AB 2873: Personal vehicle sharing: recalled vehicles.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-20
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act), prohibits a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, with exceptions. Existing law requires a personal vehicle sharing program, which facilitates the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use, to provide specified insurance coverage for a vehicle and driver while the vehicle is engaged in personal ride sharing. Under existing law, it is an infraction for a person to violate, or fail to comply with, a provision of the Vehicle Code, unless otherwise specified.
This bill would prohibit, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database, or not more than 48 hours after receiving notification of a manufacturers recall by a specified third party, a personal vehicle sharing program, as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The CARS Act provides that it does not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or the Department of Motor Vehicles related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report.
This bill would additionally provide that the CARS Act does not create any legal duty upon a personal vehicle sharing program related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after a personal vehicle sharing program obtained the recall database report.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act), prohibits a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, with exceptions. Existing law requires a personal vehicle sharing program, which facilitates the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use, to provide specified insurance coverage for a vehicle and driver while the vehicle is engaged in personal ride sharing. Under existing law, it is an infraction for a person to violate, or fail to comply with, a provision of the Vehicle Code, unless otherwise specified.
This bill would prohibit, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database, or not more than 48 hours after receiving notification of a manufacturers recall by a specified third party, a personal vehicle sharing program, as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The CARS Act provides that it does not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or the Department of Motor Vehicles related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report.
This bill would additionally provide that the CARS Act does not create any legal duty upon a personal vehicle sharing program related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after a personal vehicle sharing program obtained the recall database report.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law law, the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act (CARS Act), prohibits a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, with exceptions. Existing law requires a personal vehicle sharing program, which facilitates the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use, to provide specified insurance coverage for a vehicle and driver while the vehicle is engaged in personal ride sharing. Under existing law, it is an infraction for a person to violate, or fail to comply with, a provision of the Vehicle Code, unless otherwise specified.
This bill would prohibit prohibit, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database, or not more than 48 hours after receiving notification of a manufacturers recall by a specified third party, a personal vehicle sharing program, as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall for which a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The CARS Act provides that it does not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, or the Department of Motor Vehicles related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, or department obtained the recall database report.
This bill would additionally provide that the CARS Act does not create any legal duty upon a personal vehicle sharing program related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after a personal vehicle sharing program obtained the recall database report.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law prohibits a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, with exceptions. Existing law requires a personal vehicle sharing program, which facilitates the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use, to provide specified insurance coverage for a vehicle and driver while the vehicle is engaged in personal ride sharing. Under existing law, it is an infraction for a person to violate, or fail to comply with, a provision of the Vehicle Code, unless otherwise specified.
This bill would prohibit a personal vehicle sharing program, as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall for which a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law prohibits a dealer or rental car company, as defined, with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall after receiving a notice of the recall, as specified, until the vehicle has been repaired, with exceptions. Existing law requires a personal vehicle sharing program, which facilitates the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use, to provide specified insurance coverage for a vehicle and driver while the vehicle is engaged in personal ride sharing. Under existing law, it is an infraction for a person to violate, or fail to comply with, a provision of the Vehicle Code, unless otherwise specified.
This bill would prohibit a personal vehicle sharing program, as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall for which a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recall database. By creating new prohibitions, the violation of which would be a crime under existing law, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law defines the term rental company for those purposes to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public.Existing law prohibits a private passenger motor vehicle, as defined, from being classified for insurance purposes as a commercial, for-hire, or permissive use vehicle, or livery solely on the basis of it being used for personal vehicle sharing, as defined, if certain conditions are fulfilled. This bill would provide that the term rental company as used in the provisions governing transactions between a rental car company and its customers does not include a personal vehicle sharing program or a private passenger motor vehicle that is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, as those terms are defined in the provision governing insurance described above.This bill would enact the Personal Vehicle Sharing Act, and would state that it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting that act to establish baseline consumer protection and transparency with regard to personal vehicle sharing transactions.The bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern rather than a municipal affair and, therefore, apply to all cities, including charter cities.Existing law generally governs the transactions between a rental car company, also referred to as a rental company, and its customers. Existing law defines the term rental company for those purposes to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public.
Existing law prohibits a private passenger motor vehicle, as defined, from being classified for insurance purposes as a commercial, for-hire, or permissive use vehicle, or livery solely on the basis of it being used for personal vehicle sharing, as defined, if certain conditions are fulfilled.
This bill would provide that the term rental company as used in the provisions governing transactions between a rental car company and its customers does not include a personal vehicle sharing program or a private passenger motor vehicle that is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, as those terms are defined in the provision governing insurance described above.
This bill would enact the Personal Vehicle Sharing Act, and would state that it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting that act to establish baseline consumer protection and transparency with regard to personal vehicle sharing transactions.
The bill would include findings that the changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern rather than a municipal affair and, therefore, apply to all cities, including charter cities.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments. Existing law requires, with specified exceptions, the association of a common interest development to levy regular and special assessments to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the act. However, the association is prohibited from imposing or collecting an assessment or fee that exceeds the costs for which it is levied.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments. Existing law requires, with specified exceptions, the association of a common interest development to levy regular and special assessments to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the act. However, the association is prohibited from imposing or collecting an assessment or fee that exceeds the costs for which it is levied.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SEC. 2.Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c)As soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or not more than 48 hours after the personal vehicle sharing program receives notification of a manufacturers recall by a third party with which the personal vehicle sharing program contracts to provide notification of active recalls, a personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
(d)The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(e)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing company.
SEC. 3.Section 11760 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11760.(a)This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
(b)The changes to this section made by the act amending subdivision (a) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(c)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SEC. 2.Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c)As soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or not more than 48 hours after the personal vehicle sharing program receives notification of a manufacturers recall by a third party with which the personal vehicle sharing program contracts to provide notification of active recalls, a personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
(d)The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(e)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing company.
SEC. 3.Section 11760 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11760.(a)This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
(b)The changes to this section made by the act amending subdivision (a) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(c)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SEC. 2.Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c)A As soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or not more than 48 hours after the personal vehicle sharing program receives notification of a manufacturers recall by a third party with which the personal vehicle sharing program contracts to provide notification of active recalls, a personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations. that vehicle until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
(d)The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(e)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company. company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing company.
SEC. 3.Section 11760 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11760.(a)This article shall not create any legal duty upon the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the dealer, rental car company, personal vehicle sharing program, or department obtained the recall database report pursuant to Sections 11754 and 11758.
(b)The changes to this section made by the act amending subdivision (a) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(c)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SEC. 2.Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
(e)This section does not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)The term dealer has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b)(1)A manufacturers recall is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2)A manufacturers recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(c)(d)A recall database is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturers recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1)For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A)The recall data on a vehicle manufacturers Internet Web site for a specific vehicles line-make.
(B)The recall data in a vehicle manufacturers internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C)The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2)For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)(e)A recall database report is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e)(f)A rental car company is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SEC. 2.Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:11754.(a)No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturers recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b)If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c)A personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d)The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Section 1939.01 of the Civil Code is amended to read:1939.01.For the purpose of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:(a)(1)Rental company means a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public.(2)Rental company does not include a personal vehicle sharing program, or a private passenger motor vehicle that is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, unless that person or entity otherwise meets the definition of rental company for some reason other than participating in or facilitating personal vehicle sharing or a personal vehicle sharing program. For purposes of this paragraph, the terms personal vehicle sharing and personal vehicle sharing program have the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code. This paragraph is declaratory of existing law.(b)Renter means any person in a manner obligated under a contract for the lease or hire of a passenger vehicle from a rental company for a period of less than 30 days.(c)Additional mandatory charges means any separately stated charges that the rental company requires the renter to pay to hire or lease the vehicle for the period of time to which the rental rate applies, which are imposed by a governmental entity and specifically relate to the operation of a rental vehicle business, including, but not limited to, a customer facility charge, airport concession fee, tourism commission assessment, vehicle license recovery fee, or other government-imposed taxes or fees.(d)Airport concession fee means a charge collected by a rental company from a renter that is the renters proportionate share of the amount paid by the rental company to the owner or operator of an airport for the right or privilege of conducting a vehicle rental business on the airports premises.(e)Authorized driver means all of the following:(1)The renter.(2)The renters spouse, if that person is a licensed driver and satisfies the rental companys minimum age requirement.(3)The renters employer or coworker, if he or she is engaged in business activity with the renter, is a licensed driver, and satisfies the rental companys minimum age requirement.(4)A person expressly listed by the rental company on that renters contract as an authorized driver.(f)Customer facility charge means any fee, including an alternative fee, required by an airport to be collected by a rental company from a renter pursuant to Section 50474.21 of the Government Code.(g)Damage waiver means a rental companys agreement not to hold a renter liable for all or any portion of any damage or loss related to the rented vehicle, any loss of use of the rented vehicle, or any storage, impound, towing, or administrative charges.(h)Electronic surveillance technology means a technological method or system used to observe, monitor, or collect information, including telematics, Global Positioning System (GPS), wireless technology, or location-based technologies. Electronic surveillance technology does not include event data recorders (EDR), sensing and diagnostic modules (SDM), or other systems that are used either:(1)For the purpose of identifying, diagnosing, or monitoring functions related to the potential need to repair, service, or perform maintenance on the rental vehicle.(2)As part of the vehicles airbag sensing and diagnostic system in order to capture safety systems-related data for retrieval after a crash has occurred or in the event that the collision sensors are activated to prepare the decisionmaking computer to make the determination to deploy or not to deploy the airbag.(i)Estimated time for replacement means the number of hours of labor, or fraction thereof, needed to replace damaged vehicle parts as set forth in collision damage estimating guides generally used in the vehicle repair business and commonly known as crash books.(j)Estimated time for repair means a good faith estimate of the reasonable number of hours of labor, or fraction thereof, needed to repair damaged vehicle parts.(k)Membership program means a service offered by a rental company that permits customers to bypass the rental counter and go directly to the vehicle previously reserved or select an alternate vehicle. A membership program shall meet all of the following requirements:(1)The renter initiates enrollment by completing an application on which the renter can specify a preference for type of vehicle and acceptance or declination of optional services.(2)The rental company fully discloses, prior to the enrollees first rental as a participant in the program, all terms and conditions of the rental agreement as well as all required disclosures.(3)The renter may terminate enrollment at any time.(4)The rental company fully explains to the renter that designated preferences, as well as acceptance or declination of optional services, may be changed by the renter at any time for the next and future rentals.(5)An employee is available at the lot where the renter takes possession of the vehicle, to receive any change in the rental agreement from the renter.(l)Passenger vehicle or vehicle means a passenger vehicle as defined in Section 465 of the Vehicle Code.(m)Quote means an estimated cost of rental provided by a rental company or a third party to a potential customer that is based on information provided by the potential customer and used to generate an estimated cost of rental, including, but not limited to, potential dates of rental, locations, or classes of vehicle.(n)Tourism commission assessment means the charge collected by a rental company from a renter that has been established by the California Travel and Tourism Commission pursuant to Section 13995.65 of the Government Code.(o)Vehicle license fee means the tax imposed pursuant to the Vehicle License Fee Law (Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code).(p)Vehicle registration fee means any fee imposed pursuant to any provision of Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 9101) of Division 3 of the Vehicle Code or any other law that imposes a fee upon the registration of vehicles in this state.(q)Vehicle license recovery fee means a charge that seeks to recover the amount of any vehicle license fee and vehicle registration fee paid by a rental company for the particular class of vehicle being rented. If imposed, the vehicle license recovery fee shall be separately stated as a single charge in the quote and rental contract.SEC. 2.Chapter 1.6 (commencing with Section 1939.50) is added to Title 5 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, to read:1.6.Personal Vehicle Sharing Act1939.50.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited as, the Personal Vehicle Sharing Act.1939.51.For purposes of this chapter:(a)Personal vehicle sharing has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.(b)Personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.1939.52.It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this chapter to establish baseline consumer protection and transparency with regard to personal vehicle sharing transactions. For that reason, the Legislature finds and declares that ensuring those baseline standards is a matter of statewide concern and is not a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution. Therefore, this chapter applies to all cities, including charter cities.For the purpose of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)(1)Rental company means a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public.
