AB 2778: Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights Act: discipline.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-04-26
The Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights Act prohibits any punitive action against a public safety officer, denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, or threat of such treatment, because of the lawful exercise of the rights granted under the act, or the exercise of any rights under any existing administrative grievance procedure. The act further prohibits punitive action, or denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, against any public safety officer who has successfully completed the applicably applicable probationary period without providing an opportunity for administrative appeal.
This bill would amend the act to also prohibit any punitive action, or denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, against any public safety officer without the public agency first taking into consideration education-based alternatives to that action. specify that a public agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive action against a public safety officer when appropriate.
To the extent that this new requirement would apply to local government employers, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.The Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights Act prohibits any punitive action against a public safety officer, denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, or threat of such treatment, because of the lawful exercise of the rights granted under the act, or the exercise of any rights under any existing administrative grievance procedure. The act further prohibits punitive action, or denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, against any public safety officer who has successfully completed the applicably probationary period without providing an opportunity for administrative appeal.
This bill would amend the act to also prohibit any punitive action, or denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, against any public safety officer without the public agency first taking into consideration education-based alternatives to that action.
To the extent that this new requirement would apply to local government employers, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)No public safety officer shall be subjected to punitive action, or denied promotion, or be threatened with any such treatment, because of the lawful exercise of the rights granted under this chapter, or the exercise of any rights under any existing administrative grievance procedure.
Nothing in this section shall preclude a head of an agency from ordering a public safety officer to cooperate with other agencies involved in criminal investigations. If an officer fails to comply with such an order, the agency may officially charge him or her with insubordination.
(b)No punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken by any public agency against any public safety officer who has successfully completed the probationary period that may be required by his or her employing agency without providing the public safety officer with an opportunity for administrative appeal.
(c)No punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken by any public agency against any public safety officer without the public agency first taking into consideration education-based alternatives to that action.(c)A public agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive action against a public safety officer when appropriate.
(d)No chief of police may be removed by a public agency, or appointing authority, without providing the chief of police with written notice and the reason or reasons therefor and an opportunity for administrative appeal.
For purposes of this subdivision, the removal of a chief of police by a public agency or appointing authority, for the purpose of implementing the goals or policies, or both, of the public agency or appointing authority, for reasons including, but not limited to, incompatibility of management styles or as a result of a change in administration, shall be sufficient to constitute reason or reasons.
Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to create a property interest, where one does not exist by rule or law, in the job of Chief of Police.
(e)(1)Except as provided in this subdivision and subdivision (h), no punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken for any act, omission, or other allegation of misconduct if the investigation of the allegation is not completed within one year of the public agencys discovery by a person authorized to initiate an investigation of the allegation of an act, omission, or other misconduct. This one-year limitation period shall apply only if the act, omission, or other misconduct occurred on or after January 1, 1998. In the event that the public agency determines that discipline may be taken, it shall complete its investigation and notify the public safety officer of its proposed discipline by a Letter of Intent or Notice of Adverse Action articulating the discipline that year, except as provided in paragraph (2). The public agency shall not be required to impose the discipline within that one-year period.
(2)(A)If the act, omission, or other allegation of misconduct is also the subject of a criminal investigation or criminal prosecution, the time during which the criminal investigation or criminal prosecution is pending shall toll the one-year time period.
(B)If the public safety officer waives the one-year time period in writing, the time period shall be tolled for the period of time specified in the written waiver.
(C)If the investigation is a multijurisdictional investigation that requires a reasonable extension for coordination of the involved agencies.
(D)If the investigation involves more than one employee and requires a reasonable extension.
(E)If the investigation involves an employee who is incapacitated or otherwise unavailable.
(F)If the investigation involves a matter in civil litigation where the public safety officer is named as a party defendant, the one-year time period shall be tolled while that civil action is pending.
(G)If the investigation involves a matter in criminal litigation where the complainant is a criminal defendant, the one-year time period shall be tolled during the period of that defendants criminal investigation and prosecution.
(H)If the investigation involves an allegation of workers compensation fraud on the part of the public safety officer.
(f)Where a predisciplinary response or grievance procedure is required or utilized, the time for this response or procedure shall not be governed or limited by this chapter.
