AB 2923: San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-30
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt by ordinance new transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project, as defined. The bill would require that the adoption of, or amendments to, the TOD zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require affected local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within 2 years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are adopted by the board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station. The bill would provide that BARTs approval of TOD zoning standards is subject to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review and would designate BART as the lead agency for CEQA review, as specified.
This bill would, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after July 1, 2022, require the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning for any BART-owned parcels that are at least 75% within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board, as specified. The bill would require BART to ensure any otherwise applicable local design standards are included as general guidance to the TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design standards insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require that, where housing is proposed as part of a TOD project, a certain minimum of residential housing units is affordable housing, as specified, and that the construction of the TOD project complies with specified labor requirements. The bill would provide that when BART enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are repealed on January 1, 2029, except as otherwise specified. The bill would enact other related provisions and exceptions.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The bill would include legislative findings and declarations in support of the act being a matter of statewide concern.
(3)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt by ordinance new transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project, as defined. The bill would require that the adoption of, or amendments to, the TOD zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require affected local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within 2 years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are adopted by the board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station. The bill would provide that BARTs approval of TOD zoning standards is subject to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review and would designate BART as the lead agency for CEQA review, as specified.
This bill would, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after July 1, 2022, require the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning for any BART-owned parcels that are at least 75% within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board, as specified. The bill would require BART to ensure any otherwise applicable local design standards are included as general guidance to the TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design standards insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require that, where housing is proposed as part of a TOD project, a certain minimum of residential housing units is affordable housing, as specified, and that the construction of the TOD project complies with specified labor requirements. The bill would provide that when BART enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are repealed on January 1, 2029, except as otherwise specified. The bill would enact other related provisions and exceptions.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The bill would include legislative findings and declarations in support of the act being a matter of statewide concern.
(3)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt by ordinance new transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project, as defined. The bill would require that the adoption of, or amendments to, the TOD zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require affected local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within 2 years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are adopted by the board. board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station. The bill would provide that BARTs approval of TOD zoning standards is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review) (CEQA) review and would designate BART as the lead agency for CEQA review, as specified.
This bill would, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after this 2-year period, July 1, 2022, require the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning for any BART-owned land parcels that are at least 75% within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board, as specified. The bill would require BART to ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines standards are included in a development agreement as general guidance to the TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines standards insofar as those guidelines standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require that, where housing is proposed as part of a TOD project, a minimum of 20% of the residential housing units is are affordable housing, as specified, and that the construction of the TOD project comply with specified labor requirements. The bill would provide that when BART enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are repealed on January 1, 2029, except as otherwise specified. The bill would enact other related provisions and exceptions.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The bill would include legislative findings and declarations in support of the act being a matter of statewide concern.
(3)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt by ordinance new transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting zoning standards that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within 1/2 mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors. height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project, as defined. The bill would require that the approval adoption of, or amendment of amendments to, the TOD zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require affected local jurisdictions to adopt an a local zoning ordinance that approves the application of conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within 2 years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are approved adopted by the board. The bill would provide that the boards BARTs approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review) and would designate the board BART as the lead agency for CEQA review, as specified.
TheThis bill would require the board, would, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines zoning standards after this 2-year period, to approve require the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board. board, as specified. The bill would require the board BART to ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a as general guidance to the TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density height, minimum density, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require the board to adopt a permit streamlining process for specified TOD project applicants and would provide that a TOD project shall include a specified that, where housing is proposed as part of a TOD project, a minimum of 20% of the residential housing units is affordable housing requirement housing, as specified, and that the TOD project comply with specified labor requirements. The bill would provide that when BART enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development, as specified. The bill would provide that its provisions are repealed on January 1, 2029, except as otherwise specified. The bill would enact other related provisions and exceptions.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The bill would include legislative findings and declarations in support of the act being a matter of statewide concern.
(2)(3)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt new transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within 1/2 mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors. The bill would require that the approval or amendment of TOD zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require local jurisdictions to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of TOD zoning standards within 2 years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are approved by the board. The bill would provide that the boards approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (CEQA review) and would designate the board as the lead agency for CEQA review. review, as specified.
The bill would require the board, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after this 2-year period, to approve local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board. The bill would require the board to ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require the board to adopt a permit streamlining process for specified TOD project applicants and would provide that a TOD project shall include a specified 20% affordable housing requirement and comply with specified labor requirements.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt new transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within 1/2 mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors. The bill would require that the approval or amendment of TOD guidelines zoning standards comply with specified requirements and would require local jurisdictions to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of TOD guidelines zoning standards within 2 years of the date that the TOD guidelines zoning standards are approved by the board. The bill would provide that the boards approval of TOD guidelines zoning standards is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and would designate the board as the lead agency for CEQA review.
The bill would require the board, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after this 2-year period, to approve local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board. The bill would require the board to ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer, and would require a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill would require the board to adopt a permit streamlining process for specified TOD project applicants and would provide that a TOD project shall include a specified 20% affordable housing requirement and comply with specified labor requirements.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) with various powers and duties and establishes a board of directors as the legislative body of the district. Existing law requires the board to determine all questions of district policy and what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and authorizes the board to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities.
This bill would require the board to adopt new transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within 1/2 mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors. The bill would require that the approval or amendment of TOD guidelines comply with specified requirements and would require local jurisdictions to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of TOD guidelines within 2 years of the date that the TOD guidelines are approved by the board. The bill would provide that the boards approval of TOD guidelines is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and would designate the board as the lead agency for CEQA review.
The bill would require the board, where local zoning remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after this 2-year period, to approve local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within 1/2 mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance within the BART district in areas represented on the board. The bill would require the board to adopt a permit streamlining process for specified TOD project applicants and would provide that a TOD project shall include a specified 20% affordable housing requirement and comply with specified labor requirements.
By increasing the duties of local public officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The states economic health is significantly tied to the regional economic health of the San Francisco Bay Area. The growth and success of the Bay Areas economy is threatened by several challenges, including inadequate and unaffordable housing and excessive and increasing roadway congestion. In the state-mandated sustainable communities strategy for the Bay Area, locating affordable and market-rate housing near high-capacity transit is a primary tool with which to address these challenges and will keep the Bay Area on track to meet its state-mandated greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets.
(b)The San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (district) is a product of the Legislature, drawing its power from the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Act (Part 2 (commencing with Section 28500) of Division 10 of the Public Utilities Code), which acknowledges the statewide interest in a well-functioning, cost-effective, and fiscally sustainable district network.
(c)Recognizing the above statewide interest, the state has granted the district land use and permitting authority to build transportation facilities such as parking structures, stations, and maintenance facilities. Since that authority was granted, it has only become clearer that making those facilities financially and environmentally sustainable requires that the district have some level of authority over land use for transit-oriented development.
(d)Transportation services are uniquely tied to land use patterns, as recognized by the Legislatures enactment of Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008, which integrated the development of sustainable communities strategies into regional transportation plans. Furthermore, the district itself is unique as a transit agency in that it is governed by an elected board of directors, granting the people of the San Francisco Bay Area a greater measure of input on the districts decisions than the constituents of other agencies have on their agencies. The district is also unique because of the number of daily rail passengers it serves. Because of the districts unique status, the Legislature, pursuant to this act, intends to solely grant the district an exception to the principle that cities and counties must be reserved land use authority by granting the district a measure of limited land use authority over the parcels it owns in the immediate vicinity of its stations.
(e)The state has invested significantly in the districts infrastructure, which is estimated to be worth over twenty billion dollars ($20,000,000,000), and continues to invest tens of millions of dollars more for the districts operations every year. The state has an interest in leveraging the maximum benefits from this investment, including greenhouse gas emissions reductions, congestion reduction, air quality improvement, mobility enhancements, increased transit ridership, and increased affordable housing.
(f)For the above reasons, the authorizations in this act, which seek to deliver affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit, constitute an urgent matter of statewide concern.
SEC. 2.Section 29010.1 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.1.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)BART TOD place type means the place type described in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines (2017), as updated by the district.
(2)Eligible TOD project means a TOD project that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located is an infill site, as defined in Section 21061.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(B)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located was not acquired through eminent domain on or after July 1, 2018.
(C)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres, has at least 75 percent of its area located within one-half mile of an existing or planned district station entrance, and is located within an area represented on the board.
(D)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located is owned by the district.
(E)For a TOD project relating to a district station that existed on July 1, 2018, the TOD zoning standards and Section 29010.7 shall apply only to a parcel that is owned by the district on that date.
(F)For a TOD project relating to a planned district station, the district station has been approved by an ordinance or resolution adopted by the legislative body of the local jurisdiction with local land use zoning jurisdiction over the area in which the station is located.
(3)Floor area ratio means the ratio of gross building area of the development, excluding structured parking areas, proposed for the project, divided by the total area of the parcel or parcels used by the project, where gross building area means the sum of all finished areas of all floors of a building included within the outside faces of its exterior walls.
(4)Local jurisdiction means a city, including a charter city, a county, or a city and county.
(5)Planned district station means a station that has completed the California Environmental Quality Act review and for which construction is more than 75 percent funded.
(6)Station entrance means the entry point into an enclosed station structure, or, where that point is not clear or does not exist, the station fare gates.
(7)TOD means transit-oriented development.
(8)TOD project means any residential or commercial development project, comprised of one or more buildings, wholly or partially on district land with 50 percent of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential uses, unless a locally adopted specific plan provides for a different percentage, or other metric, of residential uses on district-owned parcels. If a locally adopted specific plan establishes a lower minimum residential use requirement for district-owned land, the specific plan metric shall serve as the minimum residential requirement.
(9)TOD project area means the parcel or parcels of land on which a TOD project is situated.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.Section 29010.6 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.6.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall, consistent with Section 28793, adopt by ordinance TOD zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project.
(2)Adopted TOD zoning standards shall establish, for each district station, the lowest permissible limit for height, density, and floor area ratio, and the highest permissible parking minimums and maximums. The zoning standards published in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum allowable density and height limits, and the highest allowable parking limits to which the board is required to adhere in adopting TOD zoning standards. The board shall not establish floor-area-ratio limits in the TOD zoning standards for each station type less than the number in the column titled residential target height multiplied by 0.6.
(3)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall not assign a lowest permissible height limit taller than the larger of the following two heights:
(A)The highest approved height as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7.
(B)One hundred fifty percent of the target height in the zoning standards published in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(4)(A)TOD zoning standards shall be adopted by July 1, 2020, and may be amended thereafter pursuant to this section.(B)(i)If the board, for any reason, does not adopt new standards for a station by July 1, 2020, Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the TOD zoning standards, with the Transit Oriented Place Types identified in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017), until that time when the board adopts new TOD zoning standards for that station.
(ii)In the case that Table 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) serves as the TOD zoning standards for any stations, the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit shall be calculated for each station type by multiplying the number in the column titled residential target height by 0.6.
(5)The district is not required to establish TOD zoning standards for a station where, according to the districts assessment, it would be impractical to develop an eligible TOD project greater than one-half acre.
(6)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall reflect the diversity of the different communities served by the districts stations.
(b)The adoption of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The district shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to relevant local jurisdictions and to communities of concern around each station. Before or during the scoping meeting, the district shall meet with each jurisdiction in which the station is located, as well as any relevant infrastructure agencies. The consultation required pursuant to this section shall include all of the following:
(A)A review of the housing needs of the jurisdiction.
(B)A review of the TOD approved and built in the past year in the jurisdiction.
(C)A review of any TOD projects proposed by the district in the jurisdiction for the past year.
(D)A discussion of any obstacles to development of any project proposed by the district.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft standards available to the public.
(3)The board shall adopt or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as adopting the TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property, which shall be consistent with district station access, district sustainability, and district TOD policy goals.
(d)(1)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards for a station, the local jurisdiction shall adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are adopted by the board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station.
(2)The district shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance conforms to the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the district determines that it does not conform to the TOD zoning standards. If, according to the districts finding, the local zoning ordinance does not conform to the TOD zoning standards after July 1, 2022, the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning for any district-owned parcels that are at least 75 percent within one-half mile of any existing or planned district station entrance in areas represented on the board. For each station, a local jurisdiction may update zoning for district-owned land to comply with TOD zoning standards until the time that the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for an eligible TOD project.
(3)If a local jurisdiction is in review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) of proposed zoning, or engaged in a lawsuit related to zoning adoption, but has not completed the adoption of those zoning standards by the time the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, the district shall, to the extent it has the authority, take into consideration the local jurisdictions proposed zoning standards in negotiating the districts development agreement with any potential eligible TOD project developer.
(4)In cases where a local jurisdictions zoning for district-owned land within one-half mile of a district station, approved as of July 1, 2018, is within 10 percent of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) and values calculated by clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) the local jurisdiction shall be exempt from the application of the TOD zoning standards for that station. In this case, the parking requirements shall be set as the parking minimum and maximum established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(e)(1)The districts approval of TOD zoning standards shall be subject to CEQA review. The district shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review for the TOD zoning standards.
(2)Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of eligible TOD projects proposed on district-owned land, shall incorporate the environmental review document certified for the TOD zoning standards consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. A public agency shall not prepare an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for rezoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) to implement TOD zoning standards or for a TOD project subsequent to the districts certification of an environmental review document for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning or TOD project creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed in the prior environmental review document, and mitigated or avoided.
(f)In the event that the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(g)The district shall establish, and amend as necessary, a parking replacement policy, consistent with the districts practice at auto-dependent stations and the districts station access policy, with specific provisions to ensure that, after the construction of the eligible TOD project, auto-dependent stations are still accessible by private automobile. The policy shall specifically consider the parking replacement needs for auto-dependent end-of-the-line stations.
(h)For any station where district commuter parking is reduced as a result of a TOD project on land where TOD zoning standards apply, the district shall develop and fund an access plan that maintains station access for at least the number of customers affected by the reduced number of commuter parking spaces, which shall include specific consideration for customers who live further than one-half mile from the station.
(i)Local jurisdictions shall not do either of the following:
(1)Require that parking, as part of an eligible TOD project, be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the TOD project.
(2)Prohibit parking from being sold, rented, or otherwise assigned separately from other parts of the eligible TOD project.
(j)Zoning in effect as a result of this section shall be considered the same as locally approved zoning for all purposes, including the density bonus law and the Housing Accountability Act.
(k)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 29010.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.7.(a)(1)This section shall only apply to an eligible TOD project that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)Has a height less than or equal to one story, or 15 feet, above the highest approved height for mixed use or residential use within a half-mile of a district station parcel or entrance on July 1, 2018, where highest approved height means the tallest height, including heights that require conditional approval, allowable pursuant to zoning, including the municipal code and any specific or area plan that covers the district station property.
(B)Has a floor area ratio equal to or less than 0.6 times the number of stories that satisfies subparagraph (A).
(2)(A)If local zoning standards allow for taller heights or larger floor area ratios than the requirements in paragraph (1), this section shall apply to any project that meets the requirements of the local zoning standards.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to local zoning standards adopted for the purpose of complying with paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6 or to BART TOD standards that have become the local zoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6.
(3)This section shall not apply to a project where the local jurisdiction finds that the project will cause a specific adverse impact to public health and safety as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(b)(1)A developer in an exclusive negotiating agreement with the district may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit as specified in Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(2)An eligible TOD project that meets the requirements in subdivision (a) shall not be required to comply with the objective planning standards in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code to be eligible for the streamlined, ministerial approval process, except as otherwise provided in this article.
(c)A developer of an eligible TOD project may apply for density bonus pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code. For purposes of an application submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), maximum allowable gross residential density, as that term is used in Section 65915 of the Government Code, includes the highest approved height, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), and the floor area ratio requirement described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). A project that meets the requirements of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) before the addition of any height increases, density increases, waivers, or concessions awarded through a density bonus shall remain eligible for streamlining under this section after the addition of a density bonus.
(d)(1)The district shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design standards, insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards, are included as general guidance to the TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design standards insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 29010.8 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.8.(a)The district shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of any of the following types of housing, within five years from the date of approval of the development agreement, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all of those housing units to the same or lower income levels:
(A)Housing that is subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents or sales prices to levels affordable, as defined in Section 50052.5 or 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to persons and families of moderate, lower, or very low income, as defined in Section 50079.5, 50093, or 50105 of the Health and Safety Code, respectively.
(B)Housing that is subject to any form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power.
(C)Housing that had been occupied by tenants within five years from the date of approval of the development agreement by a primary tenant who was low income and did not leave voluntarily.
(2)As a condition of any development on a parcel within an eligible TOD project area, replacement housing units for those described in paragraph (1) shall be subject to recorded affordability restrictions. In the case of the demolition of a rental unit, a replacement unit shall be a rental unit with restrictions for at least 55 years, with a rent level set at the same level as the previous restrictions or, if no rent restrictions were in place, at rent affordable, as defined in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to the tenant who most recently occupied the unit, or, if the income level of the most recent tenant cannot be determined, at rent affordable to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower income tenants unless the district or the TOD developer has offered, in writing, the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing unit that is available for occupancy by the displaced tenant within one-half mile of the same district station at a rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent.
(4)Require that new units shall not be occupied sooner than the date that replacement affordable housing units are available to all eligible tenants that wish to be moved into replacement units pursuant to paragraph (3).
(5)Provide relocation assistance to lower income tenants directly displaced from housing units by an eligible TOD project pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 7260) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(6)Develop a strategy, in coordination with local jurisdictions, to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options and incentivize tenant protections for very low and low-income residents within and around an eligible TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions. The strategy should specifically address mitigations for the direct and indirect impacts from the demolition of any existing housing units.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects, especially for very low, low-, and moderate-income workers.
(b)An eligible TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)(A)Where housing is proposed, restrict at least 20 percent of the residential housing units for occupancy by very low and low-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years in the case of rental units and 45 years in the case of owner-occupied units, in addition to the replacement affordable housing units described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), with a priority on residential units for very low and low-income households.
(B)If a local jurisdictions inclusionary housing requirement mandates a higher percentage of affordable units or a deeper level of affordability than that described in subparagraph (A), then that jurisdictions affordability percentage requirements shall apply in place of the requirements in subparagraph (A).
(2)The district shall develop and implement an approach to evaluating affordable housing proposals that will consider a proposals quantity and depth of affordability, and the proposals validity and feasibility with respect to the requirements of this section.
(3)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable district labor policies, including the districts policy of requiring project stabilization agreements pursuant to district Resolution 5182 (November 17, 2011), In the Matter of a Policy Requiring Project Stabilization Agreements (PSA) with Local Hire Provisions on Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) Projects.
(c)On district-owned land within the districts boundaries, the district shall ensure that a total of 30 percent of housing units are affordable, with priority given to very low and low-income households. The district shall submit a biennial report to the Department of Housing and Community Development stating the percentage of units that are restricted as affordable units, by level of affordability, for all district TOD projects.
(d)The district may exempt specific TOD projects from the application of TOD zoning standards when the project is in the approval process with a local jurisdiction before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 29010.6.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 29010.9 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.9.(a)Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, a local jurisdiction may exercise full design review and conditional use permitting authority over any eligible TOD project that does not meet the conditions specified in subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7, except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 29010.7.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 7.Section 29010.10 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.10.(a)When the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development in substantial compliance with the provisions of Sections 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, and 29010.9. However, if Section 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, or 29010.9 is repealed, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with the eligible TOD project in substantial compliance with those provisions in effect at the time the agreement was entered into.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2031, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 8.Section 29010.11 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.11.(a)Before July 1, 2027, the district shall submit a report to the Legislature assessing whether the provisions of this chapter effectively accelerate, and improve the quality of, TOD at district stations.
(b)The report shall include all of the following:
(1)The average time to deliver TOD projects begun before January 1, 2019, and after January 1, 2019.
(2)A summary of the data on travel behavior and choices for TOD residents and workers.
(3)A summary of the housing affordability in district TOD projects begun after January 1, 2019.
(4)A summary of which TOD projects were delivered pursuant to a streamlined approval process and delivered pursuant to a discretionary approval process.
(5)A cost comparison of discretionary and ministerial TOD projects.
(6)Other factors the district determines to be pertinent to the Legislatures consideration of whether to extend the sunset dates applicable to this chapter.
(c)(1)A report to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this section is repealed on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 9.Section 29010.12 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.12.(a)This article shall not apply to a district station without unentitled or undeveloped land on July 1, 2018, unless that station entitlement expires. For this purpose, undeveloped land includes, but is not limited to, surface parking.
(b)This article shall not preclude or limit the ability of a developer to seek, or the application of, a density bonus, including concessions and incentives from a local government pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 10.The Legislature finds and declares that the serious shortage of affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit is a threat to the economic health of the state and jeopardizes the states ability to achieve its greenhouse gas reduction goals and is a matter of statewide concern and not exclusively a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 11.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The states economic health is significantly tied to the regional economic health of the San Francisco Bay Area. The growth and success of the Bay Areas economy is threatened by several challenges, including inadequate and unaffordable housing and excessive and increasing roadway congestion. In the state-mandated sustainable communities strategy for the Bay Area, locating affordable and market-rate housing near high-capacity transit is a primary tool with which to address these challenges and will keep the Bay Area on track to meet its state-mandated greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets.
(b)The San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (district) is a product of the Legislature, drawing its power from the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Act (Part 2 (commencing with Section 28500) of Division 10 of the Public Utilities Code), which acknowledges the statewide interest in a well-functioning, cost-effective, and fiscally sustainable district network.
(c)Recognizing the above statewide interest, the state has granted the district land use and permitting authority to build transportation facilities such as parking structures, stations, and maintenance facilities. Since that authority was granted, it has only become clearer that making those facilities financially and environmentally sustainable requires that the district have some level of authority over land use for transit-oriented development.
(d)Transportation services are uniquely tied to land use patterns, as recognized by the Legislatures enactment of Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008, which integrated the development of sustainable communities strategies into regional transportation plans. Furthermore, the district itself is unique as a transit agency in that it is governed by an elected board of directors, granting the people of the San Francisco Bay Area a greater measure of input on the districts decisions than the constituents of other agencies have on their agencies. The district is also unique because of the number of daily rail passengers it serves. Because of the districts unique status, the Legislature, pursuant to this act, intends to solely grant the district an exception to the principle that cities and counties must be reserved land use authority by granting the district a measure of limited land use authority over the parcels it owns in the immediate vicinity of its stations.
(e)The state has invested significantly in the districts infrastructure, which is estimated to be worth over twenty billion dollars ($20,000,000,000), and continues to invest tens of millions of dollars more for the districts operations every year. The state has an interest in leveraging the maximum benefits from this investment, including greenhouse gas emissions reductions, congestion reduction, air quality improvement, mobility enhancements, increased transit ridership, and increased affordable housing.
(f)For the above reasons, the authorizations in this act, which seek to deliver affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit, constitute an urgent matter of statewide concern.
SEC. 2.Section 29010.1 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.1.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)BART TOD place type means the place type described in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines (2017), as updated by the district.
(2)Eligible TOD project means a TOD project that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located is an infill site, as defined in Section 21061.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(B)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located was not acquired through eminent domain on or after July 1, 2018.
(C)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres, has at least 75 percent of its area located within one-half mile of an existing or planned district station entrance, and is located within an area represented on the board.
(D)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located is owned by the district.
(E)For a TOD project relating to a district station that existed on July 1, 2018, the TOD zoning standards and Section 29010.7 shall apply only to a parcel that is owned by the district on that date.
(F)For a TOD project relating to a planned district station, the district station has been approved by an ordinance or resolution adopted by the legislative body of the local jurisdiction with local land use zoning jurisdiction over the area in which the station is located.
(3)Floor area ratio means the ratio of gross building area of the development, excluding structured parking areas, proposed for the project, divided by the total area of the parcel or parcels used by the project, where gross building area means the sum of all finished areas of all floors of a building included within the outside faces of its exterior walls.