(2)Rental company does not include a personal vehicle sharing program, or a private passenger motor vehicle that is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, unless that person or entity otherwise meets the definition of rental company for some reason other than participating in or facilitating personal vehicle sharing or a personal vehicle sharing program. For purposes of this paragraph, the terms personal vehicle sharing and personal vehicle sharing program have the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code. This paragraph is declaratory of existing law.
(b)Renter means any person in a manner obligated under a contract for the lease or hire of a passenger vehicle from a rental company for a period of less than 30 days.
(c)Additional mandatory charges means any separately stated charges that the rental company requires the renter to pay to hire or lease the vehicle for the period of time to which the rental rate applies, which are imposed by a governmental entity and specifically relate to the operation of a rental vehicle business, including, but not limited to, a customer facility charge, airport concession fee, tourism commission assessment, vehicle license recovery fee, or other government-imposed taxes or fees.
(d)Airport concession fee means a charge collected by a rental company from a renter that is the renters proportionate share of the amount paid by the rental company to the owner or operator of an airport for the right or privilege of conducting a vehicle rental business on the airports premises.
(e)Authorized driver means all of the following:
(1)The renter.
(2)The renters spouse, if that person is a licensed driver and satisfies the rental companys minimum age requirement.
(3)The renters employer or coworker, if he or she is engaged in business activity with the renter, is a licensed driver, and satisfies the rental companys minimum age requirement.
(4)A person expressly listed by the rental company on that renters contract as an authorized driver.
(f)Customer facility charge means any fee, including an alternative fee, required by an airport to be collected by a rental company from a renter pursuant to Section 50474.21 of the Government Code.
(g)Damage waiver means a rental companys agreement not to hold a renter liable for all or any portion of any damage or loss related to the rented vehicle, any loss of use of the rented vehicle, or any storage, impound, towing, or administrative charges.
(h)Electronic surveillance technology means a technological method or system used to observe, monitor, or collect information, including telematics, Global Positioning System (GPS), wireless technology, or location-based technologies. Electronic surveillance technology does not include event data recorders (EDR), sensing and diagnostic modules (SDM), or other systems that are used either:
(1)For the purpose of identifying, diagnosing, or monitoring functions related to the potential need to repair, service, or perform maintenance on the rental vehicle.
(2)As part of the vehicles airbag sensing and diagnostic system in order to capture safety systems-related data for retrieval after a crash has occurred or in the event that the collision sensors are activated to prepare the decisionmaking computer to make the determination to deploy or not to deploy the airbag.
(i)Estimated time for replacement means the number of hours of labor, or fraction thereof, needed to replace damaged vehicle parts as set forth in collision damage estimating guides generally used in the vehicle repair business and commonly known as crash books.
(j)Estimated time for repair means a good faith estimate of the reasonable number of hours of labor, or fraction thereof, needed to repair damaged vehicle parts.
(k)Membership program means a service offered by a rental company that permits customers to bypass the rental counter and go directly to the vehicle previously reserved or select an alternate vehicle. A membership program shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)The renter initiates enrollment by completing an application on which the renter can specify a preference for type of vehicle and acceptance or declination of optional services.
(2)The rental company fully discloses, prior to the enrollees first rental as a participant in the program, all terms and conditions of the rental agreement as well as all required disclosures.
(3)The renter may terminate enrollment at any time.
(4)The rental company fully explains to the renter that designated preferences, as well as acceptance or declination of optional services, may be changed by the renter at any time for the next and future rentals.
(5)An employee is available at the lot where the renter takes possession of the vehicle, to receive any change in the rental agreement from the renter.
(l)Passenger vehicle or vehicle means a passenger vehicle as defined in Section 465 of the Vehicle Code.
(m)Quote means an estimated cost of rental provided by a rental company or a third party to a potential customer that is based on information provided by the potential customer and used to generate an estimated cost of rental, including, but not limited to, potential dates of rental, locations, or classes of vehicle.
(n)Tourism commission assessment means the charge collected by a rental company from a renter that has been established by the California Travel and Tourism Commission pursuant to Section 13995.65 of the Government Code.
(o)Vehicle license fee means the tax imposed pursuant to the Vehicle License Fee Law (Part 5 (commencing with Section 10701) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code).
(p)Vehicle registration fee means any fee imposed pursuant to any provision of Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 9101) of Division 3 of the Vehicle Code or any other law that imposes a fee upon the registration of vehicles in this state.
(q)Vehicle license recovery fee means a charge that seeks to recover the amount of any vehicle license fee and vehicle registration fee paid by a rental company for the particular class of vehicle being rented. If imposed, the vehicle license recovery fee shall be separately stated as a single charge in the quote and rental contract.
SEC. 2.Chapter 1.6 (commencing with Section 1939.50) is added to Title 5 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, to read:1.6.Personal Vehicle Sharing Act1939.50.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited as, the Personal Vehicle Sharing Act.
1939.51.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Personal vehicle sharing has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(b)Personal vehicle sharing program has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
1939.52.It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this chapter to establish baseline consumer protection and transparency with regard to personal vehicle sharing transactions. For that reason, the Legislature finds and declares that ensuring those baseline standards is a matter of statewide concern and is not a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution. Therefore, this chapter applies to all cities, including charter cities.
SECTION 1.Section 5600 of the Civil Code is amended to read:5600.(a)Except as provided in Section 5605, the association shall levy regular assessments and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and this part.(b)An association may not impose or collect an assessment or fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied.(a)Except as provided in Section 5605, the association shall levy regular assessments and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and this act. part.
(b)An association shall may not impose or collect an assessment or fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 20, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 591, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 20, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2018 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 7, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 26). |
| Jun 20, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 7, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on T. & H. and JUD. |
| May 25, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 25, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 24, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 23, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 3.) (May 23). |
| May 14, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 10, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 9, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 24, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 5, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2018 | AB 2873 LOW Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 29, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2873 Low By Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2018 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | AB 2873 LOW Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2018 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2873
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:August 24, 2018
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 60-4 | (May 25, 2018) | SENATE: | 39-0 | (August 29, 2018) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Ensures that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from allowing any vehicle on the road that is subject to a manufacturer's safety recall, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a personal vehicle sharing program from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as defined in Vehicle Code Section 11752(b), until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) pursuant to the Code of Federal Regulations Title 49, Section 573.15.
- Requires the prohibition in 1), above, to be carried out subject to one of the following deadlines:
- As soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the NHTSA recall database; or
- Not more than 48 hours after the personal vehicle sharing program receives notification of a manufacturer's recall by a third party with which the personal vehicle sharing program contracts to provide notification of active recalls.
- Defines "personal vehicle sharing program", for the purpose of the above rules, to have the same meaning as defined in Insurance Code Section 11580.24.
- Clarifies that existing law shall not create any legal duty upon the personal vehicle sharing program related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the personal vehicle sharing program obtained the recall database report pursuant to Vehicle Code Sections 11754 and 11758.
- Clarifies that none of the changes made by this bill to Vehicle Code Sections 11754 and 11760 shall apply in any manner to pending litigation.
- Clarifies that nothing in Vehicle Code Sections 11754 and 11760 of this bill shall affect the determination of whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program.
The Senate amendments:
- Clarify when, depending on certain conditions, a PVSP must begin to prohibit facilitation or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as specified.
- Clarify that existing law creates no legal duty for PVSPs related to the accuracy of recall database reports, or to provide information added to a recall database after a PVSP obtains such a report.
- Clarify that changes made by this bill do not affect whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS: This bill provides that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs), as currently defined under the Insurance Code, are prohibited from facilitating transportation with any vehicles that are subject to a manufacturer's safety recall, subject to certain timelines. This aligns them more closely with existing recall laws that prohibit auto dealers and rental car companies from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent any vehicle subject to a manufacturer's recall.
Background on private vehicle sharing programs. In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), Chapter 454, Statutes of 2010, which for the first time established "personal vehicle sharing programs" in the law. AB 1871 defined the term to mean "a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state." (Insurance Code Section 11580.24 (b).) "Private passenger motor vehicle" was defined to mean a vehicle having at least 4 wheels that is insured, or is subject to being insured, under a personal automobile liability insurance policy insuring a single individual or individuals residing in the same household, as the named insured, except as provided
As befitting a bill that enacted provisions solely within the Insurance Code, AB 1871 provided a number of detailed insurance and liability parameters that, at least in principle, define what it means to be a PVSP. Among other things, Insurance Code Section 11580.24 provides that:
- No vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified. In other words, as a condition of participating in a PVSP with a vehicle not classified for commercial insurance, the vehicle owner must not be making a profit by sharing the car through the PVSP.
- A PVSP must provide liability insurance for private vehicles when used by drivers other than the owner in amounts equal to or greater than what the owner maintains, but in no event less than three times the amount required by the Financial Responsibility Law.
- In the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes.
- The PVSP is required to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle's private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle's owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
Safety recall provisions. Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that "[g]enerally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that: (1) poses a risk to motor vehicle safety; and (2) may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture." (See Motor Vehicle Defects and Safety Recalls: What Every Vehicle Owner Should Know, Untied States Department of Transportation. Available at: http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm.)
In December 2015, Congress passed and the President signed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America's Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act). The measure included a provision that prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall. Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a large gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature approved and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon), Chapter 682, Statutes of 2016, which sought to close the loophole for entities with fewer than 35 vehicles. As enacted, the law prohibits a rental car company or car dealer from renting or loaning any vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall, and to do so no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer's recall, or sooner if practicable.
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS) points out, however, that vehicles rented out through a PVSP are likely falling through the cracks of AB 287 because the law only applies to car dealers and rental car companies on its face, and consequently, there may be dangerous vehicles on the road right now subject to recall. Accordingly, this bill seeks to close the loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, until after any recall notices for that vehicle no longer appear in the recall database provided by the NHTSA (pursuant to Code of Federal Regulations Title 49, Section 573.15).
Recent amendments clarify that PVSPs must take action to prohibit these cars on the road either: 1) as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's recall, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the NHTSA recall database; or 2) not more than 48 hours after PVSP receives notification of a manufacturer's recall by a third party with which the PVSP contracts to provide notification of active recalls. These amendments recognize that some PVSPs may seek to comply with this bill by contracting with a third party company that receives manufacturer recall notices directly from the manufacturer and then relays this data to the PVSP for a fee. Recent amendments also clarify that existing law shall not create any legal duty upon the PVSP related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report, or any legal duty to provide information added to a recall database after the PVSP obtained the recall database report pursuant to the Vehicle Code.
Preventing interference with pending litigation. There is a robust debate about whether companies such as TURO are more appropriately regulated as rental car companies, rather than as private vehicle sharing programs. The author and TURO, the sponsor of this bill, clearly feel they should not be regulated as such, while rental car companies and organized labor unions who oppose or formerly opposed this bill clearly believe they should be. According to the author:
Since the passage of the original California law, as Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs (PVSP) have grown in popularity as hosted platforms, some entities within the state have sought to re-characterize PVSPs as rental car agencies and subject PVSPs to the rental car laws regarding fleets. The author believes that TURO is a completely different model that uses a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car-sharing, therefore are not the same. TURO does not own any of the cars or control the people using the platform.
