision (c), if If the requirements of this section do not impose the same requirements as are imposed by Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), or any regulation promulgated pursuant thereto, then this section is not operative to the extent that it is not identical to the federal requirements, and for this purpose those federal requirements are incorporated into this section and shall apply as if they were set forth in this section.
(g)Any sealer may seize any container that is in violation of this section and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any conditions that the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 3.Section 110375 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:110375.(a) No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b) No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size of the container before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(16)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(17)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any condition as the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return.
(a)No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b)No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size thereof prior to before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging or immediate product container encloses computer hardware or software designed to serve a particular computer function, if the particular computer function to be performed by the computer hardware or software is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(16)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(17)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(18)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions the court may impose to insure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 2.Section 12606.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:12606.2.(a)This section applies to food containers subject to Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), and Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 12606 does not apply to food containers subject to this section.
(b)No food containers shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading.
(c)A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of the machines used for enclosing the contents in the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need for the package to perform a specific function, such as where packaging plays a role in the preparation or consumption of a food, if that function is inherent to the nature of the food and is clearly communicated to consumers.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the food, such as a gift product consisting of a food or foods combined with a container that is intended for further use after the food is consumed or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(8)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(9)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(d)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(e)This section shall be interpreted consistent with the comments by the United States Food and Drug Administration on the regulations contained in Section 100.100 of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, interpreting Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), as those comments are reported on pages 64123 to 64137, inclusive, of Volume 58 of the Federal Register.
(f)If With the exception of paragraphs (7), (8), and (9) of subdivision (c), if the requirements of this section do not impose the same requirements as are imposed by Section 403(d) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 343(d)), or any regulation promulgated pursuant thereto, then this section is not operative to the extent that it is not identical to the federal requirements, and for this purpose those federal requirements are incorporated into this section and shall apply as if they were set forth in this section.
(g)Any sealer may seize any container that is in violation of this section and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any conditions that the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner thereof if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return. A proceeding under this section is a limited civil case if the value of the property in controversy is less than or equal to the maximum amount in controversy for a limited civil case under Section 85 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
SEC. 3.Section 110375 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:110375.(a) No container wherein commodities are packed shall have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(b) No container shall be made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. A container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents shall be considered to be filled as to be misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill. Slack fill is the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. Nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
(1)Protection of the contents of the package.
(2)The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package.
(3)Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling.
(4)The need to utilize a larger than required package or container to provide adequate space for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information, such as those based on the regulations adopted by the United States Food and Drug Administration or state or federal agencies under federal or state law, laws or regulations adopted by foreign governments, or under an industrywide voluntary labeling program.
(5)The fact that the product consists of a commodity that is packaged in a decorative or representational container where the container is part of the presentation of the product and has value that is both significant in proportion to the value of the product and independent of its function to hold the product, such as a gift combined with a container that is intended for further use after the product is consumed, or durable commemorative or promotional packages.
(6)An inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices.
(7)The product container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product contained inside, and the dimensions of the actual product container, the product, or the amount of product therein is visible to the consumer at the point of sale, or where obvious secondary use packaging is involved.
(8)The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging, or where the actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the representation is the actual size of the product or the immediate product container.
(9)The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to before use.
(10)The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear and conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package.
(11)The exterior packaging or immediate product container is a kit that consists of a system, or multiple components, designed to produce a particular result that is not dependent upon the quantity of the contents, if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(12)The exterior packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the actual, immediate container of the product being sold, or a depiction of the actual size of the container prior to before purchase.
(13)The exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift packages if the purchaser can adequately determine the quantity and sizes of the immediate product container at the point of sale.
(14)The exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product, together with a free sample or gift, wherein the exterior packaging is necessarily larger than it would otherwise be due to the inclusion of the sample or gift, if the presence of both products and the quantity of each product are clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging.
(15)The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement actual size adjacent to the depiction.
(16)The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term fill line or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
(17)The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
(c)Slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of this section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill.
(d)Any sealer may seize a container that facilitates the perpetration of deception or fraud and the contents of the container. By order of the superior court of the county within which a violation of this section occurs, the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon any condition as the court may impose to ensure against their use in violation of this chapter. The contents of any condemned container shall be returned to the owner if the owner furnishes proper facilities for the return.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 19, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 544, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 19, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 7, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 30 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 1, 2018 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 2, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 18, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 7, 2018 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 30, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 8, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 7, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 3, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 2, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 8, 2018 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2018 | AB 2632 SANTIAGO Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2632 Santiago By Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2018 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2018 | AB 2632 SANTIAGO Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2018 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2632
Author:(Santiago)
As Amended Ver:August 24, 2018
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 78-0 | (May 29, 2018) | SENATE: | 38-0 | (August 28, 2018) |
Original Committee Reference: P. & C.P.
SUMMARY: Expands exemptions in the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA); the state's statute regulating food containers subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act); and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law), under which containers subject to these laws may contain "slack fill" without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws, as specified.
The Senate amendments:
- Narrow the bill by deleting two of the three proposed new nonfunctional slack fill exemptions. The single remaining, new slack fill exemption applies where the mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
- Revise, recast, and expand an existing nonfunctional slack fill exemption that applies under the FPLA and Sherman law, so that it also applies if the product includes a line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as "Fill Line," both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. Specifies that if the product is subject to settling, the line must represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
- Apply the expanded exemption under 2), above, to food containers.
- Make other technical or clarifying changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes certain packaging requirements for containers used for distribution or sale of commodities under the FPLA, including:
- Prohibiting a container in which commodities are packed to have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or to be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud;
- Prohibiting a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declaring that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, as defined below; and,
- Defining "nonfunctional slack fill" as the empty space in a package that is filled to less substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of fifteen specified exemptions, including, for example:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to use; or
- The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear or conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package. (Business and Profession Code Sections (BPC) 12606(a) to (b).)
- These provisions under Section 12606 do not apply to food containers subject to Section 12606.2, below. (BPC 12606.2(a).).
- Establishes certain packaging requirements for food containers subject to the federal FDC Act, including:
- Prohibiting food containers from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading;
- Providing that a food container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill; and
- Defining "nonfunctional slack fill" as the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of six specified exemptions, including, for example:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling; or
- Inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum packages size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices. (BPC 12606.2(b) to (c).)
- Provides that these state provisions regarding food containers must be interpreted consistent with comments by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration interpreting federal law, as specified, and are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. (BPC 12606.2(e) to (f).)
- Establishes certain requirements for the packaging and labeling of foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics under the Sherman Law, including:
- Prohibiting a container in which commodities are packed to have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or to be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud;
- Prohibiting a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declaring that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, as defined below; and
- Defining "nonfunctional slack fill" as the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of fourteen specified exemptions, including, for example:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to use; or
- The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear or conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package. (Health and Safety Code Sections (HSC) 110375(a) to (b).)
- Defines "slack fill" as the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. (BPC 12606(b), 12606.2(c); and HSC 110375(b)). Provides that slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of the above section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill. (BPC 12606(c), 12606.2(d); and Health & Saf. Code Sec. 110375(c).)
- Authorizes any sealer to seize a container in violation of these provisions of law, and provides that by order of the Superior Court the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions imposed by the court against their use in violation of the Act. (BPC 12606(c); 12606.2(f); HSC 110375(d).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: "Slack fill" in product packaging is generally thought of as the empty space between the actual container capacity and the volume of the product in the container. Slack fill can be functional in cases where, for example, it is needed to protect the product, to allow a product to settle over time, or to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. This, as a practical matter, can be as simple as the air space between the chips and the top of the bag to prevent crumbling of the chips inside.