(4)Local jurisdiction means a city, including a charter city, a county, or a city and county.
(5)Planned district station means a station that has completed the California Environmental Quality Act review and for which construction is more than 75 percent funded.
(6)Station entrance means the entry point into an enclosed station structure, or, where that point is not clear or does not exist, the station fare gates.
(7)TOD means transit-oriented development.
(8)TOD project means any residential or commercial development project, comprised of one or more buildings, wholly or partially on district land with 50 percent of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential uses, unless a locally adopted specific plan provides for a different percentage, or other metric, of residential uses on district-owned parcels. If a locally adopted specific plan establishes a lower minimum residential use requirement for district-owned land, the specific plan metric shall serve as the minimum residential requirement.
(9)TOD project area means the parcel or parcels of land on which a TOD project is situated.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.Section 29010.6 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.6.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall, consistent with Section 28793, adopt by ordinance TOD zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project.
(2)Adopted TOD zoning standards shall establish, for each district station, the lowest permissible limit for height, density, and floor area ratio, and the highest permissible parking minimums and maximums. The zoning standards published in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum allowable density and height limits, and the highest allowable parking limits to which the board is required to adhere in adopting TOD zoning standards. The board shall not establish floor-area-ratio limits in the TOD zoning standards for each station type less than the number in the column titled residential target height multiplied by 0.6.
(3)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall not assign a lowest permissible height limit taller than the larger of the following two heights:
(A)The highest approved height as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7.
(B)One hundred fifty percent of the target height in the zoning standards published in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(4)(A)TOD zoning standards shall be adopted by July 1, 2020, and may be amended thereafter pursuant to this section.(B)(i)If the board, for any reason, does not adopt new standards for a station by July 1, 2020, Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the TOD zoning standards, with the Transit Oriented Place Types identified in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017), until that time when the board adopts new TOD zoning standards for that station.
(ii)In the case that Table 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) serves as the TOD zoning standards for any stations, the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit shall be calculated for each station type by multiplying the number in the column titled residential target height by 0.6.
(5)The district is not required to establish TOD zoning standards for a station where, according to the districts assessment, it would be impractical to develop an eligible TOD project greater than one-half acre.
(6)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall reflect the diversity of the different communities served by the districts stations.
(b)The adoption of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The district shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to relevant local jurisdictions and to communities of concern around each station. Before or during the scoping meeting, the district shall meet with each jurisdiction in which the station is located, as well as any relevant infrastructure agencies. The consultation required pursuant to this section shall include all of the following:
(A)A review of the housing needs of the jurisdiction.
(B)A review of the TOD approved and built in the past year in the jurisdiction.
(C)A review of any TOD projects proposed by the district in the jurisdiction for the past year.
(D)A discussion of any obstacles to development of any project proposed by the district.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft standards available to the public.
(3)The board shall adopt or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as adopting the TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property, which shall be consistent with district station access, district sustainability, and district TOD policy goals.
(d)(1)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards for a station, the local jurisdiction shall adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards are adopted by the board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station.
(2)The district shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance conforms to the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the district determines that it does not conform to the TOD zoning standards. If, according to the districts finding, the local zoning ordinance does not conform to the TOD zoning standards after July 1, 2022, the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning for any district-owned parcels that are at least 75 percent within one-half mile of any existing or planned district station entrance in areas represented on the board. For each station, a local jurisdiction may update zoning for district-owned land to comply with TOD zoning standards until the time that the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for an eligible TOD project.
(3)If a local jurisdiction is in review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) of proposed zoning, or engaged in a lawsuit related to zoning adoption, but has not completed the adoption of those zoning standards by the time the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, the district shall, to the extent it has the authority, take into consideration the local jurisdictions proposed zoning standards in negotiating the districts development agreement with any potential eligible TOD project developer.
(4)In cases where a local jurisdictions zoning for district-owned land within one-half mile of a district station, approved as of July 1, 2018, is within 10 percent of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) and values calculated by clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) the local jurisdiction shall be exempt from the application of the TOD zoning standards for that station. In this case, the parking requirements shall be set as the parking minimum and maximum established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(e)(1)The districts approval of TOD zoning standards shall be subject to CEQA review. The district shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review for the TOD zoning standards.
(2)Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of eligible TOD projects proposed on district-owned land, shall incorporate the environmental review document certified for the TOD zoning standards consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. A public agency shall not prepare an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for rezoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) to implement TOD zoning standards or for a TOD project subsequent to the districts certification of an environmental review document for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning or TOD project creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed in the prior environmental review document, and mitigated or avoided.
(f)In the event that the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(g)The district shall establish, and amend as necessary, a parking replacement policy, consistent with the districts practice at auto-dependent stations and the districts station access policy, with specific provisions to ensure that, after the construction of the eligible TOD project, auto-dependent stations are still accessible by private automobile. The policy shall specifically consider the parking replacement needs for auto-dependent end-of-the-line stations.
(h)For any station where district commuter parking is reduced as a result of a TOD project on land where TOD zoning standards apply, the district shall develop and fund an access plan that maintains station access for at least the number of customers affected by the reduced number of commuter parking spaces, which shall include specific consideration for customers who live further than one-half mile from the station.
(i)Local jurisdictions shall not do either of the following:
(1)Require that parking, as part of an eligible TOD project, be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the TOD project.
(2)Prohibit parking from being sold, rented, or otherwise assigned separately from other parts of the eligible TOD project.
(j)Zoning in effect as a result of this section shall be considered the same as locally approved zoning for all purposes, including the density bonus law and the Housing Accountability Act.
(k)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 29010.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.7.(a)(1)This section shall only apply to an eligible TOD project that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)Has a height less than or equal to one story, or 15 feet, above the highest approved height for mixed use or residential use within a half-mile of a district station parcel or entrance on July 1, 2018, where highest approved height means the tallest height, including heights that require conditional approval, allowable pursuant to zoning, including the municipal code and any specific or area plan that covers the district station property.
(B)Has a floor area ratio equal to or less than 0.6 times the number of stories that satisfies subparagraph (A).
(2)(A)If local zoning standards allow for taller heights or larger floor area ratios than the requirements in paragraph (1), this section shall apply to any project that meets the requirements of the local zoning standards.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to local zoning standards adopted for the purpose of complying with paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6 or to BART TOD standards that have become the local zoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6.
(3)This section shall not apply to a project where the local jurisdiction finds that the project will cause a specific adverse impact to public health and safety as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(b)(1)A developer in an exclusive negotiating agreement with the district may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit as specified in Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(2)An eligible TOD project that meets the requirements in subdivision (a) shall not be required to comply with the objective planning standards in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code to be eligible for the streamlined, ministerial approval process, except as otherwise provided in this article.
(c)A developer of an eligible TOD project may apply for density bonus pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code. For purposes of an application submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), maximum allowable gross residential density, as that term is used in Section 65915 of the Government Code, includes the highest approved height, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), and the floor area ratio requirement described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). A project that meets the requirements of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) before the addition of any height increases, density increases, waivers, or concessions awarded through a density bonus shall remain eligible for streamlining under this section after the addition of a density bonus.
(d)(1)The district shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design standards, insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards, are included as general guidance to the TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design standards insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 29010.8 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.8.(a)The district shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of any of the following types of housing, within five years from the date of approval of the development agreement, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all of those housing units to the same or lower income levels:
(A)Housing that is subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents or sales prices to levels affordable, as defined in Section 50052.5 or 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to persons and families of moderate, lower, or very low income, as defined in Section 50079.5, 50093, or 50105 of the Health and Safety Code, respectively.
(B)Housing that is subject to any form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power.
(C)Housing that had been occupied by tenants within five years from the date of approval of the development agreement by a primary tenant who was low income and did not leave voluntarily.
(2)As a condition of any development on a parcel within an eligible TOD project area, replacement housing units for those described in paragraph (1) shall be subject to recorded affordability restrictions. In the case of the demolition of a rental unit, a replacement unit shall be a rental unit with restrictions for at least 55 years, with a rent level set at the same level as the previous restrictions or, if no rent restrictions were in place, at rent affordable, as defined in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to the tenant who most recently occupied the unit, or, if the income level of the most recent tenant cannot be determined, at rent affordable to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower income tenants unless the district or the TOD developer has offered, in writing, the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing unit that is available for occupancy by the displaced tenant within one-half mile of the same district station at a rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent.
(4)Require that new units shall not be occupied sooner than the date that replacement affordable housing units are available to all eligible tenants that wish to be moved into replacement units pursuant to paragraph (3).
(5)Provide relocation assistance to lower income tenants directly displaced from housing units by an eligible TOD project pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 7260) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(6)Develop a strategy, in coordination with local jurisdictions, to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options and incentivize tenant protections for very low and low-income residents within and around an eligible TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions. The strategy should specifically address mitigations for the direct and indirect impacts from the demolition of any existing housing units.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects, especially for very low, low-, and moderate-income workers.
(b)An eligible TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)(A)Where housing is proposed, restrict at least 20 percent of the residential housing units for occupancy by very low and low-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years in the case of rental units and 45 years in the case of owner-occupied units, in addition to the replacement affordable housing units described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), with a priority on residential units for very low and low-income households.
(B)If a local jurisdictions inclusionary housing requirement mandates a higher percentage of affordable units or a deeper level of affordability than that described in subparagraph (A), then that jurisdictions affordability percentage requirements shall apply in place of the requirements in subparagraph (A).
(2)The district shall develop and implement an approach to evaluating affordable housing proposals that will consider a proposals quantity and depth of affordability, and the proposals validity and feasibility with respect to the requirements of this section.
(3)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable district labor policies, including the districts policy of requiring project stabilization agreements pursuant to district Resolution 5182 (November 17, 2011), In the Matter of a Policy Requiring Project Stabilization Agreements (PSA) with Local Hire Provisions on Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) Projects.
(c)On district-owned land within the districts boundaries, the district shall ensure that a total of 30 percent of housing units are affordable, with priority given to very low and low-income households. The district shall submit a biennial report to the Department of Housing and Community Development stating the percentage of units that are restricted as affordable units, by level of affordability, for all district TOD projects.
(d)The district may exempt specific TOD projects from the application of TOD zoning standards when the project is in the approval process with a local jurisdiction before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 29010.6.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 29010.9 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.9.(a)Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, a local jurisdiction may exercise full design review and conditional use permitting authority over any eligible TOD project that does not meet the conditions specified in subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7, except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 29010.7.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 7.Section 29010.10 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.10.(a)When the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development in substantial compliance with the provisions of Sections 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, and 29010.9. However, if Section 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, or 29010.9 is repealed, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with the eligible TOD project in substantial compliance with those provisions in effect at the time the agreement was entered into.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2031, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 8.Section 29010.11 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.11.(a)Before July 1, 2027, the district shall submit a report to the Legislature assessing whether the provisions of this chapter effectively accelerate, and improve the quality of, TOD at district stations.
(b)The report shall include all of the following:
(1)The average time to deliver TOD projects begun before January 1, 2019, and after January 1, 2019.
(2)A summary of the data on travel behavior and choices for TOD residents and workers.
(3)A summary of the housing affordability in district TOD projects begun after January 1, 2019.
(4)A summary of which TOD projects were delivered pursuant to a streamlined approval process and delivered pursuant to a discretionary approval process.
(5)A cost comparison of discretionary and ministerial TOD projects.
(6)Other factors the district determines to be pertinent to the Legislatures consideration of whether to extend the sunset dates applicable to this chapter.
(c)(1)A report to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this section is repealed on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 9.Section 29010.12 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.12.(a)This article shall not apply to a district station without unentitled or undeveloped land on July 1, 2018, unless that station entitlement expires. For this purpose, undeveloped land includes, but is not limited to, surface parking.
(b)This article shall not preclude or limit the ability of a developer to seek, or the application of, a density bonus, including concessions and incentives from a local government pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 10.The Legislature finds and declares that the serious shortage of affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit is a threat to the economic health of the state and jeopardizes the states ability to achieve its greenhouse gas reduction goals and is a matter of statewide concern and not exclusively a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 11.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The states economic health is significantly tied to the regional economic health of the San Francisco Bay Area. The growth and success of the Bay Areas economy is threatened by several challenges, including inadequate and unaffordable housing and excessive and increasing roadway congestion. In the state-mandated sustainable communities strategy for the Bay Area, locating affordable and market-rate housing near high-capacity transit is a primary tool with which to address these challenges and will keep the Bay Area on track to meet its state-mandated greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets.
(b)The San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) (district) is a product of the Legislature, drawing its power from the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Act (Part 2 (commencing with Section 28500) of Division 10 of the Public Utilities Code), which acknowledges the state-wide statewide interest in a well-functioning, cost-effective, and fiscally sustainable BART district network.
(c)Recognizing the above state-wide statewide interest, the state has granted BART the district land use and permitting authority to build transportation facilities such as parking structures, stations, and maintenance facilities. Since that authority was granted, it has only become clearer that making those facilities financially and environmentally sustainable requires that BART has the district have some level of authority over land use for housing. transit-oriented development.
(d)Transportation services are uniquely tied to land use patterns, as recognized by the Legislatures enactment of Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008, which integrated the development of sustainable communities strategies into regional transportation plans. Furthermore, BART the district itself is unique as a transit agency in that it is governed by an elected board, board of directors, granting the people of the San Francisco Bay Area a greater measure of input on BARTs the districts decisions than the constituents of other agencies have on their agencies. The district is also unique because of the number of daily rail passengers it serves. Because of BARTs the districts unique status, the Legislature, pursuant to this act, intends to solely grant BART the district an exception to the fundamental principle that cities and counties must be reserved land use authority by granting BART the district a measure of limited land use authority over the parcels it owns. owns in the immediate vicinity of its stations.
(e)The state has invested significantly in BARTs the districts infrastructure, which is estimated to be worth over twenty billion dollars ($20,000,000,000), and continues to invest tens of millions of dollars more for BARTs the districts operations every year. The state has an interest in leveraging the maximum benefits from this investment, including greenhouse gas emissions reductions, congestion reduction, air quality improvement, mobility enhancements, increased transit ridership, and increased affordable housing.
(f)For the above reasons, the authorizations in this act, which seek to deliver affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit, constitute an urgent matter of statewide concern.
SEC. 2.Section 29010.1 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.1.(a)For purpose purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Baseline TOD zoning standards means the minimum allowable density limits, the minimum allowable height limits, the minimum floor area ratio, and the highest allowable parking limits, to which the board is required to adhere to in adopting TOD zoning standards pursuant to Section 29010.6.(1)BART TOD place type means the place type described in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines (2017), as updated by the district.
(2)Eligible TOD project means a TOD project that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located is an infill site, as defined in Section 21061.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(B)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located was not acquired through eminent domain on or after July 1, 2019. 2018.
(C)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres and is acres, has at least 75 percent of its area located both within one-half mile of an existing or planned district station entrance entrance, and is located within an area represented on the board.
(D)The parcel or parcels on which the TOD project would be located has been is owned by the district since on or before July 1, 2020. district.
(E)For a TOD project relating to a district station that existed on July 1, 2018, both of the following requirements shall apply:
(i)The districts the TOD zoning standards and Section 29010.7 shall apply only to a parcel that is owned by the district on that date and to a parcel both that the district acquires after that date and that meets both of the following requirements: date.
(I)The parcel is contiguous, meaning not separated by a state controlled road, to an existing district-owned parcel within one-half mile of a station entrance.(II)The combined area of the parcel is no greater than 10 percent of the land area that the district owns within one-half mile of a station entrance.(ii)A development on land purchased by the district after July 1, 2018, shall be integrated into a TOD project, the majority of which shall be on land owned by the district on or before that date, and shall not be a stand-alone TOD project.(F)For a TOD project relating to a planned district station, it the district station has been approved by an ordinance or resolution adopted by the legislative body of each city or county the local jurisdiction with local land use zoning jurisdiction over the area in which the station is located.
(3)Floor area ratio means the gross floor area of an eligible TOD project divided by the land area of the parcel or parcels on which the eligible TOD project is built, where the land area excludes land dedicated to surface parking and circulation. ratio of gross building area of the development, excluding structured parking areas, proposed for the project, divided by the total area of the parcel or parcels used by the project, where gross building area means the sum of all finished areas of all floors of a building included within the outside faces of its exterior walls.
(4)Local jurisdiction means a city, including a charter city, a county, or a city and county.
(5)Planned district station means a station that has completed the California Environmental Quality Act review and for which construction is more than 75 percent funded.
(6)Station entrance means the entry point into an enclosed station structure, or, where that point is not clear or does not exist, the station fare gates.
(4)(7)TOD means transit-oriented development.
(5)(8)TOD project means any residential or commercial development project project, comprised of one or more buildings, wholly or partially on district land with 50 percent of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential units, uses, unless a locally adopted specific plan provides for a different percentage, or other metric, of residential units uses on district-owned parcels. If a locally adopted specific plan establishes a lower minimum residential use requirement for district-owned land, the specific plan metric shall serve as the minimum residential requirement.
(6)(9)TOD project area means the parcel or parcels of land on which a TOD project is situated.
(b)For purposes of this article, local jurisdiction includes a charter city.(c)(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.Section 29010.6 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.6.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall, consistent with Section 28793, adopt by ordinance transit-oriented development (TOD) TOD zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project.
(2)Zoning standards published in Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the baseline TOD zoning standards. Approved Adopted TOD zoning standards shall establish establish, for each district station, the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, minimum allowable floor area ratio, limit for height, density, and floor area ratio, and the highest permissible parking minimums and maximums, except that the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit for the TOD zoning standards shall be calculated as described in clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4). maximums. The zoning standards published in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum allowable density and height limits, and the highest allowable parking limits to which the board is required to adhere in adopting TOD zoning standards. The board shall not establish floor-area-ratio limits in the TOD zoning standards for each station type less than the number in the column titled residential target height multiplied by 0.6.
(3)In adopting the TOD zoning standards, the district shall establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.(3)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall not assign a lowest permissible height limit taller than the larger of the following two heights:
(A)The highest approved height as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7.
(B)One hundred fifty percent of the target height in the zoning standards published in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(4)(A)TOD zoning standards shall be adopted by July 1, 2020, and may be amended thereafter pursuant to this section.(B)(i)If the board, for any reason, fails to does not adopt new standards for a station by July 1, 2020, Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the TOD zoning standards, with the Transit Oriented Place Types identified in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017), until that time when the board adopts new TOD zoning standards. standards for that station.
(ii)In the case that Table 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) serves as the TOD zoning standards, standards for any stations, the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit shall be calculated for each station type by multiplying the number in the column titled residential target height by 0.6.
(5)The district is not required to establish TOD zoning standards for a station where, according to the districts assessment, it would be impractical to develop an eligible TOD project greater than one-half acre.
(5)(6)The TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station shall reflect the diversity of the different communities served by the districts stations.
(6)The board shall not establish floor-area-ratio limits in the TOD zoning standards less than the values described in clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4).(b)The adoption of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The district shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to relevant local jurisdictions and to communities of concern. concern around each station. Before or during the scoping meeting, the district shall meet with each jurisdiction in which the station is located, as well as any relevant infrastructure agencies. The consultation required pursuant to this section shall include all of the following:
(A)A review of the housing needs of the jurisdiction.
(B)A review of the TOD approved and built in the past year in the jurisdiction.
(C)A review of any TOD projects proposed by the district in the jurisdiction for the past year.
(D)A discussion of any obstacles to development of any project proposed by the district.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft standards available to the public.
(3)The board shall adopt or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as adopting the TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property, which shall be consistent with district station access access, district sustainability, and district TOD policy goals.
(d)(1)(A)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, standards for a station, the local jurisdiction shall adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were are adopted by the board. board for a station, or by July 1, 2022, if the board has not adopted TOD zoning standards for the station.
(B)The local zoning ordinance shall conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.(2)The district shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance conforms to the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the district determines that it does not conform to the TOD zoning standards. If, according to the districts finding, the local zoning ordinance does not conform to the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), July 1, 2022, the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any district-owned land parcels that are at least 75 percent within one-half mile of any existing or planned district station entrance in areas represented on the board. A For each station, a local jurisdiction may update zoning for district-owned land to comply with TOD zoning standards until such the time that the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for an eligible TOD project.
(3)If a local jurisdiction is in the process of adopting zoning consistent with the TOD zoning standards, including if the local jurisdiction is in the midst of a CEQA review review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) of proposed zoning, or engaged in a lawsuit related to zoning adoption, but has not completed the adoption of those zoning standards by the time the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, and if it is clear what the preferred zoning standards are, the district shall, to the extent it has the authority, follow the spirit of take into consideration the local jurisdictions proposed zoning standards in negotiating the districts development agreement with any potential eligible TOD project developer.
(4)By majority vote, the board may, for any specific station, exempt any local jurisdiction In cases where a local jurisdictions zoning for district-owned land within one-half mile of a district station, approved as of July 1, 2018, is within 10 percent of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) and values calculated by clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) the local jurisdiction shall be exempt from the application of the TOD zoning standards at any time up to the boards approval of TOD zoning standards in cases where the local zoning for that local jurisdiction was approved as of July 1, 2018, and is within 10 percent of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017). for that station. In this case, the parking requirements shall be set as the parking minimum and maximum established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(5)If district ridership is below 200,000 daily weekday riders on average for at least three consecutive calendar years, and that level of ridership is not related to a natural disaster, the requirements of this subdivision shall be inoperative, until district ridership rises above 200,000 daily weekday riders on average for a single calendar year.(e)(1)The districts approval of TOD zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). CEQA review. The district shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review for the TOD zoning standards.
(2)Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of eligible TOD projects proposed on district-owned land, shall incorporate the environmental review document certified for the TOD zoning standards consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. A public agency shall not prepare an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) to implement TOD zoning standards or for a TOD project subsequent to BARTs the districts certification of an environmental review document for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning or TOD project creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed, mitigated, or avoided in the prior environmental review document. analyzed in the prior environmental review document, and mitigated or avoided.
(f)In the event that the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(g)The district shall establish, and amend as necessary, a parking replacement policy, consistent with the districts practice at auto-dependent stations and the districts station access policy, with specific provisions to ensure that, after the construction of the eligible TOD project, auto-oriented auto-dependent stations are still accessible by private automobile. The policy shall specifically consider the parking replacement needs for auto-oriented auto-dependent end-of-the-line stations.
(h)For any station where district commuter parking is reduced as a result of a TOD project on land where TOD zoning standards apply, the district shall develop and fund an access plan that maintains station access for at least the number of customers affected by the reduced number of commuter parking spaces, which shall include specific consideration for customers who live further than one-half mile from the station.
(i)Local jurisdictions shall not do either of the following:
(1)Require that parking, as part of an eligible TOD project, be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the TOD project.
(2)Prohibit parking from being sold, rented, or otherwise assigned separately from other parts of the eligible TOD project.
(j)Zoning in effect as a result of this section shall be considered the same as locally approved zoning for all purposes, including the density bonus law and the Housing Accountability Act.
(h)(k)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 29010.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.7.(a)(1)This section shall only apply to an eligible TOD project that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)Is Has a height less than or equal to one story story, or 15 feet, above the highest local zoning restriction approved height for mixed use or residential use within a half-mile of a district station as of July 1, 2018. parcel or entrance on July 1, 2018, where highest approved height means the tallest height, including heights that require conditional approval, allowable pursuant to zoning, including the municipal code and any specific or area plan that covers the district station property.
(B)Has a floor area ratio of 2.5 or less. equal to or less than 0.6 times the number of stories that satisfies subparagraph (A).
(2)(A)If local zoning standards are more permissive allow for taller heights or larger floor area ratios than these requirements, the requirements in paragraph (1), this section shall apply to any project that meets the requirements of the local zoning standards.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to local zoning standards adopted for the purpose of complying with paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6 or to BART TOD standards that have become the local zoning pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 29010.6.
