AB 1682: Settlement agreements: sexual offenses.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-30
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would instead prohibit a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense and would additionally make these provisions applicable to a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified. The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would provide that an attorneys failure to comply with these provisions by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as specified, as a condition of settlement or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision may be grounds for professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would instead prohibit a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense and would additionally make these provisions applicable to a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified. The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would provide that an attorneys failure to comply with these provisions by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as specified, as a condition of settlement or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision may be grounds for professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would additionally instead prohibit a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense and would additionally make these provisions applicable to a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified. The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement, agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would provide that an attorneys failure to comply with these provisions by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as specified, as a condition of settlement or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision may be grounds for professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would additionally prohibit a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified. The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts access to information obtained through discovery, as prescribed. disclosure of this information, as specified. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would provide that an attorney who demands such a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with such a confidentiality or secrecy provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude that is subject to attorneys failure to comply with these provisions may be grounds for professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would additionally prohibit a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor, minor or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified. The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts access to information obtained through discovery, as prescribed. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would make provide that an attorney who demands such a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with such a confidentiality or secrecy provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude that is subject to professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would additionally prohibit a confidential confidentiality provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined. specified. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a confidential confidentiality provision in a settlement agreement, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would make an attorney who demands such a confidential confidentiality provision in a settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign such an agreement with such a confidentiality provision subject to professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. Existing law provides that the prohibition does not affect the ability of parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement requiring nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would additionally prohibit a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for an act of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined. The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited. The bill would make a confidential settlement agreement, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would make an attorney who demands such a confidential settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign such an agreement subject to professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c) as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Sections Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
(1)Restricts the disclosure of information obtained through discovery.
(2)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information obtained through discovery.
(3)Restricts access to court records regarding information obtained through discovery.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney who demands a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a), that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (c), as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with such a confidentiality or secrecy provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude, as set forth in Section 6106 of the Business and Professions Code and shall be subject to professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(e)An attorneys failure to comply with the requirements of this section may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Sections 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(4)An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.7 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that does any of the following:
(1)Restricts the disclosure of information obtained through discovery.
(2)Approves a settlement agreement that would restrict the disclosure of information obtained through discovery.
(3)Restricts access to court records regarding information obtained through discovery.
(b)Subdivision (a) does
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) do not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(c)
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (b), (c), a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney who demands a confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a), that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (b), (c), as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with such a confidentiality or secrecy provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude, as set forth in Section 6106 of the Business and Professions Code and shall be subject to professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a confidential confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code. Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Sections 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
(b)Subdivision (a) does not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(c)An Except as authorized by subdivision (b), a confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney who demands a confidential confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement described in subdivision (a), that is not otherwise authorized by subdivision (b), as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign such an agreement with such a confidentiality provision shall be subject to professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a confidential settlement agreement is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. any of the following:
(1)An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.
(2)An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1.
(3)An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code.
(b)Subdivision (a) does not preclude an agreement preventing the defendant or any person acting on his or her behalf from disclosing disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 530.5 530.55 of the Penal Code, regarding the victim of the felony sex offense listed in subdivision (a) or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information.
(c)Subdivision (a) does not apply to or affect the ability of the parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires the nondisclosure of the amount of any money paid in a settlement of a claim.
(c)An agreement described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney who demands a confidential settlement agreement described in subdivision (a) as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign such an agreement shall be subject to professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 6108.). |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 5016.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 18 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 10, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 9, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 8, 2016 | From committee: Be placed on second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| May 4, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 28, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 14, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 4360.) |
| Apr 14, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0.) |
| Apr 14, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 14, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 6, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (April 6). |
| Mar 8, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (March 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 1, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 29, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 8, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 20. |
| Jan 20, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 23, 2016 | AB 1682 STONE Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1682 Mark Stone By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 14, 2016 | AB 1682 STONE Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 6, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 8, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1682
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:August 10, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 76-0 | (April 14, 2016) | SENATE: | 38-0 | (August 16, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the secret settlement of childhood sexual abuse and exploitation cases, as well as felony sex abuse cases, as a matter of public policy. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands the type of civil actions which cannot be the subject of secret settlements to include not only acts that may be prosecuted as felony sex offenses, but also the following:
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Penal Code (PC) Section 340.1.
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in PC Section 11165.1, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to PC Sections 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6.
- Corrects a cross-referencing error to the definition of "personal identifying information" in existing law which should refer to PC Section 530.55, rather than PC 530.5.
The Senate amendments:
- Add sexual assault of an elder or dependent adult to the list of offenses for which confidential settlements are prohibited as against public policy.
- Make other minor and clarifying changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS: As a general rule, settlement agreements are useful tools in civil litigation. They have been called the grease that keeps the wheels of the civil justice system moving. Settlements encourage timely resolution of claims and help the parties avoid the expense of trial. Confidentiality provisions within settlement agreements help parties avoid the trauma and embarrassment of participating in a public trial.
However, a strong public policy argument can be made that secret settlements are inappropriate in some cases, specifically matters of concern to the public because they involve particularly vulnerable victims, highly dangerous behavior, or especially egregious conduct.