"Nonfunctional" slack fill, however, is generally treated as misleading to the consumer, who might wrongly believe that the larger container suggests a greater amount of product being purchased.
California has three statutes in place that provide slack fill restrictions for three different types of packaging: 1) non-food commodities regulated under the state's FPLA; 2) food containers, in compliance with the FDC Act; and 3) containers that hold foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics regulated under the state's Sherman Law.
The statutes dealing with products regulated by the FPLA and Sherman Law generally prohibit the use of containers that have false bottoms, sidewalls, lids, or coverings, or are otherwise presented in a way that facilitates deception or fraud, or are otherwise misleading.
A container that does not allow the consumer to view its contents is considered misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, which is treated as the empty space in a package (slack fill) that is filled to less substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than those that meet specified exemptions. A few examples of acceptable reasons for slack fill (i.e., that fall under the statutory safe harbors) from the FPLA are:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information;
- The container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer;
- The presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use;
- The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device;
- The packaging or product container is a kit that consists of multiple components if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging; and
- The packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See BPC 12606(b)(1) to (15).)
Those exemptions, notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Under the FPLA, any food containers subject to the federal FDC Act, must meet slightly different requirements for food containers in order to keep state law in line with federal law. Under that specific section of law, California law prohibits misleading food containers generally, treats food containers that do not permit full visibility of the product as misleading if they contain nonfunctional slack fill, and provides for six exemptions from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill. These six exemptions generally recognize safe harbors for:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The need for the package to perform a specific function in the preparation or consumption of food;
- The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is significant, as specified; and
- Where minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices. (See BPC 12606(c)(1) to (6).)
As narrowed by the Senate, this bill adds one new safe harbor which would exempt the following types of packaging from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill: (1) if the mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
Also as amended by the Senate, an existing safe harbor is revised, recast, expanded and applied for the first time to food containers in addition to containers subject to the FPLA or Sherman Act. This safe harbor applies to exempt from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill types of packaging where one of the following applies (changes to existing law reflected in italics):
- The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging.
- The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction (as opposed to "representation" under existing law) is the "actual size" of the product or immediate product container. If there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one "actual size" depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container.
- A line or a graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as "Fill Line," both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale. If the product is subject to settling, the line shall represent the minimum amount of product after settling.
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0005110
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2632
: in Senate
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/2/18
AYES: Hill, Allen, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Pan, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Fuller
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/29/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Grocery Manufacturers of America
DIGEST:
This bill revises and adds an exemption to the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA), the state’s statute regulating food containers (subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act), and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law) under which containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/24/18 revise and recast the reason that specified containers may contain slackfill and make another technical change.
Existing law:
- Establishes the FPLA which is designed to protect purchasers of any commodity within its provisions against deception or misrepresentation; packages and their labels should enable consumers to obtain accurate information as to the quantity of the contents and should facilitate value comparisons. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 12601)
- Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the FPLA if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified.
(BPC § 12606(b)) - States that non-functional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions, including the exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift boxes, the exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product together with a fee sample or gift, and the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, as specified. (BPC § 12606(b))
- Prohibits, under the FDC Act, a food container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. (BPC § 12606.2)
- States that a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered misleading if it contains non-functional slack fill. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Defines “non-functional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than six specified exemptions, including the need for the package to perform a specific function and the fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food, as specified. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Provides that the state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. (BPC § 12606.2(f))
- Establishes specified requirements for the packaging and labeling of foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics under the Sherman Law. (Health and Safety Code (HSC § 110340)
- Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the Sherman Law if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified. (HSC 110370(b))
- Defines “nonfunctional slack fill” to mean the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions including, the exterior packaging of the product.
This bill:
- Revise and recast an exemption to the current list of items which may contain slack fill without violating the slack fill law, including:
- The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging;
- The actual size of the product or immediate product container is clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, excluding the bottom, accompanied by a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the depiction is the ‘actual size’ of the product or immediate product container; and if there are multiple units of the same product in a package, only one ‘actual size’ depiction is required per same size product or immediate product container;
- A line or graphic that represents the product or product fill and a statement communicating that the line or graphic represents the product or product fill such as “Fill Line” both of which are clearly and conspicuously depicted on exterior packaging or the immediate product container if visible at point of sale and if the product is subject to settling, the line must represent the minimum amount of product after settling; and,
- The mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product.
- The dimensions of the product or immediate product container are visible through the exterior packaging;
- Makes other technical changes.
Background
Slack Fill. Slack fill in product packaging is the empty space between the actual capacity in the container/packaging and the volume of the product contained therein. Slack fill can be deemed to be either “functional” or “non-functional.” Functional slack fill may occur as a result of multiple factors, including when extra space in the packaging is needed to protect the product; for product settling; the need to use a larger than required package in order to accommodate mandatory and necessary labeling requirements; or, to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. Nonfunctional slack fill, however, is different than “functional slack fill” in that it is generally considered to be misleading to the consumer who may be confused and incorrectly believe that the larger product packaging will result in more product in the package than actually exists. Nonfunctional slack fill is thus generally treated as misleading to the consumer.
Federal Law. In 1966, the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act was enacted and referred to the concept of nonfunctional slack fill. The law also had a provision authorizing FDA to adopt regulations to “prevent the nonfunctional slack fill of packages” containing food, drugs, devices, or cosmetics. (FPLA, §5(c)(4)). In 1994, the FDA promulgated regulations establishing general principles on non-functional slack fill. The regulation goes on to list the six exemptions, (also referred to as “safe harbors”), to the prohibition against misleading packaging; including, for example, exempting use of non-functional slack fill when necessary to protect the contents of the package, the requirements of machines used for packaging, or the settling of the product during shipping or handling.
California Law. In order to address the issue of functional and non-functional slack fill, California has three statutes in place to protect consumers: 1) FPLA, 2) Sherman Law and the provisions of the 3) FDC Act. Similar to federal law, FPLA (BPC §§12601-12615.5) governs misleading packaging of consumer products. Specifically, BPC §12606 prohibits a container from containing a false bottom or side or lid, or to be filled in such a way as to promote deception or fraud.
In 1997, AB 1394 (Figueroa, Chapter 711, Statutes of 1997) was enacted to further prohibit a container from being made or filled as to be misleading, and provided
15 exceptions to the non-functional slack fill provisions. In 2013, as a result of
SB 465 (Correa, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2013) the provisions related to “slack fill laws” clarified one of the exemptions of what is considered “nonfunctional” slack fill under the FPLA and the Sherman Law and further amended, under the FPLA, FDC Act, and the Sherman Law, the definition of “nonfunctional slack fill.”
As previously noted, under the FPLA and the Sherman Law, a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered to be filled as misleading, if it contains “nonfunctional slack fill”. However, current law provides specified “exemptions” as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill”. Some of the exemptions as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill include: 1) protection of the contents of the package; 2) the requirements of machines used for enclosing the package; 3) unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling; 4) the need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information; 5) the container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer; 6) the presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use; and, 7) the packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See Bus. & Prof. Code §. 12606(b)(1)-(15).) (HSC § 110375(b)(1)-(14))
Regarding the FDC Act, the above exemptions specified in statute regarding what is exempted from being considered “nonfunctional” slack fill notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Specifically, BPC § 12606.2, specifies that the provisions of BPC § 12606 (which the 15 exemptions are included) do not apply to the federal FDC Act. This bill revises and adds an exemption, which would be applied under the FPLA, the Sherman Law and the federal FDC Act.