(g)If, after investigation and any predisciplinary response or procedure, the public agency decides to impose discipline, the public agency shall notify the public safety officer in writing of its decision to impose discipline, including the date that the discipline will be imposed, within 30 days of its decision, except if the public safety officer is unavailable for discipline.
(h)Notwithstanding the one-year time period specified in subdivision (e), an investigation may be reopened against a public safety officer if both of the following circumstances exist:
(1)Significant new evidence has been discovered that is likely to affect the outcome of the investigation.
(2)One of the following conditions exist:
(A)The evidence could not reasonably have been discovered in the normal course of investigation without resorting to extraordinary measures by the agency.
(B)The evidence resulted from the public safety officers predisciplinary response or procedure.
(i)For those members listed in subdivision (a) of Section 830.2 of the Penal Code, the 30-day time period provided for in subdivision (g) shall not commence with the service of a preliminary notice of adverse action, should the public agency elect to provide the public safety officer with such a notice.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.(a)No public safety officer shall be subjected to punitive action, or denied promotion, or be threatened with any such treatment, because of the lawful exercise of the rights granted under this chapter, or the exercise of any rights under any existing administrative grievance procedure.
Nothing in this section shall preclude a head of an agency from ordering a public safety officer to cooperate with other agencies involved in criminal investigations. If an officer fails to comply with such an order, the agency may officially charge him or her with insubordination.
(b)No punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken by any public agency against any public safety officer who has successfully completed the probationary period that may be required by his or her employing agency without providing the public safety officer with an opportunity for administrative appeal.
(c)No punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken by any public agency against any public safety officer without the public agency first taking into consideration education-based alternatives to that action.
(c)(d)No chief of police may be removed by a public agency, or appointing authority, without providing the chief of police with written notice and the reason or reasons therefor and an opportunity for administrative appeal.
For purposes of this subdivision, the removal of a chief of police by a public agency or appointing authority, for the purpose of implementing the goals or policies, or both, of the public agency or appointing authority, for reasons including, but not limited to, incompatibility of management styles or as a result of a change in administration, shall be sufficient to constitute reason or reasons.
Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to create a property interest, where one does not exist by rule or law, in the job of Chief of Police.
(d)(e)(1)Except as provided in this subdivision and subdivision (g), (h), no punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other than merit, shall be undertaken for any act, omission, or other allegation of misconduct if the investigation of the allegation is not completed within one year of the public agencys discovery by a person authorized to initiate an investigation of the allegation of an act, omission, or other misconduct. This one-year limitation period shall apply only if the act, omission, or other misconduct occurred on or after January 1, 1998. In the event that the public agency determines that discipline may be taken, it shall complete its investigation and notify the public safety officer of its proposed discipline by a Letter of Intent or Notice of Adverse Action articulating the discipline that year, except as provided in paragraph (2). The public agency shall not be required to impose the discipline within that one-year period.
(2)(A)If the act, omission, or other allegation of misconduct is also the subject of a criminal investigation or criminal prosecution, the time during which the criminal investigation or criminal prosecution is pending shall toll the one-year time period.
(B)If the public safety officer waives the one-year time period in writing, the time period shall be tolled for the period of time specified in the written waiver.
(C)If the investigation is a multijurisdictional investigation that requires a reasonable extension for coordination of the involved agencies.
(D)If the investigation involves more than one employee and requires a reasonable extension.
(E)If the investigation involves an employee who is incapacitated or otherwise unavailable.
(F)If the investigation involves a matter in civil litigation where the public safety officer is named as a party defendant, the one-year time period shall be tolled while that civil action is pending.
(G)If the investigation involves a matter in criminal litigation where the complainant is a criminal defendant, the one-year time period shall be tolled during the period of that defendants criminal investigation and prosecution.
(H)If the investigation involves an allegation of workers compensation fraud on the part of the public safety officer.
(e)(f)Where a predisciplinary response or grievance procedure is required or utilized, the time for this response or procedure shall not be governed or limited by this chapter.
(f)(g)If, after investigation and any predisciplinary response or procedure, the public agency decides to impose discipline, the public agency shall notify the public safety officer in writing of its decision to impose discipline, including the date that the discipline will be imposed, within 30 days of its decision, except if the public safety officer is unavailable for discipline.
(g)(h)Notwithstanding the one-year time period specified in subdivision (d), (e), an investigation may be reopened against a public safety officer if both of the following circumstances exist:
(1)Significant new evidence has been discovered that is likely to affect the outcome of the investigation.