At the time this bill was introduced, there was pending litigation in San Francisco Superior Court on the exact issue of whether TURO is subject to regulation as a rental car company. (People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., Case No. CGC-18-563803, filed Jan. 24, 2018.) In an effort to ensure that this bill does not interfere with pending litigation, the bill clarifies that specified changes to the Vehicle Code made by this bill shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation, and furthermore do not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing program. It should be noted that although proposed Section 11754(e) states "whether or not a company is a personal vehicle sharing company," that appears to be a drafting oversight as PVSP is the correct term and "personal vehicle sharing company" is an undefined term.
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0005063 FN:
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2873
:
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 13-0, 6/19/18
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Dodd, Gaines, Galgiani, McGuire, Morrell, Roth, Skinner, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wiener
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/26/18
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-4, 5/25/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Turo
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a recalled vehicle, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle is subject to a recall, or not more than 48 hours after receiving notification of a recall by a third party.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/24/18 (1) specify that a PVSP shall not facilitate for transportation with a recalled vehicle, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after a vehicle has been subject to a manufacturer’s recall or not more than 48 hours after the PVSP receives notice of a manufacturer’s recall by a third party; (2) add PVSPs to the list of entities that are not liable for the accuracy of the recall database report, or for providing information to the recall database; (3) clarify that changes made in this bill shall not apply to pending litigation; and (4) shall not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or PVSP.
Existing law:
- Defines personal vehicle sharing as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a PVSP.
- Defines a PVSP as a legal entity qualified to do business in the state engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that: (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified.
- Provides that a PVSP shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the PVSP, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the PVSP shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles.
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP.
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
- Requires the PVSP to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP.
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to certain provisions of federal law, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to the federal law, as specified.
This bill:
- Prohibits a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle, as soon as practicable but not more than 48 hours after the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by NHTSA, or not more than 48 hours after the PVSP receives notification of a manufacturer’s recall by a third party with which the PVSP contracts to provide notification of active recalls, until the vehicle no longer appears in the recall database provided by NHTSA.
- Defines PVSP to have the same meaning as defined in the Insurance Code.
- Includes PVSPs with dealers and rental car companies, which do not have legal duty upon them related to the accuracy, errors, or omissions contained in a recall database report or to provide information added to a recall database after the report is obtained.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill shall apply in any manner to pending litigation and the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company, or a personal vehicle sharing program.
Comments
- Purpose. The author states that various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car; however there are no protections for the consumer to ensure that these vehicles are not under a current recall. This bill closes a loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- What are PVSPs? In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones, Chapter 455, Statutes of 2010), which established PVSPs in the law and a number of insurance and liability parameters for the PVSPs. PVSPs provide a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car sharing. Car owners use the platform to offer their cars for rent, while car renters use it to shop for a vehicle to rent. The PVSPs make money through fees and taking a cut of the rental price. PVSPs provide car owners the opportunity to make money off the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit, and provide users generally cheaper prices to rent a car. These companies have been dubbed the ‘AirBnB’ for cars.[1] One of the popular PVSPs operating in the US is Turo, a co-sponsor of this bill.
- Increasing Number of Vehicle Recalls. Manufacturer recalls occur when a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or if there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. In 2016, there were more than 53.2 million passenger vehicles recalled, the highest ever in the United States, and the third straight year of more than 50 million recalled vehicles.[2] This increase has been in part because of the effort by the federal government to replace defective Takata air bag inflators, which has killed 15 people and injured 250 people in the United States.[3] However, not enough recalled vehicles are getting fixed. It is estimated that there are approximately 57 million vehicles under recall on the road, for various reasons, which is ~ 20% of all vehicles in the US.[4]
- Closing a Loophole. In December 2015, the federal government passed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act. The measure included a provision (the Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, named after two young women, who were killed by an unrepaired recalled rental car), which prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2016), which extended the prohibition on renting, loaning, selling of recalled vehicles to rental car companies with fewer than 35 vehicles in the state. This bill would extend similar requirements to PVSPs.
- Different Requirements for PVSPs. Existing federal and state laws prohibit rental car companies from renting, loaning, or selling recalled vehicles as soon as practical, or not more than 48 hours after receiving the safety recall notice. However, unlike rental car companies, PVSPs don’t own the vehicles on their platform. Therefore, PVSPs do not receive the recall notices and do not have to perform the necessary repairs. In order to find out about any recalled vehicles on their platform, PVSPs would have to constantly check the NHTSA database for all of their vehicles, or contract with a third party that would provide notice of any active recalls on their vehicles. In consideration of these issues, this bill prohibits a PVSP from using a recalled vehicle, as soon as practicable, but no later than 48 hours after a vehicle has been recalled, or no later than 48 hours after the PVSP has received notice from a third-party that it has contracted to provide notification of active recalls.
- Ongoing Debate. Currently, there is ongoing debate and litigation over whether or not PVSPs should just be regulated as rental car companies, and thus subject to all of the existing law that governs rental car companies, such as the law for recalled vehicles. However, while this debate is unresolved, it would be prudent through this bill to protect consumers by specifically prohibiting PVSPs from facilitating the renting of recalled vehicles on their platforms.
This bill also, in order to avoid interfering with this debate and the ongoing legal case[5], specifically provides that the bill shall not affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company or a PVSP, and shall not interfere with pending litigation concerning PVSPs.
AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2015) prohibited a dealer or rental company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall until a vehicle has been repaired, except as specified.
AB 1871 (Jones, Chapter 454, Statutes of 2010) established personal vehicle sharing programs and provided insurance and liability parameters for PVSPs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (co-source)
Turo (co-source)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
CALPIRG
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Watchdog
Internet Association
Sacramento Cares
Technet
The Safety Institute
The Trauma Foundation
1 individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/24/18)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-4, 5/25/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Voepel, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Caballero, Friedman, Gonzalez Fletcher, Kamlager-Dove
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Arambula, Bonta, Brough, Choi, Chu, Levine, Limón, Mullin, Nazarian, Steinorth, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron
8/27/18 18:53:26
**** END ****
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2018/03/30/airbnb-for-cars-is-here-and-the-rental-car-giants-are-not-happy/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.bb8f58015b74 ↑
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-autos-recall-idUSKBN16H27A ↑
https://www.nhtsa.gov/equipment/takata-recall-spotlight ↑
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/carfax-57-million-vehicles-on-us-roads-have-open-recalls-300618100.html ↑
https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/SF-sues-Turo-for-not-having-airport-permits-12522534.php ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2873
:
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 13-0, 6/19/18
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Dodd, Gaines, Galgiani, McGuire, Morrell, Roth, Skinner, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wiener
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/26/18
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-4, 5/25/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Turo
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation any vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, as specified.
Existing law:
- Defines personal vehicle sharing as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a PVSP.
- Defines a PVSP as a legal entity qualified to do business in the state engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that: (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified.
- Provides that a PVSP shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the PVSP, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the PVSP shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles.
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP.
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
- Requires the PVSP to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP.
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to certain provisions of federal law, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to the federal law, as specified.
This bill:
- Prohibits a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
- Defines PVSP to have the same meaning as defined in the Insurance Code.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill shall apply in any manner to pending litigation.
Comments
- Purpose. The author states that various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car; however there are no protections for the consumer to ensure that these vehicles are not under a current recall. This bill closes a loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- What are PVSPs? In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), which established PVSPs in the law and a number of insurance and liability parameters for the PVSPs. PVSPs provide a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car sharing. Car owners use the platform to offer their cars for rent, while car renters use it to shop for a vehicle to rent. The PVSPs make money through fees and taking a cut of the rental price. PVSPs provide car owners the opportunity to make money off the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit, and provide users generally cheaper prices to rent a car. These companies have been dubbed the ‘AirBnB’ for cars.[1] One of the popular PVSPs operating in the US is Turo, a co-sponsor of this bill.
- Increasing Number of Vehicle Recalls. Manufacturer recalls occur when a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or if there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. In 2016, there were more than 53.2 million passenger vehicles recalled, the highest ever in the United States, and the third straight year of more than 50 million recalled vehicles.[2] This increase has been in part because of the effort by the federal government to replace defective Takata air bag inflators, which has killed 15 people and injured 250 people in the United States.[3] However, not enough recalled vehicles are getting fixed. It is estimated that there are approximately 57 million vehicles under recall on the road, for various reasons, which is ~ 20% of all vehicles in the US.[4]
- Closing a Loophole. In December 2015, the federal government passed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act. The measure included a provision (the Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, named after two young women, who were killed by an unrepaired recalled rental car), which prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2016), which extended the prohibition on renting, loaning, selling of recalled vehicles to rental car companies with fewer than 35 vehicles in the state. This bill closes this gap for PVSPs as well.
- Proxy Debate. Currently, there is robust debate and litigation over whether or not PVSPs should just be regulated as rental car companies. This bill has become a proxy for this debate. The opposition contests whether it is necessary to have this bill apply a safety recall provision to PVSPs, when it could be accomplished by regulating PVSPs like rental car companies and thus applying the existing law to PVSPs. However, while this debate is ongoing, it would be prudent to protect consumers through this bill by prohibiting PVSPs from facilitating the renting of recalled vehicles on their platforms.
- Stricter Provision than for Rental Cars. Currently, existing federal and state laws prohibit rental car companies from renting, loaning, or selling recalled vehicles as soon as practical, or at most 48 hours of receiving the safety recall notice. This bill gives PVSPs in the state no time window for compliance. PVSPs differ from rental car companies in some respect regarding safety recalls, since they don’t own the vehicles. Therefore, they do not receive the safety recall notices, or perform the necessary safety recall repairs. Under this bill, PVSPs would have to check in real-time if any of their vehicles are under recall, so that they can be grounded and removed off of their platform immediately. This could potentially be another avenue through which some vehicle owners are alerted that their vehicle is under recall and needs to be fixed.
- Avoiding Litigation. In an effort to ensure that this bill does not interfere with pending litigation concerning PVSPs[5], the bill specifies that the changes to the Vehicle Code made by this bill “shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.”
AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2015) prohibited a dealer or rental company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall until a vehicle has been repaired, except as specified.