This bill seeks to revise and recast and add an exemption to the definition of “nonfunctional” slack fill: (1) where the dimension are available through the exterior packaging, as specified; (2) where the exterior packaging indicates a “fill line,” as specified; and (3) if the mode of commerce does not allow the consumer to view or handle the physical container or product
According to information from the bill’s sponsors, adding three additional exemptions would provide clarity for manufacturers and consumers. Specifically, allow a company to identify a number of products in the package and communicate the actual size and provide a silhouette of the item or a “fill line” which notes the average fill of a product, and would additionally address products purchased without a consumer’s direct access to the product prior to purchase, such as through e-commerce.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Grocery Manufacturers of America (source)
Agricultural Council of California
American Beverage Association
American Cleaning Institute
Association of Food Beverage and Consumer Products Companies
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Council for Responsible Nutrition
Household & Commercial Products Association
National Confectioners Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/24/18)
California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association
Contra Costa County District Attorney’s Office
Marin County District Attorney’s Office
Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office
Shasta County District Attorney’s Office
Sonoma County District Attorney’s Office
Yolo County District Attorney’s Office
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters contend that this bill “proposes to clearly articulate circumstances wherein nonfunctional slack fill would be deemed permissible, and in doing so, adds clarity to product manufacturers and consumers. These exemptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities. In particular, AB 2632 would provide an exemption where a package containing a discrete number of products (such as in the case of snack bars), clearly communicates the actual size and number of such products on the exterior packaging. Similarly, where a package contains a specified number of immediate product containers, which in turn contains a specified volume or amount of products (such as where contact lens solution is sold in a bottle inside a box), AB 2632 would provide an exemption when this information is communicated by depicting the immediate product containers on the exterior packaging, in combination with a “fill line.” This latter scenario would also cover products (such as powders or cereals) that may settle during shipping.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents state that the concept of defining acceptable and legal applications for “non-functional slack fill” has been a difficult task that has divided regulators and industry for many years and that any “safe harbor” to allow for “non-functional slack fill” only serves to mislead consumers.” Opponents are also concerned that this bill improperly conflicts with federal law.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/29/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
8/27/18 12:35:33
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2632
:
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/2/18
AYES: Hill, Allen, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Pan, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Fuller
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/29/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Grocery Manufacturers of America
DIGEST:
This bill adds three new exemptions to the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA), the state’s statute regulating food containers (subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act), and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law)) under which containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws, as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes the FPLA which is designed to protect purchasers of any commodity within its provisions against deception or misrepresentation; packages and their labels should enable consumers to obtain accurate information as to the quantity of the contents and should facilitate value comparisons. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 12601)
- Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the FPLA if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified.
(BPC § 12606(b)) - States that non-functional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions, including the exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift boxes, the exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product together with a fee sample or gift, and the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, as specified. (BPC § 12606(b))
- Prohibits, under the FDC Act, a food container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. (BPC § 12606.2)
- States that a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered misleading if it contains non-functional slack fill. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Defines “non-functional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than six specified exemptions, including the need for the package to perform a specific function and the fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food, as specified. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Provides that the state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. (BPC § 12606.2(f))
- Establishes specified requirements for the packaging and labeling of foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics under the Sherman Law. (Health and Safety Code (HSC § 110340)
- Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the Sherman Law if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified. (HSC 110370(b))
- Defines “nonfunctional slack fill” to mean the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions including, the exterior packaging of the product .
This bill:
- Adds the three additional exemptions to the current list of items which may contain slack fill without violating the slack fill law, including:
- The exterior packaging (of a product) to states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contain a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bear the statement “actual size” adjacent to the depiction;
- The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, to indicate the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term “fill line” or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level; and,
- The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before the purchase.
- Makes other technical changes.
Background
Slack Fill. Slack fill in product packaging is the empty space between the actual capacity in the container/packaging and the volume of the product contained therein. Slack fill can be deemed to be either “functional” or “non-functional.” Functional slack fill may occur as a result of multiple factors, including when extra space in the packaging is needed to protect the product; for product settling; the need to use a larger than required package in order to accommodate mandatory and necessary labeling requirements; or, to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. Nonfunctional slack fill, however, is different than “functional slack fill” in that it is generally considered to be misleading to the consumer who may be confused and incorrectly believe that the larger product packaging will result in more product in the package than actually exists. Nonfunctional slack fill is thus generally treated as misleading to the consumer.
Federal Law. In 1966, the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act was enacted and referred to the concept of nonfunctional slack fill. The law also had a provision authorizing FDA to adopt regulations to “prevent the nonfunctional slack fill of packages” containing food, drugs, devices, or cosmetics. (FPLA, §5(c)(4)). In 1994, the FDA promulgated regulations establishing general principles on non-functional slack fill. The regulation goes on to list the six exemptions, (also referred to as “safe harbors”), to the prohibition against misleading packaging; including, for example, exempting use of non-functional slack fill when necessary to protect the contents of the package, the requirements of machines used for packaging, or the settling of the product during shipping or handling.
California Law. In order to address the issue of functional and non-functional slack fill, California has three statutes in place to protect consumers: 1) FPLA, 2) Sherman Law and the provisions of the 3) FDC Act. Similar to federal law, FPLA (BPC §§12601-12615.5) governs misleading packaging of consumer products. Specifically, BPC §12606 prohibits a container from containing a false bottom or side or lid, or to be filled in such a way as to promote deception or fraud.
In 1997, AB 1394 (Figueroa, Chapter 711, Statutes of 1997) was enacted to further prohibit a container from being made or filled as to be misleading, and provided
15 exceptions to the non-functional slack fill provisions. In 2013, as a result of
SB 465 (Correa, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2013) the provisions related to “slack fill laws” clarified one of the exemptions of what is considered “nonfunctional” slack fill under the FPLA and the Sherman Law and further amended, under the FPLA, FDC Act, and the Sherman Law, the definition of “nonfunctional slack fill.”
As previously noted, under the FPLA and the Sherman Law, a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered to be filled as misleading, if it contains “nonfunctional slack fill”. However, current law provides specified “exemptions” as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill”. Some of the exemptions as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill include: 1) protection of the contents of the package; 2) the requirements of machines used for enclosing the package; 3) unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling; 4) the need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information; 5) the container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer; 6) the presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use; and, 7) the packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See Bus. & Prof. Code §. 12606(b)(1)-(15).) (HSC § 110375(b)(1)-(14))
Regarding the FDC Act, the above exemptions specified in statute regarding what is exempted from being considered “nonfunctional” slack fill notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Specifically, BPC § 12606.2, specifies that the provisions of BPC § 12606 (which the 15 exemptions are included) do not apply to the federal FDC Act. This bill adds three exemptions, which would be applied under the FPLA, the Sherman Law and the federal FDC Act.