(2)One of the following conditions exist:
(A)The evidence could not reasonably have been discovered in the normal course of investigation without resorting to extraordinary measures by the agency.
(B)The evidence resulted from the public safety officers predisciplinary response or procedure.
(h)(i)For those members listed in subdivision (a) of Section 830.2 of the Penal Code, the 30-day time period provided for in subdivision (f) (g) shall not commence with the service of a preliminary notice of adverse action, should the public agency elect to provide the public safety officer with such a notice.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 25, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 9, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 24). |
| Apr 10, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 3, 2018 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 20, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 8, 2018 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 9, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2778
Author:(Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 26, 2018
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 4 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill amends the Peace Officer Bill of Rights, to specify that a law enforcement agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive disciplinary action against a law enforcement officer when appropriate.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown, likely significant costs in the millions of dollars, for state entities with peace officers, such as the California Highway Patrol, California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), Department of Parks and Recreation, and others to develop education-based alternatives. In addition, CDCR anticipates a possible increase in arbitration resulting from the dispute resolution process with each case taken to arbitration costing $50,000.
- Unknown, significant reimbursable state-mandated costs, likely in the millions of dollars, to implement education-based alternatives to punitive disciplinary action against a law enforcement officer. For example, if 100 law enforcement agencies made claims for $50,000 in state-mandated costs, the total will be $5 million. Costs could actually be much higher because the state has roughly 800 law enforcement agencies and the costs of establishing and implementing alternative disciplinary programs could be substantial. While this bill is not keyed as a state mandate, it is possible that the Commission on State Mandates will determine this to be a reimbursable mandate because the bill states that law enforcement agencies should consider education-based alternatives.
COMMENTS:
Background and purpose. Sheriff Lee Baca has instituted an education-based discipline process at the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department. Education-based discipline provides an option for employees to voluntarily participate in an individualized remedial plan that emphasizes education, training, and other creative interventions, which promote a successful outcome. According to the author:
AB 2778 will ensure that law enforcement agencies consider education-based alternatives in the disciplinary process, where appropriate. Education should be one possible course of action but it does not have to be the first choice, or only choice. AB 2778 maintains flexibility for agencies to complete the disciplinary process as appropriate, but ensures we keep the goal of education for law enforcement prominent in ongoing discussions on how best to keep the public safe.
Analysis Prepared by: Jessica Peters / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2778
Author:(Carrillo) – As Introduced Ver:February 16, 2018
As Proposed to be Amended in Committee
SUMMARY: Amends the Peace Officer Bill of Rights (POBOR), to specify that a law enforcement agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive disciplinary action against a law enforcement officer when appropriate.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “public safety officer” as all peace officers, except as specified. (Gov. Code, §
3301.) - Finds and declares that effective law enforcement depends upon the maintenance of stable employer-employee relations between public safety employees and their employers. (Gov. Code, § 3301.)
- Provides that when any public safety officer is under investigation and subjected to interrogation by his or her commanding officer, or any other member of the employing public safety department, that could lead to punitive action, the interrogation shall be conducted under the specified conditions. (Government Code, § 3303.)
- States that, for purposes of the POBOR, "punitive action" means any action which may lead to dismissal, demotion, suspension, reduction in salary, written reprimand, or transfer for purposes of punishment. (Government Code, § 3303.)
- Specifies that when any public safety officer is under investigation and subjected to interrogation by his or her commanding officer, or any other member of the employing public safety department, that could lead to punitive action, the interrogation shall be conducted under the following conditions:
- The interrogation shall be conducted at a reasonable hour, preferably at a time when the public safety officer is on duty, or during the normal waking hours for the public safety officer, unless the seriousness of the investigation requires otherwise; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (a).)
- The public safety officer under investigation shall be informed prior to the interrogation of the rank, name, and command of the officer in charge of the interrogation, the interrogating officers, and all other persons to be present during the interrogation; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (b).)
- The public safety officer under investigation shall be informed of the nature of the investigation prior to any interrogation; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (c).)
- The interrogating session shall be for a reasonable period taking into consideration gravity and complexity of the issue being investigated. The person under interrogation shall be allowed to attend to his or her own personal physical necessities; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (d).)