Some legal experts say that the usual rationales and incentives cited in support of secret settlements do not fit priest abuse cases well. The victims were generally children, who ought to receive special protection; the abusers were often repeat offenders, who should have been stopped; and criminal prosecution of the priests was made all but impossible given the central importance of the victim's testimony in rape and other sexual abuse cases.
Prof. Stephen Gillers, who teaches legal ethics at New York University Law School, says that the arguments made against secret settlements in cases involving widespread harm, called mass torts by lawyers, apply with equal strength in this new setting. "Certain kinds of harm are so serious," he says, "whether it's criminal conduct by priests or exploding kitchen appliances, that we should not let plaintiffs agree to confidentiality." (Liptak, Adam. A Case that Grew in Shadows, The New York Times, March 24, 2002.)
Nevertheless, confidentiality provisions are commonly included in civil settlements. According to a number of sources, such provisions were standard in dozens, if not hundreds, of settlements of sexual abuse claims against priests around the country, including in California. According to Bishopaccountability.org, a group that tracks civil actions and settlement of clergy sex abuse cases, there have been "settlements involving 5,679 persons who allege sexual abuse by Catholic clergy. These survivors are only one-third of the 15,235 allegations that the bishops say they have received through 2009, and they are only 5% of the 100,000 United States (U.S.) victims...estimated in a 1993 study. Important as these settlements are, they represent a minority of known cases, and a tiny fraction of all the abuse perpetrated by Catholic clergy." (http://www.bishop-accountability.org/settlements/) According to one California law firm that specializes in clergy sexual abuse cases, more than 800 complaints have been filed in California against the Catholic Church since 2003 and the Church has settled a small percentage of those cases for a combined total of more than $450 million. (http://www.childmolestationvictims.com/california-catholic-clergy-sexual-abuse-information/) Despite headlines focusing on abusive priests in the Catholic Church, secret settlements involving childhood sexual abuse are by no means limited to the Catholic Church. Other recent examples where secret settlements have occurred include community youth service organizations; foster parents; administrators of homes for the mentally disabled; professional athletes; youth swim coaches; a college football coach; and pop stars.
Existing law prohibits the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. Because of strong public policy concerns, existing law makes confidential settlements either disfavored or prohibited in certain cases. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based upon a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). Likewise, Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 1002 prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action based on "an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense."
According to the author, this latter provision leaves a dangerous loophole in the law. Specifically, the author observes that many sexual abuse and exploitation offenses that victimize minors are not felonies, or can easily be characterized as non-felonies. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that many of the offenses that establish a factual basis for these civil actions are never referred to law enforcement and never reviewed by prosecutors to determine whether felony charges are appropriate. Such settlements also perpetuate a two-tiered criminal justice system in which only those without financial means to pay for the silence of their victims are prosecuted in the criminal courts. According to the author, all cases of childhood sexual abuse should be publically handled by the courts.
According to the National Center for Victims of Crime, 28% of all U.S. youth aged 14 to 17 years are sexually abused over the course of their lifetime. By shielding cases of sexual abuse and exploitation from the public and law enforcement, secret settlements unfairly allow sexual offenders, with the financial means, to pay for the silence of their victims, to escape criminal prosecution and potentially abuse other children.
While confidentiality agreements may help to facilitate settlements of individual claims, they also put the public at risk by hiding sexual predators from law enforcement and the public at large. In the case of clergy sex abuse cases, confidentiality provisions largely prevented the prosecution of pedophile priests as statutes of limitations for filing criminal charges expired. They allowed the continuing abuse of children as priests were moved from parish to parish within the U.S., and sometimes to churches outside of the country.
The public arguably has such a strong interest in the prosecution of individuals who commit acts of childhood sexual abuse and exploitation, as well as cases of sexual abuse of elder and dependent adults, that the ordinarily useful tool of confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements should not be allowed in civil actions based upon those acts. Like offenses that can be charged as felony sex offenses or violations of EADACPA, secret settlements of these claims could endanger the public, including other potential victims, and allow perpetrators to escape criminal prosecution just because they have the financial means to pay the cost of settlements.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004236
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1682
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 4/14/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill prohibits a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified, and makes a confidential settlement agreement void as a matter of law and against public policy, and subjects an attorney that fails to comply with the requirements of the bill to discipline by the State Bar of California.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/10/16 clarify that a confidential settlement agreement is one that “prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action” and fleshes out the specific attorney conduct which would subject an attorney to investigation, and potentially discipline, by the State Bar.
ANALYSIS: Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for an act that is a felony sex offense, but does not prohibit any of the following:
- An agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim;
- An agreement preventing the defendant or any person acting on the defendant's behalf from disclosing any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the felony sex offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant; and
- Any right of the crime victim to disclose his or her medical information or personal information, or relationship to the defendant. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
This bill:
- Prohibits a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for (1) an act of childhood sexual abuse, (2) sexual exploitation of a minor, or (3) an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified.
- Prohibits a court from entering an order, in any of civil actions above, restricting disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with the provision above.
- Repeals the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited.
- Provides that a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Provides that a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement is void as a matter of law and against public policy and that an attorney’s failure to comply with the requirements of the bill may be grounds for professional discipline and as to be determined the State Bar of California, as specified.