This bill seeks to add three additional exemptions to the definition of “nonfunctional” slack fill: (1) where the packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, and contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, as specified; (2) where the exterior packaging indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and is accompanied by the term “fill line,” as specified; and (3) if the mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
According to information from the bill’s sponsors, adding three additional exemptions would provide clarity for manufacturers and consumers. Specifically, allow a company to identify a number of products in the package and communicate the actual size and provide a silhouette of the item or a “fill line” which notes the average fill of a product, and would additionally address products purchased without a consumer’s direct access to the product prior to purchase, such as through e-commerce.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Grocery Manufacturers of America (source)
Agricultural Council of California
American Cleaning Institute
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Council for Responsible Nutrition
Household & Commercial Products Association
National Confectioners Association
California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association
Contra Costa County District Attorney’s Office
Marin County District Attorney’s Office
Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office
Shasta County District Attorney’s Office
Yolo County District Attorney’s Office
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters contend that this bill “proposes to clearly articulate circumstances wherein nonfunctional slack fill would be deemed permissible, and in doing so, adds clarity to product manufacturers and consumers. These exemptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities. In particular, AB 2632 would provide an exemption where a package containing a discrete number of products (such as in the case of snack bars), clearly communicates the actual size and number of such products on the exterior packaging. Similarly, where a package contains a specified number of immediate product containers, which in turn contains a specified volume or amount of products (such as where contact lens solution is sold in a bottle inside a box), AB 2632 would provide an exemption when this information is communicated by depicting the immediate product containers on the exterior packaging, in combination with a “fill line.” This latter scenario would also cover products (such as powders or cereals) that may settle during shipping.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents state that the concept of defining acceptable and legal applications for “non-functional slack fill” has been a difficult task that has divided regulators and industry for many years and that any “safe harbor” to allow for “non-functional slack fill” only serves to mislead consumers.” Opponents are also concerned that this bill improperly conflicts with federal law.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/29/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
7/3/18 16:08:02
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 2, 2018
Author: | |||
Version: | May 7, 2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Elissa Silva | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Adds three new exemptions to the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA), the state’s statute regulating food containers subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act), and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law), under which containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws, as specified.
Existing law, the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act:
- Establishes the FPLA which is designed to protect purchasers of any commodity within its provisions against deception or misrepresentation; packages and their labels should enable consumers to obtain accurate information as to the quantity of the contents and should facilitate value comparisons. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 12601)
- Prohibits any person, as specified, from distributing any packaged commodity unless it meets regulations specified by the secretary of the Department of Food and Agriculture (DFA) pertaining to labeling and packaging requirements.
(BPC § 12603) - Prohibits any container wherein commodities are packed from having a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled wholly or partially as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud.
(BPC § 12606(a)) - Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the FPLA if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified.
(BPC § 12606(b)) - States that non-functional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions, including the exterior packaging consists of single or multiunit presentation boxes of holiday or gift boxes, the exterior packaging is for a combination of one purchased product together with a fee sample or gift, and the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, as specified. (BPC § 12606(b))
Existing law, the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act:
- Prohibits, under the FDC Act, a food container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading. (BPC § 12606.2)
- States that a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered misleading if it contains non-functional slack fill. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Defines “non-functional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than six specified exemptions, including the need for the package to perform a specific function and the fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food, as specified. (BPC § 12606.2(c))
- Provides that the state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. (BPC § 12606.2(f))
Existing state law, the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law:
- Establishes specified requirements for the packaging and labeling of foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics under the Sherman Law. (Health and Safety Code (HSC § 110340)
- Prohibits any container wherein commodities are packed from having a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or be otherwise so constructed or filled wholly or partially as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud. (HSC § 110375(a))
- Prohibits a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declares that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates the Sherman Law if it contains non-functional slack fil, as specified.
(HSC 110370(b)) - Defines “nonfunctional slack fill” to mean the empty space in a package that is filled to less than its capacity for reasons other than fifteen specified exemptions including, the exterior packaging of the product
This bill:
- Adds the three additional exemptions to the current list of items which may contain slack fill without violating the slack fill law, including:
- The exterior packaging (of a product) to states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contain a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bear the statement “actual size” adjacent to the depiction;
- The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, to indicate the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term “fill line” or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level; and,
- The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before the purchase.
- Makes other technical changes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
None. This bill is not keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the Grocery Manufacturers of America. According to the Author, “Over the past twenty years there have been several attempts to bring clarity and consistency to the implementation of slack fill. However, during this same time period there has been a consistent subjective interpretation of the plain language of the statute and the purpose of the exemptions first enumerated by the Attorney General in 1988 and placed into law by the Legislature in 1997. Subjective interpretation, class action suits and regulatory actions based on slack-fill allegations continue to proliferate. As such, several food, beverage, consumer products, and general business groups identified the need to clarify several commonly employed methods for communicating the amount of product contained in a package. These additional safe harbors will reduce uncertainty for businesses and promote greater information for consumers. “
- Background.
Slack Fill. Slack fill in product packaging is the empty space between the actual capacity in the container/packaging and the volume of the product contained therein. Slack fill can be deemed to be either “functional” or “non-functional.” Functional slack fill may occur as a result of multiple factors, including when extra space in the packaging is needed to protect the product; for product settling; the need to use a larger than required package in order to accommodate mandatory and necessary labeling requirements; or, to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. Nonfunctional slack fill, however, is different than “functional slack fill” in that it is generally considered to be misleading to the consumer who may be confused and incorrectly believe that the larger product packaging will result in more product in the package than actually exists. Nonfunctional slack fill is thus generally treated as misleading to the consumer.
To help navigate the complex requirements of commodity packaging, federal and California state laws have been enacted to help delineate between what is, and what is not, appropriate slack fill in a commodity. This bill seeks to add three new “exemptions” to the definition of what is not considered “nonfunctional” slack fill in a packaged commodity.
Federal Law. The FDC Act was established in 1938 (21 U.S.C. 301 et seq) and explicitly prohibited misleading packaging for FDA regulated products. In 1966, the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act was enacted and referred to the concept of nonfunctional slack fill. The law also had a provision authorizing FDA to adopt regulations to “prevent the nonfunctional slack fill of packages” containing food, drugs, devices, or cosmetics. (FPLA, §5(c)(4)). In 1994, the FDA promulgated regulations establishing general principles on non-functional slack fill. The regulation goes on to list the six exemptions, (also referred to as “safe harbors”), to the prohibition against misleading packaging; including, for example, exempting use of non-functional slack fill when necessary to protect the contents of the package, the requirements of machines used for packaging, or the settling of the product during shipping or handling.
California Law. In order to address the issue of functional and non-functional slack fill, California has three statutes in place to protect consumers: 1) FPLA, 2) Sherman Law and the provisions of the 3) FDC Act. Similar to federal law, FPLA (BPC §§12601-12615.5) governs misleading packaging of consumer products. Specifically, BPC §12606 prohibits a container from containing a false bottom or side or lid, or to be filled in such a way as to promote deception or fraud.
In 1997, AB 1394 (Figueroa, Chapter 711, Statutes of 1997) was enacted to further prohibit a container from being made or filled as to be misleading, and provided
15 exceptions to the non-functional slack fill provisions. In 2013, as a result of
SB 465 (Correa, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2013) the provisions related to “slack fill laws” clarified one of the exemptions of what is considered “nonfunctional” slack fill under the FPLA and the Sherman Law and further amended, under the FPLA, FDC Act, and the Sherman Law, the definition of “nonfunctional slack fill.”