AB 1871 (Jones, Chapter 454, Statutes of 2010) established personal vehicle sharing programs and provided insurance and liability parameters for PVSPs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (co-source)
Turo (co-source)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
CALPIRG
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Watchdog
Internet Association
Sacramento Cares
Technet
The Safety Institute
The Trauma Foundation
1 individual
California Teamsters
California Labor Federation
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety writes that the bill “will expand the existing safety protections in federal and state law that applies to rental car companies, regarding the performance of safety recalls, to include Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs (PVSPs), as currently defined in California’s Insurance Code... The bill is a very narrowly crafted measure that focuses solely on the safety recall issue… and is an important step forward in improving auto safety.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, the California Teamsters writes that the bill’s “main purpose is to set personal vehicle sharing businesses apart in statute from what they really are, rental car companies. [This bill] would subject so called personal vehicle sharing companies to rules meant to ensure they are not rented if the vehicle is subject to a recall. Sounds good, but the problem is that rental car companies are already subject to those rules… [This bill] is the statutory equivalent of a stamp of approval that these entities are not rental car companies even though their business is to rent cars”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-4, 5/25/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Baker, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gray, Grayson, Harper, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Voepel, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Caballero, Friedman, Gonzalez Fletcher, Kamlager-Dove
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Arambula, Bonta, Brough, Choi, Chu, Levine, Limón, Mullin, Nazarian, Steinorth, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron
8/8/18 10:48:08
**** END ****
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2018/03/30/airbnb-for-cars-is-here-and-the-rental-car-giants-are-not-happy/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.bb8f58015b74 ↑
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-autos-recall-idUSKBN16H27A ↑
https://www.nhtsa.gov/equipment/takata-recall-spotlight ↑
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/carfax-57-million-vehicles-on-us-roads-have-open-recalls-300618100.html ↑
https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/SF-sues-Turo-for-not-having-airport-permits-12522534.php ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2873 (Author:Low)
Version: May 10, 2018
Hearing Date: June 26, 2018
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Personal vehicle sharing: recalled vehicles
DESCRIPTION
This bill would prohibit a personal vehicle sharing program from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
BACKGROUND
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has the authority under federal law to issue vehicle safety standards and to require manufacturers to recall vehicles that have safety defects or do not meet safety standards. If a safety defect is identified, manufacturers are required to notify the NHTSA, owners, dealers and distributors, and, correct the defect at no change (unless the vehicle is more than 10 years old). Concerns have been raised in the past about the risks of purchasing or renting a car subject to a safety recall and, as a result, steps that could be taken to reduce those risks.
As an example of the serious risks posed by safety recalls, a 2012 article published on Edmunds.com entitled “Recalled but Unrepaired Cars Are a Safety Risk to Consumers,” reported:
In April 2009, General Motors [(GM)] began sending registered letters to owners of more than 1.4 million of its cars equipped with 3.8-liter V6 engines, notifying them of a recall for 1997-2003 V6-equipped Chevrolets, Buicks, Oldsmobiles and Pontiacs to address a potential engine fire hazard. The previous year, the company had sent letters to owners of 207,000 Buicks and Pontiacs with turbocharged versions of the same engine for the same problem.
By the time the 2009 recall was issued, there had been reports filed with the [NHTSA] of almost 250 fires in such cars. The problem was thought to be caused by oil that had spilled or leaked onto heated exhaust manifold surfaces. In some cases, the oil caught fire and the flames spread to plastic parts, including the spark plug wiring channel and the upper intake manifolds and engine covers.
As almost all car-fire warnings do, the letters also urged owners not to park the cars in their garages or near homes or other flammable structures until the recall work had been completed. But not every owner of a fire-prone GM vehicle has seen that letter. Although the rate of incidents is steadily declining, there have been at least 250 additional engine fires since the recall was announced three years ago, according to reports filed with NHTSA.
In many cases, the owners of the burned-up cars said they were not aware that there had been a recall. Most had purchased the vehicles used. Many didn’t know if the required repair work had ever been done. Some of the cars that were parked in garages are believed in several cases to have caused structural damage or damage to other vehicles as flames spread.
(John O’Dell, Recalled But Unrepaired Cars Are a Safety Risk to Consumers, Edmunds (August 20, 2014) <http://www.edmunds.com/ car-safety/recalled-but-unrepaired- cars-are-a-safety-risk-to-consumers.html> [as of June 10, 2018].)
In response to concerns about unrepaired recalled vehicles, AB 287 (Gordon, Ch. 682, Stats. 2016) was passed into law. It established the Consumer Automobile Recall and Safety Act (CARS Act). (Veh. Code Sec. 11750 et seq.) The CARS Act restricted the loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent of a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall until the recall repair has been made.
SB 1871 (Jones, Ch. 454, Stats. 2010) established a legal framework for “personal vehicle sharing programs.” These programs are legal entities qualified to do business in the State of California that are engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state. Pursuant to these programs, individuals can “share” their cars with others under a regulatory structure set up by SB 1871.
This bill would now extend restrictions on the use of recalled vehicles in these personal vehicle sharing programs.
This bill passed out of the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee on a vote of 13-0.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law establishes the Consumer Automobile Recall and Safety Act (CARS Act). (Veh. Code Sec. 11750 et seq.)
Existing law, the CARS Act, provides that no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made. However, if a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired. (Veh. Code Sec. 11754.)
Existing law defines, for purposes of the CARS Act, a “rental car company” as a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California. A “manufacturer’s recall” is defined to mean a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code. (Veh. Code Sec. 11752 (b).)
Existing law defines a “personal vehicle sharing program” as a legal entity qualified to do business in the State of California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state. “Private passenger motor vehicle” is defined as a vehicle that is insured, or is subject to being insured, under a personal automobile liability insurance policy insuring a single individual or individuals residing in the same household, as the named insured, or meets the requirements of Section 16058 of the Vehicle Code, but does not include a vehicle with fewer than four wheels. “Personal vehicle sharing” means the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a personal vehicle sharing program. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(b).)
Existing law provides that no private passenger motor vehicle insured by its owner pursuant to a policy of insurance, as specified, shall be classified as a commercial vehicle, for-hire vehicle, permissive use vehicle, or livery solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing as long as all of the following circumstances apply:
- the personal vehicle sharing is conducted pursuant to a personal vehicle sharing program;
- the annual revenue received by the vehicle’s owner which was generated by the personal vehicle sharing of the vehicle does not exceed the annual expenses of owning and operating the vehicle, as specified; and
- the owner of the private passenger motor vehicle does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use, as defined, by a personal vehicle sharing user while engaged in personal vehicle sharing. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(a).)
Existing law establishes certain insurance coverage and liability requirements for personal vehicle sharing programs for each vehicle they facilitate the use of. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24.)
This bill would provide that a “personal vehicle sharing program” has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
This bill would provide that a personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
This bill would provide that these changes to the CARS Act do not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Access to an automobile is still necessary in many communities in California, as public transit doesn’t reach everywhere and some tasks cannot be completed using transit. Various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car; however there are no protections for the consumer to ensure that these vehicles are not under a current recall. AB 2873 closes a loophole by prohibiting a Personal Vehicle Sharing Program (PVSP) from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
2. Applying the CARS Act to personal vehicle sharing programs
Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that “[g]enerally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that: (1) poses a risk to motor vehicle safety; and (2) may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture.” Sample defects provided by the NHTSA include steering components that break and cause a loss of control, problems with fuel system components that may cause vehicle fires, accelerator controls that may stick, and child safety seats that contain defective safety belts that create a risk of injury. (See Motor Vehicle Defects and Safety Recalls: What Every Vehicle Owner Should Know, U.S. Department of Transportation <http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm> [as of June 11, 2018].)
The CARS Act establishes certain requirements before a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall can be loaned or rented. This bill would place similar requirements on personal vehicle sharing programs. In fact, as pointed out by Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety, these new provisions would provide more thorough consumer protection because they would place an affirmative requirement on these programs to monitor all of their vehicles for recalls. Existing provisions are triggered upon receipt of a recall notice and afford a 48-hour window.
3. The underlying legal battle
Behind the plain language of this bill is an ongoing legal fight over whether certain companies, such as Turo, a co-sponsor of this bill, should be regulated solely as private vehicle sharing programs or as rental car companies. Various stakeholders, including local governments, rental car companies, and labor groups, believe that Turo should be classified as rental car companies and should have to play by the same set of rules. Turo, and other technology groups, fight such a classification, and the attendant regulations.
Earlier this year, the City Attorney of San Francisco brought suit against Turo on behalf of the People of the State of California. The suit, in relevant part, alleges that Turo is unlawfully and unfairly operating a rental car business at the San Francisco International Airport without obtaining the proper permits. Turo vehemently disagrees with being categorized as a rental car company and argues it is a personal vehicle sharing program that should not be subject to laws in the state regulating rental car companies.
This ambiguity presents some clear concerns. In addition to the issues underlying the litigation mentioned above, Turo offers services that appear to provide for the geolocation of vehicles while they are being rented. (Turo, Introducing Turo Go <https://explore.turo.com/turo-go-announce/> [as of June 20, 2018].) The use of electronic surveillance by rental car companies is strictly limited. (See Civ. Code Sec. 1939.23.)
Because existing provisions regarding recalled vehicles already apply to rental car companies, many argue this bill is unnecessary as they contend PVSPs are in fact rental car companies. To avoid interfering with this debate and the still ongoing legal case, this bill would specifically provide that it does not apply in any manner to pending litigation.” Therefore, the legal determinations resulting from the case will not be affected by subjecting PVSPs to the recall laws pursuant to the CARS Act, even though rental car companies are already subject to the CARS Act.
This bill is not intended to and would not affect the legal classification of companies such as Turo. Therefore, PVSPs, including Turo, could still be classified as rental car companies despite this bill’s provisions. To ensure ultimate clarity, the author may wish to consider including a provision in the bill that specifically states that nothing therein should be construed to affect the determination of whether or not a company is a rental car company.
Support: Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers; CALPIRG; Center for Auto Safety; Consumer Action; Consumer Watchdog; Sacramento CARES; The Safety Institute; The Trauma Foundation; One individual
Opposition: California Labor Federation; California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
HISTORY
Source: Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety; Turo, Inc.
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
AB 287 (Gordon, Ch. 682, Stats. 2016) See Background.
SB 686 (Jackson, 2013) would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling, leasing, renting, loaning, or otherwise transferring ownership of a used vehicle if the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, unless the repairs required to correct the defect have been performed. This bill died in the Assembly Business, Professions and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 964 (Bonta, 2013) would have included manufacturer’s safety recalls on the list of prohibited conditions for certified vehicles. This bill also would have added a required pre-sale disclosure for all used vehicles regarding manufacturer’s recalls and the other safety and warranty issues. This bill died on the Assembly Floor inactive file.
Prior Vote:
Senate Transportation and Housing Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 60, Noes 4)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 3)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 6/19/2018
Author: | Low | ||
Version: | 5/10/2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jeffery Song | ||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill ensures that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation any vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines personal vehicle sharing as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a PVSP.
- Defines a PVSP as a legal entity qualified to do business in the state engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that: (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified.
- Provides that a PVSP shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the PVSP, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the PVSP shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles.
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP.
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
- Requires the PVSP to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP.
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to certain provisions of federal law, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to the federal law, as specified.
This bill:
- Prohibits a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
- Defines PVSP to have the same meaning as defined in the Insurance Code.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill shall apply in any manner to pending legislation.
COMMENTS
- Purpose. The author states that various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car; however there are no protections for the consumer to ensure that these vehicles are not under a current recall. This bill closes a loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs. In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), which established PVSPs in the law and a number of insurance and liability parameters for the PVSPs. PVSPs provide a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car sharing. Car owners use the platform to offer their cars for rent, while car renters use it to shop for a vehicle to rent. The PVSPs make money through fees and taking a cut of the rental price. PVSPs provide car owners the opportunity to make money off the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit, and provide users generally cheaper prices to rent a car. These companies have been dubbed the ‘AirBnB’ for cars.[1] One of the popular PVSPs operating in the US is Turo, a co-sponsor of this bill.
- Number of Vehicle Recalls Increasing. Manufacturer recalls occur when a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or if there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. In 2016, there were more than 53.2 million passenger vehicles recalled, the highest ever in the United States, and the third straight year of more than 50 million recalled vehicles.[2] This increase has been in part because of the effort by the federal government to replace defective Takata air bag inflators, which has killed 15 people and injured 250 people in the United States.[3] However, not enough recalled vehicles are getting fixed. It is estimated that there are approximately 57 million vehicles under recall on the road, for various reasons, which is ~ 20% of all vehicles in the US.[4]
- Closing a Loophole. In December 2015, the federal government passed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act. The measure included a provision (the Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, named after two young women, who were killed by an unrepaired recalled rental car), which prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon, 2016), which extended the prohibition on renting, loaning, selling of recalled vehicles to rental car companies with fewer than 35 vehicles in the state. This bill closes this gap for PVSPs as well.