Background
Existing law disfavors the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.) In addition, confidential settlement of a civil action where the factual basis for the action is “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense” is prohibited.
Seeking to ensure that the perpetrators of other sexual crimes are made known to the public, this bill prohibits the secret settlement of civil actions involving the sexual abuse or exploitation of minors, and the sexual abuse of elder or dependent adults.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Attorney General Kamala D. Harris
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Bay Area Women Against Rape
California Association of Code Enforcement Officers
California Coalition Against Sexual Assault
California College and University
California Police Chiefs Association
California Narcotic Officers Association
Center Against Sexual Assault of Southwest Riverside County
Center for Community Solutions
Coalition for Family Harmony
Conference of California Bar Associations
Consumer Attorneys of California
Kene Me-Wu Family Healing Center
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Monterey County Rape Crisis Center
North County Rape Crisis and Child Protection Center
One SAFE Place
Project Sister Family Services
Riverside Sheriffs Association
Women’s Center - Youth & Family Services
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/10/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support, the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs writes:
Although minors cannot legally enter into contracts or be held to settlements signed by their parents or guardians, secret settlements likely discourage them from ever reporting their abuse to law enforcement. Years later, after they are adults, it may be too late for law enforcement to act because the statute of limitation on charging the acts as crimes may have passed. Secret settlements interfere with the prosecution of predators and could endanger minors. By shielding cases from the public and law enforcement, secret settlements unfairly allow convicted sexual offenders with the financial means to pay for the silence of their victims in an attempt to escape criminal prosecution. Such settlements also endanger other potential victims by shielding such offenders from public knowledge and scrutiny.
On behalf of California Attorney General Kamala D. Harris, the California Department of Justice writes in support, “This bill closes a perilous loophole in the law that allows perpetrators of sexual abuse against children to evade full accountability by negotiating confidential settlement agreements in civil actions. By affirming that such provisions are in direct contrast with the interests of public policy, AB 1682 will ensure that California’s laws conform with its commitment to defending the welfare of its youngest residents.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 4/14/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Irwin, Levine, Melendez, Nazarian
8/12/16 13:21:58
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1682 (Author:Mark Stone)
Version: May 4, 2016
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: NR
SUBJECT
Confidential settlement agreements: sexual offenses
DESCRIPTION
This bill would prohibit a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified, and would prohibit a court from entering an order restricting access to or disclosure of any information obtained through discovery.
The bill would make a confidential settlement agreement, as specified, void as a matter of law and against public policy, and would create a presumption that an attorney who advises a client to sign such an agreement has committed an act involving moral turpitude and subject to professional discipline. The bill would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action against such an attorney.
BACKGROUND
Existing law disfavors the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.) In addition, confidential settlement of a civil action where the factual basis for the action is “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense” is prohibited.
Seeking to ensure that the perpetrators of other sexual crimes are made known to the public, this bill would prohibit the secret settlement of civil actions involving the sexual abuse or exploitation of minors, and the sexual abuse of elder or dependent adults.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law prohibits a confidential settlement agreement in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for an act that is a felony sex offense. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002(a).)
Existing law, despite the provision above, does not prohibit any of the following:
- an agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim;
- an agreement preventing the defendant or any person acting on the defendant's behalf from disclosing any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the felony sex offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant; and
- any right of the crime victim to disclose his or her medical information or personal information, or relationship to the defendant. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002(b)-(c).)
This bill would prohibit a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for (1) an act of childhood sexual abuse, (2) sexual exploitation of a minor, or (3) an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, as specified.
The bill would prohibit a court from entering an order, in any of civil actions above, restricting disclosure or access to information obtained through discovery.
The bill would repeal the provision specifying that a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires nondisclosure of the amount of money paid in settlement of a claim is not prohibited.
The bill would make a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would provide that an attorney who demands such a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with a confidentiality or secrecy provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude that is subject to professional discipline and would require the State Bar of California to investigate and take appropriate action in cases brought to its attention.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Strong public policy argument can be made that secret settlements are inappropriate in some cases, specifically matters of concern to the public because they involve particularly vulnerable victims, highly dangerous behavior, or especially egregious conduct. […]Nevertheless, confidentiality provisions are commonly included in civil settlements. Despite headlines focusing on abusive priests in the Catholic Church, secret settlements involving childhood sexual abuse are by no means limited to the Catholic Church. Other recent examples where secret settlements have occurred include community youth service organizations; foster parents; administrators of homes for the mentally disabled; professional athletes; youth swim coaches; a college football coach; and pop stars.
- Shedding light on allegations of sexual abuse
This bill would prohibit, in civil actions for damages based on allegations of child sexual abuse, child sexual exploitation, or sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult, confidential settlement agreements. In support, the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs writes:
Although minors cannot legally enter into contracts or be held to settlements signed by their parents or guardians, secret settlements likely discourage them from ever reporting their abuse to law enforcement. Years later, after they are adults, it may be too late for law enforcement to act because the statute of limitation on charging the acts as crimes may have passed. Secret settlements interfere with the prosecution of predators and could endanger minors. By shielding cases from the public and law enforcement, secret settlements unfairly allow convicted sexual offenders with the financial means to pay for the silence of their victims in an attempt to escape criminal prosecution. Such settlements also endanger other potential victims by shielding such offenders from public knowledge and scrutiny.