- The public safety officer under interrogation shall not be subjected to offensive language or threatened with punitive action, except that an officer refusing to respond to questions or submit to interrogations shall be informed that failure to answer questions directly related to the investigation or interrogation may result in punitive action; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (e).)
- The employer shall not cause the public safety officer under interrogation to be subjected to visits by the press or news media without his or her express consent nor shall his or her home address or photograph be given to the press or news media without his or her express consent; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (e).)
- No statement made during interrogation by a public safety officer under duress, coercion, or threat of punitive action shall be admissible in any subsequent civil proceeding, subject to certain qualifications; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (f).)
- The complete interrogation of a public safety officer may be recorded. If a tape recording is made of the interrogation, the public safety officer shall have access to the tape if any further proceedings are contemplated or prior to any further interrogation at a subsequent time. No notes or reports that are deemed to be confidential may be entered in the officer's personnel file; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (g).)
- If prior to or during the interrogation of a public safety officer it is deemed that he or she may be charged with a criminal offense, he or she shall be immediately informed of his or her constitutional rights; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (h).)
- Upon the filing of a formal written statement of charges, or whenever an interrogation focuses on matters that are likely to result in punitive action against any public safety officer, that officer, at his or her request, shall have the right to be represented by a representative of his or her choice who may be present at all times during the interrogation; and, (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (i).)
- The representative shall not be a person subject to the same investigation. The representative shall not be required to disclose, nor be subject to any punitive action for refusing to disclose, any information received from the officer under investigation for noncriminal matters. (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (i).)
- The interrogation shall be conducted at a reasonable hour, preferably at a time when the public safety officer is on duty, or during the normal waking hours for the public safety officer, unless the seriousness of the investigation requires otherwise; (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (a).)
- States that the restrictions on interrogation shall not apply to any interrogation of a public safety officer in the normal course of duty, counseling, instruction, or informal verbal admonishment by, or other routine or unplanned contact with, a supervisor or any other public safety officer, nor shall this section apply to an investigation concerned solely and directly with alleged criminal activities. (Government Code, § 3303, subd. (i).)
- Specifies that no public safety officer shall be subjected to punitive action, or denied promotion, or be threatened with any such treatment, because of the lawful exercise of the rights under the Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights, or the exercise of any rights under any existing administrative grievance procedure. (Gov. Code, § 3304.)
- States that administrative appeal by a public safety officer Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights shall be conducted in conformance with rules and procedures adopted by the local public agency. (Gov. Code, § 3304.5.)
- No public employee shall be subject to punitive action or denied promotion, or threatened with any such treatment, for the exercise of lawful action as an elected, appointed, or recognized representative of any employee bargaining unit. (Gov. Code, § 3502.1.)
- Public agencies and employee organizations shall not interfere with, intimidate, restrain, coerce or discriminate against public employees because of their exercise of their rights to join unions. (Gov. Code, § 3506.)
- A public agency shall not do any of the following: (Gov. Code, § 3506.5.)
- Impose or threaten to impose reprisals on employees, to discriminate or threaten to discriminate against employees, or otherwise to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees because of their exercise of rights guaranteed by this chapter;
- Deny to employee organizations the rights guaranteed to them by this chapter;
- Refuse or fail to meet and negotiate in good faith with a recognized employee organization;
- Dominate or interfere with the formation or administration of any employee organization, contribute financial or other support to any employee organization, or in any way encourage employees to join any organization in preference to another; and
- Refuse to participate in good faith in an applicable impasse procedure.
- Impose or threaten to impose reprisals on employees, to discriminate or threaten to discriminate against employees, or otherwise to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees because of their exercise of rights guaranteed by this chapter;
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "The disciplinary process to address accusations of police misconduct often leaves police departments, employees, and the community dissatisfied with the end result. Law enforcement agencies can find the process lengthy, with employees left without options, and the community without any reassurances the officers will be better prepared when they return to duty. The process is primarily punishment-oriented and leaves little room for our law enforcement officers to learn from their mistakes.