- Proxy Argument. Currently, there is a robust debate over whether or not PVSPs should be regulated as rental car companies. The author and PVSPs feel they should not be defined as rental car companies, while rental car companies and organized labor unions do. This bill has become a proxy for this argument. The opposition contests whether it is necessary to have this bill apply a safety recall provision to PVSPs, when it could be accomplished by regulating PVSPs like rental car companies and thus applying the existing law to PVSPs. However, as this debate is ongoing, it would be prudent to protect consumers through this bill by prohibiting PVSPs from facilitating the renting of recalled vehicles on their platform.
- Stricter Provision than Rental Cars. Currently, existing federal and state laws prohibit rental car companies from renting, loaning, or selling recalled vehicles as soon as practical, or at most 48 hours of receiving the safety recall notice. This bill gives PVSPs in the state no time window for compliance. PVSPs differ from rental car companies in some respect regarding safety recalls, since they don’t own the vehicles. Therefore, they do not receive the safety recall notices, or perform the necessary safety recall repairs. Under this bill, PVSPs would have to check in real-time if any of their vehicles are under recall, so that they can be grounded and removed off of their platform immediately. This could potentially be an avenue through which some vehicle owners are alerted that their vehicle is under recall and needs to be fixed.
- Avoiding Litigation. In an effort to ensure that this bill does not interfere with pending litigation concerning PVSPs[5], the bill specifies that the changes to the Vehicle Code made by this bill “shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.”
- Double Referral. This bill has also been referred to the Judiciary Committee.
Related Legislation:
AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2015) — prohibited a dealer or rental company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall until a vehicle has been repaired, except as specified.
AB 1871 (Jones, Chapter 454, Statutes of 2010) — established personal vehicle sharing programs and provided insurance and liability parameters for PVSPs.
Assembly Votes:
Floor 60-4
Approps 13-3
Privacy 9-0
Judiciary 9-0
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
6/13/2018.)
SUPPORT:
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (co-sponsor)
Turo (co-sponsor)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
CALPIRG
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Watchdog
Internet Association
Sacramento Cares
Technet
The Safety Institute
The Trauma Foundation
1 individual
OPPOSITION:
California Teamsters
-- END --
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2018/03/30/airbnb-for-cars-is-here-and-the-rental-car-giants-are-not-happy/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.bb8f58015b74 ↑
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-autos-recall-idUSKBN16H27A ↑
https://www.nhtsa.gov/equipment/takata-recall-spotlight ↑
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/carfax-57-million-vehicles-on-us-roads-have-open-recalls-300618100.html ↑
https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/SF-sues-Turo-for-not-having-airport-permits-12522534.php ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 6/19/2018
Author: | Low | ||
Version: | 5/10/2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jeffery Song | ||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill ensures that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation any vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines personal vehicle sharing as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a PVSP.
- Defines a PVSP as a legal entity qualified to do business in the state engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that: (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified.
- Provides that a PVSP shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the PVSP, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the PVSP shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles.
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP.
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
- Requires the PVSP to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP.
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to certain provisions of federal law, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to the federal law, as specified.
This bill:
- Prohibits a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
- Defines PVSP to have the same meaning as defined in the Insurance Code.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill shall apply in any manner to pending legislation.
COMMENTS
- Purpose. The author states that various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car; however there are no protections for the consumer to ensure that these vehicles are not under a current recall. This bill closes a loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer’s recall.
- Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs. In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), which established PVSPs in the law and a number of insurance and liability parameters for the PVSPs. PVSPs provide a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car sharing. Car owners use the platform to offer their cars for rent, while car renters use it to shop for a vehicle to rent. The PVSPs make money through fees and taking a cut of the rental price. PVSPs provide car owners the opportunity to make money off the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit, and provide users generally cheaper prices to rent a car. These companies have been dubbed the ‘AirBnB’ for cars.[1] One of the popular PVSPs operating in the US is Turo, a co-sponsor of this bill.
- Number of Vehicle Recalls Increasing. Manufacturer recalls occur when a motor vehicle or motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or if there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. In 2016, there were more than 53.2 million passenger vehicles recalled, the highest ever in the United States, and the third straight year of more than 50 million recalled vehicles.[2] This increase has been in part because of the effort by the federal government to replace defective Takata air bag inflators, which has killed 15 people and injured 250 people in the United States.[3] However, not enough recalled vehicles are getting fixed. It is estimated that there are approximately 57 million vehicles under recall on the road, for various reasons, which is ~ 20% of all vehicles in the US.[4]
- Closing a Loophole. In December 2015, the federal government passed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act. The measure included a provision (the Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, named after two young women, who were killed by an unrepaired recalled rental car), which prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon, 2016), which extended the prohibition on renting, loaning, selling of recalled vehicles to rental car companies with fewer than 35 vehicles in the state. This bill closes this gap for PVSPs as well.
- Proxy Argument. Currently, there is a robust debate over whether or not PVSPs should be regulated as rental car companies. The author and PVSPs feel they should not be defined as rental car companies, while rental car companies and organized labor unions do. This bill has become a proxy for this argument. The opposition contests whether it is necessary to have this bill apply a safety recall provision to PVSPs, when it could be accomplished by regulating PVSPs like rental car companies and thus applying the existing law to PVSPs. However, as this debate is ongoing, it would be prudent to protect consumers through this bill by prohibiting PVSPs from facilitating the renting of recalled vehicles on their platform.
- Stricter Provision than Rental Cars. Currently, existing federal and state laws prohibit rental car companies from renting, loaning, or selling recalled vehicles as soon as practical, or at most 48 hours of receiving the safety recall notice. This bill gives PVSPs in the state no time window for compliance. PVSPs differ from rental car companies in some respect regarding safety recalls, since they don’t own the vehicles. Therefore, they do not receive the safety recall notices, or perform the necessary safety recall repairs. Under this bill, PVSPs would have to check in real-time if any of their vehicles are under recall, so that they can be grounded and removed off of their platform immediately. This could potentially be an avenue through which some vehicle owners are alerted that their vehicle is under recall and needs to be fixed.
- Avoiding Litigation. In an effort to ensure that this bill does not interfere with pending litigation concerning PVSPs[5], the bill specifies that the changes to the Vehicle Code made by this bill “shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.”
Related Legislation:
AB 287 (Gordon, Chapter 682, Statutes of 2015) — prohibited a dealer or rental company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to a manufacturer’s recall until a vehicle has been repaired, except as specified.
AB 1871 (Jones, Chapter 454, Statutes of 2010) — established personal vehicle sharing programs and provided insurance and liability parameters for PVSPs.
Assembly Votes:
Floor 60-4
Approps 13-3
Privacy 9-0
Judiciary 9-0
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
6/13/2018.)
SUPPORT:
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
CALPIRG
Center for Auto Safety
Consumer Action
Consumer Watchdog
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (sponsor)
Internet Association
Sacramento Cares
Technet
The Safety Institute
The Trauma Foundation
Turo
1 individual
OPPOSITION:
California Teamsters
-- END --
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/innovations/wp/2018/03/30/airbnb-for-cars-is-here-and-the-rental-car-giants-are-not-happy/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.bb8f58015b74 ↑
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-autos-recall-idUSKBN16H27A ↑
https://www.nhtsa.gov/equipment/takata-recall-spotlight ↑
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/carfax-57-million-vehicles-on-us-roads-have-open-recalls-300618100.html ↑
https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/SF-sues-Turo-for-not-having-airport-permits-12522534.php ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2873
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Cunningham, Chiu, Weber, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Reyes | |
Privacy | 9-0 | Chau, Kiley, Baker, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting | |
Appropriations | 13-3 | Bigelow, Bloom, Mathis, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Fong, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Obernolte, Reyes | Gonzalez Fletcher, Friedman, Quirk |
SUMMARY: Ensures that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from allowing any vehicle on the road that is subject to a manufacturer's safety recall, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a personal vehicle sharing program from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall as defined in the Vehicle Code, Section 11752 subdivision (b), and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to the Code of Federal Regulations Title 49 Section 573.15.
- Defines "personal vehicle sharing program", for the purpose of the above rule, to have the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill shall apply in any manner to pending litigation.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS: This bill provides that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs), as currently defined under the Insurance Code, are prohibited from facilitating transportation with any vehicles that are subject to a manufacturer's safety recall. This aligns them more closely with existing recall laws that prohibit auto dealers and rental car companies from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent any vehicle subject to a manufacturer's recall.
Background on private vehicle sharing programs. In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), Chapter 454 Statutes of 2010, which for the first time established "personal vehicle sharing programs" in the law. AB 1871 defined the term to mean "a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state." (Insurance Code Section 11580.24 (b).) "Private passenger motor vehicle" was defined to mean a vehicle having at least 4 wheels that is insured, or is subject to being insured, under a personal automobile liability insurance policy insuring a single individual or individuals residing in the same household, as the named insured, except as provided
As befitting a bill that enacted provisions solely within the Insurance Code, AB 1871 provided a number of detailed insurance and liability parameters that, at least in principle, define what it means to be a PVSP. Among other things, Insurance Code Section 11580.24 provides that:
- No vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified. In other words, as a condition of participating in a PVSP with a vehicle not classified for commercial insurance, the vehicle owner must not be making a profit by sharing the car through the PVSP.
- A PVSP must provide liability insurance for private vehicles when used by drivers other than the owner in amounts equal to or greater than what the owner maintains, but in no event less than three times the amount required by the Financial Responsibility Law.
- In the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes.
- The PVSP is required to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle's private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle's owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
Safety recall provisions: Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that "[g]enerally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that: (1) poses a risk to motor vehicle safety; and (2) may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture." (See Motor Vehicle Defects and Safety Recalls: What Every Vehicle Owner Should Know, Untied States Department of Transportation. Available at: http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot. gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm.)
In December 2015, Congress passed and the President signed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America's Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act). The measure included a provision that prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall. Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a large gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature approved and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon), Chapter 682, Statutes of 2016, which sought to close the loophole for entities with fewer than 35 vehicles. As enacted, the new law prohibits a rental car company or car dealer from renting or loaning any vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS) points out, however, that vehicles rented out through a PVSP are likely falling through the cracks of AB 287 because the law only applies to car dealers and rental car companies on its face, and consequently, there may be dangerous vehicles on the road right now subject to recall. Recent amendments to this bill seek to close the loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as defined, and when a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the NHTSA (pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations).
Preventing interference with pending litigation. There is a robust debate about whether companies such as TURO are more appropriately regulated as rental car companies, rather than as private vehicle sharing programs. The author and TURO, the sponsor of this bill, clearly feel they should not be regulated as such, while rental car companies and organized labor unions who oppose this bill clearly believe they should be. According to the author:
PVSP companies have been growing in urban areas across the country and a majority of the companies provide short-term rental use of vehicles by drivers who have only minimal need to a personal vehicle, and do not want to incur the expenses associated with owning and maintaining a vehicle. In addition to providing drivers in need of a car, PVSPs also provide car owners an opportunity to be compensated for the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit.