(3)This section shall not apply to a project where the local jurisdiction finds that the project will cause a specific adverse impact to public health and safety as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code. Code, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(b)(1)A developer in an exclusive negotiating agreement with the district may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit as specified in Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(2)An eligible TOD project that meets the requirements in subdivision (a) shall not be required to comply with the objective planning standards in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code to be eligible for streamlining, the streamlined, ministerial approval process, except as otherwise provided in this article.
(c)A developer of an eligible TOD project may apply for density bonus pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code. For purposes of an application submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), maximum allowable gross residential density, as that term is used in Section 65915 of the Government Code, includes the highest approved height, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), and the floor area ratio requirement described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). A project that meets the requirements of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) before the addition of any height increases, density increases, waivers, or concessions awarded through a density bonus shall remain eligible for streamlining under this section after the addition of a density bonus.
(c)(d)(1)The district shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines standards, insofar as those standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards, are included in a development agreement as general guidance to the TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design guidelines standards insofar as those guidelines standards do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, minimum floor area ratio, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
(d)Local jurisdictions may not do any of the following:(1)Require that parking, as part of an eligible TOD project, be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the TOD project.(2)Prohibit parking from being sold, rented, or otherwise assigned separately from other parts of the eligible TOD project.(e)(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 5.Section 29010.8 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.8.(a)The district shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or were subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents to levels affordable to persons and families of low or very low income, or subject to any other form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all those affordable housing units to the same or lower income level as a condition of any development on the parcel within the TOD project area.(1)Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of any of the following types of housing, within the last five years from the date of approval of the development agreement, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all of those housing units to the same or lower income levels:(1)Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of any of the following types of housing, within five years from the date of approval of the development agreement, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all of those housing units to the same or lower income levels:
(A)Housing that is subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents or sales prices to levels affordable, as defined in Section 50052.5 or 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to persons and families of moderate, lower, or very low income, as defined in Section 50093, 50079.5, 50093, or 50105 of the Health and Safety Code, respectively.
(B)Housing that is subject to any form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power.
(C)Housing that had been occupied by tenants within the last five years from the date of approval of the development agreement by a primary tenant who was low income and did not leave voluntarily.
(2)As a condition of any development on a parcel within an eligible TOD project area, replacement housing units for those described in paragraph (1) shall be subject to recorded affordability restrictions. In the case of the demolition of rental units, a rental unit, a replacement units unit shall be rental units a rental unit with restrictions for at least 55 years, with rent levels a rent level set at the same levels level as the previous restrictions or, if no rent restrictions were in place, at rents rent affordable, as defined in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to the most recent tenants to occupy tenant who most recently occupied the units, unit, or, if the income levels level of the most recent tenants tenant cannot be determined, at rents rent affordable to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower incometenents tenants unless the district or the TOD developer has offered offered, in writing, the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing unit that is available for occupancy by the displaced tenant within one-half mile of the same district station at a rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent, and the tenant has accepted or refused the offer. rent.
(4)Require that new units shall not be occupied sooner than the date that replacement affordable housing units are available to all eligible tenants that wish to be moved into replacement units pursuant to paragraph (3).
(5)Provide relocation assistance to lower income tenants directly displaced from housing units by an eligible TOD project pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 7260) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(6)Develop a strategy, in coordination with local jurisdictions, to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options and incentivize tenant protections for very low and low-income residents within and around an eligible TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions. The strategy should specifically address mitigations for the direct and indirect impacts from the demolition of any existing housing units.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects, especially for very low, low-, and moderate-income workers.
(b)An eligible TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)(A)Where housing is proposed, restrict at least 20 percent of the residential housing units for occupancy by very low and low-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years in the case of rental units and 45 years in the case of owner-occupied units, in addition to the replacement affordable housing units described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), with a priority on residential units for very low and low-income households.
(B)If a local jurisdictions inclusionary housing requirement mandates a higher percentage of affordable units or a deeper level of affordability than that described in subparagraph (A), then that jurisdictions affordability percentage requirements shall apply in place of the requirements in subparagraph (A).
(2)The district shall develop and implement an approach to evaluating affordable housing proposals that will consider a proposals quantity and depth of affordability, and the proposals validity and feasibility with respect to the requirements of this section.
(3)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable district labor policies. policies, including the districts policy of requiring project stabilization agreements pursuant to district Resolution 5182 (November 17, 2011), In the Matter of a Policy Requiring Project Stabilization Agreements (PSA) with Local Hire Provisions on Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) Projects.
(c)On district-owned land within the districts boundaries, the district shall ensure that a total of 30 percent of housing units are affordable, with priority given to low and very low-income very low and low-income households. The district shall submit a biennial report to the Department of Housing and Community Development stating the percentage of units that are restricted as affordable units, by level of affordability, for all district TOD projects.
(d)The district may identify exempt specific TOD projects that are from the application of TOD zoning standards when the project is in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 29010.6 that are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority. 29010.6.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 29010.9 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.9.(a)Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, a local jurisdiction may exercise full design review and conditional use permitting authority over any eligible TOD project that does not meet the conditions specified in subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7. 29010.7, except as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 29010.7.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 7.Section 29010.10 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.10.(a)When the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development in substantial compliance with the provisions of Sections 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, and 29010.9. However, if Section 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, or 29010.9 is repealed, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with the eligible TOD project in substantial compliance with those provisions in effect at the time the agreement was entered into.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2031, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 8.Section 29010.11 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.11.(a)Before July 1, 2027, the district shall submit a report to the Legislature assessing whether the provisions of this chapter effectively accelerate, and improve the quality of, TOD at district stations.
(b)The report shall include all of the following:
(1)The average time to deliver TOD projects begun before January 1, 2019, and after January 1, 2019.
(2)A summary of the data on travel behavior and choices for TOD residents and workers.
(3)A summary of the housing affordability in district TOD projects begun after January 1, 2019.
(4)A summary of which TOD projects were delivered pursuant to a streamlined approval process and delivered pursuant to a discretionary approval process.
(5)A cost comparison of discretionary and ministerial TOD projects.
(6)Other factors the district determines to be pertinent to the Legislatures consideration of whether to extend the sunset dates applicable to this chapter.
(c)(1)A report to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this section is repealed on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 9.Section 29010.12 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.12.(a)This article shall not apply to a district station without unentitled or undeveloped land on July 1, 2018, unless that station entitlement expires. For this purpose, undeveloped land includes, but is not limited to, surface parking.
(b)This article shall not preclude or limit the ability of a developer to seek, or the application of, a density bonus, including concessions and incentives from a local government pursuant to Section 65915 of the Government Code.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 10.The Legislature finds and declares that the serious shortage of affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit is a threat to the economic health of the state and jeopardizes the states ability to achieve its greenhouse gas reduction goals and is a matter of statewide concern and not exclusively a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 8.SEC. 11.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The states economic health is significantly tied to the regional economic health of the San Francisco Bay Area. The growth and success of the Bay Areas economy is threatened by several challenges, including inadequate and unaffordable housing and excessive and increasing roadway congestion. In the state-mandated sustainable communities strategy for the Bay Area, locating affordable and market-rate housing near high-capacity transit is a primary tool with which to address these challenges and will keep the Bay Area on track to meet its state-mandated greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets.
(b)The San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) is a product of the Legislature, drawing its power from the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Act (Part 2 (commencing with Section 28500) of Division 10 of the Public Utilities Code), which acknowledges the state-wide interest in a well-functioning, cost-effective, and fiscally sustainable BART network.
(c)Recognizing the above state-wide interest, the state has granted BART land use and permitting authority to build transportation facilities such as parking structures, stations, and maintenance facilities. Since that authority was granted, it has only become clearer that making those facilities financially and environmentally sustainable requires that BART has some level of authority over land use for housing.
(d)Transportation services are uniquely tied to land use patterns, as recognized by the Legislatures enactment of Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008, which integrated the development of sustainable communities strategies into regional transportation plans. Furthermore, BART itself is unique as a transit agency in that it is governed by an elected board, granting the people of the San Francisco Bay Area a greater measure of input on BARTs decisions than the constituents of other agencies have on their agencies. Because of BARTs unique status, the Legislature, pursuant to this act, intends to solely grant BART an exception to the fundamental principle that cities and counties must be reserved land use authority by granting BART a measure of limited land use authority over the parcels it owns.
(e)The state has invested significantly in BARTs infrastructure, which is estimated to be worth over twenty billion dollars ($20,000,000,000), and continues to invest tens of millions of dollars more for BARTs operations every year. The state has an interest in leveraging the maximum benefits from this investment, including greenhouse gas emissions reductions, congestion reduction, air quality improvement, mobility enhancements, increased transit ridership, and increased affordable housing.
(f)For the above reasons, the authorizations in this act, which seek to deliver affordable and market-rate housing in close proximity to high-capacity transit, constitute an urgent matter of statewide concern.
SEC. 2.Section 29010.1 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.1.(a)For purpose of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Baseline TOD zoning standards means the minimum allowable density limits, the minimum allowable height limits, the minimum floor area ratio, and the highest allowable parking limits, to which the board is required to adhere to in adopting TOD zoning standards pursuant to Section 29010.6.
(2)Eligible TOD project means a TOD project that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)The parcel on which the TOD project would be located is an infill site, as defined in Section 21061.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(B)The parcel on which the TOD project would be located was not acquired through eminent domain on or after July 1, 2019.
(C)The parcel on which the TOD project would be located forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres and is located both within one-half mile of an existing or planned district station entrance and within an area represented on the board.
(D)The parcel on which the TOD project would be located has been owned by the district since on or before July 1, 2020.
(E)For a TOD project relating to a district station that existed on July 1, 2018, both of the following requirements shall apply:
(i)The districts TOD zoning standards shall apply only to a parcel that is owned by the district on that date and to a parcel both that the district acquires after that date and that meets both of the following requirements:
(I)The parcel is contiguous, meaning not separated by a state controlled road, to an existing district-owned parcel within one-half mile of a station entrance.
(II)The combined area of the parcel is no greater than 10 percent of the land area that the district owns within one-half mile of a station entrance.
(ii)A development on land purchased by the district after July 1, 2018, shall be integrated into a TOD project, the majority of which shall be on land owned by the district on or before that date, and shall not be a stand-alone TOD project.
(F)For a planned district station, it has been approved by an ordinance or resolution adopted by the legislative body of each city or county in which the station is located.
(3)Floor area ratio means the gross floor area of an eligible TOD project divided by the land area of the parcel or parcels on which the eligible TOD project is built, where the land area excludes land dedicated to surface parking and circulation.
(4)TOD means transit-oriented development.
(5)TOD project means any residential or commercial development project wholly or partially on district land with 50 percent of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential units, unless a locally adopted specific plan provides for a different percentage, or other metric, of residential units on district-owned parcels.
(6)TOD project area means the parcel or parcels of land on which a TOD project is situated.
(b)For purposes of this article, local jurisdiction includes a charter city.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SECTION 1.Section 28765.5 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:28765.5.SEC. 3.Section 29010.6 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.6.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall shall, consistent with Section 28793, adopt by ordinance transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors. height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project.
(1)(2)Zoning standards published in the current Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. zoning standards. Approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, minimum allowable floor area ratio, and the highest permissible parking minimums and maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017). except that the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit for the TOD zoning standards shall be calculated as described in clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4).
(2)(3)In approving adopting the TOD zoning standards, the board district shall establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.
(3)TOD(4)(A)TOD zoning standards shall be approved by the board adopted by April 1, 2019, July 1, 2020, and may be amended by the board thereafter pursuant to this section. If
(B)(i)If the board board, for any reason, fails to approve adopt new guidelines standards by April 1, 2019, the existing July 1, 2020, Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, TOD zoning standards, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated identified in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017). (2017), until that time when the board adopts new TOD zoning standards.
(ii)In the case that Table 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017) serves as the TOD zoning standards, the minimum allowable floor-area-ratio limit shall be calculated for each station type by multiplying the number in the column titled residential target height by 0.6.
(5)The TOD zoning standards shall reflect the diversity of the different communities served by the districts stations.
(6)The board shall not establish floor-area-ratio limits in the TOD zoning standards less than the values described in clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (4).
(b)The approval adoption of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The board district shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to communities of concern.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines standards available to the public.
(3)The board shall approve adopt or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as approving adopting the TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property. property, which shall be consistent with district station access and district TOD policy goals.
(d)(1)(A)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction shall adopt an a local zoning ordinance that approves the application of conforms to the TOD zoning standards and is operative within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved adopted by the board.
(2)(B)The local zoning ordinance shall conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
(e)(2)The board district shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with conforms to the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the board district determines that it is inconsistent with does not conform to the TOD zoning standards. If, according to the boards districts finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with does not conform to the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), (1), the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned district-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART district station entrance in areas represented on the board. A jurisdiction may update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer the district enters into the development process. an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for an eligible TOD project.
(3)If a local jurisdiction is in the process of adopting zoning consistent with the TOD zoning standards, including if the local jurisdiction is in the midst of a CEQA review of proposed zoning, or engaged in a lawsuit related to zoning adoption, but has not completed the adoption of those zoning standards by the time the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, and if it is clear what the preferred zoning standards are, the district shall, to the extent it has the authority, follow the spirit of the local jurisdictions proposed zoning standards in negotiating the districts development agreement with any potential eligible TOD project developer.
(4)By majority vote, the board may, for any specific station, exempt any local jurisdiction from the application of the TOD zoning standards at any time up to the boards approval of TOD zoning standards in cases where the local zoning for that local jurisdiction was approved as of July 1, 2018, and is within 10 percent of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017). In this case, the parking requirements shall be set as the parking minimum and maximum established in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(5)If district ridership is below 200,000 daily weekday riders on average for at least three consecutive calendar years, and that level of ridership is not related to a natural disaster, the requirements of this subdivision shall be inoperative, until district ridership rises above 200,000 daily weekday riders on average for a single calendar year.
(f)(e)(1)The boards approval districts approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). The board district shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review. review for the TOD zoning standards.
(2)Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of eligible TOD projects proposed on BART-owned district-owned land, shall incorporate the environmental impact report review document certified for the TOD zoning standards consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. A public agency need shall not prepare an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BARTs certification of an environmental impact report review document for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed and mitigated analyzed, mitigated, or avoided in the prior environmental impact report. review document.
(g)(1)A TOD development proponent may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards.(2)This subdivision shall not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment have been met.(h)(1)The board shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.(f)In the event that the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(g)The district shall establish, and amend as necessary, a parking replacement policy, consistent with the districts station access policy, with specific provisions to ensure that, after the construction of the eligible TOD project, auto-oriented stations are still accessible by private automobile. The policy shall specifically consider the parking replacement needs for auto-oriented end-of-the-line stations.
(h)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 29010.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.7.(a)(1)This section shall only apply to an eligible TOD project that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)Is less than one story above highest local zoning restriction for mixed use or residential use within a half-mile of a district station as of July 1, 2018.
(B)Has a floor area ratio of 2.5 or less.
(2)If local zoning standards are more permissive than these requirements, this section shall apply to any project that meets the requirements of the local zoning standards.
(3)This section shall not apply to a project where the local jurisdiction finds that the project will cause a specific adverse impact to public health and safety as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code.
(b)(1)A developer in an exclusive negotiating agreement with the district may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit as specified in Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(2)An eligible TOD project that meets the requirements in subdivision (a) shall not be required to comply with the objective planning standards in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code to be eligible for streamlining, except as otherwise provided in this article.
(c)(1)The district shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement as general guidance to the TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, and maximum parking allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
(d)Local jurisdictions may not do any of the following:
(1)Require that parking, as part of an eligible TOD project, be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the TOD project.
(2)Prohibit parking from being sold, rented, or otherwise assigned separately from other parts of the eligible TOD project.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.SEC. 5.Section 28765.7 29010.8 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:28765.7.(a)Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.(b)The board may waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.(c)The board29010.8.(a)The district shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or were subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents to levels affordable to persons and families of low or very low income, or subject to any other form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all those affordable housing units to the same or lower income level as a condition of any development on the parcel within the TOD project area.(2)Require that tenants directly displaced from affordable housing units by a TOD project be prioritized for placement in(1)Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of any of the following types of housing, within the last five years from the date of approval of the development agreement, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all of those housing units to the same or lower income levels:
(A)Housing that is subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents or sales prices to levels affordable, as defined in Section 50052.5 or 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to persons and families of moderate, lower, or very low income, as defined in Section 50093, 50079.5, or 50105 of the Health and Safety Code, respectively.
(B)Housing that is subject to any form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power.
(C)Housing that had been occupied by tenants within the last five years from the date of approval of the development agreement by a primary tenant who was low income and did not leave voluntarily.
(2)As a condition of any development on a parcel within an eligible TOD project area, replacement housing units for those described in paragraph (1) shall be subject to recorded affordability restrictions. In the case of the demolition of rental units, replacement units shall be rental units with restrictions for at least 55 years, with rent levels set at the same levels as the previous restrictions or, if no rent restrictions were in place, at rents affordable, as defined in Section 50053 of the Health and Safety Code, to the most recent tenants to occupy the units, or, if the income levels of the most recent tenants cannot be determined, at rents affordable to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower income tenents unless the district or the TOD developer has offered the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing units unit within new developments located on BART-owned land. one-half mile of the same district station at a rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent, and the tenant has accepted or refused the offer.
(4)Require that new units shall not be occupied sooner than the date that replacement affordable housing units are available to all eligible tenants that wish to be moved into replacement units pursuant to paragraph (3).
(5)Provide relocation assistance to lower income tenants directly displaced from housing units by an eligible TOD project pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 7260) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(3)(6)Develop a plan strategy, in coordination with local jurisdictions, to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options and incentivize tenant protections for very low and low-income residents within and around a an eligible TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions. The strategy should specifically address mitigations for the direct and indirect impacts from the demolition of any existing housing units.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects. projects, especially for very low, low-, and moderate-income workers.
(d)A(b)An eligible TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)Include (A)Where housing is proposed, restrict at least a 20-percent minimum 20 percent of the affordable residential housing units for occupancy by very low, low-, and moderate-income low and low-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years in the case of rental units and 45 years in the case of owner-occupied units, in addition to the replacement affordable housing units described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), with a priority on residential units for very low, low-, and moderate-income low and low-income households.
(B)If a local jurisdictions inclusionary housing requirement mandates a higher percentage of affordable units or a deeper level of affordability than that described in subparagraph (A), then that jurisdictions affordability percentage requirements shall apply in place of the requirements in subparagraph (A).
(2)The district shall develop and implement an approach to evaluating affordable housing proposals that will consider a proposals quantity and depth of affordability, and the proposals validity and feasibility with respect to the requirements of this section.
(2)(3)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable BART district labor policies.
(c)On district-owned land within the districts boundaries, the district shall ensure that a total of 30 percent of housing units are affordable, with priority given to low and very low-income households. The district shall submit a biennial report to the Department of Housing and Community Development stating the percentage of units that are restricted as affordable units, by level of affordability, for all district TOD projects.
(e)(d)The board district may identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 28765.5 29010.6 that are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
(e)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 6.Section 29010.9 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.9.(a)Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, a local jurisdiction may exercise full design review and conditional use permitting authority over any eligible TOD project that does not meet the conditions specified in subdivision (a) of Section 29010.7.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 7.Section 29010.10 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:29010.10.(a)When the district enters into an exclusive negotiating agreement with a developer for the development of an eligible TOD project, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with development in substantial compliance with the provisions of Sections 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, and 29010.9. However, if Section 29010.6, 29010.7, 29010.8, or 29010.9 is repealed, that agreement shall confer a vested right to proceed with the eligible TOD project in substantial compliance with those provisions in effect at the time the agreement was entered into.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2031, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.SEC. 8.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors.
(1)Zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines shall serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(2)In approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.
(3)TOD zoning standards shall be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and may be amended by the board thereafter pursuant to this section. If the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(b)The approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to communities of concern.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public.
(3)The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
(d)(1)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction shall adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
(2)The local zoning ordinance shall conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
(e)The board shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards. If, according to the boards finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. A jurisdiction may update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
(f)(1)The boards approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). The board shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
(2)Any CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land shall incorporate the CEQA review for approval of TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible. An agency may not prepare CEQA documents on rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BARTs CEQA review of the approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed.(2)Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land, shall incorporate the environmental impact report certified for the TOD zoning standards consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. A public agency need not prepare an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BARTs certification of an environmental impact report for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed and mitigated or avoided in the prior environmental impact report.
(g)(1)A TOD development proponent may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment have been met.
(h)(1)The board shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
SEC. 2.Section 28765.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:28765.7.(a) Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(b)The board may waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(c)The board shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or were subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents to levels affordable to persons and families of low or very low income, or subject to any other form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all those affordable housing units to the same or lower income level as a condition of any development on the parcel within the TOD project area.
(2)Require that tenants directly displaced from affordable housing units by a TOD project be prioritized for placement in affordable housing units within new developments located on BART-owned land.
(3)Develop a plan to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options for very low and low-income residents within and around a TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects.
(d)A TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)Include at least a 20-percent minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households.
(2)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable BART labor policies.
(e)The board may identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 28765.5 that are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors.
(1)Zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines shall serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(2)In approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.
(3)TOD zoning standards shall be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and may be amended by the board thereafter pursuant to this section. If the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(b)The approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to communities of concern.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public.
(3)The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
(d)(1)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction shall adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
(2)The local zoning ordinance shall conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
(e)The board shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards. If, according to the boards finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines zoning standards after the two-year period specified in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. A jurisdiction may update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
(f)(1)The boards approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). The board shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
(2)Any CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land shall incorporate the CEQA review for approval of TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible. An agency may not prepare CEQA documents on rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BARTs CEQA review of the approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed.
(g)(1)A TOD development proponent may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards regardless of a local jurisdictions status regarding its regional housing needs allocation. standards.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment have been met.
(h)(1)The board shall ensure any otherwise applicable local design guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
(2)A TOD developer shall adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
SEC. 2.Section 28765.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:28765.7.(a) Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(b)The board may waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(c)The board shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or were subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents to levels affordable to persons and families of low or very low income, or subject to any other form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all those affordable housing units to the same or lower income level as a condition of any development on the parcel within the TOD project area.
(2)Require that tenants directly displaced from affordable housing units by a TOD project be prioritized for placement in affordable housing units within new developments located on BART-owned land.
(3)Develop a plan to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options for very low and low-income residents within and around a TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects.
(d)A TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)Include at least a 20-percent minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households.
(2)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable BART labor policies.
(e)The board may identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 28765.5 that are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) board of directors shall adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board of directors.
(1)Zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines shall serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(2)In approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.
(3)TOD zoning standards shall be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and may be amended by the board thereafter pursuant to this section. If the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
(b)The approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards shall comply with all of the following:
(1)The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on proposed standards or proposed changes to standards. The district shall conduct direct outreach to communities of concern.
(2)Not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the standards, the district shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public.
(3)The board shall approve or reject any proposed standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
(c)Before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board shall approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
(d)(1)Where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction shall adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
(2)The local zoning ordinance shall conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
(e)The board shall make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards. If, according to the boards finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after the two-year period specified in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. A jurisdiction may update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
(f)(1)The board's approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). The board shall serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
(2)Any CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land shall incorporate the CEQA review for approval of TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible. An agency may not prepare CEQA documents on rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BARTs CEQA review of the approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed.
(g)A TOD development proponent may submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards regardless of a local jurisdictions status regarding its regional housing needs allocation.