As previously noted, under the FPLA and the Sherman Law, a container that does not allow the consumer to fully view its contents is considered to be filled as misleading, if it contains “nonfunctional slack fill”. However, current law provides specified “exemptions” as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill”. Some of the exemptions as to what may be considered “nonfunctional slack fill include:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- the need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information;
- the container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer;
- the presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use;
- the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device;
- the packaging or product container is a kit that consists of multiple components if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging; and,
- the packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See Bus. & Prof. Code §. 12606(b)(1)-(15).) (HSC § 110375(b)(1)-(14))
- protection of the contents of the package;
Regarding the FDC Act, the above exemptions specified in statute regarding what is exempted from being considered “nonfunctional” slack fill notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Specifically, BPC § 12606.2, specifies that the provisions of BPC § 12606 (which the 15 exemptions are included) do not apply to the federal FDC Act. This bill would add three exemptions, which would be applied under the FPLA, the Sherman Law and the federal FDC Act.
This bill seeks to add three additional exemptions to the definition of “nonfunctional” slack fill: (1) where the packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, and contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, as specified; (2) where the exterior packaging indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and is accompanied by the term “fill line,” as specified; and (3) if the mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
According to information from the bill’s sponsors, adding three additional exemptions would provide clarity for manufacturers and consumers. Specifically, allow a company to identify a number of products in the package and communicate the actual size and provide a silhouette of the item or a “fill line” which notes the average fill of a product, and would additionally address products purchased without a consumer’s direct access to the product prior to purchase, such as through e-commerce.
- Prior Related Legislation. SB 465 (Correa, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2013), amended packaging requirements pertaining to non-food-commodities and food containers in the FPLA, the FDC, and in the Sherman Law.
AB 1394 (Figueroa, Chapter 711, Statutes of 1997) revised the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act to expand the existing exceptions for slack fill in non-food commodities packaging from two exemptions to fifteen (based in large part on the "Slack Fill Enforcement Guidelines" agreed to in 1988 by the Attorney General, the Department of Food and Agriculture and the California Association of Weights and Measures Officials). AB 1394 aimed to reduce frivolous lawsuits against manufacturers and retailers while maintaining reasonable advertising protections for consumers.
AB 1295 (Caldera of 1997) proposed major changes to the Unfair Practices Act
(BPC 17000, et seq.) to restrict the ability of private plaintiffs to bring lawsuits alleging unfair competition or false advertising and seeking monetary recovery for a number of product manufacturers, including software manufacturers who package computer software in containers larger than necessary to hold the disk. (Status:
AB 1295 failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.)
SB 735 (Marks, Chapter 849, Statutes of 1995) prohibited food containers from being made, formed or filled as to be misleading, defined the term "nonfunctional slack fill" as the empty space in a package filled to less than capacity for reasons other than those six specified, and provided that these provisions be interpreted as consistent with the US Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) comments in the Code of Federal Regulations, as specified, and thus adopts by reference provisions of the federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. SB 735 was jointly sponsored by the Los Angeles and Venture County District Attorneys to conform California law to federal law.
- Arguments in Support. The Grocery Manufacturers Association, California Chamber of Commerce, California Grocers Association, California Manufacturers and Technology Association, California Retailers Association, Civil Justice Association of California, Household & Commercial Products Association, National Confectioners Association, Council for Responsible Nutrition, American Cleaning Institute®, and the Agricultural Council of California write in support, “AB 2632 proposes to clearly articulate circumstances wherein nonfunctional slack fill would be deemed permissible, and in doing so, adds clarity to product manufacturers and consumers. These exemptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities. In particular, AB 2632 would provide an exemption where a package containing a discrete number of products (such as in the case of snack bars), clearly communicates the actual size and number of such products on the exterior packaging. Similarly, where a package contains a specified number of immediate product containers, which in turn contains a specified volume or amount of products (such as where contact lens solution is sold in a bottle inside a box), AB 2632 would provide an exemption when this information is communicated by depicting the immediate product containers on the exterior packaging, in combination with a “fill line.” This latter scenario would also cover products (such as powders or cereals) that may settle during shipping.”
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association (CACASA) writes in opposition, “The concept of defining acceptable and legal applications for “non-functional slack fill” has been a difficult task that has divided regulators and industry for many years. CACASA has taken the consistent position that any “safe harbor” to allow for “non-functional slack fill” only serves to mislead consumers.”
The Yolo County, Santa Clara County, Marin County, Contra Costa County and the Shasta County District Attorney’s Offices, write in opposition, “AB 2632 seeks to add safe harbors to allow nonfunctional “slack fill” under additional specified conditions. After substantial consideration, we see several issues with the bill in its current form and are concerned that it improperly conflicts with federal law.”
- Policy Considerations.
- Will this bill shrink consumer protections? BPC § 12601 states that the fair packaging law is designed to protect purchasers of any commodity…against deception and misrepresentation. Packages and their labels should enable consumers to obtain accurate information as to the quantity of the contents and should facilitate value comparisons. By adding three additional exemptions to current law with respect to what is not nonfunctional slack fill, could this bill have the unintended consequence of creating consumer confusion when purchasing products and increase consumer complaints?
- Federal preemption. The slack fill provisions pertaining to food containers under the FDA Act (BPC 12606.2(e)) state that if the requirements of that section are not the same as those contained in the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act or any regulation promulgated thereunder, then this statute would not be operative to the extent that it is not identical with the federal requirements. By adding three additional exemptions to what is considered nonfunctional slack fill under this section of law, would make it different than what is under the FDA Act. The question arises as to whether or not this would be federally preempted? Additionally, as California law has more exemptions than what is permissible at the federal level, why include these three under the BPC § 12606.2?
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Grocery Manufacturers Association (sponsor)
Agricultural Council of California
American Cleaning Institute®
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Council for Responsible Nutrition
Household & Commercial Products Association
National Confectioners Association
Opposition:
California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association
Contra Costa County District Attorney’s Office
Marin County District Attorney’s Office
Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office
Shasta County District Attorney’s Office
Yolo County District Attorney’s Office
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2632
Author:(Santiago)
As Amended Ver:May 7, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Privacy | 10-0 | Chau, Kiley, Baker, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Mullin, Obernolte, Reyes, Ting |
SUMMARY: This bill adds three new exemptions to the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA); the state's statute regulating food containers subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act); and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law), under which containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws. Specifically, this bill:
- Adds to the FPLA, provisions related to the FDC Act, and Sherman Law additional safe harbors, specifying that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
- The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement "actual size" adjacent to the depiction.
- The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term "fill line" or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
- The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
- Makes other technical, non-substantive changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: Slack fill in product packaging is generally thought of as the empty space between the actual container capacity and the volume of the product in the container. Slack fill can be functional in cases where, for example, it is needed to protect the product, to allow a product to settle over time, or to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. This, as a practical matter, can be as simple as the air space between the chips and the top of the bag to prevent crumbling of the chips inside.
"Nonfunctional" slack fill, however, is generally treated as misleading to the consumer, who might wrongly believe that the larger container suggests a greater amount of product being purchased.
California has three statutes in place that provide slack fill restrictions for three different types of packaging: (1) non-food commodities regulated under the state's FPLA; (2) food containers, in compliance with the FDC Act; and (3) containers that hold foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics regulated under the state's Sherman Law.
The statutes dealing with products regulated by the FPLA and Sherman Law generally prohibit the use of containers that have false bottoms, sidewalls, lids, or coverings, or are otherwise presented in a way that facilitates deception or fraud, or are otherwise misleading.
A container that does not allow the consumer to view its contents is considered misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, which is treated as the empty space in a package (slack fill) that is filled to less substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than those that meet specified exemptions. A few examples of acceptable reasons for slack fill (i.e., that fall under the statutory safe harbors) from the FPLA are:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information;
- The container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer;
- The presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use;
- The exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device;
- The packaging or product container is a kit that consists of multiple components if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging; and
- The packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See Business and Professions Code Section 12606(b)(1)-(15).)