Since the passage of the original California law, as Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs (PVSP) have grown in popularity as hosted platforms, some entities within the state have sought to re-characterize PVSPs as rental car agencies and subject PVSPs to the rental car laws regarding fleets. The author believes that TURO is a completely different model that uses a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car-sharing, therefore are not the same. TURO does not own any of the cars or control the people using the platform.
At the time this bill was introduced, there was pending litigation in San Francisco Superior Court on the exact issue of whether TURO is subject to regulation as a rental car company. (People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., Case No. CGC-18-563803, filed Jan. 24, 2018.)
For the purpose of rules on safety recalls, this bill employs the existing definition of PVSPs, as defined under Insurance Code Section 11580.24, and codifies that use in the Vehicle Code. Opponents of the bill contest whether it is necessary to codify this definition in the Vehicle Code in order to apply the underlying recall provisions to PVSPs; instead they believe that the same can be accomplished simply by regulating PVSPs under the same law that currently applies to rental car companies.
In an effort to ensure that this bill does not interfere with pending litigation, the author has recently amended the bill to clarify that the changes to the Vehicle Code made by this bill "shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation."
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002991
Date of Hearing: May 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2873
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:May 10, 2018
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 9 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a “personal vehicle sharing program,” as defined, from facilitating or arranging for transportation with a vehicle subject to a manufacturers recall. The bill also specifies its provisions shall not apply to pending litigation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Background and purpose. This bill, reasonably, prohibits a personal vehicle sharing program from arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall. There are a number of tragically unfortunate examples associated with the use of such vehicles. For this reason, the prohibition currently applies to car dealers and car rental companies.
Statute defines a “personal vehicle sharing program” as “a legal entity qualified to do business in the State of California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.” This bill references this definition.
Pending litigation is considering whether a given business is, in fact, a rental car company or a personal vehicle sharing program. However, this bill, itself, does not determine whether any given entity should be regulated as a rental car company, a personal vehicle sharing program, or something else altogether.
It may be the case that the determination that an entity is a personal vehicle sharing program, and not a car rental company, reduces state revenues. This is because a personal vehicle sharing program might be subject to fewer state fees than is a car rental company. However, such revenue losses, should they materialize, do not result directly from this bill.
The author has significantly scaled back this bill since its introduction. The author contends it is appropriate to ensure car services of all types do not permit the use of a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturers recall.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2873 (
Author:Low) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2018
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SUBJECT: Personal Vehicle Sharing Act
SUMMARY: This bill would ensure that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from arranging to put any vehicle on the road for transportation purposes that is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall. Specifically, this bill would:
- Prohibit a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a “manufacturer’s recall” as defined under existing law, if the recall was issued for safety reasons, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to federal regulations, as specified.
- Defines “PVSP”, for these purposes, to have the same meaning as defined under the Insurance Code.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “personal vehicle sharing” as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a PVSP. Further defines PVSP to mean a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(b).)
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that: (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(a).)
- Provides that a PVSP shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the PVSP, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the PVSP shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(c)(1).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing in Section 11580.24 limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(d).)
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(f).)
- Requires, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the program to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner. (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(g).)
- Defines “rental company” to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public, and governs the transactions between a rental company and its customers, including, among other provisions, required disclosures by a rental company, mandatory contract provisions for a vehicle rental agreement, restrictions on a rental company’s use of electronic surveillance technology, and authorization for a rental company to collect specific types of fees and charges from its customers. (Civ. Code Sec. 1939.01 et seq.)
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made. (Veh. Code Sec. 11754(a).)
- Defines “rental car company,” for purposes of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California. (Veh. Code Sec. 11752(e).)
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to certain provisions of federal law, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to the federal law, as specified. (Veh. Code Sec. 11752(b); see also 49 U.S.C. Secs. 30118-30120.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: As proposed to be amended, this bill seeks to ensure that PVSPs are subject to manufacturer’s vehicle safety recalls. This bill is sponsored by TURO Inc.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “PVSP companies have been growing in urban areas across the country and a majority of the companies provide short-term rental use of vehicles by drivers who have only minimal need to a personal vehicle, and do not want to incur the expenses associated with owning and maintaining a vehicle. In addition to providing drivers in need of a car, PVSPs also provide car owners an opportunity to be compensated for the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit.
Access to an automobile is still necessary in many areas of California, as public transit doesn’t reach everywhere and some tasks cannot be completed using transit. Various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car.
Since the passage of the original California law, as PVSPs have grown in popularity as hosted platforms, the industry has acknowledged that there are some basic consumer protections that they should follow such as current recall provisions in state law.”
- Personal vehicle sharing programs: In 2010, California enacted AB 1871 (Jones, Ch. 454, Stats. 2010), which established “personal vehicle sharing programs” in the law. AB 1871 defined PVSPs to mean “a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state.” (Ins. Code Sec. 11580.24(b).) “Private passenger motor vehicle” was defined to mean a vehicle having at least four wheels that is insured, or is subject to being insured, under a personal automobile liability insurance policy insuring a single individual or individuals residing in the same household, as the named insured, except as provided.” According to the Assembly Insurance Committee’s analysis of AB 1871 (May 5, 2010), the purpose of the bill was stated as follows:
According to the author, carsharing companies would like to expand their pool of vehicles by taking advantage of privately owned vehicles while they are not in use. However, under current law, if the owner accepted compensation for allowing the vehicle to be used in a vehicle sharing program, an insurer could reclassify the vehicle as a commercial vehicle, and increase the premiums charged to the owner. The bill is designed to enable the carsharing company to enter into agreements with vehicle owners, and ensure that the owner is not disadvantaged. Further, the bill is designed to ensure that the owner’s private passenger automobile insurer is also not disadvantaged when the vehicle is in use by the vehicle sharing program.
AB 1871 provided a number of detailed insurance and liability parameters that, to some degree, define a PVSP under law. Among other things, Section 11580.24 requires that: (1) as a condition of participating in a PVSP with a vehicle not classified for commercial insurance, the vehicle owner must not be making a profit by sharing the car through the PVSP; (2) a PVSP must provide liability insurance for private vehicles when used by drivers other than the owner in amounts equal to or greater than what the owner maintains, as specified; (3) in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person other than the vehicle owner, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes; and (4) the PVSP is required to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss. (Emphasis added.)
The PVSP model is premised on the concept of individual vehicle owners allowing other persons, who they may or may not know, to use their vehicles for a fee which can offset the costs associated with owning the vehicle. Owners are allowed to do so under existing law, as long as they have the type of auto insurance required by PVSPs, as described above, and so long as they do not make more money than it costs to own and operate the vehicle. In stakeholder discussions, TURO expressed that the insurance policies required by the company were generous, with mandatory coverage of nearly all liability situations. Staff notes, however, that the TURO website shows many policy exclusions and instances where primary liability would lie with the renter.
Further, the prevalence of listings found on TURO’s website that appear to represent a single entity renting out a small fleet of vehicles from a commercial location also made it difficult to reconcile with the portrait of TURO as a PVSP where, by law, participants are prohibited from making a profit. In addition, TURO holds itself out to the public as a rental car company with webpages boasting titles such as: “Rent better cars: Choose from thousands of unique cars for rent by local hosts” and “Not your typical rental car: Bypass the rental counter and rent unforgettable cars from friendly locals.” (See <https://turo.com/> [as of April 24, 2018].)
As noted by the author, there is an ongoing debate over whether companies such as TURO are more appropriately regulated as rental car companies, rather than as PVSPs. The author and TURO, the sponsor of this bill, feel they should not be regulated as such, while rental car companies and organized labor unions who oppose this bill clearly believe they should be. Ultimately, this is also currently a matter of litigation before the courts (see People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., Case No. CGC-18-563803, filed Jan. 24, 2018) as discussed in Comment 4 below.
- Amendments accepted in Judiciary Committee seek to address interference with pending litigation and consumer protection issues: As a preliminarily matter, staff notes that this bill was double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee, where it was recently heard on April 24, 2018, and was passed out on a 9-0 vote, with amendments to be taken in this Committee for procedural reasons.
As currently in print, this bill would have interfered with pending litigation and undermined various consumer protections built around rental car vehicles. Specifically, the March 22, 2018 version of this bill would have created a new chapter in the Civil Code for yet-to-be-determined provisions to further regulate PVSPs, would have amended the statute defining rental car companies to expressly state that the definition of “rental company” does not include a PVSP, and would have stated that this change to the rental car definition is “declaratory of existing law.” In support of that March 22, 2018, version, TechNet writes:
California was an early leader in this area when in 2010, Assemblymember Dave
Jones authored AB 1871 to create Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs (PVSP) which
is also known as peer-to-peer carsharing. Rather than shoving new technology into an old framework, the bill specified that a PVSP is an entity that facilitates personal vehicle sharing and provides liability insurance for the private vehicles, collects and maintains verifiable electronic records that identify the date, time and location when a vehicle is being used by a driver who is not the owner, and provides disclosures to the vehicle owner about the law and terms and conditions of the transaction.
AB 2873 builds upon this legislature’s acknowledgement that PVSP is a different technology and service than the traditional rental car company, by statutorily clarifying that PVSP’s remain a separate model than car rental companies and thus should not be defined as a rental car transaction.
Yet, many stakeholders, including representatives from organized labor unions and the rental car company industry argue that that version lacked important consumer protections. In opposition to the March 22, 2018 version of the bill, the American Car Rental Association writes:
AB 2873 is a giant step in the wrong direction from the sound public policy imbedded in California State law that took decades to build.
Car rental customers deserve privacy from unwanted surveillance, accurate rate disclosures, fair contract terms, and most of all safe rental cars.
Car rental companies deserve assurances that all the competitors play by a basic set of rules. California should embrace a marketplace that rewards creativity and ingenuity. But let’s not be deceived – openly flouting rules is not synonymous with creativity and ingenuity.
AB 2873 comes at the expense of rental customers and rental companies alike. It’s special interest legislation that only benefits a narrow band of the car rental industry.
Instead of preserving existing law ensuring customer protection and fair competition within the industry, AB 2873 stacks the deck in favor of wealthy venture capital investors sprinting recklessly toward an IPO with little more than a scofflaw business model and low-fi website.
After much debate and discussion, as proposed to be amended based on amendments taken in the Assembly Judiciary Committee, this bill would now simply require that PVSPs are subject to vehicle safety recall provisions, which currently only apply to car dealers and rental car companies. (See AB 287 (Gordon, Ch. 682, Stats. 2016) which required used car dealers and rental car companies to check for outstanding recalls, and repair the car before transfer. AB 287 passed out of this Committee unanimously.)
The author also agreed, as part of those Assembly Judiciary Committee amendments, to strike the provision that would have declared, as a matter of existing law, that PVSPs are not rental car companies, given that committee’s conclusion that it is “hard to see what this provision is intended to do other than to interfere with pending litigation involving TURO on this precise issue.”
- Further amendments necessary to ensure that this bill does not unduly interfere with pending litigation: As noted in Comment 1, this bill is sponsored by TURO. According to the City Attorney of San Francisco’s website, the current lawsuit against TURO seeks to directly address the issue of whether TURO is indeed a rental car company. (People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., Case No. CGC-18-563803, filed Jan. 24, 2018.) The complaint alleges that TURO’s conduct harms not only its competitors, but also the public, and specifically provides:
- TURO has commercially exploited San Francisco International Airport’s (SFO) roadways and facilities while depriving SFO of fees needed to maintain those facilities for public use.
- TURO’s continued participation in unlawful curbside pickups has contributed to congestion at the terminals and flouted rules designed for the safety and convenience of travelers.