SEC. 2.Section 28765.7 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:28765.7.(a) Notwithstanding Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards. To the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
(b)The board may waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code.
(c)The board shall do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants:
(1)Require that parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or were subject to a recorded covenant, ordinance, or law that restricts rents to levels affordable to persons and families of low or very low income, or subject to any other form of rent or price control through a public entitys valid exercise of its police power, shall be subject to a policy that requires the replacement of all those affordable housing units to the same or lower income level as a condition of any development on the parcel within the TOD project area.
(2)Require that tenants directly displaced from affordable housing units by a TOD project be prioritized for placement in affordable housing units within new developments located on BART-owned land.
(3)Develop a plan to do both of the following:
(A)Increase affordable housing options for very low and low-income residents within and around a TOD project area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in MTCs regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due to changing market and development conditions.
(B)Deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects.
(d)A TOD project shall do both of the following:
(1)Include at least a 20-percent minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households.
(2)Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.4 of the Government Code and any other applicable BART labor policies.
(e)The board may identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 28765.5 that are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 1000, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 30, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 6, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 23, 2018 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 25 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 23, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 20, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 16). |
| Aug 13, 2018 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 2, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 28, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 27). |
| Jun 26, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (June 26). Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 20, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on T. & H. and GOV. & F. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (May 25). |
| May 25, 2018 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 23, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2018 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 26, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (April 23). |
| Apr 19, 2018 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 16, 2018 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Apr 12, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Apr 11, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 12, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and NAT. RES. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2018 | AB 2923 CHIU Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 23, 2018 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2923 Chiu et al. By McGuire | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2018 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 13, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2018 | AB 2923 CHIU Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2923
Amended: 8/17/18 in Senate
SENATE TRANS. & HOUSING COMMITTEE: 8-3, 6/26/18
AYES: Beall, Cannella, Allen, Dodd, Galgiani, Roth, Skinner, Wiener
NOES: Gaines, Morrell, Vidak
NO VOTE RECORDED: McGuire, Wieckowski
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/27/18
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara
NOES: Nguyen, Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/16/18
AYES: Portantino, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 42-32, 5/31/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California
State Building and Construction Trades Council (AFL-CIO)
DIGEST:
This bill requires, until January 1, 2029, cities and counties to adopt zoning standards in the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District’s (BART) transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines and establishes a streamlined approval process for certain projects on BART-owned land.
Existing law:
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, of the California Constitution, that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws. Local governments use their police power to enact zoning ordinances that shape development, including setting maximum densities for housing units, minimum numbers of required parking spaces, and setbacks to preserve privacy. These ordinances can also include conditions on development to address aesthetics, community impacts, or other particular site-specific considerations.
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 5, of the California Constitution, that it shall be competent in any city charter to provide that the city governed thereunder may make and enforce all ordinances and regulations in respect to municipal affairs, subject only to restrictions and limitations provided in their several charters and in respect to other matters that shall be subject to general laws. States that city charters adopted pursuant to the Constitution shall supersede any existing charter, and with respect to municipal affairs shall supersede all laws inconsistent therewith.
- Requires each county and city to adopt a general plan that sets out planned uses for all of the area covered by the plan.
- Establishes a streamlined, ministerial process for approving housing developments that are in compliance with the applicable objective local planning standards—including the general plan, zoning ordinances, and objective design review standards.
- Requires, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), state and local agencies to identify—and, where possible, mitigate—environmental impacts of projects.
- Creates BART as a special district to provide transit services in the San Francisco Bay Area. BART is governed by a nine-member board that is elected from districts that are based on BART’s service area. However, the parts of the BART system that lie south of the City and County of San Francisco on the Peninsula are not represented on the board.
This bill:
- Defines an “eligible TOD project” to mean a TOD project that meets all the following conditions:
- The project is located on an infill site, as defined in existing law;
- The land for the project was not acquired through eminent domain after July 1, 2018.
- The land for the project:
- Is owned by BART;
- Forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres;
- Has at least 75 percent of its area located within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance; and
- Is located within an area represented on the BART board.
- The project is on land owned by BART on July 1, 2018 if it is within a half mile of a station existing as of July 1, 2018;
- For a planned station, the BART station has been approved by the local jurisdiction with land use authority over that station and CEQA review has been completed for the station.
- Defines a “TOD project” to mean a project on BART land with 50 percent of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential uses, unless a local specific plan provides for a different amount of residential use on the site.
- Requires, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt TOD zoning standards for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio that apply to an eligible TOD project by July 1, 2020.
- Provides that adopted TOD standards establish, for each station, the lowest permissible height, density, and floor area ratio, and the highest maximum parking minimums and maximums.
- Sets the TOD standards in the 2017 version of BART’s TOD guidelines as the minimum standards, and establishes a maximum height of the greater of either:
- The highest approved height of in nearby areas, as defined;
- 150% of the target height in the 2017 BART TOD guidelines.
- Provides that if BART does not adopt standards by July 1, 2020, the standards in the 2017 TOD guidelines become the TOD zoning standards until BART adopts its own TOD standards.
- Establishes a minimum floor area ratio of 0.6 times the height designated in the TOD zoning standards, if no floor area ratio is designated by BART.
- Requires BART, prior to adopting TOD zoning standards, to:
- Hold a public hearing and conduct outreach to local governments and communities of concern around each station.
- Consult, in a specified manner, with each jurisdiction in which a station is located, as well as any relevant infrastructure agencies.
- Make available draft standards to the public 30 days before a hearing to consider adopting TOD zoning standards.
- Adopt standards at a separate hearing after the initial hearing, and approve travel demand management requirements prior to or simultaneously with the adoption of TOD zoning standards.
- Requires a city or county to adopt an ordinance that conforms to the BART TOD zoning standards within two years of BART adopting the standards, or by July 1, 2022 if BART has not adopted TOD zoning standards for a station.
- Requires BART to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards.
- Specifies that the local zoning remains in place unless the BART board determines that it is inconsistent with BART’s TOD zoning standards. However, if the local zoning standards are inconsistent after July 1, 2022, the TOD zoning standards become the local zoning for affected parcels.
- Allows a city or county to update its zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process and requires BART to take a city or county’s progress in adopting zoning standards under consideration in negotiating an agreement with a prospective developer, if local zoning is in the CEQA review process.
- Provides that if local zoning is within 10% of the standards specified in BART’s 2017 TOD guidelines and specified floor area ratios on July 1, 2018, the local jurisdiction shall be exempt from BART TOD zoning standards.
- Excludes stations without developable land from the TOD zoning standards.
- Provides that nothing in this bill affects the application of density bonus.
- Specifies that the adoption of TOD zoning standards is subject to CEQA review, and that BART is the lead agency for that review.
- Provides that any subsequent rezoning to conform to the TOD zoning standards shall incorporate the environmental review document adopted by BART, and prohibits a local agency from preparing an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a rezoning or for an eligible TOD project unless the rezoning or TOD project creates a significant impact on the environment that was not previously analyzed, mitigated, or avoided.
- Provides that TOD zoning standards are the controlling standards where there are inconsistencies with other local development regulations, and provides that TOD zoning standards in force as a result of this bill are the same as local zoning for all purposes.
- Establishes certain parking requirements for auto dependent stations and imposes certain constraints on local parking requirements.
- Allows an eligible TOD project to qualify for streamlined ministerial approval pursuant to existing law if it meets all of the following conditions:
- The project’s height is up to one story, or 15 feet, taller than the highest approved height for mixed use or residential use within a half mile of a BART station entrance;
- The project has a floor area ratio equal to or less than 0.6 times the height in (a);
- If greater than (a) or (b), local zoning standards.
- Excludes from streamlining projects that have a specific, adverse impact that cannot be mitigated.
- Allows a project eligible for streamlining to apply for a density bonus, as provided in existing law, and to retain streamlining even if it exceeds the height and floor area ratio specified in this bill.
- Requires BART to ensure that locally adopted design guidelines for projects eligible for streamlining are incorporated into an agreement with the developer, to the extent that it does not affect the standards in this bill.
- Authorizes a local jurisdiction to exercise full design review and conditional permitting for projects that do not qualify for streamlining.
- Provides a vested right for two years to an eligible TOD project that has entered into an exclusive negotiating agreement.
- Requires BART to take specified steps to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and prevent displacement of tenants, including:
- Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of specified housing affordable to moderate or lower income be subject to a policy that replaces those units within the TOD project and subjects the replacement units to a recorded affordability restriction.
- Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower income tenants unless the district or the TOD developer has offered, in writing , the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing unit that is available for occupancy by the displaced tenant within a half-mile of the same station at rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent.
- Prohibit the occupation of new units by new tenants until displaced tenants are provided the opportunity to relocate to those units.
- Provide relocation assistance consistent with existing law.
- Develop a strategy to increase affordable housing and deliver housing for essential workers in and around TOD projects, in coordination with local jurisdictions.
- Requires an eligible TOD project to restrict at least 20 percent of the units for occupancy at affordable rates by lower income households, or a higher percentage if required by a local ordinance. 30 percent of housing units must be affordable across all BART-owned land.
- Requires a project to comply with BART labor standards and labor standards in existing law for streamlined projects.
- Requires BART to report before July 1, 2027 on whether the provisions of the bill have increased housing development, including specified metrics.
- Sunsets this bill’s provisions, excluding the vested right, on January 1, 2029.
- Includes findings and declarations to support the purposes of the bill and that state the unique nature of BART as a transit district with an elected board.
Background
BART TOD guidelines and zoning standards. In May 2017, BART released a publication on its “Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines,” with the goal of beginning to implement BART’s previously adopted TOD policy. Among others, the purposes of the TOD Guidelines were to delineate what BART requires and encourages in TOD projects—such as building and street design, financial performance, partnerships and blending with the community—and to offer guidance to cities and developers in creating transit-supportive station area plans for the areas surrounding BART stations, TOD projects, and approvals within a half-mile of BART stations.
The TOD Guidelines state that BART-owned developable land, totaling 250 acres spread across 27 stations that are already built or under construction, offers a unique opportunity for TOD. The Guidelines assign each BART station a “place type”: regional centers, urban or city centers, and neighborhood or town centers. Regional centers are the central areas of San Francisco and Oakland; urban or city centers include Berkeley, other parts of Oakland and San Francisco, and other medium sized or centrally located Bay Area cities. Other cities including some in the North, East, and South Bay qualify as neighborhood or town centers.
Based on these place types, the guidelines specify zoning standards that BART identifies as conducive to TOD, including quantified standards for height, density, and parking, as follows:
Regional Center | Urban or City Center | Neighborhood or Town Center | |
Parking maximum | 1 space/unit; 2.5 spaces/1,000 sq. ft. | 0.5 space/unit; 1.6 spaces/1,000 sq. ft. | 0.375 space/unit; no office parking spaces |
Height minimum | 12 stories | 7 stories | 5 stories |
Density | 75 units/acre | ||
Seeking to encourage more transit-oriented development around BART stations, some local officials want to allow BART to modify local zoning requirements.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “to play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART’s TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area’s housing needs, reducing the Bay Area’s greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services. Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long --often more than a decade -- with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites. AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.”
- Land use questions. The California Constitution specifically grants cities and counties the exclusive ability among local governments to exercise police powers, which form the basis of local regulation of land use. California has developed a complex system for planning based on the premise that cities and counties are the agencies with this authority, which includes long-range planning for future development and infrastructure needs through general plans, zoning ordinances and other specific actions that carry out the general plan, and health and safety and design review standards. AB 2923 upends this system by taking land use decisions out of the hands of cities and counties and giving it to another local government by telling cities and counties that they must adopt BART’s standards. Granting land use authority to a local government that isn’t a municipality sets a significant precedent. Siting housing near transit is undoubtedly an important issue, but so are other concerns that are affected by land use patterns, such as managing the state’s water supplies or reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Other local agencies have significant roles to play in these issues: for example, water districts—which, like BART, have elected boards and are often regional governments—may be rightfully concerned with the pressures that new development places on water supplies. AB 2923 would grant a transit agency land use authority with the justification that dense housing near transit serves important state goals, but other local agencies may make a similar argument and request similar authority.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially significant state-mandated local costs for BART to adopt TOD zoning standards. Staff notes, however, that the bill allows BART to use its 2017 TOD Guidelines if it fails to adopt new standards by July 1, 2020. The Commission on State Mandates may determine that the bill does not impose a mandate on BART, since it functionally allows them to use existing guidelines in lieu of adopting new zoning standards. In addition, BART has general fare-setting authority. The Commission would ultimately determine whether any BART costs are reimbursable, to the extent a claim is filed. (General Fund)
- Unknown, likely significant state-mandated local costs for jurisdictions in the BART service area to adopt local zoning ordinances that conform to the district’s TOD zoning standards. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines these costs are reimbursable, there could be General Fund impacts. Staff notes, however, that cities and counties have general authority to adjust planning and permitting fees as necessary to cover administrative costs associated with new planning mandates.
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California (co-source)
State Building and Construction Trades Council (AFL-CIO) (co-source)
A. Philip Randolph Institute
350 Bay Area
Bay Area Council
Brightline Defense Project
California Apartment Association
California Asian Pacific Islander Chamber of Commerce
California League of Conservation Voters
California YIMBY
Center for Sustainable Neighborhoods
Circulate San Diego
City and County of San Francisco
Council of Infill Builders
Greenbelt Alliance
Habitat for Humanity
Local Government Commission
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Mission Hiring Hall
Natural Resources Defense Council
Northern California Carpenters Regional Council
San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
SMART, SMW Local Union No. 104
Sprinkler Fitters and Apprentices
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
SV@home
TransForm
Up for Growth California
YIMBY Action
Young Community Developers
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/23/18)
American Planning Association, California Chapter
Cities of Berkeley, Brentwood, Concord, Danville, Dublin, Fremont, Hayward, Lafayette, Livermore, Martinez, Novato, Orinda, Palmdale, Pittsburg, Pleasant Hill, Pleasanton, Riverside, San Ramon, and Walnut Creek
Contra Costa County Mayors’ Conference
County of Alameda
Debora Allen, BART Director, District 1
John McPartland, BART Director, District 5
League of California Cities
Tom Blalock, BART Director, District 6
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 42-32, 5/31/18
AYES: Arambula, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Cooley, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Reyes, Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Choi, Chu, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Harper, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Quirk-Silva, Salas, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Cooper, Quirk, Rodriguez
8/23/18 10:35:20
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2923
Author:(Chiu and Grayson)
As Amended Ver:August 17, 2018
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 42-32 | (May 31, 2018) | SENATE: | 26-13 | (August 23, 2018) |
Original Committee Reference: L. GOV.
SUMMARY: Requires, until January 1, 2029, cities and counties to adopt the zoning standards in the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District's (BART) transit-oriented development (TOD) guidelines and establishes a streamlined approval process for certain projects on BART-owned land.
The Senate amendments:
- Define the following terms:
- "Eligible TOD project" to mean a TOD project that meets all the following conditions:
- The project is located on an infill site, as defined in existing law;
- The land for the project was not acquired through eminent domain after July 1, 2018;
- The land for the project:
- Is owned by BART;
- Forms a contiguous area of at least 0.25 acres;
- Has at least 75% of its area located within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance; and,
- Is located within an area represented on the BART board;
- The project is on land owned by BART on July 1, 2018 if it is within a half mile of a station existing as of July 1, 2018; and,
- For a planned station, the BART station has been approved by the local jurisdiction with land use authority over that station and CEQA review has been completed for the station.
- "TOD project" to mean a project on BART land with 50% of the floor area of the project dedicated to residential uses, unless a local specific plan provides for a different amount of residential use on the site.
- "BART TOD place type" to mean the place type described in Table 1 and Figure 1 of the BART Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines (2017), as updated by the district.
- "Floor area ratio" to mean the ratio of gross building area of the development, excluding structured parking areas, proposed for the project, divided by the total area of the parcel or parcels used by the project, where "gross building area" means the sum of all finished areas of all floors of a building included within the outside faces of its exterior walls.
- "Local jurisdiction" to mean a city, including a charter city, a county, or a city and county.
- "Planned district station" to mean a station that has completed the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review for which construction is more than 75% funded.
- "Station entrance" to mean the entry point into an enclosed station structure, or, where that point is not clear or does not exist, the station fare gates.
- "Eligible TOD project" to mean a TOD project that meets all the following conditions:
- Require, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt TOD zoning standards for each station that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that apply to an eligible TOD project by July 1, 2020.
- Provide that adopted TOD standards establish, for each station, the lowest permissible limit for height, density, and floor area ratio, and the highest permissible parking minimums and maximums.
- Set the TOD standards in the 2017 version of BART's TOD guidelines as the minimum standards, and establishes a maximum height of the greater of either:
- The highest approved height of in nearby areas, as defined; or,
- 150% of the target height in the 2017 BART TOD guidelines.
- Provide that if BART does not adopt standards for a station by July 1, 2020, the standards in the 2017 TOD guidelines become the TOD zoning standards until BART adopts its own TOD standards for that station.
- Establish a minimum floor area ratio of 0.6 times the height designated in the TOD zoning standards for any stations, if no floor area ratio is designated by BART.
- Require BART, prior to adopting TOD zoning standards, to:
- Hold a public hearing and conduct outreach to local governments and communities of concern around each station;
- Consult, with each jurisdiction in which a station is located, as well as any relevant infrastructure agencies, and include all of the following during that consultation:
- A review of the housing needs of the jurisdiction;
- A review of the TOD approved and built in the past year in the jurisdiction;
- A review of any TOD projects proposed by the district in the jurisdiction for the past year; and,
- A discussion of any obstacles to development of any project proposed by the district.
- Make available draft standards to the public 30 days before a hearing to consider adopting TOD zoning standards; and,
- Adopt standards at a separate hearing after the initial hearing, and approve travel demand management requirements prior to or simultaneously with the adoption of TOD zoning standards.
- Require a city or county to adopt an ordinance that conforms to the BART TOD zoning standards for a station within two years of BART adopting the standards, or by July 1, 2022, if BART has not adopted TOD zoning standards for a station.
- Require BART to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Specify that the local zoning remains in place unless the BART board determines that it is inconsistent with BART's TOD zoning standards. However, if the local zoning standards are inconsistent after July 1, 2022, the TOD zoning standards become the local zoning for affected parcels.
- Allow a city or county to update its zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process and requires BART to take a city or county's progress in adopting zoning standards under consideration in negotiating an agreement with a prospective developer, if local zoning is in the CEQA review process.
- Provide that if local zoning is within 10% of the standards specified in BART's 2017 TOD guidelines and specified floor area ratios on July 1, 2018, the local jurisdiction shall be exempt from BART TOD zoning standards.
- Exclude stations without developable land from the TOD zoning standards.
- Require the TOD zoning standards adopted by the board for each station to reflect the diversity of the different communities served by the district's stations.
- Provide that nothing in this bill affects the application of density bonus.
- Specify that the adoption of TOD zoning standards is subject to CEQA review, and that BART is the lead agency for that review.
- Provide that any subsequent rezoning to conform to the TOD zoning standards shall incorporate the environmental review document adopted by BART, and prohibits a local agency from preparing an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a rezoning or for an eligible TOD project unless the rezoning or TOD project creates a significant impact on the environment that was not previously analyzed, mitigated, or avoided.
- Provide that TOD zoning standards are the controlling standards where there are inconsistencies with other local development regulations, and provides that TOD zoning standards in force as a result of this bill are the same as local zoning for all purposes.
- Establish certain parking requirements for auto dependent stations and imposes certain constraints on local parking requirements.
- Allow an eligible TOD project to qualify for streamlined ministerial approval pursuant to existing law, if it meets all of the following conditions:
- The project's height is up to one story, or 15 feet, taller than the highest approved height for mixed use or residential use within a half mile of a BART station entrance;
- The project has a floor area ratio equal to or less than 0.6 times the height in (a); and,
- If greater than a) or b), above, local zoning standards.
- Exclude from streamlining projects that have a specific, adverse impact that cannot be mitigated.
- Allow a project eligible for streamlining to apply for a density bonus, as provided in existing law, and to retain streamlining even if it exceeds the height and floor area ratio specified in this bill.
- Require BART to ensure that locally adopted design guidelines for projects eligible for streamlining are incorporated into an agreement with the developer, to the extent that it does not affect the standards in this bill.
- Authorize a local jurisdiction to exercise full design review and conditional permitting for projects that do not qualify for streamlining.
- Provide a vested right for two years to an eligible TOD project that has entered into an exclusive negotiating agreement.
- Require BART to take specified steps to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and prevent displacement of tenants, including:
- Require that any eligible TOD project that involves the demolition of specified housing affordable to moderate or lower income be subject to a policy that replaces those units within the TOD project and subjects the replacement units to a recorded affordability restriction;
- Prohibit the demolition of any unit occupied by lower income tenants unless the district or the TOD developer has offered, in writing , the tenant a commensurate or better replacement affordable housing unit that is available for occupancy by the displaced tenant within a half-mile of the same station at rent that does not exceed the tenants previous rent;
- Prohibit the occupation of new units by new tenants until displaced tenants are provided the opportunity to relocate to those units;
- Provide relocation assistance consistent with existing law; and,
- Develop a strategy to increase affordable housing and deliver housing for essential workers in and around TOD projects, in coordination with local jurisdictions.
- Require an eligible TOD project to restrict at least 20% of the units for occupancy at affordable rates by lower income households, or a higher percentage if required by a local ordinance. Thirty percent of housing units must be affordable across all BART-owned land.
- Require a project to comply with BART labor standards and labor standards in existing law for streamlined projects.
- Require BART to report before July 1, 2027, on whether the provisions of the bill have increased housing development, including specified metrics.
- Sunset this bill's provisions, excluding the vested right, on January 1, 2029.
- Include findings and declarations to support the purposes of the bill and that state the unique nature of BART as a transit district with an elected board.
AS PASSED BY THE ASSEMBLY, this bill:
- Allowed, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board.
- Required zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines to serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Specifies that approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Required the board to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type, in approving the TOD zoning standards.
- Required the TOD zoning standards to be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and allows them to be amended by the board thereafter, as specified. Specifies that if the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD GUIDELINES (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Required the approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards, to comply with all of the following:
- The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. Requires BART to conduct direct outreach to communities of concern;
- BART shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards; and,
- The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
- Required, before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board to approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
- Required, where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
- Required the local zoning ordinance to conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
- Required the board to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards.
- Required, if, according to the board's finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in 7), above, the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. Allows a jurisdiction to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
- Specified that the board's approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review). Requires the board to serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
- Required any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land to incorporate the environmental impact report (EIR) certified for the TOD zoning standards, as specified. Specifies that a public agency need not prepare an EIR or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART's certification of an EIR for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed and mitigated or avoided in the prior EIR.
- Allowed a TOD development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) have been met.
- Required the board to ensure that any otherwise applicable local design review guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
- Required a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
- Provided that in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, that the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards.
- Required, to the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, that the general plan be the controlling standard.
- Allowed the board to waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with the Government Code Section 65913.4, which is the section of SB 35 (Wiener) that allows a development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process if specified objective planning standards are met.
- Required the board to take specified actions to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, as specified.
- Required a TOD project to do both of the following:
- Include at least a 20% minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households; and,
- Comply with the labor requirements of Government Code Section 65913.14 (SB 35) and any other applicable BART labor policies.