“AB 2778 will ensure that law enforcement agencies consider education-based alternatives in the disciplinary process, where appropriate. Education should be one possible course of action but it does not have to be the first choice, or only choice. AB 2778 maintains flexibility for agencies to complete the disciplinary process as appropriate, but ensures we keep the goal of education for law enforcement prominent in ongoing discussions on how best to keep the public safe.” - Recent Cases Involving Death as a Result of Police Actions: Philando Castille, Freddie Gray, Tamir Rice, Michael Brown, and Eric Garner are among the individuals that were killed during encounters with police officers in recent years. Those deaths have raised national concern about the accountability of officers who have engaged in misconduct and the transparency of investigations into such misconduct. The March 18, 2018, shooting of Stephon Clark, an unarmed black male, by Sacramento police officers has sparked demonstrations and protests concerning police accountability.
This bill would specify that a public agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive action against a public safety officer when appropriate. The goal of the of this bill is to ensure that the disciplinary process involving police officers that have made mistakes includes consideration of options to allow the officer to learn from their mistakes. There is concern that requiring law enforcement agencies to consider education-based alternatives in every case involving police misconduct will limit the flexibility of agencies in how they approach the disciplinary process in different types of cases. The language of this bill is intended to encourage the use of education based discipline, but not put in place any mandatory requirements regarding the use of education based discipline. - Public Safety Officers Bill of Rights (POBOR): POBOR provides peace officers with procedural protections relating to investigation and interrogations of peace officers, self-incrimination, privacy, polygraph exams, searches, personnel files, and administrative appeals. When the Legislature enacted POBOR in 1976 it found and declared “that the rights and protections provided to peace officers under this chapter constitute a matter of statewide concern.” While the purpose of POBOR is to maintain stable employer-employee relations and thereby assure effective law enforcement, it also seeks to balance the competing interests of fair treatment to officers with the need for swift internal investigations to maintain public confidence in law enforcement agencies. (Pasadena Police Officers Assn. v. City of Pasadena (1990) 51 Cal.3d 564.) The language of this bill will be included within POBOR.
- The Education-Based Discipline Process (EBD): Sheriff Lee Baca has instituted education based discipline process at the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department. EBD provides an option for employees to voluntarily participate in an individualized remedial plan that emphasizes education, training, and other creative interventions which promote a successful outcome. (http://shq.lasdnews.net/shq/ebd/assets/a-new-era-for%20the-discipline-process.pdf)
EBD is offered to an employee who is facing a one to thirty day suspension. This alternative discipline cannot be utilized for demotions, discharges, or for Policy of Equality violations.
The decision to participate in Education-Based Discipline rests solely with the employee who may opt not to participate in the EBD process. The employee retains all grievance rights including the right to accept a suspension.
EBD will be offered as an alternative to an unpaid suspension to employees facing a suspension. If an employee agrees to participate in EBD, the employee will agree to any combination of the following: attend classes, attend training, conduct briefings, author a research paper, or participate in an activity addressing the behavior that resulted in the discipline. In each case where an employee agrees to participate, all EBD related activities will be conducted while on-duty.
EBD can be offered at several junctures during an investigation, including as part of a predisposition settlement agreement, or it can be offered when the employee receives their Letter of Intent to Discipline. If instead an employee files a grievance, EBD may be offered at the conclusion of the grievance process at the discretion of the unit commander. EBD is an alternative to unpaid suspension days. An employee receiving a suspension does not have to participate in EBD. An employee is welcome to consult with their union representative regarding the EBD proposal. All employee rights regarding the discipline process remain intact.
It is notable that the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department does not offer EBD as an alternative to discipline for violations of the following policies: unreasonable force; failure to report force; false statements; and failure to make statements and/or making false statements during a Department internal investigation; and, specific violations of the Policy of Equality sections. (Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Guidelines for Discipline Handbook (Revised 01-01-2017).)
- Other Disciplinary Tools: EBD has been effective in the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, but there are other disciplinary alternative or schemes which can also be effective.
Discipline Matrixes. Some police agencies have developed matrices that spell out the options for sanctions when there is a sustained violation of the rules of conduct or other policies. These agencies believe that in addition to letting employees know in advance, a matrix will help make the sanctions applied both fair and consistent. (https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/234052.pdf)
Peer Review: Officers could elect to participate in peer review rather than the formal disciplinary process if they were facing charges or exceeded the thresholds. The peer review panel considered the circumstances and suggested behavior changes they believed would help minimize further complaints.
Mediations: Although not widely used, some police agencies have turned to mediation between officers and citizens as a way of resolving complaints. A national survey identified 16 police departments with mediation programs.