- By actively promoting SFO rental car transactions after the expiration of its permit, TURO has misled both car owners and prospective renters about the lawfulness of such transactions and placed Turo car owners at risk of civil and criminal liability. (Herrera, City Attorney of San Francisco, Herrera takes Turo to court for cheating their competition and SFO (Jan. 24, 2018) <https://www.sfcityattorney.org/2018/01/24/ herrera-takes-turo-court-cheating-competition-sfo/> [as of April 24, 2018].)
By including a paragraph in California’s Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act that would require PVSPs to comply with recall laws, this bill, as proposed to be amended, would arguably distinguish PVSPs from rental cars under that Act. To the extent that such a provision could be used to influence the outcome of People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., consistent with the Legislature’s practice to routinely decline passing legislation that would directly determine the outcome of pending litigation before the judicial branch, this Committee should take utmost care to avoid the passage of legislation that would influence pending litigation.
As a matter of public policy, the Legislature has historically raised concerns about bills which actively interfere with pending litigation to the extent that the effect of the legislation would be to decide a case in favor of one party over another (i.e., resulting in a direct financial windfall to a private party), prevent a court from deciding an action based upon the laws in place at the time the cause of action accrued, or create a situation where the Legislative branch is used to circumvent the discretion and independence of the Judicial branch.
While the Assembly Judiciary Committee amendments have reduced the likelihood of active interference here by removing the “declaratory of existing law” language, and most legislation lacking such language would be interpreted to apply prospectively only, there remains reason to clarify this prospective application even further.
Certainly, staff notes that absent language to the contrary, the courts usually only apply legislation prospectively. The U.S. Supreme Court has previously observed that:
[T]he presumption against retroactive legislation is deeply rooted in our jurisprudence, and embodies a legal doctrine centuries older than our Republic. Elementary considerations of fairness dictate that individuals should have an opportunity to know what the law is and to conform their conduct accordingly; settled expectations should not be lightly disrupted. For that reason, the principle that the legal effect of conduct should ordinarily be assessed under the law that existed when the conduct took place has timeless and universal appeal. (Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244, 265 (internal citations omitted).)
Further, “[a] statute does not operate [retroactively] merely because it is applied in a case arising from conduct antedating the statute’s enactment, or upsets expectations based in prior law. Rather, the court must ask whether the new provision attaches new legal consequences to events completed before its enactment.” (Landgraf, 511 U.S. at 269-70 (internal citations omitted).) “This is not to say,” however, “that a statute may never apply retroactively.” (McClung v. Employment Dev. Dept. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 467, 475.) In California, “[a] statute’s retroactivity is, in the first instance, a policy determination for the Legislature and one to which courts defer absent some constitutional objection to retroactivity.” (Id., at 475.) Under California law, “a statute may be applied retroactively only if it contains express language of retroactivity or if other sources provide a clear and unavoidable implication that the Legislature intended retroactive application.” (Myers v. Philip Morris Companies, Inc. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 828, 844.)
Here, however, given the original intent to declare these practices as distinct from rental cars, and state that distinction to be declaratory of existing law during an active case on the same question of law, it is critical to ensure that there is no confusion or chance that a court would misinterpret this legislation as an attempt by the Legislature to make any sort of statement regarding whether or not these practices should be considered “rental car” in nature or “PVSP” in nature prior to the enactment date of this bill.
Given that the author agrees that the purpose of this bill is to increase consumer protections and not to influence active litigation, the author has agreed to the following clarifying amendments to ensure that the bill, once chaptered, cannot be utilized to influence the outcome in People of the State of California v. Turo Inc. and circumvent the discretion and independence of the judicial branch. Staff notes that the clarifying amendments taken in this Committee are indicated in underline or strikeouts, to be distinguished from those agreed to in the Assembly Judiciary Committee (as indicated in bold, italics), which are also being processed in this Committee due to procedural reasons.
Author’s amendment:
In relevant part, Section 2 of the bill amending Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read: (c) A personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, if the recall was issued for safety reasons, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d) The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
- Additional amendments suggested by Committee to ensure that this is not given a broader effect than what is intended by the Legislature: Further, in order to ensure that this bill is interpreted narrowly, the Committee suggests additional clarifying amendments. Frequently stakeholders use a change in the law, such as the new recall provision this bill would add, and build upon it in future years. Part of the ongoing debate behind this bill is whether TURO-like companies should be regulated as PVSPs, as rental car companies, or under an entirely new statutory scheme narrowly tailored to their specific business model. Any legislation determining that question would arguably be inappropriate this legislative session because of the pending litigation discussed above. That being said, it is the intent of this Committee that AB 2873 be construed narrowly within the Legislature and within practice and in such a way that it would not impact the Legislature’s future consideration of the issue. The language suggested below would preserve the question of whether TURO-type practices should be regulated as rental cars or PVSPs or something entirely new, should another bill be presented to the Legislature in the coming years.
Suggested amendment:
In relevant part, Section 2 of the bill amending Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read: (c) A personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, and a safety recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Nothing in this section shall prevent a personal vehicle sharing program from being deemed a rental company or rental car company pursuant to any other section.
(d) The changes to this section made by the act adding subdivision (c) shall not apply in any manner to pending litigation.
- Related legislation: AB 2246 (Friedman) would incorporate personal vehicle sharing programs into the definition of “rental car company” in assorted sections of the Codes. AB 2246 is currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee. As of the writing of this analysis, that bill does not have a hearing date.
- Prior legislation: AB 287 (Gordon, Ch. 682, Stats. 2016) enacted the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, which would prohibits a dealer or car rental company from loaning, renting, or offering to loan a vehicle is subject to a recall until the repair has been made.
SB 686 (Jackson, 2014) would have prohibited a vehicle dealer from selling a used vehicle if the dealer knew or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer’s safety recall and failed to correct the defect. SB 686 failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 964 (Bonta, 2013) would have prohibited a vehicle from being advertised or sold if the dealer knows or should have known that the vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's safety recall, and would have required written disclosure of specified problems with the vehicle. AB 964 was held on the inactive file on the Assembly Floor.
AB 753 (Monning, 2011) would have expressly prohibited a rental car company from renting a vehicle that is subject to a recall notice unless the vehicle has been repaired as specified in the notice. AB 753 failed passage in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 114 (Bowen, 2005) would have enhanced the process by which attempts are made to notify an owner of a motor vehicle of a required safety-related vehicle recall. SB 114 was held on the suspense file in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- Double-referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee where it was heard on April 24, 2018, and passed out on a 9-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Turo (sponsor)
California Black Chamber of Commerce
Getaround, Inc.
Global Automakers
Internet Association
Mercedes Benz
Technet
Opposition
American Car Rental Association
California Labor Federation
California Teamsters
Enterprise Holdings
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2873
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2018
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: PERSONAL VEHICLE SHARING PROGRAMS: VEHICLE RECALLS
KEY ISSUE: should PERSONAL VEHICLE SHARING PROGRAMS, AS DEFINED UNDER EXISTING LAW, BE prohibited FROM facilitating transportation with VEHICLES that are SUBJECT TO A MANUFACTURER'S SAFETY RECALl, similar to the prohibition in existing law that applies to auto dealers and rental car companies?
SYNOPSIS
Proposed author's amendments significantly narrow the scope and intent of this bill from the version currently in print. As proposed to be amended, the bill simply provides that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSP), as currently defined under the Insurance Code, are prohibited from facilitating transportation with any vehicles that are subject to a manufacturer's safety recall, as specified. This aligns PVSPs more closely with existing recall laws that prohibit auto dealers and rental car companies from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent any vehicle subject to a manufacturer's recall.
For reasons discussed below, the author proposes to amend the bill to drop controversial provisions that would have stated that PVSPs are expressly not included in the definition of a rental car company, and made that statement declaratory of existing law. This almost certainly would have interfered with pending litigation on that very issue which involves the sponsor of this bill, TURO, a prominent PVSP, and the City of San Francisco on behalf of the People of the State of California. Instead, the bill as proposed to be amended is limited to the safety recall provisions, described below, and applies the existing definition of PVSP from the Insurance Code, in order to avoid interference with the ongoing litigation as much as possible. For procedural reasons, the author has committed to taking these amendments in the Assembly Privacy & Consumer Protection Committee, should the bill be approved by this Committee. The previous version of this bill was supported by TURO, Technet, and the Internet Association, among others. The previous version of the bill was strongly opposed by the rental car industry and organized labor, including the Teamsters and the California Labor Federation. Unfortunately, because of the late timing of these amendments, it is not known at the time of this analysis whether any or all of the opponents remain opposed to the bill as it is proposed to be amended.
SUMMARY: Ensures that personal vehicle sharing programs (PVSPs) are prohibited from arranging to put any vehicle on the road for transportation purposes if that vehicle is subject to a manufacturer's safety recall. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a personal vehicle sharing program from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752 of the Vehicle Code, if the recall was issued for safety reasons, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
- Defines "personal vehicle sharing program", for the purpose of the above rule, to have the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “personal vehicle sharing” as the use of private passenger motor vehicles by persons other than the vehicle’s owner, in connection with a personal vehicle sharing program. Further defines “personal vehicle sharing program” (PVSP) to mean a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state. (Insurance Code Section 11580.24 (b). All further references are to this code unless otherwise stated.)
- Provides that no vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified. (Section 11580.24 (a).)
- Provides that a personal vehicle sharing program shall, for each private passenger vehicle that it facilitates the use of, provide insurance equal to or greater than the insurance coverage maintained by the vehicle owner and reported to the personal vehicle sharing program, during all times when the vehicle is engaged in personal vehicle sharing, except that the personal vehicle sharing program shall not provide liability coverage less than three times the minimum insurance requirements for private passenger vehicles. (Section 11580.24 (c)(1).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or any provision in a private passenger motor vehicle owner’s automobile insurance policy, in the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes. Further provides that nothing in Section 11580.24 limits the liability of the PVSP for its acts or omissions that result in injury to any persons as a result of the use or operation of a PVSP. (Section 11580.24 (d).)
- Requires the PVSP to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss. (Section 11580.24 (f).)
- Requires, in the event that the owner of the vehicle is named as a defendant in a civil action, for a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle’s owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the program shall have the duty to defend and indemnify the vehicle’s owner. (Section 11580.24 (g).)
- Defines “rental company” to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public, and governs the transactions between a rental company and its customers, including, among other provisions, required disclosures by a rental company, mandatory contract provisions for a vehicle rental agreement, restrictions on a rental company’s use of electronic surveillance technology, and authorization for a rental company to collect specific types of fees and charges from its customers. (Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 1939.01) of Title 5 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.)
- Prohibits a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles, no later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made. (Vehicle Code Section 11754 (a).)
- Defines "rental car company", for purposes of the Consumer Automotive Recall Safety Act, to mean a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California. (Vehicle Code Section 11752 (e).)
- Defines “manufacturer’s recall” to mean a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code, and provides that a manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code. (Vehicle Code Section 11752 (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Proposed author's amendments significantly narrow the scope and intent of this bill from the version of the bill currently in print. As proposed to be amended, the bill provides that personal vehicle sharing programs, as currently defined under the Insurance Code, are prohibited from facilitating transportation with any vehicles that are subject to a manufacturer's safety recall. This aligns them more closely with existing recall laws that prohibit auto dealers and rental car companies from loaning, renting, or offering for loan or rent any vehicle subject to a manufacturer's recall.
The amendments appear below in their entirety:
1) On page 2, delete lines 1-19, and delete pages 3 to 6, inclusive.
2) On page 2, insert: An act to amend Section 11752 and 11754 of the Vehicle Code.