- Allowed the board to identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to 1), through 3), above, that are proceeding with local zoning authority and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
- Required reimbursement to local agencies to be made, as specified, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by law.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially significant state-mandated local costs for BART to adopt TOD zoning standards. Staff notes, however, that the bill allows BART to use its 2017 TOD Guidelines if it fails to adopt new standards by July 1, 2020. The Commission on State Mandates may determine that the bill does not impose a mandate on BART, since it functionally allows them to use existing guidelines in lieu of adopting new zoning standards. In addition, BART has general fare-setting authority. The Commission would ultimately determine whether any BART costs are reimbursable, to the extent a claim is filed. (General Fund)
- Unknown, likely significant state-mandated local costs for jurisdictions in the BART service area to adopt local zoning ordinances that conform to the district's TOD zoning standards. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines these costs are reimbursable, there could be General Fund impacts. Staff notes, however, that cities and counties have general authority to adjust planning and permitting fees as necessary to cover administrative costs associated with new planning mandates.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "To play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART's TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area's housing needs, reducing the Bay Area's greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services.
"Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long - often more than a decade - with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites.
"AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth."
This bill is co-sponsored by the Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California and the State Building and Construction Trades Council.
- Constitutional Land Use and Zoning Powers for Cities and Counties. The California Constitution, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, states that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws. This power is often referred to as the "police power" and the courts have held that "It is from this fundamental power that local governments derive their authority to regulate land through planning, zoning, and building ordinances, thereby protecting public health, safety and welfare."
The California Constitution authorizes both general law and charter cities to: a) make and enforce all local laws and regulations not in conflict with general state laws; b) establish, purchase, and operate public works and utilities or franchise to do so; and, c) be free from state legislation delegating to a private person or body control over city property, funds, tax levies, and municipal functions. Whether a charter city may act independent of state general law in a particular domain depends upon a court's determination of whether it is a municipal affair or a matter of statewide concern.
- Override of Police Powers Delegated to Cities and Counties. According to the League of California Cities, in opposition, "Authorizing a transit agency to regulate density, height and parking requirements transfers this essential local government function from their hands to a single special district. Bestowing land use power onto a transit agency is contrary to existing law and may violate Article XI, Section 11 of the State Constitution. In In re Werner (1900) 129 Cal.567., the court struck down a state statute which granted a sanitary district the power 'to make and enforce all necessary and proper regulations from suppressing disorderly and disreputable resorts and houses of ill fame within the district and to determine the qualifications of persons authorized to sell alcohol.' The court held that the powers granted to the sanitary district violated Article XI, section 11 because the 'police power' must be exercised locally by cities and counties only (as provided by the Constitution)."
- Establishes Precedent for Future Diminishing of Local Land Use Planning. According to the American Planning Association, California Chapter, "APA California opposes altering state policy to replace local land use planning by allowing BART to zone its own property. This bill sets a precedent for other entities to request the same authority to zone their own properties however they wish. APA California believes the approach in AB 2923 will set a troubling precedent for further diminishing of local land use planning in future legislation."
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that the bill could potentially facilitate deployment of hundreds of new homes – both market-rate and affordable – precisely where they are needed, near major rail transit. Supporters also note that transit-oriented projects are notoriously contentious and approvals can take up to a decade, hindering development.
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents argue that the bill would override and undermine local planning efforts by cities and counties, and sets precedent for other special districts to ask for the same authority in the future. Opponents also point out that this bill would serve only to further BART's 'mission creep' by giving BART unchecked authority to greatly expedite development around stations instead of focusing on rebuilding the transit system.
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0004566
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 2923 (Chiu) - San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 2923 would require the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards that apply to TOD projects within ½ mile of a BART transit station, as specified. The bill would also require local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the BART TOD standards, when the local zoning in inconsistent with those standards.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 16, 2018
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant state-mandated local costs for BART to adopt TOD zoning standards. Staff notes, however, that the bill allows BART to use its 2017 TOD Guidelines if it fails to adopt new standards by July 1, 2020. The Commission on State Mandates may determine that the bill does not impose a mandate on BART, since it functionally allows them to use existing guidelines in lieu of adopting new zoning standards. In addition, BART has general fare-setting authority. The Commission would ultimately determine whether any BART costs are reimbursable, to the extent a claim is filed. (General Fund)
- Unknown, likely significant state-mandated local costs for jurisdictions in the BART service area to adopt local zoning ordinances that conform to the district’s TOD zoning standards. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines these costs are reimbursable, there could be General Fund impacts. Staff notes, however, that cities and counties have general authority to adjust planning and permitting fees as necessary to cover administrative costs associated with new planning mandates.
Author Amendments:
- Explicitly authorize a developer of a TOD project to apply for density bonus and provide that the project is still eligible for streamlining if the density bonus increases height or floor area ratio beyond what would otherwise qualify.
- Establish a formula for calculating the floor area ratio that makes a project eligible for streamlining, based off of the allowable height.
- Prohibit BART from adopting standards more restrictive than the current TOD Guidelines or more permissive than 150% of the current TOD Guidelines, or the highest locally approved height, as defined in the bill.
- Provide that zoning standards adopted under the bill must be treated the same as locally-adopted standards for all purposes.
- Require a meeting and consultation with affected cities, counties, and communities prior to adopting TOD standards.
- Provide that the bill no longer applies to newly acquired land around existing stations, stations that do not have developable land, or stations that have no undeveloped land.
- Provide that CEQA review of a TOD project on BART property is not required to analyze impacts that were previously analyzed and mitigated or avoided.
- Require a report on the effectiveness of the bill at increasing TOD construction, including housing built as a result of the bill.
- Require a plan to ensure that commuter parking at BART stations is not adversely affected.
- Clarify the types of affordable housing that must be replaced.
- Clarify that the bill doesn’t apply to parcels acquired through eminent domain after July 1, 2018.
- Clarify that the bill applies to parcels that are 75% within a half mile of a station entrance (so whole parcel doesn’t have to be within that radius)
- Allow locally-adopted specific plans to govern how much of a project must be residential and what the height and floor area ratio limits are, if applicable. Exempt BART from adopting standards for stations that do not have realistically developable land.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 2923 (Chiu) - San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 2923 would require the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards that apply to TOD projects within ½ mile of a BART transit station, as specified. The bill would also require local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the BART TOD standards, when the local zoning in inconsistent with those standards.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant state-mandated local costs for BART to adopt TOD zoning standards. Staff notes, however, that the bill allows BART to use its 2017 TOD Guidelines if it fails to adopt new standards by July 1, 2020. The Commission on State Mandates may determine that the bill does not impose a mandate on BART, since it functionally allows them to use existing guidelines in lieu of adopting new zoning standards. The Commission would ultimately determine whether any BART costs are reimbursable, to the extent a claim is filed. (General Fund)
- Unknown, likely significant state-mandated local costs for jurisdictions in the BART service area to adopt local zoning ordinances that conform to the district’s TOD zoning standards. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines these costs are reimbursable, there could be General Fund impacts. (See staff comments)
Background:
The California Constitution allows a city to "make and enforce within its limits, all local, police, sanitary and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws." It is from this fundamental power (commonly called the police power) that local governments derive their authority to regulate behavior to preserve the health, safety, and welfare of the public—including land use authority. Local governments use their police power to enact zoning ordinances that shape development, including setting maximum densities for housing units, minimum numbers of required parking spaces, and setbacks to preserve privacy. These ordinances can also include conditions on development to address aesthetics, community impacts, or other particular site-specific considerations.
BART is a rapid public transit system that connects the San Francisco Peninsula with Oakland, Berkeley, Fremont, Walnut Creek, Dublin/Pleasanton and other cities in the East Bay. BART operates over 112 miles of track and 46 stations, and a number of other stations are proposed for development. The district is governed by a nine-member board that is elected from districts that are based on BART’s service area. However, the parts of the BART system that lie south of the City and County of San Francisco on the Peninsula are not represented on the board. BART can hold and acquire property, including through the use of eminent domain, within and outside of its boundaries to carry out its powers, and can dispose of property when it is in the best interest of the transit system. BART can also hold and acquire property that is necessary for completing TOD joint development projects on property within one-half mile from the external boundaries of a BART facility, but cannot use eminent domain for these projects.
In May 2017, BART released a publication on its “Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines,” with the goal of beginning to implement BART’s previously adopted TOD policy. Among others, the purposes of the TOD Guidelines were to delineate what BART requires and encourages in TOD projects—such as building and street design, financial performance, partnerships and blending with the community—and to offer guidance to cities and developers in creating transit-supportive station area plans for the areas surrounding BART stations, TOD projects, and approvals within a half-mile of BART stations.
The TOD Guidelines state that BART-owned developable land, totaling 250 acres spread across 27 stations that are already built or under construction, offers a unique opportunity for TOD. The Guidelines assign each BART station a “place type”: regional centers, urban or city centers, and neighborhood or town centers. Regional centers are the central areas of San Francisco and Oakland; urban or city centers include Berkeley, other parts of Oakland and San Francisco, and other medium sized or centrally located Bay Area cities. Other cities including some in the North, East, and South Bay qualify as neighborhood or town centers. Based on these place types, the guidelines specify zoning standards that BART identifies as conducive to TOD, including quantified standards for height, density, and parking, as specified.
Proposed Law:
AB 2923 would require BART to adopt TOD zoning standards, by ordinance, that establish minimum local zoning requirements for height, density, parking, and floor area ratio only, that would apply to an eligible TOD project on BART-owned land within ½ mile of a station entrance. The 2017 BART TOD Guidelines would serve as the baseline zoning standards, as specified, and the adoption of standards would be subject to CEQA, with the district serving as the lead agency.
The bill would require local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards, to the extent local zoning is inconsistent with the district’s standards, and the local ordinance must be operative within two years of BART’s adoption of the standards. If the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, the TOD zoning standards will be the controlling standards.
The bill would also require BART to comply with specified requirements to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, require TOD projects to restrict at least 20% of residential housing units for occupancy by very-low- and low-income households, and require the district to ensure that 30% of the housing units on district-owned land are affordable, as specified.
These provisions would sunset on January 1, 2029.
Staff Comments:
This bill would impose a state mandated local program by requiring BART to adopt specified TOD zoning standards, by ordinance, and requiring local jurisdictions to adopt a local zoning ordinance that conforms to the BART standards. These local entities could incur significant administrative costs to perform the workload associated with these new duties. Staff notes, however, that BART has general fare-setting authority, and local jurisdictions have general authority to adjust planning and permitting fees as necessary to cover administrative costs associated with new planning mandates, which may disclaim any obligation for state-reimbursement. To the extent a local agency incurs direct costs associated with these requirements, however, and files a successful claim with the Commission on State Mandates, the bill could result in General Fund costs to reimburse those local costs.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | AB 2923 | Hearing Date: | 6/27/18 |
Author: | Chiu | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 4/30/18 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development
Requires local agencies to adopt zoning standards in the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District’s (BART) transit-oriented development guidelines.
Background
Land use regulation. The California Constitution allows a city to "make and enforce within its limits, all local, police, sanitary and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws." It is from this fundamental power (commonly called the police power) that local governments derive their authority to regulate behavior to preserve the health, safety, and welfare of the public—including land use authority.
Local governments use their police power to enact zoning ordinances that shape development, including setting maximum densities for housing units, minimum numbers of required parking spaces, and setbacks to preserve privacy. These ordinances can also include conditions on development to address aesthetics, community impacts, or other particular site-specific considerations.
The Planning and Zoning Law requires every county and city to adopt a general plan that sets out planned uses for all of the area covered by the plan. A general plan must include seven mandatory elements, including a housing element that establishes the locations and densities of housing, among other requirements. Cities’ and counties’ major land use decisions—including most zoning ordinances and other aspects of development permitting—must be consistent with their general plans. In this way, the general plan is a blueprint for future development.
Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff “ministerially” or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review, including design review and appeals processes. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review, which requires state and local agencies to identify—and, where possible, mitigate—environmental impacts of projects, while projects permitted ministerially are not.
California’s Housing Challenges. California faces a severe housing shortage. In its most recent statewide housing assessment, the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimated that California needs to build an additional 100,000 units per year over recent averages of 80,000 units per year for at least 10 years to meet the projected need for housing in the state. A variety of causes have contributed to the lack of housing production. Recent reports by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and others point to local approval processes as a major factor. They argue that local governments control most of the decisions about where, when, and how to build new housing, and those governments are quick to respond to vocal community members that may not want new neighbors. The building industry also points to CEQA review, and housing advocates note a lack of a dedicated source of funds for affordable housing.
SB 35 (Weiner, 2017). Last year, the Legislature enacted a substantial package of legislation aimed at addressing the state’s housing crisis. Among other legislation, the Legislature enacted SB 35 (Weiner, 2017) to provide for a streamlined, ministerial process for approving housing developments that are in compliance with the applicable objective local planning standards—including the general plan, zoning ordinances, and objective design review standards. In addition, to be eligible for streamlining under SB 35, a specified percentage of the total housing units in the development must be affordable to lower-income households (those under 80 percent of area median income), as follows:
- 10 percent, if the locality has not issued building permits for enough above-moderate income (>120 percent of area median income) units to meet their regional housing needs allocation (RHNA);
- 50 percent, if the locality has not issued building permits for enough lower-income units to meet their regional housing needs allocation; or
- The percentage in a local inclusionary zoning ordinance if it is higher than the requirements above.
SB 35 also included certain requirements for labor standards, such as the use of a skilled and trained workforce on an eligible project.
Transit-oriented development. Transit-oriented development (TOD), is commonly thought of as development that includes a mix of commercial, residential, office, and entertainment centered around or located near a transit station. These communities tend to be denser, more walkable, and with a greater diversity of uses than traditional zoning patterns.
Advocates for TOD suggest that successful TOD depends on access and density around the transit station: convenient access to transit fosters development, while density encourages people to use the transit system. They cite numerous benefits from TOD including:
- Increased ridership and associated revenue gains for transit systems;
- Incorporation of public and private sector engagement and investment;
- Revitalization of neighborhoods;
- Increased supply of affordable housing;
- Economic returns to surrounding landowners and businesses;
- Congestion relief and associated environmental benefits; and
- Improved safety for pedestrians and cyclists in the area.
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART). BART is a rapid public transit system that connects the San Francisco Peninsula with Oakland, Berkeley, Fremont, Walnut Creek, Dublin/Pleasanton and other cities in the East Bay. BART operates over 112 miles of track and 46 stations (four of these are combined with MUNI Metro stations and one is combined with CalTrain), and a number of other stations in the pipeline for development.
BART has its own statutes contained in the Public Utilities Code, which provide for the structure of the governing board, and the powers and duties of the district. BART is governed by a nine-member board that is elected from districts that are based on BART’s service area. However, the parts of the BART system that lie south of the City and County of San Francisco on the Peninsula are not represented on the board.
The BART board determines what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed and allows BART to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities. The board regulates such facilities, including by fixing rates and setting and enforcing regulations. BART’s statutes allow it to maintain a police department and establish an independent police auditor’s office.
BART can hold and acquire property—including through the use of eminent domain—within and outside of its boundaries to carry out its powers, and can dispose of property when it is in the best interest of the transit system. BART can also hold and acquire property that is necessary for completing transit-oriented joint development projects on property within one-half mile from the external boundaries of a BART facility, but cannot use eminent domain for these projects.
BART TOD guidelines and zoning standards. In May 2017, BART released a publication on its “Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines,” with the goal of beginning to implement BART’s previously adopted TOD policy. Among others, the purposes of the TOD Guidelines were to delineate what BART requires and encourages in TOD projects—such as building and street design, financial performance, partnerships and blending with the community—and to offer guidance to cities and developers in creating transit-supportive station area plans for the areas surrounding BART stations, TOD projects, and approvals within a half-mile of BART stations.
The TOD Guidelines state that BART-owned developable land, totaling 250 acres spread across 27 stations that are already built or under construction, offers a unique opportunity for TOD. The Guidelines assign each BART station a “place type”: regional centers, urban or city centers, and neighborhood or town centers. Regional centers are the central areas of San Francisco and Oakland; urban or city centers include Berkeley, other parts of Oakland and San Francisco, and other medium sized or centrally located Bay Area cities. Other cities including some in the North, East, and South Bay qualify as neighborhood or town centers.
Based on these place types, the guidelines specify zoning standards that BART identifies as conducive to TOD, including quantified standards for height, density, and parking, as follows:
Regional Center | Urban or City Center | Neighborhood or Town Center | |
Parking maximum | 1 space/unit; 2.5 spaces/1,000 sq. ft. | 0.5 space/unit; 1.6 spaces/1,000 sq. ft. | 0.375 space/unit; no office parking spaces |
Height minimum | 12 stories | 7 stories | 5 stories |
Density | 75 units/acre | ||
Seeking to encourage more transit-oriented development around BART stations, some local officials want to allow BART to modify local zoning requirements.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 2923 requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards on specified parcels of land it owns, and requires affected cities and counties to update zoning to be consistent with BART's zoning standards within two years.
Adoption of TOD standards. AB 2923 requires, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt TOD zoning standards that apply to land that meets all of the following conditions:
- Owned by BART;
- Located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres;
- Located within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance; and
- Located in areas having representation on the BART board.
AB 2923 establishes the zoning standards published in the current BART TOD Guidelines to serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning and specifies that approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by the BART TOD Guidelines. The bill also requires the board to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type, in approving the TOD zoning standards.
AB 2923 requires the TOD zoning standards to be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and allows them to be amended by the board thereafter, as specified. If the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing BART TOD Guidelines serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions based on place types identified in the Guidelines.
AB 2923 requires a public hearing for comments on any proposed TOD zoning standards and requires BART to conduct direct outreach to communities of concern. It must also provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public at least 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards. The board must approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards separate public hearing at least 30 days after the first hearing. When approving TOD zoning standards, the board must also approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on BART-owned property.
Local zoning conformity. If local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards adopted by BART, AB 2923 requires the applicable city or county to adopt an ordinance that conforms to the TOD zoning standards within two years of approval by the BART board. AB 2923 specifies that the local zoning ordinance must conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
The BART board must then make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. AB 2923 specifies that the local zoning remains in place unless the BART board determines that it is inconsistent with BART’s TOD zoning standards. However, if the local zoning standards are inconsistent after the end of the two-year period that local agencies have to conform to BART’s standards, the TOD zoning standards become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. AB 2923 allows a city or county to update its zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
CEQA. AB 2923 specifies that the board's approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards are subject to CEQA review and provides that the board is the lead agency for that review. Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land, must incorporate the environmental impact report (EIR) certified for the TOD zoning standards, as specified.
AB 2923 also provides that a public agency need not prepare an EIR or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART's certification of an EIR for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed and mitigated or avoided in the prior EIR.
Development approvals and SB 35. AB 2923 allows a TOD development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process enacted by SB 35 if the development satisfies those objective planning standards specified in SB 35 that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards. However, the bill’s streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable RHNA obligations have been met.
Notwithstanding the requirements of SB 35, if the TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, AB 2923 makes the TOD zoning standards the controlling standards. If there are still inconsistencies, the general plan becomes the controlling standard. However, AB 2923 allows the board to waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with the provisions of SB 35.
The bill also allows the BART board to identify specific TOD projects that have entered the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of BART’s TOD zoning standards, and that are proceeding with local zoning authority and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
Other project conditions. At least 20 percent of the units in the TOD project must be set aside for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years, and the project must comply with both SB 35’s labor requirements and BART labor policies.
The bill also requires the board to take specified actions to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, specifically:
- If a parcel has had residential uses that were subject to affordability restrictions or rent control, those units must be replaced at the same or lower income level;
- Tenants directly displaced from affordable housing units get priority for affordable housing within the new TOD development;
- BART must also develop a plan to increase affordable housing options for very low- and low-income residents within and around a TOD project area, and deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects.
AB 2923 requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines, as long as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards. The bill also directs the BART board to ensure that any otherwise applicable local design review guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “to play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART’s TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area’s housing needs, reducing the Bay Area’s greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services. Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long --often more than a decade -- with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites. AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.”
2. Land use questions. The California Constitution specifically grants cities and counties the exclusive ability among local governments to exercise police powers, which form the basis of local regulation of land use. California has developed a complex system for planning based on the premise that cities and counties are the agencies with this authority, which includes long-range planning for future development and infrastructure needs through general plans, zoning ordinances and other specific actions that carry out the general plan, and health and safety and design review standards. AB 2923 upends this system by taking land use decisions out of the hands of cities and counties and giving it to another local government by telling cities and counties that they must adopt BART’s standards. This approach raises several significant concerns:
- Given the constitutional nature of cities’ and counties’ police powers, it is unclear whether it is constitutional to delegate those powers to another local government. Specifically, in evaluating whether the Legislature may give sanitary districts the power to regulate the sale of alcohol, the California Supreme Court ruled: “The question here is whether the Legislature can graft upon an act designed for some local improvement, such as drainage, irrigation, or sanitary district, a subject entirely foreign to the purposes of such act, and a subject also which clearly falls within the police powers possessed by cities and other like corporations formed and organized for governmental purposes. Under the rule of construction, Expressio unius estexclusio alterius, the Legislature has no authority to create other public corporate bodies — whether called districts or by any other name — and clothe them with the power to make and enforce local, police, sanitary, and other regulations conferred by the constitution upon counties, cities, towns, or townships.” (In re Werner (1900) 129 Cal.567).
- In line with the above, BART is a transit district, the purpose of which is to provide a rapid transit system for the transport of passengers. Unlike cities and counties, BART is neither charged with, nor provided the authority to, provide for the general welfare of citizens within its jurisdiction. Yet, land use planning requires balancing many competing interests—such as public safety, exposure to pollution, infrastructure adequacy, and aesthetic impacts—in a manner that is most appropriately situated with a general-purpose government like a city or a county. Because of its singular purpose and focus on transportation service, BART may not be an appropriate entity to consider all the complexities of land use planning.
- Granting land use authority to a local government that isn’t a municipality sets a significant precedent. Siting housing near transit is undoubtedly an important issue, but so are other concerns that are affected by land use patterns, such as managing the state’s water supplies or reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Other local agencies have significant roles to play in these issues: for example, water districts—which, like BART, have elected boards and are often regional governments—may be rightfully concerned with the pressures that new development places on water supplies. AB 2923 would grant a transit agency land use authority with the justification that dense housing near transit serves important state goals, but other local agencies may make a similar argument and request similar authority. The Committee may wish to consider what other local agencies might ask for land use authority next if AB 2923 is enacted.
- AB 2923 allows BART to adopt minimum zoning standards that override city or county requirements if they are inconsistent. Currently, the bill specifies that the existing TOD Guidelines form the baseline standards for height, parking, and density, as well as requiring BART to adopt floor-area-ratio limits. However, nothing in the bill limits BART to these zoning standards. Future editions of the Guidelines may further encroach on local authority to include lot coverage requirements, minimum lot sizes, and even design requirements.
- The general plan is often called the “constitution for future development.” It serves an important role in shaping the location and type of development that will occur, ensuring that there is adequate infrastructure to support that development, providing adequate open space, and mitigating future risks from fire, floods, and climate change. Furthermore, the housing element within a city or county’s general plan is intended to ensure that local governments adequately plan for housing. In fact, state law requires HCD to approve each city and county’s housing element. Zoning ordinances then effectuate the requirements in the housing element and general plan. AB 2923 undermines the planning process by allowing BART’s TOD standards to trump a city or county’s general plan, potentially exposing new development to safety risks, allowing development without adequate infrastructure, or, depending on the whims of future BART boards, limiting the ability of local governments to comply with state housing laws.
- AB 2923 provides that it applies to planned stations, which grants BART the ability to further expand its land use authority simply by deciding to site a station somewhere. This creates the potential for greenfield development that eliminates valuable open space, rather than encouraging infill development that is consistent with state policies.
- The minimum standards in BART’s current TOD Guidelines may be significantly out of scale with the shape and size of development in nearby communities due to the minimum heights of five to 12 stories authorized by the bill.