Staff notes that this bill would only apply to confidential settlement agreements entered into after a civil action has been filed with the court, and thus would not prohibit earlier settlement agreements or expose alleged abusers, who settle prior to a civil suit being filed, to the public. In addition, the settling of a civil case is not necessarily an indication of guilt. The victim or defendant may not wish to go through burden and stress of litigation, and settlements often result in larger sums to the injured party because neither party needs to pay an attorney through the end of trial. That being said, this Committee has supported legislation that disfavors or prohibits confidential settlement agreements in the past to ensure, as a matter of public policy, that the public has notice of certain bad actors.
- The court’s role in managing discovery and evidence
Discovery is the formal exchange of evidentiary information and materials between parties to a pending action. A party is entitled to disclosure in discovery as a “matter of right unless statutory or public policy considerations clearly prohibit it. Greyhound v. Superior Court (1961) 56 C2d 355, 378. In general, any party may obtain discovery about any unprivileged matter that is relevant to the subject matter of the action. (Code Civ. Proc. Secs. 2016.010-2036.050.)
Once discovered, all relevant information is admissible unless excluded by statute, for reasons of public policy, or because the court determines the evidence is too unreliable to be presented to the trier of fact. Evidence Code Section 352 provides that “the court in its discretion may exclude evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the probability that its admission will (a) necessitate undue consumption of time or (b) create substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.”
This bill would prohibit the court from entering an order that restricts the disclosure of information obtained through discovery. This would arguably prevent a court from prohibiting a party from seeking information that is irrelevant to the civil law suit, and may also serve to prevent the court from excluding evidence from trial despite the fact that its probative value is substantially outweighed by the probability of misleading the jury. The ability of the judge to exclude relevant evidence under Section 352 is especially important in cases involving sexual abuse, where a victim’s sexual history may confuse or prejudice the jury, and the disclosure of such information stands to re-victimize the victim.
This bill would also prohibit the court from restricting public access to court records regarding information obtained through discovery. Given the broad scope of discovery described above, depriving the court of the ability to limit access to certain records could seriously violate the privacy rights of the parties, and third parties implicated in the discovery process. Again, this kind of public disclosure could re-victimize a victim, and could also destroy the reputation of a defendant who was falsely accused.
The Legislature has tasked courts with managing discovery and evidence because judges are in the best position to prevent abuse of the process and protect the parties. While the author’s aim of making sexual predators known to the public is a laudable goal, a “one-size-fits-all” approach would deny judges the discretion they need to ensure fairness and prevent abuse of the system.
The following amendments would strike the discovery provisions from the bill, thereby allowing a court to issue discovery protective orders and exempt certain evidence from trial for statutory or public policy reasons, but would otherwise prohibit the “sealing” or court records so that the public may have access to information related to sexual predators.
Author’s amendments:
- On page 2, strike lines 19-21 and insert “Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order restricting the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).”
- On page 3, strike lines 1-6
In support, the Conference of California Bar Associations writes, “for far too long, sexual predators, in cooperation with plaintiffs and their lawyers, have been able to keep the facts about their actions hidden from public view by agreeing to settlements in public litigation that keep the facts of the case secret. AB 1682 would substantially increase public protection by prohibiting agreements shielding these dangerous secrets in cases involving allegations of childhood sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor.”
- Attorney discipline
This bill would provide that any confidentiality or secrecy provision within a settlement agreement entered into after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy. Thus, as a practical matter, under this bill, any settlement agreement entered into would stand, but the secrecy provision would be void, thereby making the agreement open to the public.
This bill would then provide that any attorney who, in a civil action described by this bill, demands or advises that a client or party sign a settlement agreement with a confidentiality provision is presumed to have committed an act involving moral turpitude and shall be subject to professional discipline. The bill would require that the State Bar investigate the attorney. Existing law provides that “the commission of any act involving moral turpitude, dishonesty or corruption, whether the act is committed in the course of his relations as an attorney or otherwise, and whether the act is a felony or misdemeanor or not, constitutes a cause for disbarment or suspension.”
A search of the California Codes revealed that in no other statute is such a presumption used. In addition, this bill does not require that an attorney have knowledge that the confidentiality provision in a settlement agreement was prohibited, or establish how an attorney would rebut the presumption of moral turpitude. Further, the discipline included in this bill is arguably harsher than similar (or even more egregious) acts, and could amount to a deprivation of due process for an attorney who is suspended or disbarred. Accordingly, the author may wish to amend the bill to provide that an attorney who demands or advises that a client or party sign a prohibited agreement may be subject to disciplinary action.
Author’s amendment:
- Page 3, line 19 strike “An attorney who” and insert “Failure to comply with this section by any attorney may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such cases brought to its attention.”
- Page 3, strike lines 20-29
These amendments will ensure that the State Bar has the authority to investigate an attorney who advises (or demands) that a party or client sign a confidential settlement agreement in a civil action for child or elder sexual abuse. On behalf of California Attorney General Kamala D. Harris, the California Department of Justice writes, “This bill closes a perilous loophole in the law that allows perpetrators of sexual abuse against children to evade full accountability by negotiating confidential settlement agreements in civil actions. By affirming that such provisions are in direct contrast with the interests of public policy, AB 1682 will ensure that California’s laws conform with its commitment to defending the welfare of its youngest residents.”