Those exemptions, notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Under the FPLA, any food containers subject to the federal FDC Act, must meet slightly different requirements for food containers in order to keep state law in line with federal law. Under that specific section of law, California law prohibits misleading food containers generally, treats food containers that do not permit full visibility of the product as misleading if they contain nonfunctional slack fill, and provides for six exemptions from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill. These six exemptions generally recognize safe harbors for:
- Protection of the contents of the package;
- The requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- Unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- The need for the package to perform a specific function in the preparation or consumption of food;
- The fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is significant, as specified; and
- Where minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices. (See Business and Professions Code Section 12606(c)(1)-(6).)
This bill adds three new safe harbors which would exempt the following types of packaging from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill: (1) where the packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, and contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, as specified; (2) where the exterior packaging indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and is accompanied by the term "fill line," as specified; and (3) if the mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: A coalition of consumer product and food manufacturing companies and employers, including the Grocery Manufacturers Association (sponsor), the California Chamber of Commerce, California Retailers Association, and the Civil Justice Association of California, among others, writes in support of this bill:
AB 2632 proposes to clearly articulate circumstances wherein nonfunctional slack fill would be deemed permissible, and in doing so, adds clarity to product manufacturers and consumers. These exemptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities.
[…]
Due to increasing consumer product and safety protocols over the past several years, there are many products such as over the counter drugs, grooming products or alcoholic beverages that are available in the store but do not permit the consumer to have direct access until purchase. In addition, e-commerce has also increased steadily over the past several years. In both cases, items have visual and written descriptions as required by law. However, the consumer does not have access to the packaged product until after purchase. In the case of in store purchases, consumers sometimes take a purchase slip or have a clerk carry the product to checkout before purchase. In the case of e-commerce, descriptions, pictures, dimensions and consumer comments provide a narrative description until the product arrives at their homes. In both cases, consumers have made the purchase decision and manufacturers may need the same clarity for shipping containers or packaging.
Like SB 465 (Correa), Chapter 425, Statutes of 2013, AB 2632 would again update the slack fill statutes with common sense opportunities to convey information to the consumer and reduce unnecessary enforcement actions by adding additional clarity to the slack fill requirements.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association (CACASA) writes in opposition to the bill, that the "concept of defining acceptable and legal applications for 'non-functional slack fill' has been a difficult task that has divided regulators and industry for many years. CACASA has taken the consistent position that any 'safe harbor' to allow for 'non-functional slack fill' only serves to mislead consumers. For example, the presence of a photo or silhouette on the exterior of the package depicting the 'actual size' of the product should not give free reign to package the product in an oversized box and deem the unused space within the package 'legal non-functional slack fill'. County sealers would argue that the only benefit of a larger box in this case is to entice a consumer to buy one product over another."
Additionally, the County of Riverside District Attorneys argue in opposition that the new safe harbors proposed under this bill for food containers as regulated by the FDC Act would in fact be preempted under federal law.
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0002810
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2632 (
Author:Santiago) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2018
SUBJECT: Packaging and labeling: containers: slack fill
SUMMARY: This bill would add three new exemptions to the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA); the state’s statute regulating food containers subject to the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDC Act); and the Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Laws (Sherman Law), under which containers subject to any of these provisions may contain slack fill without violating the nonfunctional slack fill prohibition of those laws. Specifically, this bill would:
- Add to the FPLA, provisions related to the FDC Act, and Sherman Law additional safe harbors, specifying that nonfunctional slack fill is the empty space in a package that is filled substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of the following:
- The exterior packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, and bears the statement “actual size” adjacent to the depiction.
- The exterior packaging, or an actual size depiction of the immediate product container that is displayed on the exterior packaging, indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and which is accompanied by the term “fill line” or other statement communicating that the fill line or silhouette represents the amount of the product contained in the immediate product container. If the product is subject to settling, the statement may indicate that the line represents an average fill level.
- The mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
- Exempt, for purposes of the statute regulating food containers subject to the FDC Act, the above safe harbors from the federal preemption language which specifically limits the operation of the existing safe harbors to the extent that they are identical to specified federal requirements.
- Make other technical, non-substantive changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes certain packaging requirements for containers used for distribution or sale of commodities under the FPLA, including:
- prohibiting a container in which commodities are packed to have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or to be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud;
- prohibiting a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declaring that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, as defined below; and,
- defining “nonfunctional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to less substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of fifteen specified exemptions, including, for example:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- the presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to use; or
- the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear or conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 12606(a)-(b).)
- These provisions under Section 12606 do not apply to food containers subject to Section 12606.2, below. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 12606.2(a).).
- Establishes certain packaging requirements for food containers subject to the federal FDC Act, including:
- prohibiting food containers from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading;
- providing that a food container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill; and
- defining “nonfunctional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of six specified exemptions, including, for example:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling; or
- inability to increase the level of fill or to further reduce the size of the package, such as where some minimum packages size is necessary to accommodate required food labeling exclusive of any vignettes or other nonmandatory designs or label information, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 12606.2(b)-(c).)
- Provides that these state provisions regarding food containers must be interpreted consistent with comments by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration interpreting federal law, as specified, and are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 12606.2(e)-(f).)
- Establishes certain requirements for the packaging and labeling of foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics under the Sherman Law, including:
- prohibiting a container in which commodities are packed to have a false bottom, false sidewalls, false lid or covering, or to be otherwise so constructed or filled, wholly or partially, as to facilitate the perpetration of deception or fraud;
- prohibiting a container from being made, formed, or filled as to be misleading, and declaring that a container that does not allow a consumer to fully view its contents violates this provision if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, as defined below; and
- defining “nonfunctional slack fill” as the empty space in a package that is filled to substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than any one or more of fourteen specified exemptions, including, for example:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the contents of the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- the presence of any headspace within an immediate product container necessary to facilitate the mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing of liquids or powders by consumers prior to use; or
- the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device if the device is visible, or a clear or conspicuous depiction of the device appears on the exterior packaging, or it is readily apparent from the conspicuous exterior disclosures or the nature and name of the product that a delivery or dosing device is contained in the package. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 110375(a)-(b).)
- Defines “slack fill” as the difference between the actual capacity of a container and the volume of product contained therein. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 12606(b), 12606.2(c); and Health & Saf. Code Sec. 110375(b)). Provides that slack fill in a package shall not be used as grounds to allege a violation of the above section based solely on its presence unless it is nonfunctional slack fill. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 12606(c), 12606.2(d); and Health & Saf. Code Sec. 110375(c).)
- Authorizes any sealer to seize a container in violation of these provisions of law, and provides that by order of the Superior Court the containers seized shall be condemned and destroyed or released upon conditions imposed by the court against their use in violation of the Act. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 12606(c); 12606.2(f); Health & Saf. Code Sec. 110375(d).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to provide manufacturers and retailers with greater clarity and certainty regarding the various requirements for product and food packaging – specifically, the prohibited empty space in packages known as “nonfunctional slack fill” and the multiple exemptions to that prohibition referred to as “safe harbors.” This bill is sponsored by the Grocery Manufacturers Association.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “Over the past twenty years there have been several attempts to bring clarity and consistency to the implementation of slack fill. However, during this same time period there has been a consistent subjective interpretation of the plain language of the statute and the purpose of the exemptions first enumerated by the Attorney General in 1988 and placed into law by the Legislature in 1997.