To address some of these concerns, the Committee may wish to consider amending AB 2923 as follows:
- Incorporate findings and declarations making the case that BART is unique as an entity with both transportation responsibilities and an elected board, which justifies granting it the unique ability to regulate land use;
- Specify the types of zoning standards that BART is limited to enacting, including height, density, parking, and FAR; and
- Provide a method for calculating FAR based on height in the TOD guidelines; and
- Prohibit local governments from requiring parking to be associated with specific elements of a TOD project, so long as the project meets the bill’s parking requirements overall.
3. Master of its domain. AB 2923 raises several concerns about displacement of vulnerable populations. First, because AB 2923 only applies to BART-owned parcels, it provides a substantial incentive for BART to acquire new property. BART possesses the power to take property by eminent domain, although it cannot directly take property for TOD in this manner. It is less clear whether BART could take property through eminent domain for proposed transit facilities and then later, when those facilities do not materialize, develop housing on it. Even without eminent domain, BART will be able to pay much higher rates for land than other prospective buyers: as soon as BART buys the land, much more development is permitted on that parcel, and the value of the parcel increases dramatically. Second, the bill provides that where rent controlled or otherwise affordable units are demolished, they must be replaced, and those residents get priority for placement in the new development. But experience has shown that because housing can take a long time to get built, individuals often relocate to new areas and don’t return once they’ve been displaced. Finally, the new developments constructed as a result of this bill could result in gentrification of nearby areas. However, AB 2923 does not mandate that any of that housing be affordable to lower-income families—it could be entirely affordable to moderate-income families. As a result, AB 2923 may not sufficiently protect lower-income households from the displacement that may occur as nearby rents rise to reflect new amenities or interest in the area. To ensure that displacement is minimized and that adequate affordable housing is developed for those families that may be forced out due to gentrification, the Committee may wish to consider amending AB 2923 to:
- Explicitly prohibit the applicability of the bill to parcels acquired through eminent domain;
- Restrict the applicability of the bill to only infill parcels already owned by BART;
- Require 20 percent of the units to be affordable to low- and very low-income households, and establish a 30 percent requirement for moderate-, low-, and very low-income household affordability throughout the BART system; and
- Require that a majority of the floor area of any BART development be dedicated to residential units.
4. Not so fast. Last year, the Legislature spent considerable time and effort negotiating a compromise to allow for some streamlined, ministerial approval of housing. The result of that negotiation was SB 35, which requires compliance with local zoning and general plans and imposes a long list of conditions in order for projects to be eligible. These conditions emerged in part out of concern that going through a ministerial approval process exempts a project from CEQA review, which would ordinarily ensure that there are no significant impacts to people or the environment. But AB 2923 provides that BART’s TOD zoning standards become the controlling standards when determining what projects qualify for SB 35’s streamlined approval, and a project only has to satisfy those conditions in SB 35 that are consistent with BART’s TOD zoning standards. As a result, a much wider range of projects will be eligible for streamlining under this bill. This undermines the balance that SB 35 struck to speed project approval while ensuring that there wouldn’t be significant impacts from these projects. In addition, AB 2923 eviscerates an important affordable housing component of SB 35. Specifically, SB 35 required 50 percent of the units to be affordable if a jurisdiction has not met its lower-income RHNA requirements. Because this is inconsistent with the 20 percent affordability requirement in the bill, a project that under current law would need to provide 50 percent affordable units would now only need to provide 20 percent, which could be entirely moderate-income. Finally, the Legislature enacted SB 35 to provide streamlining only for those parcels that are consistent with all local standards. Yet AB 2923 would allow streamlining to be applied to projects that exceed current zoning and the general plan. To avoid these various consequences, the Committee may wish to consider amending AB 2923 to:
- Limit bill’s modified SB 35 process to only projects that are under local maximum height, density, and FAR as of July 1, 2018;
- For projects below current zoning that do not qualify for streamlining, allow narrower CEQA analysis that only examines the aspects of a development that make it inconsistent with the bill’s modified SB 35 process;
- Expressly authorize conditional use permitting and full design review for buildings above local maximum height, density, and FAR as of July 1, 2018.
5. Whither CEQA? In addition to expanding the applicability of streamlining under SB 35, AB 2923 further eliminates another element of CEQA review by exempting rezoning from going through CEQA. Specifically, AB 2923 provides for CEQA review of the adoption of BART’s Guidelines, but because the bill designates BART as the lead agency in charge of determining what impacts must be mitigated, it is unclear whether BART would impose all the mitigation measures required to truly reduce a project’s impacts, particularly if the necessary measures would increase costs for the project or make it infeasible. In addition, the bill provides that local agencies need not complete CEQA review for their rezoning. Supporters of the bill argue that this local level of CEQA review is redundant with the BART CEQA process provided by the bill. However, without going through this level of CEQA analysis, cities and counties would have limited means of ensuring that the impacts of development enabled by this zoning are mitigated, and opportunities for public input from affected local communities would be severely constrained. Regardless, the current phrasing of the bill is unclear: “need not” could imply a choice on the part of the local agency, and the bill refers to EIRs when those are not the only CEQA documents that can be produced. Should the Committee concur that this second level of review is unnecessary, the Committee may wish to consider amending AB 2923 to clarify that a local agency “shall not” perform CEQA review and make additional technical changes regarding the CEQA documents that BART and the local government must or must not prepare.
5. Sure, but will it work? The premise of AB 2923 is that local officials, responding to the will of their constituents, are unwilling to permit higher-density housing on parcels near BART stations. AB 2923 therefore proposes to shift land use authority to a different elected local governing body—the BART board of directors—to loosen those restrictions. But if elected officials responding to the will of their constituents is the source of this problem, shifting to another elected body may not solve the problem. Once BART assumes control of local zoning, its members may become subject to similar electoral pressures as other local officials, potentially resulting in anti-development board members being elected who may reduce the TOD guidelines to more closely match local preferences on development. Furthermore, if the goal is to increase housing density near transit, it is unclear why BART-owned parcels should be afforded special status, instead of all parcels near BART stations. If increased density near transit stations is to be a statewide priority, the Legislature may be more likely to achieve its goals by simply mandating that certain zoning rules apply to areas around BART and other transit stations and allowing local planning processes. Alternatively, the Committee may wish to consider amending AB 2923 to contain a 10-year sunset and include a provision that the bill’s terms become inactive if BART ridership drops below a threshold number.
6. Incoming! The Senate Transportation and Housing Committee will hear AB 2923 at its June 26th meeting. Should it pass that committee, the Senate Governance and Finance Committee will hear AB 2923 as the committee of second reference.
7. Mandate. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local governments for the costs of new or expanded state mandated local programs. Because AB 2923 requires cities and counties to conform to BART’s TOD zoning standards and imposes new duties on BART, Legislative Counsel says that it imposes a new state mandate. The measure states that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill imposes a reimbursable mandate, reimbursement must be made pursuant to existing statutory provisions.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Local Government Committee: 5-3
Assembly Natural Resources Committee: 7-3
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 12-4
Assembly Floor: 42-34
Support and Opposition
(6/22/18)
Support: State Building and Construction Trades Council (AFL-CIO) (Co-Sponsor); A. Philip Randolph Institute; 350 Bay Area; Bay Area Council; Brightline Defense Project; California Apartment Associaiton; California Asian Pacific Islander Chamber of Commerce; California League of Conservation Voters; California YIMBY; Circulate San Diego; City and County of San Francisco; Council of Infill Builders; Greenbelt Alliance; Habitat for Humanity; Local Government Commission; Metropolitan Transportation Commission; Mission Hiring Hall; Natural Resources Defense Council; Northern California Carpenters Regional Council; Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California; San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry; San Francisco Housing Action Coalition; SMART, SMW Local Union No. 104; Sprinkler Fitters and Apprentices; San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association; Silicon Valley Leadership Group; SV@home; TransForm; Up for Growth California; YIMBY Action; Young Community Developers.
Opposition: Alameda County Board of Supervisors; City of Fremont; City of Hayward; City of Lafayette; City of Novato; City of Pleasant Hill; League of California Cities.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING
Senator Jim Beall, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 6/26/2018
Author: | Chiu | ||
Version: | 4/30/2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Erin Riches | ||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards on specified parcels of land owned by BART, and requires affected cities and counties to update their zoning within two years to be consistent with BART’s standards.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes BART to acquire property, including by eminent domain, in order to operate its transit system within its jurisdiction.
- Authorizes BART to accept or acquire property within one-quarter of a mile from the external boundaries of a BART facility to use for TOD.
- For purposes of implementing a sustainable communities strategy, defines a “transit priority project” as a residential or mixed-use residential development within one-half mile of a major transit stop or high-quality transit center.
- For purposes of establishing an enhanced infrastructure financing district (EIFD), authorizes transit priority projects within one-half mile of a major transit stop or a high-quality transit center to qualify as an EIFD project.
- Provides that a transit village development district shall include all land within not more than one-half mile of the main entrance of a transit station.
- Requires the state’s metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) to meet specific greenhouse gas reduction targets set by the state Air Resources Board through a variety of strategies, including the development of TOD.
This bill:
- Requires the BART board of directors (BART board) to adopt TOD zoning standards (BART standards), by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting, that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land located on contiguous parcels of at least 0.25 acres, within ½ mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board.
- Requires the current BART Guidelines to serve as the baseline for the BART standards and requires the approved BART standards to establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and highest permissible parking maximums, per the 2017 BART guidelines.
- Requires the BART board, in approving the BART standards, to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type.
- Requires the BART board to approve the BART standards by April 1, 2019 and authorizes the BART board to amend them subsequently. If the BART board fails to approve new guidelines by that date, the 2017 BART Guidelines shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions.
- Requires approval of, and amendments to, the BART standards to comply with all of the following:
- The BART board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed BART standards or proposed changes to the BART standards. The BART district shall conduct direct outreach to communities of concern.
- BART shall provide public notice, and make the draft guidelines available to the public, at least 30 days before a public hearing of the BART board to consider the BART standards.
- The BART board shall approve or reject any proposed BART standards at a publicly noticed meeting not less than 30 days after the original public hearing.
- Requires the BART board, prior to or at the same time as approving the BART standards, to approve travel demand management requirements for TOD zoning projects on BART-owned property.
- Requires the local jurisdiction, where local zoning is inconsistent with the BART standards, to adopt an ordinance applying the BART standards, within two years of BART board approval of the BART standards. Requires the local zoning ordinance to conform to the BART standards without any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
- Requires, that if the BART board finds that the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the BART standards after the required two-year period, the BART standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within ½ mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance.
- Requires the BART board’s approval of the BART standards and local zoning standards to be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and requires the BART board to serve as the lead agency for CEQA review. Requires any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform to the BART standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land, to incorporate the environmental impact report (EIR) certified for the BART standards. Exempts a public agency from preparing an EIR or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning subsequent to BART’s certification of an EIR unless the agency finds that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not addressed in the prior EIR.
- Allows a TOD developer to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process pursuant to SB 35 (Wiener, 2017) if the development satisfies the objective planning standards and are consistent with the BART standards. Specifies that the streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction that has met its regional housing assessment (RHNA) obligations.
- Requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines provided they do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the BART standards.
- Provides that, to the extent that the BART standards are inconsistent with objective planning, general plan, or design review standards, the BART standards shall be the controlling standards, notwithstanding SB 35 (Wiener, 2017). To the extent that the BART standards do not resolve inconsistencies, the general plan shall be the controlling standard.
- Authorizes the BART board to waive any requirement it finds to be inconsistent with SB 35.
- Requires the BART board to do all of the following to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent direct displacement of tenants:
- Require parcels that currently have residential uses, or within the past five years have had residential uses that have been vacated or demolished, that are or have been subject to affordability covenants or rent restrictions, to replace affordable housing units to the same or lower income level.
- Requires tenants displaced from affordable units by a TOD project to be prioritized for placement in affordable housing units in new BART TOD developments.
- Develop a plan to increase affordable housing options for very-low and low-income residents within and around a TOD area, particularly in communities of concern, as defined in the Metropolitan Transportation Commission’s regional transportation plan, where there is potential for residential displacement due a changing market and development conditions, and to deliver housing for essential workers within and around TOD projects.
- Requires a TOD project to do both of the following:
- Set aside at least 20% of units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a 55-year affordability restriction.
- Comply with prevailing wage and skilled and trained workforce requirements established by SB 35 and any other applicable BART labor policies.
- Authorizes the BART board to identify specific TOD projects in the approval process with a local jurisdiction, on or before imposition of the BART standards, which are proceeding with local zoning approval and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
COMMENTS
- Purpose. The author states that to play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, as well as 4.5 million square feet of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The author states that unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities because historically, TOD projects have taken too long so BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites. The author states that this bill will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. The author states that these projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.
- What is TOD? TOD is a type of urban development that maximizes the amount of residential, business, and leisure space within walking distance of public transport. TODs typically include a central transit stop (such as a train station, light rail, or bus stop) surrounded by a high-density mixed-use area, with lower-density areas spreading out from this center. TODs are typically designed to be more walkable than other built-up areas, through using smaller block sizes and reducing the land area dedicated to automobiles (i.e., streets, parking lots, etc.). The Transit Oriented Development Institute has reported that in surveys, 51% of Americans agree that the availability of good public transportation increases their interest in moving to and living in a particular area. Furthermore, 47% of Americans say being in close proximity to public transportation impacts choices about where they live, work, and play. Benefits associated with TOD include reduced dependency on driving, allowing residents to live, work, and play in the same area, and reducing the area’s carbon footprint or negative environmental impact.
- BART. BART is an urban passenger rail provider, covering four Bay Area counties with an average weekday ridership of approximately 430,000 travelers. BART ridership surveys have found that daily riders typically walk/travel anywhere from a quarter to a half mile upon exiting a BART station. BART sponsored SB 680 (Wieckowski, 2017) last year to extend the distance it may engage in TOD, from one-quarter mile to one-half mile around its stations.
- BART TOD zoning plan. The BART board adopted an Affordable Housing Policy in January 2016, a TOD policy in June 2016, and TOD Performance Targets in December 2016. In May 2017 it released its TOD Guidelines, which articulate BART’s plans for developing station areas. According to BART’s website, it has 13 completed and under-construction projects, with seven approved projects in the pipeline. In addition, BART owns an estimated 250 acres at 27 stations that could accommodate future development. The BART Guidelines state that “BART understands it can be successful in TOD only by being a team player, that means only developing where there are willing partners and where local governments have demonstrated through their plans, policies, and actions that they are transit-supportive.” The BART Guidelines also state that “BART’s best TOD projects were built as part of a shared vision in partnership with local communities.” In contrast, this bill requires locals to rezone according to BART’s TOD policy, rather than working together in partnership. BART does not have a position on this bill.
- Conflict with SB 35. SB 35 (Wiener, 2017) allows a developer to apply for a streamlined, ministerial approval process when the local jurisdiction has not met certain RHNA requirements. Specifically, a jurisdiction that has not met its above-moderate-income RHNA must streamline approval for infill projects in which at least 10% of units are lower-income (e.g., very-low and low-income). A jurisdiction that has not met its lower-income RHNA must streamline approval for infill projects in which at least 50% of units are lower-income. This bill allows residential mixed-use projects, on BART land that satisfies local zoning standards, to be eligible for the SB 35 ministerial processes. However, since this bill requires 20% of units in a BART TOD project to be very-low, low-, or moderate-income, it appears to contradict the requirements of SB 35. The committee may wish to consider directing the author to amend this bill to align the streamlining provisions with SB 35, specifically, to ensure that the affordable set-asides in projects obtaining ministerial approval meet the 10% or 50% lower-income requirement.
- Should special districts be empowered to drive land use decisions? As noted in the Assembly Local Government Committee analysis, in general the Legislature has given cities maximum control over zoning matters while ensuring uniformity of, and public access to, zoning and planning hearings. State law lays out a process by which local jurisdictions may amend zoning ordinances. Jurisdictions make these decisions through a public process and must consider requirements such as their RHNA allocation. This bill, however, would authorize a special district to make decisions in a vacuum, without having to consider anything beyond the borders of its own land, and then require local governments to conform to those decisions. It would also set a disturbing precedent – with 4,000 special districts in California, authorizing even a small percentage of them to govern land use could have chaotic results. The committee may wish to consider whether it is appropriate to grant land use authority to a transit district.
- Does this bill provide enough affordable housing? As currently written, this bill requires each TOD project to set aside at least 20% of units for very low, low-, and moderate-income households. This committee and affordable housing advocates have expressed a desire to see a higher set-aside, or at least to limit the set-aside to very-low and low-income units. In response to these concerns, the author proposes amendments (to be taken in the next committee, due to timing constraints, as outlined in #9 below) allowing BART to evaluate a project proposal and determine whether the 20% set-aside must include moderate-income units in order to be feasible. The amendments would also specify that each project must have a set-aside of at least 15% for very-low and low-income units. The committee may wish to consider directing the author to amend this bill to explicitly require a 20% set-aside in each project for very-low and low-income units.
- Opposition concerns. The American Planning Association, California Chapter states that this bill would override local planning efforts including longstanding general plan land use plans in built-out communities, housing elements certified by HCD, sustainable communities strategies, development agreements, specific plans, and transit oriented developments. The League of California Cities states that land use regulation is a constitutionally granted local government function of cities and counties, not special districts. Bestowing land use power onto a transit agency that is unaccountable to community members is contrary to existing law and may violate the state constitution.
- Author’s amendments. The author has been working with stakeholders in recent weeks and is proposing significant amendments to this bill. The language, which this committee did not receive in final form until Wednesday, June 20th, proposes to make a large number of changes. Key provisions include:
- Affordable housing set-aside. The proposed language:
- Specifies that the 20% of units per project that are dedicated to very-low, low-, and moderate-income households are subject to a 55-year affordability restriction for rental units and 45 years for owner-occupied units.
- Allows BART to determine that the 20% set-aside is not feasible with just very-low and low-income units for a particular project, but requires a minimum of 15% of very-low and low-income units.
- Requires BART to ensure that a total of 30% of housing units in its TODs are affordable, with priority given to low- and very-low income units. Requires BART to submit a biannual report to HCD on the percentage of affordable units, by level of affordability, for all BART TOD projects.
- Displacement. The proposed language replaces the current language in the bill as follows.
- Requires any TOD project involving demolition of housing that is subject to an affordability covenant, subject to rent or price control, or occupied within the past five years by a low-income tenant who did not leave voluntarily, to replace those units to the same or lower income levels and requires those units to be subject to affordability covenant restrictions.
- Gives lower-income tenants who are displaced by a TOD project, right of first refusal to occupy replacement units within ½ mile of the same BART station at the same or lower rent level, and requires relocation assistance to be provided to these tenants.
- Provides that replacement units shall not count toward the 20% affordable housing set-aside.
- Exemptions from BART standards. The proposed language:
- Allows the BART board to exempt a local jurisdiction from the BART standards — other than the parking requirements – if the local zoning was approved as of July 1, 2018 and is within 10% of the height and floor-area-ratio standards established in the BART Guidelines.
- Provides that if BART ridership falls below a specified level for at least three consecutive calendar years, the requirements of this bill shall terminate until that level is reached again for at least a single calendar year.
- Provides that the BART standards shall not apply to any new BART station that has not been approved by the local jurisdiction.
- Provides that the BART standards shall only apply to land owned by BART on July 1, 2018. A TOD on land purchased by BART after that date shall be integrated into a TOD project, the majority of which is on land owned by BART on or prior to that date, and may not be a stand-alone project.
- Provides that if a local jurisdiction’s inclusionary housing requirement mandates a higher percentage of affordable units or a deeper level of affordability than required by this bill, then the jurisdiction’s affordability percentage requirements shall apply in place of this bill.
- Parking requirements. The proposed language:
- Requires BART to establish a parking replacement policy ensuring that, after TOD construction, auto-oriented stations are still accessible by private automobile. The policy shall specifically consider parking replacement needs for end-of-the-line stations.
- Prohibits local jurisdictions from requiring parking that is part of a BART TOD project to be associated with any specific use, residential unit, business, or portion of the project, or from prohibiting sale, rental, or other assignment of parking separately from other parts of the project.
- CEQA. The proposed language provides that when a TOD project requests but does not receive streamlined approval, the CEQA review for the project must only address the criteria not met by the project.
- Floor-area-ratio (FAR). The proposed language specifies how the minimum FAR standard shall be calculated, and requires it to be included in the BART standards.
- Design guidelines. The proposed language requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines if those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum height, minimum density, and maximum parking allowances allowed by the BART standards.
- Delayed implementation. The proposed language delays the requirement for the BART board to adopt the BART standards to July 1, 2020.
- Affordable housing set-aside. The proposed language:
- More cooking time needed. This bill completely disrupts longtime zoning practices by empowering a special district to make land use decisions. As noted above, the author is submitting a large number of amendments that this committee did not have time to fully analyze due to late receipt. The committee may wish to consider holding this bill for further discussion over interim.
- Double-referral. This bill is double-referred to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee and will be heard on June 27th. Any amendments, including the ones discussed above, will have to be taken in the Governance and Finance Committee hearing.
Related Legislation:
SB 827 (Wiener, 2017) — would have required a local jurisdiction, notwithstanding any local ordinance, general plan element, specific plan, charter, or other local law, to provide an eligible applicant with a transit-rich housing bonus if requested by the developer, as specified. This bill failed passage in this committee on April 17, 2018.
SB 680 (Wieckowski, Chapter 100, Statutes of 2017) — extends the allowable distance for BART to engage in TOD from one-quarter to one-half mile.
SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) — creates a streamlined, ministerial approval process for infill developments in localities that have failed to meet their regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) numbers.
SB 628 (Beall, Chapter 628, Statues of 2014) — established EIFDs and authorized the funding of transit priority projects, defined as within one-half mile a major transit stop or high-quality transit corridor.
AB 987 (Ma, Chapter 354, Statues of 2010) — expanded the size of a transit village development district from one-quarter mile to one-half mile from a transit station.
Assembly Votes:
Floor: 42-32
Approps: 12-4
Local Gov: 7-3
H&CD: 5-3
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 20, 2018.)
SUPPORT:
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California (co-sponsor)
State Building and Construction Trades Council (co-sponsor)
A Philip Randolph Institute
Bay Area Council
Brightline Defense
California Apartment Association
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California League of Conservation Voters
California YIMBY
Circulate San Diego
City and County of San Francisco
Council of Infill Builders
Greenbelt Alliance
Habitat for Humanity
Mission Hiring Hall
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California
Northern California Carpenters Regional Council
San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Sheet Metal Workers’ Local Union No. 104
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Sprinkler Fitters and Apprentices Local 483
SPUR
SV@home
TransForm
YIMBY Action
Young Community Developers
350 Bay Area
OPPOSITION:
Alameda County Board of Supervisors
American Planning Association, California Chapter
California Building Officials
City of Berkeley
City of Concord
City of Hayward
City of Lafayette
City of Pleasant Hill
League of California Cities
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2923
Author:(Chiu and Grayson)
As Amended Ver:
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Local Government | 5-3 | Bloom, Caballero, Cooley, Grayson, Mark Stone | Aguiar-Curry, Waldron, Voepel |
Natural Resources | 7-3 | Muratsuchi, Chau, Eggman, Limón, McCarty, Mark Stone, Reyes | Acosta, Flora, Melendez |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards on specified parcels of land it owns, and requires affected cities and counties to update zoning to be consistent with BART's zoning standards within two years. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board.
- Requires zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines to serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Specifies that approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the board to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type, in approving the TOD zoning standards.
- Requires the TOD zoning standards to be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and allows them to be amended by the board thereafter, as specified. Specifies that if the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD GUIDELINES (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards, to comply with all of the following:
- The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. Requires BART to conduct direct outreach to communities of concern;
- BART shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards; and,
- The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
- Requires, before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board to approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
- Requires, where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
- Requires the local zoning ordinance to conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
- Requires the board to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards.