Support: Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs; Attorney General Kamala D. Harris; Bay Area Women Against Rape; California Association of Code Enforcement Officers; California Coalition Against Sexual Assault; California College and University; California Police Chiefs Association; California Narcotic Officers Association; Center Against Sexual Assault of Southwest Riverside County; Center for Community Solutions; Coalition for Family Harmony; Conference of California Bar Associations; Consumer Attorneys of California; Kene Me-Wu Family Healing Center; Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association; Los Angeles Police Protective League; Monterey County Rape Crisis Center; North County Rape Crisis and Child Protection Center; One SAFE Place; Project Sister Family Services; Riverside Sheriffs Association; Women’s Center - Youth & Family Services; Numerous individuals
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012) would have, among other provisions, prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for an act of childhood sexual abuse. This bill was held on Suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2875 (Pavley, Ch. 151, Stats. 2006) prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.”
AB 634 (Steinberg, Ch. 242, Stats. 2003) enacted law disfavoring confidential settlement agreements in actions for a violation of Elder and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 18, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing: April 6, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1682
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:February 29, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill:
- Expands the type of civil actions that cannot be the subject of secret settlements to include not only acts that may be prosecuted as felony sex offenses, but also an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual exploitation of a minor.
- Provides, for settlement agreements entered into after January 1, 2017, that an attorney demanding a confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement as described above and as a condition of settlement is subject to investigation and discipline by the State Bar.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Negligible fiscal impact.
COMMENTS:
Background and Purpose. Current law, which prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action where the factual basis for the action is “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense,” arguably contains a significant loophole. Although minors cannot legally enter into contracts or settlements, and cannot be held to the terms and conditions of agreements to settle civil actions, unless those agreements are signed by their parents, guardians, or guardians ad litem and approved by a court, current law allows the secret settlement of a civil action based upon childhood sexual abuse or exploitation as long as the underlying act can be characterized as an offense other than a felony. This is problematic because many sexual abuse and exploitation offenses that victimize minors are not felonies, or can easily be characterized as less serious offenses. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that many of the offenses are never referred to law enforcement and therefore never reviewed by prosecutors to determine whether felony charges are appropriate.
AB 1682 closes this apparent loophole and protects the safety of children and the public at large. It clarifies that the secret settlement of civil actions involving the sexual abuse or exploitation of minors, whether felonies or misdemeanors, is against public policy. This bill is sponsored by the California Coalition Against Sexual Assault and is supported by Consumer Attorneys of California, numerous law enforcement agencies and associations, and numerous organizations that provide services to survivors of sexual assault. It has no known opposition.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 8, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Amended Ver:
SUBJECT: CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS: SEXUAL OFFENSES
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD STATE LAW PROHIBIT THE SECRET SETTLEMENT OF ALL CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION CASES, including those which could be charged as misdemeanors, IN ORDER TO ensurE that ALL persons who sexually abuse or exploit minors are ACCOUNTABLE TO THE PUBLIC AND LAW ENFORCEMENT, including those with the financial means to settle civil actions?
SYNOPSIS
Existing law prohibits the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code of Civil Procedure, hereafter “CCP,” Section 2017.310.) Also, CCP Section 1002 prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action where the factual basis for the action is “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.” There is arguably a significant loophole, however, in the latter provision. Although minors cannot legally enter into contracts or settlements and cannot be held to the terms and conditions of agreements to settle civil actions unless those agreements are signed by their parents, guardians, or guardians ad litem and approved by a court, current law allows the secret settlement of a civil action based upon childhood sexual abuse or exploitation as long as the underlying act can be characterized as an offense other than a felony. This is problematic because many sexual abuse and exploitation offenses that victimize minors are not felonies, or can easily be characterized as less serious offenses. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that many of the offenses are never referred to law enforcement and therefore never reviewed by prosecutors to determine whether felony charges are appropriate.
AB 1682 closes this apparent loophole and protects the safety of children and the public at large. It clarifies that the secret settlement of civil actions involving the sexual abuse or exploitation of minors, whether felonies or misdemeanors, is against public policy. If this bill becomes law, all confidentiality provisions within settlement agreements made in such cases after this bill goes into effect would be void as a matter of law. This bill also provides that attorneys who advocate for, or condition the settlement of civil actions involving sexual abuse and exploitation of children upon, the confidentiality of the settlement are subject to discipline by the State Bar and requires the Bar to investigate such attorneys. Supporters point out that secret settlements likely prevent victims from reporting their abuse to law enforcement. Years later, after they become adults, victims of childhood sexual abuse may wish to pursue criminal prosecution but may find that it is too late for criminal prosecution because the statute of limitations on charging the underlying acts as crimes has expired. This bill is sponsored by the California Coalition Against Sexual Assault and is supported by Consumer Attorneys of California, numerous law enforcement agencies and associations, and numerous organizations that provide services to survivors of sexual assault. It has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the secret settlement of childhood sexual abuse and exploitation cases, as well as felony sex abuse cases, as a matter of public policy. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands the type of civil actions which cannot be the subject of secret settlements to include not only acts that may be prosecuted as felony sex offenses, but also the following:
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Penal Code Section 340.1.
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Sections 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code.