SECTION 1. Section 11752 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:
11752. As used in this article, the following definitions apply:
(a) The term “dealer” has the same meaning as in Section 285.
(b) (1) A “manufacturer’s recall” is a recall conducted pursuant to Sections 30118 to 30120, inclusive, of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(2) A manufacturer’s recall does not include a service campaign or emission recall when the vehicle manufacturer or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has not issued a recall notice to owners of affected vehicles, pursuant to Section 30118 of Title 49 of the United States Code.
(c) A "personal vehicle sharing program" has the same meaning as defined in Section 11580.24 of the Insurance Code.
(c) (d) A “recall database” is a database from which an individual may obtain vehicle identification number (VIN) specific manufacturer’s recall information relevant to a specific vehicle.
(1) For a vehicle manufacturer that is not subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database is one of the following:
(A) The recall data on a vehicle manufacturer’s Internet Web site for a specific vehicle’s line-make.
(B) The recall data in a vehicle manufacturer’s internal system that provides information to its franchisees on vehicles subject to recall.
(C) The recall data in subparagraph (A) or (B) that is contained in a commercially available vehicle history system.
(2) For a vehicle manufacturer that is subject to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 31301 of the federal Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (Public Law 112-141), a recall database shall include, at a minimum, the recall information required pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(d) (e) A “recall database report” is a report, specific to a vehicle that is identified by its VIN, containing information obtained from a recall database.
(e) (f) A “rental car company” is a person or entity in the business of renting passenger vehicles to the public in California.
SECTION 2. Section 11754 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:
11754. (a) No later than 48 hours after receiving a notice of a manufacturer’s recall, or sooner if practicable, a dealer or rental car company with a motor vehicle fleet of 34 or fewer loaner or rental vehicles shall not loan, rent, or offer for loan or rent a vehicle subject to that recall until the recall repair has been made.
(b) If a recall notification indicates that the remedy for the recall is not immediately available and specifies actions to temporarily repair the vehicle in a manner to eliminate the safety risk that prompted the recall, the dealer or rental car company, after having the repairs completed, may loan or rent the vehicle. Once the remedy for the vehicle becomes available to the dealer or rental car company, the dealer or rental car company shall not loan or rent the vehicle until the vehicle has been repaired.
(c) A personal vehicle sharing program shall not facilitate or otherwise arrange for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 11752, if the recall was issued for safety reasons, and a recall notice has been issued by the manufacturer and appears in the recall database provided by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pursuant to Section 573.15 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SECTION 3. No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
Background on private vehicle sharing programs. In 2010, the Legislature enacted AB 1871 (Jones), Ch. 454 Stats. 2010, which for the first time established "personal vehicle sharing programs" in the law. AB 1871 defined the term to mean "a legal entity qualified to do business in California engaged in the business of facilitating the sharing of private passenger vehicles for noncommercial use by individuals within the state." (Insurance Code Section 11580.24 (b).) “Private passenger motor vehicle” was defined to mean a vehicle having at least 4 wheels that is insured, or is subject to being insured, under a personal automobile liability insurance policy insuring a single individual or individuals residing in the same household, as the named insured, except as provided. According to the Assembly Insurance Committee's analysis of AB 1871 (May 5, 2010), the purpose of the bill was stated as follows:
Purpose: According to the author, carsharing companies would like to expand their pool of vehicles by taking advantage of privately owned vehicles while they are not in use. However, under current law, if the owner accepted compensation for allowing the vehicle to be used in a vehicle sharing program, an insurer could reclassify the vehicle as a commercial vehicle, and increase the premiums charged to the owner. The bill is designed to enable the carsharing company to enter into agreements with vehicle owners, and ensure that the owner is not disadvantaged. Further, the bill is designed to ensure that the owner's private passenger automobile insurer is also not disadvantaged when the vehicle is in use by the vehicle sharing program.
As befitting a bill that enacted provisions solely within the Insurance Code, AB 1871 provided a number of detailed insurance and liability parameters that, at least in principle, define what it means to be a PVSP. Among other things, Section 11580.24 provides that:
- No vehicle insured as a private passenger vehicle shall be classified as a commercial or for-hire vehicle for insurance purposes solely because its owner allows it to be used for personal vehicle sharing through a PVSP, as long as certain conditions are met, including that (a) the owner does not knowingly place the vehicle into commercial use; and (b) the annual revenue from sharing the vehicle through a PVSP does not exceed the annual cost or expenses of operating the vehicle, as specified. In other words, as a condition of participating in a PVSP with a vehicle not classified for commercial insurance, the vehicle owner must not be making a profit by sharing the car through the PVSP.
- A PVSP must provide liability insurance for private vehicles when used by drivers other than the owner in amounts equal to or greater than what the owner maintains, but in no event less than three times the amount required by the Financial Responsibility Law.
- In the event of a loss or injury that occurs during any time period when the vehicle is under the operation and control of a person, other than the vehicle owner, pursuant to a PVSP, or otherwise under the control of a PVSP, the PVSP shall assume all liability of the owner and shall be considered the owner of the vehicle for all purposes.
- The PVSP is required to assume liability for a claim in which a dispute exists as to who was in control of the vehicle when the loss occurred giving rise to the claim, and the vehicle’s private passenger motor vehicle insurer shall indemnify the PVSP to the extent of its obligation under the applicable insurance policy, if it is determined that the vehicle’s owner was in control of the vehicle at the time of the loss.
According to the author:
PVSP companies have been growing in urban areas across the country and a majority of the companies provide short-term rental use of vehicles by drivers who have only minimal need to a personal vehicle, and do not want to incur the expenses associated with owning and maintaining a vehicle. In addition to providing drivers in need of a car, PVSPs also provide car owners an opportunity to be compensated for the use of a vehicle that would otherwise sit.
Access to an automobile is still necessary in many areas of California, as public transit doesn’t reach everywhere and some tasks cannot be completed using transit. Various forms of car sharing have helped many Californians ease the financial burden of car ownership as well as provided access to individuals who cannot afford to own a car.
Since the passage of the original California law, as Personal Vehicle Sharing Programs (PVSP) have grown in popularity as hosted platforms, some entities within the state have sought to re-characterize PVSPs as rental car agencies and subject PVSPs to the rental car laws regarding fleets. The author believes that TURO is a completely different model that uses a platform to facilitate peer-to-peer car-sharing, therefore are not the same. TURO does not own any of the cars or control the people using the platform.
As noted by the author, there is a robust debate about whether companies such as TURO are more appropriately regulated as rental car companies, rather than as private vehicle sharing programs. The author and TURO, the sponsor of this bill, clearly feel they should not be regulated as such, while rental car companies and organized labor unions who oppose this bill clearly believe they should be. The author notes that at the time this bill was introduced, there was pending litigation in San Francisco Superior Court on the exact issue of whether TURO is subject to regulation as a rental car company. (People of the State of California v. Turo Inc., Case No. CGC-18-563803, filed Jan. 24, 2018.) The version of this bill currently in print seeks to declare that PVSPs do not fall within the definition of a rental car company, and, problematically, given the pending litigation on this matter, would make this declaratory of existing law. There is also competing legislation, AB 2246, that seeks to establish that PVSPs for all intents and purposes, are included in the various operational definitions of a rental car company located throughout the codes.
In evaluating these issues, Committee staff studied the existing law on PVSPs and car rental companies; met with TURO representatives and inquired about company practices and their understanding of existing law; and studied listings, policies, and information published on TURO's website.
The PVSP model is premised on the concept of individual vehicle owners (“hosts”) allowing other persons (“guests”), who they may or may not know, to use their vehicles for a fee. They are allowed to do so under existing law, as long as they have a special type of auto insurance provided by PVSPs that provide commercial coverage during the period when the guest is using the vehicle. However, representations made about TURO's insurance and liability responsibilities under the law were hard to reconcile with the detailed explanations of TURO's insurance and protection provisions for "guests" and "hosts" published on their own website. While the former characterizations were one of generous, mandatory coverage of nearly all liability situations by TURO, the latter showed many policy exclusions and instances of where primary liability lies with the guest driver. The prevalence of listings found on TURO's website that appear to represent a single entity renting out a small fleet of vehicles from a commercial location were hard to reconcile with the portrait of TURO as a "personal vehicle sharing program" where, by law, participants are not supposed to be making profits off of vehicles shared through the program. These conflicting factors made it difficult to assess whether TURO more appropriately operates as a rental car company or a private vehicle sharing program. The best conclusion may be that it fits neither category very well, and that further work needs to be done to adapt a paradigm that fits more comfortably, while still ensuring a level playing field for new and long-time businesses operating in this field.
Proposed amendments limit the bill to safety recall provisions, and seek to eliminate interference with pending litigation. As currently in print, this bill would have created a new chapter in the Civil Code for yet-to-be-determined provisions pertaining to PVSPs, and would have amended the statute pertaining to rental car companies to expressly state that the definition of "rental company" does not include a personal vehicle sharing program, and made such statement declaratory of existing law. It is hard to see what this provision is intended to do other than to interfere with pending litigation involving TURO on this precise issue, that concerned the Committee which has a well-established history of declining to interfere with pending litigation. Proposed author's amendments to the bill, to be taken in Privacy & Consumer Protection Committee for procedural reasons, reflect the author's agreement to avoid interfering with pending litigation with this bill, and instead proceed with relatively non-controversial provisions on safety recall (discussed below) that seek to avoid interference with ongoing litigation.
Safety recall provisions: Vehicle safety recalls are necessary when a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment does not comply with a Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, or when there is a safety-related defect in the vehicle or equipment. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that “[g]enerally, a safety defect is defined as a problem that exists in a motor vehicle or item of motor vehicle equipment that: (1) poses a risk to motor vehicle safety; and (2) may exist in a group of vehicles of the same design or manufacture, or items of equipment of the same type and manufacture.” (See Motor Vehicle Defects and Safety Recalls: What Every Vehicle Owner Should Know, U.S. Department of Transportation. Available at: http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot. gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm.)
In December 2015, Congress passed and the President signed a five-year transportation funding measure – the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act). The measure included a provision that prohibits a rental car company or car dealer, with 35 or more vehicles available for rental or loan, from renting or loaning a vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall. Rental car companies or dealers with fleets under 35 cars, however, were not subject to the federal rule, leaving a large gap in public protection. In response, the Legislature approved and the Governor signed AB 287 (Gordon), Ch. 682, Stats. 2016, which sought to close the loophole for entities with fewer than 35 vehicles. As enacted, the new law prohibits a rental car company or car dealer from renting or loaning any vehicle with an unrepaired manufacturer recall.
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS) points out, however, that vehicles rented out through a PVSP are likely falling through the cracks of AB 287 because the law only applies to car dealers and rental car companies on its face, and consequently, there may be dangerous vehicles on the road right now subject to recall. As proposed to be amended, this bill would close the loophole by prohibiting a PVSP from facilitating or otherwise arranging for transportation with a vehicle that is subject to a manufacturer's recall, as defined. For purposes of this recall provision, the existing definition of PVSP from Insurance Code Section 11580.24 applies.
Pending Related Legislation: AB 2246 (Friedman) would incorporate personal vehicle sharing programs into the definition of "rental car company" in assorted sections of the Codes. AB 2246 is also currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support (to previous version of the bill)
Turo (sponsor)
Getaround, Inc.
Global Automakers
Internet Association
Mercedes Benz
Technet
Opposition (to previous version of the bill)
American Car Rental Association
California Labor Federation
California Teamsters
Enterprise Holdings
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):