- Requires, if, according to the board's finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in 7), above, the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. Allows a jurisdiction to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
- Specifies that the board's approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA review). Requires the board to serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
- Requires any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land to incorporate the environmental impact report (EIR) certified for the TOD zoning standards, as specified. Specifies that a public agency need not prepare an EIR or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART's certification of an EIR for approval of TOD zoning standards unless the public agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant effect on the environment that was not analyzed and mitigated or avoided in the prior EIR.
- Allows a TOD development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) have been met.
- Requires the board to ensure that any otherwise applicable local design review guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
- Requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
- Provides that in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, that the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards.
- Requires, to the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, that the general plan be the controlling standard.
- Allows the board to waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with the Government Code Section 65913.4, which is the section of SB 35 (Wiener) that allows a development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process if specified objective planning standards are met.
- Requires the board to take specified actions to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, as specified.
- Requires a TOD project to do both of the following:
- Include at least a 20% minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households; and,
- Comply with the labor requirements of Government Code Section 65913.14 (SB 35) and any other applicable BART labor policies.
- Allows the board to identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to 1), through 3), above, that are proceeding with local zoning authority and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
- Requires reimbursement to local agencies to be made, as specified, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by law.
EXISTING LAW:
- States, pursuant to of the California Constitution Article XI, Section 7, that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws.
- States, pursuant to the California Constitution Article XI, Section 5, that it shall be competent in any city charter to provide that the city governed thereunder may make and enforce all ordinances and regulations in respect to municipal affairs, subject only to restrictions and limitations provided in their several charters and in respect to other matters that shall be subject to general laws. States that city charters adopted pursuant to the Constitution shall supersede any existing charter, and with respect to municipal affairs shall supersede all laws inconsistent therewith.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown likely significant state-mandated local costs to BART to adopt TOD guidelines and local zoning standards for its properties per the requirements in the bill, including CEQA compliance. These costs are potentially reimbursable by the state, depending upon a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
- Unknown state-mandated local costs to local jurisdictions to approve the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of their approval by BART. These costs are potentially reimbursable by the state, depending upon a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
COMMENTS:
- Bill Summary. This bill requires the BART board to establish TOD zoning standards for mixed-use housing on BART-owned land within ½ mile of an existing or planned BART station in areas represented on the BART Board (currently Alameda, Contra Costa, and San Francisco Counties). The board would serve as lead agency for CEQA review of these standards. Within two years of the date that the Board adopts the TOD zoning standards, jurisdictions with zoning authority (meaning a city or county) would be required to update local zoning on BART-owned land to be consistent with these TOD zoning standards.
This bill requires BART to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards, and specifies that local zoning shall remain in place, unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards. If, according to the board's finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after the two-year period, the BART TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. This bill allows a city or county to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards, until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
This bill also allows residential mixed-use projects on BART land that satisfies local zoning standards to be eligible for ministerial approval processes in existing law, as established by SB 35 (Wiener) of last year. This bill requires at least 20% of the residential units constructed within each TOD project to be affordable to very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and be subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years. Prevailing wage and skilled and trained workforce requirements apply, as well as any other applicable BART labor policies.
This bill is co-sponsored by the Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California and the State Building and Construction Trades Council.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "To play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART's TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area's housing needs, reducing the Bay Area's greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services.
"Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long - often more than a decade - with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites.
"AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth."
- BART TOD Guidelines. BART recently released a publication on its Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines, dated May 2017. As stated in the introduction of that document:
In BART's three decades of experience in the development of property, BART's Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) program has continued to evolve. TOD has become a prominent fixture in the Bay Area's future propelled in part by a tailwind of rapidly-growing transit ridership; shifting consumer-housing preferences and business location decisions in support of transit rich locations; supportive state, regional and local government plans; and favorable real estate market trends.
In light of the changes in the Bay Area including adoption of aggressive greenhouse gas reduction targets, a growing housing affordability crisis, and the loss of Redevelopment as a tool to support infill development, the BART Board adopted a new TOD policy in June 2016.
The TOD Policy was followed by adoption of performance targets in December 2016 that greatly increase the pace and scale of BART's TOD projects, and set new goals for growth envisioned within the half mile station area….To achieve these targets and implement the new policy, these Guidelines are intended to clearly articulate BART's process for development, and expectations for station area planning.
The May 2017 Guidelines document also talks about the shifting market demand for TOD, and specifies that "TOD projects on BART land will meet a minimum net residential density standard of 75 units per acre, reduce auto use by lowering parking requirements below one space per unit on average and 1.6 spaces per 1,000 square feet of office space, and strive to provide incentives to take transit, bike and walk. At some stations, BART will seek to replace park and ride lots with TOD, in concert with station area access improvements guided by BART's Station Access Policy."
- Constitutional Land Use and Zoning Powers for Cities and Counties. The California Constitution, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, states that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws. This power is often referred to as the "police power" and the courts have held that "It is from this fundamental power that local governments derive their authority to regulate land through planning, zoning, and building ordinances, thereby protecting public health, safety and welfare."
One way that cities and counties use this authority is through zoning, which is the division of a city into certain types of "districts" and the application of different regulations in each "district" – like commercial, industrial or residential zones. Zoning ordinances generally fall into two categories: a) Those that regulate the height or bulk of physical structures within certain designated districts; and, b) Those that prescribe the use by which buildings within certain districts may be put. In general, the Legislature has given cities maximum control over zoning matters while ensuring uniformity of, and public access to, zoning and planning hearings.
State zoning law requires both a hearing before the planning commission, if there is one, and a hearing before the city council prior to the enactment of certain amendments to zoning ordinances. There are also minimum due process standards required in conducting those hearings so that the public can participate.
- Home Rule and Charter Cities. The California Constitution authorizes both general law and charter cities to: a) make and enforce all local laws and regulations not in conflict with general state laws; b) establish, purchase, and operate public works and utilities or franchise to do so; and, c) be free from state legislation delegating to a private person or body control over city property, funds, tax levies, and municipal functions. Whether a charter city may act independent of state general law in a particular domain depends upon a court's determination of whether it is a municipal affair or a matter of statewide concern.
The affected parcels list provided by the author's office includes BART-owned parcels in the Cities of Berkeley, El Centro, Hayward, Oakland, San Francisco (City and County of), and San Leandro, all of which are charter cities. Other affected non-charter cities with parcels include Fremont, Pleasanton, Dublin, Antioch, Pittsburg, Lafayette, Concord, Union City, and there are also parcels listed in Alameda County.
- Policy Considerations. The Legislature may wish to consider the following issues:
- Override of Police Powers Delegated to Cities and Counties. According to the League of California Cities, in opposition, "Authorizing a transit agency to regulate density, height and parking requirements transfers this essential local government function from their hands to a single special district. Bestowing land use power onto a transit agency that is unaccountable to community members is contrary to existing law and may violate Article XI, Section 11 of the State Constitution. In In re Werner (1900) 129 Cal.567., the court struck down a state statute which granted a sanitary district the power 'to make and enforce all necessary and proper regulations from suppressing disorderly and disreputable resorts and houses of ill fame within the district and to determine the qualifications of persons authorized to sell alcohol.' The court held that the powers granted to the sanitary district violated Article XI, section 11 because the 'police power' must be exercised locally by cities and counties only (as provided by the Constitution)."
- Establishes Precedent for Future Diminishing of Local Land Use Planning. According to the American Planning Association, California Chapter, "APA California opposes altering state policy to replace local land use planning by allowing BART to zone its own property. This bill sets a precedent for other entities to request the same authority to zone their own properties however they wish. In addition, BART would not be required to take into consideration what is currently on the ground, and what these local jurisdictions have already accomplished to increase density around transit. APA California believes the approach in AB 2923 will set a troubling precedent for further diminishing of local land use planning in future legislation."
- Why BART-Owned Parcels Only? The bill deals specifically with parcels of land that BART owns, near existing BART stations. The Legislature may wish to consider why increasing density in this manner should only with BART-owned parcels, as opposed to parcels that are NOT owned by BART that are near existing BART stations. If the goal is to have higher density and more affordable housing and mixed-use near transit stations, the Legislature may wish to impose a statewide approach.
- Charter Cities and Home Rule. As referenced in Comment #5, above, charter cities enjoy supremacy over their municipal affairs. This bill does not contain any provisions declaring that the contents of the bill are a "statewide affair" – which would then apply the requirements of the bill to charter cities in addition to all general law cities.
The Legislature may also wish to note that while a bill can declare intent to apply its provisions to charter cities, the true determination of whether a specific area is a municipal affair or a matter of statewide concern will be determined solely by the courts.
- BART position on this bill. BART has a "Neutral" position on the bill, and notes that the bill "could benefit BART's TOD program by accelerating the rezoning of sites for residential and mixed-use development…however, this approach this bill takes poses a shift in the working relationship between BART and its local jurisdictions."
Additionally, BART notes that "Local governments have always been key partners in BART's TOD program and most have been supportive of development occurring on BART property. BART realizes the importance of working with local jurisdictions to help ensure station area and specific plans are achievable, support TOD, and address existing community concerns."
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that the bill could potentially facilitate deployment of hundreds of new homes – both market-rate and affordable – precisely where they are needed, near major rail transit. Supporters also note that transit-oriented projects are notoriously contentious and approvals can take up to a decade, hindering development.
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents argue that the bill would override local planning efforts, including longstanding General Plan land use plans in built out communities, housing elements certified by HCD, Sustainable Communities Strategies, development agreements, specific plans, and Transit-Oriented Developments. Opponents also argue that the bill's provisions may violate the California Constitution.
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0003026
Date of Hearing: May 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2923
Author:(Chiu) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2018
Policy Committee: | Local Government | Vote: | 5 - 3 |
Natural Resources | 7 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards for BART-owned land within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station, and requires affected cities and counties to update zoning to be consistent with BART’s zoning standards within two years.
This bill also prescribes procedures for California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review of TOD zoning standards and changes undertaken pursuant to the bill, including requiring the BART board to serve as the lead agency and requiring subsequent CEQA review of rezoning or TOD projects to incorporate BART's CEQA review of the TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown likely significant state-mandated local costs to BART to adopt TOD guidelines and local zoning standards for its properties per the requirements in the bill, including CEQA compliance. These costs are potentially reimbursable by the state, depending upon a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
- Unknown state-mandated local costs to local jurisdictions to approve the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of their approval by BART. These costs are potentially reimbursable by the state, depending upon a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.
- Background. BART is a statutorily created rapid public transit system that connects the San Francisco Peninsula with Oakland, Berkeley, Fremont, Walnut Creek, Dublin/Pleasanton and other cities in the East Bay. BART has over 112 miles of track and 46 stations (four of these are combined with MUNI Metro stations and one is combined with CalTrain), and a number of other stations in the pipeline for development.
Existing law provides for BART’s governing board and the powers and duties of the district, including allowing the board to determine and undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities. The board also fixes rates, rentals, and charges, and makes and enforces rules, regulations, practices and schedules in connection with any transit facility owned or controlled by the district. BART is authorized to maintain a police department, to use eminent domain to acquire property, and to dispose of property when it is in the best interest of the transit system.
BART has an existing TOD program with TOD guidelines, most recently updated in May 2017, in which local governments are described as key partners in the planning and implementation of projects. According to BART’s website, the TOD program has successfully completed 12 developments at 11 stations, totaling 1,975 housing units and 194,000 square feet of commercial space, and includes the following projects: Castro Valley, Richmond Phase I, Fruitvale Phase I, Pleasant Hill/Contra Costa Centre, Ashby, West Dublin/Pleasanton, Hayward, East Dublin, MacArthur, South Hayward, and San Leandro. Several additional TOD projects are in the pipeline.
Each of these projects has gone through the existing planning process involving the affected city or county, its zoning code, and any applicable entitlements necessary for the development.
This bill overrides local zoning authority to allow BART to zone its own property and designates BART the lead agency for CEQA review of TOD zoning standards and projects. The bill also requires local jurisdictions to approve the application of BART’s TOD zoning standards within two years of their approval by the BART board. Notably, this bill as written does not apply to charter cities. However, the list of affected parcels includes parcels in the cities of Berkeley, El Centro, Hayward, Oakland, San Francisco, and San Leandro, each of which is a charter city.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue the bill could potentially facilitate deployment of hundreds of new homes – both market-rate and affordable – precisely where they are needed, near major rail transit. Supporters also note that transit-oriented projects are notoriously contentious and approvals can take up to a decade, hindering development.
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents argue that the bill would override local planning efforts, including longstanding general plan land use plans in built out communities, housing elements certified by HCD, Sustainable Communities Strategies, development agreements, specific plans, and TODs. Opponents also argue the bill’s provisions may violate the California Constitution. They explain that cities and counties (but not special districts) derive their land use authority through powers granted them in the state Constitution and upheld by the courts. This bill grants land use and zoning powers to BART, a special district.
- Neutral. BART has a “neutral” position on the bill, and notes the bill:
Could benefit BART’s TOD program by accelerating the rezoning of sites for residential and mixed-use development…however, this approach this bill takes poses a shift in the working relationship between BART and its local jurisdictions.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Al Muratsuchi, Acting Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2923 (
Author:Chiu) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2018
SUBJECT: San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development
SUMMARY: Requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards for BART-owned land within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station, and requires affected cities and counties to update zoning to be consistent with BART’s zoning standards within two years. Prescribes procedures for California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review of TOD zoning standards and changes undertaken pursuant to the bill, including requiring the BART board to serve as the lead agency and requiring subsequent CEQA review of rezoning or TOD projects to incorporate BART's CEQA review of the TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible.
EXISTING LAW:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines).
- Requires EIRs to be tiered whenever feasible, as determined by the lead agency, and requires, when an EIR has been prepared and certified for a program, plan, policy, or ordinance, the lead agency for a later project to examine significant environmental effects of the later project by using a tiered EIR, except that the EIR on the later project is not required to examine those effects that the lead agency determines were either:
- Mitigated or avoided as a result of the prior EIR.
- Examined at a sufficient level of detail in the prior EIR to enable those effects to be mitigated or avoided by site specific revisions, the imposition of conditions, or by other means in connection with the approval of the later project.
- Exempts from CEQA any residential development project, including any subdivision, or any zoning change that is undertaken to implement, and is consistent with, a specific plan for which an EIR has been certified after January 1, 1980, unless substantial changes or new information require the preparation of a supplemental EIR for the specific plan, in which case the exemption applies once the supplemental EIR is certified.
- Exempts from CEQA specified residential housing projects which meet detailed criteria established to ensure the project does not have a significant effect on the environment, including urban affordable housing projects not more than 100 units on a site not more than 5 acres in size, and urban infill housing projects not more than 100 units on a site not more than 4 acres in size, which is within one-half mile of a major transit stop. [SB 1925 (Sher), Chapter 1039, Statutes of 2002]
- Requires metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) to include a sustainable communities strategy (SCS), as defined, in their regional transportation plans, or an alternative planning strategy (APS), for the purpose of reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, aligns planning for transportation and housing, and creates specified incentives for the implementation of the strategies, including CEQA exemption or abbreviated review for residential or mixed-use residential "transit priority projects" if the project is consistent with the use designation, density, building intensity, and applicable policies specified for the project area in either an approved SCS or APS. [SB 375 (Steinberg), Chapter 728, Statutes of 2008]
- Establishes abbreviated CEQA review procedures for specified infill projects, where only specific or more significant effects on the environment which were not addressed in a prior planning-level EIR need be addressed. An EIR for such a project need not consider alternative locations, densities, and building intensities or growth-inducing impacts. Infill projects may include residential, retail, commercial, transit station, school, or public office building projects located within an urban area. [SB 226 (Simitian), Chapter 469, Statutes of 2011]
- Exempts from CEQA residential, mixed-use, and "employment center" projects, as defined, located within "transit priority areas," as defined, if the project is consistent with an adopted specific plan and specified elements of an SCS or APS adopted pursuant to SB 375. [SB 743 (Steinberg), Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013]
- The CEQA Guidelines include a categorical exemption for infill development projects (Section 15332), as follows:
- The project is consistent with the applicable general plan designation and all applicable general plan policies as well as with applicable zoning designation and regulations;
- The proposed development occurs within city limits on a project site of no more than five acres substantially surrounded by urban uses;
- The project site has no value as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species;
- Approval of the project would not result in any significant effects relating to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality; and,
- The site can be adequately served by all required utilities and public services.
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, of the California Constitution, that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws.
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 5, of the California Constitution, that it shall be competent in any city charter to provide that the city governed thereunder may make and enforce all ordinances and regulations in respect to municipal affairs, subject only to restrictions and limitations provided in their several charters and in respect to other matters that shall be subject to general laws. States that city charters adopted pursuant to the Constitution shall supersede any existing charter, and with respect to municipal affairs shall supersede all laws inconsistent therewith.
THIS BILL:
- Requires, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board to adopt TOD zoning standards that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board.
- Requires zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines to serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Specifies that approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the board to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type, in approving the TOD zoning standards.
- Requires the TOD zoning standards to be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and allows them to be amended by the board thereafter, as specified. Specifies that if the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD GUIDELINES (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards, to comply with all of the following:
- The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. Requires BART to conduct direct outreach to communities of concern;
- BART shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards; and,
- The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
- Requires, before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board to approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
- Requires, where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
- Requires the local zoning ordinance to conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
- Requires the board to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards.
- Requires, if, according to the board’s finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in 7), above, the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. Allows a jurisdiction to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
- Specifies that the board’s approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to CEQA. Requires the board to serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
- Requires any CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land, to incorporate the CEQA review for approval of TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible. Prohibits an agency from preparing CEQA documents on rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART’s CEQA review of the approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed.
- Allows a TOD development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) have been met.
- Requires the board to ensure that any otherwise applicable local design review guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
- Requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
- Provides that in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, that the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards.
- Requires, to the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, that the general plan be the controlling standard.
- Allows the board to waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, which is the section of SB 35 (Wiener) that allows a development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process if specified objective planning standards are met.
- Requires the board to take specified actions to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, as specified.
- Requires a TOD project to do both of the following:
- Include at least a 20-percent minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households; and,
- Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.14 (SB 35) and any other applicable BART labor policies.
- Allows the board to identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to 1), through 3), above, that are proceeding with local zoning authority and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Double referral. This bill passed the Assembly Local Government Committee on April 18, 2018 by a vote of 5-3. See the Assembly Local Government Committee analysis for a more complete discussion of the bill's change in local zoning authority.
- Author’s Statement:
To play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART’s TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area’s housing needs, reducing the Bay Area’s greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services.
Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long - often more than a decade - with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites.
AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.
- BART TOD Guidelines. BART recently released a publication on its Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines, dated May 2017. As stated in the introduction of that document:
In BART’s three decades of experience in the development of property, BART’s Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) program has continued to evolve. TOD has become a prominent fixture in the Bay Area’s future propelled in part by a tailwind of rapidly-growing transit ridership; shifting consumer-housing preferences and business location decisions in support of transit rich locations; supportive state, regional and local government plans; and favorable real estate market trends.
In light of the changes in the Bay Area including adoption of aggressive greenhouse gas reduction targets, a growing housing affordability crisis, and the loss of Redevelopment as a tool to support infill development, the BART Board adopted a new TOD policy in June 2016.
The TOD Policy was followed by adoption of performance targets in December 2016 that greatly increase the pace and scale of BART’s TOD projects, and set new goals for growth envisioned within the half mile station area….To achieve these targets and implement the new policy, these Guidelines are intended to clearly articulate BART’s process for development, and expectations for station area planning.
The May 2017 Guidelines document also talks about the shifting market demand for TOD, and specifies that “TOD projects on BART land will meet a minimum net residential density standard of 75 units per acre, reduce auto use by lowering parking requirements below one space per unit on average and 1.6 spaces per 1,000 square feet of office space, and strive to provide incentives to take transit, bike and walk. At some stations, BART will seek to replace park and ride lots with TOD, in concert with station area access improvements guided by BART’s Station Access Policy.”
BART has over 112 miles of track, and 46 stations (four of these are combined with MUNI Metro stations and one is combined with CalTrain), and a number of other stations in the pipeline for development. BART is also authorized to use eminent domain to acquire property, and can also dispose of property when it is in the best interest of the transit system. BART can also take by gift, or take and convey by grant, purchase, devise or lease, and hold and enjoy, real and personal property of every kind within or without the district that is necessary for transit-oriented joint development projects on property within one-half mile from the external boundaries of a BART facility to use for TOD.
The affected parcels list provided by the author’s office includes BART-owned parcels in the Cities of Berkeley, El Centro, Hayward, Oakland, San Francisco, and San Leandro, all of which are charter cities. Other affected non-charter cities with parcels include Fremont, Pleasanton, Dublin, Antioch, Pittsburg, Lafayette, Concord, Union City, and there are also parcels listed in Alameda County.
- In addition to changing local zoning authority, bill changes CEQA procedures related to review of TOD zoning and subsequent TOD projects. This bill not only designates BART the lead agency for CEQA review of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards (page 4, lines 17-21), it requires any, presumably later, CEQA review of rezoning and TOD projects to incorporate the CEQA review for approval of TOD zoning standards "to the greatest degree possible" (page 4, lines 22-25). This provision is apparently intended to require tiering under CEQA and avoid redundant analysis.
The bill further prohibits an agency from preparing CEQA documents on rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART’s CEQA review of the approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed (page 4, lines 25-31).
The author and the committee may wish to consider the following amendments to clarify these CEQA provisions:
(2) Any subsequent CEQA review of rezoning to conform with TOD zoning standards, and of TOD projects proposed on BART-owned land, shall incorporate the CEQA review environmental impact report certified for approval of TOD zoning standards to the greatest degree possible consistent with Section 21094 of the Public Resources Code. An agency may not prepare CEQA documents on an environmental impact report or mitigated negative declaration for a project involving rezoning to implement TOD zoning standards subsequent to BART’s CEQA review of the certification of an environmental impact report for approval of TOD zoning standards absent a finding of substantial evidence unless the agency finds, based on substantial evidence, that the rezoning creates a significant negative impact, based on standards in effect at the time that the CEQA review on the approval of the TOD zoning standards was performed effect on the environment that was not analyzed, and mitigated or avoided, in the prior environmental impact report.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California (co-sponsor)
State Building and Construction Trades Council (co-sponsor)
350 Bay Area
A.Philip Randolph Institute
Bay Area Council
Brightline Defense Project
CalAsian Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California League of Conservation Voters
California YIMBY
City and County of San Francisco
Council of Infill Builders
Greenbelt Alliance
Habitat for Humanity California
International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers
Mission Hiring Hall
San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry
San Francisco Housing Action Coalition
Sheet Metal Workers’ Local Union No. 104
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
TransForm
Up for Growth California
Young Community Developers
YIMBY Action
Opposition
American Planning Association, California Chapter (unless amended)
City of Concord
City of Lafayette
League of California Cities
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2923 (
Author:Chiu and Grayson) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2018
SUBJECT: San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District: transit-oriented development.
SUMMARY: Requires the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards on specified parcels of land it owns, and requires affected cities and counties to update zoning to be consistent with BART’s zoning standards within two years. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows, notwithstanding any other law, the BART board of directors (board) to adopt transit-oriented development (TOD) zoning standards by a majority vote at a duly noticed public meeting that establish minimum local zoning requirements for BART-owned land that is located on contiguous parcels larger than 0.25 acres, within one-half mile of an existing or planned BART station entrance, in areas having representation on the BART board.
- Requires zoning standards published in the current BART Guidelines to serve as the baseline for BART TOD zoning. Specifies that approved TOD zoning standards shall establish the lowest permissible height limits, lowest permissible density limits, and the highest permissible parking maximums, as established by Table 1 and Figure 1 of BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the board to establish and include the lowest permissible floor-area-ratio limits for each TOD place type, in approving the TOD zoning standards.