- Corrects a cross-referencing error to the definition of “personal identifying information” in existing law which should refer to Section 530.55, rather than 530.5 of the Penal Code (hereafter “PC”).
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows a court, upon petition, to appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the interests of a minor when a civil action is filed and the plaintiff is a minor. (CCP Section 337 (a).)
- Prohibits the confidential settlement agreement of any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense. (CCP Section 1002 (a).)
- Provides that 1), above, does not preclude an agreement preventing the defendant or any person acting on his or her behalf from disclosing any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the felony sex offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant and does not limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information. (CCP Section 1002 (b).)
- Provides that 1), above, does not apply to or affect the ability of the parties to enter into a settlement agreement or stipulated agreement that requires the nondisclosure of the amount of any money paid in a settlement of a claim. (CCP Section 1002 (c).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (CCP Section 2017.310 (a).)
- Defines as “childhood sexual abuse” any act committed against a plaintiff that occurred when the plaintiff was under the age of 18 years which is proscribed by certain sections of the Penal Code, including a number of sexual abuse offenses that can be charged as misdemeanors, such as the following:
- Sodomy with a person under 18 years of age (PC Section 286 (b)(1));
- Oral copulation with a person under 18 years of age (PC Section 288a (b)(1));
- Sexual penetration of a person who is under 18 years of age by another person who is under 18 years of age (PC Section 289 (h));
- Annoying or molesting any child under 18 years of age (PC Section 647.6; CCP Section 340.1 (e).)
- Defines “Sexual exploitation” as any of the following:
- Depicting a minor engaged in obscene acts in violation of PC Section 311.2 [preparing, selling, or distributing obscene matter] or subdivision (a) of PC Section 311.4 [employment of minor to perform obscene acts]. (PC Section 11165.1 (c)(1).)
- Promoting, aiding, assisting, employing, using, persuading, inducing, or coercing a person who knowingly promotes, aids, or assists, employs, uses, persuades, induces, or coerces a child, or a person responsible for a child’s welfare, who knowingly permits or encourages a child to engage in, or assist others to engage in, prostitution or a live performance involving obscene sexual conduct. (PC Section 11165.1 (c)(2).)
- Depicting a child in, or knowingly developing, duplicating, printing, downloading streaming, accessing through any electronic or digital media, or exchanging, a film, photograph, videotape, video recording, negative, or slide in which a child is engaged in an act of obscene sexual conduct. (PC Section 11165.1 (c)(3).)
- Makes it a felony or a misdemeanor for a person to knowingly do either of the following:
- Send or cause to be sent into this state for sale or distribution of any obscene matter, knowing that the matter depicts a person under the age of 18 years personally engaging in sexual conduct with intent to distribute or to exhibit to, or to exchange with others. (PC Section 311.1 (a).)
- Possess, prepare, publish, produce, develop, duplicate, or print any representation of information, data, or image of obscene matter that depicts a person under the age of 18 years personally engaging in or personally simulating sexual conduct, knowing that the person is a minor and with the intent to distribute or to exhibit to, or to exchange with, others. (PC Section 311.1 (a).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor to do either of the following:
- Write, create, or solicit the publication or distribution of advertising or other promotional material, or promote the sale, distribution, or exhibition of matter represented or held out to be obscene. (PC Section 311.5.)
- Knowingly engage or participate in, manage, produce, sponsor, present or exhibit obscene live conduct to or before an assembly or audience consisting of at least one person or spectator in any public place or in any place exposed to public view, or in any place open to the public or to a segment thereof. (PC Section 311.6.)
- Defines “personal identifying information.” (PC Section 530.55 (b).)
- Defines “felony” as a crime that is punishable with death, by imprisonment in the state prison, or imprisonment in a county jail and provides that every other crime or public offense is a misdemeanor, except those offenses that are classified as infractions. (PC Section 17 (a).)
- Provides that except in cases where a different punishment is prescribed by any law of this state, every offense declared to be a misdemeanor is punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months, or by fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both. (PC Section 19.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Minors are unable to make binding contracts and therefore can be released from any contractual obligations they make before they become adults. Civil Code section 35 provides, in relevant part, that “the contract of a minor may be disaffirmed by the minor himself, either before his majority or within a reasonable time afterwards.” The purpose of Civil Code section 35 is “to protect the minor from his own improvidence. It is often said, he who affirmatively deals with a minor, does so at his peril.” (Hohe v. San Diego Unified School Dist. (1990) 224 “Cal.App.3d 1559, 1565.) For example, in Tracy v. Gaudin (1930) 104 Cal.App. 158, a minor fraudulently obtained a new car from the plaintiff’s dealership by forging his guardian's name on a withdrawal slip. The minor later died and the dealer attempted to collect the cost of the vehicle from the minor’s estate. The court found that even though the minor received and retained the benefits of his contract, the minor’s estate was not required to restore the consideration or its equivalent to the dealer because the contract was not binding upon the minor. (Id, at 160-61.)
While a contract signed by a minor without the signature of a parent, guardian, or guardian ad litem is “voidable” by the minor (i.e. not enforceable against the minor) it is nevertheless potentially enforceable against the other party to the contract. This harsh consequence is premised upon the strong public policy against adults contracting with minors. “[T]he former cannot complain if, as a consequence of their violation of this rule of conduct, they are injured by the exercise of the right with which the law has purposely invested the latter, nor charge that the infant in exercising the right is guilty of fraud.” (Flittner v. Equitable Life Assurance Soc. (1916) 30 Cal.App. 209, 212.)