Early Intervention: Early intervention systems are designed to track various indicators and provide early identification of officers whose performance indicates emerging problems and then intervene in a useful way. (Id.)
- Amendments Proposed to be Taken in Committee: The proposed amendments specify that a law enforcement agency should consider education-based alternatives to punitive disciplinary action against a law enforcement officer when appropriate.
- Argument in Support: According to the State Coalition of Probation Organizations, “If enacted, the Law Enforcement Education Act will encourage a productive end result to the disciplinary process. AB 2778 requires public agencies to consider education-based alternatives before making final decisions on matters relating to public safety officer discipline.
“The disciplinary process to address probation officer alleged misconduct often leaves the department, employees and community dissatisfied with the end result. The current process is too often punitive, rather than restorative or education. AB 2778 seeks to encourage educational-based alternatives, like training and counseling, when appropriate to seek behavioral improvement.
“Punishment for punishment’s sake is a disservice to our officers and our community. Law enforcement should be held to the highest professional standards but high performance standards should come with effective and continuous training. Training should be an alternative for addressing honest mistakes and discipline should be carried out with a view towards improved outcomes and changed behavior.” - Argument in Opposition: According to the California Police Chiefs Association, “As police chiefs, we feel that we are more than capable to disciplining our officers as we see fit without having to follow additional mandates from the State Legislature. Furthermore, smaller departments may not have access to sufficient education-based alternatives for all the various potential policy and statutory violations we encounter. Would we then have to develop educational programs for every instance? There is also no standard for what adequate “consideration” by the agency would look like, which opens this statute up to legal challenges. There are also infractions or violations that warrant immediate reprimand but all cases under AB 2778, regardless of severity or context, would merit consideration for alternatives to punitive action.
“Lastly, while certain departments may already have similar policies as those contained in AB 2778 in place, that was then a local decision that should not be replicated across the various state agencies, many of which have disparate resources and needs.”
- Related Legislation: AB 2327 (Quirk), would require a peace officer seeking employment with a law enforcement agency to give written permission for the hiring law enforcement agency to view his or her general personnel file and any separate disciplinary file. AB 2327 is set pending a vote on the Assembly floor.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 887 (Cooper), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have defined the information that must be provided to a peace officer prior to questioning in an administrative disciplinary proceeding. AB 887 was ordered to the Senate inactive file.
- AB 1298 (Santiago), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required proof based on clear and convincing evidence when any peace officer is under investigation and subject to administrative discipline, on the allegation of making a false statement. AB 1298 was never heard in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1428 (Low), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required district attorneys to report the findings from investigations into incidents involving the shooting of a civilian by a peace officer on the internet. AB 1428 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
- SB 388 (Lieu), of the 2013-2014 Legislative Session, would have provided that if an interrogation focuses on matters that may result in punitive action against a public safety officer who is not formally under investigation, but is interviewed regarding the investigation of another public safety officer, the public safety officer being interviewed is entitled to representation, as specified. SB 388 was vetoed by the Governor.
- AB 729 (Hernández), of the 2013-2014 Legislative Session, would have provided that a union agent and a represented employee or represented former employee have a privilege to refuse to disclose any confidential communication between the employee or former employee and the union agent while the union agent was acting in his or her representative capacity, except as specified. AB 729 was vetoed by the Governor.
- SB 313 (De León), Chapter 779, Statutes of 2013, prohibits any public agency from taking any punitive action against a public safety officer, or denying a promotion on grounds other than merit, because that officer is placed on a "Brady list," as specified.
- AB 955 (De León), Chapter 494, Statutes of 2009, Specified that discipline need not be imposed upon peace officers within the one-year time limit placed upon the investigation and imposition of penalty by the Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights (POBOR).
- AB 887 (Cooper), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have defined the information that must be provided to a peace officer prior to questioning in an administrative disciplinary proceeding. AB 887 was ordered to the Senate inactive file.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
State Coalition of Probation Organizations (Sponsor)
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Fraternal Order of Police, N. California Probation, Lodge 19
Los Angeles County Deputy Probations Officers Union, AFSCME Local 685
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
Sacramento County Probation Association
Ventura County Professional Peace Officers’ Association
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California State Sheriffs’ Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Public Defenders Association
Rural County Representatives of California
Analysis Prepared by:
David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):