- Requires the TOD zoning standards to be approved by the board by April 1, 2019, and allows them to be amended by the board thereafter, as specified. Specifies that if the board fails to approve new guidelines by April 1, 2019, the existing Table 1 of BART TOD GUIDELINES (2017) shall serve as the minimum local zoning requirements for local jurisdictions, with the Transit Oriented Place Types indicated in Figure 1 of the BART TOD Guidelines (2017).
- Requires the approval of, and amendments to, the TOD zoning standards, to comply with all of the following:
- The board shall hold a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed TOD zoning standards or proposed changes to the TOD zoning standards. Requires BART to conduct direct outreach to communities of concern;
- BART shall provide public notice and make the draft guidelines available to the public not less than 30 days before a public hearing of the board to consider the TOD zoning standards; and,
- The board shall approve or reject any proposed TOD zoning standards at a publicly noticed meeting of the board not less than 30 days following the original public hearing.
- Requires, before or at the same time as approving TOD zoning standards, the board to approve travel demand management requirements for TOD projects on district-owned real property.
- Requires, where local zoning is inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards, the local jurisdiction to adopt an ordinance that approves the application of the TOD zoning standards within two years of the date that the TOD zoning standards were approved by the board.
- Requires the local zoning ordinance to conform to the TOD zoning standards without the application of any bonuses or waivers allowable under any state or local density bonus provisions.
- Requires the board to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the local zoning shall remain in place unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards.
- Requires, if, according to the board’s finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD zoning standards after the two-year period specified in 7), above, the TOD zoning standards to become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. Allows a jurisdiction to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
- Specifies that the board’s approval of TOD zoning standards and local zoning standards shall be subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Requires the board to serve as the lead agency for CEQA review.
- Allows a TOD development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies the objective planning standards specified in SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, that are consistent with the BART TOD zoning standards. Specifies that the streamlining provisions do not apply to a development located in a jurisdiction where the market rate and affordable housing obligations in the regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) have been met.
- Requires the board to ensure that any otherwise applicable local design review guidelines are included in a development agreement with a TOD developer.
- Requires a TOD developer to adhere to any applicable local design guidelines insofar as those guidelines do not prohibit the minimum density allowances required by the TOD zoning standards.
- Provides that in the event that TOD zoning standards, objective planning standards, general plan, or design review standards are mutually inconsistent, that the TOD zoning standards shall be the controlling standards.
- Requires, to the extent that the zoning standards do not resolve inconsistencies, that the general plan be the controlling standard.
- Allows the board to waive any requirement that it finds to be inconsistent with Section 65913.4 of the Government Code, which is the section of SB 35 (Wiener) that allows a development proponent to submit an application for a development that is subject to the streamlined, ministerial approval process if specified objective planning standards are met.
- Requires the board to take specified actions to avoid the loss of affordable housing units and to prevent the direct displacement of tenants, as specified.
- Requires a TOD project to do both of the following:
- Include at least a 20-percent minimum of the affordable residential housing units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years with a priority on residential units for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households; and,
- Comply with the labor requirements of Section 65913.14 (SB 35) and any other applicable BART labor policies.
- Allows the board to identify specific TOD projects that are in the approval process with a local jurisdiction on or before imposition of the TOD zoning standards adopted pursuant to 1), through 3), above, that are proceeding with local zoning authority and entitlement pursuant to existing local zoning authority.
- Requires reimbursement to local agencies to be made, as specified, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by law.
EXISTING LAW:
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, of the California Constitution, that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws.
- States, pursuant to Article XI, Section 5, of the California Constitution, that it shall be competent in any city charter to provide that the city governed thereunder may make and enforce all ordinances and regulations in respect to municipal affairs, subject only to restrictions and limitations provided in their several charters and in respect to other matters that shall be subject to general laws. States that city charters adopted pursuant to the Constitution shall supersede any existing charter, and with respect to municipal affairs shall supersede all laws inconsistent therewith.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal and contains a state-mandated local program.
COMMENTS:
- Bill Summary. This bill requires the BART board to establish TOD zoning standards for mixed-use housing on BART-owned land within ½ mile of an existing or planned BART station in areas represented on the BART Board (currently Alameda, Contra Costa, and San Francisco Counties). The board would serve as lead agency for CEQA review of these standards. Within two years of the date that the Board adopts the TOD zoning standards, jurisdictions with zoning authority (meaning a city or county) would be required to update local zoning on BART-owned land to be consistent with these TOD zoning standards. Any CEQA review of rezoning and subsequent TOD projects must incorporate the Board's CEQA review to the greatest degree possible.
The bill requires BART to make a finding as to whether the local zoning ordinance is consistent with the TOD zoning standards, and specifies that local zoning shall remain in place, unless the board determines that it is inconsistent with TOD zoning standards. If, according to the board’s finding, the local zoning ordinance remains inconsistent with the TOD guidelines after the two-year period, the BART TOD zoning standards shall become the local zoning standards for any BART-owned land within one-half mile of any existing or planned BART station entrance in areas represented on the board. The bill allows a city or county to update zoning to comply with TOD zoning standards, until such time that a BART TOD developer enters into the development process.
The bill also allows residential mixed-use projects on BART land that satisfies local zoning standards to be eligible for ministerial approval processes in existing law, as established by SB 35 (Wiener) of last year, regardless of a jurisdiction's progress in meeting its share of the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA). The bill requires at least 20% of the residential units constructed within each TOD project to be affordable to very low-, low-, and moderate-income households and be subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years. Prevailing wage and skilled and trained workforce requirements apply, as well as any other applicable BART labor policies.
This bill is co-sponsored by the Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California and the State Building and Construction Trades Council.
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “To play its part in fulfilling state and regional goals, BART recently passed a progressive and ambitious TOD policy. BART committed itself to fully building out the land it owns around its stations by 2040 to produce over 20,000 new units of housing, of which 7,000 will be affordable, and 4,500,000 sq. ft. of office and commercial space, including child care and educational facilities. The success of BART’s TOD policy is essential to meeting the Bay Area’s housing needs, reducing the Bay Area’s greenhouse gas emissions and criteria pollutants, reducing crippling congestion on Bay Area roads, and providing much needed affordable housing to low-income residents with direct, reliable, and affordable transportation connections to jobs and services.
“Unfortunately, BART cannot fully deliver on some of its most promising TOD opportunities. Historically, TOD projects have taken too long - often more than a decade - with jurisdictions demanding less housing and too much parking for transit adjacent development. These factors have increased project costs while reducing project benefits and affordability. As a result, BART has not proposed TOD on many of its opportunity sites.
“AB 2923 will help expedite the production of well designed, mixed-use development adjacent to transit. TOD projects will in turn increase transit ridership, reduce congestion and greenhouse gas outputs, and sustainably accommodate new growth.”
- BART. BART is a rapid public transit system that connects the San Francisco Peninsula with Oakland, Berkeley, Fremont, Walnut Creek, Dublin/Pleasanton and other cities in the East Bay. For more than 45 years BART has provided transportation to downtown offices, shopping centers, tourist attractions, entertainment venues, universities and other destinations for Bay Area residents and visitors alike. BART has over 112 miles of track, and 46 stations (four of these are combined with MUNI Metro stations and one is combined with CalTrain), and a number of other stations in the pipeline for development.
BART has its own statutes contained in the Public Utilities Code, which provide for the structure of the governing board, and the powers and duties of the district. The BART statutes specify that the board shall determine what transit facilities should be acquired or constructed, and allows BART to establish zones within the district to undertake the acquisition or construction of any transit facilities. The board regulates such facilities, including the fixing of rates, rentals, and charges, and the marking and enforcement of rules, regulations, practices and schedules, in connection with any transit facility owned or controlled by the district. BART is also authorized to maintain a police department and establish an office of independent police auditor.
BART is also authorized to use eminent domain to acquire property, and can also dispose
of property when it is in the best interest of the transit system. BART can also take by gift, or take and convey by grant, purchase, devise or lease, and hold and enjoy, real and personal property of every kind within or without the district that is necessary for transit-oriented joint development projects on property within ½ mile from the external boundaries of a BART facility to use for TOD.
- BART TOD Guidelines. BART recently released a publication on its Transit-Oriented Development Guidelines, dated May 2017. As stated in the introduction of that document:
In BART’s three decades of experience in the development of property, BART’s Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) program has continued to evolve. TOD has become a prominent fixture in the Bay Area’s future propelled in part by a tailwind of rapidly-growing transit ridership; shifting consumer-housing preferences and business location decisions in support of transit rich locations; supportive state, regional and local government plans; and favorable real estate market trends.
In light of the changes in the Bay Area including adoption of aggressive greenhouse gas reduction targets, a growing housing affordability crisis, and the loss of Redevelopment as a tool to support infill development, the BART Board adopted a new TOD policy in June 2016.
The TOD Policy was followed by adoption of performance targets in December 2016 that greatly increase the pace and scale of BART’s TOD projects, and set new goals for growth envisioned within the half mile station area….To achieve these targets and implement the new policy, these Guidelines are intended to clearly articulate BART’s process for development, and expectations for station area planning.
The May 2017 Guidelines document also talks about the shifting market demand for TOD, and specifies that “TOD projects on BART land will meet a minimum net residential density standard of 75 units per acre, reduce auto use by lowering parking requirements below one space per unit on average and 1.6 spaces per 1,000 square feet of office space, and strive to provide incentives to take transit, bike and walk. At some stations, BART will seek to replace park and ride lots with TOD, in concert with station area access improvements guided by BART’s Station Access Policy.”
- Constitutional Land Use and Zoning Powers for Cities and Counties. The California Constitution, pursuant to Article XI, Section 7, states that a city or county may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws (special districts do not have land use authority). This power is often referred to as the “police power” and the courts have held that “It is from this fundamental power that local governments derive their authority to regulate land through planning, zoning, and building ordinances, thereby protecting public health, safety and welfare.”
One way that cities and counties use this authority is through zoning, which is the division of a city into certain types of “districts” and the application of different regulations in each “district” – like commercial, industrial or residential zones. Zoning ordinances generally fall into two categories: (1) Those that regulate the height or bulk of physical structures within certain designated districts; and, (2) Those that prescribe the use by which buildings within certain districts may be put. In general, the Legislature has given cities maximum control over zoning matters while ensuring uniformity of, and public access to, zoning and planning hearings.
Zoning ordinances must be reasonably related to the public welfare. In order to change a zoning ordinance, there are two ways to amend: a) Reclassification of the zoning applicable to a specific property, designating a change from one district to another district – known as “rezoning;” and, b) Changes in the permitted uses or regulations on property within particular zones or citywide. The first type of amendment usually involves a change in the zoning map, without any change in the text of the zoning ordinance; the second type of amendment usually involves amending the text of the ordinance and not the map. Zoning ordinances must be consistent with the general plan and any applicable specific plan.
Both of the ways to amend zoning ordinances mentioned above are considered “legislative acts” and are not administrative or quasi-judicial in nature. State zoning law requires both a hearing before the planning commission, if there is one, and a hearing before the city council prior to the enactment of certain amendments to zoning ordinances. There are also minimum due process standards required in conducting those hearings so that the public can participate.
- Home Rule and Charter Cities. The California Constitution authorizes both general law and charter cities to: a) make and enforce all local laws and regulations not in conflict with general state laws; b) establish, purchase, and operate public works and utilities or franchise to do so; and, c) be free from state legislation delegating to a private person or body control over city property, funds, tax levies, and municipal functions.
Cities with voter-approved charters have additional home rule authority over their municipal affairs, police, subgovernments, city elections, and their elected and appointed city officials and employees. The provisions of a city charter and ordinances adopted by a charter city prevail over general state law in areas that a court determines are municipal affairs. As to matters of statewide concern, however, charter cities remain subject to state law. Whether a charter city may act independent of state general law in a particular domain depends upon a court’s determination of whether it is a municipal affair or a matter of statewide concern.
The affected parcels list provided by the author’s office includes BART-owned parcels in the Cities of Berkeley, El Centro, Hayward, Oakland, San Francisco (City and County of), and San Leandro, all of which are charter cities. Other affected non-charter cities with parcels include Fremont, Pleasanton, Dublin, Antioch, Pittsburg, Lafayette, Concord, Union City, and there are also parcels listed in Alameda County.
- Exemptions from Local Zoning in State Law. Government Code 53091(a) contains the general rule that “each local agency shall comply with all applicable building ordinances and zoning ordinances of the county or city in which the territory of the local agency is situated.” There are, however, several exceptions listed from city and county zoning in the same code section for the following reasons: a) Certain types of school facilities; b) the location or construction of facilities for the production, generation, storage, treatment, or transmission of water, wastewater, or electrical energy by a local agency; and, c) location or construction of facilities for the production, generation, storage, treatment, or transmission of water, or for the production or generation of electrical energy, facilities that are subject to Section 12808.5 of the Public Utilities Code, or electrical substations in an electrical transmission system that receives electricity at less than 100,000 volts. [Zoning ordinances of a county or city shall apply to the location or construction of facilities for the storage or transmission of electrical energy by a local agency, if the zoning ordinances make provision for those facilities.]
Government Code 53096 contains provisions that allow the board of a local agency, by vote of four-fifths of its members, and in spite of the provisions above, to render a city or county zoning ordinance inapplicable to a proposed use of property if the local agency at a noticed public hearing determines by resolution that there is no feasible alternative to its proposal. The governing board may not render a zoning ordinance inapplicable to a proposed use of property when the proposed use of the property by the local agency is for facilities not related to storage or transmission of water or electrical energy, including, but not limited to, warehouses, administrative buildings or automotive storage and repair buildings. The governing board of a local agency may make these determinations at the time it approves an environmental impact report on its proposal.
In Delta Wetlands Properties v. County of San Joaquin, the Court of Appeal of California, Third District, ruled in a case involving these particular code sections and included in the footnotes that “Section 53096 does not apply to the storage and transmission facilities themselves. Rather, it authorizes a local agency to exempt facilities which are integral to them…. Moreover, section 53096 applies only to “local agencies” consistent with the construction that limits subdivision (e) [of Section 53091] to local agencies.
In this manner, it may be that BART has the authority to exempt itself from local zoning by the affected city or county, but only for its own facilities, and not for private projects like TOD mixed-use developments. In Delta Wetlands, the Court determined that “it would make no grammatical sense to except private commercial projects from a rule that does not apply to them.”
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following issues:
- Override of Police Powers Delegated to Cities and Counties. According to the League of California Cities, in opposition, “Authorizing a transit agency to regulate density, height and parking requirements transfers this essential local government function from their hands to a single special district. Bestowing land use power onto a transit agency that is unaccountable to community members is contrary to existing law and may violate Article XI, Section 11 of the State Constitution. In In re Werner (1900) 129 Cal.567., the court struck down a state statute which granted a sanitary district the power ‘to make and enforce all necessary and proper regulations from suppressing disorderly and disreputable resorts and houses of ill fame within the district and to determine the qualifications of persons authorized to sell alcohol.’ The court held that the powers granted to the sanitary district violated Article XI, section 11 because the ‘police power’ must be exercised locally by cities and counties only (as provided by the Constitution).”
- Establishes Precedent for Future Diminishing of Local Land Use Planning. According to the American Planning Association, California Chapter, “APA California opposes altering state policy to replace local land use planning by allowing BART to zone its own property. This bill sets a precedent for other entities to request the same authority to zone their own properties however they wish. In addition, BART would not be required to take into consideration what is currently on the ground, and what these local jurisdictions have already accomplished to increase density around transit. APA California believes the approach in AB 2923 will set a troubling precedent for further diminishing of local land use planning in future legislation.”
- Charter Cities and Home Rule. As referenced in Comment #5, above, charter cities enjoy supremacy over their municipal affairs. This bill does not contain any provisions declaring that the contents of the bill are a “statewide affair” – which would then apply the requirements of the bill to charter cities in addition to all general law cities.
The Committee may wish to ask the author about his intent to include charter cities in the bill. The Committee may also wish to note that while the Legislature can declare its intent to apply provisions of a bill to charter cities, the true determination of whether a specific area is a municipal affair or a matter of statewide concern will be determined solely by the courts.
- Highlighted TOD Projects. BART’s May 2017 Guidelines document highlights several recent TOD projects:
- Pleasant Hill/Contra Costa Centre Transit Village. This project is a four-block, mixed-use TOD project on BART-owned property and includes 442 residential units (20% affordable), 39,000 square feet of retail and a 1,552 space replacement parking garage. The first phase was completed in 2010, phase two broke ground in 2017 adding 200 market rate apartments and 2,300 square feet of retail. BART worked with Contra Costa County to redesign the streets on either side of the station to blend with the surrounding community.
- San Pablo Avenue Specific Plan. This plan was adopted by the City of El Cerrito in 2014, and encourages TOD at El Cerrito’s BART stations through a form based code. While it sets height requirements, it does not dictate use, and establishes no minimum requirement for parking paired with TDM requirements for developments providing less than 0.5 spaces per unit. The Plan enables flexibility on Specific Plan regulations for certain projects, and in this manner, the City is able to provide developers with greater value if they in turn offer public benefits.
- San Leandro TOD Strategy. The City of San Leandro adopted its Downtown TOD Strategy in 2007 and has taken steps over the last decade to see plans become a reality. The first phase of new construction included a retail center, an office complex and 115-units of affordable family housing. Additional zoning code revisions that allow more intense/dense development were completed in 2016 bringing the zoning code in alignment with the TOD Strategy and setting the stage for additional residential, mixed-use and office development.
- Highlighted TOD Projects. BART’s May 2017 Guidelines document highlights several recent TOD projects:
According to BART’s website, the TOD program has completed 12 developments at
11 stations, totaling 1,975 housing units and 194,000 square feet of commercial space, and include the following projects: Castro Valley, Richmond Phase I, Fruitvale Phase I, Pleasant Hill/Contra Costa Centre, Ashby, West Dublin/Pleasanton, Hayward, East Dublin, MacArthur, South Hayward, and San Leandro.
Also in the pipeline are the following upcoming TOD projects: MacArthur Transit Village, San Leandro Senior Apartments, Walnut Creek, Fruitvale Transit Village Phase II, Pleasant Hill, Workday World Headquarters at West Dublin/Pleasanton Station, and Coliseum Transit Village.
The Committee may wish to consider that all of the projects highlighted above have gone through the normal planning process involving the affected city or county, its zoning code, and any applicable entitlements necessary for the development.
- BART’s Stated Goals on TOD projects. BART’s May 2017 Guidelines document contains information about how BART will approach TOD developments, and states that “BART will only solicit projects for development in areas with transit supportive land use regulations. BART understands it can be successful in TOD only by being a team player, that means only developing where there are willing partners and where local governments have demonstrated through their plans, policies and actions that are transit-supportive.”
BART’s May 2017 Guidelines document also states that “BART’s best TOD projects were built as part of a shared vision in partnership with local communities. BART realizes the importance of working with cities and communities to help assure that station area plans and specific plans are achievable….”
The May 2017 Guidelines document also discusses the role of local governments in their TOD policy, stating that “Local Governments are key partners in BART’s TOD program, and play an important role in the planning and implementation of BART TOD projects. BART will only solicit proposals for TOD in localities that have an adopted plan allowing for transit-supportive land uses consistent with BART’s TOD Guidelines.”
The Committee may wish to consider how this bill aligns with BART’s stated vision for interacting collaboratively with local governments on TOD projects.
- BART position on this bill. BART has a “Neutral” position on the bill, and notes that the bill “could benefit BART’s TOD program by accelerating the rezoning of sites for residential and mixed-use development…however, this approach this bill takes poses a shift in the working relationship between BART and its local jurisdictions.”
Additionally, BART notes that “Local governments have always been key partners in BART’s TOD program and most have been supportive of development occurring on BART property. BART realizes the importance of working with local jurisdictions to help ensure station area and specific plans are achievable, support TOD, and address existing community concerns.”
- Why BART-Owned Parcels Only? The bill deals specifically with parcels of land that BART owns, near existing BART stations. The Committee may wish to consider why increasing density in this manner should only occur around BART stations, as opposed to parcels that are NOT owned by BART that are near existing BART stations.
Additionally, if the goal is to have higher density and more affordable housing and mixed-use near transit stations, the Legislature may wish to impose a statewide approach.
- Alternative Approaches? The Committee may wish to consider other alternative approaches that respect the Constitutional land use authority of cities and counties, including the following:
- Alternative Approach 1: Station Area Plans. Require an affected city or county that has BART-owned parcels described in the bill to adopt a “station area plan” within two years of the BART Board adopting TOD zoning standards. The station area plan would be required to consider the BART TOD zoning standards during a public hearing, and require findings to be made if the city or county opts to zone the land differently.
- Alternative Approaches? The Committee may wish to consider other alternative approaches that respect the Constitutional land use authority of cities and counties, including the following:
The “station area plan” would be similar to a specific plan, which is a planning tool used by local agencies that effectively establishes a link between implementing policies of the general plan and the individual development proposals in a defined area. In general, specific plans can be developed in response to a single policy issue, or to address each applicable policy of the general plan, or it may also diverge from the issues contained in the general plan into other subjects viewed by the community as being of relevance.
Some jurisdictions with BART stations have already adopted the approach of using station area plans. For instance, the City of Oakland adopted the Lake Merritt Station Area Plan, a specific plan for the area around the Lake Merritt BART Station in downtown Oakland, in December of 2014. The Lake Merritt Station Area Plan is a long-range planning document that provides a framework for future development that, over the next 25 years, looks to add to the neighborhood 4,900 new housing units, 4,100 new jobs, over 400,000 feet of additional retail, and over 1.2 million square feet of office spaces. The adoption of the plan was accompanied by Planning Code and General Plan Amendments, new design guidelines, and new zoning and height area maps.
This approach would also ensure public participation at the city or county level, as these plans are formulated and adopted through a formalized process with multiple opportunities for public hearings, testimony, and adoption by the legislative body of the city or county.
- Alternative Approach 2. Updating of Applicable General Plan and Zoning Ordinances. Require an affected city or county to update parts of their applicable general plans and zoning ordinances within two years of BART updating the TOD Zoning standards. In amending the general plan or applicable zoning ordinance, the city or county would be required to consider BART TOD zoning standards during a public hearing, and require findings to be made if the city or county opts to zone the land differently.
- Alternative Approach 3. Mandate Minimum Densities Around Transit Stations. APA California suggests requiring a minimum density and affordability standard on BART properties, and allowing each jurisdiction to figure out how best to meet those minimums. This approach, however, could also run into some of the constitutional issues raised above.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that the bill could potentially facilitate deployment of hundreds of new homes – both market-rate and affordable – precisely where they are needed, near major rail transit. Supporters also note that transit-oriented projects are notoriously contentious and approvals can take up to a decade, hindering development.
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents argue that the bill would override local planning efforts, including longstanding General Plan land use plans in built out communities, housing elements certified by HCD, Sustainable Communities Strategies, development agreements, specific plans, and Transit-Oriented Developments. Opponents also argue that the bill’s provisions may violate the California Constitution.
- Double-referral. This bill is double-referred to the Natural Resources Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California [CO-SPONSOR]
State Building and Construction Trades Council [CO-SPONSOR]
A.Philip Randolph Institute
Bay Area Council
Brightline Defense
CalAsian Chamber
California Apartment Association
California League of Conservation Voters
California YIMBY
City and County of San Francisco
Council of Infill Builders
Greenbelt Alliance
Habitat for Humanity
International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers
Mission Hiring Hall
Sheet Metal Workers’ Local Union No. 104
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
SPUR (in concept)
TransForm
Young Community Developers
YIMBY Action
Individual letters (6)
Neutral
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART)
Concerns
California State Association of Counties
Opposition
American Planning Association, California Chapter (unless amended)
League of California Cities
Individual letters (2)
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Senate Standing Committee on Transportation and Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):