In order to protect the rights of minors involved in legal disputes and civil actions, California law provides minors with a number of specific procedural and substantive protections. As a general rule, minors who are parties to civil actions must appear in court proceedings through guardians, conservators, or guardians ad litem. (CCP Section 372 (a)(1).) In order to settle a disputed claim by a minor (prior to a complaint being filed), a parent or guardian must, acting on behalf of a minor, release a claim or execute a covenant not to sue. (Probate Code Section 3500.)
Furthermore, even if a parent, guardian, guardian ad litem, or conservator signs an agreement to settle a dispute claim or a pending civil action on behalf of a minor, the agreement is not binding upon the parties until it is reviewed and approved by the court. “As early as the courts of chancery, a guardian ad litem lacked the power to bind a minor litigant to a settlement agreement absent an independent investigation by the court.” (Scruton v. Korean Air Lines Co. (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 1596, 1605.) “[E]very step in the proceeding [of a minor's lawsuit] occurs under the aegis of the court” [Citation omitted] . . . Thus, “[i]t is the court's order approving the settlement that vests the guardian ad litem with the legal power to enforce the agreement. [Citation omitted].” (Ibid.) Judicial Council form MC-350 is the petition for approving a settlement of either a disputed claim (Probate Code Section 3500), or a pending action (CCP 372) involving a minor and is called a “Petition to Compromise a Minor’s Claim.” The form must be signed by the “petitioner” (the parent, guardian, guardian ad litem, or conservator of the minor) and approved by the court. The court may appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the interests of the minor “in any case when it is deemed by the court . . . expedient to appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the minor” (CCP Section 372), even when a minor has a parent or guardian to act as his or her representative in a disputed claim or a lawsuit, and is likely to do so when the interests of the parent or guardian and the minor diverge or conflict.
Enforceability of properly executed contracts, including confidentiality agreements, against minors. Assuming that a minor’s right to settle a claim or a civil action is properly executed by a parent, guardian, guardian ad litem, or conservator and approved by the court, as described above, the agreement is binding upon the minor. A binding settlement of a minor’s claim or action could presumably include a confidentiality provision. Unless prohibited by law, as discussed below (i.e. because the underlying offense is an act that may be prosecuted as a violation of EADACPA or a felony ex offense), the confidentiality provision would also be binding upon the minor. In fact, many high profile settlements of civil actions based upon childhood sexual abuse have reportedly included confidentiality provisions. In a number of those cases, however, victims have later reported their abuse to law enforcement or the media. The Committee is unaware of a case in which a victim has been sued for breach of a confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement made when the victim was a minor, but such an action is certainly possible.
History of secret settlements being used to settle civil actions, including cases of childhood sexual abuse. As a general rule, settlement agreements are useful tools in civil litigation. They have been called the grease that keeps the wheels of the civil justice system moving. Settlements encourage timely resolution of claims and help the parties avoid the expense of trial. Confidentiality provisions within settlement agreements help parties avoid the trauma and embarrassment of participating in a public trial.
However, a strong public policy argument can be made that secret settlements are inappropriate in some cases, specifically matters of concern to the public because they involve particularly vulnerable victims, highly dangerous behavior, or especially egregious conduct.
Some legal experts say that the usual rationales and incentives cited in support of secret settlements do not fit priest abuse cases well. The victims were generally children, who ought to receive special protection; the abusers were often repeat offenders, who should have been stopped; and criminal prosecution of the priests was made all but impossible given the central importance of the victim's testimony in rape and other sexual abuse cases.
Prof. Stephen Gillers, who teaches legal ethics at New York University Law School, says that the arguments made against secret settlements in cases involving widespread harm, called mass torts by lawyers, apply with equal strength in this new setting. “Certain kinds of harm are so serious,” he says, “whether it's criminal conduct by priests or exploding kitchen appliances, that we should not let plaintiffs agree to confidentiality.” (Liptak, Adam. A Case that Grew in Shadows, The New York Times, March 24, 2002.)
Nevertheless, confidentiality provisions are commonly included in civil settlements. According to a number of sources, such provisions were standard in dozens, if not hundreds, of settlements of sexual abuse claims against priests around the country, including in California. According to Bishopaccountability.org, a group that tracks civil actions and settlement of clergy sex abuse cases, there have been “settlements involving 5,679 persons who allege sexual abuse by Catholic clergy. These survivors are only one-third of the 15,235 allegations that the bishops say they have received through 2009, and they are only 5% of the 100,000 U.S. victims . . . estimated in a 1993 study. Important as these settlements are, they represent a minority of known cases, and a tiny fraction of all the abuse perpetrated by Catholic clergy.” (http://www.bishop-accountability.org/settlements/) According to one California law firm that specializes in clergy sexual abuse cases, more than 800 complaints have been filed in California against the Catholic Church since 2003 and the Church has settled a small percentage of those cases for a combined total of more than $450 million. (http://www.childmolestationvictims.com/california-catholic-clergy-sexual-abuse-information/) Despite headlines focusing on abusive priests in the Catholic Church, secret settlements involving childhood sexual abuse are by no means limited to the Catholic Church. Other recent examples where secret settlements have occurred include community youth service organizations; foster parents; administrators of homes for the mentally disabled; professional athletes; youth swim coaches; a college football coach; and pop stars.