Subjective interpretation, class action suits and regulatory actions based on slack-fill allegations continue to proliferate. As such, several food, beverage, consumer products, and general business groups identified the need to clarify several commonly employed methods for communicating the amount of product contained in a package. These additional safe harbors will reduce uncertainty for businesses and promote greater information for consumers. […]
To further facilitate uniformity in enforcement and clarity in implementation, California’s slack fill law should be amended to take account of additional techniques companies use to convey to consumers the amount of the product in a container. These exceptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities, and therefore we would propose to include these in both Section 12606 and Section 12606.2.
In particular, where a package contains a discrete number of products (such as in the case of snack bars), the size and number of such products can be clearly communicated on the exterior packaging.
Similarly, where a package contains a specified number of immediate product containers, which in turn contains a specified volume or amount of products (such as where contact lens solution is sold in a bottle inside a box), this can be communicated by depicting the immediate product containers on the exterior packaging, in combination with a “fill line.” This latter scenario would also embrace products (such as powders or cereals) that may settle during shipping.
E-commerce has substantially increased over the past several years. Specifically, consumers can order everything from fresh fruit, prepared foods, or virtually any consumer product they could purchase at a traditional bricks and mortar retail location. Items available for purchase online have visual and written descriptions in addition to also usually having consumer feedback about the item. Online purchases often have more information available to the consumer than what is generally available at the retail location. However, bananas or lip balm cannot be feasibly transported from warehouse to the doorstep without additional packaging. The additional packaging is necessary to facilitate transportation and processing in addition to the protection of the enclosed items.”
- Current slack-fill laws: Slack fill in product packaging is generally thought of as the empty space between the actual container capacity and the volume of the product in the container. Slack fill can be functional in cases where, for example, it is needed to protect the product, to allow a product to settle over time, or to accommodate machinery in the manufacturing process. This, as a practical matter, can be as simple as the air space between the chips and the top of the bag to prevent crumbling of the chips inside.
“Nonfunctional” slack fill, however, is generally treated as misleading to the consumer, who might wrongly believe that the larger container suggests a greater amount of product being purchased.
California has three statutes in place that provide slack fill restrictions for three different types of packaging: (1) non-food commodities regulated under the state’s FPLA; (2) food containers, in compliance with the FDC Act; and (3) containers that hold foods, drugs, devices, and cosmetics regulated under the state’s Sherman Law.
The statutes dealing with products regulated by the FPLA and Sherman Law generally prohibit the use of containers that have false bottoms, sidewalls, lids, or coverings, or are otherwise presented in a way that facilitates deception or fraud, or are otherwise misleading.
A container that does not allow the consumer to view its contents is considered misleading if it contains nonfunctional slack fill, which is treated as the empty space in a package (slack fill) that is filled to less substantially less than its capacity for reasons other than those that meet specified exemptions. A few examples of acceptable reasons for slack fill (i.e., that fall under the statutory safe harbors) from the FPLA are:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- the need to use a larger package or for the legible presentation of mandatory and necessary labeling information;
- the container bears a reasonable relationship to the actual amount of product inside, and the dimensions of the container, the product, or the amount of product inside is visible to the consumer;
- the presence of any headspace within a product container necessary to facilitate mixing, adding, shaking, or dispensing by the consumer prior to use;
- the exterior packaging contains a product delivery or dosing device;
- the packaging or product container is a kit that consists of multiple components if the purpose of the kit is clearly and conspicuously disclosed on the exterior packaging; and
- the packaging of the product is routinely displayed using tester units or demonstrations to consumers in retail stores, so that customers can see the container of the product being sold or the actual size of the product. (See Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 12606(b)(1)-(15).)
Those exemptions, notably do not apply in the context of food containers. Under the FPLA, any food containers subject to the federal FDC Act, must meet slightly different requirements for food containers in order to keep state law in line with federal law. Under that specific section of law, California law prohibits misleading food containers generally, treats food containers that do not permit full visibility of the product as misleading if they contain nonfunctional slack fill, and provides for six exemptions from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill. These six exemptions generally recognize safe harbors for:
- protection of the contents of the package;
- the requirements of machines used for enclosing the package;
- unavoidable product settling during shipping and handling;
- the need for the package to perform a specific function in the preparation or consumption of food;
- the fact that the product consists of a food packaged in a reusable container where the container is part of the presentation of the food and has value that is significant, as specified; and
- where minimum package size is necessary to accommodate required labeling, discourage pilfering, facilitate handling, or accommodate tamper-resistant devices. (See Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 12606(c)(1)-(6).)
This bill would add three new safe harbors which would exempt the following types of packaging from the definition of nonfunctional slack fill: (1) where the packaging states the number of product items contained in the packaging, and contains a full-scale depiction of a representative item, as specified; (2) where the exterior packaging indicates the amount of product in the container by means of a line or silhouette that represents the actual product or level of product, and is accompanied by the term “fill line,” as specified; and (3) if the mode of commerce does not involve consumer interaction with the container before purchase.
- Bill would arguably be federally preempted in part: While California law provides for various safe harbors for lawful nonfunctional slack fill, California law also states that its state provisions regarding food containers are operative only to the extent they are identical to specified federal requirements. As discussed above, this bill would now add three new exemptions. Notably, however, this bill would also seek to exempt the proposed three new safe harbors from this provision of law which ensures that the food container (FDC Act) related safe harbors only have effect to the extent that they are consistent with and identical to specified federal requirements, thus, raising questions regarding potential future preemption issues. In other words, the bill exempts these safe harbors from an existing federal preemption provision, which arguably could create a conflict if federal law later directly contradicts state law. It should also be noted that federal law currently only recognizes six exemptions for food containers, and adding additional safe harbors puts California in a position of having weaker consumer protection standards than federal law. (See 21 C.F.R. Sec. 100.100.)
The California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association, in opposition, notes that “the measure differs substantially from Federal law, which allows for only six ‘slack fill’ exemptions for food products. This measure exempts the three newly slack fill ‘safe harbors from the federal preemption language in 12606.2(f), but, as regulators, CACASA urges against weakening California’s consumer protection laws below the federal standard.” To this point, staff notes that, as a matter of public policy, California ordinarily strives for stronger consumer protection standards than that of the federal government.
As stated by the County of Riverside District Attorneys in opposition, “[t]he proposed additional language does not, and cannot, change the fact that the statute’s newly proposed provisions would be preempted. Congress has expressly made clear that no state can promulgate laws that exceed the federal requirements in this area.”
To address these concerns, the author has accepted the following amendment to remove the language creating an exception for these three new safe harbors from the state’s federal preemption provision.
Author’s amendment:
On page 6, on lines 28 and 29 strike “With the exception of paragraphs (7), (8), and (9) of
subdivision (c)”
Even with the amendment above, there is a question as to whether the new safe harbors proposed under this bill for food containers as regulated by the FDC Act would in fact be preempted under federal law. That being said, by striking the FDC Act’s exemption from federal law under this bill, the amendment would ensure that this bill does not erroneously state that California law would ever supersede federal law if a direct conflict arose.
- Additional safe harbors may not reduce litigation as intended by the sponsors of this bill: A coalition of consumer product and food manufacturing companies and employers, including the Grocery Manufacturers Association (sponsor), the California Chamber of Commerce, California Retailers Association, and the Civil Justice Association of California, among others, writes in support of this bill:
AB 2632 proposes to clearly articulate circumstances wherein nonfunctional slack fill would be deemed permissible, and in doing so, adds clarity to product manufacturers and consumers. These exemptions would apply equally to food and non-food commodities.