Existing law prohibits the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. Because of strong public policy concerns, existing law makes confidential settlements either disfavored or prohibited in certain cases. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based upon a violation of EADACPA. (CCP Section 2017.310 (a).) Likewise, CCP Section 1002 prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action based on “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.”
According to the author, this latter provision leaves a dangerous loophole in the law. Specifically, the author observes that many sexual abuse and exploitation offenses that victimize minors are not felonies, or can easily be characterized as non-felonies. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that many of the offenses that establish a factual basis for these civil actions are never referred to law enforcement and never reviewed by prosecutors to determine whether felony charges are appropriate. Such settlements also perpetuate a two-tiered criminal justice system in which only those without financial means to pay for the silence of their victims are prosecuted in the criminal courts. According to the author, all cases of childhood sexual abuse should be publically handled by the courts.
According to the sponsor, CALCASA, secret settlements endanger other children and other potential victims of sexual assault or exploitation by shielding sexual predators from public scrutiny and law enforcement review. According to the National Center for Victims of Crime, 28% of all U.S. youth aged 14 to 17 years are sexually abused over the course of their lifetime. By shielding cases of sexual abuse and exploitation from the public and law enforcement, secret settlements unfairly allow sexual offenders, with the financial means, to pay for the silence of their victims, to escape criminal prosecution and potentially abuse other children.
While confidentiality agreements may help to facilitate settlements of individual claims, they also put the public at risk by hiding sexual predators from law enforcement and the public at large. In the case of clergy sex abuse cases, confidentiality provisions largely prevented the prosecution of pedophile priests as statutes of limitations for filing criminal charges expired. They allowed the continuing abuse of children as priests were moved from parish to parish within the U.S., and sometimes to churches outside of the country.
The public arguably has such a strong interest in the prosecution of individuals who commit acts of childhood sexual abuse and exploitation that the ordinarily useful tool of confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements should not be allowed in civil actions based upon those acts. Like offenses that can be charged as felony sex offenses or violations of EADACPA, secret settlements of these claims could endanger the public, including other potential victims, and allow perpetrators to escape criminal prosecution just because they have the financial means to pay the cost of settlements.
Is it appropriate for the Legislature to require the State Bar to investigate and take appropriate action against attorneys who violate the provisions of this bill? This bill provides that an attorney who demands an unlawful confidentiality provision within a settlement agreement as a condition of settlement or who advises a client to sign an agreement with such a confidentiality provision is subject to professional discipline by the State Bar. Specifically, it provides that an attorney who violates the law by demanding a confidentiality provision as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign such an agreement “shall be subject to professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention.”
It could be argued that this language somehow interferes with the authority of the Judicial Branch which has oversight responsibility for the disciplinary function of the State Bar. However, many other statutes that restrict conduct by attorneys also specify that violation of the statute “shall be subject to discipline by the State Bar.” Also, the additional language in this bill that requires investigation is not unique. In fact, it is virtually identical to CCP Section 365, which requires the State Bar to investigate and take appropriate action in a case where an attorney fails to follow the steps set forth in CCP 364 to provide notice of an action based upon the health care provider’s professional negligence. CCP Section 365 provides that an attorney’s failure to comply with CCP Section 364 “shall be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such cases brought to its attention.” Ultimately, even under this language, it is the State Bar’s decision whether or not to take action and what action is appropriate. The only mandate on the Bar is to “investigate” which, given the public policy in favor of this prohibition, seems like the minimum that the Bar should do. Given the following findings by the State Auditor last year, a legislative mandate for the Bar to investigate these cases may be appropriate.
[T]he State Bar has not consistently fulfilled its mission to protect the public from errant attorneys and lacks accountability related to its expenditures. The State Bar has struggled historically to promptly resolve all the complaints it receives, potentially delaying the timely discipline of attorneys who engage in misconduct.
SIMILAR PAST LEGISLATION: AB 634 (Steinberg, Chapter 242, Statutes of 2003) enacted law disfavoring confidential settlement agreements in actions for a violation of EDACPA.
AB 2875 (Pavley, Chapter 151, Statutes of 2006) prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.”
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012) prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1” (but allowed secret settlement of sexual abuse cases involving adults). It also eliminated the prohibition on extended the statute of limitations in child sexual abuse cases from 26 to 35 years and established additional requirements for mandated reporters. The bill was held on Suspense in Assembly Appropriations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Coalition Against Sexual Assault (sponsor)
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Bay Area Women Against Rape
California Association of Code Enforcement Officers
California College and University Police Chiefs Association
California Narcotic Officers Association
Center Against Sexual Assault of Southwest Riverside County
Center for Community Solutions
Coalition for Family Harmony
Consumer Attorneys of California
Kene Me-Wu Family Healing Center
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Monterey County Rape Crisis Center
North County Rape Crisis and Child Protection Center
One SAFE Place
Project Sister Family Services
Riverside Sheriffs Association
Women's Center - Youth & Family Services
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by:
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):