[…]
Due to increasing consumer product and safety protocols over the past several years, there are many products such as over the counter drugs, grooming products or alcoholic beverages that are available in the store but do not permit the consumer to have direct access until purchase. In addition, e-commerce has also increased steadily over the past several years. In both cases, items have visual and written descriptions as required by law. However, the consumer does not have access to the packaged product until after purchase. In the case of in store purchases, consumers sometimes take a purchase slip or have a clerk carry the product to checkout before purchase. In the case of e-commerce, descriptions, pictures, dimensions and consumer comments provide a narrative description until the product arrives at their homes. In both cases, consumers have made the purchase decision and manufacturers may need the same clarity for shipping containers or packaging.
Like SB 465 in 2013, AB 2632 would again update the slack fill statutes with common sense opportunities to convey information to the consumer and reduce unnecessary enforcement actions by adding additional clarity to the slack fill requirements
Indeed, the author and sponsor point to a fair amount of litigation that has been brought under existing slack fill laws. The author summarizes some of these settlements and much of the case law below:
Despite clarifications in 2013 with SB 465 [SB 465 (Correa, Chapter 429, Statutes of 2013) which clarified that nonfunctional slack fill must be substantially less than the allowed capacity, and clarified an existing exemption related to the clear and conspicuous depiction of the actual size of a product], class action suits and regulatory actions based on slack-fill allegations have continue. Although some of these settlements are small, others are significant. See, e.g., People of the State of California v. Tropicana Products, Inc., Case No. 30-2017-00904499-CU-BT-CJC (Cal. Super. Orange County 2017) (settlement of $765,060 for slack fill and labeling case); People of the State of California v. General Mills Inc., Case No. cv-16-2178 (Cal. Super. Yolo County (filed Dec. 30, 2016) (settlement of $375,000 in slack fill case for food products); People v. Procter & Gamble, No. CV15-0868 (Cal. Super. Yolo County Jun. 23, 2015) (settlement for $850,000 for slack fill of various products).
At the same time, however, the Ninth Circuit and other courts across the country have begun to reject slack fill allegations on the basis that, where packaging clearly communicates the amount of product in the container, no reasonable consumer would be deceived. For example, in Ebner v. Fresh, Inc., 2016 WL 5389307 (9th Cir. Sept. 27, 2016) the Plaintiff alleged that the packaging of defendant’s lip balm product was deceptive because it used a weighted bottom, came in oversized packaging, and used a mechanism that allowed only 75% of the product to proceed up the tube. The Ninth Circuit rejected this allegation because “an accurate net weight label is affixed to every tube” and because a reasonable consumer might expect some extra weight at the bottom to keep the tube upright. Id. [at] 6. It also found that the packaging was “commonplace” and that therefore, no reasonable consumer expects the weight or the size of the package to reflect directly the quantity of product contained therein.” Id.
Other decisions have followed suit. See, e.g., Fermin v. Pfizer Inc., 2016 WL 6208291, at [at] 2 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 18, 2016) (dismissing case where “Plaintiffs seek to be protected under packaging laws but to dispense with reading the package”); Bush v. Mondelēz Int’l, Inc., 2016 WL 5886886, at [at] 3 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 7, 2016) (dismissing claims where “it is undisputed that the [Products] disclose the net weight of included product, as well as the number of cookies or crackers per container); Bautista v. CytoSport, Inc., 2016 WL 7192109, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 12, 2016) (dismissing case because “wholly conclusory allegations are insufficient to state a nonfunctional slack fill claim”); Hawkins v. UGI Corp., 2016 WL 2595990, at *3 (C.D. Cal. May 4, 2016) (dismissing case in part because “Defendants’ cylinders accurately state, as they must, the net weight of the propane contained therein”).
These decisions, particularly in light of the continued proliferation of class suits and regulatory actions regarding slack fill, support legislative action that would expand the safe harbors in the applicable California laws to encompass several commonly employed methods for communicating the amount of product contained in a package. These additional safe harbors will reduce uncertainty for businesses and promote greater information for consumers.
Staff notes, that the cases referenced by the author and sponsor above were dismissed because plaintiffs could not prove that the products were misleading, and that with the exception of Fermin v. Pfizer (in which the plaintiff’s alleged that they were tricked into buying Advil due to the size of Advil’s packaging, despite a clear indication on the bottle of the number of pills contained therein), the proposed safe harbors under this bill are not applicable to any of the cases cited above. Accordingly, it is difficult to evaluate whether these proposed safe harbors would indeed have the intended effect of reducing litigation. In addition, all of the safe harbors under existing law function to some extent to explain why the slack fill exists in the first place. For example, slack fill may be permitted because a product settled or because a box needed to be bigger to fit the text required for labeling purposes under other laws. Arguably, the safe harbors proposed under this bill instead rely on the fact that information is being conveyed to the consumer, regardless of the size of the packaging. On the other hand, if the consumer has all the information on the box about what is inside the box, then there is a question as to whether they have been truly misled simply because of the size of the outer box.
- Other arguments in opposition: The CACASA writes in opposition to the bill, that the “concept of defining acceptable and legal applications for ‘non-functional slack fill’ has been a difficult task that has divided regulators and industry for many years. CACASA has taken the consistent position that any ‘safe harbor’ to allow for ‘non-functional slack fill’ only serves to mislead consumers. For example, the presence of a photo or silhouette on the exterior of the package depicting the ‘actual size’ of the product should not give free reign to package the product in an oversized box and deem the unused space within the package ‘legal non-functional slack fill’. County sealers would argue that the only benefit of a larger box in this case is to entice a consumer to buy one product over another.”
- Prior legislation: SB 465 (Correa, Ch. 429, Stats. 2013) revised the definition for “nonfunctional slack fill” prohibited in packaged goods to require that nonfunctional slack fill be substantially less than the allowed capacity, and clarified a particular exemption to require the actual size of the product be clearly and conspicuously depicted on any side of the exterior packaging, except the bottom.
AB 1394 (Figueroa, Ch. 711, Stats. 1997) revised the Fair Packaging and Labeling Act to expand the existing exceptions for slack fill in non-food commodities packaging from two exemptions to fifteen (based in large part on the “Slack Fill Enforcement Guidelines” agreed to in 1988 by the Attorney General, the Department of Food and Agriculture and the California Association of Weights and Measures Officials). AB 1394 aimed to reduce frivolous lawsuits against manufacturers and retailers while maintaining reasonable advertising protections for consumers.
AB 1295 (Caldera, 1997) proposed major changes to the Unfair Practices Act to restrict the ability of private plaintiffs to bring lawsuits alleging unfair competition or false advertising and seeking monetary recovery for a number of product manufacturers, including software manufacturers who package computer software in containers larger than necessary to hold the disk. AB 1295 failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SB 735 (Marks, Ch. 849, Stats. of 1995) prohibited food containers from being made, formed or filled as to be misleading, defined the term “nonfunctional slack fill” as the empty space in a package filled to less than capacity for reasons other than those six specified, and provided that these provisions be interpreted as consistent with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s comments in the Code of Federal Regulations, as specified, and thus adopts by reference provisions of the federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. SB 735 was jointly sponsored by the Los Angeles and Venture County District Attorneys to conform California law to federal law.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Grocery Manufacturers Association (sponsor)
Agricultural Council of California
American Cleaning Institute
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Council for Responsible Nutrition
Household and Commercial Products Association
National Confectioners Association
Opposition
California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association
County of Riverside District Attorneys
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):